nussbaum on adaptive prefs

Economics and Philosophyhttp://journals.cambridge.org/EAP

Additional services for Economics and Philosophy:

Email alerts: Click hereSubscriptions: Click hereCommercial reprints: Click hereTerms of use : Click here

Symposium on Amartya Sen's philosophy: 5 Adaptive preferences and women's options

Martha C. Nussbaum

Economics and Philosophy / Volume 17 / Issue 01 / April 2001, pp 67 - 88DOI: 10.1017/S0266267101000153, Published online: 17 May 2001

Link to this article: http://journals.cambridge.org/abstract_S0266267101000153

How to cite this article:

Martha C. Nussbaum (2001). Symposium on Amartya Sen's philosophy: 5 Adaptive preferences and women's options. Economics and Philosophy, 17, pp 67-88 doi:10.1017/S0266267101000153

Request Permissions : Click here

Downloaded from http://journals.cambridge.org/EAP, IP address: 84.84.137.105 on 28 Sep 2012

http://journals.cambridge.org Downloaded: 28 Sep 2012 IP address: 84.84.137.105

!"#$%!&'# %( )#)*+") !,(-!$.&/%!%$."0 1)2)$+&3, $*,4,*,(5,! )(26%#,(-! %$+&%(!

!"#$%" &' ()**+")!

!"#$%&'#() *+ ,-#./0* 1/2 3.-**4

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

D"#4 )# 5*B# C,$#%+? *4$ )%5#4 .,B# 0+ )*'&" '"#5? )# -#' &%4<,$#4&#'% '(/ *4$ 5*B# &"*4-#+: D"#4 )# +## )%5#4 .,B# 0+ )"% "*C# $%4#

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

!(,C*4$(05? U#(*.*? (#+1#&',C#./9 A 5#' *4$ '*.B#$ ),'" '"#5 $0(,4- * <,#.$ '(,1: U%B,.* ,+* <(,#4$ %< R*+*4',6+ )"% "#.1+ "#( (#1%(' &*+#+ %< $%5#+',& C,%.#4&# '% '"# 1%.,&#: !"#,(+'%(,#+ *(# '%.$ 5%(# <0../ ,4 !(*? A4'(%$0&',%4:

,-

98"%"#485 &%' :14,"5"-1;? !" ENVVIL WXYZZ M%1/(,-"'! M*52(,$-# [4,C#(+,'/ \(#++

http://journals.cambridge.org


+%5#'",4- 2(*C# *4$ 4#)? '"#4 )# -#' '"# &%4<,$#4&# '"*' )# &*4 .#*(4+%5#'",4- 4#) '%%: D"#4 1%%( )%5#4 +## %'"#( 1%%( )%5#4 *+ "#*.'")%(B#(+ %4 '"# C,$#%? '"#/ +*/? GA &*4 *.+% .#*(4 *2%0' "#*.'" *4$ "#.1 +%.C#'"#+# 1(%2.#5+ ,4 5/ 4#,-"2%("%%$6: D"#4 %'"#( +#.<>#51.%/#$ )%5#4+## 5#? * C#-#'*2.# C#4$%(? 5*B,4- '"#+# <,.5+? '"#/ *.+% "*C# '"#&%4<,$#4&# '"*' '"#/ &*4 $% '",4-+ )",&" *' <,(+' +##5 ,51%++,2.#: EH,.*]*'*4,*? Q^DO EQ#.<>^51.%/#$ D%5#46+ _(-*4,`*',%4L? O"5#$*2*$?IJJNL:

.' /#010#0(&0 "(2 $%0 34425 $64 )(*"$7*1"&$4#8 09$#0!0*

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a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b0' '"# 4%',%4 %< &"%,&# *4$1(*&',&*. (#*+%4 0+#$ ,4 '"# .,+' ,+ * 4%(5*',C# 4%',%4? #51"*+,`,4- '"#&(,',&*. *&',C,'/ %< (#*+%4 ,4 * )*/ '"*' $%#+ 4%' (#<.#&' '"# *&'0*. 0+# %<(#*+%4 ,4 5*4/ .,C#+:

!",4B %< R*+*4', *4$ S*/*55*: R*+*4', +'*/#$ <%( /#*(+ ,4 *4*20+,C# 5*((,*-#: ^C#4'0*../ +"# $,$ .#*C#? *4$ 2/ 4%) +"# "*+ C#(/<,(5 C,#)+ *2%0' '"# ,51%('*4&# %< "#( 2%$,./ ,4'#-(,'/c ,4$##$? +"# *4$U%B,.* +1#4$ * .%' %< '"#,( ',5# "#.1,4- %'"#( 2*''#(#$ )%5#4 (#1%(''"#,( &*+#+ '% '"# 1%.,&# *4$ -%*$,4- '"# 1%.,&# '% $% +%5#'",4- *2%0''"# 1(%2.#5: b0' '"#(# )*+ * ',5# )"#4 R*+*4', $,$ 4%' '",4B '",+ )*/ Y#+1#&,*../ 2#<%(# "#( "0+2*4$6+ C*+#&'%5/? )"#4 +"# '"%0-"' +"# 5,-"'+',.. "*C# &",.$(#4: H,B# 5*4/ )%5#4? +"# +##5+ '% "*C# '"%0-"' '"*'*20+# )*+ 1*,4<0. *4$ 2*$? 20'? +',..? * 1*(' %< )%5#46+ .%' ,4 .,<#? @0+'+%5#'",4- )%5#4 "*C# '% 10' 01 ),'" *+ 1*(' %< 2#,4- * )%5*4

,: #)*+.) 57 ('!!8)'#



$#1#4$#4' %4 5#4? *4$ #4'*,.#$ 2/ "*C,4- .#<' "#( %)4 <*5,./ '% 5%C#,4'% * "0+2*4$6+ "%5#: !"# ,$#* '"*' ,' )*+ * C,%.*',%4 %< (,-"'+? %< .*)?%< @0+',&#? *4$ '"*' 51$ 1$75$,< "*$ (,-"'+ '"*' )#(# 2#,4- C,%.*'#$ 2/ ",+&%4$0&' Y +"# $,$ 4%' "*C# '"#+# ,$#*+ *' '"*' ',5#? *4$ 5*4/ 5*4/)%5#4 *.. %C#( '"# )%(.$ +',.. $% 4%' "*C# '"#5: a/ 04,C#(+*.,+'*11(%*&" +##5+ '% #4'*,. '"*' '"#(# ,+ +%5#'",4- )(%4- ),'" '"#1(#<#(#4&# E,< '"*' ,+ )"*' )# +"%0.$ &*.. ,'L '% 10' 01 ),'" *20+#? '"*' ,'@0+' +"%0.$ 4%' "*C# '"# +*5# (%.# ,4 +%&,*. 1%.,&/ *+ '"# 1(#<#(#4&# '%1(%'#&' *4$ $#<#4$ %4#6+ 2%$,./ ,4'#-(,'/: A' *.+% #4'*,.+ '"*' '"#(# ,++%5#'",4- )(%4- ),'" 4%' +##,4- %4#+#.< ,4 * &#('*,4 )*/? *+ * 2#*(#( %<(,-"'+ *4$ * &,',`#4 )"%+# $,-4,'/ *4$ )%('" *(# #70*. '% '"*' %< %'"#(+:

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

d,4*../? .#' 5# ,4'(%$0&# %4# <0('"#( #P*51.#? '% +"%) '"# )*/#4'(#4&"#$ 1(#<#(#4&#+ &*4 &.*+" ),'" 04,C#(+*. 4%(5+ #C#4 *' '"# .#C#.%< 2*+,& 40'(,',%4 *4$ "#*.'": A4 '"# +#5,>*(,$ *(#* %0'+,$# a*"*202>4*-*(? O4$"(* \(*$#+"? A '*.B#$ ),'" )%5#4 )"% )#(# +#C#(#./5*.4%0(,+"#$? *4$ )"%+# C,..*-# "*$ 4% (#.,*2.# &.#*4 )*'#( +011./:b#<%(# '"# *((,C*. %< * -%C#(45#4' &%4+&,%0+4#++>(*,+,4- 1(%-(*5? '"#+#)%5#4 *11*(#4'./ "*$ 4% <##.,4- %< *4-#( %( 1(%'#+' *2%0' '"#,( 1"/+,&*.+,'0*',%4: !"#/ B4#) 4% %'"#( )*/: !"#/ $,$ 4%' &%4+,$#( '"#,(&%4$,',%4+ 04"#*.'"/ %( 04+*4,'*(/? *4$ '"#/ $,$ 4%' &%4+,$#( '"#5>+#.C#+ '% 2# 5*.4%0(,+"#$: e%) '"#,( .#C#. %< $,+&%4'#4' "*+ -%4# )*/01c '"#/ 1(%'#+' '% '"# .%&*. -%C#(45#4'? *+B,4- <%( &.#*4 )*'#(? <%(#.#&'(,&,'/? <%( * "#*.'" C,+,'%(: !"#/ &%C#( '"#,( <%%$ +011.,#+ <(%5 <.,#+?'"#/ )*+" '"#,( 2%$,#+ 5%(# %<'#4: O+B#$ )"*' )*+ '"# 2,--#+' &"*4-#'"*' '"# -%C#(45#4' 1(%-(*5 "*$ 2(%0-"' '% '"#,( .,C#+? '"#/ ,55#$,>*'#./ +*,$? *+ ,< ,4 &"%(0+? GD# *(# &.#*4#( 4%)6: !"# &%4+&,%0+4#++>(*,+,4- 1(%-(*5 "*+ &.#*(./ &"*..#4-#$ #4'(#4&"#$ 1(#<#(#4&#+ *4$+*',+<*&',%4+? '*B,4- * 4%(5*',C# *11(%*&" 2*+#$ %4 *4 ,$#* %< -%%$"05*4 <04&',%4,4-:

565789:; 7<;=;<;>,;3 5>6 ?@A;>B3 @789@>3 ,;



d#5,4,+'+ )"% &"*..#4-# #4'(#4&"#$ +*',+<*&',%4+ *(# <(#70#4'./&"*(-#$ ),'" 2#,4- '%'*.,'*(,*4 *4$ *4',>$#5%&(*',& <%( @0+' '",+ )*/ %<1(%&##$,4-: D"% *(# '"#/ '% '#.. (#*. )%5#4 )"*' ,+ -%%$ <%( '"#5? %( '%5*(&" ,4'% *4 *(#* +"*1#$ 2/ '(*$,',%4 *4$ &0+'%5 ),'" 04,C#(+*.+'*4$*($+ %< )"*' %4# +"%0.$ $#5*4$ *4$ )"*' %4# +"%0.$ $#+,(#f

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

A4 '"# $#2*'# *2%0' "%) 1(#<#(#4&#+ +"%0.$ <,-0(# ,4 +%&,*. &"%,&#?)# &*4 ,$#4',</ ')% #P'(#5# 1%+,',%4+? 2#')##4 )",&" A +"*.. +,'0*'# 5/%)4: !"# <,(+' 1%+,',%4 &*4 2# &*..#$ 5)3=$8.4+$ >$,<&745#: !",+ 1%+,',%4"%.$+ '"*' *.. #P,+',4- 1(#<#(#4&#+ *(# %4 * 1*( <%( 1%.,',&*. 10(1%+#+? *4$'"*' +%&,*. &"%,&# +"%0.$ 2# 2*+#$ %4 +%5# +%(' %< *--(#-*',%4 %< *.. %<'"#5: !"# +#&%4$ 1%+,',%4 &*4 2# &*..#$ -,&."%45#:I O&&%($,4- '% '",+C,#)? '"# <*&' '"*' 1#%1.# $#+,(# %( 1(#<#( +%5#'",4- ,+ 2*+,&*../ 4%'(#.#C*4'? -,C#4 %0( B4%).#$-# %< "%) 04(#.,*2.# $#+,(#+ *4$ 1(#<#(#4&#+*(# *+ * -0,$# '% )"*' ,+ (#*../ @0+' *4$ -%%$: O&'0*. $#+,(# *4$ &"%,&#1.*/ 4% (%.# *' *.. ,4 @0+',</,4- +%5#'",4- *+ -%%$: D"*' )# 4##$ '% $% ,+'% 1(%C,$# *4 *(-05#4' <%( '"# %2@#&',C# C*.0# %< '"# (#.#C*4' +'*'# %<*<<*,(+ '"*' ,+ ,4$#1#4$#4' %< '"# <*&' '"*' 1#%1.# $#+,(# %( 1(#<#( ,'9 %4&#)# "*C# +0&" *4 *(-05#4'? )# *(# @0+',<,#$ ,4 5*B,4- #C#4 (*$,&*.$#1*('0(#+ <(%5 1#%1.#6+ *&'0*. )*4'+:

b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b0'2%'" &%4'*,4 %2C,%0+ 1(%2.#5+: ^52(*&#$ *+ * 4%(5*',C# 1%+,',%4?+02@#&',C# )#.<*(,+5 5*B#+ ,' ,51%++,2.# '% &%4$0&' * (*$,&*. &(,',70# %<

I !",+ 5*/ %( 5*/ 4%' 2# * 1%+,',%4 "#.$ 2/ \.*'%:

-< #)*+.) 57 ('!!8)'#



04@0+' ,4+','0',%4+9 ,' <%(&#+ 0+ '% +*/? <%( #P*51.#? '"*' 2#&*0+# S*/*55*"*+ *&&#1'#$ *4 04@0+' )*-# +'(0&'0(# *+ '"# )*/ '",4-+ 50+' 2#? '"*' ,+'"# )*/ '"#/ +"%0.$ (#5*,4: !",+ .,5,'*',%4 ,+ #+1#&,*../ -(*C# )"#4 )#*(# ,4 '"# 1(%&#++ %< +#.#&',4- 2*+,& 1%.,',&*. 1(,4&,1.#+ '"*' &*4 2##52%$,#$ ,4 &%4+','0',%4*. -0*(*4'##+: \.*'%4,+5? %4 '"# %'"#( "*4$?+##5+ '%% $,+$*,4<0. %< '"# ),+$%5 #52%$,#$ ,4 1#%1.#6+ *&'0*.#P1#(,#4&#c ,' +##5+ '% &*(# '%% .,''.# *2%0' )"*' S*/*55* *4$ R*+*4','",4B *2%0' &"*4-#+ ,4 '"#,( .,C#+: O4/ C,*2.# 5%$#(4 1%+,',%4? ,' +##5+?50+' '(/ '% 1(#+#(C# '"# ,51%('*4' C*.0#+ &%4'*,4#$ ,4 #*&" %< '"#+# ')%#P'(#5#+? )",.# *C%,$,4- '"#,( $#<#&'+:

A4 %($#( '% +#*(&" <%( *4 *11(%1(,*'# G5#*46 2#')##4 '"#+# #P'(#5#+?,' ),.. 2# 0+#<0. '% .%%B? <,(+'? *' )"/ 0',.,'*(,*4 #&%4%5,+'+ "*C# (#@#&'#$10(# +02@#&',C# )#.<*(,+5? *4$ "%) '"#/ "*C# '(,#$ '% (#<0(2,+" '"#)#.<*(,+' C,#): e#P'? A +"*.. .%%B *' +%5# (#*+%4+ )# 5,-"' "*C# <%(&%4&.0$,4- '"*' '"# 1(%2.#5 %< 1(#<#(#4&#>$#<%(5*',%4 (#70,(#+ 0+ '%$#1*(' *.'%-#'"#( <(%5 '"# 0',.,'*(,*4 <(*5#)%(B: d,4*../? A +"*.. +"%)"%) 5/ %)4 C,#) %< '"# &#4'(*. &*1*2,.,',#+ *$$(#++#+ '"#+# ,++0#+?*(-0,4- '"*' *' '"# .#C#. %< '"# &#4'(*. &*1*2,.,',#+ '"#(# ,+ &%4+,$#(*2.#&%4C#(-#4&# 2#')##4 * G+02+'*4',C# -%%$6 *11(%*&" '% +%&,*. -%%$+ *4$*4 G,4<%(5#$ $#+,(#6 *11(%*&":N

=' 60>1"#7*!5 $%0 7($0#("> &#7$7?)0g

O.'"%0-" +02@#&',C# )#.<*(,+5 ,+ &%55%4 ,4 2(,#< -#+'0(#+ '%)*($ *4%(5*',C# *11(%*&" ,4 #&%4%5,&+? C#(/ <#) 0',.,'*(,*4 #&%4%5,+'+ "*C#2##4 ),..,4- '% 2# '"%(%0-"-%,4- +02@#&',C# )#.<*(,+'+? %4&# '"#/&%4+,$#( 4%(5*',C# ,++0#+ "#*$ %4 *4$ #P'#4+,C#./: a,.'%4 d(,#$5*4EIJZK? 1: NIVL 1(%2*2./ )*+ '"# (#*. *(',&.#c "# &.#*(./ $,$ "%.$ '"*'&%4&#(4,4- $,<<#(#4&#+ %< C*.0# G5#4 &*4 0.',5*'#./ %4./ <,-"'6? *4$ '"*'?,4 &%4+#70#4&#? '"#(# )*+ 4%)"#(# <%( 4%(5*',C# '"#%(/ '% -% 2#/%4$+02@#&',C# )#.<*(,+5: [+0*../? "%)#C#(? #&%4%5,+'+ "*C# (#&%-4,`#$ '"*',' ,+ ,51.*0+,2.# '% '(#*' *.. #P,+',4- 1(#<#(#4&#+ *+ %4 * 1*( <%( 4%(5*',C#10(1%+#+? *4$ "*C# (#&%55#4$#$ *' .#*+' +%5# ),44%),4- %( &%(>(#&',4-:

!"# 5%+' %2C,%0+ +0&" &%((#&',%4 ,4C%.C#+ <*.+# 2#.,#< *4$ .*&B %<,4<%(5*',%4: ^C#4 ;05#? )"% ,4 -#4#(*. '"%0-"' '"*' 1*++,%4+ *4$

N d%( '"#+# '#(5+? +## !"%5*+ Q&*4.%4 EIJJg? 11: NVIYXL: Q&*4.%4 *&'0*../ 0+#+ '"# '#(5G+02+'*4',C# .,+'6? 20' *.+% 4%'#+ '"*' '"# '#(5 ,+ 1#(,.%0+? +0--#+',4- '"*' )# *(# '*.B,4-*2%0' * .*04$(/ .,+' %< 04(#.*'#$ ,'#5+? (*'"#( '"*4 * &%"#(#4' C,#):

g A %5,' *' '",+ 1%,4' * 1(#.,5,4*(/ +#&',%4 ,4 )",&" A $,++#&' '"# &%4&#1' %< G1(#<#(#4&#6'/1,&*../ 0+#$ ,4 #&%4%5,& $,+&0++,%4+? 1%,4',4- %0' '"*' ,' ,+ 2%'" &%4'#+'#$ *4$ 70,'#C*-0#9 '"# (#.#C*4' *(-05#4'+ &*4 2# <%04$ ,4 !(* M"*1'#( N *4$ *' -(#*'#( .#4-'" ,4e0++2*05 EIJJX? 11: IIJXYNIKL:

565789:; 7<;=;<;>,;3 5>6 ?@A;>B3 @789@>3 -.



$#+,(#+ &%0.$ 4%' 2# &%"#(#4'./ $##5#$ G04(#*+%4*2.#6? 5*$# #P&#1',%4+<%( &*+#+ ,4 )",&" %4# 5,+'*B#4./ 2#.,#C#+ *4 %2@#&' '% #P,+' '"*' $%#+ 4%'#P,+'? %( "%.$+ <*.+# 2#.,#<+ *2%0' *11(%1(,*'# 5#*4+ '% <0('"#( #4$+:K b0'5%+' 0',.,'*(,*4 <%..%)#(+ %< ;05# -% +%5#)"*' <0('"#( '"*4 "# $,$ ,4'"# (#&%-4,',%4 %< &%-4,',C# #((%(: !% '*B# * (#1(#+#4'*',C# #P*51.#?M"(,+'%1"#( b.,++ EIJJg? 11: KIZYIJL? )",.# $#<#4$,4- +02@#&',C# )#.><*(,+5 ,4 * C#(/ +'(%4- <%(5 ,4 &%44#&',%4 ),'" '"# 5#*+0(#5#4' %<70*.,'/ %< .,<# ,4 $#C#.%1,4- &%04'(,#+? (#&%-4,`#+ '"# 4##$ '% &%((#&' <%(,4*$#70*'# %( <*.+# ,4<%(5*',%4c G!"# ,4"*2,'*4'+ %< * 1%%( &%04'(/ <%(#P*51.#? 5*/ 4%' (#*.,`# "%) 04"#*.'"/ '"#/ *(#? *4$ '"# &%4+#70#4&#+%< '"*' ,.. "#*.'"? )"#(#*+ *4 #P1#(' ),.. B4%)6: O4%'"#( &*+# ,4 )",&"b.,++ )%0.$ *$5,' #P1#(' &%((#&',%4+ %< #P,+',4- C,#)+ ,+ '"# &*+# )"#(#)# 4##$ * -.%2*. %C#(C,#) *4$ ,4$,C,$0*.+ *(# 04*2.# '% 1(%C,$# '",+:O-*,4? "%.$+ b.,++ EIJJg? 1: KIJL? '",+ &%((#&',%4 ,+ *&&#1'*2.# 2#&*0+# ,',4C%.C#+ G,51#(<#&' C,+,%46 %4 '"# 1*(' %< '"# ,4$,C,$0*.: D# &*4 &%((#&''"# ,4$,C,$0*.6+ C,+,%4 Y -,C# "#( #/#-.*++#+? +% '% +1#*B Y ),'"%0' .%+,4-"%.$ %< G'"# <04$*5#4'*. 1%,4' '"*' 5*4? ,< 4%' '"# 5#*+0(# %< *.. '",4-+?,+ *' .#*+' '"# 5#*+0(# %< '"# +'*4$*($ %< .,C,4-6: b.,++ $%#+ 4%' $,+&0++'"# -(%04$,4- %< 2*+,& 1%.,',&*. 1(,4&,1.#+ '"*' 04$#(.,# &%4+','0',%4*.-0*(*4'##+? +% ,' ,+ 1%++,2.# '"*' "# )%0.$ 4%' #4$%(+# * 1(#<#(#4&#>2*+#$ C,#) ,4 '"*' $%5*,49 %4 '"# %'"#( "*4$? ",+ `#*.%0+ $#<#4+# %<1(#<#(#4&#+ ,4 *.. *(#*+ %< "05*4 .,<# 70*.,'/ -,C#+ 4% +0--#+',%4 '"*' "#+##+ *4/ *(#* ,4 )",&" (#.,*4&# %4 1(#<#(#4&#+ ),.. 1(%C# 1(%2.#5*',&:

O 50&" 5%(# *52,',%0+ +#' %< &%((#&',%4+ '% #P,+',4- 1(#<#(#4&#+)*+ 1(%1%+#$ 2/ S%"4 ;*(+*4/, EIJZN? 11: gJYWNL? +',.. *11*(#4'./ ),'",4'"# -#4#(*. <(*5#)%(B %< +02@#&',C# )#.<*(,+' '"#%(/: ;*(+*4/, EIJZN?1: hhL 2#-,4+ 2/ *44%04&,4- G'"# ,51%('*4' 1",.%+%1",&*. 1(,4&,1.# %<-7$<$7$%8$ &)."%"#;: b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hhLL _4 '"# %'"#( "*4$?;*(+*4/, (#&%-4,`#+ '"*' 1#%1.#6+ 1(#<#(#4&#+ *(# <(#70#4'./ G,((*',%4*.6:;# 2#.,#C#+ '"*' G*4/ +#4+,2.# #'",&*. '"#%(/6 50+' (#&%-4,`# '",+ <*&': GA')%0.$ 2# *2+0($ '% *++#(' '"*' )# "*C# '"# +*5# 5%(*. %2.,-*',%4 '%"#.1 %'"#( 1#%1.# ,4 +*',+</,4- '"#,( 0''#(./ 04(#*+%4*2.# )*4'+ *+ )#"*C# '% "#.1 '"#5 ,4 +*',+</,4- '"#,( C#(/ (#*+%4*2.# $#+,(#+6 E1: hhL: b0'

K ;05#? 6 07$&.45$ "< ()#&% ?&.)7$? bB: AA? \': AAA? Q#&: g? &%4&.0$,4- ),'" '"# <*5%0+@0$-#5#4' '"*' GA' ,+ 4%' &%4'(*(/ '% (#*+%4 '% 1(#<#( '"# $#+'(0&',%4 %< '"# )"%.# )%(.$ '%'"# +&(*'&",4- %< 5/ <,4-#(6:

-= #)*+.) 57 ('!!8)'#



)"*' &%4'#4' &*4 )# -,C# '% '",+ $,+',4&',%4? &%51*',2./ ),'" 5*,4>'*,4,4- '"# )#.<*(,+' 1(,4&,1.#f O 4%(5*',C# "#$%4,+'? "# %2+#(C#+? &%0.$#*+,./ 5*B# '"# (#.#C*4' $,+',4&',%4c * (*',%4*. )*4' ),.. 2# * )*4' <%(+%5#'",4- '"*' (#*../ $%#+ 1(%$0&# 1.#*+0(#? *4$ *4 ,((*',%4*. )*4' ),..2# <%( +%5#'",4- '"*' $%#+ 4%' (#*../ 1(%$0&# 1.#*+0(#: b0' ,< )# $% 4%'*&&#1' '"*' +%(' %< $#<,4,'# 4%(5*',C# '"#%(/ E*4$ ;*(+*4/, "*+ *.(#*$/(#@#&'#$ ,'? *11*(#4'./ ,4 <*C%( %< * '"#%(/ '"*' $#(,C#+ 4%(5*',C,'/ <(%51(#<#(#4&#+ '"#5+#.C#+L? '"#4 )"*' *(# )# '% +*/f

D# 50+' +*/? ;*(+*4/, &%4&.0$#+? '"*' 1#%1.#6+ 5*4,<#+' 1(#<#(#4&#+*(# <(#70#4'./ *' %$$+ ),'" '"#,( G'(0# 1(#<#(#4&#+6: O 1#(+%46+ (*',%4*.)*4'+ *(# '"%+# '"*' *(# &%4+,+'#4' ),'" ",+ '(0# 1(#<#(#4&#+? *4$ '"#,((*',%4*. *(# '"%+# '"*' *(# 4%': !"# $,+',4&',%4 2#')##4 '"# 5*4,<#+'*4$ '"# '(0# ,+ $#<,4#$ *+ <%..%)+c

3O 1#(+%46+8 5*4,<#+' 1(#<#(#4&#+ *(# ",+ *&'0*. 1(#<#(#4&#+ *+ 5*4,<#+'#$2/ ",+ %2+#(C#$ 2#"*C,%0(? ,4&.0$,4- 1(#<#(#4&#+ 1%++,2./ 2*+#$ %4#((%4#%0+ <*&'0*. 2#.,#<+? %( %4 &*(#.#++ (*',%4*. &"%,&#: A4 &%4'(*+'? *1#(+%46+ '(0# 1(#<#(#4&#+ *(# '"# 1(#<#(#4&#+ "# >"),' "*C# ,< "# "*$ *.. '"#(#.#C*4' <*&'0*. ,4<%(5*',%4? *.)*/+ (#*+%4#$ ),'" '"# -(#*'#+' 1%++,2.#&*(#? *4$ )#(# ,4 * +'*'# %< 5,4$ 5%+' &%4$0&,C# '% (*',%4*. &"%,&#: EIJZN?1: hhL

