networking of rivers 24 feb 2012 sc judgement.doc

8/9/2019 networking of rivers 24 feb 2012 sc judgement.doc

1/126

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION

WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 512 OF 2002

"IN RE : NETWORING OF RIVERS"

WITH

WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. !! OF 2002

J U D G M E N T

S#$%$&%' *$+ J.

1. N'$,- %'& -'$ /$+ %' 3'%4%4&' 4& W4% P'%4%4&

(C464,) N. !! 7 2002+ $ 3$%44&8 $96$%'+ 4&%4%%'9 %'

3'%4%4& /$'9 & *' %9- %$% %'' #$ $ &''9 %

&'6' #$%' $&9 33',- %4,4' %' $6$4,$/,' ''.


2/126

T+ %' 3''&% 3'%4%4& $ /''& 4&%4%%'9 #4% %'

7,,#4&8 3$-':;

"$. I' $& $3334$%' #4% 9'

94'%4&+ *' 3$%4,$,- $ #4% 4&

%' &$%' 7 M$&9$* 94'%4&8 %'

'3&9'&% &. 1 % %$' $3334$%'

1


3/126

%'34%$/,-

94%4/%'9."

2. T' $/6' 94'%4& #'' 8% /- %' 3'%4%4&'


4/126

$8$4&% %' C'&%$, G6'&*'&% $ #',, $ $8$4&% 6$4

S%$%' G6'&*'&%+ 7 '?'%46' *$&$8'*'&% 7 %' #$%'

'' 4& %' &%- /- &$%4&$,4$%4& $&9 4&%';,4&4&8

7 46' 7* G$&8$ ; C$6'4+ V$48$4;T$*/$$6$*4 3 %

C$3' *$4. A94&8 % 4*+ $ '$,- $ 4& 1@+ S4

A% C%%&+ # $9 &%%'9 %' G9$6$4 $&9

4&$ 9$*+ 88'%'9 $ 3,$& $,,'9 %' A% C%%&

2


5/126

S'*' % ,4& %' G$&8$ $&9 C$6'4 46'. I& 1@0+ S4

C.P. R$*$#$*- A4-$ $, 88'%'9 $&9 33%'9

;

$ '*'. T''$7%'+ 6$4 3,4%4$, ,'$9' 7 %'

&%- $6' 33%'9 %' $' /% & '*'

$6' $%$,,- /''& 4*3,'*'&%'9. I% 4 %' $' 7 %'

3'%4%4&' %$% %' I&%';S%$%' W$%' D43%' A%+ 15! (7

% %' A%) $&9 %' R46' B$9 A%+ 15! #'' '&$%'9

/- %' P$,4$*'&% &9' A%4,' 2!2 '$9 #4% E&%- 5! 7

L4%;I 7 %' S'6'&% S'9,' % %' C&%4%%4& 7 I&94$+

150 (''$7%'+ %' C&%4%%4&). D' % ',%$&' 7

#$%';4 S%$%'+ %' N$%4&$, W$%' D'6',3*'&% A8'&-


6/126

(''$7%'+ NWDA) $ &% /''& $,,#'9 % &9'%$'

9'%$4,'9 6'- $&9 4% 4 $8'9 %$% &,- /- &$%4&$,4$%4&

7 %' 46'+ /- %' G6'&*'&% 7 I&94$+ %4 3/,'* $&

/' ',6'9 % *' '%'&%. T' 3'%4%4&' $9 ,'9 $ #4%

/'7' %' H48 C% 7 J94$%' $% M$9$+ /'4&8 W4%

P'%4%4& N. !20 7 1@+ 3$-4&8 7 6$4 ',4'7. T4

W4% P'%4%4& #$ 943'9 7 #4%% $&- '?'%46' 9' /-

%' H48 C%. P'4%4&8 #4% 4 '?%+ %' 3'%4%4&'

@


7/126

'$,4' ,'9 #4% 3'%4%4& /'7' %4 C%+ /'4&8 W4%

P'%4%4& (C) N. 5 7 1 $&9 W4% P'%4%4& (C) N. 15 7 ;

1+ 3$-4&8 4&%' $,4$ 7 &$%4&$,4'9 &$648$%4& $&9

4&%';,4&4&8 7 $,, %' 46' 4& %' &%-.

@. W' *% &%4'+ % 3% %' '9 %$48%+ %$% &

2% S'3%'*/'+ 1+ $ B'& 7 %4 C% % *%

&%4' 7 $ #4%';3 %$% $9 $33'$'9 4& %' H4&9%$&

T4*' &'#3$3'+ 9$%'9 1% J,-+ 1+ %4%,'9 "A&9 >4'%

=# %' *$4,4 $*&$". N%4' #$ 4'9 % %' C'&%$,

P,,%4& C&%, B$9+ M&443$, C3$%4& 7 D',4+

I48$%4& $&9 F,9 D'3$%*'&% 7 %' G6'&*'&% 7 I&94$+

N$%4&$, C$34%$, T'4%- 7 D',4 $&9 %' D',4


8/126

A9*4&4%$%4&. S4&' %'&+ %' #4% 3'%4%4& 4 /'4&8

&%4&,- *&4%'9 /- %4 C%+ %4,, 9$%'. D4&8 %'

3'&9'&- 7 %4 #4% 3'%4%4&+ I.A. N. 2 $*' % /' ,'9+

#''4& %' ,'$&'9 A*4 C4$' 4& %$% $' '7''9 %

%' $99' 7 D. A.P.J. A/9, $,$*+ %' %'& P'49'&% 7

I&94$+ & %' '6' 7 %' I&9'3'&9'&' D$-. T4+ 4&%' $,4$+

',$%'9 % '$%4&8 $ &'%# /'%#''& 6$4 46' 4& %'


9/126

&%-+ #4% $ 64'# % 9'$, #4% %' 3$$94$, 4%$%4&

7 =9 4& &' 3$% 7 %' &%- $&9 98% 4& %'

3$%. I& %' #9+ 4% ',$%'9 % %' 4&%';,4&4&8 7 46'

;

$&9 %$4&8 7 %' #$%' *$&$8'*'&% *'$'. O& 1!%

S'3%'*/'+ 2002+ %4 C%+ #4,' &49'4&8 %' $49 I.A.+

94'%'9 %$% %' $33,4$%4& /' %'$%'9 $ $& 4&9'3'&9'&%

#4% 3'%4%4& $&9 4'9 &%4' % %' 6$4 S%$%'

G6'&*'&% $ #',, $ %' A%%&'- G'&'$, 7 I&94$ $&9

3$'9 %' 7,,#4&8 9':;

"B$'9 & %' 3'' 7 %' P'49'&% &

%' I&9'3'&9'&' D$- E6' ',$%4&8 % %'

&''9 7 &'%#4&8 7 %' 46' /'$'

7 %' 3$$94$, 3'&*'&& 7 =9


10/126

4& &' 3$% 7 %' &%- #4,' *'

%' 3$% 7$' 98% $% %' $*'

%4*'+ %' 3''&% $33,4$%4& 4 ,'9. I%

#4,, /' *' $3334$%' % %'$% % %'$%

4% $ 4&9'3'&9'&% P/,4 I&%''%

L4%48$%4& #4% %' $' %4%,' "IN RE :

NETWORING OF RIVERS ;; 6. ;;;"

A*'&9'9 $' %4%,' /' ,'9 #4%4& $

#''.

I' &%4' '%&$/,' & @0%

S'3%'*/'+ 2002 % %' '3&9'&% $

#',, $ % %' A%%&'- G'&'$,.

5


11/126

S'6' &%4' & %' %$&94&8 &', 7

%' '3'%46' S%$%'.

D$%4 '64'+ 4& $994%4&+ 4 3'*4%%'9."

. T4 4 # I.A. N. 2 4& W4% P'%4%4& (C464,) N.

25 7 1 #$ &6'%'9 4&% W4% P'%4%4& (C464,) N. 512

7 ;

2002. T' W4% P'%4%4& (C464,) N. 512 7 2002 #$ %$'& 3

7 '$4&8 $&9 &%4' #$ 4'9 % $,, %' S%$%'+ 4&64%4&8

$9$64% '8$94&8 %'4 %$&' & %' 4' 7 &'%#4&8

7 46'.

5. I& 64'# 7 %' $/6' 9'+ %' 3'%4%4&' 4& W4%

P'%4%4& (C464,) N. !! 7 2002 #4%9'# W4% P'%4%4& (C)


12/126

N. 5 7 1 $ #',, $ W4% P'%4%4& (C) 15 7 1+ #4

,'$6' #$ 8$&%'9 /- %4 C%.

!. A $,'$9- 94'9 $/6'+ %' 3'%4%4&' $9 ,'9

W4% P'%4%4& (C464,) N. !! 7 2002 #4% *'#$% 4*4,$

3$-' $ &%$4&'9 4& I.A. N. 2. I& %$% #4% 3'%4%4&+

%' 3'%4%4&' $ $6''9 %$% & 3$-' #4% '8$9 %

4&%' ,4&4&8 7 46' 6'4&8 %' %'& 3$% 7 %'

!


13/126

P'&4&,$ R'84& $9 /''& ,$4*'9 $&9 4% #$ $, 4

&%'&%4& %$% %' %'& 3$% #$ *% 98% 3&'

$&9 $9 /''& #4%&'4&8 *' 4&%';%$%' #$%' 943%'.

T+ ' $9 ,'9 W4% P'%4%4& (C464,) N. !! 7

2002 $&9 3$-' *$9' %''4& #'' ,4$/,' % /' $,,#'9.

;

. I& %' 3''&% $'+ #' $' &'&'9 #4% W4%

P'%4%4& (C) N.!! 7 2002+ W4% P'%4%4& (C) N. 512 7

2002 $ #',, $ %' I.A. $&9 %' &%'*3% 3'%4%4& ,'9 4&

%'' %# 3'%4%4&. A94&8,-+ %4 9' $,, 943' 7

$,, %'' *$%%' /% #' *$' 4% ,'$ %$% 3''&%,-+ #' $'

&% 9'$,4&8 #4% W4% P'%4%4& (C) N. 25 7 1.


14/126

. I% $ $, /''& $6''9 /- %' 3'%4%4&' $&9 %'

4&%'6'& 4& %'' 3'%4%4& %$% %' &''9 % &'6'

#$%' '' $&9 $4&8 %'4 3%4** &*3%4&

$& /' ''& 7* %' %'3 %$'& 4& %4 '8$9+ &% &,- /-

%' 9'6',3'9 &%4' /% $, /- 9'6',34&8 $&9 &9';

9'6',3'9 &%4'. T' G6'&*'&% 7 I&94$ $ $,#$-

#& &49'$/,' &'& '8$94&8 %' *$&$8'*'&% 7


15/126

#$%' '' 4& %' &%- $&9 $9 7$*'9+ 7 %4

33'+ %' N$%4&$, W$%' P,4- #4 4 /'4&8 39$%'9

& $ -'$,- /$4. T' N$%4&$, W$%' P,4- '' % *$'

$6$4,$/,' #$%' 33,- % %' $'$ #4 7$' %$8'.

