musical darwinism

8/9/2019 Musical Darwinism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/musical-darwinism 1/19

2

Axghbi Kbuvgjgxa> [mo Otci{gcjbuw Gapighb{gcjx cd Gjko{ouagjb{o Jc{b{gcj

bjk g{x Gj{ouxoh{gcj vg{m b Igeubuw 5*0 Vcuik25

Hcigj N*P* Mcagxlg

Axgh $ Ucabjho Ibjfbfox bjk Ig{oub{uox Igeubugbj

Xojb{o Mcxo Igeubuw) _jgtouxg{w cd Icjkcj

BEX[UBH[

Xgjho {mo agkkio cd {mo {voj{go{m hoj{uw) hcapcxoux bucjk {mo vcuik mbto xok gjko{ouagjgxa b{

cjo pcgj{ gj {mogu hbuoou) duca K{hm hcapcxou Icgx Bjkugoxxoj {c {mo xo cd igag{ok biob{cugxa gj

Pcigxm hcapcxou Vg{cik I{cxibvxlg‗x vculx* Vmgix{ {mo jov dcuax cd jc{b{gcj puoxoj{ok hmbiiojfox

dcu poudcuaoux bjk bjbiwx{x cd {mo vculx) g{ bixc puoxoj{ok cppcu{jg{gox dcu o}picub{gcj cd

gapuctgxb{gcj bjk gjkgtgkbi hmcgho* [mouo buo x{uglgjf xgagibug{gox eo{vooj {mo duookca uopuoxoj{ok

vg{m {mgx jc{b{gcjbi otci{gcj {c {mb{ cd {mo gj{oujo{ {c ”Voe 5*0*‗ [mo pucigdoub{gcj cd xchgbi

jo{vculgjf bppighb{gcjx -xhm bx Koighgcx) Hcjjc{ob bjk Kggfc' bjk xou fojoub{ok hcj{oj{ huob{o b

rbjkbuw dcu igeubugox bjk uoxobuhmoux* Xmcik vo uo{bgj cu {g{io bx fb{oloopoux cd rbig{w

hcj{uciiok ao{bkb{b3 Vmb{ ucio kc vo pibw gj {mgx jov ojtgucjaoj{3 Mcv hbj vo bkbp{ {c {mgx xmgd{

{cvbukx jcj!mgoubuhmghbi {bffgjf bjk jhcj{uciiok tchbeibuw3 Nx{ bx hcapcxoux mbto kohgkok {c

fgto p xcao hcj{uci {c {mo poudcuaou) xmcik igeubugox fgto p b kofuoo cd hcj{uci {c uoxobuhmoux gj

cukou {c loop vg{m {mo kgfg{bi {gaox3 [mgx pbpou vgii xool {c bjxvou {moxo rox{gcjx dubaok ew

Hmbuiox Kbuvgj‗x dbacx oxpcxbi cd {mo ”xutgtbi cd {mo dg{{ox{*‗ G{ gx {mo otci{gcj cd jc{b{gcj)

xpohgdghbiiw {c gjko{ouagjb{o jc{b{gcj) vmghm abw pucto i{gab{oiw {mb{ igeubugox buo jc kgjcxbux*

GJ[UCK_H[GCJ

G{ gx dg{{gjf cj {mo xoxrghoj{ojjgbi bjjgtouxbuw cd {mo peighb{gcj Hmbuiox Kbuvgj‗x ’Cugfgj cd {mo

Xpohgox‑ {mb{ mgx voii!ljcvj ab}ga) {mo xutgtbi cd {mo dg{{ox{) gx eogjf uobigxok gj {ckbw‗x igeubugox*

[mo igag{ok -bjk pucnoh{ok d{uo uokh{gcjx gj' fctoujaoj{ djkgjf) mbx mbk {mo jgj{ojkok

hcjxorojho cd huob{gjf hcapo{g{gcj eo{vooj bhbkoagh) hi{ubi bjk moug{bfo gjx{g{{gcjx

kopojkoj{ pcj {mb{ djkgjf* Du{mou {muob{x gjhiko {mo xicv uobh{gcj cd igeubugox {c {mo

hmbiiojfox pcxok ew Fccfio bjk hcaaouhgbiiw kugtoj gj{oujo{ xoutghox vmghm huob{o jdbgu

o}poh{b{gcjx cj {mo pbu{ cd cu xoux* Gj {mogu eccl Kgfg{bi Hcjxaoux Uoxmbpgjf {mo Gjdcuab{gcj

Pucdoxxgcj) Jghmcibx bjk Ucvibjkx8 c{igjo mcv {mo ibjkxhbpo cd {mo gj{oujo{ bx bj o!hcaaouho bx

abjgdox{ok gj xhm exgjoxxox bx Bab~cj bjk O!ebw mbto bi{ouok igeubuw xoux‗ o}poh{b{gcjx cd cu

xoutghox* _xoux mbto eucfm{ {mogu o!xmcppou aoj{big{w ko {c o}pcxuo {c dbho{ok eucvxgjf) xou

fojoub{ok uotgovx bjk jcv ”{bffgjf*‗ E{ uobiiw) g{ gx Fccfio gj pbu{ghibu vmghm mbx hmbjfok {mo

2[mgx pbpou gx ighojxok jkou b Huob{gto Hcaacjx 8*0 B{{uge{gcj!Jcj!Hcaaouhgbi!Xmbuo!Biglo ighojxo* Piobxo

hcjxi{ m{{p>##huob{gtohcaacjx*cuf#ighojxox#ew!jh!xb#8*0# dcu acuo gjdcuab{gcj*5 [mgx pbpou vbx dgux{ puoxoj{ok b{ {mo 5007 Gj{oujb{gcjbi Bxxchgb{gcj cd Axgh Igeubugox -GBAI' bjk

Gj{oujb{gcjbi Axghcicfghbi Xchgo{w -GAX' Hcjdouojho gj Bax{oukba) Jo{mouibjkx*

8 Kbtgk Jghmcibx bjk Gbj Ucvibjkx) Kgfg{bi hcjxaoux uoxmbpgjf {mo gjdcuab{gcj pucdoxxgcjx -Icjkcj> Dbho{

Pe*) 500='*

http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/






5

jb{uo cd {mo gjdcuab{gcj pucdoxxgcj* Gj b acx{ o}{uoao bppcu{gcjgjf cd eibao) Fccfio gx iobkgjf {c

{mo kcvjfubkgjf cd cu pucdoxxgcj* Dcu o}bapio) b{ cjo cd {mo abncu Icjkcj hciiofox) igeubugbjx buo

eogjf abko {c uobppiw dcu dovou gjdcuab{gcj pucdoxxgcjbi ncex vmghm buo jcv eogjf fubkok 80/ ioxx

gj xbibuw* Mcvotou) aw dchx cd {mgx pbpou {c gx jc{ b {gubko cj Fccfio cu bjw c{mou xpohgdgh voexg{o

e{ aouoiw {c pbgj{ {mo ibjkxhbpo cj vmghm vo xmcik uodioh{*

Hbj bjw{mgjf eo kcjo3 Voii) g{ gx gj {mo hmbjfgjf dbho cd xhmcibuiw peigxmgjf {mb{ cpoj bhhoxx

abjkb{ox abw wo{ puctgko b ahm!jookok igdoigjo {c {mo igeubugox* Igeubugox mbto bivbwx mbk b

pugabuw ucio bx hcjxoutb{cux bjk uopcxg{cugox cd ljcviokfo* Gj {mo kgfg{bi bfo Fccfio gx beio {c

cpoub{o jhmohlok bx b acjcpciw {mbjlx {c g{x uohoj{ xo{{ioaoj{ vg{m b{mcux#peigxmoux vmghm

xmgoikx g{x d{uo oddcu{x {c kgfg{gxo ecclx gj {mo _jg{ok X{b{ox duca d{uo ig{gfb{gcj* Bx pbu{ cd {mb{

xo{{ioaoj{ obhm igeubuw vcik eo fbubj{ook b{ iobx{ 2 {ouagjbi vg{m bhhoxx {c {mo dii hcj{oj{x cd g{x

eccl kgfg{gxb{gcj pucnoh{*

Gd dbhi{w vouo uorguok {c kopcxg{ {mogu vug{gjfx bjk peighb{gcjx gj {mogu uoxpoh{gto gjx{g{{gcj‗x

kgfg{bi uopcxg{cuw) bixc ljcvj bx bj cpoj bhhoxx abjkb{o) Gjx{g{{gcjbi uopcxg{cugox -GUx' hcik {moj

xouto bx bj bi{oujb{gto ackoi {c Fccfio* [mgx vcik cjiw vcul gd dbhi{w vouo uorguok {c kc {mgx ‘

bx {mo Xojb{o cd {mo Dbhi{w cd Bu{x bjk Xhgojhox) {mo ibufox{ hcjx{g{oj{ fucp b{ Mbutbuk _jgtouxg{w

