msc thesis ralph matroos v1.0

8/11/2019 Msc Thesis Ralph Matroos v1.0

1/109

"#$%&'($ )*&$+$

!"#$%& ,#-.* "#%'//$

!"#$%& ()*+, '0&01#%'//$2$%34&5%0%34&-6%05-

-#"./0# 12 7789:87

3*4",#5 ; ?&-6% @5+A&'$+%B /6 )&C*5/-/DB

-#".5 6&%7&*) "#$%&' =56/'1#%+/5 E'C*+%&C%3'&

-"6/&8+9%& ?'0 +'0 E0F0G0 G+44&'$

2*#/ 7HIJ9IHJ79

K1#'% L'+4 1#5#D&1&5% 3$+5D F#A#IM#$&4

N/1.-&O ;A&5% P'/C&$$+5D


2/109

++

:;$/ ./


3/109

+++

)*&$+$

$3M1+%%&4 +5 .#'%+#- 63-6+--1&5% /6

%*& '&Q3+'&1&5%$ 6/' %*& 4&D'&& /6

"EK);, RS KN=;TN;

+5

NR"P@);, KN=;TN;

),ENU =TSR,"E)=RT E,NG=);N)@,;

MB

,#-.* ;1+-& "#%'//$

M/'5 +5 N3'#V#/

K1#'% L'+4 1#5#D&1&5% 3$+5D F#A#IM#$&4

N/1.-&O ;A&5% P'/C&$$+5D

%*& T&%*&'-#54$

III>/I+>#"./,0,

\/D+C#

L&/'D& G+5%]&5W&D [8

9JZ[E^ ,/%%&'4#1> %*& T&%*&'-#54$

III>,%7+4*>4%)


4/109

+A

_)*+$ .#D& +$ +5%&5%+/5#--B -&6% M-#5X`


5/109

A

E3%*/'a ,#-.* ;1+-& "#%'//$

K%34&5% +4a 7789:87

E-%&'5#%& &I1#+-a '#-.*1#%'//$2D1#+-0C/1

!"#$%&'$

=5 %*& .#$% B'$ %*& &-&C%'+C+%B 4&1#54 *#$ '+$&5 # D'% 4-> #54 +% +$ .'&4+C%&4 %*#% %*+$ %'&54 W+-- C/5%+53& +5

%*& B'$ %/ C/1&0 )W/ /6 %*& 1#+5 '$/5$ %*+$ '+$& +5 &-&C%'+C+%B 4&1#54 +$ %#X+5D .-#C& +$ M&C#3$& /6 %*&

D'/W+5D W/'-4 ./.3-#%+/5 #54 %*& +5%'/43C%+/5 /6 ;-&C%'+C b&*+C-&$ _;b`0 )*&'& #'& #-$/ $&A&'#- %B.&$ /6 $1#--

&5&'DB $/3'C&$ M&+5D +5%'/43C&4 _K/-#' .#5&-$ 6/' &O#1.-&` +5 4+66&'&5% .#'%$ /6 %*& &-&C%'+C+%B 5&%W/'X C#3$+5D

&-&C%'+C+%B 5/% %/ M& D&5&'#%&4 #% /5& ./+5% M3% '#%*&' $&A&'#- 4+66&'&5% $/3'C&$ _?+$%'+M3%&4 L&5&'#%+/5`0 T/%

/5-B W+-- %*+$ +5C'$& %*& -/#4 /5 %*& ?3%C* &-&C%'+C+%B D'+4> M3% +% W+-- #-$/ 1#X& %*& &-&C%'+C+%B +5 $3C* #

5&%W/'X 1/'& A/-#%+-&0 )*& ?3%C* &-&C%'+C+%B D'+4 +$ #D&+5D #54 $%34+&$ *#A& $*/W5 %*#% +% C#55/% $3../'% %*&$&

-#%&$% 4&A&-/.1&5%$ #54 63%3'& .'&4+C%+/5$0 )*+$ C#3$&$ # .'/M-&1 $+5C& %*& &-&C%'+C+%B D'+4 W+-- $//5 'C* +%$

1#O+131 ./%&5%+#- +6 4&1#54 X&&.$ '+$+5D #% %*+$ '#%& #54 %*& D'+4 +$5(% 3.4#%&4 /' '&.-#C&40 K+1.-B #44+5D

1/'& &-&C%'+C+%B C#M-&$ #54 M+DD&' %'#5$6/'1&'$ *#$ .'/A&5 354&$+'#M-& 43& %/ C/$%> #54 %*+$ 1$ %*#% $/1&

/%*&' W#B +$ 5&&4&4 %/ 4- W+%* %*+$ .'/M-&10

)/ $/-A& %*& .'&A+/3$-B 4&$C'+M&4 .'/M-&1> # -/% /6 '&$'C* #$ M&&5 4/5& /5 W#B$ %/ +1.'/A& %*& C3''&5% D'+4>

#54 %*& 1/$% .'/1+$+5D 4&A&-/.1&5% +$ %*#% /6 %*& $1#'%ID'+40 @$+5D %*+$ #..'/#C*> %*& D'+4 W+-- $W+%C* 6'/1 #

.#$$+A& %/ # 1/'& #C%+A& 5#%3'&> /5& +5 W*+C* C/1./5&5%$ +5 %*& D'+4 W+-- M& #M-& %/ C/1135+C#%& W+%* /5/%*&'0 )*+$ C/1135+C#%+/5 C#5 6/' &O#1.-& M& +5 %*& 6/'1 /6 $%#%3$ 3.4#%&$ MB /5& C/1./5&5% %/ /5& /'

1/'& /6 %*& /%*&' C/1./5&5%$ +5 %*& D'+4> /' -+$%&5+5D %/ '&Q3&$%$ MB /5& /' 1/'& /6 %*& /%*&' C/1./5&5%$ +5

%*& D'+4 #54 .&'6/'1+5D #C%+/5$ M#$&4 /5 %*/$& '&Q3&$%$0 '&-+#M-& #54 $&C3'&

D'+4> W*+C* +5 %3'5 4+'&C%-B %'#5$-#%&$ +5%/ #5 &O%&54&4 1#O+131 ./%&5%+#- /6 %*& D'+4> 6+5#5C+#- M&5&6+%$ 6/' %*&

&-&C%'+C+%B $3..-+&'$> C/5$31&'$> #54 4&-+A&'B C/1.#5+&$ #54 &5A+'/51&5%#- M&5&6+%$ 6/' %*& &5%+'& $/C+&%B0 E$

$%#%&4 +5 %*& .'&A+/3$ $&5%&5C&> %*&$& M&5&6+%$ C#5 /5-B M& #C*+&A&4 W*&5 3$+5D .'/.&' 1#5#D&1&5% %//-$ %/

1#X& /.%+1#- 3$& /6 %*& D'+4 C/1./5&5%$ 635C%+/5#-+%+&$0 ?3& %/ %*& A#$% $+]& /6 %*& ?3%C* &-&C%'+C+%B D'+4> #54

%*& c$1#'%d C/1./5&5%$ .'/43C+5D 1/'& &A&5%$> # -/% /6 4#%# W+-- M&C/1& #A#+-#M-& 6/' .'/C&$$+5D0 E5B $/'% /6

$1#'%ID'+4 1#5#D&1&5% %//- %*&'&6/'& 13$% *#A& %*& C#.#M+-+%B %/ W/'X W+%* -#'D& #1/35%$ /6 4#%#0 )*/3D*

%*&'& #'& $&A&'#- '355+5D .'/e&C%$ W+%* C* %*&'& /W5 6/'1 /6 1#5#D&1&5% 1&%*/4 #A#+-#M-&> 5/5& /6 %*&1

#'& M#$&4 /5 N/1.-&O ;A&5% P'/C&$$+5D0

P'&A+/3$ '&$'C* *#$ $*/W5 %*#% %*& .'/M-&1$ +5 $1#'% D'+4 C/3-4 +5 6#C% M& $/-A&4 MB 3$+5D C/1.-&O &A&5%

.'/C&$$+5D #54 %*& .'/M-&1 %*+$ '&$'C* #+1$ %/ #5$W&' +$ */W $3C* # $B$%&1 $*/3-4 M& M3+-% #54 W*#% /%*&'

#$.&C%$ $*/3-4 M& #44'&$$&4 +5 /'4&' %/ +1.-&1&5% # N;P $B$%&1 +5 %*& ?3%C* &-&C%'+C+%B D'+40 ;5&O+$> K%&4+5` %/ C/543C%

+5%&'A+&W$0 E6%&' C/--&C%+5D %*& #..'/.'+#%& X5/W-&4D& W& .'/C&&4&4 MB C'%+5D # 4+D+%#- '&.'&$&5%#%+/5

_$+13-#%+/5` /6 # _6+C%+/5#-` &-&C%'+C+%B D'+4 %/ 1+1+C #-- %*& &A&5%$ %*& $1#'%ID'+4 W/3-4 .#$$ /5 %/ %*& N;PI

&5D+5&0 )*& $&C/54 $%&. W#$ %/ C/5C-34& W+%* %*& &O.&'%$ +5 %*& 6+&-4 W*+C* '3-&$ W&'& %*& 1/$% +1./'%#5% %/

X&&. #5 &-&C%'+C+%B D'+4 '355+5D +5 .'#C%+C& #54 %*&$& '3-&$ W&'& %*&5 +1.-&1&5%&4 +5 %*& N;PI&5D+5&0 )*&

K1#'% L'+4 1#5#D&1&5% 3$+5D F#A#IM#$&4

N/1.-&O ;A&5% P'/C&$$+5D


6/109

A+

'&$3-% /6 %*& .'/e&C% W#$ # 4&1/ #..-+C#%+/5> W*+C* 3$&4 %*& $+13-#%+/5 1/4&- #54 4&6+5&4 '3-&$ %/ $*/W */W

$3C* # $B$%&1 W/3-4 .&'6/'1 +5 '- -+6& $+%3#%+/5$0

)*/3D* %*+$ '&$'C* W#$ #5 &O.-/'#%/'B /5&> # A&'B C-' /A&'A+&W +$ .'&$&5%&4 #M/3% 3$+5D N;P +5 %*& 3%+-+%+&$

$&C%/' #54 $&A&'#- '&$3-%$ W*&'& #C*+&A&4 43'+5D %*& C/3'$& /6 %*+$ '&$'C*0 )*&'& W#$ # -/% /6 +56/'1#%+/5

#A#+-#M-& /5 $1#'% D'+4$ #54 /5 N/1.-&O ;A&5% P'/C&$$+5D $&.#'#%&-B> M3% %*+$ '&$'C* C/1M+5&4 %*& %W/ #54.'/A+4&$ +5$+D*% /5 W*#% $%&.$ 5&&4 %/ M& %#X&5 %/ #C%3#--B $%#'% 3$+5D N;P +5 %*& ?3%C* &-&C%'+C+%B D'+40 T&O% %/

