molan handbook
TRANSCRIPT
2 3
Table of conTenT
Introduction 1. Introduction: Motivating language learners through innovative teaching and learning practices
1.1. Anexampleofearlylanguageteaching (KaunasPanemunePrimarySchool)1.2. UsingblogstomotivatethelearningofFrenchinIreland (St.Michael’s,LoretoSecondarySchool)1.3.MovingtowardsapolyglotmindsetinAndalusia (UniversidadPablodeOlavide)1.4. EPOS–ane-portfolioforthreesectorsofeducation (FremdsprachenzentrumderHochschulenimLandBremen)
2. Introduction: Motivating language learners through language policy
2.1. MultilingualprimaryeducationinBrussels (VrijeUniversiteitBrussels)2.2. Motivationtolearnlanguagesbreaksdownculturalbarriers inLondon(WalthamstowSchoolforGirls)2.3. TheUniversityofWarsawsystemofLanguageProvision– languagesforallUniversityofWarsaw
7
11
19
25
29
33
39
45
49
53
4 5
3. Introduction: cooperation with other partners and stakeholders
3.1. RegionalActionPlanforthePromotionofMultilingualism UniversidadedoMinho3.2. FrenchforStudentsofAerospaceEngineeringCILT, theNationalCentreforLanguages3.3. LanguagelearningasasteptowardEuropeanCitizenship– EnhancesstudentexchangeCampusEuropae3.4. Languagelearningatprimaryschoolthrough etwinninginitiativeÈcolepubliquemixtedeFromont3.5. Outsidein:bringingthecommunityintoschool– motivationforlanguagesEscolaSecundáriade TomasCabreira
4. Introduction: Motivation through integration, accreditation and certification
4.1. Improvingmultilingualcompetenceofstudentsby theallocationofECTSFreieUniversitätBerlin4.2.MotivatingStudentsbymeansoffeeexemptionand theawardofECTSUniversitédesLausanne4.3.MotivationthroughcertificationBabes-Bolyai UniversityofCluj
59
65
71
75
81
85
89
93
97
101
6 7
Introduction
TheHandbookisoneofthemainoutputsofthethree-yearMOLANnet-workproject(December2007-November20101),fundedbytheEuro-peanCommissionundertheLifelongLearningProgramme(LLP),KeyActivity2–Languages.TheMOLANnetworkiscomprisedof38partnersbasedin18participatingcountriesandinSwitzerland–schools,univer-sities,organisationsandauthoritiesthatsharetheUnion’sfirmbeliefthatcommunicationinanumberofforeignlanguagesisakeycompetenceforlifelonglearning,andthatinstitutionsinformaleducationhaveaspecialresponsibilityinthisrespect.Partnersarealsoconvincedthatschoolsanduniversitiesshouldco-operateinthisendeavour.Inotherwords,MOLANisfirmlyrootedintheUnion’smultilingualismpolicy,whichtookshapeintheearlyninetiesandreacheditsclimaxwiththeappointmentofMrLeonardOrbanasCommissionerforMultilingualism.Thepartner-shipgreatlybenefitedfromtheparticipationofsubcontractors–expertsinthefieldfrom9educationalinstitutionsfromacrossEurope.
ThegrantapplicationfortheMOLANnetworkprojectwaspreparedinresponsetooneofsixstrategicprioritiessetoutforKA2Networksinthe2007LLPCall–“Networksofgoodpracticethatservetomotivatelanguagelearners”.Thisparticularstrategicprioritywasnotaccidental.Inthosedays,motivationforlanguagelearningwasoneofthemainitemsontheEU’smultilingualismagenda.Afterall,theCommission’sHighLevelGrouponMultilingualism(HLGM)(2006-7)cametothecon-clusionthat“motivationisakey,ifnotthekey,tosuccessfullanguagelearning.Enhancinglearnermotivationisthecrucialelementinachie-vingthedesiredbreakthroughinlanguagelearningacrossEurope.”AmongtherecommendationsmadebytheHLGMwasthefollowing:“ThereisawealthofexperienceavailableacrosstheUnionregardingstrategiesrelevanttoinitiatingandsustainingmotivationforthelearningoflanguages.TheCommissionshouldsupportprojectsdesignedtomakesuccessfulstrategiesforinitiatingandsustaininglearnermotivati-onknowntostakeholdersacrossEurope,andtopromotethedevelop-mentofinnovativestrategies.”
1In response to an application submitted by the co-ordinator, the MOLAN network project eligibility period was eventually extended by three months.
8 9
• extracurricularactivities• languagelearningandlanguageuselinkedtoICT;• independentandcollaborativelearning;• ContentandLanguageIntegratedLearning(CLIL).
However,whatalsobecameclearduringthecourseoftheprojectwasthatexamplesofsuccessfulpracticehavetobeseenandplacedincontext;whatispossibleinonecontextmaynotbefeasibleinanothercontext;inotherwords,nosizefitsall;
• examplescannotjustbecopied;theymaybeadapted toalignthemtodifferentcontexts;• welivein(a)rapidlychangingenvironment(s);forexample, migrantlanguagesarebecomingincreasinglyimportant;• withoutadequatefinancialsupport,eventhemostpromising initiativesmaycometonaught–andthisisthemessagethat becameevermoreclearduringthecourseoftheprojectasa resultofthefinancialcrisis;• thecontext-specificlocalfeaturesofeachuniversity/school tendtodeterminehowlanguagepoliciesaredevisedandimple- mented,ratherthananynationalorregionalstrategy–inother words,evenschoolscandesigntheirownpolicies,strategies andpractices(PSPs).
Aboveall,however,theexecutivesummariesconveyapositivemessage.TheyshowthatrelevantactioncanbetakenatEuropean,regionalandinstitutionallevel–provideddecision-andpolicy-makersaremotivated.
Theexecutivesummariesalsopointtothefuture.Infuture,oneofourmainchallengeswillbetodealwithheterogeneouslearnergroups.Howcanwearousemotivationinsituationswherelearnersarede-motivatedbecauselanguage-wisetheyareaheadoftheirpeersorbecausetheyarebehindtheirpeers?Inotherwords,theMOLANHandbookdoesnotprovideready-madeanswers;itisdesignedtoencouragepolicy-makersanddecision-makerstoreflectonwhatneedstobedoneandtotakeappropriateaction.ThecasestudiespreparedintheMOLANprojectprovideevidenceofthefactthatmultilingualcompetenceisnotjustadream–giventherightPSPs,itcanbecomereality.
AndthisiswhereMOLANcamein.MOLANpartnerswerekeentoiden-tify,describeandanalyseinnovativepolicies,strategies,andpracticesthatcouldbeshowntohaveledtoincreasedlearnermotivation.
Inthefirstone-and-a-halfyearsofthenetworkproject,partnersandsub-contractorspreparedandrevisedmorethan80casestudiesofsuccessfulpractice,focusingonthedescriptionofthesuccessstoriesidentified,theirbackgrounds,successfactors,successindicators,andbroaderimplicationsandtransferability.Inreviewingthecasestudies,partnerswerekeentoidentifysuccessstoriesthatschoolsanduniver-sitiesacrossEuropemightfindinspiringinthesensethattheymightbeencouragedtoswingintoaction.AndthisledstraighttotheHandbook.Weselected15casestudiesandrequestedtheoriginalauthorstopre-pareexecutivesummariesofthesestudies,whichwerethendiscussedinpeerreviewsessionsataprojectconferenceheldinThessalonikiin2009.Inthisexercise,successfactorsturnedouttobeofparamountimportance.MOLANpartnersidentifiedfourbroadcategories:
• Motivatinglanguagelearnersthroughinnovative teaching and learning practices;• Motivatinglanguagelearnersthoughlanguage policy;• Motivationoflanguagelearnersasaresultofco-operation with other partners and stakeholders;• Motivatinglanguagelearnersthrough integration, accreditation and certification of language learning.
AsthefourintroductorysectionsoftheHandbookmakeclear,eachofthesecategoriesiscomprisedofanumberofsub-categories.Thethe-maticcategoriesrepresentclustersofsuccessfactors.AsalsobecamecleartousinThessaloniki,theinitiativesdescribedintheexecutivesummariesnormallyfeatureseveralsuccessfactors,beitintermsofsub-categoriesbelongingtothesamecategory,beitintermsofsub-categoriesbelongingtomorethanonebroadcategory.
Interestingly,amajorityofexecutivesummariesfeatureoneformofco-operationoranotherasasuccessfactor–co-operationwithininstitutions,betweeninstitutionsinthesamesector,trans-sectoralco-operation,trans-Europeanco-operation.Othertransversalsuccessfactorsinclude
10 11
1. Motivating language learners through innovative teaching and learning practices
Whenexploringthemanyfactorsthatcanhelptoenhancesecondlanguagelearnermotivation,manylessonscanbelearnedfromthewaywebecomeproficientinourownmothertongue.
Theearliestfactorinacquiringalanguageistheneedtorelatetootherpeople,firstwithourparentsandsiblings,thenwithourpeersandotheradultsintheeducationsystem,atworkandinotherspheres.Aswegrowolder,theneedtointeractwithothersinallkindsofcircumstancesencouragesustousenewwordsandphrasesandtoexperimentwithnewregistersoflanguage.
Someoftheprogresswemakeinmasteringourfirstlanguagewillbebasedoninformalorformaltuitionwithinthefamilycircleortheeducationalsystem.Buttoalargeextentourlanguageskillswillbeacquiredthroughourownexperienceandthroughautonomouslearning,themainmotivatingfactorbeingthedesiretobecomemoreindepen-dentinourinteractionwiththewiderworld.
Finally,asweprogressthroughtheschoolsystemandthenpossibly,moveintohighereducation,ourcompetenceinthemainstreamlangua-geofeducationbecomesaprimefactorinfacilitatingouracquisitionofnewknowledge,byenablingustoattendclasses,takenotes,readandwriteassignmentsandcontributetoclassesandseminars.Wethereforebecomeawareveryearlyonintheeducationalsystemofhowimportantourfirstlanguageskillsareinhelpingusthroughthesystem,orconver-sely,ofhowmuchofahandicappoorlanguageskillscanprovetobe.
TheexamplesofinnovativeforeignlanguageteachingandlearningpracticesdescribedinthissectionoftheMOLANHandbookmirrorthethreefactorsoutlinedabove.
12 13
peersfromforeigncountriesandinthiswaytheirlanguagecompetenceiseasilyimproved.Connectingwiththe‘realworld’throughtheuseofanotherlanguagedoesnotnecessarilyinvolveactivecommunicationwithpeersinanothercountry:theinitiativedescribedbySt.Michael’sLoretoSecondarySchoolinIreland(Casestudyn°2)showshowthesimplefactofwritingabloginaforeignlanguageandmakingitpubliclyavailableviatheinternetcanbeamotivatingfactor.Again,languageskillsarecombinedwitharangeofotherskillsandprofessionalcompetences,fromICTtoproofreading,organizingandmeetingdeadlines.
EvenwhenlanguagelearninginschoolshasstronginstitutionalsupportandispartofanambitiousPlurilingualismpromotionplan(Casestudyn°3:MovingtowardsapolyglotmindsetinAndalusia),extracurricularactivitiesareagainhighlightedasbeingfundamentalinmaintainingmo-tivationthroughparticipationinlanguageweeks,festivalsandexchangeprogrammes.
Culturaleventsaregenerallyseenasawayofcomplementingandraisinginterestinlanguagelearning,especiallyatmoreadvancedlevelsintheeducationsystem.Inthisrespect,cooperationwithembassiesandsuchculturalinstitutesasGoetheInstitut,theInstitutoCervantes,ortheBritishCouncilisoftenseenasacrucialfactorestablishingthelinkbetweenthelanguageanditsuseinthewiderworldoutsidetheclassroomorlecturehall.Theseinstitutionshelpuniversitiesandschoolstoimproveknowledgeofotherculturesbyprovidingbooksforlanguagelearning,scholarshipsforsummerlanguagecourses,byholdingseminarsandworkshops,andinvitingthepublictomeetingsandlectures.
Asregardshighereducationinstitutions,anumberofcasestudies(VytautasMagnusUniversity(LT),UniversitätWien(AT),UniversitätFrei-burg(DE),UniversitéLibredeBruxelles(BE),amongothers)reportthepresenceofmobilityprogrammesandworkplacementsasasuccessfactorservingtoraiselearners’awarenessoftherelevanceoflanguageskills.Thus,studentsareprovidedwithopportunitiestogaininternatio-nalexperienceandlearnanextralanguageoroptimizetheircommuni-cativecompetenceinthetargetlanguageandmakesureofitseffective-nessintheinterculturalacademicenvironment.
connecting with the ‚real world‘ through extracurricular activities
Alllanguageteachersknowthatoneofthekeystoeffectivelearningistheteacher‘sabilitytoshowstudentsofanyagehowtheirnewlyac-quiredlanguageskillsrelatetotheirimmediateorfutureneeds,whetherthesebewritingafewsimplewordstoapupilinanothercountry,buyingapacketofcrispsduringaschooltrip,holdingasimpleconversationwithapeerduringaschoolexchange,phoningasupplier,beingabletounderstandanimportantarticlepublishedinaforeignjournalorpreparingaPowerPointpresentationforamajorconference.Learningasecondlanguageshouldfirstandforemostbeaboutexploringthemanywaysinwhichlanguageconnectswiththerealworld.Thisiswhy„extracurricu-lar“activitiesareinfactattheheartofthelanguagelearningprocess.
Bydefinition,extracurricularactivitiesintheareaoflanguagelearningcoveraverywiderangeofexperiencesandpractices.Theyrangefromwritingapersonalblogintheforeignlanguage,ore-Twinningactivitieslinkingtwoormoreschoolstointernationalworkplacementsandmobi-lityprogrammesatuniversitylevel.
AnumberofMOLANcasestudies(OrivedenKeskuskoulu(FI),Sint-Janscollege(BE),EcolepubliquemixtedeFromont/StAndrews,Orkney(FR/UK))highlighte-Twinningasaverysuccessfulmeansofmotivatingschoollearners,bothintheuseofthelanguageforcommunicationpur-posesandinenhancingpupils’understandingandknowledgeofdiffer-entEuropeancountriesandcultures.Inaddition,e-TwinningnecessarilycombineslanguageusewithICTskills,thusreinforcingtheideathatlan-guageskillsarenottobelearnedandpracticedinisolationfromotherfieldsofcompetence.Moreover,successfulproject-relatedactivitiesbasedoncommunicatingwithpeersfromprojectpartnerinstitutions,performedonlineinthecomputerlabclassroom,canbeextendedoutofschoolwiththesupportofparentsandteachers.KaunasPanemunePrimarySchoolinLithuania(Casestudyn°1below)illustrateshowthiskindofextendedactivitycanenhancelanguagelearning.Itispointedoutinanumberofcasestudiesthatthelanguageusedasthemediumofcommunicationcanbethemothertongueofoneoftheprojectpart-nerschoolsoracommonthirdlanguage.Thesuccessoftheinitiativeliesinthefactthatpupilsaremotivatedbyrealcommunicationwiththeir
14 15
weredstudentsatalllevelstotakeautonomousdecisionsandtoexplo-retheirownpathwaysinaccessinginformationandcommunicatingwiththeirpeers.Youngpeopleliketolearninpeer-groups,eitherinformalandinformalcontexts:tandem-learning,participationindiscussionforumsandInternetchatsandotherinformalactivitiesmakelearningcaptivatingandfun.
Externalfactorslikeastimulatinglearningenvironment,e.g.aself-accesslanguage-learningcentrewithhelpfulassistance,alsoplayanimportantpartinmotivatinglanguagelearning.Learninginaself-accessmultimediacentreorsurfingonsitesofpersonalinterestathomeismuchmoreattractiveandmotivatingthansittinginaclassroomwherethelevel,thetopics,thepacearebasedonaveragelearnersandwheregiftedlearnerscannotreachtheirfullpotentialandlesstalentedlearnersstruggleandfallfartherbehind.
ManyoftheMOLANcasestudies,particularlythoserelatingtoHigherEducation,refertotheimportanceofindependence,autonomyorselfdi-rectioninmotivatinglanguagelearners.Atschoollevel,languagelearn-ingstillremainsmuchmoreteacher-orientated.Independentlearningandlearnerautonomyareprincipallyimplementedthroughautonomousextracurricularactivitiessuchasthosedescribedabove,self-directedlearningspacesandtheuseofresearchbrowsersandICTingeneral.InHigherEducation,independentlanguagelearningisnowanessentialfactorinexpandinglanguagetake-up.Ittakesplacemostlyinlanguagecentreswithself-accessareas.Itisalsooftencombinedwithformalclassroomlearning(blendedlearning).Allcasestudiesmentiontheparamountroleoftutorialsupportseenasakeytoamoreself-directedwayoflanguagelearning,tothedevelopmentoflanguageawarenessandtotheenhancementoflearningstrategies.Anotherimportantpointmentionedinrelationtoautonomouslearningisitsrelevancetolifelonglearning.
empowering students to learn: independent language learning
Independent,autonomousorself-directedlearninghasalwaysplayedalargepartinacquiringforeignlanguageskills.However,theexponentialdevelopmentofICTandwebcommunicationhavegiventhisformoflearninganewdimensionandturneditintoanimportantmotivationalfactorinthedevelopmentoflanguagecompetence.
Thedegreeofindependenceorautonomyoutsidetheclassroomorlecturehallliesofcoursesomewherealongacontinuumbetweenfullyselfdirectedlearningwiththeaidofself-studylanguagebooksordigitalprogrammesatoneendandteacher-directedcourseswherethelearner’sindependencewillconsistonlyinpossibleextrawebbrowsingorreading.Inbetweenthereisamultitudeofdegreesanddifferentkindsofautonomouslearningthatcantakeplaceinavarietyofsettings(classroom,multimedialanguagecentre,athome,etc.)andinvolvedifferentpractices(self-access,learnertraining,etc.)andmodesoflearning(distancelearning,selfinstruction,etc.).Astheteachergradu-allytransfershis/hercontrolofdecisionmakingtolearners,thelatterincreasestep-by-stepcontrolovertheirlearningwithgrowingmaturityandunderstanding.Atthesametime,theroleoftheteacherchangesintooneoflearningadvisor.
