naiic honpen(本編)

National Diet of Japan Fukushima Nuclear Accident

Independent Investigation Commission

??

3

5

7

10

10

20

23

24

24

26

45

57

127

249

347

487

575

587

588

2 594

3 600

4 623

5 630

640

3

1950 1970

10

3.11

Regulatory Capture

50

3.11

50 18

????

????

100

?????

1 232011 10 30

10 12 8

2

13

3

1 4

http://law.e-gov.go.jp/htmldata/H23/H23HO112.html2 123 3

http://www.shugiin.go.jp/index.nsf/html/index_kaigiroku.htm

1167 900

3

400

12

1 633

8066

431 232011

3 11

2415

3

2000

19

38

1 4

60 80 Facebook

?????

4 http://naiic.go.jp

?????

Twitter 17

16

10

10

232011 3 11

24

2012 6

232011 3

11 3.113.11

182006

212009 6

282016 1

?????

?

??

?????

?

??

1 3

5

1 3

182006

51993

IAEA

5 5 5 3

9.11 B.5.b6

3.11

5 . . IAEA Defence in Depth6 132001 9 11 142002 2 NRC

?????

?

??

7

Regulatory Capture

7

?????

?

??

IAEA

1

LOCA

JNES

1

1SR

1

LOCA

1IC

?????

?

??SBO

IC

IC

IC

42

RCIC2

23

4

?????

?

??

15

1

3 142

?????

?

??

3km

21 23 2010km

15 12 3 12 5 44

4

15

100 Sv 167

1800km2 5mSv

1

1

?????

?

??

45 6

?????

?

??

2

?????

?

??

7

7

?????

?

??

?????

?

?????????

16

???

?????

232011 3 11

INES8 7

123

4 6 1

3

66kV

1M/C

D/G

124

6 1

124 35

SBO3

3 13

34

9

10

8 INESInternational Nuclear Event ScaleIAEA

9 2

???

?????

10 242012 3 30

1 2 3 4

6 : 00 S/C

6 : 00

910

1040

1325 RCIC

242 HPCI

925

3SGTS

1312

1536

546

11 : 36 RCIC

12 : 35 HPCI

1430

1904

1700

1101

19 : 54

1810

1850

IC

IC

RCIC

SBO

RCIC

1446

1537

D/G

920

1920

MAAP

???

?????

?

???

?

????????????

232011 3 11

. 232011 3 11

1 3

40

265GalGal

561981

182006

202008 3

5

Ss 600Gal

7

1 4 6 212009

5

212009 6

282016 1

1 3

???

?????

?

???

?

????????????

5

5 1 3

1

. .

Ss

3.11

. 40

182006

3

???

?????

?

???

?

????????????

. SA

SA

SA 31991

AM

SA

SA

SA

222010 SA

???

?????

?

???

?

??????????????

.

1

M/CM/C P/C

1

3M/CM/C

P/C P/C

1 7 3

SBO

IC

1342

5623

4

5

???

?????

?

???

?

??????????????

.

IAEA

3050

LOCA

JNES

LOCA

LOCA 10

t

15 27 2 15

???

?????

?

???

?

??????????????

35 1.5km

1 2

1 A

1

4

IC 2IC

5

1 ICAB2 14 52

111 IC 2

55 /

IAEA

IC IC

IC

1SR

23

2 SR

1 1 SR

1 SR

1

LOCA

???

?????

?

???

?

????????

.

2

ERC

1

2

???

?????

?

???

?

????????

.

???

?????

?

???

?

????????

5

.

15

2

5

5

1

5

122

5

5

???

?????

?

???

?

????????

.

. .

.

???

?????

?

???

?

????????

2

30 3

24 1

3 15

.

53 12 5 44

10

20

???

?????

?

???

?

????????????

. 6 1

900PBq 1800

5mSv

3

1 4000 4

242012 61mSv

57.01mSv 10mSv 42.310mSv 0.7

.

15

3km10km20km

20km

???

?????

?

???

?

????????????

3 60

3 15 20 30km

325

30km3 23

SPEEDI

1

.

182006

192007

192007

SPEEDI

???

?????

?

???

?

????????????

ERSSSPEEDI

ERSS

SPEEDI

ERSS SPEEDI

ERSS SPEEDI

ERSS

SPEEDI

SPEEDI

.

???

?????

?

???

?

????????????

.

???

?????

?

???

?

???????????

.

.

SA

???

?????

?

???

?

???????????

SA

5

.

SA

???

?????

?

???

?

???????????

2

31423 0

1921

2

31483

.

.

Defence in Depth

???

?????

?

???

?

???????

??????

. . . . . 3 . . GE . . 531978 . . 182006 5 S . . . . . . . . .

. . . . . . . . . . . SA . . SA SA

. . . 5 . .

??????

??????

. . . . . . . . . . . . . SB-LOCA SB-LOCA FTA

0.3cm2 SB-LOCA SB-LOCA . . . . IC 1 SR 4 . . MARK

. . . 1 SR 2 D/W .

??????

??????

. . . . ERC . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . SPEEDI . . . .

??????

??????

. . . . . . . . ) . . . 182006 192007 . .

. . . . SPEEDI . . . . . . . . . . .

??????

??????

. . . . . . . . .

. .

SBO . . . . SA SA SA . . ICRP . . . . . . . . . . .

??????

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . TMI . .

. . . . . . .

??????

- 58 -

- 59 -

*DO*DO

6V*DO

6V

7%

P

P

P

P

5%

NP

P

- 60 -

NP

P

23P

7%

%:5

N:

P

5%

Pt

23

- 61 -

- 62 -

FPFP

FPV

*DO*DOFPVFPV

PFP 16

(:8'

- 63 -

*DO*DO*DO

*DO

D

- 64 -

$V$

J $V

J

J*DOJJ*DO*DO

0*DO

E

$V$%& J *DO** N:

,

KWWSZZZDHFJRMSMLFVW1&DERXWXJRNLJHSSRX9191KWPO

- 65 -

0

0

0

*DO

*(

*(%:5*(

*(

*(

*((%$6&2

*(*(76&2

*(

P

PP

- 66 -

0$5.,

*(

*(

*(

6&&

6&&

0$5.

*(

0$5.,

- 67 -

66

$6$V6

6'

*DO6'*DO61*DO

- 68 -

- 69 -

6

6

6 6V

- 70 -

666V

$$V6

66V

6V

6G

061

0

*DO

0*DO

- 71 -

0

$

$

D6V

6V

KWWSZZZQLVDPHWLJRMSVKLQJLNDLILOHVSGI

- 72 -

NP0

00

0

6V

6V

6V

6V6V+*DO6V

6V+*DO6V6V+*DO

E

6V6V6V

6V6V6V

6V6V6V

6V

F

6

- 73 -

G

KWWSZZZQLVDPHWLJRMSJHQVKLU\RNXGRXNRXILOHVSGI

- 74 -

D

'*6:

'*6:

- 75 -

E

5&:%

66V

+&8

- 76 -

)

F

6

6

6V

03D

- 77 -

6

,$($

KWWSZZZQLVDPHWLJRMSVKLQJLNDLBBLQGH[KWPO

- 78 -

D

E

KWWSZZZPHWLJRMSSUHVVSGI

- 97 -

- 80 -

PPPP

6

6V

KWWSZZZQXFLDMS

- 81 -

*DO6V

6V

%&

6*DO*DO

- 82 -

- 83 -

- 84 -

D

D

NP

23P

23P

P23P

23P

E

23P

F

23PP

G

23P

23PP

- 85 -

23P

FP

H

0

23P

I

-1(6

23P

23P

KWWSZZZMLVKLQJRMSPDLQFKRXVDNDLNRXBSGIVDQULNXBERVRSGI

- 86 -

P

J

FP23P

K

23P

F

KWWSZZZQLVDPHWLJRMSVKLQJLNDLJLMLURNXSGI

- 87 -

23P23P

I

FP

36$

FP

2.

- 88 -

NP

- 89 -

- 90 -

23P

23P 23P

23P

23P

23P

- 91 -

KWWSZZZWHSFRFRMSQXIXNXVKLPDQSLQIRLQGH[MKWPO 23P

- 92 -

23P

23P

- 93 -

PD[

23P

-1(6

-1(6

- 94 -

-1(6

- 95 -

6$

6$

6$

$0

6$

6$

6$

6$

- 96 -

6$

6$

6$

- 97 -

6$

6$

- 98 -

6$

D

0$5.

6$

0$5.$%:5

0$5.

