march 8,20 - ky psc home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · march 8,20 13 mr. jeff...

66
109 Bagby Park Grayson, Ky 41143-1292 Telephone 606-474.5136 e 1-500-562-3532 e Fax 606-474-5862 March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard P.O. Box 6 15 Frankfort, Kentucky 40602 Re: An examination of the applicati f the Fuel Adjustment Clause of Grayson Rural Electric Cooperative Corporation From Nov. 1,20 10 through October 3 1,201 2 Case No. 2012-00562 Dear Mr. Derouen: Please find enclosed the original and six (6) copies of the responses to all information requested in the Appendix to the Order dated February, 2013. Please contact me at (606) 474-5194 or Carol Fraley at (606) 474-5136 with any questions regarding this filing. Respectfully submitjqd, f3 Enclosure A Touchstone Energy' Cooperative c--

Upload: others

Post on 31-Aug-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

109 Bagby Park Q Grayson, Ky 41143-1292 Telephone 606-474.5136 e 1-500-562-3532 e Fax 606-474-5862

March 8,20 13

Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard P.O. Box 6 15 Frankfort, Kentucky 40602

Re: An examination of the applicati f the Fuel Adjustment Clause of Grayson Rural Electric Cooperative Corporation From Nov. 1,20 10 through October 3 1,201 2

Case No. 2012-00562

Dear Mr. Derouen:

Please find enclosed the original and six (6) copies of the responses to all information requested in the Appendix to the Order dated February, 2013.

Please contact me at (606) 474-5194 or Carol Fraley at (606) 474-5136 with any questions regarding this filing.

Respectfully submitjqd, f3

Enclosure

A Touchstone Energy' Cooperative c--

Page 2: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

BE

In the Matter of:

An examination of the application of the Fuel Adjustment Clause of Grayson Rural Electric Cooperative Corporation From Nov.l,2010 through October 31,2012

Case No. 2012-00562

APPLICANT’S RESPONSES TO

COMMISSION STAFF’S REOUEST FOR INFORMATION

The applicant, Grayson Rural Electric Cooperative Corporation, makes the following

responses to the “Commission Staffs Request for Information”, as follows:

1. The witnesses who are prepared to answer questions concerning each request are Carol

Fraley and Don Combs.

2. Carol Fraley, President and CEO of Grayson Rural Electric Cooperative Corporation is

the person supervising the preparation of the

The responses and Exhibits are attached

behalf of the applicant.

orated by reference herein. 3.

Attorney for Grayson Rural Electric Cooperative Corporation Telephone: 606-474-5 194

Page 3: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

The undersigned, Carol Fraley, as President & CEO of Grayson Rural Electric Cooperative Corporation, being duly sworn, states that the responses herein are true and accurate to the best of my knowledge and belief formed after reasonable inquiry.

Dated: March 8,2013

GRAYSON RIJRAL ELECTRIC COOPERATIVE CORPORATION

By: CA

Subscribed, sworn to, and acknowledged before me by Carol Fraley, as President & CEO for Grayson Rural Electric Cooperative Corporation on behalf of said Corporation this Sth day of March, 20 13.

My Commission Expires: >?& $4 Jd/3

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

The undersigned counsel certifies that the foregoing responses have been served upon the following:

Original and Six Copies Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Commission 2 1 1 Sower Boulevard Frankfort, Kentucky 4060 1

This day of March, 20 13

R GRAYSON RUR E

Page 4: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

INDEX

Tab 1 a. Calculation of 12 - Month average Line Loss b. Line Loss reduction measures

Tab 2 Monthly Revenue Reports

Tab 3 Calculation of the Reduction in Grayson's Base Fuel Cost

Tab 4 Present E& Proposed Energy Rates

Tab 5 Tariff Changes

Page 5: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY

BEFORE THE PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION

IN THE MATTER OF:

AN EXAMINATION OF THE APPLICATION ) OF THE FUEL, ADJTJSTMENT CLAUSE OF )

CORPORATION FROM NOVEMBER 1,2010 ) GRAYSON RTJRAL ELECTRIC COOPERATIVE ) CASE NO. 2012-00562

THROUGH OCTOBER 31,2012 1

AFFIDAVIT

The affiant, Carol Hall Fraley, President & CEO of Grayson Rural Electric Cooperative Corporation, 109 Bagby Park, Grayson, Kentucky, states that, to the best of my knowledge, for the period between November 1, 20 10 to October 3 1 , 20 12, Grayson Rural Electric Cooperative Corporation has operated in compliance with each and evei-y provision of the Uniform Fuel Adjustment Clause, as prescribed in 807 KAR 5:056, and that no inquiries or complaints regarding the fuel adjustment clause have been received duiing said peiiod.

Witness my hand this 28th day of Febi-uaiy, 201 3.

Carol Hall Fraley, President k& CEO

Subscribed and sworn, or duly affiimed, before ine this 2nd day of Febiuay, 20 1 1.

My coinmission expires March 22, 2013.

Page 6: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard
Page 7: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

I

t

z 0 I

2 ln

ln

s W

-I z I

t

2 0 I :

U 0

N

N

Page 8: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard
Page 9: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard
Page 10: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

S

U C

3

0

.-

+

Page 11: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

v) t

v) 0 0

-I W

2 8 & W

> 0 0

UI a a

W

0 z 3 0

W

> 0

X t

2 0 I

U 0

z L

a

I; 0

5 3 Y d - E 2 - m al

*

a

n

*

0-

N

Page 12: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

0

0

00

0

00

0

... 0

0 -

CO

W

VI

rt: a

3: o

v

0

0

v 0

0

* C

OR

N0

23

gi

W

Nrl

(I: 3

v

V

00

o

wa

. d

VW

d

0

0

0

0

00

0

00

0

...

oE

0

4

0

m

m

m

m

m

m

W

0

r- 0

r- m m

N

r- N

'cr

CO t7

0

R

B

W

z

3

0

0

m

B 0

rl .

0

0

rl

00

0

00

0

rlrlrl

...

mo

m

mr

o

mo

m

Lom

m

mm

N

NP

Ol

wr

-

NN

m

N

N

m

H

t7R

G

mr-W

WN

NP

O

d W

W m

N O

I Lo 9' N

. . . . . . . .

w N

w P

- LO m

N m

w

~o

ww

m~

rl

rlo

r

mr

o-

m

e

dm

N

rl

m

N

N

m

0

r-l m

om

N

m

r-o

o

mo

m

m

mmm

d

mm

~

10

NN

m

m m

NP

m

wr

-

r- rl

m

5o

rl

oo

ww

~o

g

rlr

lmm

rlm

mo

L

ON

m -18

om

m o

r-

m~

NI

D~

~

wcu

~

rl

m

rl

0

z~

rl

ww

mm

wo

w

cn

w

~m

m~

~

m

rl

N

N

rl

B

~rlN

rlN

rlN

rlN

>

B rl r

l N N

m m

Q

q

Il

l

wo

w

0

Nm

P

0

NN

0

m

m

m

N

N

Lo

98

0-

~

m

w~

m od

mm

rl

mu

'

40

mm

~

10

ro

N

N

mv

.. N

Om

w

P

r-W

rlr

l

Page 13: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

IU

0

00

00

00

00

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

m

Ix

0

00

00

00

00

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

crl

IO

.

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

.

F4

f

A0

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

9'

I W

I

.. I

m

ta

ooooooooo o ooo o ooooo o

0

IE-1

0

00

00

00

00

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

w

I*

.

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

.

Ul

rld

: I

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

I

..

ID

0

00

00

00

00

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

$4

99

99

99

99

9

9 9

99

9

99

99

9

9 5

I rld

rl

drl

rl

rlrl

rl

rlrlrlrlrl

rl

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

rlrl

rl

rl

..

..

.

I I

I la

m

oo

mo

oo

rr

-

IM

m

rl

om

oo

om

rl

)$

.I .........

WN

m

m

I P

'P

Lo

I m

m

m

InW

W

I

m-r

In

I d

m

m

I m

r- w

I

mN

I

N

N

m

d' o

rlo

r(

mm

o

r- .

..

. w

mr

mw

m

mo

-o

rn

..... m

W

0

00

0

00

00

rl

W

... 9%

m

m

0

0

m

m

m

m

m

W

m

m

W

9'

0

r-

mm

m

mo

w

r-m

N

wm

N

rlw

m

m

r- cy r- W

rl

rl

I I

mo

om

oo

oP

P

mr

lo

mo

oo

mr

l

9' r

-

~n

WD

N

......... m

9,

m

m

d'

9'

0

r- N

orlo

m

mo

...

Ti

r

wm

r-mw

W

NQ

'O

~

..... W

PQ

'IDL

O

ON

wm

N

r-mN

mm

W

rl

m

r-

mm

m

W

m

r-

00

0

00

0

m0

F

lu)

m

... w

m

0

0

N

0

m

W

N

N

W

m

m

m

m

W

m

N

rl

W

0

m

mo

l m

am

r

lm

m

mW

W

WW

m

m IC

e' m

N

N

-r r- rl

m

N

I W

0

m

W

I I

om

o.

;~

oo

oo

o

mm

m

r

94

r-

wo

wo

oo

oo

.........

Nr

l

N

m

I m

W

I o

m0

o

m0

m

...

I

m

m

m

I 0

W

m

N

d' m

rl

9s

9'

m

0

r- r

N

r- m

m

r- N

I I I

I I

mm

or

-0

00

r-

r-

m

o

w0

w

O

UI

C-

~W

m

w

o

oo

o

-r I

mr-o

rloo

om

\r( rl

mc

uo

o

o~

wo

m

N

m

00

0 o P

I W

N

m

mm

m

r-w

wm

m

m

m

o

m

m

mm

m

m

o

w

~W

mo

m

o

wm

m

i

m

mw

rl

im

w

rl m

m

u,

o

r-m

N

mN

mm

r

o

rlw

m

m

mm

r-

m

m

mr

-

IO

m

u)

m

Id

m

w

m

1 m

m

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

.

..

..

.

0

0

m

mm

~

wm

mm

m

N

0

rlw

m

N

ri

d

r

ID

m

fc 9'

IN

I

c c c

c

x CT, H

ffl P

If

fl

W

PI

x

mw

m

mn

d

H

WW

d

mo

w

zP

Ix

WW

H

CO

O

c c c c

c c

%

c

c c c e

c

c c c

1-7

0

E-1 d

il 4

H

0

E-1

4

0

H

d 4

0

H

d

Page 14: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

0

0

00

0

00

0

... 0

0 *

ff

l

W W

i3 o

v

0

0

v

Loo

* C

nH

NO

HE..

Z4

Wd

O

N

w Nd

z

H

d 3

V

V

00

0 w17

* d

VW

d

0

0

00

0

00

0

OE

0

4

0

m

W

0

r

m

Lo q

I I I I I I rt

ri \

rl

3: %

x

0

0

r

m

m

N

W

m

W

W

01 w

0

0

00

0

00

0

... rl

rlrlrt

ia

m

is

1

l€

4

m

N

mr

m

Lo

mm

m

wm

ut

m m

rn

mm

w

mr

m

m

00

N

Lo

I I I I r

lI

r

tI

\

I

rl

I

....... . E-1

cu

mw

-~

om

~t

n w

mu

*o

wm

rn

rlr

l z

NO

^

mr

w-

0

mu

, w

rtm

m

N

rl

rl

0

43

:

5rtL

oO

OW

Nm

o

Sr;N

rlLo

Lo

rcrlW

O

o 01 m

u' o 10 q o

m

mw

~

wm

m

WN

~

rl

m

ri

0

zr

-o

ww

mw

mo

m

mw

~

mm

v

Nm

d

N

N

rl

E-1 d rl N

rl N

rl N

rt N

s1 €4 r

l rl N

N m

m

4'

m

N

N

Lo

mr-to

m

wm

w

mm

L

om

m

Lo

Nrn

qm

r-

0

0

mm

m

m

rl

rl

N

rl

m

I1

w

-m

o

rlm

m

o

*Loo

0

m

N

N

Lo irn

Iffl

IO

I

d

IW

I I I

3: E .. d W llr

P

0

Lo Lo

rl

a

Ei $2 EE a

n

WH

am

H

m

W D

z W >

W d

Page 15: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

IW

0

00

00

00

00

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

m

13

: 0

00

00

00

00

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

zrl .

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

.

I oio

r-

I

01

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

.. I

cr i

a ooooooooo o ooo o ooooo o

0

IE+

0

00

00

00

00

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

w ["

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

1

')

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

0

d

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

8" 0

00

00

00

00

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

*s .

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

.

..

..

.

00

00

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

E+ 6

. a

2 oio -.

z

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

2X

00

00

00

00

0 0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

IE+

0

00

00

00

00

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

IZ

.

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

.

..

..

.

!B

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

,-id

rl

rl

..

..

.

IW

0

Q0

00

00

00

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

13

: 0

00

00

00

00

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

d

10

.

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

.

* I

rlrl 4

rlrlrl

rl

rlrl

rl

rlrlrl

-I

rl

0

I OP

E!

I

I .

I

11

0

00

0

N

00

0

0

0

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

.

..

..

o

m

m

w

mm

m

r-

rl

dm

rl

rl

m

10 m

in

o

wo

mo

oo

cr

m r-

WN

O

w

~m

~o

rn

m

O

NO

WO

OO

~~

N

m

oo

m

m

~w

om

w

omo

-* m

N

o

or

0

w

cr I

cr

~

r

r-

mo

m

m

r

m

~N

N

m

0

I o

m

m

mm

w

o

mrl

o

W~

N

m

m

wm

I

mw

v

I

Nr

l

I m

m

m

rlwr-

rl

ow

r-

w

m

cr r-

W

NN

w

N

N~

m

m

rl

m

rl

I

m

II

m

oo

o-

vw

w

oo

om

m

o

om

o

r

r-

mo

m

m

mw

m

rlw

r- cr

W

...... r- N

P'

0

rl

N

rl

m

m

WN

O

mo

o

mr

m

rl

... m

N

ow

N

P

m

m

NL

ON

OW

m

NW

0m

..... m

W

m

cr

00

0

00

0

OW

rl

rl

... m

m

0

0

m

rl

rl

m

0

0

r-

m

m

OF

0

w

PN

N

rT) w

m~

m

m

mc

r

m

W

N

cr 0

m

0

rl

m

cr N

r

W

N

II

N

NO

w

rlo

mrl

... I

m

m

N

m

0

W

r- W

m

m

I

W

W

m

I I

NO

O~

OO

rn

OO

rlO

O

rl

m

mr

l

rl ......

I rl

N

I cr r-

m

0

W

m

m

m

m

m

N

ri

P'

I I I

I1

I

ow

or

co

or

lcr

m

w

wc

ro

N

o

mw

or

cr

m

ooo o

m

I m

mo

mo

ow

mm

cr

mr

lo

t-

o~

wo

m

r- cr

oo

o o

cr .

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

.

..

..

~

m

rlm

N

c

rm

o

P

~m

m

r

o

m

rl o

om

m

o

im

m

m

o

mm

o

o

wr-

m

NN

w

rl

rl

mm

m

m

I

O

om

o

mm

w

N

wrc

o

m~

m

m

m

le: m

m

w

rlw

r-

rl

ow

r-

w

NN

P

m

10

mw

I

4

rl

N

rl

rl

N

m

m

mo

qr

--

v

NN

m

w~

m

rl

m

I N

rl

I

m

I

m

W

Page 16: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

0

0

00

0

00

0

..

.

0

0 .

ff

l

W

U

d

0

v 0

0

v Loo

. fflE

-!NO

H

C.

.

Cd

Wd

O

N

tl, Nd

r& 3

V V

00

s E

o wa

* dVWd

0

0

00

0

00

0

...

e Z

$

0

4

m

m

N

m

r- P

3

I I I I I 4

d

'c N

3: 5

k-d

m

a

0

0

v

m

0

0

d

00

0

00

0

ddd

... 0

0

d

IU

1

3:

d

IV

*I

0

I ow

0

-2

3: E-! z

0

CE

-! -r& [I) E-1* X

E-1

U

H

4

H

Cm

dw

mN

mw

o

4 w

P' N

P' d d 0

w

am

dw

ad

mc

n

~m

mw

wr

v~

. . . . . . . . 0

4-

P'

WP

V

U'W

N

dW

N

d

W

I in

+.

I e

m

I*

P

N

P'

W

N

N

m

ma

w

orn

o

Po

r

mv

a

mo

v

aW

N

PW

N

N

0 P

P

0

d

I I d

I

dI

..I N

I

I

E-! W z

m

N

0

0

W

0

P

P

N

m

0

d3

:

~w

wO

ow

vP

0

MO

dm

md

wP

O

m~

av

ow

ao

i-

av

N

WD

LO

W

WN

~

4a

0

ZN

dW

WW

PW

O

wm

w

~a

wv

~m

d

N

N

d

0

0

0

dd

m

N

u~

am

ow

d~

a

mm

v

mm

Od

mo

m

.. I Iffl

Iffl

IO

I

d

ltl,

N

m

3:

E \ d W L4

6-7 3

z W

3

2

W

W

m

m

d

I i. *v

E-!W

ad

3

02

vo

Lo

2z L

4W

a

5W

k-d

n

an

3 Z

W

WH

$2: a

m

w W%

4

%

ffl*

3%

d W

5

0

PI W

(0 a

0

3:

W

PI $1

Od

NW

Pi

;l

'rO

W

s E-!

Page 17: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

00

00

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

00

00

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

00

00

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

00

00

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

00

00

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

00

00

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

00

00

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

00

00

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

.." .

.

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

rl

rl \

N

00

00

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

00

00

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

drl

rl

44

rl

rlrl

rl

rlrlrlrlrl

rl

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

0

00

0

0

00

0

0

0

,-id

rl

rl

..

..

.

11

I

00

0

0

m

ooo o

m

00

0

m

rw

m

rl

ma

m

N

6

mm

m

W

W

..

..

.

I r

lO

O0

ON

m

oo

or

lr

-

m

NP

N

m

w

m

mr- m

rl

r- x3 ......

w

N

m

r(

m

0

00

rlN

Nr-

mN

r

lW

W .. a

mm

w

NN

W

mN

m

... P

' 6

in

I

F

1%

r&

o

NO

0

... 0

m

m

m

N

am

m

m

mr

W

6

In

W

drl

m

ON

W

NrlN

N

9' m m

r

I I I I I r

lI

r

lI

-

.I

N

I

I

rl

0

m

0

m

II

I

00

0

0

6

00

0

0

P

oo

o a

r-w

m

rl

ma

m

rl

P*

m

m

0

m

W

..

..

.

