morales vs harbour center

7/26/2019 Morales vs harbour center

1/21

SECOND DIVISION

JONATHAN V. MORALES,

Petitioner,

- versus -

HARBOUR CENTRE PORT TERMINAL, INC.

Reson!ent.


2/21

".R. No. #$%&'(

Present)

CARPIO, J.,

C*+irerson,

PERE,

SERENO,

REES,

PERLAS-BERNABE, JJ.


3/21

Pro/u01+te!)

J+nu+r2 &3, &'#&

4 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -4

D E C I S I O N

PERE, J.)

Ass+i0e! in t*is etition 5or revie6 on 7ertior+ri 80e! ursu+nt to Ru0e %3 o5 t*e #99$

Ru0es o5 Civi0 Pro7e!ure is t*e De7ision# !+te! #9 June &'': ren!ere! ;2 t*e Se7i+0

Tent* Division o5 t*e Court o5 Ae+0s in CA-".R. SP No. 9&%9#,& t*e !isositive

ortion o5 6*i7* st+tes)


4/21

T*e =+7ts

On #: M+2 &''', etitioner Jon+t*+n V. Mor+0es ?Mor+0es@ 6+s *ire! ;2 reson!ent

H+r;our Centre Port Ter/in+0, In7. ?HCPTI@ +s +n A77ount+nt +n! A7tin1 =in+n7e

O7er, 6it* + /ont*02 s+0+r2 o5 P#(,'''.''.% Re1u0+rie! on #$ Nove/;er &''',3

Mor+0es 6+s ro/ote! to Division M+n+1er o5 t*e A77ountin1 De+rt/ent, 5or 6*i7*

*e 6+s 7o/ens+te! + /ont*02 s+0+r2 o5 P>>,$''.'', 0us +00o6+n7es st+rtin1 # Ju02

&''&.: Su;seuent to HCPTIs tr+ns5er to its ne6 o7es +t Vit+s, Ton!o, M+ni0+ on &

J+nu+r2 &''>, Mor+0es re7eive! +n inter-o7e /e/or+n!u/ !+te! &$ M+r7* &''>,

re+ssi1nin1 *i/ to Oer+tions Cost A77ountin1, t+se! 6it* t*e !ut2 o5 F/onitorin1+n! ev+0u+tin1 +00 7onsu/+;0es reuests, 1e+rs +n! eui/entG re0+te! to t*e

7oror+tions oer+tions +n! o5 inter+7tin1 6it* its su;-7ontr+7tor, Bu0 =0eet M+rine

Coror+tion. T*e /e/or+n!u/ 6+s issue! ;2 D+ni0o V. Sin1son ?Sin1son@, HCPTIs

ne6 A!/inistr+tion M+n+1er, !u02 note! ;2 Jo*nn2 U. =i0+rt ?=i0+rt@, its ne6 Vi7e

Presi!ent 5or A!/inistr+tion +n! =in+n7e, +n! +rove! ;2 its Presi!ent +n! C*ie5

E4e7utive O7er, Vi7ente T. Su+o, Jr.$

On ># M+r7* &''>, Mor+0es 6rote Sin1son, rotestin1 t*+t *is re+ssi1n/ent 6+s +

70e+r !e/otion sin7e t*e osition to 6*i7* *e 6+s tr+ns5erre! 6+s not evenin70u!e! in HCPTIs 0+nti00+. In resonse to Mor+0es 1riev+n7e t*+t *e *+! ;een

ee7tive02 0+7e! on o+tin1 st+tus,( Sin1son issue! + % Ari0 &''> inter-o7e

/e/or+n!u/ to t*e ee7t t*+t Ftr+ns5er o5 e/0o2ees is + /+n+1e/ent

rero1+tiveG +n! t*+t HCPTI *+! Ft*e ri1*t +n! resonsi;i0it2 to 8n! t*e er5e7t

;+0+n7e ;et6een t*e si00s +n! +;i0ities o5 e/0o2ees to t*e nee!s o5 t*e

;usiness.G9 =or t*e 6*o0e o5 t*e ensuin1 /ont* Mor+0es 6+s +;sent 5ro/ 6or

+n!or t+r!2. Sin1son issue! to Mor+0es + &9 Ari0 &''> inter-o7e /e/or+n!u/

!eno/in+te! +s + =irst


5/21

In t*e /e+nti/e, Mor+0es 80e! + 7o/0+int !+te! &3 Ari0 &''> +1+inst HCPTI, =i0+rt

