o estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - carlos nelson coutinho
TRANSCRIPT
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 1/147
D[9RTE &P[PELTIVR-
E R P L O S N E L S O N E D L I T I N I - I E I
E l E S T R U T U P H L I S M O0
R M IS E P IR D R R R Z R o
Iih lle ,
e PrSco
POPULAR
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 2/147
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 3/147
Iz0EOQ
0r1C
CU0zCU
HHC0I
C)
zC'V0V0U0
I
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 4/147
I00cU
0CZ0Va
V
0u'V
a
Va U0
i
VabU
:
0
c
)
i-C
c
00
V
C'..V
0o
H
Zo:K
U
a)
DK .0Q Nacu0a
0_a
.9
0
a_
.c
u
=aNL)0)
a
Q o
•o0En0a).0.0co
00( a
)N00
Ea(a0aa)LEo
C
O
N
.
C
O
aO0(0—
,
0a)z0a0dEa)
(
,
uJ
C0C
0CD
0.0U>00a)
>0—
,
ca)
Ca)
wUaC
)
.0a)
C0'a)
a)
C
)
0a)
a)0
Ca
C
-
VCa
V
C
a
C),Ca
U—U
C-
—
00
U
0-CH0
aaN
N
C
O\
0'C
a
N
CaN
C
O
'C
a C
a
U
U
U
U
—
N
C
-,
0 (DO
ILD U(C
0<-_C
<
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 5/147
1
.Jin
20O-g-
-0_C0:Ho-N-in 0
Z0-H-:LQ
•DU u
:EHN
<1001
OO
o<E-E00
(E ctJoin0000I--
o z JO
(N
0o-<D22ouJ5<-<oO1<u uOH0Nm<z- 0in0
0O<O:
c0•zHzL0
o>0Uin<O -
<
< 10
>
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 6/147
aC
V
0
0-
I
L
r
E
C
a
HcV
Iw
001--• 1E- E.UCVcInI
o
lD
lD
o0VV
VV
I-
IQC
vlD
ONV
CcVC—VC
UU
NDlD
--N
(D
VV
•C-CLnc
V
a(D V
. -Vd—V
E
V
(D
E
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 7/147
c
c d
10
1
C1
V
V
V
V VC
1
•CC-C(DCVC
(D
VCLE VC N
11V
•(D44
E C (D
u CCC
CV
VVVCVCVV
.(D.
(D uC o
V C D
71
u
cu m
(D
-lDU(D
VV
- 1 - C C a
(ID V
CL E
E1
E
C
V
VC
CCu N
UE - (D
(D
E
M>a
<
C
VVVV
UVU
(D
CL
V CVC
VC
V
C0C.CC
u<-uu<
V
E
1
VID
C
V' CVC
UVU (U
V (D
V
VV-d (
D
VC-d cVC1
V
CCuCDC
CC1C
CCN•—CV
V(V-d
(D
V(DVr NU-d -Cc(D•
V• uV
•1<
(D
CV
*
C•-CCC1
VV
C VD
V
E -d
'CD
•
-.10 V
C•—10
V
uB
V•EE
Cc•uuCdCVVC
C•
C 1
uVbL-CDC• • -d
CE
VC-<
(D
1
CVC
<
21
•CE
UV
C-CC C10 2•aC-CCC
CV0 (Dç
<(ID V C•VaECVCNdID
CuU2CDVC
V:
CCCVV
aVCV
(0
V
CVC
U
1
U
CVV
CE-NCCC cCCVC1CVCC
c
I
(V1C D
(0CCC
V C
C -d c
(D V1CQ
c2
EC
(IDCi E
V
*
11CCC (DC
C CC
CN°UU
CC
VC
U1
V V
C
C
CD
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 8/147
Vc)VV
I
U
V. •'JVC
I
4VVCEVUV-
CC
V
Ccc ' cIU,V0Vc
)
VVCCcVc
4,".VVU
-
V
V
V
4C8 c
- 'Vcd
VI
4-V
'VV
o
C
E
V
ci5c•_
V
.
CV - c C
VUC
—
44c(CU4CV'-
E-UV-CV
Cc)VVC 0u,VUc-
Cc)C1
ICOI
Ic)c)
I
ccCU
Vc) .I>cc'4
cO;-..
ECVECI-cV
c)
C
V4- V4-
V
VC
O
(V
C
cM cc4-=
v
VV
c
C
VQ)
44c c)
VCUV'
'M•c14
O-_O
0VE LcVCC<U
4
I1
-Cc
I —
c
V
VU E'V
U2-
VVc-VCQ)u4c
1-
4-VcV) V0<C
Vcn
C
VV
'C
VCV
c Cc Vv
c
-,--c cV
0<
6
V
EcC
4
CUc
V0< CC
:
C4C-cV'CL.4 4cVcC0C CCcCC V.
vV<U
-)
cnVV
EU- E V—4-cVCVVCC4c1cCUVBC cECVVCCVCUOE
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 9/147
E D U0ID
U
4-Vc0o0 0
0
0-
D
SoElD
V
c
-V
(
-E V o2
V
(D
JD
0
VV-U-VV -
VEElDlD0< V 00V-0E lDE 0lV
U
0V
--V
V
V0VU 0IDlD
—
cn
Qn
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 10/147
4
C
a)C
C
O.-0bD—UdOUa)
2
)
'C-C-C-C-C
C
D
--) a)a)_
a)
Q
a
)
Q
U
I0
Cla0)
—
.-UCNC0Cl4C
U
._OC
aU
——I
C
U)0
c
d0-' 0bDCCl)LC
0!
JD
0c
C
C
-C
--C
a) U)
0•EIm 1
u C
U0-
C._bD
—
a)
U
a)lm c Ua) bD-C I0
IC
bDomUCa)•U—
UO0O
- -c
-
C
) 0
—
C
C
CI
C
) E
'-0C
a)
a)
IU-cC
C
C
a)0
0UUaa) E 0UCC-C
a)
C
I
Nc
a)
lC
(Uo
4
a)-C
C)000C-Cl
a)
-c U
a)
aCQC a)
C4
cNCcCC
-C
b
a)
IC
U6C>a)a)0UC
C-
a)
C—
C-C --,Ql
Cla)
a
a
-
a
)a)
00a
_C)I
C-
çC)
.Cl r -
C
a)
C4
Q001
4a)
C(
Uç
V
C
l
C
lClIa) 00(Cla
) NC
-C
a) U L
)
04C)Na
1
bDC)0bD
U)
04
C
l
01-C
'(r0U-C
C
t
C
t
0
C
-C
a)
oC
a
a)
01C
0
Ca)
-
U
O
)
C
a) a
4
aC
U00U
aS
c 04a)
C
U-_
IcU
tz
U
a) V
0)04U
I OoU
0
VU
oooC-4•)°-4
)
V0LkaJ
C
C
C
UC0
V
4-
C
ctEM co0V-c0-ZUm00
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 11/147
4a
c
b
c
C._C açaC > a a•—-"'
,cCUo5
4
1-
0
E44
1
4-
-aflI aC
4a
_
aC
I
CdC-U..-
'4fC
a4 Ca
C UCodCU-1
01•C
D-_U0O
C C
aCbC71UcaUUaU ,4-CdU-
U U0N
.•0
a ,U
'1
-0a
0a
a
Ioal U 0—<
v
0
Ia
.—
ad-
0C
UcU
ç
a
c
a
4
0I4,
c
EI - aCCUU C TC-dtD-4- Cd -4 Ub04'-Cc Uad0
d 4ca>-
"
U U
b
-
1
.a
•d
IC
-
0
lu
CsN-—
c
•
th0
tL
'a
Ca2'.MU-0a M
c
Ez
-Eb
1
-U4-C UX' U
a
V0'c4.C0I0 14c0
c,b
oc
6U )•LCaU Ua1 =80LC
(4)aa(4(4I(4
.d—ooE-U Ca2
I
m1U
1
a
0o
CaU
-I'.0a4-4 (4' E4 -dza-C0E-C•
0 a0
C
(41.4
014
oE
a')- E
-8oa
>4
:' 0oC44
U
0
a
A' -Cma
0
'C
4
C
-
aaC
4
C'a
a4
C 4(C80C-O0U014CU
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 12/147
2
14
Cd))1
-(
V
cV2UVV
I-C4404CI-a
V
VVC0
1V0
C
Cd)
--.-VV
V I-cCCCUVVV
VCC -C
V
UCClV
-' V
'C-
VCV
—-—
CC4
VC-m U
C
VVVC
14C
-
C
VV
UV
IV1 CQ
I
CI-
--4 Q' cTC
E V 44 CV
I
V•-Cc') E•2
4
V-VVVc<C,C.-1Cl)lVCCC
. VV4)
lu
2-CCC CV
V
C(-°-"U CECCV
2EV
2
b
C
VC0
--
C
V
C1VVC
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 13/147
U"UC—
V
CVC<
U C
Q
V,
5
V-c
J<VCVCVCEE
CCCC—
>c
EVc
c<CZ CVVCU+UVCE—VVCVVV—CCCD
UVc VCCEV
—c
-CE
E
u*uE—VVCVVb
,—
,<VUC
CVVCU
EV
-<VC
UCCV
UU VJCC.
L CUl
DEVl
D
EUUV
--C(C
VU
C
<
VC
z
V
VVbO<
c#Cc#
C
<
E— VBVUC
-
<
COCC
V
C
U0rEu4
VCoEuu
C
u——CECC—-EVU C V
UU-
CVCL
0
V
C
U
VEV
C
EEECVC-U
V—
U-
C
C
VVUV
ICVCU
V -•—)
Vc
V'-C
U
BE0C
VV UcN
C
BV vJ' CV
VE<—C
E—
Z•U
C
UtJ
CCC
U
V
Bb
UCVb0E_
CCV(DVVU—
UCV•ICVIDU
V
C
lD
CINC
(—U- b UVCU
U
UV
DV0U tz
Q
UVN
'00VCVUI1
.
'VC
o
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 14/147
I -0V
UU
IU'-•
U
-0/D
0E
c
000H
OE
o0E0_D0--- VU-00-—Ud
V
0IVQ'V
obDV0VL0U
rO
rD
o-d
rD
rD
Uv--
V
'0rD 00 00-0'
U U• 0I
0VoU
E
(D-o
-
.0
0EID
0rD V
0V0—000•-U-C-&
000
0
V00VçU,o0'V
-0
CLEE
V-U0
V0E0(0E0V
VE
-.-.0EVU—00tJIDQC
14
-7
V0D
V0
VI0E°E0OCO0El VDE•V
0
VOE0
0V1D
D
UrD
VODVV00o0oEuV'U VV0Q0ii; j IDU000UD VDOVlD VE
Vo0
0
00oEU
VD00ECV
rD00
E
00
.€D
iJVOU
Eo
0ç
-E'A0 V
000V0E—U o((0.c
0D
o' U•
CE
V
cn
-7E E00-00V—UDVOoUVVO0EE
V
VV
0V0 V4-1VVrD
-0c0VV—V00u;-O0
0V EEU0U
-ç--0
0-
0E c
0
0
0UVV
rDV
0-U
V
VrD
0
0VD
EU•0
lD
.00
•< c
00•_—VUNEo
IV0rD rrD r
D
IlD —00-V
rD
rD
IlD UrD V00VV-00—0UEo0V0 U0000U
ID
00
10
oEID
r2 cr0
tZo0
D
00
o-T800000.00
ID
0•=000U-000IDIDLI
0LB
00 ID
n
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 15/147
CC(C
44
CC-dC-dCV
-dCUC-
EdV-dCCUdECd
U
(CCCU-V
-CEUU
(D
V(D d
C0
0
-
C0
C)
0
0CC)
C
C
C
-00
.0•CC
0CC
cC
EV-0CC
-0C
C
0C
C
(-CVC
-C
C(C
V-d
(CV-d
V
d0C
C
4-C
V-CC
Cd0C00-0V'0UC
d
VC)IC00VC
)
-0C'0CdC
d
0C
C
0
C
-
C000UC-
-C
CCCC)
0C00
0UVUCC
d
C
C
C00CCIC0
C
-
<0C
C
0C
C
C
C
0U0I
C
C
0C
C
C-0C
C
0UCC
E0C
C
CV
CCV0C
(D
CEd(CC-
C
C
VVV
C)CCCCC
t.4
C)
CD
'C
C
0
(CUC
C
)
(D
<(CUC
C
UCC<V(C
-C0C
CVE
C
C
(D
CC.0C-dCCV(
D
C
CCCCCL
C
D
(C2V-
dCC
C-
C
U
'CC
E
U(CD
V
C
C
(C
V
-dC(CC
C
C
1oV
:--dCCV
-(D V-dCCC V
—_..2C
C
UV:-C
-C
CV
oCCV
VC
(CC
0
CD
'cC
oU
N
(C
C)CC
.
-d
C-
V
CdUU
(C
UCCV
-b CIUVCdb
VUV
E-V<0<04C
d(CVC-UUU.U
dCC
C
<UU(C
bC
(C
.
C
C
CC
C4C
UVD
0
V-
-d•C
V
O
-C
CU
•)-(D U--V(CUdoC•.<VECCdV
U-dC(CC
Ud0C•dCC
d
(D
CCC CC CC V
V-
E
d
4CCCCCUUSCCE
CX(D NVCoVC' VVUc -
C
V
C
C
44V
(C
C
C
C-C
-C
CD
-°C'CC V
CC
CCVTo-'CCVC
V
-dCC 2oC-I
C
(C
C
U
V
C
C
<CCCVVoUI)
C
(D UC
<
C
.–
U
C0C
oCV
(C
0<ECC
C
(C
C
<dU<CCCC
C
V
.2CC0CC-CCU(C(CC
C
C.
(D
CC
C•—-
C0COV
(C
-dCVU
CCCU(C
<
U(C
-dCC
C(C
VC(CC'CUC
C
C
(C-C
C
C
•2ii (C
•L
C(C2C
C
oCEC•CV
CU04V
CCVU
<C<Uç
oCC
V
CC
U
CC
(C-doCV(D
UUC
C
C
C--()C(
D
V
V
V
C)C
IVUC—
U(C-o<CC
CC
tC
oC
(C
U
-dUVC
oUCC-
U C
C
C
(CCC
CC
-do.
(C
NC-dCVC
C
-dCVN(CC<V
U(C0U
V(D
C
'D
C
CUC(CD(C•N-C
V
C
V
C
(C
-(D
(CCC(DCCCC-
CUCV-d
(CCCC<C4V
C
.C
VVV•CCC
2-•C
.9C
dC-VCC
4C(C(C9UVC•-d
C.C
-dVECCE
C<XV
--d-d.-- o.<'CU C-dd(C2<VC2C
V<UC
V
C
VU(D
CV
-VCU
-C
•-CUCUV
CCC
U
E
2oV-Ud
C
V
CC-
oV<U-CCD
UD
CdC
C-CUC
C-CC0CC
C
CC
U
-dC
C
CC
EC(D
C
VC
CCC
CCUCCUCCV(C
D
(C
C-
-
--
--
-
--
-
--
--
-
-
-
(C
CC
C
-C
D
.
'C-U0-0C
C
C0
.H.C0C
-CCCU
4C
<(C
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 16/147
aC
)
C
)
aC<CaUC
)
C0Ca
aCC
-
a4
Ca
C-
C-
a
U4
aUC'CaU
CC
)
Ca
ECC-
a
Ca
C
)
C
C
a
aCC
a
a
a4aECa
UbD
C2CC
-
a'
-<
Ca
Caa4aECa
aCa
Ca
aU'a0C)
aCa
C4aCa
4Ca
a-)C
)
'Ca
C
a
C
a
C
-
C
a
-aaC
)
C
a
aC),IC
)0C
a
aaaC)
CCaaC
-
aCaaCaaCC-
C-
Q
)
IaaC
-
C)
C)
aC)
C
a
aaCICa
C)
CC)
-Q)C
a
aCaa,aaC)
a-aaaE
IaaC
a
a-C
a
aCa
aaaaaC
a
C)
0C
)
a-C
-.
'CC
-.
aCa<
C
C
)
C
a
C
-.
aaC)
CC
d-)aaa-C
)
-C
a
-C
a
aaC)
C
a
C
-
C
a
aC
a
-C
a
C)
C
a
-aC
a
C)aaL
C
a
a
'C4aC
-<
4Ca
C
)
C
)
a-dCC-
'Ca4C
)
Caa-dC
a
0UC
-C
0C'aC)CEa(
D
C
)
CCUabD
ax
aC
-
0aC
-<
C4Q
.
Ca
C
)
aaC
)
C-dC'CaUCC
)
C
)
-dCa
CC
)
C
-
CCa4aCa
4Ca
Ca
C
-
Q
.
U'cUUC0
'a)
-cD
C
C
a
cC2C-
—E
E
aa
(CID 2aCC0'aUa-+aa C
Ct
a
C'
a
C-
CC4'L
a-C-< 'c
-C
aaE
Ic
b
c
0<
)
o•--CUU ac•<
C
0
U
U
Ln
Oi
C
C
CU
aCC
aC
a
UC
a
C
U
Ca
Ca
'0
a
C
LW
'C
CCa
.-aCC
a
Ca
a
C
•a.0
C
C
0
U
C
)a
C
4
a-a Ca .—- 0
C
C-cc—aM-C
-4a
0
aCa
C
-
4CUraaC
)
C<C
a
C
)
C
a
C-CbD
aCa
UC
)
CUUC
)
<C
-<
4C
)
aC
)
C
)
aC4C
-<
aUa
CCUCa
Ca
abD
aaC
)a4(
D
Ca
CaC
-<
Ca
0-CC
-<
4CUC
)
aaCaCaUC'CaUC-C0
aC
aCCa)U
CIZI
U
1
E4
-'CLEaC< C
< Ca C
aCaa
a
Ca
C'Ca
Ca
-CaU..<C
-
4
a
a"CaC
)
Ca
aU0
Z
a
Ca MC C)'C - .aCa CC
0C
<U<
aCCE
-aa
C)
aC• 6
"U0aaCa C>
Bo3-Ca4,aCC
)
Ca
C
L
-CaaC
a
C
)Co
.C
)
c
C
,
a
C
C-bID
CC
-
0(D
:21 1 4aCa
C1C
C'Ca
a
a
-4
a-' c 0CCa
4- UCa-d0
Ca
4
CD
C
a aUc_C2
aC
-)
c UaCa CU
Ua
bD
C
-
—aCa
C
D
C-
Ln
C
-
C
a
Ca I
U
-a C
a
-C
C-'C4'Ca
a
Ca
4Ca-I UCC
C
a
C
-ao
C
C
Ca
-,
C
a
a-
C-4C
a
CL
C
— CC
'a
C
C
0
CCC
—
C
)
0aa
:
-
-
• C
-C
D
C
)
a
C
C
-
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 17/147
C)
a'a' C
a
"C
C
a
u
(C
-Ca
aa)
a.C
)C-"CCa aaCC
a a)—
a
_
C
C
a a
b
^
o
(0a)C
a
a
_
C
)c_C-CL
C
a '-aar.
C
a aC
a
Ca
Ca
a-
—Q
.
aa)
Ia
a-a
a
o
U
Q)
-00co0-CC
aa
a
Ca)a-.
o<aaa0" a_aa0C
Ca__aC
))C0C)'ao
LA
- -d0a) v
u
)
-.- C
C
L
b
L
'C'CC
U
C-
a
a
aaC
'AA
aaa)C
CC
da0<
"C
o<E '-C Cdda)o
l
a
a)"_O
a.a
"dCoCoUC--CC"aa-a))C"l'a)C-C0-'-)C a C
aC 0<
a<<a)—_a)OCE U "C 0,aCaaa
d
Ca
O<aQ)CCXaaE Ca'< aa
)
C
t
z
a
a'•a0 o
C
CNEC
aC)
abC
U
'
0,"
a
.
a
-CC-ç'-a dB
a
a
a)C<00
a0as-
C
0a
b
a
-
C"
a)0<a)-<a
a
)
C
CC0
-'o-CCE E CC)t 1<"a"aaQa)aC)<a•Od
'
a)
a">
a"
a
CCa)EaC
'- aaaku
-d
v "CO
b
j
^
a)Ca—
E a"
C
C - C
,0_
Ca
aaC-a
V)0a)a"aaa)
a
Caa)
a
C'CC"COaCLW0'C>aoCaD <ClaaaC-CCC
4
c
)
a<aa)La
"C
)CCa)CC
'C
E '"a.C)'aC0<0<
"C"
c
"
a00<0<a
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 18/147
-4-4CCC
D
VV' C)
'LV
V°çIoIV-40
VL
04
V0 V0
-40
4 o04V
C
.—U
o(4
4
1
1
C
U
Vc
m
Q
Vc1
V
V(4,
0OC
'cV
C
U VbV
;E
0
0" d
1•(D
(D
V
<
(0OedEVC=c0UVE
-dU
0EVC
Uç
c
c
VV4
V
UdV
(D
4V
40
Cb
D(4'V<V
.— -C0VVcom<
C
U
(0
° 2--
-0m -
)( lz
01-4CVU0C1Vo0dVUV<C
UVC
VV(D
V14
V
VV-d—
ID
VVV
u<U
Ocd
-'V
UVVU(0
Q
)M4 —
b
lD
4-dD
'
cCUC0V0<
(D
U(D0<<
Vdl4_VCVIDV(44U4-4.0c-dU C<1
-
VULCD_VCO
b
O
c
E4-V<V'02 (ud(D
UV
0
0
VoCVV—
14OC<CC0C CC4(0VbD0 >(0VEC:E-4U<Vu -U VC
U07CU(D
1
(UC0
V
OC4_<
rU.
Cod_.O
-dI
0U0bCIn4
<
1040'
I -4
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 19/147
-C:
um
z•C' C
L-V-C-
CV
UC-CC--C
u
-L.Ucn NV VCC
-
UVU CCV
Ln
.— --l
Ct
Vc
44C
Q CCVC0,VVCU•CV'-VV<22
Cd
C•
_O
CcvbD
C'CC—
C-C0CV
E
C
BC
U -Z
J
—
4-C
C
C
U
V
CV4•0-
4
cB
CV-V" CC•—VVCVU',-,cd V-E- L4-CU L-4 C
S
Z
U
CU•')V
4-
C
VVL2CCC)D
C
V
0
V
COOV4V<V4V(u 71 V4/)4C4
V
U
I
'
.CC
Ij -jCaC
<V<cCc—Vc–4<CcCc CCCCC>VV-CbC tCUaCCVC.< IW C,C.uVCCCC
u
U
V(CV4V
V
CC
C
C-UVVC-UcVOC4CUECV C- CUVVC CCV-C-U C
UUCM1
C
C)QCVvVCVVVVC
VC2<
'
V—CB
I VcV
2
'C
UCc
bD-U-V 2 VVV
CC(U Con C4.
U-aCB
cl
1
UD-
VV -VVCD0"VVC-42EC
O
)
VCVClUVCCCC.0CTVCCVVVU.UCc5U U._2 •- c V.— '•1CJU -—UV
C—L•b
C.:
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 20/147
(4
s
Cd
U
cU(4CC sC
4
C)
s
C4
'Cs
ovo4C-(4Vd
C1
V
CE
(4
C'4
MV
V
Uc
C
-
V
C
CV
o -VUC --E- -V<-CV'4d1Ucb
' UV--C -V
-
.4
'4<VV
MUUN----C(UV
c
CV
CsUQ
CVcUVCC)V--(4--4c
V
4
C
)
-000U
1
(4
•-4
C
)
U
CU VoV
CCU
-CUVcC
C
C
d)
V C
Co0
V
CVCVC
CV.< "
4
<
.0
C
umou
CVU
sCS
.CU JCCU-sEC4-CV
'-4-—
V41 uCVC,C
CUo<V<C
C
CCC.(4<V
Inm 4
V
(4=V
'eU
U
C)
<
CVV
..V
<d'
V
—
V
(UE
(
'
4U
sVV< -C
-
V
s
CVVEV V'4Cl•VCco
c
C
c°'4
VV-"< CC
C
IVC4CC
4-LCVV
-
.s -oV UU<-
U<CUbLVC1
4
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 21/147
V-IS 'Cc
d
0VU'CVVC
-CCUVC(
DCUVV
0'00U-00-0L0-0U0CU0
UU00C0EU0C)0<UC)00C
)
U00-UE
'UU'0C0UC)
Di0C
CCVU(C'CCVVV-dUV
'D
--i
CCVCVJD
(DV
CV'D
-i
C'CV(D 4(
D40U
0Di-
C
V0V-
i
:c 0C--oV(
D
•C-D
V
oo
CDi(D
CCUVCCVC
C
ID
C
V'C
UC
V
(D'C
CUU0(D
D
C- UUC0<
V
'CCID
CI ICU
.VVVV- VUC<V(D
(DVV-
iU'C
'VDi
-iUb
i
o
0
CUCCVCI
4C
VCUV-i
CCtDCUVC'C0
0CU
C)<00-
C0
0C
-01-00-0C000UCU0UU000)U
UDiU0
UDiC-DiUU000U-i10000UU0'0Di
V0C(D
V-i
(DV'CU
'
-i
CCUcr
V'-CCC'CCVErD CV0CC
-i
CcCC(D
VV-VCV(D
(D
VoV(D<
D
VV
tVC
V
C
c
-L
r
CC
.-V
C147
CV
V
j3-(DUCU
C--
V(C(D
-CVD VVV
-(D"U
r.