T4 $3'% 7 %' *$%%' ,9 /' '?'%46',- 9'$,% #4%+ &,-

47 %' 6$4 46' 4& %' &%- $' ,4&'9 $&9 $'

&$%4&$,4'9. T4 $ /''& $ *$%%' 7 3/,4 9'/$%' $&9 ;

944& 7 $ &49'$/,' %4*' $&9 %4,, &%4&' % /'

+ #4%% #4&8 $&- '='%4& 7 8&9 '$,4%-.

. T' M4&4%- 7 I48$%4&+ $,&8 #4% %' C'&%$,

W$%' C**44&+ $9 7*,$%'9 4& %' -'$ 10 $

N$%4&$, P'3'%46' P,$& (NPP) 7 3%4** %4,4$%4& 7


16/126

#$%' '' 4& %' &%- #4 '&64$8'9 4&%';/$4&

%$&7' 7 #$%' 7* #$%';3, % #$%';9'4% $'$.

A3$% 7* 946'%4&8 #$%' 7* 46' #4 $' 3,+ %

9'4% $'$+ %' 46' ,4&4&8 3,$& 4& 4% ,%4*$%' %$8' 7

9'6',3*'&% #4,, $, '&$/,' =9 *9'$%4&. I% #$

*34'9 7 %# *3&'&%: P'&4&,$ R46'

D'6',3*'&% $&9 H4*$,$-$& R46' D'6',3*'&%. T' %


17/126

4&6,6'9 *$K 4&%';,4&4&8 7 %' 46' -%'* $&9 %'

,$%%' '&64$8'9 %' &%%4& 7 %$8' ''64 &

%' 34&43$, %4/%$4' 7 46' G$&8$ $&9 B$*$3%$

4& I&94$+ B%$& $&9 N'3$,. T4 #$ % ',3 %$&7'

3, =# 7 %' '$%'& %4/%$4' 7 %' G$&8$ % %'

W'%+ $3$% 7* ,4&4&8 %' *$4& B$*$3%$ $&9 4%

%4/%$4' #4% %' G$&8$ $&9 M$$&$94 46'. T'

'*' 4 94649'9 4&% 7 *$K 3$%:

4) ;

44) I&%',4&4&8 7 M$$&$94;G9$6$4;4&$;

C$6'- 46' $&9 /4,94&8 %$8' $%

3%'&%4$, 4%' 4& %'' /$4&.


18/126

444) I&%',4&4&8 7 W'% =#4&8 46' &% 7

B*/$- $&9 % 7 T$34.

46) I&%',4&4&8 7 46' '& C$*/$,.

6) D46'4& 7 %' #'% =#4&8 46' 7*

'$,$.


19/126

10. T' 3'%4%4&' $6' $, *$9' '6'$, 88'%4&

#4 $6' /''& $33'4$%'9 /- %' *3'%'&% $%4%4'

& &49'$%4&. I% 4 '*3$4'9 %$% %' % 4 &'8,484/,'

#'& *3$'9 % %' 3%'&%4$, /'&'% #4 *$- /'

/'%#'9 & %' &$%4&. T' 3'%4%4&' ',- 3& A%4,'

2!2 7 %' C&%4%%4&+ '$9 $,&8 #4% E&%- 1+ L4% II

$&9 E&%- 5! 7 L4% I 7 %' S'6'&% S'9,' % %'

C&%4%%4& % /%$&%4$%' %'4 /*44&. F4&$,,-+ %'

3'%4%4&' /*4% %$% %' 3''6$%4& 7 #$%' ''

4 $ 3$% 7 %' 48% % ,47' $&9 ,46',49+ '&4&'9 4&

A%4,' 21 7 %' C&%4%%4& $&9 %$% %' C'&%$,

G6'&*'&% ,9 %$' 4**'94$%' $&9 8'&% %'3 %

&$%4&$,4' %' 46'+ %$% '>4%$/,' $&9 33' ;


20/126

94%4/%4& 7 #$%' $& /' '&'9 7 %' /'%%'*'&% 7

%' 33,$%4&. A94&8 % %'*+ %' C'&%$, G6'&*'&%

,9 $, $93% $,, &''$- *'$'+ /% 4'&%4$,,-

$&9 &$%$,,-+ % 4&'$' %' $/,' #$%' '' $&9 %

3''6' #$%'6' '' %' U&4& 7 I&94$ $ $,'$9-

/''& &$%$,,- 847%'9 #4%.

10


21/126

11. A $ ',% $&9 /'$' 7 %' 4&$%4& & %' 3$%

7 %' C'&%$, G6'&*'&% $&9 %' S%$%' G6'&*'&%+ 4% 4

/*4%%'9 %$% 8$&% 7 %' ',4'7 $ 3$-'9 7 4& %' #4%

3'%4%4& #,9 /' 4& &&$&' #4% %' &%4%%4&$,

344% $&9 4& %' ,$8' 3/,4 4&%''%.

12. T' ,'$&'9 A*4 C4$'+ # $9 /''& 34&8

%4 3/,4 $' 7 $ &*/' 7 -'$+ 4& 7%'$&' %

%' '>'% 7 %4 C%+ $ $, /*4%%'9 $ 9'%$4,'9 &%'

#4% '8$9 % %' /$8&9 $&9 **$- 7 %'

3''94&8 4& %'' 3'%4%4&.

1@. A 3' %' ,'$&'9 A*4 C4$'+ & 1% A8%+

2002+ %' %'& P'49'&% 7 I&94$+ D. APJ A/9, $,$*+ 4&


22/126

4 $99' % %' &$%4& & %' '6' 7 I&9'3'&9'&' D$-+ ;

$9 /'6'9 %$% %' &''9 7 %' #$ %' '$%4& 7 $

W$%' M44& #4+ 4&%' $,4$+ #,9 , 4&% %'

>'%4& 7 &'%#4&8 7 46' #4% $ 64'# % 9'$, #4% %'

3$$94$, 4%$%4& 7 =9 4& &' 3$% 7 %' &%-

$&9 98% 4& %' %'. B$'9 & %4 $&9 $ $7';

'9'9+ $ &%4' #$ 4'9+ & 1!% S'3%'*/'+ 2002+ %

11


23/126


24/126

%'' 4 4&;34&43,' &'& $*&8% $,, S%$%' % 8

$'$9 #4% %' 3K'% 7 4&%',4&4&8 7 46'.

;

15. V49' O9' 9$%'9 @0% A8%+ 200+ 4% #$ &%4'9

/- %4 C% %$%+ %8 %'' $9 /''& $ $&8' 4& %'

G6'&*'&%+ %' %'& S,44% G'&'$,+ $33'$4&8 7 %'

12


25/126

G6'&*'&%+ 4&7*'9 %4 C% %$% $ 9'44& $9 /''&

%$'&+ 4& 34&43,'+ % &%4&' #4% 4&%',4&4&8 7 46'.

1!. A 48 ,'6', T$ F' #$ '% 3. H#'6'+ 649'

9' 9$%'9 5% M$-+ 200@+ %4 C% /'6'9 %$% 4&3%

7* %' '3'%+ 4& *$&- ',9+ #'' &''$- $&9 %$%

%' T$ F' #$ % 846' 9' &49'$%4& %

4&3%. F'$4/4,4%- R'3% (''$7%'+ FR) #'' 3'3$'9

7 %' 4&%'&9'9 ,4&. S/'>'&%,-+ 649' 4% 9' 9$%'9

% A34,+ 2005+ %4 C% *$9' 4% $/,%',- ,'$ %$% %'

9' 7 %' C% 4& %'' '3'% $6' % /' *3,4'9

#4% 4& ,'%%' $&9 344%. T' FR 7 $,, ,4& #'' % /' 3%

& %' #'/4%' $7%' %'4 *3,'%4&. T4 C% $9 $,


26/126

*$9' /'6$%4& %$% %' 34 &'&% 7 $&- S%$%'

G6'&*'&% #$ &% &''$- 7 3,$4&8 %' FR & %'

#'/4%' $&9 94'%'9 %'* % /' 3,$'9. W4% 8'$%

3'$4& $&9 '?%+ %' FR 7 1! ,4& $9 /''& 3,$'9

& %' #'/4%'. A% %' '>'% 7 %' A*4+ %' #'/4%' ;

#$ 9''9 % /' *$9' 4&%'$%46' %$% 3'3,' ,9

/*4% %'4 '3&' %''%.

1@


27/126

1. T' %$% '3% ,'9 & /'$,7 7 %' G6'&*'&%

7 I&94$ $, #'9 %$% $ **4%%'' 7 '&64&*'&%$,4%+

4$, $%464% $&9 %' '3'% #,9 /' &%4%%'9 % /'

4&6,6'9 4& %' &,%$%46' 3' 7 7*,$%4& $&9

''%4& 7 %' '&%4' 3K'%.

1. T' %$% '3% ,'9+ 7* %4*' % %4*'+ $6'

/''& &49''9 /- %4 C%.

1. N#+ #' *$- 9'$, #4% %' '3&' 7 6$4

S%$%'+ $ %'- $33'$ 7* %' '9 /'7' . T'

'3&' $9$64% $6' /''& ,'9 & /'$,7 7 %'& S%$%'.

H#'6'+ %' '*$4&4&8 S%$%' $6' &% '3&9'9+ 9'34%'

%' 8$&% 7 '3'$%'9 33%&4%4' % 9 . W4,' %'


28/126

S%$%' 7 R$K$%$&+ GK$$% $&9 T$*4, N$9 $6'

33%'9 %' &'3% 7 4&%';,4&4&8 7 46'+ %' S%$%' 7

M$9-$ P$9' $9 %$%'9 %$% &'%#4&8 7 46' 4 $

/K'% 7$,,4&8 &9' %' K494%4& 7 %' C'&%$,

G6'&*'&% $&9 %' C'&%$, G6'&*'&% ,9 &49'

%' *$%%'. T' ;

1


29/126

S%$%' 7 $&$%$$+ B4$+ P&K$/+ A$* $&9 S44* $6'

846'& %'4 $336$, % %' &'3% 4&;34&43,'+ /% #4%

9'&4%' ''6$%4&+ 4.'.+ $ 4&9 7 >$,4'9 $336$,+

$84&8 %$% %' *$%%' #4% '8$9 % %' '&64&*'&%$,

$&9 &$&4$, 4*3,4$%4&+ 4;'&*4 $&9 4&%'&$%4&$,

$3'%+ $ 4&%';/$4& #$%' %$&7'+ &''9 % /'

33',- '$*4&'9 $% %' $3334$%' ,'6', 7 %'

G6'&*'&%. F '$*3,'+ $,, %' 46' 4& B4$ 484&$%'

7* N'3$, $&9 4% *$- /' &''$- 9'4$/,' % %$'

&'&% 7 &'48/4&8 &%4'+ 4 $ *$%%' #4 #,9

'>4' &49'$%4& 7 %' $3334$%' $%4%- 4& %'

C'&%$, G6'&*'&%. A94&8 % %' S%$%' 7 P&K$/+

4&%';,4&4&8 7 46' ,9 /' %$%'9 &,- 7* #$%';


30/126

3, S%$%' % S%$%' 7$4&8 #$%' 9'4%. T' S%$%' 7

A$*+ S44* $&9 '$,$ $9 $4'9 %'4 3%'% & %'

8&9 %$% %'- ,9 $6' ',46' 48% % ' %'4

#$%' '' $&9 %$% %$&7' ,9 &% $?'%

$&- 48% 7 %'' S%$%'. T' S%$%' 7 S44* #$

&'&'9 #4% 3$%4,$ '7''&' % %$334&8 7 %' -9

;

15


31/126

3#' 3%'&%4$, 4& %' S%$%' $&9 %' S%$%' 7 '$,$ '&%4',-

/K'%'9 % ,&8 94%$&'+ 4&%';/$4&+ #$%' %$&7'.

