notes on the bhāgavata on the bhāgavata.pdfit is the fruit of the tree of thought (vedas) mixed...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
NotesOnTheBhāgavataByBhaktivinodaṬhākura
(Ajadas)
![Page 2: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
PARTI-IntroducingTheSubject:
TheFruitlessReader&TheShallowCritic
1. Mostreadersaremererepositoriesoffactsandstatementsmadebyotherpeople.Butthisisnotstudy.Thestudentistoreadthefactswithaviewtocreate,andnotwiththeobjectoffruitlessretention.
2. Studentslikesatellitesshouldreflectwhateverlighttheytheyreceivefromauthorsandnotimprisonthefactsandthoughts....Thoughtisprogressive.Theauthor'sthoughtmusthaveprogressinthereaderintheshapeofcorrectionordevelopment.Heisthebestcriticwhocanshowthefurtherdevelopmentofanoldthought;butameredenounceristheenemyofprogressandconsequentlyofNature.
3. "Beginanew,"saysthecritic,becausetheoldmasonrydoesnotansweratpresent.Lettheoldauthorbeburiedbecausehistimeisgone.Theseareshallowexpressions.Progressiscertainlythelawofnatureandtheremustbecorrectionsanddevelopmentswiththeprogressoftime.Butprogressmeansgoingfurtherorrisinghigher.
4. Now,ifwearetofollowourfoolishcritic,wearetogobacktoourformerterminusandmakeanewrace,andwhenwehaverunhalftherace,anothercriticofhisstampwillcryout:"Beginanewbecausethewrongroadhasbeentaken.Inthiswayourstupidcriticswillneverallowustogooverthewholeroadandseewhatisintheotherterminus.Thustheshallowcriticandthefruitlessreaderarethetwogreatenemiesofprogress.Wemustshunthem.
TheTrueCritic&TheUsefulReader
1. Thetruecritic,ontheotherhand,advisesustopreservewhatwehavealreadyobtained,andtoadjustourracefromthatpointwherewehavearrivedin
![Page 3: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
theheatofourprogress.Hewillneveradviseustogobacktothepointwhencewestartedashefullyknowsthatinthatcasetherewillbeafruitlesslossofourvaluabletimeandlabor.Hewilldirecttheadjustmentoftheangleoftheraceatthepointwhereweare.
2. Thisisalsothecharacteristicoftheusefulstudent.Hewillreadanoldauthorandwillfindouthisexactpositionintheprogressofthought.Hewillneverproposetoburnthebookonthegroundthatitcontainsthoughtswhichareuseless.Nothoughtisuseless.Thoughtsaremeansbywhichweattainourobjects.Thereaderwhodenouncesabadthoughtdoesnotknowthatabadroadisevencapableofimprovementandconversionintoagoodone.
3. Thoughtswillnecessarilycontinuetobeanendlessseriesofmeansandobjectsintheprogressofhumanity.Thegreatreformerswillalwaysassertthattheyhavecomeoutnottodestroytheoldlaw,buttofulfillit.Valmiki,Vyāsa,Plato,Jesus,Mohamed,ConfuciusandCaitanyaMahāprabhuassertthefacteitherexpresslyorbytheirconduct.
TheBhāgavataMisunderstood:
1. TheBhāgavatalikeallreligiousworksandphilosophicalperformancesandwritingsofgreatmenhassufferedfromtheimprudentconductofuselessreadersandstupidcritics....Menofbrilliantthoughtshavepassedbytheworkinquestoftruthandphilosophy,buttheprejudicewhichtheyimbibedfromitsuselessreadersandtheirconduct(i.e.,sahajiyas),preventedthemfrommakingacandidinvestigation.
2. [...[T]ruthdoesnotbelongexclusivelytoanyindividualmanortoanynationorparticularrace.ItbelongstoGod,andmanwhetherinthePolesorontheEquator,hasarighttoclaimitasthepropertyofhisFather.]
3. TheBhāgavatahassufferedalikefromshallowcriticsbothIndianandforeign.Thatbookhasbeenaccursedanddenouncedbyagreatnumberofouryoungcountrymenwhohavescarcelyreaditscontentsandponderedoverthephilosophyonwhichitisfounded.Itisowingmostlytotheirimbibingan
![Page 4: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
unfoundedprejudiceagainstitwhentheywereinschool[undertheBritish].TheBhāgavata,asamatterofcourse,hasbeenheldinderisionbythoseteacherswhoaregenerallyofaninferiormindandintellect....Oh!Whatatroubletogetridofprejudicesgatheredinunripeyears!
5. Asfaraswecanunderstand,noenemyofVaiṣṇavismwillfindanybeautyintheBhāgavat.Thetruecriticisagenerousjudge,devoidofprejudicesandparty-spirit....[T]hecritic,inotherwords,shouldbeofthesamedispositionofmindasthatoftheauthorwhosemeritsheisrequiredtojudge.Thoughtshavedifferentways....BoththeChristianandtheVaiṣṇava[mayforinstance]utterthesamesentiment,buttheywillneverstopfightingwitheachother[simply]becausetheyhavearrivedattheircommonconclusionbydifferentwaysofthought.
6. Subjectsofphilosophyandtheologyarelikethepeaksoflargetoweringandinaccessiblemountainsstandinginthemidstofourplanetinvitingattentionandinvestigation.Thinkersandmenofdeepspeculationtaketheirobservationsthroughtheinstrumentsofreasonandconsciousness.Buttheytakedifferentpointswhentheycarryontheirwork.Thesepointsarepositionschalkedoutbythecircumstancesoftheirsocialandphilosophicallife,differentastheyareindifferentpartsoftheworld.
7. PlatolookedatthepeakofthespiritualquestionfromtheWestandVyāsamadetheobservationfromtheEast;soConfuciusdiditfromfurtherEast,andSchlegel,Spinoza,KantandGoethefromfurtherWest.Theseobservationsweremadeatdifferenttimesandbydifferentmeans,buttheconclusionisallthesameinasmuchastheobjectofobservationwasoneandthesame.TheyallhuntedaftertheGreatSpirit,theunconditionedSouloftheUniverse...,theabsolutereligion....
8. Itrequiresacandid,generous,piousandholyhearttofeelthebeautiesoftheirconclusions.Party-spirit,thatgreatenemyoftruth,willalwaysbaffletheattemptoftheinquirerwhotriestogathertruthfromreligiousworksofothernations,andwillmakehimbelievethatabsolutetruthisnowhereexceptinhisownreligiousbook....Thecritic,therefore,shouldhaveacomprehensive,good,generous,candid,impartialandsympatheticsoul.
![Page 5: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
WhatIstheBhāgavat?:
1. [ThetravelingcompanionofaEuropeanGentlemannewlyarrivedinIndia]willtellhimwithaserenelook,thattheBhāgavatisabookwhichhisOriyabearerdailyreadsintheeveningtoanumberofhearers.Itcontainsajargonofunintelligibleandsavageliteratureofthosemenwhopainttheirnoseswithsomesortofearthorsandal,andwearbeadsallovertheirbodiesinordertoprocuresalvationforthemselves.
2. Anotherofhiscompanions,whohastravelledalittleintheinterior,wouldimmediatelycontradicthimandsaythattheBhāgavatisaSanskritworkclaimedbyasectofmen,theGosvamis,whogiveMantras,likethePopesofItaly,tothecommonpeopleofBengal,andpardontheirsinsonpaymentofgoldenoughtodefraytheirsocialexpenses.
3. AyoungBengali,chainedupinEnglishthoughtsandideas,andwhollyignorantofthePre-Mohammedanhistoryofhisowncountry,willaddonemoreexplanationbysayingthattheBhāgavatisabookcontaininganaccountofthelifeofKṛṣṇa,whowasanambitiousandimmoralman!Thisisallthathecouldgatherfromhisgrandmotherwhileyethedidnotgotoschool!
4. ThusthegreatBhāgavateverremainsunknowntotheforeignersliketheelephantofthesixblindwhocaughtholdoftheseveralpartsofthebodyofthebeast!Buttruthiseternalandisneverinjuredbutforawhilebyignorance.
TheBhāgavatExplainsItself:
1. Itisthefruitofthetreeofthought(Vedas)mixedwiththenectarofthespeechofŚukadeva.Itisthetempleofspirituallove....[Itis]composedof
![Page 6: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
18,000Ślokas.ItcontainsthebestpartoftheVedasandVedanta.