Q%&,*. 0',.,'/? "# '"#4 &%4&.0$#+? +"%0.$ 2# $#<,4#$ ,4 '#(5+ %< '"# '(0#?(*'"#( '"*4 '"# 5*4,<#+'? 1(#<#(#4&#+ %< ,4$,C,$0*.+? *4$ '"# 5*P,5,`*>',%4 %< +%&,*. 0',.,'/ ,+ '"# *11(%1(,*'# +%&,*. -%*.: ;*(+*4/, 10'+ '",+ ,$#*<%()*($ *+ * 1#(<#&'./ -#4#(*. '"#%(/ %< +%&,*. &"%,&#? #+1#&,*../ ,4 '"#*(#* %< <04$*5#4'*. 1(,4&,1.#+c "# &"*(*&'#(,`#+ ",+ 1(#<#(#4&#>2*+#$#'",&*. '"#%(/ *+ *4 *.'#(4*',C# '% F*).+6+ '"#%(/ %< @0+',&#:h

!% &%5# 01 ),'" +%5#'",4- '"*' +##5+ #C#4 1(,5* <*&,# +*',+<*&'%(/?4%',&#? ;*(+*4/, "*+ "*$ '% *$$ 4%' %4./ '"# 0+0*. &%((#&',%4+ '% 2#.,#<*4$ ,4<%(5*',%4? 20' *.+% '"# +'(%4-./ 4%(5*',C# 1(%&#$0(*. ,$#* %<&*(#<0. (#*+%4,4- *4$ '"# G+'*'# %< 5,4$ 5%+' &%4$0&,C# '% (*',%4*.&"%,&#6: ;# $%#+ 4%' +1#.. %0' '",+ .*+' ,4-(#$,#4' <0('"#(? 20' )"#4 )#'",4B %< %0( &*+#+ )# &*4 #*+,./ +1%' +%5# 1#%1.# )"% *(# %". ,4 * +'*'#%< 5,4$ '"*' +##5+ &%4$0&,C# '% (*',%4*. &"%,&#c R*+*4',? ,4',5,$*'#$ 2/"#( "0+2*4$6+ 1"/+,&*. *20+# *4$ '#((,<,#$ *2%0' "#( +0(C,C*. 1(%+1#&'++"%0.$ +"# .#*C# ",59 S*/*55*? "*2,'0*'#$ '% '",4B,4- '"*' 04#70*.&%4'(%. %C#( "%0+#"%.$ ,4&%5# ,+ @0+' )%5#46+ .%'9 !*-%(#6+ &"*(*&'#(a(,4*. ,4 5/ #1,-(*1"? 0+#$ '% '",4B,4- %< "#(+#.< *+ %< .%) )%('":!"%+# &%4$,',%4+ &#('*,4./ $% 4%' +'(,B# 0+ *+ &%4$0&,C# '% (*',%4*.&"%,&#? *4$ '"*' ,+ @0+' '"# 1%,4' !*-%(#6+ &"*(*&'#( ,+ 5*B,4-? *+ +"##P1.*,4+ '% "#( "0+2*4$ "%) +"# "*+ <,4*../ $#&,$#$ '% .#*C# ",5: d%("#(? *$#70*'# &"%,&#>5*B,4- (#70,(#$? <,(+' %< *..? '"(%),4- %<< '"#

h ;*(+*4/, EIJZN? 11: KVYKIL:

565789:; 7<;=;<;>,;3 5>6 ?@A;>B3 @789@>3 -@



+.052#(%0+ +'*'# ,4$0&#$ 2/ /#*(+ %< &%4'#51' *4$ 4#-.#&': b0' ,< )#)#(# '% 10' *2+#4&# %< '(*$,',%4*. ",#(*(&"/? *2+#4&# %< <#*(? *4$ * +#4+#%< %4#6+ )%('" *4$ $,-4,'/ ,4'% '"# (*',%4*. &"%,&# 1(%&#++? )# )%0.$ 2#5%C,4- C#(/ <*( ,4$##$ <(%5 * +'*4$*($ )#.<*(,+' *11(%*&": A +"*..+0--#+' .*'#( '"*' '"#+# *$$,',%4+ (#*../ $% "#.1 0+ &%4+'(0&' *4,4<%(5#$>$#+,(# *11(%*&" '"*' ,+ %< +%5# "#0(,+',& C*.0#9 20' ,' ,+&#('*,4./ 70,'# 04&.#*( )"#'"#( ;*(+*4/, 5#*4+ '% '*B# 0+ +% <*( <(%5",+ )#.<*(,+' +'*(',4- 1%,4':

O-*,4? &%4+,$#( '"# )%5#4 %< Q^DO ,4 5/ +#&%4$ #1,-(*1"? )"%+## C,$#%+ %< )%5#4 $%,4- $*(,4- 4#) '",4-+ *4$ '"#(#2/ -#'&%4<,$#4&# '"*' '"#/ &*4 $% '"#+# '",4-+ '%%: e%) &.#*(./ ,' ,+ H,.*]*'*4,*6+ 1%,4' '"*' '"# #P1#(,#4&# %< )*'&",4- '"# C,$#%+ "#.1+ '"#+#)%5#4 5*B# *$#70*'# &"%,&#+ <%( '"#,( <0'0(# Y 4%' %4./ 2/ -,C,4- '"#54#) ,4<%(5*',%4 20' 2/ #4"*4&,4- '"#,( +#4+# %< '"#,( 1%++,2,.,',#+ *4$'"#,( )%('": b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

;*(+*4/, 5*B#+ %4# <0('"#( &%((#&',%4 '% )#.<*(,+5 '"*' '*B#+ ",55%(# &.#*(./ *)*/ <(%5 )#.<*(,+5: !",+ ,+? '"*' +%5# 1#%1.#6+ G'(0#61(#<#(#4&#+ ),.. "*C# '% 2# #P&.0$#$ *.'%-#'"#( <(%5 '"# +%&,*.>0',.,'/<04&',%4c GA4 1*(',&0.*(? )# 50+' #P&.0$# *.. &.#*(./ *4',+%&,*. 1(#<#(>#4&#+? +0&" *+ +*$,+5? #4C/? (#+#4'5#4'? *4$ 5*.,&#6:W ;*(+*4/,6+@0+',<,&*',%4 <%( '",+ 5%C# ,+ <*+&,4*',4- <%( '"# )*/ ,4 )",&" ,' (#C#*.+5%(*. ,4'0,',%4+ %< * 4%4>)#.<*(,+' B,4$ '"*' .,# 2#4#*'" ",+ )#.<*(,+5:!"# G<04$*5#4'*. 2*+,+6 %< %0( 5%(*. &%55,'5#4'+ '% %'"#(+ ,40',.,'*(,*4,+5? "# +*/+? ,+ G* -#4#(*. -%%$),.. *4$ "05*4 +/51*'"/6:!"0+ G308',.,'*(,*4 #'",&+ 5*B#+ *.. %< 0+ 5#52#(+ %< '"# +*5# 5%(*.&%5504,'/6: b0' ,< '",+ ,$#* %< * 5%(*. &%5504,'/ ,+ )"*' .,#+ 2#",4$0',.,'*(,*4,+5 *4$ -,C#+ ,'+ 4%(5*',C# @0$-#5#4'+ '"#,( *11#*.? '"#4 )#50+' ,4'#(1(#' 0',.,'*(,*4,+5 '% $#5*4$ '"# #P&.0+,%4 %< 1*('+ %< (#*.1#%1.#6+ 1#(+%4*.,',#+ '"*' *(# "%+',.# '% '"# ,$#* %< * 5%(*. &%5504,'/cGO 1#(+%4 $,+1.*/,4- ,.. ),.. '%)*($ %'"#(+ $%#+ (#5*,4 * 5#52#( %< '",+&%5504,'/? 20' 4%' ),'" ",+ )"%.# 1#(+%4*.,'/: !"*' 1*(' %< ",+1#(+%4*.,'/ '"*' "*(2%0(+ '"#+# "%+',.# *4',+%&,*. <##.,4-+ 50+' 2#

W IJZN? 1: hW? '*B,4- ,++0# ),'" S: S: M: Q5*('6+ C#(+,%4 %< 4%(5*',C# 0',.,'*(,*4 '"#%(/:

-A #)*+.) 57 ('!!8)'#



#P&.0$#$ <(%5 5#52#(+",1? *4$ "*+ 4% &.*,5 <%( * "#*(,4- )"#4 ,'&%5#+ '% $#<,4,4- %0( &%4&#1' %< +%&,*. 0',.,'/6 EIJZN? 1: hWL:

D"*' ,+ <*+&,4*',4- "#(# ,+ '% +## '"*' *4 ,$#* %< 70,'# * U*4',*4 +%('.,#+? <%( ;*(+*4/,? *' '"# 2%''%5 %< '"# 0',.,'*(,*4 +%&,*. &"%,&# <04&',%4X Y*4$ ,' ,+ %4./ *+ (#-0.*'#$ 2/ '"*' ,$#*. C,+,%4 %< * &%5504,'/ %< #4$+'"*' '"# 0',.,'/ <04&',%4 &*4 1(%C# *&&#1'*2.# *+ * 2*+,+ %< +%&,*. 1%.,&/:;*(+*4/, $%#+ 4%' +*/ #4%0-" "#(# <%( 0+ '% *+&(,2# '% ",5 * C#(/$#<,4,'# #'",&*. &%4&#1',%4: b0' ",+ (#*. ,4'#(#+' ,4 1(#<#(#4&#+ '0(4+ %0''% 2#? *' 2%''%5? +%5#'",4- .,B# U*4',*4 ,4'#(#+' ,4 (#+1#&',4- 1#(+%4+?'"#,( #70*.,'/ *4$ '"#,( *0'%4%5/? *4$ '"*' "# ,+ 4%' (#*../ *C#(+# '% *4/$#1*('0(# <(%5 0',.,'*(,*4,+5 '"*' 1(#+#(C#+ '"#+# #++#4',*. U*4',*4<#*'0(#+: A4 +"%('? ",+ C,#) ,+ %4./ ,4 *11#*(*4&# * )#.<*(,+' C,#) *' *..:

_4# 5%(# %0'1%+' %4 '"# (%*$ *)*/ <(%5 )#.<*(,+5 +"%0.$ 4%) 2#&%4+,$#(#$? +,4&# ,' ,+ 1(%2*2./ '"# +5*('#+' *4$ 5%+' &%4+,+'#4' *''#51''% (#<0(2,+" '"# 1(#<#(#4&#>2*+#$ C,#) %< +%&,*. &"%,&#: !",+ ,+ F,&"*($b(*4$'6+ C,#) %< G&%-4,',C# 1+/&"%'"#(*1/6 ,4 6 01$"7; "< .1$ @""' &%' .1$A4B1.:Z b(*4$'? .,B# ;*(+*4/, E%( '"# *11*(#4' ;*(+*4/,L ,+? 0.',5*'#./? *)#.<*(,+': ;# "%.$+ '"*' '"# 0.',5*'# &(,'#(,%4 %< 2%'" 1#(+%4*. *4$ +%&,*.(*',%4*.,'/ 50+' 2# <%04$ ),'",4 #*&" 1#(+%4? *4$ 4%' 2/ ,51%(',4- *4/C*.0#+ #P'#(4*. '% '"*' 1#(+%46+ %)4 C*.0#+: b0' +,4&# b(*4$' (#&%-4,`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gL: !",+ 1(%&#++ ,+ '"#4 0+#$ '% $#<,4#(*',%4*.,'/ ,4 $#+,(#c GA +"*.. &*.. * 1#(+%46+ $#+,(#? *C#(+,%4? %( 1.#*+0(#GG(*',%4*.66 ,< ,' )%0.$ +0(C,C# %( 2# 1(%$0&#$ 2/ &*(#<0. GG&%-4,',C#1+/&"%'"#(*1/66 <%( '"*' 1#(+%4: A +"*.. &*.. * $#+,(# GG,((*',%4*.66 ,< ,'&*44%' +0(C,C# &%51*',2./ ),'" &.#*( *4$ (#1#*'#$ @0$-#5#4'+ *2%0'#+'*2.,+"#$ <*&'+6: D# 4%',&# *.(#*$/ '"*' '"# *2+#4&# %< *0'"%(,'/?,4',5,$*',%4? *4$ ",#(*(&"/ ,4 '"# 5#'"%$ ,+ ,'+#.< 4%' +% &.#*(./ C*.0#>4#0'(*.9 ,' #P1(#++#+ C*.0#+ Y ,4$#1#4$#4&#? .,2#('/? +#.<>$(,C#4 &"%,&# Y'"*' b(*4$' *&'0*../ '",4B+ C#(/ ,51%('*4': !"#+# *(# ,4$##$ ,51%('*4'C*.0#+ '% 20,.$ ,4'% * 1(%&#$0(# %< &%-4,',C# +&(0',4/ %< $#+,(#: D"*' ,+70#+',%4*2.# ,+ '"*' )# +"%0.$ '",4B %< '"# (#+0.',4- 5#'"%$ *+ #4',(#./C*.0#><(##:

X ;# 2#-,4+ ",+ *(',&.# 2/ *44%04&,4- * $#2' '% U*4' *4$ O$*5 Q5,'"? *+ )#.. *+ '% '"#[',.,'*(,*4+ EIJZN? 11: gJYKVL:

Z F,&"*($ b: b(*4$' EIJXJ? 11: NgKYKhL: b/ &*..,4- ",+ C,#) *4 *.'#(4*',C# '% S%"4 F*).+6+'"#%(/ %< @0+',&#? b(*4$' 5*B#+ ,' &.#*( '"*' "# 5#*4+ '% 0+# ,' '% &"%%+# 2*+,& 1%.,',&*.1(,4&,1.#+:

565789:; 7<;=;<;>,;3 5>6 ?@A;>B3 @789@>3 -B



b(*4$' 4%) ,$#4',<,#+ <%0( &*'#-%(,#+ %< 5,+'*B# '"*' &%-4,',C#1+/&"%'"#(*1/ )%0.$? ,4 ",+ C,#)? (#5%C# E11: IIhYNWL: d,(+'? '"#(# ,+'"# .*(-# &*'#-%(/ %< $#+,(#+ '"*' $#1#4$ 01%4 <*.+# 2#.,#<+ E*4$ (#&*..'"*' '",+ 50+' 4%' ,4&.0$# 2#.,#<+ *2%0' 5*''#(+ %< C*.0#? )",&" (#5*,404*<<#&'#$ 2/ '"# &%-4,',C# 1(%&#++L: Q#&%4$? '"#(# *(# -#4#(*.,`*',%4+<(%5 *'/1,&*. #P*51.#+9 '"#+#? '%%? &*4 0.',5*'#./ 2# $,+.%$-#$ 2/ *5%(# #P'#4+,C# &%4<(%4'*',%4 ),'" * ),$#( (*4-# %< #P*51.#+: !",($?J

'"#(# ,+ '"# &*'#-%(/ &*..#$ G*(',<,&,*. ]#+,(#>O(%0+*. ,4 M0.'0(#>!(*4+5,++,%46: D"*' b(*4$' 5#*4+ "#(# ,+ '"*' &0.'0(#+ '(*4+5,' C*.0#+2/ #P*51.# *4$ 1(#&#1'? <(#70#4'./ ,4 )*/+ '"*' &%0.$ 4%' "*C# 2##41(%$0&#$ 2/ '"# (#*. #P1#(,#4&# %< )"*' ,+ '*.B#$ *2%0'? ),'"%0'&0.'0(*. ,4'#(<#(#4&#: b(*4$'6+ ')% #P*51.#+ *(# '"# %&&01*',%4 %<-*(2*-# &%..#&',4-? *4$ G5*((,*-# '% * 1#(+%4 %< *4%'"#( (*&#? (#.,-,%4?%( 4*',%4*.,'/6: O&'0*. #P1#(,#4&# ),'" '"#+# *&',C,',#+? +*/+ b(*4$'?&%0.$ 1(%C# C#(/ +*',+</,4-? *4$ &#('*,4./ '"#(#6+ 4% (#*+%4 '% +011%+#'"*' '"#/ )%0.$ 1(%$0&# *4 ,4'(,4+,& *C#(+,%4 ,4 +%5#%4# )"% "*$ "*$4% 1(,%( &0.'0(*. &%4$,',%4,4-: _< &%0(+#? "# 4%) +*/+? '"# +%&,*.*'','0$#+ %< %'"#(+ *(# '"#5+#.C#+ (#*. <*&'+ ),'" )",&" 1#%1.# "*C# '%$#*.: Gb0' ,4'#4+# &%4&#(4 ),'" '"# *'','0$#+ %< %'"#( 1#%1.# ,+ ,'+#.<<%04$#$ 01%4 #((%( Y '"# <*.+# 2#.,#< '"*' '"# *'','0$#+ %< %'"#(+ *(#&(0&,*../ ,51%('*4' <%( *4 *$0.'? #+1#&,*../ ,< '"# *'','0$#+ ,4 70#+',%4*(# '"%+# %< %4#6+ %)4 1*(#4'+ %4./6:

A4 '",+ <*+&,4*',4- 1*(*-(*1" )# +## b(*4$' '(/,4- '% '"# 0'5%+' '%+70##`# &%4&.0+,%4+ '"*' 1.#*+# ",5 %0' %< '"# *..#-#$./ C*.0#><(##5#'"%$ '"*' "# (#&%55#4$+: b(*4$'6+ .%C# %< .,2#('/? ",+ $#5%&(*',&(#+1#&' <%( '"%+# )"% $% 5*40*. .*2%(? *4$ ",+ $,+.,B# %< +01#(+',',%4 *..5*B# ",5 +## '"# *'','0$#+ %< '"%+# )"% +"(,4B <(%5 ,4'#(5*((,*-# *4$-*(2*-# &%..#&',4- *+ 1(%<%04$./ ,((*',%4*.: \(%2*2./ "# ,+ (,-"' '% +*/'"*' *4 04'0'%(#$ &",.$ )%0.$ #P1#(,#4&# 4% 4*'0(*. $,+$*,4 <%( '"#+#'",4-+? 20' ,' ,+ 4%' &.#*( '"*' '",+ ,+ '"# .,4# "# +"%0.$ '*B#? +,4&# *404'0'%(#$ &",.$ 5,-"' *.+% .*&B '"# 2*+,+ <%( 5*4/ +%&,*. *'','0$#+b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b(*4$'6+ .,2#(*. *4$ $#5%&(*',& ,4+',4&'+ &.*+"? *+ $,$ ;*(+*4/,6+?),'" )"*' ",+ *(-05#4' &*4 *&'0*../ $#.,C#( Y $#+1,'# '"# <*&' '"*' "# ,+5%(# "*($>"#*$#$ '"*4 ;*(+*4/, ,4 ",+ *''#51'+ '% $% ),'"%0' C*.0#+:

J A "*C# ,4C#('#$ '"# %($#( %< &*'#-%(,#+ ')% *4$ '"(##? +,4&# A <,4$ b(*4$'6+ %(,-,4*. '",($+'(*,-"'<%()*($ *4$ ",+ %(,-,4*. +#&%4$ C#(/ 1(%2.#5*',&:

-, #)*+.) 57 ('!!8)'#



b(*4$'6+ <%0('" &*'#-%(/ %< 5,+'*B# ,+ '"*' %< G^P*--#(*'#$ R*.#4&#+\(%$0&#$ 2/ ^*(./ ]#1(,C*',%46 EIJXJ? 11: INNYWL: ;,+ #P*51.# ,+ * .#''#('% ]#*( O22/? ,4 )",&" * )%5*4 &%51.*,4+ *2%0' "#( "0+2*4$? )"%-(#) 01 <*'"#(.#++ $0(,4- '"# $#1(#++,%4? *4$ "*+ 4%) 2#&%5# 70,'#)#*.'"/: e%4#'"#.#++? "# ,+ %2+#++#$ ),'" +*C,4- <%( ",+ %.$ *-#? '% *$#-(## '"*' 5*B#+ ",+ <*5,./ 04"*11/c "# 20/+ +#&%4$>"*4$ &.%'"#+?#*'+ +'*.# 2(#*$? *4$ +% %4: Eb(*4$' 4%'#+ '"*' +,5,.*( 2#"*C,%( &*4 2#<%04$ ,4 .*2%(*'%(/ (*'+:IVL ;#(#? "# +*/+? )# "*C# * +/4$(%5# ,4 )",&"#*(./ $#1(,C*',%4 *4$ ,'+ *++%&,*'#$ *4P,#',#+ .#*$ '% *4 #P*--#(*'#$ .*'#($#C#.%15#4' %< $#+,(#: ;# &.*,5+ '"*' +0&" *24%(5*../ +'(%4- $#+,(#+)%0.$ $,5,4,+" %4&# '"#,( (%%' &*0+# )*+ 2(%0-"' '% '"# +0(<*&# Y 2%'",4 '"# &*+# %< 5%4#/ *4$ ,4 '"# &*+# %< %'"#( -%%$+? +0&" *+ .%C# %(*<<#&',%4? '"*' 5,-"' *.+% 2# .*&B,4- ,4 %4#6+ #*(./ .,<#:

b0' %< &%0(+# '"# 04(#+%.C#$ 70#+',%4 ,+? )"#4 ,+ * $#+,(# <%( 5%4#/?%( <%( .%C#? G#P*--#(*'#$f6 O(# )# +011%+#$ '% 2# *2.# '% '#.. '"*'),'"%0' * '"#%(/ %< C*.0#f O4$ )"*' &%04'+ *+ G$#1(,C*',%46 ,4 #*(./.,<#f O-*,4? )# 4##$ * 4%(5*',C# *&&%04' %< 1(%1#( .%C#? *4$ 1(%1#(5*'#(,*. +011%('? '% -#' +'*('#$ "#(#: b/ &"%%+,4- * C#(/ 2,`*((# &*+#?b(*4$' &%4&#*.+ '"# $#1'" %< '",+ 1(%2.#5: b0' "#(# *-*,4? &.#*(./? "# ,+-#'',4- '% +%5# &"*(*&'#(,+',& b(*4$',*4 C*.0#>&%4&.0+,%4+ E<%( #P*51.#?1#%1.# +"%0.$ 4%' 2# C#(/ $#1#4$#4' %4 '"# .%C# *4$ *11(%C*. %< %'"#(+L'"(%0-" *4 *..#-#$./ <*&'0*. #P#(&,+#:

A4 +"%('? '"# )#.<*(,+' *''#51' '% (#<0(2,+" '"# 1(#<#(#4&#> %( $#+,(#>2*+#$ C,#) (04+ ,4'% $,<<,&0.'/9 ,' *11#*(+ 04*2.# '% $#.,C#( *.. '"*' '"#)#.<*(,+' 1",.%+%1"#(>#&%4%5,+'+ '"#5+#.C#+ )%0.$ .,B# '% -#': D# &*4-#' * &#('*,4 $,+'*4&# 2/ *$$,4- ,4<%(5*',%4 *4$ &%((#&',4- .%-,&*. #((%(:b0' '% -#' *.. '"# )*/ '% ;*(+*4/,6+ ,$#*. %< * 5%(*. &%5504,'/ %<#70*.+? %( '% b(*4$'6+ ,$#*. %< *4 ,4$#1#4$#4' "*($>"#*$#$ 04+01#(>+',',%0+ $#5%&(*',& &,',`#4(/? '"#+# '",4B#(+ "*C# "*$ '% ,4@#&' C*.0#@0$-#5#4'+ ,4'% '"# 1(%&#$0(#+ %< (#C,+,%4 Y &%4'(*(/ '% '"#,( *44%04&#$,4'#4',%4+:

@' "2"/$7C0 /#010#0(&0* "(2 $%0 #0D0&$74( 41 60>1"#7*!

A' ,+ 4%' +0(1(,+,4-? )"#4 `#*.%0+ $#<#4$#(+ %< '"# )#.<*(,+' 1(%@#&' +',..<,4$ '"#5+#.C#+ $,C#(-,4- <(%5 ,'? '"*' %'"#(+ .#++ )#$$#$ '% '"# 1(%@#&'+"%0.$ &%4&.0$# '"*'? <%( 4%(5*',C# 10(1%+#+ Y *4$ #+1#&,*../ <%( '"#10(1%+#+ %< &"%%+,4- 2*+,& 1%.,',&*. 1(,4&,1.#+ Y '"# ,4<%(5#$>$#+,(#*11(%*&" ,+ ,4*$#70*'#: A4 (#&#4' /#*(+ '"#(# "*+ 2##4 *4 #P1.%+,%4 %<)%(B *''*&B,4- '"# 1(#<#(#4&#>2*+#$ *11(%*&" '% 4%(5*',C# ,++0#+ %<102.,& &"%,&#: b0' ,' ,+ )%('" (#C,#),4- '"# $,<<#(#4' *(-05#4'+ '"*'

IV 1: INgc (*'+ )"% "*C# 2##4 $#1(,C#$ %< <%%$ (#+1%4$ 2/ 5*++,C# "%*($,4- )"#4 <%%$2#&%5#+ *204$*4':

565789:; 7<;=;<;>,;3 5>6 ?@A;>B3 @789@>3 --



"*C# 2##4 5*$#? ,4 %($#( '% +## #P*&'./ "%) <*( '"#/ $% 2(#*B ),'" *1(#<#(#4&#>2*+#$ C,#)? *4$ ,4 )"*' )*/+:

I: 01$ 67B)#$%. <7"# 6--7"-74&.$ :7"8$')7$: !"# ,4<%(5#$>$#+,(#*11(%*&" +'(0&B #C#4 ;*(+*4/, *4$ b(*4$' *+ ,4 4##$ %< 1(%&#$0(*.+011.#5#4'*',%4c ,4 $,<<#(#4' )*/+? '"#/ #*&" 20,.' ,4'% '"# 1(%&#$0(#'"# ,$#* %< * &%5504,'/ %< #70*.+? 04,4',5,$*'#$ 2/ 1%)#( %( *0'"%(,'/?*4$ 04*<<#&'#$ 2/ '"#,( %)4 *)*(#4#++ %< '"#,( 1.*&# ,4 * +%&,*.",#(*(&"/? )"#'"#( <%( #4C/ %( <%( <#*(: O4$ '",+ %< &%0(+# "*+ 2##4 *'(#5#4$%0+ *(#* %< 4%(5*',C# )%(B? *5%4- '",4B#(+ )"% &%4',40# '%2#.,#C# '"*' +%5# <%(5 %< 1(%&#$0(*.,+5 ),.. +0<<,&# *+ * 2*+,+ <%( +%&,*.&"%,&#: !"# C,#)+ %< S%"4 F*).+ *4$ S0i (-#4 ;*2#(5*+ *2%0' <*,(1(%&#$0(#+ %< 102.,& &"%,&# *(# 2%'" '%% <*5,.,*( *4$ '%% &%51.#P <%( 5#'% -#' ,4C%.C#$ ,4 $,+&0++,4- '"#5 "#(#? 20' 2%'" &.#*(./ $% ),'" (,-%(*4$ $#'*,. )"*' ;*(+*4/, $,$ 4%' <0../ $%? 20' %4./ 5#4',%4#$c '"*' ,+? '%5%$#. * U*4',*4 ,$#*. %< 5%(*. &%5504,'/? 2/ ,4'(%$0&,4- &%4+'(*,4'+%4 ,4<%(5*',%4 *4$ 1(%&#$0(#: !% '",+ $,+',4-0,+"#$ .,+' )# +"%0.$ *$$S#*4 ;*51'%4 EIJJg? 11: NNXYhWL? )"%+# <#5,4,+' 1(%&#$0(*.,+5? ,4 '"#,51%('*4' *(',&.# Gd#5,4,+' M%4'(*&'*(,*4,+56? 20,.$+ ,4'% '"# 1(%&#$0(#%< &"%,&# '"# C*.0# %< #*&" 1#(+%4 *+ *4 #4$? *4$ * $,+',4&',%4 2#')##4.#-,',5*'# *4$ ,..#-,',5*'# ,4'#(#+'+:

N: 01$ 67B)#$%. <7"# 6'&-.&.4"%: M.%+#./ .,4B#$ '% '"#+# 4%(5*',C#&(,',&,+5+ %< 0',.,'*(,*4,+5 ,+ * +#' %< *(-05#4'+ '"*' <%&0+ %4 '"#1"#4%5#4%4 %< &'&-.&.4"%? ,4 )",&" ,4$,C,$0*.+ *$@0+' '"#,( $#+,(#+ '%'"# )*/ %< .,<# '"#/ B4%): S%4 ^.+'#(6+ *&&%04' %< *$*1'*',%4 ,+ (*'"#(4*((%)./ <%&0+#$:II d%( ",5? * $#+,(# &%04'+ *+ *$*1',C# %4./ ,< ,' (#*../"*+ * <%P>*4$>-(*1#+ +'(0&'0(#c "*C,4- $#+,(#$ '"# -(*1#+? '"# <%P? +##,4-'"*' "# &*44%' -#' '"# -(*1#+? @0$-#+ '"*' '"#/ *(# +%0(: Q0&" 1(#<#(#4&#+*(# '% 2# $,+',4-0,+"#$ <(%5 &"*4-#+ ,4 $#+,(# 2*+#$ %4 .#*(4,4- *4$#P1#(,#4&#c <%( '"# .*''#( *(# .,B#./ '% 2# ,((#C#(+,2.#? )"#(#*+ *$*1',C#1(#<#(#4&#+ E<%( &,'/ .,<# )"#4 ,4 '"# &,'/? <%( &%04'(/ .,<# )"#4 ,4 '"#&%04'(/L *(# <*( <(%5 ,((#C#(+,2.#:

^.+'#(6+ +%5#)"*' (%5*4',& 1(#<#(#4&# <%( +'(,C,4- *4$ /#*(4,4-5*B#+ ",5 +0+1,&,%0+ %< *4/ $#+,(# '"*' ,+ <%(5#$ '"(%0-" *$@0+'5#4' '%(#*.,'/: b0' ,' ,+ 4%' *' *.. &.#*( "# +"%0.$ ,4 +0&" * +)##1,4- )*/&%4$#54 *$*1',C# 1(#<#(#4&#+: D# -#' 0+#$ '% "*C,4- '"# 2%$,#+ )# $%"*C#? *4$ #C#4 ,<? *+ &",.$(#4? )# )*4'#$ '% <./ .,B# 2,($+? )# +,51./$(%1 '"*' *<'#( * )",.#? *4$ *(# '"# 2#''#( <%( ,': O-*,4? +%5#%4# *+ *&",.$ 5*/ )*4' '% 2# '"# 2#+' %1#(* +,4-#( ,4 '"# )%(.$ E*+ A $,$L? %( '"#2#+' 2*+B#'2*.. 1.*/#( Y *4$ 5%+' 1#%1.# *$@0+' '"#,( *+1,(*',%4+ '% )"*''"#/ &*4 *&'0*../ *&",#C#: A' +##5+ '"*' '"#+# &"*4-#+ $% ,4C%.C# '"# <%P>

II A4 GQ%0( T(*1#+6? ,4 C.4,4.&74&%45# &%' D$;"%'? 11: NIJYgZ? *4$ ,4 '"# 2%%B %< '"# +*5#','.#: Q02+#70#4' 1*-# (#<#(#4&#+ *(# '% '"# *(',&.#: !(* &%4'*,4+ * 5%(# $#'*,.#$$,+&0++,%4 %< ^.+'#(6+ 1%+,',%4:

-: #)*+.) 57 ('!!8)'#



*4$>-(*1#+ +'(0&'0(# '"*' ^.+'#( (0.#+ %0' *+ ,4&%51*',2.# ),'"*0'%4%5/c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b0' &.#*(./ '",+ ,+ %<'#4 * -%%$ '",4-? *4$ )# 1(%2*2./ +"%0.$ 4%'#4&%0(*-# 1#%1.# '% 1#(+,+' ,4 04(#*.,+',& *+1,(*',%4+:IN

!"# &*+#+ '"*' ^.+'#( *&'0*../ "*+ ,4 5,4$ *(# ,4'#(#+',4-./ $,<<#(#4'c'"# )*/ ,4 )",&" <#0$*.,+5 5*$# 1#%1.# 4%' *+1,(# '% 1%.,',&*. #70*.,'/*4$ 5*'#(,*. )#..>2#,4-? '"# )*/ '"# A4$0+'(,*. F#C%.0',%4 04.#*+"#$ *+'%(5 %< &.*++>2*+#$ $,+&%4'#4' '"*' )*+ 1(%$0&',C# 2%'" 1%.,',&*../ *4$#&%4%5,&*../: b0' '% $,+',4-0,+" '",+ &*+# <(%5 5/ &*+#+ %< '"# 2,($ *4$'"# 2*+B#'2*.. 1.*/#(? "# 4##$+ +%5#'",4- "# $%#+ 4%' -,C# 0+? *+02+'*4',C# '"#%(/ %< @0+',&# *4$ &#4'(*. -%%$+: A' )*+ <(0,'<0. <%( '"#+#1#%1.# '% "%.$ %4'% '"#,( E-7" .$#-"7$L 04(#*.,`*2.# $#+,(#+ 2#&*0+# '"#/)#(# $#+,(#+ <%( &#4'(*. -%%$+? '",4-+ 1#%1.# *+ 1#%1.# "*C# * (,-"' '%"*C#: \#%1.#6+ .,2#('/ &*4 ,4$##$ 2# 5#*+0(#$? 4%' 2/ '"# +"##( 4052#(%< 04(#*.,`*2.# )*4'+ '"#/ "*C#? 20' 2/ '"# #P'#4' '% )",&" '"#/ )*4')"*' "05*4 2#,4-+ "*C# * (,-"' '% "*C#: !"0+ R*+*4',? )"% "*'#$ "#($%5#+',& *20+#? +##5+ * .,''.# 5%(# <(## '"*4 S*/*55*? )"% *&70,#+&#$,4 $,+&(,5,4*',%4 *4$ %11(#++,%4: b%'"? "%)#C#(? )#(# 04<(## ,4 %4#<0('"#( &(0&,*. )*/c '"#/ .*&B#$ '"# 04$#(+'*4$,4- %< '"#5+#.C#+ *+&,',`#4+ )"% "*C# (,-"'+ '"*' *(# 2#,4- C,%.*'#$: !"*' '/1# %< *$@0+'5#4''% 2*$ &,(&05+'*4&#+ ,+ ,4$##$ $#1.%(*2.#? *4$ )# C,#) ,' *+ 1(%-(#++'"*' '"#/ &%5# '% (#*.,`# '"#/ "*C# * (,-"' '% 2#''#( '(#*'5#4'? #C#4 ,<'"*' 2#''#( '(#*'5#4' ,+ 4%' /#' <%('"&%5,4-: b0' '% +*/ '",+? )# 4##$ *4*&&%04' %< )"*' '/1#+ %< '(#*'5#4' 1#%1.# "*C# * (,-"' '% #P1#&' ,4&#4'(*. *(#*+ %< '"#,( .,C#+: _4&# *-*,4? 1(%&#$0(*.,+5 Y #C#4 %< * 5%(#&%51.,&*'#$ +%(' Y +##5+ ,4+0<<,&,#4' ),'"%0' +%5#'",4- ,4 '"# )*/ %< *+02+'*4',C# '"#%(/:

Q0&" * '"#%(/ ,+ '% +%5# #P'#4' 1(%C,$#$ 2/ '"# %'"#( 1(%5,4#4'#&%4%5,+' )"% $,+&0++#+ *$*1',C# 1(#<#(#4&#+? O5*('/* Q#4:Ig Q#4<%&0+#+ %4 '"# +,'0*',%4 %< )%5#4 *4$ %'"#( $#1(,C#$ 1#%1.#9 ",+ &#4'(*.&*+# ,+ '"*' %< )%5#4 )"% $% 4%' $#+,(# +%5# 2*+,& "05*4 -%%$2#&*0+# '"#/ "*C# 2##4 .%4- "*2,'0*'#$ '% ,'+ *2+#4&# %( '%.$ '"*' ,' ,+4%' <%( +0&" *+ '"#5: d%( #P*51.#? ,4 IJKK? '"# /#*( *<'#( '"# T(#*'

IN M%4'(*+' ^.+'#(? 1: NNZ? "%.$,4- '"*' * 1#(+%46+ $#-(## %< *0'%4%5/ &*4 2# 5#*+0(#$ 2/'"# 4052#( %< '",4-+ "# )*4'+ '% $% 20' ,+ 4%' *' .,2#('/ '% $%:

Ig Q##? <%( #P*51.#? Q#4 IJJh? 11: NhJYXg9 IJZK? 11: gVXYNK:

565789:; 7<;=;<;>,;3 5>6 ?@A;>B3 @789@>3 -;



b#4-*. d*5,4#? '"# O..>A4$,* A4+','0'# %< ;/-,#4# *4$ \02.,& ;#*.'" $,$* +0(C#/ ,4 *4 *(#* 4#*( M*.&0''*? ,4&.0$,4- ,4 '"# +0(C#/ 5*4/ ),$%)+*4$ ),$%)#(+: O5%4- '"# ),$%)#(+? Kh:W 1#(&#4' (*4B#$ '"#,( "#*.'" *+#,'"#( G,..6 %( G,4$,<<#(#4'6: _4./ N:hj %< ),$%)+ 5*$# '"*' @0$-#5#4'?*4$ 4%4# *' *.. (*4B#$ '"#,( "#*.'" *+ G,4$,<<#(#4'6 E*+ Q#4 4%'#+? * 5%(#+02@#&',C# &*'#-%(/ '"*4 G,..6L: !",+ )*+ ,4 +'(,B,4- &%4'(*+' '% '"#,( (#*.+,'0*',%4? +,4&# ),$%)+ '#4$ '% 2# * 1*(',&0.*(./ $#1(,C#$ -(%01 ,4 2*+,&"#*.'" *4$ 40'(,',%4: Q#4 &%4&.0$#+c G=0,#' *&&#1'*4&# %< $#1(,C*',%4*4$ 2*$ <*'# *<<#&'+ '"# +&*.# %< $,++*',+<*&',%4 -#4#(*'#$? *4$ '"#0',.,'*(,*4 &*.&0.0+ -,C#+ +*4&','/ '% '"*' $,+'%(',%46: _4# &*4 *.+% 5*B# *(#5*(B ,4 '"# %'"#( $,(#&',%4c 1(,C,.#-#$ 1#%1.# -#' 0+#$ '% 2#,4-1*51#(#$ *4$ &*(#$ <%(? *4$ 5*/ <##. *4 040+0*../ ",-" .#C#. %<$,+&%4'#4' )"#4 '"# %4# '"*' $,$ '"# 1*51#(,4- ,+ 4% .%4-#( *(%04$:Q#4 &%4&.0$#+ '"*' '",+ 5*B#+ 0',.,'/ 70,'# ,4*$#70*'# *+ * 2*+,+ %< +%&,*.&"%,&#:

Q#46+ -(%01 %< &*+#+ ,+? 4%',&#? 2%'" 2(%*$#( *4$ 4*((%)#( '"*4^.+'#(6+: A' ,+ 2(%*$#(? 2#&*0+# Q#4 ,4&.0$#+ .,<#>.%4- "*2,'0*',%4? *4$$%#+ 4%' <%&0+ +,51./ %4 -,C,4- 01 * $#+,(# %4# %4&# "*$: O4$ '",+ ,+,51%('*4' )"#(# )%5#4 *(# &%4&#(4#$? +,4&# 5%+' %< '"# ,4'#(#+',4-&*+#+ $% ,4C%.C# .,<#>.%4- +%&,*.,`*',%4 *4$ *2+#4&# %< ,4<%(5*',%4: !"#-(%01 ,+ 4*((%)#( 2#&*0+# '"# &*+#+ %4 )",&" "# $)#..+ *.. ,4C%.C# *&#4'(*. "05*4 &*1*2,.,'/: O.'"%0-" Q#4 "*+ 4#C#( 2##4 ),..,4- '%#4$%(+# * +02+'*4',C# '"#%(/ %< '"# &#4'(*. &*1*2,.,',#+? ,4 1(*&',&# "#$%#+ +%? *4$ '"#(#<%(# $%#+ 4%' '(%02.# ",5+#.< *2%0' '"# *$*1',C#1(#<#(#4&# %< +%5#%4# )"% -,C#+ 01 ",+ $(#*5 %< 2*+B#'2*.. +'*($%5)"#4 "# <,4$+ '"*' "# ,+ 4#C#( -%,4- '% 2# '*..#( '"*4 <,C# <##' <%0( ,4&"#+E*4$ .#' 0+ +011%+# "# ,+ 4%' a0--+/ b%-0#+IKL: !"#(# ,+ 4% (%5*4',&1(#<#(#4&# <%( +'(,C,4- *+ * -%%$ ,4 ,'+#.< ,4 Q#46+ C,#)9 '"# *11(%1(,*'#>4#++ %< $#+,(# ,+ '#'"#(#$? ,51.,&,'./ *' *4/ (*'#? '% * +#4+# %< 2*+,& -%%$+%< .,<#: Q#46+ *4*./+,+ %< *$*1'*',%4 &%((#+1%4$+ )#.. '% )"*' )# <,4$ ,4'"# &*+#+ %< S*/*55*? R*+*4',? *4$ '"# )%5#4 %< O4$"(* \(*$#+": O..?2#&*0+# %< +%&,*. "*2,'0*',%4? 04$#(C*.0# &#4'(*. "05*4 &*1*2,.,',#+ '"*''"#/ .*'#( &%5# '% C*.0#:

d,4*../? '"# 1"#4%5#4%4 %< *$*1',C# 1(#<#(#4&#+ )*+ $,+&0++#$ ,4 *1*(',&0.*(./ ,..05,4*',4- )*/ 2/ S%"4 Q'0*(' a,.. ,4 01$ E)3=$8.4"% "<!"#$%: a,.. *(-0#+ '"*' 5#4 5*,4'*,4 '"#,( 1%)#( %C#( )%5#4 2/+"*1,4- )%5#46+ 1(#<#(#4&#+ *4$ $#+,(#+? %(? *+ "# 10'+ ,'? G#4+.*C3,4-8'"#,( 5,4$+6: !"#/ '#*&" )%5#4 '"*' ',5,$,'/ *4$ G(#+,-4*',%4 %< *..,4$,C,$0*. ),..6 *(# G*4 #++#4',*. 1*(' %< +#P0*. *''(*&',C#4#++6: D%5#4,4'#(4*.,`# '",+ '#*&",4-? @0+' *+ 5#4 2#&%5# *&&0+'%5#$ '% 2#,4- G'"#5*+'#(+ %< )%5#46 EIZWJ? 11: IhYIWL:

IK a0--+/ b%-0#+ ,+ *4 #P'(*%($,4*(/ h6K66 *'".#'# )"% "*+ 1.*/#$ <%( C*(,%0+ '#*5+ ,4 '"#ebO:

:< #)*+.) 57 ('!!8)'#



;%) $%#+ a,..? * [',.,'*(,*4? &(,',&,`# '"#+# *$*1',C# 1(#<#(#4&#+fM.#*(./? ),'" * 4%(5*',C# '"#%(/ %< .,2#('/ *4$ #70*.,'/: ;# 5*B#+ +%5#,4+'(05#4'*. *(-05#4'+ *2%0' '"# +%&,*. -%%$ '"*' ),.. 2# $%4# 2/ *5%(# '"%(%0-" 0+# %< )%5#46+ '*.#4'+? 20' '"# &#4'(*. *$C*4'*-# '%)",&" "# 1%,4'+ ,+ G'"# *$C*4'*-# %< "*C,4- '"# 5%+' 04,C#(+*. *4$1#(C*$,4- %< *.. "05*4 (#.*',%4+ (#-0.*'#$ 2/ @0+',&# ,4+'#*$ %< ,4@0+',&#6E1: ZWL:

!",+ ,+ "*($./ '"# %&&*+,%4 '% &%4$0&' * 1(%2,4- #P*5,4*',%4 %<a,..6+ [',.,'*(,*4,+5 *4$ ,'+ &%44#&',%4 ),'" ",+ '"#%(/ %< .,2#('/: b0' )#&*4 *' .#*+' +*/ '",+? *4$ ,' ,+ (#C#*.,4- <%( %0( 10(1%+#+: a,.. $%#+ '",4B,' ",-"./ (#.#C*4' '"*' '"# C*.0#+ "# $#<#4$+ *(# ,4 +%5# +#4+# (%%'#$ ,4"05*4 $#+,(# Y '"*' 1#%1.# )"% "*C# '(,#$ 2%'" .,2#('/ *4$ ,'+ *2+#4&#),.. 1(#<#( .,2#('/? '"*' @0+',&# ,+ * 1(%5,4#4' %2@#&' %< "05*4 +'(,C,4-:;# +011%('+ ",+ 1(%1%+*.+ ,4 F% G43$7.; ),'" (#<#(#4&# '% * 70,'#O(,+'%'#.,*4 *&&%04' %< '"# "05*4 1%)#(+ *4$ '"#,( <.%0(,+",4-?(#<#((,4- '% G* T(##B ,$#*. %< +#.<>$#C#.%15#4'6? *4$ *(-0,4- '"*' ,4 '"#*2+#4&# %< .,2#('/? G"05*4 &*1*&,',#+ *(# ),'"#(#$ *4$ +'*(C#$6 EIZhJ?11: XI? XhL: b0' "# *.+% .,4B+ '",+ O(,+'%'#.,*4 4%',%4 %< +#.<>$#C#.%15#4'),'" * 4%',%4 %< #P1#(,#4&#$ $#+,(#? +*/,4- '"*' .,2#('/ ,+ -%%$ ,4 1*('2#&*0+# ,' +*',+<,#+ &#('*,4 G1#(5*4#4' ,4'#(#+'+6 %< "05*4 2#,4-+: H,B#O(,+'%'.#? "# (#-*($+ ,' *+ 5%(# '"*4 * &%4',4-#4' 5*''#( '"*' '"#&%4+','0#4' 1*('+ %< <.%0(,+",4- *(# ,4 <*&' 1%)#(<0../ *4$ $##1./$#+,(#$: !",+ $%#+ 4%' (#+&0# '"# )#.<*(,+' 1(%@#&' ,4 ,'+ %(,-,4*. <%(5 Y20' ,' $%#+ &%4+'(*,4 '"# 5%C# '% \.*'%4,+5? ,4 *4 *11(%1(,*'# )*/: d%( ,')%0.$ "*($./ 2# 1.*0+,2.# '% +*/ '"*' R*+*4',6+ 2%$,./ ,4'#-(,'/? %(S*/*55*6+ #70*.,'/ *+ * .*2%(#(? *(# '",4-+ '% 2# 10(+0#$ *.'%-#'"#(,4$#1#4$#4'./ %< '"#,( (#.*',%4+",1 '% "05*4 $#+,(# *4$ &"%,&#: !"#)#.<*(,+' 1(%@#&' <*,.+? ,4 ,'+ +,51.#+' <%(59 20' ,' -#'+ +%5#'",4-,51%('*4' (,-"':

g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gWgL: O4%'"#( )*/'% 10' '",+ ,+ '% +*/ '"*' #C#4 ,< )# &%0.$ #4-,4##( '",4-+ +% '"*' 1#%1.#)#(# (#.,*2./ *$*1'#$ '% * C#(/ .%) .,C,4- +'*4$*($ Y *4$? *+ a,.. +*/+?'"# G5*+'#(+ %< )%5#46 "*C# ,4 5*4/ *(#*+ $%4# #P*&'./ '"*' Y '",+

565789:; 7<;=;<;>,;3 5>6 ?@A;>B3 @789@>3 :.



)%0.$ 4%' 2# '"# #4$ %< '"# ,++0# %< )"*' ,+ -%%$ %( (,-"': !"#+# <*,.0(#+'"#5+#.C#+ "*C# ,51%('*4&#? *4$ @0+' '"# 2*(# <*&' '"*' "05*4 2#,4-+*(# ,4&0((,4- '"#5 +"%0.$ 2# #4%0-" <%( 0+:

!",+ *(-05#4' ,+ '"# <.,1 +,$# %< '"# *$*1'*',%4 *(-05#4': A' '#..+ 0+1%+,',C#./ )"*' '"*' *(-05#4' '%.$ 0+ 4#-*',C#./? '"*' )# 4##$ *4%(5*',C# '"#%(/ Y 1(#<#(*2./ * '"#%(/ %< "05*4 &*1*2,.,'/ '"*' ,4&.0$#+*&&%04'+ %< #70*.,'/ *4$ .,2#('/ Y '% 1(%C,$# '"# 4%(5*',C# 2*+,+ '"*'$#+,(# <*,.+ (#.,*2./ '% 1(%C,$# 0+:

e%',&#? "%)#C#(? '"*' '"#(# *(# * 4052#( %< )*/+ %< 5*B,4- '",+*(-05#4'? 5*4/ +'%11,4- )#.. +"%(' %< %0'(,-"' \.*'%4,+5: !"# \.*'%4,+'),.. ,4$##$ +*/ '"*' '"#+# #'#(4*. ,4'(,4+,& C*.0#+ "*C# '"# C*.0# '"#/ $%*.'%-#'"#( ,4$#1#4$#4'./ %< "05*4 ",+'%(/? "05*4 &"%,&#? *4$ "05*4$#+,(#: b0' %4# 5,-"' *$%1' * $,<<#(#4' *&&%04' %< @0+',<,&*',%4? %4# '"*')%0.$ 5*B# *' .#*+' * 70*.,<,#$ (#<#(#4&# '% &"%,&# *4$ $#+,(#: F*).+6+Q%&(*',& *&&%04' %< @0+',<,&*',%4 1(%&##$,4- '%)*($ G(#<.#&',C# #70,.,>2(,056 ,+ %4# +0&" *&&%04'9 ;*51'%46+ <#5,4,+' &%4'(*&'*(,*4,+5? ),'",'+ (#<#(#4&# '% .#-,',5*'# ,4'#(#+'+? ,+ *4%'"#(:

!"0+ )# &*4 *&&#1' '"# *(-05#4' <(%5 ,4'(,4+,& C*.0# ),'"%0'*&&#1',4- '"# #P'(#5# (#@#&',%4 %< $#+,(# 0(-#$? <%( #P*51.#? 2/ !"%5*+Q&*4.%4 ,4 ",+ GR*.0#? ]#+,(#? *4$ '"# =0*.,'/ %< H,<#6:Ih Q&*4.%4 *(-0#+'"*' '"#(# *(# %4./ ')% (#*+%4+ )"/ $#+,(# ,+ %< *4/ ,4'#(#+' *' *.. ,4 '"#1(%&#++ %< @0+',</,4- *4 *&&%04' %< 70*.,'/ %< .,<#: _4# (#*+%4 ,+ "#$%4,&c'"# +*',+<*&',%4 %< * $#+,(# 5*/ 2(,4- 1.#*+0(#? *4$ 1.#*+0(# ,+ *4,4'(,4+,& -%%$: !"# %'"#( (#*+%4 ,+ "#0(,+',&c $#+,(# +'##(+ 0+ ,4 '"#$,(#&',%4 %< +%5# ,4'(,4+,& -%%$+: b0' ,4 #,'"#( &*+#? '"# (#<#(#4&# %<$#+,(# ,+ $,+1#4+*2.#c '"# "#$%4,& (#*+%4 1%,4'+ 2*&B '% '"# ,4'(,4+,&C*.0# %< 1.#*+0(#? )",&" ,+ E%4 '",+ C,#)L 4%' C*.0*2.# +,51./ 2#&*0+# ,',+ $#+,(#$9 '"# "#0(,+',& (#*+%4 1%,4'+ '% ,'#5+ )"%+# C*.0# 50+' 2#,4$#1#4$#4'./ *((,C#$ *': T,C#4 *.. '",+? *4$ -,C#4 '"*' $#+,(# ,+<(#70#4'./ 4%' +0&" * -%%$ -0,$#? '"#(# ,+ 4% 1*(',&0.*( (#*+%4 '% 2#,4'#(#+'#$ ,4 ,' ,4 &%4+'(0&',4- *4 *&&%04' %< 70*.,'/ %< .,<#:

A *5 4%' <0../ 1#(+0*$#$ 2/ '",+ *(-05#4'? <%( ')% (#*+%4+: d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c'"# (#*+%4 %< (#+1#&' A "*C# *.(#*$/ #4$%(+#$: !"# <*&' '"*' "05*42#,4-+ $#+,(# +%5#'",4- $%#+ &%04'9 ,' &%04'+ 2#&*0+# )# '",4B '"*'1%.,',&+? (,-"'./ 04$#(+'%%$? &%5#+ <(%5 1#%1.# *4$ )"*' 5*''#(+ '%

Ih A4 !(* A $,+&0++ 5%(# (#&#4' )(,',4-+ %< Q&*4.%46+ %4 '",+ ,++0#:

:= #)*+.) 57 ('!!8)'#



'"#5? 4%' <(%5 "#*C#4./ 4%(5+: A $% 4%' '",4B Q&*4.%4 $,+*-(##+ ),'"'",+9 20' '"#4 A (#5*,4 10``.#$ 2/ '"# $,+5,++,C# *'','0$# "# '*B#+ '%,4<%(5#$>$#+,(# *11(%*&"#+:

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

A' 20*7#0 "(2 D)*$717&"$74(

A4 5/ %)4 &%4&#1',%4? *4 *&&%04' %< '"# &#4'(*. &*1*2,.,',#+ 1(%C,$#+ *4#&#++*(/ 2*+,+ <%( 1%.,',&*. 1(,4&,1.#+? -,C,4- 4%' * &%51.#'# *&&%04' %<'"# -%%$ %( %< "05*4 <.%0(,+",4-? 20' * 1%.,',&*. *&&%04'? +1#&,</,4-&#('*,4 &*1*&,',#+? .,2#(',#+? *4$ %11%('04,',#+ '"*' "*C# C*.0# ,4 *4/1.*4 %< .,<# &,',`#4+ 5*/ %'"#(),+# &"%%+#: A4 '"# <,(+' 1*(' %< 5/ 1(%@#&' A*(-0# <%( +0&" *4 *11(%*&" 0+,4- *4 *(-05#4' 2*+#$ 01%4 *4 ,4'0,',C#./1%)#(<0. ,$#* %< '(0./ "05*4 <04&',%4,4-? <04&',%4,4- '"*' ,+ )%('"/ %<'"# $,-4,'/ %< '"# "05*4 2#,4-: A &.*,5 '"*' &,',`#4+ ),'" * ),$# (*4-# %<&%51(#"#4+,C# &%4&#1',%4+ %< '"# -%%$ &*4 #4$%(+# '",+ .,+' Y *+ * .,+' %<&*1*2,.,',#+? 4%' %< *&'0*. <04&',%4+ Y *+ * 2*+,+ <%( -#'',4- %4 ),'" .,<#?,4&.0$,4- 1(%5,4#4'./ 1%.,',&*. .,<#: !"#+# 2*+,& -%%$+ +011./ 1%.,',&+),'" &%4+'(*,4'+c &,',`#4+ +"%0.$ 2# 1(%C,$#$ ),'" '"#+#? )"*'#C#( #.+#1%.,',&+ *.+% 10(+0#+:

