mirai archive - 京都大学future/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/20… · mirai archive international...

19
MIRAI Archive International Research Unit of Advanced Future Studies(IRU-AFS) No.2015-007 1 ʪȃ˥ ¬˝ĮľġȵȍȗľȳɁƎ ȳɁ¶ ʏ˴fhq1LåˎȪȴĨȖʮ3÷ȗ1ˆL ƻǁ 2015 Š 8 dž 7 ƻNJ11101150 ģƎ cU¬˝ 202 Ũ˦ ʑ ǶĻǐǶɾďijľ˭ĮľĮľ˭˨ȼľȳɁȼ ươ ʪȃ ʌŗɻ¤¬˝ľĜĮľ ươ ǺʴǍɯ ── ˡ3ˠ.ǁ˨Ňŧ.«ƨˍŧ hUt 1 ʪȃlUs ʌŗ4I@3I0ģ1Ƙ &'/DK.@ ÖȝȞɎĻÐȚ3ʪȃ-4NN0ʷĕ K@&ȻDšȺȳɁP,K@&Ð> /3SmqfȐdz<3˾Ż3ʠ-^ `y Carol Graham.šȺľ3 ľɩě˰ǫʿ30-S]vhl3˹Ƌ˪ ĞĠ38.3šȺƆ4qS\38.3šȺƆ.>?ć- Ȣ3šȺƆ 3şğIKD'..-$.L3-ě˰ǫʿ4Smqf L.Pɨƈ='.Ž@ h3ecgĮɛ˿3Įɛ˿ķđ¶-ķđPìC,&SqTSj Amartya Sen QDDžÞ4šȺŧPƯɈȭǟ1,40.I0.P ʘ),JM@&º˧ȧǨ˯1L8.3šȺƆDSmqf- 0L$MPI.L.10L3-$M4'C'.-DžÞ4šȺŧ P*L.1ûʼnM,&I0ɗɤDK@ ƻǍ3šȺŧ3ʝʙ1*,Dǭ£ÑƯǠ-3ȳɁ¶-4NN0ʒɒL. .PmoftƷŪ-ɏ 140 3˽ȭP&3-$M1ŵȆ.WYUs P*,S`bf,sl0šȺŧPȀL.40)&3-' JšȺŧPƯɈȭǟ1,ƱÈ31I),ƯɈPDZCL.3öˮſ4šȺ ȳɁP,LDƅʫ0JȳɁ,L.Ǯ4@@'ȧŏˋ'.Ž

Upload: others

Post on 14-Jun-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: MIRAI Archive - 京都大学future/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/20… · MIRAI Archive International Research Unit of Advanced Future Studies(IRU-AFS) No.2015-007 1 ª å ¬ Ý . >

MIRAI Archive� �������� ������

International Research Unit of Advanced Future Studies(IRU-AFS)� � � � � � No.2015-007

1

ʪȃ˥

¬˝ĮľġȵȍȗľȳɁƎ� ȳɁ¶ ʏ˴fhq�1��LåˎȪȴĨȖʮ3÷ȗ1ˆL

ƻǁ� 2015 Š 8 dž 7 ƻNJ1110−1150

ģƎ� c��U�¬˝� 202

Ũ˦� ʑ ǶĻǐǶɾďijľ˭Įľ�Įľ˭­˨ȼľȳɁȼ� ươ

ʪȃ� ʌŗɻ¤¬˝ľĜĮľ ươ

ǺʴǍɯ──�ˡ3ˠ.ǁ˨Ňŧ.«ƨˍŧ

�h�Ut 1� ʪȃlUs��

ʌŗ��4I����@ ��3I�0ģ1�Ƙ�

�&'��/�D�K�.����@ �

� ÖȝȞɎĻÐȚ3ʪȃ-4��N�N0ʷĕ��

K@�&��ȻDšȺȳɁP�,�K@�&�Ð>

/3Sm�q�f��Ȑdz<3˾Ż3ʠ-�^

����`�y�Carol Graham.��šȺľ3

ľɩ��ě˰ǫʿ30�-S�]vhl�3˹Ƌ˪

ĞĠ3­8.3šȺƆ4��q�S��\3­8.3šȺƆ.>?ć�- Ȣ3šȺƆ

3şğIKD�'.���.- �$����.��L3-�ě˰ǫʿ4Sm�q�f

����L�.Pɨƈ =�'.Ž�@ �

���h3e�cgĮɛ˿3Įɛ˿ķđ¶-ķđPìC,�&S��qTS�j�

Amartya Sen�QD�DžÞ4šȺŧPƯɈȭǟ1�,4��0�.��I�0�.P

ʘ),�JM@�&�º�˧ȧǨ˯1�L­8.3šȺƆD�Sm�q�f��-

�0L�$MPI�. L�.10L3-�$M4'C'����.-�DžÞ4šȺŧ

P*�L�.1ûʼn�M,�&I�0ɗɤD�K@ �

ƻǍ3šȺŧ3ʝʙ1*�,D�ǭ£ÑƯǠ-3ȳɁ¶-4�N�N0ʒɒ��L.�

��.Pmof���tƷŪ-ɏ 140 3˽ȭP��&3- ��$M1ŵȆ.WYUs

P*�,S`�b�f���,s�l�0šȺŧPȀL�.4�0�)&3- �'�

J�šȺŧPƯɈȭǟ1�,�ƱÈ3��1I),ƯɈPDZCL�.3öˮſ4�šȺ

ȳɁP�,�L­Dƅʫ�0�JȳɁ�,�L.��Ǯ4�@ �@'ȧŏˋ�'.Ž

Page 2: MIRAI Archive - 京都大学future/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/20… · MIRAI Archive International Research Unit of Advanced Future Studies(IRU-AFS) No.2015-007 1 ª å ¬ Ý . >

MIRAI Archive � No.2015-007

2

�@ �

� �H�3Ȼ3ʠ4�šȺƆ1(���Ǻʴ1ILȚǷȁʻŧ1*�,- ��M4š

ȺȳɁ30�-4�>?Uc��3D3.ɨ�JM,�@ �šȺȳɁ30�-4�š

ȺPʊȖ Lɾʤ1�*3�.5��),��H�Ȼ�¢ŸȪ1ƒ�34�U��eq

Th�R_f��-Ǻʴ1ʼn�,/���êȜPŵL3�.���.- �

� �ɹ3Ʒ�&�ʠ�,�L34�y~wh.��ǜż- ��M4�U��eqTh

�R_f��.�J=L.�ɗǽȪ0ʒę�ʅ��M/D�IKţ�gXw��0ǜż

- ����@ Ȣ-šȺŧƝƱP*�L.�0/1*�OM,�L�.54�WX��

}�U�`- �OMOM30�-Dy}�`3ǁ³��),�tVU�`3ǁ³��

),�}�U�`3ǁ³��,�$3Ð1WX��}�U�`3ǁ³��L�����

ʢʫ-��@WX��}�U�`PȀN�.��ȳɁ��M,�L.Ž�@ �

� Ȼ4>Q3 4 �dž�J�ã@-4�˶ ˌɟȳ.��˶ˌ3f�_l�_1îC,�K�

$�-Ǻʴ3ȳɁP�D1�,�K@�&�Ǻʴȿ���)&J/�0L3�.���

@3Ǻʴ3s��t�/�0L3�.���@|osĔĐ�/�0),�L3��$�

���.3Ɨů˜˦P�,�K@�&3-�$M.šȺŧ3˩ÂP�H�4ʠ�&�.

