71

72

73

74

75

76

77

78

79

80

81

82

83

84

２．Ａｃｈｉｅｖｅｍｅｎｔ Ｇｒｉｄ

85

1

0809

08

Ach

ieve

men

t Grid

of O

utpu

ts (o

n fin

aliz

ing)

Pl

anne

d A

ctua

l Is

sues

No.

In

dica

tors

A

chie

vem

ent

Cou

nter

mea

sure

s/a

ssis

tanc

e/re

mar

ks

Eval

uatio

n

Out

put 1

In

stitu

tiona

l and

tech

nica

l cap

aciti

es fo

r soc

ial f

ores

try e

xten

sion

in F

ores

t Dep

artm

ent a

re s

treng

then

ed.

Sum

mar

y of

Ach

ieve

men

t of O

utpu

t1

In th

e im

porta

nt 3

Dis

trict

s, th

e ou

tcom

es o

f the

Out

put 1

will

be

achi

eved

by

2009

. The

Pro

ject

will

ass

ist f

or a

rea

of b

acks

topp

ing

of o

ther

7

Dis

trict

s. G

ood

prog

ress

has

bee

n m

ade

in th

e de

velo

pmen

t of p

olic

y an

d pl

anni

ng d

ocum

ent.

42 K

FS o

ffice

rs a

re tr

aine

d, 7

Sen

ior

offic

ers

are

train

ed, 4

KE

FRI o

ffice

rs.(a

s of

Aug

, 200

8) F

unct

iona

l Uni

t is

in p

roce

ss o

f bee

n de

velo

ped

at K

FS H

ead

Qua

rters

. In

sum

, Mos

t pol

icy

and

plan

ning

doc

umen

ts h

ave

been

dev

elop

ed a

nd c

apac

ity s

treng

then

ed b

oth

at th

e H

eadq

uarte

rs a

nd fi

eld

leve

l. S

ome

prog

ress

has

als

o be

en m

ade

in th

e 7

Dis

trict

s ou

tsid

e pr

ojec

t are

a. T

he o

utco

mes

of t

he O

utpu

t 1 w

ill th

eref

ore

be a

chie

ved

by

2009

.

93

1.1

By

Mar

ch

2009

, P

olic

y an

d pl

anni

ng

for

fore

stry

de

velo

pmen

t is

el

abor

ated

.

For e

xam

ple,

New

For

est L

aw is

end

orse

d/ad

opte

d/pa

ssed

by

the

parli

amen

t in

July

of

200

5, s

igne

d in

Nov

embe

r and

com

e in

to e

ffect

in F

ebru

ary

of 2

007.

In th

e di

stric

t le

vel,

the

stra

tegy

pla

n of

soc

ial f

ores

try is

for

mul

ated

and

impl

emen

ted

the

soci

al

fore

stry

in th

e im

porta

nt 3

Dis

trict

s (K

itui,

Mbe

ere,

and

Tha

raka

) and

Reg

ion

Coa

st o

f 3

Dis

trict

s (K

ilifi,

Kw

ale,

Mal

indi

).

Sev

eral

pol

icy

and

plan

ning

doc

umen

ts h

ave

been

form

ulat

ed a

s fo

llow

s;

- Pro

pose

d Fo

rest

Pol

icy

(Ses

sion

Pap

er N

o.4

of 2

006)

- D

raft

Keny

a Fo

rest

Stra

tegy

200

7-20

12

- Dra

ft Fo

rest

Ext

ensi

on S

trate

gy 2

007

- Ext

ensi

on O

pera

tiona

l Gui

delin

es (I

SFP

, 200

5)

- D

istri

ct E

xten

sion

Gui

delin

e(s)

(KF

S,

2007

)/Far

m F

ores

try M

anag

emen

t M

anua

l (IS

FP, 2

007)

- S

tudy

Gui

de fo

r Far

m F

ores

try T

ree

Nur

sery

Est

ablis

hmen

t - S

trate

gy fo

r Nat

iona

l Tra

nsfo

rmat

ion:

Vis

ion

2030

- V

isio

n 20

30

100

1.2

By

Mar

ch

2009

, Im

plem

enta

tion

plan

on

so

cial

fo

rest

ry

exte

nsio

n is

pr

epar

ed,

pilo

ted

and

impr

oved

in

10

dist

ricts

in s

emi-a

rid

Impl

emen

tatio

n pl

ans

on s

ocia

l for

estry

ext

ensi

on a

re p

repa

red

in t

he im

porta

nt 3

D

istri

cts.

In

oth

er 7

Dis

trict

s, M

alin

di,

Kilif

i, K

wal

e, L

akip

ia,

Wes

t Po

koｔ,

Mer

u S

outh

an

d R

achu

onyo

, the

impl

emen

tatio

n pl

an h

ave

been

pre

pare

d an

d su

bmitt

ed. H

owev

er,

the

4 D

istri

cts

(Lak

ipia

, W

est

Pok

ot,

Mer

u S

outh

an

d R

achu

onyo

) ha

ve n

ot f

ully

up

date

d ye

t.

Bec

ause

of

th

e tu

rmoi

l du

e to

po

st-p

resi

dent

el

ectio

n an

d pe

rson

nel

trans

fer

of

a C

hief

of

th

e Fo

rest

ry

Offi

ce,

80

87

2

area

. W

hen

Pro

ject

will

stre

ngth

the

tech

nica

l ass

ista

nce

of u

pdat

ing

plan

and

pro

mot

ing

soci

al f

ores

try e

xten

sion

act

iviti

es w

ith K

FS,

Indi

cato

r 1.

2 ha

s po

ssib

ilitie

s to

be

achi

eved

. (IF

SP, 2

008)

pilo

ting

and

impr

ovin

g so

cial

for

est

activ

ities

fo

r 4

(Lak

ipia

, W

est

Pok

o,

Mer

u S

outh

, an

d R

achu

onyo

) ar

e st

ill o

n in

itiat

ing.