+n! Sin1son, 5or 7onstru7tive !is/iss+0, /or+0 +n! e4e/0+r2 !+/+1es +s 6e00 +s

+ttorne2s 5ees. In suort o5 t*e 7o/0+int 6*i7* 6+s !o7ete! +s NLRC-NCR C+se

No. ''-'%-'3':#-&''> ;e5ore t*e +r;itr+0 0eve0 o5 t*e N+tion+0 L+;or Re0+tions

Co//ission ?NLRC@,#> Mor+0es +00e1e! t*+t su;seuent to its tr+ns5er to its ne6

o7es, HCPTI *+! susen!e! +00 t*e rivi0e1es enKo2e! ;2 its M+n+1ers, DivisionC*ie5s +n! Se7tion He+!s t*+t uon t*e instru7tion o5 =i0+rt, P+u0o C*risti+n Su+re,

HCPTIs Coror+te Tre+surer, in5or/e! *i/ on $ M+r7* &''> t*+t *e 6+s 1oin1 to ;e

ter/in+te! +n! *+! on02 t*ree ?>@ 6ees to 0oo 5or +not*er Ko; t*+t *+vin1

7on8r/e! *is i/en!in1 ter/in+tion on &$ M+r7* &''>, =i0+rt !e7i!e! to Fte/erG

t*e s+/e ;2 inste+! re+ssi1nin1 *i/ to Oer+tions Cost A77ountin1 +n!, t*+t *is

re+ssi1n/ent to + osition 6*i7* 6+s not in70u!e! in HCPTIs 0+nti00+ 6+s +

!e/otion +n! oer+te! +s + ter/in+tion 5ro/ e/0o2/ent +s o5 s+i! !+te.

M+int+inin1 t*+t *e suere! 1re+t *u/i0i+tion 6*en, in +!!ition to ;ein1 !erive! o5

*is o7e +n! its eui/ents, *e re7eive! no 5urt*er instru7tions 5ro/ =i0+rt +n!

Sin1son re1+r!in1 *is ne6 osition, Mor+0es 70+i/e! t*+t *e 6+s 0e5t no ot*er

7*oi7e ;ut 80e *is 7o/0+int 5or 7onstru7tive !is/iss+0.#%

Serve! 6it* su//ons on $ M+2 &''>,#3 HCPTI, =i0+rt +n! Sin1son 80e! t*eir

osition +er, +r1uin1 t*+t Mor+0es +;+n!one! *is e/0o2/ent +n! 6+s not

7onstru7tive02 !is/isse!. C+00in1 +ttention to t*e suose! 5+7t t*+t Mor+0es

ne10i1en7e *+! resu0te! in HCPTIs +2/ent o5 P>,>3','''.'' in t+4es 5ro/ 6*i7* it

6+s e4e/t +s + PEA-re1istere! 7o/+n2, s+i! reson!ents +verre! t*+t,

7on5ronte! ;2 =i0+rt so/eti/e in M+r7* &''> re1+r!in1 t*e 0+ses in *is 6orer5or/+n7e, Mor+0es +!/itte! *is in+;i0it2 to *+n!0e *is t+ss +t t*e 7oror+tions

A77ountin1 De+rt/ent t*+t +s + 7onseuen7e, HCPTI re+ssi1ne! Mor+0es 5ro/

/+n+1eri+0 +77ountin1 to oer+tions 7ost +77ountin1 +s +n e4er7ise o5 its

/+n+1e/ent rero1+tive to +ssi1n its e/0o2ees to Ko;s 5or 6*i7* t*e2 +re ;est

suite! +n!, t*+t !esite t*e Kusti87+tion in Sin1sons % Ari0 &''> re02 to *is >#

M+r7* &''> rotest +1+inst *is re+ssi1n/ent, Mor+0es 7*ose to sto reortin1 5or

6or. =+u0tin1 Mor+0es 6it* unKusti8e! re5us+0 to *ee! t*e ree+te! 6+rnin1s +n!

noti7es !ire7tin1 *i/ to reort 5or 6or, HCPTI, =i0+rt +n! Sin1son r+2e! 5or t*e

!is/iss+0 o5 t*e 7o/0+int +n! t*e 1r+nt o5 t*eir 7ounter70+i/ 5or +ttorne2s 5ees.#:

In re7eit o5 t*e +rties re0ies#$ +n! reKoin!ers,#( L+;or Ar;iter =+7un!o L. Le!+

6ent on to ren!er + De7ision !+te! Nove/;er &''>, !is/issin1 5or 0+7 o5 /erit

Mor+0es 7o/0+int 5or 7onstru7tive !is/iss+0. In !is7ountin1 s+i! e/0o2ees i00e1+0

!is/iss+0 5ro/ servi7e, t*e L+;or Ar;iter ru0e! t*+t Mor+0es re+ssi1n/ent 6+s +


6/21

v+0i! e4er7ise o5 HCPTIs /+n+1e/ent rero1+tive 6*i7* 7+nnot ;e 7onstrue! +s

7onstru7tive !is/iss+0 +;sent s*o6in1 t*+t t*e s+/e 6+s !one in ;+! 5+it* +n!

resu0te! in t*e !i/inution o5 *is s+0+r2 +n! ;ene8ts.#9 On +e+0, t*e 5ore1oin1

!e7ision 6+s, *o6ever, reverse! +n! set +si!e in t*e &9 Ju02 &''3 De7ision

ren!ere! ;2 t*e NLRCs T*ir! Division in NLRC NCR CA No. '>(3%(-'%. =in!in1 t*+t

Mor+0es re+ssi1n/ent 6+s + 70e+r !e/otion !esite 0+7 o5 s*o6in1 o5 !i/inutiono5 s+0+ries +n! ;ene8ts,&' t*e NLRC !isose! o5 t*e +e+0 in t*e 5o00o6in1 6ise)

is VACATED +n! SET ASIDE.

T*e reson!ent 7o/+n2 is or!ere! to +2 7o/0+in+nt t*e 5o00o6in1)

#. B+76+1es) ?&( M+r7* &''> to Nov. &''>@

+. S+0+r2) P>>,$'' 4 $.$$ /os. P&:#,(%9.''

;. #>t* /ont* +2) P&:#,(%9#& ,(&'.$3

-----------------

P&(>,::9.$3

&. Se+r+tion P+2) ?#: M+2 &''' to Nov. &''>@

one /ont* 5or ever2 2e+r o5 servi7e

?P>>,$''.'' 4 %@ P#>%,(''.''


7/21

----------------

Tot+0 P %#(,%:9.$3

T*e ot*er 70+i/s +re DISMISSED.

SO ORDERED.


8/21

T*e Issues

Mor+0es roers t*e 5o00o6in1 issues 5or reso0ution in seein1 t*e revers+0 o5 t*e

CAs #9 June &'': De7ision +n! #% Au1ust &'': Reso0ution, to 6it)

I


9/21


10/21

on &$ M+r7* &''>, 6it*out +n2 /ention o5 t*e osition to 6*i7* *e 6+s +7tu+002

;ein1 tr+ns5erre!. T*+t t*e re+ssi1n/ent 6+s + !e/otion is, *o6ever, evi!ent 5ro/

Mor+0es ne6 !uties 6*i7*, 5+r 5ro/ ;ein1 /+n+1eri+0 in n+ture, 6ere ver2 si/02

+n! v+1ue02 !es7ri;e! +s in70usive o5 F/onitorin1 +n! ev+0u+tin1 +00 7onsu/+;0es

reuests, 1e+rs +n! eui/ents re0+te! to HCPTIsQ oer+tionsG +s 6e00 +s F70ose

inter+7tion 6it* itsQ su;-7ontr+7tor Bu0 =0eet M+rine Coror+tion.G>:

$ 6*i7*, +s in!i7+te! in t*e 7oror+tions 0+nti00+, *+! t*e Vi7e-

Presi!ent 5or Oer+tions +t its *e0/.>( On t*e 7ontr+r2, Mor+0es !e/otion is

evi!ent 5ro/ t*e 5+7t t*+t *is re+ssi1n/ent ent+i0e! + tr+ns5er 5ro/ + /+n+1eri+0

osition to one 6*i7* 6+s not even in70u!e! in t*e 7oror+tions 0+nti00+. =or +n

e/0o2ee ne602 7*+r1e! 6it* 5un7tions 6*i7* even t*e CA re7o1nie! +s ert+inin1

to t*e Oer+tions De+rt/ent, it +0so stru7 + !is7or!+nt 7*or! t*+t Mor+0es 6+s,

Kust t*e s+/e, !ire7te! ;2 HCPTI to reort to =i0+rt, its Vi7e- Presi!ent 5or =in+n7e>9

