micro finance in assam debabrata-das
TRANSCRIPT
10 August 20101
Microfinance in Assam:
An Overview
Presented by:
Dr. Debabrata Das
Associate Professor
Tezpur University
Tezpur: Assam.
10 August 2010 2
• The objectives of the study are:
– To know the current status of the MF in
Assam.
– To study the informal micro finance
practices existing in the State.
10 August 2010 3
Research questions
• What are the microfinance providers working in Assam?
• What are the different practices and business models of
MFIs working in Assam?
• What are the other informal microfinance providers and
practices existing in the state?
10 August 20104
Data collection
Type of
institution
Name of
district
List of MFIs
Formal
microfinance
institutions
Dibrugarh • Community Health for Advanced Initiative
• North East Region Finservices Ltd
Kamrup
(Metro)
• ASOMI finance Pvt Ltd
• RGVN-CSP
• Prochesta
• Nightingale Charitable Society
Informal
microfinance
providers
Kamrup
(Rural)
• Gyandeep Pvt Society
• Ashirbad Fin Society
Nalbari • Grayma Khudra Sanchay Aachani
• Ashadeep Saving
Baksha • Jivan Bikash Sanchay Aachani
• Jananshree Khudrra Sanchay Aachani
• Family Mission Saving
Data collected from four districts of Assam
10 August 2010 5
Research Methodology
• Structured schedule
• Personal interview/discussion
• Data:– Information about the location, branches, and total staff of the
MFIs.
– Financial data about the MFIs (in last 5 years) :
– Loan portfolio size
– Total disbursement
– Number of beneficiaries
– Interest rate and Tenure of loan
– Repayment period and Repayment percentage
10 August 2010 6
Data• Activities of the MFIs
• Data about the lending model of the MFIs.
• Various products and level of micro lending.
• Loan structure and process
• MF plus activities
• Business model of the MFIs.
10 August 20107
Microfinance
Provirs
in Assam
Formal Informal
Private
Societies
Village
Societies/
Namghar
Committee /
Bathow
Village
Head/
Landlord
Goot/
Mutual
Group
Banks NFI MFIs SGSY
Commercial
banks
Co-oprative
Bank
RRBs
NABARD
SIDBI
NEDFi
NGO
NBFC
Microfinance
Providers of Assam
Village
Societies/
Namghar
Committee /
Bathow
Banking network in Assam
– 741 branches of
Commercial Banks
– 343 branches of AGVB,
– 42 branches of LDRB and
– 39 branches of
Cooperative Banks (Source: State Level Bankers’ Committee,
Assam, March 2010 )
Total loan disbursed
during the year 2009-
10 in Assam
Cumulative position
as on 31st
March 2010
Name of the Bank Amount
*
No. of
SHGs
Amount
*
No. of
SHGs
RRBs
Assam Gramin Vikash
Bank 5797.01 12253 25811 83665
Langpi Dehangi Rural
Bank 801.22 1164 2725.05 5449
Co-operative Banks
State Cooperative
Bank 1531.38 1256 5094.25 9741
Commercial Banks 10334.9 10,914 49971.03 65000
GR. TOTAL 18464.5 29583 83601.33 163855
* In lakhs
Data about microfinance disbursed by financial
institutions in Assam
10 August 2010 9
List of Microfinance organizations in
Assam
Sl. no. Name Legal form Lending model
1 Assam Gandhi Smarak Nidhi, Kamrup Society Individual
2 Associated Gramya Unnayan Society, Sivasagar Society
Individual
member
3 ASTHA, Sonitpur Society SHG
4
Centre for Development Action and Appropriate
Technology (CADAT), Sonitpur Society SHG member
5 Chaiduar Rural Development Centre, Sonitpur Society Individual