&

- 99 -

- 100 -

E

')

')')

(8

%:5

6$

SUHYHQWLRQ$0

$0

SUHYHQWLRQ$0FRVW

HIIHFWLYH$0

')'HFRQWDPLQDWLRQ)DFWRU

- 101 -

&

F

9N9

'*

'*

6$

- 201 -

$6

- 103 -

- 104 -

G

6$

15&

,&02UGHU %E%E

%E6$

6$

70,

6$

D

- 105 -

E

- 106 -

- 107 -

&$06

&$06

%:56$

,&

$0

D%7&

%:5%:5

%7&%:5$%:5

623

$0

$0

623

,&

,&

,&

,&

%7&

- 108 -

6$623

%7&

E

%:5

%7&623

(23623

$0

6$

365

D

$0$0

365$0

E

$0$0

6$

6$

6$

$0

$0

- 109 -

$0

- 110 -

6$

6$

6$

D

6$

D6$

6$

$0

E6$

$0

- 111 -

$0

F6$

$0

6$

F6$

- 112 -

6$

6$

E

D

- 113 -

1,6$

6$

6$

1,6$

36536$6$

6$

6$

6$

6$

6$

6$36$

- 114 -

6$

D

6$

6$

,3(((

6$

,3((($0

,3((($0

6$

36$

- 115 -

>@

36$

6$

-1(6-1(6-1(6

- 116 -

E

6$

15& %E

%E

-1(615&

15&%E

z

z

z

z

z

z

z

z

- 117 -

15&

%E

%E

%E

6$

6$

D

$7:6

6%26$

&9

6$ 6$

- 118 -

6$

6$

$0

6$

6$

$0

$0

$0

6$

E

6$

6$

$0

- 119 -

6$

6$

6$&

&

6$

&

$2

&

6$

$0

&

$0

&36$

6$36$

36$

6$

70,

- 120 -

,$($

6$

6$

,$($

3UHYHQWLRQ

0LWLJDWLRQ(YDFXDWLRQ

6$

6$

6$

6$

- 121 -

6$

6$

6$

- 122 -

6$

D

,$($,$($,16$*

,16$*

6$,16$*

165

185(*&5

185(*

185(*6LWLQJ

z

z

z

z

z

z

z

z

z

- 123 -

15&185(*'HIHQVHLQGHSWKSURYLVLRQV

(3E

,3(((

%E

%E

- 124 -

%E

%E

5&,&

%E

6$

6$

$0

70,6$

,3(6$0$5.

%:5

6$

- 125 -

6$

6$

$0

6$

z

z z

z

z

z

z

z

z

z

z

z

- 126 -

- 128 -

- 129 -

0&0&3&

0&0&3&3&

6%2

,&

- 130 -

D

N:%:5

W

P

W

PP%:5

%:5

8

8

- 131 -

3X

8

8002;

02;

02;

E

FP

PP

F

- 132 -

2

665 65

65

/2&$

66&&))$&

/2&$

(&&6

/2&$

(&&6

/2&$(&&6

G

- 331 -

$&2/

$&2/

6&&(

$&2/

$&2/2%66

$&2/5:%

$&2/

6&&($&2/

2U= 2+U=

+

$&2/

$&2/

D3N,.5$0

- 134 -

H

/2&$

66*76PP+2

6*76

D

- 135 -

E

W

/2&$(&&6

0,7 7KHIXWXUHRI1XFOHDU3RZHU

*:W3:5W

%:5

%:5

- 136 -

7%T : NO

NO

3:5W

W

W

F6%2

'%$

%'%$

/2&$/2&$

(&&6

(&&6

%'%$

KWWSZZZELZDNRNDVHQJRMSLQIRIDTTOLVWTOLVWHHKWPO

- 137 -

6%2

6%2

15&

6%2

7

+3&,

P

NJ

&&&,NJ

NJ

6%2

6%2

+3&,

+3&,

03D

- 138 -

03D

NJNJNJNJ

P

03D

P

P

FP

P

6%2

G

6%2+3&,

6%2

/2&$

6%2

+3&,5&,&

+3&,5&,&65

+3&,5&,&65

5&,&

655&,&

65

+3&,5&,&

+3&,5&,&65

6%26%2

,&

/2&$

- 139 -

0$5.,

/2&$

15&

185(*&5

185(*&5

- 140 -

3:5

P

P

H

185(*

&&,

- 141 -

;H;H

;H,,,

,, ,

,,,,

%T%T%T

%T

%T

(

%T %T ( ( ( ( ( (

( ( ( ( ( (

(

- 142 -

I

1$6

15&%E

,

- 143 -

N9

0&

D

- 144 -

0&0& 3&

0&0&3&3&

- 145 -

- 146 -

0&3&

- 147 -

E

N9

*DO

*DO

6*DO 6

*DO

- 148 -

F

3+6

- 149 -

G

- 150 -

H

- 151 -

D

,&,&

,&,&

5&,&

5&,&

7$)

NP

NP

5&,&5&,&

7$)

7$)PP

5&,&

+3&,

- 152 -

,&

03D

,&

,&

,&

03D

7$)PP

&&,

03D>DEV@

E

03D

>DEV@>J@

- 153 -

,&

03D

,,,,,

NP

&&,

5&,&

5&,&

6/&

&5'

5&,&

+3&,

- 451 -

&/6

KY6P

PN

&,&5

,&3+

- 155 -

F

+3&,

5&,&+3&,65

03D

7$)PP

03D>DEV@

03D>DEV@

6YK65

7$)

7$)7$)PP

7$)P6YK

P6YK

5&,&

G

- 651 -

&,&5

&,&5

PP)$7

PP)$7

56

D30

56

PP)$7

H

5

$LU

5&,&

U3KRWR6HUYLF

03D

FH&R/WG

>DEV@

0

- 157 -

03D>DEV@

0

7$)

03D>DEV@

PP

P6YK

D

$LU

U3KRWR6HUYLFDG

6%2

FH&R/WG

65

6

65

- 158 -

65

0

03D

03D

65

03D

- 159 -

E

$2

$2

$2

,$

,$6$

,$

,$

,$

,$

03D

65

65

65

65

65

08:&

- 160 -

F

%

3&0&

65

5+55+56

5+50&

5+56

08:&

%0&'

N9908:&0&'

3&'0&&3&&

3&&

0&&&0&&&0&&&

08:&08:&

65

G

5+50&&5+56

5+5

- 161 -

D

&,

&,

56

&,

&,

&,

&,

&,

&,

&,

PP)$7

&,

&,

&,

- 261 -

&,

,&3+

,&3+

,&3+

&,

,

,

,,

PN

KY6KY6

P

PNPN

- 361 -

E

&,&5

&,&5

&,&5

&,&5

&,&5/

56

&,&5

&,&5

56

&,&5

&,&5

&,&5

&,&5

&,&5

&,&5

&,&5

&,&5

E%

&,&5

&51

&,&5

- 164 -

0$5.,

0$5.,

/2&$

/2&$6%2

5&,&+3&,6%2

6%2

- 561 -

&,&5

)$7&,&5

PP)$7)$%

'5&'5&

2

2

- 166 -

F

5&,&+3&,

5&,&+3&,

65

+3&,

%:5

65

&KXQNXDQ 6KLK 7VRQJ6KHQJ )HQJ .DL&KXHQ +XDQJ &KLQ&KHK &KDQJ -RQJ5RQJ :DQJ 2Q 539

'HSUHVVXUL]DWLRQ6WUDWHJ\DQG$OWHUQDWH:DWHU6\VWHPVLQ6%2RI1XFOHDU3RZHU3ODQWV 7UDQVDFWLRQVRIWKH$PHULFDQ1XFOHDU6RFLHW\9ROSS

- 761 -

,&3+

P

WW

W

JN

W717-*P

,&&

- 168 -

&&,

&&,

G

6*76

15&

%E

- 169 -

H

%

6508:&

- 170 -

03

6&

':

':03D>J@

KWWSZZZWHSFRFRMSQXIXNXVKLPDQSIGDWDLQGH[MKWPO

- 171 -

':

;

15&

D

/-2WW&):HEHU&5+\PDQ 6WDWLRQ%ODFNRXW&DOFXODWLRQVIRU%URZQV)HUU\ &21)2DN

5LGJH1DWLRQDO/DERUDWRU\

- 173 -

6&

':

03D>J@

6&':

E

03D>J@

W

F

$0

- 174 -

G

D5&,&

5&,&

5&,&

5&,&

5&,&65

- 175 -

E65

65

65

65

%$)

F':':

':

':

':

':':

03D>J@03D>J@

':

':

6&':03D>J@

- 176 -

65

G':':

':03D>J@

':':

':

H

':':

03D>J@

':

':':

':

- 177 -

':

6YK

':':

6YK

;H

I0$$3

0$$3

J

0$$3

- 178 -

K

D

5&,&5&,&

+3&,+3&,03D>J@

03D>J@03D>J@03D>J@

+3&,03D>J@

+3&,03D>J@03D>J@

+3&,65

E65

6503D>J@03D>J@

':