AusefultooltopromotelearnerautonomyisprovidedbytheEuropeanLanguagePortfolio(ELP)whosemainaimisthepromotionofpluriling-ualismandpluriculturalism.InthePrinciplesandGuidelinespublishedbytheCouncilofEurope(http://www.coe.int/T/DG4/Linguistic/Sour-ce/Guidelines_EN.pdf),theELPisseenasenhancingthecapacityforindependentlanguagelearning,withadualfunction:„bothapedagogicfunctiontoguideandsupportthelearnerintheprocessoflanguagelearningandareportingfunctiontorecordproficienciesinlanguages“,asithelpslearnerstoplan,monitorandassesstheirlearningprocess.Thelinkbetweenindependentlearningandmotivationinlanguagelearninghasbecomeincreasinglyapparent.Sincemotivationinlangua-gelearningisprincipallyaninternallyregulatedprocess,independentlanguagelearnerswhoareawareoftheirownneeds,interestsandgoalsandareabletomakeuseoflearningstrategiesaremuchmoremotiva-tedthanpassivelearners.Inrecentyears,thespreadofICThasempo-
16 17
ThecasestudydevotedtotheFremdsprachenzentrumderHochschulenimLandeBremen(CaseStudyn°4below)highlightsthemotivationalroleofdiversifiedtutorialprogrammesandtheimplementationofEPOS,awebbasedlanguagelearningandcommunicationplatformwithanintegratedelectronicportfoliointheformoftheELPoftheEuropeanLanguageCouncil.Thissystemofferslanguagelearnersaflexiblelan-guage-learningprogramme,whichprovidesanoverviewofthelearner‘scompetenceandenhanceshis/herlearningautonomy.
acquiring knowledge through the medium of the foreign language (clIl)
Accesstoknowledge(asopposedtoinformation)throughthemediumofaforeignlanguageliesattheheartoftheEuropeanstudentexchangeandmobilityexperience,asstudentsfromothercountriesattendlectu-resandseminarsinhostuniversitiesgiveninthemainstreamlanguageofthecountryorregionconcerned.Atschoollevel,ContentandLanguageIntegratedLearning(CLIL)coversmanydifferenteducationalmodels,whichhavebeenintroducedwithvaryingdegreesofsuccess.SomeEuropeancountrieshavehadmanyyearsofexperienceusingCLIL,inothersalmostnone.Despitethesevariations,therationalesandgoalsthataregivenfortheimplementati-onofCLILhaveagreatdealincommon.The2006EurydiceSurveyonContentandLanguageIntegratedLearning(CLIL)atSchoolinEurope,analysesthesituationin30Europeancountries,wheredifferentcontextsandmodelsco-exist,dependingonvariablessuchasthestatusofthelanguage,startingage,andtheintensityanddurationoftheprogram-mes.Allinall,therearemorethan200typesofCLILprogrammesandmorethan40labelsco-existtodescribetheintegrationofcontent-learningwithlanguagelearning.However,irrespectiveofmodelorlabel,CLILisregardedasakeyinstrumentinenhancinglanguagelearningandlanguagediversityvaluesinEurope.ThisisreflectedinEUsupportgiventoanumberofCLILprojects,studies,organisationsandexperi-mentalinitiativesasanintegralpartofforeignlanguageteaching.
AlthoughnospecificcasestudyillustratingtheimplementationofCLILisincludedinthishandbook,theconceptappearsasastrongmotivati-onalfactorinanumberofthecasestudiesbelow,notablythoserela-tingtoregionsandcommunitieswithwell-definedandpro-activeearlylanguagelearningpolicies(seeCaseStudyn°3belowontheLlanesMiddleSchoolinAndalusiaandCaseStudyn°5inthenextsection:MultilingualeducationinprimaryschoolsinBrussels).
18 19
1.1. An example of early language teaching
PrimaryeducationinLithuaniaisof4yearsdurationfromtheageof7to11beforechildrentransfertothesecondarysector.Thelearningofaforeignlanguageiscompulsoryonlyinthelastyearofprimaryeducationattheageof10.Howevertherealwayshavebeensomeinterestingexperimentswithearlylanguageteachingandnowthere’squiteawidenationalnetworkofschoolscarryingthisforward,mainlyintheteachingofEnglish.
TheKaunasPanemunePrimarySchoolispartandtheleaderofthisnationalnetworkandcollaborateswiththeTeacherProfessionalDevelop-mentCentresinKaunasandVilniusintheoperationofthislanguageprogramme,whichisinnovativeaschildrenbeginlearningtheforeignlanguageattheageof8.Englishhasbeenchosenbecauseofitsglobaluseandotherlanguagesmaybeexploredinthefuture.
TheschoolhasalonghistoryofinvolvementininternationalandEuro-peanprojectsstretchingbackto1994.Thisincludes4Comeniuspro-jectsandinvolvementinSpringdays,EuropeDayandtheEuropeanDayofLanguages.
Theaimofthelanguageinitiativeistogivepupilsthenecessarybasic(primary)communicativeskillsforproficiencyinspeaking,reading,liste-ningandwritingaswellasasenseofbeingpartoftheEuropeanCom-munity.PupilsintheschoolstarttheirEnglishlessonsattheageof8,with3lessonsaweekinclasstimeaswellashavingtheopportunitytotakepartinextra-curricularactivitiesduringtheafternoonfreetime.
Withpupilmotivationinmindtheteachingstrategyisbasedonacom-municativeteachingapproachwhereenhancingmotivationandfoster-ingapositiveattitudetolanguagelearningisparamount.Aplentifulsupplyofvisualaidsisavailableandlanguageistaughtthroughmakingmusic,singing,gamesanddrama.Theschoollibrary,besideshousingastockofbooksinEnglishwhichthepupilslovetoread,isalsoequippedwithaninteractivewhiteboardlinkedto14desktopcomputerslinkedtotheschoolnetworkandothermedia.Projectworkisfrequentlycarried
20 21
TherangeoflearningpossibilitiessuchasICT,Englishbooksandthecombinationofformalandinformallearningoptionshaveenhancedmotivationandensuredgoodprogress.Moreoverspecialarrangementsareinplacetoensuresmallerclassgroupsforthelanguageprogram-me.TheuseofICT,interactivewhiteboardsandonlinelearningenablechildrentolearnmoreeasilyandinafunenvironment.Theintegrationoflanguagelearninginotherschoolactivitiesalsomotivatespupilstousetheirlanguageoutsidetheclassroom.ParticipationinthePublicSpeakingChampionshipgivespupilstheopportunitytopracticetheirspeakingskillsinaninnovativeandengagingcontextandallowsthemtodeveloptheirconfidenceandproficiencyintheEnglishlanguageaswellastheirsocialskills.
Finally,participationininternationalprojectshasbeenbeneficialinthatteachershavebeengiventheopportunitytosharegoodpracticewithteachersfromothercountriesandpupilshavealsohadthehighlymotivatingexperienceofusingaforeignlanguageinarealsituation.
Success indicators
TheresultsofaquestionnairesentouttopupilsandparentsinthespringeachyearrevealthatthereisconsiderablesatisfactionwiththeinitiativeandwiththeprogressbeingmadeinEnglish.
Theresultsalsorevealthatattitudestowardslanguagelearning,toothersubjectsandtoschoollifeingeneralhaveimprovedsincethelaunchoftheinitiative.
Thepupilshavedevelopedahighstandardofcommunicativeskillsthroughthemethodsusedintheinitiative:theyareabletointeractwithvisitorstotheschoolandcanmakepresentationsinconfidentandcor-rectEnglish.
ItisapositiveindicatorthatpupilschooseactivitiessuchastheEnglishClub,whichisoptionalandintheirowntime,asignoftheirgeneralinte-restintheinitiative.
outanditisdisplayedontheclassroomwallsandaroundtheschool.Thebestprojectsarerecognizedbybeingpresentedatschoolassem-bliesinfrontofthewholeschoolcommunity,includingtheparents.Thiswholeschoolapproachgreatlyenhancesthemotivationofpupils.
Teaching approaches
Teachersuseinteractivemethodsandteaching/learningstrategieswhichmaketheprocessoflearningattractive.UseofICT,includingwhiteboards,e-learningandacross-curricularapproachenablechildrentolearnmoreeasilyandenjoytheexperience.Pupilsenjoytheopportu-nityofusingtheInternetforlanguagelearning.
ThemostpopularclassactivityispreparationfortheEnglishPublicSpeakingChampionship.FourtimesayearpupilspreparePowerPointpresentationsontheirfavouritetopic.Theysearchmaterialonthein-ternet,insertpicturesandphotos,andusedifferentelementsofsound,musicandvideowhichtheyfilmthemselves.Thesereportsarethenpre-sentedtotheclass.Inspringthewinnersofthefourroundsintroducetheirreportstotheschoolcommunity.TheschoolinvitesotherschoolstoparticipateinthefinalroundoftheChampionshipwhichisusuallyheldonSpringdayinEuropeanschools.Parentsarealsoinvited.Intheschool,thecompilations(ofeveryyearsince2005)ofpupils’presenta-tionsatthefinalroundoftheseChampionshipsarearchived.
Success factors
Theschoolhasadaptedawholeschoolapproachandallpartnersinthewiderschoolcommunity(pupils,teachingstaff,schoolmanagement,parents)areactivelyinvolvedinthepromotionofthelanguagelearningprogramme.Thiswholeschoolapproachisessentialintheimplemen-tationofanearlystartprogrammeandensuresthattheprojectattractstheappropriatefinancefromlocalandnationalauthorities.
22 23
TeachersarealsochoosingtoparticipateinEuropeanprojectswhichallowthemtodevelopprofessionallyandfeedthatexperiencebackintotheirteaching.
SinceSeptember2009,followingthenumerousexamplesofachievinggoodresults,theprocessofearlyforeignlanguagelearningwillstartinallschoolsinLithuaniaattheageof8.
lessons to be learned
Theoveralllessontobelearnedfromtheexperienceofthepastfewye-arsisthatstartingtheteachingandlearningofaforeignlanguageatageseven/eightisinvaluableandthattheimaginativeuseofICTtodevelopanappropriatelyauthenticenvironmentandenablingthechildrentoparticipateininternationalactivitiesenhancestheirmotivation.
future plans
Inthefuture,theschoolwillexploreapossibleextensionoftheproject,whichcouldincludeotherlanguages,suchasGermanorFrench.
contact informationCountry:LithuaniaNameofschool:KaunoPanemunespradinemokykla(KaunasPanemunePrimarySchool)Address:Kariunupl.5,LT-45432Kaunas,LithuaniaEmail:[email protected]:VirginijaRupainiene,HeadTeacherTelephone:+37061573123,Tel./Fax.+37037345881
24 25
1.2. Using blogs to motivatethe learning of French in Ireland
SetupbyDeirdreMcCarthy,ateacherofFrenchattheSt.Michael´sLoretoSecondarySchool,acatholicschoolforgirlsaged12to18inNavan,acommutertowntothenorthwestofDublin,thisinitiativeinvol-vesthecreationofblogsinFrenchbyfifthyearpupils(16years)incollaborationwiththeICTdepartment.TheobjectiveoftheexperienceistoenhancethelearningofFrenchbythesepupilswhoarewellversedintheuseoftheuseofblogs.
Basedontheattractiontobloggingenjoyedbypupils,theFrenchteachersetupthisprojectwiththehelpoftheICTdepartment.TheaimistoenhancethelearningofFrenchamongpupilswhilemakinguseoftheiralreadyacquiredICTskills.32computersareavailableattheschool,allowingeachstudenttohavetheirownworkplace.StudentscanasktheirteacherforlinguisticsupportortheICTdepartmentfortechnicalhelp.
Theaimofthisprojectistoincreasestudents‘motivationtolearnFrenchthroughatechnologywithwhichtheyarealreadyfamiliar;toincreasepupilautonomy;andtocreatealanguagelearningexperiencethatcouldpotentiallybesharedwithcountlessmembersoftheon-linecommunity.
Thefollowingsuccessindicatorsaretobenoted:-thestudentswerehighlymotivatedbythefactthatanyinternetsurfercouldreadtheirblog.Thisledthemtodotheirbestinwritingtheblog,carefullyexpressingtheirpersonalopinionsaboutthetopicdiscussed,aswellastakingcarewiththeoverallappearanceoftheirblog.-theinitiativewonanawardintheannualEuropeanLanguagesAwardschemeinIrelandforbeingan“extremelyinnovativeandfunwayforthestudentstodeveloptheirskillsinthetargetlanguage”.
26 27
Acombinationofdifferentfactorshascontributedtothesuccessoftheinitiative;amongthemthecommitmentoftheFrenchteacher,thesup-portoftheschoolauthoritiesandthecooperationwiththeICTdepart-ment.Also,educationalbloggingprovesitselftobeamostacceptablemethodologyforlanguagelearningforbothteachersandstudents,whofeelitmoreinaccordancewiththedemandsoftoday‘stechnologicalsocietythanmoretraditionalmethods.Anothersuccessfactorhasbeentheusefulnessandrelevanceofthislanguagelearningexperienceforpupils´futureemployability.
contact informationCountry:IrelandNameofschool:St.Michael’s,LoretoSecondarySchool.Address:Navan,MeathWebsitehttp://www.stmichaels.eircom.netTypeofschool:Catholicgirls‘secondaryschoolEmail:[email protected]:DeirdreMcCarthyemail:[email protected]:0876818733
28 29
1.3. Moving towards a polyglot mindsetin Andalusia
WehavesurveyedIESLlanes(Sevilla,Spain),ahighschoolwhichtakespartinthePlurilingualismpromotionplanofAndalusia(henceforththePlan).ThisisanambitiousregionalpolicydocumentoftheJuntadeAndalucíaand3yearsafteritsimplementationwecanshowitsbenefits.IESLlanesisoneofthe400centersthatformanetworkofbilingualschoolsataregionallevel.DeeplyrootedinEuropeanplurilingualideology,thePlan(availableinFrench,English,SpanishandGermanat:http://www.juntadeandalucia.es/averroes/impe/web/portadaEntidad?pag=/contenidos/B/InnovacionEInvestigacion/Proyec-tosInnovadores/Plurilinguismo/&vE=mE7)setsanexampleforresourcemanagementefficiencyandmotivationandlanguagelearningincreaseinrecordtime.
Andalusiaisamonolingualregion,afeaturethatmightseriouslycompromisefuturedevelopment.Asaresult,authoritieshavestartedtofocusonthepromotionofL2/L3competencesasvitalformodernizationandprosperity;arationalethathasalreadyfosteredsuccessfullanguageplanningandeducationalpoliciesinotherregionsbothwithinandbey-ondtheEuropeanborders.
IESLlanesusesCLILmethodologyinEnglishandFrenchinthefol-lowingsubjects:Geography,History,Maths,Science(ChemistryandPhysics)andTechnology.Furthermore,IESLlanesisanICTcenter,whichmeansthatitisatechnologically-enhancedcenterwitharatioofonecomputerforeverytwopupilsandwithanovellearningproject.Thedidacticapproachisnotthetraditionalone:“cando”attitudeisboos-ted.
Extracurricularactivitiesarefundamentalforthestudents’motivation:languageweeks,festivals,andexchangeprogrammeswithBritishcen-tersareheld.IESLlanestakespartin“SchoolpartnershipsinEurope”(see:http://www.etwinning.net/es/pub/index.htm),thetwincenterisMAESYRYRFAinWales(UnitedKingdom).
30 31
-TeachershavestartedlosingsightoftheirtextbookastheonlyormainsourceofmaterialsandhavestartedcreatingtheirownL2andL3textsandactivities(seehttp://www.juntadeandalucia.es/averro-es/~41700117/ingles/bilingual.html).-Anexternalevaluationprocedurewasconducted.UniversidadPablodeOlavidewastaskedwithrunningtheevaluationforall400centers.Afullreportiscurrentlybeingprepared.Basedonthisevaluation,secondaryschoolstudentsaged13whohadbeenpartofthebilingualset-upfortwoyearsreachedB1CEFRlevelinEnglishandsimilarlevelsinFrench.Twokeyfactorsarenoteworthyhere:firstly,theselanguagecompetencelevels,althoughmeagrebyotherstandards,areoutstandingifnationallevelsareconsidered(seeEurobarometer2006forSpain);secondly,thecompetencelevelattestedwasreachedonlyafteroneandahalfyearsofinstruction.Thisallowsustoharbourhighhopesforfuturecompetencelevelswhenthisschemewillhavebeensustainedforalongertime.Furthermore,thereareanumberofexperimentalcentersinAndalusiafoundedtenyearsagothatwerelaunchedwiththeaidofAllianceFrancaise.Thestudentsofthesecentershavebeenshowntohavereachedfunctionalbilinguallevels(basedonDALFandDELFresults)aftertenyearsofinstruction.
Anoveralllessonisthatjointinterventionsofuniversities,administration,andteachersdepartmentscanworktogetherforfruitfulresults,howeverharditmaybetomakeallpartsagreeonproceduresandgoals.
contact informationCountry:SpainUniversity:UniversidadPablodeOlavideAddress:Crta.deUtrera,km.1;41013(Sevilla,España)School:InstitutodeEducacionLlanes(LlanesMiddleSchool)Address:EscultorFranciscoBuizas/n,410008SevillaEmail:www.iesllanes.netSchoolauthority:ConsejeríadeEducación(JuntadeAndalucía)
Moreover,continuoustrainingisnecessaryforteachers.Tothispurpose,UniversidadPablodeOlavideoffersamaster’sdegreeinbilingualteaching.
Themaingoalsoftheinitiativearetopromotebilingualism;mobilityandmutualknowledgebetweenstudentsandteachersfromdifferentcoun-triesinEurope,andemployability.Anumberofsuccessfactorswerevitalinordertoachievethesepurposes:theJuntadeAndaluciahasfi-nancedthePlanwith140millioneuros(2005-2008period);thePlanandthelocalAdministrationaskedAndalusianuniversitiesfortechnicalsup-portandadvice(jointresearchgroupsareupandrunningonanumberofkeyareas:Languageacrossthecurriculum,ICTandlanguagelear-ning,CLIL...);ahugenumberofwell-plannedinitiativespresentedasasinglepackweredeveloped,andwereawardedtheEuropeanLabelforLanguageInitiativesoftheEuropeanCommissionin2004,and,finally,newimaginativestrategiestohireteachingassistants(TA)weredevised(theadministrationhasfocusedonyounggraduateAmericanandEras-musuniversitystudents,whoteachtheirmothertongueasTAswhiletheygetthebenefitoftakingSpanishcoursesand,moreimportantly,ofenjoyingfullsocializationinSpanishcenters).
Thefollowingindicatorsshowthattheprogramissuccessful:-Thereisahighdemandforbilingualschoolplacesfromparents(parentssetahighvalueonthewholeprogramandkeepdemandingfurtherplaces);surveysshowtotalcommitmentbyallpartswiththenewlanguageschoolstructure.Avirtuouscyclehasbeeninitiated:parentsthinkteachersarebetterprofessionals;teachershavehigherself-esteemandstrivehardertomakethemorecomplicatedschemeasuccess;andstudentsnoticemorevariedmethodsandactivitiesandaremorecommitted.Thusthereisaninfectiouscultureofsuccessamongteachers,pupilsandparents,whoallworktogethertoimprovemethodologyandtocopewithproblemswhichariseinthemorecomplicatedpartsoftheinitiative.Thesuccessachievedcreatesgreaterself-esteemamongteachersandthisrubsoffonthepupilswhosepositiveattitudetowardslanguagelearningisnoticedbyparents.