C)
D•
c
VC
C)
C
V
U
V(D
(D
VC0V<
'C
0
V
V
(D
C
cC Uc '-
CU(
Co-c C
•
U(D V
C
VU E
C
<
V
V-0cUmE
-i-=VDVCC-3VcUV
C
(D
•U CV
C
4-E:-
(D
V
UD
m
-
(DCV
C- --4
' C•C-
U-V
c(D
VVVC
5
,E c 7:1 bn
C
-.•CCCCE
0C0<-U
V
'-Di
lu
VCdV
C
-V•C
E
'0
C
'IV
'V>
U
'C--C(D -
-
0Cr0'C
U0CDi0C00UDi
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 22/147
00
CVc—
0ccc .T••
c
V
Vic
V
oC-
1
o
00c0CI
c
VV
I—
C
(
VC
d
C
,5-C1VCV C0<0N 0
C
- C
-c
IN ——IiE
iç
—
C-C
C 0•Cc
M
=L•. 0— -C •NC-c=r0
V
0Mc
cCOC
d)
-—V,
'.-f o:z
0
00V
'
rcO
CV"0-
,
0
—
0
VCC
,—
V'ac
c
_
C
C
' .-N
>QC)
000,(I))-aC V
0
C -cCC'-cIc0CCC v-<•— 0 0 —0 V,vNV000VOaBV C
.0
C
-c
'ae0V0•ca
C.—
u
V
oV
o-e
V—VC.Vc Oa0
00VV V
'-<0VO
0aC
C
—
V
cV
E-c
<UcV
,ç0C
d VU
0cO'aoVCVC
V
a
CV0—
cl ,0bDV)0
1-4
OdV0<Vo
'acN
OC.-0—V0<Voc oO
Vo0O V
-. "ce' <U0 oae
c
cC-c'OCc,' oV<V
c)
c
V
O
d
'
c
V.JDe
ECV
e0
c0
00
'ao-e—
V
.50CcZ
C
V"- VC
eo
V
ac
c
c
C-C
C
D
0
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 23/147
00
:LL
30L-
00o
L
0
0
0
IL00L00
U"0
L
0LL
'
0oL
0
<0
<<
L
00
(JL0
0
I(1
00L(
1I4
00lD
L0<
'J
00L3LL
00"00
L0'00
40300
0L
00L
'0
0L0
(D
0—(DC 0L
-Oc_0c
V0
-EE
EVID
V
(D
0•0(DoVL0LLVVVV
D
80Ev ((D10VV0(D Eluc--00VL'0E(D(D0vVV
0(D
L
luE0ll/DQD
0<
000.00
F'1
,L1.IN
000CD
O
0
0
00
4
7Cu0
L0
(11
000L0001
aL
"00VOL
"00000• 0L0c00LL" 000xoE E
0-0-(D-rD
•VE0-(DD
0
0
0-•V0(D0(0
I-
0ID
01 v
(D 0ç' -000-(D11Vi.r 0
0
I0-. 0(D
=
0
V-•V' QoL0E00
V
(D
C
U
'C.;VO0
0
L
0-L VLV
1104
0.-L00a(D0-VL
LD
L•V
"0-0V00
0—0
1
1
4
<
0L
0ç
0010
"00
0L< =-L4-L(1--00r,0L3004
LL
0<3L0 U—L-
O
0
-
0"0LL1—
O
4-I0LO
0020(DU
3 L--aL<Q<L0
0
0
(D
LL(D
V<
0IOD
-0V0-•(DçVV=004E
<V3
0 (D
V
E
0
'a
0(D
0VI
<0-
—(D000!7M0
L-<V30
L0
o
0--300LLL 0V40lr
NNd
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 24/147
<
C•-
0
s0C
Uc
U
'D
CI
O
V
o
0C-C
'V-.CV'DVCVVE
CV•VU"•-VVV0C U0N4PV'VI•-EVoV CCCCC
NVVVVVVVNN(
4
00U
LV
•0LC
LVVVVNU
IVVC0C'NVV0 NCLNVCUN'LIC
-VCIVLIVC
'NVNVICL
VCC0
CN'4
NN1<
VC'NVVVVV0
CV'LUNLVCC
lC
LVNVV
-dVCV
VNNVCUN'I'LVC0
NUVN'LVNLVNCVCC
LNVC'NUN'LV
CUVN(4
CUCUN
C-VC-
c
I.<C
C
o
U V•
"V—
UC c0
V
c
(CV- Ig VC
CD
V 4
CbJQ
<U<oV
V
"D
'D•—
V- L
D
C—çVU.VV0
VV<V0EV0cV<V
4
I— <U
01EVV
V
-V
VVD o-UV-<8V-
VV
-UmnoVU'ICVu
V4 UVCV
VU—
'<VC
VVVUVUV-—UVV'
EViV C
u
UD
V— VV1U
U
CVO
CD
NUVVEo0B
V'VV<
V
<
cVV-Uzm8'4v—<EBV0'<IDV0•
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 25/147
VU
0UcN0Cc)V0U<
c CV0CE CUc
-j
UV
U
- cVUc)4
CUOIUC
2' V
C
NC'NCN-
CNVCCICCVCVNCCVCCUNEV0VCC--CC
'cCICV-CCVCN0CCNICCN'0
0N4U
,CCNCVNCCU
-<00NV0
-
0C0-
N-
NC-d-CNVVU
,CCNCC0CCNCNC-0V-N-CU
NCV-V-N-NI0NCCN00-N-NI0CCNVCVNC0NCICCC-0
CCVCCVV-CV0-
NCNNNUCM.
'VV-N-0.
NCNUVV'CUN0I
INIVCCCCVCCUNNNVC0
0
CC'NUVUCCUCCVENNNVCVCC0.
C'NUC0UCCUN0CICCNU0<NCC'NUC00.
0CUNVCCN-
VVCN0CEN
CU0lcVCCCVcV4400cE VV4cVE
040V
J
V .E Vc'd o
E
0
-
U b0V
VV
V
In
c
V1
V•uL-o
-0,oVEo
V1---
U0t.C---(=Cc0<VC<
U
4
o
2<0Cc.cC' UV
0
.,c -VV-c,Uoqj C--
CV
2
O UVV4-4
dV'CV0
V
V
VVcU
-c
=<0
c c- C
c
4-c
t-4
V
c
-C0
C4c
"cV
I000
b
O VV0V
4E
Ndc
0
Vc
'0VU4lccV
c
2
0
cEVVCLcCc CC0
C
00
V U0'0U-.<
NC0—UC0
0U
-c
V-V-
V
c
"0'CU
V-C0-0. 0
Uc
-0
0 1-cV0
cc-O
UC.?
C
---
V
C
4400Vc,
V1-
0<V"
l-n .041
-Vl
C0
0V
-
0c cC
'_V
VV
U0
C cC-cC
c
'V--C - -uUC U"oV.C
ckVVV
0
E
04
V4-d
-d.11!cVV: (UC'c<V-CUE ,c4
0V
-
g-VU
0
V
(U-
U
C
V
V
NN0NN-CCCC'NC'NCCC00C1<
CCLCIC'CICC0CNN-
NC
IIC0.41C
.
0"0C
CC'CN C
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 26/147
'NN
'
N-0.
-V
ONN
4
00
N
.VVa--CV0••VV' c'<U ,ç0ac—VI0VC
V
ç
00<V
<V
0<U
<V
Vo -<V0UUcE4
V00
0—
U
0:,0
V•0V
C,
0•-
V<0CVC0
0CCU0V0UVUC<V 0VU,V0mU
CCc
0Ca0V(um
0CV
lC---VV'<ccCVa-U
E0oV <CUV-0cL 00---c V
0LCM
0
m Vto
0V.0CC
C-0)C
—VU VC•
E
V
VVC
•V- U4--'V
:-€
V00,V0
c
C,U0V0UVC
•
b
V
0
0V-•—
oc
U mVb
VC4<V
VIc
C
-C
— <V•VVU<V
UVC
•_,,
V)C
VEEV0V4
s
.E
0•0
4
Q
-
kz
j,0Vd C-VCVV
r
V
—C' V
V0VU -
0
VVCoto C.o E—4—VC,—VV
1
UC•<V-C,,
LVCV
cd
Qto—V C
C.
c
C,
QoN
0-•.0C-
VVU-V<C)C41
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 27/147
C'CI
CVVI
C-C-C-C-C-C0
E -1C-
E CO Cd -C—0C0
SV0
C
O
UI
O
V
-uE LO)(UV
CO
-I
d
V
0
C
0E0X-d4
0
V-0
C
V0
V
V
VC 0
V0
N
E C
O
V•COI
0
V
COOO_oVUO0
8EV
—
C
OCO
•0V' 10' NCICC
CIO
V
0V0
EVV0-NO
C,
S0
0V0b
V V
E
çC
U
BooE V000<EC
O
00,
C
0
EE—CO
b4Co-2
V
C
'
-
In
U
CU0V
CC
CC
V
V
-
CO
C
O
V
2
EcB
c
0
V
-C C0
01
V---0-
0
c
•
c0UEV U E
C V 0 0
dU
E'cCCCVV0XV0Cd CV
.
EV3- U
O
U0E
U VS
V
ECd VC
CO
0
CUUd
VECO
Q
C
U
C- EoE
E0Cd
•I *4
-1
C
CC
VCVçC
VCVd -' VCO
C
-C5
-
0 C-E uCUOC0 .'2Vo0 dUbO 0MC
CO
0
U
-d—I4-
I
VCO UC
CO
0 E CCV0Q•CdV
V0C0dVQCC0 E C
V0
V C) C Li VUdVCdUVc
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 28/147
C
.
E<C0-daCQ<
cC
-dUEcC C
.
0'cC
cC
a-d
I cC
'C
(Ca0'acC a)UcC
0cC
Ia)
-C
'CCC
0Ca)
C-
a.
aC
)
'C
.CC
-a)
C
.
a-
a'C
C
0CC
C
C
CC a
C
C
aaaCC
aCC
a-aV'a0C
C
0L
CC
aaCC
CIa-
UC
.
0U0-dacC
a0
CC
UOCC
,a EC
C
da
.L
—)
C
,
a
-4C
C
-
o-a'V4-C
0'cC4
--C
CacCCl
aC
.
a'C
C
00Ua0cC
U
"C
-
-I1
'CCCcIC
C0Q)aC.
CC
C
C
,
VI-C-)
C-)
V0aC
C
-a
CC
aa0CC I
'CC
a.
LaCC aC
C
C
C
CC
aIaCC
-C
.
i
cJ
E—-
CC
U
.
CC
0
0cC
0 Co.'cCcC
a
' cC
.<CC
oCC
-CcC
0
a)
-a)Cd)C-'
C
CC '<.)a
).0I-C
C
)
(C
)
aa
0
C
0
)
'C
0-dacC
0C
C
cC
C-C
cC
,
IC
cC
CC
0CC
-d)
a
0
C—
)
cC
'<0
C0-dCCC
a-d'<
0
CC
U
4-C
CC I'<I
C
C
0
a)
CCl
0C
-C
cC4-C
0C
.
EaCC
CC
C
-C
a)
a00U00CC
0-da)
C0-dC
C
N 4
a"C
0aE
CC
r -0EQC
d
)
a-daaQC0'
Ca)
4
C0(C
)
0a0Ua)
-dcC -dcC
a0Uc
C
a)
-d004
C
—
a0".
10
0ç0.
_
)
-•-E=-c•CCC)
U
CC)
E-a)0
<
:<BI:U a)"E 0
Cd
-:-dL
cC -.
<
0
0
dcC cC
C
-C
C
C
cC
CCC<
cC
cC
o
a)
a0-00'cC c
C
'0
Ca.-
CC
0-d0a(C)
Ca)
cCa.
I
c
U
a
cC
aa4
0
'C
o
0
C
C
"cC
C
C
)
0
0
C
a)I-CC '
C'cC C
cC
N '-C'<a
cC
0C
C
)
CUcC .
-dC
c
-a
(CcC
:
•EE
' Ct '<
E' 00
0
-CC
-a)
CC
C
C
cCa-0aCa)cC C
C
-CC
a<
U4C
CcC (C
-l
O
—'cC
UCL
•a-CC
C0
-a)
-4CC
'-Ca
cC
-
C C
-
C0C0
C
a)a CcC
"a04-
C
a"a
d
U
C
(CN-C
a
4
C
L-cC
cC --'<cC C
)
0
cC
a
0
<
C
C
aa
0Caa
CC C
l
UCC
<a)
aasa
Ca'0UCC
a
--'CC
CcC
V
'a
Va<
x
)
NN
a
NC'C
N
aC
C
a
CC
uHV
.- -Ca'
C
-C
a
..VVa-
C' 'C
T C
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 29/147
NUc<0CaNE 0'a0'Na00C
aac
Ua.
caNcUNa'aaaaI-ca
C'NC-N4Ca
'aNcNUc'0ca
n
N
—
—
o04
ac0
CQ0CU
c
0C
ia
0
INacCacaNaCa
.
0N
cNcN"4
cC-NNcN-
a.
I 0"4
c0
0
c
0
c04cia
4Vcia
VC
d
—
-da-
1.c
14
4-O44a-
-0UC
IS
I000UI40ccc—
-c-
cUcVcc,
caVCi04cV0
e-o00a
.
V4lc-Ua0U
-c ,-V aç
V
z-
0cia U
oV0
--ia
c/a
c/a
c
-VoU.'
4a
—
E
0a0'm0 a— 0
0aV—-1<Vca0U1404— 4---0-co VUa
—
VcaN O0
C)-.a
V4cV1
c0c0Uc4ca
cccia
V0cV-dc--4Vccc0Nc-VIc
Vcia
NI-caan
ca)a)C'Nca)ca)NIUca)44CU4a0a-N
-cNc
-cCa
a)cCN0Na)
dUV
4-
c-c a
U
N
0a
4
c 0
U
c0cia 40
-@-
ccV-c-:-40
O
U0
—00
0
00U<
—
V
I
0 0.
.
.—
a0
Uo Vc 0L
-ccO
'40c(D
'-
c
V
cc
1
c
V
V
-ca—
caUQ
)1—
V
c
V -cc
•0—-VV'0c cccc040UcI
c— c•cia c
—
c-c ca0U44UrccrVVc
0
0ccc-VCico0U0U"0V-ddbV
..Ic4-0
0-
ça
-
0'Ua
0
CIO
o o
VUUb0VIccia 0
<V c
40r4U—
00c-"V-Uc00UUEccac c —c-0c0c—
ca0
c .cia
bD — < 4c1cVV-cc
Uc
c
aacUc
O 0
Uc04
L
T
-Icc0kLVccV U4"V
c'0
'<caVca' 0b
7
o Vc04
oUc
4V-ccc 4Vcc0U7U cIc-04c
ia
ccC
c
0VIcV00UVc00cI
cc4.c
cia
0cia
cca0c
cccia
V
0ca
VVUO0-d
1-c 4fcc4Vcc'cc— 0
c-
bC
:
V<
2
-c
-c
U
c c0
0
Ca
-c
—c U
04
-Lc
ca
caU0"4
U
O
UCa4
"4cIc4c
U
V NccUIc
-04c
ia
c0c
/a
c
c,VUcIccU0cV-0 04Vcc
ia
o'c-
cIc
4cOc
bD
VUUc
cc
V
CL
00c
/
cC
U
C
/
Zc
0-0<•0.0-0
0
-4
2
Ca
-C
c
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 30/147
00C
-
V'0UNNN00.
C-
C
-C
0IV
C
)
C
)
C
-
00
-0U0-0oUL
UV
C Cd C)U-lV1
' UC 0C
0
LV
0<
U0
clu
4
0-0C
C
c0
V1dU—UCV0<C)
V
0-0VV
144
CU
C
UC0
UCU4mV'-V-Cl0I<<UM00<v
2V
bD4N0Vço4 UCN0'0U•<
E°
-
-CO 4
LU
0ca
Co
CO
-C)
-U00-UI_d)I
0<0
0cUL
<U
000UC
d0-
C
-C
:-
U11Va00C
)L
U
lu
4C
cc U
c
-2C
UZ
0
-VCl4- U-*Z0
-
U0Cl0C0lUc
R
I-0UUE0U-6ECd4
Clld)-C
Cdç
CCl0
bD<cUc__C
lICo
cVU
1
4
Cl
UCbnC)V
<
LCo-C-L)V
41
oVU
V0Vç =Vc0
0-<U
Cl
'ao0
U"'0 44
'U0V0
0UC
0V
C-<0Co
0 cuIS VUVC'1C0CVUo
C
0VU0V
Co
1
0
CO
4
C
d)C
cbD
0)C)ç
CoC 0
o
VtC- -—40U1 ClC 0UV0Co 0ocUOM0UDUE_o0_0U0CU 0-4CCC
o
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 31/147
00>Cd VL C0oVt
CL,
-..
UV
' Vo -CU.-V1H-oEV0V•
Vi
0V0
1-4 C
d
0C0CVCUC' 00,mEn 4Z--C:CbrCC
0
0
VV-
C-0u
C<
0
0000
-0a
CL z
III2, 0—00C' 0UC <
-
0'0
MIZo
00C
J
U-ffL0.00
0
D
'00-C.CI00C)00CC000C(0C0V0C0
(D(0U C0V
'VVC00C
c00Vc
VI
Q
U 0.
-
0-U
c
u
0o0.V
<'01
0
000 uiçQ,
C)
o
V
C
00
V
00<cC,iIFc"I0—000VV00d '0'V0oI'V0C0U.—0VVC0-da 0cC C
,C
VU
0V
CVVVV
EC
-0
C
CCvV-1
UUo
NC)
0
C—c'VC' U0
M0
1
^
_
oou0
LA
--'C VC
E U0VC
r,V0CUC0 c
z
c
o
0
-
C0C. 0<-V0CuC•VV—<0(C0CcE C-V•
'C
0E U0<0
0.0 00C-E
C
dU-9C-U0(( 00<.E'VC010
CE
CU0U0C))0V
0C.VoUU 0U
0'0o ,1
VC
lu
-V
C0-
a.
(1 -C
0SC00'CtLU< çuC
C0
c
I
V0
0
(1<V
50
-o C(10UCV
C
V1uo0E ECdED
C
O
000'C
'I).CO
CO
<
'CO
00
0
0
<<
<
I'
0
0
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 32/147
U0
coL-4U00UV-
l
4Cl
00V
©E
0UU(
l'-
00d.S
)0
..L0
Cl
C
0U0< Cbv- 00oCVC-' C
0>•0Eo
0C
U
V0
•—00VV0(J
'E00U"
C
l
E—
LV
oE0 0
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 33/147
VUCVCUCE
VcC
C
Vo-VV
c4
C
Vo V
UV<V
0oE
V
uCVVC
VVEV'c
z
u
VC<-
-uVVC
-
V
CUCV
C"F 2cn VCr
c
2'cçU
0<-
o
k
—-•
'<
EoC 2E UUVV
CCCCo
u
m
CC)CVC
(VVCC
'1<<Ua00CE cn EUVU UEV: VE <CIS 2CCV<U<CCCCCUVC
C
c
E
V
C'C
Q
CV
0<VC
M
V
C
c
.-
V-E E V VCCCEVECVVUVCVC
E
V
IC
V
VCCCUfCU
CC)VMUC
<C
V
C
U
cl V2V
aIM CCr.
c
0
.
EVVCVCV
C
,
U CCCUV
VCVV
C
U:
VCH CCQ VE)C)
1
E
C•V(C: UC0<tC.O aE V
EV E VaE
•
C
V0<
CL U
U
k
C
E<U
C>
VUC.
VLCC
CCC
a
C
V-CC
cCO
V
U
0<
V
VE
b
V
C0<0<
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 34/147
b0 60CN V
C
V
CV'9-9.C2:2V
CV
-9999
C'VNVN9CNCCcC 'C'VOVV00V"Uc U0V02o0-VCVdUr "VCVNvC"—C
V.D
ViI 0cL
0V'-'V
U4
?D
V
NU
'4U'NC
CCCc
0 mmV0NOV,NNNVNUoUcUOccU
NV
çNUNUV,NVU 00NNN 0V0'N=-N8
0' 0C
VNV' V.EV00 -
0CNU,00E-V0 oN0N04
4
C
'4
E
N—U0V0cvCONOVNIDVlDV
4
0V- 0NV0
0NNlD-VVN.DNN0NbONUUV'4'N 7 0CNC VL
W
1ND
)U0U'V0,Zc'4C'NNNNNIDIDVNNcUV"jVNN NV
Q0D
04UUEV0
rD
'4—
'4
ND'0V4 o4-c4'N0o&N 0-0-I
'0'U0N
---'i
--VN-NNO00IVV
D
rq rq'4 CV
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 35/147
I-'
—U
VmM
c1
rD
-•
Vc1c V
VDcr c
C c1V
•
C °
-c C
M
)UcNO
rVC
CV
-u-I
•CCU1VrDCC U
c
C0 Cb0U-C _bDC•-CrCVC c CVc1LVC
Ucz
c1V-Cm
C
V
V
-c
-
a
C c
2V V
-c—
—cE•_C
C
(D CCm
(
VCCEn CCC
1CCCC•0U cDaCCVV-iDCVC4-CUbDc1Cu-4 14U VIIc
•
VCU
C
VVC—cn
C•Cl
Ccr1 ,L'mE uVUU LO )C-C1C
Icr c (C
V (C)(
dCCE
bV
L)CC
u
V
)
QCc1bDUc1CVU D6 -I-)CCc cr Uc NCCc
Vcr Cc
V
Ca) Cm
ou
C
cCCc1Cc 1<
1a
:
c1U'V1
C
m
.
C
1
c1
I avUOU— -VCM
—
CCIC
V
u
U
U
VC-I crn -C 4
c Ca
--U mc1C
d
LC)C
VCbD
UI0
V-aVVVU V VVCUc11aUCCcDUUViSc
V
UC
V
Za
VVC-- .
c1
bD Vo
V•C
- -V-dC0.
C c
:
VC
.
--d
C)
CC C
C)
CC
U
.
CCCbUC
OC)C)0C
C
Cd
0CC
C
C
-d0
-
C
C
C
aCdCd
C)CC0C0CCCCC CC C_
C
C
C
Q C)
0
COC0
I I
•-E C
C
C
OHCC0
-E
C
C
S
C
d 5•
0Xo
5C
C
C)
CC
C
C
LDCd
C
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 36/147
08U
(4
VVVE mUEEV
b
00V0
0
0#U 0Co
V
c
..k
UV0
oHC._VOC )00E0
—
c
C
IS
0<
0
—
0U0'000
c
-ULU
c
V0UV00VVNV00'VV00NU00NNV4NNNN'V
c
0VCCd 4
1— U0V
cV0cVV41VC400c C
V
Vc)4 0u,0V-
—
<N4
•<:_N
U
40
0E0V
UUVN
0•0
V
4
UU'NCa04 QCC-_C)C VE<0<.— 0—N0•V41mCv0UVV'0N
V
' -j —— -C
o0e•—UIU
V4UcC:VUVc0V0UC VVCVU0•—
—U' Vc
CV0410V)I,VV0V C.2
C
V02
00— :C
41
#
VV44
'-
VV•_—
VI4
U
'
UV1 --C. 04-44-U .04(4o0V-4-4 V
080CU
V0VNCVb>— 8CV000CC10
V0 0—
2
V0-UV
0V
•<
41VUcw >0C
4
U
-C
d
0
CCCC VUC
0
•
C
2 -CV0CI0
0
:—
•c
4
C
UU0041
C0U
(<7
UU
0c0000'VUU <C.
(
00C0
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 37/147
V-VNU-CVCN0'NUVN(VNCEVVVNNCVV2CNCVIV2
VVNVUVNNNVVN2V02VVCUVVV-CVVN0VVVV(VNCVCC
UNCVV-VCx
rz#V"V—0"V
NN'
V0
NV
U
V
N
U V•0-
U
VV
—
VV-
U
o
N2oU E
—
-UC
aaV
C U
0U
V
EN
0-
c
54 0
o
•V0— m UaEV-C V
oU0VN
°E--0-VV' UFVU— N
.0N
VU N
—•N—C
C
6
VN
00'VVE00•.
NV0V0
V
'-071U
VV
0-VVO
VVVooo--VV0Vj 0Vç0UçV
UVVVao
VV- -—
Q
0Q -' (0V—V'VU UVVU
0- L
O
S
UE
E
E(DUVV
VV
V
VUr
KDD
U
V'D (D
(D
V
ID -1
V—VV—I_V.V-V-0
VV0o<U1VOD0 -0 V
V10VEV
V
,
N—
'N
V
V
—
Uuz 0
-ao•— 2,
UVVV-VVV
(D c0VU'D cV' '—:—c0NVVU0NNU—V NVcdb
Q
NçN0
V
V
0
N.
U
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 38/147
b
r C.
I•-U•_0• C0<VVV
OV
VC
C
CC U
Cd U
0
c<-d
.V<C
0-0C<U0
-<C
C V
•U
00V<C0V<
C
<C
VI0VVVV-d-dVU0
-CV
.-:C
•b<SCO.-lc
Cd
'
—
g— EU
1US-———VcVClVCI
C
cdC
—VVCS2VCU<cCClX
C
<
V
VC(VVJ
IVClC CUCU"Uc
ICV1<
b
V:
k<C CIL
.
<C
CU—UCC0
0
E5—
CCUUcu
CVC l
UUUL7uC0
U
U
0
C00<l—UC)-
c
V—<zo
C
0VVC<CCNVCDUC-•V..C)C<CC0CUCCc-SVC C
C
NU-C-CC
CVa1
c
C
)VC-CmC
çC
'C)
CCVCVvIc;0-UCCC)C<
<
c
—<C)
CC)
C)CC)
CC_CV
C)<VU2I.cV(C—LV<ECCdU0CC)V'<VCc<0<C)0U CoC4CC)-0CC)CU U.
VCCVV<ECU
0<
0<CC)
QCU
b
z
U0<C
UC)C)C<<
<UCVVV
)
-C)CVCVC C)>c
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 39/147
--a
V
C'
V
U'VCcNCCcUQ-11 t0V
V
)
V
(C
UVUIVVP
C_C
IS
7V
-.-=w E4I<C 0<VV E
V
V
ooV-4- OUcEc +-IC
UCUcVCj
'CCo,8
O
CCU)
7C
U
C
CVcU
10
o —cm
V
c(VV
-I
7
C -EVVNCçU I>
C
I1 UCç
V
-oV rD C
V
V
V U V VVC80CN
0
V
VV CCU
C
0
D
0
- 1 NV
U V
C
-' -rD V•U(D
C U
-'ç
CNcVCV
U
V U c
4
•°<—o
' Q:I
VVUV $
(D
— 0—IcCC
V
IICVV
--d-
CD
C UVCIVrD oUVD V CVVo4cCU3(D <-V V I<
.d
U UCVV — U UVrVd>NDc.D (D
'c
<
c< Eoo— CCacUV— oCEVCVVV0
(ID(ID
ckm 8
(
D
0
VVVU
U
cDcDVV
V
< 0<V(D (0oU4VI(A V
VV
EU
Ud
(
D
r
(D C((<COUCC
V-
c
<-d
0CVVdI (
D
0
10VU ID —U
d'VV
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 40/147
CO
)
LU
I-
Ccm
V
E
U
a.
r•_ Q(D0000EV
.—D
U
iV
(DD
VeVID
(D
V> VV000)clC0)-000V(10VVV_bVV-0•V(DD —()0CID (Dc
d DD
V
k0-c<V0
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 41/147
VUEVUV0VU
0UC'1CU0CC(1
C'C
E
CL
E
4
-0UU
C
'VVUC
X—V
-CVVVu7 C
:C
CVC
V
-UUcd
CU
E U
VUQU
C
VCC0CC
>
•0,V'
jC
VE0ECC
ECVCC
-bUV—
C.