03D>J@

- 179 -

F6&

':03D>J@

6&':

':

':

6&

03D>J@

':

':6YK

- 180 -

D

N9

N9N9

0&3&

5+56

E

- 181 -

&,&5

&,&5

&:80&$

32(

56&:80

&:80&,&5

5+56&3+&:80

6&3+

&,&56&3+

6&3+&:80&,&5

5+5

'&06&3+&&0

'&5+5%:&((%5+5%

:&((%65+5

%:&((%65+5&5+5

&3&39

&3

%65+5'&5+5

%:&((

%:&((

:&((%65+5'&5+5%5+5

%

5+5&:80

- 182 -

0&3&$%

$((&:$5+56$&

%

5+5&%5+56%3&

P

((&:%3&

08:&5+5

- 183 -

$3&

0&%3&

%5+5

5+5

3&$

%$%

((&:%5+56'5+5&%

((&:

%5+5&%5+56%3&

08:&5+5

08:&+3&65+5

F

6%2

6%2

6&

N9

- 184 -

6%208:&

08:&

08:&$&

(2308:&

65

5&,&08:&

6%2

08:&PPK

P5&,&08:&03D

5&,&

6&

5&,&

08:&

65

- 581 -

&3&0

&3&0

&3&0

P

'&5+5

'&5+5

- 186 -

5+5

5+5&5+56((&:

3&

D

N9N9N9

N9

P

23P23P

P

2323sP73

P FPFP

- 187 -

0&3&

E

+3P

&+3P

&

&$&

&

$&

'+3&6%'

$&'+3&6

%'

+3sP73P

- 188 -

- 189 -

- 190 -

D

$0+9$&6*76

$&

+9$&6*76$&

$

- 191 -

E

,&

5&,&

F

%:5

- 192 -

G

H

3& &5'6/&

%:5 %:5

- 193 -

D

- 194 -

E

F

P6YK

P6YK

- 591 -

G

&,&5D

&,&5

&,&5

&,&5

,&3+

&,&5

&,&5

&,&5

,&3+&,&5

- 196 -

5&,&

E65

65

65

65

65

65

65

&5'6/&

- 197 -

F

G6%2

65

6%2

03D

- 198 -

65

6%2

6%2

D

- 199 -

NP

NP

NP

NP

17 147,904 53,685 52,970 2 13,812 4,942 6,568 4* 8,165 1,752 2,198

- 200 -

NPNP

%:5%:50$5.,

%:50$5.

$%:53:56%2

6%2

D

65

$00&&&

3UHYHQWLRQ0LWLJDWLRQ

%E

- 201 -

%

E

6*76

6*76

F

- 202 -

NP

%:5%:5%:5

%:5

G

NP

6DIHW\*RDO+RZVDIHLVVDIHHQRXJK"

- 203 -

D

15&

5*P

P

P

P

P

- 204 -

E

5*PV

NJPV

D

15&

15&%E

6%2

- 205 -

%E

E

&)5$LUFUDIW,PSDFW

$VVHVVPHQW

$%:5

%E

&)5KK6RXWK7H[DV3URMHFW$),$X[LOLDU\)HHGZDWHU,QMHFWLRQ

- 206 -

- 207 -

,$($

/2&$

-1(6

/2&$

/2&$W

NP

$

- 208 -

,&

,&

,&$%

,&

,$($

,&

,&

,&

65

65

65

65

/2&$

,&

- 209 -

0

NPNP

NPNP

*36FP


KWWSZZZWHSFRFRMSFFSUHVVEHWXBMLPDJHVDESGI

- 210 -

6V

6V

6V

6V6V

KWWSZZZWHSFRFRMSSUHVVEHWXOOBMLPDJHVDESGI

KWWSZZZWHSFRFRMSSUHVVEHWXOOBMLPDJHVDESGI

16 (: 8' 16 (: 8'

5

5

5

5

5

5

*DO

V

- 211 -

E.

D

23

P(:

23P

(:

6V+6V *DO

*DO

6V+*DO


KWWSZZZQLVDPHWLJRMSVKLQJLNDLSGI

P

P

KWWSZZZQLVDPHWLJRMSVKLQJLNDLSGI

KWWSZZZQLVDPHWLJRMSJHQVKLU\RNXGRXNRXILOHVSGI

6V+*DO6V+6V+*DO

- 212 -

(:

D23P(:E (:F

6V+6VG(:

DEG

E

- 213 -

NP

23P

(:23P


KWWSZZZSUHIQLLJDWDOJMSJHQVKLU\RNXMLVLQJLMLKWPO


- 214 -

6

6

6V


- 215 -

6V

6V

NPNP

*DO

6V

6V6V

- 216 -

)7$

-1(6

)7$6%/2&$

6%/2&$

6%/2&$

6%/2&$

(&&6,&

/RVV2I&RRODQW$FFLGHQW/2&$

/2&$

/2&$/%/2&$

/2&$6%/2&$/2&$0%/2&$

/%/2&$0%/2&$

/2&$

6%2

/2&$

6%/2&$

/%/2&$/DUJH%UHDN/2&$6%/2&$6PDOO%UHDN/2&$0%/2&$0HGLXP%UHDN/2&$

- 217 -

6%/2&$

)7$)DXOW7UHH$QDO\VLV

)7$

)7$

-1(6)7$

-1(6

)7$,&

03D03D

)7$

- 218 -

)7$

- 219 -

- 220 -

6%/2&$)7$

-1(6)7$

)7$

,&'

',&%%$$

&

)7$

)7$

5(/$302'

,& 15&5(/$302'-1(6

- 221 -

FP

,&$

$

$

$

,&%

%

%

&

&

&

,& '

,& '

)7$

FP6%/2&$

'$&

FP

,&,&

- 222 -

,&FP

'

FP

$

FP

&

- 223 -

FP

$&

FP

6%/2&$

FP$

FFWW

03D

FP

&FP

$

- 422 -

V6

V6

$&2/%6

$&2/%6

&,

- 225 -

,&

,&,&

,&

,&

,&

,&

65

%

%%

%

,$($

,$($

P

PNP

NP

P

- 226 -

P

NP

NP

P

NP

P

P

P

P

s

P

- 227 -

%

$

$%%

PP

NP

P

P

$

%$

$%

6%2

3+6

PP

$%

- 228 -

D

,&,&

$%

$%

%%

%

P

%%

,&

$%,&

%

E

- 229 -

%

%

,&

,&

$%

,&

,&

K

,&

P

$$

- 230 -

D,&

,&

03D

06,9

,&

,&,&

,&

,&%:5,&

,&$%

%:5

- 231 -

02

$%$$%%

$$$%%%

06,9

03D$%

$%

$%

$%

3$%

% 4

,&

$%

,&

,&

6%2

03D

06,903D

,&

9

,&$%,&

,&

,&

,&

,&03D

03D,&

- 232 -

K

,&

,&

K

K

K

- 233 -

K

K

,&

,&$

% 02$% ,&

K ,&

,&

,&

,&06,9

,&

,&$%

,&

,&

K,&

06,9K

K

- 234 -

,&

,&K

K

,&

,&

,&

,&$%

03D03D

,&

06,9,&

03D%$

%:5

,&

K

,&

,&

%

- 532 -

&,

&,

&,

K&,

K

&,

&,E

&,

&,

&, &,

&,

&,

$&2/&,

$&2/$&2/

&,

- 236 -

,&

/2&$

,&

,&

,&/2&$

F6%2,&,&

,&

6%2

,&

$$%%

- 237 -

06,9

,&

RXWRIRXWRI

536

,&$$%%

)6$5

,&

0202

6%2

6%2

,&02

02

- 832 -

&,,&3+

9

2020&,9

&,

&,

$20$20

$20$20

3)''

$&,

$20$20

&,

&,$20$20

&,

&,

9,60&,

5:%

- 239 -

,&

,&

$%

,&06,9

65

65

6%2

D

06,9

- 240 -

06,9

65

06,9

6%2,&03D

6%2

6%265

03D65

6&

6565

03D656&

656&

6503D03D

- 241 -

65

06,9

':

6&

65

6&

- 242 -

56E

56

56

56

56

2%6

56

56

56

56

56

56

56

- 243 -

6565

65

65

65

D

&7%7

6&':

E

&7%7

KWWSZZZFSGQSMSSGI7DNDVDNLBUHSRUWB$SUSGI

KWWSZZZMFDFRUMS

)7DQDEH $FHQDULRRIODUJHDPRXQWRIUDGLRDFWLYHPDWHULDOVGLVFKDUJHWRWKHDLUIURPWKH8QLWUHDFWRULQWKH)XNXVKLPD'DLLFKL133DFFLGHQW-RXUQDORI1XFOHDU6FLHQFHDQG7HFKQRORJ\9RO1RSS

)7DQDEH $QDO\VHVRIFRUHPHOWDQGUHPHOWLQWKH)XNXVKLPD'DLLFKLQXFOHDUUHDFWRUV -RXUQDORI1XFOHDU6FLHQFHDQG7HFKQRORJ\9RO1RSS

- 244 -

P

P

KWWSZZZPHWLJRMSHDUWKTXDNHQXFOHDUSGIBIISGI

KWWSSKRWRWHSFRFRMSGDWHMMKWPO

- 245 -

F

6*76

539

-$($

P

P

0$5.