C/1M+5+5D N;P #54 K1#'% L'+4> $&A&'#- #A#+-#M-& N;P $3+%&$ W&'& C/1.#'&4 #54 '&C/11&54#%+/5$ /6 W*+C*

%//- %/ 3$& W&'& 1#4&0 S3'%*&'1/'&> #5 #'C*+%&C%3'& /6 $3C* # N;P $B$%&1 W#$ C'%&4 3$+5D %*& .'+5C+.-&$ /6

;A&5%I?'+A&5 KRE0 )*& C&5%'#- Q3&$%+/5 43'+5D %*+$ '&$'C* W#$ */W N;P C/3-4 M& &1.-/B&4 +5 %*& $1#'% D'+4

5&%W/'X$ #54 W& *#A& #CC/1.-+$*&4 e3$% %*#%0 @$+5D %*& +5.3% /6 &O.&'%$ +5 %*& 6+&-4> %*'&& 1#+5 $1#'% D'+4

C*#--&5D&$ W&'& 4&6+5&4 #CC/'4+5D %/ .'+/'+%B> #54 +1.-&1&5%&4 3$+5D N;P %&C*5/-/DB0 )/ 1+1+C # $1#'% D'+4

5&%W/'X 6/' %*& N;P &5D+5&> # $1#'% $+13-#%+/5 D'+4 W#$ #-$/ 4&$+D5&4 #54 +1.-&1&5%&40

=% 13$% M& 1&5%+/5&4 */W&A&' %*#% N;P '&-+&$ /5 #5 &A&5% C-/34 M&+5D D&5&'#%&4 _&A&5% $/3'C&` #54 %*&

C/1./5&5%$ +5 %*& D'+4 M&+5D #M-& %/ '&C&+A& 1&$$#D&$ #54 '&1/%&-B C/5%'/--&4 _$3M$C'+M&'$ $*/3-4 M& #M-& %/

*#54-& +5C/1+5D #C%+/5$ #54 1&$$#D&$`0 M3% +%($ %'3& ./W&' -+&$

+5 %*& 6#C% %*#% %*& #5#-B$+$ C#5 63--B #3%/1#%& %*& .'/C&$$ W*+C* +5 %3'5 '&$3-%$ +5 Q3+CX&' /A&'#-- 'C%+/5

%+1&$0 ?3& %/ %*& -#CX /6 $+1+-#' $B$%&1$ _$1#'% D'+4 1#5#D&1&5%`> %+1& C/5$%'#+5%$> #54 #+1 /6 %*+$ '&$'C*

*/W&A&'> +% *#$ 5/% M&&5 ./$$+M-& %/ %&$% %*& .&'6/'1#5C& /6 %*& 4&$+D5&4 $B$%&10

U&BW/'4$a N/1.-&O ;A&5% P'/C&$$+5D> ;?E> KRE> ;?KRE> K1#'% D'+4

)%&*+&$,-. /-00,$$112

P'/60 4'0 +'0 L0F0P0"0 G/3M&5> S3-- .'/60> ;;"NK> )@ ?&-6%

?'0+'0 E0F0G0 G+44&'$> E$$+$%0 .'/60> ;;"NK> )@ ?&-6%

?'0+'0 "0S0 E$$/C0 .'/60> )P"> )@ ?&-6%

='0 ;0 ;$$&5+3$> \/D+C#> L&/'D& G+5%]&5W&D [8> ,/%%&'4#1


7/109

A++

3%14&'1

)*+$ 4/C31&5% +$ %*& '&$3-% /6 # 1#$%&' %*&$+$ .'/e&C% C/543C%&4 #% M3$+5&$$ #54 %&C*5/-/DB $&'A+C& C/1.#5B

\/D+C# +5 ,/%%&'4#10 =% +$ %*& 6+5#- .#'% /6 %*& 1#$%&' .'/D'#1 =56/'1#%+/5 E'C*+%&C%3'& #% %*& @5+A&'$+%B /6

)&C*5/-/DB ?&-6% _)@ ?&-6%`> #54 C/A&'$ #-- %*& X5/W-&4D& #54 '&$3-%$ /6 %*& .'/e&C% +5 4&%#+-0 )*+$ '&$'C* D#A&

1& 1#5B 5&W +5$+D*%$ %*& &5&'DB $&C%/' #54 '&-#%&4 M3$+5&$$ 4/1#+5$> # 6+&-4 = *#4 A&'B -+%%-& X5/W-&4D& #M/3%W*&5 &1M#'X+5D 3./50

)*/3D* %*+$ '&$'C* W#$ C/543C%&4 /5 1B /W5> = C/3-45(% *#A& 4/5& +% W+%*/3% %*& *&-. /6 ;4W+5 ;$$&5+3$> 1B

4+'&C% $3.&'A+$/' #% \/D+C#> #54 f&'% 4& T&&6> .'/e&C% 1#5#D&' #% #54 1B 4+'&C% $3.&'A+$/' #% %*& @5+A&'$+%B> F#5 G+44&'$> W*/1 #-- *&-.&4 +5 X&&.+5D 1&

/5 %*& '+D*% %'#CX 43'+5D %*& '&$'C*0 E $.&C+#- %*#5X$ #-$/ D/&$ /3% %/ C/5$3-%#5% #% \/D+C#> 6/'

.'/A+4+5D 1& W+%* %*& 13C*I5&&4&4 C/5%#C%$ +5 %*& 3%+-+%+&$ 6+&-40 = W/3-4 #-$/ -+X& %/ %*#5X "#'%+e5 f/5D#&'%$

_E--+#54&'`> ?#55B L&-4%1&+e&' #54 F/'+$ U5+DD& _;5&O+$`> #54 =5D&


8/109

A+++

_)*+$ .#D& +$ +5%&5%+/5#--B -&6% M-#5X`


9/109

+O

/-.$1.$#

/5!3678 92 :;68/6:K L%I/&M*#4$+07 4+#5 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> KN

J>J>E O*4*#+%0 6*&D P&%09Q/&7/0 RS"#6$/0T >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> KGJ>J>J ;$/ U%9 !07/,/9 L%I/& V&+. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> KG

J>J>W P%",./& 4+#5 A%,%&*.% RXA(U (0/&75T >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> KY

J>J>H Z/,*#/. I%&D 4%04,"9+%0 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> EF

/5!3678 G2 7H7;6 38E>K -+)6,/ (8/0# L&%4/99+07 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> EJ

W>E>E -#&/*) (8/0# L&%4/99+07 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> EJ

W>E>J A%)6,/= (8/0# L&%4/99+07 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> EJ

Y09K=)@E)=RT EH>K !8*+,*Q,/ A(L -"+#/9 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> EN

W>H>E (96/& >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> JF

/5!3678 F2 CBC67E !8/5:67/6>87 ????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? DD

h07E,NG=);N)@,;000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 99

h0H;T);,P,=K; E,NG=);N)@,;00000000000000000000000000000000000000000 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 99

h09E,NG=);N)@,; )iP;K0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 9h

H>J>K P"9+0/99 *&4$+#/4#"&/ >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> JH

H>J>E 10


10/109

O

h0YK;,b=N; R,=;T);? E,NG=);N)@,;0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 9Z

h0h;T);,P,=K; K;,b=N; f@K00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 9[

h0Z;b;T) ?,=b;T E,NG=);N)@,;00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000000000000000000000 98

H>\>K (8/0# 2&+8/0 !&4$+#/4#"&/ ./>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> JY

H>\>E (8/0# 2&+8/0 -]! >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> WF

h0:E,NG=);N)@,; SR, ?;b;\RP;? KiK);"000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 Y7,!-. 57 ???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? GD

/5!3678 I2 7H7;6 )7;78!6E>K -)* )/#/&9 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> WH

\>E>E 2+9#&+Q"#+%0 #&*09>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> WN

\>E>J A%)Q+0/. ^/*# *0. L%I/& 7/0/&*#%&9 RA^LT >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> WN

\>E>W -%,*& 6*0/,9 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> WG

\>E>H (0/&75 9#%&*7/ >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> WY

\>E>\ _+0. #"&Q+0/9 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> HF

Z09K"E,) L,=? NR"PRT;T) ?;K=LT00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 h7

\>J>K (,/4#&+4+#5 4*Q,/9 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> HK

\>J>E -)* )/#/&9 R-)* $%"9/9T >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> HJ

\>J>J 2+9#&+Q"#+%0 #&*09>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> HW

\>J>W A%)Q+0/. ^/*# *0. L%I/& 7/0/&*#%&9 RA^LT >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> HH

\>J>H -%,*& 6*0/,9 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> HH

\>J>\ _+0. #"&Q+0/9 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> HH

\>J>N (,/4#&+4+#5 9#%&*7/ Q*##/&+/9 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> HH

\>J>G A%)6%0/0# +./0#+>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> H\

,!-. ?0 2(, (74>7( 8(@>47 !78 8(A5 (=!;6!.>57????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? FJ

/5!3678 J2 E!:; /73K7;):;7 /5!AA7;)7C ???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? FL

:07N@,,;T) L,=? b;,K@K S@)@,; L,=?00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 000000000000000000000000000 h8

:0H\RE? fE\ETN=TL000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 h8

:09R@)EL; ?;);N)=RT00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 ZJ

:0YNRTL;K)=RT "ETEL;";T)000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 ZH

/5!3678 L2 /73 7;):;7 !;= =7E< ???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? IG

[07?;"R K;)@P ET? LRE\000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 ZY

G>K>K -4/0*&+% `K R-"0B a%0/b _+0.B a%0/b ;/)6/&*#"&/B A%,.T >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> \W

G>K>E -4/0*&+% `E R-"0B !8/&*7/b _+0.B ^+7$b ;/)6/&*#"&/B M+,.T >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> \H

G>K>J -4/0*&+% `J R-"0B ^+7$b _+0. B ^+7$b ;/)6/&*#"&/B M+,.C^%#T >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> \H

G>K>W ;/9# 9/#"6>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> \H

[0H);K) ,;K@\)K00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 Zh

[09KiK);" ="P\;";T)E)=RT000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 ZZ

[0YL,EPG=NE\ @K;, =T);,SEN;0000000000000000000000000000000000000000 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 Z[

/5!3678 M2 !8/5:67/6>87 !;= =7E< 7H!A>!6:>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> NWY>E>E A(L /07+0/ /8*,"*#+%0 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> NW


11/109

O+

Y>E>J A(L /07+0/ /8*,"*#+%0 4%04,"9+%0 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> NN

80957@D 2572;6@>57@ !78 E6.6-( :5-3??????????????????????????????????????????????????? JM

/5!3678 9N2 C>EE!8B !;= /C:87 QK 3"#"&/ I%&D +0 0*#+%0*, 7&+. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> GW

KK>E>E 3"#"&/ I%&D I+#$+0 ./9+70/. 959#/) >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> GW

KK>E>J V/0/&*, >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> GH

A:C6

87C ??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? LI

A:C6


12/109

7

_)*+$ .#D& +$ +5%&5%+/5#--B -&6% M-#5X`


13/109

H

/T&U$1% 92 :.$%-*+'$,-.)*+$ 1#$%&' %*&$+$ '&$'C*&$ %*& ./$$+M+-+%+&$ /6 C/1.-&O &A&5% .'/C&$$+5D _N;P` +5 _$1#'%` &-&C%'+C+%B D'+4$0 E$

%*& .'+C&$ /6 $&5$/' #54 C/1135+C#%+/5 %&C*5/-/DB #'& 4'/..+5D> +% +$ M&C/1+5D 1/'& #54 1/'& +5%&'&$%+5D

#54 &C/5/1+C#--B 6$+M-& %/ &1.-/B %*&$& %&C*5+Q3&$ +5 4+66&'&5% $&%%+5D$0 R5& .#'%+C3-#' $&%%+5D W*&'& %*&'&

+$ # -/% %/ M& D#+5&4 +$ %*#% /6 &-&C%'+C+%B D'+4 1#5#D&1&5%0 =% +$ M&-+&A&4 %*#% +1.-&1&5%#%+/5 /6 $&5$/'$>

#CC/1.#5+&4 MB # C/5%'/- $B$%&1> W/3-4 '&$3-% +5 #5 /A&'#-- Q3+CX&' 'C%+/5 %+1& %/ &A&5%$ D&5&'#%&4 MB %*&

D'+40 )*+$ W/3-4 - %/ +5C'$&4 &66+C+&5CB +5 %*& D'+4$ $+5C& 6/' &O#1.-&> $#6&%B %*'&$*/-4$ C#5 M& 1+5+1+]&4

W+%*/3% ./$+5D #5 #C%3#- %*'% %/ %*& $B$%&10

)*+$ C*#.%&' $%#'%$ W+%* #5 +5%'/43C%+/5 +5 W*+C* %*& '&-&A#5C& /6 %*& $3Me&C% +$ $%#%&40 K&A&'#- 4&A&-/.1&5%$ +5

%*& &-&C%'+C+%B $&C%/' #'& 4+$C3$$&4 #54 C/5C-34&4 3./50 )*& '&$% /6 %*+$ C*#.%&' C/A&'$ %*& '&$'C* Q3&$%+/5$

4&6+5&4> %*& $C/.& /6 %*& '&$'C* #$$+D51&5%> %*& '&$'C* 1&%*/4 #54 %*& 4&-+A&'#M-&$0 )*& &54 /6 %*+$

C*#.%&' D+A&$ # $*/'% /3%-+5& /6 %*& '&1#+54&' /6 %*+$ 4/C31&5%0

!"! $%&'()* +),-%./0.&1;-&C%'+C#- ./W&' $B$%&1$ /6 +543$%'+#-+]&4 &C/5/1+&$> $3C* #$ %*& T&%*&'-#54$> *#A& M&C/1& /5& /6 %*& 1/$%

C/1.-&O $B$%&1$ &A&' C'%&4 MB 1#5X+54 /A&' %*& C/3'$& /6 %*& HJ%*

C&5%3'B0 #54 *#$ C#3$&4 W/'-4W+4& &-&C%'+C+%B 3$& %/ D'/W %'&1&54/3$-B

(J.Kok, 2010)0 )*& ;5&'DB =56/'1#%+/5 E41+5+$%'#%+/5 _;=E` .'&4+C%$ %*#% W/'-4W+4& &-&C%'+C ./W&' D&5&'#%+/5

W+-- D'/W H0Yj # B' M&%W&&5 HJJY #54 HJ9J0 )/ D+A& # M&%%&' A+&W /6 %*&$& 6#C%$ = .'&$&5% B/3 W+%* %*& %#M-&

M&-/W _%#M-& 7`0

6&"V1 92 7V1'$%,',$W X%-Y$T 1#$,0&$1# (Jesse Berst, 2008)