2. TheBhāgavataispre-eminently"theBook"inIndia.Onceenterintoit,andyouaretransplanted,asitwere,intothespiritualworldwheregrossmatterhasnoexistence.ThetruefolloweroftheBhāgavatisaspiritualmanwhohasalreadycuthistemporaryconnectionwithphenomenalnature,andhasmadehimselftheinhabitantofthatregionwhereGodeternallyexistsandloves.Thismightyworkisfoundeduponinspirationanditssuperstructureisuponreflection.Tothecommonreaderithasnocharmsandisfullofdifficulty.Weare,therefore,obligedtostudyitdeeplythroughtheassistanceofsuchgreatcommentatorsasŚrīdharaSvāmīandŚrīCaitanyaMahāprabhuandHiscontemporaryfollowers.
3. NowŚrīCaitanyaMahāprabhu,thegreatpreacherofNadia,whohasbeenDeifiedbyHistalentedfollowers,tellsusthattheBhāgavatisfoundeduponthefourverseswhichVyāsareceivedfromNārada,themostlearnedofthecreatedbeings.HetellsusfurtherthatBrahmāpiercedthroughthewholeuniverseofmatterforyearsandyearsinquestofthefinalcauseoftheworld,butwhenhefailedtofinditabroad,helookedintotheconstructionofhisownspiritualnature,andthereheheardtheUniversalSpiritspeakinguntohim:
4. "...Iwasinthebeginningbeforeallspiritualandtemporalthingswerecreated,andaftertheyhavebeencreatedIaminthemallintheshapeoftheirexistenceandtruthfulness,andwhentheywillbeallgoneIshallremainfullasIwasandasIam.Whateverappearstobetruewithoutbeingarealfactitself,andwhateverisnotperceivedthoughitistrueinitselfaresubjectsofmyillusoryenergyofcreation,suchaslightanddarknessinthematerialworld."
5. [LikeBrahmā,Vyāsaalso]fellbackintohisownselfandsearchedhisownspiritualnatureandthenitwasthattheabovetruthwascommunicatedtohimforhisowngoodandthegoodoftheworld.Thesageimmediatelyperceivedthathisformerworksrequiredsupercessioninasmuchastheydidnotcontainthewholetruthandnothingbutthetruth.Inhisnewideaheobtainedthedevelopmentofhisformerideaofreligion.HecommencedtheBhāgavatinpursuanceofthischange.
![Page 7: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Sambandha,Abhidheya,Prayojana:
1. Thewholeofthisincomparableworkteachesus,accordingtoourGreatCaitanya,thethreegreattruthswhichcomposetheabsolutereligionofman.OurNadiapreachercallsthemSambandha,AbhidheyaandPrayojana,i.e.,therelationbetweenthecreatorandthecreated,thedutyofmantoGod,andtheprospectsofhumanity.
2. Inthesethreewordsissummedupthewholeoceanofhumanknowledgeasfarasithasbeenexploreduptothiseraofhumanprogress.ThesearethecardinalpointsofreligionandthewholeBhāgavatis,aswearetaughtbyŚrīCaitanya,anexplanation,bothbypreceptsandexamples,ofthesethreegreatpoints.
Sambandha-
1. [Throughout]theBhāgavatteachesusthatthereisonlyoneGodwithoutasecond,WhoisfullinHimselfandisandwillremainthesame.Timeandspace,whichprescribeconditionstocreatedobjectsaremuchbelowHissupremespiritualnature,whichisunconditionedandabsolute....
2. MāyāintervenesbetweenusandGodaslongaswearenotspiritual,andwhenweareabletobreakoffherbonds,we,eveninthismortalframe,learntocommuneinourspiritualnaturewiththeunconditionedandabsolute.No,Māyādoesnotmeanafalsethingonly,butitmeansconcealmentofeternaltruthaswell.
3. ThecreationisnotMāyāitselfbutissubjecttothatprinciple....Thetrueidealistmustbeadualistalso.HemustbelieveallthatheperceivesasnaturecreatedbyGodfullofspiritualessenceandrelations,buthemustnotbelievethattheoutwardappearanceisthetruth.TheBhāgavatteachesthatallthatwehealthilyperceiveistrue,butitsmaterialappearanceistransientandillusory....
![Page 8: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
4. NatureiseternallyspiritualbuttheinterventionofMāyāmakeshergrossandmaterial.Man,inhisprogress,attemptstoshakeoffthisgrossidea,childishandfoolishinitsnature,andbysubduingtheinterveningprincipleofMāyā,livesincontinualunionwithGodinhisspiritualnature....TheBhāgavatteachesusthisrelationbetweenmanandGod....ThisiscalledSambandha-jñānaoftheBhāgavat,orinotherwords,theknowledgeoftherelationsbetweentheconditionedandtheAbsolute.
Abhidheya-
1. ...[T]hesecondgreatprincipleinculcatedbytheBhāgavat[is]theprincipleofduty.ManmustspirituallyworshiphisGod.TherearethreewaysinwhichtheCreatorisworshipedbythecreated...accordingtotheconstitutionoftheirmind:[Asbrahman,paramātmā,andbhagavān.].
2. ThosewhoworshipGodasinfinitelygreatintheprincipleofadmirationcallHimbythenameofBrahman.Thismodeiscalledjñānaorknowledge.ThosewhoworshipGodastheUniversalSoulintheprincipleofspiritualunionwithhimgiveHimthenameofParamātmā.Thisisyoga.AndthosewhoworshipGodasallinallwithalltheirheart,bodyandstrengthstyleHimasBhagavān.Thislastprincipleisbhakti.ThebookthatprescribestherelationandworshipofBhagavān,procuresforitselfthenameBhāgavatandtheworshiperisalsocalledbythesamename.
3. ThesuperiorityoftheBhāgavatconsistsintheunitingofallsortsoftheisticworshipintooneexcellentprincipleinhumannature,whichpassesbythenameofBhakti.ThiswordhasnoequivalentintheEnglishlanguage.Piety,devotion,resignationandspiritualloveunalloyedwithanysortofpetitionexceptinthewayofrepentance,composethehighestprincipleofBhakti.TheBhāgavattellsustoworshipGodinthatgreatandinvaluableprinciple,whichisinfinitelysuperiortohumanknowledgeandtheprincipleofyoga.
4. ...[T]heprincipleofBhaktipasses[through]fivedistinctstagesinthecourseofitsdevelopmentintoitshighestandpurestform.Thenagainwhenitreachesthelastform,itissusceptibleoffurtherprogressfromthestageofprema
![Page 9: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
(love)tothatofMahābhāvawhichisinfactacompletetransitionintothespiritualuniversewhereGodaloneisthebride-groomofoursoul.ThevoluminousBhāgavatisnothingmorethanafullillustrationofthisprincipleofcontinualdevelopmentandprogressofthesoulfromgrossmattertotheAll-PerfectUniversalSpiritwhoisdistinguishedaspersonal,eternal,absolutelyfree,allpowerfulandallintelligent.
(MatterAsaDictionaryofSpirit):
5. [IntheBhāgavat]comparisonshavebeenmadewiththematerialworld,whichcannothelpbutconvincetheignorantandtheimpractical.Materialexamplesareabsolutelynecessaryfortheexplanationofspiritualideas.TheBhāgavatbelievesthatthespiritofnatureisthetruthinnatureandistheonlypracticalpartofit.
6. Thephenomenalappearanceofnatureistrulytheoretical,althoughithashadthegreatestclaimuponourbelieffromthedaysofinfancy.Theoutwardappearanceofnatureisnothingmorethanasureindexofitsspiritualface.Comparisonsarethereforenecessary.Nature,asitisbeforeoureyes,mustexplainthespirit,orelsethetruthwilleverremainconcealed,andmanwillneverrisefromhisboyhoodthoughhiswiskersandbeardgrowwhiteasthesnowsoftheHimalayas.
7. Thewholeintellectualandmoralphilosophyisexplainedbymatteritself....Allspiritualideasare...picturesfromthematerialworld,becausematterisadictionaryofspirit,andmaterialpicturesarebuttheshadowsofthespiritualaffairswhichourmaterialeyecarriesbacktoourspiritualperception.
8. GodinHisinfinitegoodnessandkindnesshasestablishedthisunfailingconnectionbetweenthetruthandtheshadowinordertoimpressuponustheeternaltruthwhichhehasreservedforus.Theclockexplainsthetime,thealphabetpointstothegatheredstoreofknowledge,thebeautifulsongofaharmoniumgivestheideaofeternalharmonyinthespiritworld,todayand
![Page 10: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
tomorrowandthedayaftertomorrow,[andthus]thrust[s]intoustheungraspedideaofeternity....[S]imilarly,materialpicturesimpressuponourspiritualnaturethetrulyspiritualideaofreligion.