-{mo DBX' tc{ok ibx{ wobu* Igeubugox vcik {moj eo beio {c hcjhoj{ub{o cj vmb{ {mow kc eox{> bktgxo

cj {mo uiox dcu b ucex{ ao{bkb{b dubaovcul bjk hcj{gjo {c ”hcjxouto‗ gj {mo kgfg{bi xojxo* [mgx

ackoi vcik jc{ eo hcj{uciiok ew tox{ok hcaaouhgbi gj{ouox{x bjk {mx vcik jc{ mbto {c vcuuw

bec{ b dgjbjhgbi ”ec{{ca igjo‗ e{ vcik xouto bx pcu{bix puctgkgjf jdo{{ouok bhhoxx {c kgfg{bi

hciioh{gcjx vg{mc{ uox{ugh{gcjx* [mo {ohmjcicfw {c xobuhm bhucxx kgfg{bi uopcxg{cugox biuobkw o}gx{x*

CBGX[OU;

gx b pugao o}bapio cd {mo pcvou cd hciichb{gjf GU kb{b* _xgjf {mo Cpoj Bhhoxx Gjg{gb{gto

Puc{chci Ao{bkb{b Mbutox{ou cu CBG!PAM) g{ kubvx {cfo{mou ctou 55agiigcj g{oax duca ctou 2200

gjx{g{{gcjx* Cjo hbj xoo vmw b peigxmou xhm bx Oixotgou vcik jc{ iglo {mgx ackoi* G{ abw dgjbiiw

fgto igeubugox {mo iotoubfo {mow jook {c pucpouiw jofc{gb{o aobjgjfdi ighojxox vmghm kc jc{ ichl gj

ekfo{x dcu {ugojjgbi hwhiox* G{ bixc puctgkox bj bi{oujb{gto {c xobuhmgjf bhucxx duooiw btbgibeio)

xhmcibuiw bu{ghiox bjk {o}{x vg{mc{ {mo jook dcu Fccfio*

Xc bfbgjx{ {mgx ebhlkucp vcik Hmbuiox Kbuvgj eo beio {c kgtgjo {mo xutgtbi cd igeubugox3 Vmb{

aobjgjfdi bkbp{b{gcjx hcik {mow bkbp{ {c gapucto {mogu hmbjhox bicjf {mo otci{gcjbuw

hcj{gja3 B{ {mgx pcgj{ b mg{hmmglou‗x touxgcj {c {mo kotoicpaoj{x gj Vox{ouj axgh jc{b{gcj abw

eofgj {c dubao pcxxgeio bjxvoux*

; ’CBGx{ou)‑ m{{p>##vvv*chih*cuf#cbgx{ou#*

http://www.oclc.org/oaister/






8

B MG[HMMGLOU‗X F_GKO [C VOX[OUJ A_XGH JC[B[GCJ

Gj {mo 22{m

hoj{uw Vox{ouj axgh eofbj {c eo dcuabiiw hckgdgok gj {mgx Fgkcjgbj mbjk?

bx b aobjx

{c cufbjgxo {cjox vg{m {mo xciag~b{gcj cd xwiibeiox ‘-cu xcffo{{c hbtb{c' b {ohmjgro abjgdox{ok gj

{mo vcul cd Ncxrgj kox Puo~ bjk ib{ou hckgdgok ew Fgcxoddc ^buigjc gj {mo 24{m

hoj{uw* [mgx vcik eo

cjo cd xotoubi kotoicpaoj{x ibwgjf c{ {mo dcuabi cufbjgxb{gcj cd axgh -pg{hm) umw{ma) mbuacjw

bjk jc{b{gcj*' ^buigjc vcik bixc moip kotoicp {mo egikgjf eichlx cd mbuacjgh {mgjlgjf ew uo!

cufbjgxgjf {mo ackox hicxou {c {mo {cjbi uobia cd abncu#agjcu*

Jc{b{gcj vcik bixc kotoicp hcjtoj{gcjx ebxok cj {mo poudcuabjho pubh{gho cd {mo kbw dcu

o}bapio) {mo xo cd dgfuok ebxx gj Bj{cjgc Jcib‗x tchbi hcapcxg{gcj) Cajg {oapcuo4* _jvug{{oj

jc{ox ecuucvgjf cj x{wigx{gh hcjtoj{gcjx cd {mo {gao) {mgx gapuctgxb{cuw {ohmjgro hcik eo

hcjx{uok bx b hcapcxou‗x ”xmcu{!mbjk‗*

Jcib vcik eo hcjdgkoj{ {mb{ {mo hcj{gjc pibwoux cd {mo kbw vcik ljcv vmb{ mo aobj{* Hoj{ugox

ib{ou gj{oupuo{oux hbj kohgpmou bjk uopighb{o {mo cugfgjbi gj{oj{gcj* Mcvotou) g{ ax{ eo xbgk {mb{

? ’[moxbux Axghbua Ib{gjbua)‑ BJCBPA AEBTU22;)

m{{p>##vvv*hma{i*gjkgbjb*ok#{ai#2;{m#BJCBPASAEBTU22;*m{ai*

4 Bj{cjgc Jcib Cajg {oapcuo # Hbj{c xcic> Cufbjc\2600!2680Q m{{p>##gj{oujo{hi{ubio*g{

http://www.chmtl.indiana.edu/tml/14th/ANOAPM_MBAVR114.html


http://internetculturale.it/







;

{mgx vbx acuo {mbj b hcapcxou‗x ib~gjoxx {gigxgjf {mo dgfuok ebxx xmcu{mbjk* G{ vbx b hcjxhgcx

kohgxgcj {c koiofb{o {c {mo poudcuaou pbu{gbi hcj{uci {c xmbpo {mo axgh*

Duca {mb{ {gao) axgh vbx actgjf gj{c acuo hcapio} bjk acuo mobtgiw jc{b{ok {ouug{cuw ctou {mgx

pougck bjk g{ vcik jc{ eo j{gi {mo agkkio cd {mo 50{m

hoj{uw {mb{ hcapcxoux vcik bfbgj uotgxg{ b

ubkghbi xmblop {c poudcuaou koiofb{ok puc{chcix* Gj {mo 27?0x Ncmj Hbfo vbx o}pougaoj{gjf vg{m

hmbjho oioaoj{x gj mgx hcapcxg{gcjx* [mgx vbx {mo pougck cd mgx hcj{uctouxgbi pgoho ;‗88‑* G{ vcik

eo {mo gjdiojho cd Obx{ouj pmgicxcpmw -xhm bx {mo G Hmgjf' vmghm vcik gapbh{ pcj jov

kotoicpaoj{x gj vox{ouj jc{b{gcj*

Gj Hcjhou{ dcu pgbjc bjk cuhmox{ub -27?6!?=' Hbfo koxhugeox {mo pgoho bx b hcjhou{ ub{mou {mbj b

hcjhou{c eohbxo bii cd {mo pibwoux) -{mo pgbjgx{ bjk gjx{uaoj{bigx{x' bh{ bx xcicgx{x) {mogu pbu{x

eogjf {c{biiw gjkopojkoj{ cd cjo bjc{mou6* [mo pgoho

=gx xhcuok dcu pgbjc bjk xopbub{o xcicx dcu 8

tgcigjx) 5 tgcibx) hoiic hcj{ubebxx) di{o kceigjf cj bi{c di{o bjk pghhcic) hibugjo{) ebxxccj -kceigjf

xb}cpmcjo') {uapo{) {ucaecjo bjk {eb* \Igx{oj {c {mo dciicvgjf xmcu{ o}houp{ duca {mo Hcjhou{ *7Q

Hbfo‗x jc{b{gcj uoxi{x gj axgh vmghm xcjkx bjk icclx touw kgddouoj{ duca {mo dgto x{bdd jc{b{gcj

vmghm mbk eooj kotoicpgjf ctou {mo pbx{ hoj{ugox*

6 Nbaox Pug{hmo{{) [mo kotoicpaoj{ cd hmbjho {ohmjgrox gj {mo axgh cd Ncmj Hbfo) 27?0!27?4 -_AG) 27=7'*

= Ncmj Hbfo) Hcjhou{ dcu Pgbjc bjk Cuhmox{ub -Jov Wcul > MojabuPuoxx) h2740'*

7 Ncmj Hbfo bjk Jo}{gao Ojxoaeio*) Kuoba -Fouabjw> Voufc) 5007'*



?

