morgan stanley mutual fund v kartick das 1994 scw 2801

8/13/2019 Morgan Stanley Mutual Fund v Kartick Das 1994 SCW 2801

1/12

Equivalent Citation: (1994)96BOMLR933, (1995)1CALLT18(SC), [1994]81CompCas318(SC), JT1994(3)SC654,1994(2)SCALE1121, (1994)4SCC225, [1994]Supp1SCR136

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

C!" App#a" $os% 4584 a&' 458 o 1994%

*#+'#' O& 2-%-5%1994

App#""a&.s Morgan Stanley Mutual Fund!"

R#spo&'#&. #arti$% Da!

&ITH

App#""a&.s Arvind 'u(ta!"

R#spo&'#&. Se$uritie! and E)$*ange +oard o, India and Or!"

Hon-.le /udge!: A%S% A&a&', M%$% /#&0a.a+a"a a&' S% Moa&, JJ%

Coun!el!:o App#""a&.#..o"a&. Ashok H. Desai, Arun Jaitley, R. Karanjawala, Dina Wadia, Nandini Gorea&' M.Karanjawala, A'!s

o R#spo&'#&.s*##&'a&. K.V. Vishwanathana&' L.P. Arawala, A'!s%

Su.0e$t: Media and Co11uni$ation

Su.0e$t: Con!u1er

A$t!2Rule!2Order!:Co&sum# o.#+.o& A+., 1986 S#+.o&s 2(1), 14

Ca!e! Re,erred:Ma+07 #s.o&7 Bau+a !% a'"a" Saaa : Co% MAN!"MH"##$%"&'(); Ma'o"a" S&'u o Boma< !%O+a" Ass=# o Boma< MAN!"MH"##$&"&'$'; C>T !% S.a&'a' /a++um O" Co%MAN!"*+"#&(,"&')%

Prior Hi!tory:om .# Ju'=m#&. a&' O'# 'a.#' 411994 o .# Ca"+u..a *s.+. Co&sum# *spu.#s R#'#ssa" oum & C%*%%Cas# $o% 35 o 1994 a&' om .# Ju'=m#&. a&' O'# 'a.#' 511994 o .# *#" ?= Cou. & %% $o% 14 o1994%

Di!(o!ition:C%A% $o% 4584 o 1994 a""o@#'% C%A% $o% 458 o 1994 'smss#'

Citing Re,eren$e:S.a.# o #s. B#&=a" a&' Os% !% S@apa& uma ua a&' Os% a&' Sa&+a.a >&!#s.m#&.s a&' Os%

*ss#&.#'Ma+07 #s.o&7 Bau+a a&' Os% !% a' La" Saaa : Com% *s+uss#'Ma'o La" S&'u o Boma< !% O+a" Ass=# o Boma< a&' Os% *ss#&.#'Commsso o >&+om#.a (C#&.a") Ca"+u..a !% S.a&'a' /a+uum O" Co% *ss#&.#'D&.#' Comm#+a" Ba&0 !% Ba&0 o >&'a MAN!"*+"###-"&'& *s+uss#'S! uma Ca'a !% Mu&+pa" Copoa.o& o *#" MAN!"*+"#%(("&''- *s+uss#'Ta


2/12

/UD'MENTS" Mo*an3 /"

1% L#a!# =a&.#'%

2% T# app#""a&. s a 'om#s.+ mu.ua" u&' #=s.##' @. S#+u.#s a&' E+a&=# Boa' o >&'a (##&a.####' .o as FSEB>F) u&'# R#=s.a.o& $o% M--5931, 'a.#' 5%11%93% T# app#""a&. s ma&a=#' < a Boa' oTus.##s% usua&. .o .# SEB> (Mu.ua" u&') R#=u"a.o&s, .# &!#s.m#&. ma&a=#m#&. +ompa&< o .# app#""a&.,Mo=a& S.a&"#< Ass#. Ma&a=#m#&. >&'a !a.# Lm.#' @as #=s.##' @. SEB> o& 5%11%93% D&'# su+#=s.a.o& Mo=a& S.a&"#< Ass#. Ma&a=#m#&. >&'a !a.# Lm.#' s +o&s..u.#' as .# ass#. ma&a=#m#&.+ompa&< o .# app#""a&.% Mo=a& S.a&"#< Ass#. Ma&a=#m#&. >&'a !a.# Lm.#' s a sus'a< o Mo=a& S.a&"#&+% @+ o"'s 5G o #Hu.&'a!a.# Lm.#' @as =a&.#' +#.+a.# o &+opoa.o& o& 18. O+.o#, 1993 < .# R#=s.a o Compas,Boma.s M#moa&'um a&' A.+"# o Asso+a.o& a!# a"so ##& appo!#' < .# SEB> as p# .# po!so&s o.# sa' R#=u"a.o&s%

