methanol as low cost alternative fuel for emission ... · methanol as low cost alternative fuel for...

74
1 The Israel Electric Corp. The Israel Electric Corp. Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers IEC and Dor Chemicals Jan 13 th , 2013 Weizman Institute of Science, Rehovot, Israel

Upload: lamxuyen

Post on 12-Jun-2018

225 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

1

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers

IEC and Dor Chemicals

Jan 13th , 2013 Weizman Institute of Science, Rehovot,

Israel

Page 2: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

2

Accounting &EconomicsDivision

Accounting &EconomicsDivision

FinancingDivision

FinancingDivision

Supply & storageDivision

Supply & storageDivisionBusiness

Development

BusinessDevelopment

NorthernNorthern

SeniorVice PresidentGeneration & Transmission

SeniorVice PresidentGeneration & Transmission

SeniorVice PresidentEngineeringProjects

SeniorVice PresidentEngineeringProjects

SeniorVice President

Strategic Resources

SeniorVice President

Strategic Resources

SeniorVice PresidentMarketing & Customer Rel

SeniorVice PresidentMarketing & Customer Rel

SeniorVice PresidentOrganization& Logistics

SeniorVice PresidentOrganization& Logistics

SeniorVice PresidentFinance &Economics

SeniorVice PresidentFinance &Economics

GenerationDivision

GenerationDivision

EngineeringDivision

EngineeringDivision

MarketingDivision

MarketingDivision

Logistics &Real EstateDivision

Logistics &Real EstateDivision

DistrictsDistricts

Transmission& Distribution

Division

Transmission& Distribution

Division

ConstructionDivision

ConstructionDivision

Quality &Systems Eng.Division

Quality &Systems Eng.Division

HumanResourcesDivision

HumanResourcesDivision

Planning, Development & Technology

Division

Planning, Development & Technology

Division

SouthernSouthern

DanDan

JerusalemJerusalem

HaifaHaifaInformation

Systems/Comm.

Division

Information Systems/Comm.

Division

C E OC E OC E O

The Israel Electric Corp. The Israel Electric Corp. –– Organization ChartOrganization Chart

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

Page 3: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

3

IECIEC’’ss Engineering Project Group OrganizationEngineering Project Group Organization

AdministrationAdministration

Public RelationPublic Relation

Legal AdvisorLegal Advisor

BusinessDevelopment

BusinessDevelopment

MechanicalEngineering

MechanicalEngineering

Sub-StationEngineering

Sub-StationEngineering

ProjectsManagement

ProjectsManagement

CivilEngineering

CivilEngineering

Electrical &Controls

Engineering

Electrical &Controls

Engineering

Cost EngineeringCost Engineering

Computerized Sys.Computerized Sys.

Technical ServicesTechnical Services

Budget ControlBudget Control

Legal AdvisorLegal Advisor

AdministrationAdministration

MechanicalConstruction

MechanicalConstruction

Tenders andContracts

Tenders andContracts

ProjectsProjects

CivilConstruction

CivilConstruction

ElectricalConstruction

ElectricalConstruction

AdministrationAdministration

Budget ControlBudget Control

Legal AdvisorLegal Advisor

Human ResourcesHuman Resources

Construction Division

Construction Construction

DivisionDivisionEngineering Division

Engineering Engineering

DivisionDivision

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

Engineering Pr0jects GroupEngineering Pr0jects GroupEngineering Pr0jects Group

Page 4: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

4

The Israel Electric Corp. Power PlantsThe Israel Electric Corp. Power Plants

Orot Rabin

2X575

4X360Rutenberg

2X575

2X550

HaifaHaifa

22XX141141

ReadingReading

22XX214214EshkolEshkol

44XX228228 1+ X370

Alon Tavor

1X370

Gezer

2X370

Tzafit

1X370

Hagit

1X370+2X350

Ramat Hovav

1X340

Coal Fired Coal Fired

Oil/Gas FiredOil/Gas Fired

Oil FiredOil Fired

Combined CyclesCombined Cycles

Gas Turbine 2,540 MwGas Turbine 2,540 Mw

Total Installed power: Total Installed power:

~13000 Mw~13000 MwThe I

sra

el

The I

sra

el E

lectr

cE

lectr

cC

orp

.

C

orp

.