Ž),�K@ �

�h�Ut 2� ǁ³3ǮÛ�PʦAʗ�ƷǴ

� Ȼ��,�&�.40

1�.��.��Q0�

.PF),�K@�&�

�@Ǻʴ3 Ȣ-01�

ʹ�),�L3�4�0

�0�A�0�3- �3�

4 Š�ɗ*.�$M�I�

F�Ğ˺1�JOM,�

L3- �h�Ut3ɡ

3��ȷ¶3�1A�,

�L.�N03-���

��Ȗʮ4A�,�L3

- ��Ȗʮ�|os L.��ǹʈL.��ãƧ.�,4�01��Ťǹ1�L3-

�*21ć�D3� =,3ǁ³1ǹʈL.���.-40�3- �}��i��

s^�����@�&JǹʈL�.��.�®4m�'�/�3.�1�&�Jǹʈ)

&.��I�1ɨ�L3- �

Page 3: MIRAI Archive - 京都大学future/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/20… · MIRAI Archive International Research Unit of Advanced Future Studies(IRU-AFS) No.2015-007 1 ª å ¬ Ý . >

MIRAI Archive � No.2015-007

3

� &.�5�(H).Ā�- ��2001 Š˼�*@K 15 Š�J�ãPŽ�Ú�,�&

'�.�4�C,ũħ3Øȯ˳����10)&3��3�N- �$M�J�lU�

h�o�`�c.��`�c3 300 ×�J� Lɑ0�@�²�ĔĐ�Ú@�&��

M� 2002 Š1ǹʈK@�&�ó.óŋ3ȸ˱��.��ƿȡ�|os�&3D 2001 Š

- ���A,AL.��@-401�ʹ�)&3�4O�L3- ���3ůǁ4Ø

ȯ˳.�ʀĻ3�@��$M�Jƿȡc�q�p- �J�@)&�Û˟�˗�D3-

$M%M�ǹʈ),�L.��'�1A�L3- �OMOM4��3Ť101�s�

�t.�,�L�PAL3- �$� L.�s������,�L.AL3- �

� �3.�1$M1Ǯ+�,01�P���0�.˒�3- �2005 Š10L.��

�ȭ3īƻ�.��ƿȡ�|os�@�&��ɹ3Ʒ�&4��3.�10),ǀď 30

Š³���'.Ǯ+�ĶCL3- ����-°Ƣ�&.�N-D����4~�_�

J�),�@ �J�©ñC3tg�W4Ơ@�JM0�3- �'�J�2001 Š�2002

Š3.�1�s����-���I�.µȡPD),��0�.��0�������

.P�N�N.�,�@�&��M�ǁ³3ǮÛFs��tPʦAʗ�.���.')

&3- ������ǮÛPʦAʗ�0�J�/�F)&Jȷ¶�Ǜ��0L�.��

µȡP*�L3�Ȼ3°¨')&3-�$3Ƴɰ-šȺ3ȳɁD�,�@�&�

�h�Ut 3� U�hl���{�t_h

� �M4ÖȝÐȚD��O),�J)�E)&ǭ£ÑƯǠ3.�3šȺŧ1˩ LȳɁ

¶30�-ȶ�M&D3- �1 ­�&K GDP ��ƽ�,�L3- ��šȺŧFȚǷȁ

ʻŧ�ƻǍ3r�l-4>.Q/��),�0��˸�ɡ�šȺŧ-�ˋ¢-ÜM,�L

Page 4: MIRAI Archive - 京都大学future/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/20… · MIRAI Archive International Research Unit of Advanced Future Studies(IRU-AFS) No.2015-007 1 ª å ¬ Ý . >

MIRAI Archive � No.2015-007

4

34ƯŦ3¦ɉ�0�0),�ǁFC&�J- �[��gɺ3ɡ�ȚǷȁʻŧ- �

GDP 4�3˄P 100 .��ƝƱ1�&ģĆ1��M'���),�L.���.Pȶ�,

�@ �

� ɗǽľ�J L.�ˌŝ4D3Pʳ�.êȜšȺƆPŵL3- �GDPěǭƎŵ

- �J�Ǝŵ���)&�J&��QD3�ʳ�L4!-�L�$M1D��OJ!

ȚǷȁʻŧFšȺŧ���J0�340#���3�.P�n��t�U�hl��

Richard Easterlin.��­� 1974 Š1ƝƬ�&3- �$M��@-Dɝ�,�,�

S��\3r�l-DćǞ3�.�AJML3- �

�h�Ut 4� ƻǍ­3šȺŧȚǷȁʻŧ

� Ð>/3D34

ěǭȚǷ˚Ĵŧ

ʨǕ�3r�lP*

�),�L3-

��ěǭȚǷ1˩

L ʩʨǕ�.�

�ß3r�l-D

ȚǷȁʻŧPǁɍ

Ý1.),�@ �

ěǭȚǷ˚Ĵŧ

ʨǕ�4łƸ� 3

Š1 1 Ę03-

���(J4ǩŠ 1

ĘʨǕ�,�L3-�IKʡɓ0r�l10),�@ ��3`��PA,�&'�.�

U�hl�����I�1 1958Š�JDž˅@-'�&� 60%˅˄-ȁʻŧ�ƤȽ�,�

@ �

� 1958 Šǀď 33 Š- ���3Š4Ð>/3 �ȭ3īƻ�3ƿȡ3ɸă10)&Š

- �@'z�o_»@��Ǧ),�K��3ʨǕPĶC&34�ěǭ�Ƌų1Ŷɷ�

,(EQ.Ņ1»Q-�@ ��.��ȰLD34�K@ ��.���L�4u

U��ʎĐ4ʳ�@�&��.������ʷĕ30�3�Ș.�,ȚǷȁʻŧ4/

3�J�- ��.���.Pɬ�,�@ �

� �3ʨǕ3�(5QDžÞ3ʨǕĢčǃPʓ&3- ��ɬ�Ʒ.�,4�Ƌã.�J

=,/�- ���$M�JʑtUp1�J=,/�- ����J1kˏ1�J=

,/�- ��.���.Pʚ�,�@�&�kˏ1�J=,ɵÛ3ȁʻŧ�º�.Ż

Page 5: MIRAI Archive - 京都大学future/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/20… · MIRAI Archive International Research Unit of Advanced Future Studies(IRU-AFS) No.2015-007 1 ª å ¬ Ý . >

MIRAI Archive � No.2015-007

5

�&­� 20%�J��&3- �$3.�-DȚǷȁʻŧ4 60%(���)&3- 2�

Dž˅-4�(H).��),�, 70%�J�10),�@ ��MD>Q.�1��)

,�L3��ŠǝƊ30�-fvS3>���0L�fvS3­ÿ�Ħ�L.�Ó

¼3ƱÈD��L.��êǑ�ċ@M,�LĂɯſ��L.A,�K@ ����3r

�l�U�hl���{�t_h3ãƧ10),�L3- �

�h�Ut 5� U�hl���{�t_h3½�ĕ�

� 0#�3U�hl���{�t_h�ĕ

03�.��.�·ɛȪ0ɗǽľ-4�ˡ.

