Multicast congestion control on many-to-many videoconferencing

Xuan Zhang

zhangx@cernet.edu.cn

Network Research Center

Tsinghua University, China

Outline

• Introduction

• Packets transmission model in multicast based many-to-many videoconference

• End-to-end packet loss rate measurement and aggregation

• Locate congestion link via tomography method

• Congestion control via adjusting senders’ bit rates

• Simulation and experiment

• Conclusions

1 Introduction

• Motivation —Application background

—Many-to-many videoconferencing is N-to-N application which consumes large bandwidth; Multicast is an efficient technology for many-to-many videoconferencing for it could save bandwidth.( Fig.1 )

—Problems?—However, network congestion would cause serious end-to-end

packets loss and delay which would debase the quality of videoconferencing.

—Goals ?—Propose a valid and efficient multicast congestion control scheme

for many-to-many videoconference.

Fig.1 The multicast-based many-to-many videoconferencing on CERNET

Introduction (2)

• Overview of the scheme

—Judge the congestion —Judge the congestion via end-to-end packet loss rate (PLR)

measurement

—Locate the congestion links—Locate the congestion links (bottleneck links) on shared

multicast tree via tomography method based on packets transmission model and end-to-end PLR.

—Congestion control via adjusting senders’ bit rate.— Adjust the sending bit rate of senders which effect the

congestion links to achieve sender-fairness.

2 Packets transmission model in multicast based many-to-many videoconference

• 2.1 Packets transmission model on one path— In one path with r links, Suppose link i drops packets with pro

bability p(i), then the successful probability of packets transmission in the path could be presented with link packet loss rate p(i) as following

(1)

— Linear expression with logarithm

(2)

k

i

ippathp1

))(1()(1

s

i

T xvipivpathp1

))(1log()())(1log(

2.1 Packets transmission model on one path (example)

• The packets transmission model on one path (A,C)

— Its linear expression:

))4(1))(3(1))(1(1(),(1 pppCAp

1

8

A

B

2

7

5

C

3

6

4

)8,7,6,5,4,3,2,1()0,0,0,0,1,1,0,1(),(),( xxxxxxxxxCAvCAy TT

2.2 Packet transmission model on N-to-N multicast based videoconferencing

• The shared multicast tree and shared links.— In many-to-many videoconferencing, all users share one session, t

he router would process their packets by using same strategy and same priority. That is said, all the media data packets from the senders in one multicast session have the same packet loss rate p(i) at link i .

• The transmission model— In N-to-N videoconferencing, there are r= N*(N-1) paths, we coul

d get r linear equation of formula (2).

—Let p(path,k) be the end-to-end PLR of jth path, vector b be a column vector with elements b(k)= log(1-p(path,k)).

—The r equations of form (2) could be expressed as linear equations with matrix G ( r*s ), which is the transmission model:

—G *x = b (3)

2.2 Packet transmission model on N-to-N multicast based videoconferencing (2)

• Gx = b (packets transmission model for N-to-N mulitcast — G:

— Row vector of matrix G corresponding path vector: — G(k,i)＝ 1 means link i on path k (Figure)

— x:— x(i)=log(1-p(i)) for link i

— b(k)— End-to-end PLR (packets loss rate) of one path — b(k)= log(1- p(path,k) )

111

111

111

00110000

00001101

00000011

G

1

8

A

B

2

7

5

C

3

6

4

3 End-to-end packet loss rate measurement and aggregation -- b(k)

• One End-to-end PLR of path(k) measurement

• Aggregate all N*(N-1) PLR to get b—PLR(x,t,ssrc) is one PLR from sender ssrc to receiver x. In a m

ulticast group with N users, each receiver could get N-1 PLR

—We build a performance server to collect and aggregate all r = N*(N-1) PLR from N users to get b

—b(k)= log(1- p(path,k) ) , k =1 ,2 ,3 … , r

)()(

),_(),,(

Ttseqtseq

TreceivedpacketsNumssrctkPLR

ssrcssrc

ssrc

4 Locate congestion link via tomography method (1)

• Judge congestion and locate bottleneck links via tomography method— Congestion judging:

— If end-to-end PLR of path(k): b(k) is larger than one threshold , we could judge congestion occurred on path(k).