9. ItisonthesereasonablegroundsthatVyāsaadoptedthemodeofexplainingourspiritualworshipwithsomesortsofmaterialphenomena,whichcorrespondwiththespiritualtruth.
10. IntheBhāgavatwehavebeenadvisedfirstofall,toconvertourselvesintomostgratefulservantsofGodasregardsourrelationtoourfellowbrethren.Ournaturehasbeendescribedasbearingthreedifferentphases:goodness,passionandignorance.Goodnessisthatpropertyinournaturewhichispurelygoodasfarasitcanbepureinourpresentstate.Passionisneithergoodnorbad.Ignoranceisevil....[I]tisourobjecttotrainup[our]affectionsandtendenciestothestandardofGoodness....
11. ...[W]eare[then]tolooktoalllivingbeingsinthesamelightinwhichwelooktoourselves,i.e.,wemustconvertourselfishnessintoallpossibledisinterestedactivitytowardsallaroundus.Love,charity,gooddeedsanddevotiontoGodwillbeouronlyaim.WethenbecometheservantsofGodbyobeyingHishighandholywishes.HerewebegintobeBhaktas....AllthisiscoveredbythetermAbhidheya,thesecondcardinalpointinthesupremereligion.
Prayojana-
1. Whatistheobjectofourspiritualdevelopment,ourprayer,ourdevotionandourunionwithGod?TheBhāgavattellsusthattheobjectisnotenjoymentorsorrow,butcontinualprogressinspiritualholinessandharmony.
2. Inthecommon-placebooksoftheHindureligion....wehavedescriptionsofalocalheavenandalocalhell;theHeavenasbeautifulasanythingonearthandtheHellaghastlyasanypictureofevil.BesidesthisHeavenwehavemany
![Page 11: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
moreplaceswheregoodsoulsaresentupinthewayofpromotion!Thereare84divisionsoftheHellitself,somemoredreadfulthantheoneMiltonhasdescribedinhis"ParadiseLost."
(ControversialPassagesConcerningDescriptionsofHell,etc.):
3. Thesearecertainlypoeticalandwereoriginallycreatedbytherulersofthecountryinordertocheckevildeedoftheignorantpeople,whoarenotabletounderstandtheconclusionsofphilosophy.ThereligionoftheBhāgavatisfreefromsuchapoetry.Indeed,insomeofthechapterswemeetwithdescriptionsofthesehellsandheavens,andaccountsofcurioustales,butwehavebeenwarnedsomewhereinthebooknottoacceptthemasrealfacts,butasinventionstooverawethewickedandtoimprovethesimpleandtheignorant.
4. TheBhāgavatcertainlytellsusofastateofrewardandpunishmentinthefutureaccordingtodeeds[performed]inourpresentsituation.Allpoeticinventions,besidesthisspiritualfact,havebeendescribedasstatementsborrowedfromotherworksinthhewayofpreservationofoldtraditionsinthebookwhichsupersededthemandputanendtothenecessityoftheirstorage.
5. IfthewholestockofHinduTheologicalworkswhichprecededtheBhāgavatwereburntliketheAlexandrianLibraryandthesacredBhāgavat[alonewas]preservedasitis,notapartofthephilosophyoftheHindus,exceptthatoftheatheisticsects,wouldbelost.TheBhāgavatthereforemaybestyledbothasareligiousworkand[as]acompendiumofallHinduhistoryandphilosophy.
6. TheBhāgavatdoesnotallowitsfollowerstoaskanythingfromGodexcepteternallovetowardsHim.Thekingdomoftheworld,thebeautiesofthelocalHeavens,andthesovereigntyoverthematerialworldareneverthesubjectsofVaiṣṇavaprayer.
![Page 12: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
7. TheVaiṣṇavameeklyandhumblysays,"Father,Master,God,FriendandHusbandofmysoul!Hallowedbythyname!IdonotapproachYouforanythingwhichYouhavealreadygivenme.IhavesinnedagainstYouandInowrepentandsolicitYourpardon.Letthyholinesstouchmysoulandmakemefreefromgrossness.LetmyspiritbedevotedmeeklytoYourHolyserviceinabsolutelovetowardsThee."
8. "IhavecalledYoumyGod,andletmysoulbewrappedupinadmirationatYourgreatness!IhaveaddressedYouasmyMasterandletmysoulbestronglydevotedtoYourservice.IhavecalledYoumyFriend,andletmysoulbeinreverentiallovetowardsYouandnotindreadorfear!IhavecalledyoumyHusbandandletmyspiritualnaturebeineternalunionwithYou,foreverlovingandneverdreading,orfeelingdisgust.Father,letmehavestrengthenoughtogouptoYouastheconsortofmysoul,sothatwemaybeoneineternallove!Peacetotheworld."
9. [TheVaiṣṇava]doesnotexpecttobethekingofacertainpartoftheuniverseafterhisdeath,nordoeshedreadalocalfieryandturbulenthell....[Noris]hisideaofsalvation[the]totalannihilationofpersonalexistence....TheVaiṣṇavaisthemeekestofallcreatures,devoidofallambition.HewantstoserveGodspirituallyafterdeath,ashehasservedHimbothinspiritandmatterwhilehere.Hisconstitutionis[spiritual]andhishighestobjectoflifeisdivineandholylove.
10. TheBhāgavat...affirmsthattheVaiṣṇavasoulwhenfreedfromgrossmatterwilldistinctlyexistnotintimeandspacebutspirituallyintheeternalkingdomofGodwhereloveislife,andhopeandcharityandcontinualecstacywithoutchangeareitsvariousmanifestations.
11. [InconsideringtheessenceofGod],twogreaterrorsstarebeforeusandfrightenusbacktoignoranceanditssatisfaction.OneofthemistheideathatGodisaboveallattributesbothmaterialandspiritualandisconsequentlyaboveallconception.Thisisanobleideabutuseless.IfGodisaboveconceptionandwithoutanysympathywiththeworld,how[explain]thiscreation,thisuniversecomposedofproperties,thedistinctionsandphasesofexistence,thedifferencesofvalue,etc.
12. TheothererroristhatGodisallattribute,i.e.,intelligence,truth,goodnessandpower.Thisisalsoaludicriousidea.Scatteredpropertiescannever
![Page 13: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
constituteaBeing.Itismoreimpossibleinthecaseof[opposing]principlessuchasJusticeandMercyandFulnessandCreativePower.
13. Thetruth,asstatedintheBhāgavat,isthatproperties,thoughmany[maybe]beligerent,areunitedinaSpiritualBeingwheretheyhavefullsympathyandharmony.Certainlythisisbeyondourcomprehension.ItissoowingtoournaturebeingfiniteandGodbeinginfinite....ThisisaglimpseoftruthandwemustregarditasTruthitself.Often,saysEmmerson,aglimpseoftruthisbetterthananarrangedsystemandheisright.
14. TheBhāgavathas,therefore,apersonal,all-intelligent,active,absolutelyfree,holy,good,all-powerful,omnipresent,justandmercifulandsupremelySpiritualDeitywithoutasecond--creating[and]preservingallthatisintheUniverse.ThehighestobjectoftheVaiṣṇavaistoservethatInfiniteBeingforeverspirituallyintheactivityofAbsoluteLove.
CriticismsoftheShallowCriticRegardingtheDeity:
1. Theshallowcriticsummarilyrejects[Vyāsa]asaman-worshiper.Hewouldgosofarastoscandalizehimasateacherofmaterialloveandlustandtheinjuriousprinciplesofexclusiveasceticism.
2. [Sucha]shallowcriticsmindwillundoubtedlybechangedifhebutreflectsupononegreatpoint,i.e.,howisitpossiblethataspiritualistoftheSchoolofVyāsa,teachingthebestprinciplesofTheism[throughout]theBhāgavata,andmakingthefourtextsquotedinthebeginningthefoundationofhismightywork,couldhaveforceduponthebeliefofmen[thenotion]thatthesensualconnectionbetweenamanwithcertainfemalesisthehighestobjectofworship?
3. Thisisimpossibledearcritic!VyāsacouldnothavetaughtthecommonVairāgitosetupaplaceofworshipwithanumberoffemales!Vyāsa,whocouldteachusrepeatedlyinthewholeofBhāgavatathatsensualpleasuresaremomentarylikethepleasuresofrubbingtheitchinghand,andthatman'shighestdutyistohavespirituallovewithGod,couldneverhaveprescribedtheworshipofsensualpleasures.Hisdescriptionsarespiritualandyoumustnotconnect
![Page 14: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
matterwith[them].
