munich chain ladder: a reserving method that … chain ladder: a reserving method that reduces the...

34
Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections Based on Incurred Losses by Gerhard Quarg and Thomas Mack “Munich Chain Ladder” by Dr. Quarg and Dr. Mack is being reprinted in Variance to give this important paper wider visibility within the actuarial community. The edi- tors of Variance invited the authors to submit their paper for republication because we believe that the techniques described in their work should be known to all actuaries doing reserve analysis. We also hope to stimulate further research in this area. This paper is reprinted from Blätter der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Versicherungs- und Finanz- mathematik, volume 26, number 4, 2004, pages 597—630. We thank the editors of that journal and the authors for allowing Variance to publish the paper. KEYWORDS Reserving methods, chain ladder, loss development, reconciliation of paid and incurred projections 266 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2 REPRINT ACKNOWLEDGMENT

Upload: phamnhan

Post on 22-May-2018

223 views

Category:

Documents


5 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Munich Chain Ladder: A ReservingMethod that Reduces the Gap

between IBNR Projections Based onPaid Losses and IBNR Projections

Based on Incurred Lossesby Gerhard Quarg and Thomas Mack

“Munich Chain Ladder” by Dr. Quarg and Dr. Mack isbeing reprinted in Variance to give this important paperwider visibility within the actuarial community. The edi-tors of Variance invited the authors to submit their paperfor republication because we believe that the techniquesdescribed in their work should be known to all actuariesdoing reserve analysis. We also hope to stimulate furtherresearch in this area. This paper is reprinted from Blätterder Deutschen Gesellschaft für Versicherungs- und Finanz-mathematik, volume 26, number 4, 2004, pages 597—630.We thank the editors of that journal and the authors forallowing Variance to publish the paper.

KEYWORDS

Reserving methods, chain ladder, loss development, reconciliation of paidand incurred projections

266 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2

REPRINT ACKNOWLEDGMENT

Page 2: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Munich Chain Ladder

VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY 267

Page 3: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Variance Advancing the Science of Risk

268 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2

Page 4: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Munich Chain Ladder

VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY 269

Page 5: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Variance Advancing the Science of Risk

270 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2

Page 6: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Munich Chain Ladder

VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY 271

Page 7: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Variance Advancing the Science of Risk

272 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2

Page 8: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Munich Chain Ladder

VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY 273

Page 9: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Variance Advancing the Science of Risk

274 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2

Page 10: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Munich Chain Ladder

VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY 275

Page 11: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Variance Advancing the Science of Risk

276 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2

Page 12: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Munich Chain Ladder

VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY 277

Page 13: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Variance Advancing the Science of Risk

278 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2

Page 14: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Munich Chain Ladder

VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY 279

Page 15: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Variance Advancing the Science of Risk

280 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2

Page 16: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Munich Chain Ladder

VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY 281

Page 17: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Variance Advancing the Science of Risk

282 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2

Page 18: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Munich Chain Ladder

VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY 283

Page 19: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Variance Advancing the Science of Risk

284 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2

Page 20: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Munich Chain Ladder

VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY 285

Page 21: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Variance Advancing the Science of Risk

286 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2

Page 22: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Munich Chain Ladder

VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY 287

Page 23: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Variance Advancing the Science of Risk

288 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2

Page 24: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Munich Chain Ladder

VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY 289

Page 25: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Variance Advancing the Science of Risk

290 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2

Page 26: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Munich Chain Ladder

VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY 291

Page 27: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Variance Advancing the Science of Risk

292 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2

Page 28: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Munich Chain Ladder

VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY 293

Page 29: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Variance Advancing the Science of Risk

294 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2

Page 30: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Munich Chain Ladder

VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY 295

Page 31: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Variance Advancing the Science of Risk

296 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2

Page 32: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Munich Chain Ladder

VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY 297

Page 33: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Variance Advancing the Science of Risk

298 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2

Page 34: Munich Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that … Chain Ladder: A Reserving Method that Reduces the Gap between IBNR Projections Based on Paid Losses and IBNR Projections BasedonIncurredLosses

Munich Chain Ladder

VOLUME 2/ISSUE 2 CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY 299