32 33
1.4. EPOS – an e-portfolio for three sectors of education
EPOSwasdevelopedatthe„Fremdsprachenzentrum“(FZHB)andatthe„LandesinstitutfürSchule“inBremen,asacommonweb-basedplatformforlanguagelearninginschools,universitiesandfurtheredu-cation.ItcontainsthedescriptorsoftheELC-ELPandoffersallpartsoftheELPineducationallystructuredlearningenvironments.Ithasbeenwelcomedbyallprominentpoliticalandeconomicinstitutions(intheregion/Europe?)asameansofenhancingplurilingualismandencoura-gingautonomouslanguagelearning.TheELPhasbeenusedinclassesandwithinautonomouslanguagelearningintheSelf-accessCentreoftheFZHBforabouteightyears.WechangedtotheEPOSplatformfouryearsago;sincethewintersemesterof2007/08,EPOShasbeenusedinthetutorialprogramoftheFZHBaswell.
EPOShasbeendevelopedincooperationwithpartnersinthesectorsofeducation,furthereducationandadulteducationinBremen.Allthesesectorsformthe„RunderTischSprachenBremen“ortheRoundTableofLanguagesinBremen.FoundermembersofthisRoundTablewillalsoconstitutethe„SprachenratBremen“whichwasofficiallylaunchedon26September2009.Inadditiontomembersoftheabove-mentionededucationalsectors,theSprachenratBremenconsistsofrepresentati-vesfromthepoliticalandeconomicsectors,andthepeopleofBremen.ThisgroupingofallavailableresourcesenhancesMultilingualisminthesenseofemployabilityandEuropeanmobility.Thiscollaborationonins-titutionallevelisoneoftheoverallsuccessfactors.
OneprojectwhichusesEPOSasacoreinstrumentisthetutorialprogramattheForeignLanguagesCentreofUniversitiesinBremenorFremd-sprachenzentrum(FZHB).ThetutorialprogramwasimplementedattheFZHBinOctober2007toenhanceplurilingualismandtoencourageau-tonomouslanguagelearning.Thisprogramaimsatcombininglanguageclasses,autonomouslanguagelearningwithEPOS,tutorialadvisoryservice,expertadvisoryserviceandfeedbackaswellaspeer-andpro-jectbasedlearning.Thelearninginthetutorialprogramisclass-indepen-dent.Studentscanregisterforanylanguageforwhichclassesareoffe-redattheFZHBorforwhichlearningmaterialinelectronicorbookformisavailable.
34 35
Furthermore,studentsareencouragedtotakepartintheTANDEMpro-gramofouruniversity.Theprogramisfreeofcharge.TheLanguageCentreoffersallthematerialanditisuptothestudentshowmuchwork-loadtheywouldliketo“invest”intheprogram.Thisautonomyfostersmotivationquitealotandcontributestothesuccessstoryoftheprogram.
InallcasesEPOSplaysanimportantrole.Itservesasaplatformforlearning,reflectionsonlearningandcommunicationbetweenlearnerandtutor,providingthepropertiesoftheELP.ThecharacteristictoolsoftheplatformarethepartsoftheELP–biography,dossierandpassportand,furthermore,alearningagreementandanonlinelearningjournal.Studentscanuploadanyfilestothedossier:texts,videos,audio-files,pictures,etc.
StudentsareexpectedtousethevariouspartsofEPOSthroughouttheirlearningprogram.WhenusingEPOS,studentshavetoreflectontheirlearningprocess,theirsuccessandthegapbetweentheiraimsandtheircurrentproficiency.Whilepeer-to-peerandproject-basedlear-ningareintegraltothelanguagecourse,thetutorialprogramservesthecognitiveandtheaffectivelearningfieldsaswellandbringsinacollabo-rativeaspect.
Thetaskoftutoringisperformedbyskilledstudentswhoofteneitherfromthelanguageorthelanguageareteachingdepartment.Wealsoac-ceptstudentswhospeakmorethanoneforeignlanguageandwhohavealreadygainedexperienceinreflectingontheirlanguagelearningawareness.Theyaretrainedinseveralworkshopsbyexpertsaswellasbyseniortutorsfortheirjob.Additionally,thereisaweeklymeetingwithalltutorsforsupervisionanddevelopmentofconcepts.Thecoordinatorisbothcoachandsupervisorforthetutorsandtutees.
Thetutorialprogramaimsatprovidingstudentswithtransferablecommunicationskillsrelevanttomobility,employability,academiclifeingeneralandthespecificrequirementsoftheiruniversitycourses.Morestudentsnowhavethechancetolearnanotherforeignlanguageandtherebyincreasetheirchancesinthejob-marketofaknowledge-basedsociety.
Furthermore,evaluationpapers,posters,powerpoint-presentations,stage-Cervuniversities–SciencesofBremenandBremerhavenBremenaswell.12ationconductedbytheFZHBhasshownthatautonomouslearningisafunwayoflearninglanguageandassuchisextremelymo-tivatingforstudents.Eachtutorialprogramendsinacelebratorymoodwherestudents’projectworkispresentedintheformofplays,etc.
TheFZHBhasestablishedacollaborationwiththeUniversityofOlden-burg,the(private)JacobsUniversityBremenandthethreegreatEuro-peanCulturalInstitutes:GoetheInstitut,InstitutoCervantesandInsti-tuteFrançais.EPOSisusedasatoolforblendedlearningintheseinstitutions,and,additionally,fortutorialprogramsinFZHB’smembertheUniversityofBremen,theUniversitiesofAppliedavenandtheUni-versityoftheArtsaswell.
Thetutorialprogramisofferedduringthesemesterandinthesemesterbreaks.IntheperiodfromOctober2007uptoMarch2008,220stu-dentsregisteredforthetutorialprogramattheuniversity.Thenumberisincreasingsteadily.Thefollowingdiagramshowsthedistributionoflanguagesandstudentsinthelastsemester,2008/2009.
languages and students
English
German
Spanish
French
Turkish
36 37
Therangeoflanguagesbeinglearntdiffersineachprogramrun.Al-together,wehavehad18differentlanguagesthathavebeenstudied,amongothersAfrikaans,Arabic,Chinese,Dutch,English,French,Ger-man,Hungarian,Italian,Japanese,Norwegian,Portuguese,Russian,SwedishandTurkish.ThelevelsrangefrombeginnertoadvancedC1withasuccessrateofnearly90%.Evaluationhasshownthatover80%oftheparticipantswouldrecommendtheprogramandaresatisfiedwiththeirtutors.85%thinkthatthequalityofthematerialisrathergoodandabout65%thinkthatproject-basedlearningwithpeersisquitesuppor-tive.
Sincethelanguageclassesofthewintersemesterof2008/09,auto-nomouslanguagelearning,thetutorialprogramandatutorprogramhavebeenlinkedinamodulatedsystematthedepartmentofGeneralStudies.Studentscannowgain9ECTSECTS(teachereducation)or15(excludingstudentsoflanguagesciencesandteachereducation).Parti-cipationisfreeofchargewhencombinedwithasemesterabroad.Wehavethereforesucceededinbridgingagapinmeetingstudents‘needs:establishingpedagogicaltoolsinelectroniclearningenvironments.Autonomouslanguagelearninghasthusbecomeattractiveandmanageable.
contact informationCountry:GermanyNameofinstitution:FremdsprachenzentrumBremen,c/oUniversitätBremenAddress:GW2,RaumA3190,Bibliothekstr.Website:http://www.fremdsprachenzentrumEmail:[email protected]:Dr.BärbelKühnTelephone:0421/218-61962Fax:0421/218-98-61962
38 39
2. Motivating language learners through language policy
Formanyyears,“foreign”languagelearningwasviewedbymanyschoolpupilsasaboringandtransitoryimpositiontobeendured,ratherthanenjoyed,fortheshortesttimepossible.Thesubjectwasdefinitelycon-finedtosecondaryschooling,as“grammar”and“textanalysis”weredeemedtobetoocomplexandserioustobeapproachedatanear-lierage.Therangeoflanguagesstudiedwaslimitedandsoweretheteachingmethodsandmaterialsused.Atuniversity,“language”lear-ningofanykindwasoftenviewedwithdisdainbyacademics,asbeingdistinctlynonacademic(asopposedtolearningaboutlanguagesandcultures)andthereforenotworthyoffeaturinginthemainstreamcurri-culum.
WithintheEuropeanUnion,thesituationhasevolvedradicallyoverthepasttwentyyears,assecondorthirdlanguagelearninghasgraduallybecomethenormthroughoutmanyeducationalsystems,frominfantschoolsrightuptopostgraduatelevel,aslanguageteachingandlear-ningmethodsandtechniqueshaveundergoneaseachangeandasotherworldlanguagesandcultureshavegraduallymadeinroadswhereFrench,GermanandSpanishusedtorulesupreme(Englishbeinginacategoryofitsown).
However,introducinglanguagetuitionatanearlyageorofferingmorediverselanguageoptionstoadvancedstudentsdoesnotinitselfgua-ranteelearnermotivation:thewaylanguagelearningisimplemented,whetherwithintheschoolcurriculumorwithinauniversitylanguagepo-licy,remainsthekeytosuccessfullanguagelearning.Inthissection,welookatsomeofthewaysinwhichthe“languageoffer”inschoolsanduniversitieshasbeenusedtomotivatelanguagelearners.
40 41
Minority language initiatives
Increasinglearnermotivationbytakingintoaccountthediversityofthestudents’immediatelinguisticandculturalenvironment,isnowsome-thingwhichmany(butbynomeansall)schoolsand/oreducationalau-thoritieshavetakenonboardwhendefininglanguagepolicyforschools.CaseStudy5illustrateshowawellthoughtoutearlylanguagelearningpolicycanhelpbridgethegapbetweenlanguagecommunitieswhileen-hancinglearningachievement.AsimilarstoryistoldinCaseStudyn°6:“Breakingdownculturalbarriers:teachingUrduininnercityLondon”.Thecasestudyshowshowtheintroductionofalesstaughtcommunitylanguage,Urdu,alongsideFrenchandSpanish,inamulticulturalschooltypicalofinnercityLondon,helpednotonlyovercomeadversecultu-ralstereotypesamongstudentsfromnonAsianbackgrounds,butalsoincreasedtheoverallleveloflanguagetake-upandlearnermotivation,resultinginimprovedall-roundlanguagecompetence.
University language policies
Eversincethe2001EuropeanYearofLanguages,theideaof‘languagesforall’hasgraduallypermeatedtheEuropeanHigherEducationArea.Tertiaryeducationinstitutionsnowseemtoagreethatplurilingualismandpluriculturalismareassetsthatstudentsmustpossessuponcom-pletingtheirdegreesiftheyaretobefullyequippedforsuccessfulpro-fessionalcareers.Thesehavethusbecomestrategictargetswhenplan-ningnewdegreesundertheBolognaprocess.Asaresult,languagepo-liciesatuniversitylevelarebecomingtheruleratherthantheexceptionandhavemadelanguagesvisibleandvaluable.
TheEuropeanstrategyonmultilingualismclearlyseemstohavemadebigadvancesattertiarylevel.Agrowingnumberofhighereducationinstitutionsappeartobeawareofthepotentialreturnstobeexpectedofincreasedfinancialandacademicinvestmentinlanguagelearning.Students,inturn,arealsopreparedtoinvestmoretime,intellectualef-fortand,insomecases,money,inlearningmorelanguagesandlearningaboutdifferentcultures,intheknowledgethatthiswillstandthemingoodsteadinacompetitivelabourmarket.
early language learning
Muchresearchhasbeendevotedinthepasttwodecadestothepro-cessesoflanguagelearningamongyounginfants.Thefindingsovertheyearsincludethefactthatevenbabiesareabletodistinguishrhythmpatternsbetweenlanguages,thatinfantscandiscriminatebetweenthesoundsoflanguagestheyhavebeenexposedto,andthatseven-montholdbilingualinfantshaveacognitiveaddedvalueovermonolingu-alsinrespondingtovisualcues.Clearly,evenininfants,learninglangua-gesisbeneficial.
Thisprocessdoesnotcometoanendonceinschool.LongbeforeEuropestarteditsmultilingualpolicyanAmericanreportshowedtheaddedvalueofearlylanguagelearning.Whencomparedtomonolingu-alsthebilingualgroupinvariablyhasbetterscoresontestsaswellasonschoolperformance(cf.WilburnRobinson1992).ThesameresultswerefoundbyEuropeanresearchers(cf.Jäppinen2005,VandeCraenetal.2007).
Asaresult,thecurrentEuropeanlanguagepolicystronglypromotingearlylanguagelearningreachesoutbeyondlanguages.Thereisnodoubtthatearlylanguagelearningbooststhelearnerinthesensethather/hislearningaptitudegetsstrengthened.Thismeansthatifproperlyimplemented,earlylanguagelearningcanbecomeanimportantmotivationalfactorintheoveralleducationalprocess.
Severalofthecasestudiesinthishandbookrelatetoearlylanguagelearninginitiatives:twohavealreadybeenlistedintheprevioussection,whileanother,onaFranco-Scottishe-twinninginitiative,featuresinthesectiondevotedtocooperationwithotherstakeholdersandpartners(Section3,CaseStudyn°).Thissectionfeaturesacaseinpoint:theSTIMOBinitiative(StimulatingMultilingualEducationinBrussels)describedinCaseStudyn°5:“MultilingualprimaryeducationinBrus-sels”.Thecaseillustrateshowaproactivelanguagepolicy,combiningmultilingualeducationandCLIL,canhelpimprovenotonlythestudents’languageskillsinbothofthelanguagesconcerned(inthiscaseFlemishandFrench)butalsooverallperformanceinothersubjects,notfor-gettingtheboostgiventotheirfutureemploymentprospectsinamulti-lingualenvironment,thusprovidingapowerfulincentivetostudentstomakethemostoftheopportunitiesprovided.
42 43
Asregardsthelanguagesonoffer,thereseemstobeaconnectionbet-weentherangeoflanguagesprovidedandthesociolinguisticfeaturesofthelocalcommunity,whethermonolingual,bilingualormultilingual,andthepresenceofalargeundergraduateinternationalstudentpopula-tion.Therangeoflanguagesonoffercanthusvaryfromahandfulto50orso.Studentchoicealsovaries,fromtotallyoptionalsystemsbasedentirelyonincentiveandmotivation,tooneswheremandatorylangua-geprovisionwithonedominantsecondlanguage(usuallyEnglish)iscombinedwithoptionalthirdorfourthlanguagelearning.Asforlearningformats,theyincludeeverykindofapproach,fromconventionalclass-roomsituationstoblendedlearning,tandempractice,consultations,andonlinelearning,allinvolvingvaryingdegreesoflearnerautonomy(seeCaseStudyn°4intheprevioussection).Studentlanguageportfolios,EuropeanDiplomaSupplements,accre-ditationand/orcertificationonthebasisoflocal,nationalorinternatio-nalschemes,areallnowpartoftheoverallpictureandallcontributetoenhancinglanguagetake-upandlearnermotivationamongstudents(seeinparticularCasestudiesn°13and14inthefourthsectionofthishand-book).
Intermsoflanguagepractice,self-learningcentreswithnativespeakertutoring,languageclubsandvariousformsoftandemlearninginvolvingnativespeakersarenowanintegralpartofthelanguagelearningexpe-rienceinmostHigherEducationinstitutions,especiallythosewithlargenumbersofforeignstudents(seeCaseStudy14“ABVlanguagemodulesattheFUB”insection4below).Thiskindof‘insitu’experiencewillthenoftenenhancethestudent’smotivationinwantingtotakepartinmobilityprogrammesandseekingforeignworkplacements,eitheraspartoforasacomplementtotheirdegreeprogramme.
Theimplementationofalanguagepolicywhichwillenhancelearnermotivationrequiresafirmfinancialcommitmentonthepartoftheuni-versity,asitimpliesadditionalexpenditureonteachingresourcesandequipmentcomparedtoexistinglanguageprovision.However,itcanalsobeausefulassettoputforwardwhenapproachinglocal,centralgovern-mentorEuropeanfundingsources,asitmaybeaprerequisiteforreceiv-ingfinancialsupport.Asregardsstudentcontributions,approachesvaryfromfreeprovisionforanystudentenrolledinadegreecourse,totheintroductionofasmalladditionalcontribution,orinsomecases,fee-payingcourses.
Alanguagepolicyalsorequiresaclearorganizationalandspatialcom-mitmentonthepartoftheinstitution,insettingupspecificstructures(languagecentres)andsettingasidededicatedareasforlanguageteach-ingandlearningactivities.Theseareallessentialfactorsinenhancingbothteacherandstudentmotivation.
InHigherEducation,thecontext-specific,localfeaturesofeachuniver-sitytendtodeterminehowlanguagepoliciesaredevisedandimplemen-ted,ratherthananynationalorregionalstrategy.TheMOLANcasestudieshaverevealedawealthofequallyinterestingapproachesgearedtowardsmotivatingstudentstolearnlanguages.Tovaryingdegrees,alloftheminvolveincreasingthenumberandvarietyoflanguagesonoffer,offeringagreatervarietyoflearningformats,implementingnewclassroomandautonomouslearningenvironments,usingstandardcompetencerefe-renceframeworkstodefineentranceandexitlevels,andimplementingaccreditationsystems.Casestudyn°7below:“Languagesforall:theUniversityofWarsawSystemofLanguageProvision”providesamoredetailedoutlineofonesuchapproach.
44 45
2.1. Multilingual primary educationin Brussels
Theproject,STIMOB(StimulatingMultilingualEducationinBrussels),startedinthreeDutch-speakingschoolsinBrusselsintheacademicyear2001/2002.TheinitiativeisbasedonCLILmethod;thechosenlanguageofinstructionisFrench.Theprogrammewaslaunchedineachschoolinoneformatatime.About20%ofthecurriculumisdevotedtoFrench.Inthefirsttwoclassesarepetitiveapproachischosen;partlyduetothelocallanguagelaws.Ontheotherhanditguaranteesthatthemessagecomesacrosseffortlessly.Itgraduallychangesfromthethirdformon.Thesubjectsinvolvedintheinitiativearearithmetic,environ-mentalstudiesandarts.(IldikóSzabó)
Amongthestrategicgoalsoftheinitiativeanewteachingapproachandcreatingapleasantlearningatmosphereareacrucialones.Changingthecurrentteachingmethodswasthechallengeteachershadtomeet.Thefactthatlanguageteachingwasbuiltonimplicitmethodsandlessattentionwaspaidtogrammarisanimportantaspect.Nevertheless,passiveskillsarenottobeneglectedorabandoned.Communicativeap-proachisakeyelementintheteachingpracticeoftheinitiative.Basedontheanalysisoftheresults,knowledgeofthetargetlanguageisbetterthancomparedwiththeresultsoftraditionalteachingmethods.Besi-des,teachers’entusiasmanddevotionareessentialtomaketheprojectsuccessful.
