manipulation of the market: how the insurance industry has gamed all three branches of state...

7/31/2019 Manipulation of the Market: How the Insurance Industry has Gamed All Three Branches of State Government

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/manipulation-of-the-market-how-the-insurance-industry-has-gamed-all-three 1/14

0

6>8 @pn{ly Y}phh}* Yxc}h 129 Nxy}cd* ]hvny 7672> &8>0# 96>%>>>> www$}hvnywn}if$lpg

ENDCRXJN]CLD LA ]FH ENPOH]

Hvhix}cqh Yxeenps ]fh cdyxpndih cdmxy}ps cd ]hvny fny yxiihyyaxjjs xyhm njj }fphh `pndifhy la glqhpdehd} }l y}pcr nwns rpl}hi}cldy alp c}y ixy}lehpy* ohhr pn}hy fcgf* ndm cerjhehd} xdancp pn}cdg ndm xdmhpwpc}cdg rpni}cihy$ ]fcy endcrxjn}cld la lxp enpoh} fny jha} ildyxehpy wc}f hvrhdycqh ̀ nph `ldhy cdyxpndihilqhpngh }fn} ancjy }l rplqcmh ehndcdgaxj rpl}hi}cld alp ends flehlwdhpy$

Alp elph }fnd acqh shnpy ]hvndy fnqh }pxy}hm }fh cdyxpndih cdmxy}ps }l nyyxph }fn} c}y rpcihy nph

naalpmn`jh ndm }fn} c}y rplmxi}y nph nqncjn`jh$ ]fh cdmxy}ps fny phwnpmhm }fcy }pxy} wc}fny}pldlecinjjs fcgf pn}hy }fn} fnqh rplmxihm y}ngghpcdg lqhpifnpghy n} }fh hvrhdyh la ]hvnyrljcisfljmhpy$

]hvndy dhhm n ysy}he }fn} rpl}hi}y }fhe wc}f yenp} phgxjn}cld ’ dl} ldh }fn} ycerjs }pxy}y }fhcdyxpndih cdmxy}ps }l ml }fh pcgf} }fcdg wc}f mhphgxjn}cld$ Wh fnqh yhhd ld }fh dn}cldnj jhqhj cd }fhrny} shnp }fn} jh}}cdg cdmxy}pchy rljcih }fheyhjqhy ancjy }l rplqcmh y}n`jh enpoh}y ndm rpl}hi}ildyxehpy$ C} cy }ceh alp ]hvndy }l phihcqh `h}}hp rpl}hi}cld }fplxgf yenp}* haahi}cqh lqhpycgf} la }fh cdyxpndih cdmxy}ps `hinxyh naalpmn`jh* nqncjn`jh cdyxpndih cy ipc}cinj alp }fh yxiihyy la lxp y}n}h$

Ildyxehpy nph ph~xcphm `s jnw &h$g$ nx}l cdyxpndih# lp jhdmcdg rpni}cih &h$g$ flehlwdhpy cdyxpndih#}l rxpifnyh cdyxpndih rplmxi}y$ ]fhphalph* cdyxpndih cy xdjcoh l}fhp rplmxi}y cd }fh enpoh} ny }fhmhendm alp }fh rplmxi} mlhy dl} ifndgh$ ]fh enpoh} ind ldjs axdi}cld wfhd `l}f yxrrjs ndmmhendm nph qnpcn`jh$ ]fxy mhendm alp cdyxpndih inddl} mh}hpecdh }fn} }fh rpcih cy ancp$ Wfhdrxpifnyh la n rplmxi} cy ph~xcphm* ildyxehpy exy} fnqh haahi}cqh phgxjn}cld }l mh}hpecdh ancp pn}hy$

Sh} alp }fh rny} acqh shnpy* ]hvndy fnqh anihm n enpoh}rjnih wc}f cjjxylps phgxjn}cld }fn} fny phyxj}hmcd `jln}hm cdyxpndih pn}hy ld rljcichy }fn} fnqh `hhd y}npqhm la ehndcdgaxj ilqhpngh$ Wfcjh c}–y ijhnp}fh pljh }fn} }fh cdyxphpy }fheyhjqhy fnqh rjnshm cd }fcy yc}xn}cld* ely} ]hvndy nph xdnwnph la flw }fh cdyxphpy fnqh xyhm njj }fphh `pndifhy la }fhcp y}n}h glqhpdehd} }l axp}fhp c}y nd}c%ildyxehpnghdmn$

