8/2/2019 MS - 2012-04-19 - TAITZ - Petition to the SCOMS to Reassign Judge + Proof of Service

1/7

Hr. Nrms Xkcxt- IR[.?3

8/2/2019 MS - 2012-04-19 - TAITZ - Petition to the SCOMS to Reassign Judge + Proof of Service

2/7

IGI_EI@BS C@XI_MNBYXN_S KVVIKM XN XLI RYV_IGI BNY_XNA GCRRCRRCVVC- IGI_EI@BS VIXCXCN@ XN XLI RYV_IGI BNY_XNA GCRRCRRCVVC AN_ _IKRRCE@GI@X NA XLI BKRI XN KHCAAI_I@X DYHEIBngi `nu vixcxcn`ir Hr. Nrms Xkcxt- IR[- liric` /Xkcxt/ k`h vixcxcn` xliRyvrigi Bnyrx na Gcccvvc xn rikce` xli bki xn k hcaairi`x dyhei.

RXKXIGI@X NA AKBXR;. Xlc bki kx lk`h uk xcgims acmih os Vixcxcn`ir Nrms Xkcxt- liric`kaxir /Xkcxt/ .?. Xli bki riqnmqi krny`h xli akbx xlkx Hignbrkxcb vkrxs na Gcccvvcyogcxxih xn xli Ribrixkrs na Rxkxi xli `kgi na Okrkbj Nokgk k Vrichi`xckmbk`hchkxi. Xkcxt yogcxxih xn xli Hignbrkxcb vkrxs k` imibxcn` blkmmi`ei ucxlunr` kaachkqcx na i|virx k`h ucx`ii lnuc`e Nokgk yc`e k anreih ocrxlbirxcacbkxi k`h k xnmi` Bn``ibxcbyx Rnbckm Ribyrcxs `ygoir 68?'1

8/2/2019 MS - 2012-04-19 - TAITZ - Petition to the SCOMS to Reassign Judge + Proof of Service

3/7

;6. Anr xli acrx xcgi dyhei Bnmigk` bn`xkbxih xli vkrxci c` xli bki- uk qck i'gkcm xun hks kaxir xli imibxcn`.C ; . Hiai`hk`x4 Hignbrkxcb vkrxs na Gcccvvc k`h xli Ribrixkrs na Rxkxi naGcccvvc anrukrhih i'gkcm xn dyhei Bnmigk` k`hXkcxt- uliri xlis nyelxhcgckm na xli bki.;?. Xkcxt rivn`hih k`h i'gkcmih dyhei Bnmigk` k`h xli hiai`hk`x.;2. Gnxcn` likrc`e uk ix anr Kvrcm ;1xl.;8. K xli Hiai`hk`x Hignbrkxcb Vkrxs bmkcgih xlkx xli bngvmkc`x c arcqnmny-Xkcxt nyelx xn yovni`k ucx`ii xn kvvikr c` bnyrx xn vrnqi xlkx xli bngvmkc`x c`nx arcqnmny.;9. K Xkcxt c k vrn i vmkc`xcaa- li acmih k gnxcn` k`h k` kaachkqcx kxxixc`e xn xliakbx xlkx yovni`k c `ibikrs anr xli yvbngc`e likrc`e. Six kekc`- xlc gnxcn`k`h kaachkqcx uiri ce`nrih os dyhei Bnmigk` k`hXkcxt bnymh `nx yovni`kucx`ii anr xli likrc`e. Rli hch vyrblki kcrvmk`i xcbjix anr lirima k`h n`iucx`i xn kvvikr c` Gcccvvc kx xli likrc`e.;1. Rlnrxms oianri xli likrc`e dyhei Bnmigk` i'gkcmih xli vkrxci xlkx hyi xnlikmxl rikn` li `iih xn bk`bim xli Kvrcm ;1 likrc`e k`h cx ucmm oi riblihymihanr k mkxir hkxi.m5.K dyhei Bnmigk` bngvmixims ce`nrih xli bki vrcnr xn xli vrcgkrs imibxcn`- cxuk `ibikrs xn acmi k `iu blkmmi`ei anr xli Ei`irkm imibxcn`. Xkcxt yogcxxihei`irkm imibxcn` blkmmi`ei xn xli Hignbrkxcb vkrxs k ri{ycrih os mku k`h six kekc`xli Hignbrkxcb vkrxs ce`nrih xli blkmmi`ei. N` Kvrcm ;?-?6;? Xkcxt bngvmixihhrkaxc`e na xli Acrx Kgi`hih Bngvmkc`x- ulcbl riairrih xn xli Ei`irkm imibxcn`k`h yogcxxih cx xn dyhei Bnmigk` n` Kvrcm ;2xl. N` xli kgi hks xli hiai`hk`xacmih k` k`uir xn xli bngvmkc`x.;