G{ vcik eo b ubkgc eucbkhbx{ cd Hbfo‗x Hcjhou{ dcu pgbjc bjk cuhmox{ub {mb{ vcik xoagjbiiw bi{ou

{mo axgh -bjk jc{b{gcj' cd Pcigxm hcapcxou Vg{cik I{cxibvxlg* _p j{gi {mgx pcgj{ mo mbk oapicwok

rg{o x{bjkbuk Vox{ouj jc{b{gcj bx dcjk gj {mo Axgro djíeuo pcu cuhmox{uo à hcukox20

-27?='

vug{{oj dcu {mo 20{m

bjjgtouxbuw cd Ebu{cl‗x kob{m*

E{ {mb{ eucbkhbx{ bvblojok gj I{cxibvxlg jov pcxxgegig{gox {c uobigxo oioaoj{x vmghm vouo

puotgcxiw j!jc{b{beio* [mo dgux{ pgohox hcapcxok gj vmb{ X{otoj X{hlw mbx koxhugeok bx mgx

”ab{uo‗ x{wio vbx -2742' dcu xabii cuhmox{ub puoagouok gj Tojgho bjk gx hmbubh{ougxok

ew b kotcitok umw{magh x{uh{uo acegio bjk [ucgx pcoax k&Mojug Aghmb} 22 -2745' dcu {vc

gjkopojkoj{ fucpx cd kgddouoj{ {gaeuox> 50 pbu{ ag}ok hmcgu bjk cuhmox{ub cd vcckvgjkx) mbup)

pgbjc bjk pouhxxgcj* [mouo buo jc x{ugjf gjx{uaoj{x bjk {mo {vc ojxoaeiox buo iok ew {vc

hcjkh{cux> cjo dcu hmcgu bjk {mo c{mou dcu {mo cuhmox{ub* Bjk jiglo Hbfo) {mgx gx axgh vmghm gx jc{

iod{ {c hmbjho*

20Vg{cik I{cxibvxlg) Axgro djíeuo> pcu cuhmox{uoà hcukox - Lubløv> PcixlgoVwkbvj* A~wh~jo< Icjkcj >

N* $ V* Hmox{ou I{k*) 27?=*'

22 Vg{cik I{cxibvxlg)[ucgx pcoax k&Mojug Aghmb}) pcu hmcou à 50 pbu{gox o{ cuhmox{ub-Lubløv> Pcixlgo

Vwkbvjgh{vc A~wh~jo) 274;*'



4

Bx Cto Jcukvbii kgxhctouok gj bj gj{outgov vg{m I{cxibvxlg) mo hcj{ucix {mo dcua tgb ”biob{cuw

hcj{oupcgj{*‗ Mo gx beio {c bj{ghgpb{o duca {mo pcgj{ cd tgov cd hcapcxg{gcj bjk otoj gj {mo hbxo cd

”{mo iobx{ gkobi‗ cd bii hcaegjb{gcjx {mo koabjk gx abko {mb{ g{ xmbii dg{ gj{c {mo dcuabi dubaovcul mo

mbx hcjx{uh{ok) {c eo b axghbiiw bkorb{o uobig~b{gcj cd mgx dcuabi gj{oj{gcjx25

*

Pcx{ Vcuik Vbu GG hcapcxoux pibhok gjhuobxgjfiw juobxcjbeio koabjkx cj {mo puohgxgcj cd {mo

gj{oupuo{oux* Hcapio} umw{magh bjk jc{b{gcjbi x{uh{uox vg{m jov o}{ojkok poudcuagjf {ohmjgrox

vouo huob{ok {c hmbiiojfo poudcuaoux* [mo gjx{uaoj{bigx{ eohbao acuo cu ioxx b abhmgjo cu

b{cab{cj* I{cxibvxlg vbx jotou gj{ouox{ok gj hcapcxgjf axgh vmghm vbx hcapio} dcu {mo xblo cd

hcapio}g{w g{xoid* Mo mbk b kgddouoj{ kopbu{uo pcgj{ gj hcj{ubx{ {c abjw cd mgx pooux* ”Mgx ebxgh

ab{ougbi) {mo dcuabi eughlx bjk acu{bu hcjxgx{x cd bhhaib{gcjx cd xcjcug{gox) {mo gj{ofubi

cufbjgxb{gcj cd vmghm gx cd aghucdcuabi gapcu{bjho) {mo axghbi x{uh{uo gx cjiw gjkguoh{iw

kopojkoj{ cj xgapio gj{outbi uoib{gcjx* Mo hbj bhmgoto b fuob{ou fojgjo hcapio}g{w cd xcjk {mbj

vg{m {mo uobig~b{gcj tgb gjx{uaoj{bigx{x cd o}bh{iw puoxhugeok x{uh{uox*

Ctou {mo dciicvgjf kohbkox I{cxibvxlg kotoicpok mgx jc{gcj bjk xo cd biob{cugh hcj{oupcgj{)

cd{oj n}{bpcxgjf {moxo xoh{gcjx vg{m diiw jc{b{ok xoh{gcjx {c og{mou kubv dcuabi hcj{ubx{x cu b

25 Vg{cik I{cxŅbvxlg bjk Cto Jcukvbii) Iu{cxŅbvxlg -X{chlmcia> V* Mbjxoj) 274='*



6

hcapio} xcjgh eiojkgjf bx gj {mo cpojgjf cd mgx 8uk

Xwapmcjw28

-27=;'* \Igx{oj {c {mgx o}houp{ cd {mo

I{cxibvxlg Xwapmcjw Jc* 82;

Q

Dciicvgjf {mo xcjgh oioaoj{x cd {mb{ cpojgjf g{ gx kgddghi{ {c kgx{gjfgxm {mo gapuctgxb{cugbi oioaoj{x

duca {mo diiw jc{b{ok oioaoj{x* [mo huob{gcj cd b xwj{moxgx cd jc{b{gcjx pibhox I{cxibvxlg gj b

jghmo cd mgx cvj* Jc{b{gcj mbx biicvok mga {c xuuojkou xcao hcj{uci cd {mo ichbi axghbi oioaoj{x

bjk cddoux bj bi{oujb{gto tgov {c {mo ugfgk hcapcxg{gcjbi x{uh{uox cd {mo {gao* [mo otci{gcjbuw

pb{m jc{b{gcj mbx {bloj mbx eooj cjo bicjf b xwx{oa cd kotoicpgjf -bjk euoblgjf cd' uiox bjk

hcj{ucix* [mo kgxxoagjb{gcj bjk uobigxb{gcj cd {mb{ jc{b{gcj abw o}gx{ bhucxx b tbugo{w cd aokgax

e{ {mo hcj{ucix mbto otcitok gj {bjkoa* [mo Igeubuw vcuik mbx bixc dciicvok b {ubnoh{cuw {cvbukx

hckgdghb{gcj cd koxhugp{gto pubh{ghox*

28 Vg{cik I{cxibvxlg) Xwapmcjw Jc* 8 -Icjkcj> Hmox{ou Axgh) 27=;*'

2; Vg{cik I{cxŅbvxlg) Xwapmcjw jc* 8 < Iox oxpbhox k xcaaogi \xcjk uohcukgjfQ -\[mo Jo{mouibjkx> Pmgigpx)

27=4'*



=

CJ B [UBNOH[CUW [CVBUKX HCKGDGHB[GCJ CD KOXHUGP[GTO PUBH[GHOX

BBHU5U5) Uofoij dùu kgo bipmbeo{gxhmo Lb{bicfgxgoujf -UBL') {mo Duojhm BDJCU) _JGABUH) bjk

otoj{biiw UKB mbto xoutok bx xo{x cd koxhugp{gto uiox bjk x{bjkbukx xok ew tbugcx hcj{ugox dcu

{mo hb{bicfgjf cd b igeubuw‗x ab{ougbix* Vg{m {mo cjxo{ cd {mo -eucvxbeio' kgfg{bi ojtgucjaoj{)

tbugcx jov ao{bkb{b dcuab{x mbto oaoufok gjhikgjf xhm dicubi tbugo{gox cd ACKX) AO[X) bjk {mo

igeubugbj‗x otou!dbtcug{o Keigj Hcuo* Vmoj cjo dbh{cux gj tbuwgjf hibxxgdghb{gcj xwx{oax xhm bx {mo

Kovow Kohgabi xwx{oa) Igeubuw cd Hcjfuoxx) bjk Eigxx) g{ eohcaox hiobu {mb{ igeubugox buo xvgaagjf

gj bj chobj cd uiox bjk x{bjkbukx vmghm bppiw {c {mo pmwxghbi bjk kgfg{bi ojtgucjaoj{ {mow jcv

gjmbeg{*

Bx {mo fuob{ pmgicxcpmou Ikvgf Vg{{fojx{ogj pcxg{ok) ”hcjxgkou dcu o}bapio) {mo puchookgjfx vo

hbii fbaox* G aobj ecbuk fbaox) hbuk fbaox) ebii fbaox) Ciwapgh fbaox bjk xc cj* Vmb{ gx

hcaacj {c {moa bii32?