3% T# 'a. s+#m# o .# app#""a&. @as appo!#' < .# Boa' o Tus.##s < C+u"a R#so"u.o& 'a.#' 8%11%93%Ts @as o@a'#' .o SEB> o .s appo!a" o& 1-%11%93% T# s+#m# @as 'u"< s+u.&s#' a&' #am' < .#SEB> a&' SEB> =a!# .s appo!a" a&' +#.a& am#&'m#&.s @## su==#s.#'%

Dpo& #+#p. o su+ appo!a" o .# s+#m#, .# app#""a&. a&' .# >&!#s.m#&. Ma&a=# .oo0 +#ssa< s.#ps .o#=& ma0#.&= .# s+#m# < ssu# o a'!#.s#m#&.s% A"" a'!#.s#m#&.s a&' pu"+.< ma.#a" @## appo!#' & @.&= #o# pu"+a.o& as #Hu#' < .# R#=u"a.o&s% usua&. .o su+ appo!a" .# app#""a&.+omm#&+#' a'!#.s&= .# pu"+ ssu#%

4% O& 18. *#+#m#, 1993 .# a'!#.s#m#&.s a&' oa'&=s @## #"#as#'% O R#=u"a.o&s s +omp"#' < .# O 1 a&' O 2%

O4 : O5 %#% T# Ba&0#s .o .# o# a# sp#++a""< #s.a' om a++#p.&= a&< app"+a.o& om o Mo=a&S.a&"#< o@. u&' om a&


3/12

A==#!#' < .s o'#, +!" app#a" as&= ou. o SL(C) $o% 22 o 1994 as +om# .o # p###'%

A=a&s. .# 'smssa" o . #..o& $o% 14 o 1994 < .# ?= Cou. o *#" +!" app#a" as&= ou. o SL $o% 321o 1994 as +om# .o # p###'%

6% M% Aso0 *#sa "#a' Cou&s#" o .# app#""a&. (Mo=a& S.a&"#< Mu.ua" u&') u=#s .# o""o@&=

(a) A posp#+.!# &!#s.o s &o. a +o&sum# .o p## a +omp"a&. u&'# .# Co&sum# o.#+.o& A+., 1986(##&a.# ###' .o as F.# A+.F)% > .a. # so, a !o"u&.a< +o&sum# asso+a.o& +a&&o. +omp"a& aou. .# ssu#o sa#s% T# sa#s a# &o. =oo's as '#' u&'# S#+.o& (/i0o .# A+.% E!#& o.#@s#, .## +a& # &o+o&sum# asso+a.o& o posp#+.!# app"+a&.s o u.u# pop#.#s% T# ssu# o sa#s @as .o op#& o& 2. Ap",1993% T# so +a""#' +o&sum# as & "a@, a posp#+.!# &!#s.o 'o#s &o. #+om# a +o&sum# as '#' u&'# .# A+.% E!#& assum&= .a. sa#s+ou"' # =oo's #o# a""o.m#&., .# so+a""#' +o&sum# as .# pu+as#' .# =oo's o a +o&s'#a.o& &o#' .# s#!+#s o .# +ompa&< o +o&s'#a.o&% ?#&+#, # s &o. #&.."#' .o ma0# a&< +omp"a&.%