4. Yes[dearcritic],younoblypointtotheimmoraldeedsofthecommonVyragis,whocallthemselvesthefollowersoftheBhāgavataandthegreatCaitanya.YounoblytellusthatVyāsa,unlesspurelyexplained,mayleadthousandsofmenintogreattroubleintimetocome.Butdearcritic!Studythehistoryofagesandcountries!Wherehaveyoufoundthephilosopherandthereformerfullyunderstoodbythepeople?
5. WhetheryougivetheAbsoluteReligioninfigures,orsimpleexpressions,orteachitbymeansofbooksororalspeeches,theignorantandthethoughtlessmustdegradeit...."Truthisgood,"isanelementaltruthwhichiseasilygraspedbythecommonpeople.ButifyoutellacommonpatientthatGodisinfinitelyintelligentandpowerfulinHisspiritualnature,hewillconceiveadifferentideafromwhatyouentertainoftheexpression.Allhighertruths,thoughintuitive,requirepreviouseducationinthesimplerones....
![Page 15: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
PARTII-TheTeachingofŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam:
TheGreatDivisions:Relationship,Function&Fruit:
1. TheteachingofŚrīmad-Bhāgavatamfallsintothreedistinctpartsaccordingasittreatsof:1)SambandhaorRelationship;2)AbhidheyaortheFunctionorActivitythatpertainstotheRelationship;and,3)PrayojanaortheObjectorFruitofsuchActivity.
2. [InthecompilationofVedanta-sutra],theaphorismsoftheUpaniṣads,whichcontainthehighestteachingoftheVedicliterature,arepresentedintheformofasystematicbodyofknowledgeundertheheadingsofSambandha,AbhidheyaandPrayojana.InhisṢat-sandarbha,ŚrīJīvaGosvāmīhasappliedthesamemethodoftreatmenttothecontentsoftheŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam,whichisadmittedtobetheonlyauthenticbhasyaorexpositionoftheVedanta-sutra.
3. Thefirstofthe"SixSandarbhas,"theTattva-sandarbha,appliesitselftotheelucidationoftheepistemologyoftranscendentalknowledge....Ithasmadepossiblethecomparativestudyofreligionontheonlyadmissibleandscientificbasis.
TranscendentalEpistemology-ASummaryoftheTattva-sandarbha:
LordŚrīKṛṣṇaandHisThreePrincipleEnergies-
![Page 16: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
1. ŚrīKṛṣṇa,theUltimateReality,isOnewithoutasecond.[He]isdistinctfromHisenergy....ŚrīKṛṣṇaisthepredominatingAbsolute.HisenergyisthepredominatedAbsoluteinthethreepositionsofantaranga[internal],tatastha[marginal],andbahiranga[external]respectively.
2. AntarangaisthatwhichpertainstotheproperEntityoftheAbsolutePerson....Theliteralmeaningofthewordis"thatwhichbelongstotheinnerbody."Andthewordśāktiisrenderedas"power."
3. Tatasthameansliterally,"thatwhichisontheborder-lineasbetweenlandandwater."ThisintermediatepowerdoesnotbelongtoanydefinableregionofthePersonofŚrīKṛṣṇa.Itmanifestsitselfontheborder-linebetweentheinnerandtheouterbodyoftheAbsolute.
4. Thepowerthatmanifestsitselfontheouterbodyisbahiranga-śākti.Asthereisno[difference]betweentheBodyandtheEntityoftheAbsolutePerson,thedistinctionsasbetweentheinner,outerandmarginalpositionsofHisBodyareintermsoftherealizationofthheindividualsoul.
5. AlthoughŚrīKṛṣṇaisOnewithoutasecond,HehasHisownmultipleFormscorrespondingtothedegreeandvarietyofHissubjectivemanifestations.ThesubjectiveentityofŚrīKṛṣṇaisnotliabletoanytransformation.Hisdifferentformsare,therefore,aspectsoftheOneFormmanifestingThemselvestothedifferentaptitudesofHisservitors.
6. ButthepowerofŚrīKṛṣṇaistransformablebythewillofŚrīKṛṣṇa.Thesetransformationsofpowerinthecasesoftheinternalandmarginalenergiesareeternalprocesses.Inthecaseoftheexternalenergythetransformationsofpoweraretemporarymanifestations.
7. ThephenomenalworldistheproductoftheexternalpowerofŚrīKṛṣṇa.TheAbsoluteRealmisthetransformationoftheinnerpower.Individualsoulsarethetransformationsofthemarginalpower.[Thesejīvas]aretheeternalinfinitesimalemanationsofthemarginalpower,capableofsubserviencytotheinnerpower,butalsosusceptibletodissociationfromtheworkingsoftheinnerpower.
![Page 17: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
MethodsofApproachingtheAbsolute-
8. ŚrīKṛṣṇaisadvaya-jñāna,orabsoluteknowledge.Absoluteknowledgecannotbechallenged.Hecanonlybeapproachedbythemethodofcompleteself-surrender,bythereciprocal,otherwiseineligible,cognitionofindividualsouls.
9. Transcendentalepistemologyisdifferentiatedfromempiricepistemologywithrespecttorelationship(sambandha),function(abhidheya),andobject(prayojana),forthereasonthatitreferstoentitiesthatarelocatedbeyondthe[limited]rangeoftheassertivecognitiveendeavornormallypracticedbythedeludedpeopleofthisworldfortheirtemporarypurposes.
10. Bythepeculiaritiesoftheirinfinitesimality,essentiallyspiritualnature,andmarginalposition,allindividualsoulshavetheconstitutionaloptionofchoicebetweencompletesubservienceandactiveorpassivehostilitytoŚrīKṛṣṇa.Theseopposedaptitudesleadthemtotheadoptionofcorrespondinglydifferentmethodsfortherealizationoftherespectiveends.
TheMethodsofActive&PassiveHostility:
1. ThosemethodsthatareadoptedforthepracticeofactivehostilitytotheAbsolutearetermedpratyakṣa(directindividualsenseperception)andparokṣa(associatedcollectivesenseperceptionbymanypersonspastandpresent)....
2. Theaparokṣamethod(themethodofcessationfromindividualandcollectivesenseperception)leadstothepositionofneutrality.
3. ThepratyakṣaandparokṣamethodsarediametricallyopposedtothemethodsapprovedbytheBhāgavataforthesearchoftheTruth.
4. Theaparokṣamethodalsotendstoanunwholesomeandnegativeresultifitseekstostandonthemererejectionofthepratyakṣaandparokṣamethods
![Page 18: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
withouttryingtoprogresstowardsthepositivetranscendence.SuchinactivepolicywouldindeedbetantamounttothepracticeofpassivehostilitytotheAbsoluteandassuchisevenmorecondemnablethanopenhostility.
5. NomethodcanberecognizedassuitableforthequestoftheTruththatisactuatedmoreorlessbythepurposeofopposingtheAbsoluteSupremacyofŚrīKṛṣṇa.Inotherwords,individualsoulscannotrealizethesubjectivenatureoftheAbsoluteexceptbytheexerciseoftheirfullestsubserviencetoŚrīKṛṣṇaandHisinnerpower[internalenergy].
6. ThefailureoftheindividualsoulstofindtheTruthisbroughtaboutbytheirowninnateperversity.TheypossessperfectfreedomofchoiceasbetweencompletesubserviencetoŚrīKṛṣṇaandthepracticeofactiveorpassivehostilitytoHim.Thereisnootheralternativeopentothem.IftheychosetorefusetoservetheyhavetopracticehostilityorindifferencetowardstheAbsolute.
7. Theperverseindividualsoulisnotobstructedintheactiveexerciseofhisfreedomofchoice.Heisenabledtoexercisethefunctionsofhostilityandindifferencewithinconsistentdeterringlimits,bythewonderfulcontrivanceofthedeludingpowerofŚrīKṛṣṇa.
8. ThecontinueddeliberateexerciseofsuchhostilityandindifferencetowardstheAbsolutebythheperverseindividualsoulresultsnecessarilyinthesuicidalabdicationofallactivitiesbythedeliberateoffender.
TheMethodsofActive&PassiveSubservience:
1. ThemethodsthatareadoptedforpracticingactiveandcompletesubserviencetotheAbsolutearetermedrespectivelyasadhokṣaja(theexternalorreverentialmethodofservingtheTranscendentalObjectofworship)andaprakṛta(theinternalorconfidentialmethodofserviceoftheAbsolute).
2. Śrīmad-BhāgavataminculcatesanddivulgesthesearchoftheAbsolutebytheadhokṣajaandaprakṛtamethods.Itcondemnsthepratyakṣaandparokṣa
![Page 19: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
methods,butrecognizestheproperuseoftheaparokṣamethod[styledaspassivesubservience].