‗ Bd{ou bj o}bagjb{gcj cd {mo oioaoj{x cd {moxo kgddouoj{ fbaox) mo dgjkx b

”hcapighb{ok jo{vcul cd xgagibug{gox ctouibppgjf bjk hugxx!hucxxgjf> xcao{gaox ctoubii xgagibug{gox)

xcao{gaox xgagibug{gox cd ko{bgi*‗ Vg{{fojx{ogj gkoj{gdgox {mo gj{ugjxgh puceioa vg{m b uiox!ebxok

kodgjg{gcj gj {mb{ oapmbxgx xmcik eo cj {mo hcfjg{gto ackoi vmghm kodgjox {mo fucpgjf ub{mou {mbj

cenoh{gto uiox* Dcu Vg{{fojx{ogj xgagibug{gox xmcik dchx cj uoib{gcjx ub{mou {mbj b{{uge{ox dcu g{ gx

{mo hcjjoh{gcjx vmghm kugto x {c uoib{o bjk i{gab{oiw dgjk cenoh{x* Mcvotou hcagjf ebhl {c {mo

Igeubuw vcuik) {mo {b}cjcagh bjk xwx{oab{gh -mgoubuhmghbi {uoox' fgkgjf hibxxgdghb{gcj pugjhgpiox xgjho

{mo {gao cd Kovow mbto ebuoiw otcitok* [mo hibxxgdghb{gcj xwx{oa vmghm xc voii xoutok {mo 2=60x

bjk iok {c pugj{ok hbukx bjk otoj{biiw abhmgjo uobkbeio kb{b xoutok oubx vmouo {mouo vbx jc

tgxgeio gj{oujo{ -bx vg{m b eucvxou*'

Xgjho {mb{ vool gj Ch{ceou 2774 vmoj Wbmcc bjk Bi{bTgx{b eofbj {c hb{ofcugxo {mo voe) Fccfio mbx

jcv hcj{gjok kcvj {mb{ pb{m vmghm mbx uoxi{ok gj b xmgd{ cd xou ojrgugox bjk uoxobuhm bvbw

duca igeubugox* Acx{ cd b igeubuw‗x djh{gcjx buo jkou{bloj vg{mgj g{x ichbi igeubuw abjbfoaoj{

xcd{vbuo -IAX' duca bhrgxg{gcj {c hb{bicfgjf bjk hguhib{gcj bjk otoj gj{ou!iojkgjf* Cjo cd {mo

acx{ tgxgeio aobjx cd bktou{gxgjf b igeubuw‗x hciioh{gcjx {c {mo c{xgko vcuik gx g{x cjigjo peigh

bhhoxx hb{bicfo -CPBH'* G{ gx {mo CPBH vmghm xooax {c ibf eomgjk {mo djh{gcjbig{w dcjk cj

hcjtoj{gcjbi hcaaouhgbi voexg{ox* Dcu o}bapio) Bab~cj eofbj xgjf dbho{ok xobuhmgjf ebhl gj

277= vmoj abjw igeubugox vouo x{gii cpoub{gjf xgjf b {oijo{ -g*o* {o}{ ebxok' gj{oudbho*

Nx{ ctou b kohbko ib{ou igeubugbjx buo eofgjjgjf {c abp b acuo uobigx{gh ibjkxhbpo* Aghmboi Mbege

mbx huob{ok {mo dciicvgjf Tojj kgbfuba24

{c kopgh{ {mo jov uciox cd bj bhbkoagh igeubuw gj b 5*0

ojtgucjaoj{*

2? Ikvgf Vg{{fojx{ogj) Pmgicxcpmghbi Gjtox{gfb{gcjx) 8uk ok* -C}dcuk> Eibhlvoii) 2746'

24 ’Bhbkoagh Igeubuw 5*0 Hcjhop{ Ackoi) Ebxgh -dgjbi touxgcj')‑

m{{p>##vvv*dighlu*hca#pmc{cx#mbegeag#82=056265#*

http://www.flickr.com/photos/habibmi/318027172/





7

Vmgix{ {mgx kcox uopuoxoj{ ahm cd {mo bh{gtg{w cd b ackouj bhbkoagh igeubuw) g{ gfjcuox {mo dbh{ {mb{

uoxobuhm ojrgugox buo ewpbxxgjf {mo igeubuw hcapio{oiw* Uodouojho bjk c{mou aokgb{ok ojrgugox buo

eogjf xppcu{ok vg{m ”Tgu{bi Uodouojho‗ bjk ”Gjx{bj{ Aoxxbfgjf*‗

Mcvotou) {mo dciicvgjf bu{ghio26

duca {mo Jov Wcul [gaox duca Nbjbuw -5007' abw giix{ub{o {mo

puceioa acuo hiobuiw* [wiou Lojjokw -bfok 7' vbx bxxgfjok {c uoxobuhm {mo Bx{ubigbj pib{wpx*

O}pibgjgjf mgx uoxobuhm puchoxx) [wiou xbwx ”vmoj {mow kcj‗{ mbto uobiiw fcck uoxi{x cj Wc[eo){moj G xo Fccfio*‗ Gd cjo iobtox bxgko {mo agxxpoiiok mabj gjp{ ao{bkb{b cjo dgjkx cj Wc[eo

bjk bhucxx {mo gj{oujo{) bx voii bx {mo uoib{ok ibhl cd gjdcuab{gcj ig{oubhw kotoicpaoj{ koxhugeok ew

{mo _HI HGEOU [oba2=

) g{ gx jc{ {mo dbh{ {mb{ {mo igeubuw vbx jc{ {mo hmgik‗x dgux{ pcu{ cd hbii bx bj

gjdcuab{gcj puctgkou vmghm gx xc kgx{uegjf* G{ gx {mb{ b Igeubuw‗x IAX nx{ kcox jc{ mbto {mo pcvou

{c bkkuoxx) io{ bicjo hcapo{o) vg{m Wc[eo bjk Fccfio*

[mx) IAX {ccix kc jc{ wo{ uodioh{ [wiou‗x kgfg{bi vcuik* Dokoub{ok xobuhmgjf tgb PUGAC) OJHCUO)

BR_BEUCVXOU buo {mo ib{ox{ IAX o}bapiox cd huob{gjf b Fccfio!iglo igeubuw ojtgucjaoj{ e{ buo

x{gii igag{ok) otoj mgjkouok) ew {mo pbubao{oux vg{mgj {mo IAX* Hbj {mow gjfox{ bii cd {mo Kguoh{cuw cd

Cpoj Bhhoxx Ncujbix3 Kodgjg{oiw* Mcv bec{ {bppgjf gj{c bii cd {mo CBG!PAM hcj{oj{ gj Cbgx{ou3Abweo* Mcv bec{ bii cd {mo tgkoc ab{ougbi btbgibeio bhucxx Wc[eo3

26 ’B{ Dgux{) Djjw Tgkocx* Jcv) b Uodouojho [cci)‑ Jov Wcul [gaox)

- m{{p>##vvv*jw{gaox*hca#5007#02#2=#exgjoxx#aokgb#2=pgjf*m{ai3Su15*

2= Dcu acuo gjdcuab{gcj cj {mo uoxobuhmoux‗ hbxo x{kw bjk dgjkgjfx cd wcjf pocpio vmc bhhoxx gjdcuab{gcj

ctou {mo gj{oujo{ xoo ’Fccfio Fojoub{gcj > NGXH)‑ Gjdcuab{gcj eombtgcu cd {mo uoxobuhmou cd {mo d{uo)

m{{p>##vvv*ngxh*bh*l#vmb{vokc#pucfubaaox#uoxcuhokgxhctouw#fccfiofoj*bxp}*

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/01/18/business/media/18ping.html?_r=2



http://www.jisc.ac.uk/whatwedo/programmes/resourcediscovery/googlegen.aspx






20

[mo Voe bx g{ o}gx{x jcv gx ahm iglo {mgx bu{vcul27

kcjo ew b Hbjbkgbj bu{gx{) Abuooj Diwjj!

Eumco ‘ gj{ouhcjjoh{ok iglo {mo joucjx xffox{ok gj {mo pgoho* [mgx gj{ouhcjjoh{okjoxx mbx

uobigxok g{xoid vg{m {mo fucv{m cd xchgbi jo{vculgjf xg{ox* Bd{ou {mo {cp xobuhm ojfgjox -Fccfio)

Wbmcc bjk hcjxgkougjf {mo Jov Wcul [gaox bu{ghio vg{m 7!wobu cik [wiou) Wc[eo' {mo jo}{ {cp

voexg{o gx Dbhoeccl* Kcox g{ hcao bx bjw xupugxo {mb{ jc igeubuw bppobux b{ {mo {cp cd {mgx igx{50

3

Pcx{ok cj g{x eicf gj Bpugi 5007) dcjkou Abul ^hloueouf bjjcjhok {mb{ Dbhoeccl mbk uofgx{ouok

g{x 500 agiigcj{m xou* Bec{ ? wobux cik) g{ gx uoabulbeio {mb{ b voexg{o mbx acuo {mbj 25/ cd {mo

27 ’Kgfg{bfo Voe 5*0)‑ m{{p>##vvv*dighlu*hca#pmc{cx#chobjdiwjj#82?8=?724#*

50 vvv*bio}b*hca aobxuox voe {ubddgh bjk c{mou gj{oujo{ ao{ughx* \[bloj cj 07 Niw 07*Q

http://www.flickr.com/photos/oceanflynn/315385916/



http://www.alexa.com/






22

vcuik‗x 2*?74 egiigcj gj{oujo{ xoux52

* G{ vcik eo gj{ouox{gjf {c ljcv mcv abjw cd {moa buo igeubuw

xoux3 Hbj igeubugox eo pbu{ cd {mo hcjtouxb{gcj {mb{ fcox cj {mouo3 Abuxmbii AhHimbj dbacxiw

x{b{ok {mo ”aokga gx {mo aoxxbfo55

*‗ Gj {mgx hbxo) {mo gj{oujo{ vg{m g{x xchgbi kwjbagh bx {mo pibho

”{c eo‗ mbx dcuotou bi{ouok {mo gjkopojkoj{ {ubnoh{cuw cd igeubugox* [c xpgj bjc{mou AhImbj igjo vo

buo igtgjf ”{mo ficebi tgiibfo58

‗ vmouo gj{ouhcjjoh{gtg{w cd xchgbi jo{vculx bjk uoxobuhm bjk

gjdcuab{gcj uo{ugotbi buo hbuugok c{ xobaioxxiw* Dcu{jb{oiw {mo d{uo gx jc{ bii fuga bx xcao

igeubuw!dchxok bppighb{gcjx mbto eooj kotoicpok bjk bkkok vg{mgj Dbhoeccl xhm bx {mcxo dcu

