on improving the convergence of radau iia methods applied ... · hal id: inria-00073949 submitted...

28
HAL Id: inria-00073949 https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés. On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied to Index 2 DAEs Anne Aubry, Philippe Chartier To cite this version: Anne Aubry, Philippe Chartier. On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied to Index 2 DAEs. [Research Report] RR-2744, INRIA. 1995. inria-00073949

Upload: others

Post on 20-May-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

HAL Id: inria-00073949https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00073949

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open accessarchive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come fromteaching and research institutions in France orabroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, estdestinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documentsscientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,émanant des établissements d’enseignement et derecherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoirespublics ou privés.

On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA MethodsApplied to Index 2 DAEs

Anne Aubry, Philippe Chartier

To cite this version:Anne Aubry, Philippe Chartier. On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied toIndex 2 DAEs. [Research Report] RR-2744, INRIA. 1995. �inria-00073949�

Page 2: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

ISS

N 0

249-

6399

appor t de r ech er ch e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

On improving the convergence of Radau IIA methodsapplied to index 2 DAEs

A. Aubry , P. Chartier

N˚ 2744Decembre 1995

PROGRAMME 6

Page 3: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and
Page 4: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

������������ ������������������� �����������������! #"%$"'&)(*(,+ �-�������.$�/0"%��21��3�4$5�*�����$��6�798:+<;=/

>@?A>CBADFEHGJI*K�?�L%M*NOE3PHQSRTEVU

WYX[Z]\OX3^`__a�b�c d�^TegfHhieYj[flkma�npoqksrFtOhua]vA_Zuw�xaHeskyj[^`oqkmZ]nza�o4emZ]\`kyflkmaHe{nihu_Jxa�X|kgtOhuaW}X[Z]~qa�o4�%ey^]wOkmn

�%^`�u�,Z]X[o�wiaCX[a�fl�ua�X3f[�ua�n.�p�����]�Cc��zxa�fHa�_��uXla����O�]��c��`���V^`\]a�j

�����������V�`�]���4�ikyj��V^��Va�X��uX[a�jqa�nio3j^znua���j�km_�iemazo[a�f[�unikytOhua�o[Zzkm_�uX[Z`�]a�o[�ua2Z]X3wia�X��Va��V^��OkmZ]huXZ` ¡�¢hunu\]a�£¤'huolo3^�_a�o[�uZuwuj4�%�ua�n¥^`�u�ieskma�w¦olZ�kmnVwiaH§¨��%��©�j«ª­¬�o%kyj�o[�ua�n¦jq�uZ`�%n��uZ`�0o[�ikyj'f�^`n��Va�kmnVfHZ]X[�VZOX3^`o[a�w®k¯nio[Z@^_�Z]X[a'aH°®flkma�npo'�]a�X3j�kmZ]nzZ` Yo[�ua.fHZ�wia��4���%��±'��wia��]aHemZ]�Va�wz�i²®©�ªV³'^�kmX[a�X¡^�nVwz´�ªiµ=^`nunua�X�ª¶¸·p¹�º¼»�½A�T¾��]�0wOks¿*a�X[a�nioqky^�em£À^�em\]a��uX3^�kyf2jq²ujqo[a�_@j'Z` �kmnVwiaH§Á�Âv*�4hunu\]a�£À¤'huo[o3^¸_a�o[�uZuwuj�v­��^]wu^`h¥¬q¬À�Ã_a�ol�uZ�wuj�vXlZpZ]ola�wo[Xla�a�j�vVj�km_�iesks Ä²Okmnu\¨^]jljqhu_�uoqkmZ]nVj�v,fHZ]_�VZij�kmoqkmZ]n*ª

ÅSÆ�ÇÈ|ɼÊ�Ë ÇÈ�Ì�ÍsɼÎÄÏ�Ð

ÑÀÒÔÓ­ÕAÒSÖ�×ÄÕAØqÙ�Ù�ؼÚqÛ]Ü*ÝlÞ4ß�à�Ú�á�Ø�â,Ø[Ýlà�ãåäæØqà]Ûuç3èHé[ê�ë4ÕAØqÙ�Ù�ؼÚYÜAØqá�Øqì`Û]íuÕAÖYÓ­Ü*î

Unite de recherche INRIA RennesIRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex (France)

Telephone : (33) 99 84 71 00 – Telecopie : (33) 99 84 71 71

Page 5: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

+<&����-�����*�4 1 � ��*$�*��$�������� ��4*�'�%������$�4/ �����-����/A"'�'� �4/0"¡13���������� &��4/����&� $�4/�� ����­���.$�4/ $� #"%$"'&)(*(,+ "%��21���� &���4�4/" $�4/�;J8 + $ � �����4�3���

$��&.6

� �·u������·@�Cd�a�o4^`X[oqkyflema��uXuxa�jqa�npola�hunua�nuZOhu�]aHese¯a�ola�f[�unikytOhua¡j�km_�iema��,Z]huX%^`_JxaHeskmZ]X[a�X}ey^�fHZOnp�]a�Xl\]a�nVfHa¡wia�j4fHZ]_�£�,Zpj[^`nio[a�j�^�em\]a��uXqkyt]hua�j}emZ]X3jlt]h��åhunua'_Jxa�o[�uZ�wia'wia��%^]wu^`h�wia%oq²i�Va'¬¼¬��0a�jqo4^`�u�ieskgtOh4xa�a��^�hun�jq²ujqo��a�_a%wOk ¿�xa�X[a�npo|k¯aHe^Te¯\Yxa��uXqkytOhua®w�� kmnVwOkyfHa¨wia�hi§*ªYW�Z]huXCey^¦_Jxa�o[�uZuwia@wia¦�%^]wu^�h=¬q¬À��w��åZ]XHwiX[a®�Âv­j[^z_�kyjqa2a�n���hu�pXla@X[a�f�tOhikma�X[o@wiaj¼k¯_��ie¯a�j�_ZuwOksrFf�^`oqkmZ]nVj'wih¨fHZuwia.�%^]wu^`hV�2w�xa��]aHemZ]�u�4xa��V^�X�©%ªu³'^�kmX[a�X�a�o�´�ªiµ=^`nunua�X�ª��%Z]hVj�e¯a�j�aH§u�ie kyflkmo[Z]nVj'a�o�uXuxa�jqa�nio[Z]nVj}ema�j�^�_ xaHeskmZ]X3^`o|k¯ZOnVj�ZO�uo[a�nphua�j'jqhuX�wOks¿�xa�Xla�npo3j��uX[ZO�ie��a�_a�j�ª� ½,����º[�����·=� jq²�j|o��a�_a�j�^�em\Yxa��uXlZ]£ÀwOks¿¡xa�X[a�nioqkmaHegj4w�� kmnVwOkyfHa��Âvp_Jxa�o[�uZuwia�j4wia.�4hunu\]a�£À¤'huo[o3^Âvp_Jxa�o[�uZuwia�j4wia.�%^]wu^`h¬q¬���vA^`X[�uX[a�j«v�fHZOnVwOk¯o|k¯ZOnVj�j�km_�iesk rFf�^�o[XqkyfHa�j�v*fHZ]_�,Zpj�kmoqkmZ]n*ª

Page 6: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

������������ ������������������� ������������������ "!�#$!�%�&'&)(*�+��������#-,.!����/0���1#����2���3#��54�6�7"(98:, ;< (A���**�C$2&��}�­�3���

¬�n X[a�fHa�nio²]a�^�X3j�vYwOks¿ a�Xla�npoqky^�e.^�em\]a��uX3^Tkgf¸a�t]hV^�oqkmZ]nVj�=¼���¡©�j�>��V^��]a��Va�a�n0jqo[hVwOkma�w!�p² �T^`X|k¯ZOhVj@^`huol�uZ]X3j�=¼j|a�a? ³%µ0�u��@Àv ? ³BA*��C]�D@Àv ?FE d4W��u�5@G>3v�^`nVw�o[�uaHkmX�k¯_��VZ]X[oH^`nVfHa%^]f'HinuZ`�4ema�wi\]a�w��i²�o[�ua%wia��]aHemZ]�u_a�nioYZ` Vjq�Va�flksrFf'jqZ`em�]a�X3jj|hVf[�@^OjY�%�JIKI�A2 ÔX[Z]_ ? W�a�o�C]b�@uZ]X��4���%��±'�' ÔX[Z]_ ? ³%µ0�u��@Àª`�'na�jq�,a�flkg^Te em²�km_�VZ]Xlo3^`nio�fleg^Oj[jYZ` ­���¡©�jY^`Xqkyj�kmnu\kmnz�uX3^]fHoqkyfHa�^�X[a¡j|a�_�km£ÔaH§��ieskyflkyo�j|²�jqola�_@j�Z` {ol�ua' ÄZ]Xl_

='LM>ONQP$R =TS'>VU WX= P =TSY>1Z1[\=TS'>'>�Z] U ^= P =TSY>'>1Z S`_ ? S�a1ZYS)b�@cZ���ua�X[aJ^-d�W�eCkyj�^]j[jqhu_�a�w¦olZ@�,a�Z� ��VZOhunVwia�wzkmnp�]a�XHjqaCk¯n ^nuaHkm\]�i�VZ]huXl�uZpZuw¥Z` 4o[�ua�jqZ�e¯huo|k¯ZOn Z` �='IK>3ªA³�a�X[a]vA�4a^�X[a4kmnpola�X[a�jqo[a�wCkmn�Z]�uoH^�kmnik¯nu\^�nphu_a�X|kgf�^Te ^`�u�uX[Z�§ikm_@^`oqkmZ]nolZ�='IK>Y^]f�fHhuX3^`o[a¢ ÄZ]X��VZ]ol�o[�ua�wOks¿*a�X[a�nioqky^�e­^`nVw�o[�ua^Te¯\Oa��uX3^�kyf�fHZ]_�,Z]nua�npoHj�ªu��e¯ol�uZ]hu\]�¦jqZ]_�a�Z` ­o[�ua'kywia�^]j��uX[a�jqa�nio[a�w�kmn�o[�ikyj%�V^��Va�X�^�eyjqZ2^`�u�iem²@o[Z�_Z]X[a'\]a�nua�X3^�e�¢hunu\]a�£À¤'huo[o3^2_a�ol�uZ�wuj�v,�4a.�4ksese� ÄZufHhVj'Z]n¨��^]wu^`h¥¬q¬À�#_�a�o[�uZ�wuj«vV\`km�]a�n¥o[�V^�o%o[�ua�²¦�4a�X[aChVjqa�wzo[Z�uhikseyw¥o[�uafHZuwia%�4���%��±'�uª`�4�uaHkmX�fHZ]nVjqo[XlhVfHoqkmZ]n^]j*�4aHeseF^]j�jqZ]_a�Z` Vo[�uaHkmXY�uX[Z]�,a�X[oqkma�j�^�X[a��uXqkma�fV²�X[a�f�^�esema�wCkmn�I]a�fHoqkmZ]n¦�]ªg�]ªµ �ua�n¦^`�u�iem²Okmnu\®^j|£Àjqo3^`\]a��%^]wu^�h¦¬q¬À� _a�ol�uZ�w2o[Z�='LM>3vio[�ua�Z]X3wia�XHj�Z� }fHZ]ni�]a�X[\Oa�nVfHa.^`X[a�X[a�jq�,a�fHoqkm�]aHem²¦��g�hJ� ÔZ]X%ol�ua P £ÀfHZ]_�,Z]nua�nio¡^`nVwigC ÔZ]X%ol�uaj[�£ÀfHZ]_�VZOnua�npok=¼j|a�a ? ³lA*��C]�-@�>3ªu¬�n j|Z]_a�j¼k¯olhV^`oqkmZ]nVj�vA�%�ua�Xla.\]a�o[o|k¯nu\¦^�n^Of�fHhuX3^`o[a��T^�emhua%Z` [�_@^�²��Va�km_�,Z]X[o3^`nioM=Ôkmn�_�a�f[�V^`nikyf�j� ÔZ]X�k¯nVj|o3^`nVfHaD>3v`Z]nua}kyj�e¯a�w o[Z�hVj|a�^�wOks¿*a�X[a�npoY^`�u�uX[Zi^]f[�*ª´'a�nua�X3^�esem²¦jq�Va�^-H]kmnu\Vv,o[�ua�Z]X3wia�X�X[a�wihVfHoqkmZ]n¦�u�ua�nuZO_a�nuZ]n¦_2^�²2�VaCZ`�]a�X3fHZ]_a'�i²@o[�ua' ÔZ`esemZ`�4kmnu\@o[a�fl�unikyt]hua�jnmo1pGq ^CrVX3jqo4�VZij[j�km�ikse kmoq² fHZ]nVj�kyjqo3j¢kmn¨^`�u�iem²Okmnu\@o[�ua��%^]wu^`hz¬q¬À� _a�o[�uZuw�olZ�ol�ua�kmnVwiaH§¦Z]nua� ÔZ]X[_�hiey^`oqkmZ]ni= Lr>�Z` ='L:>3v = L:>ON P R U WX= P Z�[�>1Z] U ^-dD= P >)Ws= P Z1[\>1tI`k¯nVfHa.��^]wu^`h�¬q¬À�0_�a�o[�uZ�wuj4^`�u�ieskma�w�olZ�kmnVwiaH§®ZOnua¡���¡©�jYaH§u�ikm�ik¯o¢ Ähiese*Z]X3wia�X4Z` ­fHZ]ni�]a�X[\]a�nVfHa� ÔZ]X P ^`nVw[�=qjqa�a��4�ua�Z]Xla�_u;`£[� ? ³BA���C]�D@�>Hv`o[�ua%Z]X3wia�X�Z` ­fHZ]ni�]a�X[\]a�nVfHa�kyjYnuZ`� ��gvhz�¡^Tegj|Z� ÔZ]X"[uªi³%Z`�4a��]a�X�v]j|Z`em�]kmnu\= Lr>¢f�^�n��VafHZ]nVj�kywia�X3^`�iem²z_Z]X[a.fHZpj|oqem²mV^Oj�^�_2^`o[o[a�X4Z` Y À^]fHo�vio[�ikyj�X[a�t]hikmX[a�j'olZa��T^�emhV^`ola.o[�uakw]^]fHZ]�iky^`n

Z` Fo[�ua¢ ÄhunVfHoqkmZ]n xJ= P Z1[�>vUy=)Ws= P Z1[\>1Z�^�d5= P >)Ws= P Z1[�>Y> ^`oYa�^Of[�jqo[a��z=ÀZ]XY�%�ua�nua��]a�X�o[�ua%fHZ]ni�]a�X[\]a�nVfHa%XH^`o[a4Z` o[�ua ��a��%o[Z]n2kmo[a�XH^`oqkmZ]n¦\Oa�o3j4o[ZiZjq_@^�ese�>3vÂk¯nVj|o[a�^]w�Z� {o[�ua' ÔhunVfHoqkmZ]n{xJ= P Z1[�>rU|=)Ws= P Z�[�>1Z}^= P >�>�ªu�'nuZ]o[�ua�XwiX3^��%�V^]fYH�kyjYo[�V^�oYo[�ua%nihu_a�Xqkyf�^�e j|Z`emhuoqkmZ]n�kyj�nuZ]o� ÄZOX3fHa�w^`ni²�emZ]nu\]a�X�o[Z'eskma�Z]n�o[�ua%fHZ]nVjqo[X3^Tk¯nio�_2^`niks ÄZ`eyw^= P >rU ] ªo1p�pGq ^%j|a�fHZ]nVw'kywia�^%fHZ]nVj¼kgj|o3jAkmn�fHZ]_�uhuoqkmnu\'o[�ua:[`£ÀfHZ]_�,Z]nua�nio*�p²�jqZ`em�Okmnu\�o[�ua4^]wuwOkmoqkmZ]nV^�epa�tOhV^`oqkmZ]n9^�dD= P >�WX= P Z�[�>3vk ª a]ª]kmn2�uX[Z]~qa�fHoqkmnu\.ol�ua%nphu_�a�Xqkyf�^�e jqZ�e¯huo|k¯ZOn@Z]n�o[�ua¡j|Z]£Àf�^�esema�w�~H�ikywuwia�n¦fHZ]nVj|o[X3^�kmnio1�uª]�4�ua�fHZ]X[X[a�j|�VZ]nVwOkmnu\nphu_a�X|kgf�^Te}j[fl�ua�_a�nuZ`�0X[a�^Owuj

='L���>������ ����] U ^�= P ��� �G>1ZP ��� ��U P �J���K�`����'��s� � � WX= P �$� � Z1[n��� � >�Z � U ��Z�������Z�g�ZP ��� � U P �J�����"� �� ���� ��Ws= P ��� ��Z1[5�$� �T>�Z] U ^-d$= P ��� � >)Ws= P ��� � Z�[5��� � >1t