C
—
C
UU
UC-eC0
(C
bDCC' eV
—
'
U
CC
C
r C'CtK
CCVUU
-eCCVUU =-eCUCV
E UUCCC<C
'7V
C•CC
)UCbn
8 CCC
(C
UCV.E'-a.
C
C
•C
-eV:
C
— C0•cCC-C0— VZucnC
-e
V •F I
•C0C
—
C —C
C
CCVC •—o
0CUC
(C
VC
V
C
'o,V0n C
C
:.CUUUC o0CC
bD•CUU'-0()'CV
C-o
E
C
C
oCC'C— CCV
'CC
)
CC
C C1
-
U'C
C
CCC0CC
E—-— CCCVCC
C
C
— (CV
CI• C
C"CCID-e
CCNV
•C—
0VCCVa
E
C
CC
'(U
-C.B CVV(-U
o0-E0ar
(C0Cu cz
CCV
—CCCC.U
c
u
CU—
C
VC
C0CC
C
CL
C
CC
L
CC
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 42/147
—
.f
00
VN
0V. -—0C
d
Cd
0U. CV0V
Cd
V
Cd
V
a
CL)
0
zIMCdQVd
-
1i1du—-EECCC00•CCCd C)dCdU,VVCVUECd)' jt. Vc') <CCUCCdVV.CVCCd,oc dEUC-Cd-
Q0
U, ) U
CL
V—
0VC
Cd
ç d
'C
CC
C-C
CC
.cLL
C
Cd
Q VCdVVV
d
Cd
0C)
)0cUV
to—
=
C
-
-0
VVUV
C
C
•C)0
Cd VEI-Cd0o U-
Cd
'B
Cd.-Cd dd
-0VVCVVH
U0-VtzCCddo')CdC tLUCdCS
:Cl-dVC'U
Cd
;4Cs
Cd
CCll
d
Q
V
0CCdl') Cd
Cd'Cd CCd
J
rM
0VEClC'C0U U
CdV0V
oCd'10V
Cd-
C.
EV
CdICdV—U•Cd)C
C°
b
V
-C
U_.0
Cd'VCdUdV0m05CdCdC
IS
Ckm 0
CdVVU0A V
CUCd
CdVCdCVC'.P
Cd
Cl
C
C
W
<EV
-CdCS
V
C
U
-o••
Cdd
d
CC)
U
oV'VCdCd-
0 .) L V CU VClV
C
0
d0NOU--cLV()0•Cd-CdZ E
d V
0V•C
0 -Cd V0l
Cd
c•-U
Cl
Cd
C
'V
U
ZCd
' •-bL
0U
-C
CC
CCCCo
-
C))C)CVCCd
C
Cd
C
CC
:
dl
CCCo
C
Cd
C)d
CCdCd0
C
-
S•CCCd
Cd
C
CC0ECdC.
-C-CdC0CC)CCCCd
C
V
CC
• d-d
C.0C.C
Cd-C
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 43/147
LI <
• -oE0U-LL
I
0000
-0L0<
-00
0-U<-C
lClVEVV•
L
<
0
V
°000—
E0
E
C
olI
0VV
L
•
••CçC
I
0<
I10
U'0
<•C,<ID Vç0
E<
U.<
c
UcoU0
0V UC)<< V<VCV
V
°)
C 0-<• 0•VV0- 0 U"V< 00V0r)—
050•V<
0
VZ
I
•r•
• IE•
< 2
V.<V°V00' E20V E-•0VVE0)V
V
cU C
,-Vo<c
,uo
0
V0<<V
VV0EEV0UM
-0<
C c
•—•
•E
Qj
ECo V
0V
<VVV2co<0<<V
o
V
° •
0
-E-E 41Qj
LCo
0
c02< EcdVUUC—
-
0EVV0<E0Ec< VVEç
IM
m
EI<E
E•EVEEVtn
USVEE00V
IuV
VC < Co
V
o0VVVV<< —VV0
0<0VoUVC
,0&V0UVu1ccV
V<
04
cUV<CoU-(LaQDC0<0CEE
00V
0cVV
U <•o0•U0-
NV
I
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 44/147
0VCVCI 0I
N(VV(0U
U4(V0UVCa
U0CUC
-
04C
NC
NC 1-VNC
VVCVV4CV'CV
c
CbDC
'a CCCNC
CCU-N
C
NC
I'CN
C
CCUC<N
C
CNC
cz
V(Vc
0'CCC
Q
c
VV'Cd'a
C U
C
'SCUV
4CI
CI CUC0V-CCC-4-C
0Uc CU
CCCC-VCCV0C
d)
CE4
(aVVCC(a0UCrCC-
C(aCCU4
(C
(C
NC
UC-N
C
"SCCENC
VC'N
C
CVNC
CCNC
-CVICNC
-CC'N
C
4'aVCNC
VCICC
IVNC
C'N
C
C
)
CCNC CVNC
NC
"SVCUCCCF 4N
C
C
)
V'aVCVENC
"SVbVCC
V-C'-NC
CC
)
"SVNC
C
-CCN
C
-CN
C
'VNC
UCCNC
-NC
VI
C-CCC
,CCU
'NC
NC
CC
Co
EE
—S (a(VCCO UU
.(a(a
•C—C(C-doV
C-0C
'aV'CUNC
UC-C
CNC
VCCCCNC
"SEVVCNC
N
C
VEV'NC U
'C'aNC
U'C
NC
CVNC
UNC
CNC
V'CUNC
V'C
'aNC
NC
V'a'aCVCNC
'CC'aCCU'aNC
U'aCC
O
s;
r'C
Oo t
sz
CV
NC
'C
-
-
-
E-C
4C(a0CCC
C
d)Q
V
•C0.UU
oUCC
-4040CVU0L00=U CC
-
C
0<U0-C
IS
V-Co
C
-0
4CV
0C
C
0
C(a
V
VV
(
U
(a
V(Cd)
V
C0EVC
-
C4-C
0UC
-
VCVEU(CU4
CCC
.
VC
d
)
0U'00(CE VC(((0
IC(aCCV
C
C0 .
C—CCU
-0CC
d)C
0
(0VCV. 0C Vq(aV
VC0CCVCC
-dUv
C
C<UCU
CEC 0<•C(
C
oC0-0' EC -.•0Cv0—UC-0,OC•UV0
Cu
U
C
VVU0C EsC' U•Cdc
Mto
C
•-odU
C
-d0Q-CV0 C'C •C-'VUd
(VCVC 0VCCI(a4-C
-VVC,—(
CUCCOC0CUoCOCCVaE
.
VU
0U CC
-
C
4
C-CQO-d-CCVCN(aV
Cs
V
(a
C
V.(VC
C0U <U0V-dC0E(a
VCU(aCV—U"
(•0—U-C
-
C -4C
(aCC
$-M
C-
-V
V
C'0V
'C
C.(CVV
V
'4
0
VV0
VC4L4CU ,0C0
-EVCV—C
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 45/147
0U00_c IV0U0
0EU UQ(
D(D
oNUVU--k
0
lD
-C
k
-VVUV0-
0
(D
0U(Do
V0VU
C'd
lV
(D
(D
U
(D.V
VI'VVU01V
I
V
VSVc—V(D.0V—U-0v-cEV V-0oVoC
VU0
r
E-•-°• b-C
•C00
:
VII'-VVD 0UI
U
Q
1*
(D Vc oEID
V
(D
C
VV
o
E
oN
V
E°(D-VDCIi 9
cV
. •' -0
00VV-V-(D
.VVC
Vcu41DVU
VVI0Vco,V
(D
V
40U'0oCV00U(F)U(DV_- -NVV—0V4•40Ucs (D(DDVS<0VU•UVDUCV
VUV
VEUD,(D
V(D9,00V
D
U
tD0VCVZV0U0V-d
V
(c4-',U0U0 -
.U-4VCVVEVP—
'
cn
E
C0D VIVVV0V40LIDC(DVV+
VC
CLD
V
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 46/147
<
V
V çe
VC—c0V
tDc
CUCVIV4C44I
VVV0EVU)LVU
N
0400<
0< E— .EVVocU-° rVVc"c
V
C
cU
V
wo:
bO
-CU0<0
—
0
44EU
o
040CV
1
V4-CLou 7M 5— 0C)<< 0 Ci.V01 EM 1(VV4VC 0E<<-V-V
4oç0CiUQcCM
VU.V'.VV 000<u0VUE
V
EEVC0—C= EVo<D
CU–C
-(uc<VU<<EçJ,•uE,-44EEV—0EVEC
V
CUUE
d)
C
c
0EV' UCVVVI-C
< E— oECU
8<
@0<40C
C"-.1
V7MjC<Cic,VE4C0C
0<'-c —VCd)0-EV .0<VdEnCi--VVCV>•C0<CV4.<.0MuuVEC0-ECdCd)IIC<'VEU-<0<oVEUCVEQ)-< E-CEcEUE<4UCdCUVC CV C-cCUM-4-CI
-Cd)C-
M 14ECTCCEE-2oV< oIVC
C41V QE—
CiEC- Z,8V0<Ec<0<C8E VUCEC
<EV
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 47/147
'QVN0U
V
VI- 0
V
V4-j 0U
0
-D0V
CV
00•.V04V0'VWD V:V0V0V0VVU'VC-b0
0
CdV0UUVICc0(
C-C
V • U
0
00c0o)-
0 .-0-UUVUCDU
c
CCC
LD
C—
V
0"00J0 0Cç
'AAV0
-C
'-c0IT:
un'0C '
1-4 10
V-
t)
Ln
C0V
:
C
-
U
V
VC
0VVV
cC
0CCdCC0VV
V
0-C
•
J--cCB 4U0VI-
0V
0
cE
2U' •0 U
E 0C
'
C
cU-
•-
-
V
k.
oE
MM,
E UVbD
E V
CC)
o2OC00—MU-0U(z-
bV'0U0B UU
V
C
V m
'
8cC
U.Ln
0
•0
"0--
U
V
cn
-0ccO0_ C1C
V0 cI-M E
6
-C
C,
VUbD VCE •_d
00Vc
-4C-
-COCdV4C
0I
'VV
E •=C-'V
C
CC
V
4CU0V
-tC0-V
V
0C
I
V
I- VC
c-C
0C
bD C
V
0C
V
0VUM
-d
-
U
0
-0q
C
IC
04CC
U
U•00
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 48/147
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 49/147
H.
0C
C
U-C)
C
Ic
<
CC
•0a
CC
CC
C
-C
4-C
0a0C-d':•da)
4
a)C-i 00C
C
-
c
NCC
a)I0'C
C
a
C
C
4'CCl
CC
c
E
c
a)
C
C
4
Cl
CC
c
00CC
0¶00BaL
c
C
0cCC
a)a-oOC
C
C
a
a)
C-C
4-C
0C0Ca0C)C,
C
ia
a)a)-0C0a
)c
a)
-0CC
-)
CC
0 4
0
0C
C0a0al
CC
00C)-caU C
l,1Q)
-00 0aa)
0ca00a0a
CC
aICC 4Cc
CC
CCC C4CC
CCC
C-CCCC-C
C
C)
"C
CC
CUCC
V4CCUC
)
CVECC
UCC
4
EVC-
C'C
C
UCC
CCC
UC
C
EE
<CCU
C
)
CCUVC
C
C)
C)
C)
V-d'CCC
C
4CC
C
C
C-C
a
0-4Ca
aa0<N-C C
CC
CC
ca
'CC
40CC
ca
a)
0-a
CC
ab'00C-C
0
ca
a'000Ca'0CV
C'C
C
UCC
CCCC
C
C
C
-
0
0Cl00aa
)
-d0CC
C
-C
CC
a
c
-0a4-C
0C)
a)
4-C
0a)00a
)00aa
)
'CC
40CC
-000C
C
a)
Cl
C
C
0a0I
a0
c
-00CcC
-
a
a
0Cd-)
m
l
00C
N
dOC
4
0CC •
CC
0
CC
:
a)C
E
•0"0
CC
aC-i Cl
0
C0CC
'00ca
'CCC
a
0
CC
' 'CC 00COC
C
C<—
L 0
-d-•CC
•
0C
009aC
0Ca)Oa)a'C
C 04
C 0•
C
C)
a)
0
'cCLiii ca0CC
-C
a
•Cl
C-C
-E
-<0
a
0O—Cc
a
C
C
0)
a
'
a)
OCl
CC
00
0
CC
0CC
C
/
a)
-C-Ca)
a)
C0C
0-E•
aCC
'CC CC
0a
4
-.S0C
U
00
I 0
ICC aa
-0C
C
4-C
C
-ia
CC
caO
dOaa
•! C
da
aa,CC CC
-oT4L CC -lC
C 0-C
C)
aa
C
C
C
0<C0
C 00
4-OC
C
-CC CC cC aCCa0C
-CC a
a)
U
0c --C CCC
4-
a
-
CC O0C
<c
CC
0
CC
Na)
40aa0C
0-<dCC
C
0r 0
0CCa
<
0
-
a)
C-
0aC-i 04COdI0CC
00C,0
-C
' a0
0'cCU
CC
a)
C
-
CC
-d)
a
)
4-00a)a)Cl
04C(U
6
4a000c 'Ca
000-0C
C
'CC
UCC
0CC
:-0CCC C0OC0aC
C 4-'0cC000
N
E -CC 0
C
C
00C
C
0aka.)'CC
0a
a)
T
<0NC
<
0a)C-0
0-/
a)a
C
-C
0CC
0C
)
C0C"CN
C
)
C
CC<
C
C
,
<
C
>
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 50/147
V
CV
CC
I-VV '0C
V
CUCV'VCVCCU
CVI
0
--•<<00•<UVVU--
lu
4
V
'0L
It N
U
U144 1i -U(00
cBU
0"UE-
-00
--
00UCO-U•-0VoU E-obD0 'Cca
!
(a
B
C
•
V-
V
ZEUU
I0VE
r r UU00r N0V•o0-NBC#)o0V0C0oo
o
4-U—o2O
---EU00Ei -._ UU-UVTC
IV
b.O
V
U—
00000" 00CUU0U10U40olD I
0
0
c"C--
-
U0
U0c U
4-
0-
k
00
-
-0000
U U0C)—
,0
_N-CUo0UUOo0-U0uu4 ---—.<U-CD 00U0BbD-0U-'-0EE-I0014-0- bU_<0<-U0VEC- •1
D pm
0— 00000>UU0U'<=UVVCIC
C
UVCCCUVVCC
)
CV2C
C
4CC-
CCV2C
C
CC
)
C-
C-VV'CUC
C
ICCUC
C
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 51/147
1IJV' V<V
0-VU1V-V
.
V
)
V
0
V
"(VS
V
0-i •-IC•2BCB0<VVVBVVb aoE—C)V—VVV)
L
VEH02--•VUV V'Uc50' BVCUV<0uU721VSCV0C)-V
E
kVVV<UU:V<NLB°oCVUC0SUVC
B2-V VUcC
lV0C9
22V•U
CV
-
CUU-l
CVVIC
C
)
C
-C
C
.
C
.
C20C
-)
C
.
C
.CC2C
-)
N22NC
-)
VN2N25NUC
-C
'CC
.CVUV0U
V,V
VVVVU5 B
V
<V00o
VVC,
o4200•VO55•V
5
<0C)
-
V0VVVC
l
V
Cl•NVrF
V0-C)V
VVVVVClU-VVU
VV0
o2UVVV•9VVdVl•d-V5
BVBV.C)VVVV- -VV•VVb71--oC.0VC0VVV 02
V
-• -BVV<ClVVVVVBV.0ç
s
,2
cV<-g0
5VV0-8•dBV0
OVC0V9CB
B<V•E:0V<B
V
CCCNV:o• V5VBVV
52VV•V.B0<B0VVVV<VVVCUVC
-)
V
L
VUCOdVV.--VOVVV--bH<i•VEV2U
5<B••BV—VVVBV'V<VVV2oU00C)VVNsscVC
.
C
)-2-BVVVa02LVVVVN N <C VOVlBVCCgCVV0Cb0VVVs Nl03VClID 0VVVCClVU-CICC-BO UC<UVB0UCV 0VvV•V VCC<OVVV5VClVV00<0CV (<
IJ.0C C -CC .0VN
C)C V
C
-C2C
C
1C -xU
c
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 52/147
2UUV
EUU
.UC.UUVV
8
'—
CC
UUU.U C C
C
UEUVC)
10
UIUUC.
UCUC.
C)
C)
UUVZ
C)
C
C
1
-0
VC
-
C
C
C
C
U2C
C
o0
U-C
0
ii C
C
CC
C
I
o
C
-Ct
•<
N
C
-I
-
C
C
C
C
10
ICUC
C
C
U
C-•'UCC
C
C
UC
C
IC
CUC
C
C
CLD C
Do
CC D
'
uU
C
C
2V2C
C
VUC
)
2UU'CC
U'CC
UC
C
C-
UU1.0
VC
C
VC
C
UC
C
CU0V'U2<C)
U
2UU
2CC
CC
LECUUE2-
-)
2U2
U-UU
)c
- L
:U-
C
C
U
:
U
C
C
CC CUUUUC
C
C
U-
-8-
C)V
0/
C
2U- -UCC
C
2
UUCC CC C
)CU
U)
UCC)
C
)U
0.U0C
,_- C
C2U3
2UC
-C
VUUVUC)
2C
C
0IUC)
C-
C
)
UVVC
-
UC
C
0/
U2C
C
UUC)
UUU2V2UU
C
C
2C
C
C
-
C
C
C)
UC)
C)
C
C
UC)
UI0
C
C
UC
C
0V2U0C
C
UC
-
2C)
2UUC
-
UU2C)
UUC)
2U2
c
0<
0._-
V
-C00<-0U
8
0 U0
.<-UNLoU.2UC'CUU0V-VUUCC) Cl
l
UUU
0<m0-
EUOUU00 C-UoU
U
UC
U0VVUUU0CCC- 0UçUcUCV0CCC0d0U-u00*—1VVCUC0VUC-C.d0UVU*V
UUC)U-<V
-C9C1U
UV
C
C)
UU-0d6UC0<0CC-(2
<U.
0<I:
0*0U
U
'.U
0
C
)
a0—
.UUU0-oQ 0c
EU UV0ç-
<
'°VCU<Cl-000ClV-V U0 10
•—
U
,70
.U'V1E0
0
0)JC
r
0<
U>L UV
E<UC
-°a-VV0ClC
V
-)UVU0Ur .) C
d)
CC
C
)
VC
C
-8CU
UdU
0
U
Cl
0D0U0-0dOUU
d
2-•U0•UC.06UV<C Uto C0UUU-
V1
b
C
lV.— UUCd)U0U:V20•0U.U-U C)-dUVVU0CC 40CUUUUdV0- -CVUUU-.2<<VC)UUU.daUVa
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 53/147
0 CCoo
CCU0U
UC
-C
C00b
D
C
C
UC
C
C
C
CCC
C
UU0C
-
VCC
C
U(C
-0
0
-0c
J0C
CCC
C
C4C
'c
CC
CcC
O
<C
UoCU
<
C
CCUC
C
CC UC
C
C
o
C
-I
U
Cc
C
U• U-CC
C
U
C
VC
V<CCE
UC
<
0<V-4C•
C
C
NCC
C
'0CC
CCVV
C V
E
V
C9UCC
(C
CC
9-C(CC NU'C
C 'cCOEC(C0UVVC
i:-:
41
C
—
040UVC -0-?U VV°E0Q)•VNo C
oC
ID
0
c
•_d0— 00• CVC)=
-<r'0C
0
U-
E
V4&ON
1
oVV
0
0
VVV-0Cvk0VUZ
C
CC
C
i CV
Q)
UUC CC -0C
C
(CC -V:CCC-
-cU0
1o0C0U < 0U<C C- U(C oU -C
CC
v-VVbE CC
U(C00
0-CC-
C )C)E
d
V
-41
VUCç
CV0008'CC 0NV.E0<VE(
C
C
V0
c2
E'--8
C
-0080V
C
C
0
C
oo'?
U
<UVCCCC0c
C
CC ,-i
C
oVC o,<
0'CE-' VC0
-i C00V04CLCCC
0<V
C
V
V0< CU
V
<CU
U V-00U_CCC_CC0<C VCC -° '- EUCVU-CC U UVCCCC UC0<VV Uo 8UUVU-&CCVVCC C U'C 4CC
CC
-VCCU.CUC
(CVCV0' .',CC C-zCU
C
U
CCCC C8U
C0U
---a
CC
CCC
U
6g
OCVCC
CC0OVVCC 0
C-C
C
C
CUN'0C
C
C00U(C
(C
'U
LCL-
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 54/147
-CI
-
.4)' (
4
a v4
C
4V)
tUJV
-C—
4C
c
u
I
44 C-
vu2
bO 14(4Caa(
4
'Vc
E4
VV.E 0
c
u
.0
1 V—V
cz
1
Q#
Vccl
c
0V040o-L
E -1 'LV'V0zL-" L.
E
0
0VV0' -L
:.L
D41
0V(D
V
-I-4 4)
,Li
'CC44co
0
V
C-V4
1 0 0
C0
CL4 t-4
0v0o(
'-
4
L
E Ij
C-C (4 0
En-1
4
0•—-
VC'0V0-dto
L00
-,VL
'4-•
L4Vd
4)01-4
rd
-
(c
0
VL0
-Li 000-C(I00'4'4' 1V0144,
c
Zn
— V,
-(4 C0u
m
L6-T
V3-
I
---0,
:0'V0004cLVL0
c0
1
olDE
o0014CD bD4
.9$
(D
0-L u0oVCV V0V
V
o
L
4$
4$
4$
I4
.
4
4
a
4$
44$
01(44-
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 55/147
U C
a
aC
Ca
C4U 0aCCa
CCa
C
-
CC
-
CCd)
a
CC)CC
C
o
a
,aE
C
C
a
Ca
'C
sC
5
Ca
Ca
-CCaCECa
CCa
EC-CC
a
-C-CC
a
-CCaN
-CC)CC
aU C<
a)
UCCUCa
-C
C
C
C
C
VCa
CaCCaa
C'CaU
CCa
U
C
C
C)'CC)
I-iLCCa
a
-
ECo
a
CCCCC—CaC
0o
a
Ca
Ca
C-C 0
00-E0aE
CI0C
a
c0
aC'C
aCaCC
CCCa
C
-CE
2
CCE
-CCS
'C
a
C
C
Ca
CCaCCa
CCCCC0C
a
Ca
CCCa
C0Ca
CCd)
C)CCEaC'Ca
NC
a
C-
Ca
-CCa
C'CC
'4CC
Cd
Ca
C
a
'4
CbL
a
CCCa
EC-CCa
CC0C-CCa
UCCCa
C)CC)U CNCa
za)
CC
a
CCC
a
U'UC'C
aC
--
-
-
C
a
aC
a
a-a4
C
U
L
o'
L
0-C
o0"a
1a
UaC
a)CCC)UCCCUCCC
aCCCCCCCaCC0
0aC
a
-0U
C
a
E
04UUUC
a4aa
0UC
a
Ca
aCa
a)
0EU
E'U
Ca
Ca
Ca
a)
'C00Ca
U
-C
'0UC
a
4a
a
--
C
)
oE0CCECaN--C)
E
CCCCCa aCC
C©-a
a
C-C0
--
aECU acr aaCU
CECaEU aCCECC
UaaU'0UC
a
UI
C
a
-C
a
U-c00
a
U'Z UCCC
a
UoUC0'Ca
Ln
a
CCa
aa
C
CL
CC
-C
C4oo--
Ca
E
C
o
'
Ca
.
Ca
C
<
•C
C-
aCaCa
CaaCC
Ca
CCa
CUa0CaC'C
a
CaCC
Ca
ECU
aU
cC•Ca-Ca
-
Ca
-CCCa
EC
C
Ca)Ca
C
C
U a
ct
a
CgCC
a
CCaCa
C
CC
CC
0
00
a
C
Ca
•0,C
a
. E
CECECC-CCa
Ca
C
•Ca
C
a
—
C
CaCCCCCC)C
b
CCC
CCCU 0UCa
'a
.0C—CC
aC
.
4
•0a-C-a
Ca
C
a
ECCCCCa
Ca
Ca
Ca
U
C—
a-<CC
C0•C.U CaU -CCCU C
CC-C-)
U CCaECa
-C
:--'C
C
)Ca ECCC
C
aa
-CECC-CC
CCC-CC
C
C
:
Ca
0CC
<C
a )
CaECcC
U
C
C
CC
aCL
n
C
C0
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 56/147
: C
LU —
II
c—
V C
00
C)
0-
V
U
NCC)•UV
cC-V0
C)0
V0
C00ECCl
C
-C
I
C
I n•V0C
d)
C
d)
'<U
C
U
o
C
C-Cl(JI.C)VCl
V
CU
u
tC
•4
-C-m -C)L
' 0(l)V"T00V4C
0
0
0
0V
0
UdVc
C
Cl
-C
C
-C
l
(C
)-CC
C
d)
0VC)<-
C
C
C)
c
C
V
- c;CVE-C-C
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 57/147
E
UI0CNNI
NCNI 'C'U
CNNC
-C)C
--NC
-NNNC'NNN'C
EVNNVC
)
NN-C
C
)
NC
)
NNE
'CN
C
'NNN'
C
-NEC
)
NN0ENC
)
N
'0U-'CC
,
U'CN'C0UUNU'4N'C0
C
0U0'NNN4-4
4-4
-NC
I
0N0-N
C
—
zI.UNC
-
'0<-C
C"
0-'C
UU-0N000I
N
N
C
))
b
oNN
N
UC
N
N
—
C
N
N
N
N
N
N
NN
N
C
NCN-)
N
C
)
'NN
N
NC
C
NC
)
N'N0NCENVNC
.