1.

3 B

y M

arch

20

09,

a fu

nctio

nal

unit

for

soci

al

fore

stry

ex

tens

ion

plan

ning

, m

onito

ring

and

eval

uatio

n is

es

tabl

ishe

d at

KFS

.

A fu

nctio

nal u

nit f

or s

ocia

l for

estry

ext

ensi

on p

lann

ing,

mon

itorin

g an

d ev

alua

tion

is

on o

rgan

izin

g in

KS

F.(S

ourc

e: O

rgan

izat

ion

char

t)

Dra

ft “T

erm

s of

Ref

eren

ce (T

OR

) for

a fu

nctio

nal u

nit f

or s

ocia

l for

estry

ext

ensi

on in

K

enya

Ser

vice

(KFS

)” is

dra

fted

as o

f Jul

y 16

th, 2

008.

In

the

situ

atio

n m

entio

ned

the

abov

e, In

dica

tor 1

.3 w

ill b

e at

tain

ed b

y 20

09.

10

0

Out

puts

2.

Soc

ial f

ores

try e

xten

sion

act

iviti

es a

mon

g in

divi

dual

farm

ers

and

farm

er g

roup

s ar

e pr

omot

ed.

Sum

mar

y of

Ach

ieve

men

t of O

utpu

t2

Goo

d pr

ogre

ss h

as b

een

achi

eved

in s

ocia

l for

estry

act

iviti

es a

mon

g fa

rmer

s gr

oups

. As

a re

sult

of F

FS, 8

0% in

divi

dual

and

farm

er g

roup

s ha

ve a

dopt

ed s

ocia

l for

estry

tec

hnol

ogy

and

skill

s. 2

34 f

arm

er f

acili

tato

rs h

ave

been

tra

ined

and

hav

e fa

cilit

ated

227

far

mer

gro

ups.

(a

ppro

xim

atel

y 3,

400

farm

ers.

(KFS

, 200

8)

100

2.1

By

Mar

ch

2009

, 60

%

of

in

divi

dual

fa

rmer

s w

ho

parti

cipa

ted

in

the

proj

ect

appl

y so

cial

fo

rest

ry p

ract

iced

by

grou

ps t

o th

eir

own

farm

s.

With

the

resu

lt of

the

curre

nt d

ata

as o

f 200

8, In

dica

tor 2

.1 h

as a

lread

y ac

hiev

ed.

Tabl

e 2-

1 P

erce

ntag

e of

Tar

get F

arm

ers

and

Sur

roun

ding

Far

mer

s P

ract

icin

g Fa

rm

Fore

stry

on

thei

r far

ms

as a

resu

lt of

FFS

Kitu

i M

beer

e Ta

raka

Av

erag

e Ta

rget

Fa

rmer

s 98

%

90%

10

0%

96%

Sur

roun

ding

Fa

rmer

s 94

%

89%

87

%

90%

Not

e: T

he p

erce

ntag

es a

re c

ompu

ted

by th

e P

roje

ct b

ased

on

the

sour

ce o

f res

ult o

f S

urve

y of

“E

nter

pris

es P

ract

iced

by

the

grou

ps”

(Impl

emen

ted

sinc

e Ju

ne 2

008y

(IS

FP,2

008)

)

10

0

2.2

By

Mar

ch 2

009,

120

fa

rmer

gr

oups

ar

e in

volv

ed

in

soci

al

fore

stry

re

late

d gr

oup

netw

ork.

Acc

ordi

ng t

he r

esul

t of

sur

vey

by I

SFP

, Ta

bula

te “

ISFP

Gro

up I

nvol

ved

in S

ocia

l Fo

rest

ry F

FS N

etw

ork

by J

uly

2008

” ind

icat

es a

s fo

llow

s.

10

0

88

3

Tabl

e 2.

2 To

tal N

umbe

r of

ISFP

Gro

up In

volv

ed in

Soc

ial F

ores

try F

FS N

etw

ork

by

July

200

8 in

3 D

istri

cts

Dis

trict

N

umbe

r of G

roup

K

itui

102

Mbe

ere

21

Thar

aka

41

tota

l 16

4 In

the

res

ult,

mor

e th

an 1

20 f

arm

er g

roup

s ar

e in

volv

ed i

n so

cial

for

estry

rel

ated

gr

oup

netw

ork

at th

is m

omen

t of A

ugus

t 200

8.

2.3

By

Mar

ch 2

009,

150

fa

rmer

s gr

oups

are

fa

cilit

ated

by

fa

rmer

s in

the

area

.

Acc

ordi

ng B

ar c

hart

and

Tabl

e of

ISFP

Cov

erag

e S

cena

rio (2

008,

ISFP

), 12

5 fa

rmer

s gr

oups

are

alre

ady

faci

litat

ed b

y fa

rmer

s fa

cilit

ator

in th

e ar

ea. 9

4 fa

rmer

s gr

oups

of

Farm

er R

un F

FS h

ave

been

faci

litat

ed b

y th

em s

ince

Apr

il 20

08.

In th

e cu

rrent

mon

itorin

g re

sult,

234

farm

er fa

cilit

ator

s ha

ve b

een

train

ed a

nd h

ave

faci

litat

ed 2

27 f

arm

er g

roup

s. (

Appr

oxim

atel

y 3,

400

farm

ers.

(KFS

, 20

08)

Hen

ce,

Indi

cato

r 2.3

has

alre

ady

been

sur

pass

ed.

10

0

2.4

By

Mar

ch

2009

, 7,

500

farm

ers

atte

nd

field

da

ys

cond

ucte

d by

farm

er

grou

ps

parti

cipa

ted

in th

e pr

ojec

t.

Acc

ordi

ng “L

ist o

f Fie

ld D

ay A

ttend

ance

” (IS

FP, 2

008)

, vis

itors

are

11,

345,

est

imat

ed

visi

tors

are

15,

165.