,&$'C* *#$ $*/W5 %*#% %*& M+DD&$% 4'+A+5D 6/'C&$ M&*+54 %*+$ D'/W%* /6 &-&C%'+C+%B 4&1#54 #'& %*& 6/--/W+5D

(Jesse Berst, 2008)a

70 )*& '#.+4 &O.#5$+/5 /6 W/'-4 ./.3-#%+/5 k L'/W%* +5 %*& 531M&' /6 .&/.-& 5&&4+5D &-&C%'+C+%B

H0 ;-&C%'+6+C#%+/5 /6 &A&'B%*+5D k L'/W%* +5 %*& 531M&' /6 4&A+C&$ %*#% '&Q3+'& &-&C%'+C+%B0

90 ;O.&C%#%+/5 +56-#%+/5 k L'/W%* +5 %*& $&5$& /6 &5%+%-&1&5% %*#% %3'5$ &-&C%'+C#- C/5A&5+&5C&$ +5%/

&$$&5%+#-$ 4&1#54&4 MB #--0

=5 #44+%+/5 %/ %*& D'/W+5D &5&'DB 4&1#54 %*&'& #'& #-$/ # 531M&' /6 /5D/+5D C*#5D&$ +5 %*& &-&C%'+C+%B $B$%&1

%*#% #'& 6/'C+5D # C*#5D& +5 +56'#$%'3C%3'& 1#5#D&1&5%0 S/' &O#1.-& %*& $*+6% %/ '&5&W#M-& &5&'DB $/3'C&$

1$ %*#% W%*&' W+-- *#A& # *+D*&' +1.#C% /5 D&5&'#%+/5 #54 %*3$ C#3$& 6-3C%3#%+/5$0 )*+$ $*+6% %/

'&5&W#M-& &5&'DB $/3'C&$> #-/5D W+%* %*& +5%'/43C%+/5 /6 NGP D&5&'#%/'$> C#3$&$ # .*&5/1&5/5 /%*&'W+$&

X5/W5 #$ ?+$%'+M3%&4 L&5&'#%+/5 _?L`0 ?+$%'+M3%&4 L&5&'#%+/5 C#3$&$ %*& D&5&'#%+/5 C#.#C+%B +5 %*& 1&4+31

#54 -/W A/-%#D& 5&%W/'X$ %/ '+$& _$+5C& &5&'DB +$ 5/ -/5D&' e3$% D&5&'#%&4 #% ./W&' .-#5%$` (J.Kok, 2010)0

230)4&%5 !678 9888 9878:;,0.*30),(30.&1 H0hZ f+--+/5 Z0HH f+--+/5 [0H8 f+--+/5

;()-0%.-.05 >,34) H0JZ)< 90[J)< Z088)Yj Hh>9j 99>:j

A)()B.,.&1, J0Z f+--+/5 70Y f+--+/5 708 f+--+/5

$)%,&13( -&*/>0)%, J hJJ "+--+/5 %/ 7 f+--+/5 Z f+--+/5 %/ [ f+--+/5

2)(( /C&1), J J0[ f+--+/5 h f+--+/5

;()-0%.- C5'%.+

B)C.-(),

J hh>[hH 9>7h7>Y98


14/109

9

E5/%*&' 4&A&-/.1&5% %*#% *#$ M&&5 D#+5+5D # -/% /6 #%%&5%+/5 '&C&5%-B +$ %*#% /6 &-&C%'+C C#'$ W*+C* #-$/ .-3D

+5%/ %*& D'+4 %/ '&C*#'D& %*&+' M#%%&'+&$0 )*& .'&4+C%+/5 +$ %*#% HJj /6 #-- C#'$ +5 %*& T&%*&'-#54$ W+-- M& &-&C%'+C

/5&$ MB %*& B' HJHJ0 )*+$ #-$/ 6/'1$ # .'/M-&1 +5 &-&C%'+C+%B D'+4 1#5#D&1&5% M&C#3$& 1/$% /6 %*&$& C#'$

W+-- M& '&C*#'D&4 43'+5D . */3'$ _M&6/'& #54 #6%&' /66+C& */3'$`0

)*& +5C'$& /6 &-&C%'+C+%B 4&1#54 #-/5D W+%* 4+$%'+M3%&4 D&5&'#%+/5 #54 %*& +5%'/43C%+/5 /6 &-&C%'+C C#'$ ./$&

# $&'+/3$ %*'% /5 %*& #D+5D ./W&' D'+4 $%+-- W+4&-B 3$&4 %/4#B0 R5 %/. /6 &A&'B%*+5D .'&A+/3$-B 1&5%+/5&4>

%*&'& +$ 5/ W#B /6 4+'&C%+5D %*& 6-/W %/ 6/--/W # $.&C+6+&4 .#%*0 /5& $.&C+6+C $&C%+/5 W/3-4 5/% $366+C&(J.Kok, 2010)0

P,X+%1 92 3-Y1% V--U 4V-Y 1Z&0UV1 (J.Kok, 2010)

)*& .'/M-&1$ 1&5%+/5&4 #M/A& _L'/W%* /6 &-&C%'+C+%B 4&1#54> ?+$%'+M3%&4 D&5&'#%+/5> ,+$& /6 %*& &-&C%'+C

C#'$`> #-/5D W+%* %*& 6#C% %*#% %*& D'+4 +% /.&'#%&$ /5 +$ #D&+5D> 1#X& +% 5&C&$$#'B %/ -//X #% 5&W W#B$ /6 D&%%+5D

%*& 1#O+131 /3% /6 %*& &-&C%'+C+%B D'+4 #54 X&&.+5D +% #-- +5 M#-#5C&0 )*& 6+'$% %*+5D %*#% C/1&$ %/ 1+54 W*&5

%*+5X+5D /6 $/-3%+/5$ 6/' %*& .'/M-&1 /6 D'/W+5D &5&'DB 4&1#54 #54 D&5&'#%+/5 +$ .'/M#M-B %*& 6/--/W+5D0 '&43C+5D &1+$$+/5$ #54 +5C'$+5D $#6&%B MB '&43C+5D %*&

C*#5C& /6 +5e3'+&$ /' &A&5 -/$$ /6 -+6& (K.Dodrill, 2010)0 E-- /6 %*&$& M&5&6+%$ C#5 /5-B M& #C*+&A&4 W*&5 1#X+5D

/.%+1#- 3$& /6 %*& $1#'% D'+4($ C#.#M+-+%+&$0 i/D&$* K+11*#5 &% #-0 $%#%& %*& 6/--/W+5D +5 %*&+' '&$'C*

(Y.Simmhan, 2011)a

:L%I/& "#+,+#+/9 *&/ +04&/*9+07,5 &%,,+07 %"# :9)*? 7&+.9 I+#$ #$/ *Q+,+#5 #% #&*4D 4%09")/& 6%I/& "9*7/ +0 0/*&

&/*,@#+)/ "9+07 9)* )/#/&9 #$*# /0*Q,/ Q+@.+&/4#+%0*, 4%))"0+4*#+%0> %I/8/& #$/ #&"/ 8*,"/ %< 9)* 7&+.9 +9

"0,%4D/. %0,5 I$/0 #$/ 8/&+#*Q,/ /=6,%9+%0 %< .*#* #$*# I+,, Q/4%)/ *8*+,*Q,/ +9 +07/9#/.b 6&%4/99/.b *0*,5c/.

*0. #&*09,*#/. +0#% )/*0+07


15/109

Y

&A&5% +5%&'.'&%&'$> &A&5% .#%%&'5 4&6+5+%+/5 #54 1#%C*+5D #-/5D W+%* C/''&-#%+/5 %&C*5+Q3&$> #54 M&+5D #M-& %/

4/ +% +5 '-I%+1&0

/5-B %*& .#'% /6 &-&C%'+C+%B C/5%'/- W+-- M& #44'&$$&4 +5 4&%#+-0 )*& .#'%$ /6 .3'C*#$&

#54 $#-& #'& +5C-34&4 +5 %*& 1#+5 Q3&$%+/5 %/ $%'&$$ %*&+' +1./'%#5C&> #54 W+-- M& C/A&'&4 -+D*%-B +5 %*&/'B0

=5 /'4&' %/ #5$W&' %*& 1#+5 Q3&$%+/5> 5&O% %/ %*& 4&A&-/.1&5% /6 %*& &5D+5& +%$&-6> %*& 6/--/W+5D $3MIQ3&$%+/5$

_Kg` #'& 4&6+5&4a

-dK> _$5 *&/ #$/ 4"&&/0# *7/+07 /,/4#&+4+#5 7&+.9 0%# *Q,/ #% 9"66% #$/ _$*# +9 *0 *66&%6&+*#/ *66,+4*#+%0 ./9+70 #% #/9# +< A(L 4*0 9"66% #$/ #&*09+#+%0 #% 9)*@

7&+. +0 #$/ 2"#4$ /,/4#&+4+#5 9/4#%& %0 #$/ +)6,/)/0#*#+%0 ,/8/,e

E$ 1&5%+/5&4> %*& '&-&A#5C& /6 %*& '&$'C* %/.+C W#$ #-'B #44'&$$&4 +5 %*& +5%'/43C%+/5 /6 %*+$ 4/C31&5%

_N*#.%&' 707` #54 %#CX-&$ $3M Q3&$%+/5 70 N*#.%&'$ H #54 9 #'& 3$&4 %/ #5$W&' %*& $&C/54 $3M Q3&$%+/50

N*#.%&' Y +$ 3$&4 %/ &-#M/'#%& /5 N;P +5 D&5&'#- #54 #-$/ $%#%& %*& '&-&A#5C& /6 N;P +5 $1#'% D'+4 _$3M Q3&$%+/5

9`0 N*#.%&' h +$ 4&4+C#%&4 %/ D&%%+5D %*& 5&C&$$#'B X5/W-&4D& #M/3% #'C*+%&C%3'&$ #54 C'%+5D /5& _$3MQ3&$%+/5 Y` #54 C*#.%&'$ Z %*'/3D* [ #'& 4&4+C#%&4 %/ #5$W&'+5D $3M Q3&$%+/5 h #54 Z0 )*& '&$3-% /6 %*&$&


16/109

h

Q3&$%+/5$ W+-- M& 3$&4 +5 %*& 6+5#- %*'&& C*#.%&'$ _N*#.%&' 8> 7J> #54 77` %/ #5$W&' #54 C/5C-34& /5 %*& 1#+5

'&$'C* Q3&$%+/50


17/109

Z

!"F G)1)%3( .1@&%*30.&1

)*+$ .'/e&C% W#$ C/543C%&4 #% %*& D'#43#%& 4&.#'%1&5% /6 \/D+C# ,/%%&'4#1 C#--&4 .3'C*#$& #54 $#-&> /5-B C/5%'/- W+-- M& #44'&$$&4 +5 %*+$ '&$'C* #54 W+-- M&