TheAscendingandDescendingProcesses:
1. Thepratyakṣa,parokṣaandthe[improper]passiveaparokṣamethodsarecollectivelycalledthearohaorascendingprocess.Theproperaparokṣa,adhokṣajaandaprakṛtimethodsconstitutetheavarohaordescendingprocess.
2. Byadoptionoftheascendingprocesstheperverseindividualsoulstrivestorealizehissuicidalendbythepositiveandnegativeperversemanipulationofmundaneexperiencegainedthroughdirectandindirectsenseperception.
3. BythedescendingprocessthesoulisenabledtostrivefortherealizationoftheunalloyedserviceoftheAbsolutebythehonestexerciseofhisunreservedreceptiveaptitudetotheInitiativeoftheAbsolutewhenHeispleasedtocomedowntotheplaneofhistinyperversecognition.
TheFruitsorObjectivesoftheDifferentMethods:
1. Thefruitsthatarerealizablebythedifferentmethodsofendeavorcorrespondtotheparticularmethodthatisfollowed.
2. Thepratyakṣaandparokṣamethodsaimatdharma(virtue),artha(utility)andkama(sensuousgratification).
3. Thewrongaparokṣamethodaimsatpseudo-mokṣa(annihilation).
4. Therightaparokṣamethodaimsatpositivetranscendence.
5. TheadhokṣajamethodaimsatbhaktiorreverentialtranscendentalserviceoftheAbsolute.
![Page 20: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
6. TheaprakṛtimethodhasinviewthherealizationofpremaorDivineLove.
TheDawningofPureTheismAsOpposedtoHostility:
1. PureTheismbeginswiththefirstappearanceofthepositivedesirefortheserviceoftheAbsolute,whoislocatedbeyondtherangeofoursensuousactivity.ItinvolvestheclearperceptionofthefactthatallempiricactivityisthedeliberatepracticeofperversehostilityagainsttheAbsolutesupremacyofŚrīKṛṣṇa.
2. ThewordadhokṣajawhichisappliedinŚrīmad-BhāgavatamtotheObjectofworshipreferstothefactthatŚrīKṛṣṇahasreservedtherightofnotbeingexposedtohumansenses.
3. ThetheisticmethodsalonethusapplytotheproperEntityoftheAbsolute.ThosewhoareinrebellionagainstthesupremacyofŚrīKṛṣṇabytheadoptionofsensuousactivityarepreventedfromallaccesstoHispresencebytheoperationof[theLord's]deludingpower[externalenergy].
4. Theindividualsoulisalwayssuseptibletobeingthusdeludedbymāyā,thelimitingormeasuringpotency.TheconditionsforthepracticeofsensuousactivitiesinthisrealmoffiniteexistenceareprovidedbyMāyāforthecorrectionofthesuicidalperversityoftherebellioussouls.
5. ItisinthismannerthatapersonwhoisaversetotheserviceofŚrīKṛṣṇaismadetoproceedalongthetracksofkarmaandjñānabytheascendingprocess,[sothathewillgain]thebitterexperienceofthepracticeofperversehostilitytoŚrīKṛṣṇaand[to]hisownself.
6. Thisworldisinhabitedbypersonswhoaredeliberatelyaddictedtothissuicidalcourse.Theyareunconditionallycommittedtotheascendingprocessforsojourninginthisrealmofnescience.Themethodisfurthercharacterizedbythehypocriticalassumptionofthevalidityofexperiencederivedthroughthesensesforprovidingprogressiveguidanceinthequest[for]astateofperfectfelicity.
![Page 21: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
7. ThemethodofquestinwhichtheTruthHimselftakestheInitiativeistermedtheavarohaordescendingprocess.TheindividualsoulcanhavenoaccesstotheAbsolutebyreasonofhisinfinitesimality,dissociablemarginalposition,andhisownnatureasanemanationofpower.Hecan,however,haveaviewoftheTruthiftheAbsoluteispleasedtomanifestHisdescenttotheplaneofhistinycognition.
8. RealtheismcannotbegintilltheindividualsoulisenabledbythedescentoftheAbsolutetohavetheopportunityforHisservice.TheAbsolutemanifestsHisdescentintheFormoftheNameortheTranscendentalDivineSoundonthelipsofHispuredevotees.
9. Dikṣa,orthecommunicationoftheknowledgeoftheTranscendentalintheFormoftheSoundtothesubmissivereceptivecognitionoftheindividualsoulbyauthoizedagentsoftheAbsolute,istheVedicmodeofinitiationintoTranscendentalKnowledge.
10. TheNameistheObjectofworshipofallpuresouls.ThetranscendentalserviceoftheName,orbhakti,istheproperfunctionofallsoulsandtheonlymodeofquestoftheTruth.ThepursuitofthisrightmethodofquestleadstoagrowingperfectionofbhaktiandprogressiverealizationofthesubjectivenatureoftheObjectofworship.
Brahman,Paramātmā&Bhagavān:
1. TheUltimateRealityistermed...asbrahman,paramātmāandbhagavān.TheBrahmanconceptionstressesthenecessityofexcludingthedeluded,concrete,limitedexperienceofthefollowersofapparenttruth.TheconceptionofParamātmāseekstoestablishatangibleconnectionbetweenthistemporalworldandtheUltimateReality.Bothoftheseconceptionspresentnotonlyanimperfect,butalsoagrosslymisleadingviewoftheAbsolute.
2. TheconceptionofBhavagānasTranscendentalPersonalitywhois
![Page 22: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
approachablebyśuddha-bhaktiorunalloyeddevotionofthesoul,correspondstothecompleterealizationoftheAbsolutewhichnecessarilyalsoaccomadatesandsupplementsthherivalconceptsofBrahmanandParamātmā.
3. TheBrahmanconceptionismisunderstoodbyexclusivemonists(kevalādvaitaoftheŚaṅkaraschool)whoquitedisingeniouslyassumethattheconceptiondeniedtheTranscendentalPersonalityandFigureoftheAbsolute.
4. TherootoftheerrorliesinthefearoftheimpersonaliststhatifconcretenessintheAbsoluteisadmitted,suchanadmissionwouldleadtotheimportationoftheundesireablefeaturesofapparenttruth(experiencedbythemethodsofsensuousperception)intothetranscendentalconceptionoftheAbsoluteRealityfavoredbythescriptures.
5. Themethodofśuddha-bhakti,whilerecognizingfullythenecessityofadmittingtheTranscendentalNatureoftheUltimateReality,doesnotdenytheimmanenttranscendentalconnectionoftheAbsolutewithmanifestmundaneexistence(whichideaisfoundintheYogi'sconceptionofParamātmā,butinawrongandoffensiveformulation).
6. TheconceptionofBhagavān,realizedbytheprocessofśuddha-bhakti,harmonizestheserespectiverequirementsassecondaryfeaturesoftheProperTranscendentalPersonalityoftheAbsolute.Theadhokṣajaandaprakṛtamethodsofquest,alonetendtosuchrealization.
Sambandha,Abhidheya,andPrayojanaDefinedInTermsoftheBhāgavata:
1. Sambandha,orrelationship,impliesanumericalreference.TheUltimateRealityisOnewithoutasecond,thoughtheaspectsoftheAbsolutemayprovedifferentindifferenteyes.TheunityoftheUltimateRealitycarriesasimilaritytotheintegerofmathematicalconception,denotingHimselfastheObjectofworship(ŚrīKṛṣṇa),andconnotingHisśaktīinherthreeaspectsandher
![Page 23: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
transformationsandproducts.
2. Under"relationship,"therefore,comeallthosepartsoftheteachingoftheBhāgavatathatrevealtheknowledgeofthesubjectivenatureofŚrīKṛṣṇa,thesubjectivenatureofHisśaktī,orpower,inallherthreeaspects,andthesubjectivenatureoftheactivitiesofthhedifferentaspectsofpower.
3. Underabhidheya,orfunction,areincludedallthosepartsoftheteachingofŚrīmad-Bhāgavatamwhichrevealthenatureoftranscendentalworshipand,negatively,oftheactivityofaversiontoŚrīKṛṣṇa.
4. Underprayojana,orfruit,areincludedthoseportionsoftheteachingofŚrīmad-Bhāgavatamthatdealwithprema,orspiritualloveand,negatively,withdharma(virtue),artha(materialutility),kāma(lust),andmokṣa(mergingintheAbsolute).
SambandhaorRelationship:
1. TheworshipofŚrīKṛṣṇaistheonlyfull-fledged,unadulteratedfunctionofallsouls--theonlycompletetheisticworship.Allotherformsofworshiprepresenttheinfinityofgradationsofapproachtowardsthiscomplete[formof]worship.
