on the detectability of bl lac objects by...

26
On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCube Chiara Righi -------------------------------------------------- Università degli Studi dell’Insubria INAF - OA Brera CollaboraCon with: F. Tavecchio, M.Landoni, D. GueLa

Upload: others

Post on 25-Sep-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This

OnthedetectabilityofBLLacobjectsbyIceCube

ChiaraRighi--------------------------------------------------UniversitàdegliStudidell’Insubria

INAF-OABrera

CollaboraConwith:F.Tavecchio,M.Landoni,D.GueLa

Page 2: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This

Overview

• High-energyNeutrinosdetectedbyIceCube

• Blazars

• BLLacobjectsasneutrinosourcecandidates

Page 3: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This

Discoveryofhigh-energyneutrinosbyIceCube

∼60eventssince2010.

3Whoproducetheseneutrinos?

Aartsen2016

Page 4: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This

Howtoobserveneutrinos

•  NeutrinointeracCons:

•  Atenergies>10GeVleptonsproduceCherenkovradiaCon.

4

Page 5: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This

DifferentsignatureCascade(νe,νμ,ντ) Tracks(νμ)

ν

ν

μ

5

CC&NC

North&South

CC

North

Page 6: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This

Searchingforsources

6

Tracks(νμ)Cascade(νe,νμ)

Wewillconsideronlyνμtosearchpossiblesourcecandidates.

≈60events(cascade+tracks)from2010

IceCubeCollaboraCon(2014,2015a)

Page 7: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This

Blazars

7

•  10%ofAGNareradio-loud

JET

Tavecchioetal.2014Tavecchioetal.2015Padovanietal.2016Resconietal.2016

Page 8: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This

8

JetspoinCngatus:

Synchrotron InverseComptonLeptonicmodel

Hadronicmodel Synchrotron Photo-mesonproducConorsynchrotron(protons)

BulkLorenzfactorΓ≈10-20

Lobs=L’δ4whereδ=[Γ(1-βcosθv)]-1

OutshinesanyotherisotropicemissioncomponentassociatedtoAGN(disk,dust)ortothehostgalaxy.

Blazars

Dopplerfactor

Page 9: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This

Blazars

9

FSRQ

BLLac • Lesspowerful• High-energypeakreachingintheTeVband• SynchrotronSelf-Compton

• Powerful• Powerful-rayemission• ExternalCompton

Page 10: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This

High-energyneutrinoproducCon

10

PeVneutrinosareassociatedtoprotonswithofEp∼1016-17eVinteracCngwithUV/sowX-rayphotons.

RelaCvisCc

protons!!

Page 11: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This

High-energyneutrinoproducCon

11

PeVneutrinosareassociatedtoprotonswithofEp∼1016-17eVinteracCngwithUV/sowX-rayphotons.

RelaCvisCc

protons!!

Page 12: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This

AreBlazarsgoodcanditates?

12

BLLac!  Padovanietal.2016(spaCalcorrelaConwithγ-ray

BLLacsdetectedabove50GeV)!  Tavecchioetal.2014efficientneutrinoproducCon

FSRQ! PossiblecorrelaConbetweenoneneutrinoeventandagamma-rayflareofaFSRQobject(Kadleretal.2016).• MuraseandWaxman2016

Page 13: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This

TeVBLLacascandidate

•  Padovanietal.(2016)

•  Tavecchioetal.(2014)

High-emi~ngBLLac(HBL)objectsaspossibleneutrinoemi~ngcandidates

SEDofMkn421

Abdoetal.2011

TeVemiLer

Page 14: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This

Themodel

14

Gamma-raysky(50GeV–2TeV) High-energyneutrinossky(>100TeV)

N.B:Onlyνμfromthenorthernhemisphere.

N.B:OnlyHBLobjectof2FHLcatalogue.

Aartsenetal.20161607.08006v1forthetotalneutrinoflux

Page 15: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This

Results

15

EffecCveAreaofthedetector

Neutrinofluxofthesourceourmodel

Page 16: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This

16Righietal.2016

Results

Page 17: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This

17Righietal.2016

Results

Page 18: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This

18

WithMonteCarlosimulaCon

Workinprogress

Awer7yearIceCubeshoulddetectMkn421.

Page 19: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This

Summary

•  IceCubeobseved≈60high-energyneutrinosabove100TeV•  SourcessCllunknown•  Blazars,andinparCcularHBL,aregoodcandidatestoproduce

high-energyneutrinos

•  ThescenarioforHBLobjectsisconsistentwithnodetecConbyIceCube

•  An“opCmisCc”esCmateoftheCmetoreach5sigmaforthetwobrightestHBLsourcesis7years.Weareclosetodetectthem?

19

Page 20: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This

Thank you!

Page 21: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This
Page 22: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This

22

Page 23: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This

ChargecurrentcrosssecCon

ALenuaConduetoEarthaveragemuonenergy-

lossrate

Neutrinofluxforeachsource

Gaisser(1990)

Page 24: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This

Spine-layermodel

Γs=15-20Γl=3-5

24

Γl

Γs

p

Ghisellinietal.2005Tavecchio&Ghisellini2008,2014

TherelaCvemoConofthetwocomponentsleadstotheamplificaConoftheradiaConfieldofthelayerasobservedinthespinereferenceframe.

InthisscenariotheBLLacobjectsaregoodcandiatestoproduceneutrino.

ThisscenarioisnotgoodforFSRQsbecauseofthephotoninrunningtophoto-mesonreacConaremostlikelytheUVphotonofthebroadlineregion(BLR).Thisimpliedavery-highenergyofprotonandsoofneutrinos.

Page 25: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This

Workinprogress

25

Murase&Waxman(2016)"constraintstocosmologicaldensity(lowerlimit)andluminosity(upperlimit)forcandidatesneutrinoemi~ngsourceclasses.WeresumethisworkbyapplyingitforHBLsources.

BLLac≠HBL

HBLhavealargerspacedensityandlowerluminosity.

Page 26: On the detectability of BL Lac objects by IceCubemoriond.in2p3.fr/VHEPU/2017/transparencies/2_monday/2_afternoon/4_righi.pdflikely the UV photon of the broad line region (BLR). This

26