20. T' U&4& 7 I&94$ ,'9 %'' 94?''&% $9$64%

9$%'9 25% O%/'+ 2002+ 5% M$-+ 200@ $&9 2% D''*/'+

200@. F* %'' $9$64%+ %' %$&9 7 %' U&4& 7 I&94$

$33'$ % /' %$% &'%#4&8 7 46' $9 /''& &49''9

#4% 8'$% '4&' '6'& $7%' %' 12 R$ C**4%%''

R'3%. S6'- $&9 %94' #'' &9'#$-. T' 10

N$%4&$, P'3'%46' P,$& 7 %' '%#4,' M4&4%- 7

I48$%4&+ 3''&%,- %' M4&4%- 7 W$%' R''+

'&64$8'9 4&%';/$4& %$&7' 7* #$%';3, % 9'4%

$'$. I% #,9 $6' 94'% /'&'%+ ,4' %' 448$%4& 7 @5


32/126

*4,,4& '%$' (M$)+ 7,, '3,4%$%4& 7 '4%4&8 448$%4&

3K'% 7 10 M$+ 3#' 8'&'$%4& 7 @ *4,,4& 4,#$%%

(W) /'49' %' 4&94'% /'&'% ,4' =9 &%,+

&$648$%4&+ #$%' 33,-+ '4'+ 3,,%4& &%,+

''$%4& 7$4,4%4'+ '*3,-*'&% 8'&'$%4&+ 4&7$%%'

$&9 4;'&*4 9'6',3*'&% '%. W4% '8$9 % %'

$336$, '>4'9+ 4% 4 /*4%%'9 %$% %' M4&4%- 7

E&64&*'&% $&9 F'%+ U&4& 7 I&94$ $9 846'& *' ;

1!


33/126

,'$$&'+ #4,' '74&8 %' $*' 4& %' $'. T'

&'&% 7 *' 7 %' S%$%' $9 &% /''& ''46'9. T'

'3'%'9 &$&4$, 4*3,4$%4& $ 7$ /$ $ 4& 2002 #$

R.5+!0+000 '.

21. H#'6'+ %' U&4& 7 I&94$ $ /*4%%'9 %$%

%'' 4 & &''4%- 7 7*$%4& 7 $ 48;3#''9

**4%%'' $ 3$-'9 7 4& %' 3'%4%4&. T' 48;,'6',

%$ 7' 4 % /' '% 3 7 &49'4&8 %' *9$,4%4' 7

%$%';#4' &'&. T' NWDA #$ '% 3 $

$%&* '84%''9 4'%- &9' %' $'84 7 M4&4%- 7

W$%' R''+ 4& N'# D',4 4& 12+ 7 %' 33' 7

3'3$$%4& 7 FR+ &9% 7 #$%';/$,$&' $&9 %'


34/126

4'&%4 %94'+ '%. 7 P'&4&,$ R'84& 46' ($&9 7

H4*$,$-$& R'84& 46' $,+ 4&' 10) $&9 4 '$9'9 /-

%' U&4& M4&4%' 7 W$%' R''. T' C4'7 M4&4%'

$&9


35/126

;

22. T' U&4& 7 I&94$ $&9 *' %$%' $6' #&

%'4 &'& $&9 %'4 $33''&4& $/% %''

3K'%+ 4&,94&8 >'%4&4&8 %' ',4$/4,4%- 7 #$%'

33,- 7* 94%$&% '+ 94%4/%4& 7 #$%' 846'& %'

'4%4&8 %4/&$, $#$9 $&9 %' &%4&'9 $6$4,$/4,4%- 7

'4%4&8 #$%' 3,'.

2@. I& $&%' $9$64%+ %' U&4& 7 I&94$ '7''9 %

%' T'* 7 R'7''&' % %' T$ F' $&9 %'

$334&%*'&% 7 4% M'*/'. A%4& P,$& I #$ 3'3$'9+

#4 #$ '3'%'9 % /' 4*3,'*'&%'9 /- 201!. O% 7 %'

4&9'3'&9'&% ,4& % /' 3'9 7 944&+ %' %


36/126

#'' %' ,4& 4& %' S%$%' 7 GK$$%+ M$$$%$+

C$%%48$ '&9,-+ %' S%$%' 7 $&$%$$+ M$9-$

P$9'+ U%%$ P$9' $&9 R$K$%$& #'' % /' 4&,9'9

4& 944& $&9 %49,-+ %' S%$%' 7 A&9$ P$9'+

T$*4, N$9 $&9 O4$ #'' % /' 4&64%'9 7 944&.

T' D'%$4,'9 PK'% R'3% (''$7%'+ DPR) #'' '3'%'9

% /' *3,'%'9 /- D''*/'+ 200!. H#'6'+ 7* %'

1


37/126

'9+ 4% $33'$ %$% %'' DPR $6' &% /''& *3,'%'9

'6'& %4,, %9$-. T' '*' 7 4&%';,4&4&8 7 ;

46'


38/126

%' T$ F' 4&,9'9 %' $336$, 7 $,, ,4&. W4% %'

4&%'&%4& % $46' $% $ 8'&'$, &'&+ /'7' '&%'4&8

4&% $8''*'&%+ %' U&4& 7 I&94$ $ 94'9 9'%$4,

#4% M$$$%$ $&9 GK$$% $&9 3',4*4&$- 944&

$ %$'& 3,$' #4% %' S%$%' 7 A&9$ P$9'+

C$%%48$+ $&$%$$+ O4$+ T$*4, N$9 $&9

P&94'-. A94&8 % %' U&4& 7 I&94$+ 4&64&8 %'

1


39/126

*$%%' 4&%'&$%4&$,,-+ $% %4 %$8'+ #$ &% $964$/,' $

%' *$%%' #$ 3'*$%'. T' NWDA #$ % /'84& %' DPR

7 %' % ,4&+ 4.'.+ %' '&;B'%#$ 3K'%+ #4 4%',7 ;

#$ '3'%'9 % %$' @0 *&% %4*'. I& %4+ %' DPR $

&# /''& 3'3$'9 #'6'+ %' 4*3,'*'&%$%4& 4 -'% %

/'84&. W' *% &%4' %$% 4& $,, %' ,4& '6'& %' DPR

$' &% '$9-+ $ 7 &#. T' 9$7% M'*$&9* 7

U&9'%$&94&8 (''$7%'+ MU) $9 /''& 4,$%'9 7

&9% 7 DPR 7 %'' *' P'&4&,$ ,4&. T'

S%$&94&8 C**4%%'' 7 %' P$,4$*'&% & W$%' R''+

(''$7%'+ %' S%$&94&8 C**4%%'')+ 4& 4% '3% 7 %'

-'$ 200;05 $ **'&%'9 %$% 7 %' 33' 7


40/126

3'3$$%4& 7 DPR 7 %' '&;B'%#$ ,4& $&9 %' P$/$%4;

$,44&9;C$*/$, ,4& 3K'%+ $ * 7 R.1 ' $9

/''& '$*$'9+ % 7 %' %%$, R.@5 ' $,,$%'9 7

NWDA. H#'6'+ %' S%$&94&8 C**4%%'' $9 /''&

&%$4&'9 % /'6' %$%+ %8 %' FR 7 %' '&;

B'%#$ ,4& #$ *3,'%'9 4& N6'*/'+ 1!+ %' 3K'%

#$ %4,, $% $ &$'&% %$8'. A% %' %4*' 7 %' '3% 4&

200;05+ %' /$4 MU /'%#''& %' G6'&*'&% 7 U%%$

20


41/126

P$9' $&9 M$9-$ P$9'+ 7 3'3$$%4& 7 DPR+ %4,,

'*$4&'9 % /' 48&'9+ & %' 8&9 %$% %' S%$%' 7 U%%$

P$9' '>4'9 *' #$%' % /' $,,$%'9 % 4%. T'- ;

7%' /'6'9 %$%+ 47 %' M4&4%- 7 W$%' R''+

G6'&*'&% 7 I&94$ $9 '% $ %4*' 7$*' 7 &$,4$%4& 7

4' ,4' %4+ %' 3'4 %4*' 7 '48% -'$ #,9 &%

$6' /''& ,%. T' *$%%' %4,, '% $% %$% %$8'. T9$-+

%8 DPR $ /''& 3'3$'9 7 %4 ,4& $,&'+ & ,4&

3K'% $ '$'9 %' 4*3,'*'&%$%4& %$8'.

25. T' '3% 7 %' S%$&94&8 C**4%%'' #4+ 4&%'

$,4$+ $9 '$*4&'9 %' 46' 4&%';,4&4&8 33$, #$

3''&%'9 % %' P$,4$*'&% 7 I&94$ & 2@9 A8%+ 200. I%


42/126

#$ %&8,- '**'&9'9 %$% %' G6'&*'&% ,9

%$' * %'3 $&9 $ 9'&4%' %4*' 7$*' % ,$- 9#& %'

849',4&' 7 *3,'%4& 7 FR+ 3'3$$%4& 7 DPR $&9

*3,'%4& 7 3K'% %$% %'- *$- /' *3,'%'9 $&9

%' /'&'% $'9 #4%4& '$&$/,' %4*' $&9 %. I%

#$ %' 34&4& 7 %' S%$&94&8 C**4%%'' %$% %' 4&%';

,4&4&8 7 H4*$,$-$& $&9 S%'& '84& 46'+ 47 9&'

21


43/126

#4%4& $ 9'&4%' '9,'+ #,9 $6' %' &$%4& 7* %'

9'6$%$%4&8 $6$8' 7 &4 98% $&9 =9. T'

'**'&9$%4& 7 %' S%$&94&8 C**4%%'' 9'$, 34*$4,-

#4% %# 4&9 7 S%$%' %' S%$%' $64&8 #$%' %$8' ;

$&9 %' S%$%' $64&8 3, #$%'. S%4,,+ %'' #,9 /' $

%49 $%'8- 7 S%$%'+ #4 #,9 /' *34'9 7 %'

S%$%' #4 $6' K% 4'&% #$%' $&9 %''7'+ 9 &%

7$,, 4& '4%' %' =9;$?'%'9 %' 98%;$?'%'9

$%'84' 7 S%$%'. T' ,' 7 S%$%' *$- &% /'

6'- 3K'%;',$%'9 /%+ %'4 &'&%


44/126

94?''&% 46'+ *$- 3$ %8 S%$%'. B% $

$,'$9- &%4'9+ ''3% &'+ & %' DPR $ 7$ /''&

&$,4'9 $&9 4& 7$%+ &&' 3% 4&% 4*3,'*'&%$%4&. T+

%4 >'%4& #,9 '*$4& 3'& $&9 $ % /' '$*4&'9 $%

%' $3334$%' %$8' /- %' *3'%'&% 7*.