0'NNUNNNC'NNN'C
NN'C
NNC
VC,
VNC
C
-
-C
'
'CCNVNN
NN'CN0
0
'U-0
'C
N
N-
U'C
(
O
'C0'C UNO'C-C
D
C-4NN'C
UUN
NUN
N
N
NNN'C
UC
D
NN
N'CC
'U
0'CUUU'C00-0NU'CN0N0'NNN'CN-0C
.
N'C0bD
U'CNUN-0N0-NN
-0-00U'C0U00
C
C
)
-C
)
0r'
4
0UNNIUI0UU—
•0
0<
U
N
IC0UU
N-Uz
'C 0N
'C 0U
'C0
U
'O
NO0N
0NNU
'
0'NN
N-
00
'CC•EN
C
-
-'NU
IUUUU
I0
0
N
07
C
N(UU'NNN
I•
N
UIU
U
-C 0
O
N
N
-NUU
E 00E
C1
A
•_
oU
L'
N
U,
N'Cb
D
'D
N0UNU'CN0N'N'CN0UN0N
I -<
UU00UNC-
NU
UUNNU'C'UNNN'CN-0N'C0b
D
NUNE 0U0U2UUU'C0-
N'NU
UOIE UUU'CN00UUUU
U
UN
U
—N
N
0
'N.—U
NUN
U
U—C,U00
<.'0-NN
,
0
0UU.<U
0
-0CO'C
C
I'4OU'C4
C
U-0•N0'Uo0NUU•
C
D
•
0
'NN
0OUu7UU
'CC
CNUNUU0C
'U1'
40
HC'I 0ON'C
U
NUUUN
0
NU
.40
D0N
N0U-•ENU'CUUNUe<0
UN0Ulz
00
UNNU
UUUC
4-
NUN4-
'C0U4-
N4
-C
UC
,
U-''CU-
,
NC
d
D
C
C
.)
U01-4
NUUbJO
UE U
(DNU'C
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 58/147
Ia4
sVCCs
-S
aCaa-
aa-aa
caa
'C
a
aCa
5a)
-aaaa)
IaI
S
aa)
aaC
a
aa-
aa)
aaa)
a
d-
dCd
'a)
Cd
-d
C
a
s
- d
a)
.
aa
-d
Cda5d
-5'C4-d
4s
CC)
a
'a)
C'Cd
C'Cd
C),C
d
NCds
-S
LCdCC
l
V-
Ca
CC)
Cl
C-
Cd
C)
4'a)
C
d
-a-
Cd-
Cd
C
a
a'aaaaa
)Ca
a)
Ca
aa'aaaa
)
a'aaa'C
C
a
aa-
a-
C
CaCC
a
-a
a)-c
a5Cd
aCd
5CCQ4-s
aCd
s
-S
Cd 5
-S
'' 'a)
Ca rC
d
a-Ca Cd
a5aCd
s
-S
Cd
Cl
Cl
aCaaCaCa-
C
d
-5CCCl
a-
Cd
CdCCEa-
Cd
--C
aa)a'C
a
b.0
05
-a
)
C
L
aC
a
C
'ac
' ,
C
a
aa)
aaa)
aa)
-aaa
-LCa
a)
-Ca
-aaaa
)a-Sa
)
-C
a
IN)
a-
aIa)
'I C
a
--aa
'aa-
C
a
-aaaaa-Sa
-Ca
aCa
aCa
-Ca
a)
E
a-
Ca
-Ca
a)
C
a
-aaa
Caaaaaaa-atoQ'
Ca
C
a
4
-s
Qaa)-C
S
Ca
aM
.
Ia5-Saaa)
aa)
-aa-SC
a
a5-
a-S-
a-
Ca
-aC
a
aC-'
a-
CCa
Ca
aaaaa'C
a
s
-S
a)CCdCC
'
CCC'Cd6C
Lw
CCd-
4QC
CdaC5
d
a)-
Ca
C-
s
-S
-
4
a
sS
dC
C
CCcu
C
s
-S
CC-S
1c
C
C
•Cd a
C
>dC'
Cd
5CdaCC
d
-C)VQ
IaCI xM a
-Cd
L CdC
)ts
'CCd
-Ca4CC
-C'
Cd
C)
Cds
-S
aCCCdaCCd4sCdCEaCdC4'a)
Cd
-
a)sS C
C
d -d ' -Cd C
d •
C
<a)
a)Cd
aa-S
C
Cdd)
CC
C
sS
a)—
Cd
C dC
C QC1a
.- .CdC
C
Q4CCdCdCd
')roCd
,N 'Cd
Cdss
a C,
s
-S
Cd
C
5
-C
C
bD CdCds-S
'S
C
4s
CCd 'a)
N
N
Ca
C
a
a
C
-
a
aLD >C
dCs
s
C
l
Cd4sQ-
Cd
-d45
aCCd
-C
l
aS-s
Cds
-S
Q4a-
aC
d
)
Cd4aC
d
-
I CdCCd
d
5-Ca5
-CCl- d
.'S )
a
C
'C 'Cd
s
-5
4
_CCd
C)
.55C
d
-0C
CdaC
)
CEsC
CC
C
'Cd Cd
CCto
aC
C),
a
--S
aas
-S
l
a)NaCl) C
lCd CC
a
(
C)
Cd- -'a) - a
o
CdCd
C
5
Ca•-SdC
)
-Cd s d
C
Cd
IEa)s-s C
l
C
d Cd LaC
d
CC
Css54
5
C)sd
Cd
CC
d
--Cd
Cd C-
V(0
5C
A5 'Cd U CdCdC
d)
EoCL Cd
U
Uu
C
lCd a)C
)
—C
CC) CCl1
CCa
Cd sd
Cd
Cl
CS)EdCC
lCd-Cd -Cd CaasS5Cd m
—-
Cd
- N
-JCd d--5d '.a) —
45
a
-
4SC• ZCCd
oC
•
TCdCd Cd'Cd
- sSC
IS
CaEa-z5ClCaaa
Cd
s
s
Cd
C
o
C
oC
Cd
aCCd
-dCd
NCd
o
Cd
aC
IS
cu
Cd
5
-
a
Cd C
d
C
lCaCl-
4
C
a0
5-
a
C
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 59/147
0
N00NtL V
Uo0IHNNN0LU
N
UVV0V
VVEEVEc
VVv=--VV0"VVUVVVVIV 0OTVULDV0VlD Vo'DV•=V0VV.VVVCn41VIVVUV•V0IDIDVOVVco000•
V
'VVVVV
r0
'Vz V
E4mVUfL
b
' -VV••0
-V00'Vc 0•—U 'VUVVVEV•.V0VVVIDU 0'D
V
00
VVID
tL
-500U'D' ID'DV
V.VVI
UVU
EVUVVI
L
LV'DV
U0•_ID
'DI U0VV0oVVV0VV00VUVV
V-0'D'DV' d '
DV0
•'V
0U--0UO0Vc
LWO
0
0—
OV OV
V
U0V
UVVV0VV•
D0
00oVV
0VoV
UIVVVVOVVcUVSVEVVV V I-W
VUC0'D•O
VOO
0VUV
V
VO
VVU VVEUVVVVVV1VVU 04
b
•VVVID0o-' 0
' V
—
U0
VVVV 0V
VVUVV
U 8mCO'VO<0V'0•I'IDVVVUVVID0VçVVV
II0-0N
00U00UU0
00H
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 60/147
C
d
_oo-&CUC
U-5-dCd 0
0
-VC
Vç
L
' V- Vc
' VVVct
EC-.-E
r1V-C o0C
CO
-V
CcC0
1
VV
•c
l
c
,
—
V
<
C
'VV
—C0-VEu6VU00c C
c
•C• CLo00V
V
V
-CCV
CV
b
j
l
14 C')UT
EECc -V"ECCC
i
C46J t4-10N oEVVVUE E VEIVV EVz
_
- 0
Va0VUVVEV00V-Ln od0CCCE
C—-E-C)VC)V00.— VVC0cE
V
-—CC
CCU.0UCUU CCONV
E
l
u
UCEE V
VV
EBI-
J
CrD
C=BB Ea E V0CLu)VV VVC0C
VE VUCVCUE (CUVc V,-V
LB V)-
OE V V UU
EUVC2UoE VVU
CcU Ucr V E
C-C
V
C
)
oVVVV01•
C .VEECcEC CUCU7
It
E
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 61/147
-.
C
V
V
E-
N
-(D—
V
Mbb
L 1
1
(NLC'N
CCLL-D
C
VNNCC
—
'-C
1
N
NN
E
-V0>V
EC0' 0VN0CVCVVVO --NOVV0EL NVd7k0CVVV
0VE
VJ
C
Vc
VVb0
-<•l
V
V
l<
0(D>=—0
' 0 V0VIiD 0V
V
(
D
Vo
D
(D
•—0(D VO
V-
VEI<c0(D-—VV0VV'VE-VbO L.0 V- 0oVVV_V•—_V-'+2(D (
D
I(DV(D((D
1>CQE_V0V0oVVEVVV0
V"d0
..o0V.V
0(D VoV-VtL
'.v."1N0,-0
0VVV0VVVV•0tdE(
D
0
5m VD
'0VV(D
VD€'-0Vc
-O
•<V
b
cV0
Vc
VdV2d-g<0D
.1
V
V.
V
VVVLW
CdVE0
-V0
1
VN-V(DV(D(D
VV41-VE 0-°ç
00-V0D •dD l V000V
0E1
-4
VD <<.. --
I<-d(D N"d00EV50<-EEczVVCV
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 62/147
6CCOVC
V
C0
C 'C •D CoCO
V
•0<
d)
'VCV
CC-a
C•
—•CC•-•0- <
C
C
C
<CO
•CC•—VV
C•kCVVC
L
<
C-t-C
I
C
O
C
.
<C
O
V'CUCO
VI—
'
CC-
C)
CO
CC
C
C
VUCICCIC
O
CCO
UC)
-CCCC'CO
CV
C
C
'
C)
CC
CCO CICCIC
)CO
I0CC
C
O
<'
7
rC
O
-
i IC
U
CO
Q
r 'C,•C•C i -C
CO
CO --C
-
-C-C
CO VIVCCEVCCVCC
CCECCICCVC
C
UC
O
VC-
CO UC'C4
CCC
O
C)
-CCO
-CC
O
VI
CL<C
O
0CCO
LC
NC-V
14
CcC
-C
CO 'CC
CO
cC
1-•—-0CO
C
0C
.
00
VU
1C
V
q
a-(I4c
C.1V
•'I—
U
V•
(D—0
0
cd0<CDC
V(D(D
V
0çv<
V-oB0(D'-C— 00•rD ç•c1-C
Q
7
Iu
o
CCIrV4C
— 8V
CVC
VC
L
CC
-.
CC'
0
V VEo
I
0<0c•'Vo— C(400LCV
V
"CE CDrD' •I •
0
C
•CQU-C0•C0C CUC) CVoo"U0<C0CC
l
41—00
C
C
VVuU'C
O
C-C
CCCID C
CID
coDVC
00VCO O'J<V -00UC Clc
Cc0U
ç0VVCC-
V
'C0
C
O
C
d)•
C0
c
V
D
CO C
-C
0UV
C°CC
V
)CVC00
0<CV
—•Ua<-C(<1-C0U
CC)VU
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 63/147
0
C
'0VI
Ln NI
'VN-0N1
'00
00UNN0UN0<C-C0C0C
NVC0N'U'0-
CN
'VN0NV-
CUV-
0
0
814
-rcOU00
D
C)UV-0UUVcUVI
V
V 0
'E00•=V
UU
0—'-
CC
V
U
u
VV0000V
C(C0
1
VC(U.,0)
.<6< (CC0UCI 0<
c
aTç Ic—UcU
'V U00<CU0NCUV0U
0C
•-TV,U0
00E
5
U
0
-0VC-V0—c'0o•— E UVC C)VU
ç<0c'VcC
C-UU
C
-
c
C
U':0
U
E
••
0k V-
NC
CCVV0_oUCU
V—U
4- U
C
)
d
"U" <C<0U•
E0ULn
• 0c'U-V0'U
V
U'002V0010VUVU0V0VN"<U'U
<VV'<U_00UC
:Lw
0o0 U< m^0—0 UUVUC- 0' CU0C0CUU02V- C- VEC14 142 U0V 40UV0ct C-0V.E0UE 0V0V'VUV0a UU=V00 "0C)CUUC-U—00Cc
IUD0VU
Cc
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 64/147
V
0
Cm E
0V
V
I_
0V0U0 i_U0VV
U
0w0U 0)6V0
V
-
-
cCV
V0°VV'0' VU—00V000V
V
a
VV
0C<VoUV
V00U 0kM
V
VOV
c CL
(U
IVC
0u-
0
)
C
U•a
VO.E
rD
0
cVV#V
•4U0"VUVVVI
C V
V,VU
C
V
C
—
'V
U0V0Umu000CC
,0EC:Lw VU0 00'VV0V00VV"0V&VUU
cV0 Ln
(U 1
C
0
0Io0
bQ
V
V
U
,"t-"d,OVV0—In
00ç-(_
0oEbL
0VV-00--0- -<0m M
C'VUV
—
-'V
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 65/147
0U
U0U
1' UU0(
D0U(
D000NIU-0
-0U
(D
_—c
-
00;'UIU-DO
1
U
(D
D
UDO
-
d
c
4'-DO
DO
DO
r<U
D1(DO
U
U4
(
U
_
DO
U
(
D
(D04
-
UUDO
U
07D
0DO
UbUIU(D
(D
UU44-'-U
U
DO
U
U
-O
D
U
U
D
C
0
DO
U
0<
U'U4(DU
DO
UDO
DO
0I4DO
04DO
DO
U•0'I00D
h—.U00
UDO
0(DO
ç
U<
rq
':0L
c
•0b•-0
lDI
•-U': 0UU4(
DDO
(D
DO
I'0(U(
D
UDO
(D
(D
(D
DO
0U(D
0DO
(D
(D
DO
44C
0U4DO
U4U440UUUU4U(D
Uk4
2
IU0UcU
lD
lDID
1-I
C
DO
U4
U
(D
(ID-U
0U
0(D
U-O
04
'O
U
UI'U1
DO
UUU0
DO0U
UDO
0UD
l
0
O U-dC0UL
(D
U
D
O
aDDO
U
•
(D
0U
DO
(DU0
-
DO
0D lid
')
-00V
D'V
U
UU
I04U4-
DO
DO
U(0DO
-UUU4(D
U(U
(
D
-U
U
U
0
04
(8. 0
0
DO
' .UU'-
0 -.0
0
0-' 0U0OocD cD
0
(8(D0(
D
UCUc
0U0(DDO
0U0DO
(D
(D UDO 'U0(
D
0
UU
(D U-
0DO DO IDO -4
0.UU—DO U -0O UU(DU0000DU•DODO
0o--ZDO DO DO DO
U
U
O
DO
U
U
UB
-<-II(DD
O
U
4
UCCD
(Dç
DU
<
S
O
U
DO
tL
DO
4.DO
U
-
C u'CDO-c
CU00
0
D
U(ID-0U
U0
0<(D
—
DO
U
(DO
--
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 66/147
V
o
0
4
0
-100V
0Vc0-(N-0c10?0V1
1
2
V
V
I-QO
(NV11
C I
0o0
0011
0 -'CoV(Nç.U
0V1
(D
V
-C
E' N
(DV
04IVVO
0CU
Cd00CdVb
.(N1•_Cd
Cd 0dV
D
NVdVo-dNbDCCCUC
'T
N=N(NDIN0C
d Q
V
-dN
Nc
-a
NN
CU00
UNN1N
N
-d—1 NC0Nl
DuN
0V—,
bDD
uN02•b0 "NNN<0-dc-' - --NNCd
V NN' •0c0NN
•N1
a
oVbDN0
o00obD0
-bD<NNC
s0
0NN0CU0'
'
"
N
Cd
(D
V
I
0- 0VV
1
V
00V0
'D
Cd(NVN
BV.CTC1
V
(N V 1
1VV00I-- 0CE0Cd
-V'CdCdN
bS0
NUUd I-•-0U4VV >d'V •d1
'V
-dV1
da-•.ECNC0 UCd(D EE• N0(NEd2& EV=0Do1
4-1
CN-d•N.ECVU011-'3VVV 1CdUE-•2-1010V
Cd
NNVd
00-9d1 (N0 CUECdU
.9V
o
U.(N1
iVd
-d
E• 9-CdCd-da1
•bDc0
VV
1'- C
NNN—NC0NN
-'
.N-NONNC
NNE0,oN0
NN1N0
_oNNN
C
oN
"
•N
- -0-
.b0NIN0N
NN NNNN
1-U'
NNCN
!
0
CNO NN-
c
-_H
-_
NoN0N-o-N
N0
NNN3'-N UN
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 67/147
CC)
C
a
C)
C
a
C-CCC-CC)
C
a
C-C)-CC
a
-CCC
Ca
CC
a
E
CCCCCa
C C
C
a
)
'C
C
BC
'C
o
C
a
C
a
C-
'C
--C
C)
)CCDCa
C))
cC
CCC)
C
)C
C)
B
.8CC-BB
CB
C
)C))ECC
C
)CC
C
CCC)C <C
a
Ca
-C C
a
CCC
a
CCC
a
CC
)
CCa
C
)
cCC'C'C<
C)CB
C)
C
a
'C CC
aB
CC-C
C C)
B
CC C
N
.
E0
u—
0 Uc
'CC0C
4
0
0
0Vl)
VUV,-a0<uC L
n
(
U
b
j
^
0c0V•0
'0—'cV0
CCd
'IUb 'C<00
C
V
Z
<aU
cC
0
dV
-V0•CC
u
'
:<Ca C•CCd'0-0k0 •0aCC 0
0
UV0
•-E 0)0UVECC-C V
-000<_0I
B
'Ca
'a
U 0Ca CC)-
C)
0b
b
C
)C)C
0<U'
0n
I
cV
a
C
a
C.
CL
DC-
C-
C'CaC
-
'CCC-CC
D
0
-CC
CC
C
C)
-C
)<<
C
a
'CdC)E
U0
•-8
.c'CCC
a
0<)V•-C'<
C
C)ECUE—0C
0CCV
C
a
2
CUdV•C)ad
C))
8a
U )
V0dmCbDUC-
0C)dC4C
)
C
U
CCC
CcVC
_V"C•bn Ca a
It
'Vr-t dV<ad-<VE
kct 0()CV00VCCo.C
<CO O Cd VU
C
Cd'-<VC
VaCC—8CiVEC
0)CV
C
C
IS
,
u
E
.C aVVCCd<a—Vi<,_<CCC-
4C
CC)
a
0V0<UCd<'CECC
C
-C
0
.0V0<0<Cd
j E Ca
cC
'C
I
d
C<<CCdçnC—c)CJVOZ8a
EV
CC
CC.C<
C'C 'C
-B
C"C
a
C
NC
CC
C.
CC•D ' -:
CCC
B
C-
-CCC
Ca
CO C
C0)
CCC)
.8
0.C)
Ca 8
c
z
Bc
•<
N
CB
-C' a'T
Ca
2
-
-
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 68/147
:•
CC
0
a)U"
-1C.
4
a'1C0
0Uo
c -C0Q.0
-UaC
a-
Ca)4CE
ECUU
aC4-CU
0
'0
2-C'C
CL
'1
a
0C
aCa
CC
C
a
(C
'
'1aCa
ECC1Ca
'1a)CCU
ClCa
'10C
Ca
luECa
EU
-C<
U
Ca
C
U
U
C
-)
C)
CCLCC
a
a-
0CC
a-C
C
-C
C
a
C
-)
a
Cc
-a
C
a
C
a
CVC-C
-'Ca
C'Ca
VVCa
CV-
C'Ca
C-
CCU
V-CCC
a
-CaC
)
Co
(C
,
CC
a
-CVCC
a
'C
C-
CC
a
c
cc
0O--O-
a
14_'04L
0
ac0-C
a
4 U Ca
C
a
c-
C
0Ca Ca
CC4'1a
a).Ca
c
Ca
U
E
'a
CUC4U
a
.Ca
a
lD '1-°
Ca
a
0
C
Ca
C;aCCa Ca a0
C
CU
Ca
C
a
C' U
- o
.
C
Vc•CC
--)-
-
0•_
C
C
a
C
4
C
U
Cla)44
ECC
a
CU
dCa
UCa
•CC
Ca
C
Uc
C
4
oa-
'Ca
U'
a)44
-CCa
4C
-
a)
ECUU
CCCa
CCUC
a
VVC
a
-C-
CC
a
0CC
a
CCCCC
a
C
a
UC0-C
VC
a
C
-)
CC
a
UCoCCa-
C.
CUbD
'CC4C0Ca)CCUCCa
UCa)4Cla)CCCUa)4CCa
44CCUa)
Ca
a-
a-Ca 4C-a-<UCc,a
Ca Ca
'1
0
Ca
U
Zn
•CC.
'2ca
c1
•C
U
o
4
C
-UEnC
a
UaC
O
.)
CCa •?C' C C
4C CIcc
0C
•C
CCa -4
c'aCC'
•c4Ca
U-_' C Ca c
CE
,
C•C'N
4
a
a
-
E-a
oCCCCa
C
-•-C
CC
.CaCcCC
C
NVC
•a
1C
a CCaH-Ca CCCCC
vU0CCa (U4-C
E
C)10E
ca
CCa
C 0E0U 2oE2-a 9bDCCCa -'C
D
CC-2CCa Cc
D
.PC
a)
ooC'2
a
C
a CCCC
V
C
a C
CC4C
a
CU•ET' 'CaC
_ICa -CCUCCa C-UQo
CC-CUCC(DC
-Caa4C Ca
CCa 44
C
l<C-UCa)'Ca Ca-C°CC0<C
C
-C
o-CCa
Ca
b
D
C
-)
Ua,CCU
c#,D
a)
4C -0-
0
C
-bD>
'0-
Ca
a)
COC
-
COCUCV
C
4C
<
r4N
t4U .I a)aCC
a)00
C
C
a)
ac
D
Ca . .0CCcUC
a Ca
41a)
CUC
a
4a) CC-C
O
-
'F
cCa C0Ca
-C-4Ca 0-CaCC
C
C
Ca
U
Ca
E
C0C
C
OC'CU
a
0
-C
a0Ca C-•4CCUUa a) CCaD UCC
a b
a
2-C
c
CUE0
CUOlD
CC•
U
_CC-C
-C
0CcD
Caa'C-CNC
IC
-C
'C
'
C
C
-.
'C
'C
c
nc
c
' CN
c
C
-
- C
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 69/147
00do0E-o=b0VVUV"VV0NUcr1VV0<0<OV U d(C•V—
UU0
OVVV2
V
O20V00<EU V<dUV0'O0V<VVU0o0c—-Vi—UU0VtLN
L
IU
C
M
-
0 g.05
0V00Vdo+V
o0'0VI'- UM0V-
-
c
c
VC
cE
VVU0V<
VU'VV-_0
V
E0VV--
VVVE
0
H
CC'
- <V0V.<00•°QTV0UC
)C)'00C/0
0
6M;coUV00C ClV
VC'
0
02°umV.-C'.,E' Vcc _V. V
E
_ -UVo
Z0V
VUE
C
V
V L U
_
.-
-dCcV
C
a
U VV
oV4c
:C4
C
C'
14U•dC)'V :
VVC/- 'd00--E
V
UCVCU
V
'
-' EV.---dV
c
-VCV<VUU<
C
4.V
LW
o<V4
"C'Vo2
U .cn
UC '
UC)
CUUUUC
-
UC
c<
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 70/147
VC00L0LVCVCVV
<V
VC-CCCVCE
c
ECVCCC
VVo
C
<
'C
C
C
,
o
.
<
'C
C
CV
ç
V0
N0UC<-C
CV0VCbO0U
VVCE
-CVVVCVVVC
-0VI
VCC
CC
C
,
CCVVVCVCCVC-
VCVV-CV<
C)
VVC<
-C
(CIL
L<VLVVV0VVCVCV<
)VVVVCC
-
CC
C
,
VVVCCCVVCV
VCVCLV"CIVVCCC0C0E
VCC
-VEC
LVC)
V
0 VCCVC
CC
-CCCV0VC
'VCVVCLVCC
C
,
VC-
(C
CVVCVV
IV0VC
-<
CEVVCV0CCCVVCCVCE"C
VVVC-
VC
Cd)
C0C0CVUVC
IVVV(
C
)
V0(C
)
V0C
V((C
)
04<C)
00E0U
CICVCCCV-CCC0C
-C
40CCV0CVbCC
VC
VCC
VCVC
C
,VVCCC0CV0
C
C-CdVc
C-VVVVC
-VCVCCCEC0VCCLVV
-<C<
-V
VCC<
C
0CVC
-CVC
-CCV-C
)
c
CCCCV
-
-
-
-
-
-
VVSm -
-V-VVV
V
-1VIM-
VC
C
,V
VV_-VC
V
-
-
-0
c
V
bQ
VV—VV
V•
V
0-0V
-
—
-VC0
0)0<
V
"C
C
d
)
C
d
)
VC)
o7
U
-0C
d)
V
U
V0V
<-C
CVc
o
<
<C
)Vo1-C
V'0V-V
V
I-CO-
C-
VC
V
V
I
C
oOCVV0EVV
'(C
)
V00U'IV0V
C<VV
UCCI
V-V0VCd)
0Vc <C)
VCV0UI
C
IC
oVN
CVVCkC
C
C)'
V'C,CC
'VVV C)C•V
CVV
VC
'C
,CV
CC
V
- VCf-cVI
C
N
•ç
CI
VC
U-UV
•V<
-O0VU-•
0C-TV0
'Vc '0V8
(C
)
UL
V
Cl
V00
V
•IC VC,
V
C-
VUc-0VV-Ec
<)-C
VC'V
V•C,
0-8VV
V<C"VC
VQCC-C C
d)
Cl
o
E
EV0V
(C
)00V
V
06
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 71/147
'
C
)
CC
)
iC
C
CNC
CUUC0E
-
U L
b
j
^
C
E !-V
-VVLCC
CVC c
C
-°V
-
a
C•E
V-aNC.V0VCV0V
U
C
C
0Vo
U
V•
-dC9
CC
CLn
V0-L
V0VV0Vc
V
Co•- --01i
C 1
C
0000
Cd00C I InV c_
v
(
VE
0
INcoVoV)0E oCo
c0
oU;;UC07t^
dE
VV C4
V
oL
MEn
dCQ— UaCCC UV0C40°CoCC'-CoV9oVUV-UdC-C VE bV
C-C L H0VSbCUC
Co
b
j
O
.