— Locate the bottleneck link via tomography method:— We could judge if link i is congested according to x(i) values.— x(i) could be gained via solving G*x= b (packets transmission model) in w

hich G and b have been known or measured beforehand.— We call these method as tomography method.

• Two method to get x(i) while solve G*x=b :— Solve the linear equations of G*x = b directly when rank(G) = r ,— Adopt “Good path” method to simplify G when G is rank deficient (r

ank (G) < s )—

4 Locate congestion link via tomography method (2)

• Good path method— In practice, we find most paths more than 50% paths in Intern

et have no loss or have only very low loss rate, we got it from our experiments.

—We know if the path loss rate is zero, all the link and logical links in the path are zero loss.

— We call this path with zero loss rate as “zero loss path” or “good path”, and we could remove zero loss links from matrix G to get simplified sub-matrix G’, and links number s’ < s until rank(G’) = s’. So we could locate the bottleneck link by solving G’x’ = b’ via “good path” methodology.

4 Locate congestion link via tomography method (3)

• Good path method example:— If PLR(C,D) and PLR(B,A) is zero, then link

8,9,5,2 is good link with zero loss rate and column 8,9,5,2 could be removed from G matrix

— If path(C,A) is congested with PLR(C,A) is larger than threshold ; link 7 could be identified as the bottleneck link

1000001000

1001000010

1001010000

0110000000

0011000010

0011010000

0100100100

0000101100

0000110000

0100000101

0000001101

0000000011

10987654321

DC

DB

DA

CD

CB

CA

BD

BC

BA

AD

AC

AB

100100

110000

110000

000000

010000

010000*

001010

001110

001000

000011

000111

000001

10987654321

DC

DB

DA

CD

CB

CA

BD

BC

BA

AD

AC

AB

1

8

A

B

2

7

5

C

3

6

4

D

9

10

5 Congestion control via adjusting senders’ bit rates

• Determine the senders whose rate should be adjusted — We could determine the congestion paths and corresponding sende

rs related to the bottleneck link from matrix G. — when link i is a bottleneck link, all paths whose row vectors at ith e

lements equal to 1 belongs to the congestion paths related to link i.— We should adjust sending rate of related senders to reduce the traf

fic load on link j to achieve sender-fairness.

• Determine acceptable sending rate and adjust the senders’ bit rates fairly— Calculation the adjusting ratio of sending bit rate.

— ratio = Throughput (e, path))/ Rate(O,sender) :— ratio means the sending rate should be adjusted from origin rate to ac

ceptable rate with ratio percentage of origin rate:

— All the senders who affect the same bottleneck link should be adjusted with the same adjusting ratio to achieve the sender-fairness

6 Simulation and experiments

• Simulation setup— RED queues are used at the routers for

intra-protocol fairness.— PIM-DM is deployed for multicast routing.— UDP data and CBR traffic type is adopted

to simulate videoconferencing

• Simulation process without congestion control— At beginning user A , D and E join the

group and send traffic with primal rate,— After 5 seconds, user B joins the multicast

group and start traffic sending.— After 10 seconds user C joins and start

traffic sending. — After 25 seconds, all users leave the group

and stop sending, simulation ends

1

11

A(0.7Mbps)

B(0.8Mbps)

3

8(1.3Mb)

2

E(0.4Mbps)

7(1.2Mb)

4

12

D(0.7Mbps)

9

10

6

5

K

H

C(0.5Mbps)

6 Simulation and experiments (2)

• Left: Prim congestion with end-to-end packet loss;• Right: Packet loss rate drop to zero via congestion control method

— At 15th seconds, A and B which affect bottleneck link 6 are adjusted from 1.2Mbps and 0.8Mbps to 0.9Mbps and 0.6Mbps with the same ratio 0.75.

— At 18th second, the sending rates of A, B are adjusted to 0.72Mbps and 0.48Mbps, and C, E are both adjusted to 0.375Mbps .

6 Simulation and experiment--Experiment on CERNET-MVC

7 Conclusion

• Congestion control is important for the quality many-to-many videoconferencing based on multicast.

• The congestion link could be located via tomography method, which based on multicast packets transmission model and end-to-end PLR measurement

• By adjusting the senders’ sending bit rate who affect on the bottleneck links, the multicast congestion control on many-to-many videoconferencing could be realized with sender-fairness.

• Simulation and experiments shows the congestion control scheme is valid .

• Thanks!