0$5.,

':

- 246 -

0$5.,

(&&6

6%2

656&

6%2

6&

':

0$5.,0$5.,

D

/2&$

':

/2&$

':6&6&

6&

%:50$5.,

':

':6&

%:5 0$5.

0

0$5.

- 247 -

0

9RO1R 9RO1R

NP

0$5.

0$5.

0$5.

.

$%:55&&9

9

- 248 -

%:5 0$5.

0$5.

- 250 -

- 251 -

(5&

- 252 -

D

E

- 253 -

F

KWWSZZZNDQWHLJRMSMSW\RXNDQSUHVVLQGH[KWPO

- 254 -

G

- 255 -

H

- 256 -

- 257 -

- 258 -

6WDWLRQ%ODFN2XW6%2

6%2 ,VRODWLRQ&RQGHQVHU

,&,&

':N3D

- 952 -

&,2%6

2%6

- 260 -

W

- 261 -

3/5

- 262 -

65

W

6/&

W

- 362 -

)

)9&3)9&3

- 462 -

- 265 -

7%

':

- 266 -

6*76

- 267 -

2%

2%

P

5&,&':

- 862 -

D

&,&5

9&3

)

- 962 -

E

)

- 270 -

&$06

)))

WK

- 271 -

65

5&,&

65

6&

NP

65

655&,&

P6YP6Y

7

- 272 -

56

56&6&69&356

9&356&6

)$7::9&3

::

56::

56

56

56

56

PP

- 372 -

56

)$770$935

56

56

56

56&6

56

56

- 274 -

65

':

%$)

':

':

PP03D':03D

PP0SD':03D

PP03D':03D

656565

03D':03D

65::

03D':03D':

- 572 -

:'

:'

:':'

&6:'):'&6

2$

2$

2020

:'

:'

- 276 -

':::

':

6&':

- 277 -

D

- 872 -

E

- 972 -

D

- 280 -

- 281 -

F

- 282 -

5:

5:

7%5:

- 283 -

7%

7%

7%

5:7%5:

5:5:

5:7%

5:7%

7%

5:

5:

- 284 -

- 285 -

- 286 -

(5&

- 287 -

D

E

F

- 288 -

D

(5&

E

(5&

D

(5&

(5&

E

(5

63((',

566

(56663((

(566

(',

(566

- 289 -

63((',

(566

- 290 -

F

G

- 291 -

NP

D

-&2

(5&

(566 63((',

- 292 -

E

F

- 293 -

(56663((',

G

NP

NP

- 294 -

H

D

- 295 -

E

F

(5&

- 296 -

D

E

F

- 297 -

G

D

- 298 -

E

-$;$

F

- 299 -

(5&

- 300 -

KWWSZZZFDRJRMSNRXEXQLLQNDLLLQNDLVDLKDLIXSGI

KWWSZZZFDRJRMSNRXEXQLLQNDLLLQNDLVDLKDLIXKWPO

KWWSZZZFDRJRMSNRXEXQLLQNDLLLQNDLVDLWRULPDWRPHSGI

- 301 -

-1(6

- 302 -

- 303 -

- 304 -

D

KWWSZZZPHWLJRMSSUHVVKWPO

- 305 -

- 306 -

E

D

- 307 -

E

- 308 -

- 309 -

- 013 -

- 311 -

- 312 -

- 313 -

D

- 314 -

*

*

- 315 -

E

D

- 316 -

E

-1(6

-$($

- 317 -

2%

NP

15&

Weve offered and theyve said,No, they dont need any. 15& 15&

- 318 -

DNP

NP

NP

ENP

NP

NP

FNP

NP

GNP

NPNP

- 319 -

- 320 -

H

NP

NPNP

NP

NP

3$=

- 321 -

(3=

NP

63((',

63((',

NPNPNPNP NPNPNP

63((',

- 322 -

NP

NP

-1(6-$($

- 323 -

- 324 -

- 325 -

- 326 -

- 327 -

- 328 -

- 329 -

- 330 -

63((',

- 331 -

D

63((',

E

63((',

- 332 -

F

63((',

63((',

63((',

63((',

- 333 -

- 334 -

D

- 335 -

- 336 -

E

F

- 337 -

NP

NP

NP

NPNP

NP

NP

NP

NP

- 338 -

NP

- 339 -

- 340 -

- 341 -

3/12 9:45 1

3/12 13:00 1

3/12 14:00

3/12 21:30 1

3/13 5:30 1

3/13 17:15 3

3/14 9:15 3

3/14 16:45 33

3/14 21:45 2

4/18 1 2 3

KWWSZZZPHWLJRMSSUHVVKWPO KWWSZZZPHWLJRMSSUHVVSGI

- 342 -

- 343 -

63((',

63((',

63((',

NP

- 443 -

AEAI 224

614

- 543 -

PN

PN

PN

PNPNPN

- 346 -

63((',

- 348 -

- 349 -

3%T

P6Y

P6YP6YP6Y

P6Y

,1(6

3%T3%T3%T

,1(63%T

- 350 -

P6YP6Y

NP

NPN%TPNPN%TP

,$($ (QYLURQPHQWDOFRQVHTXHQFHVRIWKH&KHUQRE\O$FFLGHQWDQGWKHLU5HPHGLDWLRQ7ZHQW\

- 351 -

NP

NPP6Y

NP

(XURSHDQ&RPLVVLRQ-RLQW5HVHDUFK&HQWUH(QYLURQPHQW,QVWLWXWH $WODVRIFDHVLXPGHSRVLWRQRQ(XURSHDIWHU

WKH&KHUQRE\ODFFLGHQW

,$($ &KHUQRE\OV/HJDF\+HDOWK(QYLURQPHQWDODQG6RFLRHFRQRPLFV,PSDFWVDQG5HFRPPHQGDWLRQVWRWKH

*RYHUQPHQWVRI%HODUXVWKH5XVVLDQ)HGHUDWLRQDQG8NUDLQH

- 352 -

:%&

D

- 353 -

FSP

FSPFSP

FSP

P6Y

P6YP6Y

P6Y

:+2

- 354 -

EP6Y

P6Y

P6Y

P6YP6Y

- 355 -

NPNPNP

NP

NP

NP63((',

- 356 -

NP

NP

4 4

- 357 -

4

- 358 -

NPNP

NP

4 4

- 359 -

NP

4

- 360 -

- 361 -

- 362 -

NP

NP

NP

NP

NP

44

- 363 -

D

- 364 -

E

NPNP

NPNP

NP

NP

NP

- 365 -

NP

NP

D

NPNPNP

- 366 -

4

63((',

- 367 -

E

NP

NP

NP

- 368 -

NP

NP(3=(PHUJHQF\3ODQQLQJ=RQH

NP

NP

D

NPNP

(3=

NP

- 369 -

NPNP

NPNP

NP

NPNP

E

P6Y

P6Y

3XEOLFDWLRQ

- 370 -

NPNP

D

P6YP6Y4

- 371 -

NPNP

NP

NPNP

1+.