�xP«ƨ L.êȜ�ŵJML4!- �

����Ǻʴ��1 ­�&K GDP � 6 Æ1

Ħ�&31�0#êȜ�Ħ�,�0�3��

�M�ʞƾ�M0�.�ɗǽľ3ȗʩ4��

��3-40��.���.10L�ƯŦ3

Ƀģ-��.�0#ąěƯŦ��M>/ȋŸ

1šȺŧƝǟP*�),�L3�.��.�1 ­�&K GDP �@),Děǭ�š"1

0),�0�. M5��@@-3ƯɈ3ōŧ-�)& GDP 3Ɗ˦PƯɈȭǟ. L�

.�ŕML3- �

� ł˰1��@½Pʘ)&J�˚ƞ-í,L3�.���.�O�J0�0),�L�

ěǭ3šȺPCL�.�-�M5Ƴā0�$M4I�ƯɈ03-�˚ƞ14í,L�

$���˕ɇPA*�&�.��Ž���),�šȺŧƝǟP*�),�L.�ND�

K@ �ěǭ1.),4�ʭ��3łƆ�ŵJM0�.���.-�01P M5šȺ

10ML3�ư�,>���$���ǣǯ��L3- �$M%M-šȺPǯC,�L

.���.03- �

� �MPɨ�L1�&),Ȼ4Ǻʴ�JA,�L3-�U�hl���{�t_h4�

D.D.Ǻʴ.ȚǷȁʻŧP�on�`�"L�.1Ȉȗ��LI�1Ž�@ �D

.D.Ȯ˩�0�D3P�)*�,A,�Ȯ˩�0�.�),�L'�1Ž�L3- �

�h�Ut 6� ©*3Ǻʴ

� 1984 Š1őŔǤď�Q���ǔJ��Å­£ɦ3ʣȚ .��Ǎ30�-Ǻʴ14©

*3lU���L.ˇ=,�K@ ��*�ȍʷȪǣǯ- ��M4ȁʻPž�ǣǯ-�

�1ʳ�&�� �1ȁ&�&������D3- �&.�5ɂɳ03-Ƽ���

��=&�.��ˌî�ɽȦ'�JƼ�¶ȷ1Ȱ�&���M�ȍʷȪǣǯ- �

� D��*3Ǻʴ.�,ȁʻPū�35 Ǻʴ��L�ďPǁ˨P��,Ǜ�B.��

Page 6: MIRAI Archive - 京都大学future/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/20… · MIRAI Archive International Research Unit of Advanced Future Studies(IRU-AFS) No.2015-007 1 ª å ¬ Ý . >

MIRAI Archive � No.2015-007

6

ƹʈ3��jhPǛ�B�$M-

ɕOL3Pƃ�B�����Ǻʴ

D�L��3Ǎ30�-4�ƣÊ

ŌʥPʦA�Ƽ�ȏ­PȲK&�

.Ž�0�J�$3ǮƜ(Pƕ�

,!).ʦQ-�LǛ�ADǺʴ

-�L.�OM,�@ �

� ����lU�3˗�©*3Ǻ

ʴ��L3- �ȍʷȪǣǯ4ȁ

&�&ȱ˨1ȁʻ4ˊǾ�,��

���ɳ�)6�10)&J$M´�=JM0��J�ˬȢ��L�ȁʻPū�35

Ǻʴ4�ȁʻ�Ɯɝ L�ˬȢ�0��ȍʷȪǣǯ4�-�L'�Ƽ�.���.0

3-�ǁ˨PɊɏ�,ǺʴP�&������ȁʻPū�35 Ǻʴ4�ǁ˨P˦ū�

",&);Kǁ˨P*��@!�ȍʷȪǣǯ4�ƎLJ L�..ƎLJ�&D3PD).

ʂɀ L�.�ȭȪ.0L3-�Țț1(��Ǻʴ- �$M1ʼn�,ȁʻPū�35

Ǻʴ4�ɵÛP�ǡĺ1 Lǁ˨P˦ū�"L�.�ȭȪ-�K�˹ȚțȪ03-I

Kɐɋ0Ǻʴ03-40����3I�1Û�ML3- �

�h�Ut 7� Ǻʴ.ǁ˨

� Ǻʴ30�1ǁ˨�3ǜżPÒ

M&.���.��˞ʒ-40��

.Ž),�K@ �ȁʻPž�Ǻʴ

4 �1Ǻʴ L3- ��Ǣ4ȁ

ʻ�ˊǾ L3-�U�l�z�P

��0�,4��0����-Dǁ

˨3ǜż�Źʒ10L�ȁʻPū�

35 Ǻʴ4�.�#Qǁ˨�Źʒ

- �őŔǬ4�ȁʻPū�35

&C1ɵÛ30�1D� 1 ­3±­���,�ɵÛ4Ƽ�ƣÊŌʥ3ɘnjPȲK&�

.�NPŲ,�.ū�ȣCLD��­3ɵÛ�Źʒ-�L.�),�JM@ �

�h�Ut 8� Ǻʴ1��L±­�3¯ĝ

� ¨3ģ1��,D�ɵÛ 1 ­-ɥĎ��D3Pʓ&J�*�*=,�@�3-

��D� 1 ­±­��L.�¶ʠPǛ�A0�Jǁ˨P��,¨P L�±­��L

Page 7: MIRAI Archive - 京都大学future/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/20… · MIRAI Archive International Research Unit of Advanced Future Studies(IRU-AFS) No.2015-007 1 ª å ¬ Ý . >

MIRAI Archive � No.2015-007

7

�Jǁ˨3c�s����-�L3-40��

.ƝƬ�,�@ �­˨4�ĀǏ�J0#�Ô

ć3ģ-D3PǺʴ L�.PĴB�'�J 1

­�K-Ǻʴ L34�*@J0�,�AQ0

.ǺʴP L�.-ǁ˨PǛ�B�.�-�L�

�L�4±­.ʨĻPĆO"L�.1I),�

Ǻʴʈë3�i�P�Ł1Ä*�.�-�L.