TheSTIMOBinitiativeistodiminishalanguagegapbetweenthelan-guageofthehomeandthatoftheschoolbycreatinganenvironmentwhereimmersionrules.InDutch-speakingschoolsinBrusselsteacherstendtodisregardthehomelanguagesofthepupils,namelyFrench.Needlesstosaythatthisattitudedoesnotcreateafeelingofwellbeing.ThelanguageinvolvedintheprojectwasFrenchbecauseofhistoricalandpoliticalreasons,however,manydiscussionsaboutthedesirabilityofotherlanguageswereheld.Althoughthenumberoflanguagesinvol-vedinCLILapproachhasnotchanged,afterfiveyearsofSTIMOBandrealisingthepotentialoftheapproach,theschooldecidedenthusiasti-callytoaddanumberoflessonsofEnglishtotheDutch-Frenchcurri-culum.InJanuary2008theFlemishMinistryofEducationitselftookthe
46 47
initiativetocarryoutaCLILexperimentinninesecondaryschoolsnotlocatedintheBrusselsareaorinitsperiphery.AlthoughthisexperimentisnotpartofSTIMOBinitiative,itspositiveresultscouldhaveinfluencededucationalpolicymakers.
Theinitiativehasbenefittedallthestudentshavingdifferentsociolin-guisticbackground:Dutchstudents’multilingualismisstrengthened,Frenchstudentsreceivesuppoertintheirmothertonguewherebytheirsubjectmatterlearningisboostedandspeakersofotherlanguagesreceiveinstructionintwoofficiallanguageswhichwillhelpintheirfu-turecareer.ThiswaytheEuropeanlanguagepolicyrecommending2+1languagesisfollowed.
Creatingpositiveattitudesandenhancingmotivationwereamongthegoalsoftheinitiative.Itiswellknownthatpositiveattitudestowardsthelanguageenhancemotivation.Itwasfeltthatlearningthroughalanguageenhancesbothattitudesandmotivation.
Thouroughandcontinuousanalysisofthesituation,feedbackonthecompletedtasksareimportant.Ananalysisfromwithinhasthemeritsofbeingrecognizedbytheprotagonists,inthiscasetheteachers.
Learninginanotherlanguagehasapositiveeffectonthecognitivedevelopmentofyounglearners.Interestinglyenough,knowledgeofmothertonguedidnotdecline,quitethecontrary.Subjectmatterknow-ledgeremainsthesameorevenimproves.Accordingtoresultsofco-gnitivetests,pupilsshowedbetterresultsinadministeringcalibratedmathstestsevenifarithmeticwasnotthesubjectmattertaughtinthesecondlanguage.Whenitcomestothebrain,itwasshownthatmul-tilingualbrainsaredifferentfrommonolingualbrains;bilingualschoolbrainsevolveinthesamewayasbilingualbrains.Althoughthenumberofthestudentsinvolvedhasnotincreased,thelevelsofachivementoftheinvolvedoneshave.
Stronginstitutionalsupportisessentialforasuccessfullanguageinitiative.Schoolautoritiesarethekeyfactorswhenitcomestochange.Colla-borationbetweenschoolsanduniversities,researchcentres,practitio-nersandschoolcounsellingboardsisveryimportant.Thisprojectde-monstratesthatuniversitiescanreachschoolsandspreadEurpoeanlanguagepolicies.Althoughcooperationbetweenuniversitiesandschoolsisnoteasy,universtitesshouldcommunicateasmuchastheycanandthereforetheinterface,whereallthepartnerscaninteractanddecisionmakingrelatedtotheprojectcantakeplace,isaninterestingtool.Resultsofthefollowupshouldberegularlydistributedamongteachers.
Whenitcomestolearning,continuityisoneofthemostimportantthings.Althoughitseemstobecommonsense,teachersandparentstendtoforgetaboutit.Emphasizingcontinuitybyteachersandschoolauthoritiesisthewayforward.Thisprojecthastakenthisintoaccountanditisoneofitssuccessfactors.
TheSTIMOBprojecthasprovedthatearlylanguagelearningisapo-werfullearningtool,especiallywhenusingCLILasthemethod.Sofartheresultssurpassanyotherapproachandoutclassanumberofwellmeantbutrarelysustainedinitiatives.AdditionalyCLILinitiativesdonotcostalotandcanbeeasilyimplemented.ThelanguagepedagogicalimplicationsoftheSTIMOBprojectnotonlyrefertolanguagelearningandteachingbutalsorefertoinnovativelearningpractices,changeineducationandtheEuropeanlanguagepolicy.
contact informationCountry:BelgiumNameofuniversity:TheVrijeUniversiteit(DutchlanguageUniversity)inBrusselsContactperson:PietVandeCraenEmail:[email protected]
48 49
2.2. Motivation to learn languages breaks down cultural barriers in London
Intheirquestformotivatingstudentstolearnforeignlanguages,aLondonschoolsucceededincreatingacohesiveschoolcommunityinaculturallydiverse1andsocio-economically2deprivedneighbourhood.HeadTeacherRachelMacfarlaneandherstaffintroducedfar-reachingchangestotheirsyllabusinanattempttomotivatepupilstostudythreeforeignlanguages.Theintroductionofone-termcompulsorytastersforFrench,SpanishandUrduatWalthamstowSecondarySchoolforGirlsprovokedconflictingopinionsatfirstbutinthelongrunthismovehascontributedtoachangeintheeducationalandsocialcharacteroftheschool.
Thechangesinpolicyinvolveddesigningafirstyearcurriculumwhichallowedfortheintroductionofacompulsoryone-termlanguagetasterforFrench,SpanishandUrduforallentrantsfromlocalprimaryschools.FrenchiswidelytaughtaspartofthesecondaryschoolcurriculumintheUKandSpanishisverypopularbutnotusuallytaught.Theintroduc-tionofUrdu,acommunitylanguage,wastheresultofawell-thoughtoutstrategytopromotethecreationofabondandasenseofunityamongtheculturallydiverseAsian,African,Caribbeanandwhiteoriginstudents3.Urduwasdeliberatelychosenwiththeobjectiveofdemystify-ingitsculturewithintheBritishenvironmentinwhichthestudentsstudyandlive.
ThepedagogicalplanbehindthecompulsorytastersforFrench,Spa-nishandUrduwastomotivatestudentstocontinuelearningtheselan-guagesuptoGeneralCertificateofEducation(GCSE)alevelthatmarkstheendofobligatoryschoolexamination(age15-16intheUK).ThisledeventuallytoUrdubeingoffereduptoAdvancedSubsidiary(AS)orAd-vanced2(A2)level.Astheseareadvancedexaminationsforuniversityentrancetheaimbehindthemwastomotivatestudentstopursuetheir
1 45% of the intake comes from the Asian community served by the school. For the most part the pupils are from the Muslim community and wear the hijab and trousers in the school colours, green.2 22% of students are eligible for free school meals because of the poor economic situation of their parents.
50 51
However,ofalltheabovefactorsperhapsthemostinterestingaspectoftheinitiativeisthesuccessfulintroductionofacompulsorynon-Europeanlanguagetoallentrantsforatermintheirfirstyear.Thisdecisionhasproducedtwoimportantsocialconsequences,firstly,togiveUrduparityofesteemwithEuropeanlanguageslikeFrenchandSpanish,and,secondly,toestablishacommonlinguisticandculturallinkamongstthediverseethnicgroupswithintheinstitution.ItcanbesafelysaidthatinthiscasethesuccessfulmotivationtolearnlanguageshasbrokendowntheculturalbarriersinthisLondoncom-munityschool.
contact informationCountry:UnitedKingdomNameofschool:WalthamstowSchoolforGirlsAddress:ChurchHill,Walthamstow,E179RZ,North-EastLondonWebsite:www.wsfg.waltham.sch.ukContactpersons:RachelMacfarlane(HeadTeacher),GeoffSaunders(HeadofLanguages)Email:[email protected];[email protected]:0044(0)2085099446
languagebeyondsecondaryschool.Thisplanentailedallocatingdedi-catedfinancestohumanandmaterialresourcessuchashiringlangua-geassistantsandnativelanguageteachers;organizingtripsabroadforculturalimmersion;andprovidinglanguageICTsupport.Itisimportanttonotethattheinstitutionalandcivilsocietyhaveconsistentlysupportedthisinitiative.Thesocialawareness,motivation,andencouragementofthemembersofstaffhavecontributedtocreategoodrelationsatalllevelsofthecommunitypreventingthecreationofclosedracialorreligiousgroupingsintheestablishment.Thebackingoftheschoolgovernorscommittee4hasbeenparticularlyimportantintheintroductionoftheseinnovativechangesintheschool.Itisalsoworthnotingthatatfirstthelocalschool’sadviseropposedtheideaonlingu-isticgroundsbuteventuallygavehisfullsupporttotheinitiative.
Statisticsshowthattheprogrammehassucceededinsustainingthestudents’motivationtolearnlanguages.Thenumberofstudentswishingtocontinuelearningforeignlanguagesbeyondtheageof14,increasedtoaround60%in2008.Furthermore,notonlydidtheschoolmanagetoexpandthelearningofforeignlanguagestomorethanhalfofthestudentpopulationbutalsotheresultsinthelanguageexamina-tionshavebeenconsistentlyhighstandardandwellabovethenationalaverageforgirlsintheUK.Anexternalaccoladefortheprogrammewasthemostrecentreportin2007oftheOfficeforStandardsinEducation(OFSTED)thatdescribedtheschoolas‚outstanding‘andstatedthat‚theperformanceofPakistani,whiteBritishandCaribbeanstudentsisparticularlyhigh’inallareas.Anindicationoftheschool’saccomplish-mentisthatithasbecomeverypopularwithlocalparentsandinmostyearsisheavilyoversubscribed.
WalthamstowSecondarySchoolforGirls’successcanbeputdowntoacombinationoffactors:achangeinthecurriculumtomotivatepupilstolearnthreelanguages;theintroductionofacompulsorynon-Europeanlanguage;thesupportofmembersofstaff;andtheconsistentinstitutio-nalandcivilsocietysupportforalanguage-basedinitiative.
3 four out of every five girls in the school are from ethnic minority groups4An example of civil society; the school Governors body is a group of voluntary people from the community who work with the school to influence educational policies and the decision making process.
52 53
2.3. The University of Warsaw System of Language Provision – languages for all
TheUniversityofWarsawSystemofLanguageProvision(USLP)isasystemfinancedfromtheUniversitybudgetwherebyallstudentsofthefirstcyclestudyprogrammeslearnalanguage/schoosingfromanofferingofconventional,blendedandon-linecoursesatA1–C2levelsinca50languages.Studentsareoffered240hoursoftuitionfreeofchargeandmaytakeadvantageofconsultations.Studentswithdisabi-litiesareentitledto2additionalhoursofconsultationsaweek.BylawoncompletionofthefirstcyclestudentsmustdemonstrateB2levelofproficiencyinonelanguage.Universitycertificationsystemservesthispurpose.Alternativelystudentsmayproducealanguagecertificatefromarecognisedcertificationcentre.Secondandthirdcyclestudentsmayattendfee-payingcourses.The following constitute success factorsforlanguageprovisionattheUniversityofWarsaw:languagepolicyoftheUniversityrespondingtotheneedsandthestatutoryrequirementssupportedbyadequatefundingfromtheUniversitybudget,apossibilityoffreechoicefromavariedandbroadofferingofcoursesandtypesofprovisionmatchingdifferentstudents’needs,cooperationbetweendifferentUniversityunitsinlanguageteaching,andcertificationoflanguagecompetences.
language policy and funding:
TheaimofthereformoftheUniversitysystemoflanguageprovisionundertakenin2001wastoensurethatallfirstcyclestudentshaveequalaccesstoaswideofferingoflanguagecoursesaspossibleatthesametimeattemptingtorationalisetheUniversityspendingonlanguagepro-visionandtoensuretheconditionsoftransparency,opennessandcom-parabilityofcriteriaandlearningoutcomesbyreferencetothestan-dardsofCEFR.ThecoincidenceoftheinitiativewiththeEuropeanYearofLanguagesandimplementationoftheBolognaProcesscastnewlightontheim-portanceoflanguageeducationandthesignificanceoflinguisticandinterculturalcompetencesofthestudentsandgraduatesforacademicandprofessionalmobilityandemployabilityinEurope.
54 55
TheUniversityofWarsawdeterminedtobeanactivepartofEHEAiscommittedtothepromotionofmultilingualismandinterculturalcom-petences,toenhancementofmobilityandemployabilityofitsstaff,studentsandgraduates,aswellastopromotionofEuropeanidentityanddemocraticvalues.Withoutadequatelanguageprovisionallthesecannotbereached.InternationalisationstrategyoftheUniversityin-cludeslanguagepolicyandallocationofsizeablefundingforitsimple-mentation.TheUSLPhasbecomeadurableelementoftheUniversitylandscape.Theinnovativesystemoflanguageprovisionfundingwhichdependsonthenumberofstudentstaughtwasintroducedwherebythemoneygoestothelanguagecoursesprovidersintheproportiontothenumberofstudentsattractedtothecoursesonoffer,hasstabilised.
cooperation and coordination
Toensurethebroadestchoiceoflanguagecoursesaconsortiumofproviderswasformedconsistingof:FacultiesofAppliedLinguistics,ModernLanguages,PolishStudies,OrientalStudies,andLanguageCentre,CentreforOpenandMultimediaEducation,CentreforForeignLanguageTeacherTrainingandEuropeanEducation.ToensuresmoothimplementationofthereformandcoordinationaRector’sDeputyforlanguageprovisionwasnominatedatthecentrallevel,andfacultycoor-dinatorsattherespectiveunits’level.
broad and varied offering, students’ choice
Theultimateaimistomakesurethateachfirst-cyclestudentdemons-tratesB2leveloflanguageproficiencyoncompletionofstudiesandifhe/sheisabletodemonstrateitonentrancetotheUniversitytoencou-ragehim/hertolearnanother,takingadvantageoftheofferingoffreeofcharge,creditedcourses,andtakeacertificationexamination.Thesystemoflanguageprovisioncomprises:-centralon-lineregistrationforclassesandexaminations-on-linediagnostictestingcoupledwiththeregistrationsystem-frameworkprogrammesofteachingbasedonCEFR
-conventional,blendedandon-linecoursesinca50languages(levelsA1–C2)(generalandforacademicandspecialpurposes)Thefollowinglanguagesaretaught:Albanian,Arabic,Armenian,Azeri,Basque,Belorussian,Bulgarian,Catalan,Chechen,Chinese,Coptic,Croatian,Czech,Dutch,English,Estonian,Finnish,French,Galician,Georgian,German,Greek,Hausa,Hebrew,Hindi,Hungarian,Italian,Japanese,Kazakh,Korean,Kyrgyz,Latvian,Lithuanian,Malayalam,Mongolian,Norwegian,Persian,Portuguese,Romanian,Russian,Sanskrit,Serbian,Slovak,Slovenian,Spanish,Suahili,Swedish,Tibetan,Turkish,Ukrainian,Vietnamese,andPolishasaforeignlanguageandPolishSignlanguage.Studentsarefreetochoosealanguagecourseandthelanguageoftheircertificationexamination.
certification
AnotherelementoftheSystemisconstitutedbycentrallyadministeredlanguagecertificationexaminationsbyUniversityCertificationBoardindependentofthelanguageofferingproviders.StudentswhohavepassedtheexaminationareofferedtheUniversityLanguageCertificate.TheCertificateisrecognisedintheRegulationofthePrimeMinisterof2009asadocumentcertifyinglanguagecompetencesofcivilservants.LanguagecoursesandexaminationsallocatedECTScredits,indicatedintranscriptsofrecordsandDiplomaSupplements,constituteanobligatorycomponentofthestudyprogrammes.On-lineplacementtestsareavailableforsixmostpopularlanguages.TheuseofDIALANGforplacementandself-assessment(formative)purposesisrecommended.AtthebeginningofUSLPover50%ofstudentslearnedEnglish;thenumberisslowly,butsteadilydecreasingwiththeoverallnumberoflearnersstillgrowing(presentlyca13000peryear.)Mostofthestudentsuseallthe240languagetokens,althoughtheirstu-dyprogrammesobligethemtotakepartin120or180hoursoftuition,andlearnmorethanonelanguage(inclusiveoflesswidelytaughtlan-guages);moreandmorestudentstakecertificationexamsinlesswidelyusedlanguages.
56 57
In-comingstudentstakelanguagecourses(Polishasaforeignlangua-ge,increasinglyotherse.g.Russian)seeingitasarareopportunitynotnecessarilyofferedbytheirhomeinstitution.Thefollowinghavebeenperceivedasmotivatingfactors:1.CEFRasastandardensuringcomparabilityandtransparency;2.AllocationofcreditsalsoincaseoflanguagecertificatesacquiredinexternalcertificationinstitutionswhichencouragesstudentstolearnanotherlanguageattheUniversity;3.TheProgrammeBoardoftheLanguageCentre,composedofstakeholders,electedstudentsandfaculty,ensuresconnectionwiththeUniversitymainstreamandanintegratingfactor;collaborationbetweentheCentreandstudentsandstaff;thesameroleincaseofotherprovi-dersisplayedbytheFacultyBoards;4.CertificationprovidedbyUniversityCertificationBoard,actinginawaylikeanexternalexaminerinrelationtothecourseproviders,whichenhancesthequalityofprovision;5.Co-ordinationofthesystemensuringconsistencyoftheoffering,respondingtotheneeds;linkswiththehighestauthoritiesoftheUniver-sity;6.Universityqualityassurancesystem:students’surveys(eachyeareachcourseissurveyed);staffdevelopmentandmotivationsystem;Erasmusstaffdevelopmentvisits;7.Mobilityprogrammes(academicandplacements);8.useofICT(on-lineandblendedlearningcoursesbasedonMoodle)9.USOS–UniversitySupportSystemofStudies–on-lineregistrationforcoursesandexaminations,ECTSrecords,trackingstudents’achievements;10.fairlypromptresponsivenesstotheneeds.
contact informationCountry:PolandNameofuniversity:UniversityofWarsawAddress:Warsaw,ul.KrakowskiePrzedmiescie26/28Contactperson:JolantaUrbanikowaEmail:[email protected]:+48225521402Fax:+48225521401
58 59
3. cooperation with other partners and stakeholders
Sections1and2lookedathowthemotivationtolearnotherlanguagescanbeenhancedinternallythroughmoreinnovativeteachingandlear-ningpracticesandbydiversifyingandimprovingthelanguageofferwithinschoolsanduniversitiesthroughforward-lookinglanguagepoli-cies.However,inaworldwhereconnectivityandcommunicationarethekeystosuccessfuldevelopment,schoolsanduniversitiesneveroperateinisolation:theyareincreasinglydependentonsettingupandmaintai-ningpartnershipswithotherestablishmentsandstakeholdersfromtheirownspherewithintheeducationalsystem,fromotherlevelsinthesys-tem,andfromstakeholdersoutsidethesystem.Studentmotivationinpursuingthelearningofalanguageordiscoveringnewlanguagesoftendependsonthequalityofsuchpartnershipsandventures.Thissectionwillthereforedescribethemanyavenuesexploredbyschoolsandhigh-ereducationalinstitutionsinattemptingtoenhancelearnermotivationthroughcooperation.
cooperation between higher educational institutions
Cooperationbetweendifferenthighereducationalinstitutionswithinthesamecountryorinothercountriesprovidesnewopportunitiestoex-changeideasonlanguagepolicyandplanning,teachingandlearning,currentresearchandgoodpracticemodels.Inturnthestudentsbenefitfromimprovedteachingstandards.