&-#M/'#%&4 3./5 MB 4&A&-/.+5D # $1#-- 4&1/ N;P #..-+C#%+/50

)*& 6/C3$ /6 %*& '&$'C* W+-- M& /5 %*& 4+$%'+M3%+/5 $&C%+/5 /6 %*& ?3%C* &-&C%'+C+%B D'+4l %*+$ +5C-34&$

%*& "&4+31 b/-%#D& _"b` #54 %*& \/W b/-%#D& _\b` .#'% /6 %*& D'+40

)*& 4&1/ %*#% W+-- M& 4&$+D5&4 +5 %*+$ .'/e&C% W+-- M& M#$&4 /5 %*& 6+C%+/5#- D'+4 4&6+5&4 +5 C*#.%&' Z0

)*& &A&5%$ #54 '3-&$ 3$&4 +5 %*& .'/e&C% W+-- #-$/ '&$3-% 6'/1 %*+$ _6+C%+/5#-` D'+40

!"7 D),)3%-C *)0C&+

E% %*& ./+5% /6 $%#'%+5D %*+$ '&$'C* %*&'& W#$ -+%%-& %/ 5/ +56/'1#%+/5 #A#+-#M-& /5 %*& $3Me&C% #% *#540 )*&'&

W#$ # -/% /6 -+%&'#%3'& #A#+-#M-& #M/3% $1#'% D'+4$ #54 $&.#'#%&-B #-$/ #M/3% N/1.-&O ;A&5% P'/C&$$+5D> M3%

5/%*+5D #M/3% %*& %W/ $3Me&C%$ C/1M+5&40 =% +$ 6/' %*+$ '$/5 %*#% %*& 1#+5 #..'/#C* %#X&5 6/' %*+$ '&$'C* +$

#5 &O.-/'#%/'B /5&0

(=6,%&*#%&5 &/9/*&4$+$ /6%&5 C/543C%&4 M&C#3$& %*& '&$'C* .'/M-&1 *#$ 5/% M&&5 C-'-B 4&6+5&4 B&%> /' +%$

'- $C/.& +$ #$ B&% 35C-'> W*+C* +$ &O#C%-B %*& C#$& *&'& #$ %*+$ '&$'C* +$ #-$/ 3$&4 %/ 6#1+-+#'+]& W+%* %*&

$3Me&C%0 )*& '&$3-%$ /6 &O.-/'#%/'B '&$'C* #'& 5/% 3$3#--B 3$&63- 6/' 4&C+$+/5I1#X+5D MB %*&1$&-A&$> M3% %*&B

C#5 .'/A+4& $+D5+6+C#5% +5$+D*% +5%/ # D+A&5 $+%3#%+/5> #$ %*+$ '&$'C* #+1$ %/ 4/ +5 %*& 6+&-4 /6 N/1.-&O ;A&5%

P'/C&$$+5D +5 $1#'% D'+4 5&%W/'X$0

E$ C#5 M& $&&5 +5 $&C%+/5 70H> '&$'C* Q3&$%+/5$ *#A& M&&5 4&6+5&4 #54 $*#'.&5&4 %*'/3D*/3% %*& 43'#%+/5 /6

%*+$ '&$'C*0 )*& D#%*&'+5D /6 +56/'1#%+/5 W+-- *#..&5 /5 M/%* .'+1#'B _D#%*&'+5D 5&W +56/'1#%+/5 MB

+5%&'A+&W$` #54 $&C/54#'B -&A&-$ _-+%&'#%3'& '&$'C*`0 )*& '&$'C* #-$/ +5C-34&$ # .#'% /6 %*& f"*,+#*#+8/

&/9/*&4$ 1&%*/4 $+5C& #$ #-'B 1&5%+/5&4 +5 %*& .'&A+/3$ $&5%&5C&l /5& /6 %*& Q3#-+%#%+A& '&$'C*

%&C*5+Q3&$ 3$&4 +5 %*+$ %*&$+$ +$ %*& +5%&'A+&W0 =5%&'A+&W$ C#5 #-$/ M& .#'% /6 %*& Q3#5%+%#%+A& '&$'C* 1&%*/4>

M3% %*& 1#+5 4+66&'&5C& *&'& +$ %*& 4&.%* /6 %*& +5%&'A+&W0 E$ %*& +5%&'A+&W$ C/543C%&4 43'+5D %*+$ '&$'C*

.'/e&C% W&'& '&-#%+A&-B 35$%'3C%3'&4 #54 +5 4&.%*> %*&B %#X& 1/'& /6 # Q3#-+%#%+A& 6/'1 +5 %*+$ '&$'C*0 \#$%>


18/109

:

M3% 1/$% C&'%#+5-B 5/% -$%> %*+$ '&$'C* #-$/ 4&-+A&'$ # L&%%< ]< A%04/6# RL]AT+5 %*& 6/'1 /6 # N;P &5D+5&

4&1/ %/ .'/A& +%$ 6$+M+-+%B0

@$+5D %*& D#%*&'&4 +56/'1#%+/5 #54 %*& '&$'C* Q3&$%+/5$ 4&6+5&4 #5 +5+%+#- $&%3. /6 # $3+%#M-& $+13-#%+/5

1/4&- W+-- M& 1#4&0 )*+$ 1/4&- W+-- M& A&'+6+&4 MB h &O.&'%$ +5 %*& 6+&-4 #54 #4e3$%&4 #CC/'4+5D-B0 )*& 5&O% $%&.

W+-- M& %*#% /6 +4&5%+6B+5D %*& 1/$% +1./'%#5% C*#--&5D&$ /6 &-&C%'+C+%B D'+4 1#5#D&1&5% #54 %*& D&5&'#%+/5 /6

'3-&$ 6/' %*& N;PI&5D+5&0


19/109

[

!"J K)(.B)%3'(),

E% %*& &54 /6 %*& .'/e&C% # C/5C-3$+/5 C#5 M& 1#4& #M/3% %*& #C%3#- 3$#M+-+%B /6 %*& N;P $B$%&1 6/' 3$& +5 %*&

&-&C%'+C+%B $&C%/'0 E$ 1&5%+/5&4 +5 $&C%+/5 709> %*+$ +56/'1#%+/5 C/3-4 D+A& \/D+C# #5 +4 /5 W*&%*&' %/ +5A&$%

+5 %*+$ %&C*5/-/DB /' 5/%0

)/ $31 +% 3. %*& 6/--/W+5D $*/3-4 M& %*& '&$3-% /6 %*& %*&$+$ .'/e&C%a

)*&$+$ '&./'% _%*+$ 4/C31&5%` 6/' %*& ?&-6% @5+A&'$+%B /6 )&C*5/-/DB #54 \/D+C# _


20/109

8

P,X+%1 @2 3%-[1'$ %-&*0&U


21/109

7J

!"L D)/&%0 &>0(.1)

)*+$ $&C%+/5 D+A&$ # $*/'% 4&$C'+.%+/5 /6 C* C*#.%&'0 )*+$ '&./'% W+-- '/3D*-B 6/--/W %*& $%'3C%3'& 4&.+C%&4 +5

6+D3'& H0

/T&U$1% 9+5%'/43C&$ %*& $3Me&C% MB $%#%+5D +%$ +1./'%#5C& %/ /3' $/C+&%B #54 #-$/ $%#%&$ %*& 1#+5 Q3&$%+/5 #54

$3M Q3&$%+/5$> W*+C* %*+$ '&$'C* W+-- #%%&1.% %/ #5$W&'0

/T&U$1% @ +$ 3$&4 %/ &-#M/'#%& /5 %*& ?3%C* &-&C%'+C+%B $&C%/' +5 D&5&'#-> %*& &5&'DB %'#4+5D 1#'X&%>

)'#5$1+$$+/5 KB$%&1 R.&'#%/'> ?+$%'+M3%+/5 KB$%&1 R.&'#%/' #54 %*& 4&6+5+%+/5 /6 $1#'% D'+40 =5 %*& 6+5#- .#'%

/6 %*+$ C*#.%&'> $/1& .+-/% .'/e&C%$ +5 %*& $1#'% D'+4 $&C%/' #'& D+A&50

=5 'T&U$1% D%*& 6/C3$ +$ .3% /5 $1#'% D'+4 5&%W/'X$0 )*& C*#.%&' +$ 3$&4 %/ &-#M/'#%& /5 %*& 4&6+5+%+/5 /6 #

$1#'% D'+4 #54 +%$ ./%&5%+#- M&5&6+%$ #54 1#+5 4'#WM#CX$0

/T&U$1% G+$ #-- #M/3% &A&5% .'/C&$$+5D0 T/W %*#% W& X5/W #-- W& *#A& %/ X5/W #M/3% %*& ?3%C* &-&C%'+C+%B D'+4>

%*& 6/3'%* C*#.%&' +5%'/43C&$ %*& C/5C&.% /6 N/1.-&O ;A&5% P'/C&$$+5D0 )*+$ +$ %*& 1#+5 %&C*5+Q3& %*&

'&$'C* +$ M#$&4 3./50 ?+66&'&5% N;P .-#%6/'1$ #'& #-$/ #5#-B]&4 +5 %*+$ $&C%+/5 #54 # C/5C-3$+/5 +$ 1#4& /5

W*+C* .-#%6/'1 %/ 3$&0

/T&U$1% F=$ 3$&4 %/ C/A&' %*& #'C*+%&C%3'#- #$.&C% /6 %*+$ '&$'C*0 )*& C*#.%&' $%#'%$ W+%* %*& 4&6+5+%+/5 #54

&-#M/'#%+/5 /6 $&A&'#- X&B #'C*+%&C%3'& C/1./5&5%$ 6/--/W&4 MB %*& 1#+5 #'C*+%&C%3'& 4&6+5&4 6/' %*& 4&$+D5&4

#..-+C#%+/50 S3'%*&'1/'&> %*& -+5X %/ %*& =56/'1#%+/5 E'C*+%&C%3'& %'#CX +$ #-$/ 1#4& +5 %*+$ C*#.%&'0

/T&U$1% IW+-- C/A&' %*& C#$& $%34B +5 W*+C* %*& &A&5% D&5&'#%/' _;L`> W*+C* W+-- M& 3$&4 #$ +5.3% %/ %*& N;P

&5D+5&> +$ &-#M/'#%&4 3./50 )*+$ C*#.%&' #-$/ 4&$C'+M&$ #-- /6 %*& C/1./5&5%$> W*+C* W+-- M& 3$&4 6/' %*&

$+13-#%+/5 /6 &A&5%$ #54 &-#M/'#%&$ /5 %*& 1#55&' +5 W*+C* %*& D'+4 C/1./5&5%$ W+-- M& +1.-&1&5%&4 6/' %*&

&A&5% D&5&'#%/'> W*+C* +5 %3'5 W+-- M& 3$&4 #$ +5.3% 6/' %*& 4&$+D5&4 N;P &5D+5& _4&6+5&4 +5 C*#.%&' 8`

/T&U$1% J4&$C'+M&$ %*& 1#+5 $1#'% D'+4 C*#--&5D&$ W& W+-- #%%&1.% %/ %#CX-& +5 %*+$ '&$'C* MB 3$+5D N;P #5463'%*&'1/'&> %*& 1#+5 '&Q3+'&1&5%$ /6 %*& $B$%&1 #'& $.&C+6+&4> #5#-B]&4 #54 %'#5$6/'1&4 +5 %/ '3-&$0 )*&$&

'3-&$ #'& 3$&4 +5 %*& N;P &5D+5& %/ 1#X& $&5$& /3% /6 %*& &A&5% +5.3% $%' D&5&'#%&4 MB %*& ;L0

/T&U$1% L+$ 3$&4 %/ 4&$C'+M& %*& +1.-&1&5%#%+/5 /6 %*& '3-&$ +5 %*& N;P &5D+5&0 T&O% %/ %*& +1.-&1&5%#%+/5

4&%#+-$> %*+$ C*#.%&' #-$/ C/A&'$ %*& D'#.*+C#- 3$&' +5%&'6#C& /6 %*& 4&$+D5&4 P'//6 R6 N/5C&.% _PRN`0

/T&U$1% MC/A&'$ %*& &A#-3#%+/5 /6 %*& 4&'+A&4 #'C*+%&C%3'& #54 4&$+D5&4 #..-+C#%+/50

/T&U$1% 9ND+A&$ # $311#'B /6 %*& &5%+'& .'/e&C% #54 %*&$+$> 6/--/W&4 MB %*& C/5C-3$+/5$ M#$&4 /5 %*& '&$3-%$

#CQ3+'&40

=5 'T&U$1% 99%*& '&$3-%$ /6 %*& .'/e&C% #$ W&-- #$ %*& C/5%'+M3%+/5$ 1#4& %/ %*& '&$'C* 6+&-4 #'& &-#M/'#%&4

3./50

E -+$% /6 %*& #MM'&A+#%+/5$ 3$&4 %*'/3D*/3% %*+$ '&./'% C#5 M& 6/354 +5 #..&54+O E0 =5 #..&54+O f %*& +5%&'A+&W

4/C31&5%$ C#5 M& 6/3540


22/109

77

,K%& /0 1KJ[P%HQ*R 9 2H%$ [*HI"$RP$


23/109

7H

/T&U$1% @2 =+$'T 1V1'$%,',$W #1'$-%E$ %*& %+%-& .'/M#M-B D#A& #W#B %*+$ C*#.%&' W+-- &-#M/'#%& /5 %*& &-&C%'+C+%B 4+$%'+M3%+/5 D'+4$ +5 %*&

T&%*&'-#54$0 K+5C& %*& 1#+5 Q3&$%+/5 #-$/ C/5%#+5$ %*& 1#5#D&1&5% /6 .3'C*#$& #54 $#-& 5&O% %/ C/5%'/-> %*&

&-&C%'+C+%B (Fens, 2005).3'C*#$&n$#-& #$.&C% +$ #-$/ C/A&'&4 +5 %*+$ $&C%+/50 )*& 6+'$% $&C%+/5$ W+-- C/A&' ?3%C*

&-&C%'+C+%B $&C%/' #54 %*& &5&'DB %'#4+5D 6/--/W&4 MB $1#'% 1&%&'$0

9"! K>0-C ;()-0%.-.05 M3(>) 2C3.1

)*& ?3%C* ;-&C%'+C+%B $&C%/' C/5$+$%$ /6 A#'+/3$ .#'%+&$ #54 +5 /'4&' %/ D&% # A+&W /6 %*& C/1.-&%& .+C%3'& W&

%#X& # -//X #% %*& &5&'DB A#-3& C*#+5 #$ 4&6+5&4 MB (Fens, 2005)0 E A#-3& C*#+5> #-$/ X5/W5 #$ A#-3& C*#+5

#5#-B$+$> +$ # C/5C&.% 6'/1 M3$+5&$$ 1#5#D&1&5% 6+'$% 4&$C'+M&4 MB "+C*#&- P/'%&' _78[h` #54 C#5 M& 3$&4 6/'

354&'$%#54+5D #C%+A+%+&$ +5 # $.&C+6+C +543$%'B0 =5 %*+$ C#$& %*& C*#+5 $%#'%$ #% %*& D&5&'#%+/5 /6 &-&C%'+C+%B #54 #%

C* $%#D& D#+5$ 1/'& A#-3& %/ %*& &54 C3$%/1&'0

P,X+%1 D2 7.1%XW \&V+1 'T&,.