ˇ=,�JM@ �

�h�Ut 9� �ˡ.êȜ.ǁ˨

� Ǻʴ3�i�DƝƬ�M,�,�LI�1�

Ǻʴ.4õ1�ˡ.D3P«ƨ�,êȜPŵL

.���.-40��ǁ˨P��1Ïł�"L

�.���ǁ˨3ǜżPÒM,�L.�N�ƶ

��.Ž�@ �

� Ð>/3U�hl���{�t_h- ��

ű�{�t_h.Ɔ�L34�Ǻʴȁʻ4�˔

ø3ǺʴǷë3U�l�_f��3ɟď�Ǻʴ

ȁʻ10L.��ɨ�03- �����Ǻʴ4$����.-40�,�õ¹ǁ˨�

&K1/M'�U�{_s3�LǺʴP�&��$MDƼ�Ǻʴ�,�@�.�ɳ�)

6�10),�@�3-�U�l�z���)&K�ū�35 D3��)&K�$�

��Ĵ@���i�DǙʛ�0�,4��0�3- �

� Ȼ�ã1�&ţč¶ȷ3q�}ţč3Ɛ(ƷD¸,�K@�&�3 �dž3��'-Dž

Þ3 1 �dž1ĚC,q�} CM Pz�z�Ɛ),ʢȲȕPCL3�I�3���L�

4�ǩdžğɆ1�p��p�.Ɛ*>��$3ĔĐ1ʼn LĴƅŧFʸÒƅĉȕ���

L3��f����f�� L�r���K@�&�Ǻʴ1ILêȜšȺD����

D31¸,�,�õ¹ǁ˨30�-/3I�1ǺʴP/3Ⱦŧ L�.��ǺʴŇŧ3

c�s����˞ʒ03-40�-�H���

�h�Ut 10� Ǧż0Ǻʴ

� $3ƅĎ-Ǧż0Ǻʴ4����Ǻʴ-�òƱŠã1ǹʈ)&Į­ʳ�- �ǣ��

)&D3P�Ǯ1ʳ),�@��ʳ)&.�N-�2�3 �×-n�cYo`0/4Ó˜

ƥ�,�@�3-�ʳ)&�.4#Q:�@OML��L�4�t��DǩːA,�L

�J�D�N�3- ������U10)&˻ět��Pʳ),�,D�@OM,ʓ

Page 8: MIRAI Archive - 京都大学future/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/20… · MIRAI Archive International Research Unit of Advanced Future Studies(IRU-AFS) No.2015-007 1 ª å ¬ Ý . >

MIRAI Archive � No.2015-007

8

0��$����.Dʹ�,�@�3- ��

MJ4Ǧż0Ǻʴ03- �(EQ.Ǻʴ3�

i��-�L.0�M5ʭ�0Ǻʴ140J0

�3- �

�h�Ut 10� G&�0Ǻʴ

� [�_�T�og.��¶ȷ��K@ ��

��4 100 Š��),ɮ)&NJ4 100 Š*��

L�x1�I�.�),�@ �ɵȉ3�i�

.Ǻʴ3�i���ɶ�,�L.ʭ�0Ǻʴ�

łȖ L.���.-�űJ4 100 Š��),

ɮ)&NJPÜ), 100 Š*��LŅÕFŌȍ1

�,ƧÀ�,�L3- ��J1�ʎĐ1*�

�NJPÜ)&�.14��0J!t�`�3NJ

Pǘ�LǷëD�,�L�$��� 100 Šõ¹

3�i��Ɯɝ LǺʴPłȖ�,�L��Q0¶ȷD�L3- �ȻD�3¶ȷ3ʎ

ĐP��*�D),�@ ��ȁʻƆ3�ĔĐ�ĭ�- �

�h�Ut 12� r��ǁ³3ɌȸȪǣLj3Ǻʴ

� z��3�N4�/(J�.��.ȍʷȪ0Ƽ�Ǻʴ�&��.��Ǻʴ�£ǹ0

3- ��r��ǁ³10L.ɌȸȪ0ǣLj3Ǻʴ3>��£ǹ10L�Ā*FPǛ�

B.��'Q'QɗŠĪð1I),ǻA�Ħ I�0D3- �ˢș3Ö˜�ˣ8,�

L�.1I),�ˢÛPÚ .�- ��Š

ɅFɑǁʙD½òŠ�L�4 ³Pʺ�,

*��L3-�Dž˅-4����D31ɷĎ

�Ƚ),�L��eU_�-Ā�PʟÁ L

.��*0�KǺʴ�ʉëʳ����y�Ǻ

ʴ.�����ǁ˨ǺʴȪ0D3���h1

0K**�ʉëʳ�3I�0U�{�hȪ1

ȁʻPCLD3PɖA�O",�LƆ�-

Page 9: MIRAI Archive - 京都大学future/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/20… · MIRAI Archive International Research Unit of Advanced Future Studies(IRU-AFS) No.2015-007 1 ª å ¬ Ý . >

MIRAI Archive � No.2015-007

9

�h�Ut 13� ��y�Ǻʴ

� ��y�Ǻʴ4�ǺʴPȚǷŹ˷Đ�

.Ÿ3Ź˷Đ�3©*1Û�&.��Ț

ǷŹ˷ĐPʳ�34Ǻʴɩ1.),chs

- �sU�os��{��0�0)&J

ʳ�.��q�}�ĨM,�@)&�Jʳ

���MJ1ʼn�,Ÿ3Ź˷Đ�D3�

�K@ ��M4ʳ��.1I),Ė8�

ŵJMLǺʴ-��(JPU�{�hȪ1

.�/�ʳ��*���ˡ3ɟ4Ħ�,�J!�/(J�.��5ǾKǮĎ03'�

M/D�ȚǷȁʻŧ4��J0������ŘıP�,r��ǁ³3Ǻʴɩ4Řı�,

�L3- �

�h�Ut 14� Ǻʴ-0#ǮǂJ��-�L3�

� ��-ɨ�,��&�34�ǺʴP L

.0#ǮǂJ��-�L3�.���.-

��MD�&K@�03- ��ɗǽľ

3��I�1��ˡ.D3P«ƨ�,v�

iPȁ& �v�i��L�JǺʴP�,�

v�i�0�0),êȜPŵL3- ��

ß1Źʒ1ˆJM&v�i�0�,DŸ3

v�i3I�0D3��L�$3DFDF

�&v�i3I�0D3Pȁ& âȄ�ǣ

��.Ž),½�Pʳ),�L��3I�0Ǻʴ��@Ǻʴ3Ė8P��,�MLD3

10),�L�*@K�Ǻʴ4��ˆ)&v�iPÏʻ Lʈȇ.��IK4�DFD

F�&Ÿ3v�i1âȄP��L�.�*@K�ɲ1½�U�{_s3�LƂĢP��

Lʈȇ�$M�Ǻʴ03-40���'�J��ˡ�.D0�ʈȇ-�N�.0�N�

.��x-˜Ŏ�ȁ&�M,�I�.�@�.�*21ǺʴP�&�.��ǣǯ�ļĝ

�,�L�ǺʴP L.���.4�Ǻʴv�i��L�Jʈ0�3-40�,ǺʴP

L.��Ǎɯ��L�JǺʴ L3-40��.ɨ�,�@ �

�h�Ut 15� Ǻʴ4ɲ�Ė:âȄP��LǷë

� Ȼ��3I�1ɨ�ĶC&�)��10)&�.5��K@ �ɲ4*21âȄPǯ

Cɝ�L�Ȼ&(3ɲ4õȒ-4ɵɃ-�!�*21 Ȣ.����.�&FK.KP

Page 10: MIRAI Archive - 京都大学future/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/20… · MIRAI Archive International Research Unit of Advanced Future Studies(IRU-AFS) No.2015-007 1 ª å ¬ Ý . >