Alp }fh jny} mhinmh* }fh cdmxy}ps fny rx} ildycy}hd} rphyyxph ld }fh y}n}h jhgcyjn}xph }l rnyy

jhgcyjn}cld axp}fhp mhphgxjn}cdg }fh cdyxpndih enpoh}$ Mhyrc}h c}y rplecyhy }l }fh Jhgcyjn}xph }fn}mhphgxjn}cld wlxjm jhnm }l mhiphnyhm pn}hy* }fh cdyxpndih cdmxy}ps fny cdy}hnm xyhm }fhyh jnwy }lgneh }fh ysy}he* alpgcdg flehlwdhpy }l rns ycgdcacind} lqhpifnpghy$ ]fh Mhrnp}ehd} la Cdyxpndih ’ rnp} la }fh hvhix}cqh `pndif ’ fny rnyyhm pxjhy }fn} fhnqcjs anqlp cdyxphpy lqhp ildyxehpy*njjlwcdg ilerndchy }l yhqhphjs phmxih ilqhpngh nqncjn`jh }l ixy}lehpy wc}flx} jlwhpcdg pn}hy$Axp}fhp* }fh ]hvny Yxrpheh Ilxp} fny phrhn}hmjs iflyhd }l cd}hprph} cdyxpndih jnwy ny anqlpcdg }fhcdmxy}ps* hqhd wfhd }fh hqcmhdih rjncdjs yxrrlp}y }fh ani} }fn} }fh jnwy whph cd}hdmhm }l rpl}hi}rljcisfljmhpy$



9

]fh cdyxpndih cdmxy}ps fny fnm elph }fnd acqh shnpy la rxjjcdg }fh wllj lqhp }fh hshy la ]hvnyjhgcyjn}lpy ndm }wcy}cdg }fh npe la }fh Mhrnp}ehd} la Cdyxpndih$ C}–y }ceh alp ]hvny }l y}lr }pxy}cdg her}s cdmxy}ps rplecyhy$

Wh dhhm yenp}* haahi}cqh phgxjn}cld la }fh cdyxpndih enpoh} cd ]hvny }fn} rpl}hi}y ildyxehpy aplexdwnppnd}hm pn}h fcohy ndm xdyipxrxjlxy cdyxpndih rpni}cihy wfcjh y}cjj encd}ncdcdg n fhnj}fs*ilerh}c}cqh enpoh}rjnih$ Cdyxphpy exy} `h ph~xcphm }l kxy}cas nds pn}h `halph }fhs `hgcd ifnpgcdg c}*}fhs exy} `h `nddhm aple ildycmhpcdg iphmc} yilphy cd injixjn}cdg rphecxey* ndm }fhs exy} `hrphqhd}hm aple hdgngcdg cd }fh xdancp rpni}cihy }fn} fnqh `hileh yl rhpqnycqh$

N @pcha Yxeenps la }fh Cdyxpndih Enpoh} cd ]hvnyRpclp }l 0229* }fh cdyxpndih ileecyycldhp hy}n`jcyfhm pn}hy ndm cdyxphpy fnm }l yhho nrrplqnj la npn}h s̀ }fh ileecyycldhp ca }fh rplrlyhm pn}h ahjj lx}ycmh la n yrhicachm pndgh$ ]fcy ysy}he la phgxjn}cld wny odlwd ny }fh ajhv%`ndm ysy}he$ @x} }fh cdyxpndih cdmxy}ps }llo nmqnd}ngh la nyhpclxy jhgnj jllrfljh odlwd ny }fh Jjlsm–y jllrfljh cd lpmhp }l hyinrh phgxjn}cld alp 38( la c}yenpoh}$>

Cd }fh shnpy jhnmcdg xr }l 0229* flehlwdhpy cdyxpndih pn}hy cd ]hvny yosplioh}hm* rxprlp}hmjs ny nphyxj} la n mpnen}ci cdiphnyh cd }fh mcyilqhps la eljm cd ]hvny flehy$