E$ 4&.+C%&4 +5 6+D3'& 9 %*& $%#D&$ /6 %*& ?3%C* &-&C%'+C+%B $&C%/' C#5 '/3D*-B M& C#%&D/'+]&4 +5 %*& 6/--/W+5D

$3M$&C%+/5$ (J.Makansi, 2007)a

L&5&'#%+/5

)'#5$1+$$+/5

?+$%'+M3%+/5

?&-+A&'B

=5 %*+$ C*#+5 &-&C%'+C+%B +$ D&5&'#%&4 #54 6-/W$ 6'/1 -&6% %/ '+D*% W+%* %*& &54 C/5$31&' +5 %*& -#$% $%&.0 )*& &54

C/5$31&' .#B$ 6/' %*& 4&-+A&'&4 &5&'DB> W*+C* +5+%+#%&$ # 1/5&%#'B 6-/W M#CX %/ %*& 6+'$% $%#D&0 )*& 6+'$% $%&. +5

%*& C*#+5 +$ D&5&'#%+/50 )*& .'/43C%+/5 /6 &5&'DB +5 ./W&' .-#5%$ +$ 3$3#--B #CC/1.-+$*&4 MB M3'5+5D 63&- %/

D&5&'#%& $% )*& $% +$ %*&5 .'&$$3'+]&4 #54 .3$*&4 %*'/3D* # %3'M+5&> W*+C* C#3$&$ %*& D&5&'#%/' %/

$%#'% W/'X+5D #54 %*3$ D&5&'#%& &-&C%'+C+%B0 )*& 5&O% $%&. +$ %'#5$1+$$+/50 =5 %*+$ $%&. %*& &-&C%'+C+%B +$

%'#5$./'%&4 6'/1 %*& ./W&' .-#5%$ %/ %*& $3M$%#%+/5$0 =5 /'4&' %/ 1+5+1+]& %*& -/$$ /6 &-&C%'+C+%B 43'+5D

%'#5$./'% %*& A/-%#D&> W*+C* C#5 M& $&&5 #$ W*#% 4'+A&$ %*& &-&C%'+C+%B 4/W5 %*& W+'&> +$ +5C'$&4 %/ #5B%*+5D

/A&' 77JUb0 )*& '&$./5$+M-& .#'%B 6/' %*+$ .#'% /6 %*& C*#+5 +$ )&55&) _N*#.%&' H070H0`0 )*+$ +$ 5&C&$$#'B

M&C#3$& ./W&' .-#5%$ #'& 3$3#--B -/C#%&4 6#' 6'/1 ./.3-#%+/5 C&5%&'$ #54 +5C'$+5D %*& A/-%#D& W+-- D&% %*&

&-&C%'+C+%B #% %*& $3M$%#%+/5$ 6#$%&' #54 %*3$ 4&C'$+5D -/$$ /6 &-&C%'+C+%B (J.Makansi, 2007)0 R5C& #% %*&

$3M$%#%+/5$ %*& &-&C%'+C+%B +$ -/W&'&4 +5 A/-%#D& #54 4+$%'+M3%&4 %/ $&A&'#- ./+5%$ C-/$& %/ %*& &54 3$&'0 \#$%-B

%*& &-&C%'+C+%B +$ %'#5$6/'1&4 #D#+5 #54 4&-+A&'&4 4+'&C%-B %/ %*& &54 3$&'0

9"9 A%31,*.,,.&1 I5,0)* N/)%30&% :AIN /5& /6 %*& M+DD&$% %#$X$ #%

*#54 +$ %*#% /6 M#-#5C+5D $3..-B #54 4&1#54 /6 &-&C%'+C+%B +5 /'4&' %/ #A/+4 %*& D'+4 /6 D&%%+5D /A&'-/#4&40


24/109

79

P,X+%1 G2 7V1'$%,',$W X%,* 4%-0 X1.1%&$,-. $- *1V,\1%W

)*& ?3%C* )'#5$1+$$+/5 KB$%&1 R.&'#%/' _)KR`> )&55&)> +$ '&$./5$+M-& 6/' %*& .'/.&' *#54-+5D /6 #-- %*&

&-&C%'+C+%B #M/A& 77JUb +5 %*& T&%*&'-#54$ #54 *#$ %*& ?3%C* 1+5+$%'B /6 S+5#5C& #$ %*& $/-& $*#'&*/-4&'0 )*&B

C3''&5%-B *#A& #M/3% HZ[hX1 /6 HHJXA #54 9[JXA *+D* A/-%#D& %'#5$1+$$+/5 -+5&$ #54 h:7Z X1 /6 77JXA #54

7hJXA %'#5$1+$$+/5 -+5&$ +5 %*&+' 1#5#D&1&5% (TenneT-group, 2010)0 E$ C#5 M& $&&5 +5 6+D3'& Y> %*& )KR

_)&55&)` +$ /5-B '&$./5$+M-& 6/' %*& %'#5$1+$$+/5 /6 %*& &-&C%'+C+%B #54 4/&$ 5/% D&5&'#%& #5B &-&C%'+C+%B +%$&-6

5/' 4/&$ +% 4&-+A&' &-&C%'+C+%B 4+'&C%-B %/ M3$+5&$$ /' C/5$31&'$0

9"F K.,0%.'>0.&1 I5,0)* N/)%30&% :KIN %*#% %*& &O.&'%$ C/5$3-%&4 43'+5D %*+$ '&$'C* _T&O% %/ %*& /5&$ #%

\/D+C#` #'& 6'/1 %*&$& C/1.#5+&$0

T&O% %/ %*& '&D+/5#- ?KR($ %*&'& #'& #-$/ %*& 4&-+A&'B C/1.#5+&$ -+X& ;$$&5%> T3/5> ;5&C/> ROO+/ #54

L'&&5N*/+C&> W*+C* +5 6#C% #'& 5/ 1/'& %*#5 #41+5+$%'#%+A& #54 C/11&'C+#- C/5%#C% ./+5%$ 6/' %*& C-+&5%$

(B.Baarsma, 2008)0 )*&$& C/1.#5+&$ #'& %*& 1#+5 C/5%#C% ./+5%$ 6/' &A&'B C3$%/1&' %*#% W#5%$ %/ M&

C/55&C%&4 %/ %*& D'+40 E$ $%#%&4 +5 $&C%+/5 H07> %*& 1/5&%#'B 6-/W$ 6/--/W %*& $#1& .#%* M#CXW#'4$l $%#'%+5D #%

%*& 4&-+A&'B C/1.#5+&$ _C-+&5% .#B$ 6/' &-&C%'+C+%B` #54 %'#A&-+5D #-- %*& W#B M#CX %/ %*& D&5&'#%+/5 .-#5%$0

9"H ;1)%45 A%3+.14

=5 .'&A+/3$ B'$ 4&1#54 #54 $3..-B /6 &-&C%'+C+%B W#$ M#-#5C&4 MB #4e3$%+5D &5&'DB D&5&'#%+/5 %/ &5&'DB

4&1#540 =5 '&C&5% B'$ */W&A&' 1#'X&%$ W*&'& &-&C%'+C+%B C#5 M& $/-4 #54 .3'C*#$&4 *#A& &1&'D&40 )*&$&

1#'X&% #'& Q3+%& $+1+-#' %/ $%/CX 1#'X&%$ #54 C#5 #-$/ 4&%&'1+5& %*& .'+C& /6 &-&C%'+C+%B0 )*& .'&C+$& W/'X+5D /6

%*&$& 1#'X&%$ 4+66&' .&' C/35%'B M3% +5 %*& 1/$% C/11/5 6/'1 %*&'& +$ # C/1.#5B +5 M&%W&&5 %*& C/1.#5+&$

_EPÎ;T?;^` /5 %*& 4&1#54 $+4& W*/ 1#+5%#+5 %*& C/5%'#C%$ W+%* %*& C3$%/1&' #54 %*& C/1.#5+&$ /5 %*&

$3..-B $+4& W*/ D&5&'#%& %*& &-&C%'+C+%B0 )*+$ 1$ %*#% C/1.#5+&$ -+X& %*& EPÎ;T?;^ _4+$C3$$&4 +5 %*& 5&O%

$3M$&C%+/5` 4/5(% *#A& %/ D&5&'#%& &-&C%'+C+%B0 E-- %*&B 4/ +$ M3B C/5%'#C%$ /5 %*& 1#'X&% #54 $&-- %*&1 #54 %*+$

C#5 M& 4/5& 4#BI#* /' '-I%+1&0 =6 %*&'& #'& #5B 4+66&'&5C&$ M&%W&&5 C/5%'#C%3#- /M-+D#%+/5$ _63%3'&$` #54

#C%3#- 3$#D& %*&B W+-- M& $&%%-&4 #6%&'W#'4$(J.Makansi, 2007)0

!0#$1%*&0 3-Y1% 7Z'T&.X1

@. %/ # C/3.-& /6 1/5%*$ #D/> %*&'& W&'& %W/ &OC*#5D&$ 6/' D#$ #54 &-&C%'+C+%B +5 %*& T&%*&'-#54$a )*&

E1$%&'4#1 P/W&' ;OC*#5D& _EP^` #54 %*& ?3%C* ;3'/. ;5&'DB ?&'+A#%+A&$ _;T?;^`0 EP^ *#4 +%$ 1#+5 6/C3$

/5 4#BI#* #54 +5 4#B %'#4+5D W*+-& ;T?;^ W#$ # 63%3'&$ &OC*#5D&0 E$ /6 F#53#'B h%* %*+$ B' */W&A&' %*&

%W/ C/1.#5+&$ *#A& $3CC&$$63--B 1&'D&4 +5%/ /5& C/1.#5B7 #54 %*&B C3''&5%-B /.&'#%& 354&' %*& 5#1& EPÎ

;T?;^0 )*& EPÎ;T?;^ +$ /5& /6 ;3'/.&($ 1/$% &O.&'+&5C&4 &5&'DB &OC*#5D&$ #54> $+5C& %*& 1&'D&'> /.&'#%&

4#BI#* %'#4+5D> +5 4#B %'#4+5D #-/5D W+%* 63%3'&$ %'#4+5D 6/' &-&C%'+C+%B #54 5#%3'#- D#$ +5 %*& T&%*&'-#54$>

%*& @5+%&4 U+5D4/1 #54 f&-D+310 E% %*& &54 /6 HJJ8 %*& C/1M+5&4 ./W&' #54 D#$ A/-31& /6 EPÎ;T?;^ Y7H

)


26/109

7h

/T&U$1% D2 C0&%$ X%,*)*+$ C*#.%&' W+-- M& 3$&4 %/ &-#M/'#%& /5 %*& $1#'% D'+4 +5 D&5&'#- #54 %*& .'/M-&1$ +% +$ &O.&C%&4 %/ $/-A&0

)*&'& #'& H 1#+5 '$/5$ 6/' %*& C/5$+4&'#%+/5 /6 #..-B+5D # $1#'% D'+4 /5 5#%+/5#- -&A&-(K.Dodrill, 2010)0

S+'$%-B %*& C3''&5% &-&C%'+C+%B D'+4 +$ #D+5D #54 /3%I4#%&4 +5 1#5B '&$.&C%$0 =5A&$%1&5%$ #'& 5&&4&4 %/ +1.'/A&

+%$ C/54+%+/5 #54 %/ &5$3'& %*#% %*& D'+4 *#$ &5/3D* C#.#C+%B %/ *#54-& %*& &-&C%'+C+%B 4&1#540 K&C/54-B> #54

1/'& +1./'%#5% 6/' %*+$ '&$'C*> %*&'& #'& $&A&'#- $3M$%#5%+#- M&5&6+%$ /6 3$+5D N;P W*&5 +1.-&1&5%+5D #

$1#'% D'+40

F"! O10%&+>-0.&1

R5& /6 %*& M+DD&$% C*#--&5D&$ /6 C3''&5% ./W&' $B$%&1$ +$ '355+5D # $3..-B /5 4&1#54 $B$%&1 %*#% +$ %'3-B

'&-+#M-&0 =5 %*& .#$% %*+$ *#$ -&4 %/ # ./W&' $B$%&1 M#$&4 /5 # C/5%'/--#M-& $3..-B %/ 1#%C* %*& *+D*-B

35C/5%'/--&4 4&1#540 %*& #..-+C#%+/5 /6 '&5&W#M-& &5&'DB

$/3'C&$ *#A& '+$&5 # D'% 4- #54 #'& 5/W 'C*+5D $+D5+6+C#5% -&A&-$ /6 .&5&%'#%+/50 )*& .'/M-&1 %*+$ M'+5D$

+$ %*#%> $+5C& %*& '&5&W#M-& $/3'C&$ #'& -#'D&-B 4&.&54&5% /5 C-+1#%& #54 #'& %*&'&6/'& 5/% C/5%'/--#M-&> %*&

$3..-B C#55/% $+-B M& #4e3$%&4 %/ 1&&% %*& &5&'DB 4&1#54$(Cameron W. Potter, 2009)0 )*&$&

