media tenor global tv award
DESCRIPTION
Media Tenor Global TV AwardTRANSCRIPT
2
MEDIA TENOR
Global TV
Award
Basis: 256,570 reports
in 29 international TV News programs 07/2009 –06/2010
Same companies continue to dominate news
Criterion 5
Diversity of reporting on companies
Basis: 256,570 reports in 29 international TV News programs, 01/07/2009 – 30/06/2010. Only top ten shown
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14
FOX Special Report
CCTV
RTL Aktuell
ARD Tagesthemen
ZDF heute journal
ABC World News Tonight
BBC World Service
TVE1 Telediario 2
TF1 Le Journal
SF Tagesschau
Number of companies receiving more than 20 reports
Turkish TV news dedicated to reporting on education
Criterion 11
Agenda-cutting in education coverage
Basis: 256,570 reports in 29 international TV News programs, 01/07/2009 – 30/06/2010. Only top ten shown
0.0% 0.5% 1.0% 1.5% 2.0% 2.5% 3.0%
ZDF heute journal
NBC Nightly News
BBC1 Ten o' Clock News
CCTV
BBC 2 Newsnight
SABC Afrikaans News
SABC English News
SABC Zulu/Xhosa News
TF1 Le Journal
TRT1 Ana Haber Bülteni
Percentage of coverage focused on education issues
TF1 Le Journal further strengthens environment focus
Criterion 12
Agenda-cutting in environment coverage
Basis: 256,570 reports in 29 international TV News programs, 01/07/2009 – 30/06/2010. Only top ten shown
0% 1% 2% 3% 4% 5% 6% 7% 8%
TVE1 Telediario 2
BBC 2 Newsnight
CCTV
CNN International Desk
SF Tagesschau
RTL Aktuell
ABC World News Tonight
CBS Evening News
NBC Nightly News
TF1 Le Journal
Percentage of coverage focused on environment issues
MEDIA TENOR
Global Media
Peace Award
Basis: 197,649 reports
in 37 international TV News programs 2008-2009
Level of coverage on Instability issues: 2008/2009
Good balance of instability issues critical
Basis: 197,649 international coverage reports in 37 international TV News programs
27%27%27%28%28%29%30%32%32%32%32%35%37%37%38%39%40%41%41%
0% 50% 100%
SABC SothoDubai TV
SABC EnglishNile News
TRT Ana Haber BülteniAl Arabiya
TF1 Le JournalRAI TG1
LBCTVE1 Telediario 2
SAT.1 18:30ARD Tagesthemen
RTL AktuellBBC World ServiceZDF Heute Journal
ZDF HeuteARD TagesschauBBC2 Newsnight
Al Jazeera
Other issues Instability issues
4%
7%
11%
18%
19%
48%
51%
53%
55%
55%
0% 50% 100%
SABC Africa News…
SABC News @ 10
SABC News @ One
SABC Zulu/Xhosa
CCTV-1 News Hour
…
NBC Nightly News
ABC World News
ITV News at Ten
FOX Special Report
CBS Evening News
Other issues Instability issues
Closest to target Most extreme
over/under reporting
Target
33%
Global Peace Index Award
Diversity of coverage on conflict issues: 2008/2009
Can diverse instability coverage lessen stereotyping?
0% 10% 20% 30%
SABC Zulu/Xhosa NewsSABC News @ One
SABC Venda/Tsonga…SABC English News
SABC Sotho NewsTRT Ana Haber Bülteni
Dubai TVeNews Prime Time
BBC2 NewsnightNile NewsAl Manar
RTL AktuellSF Tagesschau
ARD TagesschauNBC Nightly NewsARD Tagesthemen
LBC TVZDF Heute Journal
ZDF HeuteFOX Special Report
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30%
CBS Evening News
ABC World News Tonight
Al Arabiyah
Al Jazeera
BBC World Service
BBC Ten o' Clock News
TF1 Le Journal
RAI TG1
ITV News at Ten
TVE1 Telediario 2
Top 10 11-30
Al Arabiya
Global Peace Index Award
Basis: 197,649 international coverage reports in 37 international TV News programs
Share of all reports
10
And the overall winners…
Number of reports
Global Peace Index Award
Overall Ranking
Overall score
Basis: 197,649 international coverage reports in 37 international TV News programs
MEDIA TENOR
Agenda Setter of the Decade
2001-2010
Agenda Setter Award: Nominated Media
Die Welt
FAZ
Süddeutsche Zeitung
Frankfurter Rundschau
Bild-Zeitung
Berliner Zeitung
Tagesspiegel
Leipziger Volkszeitung
Spiegel
Focus
Stern
Die Zeit
FAS
Welt am Sonntag
Bild am Sonntag
ZDF (all programs)
ARD (all programs)
Deutschlandradio / Deutschlandfunk
Handelsblatt
FTD
Wirtschaftswoche
Wall Street Journal
Financial Times
New York Times
Washington Post
Criterion 1: Volume of quotations
Bild eclipses all other dailies
Basis: 68,030 quotations in 14 German print and television media
Number of quotations
Agenda Setter of the Decade
Criterion 2: Volume of quotations in the political section
Spiegel attracted most attention in political sections
number of quotations
Basis: 68,030 quotations in 14 German print and television media
Number of quotations
Agenda Setter of the Decade
Criterion 3: Volume of quotations in the business section
Bild is strong in the economy section as well
number of quotations
Basis: 68,030 quotations in 14 German print and television media
Number of quotations
Agenda Setter of the Decade
Criterion 5: Frequency of quotations on the front page
Spiegel quotations placed most prominently
Basis: 68,030 quotations in 14 German print and television media
Number of quotations
Agenda Setter of the Decade
Overall Ranking: Average Score
Bild leaves other national dailies far behind
Overall score (highest possible score=1.000)
Basis: 68,030 quotations in 14 German print and television media
Agenda Setter of the Decade
20
MEDIA TENOR
Country Award
Middle East & North Africa
MENA