A' +##5+ '% 5# '"*' '",+ +%(' %< &*1*2,.,',#+ *11(%*&" $#*.+ )#.. ),'"'"# 1(%2.#5+ '"*' 1.*-0#$ '"# 1(#<#(#4&#>2*+#$ *11(%*&": A' $%#+ 4%')*+'# ',5# '(/,4- '% +50--.# * +02+'*4',C# *&&%04' %< &#4'(*. &*1*2,.,',#+,4'% * 1(%&#$0(# <%( ),44%),4- $#+,(#c ,' -%#+ $,(#&'./ *4$ <%('"(,-"'./'% '"# -%%$ E*4$ '"# (,-"'IWL? '*B,4- *4 04*52,-0%0+./ &.#*( +'*4$ %4'"# 4##$ <%( '"#+# ,'#5+? *+ *4 #4*2.,4- &%(# %< )"*'#C#( #.+# "05*42#,4-+ &"%%+#: A' *$$(#++#+ '"# 1(%2.#5 %< *$*1',C# 1(#<#(#4&#? *-*,4? 2/

IW b*+,& .,2#(',#+ *4$ %11%('04,',#+? *4$ '"# $,-4,'/ *4$ #70*.,'/ %< 1#(+%4+? *(# *.. ,4&.0$#$,4 '"# *&&%04' %< '"# 2*+,& &*1*2,.,',#+:

565789:; 7<;=;<;>,;3 5>6 ?@A;>B3 @789@>3 :@



+02+'*4',C# (*'"#( '"*4 <%(5*. $#C,&#+? *+ +##5#$ 4#&#++*(/: O "*2,'0>*'#$ 1(#<#(#4&# 4%' '% "*C# *4 ,'#5 %4 '"# .,+' E1%.,',&*. .,2#(',#+? .,'#(*&/?#70*. 1%.,',&*. (,-"'+? %( )"*'#C#(L ),.. 4%' &%04' ,4 '"# +%&,*. &"%,&#<04&',%4? *4$ '"# #70*../ "*2,'0*'#$ 1(#<#(#4&# '% "*C# '"#+# '",4-+ ),..&%04': d,4*../? '"# .,+' $%#+ @0+',&# '% '"# ,4'(,4+,& C*.0# %< '"# ,'#5+ ,'&%4'*,4+? 2/ 4%' +02%($,4*',4- '"#5 '% +%5#'",4- #.+#? +0&" *+1(#<#(#4&#>+*',+<*&',%4:

A' +"%0.$ 2# *11*(#4' '"*' '"# *11(%*&" ,+ 4%' 1*'#(4*.,+',& ,4 *4/'/1,&*. +#4+#? +,4&# ,' -,C#+ +0&" * .*(-# 1.*&# '% .,2#('/? *4$ #4C,+*-#+'"# +%&,*. -%*. ,4 '#(5+ %< &*1*2,.,'/? 4%' <04&',%4,4-:IX

b0' )"*' (%.# ,+ 1.*/#$ 2/ $#+,(# ,4 '"# 1(%&#++ %< @0+',</,4- '"# .,+'%< '"# &#4'(*. &*1*2,.,',#+f ;#(# 1#%1.#6+ ,4'0,',%4+ *2%0' "%) '% 1(%&##$C*(/ -(#*'./c +%5# '",4B )# %4./ 10' '",4-+ %4 * +%04$ <%%',4- )"#4 )#$#C,+# * 1(%&#$0(# '"*' -#4#(*'#+ '"# -%%$ *+ *4 %0'10'? *4$ %'"#(+ EA5/+#.<L? '#4$ '% '",4B '"*' %0( ,4'0,',%4+ *2%0' '"# &#4'(*. &*1*2,.,',#+ *(#*' .#*+' *+ '(0+')%('"/ *+ %0( ,4'0,',%4+ *2%0' )"*' &%4+','0'#+ * -%%$1(%&#$0(#: A "*C# +*,$ +% <*( '"*' '"# &*1*2,.,',#+ C,#) #52%$,#+ *4,4'0,',C#./ 1%)#(<0. ,$#* %< '(0./ "05*4 <04&',%4,4- '"*' "*+ $##1 (%%'+,4 5*4/ $,<<#(#4' '(*$,',%4+: A "*C# 0+#$ '",+ ,4'0,',C#./ -(%04$#$*(-05#4' '% @0+',</ '"# .,+' *4$ ,'+ 1%.,',&*. (%.#: b0' 4%) A 50+' 5*B#1.*,4 )"*' (%.# %( (%.#+ A $% *++,-4 '% $#+,(# ,4 '"# 1(%&#$0(# %< *((,C,4-*' *4$ @0+',</,4- '"# .,+':

A4 -#4#(*.? '"# *&&%04' %< 1%.,',&*. @0+',<,&*',%4 '"*' A )%0.$ <*C%( .,#+&.%+# '% '"# F*).+,*4 *&&%04' %< *(-05#4' 1(%&##$,4- '%)*($ (#<.#&',C##70,.,2(,05c )# .*/ %0' '"# *(-05#4'+ <%( * -,C#4 '"#%(#',&*. 1%+,',%4?"%.$,4- ,' 01 *-*,4+' '"# G<,P#$ 1%,4'+6 ,4 %0( 5%(*. ,4'0,',%4+? *4$+##,4- "%) '"%+# ,4'0,',%4+ 2%'" '#+' *4$ *(# '#+'#$ 2/ '"# &%4&#1',%4+)# #P*5,4#? "%1,4-? %C#( ',5#? '% *&",#C# &%4+,+'#4&/ *4$ <,' ,4 %0(@0$-#5#4'+ '*B#4 *+ * )"%.#: a/ *(-05#4' ,4 '"# <,(+' 1"*+# %< 5/1(%@#&' )*+ #4C,+*-#$ *+ * <,(+' +'#1 ,4 '"# 1(%&#++ %< (#*&",4- '%)*($+0&" * (#<.#&',C# #70,.,2(,05: b#<%(# '"*' 1(%&#++ )%0.$ 2# &%51.#'# E,< ,'#C#( )%0.$ 2#L? )# )%0.$ *.+% "*C# '% .*/ %0' %'"#( &%51#',4-&%4&#1',%4+? &%51*(# '"#5 ,4 $#'*,. ),'" '",+ %4#? *4$ +## %4 )"*'-(%04$+ %0(+ #5#(-#$ *+ 5%(# &"%,&#)%('"/: !"# 1(#+#4' 1*1#( "*+'*B#4 %4# +'#1 ,4 '"*' <0('"#( 1(%@#&'? 2/ &%51*(,4- '"# +02+'*4',C#>-%%$&%4&#1',%4 ),'" C*(,%0+ 1(#<#(#4&#>2*+#$ &%4&#1',%4+: e%) '"# 70#+>',%4 +"%0.$ 2#c )"*' 1*(' ,4 '",+ 1(%&#$0(# %< (#*&",4- '%)*($ (#<.#&',C##70,.,2(,05 ,+ 1.*/#$ 2/ $#+,(#f A 2#.,#C# '"*' $#+,(# 1.*/+ ')% (%.#+"#(#c 2%'" *4 #1,+'#5,& (%.# *4$ *4 *4&,..*(/ (%.# ,4 @0+',<,&*',%4:

d,(+'? ,' +##5+ '% 5# C#(/ ,51%('*4' '"*' 1#%1.# <(%5 * ),$# C*(,#'/%< &0.'0(#+? &%5,4- '%-#'"#( ,4 &%4$,',%4+ &%4$0&,C# '% (#<.#&',C#&(,',&,+5 %< '(*$,',%4? *4$ <(## <(%5 ,4',5,$*',%4 *4$ ",#(*(&"/? +"%0.$

IX Q## !(*? M"*1'#( I <%( 5%(# #P'#4+,C# $,+&0++,%4 %< 1.0(*.,+5 *4$ &"%,&#:

:A #)*+.) 57 ('!!8)'#



*-(## '"*' '",+ .,+' ,+ * -%%$ %4#? %4# '"*' '"#/ )%0.$ &"%%+#: d,4$,4-+0&" *(#*+ %< ,4<%(5#$ *-(##5#4' ,+ #1,+'#5,&*../ C*.0*2.#? ,4 ')% )*/+c<,(+'? ,' 1%,4'+ 0+ '% *(#*+ %< "05*4 #P1(#++,%4 '"*' )# 5,-"' "*C#4#-.#&'#$ %( 04$#(#+',5*'#$: Q#&%4$? ,' '#..+ 0+ '"*' %0( ,4'0,',%4+ *2%0')"*' )%0.$ 5*B# * 1%.,',&*. &%4+#4+0+ 1%++,2.# *(# %4 '"# (,-"' '(*&B:!"# 5#'"%$%.%-/ '"*' "*+ 2##4 0+#$ '% 5%$,</ '"# .,+' +"%)+ '",+c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

b0' '"# <*&' '"*' ,4<%(5#$ $#+,(# 1.*/+ '",+ #1,+'#5,& (%.# ,4$,+&%C#(,4- '"*' )",&" ,+ .,B#./ '% 1(%5%'# 1%.,',&*. +'*2,.,'/ +"%)+ '"*',' *.+% 1.*/+ * .,5,'#$ *4$ *4&,..*(/ (%.# ,4 @0+',</,4- '"# 1%.,',&*.&%4&#1',%4c <%(? "%)#C#( *''(*&',C# ,' .%%B+? ,< )# &*44%' +"%) '"*' ,' ,+.,B#./ '% (#5*,4 +'*2.# ,' ),.. 2# $,<<,&0.' '% @0+',</ ,': A' +##5+ (,-"' '%,4&.0$# +'*2,.,'/ *5%4- '"# &%4+,$#(*',%4+ '"*' *(# ,51%('*4' ,4@0+',</,4- * 1%.,',&*. &%4&#1',%4: O4$ A *(-0# '"*' )# &*44%' +"%) '"*'%0( &%4&#1',%4 ,+ .,B#./ '% (#5*,4 +'*2.# ),'"%0' +%5# (#<#(#4&# '%,4<%(5#$ $#+,(#:

_0( ,4'#(#+' ,4 *$*1',C# 1(#<#(#4&#+ -,C#+ 0+ *4%'"#( )*/ %<*11(%*&",4- '",+ ,++0# %< +'*2,.,'/: a/ #P*51.#+ -,C# 0+ 5*4/ (#*+%4+ '%+011%+# '"*' a,.. ,+ &%((#&'c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c 1#%1.# )"% %4&# .#*(4 *4$ #P1#(,#4&# '"#+# &*1*2,.,',#+ $%4%' )*4' '% -% 2*&B? *4$ %4# (#*../ &*44%' 5*B# '"#5 -% 2*&B: !"#$#.,-"' *4$ +*',+<*&',%4 '"*' 5*B#+ 1#%1.# 04),..,4- '% -% 2*&B)*($+ ,+

565789:; 7<;=;<;>,;3 5>6 ?@A;>B3 @789@>3 :B



* C#(/ ,51%('*4' +,-4 '"*' '"# &%4&#1',%4 )# *(# $#C#.%1,4- ,+ .,B#./ '%2# * +'*2.# %4#? *4$ '"*' (#-,5#+ '"*' '")*(' &#4'(*. &*1*2,.,',#+ *(#.,B#./ '% 1(%C# 04+'*2.#: !")*(',4- 1#(5*4#4' "05*4 ,4'#(#+'+ ,+ 4%' *),+# 1%.,',&*. +'(*'#-/: O4$ '",+ #1,+'#5,& (%.# <%( $#+,(# ,+? *' '"# +*5#',5# %4&# *-*,4? *4 *4&,..*(/ @0+',<,&*'%(/ (%.#? ,4 '"# +#4+# '"*' ,' ,+,51%('*4'? ,4 %($#( '% @0+',</ %0( &%4&#1',%4? '% +"%) '"*' ,' &*4 2##P1#&'#$ '% "*C# * (#*+%4*2.# $#-(## %< +'*2,.,'/:

D%5#4 $%? %< &%0(+#? &"%%+# '% (#'0(4 '% * '(*$,',%4*. .,<# ,4 '"#"%5# <(%5 * .,<# %< #51.%/5#4' %0'+,$# '"# "%5#: !"#/ *.+% &"%%+# '%(#'0(4 '% C#,.,4- <(%5 4%4>C#,.,4-: b0' 4%',&# '"*' '",+ ,+ * &"*4-# ,4 '"#,(5%$# %< <)%8.4"%4%B? 4%' ,4 '"#,( .#C#. %< 1%.,',&*. 8&-&34,4.; *+ &,',`#4+: !%*(-0# '"*' '"# 1(#<#(#4&# <%( '"# &#4'(*. &*1*2,.,',#+ ,+ 4%' 04,$,(#&',%4*.?)# )%0.$ 4##$ '% *(-0# '"*' 1#%1.# ),+" '% -,C# 01 81"48$5 *4$"--"7.)%4.4$5 '"*' '"#/ "*C# ,4 '",+ *(#*? *+ &,',`#4+ &"%%+,4- 2*+,&1%.,',&*. 1(,4&,1.#+: O4$ '",+ ,+ <*( 5%(# $,<<,&0.' '% +"%): D"*' )#)%0.$ 4##$ '% +"%) ,+ '"*' )%5#4 )"% "*C# #P1#(,#4&#$ '"# <0.. (*4-#%< '"# &#4'(*. &*1*2,.,',#+ &"%%+#? ),'" <0.. ,4<%(5*',%4 *4$ ),'"%0',4',5,$*',%4 E#'&:L? '% $#4/ '"#+# &*1*2,.,',#+? 1%.,',&*../? '% *.. )%5#4:b0' 0+0*../ )%5#4 )"% 1(#<#( '(*$,',%4*. .,C#+? *<'#( "*C,4- .#$ %'"#(.,C#+? $% 4%' &*51*,-4 <%( * 1%.,',&*. $#4,*. %< &"%,&# '% *.. &,',`#4+:IZ

