noe cuevas-beltran, a205 153 916 (bia aug. 15, 2013)

Upload: immigrant-refugee-appellate-center-llc

Post on 14-Apr-2018

214 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/30/2019 Noe Cuevas-Beltran, A205 153 916 (BIA Aug. 15, 2013)

    1/10

    Boyle, Kevin EsquireKevin Boyle Law Oces, LLC525 Junction Road, Ste. 8550NMadison, WI 53717

    ame: CUEVAS-BELTRAN, NOE

    U.S f

    Execuve Oce gon Revew

    Bd Immigin AlOc h lk

    507 Lebu Pik, Sit 000Fals Cd. Vigia /

    HS/ICE Oice of Chief Counsel CH525 West Van uren StreetChicago, 60607

    A 205153916

    Date of this notice 8/15/2013

    Enclosed s copy of e Bod's decson nd ode n e boveeenced cse

    nclosu

    Panel Members:Gudlg, Joh

    nceey

    D cDonn C

    Cef Ck

    wUseteam Dock

    Cite as: Noe Cuevas-Beltran, A205 153 916 (BIA Aug. 15, 2013)

  • 7/30/2019 Noe Cuevas-Beltran, A205 153 916 (BIA Aug. 15, 2013)

    2/10

    CUEVAS-BELTRAN NOEA205153916DODGE COUNY JAIL JUNEAU141 NORTH MAIN STREETJUNEAU, WI 53039

    Nme CUEVASBELTRAN NOE

    US f

    Executive Oce r Immigraton Review

    Bd Imgin AlOc h lk

    07 Lbrg k 000Fal 1c1 ia 04

    HS/ICE Oce of Chef Coue CH525 We V Bue SeeChcgo IL 6060

    A 205-153916

    De of h oce 8/15/2013

    Enclosed s a copy of the Board's decision n the above-rerenced case This copy is beingprovided to you as a coutesy Your attoey or representative has been served wth thsdecison pursuant to CFR 1292(a) f the attached decision orders that you bereoved o the nted States or ars an graton Judges decson ordering that yoube reoved, any petton r revie of the attached decision must be ed wth and receivedby the appropriate cout of appeals ithn days of the date of the decision

    nclosure

    Pane Membes

    Gdg Jo

    incerely,

    D cDonna CarChief Clerk

    wiliameUs k

    Cite as: Noe Cuevas-Beltran, A205 153 916 (BIA Aug. 15, 2013)

  • 7/30/2019 Noe Cuevas-Beltran, A205 153 916 (BIA Aug. 15, 2013)

    3/10

    .S f Executive Oce r Immigration Revew

    Deciso of the Bod o mmigato Appeals

    Fas Chuh, Vgia

    Fe: A25 53 96- Cag L

    n re NOE CEVABERAN

    N EMOVAL PROCEEDG

    APEAL

    Dae

    ON BEAF OF REONDEN: Ken Bye Eqre

    O BEALF OF D: ara E ZedAan Cef Cne

    UG

    n an ra den daed Ma 27 23 an mmgran dge dened e repndenreque r a nnane; nd m remabe; dened appan r nary deparrender e gran and Nanay A; deened a e dd n denrae egby rany er reef rea; ad rdered m reed m e ned ae Me erepnden appeaed a den e rerd w be reanded

    e repnden wa nd reabe a arged a nadmble a ned f a rmenng ra urpde nder en 22(a)(2)(A()() f e A 8 C 82(a)(2)(A)()() and a preen w beng admed r pared nder en22(a)(6)(A)() f e A A banaed by nn dmen n Apr 22 e waned pn a gy pea r emabe prpery le an r equa $25 nder

    nn aw r w re e wa enened rgnay mprnen f 9 mn SeeE 2 e ared n e ned ae n 26 See a 2; r a 6 A na remaearng n ar 27 23 e g e addna nnane awa e ume f amn r pnn relef a a pendng w e rmna ad e mgrandge dened e nnane reqe

    On appea e repnden a prded a py f a reen rder e nn rmna wng a n May 3 prn enene r e 22 e ene wa reded 6 mn n Matter of Cota, 23 &N De 849 (BA 25) Bard ed a a ra den md r redue an aen rmna enene nn pr n ened and red by e gran dge and e Bard and a mded r redued enene

    regnzed a ad r prpe f e mgran aw w regard e ra rrean r eeng e dan r redn

    In e preen ae e repnden nw arge a e n nger reabe nder en22(a)(2)(A)()() f e A beae e quae r e pey ene eepn n g f eenene redun e pey ene eepn w dngabe r a nn rpey e e r a en 2 l 2(a)(2)(A)() f e A and en 22(a)(2)(A)()()