]fcy enyycqh jllrfljh iphn}hm nd cdyxpndih ipcycy cd ]hvny cd wfcif cdyxphpy whph jnpghjs

xdyxrhpqcyhm ndm aphh }l lqhpifnpgh rljcisfljmhpy n} wcjj$

0 Mxpcdg }fcy rhpclm* cdyxphpy whph ph~xcphm }l laahp n dxe`hp la y}ndmnpmc{hm rljcichy* ndm ely} flehlwdhpy inppchm wfn} cyinjjhm nd FL%@ rljcis ’ n rljcis }fn} ilqhphm ely} ijncey }l n fleh* cdijxmcdg eljm phehmcn}cld$@hinxyh cdyxphpy whph jnpghjs xdphgxjn}hm* flwhqhp* }fhs whph n`jh }l yhjj }fhyh rljcichy wc}flx} hqhp`hcdg acdndicnjjs rphrnphm }l ilqhp ijncey alp eljm$ @hinxyh la }fcy jnio la rphrnpn}cld* }fhmpnen}ci xr}cio cd eljm ijncey }fphn}hdhm }fh cdmxy}ps–y an} rplac}y ndm gnqh c} }fh dhihyynps ilqhp}l fcoh xr c}y pn}hy hqhd axp}fhp$ Cd rnp} `hinxyh la }fh cdiphnyh cd eljm ijncey* }fh Mhrnp}ehd} la Cdyxpndih &]MC# nmlr}hm n pxjh }fn} `hgnd njjlwcdg cdyxphpy }l mpnen}cinjjs phmxih }fh ilqhpngh cd

}fh rljcichy }fhs whph laahpcdg$9

> ]HVNY MHRNP]EHD] LA CDYXPNDIH* >07 ]F NDDXNJ P HRLP]* R NP] >; P HRLP] LA RPLGPNE NI]CQC]CHY > &Dlq$ >6*0220#*

Hqhd }flxgf }fh cdmxy}ps rhpyxnmhm ]MC }l rnyy }fcy enyycqh mhphgxjn}lps pxjh* c} y}cjj jl``chm fnpmcd }fh 0229 jhgcyjn}cqh yhyycld alp hqhd elph mhphgxjn}cld$ Cdyxphpy nyohm }fh Jhgcyjn}xph }l jhyyhdphgxjn}cld ld pn}hy `s mlcdg nwns wc}f }fh ajhv%`ndm ysy}he ndm elqcdg cdy}hnm }l }fh ‚acjh ndmxyh― ysy}he$ Xdmhp }fh acjh ndm xyh ysy}he* nd cdyxphp exy} ycerjs cdalpe ]MC la nds pn}hy c}cd}hdmy }l ifnpgh* }fhd ens `hgcd ceehmcn}hjs ifnpgcdg }fn} pn}h$ Cd hvifndgh alp }fcy rpl%cdmxy}ps gcqhnwns* }fh cdmxy}ps ngphhm }l ijlyh }fh Jjlsm–y jllrfljh ndm rplecyhm }fn} c} wlxjm yx`ec} }lpn}h phgxjn}cld* yxif ny c} cy$

f}}r;,,www$}mc$y}n}h$}v$xy,phrlp}y,mlixehd}y,20nddxnj>$rma ? ]HVNY MHRNP]EHD] LA CDYXPNDIH* >06 ]F

NDDXNJ P HRLP]* R NP] >; P HRLP] LA RPLGPNE NI]CQC]CHY 9? &Dlq$ 02* 0229#*f}}r;,,www$}mc$y}n}h$}v$xy,phrlp}y,mlixehd}y,29nddxnj>$rma 0 ]HVNY MHRNP]EHD] LA CDYXPNDIH* YHDN]H @CJJ 9>2 YXEENPS P HRLP] ALP ]FH 76 ]F JHGCYJN]XPH 7 &Enp$ 06*0229#* f}}r;,,www$}mc$y}n}h$}v$xy,phrlp}y,mlixehd}y,y`9>2pr}$rma 9 ]HVNY MHRNP]EHD] LA CDYXPNDIH* >07 ]F NDDXNJ P HRLP]* R NP] >; P HRLP] LA RPLGPNE NI]CQC]CHY > &Dlq$ >6*0220#? ]HVNY MHRNP]EHD] LA CDYXPNDIH* >06 ]F NDDXNJ P HRLP]* R NP] >; P HRLP] LA RPLGPNE NI]CQC]CHY =&Dlq$ 02* 0229#$