6it* 6*o/ *e +0re+!2 *+! + ro;0e/+ti7 6orin1 re0+tions*i.%' T*is /+tter 6+s

ointe! out in Mor+0es ># M+r7* &''> rotest ;ut 6+s not+;02 ;rus*e! +si!e ;2

HCPTI ;2 si/02 invoin1 /+n+1e/ent rero1+tive in its inter-o7e /e/or+n!u/

!+te! % Ari0 &''>.%#

A!/itte!02, t*e ri1*t o5 e/0o2ees to se7urit2 o5 tenure !oes not 1ive t*e/ veste!

ri1*ts to t*eir ositions to t*e e4tent o5 !erivin1 /+n+1e/ent o5 its rero1+tive to

7*+n1e t*eir +ssi1n/ents or to tr+ns5er t*e/.%& B2 /+n+1e/ent rero1+tive is

/e+nt t*e ri1*t o5 +n e/0o2er to re1u0+te +00 +se7ts o5 e/0o2/ent, su7* +s t*e

5ree!o/ to res7ri;e 6or +ssi1n/ents, 6orin1 /et*o!s, ro7esses to ;e 5o00o6e!,

re1u0+tion re1+r!in1 tr+ns5er o5 e/0o2ees, suervision o5 t*eir 6or, 0+2-o +n!

!is7i0ine, +n! !is/iss+0 +n! re7+00 o5 6orers.%> A0t*ou1* Kurisru!en7e re7o1nies

s+i! /+n+1e/ent rero1+tive, it *+s ;een ru0e! t*+t t*e e4er7ise t*ereo5, 6*i0e

or!in+ri02 not inter5ere! 6it*,%% is not +;so0ute +n! is su;Ke7t to 0i/it+tions i/ose!

;2 0+6, 7o00e7tive ;+r1+inin1 +1ree/ent, +n! 1ener+0 rin7i0es o5 5+ir 0+2 +n!Kusti7e.%3 T*us, +n e/0o2er /+2 tr+ns5er or +ssi1n e/0o2ees 5ro/ one o7e or

+re+ o5 oer+tion to +not*er, rovi!e! t*ere is no !e/otion in r+n or !i/inution o5

s+0+r2, ;ene8ts, +n! ot*er rivi0e1es, +n! t*e +7tion is not /otiv+te! ;2

!is7ri/in+tion, /+!e in ;+! 5+it*, or ee7te! +s + 5or/ o5 unis*/ent or !e/otion

6it*out su7ient 7+use.%: In!ee!, *+vin1 t*e ri1*t s*ou0! not ;e 7on5use! 6it* t*e

/+nner in 6*i7* t*+t ri1*t is e4er7ise!.%$


11/21

In its 7o//ent to t*e etition, HCPTI +r1ues t*+t Mor+0es tr+ns5er 6+s ;rou1*t

+;out ;2 t*e reor1+ni+tion o5 its 7oror+te stru7ture in &''> 6*i7* 6+s un!ert+en

in t*e e4er7ise o5 its /+n+1e/ent rero1+tive to re1u0+te ever2 +se7t o5 its

;usiness.%( T*is 70+i/ is, *o6ever, 7onsi!er+;02 +t o!!s 6it* HCPTIs +ssertions

;e5ore t*e L+;or Ar;iter to t*e ee7t, +/on1 ot*er /+tters, t*+t Mor+0es

erroneous02 +n! ne10i1ent02 +ut*orie! t*e ree+te! +2/ents o5 re+0t2 t+4es 5ro/

6*i7* t*e 7oror+tion 6+s e4e/t +s + PEA-re1istere! 7o/+n2 t*+t 7on5ronte!