PK'%4& 7 S%$% R'3% : ;

22


45/126

2!. D4?''&% S%$% R'3% $6' /''& ,'9 4& %4

$'. T' ,$% 7 %' S%$% R'3% $6' /''& ,'9 /- %'

U&4& 7 I&94$ & 1% M$+ 2011. I% $ /''& 34&%'9 %

%$% %' NWDA+ #4 #$ % *3,'%' %' %$ ',$%4&8 %

3'3$$%4& 7 FR $&9 DPR 7 ,4& 3K'%+ $ *3,'%'9

;

20 3',4*4&$- #$%';/$,$&' %9- 7 /$4&+ /;/$4&

$&9 946'4& 34&%+ %3''% $&9 %$8' $3$4%-

%94' 7 ''64+ @ %3''% %94' 7 ,4&

$,48&*'&% $&9 @2 3';7'$4/4,4%- '3% 7 ,4&+ %#$9

%' 4*3,'*'&%$%4& 7 4&%';,4&4&8 7 46' 4& %' &%-.

B$'9 & %'' %94'+ %4 $8'&- 49'&%4'9 @0 ,4& (1!


46/126

&9' %' 3'&4&,$ 46' 9'6',3*'&% *3&'&% $&9 1

&9' %' H4*$,$-$& 46' 9'6',3*'&% *3&'&%) 7

3'3$$%4& 7 FR. T' 3' 7 &'& /4,94&8 4

&;84&8+ 4& '8$9 % %' 7'$4/4,4%- 7 4*3,'*'&%4&8 %'

4&%',4&4&8 3K'%. T'' '3% $6' #& %$% $

48&4$&% '?% $&9 $%%'*3% $6' /''& *$9' $&9 %'

&>'%4&$/,' /'&'% %$% #,9 $' & %'

2@


47/126

4*3,'*'&%$%4& 7 %' 4&%',4&4&8 3K'% #4,, /' % /'&'%

%' &%- $% ,$8'. O&' $3'% %$% &''9 % /' &%4'9 4

%$%+ %4,, %9$-+ & *4& *$K 3K'% $ /''& $%$,,-

4*3,'*'&%'9 $% %' 8&9 ,'6', 9'34%' %' 7$% %$% %4

$' $ /''& 3'&94&8 /'7' %4 C% 7 *' %$& %'&

-'$. O&,- %' DPR 7 %' '&;B'%#$ ,4& $ /''&

3'3$'9 $&9 4% 4*3,'*'&%$%4& 4 $#$4%4&8 %' $336$, 7

;

%' S%$%' G6'&*'&% $ #',, $ %' $,,$%4& 7 7&9+

'6'& % /'84& %' #. T4 9' &% 3'$ #',, 7 %'

9'4' & %' 3$% 7 $&- 7 %' &'&'9 G6'&*'&% %

4*3,'*'&% %'' 3K'%+ 9'34%' %' 7$% %$% %'' 4


48/126

&$&4*4%- 7 64'# $*&8 $,, %$% %4 3K'% 4 4& %'

&$%4&$, 4&%''%.

2. T' C**4%%'' 7 E&64&*'&%$,4%+ S4$,

S4'&%4% $&9 %' E3'% & 4&%';,4&4&8 7 46'+ $9

*'% $7%' %' /*44& 7 %' S%$% R'3% 9$%'9 5%

M$+ 2010. T'- 94'9 6$4 $3'% 7 94?''&%

3K'%. I& %' H4*$,$-$& '84&+ FR 7 %# '*$4&4&8

2


49/126

,4& #'' *3,'%'9+ 4.'.+ %' S$9$;$*&$ ,4& $&9

G$8$;$*&$ L4&. T' ',9 6'- $&9 4&6'%48$%4& 7

S&' D$* & %' %'& %4/%$4' 7 %' G$&8$ ,4&+

#$ %4,, 4& 38'. T' M4&4%- 7 E&64&*'&% $&9

F'% $9 '7'9 3'*44& 7 6'- $&9 4&6'%48$%4&

7 %' M$&$;S$&;T4%$;G$&8$ ,4&+ /% %' %3''%

%9- 7 %' $,%'&$%46' J8483$;T4%$;F$$$ ,4& $

/''& *3,'%'9. I& %' P'&4&,$ '84&+ %' 3K'%

',$%4&8 % B'9%4;V$$9$ $&9 N'%$6$%4;H'*$6$%4;T$34 $'

$#$4%4&8 ;

$&$%$$ G6'&*'&% &'&%. I& N'%$6$%4;H'*6$%4;

T$34 ,4&+ %' $&$%$$ G6'&*'&% $ '7'9 %


50/126

&'&% '6'& % %' 3'3$$%4& 7 FR &%4, 9'44& 7

',$%'9 $'+ 3'&94&8 4& %' C%.

2. I& %' D$9& 9$*+ ',$%4&8 % %' '&;B'%#$ ,4&+

%# 3#' ' $&9 $ ,4& $&$, #4,, /' %$'& 3 4& P$'

I $&9 %' B'%#$ /$4& #4,, /' *3,'%'9 4& P$';II. U33'

B'%#$ S/;B$4& #4,, ''46' 344%- *3,'%4& $&9 *4&

3K'% $' 33'9 % /' *3,'%'9 %. P$';II #4,, /'

25


51/126

**'&'9 $7%' 6'- $&9 4&6'%48$%4&. H#'6'+ %4

3K'% 4 %4,, $% %' 6'- $&9 3,$&&4&8 %$8' $&9 '6'&

*3''&46' ,'$$&'+ 7* %' U%%$ P$9'

G6'&*'&%+ $6' &% /''& ''46'9. T' S%$%' 7 R$K$%$&

'7' % &49' %' MU 7 $&%' 344%- ,4&+

P$/$%4;$,44&9;C$*/$,+ &%4, %' 39$%4& 7 4%

-9,8- 3K'%.

2. S4*4,$,-+ %'' $' %' 3K'% #'' 3/,4

4&9$&' $' $'9 $8$4&% $-4&8 % 7 6'- $&9

4&6'%48$%4&. I& %' P$;T$34;N$*$9$ $&9 D$*$&8$&8$;;

P4&K$, ,4&+ '49'&% $6' #& &'& $/% %' '%'&%

7 ,$&9 % /' /*'8'9 & %' &%%4& 7 %' 33'9


52/126

9$*. I& '3&'+ %' S%$%' G6'&*'&% 7 GK$$% $&9

M$$$%$ $6' '% 3 C**4%%'' % %$' 3 %'

*$%%' #4% %' 3$&$-$% $&9 % **'&' %' 3K'%.

@0. T' NWDA $9 $,+ 4& %' ' 7 7$*4&8 7 4%

3,44'+ 33'9 4&%$;%$%' ,4&. E'3% 7 4 S%$%'

$&9 7 U&4& T'4%4'+ $,, %' S%$%' $&9 U&4&

T'4%4' $6' 4&%''% 4& %'' 4&%$;S%$%' ,4&. T''

2!


53/126

$' '48% 4&%';,4&4&8 3K'% #4 $' &9' '64'# /-

94?''&% S%$%' $%4%4'. H#'6'+ %' 9'%$4, 7 %'

946'8'&' /'%#''& %' S%$%' G6'&*'&% $' &% ,'$,-

3',% %+ '6'& $ 7 &#.

@1. A& $994%4&$, %9- #$ &9'%$'& /- %' N$%4&$,

C&4, 7 A33,4'9 E&*4 R''$ (''$7%'+ NCAER)

$&9 %' '64'9 &$, '3%+ 3/,4'9 4& A34, 200+

$''9 %' '&*4 4*3$% 7 %' 46' 4&%',4&4&8

38$* $&9 88'%'9 $& 4&6'%*'&% ,, % 3,$&+ 4.'.+ $

3$%4$, 4*3,'*'&%$%4& '9,'+ 7 %' $*'. A 3- 7

;

%4 '3% #$ /*4%%'9 4& %' -'$ 2011+ /'7' %4


54/126

C%.

@2. A $,'$9- &%4'9+ %' T$ F' #$ &%4%%'9

/- %' C'&%$, G6'&*'&% 7 4&%',4&4&8 7 46' 3K'%

4& D''*/' 2002. I% /*4%%'9 4% A%4& P,$& I $&9 II 7

4*3,'*'&%$%4& 7 %' 3K'% $&9 $, &$,4'9 %' %'* 7

'7''&' 7 %' 33' 7 %' DPR. A%4& P,$& I+

2


55/126

/*4%%'9 4& A34, 200@+ '&64$8' *3,'%4& 7 @0 FR /-

%' $%4%4' /- D''*/' 2005.

@@. A%4& P,$& II+ /*4%%'9 4& A34, 200+ *$4&,-

'&64$8'9 %' $33$4$, 7 4&94649$, 3K'%+ 4& '3'% 7

%'4 '&*4 64$/4,4%-+ 4;'&*4 $&9 '&64&*'&%$,

4*3$%+ 3'3$$%4& 7 ''%%,'*'&% 3,$& $&9 '$4&8

3''9- &'& $*&8 S%$%'. T' '3% $6' /''&

/*4%%'9 % %' C'&%$, G6'&*'&% $&9 $' &9'

&49'$%4&. W4% %4 *3,'%4& 7 #+ %' T$ F'

$9 *3,'%'9 4% /K'% $&9 %9 94,6'9. A7%' #4&94&8

3 7 %' T$ F'+ $ S3'4$, C',, & 4&%',4&4&8 7 46'

#$ '$%'9 &9' %' M4&4%- 7 W$%' R''. ;


56/126

H#'6'+ #$% $33'&'9 % %' %# A%4& P,$& '3%

/*4%%'9 /- %' T$ F' 4 $ *$%%' ,'7% % %'

4*$84&$%4& 7 $&-&'.

@. F* %' $/6'+ 4% 4 &% 94,% % 64$,4' %'

94,%4' 4& 3'3$$%4&+ ''%4&+ &$&4&8 $&9

&'& /4,94&8+ %4,,+ 4% 4 %' &''9 7 %' % $-

2


57/126

% %'' 3K'% *' '?'%46',- $&9 #4% 8'$%'

'&4%464%-.

E&*4 A3'% :

@5. A 3' %' '3% 7 %' S%$&94&8 C**4%%'' 7 %'

-'$ 200;05+ #4 #$ 3''&%'9 % %' P$,4$*'&% 7

I&94$+ %' 3,$&&'9 /98'%$- $,,$%4& #$ *$9' &9'

NWDA $ 7,,# :

@!. A%$, $,,$%4& 7 2002;0@ #$ R.15.@0 '+

%' /98'% '%4*$%' 7 200@;0 #$ 20 '+ %' '64'9

'%4*$%' 7 %' $*' -'$ #$ R.21.5 ' $&9 7

200;05+ %' /98'% '%4*$%' #$ R.@5 '.

;


58/126

@. T' A*4 C4$'+ 4& 4 '3%+ $ &%'9 %$% %'

&'# $88'8$%'9 % 7 %' '&%4' 38$* 6$4' /'%#''&

R. ++@@1.20 '+ $% 200@;0 34'+ $&9

R.+@+!5.1@ '+ $% 200@;0 34'+ 9'3'&94&8 & %'

4*3,'*'&%$%4& 7 %' 33'9 M$&$;S$&;T4%$;

G$&8$ ,4& %' J8483$;T4%$;F$$$ ,4& '3'%46',-.

2


59/126


60/126

$&9 4,,- $'$ $&9 4& $'$ #4% &,- 5 3' '&% 7

9'3'&9$/,' =# ;

4& %' /$4&+ $ ,#' IRR 7 3' '&% #$ '**'&9'9.

