nishith desai associates legal and tax counselling worldwide [email protected] vaibhav...

21
Nishith Desai Associates Legal and Tax Counselling Worldwide [email protected] www.nishithdesai.com VAIBHAV PARIKH VAIBHAV PARIKH A PRESENTATION ON MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONS MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONS UNDER THE GATS IN UNDER THE GATS IN COMPUTER AND RELATED SERVICES COMPUTER AND RELATED SERVICES ON BEHALF OF NASSCOM NASSCOM BY

Upload: xavier-daugherty

Post on 27-Mar-2015

222 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Nishith Desai Associates Legal and Tax Counselling Worldwide vaibhav@nishithdesai.com  VAIBHAV PARIKH MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONS UNDER

Nishith Desai Associates

Legal and Tax Counselling Worldwide

[email protected]

www.nishithdesai.com

VAIBHAV PARIKHVAIBHAV PARIKH

A PRESENTATION ON

MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONS MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONS UNDER THE GATS IN UNDER THE GATS IN

COMPUTER AND RELATED SERVICESCOMPUTER AND RELATED SERVICES

ON BEHALF OF NASSCOMNASSCOM

BY

Page 2: Nishith Desai Associates Legal and Tax Counselling Worldwide vaibhav@nishithdesai.com  VAIBHAV PARIKH MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONS UNDER

SYNOPSISSYNOPSIS

• IT software and services sector in India: An introduction

• Issues / constraints facing the movement of software professionals (natural persons)

• Necessity for freer movement of natural persons under the GATS

• Policy initiatives and reforms

Nishith Desai AssociatesNASSCOM

Page 3: Nishith Desai Associates Legal and Tax Counselling Worldwide vaibhav@nishithdesai.com  VAIBHAV PARIKH MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONS UNDER

itit SOFTWARE AND SERVICES SOFTWARE AND SERVICES SECTOR IN INDIASECTOR IN INDIA

• This sector accounts for

– 16% of the country's overall exports;

– 500,000 jobs; and

– US$ 1.6 billion in investments.

Nishith Desai AssociatesNASSCOM

Page 4: Nishith Desai Associates Legal and Tax Counselling Worldwide vaibhav@nishithdesai.com  VAIBHAV PARIKH MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONS UNDER

DOMESTIC SOFTWARE MARKETDOMESTIC SOFTWARE MARKET

Source:www.nasscom.org

Nishith Desai AssociatesNASSCOM

Page 5: Nishith Desai Associates Legal and Tax Counselling Worldwide vaibhav@nishithdesai.com  VAIBHAV PARIKH MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONS UNDER

SOFTWARE AND SERVICES SOFTWARE AND SERVICES EXPORTSEXPORTS

Source:www.nasscom.org Nishith Desai AssociatesNASSCOM

Page 6: Nishith Desai Associates Legal and Tax Counselling Worldwide vaibhav@nishithdesai.com  VAIBHAV PARIKH MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONS UNDER

SOFTWARE DESTINATIONSSOFTWARE DESTINATIONS

Source:www.nasscom.org

Nishith Desai AssociatesNASSCOM

Page 7: Nishith Desai Associates Legal and Tax Counselling Worldwide vaibhav@nishithdesai.com  VAIBHAV PARIKH MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONS UNDER

INDIAN SOFTWARE EXPORTS: INDIAN SOFTWARE EXPORTS: DELIVERY MODELSDELIVERY MODELS

Source:www.nasscom.org

Nishith Desai Associates

Delivery 1999-00 2000-01 2001-02 (Projected)

Onsite 57.4% 56.1% 47.3%

Offshore 34.7% 38.6% 48.6%

Products and unclassified

7.9% 5.3% 4.1%

Total (US$ Billions)

2.65 6.2 7.7

NASSCOM

Page 8: Nishith Desai Associates Legal and Tax Counselling Worldwide vaibhav@nishithdesai.com  VAIBHAV PARIKH MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONS UNDER

BIRD’S EYE VIEWBIRD’S EYE VIEW

Nishith Desai AssociatesNASSCOM

ServicesGATS

Mode 3Mode 1

Mode 4

ProductsGATT

Productized services

Servicized Products

Page 9: Nishith Desai Associates Legal and Tax Counselling Worldwide vaibhav@nishithdesai.com  VAIBHAV PARIKH MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONS UNDER

NEED FOR MOVEMENT OF NEED FOR MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONSNATURAL PERSONS

• Globalisation of economic-activities and technological developments

• Facilitation of cross-border trade in services• Leveraging on the expertise and skill that

Indian software professionals possesses in order to reach out to a global market

• Direct contact between supplier and consumer necessary for effective services

Nishith Desai AssociatesNASSCOM

Page 10: Nishith Desai Associates Legal and Tax Counselling Worldwide vaibhav@nishithdesai.com  VAIBHAV PARIKH MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONS UNDER

ISSUES / CONSTRAINTSISSUES / CONSTRAINTS

• Immigration related issues

• Inadequate recognition of qualifications, experience and training

• Differential treatment of foreign service personnel

Nishith Desai AssociatesNASSCOM

Page 11: Nishith Desai Associates Legal and Tax Counselling Worldwide vaibhav@nishithdesai.com  VAIBHAV PARIKH MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONS UNDER

IMMIGRATION ISSUESIMMIGRATION ISSUES• Visa Requirements

– Prior adequate search in national markets– Wage parity requirement

• Negates cost-based advantage of developing countries

– Differentiation in processing permits based on the level of employment

• Faster to process intra-company transferee permits for higher level employees than permits for software professionals system analysts and database consultants

Nishith Desai AssociatesNASSCOM

Page 12: Nishith Desai Associates Legal and Tax Counselling Worldwide vaibhav@nishithdesai.com  VAIBHAV PARIKH MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONS UNDER

IMMIGRATION ISSUESIMMIGRATION ISSUES• Visa Requirements (contd.)

