netherlands, with alternative fuels - alf-cemind at enci maastricht.pdfbenelux alternative fuels at...

31
Benelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from the Maastricht Cement works, the Netherlands, with alternative fuels

Upload: others

Post on 10-Mar-2020

10 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Benelux

Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht

ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007

Practical experiences from the Maastricht Cement works , the Netherlands, with alternative fuels

Page 2: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 2

Benelux

PROGRAM 30.08.2007

1. General introduction ENCI Maastricht cement works / A F

2. BioMill (dried sewage sludge grinding)

3. SBI (coarse fuels handling installation)

4. Plant visit

Page 3: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 3

Benelux

Cement grinding

Clinker production

Cement grinding

IJMUIDEN

ROTTERDAM

MAASTRICHT

DEN BOSCH

ENCI production locations

Page 4: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 4

Benelux

PLANT MAASTRICHT* New organisation per 01.07.2005* 3 hierarchical levels (MT – Teamleaders – Teams)

(Year end) Real Real Real Target2004 2005 2006 2007

ClinkerRegular FTE's 159,4 88,8 86,1 88,5Future pre pension 16 7 -

CementRegular FTE's 159,4 94,8 91,8 96,0Future pre pension 17,5 9,4 -

Plant Maastricht 318,8 217,1 194,3 184,5

Real Real Real Target2004 2005 2006 2007

Cement equivalent in Kton 1.215 1.226 1.349 1.334

Productivity Tons/Fte 3.692 5.635 6.906 7.230

Overview Manpower

Productivity

Page 5: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 5

Benelux

•Long dry kiln, 1968 (L: 180 m, Ø: 5,5 m)•2 stage preheater•Max capacity 950.000 tpy•Heat consumption 3,6 GJ/t cli•Planetary cooler•No precalcining, No midkiln firing

ENCI Maastricht cement works kiln 8

Page 6: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 6

Benelux

AF target for Europe

Target 2007 : Group: 25,0 %T.E.A.M.: 14,1 %

Page 7: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 7

Benelux

ENCI Policy

Sustainabledevelopment

AlternativeMaterials

Energy Emissions

100

100

0

100 100

0 0 0

Is according to HC AFR policy commitment

Page 8: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 8

Benelux

Limitations / constraints

Important limitations and constraints for ENCI Maastricht:

� Permit (sludges, paper, plastics, rubber, manure, animal

meal, all non-hazardous with exception for glycolbottom)

� Kiln layout (no precalcining, only main burner)

� Emissions

� Feeder availability & capacity

� Quality (P2O5)

� Production capacity

Page 9: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 9

Benelux

Fuel package history ENCI kiln-8

GJ/t cli from prim., alt.-biomass and alt.-other

0,0

0,5

1,0

1,5

2,0

2,5

3,0

3,5

4,0

4,5

5,0

1968

1970

1972

1974

1976

1978

1980

1982

1984

1986

1988

1990

1992

1994

1996

1998

2000

2002

2004

2006

GJ/

t cli

% alternative other

% alternative biomass

% primary

Page 10: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 10

Benelux

Realisation 2006

ktpy GJ/t cli Biomass %kiln Finecokes 5,3 0,22 0

PPDF40 SBI 10,8 0,31 60PPDF40 DS5 0,0 0,00 60Paper sludge Smurfit Kappa 1,2 0,01 100Anode dust 25,8 1,01 0Glycolbottom 11,8 0,23 0Dewatered sludge 0,0 0,00 100Natural gas 0,2 0,01 0Lignite 10,3 0,29 0Animal Meal 13,0 0,31 100Sewage Sludge BioMill 73,4 1,20 100Paper sludge Sappi 6,2 0,05 100Rubbergranulate 0,0 0,00 0Sewage sluge SC Heer. 0,0 0,00 100PPDF90 6,3 0,13 80

dryer Natural gas 0,9 0,04 0Lignite 2,5 0,07 0Total kiln 3,75

Fossil 8 %Biomass 49 %

Alternative 43 %Total 100 %

Fossil = % fossil fuels in fuel packageBiomass =% biomass alternative fuels in fuelpackageAlternative % non biomass alternative fuels in fuelpackage

Fossil8%

Biomass49%

Altern.43%

Page 11: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 11

Benelux

Kiln-8 specific fuel cost development

0,00

0,50

1,00

1,50

2,00

2,50

3,00

3,50

4,00

4,50

1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006

Fue

l cos

t [eu

ro p

er to

n cl

i]

Page 12: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 12

Benelux

Dosing equipment for Fuels

Page 13: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 13

Benelux

Coarse AF :PPDF

Papersludge

Glycolbottom

Solid fuel mix:Cokes

Lignite Sewage sludge,

Animal meal

IR-Flame detection

Natural gas

Cooling air

Concrete

Swirl air

Axial air

Axial air

Solid mixSwirl air

Natural gas

Glycolbottom

Side view burner head Kiln-8 Front view burner head Kiln-8

Alt. fuels

Cooling air

Burner : FLS-Swirlax burner + ENCI-overfire lance

Page 14: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 14

Benelux

BioMill (dried sewage sludge grinding)

Page 15: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 15

Benelux

• First trials with Sewage Sludge in 1996

• Sewage Sludge/Cokes mixture ground in ball mill at a low O2-content (1996 - jan. 2000).