�4�ua�Z]X3wia�X4Z` {fHZOnp�]a�Xl\]a�nVfHa' ÄZOX�ol�ua P £ÀfHZ]_�,Z]nua�npo¢kgj�jqoqksese{��g`h �¡^�nVw@f�^`n��,a.jq�uZ`�%n2o[Z��Va�nuZ`�0��g`h=�^�eyjqZz ÄZ]X�ol�uaO[`£ÀfHZ]_�,Z]nua�nio��i²¥hVj�kmnu\¥o[�ua@¬�_�ieskyflk¯o��uhunVfHoqkmZ]nJ�4�ua�Z]X[a�_zª­³�ZT�4a��]a�X�vAo[�ikyj�o[a�fl�unikyt]hua2kyjZ]nVfHa¨^`\i^�kmn fHZ]_�uhuoH^`oqkmZ]nV^�esem² _ZOX[a¦wia�_@^`nVwOkmnu\Jo[�V^`nJol�ua¦Z]Xqkm\`kmnV^�e�Z]nua�m�j|Z`em�]kmnu\ o[�ua¦nua��<km_�ieskgflkmo�V^`X[o�Z` l='L � >%X[a�tOhikmX[a�j�^`n ^]f�fHhuX3^`ola�a��`^�emhV^`oqkmZ]n Z` :^ d = P >�^`o�a�^]fl� jqo[a��*v*^`nVw nuZ]o�Z]niem²]v­^]j'�uXla��]kmZ]hVj�em²_a�npo|k¯ZOnua�wAvu�%�ua�nua��]a�X4o[�ua�fHZ]ni�]a�X[\]a�nVfHa�X3^�o[a%Z` ­ol�ua ��a��%o[Z]n�kmo[a�X3^`o|k¯ZOn@�,a�fHZ]_a�j4o[ZiZ�j|_@^�eseÀªu¬Ào%f�^`n2�Vanua��]a�X[o[�uaHema�j[j�nuZ]o[a�w o[�V^`o�kmn®^'�V^�X3^�esemaHe a�ni�Ok¯XlZ]nu_a�nio�v]o[�ikyj�^]wuwOkmoqkmZ]nV^�e fHZijqoY�4Z]hieyw�,a�jq�V^]wiZ`�4a�w��i².o[�uahVjqa.Z` �^�jqa�fHZ]nVw¸�uX[Z�fHa�jljqZ]X�ª

¬�n�o[�ikyj4�V^`�,a�X�vi��a��uXla�jqa�npo%^Co[�ikmX3w�^`�u�uXlZp^]fl�@�%�ikyfl�¨wiZia�j4nuZ]o4X[a�tOhikmX[a.^`n¦^`nV^�em²ioqkyf�^�eA ÄZOX[_ Z` X^�d.^`nVw2�%�uZpj|afHZO_�uhuo3^`oqkmZ]nV^Te¢fHZpjqo�kyj.�V^Oj�kyf�^�ese¯² a�tOhV^�e%o[Z¦�%�V^�o�kmoCkgj� ÔZ]X.ol�ua®jqoH^`nVwu^`X3wz ÔZ]X[_�hiey^`oqkmZ]n*ª�¬ÀoCkyjC�V^]jqa�wÁZ]n o[�uaÕ�ÕÃÙr��ë��[êHê

Page 7: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

� (���(�%��5�������� ��!��������ZO�Vjqa�X[�T^�oqkmZ]n=ol�V^`o.o[�ua2a�X[X[ZOX3j�k¯n o[�ua [`£ÀfHZO_�VZ]nua�nio^`X[a2a�j[jqa�nioqky^�esem²=Z` �^2emZ�f�^Te�nV^`o[huX[a]v�^`o�ema�^]j|ohu�=olZ¦o[�uaZOX3wia�X�Z` ¢fHZOnp�]a�Xl\]a�nVfHa�Z` �o[�ua P £ÀfHZ]_�,Z]nua�npo�ª*��j�^�fHZ]nVjqa�tOhua�nVfHa]v*_@^DHOkmnu\�[2_ZOX[a^]f�fHhuX3^`o[aCkyj.^2_2^`o[o[a�X'Z` Xla�fHZT�Oa�Xqkmnu\ o[�ua¨j¼k¯\Onik rFf�^�npo�o[a�Xl_@j�o[�V^`o2^`�u�Va�^`X k¯n o[�ua¥jqZ]£Àf�^�esema�w ~ E £Àjqa�Xqkma�j�Z` ¡ol�ua¦a�X[X[ZOX1�uªY�4�ikyj�kyj�_@^]wia�,Zpj[j�km�iema�i²¨fHZ]nVj¼kgwia�X|k¯nu\¥o[�uafHZ]_��VZpj�kmoqkmZ]nÁZ` �o[�ua��V^]j�kyf�_a�ol�uZ�wz�4kmo[�zkmo3jqaHes %Z`�]a�X¡j|a��]a�X3^�e�jqo[a��Vj�ªA¬�o.f�^`n¥�VanuZOo[a�w�o[�V^`o4j�km_�ksey^`X�kgwia�^Oj��4a�X[a�hVjqa�w�i²@��ª W­ª ¤�ªud��V^`n�o[Z�wia�^�eA�4kmo[�2o[�ua%Z]X3wia�X�X[a�wihVfHoqkmZ]n�Z` Y´�^`hVj[j�_a�o[�uZuwuj���ua�n¦^`�u�iesk¯a�wzo[Z2fHa�X[o3^�kmn¨j|oqks¿ �uXlZ]�iema�_@jl=¼jqa�a ? E d���;�@�>3ª�¢�ua�nua��0ZOX3wia�X%fHZ]nVwOkmoqkmZ]nVj4�4ksese­�Va.wia�ola�X[_�kmnua�w�kmn{I]a�fHoqkmZ]n¦�uªOµ �ik emaCo[�ua�²@f�^`n��,a.wia�Xqkm�]a�w�kmn¦^�j|o[X3^�km\]�ioq ÔZ]X[£�%^`XHw�_@^`nunua�X4 ÔX[Z]_�o[�ua��4Z]X'H�Z` {©�ªu³�^�kmX[a�X�vVd'ª�AAhu�ikyfl�¨^`nVw � ªp�¢Z�fl�uak= ? ³lA*��C]�-@�>3v]ol�ua�²®^`Xla¡jqo|k ese*X[aHey^`oqkm�]aHem²hunKHinuZ`�%n j¼k¯nVfHaÁo[�ua�² ^`X[aznuZ]o®jl^`oqkyj�rVa�w �p²J_�Zpjqo�fleg^Oj[j�kyf�^�e��4hunu\]a�£À¤'huolo3^ _a�o[�uZuwuj2=qjqa�a ^�eyjqZ ?FE d4��;�@�Z]X? d%d��]�n@�>3ªY¬�o�4ksese.o[�ua�n �,a¨jq�uZ`�%nJo[�V^�o@jqZ]_a�Z� ¡o[�uZijqa¨fHZ]nVwOkmoqkmZ]nVj�^�X[a¦^]fHo[hV^�esem²JX[a�wihunVwu^`nio�^`nVwJ_@^�² �VaZO_�kmo[o[a�wAª*�4�ikyj�kyj�^zfHX[hVflky^�e¢^Ojq�Va�fHoCZ` %o[�ua_a�o[�uZuwAv­j¼k¯nVfHa2kmo�^�ese¯Z`��j�o[�ua�fHZ]nVjqo[X[hVfHo|k¯ZOn Z` 4 ÄZOX[_�hieg^Oj'�4kmo[� ^_2^`nV^`\]a�^`�iema'ema��]aHeYZ` {fHZ]_��ie¯aH§ikmoq²]ª

¬�niI]a�fHoqkmZ]n ;uvio[�ua'km_�ieskma�wz_Z�wOksrFf�^`o|k¯ZOnVj%o[ZCo[�ua.fHZuwia.�4�¡����±'��^`X[a'eskyjqo[a�wAª���kmnV^�esem²]vVnihu_a�Xqkyf�^�e�X[a�jqhiemo3j%^`Xla�uXla�jqa�npola�w2o[�V^`o4ksesemhVjqo[X3^`ola.o[�ua.^]wi�`^`nio3^`\]a�j4Z� {o[�ikyj4nua�� o[a�fl�unikyt]hua]ª

����� � ��������������� �!��"��#�!�$��%'&(�*)���+-,�,�.0/1��"�2���)����^]wu^`h�¬q¬À��_a�o[�uZuwuj%f�^`n��Va�wiaHrVnua�wz�p²2o[�ua.g`� �.tOhV^]wiX3^`o[huXla' ÄZ]Xl_�hiey^]j3�465798 =TS'>;:$S0< � ��'�� � � � 8 =>= � >1Z � U ��Z������YZ1g�Z3 �7 8 =TSY>;:$S < � �� ��� � � 8 =>= � >1t� �V^`X[oqkyfHhiey^`X4_a�o[�uZuw�?��4kse eA�Va�fl�V^`X3^OfHo[a�XqkA@�a�w�i².ol�ua%o[Xqkm�iema.=>B.Z � ZC=�>u�%�ua�X[a�= � � � >T��� �'�� �EDEDED � � kgj�^.gGF.g%_@^�o[Xqks§ v� U = � � Z������'Z � � >�H ^2g«£ÀwOk¯_�a�nVj�kmZ]nV^�e%�]a�fHo[Z]X.^�nVwI=kU =>= � Z�������Z�= � >�H ^2g�£ÀwOkm_a�nVj¼k¯ZOnV^�e%�]a�fHo[Z]X�ªA¬�n o[�ua@j|a�t]huaHeÀv�4a��4ksese* ÔhuX[o[�ua�X[_�Z]X[a�hVjqaCo[�ua�nuZ]o3^`o|k¯ZOnVj JlUy=3�$Z������'Z��-> H _ K L � ^`nVwM=ONlUy=;=ON � Z������'ZC=ON � > H  ÔZ]X�^Te e�k¯nio[a�\]a�XHj PAªQSR6Q!R6Q T ½�U �«�����*�`� p ½VU ½SW ���V¾*���YXZX�� �=·i��[F½*¾���¢�uaHk¯X�fHZiaH°®flkma�npo3j'^`X[a'hunikyt]huaHem² wia�o[a�X[_ k¯nua�w¸�p²2o[�ua� ÄZ`esemZ`�4kmnu\®fHZOnVwOk¯o|k¯ZOnVj5m�Oª = � Z������'ZC= � ^`Xla�o[�ua�Z]X3wia�X[a�w$@�a�XlZpj4Z` Yo[�ua���^]wu^`h�Xqkm\]�io%�VZ�e¯²inuZ]_�ky^�e

\ =>]�>rU : �>^ �:_] �`^ �ba ] �>^ � =;] hJ�D> �>c t�ª � � Z�������Z � � j[^�oqkyj� Ä² dk=�gD>1m e P2_(f ] Z�������Z1g�hJ��g�Z � H = N U �=>PJ� �D> t;ª%�4�ua�fHZiaH°®flkma�npoHj � � � Z` Yo[�ua�_@^`o[X|k §hB j[^`oqkyj� Ô²bij=)gD>�me P2_(f ] Z�������Z1g�hJ��g�Z�Bj= N U �=;PJ� �-> = N � � t�¡j4ol�uak=��Y^`X[a.^�ese{wOkyjqoqkmnVfHo�v�B kgj�nuZ]nu£Àj�kmnu\]hiey^`X�ª

QSR6Q!Rml n ½��=· �*��·_W ����o���½*o�·u��� p ·u�µÁa�4ksese¢XlaH Äa�XC�ua�X[a@olZ¦o[�ua@^OwuwOk¯o|k¯ZOnV^�e�j�km_�iesk  Ô²Ok¯nu\J^]j[j|hu_�uoqkmZ]nVj�p2=#q�>4kmnio[X[ZuwihVfHa�wAvY^]j'dj=sr�>.^`nVwIij=;t3>%Z` �uXla��]kmZ]hVj'jqhu�Vjqa�fHoqkmZ]n*vÂ�p² wuª¯d�ª E huoHf[�ua�XJ=¼jqa�a ? ³�µ0�u��@A�V^`\]a�`��>3ª

ÒÔÓ­ÕAÒSÖ

Page 8: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

������������ ������������������� ������������������ "!�#$!�%�&'&)(*�+��������#-,.!����/0���1#����2���3#��54�6�7"(98:, �

�Oª%�'hua¨olZ=o[�ua fHZ]nVwOkmoqkmZ]nVjMik=)g->3v�dj=)gD>@^`nVw9= � U �]v4�%^]wu^�h ¬q¬�� _�a�o[�uZ�wuj2^`X[a jqo|k��2² ^]f�fHhuX3^`o[a =ÔkÀªåa]ª� �2U � � �)Z � U)��Z�������Z1g->3ª�=q�4�ua¥�]a�fHo[Z]X3j � ^`nVw = � � � Z������'Z � �c� > H ^`Xla¨jqZ`emhuoqkmZ]n Z` �o[�ua j[^�_a d�X3^`_a�Xjq²�j|o[a�_2>3ª

�ª%�4�ua�²¦^`X[a.fHZ`esemZuf�^`oqkmZ]n¦_�a�o[�uZ�wuj =¼�4�ua�Z]X[a�_ ��£TC ? ³ �%µ0�u��@Àvi�V^`\Oa.�u����>3ª;ª dk=¼��glhJ�D>}kgj'j[^`o|kgj¼rVa�w�=)AAa�__@^��`£[��� ? ³�µ0�u��@Àvi�V^`\]a.��;\>3ª�,ª p2=)g�h �D>�kyj'j[^`oqkyj�rVa�w =)AAa�__@^��`£Ô� ? ³%µ0�u��@ÀvÂ�V^`\]a���C�>Hª

�%�uo|k¯_2^�e{fHZ]ni�]a�X[\]a�nVfHaCX[a�jqhiemo3j��V^��]a��Va�a�n¥Z]�uo3^Tk¯nua�w® ÄZOX%o[�uZpjqaC_a�o[�uZuwuj%�i²2wuªsd�ª E huo3fl�ua�X'Z]n¦o[�ua�ZOnua.�V^`nVw=q�4�ua�Z]X[a�_���£T;�Z`  ? ³%µ0�u��@�>�^`nVwz©%ªV³'^�kmX[a�X�v d�ª�AAhu�ikyfl�=^`nVw � ªV�4Zuf[�uaCZ]n¦ol�ua�Z]o[�ua�X%�V^`nVw =¼�4�ua�Z]Xla�_@j�;`£[�]v�O£Ô� ^�nVw��]£Àb�Z�  ? ³lA*��C]�D@G>3ªu�4�ua�²¦^`X[a.fHZ`esema�fHo[a�w¸kmn¨��^`�iema@�]ª

kmnVwiaH§ ] =�����© > kmnVwiaH§=� kmnVwiaH§¨�P ��� �>^ � ��� �`^ � ��� �`^ �[ £ � � �`^ � � ��­^��ie¯a2��m��%�uoqkm_@^�eY\`emZ]�V^�e*a�X[X[ZOX%a�jqoqkm_@^`ola�j� ÄZOX�ol�ua�jq£ÀjqoH^`\]a'_a�o[�uZuw¦�%^]wu^�h�¬¼¬��

����� ,������S�*���� � "�2�� �V��)��S�h��%������� �!���������� ��%'"�2������O���V/1� ������"µ �ua�n¦^`�u�iem²Okmnu\¦^jq£Àjqo3^�\]a¡��^]wu^`h¦¬q¬�� _a�o[�uZuw ? U|=;B.Z � ZC=�>*o[Z�o[�ua�jq²ujqo[a�_ ='L:>Hvp�4a�Z]�uoH^�kmn

����� ����] U ^�= P ��� �c>1Z =3�D>P �$� � U P � ��� � � ��}��� � � � Ws= P ��� � Z1[ �$� � >1Z � U ��Z������'Z1g$Z =¼��>P �D� � U P �.������� �� �� � � Ws= P ��� ��Z1[n��� �c>1Z =);�>[n��� � U � ���� �'���X� ��� � � [5��� � Z =À�K>

���ua�X[a�� � � ^`X[a¥o[�ua fHZpaH°�flk¯a�nio3j¸Z` .o[�ua _@^�o[Xqks§YB ^ � ª4¬�n =À�K>3vM[ � �`^`nikyjq�ua�j��,a�f�^`hVjqa LJ=�� >�U ] ª`AAa�o�hVjnuZ`�ÃXla��ieg^OfHa¦o[�uaz�]a�fHo[Z]X2= � H*B ^ � >�H �p² ^�n ^]w�~¼hVj|o3^`�iema¦�]a�fHolZ]X�� U =�� � Z������'Z�� � >�H kmny=À��>3ª E ² wiZ�k¯nu\JjqZVv�4a¥wiaHrVnua=^ nua���_a�o[�uZuw ?���ª4¬�okyj¸a�^]j�ksem² j|a�a�n ol�V^`o�o[�ua¥Z]X3wia�X2Z`  fHZOnp�]a�Xl\]a�nVfHa¥Z` .o[�ua P £ÀfHZO_�VZ]nua�nioXla�_@^�kmnVj%hunVfl�V^`nu\]a�wAª,��j4 ÔZ]X%o[�uak[`£ÀfHZ]_�,Z]nua�nio�vVol�ua�ey^]fYH�Z` �^]f�fHhu_�hiey^`oqkmZ]n¦_2^DH]a�j�o[�ua.a�X[XlZ]X3j4�uhuX[aHem²¸e¯Zuf�^�eÀª�¢�ua¦fHZ]np�Oa�X[\]a�nVfHa¦�,a��V^��]kmZ]huX2Z` �o[�ua [`£ÀfHZ]_�,Z]nua�niokyj�o[�phVj a�npoqkmX[aHem² wia�o[a�Xl_�kmnua�w �i² o[�ua� ÔZ`esemZT�¢k¯nu\ Z]X3wia�XfHZOnVwOk¯o|k¯ZOnVj4 ÔX[Z]_��¢�ua�Z]X[a�_ C`£Àb�^`nVw�C`£TCCZ`  ? ³%µ0�u��@Àª C��½*o�½F� p � p ½VU Q"! ����#�d2!���#$#�e �'�J������/0����!�/�������Y,.)�n,T�K�1������ ���/ �r�5�������� P !���#k[ �������\�$�����3��, �}�.!� %����$�&%'.%�����!2�k��������# �)(X�����+*r�.��!� �� �

# P U-,k=)�/. � � > � 0 e S"_Mp B)1��Dd�Z�2�=TSY>43 rXZ�5v=TSY> � H76�=TSY>rU ��Z#D[JU-,j=)��8 � � > � 0 e

9 _Mp B)1��DeDZ�23= 9 >:3<;�Z�5v= 9 >�� H 6�= 9 >vU ��Z*v������ p B)1��Dd�� p B)1��De !$)� ,5����,����O������5,��=6 !i ��������$1��!�/��5%��3����������!$��#>5rZ�2{,5��!�/0!�k�����n,j!-,1,5������!�����#?*r����������+������5, � ���a��]a�X[ol�uaHe¯a�jlj�v@���V^]j¸nuZ]o2a�nuZ]hu\]� fHZ]_��VZ]nua�nio3j2o[Z ^�esemZ`�� ÔZ]X�^`n Z]X3wia�X�Z` fHZ]np�Oa�X[\]a�nVfHa \]Xla�^`o[a�X2o[�V^`nyg=A� U = � H B ^ � > H kyj2o[�uazZ]�uoqkm_@^�e��]a�fHo[ZOX5>3ª�³�a�nVfHa]v4o[Z \]a�o®j|hi°®flkma�npo2 ÔX[a�a�wiZ]_¦v��4a¦nua�a�w o[ZJfHZ]nVj�kywia�X�o[�uafHZO_�VZpj¼k¯o|k¯ZOn ?>B�Z` �?�Z`�]a�XDC jqo[a��Vj«ªA�¡j��T^`X|kg^��ie¯a2jqo[a��Vjl�K�[v � U ��Z�������Z�C ^`X[afHZ]nVj�kywia�X[a�wAvA�4a�^�eyjqZ��V^��]a.o[Zkmnio[X[ZuwihVfHa.o[�ua�XH^`oqkmZpj@En�XU ���GFr� B� �� �K�qv � U ��Z������'ZHCYª_?>B�kyj%fl�V^`X3^]fHo[a�X|k @�a�w¸�p²2o[�uaCo[Xqkm�iema�=GI�ZHJ�ZLKr>­�%�ua�X[a

M I#kyj4ol�ua.�iemZ�fYHi_@^`o[Xqks§i=;B�� � >T��� �}��� �EDEDED � B@�4kmo[� g F gC�iemZ�fYHuj%Z` �o[�ua� ÔZ]X[_N�O ØqØQPSR�TVU&W�X�Y[Z�\­Ý�á�Ø�]`Ù�ä_^Sä_ZHÙ`Z�Y�^�a�ØqÚÔØYÙbZ�^Sä_Z3Ù�ÚAc

Õ�ÕÃÙr��ë��[êHê

Page 9: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

b (���(�%��5�������� ��!��������B��0� U En� BJZB�� � U E � J � H Z ks  ����� ZB�� � U ] Z ks  ����� t

M JJkyj4ol�ua.�iemZ�fYHi�]a�fHo[Z]X�=>d��c>T� ��� �EDEDED � B2�4kmo[���iemZuf'Huj%Z� {o[�ua' ÔZ]X[_ d��rU-En� � ªM K¨kyj�o[�ua��iemZ�fYHi�]a�fHo[Z]X�=>i`�T>c� ��� �EDEDED � B�4kmo[���iemZuf'Huj�Z` {ol�ua' ÄZ]Xl_ i`�XU E5�6=r� a � � ^ �N ��� E N c JOª

�¢a��ieg^Oflk¯nu\ a J H I ^ � c H �i²®^`n¦^Ow�~¼hVjqoH^`�iema��]a�fHo[Z]X@� Z`¿*a�X3jQChF g�wia�\]Xla�a�j4Z` * ÔX[a�a�wiZ]_¦v�k ª a��uZ]�VaH Ôhiese¯²za�nuZ]hu\]� ÔZ]XDC � ��o[Z k¯nVfHXla�^]jqa�o[�ua�Z]X3wia�X'Z` �fHZ]ni�]a�X[\]a�nVfHaCZ` {ol�ua+[`£ÀfHZ]_��VZ]nua�nio�ªu¬�o%kyj�Z]huX�^�km_�nuZT� o[Z@jq�uZ`�0�uZ`�0o[ZfHZOnVjqo[X[hVfHoD� ^`nVw��uZ`�0o[ZCkm_�iema�_a�nio�o[�ua�nua��0_a�ol�uZ�w ?�B�� ��ª7 �0����/,�*�&��}���3���-�'� ������ ��4�Y�*�'��

¬�n.o[�ikyj�jqa�fHoqkmZ]n*v�o[�ua�aH¿*a�fHoqkm�]a4fHZ]nVjqo[XlhVfHoqkmZ]n.Z` ��Ákyj­wia�jlfHXqkm�Va�wAª`¬ÀoYjq�uZ]hieywC�Va�a�_�u�V^]j�kA@�a�wCo[�V^`o�kmo3j*fHZ]_��VZ]nua�nio3jwia��,a�nVw Z]n E � Z������'ZHE � v*o[�ihVj� ÄZ]XHflk¯nu\¥Z]nua2a��T^Te¯hV^�oqkmZ]nJ�Va�Xjqo[a��*ªY³�Z`��a��Oa�X�vAo[�ua�jqa�^]wuwOkmoqkmZ]nV^�e¡fHZO_�uhuo3^`oqkmZ]nVj�,a�fHZ]_aCnua�\`esk¯\�k¯�iema@^Oj�j|ZpZ]n¦^Oj4o[�ua�wOkm_a�nVj¼k¯ZOn¦Z` Yo[�ua.jq²ujqo[a�_ =YIK>Ykyj4ey^`X[\Oa�a�nuZ]hu\]�*ª� ��� �h��)��!�(�����)��6"��������¢�ua.fHZ]nVwOkmoqkmZ]nVj� ÄZOX�ZOX3wia�XjP�^`X[a�a�nihu_a�X3^�o[a�w��,aHe¯Z`�0olZ]\]a�o[�ua�X%�¢k¯ol��o[�ua�^]jljqZ�flky^`ola�w2o[X[a�a�j�ª

M P�U g]v3g0�$m�=;i � >Ykyj�X[a�t]hikmX[a�w¸�4kmo[�=>i � > �� �

� H�� U ��Z = ] >e P2_(fi��Z�������Z1g�hJ��g � H�K N U ��Z ? ? N ��� �� Z����5��Z � @ d�@ eDt =>P3>M P�U g`� �]vKg �Km�=;i � >�^�nVwi=;i � � � >�^�X[a�X[a�tOhik¯Xla�w��4kmo[�

=;i � � � > ���� ���� H K � U ��Z ? ? � ��� �� Z����5�'Z � @ d @ e Z =)gD>� H I ^ � K � � � U g�� ��Z ? � � � ��� �� Z�������Z � @ e�t =)g`� �D>

AAa�o�� � �Va I K � h �� � � K � � � ªu¬  �=)gD>�kyj�jl^`oqkyj�rVa�wAv,o[�ua�ni=;i � � � >}kgj¢a�t]hikm�T^Te¯a�nio�o[Z� H I ^ � � � U ] t

M P�U g`�J�uvKg ;Km�=;i � >3v =;i � � � >�^`nVw =;i � � � >�^`X[a�Xla�t]hikmX[a�w¸�4kmo[� �

=>i � � � >���������������� ���������������

� H7K � � � U ��Z ? ? � � � ��� �� Z����5�)Z � @ d5@ e�Z =�g`� �\>� H I ^ � K � � � U g��=��Z ? � � � ��� �� Z�������Z � @ e Z =�g`��;\>� H I K � U �� � � Z ? ? ? � ��� �� Z����5��Z � @ d�@ d5@ e�Z =�g`�=��>� H K:tSI ^ � K � � � U g�� �$Z ? ? � Z ? � � � ��� �� Z5�5����Z � @ e5@ d5@ eDZ =�g`� �\>� H I ^ � =�K:tSI K � >VU � � �� � � Z ? � Z ? � ��� �� Z��5�5��Z � @ d�@ eDt =�g`� b\>

AAa�o�� � � � �Va I K � � � h �� � � K � � �`ªi¬  �=)g`�=��>}kgj'j[^`o|kgj¼rVa�wAvuo[�ua�n{=>i � � � >Ykyj%a�tOhikm�T^�ema�nio�o[Z��� a�ØYábZ�^*Ú�^ÀÝ[Ù�á�Ú�Y ZH\�^�a�Ø��AZ3Þ4ßZ3Ù�ØqÙ&^��AäæÚÔØ4ß \�Z�á�à��A^Ac

ÒÔÓ­ÕAÒSÖ

Page 10: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

������������ ������������������� ������������������ "!�#$!�%�&'&)(*�+��������#-,.!����/0���1#����2���3#��54�6�7"(98:, �

� H7I ^ � � � � � U ] =)g ��;�>1Z � H�� � U ] =)g � �K>1Z� H K:tSI ^ � � � U ] =)g �=��>1Z � H I ^ � =�K:t � � > U ] =)g �=b�>1t

M P�U g`� ;uvKg!��m�=;i � >3v =;i � � � >3v�=;i � � � >�^`nVwi=;i � � � >4^`X[a�X[a�tOhikmX[a�w��4kmo[�

=;i � � � >

������������������������������������������������ �����������������������������������������������

� H K � � � U �$Z ? ? � � � ��� �� Z����5�)Z � @ d5@ eDZ =)g �J��>� H7I ^ � K � � � U g ��;KZ ? � � � ��� �� Z�������Z � @ e�Z =)g ��C�>� H I K � � � U �� � � Z ? ? ? � � � ��� �� Z����5��Z � @ d @ d @ e Z =)g �=��>� H K:tSI ^ � K � � � U g � �KZ ? ? � Z ? � � � ��� �� Z5�5�5�'Z � @ e�@ d�@ eDZ =)g � � ] >� H7I ^ � =�K:tSI K � � � > U � � �� � � Z ? � Z ? � � � ��� �� Z5���5��Z � @ d�@ eDZ =)g � �]�D>� H I ^ � =�K:tSI � K � > U � � �� � � ��� � � � � � Z ? � Z ? ? � ��� �� Z5�5�5�'Z � @ d @ d @ e Z =)g � ����>� H I ^ � =�K:tSI�=�K:tSI ^ � K � � � >'>VU � � � � � � � � � �� � � Z ? � Z ? � Z ? � � � ��� �� Z5�5�5��Z � @ e�@ d5@ e�Z =)g � ��;�>� H7I ^ � =�K ��tSI K � > U � � �� � � Z ? � Z � Z ? � ��� �� Z5�5����Z � @ d5@ e�Z =)g � ���K>� H I � K � U �

� � � ��� � � � � � Z ? ? ? ? � ��� �� Z��5�5�'Z � @ d @ d @ d @ e Z =)g � ����>� H I�= K t I ^ � K � � � > U � � �� � � Z ? ? ? � Z ? � � � ��� �� Z5�5�5��Z � @ e�@ d5@ d�@ e�Z =)g � ��b�>� H K:tSI K � U �� � � Z ? ? � Z ? � ��� �� Z5�5�5�'Z � @ d @ d @ e Z =)g � �`��>� H K:tSI ^ � =�K:tSI K � > U � � �� � � Z ? ? � Z ? � Z ? � ��� �� Z5���5��Z � @ d�@ e1@ d5@ e�Z =)g � ��C�>� H K � tSI ^ � K � � � U g � ��Z ? ? � Z � Z ? � � � ��� �� Z5�5�5��Z � @ e�@ d5@ e�t =)g � ����>

AAa�o�� � � � �Va I K � � � h �� � � K � � � ªi¬  �=)g`�J��>}kgj'j[^`o|kgj¼rVa�wAvuo[�ua�n{=>i � � � >Ykyj%a�tOhikm�T^�ema�nio�o[Z� H I ^ � � � � � U ] =)g`� C�>1Z � H � � � � U ] =�g`� �\>1Z� H K:tSI ^ � � � � � U ] =)g`� � ] >1Z � H I ^ � =�K:t � � � � > U ] =�g`� �O�D>1Z� H I ^ � = K t I�� � > U ] =)g`� ����>1Z � H I ^ � =�K:tSI =�K:tSI ^ � � � >'>VU ] =�g`� ��;�>1Z� H7I ^ � = K���t � � > U ] =)g`� ���K>1Z � H�I�� � U ] =�g`� ����>1Z� H I =�K:tSI ^ � � � > U ] =)g`� ��b�>1Z � H K:t � � U ] =�g`� ����>1Z� H�K:tSI ^ � =�K:t � � > U ] =)g`� ��C�>1Z � H7K ��tSI ^ � � � U ] =�g`� ����>1t

�¢�ua�jqa¡fHZOnVwOk¯o|k¯ZOnVj%^`X[a%ZO�uo3^�kmnua�w2�p²2WYX[Z]�,Zpj�kmoqkmZ]n¥��^`nVw��i²hVj�kmnu\@j�km_�iesks Ä²Okmnu\®^Oj[jqhu_�uoqkmZ]nVj�=Ôkmo�kyj}k¯_��VZ]X[oH^`npoolZ�nuZOo[a�o[�V^`o%ol�ua.fHZ]_�VZij�kmo[a._a�ol�uZ�w$?>B@j[^`o|kgj¼rVa�jjdj=¼��g�h �D>3v�ik=�gD>�^`nVwhpz=)g�hJ�D>'>3ª� ��� � � �����#/1�G�����Y�������+���+��¬�n�Z]X3wia�X%olZ�ey^`o[a�X�j�km_�iesks Ô²¦o[�ua�a�tOhV^`oqkmZ]nVj¢ ÄZOXD�.vi�4a�nuZ`� jqo3^�o[a¡j|Z]_a��V^]j�kyf�X[a�jqhiemo3j�ª

�}· � �¨� Q"! ���Xx �Y� B ^ �� B ^ � *r����� UYJ � H �:������� xJ=#K+h B ^ � >rU ] � C��½F½SW3� E ² wiaHrVnikmoqkmZ]n*v��4a¦�V^��]a�x U B ^ � J � H B ^ � ª��¡j�o[�ua¥_a�o[�uZuw ? U =>B.Z � ZC=�>%kyj�jqo|k��2² ^]f�fHhuX3^`o[a]vx U��_J H � �%�ua�X[a�� U B ^ � JÁ^`nVw9J � UV= ] Z�������Z ] Z��D> H ª%³%a�nVfHa]vlxJ=�K h B ^ � >�U�� J H � =#K h1J � H B ^ � >iU�_J H � h�� J H � JZJ H � U��_J H � h�� J H � U ] ª���}· � �¨� l ! ���v=�� ��� � >T��� �}��� �EDEDED � B �Y�k�����.g Fig �5/0������,����+�����k�k!����� 4 I ^ � �:�������Õ�ÕÃÙr��ë��[êHê

Page 11: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

C (���(�%��5�������� ��!���������i��� � U �� 5 B ^ � Z� ��� � ^ � U h �� 5 x`Z� ��� � U ] Z � � � �U � !���# � �U � hJ��t

C��½F½SW3� E ²¦wiaHrVnik¯o|k¯ZOn*v�I I ^ � U��%vikÀªåa]ªe� Z � _ fp��Z�������ZHC g�Z E5�sB �i��� � � � ^ ��N ��� E N � N � � U-#�� � Kt

A a�__@^�Ckyj�o[�ua�n�a�^]j�ksem²��uX[Z`�]a�w2�i²kmnVwihVfHoqkmZ]n¥Z]n � ª���}· � �¨��� ! ��� �X��U a � H� � � Z������'Z�� HB�� � c H �'�J�����DC FOg�#����+���K,5���$��!�/3 ��������� I K � h ���� � K ��� � !���# 9 �(�'�J�����g�#����k����, ������!$/ ��1������jB = � h ��D� � = ��� � *r�������i_ K �)(s����� ���5��.!$/�/X�������������?3 ��glh �_� �X�{� ,B���� ���� �O�e

� _(fi��Z�������ZHC g�Z �X��� � U ��N � � � �P � E N � �� g � ^ N� 9 N t C��½F½SW3��AAa�o��¦�,a�ema�j[j�o[�V^`n�Z]X�a�t]hV^�e�o[Z��g�h �uªK�uZ]X�^Te e � _(fp��Z������)Z�C gpvi�4a��V^��]a��s��� ��U<1���� ����L3��� �,vu�%�ua�X[a