(+) T## #&= &o .a&sa+.o& o u


4/12

R#=u"a.o& 2 a&' .a. .# app#""a&. '' &o. a!# a&< appo!a" as s +"#a om .# o@& 'o+um#&.% O&"< a "#..#om SEB> s##0&= .# +"a+a.o& om .# app#""a&. s po'u+#'% Ts 'o#s &o., . s u=#', amou&. .o a& appo!a" &"a@%

>. s u.# u=#' < M% /s@a&a.a& .a. .# a&0#s .o .# ssu# a. Ca"+u..a @## #a""< &os.#&.% T#o+u# &'+a.#s .a. .# app"+a.o& oms +ou"' # #+#!#' & Ca"+u..a a. .# Ba&0 o Bo'a, O"' Cou. ?ous#S.##. a&' Copoa.o& Ba&0% Capp"&= S.##.% Bo. .#s# a&+#s, . s u=#', a# &os.#&. @"# .## s &o

a&+ o Ba&0 o Bao'a a. O"' Cou. ?ous# S.##.% T## s &o s.##. +a""#' Capp"&= S.##. a. Ca"+u..a%

T# ass o a""o.m#&. @a. s s.& S%L%% (+) 32194, .# app#""a&. @ou"' u=# .a. .# ?= Cou. as 'smss#' .# @. p#..o& @.ou. a sp#a0&=o'#% T## @## mpo.a&. po&.s as#' & .# @. p#..o&% T# a&&ou&+#m#&. o .# mpu=' s+#m# o pu"+ssu# o u&.s < .# app#""a&. s, . s +o&.#&'#', @.ou. .# appo!a" o SEB> a&' s ""#=a" a&' .a. < popos&= .#a""o.m#&. o u&.s as#' o& s. +om# s. s#!#' ass, a .#a.m#&. s &o. m#.#' ou. .o sma"" &!#s.Os% T## s+o&.a!#&.o& o S#+.o&s %%, )-a&' )o .# >&'a& Compas A+., 1956% To o"' ou., as .# app#""a&. as 'o,.a. .# a""o.m#&. o u&.s @"" # as#' o& m a""o.m#&. ass a&' @. a +a=#' spo&so & .# a'!#.s#m#&. s, .s +o&.#&'#', ""#=a" & "a@, apa. om . #&= !o"a.!# o .# &oms a&' pa+.+#s & .# +ap.a" ma0#.% >& su+ a+as#, .# mp#&'&= 'sas.# +ou"' # a!o'#' o&"< < a Hu&."# &.###&+# o .# Cou.% >. s a"so u=#' .a. &'a < a& a'm&s.a.!# ++u"a +o&s..u.#' .# S#+u.#s a&' E+a&=# Boa' o >&'a (SEB>) o &!#s.ospo.#+.o&% O& 3-%1%1992, a& O'&a&+# 0&o@& as SEB> O'&a&+# @as pomu"=a.#'% O& 21%2%1992, a "" @as

4
http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','18561','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','18576','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','18581','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','25648','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0120/1982','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0120/1982','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','2742','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','18561','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','18576','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','18581','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','25648','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0120/1982','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/SC/0120/1982','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','2742','1');


5/12

&.o'u+#' &am#"< .# SEB> B"" o 1992 @+ #+am# .# A+. o& 4. Ap", 1992% >. +am# &.o o+# o& 13%1%1992 ass.a.#' & S#+.o& &/iii0o .# S#+u.< : E+a&=# Co&.o" Boa' o >&'a A+.%

O& 29%5%1992, .# Cap.a" >ssu#s Co&.o" A+., 194 @as #p#a"#'%

1-% Mu.ua" u&'s & >&'a a# #=u"a.#' < SEB> pusua&. .o .# S#+u.#s : E+a&=# Boa' o >&'a (Mu.ua" u&'s)R#=u"a.o&s, 1993% D&'# .# sa' R#=u"a.o&s, a"" mu.ua" u&'s & >&'a as a"so .# ass#. ma&a=#m#&. +ompas

a&' .# +us.o'a&s o .# mu.ua" u&'s ass#.s a# #Hu#' .o # #=s.##' @. .# SEB>% $o mu.ua" u&' & >&'a+a& appoa+ .# ma0#. @. a s+#m# u&"#ss s+#m# as ##& u""< appo!#' < SEB> @+ s .# so"# au.o.>CATE O RE>STRAT>O$