I I

r6

orl0

00

0N

~

mo

mo

oo

rl

r

Nr

m

w

am

m

m

m

N

m

mi-

m

rl

......... m

r

m-

r- m

w

P'

d.4

W

N

N~

O

mr

o

mw

W

m

mm

rlr

... m

N

m

0

om

mm

w

rlN

NN

w

..... -Is 6

m a

m

m

m

0

P' a

m

rl

rl

0

m

.... 0

m

m

0

m

N

m

a

NP

WN

D

UI

NO

NW

r

lm

a~

mm

a

N~

N

W

r- N

m

r

W

N

N

dr

l

6 9'

NN

N

N

rlr

l

II

~

NO

NO

OO

OO

a oao

m o

wm

om

oo

oo

o

m

0-0

r-

rl

m

m

m~

m

w

w

m

m

m

mra

m

..

.

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

W

N

0

rlrl

N

rl

W

rl

m

W

m a

II

I

00

0

0

m

ooo o

m

00

0

0

rw

m

N

m

a

m a

6

mw

W

6

W

..

..

.

1 I

P*

NO

~O

OO

ON

r

~m

o

o

om

mm

m

m

m

wo

o~

~o

oo

rl

r

w

mm

o

m

ON

NN

N o

m

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

.

~r r

mr-

rl

PW

N~

w

0

mw

m

P

~W

rl

NO

NN

P

0

mm

a

mr

N

m

w

m

m6

mm

r-

a

NrlN

W

6

rr

-~

m

w

w

NN

rl6

r

00

rl

mw

6

rlrl

m

Wm

mN

N

r

lv

rl

r-

m

0

m

t tm

Iffl

10

lffi I

O

I

ffl w

* h h

*

Page 18: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

0

0

00

0

00

0

... 0

0

0

0

0

0

0

u m

o

(O

HN

O

ON

W

N

rl

d

3

V V 0

wa

dVWd

gzjldr;

E

0

0

00

0

00

0

..

.

0

0

0

I I I I I I rl

rt \

m

w

P

m

m

m

m

0

0

rl

00

0

00

0

0

0

0

-2

3: E-1 z 0

rn E-+* 3

:H

JH

E2

:: Crlm

mm

NW

os

o

4m

WN

VW

om

W

o~

rl

wm

mm

m

~m

m~

3~

r-

o~

c

hrlr-

cr

rn

r~

'

mcr

~r

tm

. . . . . . . .

N

rl

rlrlrl

rl

m

W

N

* V

WO

m

mN

N

r-

0

mm

m

mm

m

mm

m

mm

r

lr

l

0

!n

m

m

N

N

in 0

rl

I I

H

W z m

N

P

0

m

m

W

0

N

rl

0

m

m

0

rl

N

m

3: ~

r-

mo

om

rl

oo

%

~m

mm

mo

mo

WN

~

rt

m

ON

mV

WP

WO

r

-m

V

rlw

mm

rl

0

zw

~w

~m

mr

-o

Q

~C

TIW

~m

m~

N

m

rl

N

N

r(

E, d

dN

rlN

rtN

rtN

* Hr

lr

lN

Nm

mV

*

rlr

l

Il

l

cu

m0

m

Nm

w

r-m

~m

mm

0

0

0

m

N

N

m

WV

O

Prl

mr

to

O

W

mm

q

mm

r

lmr

t ..

rlm

m

mr-

wm

m

wm

rl

rl

NN

rtd

m

m

om

icn

Ir

n

IO

I

d

IW

I

3: k ..

rl

m

m

rl

m

r a z

LW

%a

d

W

PI W 3

z W d

5

Page 19: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

......... 0

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

..

..

. 0

00

00

0

00

00

.....

0

0

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

.. I

0

IA

w

I*

u

I

d4

I rfp

I

I \

I

rl

I

rl

I

-.

I

9'

I 0

d

N

in

$a

2 A

o\o

2"

m

IB

w *m

H

V

m

24

IH

I

2

I I I I I I rl

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

......... 0

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

..

..

. 0

00

00

0

00

00

.....

0

0

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

......... 0

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

..

..

. 0

00

00

0

00

00

.....

00

00

0

00

00

0

..

..

.

0

0

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

......... 0

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

..

..

.

0

0

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

rl -. m

0

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

rlrf

rl

rlrl

......... 0

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

rl

rlr

f

rl

..

..

. 0

00

00

0

00

00

rlrlrlrlrf

..... 0

0

00

0

0

rl

00

0

0

0

rid

rl

rl

..

..

.

rl

I I

C-

WO

P.

00

0W

N

~o

or

oo

ow

~o

r-N

r

mm

N

r(

9'

Tor-

mw

m

N

W

NO

r-

0

m w

9'

N

Nrl

N .........

I 0

00

0

m

00

0

0

w

om

m

N

rlw

m

rl

NW

W

rl

m

mm

W

N

..

..

.

m

m

wm

o

rf

r

mr

lo

rl

..

..

.

w

40

N

w

P

O

r- N

O

N

N

ol w

w

To m

rlv

w

rl

N

Nm

mw

m

rfNrfr-w

r-r-m

No

W

NO

Trm

o

mr

or

-

m

W

W

..... r- W

m

N

W

N

m

I I

~w

or

oo

om

~

~o

or

oo

ow

~o

r-N

[c

m

m

N rl

P'

To

r

......... m

m

m

NW

N

O r

0

Lo W

P

' N

N

rf

N

m

wm

o

rl

r- m

rt

o

rl

w

ro

P

m

wm

cy

..

..

.

w

40

N

N

ON

N

m

dT

o

w

rl

N

wm

mm

m

rl

~r

lr

w

rp

aw

o

om

r-

or

m

om

u us

..... W

NO

P'O

W

m

r-

w

ww

.

. 0

00

0

rl

00

0

0

m

..

..

.

mm

N

W

ww

N

v

mN

om

m

N

rlw

m

m

~m

w

m

m

m

r-

0

To N

I I

mm

o~

oo

oo

o

N~

O~

OO

OO

O

mm

r-

mw

m

.........

ww

m

I I

I

I N

w

wo

N

N

o

m0

To

m

wq

N

w

Tom

0

0

Nr

l

4'

m .

..

..

I

N

rl

rl

0

I r-

W

rl

To

m

r

r- m

m

w

m

0

4

W

I I

m 4

' 0 0

0 0

0 w

To or lo

moo o

m^

Nm

m

m

m

wr-

To P

' r

......... m

To

~

o N

W

rrl

r- 0

mw

T

o N

N

rl

N

I 0

00

0

9' 0

00

0

0

om

m

w

rlw

m

w

~m

w

m

m

m

o

m

..

..

.

m

N

r- T

om

0

m

a

0-0

m

r- ~

m

r- m

m

m

w

..

..

.

[c

OP

' C

r

9'

ww

T

o w

d

To

w

rl

N

om

mm

o

ON

rl

r-

P

NO

To

0

mr-o

m

W

..... r

-m

~m

Tom

-

ww

m

w

mm

w

w

cn

w

NT

o

mN

..

c x c *

Page 20: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

0

0

00

0

00

0

... I I

C

IE-1

ll-1

0

0

0

0

00

0

00

0

... E

o\o to 3: IE

-1

IZ

I

O

IC

2 E-1

=:

2

0

m

0

0

0

m

v

r- cr

m

3: 5

K

00

0

00

0

dd

rt

... 0

0

cr m

9'

m

m

m

0

0

rl

rl

N

W

N

v

m

N

N

m

0

N

W

0

r.l

H

W

N

N

m

m

0

m

0

N

W

W

W

N

rl

m

0

rt

3: g

rl

mo

m~

wm

o

~O

mL

oW

Lo

NO

O

w~

mc

rm

ow

o

wm

-

rlc-w

m

WN

~

rt

m

rl

0

Z 0 4

W W

W C

n 9' 0

c

rmw

~

mm

uq

N

m

rl

N

N

rt

E-1 !%

rlN

rlN

rlN

rlN

I N

ON

0

Ln

WP

0

Wr

lc

r

0

P'

m

N

N

m

NU

SW

m

m

rt

wr

m

m

mm

m

OW

mm

m

..

X

5

K

p: W Pi

.. d 4

' W 0

rl

N

wcn

m~

~r

l

mrl

m~

rl

to

cv

1-734

dZ

H

m

m

m

m

m

rl

W

3 z

W 5 il

0

E

2

Page 21: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

W

Cd

14

W

N

4'

0 w e

d4

rlp

l

.-. N

0

.. m

0

W H

B 2 z

rl

rt -. cf

a: * 0

x rl

rl --. -*

le

1

3:

I

U

I OF

I I I IH

1

%

I I I I I I I I in

a: 4

MW

*3

: V

H o\o

ffl 3: I

H

IZ

I

O

12

2

I I I I I

2 IW

13

: I t) I do

I I I IH

I

>

I I I I I I I I I I I in

I

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

.........

00

00

00

00

0

0 0

0 0

0 0

0 0

0

.........

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

.........

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

.........

0 0

0 0

0 0

0 0

0

00

00

00

00

0

......... rtrl

rl

rlrl

I I

NL

OO

OO

OO

ON

wc

r m

W

P

Nr-

m

NW

w

-r cf

mW

r-0

r-

r- o

rt

cf N

d

N

N

wa

ow

oo

ot

no

.........

I I

NL

OO

OO

OO

ON

wc

r m

Wr-

Nr-

m

NW

W

W

cf L

OW

P

O

r- r-

0 rl

P*

N

rl

N

N

W~

OW

OO

OL

OO

.........

II

o

cf

ow

oo

oo

o

wa

o~

oo

oo

o

......... o

m

LO

NL

O

N

W

I I

WL

O0

W0

00

LO

0

-r

WO

W0

00

0N

r-0

0

mr

O

N

W

NW

0

-

cf L

OW

P

O I'

r- o

rl

cf N

r

lN

N

.........

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

rl

0

a

N

m

rl

a

r

a

rl

0

a

N

LO

rl

r- rl

a

a

W

0

rl

cf r- N

W

4

rl

N

rl

5)

rl

r

r. L K K 2 H 0 FI

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

rlrl

...

-L

O0

W

NO

mrt

WW

W

orn

rl 4

'

... a

m

cf

LO

0

mN

O

LO

&

WW

\o

m

dcf

... a

m

I m

wo

a

m0

...

0-

WN

Na

O

WW

O

WW

N

N

r-

W

WW

rlc

f

..

.

sc 3 22%

B

HH

3:

Wd

V

HO

zq

cn

tlh

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

rl

a

r- 0

-r LO

0

W

a

0

r- cf LO

0

W

I N

Pcfl

W

rl

m

m

LO

LO

0

W

e + c * 2 H 0 H

00

00

0

00

00

0

00

00

0

00

00

0

.....

00

00

0

00

00

0

.....

00

00

0

00

00

0

.....

00

00

0

00

00

0

rtrlrlrlrl

.....

ac

fw

rl

a

mw

wa

r-

.....

a

m

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

rl

N

W

N

rl

W

W

a

N

W

N

rl

W

W

a

Fi

r(

N

N

cr

cf

.

.

oc

rw

rtw

O

NW

mL

O

Wd

Nr

-

Nw

wa

W

NW

LO

a

w

r-

..... rl

cr

c * c *

0

P

P

LO

W

P'

N

0

r-

r- m

W

cr N

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

drt

...

II

0

00

0

00

mln

r-rl

mm

W

...

II

0

00

0

00

mLO

r-rl W

LO

W

...

I1

0

00

0

00

lnrn

W

LO

W

... r-rl

0

C

0 0

0

0

0

0

0

0

rl

I 0

0

0

W

r- a

l 0

0

0

m

r-

m I

c c

* *

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

4

0

rl

0

0

N

W

a

a

cf rt

N

0

r- a

rt

W

cf r- rt

N

W

N

W

rl

W

m

r-

4'

W

rl

0

rt

W

m

4

N

Page 22: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

0

00

0

00

0

0

...

0

0

0

00

0

00

0

0

...

OE

0

4

0

0

0

m

m

rl

rl

P'

U4 r

W

N

m

m

0

-2

3: E- z 0

[I] E-1* 3

:E-

u H

1-7E-1

-52

2U

+r

tW

OW

rl

NO

a

:m

r~

vw

rm

w

wr

mm

mo

m~

rrlr

csm

m~

o'

. . . . . . . . P

md

mr

lmo

m

mcs

Nr

iW

N

rl

0

00

0

00

0

0

rl

rlrlrl

... 0

0

rl

m

N

v

W

mw

m

N

om

m

N

WN

W

NW

Ln

m

rlm-

0

N

W

0

rl

[I] c7 a: E-1 0

E-1

rlm

w

ww

r

tr

t

E- w z

W

N

0

N

W

N

m

0

rl

~w

rt

om

mw

mo

~

vw

mr

w~

wo

m

mw

r

lr

rm

W

rlmW

WO

NO

W

N

Nrlm

rl

0

zo

Nw

mr

-m

oo

mmw

~c

no

u*

ru

m

rl

m

N

d

E-1 rl N

rl N

rl N

rl N

* E-lr

lrlN

Nm

mw

v

GO

, 0

mo

w

o

rm

o

o

rw

W

N

N

m

mw

m

mm

ru

ww

rim

o

ww

m

o

wm

r

.. r

lmm

m

w

w

w

mw

rt

rl

rlru

rid

rlm

v

rrl

3: 5

k4 ..

Ew

wm

rlm

rl

ww

r

mv

ri

m

rl m

rir

l cnzv

1-7

34

1-7

2

H

m w

w

m

v

m

rl

a

3 LW

Ma

an

2W

41-7

8;: a

m

E

w !z w 3

z w d

2

Page 23: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

I 0

00

00

00

00

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

: 0

00

00

00

00

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

.

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

00

00

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

00

00

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

0

00

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

00

00

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

00

00

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

0

00

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

00

00

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

00

00

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

0

00

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

00

00

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

00

00

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

drl

d

rlrlrl

d

drl

rl

dd

rl

4

r(

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

0

00

0 4

00

0

0

0

rlrl

d

rl

..

..

.

II

m

oo

or

lr

l

m

mm

o

rl

mo

ro

i-

cr

c ,

~O

OO

NV

w m

oo

cr

r-ro

wo

m o

mcr

rl

ow

m

m

usm

m

o

m~

o m

cr

~m

rl

mm

m

m

mw

LO

u

'mr o

cr o

m cr

mm

d

m

mo

o

wm

o o

cr mi- r

dm

wo

i

-w

mm

~

wm

cr

NV

~-

m

m

~m

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

.

md

r

rl

d

d

rl

00

0

0

rl

ooo o

m

md

o

m

mm

m

m

r

mN

m

m

..

..

.

00

0

w

rl

I I

I

dr

-o

mo

oo

rl

d

m

mm

o

r(

mo

ro

r-

cr

ooo o

N

~i

-o

mo

oo

~u

'

w

mm

o

cr r

mw

om

o

cr ooo o

N

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

.

..

..

.

mu

' rl

ow

m

m

crm

m

m

m~

o m

u' o

00

o r

~m

d

mm

a

m

mw

m

u

am

i- o

cr LO

m

d

o

cr o

m cr

mm

rl

m

mo

o

cr

mo

o

us m

m

m

m

cr m

r r

dm

wo

r

-w

mm

~w

r

mr

-

wm

cr

N

u*

4-1

u)

m

N~

N

0

md

r

rl

4

0

rl

d

N

N

ID

I I

I I

I

f m

oo

wo

oo

oo

m

m

wo

us

m

mL

oo

mo

oo

oo

r-.

L~

NO

m r

md

N

o

cr

m

mL

o

tom

cr

dm

cr

uq W

w

cr

N

N

w

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

.

m

II

m

m

cr

w

mm

m

m

..

r- Lo r- m

m

m

N

oo

r-

om

o

mw

om

m

Lo

m

mo

o

mm

..... L

or-

cr

N

rl

N

Lo

r

r- 'F

p

N

rl

m

rl

cr 0

m

cr N

m

00

0

00

0

00

...

mrl

mm

P

0

0

0

0

5-

4-

0

vm

o

mi- ... di-

00

P

O

r

m

r

0

m

m

m

or

r

d

i-m

cr N

rl

md

* * * * m

X

4

E-

A

0

E-

d * * * *

* * * * * * * *

* xxw

* 4

4cn

*

E-E

-H

* z

wilv

A

mo

p:

0

cn

Ab

E-

242 d il

0

E-

d A

0

b

d il

0

E-

d

Page 24: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

IC3

cr l

m

Cd

IV

(

41

I

o\o r

i

rl

l

.. I

~f

in

0

IH

w

I*

U

l

d4

I d

(4

I

-.

I

mI

0

1

-.

I

r-

I

0

d

SU

2 E

o\o

62

w *m

E

V

cn 3: I

E

IZ

d

jP

I I I I I I rl d

-. W

0

00

0

00

0

0

...

0 0 *r

o

w U

m

ov

0

0

v

mo

2

. r

n~

r-

0

W

NN

z 3

V

V

00

0 wa

2

. d

VW

d

0

0

0

00

0

00

0

0

...

og

0

4

0

m

N

0

0

N

W

m

r- cr

m

0

r- 0

cr m

0

0

00

0

00

0

ddd

... 0

0

40

-2

d

N

m

N

cr m

N

N

m

0

cr 6

dm0

m 0

U'

mc

-N

NO

W

mc

rm

mm

N

mm

d

d

..

m E

>

mE

W

c-7E

H

~m

mm

on

tw

do

A

9' 6

N 6 d 6 m

w

cn c-7

0

E

3 0

d

E

w z . . . . . . . .

mw

dm

mN

6m

rlm

m!n

wln

rlN

md

r- c

rom

u'

m6

N

Nm

N

d

m

N

N

m

0

6

cr m

N

m

m

N

0

m 4

0

d

3: 5

dr

-o

mw

oo

o

%r

lo

mr

-d

om

o

m m

(T, m

o m

ut o

wm

6

Nm

wm

W

N

Nd

m

d

0

z~

ww

mm

r-

CO

O

NO

o 4

%

Nm

ddm

N

d

m 01 w

E

dd

Nd

Nd

Nd

N

II

m

Nm

0

mr

lm

0

om

o

d

m

N

mrlm

m

o

6r-d

m

m

9-

m

m-r

mm

N

cum

m

m

ocr

r-Nm

N

!n

Nd

cr

..

d

rl

mcr

drl

lu

l

Icn

1

0

Id

I

U

I I I

N

m

m

m

d

E-& Z

d

3

OZ

v

o

cn

G (4W

GI W

*

A*

L

o*

3%

H

m

w 3

z w d

5

w (4

N

ON

mU

'mw

E

w

(4

3

E

c-7

0

E

z

Page 25: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

m

Cd

Pi

r- d

6

0 w W

d4

&P

i \

0

0 .. r- 0

W €4

2 Z

D

d

rt

rt \

W

d

sc 0

C

rl rt

rt \

W

IW

13

:

IV

I I I I IE

I

*

I I I I I I I I in

d

*3:

V €4

o\o

t3W

3: IE

-4

I2

1

0

3 IC I I I I I IW

13

:

I C

) I I

OP

I I I I

€4

Is

1

I I I I I I I I I in

irn

Iffl

IO

IC

G

IW

I I I

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

.........