_CVC:E._0CC-C.d0
C
C •CCC'
0Co UV
U
V
C
L
.
V
0 V
Cl0d<VU° C
C
a d uVrCo 0C0CV-Cd.U' r. CL
C
V
dN.VV0
V
V
'-"0'OCCCo CC'0a
C
L aVVU
4,.0dVC
0Q<-0
O V
E
V-C9V
.CCV
ro
C
C
VO->
VCo E04.C' .aVVvCC
V
EV.0V'dV
•-V
0
c
dCd4
d
U
C
I
O
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 72/147
V•
_.V(
D
(D
(D
V
0
V
4
•?••
(D
—V
—-(
D0vNN
EU14 0 0UV0U00V20dUCCUC CV
CUVV(CIS
V
C••U
UVC
C
C.*
CC
(Uc
z
CEV'CC1-C
C
CU
VC
V
I
J
I
C
C
VU
VV0V0LVVVc
C
V
oVU
0V
V0
' E0
c E•—
VVV
0-
'-bL
---VV0cUVVV
'—
U
00C
VV
I
VcV
-
00V:(D
•0E0
IEQC0(D
•EV okEV
V00(
--0UVrd
U
(D
—
I'
(
•0c
UVcD (
U
•—VV
-
(- •o--c' mC E0VO- EUVCVV
VCU
UcV
V1Ic
D
VVV_0VVV
V
0•Vc4
V0U0C
VVO
(sN0tcV
(D
-
I
Z
J
U4—
V
'VEV00
CVV
•Imtz
0
U)
V
VN VV
VVVV(D
V
-jZ
c_CCU(DU
—
VU
VUcu M C•d'C' CEb
V
C0
•(DVcCL u OC1Vu7 *
'c•CEV
-4
b,Q •0U0VV0N' VCV-0—
0•CC—.0-—CçVV(DV
C
CCCC•C
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 73/147
0aa-
a.
a-
Ea-
a)
-4
'0c(' a
)ca
)c)
(a-
c)
a<-00
cca)
0
' cc0
C L
<
c)
.-)
c
c
0
ca
E
..c-dCa.
0occda
-c0a
)
-0
' 0I_c
oC
a.
aa)-
U
C
a.
Q.I4
-
o=0a)
oa)
0a)
c0-dc0a)
0
E
a)
C
a.
-d-da)E
a)
zQ)
ccca.
C
a.
1-
acc4
ca)
c-
a
.
C
a.
Ic
4
c
cc
Ia
-
0•©(oc
C
a.Ia)cia.Q.a)c
C
C
a.
bD
Oa.C
a.dc
ia.02
c
a))
.4
-
ccC
a.
a)I-cd0aCa)a-
c—
Q.
a)
cc)C
a.
0C
a.
ad4-
4-
c0a)ca)
a)
a)d0a
)
-dC
a.
a)Ia)r0a0aC
a.
4-
a)C
a.
-dC
a.
E da
)
C
a.
E
Ic
C
a.
a)
I
ddC
a.
(D04-C
a.
d0cCa.
a)0cc0C
a.
Ic
aC
a.
Ic0a)C
t
da)-d
C
c)IC
a.C
a.
0a)-
- ))
L
0C
a.
0
0
-2acadd-d
.
0ccCD
0a-'a00adC
a.c)
c)—0
-ca
a0
dad-c-
< -
0-a) daC0d
C
a.
0dcia.
a)4-
b C
a.
00cCa.
a)4
ca)C
a.
cca)Zc04-
b
a)
C
-
aCa.
Ic
4da
a)
cia.
-da)—
a.
04-
a))
C
a
.
aC
a
.
-aC
a
.
C
)
a<
C
)
C
a-)0a)0'a
0a
0aC
a
.IC
a
.0a
)
a.
C
a
.
a
)
a.
0c0-)a
.-)C
a-)C
)
o-0a
aa)
;
c)
c
U
>
Z
U
.
a)a.c1
a0
-I
—
•0CI
-0c0
.
1c
a)a-c1-
a))
-d-
.—a)C a0cE a)oaa)a0-•a.c
ia.0ce 0Icd.odca<M0
)
c
C
U
ca)
ddIcia.cia.
Cc-a)aC
a.
0C
a.
-d•da)
U
)
a
.— -.'Ca..Za)0uo
C
a.
4-1
QIC
L
dddd
0
c
0'a—
E
-d-
c
-
.-014-4aL
0IcZd
C
a.
a)
a)
a)
—cdc
)-=o
C
a.a)
Ur Ca.
Ic
Ca.Icc-I_cca
0J0-du
c)0ac)L
6
U
'
bJa.
2
1- a)a))a
)
-
1- C
a.
C
a.
-
da.
2dd
C
E
d
----2E '<0
U
0a)
'a
a)
cC
a.
-dC
a.
0a)
-dC
a.
Ic
00C
a.
a)a)a)IcC
a.
0C
a.
00a)
C
a.
4-
C
a.
Ic
Z3
C
a.
c-
aC
a.
-dC
a.
Icd4
-Ic
4-
a)
Ia0C
a
.
0
a
a
Jo4
c
-a)
C
)
a)
L)
-
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 74/147
C
-
:
0
L
V
C_
0C')
, U.UCl
c
V
'UC)V0V(uCl VClc
0LC°VEcVClClkCo'0C•C-Uo CV
C
I •CCoU VV
CClVNC)
•
vCN-N0
N
OVU0Co
0UO
n
C
C
oNO0
n
N0OOOC
N-N)CCCC00 010?u
C
'•C0
C
I
m
4
•lE-•--•CUU V'oClC
6
Eb
IbVt-CVVCc
çVCV
-•f41ClcCaC
Cl
C
)VVV'-VVC
C)C
CCLV0UE•_-IClC.
o • VVU1
8CE
4
- V-oVU
VVCECEdV-
-VVUEUU
EUUCVUCEoClC-VUVVVClC
lUUU4oVC)
C)V'vCU-
CCC
VCVL
Cl0°aUC-
CV—
'VVVVE
V"
C
cC-' C4C
C
VC
VC
0C)
C
.o CC',0Clo
VCU•
ooVCV
/vU C"°.-oVbC•0•< ---•VClECEVV
'-
VO
C4CUoUUVC
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 75/147
CCC-CEdCCCCCC-
2
CC)CC
)CCCCC
)
-dCC-dCCCC)
CC<C)
CCCCC)
CCC-dC"CCCCC
CI0
CCUCC)
C
<CCCC)
CCC
)
C
C)
CCC
C)
CCC)
C)
C)
CCCC-C
CCCCC
)
C)4
C)
CC)
CC
CCC)
C)
CCCE
C)-dC
"CC
)
4C
C
)
CC)C-C
)CCC"CC0CC
)CCCC
1V
VC VVCVV
-
V
2V-V
4
E
C
V CV0'
E0V
CQC4V
C-<
C
cmC <C .2V0
C.- "V-ICC0(COC VCCLI
C
C<CV-CV
00Q
0
s
-
"VC"V0V
'-C
C CcC d)uCIIC
0
c
0VCCC'
V)
VrC'
LO
-'
--'
-'
CCC
CCCE
44
CdCQdCC'
C
C)
V
CCd)CC
C' 0CC
i
-C0b
j
^
C'
C
--
C
0=CC C CEV IC4CC 0 IC-oV
C
C
iCd-C
IV
-E
C'
4-
VVV
VC)>cV
VV4
V—-
')VV
0
CCC41
C
C
Q
V
C)C)
Lun
E
C1
V'
=9
C
V
C
Q
-oCC Q-
I Q
•
!iCu
0
C-CC—•CC0
C
CC1V
C
C
CbVV
C)C
C
C
-<oCC
C
'Cç-•C
C)V
'I
CL
'I '-CC4C)C
C
04.1C--
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 76/147
.
cU
oc
c
'UC•'C••—
C.
0C.
Cd
C-
C40l)C.
Cd
0Cd
0
C0
C
Cd
0CU0
'VU0U— ' 0CC,1-oodVCMVCdUC0'0I00oU-"
•Cd,VIVUCC)VCd)U0
0
o
E7
U
"o
C
UE
'0U
1-00UC0UUC'
C
-
_-
00
Cd
-4Cd
Cd
Cd
CCD
C
Cd
C.U) CCCC0.d'C
d CCU1
-
c
4
"0V0U
I
O
EVC)
UCdCd
VCd
CVVU
'V
,,'Cd
'
C
tL
Cd0d NVVICdUrUV0#00U C
d0Vd— U8o5—
C
0
Cd
V
U
UU
VUCdU0CC
OdCddd4-
Cd
U' -'Cd
CC
C U
V
Cd
V00CdiQ
U
0
4U
CClVU
VUC
CI
Cddd
C
d4
-
00VUUCdV
C
0
4Cc
CVLn
C
4-d
,-j 4
-
-
Cdd
CbJ4-
C
C,
4-dd
C
C
0
U0Cd, -
'U CCC
:-V<-
U-*:UU<
-V1VC20V
Cd4U0
Cd O0E C•.— 'L
C,Cd)VUU
UUCI0c7
U
UCdC- VU Cd
UU
-+-
CdV
Cd
U0
d
— Cd
L4ddd-
-U
Cd— VC 4
UV
C V
Cd
C--
4-
1CCCC)
C
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 77/147
C-V
C--VC
a -VC
-C
-
VC
aCCC
aaCcaCC
a
CCa
Ca
C
a
CCa
VVC
a -VC
C
a
CUCa
aV'VCCU'C
a
CVaCCa
aVVCaC
a
-VUCVVCCC
a
C'Ca
C
Va
Ca
C
CVC
C
C
a
V CV
a-VC
-Ca
CU
C
C-
- C-CUC
a
C
a
VCVUECC
C-
CCC ECaCC
a
EC
a
Ua-C
CCa
aUCUaCVCC-
EVC-
aaaC
a
Ua-C
CC
a
C
-
CC
a
VCa
VC
a
Ca
1
UC-C
CC-
C-
CC
V
c
4401Vc44-vVU04VC--_c-' 4cVC
C4-C-CoV40UCVLaV-C -VC(cCV— V-cC
-
cC
-u
-0vovvoE
4-
V
4 ° L
C
cC
-CC-"C-C0-dU44 dV0c
V04U U
00
o_VV(0C"UCD0
.' E4
CV C)D Ud 04Ev0NEWD-4
4
U-V4
IM-C—4-4dCVQ-00-I< U, V) UZV0V0C- 0C0V
-
•UCL
VUVU
QM
-dC
4-V
C)
0VUV>0c
-90-4+VVVV'V
d0
>EO
-dcm4-
4V
VOOV
' v
5L
S
V
U'UV
4CC
:a
0-
0
4
UVUVV
0
Eo4
VIE
6,
4
E0'V5VV
, V-0VVV0VV 6-1 o00
0V7C4.
C)
V)V0V
CUd-dUVV-CCc
C
-
c
C
—U-4C
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 78/147
o
' aa
-o'CaU
)Cd
ca)LCa—
a0
--C
-Ca
Ca
aaCa
aCa
CICa
a)Ca
CUaa)a-
Ca
-Ia).2a20-
a)-0CC
dC04
Cd
a)aa)4-0'4C
da'4a'4
-04
C-a
aaa
)baN'4
a
.
2"CC
.
aC-aC
-dC'aaa)a04
aaa-
a)4a'4a)14
a'4a)a14
a)04a)
'4aa)
a)aa)
a)Ca'4C-)
a-)
C'a0
a)'4
a)
C0CC
a
2a2Ca
a)'C
a
'C
.
aaa)aa0aa4a-a)
2:0-a)
U
Ia)a)Ca -C
a
04a-Ca -Iaa)a)
4aaCa
aa)4a2Ia)
4aaa)Ca
C
a
-C
a
Ia-C
)
a)0C
a
'aa)
Ca
Ca
0aa)Ca
2Ca
aCa
Ca
-a)
'CaUa)
2a)Ca
aa)
a2a)
a)a)
U
a)
aU
a)
Ca
a)UCa
a)ICa
Ca
a)a)-
a)2a)I
a)-dC'aCa(Ua)1
-
a)a)a)
aa)-dCC
.
4'a'4C
daa4aaa)a0aCa)aC
daCC
dC'4a)40aC0
4Ca
aaCa 0C
aaC
)
-02Ca
U
a2Ca
V
-)0aC
a
'
L
a1
FE
Cd
a)C
l
a)0'4aCC-
Cd
a)
4C4a'4a
aCo-.a
0Cd
a
a)
Cl
a)Cd
oaa
c
a
a"'-<'4V
ao
a
-C
o
a)-do
a)
ov'aa)a
2C.:.oE O4C
a a
•0
2
u5
•aCa Z(
aC-)a:a)
4C
-
C
oa
aa
a)
a)
aa
VN
-)
a)
'4aa)
C
a:
-)
c
0
•a)
C
aa-
a
04aa
a)ao-aa
Caa-)
1••'4CIO 0a'aI
'.
aaaa
Cd
Cd
E
•aUI- 4C
da)a)'4
4CNImaa Ca
a0
)-<0C2
a
oC0
bD CE -1-a)-0Ia"._a-.4 Ca)- .vvo
aC
a4o-aIo)N
D
E a
o—
-
-aaa)a tz
.aC-6aS C
I
aaaaaCd
aaa)
Ca4
4
S
2C2
'C
5
a)
C
aN1-a"1-a
Cw 00
Ca a)a
)d
al
C
)C)
a
CaaL
a)
aa-
)a)
at4D
"aCd
C
C
.
-4-CaC
da)-)
—JDCa)
b c a"0aaCaa
0o
4
bC -a
ba)ED
C
)
0a
C
.oC
a0
-Ca)
C4
4CdCdCC
...-a0<
-daa
a oCCd
a
Ca
-a
aC
'4 -Ca)
a)
a)
4.
a))aa
)
C
aa)
-C
0
a))'a
aQ
.
'4aQ
.
a)
C
.
-da)4
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 79/147
CVCCT
L
UC
C
C
C'VCV
C
CCC'CUC
C
CUU'CCC
B-C
C
C
-C
CUCCVCCCC
V
'•V1
C
VCVCUCCICCVUCCCVCCCICVICCUCB
0CCc
I.— ,oo-—00-CVc0V00V02oC
V
U
0 00
0ooVE006V•——0
C
C
(UM0 UV0I0
0E0CV000U
B
00— E
•0(<CCUV• V—t 0U
C
c
VC
r
-EC
V•_
b
200C
d
D
V
v
C
V
V
BC
00C
utL
CVCCUCC
IcICIC-0UV•C
V00c•
•CC
-
—C
c00C0— •V-dVVLEU-C)
UC
VVCB
to
•— 0U(1C
0
0
u4C•C—
I :—•E
0V•_c0' ' CV0
C
0
—0— 0CVl
D
E
00U
-VUVV V'DVC V0 bC0U•CD0 VCCV
C
V
lD
'D V-0o—VVD
1
'VlD
U MC
C
C
V
0-dVVVC
-60U——D0•0-UIDU0Cd 0 I
C
0C
0UV
C
•
0dV
'D 0V
0CCI
V
03ImCo•'D
— -,0,CCCr
U
cs000z-Ic CC
V—
00CU
IVV0'D Z0-CCV00C•
'D
0
•CV$00elc
U
00
NCL
C
CCVCCC
C-CV(D
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 80/147
-0
0UC
-! 0Vc -V' 0
00VV0VVVVC-C-C
V
00C0V0
2V0<
0
0VV
C
-
0VC- C—V1
Q
j
0'V22V'0CV2C—V0C
-
0C-
CC-
VV0z
O?•O0 0
V
U
0c
uu
0
0V-—
dV
—
•
V
V
o
VUVD
00c
CCVo_VV0
U
VV0
0
c
V0-VCUCulV0 V000IVV
VVV0
CCCC
c00V0&<V0
-OC,
VVEV•UCJD <VIC VVVV0—00
00VC,-EUU Cd)V
VC-Vn VCECUVCV
:
'V
UU-U0c
U0E0C
-cC0/
V0V
-0V.VCV0U
U'C
V
EUVV
7
-_UVVV9E V.0U -L0
Uu
m
VVCIVb
V
CVV9
14
--0o
VU
2•
EVVU
V
V
'VV
C
d)
CC-
VUC
C
CV
"C0c
C
0-b0
o0C-UJE9
04
C
-C
VVVV0o
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 81/147
EV0
0' 0-00UI--VIbO U-00-UI-OU-0' 0UdIC U
' U.00VVU0U—
00U' 2
0VIU)U0V 0IU0
0
UVU
0UU0CVE
0
0100
VU.0T0— V0U0C-c00UU0-0UV00U)
0
IU 00UC -
m
V••-Vg
-0•Uo.V
I
V
0
-0
U0..EI
0VU0
Io0E ca0N.DV
0
0
V
.V
IV&a
L-
L
-B.c ' U CV0V0oVIU(D(_VVUU0VV
VJDQ
VVU•
V'V0
IL
0UU00
Cc
.
U'a0•001)
U)
UCCU)UC0
0 0
V
' VV
U'<VV
uE
z
.— ,)-C
C0O
E
.PU
E
•
M
-E
o' 064 u
rU0E VNEUVr0
C
IVQVV—U
UV
-VUV-U
V
V>bLV
U
— 0VBV--E0_'VVOUOCUOVV0VVVIU4 V
M
M0
IV-'V
b
U
U
0UO
U
04I
V
0
V>VV
VI
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 82/147
oLUU14- ' LvVL0V-0C 0_0'00VV0L
L
LI) E °•TOOVV0-0
E VV
V
pC1
cC
'V
'0
0'V 8
V0CL
0
0
V
V
0
0V0
0 •' M
MI
LV
V<
c
j
0VE
VU
CV
o
IV
(5
C-_V0V
I
IC'
VVV
V
I-L
I1
0L
5
' 0LEEEII
E
00
OVVVV•Vo0c0-CVV
0
L>
0
C
UV
C'0o-
-
VV
VV:
C J
0
0
V
c -64 6,
E
C0
V0 c(UI0C)C)000I 0V-•H
Li
1CdVdCdOC3CVd0ç0OC))0
d L
dE V0-e •-a -U4-1M 0
1<
V
d0oL••V0d
LVVd
V
L
cccd1V•L
cn
dVU0obj^ dII--d0V00L00
V
dO
•0dd
lm
M ZU
-S
d0< VVdd'VM CCddV>Ld0VV0L VdC4.1 CILC)C dLdV0uZ72 r
V'dLd L oE08E0dS-CVC bV0LVd08VC0LL:-VL0I
V00
0•VL IL0-d•
NN
UVNNCCCCUC
I
N
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 83/147
ClQ)
1
W
C
Vo
c
z
UU
•
0-ClVV
U
C
d
V
00V V
C
C-C -Cd VC V0
0Co
c
z
U
•vCC0
Cl' 0V
Cl-N
C-5C_VV0 0V'-0 U
U0-b
D 0
Cl
2-
C-
C0V'--cU-•ClClc 9C 0 CllClVU
CC
UC CL
-A
C
C
CCCCCD
c VC
C C I
V
II(C cC 0Vm
CliV
C UV CUCE
)QCCcV0
(C cC V41
C'cCC
U0
-- -o-•
cC CC
E
V
V
'0V< o
5 UUVcC
•
Ln
UUClcC Co(C CUVC
C14 t
U142t (A cn
CC
b
j
^
Cl
C
•
-
'cC
CVVU'V
Cd -CC
d'0
CC -C C
V
0OZCC VC0UC
(C
CcC
CC 0VVbUCCUUC0C
c
C
bD -"C C 'C CC
VClVV0(
<
0
oUC
C
4 X'Vu
4
VV544
'CU)CC4
sB
SlC0
UUC C
C
C0-UB
C CV
cC
4
V
'I
CV
CC U
0
C
)
V'00CCl
0
tQ -5
UU
40Ic01UCC U
'UCCC C
C
C,-'C
UcC
C
U
C
'C
-T
Co
C
U
U
C U
CCU
C U
'CC U-
C -
Cd-CCC
- U
-
UC
Cd
U
C C
- U
C
CU
'U
Cm
C
U
C
' 'CU
'C
CC Cd -Cb
fl
CC "
C cC
-CCU
- C
CC 9
• CUUl
z
C UC C C
C
C'
T -C
C
-'C •CC C-CC
C
S-' U CCCcC UC CUCUUUC'CC
-S5CU9CC
3C5d
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 84/147
-VC)
o
CC
'CC L0
C
C
C
C)CC
C,U'C
CC C
CU
0'
C
C
C
)CCCCC 'C
C
)UCC -CC 4
C(C
)1
C
C
00—CC C)C)UC
)
C
)
IC
)
C
C
U0CU
VCr1
(C:Uuu -zocCC —C)-Vo0V .
V
C CC
C
)
0
C
U
4CC
VV
(C
71
C
U
1 ct (CE
C
•vCV
E -°-
LE4--. oEC-
C)
-
0
00:0V4
C V
bDV
V
V-
E
n
(C,
-C-C'C
C
)
'C—
C
C
Q
0
1CC
C
)-
C•C
C
C
C
)C
C
)
C
C
)C U
UC 0
:
CC CC
C— C
)
-.o1,C
o
CC ',
oC•
C
CC CC
•1
C0
C
CC
CC0
V
U
=E ' •-
..CC
C
0C
—
C)
C)
o
oCCCC '
CC
CC
C
C
C
)
CC
4CC)
C
,C
)CC
)C
CC
CCC
oC
o
-V
0
C
•
V0-
c
,
;C
-
-V
U
V
o-4 Uu
6
..U-CV
V
0
c,
Z
0
V
-EaC
,
V
—
)U
C
, 1'
E1<VUV
o(oE •—0U—
-
çCC,C
'CVVCU zC,UUU C11tU C
bboVCE-b
U:U
-auCJ1C(CCUCCoVCVE :C
•U
0
cC)-VdV
C
C
VQEVC
E
c
E
°m
'C
V-
CgE —E
'V
'
-I
-0
VU
-
c
z
V•tCV
o
EE•-CE - 04
V
V
V
U
U
C
)
CE
0'CC
C(C
C'C'C0C
)
C
C
UCC
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 85/147
o0001
V
1
0
0
O
D
0N
EoUN1
0
1V
V
oVL
C
01<
o
L
V
o
<
L
-
N
1rL
0
V
-
N0
V< V2VN
N
VV.2
C
-o0N0
Vv2
CD
VV'L0'0VLNsL'0'VNV0
01-
0VL
ID
N2NV0(CVV<VVCC
C'-cCVdCVCCVI-
DVC
V
V
V I
r
D
•—EVCVV(D EEVV-dCV>CCZ cCV
i-V
UC
VaC(D
U
c-4
V
-V
cc
ICv
V
I
VV
i-VID CCVrV
i
VCCCUCo-r
U
C
V
1:UV
---
VLc-z
'VdVI-dC
•'<CV-<CC
(D
a -C
-VC-dC-CCi-UU--< VV<< di0VC
(D<-V
oS-cCCV
CE
bQ
V(D (D
(D V
V
l
Qp
0b
V
CV
V
b
E
10EdC-CEc9V(D
(D
CVDC
c9EdC
N
i-VCiIVV
4u
VUiCi-
i-dCC
1
C
C
CC
ZdU
C
.V° CVcm
b
-dViUCD
VC
I
VvC4dUDVc1i-VVL
VdEVI-1-UCçEc2-< C—Vc1(DVUd0EdUV(D(DV(
D
CL<V-Zm CCC
O0
LC rID
ID
) rDVOrID
L-C
'30'VUrID
1
L
0
<
D 0L
V
o>D? -V00LU
-;J au0
rDu
rID
V'<VNCo
.
o
u
—
-< Cc
C
VN
V0
0I
L
I
0001-•
rD22
rID
-L•L'800L_V5L
o
. .oVoCN500r
D
2-EE'-NL.0LrID -j 2V'NV
0VD
,rD V
L
01
0
2
aa
-
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 86/147
OdIa
6'o•
a0
•a<aUca
V
=
2
• •00UUV
1-V
a
)
CIS
C
V
CV
'<d
E
a
00<
E
<
a
2
6
ca
d
ad <
a
d
0U
a
)
VU0
-7LW-
a
d
V V
CCCD
VVVVIVa
)
aVNVaV
V
0aVVV
E
Va'NV
NNE
V1
<
4VI)VVca
VVVI0aVVV
VI(V
IV V
aaV
VVa
-VUdO
I:0ad
V
0V
a"d
_
U C-oEV
0'<
0<-' 0
d,<'J)
1V0
a
d
0a4
0
0E Uaa<'00 E VV•U•-.=V-L- qad cVaa'<''EdVV0<"<VV0caa UadUaI adadcl )OUIa -•— iaa0
d
Viaa
d
I
a
'< VaV
0
a0a1
E
a
a
E
V0
-
V
"d
M V
V<00=4I
cz
caU
0
<0V'<a
d
Cd 'ad
1
V
'
a
d
0a00a) VV178 r V0VadO0U—-a-
V
V'<0
a
IIaCVcV
0ad a
V
a
0
E 0Va0<U
cV0aV ad CaQQUdV•Va C
a
'<
a
!
uV)
NIad
2
E
ua
IIVUN-4
acv'<
c0c
V
'<ca<
VVV
N
a0<0
4d 'a
d
VaV
Ia'<00
-s._0I 0Vca-V<VLV4-N0VV'a0-aU
VN
•
NI
VaV
<VE-a
EaNa0ad VVNN-<I 4V0ad:2a-<V-2<
Va
d
CQ
0Uo
a
d
<
V
0ad0ca'<V
-V c
'1
-
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 87/147
V
V
VCECVC;CV_VVVV
C;C<
Ct
bC
VCCN
CV
' C
l
d
V
'
E — C/D;VCE_.CVC
N(JD C<
C-C;V
;.c-CVC
'Cv
U V
'
C
l
E
VmC
'C
C C.