TheMOLANcasestudiesofferseveralconcreteexamplesofhowco-operationbetweenhighereducationalinstitutionsataregional,nationalandinternationallevelcanbenefitalltheparticipantsinvolved.
60 61
cooperation between schools
Cooperationbetweenschoolsisoneofthesuccessfactorsinmotivatinglanguagelearning.Inparticular,ithelpsspreadandenhancemotivationamongalltheactorsintheprocess(pupils/students,teachersanddepartment/schoolleaders).Inordertocooperate,schoolsneedfirstofalltoknowthemselvesandtolearnabouttheirpartners.Thefirststepisthereforetoencourageselfknowledgeandevaluationofallthepracticeslinkedtolanguagelearning(curriculum,methodologies,strategies,evaluation,numberoflanguages,teachertraining,etc).Havingclearideasabouttheaimsofalanguageteaching/learningpolicy,thesettingofnewaimsandthepreparationofprojects,makescooperationsomucheasier.Asanactionplanisbuilt,thecriteriainlookingforpartnersareestablished.
Therearetwomaintypesoffactorswhichdeterminesuccessfulcooperation:a)breakingtheisolationthatschoolsalltoooftenfindthemselvesin;andb)sharingexperiences,goodpractices,etc.Cooperationwithothershelpsschoolsovercomegeographicalisolationand/orisolationfromotheractorswithintheeducationalsystem.Byestablishingcooperationandpartnerships,theycanbemadetofeelpartofthewiderworldbeyondtheconfinesoftheplayground.Thisaspectisessentialinmotivatingalltheplayersinvolvedinlanguagelearning.Schoolauthoritiesandlanguageteacherswillfeelmoreconfi-dentintheirdecisions;andstudentsandparentswillinterpretthefactthatothers,somewhereintheworld,arestudyingthesame(ordifferent)languages,asastimulusandanincentive.
Beingintegratedinaprojectoranetwork,schoolscansharetheprob-lemsandsuccessesoftheirpracticesandbuildnewstrategiestomo-
TheInstitutodeLetraseCienciasHumanas,UniversidadedoMinhoinPortugal(CaseStudyn°8)illustrateshowcooperationataregionallevelcanbringtogetherinstitutionsfromdifferentlevelswithintheeducatio-nalsystem.StaffmembersoftheFacultyforArts&Humanitieshavecreatedanon-hierarchicalnetworkcombinedwithbilateralinstitutionalagreements.Partnersaredrawnfromvariousdifferentbackgrounds:regionalschools,nationalinstitutionsintheareaofpolitics,cultureandeconomics,localandregionalinstitutionsinvolvedinmultilingualism,andtheNationalAdministrationDirectoryforprimaryandsecondaryschools.Multilingualismandinterculturalskillsaresupportedbythisinitiative,launchedundertheumbrellaofAPPEAL,atrans-institutionalactionplantoinvestigatemultilingualpoliciesinaregionalcontext.
TheCILTCaseStudyontheUniversityofBristol’s“FrenchforAerospaceEngineeringstudents”programme(CaseStudyn°9)providesastimu-latingexampleofhowcooperationbetweendifferentuniversitiesinthesamecountry,andbetweenlanguagedepartmentsandvocational(engineeringandbuiltenvironment)departmentscanleadtothedeve-lopmentofhighlymotivatingprogrammesandmaterials.Thepurposeofthepartnershipbetweenfourdifferentuniversities,skillscouncils,pro-fessionalbodiesandemployerswastodesignanddeliveraninnovativeFrenchlanguagecourseforaerospaceengineeringstudents,incorpo-ratingastrongvocationaldimension.Giventhenatureoftheindustryinvolved,thecontextualizedlanguagecurriculumwasseenasakeyfactorinenhancingtheemployabilityofthestudents,andthereforetheirmotivationinwantingtoacquireandimprovetheirlanguageskills.
Attheinternationallevel,theEuropeanUniversityFoundation’sCampusEuropaeinitiative(Casestudyn°10)showstheimportanceofclosecooperationinensuringthesuccessofanintegratedstudentexchangenetworkacrossborders.Thisinter-universityprogrammeallowsstu-dentsfrompartnerinstitutionstospendtwoyearsoftheirstudypro-grammeininstitutionsoutsideoftheirhomecountry.TheintegrationbetweenlocalandincomingstudentsispromotedbytheassistanceofthesocalledBuddyNetwork,localstudentshelpingtheincomingstudentstoimprovelanguageskillsafterregularclassesbyorganizingleisureactivities.
62 63
Insomeprojects,suchastheintroductionofUrduinaninner-cityLon-donschool(Casestudyn°7),thesupportoftheschool’sgovernorswasinstrumentalinpromotingtheteachingofless-taughtcommunitylanguagesandembeddingtheselanguagesintheschool’ssyllabus,atfirst,againsttheopinionofthelocalschoolinspector.Theseactionshavegreatlyincreasedthenumberofstudentstakingandcontinuingthelearningofaforeignlanguage.Twowelcomeresultsofthisinitiativehavebeenthehigh-standardlanguageexamsresultswellabovethenationalaverageandtheemergenceofaunitedmultiethniccommunityintheschoolcommunity.
Projectsofaninternationalnature,suchasthee-twinningbetweenaschoolinFranceandaschoolinScotland,haveshowntheinvolvementofcivicassociationsfromtwodifferentcountriesinsupportingajointlanguagelearninginitiative.ThisisaninterestingexampleofthepowergeneratedbythecooperationbetweeneducationandcivilsocietywhichhasgivenchildrenfromisolatedcommunitiesliketheOrkneyIslandsandFromonttheopportunitytogettoknowaforeignculturebyusingmotivatingnewtechnologieslikevideo-conferencing.Thissuccessstoryrelateshowstudentswhowouldhaveneverotherwisetravelledabroadcannowinteractwiththeirpartnersandtheirenvironmentasiftheythemselveswerethere.Allthestudentsparticipatingintheprojecthavecontinuedwiththeirlanguagestohigherlevels.Finally,CaseStudyn°12:“Outsidein:bringingthecommunityintoschool”,showshowexternalstakeholdersinvitedintotheclassroom,cantransformtheattitudesoflanguagelearnersatschool.Thissimpleinitiative,takenatthelocallevelofasecondaryschoolinsouthernPor-tugal,consistsininvitingpotentialemployersandemployeesworkingforcompanieswithforeigncustomers,toaddressstudents(inEnglish)andexplainwhyforeignlanguagecompetenceisimportantintheirbusi-nesscontext.Ithasresultednotonlyinincreasedinterestinlanguagelearningbuthasprovidedadditionalincentivetosucceedintheirvoca-tionalcourses.
tivateexistinglanguagelearningandthelearningofmorelanguages.Informationandcommunicationtechnologies,bytheircontactfacili-ties,allowthebuildingofvirtuallearningcommunities.Thewallsofthelanguageclassroomcanbebrokendownasstudentsandteachersofdifferentschoolsinteractandshareeverythinginrealtime.Cooperationactivitieswherestudentsarethemainactors(aswithe-twinningpro-jects)willalsoawaketheircuriosityandwishtolearn,asCaseStudyn°11(“EarlyLanguageLearninginFranceandScotland:ane-twinninginitiative”)amplydemonstrates.
cooperation with civil society
AkeymotivationalfactorunderlyingmanyofthecasestudiesdescribedundertheMOLANprojectisthesuccessofcooperationbetweenedu-cationprovidersandsocietyatlarge.AnumberofMOLANcasestudiesshowcivilsocietygroupssuchasparents’associations,schoolgovernors,communityassociations,networks,professionalorganizationsandcompaniestakinganacti-vepartinprojectsthathavebeensuccessfulinthedisseminationandmotivationoflanguagelearning.Inthesecasesthecivilsocietygroupshavebecomeserviceproviders,innovators,informedcriticsandadvo-catesofeducationalissueswhohavereached,mobilized,trainedandengagedpeople.
Playersfromoutsidetheeducationalsystemcancontributetothesuc-cessoflanguagelearningthroughtheflexibilitywithwhichtheycanre-spondtolanguageeducationissues;theclosenesstograssrootsandculturesespeciallyinthecaseofhighlydiversecommunities;thesupportforinnovativepoliciesandstructures;thebreakingdownofsocialandgeographicalboundaries;andthecreationofvoluntarynon-hierarchicalnetworks.
64 65
3.1. Regional Action Plan for the Promotion of Multilingualism
TheMinhoUniversity(UniversidadedoMinho-UM)createdanumbrellainitiativecalledAPPEAL(Acção/PlanoparaaPromoçãodoEnsinoedaAprendizagemdasLínguas)fortheNorthernregionofPortugal,deve-lopedsince2007.Thepromotionofmultilingualismthrougharegionalactionplanofpolicy-makingbyinitiativeofauniversityisinnovativeforPortugal.Itgivesnewqualitytoactorsthatinthepastoftenoperatedinahierarchical,isolatedanddiscontinuousway.APPEALaimsatcreatingsynergiesbyefficientcommunicationandsharedactivitieswithinandacrossinstitutionsthroughamulti-lateralnetworkbasedonpluriannualagreementsbetweenuniversityandschools,withannualdefinitionsofmotivatingprojectsforteachingandlearninglanguages.
The aPPeal-approach
IntheabsenceofanationalframeworkthatputsintopracticeEUmultilingualismpolicy,andgiventheBolognasystemchangeofpre-ser-viceteachertrainingcoincidentwithexceedingschoolteacherstaffandtherecentreformofsecondaryeducation(2004),thatreducestheroleofforeignlanguageswithincurriculaandnarrowstheirvariety(givingpreferencetoEnglishandSpanish;GermanandFrenchwithdwindlingnumbers),thereisaurgentneedforpromotingmultilingualismasanoverallconcept.Thereforeitwasimportanttoincludeprimaryandsecondaryschoolsintothedevelopmentofinterface-strategiesthatjoininitiativesoflanguageteachersatschoolandatuniversitywithinare-gionalcontext.APPEALfocusesthequantitativeandqualitativeimpro-vementofcommunicativeandcooperativestructures,reachingoutforMunicipalCouncils(libraries,museums,theatres)andlocalassociations.
APPEALstartedat2007byinitiativeoftheFacultyofArts&Humanities(InstitutodeLetraseCiênciasHumanas–ILCH)andinvolvedprogressivelyotherunitsofUM,aboveall:departmentsoftheFacultyofPedagogy(InstitutodaEducação–IE)dedicatedtoteachertraining;thePublicRe-lationsBureauthatdevelopedalogisticframeforparticipationinschool
66 67
eventsandforschoolsvisitingUM(alsotheannual«SummeratUniver-sity»);theBureauforInternationalRelations,promotingmultilingualismbytestimonyofErasmus-studentsandthroughtheprogramofEras-mus-student-tutorship.Initiativesonlysucceedwhensupportedbypersonalitiesandstructuresofdecision-making.ThereforeAPPEALfocuseseffectivecommunicationbetweenandwithininstitutionsinordertodevelopandrealizetransver-salactivitiesthatelicitandsustainmotivationforlanguagelearning,lin-kingittoauthenticcontexts(useindifferentareasofknowledge:CLIL)andyouthleisureculture(music,sports,media).Forexample,visitsofschoolgroupstothecampuson‘Opendays’witharangeofshortwork-shop-activitiesdedicatedtodifferentlanguages(andcultures),thatcanbelearnedattheUM(includingRussian,Chinese,JapaneseandArab),havebeenhighlymotivating,aswellasparticipationofschoolsinKa-raokeshowsinEnglish,FrenchandGerman(involvingartsandmusicteachers)orinstory-tellingeventsusinginputfromdifferentlanguagesandenhancingspeakingbeforesmallaudienceineverydaycontexts(e.g.onthebus).Onthelevelofteaching,therehavebeenworkshop-in-itiativesofin-serviceteachertrainingthatfocusspeakingcompetencesandtheuseofnewtechnologies.Insteadofremainingonarandombasisofcontactsbetweenlanguageteachersatschoolanduniversity,APPEALaimsatestablishingongoingandstablecooperationbetweenuniversityunits(ILCH/IE)andthoseschoolsthatdevelopmultilingualpolicies(projectsthatinvolvelanguageareacoordinatorsandotherareas,e.g.throughparticipationinComeni-usprojects).
Forthispurposethereareusedtwomaininstruments:1)pluriannualbilateralinstitutionalagreementsbetweenuniversityandaschoolor‘school-cluster’[agrupamento],partlyrenewingtraditionalrelationsthathaveexistedinaveryformalizedwayovertheyearswithinthepre-Bolognamodelofteachertraining.2)awebpagewithpartlyopen/reservedaccess(partners),hostedattheUM-website(www.uminho.pt),creatinganin-groupeffectofcommunicativeandcooperativestructures,alsousefulforlaunchingnewideasandprojects.
TheactualconfigurationofanAPPEAL-networksharedby19schools(in2008-09)includesinteractionwithinstitutionsand(teacher)associa-tionsonanationallevel,aswellasonaregionalandlocallevelthroughtheirpartners.
learning outcomes
APPEALpromotesanintegrativeconceptofmultilingualisminsteadofa‘competition’betweenmoreorlessprestigious(oreasilylearned)languages.Bybringingtogetherteachersfordifferentlanguagesandpartnersfromdifferentsectorsofeducation,itispossibletostriveforavarietyoflanguagelearningandalsoforacoherentandefficientcontinuouslearningprocessintheprimaryandsecondaryschoolthroughtohighereducation;thisincludestheuseofappealingteachingmethods(speaking,newtechnologies),thepromotionof(self-)evalua-tionand(self-)assessmentbyparametersdefinedwithintheCommonEuropeanFrameworkofReferenceforLanguages(CEFRL),thusaimingatareallyprogressivetransitionfromoneeducationalsectortoanother.Focusingtheinterfacebetweensecondaryandhighereducation,theoverallaimistogetbetter-qualifiedandmotivatedcandidates,indepen-dentfromtheirspecificchoiceofacademicstudies:itisexpectedtoreachatleastB2(English)andB1(1-2otherlanguages)competencesbeforeenteringuniversity;anenhancedlearnerautonomyandknow-ledgeaboutthedocumentsortemplates(Europass)abletoassessandcertifycompetenceswithintheCEFRL.
Recent initiatives
Amongrecentnewinitiativesarethefollowing.(i)CollaborationwithTecMinho(collaborationbetweentheUniversity,andlocalindustryandbusinessassociations)intheareaofin-servicetrainingforlanguageteachers,withspecialemphasisontechnologicalapplicationsinlanguageteachingandlearning;
68 69
(ii)creationofajointworkinggrouptolookintothepossibilityofreinte-gratinglanguagelearningintoselectundergraduatestudyprogrammes(forexample,InternationalRelations;CommunicationScience/Jour-nalism),focussingonRomancelanguages(usingtheInter-comprehen-sionapproach).Anotherworkinggroup,whichincludesrepresentativesofthreeschools,istryingtofindwaysofstoppingthedeclineofFrenchinsecondaryschools;(iii)creationofjointworkinggroupsonPortugueseasaforeignlangua-gewithaviewtointegratingchildrenwithamigrantbackgroundintoschools,andonthequestionofAcademicStandardLanguageacquisi-tion;(iv)establishmentofalinkbetweentheAPPEALnetworkandanetworkof«pilotschools»setupbytheGoetheInstitutePortugalatnationallevelwithaviewtostimulatingmotivationforthelearningofGerman.
lessons to be learned
SincethelaunchoftheAPPEAL-initiative-decision-makersatuniversityandschoolsoftheregionbecomeincreasinglyawareofmultilingualismastransversalkeycompetence(motivationtogobeyondEnglish;continuouslearningprocess)andofthenecessitytoacquirespecificskillsrelatedtoacademiclifeandemployabilitywithinalife-long-learningperspective;-schoolsparticipateincreasinglyinactivitiespromotedbyuniversityandviceversa;-moreschoolsarewillingtojointheAPPEAL-network(10schoolsin2010);-localandregionalmediagivemoreimportancetotheinitiativespro-motedwithinthenetwork,enhancingtherelevanceofmultilingualismforsocietyandeducation.APPEALfocusesontheimprovementofinter-andintra-institutionalcommunicationandonthedisseminationofactivitiesthatarenormallyconfinedtoabilateralorlocallyisolatedscope.Thenetworkdynamicsdependonthecontinuousandefficientworkdonebylogisticandopi-nionleadersatuniversityandatschools.Thereforeperiodicalmeetingsareofutmostimportanceinordertoassurecohesion,fosterin-groupeffectsandconvinceothers.
Therehastobearealisticunderstandingofwhatispossibleandsustainableintermsofinteractionandactivities.Onlylong-termplan-ningaswellasacertainroutineofactivitiesandperiodicityofeventsleadstothefullsocialrecognitionofAPPEAL.Thisisoneofthemostimportantsuccessfactorsofthisumbrella-initiative,becauseitgivesprestigetothepartnersinvolvedandenhancestherelevanceofmulti-lingualismwithinaconcreteregionalcontext.
contact informationCountry:PortugalNameofuniversity:UniversidadedoMinho/InstitutodeLetraseCiênciasHumanas(ILCH)Address:CampusdeGualtar,4710–057BragaContactpersons:Prof.OrlandoGrossegesse,MarieManuelleCostaSilvaEmail:[email protected];[email protected]:00351-253-604190
70 71
3.2. French for Students of Aerospace Engineering
FourBritishUniversities,Bristol,Loughborough,KingstonandSalford,eachdesignedandpilotedlanguagemoduleslinkedtoEngineeringandBuiltEnvironmentDegrees.WithineachUniversity,alanguageexpertworkscloselywithavocationalexperttodesignthemodulesinconsultationwithemployersandprofessionalbodies.Aspartofthisproject,BristolUniversitydevelopeda20hourcourseinFrenchtobetaughtover10weekswithinthecontextoftheaerospaceindustry.Theprojectinvolvedsuccessfulcollaborationwithanimportantlocalemplo-yer,AirbusUKandtheappropriateprofessionalbody,theEngineeringCounciloftheUnitedKingdom.
TheLanguageGatewaysintotheProfessionsprojectisaninnovativepartnershipprojectcoordinatedbyCILT,theNationalCentreforLang-uagesandwasfundedbyDIUS,theDepartmentofInnovation,Univer-sitiesandSkills.Partnersintheprojectincludethemodernlanguagesdepartmentsandvocational(engineeringorbuiltenvironment)depart-mentswithintheUniversitiesofBristol,Kingston,LoughboroughandSalford,workingincollaborationwithsectorskillscouncils,professionalbodiesandemployerstodesignanddelivercontextualisedlanguagecoursestostudentsonengineeringandbuiltenvironmentdegrees.