8/2/2019 MS - 2012-04-19 - TAITZ - Petition to the SCOMS to Reassign Judge + Proof of Service

4/7

kxxngis vrn lkb qcbi- ulirios li bnymh yogcx xli yovni`k xn xli bmirj na xlibnyrx anr ce`kxyri k`h `nx onxlirdyhei bnmigk` ucxl ri{yix xn ce` yovni`knr kmxigkxcqims li kjih anr dyhei bnmigk` xn ce` xli yovni`k- ulcbl libnymh yi xn i`anrbi xli yovni`k c` bkmcangck- uliri li c`xi`hih xn bn`hybxngi na xli hivncxcn`. Xkcxt kmn kjih anr bmkrcacbkxcn` na xli xkxy na xli bkic` riekrh xn xli Acrx kgi`hih bngvmkc`x- k cx uk hrkaxih k`h ce`ih n` Kvrcmm?xl k k acrx Kgi`hih bngvmkc`x k na _celx oianri acmc`e na k` k`uir- oyxbrnih c` xli gkcm ucxl xli k`uir acmih os xli hiai`i.;

8/2/2019 MS - 2012-04-19 - TAITZ - Petition to the SCOMS to Reassign Judge + Proof of Service

5/7

9. Xli akbx xlkx dyhei Bnmigk` hch `nx bn`xkbx xli vkrxci anr k gn`xl k`h ukcxihy`xcm kaxir xli vrcgkrs imibxcn`- lnu xlkx dyhei Bnmigk` c ockih kekc`x xlcbki k`h kekc`x xli Vmkc`xcaa Xkcxt k`h cgvms hibchih xn jcmm xli bki oianri cxxkrxih.1. Xli akbx xlkx dyhei Bnmigk` ukcxih anr k gn`xl y`xcm kaxir xli vrcgkrs imibxcn`lnu k` koyi nadyhcbckm hcbrixcn`- k xli bki bmikrms lkh xn oi likrh xcgimsoianri xli vrcgkrs. Xlc c vkrxcbymkrms ieriecny c` mcelx na xli akbxxlkx Xkcxtvrnqchih dyhei Bnmigk` ucxl iqchi`bi xlkx Okrkbj Nokgk c yc`e k anreih ocrxlbirxcacbkxi k`h k Rnbckm Ribyrcxs `ygoi{ ulcbl uk `iqir kce`ih xn lcg. DyheiBnmigk` lkh c` arn`x na lcg iqchi`bi na xli erikxix brcgc`kmcxs c` xli lcxnrs naxlc `kxcn`- yyrvkxcn` na xli Y.R. Vrichi`bs k`h li gkhi k bn`bci`bi hibccn` xnecqi Okrkbj Nokgk k vk k`h kmmnu lcg n` xli okmmnx c` xli Vrcgkrs imibxcn`ucxlnyx k emcxbl.5 . Xkcxt uk i`xcxmih xn lir Acrx kgi`hgi`x rcelx xn k gik`c`eaym rihri naerciqk`bi. Xlc rcelx uk qcnmkxih os dyhei Bnmigk` y`hir bnmnr na kyxlnrcxs-uli` dyhei Bnmigk` cgvms ce`nrih lir vrcgkrs imibxcn` blkmmi`ei y`xcm kaxir xliimibxcn`.

_IAYRKM XN V_NQCHI BMK_CACBKXCN@ K@H ICXLI_ RXE@RYOVNI@KR N_ E_K@X V_N LKB QCBI HI@CIR XKCXT GIK@CEAYM_IH_IRR NA E_CIQK@BIR HY_C@E XLI EI@I_KM IMIBXCN@BLKMMI@EI.m. Kaxir Xkcxt uk hi`cih lir acrx kgi`hgi`x rcelx anr rihri na erciqk`bihyrc`e xli vrcgkrs blkmmi`ei- li c hiivms bn`bigih konyx cgcmkr hi akbxn hi`ckmna lir Acrx Kgi`hgi`x rcelx `nu hyrc`e xli ei`irkm imibxcn` blkmmi`ei.?. K vibymckr cxykxcn` hiqimnvih c` xlkx xli Acrx kgi`hih bngvmkc`x ,I|lcocx ?#uk yogcxxih xn dyhei Bnmigk` xli kgi hks k xli k`uir. Xli acrx kgi`hihbngvmkc`x uk hrkaxih k k gkxxir na rcelx- vrcnr xn k` k`uir oic`e acmih. Xkcxtkjihdyhei anr bmkrcacbkxcn`- k xn ulkx c xli xkxy na xli bki4 hni dyheiBnmigk` ii cx k k Acrx kgi`hih Bngvmkc`x k k gkxxir na rcelx nr ucmm li vrnqchik mikqi na bnyrx anr xli Acrx Kgi`hih Bngvmkc`x. Dyhei Bnmigk` hch `nx vrnqchik`s bmkrcacbkxcn`- ulcbl gkji cx hcaacbymx xn j`nu anr yri ulcbl bngvmkc`x c xlinvirkxcqi vmikhc`e.2. Rc`bi xli hiai`hk`x acmih k` k`uir- xli vkrxci kri c` hcbnqirs vlki- lnuiqirDyhei Bnmigk` c hi`sc`e Xkcxt k`s gik`c`eaym hcbnqirs k vkrx na lir AcrxKgi`hgi`x rcelx anr _ihri na Erciqk`bi k li c `icxlir rivn`hc`e xn lir`ygirny vixcxcn` k`h kaarhkqcx ucxl ri{yix xn ce` Gcccvvc yovni`k nrukcqi k vrnbihyrkm ri{ycrigi`x nak mnbkm kxxnr`is bn'ce`nr k`h erk`x lir vrn lkbqcbi- n xlkx li bk` cyi Gcccvvc yovni`k lirima k`h lkqi xlig ce`ih osxli bmirj na xli bnyrx. @nx n`ms Xkcxt bk``nx bn`hybx gik`c`eaym ei`irkm hcbnqirs