'C•
' -CE
b
CCVCCV
CC-C
E
C' <— -
C
r)UC V-
V—
Uc-CC
C
1.
r
CCD
CC
.C
C
U
UdCU
C
C
UC
C
V
'VIVC
CC
VV-dIVV
CU
CCCV
<
VC
' CdN
IV
U
. CC C
-n
C E
C
U
VC'Vc
C
UU
U
-C
-C
<VUCC<C•VCCV
b
j
^
V—
'cC
CCCCUCECtDV Jcj C0CE C< Cc
d
C
V
C
CC C
V
UVV
CVVC
CCCU-UC
C
C
CCCCUj
E CC-UC
E
C;-CNCUVVVV
C
V
<VC
;CEE
CECV
C-
U-C
C C
C'
V
C'C
;
C
C
Cr
C
c
V
CVCV;
V
C
c ;E
V
-C
1-4
CN
E2
-CU
V
CV
V
UC.CbCC
V-D;;
V <EECb
j
O
CCC;.0u-CV
CIV
C CC C
'C
C
VV
C
—
C •E
V
C<
' EE
CCE
CC
E
M-VC
UVU'CbC
VEV
C-c<—
'C
"-
C
E 'CC"
U
,
U
Vd
C(CCcC
V
41
C
C
<.E
N.CV
C
—
E U
V
CVc
E CCCE C
D
V
E V
C
UCC<
rl 0
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 88/147
0-dVN4Vs-C
U0U'
'04Cl
VC05UVVC
-
4U
-dC,V'0U
-dC
-C
4C
-d0U54
5(C
)
V
-d-
CVC NUU—
V
'C
dOUU
C
.
0CC-
C)
C
C
C00Os
C)C-
C
C
cC
0
C
-0C
C
C
,c
cO0C
C
CC'C
000
4-
CCCC
C
0
CC
0CCC00'C'COs
CZ
C
d)
r C
C
C,004
5c
C
C
)
C
C
-C
C
V5-C
VC,V'0CU0UC
C
C
C
0V0C
C
U-c
CV(
5.
0UCC
lc
5(D'V
EVC
lc
-C
C
V4c
0CI
C
C
-C
C
'C 0
4
0U
04VC
C
C'CC
C
C
C
C)
C0
00C 0C)C)
0COs
00'2CCC 0C0CCC00OC
0'5 C
)
"5
4C
C
C)
C2C)
C
C
00C
C
00C
C
0CC)
C0000C)
2C)200C00'C
C
CC)
C)
C)
CC
C
O
s
CC)
C
CC)
•00C)
C-
C)2C
)C
C
0CD
0C
C
C)00C
C
C0CC
C
0C
C
CC)
O
s
CC)
C)
C)
C
C
0000C-
C
)
O
s
0CCC0Os
000C-
O
s
0CC200C5)
20C5C)
0'CC 0CC
C
CC'C0C
020CC
C
0C
C
C
C
C0'CCCO
sCC
C)
C
C
CC
C
CCO
s
C5)0CC
C
0CO
s
0CC)
CO
s
'CCC
C-0b0
C
C
C)0C0C
C
CC)
'0C
C
CC)
0'CC
z00C
C
20002CC0-C2CCC
C
0C0C
C
C
C
2CC
C
0C
C
C
C,C
C
C)
O
s
C
.
C20
2C)200'00
'CC
C,
CCC
CC,
C)0
CC)
O
s
C
C
2CCC
C
C
0CO
s0C
'CC
C
00C)0CC 0C
)
CCO
s
CC
—
C_C
'0-.0C
-
cU0.U
cC
)
0EV00C-C
0_C
00C,
0_C
00
c1 Cd
-
.-'-—cU0
?
ç
0
C
.:o----- -0c-'0O
0
c7
E
o
:
-dc
--0
C
-°C
0-5u O0•d
-_ C(5.
-d0CU(5C
-d00C--0C0-d0C,C
C
40'5Vc
04V5-
-d
-
(V-c
-dC(5.
00_C
0-i0'cCU
C
C
4C
C
C(C)
0UC
C
-'V00CI
C;C
0-i
c
U5C,
CC
-d
o
c
C
Cl-U
c
—UO-,c
c
' 0Oc0
CsC0
5
-d
0c)U04C
C
)
C
0
5-
-dU
Oo0
O
,x004UcCcC
0UUD
0'cCV0C
0C4--0-05C0.04—OdcCU0-•00• Cl
0cCV0
CC
C
c
dVdVV5-
5_
4CcCc
cC
O
0C•V0cC
0Uc
•C
sCd
c
-dcC
- 05
-
VCV0d
5CcC
0-0CC
s)
-dcCcC
C,
0U
0C'C
(C)
C
'C
0UC.00UC
C
c
0
—U0U
'V(
c
VOC
0
00-c
—UcC5-C '500C
s0
C
vC-
C
-C
C
C
CC C C
,
'-0uO•C)Uc
o0U)5
VC
odcC
C,
C5
0'0cb
N
-C
C00NC
CC
C
CC 0V4
04CCC l
CCC
C
C
2C0-40CC'CC C
C
d
CCdO0CVV
--
-
-
CQo02'C
C
-c
O
s2
00
CC-
N
C,
0
CC
0
002)
0•2-C
s
'
C02
00
0
0
— 00
_
25
C
)C-C,
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 89/147
I-2CC
0
V
V
u
0
EUVVV•V0V0-00-
-c
U0c0V 0
— (<VV
dD
dU
C
U
IDV
0 —C
VVV
C
) ZCLV 0Um
0c000Nc0I•2E00-V'-V•hV082u-2 o0-N+5-VVr,0oE0-
00
00E00VV0V 0V0VU—nVm40UL16mV UU&) 0-CV-0
c
VUV
c --VNU'c0V0VEC
IS c
vUQc0—
U
U o'0r
c.•VVUcVCdU.0Vvz2V8o2I8U0u
V
VVVVEE
.CC
C0
CQ-
V
V
V—
V
C
-VCV
VVCC
C
D
U
NC
UI
UUC
C
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 90/147
-
.
Cc0OV
0
V00
V
V
0-0r0VV0C U
UV inu
C
V0•0-C 0C0<,VJ
kV0V,o0,
0V
•—
0UVC20000<VOLV00Vd:•—-1 V
V<V
(UCu00V
0
zLC
"
V
—4C
4 IC
1V
C
V
c
0V'00VC;.•<V—•--z
;0C.bD
—C)
V
-C
0
-0U0
0
V
—
VU'0
< '0
IL
0L00
V
V—
-I
--g
N
V
C
C
'C
C
VV
d
C)=
m
VI IV'I04"00tcUC'0VV
'4•,••-g
U
VL
4
0
_
0UOU•
, CV0VCl'm
O
I-UVV
07V
U JD
—
V0EV4Cl
'C'
EV0V
c
0VC'
c
o@UQV00V-U-
<
O
V-
V
'0CL4 <=
<
LzV'
C
00C
0
IC--VCVOS J<0
V
V4 C61UE00-V"-Eo•00VU
<
I
C'0 0VUO
C,•
Fk0VE•L:0d
0
C.
-C,U'
C0U--
U'(UId)
—
V
000U
QE 0VVUVC)-UIC C).d
0C)
000U0'00C
C
000V—
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 91/147
C
oO-o
2V
0C
0
o
O2°2CCC0
C
-
C
oi0V=-Vo
C
OVV0U
Vtoto
0_•UVVV•0
0
0
Ctoto
U
0
VMVto
V
E
luz-
V
V
to
V•ocE
CLI
0DOC
(Dto
0c0Vk0VVVVV
to
0
VVV j o
VVV
C
A
VV
UEBV
(D
b
0
to
E
VUEV
ZU0
I0-V(U70o00VVVC-0VC
C
C
C
C
0
(
-o
to(D0VC
lD
0V
0UU>C(DtO0—VVV0VE;(•o
U
4-
VEV
VEoV-(D
E0
0V
to
VOC VU°EV
V5
(toV
EoVVoVV
(Dto
0VVVV0
V•V0(UN(N(DVD<0-
Q
-0U c
-
V(D0
(D•(
(D
C
U bto
VVV
to0V
UU
Do
L
°
(D
b
VU
0D
(1
V
to
5-•
o0
E o
N-VO
toV
.0(Dto(D0—
o
o
0
(O(V
V
P VU
D
to(0(D
V
UV•
Vto0UUV
(DV< to-O
(I.T0(D
Vc
•-tcTc
t
toET
•CU
to
to
(VV•
-C V
0
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 92/147
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 93/147
C0•
•jU0I'V
UV—4'VU40
U•0o
V
—
o000
••
-0
(D0U0—0U
—
—-
a
T •C
UUVI_0U0(DD'V'U;d
d
2
IE
d
I;C(D•(D
(DV
a
UD
o,0V•(DC-d(D(' VVVE
•
4V
(D CV0•:2
cDDd
2(D0U
cn
V
-
o2V'D'VbE'0V-0•--UU-(DS -"
•
C(DV
'D
Ca V
on
V
oVd ID
U
2
U
U
U' U
I
U
UUO
U
r0
2E10
0
I.2IDU
ID
Q
0
4—
•
0'0
(0U'UUC
0
-a00VvaVEVU0V•-i0'-0'
A CL
U
-v-
-aUVV0VV
UDa
V
VU1 I
—
V
'C
0V
'c
0
VV0
HU
0D
V
0'-
0UV0a U-U0C
0V0U
V(DV
0UVD1D
D
••Da
V
(D
V
VEVcDcUO•'DVVVc•(D(DE" •UoVV C-
(DCa
U
VV
'DcD
-8
C
ID
V
•—
(Dct
U
0a
d0E.-UNOC V-8cDU• I(D
•
Vk0'V(D
Ubu
U(D(D
(D
(DU
V
V
cUU•
-8-4
V
0
E V
2aD
^
cz
o4-0
C
-n
V
E(D(DVV
cD 0VV
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 94/147
VUV(U
VcCUCdC<C -',9E
V
C
CVV
U
•
I EQCV
V
rC_-
V<<
o
CC<V
CCd
VCV E o VCC)U4 UCVE cCU-EC8—LVC
d
O
E
•
V-.<U_
a
U
CcCdç
X
^
l
-E-CEoCVUUrC
' CU
UUC-E <'CCV
E
U
•
V
UoE . -E -:VUVvEQ CC-5 -VCCUI
Cd)
C
CCC
V
C
C
VdVb
00CE -
V
V<C
<
,-<V
CEE°i
U
q
j
V4
CC<
E CEC<V4V
c
L
CVCUCdVC
,
CE 4
r
CV
.
U4C
C
C EC
C<4-bCVE C CECE4VI
M
UUVC
V
0C<4Cd-CçC4C—VC
dCcE'CCVC8
4C
CVV
c-C8—0EEE U
.C0< o<E,V
-C
c
d
oU
VC'
EC EC0oc<-VV<C
4CVVC
Cd
,0CUCcCo
'
V
43 Im C
d
C°Q
j
>
CVV
<CoEc
n
Cd<C
•°Cd)CV
•-<-S 0<—•E
0-••,
VVVC
Mm'
U
-
5E87°°VV
CCCC
CCCCC(D
C-
C'
C
CC
Co
C
c oo
z
oCL
IN
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 95/147
CVCEV-CCNCC-C
VI-CC
CVVVC
C
INUC
C
CCUVUNVCV
CVUVCCC
VC VCVC"
C
00Cl
C
l
0IC)
044-
C)
-4
0Cl(4
•—0
1-
0C)
0U
0—'4C
)1-
C
C)0
C)001
-<
0C)
C
d)
C'
C)
C
-
00C)
0C)
oCC4
04
CCcVC0
uC
13
CC
C
N
C
C"CV•E
)1-C
'CUUC0-UV
C
C
'
-4C
'
1-
C)
-Cl
1-
(400
C
)
1'4C)
(41-
00'
4C)4C
)
0C
)r
1-
C)
000C)
C)
t4
M
0'4000C'
C'
C
d)
1-
C
.
1-
'4C)
C)
0
C
Q4-
C
4-
C
c'4
44-
0o0
-j 1-
C0
C
C)
4
C)
—
'4C)
C))
C)
o-0C
))
C
C)
0 QC)—0
1-
<00C)4- C
-
1-
ço•-0o•
C
'
0I
0--o(C)
'4 tD'4
C)
C
-bC)
IC
(Cd)-)Cl
(4
o1-
C)
C
'
-C)
0
'0Uc•Cl
C)
C
l
C
d)
1_ •
o-0'4-Cl;-C
lU<oC)
()01Q01- C
C
C)
Cl
C'
-C
0
(4cC)
oC))-0'4U(4UC
-
0
-(4- )o
<
0
C)
C
U0C44
'-0On 4 (4
0C
o-c)
-d)-0C
)
Q
0
C)C
0
C
d)
U-'40
C)vC<4-•o•c
0<-<-0
0C)
U
1-
C1)Cd)C
0C
d,
01-
-0'40C
ClU<(C
)
'<0UC)
-0
(4C -z•C—'4o4-C
0
o
l4-
C
C)
oUC
' 0'4
0-0C C''C
C
C'(4dcC
)C
d)
-c0
C)'
-dC
I
c
•' 0oEN0U-)E
C<
-0' 1•4
L4E
c
o 0U
L
•c
C'-I<-d-0C
'
0U
<
•E00 (b0U1-
U0ctn 400C'
C)
4-
00Cd)
C)0I
C)0
)CI
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 96/147
C
C
•C- CvCC'D'C
C
-T< .4
C
4a
144
CC)Ca
C-4a
-
•C-aCa a C
a
aC.C)
c
C
-4CC
)Ca
-a)
C
a
ICa
S
VCaS
C
a
C
)
a
C
a-
C
)
0VCa
CC)V04a'C
C
C
a
a-
CaS
'a0S
C
a
CC)
CCCC)
C
o
C
o
CC)
b'CC-CCCS
aCCCVS
C)
V
-CC
—
_
a))
•C
(D
tb
a(DV
(DaaO
4
4-
a)
V00Ca
J0ao E
a)0CC0
0to
a-cd0-cCa C
-0•a0ddDOd00a 0(Da d0-ad-a
0aaQa
4Ca0
a
'Ca4 aCCa004aoCCC444CaCa
a
Cb
a
0B0
Ca
-Ca D1o lDCaC
a 0a4lD 4 'C •40Caa-a0-
C
)
NN
a01a)C6v
6alD0
bb00Ca (DC
)CC0D--
Ca
,4
SD
Ca
Ca 0"40ao5aI4-aC0LCa lD
Ca
a0I0V4CaC
Ca ICa D
a
4
-0aaC
W
U
Ca
aS
aU
a
EC
a
a 'C
a
a0a0oC
4
Caa0Q
Ca
T S
lD
Ca
c
c4
-0Z0CaM44aCC4- r4a0a •-B
a)
aa)-
CC
+
Ca
-o00/D
a -CJ
E
Ca )
-' 0CEOa)D 01-a)a) -'' )
0D
Ca CdOrD 0a
'Ca
ad
CU40C
40C0
0l
aC•CC
I I' 4
'Ca
-4'
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 97/147
aaC-
-a4
C
'a-CC
aCaaaCaaa)bD
'CCCC'aCl
a'aCCaaU-aC-CCaC
CaaC)
ECa
aC)
aa-
C
a
C
-
-C-aCa
aaC
)
CCaa
C
)
a<C
a
C:
a)aCa
-C)
Ca
Ca a
C
-C-C.C)
-CaaC
C
)
-C
l
C'aCa
CCa)aCa CaC<
C
a
Ca)Ca
-C
ia)aI
C
CC)
C
-
I C'C
aa)C
)
-Da)a)C)
C)
a'C
aCa Caa)C
a Ca
a)Ca'C-
C)
a)C)
ECa
aCa
CaC)
aCa
C-
Ca-a
C
a
CC
-S
aC
l
Saa
Cl
Oa
CaCa
aCaC
E
CC•CaC
C
a
C
0._Cl-C
l4-C
>
c
c CC b0
a
C)--C
C
'
C
aaCl
:E'cc
-aaC_a)
C
lt<Daca'C
Cl4-C
C
-
C
C
aC
—C)
a.•zC•aC)CbD
a
C0aC
l
bD
C
Cb
C
C
)
- -j aa)abDCC4CCaaCCa
HC
aEa
a
Oaa)C
aC
Caa)Q.
-a)C-
C
C
)
2aEC
CCaa,
CUCa
aC-C'CCCcb
DaCl
C
C)—
C
C-
aaCC
a
aa7:m
aC
C-
aaCl
Cl
U-0-
ClaaCC
Cl
'-' CCaC E
Ca)aCa
)
a
.—
C
•aaa)
C
Ca'akabDCa)
a'Ck-i-Claa-CaCa
aa)aCClCaCCr
aCC
C
aUaaa
C
l
a
-C-U
aaC
C
l
c
Cla).'C
C
C
C)
CC
,aC
J
Ca
aC
)
aCC
a
C
14a)
C
l
-CICCa
um
aaCCCa aa-.-
a
CCCaaC
Cl
aa
,
Ck
C
C-
a
CClC
a•
C
C
a
CC
Cl
aC-CCa a)CCCl
'a
ClCa-
a
.Cla
C
faaa0C
CCC
a
CCC
l0CE -CacCl
CaC
C aC
CCC'aCCiCCa
CClaCl-—
Q
CaaClaala_aaaCCC
IS
a
C)0CCaC
l
bDCCC
Cl
a-
O
Ck—a a
a
CaI
C
&D0
Ca
aCClaC
C a'SCI aCa)C0
Caa:D aCl
C
l
aCaCCCCCl
aCaCCC
l
'aC
_
C
Caa--CCCl
aa-j aaaC
-
-
-
-
-
-
--
-
-
-
-
C
'C
a
C
lCC
-aCCC
Ca
C
C
-
Ca
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 98/147
-CCC
-C0I
C-C
VUcCV'0U
C-C
CNCC
-0C0C0C)
C0CC0C-C
04C
O
0C
-Cl-d
-C0C)
ç
V0U
U<VC
C
U0U-dUC-C
VUCl
04-C
Cl00
C0U0N000U
C
C-
UU•
iD
V
VUC
0000C
0'C UC
U--
'CC C Cldl
C
)•ClC
C
V
VC
-C
0dVC)
00C
:- C)CUCb-0•CC
C-C '0
O
C
0
'VH
C0C)
IC
-0C
C
C
C
-000-CCC-CC-0I
C
C
C
EC
C
C)
c
C
ClV-40
0ClCVU
NVU
C4-C C
-C
MU
C-
Cl4-C
—
-4-C
—0cC
C
)
U
V
C
U4-C
'V-dC-
Cl
VC-C
E0U4-C
4-C
UC-
UC-C
VC
C
-dCC
-C
C
V-dC-
CC
CC
kUVC
lCC
C
-C
Cl
'CC
C
C
C
•bJD
00VC-C
dl
0UC
C
UC
-C
<VC
-C
C
C
C
C
-dVCl
C
C
0UUC-C
0-dUC
-C
UC
C
'CC
C
U0-dV-dCC
U'00EV4-C
Cl
V0'CC
UC
UU0UCC
VUVC-
CC
0C
CC
'CCC
bD
C
C
4-C
-dUC-UC
C
'CUCl
-V'CUCl
UC
d)
CC
C
-C
Cl
4C
Cl00
C0VC
l000C
C
0Cl
CC VC
-
0VC
-
.00(1C
C
-dC
C
N-d0CC
C
CC
VCl
004.1
0U4C
0C
C
C
C
C
0Cl0C
C
U0
C
C
C00CC
C
-0C
C
00C
C
C'CC
C
-
0C
C
0
U-d0C-C Cl
CC 0
U-UCDN4-C
C-
000UC
l0EI
CC
0Cl0C
C
VV-dCC 0UC
lUC
C
-d0C
C
C
UC
-C
'CCl
0U
Cl
0-dC-0-dC
C
C
-C
0UU
•0—C)cC
-C
0C)C
-C
C
-C
C)0
O
V
U Vc bD
Cl•V
C
-ClCl
PO0C
C)0
.CC
l
0
-C-C C
-C
0C I r
'
d0OUC V
0ClUC)bD0
0-c00C
-C
U--dcV'0U--dC-C
lV
0Ud
C0
C0C
C
. C
C
CC
EV0
V
CC
C
VVO 0CC_C0
CC
-•
C
V4C
In
0C0-
CC
CC
00OC
UC
Cd
VV
V
0
dV4
U
•ClClC-C
040VV
——
C
C
000CC
0
C
'C
CC
C
0
CC
C
l
CC v9
0
0
C)C
CC V-d
•00•EEClO'0C
-C
C
C
-
0
0
0CC
0C
O
'V00CCC CC
d
NC)
-
m
C)
C
6
-
r
C
C
0
cCN
'C-
C
,•C
0C
d CC0
00 -
--
-
-
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 99/147
..0'Vr
V
E
V
C
l
-
--C
l
o•
CL
-
'Cc-.V-C'VVC
L
4.1
o
V
CC4.1
VLV-CC0VL-
jC
-
C
C
-
VVL4.1
'VV-LL
C0C
)
VCl
IVC
)C
V<.1
V
CL-.C_V
VC
-
V(nCl-
41
C2CC
I
V4.1
rVCld
'4
LCVLC
l
C
l
L
t
0
CL'CCVC
l
CV1.1
VV4.1
VCCLz C-CI
4.1
0C
-
C0
I4.1
C
l
4.1
C
l
C0CVCCV4.1
C
l
CVC
-C
l
C
l
CC
l
CL'CCV-
L0CC
-
-'VC
)
-jbD
01.4
0'CC-
0C
C
l
C-4.1
C
l
VLC
l
CLLVLCl
C
l
VLL'CLC
l
CC
l
VC
_I
L
C
l
ECL'VVC
IS
CCCC
l
Lr
<VLC
l
C
l
VC-
LL
C
-
C c
'C)
0'CC
C
)
0EC
C
4VC
C
E00CI
'000C
C
4VC
C
EC)-VE0C
0C)C
C
4V
CC)CV-C
C
C
- C
C
C4C
C
-C
CCCC
0'CC,
0-C
4CCC
C
C
C
C
VC CCCECC
C
ICC
C
C
'0(
C
C
C
-C
CC
CC'VL0'CC
CC4VC
C
IC1
.
CC0CI'0-C0EC
C
1
.
VC
C
0V0
NCL
V
61-
C
L
V
0•C
C
-
.VcVCC
Q
D--•
V
V
CC
V
L
L
V
oo•' CV
C
l
V
L
L
V
LL
V
C
-
VVCL
IV-uE
oo
00I
C
)C
_
'<C
C11 C
C
'C4
C
C
CCC-<
CLCVC-
C
-
V4.1
CC
l
CLVCC
l
0
0L<VLC
l
I
L
VC1.1
L
0C
l
C
C
-C
1.1
Z
VC-1
L
L
C
1VV
C)
C
<
VVVV
oL-
V
cu
C--C
-
VC
C
)
C1.1
1.1
LdC0_CCC
V9-c
C
VC-r
VL
C
)
-C
VoV-
0
L
CV
L
VVCc-•i VC
l
•C_I4.1 C
I
C01
L
C,V
b
V
Eo•
oC)C)
L
VC L cuc
C
l
-CV
IC
-
C<
CCCC-
IC-CC.-4.1 'VVCcz
C
-
C
_I
V
C
-IV
CC
C
lCl
Cc
C
--C
V
V
C
l
0<
V
V
LE-kVC V
0<
-CcLL
C
I
C
-
C-V_C
-
0
C-C0l
L C
C
L
V-Lb
'C
C
-L
V
V-CL
V
L
C
VC)
C
l
C
V
C-C-HVE4.1 V-ClVLiCcdC
)
-C-VVCC
lCl
C
C
l
V
C
VC-CLC
l
VC0LC
I
IC-C
C
l
C
l
-•V-CV
C
d
UVV1C
-
VoE
L-4 C)L-.9CC-CC'20CI_
'VC
l
VCl
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 100/147
i
(D
l
UCU11
lD
1 U
U
U.i Cao6
oC
U• 1(D01U(D
UC11U U>0IaO>0I D
0<a U-0
00U0oU0oUv0OO
000U
0Z
1C0U(D
CU1CUUCC(D
(D
CU1(D
(D
101(D—C(
D
U
1
•U
U0(DC
(D
D0 C
0.0CU0<0U
-C
oD0
•-C•
002
aDEo0
0-'5
a000.
.U
0:UU"50
0o
5
U
c
d
•05-
E
UUga r
.
C
—V
VC
UC
N
J
1
(DU0çU
ç
'A
(D
lDDDDD
0-p
o,
,c
C
(D2(D
c
l
U
oU
U
V.o
1
U/
UtD
U
—L -2
CCC
6
dUUU(Do
UUUU
V
(D
0ç
(D
U
•11
0<•T•UCcU>V
U1UU U1
C
UDUC(
D
C
C
cn
U1U1
0
UUC<-UU-
( C(1(D
VUE
4
tmkm
7
1D
CCU U(DU(D
U
UUUr
(D
C
UUUUU(D
V
C
U1
—1(D
(DDU
(DUDCd <gC0
U
CUU
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 101/147
C
C
E0I0000VZ0-C
CC
I
IrL
bC
C
WuC -0cV0VV°:-g
00•0— 'V0cV0
0
<EV
V,
U0-C
<Um
V
V
0.
EIU'V2VIC c<<O'VV
c
UC)n
'c0j UuL0
oE(
c
'V
0
V
<<C0
V
-C V0
VVCO D U
0V<V0-ccI< (D 0CVVVcVcm0VV0I
VC
U-C(D DV41VC
-C CV
0
0V04C
C
J
Q
0 mV U(D
C
UVo<(CD Eo0<' V0 V—V0V-C<0<UoCCUU< —
EVDO-1
V
VVV
V
-
—
0C<-U(DU00a. Cm 41a0V=EzVk'2—:D
VV
<
0
E
U'—V(CD
c
(CD
-0
VC
0E—c
VD
Z2JCç
(
D
<0
0
0DU
'
VC0
V
V
UD0<<Q<V00
-CCC
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 102/147
1o
V
'CCC
;
-V-V
CCC-C
C)4
'C)
0'
CC
0
CCCVC)
C
C
)
C
C
)
-
VVCCC
C
.
0CC
.
IC
.