2X370

2X630*

* Projects under execution

Page 5: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

5

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. The Israel Electric Corp. The Israel Electric Corp. –– Fuel Burned Fuel Burned

••Bituminous coal Bituminous coal –– very wide range of properties very wide range of properties

••SubSub--bituminous coal bituminous coal –– Low SulfurLow Sulfur

••Heavy Fuel Oil#6Heavy Fuel Oil#6

••Light fuel Oil#2Light fuel Oil#2

••Natural GasNatural Gas

••MethanolMethanol

•• Preparation for Biomass (Preparation for Biomass (BiocoalBiocoal) and Coal co) and Coal co--firingfiring

••Preparation for Coal and Sewage coPreparation for Coal and Sewage co--firingfiring

••Oil ShaleOil Shale

Page 6: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

6

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. The Israel Electric Corp. The Israel Electric Corp. –– Emission Reduction activity Emission Reduction activity

••Low Low NOxNOx Firing System Implementation Firing System Implementation

••Post Combustion Treatment:Post Combustion Treatment:

••SCR installation for SCR installation for NOxNOx ReductionReduction

••FGD installation for SOFGD installation for SO2 2 ReductionReduction

••ESP for ash reductionESP for ash reduction

Page 7: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

7

OutlineOutlineT

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

––E

ngin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Engin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Methanol Fuel properties

• Chemical Formula CH3OH

• Molecular weight 32.04

• Flash point 12 C (to 41 C)

• Auto ignition temperature 464 C

• Combustion (Adiabatic) temperature 2045 C

• Low heating value 4777 kcal/kg

• Density 793 kg/ M3 at 30 C

Page 8: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

8

OverviewOverviewT

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

• Methanol is an attractive future fuel for utility boilers and gas turbine engines.

Methanol can achieve:1. Lower NOx emissions due to the lower flame

temperature and no FBN.

2. Since methanol has no sulfur there are no SO2 emissions.

3. The clean burning characteristics of methanol are expected to lead to clean heat surfaces and lower maintenance than with HFO or even with LFO.

4. Relative to NG and FO , methanol can achieve higher power output due to higher mass flow in GT engines.

Page 9: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

9

Mechanism of Mechanism of NOxNOx Emission FormationEmission Formation

There are three known mechanism of NOx formation

- Thermal NOx

- Fuel NOx

- Prompt NOx

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

Page 10: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

10

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

NOxNOx formation mechanismformation mechanism

Page 11: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

11

Combustion temperature of blend of Combustion temperature of blend of

methanol and HFOmethanol and HFOT

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

Combustion temperature of blend of methanol and HFO

vs metanol heat fraction

2020

2040

2060

2080

2100

2120

2140

2160

2180

2200

2220

2240

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100

Methanol heat fraction, %

Ble

nd

co

mb

usti

on

tem

pera

ture

,C

Page 12: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

12

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

Methanol and HFO Co-Firing At Large Utility Boiler of 140 Mw

Unit

Page 13: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

13

Haifa Power Plant SiteHaifa Power Plant SiteT

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

––E

ngin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Engin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Page 14: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

14

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

––E

ngin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Engin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Steam Generator of Haifa C Steam Generator of Haifa C –– General viewGeneral view

140 Mw unit140 Mw unit

Page 15: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

15

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

––E

ngin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Engin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Primary measures implementationPrimary measures implementation

Furnace Furnace crossectioncrossection

Page 16: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

16

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

––E

ngin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Engin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Primary measures implementationPrimary measures implementation

Burner Burner –– General viewGeneral view

Page 17: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

17

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

––E

ngin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Engin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Primary measures implementationPrimary measures implementation

Burner Burner –– DesignDesign

Page 18: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

18

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

––E

ngin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Engin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Primary measures implementationPrimary measures implementation

HFO Atomizer HFO Atomizer –– General viewGeneral view

Page 19: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

19

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

––E

ngin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Engin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Primary measures implementationPrimary measures implementation

HFO Atomizer HFO Atomizer –– General viewGeneral view

Page 20: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

20

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

––E

ngin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Engin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Upgrading for Methanol Firing Upgrading for Methanol Firing

Methanol Atomizer Methanol Atomizer –– General viewGeneral view

Page 21: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

21

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

––E

ngin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Engin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Upgrading for Methanol Firing Upgrading for Methanol Firing

Key DiagramKey Diagram

Page 22: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

22

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. Methanol Storage TankMethanol Storage Tank

Page 23: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

23

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. Methanol supply displayMethanol supply display

Page 24: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

24

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

NOxNOx reduction tests resultsreduction tests results

Unit#3 Haifa PS BoilerUnit#3 Haifa PS Boiler

Page 25: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

25

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

NOxNOx reduction tests resultsreduction tests results

DOR Chemicals boiler (Capacity 10 DOR Chemicals boiler (Capacity 10 t/ht/h))

Page 26: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

26

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. Particulates reduction tests resultsParticulates reduction tests results

Unit#3 Haifa PS BoilerUnit#3 Haifa PS Boiler

Page 27: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

27

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. SO2 reduction tests resultsSO2 reduction tests results