NX[CU) VcuikHb{ bjk HCPBH* Cjho xoux mbto bkkok {moxo xobuhm ec}ox -bjk tbugcx

b{moj{ghb{gcj puc{chcix dcu NX[CU' {c {mogu pucdgio) {mow hbj kc bii cd {mogu uoxobuhm ”vg{mgj‗

Dbhoeccl vg{mc{ mbtgjf {c iobto jo{vculgjf bjk xchgbigxgjf vg{m dugojkx* Vmw iobto b tgiibfo vmghm

gx {uiw ficebi3

5;

Koxpg{o {mo dbh{ {mb{ g{ kcox jc{ bppobu gj {mo {cp 50 voe kox{gjb{gcjx) VcuikHb{‗x mcikgjfx vmghm

hcj{bgj xcao 2*;? egiigcj g{oax bhucxx 287 agiigcj egeigcfubpmgh uohcukx) agfm{ x{gii pouhogtok -b{

52 m{{p>##vvv*gj{oujo{vcuikx{b{x*hca#x{b{x*m{a aobxuox {mo jaeou cd gj{oujo{ xoux gj {mo vcuik* \[bloj

82 Abuhm 07*Q

55 Abuxmbii AhImbj) _jkoux{bjkgjf Aokgb> [mo O}{ojxgcjx cd Abj -Icjkcj> Uc{iokfo $ L*Pbi) 274;'*

58 Abuxmbii AhImbj) [mo F{ojeouf Fbib}w> [mo Ablgjf cd [wpcfubpmgh Abj -[cucj{c> _jgtouxg{w cd [cucj{c

Puoxx) 2745'*

5;B xjbpxmc{ duca aw Dbhoeccl pucdgio vmghm {gigxox {mo NX[CU) HCPBH bjk VcuikHb{ bppighb{gcjx*

http://www.internetworldstats.com/stats.htm






25

iobx{ vg{mgj {mo igeubuw hcaajg{w' bx ”{mo‗ ficebi eccl hb{bicfo* G{ gx ibkbeio {mb{ b{{oap{x buo

abko {c abulo{ {mogu xoutghox tgb xchgbi jo{vculgjf xg{ox bx koacjx{ub{ok gj Dbhoeccl* E{ b uohoj{

xutow jkou{bloj ew CHIH5?

-5007' uotobix {mo kgtoufoj{ pugcug{gox gj bxhou{bgjgjf ”vmb{ xoux bjk

igeubugbjx vbj{‗ pbu{ghibuiw gj igfm{ cd {mo ctoubii {uojkx gj gj{oujo{ bh{gtg{w*

Igeubugbjx) bhhcukgjf {c {mo xutow) buo acx{ hcjhoujok bec{ kpighb{o uohcukx gj VcuikHb{ vg{m

?5/ dbtcugjf bjw ojmbjhoaoj{ vmghm uohcjhgiox cu ”hiobjx p‗ bii cd {mo kpighb{o uohcukx* _xoux

gjhgkoj{biiw vouo bd{ou igjlx {c acuo dii {o}{ -84/' bjk acuo xenoh{ gjdcuab{gcj -85/'* C{mou

uorox{x dcu [beio cd Hcj{oj{x -[CH' gjdcuab{gcj bjk dcu xaabugox bjk#cu bex{ubh{x vouo dbu{mou

kcvj {mo igx{*

”Acuo dii {o}{‗ gx poudoh{iw jkoux{bjkbeio) otoj gd xoux abw jc{ jkoux{bjk diiw gxxox cd ighojxgjf

bjk bjjbi xexhugp{gcj* ”Acuo xenoh{ gjdcuab{gcj‗ gx b eg{ acuo baegfcx bjk uorguox du{mou

xhu{gjw* VcuikHb{‗x igeubugbjx buo jxuo mcv {c gj{oupuo{ {mgx* Kc xoux aobj {mow vbj{ otoj

acuo ucex{ xenoh{ mobkgjfx vmghm buo ibecu gj{ojxgto {c huob{o3 [c xhuw {mucfm {mo icclgjf fibxx

CHIH mbx hcapio{oiw agxxok {mo ubeeg{ mcio* Bjk vmgix{ igeubugox mobtgiw gjtox{ gj egikgjf {cp kcvj

hibxxgdghb{gcj bjk gjko}beio xenoh{ {b}cjcagox) {mo uopcu{ hcjdguax ”g{ gx jigloiw {mb{ {mow aobj

acuo hcj{uciiok xenoh{ mobkgjfx*‗

O}pougojho duca xgjf hcaaouhgbi xg{ox iglo Bab~cj vmouo xoux hbj ablo puckh{ ub{gjfx)

uohcaaojkb{gcjx bjk bkk pouxcjbigxok {bfx) ju{uox {mogu jkoux{bjkgjf bjk o}poh{b{gcjx cd {mo

cjigjo ojtgucjaoj{* [mgx _u !o}pougojho xmbpox bjk gjdcuax {mogu xbegig{w cd VcuikHb{* Vmw

kcoxj‗{ CHIH xoo {mgx3 Vmoj cjo hcjxgkoux {mo igag{ok pugxa cd gjdcuab{gcj xhgojho) g{ gx jc

xupugxo {c dgjk ec}ox cd uiox cd hibxxgdghb{gcj) hb{bicfgjf) ao{bkb{b uorguoaoj{x) b{mcug{w dgiox*

Toj{ugjf c{xgko cd {mgx igag{ok ojtgucjaoj{) g{ eohcaox hiobu {mb{ ”acuo xenoh{ gjdcuab{gcj‗

ax{ eo tgovok gj hcj{o}{ cd bj _u!Fox{bi{ * Voexg{ox -xhm bx Kggfc) Koighgcx) Dighlu) Dui) Wc[eo)

Kbgiwac{gcj' vmghm biicv xou fojoub{ok ao{bkb{b -vmghm vgii eo acuo diiw o}picuok jcv' mbto

dicugxmok iglo ig{{io fuooj xmcc{x ctou {mo pbx{ dov wobux bjk puoxoj{ bj bi{oujb{gto ibwou cd xenoh{

ao{bkb{b dcu {mo xou*

ABLGJF [MO VOE POUXCJBI

Hcaacj {c bii cd {moxo voexg{ox gx {mo begig{w cd b xou {c {bf bjk koxhugeo bj cenoh{ vg{m tchbeibuw

cd mgx#mou hmcgho gj mgx#mou uoxpoh{gto ibjfbfo* Fcjo buo {mo x{uh{uok uiox cd BBHU5) {mo ugfgkhibxxgdwgjf cd {cpgh bjk {mo b{mcug{w dgiox vmghm hcjxcigkb{o bjk abgj{bgj b igeubuw‗x kb{bxo{x* [moxo

jhcj{uciiok lowvcukx gjmouoj{iw pcxxoxx bii cd {mo puceioax vg{m jb{ubi ibjfbfo gj bii cd g{x

mcacjwagh) pciwxoagh) mo{oucpmcjgh bjk xwjcjwagh ficuw* Haib{gtoiw) {mo hcaegjb{gcj cd bii cd

b xou‗x {bf hciioh{gcj vcik dcua vmb{ [mcabx Tbjkou Vbi hcgjok bx dcilxcjcaw) ”b xou!

fojoub{ok hibxxgdghb{gcj oaoufgjf {mucfm ec{{ca!p hcjxojxx*54

‗

5? ’Cjigjo Hb{bicfx> Vmb{ _xoux bjk Igeubugbjx Vbj{)‑ 5007*

m{{p>##vvv*chih*cuf#l#oj#uopcu{x#cjigjohb{bicfx#kodbi{*m{a*

54 ’Dcilxcjcaw)‑ m{{p>##vvv*tbjkouvbi*jo{#dcilxcjcaw*m{ai*

http://www.oclc.org/uk/en/reports/onlinecatalogs/default.htm


http://www.vanderwal.net/folksonomy.html







28

Vg{m bii cd {mo igjfgx{gh puceioax hcpiok vg{m ai{gpio ibjfbfox cpoub{gjf cj b jgdgok pib{dcua)

vmw xmcik igeubugox vbj{ {c acto {cvbukx xhm bj juofib{ok dubaovcul3 Mbtgjf o}bagjok {mo

acx{ pcpibu gj{oujo{ kox{gjb{gcjx) b acuo {mcucfm o}bagjb{gcj cd gjdcuab{gcj eombtgcu pb{{oujx

cd cjigjo xoux gx jcv gj cukou*

Vmgix{ {mo HGEOU Pucnoh{ fucp o}hixgtoiw o}bagjok xobuhm eombtgcubi pb{{oujx gj hmgikuoj) {mo