S'46' F4&$&' C**44& $, %''9 & '6'-

7 $ '%$4& 3''&%$8' 7 %' $34%$, 4&6'%*'&% $3$% 7*

#4&8 '3'&'. T' E,'6'&% F4&$&' C**44& $

'8&4'9 %$% %4 #,9 $6' % /' 9&' 4& $ 8$9$,

@0


61/126

*$&&'. R''43% ,9 6' &% &,- *$4&%'&$&'

'3'&94%' /% $, ,'$6' *' 3, $ '%& & %'

$34%$, 4&6'%'9.

@. T4 NCAER '3%+ #4% *' 48&4$&'+ &%4'9

%$% &%4, 200@;0+ 4% #$ &,- 4& 7 -'$ %$% %'

'&*- 8'# $% *' %$& 3' '&% 3' $&&*. E$ 7

%'' -'$ 4&49'9 #4% 6'- 48 $%' 7 8#% 4& %'

$84,%$, '%. I& &%$%+ 4&9%- $&9 '64'

'% $6'+ $% /'%+ 3,,'9 3 %' G D*'%4 P9%

(GDP) 8#% % .@ 3' '&% 3' $&&* #'& %'' #$ &

48&4$&% &%4/%4& 7* %' $84,%$, '%. T'

'3% ,'$,- 34&' %$% 4&%',4&4&8 7 46' 3K'% #4,,


62/126

36' 74%7, 7 %' &$%4& $ $ #,' $&9 #,9 '6' $

8'$%' 33' /- $,,#4&8 48' '%& 7* %'

$84,%$, '% 7 %' /'&'% 7 %' '&%4' '&*-. ;

T4 #,9 $, ',% 4& 36494&8 7 6$4'9 /'&'% ,4'

&%, 7 =9+ 36494&8 #$%' % 98%;3&' S%$%'+

36494&8 #$%' % $ ,$8' 3$% 7 $84,%$, ,$&9 $&9

'6'& 3#' 8'&'$%4&. B'49' $&&4&8 % %' /'&'% 7

@1


63/126

%' &%-+ 4% #4,, $, ',3 %' &%4' ,4' N'3$, '%.+

% 3,47%4&8 I&94$ 4&%'&$%4&$, ,'. I*3%$&%,-+ %'-

$, 34&% % % $ 6'- 4*3%$&% 7$'% 7 4&%',4&4&8 7

46'+ 4.'.+ 4% *$- ',% 4& '9%4& 7 *' 94'$' 9'

% %' 33,- 7 $7' 94&4&8 #$%' $&9 % '6' $ 8'$%'

33' 7 *$&4%-.

0. T' B$$ 9$* $ $, /''& 4%'9 $ $& '$*3,'

4& %4 '3% $ $64&8 '&$/,'9 %' S%$%' 7 P&K$/ $&9

H$-$&$ % '84%' 7$%' 8#% $ *3$'9 % %' '% 7

%' &%-. T4 3K'% 3649'9 $& $994%4&$, 448$%'9

$'$ % %' '%'&% 7 !. *4,,4& '%$' 6' @5 -'$.

I&'$'9 448$%4& 4&%'&4%- ,'9 % 4&'$'9 $8' 7 H48


64/126

4',94&8 V$4'%- (HV) ''9 #4 $% 3''&% &%4%%'

*' %$& 0 3' '&% 7 %' $'$ &9' #'$% $&9 0 3'

'&% 7 $'$ &9' 3$99- ,%46$%4&. T' '84& ' *'

7 %' *% $96$&'9 $84,%$, %'&,84' 4& I&94$. ;

NCAER+ #4,' 9'34%4&8 %' 36'%- $%4 64;;64 %''

S%$%' $&9 %' %' S%$%' $,, 6' I&94$+ $ 3649'9 %'

7,,#4&8 %$/,':

@2


65/126

S%$%' R$, U/$& A,

,

A

'$

1@; 1;00 1@; 1;00 1@; 1;

00

P&K$/ 2.21 !.@5 2.! 5.5 2.15 !.1!

H$-$&$ @.2@ .2 0.1 10.00 @5.@! .

A,, I&94$ 5!. 2.0 .01 2@.!2 5. 2!.10

1. T+ %'- &,9' %$% %' B$$ D$* #$

4&%*'&%$, 4& ',34&8 I&94$ $4'6' 79 '4%-+ 4&

'94&8 6,$%4,4%- 7 79 8$4& 34' $&9 9',4&4&8 %'

4&49'&' 7 36'%- 4& %' '84&.


66/126

2. B'49' 34&%4&8 % %' /'&'% 7 B$$ D$*+

%' NCAER R'3% $, %$%' %$% %' ,4& $&$, $6' /%

% $&9 ,&8 %'* 4*3$% & %' '&*-. S% %'*

4*3$% 7 ,4& $&$, 4 4& %' 7* 7 4&'$'9 '*3,-*'&%

;

@@


67/126

33%&4%4' $&9 %' 8#% 7 %' '64' '%. I& %'

*'94* % ,&8 %'*+ %' *$K 4*3$% 7 ,4& $&$, 4

%8 4&'$'9 $&9 $'9 448$%4&. A,%8 %'

*$K $&9 94'% 8$4&' 7* %' 4&%',4&4&8 7 46' (ILR)

38$**' #4,, /' $84,%' $&9 $84,%';9'3'&9$&%

',9+ %' '&%4' '&*- #4,, /'&'% /'$' 7

4&'$'9 $84,%$, 39%4& $&9 %' /'&'%.

@. T' R'3% 7 %' NCAER $ 34&%'9 % 6$4

/'&'% 7 46' 4&%',4&4&8 38$**' $% %' S%$%' $&9

N$%4&$, ,'6',. H#'6'+ #'& *4&8 % %' &$&4$,

$3'% 7 %' 38$**'+ %# &'3% $' 7 8'$%

','6$&': %,-+ %' 4&6'%*'&% %$4& $&9 '&9,-+ %'


68/126

3' 7 &$&4$, 4&6'%*'&% $&9 4% '3*'&%.

P4*$4,-+ 4% 4 ,'$ 7* %' '9 /'7' %$% %4 4 $

38$**'


69/126

#,9 4&'$' 8$9$,,- 3'$4&8 4& %' -'$ 2011;2012. I%

;

#4,, %'& %$% 7$,,4&8. I&6'%*'&% ,,% 7* %' -'$

200;200 % 201;2015 #4,, $6' &49'$/,' %$4& &

%' C'&%$, G6'&*'&% &$&'+ '3'4$,,- $7%' %'

3$$8' 7 F4$, R'3&4/4,4%- $&9 B98'% M$&$8'*'&%

R,' (FRBMR). T' G6'&*'&% 4 &# **4%%'9 %

'94&8 $, 9'4% /- 0.@ 3''&%$8' 34&% 7 GDP '6'-

-'$ $&9 #$ % '9' %' $, 9'4% 9#& % @ 3' '&%

7 GDP /- %' $, -'$ 200;200. T' FRBMR $, 3%

$ '%4%4& & G6'&*'&% /#4&8. I& '$

/'>'&% &$&4$, -'$+ %' ,4*4% & /#4&8 7 3'


70/126

'&% 7 GDP #$ % 38'46',- '9'9 /- $% ,'$% 1

3''&%$8' 34&% 7 GDP+ $ **4%*'&% #4 4 % /'

$9''9 % /- $,, G6'&*'&%. T' 4&6'%*'&% 3,$&

3'3$'9 /- %' NCAER #$ 4&%'&9'9 % ',3 4& ,'$4&8

9/% 4& %' *4&9 7 %' 3'3,' $&9 33&'&% 7 %'

38$**' %$% 4&6'%*'&% 4 &% 84&8 % %$' 3,$' 4& $

4&8,' 3,' 7 -'$+ /% 6' $ 3'49 7 $% ,'$% %'&

-'$. S4&' %' 4*3$% $&$,-4 &9'%$'& /- %'

@5


71/126

NCAER $*' %$% %' I&%',4&4&8 7 R46' (ILR)

38$**' 4 '&%4',- &$&'9 /- %' C'&%$, G6'&*'&%+

;

$ ,&8' ,,% 3,$& #,9 $, ',3 4& '94&8 %' 4*3$%

& 3/,4 &$&'.

. T' NCAER $ $, 88'%'9 $&8' #4 $'

&''$- 7 %' '?'%46' 4*3,'*'&%$%4& 7 %' 46'

&'%#4&8 38$**'. I&%' $,4$+ 4% 4&,9' %' 344&8 7

448$%4& /'&'% $&9 4*36'*'&% 4& %' >$,4%- 7 '64'.

I% #4,, /' '7, % &%4' $% %4 %$8'+ %'' 88'%'9

$&8' %'*'9 $ C$&8' &''$- #4 $' $ &9':

"A '644& 7 #$%' $%' 4 &''$- 4&


72/126

%' 4&%''% 7 '4'&-. H#'6'+ 4%

,9 8 $&9 4& $&9 #4%

4*36'*'&% 4& %' >$,4%- 7 '64'

(G6'&*'&% 7 I&94$ 12). S3'4

'**'&9$%4& #'' *$9' /- %'

C**4%%'' & P44&8 7 I48$%4& W$%'

(G6'&*'&% 7 I&94$+ 12) #4% '8$9

% 344&8:

1. W$%' $%' $' $ 7*

7 ' $8'+ $&9

&% $ %$. U' 7

3/,4 448$%4& *%

@!


73/126

*''% %' % 7 %'

448$%4& '64'.

2. A 448$%4& 4 &' 7

%' '- 4&3% 4*4,$

% ''9 $&9 7'%4,4'+

4% 344&8 ,9 /'

$99''9 4& %' %

%'3.

@. U&9';344&8 7

448$%4& 4 *$4&,-

'3&4/,' 7 %' ;

. 9'%'4$%4&8 >$,4%- 7

448$%4& '64'. A

'644& 7 #$%' $%'

4 &''$- 4& %'

4&%''% 7 '4'&-.

H#'6'+ 4% ,9 8

$&9 4& $&9 #4%

4*36'*'&% 4& %'

>$,4%- 7 '64'.

5. R$%' 7 &&;

$84,%$, '

(9*'%4 $&9


74/126

4&9%4$,) ,9 $,

/' '64'9 %$% 7,,

% 4 '6''9.

!. R$%' ,9 /' /$'9

& OM &* $&9

$34%$, $8'

(4&%''% $&9

9'3'4$%4&).

@


75/126

. A6'$84&8 7 $%' /-

'84& $&9


76/126

/' $33$'9 #4%

$%4& 9' %

*3,'4%4' 4&6,6'9

#4% 4%.

. ;

10.W$%' $%' ,9 /'

$33,4'9 & %#;3$%

%$4?. A,, ,$&9 4&

@


77/126

**$&9 $'$ ,9

3$- $ =$% $&&$, 7''

& $ 3' '%$' /$4

7 *'*/'43 7 %'

-%'* $&9 $ 6$4$/,'

7'' ,4&'9 % %' $%$,

'%'&% 7 '64'

(6,*' $'$) '9

/- '$ *'*/'.

11.T' *6' % 7,,;

='98'9 6,*'%4

344&8 $&&% /'

4&%9'9

4**'94$%',-. T'

33'9

$%4&$,4$%4& 7 #$%'

344&8 #4,, $6' % /'

$*3,4'9 4& %''

3$'.