4&A&-/.1&5%$ #'& 1#X+5D +% +1./$$+M-& %/ C/5%+53& &-&C%'+C+%B D'+4 1#5#D&1&5% %*& W#B +% C3''&5%-B 4/5&> #54

%*&'&6/' # C*#5D& +$ 5&&4&40 K1#'%ID'+4 #44'&$$&$ %*#% C*#5D& MB #..'/#C*+5D %*& 1#5#D&1&5% /6 %*& D'+4 +5 #

4+66&'&5% 1#55&'0 )*& 3$& /6 $1#'%ID'+4$ #--/W$ # 1/'& 6-&O+M-& 1#5#D&1&5% $B$%&1> W*+C* C#5 M& #C*+&A&4 +5

1#5B W#B$ 6'/1 ?&1#54 K+4& "#5#D&1&5% _?K"` %/ &-&C%'+C+%B $%/'#D&0

F"9 K)@.1.0.&1

)*& @K T#%+/5#- ;5&'DB )&C*5/-/DB \#M/'#%/'B _T;)\` 4&6+5&$ : .'+5C+.-& C*#'#C%&'+$%+C$ /6 %*& $1#'% D'+4

(K.Dodrill, 2010)a

;5#M-&$ EC%+A& .#'%+C+.#%+/5 MB C3$%/1&'$

ECC/11/4#%&$ #-- D&5&'#%+/5 #54 $%/'#D& /.%+/5$

;5#M-&$ 5&W .'/43C%$> $&'A+C&$ #54 1#'X&%$

P'/A+4&$ ./W&' Q3#-+%B 6/' %*& 4+D+%#- &C/5/1B

R.%+1+]&$ #$$&% 3%+-+]#%+/5 #54 /.&'#%&$ &66+C+&5%-B

E5%+C+.#%&$ #54 '&$./54$ %/ $B$%&1 4+$%3'M#5C&$

R.&'#%&$ '&$+-+&5%-B #D#+5$% #%%#CX #54 5#%3'#- 4+$#$%&'

T&O% %/ %*&$& C*#'#C%&'+$%+C$ %*&B #-$/ 4&$C'+M& %*& 6/--/W+5D Z X&B A#-3&$ 6'/1 W*+C* %*& M&5&6+%$ W+-- '&$3-%

#6%&' +1.'/A&1&5%$a

,&-+#M+-+%B I =1.'/A&1&5%$ W/3-4 - %/ # '&43C&4 6'&Q3&5CB #54 43'#%+/5 /6 /3%#D&$> # '&43C%+/5 +5

%*& 531M&' /6 4+$%3'M#5C&$ 43& %/ .//' ./W&' Q3#-+%B> #54 A+'%3#- &-+1+5#%+/5 /6 W+4&$.'

M-#CX/3%$0

;C/5/1+C I =1.'/A&1&5%$ W/3-4 M& '-+]&4 6'/1 +1.'/A&4 1&%&'$ '&$3-%+5D +5 1/'& #CC3'#%&

+56/'1#%+/5 /5 %*& 3$#D& /6 &Q3+.1&5% #54 %*3$ # -/W&' M+--0

;66+C+&5CB I =1.'/A&1&5%$ W/3-4 '&43C& %*& C/$% /6 .'/43C+5D> 4&-+A&'+5D #54 C/5$31+5D &-&C%'+C+%B0

;5A+'/51&5%#- I =1.'/A&1&5%$ W/3-4 #-$/ M& #5 &66&C% /6 +1.-&1&5%+5D # $1#'% D'+4 $+5C& +1.'/A&4

&66+C+&5CB W/3-4 - %/ # '&43C%+/5 +5 &1+$$+/5$ #54 4+$C*#'D&$ W*&5 C/1.#'&4 %/ %*& C3''&5%

$+%3#%+/50

K&C3'+%B I =1.'/A&1&5%$ W/3-4 - %/ #5 +5C'$& +5 %*& '/M3$%5&$$ #54 '&$+-+&5CB /6 %*& D'+4 6'/1 #

.*B$+C#- #54 CBM&' .&'$.&C%+A&0


27/109

7Z

K#6&%B I =1.'/A&1&5%$ W/3-4 - %/ '&43C&4 $#6&%B *#]#'4$ #$ W&-- #$ %+1& /6 &O./$3'& %/ *#]#'4$0

S'/1 %*+$ -+$% W& 6+54 %*#% %*& &O.&C%&4 +1.'/A&1&5%$ '&$3-%+5D 6'/1 %*& +1.-&1&5%#%+/5 /6 # $1#'% D'+4 W+--

M& 5/%+CM-& %*'/3D*/3% %*& W*/-& $/C+&%B0 )*& 4&-+A&'B C/1.#5+&$ W+-- *#A& %*& /../'%35+%B %/ $+D5+6+C#5%-B

'&43C& %*&+' C#.+%#- C/$%$ #54 '5 # '&%3'5 6/' %*&+' $*#'&*/-4&'$> &-&C%'+C+%B $3..-+&'$ *#A& %*& /../'%35+%B %/

&5%&' 5&W 1#'X&%$ C'%&4 MB %*& $1#'% D'+4 _'&5&W#M-& D&5&'#%+/5 #54 $%/'#D& 6/' &O#1.-&`> N/5$31&'$ *#A&

%*& /../'%35+%B %/ '&43C& %*&+' &5&'DB M+--$ #54 '&43C& %*& -/$$&$ C#3$&4 MB /3%#D&$ #54 ./W&' Q3#-+%B &A&5%$

#54 K/C+&%B W+-- M&5&6+% 6'/1 # $%+13-#%&4 &C/5/1B> +1.'/A&4 &5A+'/51&5%#- C/54+%+/5$ #54 +1.'/A&4

5#%+/5#- $&C3'+%B0

K+5C& %*& $1#'% D'+4 #54 +%$ M&5&6+%$ 4+$C3$$&4 #M/A& #'& # M+% #M$%'#C% W& .'&$&5% B/3 W+%* # C/3.-& /6 $1#'%

D'+4 4&6+5+%+/5$ #54 %*& /5& W& W+-- #4*&'& %/ %*'/3D*/3% %*+$ .'/e&C%0

(M)J(Johan Boekema, 2009, p. 7)

! -)* V&+. 7/0/&*#/9 *0. .+9#&+Q"#/9 /,/4#&+4+#5 )%&/ / 1# /0*Q,/9 #I%@I*5 /=4$*07/ I+#$ 4"9#%)/&9 6&%8+.+07 7&/*#/& +0 1# /0*Q,/9 #I%@I*5 /=4$*07/ I+#$ 4"9#%)/&9 6&%8+.+07 7&/*#/& +0


28/109

7:

F"F D)(30)+ P&%Q

E% %*& %+1& /6 %*+$ '&$'C*> %*&'& W&'& #-'B # C/3.-& /6 $1#'% D'+4 .'/e&C%$> W*+C* e3$% $%#'%&4 /' W&'& e3$%

$%#'%+5D 3.0 =5 %*+$ $&C%+/5> %*& 1/$% +1./'%#5% /6 %*&$& .+-/% .'/e&C%$ #'& 4&$C'+M&4 #54 C/1.#'&4 %/ %*+$

'&$'C*0 )/ C/5C-34& %*+$ $&C%+/5> %*& $/'% /6 1#5#D&1&5% 3$&4 6/' C* .+-/% .'/e&C% W+-- M& #5#-B$&4 %/ $&&

+5 W*#% #$.&C% %*&$& .'/e&C%$ 4+66&' 6'/1 %*+$ '&$'C*0

F"F"! $&P)%R30-C.14 -.05

)*& 6+'$% &O#1.-& W& W+-- 4&$C'+M& *&'& +$ # 4&1/5$%'#%+/5 .'/e&C%> W*+C* 4+$.-#B$ %*& &5&'DB +56'#$%'3C%3'& /6

%*& 63%3'&0 P/W&'"#%C*+5D N+%B +$ #5 &O.&'+1&5% +5 %*& ?3%C* C+%B /6 G//DX&'X #54 +5C-34&$ Hh */3$&$

C/55&C%&4 %/ C* /%*&' MB $1#'% D'+40 )*& 1#+5 +4 +$ %*#% &5&'DB W+-- 5/ -/5D&' M& D&5&'#%&4 #% C&5%'#-

./+5%$> M3% W+-- M& 4&C&5%'#-+]&4 #54 4+A+4&4 +5%/ $1#-- $3$%#+5#M-& D&5&'#%+/5 .-#5%$ W+%*+5 %*& G//DX&'X

5&%W/'X0 ;O#1.-&$ /6 4&C&5%'#-+]&4 D&5&'#%+/5 +5C-34& $/-#' .#5&-$> W+54 %3'M+5&$ #54 N/1M+5&4 G% #54

P/W&' D&5&'#%/'$ _NGP`0 )*&'& +$ */W&A&' # .'/M-&1 W+%* %*+$ #..'/#C*> $/-#' #54 W+54 ./W&' #'& *A+-B

4&.&54&5% /5 %*& W%*&' #54 %*& 3$& /6 NGP D&5&'#%/'$ W+-- - %/ #5 &OC&$$ /6 &-&C%'+C+%B 43'+5D %*& W+5%&'

.&'+/4 W*&5 # -/% /6 *% +$ 5&&4&40 E-- %*&$& 6-3C%3#%+/5$ - %/ %*& 6#C% %*#% 3$#D& #54 D&5&'#%+/5 /6 &5&'DB

#'& 5/% # $B5C*'/5/3$ .'/C&$$0 K/-#' .#5&-$ 6/' &O#1.-& D&5&'#%& # -/% /6 &-&C%'+C+%B 43'+5D %*& 4#B> M3% %*+$ +$

#-$/ %*& %+1& W*&5 1/$% .&/.-& #'& #% W/'X #54 %*& &-&C%'+C+%B 4&1#54 +$ -/W&' %*#5 +5 %*& 1/'5+5D /'

&A&5+5Dn5+D*%0 =5 /'4&' %/ 4- W+%* %*+$ +1M#-#5C& /6 $3..-B #54 4&1#54 %*& P/W&'"#%C*&' _6+D3'& 8` +$

+5%'/43C&40

3-Y1%E&$'T1%

W*+C* .&'6/'1$ %*& .'+C& 6/'1+5D .'/C&$$0 )*& #3C%+/5&&' C/--&C%$ #-- %*& M+4$ 6'/1 %*&

#D&5%$ C/55&C%&4 4+'&C%-B %/ +% +5%/ /5& $+5D-& M+4> $'C*&$ 6/' %*& &Q3+-+M'+31 .'+C& #54 C/1135+C#%&$ # .'+C&

3.4#%& M#CX +5 C#$& /6 # $+D5+6+C#5% .'+C& C*#5D&0 )*& C/5C&5%'#%/' #D&5%$ *#A& %*& $#1& %#$X$ M3% 4/ %*+$ 6/' #

$3MD'/3. /6 4&A+C&$0 )/W#'4$ %*& E3C%+/5&&' +% 1+1+C$ %*& 4&A+C& #D&5%$> #54 %/W#'4$ %*& 4&A+C& #D&5%$ +%

1+1+C$ %*& #3C%+/5&&'0 T&O% %/ %*&$& #D&5%$ B/3 #-$/ *#A& %*& 4&A+C& #D&5%$ W*+C* #C% #$ 1#5#D&'$ 6/' C*$&.#'#%& 4&A+C&0 )*& 4&A+C& #D&5%$ W+-- M+4 /5 &-&C%'+C+%B 35+%$ #% %*& C/5C&5%'#%/' #D&5%$ #54 W+-- M#CX /3%

W*&5 &-&C%'+C+%B .'+C&$ D&% '--B *+D* _K3..-B -/W&' %*#5 4&1#54`0 )*+$ W+-- C#3$& %*& 4&A+C&$ W+%* # -/W&'