1���� � U � � ^ �N ��� E N =�E N = ��g N JD> � ZL���� � U E5�mB{=AE5�s=M��gn��JD> � h ���� � =GEn� =M��gn��JD> ��� � tL3��� �2f�^`n��VaCaH§��V^`nVwia�wz^]j� ÔZ`esemZT�'jL3��� � U � � N � 7 � �P � E N � �� g � ^ N� Bj=ONlh ��D� � � �D� �N � 7 � � � �P � E�N� g �D� � ^ N� =ON

U � � N � 7 � �P � E N � �� g � ^ N� 9 N h ���� � g �D� �� J�t�%�¢k¯nu\2o[Z ik=�gD>3vi�4a��V^��]a 9 N U ]  ÔZ]X%^�ese­kmnio[a�\]a�XjP���g]vu�ua�nVfHa

L ��� � U ��N � � � �P�� E N � �� g � ^ N� 9 N h �� � � g �D� �� J�tI`km_�ksey^`Xqem²]v71���� �@f�^`n��,a.aH§u�V^`nVwia�w¦^]j

1���� �kU � ^ ��N �� E N � �� � � 7 � �� � E�N g � ^

�N = � � t

��Z`�.v�dk=¼�$g�h �->­km_�ieskma�j�ol�V^`o e � _ f ] Z�������Z3�$g`h=�_g�Z = � UYJ � H = � U �� � � J�Z^�nVw�^]j�+3 ��g�h �uvu�4a�Z]�uo3^Tk¯n

1���� � U ���� � � � � ^ �N ��� � � � � 7 � � � �� � � � E � � �N g � ^ �N � JU ���� � a � � ^ �N ��� =GE N � g N > ��� � h{g ��� �N c JU ���� � a � � ^ �N ��� g �D� �N � � h{g �D� �N c JU ���� � g �D� �� J$t�

ÒÔÓ­ÕAÒSÖ

Page 12: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

������������ ������������������� ������������������ "!�#$!�%�&'&)(*�+��������#-,.!����/0���1#����2���3#��54�6�7"(98:, �

�}· � �¨�����X���!�/�/ � /0�5,�,�����!��¦��g�h �_� x 9 � U ] � C��½F½SW3�A�4�ikyj4 ÔZ`esemZ`��j%^`o%ZOnVfHa' ÄX[ZO_ dk=¼�$g�h �->3ª��}· � �¨��� ! ��� a�� H� � � Z������'Z � HB�� � c H �Y�l������ ��������� I ^ � � � �X�������l�5��`!�/�/������������� ��3 ��g�h��_�7I ^ � � � � , �$�� ����� � e

� _(fp��Z������)Z�C g�Z � ��� ��U ��N � � � �P � E N� g � ^ N� B ^ � 9 N t C��½F½SW3� E ²¨wiaHrVnikmoqkmZ]n*v � ��� ��U � B�'�� �i��� � � � � �Vª��uX[Z]_ AAa�__2^@�uv � ��� ��UQh �� 5 x �s� ^ � � �k� �� 5 B ^ � �s��� �VªF±'j�kmnu\A a�__@^�;uvi�4a�Z]�uo3^Tk¯n

� ��� ��U h �En� ��N � � � �P � E N � �� ^ � g � ^ N� ^ � x 9 N � ��N � � � �P�� E N� g � ^ N� B ^ � 9 N Z^�nVw2��a�hVj|a+AAa�__2^��o[ZfHZ]_�iema�o[aCo[�ua��uX[ZiZ` [ª���}· � �¨���X���!�/�/ � /0�5,�,�����!��¦��g�h{;_� xJ=;=Dt 9 � >:U ] � C��½F½SW3�`�4�ikyjA ÔZ`esemZ`��j*jqo[XH^�km\]�po| ÄZ]Xl�¢^�X3wOem²4 ÄXlZ]_ o[�uaYZ]X3wia�X­fHZOnVwOk¯o|k¯ZOnVj� ÄZ]XAo[�uaYolX[a�a�j ? ? ��� � ��� �� Z�������Z � @ e @ d ^`nVw ? ? � Z ? �

��� �� Z��5�5��Z � @ d @ e @ d ª�

�}· � �¨���� � ! ��� a� H� � � Z������'Z HB�� � c H �'�J������ ��������$ K t I ^ � �X���

� � �+3 ��g�h=��������� ��� � U ��N � � � �P � a E N � �� g � ^ N� =Dt B ^ � 9 N � E N� g �D� � ^ N� B ^ � 9 N c t6 � ! ��� a�� H� � � Z�������Z � HB�� � c H �Y�k�����k ���������QI ^ � =�K:t �X��>��

� � �+3 ��g�h�;�������� � ��� � U ��N � � � �P � a E N � �� g � ^ N� B ^ � =;=Dt 9 N >X� E N� g �D� � ^ N� B ^ � 9 N c t C��½F½SW3� E ²¨wiaHrVnikmoqkmZ]n*v ��� �iU =�En� = � gn� J-> � ��� �¦^`nVw o[�ua�rVX3jqo��V^�X[o�Z` �ol�ua�Xla�jqhiemo�kyj�Z]�uoH^�kmnua�w �i²¨^`�u�iem²Okmnu\A a�__@^�uª ��Z`�.viema�o a 1 H� � � Z�������Z�1 HB�� � c H wia�nuZ]o[aCo[�ua��]a�fHo[ZOX K:t �s�Vª��ÂX[Z]_ AAa�__@^�;uvi�4a.f�^`n��%Xqkmo[a 1���� �2^]j

1��� �kU ��N � � � �P � a E N � �� g � ^ N� =Dt 9 N � E N � �� g �D� � ^ N� 9 N c tµÁa��V^��Oa' ÄhuX[ol�ua�X[_Z]X[a � ��� � U � B�'��� �i��� � 1 � � �,vVjqZo[�V^�o A a�__@^�Cema�^]wuj�o[Z

� ��� � U h �� 5 1�� ^ � � ��� �� 5 B ^ � 1��� �U h�� � N � � � �P � � ����� �5�� N� 5 g � ^ N� xJ=;=Dt 9 N >X� ����� N5�� N� 5 g �D� � ^ N� x 9 N���i� � N � � � �P � a E N � �� g � ^ N� B ^ � =;=Dt 9 N >s� E N� g �D� � ^ N� B ^ � 9 N c t

Õ�ÕÃÙr��ë��[êHê

Page 13: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

� ] (���(�%��5�������� ��!���������¢�ua�X[a�jqhiemo�ol�ua�n��Va�fHZ]_a�j'^fHZ]nVj|a�t]hua�nVfHa�Z` *ema�__2^]j%�2^`nVw�buª�

�}· � �¨����X���!�/�/ � /0�5,�,�����!��¦��g�h{; x B 9 � U ] Zx B�=;=Dt B ^ � 9 ��> U ] t C��½F½SW3�V�¢�ikgj} ÔZ`esemZT�'j� ÔX[Z]_#ol�ua�Z]XHwia�X�fHZ]nVwOkmoqkmZ]nVj� ÔZ]X�o[�ua�olX[a�a�j ? ? �

��� �� Z����5�'Z � @ @ d]v ? ��� � ��� �� Z�������Z � @ d�^`nVw ? � Z ? �D� �

��� �� Z5�5����Z � @ e5@ d]ª�

�}· � �¨����X���!�/�/ � /0�5,�,�����!��¦��g�h¥� xJ=;= � t 9 � > U ] ZxJ=;=Dt B 9 ��> U ] ZxJ=;=Dt B9=;=Dt B ^ � 9 �K>'>VU ] t C��½F½SW3�4�4�ua2X[a�jqhiemo3jC ÔZ`esemZT�  ÄX[ZO_ ol�ua@Z]XHwia�X@fHZ]nVwOkmoqkmZ]nVjC ÔZ]X�o[�ua�o[X[a�a�j ? ? � Z � Z ? �

��� �� Z5�5����Z � @ d5@ e5@ d]v ? ? �D� � ��� �� Z�������Z � @ e5@ d]v? ? � Z ? ? �

��� �� Z��5�5��Z � @ d�@ d5@ e5@ d]v ? ? � Z ? ��� � ��� �� Z5�5�5�'Z � @ d5@ e5@ d.^�nVw ? ? � Z ? � Z ? �D� �

��� �� Z5�5�5�YZ � @ e1@ d�@ e�@ dpª�� ��� &(�!��+��6"��$% �V�M" 2���� �O� "��7�V��/1��"�2���)¬�n�Z]X3wia�X%olZ\]a�o�^�ol�ik¯XHwi£ÔZ]X3wia�X%_a�ol�uZ�wAv�� �V^]j4olZ@j[^`oqkyj� Ô²2o[�ua' ÄZ�e emZ`�4kmnu\�e kmnua�^`X�jq²ujqo[a�_ =YL���� � >1m

� H � U � = ] >1Z � H K � U � =q��>1Z� H K U � =3�D>1Z � H I ^ � � � U ] =�;�>1t

��^DHOkmnu\?C U ��ema�^]wuj'o[Z¦^2jq²�j|o[a�_��¢k¯ol� �@a�tOhV^`oqkmZ]nVj�^�nVw¦��hunKHinuZ`�%nVj�ª��uZ]X�fHZ]ni�]a�nikma�nVfHa]v*�4a�X[a�f�^�ese��VaHemZ`�ol�ua.fHZpaH°®flkma�nio3j�Z` {ol�ua.�`£Àjqo3^`\Oa¡�%^Owu^`h¦¬q¬À� _�a�o[�uZ�wAv

? U �� � � h �� �� � h �

� h � t�¢�ua�_@^`o[Xqks§h\ fHZOX[X[a�jq�,Z]nVwOkmnu\@o[Zz='L��3� � >Ykyj4ol�ua�n¦Z` Yo[�ua' ÔZ]X[_

\ U ���� � � � ��� E � E � �

� =H�:�J��E � > ��� E �� E �� �� =H�:�J��E � � � E �� >)�h ���� E �� �� E �� h ���� =3�`h E � > � �� =H��h E � > ������� Z

^�nVw2��a��V^��]awia�o5=;\ >rU h C

�`��; E � =�� E �� h C�E �� �=��E � h ��>1t³�a�nVfHa]vi ÔZ]X�^�ese4E � _i= ] Z��D>3v \�kyj%nuZOnu£Àj�kmnu\]hiey^`X¡^�nVw�='L��3� � >{�V^Oj4o[�ua� ÔZ`esemZ`�4kmnu\@hunikytOhua�jqZ`emhuoqkmZ]n

� � U �� � N ���N ^ ���N � � ���N ^ � � �N � � N ^ � � �N ^�� � �N � � N ^ � Z � � U �

� � N ���N ^�� ���N � �'� ���N ^ � �N ^ � N � � � �N ^�� � �N � � N ^ � Z� � U h � � � �N ^�� � �N � � � � �N ^ � 7 � N � � � �N ^�� � �N � � N ^ � Z � U h �� � �N ^�� � �N � � � � �N ^�� � N � � � �N ^�� � �N � � N ^ � t

ÒÔÓ­ÕAÒSÖ

Page 14: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

������������ ������������������� ������������������ "!�#$!�%�&'&)(*�+��������#-,.!����/0���1#����2���3#��54�6�7"(98:, �]�

� ��� &(�!��+��6"��$% �V�M" 2���� �O� "��7�V��/1��"�2���)¬�n�Z]X3wia�X%olZ\]a�o�^Cru Ôo[�u£ÔZ]XHwia�X%_a�o[�uZuwAv�� _�hVj|o¢jl^`oqkyj� Ô²@o[�ua� ÄZ�e emZ`�4kmnu\�eskmnua�^`X.jq²ujqo[a�_ =YL���� � >1m

� H � U � = ] >�Z � H K U � =¼��>1Z� H�K U � =3�D>�Z � H7I ^ � � U ] =¼b�>1Z� H K � U � =¼��>�Z � H � � U ] =[��>1Z� H K � U � =);�>�Z � H K:tSI ^ � � � U ] =)C�>1Z� H I ^ � � � U ] =À�K>�Z � H I ^ � =�K:t � � >VU ] =¼��>1t

��^DHOkmnu\`C�U ;%nuZ`�Áema�^]wujYo[Z�^'jq²�j|o[a�_ �¢k¯ol��ola�n�a�tOhV^`oqkmZ]nVj��uhuoYZOnie¯²Cnikmnua%hunKHpnuZ`�%nVj«ªT³�Z`��a��Oa�X�v��4a4�4kse eFj|�uZT�kmn�o[�ikyj%j|a�fHoqkmZ]n*vuo[�V^`o4Z]nua�Z� ­o[�ua�jqa�a�tOhV^`oqkmZ]nVj�kyj�kywia�nioqkyf�^�esem²¨j[^`o|kgj¼rVa�wAªAd�Z`esema�fHoqkmnu\®^Te e�X[a�jqhiemo3j4Z` MI]a�fHoqkmZ]n¨�uª �uv�4a�\]a�o

� � U ���E� 9 �E� 9 �E� 9 �

�� Z I ^ � � � U ��

�E �� B ^ � 9 �E �� B ^ � 9 �E �� B ^ � 9 �

�� Z

I ^ � � U ���E� B ^ � 9 E� B ^ � 9 � � E �� g � B ^ � 9 �E� B ^ � 9 � � E �� g � B ^ � 9 �

� � Z I ^ � =�K:t � � > U ��

�E� B ^ � =;=Dt 9 � >E� B ^ � =;=Dt 9 � >X� E �� g � B ^ � 9 �E� B ^ � =;=Dt 9 � >X� E �� g � B ^ � 9 �

� � Z

K:tSI ^ � � � U ���E� =Dt B ^ � 9 �E� =Dt B ^ � 9 � � E �� g � B ^ � 9 �E� =Dt B ^ � 9 � � E �� g � B ^ � 9 �

� � t

A a�o�� � �Va>I ^ � � h=� I ^ � =�K:t � � >3v � � �,a K:tSI ^ � � � h�I ^ � =�K:t � � >3v�� � �Va B ^ � 9 h � B ^ � =>=Dt 9 � >�^`nVw�� � �Va=Dt B ^ � 9 � h B ^ � =;=Dt 9 � >3ªu¬�o4kyj4 ÔZ]hunVw2o[�V^`o� � U ��

�E� � �E� � �E� � �

�� ^`nVw�� � U ��

�E� � �E� � �E� � �

�� Z

^�nVw2o[�ua.jq²ujqo[a�_ ='L ��� � >Ykyj%a�tOhikm�T^�ema�nio�o[Z� H � U � = ] >�Z � H K U � =¼��>1Z� H�K U � =3�D>�Z � H � � U ] =¼b�>1Z� H K � U � =¼��>�Z � H � � U ] =[��>1Z� H�K � U � =);�>�Z � H � � U ] =)C�>1Z� H I ^ � � � U ] =À�K>�Z � H I ^ � =�K:t � � >VU ] =¼��>1t

� [F·i½F��·�� Q � � ��� � !��3#�� � !����/0������!��/ �k#��}�\����#�������� C��½F½SW3�,¬Ào�kyj%a�nuZ]hu\O��o[Z@jq�uZ`�0o[�V^�o � � v�� � ^`nVw 9 � ^`Xla'e kmnua�^`X|e¯²¥wia��Va�nVwia�nio�ªsI`k¯nVfHa�? U =;BJZ � Z�=�>Akyj%Z` YZ]X3wia�X�� ÄZ]X4o[�ua.wOks¿*a�X[a�nioqky^�e�fHZ]_�VZOnua�npo�vÂ��a��V^��]a

� H B ^ � = U ��Z � H B ^ � =;=Dt Bj= � > U � Z� H B = � U �� 7 Z � H = U � Z� H =Dt B ^ � = U Zj|Z�ol�V^`o � H 9 � U � H�� � U � H�� � U ] ª ��Z`�.v � �U ] km_�iesk¯a�j'ol�ua�X[a�jqhiemo�ª �

��·��=�V��� Q�� �������� ���@E � U-E � U-E � U �� �r�����k ��������$',QI ^ � � � � � � !���#�� ��� � �$B�n4�!����/0�� �Y�1�����k�./0������!�1/ �#$���\����#�������� (�� ���� ��J����� ,��r���r� ,B,5%������������v��� ,1��� * ����!�� B ^ � 9 � � 9 � !��3# � � !���k#����K����#$��������(�, � H B ^ � 9 � U

Õ�ÕÃÙr��ë��[êHê

Page 15: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

��� (���(�%��5�������� ��!��������� H = � h � � H B ^ � = U ] �@*r�2��!��{��������/0%�#���!D,���� (X���1������ � �"&1�{����� ,��1!D,5�O� � #��}�\���3#D,+�$�����3���K!��!��k����������!��`�1!��(�'�k�n���D,5����, ��!D,.�����k���3���k��� �k��������%�!��3�����6��

������ H7�� � � � = 9 >� �5v= 9 >�� H 6�= 9 >XhJ�� -Z*v������ p$B@1'�De�=q��>kU f 9 _hp$B@1'�De��A23= 9 >vU �_g � (X��� ,O,5�1���J,O!{��!$��%��!�/r����!�/`���{!��n������ �� �B,5���3�1�2����� ,2� ,2!��!$����������`���2�k���3���k��� ��������/0����!�/����)�$ � � �$.������ ����������3�1� �@(�! �n/ �k62����/�/ ������,�������������5,.��� p B)1��DeD=q��>B!��3#2����� �!�/0%��n,.���.������!-,1,5������!�����#`�5%��3���������K, � ��5 !���#>6 �)(����1�$����%���������� ��� ,�� *r�+��G� ������������ ������� ������� 9 � = 9 > 5 = 9 > 6�= 9 >? ? ��� �� Z�������Z � @ d @ e � � = ? � ��� �� Z�������Z � @ e � �� B ^ � = �? ? ? � Z � Z � Z � @ d�@ d�@ e � � B = ? ? � Z ? ��� �� Z��5�5��Z � @ e1@ d5@ e � � =Dt B ^ � = ? � Z ? � Z � Z � Z � @0d'@ e b � B ^ � =;=Dt B = >? � Z ? ? � Z � Z � @ d @ d @ e b � 7

� B ^ � =;=Dt B � = � >? � Z ? � Z ? � Z � Z � @0e�@ d�@ e �`� � B ^ � =;=Dt B�=;=Dt B ^ � = >'>? � Z � Z ? � Z � Z � @0d'@ e ��� �� B ^ � =;=&��t B = � >? ? ? ? � Z � Z � @ d'@ d5@ d5@ e � � ] B �O= �? ? ? � Z ? � Z � Z � Z � @ e�@ d5@ d�@ e � B9=;=Dt B ^ � = >? ? � Z ? � Z � Z � @ d @ d @ e � � =Dt Bj= �? ? � Z ? � Z ? � Z � Z � @ d'@ e1@ d�@ e �]� =Dt B ^ � =;=Dt B = � >? ? � Z � Z ? � Z � Z � Z � @ e�@ d5@ e � ] � = � t B ^ � =

��^`�iema��Kmu��X[a�a�j�Z`  p$B@1�� e =¼��>�^`nVw2o[�uaHkmX�^]j[jqZuflky^`o[a�w2 ÔhunVfHoqkmZ]nVj� ��� ��V��"���2-��% "�2������*���! #"%$

��Z�^Of[�ikma��]a�Z]XHwia�X��' ÔZ]X�ol�ua.^�em\]a��uX3^�kyf'fHZ]_�VZOnua�npo�vi�4a'�V^��Oa�o[Z�jqZ`em�]a�o[�ua�jq²ujqo[a�_ ='L��3� >�fHZ]_�,Zpjqa�w2Z` r=;i >3v=>i >Hv�=;i � >{^`nVwz=;i � >:=¼j|a�a�I]a�fHoqkmZ]n¦�uªm�->3v`o[�V^`o�kyj�o[Z�jl^�²�`�Ca�t]hV^�oqkmZ]nVj�ªud�Z]_�V^`Xqkmnu\�o[�ua%nihu_��Va�X4Z` *a�tOhV^`oqkmZ]nVj^�nVw¦ol�ua�nihu_��Va�X�Z` 4hunKHpnuZ`�%n*vA�4a�fHZ]hieyw fHZ]nVjqa�tOhua�npo|e¯²¥o[�ikmnKH¥Z` 4o3^DHOk¯nu\?C�U:buª,¬Àn¥ À^]fHo�vÂkmo.f�^`n¥�Va@j|�uZT��nol�V^`o C�U ��kgj�j|hi°®flkma�npo�v*j¼k¯nVfHa2�a�tOhV^`oqkmZ]nVj�^`Xla.kywia�nioqkyf�^�esem²=j[^`oqkyj�rVa�w =¼j|a�aOI]a�fHo|k¯ZOn=buªm�D>HªV³%Z`�4a��]a�X�v�k¯o.wiZia�jnuZOo.jqa�a�_�X[a�^]jqZOnV^`�iema@^`ni²�_Z]X[a�o[Z¦fHZ]nVj¼kgwia�X�^2�uX3^]fHoqkyf�^�eYkm_�iema�_a�nio3^`o|k¯ZOn Z` �ol�ua fHZOX[X[a�jq�,Z]nVwOkmnu\¨_�a�o[�uZ�wAvZ`�4kmnu\olZ�ol�ua�fHZ]_�iemaH§ikmo¼²�Z� ­o[�ua� ÔZ]X[_�hiey^]j} ÔZ]X%�T^�Xqky^`�iema j|o[a��Vj�kA@�a]ª��·��=�V��� l & ��������,5������,5�&�5��� ,"�����K,5��!��3� � �6� ����E � U-E � U ������U<E . ���������'���(��%�!��������K,�!���l��#$����������!�/�/ ��, !$��� ,*)"��#� ,5�1�,+�����������.- � � ���:!���# C �1!��I�Y�.�n���D,5���i�/��%�!$/X�����*�0 1 �.$2��2@��"4���3����/0�*� ���������C$�� #+<8:+4365

�¢�ua.;`£Àjqo3^`\Oa.�%^]wu^`h�¬q¬À��_a�o[�uZuw2�V^]j��Va�a�n�km_�iema�_a�nio[a�wz�i²®©�ªV³�^Tk¯Xla�X¡^`nVwz´�ªuµ=^`nunua�X¢k¯n¥Z]XHwia�X%o[ZjqZ`em�]a�uXlZ]�iema�_@jYZ` Ao[�ua� ÄZOX[_ \ R U xJ= >3ª�����©�jY^`nVw��%��©�j�Z` ,kmnVwiaH§ema�j[jYo[�V^�n�ZOXYa�t]hV^�eVolZ�o[�uX[a�a%f�^`n�,a�jqZ`em�]a�w�i².ol�ikgj4fHZuwia]vpf�^�esema�w2�4�¡����±'�uª`� �uX[a�flkyjqa�wia�j[fHXqkm�uoqkmZ]n�kgj}\`km�]a�n�kmn�I]a�fHoqkmZ]n@¬87�£TC ? ³�µ �Â�1@V^�nVw��4a��¢k ese­^]wiZ]�uool�ua�nuZOo3^`oqkmZ]nVj'hVjqa�wÁo[�ua�X[a]ªA¬�_�iema�_a�nioqkmnu\¨ZOhuX�_a�o[�uZuw¥X[a�tOhik¯Xla�j.j�eskm\]�io._ZuwOksrFf�^`oqkmZ]nVjCo[Z�o[�ua@j|hu�uX[Z]huoqkmnua�j~ X3^]wufHZ]X1��^`nVw{~«jqZ`emZ]huo1�����ikgfl�¨^�X[a.^]fHo[hV^�esem²�X[a��iey^]fHa�w¸X[a�jq�Va�fHo|k¯�OaHe¯²z�p²{~HX3^OwufHZ]X @���^`nVw�~«jqZ`emZ]huo @��uª

ÒÔÓ­ÕAÒSÖ

Page 16: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

������������ ������������������� ������������������ "!�#$!�%�&'&)(*�+��������#-,.!����/0���1#����2���3#��54�6�7"(98:, ��;�G��� � ��)���� ���!"��#����$"��9����)����V��%niem²2o[�ua�fHZ]_�uhuo3^`o|k¯ZOn@Z` �o[�ua¡^Te¯\Oa��uX3^�kyf�fHZ]_�,Z]nua�npo9=)[�>*kyj4_�Z�wOksrVa�wi= k  Y^`nkmnVwiaH§¦���%��©Ákyj%jqZ`em�]a�w3>3ª��%nVfHaol�ua �����jqo[a����V^]j¢�Va�a�n¨^Of�fHa��uo[a�wAvVoq�4Z�f�^Ojqa�j�^�X[a.fHZ]nVj�kywia�X[a�w�m�Oª�e¯a�jlj%o[�V^�n�o[�uX[a�a.jqo[a��Vj¢�V^��Oa��,a�a�n fHZO_�uhuo[a�wAªV�4�ua�n*vÂ��a�HOa�a���o[�ua'kmnpo[a�XlnV^�e{jqo3^�\]a�j`[5��� � v3[5��� � vK[n��� � ^`nVwo[�ua�jqola��¦j�kA@�a+�K�Aªu�4�ua.�`^�emhua.Z` `= P ��� � Z1[5�D� � >Ykyj9= P ��� � Z�[5��� � >3ª�ª4o[�uX[a�a�Z]X%_ZOX[a�jqola��Vj'�V^��Oa��Va�a�n=fHZ]_��uhuo[a�wAªF�¢�ua�n*vA��aJH]a�a��¦ol�ua.kmnio[a�X[nV^�e�jqo3^�\]a�j�[5�$� � v[n��� � v�[5�$� � ^`nVwo[�ua�jqola��¦j�kA@�a+� � ª E � v E � ^�X[a.fHZ]_�uhuo[a�w2�i²2o[�ua� ÔZ]X[_�hiey^]j

E � U � � ^ ���� ^ � ����� ^ � � �K� ^`nVw�E � U � � ^ ���� ^ � ����� ^ � ����� Z^`nVw?� �p²2o[�ua.jqhu�uXlZ]huoqkmnua ~H�Oa�fHo¼�'���uª��ÂZ]X�= P �D� � Z1[n��� � >���a��uhuo

P �D� � U P �$� � Z[5��� � U � � [n� ^ � � � � � � [n� ^ � � � � � � [n� ^ � � � � � [n� ^ � � � � � [n� ^ � � � �� � [ � ^ � � � � � � [ ��� � � � � [ ��� � � � � [ ��� � t��·��=�V��� � �X��������3�����3%���%$,O��%��F�%���,C� *r� �3�1��# !$/ ,5�i��� ������������� ��������1�3!�/v,5��!����n,O�� ������*r�i,5������,�� �� �����#$� 0B�����������!�/��������\���3������, � , ����,5�1�������$� � � 6 � 6 � ��G��� ����0��+��� �V+�"��G��!�� Rml*R6Q � ·u�`�H» l¬�n¥Z]X3wia�X�o[Z�fHZ]_�uhuo[a�o[�ua� ÄZOX[_@^�eYaH§��uXla�j[j�kmZ]n¥Z`  � ^�nVw¦olZ®fHX[a�^�o[a�o[�ua^]j[jqZuflky^`o[a�w¸ ÄZOX[o[X3^`n¦j|hu�uX[Z]huoqkmnua]vAo[�ua_2^`nikm�uhieg^�oqkmZ]n=�V^Of'H`^`\]a �¥^`�iema�%^]j'hVjqa�wAª��Ãf�^�ese�olZ��]a�fHoq���2hVjqa�j�ol�ua� ÄZOX[_@^`o� ������������������ �"!# $�%!'& (!'&���)�v���ua�X[a.o[�ua�kmnu�uhuo3j�^�X[a.Z]nuaCZ` Yo[�ua�rV�]a�f�^]jqa�j%wia�jlfHXqkm�Va�w¥�,aHe¯Z`�*=*�����+�D>�^`nVw¸o[�ua.�V^�X3^`_a�o[a�XHj@E � v�E � =,&-(!'&��K>3ª�¢�ua�Z]huo[�uhuo4kyj�o[�ua��]a�fHo[Z]X � =. $�2>Hª\��km�]a�f�^]jqa�j%^�X[a.fHZ]nVj�kywia�X[a�w�m�Oª@E � U E � U E � U �

� ª,¬Àn¥o[�ikyj'f�^]jqa]v,��aC�V^��]a�jqa�a�nzo[�V^`o � wia��,a�nVwuj�Z]nzZ]nua.�V^�X3^`_a�o[a�X�ªu¬Ào�kyj'Z]�uoqkm_�kA@�a�w^]j4aH§u�ieg^Tk¯nua�w¸kmn¨�¢a�_@^`X'H �]ª

�ª@E � U-E � ^�nVwVE � �U-E � ª;ª@E � U-E � ^�nVwVE � �U-E � ª�,ª@E � U-E � ^�nVwVE � �U-E � ª�ª@E � �U-E � v�E � �U E � ^`nVw?E � �U E � ª

�¢�ikgjC^�esemZT�'j'hVj�o[Z2X[a�wihVfHa2o[�uafHZpjqo�Z` %fHZ]_�uhuo3^`o|k¯ZOn ^�nVw¥o[Z�aHeskm_�kmnV^`o[a�fHZ]_�uhuo3^`o|k¯ZOnV^�e��uX[Z]�iema�_@j5mA�V^Ow¥�4ahVj|a�w2o[�ua.\]a�nua�XH^�e*aH§��uX[a�jlj�kmZ]n¦Z`  � =¼f�^]jqa.��>Hv�wOkm�Okyj�kmZ]nVj'�p²$@�a�X[Z2�4Z]hieyw2�V^��Oa�Z�f�fHhuX[a�w®kmn¦o[�ua.f�^]j|a�j���o[Z�,ª� Rml*Rml T ½�UV� p U �F½ � ��½��A� o �A���¬�n=ol�ua¦fHZ�wia��%^]wu^`hV�Âv­ol�ua®jqhu�uXlZ]huoqkmnua�~�jqZ`emZ]huo��¦�uXlZT�Okywia�jCo[�ua@hVj|a�X�4kmo[�J^`�u�uX[Z�§pkm_@^�oqkmZ]nVj�^`o�a�t]hikywOkyjqo3^`nioZOhuo[�uhuo[£Ô�VZ�k¯nio3j�ªi�4�ua�fHZ]X[X[a�jq�,Z]nVwOkmnu\�kmnpola�X[�VZ`ey^`o|k¯ZOn2 ÄZ]Xl_�hiey^]j�^`X[a4km_�iema�_a�nio[a�w®k¯n2o[�ua�jqhu�uX[Z]huo|k¯nua�~�fHZ]nio[X3�$�uª~«fHZ]npolX3��=À¬Hv §>��%\`km�]a�j4^`n�^`�u�uX[Z�§ikm_@^`oqkmZ]n �0/�= � >*o[Z�o[�ua K ��� fHZ]_�,Z]nua�npo4Z` �o[�ua¡j|Z`emhuoqkmZ]n ^`o�ol�ua��,Z`kmnpo ]�=;]j|�uZ]hieyw2eskma�kmn¦o[�ua�kmnpo[a�Xl�T^�e ? ]K��Z�]K��� � @�>Hª � kyj%o[�ua.fHZ�e emZuf�^`oqkmZ]n¥�VZ�e¯²inuZ]_�ky^�eTmÂkmo%kyj4Z` �wia�\]X[a�ak;�^`nVw¦wiaHrVnua�w¸�p²

��=;]��K> U ��Z��=;]���� =�������>VU �$� �'Z � U ��Z3�KZ�;KtÕ�ÕÃÙr��ë��[êHê

Page 17: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

�«� (���(�%��5�������� ��!���������ÂZ]X�kmnVwiaH§ ����¡©�j�v � Uy= 9 Z ��>Y�%�ua�X[a 9 Z �^`X[a��,Z`em²pnuZO_�ky^�eyj'Z` }wia�\OX[a�a.;��%�ikyfl�¨j[^`o|kgj¼ Ä²

9 =;]���> U P ��Z ��=;]��K> U [5��Z9 =;]��.� =����K�3> U P ��� ��Z ��=;]���� =�� ����>VU [5�$� �)Z � U ��Z3�KZ�;KtE ²��4�ua�Z]X[a�_ ��£TC�= ? ³�µ0�u�'@G>3vi��a��V^��]a

9 =;] > h P =;]�>rU-,j=)� >�^`nVw �K=>]�>Xh{[�=;] >rU-,k=)� � >1t��j'Z]huX.^�km_ kgj�o[Z2kmnVfHX[a�^]jqa�o[�uaZ]X3wia�X�Z� ¢fHZ]ni�]a�X[\]a�nVfHa  ÄZ]X'o[�ua@^Te¯\Oa��uX3^�kyffHZ]_�,Z]nua�nio�v,kmo�jqa�a�_@j�nV^`o[huX3^Te{o[Zj|a�^`X3fl�' ÄZ]X�^`n�^`�u�uXlZ�§ikm_@^`oqkmZ]n��J=>]�>:U|= r =;]�>1Z�;$=;]�>'>iZ`  =>]�>rUy= P =;]�>1Z�[�=;] >'>�j[^�oqkyj� Ä²Okmnu\��J=>]�>5h =;]�>rU ,k=)� >3ª� o o���½�� p � �u� p ½VU ½SW [�=>]�>A a�oj]��,a.Z` Yo[�ua' ÔZ]X[_ ]�� ^ � ���D�z�%�ua�X[a.�zU �K� ^ � ���K� ^ � �����Vªuµ a.wiaHrVnua$;�^]j} ÔZ`ese¯Z`��j

;$=;]�>rU �� � ��� � � =��$>)[ � ^ � � � � � � ��� =��$>)[ � ^ � � � � � � �3� =��$>)[ �$� � Z���ua�X[a�o[�ua��]a�fHo[ZOXD��=���>rU|=�� � =��$>1Z������'Z�� � =��$>'> H j[^`oqkyj�rVa�j4ol�ua'e kmnua�^`X.j|²�jqola�_

L e��� � =���> ������� ������

� Hv=��$> � U � = ] >�Z � Hr=��$>�K U � =¼�\>1Z

� H =��$>�K U � =3�D>�Z � H =��$> � � U ] =¼b\>1Z� Hv=��$>�K � U �� =¼��>�Z � Hr=��$>�� � U ] =[�$>1Z� H =��$>�K � U � � =);�>�Z � H =��$> � � U ] =)C\>1Z� H =��$>GI ^ � � � U ] =À�K>�Z � H =��$>GI ^ � = K t � � > U ] =¼�\>1t