00

00

00

00

0

0 0

0 0

0 0

0 0

0

.........

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

.........

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

.........

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

rld

rt

rtrtrt

.........

I I

I

WN

OW

00

0X

l"

N

mP

ON

00

0P

O

......... PV

N

oa

r-

mm

w

m

dm

m

m

m

mo

d

m

or-

r- w

m 6

rlN

N

d

I I

I

W N

O W

0 0

0 9

' N

mP

ON

OO

OP

0

......... r-e

N

o

mr

-

mm

w

m

rtm

mm

m

mm

rc

m

d

or-

r- w

m 6

rt

N

N I

I I

or-o

No

oo

oe

r

tm

~r

no

~~

~r

c

......... r

lm

N

0

6

Q4

P

r

ld

I I

I

wm

oo

oo

o-

w

vw

od

oo

or

-r

t

......... 0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

rt

0

N

N

r- N

0

0

N

m

0

N

N

P

N

0

0

N

m I

0

94

9'

m

m

m

N

W

rt

W

0

0

N

m

c c c c 1-11

0

€4

z

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

dd

...

mr-o

m

mo

Nm

m

m

... 0

0

rlm

4-

mr

-o

m

mo

...

00

r

lm

NO

?

d=3

mm

II

0 9

' 0

mm

o

... 4

-

9s

mdo

wm

o

... N

e

mm

N

Cn

de

mm

x 3 x

xw

4

4m

P

PH

3:

w1-11v €

44

2

rn1-11h

sg2

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

d

0

m

rl

W

rt

m

W

0

m

rt

W

rl

m

W

I e 6

W 6

I;F

r- r- 0

N

Lo W

c

c c

c d

0

€4

s

00

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

..

..

..

0

00

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

0

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

..

.

..

..

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

0

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

..

.

..

..

00

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

..

..

..

00

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

rlrl4

drl

4

..

..

..

r-Lo

mo

m

m

wr

mm

ol

m

T'r

lN

Nr

l

W

me

mm

*ry

m

W

Q-

PN

m

m

me

ry

w

m

rg

m

rl

rt

..

..

..

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

00

0

0

rt

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

dd

rt

d

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

Lo .

..

..

o

m

-r m

m

o

r;

~ r

t w

w

m

d

40

r- N

N

r-mm

om

m

w

ooo o

w

wr-m

mo

l m

P

00

0

0

N

r-

rt

~~

rl

w

m

om

e

r- m

6m

-N

m

m

m

o

'ir 9%

rncrr-cum

m

w

w

W

d

LO

Q'

NW

-

rt

-+

Lo

m

Q

mN

m

T

i d

N

N

..

..

..

.

..

..

.

II

r,

r-

r-

W

W

W

r- V

6

m

rl

d

W

m

m

..

ommoo

0

w

00

0

0 d

or-m

m\o

0

r- 0

00

0

w

..

..

..

.

..

..

.

~N

NW

m m

om -

e

6r

yW

.r

r

tm

9

'm-m

10

m

07

0

V

Lo 6

PN

ol

m

W

w

w

w

Lo N

N

u)

mN

r

lr

t

ffl W V H 2 W ffl

sc d

4

1-11 1-11 H

V z

ffl P

ic

0

HP

i

3:

WW

rn

€4a

dH

Wffld

mow

zO

-43:

WW€4

60

0

c c c e 1-11

0

€4

Z

4

d

W z n

Page 26: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

IW

i

IV

I

o\o I

r 1

3:

0

0

00

0

00

0

..

.

0

0 *

vl

W W

ffi

ov

0

o

v m

o

. (

II

hN

O

HZ

. -

E4

-4

O

N

W N

rl

z 3

V

V

00

$ 2

o

wn

*

ffivw

rl

0

0

d

srm

V

$W

0

0

00

0

00

0

... h a\o

il m Ih

IZ

1

0

2 If:

h

::

I

0

0

0

0

0

N

0

Lo Lo -

m

E m

- Lo rl Tr m

0

m

N

- IW

13

:

I C

) I I OiD I I I

0

0

00

0

00

0

rlr(rl

... 0

0

r(

rl

0

-2

3: e

z 0 Zh

--p: rn hsr X

i3

W H 4E-1

~~

~m

ro

ww

wo

F

cm

orlm

r-.;rInc

u

wo

m~

om

~c

n

r-

mo

rn

mo

~o

m

ar

-

om

u~

~

m

NN

~

. . . . . . . .

N

rl

W

N

N

Lo

rm

o

rl

mr

c

r-m

wm

m

Lo

-0

Lo

rlW

00

N

N

0

W

0

rl

r

vl 4

0

E-1 E! h

W

z r

mo

In P

' 0

rlwr-

In

dW

u+ 9

% m

wm

m

00

N

N

0

r- W

W

N

N

In

r

cr rl

0

N

rl

rl

m

0

rl

m

zo

mm

Lo

mu

+m

o

%L

;L

OL

ON

P~

O~

O

LO

NO

~N

~+

WO

r

oa

m

~m

rm

W

N

~r

lm

rl

0

zo

or~

or(ro

o

ma

w

mo

d-

N

m

rlr

lm

N

r(

rl&

w

Lo

mrl

NW

W

Nr

l

0

0

0

W

N

wm

u*

rr-

or

a

crm

a

do

rlrl

wm

m

NL

O

N

N

mc

r

NN

Lo

..

vu

+m

0

-

0

0

rlr

l

rlrl

N

In

n

3 BW

sn

a

n

ZW

WH

2; a

m

ffi W

B

0

PI W Lo ffi 0

3:

t-7

0 h

$

Page 27: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

0

N

rl

rl w 0

dFC

+PI \

m

0

\

m

0

w E-r

2

3

!z

rl

rl --. r-

!z a

0

G rl

rl \

r-

IU

1

3:

IU

I I o\o I I I IE

-! la

I I I I I I I I

!x d wC) *

X

C)

E-r d!= m A d x

I

H

IZ

in

I8

I I I I I I IC

)

13

:

10

I o\o I I I IE

-1

I>

I I I I I I I I I I I 13

3

1H

1

2

IO

in

I I I Im

I

m

IO

lp

:

IC

)

I I

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

.........

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

.........

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

.........

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

.........

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

rlr

l rl

rlrlrl

.........

II

m

ao

oo

oo

rl

m

am

oo

oo

or

lo

.........

ma

oo

oo

oA

m

mm

oo

oo

or

lo

il~

N

w

aw

P

O o

mm

m

mrl

m

mw

r-

......... r-m

m

W

vlr

;oo

bo

oo

oo

m

r-

oo

oo

oo

o

ma

......... m

w

0

N

II

a uq o m

oo

o rl m

m

wo

oo

oo

rl

o

......... w

m

N

wa

w

rlm

a

mm

m

40

m

m

wr-

r-m

m

W

0 4

P'

rl

N

N

E-! z w z H

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

rl

W

N

r- 0

m

rl

N

N

m

W

N

r- 0

m

rl

N

N

m

Fi

0

N

r- rl

Lo N

m

m

m

m

rl

N

N

h

h h

h d

0

H

2

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

rlrl

...

mN

O

rlw

o

VW

... m

m

mo

N

m

NO

LO

N0

r

lw

o

VW

... m

m

mo

N

m

Nm

I w

mo

m

m0

r

lW

rl ...

Fir

-0

C

NO

LO

O

... v

m

mo

N

m

Nu) x 2

22E

2:2 E-!&

n

X

WdO

HA2

Cndh

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

4

r

r- 0

N

v

m

r-

r

r- 0

N

-r m

r- I rl

N

m

m

rn

m

N

v

m

r-

h x h h i

E-! 0

H

00

00

0

00

00

0

.....

00

00

0

00

00

0

.....

00

00

0

00

00

0

.....

00

00

0

00

00

0

.....

00

00

0

00

00

0

rlrlrlrlrl

.....

m

a

r- N

m

r- 33

rl

rl

r- m

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

rl

- r v

4

r- - 0 N

v

r- v

rl

r- - 0 N

a

N

r- rl

In

=s

r- W

v

0

N

a

h h h h 2 E-,

0

Et

rl

a

m

a

m

v

N

rl

a

m

m

m

v

N

m w u, 2 2 2 w (0

a

p:

a

H

V

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

rlrl

...

00

0

00

0

... o

m

am

v

m

00

0

00

0

... o

m

aN

Q

' m

00

0

00

0

... o

m

am

v

Lo

m (4m

H(

4

zmw

p:H

W

mC

C

P2

OW

zP

Ix

WWE

mmn

=no

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

rl

0

0

a

rl

m

m

0

0

a

rl

ro m

0

0

a

rl

m

m

h h h h d

0

E-,

2

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

rl

m

m

m

-3

v

0

W

N

m

W

9'

a

m

a

N

N

W

N

r- m

r- W

m

r- m

m

m

rl

r- rl

m

N

m

a

c c h x 4

0

H

2 n 3 C)

c

d

\

,9 0

Page 28: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

0

0 .r

n

W

W

0;

OV

0

3 o

v m

o

mB

m0

2

%i

W

drl

d

3

u

V

00

0 wa

w

* d

VW

4

0

0

00

0

00

0

...

0

0

0

0

00

0

00

0

...

02

0

4

0

r- m

0

0

m

B 0

d

N

0 e

m

m

N

P'

r

ffl 4

4

B

0

er

m~

mw

eo

B .

..

..

..

.E

+

mm

mm

mm

om

w

Or

-O

WN

ON

O

2

w m

r

NW

N

N~

.f

fl

0

B>

rl

mB

4E-r

E 3 N e rl r;F

N e m

N

e o rl 4

%

rl

0

0

N

Ul

00

0

00

0

... 0

0

do

-2

E

0

0

rl

m

N

rlrlrl

E 0

0

0

CE

-, m

-rr;

N

m

41

r

ll

-

.I

m

i

I

m

N

mo

m

mrlW

N

NV

W

0-

P

me

w

mm

m

mm

N

N

Ti

0

m

N

m

m

m

0

W

rt

0

rl

m

5 m

m m

o 4

' e m

o

&m

r~

mm

o~

o

mm

m

mm

wm

W

N

~r

lm

P

rlO

er

le

NO

d

0

2 N

P

W 0

P 4

' 0

~m

w

mo

de

~

m

rlr

lm

N

rl

0

0

0

dd

E+ d

rlN

rlN

dN

rlN

sr B rl r

l N N

m m

e

W

N

rm

m

dm

w

wm

m

o

~m

o

om

p

er(

am

m

mm

O

N

m

m

wr

N

N

m

e

rl

dW

..

dd

I I Iffl

Iffl

10

I

d

10

I

N

m

I

m

B -. d W P-I

cx

ww

~m

m~

Wd

em

mr

l m

m

Wd

rl

0 c 4

' 43d

A2

H

m

ril

0 a

-r m

rl

a z 5W Ma

W 3

2

W d

z4

Page 29: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

IO

0

00

00

00

00

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

;3 9

99

99

99

99

9

99

9

9 9

99

99

9

I I d,O

I

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

I I lQ

0

00

00

00

00

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

IF 9

99

99

99

99

9

99

9

9 9

99

99

9

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

d

i$O

0

00

00

00

00

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

00

00

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

0

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

E4

O\Q

rn ra: d

m

00

00

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

;E

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

0

00

00

00

00

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

;!2

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

I IO

0

00

00

00

00

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

00

00

00

00

0

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

I d

rl

rl

rlrlrl

rl

drl

rl

rlrld

rlrl d

I do

I I3

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

0

00

0

0

00

0

0

0

dd

rl

rl

..

..

.

I 1

1

r-

mo

r-

oo

o~

r(

o

wr

lo

r-

wm

mm

m 6

I d

w

w

u'w

m

w

wm

o

mo

~d

w

m

1 c

rw

rl

ov

m

m

rc

y

N

r-

~m

mw

m

I r-cr

m

wm

w

o

rlm

r-

mm

m~

m N

I m

m

m

rluq

N

mm

d

wr

-

I w

m

v

rl

rl

NW

W

v

rlr

l

Id

m

N

N

IN

N

I !

::94

9?

9?

?

4 9

N9

rl :::41

:

00

0

0

r- 0

00

0

rl

ow

w

0

m

wr

l

w

wc

r

rl

rl

c

N

..

..

.

m~

rl

rl

m

I I 13

:

10

I

C

1.. IE

-! I

W

rn

lZ

tl

ow

HW

is

$5

I I

I

PW

01

'0

00

Nd

d

wo

mo

oo

Gl

m

......... 0

m

wr

lo

m

N0

w

m

r-v

rim

m

W

NO

... r- rl

0

N

rl

W

r

wm

mm

m

mo

cu

cy

w

mm

mc

um

ww

rlmm

C-N

Urn

tnW

P'

W

d

rl

N

..... d

W

m

N

m

r-

rl d

00

0

00

0

*.. 0

0

m

rl

W

W

rl

W

m

0

W

0

N

rl

m

A N

d

N

m

N

II

I

WL

OO

NO

OO

OO

w

mo

ro

ow

oo

m

w

m

m

......... m

Gl

N

d

PN

rl

II

m

mo

U

+ N

0

mm

d ...

I r- P

- W

m

m

m

m

W

0

r

rl

cr d

m

0

m

r- 4

W

9%

m

v

rl

m

d

cr -r W

m

cr

m

m

r(

rl

13

l

b

lQ

16: I I I I Ir

n

10

1

IO

I

d

I [!I

I I I

I I

I

mm

om

oo

o~

rl

c

r~

o~

oo

.~

~m

m

mo

v

mw

m

or-

d

md

m

om

m

m

mv

w

m

m

rld

m

m

v

rl

cr ......... m

W

mm

o

om

d 0' 0

...

om

mm

cu

oc

uw

m

mm

Nm

ow

rlm

m

..... N

L0rn-T

W

T

i

N

d

W

W

r- N

r- rl N

4

d

00

0

00

0

ow

G

lN

m

rl

... m

0

0

m

rl

W

W

Ti

m

W

rl

0

0

rl

m

N

N

r

W

W

W

rl

W

m

W

P*

m

m

N

m

c * c c

c * * * c

e c

c * e * * t7 ra: x

0

E-!

d €4 0

E-!

d €4 0

E-!

Page 30: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

wr-w

m

mm

r- m

...

ON

0

Ar

lr

l

N

rl

...

a

W

cr r- d

m

d

0

rl

z

5

rl --. a

4

Q*

rl

cr

r

m

m

N

4'

a

N

0

NcrN

rlrld

cr rl

... 4

0

-2

3: R

2

0

CH

-6

[I] R

sr 3:€4 W H

de

c a:

W

aw

m

mo

w

am

N

a

oo

rl

r-mm

N

WW

d

Nm

m

m

dd

m

W

m

0

4'

W

ffl 4

a: e 0 H

ow

a~

ow

wo

9' cr m

m m

a o

a

ow

ow

mo

mo

cra

r- m

om

d

am

N

N~

N

d

W cr d

Q Pl

Q' 0 N

. . . . . . . .

rl

I

rl

I

--

.I

a

1

I

R

W z W

N

01 m

m

0

43

:

gm

wm

oo

cr

mo

s

ow

~m

~o

ao

N

0 0

4, N

d 0

0

da

m

mm

mm

W

N

~r

la

rl

0

zv

ar

-w

mr

-0

0

mm

w

rnO

Nc

r ~m

rlrlm

N

rl

e

drlN

rlN

rlN

rlN

* Rd

rlN

Nm

mc

rd

Il

l

4'r

-rl

0

om

w

0

lnP

N

0

rlr

lm

I m

N

N

m

I I I Iffl

Icn

I (3 I2 I I I

X E $ -. 14

r- N

10 ln

rl

w WC

3*

5:

w 3

z w d

5

Page 31: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

IC3

1

3:

I C

)

I a\o

I I

mm

om

oo

wr

-m

m

wo

mo

or

-w

m

......... dW

d

rn

m

wm

o

ww

o

... m

m

dm

wo

r-

m

r-

u*

om

.....

dd

m

m

mw

o o

m

mm

o

m

m

..

..

.

d

r- d

v

0 W

u d

4

414

\

m

0

\

0

rl

I la

I

H

I>

I I I I I I I

md

I I

I

or

-o

~o

om

rl

w

dv

ow

oo

mw

~

am

m

P

MP

.........

I 0

00

0

v

00

0

0

0

ma

u

* m

o

w

w

d

wo

v

m

m

N

u

* 4

dw

W

0

N

..

..

.

N

m

mm

o

Nd

O

00

...

mo

w

m

v 4

' O

N

rl U

'

mw

dw

r-

ww

r-

04

mN

ww

m

mw

mm

d

ww

r-am

~

mu

'r

-o

m~

m

m

m

.....

d

0

r- r

uj

m

0

0

m

w

N

m

Id

rl

d

0

Lo

m

m

r- m

dW

0

m

d

U'N

O

N

d

..

..

.

W 2 n

H dP

1-7 3: N

OO

NO

OO

~O

m

mm

o

m

wm

wm

v

m

IH

r

(m

om

oo

od

m

w

PN

O

m

mr

wm

w

o

I2

.

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

.

I I

I

2

mm

dm

o

m

NW

v

N

dd

N

00

0

0

w

om

0

m

d

om

m

d

mrt

w

0

mv

w

w

..

..

.

18 I

N

r- m

m

U

T

mv

m

v

mo

m

m

wm

w

v

d

0

N

m

m

N

r- W

m

m

m

w

W

d

m

m

mr

-

m

0

N

d

d

--. m

10

do

om

oo

od

d

N

WN

O

m

vm

md

v ut

13

: d

00

d0

00

0d

rl

dd

0

d

rtO

dr-ld

d

10

.

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

.

I I O

P

I I

N~

O

v

N

0-0

m

d

..

..

.

I I

II

I

R

mw

Om

OO

~~

m

w

om

0

m

w~

dw

v

m

IH

~

~O

~O

OO

NN

m

w

r-o

m

PI-m

mo

v

4

I>

.

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

.

I w

d

w

wm

v o

NO

m

d

mm

dv

m

I

mm

w

T

PN

~

m ~d

m

om

u-

~w

N

I m

o

m

r-v

r-

w

vm

m

w

oc

om

m

d

I d

r- w

~

md

o

vd

in

m~

mw

m rl

I m

w

N

w~

wm

m

dm

md

w

I m

m

m

dm

rt

m

mm

N

N

dI

w

W

d

d

dI

d

d

rt

--

.I

m

i

I o

oo

o

m

oo

o

o

m

mv

m

v

w

o

m

m

am

m

rl

08 m

m

m

m

..

..

.

U'

NW

O

m ~owru' P

mm

o

m

r-om

mm

m

P

.

..

..