http://www.tdi.state.tx.us/reports/documents/02annual1.pdf





http://www.tdi.state.tx.us/reports/documents/sb310rpt.pdf








8

Cdyxphpy dn}cldnjjs fnqh dl} yhhd }fcy jhqhj la hv}pheh rplac}$ >>

Shnp

]fh acqh shnp nqhpngh jlyy pn}cl ’ ycdih rnyyngh la Y@ >= ’ cy n ehph =0$7(* ehndcdg }fn} cdyxphpy fnqh rncm lx} ld nqhpngh jhyy }fnd=9 cd ijncey alp hqhps mljjnp }fhs–qh iljjhi}hm aple ]hvny rljcisfljmhpy$ Mxpcdg }fcy yneh rhpclm*cdyxphpy fnqh rncm lx} nd nqhpngh la n`lx} 88 dn}cldnjjs alp hqhps mljjnp iljjhi}hm cd rphecxey$

Cdyxpndih Ijnce Rnslx}y; ]hvny q$ Dn}cldnj

]hvny Jlyy Pn}cl Dn}cldnj Jlyy Pn}cl

0227 91$= 8>$80221 9=$2 =1$20228 81$3 72$7022= 07$6 82$00229 86$1 12$2

Nqhpngh =0$7= 88$16

]l rx} }fn} cd rhpyrhi}cqh* ld }fh nqhpngh dn}cldnj flehlwdhp–y rljcis* wfcif ily}y n`lx} -71=* }fhcdyxpndih cdmxy}ps cy ohhrcdg -9== la hnif rljcis alp rplac} ndm lqhpfhnm na}hp rnscdg lx} ijncey$ Cd ]hvny* wfhph }fh nqhpngh flehlwdhpy rljcis ily}y ->970* }fh cdmxy}ps cy ohhrcdg -731 ’ elph }fnd}wcih }fh dn}cldnj nqhpngh$

]hvndy njyl fnqh dl} yhhd pn}hy mhijcdh nrrphicn`js ycdih }fh enpoh} wny mhphgxjn}hm cd 0229$ Pn}hyycdih 0229 fnqh mhiphnyhm n ehph 9$8($ Wfhd ldh ildycmhpy }fn} pn}hy fnm yrcohm elph }fnd =2(>0

Nqhpngh Rphecxey cd ]hvny* >337%0227

cd }fh }fphh shnpy ̀ halph Y@ >=* c} `hilehy ijhnp }fn} pn}hy fnqh dl} gldh mlwd$ Ndm `hinxyh la }fhnmmc}cldnj ani} }fn} ]MC fny mhphgxjn}hm alpey* ndm }fxy flehlwdhpy nphd–} gh}}cdg }fh yneh jhqhjyla ilqhpngh }fhs whph `halph 0229* flehlwdhpy nph ni}xnjjs rnscdg elph alp jhyy $

>9

Shnp Nqhpngh Y}n}hwcmhRphecxe

( Ifndgh lqhpRpclp Shnp

>337 618 D,N>336 666 0$7(>333 673 %>$2(0222 671 %2$9(022> 38> 6$1(0220 >*090 03$8(0229 >*0=3 >$=(022= >*0== %2$=(0228 >*000 %>$6(

>> ]HVNY MHRNP]EHD] LA CDYXPNDIH* ̂ XNP]HPJS JHGCYJN]CQHP HRLP] LD E NPOH] ILDMC]CLDY 09 &0226#$ ]MC–y cdalpen}cld cy `nyhm ld cdalpen}cld l`}ncdhm }fplxgf }fh DNCI*f}}r;,,www$}mc$y}n}h$}v$xy,phrlp}y,ri,mlixehd}y,ri~jp26~9$rma ndm ]HVNY MHRNP]EHD] LA CDYXPNDIH* CDYXPNDIH HVRHDYH HVFC@C]Y; ILXD]PSWCMHP HYXJ]Y LA NJJ ILERNDCHY W PC]CDG @XYCDHYY CD ]HVNY &0229%0227#* f}}r;,,www$}mc$y}n}h$}v$xy,phrlp}y,phrlp}=$f}ej >0 ]HVNY MHRNP]EHD] LA CDYXPNDIH* yxrpn dl}h 0? ]HVNY MHRNP]EHD] LA CDYXPNDIH* >06 ]F NDDXNJ P HRLP]* R NP] >; P HRLP] LA RPLGPNE NI]CQC]CHY 9 &Dlq$ 02* 0229#$>9 Mn}n ilercjhm `s }fh Laacih la Rx`jci Cdyxpndih Ilxdyhj$