MIRAI Archive � No.2015-007

10

�,�0�M50J0�ļĝ-�L�ĬȢ�J

3ƂĢP*21ǯC,�,�ĬȢ�J3ƂĢP

˙Ƶ L.�ɲ4Źʒ1ˆJM,ŢʔPȚAÚ

��� L���M4ɧĽĄ�Q3�.5'.

Ž),!).âȄPDJ�ɝ�,�&3- ��

®Ę3ȧʊ1�&),ʨ=0��,AL.��

M4ɿNJÉ�˛ÐȚ3�ɲ�ƲȗǴ .��Ǎ

30�3�.5'.���.�O�K@�&�

ɿNJÐȚ�/�D�K�.����@�&��M�Ǻʴ3ǍʷPʘ�ů,,�L3-4

0�-�H���

�h�Ut 16� Ǻʴȷ¶�Jțǚȷ¶<

� �@@-OMOM4�Ǻʴ1I),ɲ1âȄ

P��,ȁʻPŵI�.��ʈëPƋų�J!

).�,�&3- ���@4Ǻʴʈë�ĭǞ

ð�,�,�L�$M4Ǻʴȷ¶�ƙ�),�

L.���.-40�,�Ǻʴ3ǜż�ƙ�)

,�L3- �Ǻʴ4ɲ1âȄ���JMM5

I�3-�Ź!�D�ˡ.�xP«ƨ�0�,

DI���x.�xP«ƨ�,DI���0Q

1D«ƨ�0�,D�&.�5Ð>/3ÖȝÐȚ3�ʠ3I�1k�f���^�~l

�3ʭ��PƆ�L'�-DI�3- �

�h�Ut 17� ǺʴȚț

� OMOM4�@K1DǺʴȷ¶1Ǫ�M,�

L3-�U�hl���{�t_h3I�0ʓ

ƷP�,�@�3- ���*4Ǻʴ4Țț

°¨P L�.-DŵJML��MDőŔǤ

ďÐȚ�ãˇ3Ǎ3¢-�Ǻʴ.Țț4ć�ǝ

ˎPD*D3-�L.ˇ=,�JM@ �0#

0JȚț4�ʧPʗDZ L&C1��ˡP*

�),�xPǺɫ�,ljˬ@-101�PüC

Lʈȇ-�L�$���ƅĎ-4�g��Dć�- �¦ɉ��),hag�����

),�$MP�0�,Ȉ¨1Ņ1Ŝ),�L�$���ƅĎ-4°¨.ć�03-�L�

Page 11: MIRAI Archive - 京都大学future/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/20… · MIRAI Archive International Research Unit of Advanced Future Studies(IRU-AFS) No.2015-007 1 ª å ¬ Ý . >

MIRAI Archive � No.2015-007

11

� Ȥʷ0D3�ɆÁ10L.���.��ʭ��3Ȏŷ'.Ž�3- �{�.a�^

�/(JD 100 ×�J�-ʳ�L.��q��{�_.f�o~�`j�l�1ʈ�3

�ć�ÁÈPD),�L.���@3ɼ�­1.),4���.zuuDć�ÁÈ-

=&�>�P=L3- ��M�ʭ��3ɘǑ- �ć�I�1ʭ�10L.°¨.

Ǻʴ�ɆÁ10L�

�h�Ut 18� ǺʴƖʵ

� ć�I�1�ƖʵDǺʴ

.ć�10K@ ��U_

���RUu�h.��D

3��K@ ����go

_j^��qT�i.��

¶ȷ�³ʊȪ0D3- ��

Ōÿ3 3 �×.� 5 �×.

�P˳C,}gwh1Ɩʵ

P�,�$3}gwh�Ɗ

ç�&J�l��PDJ�

L3- �Ȼ4�D.D.

�3Ƿë3Į�R�- �

� LJĈ0¿-4Œő3ǖİ˛g��i.��¶ȷ��K@ �1 Ȱ 15 �×�J��,�

įȉ3ʆ-ƏǓC Lɑg��i- �ȋȑȪ0�R���L3- ��0�0��

ɹȪ0��aos�0��$���}gwh1ʼn�,�3 �×.� 5 �×.�P�R�

�J˳C,*�),DJ),�ĩM&J�l���ƍ),�L�$3}gwh�ļɝ

L�D�ĩM0�,D�3 �×3_���á-ǖİ˛g��iPʳ�LǠàPDJ�L�

�R�4D.D.g��i�ǣ��)&3-$M-Įȁʻ�$���}gwh-�Ɩʵ

P L3'�M/D��*4$M4ǺʴPǛ�BƖʵ-�)&K L.���.- �

�h�Ut 19� Ǻʴɱ�Ǻʴ

Page 12: MIRAI Archive - 京都大学future/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/20… · MIRAI Archive International Research Unit of Advanced Future Studies(IRU-AFS) No.2015-007 1 ª å ¬ Ý . >

MIRAI Archive � No.2015-007

12

�h�Ut 20� Ŋǚ£Ĺ 2.0

� ɱ�Ǻʴ3ë�D�K@ �h�Ut3I�0Ǎ��@ĩM,�@ �ǺʴP�0�

�M/D�Ǻʴ.ć�êǑ�ȁʻPŵL­8.�Ú,�,�@ ��30�-�*'�

�Ŋǚ£Ĺ 2.0 PýK��&�.Ž�@ �Ŋǚ£Ĺ 2.0 .I5ML­8.4�y�z

�tĮľ0/PÚ,ľǥPƜ(0�J�¶ȷ-Ì��.PFC,Ŋǚ£Ĺ10K�Ə

+�Kg��FɢAȍ0/P L3- �$M-ĞĠ-˳@),«ƨ¶P�,ʭ��3

łƆPŵL.��­8.- �$���­8.�Ħ�,�,�L3- �

�h�Ut 21� µǚȷ¶�J3˵ɱ

�h�Ut ��� �U\�i������s

� µǚȷ¶�J˵ɱ�,šȺPŵ,�L­8.03- �űij&(4½PǯC,�L�

.��.�\�h����]�.�,Ț�,���.�ƉM- �ɢAȍP�,�$M

P��`1So��,\�h�£Ĺ10K&��ʶ�Ǻʴɩ�10K&�3- �

Page 13: MIRAI Archive - 京都大学future/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/20… · MIRAI Archive International Research Unit of Advanced Future Studies(IRU-AFS) No.2015-007 1 ª å ¬ Ý . >