1% >& ##+s# o .# po@#s +o#' < S#+.o& -#o .# S#+u.#s a&' E+a&=# Boa' o >&'a A+., 1992 (15 o1992) #a' @. S#+u.#s a&' E+a&=# Boa' o >&'a (Mu.ua" u&') R#=u"a.o&s, 1993 ma'# .##u&'# .#Boa' ##< =a&.s a +#.+a.# o #=s.a.o& .o

MORA$ STA$LEI MDTDAL D$*

as a Mu.ua" u&'%

) R#=s.a.o& +o'# o .# Mu.ua" u&' s M--5931

B< o'#%

T# app#""a&. +ompa&< s ma&a=#' < a oa' o Tus.##s% >& a++o'a&+# @. .# sa' R#=u"a.o&s, .# &!#s.m#&.ma&a=#m#&. +ompa&< o .# app#""a&. Mo=a& S.a&"#< Ass#. Ma&a=#m#&. >&'a !.% L.'% s a"so #=s.##' @.

SEB>% T# +#.+a.# .o .s ##+. s as u&'#

SECDR>T>ES A$*EKC?A$E BOAR* O >$*>A

L.."# : Co%

C#&.a" Ba&0 Bu"'&=Boma< 4-- -23

>> MAR2299693 $o!#m# 5, 1993%

*#a S,

RE Mo=a& S.a&"#< Mu.ua" u&'

Ts as ###&+# .o .# app"+a.o& ma'# < Mo=a& : S.a&"#< up, >&+%, .o spo&so a Mu.ua" u&'%

>& .#ms o R#=u"a.o& 2- o .# S#+u.#s a&' E+a&=# Boa' o >&'a (Mu.ua" u&'s) R#=u"a.o&s 1993, @###< =a&. ou appo!a" .o Mo=a& S.a&"#< Ass#. Ma&a=#m#&. >&'a !.% L.'%, .o a+. as .# Ass#. Ma&a=#m#&.Compa&< o Mo=a& S.a&"#< Mu.ua" u&'%

5
http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','25634','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','26100','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','25634','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','26100','1');


6/12

# a"so =a&. #=s.a.o& .o Mo=a& S.a&"#< Mu.ua" u&' & .#ms o R#=u"a.o& 9 o .# R#=u"a.o&s su7#+. .o .###+u.o& o .# Cus.o'a& A=##m#&. #.@##& .# Boa' o Tus.##s a&' S.o+0 ?o"'&= Copoa.o& o >&'a L.'%T# +#.+a.# o R#=s.a.o& & om B s #&+"os#'% "#as# Huo.# .# R#=s.a.o& &um# & % O& 8%11%1993, .# Boa' o Tus.##s, < a++u"a R#so"u.o& appo!#' .# 'a. s+#m#, .# sam# @as o@a'#' .o SEB> o& 1-%11%1993% T# s+#m# @as'u"< s+u.&s#' a&' #am' < .# SEB>% B< .s "#..# 'a.#' 23%11%1993, a''#ss#' .o E&am &a&+a" Co&su".a&.s!.% L.'%, o o .# 7o& L#a' Ma&a=#s, SEB> =a!# .s appo!a"% >. s s.a.#' .a. .# s+#m# as ##& #am' @as +omp"#' @.% >. s a.# .s .# app#""a&. .oo0 .# +#ssa< s.#ps a&' #=a&ma0#.&= .# s+#m# < ssu&= a'!#.s#m#&.s & .# p#ss, o"'&= p#s#&.a.o&s @. o0#s #.+% A""a'!#.s#m#&.s a&' pu"+.< ma.#a" a!# ##& appo!#' < SEB> as u&'#

S#+u.#s a&' E+a&=# Boa' o >&'a%

E&am &a&+a" Co&su".a&.s !.% L.'%24 B* Ra7aaa'u Compou&',Ama"a" *os Ma=,Boma> MAR2465593 $o!#m# 25, 1993%