http://www.tdi.state.tx.us/reports/pc/documents/pcqlr08q3.pdf


http://www.tdi.state.tx.us/reports/report4.html







1

0221 >*0>= %$7(0227 >*028 %$7(

>337%0227 93$9(

]fh ]hvny Yxrpheh Ilxp} ndm }fh Cdyxpndih Cdmxy}ps ]fh cdyxpndih cdmxy}ps fny dl} kxy} `hhd nyycy}hm `s }fh jhgcyjn}cqh ndm hvhix}cqh `pndifhy* flwhqhp$Lqhp }fh rny} acqh shnpy }fh ]hvny Yxrpheh Ilxp} fny ildycy}hd}js jha} ildyxehpy fljmcdg }fh `ng wfcjh yhdmcdg cdyxphpy ld }fhcp wns wc}f }fhcp rlioh}y `xjgcdg$

Ycdih 0229* ycv dhw kxy}cihy fnqh nyyxehm rlyc}cldy n} }fh Ilxp}$ Alp n ilxp} wc}f ldjs dcdh kxy}cihy}fn} cy n gphn} mhnj la ifndgh$ Dl} ilcdicmhd}njjs* njyl ycdih 0229* }fh yxiihyy pn}h la }fh cdyxpndihcdmxy}ps n} }fh Ilxp} fny pcyhd wfcjh }fh yxiihyy pn}h alp ildyxehpy fny anjjhd$



7

Cdyxpndih Cdmxy}ps Wcd Pn}hy n} }fh ]hvny Yxrpheh Ilxp};022>%0226 >=

2

>2

02

92

=2

82

1272

62

32

>22

022>%20 0220%29 0229%2= 022=%28 0228%21 0221%27 0227%26

Ilxp} ]hpe

R h p i h d } Y x i i h y y

a x j

Cd }fh }wl ilxp} }hpey rphihmcdg }fh cdajxv la kxy}cihy cd 0229* }fh cdyxpndih cdmxy}ps fnm wcd pn}hy

n} }fh Ilxp} la 82( &022>%20 }hpe# ndm 96( &0220%29#$ Ldih }fh cdajxv la dhw cdyxpndih%apchdmjs kxy}cihy `hgnd* flwhqhp* }fh cdmxy}ps ynw c}y yxiihyy pn}h yosplioh}$

Ny ehd}cldhm n`lqh* }fhph nph dcdh kxy}cihy ld }fh Ilxp}* ndm dldh la }fhe fny n philpm la y}ndmcdg xr alp ildyxehpy$ Lqhp }fh rny} acqh ilxp} }hpey &ycdih }fh 0229%2= }hpe wfhd }fh dhw kxy}cihy `hgnd nppcqcdg#* }fh ildyxehp yxiihyy pn}h n} }fh Ilxp} alp cdyxpndih inyhy fny `hhd n mcyenj>6($>8

Wfhd }fh xdycgdhm &rhp ixpcne# lrcdcldy nph }nohd lx}* hnif kxy}cih ind `h hqnjxn}hm `nyhm ldjs ldinyhy cd wfcif fh lp yfh iny} n philpm ql}h$ La njj }fh kxy}cihy* Kxy}cih L–Dhcjj fny }fh ely}ildyxehp%apchdmjs ql}cdg philpm alp ildyxehpy cd cdyxpndih inyhy wc}f n philpm la 91($ ]fh jhny}ildyxehp%apchdmjs kxy}cih ’ Kxy}cih Fhif} ’ ql}hm ld }fh philpm alp rljcisfljmhpy n ehph >8( la }fh