2. Puretheism,involvingtheactivereciprocalrelationshipofthesoulwiththeDivinity,doesnotbeginuntilthereisactualrealizationoftheTranscendentalPersonalityofBhagavānŚrīKṛṣṇa.ThedegreeofthisrealizationcorrespondstothatofthelovingaptitudeofHisworshiper.
(LordŚrīKṛṣṇa,theSupremePersonalityofGodhead):
![Page 24: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
3. TheProperFigureofŚrīKṛṣṇa(Svayam-rūpa)isidenticalwiththeEntityofKṛṣṇa,andisOnewithoutasecond.ThereisaninfinityofAspectsoftheDivineFigurethatemanatefromtheFigure-in-Himself(Svayam-rūpa).ThesepluralaspectsoftheDivineFigureareofthenatureofIdentities,Manifestations,Expansions,PlenaryParts,PlenaryPartsofParts,DescendingDivinities(avatāras),etc.TheseDivineAspects,WhoarepartandparceloftheDivinityinHisfulness,areworshipedbythecorrespondingaptitudesofloveofTheirrespectiveworshipers.
4. [Justasa]relationshipofservicesubsistsbetweenŚrīKṛṣṇaandHispower(śaktī)inallheraspectsandtransformations,[similarly][t]heinfiniteAspectsoftheDivinePersonalityHimself,emanatingfromtheFigure-in-Himself(Svayam-rūpa),arerelatedtoŚrīKṛṣṇaasServitor-DivinitiesWhoarepossessorsofpower.
5. TheseDivinePersonsshowanorderofclassificationintothecategoriesofSvayam-prakāṣa(Manifestation-in-Himself),Tadekātma-rūpa(EssentiallyIdenticalFigure),andAveṣa-rūpa(TheFigureofDivineSuper-imposition).Ofthese,Svayam-prakāṣais,asitwere,theotherselfofSvayam-rūpa,andisalsoOnewithoutasecond.Tadekātma-rūpaandAveṣa-rūpaaremultifarious.
6. EachoftheseDivinePersonspossessesHisownabsoluterealm(Vaikuṇṭha)whereHeisservedbytheinfinityofHisservitors.TheseVaikuṇṭhastranscendthecountlessworldsoffiniteexistenceconstitutingtherealmofthedeludingpower.
7. ŚrīKṛṣṇaispossessedof64DivineExcellences.ŚrīNārāyaṇa,theSupremeObjectofreverentialworship,possesses60ofthefullperfectionsofDivineExcellence.BrahmāandRudra,whowieldthedelegatedpowersofmundanecreationanddestruction,possess55Excellences,butnotintheirfulldivinemeasure.Individualsouls(jīvas)possess50oftheExcellencesofKṛṣṇainaninfinitesimalmeasure.
8. ThecluetotheSupremeExcellenceofthePersonalityofŚrīKṛṣṇaissuppliedbytheprincipleofRasawhichisdefinedbyŚrīRūpaas"thatecstaticprincipleofconcentrateddeliciousnessthatistastedbyŚrīKṛṣṇaandinsequelreciprocatedbytheservingindividualsoulontheplanethattranscendsmundanethought."ŚrīKṛṣṇaistheFigure-in-HimselfofthewholecompassofthenectarineprincipleofRasa.TheFigureofKṛṣṇaexcelsallHisotherAspectsof
![Page 25: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
HisDivinePersonalitybybeingtheSupremeRepositoryofalltheRasas.
(ThePrincipleofRādhā-Kṛṣṇa):
9. TheSupremePossessorofpower,ŚrīKṛṣṇa,isinseparablycoupledwithHisantaranga-śaktī,orpowerinheringinHisOwnproperFigure.Śrīmad-Bhāgavatamreferstotheserviceofoneparticulargopī(lit.,onewhoisfullyeligiblefortheserviceofŚrīKṛṣṇa)beingpreferredbyŚrīKṛṣṇaabovealltheothergopīs.
10. Inotherwords,antaranga-śaktīisoneandall-perfect.Sheisthe"predominatedAbsolute."Shehasherownspecificfigure,viz.,thatofŚrīRādhikā.Thetwoaspectsoftheantarangā-orsvarupa-śaktī,namely,tataṣthā-śaktīandmāyā-orbahirangā-śaktī,revealthemselvesintheintermediateandouterregionsoftheDivineFigure.
(TheIndividualJīvaSoul):
11. Jīvasorindividualsoulsaredetachable,infinitesimalemanationsofthetataṣthā-śaktī,sharingtheessenceoftheplenaryspiritualpower.[They]appearontheborder-linebetweentheinnerandouterzonesofdivinepower.Theyhavenolocusstandiintheirnascentortataṣthāstate.Theyareeternallyexposedtotheoppositeattractionsofsvarupa-śaktīandmāyā-śaktīatthetwopoles.
12. Theirproperaffinityiswithsvarupa-śaktī,buttheyaresusceptibletobeoverpoweredbymāyā-śaktī,attheiroption.Iftheychoosetobethesubservientsofmāyā-śaktī,theyaresubjectedtoignoranceoftheirpropernaturewhichresultsinconfirmedaversiontotheserviceofŚrīKṛṣṇa.Inthismannerisbroughtaboutthedeludedconditionofindividualsoulswhosojournintherealmofmāyā.
![Page 26: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
13. Theconstitutionsofindividualsoulsintheirnascentstate,andtherealmofmāyāarecomparabletotheouterpenumbralandtheshadowyzonesrespectivelyofthesun,whilethepositionofantarangā-śaktīisliketheinnerballoflightwhichistheproperabodeoftheSun-god,whocorrespondstoŚrīKṛṣṇa[inthisanalogy].
14. Individualsoulsaredetachable,infinitesimalemanationsofthemarginalpowerlocatedontheborder-lineandexposedtotheoppositepullsoftheinternalandexternalenergies.Theyaredistinctfromtheplenaryemanations,manifestationsandmultiplesoftheinternalenergyontheonehand,andfromtheproductsoftheexternalenergyontheother.
15. Theindividualsoul,inhisnascentmarginalposition,isconfrontedwiththealternativeofchoicebetweensubserviencetotheplenarypowerontheonehandandapparentdominationoverthedeludingpowerontheother.Whenhechoosesthelatteralternative,heforgetshisrelationshipofsubserviencetotheinnerpowerandhissubserviencetoŚrīKṛṣṇathroughsuchsubservience.
16. ItisneverpossiblefortheconditionedsoultounderstandthenatureoftheserviceofŚrīKṛṣṇathatisrenderedbyHisinnerpower.Thereis,therefore,acategoricaldistinctionbetweenthefunctionofindividualsoulsandthatoftheinnerpower,evenontheplaneofservice.
17. IntheworksofthefollowersofŚrīCaitanyaMahāprabhuwhopropoundedtheschoolofacintya-bhedābheda-tattva(simultaneousonenessanddifference)thesubjectoftheworkingoftheinnerpowerandindividualsoulshasbeentreatedinallitsdetails.ThecluetothecomparativestudyoftheworkingofpoweronthetranscendentalplaneissuppliedbythheaccountoftherāsadanceinŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam.
18. Whentheindividualsoulchoosesunreservedsubserviencetotheinnerpower,hehasaccesstotheserviceoftheuntamperedPersonalityoftheAbsolute.Thekaivalyastate,mentionedinŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam,isthestateofunalloyeddevotiontotheuntamperedPersonalityoftheAbsolute.
(HowtheMonistsMisunderstandKṛṇṣa-līlā):
![Page 27: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
19. Exclusivemonistsimaginethatthefigureoftheobjectofworshipexistsonlyinthemundaneworldandthatinthefinalpositionthereisalsonoactivityofworship.Inotherwords,theydenythepossibilityofthelīlā,ortheeternaltranscendentalactivitiesofŚrīKṛṣṇa.
20. Śrīmad-Bhāgavatamflatlydeniesthisgroundlesscontentioninthemostexplicitterms.Thereistotalabsenceofallmundanereferenceinthetranscendentalactivityofśuddha-bhakti.
21. Thewordactivityisnotexpressiveoflīlā.Itcorrespondstokriyāormundaneactivity.Transcendentalactivitiyhasneitherbeginningorend.Thereis,ofcourse,relativityinlīlā,butitisnottheunwholesomerelativityofmundaneactivityorkriyā.Thenotionthatlilācanhaveanendorterminationisduetoignorantconfusionbetweentheconceptionsoflīlāandkriyā.
22. Śuddha-bhaktibelongstothecategoryoflīlā.InVṛndāvanathegopīsserveŚrīKṛṣṇabyunconventionalamorouslove.Thesuper-excellenceofthisservicecannotbeadmittediftheabsolutelywholesomenatureofallunalloyedactivityontheplaneofVrajaisdisbelieved,onprinciple,byone'signorantperversejudgement.
