much ado about nothing - ielrc.orgmuch ado about nothing a critical analysis of the matrimonial...

35
This paper can be downloaded in PDF format from IELRC’s website at http://www.ielrc.org/content/a1609.pdf MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar Yearbook of Law (2016), p. 71-102. International Environmental Law Research Centre International Environmental Law Research Centre [email protected] www.ielrc.org

Upload: others

Post on 29-May-2020

13 views

Category:

Documents


4 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar

This paper can be downloaded in PDF format from IELRC’s website athttp://www.ielrc.org/content/a1609.pdf

MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHINGA CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE

MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA

Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi

Published in: 6 Zanzibar Yearbook of Law (2016), p. 71-102.

International EnvironmentalLaw Research Centre

International Environmental Law Research [email protected]

Page 2: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 3: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar

MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING: A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA

Patricia Kameri-Mbote,. & Muriuki Muriungi,.,.

I. Introduction

II. The Conceptual Bases of Matrimonial Property

A. The Doctrine of Coverture and Its Incidents

B. Communal Vis a Vis Separate Property Holding

III. Matrimonial Property from a Historical Perspective

A. The Problem with Legal Pluralism and Its Implications for Matrimonial Property

B. Law's Solution to the Problem: MWPA

C. Giving with one Hand and Taking with the Other Hand: Jurisprudence on Matrimonial Property before the Constitution of Kenya 2010

IV. The Promise: Constitution of Kenya 2010

A. Equality and Non-Discrimination

B. Protection of Matrimonial Property

C. Ray of Hope: Jurisprudence between 2010 and 2013

V. Encounters between Reality and Rhetoric

A. Matrimonial Property Act (MPA) 201 3

B. Land Laws (Amendment) Act 201 6

C. Jurisprudence on Matrimonial Property Post 201 3

VI. Conclusion

I. Introduction

Kenya's Constitution recognizes the family as the natural and fundamental unit of society which needs the protection of the State.1 Despite this exhortation of the Constitution, issues pertaining to the family continue to

ofo Professor of Law, School of Law, University of Nairobi, Kenya. Contacts: [email protected]

ofoofo Graduate Assistant, School of Law, University of Nairobi, Kenya. Contacts: [email protected]

1 Article 45 of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010.

Page 4: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 5: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 6: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 7: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 8: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 9: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 10: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 11: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 12: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 13: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 14: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 15: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 16: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 17: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 18: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 19: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 20: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 21: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 22: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 23: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 24: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 25: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 26: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 27: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 28: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 29: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 30: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 31: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 32: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 33: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 34: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar
Page 35: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING - IELRC.ORGMUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE MATRIMONIAL PROPERTY IN KENYA Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Muriuki Muriungi Published in: 6 Zanzibar