Aspartofthisproject,academicsatBristolUniversity,workingwithalo-calemployer,AirbusUKaswellastheEngineeringCounciloftheUnitedKingdom(ECUK),developeda20hourcourseinFrench,tobetaughtover10weeks,forundergraduatestudentsofaerospaceandavionicsengineeringwithanentrylevelofFrenchAlevelorequivalent.Theuniversitydevelopedacontextualisedlanguagecurriculumincludingthehistoryofavionics,specialistterminology,interviewswithindustryprofessionals,businessFrench,vocabularyandgrammarexercises,plusinformationandlinkstocareersinaerospaceandavionics.Fiveon-linepackageshavebeendevelopedusingCourseGenieauthorwareanddeliveredontheUniversity’svirtuallearningenvironment(VLE)Blackboard.Withintheinstitutiontheprojectrequiredcollaborationbetweenthelanguageandengineeringdepartmentsaswellastheca-reersadviceservice,whosetaskistoimprovegraduateemployability,whichincludespromotinglanguageandinterculturalskills.
72 73
Elevenstudentsenrolledinthefirstyearanddisplayedanenthusiasticresponsetothecourse,whichtheyallcompleted.Therewaspositivefeedback,notonlyfromthestudents,butalsofromtheemployerandthefaculty.TheUniversityconsideredtheprojecttobeasuccessanddemonstrateditsrecognitionbytheissueofapressrelease,whiletheVice-Chancellorhaspersonallycomplementedthelanguageandengineeringdepartmentonthecourseandissupportiveoffuturedevelopments.
Theprojectorganisersconsiderthatthesuccessfuloutcomeoftheprojectisbasedonthestronginstitutionalsupportforsuchalanguageinitiative,theinternationalenvironmentwithintheinstitution,goodin-terdepartmentalcollaborationandtheexcellentrelationshipdevelopedwithAirbusUK.Bylinkinglanguagelearningtostudents’employabilityaswellasintegratingthiswithstudent’smainstreamacademicsubject,thestudentswerehighlymotivatedtolearnalanguagewithinacon-textthattheyhadalreadymastered.FormativeevaluationandsupportprovidedbyCILThasbeendevelopedanddeliveredinordertosupporttheteamsandenablethesharingofbestpracticeatkeystagesintheproject,whilefundingfromDIUScreatedaspaceandopportunitytodevelopmaterials,enhancethecurriculumandteachthecourse.Thedecisiontoexpandandenhanceanalreadyaccreditedcoursewiththeproductionofadditional,contextualisedmaterialsprovidedasolidfoun-dationfortheproject.
Inconsideringhowtoencouragestudentstopursuefurtherlanguagestudyinasituationwherethereisfreechoice,thequestionofimprovingemployabilityisacknowledgedascrucialintoday‘senvironment.Thiswasrecognisedinthestatedaimsofthecourse,whichspeakofinfor-mingthenextgenerationofaerospaceengineersabouttheimportanceofdevelopinglanguageandinterculturalskillsfortheirfuturecareersandtomaketheacquisitionoftheseskillsrelevanttotheaerospaceindustry.
Thiswouldbeachievedbybuildingonlanguagecompetencesacquiredatsecondaryschoolthroughthecreationofanintegratedapproachtolanguagelearning,therebyenablingstudentstogainaccesstospecia-listmaterialinthetargetlanguage.Thestudentspracticedmakingpresentationsandwritingarticles,anddevelopedworkplacerelatedcommunicativeskills.Awarenessofinterculturallearningandskillsandtheirimportanceforprofessionaldevelopmentisaimedtopromotegraduates’employabilityandprofessionalmobility,whilemotivatingstudentstoundertakefurtherlanguagelearning.
Awiderangeofmaterialsweredevelopedincollaborationwiththeemployer,AirbusUK,andarecurrentlyavailableontheuniversity‘sVLE.ThesematerialsareintheprocessofbeingformattedinordertobemadeavailableviaCILT’sVirtualLanguageResourceBankforgeneralusebyotherinstitutions.Theproductionoftailor-madematerialswasseenascrucialtothesuccessofacoursewhichbuildsuponexistinglanguagecompetenceandmovesittoahigherlevel.
Aftercompletingthecourse,oneofthestudentssaid:‘TheLanguageGatewayisanengagingwayoflearningandputtingintocontextFrenchforaerospaceengineering.Itcatersforreading,listeningandwritinginanenjoyablemanner.IfounditeasiertolearntechnicalvocabularyusingtheGatewayasitisinteractive.Iparticularlylikethesectionthatprovidesyouwithlinkstofurtherinformationonthetopicstheexercisesdealtwith.’
contact informationCountry:UnitedKingdomNameoforganisation:CILT,theNationalCentreforLanguagesAddress:3rdFloor,111WestminsterBridgeRoad,LondonSE17HRContactperson:SteveCushion,HigherEducationAdviserEmail:[email protected]:00442076333300
74 75
3.3. Language learning as a step toward European Citizenship – Enhances student exchange
InCampusEuropae(CE)studentsfromavarietyofacademicdisciplinesareencouragedtospendtwoyearsintwouniversities,eachlocatedinadifferentEuropeanlinguisticcommunity(anexceptionisgrantedforLuxembourgishstudents).Whilstpursuingtheirregularcourseofstudystudentsarelearningthelanguageoftheirhostuniversity.Thelearningprocessissupportedbyaselectedsetofsupportingtools.Priortodeparturestudentsareparticipatinginanintroductorye-learninglanguagecourse,followedbyintensivefourweekslanguageprogramsuponarrivalatthehostinstitution.Accompanying,year-longlanguagecoursessupplementthelearningprocess.Individualmentorsandtheopportunitytopursueandinternshipatalocalcompanyorotherinstitu-tionfurtherfacilitateintegrationintothesocial,culturalandacademicenvironment.Anemphasisisputontheacquisitionofthelesser-taughtlanguagesofEuropealearningprocesswhichallowsforaslowbutsteadyimmersionintothelocallinguisticculture.
TheEuropeanUniversityFoundation–CampusEuropae(EUF-CE)isanetworkofnow20Europeanuniversities,whichengageinenhancedstudentexchange.Fieldsofcooperationwithinthenetworkarelangua-gelearningandcoordinationofacademicrecognition.StudentsspendaminimumofoneyearatanotherEuropeanUniversityandcanoptforaseconduniversitywithinthenetwork.Bothuniversitiesmusthaveadifferentlinguisticbackground.
Theimmediateaimsareforthestudentmoverstoachievesufficientproficiencyinthehostlanguageinordertobeabletoattendclassesatthehostuniversity.Inthemid-termtheyareexpectedtoacquireinter-culturalcompetencesandgetacquaintedtothecultureandsocietyofthehostcountry.Thelong-termgoalisforthemtobecomeemployableontheEuropeanlabormarketbybeingabletomasteratleasttwo–inanoptimalcase–otherlanguagesthantheirmothertonguewithsustai-nedexperienceofmobilityandagoodunderstandingofinterculturalinteraction.
76 77
language learning
Althoughsomememberuniversitiesarelocatedincountriesofferingmorewidelyspokenlanguages,thenetworkfocusesonlessertaught–thoughnotnecessarilyspoken–languages.TherangeoflanguagestaughtwithinthenetworkincludesFinnish,French,German,Italian,Latvian,Lithuanian,Portuguese,Polish,Russian,Serbian,SpanishandTurkish.
Languagelearningtakesplaceinthreestages.BeforedepartureCam-pusEuropaeofferse-languagecoursesforallstudents,whichwerede-velopedwiththememberuniversitiesaspartoftheEU-financedHookUp!project.ThesecoursescontainactiveandinteractiveelementsandareaimedatbringingthestudentatleasttoanA1leveloftheCom-monEuropeanFrameworkofReferenceforLanguages(CEFRL).Stu-dentsarestronglyencouragedtoparticipateinthee-learningmodulesassomeuniversities,asaresultofthisoffer,donotofferA1beginnercourseanymore.Inthefuturethee-learningmodulescanbedevelopedtosupplementtheface-tofacecourses.
Uponarrivalatthehostuniversitystudentsareofferedintensivelangua-gecoursesforaminimumoffourweeks(onexceptionwithinthenet-work,whichonlyacceptsstudentswithalevelofB1uponarrival)andatleast5hourslanguagecoursesperday.Thepurposeofthesecoursesistoimprovethelanguageproficiencyandsupporttheprocessofimmer-sionintothenewlanguageandenvironment.Attheendofthecoursestheparticipantsshouldbeabletolistentolecturesinthelanguageofthehostuniversity.PartnerUniversitiesareabletoapplytotheEUF–CECampusEuropaeforfinancialsupporttoorganizeintensivelanguagecourses;anumberofuniversitieshaveavailedofthisofferwhichcanbeanimportantin-centivetofurtherimprovethequalityofthosecourses.
Throughouttheacademicyearstudentsvisitlanguagecourseswithalesserintensitytofurtherimprovetheirlanguageskills.AttheendoftheirstaytheyshouldhaveachievedalanguageproficiencylevelofB1undertheCEFRL.
Institutional support
UniversitiesareencouragedtooffercoursesinEnglish,atleastforthefirstsemester,howevernotallinstitutionshavethecapacity,andsome-timesstudentsarenotabletofollowcourseinEnglishduetoalackofproficiencyinthelanguage.Inanycaseprofessorsareaskedtoholdexaminationsinotherlanguagesthanthatofthehostuniversityandemploydifferentexaminationmodes.
EspeciallyinthebeginningCEmoversaresidedwithaCE-buddy,alocalstudentwhoassistsinheintegrationatthehomeuniversityandisreadytoanswerpracticalquestionsandhelpwithadministrativeproce-dures.
AnotherperspectivecanbeopenedbyLearningEmployabilityPlaces(LEPs),whichareorganizedincooperationwithlocalentrepreneursandotherinstitutions.Suchinternships,whichhaveaworkvolumeofabout10hoursperweekandrunthroughouttheyear,cangivestudentsaglimpseofaprofessionalenvironmentinthehostcountry.However,LEPscannotbeofferedtoallstudentsasallocationheavilydependsonthequalificationoftherespectivestudentandavailabilityofLEPsattheuniversitycity.
academic cooperation
InordertopaytributetothechangingstructureofacademicprogramsCEpaysincreasedattentiontotheissueofacademicrecognition.Duetofinancialconstraintsstudentsonlyagreetobemobileiftherecog-nitionoftheiracademicachievementscanbeguaranteed.Therefore,teachersfromalluniversitiesregularlymeetinseveralSubjectCommit-teesfortherespectiveacademicfields(Business&Economics,Engi-neering,Humanities,Law,Medicine,NaturalSciences,TeacherTraining)todevelopasystemofex-anterecognition,whichshouldfacilitatethedraftingoflearningagreementsandsafeguardthattheyarerespected.TheSubjectCommitteesinteraliadiscusslanguageissuesagainstthebackgroundoftheiracademicfields.SomeuniversitiesgranttherecognitionofthelanguagecoursescompletedduringCEexchange.
78 79
certification
StudentswhofulfilltheacademicrequirementsoftheirCEyearandinadditioncomplywithcertainlanguagerequirementsarerewardedwithaCE-certificateafteronCEyear.ThiscertificateconfirmsthatthestudenthasfulfilledthecriteriaincollectingaminimumnumberofECTScreditsinhisorheracademicfield,whichwillbedulyrecognizedbythehomeuniversityandthatheorshehasfulfilledthelanguagerequirementsinmeetingtheB1levelofthelanguageofthehostuniversity.StudentswhodoafullCEcycleinthecourseoftheirundergraduateandgraduatestudies(orequivalent),thusspendingtwoyearsattwodifferentuniversities,andmeetthecriteriaforthecertificatebothtimes,areawardedaCD-Degree,whichisanacademicdegreeawardedunderLuxembourglawbytheEUF-CE,inadditiontotheirnationaldegree.Thedegreecertifiesacademicexcellence,linguisticskillsinthreelangu-agesandinterculturalcompetence.
Development of the program
From2004-2010morethan550studentshaveparticipatedintheCEexchangeprogram.DesignedasanexperimentalprogramCEhasbecomeatangibleassetintheinternationalportfolioofthememberuniversities.WhereasCEcannotescapetheuncertaintiesofstudentexchangeasregardspracticalimplementation,anumberofsuccessfactorsandproblematicissuescanbeisolatedbasedontheexperiencegathered.
Throughouttheyearsandimbalanceinmoverdistributioncanbeobserved,ageneraltrendfromeasttowestisonlycounteredbystrongbilateralrelationsbetweencertainuniversities,e.gUniversityofAveiro(Portugal)andUniversityofNoviSad(Serbia).ThetraditionalErasmusdestinationsuchasItaly,GermanyandSpainstillhostthemajorityofCEmovers.Nevertheless,othercountriesdohaveafairshareofinco-mingmovers.GoodexamplesareLatvia,SerbiaandPoland.CEmoverscoverthefullrangeofacademicdisciplines,mirroringtheSubjectCom-mittees.ThemajoritysofarcomesformBusiness&economics,trailedbyTeacherTraining.Especiallytheformerischaracterizedbyawide
offerofEnglishliteratureeasilyavailableandEnglishasanaturalwor-kinglanguage.Incontrast,Lawasasubjectrelyingonadvancedlingu-isticskillsonlyattractsasmallnumberofstudentstoatypicalexchangedestinations.ThosestudentswhofollowthelanguagelearningpathwaysusuallysucceedinattainingaB1level(orhigher)oftherespectivelanguageandconfirmabetterunderstandingoftheirhostcountry.Acertaindegreeoflanguageproficiencygoeshandinhandwithacademicsuccess.Thelanguagelearningprocesscanbesupplementedbyanumberofpractices,e.g.strategicplacementofforeignstudentswithlocalstu-dentsinstudentdormitoriesinordertoincreasetheexposuretotheforeignlanguageandavoidincreasedexposuretoEnglish.Astablestartinglevelofthelocallanguagefurtherseemstomotivatestudentstoapplytheirknowledgeanddecreasesinitialhesitationandfear.Asuccessfulexperienceinthefirstyearstimulatesstudentstogoforanotheryear–toadifferentuniversityinadifferentcountry;subjecti-vegoodpracticesserveasmotivation.
CampusEuropaehashadconsiderablesuccessinencouragingstu-dentstomovetocountrieswhoselanguagesarelessfrequentlytaughtandinenablingtheacquisitionofworkinglevelsofbothgeneralandprofessionallyrelatedlinguisticcompetenceinthetargetlanguages.TheexperienceofstudyingintwohostenvironmentsaswellaswithingroupsofstudentsfromdifferentnationalitiesallowsthoseconcernedtoacquireanunderstandingofthediversityofEuropeanculturesandbe-comebetterequippedforacareerinamulticultural,multilingualEurope.
contact informationCountry:LuxemburgNameoforganizationCampusEuropaeWebsite:www.campuseuropae.orgContactperson:BerndJustinJütteEmail:[email protected]
80 81
3.4. Language learning at primary school through e-twinning initiative
Twoprimaryschoolslocatedinisolated,ruralsurroundings,oneinFrance,theotherinScotland,establishedane-twinninglinkthroughvideoconferencing,soastointroduceFrenchlessonstotheScottishpupilsandEnglishlanguagelearningtotheFrenchstudents.Theseearlylanguageclassesweretaughttopupilsof9-11yearsold.TheScottishandFrenchchildrenseenonthescreenintheclassroomswereauthenticandtheteacherswereveryenthusiasticabouttheresultstheinitiativeachieved:thestudentsweremotivatedtointroducethemsel-ves,toplaygamesandtocommunicateeffectively.
ThelearningofEnglishandFrenchisbasedontheuseoflivevideoconferencingactingasastimulustomotivatethelearnersandthroughtheuseoflanguagebynativespeakersasamodelforthelearners.
Inbothcasestheforeignlanguageisorganizedandtaughtbytheheadteachertoallpupilsinthefinaltwoyearsofprimaryschool.IntheFrenchschoolonlyEnglishistaughtintwosessionsperweek.TheScottishschoolteachesFrenchandalsoGermantothesameyeargroups.Languageteachinginbothgroupsisassociatedwiththelear-ningofothersubjects.
Thelinkbetweentheschoolswasestablishedthroughacontactsemi-narheldbytheBritishCouncilinParisandbothschoolsbenefitfromtheassistanceofe-twinninginitiativeinBrussels.Thelinkismaintainedthroughtheuseofvideoconferencing(equippedwithMarratechfaci-lities)andbothschoolsareequippedtoreceiveandsendclassroomscenestotheothertoenablethepupilstocarryoutliveconversationswiththeirpartners.InthecaseoftheFrenchchildren(totalof26),languagelessonstakeplaceintheregularclass,andintheScottishschoolthepupils(totalof18)areeitherdrawnfromtheirregularclassesandfollowlessonsatlunchtimewhenvideoconferencingistakingplace,oratothertimesincooperationwiththeclassteacher.
82 83
-Thepositiveexperienceoflearningalanguageinfluencestheirdesiretocontinuestudyinglanguagesinthesecondaryschoolandtotakeuplearninganewlanguage.-Thefirstcohortofpupilshasreachedsecondaryschoolandhasbeencomplimentedontheiruseofthelanguageandtheirenthusiasmforlearning.-Thereisaclearspin-offontothelearningofothersubjectsandthepupils’wholeattitudetoschoollife,whichismorepositiveasaresultofthisexperience.-Thelinkwasrunner-upintheNationale-twinningawardsin2008inScotlandandachievedtheintermediateinternationalawardin2007.
contact informationCountry:FranceNameofschool:ÉcolepubliquemixtedeFromontAddress:3placedel‘Eglise,77760Fromont.FranceContactperson:MarieRössler,DirectriceEmail:[email protected]:ScotlandNameofschool:StAndrew´sPrimarySchoolAddress:Toab,Orkney,Scotland.KW17ZQUContactperson:AnnGilmour,FormerHeadTeacherEmail:[email protected]:00441856861256
Apartfromintroductionsintheotherlanguage,gamesandbasicphra-ses,thepupilsalsoexchangenewsitems,weatherforecasts,anddra-wings.Theysingsongstoeachotherandtheyhavecarriedoutastudyonthearchitectureofbothvillages.Thismeansthatabasicstockoflanguageismemorizedthroughtheseactivities.
TheScottishHeadteacheremphasisedthat“theimportanceofteachingFrenchintheprimaryschoolistodevelopenthusiasmandaninterestinthelivesofchildreninFrance”.TheHeadoftheFrenchschoolsummeduphergroup’sobjectivesinsimilarterms.