NPNP

E

- 372 -

NPNPNP

NPNP

D

NP

- 373 -

63((',

63((',

4

- 374 -

P6Y

63((',

63((',

63((',

63((',

63((',

E

63((',

63((',

63((',

- 375 -

63((',

63((',63((',

63((',

63((',

63((',

NPNP

NPP6Y

D

- 376 -

63((',

,$($

79

63((',

E

63((',

6YK6YK

- 377 -

6YK

,&53

P6YP6Y

,$($

,&53

3XE

3XEOLFDWLRQ

- 378 -

P6YP6YNPNP

NP

,&53P6Y

P6Y

,&53

,&53

P6Y

P6Y

- 379 -

P6YP6Y

P6YKP6Y

6YK

- 380 -

NP

-&2

D

NP

NPNP

NP

E

F

NP

NP

- 381 -

- 382 -

D E

F

G

12OFC

12

12

14

12

1415

12

12

121314

3

12

13

1213

1314

14

14

1415

0

0

4

3

3

0

40

- 383 -

D

E

- 384 -

F

NP

NP

- 385 -

G

D

- 386 -

E

F

- 387 -

NP

D

- 388 -

'0$7

NP

E

- 389 -

NP

- 390 -

63((',

(56663((',

(566

63((',

(56663((',

(56663((',

- 391 -

(566

63((',

63((',

-&2

-1(6

-$($

- 392 -

-&2

- 393 -

D3$=

3$=

KWWSZZZQVFJRMSLQIRKWPO

182006192007

IAEA

3WG

74

418

314

329

424

426

524

69

614

427

1128

82105

1214

424524

615

619

WG13

18 20061WG

18 2006 2WG

18 20065WG

18 20063WG18 20064WG

141534

18

19

- 394 -

,$($&66

'6*6*$UUDQJHPHQWIRU3UHSDUDWLRQIRU1XFOHDURU5DGLRORJLFDO

(PHUJHQF\

'6

,$($

,$($

3$=

83=(3=

3$=

(3=

3$=83=

- 395 -

(PHUJHQF\3ODQQLQJ=RQH

NP

(56663((',

(56663((',

(56663((',

(566(566

63((',

63((',

E

,$($

83=

KWWSZZZQVFJRMSVHQPRQVKLGDLERXVLQERXVLQVLU\RSGI

KWWSZZZQVFJRMSVHQPRQVRNLERXVLQERXVLQBVRKWP3$=


- 396 -

3$=

(566

3$=

KWWSZZZPH[WJRMSEBPHQXVKLQJLFKRXVDJLM\XWXVKLU\RBBLFV)LOHVDILHOGILOH

BHSGI

KWWSZZZQVFJRMSLQIRVLU\RSGI

- 397 -

F3$=

3$=

3$=

3$=

3$=83=

($/2,/

3$=($/2,/

,$($

KWWSZZZQVFJRMSVHQPRQVRNLVLVHWXERVLVHWXERBVRSGI

- 398 -

D3$=

-$($3$=

-1(6-$($

3$=

3$=

,$($($/'6

*6*&ULWHULDIRU8VHLQ3UHSDUHGQHVVDQG5HVSRQVHIRU1XFOHDURU

5DGLRORJLFDO(PHUJHQF\

KWWSZZZQVFJRMSVHQPRQVKLGDLVLVHWXERVLVHWXERVLU\RSGI

-$($3$=

KWWSZZZQVFJRMSVHQPRQVKLGDLERXVLQERXVLQBVVLU\RSGI

- 399 -

E

(3=NP

(3=NP

3$=


KWWSZZZQVFJRMSLQIRVLU\RSGI 3$=

1012

222010232011

74

122

123

1222

113

23

225

39

22

23

- 400 -

3$=($/83=2,/

-1(6-$($

(3=

NP

F

(3=3$=

KWWSZZZQVFJRMSLQIRKWPO 83=

(3=(3=83=

83=


3$=3$=($/2,/


- 401 -

3$=

(56663((',

3$=

- 402 -

D

E

- 403 -

F

KWWSZZZPHWLJRMSPHWLBOLEUHSRUWI\(SGI,$($

KWWSZZZPHWLJRMSFRPPLWWHHVXPPDU\BBBSGI

- 404 -

-&2

G

H

KWWSZZZPHWLJRMSFRPPLWWHHVXPPDU\JLMLURNXSGI

- 405 -

D

E

KWWSZZZSUHIQLLJDWDOJMSJHQVKLU\RNXKWPO

KWWSZZZQLVDPHWLJRMSRVKLUDVHKWPO


- 406 -


- 407 -

KWWSZDUSQGOJRMSLQIRQGOMSSLGZZZVRXPXJRMSVQHZVSGIBBSGI

KWWSZZZPHWLJRMSFRPPLWWHHPDWHULDOVGRZQORDGILOHVJEMSGI

- 408 -

D

E


- 409 -

F

63((',


- 410 -

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

- 411 -

(566 63((',

(566

63((',

63((',

(56663((',(566

63((',

63((',

(56663((',

D(566

(566

(566

-1(6

-$($

- 412 -

(566

(566-1(6

(566

(566(5&

(56663((',

E63((',

63((',

63((',

63((',

63((',

63((',(566%TK

NP

NP

(5&

(56663((',

- 413 -

(56663((',

D

(56663((',

%TK63((',

(566 63((',

63((',

(566

63((',

63((',(566

E

(566

63((',

(566

F

(56663((',

63((',

(566

- 414 -

(56663((',

-1(6-$($

(56663((',

(566

(566

(566

63((',

(56663((',

(566

63((',

D(566

(566

(566

(566

-1(6

(566

E63((',

(56663((',

(566

- 415 -

63((',

F63((',

63((',

63((',

KWWSZZZERXVDLQHMSVSHHGLURNSGI

(566

(5&

- 416 -

63((',

63((',

63((',

-&2

G63((',

D (566

63((',

63((',

63((',

63((',

63((',

63((',

63((',

63((',

- 417 -

(56663((',

63((',

D(566

D (566

(566

(566

(566

E63((',

E 63((',(566

%TK(566

D

63((',(566

63((',

63((',

KWWSZZZSUHIIXNXVKLPDMSQXFOHDULQIRKWPO

- 418 -

63((',

NP

NP

NP

- 419 -

63((',

63((',

63((',

KWWSZZZERXVDLQHMSVSHHGLURNSGI

F

KWW

KWW

63

63((',

WSZZZERXVD

WSZZZERXVD

3((',

63((',

DLQHMSVSHHG

DLQHMSVSHHG

,

LURN

LURN

- 420 -

63(

63(

((',

SGI

((',

SGI

6

63((',

- 421 -

63((',

G

D63((',

63((',

(56663((',

63((',

63((',

63((',

63((',

63((',

D63((',

G

63((',

63((',

63((',

- 422 -

63((',

63((',

3/15 SPEEDI

3/23 (a)

4/10 (a)

4/25 SPEEDI

4/26 (b)(b)

4/30 SPEEDI

5/2 SPEEDI

5/3 (c)

(a) (b) ERSS (c) ERSS

63((',

63((',

63((',

E

KWW

WSZZZQVFJ

63

JRMSLQIR

((',

BWRSBVLU\R

- 423 -

63((',

63(('

SGI

',

63((',

63(

((',

- 424 -

,'((36F

,'((36

,'((36

,'((36,'((36

,'((36

- 425 -

-&2

-&2

-&2

- 426 -

D

NPNP

NP

- 427 -

E

146

40

30

20

10

30

6430

NP

23

35

6

1020

2030

- 428 -

D

147

3676

1275%79

0 1 2 35

59%

13%16%

4%

46%

13%

33%

17%

- 429 -

NP

E

F

1,56

- 430 -

1,56

1,56

- 431 -

'1$

'1$'1$

- 432 -

P6YP6Y

P6Y

'1$

'1$

P6Y

P6Y

1DWLRQDO5HVHDUFK&RXQFLO+HDOWKULVNVIURPH[SRVXUHWRORZOHYHOVRILRQL]LQJUDGLDWLRQ%(,5 3KDVH

7KH1DWLRQDO$FDGHPLHV3UHVV2]DVD.HWDO 6WXGLHVRIWKH0RUWDOLW\RI$WRPLF%RPE6XUYLYRUV5HSRUW$Q2YHUYLHZ

RI&DQFHUDQG1RQFDQFHU'LVHDVHV 5DGLDWLRQ5HVHDUFK9ROSS

- 433 -

P6Y

P6Y

,&53D/17

/17

P6Y

%UHQQHU'-HWDO &DQFHUULVNVDWWULEXWDEOHWRORZGRVHVRILRQL]LQJUDGLDWLRQ$VVHVVLQJZKDWZH

UHDOO\NQRZ 3URFHHGLQJVRIWKH1DWLRQDO$FDGHP\RI6FLHQFHV9ROSS%UHQQHU'-HWDO &DQFHUULVNVDWWULEXWDEOHWRORZGRVHVRILRQL]LQJUDGLDWLRQ$VVHVVLQJZKDWZH