H

ence

, Out

put 2

.4 h

as p

ossi

bilit

ies

to b

e ac

hiev

ed b

y 20

09.

10

0

2.5

By

Mar

ch

2009

, 70

% o

f far

mer

s w

ho

parti

cipa

ted

the

proj

ect

appr

ecia

te

the

proj

ect

exte

nsio

n m

odel

.

As

tabl

e 2.

5-i)

and

-ii)

show

n be

low,

the

far

mer

s w

ho l

earn

ed n

ew t

echn

ique

are

m

ore

than

70%

. It p

asse

d In

dica

tor 2

.5.

Tabl

e 2.

5-i)

Farm

ers

who

Par

ticip

ated

the

Pro

ject

App

reci

ate

the

Pro

ject

Ext

ensi

on

Mod

el (T

arge

t Far

mer

s)

To

tal

of

answ

ered

“E

xcel

lent

”

Tota

l of

an

swer

ed

“Goo

d”

Sam

ple

Num

ber

Rat

e of

ans

wer

ed

“Exc

elle

nt” a

nd

“Goo

d” in

the

sam

ple

Kitu

i 18

25

41

80

%

Mbe

ere

29

19

49

98%

Th

arak

a 16

12

39

71

%

(Ave

rage

: 83%

) S

ourc

e:

Res

ult

of

Sur

vey

of

“Eva

luat

ion

of

ISFP

ex

tens

ion

mod

el/p

acka

ge”

(Jun

e,20

08, i

mpl

emen

ted

by th

e P

roje

ct)

10

0

89

4

Tabl

e 2.

5-ii)

Far

mer

s w

ho P

artic

ipat

ed th

e P

roje

ct A

ppre

ciat

e th

e P

roje

ct E

xten

sion

M

odel

(Sur

roun

ding

Far

mer

s)

To

tal

of

answ

ered

“E

xcel

lent

”

Tota

l of

an

swer

ed

“Goo

d”

Sam

ple

Num

ber

Rat

e of

ans

wer

ed

“Exc

elle

nt” a

nd

“Goo

d” in

the

sam

ple

Kitu

i 23

52

11

3 70

%

Mbe

ere

21

41

85

68%

Th

arak

a 21

41

96

64

%

(Ave

rage

: 67.

3)

Sou

rce:

R

esul

t of

S

urve

y of

“E

valu

atio

n of

IS

FP

exte

nsio

n m

odel

/pac

kage

” (J

une,

2008

, im

plem

ente

d by

the

Pro

ject

)

2.6

By

Mar

ch

2009

, 60

%

of

K

FS

exte

nsio

n st

aff

invo

lved

in

th

e pr

ojec

t im

plem

enta

tion

are

reco

gniz

ed

as

qual

ified

fa

rm

fore

stry

FF

S fa

cilit

ator

s.

The

chec

k sh

eet w

as d

evel

oped

in J

une

and

only

pre

test

ed c

heck

was

impl

emen

ted.

(s

ee

the

chec

k sh

eet:

Nam

e of

“C

heck

Sh

eet

of

Eva

luat

e FF

S F

acilit

ator

s”,

deve

lope

d in

Jun

e, 2

008,

by

ISFP

) In

the

resu

lt of

pre

test

, the

qua

lifie

d 66

% o

f KFS

ex

tens

ion

staf

f are

invo

lved

in th

e pr

ojec

t im

plem

enta

tion.

(Num

ber o

f DFE

O w

ho g

et

poin

t of m

ore

than

80%

div

ided

by

sam

ple

num

ber o

f DFE

Os

(3) i

s 66

%) (

KFS

,200

8)

Alth

ough

the

resu

lt of

pre

test

is 6

6%, t

he p

erce

ntag

e is

pas

sed

over

60%

of I

ndic

ator

2.

6 of

Out

put 2

.

10

0

2.7

By

Mar

ch 2

009,

120

fa

rmer

s gr

oups

are

fa

cilit

ated

by

K

FS

exte

nsio

n st

aff i

n th

e ar

ea.

91 fa

rmer

s gr

oups

are

alre

ady

faci

litat

ed b

y D

FEO

s. 2

2 fa

rmer

s gr

oups

hav

e be

en

faci

litat

ed b

y D

FEO

s si

nce

Sep

.200

7. In

cas

e, it

incl

udes

farm

ers

grou

ps fa

cilit

ated

by

DFE

Os

in o

ther

dis

trict

(exc

ept K

itui,

Mbe

ere,

and

Tha

raka

) (IF

SP,

200

8)

Acc

ordi

ng to

a b

ar c

hart

of “I

SFP

FFS

Cov

erag

e S

cena

rio”,

(ISFP

, 200

7), 2

16 g

roup

s ar

e fa

cilit

ated

by

DFE

O in

clud

ing

with

bac

ksto

ppin

g. M

ore

than

17

Ext

ensi

on R

un

farm

er g

roup

s an

d 94

Far

mer

Run

gro

ups

will

be

faci

litat

ed b

y M

arch

of 2

009.

Hen

ce,

the

num

ber w

ill ex

ceed

mor

e th

an 1

20 g

roup

s by

the

end

of th

e P

roje

ct.

10

0

O

ther

s

Out

put 3

. 3

farm

ers

and

othe

r sta

keho

lder

s ob

tain

eno

ugh

prac

tical

kno

wle

dge

and

tech

niqu

es.

Sum

mar

y of

Ach

ieve

men

t of O

utpu

t 3

80

% o

f the

4,9

65 ta

rget

farm

ers

appr

ecia

te th

e kn

owle

dge

and

tech

niqu

es le

arnt

thro

ugh

FFS

and

man

y ha

ve

plan

ted

trees

on

thei

r far

ms.

100

90

5 3.