(TheTranscendentalPurposeofVarṇāśrama):
23. Thefunctionofconditionedsoulsisoftwokinds.Thefunctionthatisprovidedbythevarṇāśramasystemforconditionedsoulsisnotopposedtośuddha-bhakti.Śrīmad-Bhāgavatamhastreatedthevarṇāśramasystemfromthepointofviewofunalloyeddevotion.Therebyithasprovidedanintelligentwayofviewingthesituationofconditionedsoulsduringtheirsojourntothemundaneworld.
24. ThespiritualvalueofthevarṇāśramasystemisduetothefactthatitadmitsthepossibilityoftheactivityofconditionedsoulsbeingendowedwithreflectedspiritualqualitybybeingdirectedtowardstheunalloyedserviceoftheAbsolute
![Page 28: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
onthetranscendentalplane.
25. Itisthepurposeofthevarṇāśramaregulationtoimpartthisdirectiontotheactivityoftheconditionedsouls.ThecrucialnatureofthistheisticpurposeofthevarṇāśramaarrangementisfullytreatedinŚrīmad-Bhāgavatam.Itisnotexplicitlytreatedinanyotherśāstricwork.
AbhidheyaorFunction:
(Unalloyed,VarṇāśramaandIgnorantFunctionsoftheSoul):
1. Śuddha-bhaktiistheonlyproperfunctionofallunalloyedindividualsoulsandislocatedontheplaneoftranscendence.ButallanimatelifeformsarepotentiallyeligibleforthetranscendentalserviceoftheAbsolute.
2. Varṇāśramalifeisnottheunalloyedspirituallifethatisledbyfullyliberatedsouls.Itisthestagepreparatorytosuchlife.Neitherisitonaparwiththelifeofunmixedsensuousnessthatisledbypeopleoutsidethevarṇāśramasociety.
3. EveryformofactivityofconditionedsoulsoutsidethevarṇāśramasystemisinspiredbymeaninglessmalicioushostilitytotheAbsolute.Allsuchactivityisnecessarilyatheistical.ThismundaneworldisthecongenialsphereforthepracticeofthedeludeddominatingactivitythatiscovetedbyconditionedsoulsforpracticingactiveaversiontowardstheAbsolute.Theconditionsforsuchactivityaresuppliedbythedeludingpower.Theyconstitutetherealmofnescience,spiritualignoranceoracit.
4. Butassoonastheactivityofcit,oruneclipsedcognitionisarousedinthespiritualessenceofthemisguidedsoul,itdissipatesbyitsappearancesuchwrongaddictiontotheignorantactivitiesofthisworldandalsothesusceptibilityofbeingtemptedbythedeludingpower.
![Page 29: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
5. Thereisnocommongroundbetweentheunalloyedspiritualfunctionandtheactivityofconditionedsoulsinthegripofnescience.Theonedoesnotdove-tailintotheother.Itisforthisreasonthattheunalloyedspiritualfunctioncanneverbeunderstoodbytheresourcesofthearchaeologists,historians,allegorists,philosophers,etc.,ofthisworld.
6. SuchempiricspeculationstamperwiththetranscendentalPersonalityoftheAbsolute.TheybelongtotherealmofnescienceandconstitutetheactivedenialoftheEntityoftheAbsolute.Byindulginginsuchspeculationsourspiritualnatureisdeprivedofitsproperfunction.
7. Conductenjoinedbythevarṇāśramasystemiscalculatedtocounteracttheinherentatheisticaltrendofallworldlyactivitieswhichareunavoidableintheconditionedstate.
8. Activitiesthatarepromptedbytheurgeforsensuousenjoymentcreatethediscordantdiversityofthisworld.Onewhoisaddictedtoworldlyenjoymenthasadeludedwayoflookingateverything.WhensuchapersonisestablishedintheproperactivityofhisunalloyedspiritualnaturetowardshisTranscendentalMaster,theonlyRecipientofallwillingserviceintheeternalworld,thetrueviewofeverythingisrevealedtohisservingvision.Therecanbenoignoranceandmiseryiftheworldisviewedaright.
9. Theurgeforsensuousenjoymentexpressesitselfintheinstitutionsoffamilyandsocietyofworldly-mindedpersons.Theyaretrapsofthedeludingenergy.ButtheseverytrapsareusedasinstrumentsofservicetotheABsolutebytheawakenedsoul.
10. ThehymnsoftheBhāgavataalwaysrevealtheeternalserviceoftheAbsoluteonthehighestplane,identicalwiththePersonalityofŚrīGaurasundara,totheenlightenedsoul....ThelanguageofŚrīmad-Bhāgavatamrevealsitstruemeaningonlytotheenlightenedsoul.Thatmeaningisverydifferentfromwhateventhemostrenownedlinguistsmaysupposeittobeintheirblindempiricvanity.
(TheNatureofTranscendentalVraja-līlā):
![Page 30: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
11. TheBhāgavatagivesthehighestpositiontotheserviceofŚrīKṛṣṇabythegopīsofVṛndāvana.Initsaccountoftherāsadance,itgivesthecluetothedistinctivenatureoftheservicesofŚrīRādhikāandtheothermilkmaids.
12. ŚrīKṛṣṇaisservedbyŚrīRādhikābyherselfandsimultaneouslybyhermultiplebodilyformsintheshapesoftheresidentsofVraja.Theservicesoftheothermilkmaids,ofNandaandYaśodā,ofŚrīdamaandSudama,andofalltheassociatesandservitorsofKṛṣṇainVraja,arepartandparceloftheserviceofŚrīRādhikā.
13. ŚrīGurudevabelongstothisinnergroupofservitors.HeisthedivinemanifestedentityfordisclosingtheformsandactivitiesofalleternalservitorsofŚrīKṛṣṇa.ThefunctionofŚrīGurudevaisafundamentalfactinthelīlāofVrajawhereŚrīKṛṣṇaisservedastheemporiumofalltherāsas.TheservitorsofVrajaministertothegratificationofthesensesofKṛṣṇaineveryway.ŚrīGurudevaisthedivineexcitingagentoftheservingactivityofVraja.
14. [ThenatureofTranscendentalVrajaLīlāisliabletobemisunderstoodbytheempiricstudyoftheBhāgavata.Thelimitofempiricinferenceisreachedbythespeculationsoftheparokṣamethod.Bytheabandonmentofempiricism,representedbytheaparokṣamethod,theBrahmanandParamātmāconceptionsarerealized.Butthesealsoarenotobjectsofworship.]
15. [Wehavealreadyseenthattheactivityofserviceispossibleonlyontheplaneofadhokṣaja,whichyieldstherealizationoftheMajesticPersonalityoftheAbsoluteasŚrīNārāyaṇa.Aprakṛta-vraja-līlā,thecentraltopicoftheBhāgavataisthehighestformofadhokṣajarealization.]
(TranscendentalandMundaneSexuality):
16. ThedalliancesofŚrīKṛṣṇainVrajahaveacloseresemblancetounconventionalmundaneamour.Sexuality,inallitsforms,isanessentiallyrepulsiveaffaironthemundaneplane.Itis,therefore,impossibletounderstand
![Page 31: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
howthecorrespondingtranscendentalactivitycanbethemostexquisitelywholesomeserviceoftheAbsolute.
17. Itis,however,possibletobereconciled,tosomeextent,tothetruthofthenarrativeoftheBhāgavataifwearepreparedtoadmitthereasonablenessofthedoctrinethatthemundaneworldistheunwholesomereflectionoftherealmoftheAbsolute,andthatthisworldappearsinascaleofvaluesthatisthereverseofthatwhichobtainsintherealityofwhichithappenstobetheshadow.
18. IntheformofthenarrativeoftheBhāgavata,theTranscendentalVraja-līlāmanifestsitsdescenttotheplaneofourmundanevisioninsymbolicshapesresemblingthoseofthecorrespondingmundaneevents.
19. Ifwearedisposed,foranyreason,tounderestimatethetranscendentalsymbolismofthenarrativeoftheBhāgavata,weareunabletoavoidunfavorableandhastyconclusionsregardingthenatureofthehighest,themostperfectandthemostcharmingformofthelovingserviceoftheDivinitytowhichallotherformsofHisserviceareastheavenuesofapproach.
20. Sexualitysymolizesthehighestattractionandtheacmeofdeliciousnessintranscendentalservice.IntheamorousperformancesofVraja,thesecretsoftheeternallifeareexhibitedintheiruncoveredperfectionintheactivityoftheloveofunalloyedsouls.