±'j�kmnu\o[�uaCnuZ]o3^`o|k¯ZOnVj�Z� }jqa�fHo|k¯ZOn¨�uªå�,vp�4a��V^��]a

C��½*o�½F� p � p ½VU l �X���!�/�/�k_i= ] Z��5@6�XL e��� � =��$>M�\�D,�,5�5,�, �n,B!�, �$/ %��������i!���#;$=;]K� ^ � ���D��> h [�=;]�� ^ � ��D��>`U-,k=�� >1t

C��½F½SW3���uX[ZO_��4�ua�Z]X[a�_ C`£À�^`nVw2C`£Àb�k¯n ? ³�µ �Â�1@�vp�4a��V^��]a;�=>]K� ^ � ���� > h{[\=;]K� ^ � ��D��>:U ,k=)� >Yks¿ � H =��$>�6�= 9 >rU ��� � � �

5v= 9 > Ze9 _hp$B@1'�De�Z 2�= 9 >43!��t

��f�fHZ]X3wOkmnu\�o[Z2o[�ua^`nV^�em²uj�kyj'Z` ¢j|a�fHoqkmZ]n �uªm�]vuol�ikgj�ema�^]wuj�o[Z2o[�uajq²�j|o[a�_ L e��� � =��$>%�%�ikyf[�*vA�i²¨�¢�ua�Z]X[a�_9�]vV�,Zpjq£j|a�j[jqa�j%^j|Z`emhuoqkmZ]n*ª��

�¢�ua¡jqhu�uXlZ]huoqkmnuaj~ �]a�fHoq� @��.fHZ]_��uhuo[a�jQ��=��$>3ªO�¡j{ ÄZOX�o[�ua'�]a�fHo[Z]XQ�.v�rV�]a�f�^]jqa�j4^`X[a�fHZOnVj�kywia�X[a�wAªuµ �ua�n � � ^ � U��� ^ � U ���Fv@�9=��$>®wia��,a�nVwujzZ]n0Z]nua �V^�X3^`_a�o[a�Xi=qf�^]jqaJ�D>@���ikgfl� kyjznuZ]o¦^]w�~qhVjqo[a�w0^Oj�k¯n �4a�_@^�X'H �]ª4¬Ànol�ikgj�f�^]jqa]vYo[�uaz�T^�emhua¥wiaHrVnua�w �i²JfHZ]npo|k¯nihikmoq²  ÄZ]X>��=��$>�kyj2f[�uZiZpjqa�n*ª}� f�^�ese�o[Z�~H�]a�fHoq� @��¥hVj|a�j�o[�ua� ÔZ]X[_2^`o �������� �������� �"!# $�� �!'& (!'&���!#��)�v]�%�ua�X[a�o[�uaCkmnu�uhuo3j�^`Xla�ZOnua.Z` 4o[�ua�rV�]af�^]j|a�j�wia�j[fHXqkm�Va�w¥�,aH ÄZOX[a�=*����� �->�^`nVwol�ua��V^`X3^`_a�ola�X3jQE � v E � v���=ÀXla�jq�Va�fHoqkm�]aHem² &-(!'&���!#�v>3ªu�4�ua�Z]huol�uhuo4kyj%o[�ua��Oa�fHo[Z]XD�9=��$>�=. $�� �>3ª� o o���½�� p � �u� p ½VU ½SW P =;]�>A a�oj]��,a.Z` Yo[�ua' ÔZ]X[_ ] � ^ � � tK�2�%�ua�Xla+�zU � � ^ � � � � ^`nVw2� � ^ � U-ED�*ªuµÁa.wiaHrVnua rz^]j� ÔZ`ese¯Z`��j

r�=;] >rU ��� ��� d���=>t3>)[5� ^ � � �K� d � ����=>t3>)[5�$� �TZÒÔÓ­ÕAÒSÖ

Page 18: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

������������ ������������������� ������������������ "!�#$!�%�&'&)(*�+��������#-,.!����/0���1#����2���3#��54�6�7"(98:, ���

���ua�X[a�o[�ua��]a�fHo[ZOXjdk=;t3>rU|= d � =>t3>1Z����5�)Z�d � =;t3>'> H j[^`o|kgj¼rVa�j%o[�ua'eskmnua�^`X�jq²ujqo[a�_L d��� � =;t3> ��� ��

d HM=;t3> U � = ] >1Z d Hr=>t3>;i � U t � =);�>1Zd H =;t3>;i U t =3�->1Z d H =>t3>;i U t =À�K>1Zd H =;t3>;i � U t � =¼�\>1Z d H =>t3>GIki � U � � =¼��>1t=�IOZ�I H dk=3�D>�ZCik>,kyjYo[�ua'�4hunu\]a�£À¤'huo[o3^C_a�ol�uZ�w�? � Z]�uo3^�kmnua�w��p²�o[�ua'fHZ]_�VZij�kmoqkmZ]n@Z� Fo[�uaB;�£Àjqo3^`\]a%�%^Owu^`h¬q¬À�_�a�o[�uZ�w$? Uy=;BJZ � Z�=�>*ZT�Oa�X%oq��Zjqola��Vj�v

? � U E�= E�B ]E�J`� =3��h E�>>= E�J � H =H��h E$>;B

E � =H��h E$> � Z^�nVw kyj%ol�ua��]a�fHo[Z]X�= � ��� ���Z�������Z���> H ª C��½*o�½F� p � p ½VU � e tO_ = ] Z��n@TZ r =;]K� ^ � � tK� >Xh P =;]K� ^ � � tK��>vU-,k=�� >1t C��½F½SW3�vAAa�o�hVj�kmnio[X[ZuwihVfHa�o[�ua��]a�fHo[Z]X p2=>t3>:U I ^ H dj=;t3>`UQ=�pk�c=;t3>'> � ��� �EDEDED � � ^�nVw¦ol�ua. ÔZ`esemZ`�4kmnu\��VZ`em²inuZ]_�ky^�e9 m

9 =;]�� ^ � � tK��>rU P � ^ � � �� � �� pk�c=;t3>)Ws= P � ^ � � �TZ1[n� ^ � � �c>� pk� � � =;t3>)Ws= P ��� �TZ�[5�$� ��>1t�ÂX[Z]_Ã�4�ua�Z]Xla�_ C`£À�^`nVw2C�£ÀbCkmn ? ³�µ0�u��@Àvi��a��V^��]a9 =;]�� ^ � � tK� >Xh P =;]K� ^ � � tK��>vU-,k=�� >Yks¿ p H =;t3>�6�=TS'>vU t�� � � �

5v=TSY>e S`_hp$B@1��-d�Z 2�=cS'> 3J� =��J>�t

±'j�kmnu\o[�uaC�VZ`kmnio3j4Z` Yo[�ua'kmnio[a�X[nV^�e{j|o3^`\]a�j�vOkmo� ÄZ`esemZ`��j

9 =;]K� ^ � � tK��>rUYLJ=�� > P � ^ � � �� � �� pk�G=;t3> P � ^ � � �3� pk� � � =;t3> P ��� �TZj|Z�ol�V^`o�=��J>Ykyj�a�t]hikm�`^�ema�npo�o[Z�o[�ua.j|²�jqola�_ L d�3� � =;t3>3ª���¢�ua¦jqhu�uX[Z]huoqkmnua ~H�]a�fHoq�%²K�¦fHZ]_�uhuola�j dk=;t3>Hª­��f�^�ese�o[Z�~H�Oa�fHo¼��²\�zhVjqa�j�ol�ua2 ÄZ]Xl_@^`o ��������� � $��� !'& !#��)�v���ua�X[a4o[�ua4kmnu�uhuo3j�^�X[a%o[�ua4�V^`X3^�_a�o[a�X3j:E'^`nVw tj=ÀX[a�jq�,a�fHoqkm�]aHem²�& !#� >­^�nVw�o[�ua4Z]huo[�uhuo�o[�ua4�]a�fHo[Z]X�dj=;t3>r=. $��� >3ª�¢�ua¡jqhu�uXlZ]huoqkmnuaj~«jqZ`emZ]huo @��C�uX[Z`�Okgwia�j�o[�ua'hVjqa�X4�4kmo[��^`�u�uX[Z�§ik¯_2^`oqkmZ]nVj�=sr�=;] �

�8� � >1Z�;$=;] � �8� � >'>­Z` M= P =>] � �8� � >�Z1[�=;] � �8� � >'>^�o�a�tOhikywOkyjqo3^`nio�Z]huo[�uhuo[£Ô�,Z`kmnpoHjl=;] ��8� � >T� ��� �EDEDED � ��ª3�uZ]X4o[�ua�wOk ¿*a�X[a�nioqky^�e{fHZO_�VZ]nua�nio�v!] � �8� � kyj%Z� ­o[�ua� ÔZ]X[_ ]�� ^ � �t3=��K� ^ � ���K��>��%�ua�Xla t®kyj�f[�uZiZpjqa�n jqZ�^]j�o[Z®jl^`oqkyj� Ô²h]K���1] �

� � � 31]���� � ^`nVw¸ ÄZOX�o[�ua^�em\]a��uXH^�kyf.ZOnua]v*] � � � � kyjZ� ¢ol�ua� ÄZOX[_ ] � ^ � � �$=)� � ^ � � � � ^ � � � � >%���ua�X[a �®kyj�fl�uZiZpjqa�n¥kmnJj[^`oqkyj� Ô²I] � ^ � � ] � �8� � 3 ] � ª���f�^�ese�o[Z~«jqZ`emZ]huo @��ChVjqa�j�o[�ua' ÔZ]X[_@^`o��������� ����$& !� ������ !� !�� !��$����� ! ����� � !'& (!'&���!������-��!��-��!�����!�� � � ��)�Z

���ua�X[a�o[�uaCk¯nu�uhuoHj.^`X[aCo[�ua�nphu_��,a�X�Z` ¢^]f�fHa��uola�w¨j|o[a��VjJ=��$&�>3v�]K�i=� ������X>3vV]���� � =� r>3vs= P ��� � Z�[5��� � >�=�� >3vuo[�uaj|²�jqola�_ �æj%wOkm_a�nVj�kmZ]n =��-���r>3vÂZ]nua.Z` Yo[�ua�rV�]a�f�^]j|a�j�wia�j[fHX|k¯�,a�w¥�VaH ÔZ]X[a� ÄZOX%o[�ua�fHZO_�uhuo3^`oqkmZ]n�Z� =��=��$>�=������ �->3vol�ua��V^`XH^`_a�o[a�X3jQEi�]v E`� = & (!'&��K>Hvpol�ua¡jqola��Vj�kA@�a+�K� ^ � � ��� ^ � �{�K�AvK�K� ^ � vK�K�2=������-��!��$��!����K>Y^`nVw�^ E ZiZ`ema�^`n�`^`Xqky^`�iema�=�� � � �v>�olZ.kmnVwOkyf�^`o[aCks �o[�ua'ey^]jqo'fHZ]_�uhuo3^`o|k¯ZOnV^�e­jqo[a��¦�V^Oj4�Va�a�nzX[a�^]fl�ua�wAªÕ�ÕÃÙr��ë��[êHê

Page 19: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

��b (���(�%��5�������� ��!��������

-2

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

0.01 0.1 1 10

significant digits

cpu time

modified radau5radau5

��km\]huX[a�$mVWYX[a�flkyj�kmZ]nz�]a�X3jqhVj�fHZ]_�uhuoqkmnu\2oqkm_a.£�^�em\]a��uXH^�kyf.fHZ]_�,Z]nua�nio3j4£�ola�jqo4�uX[Z]�iema�_� � &�-�4��[��"¡1 ��6����4���� �����*/

�G��� � �!�Z" �����$����!/µÁa.fHZ]nVj�kywia�X�ol�ua'k¯nVwiaH§¥oq��Z��uX[ZO�ie¯a�_�m

��� ��P R =TSY> U � R =TS'> � ] h��

� ] �iP =TSY>���[�=TSY> P =TS'>] U P H =TS'> P =TSY>Xh � Z'S:_ ? h���Z��]�n@TZ���ua�X[a��0kyj4o[�ua� ÄZ�e emZ`�4kmnu\�k¯nirVnikmo[aHem²¥jq_ZiZ]o[�2 ÔhunVfHoqkmZ]nXm

��=TS'>MU ������� ������

� � aH§u� a � �� � ^ � c k   � S�� �0��Z� � aH§u� a � � ^ � �� � ^ � � ^ � c k   � S h=� � �0�$Z� � aH§u� a � � ^ � 7 � �� � ^ � 7 � � ^ � c k   � S h � ] � � ��Z] Z]o[�ua�X[�4kyjqa�Z

�¢k¯ol�¦fHZ]nVj�kyjqo3^`nio4kmnikmoqky^�eY�T^�emhua�j�ªA�4�ua.aH§V^]fHo�j|Z`emhuoqkmZ]n�kyj

P � =TSY> U fHZpj =���=cS'>'>�ZP � =TSY> U j�kmnJ=���=cS'>'>�Z[�=cS'> U ] t¬�n��VZ]o[��fHZ�wia�j«v`��a4jqa�o+� � &�� =��K>rU ] t ]�] �Ov ����&��v=¼��>rU ] t �]�uv ����&��v=¼b�>rU ��tF;�^`nVw¡kmnik¯o|kg^Te jqo[a���j�kA@�a��2U � ] ^ �= � � &�� =��K>�kgj�o[�uaC�V^`X3^`_a�ola�X¸kmn¦ol�ua�jqo[ZO�u�ik¯nu\�fHXqkmo[a�XqkmZ]n¸ ÄZOX �%a���o[Z]n��æj4_�a�o[�uZ�wAª � � &�� =��K>3v"����&��v=¼��>�^`Xlaol�ua��V^`X3^`_a�ola�X3j = � v = � kmnzo[�ua.jqo[a��Vj�kA@�a�fHZ]npolX[Z`eÀvVjqa�a ? ³%µ0�u�Y@Àvu�V^`\Oa��; ] £[��;��K>3ª¬�n2rV\]huX[a2�]vi��a��iemZ]o'o[�ua ��� ¦oqkm_a.^�\p^�kmnVjqo%o[�ua�nihu_��Va�X'Z` �j�km\]niksrFf�^`npo�wOkm\`kmo3j9=1h�emZ]\ � 7 =¼^��VjqZ`emhuo[a�a�X[X[ZOX5>'>YZ` ol�ua.^�em\]a��uX3^�kyf�fHZ]_�,Z]nua�npoHj�vi ÔZ]X%�VZOo[�¨fHZuwia�j�ª��uZ]X4o[�ikyj�v,�4a�hVjqa�fHZ]nioqkmnihuZ]hVj%ZOhuo[�uhuo3jJmuZ]huo[�uhuo3j�^`X[a�X[a�tOhikmX[a�w^�orST�rU ST� ^ � � ] tæ�uv`�4a�fHZ]_��uhuo[a�ol�ua%\`emZ]�V^�eAa�X[X[Z]X4^`nVwol�ua�no3^DH]a�o[�ua%_@^�§ikm_�hu_ Z`�]a�X�^Te e*�`^�emhua�j�ªi¬Àn�rV\]huX[a��uv�4a%�iemZ]o4o[�ua ��� @oqkm_a�^`\p^Tk¯nVj|o�ol�ua%nphu_��,a�X�Z� {j�km\]niksrFf�^`nio�rV\OhuX[a�j�Z` *o[�ua¡wOks¿*a�X[a�nioqky^�e­fHZ]_�,Z]nua�npoHj�v` ÔZ]X��,Z]o[�fHZuwia�j�ª¬�n�o[�ua� ÔZ`esemZ`�4kmnu\@�uX[ZO�ie¯a�_2j�vuZ]niem²�o[�ua�_ZuwOksrVa�wz�V^`X3^`_a�ola�X3j��4kse eY�Va�jq�uZ`�%n*ª

ÒÔÓ­ÕAÒSÖ

Page 20: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

������������ ������������������� ������������������ "!�#$!�%�&'&)(*�+��������#-,.!����/0���1#����2���3#��54�6�7"(98:, �`�

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

0.01 0.1 1 10

significant digits

cpu time

modified radau5radau5

��km\]huX[a��KmuWYX[a�flkyj�kmZ]n¥�]a�X3j|hVj%fHZ]_�uhuoqkmnu\2oqkm_a�£�wOks¿*a�X[a�npo|kg^Te}fHZ]_��VZ]nua�nio3j4£Yo[a�j|o%�uX[Z]�iema�_�G��� � ���)�+ �#+�/�¢�ua�j�km_�iema�jqo�fHZ]nVjqo[XH^�kmnua�w�_a�fl�V^`nikyf�^�e�jq²ujqo[a�_ kgj�o[�uaY�,a�nVwihie¯hu_zv]�%�uZpj|aYa�t]hV^`o|k¯ZOnVj*Z` i_Z]oqkmZ]nVj�^`X[a�wia�j[fHX|k¯�,a�wkmn ? ³�µ �Â�1@�v`�V^`\]a%��C$;`£Ô��C]�uª�µ a%�V^��]a'^`�u�iesk¯a�w2ol�ua�fHZ�wia��%^]wu^�hV�.^`nVw�o[�ua%_ZuwOksrVa�w�fHZ�wia�o[Z.o[�ua�´.´ A =[´�a�^�X�v´'hu�uo3^�^`nVw A aHk¯_ Hphu�iema�X5>4 ÔZ]X[_�hiey^`oqkmZ]n