V0C)
CCCC CCCC
C-
-C0CCC
C-V0'C
C
C
C)
CCC C
C
)
C
C
)
CCC
JC
V
CCC
CCC
C
C
)
CC
o
)
—C
C
d
C— VCC
CUVCVuUC
—
.CCC
o
—CLVVUV
C VC
biD
U
VEC
VV
U—
V
C )C) VC
V
VC00
CCICCC
)t
(CCIC
-VC--C-ClC< VUV<
CbD
C
c
VVU3
VICUV
VC
C
-ECUVVmCCCVC
UCI
1
C)CC
lCVV
VC0
'''CcnC-
V-I-CbDuVCrCCCCU
L
C
C
C
E V
1
4
VC
VCUCS—V UC
–-C CD
VUoCVVCm mVbCVC)CC
VCV C UCCVCCCcnCCCC
C
VC
C-C VCC
VVC
)uLCcC CCIVIVCcC
CC
._
UCVCV
CCVC
CC
VCVCVCL
C
L
Cg CU2UC-UVCVVCC-b—
V-_VCCO1
CU
V
C V1C—
C
VCVV-C
VUV
C
C
C
C>C
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 103/147
CCEC
oC_CC-)cC-,CC'V
C
-t VV
CC
V
o
'00CC-CC-C-
C
-
VCVCCCC
-
-UCVCCC
.
C
-
0
0C,
C0C-
I
-CCCC
CC
0
VCCCCC)
CCC C(
U
CC-UCC-UCC
CC'C
C
-
C
-
-CC0C
-
CCCCC)
VV C-
C
•C'26UU'CL'C-' 'Cc)—C-
0-x•C
TU
U
vCU
Uc
UC C
CCU
0-•
' 0U0C
'<
1
O
UU-C -C'
6
uuE
I-
0
--U-U-2
44,EU
-'U,M
c
C
C
UC0C-C 0COOCU
'C
-CC00(UU
'CC0C
0U—
C
-C
U
0
C
O0UC)U
-CU
'C
C0UI
EUU'C•
CUU
0C
0
•0 c0CCU
c
0'
41o
0
_U
UU
I"O UU0
cU-0o04
C
C
0•0
0oUC
—
—U>
0UU
CCOOUE0C-< CCOIC
IS
0
U— 0
UU
Ia
0
c
UUU•'CUU
0 U'<0-0C-OU
'
2
'C
(n
0U
4c,
Cl
20
C
'
U
C
"C
0OU00'C'C
2o20VUC 22UQj.UCU'C
0
—0U)U-U
U c
a
U
'UC2 U0EU:CUU0mOU-0, UUrT U U00
C
CL
' C
C
-C
UCC00'C0U00UC4C-
00UU'C'CUCCU_'CC
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 104/147
VV.
b0
Cd
U Vc VQ—
V-
•-0CCU0
VUc-cVV0.0B1
•••-
EE
-
L
H•In
-
VV
aVQjd0CU•
U
0•-' a.
0UC
V
I-i -
00D
VC
idVVVVo
C0cVn0CVVrUEOcVVUk.V
U
•
C-000VV CB
VVb
2
—-
0
V
V V0
C0VVV 0U
c
VVC4
-c
—
0 00lu
V
V00V0
C
7
VUBEV
11
C
-dc0
0EV CU
CV
,d U
VCc
aEC
M
_
c
0
Vc IM Ca-O V
U
Co
CU
V
C
-
D
VV
Vc,V
C-OCdad--C Uo V
-g
C
-1
C
._CCCVC-Cc
CC UdcVCcCcdV
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 105/147
c0
I-—0 (DOV"—-- rcn 0D(DUV—
oV
-VV
IrV
-
0I 'n
4
1UV(D
U.cn 0 Vc V<°00•+ V00(Dcu
V
0V
(<VU
ID
(DC
0
.
°'0-
D
V1 UV0mV
0
6
c
D
'VI01<EV<
0
0
VU
0V0._u
II0'D cL
n
(
D
0- m
V
0
Im
C
V
0
cu
'V
VV
N
0<
V
I-<
0
m4-1
0V0
0
(DU
-.0<oV
ic:>
D-(D
4
1
lDO(D0'<V00
(D
U
U0
V'UE
VD
40E U'IDCL4-4
•00
EVE
V
C
VVU0V4 'cVVVV(DU44<LB0V;
4
V
C'
(D V(D4V cn
V<V(D-0V0U
0
100
V
N..
lI
(D
(N
CI1•VN
CLCCCC
I-
NQCNCCLVLLNNVLLVNNVIN
V'L
N
VVV
C
V1VC
CCN
N1VNC
NCNLI
LC CCu
CVI
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 106/147
CCCCUC.CECCCEC
'CU
CC
C
4-NU
C
C
C
E0CC
C'C
I-CCC
-jCC
-
<0C
-
0C—
-
C
C
CC
C)CC
VC
C)
C)
C
.•C<C
'C
LC
-
CV
VCCC)
C<
C)
C
-
CcCC
C
CVC-C
CC
l
CC
C
-
C)CC CC
C
VC-
C)CCC
C
4
CC-o4C
)
'CCU.CC-<C)
C
l
C4CC)CCC-CICC<
C)
CC
U UCC(0-CCCo--CC
'CUC
l
CC
.
0C)
4'CCC.
CUC<C)
-C
CCCC
l
CICC
.
CoCUCCC-CCCUCCC
.
CC)
'CC
C
)
CC-C
CC
CCCUC4CCINC-C CICCC<CC
.4I
CC-
C
)
CC<C
C
UCC
-CC
C
CC
V-CCCVC)
VVC
C
C
-C
)
0 C
C
U<CC -CC
C
C)
CC)
C)-CVC
-
CCC
C
C
-CCC
CC
C
CC)-C
,
C)C,
CV1
CZZI
4ICC
CCICC
CCC
CV-C
C
CC
C)
C<C
C
CVCCCCC
VICC)
CC)C-OCcC
C
CCC
VV
VCC
-CCC
C-C<
)CC
C)
C<VCC'C
C
CCC
)
C)
CCC
NCC
VCCCCC'C-CC
C
C
-
CCC
)
'C
)C
CCVVVVVC)-CC
C
-CCCC
C
C
)
CCCC
Cl
CCCl
CCCCICCC
C
)
ClC-C C-C C-C 4
CC0CCC4
CCCC
lCC
-
C4C
CCECCl
CCCCCC1
'CCCC-C C4-C
Cl
CCCCCCC<UCCUCCUCCl
C
d)
CCCl
CUC4C
C
.
CCC)
C
d)
C4CCC-C Fw
r C-C -C
C
1
CCCUC-CCC
C
C-
C'C C
-C
C
CC
-CC —
-CCU
C
C
4
C.
Cl
C
.0CCUoCC
CCz
C-
C
l
CC-C CCC-
C
0C'CC
lCCNCIC'CCCC-C C4
CCCCCCU
C<UC'CC C
l
CCECCUC
CC
4
CC)
-CC
<)
C
C0
I-C I
Cl
<C)CCr
C
CU
Cl
C)<C
C-E4-C
'CCCECC'
U
C4-C
CCCCC'CCCECCCCU'C<C-0CCCCCCCU'C4CCC'C
4-C
IUC
NNC
-C'C
C
U<
C
C
-4C
C'CUCCCCUC'CCCUCC'CC<C
u
C•C.' CCCc-7
1
u
N-CCo04CU1-<
CCCC)C
C.'o•EC
C
)
C
C
C
.
CC)
C
C
C
d)
C
CC•C'CU C-
U-CCCl
-
C)
<UCC-
00
C
C
C
1C
.o•CC-
CC
CCU
CC)C
Cl
CCCC<C
C
l
CC
U
L
Cl
41CU
C
C-C C
C
CC
4
-C
C-
C)C
_UCC
CC
•CClHC
-
U
C
C
C
<
):U,Cl
-Cc CC-UC
CC4CCC
C
C
U
C
U
?f
'CC
CCU C
<CC)CC C'CC'CCCC4I
CC
4
C CU--C
CC)C
-CCCC
b
E
CaCCCC-
C
CCC
CCC
Cl
CCClClC
Cl
CC-4-C
C<CC)
•CCCCC
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 107/147
BC
2oC-V
CC
CC
BCC
•-2--B,VC-CUCCUcVC
CC 'C
C
2CU
C
• C22C
V
C
C
l
C
C
NC
V
CC
C
CV
B
'
B
C-V
C
T
BCUC
,
CC 4-
C
l
CC
l
C
)
ICVC
)
C
l
CVC4-
C
)
ICCC CC
l
C'C)
C
)
C
l
C'C
CC
-
CCBC
C
VB
-aa-aELaV-Vu
U-
aVVU,2CV
C
accda-'V
a-'V
-<0V
Va4E6 cvaOV aClU E---aCllC
)I3
C
l
U
UC'VC-2 I f-<VVVUU7u1
E
VV
0M
aEa.E
aVUUJV
VHEQ
C
d
Idv0
C
C
)
2
0C
C
)
C
C
C
CC C
C
D
0
V a4-Ua<
C
- -C
4CC
V.E-U<-eNC
1-
V a-4
64- - '4-U"14C"<-dC-4kV4UVC4 V
(U OnaV U
lC
C
C
a
CC
-QC)VU '-aV Ea<C' 2 unCC
)Cl
l)CC
E
n
-E
-VEC
l
EV'V E2 CCa
NCC
V—
v
'd
'V
a,2B
EEUVU-av-'VEaE
V
22VEEaa 4T
VC
-C
C.2V.VcaUVEEU.aV
V
-Ub
C
d a a
<
U
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 108/147
V-VV
CUçVC'V0C:V
C
-0-0IVd.0N
V-C
.-Co-C°
CC
0
.
'000-CCr'
0
It
UVV
o<0Uc_c
C,
CC
0E
C- C
M- C
8
c
V
4c2C
U0<4.ct
o0
C
' 0L -QCc °oo0
l
u
C
000icVCV
2
cn 4
C,V
V°-oc
IC:C 0VcVc 00
VVc•LV-CC 0<)VIU
!O
0
0-0 0D
0
oE
VoV
I
.0I0c
a* -d
(:
v
C".
0C
IC
C
0
'DVtD,o
•_
ç.Vct
-
C-o
c
-.1
•0LV0VU
V
0Q
)
•C
I
1ou0-d
00c
-
C:U
Vd-d)C-V.
E
U' •0s
cd 4
0
:
00V0
V
i_=
c
U
c
cz V•0 C
IEC)CVS—
<Vc:
CV0a 0U VC0
0C•I0
0
d
to
Nzt
V
IVVCC
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 109/147
CVVE
N4VI-N'4V-CCVV
V-4C
)
NC
CCUCCUVNVN4NCCC'N
0
ouru'C c
NNCC
/C
u
0N4NCC)
CCCN'C0'NzC)
CC)
CC)
I-CC
-CCCC)
E
C
CE
C)
C'0C'NCVCVCV4-C0ECC
-cCNC)
C0N4
NV44
•0IC-NNV-C0-CN-CC
)UC
,
CNV
C)
C0CN-CNU
NINC)
-CNU4UN-CC)
N-CNNIC)
C00-C'CC-CC'NUN4C-CNC
)CCC
)NC0C
IC)V-CNNU'CCUCCCC
)C0C-NCC
)4E
C'-0CCCNNU0CNCCCUV-N
NCCCUC)
N-CNU4C
.NCC
)E N-CCC
C
N'4VNC'NUC)
UCCUN4C'C4C
CU'CCC)
0U44
'CCC-C0E
0-CC
)
-N-C-CCC)V4
4CC
)44VN-C0CNUCC
V-CN-CNV'4NC-C-
C'NCC)
0NdC,
'CCN4C)
C-CNU-CC0-CC-vCUC'C
0 VNU4'0-CNNC0-C0-NCCC)-CNCC
)NCUI'C-CC-CC'C0C'NCV I'4N•0C
-04
-N-4NNN40-CNC
-
C'4VCNC-vbCC0UN-C
4-
N'0NC•0C-
'4—
NN44
NNNN4-
-'4N4
-A
N44
•00-N
N44
N4-
NN4-
4N4-
-A'0'044-4
'04-
N
IV-CN-CC
-4CUNN-Cb'44
40C
.
NN(U
C)
b '4E VNNE
C
-
N-N'0C
-
'
NC)
NU4-cN'4-00NC4
NC-'CCNVCN-CUC
)C'4C
,
NCUC-CI0UN
NCC)
CNCC)
-CCCC)
CVV-CV-C0CCCCCC-CN-CC0IVV-CCCCN-CNU
NUUNNCNCC)
N4CNE
C-
'A C90.CNVN'V0
0N0C
-0CC
N
0
_0
C
/C
-_oCC
4-4CC<V0
C
/C
C/C
C
-A
2
NVVCC
0--0V'-bD0oI In
VC
'N-A
N
-
C
/C
2
V
0C
/C
VC/C
C
/C
oVC-A
'40'4C
/C
Cd
4VVC
/C
0C/C
C
/C
VCC
-<
4V
C-0CC
.4
C00
4
2V14
CC-A
V'4CV14
4CV4-4
C00C/C
VVVC
/C
4C-
'4N
-
0C
0C
/C
EV-C0
C
-A
CC
/C
0-0 C14
C'4V-EC
V-0-'4CVC/C
0CVC
/C
C0CV
C
/C
4C
/C
C
-A
C4C1.4
4C
/C
VC
/C
C'00 CC0C00C
/C
CC/C
4-4
4
2CCC
/C
VC-C'
4
C'4
'04C
/C
-CC
/C
00'0
V
4
4
N''4
-BT•-NOE
oV
0<
E0u"
C
C
o"rD V0
V4
I4-<
-4—V0zVV
C
/C
0V'-0u00o,C/C CCH4
V
..•-C,0 "40
Cc4
-'C 0
0C/C
4
-
C
4VC0•00C
/C
cCC- oC
/C
- V0VIC'4/C
C
-
'4_
C_CC
-VocO
CC
C
oCVO—- 44
00'4V
4-
.000-00V'S4.,V•'4u0<C-CCC
CO
-
C
-
VC/C
C
4
C
C4004'V0-C0-4CVoV1.4
00
CVVC
/C
CV
42C
C0CCC—0
C
--CNC
/C
VC/C 0-
V-dc-dCVC00o—
V8-
4
'0U
-
-
-
-
NC
C
C
)
c0
---4
.
-
4-
N
-0N
0 c
C)
4
C
00
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 110/147
•E
U
VL
E
C6
'0V
0VV
EOM V.°VVzsV'VVU2I—'Vb
L
VV
VVV-
V
V0
U w_C
ç0Vr 2V-
1•E
V
L00 <MV<t
-
jo
U—VV
VVV9VZ
U
C)1
9UV
01
00Cu
0CL
C
c
C
-C
V
V
u VV
V
V
CCV
Q
.VCiVV'VVV
V
V
V
'V.V
•L,VcVV
VVVCVVV
C
V
VV
uVV
u
V
VC-
VVV
V
4
V
V
'<
CU
VVVV
V'-VC-C
V•VVVV•VVV'<VV
C
<VVVU
C
V0
c(U
m
2E0UVV
V
<UV
-<VVi- 90-0 4C-0V1'2VV0UI
IVVVI0•E2••00V'0V
0
I
c# VV
C0<C
E I<
VV0CVV
0V
0N0
0-
'V0C
-UUVc0
'V<00<V V
V
0Vu
U
' V009E•
VV-V
VV
-
VU
V
0<VV
V
vE?2-6V$-V—V4V
c
C-00iEVE
o
(VV00
U<EE0<<
0UV--0V
-V<QT040
-92 V
0<
VUVC
U
•D VVVVC
'V,0V
V
'UVIEV
V
V(C,E"000V•VUVd VVC,-V
V2U
0<
U
V
V
004V<0
U0-C CV
i:oVU 0E
c
VCDV•
—
<E0U)-
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 111/147
NV14
4-U4
VNCNNCCC'
VUCICCz
4CCICEC
—VV
U
4UCV1o•9CIC
.C
CNC
VC
4NCV-CNNIUCCC'
NUN
UN4
-
UN
C
4U
4N14U
CCN
CC
N
CU 'I
C'
U—
•-EoU
C
V
C
o(
C
— •V
— '
4
•CcV•',V
c
C)
4CVC4-cCVZA
u
14
V
•-444-c C0NV
C
.40
CU
00CN
C
CU
V-
CI
V
C1-4CCj,V.CU-.> CV
4
°=V
C
U -CVVvV
oc
4UC
c
C
IS
(••<4CC
',U1 -cVc' V•)J44' CQCC-1
C
CC
pm o
4IOVC
UV-0QU
CC
CCcVCC
V
(UbO
ZtC,
C
(UV
C
4
4VN
CV--0VCC
cL
C
-U
41
1-C
V'-4
V
C
CC
1
3
E•oC
-V
VCcVUcu!-
V4CC'CV
0VVC'V44 ff CC VEUVUCISC'VoEVVr-0mU>
C-CCCUCC
-d4.
UCCCCCCCICU-4NN
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 112/147
l)
V
UU
7 uc -VC
C
UUH0V
CC
UUCUIC
d
0C.
0
UU-Cd
-VC
d
0CC
V
oVC
d
1o
•
CC
aT
C
V
o•Cd
I-C
d
a-
V00C
d
V00Ua-00C
d
UC
d
E0C,
C
d
VU0C
d
CC
I(1
VC
d
I0'Cd
VVI0-VC
d
C
d
0C
d
a0-V
0
V-VC
d
V0Cd
V'1
C
d
V-V'00V
0Cd-OCdI0-'C
dU0VUr0UCdC
lVC
a)
VIaCdCd-
iD
VCl
V0bID
0
N0C
d
,0Cd
a
-
0I0'0
a
-
00'V0IEL
VC
d
C
d
-VCd
V0 V-VC
d
U-VC,0V0VC
d
0C
d
IU-V0V0V00Cd
,0Cd
a0Cd
U0C
d
UVV0
Cd
C
d
1<
'UCd
C
d
0-VC
d
0C
d
aV-VCd
VUVa
-
V00Cd
-DCda
ICd<
0
U
CdC
')Va
c
V
U
0C
Cd
IC
CdV
0V
a-
<0caVdCl
Cd•CdaUVcI0
d
0,-
•
C
-aNC
dIa
4
—
a
Cl
C
d
Cl
V4
—
a
I<aC
I
VCl
0U0Cd
Cd0ClVI
a0VaVCdVbi
D
-d0Cd0CdVCdCl00CdV0VVCdI
aV4
aV-00U0Cd
-OCd
Ia
0V0UbID
'C0VVa0aV0Ia
00VCda0CdCl
Ia
CdIa0C
lVVI
a0
VUVClVaVC
lCl
-—
a
CdCdIa
Cd
E0'CdUVCd
-l
CdCl
Vaa
C
a)
0Cl0
VUV01
U-000UVbJO
lu0
c0
:
0
V
0x-UC
V11
C1
V-E
00V
.1
V
-aV-IC -Uc c<o
•
biD
<
0Eo•.-U1-1
U<
-hU
'1
Cl
11)
CU0 VC-VV
.
VCl
0CV
U 0
C
d 0V-
00o0-VC
d
VVQV-VU
d
iE2 ---CC
VCd
0Cd
0V
-E 1l0d0-V
.--0UCd0Cl
UUCC
•0U'C
C
0L
-I
L
I
aCNIa
CE
Cdd
CdVVCddC
d
Cd•-4-a CC
0
<
dCd
U
oU—.1
Vo—C)
VV
4CIaC
C
0'
CcIa
' V00
Ia
Vl
•2C
dd
UV
V-C)Cd
V
-V
-<Cd
CUCd
kV-'C
d
Cl
V-
V•< 07-<Co0VUVa-UbDVVVIal0Cd
1aCd
-•a
.— I-V
o1--V
VV•V
Cd
V4LCl
o•a' •
a
0V
ob:d
-
0-a-a L)
CC
2
C
•9
VoU 0VCCC
'2VDC
C
0
0CC CC
C
)
CC CC
I"
U
C CC I
0
CC
00UC
C
C
CO
,,0C
'-a0C
<o0
NCCC)Q"UNC'0C
0
-
--VN
U0U
—
-
VC
0
0
a
C
C
U'LV0, 6
I
-90V
C
V—-aU0 0C <
b0
,0
'OCCVV
UCVCC IdIC)
0U-C
-s
-
-
-
-
-
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 113/147
VrCV0L-O0UC
-
0<
0
00VV-UE
CVE 0
U0C-
V0C0<
VV--
V-VC0<
0UbD
C-0C
.0V-0
<
-
'Vo
V
o-.cV'0C."0o-E
L
U0
-o-C
V0V
0<
V
V
cCc.cU0C.<C0<CCOCO-
C
-
VC
V i S
VCCV
<UC 0CUVc 0
<
4C,
VCd
C
-
CV-j c-V-OC
VCVC-dVCVUCV0CC
C0C)'00C)0C4C)0C020C-VC0C0CC
-4CCIC)
-VCC)22C-VC-V0-V-VCCCCCC
.C)a-C0CC- 0CCCC
-
C)NC0C)-VC
-C)C
-CNCC
-
0CC"3C
4CCCCCCC-
CC'CCC0CC-
C-VC)C2C)CC
.CC'CCCCC
-CC)
-V2'CC
C
.
C
.
CIC-
C
M
V-d
CC-d-3U0V
-d
-dC
.
C
-dC4
-C
V
CCC
-
CC
C-d-dCCCC)
-VC2CC2C0CC-
CC2C'CCC-VCC-CCC-VCC0'C2C2CCC
'CC0
CCCCCC<
CCCC)C-
C)CC-VCCCCC0
CNCCC
-CCCC'CCC-VCC-CCCC
-C)CC
C
l
CCC)2CCC22CC)C
C2C-
CC'
2C)2C-CCCC-
0C2C)CC
—
IC
-VCC)C-
C)2AC-V
V-d'VC0C,
-OQ14Cl
V-dV0CC,
VV-d-dC-UC
,C,
VCl0E0Cc
VCCC
d,
C-VCC
d
V0<
CC,
Vc CCCC-0-dCC-dC
d
VUc
b
-C-
V0
,
0V0
U0<c0oc
c
bG
VC<
0cEV
C
I
bD
E0C>oC
V
.',-0c -<
' EU'I0VC V
UU<VC.UC0C
l
C0V.0<
V
.çCCl
0V
CbC
V4UC
)0-dVC
d)
C
0<
0CC
C
'1-dC
C
-C
VCVECUCU'VCCCCCCC,
CC0C0C,
C'
CU
--
ClIVC..UC
V
C'
V
C
C.
--d-VVC
CI
CI
U
0l
V
C,
C-0UVC
C,--'
c.000C
VoV
-d- V0
C
0 CV'
-C0-cUrI0--CCVC0V<
V
-VC0VCCd
V
--
0CC
C
VC,
C
C0-.'--0CCC
V
C)U
VV
E
o 0 -
--
-
--
-
--
-
--
---
-
-
-----
C)C C- C ,-C-CcoCEU2-V2C
C0
' d-N
oC<C_
2-d
U>m
C<
N0
'C0
C C 'CC CC
NC
N CC
6VCC2E
oC-CC0C-Oo-C
CC
o6-C
2.2C C
-M M
l
uaa
02022°CC)I
-
C
CC
)-
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 114/147
V
0V<V
VVVQr-CCCdQ1CVQ-<0c
C
V
Cc
C
I
I1
c
UI—
6
ua
V0QJ4E-'VV
V
jD
<-
<
c
C
—
C__E0 CID
V CE_VC0<V
V
EU
U
D
rD
(D
VECC
1
U
E
L
d
<U
1<
c
2
-4
2
C
U-aU
00V2
—I0
C-VVI-C '
VC
CIVVDc
Q
CCE1U
CCDC
IVU&4—CUCc •—
'
E0-MClIDV
ç
VoVU
V
E
U
C
r
EUB-4
V
V"CVVU0VVE
VUNV
a
•-
-
2CVV00o
V0
Vha<6%VEoE
E
UVCU0m
C
1
U
0VCV
VVuC
U U"
CS
VVsV
2 <EVD
-(D
E9
CB-C
C)
U U C)
U C
)
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 115/147
"
C
—CFVL•
CVC
-d
—
E— E'CVV< -
VVCN
olcClUU
C)CI
CMu•d0V
C
0C
Nckm
ClCl(V0c
—
'UCU
VV
c
VV•— UVUl
C
CCVC)•d<l)dC,
2 •Cr
'dVV
c ClVC'C4a—-
U
uC
I C)CcdVVVVCV
I
C CV
Clkd
4U
bZ—
C
)V
41
VE
V
:0
11
WD
V ECC0C
oVV< V
CVoVbVC0<UlUC)
U
C°C
,U<
U<oM
-d
0
n
— —
lq.
'ECV
b
CI
-od
cI-
dC
UoUVQ
CI
C
I
0— cVU
EEC)LJCC
C0dVCE
(nC
UU
CCVCICIC"C
O
'VVo<'cCC)UC
)0dV0<VU—UCC0EOM-OEO
M
UdV
U
c
O
V
C VU0<um
-dC
'CCI<C)VC < •CCUC
CCllV_o<VCoVMISU'd
U
V
c
4<
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 116/147
a
C -Lo
V
cVv04
'4CI
'C0 vC-
Ae C -c
-C
•
C
)
C
-
'4U*44 oCC
U
°
-C)_'4CC'4
4
0
4 44
L
U4LC,
xV-l
V'C0
C
l
CCC
l
C-dCEV-4VU
)
a4CV-4CCaVCC'V
IIc
1cz
-
,
C'C-
,
C4U
C<44
-
'44CCCCCV
-C
44.
-I44
4.
C-CC4CC
-C44.
44
4CCI4
-
to-C
-•V0 C0dc0c-C'4U(
4)
CC4aCC4-C4ICCaCU4
'C)
C4C-4)
C-CCU4IV-CC4-CCI44
-
CC
)
CV
C
M
C
M
N-4IC44
aCa'V-Ca44.
C
-
0V0<0V1C0
V1-d
C
l
01
0CCC40V
0-VC0
C
-
0E0c CCC
-
4C
l
V-dVC-
4VC'40
C
l
CCV-d4
4.
-d44.