;2 =i0+rt re1+r!in1 *is oor 6or er5or/+n7e 6*i7* resu0te! in 0osses +/ountin1 to

P>,>3','''.'', Mor+0es +!/itte! *is in+;i0it2 to *+n!0e *is Ko; +t t*e +77ountin1

!e+rt/ent +n!, t*+t +s + 7onseuen7e, HCPTI !e7i!e! to re+ssi1n *i/ to t*e

Oer+tions Cost A77ountin1.%9 # M+r7* &''> rotest +1+inst *is re+ssi1n/ent.3'

B2 itse05, HCPTIs 70+i/ o5 reor1+ni+tion is ;ere5t o5 +n2 suortin1 evi!en7e in t*e

re7or!. H+vin1 ointe! out t*e /+tter in *is ># M+r7* &''> 6ritten rotest, Mor+0es

6+s +;0e to rove t*+t HCPTIs e4istin1 0+nti00+ !i! not in70u!e +n Oer+tions Cost

A77ountin1 De+rt/ent +n!or +n Oer+tions Cost A77ount+nt.3# As t*e +rt2

;e0+te!02 seein1 to Kusti52 t*e re+ssi1n/ent !ue to t*e suose! reor1+ni+tion o5

its 7oror+te stru7ture, HCPTI, in 7ontr+st, !i! not even ;ot*er to s*o6 t*+t it *+!

i/0e/ente! + 7oror+te reor1+ni+tion +n!or +rove! + ne6 0+nti00+ o5

ositions 6*i7* in70u!e! t*e one to 6*i7* Mor+0es 6+s ;ein1 tr+ns5erre!. Sin7e t*e

;ur!en o5 evi!en7e 0ies 6it* t*e +rt2 6*o +sserts t*e +r/+tive o5 +n issue, t*e

reson!ent *+s to rove t*e +00e1+tions in *is +r/+tive !e5enses in t*e s+/e

/+nner t*+t t*e 7o/0+in+nt *+s to rove t*e +00e1+tions in t*e 7o/0+int.3& In

+!/inistr+tive or u+si-Ku!i7i+0 ro7ee!in1s 0ie t*ose 7on!u7te! ;e5ore t*e NLRC,

t*e st+n!+r! o5 roo5 is su;st+nti+0 evi!en7e 6*i7* is un!erstoo! to ;e /ore t*+n

Kust + s7inti00+ or su7* +/ount o5 re0ev+nt evi!en7e 6*i7* + re+son+;0e /in! /i1*t

+77et +s +!eu+te to Kusti52 + 7on70usion.3>

H+vin1 +00e1e! &$ M+r7* &''> +s t*e !+te o5 *is 7onstru7tive !is/iss+0, Mor+0es

6+s erroneous02 t+en to t+s ;2 t*e CA 5or in7onsistent02 70+i/in1 t*+t *e too +

0e+ve o5 +;sen7e 5ro/ % Ari0 &''> to #$ Ari0 &''>.3% As t*e !+te o5 *is

re+ssi1n/ent, &$ M+r7* &''> 6+s un!erst+n!+;02 se7i8e! ;2 Mor+0es +s t*e !+te


12/21

o5 *is 7onstru7tive !is/iss+0 sin7e it 6+s on s+i! !+te t*+t *e 7onsi!ere! *i/se05

!e/ote!. A0on1si!e *is reortin1 5or !ut2 su;seuent t*ereto, Mor+0es 0e+ve o5

+;sen7e on t*e +5ores+i! !+tes is, in turn, ;uttresse! ;2 HCPTIs &9 Ari0 &''> Inter-

O7e Me/or+n!u/ 6*i7*, 0+;e0e! +s + =irst # M+r7* &''> rotest +1+inst t*e !e/otion t*+t resu0te! 5ro/ *is re+ssi1n/ent to

Oer+tions Cost A77ountin1.3:

A0t*ou1* /u7* *+! ;een /+!e +;out Mor+0es suose! re5us+0 to *ee! *is

e/0o2ers ree+te! !ire7tives 5or *i/ to return to 6or, our erus+0 o5 t*e re7or!

+0so s*o6s t*+t HCPTIs t*eor2 o5 +;+n!on/ent o5 e/0o2/ent 7+nnot ;e+r 70ose

s7rutin2. , t*e Inter-O7e Me/or+n!u/ 0+;e0e!