    1 e reedng bere e mgran dge n aer were eed n CagIn g de nferene pra en 4(b)(2)(A)() f e A 8 C 229a(b)(2)(A)()

    Cite as: Noe Cuevas-Beltran, A205 153 916 (BIA Aug. 15, 2013)

  • 7/30/2019 Noe Cuevas-Beltran, A205 153 916 (BIA Aug. 15, 2013)

    4/10

    A205 153 96

    prvdes that a responden w not be und remoable as concted o a crme nong moralpude der section 22(a)(2)(A)(i)(I) of the Act e aen commed ony one such crme,he maxmum penay possible r the crime o whch the alen was conicted dd not exceedmpsonmen r one yea, and he aen ws not sentenced o a te o mprsoent nexcss of 6 monhs. Furher, he responden ndcates ta te reduced sentence should boster

    hs onenion tha he shoud hae been graned olunay depature under secon 24B of theAc 8 USC 1229c whch rele was dened by the Imgraton udge n the exerciseof discreton

    We nd t approprate o remand he record so hat the mmgraton Judge may consder theee of he crminal cout's order on the respondent's remoabty and hs dscreonayeigibiliy r ounary depare, n gh o Maer o Coa supra. Te Depamenof Homeand Secury ("S) does no oppose remand On reand, boh e respondent andhe DHS wil hae the oppony to proide the Imgraon udge wth addonaldocmenaion The respondent may appy r any m of ree r whch he can esabshelgbly

    Accordngy we enter he lowng order

    ORDER: he record is remanded to e Imgraon Cour r rer proceedngs and rte ssuance o a new decson, consstent wh ths opnon

    2 e 22 concton s r a Cass A msdemeaor crryng a amm prson sentence of9 onh See Ws Sa 9432(1)(a d 9395 ((a

    2

    vv vvvv1 "'Cite as: Noe Cuevas-Beltran, A205 153 916 (BIA Aug. 15, 2013)

  • 7/30/2019 Noe Cuevas-Beltran, A205 153 916 (BIA Aug. 15, 2013)

    5/10. . 3

    UNITED SAS DEPARTMT OF JUSTICEEXECUTVE OFC OR MMIGRAIO REVW

    UITED SATS MMGRAIO COURTCHCAGO, LLOS

    e: A205-15396

    n the Mater of

    March 27, 2013

    O CUEVAS-BRA))

    ))

    RMOVA PROCEENGS

    RSPONEN

    CARGS Sectio 22(a)(6)(A)() of he Immgraon ad Naoalty Ac

    Seco 212(a)(2)(A)(i)() o the Immgrao ad Naonaty Ac

    APPCATOS Voluay depaure.

    O BAF OF RSPOE KVN P BOYL, Esqure

    O BHAF OF DHS

    525 Junction Road, Sue 8550NMadison Wsconsn 5377

    SARA ZEL squire

    ORAL DECSO

    he espode s a 23year-old mae ative ad ctize of Mexco who was

    ssued a Noce o Apear on anuary 1 2013 he respodet apeared a a Mase

    Caenda setng the charges were ead to hm he espodent idcaed tha he

    undersood them ad his mate was conued o ebruay 2 On ha dae, he

    resondent's cousel requesed aoher contuance so hat he responde mgt

    pursue some ost-covico reef ad the Cou graned ha request conug he

    1

    J .VHQ.WIl$i

  • 7/30/2019 Noe Cuevas-Beltran, A205 153 916 (BIA Aug. 15, 2013)