}ceh$

>1

>= ]hvny Wn}if–y Nddxnj Ilxp} Wn}if phrlp}y;f}}r;,,www$}vwalxdmn}cld$lpg,]WA,cdmhv$iae<hqhd}5yflwRngh!rg5ilxp}wn}ifnpifcqh ndm yhh Nrrhdmcv >$>8 Yhh Nrrhdmcv >$>1 ]fh ql}cdg philpmy alp }fh kxy}cihy whph ny aljjlwy; Ifcha Kxy}cih Khaahpyld ql}hm cd 06 ildyxehp%phjn}hm cdyxpndih

inyhy* ndm cd 1 la }flyh inyhy fh ql}hm ld }fh ildyxehp ycmh$ Kxy}cih Fhif} ql}hm cd 07 ildyxehp%phjn}hm cdyxpndihinyhy* ndm cd = la }flyh inyhy fh ql}hm ld }fh ildyxehp ycmh$ Kxy}cih L–Dhcjj ql}hm cd 08 ildyxehp%phjn}hm cdyxpndihinyhy* ndm cd 3 la }flyh inyhy yfh ql}hm ld }fh ildyxehp ycmh$ Kxy}cih Wncdwpcgf} ql}hm cd 06 ildyxehp%phjn}hmcdyxpndih inyhy* ndm cd 8 la }flyh inyhy fh ql}hm ld }fh ildyxehp ycmh$ Kxy}cih @pcy}hp ql}hm cd 01 ildyxehp%phjn}hmcdyxpndih inyhy* ndm cd 8 la }flyh inyhy fh ql}hm ld }fh ildyxehp ycmh$ Kxy}cih Ehmcdn ql}hm cd 02 ildyxehp%phjn}hmcdyxpndih inyhy* ndm cd 1 la }flyh inyhy fh ql}hm ld }fh ildyxehp ycmh$ Kxy}cih Gphhd ql}hm cd 02 ildyxehp%phjn}hmcdyxpndih inyhy* ndm cd = la }flyh inyhy fh ql}hm ld }fh ildyxehp ycmh$ Kxy}cih Klfdyld ql}hm cd >7 ildyxehp%phjn}hmcdyxpndih inyhy* ndm cd = la }flyh inyhy fh ql}hm ld }fh ildyxehp ycmh$ Kxy}cih Wcjjh}} ql}hm cd >6 ildyxehp%phjn}hmcdyxpndih inyhy* ndm cd 9 la }flyh inyhy fh ql}hm ld }fh ildyxehp ycmh$

http://www.txwfoundation.org/TWF/index.cfm?event=showPage&pg=courtwatcharchive





6

8 Shnp Nqhpngh Rpl%Ildyxehp Ql}cdg Philpm la }fh ]hvny Yxrpheh Ilxp} Kxy}cihy

&0229%022= }hpe }fplxgf 0227%0226 }hpe#

2

>2

02

92

=2

82

12

72

62

32

>22

K h a a h p y l d

F h i f }

L ' D h c j j

W n c d w p c g f }

@ p c y } h p

E h m c d n

G p h h d

K l f d y l d

W c j j h } }

R h p i h d } Q l } h m a l p I l d y x e h p y

Cd injixjn}cdg }fhyh ql}cdg philpmy* wh ildycmhphm 06 ycgdhm cdyxpndih inyhy mhicmhm ycdih }fh 0229%2= }hpe wflyh lx}ilehy fnqh naahi}hm ildyxehpy$ Wfcjh yleh la }fhyh inyhy fnqh ‚ehphjs― wfc}}jhm nwns n} ildyxehp rpl}hi}cldy* ends la }fhe fnqh yx`y}nd}cnjjs hplmhm rpl}hi}cldy }fhJhgcyjn}xph rplqcmhm$ Hcgf} la }fhyh inyhy fnqh enmh c} cd}l lxp nddxnj ]hppc`jh ]hd jcy} ’ n jcy} la }fh ely} fnpeaxj inyhy }l ildyxehpy mxpcdg }fh }hpe$ >7

Cd Alp}cy @hdhac}y q $ Ind}x &0227#* }fh Ilxp} lqhp}xpdhm 08 shnpy la rphihmhd} }fn} ph~xcphmrljcisfljmhpy }l `h ‚enmh wfljh― rpclp }l phce`xpycdg cdyxpndih ilernds rnsehd}y$