..

..

..

I

I

I 0

00

0

r- ooo o

m

dr

-o

mo

oo

mm

m

N

U'O

wO

OO

wO

r-

..

..

..

..

..

.

..

..

oo

o

m

~m

o

m

o

dm

m

N

NO

m

N

Y3 N

U

' vu

- 0

do

r-

am

m

o

m

v

mo

m

m

w

m

u-

m

w

u*

dN

m

0

d

N

I1

I

I

md

ou

*o

oo

om

d

md

ov

oo

oo

m

ut

..

..

..

..

..

I

I

I I

I

rlm

o

o

N

mm

m

a

ui'o

o

m P

vm

m

N

d

d

d

dv

m

m

rt

..

.

..

..

m

m

0

1 0

d

dN

N

w

m

m

..

w

m

r-

ch

m

m

U

' W

0

m

d

!n

I I I I Icn

Iffl

IO

I

d

I (9

Id

I I

0

N

W

N

r

m

N

0

N

mm

o

av

o

... r-0

-0

ww

N

'ir d

r

m

m

OO

WD

r-

N

oo

mm

m

ow

om

d

vm

d

..... W

Nd

m

Pd

r- d

m

m

ID 0

m

P

d

m

II

0

00

0

00

00

N

m

0

N

... I 0

0

u- d

I m

mo

mo

oo

mv

w

mo

do

oo

wv

dN

w

......... 0

0

d

N

W

v

N

w

m

m

v

m

v

N

N

0

0

N

m

m

c c e c d

W Lo 1-7

0

H

2 ffl 1

4f

fl

c

u1

4c

xfflw

6

rnH

R

c d

H

Wfflp

: crl

mo

u

WW

H

0

CR

O

H

ZQ

3:

2

* * * * d

4

1-7 il H

u 2

>a

u

z

d1-74

WW

Z

Z3

W

Wh

R

1-7

0

H

2 a

9 u

Page 32: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

IU

J'

I m

+ 1

0

I

r

r- m

mm

r-r-r- .

..

m

0 .

m

rl

w

a

-d

ov

m

vo

-

fflE4

0

OH

0

Ur

l

z

H

V V

* d

VW

ao

a

wa

I o\o

I I

N

Lo

0

r- 6

vm

r- 6

OL

O

wo

w

Lo

r0

0

mo

m

mo

a

om

m

am

r

lr

l

-d

*X

V

2" m

rlm

0 r

i 0

...

?2

N

0

rl

m

N

t-. m w

m

mm

r

r-

m

mw

m

om-

mm

W

ww

r

lr

l

a

m

N

Lo

94

m

W

Lo 6

m

k N

0

rl -s?

m

H

z 0

0

6

ED

w

--d

.

m

0

H>

r r(

mH

U

a

a

Lo

N 6

m

m

0

m

-;P

IU

1

3:

IV

I

6

rl

06

0

r(rlX-4

...

I a\o

I I

W

a

.ifvm

w

rc

r

mm

t-

am

rl

Nn

.4

Nd

6

rfmm

6

Lo

r

lr

l

m

1-7 a:

H

H

0

dH

x

wm

aa

mw

rl

o

H

a: m m

rl LO

03 9' L

ON

........ E4

wm

mw

ma

oa

w

ww

ow

oo

oo

2

r0

mr

6

0m

v

Nm

N

Nm

rl

0

m

N

ma^

o

ww

03

a

m

mm

9'

0

N

6

W

N

rl

0

rl

I ,*

I I I

Lo W

m

I I 13

:

IH

I

Z

I.. IH

I

W

ml

z

A

a:!%

Ha

: o

w

H*

18 m

N

N

Lo 3: 5

0w

mm

t-

9'6

0

sm

r~

r-

vo

mo

m

am

~

mm

m

WN

~

rl

a

ut 0 0

9' L

o 6

m 0

rl

Il

l

rlm

w

0

0.3

0

0

ww

r

lr

l

mr-m

o

0

~~

ot

-r

wm

mo

m

om

Q* N

a w

N

m

rlr

lm

N

rl

H

drlN

rlN

rlN

rlN

>< H

rl r

l N N

m m

9' 6

am

Z

fflH

UH

G

E4 I(

I1

2Z

Z

1% I$ I I I I I l

m

Im

IU

I I I I 12

m

N

N

m

93

-m

00

o

mm

a

m

wo

n

06

m

mcu

..

N~

W 61-

mrS

0

Nrl

w

w

ww

r(

rl

Nm

rlrl

-d

rlw

mc

r~

r-

W

N

om

wd

m

m

mr

lrl

fflZ

6

43

4

4z

H

m

-d W

5

0

!a

W

m

-d 0

X

W

3

z W >

2

Page 33: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

m

Cr

l (4

N

m

cr 0 w W

rlA

r

l(4

-,

W

0

.., rl

rl

w E

8 z 3

d

rl

rl \

0

rl

p: 2r 0

C 7 v

i rl \

0

rl

w E zn Od

(4w W

E

dfflffl I

W

13

:

I C

)

I d,O

I I I I

E

Is

r

I I I I I I I I

d

A WD

*3:

v E

dr"

4 la

2 IS m

IH

I

Z

I I I I I I

IW

1

3:

I

V

I I o\o

I I I IE

I

*

I I I I I I I I I I I IE

I

Z

10

I

C

I.. IE

I

W

IZ

la

Im

I H

4

WW

Ap

: S

UE

A

w > w

af

fl

d

ZfflE

Z"

E';1

dYB

We3

Iffl

13

1

b

IA

la

I I I I I tffl Iffl

10

lp

:

I (9 I I t

mm

om

oo

ww

rl

r-

mo

r-

oo

rm

m

......... rlm

rl

I I

1

mm

om

oo

mc

ro

m

mo

mo

om

om

wm

m

r

-~

ar

-

mo

cr

mr-m

c

rm

o

mm

m

mm

N

r

lc

r~

d

W rl

m

.........

mc

r cr

rt

Orl

N

wo

or

lo

oo

ww

o

rlo

rlo

oo

rlo

.........

I I

m w

or- o o

o m

us

w 0

0 r-

0 0

0 P

4 0

......... m

m

m

00

o

m

m

4-0

m

w

v

wo

P

rl

m

rl

rl

W

cr rr

Wr

l

rl

oo

om

oo

or

(r

l

rlo

orlo

oo

orl

.........

I 1

1

rlr

lo

mo

oo

tn

m

ow

oc

ro

oo

~m

W

rl

W

W

OO

m

cr N

v

ww

rlr-

r- r-v

o

3w

w

~

mr

l

vr

N

W

N

ww

m

r-4

W

d .........

I I

r. w o m

o o

or( o

o

mo

mo

oo

wN

.

..

..

..

..

c

rr- cr

WO

m

o

m

-0

m

m

w

0 9

' rlv

m

rlm

rt

I I

m w

o 'ill o

o o

o o

om

r-

md

o

NL

DO

LO

OO

OO

O

......... a

rt

rl

I I

ON

O~

OO

O~

~O

m

mo

mo

oo

Wc

q

......... -P

N

W

O

WN

1;F

-0

~

m

r- 0

-

tn

cr

rt

mcr

m

rlm

r- d

0 a

r- W

rl

m

rl

cr r- m

m

rl

W

0

m

rl

W

9'

rl d

rl

rl r

rl

t-i

W

r-

r- m

m

cr

W

rl

W

rl

h

W

9'

r- W

cr 0

W

rl

I t-i N

m

r- r- rl

0

m

N

In

cr W

0

rl

m

* * x * 4

3

3

d E

PrlO

P

WO

...

mm

o

mm

cum

wv

o

ON

Nr-

PW

rlc

r

...

ow

0

rlo

o

...

rlm

o

mm

r-m

dm

-N

O

rlN

O

W

...

tn

d0

d

rt0

...

NW

O

OW

0

... m

a

mr-

mrv

mw

m

r- rlm

mm

o

mr-

om

... v

m

ON

N

cr

I1

m

mo

mm

N

dO

... v

r-

mo

rl-0

Wt

n

00

ncr

3N

N

cr

...

X

A

E

<XW

64

0

-1

EH

3:

L7

4V

4

42

nA

&

$82

0

W

r- rl

m

m

m

N

m

W

m

0

0

r- m

m

m

W

m

N

rl

0

r- rl

rl

W

0 0

m

tn N

r- m

0

N

W

I rl

v

W

m

ID

W

m

m

W

N

W

h * h h 4

c 3 2

or

nm

ww

W

WO

OP

.....

rlrl

mrlu

qw

w

mv

om

o

om

vr

-w

v

mm

wm

r-rlm

mm

rlm

wr-o

~

mm

.....

cr -J rl

mo

mr

w

o-lr

loo

.....

crm

ww

rl

wt-rlm

m

crN

WW

cr

r-mo

r-m

crm

mm

m

WW

N

m

0

4

.....

om

mo

rl

rl0

0N

rt

.....

mw

rnr-m

O

r-

Wr

-N

vm

r-

ow

r

lW

NW

IO

w

rlw

mo

F

NV

PV

m

mr

-

m

rl

rl

.....

vo

mm

m

oo

ww

ri

m

ww

ow

m

mc

rm

v

rl

rl

NL

Or

-

m

md

rl

m

m

.....

,-I

I Ijl

W

0

m

m

N

m

m

rl

rl

m

m

oo

mm

r.

o

om

wr

-

mu

3m

m

md

rl

m

..... W

WO

W

rlN

L0

W

rl

0

w Wf

fl

d

ff

lW

Vp

:AE

-r rs

ZC

>.I d 3: C

) A

E3

V

4c

> dp:

AV

VW

W

ZO

ffl3:

Z

WW

HE

E-

I

0r

p:C

OO

s3zm

m

r-

m

P'

r- m

r- m

m

m

rl

r- 0

m

r- 0

0

W

0

4

m

rl

d

W

cr W

N

9'

W

rl

N

rl

0

m

rl

N

W

rl

r

m I

W

m

N

m

rl

30 cr gr IC

W

rl

m

m

* * h * 4

A

E

0

E-r

m

W

0

rl

9'

N

m

m

W

0

rt h

Q

, N

ffl w V

H

>

e: w (I] * p:

4

H

V

5 2

mr

lo

P

' W 0

...

I 0

00

0

00

...

mm

cu

m

PN

W

rl

wm

o

AN

0

...

I 0

00

0

00

00

N

m

rlrl

In

...

NW

O

Wm

o

... e-! I 0

00

0

00

W P

, T

IN

rl d

... o

m

00

0

00

0

mm

m

w

mm

v

00

0

00

0

m lo

w

w

cr

... m

m

ffl m

ff

l

H0

r

xm

w

fflea

d

H

Wt

nd

m

ow

C

am

W

WE

C

:aO

N

W

0

0

cr m

r'

m

r-

m

N

0

0

0

r- 0

Lo

m

v

0

0

m

m

W

0

rt

0

0

0

m

-3 m

0

0

0

m

cr m

* * * h d

0

E-r

5

0

W

m

m

m

N

v

rl

W

m

N

N

W

0

cr N

0

W

W 4

rl

m

m

rl

rl

0

0

W

7-4

m

rl

N

W

rl

m

m

m

m

m

r- rl

W

0

N

9'

m

r- W

d

m

m

cn m

rl

to

rl 0

0

N

m

* * h h 4

0

E

z

W

d 2 a

Page 34: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

0

r

NO

N

rrr

W

I m

I

0

m

lD

WN

u

rl

m

rr

lm

a

mn

m

N

N

Ln o

imm

; ~

nm

m

om

m

rlr

l

NC

\1

0

rl

mo

m

orlo

.

..

m

N

N

Ln

~m

m

mu

)* m

mr

m

mr

r

mo

m

o

No

m

rl

N

m

m

N

m

I rl

rl --. rl

N

m

r

rl

dt m

v

rl

Nv

N

rlr

lrl

..

*

rl

0

rl

N

v

m

u)

m

rl

rm

m

u)m

vm

~

rm

rl

Ln

NW

oo

rl

Nn

Ln

L

nL

n

rlr

l

Ln UJ m

..

..

..

..

m

dt

mm

om

rm

r

lo

or

rlo

ro

E d

tm

r

mow

=^

0

~m

N

N~

r

dt N

4

m

N

N

Lo

ON

N

Ln

mv

m

rw

m

vm

r

mr

l

mo

Or

lN

rl

N

r

v

Ln

v

0

N

rl

r

I1

o r r.

mw

r

mm

m

N

N

Ln

om

m

rL

n

mr

r

~n

r

mw

m

vm

r

mr

l

r.L

n

m

o

00

rl

N

~m

rlr

l

UJ

Ln

rl

VN

~N

N

..

I

m

W

v

Ln rl

Page 35: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

I I I Irn

Irn

I8

I*

........ rlN

d

I I

1

mr

lo

mo

om

rv

m

ro

wo

om

lo

m

......... tn

rl m

r

mw

m

m

~n

~

nm

w

riv

m

L

nw

o

NL

~

r

rl

w~

m

m

tn v

or

v

rl

mr

l N

m~

oo

oo

or

i~

o

do

rio

oo

rio

.

..

..

..

..

I I

vw

oo

oo

om

v

vd

om

oo

ow

~n

w

m

v

rim

ma

rl

wo

w

v,

m

wr

l N

ri

Ln m

r. ~n

d+

rlN

N

..

..

..

..

.

~o

om

oo

or

lm

rio

orio

oo

oo

.

..

..

..

..

I 1

1

Nv

,o

v0

00

wN

w

v,

o~

oo

or

r

..

..

..

..

I I

~r

lo

mo

oo

mm

m

mo

mo

oo

oo

.

..

..

..

..

m

m

N

dv,

vv

ri

om

o

v

Ln m

v

mr

i Ln

Ti

ov

ri

ri

N

I I

Ln

ri

ow

oo

oo

o

O~

O~

OO

OO

O

..

..

..

..

r

m

w

om

N

ri

in d

ri

I I

ml

no

mo

oo

oo

r

No

vo

oo

mm

.

..

..

..

..

o

r

m

rid

Lnv

v

om

N

v

w

mm

m

ri

Ln rl

ow

d

ri N

Ln r

w

rl

r- 03 v

m

v

m

ri

N

03 0

m

v

Ln m

m

m

Ln r- rl

m

ri

N

w

r- 0

0

Ln

v

W

ri

m

Ln Ln

C- 0

ri w

ri

N

r I

0

r

v

N

N

Ln N

N

m

m

N

w

ri

N

c c c K d E-c 0

E

ow0

pr

o

...

mr

io

o

vo

o

w

mm

w

r

mr

..

.

mo

r

lLn

mm

o

00

0

..

.

vm

o

mm

o

... v

N

co

d

d' 0

wv

rlv

w m

o

rld

0

..

.

mm

o

Nr

iO

om

r

m

wm

m

a

rim

*.

.

NLn

ON

0

NW

O

rlr- m

rl

..

.

me

m

rl d

Ln

11

m

vo

m

No

.

..

w

rl

PN

w

mw

o

rm

m

m

Lnv

or4

N

Ln

mo

o

...

i3 222

$0

E

EE

H

caq rn

4b

v

r

v

v

w

N

v

w

W

m

m

0

r- N

r

m

v

0

w

m

rl

r

m

v

0

0

m

ri

Ln

N

0

m

m

r

N

I-! I

Ln r

r

m

w

m

Ln

w

m

m

rl r

c c c c d h 0

h

m~

ri

wm

r

wo

rr

.

..

..

rl

rm

ow

m

rl*

oL

nrl

ri

wm

o~

m

oo

rirlo

.

..

..

mm

wv

Ln

r

io

mw

o

rlm

wm

m

ma

rr

m

mm

mo

m

rl

md

m

..

..

.

m

Ln

mm

wr

m

oo

rio

rl

..

I.

.

mm

wv

m

om

ar

nm

m

r-mm

m

mm

rr

rl

m

rl

vv

o

mm

lcw

rl

mm

d

m

N

rl

.....

rlwrfL

nm

o

~v

or

o

wm

mr

m

mm

mo

rlr

iov

r

ri

wm

m

w

ri

..

..

.

rl

m

0

Ln

0

v

m

m

ri

rl

m

0w

rlL

nw

o

mv

om

.

.e

..

m

r

m

rl

m

w

ri

m

m

Ln rl

v

0

m

r

0

W

v

w

m

m

rl

w

0

0

w

rl

P

in N

rl

0

Ln

Ln Ln v

Ln

d

r I

m

Ln

v

m

m

0

0

v

Ln

rl

m

r

c c c c d h 0

h

I 0

00

0

Ln o

oo

o

m

..

..

.

Lno

Ln a3

wD

N

Ln 0

rfr

m

r

m

mw

N

N

N

C- v

N

mm

o

o

m

mm

o

cy o

m *

..

I

.

ooo o r

00

0

0

ID .

..

..

o

ri

4

Ln w

w

N

w

mv

0

m

ri

rl

v

rl

N

ri

~m

mm

o

om

0

..

.

I 0

00

0

00

...

tnm

m

m

rim

Ln d

00

0

00

0

OLn

w

m

..

.

mr

00

0

00

0

om

m

r

v,

m

..

.

rn P

Iv

1

HP

c

xrn

w

rnB

R

PIH

ww

E

zn

o

m

m

0

0

v

v

w

v

rl

0

0

m

0

P

m

0

0

Ln 0

r- m

c c c c d E

0

E

m

ri

0

N

v

0

v

m

rl

w

a, ri

N

N

ri

c-. rl

v

r- v

N

<D

ri

m

r

m

rl

0

w

0

m

m

m

m

v

v

N

c c c c d E-l 0

E-l

1 L?

Page 36: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

ww

w

mm

m

... W

m

W

m

r- N

W

W

rl

ow

0

Nr

lN

...

W

W

wo

w

P q

* rl

W

m

m

m

rl d

m

m

- - 0 d

m E P

ri

0

0

0

- cr m

9' V

d

rld

.

..

cp rl

1

m

E4 z 0

5: - 0

z

d

m

m

N

4'

0

W

m

W

m

E4 .I% * E4

01 d

0

E4

z In

W

m

0

rl

E4 w z

0

W

r- m

N

r-

W

N

N

m

hl

0

W

dX

r- 0

T

i

%m

mm

mo

r-

mo

tG

Nm

NN

r-rlwO

m

mO

mm

rlN

0

-w

m

mw

om

W

N

Nr

lO

Il

l

rlm

-

0-

FC

F

00

0

0

00

N

N

0

0

0

r-m

00

N

W

NN

W

N

r-m

Od

rld

.I

m

N

N

m

Page 37: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

I 0

00

0

rl

00

0

0

m

mo

m

d

NO

N

w

rlrl

N

rl

t- r

-a

m

m

m

0

ll

n

ar

lo

mo

om

rlm

N

m

mo

w

a

mv

wm

v

*

mm

o

r-mrl

9,

ma

, r-

rlcv

ma

w

m

mN

r-

mN

t- a,

0-3

m

m

mm

mm

rl

W-;F

a

mm

m

m NP

m

u'r

lmr

l- rl

m~

m

rlw

m

m

w-r

o

wd

mm

w

m

am

m

a

u-

am

m

P

om

or

-o

om

wr

l

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

rl

WN

O

m

mm

mw

m u*

..