    6/10

    ase to Marh 27 2013 On Marh 27, 2013, the respondent agan appeared n Cou

    wth ounsel Peadngs were taken on Marh 27. The respondent admtted that s not

    a tzen o the Unted States, and that he s a tzen o Mexo he respondent

    admtted that he entered the Unted States wthout nspeton n the year 2006 The

    respondent nether admtted nor dened aegaton 5. The ote to Appear was marked

    as Exht 1 Convton douments rom Wsonsn were marked as Exht 2 Aer

    revewng xht 2, the Cout ound that statements n alegaton 5 were unded and

    the Court, thereore, sustaned oth o the harges ontaned n the ote to Appear

    he Cou was inormed that the postonvton ree had not yet een granted

    that the proseutor had agreed to a reduton n the sentene ut that woud requre the

    onurrene o the proaton oer and, o ourse, the judge Respondents ounse

    presented the Court wth a opy o the moton to mod sentene, and normed the

    Court that no hearng date had yet een set, and sought another ontnuane to otan

    that ree

    The Cout nqured as to whether suh rele, otaned, woud render the

    respondentege or mmgraton ree, and was noed that t woud not t woud,

    however, eet the respondents elgty r ond. Sne the ree sought even

    granted, would not render the respondent egle or any orm o Immgraton rele, and

    would only pean to ond, the Cou n the exerse o ts dsreton dened the request

    r yet another ontnuane he Cou notes that there s no assurane that the moton

    wl e granted sne t does not yet have the onurrene o the proaton oer, and

    the udge has ovously not yet onsdered t Moreover even granted t woud not

    render the respondent elge or any nd o ree he Cou noted that t had

    ontnued the ase twe n the past, and n the exerse o ts dsreton onluded that

    another ontnuane was not merted The respondent then requested volunta

    A205153916 2 Marh 27, 201

  • 7/30/2019 Noe Cuevas-Beltran, A205 153 916 (BIA Aug. 15, 2013)

    7/10

    depaue

    VOLUNARY DPARUR

    The esponden s o sauoy baed fom vounay depaue I heefoe

    beomes a mae of he Cous dseon n exesng hs dseo he Cou mus

    ake no aou he espodes es o he Ued Saes ludg hs lengh of

    esdene and aso hs famy es he Cou mus aso ake no aoun negave

    faos suh as mnal odu he esponden aodng o a poe fom hs

    aoney eeed he Ued Saes n 2006 The only elaves n he Uned Saes who

    have egal saus ae a sse-naw and a nee On he negave sde he esponde

    sands onved of he oense of he of movable popey fo whh he was

    senened o e monhs naeaon The onvon eneed on Ap 1 202

    he Govenme submed a Fom 23, whh he Cou maked as xhb 3

    xhb 1 beg he Noe o Appea ad xhb 2 beng onvon doumens fom he

    espondens onvon he Fom -213 whh s a eable doumen ndaes ha

    he esponden was wokng unde a ame no hs own bu ahe hs ode bohesname and ha he was usg a Soal Seuy numbe ha was o hs own These ae

    negave faos

    In addo he Cou has evewed he onvon doumes whh evea he

    esponden soe a moo vehle he umsanes aodg o a adav se h

    as a pa of xhb 2 sgned and swon o by a deeve ay Slmans daes n

    pee pa ha he esponden we o he aea of a al yad whee a empoyee

    hee who was wokng he gh sh had saed hs vehe o e he vehle wam up

    n he od he espoden whou auhoy eneed he vehe and saed o dve

    away Hs me was noed and a deeve fo he aoad ompay n unfom and

    maked vehe pusued he esponden he esponden onnued o ee he sene

    A205-53-96 3 ah 2 20

  • 7/30/2019 Noe Cuevas-Beltran, A205 153 916 (BIA Aug. 15, 2013)

    8/10

    or abot 300 yads t the vehicles tres became stuck o the aroad tacks Whe

    the oce the raroad appoached accodng to the adavt the defendant

    meang the respodet bega to dck dow the drves seat ad hde hs hands

    der the steeg wheel e was detaned hs s a batat act of dshonesty ad

    the ad to make mattes wose the espodet attempted to ee om the ormed

    alroad secuty ocer

    Consdeng ths aog wth the act that the respodet was wokng under a

    name ot hs ow and usg a Socal Secuty umber not hs own ad aso takg to

    accot the rececy o hs thet covicto weghg a o ths agast the

    respodets athe th tes to the Uited States coclde that the execse o my

    dsceton I oght ot gat the respodents reqest voltay depaue

    ORDR

    I S RBY ORDRD that the espodents request r a cotnuace s

    deed

    I IS FURTR ORDRD that the respondets eqest fr voltaydepae s dened

    I S FURTR ORDRD that the respondent be emoved from the Uted

    States to Mexco o the charge cotaied hs Notce to Appear

    signature

    A2055396

    Pee ee te nextpage fo eetoniPILP DiMARZIOmigation Judge

    4 Mach 2 20

  • 7/30/2019 Noe Cuevas-Beltran, A205 153 916 (BIA Aug. 15, 2013)

    9/10

    -

    A205-15396 5 March 27, 201

  • 7/30/2019 Noe Cuevas-Beltran, A205 153 916 (BIA Aug. 15, 2013)

    10/10

    /Isl/

    Immigration Judge PHILP L. DIMARZIO

    dimarzip on May 28, 2013 at 5:0 PM GMT

    A205-596 6ch

    2 20