MIRAI Archive � No.2015-007

13

�h�Ut 23� 24� ƻǍ1DŊǚ£Ĺ 2.0 ���

� ƻǍ-D�3Ŋǚ£Ĺ 2.0 4ź8ņ),�,�@ ��Uk�g���.��D3P

ɬ�&�.4�K@"Q��èȋĂɯ0ɪȋ}�3�.Pʘ�@ ��£Ĺ3¢-4�

M1e�mP*�K���,=L3- �����Ə+�K3D31�'O),�L

.��_o_{ot1ɵÛ�˧ȧ�&�f~Pˀ",ʐCJM&�.��$M�J]�

rv�`£Ĺ��ɵÛ3=LD34ĿÓ3&C1ɵÛ-*�K&�.�������

����s�Ħ�**�K@ ��ª�ëț�c��vqT3�L��f��ȚǷ.�

,c��f��-Ʀ�,�L3�]�rv�`£Ĺ- �ţč-ýK��JM,�L.

��34��M1ÔƆ L�ŁƱ3�h��Įʇ��L�J�����ţčʊȖ10)

,�L3- �

� �U������.��Ə+�K3d�PɢQ-�),ˁ)�P*�L.���_]

^��\�-ȩ×f�o�3Ȩ��ȫ1��\�-ɜPƦ�,��g-n�P L.ɜ

ȫ�-�L�����Ə+�K�����s -1ƻǍ1D�,�@ �

�h�Ut 24

� '�J�Ǻʴ4�ˡ�¯ĝ LD3'�P

Ɵ�,�L.ȓ�,��ˡ�¯ĝ�0�,D�

°¨-DƖʵ-D*0�K-DǺʴʈë.0

K�L.���.- �

Page 14: MIRAI Archive - 京都大学future/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/20… · MIRAI Archive International Research Unit of Advanced Future Studies(IRU-AFS) No.2015-007 1 ª å ¬ Ý . >

MIRAI Archive � No.2015-007

14

�h�Ut 25

� éÌǁ³14­˨�ȥĬ�MLI�0�.

P�OM,�@�&���M�J4�ˡ�˫

ń�ML�.D�K�L3-40�-�H�

��Džų1$3³ʊ¿.�,3c�o_��

aosPɔ¯�@ ��M4�Ȭ1��®Š

4 8 dž 14 ƻ16 ƻ1ǐ¬3ě˰ŏȶģ-ʈ

0OM,ɏ 55 �­�˳@L3- �rTiv

���t3Ǥdž3��ƻ-D 27 �­�J�

03-�$3Æ�J�3­���1�Ǯ1˳@L3- �

� �3ĮU��s4ƱĈ3��m�3D.1 2,000 ­3���qTS-˓ė�M,�@

���1ţč³ȗť0/3��4�)��ÒM0�3- �I� L1ʵǍ��ˡ�

�30�1Ò)&.&Q1˓ė��@���0�0L3- ��3U��sP'��'

.Ž),�L­��k�f���^�~l�.�c��vqT.�,˓ė�,�L�J

-�L3- ��3U��s3��m�&(4 2,000 ­3���qTSP*��3-

��µǚɗėɩ�йFɚƴPÎ1�,ŴǚđPŴO"LFKƷ.4Ó�Ȥ0L��m

�fo�PȧƩ�,�@ ��ˡPƑO0�-��m�10L.���.4�#Q#Q

ß3ʵʷ03- 2�

� �ˡ�0��J�$-�L.��D3�ȖM,�,�L�ǎȅ˲ÃÐȚ4�����

lU�3��m��D�M@"Q��3I�0ȳɁ¶D�ˡ3ƪŵ�Ò)&ȱ˨1AQ

0FLǮP0��,�@)&K L3-40�-�H����3I�0ƅĎ-��M�

J4�ˡ�˫ń�MLI�0ǺʴDÚ,�L3-�ǺʴʈëPţ�Ɵ�L�°¨FƖʵ

0/3�N�N0D3DƟ�,Ɲǟð�&�.Ž),�K@ �

� �Ǽɭ�K�.����@�&�

ʑ��K�.����@�&�$M-4A0�@3>��Jʷĕ0/4�K@"Q��

Ǭ��*4U�hl��.��34�Ȼ�S��\-ÙươP�,�&.�3ćÍ0

3- �B��4U�hl���yU�ffh Easterlin hypothesis .��3��),�

$M4ÚȚȕ.Ǝŵ3˩Â-�Ȼ�U�hl���yU�ffhPƱľȪ1ʞƾ�&3

- ��$3�.ű4y~wh3>�-LJĈ10)&��3U�hl���{�t_h

4#Q#Q�Z���,�0�)&3-�4�C,ɬ�,�ùɨ10K@�&�

� U�hl��4Ȼ�S��\�JŜ),�L.�14$�.�3Š')&3- ��

$3.�1D3 ��ɼ�IJ�Q.ɘĸ�,�Ļ/D�Ț@M&.�')&.Ž�@ �

Page 15: MIRAI Archive - 京都大学future/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/20… · MIRAI Archive International Research Unit of Advanced Future Studies(IRU-AFS) No.2015-007 1 ª å ¬ Ý . >

MIRAI Archive � No.2015-007

15

&:Q$M�ű3šȺʙȀPȳɁ L�)��10)&3- ��

� ʷĕ03- ��y~wh.��34š".���.-�9*�OMOM4/Q01

�ˡ��),D�Ú �,D�š".Ɔ�L34ȒɃ'.Ž�@ �$� L.�y~

whPȳɁ L1�&),�y~wh.4�ʘ-Łɦ�&J0Q03��D� -1Ł

ɦPˇ=JM,�L�D�M@"Q�0Q03-�H��

ʌŗ�ǻ�ĕ- ��ʘ-4ʘ�0�3- ���H�4ʠ30�14ÒM,�@"

Q��ÖȝÐȚ3�ʠ3I�1Å­3š".k�f���^�~l�0/3ȷ¶3š"