1 B

y M

arch

20

09,

50%

of f

arm

ers

who

pa

rtici

pate

d in

th

e pr

ojec

t im

plem

ente

d ne

w

tech

niqu

es

lear

ned

thro

ugh

the

proj

ect

in t

heir

own

farm

s.

As

tabl

e 3.

1.1-

i),-ii

) –iii

) an

-iv) s

how

n be

low,

the

farm

ers

who

lear

ned

new

tech

niqu

e ar

e m

ore

than

50%

. It p

asse

d In

dica

tor 3

.1.

Ta

ble

3.1-

i) Pe

rcen

tage

of f

arm

ers

who

par

ticip

ated

in th

e pr

ojec

t im

plem

ente

d ne

w

tech

niqu

es le

arne

d (E

xten

sion

-Run

Tar

get F

arm

ers)

Tota

l num

ber

of o

ver

50%

of

rate

of a

pplic

atio

n To

tal

num

ber

of

tech

niqu

e ite

ms

%

Kitu

i 52

58

90

M

beer

e 71

80

89

Th

arak

a 79

80

99

S

ourc

e: R

esul

t of

sur

vey

of t

abul

ate

“App

licat

ion

of F

FS t

echn

ique

s on

indi

vidu

al

farm

s” (J

une,

200

7), “

Ext

ensi

on R

un 2

G (2

nd G

ener

atio

n) a

nd 3

G (3

rd G

ener

atio

n)”

Tabl

e 3.

1-ii)

Per

cent

age

of fa

rmer

s w

ho p

artic

ipat

ed in

the

proj

ect i

mpl

emen

ted

new

te

chni

ques

lear

ned

(Ext

ensi

on-R

un S

urro

undi

ng F

arm

ers)

Tota

l num

ber

of o

ver

50%

of

rate

of a

pplic

atio

n To

tal

num

ber

of

tech

niqu

e ite

ms

%

Kitu

i 61

70

87

M

beer

e 48

70

68

Th

arak

a 79

80

99

S

ourc

e: R

esul

t of

sur

vey

of t

abul

ate

“App

licat

ion

of F

FS t

echn

ique

s on

indi

vidu

al

farm

s” (J

une,

200

7), “

Ext

ensi

on R

un 2

G a

nd 3

G”

Tabl

e 3.

1-iii

) Per

cent

age

of fa

rmer

s w

ho p

artic

ipat

ed in

the

proj

ect i

mpl

emen

ted

new

te

chni

ques

lear

ned

(Far

mer

-Run

Tar

get F

arm

ers)

Tota

l num

ber

of o

ver

50%

of

rate

of a

pplic

atio

n To

tal

num

ber

of

tech

niqu

e ite

ms

%

Kitu

i 71

80

89

M

beer

e 63

80

79

Th

arak

a 70

80

88

S

ourc

e: R

esul

t of

sur

vey

of t

abul

ate

“App

licat

ion

of F

FS t

echn

ique

s on

indi

vidu

al

farm

s” (J

une,

200

7), “

Ext

ensi

on R

un 2

G a

nd 3

G”

10

0

91

6

Tabl

e 3.

1-iv

) Per

cent

age

of fa

rmer

s w

ho p

artic

ipat

ed in

the

proj

ect i

mpl

emen

ted

new

te

chni

ques

lear

ned

(Far

mer

-Run

Sur

roun

ding

Far

mer

s)

To

tal n

umbe

r of

ove

r 50

%

of ra

te o

f app

licat

ion

Tota

l nu

mbe

r of

te

chni

que

item

s %

Kitu

i 62

80

78

M

beer

e 43

80

54

Th

arak

a 43

80

54

S

ourc

e: R

esul

t of

sur

vey

of t

abul

ate

“App

licat

ion

of F

FS t

echn

ique

s on

indi

vidu

al

farm

s” (J

une,

200

7), “

Ext

ensi

on R

un 2

G a

nd 3

G”

3.

2 B

y M

arch

20

09,

70%

of f

arm

ers

who

pa

rtici

pate

d in

th

e pr

ojec

t ap

prec

iate

kn

owle

dge

and

tech

niqu

es p

rovi

ded

by th

e pr

ojec

t.

Acc

ordi

ng to

the

Pro

ject

, the

follo

win

g ac

com

plis

hmen

t is

stat

ed;

Tabl

e 3.

2 U

sefu

lnes

s of

tech

niqu

es le

arnt

thro

ugh

ISFP

FFS

, ans

wer

ed: Y

ES

Ye

s To

tal

Per

cent

age

Kitu

i 41

50

82

%

Mbe

ere

38

47

81%

Th

arak

a 35

39

89

%

(Ave

rage

:84%

) (R

elev

ance

res

ourc

e: R

esul

t of S

urve

y of

“U

sefu

lnes

s of

tech

niqu

es le

arnt

thro

ugh

ISFP

FFS

” (su

rvey

ed b

y th

e P

roje

ct, J

une

2008

), un

title

d ta

ble

of “E

xten

sion

Mod

el”,

ISFP

, 200

8)

Not

e: (

tota

l nu

mbe

r of

yes

“4-

1 H

ave

you

foun

d an

y ne

w t

echn

ique

s us

eful

ly?”

) di

vide

d by

(tot

al s

ampl

e nu

mbe

rs).

With

the

resu

lt of

the

curre

nt d

ata

as o

f 200

8, a

vera

ge is

84%

. Hen

ce, I

ndic

ator

3.2

ha

s po

ssib

ilitie

s to

be

achi

eved

.

