musical qualia, context, time, and emotion - university of california

27

Upload: others

Post on 12-Feb-2022

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

� ��������� ����������������������������! "��# �$������% &'# �(�)�����

*,+.-0/�13254�6879+.:.;3/=<>@?BADC�[email protected][?JIDY\?�]_^`IVaSZbIV?B?BEcZdIVae@IfZ[gO?BEchGZdFji�LONkP�COlbZ[NmLOE0IfZdCnC�FoX.COI(>oZ[?BaOLVpqeoX.r

s�tvuBwyx�zf{OwS|�} ?JC�Ecl[i�COldlKldZdhWFW?JIf?BEch~Y\LSIfhcZd�V?BEvFG�V?RhcTV�.�W?JY\FGZ[gO?�COhWA3?JY\FGhvLONDHnTfhGZdY�pOhGTDYc�nCOhvZdFGh~?JH9L��FGZdLSIfCOl~FWLSIf?Op�FWL��fCygO?�AfEcZdH�C�Eci�ZbH9A3LOEGFGCOIfY\?O����TVFoY\LSIKFW?JH9A3LOEcC�EGi�AU�fZdl[LShWLOAU�V?BEch)LON�FW?JI��VLy�MIV�AUldCJiOp`ZdaSIVLOEG?OpkLOE�?BgO?JI��V?JIKi�hGTfY0��COhGAq?JY\FGh�LONM?\�,A3?BEcZ[?JIDY\?O����LOEG?BL=gO?BEJp`FWEcCO�DZ[FGZ[LSIfCOl�AD�fZdldLShWL��AU�fZ[?JhkLON�HnTfhGZdY�FWEGi�FWL��f?JY\LSI�FW?\�.FGTfCOldZ[�B?@Z[FB�ke�hcZdIVaHnTfhGZdY)COh�COI�?\�VCOH9ADl[?OpKFG�fZdh�ADC�A3?BEQ?\�.ADl[LOEG?JhFG�f?�hWFWEcTfY\FGTVEc?9LONR�,TfCOldZ[FGC�FGZdgO?n?\�.A3?BEcZ[?JIfY\?Op��V?JH9LSIfhWFWE0C�FGZdIVa�FG�fC�FZ[FZdh�HnTfl[FGZ[�jldCJiO?BE�?JH9?BEcaO?JI�FBpIfLSI.�jY\LSH9A3LShGZ[FGZ[LSIDCOl�p�?JIfCOY\FW?J��pKCOID�9hGZ[FGTfC�FGZ[LSI��V?BA3?JIf�f?JI�FBpSCOH9LSIfa�LOFG�V?BE`IVLSI.��P)C�EGFW?JhGZdCOInAfEGLOAf�?BEcFGZ[?JhB��oTVEM?\�.ADldCOIDC�FGZ[LSIfh@�VEcCJ��LSI�EG?JY\?JIKF@�RLOEG��ZbI�Y\LOaSIfZ[FGZdgO?nhGYBZd?JIfY\?Op�ZdIfYBldTf�DZdIVa��Dl[?JIf�DZdIVaVpZbH�C�aO?RhcYc�V?JH�COhJp�COIf�nhW?JIfhWLOEGiH�?JH9LOEGiOpSCOhv��?JlblKCOhvLSInAD�V?JIVLSH�?JIVLSl[LOaOiO��r��fZ[?BEcC�E0Yc�fZdYBCOl,hWFWEcTDY��FGTfEG?�FWEcCOIfhWN�LOEcH�C�FGZdLSI(�DCOhW?J��Y\LSH�ADl[?\�VZ[Fji�FG�V?BLOEGi�Zdh)C�AfADlbZ[?J��FWL�LO�fFGCOZdI�C IVLSI.�jldZdIf?JC�E��fi,IfCOH Z¡�YBCOl~hWi,hGFW?JH�h¢?\�.ADldCOIfC�FGZdLSI�LONv�,TfCOldZdC�COIf��?JH�LOFGZ[LSI�FG�fC�F)Ec?JhWA3?JY\FGh)AD�V?JIVLSH�?JIVLSl[LOaSZdYBCOl�ZdIDhGZ[aS�KFGhC��3LSTVF�FGZdH9?Op.ZdIfYBldTD�fZdIVaoEG?BFW?JIKFGZ[LSI�COIf� ADEGLOFW?JI�FGZdLSI��k£¢�V?�Y\LSH�ADl[?\�VZ[Fji�H9?JCOhcTVEG?MADEGLyg.Zd�V?Jh`�qLOFG�C�H9?BFWEcZbY¤hWFWE0TfY\FGTVEG?�COIf�5C�A3LOFW?JIKFGZdCOl`N¥TfIfY\FGZdLSI�p�LSI�hWAUCOY\?Jh�LONMADZ[?JY\?JhnFG�fC�F�C�EG?�Y\LSIDhWFWEcTfY\FW?J�TDhGZdIVa�aSZ[gO?JI¤?Jl[?JH9?JIKFGh`COID��FWEcCOIfhGNmLOEcH C�FGZ[LSIfhBpK�MZ[FG�9�R?JZ[aS�KFGh`FG�fC�F�EG?B¦f?JY\F�FG�V?JZ[E`Y\LOaSIfZdFGZ[gO?��fZd§9�YBTDl[FjiO�Q¨�Ly�R?BgO?BEJpVFG�V?@C�AfAfEGLSCOY0�¤Zdh�IVLOF`Ec?J�fTfY\FGZ[LSIfZbhWFB©KTfhcZdIVaZdH9ADEGLyg.ZdhGC�FGZ[LSI COIf��FG�V?�?BgOLSldTVFGZ[LSILON�HnTfhGZdYBCOlVIfLOFGC�FGZ[LSI COh��fC�FGC.pK�R?MC�EGaSTf?)FG�fC�F�hGZdFGTfC�FW?J�fIV?JhGhJpS?JhWA3?JYBZdCOldl[i�?JIfCOY\FGH9?JIKFRCOIf� hWL,YBZbCOlY\LSIKFW?\�.FBpqC�EG?��O?Bi�COhGAq?JY\FGh¢LON�HnTfhGZbYBCOl�Y\LSIfhGYBZ[LSTfhcIV?JhGhB�

ª «f¬o­q®�¯°�±�²v­�³G¯�¬£¢�fZbh¢ADC�A3?BE�CO�D�VEG?JhGhW?Jh@ZdhGhcTV?JhMZdI�FG�V?nAD�fZdl[LShGLOAD��iOpqY\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[gO?�hGYBZ[?JIDY\?OpqCOIf��hWL.YBZ[LSl[LOaOi�LONQHnTfhGZbY�pqYBldTDhWFW?BEG?J�C�EGLSTfID��FG�V?�IVLOFGZ[LSI5LONM´8µ zD¶¥·mz�¸ pk���fZdYc�º¹�EGLSTVaS�fldi�hGAq?JC��.ZdIVaK»C�EG?�FG�V?��,TfCOldZdFGC�FGZ[gO?¤COhWA3?JY\FGhnLON¢Y\LSIfhGYBZdLSTfh?\�.Aq?BE0Z[?JIfY\?O�¼½I�ADC�EGFGZdYBTflbC�EJpU�R?�Y\LSIfhGZb�V?BEoFG�V?9hWFWEcTfY\FGTVEc?�LON��KTDCOldZdC.p3FG�fC�F�ZdhBp3FG�V?JZ[EoADC�EcFGhBp8COIf���VLy�_FG�fLShW?ADC�EGFGhMY\LSH��DZbIV?O���@FG�V?BEMY\LSIDY\?BEcIfhMZbIfYBldTf�V?oY\LSIKFW?\�,FGTfCOlbZ[FjiOpqH9?JH9LOEGiOpDhcCOldZ[?JIfY\iOpVFGZdH�?COIf�(?JH9LOFGZ[LSI8�

X,?JY\FGZdLSIfhn¾�COIf��¿(N�L,YBTfh�LSI5FG�V? AD�DZdl[LShWLOAD�Ki�LON¢H�TfhcZdY�p���Z[FG��X,?JY\FGZdLSI�¾,�dÀ��V?BgOLOFW?J��FWL�C�gO?BEGi��,TfZdYG��fZdhGFWLOEcZdYBCOl3hGTVEGgO?BiOpUCOIf�(�MZ[FG��X,?JY\FGZdLSI�¾,�Á¾�?\�.ADl[LOEcZdIfa�hGLSH9?IVLOFGZ[LSIfh¢LONvY\LSIKFW?\�,F@COIf��hGZdFGTfC�FW?J�fIV?JhGhJp.ZbIfYBldTf�.�ZdIVa�FG�V?�½N�LSTVEGFG��A3?BEchGLSIfÃ�H9?BFG�VL.�VLSl[LOaOi�FG�fC�FZdhoTfhW?J��ZdI�FG�DZdh@ADC�A3?BEJ�9X.?JY\FGZ[LSI�¿�NmL.YBTfhW?JhLSI��KTfCOlbZ[FGC�FGZ[gO?COhWA3?JY\FGh@LON`HnTfhGZdY�p3hW�O?BFGYc�DZdIVa�hWLSH9?�A3LShGZ[FGZ[LSIfh¢FG�fC�FoAD�fZdl[LShGLOAD�V?BEch¢�DCJgO?�FGC��O?JI�p8ZdIfYBlbTf�fZdIVa�FG�V?�hW?BADC�E0C�FGZ[LSILONQhGTV�V�½?JY\FGZ[gO?�NmEcLSHÄLO�.�W?JY\FGZ[gO?�COhWA3?JY\FGhBpDFWEG?JC�FGZbIVa¤H�COZbIfl[i�FG�V?�ldC�FWFW?BEypqCOIf�$�fTV�f�UZdIVa�FG�V?�N�LOEcH9?BE�ÂW�KTDCOldZdC.�ÅÃÆ�?AfEcLOAqLShG?@COI(COl[FW?BE0IfC�FGZ[gO?C�AfAfEcLSCOYc��pfhGTfAfA3LOEGFW?J���Ki¤?\�.COH9AUl[?JhGÇo�V?JH9LSIfhGFWEcC�FGZdIVa�hWLSH9?YBTVE0Z[LSTfhRAfEGLOA3?BEW�FGZ[?Jh�LON�HnTfhGZbYBCOlQ�KTDCOldZdC.p�hcTfYc�5COh��fCyg,ZbIVa��V?BFW?BEGLOaO?JIV?BLSTDhnY\LSH�AqLSIf?JI�FGh��MZ[FG��HnTfl[FGZ[AUl[?9l[?BgO?JldhBpvY\LSH��DZbIfZdIVaIVLSI.�jY\LSH�AqLShcZ[FGZ[LSIfCOldldiOpvCOIf��C�AfAfEcLOAfEcZdC�FGZdIfa�FW?JH9A3LOEcCOldl[i�ADEcZ[LOE��,TfCOldZbC5¹�FG�,Tfhng,Z[LSlbC�FGZdIVa$hGLSH9?�IDCOZ[gO?(Zd�V?JCOhC��3LSTVF�FW?JH9A3LOEcCOl�ldZdIf?JC�EcZ[Fji¤LON~A3?BEcY\?BAfFGZdLSIU»0�Q£¢�V?JhW?�AU�V?JIVLSH9?JIfC�C�EG?ZbI�FW?BEG?JhGFGZdIVa9ZdI�FG�V?JH�hW?JldgO?JhBpDCOIf��FG�V?BiCOldhWL5Y\LSI�FWEcZd�DTVFW?(FWL5hG�O?BAfFGZdYBZdhGHÈC��3LSTVF FG�V?�LSIKFWLSl[LOaSZdYBCOlMhGFGC�FGTfh�LON��,TfCOldZdC.�ºX.?JY\FGZ[LSI!¿,�dÀ��DZdhGYBTfhGhG?Jh�FGZdH9?Y\LSIfhGYBZdLSTfhGIV?JhGhJpfZdIfYBldTf�DZdIVa�^��fHnTfIf��¨�TDhGhW?BEcl�ÉÅh)IfLOFGZ[LSIfh)LON�N�EG?JhG�(H9?JH9LOEciOpfEG?BFW?JIKFGZ[LSI�pDCOIf��AfEGLOFW?JIKFGZ[LSI��

X,?JY\FGZdLSI(ÊV�dÀ�fZdhcYBTfhGhW?Jh�hWLSH9?Y\LOaSIDZ[FGZ[gO?hGYBZ[?JIDY\?�LONvHnTfhGZdY�pVC�EGaSTDZdIVa�NmLOEMFG�V?�EG?Jl[?Bg�COIfY\?�LONvEG?JY\?JI�F��V?BgO?Jl¡�LOADH9?JIKFGhMZbI�Y\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[gO?nldZdIVaSTDZdhWFGZdYBhBp.ZdIfYBlbTf�fZdIVa�ZdH�C�aO?�hGYc�V?JH COh�COIf���Dl[?JIf�fZbIVaV��X,?JY\FGZ[LSI�ÊV�Á¾9?\�.FW?JIf�fh¢FG�f?JhW?Zd�V?JCOhnFWL��fCOIf�Dl[?¤hWFWE0TfY\FGTVEG?�H9LOEG?�?\Ëq?JY\FGZdgO?Jl[iOp`�M�DZdl[?�X.?JY\FGZ[LSI�ÊV�Á¿,p`�M�fZbYc��ZdhnFG�V?¤FW?JY0�fIfZdYBCOl��V?JC�EcFnLON�FG�V?ADC�A3?BEJpV�V?BgO?Jl[LOAUh¢C9�fZ[?BEcC�E0Yc�fZdYBCOl�hGFWEcTfY\FGTVEcCOl�Y\LSH�ADl[?\�VZ[Fji�FG�V?BLOEGi��MZ[FG��FWEcCOIDhWNmLOE0H�C�FGZ[LSIfhBp.�M�DZdYc�(Zdh)TDhW?J��FWLÌÎÍ3Ï=ÐkÑ�ÒÅÓ�Ô�Õ=ÖÁ×cØ~Ù¡Ú0ØÎÛ�ÚcÙVÜÎÏ�ÒÅÑ8ÝOÐ�ØÎÏ�×cÝ�Ñ�Õ=Ó=Ù[×cÛ)ÒÅÖÁÒÁ×GØ~ÞqÚ0Øjß@ÒÅÑMà¥áBÕ�×cÖÅÐ�â ãä�Í3Ï=ÐkÖÅнå�ÜÎÕ=ØÎÐkæ�Ð�ØÎÑ�ÒÅÚ�ÓoÚcÙ.ÜÎÏ�ÒÅÑ8Û¢×cÜÎÐ�ØÎÒÁ×cÖ�ÙçÐW×cÜÎÕyØÎÐWß@Ñ�Ï�ÚcØ�Ü~Ý�ÒÁ×0Ó=Ú�Ñ�нÔ�Û)Ð�ÓJÜÎÑ�ÝOÐèØ�Ù¡Ú0ØÎÛ)нß@éBê¢ë~êBÚ0ì\Ú)ívÚ0Ô�Õ=нÓ�×0Ñ~ÒÅÖÅÖÁÕ=Ñ¥Ü�Øj×cÜÎÒÅÚ�Ó=ѽâ

À

Page 2: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

H9L.�V?Jlv�KTfCOlbZdC.p�COIf��FG�V?JI�?\�,FW?JIf�f?J��FWL�Y\LSIDhWFWEcTfY\F�C(�Vi.IfCOH�ZdYBCOlvhWi.hWFW?JH�hoH9L.�V?JlvLON�HnTfhGZdYBCOlvY\LSH9AfEc?J�V?JI.�hGZ[LSI8��X,?JY\FGZ[LSI��MY\LSIfY\?BEcIfhvFG�V?�hWL.YBZ[LSl[LOaOiLONfHnTfhGZdY�pOC�EGaSTDZdIVaMFG�DC�FvH�COIKi�AD�V?JIfLSH9?JIfCM�DZdhGYBTfhGhG?J��ZdI�AfEG?Bg.Z[LSTfhhW?JY\FGZ[LSIDhBp~ZdIfYBlbTf�fZdIVa��,TfCOldZbC.p8�fCJgO?�C(hGZdaSIfZ��DYBCOIKF@hGL,YBZdCOl�Y\LSH9A3LSIV?JIKFB�n¼èFoFGC��O?Jh�COh��fC�FGC(COI�ZdH9AfEcLyg.ZdhGC�FGZ[LSI�,i��MiOLO�OL��oLOaSTV?JI�¹����fZdYc��Zdh¢�VL.YBTfH9?JIKFW?J��ZdI�rMAfA3?JIf�DZ¡��r�»0pUCOIf��hWLSH9?�LO�UhW?BEGg�C�FGZ[LSIfh¢LSI�FG�V??BgOLSldTfFGZ[LSILON¢HnTfhGZdYBCOl�IVLOFGC�FGZ[LSI��$X,?JY\FGZdLSI���VEcCJ��h�hWLSH9?�Y\LSIfYBldTfhcZ[LSIfh�C��3LSTVF�Y\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[g.ZdhGH(pvCOIf��C��qLSTfFFG�V? LOE0Z[aSZdI�phWFWEcTDY\FGTVEG?OpfCOIf��hGFGTf�Vi LON�?JH9LOFGZdLSI�COIf��Y\LSIfhcYBZ[LSTfhGIV?JhchB�

£¢�f?�hWFGTf�Vi�LONHnTfhGZdY(Zdh¤TfhGTfCOlbl[i�FG�V?$hWFGTf�Vi�LONoEG?BAfEG?JhG?JI�FGC�FGZ[LSIDh�LONHnTfhGZdY�p�H9LShWFGl[i�hGY\LOEc?JhBp¢ZdI�N¥COY\FBpH9LShWFGldi�N�LOEcH�COlMAfEGLOA3?BEGFGZ[?Jh�LON�?JZ[aS��FW?B?JIKFG� COIf�!IDZdIV?BFW?B?JIKFG� Y\?JIKFGTVEGi�hGY\LOEc?Jh¤ZdI�FG�V?$^�TVEGLOA3?JCOI!YBldCOhchGZdYBCOlFWEcCO�fZdFGZ[LSI�����TVF�hGY\LOEc?Jh�C�EG? IfLOFH�TfhcZdY�p�COIf���DZ[aSZ[FGCOl�EG?JY\LOEc�DZdIVa(FW?JYc�DIVLSl[LOaOi�H�C��O?Jh�AqLShchGZ[�Dl[?�HnTfYc�5H9LOEG?�V?BFGCOZdld?J��EG?BAfEG?JhW?JIKFGC�FGZ[LSIfh¢LONvC9HnTfYc���fEGLSCO�V?BE¢E0COIVaO?�LONvhGFji.l[?JhBpfZdIfYBlbTf�fZdIVa�FG�VLShW?�N�LOE¢�M�fZbYc��hGY\LOEG?Jh��VL�IVLOF?\�VZdhWFMCOIf��=LOE��RLSTfld��IfLOFM�3?gO?BEGi��V?JldAfN�TDlU?BgO?JI�Z[NvFG�V?Bi��fZb�(?\�.ZbhWFB�)¨ML=��?BgO?BEJp3FG�fZbh¢hWFGZdldl~l[?JCJgO?Jh@TfhM�f?JCOldZdIVa�MZ[FG��EG?BAfEG?JhW?JIKFGC�FGZ[LSIfhJ�Qr�Y\FGTfCOlbl[iOp�¼Q�VL�IVLOF`FG�fZbIV�nZdF��V?JhGZdEcC��Dl[?)FWL��DCOIfZdhG��EG?BAfEG?JhW?JIKFGC�FGZ[LSIfhJ©KFG�V?�AfEGLO�Dld?JH Zdh�MZ[FG��FG�V? Â½LO�.�W?JY\FGZ[gO?JÃ�FG�fZ[Ec��A3?BEchWLSI C�AfAfEGLSCOY0� TfhGTDCOldl[i�FGC��O?JI¤FWL�Ec?BAfEG?JhW?JIKFGC�FGZ[LSIfhBpKEcC�FG�V?BEQFG�DCOI��MZ[FG��FG�V?JZ[E?\�VZdhWFW?JIfY\?@LOE�FG�V?JZ[E�TfhW?O���oTVE�AfEGLOA3LShW?J��COl[FW?BEcIfC�FGZdgO?@Zdh�FG�V?�½NmLSTfEGFG� A3?BEchGLSIfÃ�H9?BFG�fL,��hW�O?BFGY0�V?J�(ZdI�X.?JY\FGZ[LSI¾,�Á¾,pV�M�fZbYc��Ec?J�KTfZdEG?Jh ����������������� FWL��3?MFGC��O?JI(HnTfYc��H9LOEG?ohW?BEcZdLSTfhGl[iOp.ZdIfYBldTD�fZdIVa�Z[FGhRhWL.YBZdCOl3hGZ[FGTfC�FW?J�fIf?JhGhB��Æ�?�VL�FG�fZbh9IVLOF�LSIfl[i5FG�VEGLSTVaS�!YBl[LShW?�C�FWFW?JIKFGZ[LSI!FWL�LSTVE�EG?JhWA3LSIfhG?Jh�FWL�H�TDhGZdY�p`�UTVF�COldhWL�ZdI!X.?JY\FGZ[LSI�ÊV�Á¿,p��KiY\LSIfhWFWE0TfY\FGZdIVa���� �����!�¤LON)ldZdhWFW?JIDZdIVaVp~COIf��Y\LSH9ADC�EcZdIfa�FG�V?JZ[EEc?JhWA3LSIfhW?Jh��MZdFG��LSTVE�L=�MI�pv�MZ[FG��EG?JhcTfl[FGhoN�EGLSH?\�.Aq?BE0ZdH9?JIKFGCOl3ADhWi.Yc�VLSl[LOaOiOpUCOIf�(�MZ[FG��Ec?Jl[?Bg�COIKF¢AD�DZdl[LShWLOAD�DZdYBCOlUCOID��H�TDhGZdY\LSl[LOaSZdYBCOl�lbZ[FW?BEcC�FGTVEG?O�"$#&%('*)�+-,�.�/102.�34.�'6587¼`FG�DCOIV� >@E:9�?JI���LOaSZ3LON�X,LSIKi N�LOE¢�fZdhRhGTVaOaO?JhWFGZdLSI�FWL9�¢EcZ[FW?oTVA(H�i¤LO�DhW?BEGg�C�FGZ[LSIfhRLSI(HnTfhGZdYBCOl3�,TfCOldZdC.p.>@E;kLSl[�.H�C�E<9ldZ[?JI$COIf�-=`EGLONQ>oZ[?BFW?BE<9COTVN¥H�COIfI�LON`FG�V?>=v?BEGN�LOEcH�ZdIfa¤r�EGFGh�e@IfZ[gO?BE0hGZ[Fji(LON(;oZ[?JIfIDC.pqCOIf�-=QEGLON�¢LO�3?BEGF�£�EcC�AfADl`LON¢FG�V?�e�IfZdgO?BEchGZ[Fèi�LON:;@Zd?JIfIfC.pkN�LOE�FG�V?JZdEn�VLShGADZ[FGCOldZ[Fèi��fTVEcZbIVa�C�g,ZdhcZ[F�ZdI5�M�fZdY0��hWLSH�?�LONFG�V?JhW?�Zd�f?JCOh��R?BEG?�aSZ[gO?JI(ZbI AfEc?JldZdH�ZdIDC�EGi�N�LOEcH(p?=`EGLONv�$Z[FGhGT��@��CO�fCnNmLOE)ZdIKg.Z[FGZdIVanCnld?JY\FGTVEG?oLSI�FG�fZdh�hGTV�.�W?JY\FC�F@9�?JZ[L(e@IfZ[gO?BEchcZ[FjiOpA=`EGLON�h�>oCyg,Zd����LOEcaOL�COIf�$=QEGLONB�@?BLOEGaO?DC~?B�MZdh@LON�eoP¢XV>�p�COIf��>@Ech�^`EcZ[�$��i.ZdI�COIf�;kLSl[�.H�C�E�9ldZ[?JI�NmLOEng�COlbTfC��Dl[?�Y\LSH�H9?JIKFGhnCOID��?JIfY\LSTfEcC�aO?JH9?JIKFBp*=QEGLON¥h9P��fCJiSC�PR�B?BE0IVLy�MZbI�COIf��P��fZdIDC�EGie@IVa�LONqe�P¢X.>ºN�LOEkADTVFWFGZdIfaoTfA9�MZ[FG��CogO?BEGi�?JC�Ecl[i�gO?BEchGZ[LSI9ZdI�FG�f?JZ[EQYBldCOhGh�LSI�H�?BFGC�AD�VLOE`COIf�9HnTfhGZbY�p�COIf�9>@EESTDI$£vCOIfZ�LONQFG�V?���E0COZdI�XVYBZ[?JIfY\?n¼�IfhGFGZ[FGTVFW?(¹FESC�ADCOIU»¢N�LOEohGLSH9?nhGFGZdH�TDldC�FGZdIVa�Y\LSI�gO?BEchcC�FGZ[LSIfhoLSI��Vi,IDCOH�ZdYBCOlhWi.hWFW?JH�hoCOIf�$Y\LSIfhGYBZ[LSTfhcIV?JhGhB�GC~COhWF@�DTVF�N�C�E@NmEcLSH l[?JCOhGFBpU¼¢FG�DCOIV��H�i��MZ[N�?OpH�¢iOLO�OL(r@H�CO�V?B?��@LOaSTV?JI�p3N�LOE�V?BEM�f?Jl[A�ZdI�A3?BEGN�LOEcH�ZdIVanFG�fZdh�AUC�Aq?BEypfCOIf�(N�LOEMZdH�H9?BE0hGZdIVa�H9?ZdI(HnTfhGZdYBCOl8AfEGL��W?JY\FGhB�

I J�¯GKMLON4P9³RQc¯ Sq¯UT�P<V ¯UWYX ±ZSq³c²[VLSldldLy�MZdIfa�Cn�fE0Z[?BN8LygO?BEcg,Z[?B� LON�hWLSH9?�FWE0CO�fZ[FGZ[LSIfCOlUÆ�?JhWFW?BEcI�AD�fZdldLShWLOAD�fZdYBCOlfg,Z[?B��h�LON�HnTfhGZdY�pVhWLSH9?COldFW?BEcIfC��FGZ[gO?JhM�DCOhW?J�(LSI(Ec?JY\?JI�FM�f?BgO?Jl[LOADH9?JIKFGhMZdI(hGL,YBZ[LSldLOaOi�COIf��Y\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[gO?�hcYBZ[?JIfY\?�C�EG?�DZdhGYBTfhGhG?J���\^]�_ ` )63a.cbGd&ef/*gh58g�)2'1ef, ij.�7k58.ldm'onYg�.?+-7£¢�V?R?JC�EcldZd?JhWFvZbIV¦DTV?JIKFGZdCOlOg.Z[?B�MhvLSI�H�TDhGZdY`ZbI�FG�V?�Æ�?JhWFW?BE0I�FWEcCO�fZ[FGZ[LSInY\LSH9?�N�EGLSHp=Qi,FG�fC�aOLOEcCOhBpS���VL@YBlbCOZdH9?J�FG�fC�FQHnTfhGZdYRZdhv?JhGhW?JIKFGZdCOldldi�H�C�FG�V?JH�C�FGZbYBCOl�pS�DCOhW?J��LSI9�DZdh��fZdhGY\L=gO?BEGi�FG�DC�FvFG�f?)EcC�FGZ[LSh�LONDFG�f?)FWLSIV?JhkZdI�H�TDhGZdYBCOlZdIKFW?BEGg�COldh)C�EG?�hGZbH9ADl[?oEcC�FGZ[LSIDCOl�IKTfH��3?BEchB�Qr�FWFW?JH9ADFGh¢FWL Ec?J�fTfY\?HnTfhGZdY@FWL¤H C�FG�V?JH�C�FGZdYBh�C�EG?��Ki(IVL�H�?JCOIfhY\LSI?�DIf?J��FWL�COI�FGZd�,TfZ[FèiU©kN�LOEn?\�.COH9AUl[?Op�FG�V? aOEG?JC�F�Y\LSIKFW?JH9A3LOEcC�EGi�@Ec?B?B��Y\LSH9A3LShW?BErq`COIDIfZdh>s�?JIfC��.Zdh��fCOh�¢EcZdFWFW?JI¤?\�.FW?JIfhGZdgO?Jl[i�¹�FG�fLSTVaS�(IVLOF¢COl[��CJi.h¢Y\LS�V?BEG?JIKFGl[if»RZdI�FG�fZdh�H9L.�V?O�1�¢?BFGTfEcIfZdIVanFWL�COIKFGZd�KTDZ[FjiOpl=�ldC�FWLVpfZdI�fZdhut:�wv�xlyz�!�F{}|~��Ê8�Îp,�¢EGLOFW?@FG�fC�F�Â\�[�[�,HnTfhGZdYM?J�fTfYBC�FGZ[LSI�Zdh�LON�ADC�EcCOH9LSTDI�FRZdH9A3LOEGFGCOIfY\?O�Q��LOEG?�FG�DCOI�COIKi,FG�fZdIVa?JldhW?Op@Ec�KiKFG�DH COIf� H9?Jl[L.�Vi��DID� FG�f?JZ[E(�RCyi hWFWEcCOZ[aS�KF�FWL�FG�V?��V?B?BA3?JhWF�ADC�EGFGh�LONnLSTVE(�3?JZdIVaVpÅà �M�fZbYc� ZdhY\LSIfhGZbhWFW?JI�F��MZ[FG���M�DC�FH�COI�i�HnTfhGZdYBZbCOIfh�COIf��?J�fTDYBC�FGZ[LSIfCOlkADhGi,Y0�VLSl[LOaSZdhWFGh�FG�fZdIV�$FWL,�DCJiO���RTfFr=`ldC�FWL$COldhWLhW?B?JH�h�COldZdaSIV?J���MZdFG� H�COIKi�Y\LSI�FW?JH�AqLOE0C�EGi�A3LSldZ[FGZdYBCOlDY\LSIfhW?BEGg�C�FGZ[gO?JhBpVZdI �MZdhG�fZbIVa�FWL�ÂWYBld?JCOI¤LSTfE�EG?BAUTV�DldZdY�LON

¾

Page 3: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

�V?BAfE0CJg.Z[Fji | ZdI�FG�V?�C�EGFGh �v�[�[�,Y\LSIfIV?JY\FW?J���MZ[FG�9g.Tfl[aSC�E0Z[FjiOp.ZdIfhWLSld?JIfY\?Op�H�CO�fIf?JhGhBp�LOERLOFG�V?BER?Bg,ZbldhB�ÅÃ�£¢�,TfhBp�=�ldC�FWL��COhQIVLOFQCHnTfhGZdYBCOl =�ldC�FWLSIfZdhWFBp��q?JlbZ[?Bg,ZbIVaMFG�fC�F�H�TfhcZdYBCOl,LO�.�½?JY\FGh`?\�.ZbhWFQZdI�hWLSH9?MZb�V?JCOl,EG?JCOldH(p�ZbIf�V?BA3?JIf�V?JIKFGl[iLONk�KTDH�COIfhB©.LSI(FG�V?�Y\LSI�FWEcC�EciOpH=`lbC�FWLVÉÅh¢g.Z[?B� Zdh)N�L,YBTDhW?J��LSI�FG�V?H�LOEcCOl8Yc�DC�EcCOY\FW?BE�LONkHnTfhGZdYBZbCOIfhB�

r Y\LSH�H�LSI�g.Z[?B� �fTfEcZdIVa�FG�V?D�MLSH�COIKFGZdY�?BEcC��RCOh�FG�fC�F�aOL,L.��HnTfhGZdY�ZbhCOI�COYBYBTVE0C�FW?¤EG?BADEG?JhW?JIKFGC�FGZ[LSILON¢FG�V?�?JH9LOFGZdLSIfhnLON�Z[FGhnY\LSH9A3LShW?BEJ��r@l[FG�VLSTVaS��hWFGZdlbl`Y\LSH�H9LSI�COH�LSIVa�FG�V?¤aO?JIf?BEcCOlRADTV�DldZbY�p�FG�fZbh�g.Z[?B� ZdhEcC�EG?Jldi5COYBY\?BAfFW?J� �Ki�AfEGLON�?JhGhGZdLSIfCOldh � ��=v?BEc�fC�ADh9FG�f?(?JC�EcldZ[?JhWF9A3?BEchcTfCOhGZ[gO?(C�EGaSTfH�?JI�FGh¤C�aSCOZdIfhWF�Z[F�C�Ec?��fTV?FWL�FG�V?Z;oZ[?JIfIV?JhG?�Y\EcZ[FGZdY�^`�DTfC�Ec��¨�COIDhGldZdYc�| Êm� �Îp8���VL�COhGY\EcZ[�3?J��FG�V?9?JH9LOFGZdLSIfCOl�EG?JhWA3LSIfhW?JhoLON�ldZdhGFW?JIV?BEch@FWLCOIfCOl[LOaSZd?Jh��q?BFè��?B?JI��fi,IfCOH ZdY�ADC�FWFW?BE0Ifh�LON�HnTfhGZdY¤COIf��?JH9LOFGZ[LSIfhJ��>@?JhWADZ[FW?�FG�fZdh�C�AfADC�Ec?JI�FGl[i5Y\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[g.ZdhWFg.Z[?B�p�¨@COIfhGlbZdYG��hW?B?JH�h�FWL$�fCygO? �3?B?JI�C(�.ZdIf��LONB=`lbC�FWLSIfZdhWFBpvCOhGhW?BEGFGZdIfa�FG�fC�FFG�V? �q?JCOTfFji�LON)H�TfhcZdY�?\�.ZbhWFGhZdIf�f?BAq?JID�V?JI�FGldi�LON)COI�i�lbZdhWFW?JIV?BEJ��r@l[FG�VLSTVaS� } ?JldhGLSI�@L,L,�DH�COI�Zdh�COldhWL�ZbI�FW?BEG?JhGFW?J�5ZdI�H�TfhcZdYBCOlQADC�FWFW?BE0IfhBp�V?�Zd�V?JIKFGZ��f?JhC$H�TfhcZdYBCOlQ�RLOEG���MZ[FG�5Z[FGh�hGY\LOEc?¤COIf�5�MZ[FG��FG�f?¤YBldCOhGh�LON¢Z[FGh�COTfFG�V?JI�FGZbY�A3?BEGN�LOEcH�COIfY\?Jh | Ê�¿ �Î�Æ�?9C�EGaSTV?�C�aSCOZdIfhWF@FG�fZdh�ÂWhGY\LOEG?�IVLSH�ZbIfCOldZdhGH Ã9�Ki�IfLOFGZdIVa FG�DC�FohcY\LOEG?Jh@LONmFW?JI��VL�IVLOF@?\�.ZdhGFBpqCOIf�$N�LOEohGFji.l[?JhhGTfY0��COh�COH��DZd?JI�FoH�TDhGZdY�p3��LSTDld�$H C��O?�ldZ[FWFGl[?nhW?JIfhW?�?BgO?JI�Z[NkFG�V?Bi��fZd��?\�.ZdhGFB����LOEG?�EG?JY\?JIKF�FG�fZdIf�O?BEchBpq?O� aV�[p=v?BFW?BEr9Z[g,i |~�.À��Îp�FGC��O?�C(Y\LOaSIDZ[FGZ[g.ZdhWF�C�ADAfEGLSCOYc�8p~�V?z�DIfZbIVa¤HnTfhGZdYnZdI$FW?BEcH�hoLONRY\LSIfhGYBZ[LSTfh@ADC�FWFW?BE0Ifh�ZdI�FG�V?H�ZdID�fh@LONRldZbhWFW?JIV?BEchB�nr�ldFG�VLSTVaS��HnTfhGZdYnFG�V?BLOEGi�EcC�FG�V?BE�FG�fCOI�AD�fZdldLShWLOAD�KiOp3COID���¢EcZ[FWFW?JI��3?BN�LOEG?�FG�V?9EcZdhG?nLONY\LOaSIfZ[FGZdg,ZdhcH(p�FG�V?�ADZ[LSIV?B?BEcZbIVaM�RLOEG��LON�C8?BLSIfC�E0����?BiO?BEU|~�8� �.FGC��O?Jh�CoY\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[gO?)C�AfAfEcLSCOYc��p��f?z�DIfZdIVa@H�TDhGZdYBCOl?\�.Aq?BE0Z[?JIfY\?�ZbIfhWFW?JCO�¤LON~H�TDhGZdY�p.COIf��?JH9AD�fCOhGZd�JZdIVa�hWFWE0TfY\FGTVEG?Op.COI�FGZbYBZ[ADC�FGZ[LSI�p.COIf�¤?JH9LOFGZ[LSI�pVZdI �RCyi,h�Ec?JldC�FW?J�FWL�FG�VLShG?ZdI�X,?JY\FGZ[LSI(ÊV�Á¿9�q?JldLy��k¼½I�FW?BEc?JhWFGZdIVaSl[iOpf��?BiO?BEJÉÅh�FG�VEG?B?�fZdhGFGZdIVaSTfZdhc�fZdIVaY0�fC�EcCOY\FW?BEcZdhGFGZdYBh¢LON�H�TDhGZdYBCOl?\�.Aq?BE0Z[?JIfY\?�¹�LSI�ADC�aO? ¾O¿(LON<|~�8�8��»@�VL�IVLOFH9?JIKFGZ[LSI�hWLSTDIf��p8COIf��¹¥COhGhcTfH�ZdIVa�FG�V? LSH�ZdhGhGZdLSI�Zbh��V?JldZ[�3?BEcC�FW?=»C�EG?hWL�C��UhWFWEcCOY\FMCOh)FWL ?JIfY\LSH9ADCOhGhMhW?J�KTf?JIfY\?Jh)LON�IVLSI.�ÎEG?BN�?BEG?JIKFGZdCOl3g,ZbhGTfCOl3hWFGZdHnTfldZ�©,¼�ldZ[�O?oFG�fZdhBpVCOIf�(IfLOFW?�Z[FGhY\LSIfhGZbhWFW?JIfY\i��MZ[FG�(hWLSH9?�AqLShGFGH9L,�f?BEcI�g,Zd?B�Mh�FG�fC�FMHnTfhGZdY��DCOh¢COI�ZdIf�f?BEG?JI�F¢HnTfl[FGZbH9?J�fZdCnYc�fC�E0COY\FW?BEJ�

£¢�f?BL,�VLOE�r��VLOE0IVLY|¡À��`FGC��O?JhnC�IV?BL��è�$C�EW�VZdhWF�hGL,YBZdCOl`Y\EcZ[FGZdYBCOl�g.Z[?B� LON)HnTfhGZdY�p�NmL.YBTfhGZdIfa�LSI5Z[FGh�EGLSld?JhZdIY\LSIfhGTDH9?BEcZdhGH�p`YBldCOhGh9�fZ[Ëq?BEG?JIDY\?Op`?BFGY���>@?JhWADZ[FW?(FG�DZdhBpQLSIV?(LONo�fZdh�H9LOEc?(AD�fZdl[LShGLOAD�fZdYBCOl�hWFGC�FW?JH9?JIKFGhBp�FG�fC�FÂWHnTfhGZdY�ZdhoaO?JhWFGTfEG?OpÅÃ�?JH��fEcCOY\?Jh�C��DhWFWEcCOY\FGZ[LSI8p~COIf��H�COIKi$Ec?JY\?JI�FY\LSH9A3LShW?BE0hBp~ZdIfYBlbTf�fZdIVa ¼èaOLOEnX.FWEcCJg.ZdIfhW�,iOphGTVADAqLOEcF�hWFWEGLSIVaO?BEng.Z[?B�MhBpkZdI��M�fZdY0��HnTfhGZdY¤�fCOh�LSIDl[i�C��DhWFWEcCOY\F9HnTfhGZdYBCOl�Y\LSI�FW?JIKFB��X.TfY0��g.Z[?B�Mh�EG?JhW?JH��Dl[?FG�VLShW?RLONDH9L.�V?BEcIDZdhWF~H9L=gO?JH9?JIKFGhQhGTfY0��COh�l[LOaSZdYBCOl,A3LShGZ[FGZdg,ZdhcH(pJ�M�fZbYc�nC�FWFW?JH9AfFGhvFWLoEG?J�fTfY\?�COldl~ÂWH�?JCOIfZdIVaON¥TfldÃZdIVN�LOEcH�C�FGZdLSI$FWL$C��DhWFWEcCOY\F�ldLOaSZdY�p~COh��R?JldlkCOh��Z[FG��ADhWi.Yc�VLSl[LOaSZbYBCOlk�3?J�fCJg.Z[LOEcZdhcH(p�COIf���MZ[FG� ½?JldZbH�ZdIfZ[FGZdg,ZdhGFGÃFWEG?JIf�Dh8�M�fZbYc��C�FWFW?JH�AfF�FWL@�V?Jld?BFW?�COldlKH9?JI�FGZdLSI�LONfY\LSIfhcYBZ[LSTfhGIV?JhchR¹¥hW?B?¢X,?JY\FGZ[LSI�¿)�3?Jl[L=�@»0�k��L.�V?BEcIfZbhWF~r@IVaSl[L��r@H9?BEcZdYBCOI�COIDCOl[iKFGZbY�AU�fZdl[LShWLOAU��i�ZbI�aO?JIV?BEcCOlf�VL=�MIVADlbCJi.h�LOE`Z[aSIVLOEG?JhQFG�V?¢�KTDCOldZ[FGC�FGZ[gO?¢COhWA3?JY\FGhkLONq?\�.Aq?BE0Z[?JIfY\?Op�V?JhWAUZ[FW?�hWFWEcLSIVa�?\�.A3?BEcZdH9?JIKFGCOlf?Bg.Zd�V?JIDY\?�LON~ZdFGh�ZdH�AqLOEcFGCOIfY\?Op�?O� aV�[pVN�LOERH�LOFGZ[g�C�FGZdLSI�COID� EG?JYBCOlbl |¡À��k�Î��X.?JY\FGZ[LSI¿,�dÀM�DZdhGYBTfhGhG?JhQhWLSH9?MZb�V?JCOhQN�EGLSH_AD�f?JIVLSH9?JIVLSl[LOaOiOp.COI C�ADAfEGLSCOYc� FG�fC�F`FGC��O?JhRY\LSIfhGYBZdLSTfhGIV?JhGh�COh`Y\?JIKFWEcCOl�p.COIf�X,?JY\FGZ[LSI-�9ZdIfYBldTD�V?Jh�C�Y\EcZ[FGZd�,TV?oLON�Y\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[g.ZdhGH(�

Æ �fC�F�hW?B?JH�h�YBl[?JC�E�NmEcLSH COldlUFG�fZdh�Zdh�FG�fC�FRHnTfhGZbYMZdh�LSIV?@LON�FG�V?@ld?JCOhWFRhG?BFWFGl[?J��C�EG?JCOhRLON8AD�fZdldLShWLOAD�KiO�vr@If�LON~Y\LSTVE0hW?�Æ�?JhGFW?BEcI�g,Zd?B�Mh�C�EG?@IfLOF�FG�V?oLSIfldi9LSIV?Jh�CJg�COZdldC��Dl[?O©V�V?B?BA�COIf��ZdIKFW?BEG?JhWFGZdIfa�Zd�V?JCOh�YBCOI��3?MN�LSTfIf��ZdIH�COIKi�IfLSI.�ÎÆ�?JhWFW?BEcI�FWEcCO�fZ[FGZ[LSIDhBp8ZdIfYBldTD�fZdIVa¤FG�VLShW?�LON¢P��fZdIDC.p2ESC�ADCOI�p�COIf����COldZ�����LOEG?BLygO?BEJp�?BgO?JI���Z[FG�fZdIFG�V?oÆ�?JhWFW?BEcI�FWE0CO�fZ[FGZ[LSI�p.HnTfYc��LON~g�COldTV?oYBCOI��3?@l[?JC�E0IV?J��NmEGLSH'hGTDYc��LONmFW?JI(ZdaSIVLOEG?J�¤aO?JIVEG?Jh)COh)CJg�COIKF)aSC�Ec�V?�GC��B�OpU>@?Jl[FGC9�DlbTV?JhBpV�fZ[AV�j�fLOA8pKN�LSl[��H�TDhGZdY�pVaOLShWA3?Jl�pfCOIf���V?JCJg,i(H9?BFGCOl�EGL.YG�q�\^]�\ � )2'658.��^5�� ` gF5�1e�58.�/ '1.�7 7�ue ' /���3� B)(/*gw3a.H'25£�EcCO�fZ[FGZ[LSIDCOl�AU�fZdl[LShWLOAU�fZdYBCOl`C�ADAfEGLSCOYc�f?Jh�ldZ[�O?�FG�VLShW?��fZbhGYBTfhGhW?J��ZdI�FG�V?(ADEG?Bg,ZdLSTfh�hGTV�DhW?JY\FGZdLSI5FW?JID��FWL��V?\�Y\LSIKFW?\�,FGTfCOlbZ[�B?nHnTfhGZbY���r_Y\LSH H9LSI$C�ADAfEGLSCOYc��ZdhMFWL�Zd�f?JI�FGZ[N�i�C HnTfhGZdYBCOl~LO�.�½?JY\F@�MZ[FG��hWLSH9?nADTVEG?Jl[i�N�LOEcH�COl?JIKFGZ[FjiOp��M�fZdY0� IV?JY\?JhchGC�EcZdl[i�LSH�ZdFGh¤COIº?JIVLOEcH�LSTfh¤COH�LSTfI�F�LONEG?Jld?Bg�COIKF�ZbIVNmLOE0H�C�FGZ[LSI�� [fLOE�?\�VCOH9ADld?OpMIVLFWEcCOIfhcY\EcZ[AfFGZ[LSI8p`IVLOF9?BgO?JI!C�hWA3?JY\FWEcCOl)COIfCOl[i.hGZdhBp�l[?BF�COl[LSIV?�C�hcY\LOEG?Op)YBCOI�YBC�AfFGTVEG?�COlbl�FG�V?�I,TfCOIfY\?Jh9LONoCOICOY\FGTfCOl�A3?BEGN�LOEcH�COIfY\?Op����fZdYc�$�MZdlbl~ZdIfYBlbTf�V?�AUC�EGFGZdYBTfldC�EoH9?J�fZbC�FGZ[LSIfh@�Ki$ADC�EGFGZdYBTDldC�E@HnTfhGZbYBZdCOIfhBp3H�TDhGZdYBCOl�ZdI.�hWFWEcTDH9?JI�FGhJp�lbZdhWFW?JIV?BEchJp�COID��EGL,LSH�hB��£¢�V?¤AD�fZdl[LShGLOAD�fZdYBCOlk?BEcEGLOE�FG�DC�FnTfID�V?BEcldZ[?Jh�hGTfYc��H�ZdhGFGC��O?Jh�Ec?JhW?JH��Ul[?Jh��� нÚ�Ó�×cØjß��@Ð�êBÐ�Ø�� �����UÑ�Õ=Ô�Ô0нѥÜÎÑkÜÎÏ�×cÜvÜÎÏ�ÒÅÑ�ÒÅÑQÒÁÓ�Ý�×GØ�ÜQéOнåW×cÕ�Ñ�Ð�нÛ)ÚcÜÎÒÅÚ�Ó�×cÖVØÎнÑ�ÝOÚ�Ó=Ñ�нÑkÚ0Ù ÜÎнÓnéOнå�Ú�Û)Ð)ßyнÓ�×GÜÎÕ=ØÎÐWßoÜÎÏ=ØÎÚ0Õ�Ô0ÏÒÅÓBÜÎнÖÅÖÁÐ�å�ÜÎÕ�×cÖ.×0Ó�×0Ö êyÑ�ÒÅÑv×cÓ�ß�ÝyØÎÚ0ÙçнÑ�Ñ�ÒÅÚ�Ó�×cÖ,Ü�Øj×0ÒÅÓ=ÒÁÓ=Ô=â

¿

Page 4: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

FG�fC�F�LON8H�C�FG�V?JH�C�FGZdYBCOl�=`lbC�FWLSIfZdhGH(p,ZdI9�M�DZdYc�¤CFWEcCOIfhcY\?JIf�V?JIKFGCOlDLSIKFWLSl[LOaSZdYBCOlqhWFGC�FGTfhRZdh`YBlbCOZdH9?J��N�LOE�H C�FG�V?\�H�C�FGZdYBCOlfLO�.�½?JY\FGhJ�`��LOEG?BL=gO?BEJpVCOI�?JH9AU�fCOhGZdh�LSI9N�LOEcH�COlDIVLOFGC�FGZ[LSI If?JY\?JhGhGC�EcZdldin�VL=�MIVaOEcCO�f?JhkFWEcCO�fZ[FGZdLSIfhBpShGTfY0�COhMY\LSIKFW?JH9A3LOEcC�EGi��GC��B�OpUZdI��M�DZdYc�(ZdH�AfEGLyg.ZdhGC�FGZdLSI(�fCOh)aOEG?JC�FMZbH9A3LOEGFGCOIfY\?O�

�oIf?�C�AfAfEGLSCOY0��FWL�CJgOLSZd�DZdIVa�hGTfY0��AfEGLO�Ul[?JH�hoZdhoFWL(EG?JZ[N�i�FG�f?�IVLOFGZ[LSI�LON�Y\LSI�FW?\�.FB� ��TVF�EG?JhG?JC�EcYc�V?BE0hZdI�M�fC�F~��?RH�CJiYBCOldl�AD�V?JIVLSH�?JIVLSl[LOaSZdYBCOlKhWL,YBZdLSl[LOaOiOp�NmLOE�?\�.COH9AUl[?Op�ZbI�?BFG�fIVLSH9?BFG�fL,�VLSldLOaOiD|~���.p�¾�� �Îp�?JH9AD�DCOhGZ[�B?FG�fC�F�Y\LSI�FW?\�.FQZdh��Vi,IDCOH�ZdYBCOldl[io?JH9?BEcaO?JI�FvNmEcLSH COY\FGZ[g.Z[FèiOpSEcC�FG�V?BEvFG�fCOI>�V�,?J�8p��f?z�DIfC��Dl[?�ZdI�CO�Vg�COIfY\?OpON�LOEcH�COldldiEG?BAfEc?JhW?JI�FGC��Ul[?Op�LOE`hG?BADC�EcC��Dl[?)N�EGLSH COY\FGZdg,Z[FèiO�Q£¢�,TfhkLSIV?Mhc�VLSTfld�9hWA3?JC��nLON � � � x��&��� ���&{ � � � �l�0p,LOEG� { {�� ��� � �l�}����&{ � � � �DpUEcC�FG�f?BEMFG�fCOI�LON {R� ������&� x� �����k� �� � v� ���z�z�����8� �F� �?�0p��3?JYBCOTfhG?�IV?JZ[FG�V?BE@hGZ[FGTfC�FGZdLSIfh¢IVLOE�FG�V?JZ[EMY\LSIKFW?\�,FGhC�EG?�hWA3?JYBZ��UC��Dl[?OpkEG?BAfEc?JhW?JI�FGC��Ul[?Op�hWFGC��Ul[?OpQLOE hW?BAUC�EcC��Dl[?�N�EGLSH FG�V?JZ[E9COY\FGTfCOl¢TDhW?JhB�c[VLOE�?\�VCOH9ADl[?Op��M�V?JI�CY\LSIKFW?JH9A3LOEcC�EGi(Y\LSH9A3LShW?BE�lbZ[�O?£~LOE0T�£�C��O?JH Z[FGhGT��,TVLOFW?Jh�>�?B�UTfhGhWiOpf?BgO?JI$Z[N�hWLSH9?�H9?JCOhcTVEG?JhMC�Ec?�Zd�V?JIKFGZdYBCOl�pFG�V?¤?\Ëq?JY\F9Zdh�EcCO�fZdYBCOldldi��fZ[Ëq?BEG?JIKFN�EGLSH FG�V? LOEcZdaSZdIfCOl�©kCOIf�5hGZdH�ZdlbC�Ecl[i��M�f?JI�¨@COIfh�Æ�?BE0IV?BE9¨M?JIV�B?��KTfLOFW?JhP�TV�UCOI�N�LSl[�(hWLSIVaSh@LOEo��LSIKFW?BgO?BEc�fZ��@^QgO?JI�ZdI�C���LO�JC�EcF@AUZdCOIVL hWLSIDC�FGC.pqFG�f?nhW?JY\LSID��?JIKFWEcCOIfY\?nLON`C¤FG�V?JH9?YBCOI��DCJgO?�C9gO?BEci��DZ¡Ëq?BEc?JI�F)?\Ë3?JY\FMN�EGLSH'FG�V?@�DEchWFB�

=�COTfl�>@LSTVEcZdhc�a| ¾O¿ ��aSZ[gO?Jh�COI�ZdIfhGZdaS��FWN¥TflQ�fZbhGYBTfhGhGZdLSI�LONMY\LSIKFW?\�,F�ZbI5Y\LSIfIf?JY\FGZ[LSI��MZ[FG��YBTVEGEG?JIKF�FWEc?JIf�fhFWLy��C�Ec�fh�TV�DZd�,TfZ[FWLSTDhMLOE�ÂWY\LSIKFW?\�.F�CJ��C�EG?JÃ$Y\LSH9ADTVFGZdIfaV©~FG�V?9AfEcLO�Dl[?JH"CO�f�VEc?JhGhW?J���,i$FG�fZbhU�D?Jld��Zdh��VL=� FWLTfhW?�A3Ly�R?BEGN¥Tfl�If?B� hW?JIDhWLOE�FW?JYc�fIVLSldLOaSZ[?Jh�FWL�H�C��O?�Y\LSH9ADTVFGC�FGZ[LSIDCOl@hGi,hWFW?JH h(H9LOEG?�EG?JhWA3LSIfhGZ[gO?$FWL�FG�V?JZ[ETfhW?BE0hBÉ�AD�Ki,hGZbYBCOlQCOIf��hWL.YBZdCOl�hW?BFWFGZdIVaShBpvCOh�FG�fLShW? TfhW?BE0hH9LygO?�FG�VEGLSTfaS��COIf��H9L.�fZ[N�i�FG�V?JhW? hW?BFWFGZbIVaShB��£¢�fZdh�fCOh@FGTVEcIf?J��LSTVF@FWL��q?�TfIV?\�.A3?JY\FW?J�fl[i(�fZ[§¤YBTfl[FBpUCOID��>@LSTVE0ZdhG��YBlbCOZdH�h�FG�fZdh@ZdhM?JhchW?JI�FGZbCOldl[i(N�LOE@Ec?JCOhWLSIfholdZ[�O?FG�VLShW?��V?JhGY\EcZ[�3?J��C��3LygO?O�

�$TfhGZdYBCOlB=�ldC�FWLSIfZdhcH(p�hGY\LOEc?�IVLSH�ZdIfCOlbZdhGH(pQY\LOaSIfZdFGZ[g,ZbhGH(p`COIf�!H9L,�f?BEcIfZdhWF�C�AfAfEcLSCOYc�V?Jh¤ZdI�aO?JIV?BEcCOl�p�COldlCOhGhGTDH9?¢FG�V?�AfEcZdH�COY\i�LON3EG?BAfEc?JhW?JI�FGC�FGZdLSI�p,COID� �V?JIfY\?@COldlV¦fLSTDIf�V?BEQN�LOE�hGZbH�ZdldC�EkEG?JCOhGLSIfhB��PRLSIKFW?\�,F�ZdhQY\E0TfYBZdCOlFWL(ZdIKFW?BEGAfEG?BFGC�FGZ[LSI8p��DTVFoZ[F@Zbh��V?BFW?BE0H�ZdIV?J��COhoADC�EGF@LON`FG�f?nADEGL,Y\?Jhch�LONRZdIKFW?BEGAfEG?BFGC�FGZ[LSI8p3IfLOFoZbIf�V?BA3?JIf�V?JIKFGl[iLOE�ZdI�CO�fg�COIfY\? LON�ZdFB�¤PR?BEGFGCOZdI�?Jl[?JH�?JI�FGh�C�EG?�EG?JY\LOaSIfZd�B?J��COhFG�V?�Y\LSIKFW?\�.F�LON��M�fC�FZdho�3?JZdIfa�ZbI�FW?BEGADEG?BFW?J��p�M�fZbl[?�LOFG�V?BE0h(�3?JY\LSH9?�ADC�EGF�LON�FG�f?�?JH9?BEGaO?JIKF�H�TfhcZdYBCOl(½LO�.�W?JY\FGÃ�Z[FGhW?Jl[N�p�COID� hWFGZdldl�LOFG�V?BEch(C�EG?��f?B?JH9?J�Z[EGEc?Jl[?Bg�COIKFB�)��LOEG?BL=gO?BEJp3FG�V??Jl[?JH�?JI�FGh@ZdIKgOLSl[gO?J��COIf��FG�V?JZ[EMhGFGC�FGTfh�YBCOI�Yc�DCOIVaO?�gO?BEGi(E0C�ADZd�fl[iO��£¢�KTDhBpf?BgO?BEGiA3?BEGN�LOEcH�COIfY\?�Zdh¢TDIfZd�,TV?Jl[i�hGZ[FGTDC�FW?J��pVNmLOEM�qLOFG��A3?BEGN�LOEcH9?BE0h)COIf�(ldZdhWFW?JIf?BEchBpVZdI��M�fC�F¢H CJi��3?@gO?BEci��fZ[Ëq?BEG?JIKF��CJi.hB�5¼½I�ADC�EGFGZbYBTfldC�EJpk?BgO?BEGi�A3?BEGN�LOEcH�COIfY\?�Zdh���� t����v· � � p�ZdI�FG�V?(hW?JIfhW?(FG�fC�F�gO?BEGi�ADC�EGFGZbYBTfldC�E9COhWA3?JY\FGhLONR?JCOYc�5ADC�EGFGZdYBZ[AUCOI�F�C�EG?��V?B?BAUl[i�ZbH9ADldZdYBC�FW?J��ZdI�FG�f?9AfEGL.Y\?JhGhW?Jh�LON�ZdIKFW?BEGAfEG?BFGC�FGZ[LSI8p8A3LOFW?JI�FGZdCOlbl[i$ZdIDYBldTf�fZdIfaFG�V?JZ[E)COTf�DZ[FWLOEGi YBC�ADC��UZdldZ[FGZ[?JhJpKYBl[LOFG�fZbIVaVpVY\LSH9ADCOIfZ[LSIDhBp,HnTfhGZbYBCOlqhG�,ZdlbldhBpSAfE0Z[LOE)H�TfhcZdYBCOlD?\�.A3?BEcZ[?JIfY\?JhJp.ZbH9ADldZdYBZdFhWL.YBZdCOlv�3?JldZ[?BN¥hn¹�?O� aV�[p�FG�fC�F�LOA3?BEcC¤Zbh@�DZ[aS��hWFGC�FGTfhBp8LOE�FG�DC�F@AUTfIV��Y0�fCOldl[?JIVaO?Jh�H COZdIfhWFWEG?JCOH g�COldTV?Jh0»0p8hGADC�FGZdCOll[L.YBC�FGZ[LSI�pk?BFGY��[pRCOIf��Y\?BEGFGCOZdIfl[i�IfLOFn?\�VYBldTf�DZdIVa�FG�V?JZdEnEc?JCOhWLSIfhnNmLOE��3?JZdIVa$FG�V?BEG?�C�F9COldl�¹�FG�fZdhnZdh�Y\LSIfhGZdhWFW?JIKF�MZ[FG�$FG�V?�YBTfl[FGTVE0COl��fZbhWFWLOEcZdYBCOl�C�AfAfEGLSCOY0��LON*C8?Bg-;�i,aOLOFGhW�,i| � �k��»0����LOEG?�FG�fCOI�FG�fC�FBp�ADC�EGFGZbYBZ[ADCOIKFGh���� zD{Ow pLOE�COY\FGZ[gO?Jl[i�Y\LSIfhWFWE0TfY\FBp)FG�V?$Y\LSIKFW?\�.F¤LONHnTfhGZdYBCOl¢?\�,A3?BEcZ[?JIDY\?Op�hGLSH9?BFGZdH9?Jh��KTDZ[FW?�g.ZdhGZ[�Dldi5hWLVp)COh�ZdI�EGL.YG�Y\LSIfY\?BEGFGh)COID�¤��C�EcC�LO�O?oADC�EGFGZd?JhBp.?O� aV�[pV�MZ[FG��hG�VLSTVFGh�LON8?JIfY\LSTVE0C�aO?JH9?JI�F)LOE)�fZbhWADC�EcC�aO?JH9?JIKFB�Q>oCJg.Zd��X.Tf�fIfLy�aSZ[gO?Jh)COI�ZdIfhcZ[aS��FWN¥TflV?BFG�DIVLSH9?BFG�VL.�VLSl[LOaSZdYBCOl3�V?JhcY\EcZ[AfFGZ[LSI¤LON~l[?JC�E0IfZdIVa�FWLnAUldCJio�GC��B�oADZdCOIVLVp,?JH9AD�DCOhGZ[�JZdIVa�FG�V?EGLSl[?�LON�FG�V?��3L.�Vi�¹¥�f?JIfY\?�Z[FGh)FGZdFGl[?Op������ �>���r� �?�"!#� ����| �%$ ��»0�

��LShWF`hGYBZd?JI�FGZ��UYRhGFGTf�fZ[?Jh�LON3C�EGFQC�EG?¢ADEGLO�Dl[?JH�C�FGZbY�N�LOEQhGZdH ZdldC�E�EG?JCOhWLSIfhJ�v¼½I�ADC�EGFGZbYBTfldC�EJpOFG�V?)FG�DZ[Ec�nA3?BEchWLSI�pLO�.�W?JY\FGZ[gO?�A3?BEchWA3?JY\FGZ[gO?�LON�hcYBZ[?JIfY\?�EG?J�,TfZ[EG?Jh�C�hWFGC��Dld?�Y\LSlbl[?JY\FGZ[LSIºLON�½LO�V�½?JY\FGhGÃ�FWL��q?�TfhW?J� COh�ÂW�DC�FGC.pÅÃ�M�fZbYc��FG�f?BEG?BNmLOEc?��3?JY\LSH9?��V?JY\LSI�FW?\�.FGTfCOldZd�B?J��p¢�MZ[FG�!FG�V?JZ[E�hGZ[FGTfC�FW?J�fIf?JhGhBp�?JH��3L.�fZdH9?JIKFBp¢COIf� ZdI�FW?BE0COY\FGZ[gO?hWL.YBZdCOlRIfC�FGTVEG?�Z[aSIVLOEG?J������LOEG?BL=gO?BEJp`COIKi�Yc�fLSZdY\?¤LON�C �V�.?J�5�DC�FGCOhW?BF9IV?JY\?JhGhGC�EcZbl[i�H�C��O?Jh�hWLSH9?�C�EG�DZ[FWEcC�EciAfEG?JhcTVAfA3LShGZ[FGZ[LSIDhQC��3LSTVF�FG�f?oIDC�FGTVEG?@LON~�M�fC�F)ZdhRCOIfCOl[i,�B?J���1[VLOEM?\�.COH9AUl[?Op.Fji,ADZdYBCOlqFW?\�,FW�3L,LO�,h�LSI��fC�E0H9LSI�i�V?JCOl.?\�VYBldTfhGZdgO?Jl[i��MZdFG��FWE0CO�fZ[FGZ[LSIfCOl.Æ�?JhGFW?BEcI�YBldCOhGhcZdYBCOlVH�TDhGZdY�pS?O� aV�[p | ¾ �Îp�COh`�fL@FèiKAUZdYBCOlfC�EGFGZ��UYBZdCOl.ZdI�FW?JlbldZ[aO?JIfY\?AfEGL��W?JY\FGhBp.?O� aV�[p��@?BE0�fC�Ec�¤ÆºZd�DH9?BE@| ��� �8TfhW?Jh�?Jl[?JY\FWEGLSIfZdY@FWEcCOIDhGY\EcZ[AfFGZdLSIfhQLON�Aq?BEcNmLOEcH COIfY\?Jh`LON���LO�JC�EcF)ADZdCOIVLhWLSIfC�FGCOh(COh��fC�FGC.�_¼½I FG�V?$g.ZdhGTDCOl�C�EGFGhJpU�MCOH COYc�fCOIf�fEcCOI COIf� ¨@Z[EchGFW?JZdIo|~�8�8�oTfhG?$LOAfFGZbYBCOl�ZdlbldTfhGZ[LSIDh�COIf�YBldCOhGhcZdYBCOl~¼½If�fZbCOI�?BEGLOFGZdYnC�EGFoCOho�fC�FGC.p��M�fZdld?'&q?B�.Z�TfhG?Jh�H�COZbIfl[i��¢?JIfCOZbhGhGCOIfY\?�COIf�$?JC�Ecl[i�H9L.�V?BEcI$C�EGF�|(�O¾ �ÎpCOIf��£vCJi.l[LOEkYBldCOhGhGZ��D?Jh~FG�V?)�VE0Z[A�C�EGF�LONHE�COYG�.hWLSI�=vLSldl[L.YG�nTfhGZdIVaMNmEcCOY\FGCOlV�DZdH9?JIfhGZdLSI | ��¾ �Î��r�ldFG�VLSTVaS��Y\?BEGFGCOZdIfldig�COldTfC��Dl[?nZdI�FG�f?JZ[EoLy�MI��VLSH�COZbIfhBpDLSIf?�hc�VLSTfld���q?nYBCOTVFGZ[LSTfhoC��3LSTVF@aO?JIV?BEcCOldZd�JZdIVa�FG�V?9Y\LSIfYBlbTfhGZ[LSIfhMLON`hGTfY0�hWFGTf�DZ[?JhBpfADC�EcFGZdYBTfldC�Ecldi N�LOE�Y\LSIKFW?JH9A3LOEcC�EGi�C�EGFBpqC H�C=�WLOE�FG�f?JH9?LONk�M�fZbYc���fCOh��3?B?JI(FWL¤�,TV?JhWFGZdLSI��M�fC�F@C�EGF

Ê

Page 5: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

ZdhBpfCOID��FWL ?\�.ADl[LOEG?�Z[FGh)�3LSTfID�fC�EcZ[?Jh}| ¿8� �Î�£¢�DZdh¢ADC�A3?BEo�VEcCy�MhMLSI��fC�FGC�N�EGLSH �qLOFG��hGYBZ[?JIDY\?nCOIf�$AD�V?JIfLSH9?JIVLSl[LOaOiOp�ZdI�C¤hGADZ[EcZ[F�hGZdH�ZdlbC�E¢FG�V?�ÂWIV?JT.�

EGLOAD�f?JIVLSH9?JIVLSl[LOaOi.Ã�LON�[VEcCOIfYBZbhGY\L<;QC�EG?JldC�| �=Ê8�ÎpSCOh�C@�RCyi�FWL@EG?JY\LSIfYBZdl[? �fEchGF�COIf�nFG�fZ[E0�A3?BEchWLSI�A3?BEchWA3?JY\FGZ[gO?JhBp�,i�COldl[Ly��ZdIVa�?JCOYc��FWL�ZdH9A3LShW?¢Y\LSIfhGFWEcCOZdIKFGh�TVA3LSI9FG�f?MLOFG�V?BEJ��XVTfYc�¤C�AfAfEGLSCOY0�V?Jh�COYc�,IfLy�Ml[?J�faO?�FG�fC�FRFG�V?U�fEchWFCOIf��FG�fZ[E0��A3?BEchWLSI$A3?BEchWA3?JY\FGZ[gO?Jh�EG?BgO?JCOl�Fj�RL(gO?BEGi��fZ¡Ë3?BEG?JI�Fo�VLSH�COZbIfhBp�IV?JZ[FG�V?BE@LON`���fZdYc��YBCOI��3?�Ec?J�fTfY\?J�FWL�FG�V?(LOFG�f?BEJp��DTVF�FG�V?Bi�COldhWL��V?JIKi�FG�fC�F�FG�V?JhW?��fLSH�COZdIfh9C�EG?$ZdIfY\LSH9ADC�FGZd�Dl[?O��¼èF Zbh9ZdH9A3LOEGFGCOIKFnFWL5IVLOFW?FG�fC�FAU�V?JIVLSH9?JIVLSldLOaOi�Zdh��H�8��H9?BEG?Jldi$C�H9LOEc? �fZdhGYBZdADldZdIV?J��NmLOE0H"LON)ZdI�FWEcLShWA3?JY\FGZ[LSI�p8�DTfF�EcC�FG�V?BE�C�FWFW?JH9ADFGhFWL�?JID�fCOIfY\?$hG?JIfhGZ[FGZ[g.Z[Fèi5FWL5LOEc�fZdIfC�Eci�?\�.Aq?BE0Z[?JIfY\?Op��MZ[FG�VLSTfF �fZdhWFWLOEcFGZ[LSI�YBCOTfhW?J�!�Ki�hW?BAUC�EcC�FGZ[LSI NmEGLSH�Z[FGhIfC�FGTVE0COl`Y\LSIKFW?\�,F��S��£M�V? C�AfAfEcLSCOYc�5LON)FG�fZdhAUC�Aq?BE�aOLK?Jhn�3?BiOLSIf��FG�DC�F�LONB;QC�EG?JldC$ZdI�FG�f? N�LSldl[Ly��ZdIVa(��CJi.h��¹½Ày»MZ[F�CO�fH Z[FGh�IfLOFk�GTfhWF�If?JTVEGLShGYBZ[?JIDY\?OpU�DTfFMCOldhWL�FG�V?�FG�DZ[Ec�(A3?BEchWLSI$A3?BEchWA3?JY\FGZ[gO?JhMLONkLOFG�V?BE�hGYBZ[?JIfY\?JhBpq?JhWA3?\�YBZdCOldldi�?BgOLSlbTVFGZ[LSI�pQCOhn�R?Jldl�COhnLONMY\E0Z[FGZdYBCOlRhWFGTf�fZ[?Jh�ZdI5FG�V?�C�EcFGhnCOID���,TfH�COIDZ[FGZ[?JhB©M¹�¾S»�Z[F�FGC��O?Jh9COYBY\LSTfI�F9LONFG�V?�ÂWhW?JY\LSIf��Aq?BE0hWLSIfäAq?BE0hWA3?JY\FGZ[gO?�LON�hWL.YBZ[?BFjiOp�ZdI�FG�V?9hWFji.l[?9ZdldldTDhWFWEcC�FW?J�$�Ki�X,?JY\FGZ[LSI��,©�COID��¹�¿S»@ZdF@AUldCOY\?JhaOEG?JC�FW?BE�?JH9AD�fCOhGZbh�LSI�FG�V?9ldZ[gO?J��?\�.Aq?BE0Z[?JIfY\?9COIf��A3?BEchWLSIfCOlvFWEcCOIDhWNmLOE0H�C�FGZ[LSI�LON�hGYBZ[?JIKFGZdhWFGhBp�FW?JY0�fIVLSl[LOaSZdhGFGhBpY\EcZ[FGZbYBhBpf?BFGY�������£¢�V?�ZdIKFW?JIKFGZ[LSI�LON�FG�fZdhMC�AfAfEGLSCOY0��ZdhMFWL CO�Vg�COIfY\?�hGYBZd?JI�FGZ��UY��,IfLy�Ml[?J�faO?OpfFW?JYc�fIDZdYBCOl8AfE0COY\FGZdY\?OpA3?BEchWLSIfCOl�Cy�RC�Ec?JIV?JhGhBp3COIf�(FG�V?��V?JCOl[FG�(LONkhWL.YBZ[?BFjiO�R¼�AfEGLOA3LShW?�FWL YBCOlbl8Z[F¢FG�V?�� � µ x=w�� � x�u � � � � w�� ��� LOE � x=u � {Sw=·�� �UpfhGZdIfY\?oZ[FR?JIfY\LSH9ADCOhGhG?Jh�FG�V?<�fEchWFBp.hW?JY\LSIf��pfCOID�¤FG�DZ[Ec��A3?BEchGLSI¤A3?BEchGAq?JY\FGZdgO?JhBp,COID�¤�3?JYBCOTfhG?@LONCOI�COIfCOl[LOaOi��MZdFG��FG�V?�½NmLSTVEcFG�¤H9LSH�?JI�FBpÅÃ��M�DZdYc�¤Zdh`�V?JhcY\EcZ[�3?J��C�FRFG�V?�?JID��LONvX,?JY\FGZdLSI �,�Q£¢�DZdhkADC�A3?BE�ZdldldTfhW�FWEcC�FW?JhMFG�V?C�AfADldZbYBC�FGZ[LSI�LON�FG�fZbh)C�AfAfEGLSCOY0�(FWL�H�TDhGZdY�pfZdI��M�fZbYc�(COldl3FG�VEc?B?�Aq?BE0hWA3?JY\FGZ[gO?Jh�ADldCyi¤COI�ZdH�AqLOEcFGCOI�FEGLSl[?O��¼�FRhG?B?JH�hRFWL�H�?MFG�fC�F)hGTfY0�¤COI�C�AfADEGLSCOYc��Zdh��KTfZdFW?�IfC�FGTVE0COl�p,hcZdIfY\?�ZdF�Zdh��M�fC�F�H�COIKi9LON~TfhR�VLnCOIKi,�RCyiOpCOIf�(�V?JIDY\?Z[F)�VLK?JhMIVLOF)EG?J�,TfZ[EG?oCOI�i�?JldC��3LOEcC�FW?H9?BFG�fL,�VLSldLOaSZdYBCOlK�WTDhWFGZ��DYBC�FGZ[LSI8��¨�Ly�R?BgO?BEJpqFG�V?oN�COY\FMFG�fC�F¢Z[FYc�DCOldl[?JIVaO?Jh¢hGLSH9?��V?B?BADldi ?JIKFWEG?JIfYc�f?J��hWFWEcZdY\FGTfEG?Jh�LONkY\LSI�gO?JIKFGZ[LSIfCOl�hGYBZ[?JIfY\?Opf�VL,?Jh)EcCOZbhW?ZdhGhGTf?Jh�FG�fC�F)EG?J�,TfZ[EG?N¥TVEGFG�V?BE¢�fZbhGYBTfhGhGZdLSI�p,COldFG�VLSTVaS�(FG�fZbh�ADC�A3?BE¢Zdh¢IVLOF)FG�V?�EcZ[aS�KF)ADldCOY\?�FWL �VL¤Z[FB�

� X ±ZS3³G²��:Q�� ±��:Qc³��C~ZbhWFW?JIV?BEchMaO?JIV?BEcCOldl[i�Y\LSIDhGZd�V?BE�FG�V?n�,TfCOldZdFGC�FGZ[gO?�N�?B?Jl~LON�H�TfhcZdY�FWL��q?nZ[FGh�?JhGhW?JIfY\?�COIf��Z[FGhMY0�fZ[?BN`C�FWFWEcCOY\FGZdLSI�p?JH9LOFGZ[LSI�LON~Y\LSTfEchW?@�q?JZbIVa�C�AfEcZdH9?M?\�.COH9AUl[?O�Q��TVFRCOh�IVLOFW?J��ZdI FG�V?@AfEG?Bg.Z[LSTfh`hG?JY\FGZ[LSI�pVH�COIKi�AD�fZdldLShWLOAD�V?BEchZ[aSIVLOEc?@FG�f?o�,TfCOldZdFGC�FGZ[gO?@COhGAq?JY\F)LON�?\�,A3?BEcZd?JIfY\?OpVCOIf��hWLSH9?�?BgO?JI(�V?JIKi¤Z[FGhR?\�VZdhWFW?JIfY\?O�`ƺ�V?JI(ZdFRZdh�CO�fH Z[FWFW?J�FG�fC�F)?\�.A3?BEcZ[?JIfY\?�Zdh�IVLOFv�GTfhWF�A3?BEcY\?BAfFGTfCOl3COIf�(Y\LSIDY\?BAfFGTfCOl�pfC�Y\LSH�H9LSI�C�AfAfEGLSCOY0��ZdhRFWL�½�fEcCOYc�O?BFGÃ�LOE¢?\�VZdl[?FG�V?R�KTfCOlbZ[FGC�FGZ[gO?�COhGAq?JY\FGhJp�COID��Y\LSIfY\?JIKFWEcC�FW?)C�FWFW?JIKFGZ[LSInLSI�COhWA3?JY\FGh�FG�fC�F�C�EG?`EG?J�DTfYBZ[�Dl[?kFWLohGYBZ[?JIKFGZ��DY`COIfCOl[i.hGZdhBp�M�fZbYc��NmLOE¢HnTfhGZbYM�RLSTfld�(ZdIDYBldTf�V?@�fTVEcC�FGZ[LSI�ZdI�H�ZdlbldZdhW?JY\LSIf�DhBpKZdIKFW?JIfhGZdFji ZdI��V?JYBZd�q?JlbhBp,COID�(hWA3?JY\FWEcCOl3COIfCOl[i.hGZdhLON�FGZdH��fEG?JhB©KFG�V?¢EG?JYBCOlbYBZ[FWEcCOIKF`EG?JhGZb�fTfC�C�EG?�FG�V?JI �fTf�f�3?J��ÂW�KTfCOlbZdCOÃCOIf�9FG�f?BEG?JC�NmFW?BE)ldC�EcaO?Jl[inZdaSIVLOEG?J���ke@If�V?BEFG�fZdh�g.Z[?B�pV�,TfCOldZdC�C�EG?��M�fC�FBÉÅh¢l[?BN�F)C�NmFW?BE�FG�V?�LO�.�W?JY\FGZ[gO?�COhWA3?JY\FGh¢C�Ec?�hGTV�fFWE0COY\FW?J��¹¥C�g�C�E0ZdCOI�F¢Zbh�FG�fC�FM�,TfCOldZdCC�EG?9�M�DC�FBÉÅhl[?BN�FC�NmFW?BEnZdI�FW?JIKFGZ[LSIfCOlbZ[Fji�Zdh�hGTV�fFWE0COY\FW?J����hW?B? |¡À\Ê8��NmLOEC(Ec?JldC�FGZ[gO?Jl[i�YBl[?JC�E?\�.AqLShcZ[FGZ[LSI�LONRFG�fZdhCOIf��EG?JlbC�FW?J��ZdhGhGTV?Jh�»0�5£¢�V?�EG?JhcTfl[FGZdIVa$EG?JhGZd�DTfCOl�YBC�FW?BaOLOEci���Y\LSTDld��ZdIfYBldTD�V?¤IVLSIV�jY\LSIfY\?BAfFGTfCOl)COhGhGL,YBZdC�FGZdLSIfhBp?JH9LOFGZ[LSIDCOl`Y\LSIKFW?JI�FBpQ?BFGY���^Q�.COH�ADl[?JhN�EGLSH�Aq?BE0Y\?BAfFGZ[LSI�C�EG?¤LONmFW?JI5aSZ[gO?JI�pkhGZbIfY\?��M�fC�F���?¤Aq?BE0Y\?JZ[gO? LON�FW?JI�fZ¡Ë3?BEch8hcZ[aSIfZ��DYBCOIKFGl[i@NmEcLSH �M�DC�F~AD�Ki,hcZdYBCOlSZdIfhGFWEcTfH9?JIKFGh�EG?BgO?JCOl.COh�LO�.�½?JY\FGZdgO?O�^=v?BEc�DC�ADh8FG�V?RH9LShWFvY\LSH�H9LSIfl[iTfhW?J��?\�.COH�ADl[?�Zbh¢FG�V?�½EG?J�fIV?Jhch¢LONQEG?J�DÃ.©qhWLSH�?�LOFG�V?BEch@C�EG?nFG�V?�hGAq?JYBZbCOl~�,TfCOldZ[FGZ[?Jh¢LON`C hGldLy�Ml[i��3?JIKF�H�C=�WLOEFWL�H�ZdIVLOEnFG�fZ[E0��p�FG�f?�hcH9?JldlQLON�LSIfZ[LSI�pkCOIf��FG�V?��DldTf?JIV?JhGh�LONMhW�,iO���oNMY\LSTVEchW?�COIKi�ADZ[?JY\?�LONMHnTfhGZdY�ZdhnCOI?\�VCOH9ADl[?Op¢COl[FG�fLSTVaS�!FG�f?$AD�DZdl[LShWLOAD�DZdYBCOl�ldZ[FW?BEcC�FGTVEc?�FW?JIf�fh¤FWL�hG��i�Cy�RCyi!N�EGLSH�?\�.COH9AUl[?Jh¤�DCJg.ZdIVa5hGFWEGLSIVa?JH9LOFGZ[LSIDCOl8Y\LSIfIVLOFGC�FGZ[LSIDhB�

��� ÒÅÓ�å½Ð�Ü�Øj×cÒÁÓ=ÒÅÓ�Ô)ÒÅÓoÝ�Ï=нÓ�Ú0Û)нÓ�Ú0ÖÅÚ�Ô�ÒÅåW×cÖ.Ú�é=Ñ�Ð�ØÎæ0×cÜÎÒÅÚ�ÓoÒÅÑ�ß=Ò��)å½Õ=Ö Ü~ÜÎÚRÚ�é=Üj×cÒÅÓ �"!UÕ�ß�ßyÏ�ÒÅÑ¥Ü~Û)ÐWß=Ò Üj×GÜÎÒÁÚ0ÓoÒÅÑ�ÚcÙçÜÎнÓ@Û)нÓBÜÎÒÁÚ0Ó�ÐWß�×0Ñ×0Ó@×0Ö ÜÎÐ�ØÎÓ�×cÜÎÒÅæ\Ð#�JÞ8Ï�ÒÅåjÏ@Û)ÚcØÎнÚGæ\Ð�Ø�Ï�×0Ñ8×�Ô0ÚBÚJß�Ü�Øj×0åjì)ØÎнå½ÚcØjß�ÒÅÓ@×cÓBÜÎÒÁå�ÒÁÝ�×cÜÎÒÅÓ�Ô�ØÎнÑ�Õ�Ö ÜÎÑ3ÙçØÎÚ0Û�å½Ú�Ô0Ó�Ò ÜÎÒÅæ\Ð�Ñ�å½ÒÅнÓ=å½Ð%$[Ñ�нР� нå�ÜÎÒÅÚ�Ó �'&èâ(*)vÕyØ3Û)Ð�ÜÎÏ=ÚJߢ×0ÖÅÑ�Ú�ßyÒ�+SÐèØÎÑqÙçØÎÚ0Û�ÜÎÏ�ÐMà�Ï=Ð�ÜÎÐ�ØÎÚ�Ý=Ï�нÓ=Ú�Û)нÓ=Ú�ÖÅÚ�Ôcêyã�ÚcÙ-,�нÓ=Ó�Ð�Ü�Ü � .0/��1�BÜÎÏ�Ú0Õ�Ô0ÏMÜÎÏ=ÒÁÑ3ß=ÒÅÑ�å½Õ�Ñ�Ñ�ÒÅÚ0Ó�ÖÅÒÅнÑ�Ú�ÕyÜÎÑ�ÒÁß=Ð�ÜÎÏ=ÐÑ�å½Ú0ÝOÐkÚ0ÙVÜÎÏ�ÒÅÑ8Ý�×cÝOÐ�ØWâ2 ë~нÑ�ÒÁß=Õ�×0ÖKåW×cÜÎнÔ0Ú0ØÎÒÅнÑ�Ú0ÙçÜÎÐ�ÓoÏ�×Wæ\ÐQ×RÑ�ÝOÐ�å½ÒÁ×0Ö.Ñ�ÚBå½ÒÅÚ0ÖÁÚ0Ô�ÒÅåW×cÖ43�×Wæ\Ú0Ø���×0ÑMàmÜÎÏ=ÐkÚ0ÜÎÏ�ÐèØ�� ã�Þ8Ï=ÒÅåèÏoÒÅÑ~Ý�×GØ�ÜÎÒ ×cÖÅÖÅê@Õ�Ó=ìyÓ=ÚWÞ8Ó �yÝ�×GØ�ÜÎÒ ×cÖÅÖÅê١н×cØÎÐWß5�vÝ�×cØ�ÜÎÒÁ×0ÖÅÖ ê(æ0×0ÖÅÚ0ØÎÒ�6½ÐWß5��×0Ó�ß(×cÖ Þ�×½êyÑo×0Û�é�ÒÅÔ�Õ=Ú�Õ=ѽâ8749=×cÛ)Ý�ÖÅнѢÖÅнÑ�Ñ@нÑ�ÚcÜÎÐ�ØÎÒÅå�ÜÎÏ�×0Ó�áBÕ�×cÖÅÒ ×�ÒÅÓ=å½ÖÅÕ�ß=Ð�Øj×cå½ÒÁ×0ÖQ×0Ó�ß�Ð�ÜÎÏ=Ó�ÒÅåÛ)ÒÅÓ�ÚcØÎÒÅÜÎÒÅнÑ*�=Ó�ÐèÞ�ßyÒÅÑ�ÐW×0Ñ�нÑ*�O×0Ó�ßMÒÅÓoÑ�Ú�Û)Ð�å�ÒÅØÎå�ÖÁÐ�Ñ*��å½Ú0Ó�Ñ�å½ÒÅÚ�Õ=Ñ�Ó�нÑ�Ñ�Ò ÜÎÑ�Ð½Ö Ù�â

Page 6: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

r �fZ[§ YBTfldFji9�MZ[FG���,TfCOldZdC�CO�VgOL.YBCOY\i�Zbh�FG�DC�F�ZdF�FW?JIf�Dh�FWLnEc?JZ[Nmi¤�KTfCOlbZdC.pKaSZdg,ZdIfa�FG�V?JH ZbIf�V?BA3?JIf�V?JIKFQ?\�VZdh½�FW?JIfY\?¢COh(=�ldC�FWLSIfZdYR?JIKFGZ[FGZ[?JhBpSCOIf�9ZbI�FWEGL.�fTfYBZbIVa�C@N¥TfIf�fCOH9?JIKFGCOl,LSI�FWLSldLOaSZdYBCOlf�fZdhGFGZdIfY\FGZ[LSI��q?BFè��?B?JI hGTV�.�W?JY\FGZ[gO?COIf��LO�.�W?JY\FGZ[gO?�COhWA3?JY\FGhoLON`?\�.A3?BEcZ[?JIfY\?O�@[fLOE?\�.COH�ADl[?Op8>oCJg.Zd��P��fCOldH�?BEch�|¡ÀOÀ��QYBldCOZdH�h@FG�V?BEG?9C�EG?�Fè��L(N¥TfI.��fCOH9?JIKFGCOl�½�RLOEcld��hcTV�DhWFGCOIfY\?JhJpÅÃ�H�C�FWFW?BE�COIf��ZdIVN�LOEcH�C�FGZdLSI��9¼èFhG?B?JH�hFWL�H�?9FG�fC�F�hGTfY0��C�AfADEGLSCOYc�V?Jh�C�EG?�M�fC�F¢>oCOIfZd?Jl8>@?JIfIV?BFWF |¡À � �~C�EGaSTV?JhMC�aSCOZbIfhWFBpDCOl[FG�fLSTVaS���V?�Zbh)hWLSH9?BFGZdH9?Jh�COYBYBTfhW?J��LONvC�EGaSTDZdIVa�C�aSCOZdIfhGF¢FG�V??\�VZdhWFW?JIfY\?�LON~�KTDCOldZ[FGC�FGZ[gO?¢?\�.A3?BEcZ[?JIfY\?�COhRhcTfYc���kr aO?JI,TfZdIV?M?JldZdH�ZdIDZ[FGZ[g.ZdhWF�Zdh*[VE0COIfYBZdh)PREcZdYc�(¹�LON8> } r N¥COH9?=»0p�M�VL��¢EcLOFW?� qQLST�É EG? IfLOFG�fZdIVa��DTVF�C�ADCOYc��LONRIV?JTfEGLSIfhGÃ$|¡À � �Ω�hW?B? COldhGLY|¡ÀJ¾ �Î� �oIV?�H9LOFGZ[g�C�FGZ[LSI�N�LOE��,TfCOldZdCZdh�FWL�Yc�fCOlbl[?JIVaO?��VLSH�ZdIfCOIKF@EG?J�fTfY\FGZ[LSIDZdhWFMAUC�EcCO�fZ[aSH�h�LON`IV?JTfEGLShGYBZ[?JIfY\?Op8COIDCOl[iKFGZbY�AD�DZdl[LShWLOAD�KiOpUCOID�$?\�.A3?BEcZ¡�H9?JIKFGCOlvADhWi.Yc�VLSl[LOaOiO�<[VLOEo?\�VCOH9ADl[?Op8P��fCOldH�?BEch>|¡ÀOÀ���A3LShW?Jh��M�fC�F��f?nYBCOldlbh¤Â½FG�V?��fC�Ec��AfEGLO�Dld?JH(pÅà���fZdYc�$ZdhFWL�?\�,ADlbCOZdI��,TfCOldZdC�ZbI�FG�V?�ldCOIVaSTfC�aO?�LON)FG�V?¤�DC�Ec��hGYBZd?JIfY\?JhBpk�fZdh�AfEG?JhGTfH�AfFGZ[LSI��3?JZdIVa(FG�DC�F�FG�fZbh�H�Cyi�IVLOF�3?�A3LShGhGZ[�Ul[?O��Æ�?¤C�EcaSTV? FG�fC�FnY\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[gO?�COIf���,TfCOldZdFGC�FGZ[gO? COhWA3?JY\FGhLON)?\�.A3?BEcZ[?JIfY\?�C�Ec?¤ZdIfhG?BADC�EcC��Dl[?Op~?BgO?JIFG�VLSTVaS� �fEchWF¢COIf��FG�DZ[Ec��A3?BEchWLSI(C�AfADEGLSCOYc�V?Jh�C�EGFGZ��DYBZbCOldl[i hW?BAUC�EcC�FW?�FG�V?JH��

Æ �fC�FW?BgO?BE9C�AfAfEGLSCOY0�5ZbhFGC��O?JI�pk�,TfCOldZdC�C�Ec? LON�FW?JI5Y\LSIfhcZd�V?BEG?J��FWL��3? �8�h� �Z�F{BpkZ�� ?O�[pkIVLSI.�ÎEc?J�fTfYBZ[�Dld?Op8LOE�MZ[FG�fLSTVF`Y\LSIfhWFGZdFGTV?JI�FRADC�EGFGhJp,ZdI¤�fC�EcH9LSIKi9�MZ[FG�¤�VL.Y\FWEcZdIV?Jh`LON8l[LOaSZdYBCOlUAqLShcZ[FGZ[g.ZdhGH(pO?O� aV�[pVCOhRLONmFW?JI�C�FWFWEcZd�DTVFW?J�FWL�Æ Z[FWFWaO?JIfhGFW?JZdI�ÉÅh��� �&{ ���&� x���|(��$ �Î�(£¢�VLSTfaS��¼�fCJgO?�IV?BgO?BE�hW?B?JI5ZdF�hWFGC�FW?J���KTfZdFW? hWL��UCOld�fl[iOp8FG�f? FG�V?BLOEGi¹��DTVFMAq?BE0�fC�ADh�½�3?JldZ[?BNGàZdh¢C��3?BFWFW?BE@FW?BEcH(pqhGZdIfY\?�ZdFMZdhMhGL LON�FW?JI$ZdH�ADldZdYBZ[F0»`hW?B?JH�h�FWL��q?�FG�fC�F��,TfCOldZdC9C�FWLSH hC�EG?�Y\LSH9AUl[?BFW?Jl[i ZdIf�V?BA3?JIf�V?JIKF�NmEGLSH ?Jld?JH9?JI�FGh�LON�A3?BEcY\?BAfFGZdLSI COIf� Y\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[LSI8p@�UTVF(hWLSH9?J�VL=��Y\LSH��UZdIV?�MZ[FG�$FG�V?JH FWL�aSZ[gO?�H9LSl[?JYBTfl[?Jh@LONQ?\�.A3?BEcZ[?JIfY\?O�<[VLOE�?\�VCOH9ADl[?Op3FG�fZbhMg.Z[?B� YBCOI��q?nZdIVN�?BEGEG?J��NmEGLSH hWFGCOID�fC�Ec�HnTfhGZdYBCOl)IVLOFGC�FGZdLSI�p��M�V?BEG?(FG�V?��,TfCOldZdFGC�FGZ[gO?Op�LOE�½?\�,ADEG?JhGhGZ[gO?OpÅÃ�COhWA3?JY\FGh�C�Ec?�aSZ[gO?JI!ZbI�IfC�FGTVEcCOl)ldCOIfaSTfC�aO?OpFji,ADZdYBCOlbl[i�¼èFGCOldZbCOI ¹�?O� aV�[p �&� ���� �� ��������pÅà  � �8����� ��� �F{R�OpÅà  {R�8� �hvH� �� �h�BÃ�»0p`�M�V?BEG?JCOh�ADZ[FGYc��COIf�5�fTVEcC�FGZ[LSI5C�EG?aSZ[gO?JI�ZbI�COI�C��DhWFWEcCOY\F�hWi,H��3LSldZdYnldCOIVaSTfC�aO?����9¼½IKFW?BEG?JhWFGZdIVaSldiOp8FW?JH9A3L(L,YBYBTfADZ[?Jh�COI�ZdIKFW?BEcH9?J�DZdC�FW?9A3LShGZ[FGZ[LSI�p�MZ[FG� �3LOFG�º�,ZdID�fh LON�IVLOFGC�FGZ[LSI ZdIºCOY\FGZ[gO?�TfhW?Op�FG�VLSTVaS� HnTfhGZdYBZdCOIDh LON�FW?JI ZdIKFW?BEGAfEG?BF¤?BgO?JI �KTDZ[FW?$ADEG?JYBZdhW?FW?JH9A3L$H C�EG�,ZbIVaSh ¹¥ZdI��q?JC�FGh�A3?BE�H�ZbIKTVFW?=»�COh�Z[N�FG�V?Bi��R?BEG?��KTDCOldZ[FGC�FGZ[gO?O����LOEG?BLygO?BEJp`gOLSldTfH9?�¹¥ZdI�FW?JIDhGZ[Fjif»H�C�EG�.ZdIVaSh�C�EG?�COldhWL$ZbI�FW?BEcH�?J�fZdC�FW?Op�FG�V?�IVLOFGC�FGZ[LSI�TfhW?J��Y\LSIfhGZdhWFGZbIVa�LON¢Y\LSIKFWEcCOY\FGZ[LSIfh�LON¢IfC�FGTfEcCOl�lbCOIVaSTfC�aO?¹¥C�aSCOZdI�N�EGLSH ¼èFGCOldZbCOIU»�E0C�FG�V?BE�FG�fCOI�AfEG?JYBZdhW?��V?JYBZ[�3?Jl�l[?BgO?JldhB��PRLSIKFW?JH9A3LOEcC�EGi�YBlbCOhGhGZdYBCOlRH�TDhGZdY¤?JldC��3LOEcC�FW?JhFG�V?JhW?(Y\LSIKgO?JI�FGZdLSIfh9ZdI�IKTfH�?BEGLSTfhn�RCyi,hJpQ�MZ[FG�5g�C�Eci,ZdIfa��V?BaOEc?B?Jh�LONMhGTfYBY\?JhGhJp`TfhGTfCOlbl[i�FWL�aSZdgO?�Y\LSH�AqLShG?BEchH9LOEG?�Y\LSI�FWEGLSlULygO?BERA3?BEGN�LOEcH9?BEchB©�NmLOE�?\�.COH9AUl[?Op�FG�V?M¼èFGCOldZbCOI�Y\LSI�FW?JH�AqLOE0C�EGi9YBldCOhGhGZdYBCOlDY\LSH9A3LShW?BE C�TfZ[aSZ } LSIVL�fZdhGFGZdIVaSTfZdhc�V?Jh�I,TfH9?BEcLSTfh��,ZbIf�fhRLON�Nm?BEcH C�FGC���ZdI(hWLSH9?LON��fZdh)hcY\LOEG?JhB�Q¼�F¢Zdh)?JCOhWi�FWL��DID��?\�.COH9AUl[?Jh)LON�IVLSI.�C�FWLSH�ZdYnHnTfhGZdYBCOl8�,TfCOldZbC.pU�fCyg,ZdIfa C N�?B?JldZdIfa�FWLSIV?�FG�DC�F@C�EG?nIVLOF�hcZdH9ADl[?Y\LSH��DZdIDC�FGZ[LSIfh¢LONkFG�f?�N�?B?JldZdIVa�FWLSIf?JhLON)FG�V?JZ[EnY\LSIfhWFGZ[FGTf?JI�FGhB©`FG�fZdh�H�?JCOIfh�FG�DC�F��,TfCOldZdC�C�Ec?�IVLSIV�jY\LSH9A3LShGZ[FGZ[LSIfCOlÎ��[fLOE�?\�VCOH9ADl[?OpkC$H�ZdIVLOE�FWEcZdCO��fCOh@C N�?B?JldZdIfa�FG�fC�FoYBCOIfIVLOFM�3?nZdIVN�?BEGEG?J�(�,i�ldZdhWFW?JIDZdIVa9FWL�Z[FGhMFG�fEG?B?�IVLOFW?Jh@LSI$FG�VEG?B?�hGTV§ YBZd?JI�FGl[i�hW?BADC�E0C�FW?J�L.YBYBCOhGZ[LSIfhB�

£¢�f?�g.Z[?B� LON�FG�DZdh�ADC�A3?BEJpM�M�DZdYc� Zdh�ZdIV¦UTV?JIfY\?J� �Ki AD�V?JIVLSH9?JIfLSl[LOaOiOp�?JhGAq?JYBZbCOldl[i�FG�fC�F(LONn^`�fHnTfIf�¨@TfhGhW?BEcl1| Ê � ��COIf���$C�EGFGZdI$¨M?JZd�f?BaOaO?BE | Ê �k�ÎpDZbh)FG�fC�FM�,TfCOldZdC9C�Ec?�IVLOFMhW?BAUC�EcC��Dl[?�N�EGLSH ?\�.A3?BEcZ[?JIfY\?OpfCOIf��FG�fC�F?\�.Aq?BE0Z[?JIfY\?�Zdh AfEcZdH�C�EciO�4�oZ[gO?JI!FG�fZdh9g.Z[?B�p)Z[F Zbh�Y\LSI�gO?JIDZ[?JI�F¤FWL5TfhG?�FG�V?��RLOEc� ÂW�,TfCOl[?JÃ�FWL�?JH9AD�DCOhGZ[�B?FG�fC�F@��?�CO�f�VEc?JhGhMFG�DZdhMADEcZdH�C�EGi�?\�.A3?BEcZ[?JIKFGZdCOl~�fZbH9?JIfhGZ[LSI8pfEcC�FG�V?BE@FG�fCOI�LO�.�W?JY\FGZ[gO?nH�?JCOhGTVEG?JH9?JIKFGhBp�COIf�$FWLZdIVN�LOEcH�COlbl[i$�V?z�UIV?�ÂW´8µ zD¶¥·mz Ã$COhnY\LSIfhGYBZ[LSTDh?\�.Aq?BE0Z[?JIfY\?Jh��DCJg.ZdIVa$TDIfZ[Fji��9COIf�5�fTVEcC�FGZ[LSI8��£M�fZdh�V?z�UIfZ[FGZ[LSI�VL,?Jh�IVLOFnhW?BADC�EcC�FW?�ÂWhGTV�V�½?JY\FGZ[gO?JÃ$COhWA3?JY\FGh�N�EGLSH hWLSH9? LOFG�f?BEJpkCOldl[?BaO?J�fl[i ½LO�.�W?JY\FGZ[gO?JÃ�COhWA3?JY\FGh�����?�Y\LSTfld�A3?BEc�fC�ADh�hGCJi5FG�fC�F�Z[F�g.Z[?B�Mh�?BgO?BEGi,FG�fZdIVa�COh�hGTV�.�W?JY\FGZ[gO?Opk�DTVFnZ[F��RLSTfld�5�3?¤HnTfYc���3?BFWFW?BE�FWL�hGCJi�FG�DC�F��R?Y\LSIfhGZb�V?BE¤FG�f?��fZbhWFGZdIfY\FGZ[LSI H9?JCOIfZdIfaSl[?JhGh�C�F¤FG�fZbh¤l[?BgO?Jl@LON�COIDCOl[i,hcZdhB� £M�fZdh�C�AfAfEGLSCOY0� FWL��,TfCOldZdC�?JhGYBC�A3?JhY\EcZ[FGZbYBZdhGH�h@ldZ[�O?nFG�VLShW?9CO�Vg�COIfY\?J���,i$>@?JIfIV?BFWF�|¡À � �Î�nr�Y\FGTfCOlbl[iOp3LSTVEog,Z[?B� LON�FG�V?9IfC�FGTVEG?�LON��,TfCOldZbC ZdhohGTfY0�FG�fC�F�ZdFZdhH9LOEG?�C�ADAfEGLOAfEcZbC�FW?9FWL���� �m���)FG�f?9AfEGL.�fTfY\FGZ[LSI�LON��KTDCOldZdC�FG�fCOI�ZdFZdh�FWL��V?z�UIV?��KTDCOldZdC.©�hG?B?�FG�V?�V?BgO?Jl[LOAUH9?JI�FGh�ZdI�X,?JY\FGZ[LSI�ÊV�Á¿,�

�$TfhGZdYBCOl¢AfEcCOY\FGZdY\?�Y\LSI?�fEcH�h�FG�fC�F hW?BADC�E0C�FGZ[LSI�LON�,TfCOIKFGZ[FGC�FGZ[gO?�COIf� �KTDCOldZ[FGC�FGZ[gO?�COhGAq?JY\FGh¤Zdh�ZdlbldTfhWLOEGiOpC�H�C�FWFW?BE�LONoIVLOFGC�FGZ[LSIDCOl)Y\LSI�gO?JIfZd?JIfY\?�COIf��FWEcCO�fZdFGZ[LSI�p`IVLOF9COI�ZbIf�V?BEG?JIKF�ADEGLOA3?BEGFji5LON�HnTfhGZdY�Z[FGhW?JldNè�Y[fLOE

� !UÕ=Ü8ÜÎÏ�ÒÅÑ�Ó�ÚcÜj×cÜÎÒÅÚ�Ó�ÒÅÑ8Ñ�Ú�Û)ÐèÞ8Ï�×cÜ~ÒÅå½Ú0Ó�ÒÅå#��ÒÅÓMÜÎÏ�Ð�ÜÎнåjÏ�Ó=ÒÁå½×0Ö�Ñ�нÓ�Ñ�ÐkÚcÙqÏ�×GØÎÖÁÐ�Ñ � ×0Ó�ßyÐ�ØÎÑ��.Ð½Ò ØÎå½Ð � �� ��dâ� Í3Ï=нÑ�Ð`×cØÎÐ�ØÎнѥÜÎÑ8ÚcÙ.ÙçØÎнÐ`ßyÕ=Øj×cÜÎÒÅÚ0ÓKâ���mÓRÜÎÏ�ÐqÑ�нÓ�Ñ�Ð8Ú0ÙSéOÐ�ÒÁÓ=Ô�Ð 9yÝOÐ�ØÎÒÅнÓ=å½ÐWß�×cÑDÞ8Ï=Ú�ÖÅÐ#�Bнæ�нÓ�ÜÎÏ=Ú�Õ�Ô0Ï�ÝOÚ�Ñ�Ñ�ÒÅé=ÖÅê�×0ÖÅÑ�ÚkÐ 9yÝOÐ�ØÎÒÅнÓ=å½ÐWß�×cÑDÏ�×WæyÒÅÓ=Ôkß=ÒÅÑ¥ÜÎÒÅÓ�Ô0Õ�ÒÅÑ�Ï�×cé�ÖÅÐ8Ý�×cØ�ÜÎѽâ

Page 7: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

?\�VCOH9ADl[?OpKFG�V?MhGCOH9?��¢EcZ[FWFW?JI�AD�VEcCOhW?�ZdhkA3?BEGN�LOEcH9?J��ZdI9C�gO?BEGi��fZ¡Ë3?BEG?JIKFk�RCyi�Z[N�Z[FkL.YBYBTVEch`ZbI�C���LO�JC�EGF�hcY\LOEG?LOE�C�PRLSTfIKF���COhGZd?¤hGY\LOEG?OpkCOIf�5?\�.Aq?BE0Z[?JIfY\?J��ldZbhWFW?JIV?BEch�YBCOI�?JCOhGZbl[i��V?BFW?JY\FnH COI�i�g�C�EcZdCOIKFGh�?BgO?JI5�MZ[FG�DZdI�ChGZdIfaSl[?aO?JIVEG?Op3COh@��?Jlbl~COh�gO?BEGi�H�COIKi(aO?JIVEG?JhBpqEG?JCOldZd�B?J��N�LOE�?\�VCOH9ADld?�FG�VEGLSTfaS��hGH�COlbl8g�C�EcZdC�FGZ[LSIfh�ZdI�FGZbH�ZdIVa¹�?O� aV�[pH9�COIfhGCOh�P�ZdFji�hW�MZdIVaVpD��?BEchW?Bi��3?JC�FBpfCOIf��r�N�EGL���P�TV�DCOI��3?B�3LOAq»0�

¨�?BEG?�C�Ec?MhWLSH9?�N�TVEcFG�V?BE`YBTVEcZdLSTfh�AfEGLOA3?BEGFGZ[?JhQLON3HnTfhGZbYBCOlf�KTDCOldZdC-�,X.H COldlVYc�fCOIfaO?Jh�YBCOI¤�fCJgO?o�KTfaO?¢?\Ëq?JY\FGhJp?O� aV�[p�Y0�fCOIVaSZdIfa(LSIV?�IVLOFW?9LON�C�FWE0CO�fZ[FGZ[LSIfCOl��fZbC�FWLSIfZdY�H9?Jl[L.�Vi��,i�C(�,TfC�EGFW?BE�FWLSIf?O��r@ldhWLVp~FG�V?9hGCOH9?��,TfCOl[?H�Cyi��DCJgO?�Y\LSH�AqLSIf?JI�FGh)LONkH�COIKi��fZ¡Ë3?BEG?JI�F)�.ZdIf�DhB©.NmLOE¢?\�VCOH9ADld?OpfFG�V?TVADlbZ[NmFW?J��N�?B?JldZdIVa9LONvFG�V?@�UIfCOl�Yc�VLOE0TfhZdI�FG�V?>��l[LOEcZdCnLON��RCOY0��ÉÅh���� � �H�� �� � �R�C�EcZdhG?Jh)NmEcLSH C�gO?BEGi(Y\LSH9ADl[?\��ZdI�FW?BE0COY\FGZ[LSI(LON�H9?Jl[L.�ViOpf�fC�EcH9LSIKiOpgOLSZdYBZdIfa�=LOEcYc�V?JhGFWEcC�FGZ[LSI�p�FW?JH9A3L�Y0�fCOIVaO?JhBp��O?Bi�Yc�fCOIfaO?JhBpkCOIf���Vi.IfCOH�ZbYBh ¸�� �(��LOEG?BLygO?BEJpkFW?JH�AqLOE0COldl[i�AfEcZ[LOE�,TfCOldZdC�H CJi��3?�C�ADAfEGLOAfEcZbC�FW?J�5¹¥�V?BA3?JIf�fZbIVa9LSI$hcCOldZ[?JIfY\if»0pUFG�,Tfh�g,ZdLSldC�FGZdIVa�L=gO?BEcl[i�hcZdH9ADl[?Zb�V?JCOh�C��3LSTVF�FG�V?FW?JH9A3LOEcCOl�ldZdIV?JC�EcZdFji�LONkA3?BEcY\?BAfFGZ[LSI�©UNmLOE@?\�VCOH9ADl[?Op3ZdI�C¤EcC�ADZd��Yc�VEGLSH C�FGZdY�E0TfI�pDH9LShGF@IVLOFW?Jh��MZdlbl8l[LShW?�FG�V?JZ[EZd�V?JIKFGZ[FèiOp�?\�VY\?BAfF�¹�AqLOFW?JIKFGZdCOldldiV»qFG�f?*�fEchGF~COIf��lbCOhWFB��r@H��UZ[aSTfZ[FGZ[?Jh8gO?BEGi�A3LShGhGZ[�Dld?OpyCOIf��C�Ec?`LON�FW?JI�?\�.ADl[LSZ[FW?J���KiY\LSH9A3LShW?BEchJpS?O� aV�[pKZdInN¥COldhW?�?JIf�fZbIVaShB��£M�V?BEG?)C�EG?¢COldhWLZbH9A3LOEGFGCOI�F�ldC�EGaO?)aOE0COZdIn?\Ëq?JY\FGhBp.hGTfY0�9COhQhGZdH ZdldC�EcZ[FèiCOIf�Y\LSIKFWEcCOhWF�ZdI�FG�f?��V?BgO?Jl[LOADH9?JIKFhW?JY\FGZ[LSI�LONRC(YBldCOhchGZdYBCOlkhWLSIfC�FGC.��r ADC�EGFGZbYBTfldC�Ecl[i$ZdI�FW?BEc?JhWFGZdIVa�AD�V?JIfLSH9?JIVLSIZdhn�M�V?JI�hGLSH9?�H�C�FW?BEcZdCOl�Âm�GTfH9ADhcÃ$N�EGLSH �3?JZdIVa�C�hW?J�,TV?JIfY\?�FWL��3?JZdIVa�FG�V?(LOA3?BEcC�FGZ[LSI�LON@C�AfEGL.Y\?JhGhB©)H�iN¥CJgOLOEcZ[FW?9?\�VCOH9ADld?�L.YBYBTVEchoZdI�FG�V?�FG�fZ[E0��ADZ[?JY\?�LONRr�IKFWLSI�Æ�?B�3?BEcI�ÉÅh��*��8��B�F�R{ ��� ���� � { �?����� ��p�LOADTfh�À $.p�M�V?JI5C�hW?J�,TV?JIfY\?�LON¢Z[EGEc?BaSTfldC�EA3?BEcYBTfhchGZ[gO? hWLSTDIf�fh�Zbh�hGTf�D�V?JIfl[i$Aq?BE0Y\?JZ[gO?J�5COh�FG�V?¤?BEGEcC�FGZdY LOAq?BE0C�FGZ[LSI�LONhWLSH9?9H�COldN�TfIDY\FGZ[LSIfZdIVa¤�V?Bg,ZbY\?Op3hcTfYc��COh�C��fEGLO�O?JI�YBl[L.YG�q©~�VL=��?BgO?BEyp~�KTDCOldZdC���Z[FG�fZdI�FG�V?9Y\i,YBl[?Jh�hGFGZdldl8Ec?BFGCOZdIZdIf�DZ[g,Zb�fTfCOldZ[FèiO�~X.TfYc�nAD�f?JIVLSH9?JIfC��V?JH9LSIfhWFWE0C�FW?RFG�DC�F��,TfCOldZbCMC�EG?RN�C�E�N�EGLSH��3?JZdIVaMC�FWLSH�ZbY�LOEkY\LSH9A3LShGZdFGZ[LSIfCOl�pCOIf���V?JIfY\?�N�C�EnN�EGLSH��3?JZdIfa�P�C�EGFW?JhcZdCOI�pkZdI�FG�f?�hW?JIDhW? LONM>@?JhGYBC�EcFW?JhBÉ��r� �z{R� x� �z� �8���Y�z� � � �$| ¾.À��Îpk�M�fZbYc�EG?JY\LSH�H�?JIf�fhCOIfCOldiK�JZdIfa(AD�V?JIVLSH9?JIDC�ZdIKFWL�ÂWCOh�H�COIKi�ADC�EGFGhCOh�A3LShGhGZ[�Dld?OpÅÃ(?JCOYc�5LON��M�fZdY0��Zdh�ÂWYBl[?JC�E�COIf��fZdhGFGZdIfY\FBpÅÃ�COIf�(FG�V?JI!½aOEcCO�fTfCOldldi�COIf���,i(�V?BaOEG?B?JhMEG?JCOYc�fZbIVa9FWLy��C�Ec�fh�H9LOEG?�Y\LSH9AUl[?\���.IVL=�Ml[?J�VaO?Jà ¸W¸ �

�$TfhGZdYBCOlv�,TfCOldZdC9ADEGLyg.Zd�V?nY\LSIfY\EG?BFW?9Y\LSTfIKFW?BEW�Î?\�.COH�ADl[?Jh@FWL�Y\?BEcFGCOZdI�AD�fZdl[LShGLOAD�fZdYBCOl3A3LShGZ[FGZdLSIfhBpDZdIDYBldTf�fZdIfa�REG?JIKFGCOIVLVÉÅh@FG�V?JhGZdhMLSI$ZdIKFW?JIKFGZ[LSIfCOldZ[FèiOpU���fZdYc�5¹¥TfIf�V?BE@hWLSH9?�ZbI�FW?BEGADEG?BFGC�FGZ[LSIfhBpU?O� aV�[p1|¡À\Ê&��»)�fLSld�fh¢FG�DC�FM?BgO?BEGiFG�VLSTVaS�KFM�fCOh�COI�ZdIKFW?JI�FGZdLSIfCOl8Y\LSH9A3LSIV?JIKFBpDhWLSH9?$½FG�fZdIVaSÃ9FG�DC�FMZ[F¢Zdh¢C��3LSTVFB� [VLOEJpUCOldFG�VLSTVaS��hWLSH�?�H�TDhGZdYBCOlFG�VLSTVaS�KFGh�C�EG? ÂWC��3LSTVFGÃ5hGLSH9?BFG�fZdIVa ¹�?O� aV�[pG�MLSH�COIºNmLSTDI�FGCOZdIDh0»0pMH9LShWF�C�EG?�IVLOFBp�TDIfl[?JhGh Aq?BE0�fC�ADh C�gO?BEGi�fEGLSCO�$IVLOFGZ[LSI(LONÂWC��3LSTVFGäZdh¢COldldLy�R?J��pD�M�DZdYc��ZbIfYBldTf�V?Jh)ZbI�FWEcC��jHnTfhGZbYBCOl�EG?JldC�FGZ[LSIDhG�fZ[ADhJp.hcZdIfY\?H9LShWF@H�TDhGZdYBCOlFG�VLSTVaS�KFGh)C�EG?oLSIfl[i¤C��qLSTfF�LOFG�V?BE¢COhGAq?JY\FGh�LONvH�TDhGZdY���¼�I�CO�f�DZ[FGZ[LSI�pKFG�V?o?JIf��LON�X,?JY\FGZ[LSI�¿,�dÀ@EG?BN¥TVFW?Jh)hWLSH�?@LON¨@TfH9?OÉÅh)g.Z[?B�Mh)LSI�FGZdH9?D| Ê � �Î�RX.?JY\FGZ[LSI �9�fZbhGYBTfhGhW?Jh)hGLSH9?N¥TVEGFG�V?BE¢�fZbhGY\LSI?�fEcH C�FGZ[LSIfh�COIf��ZdH�ADldZdYBC�FGZ[LSIDhB��^]�_ b g�34. � )6'*7 #?gh) � 7 '1.�7 7£¢�V?RhGTV�.�W?JY\FGZ[gO?RA3?BEcY\?BAfFGZ[LSI�LONfFGZdH9?Op��M�fZbYc��Zbh�YBl[?JC�E0l[iY\EcTfYBZdCOl�NmLOE�HnTfhGZdY�pO�fCOh��3?B?JI�ZdIKgO?JhWFGZ[aSC�FW?J���V?B?BAUl[i��KiAD�V?JIfLSH9?JIVLSl[LOaSZdhGFGhBp�?JhWA3?JYBZdCOldl[i�^��fHnTfIf�n¨�TfhchW?BEcl�p��M�VLShG?R�RLOEG�nH�C��O?Jhk?\�.ADldZdYBZ[FvTfhW?�LONUHnTfhGZbY�pSC�FQl[?JCOhWFkCOhQCH9?BFGC�AD�fLOE ¸ Ç | Ê � �Î�`¨�TDhGhW?BEclq�V?JhGY\EcZd�q?JhRhWLSH9?�ZdH�AqLOEcFGCOI�F��RCyi,h¢ZbI �M�DZdYc�¤LSTVE)COY\FGTfCOl�hGTV�V�½?JY\FGZ[gO?o?\�.A3?BEcZ[?JIfY\?LONMFG�f?�FG�fEG?B?\�ÎNmLSlb���fZ[g.ZdhGZ[LSI5ZdI�FWL�ADCOhGFBpQAfEG?JhW?JIKFBp�COID�5N¥TVFGTVEc?��fZ[Ëq?BEchnN�EGLSH FG�V?(TfhGTfCOlRAD�Ki.hGZdYBCOl�hGYBZ[?JIKFGZ��DYCOIfCOl[i.hGZdhJ��¨M?�LO�DhG?BEGgO?Jh�FG�fC�F�FG�V?�¦fL=�_LON�FGZbH9?nZbh�C�Y\LSIKFGZdI,TfCOl�ÂWhGZdIf�,ZdIfa¤CJ��CJi.Ã�ZbI�FWL�FG�V?�ADCOhWFBp�COIf��FG�fC�F?\�.Aq?BE0Z[?JIfY\?�YBCOI�LSIfldi$L.YBYBTVE�ZdI�FG�f?�AfEG?JhW?JIKFB� £¢�,TfhBp~FG�V?�ADCOhWFYBCOI��3?9?\�,A3?BEcZ[?JIDY\?J��ZdI�FG�V?�AfEc?JhW?JI�FBp��DTVFZdI�C��fZ¡Ë3?BEG?JIKF ��� ����N�EGLSH FG�fC�F�ZbI5���fZdYc��Z[Fn��COh9LOEcZ[aSZdIDCOldl[i�?\�,A3?BEcZd?JIfY\?J����¨@TfhGhW?BE0lRIDCOH9?Jh�FG�fZdh�H9L.�V?x � w ��� w=· � �`©�Z[FoCOldl[Ly��h�Tfh@FWL��fZdhWFGZbIVaSTfZdhG��AfEG?JhW?JIKF�?\�.A3?BEcZ[?JIfY\?�NmEcLSH AUCOhWF�?\�.A3?BEcZ[?JIfY\?Opq?BgO?JI�FG�VLSTVaS���3LOFG�C�EG?9?\�.A3?BEcZ[?JIfY\?J��ZdI�FG�f?�IVLy��9¼½I�CO�f�fZdFGZ[LSI�p��M�fZbl[?nlbZdhWFW?JIfZdIfa¤FWL�HnTfhGZbY�p���? C�Ec?�Y\LSIfhWFGCOIKFGl[i�COI�FGZdYBZdADC�FGZdIVa�M�fC�F�H�CJi�Y\LSH9?oIV?\�.FBpKC�H9L,�f?¢FG�fC�F�¨@TfhGhG?BEclfIfCOH9?Jh vx �Dw � � w�· � �Q©,FG�fZdh`ZdhQ�M�DC�F`H�C��O?JhRZ[FQA3LShGhGZ[�Ul[?�NmLOE�TfhÌ�� �mÓ@Û�Õ�Ñ�ÒÅå#�Dà¥ßJê=Ó�×0Û)ÒÅå½Ñ�ã�Õ=Ñ�Õ�×cÖÁÖ êMØÎÐ�Ù¡ÐèØÎÑ~Û¢×cÒÅÓ�Ö ê¢ÜÎÚ)×0Û)Ý=ÖÁÒ ÜÎÕ�ß=Ð#�yнæ\Ð�Ó�ÜÎÏ�Ú0Õ�Ô0Ïo×0ÖÅÖKÝ�×cØj×cÛ)Ð�ÜÎÐ�ØÎÑ~×cØÎÐkå�Ú�Ó�Ñ¥Üj×cÓBÜÎÖÅêMåjÏ�×cÓ�Ô�ÒÅÓ=Ô=âÌ�Ì�� Ö ÜÎÏ�Ú�Õ=Ô�Ï ,�Ð�Ñ�åW×cØ�ÜÎнÑvß=ÒÁßoÓ�ÚcÜ�Ü�ØÎн×cÜkáBÕ�×0ÖÅÒÁ×)×0ÑvÑ�Õ=åèÏ �OÓ�ÚcØ�ßyÒÁßoÏ�ÐQÓ�×cÛ)ÐkÏ�ÒÅÑvÑ�Û¢×cÖÁÖÅнѥÜ�Ý�×GØ�ÜÎÑ�×GÜÎÚ�Û)Ñ*�OÒ Ü�Ñ�ннÛ)Ñ8Ù[×0Ò Ø�ÜÎÚMÑÎ×½êÜÎÏ�×GÜ�Ï�ÒÅÑ�å½ÖÅÐW×GØ�ß=нÑ�å�ØÎÒÅÝyÜÎÒÁÚ0Ó@ÚcÙ.Ï�ÒÅÑ�Û)Ð�ÜÎÏ=ÚJß �y×cÓ�ߢÏ�ÒÅÑ�æ\Ð�Ø�ê¢ÒÅÛ)Ý=ØÎÐ�Ñ�Ñ�ÒÁæ�Ð�×0Ý=Ý�ÖÅÒÅåW×cÜÎÒÅÚ0ÓoÚ0Ù,ÒÅÜ8ÒÅÓMØÎÐWß=Õ=å½ÒÅÓ�Ô`Ô�нÚ0Û)Ð�Ü�Ø�ê)ÜÎÚ�×GØÎÒÅÜÎÏ=Û)Ð�ÜÎÒÅåÞ8Ò ÜÎÏ 3×GØ�ÜÎнÑ�ÒÁ×0Ó�å½ÚBÚcØjß=ÒÅÓ�×GÜÎнÑ*�=ÞqÐ�ØÎÐkнÓ=Ú0ØÎÛ)Ú�Õ=Ñ�Ö ê¢ÒÁÓ 3�Õ=нÓBÜÎÒ ×cÖOÙ¡Ú0Ø�×cÖÁÖ�Ñ�Õ�é=Ñ�ÐWáBÕ�нÓBÜqÝ�Ï�ÒÅÖÅÚ�Ñ�Ú0Ý�ÏBêMÚ0ÙVÑ�å�ÒÁÐ�Ó�å½Ð#�yÞ8Ï�ÒÅåjÏ@ÚcÙçÜÎнÓ�ÒÁÛ)ÝOÚ0Ñ�Ð×RÑ¥Ü�ØÎÒÅå�ÜÎÐ�Ø~ÒÅÓBÜÎÐ�ØÎÝ=ØÎÐèÜj×cÜÎÒÅÚ�Ó@ÜÎÏ�×0ÓMÞ�×0Ñ~Ý=ØÎÚ0é�×cé�Ö êMÒÁÓBÜÎнÓ�ß=ÐWßMéBê ,vнÑ�åW×cØ�ÜÎÐ�ѽâÌmä ívÒÅæ\Ð�Ó@ÜÎÏ�Ð�Û)ÐèÜÎÏ�ÚJß=Ñ�ÚcÙVÝ�Ï=нÓ�Ú0Û)нÓ�Ú0ÖÅÚ�Ô0ê��yÒ Ü~ÒÅÑ~ÖÅÒÅì\Ð½Ö êMÜÎÏ�×GÜ��vÕ�Ñ�Ñ�ÐèØÎÖ,×cå�ÜÎÕ�×cÖÁÖ ê�Õ�Ñ�ÐWß�ÛRÕ�Ñ�ÒÅå�ÒÅÓMÜÎÏ�нÑ�ÐkÒÅÓJæ\нѥÜÎÒÅÔ\×GÜÎÒÅÚ�Ó�ѽâ

Page 8: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

FWL�?\�.Aq?BE0Z[?JIfY\?��KTfCOlbZdCMLON3hGTVEcAfEcZdhW?O� } LOFW?)FG�fC�FkADEGLOFW?JI�FGZdLSI9Zdh�IVLOFkhWi,H H9?BFWEcZdYBCOl.�MZdFG��EG?BFW?JIKFGZ[LSI ��Z[Fk�VL,?JhkIVLOFAfEGL=g,Zb�V?nC(hcZdIVaSl[?�ÂWZdH�C�aO?JÃ(LON��M�fC�F�ZdhoY\LSH�ZdIVaVp��UTVF�E0C�FG�V?BEC(Y\LSH9ADl[?\��IV?BFj�RLOEG�$LON�?\�.A3?JY\FGC�FGZ[LSIfh�C��3LSTVF�M�fC�F¢H Z[aS��F¢Y\LSH�?O�

¨@TfhGhW?BE0l�ÉÅh@LO�DhW?BEGg�C�FGZ[LSIfh@LSI�EG?BFW?JIKFGZ[LSI�C�EG?9Y\LSI?�DEcH9?J���Ki$EG?JY\?JIKF�EG?JhW?JC�EcY0��LSI�FW?JH9A3LOEcCOl�Y\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[LSI�LONHnTfhGZdYZ|~�8� �ÎpfZd�V?JIKFGZ[N�i,ZbIVa�CnAfEG?\�jY\LSIfhcYBZ[LSTfhR�DT.Ë3?BE�LON�C��3LSTVFoÀ $9hW?JY\LSIf�fhB�Q£M�fZdh��DT.Ë3?BERY\LOEGEc?JhWA3LSIf�fhRFWL��M�fC�F¨@TfhGhW?BEcl�YBCOlbldh � x � u� � � � �Dx�� ¸ � pDCOIf�(Z[F¢�fZ[Ëq?BEch�N�EGLSH'FG�V?�H9LOEG?�N¥COH�ZdldZdC�E)hG�fLOEGF)FW?BEcHÄH9?JH�LOEGi�COID�(l[LSIVaFW?BEcH H9?JH9LOEciOp3ZbI�FG�fC�F�Z[F@Zdh�IfLOF@Y\LSIfhcYBZ[LSTfhBp3Z�� ?O�[p�Z[FM�RLOEG�.h@�M�V?BFG�V?BE@LOE�IVLOF��R?�C�EG?nCy�RC�Ec?9LON`Z[Fn¹�FG�fLSTVaS�Y\LSIfhGYBZdLSTfh C�FWFW?JIKFGZ[LSI H�CJi H�C��O?�ZdF���LOEc���q?BFWFW?BE\»0���@N�Y\LSTVEchW?Op)FG�f?�FWEcCO�fZdFGZ[LSIfCOlMhc�VLOEGF COIf� l[LSIVa5FW?BEcHH9?JH9LOE0Z[?Jh�COldhWLnADldCJi¤ZdH9A3LOEGFGCOIKF`EGLSl[?Jh�ZdI�HnTfhGZdY�p.COldl[L=�MZdIVanTfh`FWL�EG?JY\LOaSIDZ[�B?oFG�V?JH9?Jh�FG�fC�F�EG?JYBTVE�ZdI�CnADZ[?JY\?OpCOIf�¤ADZ[?JY\?Jh�FG�fC�FR��?o�fCJgO?oAfEc?Bg,Z[LSTDhGl[i��V?JC�Ec��� } LOFW?@FG�DC�F�EG?JZ �DYBC�FGZ[LSI�FG�fEGLSTVaS�¤EG?BA3?BFGZ[FGZ[LSI�LON�C�hW?J�,TV?JIfY\?@FWLC�AfEGL.Y\?JhGh)�RLOEG�.h)�3?JhWF¢Z[N�FG�V?hW?J�,TV?JIfY\?�Zdh)hc�VLOEGF�?JIVLSTVaS�(FWLD�fF¢ZdIKFWL9FG�V?�NmEc?JhG�(H9?JH9LOEGi��DT.Ë3?BEJpV?JhWA3?JYBZdCOlbl[iZ[NqFG�V?BEG?MC�Ec?MY\LSI�FGZbIKTfCOlDg�C�E0ZdC�FGZ[LSIfhBpKCOh`ZdI9FG�f?¢FG�fZ[Ec��AUZ[?JY\?¢LON3Æ�?B�3?BEcI�ÉÅhQLOAUTfh¢À $.�Q£¢�V?BEc?¢�VL�IVLOFQiO?BF�C�AfA3?JC�EFWL��3?COIKi�If?JTVEGL��jY\LOaSIfZ[FGZdgO?hWFGTf�fZ[?Jh�LON�AfEcLOFW?JI�FGZ[LSI8�

[VLOE�¨�TfhchW?BEcl�p)½LO�.�W?JY\FGZ[gO? H9LSH�?JI�FGhGÃ�LON�FGZdH9?9C�EG?9IVLOF�AfEc?\�j�V?BFW?BEcH�ZdIf?J��pU�UTVFoEcC�FG�V?BEJp�LO�.�W?JY\FGh½�jZdIV�ÎFGZdH9?C�EcZdhG?)FG�VEGLSTVaS�9ADEGL,Y\?JhchW?JhkLONqEG?BFW?JI�FGZdLSI COIf�9ADEGLOFW?JI�FGZdLSI��k¨�Zdh�aOLSCOlD�RCOh`FWL��fZdhcY\LygO?BE`FG�f?¢LOEcZ[aSZdI�LONqFGZdH9?Op,COIf�FG�V?JhW?�AfEGL.Y\?JhGhW?Jh@C�EG?��fZdh¢COIfhG��?BEJ�o�oTVE¢LO�DhG?BEGg�C�FGZdLSIfhMLSI�HnTfhGZdYBCOl��KTfCOlbZdC��V?JH9LSIDhWFWEcC�FW?�FG�DC�F�LSIfldi�Y\?BEcFGCOZdIhGCOldZd?JI�F)Y\LSI?�faSTfEcC�FGZ[LSIfh�LONvLO�.�W?JY\FGh¢COIf�(EG?JlbC�FGZ[LSIfhR�3?JY\LSH9?hWL�hWLSldZb�fZ��f?J��p,COIf�(FG�fC�F¢ZdF�Zbh�FG�fZdh�hWLSldZd�DZ��DYBC�FGZ[LSIFG�fC�FvY\EG?JC�FW?JhkC�AfADC�EG?JIKF�ÂWH�LSH9?JI�FGhcÃ�ZdI�FGZdH9?O©�LOFG�V?BE�l[?JhGhvhGCOldZ[?JIKF~Y\LSI?�DaSTVEcC�FGZ[LSIfh�C�EG?�ld?JhGh�hGLSldZd�fZ��D?J��pJCOIf�nl[?JhGhldZ[�O?Jldi¤FWL¤�q?�EG?BFGCOZdIV?J��LOE¤Â½LO�.�W?JY\FGZ��f?J�fäCOh¢?BgO?JIKFGhB����LOEG?BLygO?BEypqFG�f?JhW?�H9LSH9?JIKFGhBp3TfIfldZd�O?@FG�fLShW?�LONkAD�Ki.hGZdYBhBp�fCygO?��fTVE0C�FGZ[LSI�pOLOE�C�Ec?�½FW?JH9A3LOEcCOldl[inFG�fZdYc�UpÅÃ�hGZdIfY\?)FG�V?BinEG?JldC�FW?MFWL�EG?JCOlV?BgO?JIKFGh��M�fZdY0��FGC��O?MFGZdH9?)FWL�AfEGL.Y\?JhGh¹�FG�V?9AfEcL,Y\?JhGhcZdIVa�FGZdH9?�Zdh�C��3LSTVF�LSIf?9FW?JI�FG��LONRC�hW?JY\LSIf��p8�UTVF�g�C�EcZ[?Jh�Y\LSIDhGZd�V?BEcC��Ul[i(�MZ[FG��Y\LSIf�fZdFGZ[LSIfh0»0�¼½ICO�f�fZdFGZ[LSI�pSEG?JlbC�FGZ[LSIfhG�fZdADh�FG�fC�F��VLSld� C�hGCOldZ[?JIKF�Y\LSIl�faSTVEcC�FGZ[LSI FWLOaO?BFG�V?BE¢C�EG?�EG?BFGCOZdIV?J�¤ZdI H9?JH�LOEGi9�MZ[FG� FG�V?JZ[EhGCOldZd?JI�F�Y\LSIfhWFGZ[FGTf?JI�FGhBpRCOIf��FG�V?JZ[E9�,TfCOldZdC.��¼½If�V?B?J��pQFG�f?BEG?(Zdh�HnTfY0��?\�,A3?BEcZdH�?JI�FGCOlR?Bg.Zd�V?JIfY\?�FG�fC�F��,TfCOldZdC.pC�F9l[?JCOhWF�?JH9LOFGZ[LSIDCOlR�,TfCOldZbC.pvN¥TfIfY\FGZdLSI5COh�ÂWZdID�fZdY\?JhGÃ�NmLOE�FG�V?�EG?BFWEcZd?Bg�COl�LON�H9?JH�LOEcZ[?JhBpQCOhn�R?Jldl�COh�AUldCJi.ZdIVaZdH9A3LOEGFGCOIKFnEGLSl[?Jh9ZdI�H�COIKi�LOFG�V?BE¤H9?JI�FGCOl�ADEGL,Y\?JhchW?JhBp�ZbIfYBldTf�fZbIVa(EG?JCOhWLSIfZbIVaVp`?O� aV�[p�hW?B?�|¡À �Vp)À��k�Î��¨�TfhchW?BEcl�VL,?JhoIVLOF@�DZdhGYBTfhGh@�,TfCOldZdC.pq�DTVF�LSTVE�H�TfhcZdYBCOl~LO�UhW?BEGg�C�FGZ[LSIfhohG�VL=�Mh@FG�fC�FoLSIfl[i�hGCOldZd?JI�F@A3?BEcY\?BAfFGZ[LSIfh��3?JY\LSH9?AD�V?JIfLSH9?JIVLSl[LOaSZdYBCOlv?BgO?JIKFGhBp~COIf��FG�fC�FoLSIfldi�FG�V?JhW?9�fCygO?�COI�COhGhWL.YBZdC�FW?J���KTDCOldZdC.©3��?9��Zdldl~C�EcaSTV?9ZdI�X.?JY\FGZ[LSIÊV�Á¿�FG�fC�FMFG�fZdh¢�fCOh¢FWL �VL9�MZ[FG��ADEGLOFW?JI�FGZdLSI�COIf��COIKFGZdYBZ[ADC�FGZdLSI��

£¢�f?JhW?�LO�DhW?BEGg�C�FGZ[LSIfh�COldhWL��fZbhGY\LSI?�fEcH COhWA3?JY\FGh�LONU>oCJg.Zd�9¨@TfH9?OÉÅh�A3LSZdIKFGZdldZdhGF8FG�V?BLOEGi�LONDFGZdH9?}| Ê � �Î�k¨@TfH9?��COhEcZ[aS�KF�FG�fC�F�FGZdH9?�Y\LSIfhGZbhWFGh�LON)�fZdhGY\Ec?BFW?9?BADZdhWL.�V?JhBp8�UTVF��¢EGLSIVa�FG�fC�FFG�V?JhW?¤C�EG? �fZdhcY\EG?BFW?�A3LSZdIKF½�jldZ[�O?9ZdI.�hWFGCOIKFGhBp3hGZdIfY\?�HnTfhGZbYBCOl~�,TfCOldZdC�C�Ec?�YBl[?JC�Ecldi�½FW?JH�AqLOE0COldl[i�FG�fZdYc�UpÅÃ�Z�� ?O�[pU�DCJgO?��fTVEcC�FGZ[LSIDh¢FG�fC�F@YBCOIfIVLOFoH9?JCOI.�ZdIVaON¥Tfldldi9�q?o�fEcLO�O?JI�ZdIKFWL9AqLSZbI�FGhB©VH9LOEc?BLygO?BEJpqZ[F)Zdh�?JCOhWi�FWL��DIf�(HnTfhGZdYBCOlq?\�VCOH9ADl[?JhMZdI��M�fZdY0�(COI(?BgO?JI�F��fCOhZdldl[�j�V?z�DIV?J�(LOE@aOEcCO�fTDCOl~LSIfhG?BF@COIf��=LOEoY\LSIDYBldTfhGZ[LSI�¹�?O� aV�[p8ZdI$aOEGLSTVA�ZdH9AfEGL=g,ZbhGC�FGZ[LSIfhM�Ki(FG�V?�r�EGF@^�IfhW?JH��Dl[?LON�P)�fZdYBC�aOLK»0��r@l[N�EG?J� } LOEGFG��Æ �fZ[FW?J�V?JCO��| ��� �kZbh@COIfLOFG�V?BE�AD�fZdldLShWLOAD�V?BEMZbI$FG�DZdhoYBC�FW?BaOLOEGiO�n¨@ZdhoIVLOFGZ[LSIDh�LONAfEG?J�f?JIfhGZ[LSI(COIf��Y\LSIfY\EG?JhGY\?JIfY\?OpqCOIf���fZbh�½?BA3L,Y0�fCOldÃ9FG�V?BLOEci¤LON�FGZdH9?OpU�fCJgO?nhGZdH�ZdlbC�EcZ[FGZ[?Jh��MZ[FG�(¨@TfhGhW?BE0l8COIf��MZ[FG��FG�V?�FG�f?BLOEGi(LONQ�KTDCOldZdC�ZdI�FG�fZdh¢AUC�Aq?BEy� } LOE�hG�VLSTflb����?nN�COZbl�FWL�H�?JI�FGZ[LSI$Æ ZdldldZdCOHOE�COH9?JhZ|~��$ �ÎpU���VLShW?AfEG?JhcY\?JI�FMZb�V?JCOh¢C�EG?�N¥TVEGFG�V?BE)�DEcZ[?B¦fi��fZdhGYBTfhchW?J��ZdI�X,?JY\FGZ[LSI �,�

E�TfI�£�COIfZ}| �,À��)LO�DhG?BEGgO?J��FG�fC�F9�fTVEcZbIVa�C�hW?JIfhGLOEGi��jH�LOFWLOE�l[?JC�EcIfZdIfa�FGCOhW�qp�C�hGZdHnTfldC�FW?J�5EGLO�3LOF��MZ[FG��CY\?BEGFGCOZdI��fZ[?BE0C�EcYc�fZbYBCOl~IV?JTVE0COl~IV?BF@C�EcYc�fZdFW?JY\FGTVEG?n?\�.�fZd�DZ[FW?J�(FWEcCOIDhGZ[FGZ[LSIfhM�3?BFj�R?B?JI�AD�DCOhW?JhMLONQY\LS�f?BEG?JIfY\?9COIf�ZdIfY\LS�f?BEG?JIfY\?�ZbI�Z[FGhvCOIKFGZdYBZ[ADC�FGZ[LSI�LONfA3?BEcY\?BAfFGZ[LSIDhBp=���V?BEG?RFG�V?`EG?JhcTfl[FGZdIVa�Y\LS�V?BEG?JIKF�Y0�KTDIV�,hvY\LOEGEG?JhGAqLSID�FWLoFG�V?hWFWEcTDY\FGTVEG?oLON�FG�f?�FGCOhW�U��£�COIfZ3Ec?JldC�FW?Jh�FG�fZdh�FWL�¨@TfhGhW?BE0l�ÉÅhRAD�V?JIVLSH9?JIfLSl[LOaOi¤LON�FGZdH9?OpfZdI�FG�fC�FMFG�V?�Yc�,TfIV�.h¢C�EG?ÂWZdH�H COIV?JI�FGÃMNmLOE�FG�V?`EcLO�qLOFB� ;QC�EG?JldC | � � �KCOlbhWL�hWFGTD�fZ[?J�hWLSH�?�Y\LSIfIV?JY\FGZdLSIfh~�3?BFè��?B?JInY\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[gO?RIV?JTVEGLShcYBZ[?JIfY\?COIf� ¨@TfhGhW?BE0l�ÉÅh AU�V?JIVLSH9?JIVLSldLOaOi!LONnFGZdH9?Op�ZbI AUC�EGF(COh(COI ZdldldTDhWFWEcC�FGZ[LSI!LON�FG�V?�IV?JTfEGLOAD�V?JIVLSH�?JIVLSl[LOaSZdYBCOlH9?BFG�VL.��ZdIKFWEGL.�fTfY\?J�(ZdI�| �=Ê&�Î�Ì � � Õ�Ñ�Õ�×cÖ�ÜÎÐèØÎÛ�Ù¡Ú0Ø�Ò Ü~ÒÁÓ@Ý�Ñ¥êyåèÏ=Ú�ÖÅÚ�Ôcê@ÒÅÑ¢à�Ñ�Ð�Ó�Ñ�Ú0Ø�ê@Û)нÛ)Ú0Ø�êBâ ã��vÚcÜÎÐQ×0ÖÅÑ�Ú�ÜÎÏ�×GÜ�Ñ�Ï=Ú0Ø�Ü8ÜÎÐ�ØÎÛ�×cÕ�ß=Ò ÜÎÚcØ�ê@Û)нÛ)ÚcØ�ê¢ÒÅÑ�×céOÚ�ÕyÜ 0/Ñ�нå½Ú0Ó�ßyÑ $[Õ=Ó�ÖÅнÑ�Ñ�ØÎÐ�Ù ØÎнÑ�Ï�ÐWß�éJê¢ØÎнÝOÐèÜÎÒÅÜÎÒÅÚ0Ó"& ��×0Ó�ßMÜÎÏyÕ=Ñ�ÒÅÑ�áBÕ=ÒÅÜÎÐ�ß=ÒÅÑ¥ÜÎÒÅÓ�å�Ü8ÙçØÎÚ0Û�Ñ�нÓ�Ñ�ÚcØ�ê@Û)Ð�Û)Ú0Ø�êBâ

Page 9: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

� � L�� X ¯°�L*Q S WJ¯�®�� ¬�°�LQ®fSD­ �¢¬�°�³0¬�� X ±ZS3³G²£¢�fZbh�hW?JY\FGZdLSI�hGTVaOaO?JhWFGhFG�fC�F���?�YBCOI��3?BFWFW?BE�TDIf�V?BEchWFGCOID���M�DC�FoZdFoH�?JCOIfhoFWL�TfIf�V?BE0hWFGCOIf��H�TDhGZdY��Ki�Y\LSI.�hWFWEcTDY\FGZdIVa�H9L.�V?JldhLON�� �� �R?¤TDIf�V?BEchWFGCOID��H�TDhGZdY���C~Z[�O? COlblQH9L.�V?JldhBp�LSTVEch��Zdldl��3?�ADC�EGFGZbCOlQ�V?JhGY\EcZdAfFGZ[LSIfhY\LSIfhWFWE0TfY\FW?J��N�LOE9ADC�EGFGZdYBTflbC�EnAUTVEGA3LShW?JhBpQ�UTVF9COldhWLVp�hcZdIfY\?�FG�V?Bi�C�EG?�H�C�FG�V?JH�C�FGZbYBCOl¢H9L.�V?JldhBpQFG�f?Bi�YBCOI��3?H9LOEG?�AfEG?JYBZbhW?OpkCOIf�5H�LOEG? N¥COldhGZ��UC��Dl[?OpvFG�fCOI5H�LOEG?¤FWE0CO�fZ[FGZ[LSIfCOl`AD�fZdldLShWLOAD�fZdYBCOl�LOE�HnTfhGZdY\LSl[LOaSZbYBCOl`FG�V?BLOE0Z[?JhB��oTVE�C�AfADEGLSCOYc��Zbh�ZdI�FW?JID�V?J��FWL�C�AfADl[i�FWL�Y\LSI�FW?JH�AqLOE0C�EGi�HnTfhGZbYBCOlvH COIfZ[N�?JhWFGC�FGZ[LSIfhBp8hcTfYc��COh�IfLSZdhW?9H�TDhGZdY�p�fZ[aSZdFGCOlKHnTfl[FGZdH�?J�fZdC)AfEcL,�fTDY\FGZ[LSIfhBp=NmEG?B?��GC��B�)ZdH9AfEGL=g,ZbhGC�FGZ[LSI�p�H�TDhGZdY`hcYBTfl[AfFGTVEc?JhBp=?JIKg.Z[EGLSIfH9?JIKFGCOl.H�TDhGZdY�p�?BFGY��£¢�VLSTfaS�¤H9LOEc?�EcZdaOLOEGLSTfhBpKFG�V?�FG�f?BLOEGi �fCOh�H�COIKi�A3LSZdIKFGhQLON~Y\LSIKFGCOY\F)�MZ[FG�¤FG�V?oZdIfIVL=g�C�FGZ[gO?���LOEc��LON2C8?BLSIDC�Ec���?BiO?BE}|~�8� �ÎpKADC�EcFGZdYBTfldC�Ecldi�EG?BaSC�E0�fZdIVaFG�f?�ZdH9A3LOEGFGCOIDY\?¢LON8COI�FGZbYBZ[ADC�FGZ[LSI¤ZdI HnTfhGZdY�p,COIf� YBCOI�?BgO?JI¤�3?�hW?B?JI�COhCOI�C�FWFW?JH9AfF�FWL�TVA��fC�FW?���?BiO?BEJÉÅh���LOEc�U©v�VLy�R?BgO?BEJp~LSTfEC�AfAfEGLSCOY0��COldhWL��fZ[Ëq?BEchoZdI�hWLSH�?�hGZ[aSIfZ��UYBCOI�Fo��CJi.hBpADC�EGFGZbYBTfldC�Ecl[i�Z[FGh¢FW?JY0�fIfZdYBCOlvH�COY0�fZdIV?BEGi�N�LOE@�DCOIf�fldZdIfa�hGFWEcTfY\FGTVEG?�COIf���fZd?BEcC�EcYc�DZdYBCOl8Y\LSH9ADld?\�.Z[FèiO�¢£¢�V?BEG?nC�EG?LON~Y\LSTVE0hW?�H�COIKi�LOFG�V?BE)H�C�FG�f?JH�C�FGZdYBCOl3C�AfAfEGLSCOY0�V?JhRFWLnHnTfhGZbY�pK?O� aV�[pVhW?B?oFG�V?@Y\LSldl[?JY\FGZ[LSI$|~�k�Îp.FG�VLSTVaS��TfhGTfCOlbl[iFG�V?Bi(C�EG?ldZbH�Z[FW?J��FWL¤YBldCOhchGZdYBCOl�HnTfhGZdY�pfCOIf��LONmFW?JI��DCJgO?�CD=`ldC�FWLSIfZbhWF�AD�fZdl[LShGLOAD��iO�1]�_ � .?58e ���*)Ad$ef'*/���,�.�'*/ g�'10�¢?JhG?JC�EcYc� ZdI�Y\LOaSIDZ[FGZ[gO?�ldZdIVaSTfZbhWFGZdYBhn�Kia�o?BLOEGaO? C�C��OL�Ë COIf�!LOFG�V?BEch�TfIf�V?BE¤FG�V?��DCOIDIV?BE�LON�ÂWY\LSIfY\?BAfFGTDCOlH9?BFGC�AD�fLOE�FG�V?BLOEGi.à ¹¥C��f�fEc?Bg,ZdC�FW?J� ÂcP)��£MÃ�»(�fCOh(aOEc?JC�FGl[iº�f?B?BAq?JIf?J� LSTVE�TfID�V?BEchWFGCOIf�DZdIVa�LON9H9?BFGC�AU�VLOE|~��Êfp �O¿ �Îp¢hG�VLy��ZdIVa�FG�fC�F H COI�i�H9?BFGC�AU�VLOEch Y\LSH�?$ZdI�N¥COH�ZdldZd?JhBp�YBCOldld?J� · � z�� � uJ{ � ��� zDu p�FG�fC�F¤hG�DC�EG?�CY\LSH�H9LSI�ADC�FWFW?BEcI����oIf?@?\�VCOH9ADld?oZbh������ � ���������! 3pVCOh)ZdI�½¼�ÉÅH N�?B?JldZdIVa�TVA(FWL.�fCJiOpÅÃ9LOE�ÂW¨�?OÉÅhMH�Lyg.ZdIVa9TVAZdIKFWL¤H�COIDC�aO?JH9?JI�FBpÅÃ�LOE(ÂW¨@Zdh�aOLSCOldhoC�EG?��fZdaS�V?BEMFG�fCOI�FG�fC�FB�Åà X,LSH9?�ZdH�C�aO?nhGYc�V?JH COhBp�ZdIfYBldTf�DZdIVa�FG�fZdhMLSIV?OpC�EG?naOEGLSTfIf�f?J�$ZdI�FG�V?��KTfH COI��3L.�Vi ¸ �COID�$C�EG?9YBCOldld?J� tvzfuy·�{�· � z�� � uJ{�� ��� zfu ©qFG�f?Bi�FW?JIf�$FWL�i.Z[?Jld��FG�V?H9LShWF�A3?BEchGTfCOhGZdgO?H9?BFGC�AD�VLOEchJ��X.TfYc�$ZdH�C�aO?nhGYc�V?JH COh��VL¤L,YBYBTfE�ZdI�HnTfhGZbY�©DN�LOE�?\�VCOH9ADl[?OpUCOI$COIVaO?JlbZdYYc�fLSZ[E�MZ[FG�(�DZ[aS��gOLSZdY\?JhMZbIfhWFGCOIKFGZdC�FW?Jh¢FG�V?"�#��� � ���$�%���! �hGYc�V?JH C.�

[fCOTDY\LSIfIfZ[?BEMCOID��£�TfEcIV?BEr| ¾8�.pU¾� �~�fCJgO?nhWFGTf�fZ[?J� t�¶ � � ��· � � pDLOE { � � { � ~w µ zD¶)· � w � �Dx�zVw=· � �QpDYBlbCOZdH�ZdIVaZ[FoZdhoC��DCOhGZdYn�KTDH�COI�Y\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[gO?�LOA3?BEcC�FGZ[LSI�p�ZdIKg.ZdhGZ[�Dld?�COIf��?\ËqLOEcFGl[?JhGhBp��DTfF@IVLSIf?BFG�V?Jl[?JhGh@N¥TfIf�fCOH9?JIKFGCOl�COIf�A3?BEGg�COhGZ[gO?Op.C�AfA3?JC�EcZdIVaZdI FG�V?oY\LSIfhWFWEcTfY\FGZdLSI¤COIf��TfIf�f?BEchWFGCOIf�fZbIVaoLON~H9?BFGC�AD�VLOE0hBp,COh��R?JldlUCOhRZdI¤H�COI�i LOFG�V?BEY\LOaSIfZ[FGZdgO?�AU�V?JIVLSH9?JIfC.p�ZdIfYBldTf�DZdIVa�aOEcCOH�H C�E�COID� Ec?JCOhWLSIfZdIVaV� �$COI�iºhGZdH9AUl[?�?\�VCOH9ADl[?Jh�C�EG?��Dl[?JID�fh LONFj�RL��RLOEc�fhBp�hGTfY0� ÂW�VLSTfhG?B�qLSC�FBpÅÃ�½EGLSCO�V�.ZdldlÎpÅà Âm�GC��B��ADZdCOIVLVpÅÃ�ÂWY\LSH9ADTfFW?BE�g,ZdEcTfhBpÅà ÂWYBldCOhGhGZdYBCOl)Y\LSH�AqLShG?BEJpÅÃCOIf��ÂWH9?JldL,�VE0COH�C�FGZdY�Y\LSIf�fTDY\FWLOEJ�ÅÃ�£�L9?\�,ADlbCOZdI�hGTfYc��AD�V?JIVLSH9?JIDC.pV�Dl[?JIf�fZbIVa�FG�V?BLOEci�¹¥C��f�DEG?Bg,ZbC�FW?J��ÂW��£¢Ã�»A3LShGZ[FGh�FG�fC�FkY\LSIfY\?BAfFGhkY\LSH9?)ZdInYBldTfhGFW?BEchBpOYBCOldl[?J� { � � { � �w µ zU¶�u vzf{ � u pS�M�fZbYc�nY\LSIfhGZdhWFvLONDY\?BEGFGCOZbI9Z[FW?JH�h�COIf�Y\?BEGFGCOZdI�EG?JlbC�FGZ[LSIfhFG�DC�F��fLSld��COH9LSIfa$FG�V?JH���X.TDYc��hWADCOY\?Jh�C�EG?�EG?JldC�FGZ[gO?Jl[i�hcH�COldl�pvFWEcCOIfhGZdFWLOEGi�Y\LSIfhWFWEcTDY\FGhBphW?Jl[?JY\FW?J�ºLSIºFG�V?�¦fi�N�EGLSH�lbC�EGaO?BE(�VLSH�COZdIfhJp)FWL�H9?B?BF(COIºZdH�H9?J�DZdC�FW?$IV?B?J�8pMhGTfY0� COh�TfIf�f?BEchWFGCOIf�fZbIVa�CADC�EGFGZbYBTfldC�E¢AD�fEcCOhW?LOEohW?JIKFW?JIfY\?O�M¨�Ly�R?BgO?BEJp3��?��VL IVLOF@COhGhGTfH�?�FG�fC�F�FG�V?Bi�C�EG?�If?JY\?JhGhGC�EcZdldi�FG�f?'� · � · � zU¶hGTfY0� hWADCOY\?Jh�If?B?J�V?J� FWL�TfIf�V?BE0hWFGCOIf� C�aSZ[gO?JI �Dl[?JID��p�hGZbIfY\?$FG�DC�F�YBCOI LSIfl[i �q?��V?BFW?BE0H�ZdIV?J� C�N�FW?BE�FG�V?�Dl[?JID���fCOh�3?B?JI�TfID�V?BEchWFWL,L,�8�¤��LOEc?BLygO?BEJpQ�fZ[Ëq?BEG?JIKF��Dl[?JID�fh�H�CJi�LSH Z[F��fZ¡Ë3?BEG?JIKF�?Jl[?JH9?JIKFGhLON)FG�V?¤ZdIVADTVFhWADCOY\?JhJp8COIf��Z[F�H�CJi�COldhWL��3?nIV?JY\?JhchGC�EGi�FWL�EG?JY\E0TfZ[FoCO�f�fZ[FGZ[LSIDCOl�ZdIfNmLOEcH C�FGZ[LSI�N�EGLSH LOFG�V?BEhWAUCOY\?Jh�ZdI�LOE0�V?BEFWL�TfIf�V?BEchGFGCOIf��C�Ul[?JIf����£¢�V?MC��UhWFWEcCOY\F�H�C�FG�V?JH�C�FGZdYBCOlqhWFWEcTDY\FGTVEG?MLON8C�Y\LSIfY\?BAfFGTfCOlqhWADCOY\?oY\LSIfhGZbhWFGhQLON8C�hW?BFLON`C�FWLSH�ZbY�?Jld?JH9?JI�FGh@FWLOaO?BFG�V?BE���Z[FG�$C�hW?BFoLONQEG?JlbC�FGZ[LSI$ZbIfhWFGCOIfY\?Jh@COH9LSIVa�FG�VLShW?n?Jl[?JH9?JIKFGh�| ¿�Ê8�Ω3LON�Y\LSTfEchW?OphGTfY0��C�Ec?BAfEG?JhW?JIKFGC�FGZ[LSI�IV?JY\?JhchGC�EcZdl[i�LSH�Z[FGhMFG�V?��,TfCOldZ[FGC�FGZdgO?OpV?\�,A3?BEcZ[?JIKFGZdCOl�COhWA3?JY\FGh�LON����fC�FMZdh)Ec?BAfEG?JhW?JIKFW?J�¹�FG�V?o�KTDCOldZdC�»0�'& � � { � ~w µ zD¶ � z4 v· � �Du C�EG?@ADC�EGFGZdCOlDN�TfIDY\FGZ[LSIfhkN�EGLSH FG�V?@ZdFW?JH COIf� EG?JldC�FGZ[LSI�ZdIfhGFGCOIfY\?Jh`LONLSIV?@hWADCOY\?¢FWL�FG�VLShW?MLON�COIVLOFG�f?BEJp,COID� { � � { � �w µ zU¶k· � w � �Ux=zVw�· � � � � w)( �Dx+*�u C�EG?�IV?BFj�RLOEG�.h`LON8Y\LSIfY\?BADFGTfCOlhWADCOY\?Jh�COIf��H�C�ADADZdIVaShRFG�fC�FMC�Ec?FWL��3?��Dl[?JIf�f?J�¤FWLOaO?BFG�f?BEJ�Ì � Í3Ï=Ð�Ñ�Ú�ÕyØÎå½Ð-,/.QÒÅÑfÔ0ØÎÚ�Õ=Ó�ßyÐWßRÒÅÓRÚ0Õ=ØDÐ 9yÝOÐ�ØÎÒÅнÓ�å�Ð�Ú0ÙSÔ0Øj×WæJÒ Ü�ê���×0Ó�ß�ÜÎÏ�Ð3Ñ�åjÏ�Ð�Û¢×�Ò ÜÎÑ�Ð½Ö ÙSÒÅÑUÔcØÎÚ�Õ�Ó�ß=ÐWß`ÒÅÓ�нæ\Ð�Ø�ê=ß=×WêQÐ 9=ÝOÐèØÎÒÁÐ�Ó�å½Ð½Ñ*�Ñ�Õ�åjÏo×cÑ~ÜÎÏ�×cÜ�Þ8Ï=нÓ@ÜÎÏ�ÐèØÎÐ�ÒÅÑ~Û)ÚcØÎÐkéOнÐ�Ø~ÒÅÓo×RÔ0ÖÁ×0Ñ�Ñ*�OÚcØ�Û)ÚcØÎÐ�ÝOÐW×cÓyÕyÜÎÑ8ÒÁÓ@×RÝ�ÒÅÖÅÐ#�=ÜÎÏ�Ð�ÖÅнæ\Ð�ÖKÔ0ÚBнÑ�Õ=Ý �=×0Ó�ß�ÜÎÏ�×GÜ�ÜÎÏ�ÒÅÑ8ÒÅÑ�×�Ñ¥Üj×cÜÎÐÞ3ÐkÚcÙçÜÎнÓ@Ý=ØÎÐ�ÙçÐ�Ø10�ÜÎÏ=Ð�ØÎÐ�Ù¡ÚcØÎÐ�ÜÎÏ�ÐkÒÅÛ¢×0Ô0Ð�Ñ�åjÏ�нۢ×32!4/57698;:<,=.5�=ß=ÒÅÑ�å½Õ=Ñ�Ñ�ÐWß@ÒÅÓ � � �� �=ÒÅÑ8нæ\нÓ�Û)Ú0ØÎÐké�×cÑ�ÒÅå�â