�/�ɛĆ-�L������U�s'.Ž),�K@ �Å­� 1 ­'�-šȺ14

0M0��šȺ0ȷ¶30�1šȺ0ɵÛ��L.�1�4�C,>Q.�3š"PƆ

�L3-40�-�H���

Ǭ�$3.�3šȺ.��34�/�F),ʙȀ-�L3-�H��ĒľȪ.��I

�0�.-40�,�ȳɁʼnʮ.�,Ɲǟð�I�.�&.�14/3I�1 M5I

�3��y~whP��F),Łɦ L.��34�&:QOMOM�Ɔ�L�..4

ß03'.Ž�3- �

ʌŗ�ɨ�,�L34�ȷ¶1ɵÛ�/�ʰȔ�ŰɃ),�L�.��łƆ.�ȷ¶�

J/�ƓʢPþ�,�L3�.��úƷĉ3Ɔʔ�šȺƆ.�,ĭ�3­�ǯC,�L

D3-40��.Ž),�@ �����ʘ�Ʒ4˘Ü�/��4O�K@"Q��S

m��h�hAdam Smith3ȸ3ʓ��LƏ�.��ǜż��K@ �Å­�ɵÛ

3ȻàȻǣPˈǯ L.ȷ¶Ó¼�I�0L�ʰȔ�,�L.��ƅʫ��K�$M-

­8.�ʗƮ�M&ǮƜ(10)&.Ž�@ �

� ŧƊ˦ǁ³3ƻǍ­D�ɵÛ�š"10L.$M�ȷ¶Ó¼3š"1ɘ8*�I�

0U��g��)&.Ž�3- ������@3ȷ¶-ɵÛ 1 ­�šȺ10)&.�

,D�$M�ȷ¶1·ƭ�0�3-�˦ɝ��0�3-40���ȷ¶Ó¼Dš"-�

),ɵÛDš"-�L�$���ȘĥP/3I�1}g��Ȫ1*�L3��˞ʒ�.

Ž),�K@ �

� gX��i��_���tJames L. McClelland.��­�$MP˖Ɗðȷ¶.��

I�1ʘ),�@ �ɵÛ�ȷ¶30�-ŰɃ),�,�ŰɃ),�LɵÛ��L.�

��.-ɵÛDš"10ML��$���ȐƇP/3I�1*�L3�.���.�0.

Ž),�L3- �(H).�ʘ-4ȟ���1��3- ��

Ǭ�Ɲǟð L1�&K�&.�5ĿÓ.�Ǝŵ.���)��1ʙȀ L˽ȭ��

Page 16: MIRAI Archive - 京都大学future/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/20… · MIRAI Archive International Research Unit of Advanced Future Studies(IRU-AFS) No.2015-007 1 ª å ¬ Ý . >

MIRAI Archive � No.2015-007

16

L.���.- ��

ʌŗ�$�- 2�$���˽ȭ��),�ƯŦD 140 �J�˽ȭP¡=&3- �1978

Š1ƌŬÐȚ&(�ȳɁ�M&D3�Ǧ),�,�27 ˽ȭ��*0�K.�Ņƺ.�

Ǝŵ.�1ʼn Lȁʻŧ.$M�JɟĆšȺŧ.�/�Ȯ˩��L3�.���.Pʨ

=JM&3- �ɘǑ.�,4�27 3�(3 25 @-�@Kȁʻ-0��Dž˅ɘĸ�,

Ņƺ˩Â4Dž-�M5�ɟĆȪ0šȺŧD�0LI�0�.DAJML3-�šȺ

Ɔ14ɣF�0ǝˎ��0��.��ɘʩPˇ=JM,�@ �

� ǝˎ��)�K.�,�0�.Å3ʒɒPWYUs²��&ȆƱPʻ���&D3

Ps�l�0ŵȆ. LI�0Ɲǟ4*�M@"Q3-�$���@šȺŧPȀL.�

N-wo_10),�@ �Å3ʒɒ4'�&��Q0D3.��D3��L3-

��$M4­1I),˗��WYUsD*�1��- 2�

Ǭ�ʲŞ3˫ń.���D�N�ǜżPɬ�",�&'�@�&�ʵǍ.��D3�

$�.�1ʋŭ�,�LȐdz1�K@ I2�\�����_hKarl Heinrich Marx

�ä¾ÁÈ.���.P�),�ɻ Ǎ4Ħǧ L÷ȗ��L.��@�&��)�H��

$M4ȷ¶˓ë30�-4�ƫý.��.�N-Ćȗð�M,�@)&3- ��ʵǍ

.��34�01�ĵ0D3PȚAÚ æ��),ɵŚĦǧ L�.�Ƨȶ�M&�

� OMOM4ʲŞ.��.ȗſȪ14�xPʳ�ƏǨ'.Ž),�L3'�M/D��

*4ʲŞ$3D31æ��L3- �'�Jˡ�ǣ���.0L3- I2�'�

J�ƪP�,@-D�ǵǗP�&K�ˡʄȴKP L.���.��L�$���ĵ0

­˨3ÇˤȪ0ǣLjPČ���Læ��ʲŞ14!).�)&3'.Ž�@ �

� $M-4ʲŞ��M'�ʋŭ�&.�1/�0L3��Çˤ�&­˨3ǣLj4��)

&�/�0L3��$M.D­˨3ˑɱȪ0ÇˤȪ0ǣLj�0�0),�&3�.��

�.�ɨ�JM@ �

� �Q�3 ³�/�0L3���@3ɼ�­&(4�ʽ),˂ˉƏǨ.�,��ɨ�

,�0��E0�- ��OMOM3�N4�/Q017D��Ž�P�,D�)�I

�ʽ1¥K&�.��­�&��Q�@�&�$���ȹ��D3PƏ1ÒM&�.

��ǣ�!).�K@�&I2�

� �@K1D 3¢�_���10L.��),�š10L.��34�S�_f�t�

s_�T�Alexis-Charles-Henri Clérel de Tocqueville.�����h3ĬìĮɴP�

&­�S��\1ʈ),����h3ȗƄP¼Ȗ�&I�0_���0S��\-�0

Q-�M'����c���ǹʈ)&3��.ʘ�@�&�Ȼ3Ȍʕ���*,Ȩʯ£

ɦǁ³3[�hs��S1ʈ)&.�1� ��_���0Q'�M/D��Q01*

Page 17: MIRAI Archive - 京都大学future/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/20… · MIRAI Archive International Research Unit of Advanced Future Studies(IRU-AFS) No.2015-007 1 ª å ¬ Ý . >

MIRAI Archive � No.2015-007

17

@J0�ě40��.ʘ),�@�&�S_f��D01D0�.�N.ʘ),�&3

- ��$M��)��1�@/�0),�L3�.���.- I2�

� '�JÐȚ��)�E),�JMLʲŞ3˫ń.���.���)��1Ȗł10K

**�L.�1ʲŞ�Č���,�&D3��­˨3ȹ��ǣLjFÇˤȪ0ǣLj4�

/�0L3-�H���01��ƅʓP�&'�M5�

ʌŗ�ʲŞ1*�,4ɧĽĄ�Q3�ēɲʩ .��Ǎ30�1ǃ�,�L3- ��

ʲŞ4ɲ3ǡɯ$3D3-�L.ˇ=,�L3- �'�J�$M4F)6Kɲ�ĮĴ

�0Ɔ�'.Ž�3- ��ˡ3æ�Ȉ�0L�.40�,��ˡ-ʳ�0�D3.