.'+/'+%B %/ C$& %*&+' W/'X '+D*% #W#B #54 W#+% 6/' %*& .'+C&$ %/ 4'/. _4&1#54 -/W&' %*#5 $3..-B`0

P,X+%1 I2 3-Y1% E&$'T1% '-.'1U$


29/109

7[

F"F"9 M3-30.&1 /3%Q S%&1,')%4)1 :T>0/C)1 W*+C* $%#'%&4 /3% #$ #5 &O.&'+1&5% +5

HJJh0 )*& .'/e&C% W#$ $%#'%&4> C/5C&'5+5D %/ %*& NRH &1+$$+/5 '&43C%+/5 #54 -&$$ 4&.&54&5C& /5 C/5A&5%+/5#-

63&-$> *&5C& %*& $%&. %/ '&5&W#M-& &5&'DB '&$/3'C&$0 )*& .#'X C/5$+$%$ /6 H7J */-+4#B */3$&$> /6 W*+C* 7J[

*#A& M&&5 +5$%#--&4 W+%* /A&' 9JJJ 1H /6 $/-#' .#5&-$ /5 %*& '//60 E "bn\b 7JXbnYJJb> YJJXb %'#5$6/'1&' +$

3$&4 %/ C/55&C% %*& f'/5$M&'D&5 5&%W/'X %/ %*& 5#%+/5#- D'+4(D.T. Ho, 2010)0 S3'%*&'1/'& %*& D'+4 C/5$+$%$/6 H M#%%&'B M#5X$> W*+C* #'& 3$&4 #$ &-&C%'+C#- $%/'#D&0 =5 %*+$ $&%%+5D> %*& %'#5$6/'1&' C#5 #-$/ M& 3$&4 %/

4&-+A&' &-&C%'+C+%B M#CX %/ %*& D'+40 S+D3'& : +--3$%'#%&$ #5 +1#D& /6 %*& f'/5$M&'D&5 D'+4 /5 %*& -&6% #54 +%$

$+1.-+6+&4 $+5D-&I-+5& 4+#D'#1 /5 %*& '+D*%0

P,X+%1 J2 H&^&.$,1U&%^ O%-.#"1%X1. (D.T. Ho, 2010)

)*& 1#+5 .3'./$& /6 %*+$ D'+4 +$ %/ 1/5+%/' %*& &66&C%$ /6 4+$%'+M3%&4 D&5&'#%+/5 /5 +%$ 5&%W/'X C/1./5&5%$

_*#'1/5+C 4+$%/'%+/5` M3% +%$ $&%3. +$ $+1+-#' %/ %*& $+13-#%+/5 D'+4 +5%'/43C&4 +5 C*#.%&' Z0

F"F"F AC) U&, V14)(), $&P)% G%.+

)*& C+%B /6 \/$ E5D&-&$ +$ $&'A&4 MB %*& ?&.#'%1&5% /6 W*&'& %*&'& +$ # $&.#'#%& )KR #54 $&A&'#-

?KR($> %*+$ .3M-+C 3%+-+%B +$ A&'%+C#--B +5%&D'#%&4 #54 C/5%'/-$ #54 /.&'#%&$ +%($ /W5 ./W&' D&5&'#%+/5>

%'#5$1+$$+/5 #54 4+$%'+M3%+/5 $B$%&1$0 ?3& %/ %*& -#%&$% D/#-$ /6 '&43C+5D +%($ C#'M/5 &1+$$+/5$ #54 +5C'$+5D

+%$ $*#'& /6 '&5&W#M-& &5&'DB $/3'C&$> %*& ?

W*+C* W/3-4 $%+13-#%& %*& 3%+-+%B 1#'X&% %/ 6/' &O#1.-& +4&5%+6B 5&W &5&'DB

$/3'C&$ #54 1#X& %*& &-&C%'+C D'+4 $1#'%&' #54 %*&'&6/'& %*& \E ?

+$ %/ '&43C& .&' C#.+%# ./W&' 3$#D& /A&'#-- _-/W&'

C#'M/5 &1+$$+/5$`> #54 %*& $&C/54> +$ %/ '&43C& %*& . ./W&' 3$#D& /A&'#-- MB $*+6%+5D ./W&' 3$#D& %/ /66

. */3'$ _'&43C&$ %*& &O%&5% /6 353$&4 $.#'& C#.#C+%B`0 i/D&$* K+11*#5 &% #-0 D+A& #5 &O#1.-& W*&'& %*&

M#$& -/#4 /5 # %B.+C#- 4#B +5 \E ?


30/109

78

&O.#5$+/5 /' -/#4 C3'%#+-1&5%0 ?

/' 3$+5D #

A#'+#M-& '#%& 1#'X&% 1/4&- %*#% +5C'$&$ .'+C&$ 43'+5D $*/'%#D&0 P'+/' C/11+%1&5% MB C/5$31&'$ W/3-4 #--/W

%*& C/5%'/- %/ %3'5 /66 %*& C/5$31&'$( &Q3+.1&5% /' $&54 # $+D5#- %/ %*& C/5$31&' %/ '&43C& C/5$31.%+/5 +5

'&%3'5 6/' C/5$31&' +5C&5%+A&$(Y.Simmhan, 2011)0

F"F"H S&>(+)% -.05 2&(&%3+& :W2;U ;1)%45 4&-+A&'B #54 &5&'DB C/5$31.%+/50 )*& X&B C/1./5&5%$ /6 K1#'% L'+4 N+%B +5C-34&(Xcel-Energy)a

E 4B5#1+C $B$%&1 '+C* +5 +56/'1#%+/5 %&C*5/-/DB

G+D*I$.&&4> '-I%+1&> %W/IW#B C/1135+C#%+/5$

K&5$/'$ %*'/3D*/3% %*& D'+4 &5#M-+5D '#.+4 4+#D5/$+$ #54 C/''&C%+/5$

?&C+$+/5I1#X+5D 4#%# #54 $3../'% 6/' . &66+C+&5CB

?+$%'+M3%&4 D&5&'#%+/5 %&C*5/-/D+&$ _K3C* #$ W+54 %3'M+5&$> $/-#' .#5&-$> #54 .-3D +5 *BM'+4 &-&C%'+C

A&*+C-&$`

E3%/1#%&4 $1#'% $3M$%#%+/5$

=5I */1& &5&'DB C/5%'/- 4&A+C&$

E3%/1#%&4 */1& &5&'DB 3$&

fB HJJ8 ^C&- ;5&'DB *#4 +5$%#--&4 $&5$+5D #54 C/1135+C#%+/5$ &Q3+.1&5% %/ 1/5+%/' %*& f/3-4&' 4+$%'+M3%+/5

D'+4 C/A&'+5D /A&' Yh>JJJ */1&$0 N3''&5%-B %*&B *#A& +5$%#--&4 1/'& %*#5 HJ 4+$.#'#%& $/6%W#'& #..-+C#%+/5$

#54 8h 5&W 4#%# +5%&D'#%+/5 +5%&'6#C&$ %/ $3../'% K1#'%L'+4N+%B> #-/5D W+%* #..'/O+1#%&-B Y>hJJ D'+4

C/54+%+/5 $&5$/'$ #54 HY>JJJ $1#'% 1&%&'$(MetaVu Xcel Boulder city evaluation, 2011)0 =56/'1#%+/5 #M/3%

%*& #C%3#- 1#5#D&1&5% $B$%&1 3$&4 +5 %*+$ .'/e&C% *#$ .'/A&5 A&'B *#'4 %/ 6+54 #54 C#5 %*&'&6/'& 5/% M&

+5C-34&4 +5 %*+$ $3MC*#.%&'0 )*& '$/5 %*+$ .'/e&C% +$ $%+-- 4+$C3$$&4 *&'& C/1&$ 6'/1 %*& -&$$/5$ -'5&4 +5 %*+$

.+-/% .'/e&C%0

?3& %/ -#CX /6 # .'/.&' C/$% M&5&6+% #5#-B$+$> %*& .'/e&C% &OC&&4&4 +%$ M34D&% MB 5'-B %'+.-& %*& +5+%+#- #1/35%

#44+5D 3. %/ YY>[ "+--+/5 4/--#'$(Jeffe, 2010)0 ECC/'4+5D %/ ^C&-> %*& C/$% 4'+A&'$ W&'& %*& #44&4 &O.&5$& +5

-#B+5D 6+M&'I/.%+C C#M-&$ %/ C* /6 %*& H9JJJ $1#'% 1&%&'$ #54 %*& 5&C&$$#'B $/6%W#'& %/ '35 %*& $B$%&10


31/109

HJ

F"F"7 D)(30)+ P&%Q -&1-(>,.&1

)*/3D* $&A&'#- $1#'% D'+4 .+-/% .'/e&C%$ #'& #A#+-#M-& %*'/3D*/3% %*& W/'-4> +% *#$ .'/A&5 '#%*&' 4+66+C3-% %/

#CQ3+'& %*& -&A&- /6 +56/'1#%+/5 5&&4&4 +5 /'4&' %/ 1#X& $&5$& /3% /6 %*&$& 4+66&'&5% .'/e&C%$ #54 C/1.#'&

%*&1 %/ %*& #..'/#C* .'&$&5%&4 +5 %*+$ %*&$+$0 )*& .'&A+/3$-B 1&5%+/5&4 .'/e&C%$ #'& #-- 6/C3$&4 /5 4&1#54

'&$./5$& /.%+1+]#%+/5 +5 W*+C* %*& 3%+-+%+&$ %'B %/ 1#%C* %*& &5&'DB $3..-B %/ 4&1#540 )*& 1#+5 6/C3$ #C'/$$

1/$% /6 %*&$& .'/e&C%$ -+&$ W+%*+5 %*& */3$&$ #54 1#X+5D %*& C/1./5&5%$ +5$+4& C* */3$& c$1#'%d0 )*&$&$1#'% C/1./5&5%$ C#5 %*&5 M& $W+%C*&4 /5 /' /66 '&1/%&-B> $/ %*#% %*& 1#5#D&1&5% $B$%&1 C#5 4&C+4& W*&5

+$ %*& M&$% %+1& %/ $W+%C* /5 C* 4&A+C&0 @$+5D %*+$ %&C*5+Q3& ./W&' 3$#D& C#5 M& #-+D5&4 W+%* D&5&'#%+/5

'&$3-%+5D +5 # 1/'& $%#M-& #54 &66+C+&5% &-&C%'+C+%B D'+40

^+ S#5D &% #-0 4&$C'+M& %*& $1#'% D'+4 #$ # W*/-& MB 4&6+5+5D %*'&& $/IC#--&4 $B$%&1$ /6 W*+C* %*& $1#'% D'+4

C/5$+$%$(X. Fang, 2011)a

K1#'% +56'#$%'3C%3'& $B$%&1 k ;$/ /0/&75b +0

K1#'% .'/%&C%+/5 $B$%&1 I ;$/ 9)* 6&%#/4#+%0 959#/) +9 #$/ 9"Q959#/) +0 -V #$*# 6&%8+./9 *.8*04/.

7&+. &/,+*Q+,+#5 *0*,59+9b

)*& 1#+5 6/C3$ /6 %*+$ '&$'C* +$ /5 %*& .#'% %*&B 4&6+5&4 #$ %*& cK1#'% 1#5#D&1&5% $B$%&1d> #54 %*& '$/5

%*&+' W/'X +$ .'&$&5%&4 *&'& +$ M&C#3$& %*&B #-$/ #5#-B$&4 W*+C* 1&%*/4$ #'& C3''&5%-B M&+5D 3$&4 6/' C* /6

%*& %*'&& C#%&D/'+&$0 =5 %*& 6+D3'& M&-/W _6+D3'& [` B/3 C#5 6+54 %*& 1&%*/4$ 6/354 6/' $1#'% 1#5#D&1&5%(X.