Page 10: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

£¢�f?@hGZbH9ADl[?JhWF��Dl[?JIf�Dh ¸ �M�fCygO?�FG�V?oNmLOE0H LON [�Z[aSTVEG?�À�pV�M�V?BEG?�� ¸ COIf��� Ç C�EG?�YBCOldld?J�¤FG�f? · � µ w9u vzf{ � u p�ÄZdh@YBCOldl[?J��FG�V? tv¶ ��� � u �zf{ �Dp3COIf��� FG�f? � � � � x�·�{�u �zD{ �D©3FG�V?�ldC�FWFW?BE�Y\LSIKFGCOZdIfhoY\LSIfY\?BAfFGTfCOlvhWFWEcTDY\FGTVEG?FG�fC�F�Zdh hG�DC�EG?J���,i�FG�V?�Fè��L�ZdIVAUTVF�hWADCOY\?Jh ¸ �S� r tv¶ ��� � �U· � LON�� ¸�� � Ç ��� � x � Y\LSIfhGZdhGFGh�LONC�hGADCOY\?�FWLOaO?BFG�V?BE¤�MZ[FG��Y\LSIfY\?BAfFGTDCOl¢H�C�AfADZbIVaSh� ¸�� ��p � Ç � ��p�COIf��� � �¤��£¢�f?BEG?(H�CJi��3?(H�COI�i�hGTfY0��Dl[?JID�VLSZd�fhBpO�UTVFQEG?JldC�FGZdgO?Jl[i�Nm?B� C�EG?�lbZ[�O?Jl[i�FWL��3?MZdIKFW?BEG?JhWFGZbIVaV�k£¢�V?BEG?BN�LOEG?�CO�D�fZ[FGZ[LSIfCOlfAfEcZdIfYBZdADl[?Jh�C�EG?�If?B?J�V?J�N�LOEQZd�V?JIKFGZ[Nmi.ZdIVaMFG�V?¢H9LShWFkZdIKFW?BEG?JhWFGZdIfa�A3LShGhGZd�DZdldZ[FGZd?JhBpyhWL�FG�fC�F��R?¢YBCOI9�V?z�DIV?�C tv¶ ��� � FWLo�3?�C@�Dld?JIf�VLSZd��FG�fC�FZdh ��v�� ��� � ����Z[FG��EG?JhWA3?JY\FQFWL�FG�V?JhW?¢AfE0ZdIfYBZ[ADld?JhB�A[fCOTfY\LSIfIDZ[?BE�COIf� £�TVE0IV?BEQhGTVaOaO?JhWFRCI,TfH��3?BEQLON�½LOAfFGZdH COldZ[FjiAfEcZbIfYBZ[ADl[?JhcäFG�DC�FnhW?BEcgO? FG�fZdh�ADTVEGA3LShW?�¹¥hW?B?(P)�fC�AfFW?BE¤À ��LONr| ¾�k��»0pk�DTfFFG�V?Bi�C�EG?¤FWLKL�g�C�aSTV?¤FWL$�3? ?JCOhGZdldiN�LOEcH�COldZ[�B?J�8��r FW?JIKFGC�FGZ[gO?�COIf���fZ[§¤YBTfl[FR�DTVFRAfEG?JYBZdhW?�H�C�FG�f?JH�C�FGZdYBCOl�C�AfAfEcLSCOYc��ZdhRaSZ[gO?JI�ZdI�rMAfA3?JIf�DZ¡��� LON| Ê $ �Îpq�DCOhW?J�$LSI$C�H9L.�fZ��DYBC�FGZdLSI(LONQFG�V?nYBC�FW?BaOLOEGi�FG�V?BLOEc?BFGZdY�IfLOFGZ[LSI�LON½AUTfhG�VLSTVFGà |~�8� �ΩqFG�fZdh@H9L,�DZ��DYBC�FGZ[LSIFGC��O?Jh�CO�fg�COIKFGC�aO?�LON�COI�LOE0�V?BEcZdIVa�EG?JldC�FGZdLSI�LSI�H9LOEGAD�fZbhGH�hBpq�MZ[FG��EG?JhWA3?JY\FoFWL(FG�V?JZ[E��,TfCOldZ[FèiOp8COh�fZdhcYBTfhGhW?J�ZdI | ¿�Ê8�Î�Q£¢�V?@ZdIKFGTfZ[FGZ[LSI¤Zdh`FG�DC�FRIVLOFG�DZdIVa�YBCOI��3?�CO�D�V?J� FWL�LOE)hGTV�DFWEcCOY\FW?J� N�EGLSH'hGTfY0�¤COI�LOAfFGZbH�COlD�Ul[?JIf�VLSZd��MZ[FG�fLSTVF`g.Z[LSldC�FGZdIfa�Y\LSIfhGZbhWFW?JIfY\i�LOE)hGZdH�ADldZdYBZ[FèinZbI¤hWLSH�?@��CJiO��¨ML=��?BgO?BEJpDFG�V?BEG?oYBCOI�hGFGZdldlf�3?oH9LOEG?@FG�fCOI�LSIV?�Dl[?JID��ZbI�FG�fZdhohW?JIfhW?OpvCOhCOI�?\�VCOH9ADl[?��fZbhGYBTfhGhW?J���3?Jl[L=�_�MZdldlvH�C��O?�gO?BEGi�YBl[?JC�EJ�9¼�FhG�VLSTDld��COldhWL(�3?9IVLOFW?J�FG�fC�FRFG�fZdhRIVLOFGZ[LSI¤LON8�Dl[?JID��?JCOhGZdldi9aO?JIV?BEcCOldZ[�B?JhRFWL�COI�i¤IKTfH��3?BE�LON�hW?JH�Z[LOFGZdY�hWADCOY\?JhBpVCOIf�¤?BgO?JI�FWL�C�EG�DZ[FWEcC�Eci�fZdC�aOE0COH�h LONhG?JH�Z[LOFGZdY$hWADCOY\?Jh�COIf�ºH9LOEGAD�fZbhGH�hBpRNmLOE��M�fZbYc��FG�f?BEG?�C�Ec?�H�COIKi�hGZ[aSIDZ��DYBCOIKF C�AfADldZbYBC�FGZ[LSIfhB�£¢�,TfhBp�FG�V?(?JH9AD�fCOhcZdhnLSI��VLSTV�Dld?�hcY\LOAq?(�Ul[?JIf�fZdIfa$ZdI | ¾�k�MhG?B?JH�h�hWLSH9?B���fC�F9LSTVF�LON@ADldCOY\?�ZdI�COl[aO?B�DEcCOZdYhW?JH�ZdLOFGZdYBhBpf�3?JYBCOTfhW?nZ[FGhMH C=�½LOE@C�AfADldZdYBC�FGZdLSIfh)Fji,ADZdYBCOlbl[i�ZbI�gOLSl[gO?�H�TfldFGZ[ADl[?(ÂWhGY\LOA3?JhGÃ�C�EcZdhGZbIVa�NmEGLSH H�TDl[FGZ[ADl[?hWADCOY\?Jh�COIf��H9LOEcAD�fZdhGH h�COH9LSIfa�FG�V?JH(�

��� ���

��

�� �

��� ���

��

�� ��

� ¸ � Ç

[�Z[aSTVEG?�À ��r ��l[?JIf��>@ZbC�aOEcCOH

¼�F9�fCOhnAq?BE0�fC�ADhnIVLOF��q?B?JI�hGTf§ YBZ[?JIKFGl[i�?JH9AD�fCOhcZ[�B?J��ZdI�FG�f?���£ ldZdFW?BEcC�FGTVEG?¤FG�fC�F��Dl[?JIf�fZbIVa��VL,?Jh9IVLOFCOl[��CJi.h�aSZ[gO?$C�TfIfZd�,TV?�EG?JhGTDl[FB��[VLOE�?\�.COH9AUl[?Op�FG�f?(NmLSldldLy�MZdIfa�C�EG?�N�LSTVE��fZ¡Ë3?BEG?JIKF9�Dl[?JIf�fh�LON�Y\LSIfY\?BADFGTfCOlhWADCOY\?Jh�N�LOE�ÂW�VLSTfhW?JÃoCOIf��½�3LSC�FGÃ-���VLSTfhW?B�3LSC�FB©S�3LSC�FG�VLSTfhG?O©�COH9AD�fZd�DZ[LSTfhA�2;�©OCOIf���3LSC�F�NmLOEkH9L=g,ZdIfa@�VLSTDhW?JhB�£¢�V?�lbCOhWF H�Cyi��3?�C��UZ[F�hGTVEGADEcZdhGZdIfaVpk�DTVF9¼�LSIfY\?�hGCy� hGTDYc��C��qLSC�F¤ZdI!�@�DCOI�p¢X.Y\LOFGldCOID��p�FWE0COIfhWA3LOEGFGZdIVaAfEG?BN¥C��fEcZbYBC�FW?J���VLSH9?Jh)FWL¤C�IV?JC�EG�,i�ZbhGldCOIf����£¢�V?BEc?C�EG?�COldhWL�hGLSH9?LOFG�V?BEJpD?BgO?JI�l[?JhGh¢LO�Kg.Z[LSTfh)�Ul[?JIf�fh}| ¿�� �Î�

£¢�f?�P)�$£ g.Z[?B� LON¢H9?BFGC�AD�VLOE�COhGhWL.YBZdC�FW?Jh�COhWA3?JY\FGh�LON)LSIf?¤�VLSH�COZbI�FWL�COIVLOFG�V?BEJpkCOIf���V?JhGY\EcZd�q?JhFG�fZdhCOhGhWL.YBZdC�FGZ[LSI$TfhGZdIfa�C�H�C�AfADZbIVaVpfLON��M�fZdY0�(FG�V?�FGC�EGaO?BF��VLSH COZdI�Y\LSIfY\?BEcIDhM�M�DC�F¢FG�V?�H9?BFGC�AU�VLOE@Zbh�ÂWC��3LSTVFB�ÅÃ�oI(FG�f?�LOFG�V?BE@�fCOIf��pD��£ g,Z[?B��h¢H9?BFGC�AD�VLOE0hMCOh�ÂWY\EGLShGh½�jhWAUCOY\?nH�C�ADADZdIVaShGÃnFG�fC�F@C�EcZdhW?�NmEGLSH �Dl[?JIf�DZdIVa�Y\LSI.�Y\?BAfFGTfCOlVhGADCOY\?Jhk?\�.FWEcCOY\FW?J��N�EGLSH FG�V?¢�VLSH COZdIfh�ZdIKgOLSl[gO?J���([VLOEQ?\�VCOH9ADl[?Op�FG�V?¢H9?BFGC�AD�VLOEÂWH�i�l[LygO?MZbhvCoEcLShW?JÃC�EcZdhG?Jh�N�EGLSH �Dl[?JIf�DZdIVa�Y\LSIfY\?BAfFGTDCOlRhGADCOY\?Jh�NmLOE�ÂWH�i5l[L=gO?JÃ�COID��½EcLShW?OpÅÃ�hGTfY0��FG�DC�FnFG�f?�Zd�f?JI�FGZ��UYBC�FGZ[LSI�LONÌ�(½Í3Ï=ÒÅÑ�ßyÒÁ×0Ô0Øj×cÛ ÒÅÑ�àmÕ�Ý=Ñ�Ò ßyÐ)ß=ÚWÞ8Ó=ã@ÙçØÎÚ0Û ÜÎÏ�×cÜQÕ=Ñ�ÐWß�éBê���×cÕ�å½Ú0Ó�Ó=ÒÁÐèØ`×0Ó�ß�Í,Õ=ØÎÓ=Ð�Ø��KÒÁÓ�ÜÎÏ�×GÜQÚ�Õ=Ø`×GØ�ØÎÚWÞ8Ñ�Ô0ÚoÕ�Ý �KÞ8Ò ÜÎÏ�ÜÎÏ=ÐÔ�Ð�Ó�Ð�ØÎÒÅå���Ú0Ó�ÜÎÏ�Ð�éOÚcÜ�ÜÎÚ�Û �B×cÓ�ß�ÜÎÏ=Ð�é�ÖÅнÓ�ß���Ú�Ó�ÜÎÏ�Ð�ÜÎÚ�Ý�âfÍ3Ï�ÒÅÑDÒÁÑUß=Õ=Ð3ÜÎÚQ×�ÝOÐ�ØÎæ0×0Ñ�ÒÅæ\Ð8×0Ó�ßRÓ�×GÜÎÕ=Øj×cÖ�ß=Õ�×0ÖÅÒ Ü�êRéOÐ�Ü�ÞqннÓRÜÎÏ=нÚ0ØÎÒÅнÑ×0Ó�ßMÛ)ÚJßyнÖÅÑ*��ÒÅÓ¢ÜÎÏ�Ð�Ñ�Ð�Ó�Ñ�ÐvÜÎÏ�×cÜ3ÜÎÏ=нÑ�ÐvÜÎÐ�ØÎÛ)Ñ�×GØÎÐkÕ�Ñ�ÐWߢÒÅÓ@Û¢×GÜÎÏ�нۢ×GÜÎÒÁå½×0ÖOÖÅÚ�Ô0ÒÁå)0�Ñ�нР� нå�ÜÎÒÅÚ�Ó��=â .`ÙçÚ0Ø8Ù¡ÕyØ�ÜÎÏ�Ð�Ø8ßyÒÅÑ�å½Õ�Ñ�Ñ�ÒÅÚ�Ó�â )vÕyØå½Ú0Óyæ�нÓBÜÎÒÁÚ0Ó�ÒÅÑ8×cÖÁÑ�ÚRå½Ú�Ó=Ñ�ÒÁÑ¥ÜÎÐ�ÓJÜ8Þ8Ò ÜÎÏ�ÜÎÏ=Ð�Þ3×Wê¢ÜÎÏ�×cÜ�Ñ�Õ=åèÏ@ß=ÒÁ×0ÔcØj×0Û)Ñ8×cØÎÐvÕ�Ñ�Õ�×cÖÅÖÅê�ßJØj×WÞ8Ó�ÒÅÓ�Û¢×GÜÎÏ�нۢ×GÜÎÒÁå�Ñ*��×cÑ3Þ3нÖÅÖK×0Ñ3Þ8Ò ÜÎÏ�ÜÎÏ=ÐÒÅÛ¢×0Ô0ÐkÑ�åèÏ=нۢ×'2!4/57698;:<,/. $[Ñ�ÒÅÓ�å½Ð���ÒÅÑMàmÛ)Ú0ØÎнã'&èâ � ÖÅÑ�Ú����×0Õ=å½Ú�Ó=Ó�ÒÅÐ�Ø�×0Ó�ß@Í,ÕyØÎÓ�Ð�Ø�ßyÚRÓ�ÚcÜ~ÒÁÓ=å½ÖÅÕ�ßyÐvÜÎÏ�ÐkÛ¢×cÝ�� �!�)âÌ 2 ��ÚWÞ3нæ\ÐèØ�� � "� �=Õ�Ñ�нÑfÜÎÏ�Ð3ÜÎÐèØÎÛ à$#&%�')(�')*+%-,.(Jã��éOнåW×cÕ�Ñ�Ð8Ò ÜUÒÅÑDÛ)Ú0ØÎÐ8ßyнÑ�å�ØÎÒÅÝ=ÜÎÒÅæ\Ð�ÚcÙKÏ=ÚWÞ ÜÎÏ=ÒÅÑUÑ�Ý�×0å½Ð�ÒÅÑDÕ�Ñ�ÐWßRÒÅÓ¢×cÝ�Ý�ÖÅÒÅåW×GÜÎÒÁÚ0Ó�ÑÜÎÚ�Õ=Ñ�Ð�Ø~ÒÁÓBÜÎÐ�Ø�Ù¡×0å½ÐQßyнÑ�ÒÅÔ�Ó�â

À $

Page 11: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

FG�V?Fè��L�Z[FW?JH�h¤ÂWl[LygO?JÃ�COIf��½EGLShG?JàZdI(FG�f?�Dl[?JIf�(hGADCOY\?�aSZ[gO?JhMEcZdhW?�FWL�C�Y\LOEGEG?JhGAqLSID�V?JIfY\?��3?BFj�R?B?JI$Y\?BEcFGCOZdIZ[FW?JH�h�ZbI$FG�f?9EGLShW?9hWADCOY\?�COIf��FG�f?nFGC�EcaO?BF�l[LygO?¤hWADCOY\?O��X.TfYc� � � wyz4 � �Ux�·�{�t�¶ ��� ��u C�EG?�� � � �Z��� � �F{BpvZdIFG�fC�FnCOh�HnTfYc��COh�AqLShchGZ[�Dl[?�LON�FG�V?¤FGC�EGaO?BFnhGADCOY\?¤Zdh�ZdH9A3LOEGFW?J��ZbI�FWL$FG�V?��Dl[?JID��hWADCOY\?Op��M�V?BEc?JCOhLSIfl[i��O?BiCOhWA3?JY\FGh�N�EGLSH'FG�V?hWLSTVE0Y\?ohGADCOY\?OpfCOhGhWL.YBZdC�FW?J�(�MZdFG�¤?Jld?JH9?JI�FGh�FG�DC�F¢�fCJgO?�3?B?JI�Zd�V?JIKFGZ��f?J�¤�MZ[FG��?Jl[?JH�?JI�FGh)LONFG�V?¢FGC�EcaO?BF�hWADCOY\?Op,C�EG?MZdH�AqLOEcFW?J��pO?O� aV�[p,hG��?B?BF`hcH9?JldlVCOIf��C�FWFWE0COY\FGZ[gO?�Y\LSl[LOEy©,H9LOEc?BLygO?BEJp.IfCOH9?JhkN�EGLSH_FG�f?¢FWLOAhWADCOY\?�FGC��O?�AfEG?JY\?J�f?JIfY\?LygO?BE@FG�VLShW?�ZdI�FG�V?hWLSTVE0Y\?�hWADCOY\?OpDhGL�FG�fC�F¢EG?JlbC�FGZ[LSIfh)ZdI�FG�V?�hWLSTVEcY\?�hGADCOY\?�3?JY\LSH9?ÂWC�FWFWEcZ[�UTVFW?J�fÃ�FWL�ZdFW?JH�h�ZdI FG�f?�FGC�EGaO?BF¢hGADCOY\?O���oTVE�C�AfAfEGLSCOY0�(�fZ¡Ë3?BEch�NmEGLSH LOEGFG�VL.�VLy����£ IVLOF�LSIDl[i�ZdI¤FG�fC�F�R?�COldl[L=��H COI�i�H9LOEc?��.ZdIf�fh)LONQhGFWEcTfY\FGTVEG?�ZdI�LSTVE@hWADCOY\?Jh�¹¥COho�fZdhGYBTfhchW?J�(�3?Jl[Ly��ZdI$X,?JY\FGZdLSI�ÊV�Á¾S»0p3�DTVF�COldhWLZdI¤FG�fC�F���?��VL�IVLOF �fEchWF�Y\LSIfhWFWE0TfY\F)C�H�ZbIfZdH�COlUZdH�C�aO?oZdI FG�f?@�Ul[?JIf� hGADCOY\?�COIf��FG�V?JI�½AfEGL��W?JY\FGÃ�FG�fC�F)hGCOH9?H�C�FW?BEcZbCOl`�DCOYc��FWL�FG�V? FGC�EcaO?BF�hWADCOY\?Opk�DTVFnZdIfhWFW?JCO�8p��R?¤�UTfZdld��FG�f?¤?JIKFGZ[EG?¤EG?JhGTfl[FnhWFWEcTfY\FGTfEG?¤ZdI�FG�V?��Dl[?JIf�hWADCOY\?O��£¢�KTDh�Z[FRZdhRIVLOF�FG�V?@YBCOhG?@N�LOE)Tfh�FG�fC�FBpfZdI¤NmLOEcH ZdIVaFG�V?o�Dld?JIf��p�?Jld?JH9?JI�FGh�C�EG?oAfEc?BNm?BEG?JIKFGZdCOldldinLSH Z[FWFW?J�N�EGLSH FG�f?MFGC�EGaO?BF)hWADCOY\?Op,LSIfl[i�FWLn�3?MEG?JhWFWLOEc?J�¤TVA3LSI9ADEGL��½?JY\FGZdLSI�p,COh��MZ[FG� FG�[email protected]\?J�fTVEG?M�f?JhGY\EcZ[�3?J��ZdI-| ÊOÊ8�Î�X.ZdIDY\?)P)�$£��fCOh��3?B?JI�H�COZdIfl[iY\LSIDY\?BEcIV?J�n�MZ[FG�nN¥COH�ZdldZ[?Jh�LONUH�?BFGC�AD�VLOEch��fCyg,ZdIfa@C�hG�DC�EG?J�nADC�FWFW?BEcI�pO�M�f?BEG?JCOh��£_�fCOho�3?B?JI�H9LOEG?9Y\LSIfY\?BEcIV?J����Z[FG���VLy� IVL=gO?JlkH9?BFGC�AD�VLOE0h�YBCOI��q?�TfIf�f?BEchWFWL,L,��pqFG�V?9Fè��L(FG�V?BLOE0Z[?Jh�C�EG?Y\LSH9ADC�FGZd�Dl[?OpDCOIf�$YBCOI��3LOFG��ADldCJi(C EGLSl[?�ZdI�TfIf�V?BEchGFGCOIf�fZdIVa9Y\LSH9AUl[?\��ldCOIVaSTfC�aO?O�)£¢�fZbh¢COIf��Ec?JldC�FW?J��ZdhchGTV?JhC�EG?��DZdhGYBTfhGhG?J�¤��Z[FG�(H�COIKi�ZbI�FW?BEG?JhGFGZdIVa9�V?BFGCOZdldhMZdI�| ÊOÊ8�Î�

£¢�f?¤Y\LSIfY\?BAfFGTDCOl�hWAUCOY\?JhBpkH�C�AfADZdIfaShCOIf�5�Dl[?JIf�fZbIVa�LON¢Y\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[gO?�ldZdIVaSTDZdhWFGZdYBh�hW?B?JH �R?Jldl`CO�fC�ADFW?J��N�LOEFWEG?JC�FGZdIfa�H COI�iºCOhWA3?JY\FGh�LON�ldZ[FW?BE0C�FGTVEG?OpMCOh(ZdIp| ��¿ �Îp@COh���?Jlbl@COh(hGLSH9?�EG?JY\?JI�F�FWEG?JID�fh�ZdI C�EGFBp�ZdIDYBldTf�fZdIfa¹�FG�V?(gO?BEGi�C�AfFGldi5IfCOH9?J�q»nY\LSIfY\?BAfFGTfCOl¢C�EcF�H9LygO?JH9?JIKFBp)COIf���MZdFG�5FG�f?�Y\LSIfY\?BAfFGTfCOl¢COhGAq?JY\FGh�LON��RLOEG�.h�ZdIH�COIKi�LOFG�V?BE¤hWFji.l[?JhBp��M�fZdY0��C�Ec?�LON�FW?JI��V?JhcZ[aSIV?J��FWL�AfEGL=gOLO�O?�Y\LSIfY\?BAfFGTfCOl)Y\LSIf¦DZdY\FGh�LOE9FWL�N�LOEcY\?�TfI,TfhGTfCOlY\LSIfY\?BAfFGTDCOl~�Dld?JIf�fhB�¢�oIV?�ZbH9A3LOEGFGCOI�F�C�AfADldZdYBC�FGZdLSI�Zdh)FG�V?nY\LSH��UZdIfC�FGZ[LSI�LONQH�TfhcZdYCOIf�$l[iKE0ZdYBhBpDCOh@hW�.Zdldl[N¥Tfldl[ihWFGTf�DZ[?J�(TfhGZdIfa�Y\EcLShGh½�j�VLSH�COZbI�H�C�AfADZbIVaShR�Ki�C~Cy�¢EG?JIfY\? &q�DZ[�OL=�MhW�.Z1|(�.À��Î��¨�Ly�R?BgO?BEJpDFG�f?NmE0COH9?B��LOEc��hG?B?JH�hFWL,L�Ec?JhWFWEcZdY\FW?J�ºN�LOE�hGFGTf�Vi.ZdIVa��Dld?JIf�fZdIVa �(� � �m� � HnTfhGZbY�p)?O� aV�[p@�fC�E0H9LSI�iOp�A3LSl[iKAU�VLSI�iOp)A3LSl[i,Ec�KiKFG�DH(p�?BFGY��[p�3?JYBCOTfhW?�H�TfhcZdYBCOlMhWFWE0TfY\FGTVEG?�Zbh ZdIf�f?BEG?JI�FGldi��DZ[?BEcC�EcY0�fZdYBCOl�p�COIf�º�V?JIfY\?$YBCOIDIVLOF �3?$CO�f?J�KTfC�FW?Jldi��V?JhGY\EcZ[�3?J�TfhGZbIVa¤LSIDl[i$C�FWLSH�ZbY9?Jl[?JH9?JIKFGhCOIf��EG?JlbC�FGZ[LSI�ZdIfhWFGCOIDY\?JhCOH9LSIVa(FG�V?JH���e�If�f?BEchWFGCOIf�fZbIVa¤�VL=� C(ADC�EcFGZdYBTfldC�EH9?Jl[L.�ViOpDY0�VLOEc�$hW?J�KTf?JIfY\?OpUCOIf��Ec��i,FG�fH YBCOI��RLOEG��FWLOaO?BFG�V?BEoEG?J�KTDZ[EG?Jh¢YBl[LShG?�C�FWFW?JI�FGZdLSI�FWL¤FG�V?�Y\LSH9A3LSIV?JIKFIVLOFW?JhBp3AD�fEcCOhW?JhBp3Yc�VLOE0�fhoCOIf���3?JC�FGhBp3COh@��?Jlbl�COh@FWL�FG�V?JZ[EohGTV��Y\LSH9A3LSIV?JIKFGhB� [VLOEcFGTfIfC�FW?Jl[iOp8Z[F@C�AfA3?JC�Ech�FG�fC�FFG�V?¢CO�f�f?J��aO?JIV?BEcCOldZ[Fèi�LON3hW?JH�ZdLOFGZdY�hWADCOY\?JhQCOIf�9hG?JH�Z[LOFGZdY)H9LOEcAD�fZdhGH hBp�COh`hW�O?BFGYc�V?J�¤ZdI�FG�V?¢IV?\�.FQhGTV�UhW?JY\FGZ[LSI�pZdh�CO�V?J�KTDC�FW?¤N�LOE�hGTDYc�5ADTVEGA3LShW?JhB��¼½I�FG�V?�eoP¢XV>Ä��?JCOIfZbIVa$COIf��PRLSH9ADTfFGC�FGZ[LSIYC�C��8p [fLJ��¨@C�EGEG?JlblQCOIf��¼�fCygO?MCOI�?\�,A3?BEcZbH9?JI�FGCOl,�Dld?JIf�fZdIVa@COl[aOLOEcZ[FG�DH(pO�M�fZdY0���fCOh�aO?JIV?BEcC�FW?J�¤IVLygO?JlVH9?BFGC�AU�VLOEchQTfhG?J��pO�M�fZdY0��ZdInFGTVEcI�R?BEG?�TfhW?J�(ZbI�aO?JIV?BEcC�FGZdIVa AqL,?JH�hr| ¿�� �Î�1]�\ ` .H34g�)f5&g�# ` �*ef# .�7-e ' / ` 58d � # 5 �*d&ef, ��,�.�'*/ g�'*0�R?BNmLOEc? ZdIKFWEGL,�DTfYBZdIVa�COl[aO?B�fEcCOZdY9hG?JH�Z[LOFGZdYBh�COIf��hGFWEcTfY\FGTVEcCOlv�Dld?JIf�fZdIVaVp�Z[F�ZdhoaOL,L.��FWL��3?�YBld?JC�EC��qLSTfF�FG�V?JZ[EAD�fZbl[LShWLOAD�fZbYBCOlULOE0Z[?JI�FGC�FGZdLSI��)£¢�V?EG?JCOhGLSI�N�LOEMFGC��.ZdIVa¤hGAq?JYBZbCOl8YBC�EG?���Z[FG�(FG�fZdhMZdh¢FG�fC�FBpqZdI(Æ�?JhWFW?BE0I�YBTDl[FGTVEG?OpH�C�FG�V?JH C�FGZdYBCOl8N�LOEcH�COldZbhGH�h)C�EG?LON�FW?JI$aSZ[gO?JI�C hGFGC�FGTfh¢�3?BiOLSIf�(���fC�F¢FG�V?Bi(�V?JhW?BEcgO?O� [VLOE�?\�.COH�ADl[?OpD^�TfYBldZd��¢EGLOFW?Op�ÂW£¢�V?@ldCJ��hQLON8IfC�FGTVEc?�C�EG?��DTVFQFG�V?oH�C�FG�V?JH C�FGZdYBCOlDFG�fLSTVaS��FGh�LON6�@L.���ÅÃ�X.ZdH ZdldC�Ecl[iOp�FG�V?�ÂWhGZ[FGTfC�FGZdLSIfhGÃZdI$FG�V?�hGZ[FGTfC�FGZ[LSI�hW?JH�COIKFGZdYBh@LON���C�EG��ZdhW?�COID� =v?BEGEciOpq���fZdYc�$EG?JhW?JH��Dl[?�Y\LSIfY\?BAfFGTDCOlvhGADCOY\?Jh�¹��DTVF@C�EG?9H9LOEG?hWLOAD�DZdhWFGZdYBC�FW?J�8��A3?BEc�fC�AUhD�h� ��hGLOAD�fZdhWFGZbYBC�FW?J�U»0pkC�EG?¤Y\LSIfhcZd�V?BEG?J�5FWL$�3?�COY\FGTfCOldl[i�?\�VZdhWFGZdIfaVpvZd�f?JCOl*=`lbC�FWLSIfZdY?JIKFGZ[FGZ[?Jh | � �Î��X,LSH9?B���fC�Fl[?JhGh�aOE0COIf�fl[iOp�LSIV? H�Z[aS�KF�Y\LSIfhcZd�V?BE�FG�fC�FnY\LSIfY\?BAfFGTfCOl�hWADCOY\?Jh�hGLSH9?J�VLy� COl[EG?JCO�Vi?\�VZdhWF�ZbI(FG�V?��DEcCOZdI��)¨�Ly�R?BgO?BEJp3FG�V?�A3LSZdIKF)LONkg.Z[?B� LONkFG�DZdh)ADC�A3?BE�Zbh¢FG�fC�FoCOldl8N�LOEcH�COlbZdhGH�h)C�EG?�Y\LSIfhWFWE0TfY\FW?J�ZdI�FG�V?Y\LSTfEchW?LON�hWLSH9?FGCOhG�UpDhcTfYc�(COh�hGYBZ[?JIKFGZ��DYohWFGTf�Vi�LOE¢?JIVaSZbIV?B?BEcZdIVa9�V?JhcZ[aSI�p.NmLOEMFG�V?�V?JTVEcZbhWFGZdY@ADTVEGA3LShW?LON8N¥COYBZdldZ[FGC�FGZbIVa�Y\LSIfhcZd�V?BEcC�FGZ[LSI¤LON~Y\?BEGFGCOZbI¤ZdhchGTV?JhRZdI FG�DC�F�FGCOhW�q�`e@If�V?BERFG�fZdh�g,Zd?B�pKCOldlUFG�V?BLOEcZd?JhRC�Ec?@hGZdFGTfC�FW?J�hWL.YBZdCOl8?JIKFGZ[FGZ[?JhJpqH�C�FG�f?JH�C�FGZdYBCOl�FG�V?BLOEcZ[?Jh@IVL¤ld?JhGhMFG�DCOI�LOFG�V?BE0hB©ULONQY\LSTfEchW?Op3FG�fZdh��VLK?Jh�IVLOFoH9?JCOI�FG�DC�F�FG�V?BiC�EG?�IfLOF¢TfhW?BN¥Tfl��

P�lbCOhGhGZdYBCOl@hW?JH�Z[LOFGZbYBh��RCOh�N�LSTfIf�V?J�º�,iºP��fC�E0l[?Jh�X.COIf�V?BEch�=v?JZ[EcY\?�|~�O¿ �COIf� [V?BE0�fZdIfCOIf� �V?�X.COTfhchGTVEG?|~��k�`ZdI�FG�f?�ldC�FW?�IfZdIV?BFW?B?JIKFG��Y\?JIKFGTVEGiO��=v?JZ[EcY\?9��COh�COI�r@H9?BEcZbYBCOI�l[LOaSZdYBZdCOI�Y\LSIDY\?BEcIV?J���MZdFG��AfEGLO�Dl[?JH h�LON

ÀOÀ

Page 12: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

H9?JCOIfZbIVanCOID�¤Ec?BNm?BEG?JIDY\?Op,���VLnY\LSIDYBldTf�V?J��FG�fC�F�FG�V?JhW?�C�EG?oEG?JlbC�FGZ[LSIfCOlUEcC�FG�V?BE�FG�fCOI(�V?JIVLOFGC�FGZdLSIfCOl�pVCOIf�¤�M�VLCOldhWL�H�CO�V?�COI¤ZdIV¦DTf?JI�FGZdCOlV�DZdhWFGZdIfY\FGZdLSI9COH9LSIVa�H�L,�V?Jh`LON3EG?BNm?BEc?JIfY\?Op,COhRhWi.H��3LSldZbY�p�ZdIf�V?\�VZdYBCOl�pOLOERZdY\LSIfZdY�¹¥hW?B?N�LKLOFGIVLOFW? �O»0��X.COTDhGhGTVEG?OpqC�X,�MZdhGh�ldZdIVaSTDZdhWFBpf��COI�FW?J��FWL(TfID�V?BEchWFGCOIf�$�VLy� N�?JC�FGTVEG?Jh@LON`ldCOIfaSTfC�aO?JhoEG?JldC�FW?nFWLH9?JCOIfZbIVaShBpQCOIf���V?�?JH9AU�fCOhGZ[�B?J���DZdIDC�EGi�Nm?JC�FGTfEG?Jh9COIf���V?JIVLOFGC�FGZ[LSIDCOl)H9?JCOIfZdIVaV����LOEG?(Ec?JY\?JI�F9FG�fZbIV�O?BEchBphGTfY0��COh*[fEG?JIfYc��ldZ[FW?BE0C�EGi�FG�V?BLOE0ZdhWF*�MLSldCOIf����C�EGFG�V?JhG|~� �ÎpKY\LSH��DZdIf?J��COIf�9?\�.FW?JIf�V?J� FG�V?JhW?¢FG�V?BLOE0Z[?JhBpKY\Ec?JC�FGZdIVaC�A3Ly�R?BEGN¥TfloldCOIVaSTfC�aO?�N�LOE�YBTfl[FGTVEcCOloCOIf� H�?J�fZdC�hWFGTf�fZ[?JhJpM�M�fZbYc� ZdIºg�C�E0Z[LSTfh�gO?BEchGZ[LSIDh(�fCOh��3?B?JI YBCOldl[?J�hW?JH�ZdLOFGZdYBhBp~hW?JH Z[LSl[LOaOiOp�hWFWEcTfY\FGTVE0COldZdhGH(p�COIf���DIfCOldl[i�AqLShGF½�jhWFWEcTfY\FGTVE0COldZdhGH(�9¨�Ly�R?BgO?BEJp�FG�fZdho�3L.�Vi�LON�FG�V?BLOEGildCOYc�,hMFG�V?�H�C�FG�V?JH C�FGZdYBCOl8AfEc?JYBZdhGZ[LSI(IV?B?J�f?J�(NmLOE�hGYBZ[?JIKFGZ��DY�COIfCOl[i.hGZdhJpfCOIf��COldhWL��fLK?Jh�IVLOF¢CO�f�VEG?Jhch¢�Vi.IfCOH�ZdYhGZ[aSIDhBp,hGL,YBZdCOl3ZdhchGTV?Jh�hGTfY0�(COh)C�EcZdhW?oZdI�Y\LSldldC��3LOEcC�FGZ[LSI8pKLOE)FG�V?�hWi.hWFW?JH�C�FGZbY�H�C�AfADZdIfa�LON�hcZ[aSIfh�ZdI�LSIV?�hWi.hWFW?JHFWL�hGZ[aSIfhnZdI�COIVLOFG�V?BEJ©RH9LOEG?BL=gO?BEJp�H�COIKi�gO?BE0hGZ[LSIfh�FW?JIf��FWLy��C�Ec�fh9C =`ldC�FWLSIDZdhWFng,Z[?B� LON�hcZ[aSIfhB��r�l[aO?B�DEcCOZdYhW?JH�ZdLOFGZdYBhBpQ�M�DZdYc�5�RCOh�LOE0Z[aSZdIfCOldldi��f?BgO?Jl[LOA3?J��COh9C�N�LSTfIf�fC�FGZdLSI5N�LOE9TfhW?BE9ZdIKFW?BEGN¥COY\?��V?JhGZ[aSI�pQC�FWFW?JH�AfFGh�FWLLygO?BE0Y\LSH9?$FG�f?JhW?�AfEcLO�Dl[?JH�hB�!Æ�?$IVL=� aSZ[gO?�COI ZdIKFGTfZ[FGZ[gO?�ZdIKFWEGL.�fTfY\FGZ[LSI�FWL5FG�V?���CJi�FG�fC�F¤Z[F�FWEG?JC�FGh¤FG�V?hWFWEcTDY\FGTVEG?�LONMY\LSH�ADl[?\��hGZ[aSIfhJpvhGTDYc��COh�HnTfhGZdYBCOl`hGY\LOEG?JhBpk�3L,LO�,hBp�COIf��aOEcC�AD�fZdYBCOl�TfhW?BEnZdI�FW?BEcN�COY\?JhB�$>�?BFGCOZbldhLSH�Z[FWFW?J�$�V?BEG?YBCOI��q?�N�LSTfIf��ZdI�| ¿�ÊfpU¿�,pq¿8� �ΩfFG�fZdh¢FG�V?BLOEGi�LOEcZ[aSZdIDC�FW?J��ZdI(COI�?JC�E0l[i¤?\�.A3?BEcZdH9?JIKFGCOl8hWFGTD�Vi¤LONHnTfl[FGZdH9?J�DZdC�ld?JC�EcIfZdIVa | ¿�� �ÎpUCOIf�(��COh¢CO�fC�AfFW?J��FWL TfhW?BEMZbI�FW?BEGN¥COY\?��V?JhcZ[aSI(ZdI�| ¿O¾ �Î�

r u ��� · �Dw=·�{ u �8uBw ��� LOE u ��� · �Dw=·�{ w�� � �Dx�� Y\LSIfhcZdhWFGh�LON ��C uy·%� � zVw µ x �Dp)�M�DZdYc�!aSZ[gO?Jh¤IDCOH9?Jh�N�LOEhWLOEGFGh ¸ ��p`hGTV�DhGLOEGFGhBpkCOIf��LOA3?BEcC�FGZ[LSIfhB©RhWLSH9? z��~· � � u ©�C ¶ � � � ¶ �Dx%� � x�· � � LSI�hWLOEGFGh��fCyg,ZbIVa�C�H�C��VZdHnTfH?Jl[?JH9?JIKF9YBCOldl[?J��FG�V? w � hWLOEGFB©)COIf��C �x�· �Dx�·mw � �Ux � � x�· � � LSI�FG�V?(Y\LSIfhWFWEcTfY\FWLOE0hnC�F9?JCOY0��l[?BgO?Jl�pk���V?BEG?Y\LSIfhWFWE0TfY\FWLOEch)C�EG?@LOA3?BEcC�FGZ[LSIfhRFG�fC�F��DTfZbld��IV?B� hGZ[aSIDh`N�EGLSH aSZ[gO?JI�ADC�EGFGhB��X.LOEGFGh�YBldCOhGhGZ[N�i9FG�V?@ADC�EGFGhRLON�hcZ[aSIfhBpCOH9LSIVa �M�fZdY0�(�fC�FGC�hWLOEGFGh¢AfEGLyg.Zd�V?og�COldTV?Jh)N�LOE¢C�FWFWEcZ[�UTVFW?Jh)LONkhGZ[aSIfh¹¥hcTfYc��COhMY\LSl[LOE�COIf�(hcZ[�B?=»0�`rM�.Z[LSH h¢C�EG?Y\LSIfhWFWE0COZdI�FGh@LSI�FG�V?nA3LShGhGZ[�Dld?�hGZ[aSIfh�LON`C�hWi.hWFW?JH(�}C8?BgO?Jlbh�?\�.AfEG?Jhch�FG�f?��M�fLSl[?\�ÎADC�EGF@�fZ[?BEcC�EcY0��i�LON`Y\LSH9ADl[?\�hGZ[aSIDhBpS�M�V?BEc?JCOhkAfEcZ[LOE0Z[FGZ[?Jhv?\�,ADEG?JhGhkFG�V?MEG?JldC�FGZ[gO?MZbH9A3LOEGFGCOIfY\?)LON3Y\LSIfhWFWEcTfY\FWLOE0h`COIf�9FG�f?JZ[E`C�EGaSTfH�?JI�FGhB©.hWL.YBZdCOlZdhGhcTV?Jh�ADldCyiCOI�ZdH�AqLOEcFGCOI�F8EcLSl[?�ZdI��V?BFW?BEcH�ZdIDZdIVa)FG�V?JhW?�LOEc�V?BEcZbIVaShB�~£¢�DZdh8C�AfAfEcLSCOYc�n�fCOh�CMEcZdY0��H�C�FG�V?JH C�FGZdYBCOlN�LSTfIf�fC�FGZ[LSI8p~?O� aV�[p | Ê $Vp�Ê�¾.p~ÊfÀ��ÎpkhGZbIfY\? C�hcZ[aSIfC�FGTVEG? ADldTfho?J�,TfC�FGZ[LSIfCOlRC��VZ[LSH�h�Zbh�COI�COldaO?B�fEcCOZdY FG�V?BLOEGiOp�LSI�M�fZbYc��FG�V?BEG?)Zdh�ColdC�EGaO?�ldZ[FW?BEcC�FGTVEc?O�vr!FG�V?BLOEGiK�Î�DCOhW?J��C�AfAfEGLSCOY0�9ZdhvAfEG?BN�?BEcC��Dl[?�FWLCoH9LOEG?�Y\LSIfY\EG?BFW?¢hW?BF½�Î�DCOhG?J�C�AfAfEcLSCOYc��p.�3?JYBCOTfhW?oZ[F�COlbl[Ly�MhR�3LOFG��H�TfldFGZ[ADl[?MH�L,�V?Jlbh`COIf��LOA3?JI¤hGFWEcTfY\FGTVEG?Op,�3LOFG��LON8�M�fZdY0� C�EG?�ZdH�AqLOEcFGCOI�FN�LOE�C�AfADldZdYBC�FGZdLSIfhB��£¢�f? �DEchWF9H9?JCOIfhBp`NmLOE9?\�VCOH9ADl[?Op�FG�V?BEG?�C�EG?(H�COIKi��RCyi,h9FWL�AUldCJi�C�hGY\LOEG?Op`���fZdl[?�FG�V?hW?JY\LSIf�¤H9?JCOIfh`FG�fC�F`CO�f�fZdFGZ[LSIfCOlVhWFWEcTDY\FGTVEG?�¹¥hGTDYc� COh�COIVLOFG�V?BERH9LygO?JH9?JIKF0»QLOE�Y\LSIfhWFWE0COZdI�FGh@¹�?O� aV�[p.LSI�FW?JH9A3LK»YBCOI��3?�ZbH9A3LShW?J�5C�F�C�ldC�FW?BE9FGZbH9?O��¼½I�CO�D�fZ[FGZ[LSI�pQZdFnZdh�H9LOEc?�IDC�FGTVEcCOlRFWL�FWEG?JC�F�l[?BgO?Jldh9COIf��AfE0Z[LOEcZ[FGZ[?Jh�ZdIFG�V?BLOEcZd?JhB��PRLSIfY\?BAfFGTDCOl8hWADCOY\?Jh¢Y\LOEcEG?JhWA3LSIf��FWL�FG�V?�gO?BEci�hWA3?JYBZdCOl�YBCOhG?LONvhG?JH�Z[LOFGZdY@FG�V?BLOEcZd?Jh)�M�V?BEG?�FG�f?BEG?ZdhLSIfl[i�LSIV?@hWLOEGFBpKFG�V?BEG?�C�Ec?�IVL�LOAq?BE0C�FGZ[LSIfhk?\�VY\?BAfFRFG�VLShW?MEc?BAfEG?JhW?JIKFGZdIVa�C�FWLSH ZdY¢?Jl[?JH�?JI�FGhRCOIf��Ec?JldC�FGZ[LSIfhBp,COIf�C��VZ[LSH�h)LSIfldi�COhGhG?BEGF)FG�fC�FMC9Ec?JldC�FGZ[LSI��VLSlb�fh�LONvY\?BEcFGCOZdI�Y\LSIfhWFGCOIKFGhB�

[email protected]�FW?J���MZ[FG��COI�i�FG�V?BLOEGi�C�EG?�COldl�FG�V?�hWFWEcTfY\FGTVEc?Jh�¹¥YBCOldld?J� � ��� � ¶�u LOE zD¶%� � tvx=zDu »�FG�DC�FnADEGLyg.Zd�V?� ����� �v� �z���8� �F� �?��N�LOE`FG�V?�FG�fZdIVaShQZbI9FG�V?�hcZ[aSIfC�FGTVEG?MLONqFG�f?MFG�V?BLOEGi �khWLOEGFGhRC�EG?�ZbI�FW?BEGADEG?BFW?J��COhRhW?BFGhB©,LOAq?BE0C�FGZ[LSIhWi.H��3LSldh)C�Ec?�ZdIKFW?BEGAfEG?BFW?J��COh¢N�TfIDY\FGZ[LSIfh�LSI�FG�f?JhW?�hW?BFGhBpD�MZ[FG�(Y\LSIfhWFGCOIKF�hGi,H��3LSldh)ZdIKFW?BEGAfEG?BFW?J��COh¢?Jl[?JH9?JIKFGhB©COldl�ZdI�hGTDYc��C ��CJi�COhMFWL�hGC�FGZdhWN�i(FG�V?�C��.ZdLSH�h�ZbI�FG�V?nFG�V?BLOEGiO�@£¢�V?�FG�f?BLOEGi�Zdh�FG�KTfh@C¤NmLOEcH COl~ldCOIVaSTDC�aO?�N�LOEFGCOl[�.ZdIVa C��3LSTVF@hGTfY0�$H9L.�V?JldhJ�:[VLOEo?\�.COH9AUl[?OpUFG�f?�hWADCOY\?nLONQH9L.�V?JldhMNmLOEoC FG�f?BLOEGi(LONQ�3LKLO�.hMY\LSIDhGZdhWFGh�LONQCOldl�3LKLO�.ho�fCJg.ZdIVa�FG�V?9hWFWE0TfY\FGTVEG?�hWA3?JYBZ��f?J��ZdI�FG�V?�FG�V?BLOEGiO����L.�V?JldhoCOIf��FG�V?BLOEcZd?Jh�C�EG? � x� �`��CJi.h�LON�ldLKLO�.ZdIVaC�F¢FG�V?�hGCOH9?�FG�fZdIfaVpfhGZdIfY\?COhGhGL,YBZdC�FW?J���MZ[FG�(COIKi�YBlbCOhGh)LONkhWFWEcTfY\FGTfEG?Jh)Zdh¢C9TfIDZd�KTf?oH�LShWF)EG?JhWFWEcZbY\FGZ[gO?FG�V?BLOEGiFG�fC�FM�DCOh)FG�V?aSZ[gO?JI�LSIV?JhMCOH9LSIfa�Z[FGh¢H9L.�V?JldhB�

�$C�AfADZdIfaShQ�3?BFj�R?B?JI�hWFWEcTfY\FGTVEc?JhQ�3?JYBCOH9?�ZbIfY\EG?JCOhGZdIfaSl[inZbH9A3LOEGFGCOI�F�ZdI�Fè��?JIKFGZ[?BFG��Y\?JI�FGTfEGi�H�C�FG�V?JH�C�FGZbYBhCOIf� Z[FGh C�AfAUldZdYBC�FGZ[LSIfhJ©¢?\�.COH�ADl[?Jh ZbIfYBldTf�V?(ldZbIV?JC�E�FWEcCOIfhGNmLOEcH C�FGZ[LSIfh$¹¥COID��FG�V?JZ[E¤EG?BAfEG?JhG?JI�FGC�FGZ[LSIDh¤COh¤H�C��FWEcZdY\?Jh�»0pQY\LSI�FGZdI,TVLSTfhnH�C�ADhnLONMhGADCOY\?JhBpQ�fZ¡Ë3?BEG?JIKFGZdC��Dl[?¤COIf�5COIDCOl[iKFGZbY�N¥TfIfY\FGZ[LSIfhJpvaOEcLSTVA��fLSH9LSH9LOEGAD�DZdhGH�hBpCOIf�$H�TfY0��H9LOEc?O�M��C�AfAUZdIVaSh)�3?BFj�R?B?JI�hGZ[aSI�hGi,hWFW?JH hMC�EG?�LSIfl[i(IVLy��C�AfA3?JC�EcZdIVa¤ZdI�hW?JH�ZdLOFGZdYBhBpDCOh@TfIfZ[N�LOEcHEG?BAfEc?JhW?JI�FGC�FGZdLSIfhMN�LOE�hcZ[aSIfhMZbI�C hWLSTfEcY\?�hWAUCOY\?��,i(hGZ[aSIfh�ZdI�C�FGC�EcaO?BFohGADCOY\?O��X.ZdIfY\?���?�NmLOEcH COldZ[�B?�hGZdaSI�hWi.h½�FW?JH�hnCOh�COl[aO?B�fEcCOZdY�FG�V?BLOEcZ[?Jh��MZ[FG�5CO�f�fZ[FGZ[LSIDCOlQhWFWEcTfY\FGTfEG?Op���?�hG�VLSTfld��NmLOEcH COldZ[�B? u ��� · �Dw=·�{ � �Ux ��·�u � uÌ � Í3Ï=Ð�Þ3ÚcØjß�à�Ñ�ÚcØ�ÜÎã)ÒÁÑ8Õ=Ñ�ÐWß�ÜÎÚ)×Wæ\Ú0Ò ß¢ÜÎÏ�ÐQ×cÛRé�ÒÅÔ0Õ�Ò ÜÎÒÅнÑ�Ú0ÙVÜÎÏ=ÐvÞ3ÚcØjß�àmÜmê=ÝOÐ0â ã

ÀJ¾

Page 13: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

COh�H�C�AfAUZdIVaSh�LON`FG�V?BLOEcZd?JhoFG�fC�FoAfEG?JhW?BEGgO?9FG�f?�CO�D�fZ[FGZ[LSIfCOl�hWFWEcTfY\FGTfEG?O©~�VL=��?BgO?BEJp~FG�V?JhW?�H�C�AfAUZdIVaSh@H�TfhGF@�3?ADC�EGFGZbCOl�p��3?JYBCOTfhW?9ZdI�aO?JIV?BEcCOlÎp~IVLOFCOldlvLONRFG�V?�hWLOEGFGhBp�Y\LSIfhWFWEcTfY\FWLOE0hBp8?BFGY��~C�EG?9ADEG?JhW?BEGgO?J��ZdI�Ec?JCOl�?\�.COH9AUl[?JhB�[VLOE¢?\�VCOH9ADld?Op,FG�f?ohG?JH�Z[LOFGZdYoH9LOEGAU�fZdhGH NmEGLSH'FG�f?@EcLShW?�hWADCOY\?�FWL9FG�V?o�Dl[?JID�¤hWAUCOY\?@N�LOE)FG�V?�H9?BFGC�AD�fLOE�ÂG��il[L=gO?�Zdh�C�EGLShW?JÃ�¹¥H9LShWF@ldZ[�O?Jl[if»�LSH�Z[FGhMNm?BEGFGZbldZ[�B?BEMCOIf�$ZdIfhW?JY\FGhJpf�M�fZdld? ¹�AqLShchGZ[�Dl[if»`AfEG?JhW?BEcg,ZdIfa�C�F�l[?JCOhWF�LSIV?�LONA3?BEGN¥TfH9?oCOIf�(FG�VLOEcIDhB�k¼�I(CO�D�fZ[FGZ[LSI�FWL�FG�V?hGFWEcTfY\FGTVEG?�LON�COl[aO?B�fE0COZdYoFG�V?BLOEcZ[?JhJpfhW?JH�Z[LOFGZdYoH9LOEcAD�fZdhGH hRhc�VLSTfld�COldhWL�¹�ADC�EGFGZbCOldl[if»�AfEG?JhG?BEGgO?�FG�f?�AfE0Z[LOEcZ[FGZ[?Jh�COIf��l[?BgO?Jldh�LON`FG�V?�hWLSTVE0Y\?nhWAUCOY\?O�£¢�V?�?\�.FW?JIKF�FWL����fZdYc�$C�H9LOEW�AD�fZbhGH AfEc?JhW?BEGgO?JhRFG�V?og�C�E0Z[LSTfh�Nm?JC�FGTVEc?Jh�LONvhW?JH�Z[LOFGZbY¢FG�V?BLOEcZd?JhRZbhRCOI�ZdH�AqLOEcFGCOI�FR�V?BFW?BEcH�ZdIDCOI�FRLON~Z[FGh��,TfCOldZ[Fèi| Ê $ �Î��X,?JH Z[LOFGZdY@H9LOEGAD�fZbhGH�hQYBCOI�COldhWLn�3?@TDhW?J� FWL�EG?JlbC�FW?@HnTfhGZdYMFWL�?\�,FWEcC��jHnTfhGZbYBCOlU?Jld?JH9?JI�FGhJ�1[VLOE)?\�.COH�ADl[?Opl[?BFWFW?BEch�LONMCOI�COl[AD�fC��3?BF�YBCOI5�3? COhGhWL.YBZdC�FW?J���MZ[FG�5IVLOFW?JhBpkhWL�FG�fC�F�hG?J�KTV?JIDY\?Jh�LON¢IfLOFW?JhnYBCOI�hWA3?JldlQIDCOH9?JhBpC��3LSTVFo�M�fZdY0��hWLSH9?�ZdIfNmLOEcH C�FGZ[LSI�Y\LSTfld���3?�aSZ[gO?JI�p8?O� aV�[p�FG�fC�F� ��������Ã(Zdh@FG�V?�IDCOH9?9LONRC(Y\LSH�AqLShG?BE��M�VLldZ[�O?JhMhGTfYc��FWEcZdYG�.hB�

£¢�f?�hcZdH9ADl[?�N�LOEcH LON��Ul[?JIf� ZdI [�Z[aSTVEG?�À�C�AfAUldZ[?Jh��WTDhWF(COh(��?JlbloFWL�hW?JH�Z[LOFGZdY�hGADCOY\?Jh�COIf� hW?JH Z[LOFGZdYH9LOEGAU�fZdhGH�hJ�¼�I�FG�DZdhoaO?JIV?BEcCOldZd�JC�FGZ[LSI�p8FG�V?9�fZbC�aOEcCOH ZdhoYBCOldl[?J��C uJwyx µ {Ow µ x�zD¶@tv¶ ��� � �v·�z��Ux=z � COIf��� CuBwyx µ {Ow µ x=zD¶Mtv¶ ��� � ���LOEc?BLygO?BEJp�FG�fZbh�COldhGL¤?\�.FW?JIf�fh@FWL(�fZdC�aOEcCOH hM�MZdFG�$COIKi�I,TfH��3?BE@LON`hW?JH�ZdLOFGZdY�hWAUCOY\?JhBpCOIf��?BgO?JI�FWL�C�EG�UZ[FWEcC�EGi �DZdC�aOEcCOH�h�LONvhW?JH�Z[LOFGZdYohWAUCOY\?Jh)COIf�(H9LOEGAD�DZdhGH�hBp,ZdI��M�fZdY0��YBCOhW?�LSIV?�H�CJi�hWA3?JC�� LONC uBw=x µ {Ow µ x=zU¶R· � w � �Dx�zVw=· � � � � w ( �Dx+* �1]� ` 58d � # 5�1d&ef, � )23 � ,�.��1gF5�� ��Dd&)f58.�'65&gh)6' ef'*/� �*e ,wghe£¢�fZbhhW?JY\FGZ[LSI5�V?BgO?Jl[LOADh�C�H9L.�V?JlkN�LOE�FG�V?¤TfIf�V?BEchGFGCOIf�fZdIVa�LON¢HnTfhGZdY�p��DCOhW?J��LSI�C�Y\LSH�ADl[?\�VZ[Fji�FG�V?BLOEGi�N�LOE�fZ[?BE0C�EcYc�fZbYBCOlvhGFWEcTfY\FGTVEG?Jh@FG�fC�FC�Ec?�Y\LSIfhWFWEcTfY\FW?J��FG�VEGLSTVaS��hG�fC�E0ZdIVa�COIf��FWEcCOIfhWN�LOEcH�C�FGZdLSI ¸ � ��£¢�V?�EG?JhcTfl[FGZdIVaFG�V?BLOEGi�C�AfA3?JC�Ech8FWL�YBC�AfFGTVEc?`H�COIKi@N�?JC�FGTVEG?Jh~LONfH�TDhGZdYBCOlO�,TfCOldZdC.p�COh8�R?JldlSCOh�LON.¨@TfhGhG?BEcl�ÉÅh�IVLOFGZ[LSIDh8LON.EG?BFW?JIKFGZ[LSICOIf��AfEcLOFW?JI�FGZ[LSI8��r@hk�3?BN�LOEG?OpSEG?JCO�V?BE0hQhG�VLSTflb���3?¢Cy�RC�EG?MFG�fC�F`C�AfADlbZdYBC�FGZ[LSIfhvLON�hGTfY0�9C�NmLOE0H�COldZ[�JC�FGZ[LSI9hc�VLSTfld��3?MaOEGLSTDIf�V?J� ZbI hWL.YBZdCOl�p,Y\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[gO?Op.COIf�¤?JH��3L.�fZ[?J�9EG?JCOlbZ[FjiOp.FG�fC�FRIVLnhGAq?JYBZbCOlVLSI�FWLSldLOaSZdYBCOl3hWFGC�FGTfh�Zdh`YBlbCOZdH9?J�N�LOERFG�f?oC��UhWFWEcCOY\FGZ[LSIfh)ZbI�gOLSl[gO?J�8p.COID�¤FG�DC�F�ZdFRZdh�IVLOF)ZdIKFW?JIf�V?J��COh)CnaOEcCOIf��aO?JIV?BE0COlqhGLSldTVFGZ[LSI¤FWL�COldlUAqLShchGZ[�Dl[?AfEGLO�Ul[?JH�h)ZdI�FG�V?�AU�fZdl[LShWLOAU��iOp.ADhWi.Yc�fLSl[LOaOiOpDhWL.YBZ[LSl[LOaOiOpf?BFGY��ULONkH�TfhcZdY�pVl[?BFMCOl[LSIV?�LONkY\LSIfhcYBZ[LSTfhGIV?JhchB�

£�EcCO�fZ[FGZdLSIfCOl3XV�fCOIfIVLSI�ZdIVN�LOEcH�C�FGZdLSI FG�V?BLOEci |~��� �8�fCOh�AUldCJiO?J�(C9H9L.�V?JhWF�EGLSld?@ZdI�HnTfhGZdY�FG�V?BLOEGiOpD�DTVF��fCOh�3?B?JI�EcZ[aS�KFGl[i�Y\EcZ[FGZdYBZd�B?J��NmLOEnZ[FGhZdIfC��UZdldZ[Fèi�FWL�H9L=gO?¤�3?BiOLSIf��ldL,YBCOlkN�?JC�FGTVEG?Jh�¹¥hGTfY0��COh�hGL�YBCOldl[?J� �3�ÎaOE0COH�h0»FWL�ldC�EGaO?BE�aOEcCOZdI�hWFWE0TfY\FGTVEG?JhBpQhcTfYc��COh9hWLSIfC�FGC�N�LOEcH(����LOEG?�N�TDIf�fCOH9?JIKFGCOldl[iOpQC�FG�V?BLOEGi�FG�fC�F9Zdhn�DCOhW?J��LSIAfEGLO�UC��DZdldZ[Fèi�IV?JY\?JhGhGC�E0Zdl[i�H�C��O?Jh�hWLSH9?�gO?BEGi��fTV�DZ[LSTDhMCOhGhGTDH9AfFGZ[LSIfhoC��3LSTVFoFG�V?9IfC�FGTVEc?nLONRH�TDhGZdY�p8hGTfY0��COhFG�fC�FoFG�V?BEG?�C�EG?9�fZdhcY\EG?BFW?nC�FWLSH ZdYn?BgO?JI�FGhBp��fCJg.ZdIVa �V�.?J��AfEcLO�DC��DZdldZdFGZ[?Jh ¸ � ��PRLSH�ADl[?\�VZ[Fji��UCOhW?J��ZdIVN�LOEcH�C�FGZ[LSIFG�V?BLOEcZd?JhBp¢COl[LSIVa�ldZdIV?Jh9AUZ[LSIV?B?BEG?J�!�Ki�r@If�VEG?JZ 9�LSldH9LOaOLOEGL=go|~�O¾ �ÎpMC�Ec?$H9LOEG?�C�FWFWEcCOY\FGZ[gO?Op@hGZdIfY\?$FG�V?Bi�YBCOIA3LOFW?JI�FGZbCOldl[i�?JIfY\LSH9ADCOhGhn�fZ[?BE0C�EcYc�fZbYBCOlQhWFWEcTfY\FGTfEG?JhBp�Z�� ?O�[pkIV?JhWFW?J�5�M�VLSl[?k=ADC�EcF��fZ[?BEcC�E0Yc�fZ[?JhJ��¨�Ly�R?BgO?BEJpQFG�V?BihW?B?JH TfIfC��Dl[?oFWL�FGC��O?nCOYBY\LSTfIKFMLONvNm?JC�FGTVEc?Jh¢LON�H9?JH9LOEGi(ldZ[�O?oFG�VLShG?��fZdhGYBTDhGhW?J�(ZdI�X,?JY\FGZdLSI�¿,�dÀ��

r �O?Bi!Y\LSIDY\?BAfF¤LOND| ¿.Àz�@Zdh FG�fC�F¤LONCOI COIfCOl[i.hGZdh LOE�ÂWTfID�V?BEchWFGCOIf�DZdIVaSÃ�LONC�hGi,hWFW?JH�� �VEcCJ��I�N�EGLSHhWLSH9?naSZ[gO?JI$N�COH Zdl[i�LOE�ÂWhGADCOY\?JàLONQhGi,hWFW?JH hB�oX.TDYc��COI z � zD¶ �8uy·�u�� ZdhMC�IV?BFj�RLOEG��LONQY\LSH�AqLSIf?JI�FGhBpq�M�fZbYc�i.Z[?Jld�������V?JI¤Y\LSH��DZdIf?J��p.�M�V?BEG?�?JCOYc��Y\LSH9A3LSIV?JIKF)ZdI � ZdhR?JZ[FG�V?BE�C�FWLSH�ZdY�pfC�Y\LSH��DZdIfC�FGZ[LSI�LON8LOFG�f?BE¢l[Ly�R?BEl[?BgO?Jl�Y\LSH9A3LSIV?JIKFGh�ZdI � pkLOE�?JldhW?�C�FWEcCOIDhWNmLOE0H�C�FGZ[LSI5LONMhWLSH9?(l[L=��?BE9l[?BgO?JlRY\LSH9A3LSIV?JIKF�ZbI � pk�M�V?BEG?�FG�V?C�FWLSH�ZdY�Y\LSH9A3LSIV?JIKFGhBp�FG�V?9H9L.�V?Jh@LON�Y\LSH��DZdIDC�FGZ[LSI�p3COIf��FG�V?9COldl[Ly�R?J��FWEcCOIfhGNmLOEcH C�FGZ[LSIfh@C�EG?Z�V�,?J��N�LOE�FG�V?aSZ[gO?JI!N�COH�Zbl[i�LON�hWi.hWFW?JH�hBp�?JCOY0�!�MZdFG��C�I,TfH��3?BEcZbYBCOl9½��?JZ[aS�KFGÃ����fZdYc��EG?B¦f?JY\FGh ZdFGh�Y\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[gO?��fZ[§ YBTDl[FjiO�[VLOE�H�TfhcZdY�p�FG�f?�COldl[L=��?J��Y\LSH�AqLSIf?JI�FGh¤H�Z[aS�KF9�q?(Ec?BAfEG?JhW?JIKFW?J��COh�N¥TfIfY\FGZdLSIfh�NmEcLSH C�FW?JH9A3LOEcCOl¢�fLSH�COZdIZdIKFWL�C��VLSH�COZbI�LON�HnTfhGZdYBCOl@IVLOFGC�FGZ[LSI8©@FG�f?�hW?BF�LON�hGTDYc� N�TfIDY\FGZ[LSIfh¤NmLOEcH h¤C�ÂWhWADCOY\?JÃ�YBCOldl[?J� FG�V? uBwyzVw �Ì � Í3Ï=Ð)ÜÎÏ�нÚcØ�ê�Þ3×0Ñ`ÒÁÓBÜ�ØÎÚJßyÕ�å½ÐWß�ÒÁÓ � ����1�Vé�ÕyÜ`ØÎÐ�Ñ�ÐW×cØÎåjÏ9Ï�×cÑR×0ß=æ0×0Ó�å�ÐWß�éOÐ�ê\Ú�Ó�ß�Þ8Ï�×cÜ�ÒÅÑ`ß=нÑ�å�ØÎÒÅéOÐWßnÜÎÏ=Ð�ØÎÐ#�f×cÓ�ßnÛ)ÚcØÎнÚGæ\Ð�Ø��Ñ�Ú�Û)ÐvÝ=ØÎнÑ�Õ=Ý�ÝOÚ�Ñ�Ò ÜÎÒÅÚ�Ó=Ñ�ÚcÙ.ÜÎÏ�×GÜ~Ý�×0ÝOÐèØ8Ó�Ú�ÖÅÚ�Ó=Ô�Ð�Ø�Ñ�ннÛ�×cå½å½Ð½ÝyÜj×0é=ÖÁÐ0âÌ �WÍ3Ï=Ú�Õ=Ô�ÏnÜÎÏ=ÒÁÑkÒÅÑQÓ�ÚcÜ��.ÚcÙ�å½Ú�ÕyØÎÑ�Ð#�.ÜÎÚ�ÑÎ×Wê�ÜÎÏ�×GÜQÝ=ØÎÚ0é�×0é=ÒÅÖÁÒ Ümê�å½×0Ó�Ó=Ú0Ü`éOÐ�Õ=Ñ�ÐWßn×cÑ�×�å½Ú�Û)ÝOÚ0Ñ�ÒÅÜÎÒÅÚ0Ó�×0ÖDÜÎнåjÏ�Ó�ÒÁáBÕ�Ð0�,Ð�â Ôyâ ����Ú�Ï=Ó

3×0Ô0Ð#���3×cÓ�Ó�ÒÅÑ���нÓ�×cìJÒÁÑ*��í�êBÚcØÎÔ�Ò � ÒÅÔ0Ð�ÜÎÒ ��×cÓ�ߢÚ0ÜÎÏ�ÐèØÎÑ3Ï�×Wæ\Ðvß=Ú�Ó=ÐvÑ�Ú 0�é=Õ=Ü3Ò Ü8ÒÅÑ8ß=Ú0Õ�éyÜ�Ù¡Õ�Ö�ÜÎÏ�×cÜ�Û)Ú0Ñ¥Ü3ÖÅÒÅÑ¥ÜÎнÓ�ÐèØÎÑ�×GÜ�ÜÎнÛ)Ý=ÜUÜÎÚ�ÒÅÓyÙ¡Ð�ØÜÎÏ�Ú0Ñ�Ð�ÜÎнåjÏ�Ó�ÒÁáBÕ�Ð�Ñ3ÙçØÎÚ�Û�Þ8Ï�×cÜ8ÜÎÏ�Ðèê�Ï=ÐW×cØ��=Ð½Ò ÜÎÏ�ÐèØ�å�Ú�Ó�Ñ�å�ÒÁÚ0Õ�Ñ�Ö êoÚcØ~Õ�Ó�å�Ú�Ó�Ñ�å�ÒÁÚ0Õ�Ñ�Ö êBâ

ÀJ¿

Page 14: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

u vzf{ �,Ç � ��£¢�V? { � � �¶ � �~·mw ��� ¹ � »MLONRCOI�COIfCOl[i.hGZdh � Zdh@FG�V?��R?JZ[aS��FW?J��hcTfH LON`FG�V?9Y\LSH9ADld?\�.Z[FGZd?Jh�LON�FG�V?Y\LSH9A3LSIV?JIKFGh�LON � pO�M�fZdY0��ZbI�FGTfEcI�C�Ec?¢COldhWLohGTfYc���R?JZ[aS�KFW?J�9hGTfH�hJp�COID�nhGL@LSI��fZd?BEcC�EcYc�DZdYBCOldl[iOpO�VL=�MInFWLhWLSH9?C�FWLSH�ZdY Ç ¸ ?Jld?JH9?JI�FGhJpfIVLOFGZdIVa�FG�fC�F)EG?JTDhW?oLON�COI(?\�VZdhWFGZdIfanY\LSH9A3LSIV?JIKF)LOE¢hGTV��Y\LSH9A3LSIV?JIKFR�MZdldlqZdI�aO?JIV?BEcCOl��3?�R?JZ[aS��FW?J�!H�TfY0��l[?JhGh9�V?JCyg,Zbl[i�FG�fCOI�FG�f? �DEchWF9TfhW?O��£¢�V?JhW?��R?JZ[aS��FGh C�EG?�IVLOF9AfEGLO�UC��DZdldZ[FGZd?JhBpvIfLOF9?BgO?JI�hWLYBCOldl[?J�ºÂWhGTV�V�½?JY\FGZ[gO?JÃ�AfEcLO�DC��DZdldZdFGZ[?JhBpV�3?JYBCOTfhW?�Y\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[gO?��fZ[§¤YBTfl[Fji�Zbh¢LSIfl[i(AUC�EGFGZdCOldl[i(�V?BFW?BE0H�ZdIV?J�$�Ki�AfEcZ[LOE?\�.Aq?BE0Z[?JIfY\?O�Y[�ZdIfCOlbl[iOp�FG�V? uBwyx µ {Ow µ x�zD¶n{ � � �¶ � �~·mw � LON ��ZdhnFG�V?(IVLSI.�jIV?BaSC�FGZ[gO?(Ec?JCOlRI,TfH��3?BE��f?JIVLOFW?J���¹ �Q»0pK���fZdYc�9ZbhQFG�V?MH ZdIfZdHnTfH�LON3FG�V?MY\LSH9ADld?\�.Z[FGZd?Jh � ¹ � »vLON8COldlfCOIDCOl[i,hG?Jh � LON �R�k£¢�V?)EG?JhGTDl[FkLON�COIfCOl[i.hGZdhZdh¢IfLOFk�GTfhWF)FG�fZdhMIKTfH��3?BEJpf�DTfF¢H9LOEG?�hcZ[aSIfZ��DYBCOIKFGl[iOpVi.Z[?Jld�fh)C¤hGZdH9AUl[?JhWF)�fZ[?BEcC�E0Yc�fZdYBCOl~hWFWEcTfY\FGTVE0COl8COIfCOl[i.hGZdh �LON���¹�FG�VLSTVaS� FG�fZdhkCOIfCOl[i.hGZdhkIf?B?J�9IVLOFQ�3?)TfIfZd�,TV?=»0©SFG�fZbhkCOIfCOl[i.hGZdh�EG?BgO?JCOldh`IVLOFQLSIfl[inhGH�COldl.aOE0COZdI9hWFWEcTfY\FGTfEG?JhBp�DTVFQCOlbhWLldC�EGaO?¢aOE0COZdI�hWFWEcTDY\FGTVEG?JhBp�COh`��?JlblVCOh`�VL=�!COldlVFG�V?JhG?MhWFWEcTfY\FGTfEG?JhQC�EG?¢ZdIKFW?BEW�ÎEG?JlbC�FW?J��� } LOFW?�FG�fC�F���¹ �Q»Zdh<�H�&�)C�H9?JCOhGTVEc?�LON�C�?JhGFG�V?BFGZdY�AfEc?BNm?BEG?JIDY\?OpDldZ[�O?oFG�fC�F¢LON*�@?BLOEcaO?�>oCJg.Zd����Z[EG�.�VL�Ë�|(�k�Î�

£)�RLTfI,TfhGTfCOlKN�?JC�FGTVEG?JhkLONUFG�fZdh�FG�V?BLOEGinC�EG?)FG�fC�FQY\LSH9A3LSIV?JIKFGhkCOIf��FWEcCOIDhWNmLOE0H�C�FGZ[LSIfhk�fCygO?)��?JZdaS��FGhBp,COIf�FG�fC�F�hWLSH9?9Y\LSH9A3LSIV?JIKFGh�H�Cyi��3?�FWEcCOIfhWN�LOEcH�C�FGZ[LSIDhMLON�LOFG�V?BEY\LSH9A3LSIV?JIKFGhB�¼½I�ZdFGh@C�ADADldZdYBC�FGZ[LSI$FWL(H�TDhGZdY�pFG�V?�R?JZ[aS�KFMLONkC�FWE0COIfhWN�LOEcH�C�FGZ[LSI�hc�VLSTfld���3?��V?BFW?BE0H�ZdIV?J�(�,i(Z[FGh¢Y\LOaSIfZdFGZ[gO?��fZd§ YBTfl[FèiO�`£¢�,TfhBpfN�LOE�YBldCOhchGZdYBCOlHnTfhGZdY�p.C�Ec?BAq?JC�F�LON~C�¹¥IVLOF�FWL,L�TDI��MZd?Jld�Vif»vhW?BaSH9?JIKF¢hG�VLSTfld�¤�fCJgO?�C�gO?BEGi¤ldLy� CO�f�fZ[FGZdLSIfCOlDY\LSH9AUl[?\�.ZdFjiOpVCOIf�C�FWEcCOIfhWA3LShGZdFGZ[LSI�LONRZ[F��,i$C �fN�FG�$LOEC¤N�LSTVEGFG��hG�fLSTfld���DCJgO?9gO?BEGi�ldZ[FWFGl[?nH9LOEG?Op��M�V?BEc?JCOh@H�LOEG?9Y\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[gO?Jl[i�fZ[§¤YBTfl[FnFWEcCOIfhWN�LOEcH�C�FGZ[LSIDhBpRhcTfYc��COh�EG?BFWEGLOaOEcCO�V?$ZdI�gO?BE0hGZ[LSI�pRhG�VLSTfld���fCygO?$C�aOEc?JC�FW?BE �R?JZ[aS��FB� } LOFW?�COldhWLFG�fC�F�FG�DZdh9FG�V?BLOEGi�Zdh9IfLOF ldZdH�ZdFW?J��FWL�hWFGCOIf�fC�E0��H�TDhGZdYBCOl)IVLOFGC�FGZ[LSI8©MLSI�FG�V?$Y\LSI�FWEcC�EciOp)?JI�FGZ[Ec?Jl[i5�fZ[Ëq?BEG?JIKF�fZdH�?JIfhGZ[LSIfhRY\LSTfld���3?�IVLOFGC�FW?J�(N�LOE¢CnADC�EGFGZdYBTflbC�ERA3?BEGN�LOEcH�COIDY\?Op.hcTfYc�(COh¢HnTfhGZbYBZdCOI �UZ[LSH9?BFWEcZdYBh�¹�?O� aV�[pq�V?JC�EGFEcC�FW?MCOID��AqLShGFGTVEG?=»0pSLOEQCOTf�DZ[?JIfY\?¢COY\LSTfhWFGZbY�?JIV?BEGaOiOpKCOID��LONqY\LSTVE0hW?¢hWA3?JY\FWEcCOlVCOIfCOl[i.hW?JhkLOE`LOFG�V?BE`l[?JhGhk�f?BFGCOZdl[?J�COIfCOl[i.hW?Jh)LON�FGZdH��fEG?O�

Æ�?MC�Ec?)��LOEG�.ZdIVaoFWLZdH�ADl[?JH9?JIKFvCOI9COldaOLOEcZ[FG�fH FWLY\LSH9AUTVFW?)FG�V?¢H�ZdIDZdH�TDH Y\LSH9ADld?\�.Z[FèinCOID�nCOhchWL,YBZbC�FW?J�hGZdH�ADl[?JhWFRhWFWEcTfY\FGTVE0COlqCOIDCOl[i,hG?Jh�LON~FW?JH9A3LOEcCOl�hW?J�,TV?JIfY\?JhJpV�DCOhW?J��LSI�FW?JYc�fIDZd�KTf?Jh�LON��Vi.IfCOH�ZdY@COIf���DCOYc�KFWE0COYG�AfEGLOaOE0COH�H�ZdIVaV�vÆ�?MN�LSTfIf�9COI�?JC�Ecl[inAfEGLOFWLOFji,A3?¢FWL�3?)gO?BEGi9ZdIV?B§¤YBZ[?JI�FQZbI��qLOFG��FGZdH9?¢COIf��hGADCOY\?O�Q¨ML=��?BgO?BEyphGZdIDY\?o�,TfH�COI(HnTfhGZbY�ldZdhWFW?JIV?BE0hBp,COh�COI(COZd�(FWL�TfID�V?BEchWFGCOIf�DZdIVa�H�TfhcZdYoZdI�EG?JCOl�FGZdH9?OpVFWEci¤FWL COIKFGZdYBZ[AUC�FW?��M�fC�FH�Z[aS�KF�Y\LSH9?@If?\�,FBp.�DCOhW?J�¤LSI��M�fC�FRFG�V?Bi �fCygO?�COl[EG?JCO�Vi��V?JC�E0��p,COID� LSI�YBTfl[FGTfEG?\�jhWA3?JYBZ��DY¢Y\LSIKgO?JIKFGZ[LSIfhBpfZ[FRZdhIfC�FGTVE0COl3FWL�ZdIfY\LOEGA3LOEcC�FW?�hGTfY0�(N�?JC�FGTVEG?Jh¢ZdIKFWL9C9H9L.�fZ��f?J��H9L.�V?Jl�pVCOIf�(ZdH�ADl[?JH9?JIKFRZdFRN�LOE¢?\�.A3?BEcZdH9?JIKFGC�FGZ[LSI��C8?BFoTfh@YBCOldlvFG�fZdh�H9L,�f?Jl~FG�V? s � w=·�{�· �zfw �Dx���� ��� � ¶ �@¼èF@�MZdlbl~�fCygO?�C�H9?JH9LOEci��fZ[?BEcC�EcY0��iOp3�MZdFG�$hW?JIDhWLOEGiOphG�VLOEcF�FW?BEcH�p,COIf��l[LSIfa�FW?BEcH'Y\LSH9A3LSIV?JIKFGhBp.�M�V?BEG?�FG�V?oldC�FWFW?BE)ZdIfYBldTf�f?JhQFW?JH9ADlbC�FW?Jh�N�LOE)YBTfl[FGTVE0COldl[inAfEG?BN�?BEGEG?J�hWFWEcTDY\FGTVEG?JhB��£¢�f? COhGhWL.YBZdC�FW?J�5��?JZ[aS�KFGh�hG�VLSTflb��Y\LOEGEG?JhWA3LSIf��FWL$FG�V?¤?JCOhW?�LON)EG?BFWEcZ[?Bg.ZdIVa�ZdIfNmLOEcH C�FGZ[LSI�N�EGLSHFG�V?�g�C�E0Z[LSTfhnldCJiO?BEchnLONMH�?JH9LOEGiO� [VLOE�Z[FW?JH�hnZdI5FG�V?¤hW?JIDhWLOEGi�H9?JH�LOEGi��DT.Ë3?BEJpvFG�V?JhW?��R?JZ[aS��FGh�hG�fLSTfld���3?gO?BEGi�l[L=�pf�M�DZdl[?�Z[FW?JH�h�ZdI�hG�VLOEcFMCOIf��ldLSIVa�FW?BEcH H9?JH9LOEGi(hG�VLSTDld�(�fCJgO?naOEG?JC�FW?BE@��?JZdaS��FB�)r@l[FG�VLSTVaS�(FG�f?JhW?H9L.�fZ��DYBC�FGZdLSIfh���LSTDld��l[?JCO� FWL�COI COldaOLOEcZ[FG�fH_FG�DC�F�Zdh�H�TfY0� H9LOEc?¢?B§ YBZ[?JIKF�COIf� YBl[LShW?BERFWL��,TfH�COI�ldZbhWFW?JIfZdIVaVpFG�V?�EG?JhGTfldFGZdIVa$hGFWEcTfY\FGTVEcCOlRCOIfCOl[i.hW?Jh���LSTDld���3?�TfIfldZd�O?Jl[i$FWL��fCygO?�H�ZdIfZbH�TfH�Y\LSH9ADl[?\�VZ[Fjiq©��fLy�R?BgO?BEJp`FG�V?BihG�VLSTDld���3? YBl[LShW?�FWL�H�ZdIfZbH�TfH ���V?JI�FG�V?�AUC�EcCOH9?BFW?BEchnCOIf��FW?JH9AUldC�FW?Jh�C�Ec? C�aOL,L,�5H�C�FGYc�5FWL$C�hWFji.l[? LONHnTfhGZdY�����?BFG�VL.�fh�N�LOE hWA3?JYBZ[N�i,ZbIVa�FG�V?�hGFGC�FW?�hWADCOY\?(LON@AqLShchGZ[�Dl[?��fZ[?BEcC�E0Yc�fZdYBCOl��V?JhcY\EcZ[AfFGZ[LSIDh�LONoH�TDhGZdY�C�EG?�V?JhGY\E0Z[�3?J�(ZdI�| ¿.À��ÎpDCOIf��C�EG?�C�hWA3?JYBZdCOl~YBCOhW?LON�FG�V?�hW?JH Z[LOFGZdYhWi.hWFW?JH�hM�V?JhGY\EcZ[�3?J�(ZdI�X.?JY\FGZ[LSI�ÊV�Á¾,�Rr�hcTV�fFGl[?FW?JYc�DIfZdYBCOl8A3LSZdIKF)FG�fC�F���?�LSIfl[i�H9?JI�FGZdLSI��V?BEG?nZdI�ADCOhGhcZdIVaVpDZdh¢FWL EG?JY\LSIfYBZbl[?FG�V?nhW?BF½�Î�DCOhW?J��hG�V?JC�NkH9L.�V?Jldh)LON| ¿.À��Q�MZdFG�$FG�f?9FG�V?BLOEGiK�Î�DCOhW?J��COl[aO?B�fE0COZdY9hW?JH�Z[LOFGZbYBhoLON�X,?JY\FGZ[LSI�ÊV�Á¾,©��fZd�D�V?JI�COl[aO?B�fEcC$| ¿8� �`YBCOI��3?�TfhW?J��N�LOEFG�fZdh�AUTVEGA3LShW?O�

£¢�f?�r@IKFGZdYBZ[ADC�FWLOEGi���L.�V?JlVYBCOI��3?�EG?JldC�FW?J��FWL�FG�V?�AD�f?JIVLSH9?JIVLSl[LOaOi�LONqHnTfhGZbY�ldZbhWFW?JIfZdIVa�FG�VEGLSTVaS�9hG?BgO?BEcCOl�KiKA3LOFG�V?JhW?Jh ��£¢�V?:�fE0hWF`ZdhGhcTV?OpS�M�fZbYc���R?�YBCOlblVFG�V? ��zD· ��� � �fw� � u=·mu p,ZdhQFG�fC�F`LSTVE��fZ[?JC�E0Yc�fZdYBCOlDCOIfCOl[i.hW?JhBpTfhGZbIVa�ADhWi.Yc�fLSl[LOaSZdYBCOldl[i�COID�5YBTfldFGTVEcCOldl[i�C�AfAfEcLOAfEcZdC�FW?�Y\LSH9A3LSIV?JI�FGh�COIf�5�R?JZ[aS��FGhJpQC�EG?�TDIf�V?BEchWFGCOID�fZdIVaSh�LON�RLOEG�,h¤N�LOE�C�AfADEGLOAfEcZdC�FW?�COTf�fZ[?JIDY\?JhBp)COIf�!FG�DC�F�C�H�ZdIfZbH�TfHÈY\LSH�ADl[?\�VZ[Fji�COIfCOldi,hGZbh�aSZ[gO?Jh�C ½�3?JhWFGÃ�hGTfY0�ä � Í3Ï=ÐRÑ�Ý�×0å½Ð�åW×0Ó�éOÐ�å�Ú�Ó�Ñ¥Ü�Øj×cÒÅÓ�ÐWßéBê�× 9yÒÅÚ�Û)Ñ�ÜÎÏ�×cÜ�ß=ÒÅÑÎ×0ÖÅÖÅÚWÞ�Ñ�Ú�Û)Ð`Ù¡Õ�Ó=å�ÜÎÒÅÚ�Ó=Ñ 0,×cÖÅÑ�Ú�KÛRÕ�Ö ÜÎÒÅÝ�ÖÅÐ`ÝOÐ�Ø�Ù¡ÚcØÎÛ)Ð�ØÎÑ%$[ÚcØ�Ý�×GØ�ÜÎÑ &�åW×cÓéOÐkÏ�×cÓ�ßyÖÁнß�éBê¢ÖÅÐ�Ü�ÜÎÒÅÓ�Ô�nÜj×0ì\Ðkæ0×0ÖÅÕ=нÑ�ÒÅÓ�×RÝ=ØÎÚJßyÕ�å�Ü8Ñ�Ý�×0å½ÐkÚcÙfÓ�ÚcÜj×cÜÎÒÅÚ�Ó�×0Ö,åjÏ�Ú0ÒÅå½Ð½Ñ½âäèÌ Í3Ï=нÑ�Ð�Ó=нÐWß�Ó=Ú0Ü�éOÐv×cÜÎÚ0Û)ÒÁåvÒÁÓMÜÎÏ�Ð�Ñ�нÓ�Ñ�Ð�ÚcÙ.Ï�×GæJÒÅÓ�Ô`Ó�Ú�å½Ú�Û)ÝOÚ0Ó�нÓBÜqÝ�×cØ�ÜÎÑ*�=é�ÕyÜ3Ú0Ó�Ö êMÒÁÓ¢ÜÎÏ�ÐvÑ�нÓ�Ñ�Ð�ÚcÙ.éOнÒÅÓ=Ô�Ü�ØÎÐW×GÜÎÐWß�×cÑ~×Þ8Ï�Ú0ÖÅÐ 0JÙ¡Ú0Ø8Ð 9�×cÛ)Ý�ÖÅÐ#�\ÜÎÏ=Ð�Ú0ÝOнÓ�ÒÅÓ=Ô`ÙçÚ�Õ=Ø3Ó�Ú0ÜÎÐ�ÑqÚ0Ù-!qнÐ�ÜÎÏ=ÚGæ\нÓ� Ñ ��ÙçÜÎϢѥêyÛ)Ý�Ï=Ú�ÓBêR×cØÎÐ�×GÜÎÚ�Û)ÒÅåvÒÅÓ)ÜÎÏ�ÒÅÑ3Ñ�Ð�Ó�Ñ�Ð8Ù¡Ú0Ø8Û¢×cÓBê�ÖÅÒÅÑ¥ÜÎнÓ�Ð�ØÎѽâ

À\Ê

Page 15: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

TfIf�f?BEchWFGCOIf�fZbIVaVp�COldLSIVao�MZ[FG��CoAfEG?JYBZdhG?RhWFWE0TfY\FGTVEcCOl.COIfCOl[i.hGZdhvLONUFG�V?)��LOEc��ZdI��,TV?JhWFGZ[LSI��QX,?JY\LSIf�8pOFG�V?�� µ zD¶¥·�z� � �fw� � u=·mu hcCJi.h�FG�fC�F�FG�V?��R?JZ[aS�KF�LON~C�TfIfZ[FRY\LOEGEG?JhWA3LSIf�fho¹¥ZdIKgO?BEchW?Jl[if»QFWL�ZdFGhRhcCOldZ[?JIfY\iOpVCOIf�¤FG�V?�hGCOldZ[?JIDY\iLON¢C�TDIfZ[F�aSZ[gO?Jh�Z[FGh�hWFWEc?JIVaOFG�5COh�C��,TfCOl[?O�(£¢�fZbhYBCOI�?\�.ADldCOZdI�hWLSH9? LON)FG�f?�A3?JYBTfldZdC�EAU�V?JIVLSH9?JIVLSldLOaOi�LONHnTfhGZdYBCOlV�,TfCOldZdC@�fZdhcYBTfhGhW?J��ZdI�AfEc?Bg,Z[LSTDhvhG?JY\FGZ[LSIfhB�([VLOE�?\�.COH9AUl[?Op�Z[F�?\�.ADldCOZdIfh��VL=��FG�V?¢�,TfCOldZdC@LON3hGTV�fAU�VEcCOhW?JhYBCOI��3? C��UhWLOEG�3?J��ZdIKFWL�FG�V? �,TfCOldZbC�LON�lbC�EGaO?BE�AD�fEcCOhW?Jh��FG�DZdh�L.YBYBTVEch���V?JI�IV?B� TDIfZ[FGh�LON)l[L=� �R?JZ[aS��FnC�EG?N�LOEcH9?J���Ki�ZbIfY\LOEGA3LOEcC�FGZdIVaMAfEcZ[LOEvH�C�FW?BEcZdCOlKLONfLOEcZ[aSZbIfCOldl[io�fZ[aS�V?BE���?JZdaS��FB� � � �fw� � u=·mu�� hGCyi,hvFG�fC�F�ColdC�EGaO?\�aOEcCOZdI�TfIfZdFMLON�ldLy����?JZ[aS�KF�Zdh�LSIV?�FG�fC�F�ZdhM?\�.A3?JY\FW?J��COIf�$EG?JH9?JH��q?BEc?J��©�C�TDIfZ[FMLON`EG?JldC�FGZ[gO?Jl[i$�fZ[aS���R?JZ[aS�KFZdhhcTVEGAfEcZbhGZdIVaVp3COIf���V?JIDY\?�ZdhCOldhWL(Ec?JH9?JH��3?BEG?J� ¹�FG�VLSTVaS��C�gO?BEGi�Y\LSH�ADl[?\��TfIfZ[F�H�Cyi��q?9FWL,L��fZd§ YBTfl[F@FWLEG?JH9?JH��3?BEQ�R?Jldlm»0�k£¢�fZdhkC�aOEc?B?Jh`�MZdFG� ��?BiO?BEyÉÅh`g.Z[?B�o|~�8� �UFG�fC�F�COIKFGZdYBZ[ADC�FGZdLSI9ADldCyi,hQC��O?Bi�EGLSl[?O�k£¢�V?¢Ec?JldC�FGZ[LSILON�FG�V?JhW?�KiKA3LOFG�V?JhG?Jh)FWL ?JH9LOFGZdLSI�Zdh¢Y\LSIfhcZd�V?BEG?J�(ZdI�X.?JY\FGZ[LSI �,�

£¢�f?�V?BFW?BEcH�ZdIDC�FGZ[LSI(LONkhGCOldZ[?JIDY\i�Zdh¢LON�Y\LSTfEchW?�COI�?JH9ADZ[EcZbYBCOlqZbhGhGTV?OpfCOIf���MZdldl��fZ[Ëq?BE¢IVLOFMLSIfl[i�NmEGLSH LSIV?YBTfl[FGTfEG?�FWLCOIVLOFG�V?BEJpK�DTVFkCOldhWL�N�EGLSH LSIV?¢hWFèi,ld?)FWL�COIVLOFG�V?BEJpKCOIf��?BgO?JI�N�EGLSH LSIV?¢ldZbhWFW?JIV?BE�FWL�COIVLOFG�V?BEy�1��Z[gO?JICO�V?J�,TfC�FW?�hcCOldZ[?JIfY\i��fC�FGC.pKC�ADAfEGLOAfEcZbC�FW?¢Y\LSH9A3LSIV?JI�FGh�COIf���R?JZ[aS�KFGh`YBCOI �q?¢�f?BFW?BEcH�ZdIV?J��NmLOE`C�H9L,�f?Jl�pS�M�fZbYc�Y\LSTfld��FG�V?JI(�3?�EcTfI�COID��Y\LSH9ADC�EG?J���MZ[FG�(FG�V?)�WTf�faO?JH9?JI�FGh¢LONvEc?JCOl~ldZdhGFW?JIV?BEch¹¥Z[FMZbh�LON�Y\LSTfEchW?�IV?JY\?JhchGC�EGi�FWLYBC�EG?BN¥Tfldl[i$�V?JhGZ[aSI�?\�.Aq?BE0ZdH9?JIKFGhoNmLOE�FG�fZbh�AUTVEGA3LShW?=»0��£M�V?�¦f?\�.Zd�DZdldZ[Fèi�FWL�Yc�VL,LShW?�Y\LSH9A3LSIV?JIKFGhCOIf���R?JZ[aS�KFGhZdh�COI�ZdH9A3LOEGFGCOIKF�N�?JC�FGTVEG?�LONMFG�DZdh�C�ADAfEGLSCOYc�8p`COIf���fZdhWFGZbIVaSTfZdhG�f?JhZ[FnNmEGLSH �VL,LSH9?J��H9L.�V?BEcIfZbhWF�C�FWFW?JH9ADFGhFWL$�f?z�DIV?�TfIfZdgO?BEchGCOlkC�?JhWFG�V?BFGZbY H9?JCOhGTfEG?JhBp�hGTfYc��COh�FG�fC�F�LON:�o?BLOEGaO?���Z[Ec�,�VL�Ë |(� �Î��ESTfhGF�FWL��3?�YBl[?JC�EJpvFG�V?�V?JhGY\E0Z[AfFGZ[LSI�LON)Y\LSH9A3LSIV?JIKFGh�Zbh�VLSIV? TDhGZdIVa(hW?JH�ZdLOFGZdY�hWADCOY\?JhJp�COID��FG�V? Y\LSH9A3LShGZdFGZ[LSI�LON)C�HnTfhGZdYBCOlQADZ[?JY\?N�EGLSH_Z[FGhkY\LSH9A3LSIV?JIKFGhQZdh�Co�Dl[?JID��LONqFG�VLShW?¢Y\LSH�AqLSIf?JI�FGhBpKZdIn?\�.COY\FGl[inFG�V?¢hW?JIDhW?�LONqhWFWE0TfY\FGTVEcCOl,�Dl[?JID�fZdIVa�FG�fC�FZdh@�V?JhGY\EcZd�q?J��ZdI�X.?JY\FGZ[LSI�ÊV�Á¾,��£¢�f?nY\EGLShch½�jhWADCOY\?9H�C�AfAUZdIVaSh¢FG�DC�F�EG?JhcTfl[FMN�EGLSH �Dl[?JIf�DZdIVa�C�EG?�ZdIKFWEcC��jH�TDhGZdYBCOlH9?BFGC�AD�fLOEchBpV?JhWA3?JYBZdCOldldi FG�VLShW?�FG�fC�FMC�EcZdhG?�NmEGLSHÄFWEcCOIfhWN�LOEcH�C�FGZ[LSIDhB�

£¢�f?¤r@I�FGZdYBZdADC�FWLOEGi���L,�V?Jl�YBC�AfFGTVEG?Jh�COhWA3?JY\FGh�LONM¨@TfhGhW?BEclÎÉÅhAD�V?JIfLSH9?JIVLSl[LOaOi�LON)FGZdH�?O� [VLOE�?\�.COH�ADl[?OpZ[FM�DCOh¢gO?BEchGZdLSIfh¢LONk�3LOFG��Ec?BFW?JI�FGZ[LSI�COIf��AfEGLOFW?JIKFGZ[LSI�pDCOIf��FG�V?�E0Z[aS��FM�,ZdID�(LONkEG?JldC�FGZ[LSIDhG�fZ[A(�3?BFj�R?B?JI$FG�V?JH(�¼�FMCOldhWL ZbH9ADldZ[?Jh�¨@TfhGhW?BE0l�ÉÅh�ADZ[FG�Ki¤LO�UhW?BEGg�C�FGZ[LSI(FG�fC�F�FW?JH9A3LOEcCOl3LO�.�W?JY\FGhn¹¥Z�� ?O�[pqhGCOldZ[?JIKF)?BgO?JIKFGhMLOE@�KTfCOlbZdC�»RC�EG?Yc�DC�EcCOY\FW?BEcZ[�B?J���,i�3LOFG���fTVEcC�FGZ[LSInCOIf�nTfIfZ[FèiO�kXVZdIfY\?�ZdFvZdhvIVLOF�TfhW?BN¥TflKFWLoCOIKFGZdYBZ[AUC�FW?R�V?BFGCOZbldh~gO?BEci�N¥C�E�ZbI�FWL@FG�V?N¥TVFGTVEG?OpO�3?JYBCOTfhW?RFG�V?¢I,TfH��q?BEvLONUY0�VLSZdY\?JhkaOEcLy�Mh�gO?BEGin�KTDZdYG�.l[iOpSCOI9ZdH9AUl[?JH9?JIKFGC�FGZ[LSI�LONUAfEGLOFW?JIKFGZ[LSI�pS���V?BFG�V?BEIfC�FGTVE0COlfLOE�C�EGFGZ��DYBZdCOlÎp�IV?B?J�fhRC�hWFWE0TfY\FGTVEG?�FWL�COYBY\LSH�H9L.�fC�FW?�HnTfl[FGZ[ADld?OpSEG?JldC�FGZ[gO?Jldi�hc�VLOEGF`ADEGL��½?JY\FGZdLSIfhBp��UCOhW?J�LSI��M�fC�F�ZdhRIVLy� �3?JZdIVan�V?JC�Ec��p,�MZ[FG�¤��?JZdaS��FGhRFG�fC�F)ZdIfY\Ec?JCOhW?���Z[FG� ?JlbC�ADhW?J�¤FGZdH9?O©.FG�fZdhRZdhRC�aOL,L,��YBCOIf�DZd�fC�FW?N�LOE�ZdH9AUl[?JH9?JIKFGC�FGZ[LSI��,i(C IV?JTVE0COl8IV?BFMLONQY\LSH�Aq?BFGZbIVa ¨�?B�f�DZdCOI$Y\?Jldl~COhGhG?JH��DlbZ[?JhBpDZdI��qLOFG��FG�V?��,TfH�COI$COIf�COl[aOLOEcZdFG�fH�ZdYoZdIfhGFGCOI�FGZdC�FGZdLSIfhBpfCOh)�R?Jldl8COh)EcLO�qLOFGh�¹¥COhMZdIY| �,Àz��»0pDCOIf��Z[F¢COlbhWL�CJgOLSZd�Dh¢EG?JldZbCOIfY\?oLSI�LSld�(hWFèi,ld?�rM¼EG?BAfEc?JhW?JI�FGC�FGZdLSI�COIf�(ADlbCOIfIfZdIVaV�

£¢�f?nH�C�FG�f?JH�C�FGZdYBCOlvAfEGLOA3?BEGFGZ[?Jh�LONQFG�V?��fZ[?BE0C�EcYc�fZbYBCOl�Y\LSH9AUl[?\�.ZdFji�H9?JCOhcTVEG?�C�EG?�gO?BEci�ADl[?JCOhcZdIVa �)Z[FohGC�F½�Zdh �D?JhMCOldl�FG�V?�H C=�½LOEo?J�,TfC�FGZ[LSIfh@COIf��ZdIV?J�,TfC�FGZ[LSIfhMLONQFG�V?�YBldCOhGhGZdYBCOl�X.�fCOIfIfLSI�ZdIVN�LOEcH�C�FGZdLSI�FG�V?BLOEGi.ÇWÇ�pq?BgO?JIFG�VLSTVaS�$Z[F¢aOEG?JC�FGldi(aO?JIV?BEcCOldZ[�B?Jh�FG�fC�F@IVLOFGZ[LSI�pqCOh¢�R?Jldl~COh�aO?JIV?BEcCOldZd�JZdIVa�9�LSldH�LOaOLOEGLyg�hGFji.l[?�Y\LSH9ADld?\�.Z[Fèi�IVL��FGZ[LSIfhJ�@£¢�DZdh¢aO?JIV?BE0COldZ[�JC�FGZ[LSI��WTDhWFGZ��f?Jh@TfhGZdIfa hGTfY0�$FW?BE0H�hoCOh�½?JIKFWEGLOA,i,Ã�LOE�¹¥TfIf�f?BE@C��fZ¡Ë3?BEG?JIKF@H9?BFGC�AU�VLOE�»Â½FW?JH9A3?BEcC�FGTVEc?JÃ�N�LOE��¹ �`»0pUCOl[FG�VLSTfaS�(FG�V?FW?BEcH�ÂW�V?JIfhGZdFji.Ã�H�Z[aS�KF¢�3?�AfEG?BN�?BEGEG?J�(�,i(H�TDhGZdY\LSl[LOaSZdhGFGhB����LOEG?\�LygO?BEypvY\LSldZbH�Z[FGh�ZdI�FG�f?�hW?JIfhW?�LON�YBC�FW?BaOLOEGi�FG�f?BLOEGi�|~�8� ��C�EG?�ZdIKgOLSl[gO?J�5ZdI�FG�V? Y\LSH9A3LShGZdFGZ[LSI�LONR�DZ[?BEcC�EcY0�fZdYBCOlhWi.hWFW?JH�hr| ¿.À �ÎpfZdI�FG�V?�Ul[?JIf�fZdIfa�LON�Y\LSIfY\?BAfFGTfCOl�hWADCOY\?JhBpUCOIf��H9LOEG?�aO?JIf?BEcCOldl[iOpVLONkhW?JH�ZdLOFGZdY�hWi.hWFW?JH�hr| ¿�Ê8�Î�

£¢�f? { � � ��·mw=· � � zD¶k{ � � �¶ � �~·mw � �èµ � {Ow=· � �`pV�V?JIVLOFW?J� ��¹ ����� �Q»0p.ZdIKFGTfZ[FGZ[gO?Jldi�H�?JCOhGTVEG?Jh�FG�V?'�m�&� � � � � � � �?\Ë3LOEGFRIf?B?J�V?J� FWL�TfIf�f?BEchWFGCOIf� � � aSZ[gO?JI¤FG�fC�F �5Zdh�COl[EG?JCO�Vi�TDIf�V?BEchWFWL,L.� | ¿.Àz�Îp,LOE�FG�f?>�H� � ��� � �9LON � � Ec?JldC�FGZ[gO?FWL �R©`Z[FADEGLyg.Zd�V?JhnC�H9L.�V?Jl`NmLOEnFG�V?¤Y\LOaSIDZ[FGZ[gO?��fZdhWFGCOIfY\? Ç � NmEcLSH � FWL ���¥��¼½I�FG�f?¤YBCOhW?�LON¢HnTfhGZdY9���V?BEG?� � � �ºC�EG?nFW?JH9A3LOEcCOl�hG?BEcZ[?JhBp�� H�Z[aS�KF��3?�COI�ZdIKFGZ[FGCOlvhW?BaSH9?JIKFoLON � � �G=`EGLOFW?JI�FGZdLSI�C�FWFW?JH9AfFGh@FWL�AfEG?J�fZdY\F@COI?\�.FW?JIfhGZ[LSI � � LON � LSTVFoFWL�hWLSH9?9ldZbH�Z[F���Z�oZdgO?JI�C¤AUZ[?JY\?9TfhGZdIVa�hWLSH9?Z�V�.?J��?Jl[?JH9?JIKFGhBp�FWEcCOIfhWN�LOEcH�C�FGZdLSIfhBpä�ä ��ÚWÞ3нæ\ÐèØ��=ÜÎÏ=нÑ�Ð�ØÎнÖÁ×cÜÎÒÅÚ�Ó=Ñ~Þ8ÒÅÖÅÖ,Ú0Ó�Ö êMéOÐQ×0Ý=Ý=ØÎÚ�9yÒÁÛ¢×GÜÎÐ½Ö êMÑÎ×cÜÎÒÅÑ ��ÐWßMÙ¡Ú0Ø~ÜÎÏ�Ð � ÓBÜÎÒÅå½ÒÅÝ�×cÜÎÚcØ�ê �@ÚJß=нÖ[âä ��� Ü�ØÎÒÅå�ÜÎÖ êoÑ�ÝOÐW×cìyÒÅÓ=Ô�OÒ Ü~Ý=ØÎÚGæJÒÁß=нÑ�×)áBÕ�×0Ñ�Ò�bÝ�Ñ�Ð�Õ�ß=Ú�bÛ)Ð�Ü�ØÎÒÅå#��Ñ�ÒÅÓ=å½Ð� �$ ����� �4&~ÒÅÑ�Ó=Ú0Ü�Ñ¥êyÛ)Û)Ð�Ü�ØÎÒÅå#�yÒdâ Ð�â��SÑ�Ú0Û)Ð�ÜÎÒÅÛ)нÑ� �$ ����� �4&��� �$ ��� ��� & �y×0Ó�ßMÒÅÓ¢Ô�Ð�Ó�Ð�Øj×cÖ�Ò Ü8×cÖÅÑ�Ú�Ù[×cÒÅÖÁÑ3ÜÎÚ`ÑÎ×cÜÎÒÅÑ¥Ù ê)ÜÎÏ�ÐvÝyØÎÚ�ÝOÐ�Ø�Ümê� �$ ����� �4& � /`Ò�+ ��� � � �y×0Ö ÜÎÏ�Ú0Õ�Ô0Ï�Ò Ü8ßyÚBнÑ3ÑÎ×cÜÎÒÅÑ¥Ù ê)ÜÎÏ�ÒÅÑqÞ8Ï�Ð�ÓØÎнѥÜ�ØÎÒÅå�ÜÎÐWߢÜÎÚRÑ�Ð�ØÎÒÅнÑ~Ú0ÙKÜÎÏ�Ð�ÑÎ×cÛ)Ð�ÖÅнÓ�ÔcÜÎÏ �yÒÅÓ�Þ8Ï=ÒÁåjÏ@å½×0Ñ�ÐkÒ Ü8Ô�ÒÅæ\нÑ8×�áBÕ�×0Ñ�Ò�bÛ)Ð�Ü�ØÎÒÅå#�JÞ8Ï�ÒÅåjÏ@åW×cÓ�ÜÎÏ=нÓ�éOÐvÑ¥ê=Û)Û)ÐèÜ�ØÎÒ 6�ÐWß�ÜÎÚ�êyÒÅнÖÁß×RÝyØÎÚ�ÝOÐ�Ø~Û)Ð�Ü�ØÎÒÅå#���"$ ����� � & ���! #"%$ �$ ����� �4&&�' �$ ��� ��� &'(Bâ

