narrative exposure therapy (net) concept and efficacynet: evidence net causes a significant...

23
Concept and Efficacy Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET)

Upload: others

Post on 05-Jun-2020

10 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET) Concept and EfficacyNET: Evidence NET causes a significant reduction of PTSD even in unsafe living conditions There is no indication that NET can cause

Concept and Efficacy

Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET)

Page 2: Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET) Concept and EfficacyNET: Evidence NET causes a significant reduction of PTSD even in unsafe living conditions There is no indication that NET can cause
Page 3: Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET) Concept and EfficacyNET: Evidence NET causes a significant reduction of PTSD even in unsafe living conditions There is no indication that NET can cause

Darood

Hawiye

Mogadishu

Kismaayo

Mandera

Nairobi

Busia

Bdad Hawa

Kampala

Nakivale

Abdul‘s story

Page 4: Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET) Concept and EfficacyNET: Evidence NET causes a significant reduction of PTSD even in unsafe living conditions There is no indication that NET can cause

Trauma and Memory

Page 5: Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET) Concept and EfficacyNET: Evidence NET causes a significant reduction of PTSD even in unsafe living conditions There is no indication that NET can cause

The brain under threat

Arnsten et al., Nat Rev Neurosci 2009

Page 6: Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET) Concept and EfficacyNET: Evidence NET causes a significant reduction of PTSD even in unsafe living conditions There is no indication that NET can cause

Threat Cascade

Schauer & Elbert 2010

Page 7: Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET) Concept and EfficacyNET: Evidence NET causes a significant reduction of PTSD even in unsafe living conditions There is no indication that NET can cause

Associative Memory

(Hot Memory)

Automatically activated by cues

Sensory, emotional & physiological perceptions

Fragmentary reports

Sensation of „Here and Now“

Context Memory

(Cold memory)

Deliberately retrievable

Knowledge about the event in the context of life, time & space

Chronological report

Page 8: Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET) Concept and EfficacyNET: Evidence NET causes a significant reduction of PTSD even in unsafe living conditions There is no indication that NET can cause

Stress and Memory

stress level

mem

ory

perf

orm

ance

0

25

50

75

100

Amygdala

Hippocampus

Page 9: Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET) Concept and EfficacyNET: Evidence NET causes a significant reduction of PTSD even in unsafe living conditions There is no indication that NET can cause

I was living

in Mogadishu.

It happened

during the

afternoon.

Before that I’ve been to

school.COLD

Threat network of a traumatic event

sensory cognitive physiologicalemotional

sister screaming

carpet

gun

It hurts!

I can‘t do

anything!

anger

fear

despair

fast breathing

heart beating

HOT

sweating

soldiers

horror

guilt

shivering

Why isn‘t

anybody helping?

Page 10: Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET) Concept and EfficacyNET: Evidence NET causes a significant reduction of PTSD even in unsafe living conditions There is no indication that NET can cause

Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)

re-experiencing

hyperarousal

avoidance

Page 11: Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET) Concept and EfficacyNET: Evidence NET causes a significant reduction of PTSD even in unsafe living conditions There is no indication that NET can cause

Clinical research with populations affected by war and conflict

Torture and war victims seeking asylum in Italy and Germany

Tamil children in Sri Lanka

Afghan children in

Kabul

Ex-combattants and civilians in

Somaliland

Ethiopian HIV-AIDS orphans

Former child soldier in Northern

Uganda

Genocide orphans

and widows in Ruanda

Page 12: Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET) Concept and EfficacyNET: Evidence NET causes a significant reduction of PTSD even in unsafe living conditions There is no indication that NET can cause

mother

screaming

water

It hurt‘s!

I can‘t do

anything!

fear

fast breathing

sweatingsound of

wave

horror

guilt

Why isn’t any-

body helping?

sister‘s

doll

shivering

fear

heartbeat

sweating

stick

shame

smell of alcohol

Will it end?

Why is he doing this?

body

position

aeroplane

temple

I am going to die!