12.I& %' % 3$'+

$%4&$,4$%4& $&9

4*3,4$%4& 7 %'


78/126

'4%4&8 -%'* 7

$'*'&% (/$'9 &

3;#4' 448$%'9

$'$ & $& 4&94649$,

/$4) % $ -%'* 7

'$&;3'4 $'$

$%' ,9 /' %$'&

3. T' ,'6', 7 %

'6'- % /' $4*'9

94&8 %' % 3$'

@


79/126

,9 $% ,'$% 6'

OM % $&9 1 3'

'&% 4&%''% & $34%$,

'*3,-'9. T'

448$%'9 $'$ &9' $

3 #4 3'$9

6' % *' %$& &'

'$& ,9 /'

$8'9 $% %' $%'

$33,4$/,' % 94?''&%

'$&. H#'6'+ 4&

'$ '$&+

94%4&%4& ,9 /'

*$9' ;

1@./'%#''& 3$99-+

8$$&'+ $&9

3''&&4$, 3.

1.I& %' '&9 3$'+

%' $4* ,9 /' &

6,*'%4 *'$' 7

448$%4& #$%'

$84&8.

15.I& %49 3$'+ %'


80/126

7 ,9 /' &

3'3,' 3$%443$%4&

7 4*364&8 #$%'

' $&9+ %+

39%464%-.

T' '**'&9$%4& 7 %' C**4%%''

& P44&8 7 I48$%4& ($, &#& $ %'

V$49-&$%$& C**4%%'' R'3%) #''

7%' %94'9 /- %' G3 7 O'

7*'9 /- %' P,$&&4&8 C**44& 4&

0


81/126


82/126

9'6',3*'&% /K'%46'. T' 9$7% 3,4-

4 -'% % /' &$,4'9 /- %' N$%4&$,

A964- C&4, (NAC). T' NAC 4&%'&9

% &$,4' $ '$/4,4%$%4& 3$$8' %$%

4&,9'+ 4&%' $,4$+ 36494&8 ,$&9 7 $,,

$84,%$, 7$*4,4'+ 4*3,'*'&%4&8

3'4$, '*3,-*'&% 8$$&%''

38$**'+ 36494&8 *'%'$9 $&9

9#',,4&8 '+ /'$4&8 %$&3%$%4&

%+ 36494&8 %$4&4&8 $&9 %' 33%

'64'+ 4&%4%%4&8 $ '$/4,4%$%4& 8$&%

4& 9' % *3'&$%' , 7

4&*'


83/126

R'$/4,4%$%4& P,4- $ $&9 #'& 4% 8'%

&$,4'9."

5. B'49' *$4&8 %' $/6' /'6$%4& $&9

'**'&9$%4&+ %' NCAER $, 88'% %$% $7%'

*3,'%4& 7 %' ,4&4&8 7 46' 38$**'+ %' 94?''&%

46' ,4& ,9 /' *$4&%$4&'9 /- '3$$%' 46' /$4&

8$&4$%4&+ #4 #,9 $,, /' 7&%4&4&8 &9' %'

94'% &%, 7 %' C'&%$, W$%' C**44&

%' $3334$%' '&%$, /9-.

!. I& %' **4&8 3 7 4% R'3%+ %' NCAER $

%$%'9 %$% #$%' 4 ''&%4$, 7 39%4& 7 79+ ;

'&*4 8#%+ '$,% $&9 33% % '&64&*'&%. I%


84/126

*$4& &%4/%4& % '&*4 #',,;/'4&8 4 %8 4% '

7 $84,%' % 4*36' 79 '4%-. W$%' 4 ''&%4$, %

4&'$' $84,%$, 39%464%- &9' *9'& %'&,8-.

N'$,- ! 3' '&% 7 %' 33,$%4& 4& $, $'$ $&9 3'

'&% 4& /$& $'$ 9'3'&9 & $84,%' $ %'4 34&43$,

' 7 4&*'. T' $&$,-4 $4'9 % 4& %' S%$%'

# %$% %' ILR 38$**' $ %' 3%'&%4$, % 4&'$'

%' 8#% $%' 7 $84,%'+ #4 9',4&'9 7* . 3'

2


85/126

'&% 4& 10 % @.0 3' '&% 4& 10 $&9 #4 4 %4,,

'3%4/,' % %' 6$8$4' 7 $4&7$,,. I& 9' % 3%

'&*- & %' 48 8#% 3$% $&9 4*36' %' >$,4%-

7 ,47' 7 3'3,' 4& %' $, $'$+ $ *4'9 3,4- 7 /%

4&'$'9 $6$4,$/4,4%- 7 448$%4& $&9 4&'$4&8 &&;7$*

$%464%- 4 '>4'9.

P4&43,' A33,4'9:

. F* %' $/6' &$$%'9 7$%+ %$%'9

'**'&9$%4& $&9 34&43,'+ 4% 4 ,'$ %$% 34*$4,-

%'' 4 &$&4*4%- /'%#''& $,, &'&'9 $%4%4' ;

4&,94&8 %' C'&%' $&9 $ *$K4%- 7 %' S%$%'

G6'&*'&%+ #4% %' ''3%4& 7 &' %#+ %$%


86/126

4*3,'*'&%$%4& 7 46' ,4&4&8 #4,, /' 6'- /'&'4$,. I&

7$%+ %' '3'% 34&4& &64&4&8,- 943', $,, %'

4*3'4&. T'' $,, /' 8'$%' 8#% 4& $84,%$,

$&9 $,,4'9 '%+ 33'4%- $&9 %4*, % %' '&*-

3%'&%4$,,- $4&8 4&'$' 4& 3' $34%$ 4&*'+ 4&

$994%4& % %' % $&9 ,&8 %'* /'&'% ,4',- % $'

/- 4*3,'*'&%$%4&. T'' #,9 $' 47 %' '3'%

@


87/126

'**'&9$%4& $' 4*3,'*'&%'9 33',- $&9 #4%4& $

%4*'7$*'. T'& %'' $,, /' $9,- $&- &$&4$, %$4&

& %' '&*-. O& %' &%$-+ 4*3,'*'&%$%4&

#,9 ',3 $96$&'*'&% 7 I&94$ GDP $&9 /4&8 8'$%'

#'$,% $&9 33'4%- % %' &$%4& $ $ #,'. B'49'

$%$, /'&'% $4&8 % %' **& *$&+ %'

G6'&*'&% $, /'&'% 7* %' 9'&4%' 34/4,4%- 7

$64&8 %' S%$%' 7* 98% & %' &' $&9 $&9 =9

& %' %'. T4 3K'%+ #'& 4% /'*' $ '$,4%-+ #4,,

3649' 4**'$$/,' /'&'%. W' '' & '$& $ % #-

%' G6'&*'&% ,9 &% %$' $3334$%' $&9 %4*',- ;

4&%''% 4& %' ''%4& 7 %4 3K'%+ 3$%4,$,- #'&+


88/126

4& %' 6$4 $9$64% ,'9 /- %' C'&%$, $&9 %' S%$%'

G6'&*'&%+ 4% $ /''& $*'9 %$% %' 86'&*'&% $'

6'- ''& % 4*3,'*'&% %4 3K'% #4% 8'$% 4&'4%- $&9

'?'%46'&'.

. T' S%$%' 7 R$K$%$&+ GK$$%+ T$*4, N$9 $6'

7,,- 33%'9 %' &'3%. M$9-$ P$9' $ $,

33%'9 %' S'*'+ /% /',4'6' %$% 4% *% /'


89/126

4*3,'*'&%'9 /- %' C'&%$, G6'&*'&%. T' S%$%' 7

$&$%$$+ B4$+ P&K$/ $&9 S44* $6' 846'& *'

>$,4'9 $336$,. T'4 *$4& &'& 4+ #4% '8$9 %

4&%' /$4& %$&7'+ #4 *% 4&6,6' >49 3 >+ $

#4% $&- %' '' 4&%';,4&4&8 *% /' 7* #$%'

3, % #$%' 9'4% S%$%' $&9 4& '8$9 %

'&64&*'&%$, $&9 &$&4$, 4*3,4$%4&. S*' 7 %'

%' S%$%' $' &% &&'%'9 #4% %'' 3K'% $ %'-

$6' & 3$%443$%4& 4& 4&%';,4&4&8 7 46'. T' S%$%' 7

'$,$ $ 3%'%'9 % *' '%'&%+ % %' ,&8 94%$&'

4&%' /$4& #$%' %$&7' & %' /$4 %$% %' S%$%' &''9

;


90/126

#$%' % 33,- %'4 4&%4$%' &'%# 7 &$%$, $&9 *$&;

*$9' $&&',.

. I% 4 $, %' $' 7 %' S%$%' 7 '$,$ %$% %'4

46' $' *&&;7'9 $&9 &% 3''&&4$, 4& &$%'+

%''7'+ '$,$ '3'4'&' '6'' #$%' $4%- 94&8

**' ?;*&& *&%.

5


91/126

50. T' %$&9 %$'& /- %' '3'%46' S%$%'+ $ &%4'9

$/6'+ # %$%+ /- $&9 ,$8'+ %'' 4 &$&4*4%- 4&

$'3%4&8 4&%',4&4&8 7 46' /% %' ''6$%4& 7 %''

S%$%' $& $, &% /' 48&'9+ /'4&8 ',$%$/,' % %'4

3$%4,$ '&*4+ 8'8$34$, $&9 4;'&*4

&''9. T'' $' *$%%' #4 >$',- 7$,, #4%4& %'

9*$4& 7 8'&'$, &'& $&9 %+ '>4' $ 7$*'#

% /' 7*,$%'9 /- %' *3'%'&% G6'&*'&% %'

L'84,$%'+ $ %' $' *$- /'+ 34 % 4% ''%4&.

51. T' N$%4&$, C**44& 7 R'64'# 7 %' W4&8

7 %' C&%4%%4& (NCRWC) 2002 4& 4% R'3% $, 9'$,%

#4% $&%' 4*3%$&% 7$'% 7 46' 4&%',4&4&8 4.'. $4&8


92/126

7 46' #$%'. E3,$4&4&8 %' 9%4&' 7 46' $4&8+ 4%

;

9'4/'9 D%4&' 7 R43$4$& R48%+ D%4&' 7 P4

A3334$%4&+ T'4%4$, I&%'84%- T'-+ D%4&' 7

T'4%4$, S6''48&%-+ E&8,4 C**& L$# P4&43,' 7

R43$4$& R48%+ D%4&' 7 C**&4%- I&%''%+ D%4&' 7

E>4%$/,' A33%4&*'&%. I% $, '3,$4&'9 %$% #'&

!


93/126

9'%'*4&4&8 #$% $ '$&$/,' $&9 '>4%$/,' $' 4+ %'

7$% #4 ,9 /' %$'& 4&% &49'$%4&. I& %$%

/'$,7+ 4% 3'4$,,- '7''9 % $8''*'&%+ K944$,

9'44&+ $#$9 $&9 %* %$% $,'$9- $' 4& 3,$'.