��������� ��������

r R =cS'> U 9 =TSY> h r�=TSY>��v=TS'>1Z; R =TSY> U �K=TSY> h ;$=TS'>�� =cS'>1Z�V9 R =TS'>VU h�r�=TS'>��=cS'>1Z� � R =TS'> U h@;�=cS'>���=TSY> h�^ Z] U r�=TS'>A�M� ;�=cS'>��Mh � ��Z] U r�=TS'> 9 =TSY>X� ;$=TS'>���=TSY>1Z

S"_ ? ] Z�� ] @TZ�¢k¯ol� fHZ]nVj¼kgj|o3^`nio.kmnikmoqky^�e��`^�emhua�j r�= ] >.U��]v:;�= ] >.U ] v 9 = ] >JU ] v ��= ] >JU ] v���= ] >.U ] ^`nVw�� = ] >.U ] ªv�uZ]Xj¼k¯_��ie kyflkmoq²]vA�4a�o[ZpZ$H � U �]v$^�U �.^`nVw

� U �]ª¬�n rV\]huX[a{; =�X[a�jq�Va�fHo|k¯�OaHe¯² �K>HvY�4a¨�iemZ]o2o[�ua ��� 0oqkm_a ^`\p^�kmnVjqo2o[�uaznphu_��Va�X�Z� �j�km\]niksrFf�^`npo¥wOkm\`kmo3j2Z` .o[�ua^Te¯\Oa��uX3^�kyfk=ÀXla�jq�*ªuwOk ¿*a�X[a�nioqky^�e�>%fHZ]_�VZOnua�npo3j«vi ÄZOX%�VZ]ol�¦fHZ�wia�j�ª�G��� � +��6"��. ��) �1/1�!� 2��7��#� /�Ãjqa��Oa�n=�,Z�wi² _�a�f[�V^`nikyjq_ kyj.wia�jlfHXqkm�Va�w kmn ? ³�µ �Â�1@�vA�V^`\]a@��;Â��£À�`�p�uªAµÁa�V^��]a@^`�u�ieskma�w o[�ua@fHZuwia®��^]wu^`hV�^�nVw2o[�ua�_ZuwOk rVa�w¥fHZuwia.o[Z�o[�ua�kmnVwiaH§¨�C ÄZOX[_�hieg^�oqkmZ]n

��� ��; R =TS'> U ��=TSY>1Z� R =cS'>VU \ =�;$=TSY>'> ^ � a WX=A;�=cS'>1Z �K=TSY>'>h H =�;$=TSY>'>���=TS'> c Z] U j=�;$=TS'>Y>��K=cS'>1Z S`_ ? ] Z�;Ktm� ] ^ � @cZ

�¢k¯ol�¦fHZ]nVj�kyjqo3^`nio4kmnikmoqky^�eY�T^�emhua�j�ª¬�n�rV\]huXla��l=ÀXla�jq�Va�fHoqkm�]aHem²�b�>3vH�4aY�ie¯ZOo­o[�ua ��� .oqkm_a�^�\p^�kmnVjqo*o[�ua�nphu_��,a�X­Z` Vj�km\]niksrFf�^`nio�wOkm\`kmo3j*Z� �o[�ua4^�em\]a��uX3^�kyf=�X[a�jq�*ªuwOks¿ a�Xla�npoqky^�e�>%fHZ]_�,Z]nua�npoHj�vi ÔZ]X%�VZOo[�¦fHZ�wia�j«ªF³�a�X[a]vuZ]huol�uhuo3j%^`X[a'X[a�tOhikmX[a�w¥^`o`ST�vU�ST� ^ � � ] t ]�]�] ;ª�G��� �I�#����2������V� �����!����+�� � �����"�������¢�ikgj�j¼k¯_��ie ksrVa�w _ZuwiaHe.Z` ^Jwi²pnV^`_ kgfÁj�km_�hiey^`o|k¯ZOn �uX[ZO�ie¯a�_ kmn �Va�o[XlZ�fl�ikm_�kyf�^�e�a�nu\`kmnua�a�Xqkmnu\ kyj¦wia�j[fHX|k¯�,a�wkmn ? ³lA*��C]�-@Àvu�V^`\]a2�]��b`£[�O��Cuªiµ a.�V^��]a�^`�u�ieskma�w¥o[�ua�fHZuwia�%^]wu^`hV�2^`nVwzo[�uaC_Z�wOksrVa�w¥fHZuwia�olZ@o[�ua� ÄZ�e emZ`�4kmnu\Õ�ÕÃÙr��ë��[êHê

Page 21: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

��C (���(�%��5�������� ��!��������

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

0.1 1 10 100

significant digits

cpu time

modified radau5radau5

��k¯\OhuX[a+;KmuW}X[a�flkyj�kmZ]n¥�]a�X3jqhVj%fHZO_�uhuoqkmnu\oqkm_aC£�^�em\]a��uX3^�kyf.fHZO_�VZ]nua�nio3j4£��Va�nVwihiemhu_

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

0.1 1 10 100

significant digits

cpu time

modified radau5radau5

��km\]huXla.��muWYXla�flkgj¼k¯ZOn¨�Oa�X3jqhVj%fHZ]_��uhuoqkmnu\@oqkm_a�£�wOks¿*a�X[a�nioqky^�e�fHZ]_�VZOnua�npo3j¢£Y�Va�nVwihiemhu_

ÒÔÓ­ÕAÒSÖ

Page 22: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

������������ ������������������� ������������������ "!�#$!�%�&'&)(*�+��������#-,.!����/0���1#����2���3#��54�6�7"(98:, ���

-1

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

1 10 100 1000

significant digits

cpu time

modified radau5radau5

��km\]huX[a��KmuWYX[a�flkyj�kmZ]n¥�]a�XHjqhVj%fHZ]_�uhuo|k¯nu\�oqkm_a.£�^�em\]a��uXH^�kyf.fHZ]_�,Z]nua�nio3j%£�j|a��]a�n��VZuwi²�_a�fl�V^`nikyjq_

-2

0

2

4

6

8

10

1 10 100 1000

significant digits

cpu time

modified radau5radau5

��km\]huXla.bKmVWYXla�flkgj¼k¯ZOn¦�]a�X3j|hVj%fHZ]_�uhuoqkmnu\2oqkm_a�£�wOks¿*a�X[a�nioqky^�e{fHZ]_��VZ]nua�nio3j4£4jqa��]a�n��VZuwi²�_a�fl�V^`nikyjq_

Õ�ÕÃÙr��ë��[êHê

Page 23: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

� ] (���(�%��5�������� ��!��������

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

0.01 0.1 1 10

significant digits

cpu time

modified radau5radau5

��k¯\OhuX[a���mVW}X[a�flkyj�kmZ]n¦�]a�XHjqhVj%fHZ]_�uhuo|k¯nu\2oqkm_aC£�^�em\]a��uX3^�kyf.fHZO_�VZ]nua�nio3j4£�wOkyj[fl�V^`X[\Oa.�uX[a�j[j|huX[a�fHZ]nio[X[Z�e

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

0.01 0.1 1 10

significant digits

cpu time

modified radau5radau5

��km\]huXla+CKmuWYXla�flkgj¼k¯ZOn¨�Oa�X3jqhVj%fHZ]_��uhuoqkmnu\oqkm_a.£�wOks¿*a�X[a�nioqky^�e�fHZ]_�VZOnua�npo3j¢£�wOkgjlf[�V^`Xl\]a.�uX[a�jljqhuX[a.fHZ]nio[X[Z`ekmnVwiaH§¨�C ÔZ]X[_�hiey^`oqkmZ]nXm

����������� ����������

�v=TSY> U �����=o3^�nu��=TS hJ� ] >1Zr =TS'> U � � 7 =);Kt ;]�lh ] t ] �T� � =TSY>�� ] t ]�] � � =TS'>�� >1ZP R =TSY> U �� 7�a gD=TSY> h . � � �� h�P3=TS'> c Zg R =TS'> U h �� =sr�=TSY> h �]�Ktg�D>1Z\ R =TS'>VU �v=TS'> h � =TS'>�Z] U a � � � �� 7 c � h¥�p�Ktæ��C � � a � � � ���� � N � � � c � Z

S`_ ? ] Zl� ] @TZ

�¢k¯ol�¦fHZ]nVj�kyjqo3^`nio4kmnikmoqky^�eY�T^�emhua�j�ªA³%a�Xla]vikmnik¯o|kg^Te�jqo[a��¦j�kA@�a+�®kyj%a�tOhV^�e­o[Zz� ] ^ ª¬�n rV\]huX[a ��=�X[a�jq�Va�fHo|k¯�OaHe¯²yC�>HvY�4a¨�iemZ]o2o[�ua ��� 0oqkm_a ^`\p^�kmnVjqo2o[�uaznphu_��Va�X�Z� �j�km\]niksrFf�^`npo¥wOkm\`kmo3j2Z` .o[�ua^Te¯\Oa��uX3^�kyf�=�X[a�jq�*ªuwOks¿ a�Xla�npoqky^�e�>�fHZO_�VZ]nua�nio3j�v� ÄZOX��VZOo[�®fHZuwia�j�ªV³�a�X[a]vOZ]huo[�uhuo3j4^`X[a'X[a�tOhikmX[a�w@^�o"S � U�S � ^ � � ] t �uª

ÒÔÓ­ÕAÒSÖ

Page 24: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

������������ ������������������� ������������������ "!�#$!�%�&'&)(*�+��������#-,.!����/0���1#����2���3#��54�6�7"(98:, �u�

5 �0�����¢1�&�/��3���

�<nua�� j¼k¯_��ie¯azo[a�fl�unikgtOhua¦olZ¦Z`�]a�X3fHZ]_�a@o[�ua2Z]X3wia�X�X[a�wihVfHo|k¯ZOnJ�u�ua�nuZ]_a�nuZ]n*v�^��u�Va�^`Xqkmnu\¥ ÔZ]XCo[�ua¦^�em\]a��uX3^�kyffHZO_�VZ]nua�nio%�%�ua�n¥�%^]wu^`h�¬q¬��#_a�o[�uZuwuj%^`Xla.^`�u�iesk¯a�wzo[ZCkmnVwiaH§¨oq�4Z�%��©�j«v]kyj��uX[Z]�,Zpjqa�wAª¬�nVfHX[a�^]j�kmnu\2o[�ua�Z]X3wia�X�Z` }fHZOnp�]a�Xl\]a�nVfHa.Z` :[Ckyj�_@^]wia��VZij[j�km�iema��i²�fHZ]nVj�kywia�Xqkmnu\�o[�ua.fHZ]_�,Zpj�kmoqkmZ]n¥Z` ­ol�ua.�V^]j�kyf_�a�o[�uZ�w��4kmo[�2kmo3jqaHes YZ`�]a�X@C¦jqo[a��Vj«ªp��j�[n��� � kyj�wiaHrVnua�w®kmn�o[�ua��V^]j�kyf'_a�o[�uZuw2^]j4^�eskmnua�^`X�fHZ]_��ikmnV^`oqkmZ]n�Z` *o[�uakmnio[a�X[nV^�e­jqoH^`\]a�j�vu^C\]ZiZ�w�fl�uZ`kyfHa.Z` :C¨j|�uZ]hieyw��uX[Z`�Okgwia�a�nuZOhu\]�2 ÄXla�a�wiZ]_  ÔZ]X4o[�ua�Z]X3wia�X%fHZ]nVwOkmoqkmZ]nVj'^]j[jqZuflky^`o[a�w�¢k¯ol�¨ol�ua�fHZ]_�,Zpj�kmo[a�_a�o[�uZuwzo[Z2�Va@j[^�oqkyj�rVa�wAªVµÁa��V^��]a�wia�o[a�X[_�kmnua�w¥ol�ua�jqa�Z]X3wia�X�fHZ]nVwOkmoqkmZ]nVj��%�ikyfl�=wia�Xqkm�]aj|o[X3^�km\]�ioq ÔZ]X[�%^`X3wOem²2 ÔX[Z]_�o[�ua�4Z]X'H�Z` %©%ª*³'^�kmX[a�X�v}d�ªXAAhu�ikyf[�J^`nVw(� ª*�4Zuf[�ua2=qjqa�fHoqkmZ]n=�uªg�D>3ªA�4�ua�n �4a��V^��Oaj|�uZT��n�o[�V^`o�jqZO_a�Z` Yo[�uZpjqa.fHZ]nVwOkmoqkmZ]nVj�^�X[a�X[a�wihunVwu^`nio¡^�nVw�_�km\]�io%�VaCZ]_�kmo[o[a�w® ÄZOX�jq£Àjqo3^�\]a.�%^]wu^`hz¬q¬À� _a�£ol�uZ�wuj4�¢k¯ol� g`3J�z=¼jqa�fHoqkmZ]n¥�uª ;Co[Z�uªæ��>Hª¬�o�fHZ]hieyw�,a4kmnpola�X[a�jqoqkmnu\�o[Z�\]a�nua�X3^Te kA@�a'o[�ikyj�j�km_�iesksrFf�^`oqkmZ]nVj¢o[Z.^`ni² ��^]wu^`h¬q¬À� _a�o[�uZuwuj�ª`� \]a�nua�X3^�eFtOhua�jqoqkmZ]n�¢k ese­�,a�o[Z�wia�ola�X[_�kmnua��uZ`� _2^`np²2fHZ]_�VZij�kmoqkmZ]nVj4Z` {^�jq£Àj|o3^`\]a���^]wu^`h�¬q¬À� _a�ol�uZ�w��V^��]a�olZ��,a¡fHZOnVj�kywia�X[a�w�o[ZZO�uo3^�kmn@^`nZOX3wia�X4Z`  fHZ]ni�]a�X[\Oa�nVfHa�a�tOhV^�eFolZ���gvh¦�� ÔZ]X�ol�ua�^�em\]a��uX3^�kyf'fHZ]_�,Z]nua�npo�ªp³�ZT�4a��]a�X�v�k¯o%wiZia�jYnuZ]o4jqa�a�_Xla�^]jqZ]nV^`�iema^`ni²¦_ZOX[a.o[Z¦fHZOnVj�kywia�X�^��uX3^]fHoqkyf�^�eYkm_�iema�_a�nio3^`oqkmZ]nÁZ` �o[�uafHZ]XlX[a�jq�VZOnVwOk¯nu\z_a�o[�uZuw¸ ÄZ]X�g 0�VvZ`�4kmnu\olZ�ol�ua�fHZ]_�iemaH§ikmo¼²�Z� ­o[�ua� ÔZ]X[_�hiey^]j} ÔZ]X%�T^�Xqky^`�iema j|o[a��Vj�kA@�a]ª�¢�ua� ÄZOX[_�hieg^Oj� ÄZ]X.g U ;¸�V^��]a��Va�a�nÁk¯nVfHZOX[�VZ]XH^`o[a�wzkmn o[�ua2fHZ�wia@��^]wu^`hV�¦wia��OaHe¯ZO�Va�w �i²¨©%ª*³'^�kmX[a�X�^`nVw ´�ªµ ^`nunua�X�ªsI`e km\]�io._�Z�wOksrFf�^`oqkmZ]nVj��4a�X[a�X[a�t]hikmX[a�w�=¼jqa�fHoqkmZ]n{;�>3ª��%niem²¥o[�uafHZ]_�uhuo3^`o|k¯ZOn¦Z` 4o[�ua^�em\]a��uX3^�kyffHZ]_�£�,Z]nua�nio%�%^]j�_Z�wOksrVa�wz^`nVw¦^Cnua��0�uX[ZufHa�wihuX[a�k¯nzZ]X3wia�X%olZ��V^��]a.fHZOnpoqkmnihuZ]hVj4Z]huol�uhuo3j��¢^Oj%fHX[a�^`o[a�w2���ua�X[a��4a�V^��]a'hVjqa�w¸Z]huX%o[a�fl�unikyt]hua� ÄZ]X4�,Z]o[�¦fHZ]_�,Z]nua�nio3j�=q^�em\]a��uX3^�kyf�^`nVw�wOks¿*a�X[a�nioqky^�e�>�o[ZfHZ]_��uhuo[a�^`�u�uXlZ�§ikm_@^`oqkmZ]nVjZ� ­Z]X3wia�X4rV�Oa�^`o4a�tOhikgwOkyjqoH^`npo'Z]huo[�uhuol£Ô�VZ`kmnio3j�ª

��f�fHZ]X3wOkmnu\ o[Z¥Z]huXnihu_a�Xqkyf�^�e�aH§u�Va�X|k¯_�a�npo3j«v�X[a�j|hie¯oHjC ÄZOXo[�ua¦wOks¿*a�X[a�npo|kg^Te¡fHZ]_�,Z]nua�npoHj^`X[a¦wOkyj[^`�u�,Z`kmnpo|k¯nu\,ª³�Z`�4a��]a�X�vAo[�uahVj|a@Z` %Z]huXCo[a�fl�unikgtOhua2kmn=ol�ua®fHZuwia®��^]wu^`hV�¸ema�^]wujCo[Z¨^`n k¯nVfHXla�^]jqa2Z` %o[�ua®^Of�fHhuX3^]fH²¥ ÔZ]X�o[�ua^Te¯\Oa��uX3^�kyf.fHZ]_��VZ]nua�nio3jl=À���ua�n�o[Z`ema�X3^`nVfHa�j'^`X[a.jqhi°�flk¯a�nioqem²¦jq_@^Te e�>3ª� +Ã������6��

�G��� � ����Z" � +��_"�����-� %'"�2�� � �!�_"��V��� �G "�2������*��� #" $

¬�n�o[�ikyj%jqa�fHoqkmZ]n*vÂ��a�aH§u�iey^�kmnua�wzo[�ua.f�^�eyfHhiemhVj%Z` �eskmnua�^`X¡^Te¯\Oa��uX3^ChVjqa�w�o[Zjq�uZ`� o[�V^`o%fHZ]_��VZpjqa�w�rV�Oa�oqkm_a�j4o[�uaj|£Àjqo3^`\]a%�%^Owu^`h@¬q¬�� _a�ol�uZ�wCkyj4jqhi°®flkma�nio�k¯n2o[�ua�f�^]jqaBg9U �Vª�AAa�o4aH§��V^�nVwo[�ua¢ ÄZ`esemZ`�4kmnu\��]a�fHo[Z]X3j}Z` r=;i � >:=ÀµÁahVj|a.AAa�__@^�C\>

I ^ � � U ����E � B ^ � 9 � H� H � ��� �EDEDED � B ZI ^ � � U ����E � B ^ � 9 � � E � g5�6B ^ � 9 � H� H � ��� �EDEDED � B Z� U ����E � 9 � H� H � ��� �EDEDED � B ZK:tSI ^ � � U � � E � =Dt B ^ � 9 � E

� g5�6B ^ � 9 � H H � ��� �EDEDED � B ZI ^ � =�K:t � > U � � E � B ^ � =;=Dt 9 >X� E

� g5�6B ^ � 9 � H� H � ��� �EDEDED � B Z^�nVw2o[�ua' ÄZ�e emZ`�4kmnu\2�]a�fHo[Z]X3j¢Z` :=;i � >�=ÀµÁa�hVjqa+AAa�_�_@^��>

Õ�ÕÃÙr��ë��[êHê

Page 25: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

�O� (���(�%��5�������� ��!��������I ^ � � � U ��� E �� B ^ � 9 � � b�E � g5�6B ^ � 9 �J��E � g �� B ^ � 9 � H� H � ��� �EDEDED � B Z� U ��� E �� 9 �=��E � gn� 9 � H H � �� �EDEDED � B ZK:tSI ^ � � U ��� E �� =Dt B ^ � 9 � E � gn��B ^ � 9 �=� E � gn� =Dt B ^ � 9 � � E � g �� B ^ � 9 � H� H � �� �EDEDED � B ZI ^ � =�K:t � > U � � E �� B ^ � =;=Dt 9 >X� E � g5�6B ^ � 9 �J��E � gn� B ^ � =;=Dt 9 >X�J��E � g �� B ^ � 9 � H H � �� �EDEDED � B ZI ^ � =�K:tSI�� > U � � E �� B ^ � =;=Dt B 9 >X� E � gn� 9 � H H � ��� �EDEDED � B ZI ^ � =�K:tSI�=�K:tSI ^ � � >'>VU � � E �� B ^ � =>=Dt B�=>=Dt B ^ � 9 >'>X� E � g5��B ^ � =>=Dt 9 >X� E � g5�6=Dt B ^ � 9 �DE � g �� B ^ � 9 � H H � ��� �EDEDED � B ZI ^ � =�K ��t � > U � � E �� B ^ � =;=&��t 9 >X�=��E � gn��B ^ � =;=Dt 9 >� E

� g �� B ^ � 9 � H H � ��� �EDEDED � B ZI�� U � � E �� B 9 � H H � ��� �EDEDED � B ZI�= K t I ^ � � > U � � E �� B�=>=Dt B ^ � 9 >X� E � gn� 9 � H H � ��� �EDEDED � B ZK:t � U ��� E �� =Dt 9 � E � g � 9 � H� H � �� �EDEDED � B ZK:tSI ^ � =�K:t � > U � � E �� =Dt B ^ � =>=Dt 9 >s� E � gn� =Dt B ^ � 9 � E � gn� B ^ � =;=Dt 9 >X� E

� g �� B ^ � 9 � H H � �� �EDEDED � B ZK � tSI ^ � � U � � E �� = � t B ^ � 9 �J��E � g � =Dt B ^ � 9 � E

� g �� B ^ � 9 � H H � ��� �EDEDED � B tA a�o4kmnpo[XlZ�wihVfHaCo[�ua� ÔZ`esemZT�¢k¯nu\��]a�fHo[Z]X3j� � U I ^ � � h=�I ^ � = K t � >1Z� � U K:tSI ^ � � h+I ^ � =�K:t � >1Z� � U � h � I�=�K:tSI ^ � � >�Z� � U � h � I ^ � =�K:tSI � >�Z� � U � h � K t � Z� U K:tSI ^ � =�K:t � > h I ^ � =�K:tSI�= K t I ^ � � >Y>1Z� U I ^ � =�K � t � >s�+K � tSI ^ � � h+K:tSI =�K:tSI ^ � � > h+K:tSI ^ � =�K:t � >1Z� � U � �[K t I ^ � � h+I ^ � =�K:t � > � h � ��K � tSI ^ � � h I ^ � =�K � t � > � Z� � U ��� � K � tSI ^ � � � I ^ � =�K � t � > � h b � K:tSI ^ � � � I ^ � = K t � > � � � I ^ � � � Z= kgwia�_  ÄZ]X�o[�ua��]a�fHo[Z]XHj`S � UYB ^ � 9 h � B ^ � =Dt 9 vKS � v�� � v�ªmªmªAv � � >Yo[�ua�n

� � U � E � � B ^ � 9 h ��B ^ � =;=Dt 9 > � H H � ��� �EDEDED � B Z� � U � E � � =Dt B ^ � 9 h B ^ � =;=Dt 9 > � H H � ��� �EDEDED � B Z� � U � E �� � 9 h ��B�=>=Dt B ^ � 9 > � H H � ��� �EDEDED � B Z� � U � E �� � 9 h ��B ^ � =;=Dt B 9 > � H H � ��� �EDEDED � B Z� � U � E �� = 9 h=��=Dt 9 > H H � ��� �EDEDED � B Z� U � E �� � =Dt B ^ � =>=Dt 9 > hIB ^ � =>=Dt B�=>=Dt B ^ � 9 >'> � H H � �� �EDEDED � B Z� U � E �� � B ^ � =;= � t 9 >X� = � t B ^ � 9 hI=Dt B9=;=Dt B ^ � 9 >Xh�=Dt B ^ � =;=Dt 9 > � H H � ��� �EDEDED � B Z� � U � E �� � � � =Dt B ^ � 9 h�B ^ � =;=Dt 9 > � h � � = � t B ^ � 9 hIB ^ � =>= � t 9 > � � H H � �� �EDEDED � B Z� � U � E �� � h%b � =Dt B ^ � 9 � B ^ � =;=Dt 9 > � � ��� � =&��t B ^ � 9 � B ^ � =;=&��t 9 > � �=��B ^ � 9 � � H H � ��� �EDEDED � B Z

^�nVw2o[�ua.jq²ujqo[a�_ ='L ��� >Ykyj%a�tOhikm�T^�ema�nio�o[ZÒÔÓ­ÕAÒSÖ

Page 26: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

������������ ������������������� ������������������ "!�#$!�%�&'&)(*�+��������#-,.!����/0���1#����2���3#��54�6�7"(98:, ��;� H � U � = ] >�Z � H7I ^ � � � U ] =3����>1Z� H K U � =3�D>�Z � H � U ] =3��;�>1Z� H K�� U � =¼��>�Z � H � � U ] =3�«�K>1Z� H K � U � =);�>�Z � H � � U ] =3����>1Z� H K U � =À�K>�Z � H � � U ] =3��b�>1Z� H I ^ � � U ] =¼��>�Z � H � U ] =3����>1Z� H K U � =¼b�>�Z � H I ^ � = K � t � > U ] =3��C�>1Z� H � � U ] =[��>�Z � H7I � U ] =3����>1Z� H � U ] =)C�>�Z � H � � U ] =¼� ] >1Z� H � � U ] =¼��>�Z � H � � U ] =¼�Â�D>1Z� H I ^ � =�K:t � >VU ] =3� ] >1Z � H K:tSI ^ � =�K:t � >VU ] =¼�O��>1Z� H K � U ] =3�]�->1Z � H � U ] =¼�$;�>1t

C��½*o�½F� p � p ½VU �� � � � ��� � ��I�� !��3# � � !����/0������!�1/ �k#��}�\���3#����3���6 � � � ��� � ��I�� !��3# � !����/0������!�1/ �k#��}�\���3#����3���� � � � ��� � ��I�� !��3# � !����/0������!�1/ �k#��}�\���3#����3���

� � � � ��� � ��I�� !��3# � � !����/0������!�1/ �k#��}�\���3#����3���� � � � ��� � ��I�� !��3# � � !����/0������!�1/ �k#��}�\���3#����3��� C��½F½SW3� E a�f�^�hVjqa�Z` �o[�ua�aH§��uXla�j[j�kmZ]n¥Z` �o[�ua��]a�fHo[ZOX3j � � v � � v�I�� ^`nVw � � vÂk¯o�kyj�jqhi°®flkma�nio�o[Z®j|�uZT� o[�V^`o

� � v � � v�B 9 ^`nVw � � ^`X[a�esk¯nua�^�Xqem² wia��,a�nVwia�npo =Ôkywia�_� ÄZOX�o[�uaC�V^`X[o��olZ@�Z� �o[�ua.�uX[ZO�VZpj�kmoqkmZ]n�>Hª*�4�ua._a�ol�uZ�wL|Uy=>B.Z � ZC=�>Akyj%Z� *emZ�f�^�e�Z]X3wia�XBCC ÔZ]X4o[�ua.wOks¿*a�X[a�nioqky^�e}fHZO_�VZ]nua�nio�ªu�4�ihVj�vuZ]XHwia�X�fHZ]nVwOkmoqkmZ]nVj'^]j[jqZuflky^`o[a�w2�4kmo[�ol�ua�o[X[a�a�j4Z` �p$B@1��-dD=[��>�^`X[a.j[^�oqkyj�rVa�wAªu¬Ànz�V^`X[oqkyfHhiey^`X�v� HVB ^ � = � U ��Z � HVB ^ � =>=Dt BD��= > U �

� 7 Z� H B ^ � =;=Dt B = > U �� Z � H B ^ � =>=Dt B�=>=Dt B ^ � = >Y> U � Z� H B ^ � =;= � t B = > U � Z � H B = U �� Z� H B�=;=Dt B ^ � = > U � Z � H = � U �� Z� H =Dt Bj= U �

� Z � H =Dt B ^ � = � U � � Z� HV=Dt B ^ � =;=Dt B = >VU �� Z � HV=&��t B ^ � = U � t��kmnV^�esem²]v,��a�ZO�uo3^�kmn� H � � U � H � � U � H � � U � H � U ] Z� H � U � H�� � U � H�� � U � HVB 9 U ] Z

�uhuo � �U ] vu�ua�nVfHa.ol�ua��uX[Z]�VZij�kmoqkmZ]n�kyj'jq�uZ`�%n*ª���·��=�V��� �Q& �.�����.,5�����{,5��� �J� ,.�����K,5��!��3� � �6� ����E � U ������U-E . ���:������� *r�J��!$ ��� � � � ��� � ��I ^ � � !��3# � !����/0���3�1!$1/ �k#����K���3#����3���6 � � � ��� � � � !���# � !���+/0������!��/ �k#��}�\����#��������� � � � ��� � ��I�� !��3# � � !���k/ ������!��/ �+#$���\����#��������

� � � � ��� � ��I�� !��3# � � !���k/ ������!��/ �+#$���\����#�������������3�1� � �3���3�.�(��%�!��������K,.!���k��#����3������!�/�/ �J,5!���� , )`�1#�!$��# r �1!��(�'�k�n�����D,5���i�(��%�!�/X����� �$%�O�Õ�ÕÃÙr��ë��[êHê

Page 27: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

��� (���(�%��5�������� ��!�������� #�4���4*�������4/

?FE d4��;D@ ¤�ª E huX[X3^`\Oa�^`nVw��ª W­ª ¤�ªud��V^`n*ªM����,5�+�������������k!��3#k���#���l��1#�%����������2� 0B�1����,�� ��������/0�������v %����$�&%'.%�����!z� ����k%�/0!���ª w`Z]huX[nV^�e�Z` �fHZ]_��uhuo3^`oqkmZ]nV^�e.^`nVw!���u�ieskma�w �¥^`ol�ua�_@^`oqkyf�j��p�uv'���]��;uª���Z]X[ol�u£³%Z`esey^`nVwAv�d�� �-���i�T�uª?FE d4W��u�5@�¤�ªæ©%ª E X[a�nV^`n*v�IVª AYªid�^�_�u�VaHeseÀvu^`nVw�AYªæ��ªpW�a�o @�Z`eywAª�� %��k�������!�/�, ��/0%������$�2���B����������!�/K �!�/0%��M��)�_�5/0���J,���i#�� 0B�����������!�/ %)!�/ �����5�!����.�(��%�!��������K,�ª �%Z]Xlo[�¦³%Z�e ey^`nVwAv����]�Â�]ª �%a����YZOX'HFª? d%d��]�D@ ��ª,d��V^`n@^`nVw2W�ªud��V^�X[oqkma�X�ªX( :�$���K�D,5��������� ! !�*��5��� �%����$�&%G'.%�����!��i��������#D,"( ���/0����#����k&���#��n4b%)67 � 0B�����������!�/ % (�/ �����5�!�����8 ��%�!������$�K,�ª­¬q�4¬'I]��vX�ua��iXqkma�X.���O�]�uªYWYhu�ieskyf�^`oqkmZ]nzkmnpola�X[nua.n*ª CO��;uª? ³4km\p��;-@ ¬3ªY³4km\]hua�XH^]j�ª :��� ������������,����2����� (�!��D/ �$��54Y�\!���, �������5��O������, ��/0%������$�����2#�� 0B������3����!$/_%�!�/ �����5�!����, ��,5�����J, ª ��Z]X[o[��³�Z`eseg^�nVwAvY���]��;uª����u�ieskma�w ��hu_a�Xqkyf�^�e �¥^`ol�ua�_@^`oqkyf�j����Âvp�V^�\]a��p�i��£À� ] �]ª? ³BA*��C]�D@�©%ª4³�^�kmX[a�X�v%d�ª`AAhu�ikyfl�*v�^`nVw �=ª4�4Zuf[�ua]ª (X����� %��k�������!�/ +��/0%������$� �}� 7�� 0B�����������!�/`(�/ �����5�!����+*��, �����J, � �2 �%������ %G'.%�����!�����������#-, ª�I]�uXqkmnu\]a�X[£�7Ya�X|eg^�\Vv4����C]�uª�AAa�fHo[huX[a ��Z]o[a�j'kmn �¥^`o[�ua�_@^`o|kgf�j��� ] �uª? ³ ��µ0�u�5@�©%ªA³�^�kmX[a�X�vvIVªæW�ª ���`X3jqa�olo�vV^`nVwÁ´�ª,µ=^`nunua�X�ª�+��/0 ������ ���#�����!$C� 7 � 0B��)��������!�/s8 ��%�!��������K, � ��/ � ��ªI]�uXqkmnu\]a�X[£�7Ya�Xqey^`\Vv����]�Â�]ªY�`nVw�©�wOkmoqkmZ]n*ª? ³%µ0�u�5@ ©%ª�³'^�kmX[a�X¥^`nVw ´�ª4µ=^`nunua�X�ª +���� 0 �"�� �5/0���.,{!��3# 7 � 0B�����������!�/�(�/ �����5�!����(�"�� �n/ ���J, � ��$/ � 6 �]ªI]�uXqkmnu\]a�X[£�7Ya�Xqey^`\Vv����]�Â�]ªY�`nVw�©�wOkmoqkmZ]n*ª? W�a�o1C]bD@ AYªæ��ª]W�a�o @�Z�egwAª�( #��n, ��1� �������������7"(,+ + !�� ( #�� 0B������3����!$/ K(�/ ��� �n�!���� +*��, ����� +��/0 ���Hª�W}X[ZufHa�a�wOk¯nu\ijZ` {¬>�z��d�Iµ Z]X|egw2�uXlZ]\]X[a�j[j«v*����C]bª �zZ]nio[X[a�^�eÀv,d�^`nV^]wu^ª

ÒÔÓ­ÕAÒSÖ

Page 28: On Improving the Convergence of Radau IIA Methods Applied ... · HAL Id: inria-00073949 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and

Unite de recherche INRIA Lorraine, Technopole de Nancy-Brabois, Campus scientifique,615 rue du Jardin Botanique, BP 101, 54600 VILLERS LES NANCY

Unite de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES CedexUnite de recherche INRIA Rhone-Alpes, 46 avenue Felix Viallet, 38031 GRENOBLE Cedex 1

Unite de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY CedexUnite de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis, 2004 route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 SOPHIA-ANTIPOLIS Cedex

EditeurINRIA, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex (France)

ISSN 0249-6399