Fang, 2011)0

"/$% /6 %*& .'&A+/3$-B 4&6+5&4 .'/e&C%$ 6#-- 354&' %*& EC%+/5 C#%&D/'B #$ 4&1#54 $+4& 1#5#D&1&5% 6/'1$ %*&

C&5%'#- .#'% /6 %*& 1#5#D&1&5% $B$%&10 N/1.-&O ;A&5% P'/C&$$+5D 4/&$ 5/% '--B 6#-- +5 %/ /5& /6 %*&$&

4&6+5&4 C#%&D/'+&$ #$ +% C#5 M& 3$&4 6/' 13-%+.-& .3'./$&$ _R.%+1+]#%+/5> E3C%+/5` #54 C#5 M& C/1M+5&4 W+%*

1#C*+5& -'5+5D 6/' &O#1.-&> W*+C* D+A&$ +% #5 #4A#5%#D& /A&' %*&$& 1&%*/4$0

P,X+%1 L2 C0&%$ 0&.&X101.$ 01$T-*#


32/109

H7

^ S#5D &% #-0 #-$/ $%#%& %*#% %*&'& #'& C3''&5%-B #..'/O+1#%&-B 8J $1#'% D'+4 '&-#%&4 .'/e&C%$ '355+5D #-- /A&'

%*& W/'-4 #$ C#5 M& $&&5 +5 %*& 6/--/W+5D 6+D3'&0

E$ B/3 C#5 $&& %*&'& #'& $&A&'#- $1#'% D'+4 .'/e&C%$ '355+5D> M3% +5 4+66&'&5% 4+'&C%+/5$0 )*& +1./'%#5% /5&$ 6/'

%*+$ '&$'C* #'& %*& M-3& _E"=` #54 '&4 _=K` .'/e&C%$0 )*& E"= .'/e&C%$ 6/C3$ 1/'& /5& $1#'% 1&%&'+5D #54

$1#'% */3$&$ _*/3$& C/1./5&5%$` W*&'$ %*& =K 6/C3$&$ /5 %*& &5%+'& D'+4 _)*+$ .'/e&C%`0 )*/3D* %*&'& +$

$/1& +56/'1#%+/5 #A#+-#M-& /5 1/$% /6 %*&$& .'/e&C%$> %*& +56/'1#%+/5 6/354 4/&$5(% D/ +5 4&%#+-> W*+C* +$ W*B

%*&B #'& 5/% 1&5%+/5&4 +5 %*+$ C*#.%&'0

P,X+%1 M2 C0&%$ X%,* U,V-$ U%-[1'$#


33/109

HH

/T&U$1% G2 7\1.$ 3%-'1##,.XE5 /W- *35%$ 1+C& #% 5+D*% #54 W+-- ./35C& /5 # 1/3$& 6'/1 6-+D*% W*&5 +% 4&%&C%$ +% 1/A+5D /5 %*& D'/3540

)*& 1/3$& 1+D*% $&5$& %*+$ #54 '&$./54 MB e31.+5D /3% /6 %*& W#B M3% W+-- 4+& +6 +% '&$./54$ +5#..'/.'+#%&-B>

%*+$ +$ '&6&''&4 %/ #$ # $&5$& #54 '&$./54 $B$%&1(K.Chandy M. A., 2007)0 $/ &A&5% .'/C&$$+5D *#$ # -/5D *+$%/'B> /6 W*+C* # D'% 4- +5

C/1.3%&' $C+&5C&0 =6 W& #..-B %*+$ C/5C&.% %/ %*& M3$+5&$$ W& 4+$C3$$&4 '-+&' +5 %*+$ 4/C31&5% _?3%C*

&-&C%'+C+%B $&C%/' N*#.%&' H0` W& $&& %*#% +% 6+%$ .&'6&C%-B0 E C&5%'#- $&5$& #54 '&$./54 $B$%&1 C/3-4 1/5+%/' %*&

&5%+'& 5&%W/'X M#$&4 /5 '-I%+1& +5C/1+5D &A&5%$0 @./5 '&C&+A+5D %*&$& &A&5%$> #C%+/5$ #54 5/%+6+C#%+/5$ C#5

M& D&5&'#%&40 )*+$ $/'% /6 $&5$& #54 '&$./54 $B$%&1 M#$&4 /5 &A&5% .'/C&$$+5D C/3-4 $&5$& C*#5D&$ +5 %*&

&-&C%'+C+%B D'+4 _C/55&C%/' 6#+-3'&$> M'/X&5 C#M-&$` /' +5 &5&'DB .'+C&$ _M3B &-&C%'+C+%B 6'/1 %*& 5&%> 3$& /W5 NGP

/' $&-- &5&'DB 3$+5D %*& EP^` #54 '&$./54 #CC/'4+5D-B0

)*+$ C*#.%&' W+-- C/A&' #-- W& 5&&4 %/ X5/W #M/3% &A&5% .'/C&$$+5D0 6/--/W&4 MB %*& 4+66&'&5% %B.&$ /6 &A&5% .'/C&$$+5D #..'/#C*&$0 )*& 5&O% $&C%+/5 4+A&$ M#CX

+5%/ %*& M&D+55+5D /6 &A&5% .'/C&$$+5D +5 %*& 6/'1 /6 $+%3#%+/5 #W#'&5&$$0 =5 %*& $&C%+/5 /5 $+%3#%+/5

#W#'&5&$$> %*& .'+5C+.-&$ #'& -+5X&4 %/ %*& C3''&5% #..'/#C*&$0


34/109

H9

H"9 ;B)10 $%&-),,.14 3//%&3-C),

)*& P#%'+C+# K&BM/-4 L'/3. 4&6+5&$ %*'&& X+54$ /6 &A&5% .'/C&$$+5D 1&%*/4$> %*& 6+'$% /5& M&+5D $+1.-& &A&5%

.'/C&$$+5D> %*& $&C/54 /5& $%' &A&5% .'/C&$$+5D #54 %*& %*+'4 C/1.-&O &A&5% .'/C&$$+5D (Michelson,

2006)0 =5 /'4&' %/ D&% # M&%%&' D'#$. /6 %*& 4+66&'&5% %B.&$ /6 &A&5% .'/C&$$+5D W& 6+'$% %#X& # -//X #% &A&5%

6-/W$ %/ #+4 +5 4&$C'+M+5D %*& %B.&$ #54 4+A+4& #5 &A&5% 6-/W +5%/ Y $&C%+/5$(Michelson, 2006)0 )*& 6+'$% .#'% +$

%*#% /6 %*& &A&5% D&5&'#%/'$ W*+C*> #$ %*& 5#1& +1.-+&$> +$ %*& $/3'C& /6 %*& D&5&'#%&4 &A&5%$ +5 %*& $B$%&10K&C/54-B W& *#A& %*& &A&5% C*#55&- W*+C* C#5 M& $&&5 #$ %*& 1&$$#D+5D M#CXM/5& /6 %*& $B$%&1 %'#5$./'%+5D

%*& 1&$$#D&$ M&%W&&5 &A&5% D&5&'#%/'$> .'/C&$$+5D &5D+5&$ #54 4/W5$%' $3M$C'+M&'$ (Michelson, 2006)0

)*& %*+'4 .#'% +$ %*& &A&5%I.'/C&$$+5D &5D+5&> W*+C* &A#-3#%&$ %*& '&C&+A&4 &A&5%$ #D#+5$% %*& &A&5% .'/C&$$+5D

'3-&$ C#3$+5D #C%+/5$ %/ M& +5+%+#%&40 )*& -#$% .#'% /6 %*& &A&5% 6-/W +$ %*& 4/W5$%' &A&5% 4'+A&5 #C%+A+%B>

W*+C* +5+%+#%&$ 531&'/3$ 4/W5$%' #C%+A+%+&$0 =5 %*& 5&O% $3M$&C%+/5$ W& W+-- %#X& # -//X #% C* /6 %*&

&A&5% .'/C&$$+5D #..'/#C*&$ 1&5%+/5&4 #M/A&0

H"9"! I.*/() ;B)10 $%&-),,.14

=5 $+1.-& &A&5% .'/C&$$+5D> # 5/%#M-& %*+5D *#..&5$> +5+%+#%+5D 4/W5$%' #C%+/5_$` (Michelson, 2006)0 E5

&O#1.-& /6 %*+$ C/3-4 M& B/3 $%#54+5D #% # C#' 4-&'$*+. -//X+5D 6/' # 5&W C#'0 E 6/'1 /6 $+1.-& &A&5%

.'/C&$$+5D +5+%+#%+5D 4/W5$%' /6 #C%+/5$ W/3-4 M& %*& $%/'& 1#5#D&' '&Q3&$%+5D # 5&W 1/4&- 6/' 4+$.-#B>

M&C#3$& /6 %*& &A&5% %*#% #5 /-4&' 1/4&- W#$ $/-4 #54 -&6% #5 &1.%B $./% #% %*& 4-&'$*+.0 )*& '&Q3&$% W/3-4

M& 4/5& #% %*& 4-&' W*/ %*&5 +5 %3'5 '&Q3&$%$ $*+..+5D 6/' %*& C#' %/ %*& -/C#%+/5 /6 %*& 4-&'$*+.0 @./5

4&-+A&'B %*& $%/'& 1#5#D&' +$ 5/%+6+&4 #54 *& #''#5D&$ 6/' #5 &1.-/B&& %/ .+CX 3. %*& C#' #54 4'+A& +% %/ %*&

4-&'$*+. W*&'& *& 5/%+6+&$ %*& $%/'& 1#5#D&' %*#% %*& C#' #''+A&4 #54 %*& 1#5#D&' .+CX$ # $./% 6/' %*& C#' %/

M& 4+$.-#B&40 )*+$ 6/'1 /6 $+1.-& &A&5% .'/C&$$+5D +$ C/11/5-B 3$&4 %/ 4'+A& %*& '- %+1& 6-/W /6 W/'X> %#X+5D

%*& -#D #54 C/$% /3% /6 # M3$+5&$$0

H"9"9 I0%)3* ;B)10 $%&-),,.14

=5 $%' &A&5% .'/C&$$+5D $&A&'#- $/3'C&$ D&5&'#%& &A&5%$> W*+C* #'& %*&5 .'/C&$$&4 4+'&C%-B (Michelson,

2006)0 f/%* 5/%#M-& #54 /'4+5#'B &A&5%$ C#5 /CC3'0 R'4+5#'B &A&5%$ C#5 M& $C'&&5&4 6/' 5/%#M+-+%B #54

$%'&4 %/ +56/'1#%+/5 $3M$C'+M&'$(Michelson, 2006)0

H"9"F 2&*/()X ;B)10 $%&-),,.14

)*& 4+66&'&5C& M&%W&&5 N/1.-&O ;A&5% P'/C&$$+5D #54 K%' ;A&5% P'/C&$$+5D +$ %*#% N;P #-$/ #--/W$ B/3 %/

#CC&$$ &A&5%$ %*#% *#..&5&4 +5 %*& .#$% #54 3$& %*&1 +5 #5B /'4&' W*&'$ K;P /5-B #--/W$ B/3 %/ 3$& #54

#5#-B$& %*& &A&5%$ +5 %*& /'4&' %*&B #''+A&0 )*& &A&5% C#5 C/1& 6'/1 A#'+/3$ $/3'C&$ #54 1#B /CC3' /A&' #

-/5D .&'+/4 /6 %+1&0 N;P '&Q3+'&$ $/.*+$%+C#%&4 &A&5% +5%&'.'&%&'$> &A&5% .#%%&'5 4&6+5+%+/5 #54 1#%C*+5D #-/5D

W+%* C/''&-#%+/5 %&C*5+Q3&$0


35/109

HY

H"F I.0>30.&1 VP3%)1),,

;A&5 M&6/'& $&5$& #54 '&$./54 $B$%&1$ #$ 4&6+5&4 MB K0G#&CX&- +5 7888 (S.Haeckel, 1999)> "+C# ,0 ;54$-&B

'&$'C*&4 %*& %*&/'B /6 $+%3#%+/5 #W#'&5&$$ _KE` +5 4B5#1+C $B$%&1$ (Endsley, 1995, pp. 32-34)0 )*/3D*

+5+%+#--B %*& C/5C&.% /6 $+%3#%+/5 #W#'&5&$$ 4&$C'+M&$ # 1/4&- M#$&4 /5 +%$ '/-& +5 4B5#1+C *31#5 4&C+$+/5I

1#X+5D +5 # A#'+&%B /6 4/1#+5$> +% +$ %*+$ $#1& C/5C&.%> W*+C* -&4 %/ %*& &A&5% .'/C&$$+5D C/5C&.%$ W& X5/W

%/4#B0 K/1& /6 %*& %*&/'+&$ 3$&4 +5 ;54$-&B($ '&$'C* 4#%& M#CX %/ 78[80 =% +$ 6/' %*+$ '$/5 %*#% %*& 1#+5$%&.$ /6 KE #'& 4+$C3$$&4 *&'& %/ .'&$&5% B/3 W+%* # C-' .+C%3'& /6 ;A&5% P'/C&$$+5D #54 +%$ *+$%/'B0

#$ W& X5/W +%

%/4#B0 )*&'& +$ # .&'C&.%+/5 /6 %*& &5A+'/51&5% W+%*+5 # A/-31& /6 %+1& #54 $.#C& _&A&5% .'/C&$$+5D #-$/

'C%$ /5 # .&'C&.%+/5 _/' $%#%&` /6 %*& &5A+'/51&5%`> %*& C/1.'&*&5$+/5 /6 %*&+' 1+5D _%*+$ $%&. C#5 M&

$&&5 #$ %*& '3-&$ /6 N;P W*+C* #44 1+5D %/ C&'%#+5 &A&5%$`> #54 %*& .'/e&C%+/5 /6 %*&+' $%#%3$ +5 %*& 5'

63%3'& _)*+$ .#'% C/5C&'5$ %*& 4&C+$+/5$ %*#% W+-- M& 1#4& M#$&4 /5 %*& C/1.'&*&5$+/5`0 )*& 1/4&- 4&6+5&4 6/'

KE _S+D3'& 8` $*/W$ %*'&& -&A&-$ +5 K+%3#%+/5 EW#'&5&$$0 #54 4B5#1+C$ /6

'&-&A#5% &-&1&5%$ +5 %*& &5A+

msc thesis ralph matroos v1.0

Documents