F%'*'+ ',$%46' '&*4 $&9 4$, &''9 7

4&%''%'9 %$%'+ 6,*' 7 %'$* $&9 4% '+ ,$&9 &%

#$%''9 #'' %' ','6$&% &49'$%4&. T+ 4% #4,, /'

7 %' '3'% /94' $,&' % '$*4&' & 4' $&9

%'4 4*3$% & %' 3K'%.

52. B' %$% $ 4% *$-+ #' $6' & '4%$%4& 4&

/'64&8 %$% %' &$%4&$, 4&%''% *% %$' 3''9'&'

6' %' 4&%''% 7 %' 4&94649$, S%$%'. T' S%$%'


94/126

G6'&*'&% $' '3'%'9 % 64'# &$%4&$, 3/,'* #4% $

8'$%' /K'%464%-+ $%4&$,4%- $&9 344% 7 '64' % %'

&$%4& $&9 ;

4,,;7&9'9 /K'%4& *$- ',% 4& 8'$%' $*+ &% &,-

% %' &'48/4&8 S%$%' /% $, % %' &$%4& $% ,$8'.


95/126

5@. N#+ #' *$- '7' % '%$4& &%4%%4&$,

3644& #4 $6' /'$4&8 & %' *$%%' 4& 4'

/'7' . U&9' %' &%4%%4&$, '*'+ %'' 4 $

,'$ 9'*$$%4& 7 ',9 7 3'$%4& $&9 K494%4&

/'%#''& %' L'84,$%'+ J944$- $&9 %' E'%46'. T'

L'84,$%' *$- $6' &% 4%',7 %' 3#' % *$' '%$4&

3'4 ,'84,$%4& &% &,- 86'&4&8 $ ',9 7 4%

,'84,$%46' *3'%'&' $ 3649'9 4& %' S'6'&% S'9,'

7 %' C&%4%%4&+ /% $, '8$94&8 $ 3$%4,$ 943%'

'7'$/,' % &' 7 %' A%4,' 4%',7. A%4,' 2!2 7 %'

C&%4%%4& 4 &' 7 3#'. U&9' %4 A%4,'+ %'

P$,4$*'&%+ /- ,$#+ $& 3649' 7 %' $9K94$%4& 7 $&-

943%' *3,$4&% #4% '3'% % %' '+ 94%4/%4&


96/126

$&9 &%, 7 #$%' 7 $&- 4&%';%$%' 46' 46' 6$,,'-.

5. A%4,' 2!2(2) 7 %' C&%4%%4& 3'& #4% $ &&;

/%$&%' '3'4&+ %$% &%#4%%$&94&8 $&-%4&8

&%$4&'9 4& %' C&%4%%4&+ P$,4$*'&% *$- /- ,$# ;

3649' %$% &'4%' %' S3'*' C% & $&- %' C%

$,, ''4' K494%4& 4& '3'% 7 $&- 943%'

*3,$4&% $ '7''9 % 4& A%4,' 2!2(1). I& %' #9+


97/126

%' P$,4$*'&% $& ''6' % 4%',7+ %' 3#' % % %'

K494%4& 7 %' %+ 4&,94&8 %' 48'% C% 7 %'

,$&9+ 4& ',$%4& % $ #$%' 943%' $ %$%'9 &9' %4

A%4,'. T' K494%4& 7 %' C% #4,, /' %'9 &,-

#4% '8$9 % %' $9K94$%4& 7 %' 943%' $&9 &% $,,

*$%%' 4&49'&%$, %''%. F '$*3,'+ %' S3'*'

C% $& '%$4&,- 94'% %' C'&%$, G6'&*'&% % 7,,,

4% %$%%- /,48$%4& &9' S'%4& 7 %' A%+ #4 4

*$&9$%-+ #4%% 9'494&8 $&- #$%' 943%' /'%#''& %'

S%$%'. S'' : T$*4, N$9 C$6'- N''33$$&$

V4,$43,8$, V46$$-48$, N$,$ U4*$4 P$98$33 S$&8$*

6. U&4& 7 I&94$ O.+ AIR 10 SC 1@1!.


98/126

55. O&' 7 %' 34/,' 64'# %$'& #4% '8$9 %

A%4,' 2!2 4 %$% %' ' 7 '3'4& *$- 4& %'

C&%4%%4& 9' &% 4&94$%' $ ,'$ ,'84,$%46' 4&%'&%+

%+ 4% *$- /' 34/,' %$% S'%4& 11 7 %' A% ,9

'7' &,- % 943%' $ $' $,'$9- '7''9 % $

;


99/126

T4/&$, $&9 #4 $' %49' %' 364'# 7 %' %.

O&' $ 3'4 $9K94$%- *'$&4* 4 '$%'9+ %$%

*$4&'- *' 4&% 3'$%4& #4% %' '$%4& 7 %'

T4/&$, $&9 3/$/,-+ %'& $,&' #4,, %' C%

K494%4& /' %'9.

5!. T' S'6'&% S'9,' % %' C&%4%%4& 3',, %

94?''&% ',9 7 ,'84,$%4& &9' %' U&4& L4% (L4% I)+

S%$%' L4% (L4% II) $&9 C&'&% L4% (L4% III). E&%- 5! 7

L4% I '*3#' %' U&4& P$,4$*'&% % '&$% ,$# 4&

',$%4& % %' '8,$%4& $&9 9'6',3*'&% 7 4&%';%$%'

46' $&9 46' 6$,,'-+ % %' '%'&% %$% '8,$%4&

$&9 9'6',3*'&% 4 9',$'9 /- %' P$,4$*'&%+ /- ,$#+ %


100/126

/' '3'94'&% 4& %' 3/,4 4&%''%. E&%- 5 9'$, #4%

4&8 $&9 '4' /'-&9 %'4%4$, #$%'. E&%- 4

$ '49$, '&%-+ #4 &7' %' ,'84,$%46' ',9 3&

%' U&4& P$,4$*'&% #4 $' &% 3'4$,,- 3649'9 7

&9' L4% II $&9


101/126

A84,%' 4 $8$4& $ S%$%' /K'%. T' C&'&% L4%

(L4% III) 9' &% &%$4& $&- '&%- 4& '8$9 % #$%' $&9

$84,%'+ $ .

5. E&%- 2 7 L4% III 4 %' ,$# ',$%4&8 % $>44%4&

$&9 '>44%4& 7 33'%- /- %' U&4& $&9 %' S%$%'

P$,4$*'&%. T' ',% 4 %$%+ 4& ',$%4& % $>44%4&+

%' C'&%' $&9 %' S%$%'+ /%+ $6' 3#' % ,'84,$%'.

E&%- 20 7 L4% III 9'$, #4% '&*4 $&9 4$, 3,$&&4&8.

T+ #4% %' $49 7 %' '49$, 3#' &9' E&%- +

L4% I+ %' U&4& P$,4$*'&% 8'% $ 6'- #49' ',9 7

,'84,$%4&+ ',$%$/,' % 6$4 /K'%.

5. T' R46' B$9 A%+ 15! #$ '&$%'9 /- %'


102/126

P$,4$*'&% &9' E&%- 5! 7 L4% I. T' I&%';S%$%' W$%'

D43%' A% #$ $, '&$%'9 #4% '7''&' % %' $*'

E&%-. W''$ %' *$&9$%' 7 %' ,$%%' 4 % 3649' $

*$4&'- 7 %' '%%,'*'&% 7 943%'+ %' 7*' 4 $&

A% % '%$/,4 B$9 7 %' '8,$%4& $&9 9'6',3*'&%

7 4&%';S%$%' 46' /$4&+ %8 $964' $&9 94&$%4&+

;

51


103/126


104/126

%' 64'# %$% 4& S'%4& 11 7 %' A%+ %' '3'4& '+

94%4/%4& $&9 &%, 7 #$%' 4& $&- 46' $' %' '-

#9 4& 9'%'*4&$%4& 7 %' 3' 7 3#' &7''9 & $

T4/&$, &%4%%'9 &9' S'%4& @ 7 %' A%. I7 $ *$%%'

7',, %49' %' 3' 7 %'' %'' 4$, #9+ %' 3#'

7 S'%4& 11 4& %4&8 %' K494%4& 7 %' % 4&

'3'% 7 $&- #$%' 943%'+ #4 4 %'#4' % /' ;

52


105/126

'7''9 % T4/&$,+ #,9 &% $6' $&- *$&&' 7

$33,4$%4&. T' %'% 7 *$4&%$4&$/4,4%- 7 $ ,'8$, $%4&

4&4%4$%'9 /- $ S%$%' 4& $ C% #,9 % /'+ #'%' %'

4' $4'9 %''4& $' '7'$/,' % $ T4/&$, 7

$9K94$%4& 7 %' *$&&' 7 '+ 94%4/%4& $&9 &%,

7 #$%'.

!1. F%'+ %4 C% #4,' 9',4&4&8 % 4' $

*$&9$* 94'%4&8 %' S%$%' 7 $&$%$$+ A&9$

P$9' $&9 M$$$%$ % &%4%%' $ **& T4/&$,+

',9:

"1!. ......I% 4 '%%,'9 ,$# %$% $

94'%4& $&&% 34/,- /' 8$&%'9

$ % *3', $& $%4%- % ''4' $

3#' #4 $ $ /%$&%4$, ','*'&% 7


106/126

94'%4&. I& $&- '6'&% %' *$&9$* %

''4' $ 3#' #4 4 ,'84,$%46' 4&

$$%' $&&% /' 4'9 $&9 I $* 4&

7,, $8''*'&% #4% %' /*44& 7 M.

S,44% G'&'$, & %4 ' $ #',,. A%

/'% 4% #,9 &,- /' $& 4' 7 89

86'&$&' /% %$% /- 4%',7 #,9 &%

*'$& $&9 4*3,- %$% %' U&4&

G6'&*'&% $ ''%46' 3#' '6'& %

7' $ '%%,'*'&% 3& %' S%$%'."

;

5@


107/126

!2. T' $/6' %$%'9 34&43,' ,'$,- # %$% $

8'$%' ','*'&% 7 *%$,4%- $&9 &'& &''9 % /'

/4,% /'%#''& %' S%$%' $&9 %' C'&%' & %' &' $&9+

$&9 %' S%$%' 4&%' ' & %' %'. I% #4,, /' 6'- 94,%

7 %' C% % &9'%$' $& ''4' #4%4& %'

,4*4%'9 3' 7 4% 3#' 7 K944$, '64'# $&9 '6'& & %'

/$4 7 '3$&9'9 34&43,' 7 P/,4 I&%''% L4%48$%4&. A

P/,4 I&%''% L4%48$%4& /'7' %4 C% $ % 7$,, #4%4&

%' &% 7 &%4%%4&$, ,$#+ $ & K494%4& 4

#49' %$& %4 C% &%4%%4&$, K494%4& &9'

A%4,' @2 7 %' C&%4%%4&. T' C% $& $9,- %$'

&% 4%',7 %$ 7 *$4&8 7 $ 3,4- 9'44& 3,$&&4&8

7 %' &%- 9'%'*4&4&8 '&*4 7$% %'


108/126

4$, $3'% ,4' &''9 7 $>44%4& $&9 &%%4& 7

46' ,4&4&8 $&&', &9' %$% 38$*. T' C% 4 &%

'>433'9 % %$' '3'% 9'44& $&9 %'- ''&%4$,,-

,9 /' ,'7% 7 %' C'&%$, G6'&*'&% $&9 %'

&'&'9 S%$%'. S $& $%%'*3% /- %' C% *$-

$*&% % %' C% 4%%4&8 4& K98*'&% 6' %' 34&4& 7

%' '3'% 4& %' '3'%46' ',9+ #4%% $&- %, $&9 ;

5


109/126

'3'%4' $% 4% 943$,. T' '>4'*'&% 4& %' 3''&%

$' $6' 94?''&% 94*'&4&. T' 3,$&&4&8+ $>44%4&+

&$&4&8+ 344&8+ 464, &%%4&+ '&64&*'&%$, 4'

4&6,6'9 $' 3,4- 9'44& $?'%4&8 %' ,'84,$%46'

*3'%'&' $&9 #,9 >$',- 7$,, 4& %' 9*$4& 7 %'

G6'&*'&% 7 S%$%' $&9 C'&%'. W' '%$4&,- ,9 &%

/' &9'%9 % '6'& 4*3,- %$% %' 33'9 3K'% 7

4&%';,4&4&8 7 46' ,9 &% /' *3,'%'9.