21. Wemaynotice,inpassing,certainsignificantdifferencesbetweenŚrīKṛṣṇa'samorousdalliancesandmundanesexactivitywhichshouldpreventanyhastyconclusions:1)InVraja-līlā,ŚrīKṛṣṇaisundertheageofelevenyears;and,2)ThespiritualmilkmaidsneverconceiveandbearchildrentoŚrīKṛṣṇa(thechildrenbornofŚrīKṛṣṇabelongtothelessperfectlīlāofDvaraka).
22. TosupposetheDivinelīlātobeaproductofanthropomorphicspeculationisthegreatestoffense.TheBhāgavtadeclaresthattherealizationofthetruenatureoftheVraja-līlā,inpursuanceoftheśrautamethod,istheonlyremedyforallconditionedsoulsafflictedwiththediseaseofmundanesexuality.
23. Theconventionsofcivilizedsocietyfortheregulationofsexualrelationshipsattaintheirethicalperfectioninthevarṇāśramaarrangement.ThusapersonbelongingtothevarṇāśramasocietycanreadilyappreciatethetransparentmoralpurityoflifeontheplaneofVaikuṇṭhaandAyodhya,
![Page 32: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
althoughhecannotunderstandtheiresotericnature.Inthoserealms,theGodheadposesastheidealmonogamoushusband.
24. TheethicalrestrictionsofsexrelationshipsthatareimposedatAyodhyabytheformofthemonogamousmarriagearerelaxedatDvarakawheretheABsolutemanifestsHisfullerPersonalityandappearsintheguiseofthepolygamoushusband.
25. TheconventionsofmarriageareabrogatedaltogetherinVṛndāvanawherethesanctityofwedlockbecomessecondaryandafoiltotheamorousexploitsofŚrīKṛṣṇainHisfullestmanifestation.
26. Thespiritualfunctioninitsunalloyedformhasarealcorrespondencetomundaneactivity,withthedistinctionthatitsobjective,modeofactivityandinstrumentalareunalloyedspirit.Thismakestheinconceivabledifferencebetweenthespiritualfunctionandmundaneactivity.ItalsosuppliesakindofexplanationforthefactthatthoseactivitiesinVrajawhichcorrespondtothemostwholesomeperformancesonthemundaneplane,arecomparativelyspeakingtheleastpleasinginthesightofŚrīKṛṣṇa.
(ThePlaneofMundaneEnjoymentandthePlaneofSpiritualService):
27. ThesoleobjectofallspiritualactivityisgratificationofthesensesofŚrīKṛṣṇa.WhenŚrīKṛṣṇaispleased,Hisservitorsexperienceunmixedjoy.Thisisthereverseofwhathappensinthisworld.Activitythatyieldsenjoymenttothepersonindulginginthesamealonepossessesattractiononthemundaneplane.Butsuchselfishpleasureisnevercovetedontheplaneofspiritualservice.
28. Theplaneofmundanesensuousenjoymentistherebysharplydifferentiatedfromthatofspiritualservicewithrespecttothequalityandorientationoftheirrespectiveactivities.Desireformundaneenjoymentispotentially,butuncongenially,inherentinthesoul.Anditcanbecultivatedathisoption.Thepracticeofit,however,leadstotheabeyanceofhistrulynaturalserving
![Page 33: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
function.
29. Moderncivilizationdoesnotsuspectitsowndegradationinseekingexclusivelyformundaneenjoyment.Themindandbodyofmanhaveanaturalaptitudeforsensuousgratification,andallhisordinarymundaneactivitiesarepracticedforitsrealization.[Thus]few...cangrasp[thefactthat]theunalloyedessenceofthesoulhasanaturalaptitudefortheexclusiveserviceoftheAbsolutewhichisutterlyincompatiblewithmundanesensuousliving.
30. InthetranscendentalserviceoftheAbsolutetheaptitude,form,aswellasingredientsareuncoveredabsolutelywholesomelivingreality.Inthiscompleteuncoveringofthepropernatureofapersonbytheperfectionofhisservingfunction,heisenabledtorealizefullytheabidinginterestsofhisrealentity[orself].SuchunconditionalsubmissiveactivitytowardstheAbsoluteisalsonecessarilyidenticalwiththerealizationoftheperfectfreedomofthesoul,whichexpressesitselfinthehighestformsofhisservingactivity.
PrayojanaorFruit:
1. InthepositionofcompleterealizationoftheactivityoftheuncoveredsoulapersonbecomeseligibleforparticipationintheTranscendentalpastimesorlīlāofŚrīKṛṣṇa....Therealizationofthisall-absorbingloveforŚrīKṛṣṇaistheFRUITorprayojanaoftheeternalspiritualactivitiesofallpuresouls.
2. ŚrīKṛṣṇaisdirectlyservedbyHisplenaryinnerpowerasHisonlyconsort.TheresidentsofVraja,theplaneofthisinnerservice,areextensionsofthefigureoftheplenaryDivinepower.Theyarethedivineparticipantsinthedivinepastimes,asallthoseentitiesdisplaythenatureofthefullservitorshipoftheDivinity.
3. Notsothesoulsofmen,allofwhomaresusceptibletothetemptationsofferedbythedeludingfaceoftheplenarypowerforpreventingtheaccessofthenon-residentsofVrajatothearenaoftheDivinepastimes.We,the
![Page 34: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
sojournersofthismundaneplane,havebeenthuskeptoutoftheplaneofVrajabythedeludingfaceoftheDivinePower.
4. IndividualsoulswhoarenotpartandparceloftheinnerplenarypowerhavenoautomaticaccesstotheplaneofVraja.TheyarealsolackinginspontaneousloveforŚrīKṛṣṇa.ItispossibleforthemtoattaintotheloveofŚrīKṛṣṇaonlyasacceptedsubservientsoftheinhabitantsofVraja.
5. ThefirstappearanceofthespontaneouslovingaptitudeforŚrīKṛṣṇainanindividualsoulelevateshimtotheconditionofthemadhyam-bhagavataasdistinctfromtheconditionofthemahā-bhagavatawhopossessesloveforŚrīKṛṣṇaintheplenarymeasurewhichmakeshimeligibleforparticipatingasasubservientoftheservitorsofVraja,inthelovingactivitiesofthehighestsphereofservice.
6. Inproportionasthehesitant,reverentialservingdispositionofthemadhyam-bhagavataisgraduallydeveloped,bythepracticeofpureservice,intooneofsubserviencytotheinhabitantsofVrajaintheirunconventionalperformancesofthehighestlovingservicesofŚrīKṛṣṇa,suchhesitationanddistancearesupersededbygrowingconfidenceandproximitytotheObjectofone'shighestlove.Therebythespiritualvisionisperfected,inconformitywiththenaturalcapacityofanindividual,andheisenabledtorealizethefullfunctionofhisspecificspiritualself.
7. Goloka-VṛndāvanaisrealizableinthesymbolicVṛndāvanathatisopentoourviewinthisworldbyallpersonswhoselovehasbeenperfectedbythemercyoftheinhabitantsofTranscendentalVraja,andnototherwise.
8. ThegrossestmisunderstandingofthesubjectoftheVraja-līlāofŚrīKṛṣṇaisinevitableiftheseconsiderationsarenotkeptinview.AllpersonsunderthesinisterinfluenceofthedeludingpowerofNesciencearesubjecttosuchmisunderstandinginoneformoranother.Theyarefatedtoseenothingbutamundanetractofcountryintheterrestrial(Bhauma)Vṛndāvana,andthepracticeofthegossestformsofdebaucheryintheVrajapastimesofŚrīKṛṣṇa.
9. Butthetrueesotericvisionofthemahā-bhagavataisverydifferentfromtherealizationofdeludedhumanity.ItisdescribedinŚrīCaitanya-caritāmṛta,Madhya-līlā,17-55:
WhenŚrīKṛṣṇaCaitanyacatchessightofawood,itappearstoHiminthe
![Page 35: Notes On The Bhāgavata On The Bhāgavata.pdfIt is the fruit of the tree of thought (Vedas) mixed with the nectar of the speech of Śukadeva. It is the temple of spiritual love](https://reader036.vdocuments.mx/reader036/viewer/2022071420/611958be67cf0e3e7d40c166/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
likenessofVṛndāvana;andwhenHelooksatahill,HemistakesitforGovardhana."
THEEND.
Civilizedsocietyfortheregulationofsexualrelationshipsattaintheirethicalperfectioninthevarṇāśramaarrangement.Thusapersonbelongingtothevarṇāśramasocietycanreadilyappreciatethetransparentmoralpurityoflifeontheplane...