6 Dainijan Gaon Mahila Society Society Mixed
7 Deshabandhu Club Behara Bazar, Cachar Society SHGs
8 Gana Chetana Samaj Balipara, Sonitpur Society MFI-Federation
9 GRAMIN, Biswanath Chariali, Sonitpur
Society
MFI
10 August 2010 10
Sl. no. Name Legal form Lending model
10
Jyoti Puthibharal and Yuvak Sangha,
Sonitpur Society MFI-SHG member
11 Manab Seba Sangh, Kamrup Society SHG
12
North East Regional Human
Resource Dev. Society
(NERHURDS), Kamrup Society Mixed
13 PROCESTS, Guwahati Society SHG
14 RGVN, Guwahati
Society transforming
to NBFC others
15 Singkhap Mahila Samity ,Sivasagar Society SHG
16
Sipajhar Diamond Club Community
Centre, Darrang Society MFI-NGO-SHG
17
Social Action for Appropriate and
advancement in Rural Areas (
SATRA), Darrang Society Bank-NGO-SHG
10 August 2010 11
Name Legal form Lending model
18
The North East Centre for All Round
Development (CARD), Darrang Society MFI-SHG member
19
Tinsukia Gaon Tribal Mahila
Samittee Society Mixed
20 CHAI, Dibrugarh Project MFI
21 North east Finservices ltd NBFC MFI
22 Nightangle Charitable Society NGO JLG
23 Asomi Fin PVT Ltd MFI SHG, JLG, Individual
10 August 2010 12
Comparative profile of the MFIs
MFIs Number of
branches
Total staff Total number
of
beneficiaries
RGVN-CSP 78 467 29,309 groups
NEDFi Offices in 8
states of NE
79 83367 (10177
groups
ASOMI Finance
Pvt ltd
50 196 37,439 (2897
SHGs
PROCHESTA 6 48 2897 groups
NCS 4 13 9526
NERFS 72 500 49,475
CHAI 1 11 400
10 August 2010 13
Continued…
MFIs Fund providers
RGVN-CSP FWWB, Opportunity International, IDBI, NABARD, SIDBI,
NEDFI, HDFC and ICICI
ASOMI
Finance Pvt ltd
Loan from Nationalised banks and Iincofin of Belgium
NEDFi IDBI, ICICI ,IFCI, Small Industries Development Bank of
India, Insurance Companies – LIC, GI, UTI bank and SBI
PROCHESTA Loans from Nationalised banks, NABARD, AGVN, SIDBI,
Gyan Vigyan Samiti Assam, State Resourse Centre
Assam, Jan hikshan Sansthan, FWWB, IIBM
NCS Nationalised banks, NEDFI, RGVN, SIDBI
NERFSPL Nationalised banks, NEDFI, RGVN, SIDBI
CHAI All India tea association, Tazo Tea, Mercy corps
*Informal institutions collect money from the depositors and disbursed the
same to the creditors
10 August 201014
Financial portfolio of the MFIsMFIs Loan
portfolio [In
Rs] as on
June 2010
Interest rate of Loan Tenure for
loan
Repayment
schedule
RGVN-CSP 56.42 crore 10% and 7 % 1 year Weekly and
monthly
ASOMI Finance
Pvt ltd
45.82 crore 15 % (per annum) 1 year Weekly
NEDFi 25.27 crore# PLR+0.5% 1-5 years Monthly
PROCHESTA 23.269 crore 18 % (per annum) 1-7 years Monthly
NCS 4.73 crore 13% (per annum) 1 year Monthly
NERFS 103 crore* 30 % (per annum) 1 year Flexible
CHAI3.010 crore
7.5 % (per annum) 1 year Fortnightly
and
monthly
*As on 31st September 2009, # as on 31st December 2009
Repayment percentage: 97 – 99 %
10 August 2010 15
Products of some of the MFIs
RGVN-CSP CHAI PROCHESTA NCS
•SHG preliminary-Rs 500
– Rs 2,000
•SHG – Rs 4,000- Rs
20,000
•JLG- Rs 3,000-Rs
30,000
•Microenterprise
Development- Rs 25,000
– Rs 50,000
•EDP – Rs 16,000- Rs
14,000
•EPM – sponsored
•Individual
enterprise loan – Rs
20,000- Rs 50,000
•Joint liability loan –
Rs 5,000- Rs 50,000
•SGH loan – Rs
1,000 – 10,000
• SHG loan
• Individual loan
•The three loan
levels are:
Rs. 1,000 – Rs.