Pov Uoxobuhm Hoj{uo -b jcjpbu{gxbj bjk jcjpucdg{ {mgjl {bjl' mbx dcu kohbkox eooj x{kwgjf {uojkx

bjk b{{g{kox xmbpgjf Baoughb* Ko {c {mo puotbiojho cd {mo gj{oujo{ gj {ckbw‗x xchgo{w) Pov x{kgox

g{x gapbh{ cj ”dbagigox) hcaajg{gox) vcul bjk mcao) kbgiw igdo) okhb{gcj) mobi{m hbuo) bjk hgtgh bjk

pcig{ghbi igdo*‗

B Pov Gj{oujo{ bjk Baoughbj Igdo Pucnoh{ uopcu{56

peigxmok gj Kohoaeou 5004 uotobiok {mb{ 5=/ cd

gj{oujo{ xoux mbto {bffok cu hb{ofcugxok cjigjo hcj{oj{* Bi{mcfm {mo Pov‗x vcul gx igag{ok gj {mb{

g{x x{kgox buo igag{ok xcioiw {c Baoughbj xoux) {mogu vcul gx {mcucfm bjk cjo hcik gjdou {mb{ {moxo

gxxox bjk {uojkx buo xgagibu bhucxx gjkx{ugbigxok hcj{ugox -g*o* xhm bx {mo F50 fucpgjf cd

jb{gcjx'* Bi{mcfm {mgx uopcu{ gx b hcpio wobux cik) cjo vcik o}poh{ {mb{ {mouo gx vgkou kgddxgcj

jcv cd {bffgjf bjk hb{ofcugxb{gcj cd cjigjo hcj{oj{ bx {mo jo}{ hbxo x{kw vgii b{{ox{*

Xcao hi{ubi gjx{g{{gcjx) xhm bx {mo Jb{gcjbi Igeubuw cd Bx{ubigb gj 5006 bjk {mo Igeubuw cd

Hcjfuoxx gj 500=) mbto biicvok xcao cd {mogu kgfg{bi hciioh{gcjx {c eo picbkok cj Dighlu {c gjhuobxo

{mo o}pcxuo cd {mogu hciioh{gcjx bjk cpoj {moa p {c b vgkou bkgojho* Dighlu gx cjo cd {mo voexg{ox

-vmghm kcox ablo {mo {cp 50' aoj{gcjok obuigou vmghm biicvx xoux {c picbk pouxcjbi pgh{uox bjk

xmbuo pugtb{oiw cu bhucxx {mo jo{vcul vg{m tbuwgjf kofuoox cd Huob{gto Hcaacjx Ighojxox*

Pmc{cfubpmx buo hb{bicfok duooiw ew gjkgtgkbix xgjf b dcilxcjcagh bppucbhm*

Bx pbu{ cd {mgx pgic{ pucnoh{) {mo Igeubuw cd Hcjfuoxx -ICH' pibhok ;42? cd g{x ctou cjo agiigcj kgfg{gxokgabfox cj{c {mo Dighlu Hcaacjx

5=vmghm gx b kgx{gjh{ e{ {c{biiw gj{ofub{ok xoh{gcj cd Dighlu vmghm

mbx {mo hciioh{gcjx cd bucjk 80 pbu{jou hi{ubi gjx{g{{gcjx duooiw btbgibeio bjk xobuhmbeio bjk

koxhugeox g{xoid bx ”wcu cppcu{jg{w {c hcj{uge{o {c koxhugegjf {mo vcuik‗x peigh pmc{c hciioh{gcjx*‗

56 ’[bffgjf y Pov Uoxobuhm Hoj{ou&x Gj{oujo{ $ Baoughbj Igdo Pucnoh{)‑

m{{p>##vvv*povgj{oujo{*cuf#Uopcu{x#5006#[bffgjf*bxp}*

5= vvv*dighlu*hca#hcaacjx

http://www.pewinternet.org/Reports/2007/Tagging.aspx


http://www.flickr.com/commons







2;

Bx cd Ch{ceou 500= vmoj {mo ICH kb{b vbx bjbiwxok57

42)264 {bfx vouo huob{ok ew 5?2= jgro

Dighlu bhhcj{x bjk bkkok {c {mo kgfg{bi hciioh{gcj‗x ao{bkb{b* [mo gj{ofug{w cd {mo ao{bkb{b vbx

gapuctok ew gjkgtgkbix vmc vouo ichbi o}pou{x cj xcao cd {mo puotgcxiw jgkoj{gdgbeio pgh{uox80

*

[ubkg{gcjbi igeubugbjx mbto jc{ok {mb{ xhm bj juofib{ok xou fojoub{ok xwx{oa cd lowvcukx abw

uoxi{ gj {mo pibhoaoj{ cd ubjkca) gjbhhub{o cu gjbppucpugb{o {bfx {c {mo uohcuk* Mcvotou) {mouo

vouo ioxx {mbj 5? gjx{bjhox cd xou!fojoub{ok hcj{oj{ vmghm uorguok uoactbi duca {mo 6244

hcaaoj{x iod{ cj jobuiw 5=68 pgh{uox*

Cjho b hciioh{gcj mbx eooj cpojok p) g{ gx hiobu {mb{ {bffgjf gapuctox bjk gjhuobxox uoxcuho

kgxhctouw* Bx Kbtgk Vogjeoufou mbx uoabulok ”otouw{mgjf gx hcjjoh{ok bjk {mouodcuo otouw{mgjf gx

ao{bkb{b82

*‗ G{ mbx eohcao bppbuoj{ {mb{ {mo ICH mbx uobigxok {mo eojodg{ cd fgtgjf p xcao hcj{uci

{c {mo xou* ”Acuo {mbj ?00 uohcukx mbto eooj ojmbjhok vg{m gjdcuab{gcj puctgkok ew {mo Dighlu

hcaajg{w*‗ Gjkook d{uo gjg{gb{gtox gjhiko pcpib{gjf {mo egeigcfubpmgh uohcukx vg{m {bfx ibeoiiok

bx jhcj{uciiok gjko} {ouax -ABUH 4?8'* [mgx dxgcj cd ABUH bjk dcilxcjcaw abw pucto bj

ojkobugjf iofbhw {c d{uo gjdcuab{gcj uoxcuho kgxhctouw aohmbjgxax* G{ xmcik eo x{b{ok {mb{ {mo

ICH pgic{ pucnoh{ egi{ pcj b xgagibu b{{oap{ b{ {bffgjf jkou{bloj ew Bx{ubigbj bjk Jov ^obibjk

hi{ubi gjx{g{{gcjx xhm bx {mo Pcvoumcxo Axoa) Pgh{uo Bx{ubigb -dokoub{ok pgh{uo

hciioh{gcjx abjbfok ew {mo Jb{gcjbi Igeubuw cd Bx{ubigb' bjk J^Axoa*

Rg{o xgapiw) {bffgjf koacjx{ub{ox hcj{gjok uoiotbjho gj b kwjbagh vcuik* Xcao igeubugbjx mbto

{c abgj{bgj b xo{ cd _UIx) igjlx cd uoiotbj{ uoxcuhox dcu cu uoxpoh{gto xenoh{ hcaajg{gox* Dcu

axgh) cjo cd {mo hibxxgh ao{b!voexg{ox btbgibeio gx {mo Ucwbi Mciicvbw Fcikoj Pbfox85

vmghm

b{{oap{x b Wbmcc!iglo hb{ofcugxb{gcj cd axgh uoib{ok voepbfox* [mo puceioa vg{m xhm b x{uh{uo

gx {mb{ g{ kcox jc{ biicv fubjibu mcug~cj{bi xobuhmgjf cd uoxcuhox* G{ gx bixc b {cp!kcvj bppucbhm

vmghm igag{x gjdcuab{gcj uo{ugotbi* Xcao Fccfio djh{gcjbig{w mbx eooj bkkok dcu {mo ”Hcjdouojhox‗

{be e{ cjo gx igag{ok {c lowvcuk pougckghg{w*

57 Aghmoiio Xpugjfou) Eo{m Kibebmj) o{ bi*) Dcu {mo hcaacj fcck> {mo Igeubuw cd Hcjfuoxx Dighlu Pgic{ Pucnoh{ )

vvv*ich*fct#uu#pugj{#dighlu Suopcu{Sdgjbi*pkd

80[mo gapuctoaoj{ cd {mo ao{bkb{b ko {c {mo hcj{uge{gcj cd x{ubjfoux egikx cj {mo pmojcaojcj cd hucvk

xcuhgjf bjk bjk fucp gj{oiigfojho* Dcu du{mou gjdcuab{gcj cj {moxo {vc pmojcaojb hcjxi{ Hibw Xmgulw)

Mouo hcaox otouweckw mcv hmbjfo mbppojx vmoj pocpio hcao {cfo{mou -Icjkcj > Pojfgj) 5007' bjk Nbaox

Xucvgohlg) [mo vgxkca cd hucvkx vmw {mo abjw buo xabu{ou {mbj {mo dov bjk mcv hciioh{gto vgxkca xmbpox

exgjoxx) ohcjcaghx) xchgo{gox) bjk jb{gcjx -Icjkcj > Ig{{io) Eucvj) 500;'*

82Kbtgk Vogjeoufou) Otouw{mgjf gx agxhoiibjocx {mo pcvou cd {mo jov kgfg{bi kgxcukou ) 2x{ ok* -Jov Wcul>

[gaox Ecclx#Mojuw Mci{ bjk Hc*) 5006'*

85 m{{p>##voe*ao*hca#npomx#fcikoj!pbfox#Gjko}*m{ai

http://www.loc.gov/rr/print/flickr_report_final.pdf






http://web.me.com/jpehs/golden-pages/Index.html







2?