!@. W' #,9 '**'&9+ #4% $,, %' K944$, $%4%-

$% **$&9+ %$% %'' 3K'% $' 4& %' &$%4&$,

4&%''%+ $ 4 %' &$&4* 64'# 7 $,, '3'%+ *% S%$%'

G6'&*'&% $&9 3$%4,$,-+ %' C'&%$, G6'&*'&%.


110/126

B% %4 C% *$- &% /' $ 6'- $3334$%' 7* 7

3,$&&4&8 $&9 4*3,'*'&%$%4& 7 $ 38$**' $64&8

#49' &$%4&$, 94*'&4& $&9 $*4$%4&. I% #4,, &% &,-

/' 9'4$/,'+ /% $, 4&'64%$/,' %$% $& $3334$%' /9-

,9 /' '$%'9 % 3,$&+ &%% $&9 4*3,'*'&% %4

4&%' ,4&4&8 7 46' 38$* 7 %' /'&'% 7 %' &$%4&

$ $ #,'.

55


111/126

;

!. R'$,44&8 ,4*4%$%4&+ #' #,9 &$,,- 943' 7

%4 P/,4 I&%''% L4%48$%4& #4% %' 7,,#4&8 94'%4&:;

(I) W' 94'% %' U&4& 7 I&94$ $&9 3$%4,$,- %'

M4&4%- 7 W$%' R''+ G6'&*'&% 7 I&94$+ %

7%#4% &%4%%' $ C**4%%'' % /' $,,'9 $ S3'4$,

C**4%%'' 7 I&%';,4&4&8 7 R46' (''4&$7%'

'7''9 $ %' C**4%%'') 7 #4+ %' 7,,#4&8

$,, /' %' M'*/':;

($) T' H&/,' M4&4%' 7 W$%' R''.

(/) S''%$-+ M4&4%- 7 W$%' R''.

() S''%$-+ M4&4%- 7 E&64&*'&% $&9 F'%.

(9) C$4*$&+ C'&%$, W$%' C**44&.


112/126

(') M'*/';S''%$-+ N$%4&$, W$%' D'6',3*'&%

A%4%-.

(7) F '3'% % /' &*4&$%'9+ &' '$ 7* %'

7,,#4&8 M4&4%4'


113/126

(444) O&' E3'% 7* %' P,$&&4&8 C**44&

;

(46) O&' E3'% 7* %' M4&4%- 7 E&64&*'&%

F'%.

(8) M4&4%' 7 W$%' $&9


114/126

(4) T# 4$, $%464% % /' &*4&$%'9 /- '$ 7

%' &'&'9 M4&4%4'.

(K) M. R$&K4% *$ (A*4 C4$').

(II) T' C**4%%'' $,, *''%+ $% ,'$%+ &' 4& %#

*&% $&9 $,, *$4&%$4& '9 7 4% 944&

$&9 %' M4&%'.

5


115/126

(III) I& %' $/'&' 7 $&- 3'& 7* *''%4&8+

4'3'%46' 7 4


116/126


117/126

(VI) A,, %' '3% 7 %' '3'% /94' $ #',, $ %' %$%

'3% ,'9 /'7' %4 C% 94&8 %' 3'&9'&- 7

%4 3'%4%4&+ $,, /' 3,$'9 /'7' %' C**4%%'' 7

;

4% &49'$%4&. U3& 9' $&$,-4 7 %' R'3% $&9

'3'% 34&4&+ %' C**4%%'' $,, 3'3$' 4% 3,$&

7 4*3,'*'&%$%4& 7 %' 3K'%.

(VII) T' 3,$& 3'3$'9 $,, $6' 94?''&% 3$'+

94'%,- ',$%$/,' % %' 3,$&&4&8+ 4*3,'*'&%$%4&+

&%%4&+ ''%4& $&9 *3,'%4& 7 %' 3K'%.

(VIII) W' $' 4&7*'9 %$% ,$8' * $6' /''& 3'&% &

3'3$$%4& 7 4&4%4$, $&9 9'%$4,'9 3K'% '3% 7 %'

3K'% '&;B'%#$ PK'%. T' DPR 4 &# '$9-.


118/126

T' S%$%' 7 M$9-$ P$9' $&9 U%%$ P$9' $&9

$, %' C'&%$, G6'&*'&% $9 $,'$9- 846'& %'4

$336$, $&9 &'&%. T' ,$4$%4& 8% #4,, /'

94'9 /- %' C**4%%''. W' #,9 94'% %'

C**4%%'' % %$' 3 %4 3K'% 7 4*3,'*'&%$%4&

$% %' % 4&%$&' 4%',7.

5


119/126

(I) ''34&8 4& 64'# %' '3'% '3%+ #' $6' &

'4%$%4& 4& /'64&8 $&9 94'%4&8 %$% %4*' 4 $

6'- *$%'4$, 7$% 4& %' '?'%46' ''%4& 7 %'

I&%',4&4&8 7 R46' 3K'%. A 34&%'9 % 4& %'

R'3% /- NCAER $&9 /- %' S%$&94&8 C**4%%''+ %'

;

9',$- $ $96'',- $?'%'9 %' &$&4$, /'&'% %$% ,9

$6' $'9 % %' &'&'9 3$%4' $&9 %' 3'3,'

$% ,$8' $&9 4 4& 7$% &# 3%%4&8 $ &$&4$, %$4& &

$,, &'&'9.

() I% 4 94'%'9 %$% %' C**4%%'' $,, %$' * %'3

$&9 $ 9'&4%' %4*'7$*' % ,$- 9#& %' 849',4&'

7 *3,'%4& 7 7'$4/4,4%- '3% %' '3%


120/126

$&9 $,, '&' %' *3,'%4& 7 3K'% %$% %'

/'&'% $' #4%4& '$&$/,' %4*' $&9 %.

(I) A% %' 4&4%4$, %$8'+ %4 38$* *$- &% 4&6,6'

%' S%$%' #4 $6' 4'&% #$%' $&9 $' &%

/%$&%4$,,- 4&6,6'9 4& $&- 4&%';,4&4&8 7 46'

38$**' $&9 %' 3K'% $& /' *3,'%'9 #4%%

%'4 '?'%46' 3$%443$%4&.

!0


121/126

(II) H#'6'+ %' C**4%%'' *$- 4&6,6' $&- S%$%' 7

'?'%46' *3,'%4& 7 %' 38$**' $% $&-

/'>'&% %$8'.

(III) T'' $' 3K'% #'' %' 3$3' # $ /''&

84&8 7 %' ,$% %'& -'$ $&9 $% /%$&%4$, % %

%' 3/,4 ''>'. T''7'+ #' 94'% %' C'&%$,

;

$&9 %' S%$%' G6'&*'&% % 3$%443$%' 4& %' 38$*

$&9 '&9' $,, &$&4$,+ $9*4&4%$%46' $&9 ''%46'

',3 % *3,'%' %'' 3K'% *' '?'%46',-.

(IV) I% 4 '649'&% 7* %' '9 %$% %' R'3%

/*4%%'9 /- %' T$ F' $6' &% /''& $%'9

3&. T+ %' '&%4' '?% 3% 4& /- %' T$ F'


122/126

$ 3$%4$,,- /''& 7 & ' % %' &'&'9

86'&*'&%+ * ,' %' 3/,4. T' T$ F'

$ &# /''& #&9 3. L'% %' '3% 7 %' T$

F' $, /' 3,$'9 /'7' %' C**4%%'' #4 $,,+

#4%% 7$4,+ %$' 9' &%' 7 %' 88'%4& *$9'

%''4& $&9 %$' 9'44& $ % # %' $*' $' %

/' 4*3,'*'&%'9 7 %' /'&'% 7 %' 3/,4 $% ,$8'.

!1


123/126

(V) T' C**4%%'' &%4%%'9 &9' %4 9' $,, /'

'3&4/,' 7 $-4&8 % %' 4&%';,4&4&8 38$*.

I% 9'44& $,, %$' 3''9'&' 6' $,,

$9*4&4%$%46' /94' '$%'9 &9' %' 9' 7 %4

C% %'#4'.

;

(VI) W' 8$&% ,4/'%- % %' ,'$&'9 A*4 C4$' % ,'

&%'*3% 3'%4%4& 4& %4 C%+ 4& %' '6'&% 7 9'7$,%

&&;*3,4$&' 7 %' 94'%4& &%$4&'9 4& %4

9'.

!5. W' #,9 7$4, 4& 9%- 47 #' 9 &% 3,$' &

'9 %' $33'4$%4& 7 %' 6$,$/,' $&9 $/,' $4%$&'

'&9''9 /- %' ,'$&'9 A*4 C4$' $&9 $,, %' '&4


124/126

&', $&9 $4%4&8 &', $33'$4&8 4& %' 3''&% PIL.

!!. W' &% &,- '3' $ 34 3' 7 3''9-

4*3,'*'&%$%4& /% $, 9 ''/- 4' $ *$&9$* %

%' C'&%$, $&9 %' S%$%' G6'&*'&% &'&'9 % *3,-

#4% %' 94'%4& &%$4&'9 4& %4 K98*'&% '?'%46',-

$&9 '3'94%4,- $&9 #4%% 9'7$,%. T4 4 $ *$%%' 7

&$%4&$, /'&'% $&9 38'. W' '' & '$& #- $&-

!2


125/126

S%$%' ,9 ,$8 /'4&9 4& &%4/%4&8 4% /4% % /4&8 %'

I&%';,4&4&8 R46' P8$* % $ '+ % $64&8 %'

3'3,' ,464&8 4& 98%;3&' &' 7* &8' $&9

3'3,' ,464&8 4& =9;3&' $'$ 7* %' 9'%%4&

$'9 /- =9.

;

!. W4% %' /'6$%4& $&9 94'%4& '9'9

3$+ W4% P'%4%4& (C464,) N.512 7 2002+ W4% P'%4%4&

(C464,) N.!! 7 2002 $&9 $,, %' $33,4$%4& ,'9 4& /%

%'' #4% 3'%4%4& $' ''/- &$,,- 943'9 7 #4% &

9' $ % %.


126/126

.............................CJI.

S.H. $3$94$

..................................+J.

A.. P$%&$4

..................................+J.

S#$%$&%' *$

N'# D',4

F'/$- 2+ 2012%%3:

networking of rivers 24 feb 2012 sc judgement.doc

Documents