10

0

Out

put 4

. In

form

atio

n on

soc

ial f

ores

try e

xten

sion

and

rela

ted

issu

es is

sha

red

amon

g th

e st

akeh

olde

rs

Sum

mar

y of

Ach

ieve

men

t Out

put 4

A

lthou

gh th

e ta

rget

num

ber o

f peo

ple

visi

ting

the

proj

ect w

ebsi

te w

as a

t 4,0

00, t

he a

ctua

l num

ber t

o da

te s

tand

s at

10,

451,

indi

catin

g an

d an

incr

ease

d in

tere

st in

soc

ial f

ores

try

80

4.1

By

Mar

ch 2

009,

num

ber

of s

take

hold

ers,

who

are

aw

are

of i

nfor

mat

ion

on

soci

al fo

rest

ry e

xten

sion

, is

in

crea

sed

by

5 %

Bas

ed o

n th

e M

id-te

rm e

valu

atio

n, t

he n

umbe

rs o

f th

e st

akeh

olde

rs a

re a

s fo

llow

s;

80

92

7

com

pare

d to

200

4 le

vel.

Tabl

e 4.

1 N

umbe

rs o

f sta

keho

lder

s w

ho a

re a

war

e of

soc

ial f

ores

try e

xten

sion

N

airo

bi

Kitu

i M

beer

e Th

arak

a 11

%

7%

14%

32

%

Sou

rce:

Rep

ort o

f Mid

term

Eva

luat

ion,

p89

, DIC

, Jul

y, 2

006)

4.2

By

Mar

ch

2009

, 4,

000

peop

le v

isit

the

proj

ect

web

site

.

Num

ber o

f vis

itors

: 8,

432

(as

of

Aug

ust 4

, 200

8)

We

can

chec

k th

e la

test

num

ber a

t ht

tp://

ww

w.is

fp-fd

.org

/aw

stat

s.pl

/?co

nfig

=isf

p-fd

.org

(S

ourc

e: W

eb s

ite o

f sta

tistic

s of

vis

itors

num

ber,

is

fp-fd

.org

,:http

://w

ww.

isfp

-fd.o

rg/a

wst

ats.

pl/?

conf

ig-is

fp-fd

.org

)

80

*The

“E

valu

atio

n” in

this

GR

ID is

bas

ed o

n ag

reem

ent b

y Jo

int E

valu

atio

n te

am o

f Ter

min

al E

valu

atio

n.

*Sca

le: 2

0, 4

0, 6

0, 8

0, 1

00%

at t

his t

erm

of A

ug, 2

008.

*T

he st

atis

tic ta

bles

are

arr

ange

d ba

sed

on th

e co

llect

ed d

ata

mon

itore

d in

the

field

leve

l to

asse

ss th

e pr

ojec

t ach

ieve

men

t.

*Som

e of

the

data

is r

epor

ted

by th

e Pr

ojec

t in

this

term

of A

ug, 2

008.

93

1

0809

08

Ach

ieve

men

t GR

ID o

f Pro

ject

Pur

pose

and

Ove

rall

Goa

l (on

fina

lizin

g)

Plan

ned

Act

ual

No.

In

dica

tors

A

chie

vem

ent

Issu

es

Cou

nter

mea

sure

s/as

sist

ance

Eval

uati

on

Ove

rall

Goa

l: Li

ving

sta

ndar

ds o

f the

peo

ple

in s

emi-a

rid a

reas

are

impr

oved

whi

le e

nhan

cing

sus

tain

able

env

ironm

enta

l con

serv

atio

n O

vera

ll Ev

alua

tion

of O

vera

ll G

oal:

Farm

ers

are

alre

ady

gene

ratin

g in

com

e fro

m s

ales

of p

rodu

ctio

ns fr

om s

ocia

l for

est p

rodu

cts,

suc

h as

Man

go o

rcha

rd, t

hree

num

bers

and

w

oodl

ots

in th

e pr

ojec

t are

a. T

he in

tere

st g

ener

ated

will

enh

ance

tree

pla

ntin

g an

d su

stai

nabl

e w

ood

prod

uctio

n in

targ

et a

nd o

ther

are

as.

Hen

ce, F

arm

ers

are

alre

ady

gene

ratin

g in

com

e fro

m s

ales

of s

ocia

l for

est p

rodu

cts

from

e.g

. Man

go o

rcha

rd, t

ree

nurs

erie

s an

d w

oodl

ots

in

the

proj

ect a

rea.

87

1.1

By

2014

, ag

ricul

tura

l co

ntrib

utio

n to

ho

useh

old

inco

me

in s

emi-a

rid a

reas

is

impr

oved

by

1 %

th

roug

h th

e us

e an

d sa

le o

f so

cial

fo

rest

ry

prod

ucts

co

mpa

red

to y

ear

2004

leve

l.

In th

e fie

ld s

urve

y, s

ome

agric

ultu

re a

ctiv

ities

con

tribu

te th

e liv

elih

ood

are

sele

cted

by

farm

ers/

grou

ps;

e.g.

) - M

aize

pro

duct

ion

- Man

go

- Dai

ly g

oods

- P

oles

- O

nion

s, to

mat

os

- Gra

sses

for c

attle

- S

eedl

ing

(tree

/frui

ts)

- Hon

ey

- Pou

ltry

(Chi

cken

/egg

s)

S

ome

farm

ers/

grou

ps h

ave

plan

of c

omm

on a

ccou

nt fo

r fut

ure

inve

stm

ent.

They

are

ac

cess

ing

fund

ing

from

oth

er re

sour

ces

thro

ugh

FFS

.

The

data

for t

he

stat

istic

of

Indi

cato

r s

(1.1

/1.2

) are

not

co

llect

ed d

urin

g IF

SP. I

nste

ad,

the

achi

evem

ent

acco

mpl

ish

stat

emen

t is

verif

ied

the

info

rmat

ion

colle

cted

in

Fiel

d S

urve

y by

JE

T m

embe

rs.

100

1.2

By

2014

, ac

cess

ible

su

stai

nabl

e w

ood

prod

uctio

n re

late

d to

fa

rmla

nds

is

pred

icte

d to

in

crea

se

by

3 %

co

mpa

red

to y

ear

2004

leve

l.