E
VCCVaCUCC-
-CU
4CC-
aCC-
4CCU
aCUVC0CC-
-CCCC-
VCC)
aCC-
-4,
4U
CVC4ECC-
CC4
C)
CV-CCCC444CUCC
-
-4C
C-
aCC-
CC-
'4-CVCCCCC-
aCCVCC-
-
C
-
C<
)CC
VC0U
C-4,
C)
-CCC-
IC-CC-
N
C-aCCC4CCC-
-VCVaC
C-
44UCCCC
)
-CCC-
-CU
CC-
CC-aC
-
C4aVV-C
C
-
CCUCIaC-N
VCC
CC-
a0CCC-
aCCCVECC-
'-CaaC4.
C
)
-C-CaaC-4C
)CC
4CC)
aCC-
U'-C
4-
CaCaC4-C44.
4-CC-CC
C-
4
-
V-C'CC
CCU4-
C4-
4N4C-CCCaaCC
)
'CCC'C
)
VC-
VC4aCC-
U40
CC-CC
)
EC4,"CCC-
C
)
40CVE4-CCU'
C
)
C)
-CC44CVC'C
C
-
UCC-
44
-
C--
aC
CCICC4CaVC-CC-
aC4CC4C-CCC-
NC-C
4
-
CaCCC4-
CC'C
)
C
)
-CN4-CVC-'C
)
C'4CC-
U
a4aC-CC-C
)
-C
-C440
C)
CC-CVC
)
-C4-4-CC
C-
-CC-
4-CCCaCC
C-
aC
VCoCC
l0-C1-I'C
V0
-e-CC2
C
V
'C
'C
c(
HCC
'C
C
l
-dC
N
N
C
'4.- -
-
-
--4 VIC
VVV
Vc
4
V0ICV
IroL
• C4V'4VC
çV0Ln
VC
'4C
4444.
4
V
a
C
)
C-oC-CV4
V--C
tL
C
V
C
4
4
40
N
C
)-'4
CC-
-CC
-C
-CC--s-C
'C
)CV-UC)C4
C
CC-4)UVC
C
4C44.
4
CC-
a
U
,VU)
o
CC-
CC-
aCC- C-
a-C
C
-
-C)CCCCCCCUCC-
C
C<V
CCC C
CCCC
CC- oE-Co
.C
CCCCC•U V
V•C
-
I-dV
0
0Cl
C
440c01
,0C
)
1
1
.
C44
C
l
1• 1-4
C
l
14.
-C
d.l
11
1
1
CIVrC0CC
EV
0CV(U0
1C
l
o
4<
14C
l
C
l
VC
'4
VCl
V
C
-
V
C
o
U1C
--VV'4
V-V
1-d
4.
<14.
<
Io-d
4.
14.
14.1-4
4ICCV
d'C
C
l
V
I C'C
C0 EC0r
C
lCc
C
'C'C
C
A
E
-•0VC
0V1 S'C
CDInI
0114.
x'C
I
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 117/147
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 118/147
cQvV
UV0
U 0V
M
c
-
N
-C L —cz —U0—aVvvVUa c
_n
CIS
•V-
uv0d
.0VScV
av0
c
v•0.
c c99-
-
02V
d
9cc
c
0V0
-I
C
-
cC
V
cC
ccCCo C—0C0cC0V
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 119/147
01
(00(D
z0<
0CU
(D
D
0VO–0< 0VE•
(0
0
•C •— (D
-1D
00
0D00V <0< V(0<!cD (
00UV
•0•c-
<
V0
L5(
D
(D
0< (DCV
—VC
•0
C
UV(
CV0
O 5
00<0O•-V V0(D
U<VIV(0(D
-cV0V(0VU
I(
C
0(0V(D
0(
C
(DoOOV=V(D'(0oCD°EVVUV0O VV0VVVO u-fl V0VUdUI-Z
(0V
0
V
(00bD
V0 0V0VE0
SC
VU(D
VVQ0SEV•VV
VVV01Vo d—U
UVI0C
(
V D(0CV070(D(DV(DV0Vb
oE
UC
0b
VE
V
(D
00
V
VVE0CUD
6
0(
_0
(D
U —D0
c-V
VV
(DV
(ID
D(DCD
' 0U00(D
LUV(D(D
V0.V(U V4
Vtn0c 4I
(D(0
VD
VVDU
C
V
UD0D
U
(DUOEVV(00
0
U
6V
(0V1q
(D
VU
-•UV 000
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 120/147
.<
C
<VUVV
I
C
VoE
.,<-.-
V
0
••0
0Vc U
<0
V-C
-0z
I V
CV
ZVVZ—--
U_
VUU-CE
V:VVE
<CV•
VO
bD
IEC V
-—u
0
m r
V
C )U
cC
C,
-V
CcU
C
C
)
VVV
d CCd)<
VQCd)
C
C
OCV
•
C
VlVC
')VB
0aV
•
c
C)U
CV
C
d)C<o
•<
0
zVC-
-kVC0CV.VoV
V
C
C
dV1C VC
0
oC)C
CCC)UC•Cd) 0<2CmCZV
0C
Cl
c
C
VCVCl•<U
V•CCC
VU
<
E
0EV
U
V
U0<UCl
U
C
Co0
-
V
•
"V
EUCd
z Cl('
< ••
UVUCCl
V
d)
C)bVC
,
UVVC
V
C—V
.<
0<)
Um•0
V
IU
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 121/147
L
•V
VVCVV.0VC< VU0NNa
EUE
0C
Q
C.
UC
0C
C
C
C
•
C
—:C
C
VCCC
C
V
C
—C
In
C
E UVEM14 "aVCI
<V"J 0C
". C-C_INVVC
E
••cIC<<V.
VIdI
CU VECCVO1-9 0C:U
1
C
UV
E UUVCC
CC V)I
V<.1 EUcd V
,UI cl
V
C
CVC
C
a
UV
C
C.—
,,
Z0JD
U UC
CVc0Ccdkm <C
C
cl
Vt
'
o
C
U
C C-.
C
0
)
•-oçE
C
)-C
V
0Vc)C•• CcCC:C C'-CUCU
(CZ
IE
C•_SCVV
0o VC
VCc
V<UCaC
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 122/147
C
VCEVi
C
04
(D
<
CU
•—V
(DI CV(
D
CV
(<(D
(D
—C<U
VO
D(D
D41•(DVrd cNCVVLQ Cc_— •<'MECIDc (D(D ;_—c(
D
r V-U --E,CC-VVVUV VVV-—---Vc-0C
(004
0
C-
(D U(D a•(
U
rD
C
VcVC
C
V(D
•>D
(0
1
C4 •U•D•o0V0(D
U
C—
0
CID
C-c —VorVUOObjO
•\4
C
Uo-
V
(D
CV—'I-VV4
(0
_C ZZ
•(D
&0b
•
V
--
g 0
' .0•
cuU
OU4VU4
U
(D
4
a
'C
V
.—Cc
VCVz2
(D
-U'--VU(ID—4
'-Cc
CC— - 0-VC4 CCO•CC U (DVVV\N 'C4-1 6V
0C
V0
Z
V(
VVCCC•00(D V(DC•-<•-0V
0
C•0
-•CrD Q a
-C
(D
Cd
c
V
• -
D
bD
rDUV
(D
C
VC=(DD•C
C-(D 4 V2a(
D
cpVU.
•(D (DV
CJD
—
V
C&
<<-
V
c
(
D
V4VCCC(D DUVUbCC
I
C
V
VCi C
COC
UV
;
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 123/147
0c
0V.-
'V—
-UV
4
U
V
•V
0ccJ
I
Vc
W
C
c ciVVac
-
o
U
U
U
I
V-o .—
iVQaoVVV-V- •7
a
2V
c
ciC
cic
V
00N
V
o
Vd
0V
Q
.c •IcVc
y
'VE
V0cV
ccUc C,-5
m
Cd
-u bD
-c
Z
C
c)VV00IzL00
ud2
00'._Edd,0
V0
' 0Vc
'0V
I
:dU.,Vc—
0dO
d
V
UV
7w
0
cc
Vd0
U
V
M
UdU.Z00c
-0
EV'U
Zz
dV
U
0
Q 0V00
VV
c)U
V0d-•J
-d—
Vd
dEE
c
VOcVd
V—
cd01m
-
V
dVc,0c
VUc0VV'VLcCc)
')
.—
c
V
Q
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 124/147
.0VVc0UUOI#00V')VD1VoE0
V4V0
04
0UUVVV0V.E V4—VUC V 00VV4-
cV(c0•'000u0
VV
V
U
0
V4
VQ0U0MVU
-
Iç)LVV4-04
Cl0U0UU
c
C)"c
-I4
54c'Vc44V
V'
4)J•
0
0'VC)C)0VUV 0crECl005V0)VC)-1UVU V1
4—:c0Z 0VV c-0
a
,
, VUVu
l
V
Vo c U.40Vo
0U
U0
-(_
4-
04)V-C4-F4V
00a1-V
4
to
C0)
4
U-4o)VEtn
VCl
00•
VV
V_
VU
'E
E
0 aV0VU -0Ucd' 0Cl4l-c o
V
- 0
-cV00
o4
'
UVc
c
)c4CaVc cVQco,44-ClCVZ
0 uumV 4U
04-l0400b
UC)Cl 0
VCl)
UC)V
<-2
00C)C)
V
V VVV0UcV1
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 125/147
'0C
)V VVC)4
0VV
V
0
0bDV
0
ru
C—0)CNct
c'VV
_o--
VU
VV
CV
(1
CC0V
n
000C1C
V
V
VV00'E
M I
—
0C
E
I
L-4
VV
0
u Zn >\^^ Z,
U CVM0UC
I_ VVV(—V)VOV0\0V-
U
0
--4C0°L0-—U0
VC
V
C
-C
0Co
VV
C
C
-•—CC 004040-i•:V00U
V—0
-Ca
E
-
41•mC
c
ct
c•'
u
.
V:. -VUCI
C•-
44CC
-C•
' C)V040VN
CN
CC
'V
0N,
-
U
C)CCV
V0 0
C0
V—0CC 4CC
-V
CCC C
V
CCC
d
V-
UCC
C
C-.
-k
0Vj
VL
-
-C.'1CuIt VV
UV0C
Q VVCVCVCCO
E
V00UU
1CoV
4C0V4V
1C
0C
cS
1-2.4CCC
VC
1C
C,V0C
çVCoI0
VCl
0 0C
I
O
C
VVCV0•U4-
a
V-UCo0-
--
C UkVCcC CQCl - In C
C
o V
'V-
-E )U'V
V04
1CC V-0c C
C
CVOCc)(
c0
0lVCVa_
Z
:
u
VCCC
C
Z
U
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 126/147
0o,cCOr(5UMz
4
0V
-?L-I
I
Vc
V
—c)4
-C
C
V-C
V
VV
44
U
4
L
V
V
UVVEEV
-U
0c)cVco)V U)CEV
V11
r V
IU C)cVVcr
V-V
8ECIccC cVC
VcV0VCu VC c
I
Vc
VIQ
—V
V
•
VCC1
U
0
VUCV
._
0U
DN
C
V
VV
VQC
VId
C
0
CcoU
C
V
1V
V
0Vc-
oVc VUVc
I
c,V
uC
VC' U
CE
c
VUV-
)
11
C)
00V
V
V—Oc:5)0)C UU)c)VCrmW
4c
—
V-cVVc) UcNC.CO
c
C—
-dOVVV
V
V
V
ocCk VCCN—
c
oVcVEU
c0c,-ooE0o U8E
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 127/147
-±
-
VV
0
V0V
bL
c
cQ V-Uc
0U0V
-a.o1
VU0Zo E p VV--uV-Vr•——
-VV
-UV
V
E
00c0cuV
C0V0UuC)
V
4c_
U
V-
V
U
V0VVV0.VM'VV
VVC0V(
UV
—0C
d) 0V0VV0)
V
I
V
VC
d)
z=0
-
00V0LQ0V
0VV
CVN)U
Vwn
VV
' 0
V
0
l
0
E
4C
NO-C
—VM
V
UVUUVVV0VEE Cu
VVVUU
toVU0VcU
VU
U
VCoUU
C
CL
VCId
IC
d) VV
U00U:-0-
z
VV0
V00 V0VCd)Cd)UV
I
z
U
V
V
U
VCUi 71VU:VCV zc0U0
<V
0VVV'V
U0
0 C
Cd_U
0CVCV
.V_VU
VV0
C0
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 128/147
0
ErJma
CcU
V -V
(U-
10
o104-vEVVV
-
U(Co
Vo
Cc E
C•vo (0-CC.UOCVloo)VI
oV
V
U\
10
O
oU
1
7v
10
C
- 1-
N-C•VVoCQCO-_u7UtoJNVMCU0CV•VV°C/Dç10C1E
-
V
=V
v
UO
C
UVCU
1C)
'
-Z01DC
a
c
VC
1C)1-1ZZ-4r00o
CV—41-C.< /VUVC<rMZVc<U->•1)0 V
roEC0CovU
1C
-0
0<U
U
U0<
0 C
1
/0
01Q
•
Co"
VCV
1VU
CC
0
1CO0C<
1V
i-EEC
c1UC-UVV°V0C
cV
4
CU
C
CcV
0
000C)0
m4V
E
V1
V4Coc<L
1U
0<
E
V
c
V
-<
-°CVLQC1V-aEV4-0cr4Vc Vo UV C0 C
/V
<V
Vo
41UCUcC1°11
cçV
'CU- <C1
1
V
U
VU
-1VcVo<U
C
1
0
UV
VV
1/0 0VU
01o0LSC4CoV
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 129/147
VC
U
C
V
V
IVV
C
VEVV
cV
I
c
VVV
0<<CVV
C
bDO
CUU
VVUU
C
V<V44fr—V.
N
•—C
0c
U cccC<<_ EUVMU'CUUcd CCCU<VC
I(DVV(D V1I<-41CUUccVCcNN< CVC
EL4-VVVEVVC•0ECo CVU0UEUVU I<VO0DCVCV 00
CVC:z M
U
E5 1c
oVU
C
I-Q
VC CV
U1
0E—Ed
4-1
V0VC6o' ENCEC
V
UVV
<
lD
lD
VU
0<
V
1
C10UVlDVtDCJ<I-VrDU11C•->c
1
c
V -VI_V
CC0
E
o-E<EV
lD
V—D
0
o
'
'1
°E UP
DV
çrrsD
V(D C(UV—lDICI.<VV14o
lD
oV
U
1V<V00U<D1CVCVV0< UVUE
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 130/147
(D
0V
Ic
0
d
V-
•D
VV
0
(D
V00V
0
c
VVV
.-1(D?EdNE:
0VI
•4
V
ç
-z
1VV01•0V
I-V
VC
1VDV•I0
b
E
0
CC• E0U— •
V
(D-4-':V(D0UEVIU 0• 1V
Cr0
00
UVmm
cUU
0ID
CS C)
VE
V
I
l-
C CVV
IV
l
UU
0c;
ôct
Q. U
4
V0V 4 VI
u
V(D--
U
c
u
0 L
. u
I-4(D
V(D QV
C
aE)rD0VDIc0c--Cum (DDVN0(D(DUUUccE VID(_- UV1Q0( 0(
DI(DIV(D(DV(D(D
7
V
0
V
• V0VVU0
E
C
t
U
(DC
V
cl
VIDVD
0V
o
'0
E
'0
0000UD
E
(
D
Q
— 0—•
C
(u u
0C
(D
ç
E
0
0
01V0D
Um
V(
D
(I
V0I
V
(DU0'00C0V000VE I
0Vc
V0•-I-—
V0VVV
UU
0• CV U
oUD0V
vCEs—
V
' UU0NU
IV
U
DVd.(I0
v
00
0aV-o
V
U
(D0DcUU
VVV
V
ç
UID
0CCL,VUbD' U0c
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 131/147
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 132/147
Vc0CQO0VI U C V0OUV
)C)
0OVV0l
lH0-C ' -C U-0C)u8CU
C
-C
C)CJVçClC)_UC_-o0l
VV
l
Cl0
VJV000 C)
Cl
C u
Cl),0-CVl EC)O-VV-0;CVU0
VV
VUVU
VOT)0V
'VV
V
V0C
0VVU0-0U0
E
C)VCCCcç
I
0C 0UU
V
V
cVCCC
oI-E<0-E
V
0
-)OECE0EV
0
—
Ed E
ç
VV004UC)VCC•.EUWlo
CClC
-C
l—EC C-C VCCU—0Ol0b1VOV)0CC)V)0U
VU o_Vo41C1C
-C
VU
EU
-C
VVVUVC)C)
-VU— 0o-00l' 0OVVC
)l
Cl
ClL
I
UU
VVVClVCV—
C-
0CCdCCd 0UVC01 C
lUU
C)C)C
)0
-O-
0:)-CVc
V
c
V0M0C-C Q)UC-C ••
0 Vd—
çV
U<c
0
C
d)
Cld
0VCC
CCVC0V C)U
VC
d)
C
)CVO0
0CE' 0E
cV
VVC
C
V0•-C•InuCd UC EVVV0U0
0VU
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 133/147
-
c
u
0U
C-
U0
<-Vc
c
d
0
-
-i1
I
-dV---)VVU0<01E o-dV0V'0-0E VU-Cd-VçU C)dECV0VV000'D 0 7 dV
E
C
o
<
U
I
U
c 0
C
V'nC—IVV'VVIV0 dCC -V0VVV0
<'V"g
' )U•U00d 0
0VVVUV-0-0<U
V
•
lC<U
<
)
V<C)•C: t <
V'0V
C
d
14 <Q4
1
0<-
0b<
'0UCd0
0çVUr.
C
<E
4V'4L
C
)
u
VC
V'4C)O
bD
0'VCUVc
<d0U04VV
UV
Q
-<CU'4'0
bD 0U
'4
V
U'4
'C
<VUc
u
VC)
U1
—
VU VVVU
0
b
U
t
.
C
0
d<0U<CC
E
0d
00'4
.
<
V0.E •UV-Vd
V0VUC
'40dVV
'I V
*)4VUUE
Cl V40
E
C0
b4V0UV
VUd
1<
0 V
V
-dVs<d0
C)oE
a4.
ho
N0o0<
1d'4
4
.
1
--0d
-
I
C
J
0
0C)<VC)U0
V.o0
a<
<<V
'C0"4
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 134/147
U -Qy
lDD c
.E
—
CV
4lIDC
oVV(D
C
U
— TCcCCs
(-
. ECCV
I-ç
C)CL'-
IcC
c
C
•V
V—•DU
Q<V
IO0-<V
C•0
(D
I.<VEC.:<
0)U
SEu(J
VC(D
Eao
00<(IDEC
0
C
C(DVC
D
U
u
C
—0<
-CF
4.1
2V
-u8— c2DaO<0D0(0
(DD(D VVEV'CCo—(
DD' D(D-CoVV(VC(D-.9(<E
(
D
Uc
Q
C
0VEE<VU4
C
(D
UVZ
X
C
V
C
1
(DUVV
C
C(D
.-_
(D01(D
C.9V
(.1
•H
E<V2
•-.-C (
D
V
E
to
<
C
(<
Cc
(DDD(DDDV
U4
-C
CCCCM
bV< (<Q 41
VD—
0u
U
V-<
(D
V(D
V(<(DC•
C
4(D
E'Vz0V
CCD
V'C
E)CV
C<
E<1C
1
U4
()VDD 4
CC-
.
CD<CV( U<2
E
CVUCE(
D 0V
U
DUDV4(
D
o<CD
V -VD' CC9 DVCc4
1
E
'CbC
7m
•CD
E< VUC
0UC(<(D
C)
E(JCC' oVD<Sc0V
(V I
D
I-EECc-(LVVSEo<U0<V,(DCC(<E
U
CD
-d5
2C
-
•
c
VR
D
V
VuU
U
U
u5
I,- •—c5<C0.E<—
"<UQ'CE(<
C< 0V.oEV-E0<VV
0
I
V
I(< C (D IC
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 135/147
:>1 U-g
14
E
°vUVcu E
V
c0V
-c.2C 0In
-0E
VUV
00-Vr a'0V0rJ00 -
0.
C
I0Q
'0b
r.
-'0
0V0V
0
-
C
rJ•C-r.
-LIV
C
' loto
VVU
•CQ
C
zt
UE
-
V
---LUV'—UVI--
0
V.!C CccVC
EECLI
CC
VE V
CVV
CEV
T
C0EEV
-CNNU
EVCVV
r.V
U
U'
Cul
C2kV UVC UC0 E V
'
"
1V
E
0
"
.0 V'0
V-EV' V
V
C
ET
E
U
E
-VlD cd
E
C
CL
E
VZV
D
V
>
')0CVE .oE'LUV
D -0 C-C
Va
V
'00V'Ikm
-
VC
D
E VV E
V00E— U 0C' CCo V
D
Vto
•CPUM,(D
VCCIV
(DDUccCNU
-.
o
-
a
C
V
IVUVVVQ
VU0VE • 'C0E VU t4
E
CUvC<VIfCI.E .1EC0C 'C-coV-
ZI
(D 0CUCCUC •0
0c
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 136/147
L
(D
:
0
-dV
D
;D
0-Cc-D(
DVO
VV
0E00
E
(C
44_
V2V0
m0.D
0uuLUCz
2
0I
1o
2—°u0CI
H0-2
a-
I(D-V
+
'0V0V0I-
—
41'V
EV D
VV
V
c
0O
CE
V
U0
V
O UVVc00 buU-d0VVV:U41UE
U
VcV
EVV•_
C1w
(DI
•b
(D
V•UtaV0
VVd—VE0U0m
'0'-•1E-U0 •V 1-4U0VO•- $Vd2C0Uo0D V
E
V0Ec0-0E(ID"U0- N0•<EdVVV0ZUC-d
V-
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 137/147
-<
L
I
t
G05
l
1--U NuU•vou-N!BO[1
L
Iu0
-
E2z.a
&
c51il - i 5t; u 00-0—I0.
IVFH
-
.-00J0<U
v7
5
-
UuU mr0uU0vO0V00_
r4 Z
E
i
.0
UUr00i -001
-F-
I
C
c
t
UZ<-
0U
I
t
o0
-0Q0
2C0•cu
a0
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 138/147
U
r
o
m
E
00
'O99NVc
VVOVV.V-
'.0050-UQUc0S
'I
_0
00a.V00VIV000U
E0u -;
;sf
.9 200:500
k
00VVV0VOU
0" "000V 0V0V 9E
D
-Um
!
U- U
IZI
— ,—0UU0V5'
Q
V9Ro
0Cc:CL
o
VQS ED
VS
3U
VcOC I
1nUoI .0U90Eo50
00VU000
9VU2o0oSEV0O0VV •0.0O•-DT-?0U00U0"2U LI oZ2995SC9
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 139/147
S
-i%UUJh1vOI- r
-EC
0
'
1u
-b
—J=o
o
i!4H- ---> -L5
C E
ob
NUCZZUU
UIV-O:1C
H!- hUW
tHNzZ-u
l1
;CC°
lz
-
:!0_EOS
__o
S
-C Jc-1U WI1:UU-I
•
34b
C9U
c
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 140/147
U-
u
'
o_
-
E
-0--0)UV.--
V•.0_CFQIL7IU
-a4i1cI!!IC-oZ2
0
!!f-1 V
o
-oVS
0-0 u V.0 o
Iu05
CC
-
zo
O0.0V
V
0-;E
-
CIO
0C5_CENV0VV
U
EI4
-
VS
0V
1
7
,
U
0
bb U 5
0.0
0H IU!!1 !J!4
r4
7
—
h —
Ir4uC
L
I
zS-U
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 141/147
l
f
fuuE 00
'FU
0v,i11 m0
.
0-o—o-000 N'&LN_A;t-J,50_
!4
06 6
V0
-000
-V
.V
NO
oZofv0i -NV0oVOo0
0 o-
iE
LD
V0—
V-
-Q
0Jr,H0 ii Z1 C^ u g - -,:; CF
z z,
i1I!
0
0V
iV !hU -RiJ1I 11
0
.0O0V
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 142/147
VO0'ZI11!!FifI
d
bj
c
d
-
0
:-UEOoONz
o2O
c
z
4z,
II10
ç0Co -1U-fiI.-_-44, uVOCVUU-o-
u
—
0C0014 1oUVCoV©0V0
!1t1Fa7
o
V
---
°E
•
112HIUUI1UVOaVrq
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 143/147
Id0
VV
VVVc =1 u-
CCVV
ECV0
VCCVV
V
VC
f- 0
VC
o u0n' E-aS1C
0C0VVVVVUu.0V_VVVVVV!!--- CV.8_o
'E0.V
V
o E
o-d!--1!JDCQCVVVIDC0lz
C,
CEVCVt U Llz
VCCC0
-F
-V
V
01
0V
U
VC
V
V V0VV0VVV VVc0
CU
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 144/147
-0E
HC_
-
a-e
-
1 DI - 0°-
',fU-UUU00000U9--9r_m ' -90_
01C 00Cuu0--o9<ooU00U.ou9H HV
0
00
-0o-i
izf!Vm-<VV0a 9
0•00,v9V0 'd9Uu9UHo
uo$
UU•E9i 000OV9O U0VQo0a
-am1
0V
_O9u=oVZtE
20.5c d9-V0090SSV0 UVU0QV
-
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 145/147
—
c—CCN•C-b
CUU51-U
-
.RO
•0v
C
i'1nI
C
C6C
IOE
UU
C0u2 IhI-f h
CD U0n-IU/DQUC-C
Uu•b•_U00
cCc 0
UT
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 146/147
8/3/2019 O estruturalismo e a miséria da razão - Carlos Nelson Coutinho
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/o-estruturalismo-e-a-miseria-da-razao-carlos-nelson-coutinho 147/147
Urna análise humanista de nossa época coloca a nu a mutilacão
da praxis pela rnanipulação, a necessária irracionalidade de urna
vida voltada para o consurno supérfluo e hurnanamente insensa-
to. Urna visao concretarnente historicista revela as possibilidades
de rnudanca e transforrnaçao latentes, embora dissirnuladas pelas
aparéncias fetichizadas que se pretendern irnutáveis. A dialética,
finalmente, denunciaria a contradicao entre urn mundo aparen-
ternente "organizado" (corn os rneios de urna razão burocrática)
e a irracionalidade objetiva do conjunto da sociedade, superan-
do assirn os Iirnites de urna "razâo" que se concentra nas regras,
nos rneios, enquanto abandona corno incognoscIvel o conteñdo
e a finalidade da vida e da sociedade.
Carlos N elson Coutinho