..

.

0 0

Nm

W

N

Q

' rl

b

r- r

lr

l

m

4m

NW

m

m

r- N

C

ON

N

~c

no

o

m

mr

lo

N

rl

N .

..

..

I 0

00

0

w

00

0

0

m

00

0

m

am

r-

m

Nm

w

-P

r- r

-N

m

0

W

2 'm

O&

OW

OO

Od

q

W

ON

0

N

NO

dO

N

W

IW

1

2;

r

No

oo

oo

am

.

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

.

a

wm

o

Q,

r-mm

rlr- N

.

..

..

m

d

w

arl

rl

av

mh

lrl

t- a

o

m

rlrl

m

om

~r

lm

w m

e

wm

r-

o a

AM

a

r-r- v

m

w

r-

u'

10

m

e

17

mm

4

I Im

wt

-

mm

m

N

w

r- Lo

I m

m

wm

rl

rlm

m

0

0

am

o

m d

N~

O

m

rl

..

..

.

I I

I 0

00

0

m

00

0

0

d

IC

.

nr

lo

mo

oo

Nr

-

rl

cr

mo

r-

m~

e~

m

w

IE

m

qo

mo

oo

oo

m

w

wo

N

r-m

rlmw

m

Lor-

N

m

qw

N

m

w

om

m

d

w

rl

aw

r-

mm

m

m

rl

m

w

I m

r- o

e

mm

03

ma

m

q

mrn

toq

~ N

r(m

m

a

I at- a

PN

W

IC

wm

o

mr

lm

m~

r(

wr

lr

lm

a

N~

~P

N a

~m

I r

-N

N

I

rlm

m

I

P

Ir

l

I1

;* dr-. .;

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

.

..

..

I N

W

w

ma

r-

m

U*N

r-

r-

~r

la

m N

d

03 rl

rlr

l

rl

r-

rl

m

mm

W

rl

I I im

r

l~

~o

mo

oo

ma

e

ww

o

N

mm

mm

m

o

m

oo

o

o

w

IF

w

~~

om

oo

om

m

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

.

w

N

O

m

PN

N~

~

o

m

00

0

o

m

wr-

m

md

w

o

mw

mm

a

d

or-

r- cn

at-

rn

wm

q

am

ww

rl

rl o

04

rl

N

IO

w

w

rl

IZ

m

m

rl

I--. do

m

IE-1

e

r- m

IW

mu

* q

I I

1

I

..

..

.

FC

n d

m

P7

rlQs

mm

Q

' W

U

*P

rl

07 4

Nm

r- N

mw

rl

m

om

m

mo

-

r- m

9'

N

NN

m

Nm

m

cr

m

N

I I

I ffl

mr

l0

00

00

00

r-

om

0

m

m

om

t-

o

m

It

w

w

r-

P

ww

w

w

rlr

l

I I

I

rnP

N

N0

m0

00

00

.

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

03

ew

o 0

r- .

.

E-1E

grl

HZ

mw

WD

'ir m

Iffl

N

13

r-

lb

in

Id

mm

r-

dW

00

0

v

w

Pm

N

r-

m

w

rl

m

rl

W

m

cn N

I I I

I m

mo

mo

oo

ma

rl

wa

o

m

om

am

m

w

m

oo

o

o

P

I m

~o

wo

oq

mm

.

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

.

m

am

o

m

ON

N~

N

r- m

ooo o

I;F

I

mr-

m

am

m

a

mm

m

m o

orl

rl

cn Iffl

dN

r-

r-cn

m

mrl

o

rlv

mm

0

m

wr-

rl

\o

lffl

md

rl

mr-

N e

rl

Nd

0

m

IO

0

30

rn

I

d

wr-

m

N

IC1

m

q q

Im

I

N

I I

II

I

..

..

.

wt-

w

wr-

e

mw

mo

m

rl

or-

r- rl

mq

cu

N

N

am

rl

a

rl

m

NO

m

e

N

m

Page 38: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

6 0

d*

mo

m

... rl

m

0 .

ff

l

dW

W

-d

0

C)

m

du

m

. f

flW

N

m

Ur

l

-d 3

u u 0

0

. -d

uw

3

2 $45;

5

o wa

rl

0

0

d

m

N

mr-m

m

Nm

m

wm

V

mm

m

mm

w

mr-

mm

0

0

01 m

0

0

00

0

00

0

rld

d

... rl

05

i

m4

rl

0

rl

N

m

W

hl

N

m

WF-m

L

DN

W

mw

m

u' m

m

mm

m

qm

r

00

m

m

m

rl

m

m

m

5 r- m

W

rl

V

m

6

N 6

m

ffl

0

0

00

0

00

0

ddd

... 0

0

d

mr

o

mo

m

m

VW

W

mrlr-

06

-3

mw

N

N

01

N

m

mm

rc

d

d 5 m

mw

ww

o

~-1

r

lm

ow

m~

...... E-4

mm

6o

wm

W

or

mm

wo

Z

r

ma

r-

6

Nd

W

rl

m

N

rl

r- rl

m

m

m

N d

N

m

0

rl

x

5: r m

m m

N N

m o

M 01 0

N N

m W

Q

' 0

m6

Om

mN

mo

~

mm

m

wo

m

WN

N

rl

O

d

d

Il

l

om

w

o

W6

N

0

u'o

m

0

WN

m

W

N

mm

m

dp

r

or

r-m

m

mm

d

w

m rn

iw

.. I Iffl

Iffl

IU

I2

N

m

-. . ..

0-

3~

0

mm

w

mrl

am

m

w

a

-

N

N

Nm

d

rl

3: 8

M cc W PI

\

-dm

wm

rlu+

m

WN

mo

m

mm

w

rt c

nC

6

d3

d

dZ

H

m

m

rc V

m

rl

Page 39: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

Si

om

0

mo

o

ON

4 ...

00

0

00

0

Om

W

m

rl

rl

...

00

0

00

0

rfrl

...

00

0

00

0

Om

W

O

rl

rl

..

I

00

0

00

0

rlrl

.I

.

I 0

00

0

00

mm

r

lm

mm

N

... ~m

rm

.

.

rl

ON

0

0

mw

.

.

r

dm

0

A

m

om

0

..

..

. U

a v

mo

mo

oo

o~

o

oo

cn

oo

oo

m

......... rlrl

I I

I

j~

om

oo

o-

m

3N

OW

OO

OI

om

.........

IW

1

3:

IO

I I $9

I I I la

I

R

I*

I I I I I I I I

d 4

WU

*3

: V

R o\o

0 X

IR

I

Z

2 18 I I I I I I

r C

rl

rl

m

m

0 w W

N

4

rlp

I \

m

0 \

N

0

W

R 4

a z

2 N

r-l \

rl

d

* 0

c 4 m

;r: N

rl -,

ri

dm

~o

m m

>~

wo

m

m

..

..

..

r-

WN

O

m

N

mo

o

m

..

..

.

Q-

m~

0

m

or-

m

o

mrl

0

rl

ow

r-

N

~r

- m

m

rl

rl

0

0

rl

0

0

Lo

rl

rl

m

0

0

rl

0

0

0

0

N

r

m

m

W

m

W

0

0

rl

N

0

W

r- Lo W

m

W

m

0

0

rl

N

0

m

cr m

P

l m

rl

W

0

m

N

m

N

m

r

rl

W

W

N

Lo Q

i

m 6

m

U rl

W

30

00

0

0

30

00

0

0

-Id+ 4

4

..

..

..

0

00

0

0

00

0

rl

rlr

l .

..

. C C 3

3

-I

n

n 3

T

3

Ln

.

0

0

4

W

I

33 6

10 m

m

W

rl

m

m

m

6

W I

m

0

7-4 m

m

m

m

m

m

rl

W

c * c *

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

rlrl

rl

rlrlrl

.........

I I

I

OW

o m

o o

o m

* m

ON

OW

OO

OL

Om

.........

wm

o

omo

qN

P

P

Wo

o

m

m

mm

W

mm

m

r

lw

~

mw

6

W

xm

~o

m

m

n~

wo

m

m

..

..

..

r-

WN

O

N

mo

o

..

..

us

m N

m

m

r- o

md

rl

ow

N

N

P

I

.. rf W

0

0

rl

W

W

W

W

N

rl

W

P

N

Nr

l

W

0

0

rl

6

W

m

m

m

m

0

N

- W

m

m

m

0

m

N

I N

N

m

r

W

m

W

r- 0

rl

N

m

* r * c $2

4

E-,

0

R

00

00

0

00

00

0

rlrlrlrlrl

..... 0

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

rlrl

rl

......... rlrl

00

0

00

0

rlrl

...

mo

o

mm

o

e.

.

Nm

4

, 0

N-

NW

rlr-

mo

o

NO

-0

N

4'

NW

mm

o

... rlr

I1

w

mo

m

rl

o

... P

W

NN

mm

o

rlm

o

om

...

1-N

N

-

Fir-

NW

X

I N

~O

NO

OO

N~

r

lr

lo

mo

oo

mm

.........

hm

mw

o

mN

Orl.(h

l m

mm

mN

m

m-

mw

m

rlm

m

0-

0

r

N

....

m

..

Q

-W

PP

W

m

Wr

l

Wd

mw

m

d

m rl

r-r

l m

m

m

m

Nrl

-;S

r

N

I 0

00

G

00

0

0

LnLn

0

..

..

I

N~

ON

OO

ON

~

w

rl

rl

om

oo

om

m

w

vm

m

r-r-

w

mw

m

w

m

N

rlm

rl

Wr

l

rl

r-rl

m

wr

l m

m

m

m

r- N

rl -

N

r- N

.......... m

Lo

mW

0

mm

mm

~

~m

vm

w

mrlm

m

0

-0

r

N

Ln

NO

rlN

.....

m

m

m

m 0 Q

%

N

r m

m

m

r

0

* N

m

w u n

W

0

* d

2 2 ;I: 2 u

~.

rl m

4'

mm

0

NN

I N

N

m

m

I

I m

rl

or

-o

oo

oo

m

r

rm

om

oo

oo

o

o

r- 4'

m

m

u*

m

I

..

..

..

..

..

r- N

W

N

m

Lo

m

r

m

0

m

00

0

0

r- 0

00

0

w

rlm

- o

..

..

.

mm

o

r

ww

o

r

N

~m

N 4

W

m~

om

oo

o&

m m

mm

om

oo

om

m

P

..

..

..

..

..

o

m 0

rr

m

o

rl

m

wm

rl

wm

m

W

rl

N

m

rl r

wr

l m

N

wm

m

N

rl

4*

r

OL

nW

WN

O

NO

rl-

mm

mr

cn

-mm

rlm

m

..... 6

0

r- N

I im

Iffl

IW

I I I IS

r- N

I

R

z W

I

Page 40: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

00

0

‘if Lo Q’

... I

U

13

: I L) I I

o\o

0

Lo

W

Lo

in

I

R

1%

I I I I

v

0

d

0

Lo

I-O

r-

‘ifm‘if

...

oE

r

-A

r

m

r- N

r- v

Lo ‘if

Io

N

d

‘if

m

m

m

m

N

‘if

ffl 4

0

E+

R w z

z

mm

m

orn

o

mo

-

m Q

* a

mm

N

?O

r-

r-

m

NN

W

N

N

Lo

0

d

3: E

00

0

00

0

ddd

... I

U

13

:

IV

I I

OP

I

0

0

0

-2

3: €i

z 0

E2

ffl E+* r

R

a

H

c7

H

~m

d~

mm

mm

o

d~

~o

wa

mw

d~

r

-r

-r

-m

oo

wm

d

r-

mp

vm

wo

N

WW

vm

r-‘if ~m

dm

N

rl

. . . . , . . .

d

I I I It

I

>

WW

N

mN

N

wm

o

ad

d

-v

m

wm

m

mm

N

N

m

N

N

m

I I I I lr

IR

I

Z

I.. IR

I

W

II

Z

I ‘d

)W

I

V

18

:rx

a3 N

N

Lo r

td

o~

ln

~w

mm

o

m-

rm

Lo

m~

mo

N

WW

m

om

d

rl

~d

WO

ln

ON

00

WN

N

rl

O

0

zL

od

Wr

wlo

I-

0

mm

w

mo

m‘if

dm

rlr

lm

N

d

R

dr

(N

rl

Nr

lN

rl

N

>

E-I rl N

N m

m Q

, ‘if

Il

l

wo

w

0

mw

rl

o

ww

ln

0

rld

m

lf

fl

HZ

?

RC

E+

Iffl

13

Ih

la

:

I I I I I Iffl

Iffl

IO

I

d

la

iffl€i

1Z

W

in

m

N

N

m

r

5 .. d w (4

m

m

r- m

a

3 S

W

tda

d

W u*

A*

ffl*

3

%

W

3

z W

d

6 4

0

R

d

Page 41: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

lo

1

3:

I C

) I I

O\Q

I I I la

IE

-1

I*

I I I I I I I I

d

*m V

E-1 ov

m

a: 4

3w

m

IE-1

I

Z

10

15

: I I I I I I

mm

om

oo

wo

w

rl

mr

lo

m

m

mrlm

m

N

mo

ow

oo

mo

m

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

e

ww

o

w

Q*

N~

OV

Q

C~

'

I I

1

r-o

oo

oo

o~

*o

m m

mo

r-

~o

r-

md

m

w

om

w

r- N

W

rl

mw

m~

~

m

wr

l m

r-w

w

m

00

rl

NO

NN

O o

am

m

m

wm

rl

PI-

FF m

ww

mr

m

~m

m

rlw

rl rl

ow

m

r-

mrlw

Q

* W

N

r- -cy

m

N

mw

rl

rl

rlr

l

mm

O

N

m

~m

ow

oo

ow

~r

(

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

m

~

r-

0

o

om

w~

w

N

w

wm

W

~O

OO

OO

OO

~

m

mw

o

m

eo

~o

m

m

Q+

Ln

OL

oO

OO

OW

.

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

.

4'

Q+

-0

lO

U3

QS

Oe

FF

rl

I r-~

.o

rlo

oo

o~

w

N

~O

m

o

mm

mw

P

'

am

m

N

I- m

m

w

o

~r

m~

m

m

mm

N

m

w

rl

wm

m

L

ON

ON

CJ

~

m

mr-

rl

wm

m

rlm

wm

m

m

m o

m~

N

m

N~

N

w

mr-

m

mw

r-

I

~m

om

oo

od

r-

.

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

.

N

mr

-o

o

~N

NN

W

w

rl

mr

lr

-

mw

Pr-

0 W

4'

rlrl

m

NN

0

m

lw 0

00

00

00

00

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

I rlrl

r(

drl

rl

r(rlr(rl?

! rl

I$

99

99

99

99

9

9 9

99

9

99

99

9

9

vw

o

m

N

am

0

r- =?

~m

m

..

..

.

II

I

00

0

0

v-4 0

00

0 a

..

..

.

0

r-

mo

o

m

om

0

N

Q'

drl

4

..

..

.

II

I

00

0 o

m

00

0

0

m

00

o

m

r-w

m

2-4 m

m

m

N

w

mm

m

m

..

..

.

w

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

drl

rl

,+ .

..

..

ooo o

m

00

0

0

w

or(

rl

m

0.4

rl

w

or-

I- m

~

FF

m

m

rl

rt

w

m

N

II

a

~~

mo

mo

om

mm

m

m

mo

rl

mw

mo

o

m

I*

I m

r- r-

rlm

w

IC

wm

m

~

m-

wm

m

I N

U)

FF rl

m

NA

w

m

rlwrlm

m

I

mw

m

rl

~r

lo

~

NP

m

o

rl

m~

w

mm

m

4'

I rlrl

w

Im

N

iE-1

r- o

r-ooow

m

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

m

rlr

lo

m

ow

~s

or

l w

.

..

..

I

mu

N

WOY

m

U)N

P

m

mw

rlw

NN

m

I

N

I

II

w

mo

mo

ow

mm

r

~o

ro

oo

mm

m

w

N

wo

r- m

?

r- rlm

u*

NO

-

LD

d

mw

m

rl

~

rl

drl

w

m

N .........

I m

mo

r-

oo

oo

o

rl

mo

r-

00

00

0

rlm

m

.........

wo

O

N

mm

o

rlrl0

ON

Nr

l

ON

N

W

... m

m

orlo

r-m

o

mm

N

rl

... P

* m

rl

m

r- FF N

m

m

i(

0

rl

m

m

mm

mo

o

om

-a

<o

d

.....

W

m

m

0

m

m

m

m

m

N

r- m

m

w

m

m

0

FF N

m

W

m

m

m

m

m

N

N

m

r- FF N

00

0

00

0

0

0

rl

rl

r- m

rl

W

m

m

r- N

m

rl

0

m

N

W

0

0

m

N

ID

I I I m

r-

ow

oo

mm

m

a mro o

om

mo

w

r- m

ooo o

w

I ooo o

m

I i(o

r-o

rl

wo

r-

o

mw

w

m

wr

lm

w

N

or(

rl

r- i

m N

P

m

rlm

w

N

mrl

m

mw

wo

o

m

od

rl

e

IO

N

U3

W

rl

0

00

0

dW

dN

N

[-.

0-

P

t- m

o

w

r(

~*

m o

rl

rl

m

m

N

II

mw

om

oo

ow

m

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

.

w

ww

o

m

om

wo

m

m

N

..

..

.

mQ

'N

N

N

Ul'fl $

rl

N

03 O

N

N

rl

m

NW

m

m

I

m

N

IN

I I

(I]

w

A

Page 42: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

5, c

m

m

-m

a

Nm

N

...

4'

W

Io m

rl

E4 o

c

m4

m

ew

o

mm

N

NP

O

mm

m

mm

Cn

mm

m

mm

d

rl

d

W

4 N

N

0

m

-3

N

m

0

rl

X

E -$ 0

N

03 m

m

0

0

rl

00

0

00

0

rlrld

...