Acombinationoffactorsseemstopointtothesuccessoftheinitiative:-theuseoftechnologyisattractivetochildrenofthisageandtheyenjoyshowingtheirskillswhenhandlingthevideoconferencing.-Theyalsolovethecompetitivenessofthevideoconferencinggames.-Thelinkwiththeschoolintheothercountryisthekeytothechildren’sobviousenjoyment.-TheScottishandFrenchchildrentheyseeonthescreenintheirclassroomsarerealandspeakwithauthenticaccentsofOrcadianandFrenchchildren.-Bondshavebeencreatedbetweenthechildrenandthismotivatesthemtolearntocommunicate.-Thecommunitiesinwhichtheyliveshareacertainsenseofisolationandthisexperienceopensawindowontheoutsideworld.Successindicatorsarealsoseveral:-TheenthusiasmofthepupilsfortheirEnglishclassisthemostnotableone;theyarekeentoparticipateandinteractandthereisnolackofvolunteerstoanswerandaskquestionsinbothschools.-IntheScottishschoolthechildrenaresoenthusiastictheytaketheinitiativetocompilephotostoriesingroupsorontheirown,-Inbothschoolstheyarewillingtogiveuppartoftheirlunchbreaktovideoconferencewiththeotherschool.-Thepupilsspeakinwholesentenceswhenrequiredanddosowithareasonablyauthenticaccent.AlllessonstakepartinEnglishinFranceandinFrenchintheOrkneysandatthisstagepupilsarenotexposedtowrittenEnglishorFrench,justspoken.
84 85
3.5. Outside in: bringing the communityinto school – motivation for languages
EscolaSecundáriadeTomásCabreiraisacentenarysecondaryschoolwithalargeexperienceinvocationalandprofessionalcourses.ForthatreasonFilomenaConceição,aslanguageteacherandasCoordinatoroftheLanguageDepartment,preparesanoriginalandwellsucceededcasestudy.Sheorganizesdifferentvisitsofstakeholderstocomeintotheclassroomtoexplaintheneedforforeignlanguagesondifferentprofessionalactivitiesaroundschool.Thesevisitorsmadetheirpresentationsandledallthediscussionswiththestudentsinforeignlanguages.Thisisanexampleofgoodpracticetoincreasemotivationinlanguagelearning.
Evenifschooldoesnothavethelegalpossibilitytodevelopitsownpoliciesinthecurriculumstructure,thecreationandthepromotionofappropriatestrategiestoenhancestudents’competencesisitsspecificmission.Inthevocationalarea,inwhichthecoredisciplinesofthecurriculumarefromfieldsaselectricity,accountancy,tourism,renewab-leenergies,mechatronics,chemistryetc,motivatingstudentstoforeignlanguageleaningcan,inseveralcases,beahugechallenge.
Theauthorinvitessome(onceayear)externalstakeholdersoftheregiontoaddressstudents(inEnglish)andtoexplainthemtheneedofforeignlanguagesatwork,intheregion.Thestakeholdersarefrommul-tinationalornationalenterprisesthathaveascostumersalargenumberofforeigners.Theentireregionalcontextisdeeplydependentontou-rismmobilityandtourismrelatedactivities.Externalemployeeswereinvitedtoexplaintheiractivitiesandhowtheyaredependentongoodcompetencesinlanguagesandincommunication.TheyemphasizehowEnglishisimportantbutalsohowitisnotenough.Theinterculturalcom-municationconstraintswerestressed.
Thiscasestudypresentsanexampleofanefforttoincreasetheinterestinforeignlanguagelearningandtheawarenessoflanguagesrelevanceintheirfuturecareers.Withthisinitiativestudentsarealsosupposed:a)tolinklanguagestovocationalactivitiescreatinganintegratedap-proachtolanguageleaningwithintheprofessionalcontext,developing
86 87
Cabreira(bothledbytheauthorofthecasestudy).Oneoftheexternalparticipantsofthefirstyearoftheinitiativehasbecomeamemberoftheschoolcouncil.That’sasignthatthiscasestudynotonlymotiva-tesstudentstolearnlanguagesbutalsostakeholderstoparticipateinschoollife.Thesetwoevidencesjustifythetitleofthecasestudy“Out-sidein:bringingthecommunityintoschool–motivationforlanguages”.
contact informationCountry:PortugalNameofschool:EscolaSecundáriadeTomásCabreiraAddress:RuaManuelArriaga,8000FaroContactperson:FilomenaConceição,LanguagesDepartementCoordinatorEmail:[email protected]
communicativeskills,promotingmultilingualismandtheawarenessoftherealityoutsideschool;b)tobeawareofrealcommunicationsitua-tionsintheirprofessionalfieldswithspecificterminology,specificcultu-ralandprofessionalcharacteristics.Finally,thisinitiativeaimsatpromo-tingthecreationofplacesforinternshipsand/orforworkplacements,aswell.Asresultsoftheinitiative,whichoccuronceayearwhenbet-ween3and5ofthepotentialemployersvisittheschool,arealincreaseofinterestcanbeobservedandstudentsaremoremotivatedtoreadabouttheirvocationalsubjects.Theyseemtounderstandbettertheroleandthevalueofthelinguisticandcommunicativecompetencesintheirfutureprofessionaldevelopment.Studentsbecomemoreselfconfidentinforeignlanguageafterusingittoaskinformationabouttheworldofworkandtodiscusswiththestakeholders;theyenhance,thisway,also,theirperformanceinoralactivitiesinclassanditinfluencesglobalassessment,andmotivation.Inthenon-linguisticdisciplines,teachersnoticedabetterperformanceandmoreinterestofstudents.Itseemsthatwiththisinitiative,wheretheyhavebeenexposedtotheirpossiblecontextofworkinaforeignlanguage,theinterestabouttheirvocationalcourseincreases.Itisclearthatanhigherlevelofachievementinlan-guagetasksinclassandinactivitiesinsomeothersubjectsisreal.Thisopportunityofsharingknowledgeisanimportantspin-offontolearningofothersubjects/contextsandthechangingofwholestudents’attitudeisthebestsignoftheirmotivation.
Theenhancementofmotivationmentionedabovecanbejustifiedbydifferentfactorslinkedtotheinnovationoftheinitiativewhichis,insomeway,anopenofawindowtotheoutsideworldandabondwiththeworkcontext.ThestrongsupportoftheHeadofschoolandthecommitmentofalltheparticipantsastheavailabilityofthestakeholderswhicharekeenonparticipatingandinteractinginaforeignlanguagecanbeseenintheenthusiasmofparticipants.Theinformaldisseminationoftheresultsofthisinitiativehashadastrongimpactonthemotivationofotherteachingstaff.Anevidenceofthisimpactonschoollifeisthefactthat,sincethefirstyearoftheiniti-ative,theincreasinnumberofstudents(fromvocationalandnon-voca-tionalcourses)whowanttoparticipateinthenationalcontest(promotedbytheministryofeducation)“AsLínguasabremcaminhos”(Languagesopenways).Thefirstandthesecondnationalprizesofthe2008/2009editionwerewonbygroupsofstudentsofEscolaSecundáriadeTomás
88 89
4. Motivating through integration, accreditation and certification
Amajorfactorintheenhancementofstudentmotivationinexpandingtheirmultilingualandmulticulturalcompetenceathighereducationlevelistheintegrationoflanguagelearning(optionalormandatory)intothestudyprogrammesofalldisciplines.Alanguagepolicybasedonthepromotionofmultilingualism(implyingtheofferofabroadpaletteoflanguagesandallowingfreechoiceoflanguagesforstudents)andprovidingforrecognitionofthetimeandeffortinvestedbystudentsinlanguagelearning,combinedwiththedefinitionoflearningoutcomesrelatedtothespecificcommunicativeneedsofstudentsandgraduates,canmakeamajorcontributioninencouragingmorestudentstolearnmorelanguages.
TheMOLANHigherEducationcasestudiesshowthattherearemanypathwaystoachievingtheintegrationoflanguagelearninginstudyprogrammes.InsomecountrieswithnationalregulatoryframeworksforHE(asinFrance),secondorthirdlanguagelearningmaybemandatoryfortheawardingofBachelororMaster‘sDegrees.Inothers(suchasPo-land),nationalregulationsgovernthelevelofcompetenceteachersareexpectedtoenablestudentstoachieveattheendoftheirfirstcyclede-gree(seeCaseStudyn°7insection2above).Incaseswhereprogram-mesandobjectivesareentirelydeterminedatuniversitylevel,provisionrangesfromthemandatorytotheentirelyoptional,butinthelattercase,varyingdegreesofincentiveareprovidedtoencouragestudentstotakeupandpursuelanguagelearningwithintheircourseofstudies.Thespectacularincreasesinthetake-upoftheABVlanguagemodulesatFreieUniversitätBerlin(CaseStudyn°13)orofthoseofferedbytheUniversityofLausanneLanguageCentre(CaseStudyn°14)showhowaflexibleapproachtointegrationwithinthecurriculumcanbeapowerfultoolforenhancingstudentmotivation.
Acommonfeatureofsuccessfullyintegratedlanguagemodulesistherecognitionofstudentengagementthroughaccreditation.WithintheframeworkoftheEuropeanHigherEducationArea(EHEA)thismeanstheattributionofECTScredits.Thesecreditsrelatelearningactivitiestotheworkloadofstudents(1creditforaworkloadof25-30hours)and
90 91
Certificationmaybeusedsimplyasanoptional„bonus“incentiveforstudentstoachieveagivenlevelofcompetenceatvariousstagesoftheirstudyprogramme,orasamandatoryrequirementvalidatingagiventargetlevelsetinordertobeawardedadegree(e.g.theWarsawCaseStudyabove).
Howevereachoftheaboveincentivesisactuallyimplemented,theirsuccessinmotivatingstudentstotakeupmorelanguagesandtoim-provetheiroveralllanguagecompetenceisheavilydependentonalltheotherfactorsdescribedintheprevioussectionsofthishandbook:cer-tificationortestingonlymakesenseiftheyenablestudentstomeasureprogressmadeinintegratedlanguagemoduleorcoursetakenaspartoftheircurriculum,withintheframeworkofaclearlydefined,administeredandsupportedlanguagepolicy;themoduleorcoursewillonlybebene-ficialiftheyaimtoachieveclearlearningoutcomesandiftheyinvolvestimulatingteachingandlearningmethodsandmaterials;andfinallynoneofthecompetencesacquiredwillmakesenseiftheyarenotputtouseinanacademicorprofessionalcontextbyinteractingwithotherlanguageusers.Hopefully,thisiswhatallthecasestudiesinthisHand-bookamplydemonstrate.
thedefinitionoflearningoutcomesintermsofcompetencesasdefinedintheCouncilofEurope‘sCommonEuropeanFrameworkofReferenceforLanguages(CEFR).Theyarethuseasilycomprehensibleataninternationallevelandtoanon-specialistpublic.Theyalsotakeintoaccountstakeholders‘needsandarethusrelevantforacademicstudy,futurecareerandemployabilityandformobilityandsocialintegration.AlltheHigherEducationcasesincludedinthishandbook,whetherinWarsaw,Berlin,Bremen,orLausanne,featuretheawardingofECTScreditsforthesuccessfulcompletionoflanguagemodules.
Inalife-longlearningprocesswhereprofessionalcompetencesareconstantlyreassessedandcanoftenbevalidatedwithinthecontextoffurtherorcontinuingeducation,languagecertificationhasbecomeanincreasinglyimportantelementofstudentmotivation.Tobeofusetothestudent,certificationmustofcoursebefoundedonaclearandinternationallyrecognisedreferenceframeworkofcompetence.ThisisnowgenerallythecasewithintheEuropeanHigherEducationArea,withthealignmentofmanymainstreamlanguagecertificationsontheCEFR.ManyUniversityLanguageCentresnowofferstudentstheopportunitytoobtaininternationallanguagecertificatessuchasthoseadministeredbyCambridgeESOL,theGoetheInstitut,InstitutoCervantesortheCen-treinternationald‘étudespédagogiques,ortest“scores”suchasthoseprovidedbytheIELTS-andETS-administeredtests.Alongsidethecertificationsandtestsadministeredbytheseinternationalbodies,agrowingnumberofFrenchuniversitiesalsodelivertheCLES(Certificatdelanguesdel‘enseignementsupérieur),anationalcertificateofcom-petenceawardedtostudentsachievingaB2levelinasecondorthirdlanguageduringthecourseofadegreeprogramme(CaseStudyn°15?).LocallydesignedandadministeredCEFR-basedlanguagecertificatescanalsobefoundinanumberofuniversities,asforexampleatBabes-BolyaiUniversityCluj-Napoca(Romania)(CaseStudyn°15).
92 93
4.1. Improving multilingual competence of students by the allocation of ECTS
Inordertopromotemultilingualcompetence,students’mobilityandemployability,lifelonglearningandlanguagediversityinEurope,theLanguageCentreoftheFreieUniversitätBerlin(FUB)implementedin2005languagesmodulesforBachelorstudentsofotheracademicdisciplineswhocompleteageneralpreparationforprofessionallife(AB-VAllgemeineBerufsvorbereitung)withintheircurriculumframework.12languages,amongthemless-taughtlanguageslikeArabic,Chinese,Dutch,Portuguese,RussianandTurkishareconcernedbythisinitiative.StudentscanlearnalanguagestartingfromanylevelandreachvariousCEFRlevelsfromA2.1toC1.2.EachlanguagemoduleiscreditedbyanallocationofECTS.
TheBachelorstructureplansthatstudentscompleteageneralprepa-rationforprofessionallife(ABV)whoseaimistoprovidestudentswithrelevantskillsandabilitiesontheEuropeanlabourmarket.ApartoftheABVisdedicatedtolanguages,forwhichstudentsget5ECTSforeachmoduleandcanreachupto15ECTSfor3semestersofstudy.
TheLanguageCentre,asthecentralserviceinchargeofthelanguagetrainingforFUBstudents,tookthechallengetodesignanewmodularcurriculumforalltaughtlanguages.ThelearningoutcomesoftheABVlanguagesmodulesarebasedontheStudyRegulationsoftheUniver-sitywhichdescribeforeachcompetencethelearningoutcomesandtargetedlevels.Theyaimononehandtoprovidestudentswithtransfe-rablecommunicativeskillsrelevanttoemployability,mobilityandacade-miclife;andontheotherhandtopromotelearners´autonomyinordertoendowstudentswithlearningcompetence.InthecaseofSpanishlanguage,thishasledtoaninstitutionalcooperationwiththeInstitutoCervantesBerlin.
94 95
After8semestersofimplementation,successindicatorsshowthattheABVlanguagesmodulesinitiativeisturningintoasuccessstory.Thegeneralnumberofstudentstakingpartinlanguagesmodulesincrea-sesconstantly,from130studentsinthewintersemester2005/2006to755in2007/2008,suchasthenumberofstudentswhostartlearningalanguagefrombeginners´level.Furthermore,theopportunitytolearnless-taughtlanguagesatabeginners´levellikeArabic,Chinese,Dutch,Portuguese,RussianandTurkishaswellaslanguagessuchasEnglish,French,GermanasaForeignLanguage,Italian,Polish,andSpanishseemstomotivatestudentstotakeacourse.Thenumberofstudentsstartingfrombeginners´levelArabiccoursesreached95inthewintersemester2007/2008.Besidesthis,weobserveagrowingpartofstudentswholearnasecondorathirdlanguageinsideoroutsidethesamelinguisticfamily,showingthattheABVframeisausefultooltopromotelanguagediversityandmultilingualcompetence.Apartfromtheseindicatorsconcerningtheincreasednumberofstu-dentstakinglanguagescoursesinarangeof12languages,thetranspa-rencyofgainsinlanguagecompetenceendowsstudentswithobjectivecommunicativeskills,aswellasenhancingprofessionalqualificationsandinternationalmobility.TakingtheexampleoflanguagessuchasFrench,Italian,PortugueseandSpanish,studentsstartingfrombegin-ners´levelcanachievelevelA2.1
ThesuccessoftheintroductionofABVlanguagesmodulesiscertainlyduetoacombinationoffactorswhichallactinsynergy.Firstly,weshouldmentiontheallocationofECTSwhichgiveslanguagesanequalstatuswithothersubjectsandplaysabigpartinthemotivationofstudentstotakelanguagescourses.Thefactthatlanguagescoursesaretuitionfreecanalsobeseenasadeterminantfactorformotivation.ThestronginstitutionalsupportthattheLanguageCentrebenefitsfrommakesitalsopossibletouseICTandnewlearningenvironmentineverycourse.Theflexibilityofthecourseformatgivesthestudentsthechoicebetweenextensiveorintensivecoursesandadaptstostudentsneedsandavailability.Theteacher´squalifications,motivationandsenseofinnovationplayabigpartinmakingthecoursesattractiveandthelear-ningsuccessful.
Lastbutnotleast,amajoremphasisshouldbeputonthecontributionoftheIndependentLanguageLearningCentre(ILLC).ThiscentremakesuppartoftheLanguagecentreandplaysacrucialroleinsupportingthelearningofalanguageinsideandoutsideoftheclassroom.TheILLCprovidesserviceslikelanguageadvice,workshops,organisesTandemprojectsandgathersresourcesandmaterialswhichareintegratedintothelanguagecourses.AdedicatedspaceforFrenchlanguage,“Espacefrançais”hasbeenimplementedanddevelopsprojectstosustainandpromoteFrenchlearning.Thewebsite(http://www.sprachenzentrum.fuberlin.de/slz/index.html)proposesanonlinecatalogueandlinksforlearninglanguages.AllthistogethermakestheLanguageCentrealearningspacededicatedtolearninglanguagesinacitythatalsohasastrongmultilingualprofile.
Aswe´veseen,thelessonsthatcanbelearntfromthisongoingandsuccessfulinitiative,isthatfactorssuchasallocationofECTS,awideofferinginlanguages,stronginstitutionalsupport,transparentandverifiablelearningoutcomescombinedwiththeintegrationofICTandalocallinguisticenvironmenthaveadefiniteeffectonstudents´motivationtolearnlanguages.ItalsoincreaseslearningcompetenceandpromotesamultilingualprofileforthenextgenerationofEuropeancitizens.
contact informationCountry:GermanyNameofuniversity:FreieUniversitätBerlin,ZESprachenzentrumAddress:HabelschwerdterAllee45,14195BerlinWebsite:http://www.sprachenzentrum.fu-berlin.de/Contactperson:IsabelleOrtizEmail:[email protected]+493083855680
96 97
4.2. Motivating students by means of fee exemption and the award of ECTS
In2005,theLanguageCentreofLausanneUniversitychangedfromafeebasedandentirelyoptionalsystemoflanguagelearningtoanon-feeapproachcombinedwithstructuralintegrationintothestudyprogram-mes.Thishasprovedtobeamajormotivatingfactorformorestudentstoengageseriouslyincontinuingtoexpandtheirmultilingualandmul-ticulturalcompetencebycontinuingtolearnorlearningnewlanguagesduringtheirstudies.AnumberoffacultiesoftheUniversitynowofferthepossibilityintheirBachelorandMastercyclestovalidatethroughtheattributionofECTScreditsthelanguagelearningeffortsundertakenintheLanguageCentre.
Soastopromoteindividualmultilingualism,alllanguagelearningforstudentsattheLanguageCentreisfreeofchargeandpotentiallycredit-bearing(providedthatpredefinedassessmentcriteriaarefulfilled).Studentscanchooseanyofthesevenlanguagesavailableattheirownstartinglevelandcanthusenlargetheirmultilingualandmulticulturalprofileinrelationtotheirneeds,interests,priorcompetencesandbymeansofindividuallearningpaths.Thiscreatesthemanydifferentheterogeneousmultilingualprofilesnecessaryforsociety,asopposedtodevelopingonlyonelanguageatahomogeneouslevel,andthusrepresentsapowerfulaspectofmotivationforlearningmoreandnewlanguages.