Unit#3 Haifa PS BoilerUnit#3 Haifa PS Boiler

Page 28: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

28

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. Other emission reduction tests resultsOther emission reduction tests results

Unit#3 Haifa PS BoilerUnit#3 Haifa PS Boiler

CO emission CO emission -- ““00””

FormaldehydeFormaldehyde -- ““00””

Page 29: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

29

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. Comparison of furnace heat absorption for HFO Comparison of furnace heat absorption for HFO

and HFOand HFO--metanolmetanol coco--firingfiring

Page 30: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

30

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. Secondary Secondary SuperheaterSuperheater metal temperature metal temperature

(90MW)(90MW)

Page 31: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

31

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. ReheaterReheater metal temperature (90MW)metal temperature (90MW)

Page 32: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

32

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. Primary Primary superheatersuperheater metal temperature (90MW)metal temperature (90MW)

Page 33: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

33

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. HFOHFO--Methanol CoMethanol Co--Firing TestFiring Test

ResultsResults

4606903870NegligibleNegligible33038090

4106903760NegligibleNegligible30037070

3506902547NegligibleNegligible27034550

HFO-Met

Co-FiringHFO

HFO-Met

Co-FiringHFO

HFO-Met

Co-FiringHFO

HFO-Met

Co-FiringHFO

SO2, mg/dNm3@15%Particulates

mg/dNm3@15%

CO,

mg/dNm3@15%

NOx, mg/dNm3@15%

Unit Load,

Mw

Page 34: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

34

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

Methanol Firing at FT4C TWIN PAC 50 MWe GT Unit

Page 35: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

35

Caesarea Power Plant SiteCaesarea Power Plant SiteT

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

––E

ngin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Engin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Tested unit

Page 36: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

36

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. TP TP --1 Base Plate Assembly1 Base Plate Assembly

Page 37: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

37

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

––E

ngin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Engin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

FT4 FT4 –– Engine & Power TurbineEngine & Power Turbine

Page 38: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

38

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

––E

ngin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Engin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

LinerLiner–– General viewGeneral view

Page 39: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

39

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

––E

ngin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Engin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

LinerLiner–– General viewGeneral view

Page 40: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

40

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

––E

ngin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Engin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

LinerLiner–– General viewGeneral view

Page 41: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

41

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

––E

ngin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Engin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

NozzleNozzle–– General viewGeneral view

Page 42: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

42

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

––E

ngin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Engin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

FO Atomizer AssemblyFO Atomizer Assembly–– General viewGeneral view

Page 43: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

43

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

––E

ngin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Engin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

FO Atomizer FO Atomizer –– General viewGeneral view

Page 44: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

44

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

––E

ngin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Engin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

FO Supply SchemeFO Supply Scheme

Page 45: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

45

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

Flame temperture distribution through liner length

1400

1450

1500

1550

1600

1650

1700

1750

1800

1850

1900

1950

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26

Calculation zone number

Tem

pera

ture

, C

Fuel oil#2

Methanol

Calculated Flame Temperature DistributionCalculated Flame Temperature Distribution

100% Load100% Load

Page 46: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

46

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. Calculated Liner Wall Temperature DistributionCalculated Liner Wall Temperature Distribution

100% Load100% Load

Relative liner wall metal temperature reduction during

methanol burning

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26

Calculation zone number

Meta

no

l to

FO

#2 w

all

meta

l

tem

pera

ture

rati

o

Page 47: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

47

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

Comparison of Comparison of NOxNOx Formation Through Liner Formation Through Liner

Length for FO#2 and Methanol FiringLength for FO#2 and Methanol Firing

100% Load100% Load

NOx emission formation through liner length

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26

Calculation zone number

NO

x,m

g/d

Nm

3 @

15%

O2

,

Fuel oil#2, calculated

Methanol, calculated

Fuel oil#2, measured

Log. (Fuel oil#2, calculated)

Log. (Methanol, calculated)

Page 48: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

48

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

––E

ngin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Engin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Upgrading for Methanol Firing Upgrading for Methanol Firing

Key DiagramKey Diagram

Page 49: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

49

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. Methanol TestMethanol Test

Methanol tankMethanol tank

Page 50: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

50

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. Methanol TestMethanol Test

piping connectionpiping connection

Page 51: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

51

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. Methanol TestMethanol Test

Control Room DisplayControl Room Display

Page 52: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

52

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. Methanol TestMethanol Test

Emission measurements Emission measurements

instruments general viewinstruments general view

Page 53: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

53

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

Average TT7 as function of GT load

Tamb=22-24C

800825850875900925950975

100010251050107511001125115011751200

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

GT load, Mw

TT

7, F

Oil#2 Methanol Power (Oil#2) Linear (Methanol)