In fi

eld

surv

ey, f

acto

rs to

con

tribu

te th

e liv

elih

ood

are

foun

d as

follo

ws/

grou

ps;

- Tre

e nu

rser

y en

terp

rise

- Woo

dlot

s - F

uel w

oods

(e.g

. Mel

ia, G

rave

lia, Y

ukal

iptu

s, S

enna

sim

ea, J

atro

pha,

etc

)

ditto

80

(1.3

) O

ther

s:

Soc

ial N

etw

ork

In fi

eld

surv

ey, f

acto

rs to

con

tribu

te th

e liv

elih

ood

are

foun

d as

follo

ws/

grou

ps;

e.g.

) N

etw

ork,

Soc

ial,

Mar

ketin

g, a

nd T

ree

plan

ting

80

94

2

Pr

ojec

t Pur

pose

: Ind

ivid

ual f

arm

ers,

farm

er g

roup

s an

d ot

her s

take

hold

ers

inte

nsify

soc

ial f

ores

try p

ract

ices

in s

emi-a

rid a

reas

. O

vera

ll Ev

alua

tion

of P

roje

ct P

urpo

se: p

ossi

ble

to b

e ac

hiev

ed

Goo

d pr

ogre

ss h

as b

een

mad

e in

ach

ievi

ng th

e fo

ur o

utpu

ts, i

t is

ther

efor

e an

ticip

ated

that

the

Pro

ject

Pur

pose

will

be

real

ized

by

Mar

ch

2009

.

97

1.

Dat

a no

ted

belo

w s

how

s th

e in

crea

sed

by 2

009

com

pare

d to

200

4 in

Kitu

i, M

beer

e an

d Th

arak

a D

istr

ict a

mon

g ta

rget

gro

up.

i) N

umbe

r of

tre

e se

edlin

g an

nual

ly

prod

uced

on

fa

rm. :

50%

Acc

ordi

ng to

the

Pro

ject

, the

follo

win

g ac

com

plis

hmen

t is

stat

ed;

Tabl

e 1-

i) N

umbe

r of T

ree

See

dlin

gs A

nnua

lly P

rodu

ced

on fa

rms

in 3

Dis

trict

s (

1st

Gen

erat

ion

Exte

nsio

n R

un, T

arge

t far

mer

s)

Ye

ar04

Ye

ar05

Ye

ar06

Ye

ar07

K

itui

3,36

1 9,

414

7,02

5 6,

581

Mbe

ere

122

567

3,56

7 3,

312

Thar

aka

14

446

126

- N

ote

Num

ber

of th

e ta

rget

farm

hous

es is

36,

whi

ch a

re th

e fir

st g

ener

atio

n of

ext

ensi

on-ru

n.

i.e. I

ncre

ase

rate

of K

itui b

etw

een

2004

and

200

7 is

95.

8%.

Sou

rce:

”Num

bers

of t

ree

seed

lings

ann

ually

pla

nted

on

farm

am

ong

1st G

ener

atio

n E

xten

sion

ru

n ta

rget

farm

ers”

(ISFP

,200

8)

100

ii)

Num

ber

of

trees

an

nual

ly

plan

ted

on fa

rms.

:50%

Acc

ordi

ng to

the

Pro

ject

, the

follo

win

g ac

com

plis

hmen

t is

stat

ed;

Tabl

e 1-

ii) N

umbe

r of A

nnua

l Pla

nted

on

farm

in 3

Dis

trict

s (

1st G

ener

atio

n Ex

tens

ion

Run

, Ta

rget

farm

ers)

Year

03

Year

04

Year

05

Year

06

Year

07

Kitu

i 1,

713

2,78

9 3,

408

3,68

6 4,

061

Mbe

ere

338

268

472

2,07

0 1,

615

Thar

aka

975

3,47

8 4,

414

817

- N

ote:

Num

ber o

f the

targ

et fa

rmho

uses

is 3

6, w

hich

are

the

first

gen

erat

ion

of e

xten

sion

-run.

i.e

. Inc

reas

e ra

te o

f Kitu

i bet

wee

n 20

04 a

nd 2

007

is 4

5.6%

.

Sou

rce:

”Num

bers

of t

ree

seed

lings

ann

ually

pla

nted

on

farm

am

ong

1st G

ener

atio

n E

xten

sion

ru

n ta

rget

farm

ers”

(ISFP

,200

8)

10

0

iii)

Indi

vidu

al

farm

ers

and

farm

er g

roup

s w

ho

intro

duce

d hi

ghly

m

arke

tabl

e tre

e sp

ecie

s fo

r

Exa

min

ed th

e ra

te o

f inc

reas

ed n

umbe

rs o

f far

mer

s, 1

-iii-1

) w

ho s

tart

prod

ucin

g an

d 1-

iii-2

) w

ho p

lant

new

ly s

eedl

ing

tree

of M

elia

, Nee

m, E

ucal

yput

s an

d gr

afte

d M

ango

; and

the

trees

of

the

resp

ect

spec

ies,

the

num

bers

of

the

farm

ers

are

incr

easi

ng.

Show

ing

the

tabl

e be

low,

In

dica

tor 1

-iii)

will

be/

is a

chie

ved

by 2

010.

10

0

95

3

seed

ling

prod

uctio

n or

tre

e pl

antin

g on

farm

at

leas

t on

e sp

ecie

s.:5

0%

Tabl

e 1-

iii) -

1) In

crea

se ra

te o

f num

bers

of i

ndiv

idua

l far

mer

s an

d fa

rmer

gro

ups

who

intro

duce

hi

ghly

mar

keta

ble

tree

spec

ies

(Kitu

i, M

beer

e, a

nd T

hara

ka).