TheLanguageCentreoffersapluralityofextensiveandintensivelear-ningpossibilitiesduringthewholeacademicyear,includinganim-portantintegrationofnewlearningenvironments(newtechnologies,Tandemlearning,tutoring,etc.)andindividualisedlearning.ThustheCentreisabletoovercometimeconstraintsandaccommodateindividu-alpreferences.Fromapedagogicalpointofview,allmodulesapplyanaction-orientedapproach,takingintoconsiderationthespecificcom-municationneedsofthestudentsandfutureprofessionals,consciouslydevelopinginterculturalcompetenceandpromotinglearners’abilitytolearnindependently,inordertoencourageandequipstudentsforcon-tinuedlanguagelearningduringandaftertheirstudies.TheCentrealsotriestoraiseawarenesslevelsamongstudentsoftheroleandimpor-
98 99
Secondly,withthecreationoftheEHEAasaleverandthenecessityforuniversitiestoengageininternationalisationstrategies,theattitudeoftheadministrationoftheUniversitytolanguagelearninghaschanged.Withregardtothenewchallenges,anincreasedawarenessofthecen-tralroleofanappropriatemultilingualandmulticulturalprofileforeverystudenthasarisen.Thishasledtomoresupportforandengagementwiththeprojectonthepartoftheuniversityadministration,andinparti-culartosupplementarybudgetallocationandinstitutionalsupport,parti-cularlythroughtheLanguagePolicyCommissionoftheRectorate.Thiscommissioniscomposedofmembersofallfaculties,students,langua-gespecialistsandotherbodies,allowingontheonehandthesettingupofaprojectofaninstitutionallanguagepolicyasauniversity-widequestionratherthanonlyafaculty-levelconcern,andontheothertheopportunitytodemonstratethebenefitsofthechange.
Otherimportantfactorsinthesuccessoftheprojectaretheabilitytoemploywell-trainedandcommittedstaffwithappropriateworkingconditionsandongoingin-servicetraining;thedefinitionofqualitycrite-riainlinewiththerequirementsofBolognaforlanguagelearningmo-dules;thepresenceofhigh-qualitysupportstructuresforindependentlearningfacilitiesandtheexistenceofaqualitycultureandareflectiveapproachwithintheCentre’steam.Otheraspectsconcernappropriateinfrastructuresandcoursemodalities(e.g.smallgroups,flexibletimetables);astudent-centred,interactiveapproachrelatedtostudents’needsandintegratingprovenmethodsplusthelatestinnovationsandmostrecentresearchfindings;andtheconstantkeepinginmindhowbesttodevelopstudents’multilingualandmulticulturalcompetence.
contact informationCountry:SwitzerlandNameofuniversity:UniversitédeLausanneCentredelangues,BâtimentAnthropoleAddress:1015LausanneWebsite:http://www.unil.ch/cdlContactperson:Dr.BrigitteForsterVosickiEmail:[email protected]:+41216922921
tanceoflanguagelearningforacademicneeds,employabilityandsocialintegration.
ExpectedlearningoutcomesaredefinedinaccordancewiththerequirementsofBologna,expressedintermsofcompetencesandrelatedtothereferencelevelsofthe„CommonEuropeanFrameworkofReferenceforLanguages“oftheCouncilofEuropebymeansofthesystematicuseoftheEuropeanLanguagePortfolio(ELP)forHigherEducationoftheEuropeanLanguageCouncil(ELC/CEL).Thisallowstransparencyandcomparabilityataninternationallevelandthecoher-entdocumentationofthestudents‘multilingualandmulticulturalcom-petencefromthepointofviewofthelifelonglearningparadigm.Multipleandalternativeformsofassessmentallowtheevaluationofthevariousaspectsofmultilingualandmulticulturalcompetenceandthecapacitytolearn.
FeeexemptionandtherecognitionoflanguagelearningeffortsthroughtheawardofECTShaveledtoanotableincreaseinthenumberofparticipantsenrolledintheLanguageCentre(approximately2,500studentsperyearcannowbenefitfromthisopportunity,asopposedtoaround750studentsbeforethechanges).Positivestudentfeed-backisanothersourceshowingtheincreaseinstudent‘smotivationforcontinu-edlanguagelearningasaresultoftheseimprovements.
Thisstructuralchangetookplacethanksacombinationofdifferentfac-tors.Firstamongthesewastheperseveranceoftheinitiatorsofthepro-jectwiththeirclearvision,continuouslyactingatmultiplelevels,suchascommissionwork,congresses,round-tablediscussions,researchpro-jects,presentations,invitationofinternationalexpertstodemonstrateexamplesofbestpractice,etc.,andinvolvingrelevantstakeholderssuchasuniversitydecisionmakers,students,facultymembers.Thisinordertodemonstrateanddeepenunderstandingofwhythesemeasu-resarecrucialinrelationtotherealisationoftheobjectivesofBologna,toshowtherelevanceandbenefitsoftheprojectandtostimulatere-flectiononimplementationstrategies.Anotheraspectofthisconstantadvocacyistheneedtochangebeliefsandrepresentationsconcerninglanguagesandlanguagelearningandtocircumventnumerousformsofresistance.
100 101
4.3. Motivation through certification
The2001languagepolicyoftheBabes-BolyaiUniversityofCluj(BBU)setsclearlanguageproficiencystandardsandintroduceslanguagecertificationaccordingtoCEFRlevelsaspartofuniversitydegrees.Itwasimplementedinthecontextofagovernmentalrecommendationofintroducingalanguagecomponenttouniversitydegrees.Twolanguagecentreshavebeensetuptodevelopandprovidelanguagetestingandcertificationservicesataffordableprices.Studentsaremotivatedtocheckandimprovetheirlanguageproficiencylevel,becomemoreauto-nomouslearners,andfamiliarisethemselveswiththeCEFR.Thelan-guagepolicymayproveausefultooltopromoteinternationalmobility,employability,andregionalplurilingualism.
ThedocumentTowardaEuropeanLanguagePolicyinBBUwasadop-tedbytheSenateofBBUinDecember2001.Itstipulatestheimplemen-tationofa1+2languagepolicyforallstudentsoftheuniversity:afirstlanguageAandtwosecondlanguagesBandC.StudentscanselectlanguageBfromamongsixlanguages:English,French,German,Itali-an,Spanish,andRussian.LanguageCmaybeanynon-nativemodernlanguageonofferinfacultiesandlanguagecentres.WhilelanguageBisobligatoryinthefirstyearofdegreecourses,languageCishighlyre-commended,butnotimposed.
Theinitiativeissetagainstthebackgroundofexperienceshowingthatthemajorityofstudentsconsideredlanguagelearningaslessimportantthantheirotheracademicpursuits.Itaimstoraisestudents’awarenessofthesignificanceoflinguisticcompetence,inparticularforemployabili-ty,andthusimprovetheirmotivationtolearnlanguages.TheadaptationoflanguageteachingandassessmenttotheCEFRistoensurethatthelanguagecomponentofBBUdegreesismeasuredaccordingtoEuro-peanqualitystandards;thatBBUgraduatesmeetthelanguageprofici-encystandardssetbytheuniversity;thattheymeetemployabilitycrite-ria;thattheyhaveaccesstoacademicandprofessionalresourcesandareabletocooperatescientificallyandprofessionallyinaninternationalcontext.
102 103
Inordertoensurethatqualitylanguagelearningstandardsareachieved,theinitiativeintroducedoneforeignlanguagecertificationaccordingtotheCEFRasapartofBachelor,Masteranddoctoraldegrees.TheinitialtargetwasforstudentstoachieveB2levelofproficiencyinonelangua-geBasaconditiontogainaccesstoBachelordegreeexaminationsorenrolinMasterordoctoralprogrammes.However,asthisrequirementprovedtobetooambitiousforaboutathirdofthestudents,thepolicywasamendedin2004,introducinganoncompulsoryexitlanguagetestattheendofBachelorprogrammes.
TheALPHALanguageCentre,affiliatedtotheFacultyofLetters,wassetupin2002.TogetherwiththeLINGUALanguageCentre,affiliatedtotheFacultyofEconomics,itofferscoursesandcertificationinawiderangeoflanguages:inadditiontothesixlanguagesmentionedabove,therearecoursesofregionalandotherEuropeanlanguagesaswellasnon-Europeanlanguagesofglobaleconomicimportance.Certificationisnotfree,butpricesareverylowforstudentsandstaff.Certificationisalsoavailabletothegeneralpublic;theprofitmadefromthisallowsthelanguagecentrestobefinanciallysustainable.
Thesuccessoftheinitiativeisindicatedbyanumberoffacts.Evenafterthe2004policychange,whichmadelanguagecertificationnolongerobligatoryinBachelordegrees,certificationisstillsoughtbyatleast70%offuturegraduates.Asignificantnumberofcandidatesachieveautonomyaslanguagelearners:in2007,38%purchasedthePrepara-toryGuidetotheALPHACertificateTest,whichoffersanintroductiontoboththeALPHAlanguagetestandtotheCEFR.Inthesameyear,7.8%ofthecandidatesattendedpreparatorycoursestargetingB2level;thisfactshowsthemotivationofstudentstoreachthequalitystandardssetbyBBU.
Anumberofsuccessfactorsexplainthestudents’motivation.OneofthemisthattheydecidetoobtaincertificationatalowpriceduringtheirBachelordegreeincasetheydecidetoenrolinaMasterprogrammelater,wherelanguageproficiencywillberequired.ALPHAlanguagecertificationhasgainedprestigeamongotheracademicinstitutionsandemployers.BBU’slanguagepolicyhasraisedstudents’awarenessoftheimportanceoflinguisticcompetenceforemployability.Thelanguagecentresprovidehighqualityservicesataffordableprices;whatismore,asCEFR-calibratedcertificationhelpsstudentsidentifytheirstrengthsandweaknessesandsetgoals,theyaremotivatedtolearnlanguagesevenoutsidethecurriculum.Moreover,highlevelsofproficiencyinlan-guagesareappreciatedinTransylvaniansociety–moststudentsachie-veB2levelorabove,whichmakeslanguagecertificationarewardingexperience.
However,experiencehasshownthatwhilestudentsachieveincrea-singlyhighlevelsofproficiencyinEnglish,otherlanguagesarenotinequallyhighdemand.The2008BBUlanguagepolicytriestoleadstu-dentstowardsplurilingualismmoresuccessfullybypromotingthestu-dyofregionallanguages:inMasterdegreeslanguageCatB1levelisrequiredatgraduation.Itisexpectedthatasignificantnumberofstu-dentswillchooseregionallanguagestomeetthisrequirement,andthusincreasetheprestigeofanddemandforlanguagesfromthemultiethniccontextinTransylvania.
contact informationCountry:RomaniaNameofuniversity:Babes-BolyaiUniversityofClujAddress:Str.HoreaNr.31,400202,Cluj-NapocaContactperson:AdrianaTodeaEmail:[email protected]:+40264434164
104 105
Molan partner institutions and organisations
country institution / organisation individual contributors
DE FreieUniversitätBerlin– WolfgangMackiewicz co-ordinatinginstitution IsabelleOrtiz LiljaSauter MariaGiovannaTassinariAT UniversitätWien ArthurMettinger FlorianFeldbauer Sanda-MonicaMelegaBE Conseileuropéenpour WolfgangMackiewicz leslangues/ EuropeanLanguageCouncilBE UniversitéLibredeBruxelles IanTudorBE VrijeUniversiteitBrussel PietvandeCraen EvaMigomBE HendrikConscienceschool DidiervandeGucht BrusselBE HogeschoolUniversiteit ErikUytterhoeven Brussel LudoTeeuwen BE EUNPartnershipAISBL– MarcDurando „EuropeanSchoolnet“ SilviaBinger PaddyCarpenter (consultant) AnneGilleran NathalieScheeckCH UniversitédeLausanne Anne-ClaudeBerthoud BrigitteForsterVosickiCY PanepistimioKipru PavlosPavlouDE Albert-Ludwigs-Universität JaninaCünnen Freiburg SonjaDierks FrankReiserDE Europa-UniversitätViadrina ThomasVogel Frankfurt/Oder AndreasBahrDE Friedrich-List-SchuleBerlin RainerJahn
106 107
DK AarhusUniversitet/ KarenM.Lauridsen AarhusUniversity BusinessandSocialSciencesDK HandelshøjskoleniKøbenhavnOleHelmersenES UniversidadPompeuFabra CarmenPérezVidal Barcelona MireiaCalmNovellasES UniversidadPablode FranciscoLorenzo OlavideSevilla VirginadeAlbaQuinonesFR UniversitéCharles-de-Gaulle– SophieBabault Lille3 MartineBenoit RodicaCalciuFR UniversitéRennes2 DanielToudicGR AristotelioPanepistimio AngelikiKiliari Thessalonikis Anna-MariaHatzitheodorouHU KodolányiJánosF_iskola CsillaSárdi Székesfehérvár KiszelyZoltánIE InstitiúidTeicneolaíochta KristinBrogan TráLi(Tralee)IT UniversitàdeglistudidiTorino AnneChiarloni StefanKatherLT KaunoTechnologijos AudroneDaubariene Universitetas ReginaPetrylaite IlonaRinkevicieneLT VytautoDid_iojouniversitetas InetaDabasinskiene NemiraMacianskiene NataljaMazeikieneLU EuropeanUniversity BerndJustinJütte Foundation(EUF) KrzystofKaluznyPL UniwersytetWarszawski JolantaUrbanokowaPT UniversidadedoAlgarveFaro ManuelCélioConceição MariaConceiçãoBravoPT UniversidadedoMinhoBraga OrlandoGrossegesse MarieManuelleSilva AgrupamentodeEscolas DiamantinoMartins D.AfonsoIIIFaro
country institution / organisation individual contributors
PT DirecçãoRegionalde MariadoCarmoGonçalves EducaçãodoAlgarvePT EscolaSecundáriade FilomenaConceição TomásCabreiraFaroPT DirecçãoRegionalde MariadoCarmoGonçalves EducaçãodoAlgarveRO UniversitateaBabe_- AdrianaTodea BolyaiCluj-NapocaSI UniverzavLjubljani, Neva_libar FilozofskafakultetaTR HacettepeÜniversitesiAnkara AyferAltay ElifErsozlu OrhunYakinUK TheNationalCentrefor TeresaBirks Languages–CILTLondon SteveCushion GeoffSwinnUK UniversityofUlster ElisabethLillie VictoriaRiosCastano GregoryTonerUK UniversityofWolverhampton HenriettaHarnisch
country institution / organisation individual contributors
108 109
external experts
DE AdrianBröking Friedrich-Ebert-Oberschule BerlinDE AstridBuschmann-Göbels Fremdsprachenzentrum derHochschulenimLand BremenDE DorisGebert UniversitätPotsdamDE BärbelKühn Fremdsprachenzentrum derHochschulenimLand BremenDE MalgorzataMajewska-Meyers MalgorzataMajewska- MeyersDE HeidrunPeters Ernst-Moritz-Arndt- UniversitätGreifswaldES YolandaRuizdeZarobe EuskalHerriko UnibertsitateaHU IldikóSzábo KecskemétiF_iskolaIE TanyaFlanagan KildareEducationCentreIS Oddn_Sverrisdóttir HáskóliÍslandsIT MargritWetter Universitàdeglistudidi Roma„LaSapienza“UK AnnaCallahan UniversityofEssexUK GladisGarcia UniversityofEssex
evaluation board
IT-chair MaurizioViezzi UniversitàdieTriesteBE BrianFox EuropeanCommission,DG InterpretationBEBE RegisRitz EuropeanUniversity Association,BrusselsBEFR AnnieLhérété Ministèredel‘Education nationale,ParisFRUK RichardWhewell UniversityofStrathclyde
110 111
Management committee
DE WolfgangMackiewicz, FreieUniversitätBerlin Co-ordinator BE MarcDurando, EUNPartnershipAISBL– Deputyco-ordinator „EuropeanSchoolnet“AT ArthurMettinger UniversitätWienCH Anne-ClaudeBerthoud UniversitédeLausanneES CarmenPérezVidal UniversidadPompeu FabraBarcelonaFR DanielToudic UniversitéRennes2LT InetaDabasinskiene VytautoDid_iojouniversitetas
Project manager
DE DieterJirmann-Heidl FreieUniversitätBerlin
GratefulthanksarealsoduetothemanyteachersthroughoutEuropewhowillinglyprovidedinformationabouttheirlanguageteachinginitiativefromwhichthecasestudieswerecompiled.
112 113
contributing schools
Ensemblescolaire Nancy FranceSaintLéonIX. Ecolepubliquemixte Fromont FrancedeFromontStAndrewsPrimarySchoolToab OrkneyIslands ScotlandHässelbygårdsskolan Hässelby SwedenSiegerland– Berlin GermanyGrundschuleWildernSchool Southampton UnitedKingdomCollègeInternational Fontainebleau FranceIstitutoTecnico Verona ItalyIndustriale(ITIS)Marconi LycéeFulbert Chartres FranceTheMidlandsCurriculumCentrefor WestMidlands UnitedKingdomLanguages,UniversityofWolverhampton Lycéeprofessionnel Montbard FranceEugèneGuillaume OrivedenKeskuskoulu Orivesi Finland1stExperimental Athens GreeceLyceumofAthens Sint-Janscollege Poperinge BelgiumLiceoScientifico Livorno Italy„FrancescoCecioni“ MaloreesJunior London UKNorthTown Taunton UKPrimarySchool SeduvaGymnasium Seduva LithuaniaKedainiaiLanguage LithuaniaSchool L’écolesecondaire Alytus LithuaniaDzukijad’Alytus St.Michael’s,Loreto Navan IrelandSecondarySchool
114 115
St.Laurence‘sNational Greystones, IrelandSchool WicklowHucknallNationalC Hucknall UKofEPrimarySchool EscolaSecundária Faro PortugaldePinheiroeRosa WhitehouseCommon WestMidlands UKPrimarySchool SabhalMòrOstaig IsleofSkye ScotlandPortmarnock Portmarnock IrelandCommunitySchool I.I.S.S.Vivante-Pitagora Bari ItalyBradleyCE Ashbourne UKPrimarySchool ZespolSzkol Zawiercie PolandGimnazjumiSzkolaPodstawowanr13 Brentfield London UKPrimarySchool Göztepe_hsanKur_ Göztepe Turkeyuno_luAnadoluLisesi(HighSchool) WalthamstowSchool Walthamstow UKforGirlsOnze-Lieve- Poperinge BelgiumVrouwe-instituut KarinthyFrigyes Budapest HungaryGimnázium
116 117
Editedby
DanielToudicUniversitéRennes21,PlaceduRecteurH.leMoalFR-35043Rennes
and
WolfgangMackiewiczFreieUniversitätBerlinZESprachenzentrumHabelschwerdterAllee45DE-14195Berlin
Gestaltung:elsner.elsnerDatum:Juni2011Auflage:1000Stück