UHDOO\NQRZ 3URFHHGLQJVRIWKH1DWLRQDO$FDGHP\RI6FLHQFHV9ROSS

- 434 -

,&53/17P6Y

P6Y

P6YP6Y

P6Y

P6Y

,&53

,&53

P6Y6Y

,$5&

P6Y

6Y

3XEOLFDWLRQ

3XEOLFDWLRQ

(XURSHDQ&RPPLWWHHRQ5DGLDWLRQ5LVN 5HFRPPHQGDWLRQVRIWKH(&557KH+HDOWK(IIHFWVRI([SRVXUH

WR/RZ'RVHVRI,RQL]LQJ5DGLDWLRQ .UHVWLQLQD/

- 435 -

NP

P6Y

P6Y

6Y6Y

P6Y

LQGXVWU\(VWLPDWHVRIUDGLDWLRQUHODWHGFDQFHUULVNV 5DGLDWLRQ5HVHDUFK9ROSS

.RHUEOHLQ$ &$183,6VWXG\VWUHQJWKHQVHYLGHQFHRILQFUHDVHGOHXNDHPLDUDWHVQHDUQXFOHDUSRZHUSODQWV

,QWHUQDWLRQDO-RXUQDORI(SLGHPLRORJ\9ROSS6FKPLW])HXHUKDNH,HWDO /HXNHPLD

LQWKHSUR[LPLW\RID*HUPDQERLOLQJZDWHUQXFOHDUUHDFWRUHYLGHQFHRISRSXODWLRQH[SRVXUHE\FKURPRVRPH

VWXGLHVDQGHQYLURQPHQWDOUDGLRDFWLYLW\ (QYLURQPHQWDO+HDOWK3HUVSHFWLYHV9RO6XSSOHPHQW

SS1DLU55HWDO %DFNJURXQGUDGLDWLRQDQGFDQFHULQFLGHQFHLQ.HUDOD,QGLD.DUDQDJDSSDOO\FRKRUWVWXG\

+HDOWKSK\VLFV9ROSSP6Y

P6Y

P6Y3UHVWRQ'/HWDO 6WXGLHVRIPRUWDOLW\RIDWRPLFERPEVXUYLYRUV5HSRUW6ROLGFDQFHUDQGQRQFDQFHU

GLVHDVHPRUWDOLW\ 5DGLDWLRQ5HVHDUFK9ROSS:DNHIRUG5HWDO5LVNFRHIILFLHQWIRUFKLOGKRRGFDQFHUDIWHULQWUDXWHULQHLUUDGLDFWLRQDUHYLHZ

,QWHUQDWLRQDO-RXUQDORI5DGLDWLRQ%LRORJ\9ROSS

- 436 -

'1$

1DWLRQDO5HVHDUFK&RXQFLO+HDOWKULVNVIURPH[SRVXUHWRORZOHYHOVRILRQL]LQJUDGLDWLRQ%(,5 3KDVH

7KH1DWLRQDO$FDGHPLHV3UHVV6KLPL]X

- 437 -

P6YP6Y

P6Y

D

,331:*)6 +HDOWK(IIHFWVRI&KHUQRE\O\HDUVDIWHUWKHUHDFWRUFDWDVWURSKH,331:DQG*)65HSRUW

- 438 -

E

P6Y

- 439 -

%6(

FULWLFDOWKLQNLQJ

(8

177

- 440 -

- 441 -

NP

63((',

D

FSP

FSP

FSPFS

FSP

P6Y

FSP

2)&

- 442 -

E

NP

NP

63((',

63((',

NP

%TNJ

NP

- 344 -

F

PSF

G

- 444 -

HNP

NP

NP

1213

13

15

151318

16

15

/

21000

845

340

7250

152500257700

3000

1314

8000

/

- 445 -

NP

- 446 -

- 447 -

:%&

- 448 -

P6Y

P6Y

P6Y

,&53 $JHGHSHQGHQW'RVHVWR0HPEHUVRIWKH3XEOLFIURP,QWDNHRI5DGLRQXFOLGHV3DUW,QJHVWLRQ'RVH

&RHIILFLHQWV,&533XEOLFDWLRQ

63((',

NP

P6Y

- 449 -

P6Y

P6Y

0LQLVWU\RI8NUDLQHRI(PHUJHQFLHV 7ZHQW\ILYH

- 450 -

D

%%T

%T%T

%TNJ

%TNJ

, %T&V %T

- 451 -

P6Y

P6Y

P6Y

P6Y

- 452 -

E

P6Y

P6Y

- 453 -

,

%TNJ

%TNJ

%TNJ

%TNJ

%TNJ

%TNJ

3X3X3X3X$P&P

&P&P

%TNJ

%TNJ

%TNJ

%TNJ

,&53

- 454 -

P6Y

P6Y

,&53

P6Y

F

3XEOLFDWLRQ

(3=

- 455 -

- 456 -

G

%T

%T

- 457 -

HP6Y

P6Y

- 458 -

P6Y

P6Y,&53

(8

P6Y

P6Y

- 459 -

(8

%T(JJ

%TNJ

%TNJ

%TNJ

%TNJ

%TNJ

%TNJ

,$($ (QYLURQPHQWDO&RQVHTXHQFHVRIWKH&KHUQRE\O$FFLGHQWDQGWKHLU5HPHGLDWLRQ7ZHQW\

- 460 -

:%&

D:%&

:%&

:%&

E

:%&

:%&

:%&

:%&

:%&

- 461 -

F

:%&

:%&

:%&:%&

:%&:%&

- 462 -

:%&

:%&

- 463 -

NPNP

P6Y

,&53

P6Y

,&53

P6Y

P6Y

3XEOLFDWLRQ

- 464 -

P6Y6Y

P6Y

6YK

6YK

6YK

6YK6YK

P6Y

6YK,&53

P6Y

P6Y6YK6YK

P6Y

- 465 -

P6Y

P6Y

P6Y

P6Y

P6Y

6YK

6YK

,&53

3XEOLFDWLRQ

&LNP&LNP

&LNP

P6Y

6YK

P6YK

- 466 -

/17

P6Y

P6Y

P6YP6Y

P6Y

- 467 -

P6YP6Y

P6Y

P6Y

P69P6Y

/17

P6Y ,&53

P6Y,&53

P6Y

P6Y

P6Y

P6Y

- 468 -

D

P6Y

E

P6Y

P6Y

P6Y

FP6Y

$/$5$$V/RZDVUHDVRQDEO\DFKLHYDEOH

$/$5$,&53

3XEOLFDWLRQP6YP6YP6YP6Y

- 469 -

P6Y

P6Y

P6Y

P6Y

P6Y

D

-

P6Y

P6YP6YP6YP6YP6YP6YP6YP6YP6Y

P6YP6YP6YP6YP6Y

P6Y

- 470 -

47%

8%

53%

95%

98%

92%

99%

99%

0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%

- 471 -

E

D

$3'

$3'

$3'

$3'

$3'

$3'

$3'

$3'$3'

$3'

P6YD

%TE%T

$3'

$3'

- 472 -

$3'

$3'

$3'

$3'

$3'

$3'

60%

57%

46%

47%

48%

54%

8%

4%

12%

0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%

1

- 473 -

E

:%&

P6Y

:%&:%&

:%&

:%&

-$($

:%&

:%&-$($

:%&

:%&

55%

63%

49%

17%

12%

15%

28%

25%

35%

0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%

- 474 -

- 475 -

V\QGURPHRIDYLFWLP

V\QGURPHRIVRFLDOH[FOXVLRQ

-&2

0LQLVWU\RI8NUDLQHRI(PHUJHQFLHV 7ZHQW\ILYH

- 476 -

376'

- 477 -

D


- 478 -

E

%TNJ

%TNJ


- 479 -

,QWHUQDWLRQDO%XVLQHVV7LPHV$XJXVW

KWWSMSLEWLPHVFRPDUWLFOHEL]QHZVKWPO

- 480 -

6Y

- 481 -

D

FP

P

P

6Y

6Y

6Y6Y

%

$

- 482 -

6YK

6Y6Y

E

- 483 -

P

D


- 484 -

E

D

- 485 -

P6Y

D

E

- 486 -

- 488 -

- 489 -

- 490 -

- 491 -

02;

- 492 -

'*6:

- 493 -

- 494 -

D

-1(6

23P

23P

-1(6

2.

-1(6

P

E36$

36$

- 495 -

FP

36$

36$

F

FP

2.

- 496 -

G

FP

P

P

P

H

- 497 -

D

23P

23P23P

E

- 498 -

:*:*

:*

- 499 -

F

- 500 -

P

36$

36$36$

6$

- 501 -

6%2 6%2

- 502 -

:*

:*

6%2

:*

:*

:*

- 503 -

6%2

6%2

:*

6%2

6%2

'*36$

5*

6%2

'*

:*

'*

'*'*

:*

:*

- 504 -

- 505 -

6$

6$

- 506 -

zz

z z

z

zzz

zz

zz

z

- 507 -

183(&

D

- 508 -

183(&

E

183(&

F

G

- 509 -

H183(&

183(&

I183(&

183(&

183(&

- 510 -

D

:*:*:*:*

E

F

- 511 -

*DO

D

- 512 -

E

,6V

- 513 -

*DO

F

- 514 -

6V

G

- 515 -

H

I

- 516 -

6$6$

,$($6$

6$6$

6$

6$

D,$($,556

,$($,556

- 517 -

E

6$

$0

6$

6$

6$

6$

- 518 -

6$

,$($6$

$0

36$$0

6$

6$%'%(6$

6$&9

DVEXLOW$0

EXLOWLQ6$

6$

6$

6$

6$

$0

- 519 -

6$

6$

6$

- 520 -

6$

6$

,&53

,&53

- 521 -

,&53

,&53

P6Y\

- 522 -

,&53

,&53

,&53

(8

- 523 -

,&53,$($%66

,&53

,&53

- 425 -

$63$63

- 525 -

$6

- 526 -

- 527 -

y

y

y

y

y

y

y

y

y

- 528 -

- 529 -

3/56&&

2*

63

- 035 -

%$

- 531 -

$

$

%

%

$

%

- 532 -

%

$ %

- 335 -

%$

- 534 -

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

-4000

-3000

-2000

-1000

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

()