Basis: 8,105 reports in 25 leading international media 06/2009 – 06/2010
The Nominees
Egypt
Israel
Jordan
Qatar
Bahrain
Saudi Arabia
United Arab Emirates
These countries achieved a volume over 48 articles in non-Arab media for the period
with a balanced rating above -30%
MENA Communicator Award
Nominees
MENA Communicator Award
Categories
Issue categories
Business & Investment
Economy
Crime & Corruption
Culture
Domestic Political Issues
International Relations
Analyst opinion
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
Qatar
Bahrain
Egypt
Cyprus
Syria
United Arab Emirates
Jordan
Israel
Saudi Arabia
Turkey
Jemen
Iraq
Palestine
Gaza
Oman
Lebanon
Iran
Kuwait
MENA Communicator Award
Rating of MENA countries: June 2009 - June 2010
Qatari ratings exemplary in 2009-2010
Most Negative
Most Positive
negative no clear rating positive
Basis: 8,105 reports in 25 international leading media, 06/2009 – 06/2010
Dubai struggles as Qatar buys the world
MENA Communicator Award
Business and investment
Note: Only the countries with more than 5 reports on this issue category are shown
0% 10% 20%
United Arab Emirates
Qatar
Turkey
Egypt
Israel
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
United Arab Emirates
Qatar
Turkey
Egypt
Israel
negative no clear rating positiveShare of all reports on MENA countries
Basis: 8,105 reports in 25 international leading media, 06/2009 – 06/2010
0% 2% 4% 6% 8% 10%
United Arab Emirates
Israel
Egypt
Turkey
Architecture puts UAE on the world map
MENA Communicator Award
Culture
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
United Arab Emirates
Israel
Egypt
Turkey
Note: Only the countries with more than 5 reports on this issue category are shown
negative no clear rating positive% of Country agenda
Basis: 8,105 reports in 25 international leading media, 06/2009 – 06/2010
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
Israel
Saudi Arabia
Turkey
Qatar
Egypt
United Arab Emirates
MENA Communicator Award
Internal Politics
0% 10% 20% 30% 40%
Israel
Saudi Arabia
Turkey
Qatar
Egypt
United Arab Emirates
Israeli internal politics a key for the future
Note: Only the countries with more than 5 reports on this issue category are shown
negative no clear rating positiveShare of all reports
Basis: 8,105 reports in 25 international leading media, 06/2009 – 06/2010
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70%
Israel
Turkey
Saudi Arabia
Egypt
Qatar
United Arab Emirates
MENA Communicator Award
International Affairs
Egypt and Turkey benefit from active role
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
Israel
Turkey
Saudi Arabia
Egypt
Qatar
United Arab Emirates
Note: Only the countries with more than 5 reports on this issue category are shown
negative no clear rating positive% of Country´s agenda
Basis: 8,105 reports in 25 international leading media, 06/2009 – 06/2010
Basis: 24,019 reports in foreign reporting
in 36 international leading media
MEDIA TENOR
G 20
Award
06/2008-06/2009
G20 Award
Rating of G20 countries –June 2008- June 2009
G20 countries with a very mixed profile
Most Negative
Most Positive
negative no clear rating positive
Basis: 24 019 reports in foreign reporting in 36 international leading media, 06/2008 – 06/2009
Saudi Royals representing their country Internal politics
Volume Rating
% of reports negative no clear rating positive
G20 Award
Criteria 5: Internal Politics – June 2008- June 2009
Basis: 24 019 reports in foreign reporting in 36 international leading media, 06/2008 – 06/2009
Note: Only the countries with more than 20 reports on this issue category are shown
Russia’s foreign role a key to its image International Affairs
G20 Award
Criteria 6: Role in International Affairs – June 2008- June 2009
Basis: 24 019 reports in foreign reporting in 36 international leading media, 06/2008 – 06/2009
Note: Only the countries with more than 20 reports on this issue category are shown
% of reports negative no clear rating positive
Volume Rating
Top Overall scores Score calculations
G20 Award
Ranking
Overall score
MEDIA TENOR
Special Award
Basis: 31,736 news stories on crime, crime
prevention, war and international conflicts 01-09/2010
Violence against Women
Domestic / International Violence: The Protagonists, International TV, 01-09/2010
Violence: Who is Involved?
Basis: 31,736 news stories on crime, crime prevention, war and international conflicts in 40 international TV news programs
Missing to 100%: Countries, regions, international organizations,
health service, education, science, and individuals
Violence against Women
Salience of violence against women, international TV news, 01-09/2010
British News Most Aware of Violence Against Women
Basis: 196,918 news stories in 40 international TV news programs
Share of stories on violence against women
MEDIA TENOR
Agenda Setter Award
Business Media
Basis: 68,030 quotations
in 14 German print and television media 2001-2010
40
Overall Ranking: average score
Wirtschaftswoche made up most positions
Average score in quotation ranking 2001-2010
Basis: 68,030 quotations in 14 German print and television media
Agenda Setter Award: Business Media