*#a S,

R# A'!#.s#m#&. +ampa=& o Mo=a& S.a&"#&+%

. ###&+# .o


7/12

> #&+"os# a +op< o "#..# #+#!#' om SEB> & #=a' .o .# +a&=#s su==#s.#' & .# FS+#m# Campa=&F% "#as#+a< ou. .# +a&=#s as #Hu#' < SEB> a&' =#. .# appo!a" o Mo=a& S.a&"#< Ass#s. Ma&a=#m#&. #o# .s#"#as#%

Ta&0&= & !#@ o .s, . @"" # +"#a .a. .# a""#=a.o&s o #spo&'#&.s .a. .#SEB> as &o. appo!#' .# o.# 'o+um#&.s s .o.a""< as#"#ss%

12% T## s a"so a +a""#&=# .o .# m#.o' o a""o.m#&.% T# #"#!a&. +"aus# p#.a&&= .o .# m#.o' o a""o.m#&. sas u&'#

T# o# T# .a=#.#' amou&. .o # ssu#' s Rs% 3-- +o#s% D&.s a# .o # ssu#' a. a p+# o Rs% 1- p# u&.,pa


8/12

po+##'s +a& # &!#s.#' Hu+0"< .o #. om .# ma0#. oppo.u&.#s% Ts #'u+#s .# +os. o +o""#+.o& .a. .#&!#s.o as .o #a% >& .s ma& < a'op.&= .# s. +om# s. s#!#' ass .# s+#m# #+om#s mo#&!#s.o #&'"R (1926) C 38 % >. @as os#!#' .us

T# Compa&< s #&.."#' .o '#a" @. .# sa#o"'# @o s o& .# #=s.#, a&' o&"< a p#so& @o s o& .# #=s.#s & .# u"" s#&s# o .# @o' o@ o .# sa#% Bu. .# .."# .o =#. o& .# #=s.# +o&ss.s & .# poss#sso& o a+#.+a.# .o=#.# @. a .a&s# s=' < .# #=s.##' o"'#% Ts s @a. Bau+a a'% ?# a' .# +#.+a.#s

8
http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','2726','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','25374','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','25374','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','25374','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/MH/0045/1926','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','2726','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','25374','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','25374','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/ba/disp.asp','25374','1');http://fnopenglobalpopup%28%27/citation/crosscitations.asp','MANU/MH/0045/1926','1');


9/12

a&' "a&0 .a&s#s, s=' < .# #=s.##' o"'#s% >. @ou"' # a& ups#. o a"" S.o+0 E+a&=# .a&sa+.o&s .@## su==#s.#' .a. a o0# @o so"' sa#s < =#a" '#s+p.o& '' &o. mp"#m#&. s a=a& < supp"R (195-) C 21, . @as #"' .us

A sa"# a++o'&= .o .# Sa"# o oo's A+. (a&' & >&'a =oo's &+"u'# sa#s o 7o&. s.o+0 +ompas) .a0#s p"a+#@#& .# pop#.< pass#s om .# s#""# .o .# u #=a' s a' .o .#'#&.o& o +omp"a&. u&'# .# A+., . @"" # +"#a .a. &o posp#+.!# &!#s.o +ou"' a"" u&'# .# A+.%

a. s .a. # +ou"' +omp"a& o u&'# .# A+. Ts .a0#s us .o .# '#&.o& o +omp"a&. u&'# S#+.o& (/10@+#a's as o""o@s

2(+) +omp"a&. m#a&s a&< a""#=a.o& & @.&= ma'# < a +omp"a&a&. .a.