Methanol TestMethanol Test

ResultsResults

Page 54: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

54

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. Methanol TestMethanol Test

ResultsResults

Page 55: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

55

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. Methanol TestMethanol Test

ResultsResults

Page 56: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

56

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. Methanol TestMethanol Test

ResultsResults

Page 57: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

57

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. Methanol TestMethanol Test

ResultsResults

Page 58: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

58

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. Methanol TestMethanol Test

ResultsResults

Page 59: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

59

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. Methanol TestMethanol Test

ResultsResults

Page 60: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

60

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. Methanol TestMethanol Test

ResultsResults

Page 61: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

61

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. Methanol TestMethanol Test

ResultsResults

Formaldehyde as function of GT load

0

5

10

15

20

25

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

GT load, Mw

Fo

rma

lde

hy

de

,

mg

/dN

m3

@1

5%

O2

Methanol

Formaldehyde Limit

Page 62: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

62

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. Methanol TestMethanol Test

ResultsResults

5036.37132.0224.09.0

01.56306.756.510.0

0501.3613.78164.463.464.5269.013.6

0501.2813.28107.443.971.2296.916.0

5012.5923.0372.722.5

MetLFO#2MetLFO#2MetLFO#2MetLFO#2

SO2,

mg/dNm3@15%

Particulates

mg/dNm3@15%

CO,

mg/dNm3@15%

NOx,

mg/dNm3@15%GT Load,

Mw

Page 63: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

63

NEXT PHASE

• RESTORE CAPACITY• We need to double the fuel flow• We need to open the bottle necks:

– High Pressure Pumps (replaced by external pumps)

– Modulating valve (replaced by VSD)

– Pressure & Dump valves (internal strainer replaced)

– Spraying nozzles (replaced from Excello nozzles to Delevan)

• Two phase Test (In Eilat)– Run a short term test to check feasibility of such a system and validate

perfomance & low emissions

(2-3 weeks)

– Run a long term test to gain operational experience and confidence in the system

(2-3 years, 1500-2000 hrs each year)

Page 64: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

64

Fuel oil

Methanol

Filters

By others

ps

i

ps

i

Fuel SOVs

(shut-off valves)

gpm

gpm

75 HP

VSD

Engine

80 gpm

pump

40 gpm

pump

Control House

Mixing Block

30 HP

VSD

PEPCO Fuel Control Proposal for

dual Methanol system (one skid)

1.5” SS pipe

1.25” SS pipeInlet piping

both fuels 3”

400V 50Hz

~75KVA

Control Air 250-

110 psi

Motor power

wire from VSDControl wires:

2 digital outputs

2 analog inputs

2 analog outputs

PEPCO

Fuel Control

Control wires:2 digital outputs

6 digital inputs

5 analog inputs

Restoring Capcity – fuel control & external pumps

Page 65: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

65

Eilat test – restoring capicity

•Replacing nozzles to Delevan high flow

Page 66: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

66

Adding external

high perssure pumps

Page 67: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

67

Adapting fuel unloading and

storage sytem

• New unloading piping

• Tank adaptation – floating roof

Page 68: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

68

Adapting fire fighting system

Page 69: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

69

Fuel unlouding platform

Page 70: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

70

Danger zone analysis

Page 71: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

71

Time Schedule

Page 72: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

72

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

––E

ngin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Engin

eerin

g D

ivis

ion

Long Term Methanol Firing Long Term Methanol Firing

Modification in Modification in EilatEilat

The IEC in cooperation with Dor Chemicals are in advanced stage of the project converting FT4C TWIN PAC 50 MWe GT Unit in Eilat to mehanol firing.

The target is to collect long term data of operating the GT on methanol, which is scheduled to start later this year.

Page 73: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

73

July 2008

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.

Summary Summary

The results presented here clearly show that with minor lowThe results presented here clearly show that with minor low

cost fuel system retrofit methanol firing leads to significantcost fuel system retrofit methanol firing leads to significant

NOxNOx, , SO2SO2 and and particulatesparticulates emission reduction while similaremission reduction while similar

facilities performance characteristics are preserved. facilities performance characteristics are preserved.

We believe that the conclusions of the present work are general We believe that the conclusions of the present work are general and canand can

be applied to other boilers and gas turbines as well. be applied to other boilers and gas turbines as well.

Page 74: Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission ... · Methanol As Low Cost Alternative Fuel For Emission Reduction In Gas Turbines and Utilities Boilers ... boilers and gas turbine

74

The I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

. T

he I

sra

el E

lectr

ic C

orp

.