– Cumbersome procedure for issuance of work permits

• Time frame of 2 weeks to 3 to 4 months, or even longer!

– Quota restrictions• H-1B visa quota – Cap on economic expansion

– Restrictions on transferability and mobility– Limitation on duration of stay

• Economic Needs, local market needs test

Nishith Desai AssociatesNASSCOM

Page 13: Nishith Desai Associates Legal and Tax Counselling Worldwide vaibhav@nishithdesai.com  VAIBHAV PARIKH MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONS UNDER

INADEQUATE RECOGNITIONINADEQUATE RECOGNITION• Foreign countries find the educational and

work experience / training qualifications of software engineers to be insufficient– Eg. UK – Five years of experience or

graduation and two years of senior post-graduation work experience

– Eg. U.S. – 3 years professional experience

• Issue: Indians may be sufficiently skilled without satisfying the above criteria

Nishith Desai AssociatesNASSCOM

Page 14: Nishith Desai Associates Legal and Tax Counselling Worldwide vaibhav@nishithdesai.com  VAIBHAV PARIKH MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONS UNDER

DIFFERENTIAL TREATMENTDIFFERENTIAL TREATMENT• Tax implications on temporary foreign

service providers– Social security taxes in the US – no tax credit in

home country – erodes the cost advantage

• Government procurement policies favour domestic suppliers – eg. data processing

• Government approval required– Setting up operations – nature of entity and

establishment of local offices– Remittance of foreign exchange

Nishith Desai AssociatesNASSCOM

Page 15: Nishith Desai Associates Legal and Tax Counselling Worldwide vaibhav@nishithdesai.com  VAIBHAV PARIKH MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONS UNDER

DRAWBACKS / LOSSESDRAWBACKS / LOSSES

• Loss of business opportunities

• Higher costs for the customers / consumers

• Uncertainty, delays in deputing personnel

• Difficulties in transferring between sites in host country

• Wage parity condition erodes cost advantage

Nishith Desai AssociatesNASSCOM

Page 16: Nishith Desai Associates Legal and Tax Counselling Worldwide vaibhav@nishithdesai.com  VAIBHAV PARIKH MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONS UNDER

BROAD POLICY INITIATIVES/ BROAD POLICY INITIATIVES/ REFORMSREFORMS

• Improving the structure of GATS commitments

• Removal of existing limitations

Nishith Desai AssociatesNASSCOM

Page 17: Nishith Desai Associates Legal and Tax Counselling Worldwide vaibhav@nishithdesai.com  VAIBHAV PARIKH MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONS UNDER

IMPROVING THE STRUCTURE OF IMPROVING THE STRUCTURE OF GATS COMMITMENTSGATS COMMITMENTS

• Horizontal Commitments– Specifically include individual professionals– Clear eligibility criteria to be determined– Uniformity in definitions– Further expansion to include middle and lower

level professionals in the category of “other persons” or “specialists”

Source: India’s proposal to WTO

Nishith Desai AssociatesNASSCOM

Page 18: Nishith Desai Associates Legal and Tax Counselling Worldwide vaibhav@nishithdesai.com  VAIBHAV PARIKH MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONS UNDER

IMPROVING THE STRUCTURE OF IMPROVING THE STRUCTURE OF COMMITMENTSCOMMITMENTS

• Sectoral Commitments– Developed countries to make commitments in

all sub-sectors for computer and related services.

Source: India’s proposal to WTO

Nishith Desai AssociatesNASSCOM

Page 19: Nishith Desai Associates Legal and Tax Counselling Worldwide vaibhav@nishithdesai.com  VAIBHAV PARIKH MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONS UNDER

REMOVING EXISTING REMOVING EXISTING LIMITATIONSLIMITATIONS

• Visa requirements– Transparent visa application procedures– Simplify application procedures– Less stringent norms for entry and stay– Remove labour conditions for specialty occupations

(US)– Remove labour market test requirement for all

specialists (Australia)– Establish guidelines for wage parity– Impose conditions to prevent exploitation of foreign

workers– De-link temporary visas from permanent visas

Nishith Desai AssociatesNASSCOM

Page 20: Nishith Desai Associates Legal and Tax Counselling Worldwide vaibhav@nishithdesai.com  VAIBHAV PARIKH MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONS UNDER

REMOVING EXISTING REMOVING EXISTING LIMITATIONSLIMITATIONS

• Clear criteria for the Economic Needs Test

• Social Security and Totalisation issues– Bilateral agreements – Exemptions from contributions for professionals

of developing countries

• Recognition of work experience and qualifications of IT professionals

Nishith Desai AssociatesNASSCOM

Page 21: Nishith Desai Associates Legal and Tax Counselling Worldwide vaibhav@nishithdesai.com  VAIBHAV PARIKH MOVEMENT OF NATURAL PERSONS UNDER

WAY FORWARDWAY FORWARD

• Liberalization of Mode 4

• Amendments in domestic regulations

• Formation of international and bilateral agreements and treaties

• GATS Visa – Debate already initiated

THANK YOUTHANK YOUNishith Desai AssociatesNASSCOM