3ǫ˞�ĪOL3'.Ž�3- �

� Ǻʴȷ¶4�ˡ�ǫʿȪ�ɯ-�ǣ��D34�ˡ-ʳ�Lȷ¶- �Ð>/3ʲŞ

3˫ń3D.10),�Lɨ�Ʒ-4�>Q.�1ǣ��D34�ˡ-ʳ�0�D3�

ĭ�0),�,�L�Džų1ȟ���&[l_3˳@K-�Lc�o_��aosD˧

Ë�I�.�&J�&:Q½ó�×D��0�,40J0�3-�H���űJ4Ń·

ʴD0�,��`3*0�K'�-�½Š½dž½ƻ1FL�.���.�ţ@),˳@

),�L�$M-ʃP˧�&J 55 �­˳@L�$MPţč¶ȷ�łƸ�I�.�&J-

�L�.��.�-�0��$����.�ʹ�),�,�L3-��ˡ-ʳ�0�D

33ÁÈ�@),�,�L3-40��0.Ž�@ ���ˡɵʼ�0�0L�.4

0�.���.- �

� šȺƝǟ3ʬʩ-DI��OML3- ����l�ȳɁǸ3­8.4GDP 1³O

LšȺƝǟ�Źʒ'�GNH Ɲǟ�Źʒ'�.�)�EL�M/D����h3Įɛ˿Ģ

čǃ-D�$3±-�@šȺƝǟPȳɁ�,�L­8.D�GNH 4 GDP 3³DŽƝǟ-

40� GDP Pʍŀ L.���L�4 GDP PIKïƚȪ1Ɵ�LƝǟ.���.-�

GDP PĊŁ�,�L3-40��GDP �0�M5�šȺƝǟ4*�M0�.Ž�3-�

@)&�ʲŞɗǽ�0�0L3-40�.Ž�@ �

Ǭ�ȻD²�ʻ�A&�0.�N-�&��Y��o|����Erich Seligmann

Fromm')&.Ž�3- ���L¨ǒPD*&C1�L��J�L&C1D*�

.ű4ǃ�,�@ I2��@3Ǻʴ3ʠ4�>.Q/D*&C1�L�.���.

PãƧ.�&ʬʩP�M,�LI�0ǮD L3- ��L&C1D*�.��>�1

��0�.Ʉ§.�$��)&ȷ¶4Ú,�0�'N�.Ž),�L3- ��/��

ɨ�- ��

ʌŗ�@�1$3ʾƨ'.Ž�@ �Well-being.���.5ɵ¼D��L&C1D*�

Page 18: MIRAI Archive - 京都大学future/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/20… · MIRAI Archive International Research Unit of Advanced Future Studies(IRU-AFS) No.2015-007 1 ª å ¬ Ý . >

MIRAI Archive � No.2015-007

18

P/�ɨ�&JI��.��ȳɁ'.Ž�@ ��3�&K�šȺȳɁP�,�LƷ3

0�-D�ʾƨ�@'�@�-�,�0�3-40��.Ž�@ �Ȼ4Ǻʴȷ¶3ɨ

�Ʒ-40��@�1�@Ǭ��)�E)&I�1 Well-being ���L�.�DžÞ1

�),�$3&C101�Źʒ-�L.��Ǻʴʩ10),��3-40��.Ž�@

Ǭ�$3ʠPɬ�,�,Ž)&3- ��šȺŧ1*�,^��z�/�3��3

���3ě4>Q.�1šȺ03�/��.��ʬʩD�K@ I2�ǿ˄¬©�Q.

��ȊǍ3­�ǃ�,�JMLǍ30�1Ǣ3I�0ʠ��K@ �ƾDzɞƶ3�N1

Ĭě­�ƻǍ1F),�&.�1�ã˅³3ǁ³1�L4!3ƻǍ­��/��,�Q

01yo~�1Ț�,�LI�1A�L3��.���.P�(�(1ǃ�,�L3-

�ƻǍ1»AȰ�&&��Q3Ĭě­�$���ʖňPǦ�,�L�ʱ��3'�M

/D�űJ4šȺ-�L.��ʜˇP�)6�Ǧ�,�L3- �

� Ȼ4ǿ˄�Q3ǃ�&ǍPʦQ-�4�C,$3I�0�.PȲK@�&��$M)

,0Q03-�H�2�Ôć¼1ƎŐ�,�,Å4$M>/Ů�0�3'.Ž�3- �

ǎʁÔć¼.�˝ś3Ôć¼4 ��Ō��,�ǰƌ4 100 �­�J�3­�»Q-�

L.�OM&3- ���&L.�N1ɠĞ��L3- ��&L.�N1ȝĜ��L�

$���Ō��c��vqT3Ó¼.�,Į�0D3��L�

� OMOM�Jɨ�&J��3ǁ³4/�ɨ�,D�š3Ĥ3I�0ǁ³')&.Ž�

3- ��˅³3ƀƁPI�Ȳ),�L4!3���o{3­˨�A,��Q01šȺ

0ě3­˨4�0��.�(�(1Ǧ�,�LJ��3- �$M),�)&�/�ɨ

�M5I�3�0.�

� �ˡ3Ǻʴ3ĕ.4˗�ƅĎ3šȺƆ�$M4�).ã˅³-����o{'),

$���ǁ³��).�),�$MP���o{4Ƒƛ�,�L3- I2�ƻǍDƑ

ƛ"�LP�0�0),�Ƒƛ�,�L3- ��M4¢ 10L3�/��4O�J

0�3- ��˅³.��D3�ʹ�LD).ã3ǁ³�D�M@"Q�$3.�3­

˨�Ó¼.�,D),�LšȺƆ.Ȗ³3�ˡPġȂ1�&šȺƆ.3��'14 �

�ř��L.��Ɔ���&3- �$3ġȂ4/�Ơ@�M5I�3�.�

ʌŗ�ã˅³�Ǎů1šȺ')&3�/��.��34�ȻDʡ��0�3- ��&

:QĬ�JAL.šȺ1A�,�@�3'.Ž�@ ���1Ú,�L34e�gX_

qT��WX�}�U�`.��$3­�ɵŚȟč�&£ʖȪšȺƆ03- ��Ĭ�

J$���Nj˧0ƳƾPA&.�14/�DšȺ$�1A�L�

� ��l��šȺ'.��3D�$M1(��D3��K@ �Ȼ4 1990 Š1��l�

Page 19: MIRAI Archive - 京都大学future/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/20… · MIRAI Archive International Research Unit of Advanced Future Studies(IRU-AFS) No.2015-007 1 ª å ¬ Ý . >

MIRAI Archive � No.2015-007

19

1ʈ�@�&��$Q01šȺ$�14A�0�)&- ��)��1�@��l�-

šȺŧʨǕP L.�Ƞijř-ijſ3>��šȺŧ4º�.��˝ś.˃ǎ-4šȺŧ

3ř��K@ �òƔ�ə�1ô3œŖě3­PA&J�°¨D0�,3Q8K�,I

�0�.A�&.���.�Į��3-40�-�H���

ʑ��M-ɕOJ",�&'�@ ��K�.����@�&