Kitu

i m

/Mel

ia v

N

eem

E

ucal

yptu

s M

ango

+3

3%

+56%

+1

1%

+28%

M

beer

e m

/Mel

ia v

N

eem

E

ucal

yptu

s M

ango

+5

6%

+56%

+3

3%

+56%

Th

arak

a m

/Mel

ia v

N

eem

E

ucal

yptu

s M

ango

+4

4%

+56%

+5

6%

+33%

S

ourc

e:”N

umbe

r of i

ndiv

idua

l far

mer

s w

ho in

trodu

ced

high

ly m

arke

tabl

e tre

e sp

ecie

s fo

r se

edlin

g pr

oduc

tion

on fa

rm” (

ISFP

, 200

8)

Tabl

e 1-

iii)-2

) In

crea

sed

rate

of

indi

vidu

al f

arm

ers

and

farm

er g

roup

s w

ho p

lant

new

ly t

ree

spec

ies

(3 D

istri

cts)

. K

itui

m/M

elia

v

Nee

m

Euc

alyp

tus

Man

go

+72%

+5

0%

+28%

+8

3%

Mbe

ere

m/M

elia

v

Nee

m

Euc

alyp

tus

Man

go

+56%

+8

9%

+100

%

+78%

Th

arak

a m

/Mel

ia v

N

eem

E

ucal

yptu

s M

ango

+7

8%

+7%

+4

4%

+56%

S

ourc

e:”N

umbe

r of i

ndiv

idua

l far

mer

s w

ho in

trodu

ced

high

ly m

arke

tabl

e tre

e sp

ecie

s fo

r pl

antin

g on

farm

” (IS

FP, 2

008)

iv

)

Num

bers

of

In

divi

dual

fa

rmer

s an

d fa

rmer

gro

ups

who

ne

wly

im

plem

ent

soci

al

fore

stry

ac

tiviti

es.(o

r ta

rget

Rev

iew

ing

the

Tabl

e 1-

iv).

The

70%

of I

ndic

ator

1-v

i) is

alre

ady

exce

eded

. Ta

ble

1-iv

) Num

ber o

f Sur

roun

ding

and

Tar

get F

arm

ers

of 3

Dis

trict

s

10

0

96

4

hous

ehol

ds

of

farm

ers)

:70%

Kitu

i M

beer

e Th

arak

a 98

%

90%

10

0%

Not

e: %

is a

rate

of t

arge

t far

mer

.

Rel

evan

t sou

rce:

“Num

ber o

f sam

ple

for f

inal

eva

luat

ion”

, (IS

FP, 2

008)

2.

D

ata

note

d be

low

sho

w th

e in

crea

se b

y 20

09 c

ompa

red

to 2

004

in K

itui,

Mbe

ere

and

Thar

aka

Dis

tric

ts in

sur

roun

ding

are

a of

targ

et

grou

ps.

i) N

umbe

r of

tre

e se

edlin

g an

nual

ly

prod

uced

on

fa

rm. :

5%

Acc

ordi

ng to

the

Pro

ject

, the

follo

win

g ac

com

plis

hmen

t is

stat

ed;

Tabl

e 2-

i) N

umbe

r of T

ree

See

dlin

gs A

nnua

lly P

rodu

ced

on fa

rms

in 3

Dis

trict

s (

1st

Gen

erat

ion

Exte

nsio

n R

un, S

urro

undi

ng fa

rmer

s)

Ye

ar04

Ye

ar05

Ye

ar06

Ye

ar07

K

itui

8,82

9 40

,826

62

,111

42

,329

M

beer

e 11

7 65

3,

138

469

Thar

aka

1325

64

0 14

09

- N

ote

Num

ber o

f the

targ

et fa

rmho

uses

is 3

6, w

hich

are

the

first

gen

erat

ion

of e

xten

sion

-run.

S

ourc

e:”N

umbe

r of t

ree

seed

lings

ann

ually

pla

nted

on

farm

am

ong

1st G

ener

atio

n E

xten

sion

ru

n su

rroun

ding

farm

ers”

(ISFP

,200

8)

10

0

ii)

Num

ber

of

trees

an

nual

ly

plan

ted

on fa

rm. :

5%

Acc

ordi

ng to

the

Pro

ject

, the

follo

win

g ac

com

plis

hmen

t is

stat

ed;

Tabl

e 2-

ii) N

umbe

r of T

rees

ann

ually

pla

nted

on

farm

in 3

Dis

trict

s (

1st G

ener

atio

n Ex

tens

ion

Run

, Sur

roun

ding

farm

ers)

Year

03

Year

04

Year

05

Year

06

Year

07

Kitu

i 2,

295

1,22

1 1,

728

13,3

25

14,5

94

Mbe

ere

2,35

7 55

2 78

0 1,

996

1,77

8 Th

arak

a 16

2 1,

365

838

1,76

6 -

Not

e: N

umbe

r of t

he ta

rget

farm

hous

es is

36,

whi

ch a

re th

e fir

st g

ener

atio

n of

ext

ensi

on-ru

n.

Sou

rce:

”Num

ber o

f tre

e se

edlin

gs a

nnua

lly p

lant

ed o

n fa

rm a

mon

g 1s

t Gen

erat

ion

Ext

ensi

on

run

surro

undi

ng fa

rmer

s”(IS

FP,2

008)

10

0

iii)

Indi

vidu

al

farm

ers

and

farm

er g

roup

s w

ho

intro

duce

d hi

ghly

m

arke

tabl

e tre

e sp

ecie

s fo

r se

edlin

g pr

oduc

tion

or t

ree

plan

ting

on fa

rm a

t

Rev

iew

ing

the

Tabl

e 2-

iii)-1

) and

-2) b

elow

, mos

t of i

ncre

ase

rate

of t

he h

ighl

y m

arke

tabl

e tre

e sp

ecie

s fo

r see

dlin

g pr

oduc

tion

or tr

ee p

lant

ing

on fa

rm is

exc

eede

d 5%

.