() as a #su". o a&< u&a .a'# pa+.+# a'op.#' < a&< .a'#, .# +omp"a&a&. as su##' "oss o 'ama=#;

() .# =oo's m#&.o' & .# +omp"a&. su# om o o mo# '##+.s;

() .# s#!+#s m#&.o' & .# +omp"a&. su# om '#+#&+< & a&< #sp#+.;

(!) a .a'# as +a=#' o .# =oo's m#&.o' & .# +omp"a&. a p+# & #+#ss o .# p+# #' < o u&'# a&& !#@ o ou a&s@#s .o Hu#s.o&s $o% 1 : 2, . o""o@s .a. .# Co&sum# o.#+.o& oum as &o 7us'+.o&@a.so#!#%

19% % $o% 4 a. a# .# =u'&= p&+p"#s & #"a.o& .o .# =a&. o a& a'&.#m &7u&+.o& & su+ a#as o .#u&+.o&&= o .# +ap.a"ma0#. a&' pu"+ ssu#s o .# +opoa.# s#+.os a&' @#.# +#.a& F!#&u# #s.+.o&

+"aus#sF @ou"' #Hu# .o # #!o"!#' 7u'+a""< as as ##& 'o & +as#s su+ as Sa&+a.aFs +as# (supa) #.+%

As a p&+p"#, #pa.# &7u&+.o& +ou"' # =a&.#' o&"< u&'# #+#p.o&a" ++ums.a&+#s% T# a+.os @+ sou"'@#= @. .# Cou. & .# =a&. o #pa.# &7u&+.o& a#

(a) @## #paa"# o s#ous ms+# @"" #&su# .o .# p"a&.;

() @#.# .# #usa" o #pa.# &7u&+.o& @ou"' &!o"!# =#a.# &7us.+# .a& .# =a&. o . @ou"' &!o"!#;

(+) .# +ou. @"" a"so +o&s'# .# .m# a. @+ .# p"a&. s. a' &o.+# o .# a+. +omp"a' so .a. .# ma0&=o mpop# o'# a=a&s. a pa.< & s as#&+# s p#!#&.#';

(') .# +ou. @"" +o&s'# @#.# .# p"a&. a' a+Hu#s+#' o som# .m# a&' & su+ ++ums.a&+#s . @"" &o.

=a&. # pa.# &7u&+.o&;

(#) .# +ou. @ou"' #p#+. a pa.< app"&'a @as a pa&S! uma Ca'a !% Muni1i2al +or2oration o8 Delhi MAN!"*+"#%(("&''- [1993]3SCR522 , . s s.a.#' asu&'#

T# Cou. sa"" #+o' .# #aso&s @< a& #pa.# o'# &7u&+.o& @as #&= pass#' & .# a+.s a&' ++ums.a&+#so a pa.+u"a +as#% >& .s a+0=ou&', .# #Hu#m#&. o #+o'&= .# #aso&s o =a&. o # pa.# &7u&+.o&+a&&o. # #"' .o # a m## oma".


11/12

.# po!so as ##& o""o@#'% T# pa.< @+ &!o0#s .# 7us'+.o& o .# +ou. o =a&. o a& o'# o #s.a&a=a&s. a pa.


12/12

23% % $o% 5 a. s .# s+op# o S#+.o& &$o .# A+. T# sa' S#+.o& #a's as u&'#

(1) >, a.# .# po+##'&= +o&'u+.#' u&'# S#+.o& &-, .# *s.+. oum s sa.s#' .a. .# =oo's +omp"a'a=a&s. su# om a&< o .# '##+.s sp#+#' & .# +omp"a&. o .a. a&< o .# a""#=a.o&s +o&.a' & .#+omp"a&. aou. .# s#!+#s a# po!#', . sa"" ssu# a& o'# .o .# oppos.# pa.< '#+.&= m .o .a0# o o mo#o .# o""o@&= .&=s, &am#"<

(a) .o #mo!# .# '##+. po&.#' ou. < .# appopa.# "aoa.o< om .# =oo's & Hu#s.o& ;

() .o #p"a+# .# =oo's @. @ =oo's o sm"a '#s+p.o& @+ sa"" # ## om a&< '##+.;

(+) .o #.u& .o .# +omp"a&a&. .# p+#, o, as .# +as# ma< #, .# +a=#s pa' < .# +omp"a&a&.;

(') .o pa< su+ amou&. as ma< # a@a'#' < . as +omp#&sa.o& .o .# +o&sum# o a&< "oss o &7u< su##'

morgan stanley mutual fund v kartick das 1994 scw 2801

Documents