nature peer review protein folds

10
peer review Débora Miranda Jan 2011

Upload: debora-miranda

Post on 13-Jul-2015

366 views

Category:

Education


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Nature peer review protein folds

peer review

Débora MirandaJan 2011

Page 2: Nature peer review protein folds

Article

• Biology

• 6 Authors

• University of Texas

• Rockefeller University, NY

Page 3: Nature peer review protein folds

CITATIONS 122 Citations

and : 44

Web of Knowledge only: 78

Type 88 articles 13 letters 11 reviews 7 proceedings papers 2 editorial material 1 meeting abstract

Page 4: Nature peer review protein folds

BIAS A – author

6

B – institution 5

C – known associations 0 5%

95%

BiasNo Bias

Page 5: Nature peer review protein folds

BIAS 5/6 Author bias

Rama Ranganathan (University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center)

Page 6: Nature peer review protein folds

JOURNALS

Public Library of Science (PLoS)

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS)

13%

9%78%

PLoSPNASOther

Page 7: Nature peer review protein folds

JOURNAL RELEVANCE

Nature Publishing Group (5) Molecular Systems Biology Nature Structural & Molecular Biology Embo journal

High Impact Factor (8.993 - 12.243) Average 5.236

Page 8: Nature peer review protein folds

PRESS COVERAGE Blogs

Scientific Clearing House Macromolecular Modeling Blog Nature blog, molecular systems biology Discount thoughts PLoS blog (Pacific Symposium on Biocomputing)

News Scientists at University of Manchester, Faculty of Life

Sciences target proteomics, News Rx, http://www.newsrx.com/newsletters/Proteomics-Weekly.html

Page 9: Nature peer review protein folds

CONCLUSIONS Transparency

Author

All journals peer reviewed

Subject less press coverage relevance over the years

Page 10: Nature peer review protein folds

NEXT STEP

Compare with other articles/issues