À �

Page 16: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

COIf����?JZ[aS�KFGhBp�C { � � �¶ � �~·mw � vx ����¶ ��Zdh��f?BFW?BEcH�ZdIV?J��N�LOE�FG�f? ADZ[?JY\?Op��R¹ � ��� »�� ��¹ �� � ����� J»0p��M�f?BEG? ���V?JIVLOFW?JhnCOI�ZdIfZ[FGZdCOlkhG?BaSH9?JI�FnLON � TVA�FWL�FGZdH9? � pkCOIf� ��Zdh�C��DT.Ë3?BE�hGZ[�B?O©QZbI�FGTfZdFGZ[gO?Jl[iOp� ZdhZdIKFW?JIf�V?J��FWLH9?JCOhGTfEG?9FG�V?9Y\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[gO?9?\Ë3LOEGFEc?J�KTfZdEG?J��FWL�TfIf�V?BEchGFGCOIf��FG�V?9hWFWEcTfY\FGTVEc?9LON`FG�V?9ADZd?JY\?�C�F�?JCOYc��H�LSH9?JI�F � �X.�fC�EcA�g�C�EcZdC�FGZ[LSIfhnZdI���¹ � ��� »��MZdlblQY\LOEGEG?JhWA3LSIf�5FWL�FG�V?¤�3LSTfID�fC�EcZ[?Jh�LON�ZdH9A3LOEGFGCOIKF�hWFWEcTDY\FGTVEcCOl`TDIfZ[FGhB� [fLOE?\�VCOH9ADl[?Op.ZdI�COI�r@r@�Rr NmLOE0H(pKFG�f?BEG?���ZdldlV�3?oC�hG�DC�EGA��fEGLOA�ZbI¤Y\LSH9AUl[?\�.ZdFji�C�F�FG�V?@�qLSTDIf�fC�EGi��3?BFj�R?B?JI�FG�V?�fEchGF`COIf� hG?JY\LSIf�¤r TfIDZ[FBp�COIf�¤C�hG�fC�EcA EcZdhG?MC�F`FG�V?��3LSTfIf�fC�EGi��3?BFj�R?B?JI¤FG�f?MhW?JY\LSIf��r COIf��FG�f?���TfIfZdFB�Q�oNY\LSTVEchG?OpVFG�V?�?\�.COY\FMg�COldTf?Jh��MZdldlU�V?BA3?JIf��LSI(�M�fC�F)H�C�FW?BEcZbCOl�Zdh�?JIfY\L.�V?J�(ZdI�FG�V?�V?JhGY\E0Z[AfFGZ[LSI��5LON�FG�f?�ADZ[?JY\?OpN�LOE¢?\�.COH�ADl[?OpV�M�V?BFG�f?BEMH�ZdY\EGL��ÎFWLSIDCOl8COIf��H�ZbY\EGL��ÎFGZdH��fEcCOl�ZdIV¦D?JY\FGZ[LSIfh)C�EG?ZdIDYBldTf�V?J���

r@H9LSIVa�H COI�i�LOFG�V?BE`Y\LSIDY\?BAfFGh`FG�DC�F`YBCOI��3?)�V?z�DIV?J���MZ[FG�fZdInFG�fZbh�FG�V?BLOEGiOp.C�H9?JCOhGTVEG?MLON3�fLy�!HnTfYc� LSIV?hWFWEcTDY\FGTVEG? ���8EG?JhW?JH��Dl[?JhoCOIVLOFG�f?BE ��pqaSZdgO?JI$�,i��f¹ ��� � �Q»�� ��¹ ����� �Q»�� ��¹ �Q»0p~hW?B?JH�h@EG?Jld?Bg�COIKF�N�LOEoFG�fZdIV�.ZdIVaC��3LSTVFoZdH9AfEGL=g,ZbhGC�FGZ[LSI�pq�M�V?BEG? � � � �ºC�EG?9hW?BaSH9?JIKFGhoLygO?BEFG�f?nhGCOH�?nFW?JH�AqLOE0COlvZbI�FW?BEGg�COl�pqAfEGL.�fTfY\?J�$�Ki$Fj�RL�fZ¡Ë3?BEG?JIKFZdH9AfEcLyg.ZdhW?BEchBp8hcZdIfY\?��(H9?JCOhGTVEc?JhFG�V?9?\�.FW?JI�F�FWL��M�DZdYc��LSIV?¤H�TfhcZdYBZdCOI�Zdh�N�LSldl[L=�MZdIVaVp�LOEnZdho�3?JZdIVaZdIV¦UTV?JIfY\?J�9�,iOpKFG�f?MLOFG�V?BEJ�Q£M�fZdh x � u � � t�¶�z � { � � � zfu µ x �nZdh:���8�`hWi.H�H9?BFWE0ZdY�pKCOIf�¤�V?JIfY\?@Zdh`YBl[LShG?BE�FWL�LSTVEZdIKFGTfZ[FGZ[LSI�N�LOE`FG�DZdhkC�AfADldZbYBC�FGZ[LSI9FG�fCOI FG�V?MTfhGTDCOlVhWFGC�FGZdhWFGZdYBCOlUY\LSIfY\?BAfF�LON3Y\LOEcEG?JldC�FGZ[LSI�pK�M�fZdY0��ZdhQhGi,H�H�?BFWEcZdYBCOl��£)�RL�LOFG�V?BEQZdH9A3LOEGFGCOIKFkY\LSIfY\?BAfFGhkaO?JIf?BEcCOldZ[�JZdIfaoYBlbCOhGhGZdYBCOlDX.�DCOIfIVLSI�FG�V?BLOEGiOpKC�Ec?)FG�V? ��µ w µ zD¶~· � � �Ux � zVw=· � �LON�� � COIf���Rp��f?z�DIV?J���,i �U¹ � � � �Q»�� ��¹ � � »�� ��¹ � � � �Q»0pOCOIf��FG�V?�� �U· � wM· � � �Dx � zVw=· � �¤LON�� � COIf���Rp��f?JIVLOFW?J���¹ ��� � �Q»0pv�f?z�DIV?J��FWL$�q?9FG�f? H�ZdIfZbH�TfH"Y\LSH�ADl[?\�VZ[Fji�EG?J�,TfZ[EG?J��FWL$EG?JCOldZ[�B?-yR�8� � � COIf� �������$TVFGTfCOl�COIf��WLSZdI�FnZdIVN�LOEcH�C�FGZ[LSI�C�EG? �3LOFG��hGi,H�H�?BFWEcZdY ZbI�FG�V?JZ[E�Fj�RL�C�EGaSTDH9?JI�FGhJ©`hW?B? | ¿.À ��N�LOE�H9LOEc?¤�V?BFGCOZdlÎpvZdIDYBldTf�fZdIfaAfEGL,LON¥hLON)FG�V?JhW?�COIf��LOFG�V?BE�?J�,TfCOldZdFGZ[?Jh�COIf�5ZdIV?J�,TfCOldZ[FGZd?JhoN�COH�ZbldZdC�EN�EGLSH FG�f?(X.�DCOIfIVLSI�FG�V?BLOEciO��r�IfLOFG�V?BEZdIKFW?BEG?JhWFGZdIfa5IVLOFGZ[LSIºN�LOE�?\�,ADldLOEcC�FGZ[LSIºZdh FG�f?�Y\LSH�ADl[?\�VZ[Fji!�DZ¡Ëq?BEc?JIfY\?��3?BFj�R?B?JI FG�V?�COI�FGZbYBZ[ADC�FW?J� COIf�ºFG�V?COY\FGTfCOl�Y\LSI�FGZdI,TfC�FGZ[LSI�LON�C9hG?BaSH9?JI�FBpqhGZdIfY\?�FG�DZdh)H9?JCOhGTVEc?Jh)FG�V?�ÂWhGTfEGAfEcZdhG?JÃ�LONvFG�V?�COY\FGTDCOl8Y\LSI�FGZbIKTfC�FGZdLSI��

Æ�?�ZdIKFW?JIf�$FWL(TfhW?nFG�V?9r�IKFGZdYBZ[ADC�FWLOEci�r�ldaOLOEcZ[FG�fH ZdI�hWLSH9?9Y\LSH9ADTVFGC�FGZdLSIfCOlv?\�,A3?BEcZdH�?JI�FGhBpqFWL�g�COlbZd�fC�FW?FG�V?@COhGhGTfH9ADFGZ[LSIfh��3?J�fZdIf�9ZdFQLSI�EG?JCOlUH�TDhGZdYBCOlf?\�VCOH9ADld?JhB��Æ�?M�MZdlbl.�q?BaSZbI9�MZ[FG��hcZdH9ADl[?�?\�VCOH9ADl[?JhJpKCOIf� FG�V?JI�DTfZbld�fZdIVaMLSI�FG�fC�FQ?\�.A3?BEcZ[?JIfY\?Op�aOEcCO�fTfCOldldi�H9LygO?�FWL�H9LOEG?�COIf�9H9LOEG?MY\LSH�ADl[?\��?\�.COH9AUl[?JhB�vÆ�?��fCygO?MCOl[EG?JCO�VihWFGTf�DZ[?J��hWLSH9?�hGZdH�ADl[?�H�?Jl[L,�DZ[?Jh9¹�?O� aV�[pvI,TVEchW?BEci�Ec�Ki,H9?Jh�»MZbI�| ¿.À��Îp~COIf���MZbldl~�RLOEG�$LSTVE��RCyi�TVA8p��MZ[FG��¹�N�LOE?\�VCOH9ADl[?=»nP��fC�EclbZ[? =�C�EG�O?BE�hWLSldLShnCOh9COI�ZdIKFW?BEcH9?J�DZdC�FW?�hGFW?BA8pQFWLy��C�Ec�fh9Y\LSIKFW?JH9A3LOEcC�EGi5aOEGLSTVA�ZdH9ADEGLyg.ZdhW?J�HnTfhGZdY�pkhWLSH9?��,TfCOldZ[FGC�FGZ[gO?�COhWA3?JY\FGhnLON¢�M�fZdY0�5C�Ec?¤?\�.ADl[LOEG?J�5ZdI5��LOEG���MZ[FG��>oCyg,Zd���RLOEGaOL�|¡À $ �ÎpQCOhn�fEcZd?B¦fi�fZdhcYBTfhGhW?J�9C�FQFG�f?¢?JIf��LON~X,?JY\FGZdLSID�,�k¼èF`��LSTflb�9COldhWL�3?¢ZdIKFW?BEG?JhWFGZdIfa�FWL�COIfCOl[i,�B?MhWLSH�?¢LON3FG�V?¢?\�VCOH9ADl[?Jh�TfhW?J��,i���?BiO?BE<|~�8� �Î��£M�fZdhv?\�,A3?BEcZbH9?JI�FGCOlfAfEGLOaOEcCOH�H�?¢hG�VLSTfld�nEcCOZbhW?¢ZdIKFW?BEG?JhWFGZdIVaY0�fCOldl[?JIfaO?JhkNmLOE`FG�V?)FG�V?BLOEGiOp.COIf�FG�,Tfh¢hWFGZdHnTfldC�FW?ZdFGh)N�TfEGFG�V?BE¢�V?BgO?Jl[LOAUH9?JI�FB��X,LSH9?�LON�FG�VLShW?�Y0�fCOldl[?JIfaO?Jh)�MZdldl3TfID�VLSTV�fFW?J�fldi ZdIKgOLSl[gO?�KTDCOldZdC.�

�oTfE@Y\LSH9AUl[?\�.ZdFji��DCOhG?J��C�ADAfEGLSCOYc��YBCOI��3?n?\�,FW?JIf�f?J�$FWL(H9LOEc?��DZ[EG?JY\FGl[i�CO�f�fEG?JhGh@�Vi,IDCOH�ZdY�COhGAq?JY\FGhoLONHnTfhGZdY�p��,i�g.Z[?B�MZdIVa�FG�V?)hWADCOY\?�LONfADZd?JY\?JhkCOhvCo�Vi.IfCOH�ZbYBCOlKhWi.hWFW?JH Ç*� pO��Z[FG��Y\LSIf�fZ[FGZ[LSIDCOlKY\LSH9AUl[?\�.ZdFji ��¹ ���'� �Q»AfEGL=g,Zb�fZdIVa�C(IVLOFGZ[LSI�LON��fZdhWFGCOIDY\?�¹¥hW?B?9NmL,LOFGIVLOFW?¤¾O¿S»�COIf���MZ[FG��FG�V?�Y\LSH�ADl[?\�VZ[Fji�AfEGL8�Dld?�� COhC�A3LOFW?JIKFGZdCOlLOE�?JIV?BEGaOi�N¥TfIfY\FGZdLSI�pkhWL$FG�DC�F�IfLOFGZ[LSIfhnldZ[�O?¤YBTfEGg�C�FGTfEG?Opk�DCOhGZdI�LONMC�FWFWEcCOY\FGZ[LSI8p`COIf��hGCO�f�fld? A3LSZdIKF��3?JY\LSH9?H9?JCOIfZbIVaON�TDl��(¨M?BEG?�C�EG?�hWLSH9?�?\�.COH�ADl[?JhLON��Vi,IDCOH�ZdYBCOl`hGi,hWFW?JH h�Y\LSIfY\?BADFGh�FG�DC�FnY\LOEGEc?JhWA3LSIf��FWL�H�TDhGZdYBCOlY\LSIfY\?BAfFGh �`C��DCOhGZdI�LON�C�FWFWEcCOY\FGZ[LSI$Zdh)C�EG?BaSZ[LSI�LON�l[Ly� ?JIV?BEGaOiq©fC9�fZ[EG?JY\FGZ[LSI�LONvH9LOFGZ[LSI�¹�aSZdgO?JI(�Ki�C�FGCOIVaO?JIKFgO?JY\FWLOEMFWL¤C�ADZ[?JY\?=»RZdh)hGZbH�ZdldC�ERFWL�FG�V?IVLOFGZdLSI�LON@½aO?JhWFGTfEG?JÃ�COhMTDhW?J�(ZdI�H�TDhGZdY\LSl[LOaOiq©fY\LSH9ADl[?\�VZ[Fèi�Zdh)hcZdH�ZdldC�EFWL��M�DC�F¢Zdh�LONmFW?JI$YBCOldl[?J��ÂW�f?JIfhGZ[Fèi,Ã9ZdI(HnTfhGZbY�©fCOIf��AD�fCOhW?�FWE0COIfhGZ[FGZ[LSIDh)Y\LOEGEG?JhWA3LSIf��FWL hcZ[aSIfZ��DYBCOIKF)Yc�fCOIfaO?JhZdI FG�V?MFW?\�.FGTVEG?@LON8hW?BaSH9?JIKFGhB� } LOFW?oFG�fC�F`FG�V?or@I�FGZdYBZdADC�FWLOEGi ��L,�V?JlUhG�VLSTflb�9�3?�TfhW?J�8pKhGZdIDY\?MFG�V?@Y\LSH9ADl[?\�VZ[FjiH9?JCOhGTfEG?Jh�C�Ec?¤TfhW?J�5FWL�?\�,FWEcC�A3LSldC�FW?�COl[LSIVa�C�aSZ[gO?JI5ADC�FG��pkCOIf�5FG�fC�F�LSIV?�YBCOI�C�AfADldi�FG�f?¤hGCOH9?�Zd�V?JCOh�FWLAfEGL��W?JY\FGZ[LSIfh�LON)FG�V?�hWFGC�FW?�hWADCOY\?�LSI�FWL�hWLSH9?�l[L=��?BE��fZdH9?JIDhGZ[LSIfCOlQhGADCOY\?O©Q�MZ[FG�5COI5C�ADAfEGLOAfEcZbC�FW?¤Yc�fLSZdY\?¤LONY\L,LOEc�fZdIfC�FW?JhJpVFG�fZdh¢Y\LSTflb��aSZ[gO?�COI�ZdIKFW?BEG?JhWFGZbIVa9AD�fCOhW?hGADCOY\?N�LOEMhWLSH9?�YBlbCOhGh)LONvADZ[?JY\?JhB�ä �WÍ3Ï=ÒÅÑRØÎÐ�Ù¡ÐèØÎÑRÜÎÚ�×å�Ö ×cÑ�Ñ�Ú0Ù�Û¢×cÜÎÏ=нۢ×cÜÎÒÅåW×cÖqÛ)ÚJßyнÖÅÑRÚ0Ù~å½Ú0Û)Ý�ÖÅÐ 9nÑ¥ê=Ñ¥ÜÎÐ�Û)Ñ�Ï�×GæJÒÅÓ�ÔÚcØÎÒÁÔ0ÒÅÓ�Ñ�Û¢×cÒÁÓ=Ö ê�ÒÅÓ�Ý�ÏBêyÑ�ÒÁå�Ñ*�Ué=Õ=Ü`Þ8Ò ÜÎÏ×0Ý=Ý�ÖÅÒÅåW×cÜÎÒÅÚ0Ó�Ñ�ÜÎÚnÛ¢×cÓBê9×cØÎн×0Ñ*��ÒÅÓ�å�ÖÁÕ�ß=ÒÅÓ�Ô�ÛRÕ=Ö ÜÎÒÁÛ)нß=ÒÁ× � ���dâ��nÐ�Þ8ÒÅÖÅÖ�Õ=Ñ�Ð�ÜÎÐ�ØÎÛ)ÒÅÓ=Ú�ÖÅÚ�Ôcê9ÙçØÎÚ�Û ÜÎÏ�ÒÅÑ)×cØÎÐ½× 08Ð�â Ô=â���Ñ�Ð�Ð � ��8Ù¡ÚcØM×Ý=ØÎÐ�å½ÒÅÑ�Ðké�Õ=Ü�ØÎÐ�Ö ×GÜÎÒÅæ\Ð½Ö ê¢ØÎÐW×�ß=×0é�ÖÅÐQÐ 9yÝOÚ�Ñ�Ò ÜÎÒÅÚ�Ó�â ,�Õ�ÐvÜÎÚ`ÜÎÏ�Ð½Ò Ø~å½Ú0Û)Ý�ÖÅÐ 9yÒ Ü�ê��BÙ¡ÕyØ�ÜÎÏ�Ð�Ø~ßyÐ�Üj×0ÒÅÖÅÑ8Ú0Ù.ÜÎÏ=ÒÅÑ�×cÝ�ÝyØÎÚ\×0åjÏo×GØÎÐQß=Ð�ÙçÐ�Ø�ØÎÐWß�ÜÎÚ�×Ù¡ÕyÜÎÕ=ØÎÐ�Ý�×0ÝOÐ�Ø10BÛ)ÚcØÎнÚGæ\Ð�Ø��0ØÎÐW×0ÖÅÒ�6½ÒÅÓ�ÔkÒ ÜÎÑfÙ¡Õ�ÖÅÖ=ÝOÚ0ÜÎнÓBÜÎÒÁ×0ÖJÞ8ÒÅÖÁÖ=ØÎÐWáBÕ�Ò ØÎÐ�Ó�Ú0Ó dÜ�ØÎÒÅæyÒÁ×cÖ�×0ß�ß=Ò ÜÎÒÅÚ�Ó=Ñ*�BÑ�Õ�åjÏ)×cÑDÐ 9yÜÎÐ�Ó�ß=ÒÅÓ=ÔvÜÎÏ�Ð�Ï=ÒÁÐèØj×cØÎåjÏ�ÒÅåW×0Öå½Ú0Û)Ý�ÖÅÐ 9yÒ Ü�ê)ÜÎÏ�Ð�Ú0Ø�êMÜÎÚ�å½Ú�ÓBÜÎÒÅÓJÕ�Ú0Õ�Ñ�Ñ¥êyÑ¥ÜÎнÛ)ѽâ

À �

Page 17: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

� � PZL J�¯²Q³ �:Q��$³ W LįUW�X ±ZSq³c²�$COI�i��MEcZ[FW?BEch¤�fCJgO?�CO�f�VEG?JhchW?J�!FG�f?$hWL.YBZdCOl@COhWA3?JY\FGh LON�HnTfhGZbY�p�COH�LSIVa5���VLSH LSIf?$H�Z[aS�KF AUC�EGFGZdYBTfldC�E0l[iH9?JIKFGZ[LSI�£¢�V?BL.�VLOE9r��fLOEcIVL�|¡À��Ω�LON�Y\LSTVEchG?Op`H�TDhGZdY�Zdh�Z[EGEG?J�fTDYBZ[�Dl[i�hWL.YBZdCOl�pQCOIf��FG�V?BEc?�ZbhnlbZ[FWFGl[? Ec?JCOhWLSI�FWL�3?JldC��3LOE)FG�fZdh)A3LSZdIKF¢�V?BEG?O��¨�Ly�R?BgO?BEJpqZdFMhW?B?JH�hM��LOEGFG��EcCOZdhGZbIVa�Fj�RL¤ZdhGhcTV?Jh)�M�fZbYc�(N¥TVEGFG�V?BE�ZdldldTfH ZdIfC�FW?ohWLSH9?AfEG?Bg.Z[LSTfh��fZbhGYBTfhGhGZdLSI ZdI FG�DZdh�ADC�A3?BEJ� £M�V? �fEchWF(Zdh(ZdH�AfEGLyg.ZdhGC�FGZdLSI�p¢�M�fZbYc� �VEcCy�Mh�LSI COI ?JhGhcCJiº�Ki COIZdH9ADEGLyg.ZdhW?BE9¹ �¢iOLO�OL �oLOaSTV?JIU»�LSI�C�ADC�EGFGZdYBTDldC�EoAq?BEcNmLOEcH COIfY\?�¹¥C�F����fZdYc��FG�fZbh@COTfFG�VLOE��RCOh�COlbhWL�AfEG?JhW?JIKF0»0paSZ[gO?JI�ZdI�r�AfA3?JIf�fZ¡�(r��£M�V?nhG?JY\LSIf��ZdhGhGTf?�Zdh�FG�V?�?BgOLSldTVFGZ[LSI�LON`HnTfhGZbYBCOlvIfLOFGC�FGZ[LSI�p3�MZ[FG��hWLSH9?n?JH9AD�DCOhGZdhLSI(FG�V?�g�COldTf?Jh)FG�fC�F¢FG�fZbh�EG?BgO?JCOldhB�

¼½H9AfEGL=g,ZbhGC�FGZ[LSI�Yc�fCOlbl[?JIVaO?Jh9IVLOFGZ[LSIDh�LON@H�TDhGZdY�COh9AfEG?\�Î?\�VZdhWFGZdIfa$Zd�V?JCOlRN�LOEcH(p`COh9hcY\LOEG?Op�LOE�COh9C�hW?BF9LONA3?BEGN�LOEcH�COIfY\?JhB��^QgO?BEci�ZbH9AfEGL=g,ZdhcC�FGZ[LSI�ZdhoTfIfZd�,TV?Op8COIf��Zdh�TDIfZd�,TV?Jl[i(FGZ[?J��FWL�FG�f?9ADC�EGFGZdYBTflbC�E@?JIKg.Z[EGLSIfH9?JIKFZdI �M�fZdY0� Z[F�L,YBYBTVEcEG?J���k£¢�,TfhBp�N�LOERFG�V?@ZbH9AfEGL=g,ZdhcC�FGZ[LSI��fZdhcYBTfhGhW?J��ZbI r�AfA3?JIf�fZ¡�9r�p,FG�V?ol[L.YBC�FGZ[LSI ZdID;@Zd?JIfIfC.pFG�V?�hWFGC�EGF�LON�FG�V?¤¼èE0CO��ZbI�g�COhGZ[LSI�p�FG�V? C�FGH9LShGAD�V?BEG?¤LON�C$TfIfZ[gO?BE0hGZ[Fji�hW?JH�ZbIfC�EJp~FG�f?¤COTf�fZd?JIfY\?9LON¢CO�Vg�COIfY\?J�HnTfhGZdY)hWFGTD�V?JI�FGhJpKCOIf�9FG�f?MhWLOAD�fZbhWFGZdYBC�FW?J�9�VLShWFGhJpKCOldlVAUldCJiO?J��ZbH9A3LOEGFGCOI�FkEcLSl[?JhQZdI9���fC�Fk�RCOh�A3?BEGN�LOEcH9?J��pS�VL=�Z[Fo��COhA3?BEGN�LOEcH9?J��p�COIf���fLy� Z[Fo��COh�EG?JY\?JZ[gO?J�8��^QgO?JI�?\�VCOY\FGl[i�FG�V?�hGCOH9?�COY\LSTDhWFGZdY�?JIV?BEGaOi�ZdI�C(�fZ[Ëq?BEG?JIKF?JIKg,Z[EcLSIfH9?JIKFn�RLSTfld���fCygO?(�3?B?JI�C��DZ¡Ëq?BEc?JI�Fn?BgO?JI�FBpR?O� aV�[p�Y\LSIfhGZd�V?BE9C�YBC�N�?OpRC�IfZ[aS�KF9YBldTV�8pQCOID��C�hGFWEG?B?BFY\LOEcIV?BEy©.COID��IfLn�VLSTf�fFBpK?JCOY0��hGTfY0��Yc�fCOIVaO?oLON�?JI�g.Z[EGLSIfH�?JI�FR��LSTDld�¤COlbhWLnY0�fCOIVaO?oFG�V?oA3?BEGN�LOEcH�COIfY\?O��Æ �V?JIC�hGZdH�ZbldC�E�hW?JH ZdIfC�E��RCOh�aSZdgO?JI(C�F¢Cn�DZ¡Ëq?BEc?JI�F�TfIfZ[gO?BE0hGZ[Fji¤ZdID;oZ[?JIfIDC�CnN�?B� �fCJi.h)ldC�FW?BEJpVCOl[EG?JCO�fi FG�V?oN�?B?JldZdIVaLONvFG�V?��C�E¢�RCOhM�fZ¡Ë3?BEG?JI�FBpVFG�f?�COTf�fZ[?JIDY\?@��COhM�DZ¡Ëq?BEc?JI�F¹�FG�V?BEG?���?BEG?�H�COI�i�TfIf�f?BEGaOEcCO�fTfC�FW?�C�EGFGhMH�C=�½LOE0h0»0pFG�V?EcLKLSH ��COh¢�fZ[Ëq?BEG?JIKF�¹¥Y\EGL=�M�V?J�U»0pqCOIf�(hWL�LON�Y\LSTVEchW?OpDFG�V?A3?BEGN�LOEcH�COIfY\?���COh¢�fZ¡Ë3?BEG?JIKFGÇ����

£¢�DZdh��fCOh�AfEGLON�LSTfIf��ZdH9AUldZdYBC�FGZ[LSIfh`NmLOE��KTfCOlbZdC-��FG�V?��KTfCOlbZ[FGC�FGZ[gO?�N�?B?JldZdIVanLONvHnTfhGZbYn¹�LOE¢LON�COIKiKFG�fZbIVa�?JldhW?=»ZdhRIVLOF��WTDhWF�Y\LOaSIfZdFGZ[gO?OpVZ[FRZbh�COldhGLnhWL.YBZdCOl��Qr@h�COI�iOLSIf?ohcTV§ YBZ[?JIKFGl[i9?\�.Aq?BE0Z[?JIfY\?J�¤�MZ[FG��ZdH9AfEGL=g,ZbhGC�FGZ[LSI��.IVL=�MhBp�,TfCOldZdC�C�EcZdhG?�ZbI�ZdI�FW?BE0COY\FGZ[LSI��MZ[FG��LOFG�f?BE�H�TDhGZdYBZdCOIfhJpqFG�f? COTf�fZ[?JIDY\?Op�FG�V?9EGL,LSH ¹¥Z[FGh�ADC�EcFGZdYBTfldC�E�COY\LSTfhWFGZbYBhBp?O� aV�[p�ZdFGh�Ec?JhWLSIfCOIKFnN�EG?J�,TV?JIfYBZ[?Jh�»0pkFG�V?�IDC�FGTVEG?�LONMFG�V?�ZdIKg,Z[FGC�FGZdLSI�FWL�A3?BEGN�LOEcH(p�FG�V?��fZdhWFWLOEci�LON¢LOFG�V?BE9A3?BEW�N�LOEcH�COIfY\?Jh¤ZdI�hGZdH ZdldC�E9YBZ[EcYBTfH hWFGCOIfY\?JhBp)COIf��H�LOEG?Op)H�TfY0�!H9LOEc?O�ºr@hD�MiOLO�OL��¢EGLOFW?Op9ÂWZdH�AfEGLyg.ZdhGC�FGZdLSI�ZdhZdIKFW?BEcY\LSIfIV?JY\FGZdLSI��ÅÃ"¼½I5FG�f?�FW?JY0�fIfZdYBCOl�ldCOIfaSTfC�aO?�LONoX,?JY\FGZ[LSI�¾,�Á¾,p��KTDCOldZdC�C�Ec?�hcZ[FGTfC�FW?J��p`COID�5FG�DC�F�hcZ[FGTfC�F½�?J�fIV?Jhch9Zdh9IVLOF@�GTfhWF9Y\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[gO?OpRLOE�?BgO?JI�?JH��3L,�DZ[?J��p`Z[F9Zdh�?JIDCOY\FW?J� ���oTfCOldZbC$C�EG?(?JIDCOY\FW?J�!ZdI�ADC�EcFGZdYBTfldC�EA3?BEGN�LOEcH�COIfY\?JhB©KFG�V?Bi�YBCOIfIVLOF��3?MhW?BADC�EcC�FW?J��N�EGLSH FG�f?��Vi.IfCOH�ZdYBhQLON�FG�VLShW?MA3?BEGN�LOEcH�COIDY\?JhBpKCOIf� NmEcLSH ?BgO?BEGiK�FG�fZdIfa�FG�DC�F�Y\LSI�FWE0Z[�DTVFW?Jh�FWL(FG�fLShW? �Vi.IfCOH�ZdYBhJ�Z[fLSldl[Ly��ZdIVa�;�i,aOLOFGhW�,i | � �k�Îp8�R?��RLSTfld��?JhWA3?JYBZdCOldldi�H9?JIKFGZ[LSIH�C�FW?BEcZbCOl,H�?J�fZdC�FGZ[LSI�¹�?O� aV�[pKZdIDhWFWEcTfH9?JIKFGhBpOhGY\LOEG?JhJpOaO?JhWFGTVEG?Jh��,i�HnTfhGZdYBZbCOIfhBp�COIf��hWLSTfIf�nZ[FGhW?Jl[N0»0pSCOID��YBTfldFGTVEcCOl�p�fZdhGFWLOEcZdYBCOl`�f?BgO?Jl[LOADH9?JIKFBpQZdIfYBldTD�fZdIVa�FG�V?�hWFji.ldZdhGFGZdY�?\�.A3?JY\FGC�FGZ[LSIfhnEG?JhGZd�DZdIVa�ZdI5l[LSIVa�FW?BEcH H�?JH9LOEGiOpk�M�fZbYc��MZdlblULON�Y\LSTVEchG?�Yc�fCOIfaO?�COhMldZbhWFW?JIfZdIVan?\�.Aq?BE0Z[?JIfY\?COYBYBTfHnTfldC�FW?JhB�

£vTVEcIfZbIVa)FWLoFG�V?�hW?JY\LSID��FWLOAUZdY�p�FG�V?RIfLOFGC�FGZ[LSI�LONDÆ�?JhWFW?BEcI�YBldCOhGhGZbYBCOlKHnTfhGZdY��fCOhvCOI�ZdIKFW?BEG?JhWFGZbIVaM?BgOLSldTfFGZ[LSI�p�MZ[FG� C�YBl[?JC�ERAfEGLOaOEc?JhGhGZ[LSI9FWL=�RC�E0�fhR?\�,?BEcYBZbhGZdIVa�H�LOEG?�Y\LSIKFWEGLSlULygO?BE�A3?BEGNmLOE0H9?BEchB��^`C�Ecldi�HnTfhGZbY¢IVLOFGC�FGZ[LSI��fZd�IVLOFo?BgO?JI�hWA3?JYBZ[N�i��fTVEcC�FGZdLSI�pqld?BF@COl[LSIf?nCOH9AUldZ[FGTf�V?Opq�M�V?BEc?JCOh@hGLSH9?�EG?JY\?JI�F�IVLOFGC�FGZdLSI�C�FWFW?JH9AfFGhoFWL(hWA3?JYBZ[N�ig�C�EcZ[LSTfh�COhWA3?JY\FGh�LON�ZbI�FWLSIfC�FGZdLSI�p~COl[FG�VLSTfaS��FG�fZdh�YBCOI��q?9gO?BEci��fZd§ YBTfl[FBp8COh�FG�V?�hGTV�fFGld?�ZdIV¦f?JY\FGZ[LSIDh�LON��GC��B�HnTfhGZdYBZdCOIDhRhcTfYc�(COhM�$Zdl[?Jh)>oCyg,ZdhMH�C��O??JhWA3?JYBZdCOldldi$¹¥COIf��gO?BEGi��3?JCOTVFGZ[N¥Tfldl[if»�YBl[?JC�Ey�`r�lbhWLVpVEG?JYBCOldl3LSTVE)?JC�E0ldZ[?BEH9?JIKFGZ[LSI(LON } LSIVLVÉÅh¢N�?BEcH�C�FGC.�

} LOFGC�FGZ[LSI�Zdh(IV?BgO?BE�g�COldTV?�If?JTVFWEcCOl ��Z[F�ZbI�gOLSl[gO?Jh$Yc�VLSZbY\?Jh�LON��M�fC�F(FWLºIVLOFGC�FW?OpFG�fC�F�ZbhBpoLON��M�DC�F�ZdhZdH9A3LOEGFGCOIKFB©q?BgO?JI$FG�f?nY0�VLSZdY\?��h��IVLOFGC�FW?9ZdIKgOLSl[gO?JhMFG�f?�g�COldTV?�LONQ?\�,?BE0YBZdhGZdIVa¤Y\?BEGFGCOZdI�NmLOE0H�hMLON�Y\LSI�FWEGLSlvL=gO?BEA3?BEGN�LOEcH9?BEchB��£M�V?¤hGZdFGTfC�FGZ[LSI�Zbh�hGZbH�ZdldC�E�N�LOE�FWE0COIfhGY\EcZ[ADFGZ[LSI�p�COIf��?BgO?JI�N�LOEnCOIDCOl[i,hcZdhBpv�q?JYBCOTDhW?¤COI�COIfCOl[i.hWFHnTfhWF�H�C��O?�g�COldTV?\�jlbCO�V?JI Yc�VLSZdY\?Jh�LON����fC�F(FWL�COIfCOl[i,�B?Op�VLy�"FWL COIfCOl[i,�B?�Z[FBp�COIf� �VLy��FWL�EG?BA3LOEGF(FG�V?EG?JhGTDl[FGhBp.COH9LSIVanLOFG�V?BE)FG�fZdIVaShJ�^[fLOE)?\�.COH9AUl[?Op,hGAq?JY\FWE0COlqCOIDCOl[i,hcZdh�ZbI�gOLSl[gO?JhRFG�V?og�COldTV?@Yc�VLSZdY\?oLONvl[?JCJg.ZdIVanLSTVFA3?BEGN�LOEcH9?BE)ZdIKFW?BEcCOY\FGZ[LSIfhB�Q¨�Ly�R?BgO?BEJpUFG�fZdh��VL,?Jh¢IVLOF)H9?JCOI�Z[F)Zdh�IV?JY\?JhchGC�EGi�FWL9�q?JY\LSH�?�VLOA3?Jl[?JhGhGl[i�H Z[EG?J��ZdIC�hW��COH9A�LON�EG?JlbC�FGZ[g,ZdFjiO����IV?�YBCOI�COl[��CJi.h�hGAq?JC���ZdI�LSIf?OÉÅhLy��I�gOLSZdY\?OpvNmEcLSH"LSIV?OÉÅhLSIf?�g�COlbTV?JhBp�COID��LSIV?ä ( � ØÎÐW×�ßyÐ�ØQÞ8Ï�ÚoÏ�×0ÑkÝOÚ0Ó�ß=ÐèØÎÐWß � нå�ÜÎÒÅÚ�Ó �=â oÛ)ÒÅÔ�ÏBÜ�Þ3Ú0Ó�ßyÐ�Ø`Ï�ÚWÞ�×0Õ�ß=ÒÅнÓ�å�Ð#�,ØÎÚBÚ0Û ×0å½Ú0Õ�Ñ¥ÜÎÒÅå½Ñ*�fÐ�ÜÎå�â�å½Ú0Õ�ÖÁßnнÓBÜÎÐ�ØQÒÅÓBÜÎÚ�ÜÎÏ=Ð

� ÓBÜÎÒÅå½ÒÅÝ�×GÜÎÚ0Ø�ê �@ÚJß=нÖ�ÜÎÚQ×�+Sнå�ÜqÒÅÜÎÑ�à�ÖÅÒÅÑ¥ÜÎнÓ�ÒÅÓ=Ô=â ã�Í3Ï=Ð�×cÓ�Ñ¥ÞqÐ�Ø3ÒÅÑUØj×GÜÎÏ�Ð�ØUÑ�ÒÅÛ)Ý�ÖÅÐ��f×cÓ¢×0Õ�ß=ÒÅнÓ�å�Ð~å½×0Ó¢éOÐ�Ü�Øj×0Ó�Ñ�åèØÎÒÁéOнß)×0ÑqÒ Ù�Ò ÜUÞqÐ�ØÎÐÚ�Ó=ÐkÚ0Ù.ÜÎÏ=ÐkÛRÕ=Ñ�ÒÁå�Ò ×cÓ�Ñ*�=×0Ó�ß�ØÎнÖÁ×cÜÎнß�ÜÎÚ�Ú0ÜÎÏ=Ð�Ø8ÜÎÒÅÛ)Ð bæ�×GØ�ê=ÒÅÓ=Ô�Ý�×cØj×0Û)ÐèÜÎÐ�ØÎÑ�éBê@×cÝ�ÝyØÎÚ�Ý=ØÎÒÁ×GÜÎÐkå½Ú�Û)ÝOÚ0Ó�нÓBÜÎÑ8×0Ó�ßMÞqнÒÅÔ�ÏBÜÎѽâ

À��

Page 18: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

YBCOI�COldhWL¤Y\LSH�ADC�EG?ng�C�EcZdLSTfh¢N�LOEcH�hMLONQCOIfCOl[i.hGZdhBpDCOID��TfhW?�FG�fC�F@FWL¤�V?Jl[A�ZdIVN�?BE¢FG�V?JZ[E�g�COlbTV?JhB���oIV?nC�AfAfEGLSCOY0�Zdh�FWL�?\�.AqLShG?¤hWLSH9?��V?BFGCOZdldhFG�fC�F�C�EG?�Z[aSIVLOEG?J���Ki�hWLSH�? N�LOEcH�LON)COIfCOldi,hW?JhJp��DTfFFG�fC�F�C�Ec?¤ZdH9A3LOEGFGCOIKFN�LOEÂWCOl[FW?BEcIDC�FGZ[gO?JÃ�NmLOEcH h¤LON�H�TfhcZdY5¹¥IVLOFW?�FG�V?��fZ[aS�Dl[i�g�COldTf?\�jldCO�V?JIºTfhW?�LON�FG�V?�FW?BEcH ÂWCOl[FW?BEcIfC�FGZ[gO?JÃ�� »0� [fLOE?\�VCOH9ADl[?Op�LSIV?�H Z[aS��F�TfhG?�YBldLShW?Jl[i�FGZbH9?J��hW?J�KTf?JIfY\?Jh�LON�hGAq?JY\FWE0COlkCOIfCOl[i.hW?Jh�ZdIfhWFW?JCO��LONRFWEcCOIfhGY\E0Z[AfFGZ[LSI�COhC�DCOhGZbh�N�LOE�?\�VCOH�ZdIDZdIVa�hWLSH�? �DIf?¤�V?BFGCOZdlbh�LON¢AUZ[FGYc��pkZdIKFWLSIfC�FGZ[LSI8pv?BFGY����@N¢Y\LSTfEchW?¤COIKi��fZbhGYBTfhGhGZdLSI�LONMhGTfY0��fC�FGC�Zbh)Z[FGhW?Jl[N�C�NmLOE0H LON�FWEcCOIfhGY\EcZdAfFGZ[LSI�p.�M�fZbYc�(C�aSCOZdI�If?JY\?JhGhGC�EcZdldi¤ZdIKgOLSl[gO?Jh¢g�COldTV?Y0�VLSZdY\?JhB�

X.ZbH�ZdldC�E�Y\LSIfhGZd�f?BEcC�FGZ[LSIfhkC�AfAUl[i�FWLhWFWE0TfY\FGTVEG?OpS���fZdYc�9COlbhWL�?JIfY\L.�V?Jhkg�COldTV?JhBp�hcZdIfY\?)�V?JYBZd�fZbIVao�M�fC�FkY\LSTfIKFGhCOh�hWFWEcTfY\FGTfEG?�ZdhvC�g�COldTf?\�jldCO�V?JInYc�VLSZdY\?O�([VLOE�?\�VCOH9ADl[?OpOCOIKiAfEG?BN�?BEG?JIfY\?R�3?BFj�R?B?JI�hWi,H H9?BFWEGi�COIf�nCOhWi.H�H9?BFWEGiZdhog�COldTV?\�jldCO�f?JI�p8COIf��?BgO?JI��M�DC�FoY\LSTDI�FGh�COh�hWi,H H9?BFWEGi�ZdhoYBTfl[FGTVEcCOlbl[i��V?BFW?BEcH�ZbIV?J����£¢�V?9�fZdhWFWLOE0ZdYBCOlvFWEG?JIf�FWLy��C�Ec�fh�?BgO?BE�H9LOEG?oAfEG?JYBZdhG?@IVLOFGC�FGZdLSI�pVCOIf��FG�V?oY\LSIfY\LSH�Z[FGCOIKF¢�VLy��IVaOEcCO�fZdIfa�LONvZdH9AfEGL=g,ZbhGC�FGZ[LSI¤�MZ[FG�fZdI FG�V?YBldCOhGhcZdYBCOlDFWE0CO�fZ[FGZ[LSI�p.C�FWFW?JhWF)FWL9COI�LSIVaOLSZdIfan�V?Bg�COldTfC�FGZdLSI LONv�KTfCOlbZ[FGC�FGZ[gO?oCOhWA3?JY\FGh�LON�?\�,A3?BEcZd?JIfY\?Op,ZbI N¥CJgOLOE¢LONH9LOEG?��,TfCOIKFGZ[FGC�FGZ[gO?�COhWA3?JY\FGhBpfCOIf��FG�fZdhRY\LOEGEG?JlbC�FW?Jh)�MZ[FG��hWLSH9?oLON~FG�f?@AU�fZdl[LShWLOAU�fZdYBCOlfH9L=gO?JH9?JIKFGhM�fZdhcYBTfhGhW?J�?JC�EcldZd?BE�ZdI$FG�fZdhMADC�A3?BEJ� �oTfCOlbZdC�EG?BADEG?JhW?JIKF�C¤�,ZdID��LONQEG?B�3?JldlbZ[LSI(C�aSCOZdIfhWFoCOldl~FG�fZdhBp3H�COIfZ[N�?JhWFGZdIfa IVLOF@LSIfl[i(ZdIAD�fZbl[LShWLOAD�KiOpO�DTVFQCOldhGL�COh`C��,ZdID��LON3hGL,YBZdCOlDH9LygO?JH9?JIKFBp.?O� aV�[p |~�� �Î�Q�RTfF`�V?JhWADZdFW?¢COldlVFG�fZdhJpSZ[F`hG�VLSTDld�9Y\?BEGFGCOZdIfldiIVLOF��3?�FG�fLSTVaS��F)FG�DC�F��,TfCOldZbC�C�EG?�ZdIDY\LSH9ADC�FGZ[�Dld?M�MZ[FG��FW?JY0�fIfZdYBCOl3AfEcLOaOEG?JhGhRLOE)�MZ[FG��H�C�FG�V?JH C�FGZdYBCOl�H9L.�V?JldhB©COh@hGTVaOaO?JhWFW?J��ZdI$X.?JY\FGZ[LSIfh�ÊV�Á¾�COIf�$ÊV�Á¿,pqhcTfYc�$FW?JYc�fIDZd�KTf?JhMYBCOI$�q?�TfhW?J��FWL�H9L.�V?Jl8�,TfCOldZdC.pqCOIf��FWL¤?\�,AUl[LOEG?FG�V?JZ[E)ADEGLOA3?BEGFGZ[?Jh)ZdI�aOEG?JC�FW?BEo�V?BAfFG�8�

r@I�ZdIKFW?BEG?JhWFGZdIfa��i,A3LOFG�V?JhGZdhkZdhQFG�fC�FQaOL,L,���WC��B�MZbH9AfEGL=g,ZdhcC�FGZ[LSI9ZdIKgOLSl[gO?JhkN�LOEcH�hkLON�ldC�EGaO?MaOEcCOZdI9hWFWEcTDY\FGTVEG?FG�fC�FM�DZ¡Ëq?BE)N�EGLSH FG�fLShW?LONkYBldCOhGhGZbYBCOl8H�TDhGZdY�pfCOIf��ZdN�hWLVpf�R?�YBCOI$�VLOA3?�NmLOE¢LSTfEMH�ZdIfZbH�TfH'Y\LSH9AUl[?\�.ZdFji�COl[aOL��EcZ[FG�DH FWL�H�C��O?�FG�f?JhW?@hGFWEcTfY\FGTVEG?JhRH9LOEG?�?\�,AUldZdYBZ[FB©KFG�V?BEG?oC�EG?�COldhGLnhWLSH�?�ZdIKFW?BEG?JhWFGZdIfa�hGH�COlblfaOEcCOZdI�hWFWEcTDY\FGTVEG?JhFWL@�q?�?\�,AUl[LOEG?J���Q�@NfY\LSTVEchG?Op�FG�f?�gO?BEGi�Zd�V?JC¢LONUl[LKLO�.ZdIVaMNmLOEkhGTfY0��hGFWEcTfY\FGTVEG?JhvZdIKgOLSl[gO?Jhvg�COlbTV?JhB��r�EG?JldC�FW?J�nZd�V?JCZdhkFWL�Zd�V?JIKFGZ[Nmi�ADC�FWFW?BEcIfh`LON�ZdI�FW?BE0COY\FGZ[LSI COH9LSIfa�ZdH9AfEcLyg.ZdhGZdIVaoHnTfhGZdYBZdCOIDhB��rºEG?JhW?JC�E0Yc��ADEGL��½?JY\F�LSI9FG�fZdh`Y\LSTfld�H�C��O?�fTDCOlqTDhW?oLON�g.Zd�V?BL�EG?JY\LOEc�DZdIVaSh�COIf��FG�V?hWFWE0TfY\FGTVEcCOlqEG?JhW?JH��DldCOIDY\?oH�?JCOhGTVEG? ��ZdI�FWEcL,�fTDY\?J��ZbI(X.?JY\FGZ[LSIÊV�Á¿,p�FWL$FWEci�FWL��V?BFW?BEcH ZdIV?�hWL.YBZdCOl`COID��HnTfhGZdYBCOlQY\LSIKFW?\�.FGh��M�V?BEG?�LSIf?¤ZdH9ADEGLyg.ZdhW?BEZdH Z[FGC�FW?JhBp�hGTVAfA3LOEGFGhBp�LOEYc�DCOldl[?JIVaO?Jh¢COIfLOFG�V?BEJ�

r�AfADldZbYBC�FGZ[LSI�LON�FG�V?��Vi.IfCOH�ZdYBCOl�hWi.hWFW?JH�h�C�AfAfEGLSCOY0� FWL�N�EG?B?$ZdH�AfEGLyg.ZdhGC�FGZdLSI!C�EG?��3?JZdIVa�?\�.ADl[LOEG?J� ZdIY\LSldldC��3LOEcC�FGZdLSI(�MZ[FG�(>oCJg.Zd�$��LOEcaOL |¡À $ �Î�Rr AfEc?JldZdH�ZdIDC�EGi�LO�DhW?BEcg�C�FGZ[LSI�Zdh)FG�fC�FMZbH9AfEGL=g,ZdhG?BEch)�VL�IVLOF¢�3?J�fCygO?ldZ[�O?(AUC�EGFGZdYBl[?Jh9ZdI�AU��i.hGZdYBh���FG�V?Bi�EcC�Ec?Jl[i5ldZbIVaO?BE�ZdI�l[L=�Ä?JIV?BEGaOi��DCOhGZdIDh�LONoC�FWFWE0COY\FGZ[LSI�p)COIf��LON�FW?JI�FWEGi�FWLCJgOLSZb��?BgO?JI�aO?BFWFGZdIfa�IV?JC�E9FG�V?JH(©)FG�V?Bi�hWLSH9?BFGZbH9?Jh�ÂW�V?BN�i�aOEcCyg,ZdFji.Ã!¹�LOE�ÂW�V?BN�i5?JIKFWEGLOA,iOpÅÃ��V?BA3?JIf�fZdIVa$LSIFG�V?Y0�VLSZdY\?LONkH9?BFGC�AD�fLOE�»RCOIf�n�GTfH9A�FWL C��DZ[aS�V?BE)Y\LSH9ADl[?\�VZ[FèiU©DCOID��FG�V?Bi(hWLSH9?BFGZdH9?Jh¢FWL hGTVEGN�COI�½?J�VaO?�LONYc�DC�LShGÃ�N�LOE�C��DZ[FBp~�q?BN�LOEG?9gO?B?BEcZbIVa(L�Ë�ZbI�C�IV?B� �fZ[Ec?JY\FGZ[LSI�©�hG?B? COldhWLY|(�k�Î� } L��VLSTV�DF�FG�V?�ZdH9ADlbZdYBZ[F��fEcCOH�CCOIf��hW?JIfhG?¤LON�NmEG?B?J�fLSH ZbI�gOLSl[gO?J��ZdI5FG�fZdh�Zdh�ADC�EGFnLONMFG�f?�C�FWFWE0COY\FGZ[LSI�LONMFG�V?��3?JhWF�ZdH9AfEGL=g,ZbhW?J�5HnTfhGZbY���¼�FH�C��O?Jh�ZdIKFGTfZ[FGZ[gO?(hW?JIfhG?�FG�fC�F�FG�V?$�Vi,IDCOH�ZdY(�V?BgO?Jl[LOAUH9?JI�F LONoHnTfhGZbY(hG�VLSTfld��ZbI�gOLSl[gO?�COIKFGZdYBZ[AUC�FGZ[LSI�pRFGZdH9?Y\LSIfhGYBZdLSTfhGIV?JhGhJpD�KTDCOldZdC.pDCOIf��Y\LSH9ADl[?\�VZ[Fji(ZdI�N�TfID�fCOH9?JIKFGCOl��RCyi,hJpqCOIf��LSIV?�H�ZdaS��F¢aOL�hWL N¥C�E�COhMFWL¤hGTfaOaO?JhWFFG�fC�F¢FG�f?BLOEcZ[?Jh)FG�fC�F��VL�IVLOFMCO�f�fEG?JhGh�FG�V?JhW?�ZdhGhGTV?Jh)YBCOIDIVLOF¢�3?CO�V?J�,TfC�FW?O�

� � ¯�¬�²1Q0±ZSq³c¯�¬ZS

£¢�fZbhkADC�A3?BE��fCOhRC�FWFW?JH9AfFW?J��FWLn?\�,AUl[LOEG?MFG�f?��,TfCOldZ[FGC�FGZ[gO?@COhWA3?JY\FGh`LON�?\�.A3?BEcZ[?JIfY\?@TfhGZdIfaH�TfhcZdYMCOhR�fC�FGC.pVCOIf�FWLMAUldCOY\?QFG�fZdh8?\�,ADldLOEcC�FGZ[LSIZdIFG�V?�Y\LSIKFW?\�,FvLONVhWLSH9?�EG?Jl[?Bg�COI�F8AU�fZdl[LShWLOAU�fZdYBCOl�pJY\LOaSIfZdFGZ[gO?`hGYBZ[?JIKFGZ��DY�p�COIf��H�C�FG�.�?JH�C�FGZdYBCOlUFG�V?BLOEcZd?JhB�`�oTVEQLO�DhG?BEGg�C�FGZdLSIfh��DCJgO?�hcTVAfA3LOEGFW?J��Y\?BEGFGCOZbI FG�V?BLOE0Z[?Jh`COIf�¤Yc�fCOlbl[?JIVaO?J��LOFG�f?BEchB�Qr@H9LSIVaFG�VLShW?�hGTVAfA3LOEGFW?J��C�Ec?M¨�TDhGhW?BEcl�ÉÅhQAD�V?JIVLSH9?JIfLSl[LOaOi�LON3FGZdH�?Opm;@iKaOLOFGhW�,iqÉÅh�YBTfldFGTVEcCOl¡�j�fZbhWFWLOEcZdYBCOl.C�AfAfEcLSCOYc��p.COIf���?BiO?BEJÉÅh`COIKFGZdYBZ[ADC�FWLOEcinC�AfADEGLSCOYc��pK�M�fZdld?)P��DCOldH9?BEchBÉO�fTDCOldZdhGH(pO�REG?JIKFGCOIVLVÉÅhQFG�f?JhGZdh�LSI�ZdIKFW?JIKFGZ[LSIfCOldZ[FèiOp��,TfCOldZdCEG?JCOldZbhGH(pD�,TfCOldZdC C�FWLSH�ZdhGH(p3¨@TfH9?OÉÅh¢A3LSZdIKFGZdldZbhWF�FGZdH9?Op3COIf��YBldCOhchGZdYBCOl~Y\LOaSIDZ[FGZ[g.ZdhGH �DCJgO?n�q?B?JI$�fZdhGY\LSIl�fEcH9?J�C�FQl[?JCOhWFQZbI�ADC�EGFB��r�ldl,FG�V?JhG?)AqLShcZ[FGZ[LSIfhv�R?BEG?¢�fZdhGYBTDhGhW?J��ZdInFG�V?)�3L,�fiLONUFG�f?)ADC�A3?BEJpOLONmFW?JI��fEcZ[?B¦fiOpOCOIf�9hGLSH9?\�FGZdH9?Jh@�MZdFG�VLSTVF@FG�V?�FW?JYc�fIfZbYBCOl�FW?BEcH�ZdIVLSldLOaOiO�� �oTfCOldZdC¤EG?JCOldZbhGH�Ã�COhGhW?BEGFGhoFG�fC�F��,TfCOldZdC��fCygO?9EG?JCOlv?\�.ZdhGFW?JIfY\?¹�LOE¤Â½LSIKFWLSl[LOaSZdYBCOl�hWFGC�FGTfhGÃ�»0pqCOIf��ÂW�,TfCOldZdC�C�FWLSH�ZbhGH�Ã�COhGhG?BEGFGh¢FG�fC�F��KTfCOlbZdC�C�EG?�ZdIf�f?JY\LSH9A3LShGC��Dl[?O�

À �

Page 19: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

r@H9LSIVa$FG�V? IV?B� Zd�V?JCOh�ZbI�FG�fZdh�AUC�Aq?BEyp~LSIV?�H�Z[aS�KF�MZdhG��FWL��fZ[aS�flbZ[aS��FoFG�V?��fZdhGYBTDhGhGZ[LSI�LON)Y\LSIKFW?\�,F�ZdIHnTfhGZdY�p,FG�V?o�V?z�DIfZ[FGZdLSI�LON~�,TfCOldZdC�FG�fC�F�CJgOLSZd�fh)�DTfCOldZdhGH�pSFG�V?oC�AfADldZdYBC�FGZdLSI�LON�hGFWEcTfY\FGTVEcCOlD�Dl[?JIf�DZdIVaFWL�H�TDhGZdY�pFG�V?�r@I�FGZdYBZdADC�FWLOEGi���L.�V?Jl3LON�HnTfhGZdYoTfID�V?BEchWFGCOIf�DZdIVaVp�FG�f? ��TfCOldZdCnCOIf��X�¨Mi,A3LOFG�V?JhW?Jh)C��3LSTVF�FG�V?�hWFWEcTDY\FGTVEG?LON��KTfCOlbZdC.p.FG�V?o?JH9AD�fCOhGZbh�LSI�hWL,YBZbCOlqCOID��g�COldTf?oZbhGhGTV?Jh)ZdI�HnTfhGZdY�pVCOIf��FG�f?�EG?JhW?JC�EcY0�(AfEGL��W?JY\FGh¢hGTVaOaO?JhGFW?J�(�KiFG�V?Ec?JhW?JH��UldCOIfY\?H9?JCOhGTfEG?COIf�(FG�V?�Y\LSH9ADl[?\�VZ[FjiK�Î�DCOhW?J���Vi,IDCOH�ZdYBCOl�hWi.hWFW?JH�h¢H�L,�V?JlÎ�

PRLOaSIDZ[FGZ[g.ZdhGH �RCOh COldhWL�H9?JIKFGZ[LSIV?J��hW?BgO?BEcCOl¢FGZdH9?Jh9�DTfF�IfLOF��fZdhGYBTfhchW?J�5ZbI��V?BFGCOZdl��C~Z[�O?�H�COIKi�LOFG�V?BEFG�V?BLOEcZd?JhBp)Y\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[g.ZdhGH C�EcLShW?$COh¤C�EG?B�3?JldldZdLSI�C�aSCOZbIfhWF FG�f?�LygO?BEcldi�EG?JhWFWEcZdY\FGZdgO?���LOE0ld�Vg.Z[?B� LONhWLSH9?$AfEcZ[LOEFG�V?BLOEGiOpSZbIFG�fZdh�YBCOhW?OpO�3?J�fCJg.Z[LOEcZbhGH(py���fZdYc��FWEcZ[?J��FWL@hWFGTD�Vio�q?J�DCJg.Z[LOE���Z[FG�VLSTVF~ZbI�gOLO�.ZdIVaMH ZdIf���vP�LOaSIfZ[FGZ[g.ZdhGHZdInFG�V?��fEGLSCO��hW?JIDhW?�LONDFGC��.ZdIVa�H�ZdIf�nhW?BEcZdLSTfhGl[iOpOZdh�CO�fH�ZdEcC��Dl[?Op��DTVF�ZdInN¥COY\FBp�H9LShWFQY\LOaSIfZdFGZ[g,ZbhWF�Ec?JhW?JC�EcYc��FGC��O?JhC(HnTfYc��H�LOEG?9IfC�EGEGL=�_g,Z[?B��p~ZdI��M�fZdY0��Y\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[LSI�Zdh�Y\LSIDhGZd�V?BEG?J��Y\LSH9AUTVFGC�FGZ[LSI�p~hGL(FG�fC�F��3L,�ViOp�?JH�LOFGZ[LSI�pCOIf� hWL.YBZ[?BFèi C�Ec?�IV?BaSl[?JY\FW?J��p�COIf� FG�V?�EG?BAfEG?JhG?JI�FGC�FGZ[LSI LON��.IVLy��l[?J�VaO?�?JH9?BEGaO?Jh$COh�C�Y\?JIKFWEcCOl�AfEcLO�Dl[?JH(�¼½I5Z[FGh�YBldCOhGhGZbY�N�LOEcH(pkIVLy�'YBCOldl[?J��½aOL,L,��LSld��N�COhG�DZ[LSIV?J��r�¼½Ã�LOE�Â������ �!�jpÅÃ��,IfLy�Ml[?J�faO?�Zdh�EG?BAfEG?JhG?JI�FW?J��ZdIhWi.H��3LSldZbY9l[LOaSZdY�p�COI�C�AfAfEcLSCOYc�5�M�fZdY0��FG�V?¤ldLOaSZdYBCOlQA3LShGZ[FGZdg,ZdhGFGhoLONRFG�f?D;oZ[?JIfIfC$P)Z[EcYBl[?9�RLSTfld��ADEG?JhGTfH�C��Ul[i�fCygO?¤?JIf�fLOEchW?J���(£¢�V?�Y\LSIfhWADZbYBTVLSTfh�N¥COZdldTVEc?9LON)FG�fZdh�C�ADAfEGLSCOYc�8pv?O� aV�[pQZbI�FG�V?�ESC�ADCOIV?JhG? [�Z[N�FG��@?JIV?BE0C�FGZ[LSIAfEGL��W?JY\FBp~�fCOh�ZbIfhWADZ[Ec?J�$C(I,TfH��q?BEoLON��DZ[LSl[LOaSZdYBCOlbl[i�H9LOFGZ[g�C�FW?J��EG?z�UIV?JH9?JIKFGhBp8hGTfY0��COhIV?JTVEcCOl�IV?BFGh�COIf��hWL��YBCOldl[?J�nC�EGFGZ��UYBZdCOlKlbZ[Nm?Op��M�DZdYc�n�VLoIVLOFBpS�VLy�R?BgO?BEJp�C��UCOIf�VLSInFG�V?�Y\LSH9ADTVFGC�FGZ[LSIDCOl,H�L,�V?JlÎp�IfLOE��fL�FG�V?Bi�hWLSl[gO?�FG�V?AfEGLO�Ul[?JH LONfEG?BADEG?JhW?JIKFGC�FGZ[LSI�p��M�fZdY0��YBCOI��3?`H9LOEG?RAfEG?JYBZdhG?Jl[i�N�LOEcHnTfldC�FW?J�nCOh~FG�f?:� � �Dy �8�m�� � x �H� � ���uv �myz���z��pA3LShW?J��pq�DTVF@IVLOF@hGLSl[gO?J��p3�Ki�X,FW?Bg�COI�¨@C�EcIfCO�c| Êm� � �¢FG�V?�ZdhGhcTV?�Zdh@�VL=��FG�f?nhWi.H��qLSlbZdY�EG?BAfEc?JhW?JI�FGC�FGZdLSIfhoTfhW?J�ZdI(C�Y\LSH�ADTVFGC�FGZ[LSIfCOl~H9L,�f?Jl�YBCOI�Y\LSH9?FWL EG?BNm?BEMFWL�FG�V?EG?JCOl8��LOEclb���

Æ �fZdl[?nFG�V?�ZdIfNmLOEcH C�FGZ[LSI�AfEGL.Y\?JhGhGZdIVa�H9L.�V?JldhoLONRY\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[g.ZdhGH C�AfA3?JC�ECO�V?J�,TfC�FW?�N�LOEH�COIKi�COhWA3?JY\FGh�LONl[L=� l[?BgO?Jl�A3?BEcY\?BAfFGZ[LSI�p�FG�f?JZ[Eo?\�.YBldTDhGZ[LSI�¹�LOE�YBTVEchGLOEGi�FWEG?JC�FGH9?JIKF0»oLON�?JH��3L.�fZdH9?JIKFBp�?JH9LOFGZ[LSI8p~COIf��hWL.YBZ[?BFjiEG?JIf�f?BE FG�V?JH TfIfhGC�FGZbhWN�COY\FWLOEci�COh�C5FG�V?BLOEGi�LON��M�fC�F�Z[F H9?JCOIDh FWL5�q?��KTDH�COIo| ¾�Êfp � � �Î� ¼½I�ADC�EGFGZbYBTfldC�EJp?JH��qL.�fZdH�?JI�FBp.?JH9LOFGZ[LSI8pDCOIf�(hWL.YBZ[?BFji(C�EG?Y\?BEcFGCOZdIfl[i�ZdH9A3LOEGFGCOIKF)ADC�EGFGh�LONk�VLy� EG?JCOl��KTDH�COIfh¢YBCOI(�3?�ldZ[g.ZdIVahWLSldTfFGZ[LSIfh¢FWL�FG�V?nhWi,H��3LSl8aOEGLSTDIf�fZdIVa AfEGLO�Dl[?JH��¢£¢�V?A3?BEGg�COhGZ[gO?nZdIV¦DTV?JIDY\?LONQY\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[g.ZdhGH Zdh¢ADEG?JhGTfH�C��Ul[iLSIV?�EG?JCOhGLSI��M��i��KTDCOldZdC�ZdI�aO?JIV?BEcCOl�pfCOID�¤?JH�LOFGZ[LSI�ZdI�ADC�EGFGZbYBTfldC�EJp.�fCJgO?��q?B?JI(hGL�If?BaSl[?JY\FW?J�(�,i¤FWEcCO�DZ[FGZ[LSIfCOlAD�fZbl[LShWLOAD�Ki�LON�H�ZdID��p,r�¼�p.lbZdIVaSTfZdhGFGZdYBhBp�COIf��hWL�LSI��kÆ�?H CJi��VLOA3?�FG�fC�F�FG�fZbhRZbhRIfLy� �3?BaSZdIfIfZbIVaFWL�Yc�DCOIVaO?O�

�oTfE�LO�DhG?BEGg�C�FGZdLSIfh�LSI�H�TfhcZdYBCOl��,TfCOldZbC$TfID�V?BEcH�ZdIf?$¹¥Y\LSH9ADTVFGC�FGZdLSIfCOlm»�Y\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[g.ZdhGH���>@?JhGY\EcC�FW?JhJÉ �r� ���{R�8x �z� � � �Y�z� � � � | ¾.À��QCOIf��IV?JC�Ecl[i$COldl�hcTV�DhW?J�,TV?JIKF@H9?BFG�fL,�VLSldLOaSZdYBCOlvaSTfZd�V?JldZbIV?Jh¢N�LOE�hGYBZ[?JIKFGZ��DY�EG?JhW?JC�EcY0��phGTVaOaO?JhGFMFG�fC�F�?Jl[?JH9?JIKFGh¢LONkCOI�i(Ec?JCOhWLSIfC��Dl[?��,ZdID�(hG�VLSTfld�(Y\LSH��DZdIf?�ZdI(��CJi.h�IfLOF¢FWLKL��fZdhGhcZdH�ZdldC�ERN�EGLSH �VL=�C�FWLSH�hnY\LSH��UZdIV?9FWL�N�LOEcH�H�LSl[?JYBTfl[?JhB�¤�RTfF���?��fCJgO?�hW?B?JI�FG�fC�FnH�TfhcZdYBCOlk�KTDCOldZdC��3?J�fCJgO? gO?BEGi��fZ¡Ë3?BEG?JI�FGldiN�EGLSH FG�fC�F)Zd�V?JCOl�p.hWL9H�TDYc�(hWL�FG�fC�F)Z[F�Zdh��fZ[§ YBTDl[F`FWL9ZdH�C�aSZbIV?�E0Tfl[?Jh�NmLOE)C�ÂWYBCOldYBTfldTDh�LONv�KTDCOldZdCOÃ�FG�fC�F)Y\LSTfld�CO�V?J�,TfC�FW?Jl[in�V?JhGY\EcZ[�3?R�VLy���,TfCOldZdC�Y\LSH��UZdIV?O��£¢�fZdhvZdh�ZdI�ADC�EGF��3?JYBCOTfhW?)�KTDCOldZdCMC�Ec?RFW?JH�AqLOE0COlK?JIKFGZ[FGZ[?JhkC�E0ZdhGZdIVaFG�VEGLSTfaS��FG�V?�LOA3?BEcC�FGZ[LSI(LON�C9Y\LSH9ADl[?\�3pf�V?BFW?BEGLOaO?JIf?BLSTfh�hGi,hWFW?JH Ç � FG�DC�FMZdh)ldC�EGaO?Jldi¤TfIfY\LSIDhGYBZ[LSTfhBpVZdIDYBldTf�fZdIfaH9L.�fTfl[?Jh`FG�fC�F)YBCOI��3?MEGLSTVaS�Dl[i��V?JhGY\EcZd�q?J�¤COhR�DT.Ë3?BEchBp.H9?JH9LOEcZ[?JhJpKADC�FWFW?BE0I�EG?JY\LOaSIfZ[�B?BEchJp.COIKFGZdYBZ[AUC�FWLOEchBpVCOIf�?JH9LOFGZ[LSIDCOl�Nm?B?J�V�UCOYG�.Ç � �nr@l[FG�VLSTfaS��hGTfYc���V?JhGY\EcZ[ADFGZ[LSIfh@TfhGZdIVa�COI�ZdIfNmLOEcH C�FGZ[LSI�AfEGL.Y\?JhGhGZdIVa�H9?BFGC�AD�fLOE�YBCOIY\?BEGFGCOZdIDl[i9�3?��V?Jl[ADN�TflÎpSFG�V?oTfIf�V?BEcldi,ZdIfaY\LSH9ADl[?\�VZ[Fji¤H�C��O?Jh)Z[F�ZbH9A3LShGhGZ[�Dld?)FWLn�VLnEG?JCOldZbhWFGZdYMhcZdH�TDldC�FGZ[LSIfhBp,COIf�TfIVEc?JCOhWLSIfC��Dl[?oFWL¤?\�,A3?JY\FMhGZbH9ADl[?�ldCy�Mh)FWL �VLSlb��NmLOE@�KTfCOlbZdC.�k¼�ID�V?B?J��pVEG?BN�?BEG?JIfY\?FWL�YBTfl[FGTVE0COl�IVLOEcH�hBpf�DZdhWFWLOEW�ZdYBCOl�Y\LSIf�fZ[FGZ[LSIDhCOIf��AfEc?JY\?J�V?JI�FGhJpvADEcZ[g�C�FW?�?JH9LOFGZ[LSIfCOl�hWFGC�FW?JhBpkADTf�DldZdY�EG?JCOY\FGZ[LSIfhJp�COID��hWL�LSI8pvC�EG?�TfhGTfCOlbl[iHnTfYc�5H9LOEG?¤�f?Jl[AfN¥Tfl�ZdI�TfID�V?BEchWFGCOIf�DZdIVa�H�TfhcZdY9FG�fCOI5hWA3?JYBTfldC�FGZ[LSIfh�DCOhW?J��LSI5IV?JTVEcCOl`C�EcYc�fZdFW?JY\FGTVEG?O��¼èFnZdhFji,ADZdYBCOl3LONv?JH9?BEGaO?JIKF¢AD�f?JIVLSH9?JIfC.pVZ�� ?O�[pVLON�l[?BgO?Jldh�LON�Y\LSH9ADl[?\�VZ[Fèi FG�fC�F¢YBCOI(LSIDl[i �3?�hW?B?JI(C�FMC�ldC�EGaO?BEMaOEcCOZdILON`�V?JhcY\EcZ[AfFGZ[LSI8pDFG�fC�F@FG�V?Bi$�fL¤IVLOFoN¥Tfldl[i�EG?J�fTfY\?nFWL�l[Ly�R?BEl[?BgO?JldhB©�ZdI�FG�fZdh@hW?JIfhW?Op3FG�V?Bi$C�EG?��z�D� F�����H�¥�<[fLOE?\�VCOH9ADl[?Op.ldCJ��h`C��3LSTVF`g�COl[?JIfY\?@ZdI�Y0�V?JH�ZdhWFWEci�C�EG?��fZd§ YBTfl[FkFWL�EG?J�fTfY\?�FWL�FG�V?@l[?BgO?JlfLON8�,TfCOIKFGTfH H9?JYc�fCOIDZdYBhB��R?JYBCOTfhW?�LON¢hGTfY0�5Y\LSH9AUl[?\�.ZdFGZ[?JhBp�ZdF�hW?B?JH�h��RLOEGFG�����fZdl[?9FWL�?\�,AUl[LOEG?�FG�V?�hGZdH9AUl[?BEJp~�fZdaS�V?BE�l[?BgO?Jl�H9L.�V?JldhLONX,?JY\FGZ[LSI�ÊV��¨�Ly�R?BgO?BEJp~FG�fZbh��VL,?JhoIVLOFoH9?JCOI�FG�fC�Fog�COldTDC��Dl[?�ZbIfhGZ[aS�KFGhMYBCOIfIfLOF@�3?��fCO�$NmEGLSH H9L.�V?Jldh@C�FoFG�V?ä 2 Í3Ï=ÒÅÑ3ÒÅÑUÜ�êyÝ=ÒÁå½×0Ö�ÚcÙvàmÑ¥ê=Ñ¥ÜÎÐ�Û)Ñ�ã`ÝyØÎÚJß=Õ=å½ÐWß)éBê�нæ\Ú0ÖÅÕ=ÜÎÒÅÚ�Ó �BÜÎÏ=ØÎÚ�Õ=Ô�Ï�ÜÎÏ=Ð�ÔcØj×�ß=Õ�×0ÖS×cå½å�ØÎÐ�ÜÎÒÅÚ�ÓMÚ0ÙKÓ�ÐèÞ�١н×cÜÎÕ=ØÎÐ�Ñ3Ú�Ó)ÜÎÚ�Ý¢ÚcÙKÚ0ÖÁß=Ð�ØÑ¥Ü�ØÎÕ�åèÜÎÕ=ØÎÐ½Ñ 0DÒ Ü�×0ÖÅÑ�ÚÑ�Õ�Ô�Ô0нѥÜÎÑ�ÜÎÏ�×cÜQÜÎÏ�Ð)Û�Õ�Ñ�ÒÅå)Ú0Ù~×oÏ=ÒÅÔ�Ï�Ö ênß=нæ�нÖÅÚ�ÝOÐWß9×cÖÁÒÅнÓ9Ñ�ÝOÐ�å½ÒÅнÑ�ÞqÚ�Õ�ÖÁß�×cÖÅÛ)Ú�Ñ¥Ü�å½Ð�Ø�Üj×0ÒÅÓ=ÖÅênéOÐ)ÛRÕyÜÎÕ�×0ÖÅÖ êÕ�Ó=ÒÅÓJÜÎÐ�ÖÁÖÅÒÅÔ�ÒÅé=ÖÁÐ $d×cÓ�ß�Ð�æ\нÓ@Õ=Ô�Ö ê�&UÜÎÚ�ÏJÕ�Û¢×cÓ�ѽâä ��� Ú�Û)Ð�ÒÅÓBÜÎÐ�ØÎнѥÜÎÒÅÓ=Ô�Ñ�Õ�Ô0Ô�нѥÜÎÒÅÚ�Ó=Ñ�×céOÚ�Õ=Ü�ÜÎÏ=ÐkÓ�нÕyØj×0ÖSé�×cÑ�нÑ~Ú0ÙfáBÕ�×cÖÅÒ ×)×GØÎÐkÔ�ÒÅæ\нÓ�ÒÅÓ � �'.��dâ

À �

Page 20: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

IV?JTVE0COlkl[?BgO?Jl�p�COh�ZdldldTDhWFWEcC�FW?J���,i�FG�f?�A3LShGhGZ[�Dld?nY\?Jldl`COhGhW?JH��Dl[i�H9L,�f?JlkNmLOE�AfEGLOFW?JIKFGZ[LSI�ZdI�X.?JY\FGZ[LSI�ÊV�Á¿,���oIFG�V?�LOFG�V?BE��fCOID��pSFG�V?@�Vi,IDCOH�ZdYBCOlfhWi.hWFW?JH�h`FG�V?BLOEGi9LON~X,?JY\FGZ[LSI ÊV�Á¿�H�L,�V?JlbhQ�KTDCOldZdC.pS?JH9LOFGZdLSI�p�?BFGY��.C�F�C�H9LOEG?C��DhWFWE0COY\FBpD?JH9?BEGaO?JIKFBpfaSl[LO�UCOl8l[?BgO?Jl��

r@I�FGZbYBZ[ADC�FGZ[LSI¤�fCOhR�q?B?JI ��?JlblD?\�.ADl[LOEG?J�¤ZdI hGLSH9?@C�Ec?JCOh�LON�Y\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[gO?oIV?JTVEGLShcYBZ[?JIfY\?Op.ZdIfYBldTf�DZdIVao?\Ëq?BEc?JIfY\?Y\LOA,i�ZdI�A3?BEcY\?BAfFGZ[LSI8p�COIf��>oCOIfZd?Jl`>@?JIfIV?BFWFn�fCOh?BgO?JI��¢EcZ[FWFW?JI�FG�fC�F�ÂWCOldl`�fEcCOZdIfh�C�Ec?OpvZdI�?JhGhW?JIfY\?OpkCOIKFGZdYBZ¡�ADC�FGZ[LSI$H�COYc�DZdIV?JhGà |¡À � �Î�¢¨ML=��?BgO?BEyp3Y\LOaSIDZ[FGZ[gO?�hcYBZ[?JIfY\?��DCOhMADCOZb��ldZ[FWFGl[?C�FWFW?JIKFGZ[LSI�FWL FG�f?��.ZdIf�(LONQC��DhGFWEcCOY\FCOIKFGZdYBZ[ADC�FGZ[LSI�ZdIKgOLSl[gO?J�(ZdI�HnTfhGZdY�pVl[?BF)COl[LSIV?oFWL9Z[FGh)Y\LSIfIf?JY\FGZ[LSI��MZ[FG��?JH9LOFGZ[LSI8p.COID�¤FG�DZdhRADC�A3?BE�COlbhWL9�fCOh)hWLN¥C�EohcCOZd��Ec?JldC�FGZ[gO?Jl[i�lbZ[FWFGl[?�C��3LSTVF@?JH9LOFGZ[LSI8pq���fZdYc��ZdhoC�N�FW?BEoCOlbl�FG�f?�?JhGhG?JIfY\?�LON`�KTDCOldZdC.���?BiO?BED|~�8� �kC�EcaSTV?JhN�LOE�C�ÂWldCJ� LON8C�Ëq?JY\FBpÅÃ�FG�fC�F�?JH9LOFGZ[LSI�ZdI�HnTfhGZdY ÂWZdhQ?BgOLO�O?J���M�f?JI�C�FW?JID�V?JIfY\i�FWL�Ec?JhWA3LSIf��ZdhQZbIf�fZ[�DZdFW?J��pÅÃoLOEZdI(C¤l[?JhGh)�3?J�fCyg,Z[LOE0ZdhWF)ldCOIVaSTfC�aO?OpU�M�V?JI(COI�?\�,A3?JY\FGC�FGZ[LSI$Zdh¢IVLOFMH�?BFB��¨�Ly�R?BgO?BEJp3FG�fZdh)C�AfAfEcLSCOYc��hG?B?JH�h¢FWL,LhGZdH�ADl[?Op8COhZdh�hcTVaOaO?JhWFW?J���,i�FG�V?�I,TfH9?BEGLSTfh��,TfCOldZ �DYBC�FGZ[LSIfhoFG�fC�F���?BiO?BE�ZdhoNmLOE0Y\?J��FWL�ZdIKgOLO�O?¤ZdI�LOEc�f?BEFWLC�AfADldi FG�fZdh)lbCJ� FWL ADC�EGFGZdYBTflbC�E)?\�.COH9AUl[?JhB�kÆ�?��3?JldZd?BgO?@FG�DC�F¢FG�V? �oTDCOldZdC�¨Mi,A3LOFG�V?JhGZdh�aSZdgO?JI�ZdI$X,?JY\FGZdLSI(ÊV�Á¿Zdh)H9LOEc?AfEG?JYBZdhG?OpfY\LygO?BEch@C�FMl[?JCOhWF�COhMH�COIKi¤?\�VCOH9ADld?JhBpfCOIf��ZdhMH9LOEG?COH9?JIfC��Ul[?�FWL�?JH9ADZdEcZdYBCOl3FW?JhWFBpfFG�fLSTVaS�LON�Y\LSTfEchW?oH�TfY0����LOEc� Zdh�IV?B?J�V?J��FWL�g�COlbZd�fC�FW?@FG�V?JhW?o�3?JldZ[?BN¥hB��¼�F�hW?B?JH�h�A3LShGhGZ[�Ul[?¢FG�fC�F)hWLSH9?�hGTDYc��C�AfAfEGLSCOY0�Y\LSTfld��AfEcLyg.Zd�V?9C�NmLSTDIf�fC�FGZ[LSI�N�LOEC�N�TVFGTfEG?9H�TfhcZdY\LSl[LOaOi�FG�DC�FZdh@�qLOFG��H�LOEG?9AfEG?JYBZdhG?nCOIf��H�LOEG?�CO�V?J�,TfC�FW?N�LOEMY\LSI�FW?JH�AqLOE0C�EGi�NmLOEcH h)LON�?\�.AfEG?JhchGZ[LSI��

£¢�f?BEG?nZbh@C�YBl[?JC�E�?BgOLSldTfFGZ[LSIfC�EGi�?\�.ADldCOIDC�FGZ[LSI�NmLOEoFG�V?�EGLSl[?nLONQ?JH9LOFGZdLSI�ZdI$�f?Jl[ADZdIVa LOEGaSCOIfZdhGH h�ADEG?J�fZdY\F?BgO?JIKFGh(ZdI�FG�V?JZdE¤?JIKg,ZdEGLSIfH9?JIKF���£~L�AfEGLSH9LOFW?�hGTVEcg,Z[g�COl�p)H9L.�V?BEcC�FW?�YBTVEcZ[LShcZ[Fji�COIf�º�fZdhGY\L=gO?BEGi!hG�fLSTfld���3?EG?B��C�Ec�V?J��p��M�fZdl[?RTfIfY\?BEGFGCOZbI�FèinhG�fLSTfld��C�EGLSTfhW?)ZdIKFW?BEG?JhWFBp��DTVFkhG�VLSTflb���3?JY\LSH9?¢TDIVADl[?JCOhGCOIKF��M�V?JI�hGTV§¤YBZ[?JI�FGldihWFWEGLSIfaV�1C8?BF�Tfh�YBCOlblDFG�fZbh�� � �fw� � u=·mu�� �VP�LSH��DZbIV?J���MZdFG��FG�V? �oTfCOldZbC¨Mi,A3LOFG�V?JhGZdhJpKZ[F�AfEGLyg.Zd�V?JhRCEcLSTVaS�aSTfZd�f?�FWL FG�V?�.ZdIf�Dh�LONv?JH�LOFGZ[LSI�ZdI�H�TfhcZdY�pfCOIf��FG�f?�YBZ[EcYBTfH hWFGCOIfY\?Jh)LONkFG�V?JZdE¢AfEGL.�fTfY\FGZ[LSI �v?JH�LOFGZ[LSI$C�E0ZdhW?JhN�EGLSH Ec?JldC�FGZ[LSIfh�ZdI FG�V? ÂWIVL=�MÃ�COH9LSIVa�EG?BFW?JIKFGZ[LSI�pMADEGLOFW?JI�FGZdLSI�pMCOIf� A3?BEcY\?BAfFGZ[LSI�©@FG�V?�EcZ[aS�KF �DCOlbCOIfY\?$LONIVL=gO?Jl[Fji�COIf��ADEG?J�fZdY\FGC��DZbldZ[Fji��MZdlblQH�COZdIKFGCOZdI�ZdI�FW?BEc?JhWFnCOID��ADld?JCOhGTVEG?Op��M�fZbl[?9FWLKL�ldZdFWFGl[? IVL=gO?Jl[Fji5�MZdldlQYBCOTDhW?l[LShGh¢LONvZdIKFW?BEG?JhWFBpUCOIf�(FWL,L H�TDYc�(�MZbldlq�q?JY\LSH�?�TfIVADld?JCOhGCOI�F Ç � �

£¢�f?R�KiKA3LOFG�V?JhG?Jh�ZdI�FG�fZdh�ADC�A3?BE��fCJgO?�LOFG�V?BEkZdH9AUldZdYBC�FGZ[LSIfhJpy�DTVF�FWL�CJgOLSZd���fZdlbTVFGZdIVa¢Z[FGhvN�L,YBTDhBp���?�H9?JIKFGZ[LSILSIfl[inFG�V?)N�LSldl[L=�MZdIVaV��£¢�V?Bi�?\�,ADlbCOZdI��M�KinHnTfhGZdY�?\�V�fZ[�UZ[FGh�CY\LSI�FGZbIKTfCOlD�V?BgO?Jl[LOADH9?JIKFQLON3IV?B����CJi.hQFWL�Y\Ec?JC�FW?COIf��H�COIfZdADTfldC�FW?�ldZdhWFW?JIf?BE�?\�.A3?JY\FGC�FGZ[LSIfhBp~COhoLSlb�V?BEo�RCyi,h��3?JY\LSH9?9FWL,L�N�COH ZdldZdC�EJ©�ZdID�V?B?J��p�Z[F�Zdh@A3LShGhGZ[�Dld?FWLg.Z[?B� FG�f?��M�fLSl[?n�DZdhWFWLOEGi(LON`HnTfhGZbY�ZdI$FG�fZdh@ldZ[aS�KFB��£¢�f?Bi�COldhWL�?\�,AUldCOZdI�FG�f?�ADld?JCOhGTVEG?�FG�fC�F�H�TfhcZdYBZdCOIfhn¹¥COIf�H�COIKi�LOFG�V?BE�AfEGLON�?JhGhGZdLSIfCOldh0»�FGC��O?�ZdI�l[?JC�E0IfZdIVa�IV?B� hG�,Zdlbldh�COIf�5N¥TVEGFG�V?BE��V?BgO?Jl[LOADZbIVa�LSld��hW�.ZdldldhJ��r�IfLOFG�V?BEZdH9AUldZdYBC�FGZ[LSI�N�LOE�l[?JC�E0IfZdIVaZdh`FG�fC�F`FW?JhGF½�ÎLOEcZ[?JIKFW?J� FW?JCOY0�fZdIVa�YBCOI��3?MCOIKFGZ¡�ÎAfEGL.�fTfY\FGZdgO?Op��3?JYBCOTfhW?@Z[F`YBCOI ZbIf�fZ[�DZdF?JH9LOFGZ[LSIDCOl�EG?JhWA3LSIfhW?OpVADEG?BgO?JI�FM?\�,ADldLOEcC�FGZ[LSI�pfCOIf�(�DTfldl3YBTVEcZ[LShcZ[FjiO�

PRLSIDhGYBZ[LSTfhGIf?JhGh`�fCOh�hWL�N¥C�ER�q?B?JI¤H9?JIKFGZ[LSIV?J� H COZdIfl[i�ZdI�Ec?JldC�FGZ[LSI�FWLnFGZdH9?�COIf�¤�,TfCOldZbC.�kX,?JY\FGZdLSI�¾,�Á¾�COIf�X,?JY\FGZ[LSI�¿¤C�EGaSTV?J�$FG�fC�F�?JIDCOY\FGH9?JI�F�IVLOF�LSIfl[i(Y\LSIfhWFWE0TfY\FGh@LO�.�½?JY\FGhW�jZdI.�ÎFGZdH9?Opq�DTVF�COldhWL�FG�V?JZ[E�Y\LSIKFW?\�.FGhBp8COIf�?BgO?JI�FGZdH9?�Z[FGhW?Jl[N�pDFG�fEGLSTVaS�$AfEGL.Y\?JhGhW?Jh�FG�fC�F�ZdI�gOLSldgO?�EG?BFW?JIKFGZ[LSI�p3COIf�$AfEGLOFW?JIKFGZ[LSI�LOE@COIKFGZdYBZ[AUC�FGZ[LSI��oX.?JY\FGZ[LSIÊV�Á¿5C�EGaSTV?J��FG�DC�F¤�,TfCOldZdC�C�Ec?$�V?BFW?BEcH ZdIV?J���,i�g�C�EcZbC�FGZ[LSIfh�LONhcCOldZ[?JIfY\iOp�LOE¤ZbI�FG�V?�H�L,�V?JlÎpRLON��R?JZ[aS�KFBp¢COhCOI�ZdIKFWEcZdIfhGZbY�ADC�EGFnLONMFG�V?JhW?�AfEGL.Y\?JhGhW?JhJpk�M�fZdY0�5Z[FnFG�V?BEG?BN�LOEG?�hW?B?JH�hnEG?JCOhWLSIDC��Dl[?�FWL�YBCOlbl u ��� · �Uuy·�u ���RLOFG�¨@TfhGhW?BEclÎÉÅh�FGZdH9?�Y\LSIfhWFWEcTDY\FGZ[LSI!COIf� LSTVE��KTDCOldZdC�Y\LSIfhGFWEcTfY\FGZ[LSI!i,Z[?Jlb�!Y\LSIfhGYBZdLSTfh ?BgO?JIKFGhBpMCOID�!FG�V?$NmLOE0H9?BEYBCOI5�q?�hW?B?JI�COh�ZdH�ADldZ[?J���,i�FG�V?�ldC�FWFW?BEJpkCOl[FG�VLSTVaS��Z[F�hc�VLSTfld���3?�IVLOFW?J��FG�DC�FnHnTfYc�5LON)�M�fC�F�aOLK?JhnLSI�ZdhTfIfY\LSIDhGYBZ[LSTfhBpVZdIDYBldTf�fZdIfa�HnTfYc��LONvCOIKFGZdYBZ[ADC�FGZdLSI�COIf�(hGCOldZd?JIfY\i��f?BFW?BEcH�ZdIfC�FGZdLSI��

£¢�DZdhMhGTfaOaO?JhWFGhoFG�fC�F�� ����Y\LSIfhGYBZ[LSTfhcIV?JhGh@C�EcZdhW?Jh�FG�VEGLSTVaS��hW?JIfhG?\�jH�C��,ZbIVa¤ADEGL,Y\?JhchW?JhoZdI�gOLSldg,ZdIfa COI�FGZbYBZ[ADC��FGZ[LSI�pv�M�fZbYc��AfEcL,�fTDY\?��KTfCOlbZdC(COh�hcTV§ YBZ[?JIKFGl[i�hGCOldZ[?JIKF�Yc�,TfIV�.hB��C8?BFnTfh�YBCOldlQFG�fZdhFG�f? & � � ��fw� � uy·�u ©QZ[FAfEGL=g,Zb�V?Jh�C$FG�f?BLOEGi�N�LOE9FG�V?�LOEcZ[aSZdI�COIf��hWFWEcTDY\FGTVEG?�LON�Y\LSIfhcYBZ[LSTfhGIV?JhchB��¼èN@Y\LOEGEG?JY\FBpRZ[F���LSTflb�5�V?JldA�FWL�?\�,�ADldCOZbI��M��i(Y\LSIfhcYBZ[LSTfhGIV?JhchMY\LSIKFGZdIKTf?Jh¢FWL¤hG?B?JH hWL¤H�i.hWFW?BEcZ[LSTDh���Z[F�Zdh)�3?JYBCOTfhW?�R?��DCJgO?n�q?B?JI�l[LKLO�.ZdIVa�C�F@Z[FFG�VEGLSTfaS��ZbIfC�AfAfEGLOADEcZdC�FW?Op��fZbhWFWLOEGFGZdIVanl[?JIfhW?JhJ©,N�LOE�?\�.COH�ADl[?OpVC�FWFW?JH9AfFGZdIfa�FWL�g.Z[?B� �KTfCOlbZdC�COh�LO�.�W?JY\FGZ[gO?oN¥COY\FGhBpLOEnFWL$COhGhGZdaSI�FG�V?JH hWLSH9?�IV?B� LSIKFWLSl[LOaSZdYBCOl�hWFGC�FGTfhJpvZdIDhWFW?JCO��LON¢hW?B?JZbIVa$hW?BaSH�?JI�FGC�FGZ[LSI��,i�hGCOldZ[?JIfY\i�COhnCOIZdIV?Bg.Z[FGC��Dld?�Nm?JC�FGTfEG?�LON¢LSTVE�AfEGL.Y\?JhGhW?Jh�LONM?JIfCOY\FW?J��A3?BEcY\?BADFGZ[LSI���¼�F�COldhWL�ZdH9ADldZd?JhFG�fC�F�H�TDYc��EG?JhW?JC�EcY0��LSIä ��!UÕ=Ü~Ò Ü�Ñ�Ï=Ú�Õ=Ö ßMéOÐkÓ�ÚcÜÎÐWßMÜÎÏ�×cÜ8ÛRÕ=åèÏMå½Ú0ÓJÜÎÐ�Û)ÝOÚ0Øj×cØ�êMÛ�Õ�Ñ�ÒÅå�ÒÅÑ8Ð 9yÝ�ÖÅÚ0ØÎÒÅÓ�ÔRÔ0Øj×�ß=×cÜÎÒÅÚ�Ó=Ñ�ÚcÙVÜÎÏ�ÒÅÑ8Õ�Ó=Ý�ÖÅÐW×0ÑÎ×cÓBÜÎÓ�нÑ�ѽâ

¾�$

Page 21: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

Y\LSIfhGYBZdLSTfhGIV?JhGho�fCOho�3?B?JI�H�ZdhGNmL.YBTfhW?J��LSI�A3?BEcZ[AD�f?BEcCOl~ZdhchGTV?JhBp3FG�V?BEG?B�,i�ADEGL,�DTfYBZdIVa H ZdhGl[?JCO�fZbIVa EG?JhcTfl[FGhB�¼½ICO�f�fZdFGZ[LSI�p~Z[F�hGTVaOaO?JhWFGh�FG�fC�F�HnTfhGZbY9Zdh�COI5Zd�V?JCOlk?\�.A3?BEcZdH9?JIKFGCOlQH9?J�fZbTfH NmLOE�FG�V?¤hGFGTf�Vi�LON�Y\LSIDhGYBZ[LSTfhGIf?JhGhBphGZdIDY\?Z[FMCOldl[L=�Mh¢TfhMhW?B?@�DIV?�f?BFGCOZdldh¢ZdI�FG�V?AfEGL.�fTfY\FGZdLSI¤LONk�,TfCOldZdC.pfZbh¢hGTV�.�W?JY\F¢FWL�?\�.A3?BEcZdH9?JIKFGCOl8H�COIDZ[ADTfldC��FGZ[LSI�ZdI�C�g�C�E0Z[?BFji9LON���CJi.hBpVCOl[EG?JCO�Vi��DCOh�C�EcZdYc�¤ldZ[FW?BEcC�FGTfEG?�COIf�¤�fZdhGYBZdADldZdIV?RLON8FWEcCOZbIfZdIVaVp�COID� Zdh�COH9?JIfC��Dl[?�FWLH9L.�V?JlVY\LSIfhWFWE0TfY\FGZ[LSI�C�F`hG?BgO?BEcCOlDl[?BgO?Jlbh Ç � ��£M�V?M��COZbI�p �oTfCOlbZdC.pS^�COIf� P�¨Mi,A3LOFG�V?JhW?JhQ�V?JldA�TfIf�V?BEchGFGCOIf��FG�V?hWFWEcTDY\FGTVEG?�LON�Y\LSIfhGYBZ[LSTfhcIV?JhGh��QZ[FGh)hG?BaSH9?JI�FGh�C�EG?��,TfCOldZdC.pV�fZd?BEcC�EcYc�DZdYBCOldl[i�LOEcaSCOIfZ[�B?J�(�,i¤FG�f?JZ[E¢hGCOldZ[?JIDY\iOpV�MZ[FG�?JH9LOFGZ[LSIDCOl�FWLSIV?��V?BFW?BEcH�ZbIV?J���Ki$FG�V?JZ[EoEG?JhWLSIDCOIfY\?��MZ[FG��AfEcLOFW?JI�FGZ[LSI8��¼�Fo�MZdldl��3?�hcTVEGAfEcZbhGZdIVa ZdNQFG�V?9N¥TVFGTVEG?�VL,?JhoIVLOF�hW?B?9C¤aOEc?JC�F�V?JCOl�H9LOEG?�EG?JhW?JC�EcY0��LSI�FGZdH9?Op3?JH9LOFGZ[LSI�COID��Y\LSIDhGYBZ[LSTfhGIf?JhGhoTfhGZdIVa�H�TDhGZdYnCOh��fC�FGC.pCOh¢�R?Jldl�COhMEG?JhW?JC�EcY0��LSI�HnTfhGZdYoTfhcZdIVa9Y\LSIfY\?BAfFGhMNmEGLSH Y\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[gO?�hcYBZ[?JIfY\?�COIf��Y\LSIfhGYBZ[LSTfhcIV?JhGh)hWFGTf�DZ[?JhB�

�$COI�i �¢EcZ[FW?BEch��fCJgO?�CO�Vg�COIfY\?J��Zd�V?JCOh�FG�fC�F�C�EG?@Y\LSIDhGZdhWFW?JIKF���Z[FG� COIf��=LOERhGZbH�ZdldC�EQFWLnFG�V?P�¨�i,AqLOFG�f?JhGZdhB©�R?MIVLy� �fEcZ[?B¦Di�hGTVEcgO?Bi¢�GTfhWFQC�N�?B�!LON3FG�V?JhG?O��£M�V?)EGLSl[?¢LON3FGZdH�?¢ZdI9Y\LSIfhGYBZ[LSTDhGIV?JhGhk��COh`hGFWEG?JhGhW?J� �KinƺZbldldZdCOHESCOH�?JhBp`�M�fL��V?JhGY\EcZ[�3?J�5FG�V?�ÂWhWA3?JYBZ[LSTfh�ADEG?JhW?JIKFGÃ�COh��fCJg.ZdIVa ÂWC�Y\?BEcFGCOZdI��fEG?JCO�VFG��LONoZ[FGh�L=�MI�LSI��M�fZbYc��R?�hGZ[F�A3?BEcYc�V?J�8pUCOIf��NmEGLSH �M�fZbYc���R?�ldLKLO��ZdI�Fj�RL��DZ[EG?JY\FGZ[LSIfhMZdI�FWL¤FGZdH9?Jà |~��$8�ΩfESCOH9?Jh�FG�VLSTVaS�KF�FG�DZdh¢��COhC��3LSTVF�ÀJ¾9hW?JY\LSIf�DhBpfZdI(YBl[LShW?C�aOEc?B?JH9?JI�FM�MZ[FG��|~�8� �Î� E�COH9?Jh)COldhWL9�MEGLOFW?�FG�fC�F¢FG�V?hGFWEG?JCOH LON�Y\LSIfhGYBZ[LSTfhcIV?JhGhZdh9ÂWldZd�O?oC��UZ[Ec��ÉÅh�ldZ[N�?Op.H�CO�V?�LON�COI(COl[FW?BEcIfC�FGZ[LSI�LONv¦DZ[aS�KFGh)COIf��A3?BEcY0�fZdIVaShBpÅÃ�C�gO?BEGi �DIV?��V?JhcY\EcZ[AfFGZ[LSI�LONvFG�V?Yc�,TfIV�.ZdIVa¤LON`Y\LSIfhGYBZdLSTfhGIV?JhGhJp3COID�$�V?�Y\LSIfhGZb�V?BEG?J�$FG�V?�EGLSl[?nLON`COI�FGZbYBZ[ADC�FGZ[LSI�p3TfhGZbIVa FG�V?nFW?BEcH ½FW?JIf�V?JIDY\iO�ÅÃ�$C�EGFGZdI�¨M?JZb�V?BaOaO?BEJÉÅh@EG?JCO�ViK�ÎFWL��j�fCOIf��| Ê �k�kZdh@COldhWL�EG?JldC�FW?J�8�@¨�Ly�R?BgO?BEJp~FG�f?nY\LSH��DZdIfC�FGZdLSI�LONRY\LSIfhGYBZ[LSTfhcIV?JhGhCOIf��COIKFGZdYBZ[ADC�FGZdLSI��fCOh�EG?JY\?JZ[gO?J��Ec?JldC�FGZ[gO?Jl[i�lbZ[FWFGl[?(hGYBZ[?JIKFGZ��DY�C�FWFW?JIKFGZ[LSI�TfIKFGZdlREG?JY\?JIKFGl[iO� �MCOl[AD��^�ldldZdhnCOIf�} C�FGZ[��C } ?B�¢FWLSI | ¾8�8�)CO�fg�COIfY\?Jh C��Ki,AqLOFG�f?JhGZdhnEG?JldC�FW?J��FWL�LSTVE0hBpQ�DTVF��VL�IVLOF9Y\LSIfhcZd�V?BE�FGZdH9?Op`�,TfCOldZbC.pQLOEFG�V?JZ[EhGFWEcTfY\FGTVEG?JhJ� ��LOEG?BL=gO?BEJpk^`ldlbZdhoCOIf� } ?B�¢FWLSI�p�COID��H�COIKi$LOFG�V?BE0hBp�ZdIDYBldTf�fZdIfa �¢L.�fIV?Bi�PRLOFWFW?BEcZdlbl:|¡ÀJ¿ �Îp�¢L.�VLSl[N�L�C~lbZdI��COhBp`COID�a�@?BEcCOld�!^`�V?JldH COI�p�ldZbH�Z[F�FG�V?JZ[E�Y\LSIfhcZd�V?BEcC�FGZ[LSI�LON@COIKFGZdYBZ[ADC�FGZdLSI�FWL�hW?JIfhGLOEGi��jH�LOFWLOEhWi.hWFW?JH�hBpD�M�fZdY0��?\�.YBldTD�V?Jh�FG�V?�YBCOhW?�LON�HnTfhGZbY��

r@I�ZdIfhcZ[aS��FWN¥TflDADC�A3?BE)LON } ?B�¢FWLSIY|~��$ �~Y\LSH�?Jh¢?BgO?JI�YBl[LShG?BEJpfhGTVaOaO?JhWFGZbIVa�C9IfC�FGTVEcCOlbZdhWFGZdY�?\�,AUldCOIfC�FGZ[LSI�N�LOEFG�V?�?JH9?BEGaO?JIfY\?�LONQY\LSIfhGYBZdLSTfhGIV?JhGhJpUZdI��M�fZdY0�(�fEcCOZdI�AfEGL.Y\?JhGhW?Jh�AfEGL=g,Zd�f?�C�AD�Ki.hGZdYBCOl8�UCOhGZdh¢N�LOE@FG�V?�H�i,hGFW?BEcZ¡�LSTfhoCOIf��ZdIV?\Ë�C��Dl[?nYc�fC�E0COY\FW?BE�LON��,TfCOldZdC.pq�MZ[FG�VLSTfF�YBldCOZdH ZdIVa�FG�fC�FoFG�V?Bi�COY\FGTfCOldl[i(?\�VZdhWFB� } ?B�¢FWLSI�hGTVaOaO?JhGFGhFG�fC�FoY\LSIfhGYBZ[LSTDhGIV?JhGhM?JH9?BEGaO?Jh@FWL¤�fCOID�fl[?FG�V?nIVLygO?JldFji�FG�fC�F@EG?JhGTDl[FGh¢N�EGLSHÄ�Ul[?JIf�fZdIfa�ZdIfY\LSH9ADC�FGZd�Dl[?Y\LSH9A3L��IV?JIKFGhB��¨�Ly�R?BgO?BEJpk�V?BE�IVLOFGZ[LSI�LON��Dld?JIf�fZdIVa�Zdho�DZbIf�fZdIVaVp3�M�f?BEG?JCOh�LSTVEIVLOFGZdLSI�Zdh�C(AfEc?JYBZdhW?�H�C�FG�V?JH C�FGZdYBCOlN�LOEcH�COldZ[�JC�FGZdLSIo| ¿�Ê8�@LONC�hWFWEcTDY\FGTVEcCOl)aO?JIV?BE0COldZ[�JC�FGZ[LSI LON�FG�V?$Y\LOaSIDZ[FGZ[gO?$lbZdIVaSTfZdhGFGZdY�IVLOFGZ[LSI�LON��Ul[?JIf�fZdIfa � � ���LOEG?BLygO?BEJp.�R?��VL�IVLOF�C�aOEG?B?@�MZ[FG�-|~��$ �DFG�fC�F�FG�V?M�Dld?JIf�V?J�9Z[FW?JH�h�H�TDhWFQ�3?MZdIfY\LSH�ADC�FGZ[�Dl[?OpSYBlbCOZdH�ZdIVaZbIfhWFW?JCO�FG�fC�F)H9LOEG?oY\LSH9ADld?\� �Dl[?JIf�Dh`AfEcL,�fTDY\?�H9LOEG?oY\LSIfhGYBZdLSTfh��KTfCOlbZdC.�([VLOE¢TfhBp.ZdIV?\Ë�C��DZdldZdFji9C�EcZdhW?JhR�3?JYBCOTfhW?o�,TfCOldZdC�fCygO?¤�fZ[?BE0C�EcYc�fZbYBCOldl[i$hGFWEcTfY\FGTVEG?J��AUC�EGFGh�MZdFG��g�C�EcZbC��Dl[?�hGCOldZd?JIfY\iOp~�M�DZdl[?�FW?JH9A3LOEcCOlkFG�fZbYG�.IV?JhGh�EG?JhcTfl[FGhoN�EGLSHFG�V?@Y\LSIfYBTVEGEG?JIKFRLOAq?BE0C�FGZ[LSI LON�A3?BEcY\?BADFGZ[LSI�p�Ec?BFW?JI�FGZ[LSI8p,COIf�¤AfEGLOFW?JIKFGZ[LSI�p,�M�V?BEc?JCOh } ?B�¢FWLSI�C�FWFWEcZ[�DTfFW?Jh`�3LOFG�ZdIV?\Ë�C��DZdlbZ[Fji COID�(FW?JH9A3LOEcCOl3FG�fZdYc�,If?JhGh)FWL�FG�V?��Dl[?JIf�fZbIVa�LON�ZdIfY\LSH�ADC�FGZ[�Dl[?JhJ�

r@l[FG�VLSTVaS��?JIKFG�,TfhGZdCOhWFGZbY�C��qLSTfF¢COI�FGZdYBZdADC�FGZ[LSI�pV>@?JIfIV?BFWFM�fLK?Jh¢lbZ[FWFGl[?o�MZ[FG�(Z[FB©fH�LOEG?BLygO?BEJpq�fZdh)�V?BFW?BEcLOAD�V?\�IVLSH9?JIfLSl[LOaOi�COIf���fZdh`C�EcaSTfH9?JIKFGhRC�aSCOZbIfhWF��,TfCOldZbC�fZdhWFGCOIDY\?��fZdH NmEcLSH Y\LSIfhcYBZ[LSTfhGIV?Jhch`COldH9LShGFRCOh�N�C�E�COhRFG�V?�3?J�fCJg.Z[LOEcZbhWFGh~AUTVF�FG�V?JH�hW?Jl[gO?JhJ�(�oZd�DhWLSI�ÉÅhv?JY\LSl[LOaSZdYBCOlfAq?BE0Y\?BAfFGZ[LSI�ZdhvLSIV?�?JC�Ecl[i�FG�V?BLOEGi�TDhGZdIVa@COI�FGZdYBZdADC�FGZ[LSI�ZdIC�hW?BEcZ[LSTDh���CJi$| ¾��.pf¿�$ �Î�`£M�V?BEG?oZdh�COldhWL���LOEc� LSI(COIKFGZdYBZ[ADC�FGZ[LSI�ZdI�FG�V?�hW?JH Z[LOFGZdY@FWEcCO�fZ[FGZdLSI¤�,i¤�$Zd�fCOZ } CO�fZdI|~��� �Î�n¼�I�H�i$LOAUZdIfZ[LSI�pqFG�V?9ZdIfhcZ[aS��FGh@LONR¨�TfhchW?BEcl�COIf��ESCOH�?Jh�C�EG?9FG�V?9H9LShWFhGTfaOaO?JhWFGZ[gO?O��¨�TfhchW?BEcl�COYc�fZd?BgO?JhC�hWFGTDIfIfZdIVa��V?BAfFG��LON�COIfCOldi,hGZbh�LONoFG�V?(AU�V?JIVLSH9?JIVLSldLOaOi5LON@FGZdH9?OpR�M�fZdld?�E�COH9?Jh�?\�V�fZ[�DZdFGhnC�EG?JH�C�EG��C��Dl[?�fEG?JCO�fFG��COIf� YBlbC�EcZ[Fji�LON3g.ZdhGZ[LSI�pKZdI9�3LOFG��YBCOhW?Jh��MZ[FG�VLSTfFQ�3?JIV?z�fFkLON3FG�V?M?JIfLOEcH9LSTfh`EG?JY\?JI�FRCO�Vg�COIfY\?Jh`ZdI Y\LOa��IfZ[FGZdgO?�hGYBZ[?JIfY\?O�¢��TVFoZ[FMhc�VLSTfld��COlbhWL �3?�IVLOFW?J�$FG�fC�F@H�COI�i(LON`FG�V?�hGCOH�?�ZdIfhcZ[aS��FGhMYBCOI��3?�N�LSTfIf��Y\?JI�FGTVE0Z[?Jh?JC�EcldZd?BEMZdI(FG�V?n��Tf�f�f�fZbhWF)H9?J�fZ[FGC�FGZ[LSI$ldZ[FW?BEcC�FGTfEG?O���oTfEMC�AfAfEGLSCOY0�$�DZ¡Ëq?BE0h)NmEcLSH COldl�FG�f?JhW?�ZdI�Z[FGh¢aOEGLSTDIf�fZdIVaZdI(FG�f?���COZbI�¨Mi,A3LOFG�V?JhGZdhJpV�MZ[FG�(Z[FGh��fZ[?BEcC�EcY0�fZdYBCOl�IV?BFè��LOEc�,h�LON���?JZ[aS�KFW?J��pDhc�fC�EG?J��pDCOID�(FWEcCOIfhWN�LOEcH9?J��Y\LSH��A3LSIV?JIKFGhBp8COIf��ZdI�FG�V?�AfEc?JYBZdhGZ[LSI�FG�fC�F�FG�fC�F�H9L,�f?JlvYBCOI�Y\LSIVNm?BE�LSI�AfEG?J�fZdY\FGZdLSIfh@FG�fC�FC�EG?�H�CO�V?�TDhGZdIVa�FG�V?LOFG�V?BE@��i,A3LOFG�V?JhW?JhB�ä � ��Ú0ÜÎÐ�ÜÎÏ=Ð�å½Ú�Ó=Ñ�ÒÅÑ¥ÜÎнÓ�å�ê�Ú0ÙVÜÎÏ=нÑ�Ð�ÝOÚ0ÒÁÓBÜÎÑ�Þ8Ò ÜÎÏ@ÜÎÏ�Ð�Ù¡Ú�ÕyØ�ÜÎÏoÝOÐ�ØÎÑ�Ú0ÓoÛ)Ð�ÜÎÏ�ÚJßMÚ0Ù � нå�ÜÎÒÅÚ�Ó .Jâ .Jâ� � !UÕ=Ü8Õ�Ó�ß=Ð�ØqÜÎÏ�Ð�ÝOÐ�ØÎÏ�×0Ý=Ñ�Ý=ØÎнÑ�Õ=Û)Ý=ÜÎÒÅæ\Ð~å½ÖÁ×0ÒÅÛ�ÜÎÏ�×GÜ8Ñ¥Ü�ØÎÕ�å�ÜÎÕyØj×0ÖSé�ÖÅнÓ�ß=ÒÅÓ�Ô�Ð 9yÝ�ÖÅÒÅåW×cÜÎнÑ8é=ÒÁÓ�ß=ÒÅÓ�Ô �yÚ�Õ=Ø8Ó=Ú0ÜÎÒÅÚ�Ó�åW×0Ó�éOÐ�Ñ�ннÓ@×0Ñ×0Ó@Ð 9yÝ�ÖÅÒÅåW×cÜÎÒÅÚ�Ó@Ú0ÙfÏ�ÐèØÎѽâ