10,000
Rs 5,000 –Rs.
15,000
Rs. 10,000 –
Rs. 20,000
• JLG
•Rs.3,000-
25,000
10 August 2010 16
Microfinance Plus activities
Asomi
Fin.(Pvt)Ltd
Accident policy from United India, and
health insurance with APOLLO MUNICH
Health Insurance Company.
PROCHESTA Housing Finance for rural women.
CHAI Emergency medical help, vocational training
and scholarships to school dropouts.
Business development service centre.
RGVN –CSP Employment Generation Mission and
Insurance Cover.
NEDFi 3 Workshop cum Training Programs
10 August 2010 17
Informal microfinance providers
Saving society Amount
require to
open an a/c
Deposit limit Interest
on
deposit
Loan
against
deposit
Interest
on loan
Janashree Khudrrs
Sanchay Aachani
Rs. 10 Rs. 5 (min)
Rs. 200 (max)
per day
12 % per
annum
90 % 3 % per
month
Jivan Bikash
Sanchay Aachani
Rs. 10 Rs. 100 (min)
Rs. 200 (max)
Per month
12% p.a. 80 % 3 % per
month
Gyandeep Pvt
Sociey
Rs.10 Rs. 50 (min)
Per week
12 % per
annum
80 % 3 % per
month
Ashirbad Fin
Society
Rs.10 Rs. 50 (min)
Per week
12 % per
annum
80 % 4 % per
month
Ashadeep Saving Rs. 10 Rs.50 (min)
Per month
12 % per
annum
80 % 3 % per
month
Family Mission
Saving
Rs.10 Rs. 5 (min)
Per day
12 % per
annum
100 % 3 % per
month
Grayma Khudra
Sanchay Aachani
Rs.10 Rs. 50 (min)
Per month
24 % per
annum
90 % 4 % per
month
10 August 201018
Key findings• Micro finance industry in the State is in initial growth
phase. Microfinance is witnessing a faster growth in the state which is reflected in the increasing number of microfinance providers and quantum of finance provided.
• There are different types of microfinance providers in Assam. Many National level MFIs are emerging in the scene recently (Bandhan, ASHA, etc).
• Major role is played by the banks. The role of RRBs is very prominent in financing SHGs in relative terms.
• A few local MFIs have stepped strongly in the sector.
10 August 2010 19
Continued…
• Informal microfinance practices are very strong and active in lower part of Assam.
• Most of the informal microfinance providers are not having any legal status (except one which was registered as NGO)
• The interest rate charged by informal microfinance providers is very high. It ranges from 36 – 48 % per annum whereas in case of formal MFIs it ranges 7.5 % to 30 % per annum.
• Availability of credit is given preference over the cost of credit by the borrowers.
Continued…
• Demand for micro credit is very high and a wide gap of demand-supply is observed specially in the rural areas.
• Most of the MFIs are deviated from the social mission to commercial goal.
• Unethical competition led to multiple lending.
Concerns of MFIs
• Legal hassles specially in renewal of registration
• Problem in fundraising
• Market distortion by SGSY
10 August 2010 22
Issues while carrying out research
• Weak MIS of the microfinance providers.
It is difficult to get data in proper format.
• MFIs are reluctant to share information.
10 August 2010 23
Future research questions
• Possibility of making credit available to
small borrowers at a lower cost.
• Issues to deal with the problem of multiple
lending.
10 August 2010 24
THANK YOU