• “BioMill” a vertical roller mill for grinding Sewage Sludge commisioned in feb. 2000 (joint venture, ENCI / ZL)

• Sewage Sludge consumption : 1997 : <1 tph2000 : 3,5 tph (BioMill 1) 2004 : >6 tph (BioMill 2)2007 : 11 tph

Sewage sludge at ENCI; history

Page 16: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 16

Benelux

Bio Mill

joint venture

WBL35 kton unground sludge 80 kton ground sludge

operation +capital costs

profit share 50% profit share 50%

Other suppliers

45 kton unground sludge

Joint venture ENCI / WBL

WIN-WIN: solving a waste problem together with the Government

Page 17: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 17

Benelux

Vertical roller mill - BMH

Page 18: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 18

Benelux

Day stock silos for ground sludge

Storage silos for unground sludge

Filter

Vertical Mill110 kW

BioMill

Wim Heldens

Explosion valve

Filter

Filter

DosingequipmentCoriolis

Pump

Fan

Explosion valveExplosion valve

Kiln

Tm

Tm

Page 19: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 19

Benelux

Page 20: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 20

Benelux

Sewage sludge consumption history

Sewage sludge consumption (kg/t cli)

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006

kg/t

cli

BioMill 2

BioMill 1

Page 21: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 21

Benelux

Sewage sludge limits and constraints

Ash : Av. Ash conc. 33% => raw meal quality adjusted accordingly(LSF raw meal >> 100)

Hg :Hg-limit 0,05 mg/Nm3 => ESP dust purge to break Hg-cycle

Cl : Build up of Cl in kiln system => ESP dust purge to break Cl-cycle

P2O5 :P2O5 in cli >0,8% => LSF cli increased to compensate for drop in early strength.

Page 22: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 22

Benelux

SBI (coarse fuels handling installation)

Page 23: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 23

Benelux

Motivation for waste fuel burner

Lowering fuel costs

Introduction of coarse fuels (rubber)

No preca., no midkiln.

Limited possibilities at coal channel (width : 57 mm)

Burner adjustment !

Page 24: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 24

Benelux

1993 : Waste fuel burner, overfire lance

Considerations :� Burnout characteristics� Experience elsewhere (proven tech.)� Low cost solution

Solution :� Overfire lance, mounted on main burner � Costs : appr. 20 k€� Not required to make big adjustments to swirlax

burner (e.g. reinforcement of trolly)

Page 25: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 25

Benelux

Waste fuel burner

� Outer diam. : 219 mm� Fuel feed channel : 125 mm� Cooling air : not in use.� Transport air : 2100 Nm3/h� Air velocity : 50 m/s� Burner weight : + 25 % (appr.)� Capacity : appr. 5 tph

Page 26: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 26

Benelux

Schematic overview coarse fuels handling/firing

• Simple lay out• Low inv. cost : appr. 150 k€

Page 27: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 27

Benelux

History firing through waste fuel burner

� 1993 : erection of waste fuel burner & waste fuel h andling installation for coarse fuels (simple lay out)

� 1994 : first trials with shredded rubber (< 2cm)

� 1995 : trials with plastic chips

� 1998 : trials with Rofire

� 1999 : introduction of Paper sludge (dry)

� 2000 : introduction of Rofire

� 2001 : replacement of first waste fuel handling ins tallation by definite installation (SBI)

� 2006 : introduction of Paper sludge (wet), PPDF40 a nd PPDF 90

� 2007 : addition of extra feeder for introduction of low calorific coarse fuels (TBI).

Page 28: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 28

Benelux

SBI

Main burner

Overfire lance

FLS-swirlax + overfire lance

Fuel 1 Fuel 2

Belt weigh feeders

inv. cost : appr. 2.700 k€

Page 29: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 29

Benelux

TBI, simple feeder for low calorific fuels

� Increase in feedingflexibility

� Releave of unloading &handling load at SBI

� Inv. appr. 100 k €

Page 30: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 30

Benelux

Heat input through waste fuel burner

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

20

1968

1970

1972

1974

1976

1978

1980

1982

1984

1986

1988

1990

1992

1994

1996

1998

2000

2002

2004

2006

% o

f tot

al h

eat i

nput

Page 31: Netherlands, with alternative fuels - ALF-CEMIND at ENCI Maastricht.pdfBenelux Alternative fuels at ENCI Maastricht ALF-CEMIND study tour, aug 29 & 30, 2007 Practical experiences from

Pg: 31

Benelux

SBI limits and constraints

Fuel handling capacity : Truck unloading capacity / crane capacity / AF bulk density=> Strict logistics planning, crane software improvement, quality specs regarding bulk density

Burnout :Coarse fuels burnout vs fine fuels burnout => Heat-% fromcoarse fuels limited to 20 %.

Equipment availability :SBI “MTBF“ not good => change in rotary valve size and type, crane software improvement, no rubber anymore.

Cl : Build up of Cl in kiln system => ESP dust purge to break Cl-cycle, Cl limit in quality specs for AF.