¾.À

Page 22: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

¼��MZdhG�5FWL�YBl[LShW?�FG�fZdhn?JhGhGCyi5�,i�?\�.FW?JIf�fZdIfa�C��fZdhcYBTfhGhGZ[LSI�C��3LSTVF�C�EGF9COIf��FG�V?(hGCOY\EG?J���3?BaSTfI�ZdI | ¿O¿ �Î�£¢�V?oAfEc?JhW?JI�F)AUC�Aq?BE¢�DCOh¢C�EGaSTV?J�(FG�DC�F¢Y\LSIfhGYBZ[LSTfhcIV?JhGhBpf�,TfCOldZdC.pVCOIf��FG�f?�AD�V?JIVLSH9?JIDCOl3��LOEclb��LON�?\�.A3?BEcZ[?JIfY\?C�EG?9AfEcL,�fTDY\?J�$�,i$Y\LSH�ADl[?\��COID��ldC�EGaO?Jl[i�TfIfY\[email protected]\?JhGhW?JhBp��DTfFoZdFo�DCOh�IVLOF�A3LSZdI�FW?J��LSTVF�FG�DC�F�FG�fZdhTfIf�f?BEcH�ZdIV?Jh¢�q?JlbZ[?BNvZbI�FG�V?�?\�.ZdhGFW?JIfY\?�LON�COI$ZdID�V?BA3?JIf�V?JIKF¢TfIfZ��f?J�!ÂWhW?Jl[N��Åà �oTVE@��i,A3LOFG�V?JhW?Jho�VL¤IfLOF�ZdH9AUl[iFG�fC�F�A3?BLOADl[?��VL�IVLOF�?\�.ZbhWFBpMLOE(FG�fC�F�FG�V?�C�AfA3?JC�EcCOIDY\?�LONnC�TfIfZ��f?J�ºZdIf�f?BAq?JID�V?JI�F¤hW?Jl[N��VL,?Jh(IVLOF�?\�VZdhWFBp�DTVF�EcC�FG�f?BE(FG�fC�F(FG�V?�TfIfZ[Fèi COIf�ºFG�V?�ZbIf�V?BA3?JIf�V?JIfY\?��fCJgO?5COI ZdldldTfhGLOEGi�Yc�fC�EcCOY\FW?BEy� Æ�?�C�EG?�Y\LSH9ADl[?\�3p�V?BA3?JIf�V?JIKF��3?JZdIVaShBpVY\LSIKFGZdIKTDCOldl[i Ec?JY\EG?JC�FW?J�$COh ÂWY\LSIfhGYBZ[LSTfhcÃ9FG�VEGLSTVaS�(hcCOldZ[?JIKF)?BgO?JI�FGhBpq�V?BFW?BEcH�ZbIV?J�(COh¢hGTfY0�ZdI�C¢Y\LSH�ADldZdYBC�FW?J��AfEGL.Y\?JhGh�FG�fC�F~Zbh8YBTfl[FGTVE0COlOCOIf��fZdhGFWLOEcZdYBCOl�pyCOh~��?JlblSCOh~Y\LOaSIfZdFGZ[gO?O�kXVZdH�ZdldC�E0l[iOp\LSTVE~?\�.A3?BEcZ[?JIfY\?LON)FG�V?���LOE0ld��Zdh�ÂWH�COI,TVN¥COY\FGTVEG?J�fÃ��Ki�FG�DZdhAfEcL,Y\?JhGhJp�C�Y\LSH9ADld?\��COIf��?BgO?BE9hG�fZdNmFGZdIfa�H9LShGCOZdY LONM�,TfCOldZdC(LONg�C�EcZ[LSTfh@FW?\�.FGTVEG?JhCOIf��hcZ[�B?JhB©8FG�fZbh@�fLK?Jh�IVLOF�ZdH�ADl[i(FG�fC�F�FG�V?BEc?�Zbh�IVL�½EG?JCOl���LOE0ld��pÅÃ��DTVF@EcC�FG�V?BE�FG�fC�FoLSTVECOYBY\?JhGh FWL�Z[F9Zdh�COYc�fZ[?BgO?J�!ZdI�C�gO?BEGi�Y\LSH�ADl[?\��COID��ZdIfY\LSH9ADld?BFW?¤��CJiO�!X.ZdH ZdldC�E�ZdIfhGZ[aS�KFGhn��?BEc?�?\�.AfEG?JhchW?J�IV?JC�Ecldi(Fj�RL(FG�VLSTfhGCOIf�$iO?JC�EchoC�aOL(�,i�FG�V?n¼�If�DZdCOI�AD�DZdl[LShWLOAD�f?BEW�jhGC�aO? } C�aSC�E¥�GTfIfC |~��� �Îp�COl[FG�VLSTVaS��LON`Y\LSTfEchW?TfhGZbIVanC �fZ¡Ë3?BEG?JI�F)ldCOIfaSTfC�aO?OpfFG�fC�F)LONk��CO�DCJiSCOIfC¤�RTD�f�f�fZdhcH(����LOEG?�EG?JY\?JIKF¢FG�fZbIV�O?BEch)ldZ[�O?�>@LOaO?JI | ¾O¾ ��COIf�9�?JZ �GZ } ZdhG�fZ[FGCOIDZ^|~�.Àz�ÎpDCOH9LSIVa H COI�i�LOFG�V?BEchBpU�fCJgO?�COlbhWL�?\�.AfEG?JhGhW?J�(hcZdH�ZdldC�E)ZdIDhGZ[aS�KFGhB�

��i�H9?J�DZ[FGC�FGZ[LSInFW?JCOYc�V?BEyp.P����LOaOiSCOH £~EcTDIVaOADCG�MZdIVA3L.Yc�V?OpOhGCOZb��FG�DC�FvFG�f?RAUTVEGA3LShW?RLONUC�EGFkZdhvFWLhG�VL=��LSTVEIVLSI.�Î?\�VZdhWFW?JIDY\?MZdI�FG�V?)�RLOEcld���v¼�F`hW?B?JH�hkFWL�H9?¢FG�fC�FQYBl[LShG?MC�FWFW?JI�FGZdLSI�FWL�HnTfhGZbY�pSCOIf�9FWL��VL=���R?M�V?JC�E�ZdFBp�YBCOIaSZ[gO?nAfEG?JYBZdhG?Jl[i(FG�fZdh@ZdIfhGZdaS��FB�@£¢�V?n?\�,A3?BEcZ[?JIDY\?�YBCOI��3?�g.Z[g.Zd��pDYBl[?JC�Eyp3COID���f?B?BADl[i�H9L=g,ZdIfaV��¼½If�V?B?J��p3Z[FoYBCOI�3?nCOI�?\�.A3?BEcZ[?JIfY\?nLON`FG�f?�½N�LSTVEGFG��H9LSH�?JI�FGÃ�¹ � x �Dy�� �m�u� � � � v��-{ � ��� v ��ZdI�£¢Z[�3?BFGCOIU»0p�COI�?\�.A3?BEcZ[?JIfY\?LONkFGZdH9?nhGTfhWA3?JIf�f?J��pVLONk�3?JZdIVa�IVLOF@ADCOhWFBpUAfEG?JhW?JIKFBpULOE@N¥TVFGTVEG?OpU�DTVFMC¤ldZdH�Z[FGld?JhGh)hWADCOY\?nLONkaOEG?JC�F@?J�KTfCOIDZdH�Z[FèiFG�fC�F�TfIfZ��D?JhQCOIf��FWE0COIfhGY\?JIf�fhRCOldlDFG�VEG?B?Op.COIf�¤ZbI��M�fZbYc�9�3LOFG��hW?Jl[N�COIf�¤��LOEclb� �fZdhcC�AfA3?JC�EJ��£¢�DZdh`hWAUCOY\?@Zdh`FG�V?C��3L,�f?�LON�FG�V?�hGCOY\EG?J���

� ����� «lK T�®�¯���³RS �R­�³G¯@¬ � ¯)­ L1S£¢�V?9N�LSldl[L=�MZdIVa�aSZ[gO?Jh�C(A3?BEGN�LOEcH9?BEJÉÅh�g.Z[?B�_LON�LSIV?�AUC�EGFGZdYBTfldC�EZbH9AfEGL=g,ZdhcC�FGZ[LSI��9¼�F�Zdh�TfhW?J��COh��fC�FGC�ZbI�FG�V?�3L,�fi LONvFG�fZdh)ADC�A3?BEJ�

��I�¾�$��$C�EcYc��¾�$�$S¿,pvFG�f?��fCJi�FG�V?9¼�EcCO���RC�E��q?BaSCOI8p~¼@Aq?BEcNmLOEcH�?J��COI�ZdH9AfEcLyg.ZdhGC�FGZ[LSI�C�FFG�V?e@IfZ[gO?BE0hGZ[Fji�LONG;@Z[?JIDIfC�¹¥COIf��C�aSCOZdI�LSI ¾�����C�E0Yc��p�C�F�FG�V? =v?BEGN�LOEcH�ZdIfa�r�EGFGh�e@IfZ[gO?BE0hGZ[Fji5LON;oZ[?JIfIDC�»0p�ZbI�Y\LSIfIV?JY\FGZdLSI��MZdFG��l[?JY\FGTVEc?Jh~�,iH�i�,TfhW�UCOIf��LSInhWLSH9?�Y\LOaSIfZ[FGZ[gO?�COIf�AU�fZdl[LShWLOAU�fZdYBCOlCOhGAq?JY\FGh~LONVH�TfhcZdY��2=�C�EGF8LON.FG�V?`ld?JY\FGTVEG?QhG�VL=��?J���VLy��FG�V?`hGCOH9?ÂWH Zd�f�fl[?kr@âY\LSTfld�o�3?kA3?BEcY\?JZ[gO?J�FWLOFGCOlbl[i(�fZ¡Ë3?BEG?JI�FGldiOp.�f?BAq?JID�fZdIVanLSI�Z[FGh)Y\LSIKFW?\�.FB�

¼R�f?JYBZd�V?J��FWL¤TDhW?�FG�fZdh¢hcCOH9?�IVLOFW?OpDCOID��hWLSH9?LON�FG�VLShG?�Y\LSI�FW?\�.FGhBp3COh¢C9�DCOhcZdh)N�LOEMZdH9AfEcLyg.Z¡�hcC�FGZ[LSI�pfIVLOF¢N�LOEGaO?BFWFGZdIfa�;@Z[?JIDIfC.pfC�YBZ[Fèi¤FG�fC�FM?\�,A3?BEcZ[?JIDY\?J�(H�TfY0�(ADCOZdI(COh¢��?Jldl�COhMH�TfY0�(aOEG?JC�FHnTfhGZbYnZbI�ZdFGh��fZdhWFWLOEGiOp8COID�$LON�Y\LSTVEchG?n�3?JZdIfa¤gO?BEGi�CJ��C�EG?�LON�FG�V?9��C�EJp~COIf��FG�fZbIV�,ZbIVa¤�VL=�_?Bg��?BEciKFG�fZbIVa�Zbh@Y\LSIDIV?JY\FW?J��p8FG�V?�A3?BEGN�LOEcH9?BEJp3FG�V?9COTf�DZ[?JIfY\?Op3FG�V?�YBZ[FèiOp�FG�V?9�RC�Eyp�FG�V?9hGCO�fIV?JhGhoCOIf�AUCOZdI�pVFG�V?��M�fLSl[?�LONv�DZdhWFWLOEGiO�

��Zb�f�fl[?¢r Zdh�C�3?BaSZdIfIfZbIVa�hWLSTfIf��p,COIf��LSI¤C�aOL,L.��ADZdCOIfL¤¹¥hGTfY0�¤COh�FG�V?��RLShW?JID�VLOEGN�?BE`aOEcCOIf�FG�f?Bi�aSCJgO?�H9?�N�LOE AfEcCOY\FGZbY\?=»�iOLSTºYBCOI!�V?JC�E�Z[FGh H�COIKi�Y\LSl[LOEch��fCOIVaSZdIfa�ZdI�hWADCOY\?Op)YBC�EGEci,ZdIfaFG�f?�ADCOZdI�LONQIKTfH�?BEGLSTfh¢ldZdgO?JhBpDN�EGLSH ��LO�JC�EGF@FWL Æ�?B�3?BEcI�pqCOIf��IfLy� A3L,LOE�£vTVEG�.ZdhG�(ZdH H�Z[aOEcCOIKF�RLOEG�O?BEchJpDCOIf�(¼�EcCO�,Z8YBZ[g.ZdldZdCOIfhJ����TVF¢iOLST$YBCOI�COldhWL �f?JC�EM�VLOA3?COIf�(l[L=gO?O�

C8L=�ºr �DCOh�COI�COIVaOEGi�hGLSTfIf��p,COI�C�aOaOEc?JhGhGZ[gO?@�MZdhG� FWLnY\LSIKFWEGLSl�pVCnY\i,IDZdYBCOlDg.Z[?B�� �UTVF�hWFGZbldl��Z[FG��ADCOZdI(ZdIDhGZd�V?@LONkZ[FBpfCOIf�(FG�V?�A3LShGhcZ[�DZdldZdFji9LONkTfIf�V?BE0hWFGCOIf�fZdIfaV�

¨�ZdaS��r�Zdh�ldZ[�O?oC9hGY\EG?JCOH�pfC9l[LygO?J��LSIV?ldLShWF)ZdI�FG�V?o�RC�EJpVN�EcTfhGFWEcC�FGZ[LSI�pVIV?B?J��©.LOEMCn�M�DZdhWA3?BEJp?BgO?JI$C�YBC�EG?JhGhJ�

^QgO?BEGi�IVLOFW?��fCOh�ZdFGhLygO?BEcFWLSIV?JhBpkCOIf��FG�f?Bi�C�Ec?¤COldlQY\LSIDIV?JY\FW?J��pkCOh�C�EG?�COldlkLON¢TfhJp�H�Zd�D�fl[?Op�DZ[aS��pfl[L=�pf�VLOA3?OpVNm?JC�EypfADCOZdI�pVCOIf��l[LygO?O�

¼�H�AfEGLyg.ZdhGC�FGZdLSI(Zdh)ZdIKFW?BEcY\LSIfIV?JY\FGZ[LSI8�¾O¾

Page 23: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

�¢iOLO�OL�r�H�CO�f?B? �@LOaSTV?JI¿�ESTfIf?�¾�$�$S¿

� L1W L`®fL`¬�²(L1S|¡À��n£M�V?BL,�fLOE¢r��VLOE0IVLV��� � � ��� �>� � �$x���� {J�UP�COldZ[N�LOEcIfZbC.p.¾�$�$S¾,�q£~EcCOIDhGldC�FW?J�(�,i ��ZdYc�DC�Ec� C8?BADAq?BEcFB�| ¾k�n^��V��C�Ec��r@ld�V�R?Jldl¢COIf� P)C�[email protected]�fCOYc�KFW?BEJ��!#�� ��� �� � �H����� � {����2� �m� ��� �O��¨�C�EcY\LSTfEGFBpÀ �����,�)X.?JY\LSIf�

?J�DZ[FGZ[LSI��| ¿k� 9�C�FG�fl[?B?JI�r@ldldZdaOLKL.��pD£¢ZbH X.COTV?BEJpqCOIf�-E�COH9?Jh qQLOEG�O?O��� � �&� ���<�� ��� � � xl{ � �F� � �h� �#� ��� �Z�F{�� ���� � �

���z� �0�qX,ADEcZdIVaO?BEJp3À ���8�,�3£~?\�.FW�3LKLO�.h¢ZdI��$C�FG�V?JH�C�FGZdYBCOl�X.YBZ[?JIfY\?JhJ�| Ê � =v?BFW?BE��RLOaS��r@If�V?BEchG?JI��=�$Tfl[FGZdH9?J�DZdCRAD�fCOhW?`hGADCOY\?JhB� �$x ��� � �D� � � � �H� � �!� � ����� vmvH�!�F{��&� � � �l�0p����Á¾�$ � �,¾O¿�Kp

À �����,�|~�k���o?BEcC�Ec�(r@hGhGCJiSC�aVpq¨�COIDhB[V?JZdYc�KFGZdIVaO?BEypfCOIf� EOLSh �?\��[VE0COIfYBZdhGY\LD�ML,�fEcZ[aSTV?JhB� � �&� � ��� �8� �F{�� � ��� �$x���� {���

�r�F�m� �8� � �&� � ��� �8� �F{�� � �A�� �x ���3X,AfE0ZdIVaO?BEJpf¾�$�$S¾,�|~�k� �MLSldCOIf�n��C�EGFG�V?JhB���u� ���D�z��� �B� ��� ���Z� �8� � � ���S¨�Zdlbl�COIf��Æ�COIVaVpDÀ �8���,�S£�EcCOIfhB��r@IfIV?BFWFW?uC~CJgO?BE0hkCOIf��PRLSldZdI

XVH�Z[FG���| � �ZESLSI���C�EG�MZdhG?COIf� EOLS�DI�=�?BEcEGiO���l� � x�8� � �8�?�'� �H���<�F� � � xl�m�����U��¼�£ ¹¥�REcCO�fNmLOEc�q»0p~À ���O¿,�|(�k���o?BLOEGaO?�>oCJg.Zd����Z[Ec�,�VL�Ë����G����� �?�z� �F{��Y� � � x� �B�D¨@C�EGg�C�E0��p8À �O¿O¿,�|(�k�n>oCyg,Zd���RLOEGaOLV�8£¢�f?�LOEc�f?BEcl[i��fZdhGLOEc�V?BEMLON`NmEG?B?9ZdH�AfEGLyg.ZdhGC�FGZdLSI�� ��m{z� � {>t:� � �h� �o� ���:� �m�H� �Zx � �F{R� ��� � ��p

À $.pq¾�$�$S¾,�|¡À $ �n>oCyg,Zd�!��LOEcaOL�COIf� ESLShW?BAD� �@LOaSTV?JI8�RX,i.IfY�LOE hW��C�EcH �-�@EcLSTVA��Vi.IfCOH�ZdYBh9ZdI�HnTfhGZbYBCOl�NmEG?B?�ZbH9AfEGL��

g.ZdhGC�FGZdLSI���¼�IY�MZdY0�fC�Ec��=�C�EcIfYBTfFWFBpvr@IfIV?B��C�FWEcZdI�9?JhGhGl[?BEJp�COIf��[VEcCOIf� &�ZdH�H9?BEJp~?J�fZ[FWLOEchBp � { � � � � ���8����(�8� �z� �z�H{ �Y� �� ����� �8� �z{z� vH�!� ���� � �$x���� { � ��� ����pMAUC�aO?Jh �O¾ � �O¾,�M¾�$�$�ÊV�¢¨M?Jld� �@E0C��Op�[email protected]�À � �UÀ �r�AfEcZbl3¾�$�$�ÊV�

|¡ÀOÀ��n>oCyg,Zd��P��fCOldH9?BE0hB� � � ���(� �?�z{z�F� x � � � �H��� � �z���� { �-��� ����x ��� � �D�������8� � � �R�� �������.NmLOEc�8p3À ���8�,�|¡ÀJ¾k� =�COTflvP��KTfEcYc�flbCOIf��� � � ���u���&��� �>� �Gt:� � ��� ���u� � � �����8�B���r� � � �H�8x �ç�U��¼�£p8À ���8�,�|¡ÀJ¿k� �ML,�DIV?Bi�PRLOFWFW?BE0Zdldl��3^QgOLSldTfFGZ[LSI�p8Y\LOaSIfZ[FGZdLSI�COIf��Y\LSIfhGYBZ[LSTDhGIV?JhGhB�"!?� x� � � � ���#�(� �l��{z�F� x � � ���R����� xl� �h����p

�V¹�¾S»0�Á¿ �UÀ��Kp8¾�$�$VÀ��|¡À\Ê �n£MZdH PREcCOIV?O� � �?� �Y� { � � �l�F{��8� � � �H���l�MLSTVFGl[?J�VaO?Opq¾�$�$S¿,�3X,?JY\LSIf��?J�fZ[FGZ[LSI��|¡À �k� [fEcCOIfYBZdh�P�EcZdYG�q��� � ���}���h� �l����������� !"� v �8� �?��� ���$ � � � �z{z�h����� � � { �z���� { � �z�� � � � �z� x � �.X.Y\EcZ[�DIf?BEk] X.LSIfhBp

À ����ÊV�|¡À �k�nr@IKFWLSIfZ[L�>oCOH�COhGZ[LV� �Z����{ �� ������&%'� �� ��B���&� � � �(�^t:� � ��� � �8�H��� � �"!@x � � � � ��8���f�qrMgOLSI8p~À ����ÊV�|¡À�� �nr@IKFWLSIfZ[L�>oCOH�COhGZ[LV� � � � �2� ���������c��� � � �8� ! � v&v�� �?�$ �G� ����� �B���&� � � � � ���Y� � � � �*)k� ������+�(� � �

�z{z�F� x � �����R���D¨�C�E0Y\LSTVEGFBp~À �����,�|¡À �k�n>oCOIfZd?Jl�>�?JIDIV?BFWFB���(� �l��{z�F� x �,���vH��� ��� � ��� =v?JIVaSTfZdI�p�À ���.À��|¡À �k�n>oCOIfZd?JlU>@?JIfIV?BFWFB� ��TfZdIfZdIfa�KTfCOlbZdC.��¼½I¤^��VLSC�Ec�VL���ZdhGZdCOY0��COIf��r�IKFG�VLSIKi¤��C�E0Y\?Jl�p.?J�fZ[FWLOEchBp-�(� �l��{z�F� x � �

� ���R�@� �.�(� �������Uv �� ��� �/�H{ �F�z�H{ �BpVADC�aO?Jh¢Ê�¾ � � �K�8���.NmLOE0��p�À ���8�,���M?BAfEcZdIKF�LON�À ������?J�fZ[FGZ[LSI8�| ¾�$ �n>oCOIfZd?Jlk>�?JIDIV?BFWFB�8Æ �VLVÉÅh�LSI$�fE0hWF10 ¨�?BFW?BEGLOAD�V?JIfLSH9?JIVLSl[LOaOi�?\�.ADldCOZdIV?J�8�2!?� x� � � � ���#�(� �l��{z�F� x � � ���R�

�H� x?�8�F���0p~À $f¹ � �UÀ $�»0�dÀ � �,¿�$.p�¾�$�$S¿,�| ¾.À�� �M?JI �?�>@?JhGYBC�EGFW?JhB���r� �z{R� x� �z�Z� � � �z� � � �O�H=QEc?JI�FGZdY\?¨@COldl�p8À �8�8�,���@EcZ[aSZbIfCOlqNmEGLSH�À �O¿�K�| ¾O¾k�n>@LOaO?JI��2��� �myR� ���z� � ���3 �z�4�u�R� ���k� y � � � � ���f�De@IfZ[gO?BE0hGZ[Fji¤LONk¨�Cy�RCOZdZÎp8À ���O¾,�

¾O¿

Page 24: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

| ¾O¿k� =�COTfl@>@LSTVEcZdhc���`Æ �fC�F���?�FGCOl[� C��qLSTfF �M�V?JI �R?�FGCOld�!C��3LSTVF�Y\LSIKFW?\�.FB� � ���8��� �"� �H���1y����zx � �h� x ��(�8� v�x � � ���Spq¾�$�$S¿,�3��IfldZdIV?@?J�fZ[FGZdLSI��

| ¾�Ê �n¨@TV�3?BEGF)>@EG?Bi,N�TfhJ��� � �8���(� �UvHx?��� � ��� � � � � � ��% � �>�O�D��¼½£�p~À ���O¾,�| ¾8�k� ��COl[AD��^�ldldZdh)COID� } C�FGZ[��C } ?B�¢FWLSI��U£M�VEG?B?ADC�E0CO�VLJ�.?Jh@LONkAD�V?JIVLSH9?JIDCOl8Y\LSIfhGYBZ[LSTDhGIV?JhGh����REcZd�VaSZbIVa9FG�V?

?\�.ADldCOIDC�FWLOEGi¤aSC�A~��! �8x ���� �^��� �(� �l��{z�F� x � � ���R� �H� x?�8�F���0pH�V¹�ÊK»0� ÊfÀ � ��ÊOÊ�¾,p`À �����,�| ¾8�k����Zdldl[?Jh$[fCOTDY\LSIfIfZ[?BE�COID� ��C�EG�_£vTVEcIV?BEy�P�LSIfY\?BAfFGTfCOl�ZbI�FW?BaOEcC�FGZdLSI IV?BFj�RLOEG�.hB� �(�R�8�l� � ��8�.��{z�h���H{��\p

¾O¾V¹�¾S»0�dÀJ¿O¿ �UÀ ��Kp�À �����,�| ¾� ����Zdldl[?JhB[fCOTDY\LSIfIfZ[?BEMCOID����C�EG�(£vTVEcIV?BEy� � �?� ����� � � � ������)��D��COhGZdY�pU¾�$�$S¾,�| ¾��k�n¨@C�EGLSld� �oC�E �DIV�O?JlÎ� ��� xl� �F���@���/�B� ���H� �D�z� � � �&� ��� �����A=QEc?JI�FGZdY\?\�j¨@COldl�p8À �8��K�| ¾��k�ZE�COH9?Jh}�oZ[�DhWLSI8�D£¢�V?�FG�V?BLOEGi(LON`C�Ë3LOEc�fCOIfY\?JhJ�U¼½I �MLO�q?BEcFoX.�fCy��COID�-EOLS�DI$�REcCOIfhGNmLOEc�8pf?J�fZ[FWLOEchJp U� ��

{���� � � ��� ���U{ � � ��� � �H���>����(��� �� �H�� �� ��� �#�:{ � � �R�8�F{�� �� � �8{ � � ��� �����q^QEcl[�UCOTfH(p3À �� �K�| ¿�$ �ZE�COH9?JhU�oZd�DhWLSI����G�/�:{ � ��� �8�F{�� � � vmv� � �&{ �-�h�.�2��� x� � � {��wv�� �F� �f�q¨MLSTfaS��FWLSI���Z��¤ZdI�p�À ����,�| ¿.À��ZESLShW?BAD���@LOaSTV?JI8�8P�LSH9ADl[?\�VZ[Fji(LONR�fZ[?BEcC�E0Yc�fZdYBCOlbl[i�LOEGaSCOIfZ[�B?J��hWi.hWFW?JH�hoCOIf��FG�V?9hWFWEcTDY\FGTVEG?nLON`H�TDhGZdYBCOl

?\�.A3?BEcZ[?JIfY\?JhJ�� ����� ����8� �F� ��� ��!?� x� ���8�6����:�z��� � � � �k������� �0p3¿V¹�ÊK»0�Á¾O¿� �,¾8�.À�pQÀ �� �K�| ¿O¾k�ZESLShW?BAD� �@LOaSTf?JI�� X,?JH�ZdLOFGZdY H9LOEGAD�DZdhGH�hBp À ���8�,� rMg�COZdldC��Ul[? LSI FG�V? �R?B� C�F

�� ����������������������������������� �"!$#�!��$� %���&(' &��"��� �$�*)�)+�-,$.�)�/0� ^`C�Ecl[i gO?BEchGZdLSI ZdI � { 1 � �(� � ��1 �����z����� �� �����"� �k������� �$��������Z�F�8� � { � R��v?� { � ��8� � �l� ��1� 0p,?J��� EV�.r�l[�UTfhBp�r��.��?Bi.hWFW?Jl3COIf� ��� �oTDZdI�FW?BEcLVp } C�FB�¼½IfhWFB�QX.YBZ[?JIDY\?�] £�?JYc�fIfLSl[LOaOiOp@¹h�oCOZdFG�V?BEchW�3?BEGa���>npQ¾�$�,¾O¿��oY\FWLO�3?BE(À ���8�S»nADC�aO?Jh�¾8� �,¿.À���X,?B?(COldhWLe�P¢X.> >@?BAfFB�qP�LSH9ADTVFW?BE@XVYBZ[?JIfY\?�]_^�IVaV�l�¢?BA3LOEGF�P¢X�� � �8�O¿,pvÀ ����K�

| ¿O¿k�ZESLShW?BAD� �@LOaSTf?JI��f¼½I�FWEGL.�fTfY\FGZdLSI���!?� x� ���� �6��� �(� �?��{ � �8x�������� � ��� xl� �h���0p��V¹F�& �O»0� � �UÀ\ÊVpQÀ �����,�U¼�IKFWEGL.�fTfY��FGZdLSI(FWL hWA3?JYBZdCOl�ZdhchGTV?Op � �� � ��� � �?� �� � � ��� �� ��32��

| ¿�Ê �ZESLShW?BAD�a�oLOaSTV?JI���r@I!ZbI�FWEGL.�fTfY\FGZdLSI�FWL�COl[aO?B�fEcCOZbY�hW?JH�Z[LOFGZbYBhBp��MZ[FG��C�AfADlbZdYBC�FGZ[LSIfh�FWL�TfhW?BE ZdIKFW?BEGN¥COY\?�f?JhGZ[aSI��Q¼½IºP)�VEGi.hWFWLOAD�V?BE } ?J�fCOIDZ[gUp�?J�fZdFWLOEJp �(� �UvHx?���8� �F� � �z�� � �z��� v�� �� ��� �G���8� � � � �8�H�+� �����H� �0pAUC�aO?Jh�¾�Ê�¾ �,¾��.À��~X,AfEcZbIVaO?BEJp3À �����,�HC8?JY\FGTfEG? } LOFW?Jh�ZdI(r�EGFGZ��UYBZdCOlq¼�IKFW?JldldZ[aO?JIDY\?Op?;kLSldTfH9? À �8�O¾,�

| ¿8�k�ZESLShW?BAD�-�oLOaSTV?JI��fÆ �fC�FMZdhMC�EGF10+! � x� ���� �^��� �(� �?�z{z�F� x � �����R� �H� x?�8�F���0p �.¹ �&��S»0� � �UÀ �,p~¾�$�$�$.�q¼�IKFWEGL.�fTfY��FGZdLSI(FWL hWA3?JYBZdCOl�ZdhchGTV?Op � �� � ��� � �?� �� � � ��� �� ��+4S�

| ¿8�k�ZESLShW?BAD� �@LOaSTf?JI���X,?JH Z[LOFGZdY�H9LOEGAD�DZdhGH�hBpkEc?BAfEG?JhW?JIKFGC�FGZ[LSIfhBp�COIf���Ul[?JIf�fZdIfa$N�LOE�ZdIKFW?BEGN�COY\?$�V?JhGZ[aSI��k¼½I � { �R�R� � ��� �1� ���#� � � � �� 1) � � � vo� � �<� � � y � �F{ � �z� � � � ��� � � � ���&x�� ��� � { ���R� � ���Sp�ADC�aO?Jh�À0�UÀ �,�ro�$roX.£ =QEG?JhGhJpD¾�$�$S¿,��PRLSIfNm?BEG?JIDY\?�V?Jld�(ZdI�;k?BEGLSIDC.pD¼�FGCOl[iOpD¾8� �,¾��r@TVaSTfhGFBpD¾�$�$S¿,�

| ¿� �ZESLShW?BAD�-�oLOaSTV?JI�COIf� [VLJ�$¨@C�EGEG?Jlbl��.¼�IVN�LOEcH�C�FGZdLSI(g,ZbhGTfCOldZ[�JC�FGZdLSI�COID��hW?JH�ZdLOFGZdY�H9LOEGAD�DZdhGH�hB�,¼½I-�@EcCOIKF�$COldY\LSldH�pf?J�fZ[FWLOEJp,�A��� x� �ft:�wv� ��� �������&� � � �l��� ��� ����� �v� �z���8� �F� �?���8^`ldhW?Bg.Z[?BEJpD¾�$�$S¿,� =QEcL,Y\?B?J�fZbIVaSh)LONQC�RLOEG�.hG�VLOA��f?Jld�(ZdI�C~ZdgO?BEGA3LKLSl�pVeG99�

| ¿��k�ZESLShW?BAD���@LOaSTV?JI�COIf�D[VLy�¤¨@C�EGEG?Jldl���[VLSTfIf�fC�FGZdLSIfhQN�LOE�COY\FGZ[gO?oHnTfl[FGZdH9?J�DZdC�IfC�EGEcC�FGZdgO?"�QX.?JH�Z[LOFGZdY¢hGADCOY\?JhCOID�$hWFWE0TfY\FGTVEcCOl~�Dl[?JIf�fZbIVaVpD¾�$�$�ÊV�8£~L�C�AfA3?JC�E@ZbI65 � w � x=zD{Ow=· � � �3w µ �v· � uO|�� ��{K·mzU¶87 � ��z �~· � µ x�z � �& � � ��µ � ·�{SzVw=· � � · � 79· �U¶ ���q·m{�zD¶)z � �ºs�x=w=· �v{K·mzU¶ � �8uBw ��� u �

| ¿��k�ZESLShW?BAD���@LOaSTV?JI�COIf��P��fC�E0l[LOFWFW? C�ZdIf�V?O�O�@AfFGZdH�COlKhWFWEcTfY\FGTfEG?Jh~N�LOE�H�TfldFGZ¡�jH9?J�fZdCMZdIfhWFWEcTDY\FGZ[LSI��y£�?JYc�fIDZdYBCOlEc?BAqLOEcFBpUX �¢¼�¼�IKFW?BEcIfC�FGZ[LSIDCOl�p8À ����ÊV�U£�L��@§ Y\?�LON } CJg�COl2�¢?JhG?JC�EcYc��p�=`hWi.Yc�fLSl[LOaSZdYBCOl�X.YBZd?JIfY\?Jh¢>oZ[g.ZdhGZ[LSI��

| Ê $ �ZESLShW?BAD� �@LOaSTV?JI�COIf� �@EcCOIKFM��COldY\LSlbH(� �G� � � y �� �F{ ����� � ��� �F{��r���� �Uv?� ��8� � � � �R�� � � �0�q��¼½£�p�À ���8�,�| ÊfÀ��ZESLShW?BAD� �@LOaSTV?JI�pG�oEcZ[aOLOEG? �¢L:9hGT�p)COIf�49COZUC~ZdI���P�LSIf�fZ[FGZ[LSIDCOl¢YBZ[EcYBTflbC�E Y\LSZdIf�fTDY\FGZ[gO?�EG?B�MEcZ[FGZdIVaV�k¼½I

t � { �z��� � ���H� �B� � �G�~���ky � � { �Z� � �z� ��vH�D����� �H�R{ �m�l���zx�������2�; � � ����� ���&� � � � � � � �� 1) � � � v � � � � ��% <�4S�X.AfEcZdIVaO?BEypkC8?JY\FGTfEG? } LOFW?Jh�ZdI9PRLSH9ADTVFW?BEkX.YBZ[?JIfY\?Op�FWL�C�AfA3?JC�Ev¾�$�$S¿,�KX.?Jl[?JY\FW?J��AUC�Aq?BE0h~N�EGLSH�CM�RLOEG�.hG�VLOA�f?Jld�(ZdI�[VEcCOTf?JIfYc�fZd?JH�hW?B?Op��@?BE0H�COI�iOp3¾�Ê��,¾� �oY\FWLO�3?BEo¾�$�$S¾,�

¾�Ê

Page 25: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

| Ê�¾k�ZESLShW?BAD���@LOaSTV?JI8p2ESCOH9?Jh�£¢�DC�FGYc�V?BEJp8COID��^`EcZdY�Æ�C�aSIV?BEJ�8r@I�ZdIfZ[FGZdCOl�COl[aO?B�fEcC�C�AfADEGLSCOYc��FWL�FG�V?9hWA3?JY��Z �DYBC�FGZ[LSI�p)Y\LOEGEG?JY\FGIf?JhGh¤COID�!ZdH9AUl[?JH9?JIKFGC�FGZ[LSI�LONC��DhWFWE0COY\F¤�fC�FGC�Fji,Aq?JhJ�`¼½I �MCyi,H�LSIf� qQ?J��p)?J�DZ[FWLOEJp� x� �z��� �� ���H� �r��� � � ��8� �Z� ��� � �z� � � �&� ��� ���*� &�8pVADC�aO?Jh ��$�UÀ\Ê �,�f=QEG?JIKFGZdY\?\�j¨@COldl�p8À ����,�

| Ê�¿k� } ?JldhWLSI4�@LKL.�fH�COI8� � � ���&x� ����� � � � �� �G�.� v&v � �m{ �a�h� � � �?� �� �c� �4�� ��yR� �!�0���RLO�f�Uh½�è��?BEcEcZdldl�pÀ �8���,�

| ÊOÊ �ZESLShW?BAD�D�@E0CO�ViOpK£�L,�D�9��C��,l[?BiOp,COIf� X,?JCOIfIDC�PRLSTfldhWLSI8����l[?JIf�DZdIVaoCOIf��H9?BFGC�AD�fLOEJ�O¼�I���CJi.H9LSIf� ��Z[�f�DhCOID�-�@?BEcC�Ec��X,FW?B?JI�pf?J�fZdFWLOEchBp �Y� ��� v � �� r� � �(� �&�l� � ��8���^� ���8x ����� �F{��0�U��?JI��WCOH�ZbIfhBp�À �����,�

| Êm�k�n^��fTfC�Ec�(¨@COIfhGlbZdYG�q� �u� � �?� � x � �F{�� � � � �<� � x?� � � x �ç�D¨@COYG�O?BFWFBp�À ���8�,�U?J�fZdFW?J���Ki �@?BL�Ë3EG?Bi�=�CJi,�JCOI�FB�| Êm�k�9X.FW?Bg�COI�¨@C�EcIfCO�8�D£¢�V?�hWi.H��3LSl�aOEcLSTfIf�fZdIfa�AfEcLO�Dl[?JH(� � �k��� { � ��pVÊ�¾��Á¿O¿8� �,¿�Êm�,pQÀ ����$.�| Ê � ���$C�EGFGZdI ¨�?JZd�V?BaOaO?BEy���<��� ��� �8�H� �6� �D�\�¢��ldCOYc�K�R?Jldl�p9À �8�O¾,��£�EcCOIfhcldC�FW?J� �,i4EOLS�DI ��COYB�,TfC�EGE0Z[?�COIf�

^��V��C�Ec���¢LO�DZbIfhWLSI�N�EGLSH ���z��� x �H� 3 ��� �¥p } Zd?JH9?BiO?BEJp~À �O¾�K�| Ê �k�n>oCyg,Zd��¨�TfH�?O��� �� � �&� � � ����� !@x ���8��� �8� x� �B��;oZ[�.ZdIVaVp�À ���8�,�3�@E0Z[aSZdIfCOlqN�EGLSH À��=Ê $.�| Ê �k�n^��fH9LSIf�(¨@TfhGhG?BEcl�� � �z�H� �D����� � �R��� ���, ����� � � � �6� ��� �$�(�8�?��{ � � x ������� �0�D¼½If�fZbCOIfC.p�À �8��ÊV�|~��$ ��Æ ZdldlbZdCOH ESCOH9?JhB� ����H{ � v������@� �� � �8{ � � ��� �����3>@LygO?BEJpvÀ �8��$.�3�@EcZdaSZdIfCOldl[i9AUTV�DldZdhc�V?J�$À ����$.�|~�.À�� =v?BFW?BEG9Z[g,iO� � � ���(�� �m� ���� ��� � :t ���:� { � �F� �?�Z� � � x � �F{�� � ���v ���R� �F� �f��=QEcZbIfY\?BFWLSI�p8À ����$.�|~�O¾k�nr@If�VEc?JZH9�LSlbH9LOaOLOEGLygq�f£¢�VEc?B?@C�AfADEGLSCOYc�V?Jh�FWL�FG�V?��,TfCOIKFGZ[FGC�FGZ[gO?�V?z�DIDZ[FGZ[LSI�LONvZdIVN�LOEcH�C�FGZ[LSI8� �myz���z�>�

� �, � �z�� � �8� �F� � � � �?� �Z���R��� � �DpvÀ �dÀ0�UÀOÀ�p�À �8�8�,�|~�O¿k���o?BLOEGaO?�C~C��OL�Ë�� � � �D���(� �*� � � ��� �B� � � ��'� � ��� � x � � �m��� � �$ � � �8�G{��8�����m�� ��F���' � �8� � � ��y � x?� � �?�

�Z� �H���qP)�fZdYBC�aOLVp~À ����K�|~��Ê ���o?BLOEGaO?>C�C��OL�Ë�COID����C�Ec��ESLS�fIfhWLSI8� � �z��� v�� �� � �-���^� � � � ���qP��fZbYBC�aOLVp8À ����$.�|~�8�k�9XVCOTfIf�V?BEch¢�$COY@C�COIV?O� � �8�����m�� ��F��� �z�� r� � � � �� �) ����� � �8� � �z���&� � { � � �D�3X,AfE0ZdIVaO?BEJp3À ��,À��|~�8�k� C~?BLSIfC�Ec����?BiO?BEJ� �u���8� �F� � � �H� �Y��� �l� ��� ��� �$x���� {J�UP��fZdYBC�aOLVp8À �8�8�,�|~�� � 9?JI���LOaSZÎ� �oTfCOldZbCnH COIfZ[N�?JhWFWLV� ,$.�.�&�� ������ ��� ��'$/�"'� )�'"%��� $�$��.$#0���"# ) �|~���k���$Zd�fCOZ } CO�fZdI8� �$��������G��� �F{z� v��8� �F� � � �H� � � �m� �0�q��?JlbhW?BEJp~À ���.À��|~���k� } C�aSC�E¥�GTfIfC.� �$x � � � �&��� � � �Z� )��*)��� �*)��������.NmLOEc�8p8À ���8�,�U£�EcCOIfhGldC�FW?J���Ki�ESCyi ��C�E �f?Jld���|~��$ � } Z[FGZ[��C } ?B�¢FWLSI��)^�H9?BEGaO?JIfY\?�COIf� FG�V?�TfIfZd�,TV?JIV?JhGh LON�Y\LSIfhGYBZdLSTfhGIV?JhGhJ� !?� x� � � �<� � �(� �l��{z�F� x � � ���R�

�H� x?�8�F���0p��V¹ � � �S»0� Ê � � ���,p~¾�$�$VÀ��|~�.À�� 9?JZ �WZ } ZdhG�DZ[FGCOIfZ��lt:�������8�F� � � �H���>�8� �m� ���8�����R���De�IDZ[gO?BEchGZ[Fèi¤LONQP�COldZdNmLOEcIDZdC.pqÀ ���O¾,�|~�O¾k���o?BLOEGa } LOEGFG�VL�Ë�� ��TfCOldZdC�COID��gO?JIKFWEcCOl~ADEG?BNmEcLSI�FGCOl�Y\LOEGFGZdYBCOl�N�TfIDY\FGZ[LSI ���ÁIf?JTVEGLOAD�V?JIfLSH9?JIVLSl[LOaSZdYBCOlÎÉD��iK�

A3LOFG�V?JhcZdhB� ! �8x ���� �^��� �(� �l��{z�F� x � � ���R� �H� x?�8�F���0p~À $f¹ �S»0�dÀ\Ê���Ê �,p�¾�$�$S¿,�|~�O¿k�9P)�fC�Ecl[?Jh�XVCOTfIf�V?BEch(=v?JZ[E0Y\?O���(� � ���R{ ���R� �� vl� �0�.¨�C�EGg�C�Ec��pUÀ �8�8�,�,¼½ID�ogOLSlbTfH9?JhB©.hW?B?M?JhGAq?JYBZbCOldl[ir;kLSlbTfH9?

¾���^`l[?JH9?JIKFGh)LON(C8LOaSZbY��|~��Ê � =�ldC�FWLV� � � �}t �wvHx�y����F{B�D^`gO?BEGi,H COI�p8À ���O¿,�|~�8�k�>;oZdldCyiSCOIV?BEnXq�A��COH�COYc�DCOIf�VEcCOI�COID��ƺZdlbldZdCOH ¨�ZdEchWFW?JZdI��3£¢�V?�hcYBZ[?JIfY\?9LON�C�EGF��C�IV?JTVEcLSl[LOaSZdYBCOl�FG�V?BLOEGi

LON�C�?JhWFG�V?BFGZbY?\�.Aq?BE0Z[?JIfY\?O� !?� x� ���8�6��� �(� �l��{z�F� x � � ���R� ��� xl� �F���0pH�V¹F�& �O»0�dÀ � � �.À�pQÀ �����,�|~�8�k���$Z[�,�OL¤X.COH�hBpl��ZdZ[FWFGC�¨@C�EcZ�plEV�l��Z[NèpVCOIf� Ef�?9IKTDTVFGZdldC.�.£¢�V?��,TfH�COI(COTf�fZdFWLOEGi¤hW?JIDhWLOEGi¤H�?JH9LOEGi�FWEcCOY\?

A3?BEchcZdhWFGhQC��3LSTVF@À $�hW?JY � } ?JTVEGLSH C�aSIV?BFGZdY�?Bg,Zd�f?JIfY\?O� !?� x� � � �A��� �(�R�8�l� � ��8��� ��x� � ��{ �F�z�H{ �Bp ���Á¿8�O¿ �,¿�%$.pÀ ���O¿,�

|~�� � [f?BEc�fZdIfCOID���f?¤X.COTfhGhGTfEG?O� �(�8x �z�D� � �:�z��� � ���(��� �8x � ��� � {z�0�8>oTfYc�K�RLOEGFG��pRÀ �� �,�~£~E0COIfhGldC�FW?J���,i-�MLyi¨@C�EGEcZbhB�

|~���k�9P)ldCOTf�V?RXV�fCOIfIVLSInCOIf��Æ�C�EGEG?JInÆ�?JCJgO?BEJ� � � ��� �8� � �z���&� � { � � � � � �� �>� ���(�8� �Zx �l�F{��8� �F� �f�Ke�IfZdgO?BEchGZ[FèiLONv¼½ldldZdIVLSZbhBpqÀ �8��ÊV�

¾8�

Page 26: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

|~���k� C�TfY\inX.TDYc�fH�COI8� B� � �l���8�H� ��� � x�8���R���U{ � �F� �?� � � � �myz���z� ��� !@x � � � �w� �&{ �m��� � �(�8� �Zx �l�F{��8� �F� �f�P)COH��fE0Zd�VaO?Op�À ����K�

| �%$ �n>oCyg,Zd��X.Tf�fIVL=�� ����� � ���@� �?�"!#� �����U��COIKFGCOH(p�À ����,���¢?BAfEcZbI�FW?J���,i�¨@C�EGg�C�Ec���| �,À��ZE�TfI�£�COIDZ��q£M�V?9�Vi,IDCOH�ZdYBCOlvhWi,hGFW?JH�h�COYBY\LSTfIKFGhN�LOE@AU�V?JIVLSH9?JIVLSldLOaOi�LON�ZbH�H�COIV?JIKFoFGZdH9?"��r@I�ZdIKFW?BEW�

ADEG?BFGC�FGZ[LSI¤NmEGLSH'C�EGLO�3LOFGZdYBhRhWi,IKFG�V?BFGZdY@hWFGTf�fiO� !?� x� ���8�2��� �(�8�?��{ � � x ������� �,��� xl� �h����p�ÀOÀ � X.TV�DH�ZdFWFW?J� N�LOEAUTV�DldZdYBC�FGZdLSI�p.¾�$�$�ÊV�

| ��¾k� ��ZdYc�DC�Ec��£vCJi.l[LOEJ�D£¢�f?TfhW?LONkhGYBZ[?JIDY\?FWL¤ZdIKgO?JhWFGZ[aSC�FW?ZESCOYc�,hWLSI-=vLSldl[L.YG�qÉÅhM�VEcZdA(ADCOZdIKFGZdIVaShB� !?� x� � � � ����(�8�?��{ � � x ������� � ��� xl� �h���0p �.¹ �&��S»0�dÀJ¿� �UÀ ��$.p�¾�$�$�$.�

| ��¿k���$C�EG�(£vTVEcIV?BEJ� � � ���(� ��� ��� � � � �H���U���.N�LOEc��p8À ����K�| �=Ê � [fEcCOIfYBZdhGY\L<;QC�EG?JlbC.� } ?JTVEcLOAD�V?JIVLSH9?JIfLSl[LOaOi �vr�H9?BFG�VL.�VLSl[LOaSZbYBCOlKEc?JH9?J�ViN�LOEkFG�V?��fC�Ec�nAfEGLO�Dld?JH(��!?� x� �

� � �6��� �(�8�?��{ � � x ������� � ��� xl� �h���0pq¿V¹�ÊK»0�Á¿O¿�$�,¿�Ê �,pQÀ ���8�,�| � �k� [fEcCOIfYBZdhGY\L ;QC�EG?JldC.�2=`EG?JhW?JIKF½�ÎFGZdH9? Y\LSIfhcYBZ[LSTfhGIV?JhchB� ! �8x ���� � ���#�(� �?�z{z�F� x � �����R� ��� xl� �h����p �V¹�¾&�¿S»0�dÀOÀOÀ0�

À\Ê $.pvÀ �����,�| � �k� [fEcCOIfYBZdhGY\LD;QC�EG?JldC.pD^`g�COI�£M�VLSH9ADhWLSI8pfCOIf�(^`l[?JCOIfLOE �¢LShGY0��� � � ���B�Dy � � �h� � � � �H���D��¼�£�p�À ���.À��| � � � C~?Bg ;@i,aOLOFGhW�KiO��� � �H�D��� �H� {z�h�z� ���D¨@C�EGg�C�E0��p8À ���8�,�| ���k�nr@l[N�EG?J� } LOEGFG�(Æ �fZ[FW?J�V?JCO��� � { ���R�'� ���Zt � � ��� � ��� [VEG?B?Op~À ���8�,�8�@EcZdaSZdIfCOldl[i9AUTV�DldZdhc�V?J��À �O¾��,�| ���k���o?BEc�fC�Ec��ƺZd�DH9?BEJ�8>oZdhGY\L=gO?BEcZdIVa�hGZdH9ADld?nE0Tfl[?JhZdI�Y\LSH9ADl[?\���fC�FGC-��C�H9?BFGC��jld?JC�EcIfZdIVa$COl[aOLOEcZ[FG�fH COIf�

hGLSH9?�hGTVEcAfEcZdhGZbIVa�HnTfhGZdYBCOl8�DZdhGY\LygO?BE0Z[?JhB��� �� � � {z� � �� �����z����� � ���H{��\p8À\Êm�V¹�¾S»0�dÀJ¾�� �UÀ\Ê �,p�¾�$�$S¿,�|(��$ � C�Tf�V�MZda Æ Z[FWFWaO?JIfhWFW?JZdI8� �� �&{ ���&� x�� �2� �8�F{R� � �m����� �z� v �m�F{zx �0� �¢LSTVFGld?J�VaO?9COIf�$9�?BaSCOI$=�COTfl�pQÀ �O¾O¾,�~^�I.�

aSlbZdhG�¤FWEcCOIfhGldC�FGZdLSI �,i¤>n� [R�l=v?JC�Ech)COIf���@� [��f�$Y �oTfZdIDIV?JhGhBp.�MZ[FG��COI�¼�IKFWEGL.�fTfY\FGZ[LSI��,i �R?BEGFWEcCOIf����Tfh½�hG?Jldl�©.LOEcZ[aSZdIDCOl2�@?BEcH�COI(?J�DZ[FGZ[LSI(ZdI#�G����� � �����m� �#�8� x� �v �m� � � ��� v ���F�Bp�À �O¾.À��

|(�.À�� C�CJ�¢Ec?JIfY\?'&q�DZd�OLy�MhW�.Z��-�(� �H{��wv�� x� ��� ��� ��� � x ��� {J�U���,N�LOEc��pf¾�$�$S¾,�|(�O¾k�9X.?JH�Z[E�&q?B�.Z��VrMEcFMCOIf�(FG�V?��DEcCOZdI�� !?� x� ���8� ��� �(�8�?��{ � � x ������� � ��� xl� �F���0pH�V¹F�& �O»0� � � � �.À�p�À �����,�

¾8�

Page 27: Musical Qualia, Context, Time, and Emotion - University of California

�º¯@¬@­�L�¬@­�S� 5 � wyx%��� µ {Ow�· � � �

� ��� � ��� ��·¥¶ �Du � � � � � � µ uy·�{ �

¾,�dÀ X,LSH9?�£~EcCO�DZ[FGZ[LSIfCOlqÆ�?JhWFW?BEcI-;oZ[?B�Mh ������������������������������������������ ¾¾,�Á¾ PRLSIKFW?\�,FBp�X.Z[FGTfC�FW?J�DIV?JhGhBpfCOIf�(^�H��3L.�fZdH9?JIKF������������������������������������� ¿

� � µ uy·�{SzD¶ � µ zU¶�·�z �

¿,�dÀ £¢ZdH�?�PRLSIfhGYBZ[LSTDhGIV?JhGh ���������������������������������������������������� �

� � � ( � ��� � ¶�u � �Dx� � � � x=uBw=z � ��· � � � µ u=·m{

ÊV�dÀ ��?BFGC�AD�VLOE�COID����l[?JIf�fZdIfa ������������������������������������������������� �ÊV�Á¾ X,?JH�ZdLOFGZdY�X,ADCOY\?Jh�COIf��X,FWEcTfY\FGTfEcCOl���l[?JIf�fZdIfa������������������������������������� ÀOÀÊV�Á¿ X,FWEcTDY\FGTVEcCOl~PRLSH9AUl[?\�.ZdFjiOpl=QEcLOFW?JI�FGZ[LSI$COIf� �oTDCOldZdC��������������������������������� ÀJ¿

� � � � ����{�·�zD¶ �R· � � � � � µ uy·�{ ���

� & � � {K¶ µ uy· � � u ���

s �Ss� 5 � �x%���~·muyzVw=· � � � �fw � u ���

¾