Xc o}pougaoj{x vg{m tbugcx xchgbi ecclabulgjf xoutghox bjk {mo huob{gcj cd dcilxcjcagox tgb

{bffgjf mbto eooj jkou{bloj bx b pbu{ cd {mgx uoxobuhm* Voexg{ox xhm bx Dui) Kggfc bjk Koighgcx

biicv {mo uoxobuhmou {c xbto bj _UI bjk bkk {bfx dcu hb{ofcugxb{gcj bjk otoj acuo pouxcjbigxok

gkgcxwjhub{gh uo{ugotbi -o*f* {mo {bf ”;uoxpucn‗ vmghm hcik eo {ubjxib{ok gj{c ”dcu {mgx uoxobuhm

pucnoh{‗'*

Gj bkkg{gcj {c dgjkgjf b xci{gcj dcu xobuhmgjf bhucxx mgoubuhmghbi hb{ofcugox -g*o* axgh dbho{x') {moxo

o}pougaoj{x mbto iok {c b puc{c{wpo dcu b ao{bkb{b dubaovcul gj {mo xchgbi ecclabulgjf voexg{o

Koighgcx* Vmb{ G mbto koxgfjb{ok bx XcEcAoD cu Xchgbi Ecclabulgjf Ao{bkb{b Dubaovcul)

b{{oap{x {c pii {cfo{mou uoxcuhox vmghm vcik jc{ jcuabiiw eo gjfox{ok ew {mo jcuabi aobjx

-bffuofb{ok tgb CBG!PAM' cu vmghm uoabgj c{xgko {mo xhcpo cd huuoj{ IAX xhm bx b tgkoc duca

Kbgiwac{gcj cu Wc[eo*

Hcpiok vg{m {mo igjfgx{gh puceioax aoj{gcjok obuigou) {moxo dcilxcjcagox mbto {mo bkkg{gcjbi

puceioa cd {bf kgxbaegfb{gcj* [mgx vcik jc{ eo b puceioa dcu xoabj{gh xwx{oax bx {mcxo mbto

eooj kgxhxxok {mucfmc{ {mgx hcjdouojho* Kcox {mo ”XD‗ gj Koighgcx x{bjk dcu Xbj Dubjhgxhc cuXhgojho dgh{gcj3 Kcox {mo {bf ”ao{bi‗ pou{bgj {c ao{biiufw cu mobtw ao{bi axgh3 Hix{ougjf bjk

{mo xo cd igag{ok {b}cjcaghbi x{uh{uox abw puctgko b xci{gcj {c {mgx* Gd cjo hcj{gjcxiw bkkx

acuo bjk acuo lowvcuk {bfx) g{ xmcik kgxbaegfb{o bjk hix{ou {mo uoiotbj{ _UIx*

KODOB[GJF KGXBAEGF_B[GCJ VG[M XCECAOD

Eodcuo kopbu{gjf {cc dbu bvbw vg{m {mgx {ohmjghbi nbufcj) g{ gx {mo ojk!xou {mb{ gx acx{ pbubacj{*

[mgx jov XcEcAoD dubaovcul vgii eo aobjgjfioxx jioxx uoxobuhmoux hbj uobkgiw gkoj{gdw {mo

eojodg{x bjk x{uojf{m cd {mo xwx{oa bjk g{ gx uobkgiw xbeio* Mcv vgii {mo xoux bppucbhm Axgh

Uoxobuhm 5*03



24

Bx b pbu{ cd {mgx o}pougaoj{) mjkuokx cd _UIx uoib{ok {c axgh bhucxx {mo voe mbto eooj

ecclabulok bjk {bffok gj Koighgcx* Gj {mo dciicvgjf o}bapio88

) bii cd {mo _UIx uoib{ok {c

”X{ubtgjxlw‗ mbto eooj uo{ugotok duca aw Koighgcx ecclabul dook* [mo uok buucv gjkghb{ox

uohcukgjfx cd X{ubtgjxlw‗x Io Xbhuo k Pugj{oapx -Ug{o cd Xpugjf' kubvj duca bhucxx voexg{ox xhm bx

{mo Gj{oujo{ Buhmgto bjk Wc[eo* [mo eio buucvx gjkghb{o {o}{x cj X{ubtgjxlw vmghm gjhiko bj o!

eccl duca {mo _jgtouxg{w cd Hbigdcujgb‗x o!Xhmcibuxmgp okg{gcj) bj o!{moxgx duca {mo _jgtouxg{w cd

Uchmox{ou) bj o!eccl c{xgko cd hcpwugfm{ xhbjjok ew Fccfio bjk bj bu{ghio* Hou{bgjiw Cbgx{ou vcik

mbutox{ xcao cd {moxo kgfg{bi xuucfb{ox e{ {mo uohcukgjfx bx voii3 Vmb{ IAX vcik eo beio {c

mbutox{ {moa3 [mb{ gx {mo pcvou cd xchgbi ecclabulgjf bjk dcilxcjcaw) cddougjf b jov pb{m dcu

igeubugbjx bjk igeubugox {cvbukx {mo abjbfoaoj{ bjk uo{ugotbegig{w cd kgfg{biiw ecuj cenoh{x*

XcEcAoD oaib{ox oioaoj{x cd DUEU -Djh{gcjbi Uorguoaoj{x dcu Egeigcfubpmgh Uohcukx' xhm bx

{mo xcuho#cenoh{ bjk ABUH dgoikx gjhcupcub{gjf pbu{x cd {mo 00=) 200) 5;?) 800) 4?0) bjk =?4* Gj

{mgx abjjou dbho{ok xobuhmgjf hbj eo jkou{bloj bhhcukgjf {c xcuho xhm bx ”wc{eo‗ cu ”kbgiw‗

”ac{gcj‗ cu dcuab{ xhm bx ”o!eccl‗ cu ”o!{moxgx‗* Vgii {mgx uopibho b {b}cjcagh ao{bkb{b dubaovcul3

XcEcAoD bxpguox {c uoxpcjk {c {mo gjdio}gegig{w cd ABUH bjk c{mou uiox!ebxok bppucbhmox*

Dcilxcjcaw puctgkox b dio}geio -g*o* eojkbeio' x{uh{uo {c biicv dcu {mo huob{gcj cd jov aokgb bjk

fojuox bhucxx {mo gj{oujo{* Igeubuw x{bjkbukx mbto uoabgjok ugfgkiw dg}ok* [mo huob{gcj bjk xo cd

ABUH =?48;

vcik eo b fcck o}bapio cd mcv cjo dgoik hbjjc{ koxhugeo {mo tbugo{w cd fojuo

btbgibeio jcv cj {mo gj{oujo{* Otoj vg{m bppucpugb{o bjk ucex{ koigag{oux g{ gx cetgcx {mb{ {mo

eojodg{x gjtcitok vcik jc{ eo hcx{!oddoh{gto {c huob{o bjk x{gii jc{ obxgiw biicv hucxx!xobuhmgjf gj b

aobjgjfdi vbw dcu uoxobuhmoux* [mgx gx jc{ {c xbw {mb{ gapuctoaoj{x xmcik jc{ eo abko"

88 vvv*koighgcx*hca#hcigj62#x{ubtgjxlw

8; m{{p>##vvv*ich*fct#abuh#=?4fgko*m{ai

http://www.delicious.com/colin71/stravinsky



http://www.loc.gov/marc/856guide.html







26

Hb{bicfox -bjk xobuhm uo{ugotbi' hbj hou{bgjiw eo gapuctok vg{m mweugk ackoix xhm bx {mb{ cddouok

ew Igeubuw[mgjf8?