0

0

do

-2

3: E

z

00

m

C

H

m -6

.r

n

0

Esr

d

XdR

0

P 3 03 N

N

m

........ E

~

or

,m

mm

mm

w w

r-mr-rlt-o

rl z

rm

w

mc

nt-w

r

lm

Nd

m

d

0

m

N

m

W

N

01 m

m-m

N

OW

m

Nr

l in W

4'

U' m

m

vm

r- d

rl

m

m

0

m

0

0

m

m

N

d

0

4

0

0

0

m

N

N

m

mw

m

ow

o

rn

m

om

ww

w

ow

e

mr-

mo

rl

d

Nm

.-id

wm

t- m

m

.. ~

n

m

m-

3: E .. d w 14

d

m

m

rl

a

3 EW

sa

W 3

z W d

5 4

0

E

2

Page 43: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

IC1

1

3:

I CI

I ow I I I la

I

E4

I

%

I I I I I I I I

z X UW

Ha: V

i o\o

2 a: IE

4

IZ

I

O

IC

I I I I W

3: V

O\Q

1 E- %

3: E4 z 0

C

\

E4 W

z (I)

H

Q'N

Ort0

00

0N

N

OO

mO

OO

Om

.........

I I

I

-m

or

oo

or

-~

m

mo

mo

oo

~m

NW

N

o

mm

r

t~

9'

r-4

-

mrl

r

mo

o

mo

l o

~W

N

m .........

om

Q

' w

u,

r-- rt

lf

)N

OW

OO

OO

Gl

N

mo

mo

oo

o~

.

..

..

..

..

I I

No

or

-o

oo

w~

r-N

r-

mm

N

d

PC

P

' r- m

m

m

NW

N

O

r- 0

mw

cr

N

Nrl

N

r-m

or-O

OO

WN

.........

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

rld

rl

drl

.........

I I

rt

or

to

oo

cr

m

il

wo

wo

oo

r-

o

mm

N

r-m

crm

o

......... r- Q

* N

O

N

NO

m

rl

m r

t P

' N

0

N

I I

r-

rlo

rto

oo

cr

m

ww

ow

oo

or

-0

r-6

N

O

N

mm

N

r-0

, 9

10

1

0

W0-7

NO

m

rt

m r

t P

, N

0

N

.........

II

I

mN

ON

00

00

0

ID Lo 0

Q' 0

0 0

0 0

crm

N

u

-m

0

ow

W

.........

I I

wm

om

oo

o~

m

mo

oo

oo

or

-0

.........

m

N

m

N

W

xr

0

V?

W

CD

m

m

N

m

r- m

N

m

rl

N

m

m

0

0

rt

N

0

r-.

m

0

7.4

cr rt

N

N

0

r- 0

rt

cr rl

N

m I

W

W

N

10 m

m

m

W

m

r- rl

m

rl

N

m

* * * c il 4

E4 0

E+

&LO

O

mN

o

...

WN

O

Nm

O

crm

...

PO

r-m

w

w

mm

rl

m ua

o

NN

O

...

mm

o

ad0

40

r-0

O

N

rt-

... w

m

00

0

00

0

rld

...

cu

m0

w

oo

mo

W

N

mo

P

O

rlm

...

NW

O

wo

o

mo

W

N

mo

r

o

...

rlm

II

T

mo

m

mo

...

wo

9' 0

N

rl

wr

to

Q

'd

O

u,O

rlN

drt

rtm

... m

o X

d x

xw

W

HH

3:

Wc

7V

E442

fflc7

ki

p4

m

$$2

W

N

m

d

W

W

W

m

N

m

m

N

rt

rt

N

N

Q'

W

r-

0

0

rl

m

W

m

m

m

P

W

m

W

m

m

m

r

W

I N

N

r- P

' W

r

m

m

W

N

W

m

* c

e * t.2

0

E4 2

r-m

wa

m

Nrtr-N

N

.....

Q'ln

NW

W

rtt-

oo

m

..... o

rlm

mm

m

mm

wm

m

mm

mc

r 0

OQ

'rt

mr

l-

4

W

WW

rO

NW

m

mv

wr

l

.....

Nm

mm

m

rlN

rlr

-w

r-r-O

)N

O

wN

oP

4'm

o

mr-o

r- m

v

m-0

.....

W

m

00

00

0

00

00

0

rlrlrlrlrt

.....

dr

tW

Q'

d

wm

crr-w

mm

mrtm

Q

'mr

lrlO

m

rtm

rlm

N

r-rtN

m

W

rl

.....

- 0

W

r- m

N

6

d

m

W

N

m

ortm

Q+

rl 0

rO

Tr

-W

..... m

mrtm

m

rlr

ld

rtmrtlD

r-rlN

W

rl

W

N

W

rl

W

W

W

r- m

W

-? rt

r- m

m

N

N

m

m

0

0

rl

m

N

W

N

m

rt

rt r

m

N

W

N

m

rl

74

r- I 0

r- N

d

W

m

m

m

m

Pl

4

r- rl

c

c * c

4

0

E4

d

W

W

W

m

m

- N

W

W

W

m

6

N

m

(I) W

V

H

>

lz w 0 %

d

il H

V

z 4

2

mw

o

mr

lo

...

rtr

- 0

rl

I 0

00

0

00

00

O

W

IO ..

.

mr

to

m

4' 0

cr W

...

I 00

0

00

0

00

r

tW

W

... a

m

00

0

00

0

drl

...

II

0

00

0

00

00

Q

'W

OQ

' r

lW

...

I1

0

00

0

00

00

Q

'W

OQ

' d

W

...

I1

0

00

0

00

00

P

' m

0-9

dW

...

ffl &

ff

l

n&

Z

fflW

fflB

Q

dH

Wf

fl

d

WW

B

C:a

O

gg;

P'

N

m

rt

I 0

0

0

m

Q*

m

Q4

r-

0

0

ID m

W

W

0

0

d

I 0

0

0

r- - r- I 0

0

0

r- - r- I 0

0

0

r- Q

' r- c c c %

A

0

E4

d

m

N

W

r-

N

0

N

N

W

P'

m

m

N

u, m

N

d

rl

W

W

N

m

rl

0

d

0

W

r

m

m

N

W 6

N

W

m

0

Q'

r- Lo 6

01

m

m

0

W

0

m

P'

m

- m

r- m

m

r-

0

P'

N

c * c * 4

0

E4 a

d 3 W

Page 44: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

m

N

I I N

rl

m

0

N

Ln N

O%

N

w

0

rl

m

0

co N

N

Ln

ri 0

r

Ln *

I I I I I I u i

$ ..

ti 0

Ln rl

m

* m

rl 0

e m

3 P 0

P

0

0

rl

00

0

00

0

rir

lrl

..

.

0

0

ri

0

N

m

0

rl

00 N

N

m

02 N

N

0

N

m

Ln r-! m

0

w

rl

Ln rl

rl

N

Ln

0

0

0

m

N

N

m

I I I lm

I

m

IO

;?$ I I

0

N

* m

2 P 0 P

Page 45: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

w~

oc

ro

oo

ow

r

l0

0N

00

00

m

.........

I I

I

0 r 0

m 0

0 0

N N

co cr o

cr o o

o m

r

.........

mo

om

oo

oo

m

rlm

ON

OO

OO

m

.........

I I

wm

om

oo

om

o

N m

0 0

0 0

0 0

N

..

..

..

..

.

..

m

r

mm

m

cr m

N

P

m

mW

cr

ro r

or!

cr A

N

N

mu) t- N

00

00

00

00

0

0 0

0 0

0 0

0 0

0

rid

rl

rlr

lrl

.........

11

w

m 0

m 0

0 N

N Ln

mm

oo

oo

mm

m

crm

rl

mm

cr

mo

0

rlmc

r m

cr r

NO

m

r

m

cr r

8-4 ......... c

rrl Lo N

I I

I

w m

0 m

0 0

N N

m

mm

oo

oo

mm

m

..

..

..

..

.

..

rl

mm

cr

mo

o

rim

+

crd

m

m

cr

r- N

N

O

m

c-m

cr

C - v

r.0

m

w

cr

ow

r r

-I N

riO

rl

rlr

lmr

lrl

rl

..

..

..

..

..

.

m

r-!

I I

I r

l0

0w

oO

N0

0

rN

or

lo

om

oo

r

N r-

m

m

rl

......... N

1 I

rm

om

o0

0N

LO

mcr

mc

r N

m

m

drl

cro 0

m

wc

r P

N

NO

m

r. m

cr

r rl

~n

oo

rl

-r

oo

om

m

.........

oro

rl r

l 0.

.. 0

0

rw

c

rr

rdl

mo

N

r o

mt-crc-m

w

N

O~

(N

~

N

mm

wm

o

cr m

rlm

mm

N ..

..

..

rl

Nr

ld

r

mN

m

rl

m

r

Ln cr m

cr cr r

o

vm

o

m

mc

rmrlm

N

m

m

No

o

m~

wr

nr

w .

..

..

..

..

..

cv

md

r

mw

dm

d

N

m

mm

cr

mm

mw

cr

rl

m

wm

m

m

m~

ww

m r

lw

m

or

mw

w

rm

r

-d

cr

w

m

m

r-i

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

rl

rl

rlr

lrlr

lrl

rl

..

..

..

..

..

.

mr

lo

cr

p

ocro

rl

rl

d

..

..

.

II

I

00

0

0

mm

0

00

0

o

r

NW

w

crcr

rl

rlw

r

N

m

..

..

.

do0

m

m

wo

o

m

..

..

.

rl

II

I

00

0

0 0

00

0

0

0

*..

* *

d

N

ooo o

m

00

0

0

w

m

mm

o r

wc

rmm

m

0

p

~r

lo

cr

~m

mm

cr

N

..

..

.

..

..

..

..

..

.

00

o

m

mc

r w

N

m

m

c- w

m

oc

rr

lrl

m

m

w

wm

wm

m

m

rl

00

m

m

r

N

r.w

m

r

lrlo

mm

rl

~r

rl

m

m+

Nm

cr

NN

0

rlr

l

N

rl

rl

cr

m

m

m

rl

I

m

mm

o p

wc

rm

mm

o

r

oo

o

o

m

~m

mm

y N

m

oo

o

o

N

r ~

rl

o

. .

..

? ....

m

mr

w

m

oc

rr

lrl

m

N

00

o

N

m

dc

r w

w

mw

mm

m

N

m

cr

w

m

(u

rw

m

r

lrlo

mm

rl

+ rl

ow

m

m

rl

P

~r

rl

m

mc

rm

md

'

NN

N

0

rl

rl

N

r

lr

lc

r

mm

m

rl

..

..

..

.

I I

I

mm

m

a,

mm

N

N

I I

I

m

mm

o

cr u)

m

40

0

N

N

wm

m

rf

m

..

.

..

..

.

mw

rl

W

m

oc

r

m

w

m

r- r m

I cr

pqo

rl o

cr

mm

rl

m r

ooo o o

m

*N

O r

om

mm

m

o

m

oo

o

o

r

..

..

..

..

..

..

.

..

..

N

r

lw

r o

qr

lm

m

N

0

0

o

m

o

wm

rl

mw

mr

l w

N

m

cr

w

w

w

rw

cr

rlo

m.0

rl

cr rl

ow

m

m

m

cr

mm

cr

m

N

NN

0

N

rrl

m

rlr

l

N

rl

dc

r m

m

rl

m

w c

Page 46: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

0

0 .(I]

rlw

w d

ov

r- m

um

.

mP

N

3

2 2

2i

wd

p: 3

V V 0

0

E

o wa

. dVW

d

-O

W

rl

Nd

0

N

..

.

cr

NW

c

ra

m

mN

N

qc

'N

o

m0

m

wo

N

rlcr

4r

l

rlr

l

0

cr rl

w

N

> d 4

ww

Wm

I

V

cr a 9

' d

rld

0

N

...

a

r- m

N

N

m

mw

m

oa

a

WN

W

NW

rn

4W

cr

d V

I 9'

ww

r

lr

l

0

m

w

m

cr

0

rl

3: E

I

0

0

0

0

00

0

00

0

rlrlrl

...

rl

NW

rlr-m

mN

o

CD

WW

c

'mrl

mw

d

rl

md

a

dN

W

rlr-m

WN

O

wc

rm

r-

Wd

m

w

rlr

l

mr

la

Il

l

Lo

om

m

om

o

mm

0

0

cr

cr

0

-2

3: H

z

0

CH

-

d

rl

d

0

r- W

0

rl

m

N

N

m

I I I I N

I

dI

-

.I

L

o1

!

0

r- W

cr r- 0

m

N

N

m

d

..

N

0

d

0

rl

W d

rl

d

rl

0

z a w

w c'

PI m

m d

mm

w

mo

wc

r

rlm

N

r

ldm

rl

H

dr

lN

rl

Nr

lN

dN

W

Pd

rl

NN

WW

cr

cr

0

0

0

m

N

N

m

W w+

4%

(I]+

3

+

W 3

z W p:

f-6

a

0

H

z c

"c

7

c3

Page 47: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

m

m

m

0 W

#

Na:

rl@

m .. rl -. W

0

W

P

2 z 3

d

N

rl .. m

p: H

0 z tl il H

m N

rl \

m

IW

13

:

10

I I o\o

I I IE

i I

*

I I I I I I I I in

d

w3

: V

Ed dQ

rn

3u

5 1% 3: IE

i l

Z

1 I I I I I W 3: C

)

OiD

a

E 3: E

i

e 9 i; .

1 Irn

lrn

I

O

IP

;

I#

I

mm

om

oo

mO

hI

r

l0

0r

l0

0N

ON

.........

I I

I

rlu

'o uq o o o m

m

0 N

0 u

, 0 0

0 m

rl

......... o

w

m

Op

lU

' p

m

m

wm

~

dm

m

d

r-m

dW

m

N

PO

m

m

m

wm

....

Wm

N

N

rl

u-

do

oo

or

-o

m

rl

NO

NO

ON

ON

.........

I I

1

rlr

-o

mo

oo

rld

~

r-

om

oo

o~

u-

m

v

rl

ow

m

~m

rl

mo

m

......... 0.6

pl

mm

d

mr-

r- rl

worn

u- N

m

rl

rl

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

?id

rl

dd

rl

.........

I I

1

r-

do

rn

oo

op

l~

w

r-

o~

oo

o~

rn

.........

c-v

0

mm

o

u-u- m

o

om

o

m

W

Wm

o

mrl

m

0

Nr-

u- N

P

rl

I I

I

Pr

lo

mo

oo

plW

w

r-or-O

OO

PL

D

PV

0

mo

o

u-p

l m

o

om

o

m

W

Wm

o

mr

l m

0

Nr-

u- N

P

4 .........

II

I

d rl 0

N 0

0 rl 0

0

mm

om

oo

wo

o

mr-

o

W

......... m

rl

u- N

P'

rl

rl

m

N

m

r- 0

m

0

N

rl

pl

rl

m

m

m

m

W

10

v

r- 4

0

0

rl

r- m

m

r- r- d

N

r- rl

P

m

m

r t'

r-

rl

N

rl

P

0

m

m

rl

0

m

m

0

m

rl

N

rl

r-

* * * * 2 €-I

0

Ei

mp

lo

rlr

lo

.. 1

mm

o

mr

-o

u-m

p

lm

mm

... m

N

00

N

mu

-o

?

Id

0

...

mm

o

mm

o

u-m

m

w

mo

... W

O

rlu-

00

0

00

0

rld

...

-33 r- 0

m P

* o

mo

m

pl

mr

l

... P

O

49

u-r-0

m

US o

mo

m

u-

mrl

...

PO

rlp

l

om

o

m U

' o

... m

u-

P

N

Q* r;F

0

WO

O

VW

rlrl

r-0

du-

... N

m x 2

$22

2s2

xx

w

3: WtlV

Ra

:Z

vlt

lh

m

rl

m

m

m

W

N

rl P

m

m

rl

d

P'

m

r

m

0

m

0

0

rl

rl

cr 0

u- m

P

m

rl

pl

0

u- m

P

m

m P

m P

N

m

W

0

W

01 P

m

* * * * 2 &I 0

H

C4

rlmr-w

rlr

loo

rl

..

I.

.

wm

r-r-m

~p

lm

mm

m

wo

r-p

l P

W~

NO

N

WW

LO

rl

mrlm

mrl

N

m

.....

WN

pl

mrlr

lop

l rlm

mo

rl .....

mo

r-or-

~m

wo

rn

.....

mm

m

m

plm

o o

wm

m

m

U'm

P

0

N

rl

00

00

0

00

00

0

rlrtrlrld

.....

~m

rl

mm

~

~m

pl

cr

o

u-

PW

m

i-m

om

w

~r

lw

mr

l

d

m

m

m .....

rl

I

0

P

N

0

N

N

N

m

P

m

m

om

?im

d

ow

mu

-m

mo

mw

m

..... u

-r-wr!

dW

mN

r

lm

4

W

rl

N

m

m

m

m

m

W P

m

rl

P'

0

pl

v

Ut

N

rl

m

0

0

rl

r- m r

m

m

rl

v

rl

P

m

r

m

m

rl

u- rl

I

0

N

m

m

0

0

0

m

u- rl

u- rl

* * * * tl 4

H

0

E+

m

m

r- m

rl

9'

N

m

m

rl P

pl

N

m

ffl W V H

>

d

W

ffl

2 2 2 tl H

V

NN

O

plm

o

m

...

1 0

00

0

00

mm

0

-

rlrl

... m

m

r-

mo

m

oo

...

m

00

0

00

0

00

...

mrl

mm

P

00

0

00

0

drl

...

00

0

00

0

LO

O

vrl

u-rl N

rl

...

00

0

00

0

in

0

vrl

crrl N

rl

...

00

0

00

0

LO

O

u-rl

plrl

N

rl

..

.

rn @

rn

H

I&

ZrnW

wE

ia

dH

Wrnd

mow

ccL

3:

WWH

zn

o

m

m

m

N

0

0

0

N

u-

W r

m

d

0

0

0

0

m

m

0

0

rl

0

0

m

m

m

N

rl

0

0

In

ro In

N

4

0

0

m

m

m

N

rl

* n * * tl

0

Ed

$

u- rl

P

In

d

W

P

pl

W

m

rl

m

u- rl

rl

m

W

m

m

N

m

m

rl

rl

0

rl

N

m

r- pl

m

W

rl

m

m

0

m

m

m

m

m

ID

m

rl

Q*

0

d

m

W

N

m

W

u- m

rl

N

r- m

m

rl

* * * * $4

a: Ei

0

E+

z l=z d 0

n

6

Page 48: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

m

m -

VI

W u d

0

C)

r- in

vo

.

mE

-iin

B

41 H

i u

d

d

3

V

V

00

5

o wa

. d

cJ

W

WO

W

dNd

0

N

... - c-l

a: 0

m

m

0 w u Na:

rl

Qr

-. in

0

\

r- 0

W

E-i

2 z 3 d N

rl \

W

d

sr 2 H

m N d .. W

la

1

3:

IV

I I

o\o I I I I

Et

Is

r

I I I I I I I I

d

*3:

v

Et d3 m in

3"

5 IB

3: IE

t

IZ

I I I I I I

dr

l

00

0

00

0

0

0

...

Et 0

0

02

in

0

0

0

W

m

W

N

-J

m

W

N

4'

m

m d

0

Et

Et W z

2

0

0

00

0

00

0

rld

d

...