(

)

- 535 -

7/-$17,

:$12&35

RU

- 536 -

6$

- 537 -

'*

'*

- 538 -

'*

+3&,

- 539 -

9

*DO

*DO

*DO

N:

N:

- 540 -

//

- 541 -

D

- 542 -

':

6YK

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0

500

1,000

1,500

2,000

23:00 1:00 3:00 5:00 7:00 9:00 11:00 13:00

D/WM

P a

bs

m

m

mm D/WMPaabs

2500

2000

1500

1000

D/S

11930.0Sv/h

- 543 -

F

- 445 -

)

)

)

- 545 -

)

1,6$

1,6$

D

- 546 -

E

N: N: N:

N: N: N:

N:

N:N:

N:

N:N:

N:N:

N:

N:N:

N:N:

N:

- 547 -

- 548 -

70,

KWWSZZZWHSFRFRMSFFSUHVVEHWXBMLPDJHVFSGI

- 549 -

70,

$

-RKQ*.HPHQ\ 3UHVLGHQWV&RPPLVVLRQRQWKH$FFLGHQWDW7KUHH0LOH,VODQG S-DPHV0$FWLRQDQG0DUN+LEEV :K\)XNXVKLPDZDVSUHYHQWDEOH 7KH&DUQHJLH3DSHUV1XFOHDU3ROLF\

S

- 550 -

- 551 -

SA

SA

3

PAZ

PSA

- 552 -

70,

,$($

,$($

,$($

,$($ /RQJ7HUP6WUXFWXUHRIWKH,$($6DIHW\6WDQGDUGV

DQG6WDWXV SS KWWSZZZQVLDHDRUJFRPPLWWHHVILOHV&66VWDWXVSGI

,$($6DIHW\6WDQGDUG6HULHV6))XQGDPHQWDO6DIHW\3ULQFLSOHVSS

SPEEDI

5

- 553 -

15&

15&

$

- 554 -

,$($

-&2

KWWSZZZQVFJRMSNLVHLSGISDJHBSDJHBSGI

- 555 -

(/(&75,&,7

- 556 -

/RLQUHODWLYHODWUDQVSDUHQFHHWODVFXULWHQPDWLUHQXFODLUH

':3+6()5$0(:25.'2&80(17SS

KWWSZZZKVHJRYXNDERXWXVKRZZHZRUNPDQDJHPHQWGZSKVHSGI

'HSDUWPHQWRI(QHUJ\DQG&OLPDWH&KDQJH 7+(81,7('.,1*'206),)7+1$7,21$/5(3257

21&203/,$1&(:,7+7+(&219(17,212118&/($56$)(7

- 557 -

15&

761

85/

KWWSZZZPHWLJRMSUHSRUWGRZQORDGILOHVJGMSGI

KWWSZZZPHWLJRMSUHSRUWGRZQORDGILOHVJGMSGI


- 558 -

-1(6

-$($

- 559 -

63((',

,$($

,$($0,66,215(32577+(*5($7($67-$3$1($57+48$.((;3(570,66,21,$($,17(51$7,21$/)$&7),1',1*

(;3(570,66,212)7+()8.86+,0$'$,,&+,133$&&,'(17)2//2:,1*7+(*5($7($67-$3$1($57+48$.($1'7681$0,

7RN\R)XNXVKLPD'DLLFKL133)XNXVKLPD'DLQL133DQG7RNDL'DLQL133-DSDQ0D\-XQH

SS

- 560 -

,$($

,$($

,$($6DIHW\6WDQGDUG6HULHV6))XQGDPHQWDO6DIHW\3ULQFLSOHVS,$($6DIHW\6WDQGDUG6HULHV6))XQGDPHQWDO6DIHW\3ULQFLSOHVS

- 561 -

70,

(8

,$($

,$($

,$($

,$($

,$($,556

(QHUJ\5HYLHZ

,$($ ,QWHJUDWHG5HJXODWRU\5HYLHZVHUYLFH KWWSZZZQVLDHDRUJUHYLHZVUVUHYLHZVDVS

,$($ ,QWHJUDWHG5HJXODWRU\5HYLHZ6HUYLFH,556WR-DSDQ

KWWSZZZQLVDPHWLJRMSJHQVKLU\RNXILOHVUHSRUWSGI

- 562 -

,556

,$($

,556

,556

,556

KWWSZZZPHWLJRMSLQIRUPDWLRQBGRZQORDGILOH6UHYLHZB6KHHWSGI

&RQYHQWLRQRQ1XFOHDU6DIHW\ 4XHVWLRQV3RVWHGWR-DSDQLQ SS*RYHUQPHQWRI-DSDQ &RQYHQWLRQRQ1XFOHDU6DIHW\1DWLRQDO5HSRUWRI-DSDQIRUWKH)RXUWKUHYLHZ0HHWLQJ

IAEA

- 563 -

,556

,$($

,556

,55626$57

S KWWSZZZQLVDPHWLJRMSHQJOLVKLQWHUQDWLRQDOFRRSHUDWLRQFRQYHQWLRQVFQV

SGIWKB1DWLRQDO5HSRUWSGI

,$($,55626$57

- 564 -

26$5726$57

26$57

- 565 -

15&

$61

70,

15&,132

'&

NRC ASN

IRSN

CLIASN

CLIASN

- 566 -

70,

70,

70,

y 15&

y 15&

y :HE15&

y

y )(0$

y y

y ,132

y ,132

D70,

$(&

$

- 567 -

15&'2(

70,

E70,

15&

15&

15&15&

15&

15&

15&*$2

70,15&

15&

('2

('2

15&

$(&

15&

15&15&

70,('2

15&

15&

-RKQ*.HPHQ\ 3UHVLGHQWV&RPPLVVLRQRQWKH$FFLGHQWDW7KUHH0LOH,VODQG S-RKQ*.HPHQ\ 3UHVLGHQWV&RPPLVVLRQRQWKH$FFLGHQWDW7KUHH0LOH,VODQG S

- 568 -

70,

70,

15&

F70,

70,

70,

,132

y 70,15&15&

2,*

15&('2

15&

('2

('2

('2

15&

-DPHV57HPSOHV 7KH1XFOHDU5HJXODWRU\&RPPLVVLRQDQGWKH3ROLWLFVRI5HJXODWRU\5HIRUP6LQFH7KUHH

PLOH,VODQG3XEOLF$GPLQLVWUDWLRQ5HYLHZ9RO1RSS15& 5HVROXWLRQRI*HQHULFVDIHW\,VVXHV7DVN9)2UJDQL]DWLRQDQG0DQDJHPHQW185(*0DLQ5HSRUW

ZLWK6XSSOHPHQWV

KWWSZZZVHUFRUJGRFXPHQWV-RLQW6WDQGLQJ&RPPLWWHHV6(5&-RLQW&RPPLWWHH0HHWLQJ

0\UWOH%HDFKD&ODLU*RGGDUG.H\QRWH6SHDNHUIURP,132SGI

- 569 -

15&('2

15&2,*15&

y 70,15&

2,15&15&

15&

15&15&

15&

15&

y 70,15&

15&:HE

15&

y 70,15&

15&

*URZ2XU2ZQ

15& 5HVROXWLRQRI*HQHULFVDIHW\,VVXHV7DVN,9$6WUHQJWKHQ(QIRUFHPHQW3URFHVV185(*0DLQ

5HSRUWZLWK6XSSOHPHQWV

KWWSZZZQUFJRYUHDGLQJUPGRFFROOHFWLRQVQXUHJVVWDIIVUVHFDKWPO

$15&

- 570 -

15&

15&

15&

15&

)(0$

)(0$

)(0$70,

)(0$

15&

15& 5HVROXWLRQRI*HQHULF6DIHW\,VVXHV7DVN,9'15&6WDII7UDLQLQJ185(*0DLQ5HSRUWVZLWK

6XSSOHPHQWV KWWSZZZQUFJRYUHDGLQJUPGRFFROOHFWLRQVQXUHJVVWDIIV6UVHFGKWPO

$8QLWHG6WDWHV2IILFHRI3HUVRQQHO0DQDJHPHQW (PSOR\HH6XPPDU\)HHGEDFN5HSRUWRIWKH)HGHUDO(PSOR\HH

9LHZSRLQW6XUYH\ KWWSSEDGXSZVQUFJRYGRFV0/0/SGI *:

)(0$)(0$

15& 5HVROXWLRQRI*HQHULF6DIHW\,VVXHV7DVN,,,%(PHUJHQF\3UHSDUHGQHVVRI6WDWHDQG/RFDO*RYHUQPHQWV

185(*0DLQ5HSRUWVZLWK6XSSOHPHQWV

KWWSZZZQUFJRYUHDGLQJUPGRFFROOHFWLRQVQXUHJVVWDIIVUVHFEKWPO

- 571 -

15&

70,,132

70,

,132

&(2

,132

,132

15&,132

y ,132,132,132&(2

&(2,132

&(2,132

1(,/

,132&(2

,132,132

,132

15&15&

15& 5HVROXWLRQRI*HQHULFVDIHW\,VVXHV7DVN,,,&3XEOLF,QIRUPDWLRQ185(*0DLQ5HSRUWZLWK

6XSSOHPHQWV KWWSZZZQUFJRYUHDGLQJUPGRFFROOHFWLRQVQXUHJVVWDIIVUVHFFKWPO

$,132

- 572 -

,132

$61

,561

&($

&/,

761

'6,1

$61

$61,561$61

&/,&/,

D

$61$61

23(&67

$61

E

761&/,

&/,

15&

- 573 -

$61:HE

&/,761

&/,&/,

$61&/,

761&/,

&/,$61

$61

F

$61 $61

,561$61

,561$61

$61

,$($

/RLQrGXMXLQUHODWLYH ODWUDQVSDUHQFHHWODVFXULWHQPDWLUHQXFODLUH

$61$61 7KH)UHQFK1XFOHDU/HJLVODWLRQ SS

KWWSZZZDQVQRUJ&RPPRQWRSLFV2SHQ7RSLFDVS[",' /RLQr

GXMXLQUHODWLYH ODWUDQVSDUHQFHHWODVFXULWHQPDWLUHQXFODLUH

- 574 -

- 576 -

- 577 -

'HIHQFHLQ'HSWK

- 578 -

D

- 579 -

-&2

E

D


- 580 -

F

'HIHQFHLQ'HSWK

D

- 581 -

,$($

E

,$($6DIHW\6WDQGDUG6HULHV6))XQGDPHQWDO6DIHW\3ULQFLSOHV

- 582 -

F

,$($

- 583 -

,$($6DIHW\6WDQGDUGV6HULHV*653UHSDUHGQHVVDQG5HVSRQVHIRUD1XFOHDURU5DGLRORJLFDO(PHUJHQF\

6DIHW\5HTXLUHPHQWV

-&2

- 584 -

- 585 -

- 685 -

1

2

3

4

5

1

???

?

????????

11156

32166 36223

23

???

?

????????

1F Fukushima Daiichi 2F Fukushima Daini AM Accident Management AO Air Operated Valve ARI Alternative Rods Injection ATWS Anticipated Transient Without

Scram

B-DBA Beyond Design Basis Accident BAF Bottom of Active Fuel BWR Boiling Water Reactor CAMS Conta inment Atomosphere

Monitoring System

CCI Core-Concrete Interaction CRD Control Rod Drive CV Containment Vessel Vent D/G Diesel Generator D/W Dry-Well DBA Design Basis Accident DGSW Diesel Generator Sea Water

System

ECCS Emergency Core Cooling System EECW Emergency Equipment Cooling

Water

EOP Emergency Operating Procedures ERC Emergency Response Center ERSS Emergency Response Support

System

FAC Flow-Accelerated Corrosion FTA Fault Tree Analysis HCU Hydraulic Control System HPCI High Pressure Coolant Injection

System

HPCS High Pressure Core Spray System

HVAC Heating Ventilating and Air Conditioning System

IA Instrument Air system IAEA International Atomic Energy

Agency

IC Isolation Condenser ICRP International Commission on

Radiological Protection

INES The International Nuclear and Radiological Event Scale

IPE Individual Plant Examination IPEEE Individual Plant Examination for

External Events

JAEA Japan Atomic Energy Agency

???

?

????????

JNES Japan Nuclear Energy Safety

Organization

LB-LOCA Large Break LOCA LOCA Loss Of Coolant Accident LPCI Low Pressure Coolant Injection

System

M/C Metal-Clad Switch Gear MAAP Modular Accident Analysis

Program

MB-LOCA Medium Break LOCA MCC Motor Control Center MOX Mixed Oxide Fuel MO Motor Operated valve MP Monitoring Post MSIV Main Steam Isolation Valve MUWC Make-Up Water Condensate system NISA Nuclear and Industrial Safety

Agency

NRC Nuclear Regulatory Commission P/C Power Center PSA Probabilistic Safety Assessment PSR Periodic Safety Review RCIC Reactor Core Isolation Cooling

System

RHR Residual Heat Removal System RHRC Residual Heat Removal Cooling

System

RHRS Residual Heat Removal Sea Water System

RPT Recirculation Pump Trip RPV Reactor Pressure Vessel S/C Suppression Chamber SA Severe Accident SB-LOCA Small Break LOCA SBO Station Blackout SCC Stress Corrosion Cracking SGTS Standby Gas Treatment System SHC Shutdown Cooling System SLC Standby Liquid Control System SOP Severe Accident Operating

Procedures

SPEEDI System for Prediction ofEnvironmental Emergency DoseInformation

SR Safety Relief Valve T/B Turbine Building TAF Top of Active Fuel UHS Ultimate Heat Sink WBC Whole Body Counter WHO World Health Organization

???

?

????????

HPCI

IC

INES IAEA7

LOCA Loss Of Coolant Accident

RCIC

S/C

SBO SR

Gy/h/

Gy 1 kg

cpm 1

???

?

????????

Sv

2

SA

-

IAEA 5

2

2

1 Gy 20 Sv 1 Gy 1 Sv

2

???

?

????????

B.5.b 132001 9 11 142002 NRC

Bq 1

???

?

???????????????

2

1.

2.

3.

4.

???

?

???????????????

5.

6.

7.

8.

???

?

???????????????

9.

J-ALERT

10.

PAZ 20km30km

11.

20km

12.

???

?

???????????????

13.

14.

15.

1 4

1

2

3

4

???

?

???????????????

5 4 5

6 4

16.

1

2003 2010

NRC 2001 2009

2010

IAEA 2011

2B.5.b

9-11 2002 2 25NRCB.5.b

1

???

?

???????????????

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

???

?

??????

3

http://naiic.go.jp

1 231219

2 24116 :

3 24130

4 24215 16

5 24227 A

6 24314

7 24319

8 24328

9 24418

10 24421

11 24422

12 24514

13 24516 16

14 24517

15 24527

16 24528

17 24529

18 2468

19 2469

???

?

??????

1231219

12 18 12 19

9

???

?

??????

224116

SPEEDI

1

2

3

???

?

??????

3 24130

SPEEDI

mSv

???

?

??????

4 2421516

39(1964)

???

?

??????

524227

(NRC)INPO

NRC

???

?

??????

624314

182006

142002

???

?

??????

724319

???

?

??????

8 24328

IAEA

5 3IAEA

???

?

??????

924418

???

?

??????

11 12 10km20kmSPEEDI SPEEDI 1119

10 24421

11 24422

PTA

PTA

???

?

??????

4

???

?

??????

1224514

???

?

??????

13 2451616

2006 9 B.5.b

B.5.b 2011 6 18

3

???

?

??????

1424517

356 SPEEDI

???

?

??????

1 2 3 4 5

1

???

?

??????

1524527

???

?

??????

1624528

212 15

???

?

??????

???

?

??????

17 24529

3 2010 SPEEDI

23 3553SPEEDI

???

?

??????

182468

???

?

??????

192469

1 2 3 4

2

???

?

??????

5SPEEDI SPEEDI 6 4 5

???

?

????????????????????

4

???

?

????????????????????

5

1986

1965

6

2004 12

M9.1 M8.6 M8.6

10

???

?

??????????????

???

?

??????????????

3.11

3.11

17 6 22

JR

53

24

54

2

???

?

??????????????

???

?

??????????????

3

1

26

54

ICRP

. .

J

???

?

??????????????

???

?

??????????????

3.11

10 10

3.11

3.11

2006

???

?

??????????????

???

?

??????????????

The Theory of Economic Regulation

11

???

?

??????????????

???

?

??????????????

1969 1979 UCLA 1983

2003 07 2006

08 WHO2005 09

Health and Global Policy Institute Chair and Founder, IMPACT Foundation Japan

http://www.kiyoshikurokawa.com/

1973

19962008

1967

HICARE

1974

??????

??????

??????

??????

2002

9

SSDI

100-001417103-3581-5111http://naiic.go.jp

2012

naiic honpen(本編)

Documents