+s + Se7on! 3$ or t6o ?&@ !+2s +5ter su//ons 6ere serve! on HCPTI, =i0+rt +n! Sin1son on

$ M+2 &''>.3( Sent to Mor+0es on &: M+2 &''> or +5ter t*e +rties initi+0

7on5eren7e ;e5ore t*e L+;or Ar;iter on #9 M+2 &''>,39 t*ere 6+s o;vious02 even

0ess re+son 5or HCPTIs && M+2 &''> 0etter !eno/in+te! +s Noti7e to Reort 5or


13/21

JOSE PORTU"AL PERE

Asso7i+te Justi7e


14/21

MARIA LOURDES P. A. SERENO BIENVENIDO L. REES

Asso7i+te Justi7e Asso7i+te Justi7e

ESTELA M. PERLAS-BERNABE

Asso7i+te Justi7e


15/21

ATTESTATION

I +ttest t*+t t*e 7on70usions in t*e +;ove De7ision 6ere re+7*e! in 7onsu0t+tion

;e5ore t*e 7+se 6+s +ssi1ne! to t*e 6riter o5 t*e oinion o5 t*e Courts Division.

ANTONIO T. CARPIO

Asso7i+te Justi7e

C*+irerson, Se7on! Division

CERTI=ICATION

Pursu+nt to Se7tion #>, Arti70e VIII o5 t*e Constitution +n! t*e Division C*+irersonsAttest+tion, it is *ere;2 7erti8e! t*+t t*e 7on70usions in t*e +;ove De7ision 6ere

re+7*e! in 7onsu0t+tion ;e5ore t*e 7+se 6+s +ssi1ne! to t*e 6riter o5 t*e oinion o5

t*e Courts Division.


16/21

RENATO C. CORONA

C*ie5 Justi7e

# Asso7i+te Justi7e Este0+ M. Per0+s-Bern+;e is !esi1n+te! +s A7tin1 Me/;er o5 t*e

Se7on! Division er Se7i+0 Or!er No. ##$% !+te! 9 J+nu+r2 &'#&.

Penne! ;2 Asso7i+te Justi7e An!res B. Re2es, Jr. +n! 7on7urre! in ;2 Asso7i+te

Justi7es H+i/ S. A;!u06+*i! +n! Vi7ente . Ro4+s.

& Re7or!, CA-".R. SP No. 9&%9#, CAs #9 June &'': De7ision, . &::-&$$.

> I!. +t &$$.

% Re7or!, NLRC C+se No. ''-'%-'3':#-&''>, #: M+2 &''' Initi+0 >.

3 #$ Nove/;er &''' Letter, i! +t >(.

: && O7to;er &''& Letter, i!. +t %$.

$ &$ M+r7* &''> Inter-O7e Me/or+n!u/, i!. +t 3%.

( Letter ># M+r7* &''>, i!. +t 3$.


17/21

9 % Ari0 &''> Inter-O7e Me/or+n!u/, i!. +t (9.

#' &9 Ari0 &''> Inter-O7e Me/or+n!u/, i!. +t 9'.

## : M+2 &''> Inter-O7e Me/or+n!u/, i!. +t 9&.

#& && M+2 &''> Inter-O7e Me/or+n!u/, i!. +t 9%.

#> &3 Ari0 &''> Co/0+int, i!. +t &.

#% Mor+0es A!+vit #3 Au1ust &''>, i!. +t &$->#.

#3 &9 Ari0 &'': Su//ons, i!. +t :.

#: Reson!ents ## Au1ust &''> Position P+er, i!. +t :#-$:.

#$ Mor+0es > Sete/;er &''> Re02 +n! Reson!ents ## Sete/;er &''> Re02,

i!. +t 9$-#': ###-##9.

#( Reson!ents &: Sete/;er &''> ReKoin!er +n! Mor+0es >' Sete/;er &''>

ReKoin!er, i!. +t #-#%#.

#9 L+;or Ar;iters Nove/;er &''> De7ision, i!. +t #%&-#3:.

&' NLRCs &9 Ju02 &''3 De7ision, i!. +t >'>->#>.


18/21

I!. +t >#&.

&& NLRCs #' O7to;er &''3 Reso0ution, i!. +t >:%->:3.

&> CA ro00o, CA-".R. SP No. 9&%9#, HCPTIs #> De7e/;er &''3 Ru0e :3 Petition 5or

Certior+ri, . &->3.

&% Re7or!, NLRC C+se No. ''-'%-'3:#-&''>, NLRCs > Nove/;er &''3 Entr2 o5

Ju!1/ent.

&3 Mor+0es #> =e;ru+r2 &'': Motion 5or E4e7ution, i!. +t %'(-%'9.