NW

W

mm

d

Nw

m

mw

d

rl 4

' W

rl

WW

w

m

dd

NW

m

mm

rl

NW

m

mm

d

d Q

' w

rl m

4'

mm

d

d

II

m

in

r-r- m

m

0

0

u 3: V

o\o

a

E-i sr 3: Et z

0

c Et W 0

..

d

0

r- Q

'

rl

m

N

N

m

0

rl

0

r- 4,

0

rl

m - r- m

0

In m

m

N

01 in

0

0

0

m

N

01 m

m 5

i&

d W

PI W

3

>

W

d

\

E

in

N

m

d

a 3 E6

9:: an

ZW

WH

am

d

0

Et

2

Page 49: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

IW

1

3:

1

0

I a

I I I IO

I

H

IW

I I I I I I I I

ffi

*rn C)

k do

(0

3”

3 rn I

H

IZ

1

0

IX

I I I I I I 1W

Irn

1

v

I*

I I I

H

lsr

I I I I I I I I I I 1.s: I

H

IZ

in

18

I Iffl

Iffl

10

I

d

IO

I

$0 r o

m o o

m N

w

rl 0

0 rl 0

0 N 0

rl

.........

I I

I

rl

6o

6o

oo

mm

O

N0

‘j

c0

00

mr

l

......... o

w

m

0-

36

r-m

m

wm

~

rlm

m

rlr-m

r

lw

m

Nr

-0

m

w

m

wm

w

w

N

N

rl

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

.........

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

.........

00

00

00

00

0

0 0

0 0

0 0

0 0

0

rlrl

rl

rlrlrf

.........

...... 6

r-

W

OO

N

om

TJ

‘jcm

m

mm

w

W

~N

r

lm

rl

ow

m

‘jc

w

‘jc

m

d

I I

I

N~

O~

OO

ON

N

WW

00

00

0W

N

‘jcp

m

OO

N

om

P

’ m

m

w

WD

N

rlm

rl

ow

m

‘jc

w

‘jc

m

rl .........

I I

om

om

oo

oo

r-

O

WO

d0

00

0N

.........

rl

m

I 1

1

WO

ON

OO

OW

U‘

‘jcm

6

O

ON

rlm

rl

N~

OO

OO

ON

~

om

m

P

’N

~

mm

w

W

~N

m .........

ow

m

U

‘ w

P‘

rl

W

rl

rl

m

m

N

r- 0

In 0

N

rl

0

0

0

0

0

0

7-4

m

rl

N

m

W

W

m

m

rl

m

d

N

m

W

W

W

rl

m I

W

P

0

m

rl

m

N

W

6

W

W

rl

m

* c * * 4

0

E+ z

rl

wo

N

rlO

...

mo

o

mr-o

...

qm

LO

N

em

0

0

N

mm

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

drl

...

wm

o

rrlo

...

Wq

L

DW

o

m

TiU

mm

ma

lo

Pd

O

W6

L

OW

o

m

rl P

... m

m

II

N

rl

O

rlr

-0

WN

74 ...

om

o

mm

o

... w

w

ww

o

m

rlq

m

m X

2

22:

€402

HH

H

X

W4V

HA

Z

4u

ffld

h

r

rl

m

W

W

N

rl

r- W

m

0

0

0

0

0

0

rl

W

m c

rl

P‘

6

W

W

m

r- rl

P* 6

W I

W

m

m

rl

m

r- W

W

‘jc

‘jc

W

* * * 6 4

0

H

d

rlO

ON

rl

rlrlrlr-iN

.....

wm

pp

m

Nv

mm

m

mw

or

-6

r

-w

mN

o

Nw

wm

rl

mrlm

mrl

WN

6

N

m

.....

00

00

0

00

00

0

.....

00

00

0

00

00

0

.....

00

00

0

00

00

0

rld

rlrlrl

.....

mO

mw

N

Nd

0r

-r

-

L-W

Nm

m

or

lrlw

rl

OW

N

m

rl

W

rlmm

r-m

.....

rO

OW

WN

NrlO

r-r-

PW

Nm

m

or

lrlw

rl

OW

N

m

rl

m

rlm

m?

m

.....

I m

m

rl

r

N

W

r- 0

0

W

oo

mw

r

om

mr

N

.....

rl

ffl w

rl

N

N

m

m

m

m

m

W

r-

0

0

0

0

0

0

d

rl r

P

W

rl

W

m

rl

rl

P

r- W

rl

W

W

rl

I m

c

W

W

6

rl

rl

W

m

rl

m

c c c c d

A

H

0

E+

rl

P

m

N

W

‘jc

N

rl

r- m

N

W

‘jc

N

rc w V H

w ffl

W

ffi A

4

4

H

u z 4

2

mw

o

or-0

rn

... N

I 0

00

0

00

mm

W

m

0-

rlrl

...

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

,-id

...

I 0

00

0

00

mm

m

P*

m

.-I 7

...

I 0

00

0

00

...

mm

06

m

rl

P‘

I 0

00

0

00

mm

L

l-

6

m

rl

-34

...

ffl P

Im

H

PI

rnm

w

mH

n

dH

W

fflnLr;

mo

w

XQ

X

ww

H

xn

o

0

0

cn cn

0

0

0

N

6

0

0

0

0

0

0

rl

0

0

W

m

r

rl

‘jc

0

0

m

m

r

rl

6

0

0

W

m

r

rl

P‘

* * * c 4

A

R

0

H

W

rl

r- m

rl

W

r- 4‘

W

m

W d

0

0

0

0

d

0

rl

0

0

W

m

m

m

m

N

N

rl

r- m

r- rl

0

W

N

01

q

m

74

0

0

0

m

r- m

W

r- rl

0

m

N

N

* c * * 2 El

0

H

a

3 W

Page 50: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

W

m

0

rl

w

0

rl

N

0

rl

0

r- m

0

rl

0

0

rl

0

N

0

rl

m

c

N

0

rl

m

ww

w

rlrlrl

... W

rl

3 I: u

W

W

rlm

w

ow

w

mm

W

NN

e

ri

d

om

m

rlw

m

mo

m

mm

a P

F

W

rl

mw

m

drld

...

m

m

- m

m

e

e

r-mo

m

e0

rlm

r- m

rlw

4' cr w

W

mm

0

0

NN

W

N

N

m

00

0

00

0

r(

rlrlrl

0

0

... 13 X

V

rl

WP

w

we

W

N

N

m

mo

m

at-

w

00

-

0m

m

NN

N

N

a

E-, >I

m

N

rlwr-

4'

ww

e -

ar

-w

o

m-

m

mm

m

03

om

m

m

NN

P

X

E+ z 0 c !3

W

z

-.. N

m

X

g

mo

o~

nm

wm

m

sm

om

t-r

lmm

t-

rl

~a

mm

m~

o

NW

U'

mr-r-m

W

N

~r

lm

rl

..

NN

4

rl

0

zrlw

wL

nt-

wrlr

l w

r-w

mo

r-- rlm

rlrlm

rl

N

E+ C

SrlN

rlN

rlN

rlN

w

Eir

lrlN

Nm

me

e

W

N

N

m

v1 v1 0

Page 51: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

m

m

N

0 w 0

N

.4

rla

.. m

0

.. 0

m

W

H

2 z 3

d

N

.-I .. r d

t, 0 r 1- n

a N

rl \

r'

w

IW

13

: I

V

I o\a

I I I IE-,

It

,

I I I I I I I in

d

t,3: V

€4

O

\Q

m a r7 3: I

H

12

1

0

IC

$"

I I I I I W 3: V

,\a n

H

t,

3: H

z s \ E

-, w z

c PI

t,u

E-cw Z

K

3

OZ

v

o

m at,

Wd

dP

PI (3

ln

mo

Wo

od

--

r

lO

Or

lO

ON

~r

l

.........

I I

1

Q* m

o 9

' o o

o - m

m

mo

-o

oo

wr

l

......... rlm

rl

wm

o

vm

m

q

mw

o

m o

P

-W

m

m

r(

wm

r-

mr-

w

WO

rl

mw

N

9'd

O W

0 0

r( 0

d

OO

rl

00

NO

rl

.........

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

drl

rl

rlrlrl

.........

I I

I

mw

om

oo

mw

m

mm

om

oo

~d

m

NW

m

mm

rlm

m

w

mo

rlr-

m

wa

r

rm

m

o -

.........

mrl

6r-

cy m

N

I I

I

mm

om

oo

mm

w

mm

om

oo

~r

lm

.

..

..

..

..

I I

I -r o

rlo

oo

oo

m

mo

mo

OO

OO

m

o 0

0

mrl o

d

mr

-

.........

I I

1

mm

o~

oo

mw

m

mm

om

oo

Nr

lm

.........

wr

m

m

mm

0

0

m

lnm

o

mm

W

W

mr-

r-m

mr

l m

o

m

mr- -

m

N

W

rl

r

0

0

0

m

N

m

9'

d

m

m

rl

W

N

r- 0

In rl

m

N

N

0

0

rl

m

9'

0

r- m

m

m

N

N

ln

- 0

r- m

m

m

N

N I

m

r- m

0

rl

m

m

N

6

W

W

0

0

m

N

c

c e c

mw

o

rlrl0

...

wr

o

mm

m

rl r

m

rlm

om

0

... N

IT

rlm

mm

o

44

0

...

ON

0

rl

W0

-10

m0

N

m

Nm

... m

m

00

0

00

0

rld

...

NW

O

rlm

0

t-W

em

N

m

rlm

N

U7

e.

.

cu

m0

r

lm

0

r-

W

6m

N

m

dm

N

u)

...

II

N

mO

ln

ln0

... m

m

N

9* rl 0

w

mo

rw

... w

m

NU

3

rlm

N

U? x z

E22

$86

xx

w

a4m

PE

-rn

3:

mr

7h

r

rl

m

9'

6

0

r- W

9'

9,

W

d

r

r- 0

N

6

m

r-

0

0

rl

0

m

m

0

W

r- m

0

m

m

0

W

m

r I

m

0

m

m

m

m

m

m

W

W

r

c c * e 1-7

0

H

z

rlm

6w

m

rlO

mrlN

.....

6N

Om

O

or-m

mrl

..... m

rl

om

m

mm

mrlr(

-a*

mm

om

N

rl

rl

WN

o

m-

0

rl

m

Nw

mm

m

rld

0O

rl

.....

mm

ww

rl

r-

~u

vm

rl

mc

um

mo

.....

mm

orlr

-

rlmW

Q'N

P

Nd

m

0

N

00

00

0

00

00

0

rlrlrlrlrl

.....

Wm

mN

m

mo

wr

-r

l r-w

r-m-

rlr

lrm

rl

mw

rlm

rl

..... m

oo

m

ri

m

N

WW

mN

m

mw

rlm

rl

mo

wr-rl

r-

mr

mw

r

lrlr

-mr

l m

oo

m

rl

ln

N

.....

W

m

m

rl

m

m

r- m

d

In

l-7

om

mc

vr

l o

wr

lmm

..

ON

?-

00

mr

mw

r

lr

m~

d

m

N

6

N

W

10

';p

0

rl

0

rl

r

m

W 4

Yr r- - rl FF 0

N

r

0

0

rl

W

N

rl

0

N

W

N

cn W

N

rl

0

N

W

N

m I rl

m

m

m

- - r- rl N

W

N

c c c c il

0

E-c

z

m

0

m

m

W

6

N

m

0

m

W

m

9'

N

m w V

n

w m t, d d

6.2 1-7 n

0

z 2

rm

o

ON

0

..

.

I 0

00

0

00

ln-

... e

m

mm

W

mm

o

0-0

...

00

0

00

0

... o

m

mN

- m

00

0

00

0

rlrl

...

I 0

00

0

00

Om

P

W

rl

*I

.

r I

00

0

00

0

00

r- rl

... r

w

I 0

00

0

00

Om

r

-W

r- rl

...

m am

n

a

3:fflw

d

n

WU

Id

Illow

C

PIZ

wWE

COO

me

n m

N

0

0

m

m

m

m

N

m

0

0

m

rl

ln

m

0

0

rl

I 0

0

10

W

rl

m I

0

0

m

W

rl

m I

0

0

m

W

rl

m

6

c

c c r7

0

E-c

z

W

rl

N

rl

r

m

0

rl

W

d

W

r(

W

rl

m

m

m

6

9'

0

W

N

m

0

0

rl

r

m

m

W

rl

N

W

N

r

N

W

m

m

u)

W

W

N

m

m

m

r- W

m

m

m

c c c c r7 a E-l 0

H

a

z W

Page 52: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

ww

w

rlf-irl

... m

cn .

VI

W

W

e: 6, 3:

0

C)

W

rl

rlm

w

rim

a

a0

a

NN

-

44

om

m

om

m

mm

m

mm

3 4

.I

m

W

m

rl

m

00

0

00

0

... 9 d

0

0

m

N

m

m

m

tn -r

0

0

-r w

0

-r

a

m

W

0

6

m

VI

CI

0

E+ E+ W

z

d

0

0

rl

00

0

00

0

rld

d

...

r-

rC

-4

r

w-

r

?o

m

0d

-r

mm

w

r(

d

NN

ama

Ic-rd

P

W6

a

am

r

om

0

-r-r

m(?w

d

rl

N

N

I w

wo

Wdm

mr

-d

mm

m

P

m

N

N

In

0

rl

m

0

m

6

4

21'

m

N

N

tn 0

rl

N

m

d

N

rl

4

3

d

..

d

0

ZW

dW

tn

r-

mmd

m w

w

mo

m QS

dm

r

ld

m

N

d

0

0

0

P

d rl N

rl N

d N

rl N

* E+ rl d N

N m

m -r

9'

m

N

N

m

d W

m fflc

AD

A

D

H

m

mw

m

N

6

rl

Wm

N

Na

W

md

rl cn rl

a

m

6

m

d

Page 53: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

(5,

3: V

a\o

R

E,

sr 3: R

z

0

c E+ W

z

-.

mw

ow

oo

mo

r-

r

l0

0r

l0

0N

Or

l

.........

I I

I

6m

o~

oo

op

tw

a

wo

~o

oO

Wr

l

rlm

rl

wm

o

-m a

wm

w

mw

o

~Q

'W

w

m

rl

NW

r-

w

o

rl

wr

m

w

w

N

9'

rl .........

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

.........

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

.........

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

drl

rl

drlrl

.........

I I

I

wo

mo

om

rl

w

rl

ro

~o

or

mm

a

m

w

mw

r

04

w

m

or

t

mm

m

w

dd

m

o

m

ow

6

......... m

rl

I I

I

ac

vo

mo

om

r(

w

rl r

0 N

o o r- in

a

am

w

m

wr

0

4

w

mo

d

mm

m

W

rl

d

a

mo

In

mw

6

N

N .........

d

II

I

ar

-o

wo

or

lo

r'

rl

mo

ao

or

lo

~

wp

t rl

w

mv

o

pt

rl .........

I I

I

om

om

oo

6r

lr

l

or

l~

~~

ow

mr

rlrl o

r-

wr

rrl

m

WO

d

6m

w

W

rl

d

a

rl

60

m

mw

pt

N

N ......... m

a

wo

w

m

wN

or

(

rl

rl

rlr

lo

rl

rl

om

ov

N

.

..

..

..

..

r- w

ro

m

6

~m

a0

w

o

am

a

rlo

aN

pt

o

wrl

o

mm

wrlrl

o

m

pa

r-

em

mo

m

r- N

~

m

w

Nr

lr

lW

N

rl

mr

lm

g

to

mp

tw

0

0

rlr

l

md

m

pt

m

0 .

..

..

..

..

..

o

m0

pt

or-w

wrl

m

6

rl

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

0 .

..

..

..

..

..

0

00

0

00

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

0 .

..

..

..

..

..

0

00

0

00

00

0

0

0

0

rl

pt

cy

m

ol W

W

Lo

N

N

6

9'

m a

W

W

Lo N

N

0

W

m

W

m

pt

W

rl

rl

W

m

N

N

m

* * * *

00

0

00

0

rlrl

...

mp

to

rlr

-0

AN

rlp

t

Cn

W

rlm

N

m

...

m-

o

dr-0

r

lN

rl 9'

... a

w

rlm

w

m

I e

ao

m

oo

r

lm

mN

...

rm

o

ww

o

Nm

6d

mW

d

m

Nm

...

x 2 22% E

,E,H

m

W

il

U

e42

au

a:

PO

P:

mr7

h

0

0

rl

r m

W

Lo m Lo

r

r- W

W

m

m m

r- I m

9'

N

N

m

W

10 m

m

r- * c * c $

2

a R 0

E,

00

00

0

c3

00

00

drld

4

.....

am

wo

o

r-r-60

6

mw

r- N

or--

w

FT

dN

N

O

ON

6

rl

N

N

.....

am

wo

o

r-r-6O

-J .....

mw

r- N

or--

w

Vr

lN

N

O

ON

p

td

N

N

a

r

r

r- 6

m

m

0

6

0

pt

om

mo

m

or

pt

ow

m

r- r

..... P

pt

N

rl

N

N

ON

d

N

N

rn

0

0

rl

m

W

to 0

r- N

N

m

m

W

W

0

N

N

r- m

r- r 6

m W

W

m

m

W

N

m

N

* * c c t.2

0

E,

2

rl

pt

W

6

m

I;s

N

rl 6

W

pt

m

9'

N

m

u V

H

2 W 0

P d

a 4

V z

a 2

mm

o

w

W

mm

o

6

4

..

..

.

I 0

00

0

N

00

0

0

..

..

.

rl

W

rl

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

00

0

00

0

rlrl

...

00

0

00

0

00

w

o

N

... m

m

00

0

00

0

00

w

o

N

... m

m

00

0

00

0

00

w

o

mm

N

...

m

PI

m

HP

I

Zo

lW

l&H

w

mffi

mo

w

Ea0

m-

a

Z2!E

0

0

r(

0

0

0

W

W

N

0

0

0 9

W

N

0

0

0

W

W

N

* i

* c r7

0

R

2

0

3

rl

m

r- W

N

I;s

0

rl

W

N

I;s

rl

0

r- I;s

W

N

a

m

.-I a

rl 6

0

rl

6

m

N

W

N

m

m

N

a

a

i

c c c tll

0

E,

2

[!I

z 2 a

Page 54: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

rlm

w

om

m

dm

m

om

m

mm

m

m

W

m

rl

m

moa

NN

-

mm

w :

d

3

ri

d

05

0 wa

. d

UW

0

0

00

0

00

0

...