Tabl

e 2-

iii)-1

) I

ncre

ase

rate

of N

umbe

r of S

eedl

ing

Pro

duct

ions

K

itui

10

0

97

5

leas

t on

e sp

ecie

s.:5

%

m/M

elia

v

Nee

m

Euc

alyp

tus

Man

go

+31%

+5

3%

+17%

+1

7%

Mbe

ere

m/M

elia

v

Nee

m

Euc

alyp

tus

Man

go

+56%

+1

1%

0%

+39%

Th

arak

a m

/Mel

ia v

N

eem

E

ucal

yptu

s M

ango

+5

6%

+61%

+6

%

+39%

S

ourc

e:”N

umbe

r of s

eedl

ing

prod

uctio

ns o

n fa

rm”(I

SFP

,200

8)

Tabl

e 2-

iii)-2

) I

ncre

ased

rate

of n

umbe

r of t

ree

plan

tatio

n

Kitu

i m

/Mel

ia v

N

eem

E

ucal

yptu

s M

ango

+2

5%

36%

22

%

36%

M

beer

e m

/Mel

ia v

N

eem

E

ucal

yptu

s M

ango

94

%

50%

6%

50

%

Thar

aka

m/M

elia

v

Nee

m

Euc

alyp

tus

Man

go

28%

56

%

17%

11

%

Sou

rce:

”Num

ber o

f tre

e an

nual

ly p

lant

ed o

n fa

rm”(I

SFP

,200

8)

iv

) N

umbe

r of

in

divi

dual

fa

rmer

s an

d fa

rmer

gro

ups

who

ne

wly

im

plem

ent

soci

al

fore

stry

ac

tiviti

es.:5

%

Rev

iew

ing

the

Tabl

e 2-

iv)-1

, -2

and

-3 b

elow

, mos

t of i

ncre

ase

rate

of s

urro

undi

ng fa

rmer

s is

ex

ceed

ed 5

% o

f Ind

icat

or 2

-iv) .

Ta

ble

2-iv

)-1 P

erce

ntag

e of

Sur

roun

ding

Far

mer

s K

itui

Mbe

ere

Thar

aka

94％

89

％

87％

N

ote:

% is

a ra

te o

f sur

roun

ding

farm

er.

S

ourc

e: T

abul

ated

“en

terp

rise

of s

urro

undi

ng a

nd t

arge

t fa

rmer

s in

3 D

istri

cts”

, IS

FP,

Aug

.

10

0

98

6

2008

(ISF

P, 2

008)

Ta

ble

2-iv

)-2 N

umbe

r of

Ind

ivid

ual

Farm

ers

and

Sur

roun

ding

Far

mer

s at

the

Mid

-term

E

valu

atio

n (A

ug, 2

006)

Kitu

i M

beer

e Th

arak

a To

tal

Num

ber o

f Tar

get F

arm

ers

18

9 9

36

Num

ber o

f Sur

roun

ding

Far

mer

s 36

18

18

72

S

ourc

e: “N

umbe

r of S

ampl

e of

Fin

al E

valu

atio

n” (T

he P

roje

ct, 2

008,

Aug

.) Ta

ble

2-iv

)-3 N

umbe

r of

Indi

vidu

al F

arm

ers

and

Surro

undi

ng F

arm

ers

at th

e tim

e of

Aug

ust,

2008

Kitu

i M

beer

e Th

arak

a To

tal

Num

ber o

f Tar

get F

arm

ers

30

24

24

78

Num

ber o

f Sur

roun

ding

Far

mer

s 60

48

48

15

6 S

ourc

e: “N

umbe

r of S

ampl

e of

Fin

al E

valu

atio

n” (T

he P

roje

ct, 2

008,

Aug

.) 3

Pla

nnin

g on

soc

ial

fore

stry

ex

tens

ion

is p

rom

oted

in

10

dist

ricts

in

se

mi-a

rid a

reas

.

Pla

n of

the

targ

et 3

dis

trict

s is

form

ulat

ed. (

The

plan

s ar

e co

llect

ed b

y JE

T of

Ter

min

al

Eva

luat

ion

in A

ug, 2

008)

In o

ther

3 d

istri

cts

(Mal

indi

, Kilif

i, K

wal

e) F

FS is

run

in 2

007/

8.

Bec

ause

of t

he c

onfu

sing

dur

ing

pres

iden

t ele

ctio

n te

rm, a

nd p

erso

nnel

tran

sfer

red

of D

irect

or

of H

Q, f

our d

istri

cts

of s

even

had

som

e pr

oble

ms.

A p

art o

f the

dis

trict

s ar

e re

-def

ined

in y

ear

2007

and

200

8. In

the

four

dis

trict

s, L

aiki

pia,

Wes

t Pok

ot, a

nd M

eru

Sou

th, t

he s

ocia

l for

estry

ex

tens

ion

in o

n im

plem

entin

g.

If th

e P

roje

ct k

eeps

ass

istin

g by

the

end

of 2

009,

Indi

cato

r 3 w

ill b

e re

aliz

ed.

The

rest

s ha

ve

prob

lem

s e.

g.

pers

onne

l tra

nsfe

r, po

st-e

lect

ion

turm

oil.

(The

P

roje

ct)

70

*The

“E

valu

atio

n” in

this

GR

ID is

bas

ed o

n ag

reem

ent b

y Jo

int E

valu

atio

n te

am o

f Ter

min

al E

valu

atio

n.

*Sca

le: 2

0, 4

0, 6

0, 8

0, 1

00%

at t

his t

erm

of A

ug, 2

008.

*T

he st

atis

tic ta

bles

are

arr

ange

d ba

sed

on th

e co

llect

ed d

ata

mon

itore

d in

the

field

leve

l to

asse

ss th

e pr

ojec

t ach

ieve

men

t.

*Som

e of

the

data

is r

epor

ted

by th

e Pr

ojec

t in

this

term

of A

ug, 2

008.

99