Where should

I hide?anger

despair

heartbeat

bloodheadache

legs shivering

Page 13: Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET) Concept and EfficacyNET: Evidence NET causes a significant reduction of PTSD even in unsafe living conditions There is no indication that NET can cause

Implications for the Treatment of PTSD

Page 14: Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET) Concept and EfficacyNET: Evidence NET causes a significant reduction of PTSD even in unsafe living conditions There is no indication that NET can cause

Relevant mechanisms:

- Activation of the fear network + Completion of

autobiographic memory =>

- Contextualization of associative memory

- Inhibition of threat structure

Requisites for a therapy that can be used “in the field”:

- short duration

- easy to learn

- culturally sensitive

- account for social and political context

Implications for the Treatment of PTSD

Page 15: Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET) Concept and EfficacyNET: Evidence NET causes a significant reduction of PTSD even in unsafe living conditions There is no indication that NET can cause

Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET)

Use of the narration for human right work

Combination of behavioural exposure and testimony therapy (Lira and Weinstein)

Psychoeducation

Documentation of biography

Page 16: Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET) Concept and EfficacyNET: Evidence NET causes a significant reduction of PTSD even in unsafe living conditions There is no indication that NET can cause

NET - The procedure

Page 17: Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET) Concept and EfficacyNET: Evidence NET causes a significant reduction of PTSD even in unsafe living conditions There is no indication that NET can cause

NET – the procedure

0. Session:

Diagnostic Interview

1. Session:

psycho-education (for child and parents),

lifeline, drawing/photo of the lifeline

start with narration

for example:

- life circumstances when patient was born

- siblings

- school

- friends

Page 18: Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET) Concept and EfficacyNET: Evidence NET causes a significant reduction of PTSD even in unsafe living conditions There is no indication that NET can cause

NET - Lifeline

Rope as symbol for Life

Flowers as symbols for good events

Stones as symbols for bad events

Page 19: Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET) Concept and EfficacyNET: Evidence NET causes a significant reduction of PTSD even in unsafe living conditions There is no indication that NET can cause

2.-7. Session:

re-read preliminary narration

fill in more details

continue with narration

slow down whenever you

approach a traumatic “stone”

8. Session (or any other LAST session):

re-read the narration for the last time

(maybe add hopes for the future)

signing ritual and handing over of narration

NET – the procedure

Page 20: Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET) Concept and EfficacyNET: Evidence NET causes a significant reduction of PTSD even in unsafe living conditions There is no indication that NET can cause

Re-creating context for hot memory

Cold memory/Context

Space: Where did it happen?

Time: When did it happen?

Chronology: What happened?What happened next?

Hot memory

Sensory: What did you see smell, taste, hear?

Cognitive: What did you think?

Emotional: What did you feel?

Physiological: How did your body react?

Page 21: Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET) Concept and EfficacyNET: Evidence NET causes a significant reduction of PTSD even in unsafe living conditions There is no indication that NET can cause

NET & KIDNET: The Evidence

Page 22: Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET) Concept and EfficacyNET: Evidence NET causes a significant reduction of PTSD even in unsafe living conditions There is no indication that NET can cause

NET: Evidence

NET causes a significant reduction of PTSD even in unsafe living conditions

There is no indication that NET can cause serious side effects or harm

NET has comparably low rate of drop outs

NET has been superior to supportive counselling (Neuner et al. 2004, Ertl et al., 2011) and short IPT (Schaal et al, 2009) and anxiety management CBT (Hensel-Dittmann, 2011)

NET is effective for children between 7 and 16 (Ruf et al, 2010, Catani et al, 2009), with adolescents and young adults (Schaal et al. 2009, Ertl et al.) as well as withelder participants of about 75 years (Bichescu et al., 2007)

NET can be carried out by trained lay therapists (Neuner et al., 2008, Catani et al., 2010, Schauer et al, in prep., Ertl et al., 2011, Jacob et al., 2014)

NET can be dissiminated in a train-the-trainer appraoch (Jacob et al. 2014)

Robjant & Fazel (2011), Clin Psy Rev

Page 23: Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET) Concept and EfficacyNET: Evidence NET causes a significant reduction of PTSD even in unsafe living conditions There is no indication that NET can cause

THANK YOU!