Xkcxt q Hignbrkxcb Vkrxs m`xirmnbyxnrs kvvikm xn xli Ryvrigi Bnyrx 9

8/2/2019 MS - 2012-04-19 - TAITZ - Petition to the SCOMS to Reassign Judge + Proof of Service

6/7

c` xli bki- li c `nx komi xn yovni`k ucx`ii anr xli likrc`e xlkx dyheiBnmigk` c c`xi`hc`e xn lnmh n` Gks 5xl-?6;?.8. Dyhei Bnmigk` c `nx rivn`hc`e k`h `nx vrnqchc`e k`s bmkrcacbkxcn`- ulkxgnxcn` c li c`xi`hc`e xn likr kx xli gnxcn` likrc`e- k`h `nx vrnqchc`e k`sgik`c`eaym bmkrcacbkxcn` nr rivn`i n` xli bki.9. Xlc c k bki na `kxcn`km cgvnrxk`bi. Kxxkblih Acrx kgi`hih Bngvmkc`x k`hi|lcocx lnu xli gnx ieriecny brcgc`kmcxs os Okrkbj Nokgk k`h ngienqiggi`xkm oyrikybrkx kchc`e k`h koixxc`e lcg c` lchc`e lc yi na k anreihocrxl birxcacbkxi k`h lc yi na k Bn``ibxcbyx Rnbckm Ribyrcxs `ygoi{ ulcbl uk`iqir kce`ih xn lcg. Ui lkqi k` c`hcqchykm ucxl y`j`nu` nrcec` k`h y`j`nu`kmmieck`bi yyrvc`e xli Ulcxi Lnyi k`h c`xi`hc`e xn vrnmn`e xlc yyrvkxcn` anranyr gnri sikr nr vncoms mn`eir. Bcqcm rcelx na iqirs Kgircbk` bcxcti`- YRibn`ngs k`h `kxcn`km ibyrcxs kri kx xkji. Xli blrn`nmnes k`h xli akbx na xlibki lnu xlkx xli vibckm dyhei kce`ih os xli vrichc`e dyhei na xli RyvrigiBnyrx- c ockih kekc`x xli Vmkc`xcaa k`h qcnmkxih xli Vmkc`xcaa rcelx anr rihrinaerciqk`bi hyrc`e xli vrcgkrs imibxcn`. Xliri c k ircny bn`big xlkx xlc ockucmm bn`xc`yi `nu hyrc`e xli ei`irkm imibxcn` blkmmi`ei.Okih n` kmm na xli konqi cx c `ibikrs xn rikce` xlc bki xn k`nxlir vibckmdyhei.

BN@BMYRCN@Okih n` kmm na xli iqchi`bi k`h kreygi`x vrii`xih liric` xli bki kx lk`hlnymh oi rikce`ih xn k hcaairi`x vibckm dyhei._ivibxaymms ryKPcxx/kr--%% m r-'''%%. .''C$ Hr. Nrms Xkcxt. IR[ ]

Xkcxt q Hignbrkxcb Vkrxs C`xirmnbyxnrs kvvikm xn xli Ryvrigi Bnyrx

8/2/2019 MS - 2012-04-19 - TAITZ - Petition to the SCOMS to Reassign Judge + Proof of Service

7/7

Vrnna na irqcbim% _cxk Gngxktck`- kg nqir ;< sikr nmh- `nx k vkrxs xn xlc kbxcn` k`h C kxxix xlkx C irqih kmm xli vkrxcic` xli konqi bkvxcn`ih kbxcn` ucxl xlc xli konqi gnxcn` n` 68.;3.?N?

c`ih_Uhkxih a'LzcY