^C#4 ,4 '"# *11*(#4' &*+# )"#(# #P1#(,#4&#$ )%5#4 $% &*51*,-4 %42#"*.< %< -#4#(*. (#+'(,&',%4+? *+ +##5#$ '% 2# '"# &*+# ,4 A(*4? ,' ,+#P'(#5#./ 04.,B#./ '"*' '"# )%5#4 <%(#+*) *4$ ),+"#$ '"# ",-"./(#1(#++,C# (#-,5# '"*' #4+0#$: !"*' (#-,5# "*+ 4%' 2##4 +'*2.#? 2#&*0+#,' '")*('+ &#4'(*. &*1*2,.,',#+:

b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c <%( '",+$#.,-"' ,'+#.< "#.1+ 0+ '% @0+',</ %0( .,+' *+ %4# '"*' ,+ (#+1#&'<0. %< '"#,(1#(+%4*.,',#+: d,4*../? %< &%0(+#? $#+,(# 1.*/+ * (%.# ,4 '"# <*&' '"*' '"#-%*. ,+ #P1(#++#$ ,4 '#(5+ %< &*1*2,.,',#+ *4$ 4%' *&'0*. <04&',%4,4-+: D#(#+1#&' '"# ,51%('*4&# %< $#+,(# *4$ 1(#<#(#4&# 2/ 20,.$,4- ,4'% '"#5%+' 2*+,& .#C#. %< '"# *&&%04' '"# %1',%4 '% 10(+0# '"# -%*. %( 4%' '%10(+0# ,':

IZ Q## <0('"#( ,4 !(*? M"*1'#( g:

:, #)*+.) 57 ('!!8)'#



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

"//0(2795 $%0 &0($#"> %)!"( &"/"+7>7$70*

!# $%&'# b#,4- *2.# '% .,C# '% '"# #4$ %< * "05*4 .,<# %< 4%(5*. .#4-'"9 4%' $/,4-1(#5*'0(#./? %( 2#<%(# %4#6+ .,<# ,+ +% (#$0&#$ *+ '% 2# 4%' )%('" .,C,4-:

(# )*+%,- .'/,01# b#,4- *2.# '% "*C# -%%$ "#*.'"? ,4&.0$,4- (#1(%$0&',C# "#*.'"9'% 2# *$#70*'#./ 4%0(,+"#$9 '% "*C# *$#70*'# +"#.'#(:

2# )*+%,- 340'56%0-# b#,4- *2.# '% 5%C# <(##./ <(%5 1.*&# '% 1.*&#9 '% 2# +#&0(#*-*,4+' C,%.#4' *++*0.'? ,4&.0$,4- +#P0*. *++*0.' *4$ $%5#+',& C,%.#4&#9 "*C,4-%11%('04,',#+ <%( +#P0*. +*',+<*&',%4 *4$ <%( &"%,&# ,4 5*''#(+ %< (#1(%$0&',%4:

7# 8'49'9: 3;/5%4/0%*4: /4+ <1*=510# b#,4- *2.# '% 0+# '"# +#4+#+? '% ,5*-,4#?'",4B? *4$ (#*+%4 Y *4$ '% $% '"#+# '",4-+ ,4 * G'(0./ "05*46 )*/? * )*/,4<%(5#$ *4$ &0.',C*'#$ 2/ *4 *$#70*'# #$0&*',%4? ,4&.0$,4-? 20' 2/ 4% 5#*4+.,5,'#$ '%? .,'#(*&/ *4$ 2*+,& 5*'"#5*',&*. *4$ +&,#4',<,& '(*,4,4-: b#,4- *2.# '%0+# ,5*-,4*',%4 *4$ '"%0-"' ,4 &%44#&',%4 ),'" #P1#(,#4&,4- *4$ 1(%$0&,4-)%(B+ *4$ #C#4'+ %< %4#6+ %)4 &"%,&#? (#.,-,%0+? .,'#(*(/? 50+,&*.? *4$ +% <%('":b#,4- *2.# '% 0+# %4#6+ 5,4$ ,4 )*/+ 1(%'#&'#$ 2/ -0*(*4'##+ %< <(##$%5 %<#P1(#++,%4 ),'" (#+1#&' '% 2%'" 1%.,',&*. *4$ *(',+',& +1##&"? *4$ <(##$%5 %<(#.,-,%0+ #P#(&,+#: b#,4- *2.# '% "*C# 1.#*+0(*2.# #P1#(,#4&#+ *4$ '% *C%,$ 4%4>2#4#<,&,*. 1*,4:

># ?;*0%*49# b#,4- *2.# '% "*C# *''*&"5#4'+ '% '",4-+ *4$ 1#%1.# %0'+,$#%0(+#.C#+9 '% .%C# '"%+# )"% .%C# *4$ &*(# <%( 0+? '% -(,#C# *' '"#,( *2+#4&#9 ,4-#4#(*.? '% .%C#? '% -(,#C#? '% #P1#(,#4&# .%4-,4-? -(*','0$#? *4$ @0+',<,#$ *4-#(:e%' "*C,4- %4#6+ #5%',%4*. $#C#.%15#4' 2.,-"'#$ 2/ <#*( *4$ *4P,#'/:EQ011%(',4- '",+ &*1*2,.,'/ 5#*4+ +011%(',4- <%(5+ %< "05*4 *++%&,*',%4 '"*'&*4 2# +"%)4 '% 2# &(0&,*. ,4 '"#,( $#C#.%15#4':L

@# A6/B0%B/, C'/9*4# b#,4- *2.# '% <%(5 * &%4&#1',%4 %< '"# -%%$ *4$ '% #4-*-# ,4&(,',&*. (#<.#&',%4 *2%0' '"# 1.*44,4- %< %4#6+ .,<#: E!",+ #4'*,.+ 1(%'#&',%4 <%( '"#.,2#('/ %< &%4+&,#4&# *4$ (#.,-,%0+ %2+#(C*4&#:L

"# D&&%,%/0%*4# D# b#,4- *2.# '% .,C# ),'" *4$ '%)*($ %'"#(+? '% (#&%-4,`# *4$+"%) &%4&#(4 <%( %'"#( "05*4 2#,4-+? '% #4-*-# ,4 C*(,%0+ <%(5+ %< +%&,*.,4'#(*&',%49 '% 2# *2.# '% ,5*-,4# '"# +,'0*',%4 %< *4%'"#(: E\(%'#&',4- '",+&*1*2,.,'/ 5#*4+ 1(%'#&',4- ,4+','0',%4+ '"*' &%4+','0'# *4$ 4%0(,+" +0&" <%(5+ %<*<<,.,*',%4? *4$ *.+% 1(%'#&',4- '"# <(##$%5 %< *++#52./ *4$ 1%.,',&*. +1##&":L)# ;*C,4- '"# +%&,*. 2*+#+ %< +#.<>(#+1#&' *4$ 4%4>"05,.,*',%49 2#,4- *2.# '% 2#'(#*'#$ *+ * $,-4,<,#$ 2#,4- )"%+# )%('" ,+ #70*. '% '"*' %< %'"#(+: !",+ #4'*,.+

565789:; 7<;=;<;>,;3 5>6 ?@A;>B3 @789@>3 :-



1(%C,+,%4+ %< 4%4>$,+&(,5,4*',%4 %4 '"# 2*+,+ %< (*&#? +#P? +#P0*. %(,#4'*',%4?#'"4,&,'/? &*+'#? (#.,-,%4? *4$ 4*',%4*. %(,-,4:

E# F01'6 8G'B%'9# b#,4- *2.# '% .,C# ),'" &%4&#(4 <%( *4$ ,4 (#.*',%4 '% *4,5*.+?1.*4'+? *4$ '"# )%(.$ %< 4*'0(#:

H# A,/-# b#,4- *2.# '% .*0-"? '% 1.*/? '% #4@%/ (#&(#*',%4*. *&',C,',#+:

!I# J*406*, FK'6 F4'L9 ?4K%6*4;'40#D# A*,%0%B/,# b#,4- *2.# '% 1*(',&,1*'# #<<#&',C#./ ,4 1%.,',&*. &"%,&#+ '"*' -%C#(4%4#6+ .,<#9 "*C,4- '"# (,-"' %< 1%.,',&*. 1*(',&,1*',%4? 1(%'#&',%4 %< <(## +1##&" *4$*++%&,*',%4:)# M/0'6%/,# b#,4- *2.# '% "%.$ 1(%1#('/ E2%'" .*4$ *4$ 5%C*2.# -%%$+L? *4$"*C,4- 1(%1#('/ (,-"'+ %4 *4 #70*. 2*+,+ ),'" %'"#(+9 "*C,4- '"# (,-"' '% +##B#51.%/5#4' %4 *4 #70*. 2*+,+ ),'" %'"#(+9 "*C,4- '"# <(##$%5 <(%5 04>)*((*4'#$ +#*(&" *4$ +#,`0(#: A4 )%(B? 2#,4- *2.# '% )%(B *+ * "05*4 2#,4-?#P#(&,+,4- 1(*&',&*. (#*+%4 *4$ #4'#(,4- ,4'% 5#*4,4-<0. (#.*',%4+",1+ %< 50'0*.(#&%-4,',%4 ),'" %'"#( )%(B#(+:

#010#0(&0*

b.,++? M"(,+'%1"#(: IJJg: GH,<#+'/.# *4$ '"# Q'*4$*($ %< H,C,4-6: A4 01$ I)&,4.; "< G4<$?11: KIhYgW: a: e0++2*05 *4$ O: Q#4 E#$+:L: M.*(#4$%4 \(#++

b(*4$'? F,&"*($ b: IJXJ: 6 01$"7; "< .1$ @""' &%' .1$ A4B1.: M.*(#4$%4 \(#++^.+'#(? S%4: IJZN: GQ%0( T(*1#+6: A4 C.4,4.&74&%45# &%' D$;"%'? 11: NIJYgZ: O5*('/* Q#4 *4$

b#(4*($ D,..,*5+ E#$+:L: M*52(,$-# [4,C#(+,'/ \(#++^.+'#(? S%4: IJZg: E")7 @7&-$5: M*52(,$-# [4,C#(+,'/ \(#++d(,#$5*4? a,.'%4: IJZK: G!"# a#'"%$%.%-/ %< \%+,',C# ^&%4%5,&+6: A4 01$ :14,"5"-1; "<

98"%"#485? 1: NIV: ]*4,#. a: ;*0+5*4 E#$:L: M*52(,$-# [4,C#(+,'/ \(#++;*51'%4? S#*4: IJJg: Gd#5,4,+' M%4'(*&'*(,*4,+56: A4 6 J4%' "< F%$K5 F>%/ L$#4%45. 955&;5

"% A$&5"% &%' F3=$8.4+4.;? 11: NNXYhW: H: O4'%4/ *4$ M: D,'' E#$+:L: D#+'C,#);*(+*4/,? S%"4 M: IJZN: Ga%(*.,'/ *4$ '"# !"#%(/ %< F*',%4*. b#"*C,%(6: A4 C.4,4.&74&%45#

&%' D$;"%'? 11: gJYWN: O5*('/* Q#4 *4$ b#(4*($ D,..,*5+ E#$+:L: M*52(,$-#[4,C#(+,'/ \(#++

;05#? ]*C,$: IXgJ 3IZZZ8: 6 07$&.45$ "< ()#&% ?&.)7$? b%%B AA? \*(' AAA? Q#&',%4 g: _P<%($[4,C#(+,'/ \(#++

a,..? S: Q: IZhJ: F% G43$7.;: A4$,*4*1%.,+c H,2(*(/ %< H,2#(*. O('+a,..? S: Q: IZWJ: 01$ E)3=$8.4"% "< !"#$%: Q: a: _B,4 E#$:L: ;*&B#''e0++2*05? a: IJJX: Gd.*)#$ <%04$*',%4+c '"# 1",.%+%1",&*. &(,',70# %< E* &#('*,4 '/1# %<L

#&%4%5,&+6: C%4+$754.; "< 2148&B" G&> A$+4$>? WKcIIJXYIKe0++2*05? a: NVVV: !"#$% &%' ()#&% *$+$,"-#$%./ 01$ 2&-&34,4.4$5 6--7"&81: M*52(,$-#

[4,C#(+,'/ \(#++F%+#? U*.,5*: IJJN:!1$7$ !"#$% 67$ G$&'$75/ 01$ E9!6J"+$#$%. 4% H%'4&: k#$ b%%B+Q&*4.%4? !: a: IJJg: GR*.0#? ]#+,(# *4$ =0*.,'/ %< H,<#6: A4 01$ I)&,4.; "< G4<$? 11: NVIYX:

a: e0++2*05 *4$ O: Q#4 E#$+:L: M.*(#4$%4 \(#++Q#4? O5*('/*: IJZK: GF,-"'+ *4$ M*1*2,.,',#+6: A4 A$5")78$5M N&,)$5M &%' *$+$,"-#$%.?

11: gVXYNK: b.*&B)#.. *4$ ;*(C*($ [4,C#(+,'/ \(#++Q#4? O5*('/*: IJZK: Gd*5,./ *4$ d%%$c Q#P b,*+ ,4 \%C#('/6: A4 A$5")78$5M N&,)$5M &%'

*$+$,"-#$%.? 11: gKWYWh: b.*&B)#.. *4$ ;*(C*($ [4,C#(+,'/ \(#++Q#4? O5*('/*: IJJh: GT#4$#( A4#70*.,'/ *4$ !"#%(,#+ %< S0+',&#6: A4 !"#$%M 2),.)7$M &%'

*$+$,"-#$%.? 11: NhJYXg: a: e0++2*05 *4$ S: T.%C#( E#$+:L: M.*(#4$%4 \(#++

:: #)*+.) 57 ('!!8)'#


nussbaum on adaptive prefs

Documents