*

Gj bkkg{gcj {c pouxcjbigxb{gcj) Voe 5*0 cddoux abxmpx -cu mweugk hcaegjb{gcjx' cd {ohmjcicfgox*

Igeubuw[mgjf biicvx bjwcjo {c eohcao b hb{bicfou* Bec{ b agiigcj gjkgtgkbix hb{bicfo ecclx bjk

xmbuo {mogu uoxpoh{gto ao{bkb{b bjk pouxcjbigxok {bfx* [mo Xbj Dubjhgxhc X{b{o _jgtouxg{w Igeubuw

huob{ok b abxmp cd {mogu CPBH vg{m Igeubuw[mgjf bjk uopuoxoj{x bjc{mou otci{gcjbuw x{op* G{ gx b

xgapio nbtb xhugp{ {mb{ huob{ox {mo {bf hick bjk {bilx vg{m Igeubuw[mgjf* Xc dcu o}bapio) {mo

Igeubuw‗x egeigcfubpmgh uohcuk cd X{ubtgjxlw‗x xhcuo cd [mo Ug{o cd Xpugjf84

gx ojmbjhok vg{m

jhcj{uciiok lowvcukx xhm bx 50{m

hoj{uw # ackoujgx{) o{h* {c gapucto gjdcuab{gcj uo{ugotbi*

Vgii dcilxcjcaw cpoj b jov vbu bfbgjx{ {mo hcj{uciiok uiox bjk x{bjkbukx igeubugox mbto bivbwxpuc{oh{ok3 Gd igeubugox buo cpoj agjkok bjk tgov {moxo otci{gcjbuw {uojkx hcj{o}{biiw* Pucebeiw

jc{* Hou{bgjiw {mo voe x{b{gx{ghbi kb{b bjk gjdcuab{gcj xoolgjf eombtgcu xpoblx dcu {moaxoitox*

[mouo vgii hou{bgjiw eo puoxxuo {c kc xc oxpohgbiiw vg{m {mo huuoj{ dgjbjhgbi kcvj{uj hcjducj{gjf

bhbkoagh igeubugox gj{oujb{gcjbiiw* [vc uohoj{ uopcu{x ew {mo Bxxchgb{gcj cd Uoxobuhm Igeubugox -BUI'

bjk {mo Hcjhgi cj Igeubuw bjk Gjdcuab{gcj Uoxcuhox -HIGU' ablo {mogu pcxg{gcj hiobu* Bj BUI

X{ub{ofgh Pibj Uotgov [bxl Dcuho mbx uohcaaojkok {mb{ gj {moxo hmbiiojfgjf {gaox {c ”pxm igeubugox

{c hcjx{uh{ jov dcuax cd ojfbfoaoj{ bjk xppcu{*86

‗ Hou{bgjiw {mo actoaoj{ {cvbukx kgfg{bi

uoxcuho mbx jc{ fcjo jjc{ghok ew HIGU vmc jc{o hug{ghbiiw) ”igeubugox {ojk {c eo ugxl!btouxo

cufbjgxb{gcjx< {c uoabgj uoiotbj{) {mow ax{ eo vgiigjf {c o}pougaoj{ bjk gjjctb{o*8=

‗

Igeubugox hbjjc{ bddcuk {c gfjcuo {moxo {uojkx gj cukou {c ”uoabgj uoiotbj{*‗ Kofuoox cd hcj{uci mbto

bivbwx eooj b{ {mo mobu{ cd gjdcuab{gcj xhgojho* Hbj bj jhcj{uciiok xwx{oa eo uofib{ok3 Kgo!mbuk

8? vvv*igeubuw{mgjf*hca

84 m{{p>##cpbh*xdx*ok

86 Bxxchgb{gcj cd Uoxobuhm Igeubugox) -5007' [ubjxdcuab{gcjbi [gaox> Bj Ojtgucjaoj{bi Xhbj Puopbuok ew {mo

BUI X{ub{ofgh Pibj Uotgov [bxl Dcuho vvv*bui*cuf#eazkch#{ubjxdcuab{gcjbi!{gaox*pkd

8=

Hcjhgi cj Igeubuw bjk Gjdcuab{gcj Uoxcuhox) -500=' Jc Eugod Hbjkio> Uohcjhogtgjf Uoxobuhm Igeubugox dcu {mo 52

x{ Hoj{uw m{{p>##vvv*higu*cuf#pex#bex{ubh{#pe2;5bex{*m{ai

http://www.librarything.com/



http://opac.sfsu.edu/



http://www.arl.org/bm~doc/transformational-times.pdf



http://www.clir.org/pubs/abstract/pub142abst.html









2=

hb{bicfgjf bppbub{hmglx vgii jkce{okiw xbw jc e{ cufbjgxb{gcjx xhm bx {mo Kgfg{bi Igeubuw

Dokoub{gcj kc mbto b acuo gjhixgto tgov cd {mo d{uo*

Gj {mogu uohoj{ uopcu{ cj D{uo Kguoh{gcjx gj Ao{bkb{b Uoaokgb{gcj dcu Ao{bkb{b Bffuofb{cux) {mo

fucp uoxpcjkx {c {mo dciicvgjf koxguok xoutgho uorox{) ”Gjhuobxo btbgibeio xobuhm {ouax gj uohcukx

ew gjhcupcub{gjf xou!xffox{ok {bfx gj{c ao{bkb{b*‗ [mo uopcu{‗x pugjhgpbi b{mcu) Fuo{b ko Fucb{

vug{ox) ”dcu ao{bkb{b dcuab{x {mb{ xppcu{ g{) {bfx hcik eo mbutox{ok bjk gjxou{ok gj{c xenoh{

dgoikx) abulok vg{m {mogu xcuho* Bi{oujb{gtoiw) {mo {ouax hcik eo mcxok xopbub{oiw duca {mo

ao{bkb{b e{ bffuofb{ok {cfo{mou*87

‗ [mb{ gjkook vcik loop igeubugox uoiotbj{*

B HGUHIO CD U_IOX

[mgx uobiiw eugjfx x dii hguhio vg{m {mo iotoix cd hcj{uci dcjk gj Vg{cik I{cxibvxlg‗x axgh*

Bi{mcfm mo mgaxoid uopuoxoj{x cjo x{op cj {mo otci{gcjbuw ibkkou cd jc{b{gcj x{bjkbukx) mgx ujf

uopuoxoj{x {mo eox{ cd ec{m vcuikx) b mweugk dcu {mo igeubuw bjk gjdcuab{gcj pucdoxxgcj {c iobuj duca

bjk oaib{o* I{cxibvxlg x{gii vbj{ok ibufo x{uh{ubi hcj{uci ctou mgx hcapcxg{gcj* Poudcuabjhox

cd mgx vcul vcik x{gii eo uohcfjgxbeio bx gj {mo Xwapmcjw Jc* 8 e{ mo biicvok dcu ig{{io tbugb{gcjx b{

{mo aghuciotoi -g*o* {mo poudcuaou' {c gapucto {mo vcul bjk hcj{uge{o {c obhm poudcuabjho‗x

jgrojoxx*

;0

Xgagibuiw) {mo Igeubuw vcuik jookx {c iccxoj g{x uorguoaoj{x bjk uiox xc {mb{ gjdcuab{gcj uo{ugotbi

pcxxgegig{gox buo ab}gagxok* Dcilxcjcaw kcox jc{ uopuoxoj{ {mo ojk cd b{mcug{w hcj{uci) aouoiw {mo

jo}{ ujf p {mo otci{gcjbuw hmbgj cd ao{bkb{b* Gd {mouo buo bjw ioxxcjx duca aw XcEcAoD

o}pougaoj{) g{ gx {mb{ {bfx gapucto gjdcuab{gcj uo{ugotbi bjk biicv {mo uoxobuhmou {mo begig{w {c abp

{mo kgfg{bi cenoh{x {mow ojhcj{ou ctou {mo hcuxo cd {mogu uoxobuhm cj {mo gj{oujo{* Otoj {mo eox{

87Fuo{b ko Fucb{) D{uo Kguoh{gcjx gj Ao{bkb{b Uoaokgb{gcj dcu Ao{bkb{b Bffuofb{cux -Kgfg{bi Igeubuw

Dokoub{gcj) 5007' vvv*kgfige*cuf#brgdou#kid220*pkd

;0 m{{p>##vvv*dighlu*hca#toffgoibxbfjb

http://www.diglib.org/aquifer/dlf110.pdf



http://www.flickr.com/veggielasagna







IAX gj {mo vcuik hbjjc{ kc {mb{* Xc) Axgh Igeubuw Uoxobuhm 5*0 vgii jook {c hbuuw kofuoox cd

pouxcjbigxb{gcj) gjkgtgkbigxb{gcj bjk hx{cagxb{gcj* [mo IAX -bjk {mo uiox fctoujgjf g{' vgii jook

{c eo gj{oucpoubeio vg{m xchgbi jo{vculx bjk c{mou {mguk pbu{w xwx{oax bjk poumbpx acx{

gapcu{bj{iw) eo hmbubh{ougxok ew b dcilxcjcagh dcjkb{gcj* Bx {mo gj{oujo{ hcj{gjox {c otcito)

igeubugox ax{ jc{ xo kgjcxbux bx {mogu ucio ackoi bjk eo uoiofb{ok {c abgj{bgjgjf b dov xpohgbi

bjk mgx{cugh hciioh{gcjx bagkx{ {mo kgfg{bi vcuik* [mow ax{ {blo p {mo abj{io cd pcxxgegig{w bjk

hmbjho bjk p{ g{ b{ {mo mobu{ cd b jov cpoub{gjf ackoi dcu {mo d{uo* Cjiw {moj vgii igeubugox

uoabgj uoiotbj{ bjk xutgto bx {mo dg{{ox{*

musical darwinism

Documents