&: #3 Au1ust &'': Minutes o5 Pro7ee!in1s ;e5ore L+;or Ar;iter A0i/+n D.

M+n1+n!o1, i!. +t %3%.

&$ CA ro00o, CA-".R. SP No. 9&%9#, CAs #9 June &'': De7ision, . &::-&$$.

&( CAs #% Au1ust &'': Reso0ution, i!. +t >#3.

&9 Ro00o, . :#(.

>' "0o;e Te0e7o/, In7. v. =0oren!o-=0ores, %>( P*i0. $3:, $:: ?&''&@ 7itin1 P*i0iine

J++n A7tive C+r;on Coror+tion v. NLRC, et +0., &3> P*i0. #%9, #3&, ?#9(9@.

># Uni6i!e S+0es


19/21

>> P*i0iine Veter+ns B+n v. N+tion+0 L+;or Re0+tions Co//ission, ".R. No.

#((((&, >' M+r7* &'#', :#$ SCRA &'%, &.

>% 3 Re7or!, NLRC C+se No. ''-'%-'3:#-&''>, & De7e/;er &''& Inter-O7e

Me/or+n!u/, . %9.

>: &$ M+r7* &''> Inter-O7e Me/or+n!u/, i!. +t 3%.

>$ Re7or!, CA-".R. SP No. 9&%9#, . &$>.

>( Re7or!, NLRC C+se No. ''-'%-'3:#-&''>, . 33.

>9 I!. +t 3' 3%.

%' I!. +t #'&.

%# I!. +t (9.

%& Men!o+ v. Rur+0 B+n o5 Lu7;+n, ".R. No. #33%, $ Ju02 &''%, %>> SCRA $3:,

$::.

%> Mer7+!o v. AMA Co/uter Co00e1e-P+r++ue Cit2, In7., ".R. No. #(>3$&, #>

Ari0 &'#', :#( SCRA (, &>$.

%% C+sti00o v. N+tion+0 L+;or Re0+tions Co//ission, >:$ P*i0. :'3, :#: ?#999@.


20/21

%3 Noris Tr+!in1 Co., In7. v. NLRC, 3'% P*i0. $'9, $#( ?&''3@.

%: Heri!+ v. =C P+6ns*o +n! Je6e0r2 Store, ".R. No. #$&:'#, #: Ari0 &''9, 3(3SCRA >93, %'#.

%$ E/ir+te Se7urit2 +n! M+inten+n7e S2ste/s, In7. +n! Ro;erto A. +n v. Menese,

".R. No. #(&(%(, 3 O7to;er &'##.

%( Ro00o, . #'9-##'.

%9 Re7or!, NLRC C+se No. ''-'%-'3:#-&''>, . :>-:% $' 9(-99.

3' Letter !+te! ># M+r7* &''>, i!. +t 3$.

3# HCPTI P0+nti00+ o5 Positions 5or C &''&, i!. +t 33-3:.

3& A0+n E0e7tri7 Cooer+tive, In7oror+te! v. NLRC, >(' P*i0. &&3, &%3 ?&'''@.

3> S+0v+!or v. P*i0iine Minin1 Servi7e Coror+tion, %%> P*i0. ($(, (((-((9 ?&''>@.

3% Re7or!, CA-".R. SP No. 9&%9#, . &$3.

33 Re7or!, NLRC C+se No. ''-'%-'3:#-&''>, Inter-O7e Me/or+n!u/ !+te! &9

Ari0 &''>, . 9'.

3: Ro00o, . #%#.


21/21

3$ Re7or!, NLRC C+se No. ''-'%-'3:#-&''>, JRS E4ress 3 M+2 &''9 Re7eit, .

9>.

3( Return C+r!s 5or Su//ons, i!. +t >-3.

39 #9 M+2 &''> Minutes, i!. +t $.

:' A0iten v. U-Nee! Lu/;er H+r!6+re, ".R. No. #:(9>#, #& Sete/;er &'':, 3'#

SCRA 3$$, 3(:.

:# B+ron Reu;0i7 T*e+tri7+0 v. Per+0t+, ".R. No. #$'3&3, & O7to;er &''9, :'& SCRA

&3(, &:3.

:& Me1+5or7e Se7urit2 +n! A00ie! Servi7es, In7. v. L+7t+o, ".R. No. #:'9%', Ju02

&''(, 339 SCRA ##', ##(.

morales vs harbour center

Documents