02

o

a

0

m

m

m

m

r- m

-

0

0

3: E

N

rl

--. m

m

m

m

e

Ff

U'

N

N

- m

ffl il a H

0

R

H

W

z

0

0

0

0

rl

m

N

N

m

I I

Nl

r

lI

\

I

m1

I

0

-J m

m

r- 0

m

N

N

m

0

d

0

m

d

ri

m

0

~r

lrl-

t.j.mr

mr

nd

m

r-w

mo

m-

N

rlm

r

lrlm

rl

H

dd

NrlN

rlN

rlN

0

0

0

m

N

N

m

io)

tm

1

0

Id

I

0

I I I

.. o

w-

o

m

om

m

mm

m

m

m

r

rl

r(

riN

rlrl

3: B E3 --. 64

cr;;9.w

mm

rlm

WN

rl-

m

mm

m

rlrl fflz-

43

4

ilz

H

m

W

PI H

o~

mw

m~

HW

PI >

R

ri

cr 10 ri

m

a

z 2 EB

W

3

Z W

b- W d

il

0

R

d

Page 55: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

rl

W

W

0 W

W

N

4

dP

I

-. m

0

'., 0

7-i

w

€4

8 z 3

ffi

N

rl --.

m

ffi * 0

z3 1 1

H

m N

rl .. m

IW

I

X

IV

I I ow

I I I IH

I

*

ta

I

30

W

X

V

H 60

(0

4

il X

€4 z 0

G

mr

-o

wo

oo

om

rlo

orlo

oo

orl

.........

I I

t

cr

mo

~o

oo

cr

m

mm

oc

ro

oo

Wr

l

.........

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

.........

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

.........

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

rlrl

rl

rlrl

.........

I I

rlm

Om

OO

Om

m

m P

* 0 m

0 0

0 rl r

l

W-

r(

wcr

m

N

WN

W

W

dm

P

rl

N Q

a

Ul

N W

P

' 0

N ......... cr

rl

r

0

0

0

N

W

cr rl

m

m

0

0

0

0

0

0

rl

W

m

m

m

N

rl

0

N

m

W

m

03 m

N

rl

0

N

m I

a, q

W

m

W

rl

cr m

rl

W

m

rl

0

N

c c c e c7 0

E+

z

drl0

...

mr

o

om

0

mm

m

rl

NW

4

W

rl

W

... r

m

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

rlrl

...

mm

o

m*

0

om

P

I0

Or-

N-

... m

m

mm

o

mc

r0

o

m

r-m

Or-

N P

'

... m

m

II

m

N0

m

mo

W

W

N r

l

...

r-4

0

dm

0

... crm

m

w

mm

O

P

NV

x 2 335

$82

HBH

3: W

il

U

H4

Z

m4

GA

m

Ti

m

-r cr 0

'9

Q'

cr

r-

0

0

0

0

0

0

rl

m

0

cr N

m

03 W

m

0

4'

N

m

m

W I

0

01

m

m

m

rn

W

W

m

m

W

c * * c crl

0 H

d

Nm

mo

r-

rto

rlo

rl

.....

u-N

mm

o

OP

WW

4

mr

lo

mN

m

mw

rlrl .....

crm

wo

m

Nr

lr

lW

N

0

m

P'

W

0

rl

00

00

0

00

00

0

.....

00

00

0

00

00

0

.....

00

00

0

00

00

0

rlrlrl

rl

.....

rl

Ul

rl

OW

o

r-mo

r- W

WP

' 0

Wr

lO

N

m

w

4' W

rl

W .....

m~

rl

m

rl

lo

rl

OW

WW

cr

0

Wr

tO

N

m

w-

W

m

rl

or

-m

or

mr

rl

m

.....

I N

m

4

0

W

r- W

N

W

m

W

r- rl

W

m

cr 0

r- rl

W

0

rl

0

0

0

0

0

0

rl

0

0

q

W

4'

0

rl

m

0

0

rs m

Q

* 0

6)

rl

I N

m

r- N

N

m

rl

rl

m

0

rl

m

c c c + c7 4 H

0

E-

rl

rl

N

P

W

cr N

rl

rl

N

r W

cr N

ffl W

V

H

W

ffl

W

ffi 4

il $4

H

V

2 2

NP

O

NN

O

...

I 00

0

00

0

me

...

crm

cnm

W

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

rlrl

...

I 00

0

00

0

00

r

lW

N

m

rl

...

I 0

00

0

00

m0

r

lW

N

m

rl

...

I 00

0

00

0

LO

O

rl

W

NW

rl

...

m HP

I

XW

W

fflwa

G

H

WC

nffi

mo

w

CP

IZ

W

WH

zao W

N

0

0

m

m

W

m

0

0

0

0

0

0

rl

0

0

m W

W

rl

0

0

m

W

W

rl

0

0

m

W

W

rl

* c c c il

0

E+

z

Q*

rt

N

rl

r-

m

0

rl

W

rl

W

rl

0

0

0

0

rt 3

rl

N

0

W

W

W

W

rl

W

N

W

rl

0

cr W

W

ut

N

m

rl r- rl

ri

r- m

m

N

v

03 N

v

10 0

W

N

+ c c n c7

0 H

a

z W

z 2

Page 56: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

N

0 .

ff

l

rlw

13 d a: 3:

ov

rl

wv

m

. fflc+

r- 0

r- rl

22; E 1

34

d

3

V

V

00

0 wa

. d

VW

rl

W4

rlrlrl

W

4

I13

I

P

I C

) I I

OY

)

I I I IR

I

*

in

r

lmw

o

mm

r

lwm

o

mw

m

mm

m

om

N

N-

m

m

rl

d

00

0

00

0

...

m

ID

W d

W

d

*m L1

8" 0

0

0

0

W

IT

m

e

r

I

00

0

00

0

drlrl

... 0

0

rl

m

N

N

m

(J

lrlO

r

lO

N

m-

a

wm

m

p-

4

r-m

rl

mw

r

lr

l

m

E+* m

E-4 " 4E

-4 H C

wm

mm

o-

dW

a: LO

m e N

m rl m

w

0m

wD

Nm

ww

m

om

~-

?m

wm

~

rlr-w

ma

rl-

?

. . . . . . . . N

m

N

mr

l- rl

ad

o

m-?

m

wm

m

rl

ON

r- cl' rl

r-

Wr

l

mw

0

m

W

0

rl

m

IT

r- rl

m

rl

rl

m

m

N

im

I

R

IZ

I

O

IC

I-. IE

.4

IW

IZ

N

m

d * 8

m

N

N

m

I I I Iffl

Iffl

IO

I

d

I13

3: E .. [4

W

3

z W

d

Ei

0

rl

Ut

m

rl

d

W 3 0

[4

W

ffl d 0

m

Page 57: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

la

1

3:

IV

I o\o

I I I If

3

I*

I i

n

I

d

*X

V

€4 o\Q

[I]

2"

5 !S

3: I

f3

I

Z

I I I I I I lw

1

3:

IV

I ov

I I I If

3

I>

I I I I I I I I I I I 13

:

10

in

I!2

I I I I Iv

l

Iffl

IO

I

d

tu

I I

rlr

lo

wo

oo

or

l

rfo

orlo

oo

orl

.........

I I

1

wm

o-

oo

o-

m

cn

rn

o~

~o

oo

wr

l

rlm

rf

wm

o

vm

m

-m

m

......... m

m

o

r--w

mm

rl

~m

r-

m

r- m

w

o

mm

N

,-I

- rl 00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

.........

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

.........

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

rlrt

rl

44

.........

I I

mo

ow

oo

ow

o

rf

mo

Q+

oo

om

o

mr-

m

Om

w

w

m

Nm

m

m

r- m

.ism

m

N

0

4

CT

rl

.........

r

rl

I I

mo

ow

oo

ow

o

rlm

o.is

oo

om

o

m r-.

m

00

w

w

m

Nm

m

m

r- m

-m

m

N

0

4 -

rl

r- rl .........

Amooooooo

mrf

m

mr

l0

00

00

00

Nm

.........

N

I I

-3 m

0 w

0 0

0 w

0

om

m

O

m

om

m

N

W

mm

r-

m

r-m

m

N

0 rl

Qt

4

r- rl

-r

cr

o1

;~

oo

om

o

.........

H

€4

3ffl

zaf3

W

WH

HH

z-.n

tnv

3

acnE

+1-7w

w

d 1-7 4

3: w h C

) w €4 w

wc

w>

z €42

ZD

WH

ZW

ZZ

O

w L( a J H

6 c7

H C

)

w Z

f3

ff

l4

dG

2

N

rl

r

0

0

0

N

m

-J rf

m

m

0

0

0

0

0

0

rl

m

m

m

m

m

N

rr r- rl

m

m

m

N

m

w

r- rl

I

rl

-J

w

m

N

m

rl

m

r- rl

N

N

m

r- rl

c c c c c7

0

B

d

r. N

o

rlrl0

.

..

mr-o

mm

m

om

0

... r-m

N

m

rl

W

rfm

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

..

.

00

0

00

0

rlrl

...

U' v

0

mm

0

wcn

Nr-

rl

w

... m

rf m

rl

CT

-0

r

Or

00

wm

m

rl

NC

m

rl rf-

...

II

C

nN

O

-0

0

mm

m

m

rl ...

mw

o

om

0

0-

mrl

mrl

rlw

... m

m X

d

xx

w

44

ffl

f3f3

H

3: W

c7

V

f342

m4

G,

dg2

m

rl

m

CT

Q'

0

r- W

Q

' Tr

0

0

0

0

0

0

rl

m

0

W

m

m

0

w

m

0

w

m

0,

0

W I

rl

m

m

-1

N

m

Lo

-J

0

N

rl

w

c

* * c 2 €4

0

H

rlr

no

o-

m

rlO

NO

rl

rf

..

..

..

Q

'WO

N

4

00

0

rl

..

..

.

I e

~m

mo

w

0

00

0

N

or

-m

mr

l m

0

00

0

rl

..

..

..

.

..

..

m

rlo

mm

C

T tn

v

m

r- m

mm

rtr

l o

-m

m

o

C

Tm

mo

m

r- m

m

01 rl

Nr

fr

lW

N

rl

w

mm

o

m-

m

W

m

00

rl

rlr

l

W

rl

00

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

..

..

..

00

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

..

..

..

00

00

0

0

00

00

0

0

rlrlrl

rl

rl

..

..

..

mm

mo

r- "rl

rlr

-m

om

rf

..

..

..

o

m^

m

r(

or

-m

m

o

mr

lm

01 r-

Ww

mN

m

r

ow

r

lr

i

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

00

0

0

rl

00

0

0

0

rlrl

rt

rl

..

..

.

00

0

0

rl

00

0

0

r- .

..

..

m

m

m

m

rl-

m

m

WN

U7

r(

r- 0

0

N

mm

m

rlr-m

Om

N

mr

lm

CT

w

... m

r-m

m

or-

rl

m

00

0

0

0

om

rl

m

ooo o

m

mr

lm

m

m

03

03

m

oC

T

mN

m

w

mr

-r

-

rl-

mm

m

N-

N

O

WN

m

r

lr

l

0

N

..

..

.

..

..

II

m

w

w

rl

00

0

mm

m

N

N

- m

mm

m

- u* N

m

0

m

m

om

mo

m

r- m

0

00

0

w

or

mo

o

rf

m

oo

o

o

m

..

..

..

.

..

..

.

mw

m

w

m

r-m

N

m

v

4

0

N

03 P

WW

NW

m

wN

r

lr

l

mm

m

rl

m

r-

rl

0

0

N

ffl W

w

ff

l

d;m

W

4W

wm

3

:UG

V

d4

f3

43:z

*G

3:

V4

f33V

1-7v G

Is

4v

vw

w

zoffl3

:x W

WH

Hf3

P

1G

CO

O

cn W

V

x H

W

ffl

* d

1-7 H

V

2 5 3

Lo P

Im

H

PI

3

:VlW

GH

w

ffllr;

mw

a

mo

w

5:a

o

E22

* * c r-7

0

h

d a

3 w

Page 58: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

IW

0

Im

0

1

v

*

W

d

Ln

Wtn

rld

rl

... I I I

H 0

I

*

. I I I I I I in o

m

W

m

d

m

I

l% *m 0

C)

. 8"

0

V

00

* lx

vw

o wa

0

0

0

0

00

0

00

0

... E4 o\o m

r-7 X

O

IH

0

1

2

. 1

0

IC

I I I I I I

W

r- rl

N

W

tn w

m

B 0

0

00

0

00

0

drlrl

... 0

0

rl

=$ W

N

0'

IW

0

I

m 0

IV

*

I ow

I I

d

d

0

-2

m H z 0 cE+ -lx ffl H>

XH

W

H

r-7H

X

Nm

m

4w

wv

m

r-w

Om

?

dr

-w

N

W

N ...

m

Ln 0

m

P'

I IB

I

*

in

W

N

N

tn

Nd

W

m-rw

w

wm

m

Nd

c

n-w

P

' m 02

00

N

N

0

10 r- 0

d

ffl r-7

0 H

2 H

W

z m

N

0

to r-

N

Ln 0

rl

3: S

wd

oo

rn

mw

m

Y;

mr

-o

ow

~o

r-

r

lr-

mm

om

tno

N

r--r

mr-m

m

WN

N

dO

rl

rl

0

zw

Nw

=?

wtn

cn

d

r-r-w

mo

o-

rlm

4

d-

Y

N

rl

H

CG

dN

dN

rlN

dN

* H rl d N

N m

m C

F =a*

mo

H

N

z.

w

cn

e

o

H

0,

(o

r-

3

b

a

4

00

0

00

0

00

.

..

0

0

W

N

N

tn

Page 59: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

IW

1

3:

IU

I

o\a I I I I

R

IE

1

st

I I I I I I I I

rr: *3

: u

E o\o

ro 4 4 3:

IE

I

Z

SW

IS

I I I I I I IO

1

3:

iu

I I

Oio

I I I If

I I

:

I I I I I I I I I I I I 13

:

IE

I

Z

10

IE-1

I

N

IZ

rr: st V

I roE-1 H

Z

zw

HC

E

Iv

)

13

l

b

I?! $ i$

I I I I Iro

Iro

IO

le

: I

W

I I I

cr

rl

0W

00

00

rl

rlo

orlo

oo

or(

.........

I I

t

crm

oc

ro

oo

d.m

a

m o us o o o

w rl

rlm

Ti

w

mo

u

'm

a

crm

m

mm

o

ru

3w

m

m

rl

~m

r

mr

m

WO

mm

N

rl

cr .........

rl

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

.........

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

..

..

..

..

.

00

00

00

00

0

00

00

00

00

0

rlrl

rl

rlrl

.........

I I

?r

ow

oo

oc

rm

ir

-o

r-o

oo

mo

.........

rla

rl

9' w

m

m

N

N

-0

m

rl

art

cr rl

rl

N

rc

r

w

a

I I

ar

-o

wo

oo

gc

m

rlr

-o

ro

oo

mo

.........

rla

rl

P' W

m

m

N

N

9'0

m

rl

a rl

P*

rl

rl

N

rc

r

w

a

I I

cr

mo

cr

oo

oo

o

rm

om

oo

oo

o

w

94

m

m

......... w

rl

0

ON

I I

mh

ioo

oo

o.;p

m

am

or

lo

oo

rn

o

......... r-rl

N

*W

a

m

m

N

NO

U

l rl

or(

cr rl

N

N

rm

m

a

m

rl

r

0

0

0

m

N

m

6

r(

m

0

0

0

0

0

0

rl

r- m

cr r- rl

cr N

N

m

r- m

gc

r- d

cr N

N

m

I m

Lo

m

m

N

m

0

a

m

m

0

0

Lo N

N

* * * * 4

d: E-1 0

El

mw

o

rlrl0

.

..

mr

o

om

o

am

m

rl

ra

rlm

... N

m

rlm

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

...

00

0

00

0

rlrt

...

rld

0

CU

VO

...

am

r

m

6m

0

7

Nm

drl0

m

gc

o

... O

IN

em

r-m

0

-

Nr

O

II

m

-0

w

ao

...

rlm

r

lW

rlN

9- W

0

V.m

O

... rlm

W

rl

m

W

0-

NO

x

3 x

xw

4

hc

m

BBH

m

Wd

V

Hd

Z

roc-7

Ly

2:s

W

rl

m

9'

cr 0

r- W

cr cr

0

0

0

0

0

0

rl

N

N

N

0

rl

m

r-

N

N

N

0

rl

rT) r I

m

m

r

r

m

0

m

a

r- 6

Lo r

* * n c 4

0

E-1

3

am

rw

o

orlr

l .

..

.

00

00

0

00

0

....

00

00

0

00

0

....

00

00

0

00

0

rlrlrlrl

....

crm

up

'o

dr

am

....

om

rd

a

rm

m

r-rlm

a

mm

N

N

N

0

rl

N

rl

N

P*

0

rl

m

0

0

0

0

0

0

rl

N

m

9'

Lo cr N

N

a

cr m 9

' 0 0

N

rlr

-a

ao

m

ar

mm

m

r

dm

m

9'

mm

a

...... o

mr-.-I

cr

N

N

N

9'

OW

rl

04

0

0

a

9'

r- m

m

N

orn

ulo

r

ora

a

a

..

..

.

mr-rl

cr r-m

m

a

rlm

a

N

m

Lo

o

N

n

ri

N

W

m

6

0

d

0

rl

r

m

0

0

0

0

0

0

rl

rl

cr m

r

rl

W

m

N

rl

6

m

rl

W

m

N

r I

m

rl

0

93

m

W

m

m

r d

0

m

N

* n * n 4

0

E-1

3

m

rl

0

0

cr N

r

m

rl

0

0

cr N

r

(I] W

V

H

3. rr: W w

st rr: 4

H

u 2 5

ra

o

93

m

rl9

'0

m

rl

..

..

.

00

0

0

N

00

0

0

rl

..

..

.

mu

' a

r- c

rm

m o

am

a

rl

w

ma

W

rl

W

rl

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

00

0

0

0

00

0

0

0

..

..

.

00

0

00

0

rlrl

...

I 0

00

0

00

00

rlm

m

... r-m

I 0

00

0

00

00

rlm

m

... r

m

I 0

00

0

00

00

rlm

m

... r

m

ro 14ro

H1

4

mw

w

v)

BR

dH

wrorr:

mow

2143:

0

0

rl

0

0

0

rl

N

m

0

0

0

rl

N

m

0

0

0

rl

N

m

* * * n d

0 E

3

0

0

d

cr rl

0

W

0

m

m

N

m

N

m

0

W

r- 0

W

N

a

m

m

W

rl

m

a

rl

cr cr m

cr -7

0

m

N

a

* * * * 4

0 E

z

3 2 a

, I I 1 I I i i I I ! j i I i ! I I

Page 60: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard
Page 61: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

S

3 Y

5 a

00

Page 62: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard
Page 63: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard
Page 64: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard
Page 65: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard
Page 66: March 8,20 - KY PSC Home cases/2012-00562/20130308... · 2013. 3. 8. · March 8,20 13 Mr. Jeff Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Cornmission 21 1 Sower Boulevard

Y- o .E