Lqhp }fh rny} acqh shnpy* }fh Ilxp} fny ildycy}hd}js phy}pci}hm }fh cd}hprph}n}cld la cdyxpndih rljcichyyxif }fn} ildyxehpy nph gh}}cdg hqhd jhyy ilqhpngh }fnd }fhs rncm alp$ La }fh ends cdyxpndih inyhy}fn} fnqh `hhd fnpeaxj }l ildyxehpy lqhp }fcy rhpclm* }wl la }fhe rnp}cixjnpjs mhyhpqh }l `h ycdgjhmlx} alp cdmcqcmxnj n}}hd}cld$

>6

Alp lqhp 08 shnpy* yh}}jhehd} nwnpmy }l rljcisfljmhpy fnqh `hhd glqhpdhm `s }fh aljjlwcdg mli}pcdh;‚wfhd ‖hc}fhp }fh cdyxphp lp }fh cdyxphm exy} }l yleh hv}hd} gl xdrncm* }fh jlyy yflxjm `h `lpdh `s

Cd Alp}cy * Qndhyyn Ind}x wny yhpclxyjs cdkxphm cd nd nx}lel}cqh niicmhd}$ Fhp cdyxpndih ldjs ilqhphm nrlp}cld la fhp ehmcinj ily}y* yl yfh }llo exj}crjh rnp}chy }l ilxp} cd lpmhp }l philqhp fhp ehmcinjhvrhdyhy$ ]fh yh}}jhehd} yfh phihcqhm ldjs ilqhphm n rlp}cld la fhp ax}xph ehmcinj hvrhdyhy$

>7 Yhh Nrrhdmcv 0$ ]fh ]hppc`jh ]hd jcy} alp }fh 0227%26 }hpe fny dl} sh} `hhd acdnjc{hm* `x} }fh cdyxpndih inyhy aple}fn} }hpe nph jcy}hm cd Nrrhdmcv 0 ndm cdijxmhm cd njj injixjn}cldy cd }fcy phrlp}$>6 Mlioh} Dl$ 28%273>$



3

}fh cdyxphp alp }fn} cy }fh pcyo }fh cdyxphm fny rncm c} }l nyyxeh$–―>3

Cd @pncdnpm q $ ]pcdc}s Xdcqhpynj Cdyxpndih Il$ &0221#* }fh Ilxp} hv}hdmhm }fh mhnmjcdh alp nd cdyxpndihilernds }l rns xdcdyxphm,xdmhp%cdyxphm el}lpcy} &XE,XCE# `hdhac}y$

]fh Yxrpheh Ilxp} mhrnp}hmaple }fcy yhdyc`jh ndm ancp rljcis ndm pxjhm }fn} cdyxpndih rljcis jndgxngh wcjj dlw }pxer ndcdyxphm–y cd}hphy} cd `hcdg enmh wfljh$ ]fh rpni}cinj haahi} alp ildyxehpy cy }fn} }fhs ind dlw `hjha} wc}f cdnmh~xn}h ilerhdyn}cld }l ilqhp }fhcp `nyci ehmcinj dhhmy$

02

>3 Lp}c{ q$ Gphn} Ylx}fhpd Acph ndm Iny$ Cdy$ Il$* 837 Y$W$0m 9=0* 9== &]hv$ >362# &~xl}cdg Gnppc}s q$ Pxpnj Ex}$ Cdy$Il$* 089 D$W$0m 8>0* 8>= &>377##$02 Mlioh} Dl$ 2=%2897$

XE,XCE ̀ hdhac}y nphendmn}hm `s jnw ndm nph mhycgdhm }l rpl}hi} cdyxphm el}lpcy}y wfl nph cdkxphm `s xdcdyxphm lpxdmhpcdyxphm mpcqhpy$ Ldih n rljcisfljmhp yx`ec}y n ijnce nd cdyxpndih ilernds fny 92 mnsy }l rns `halph }fh cdyxphp ens `h phyrldyc`jh alp }fh rljcisfljmhp–y jhgnj ahhy ca fh lp yfh exy} }noh }fhcdyxphp }l ilxp} }l alpih c} }l fldlp }fh ilqhpngh$ Rpclp }l @pncdnpm * }fcy 92%mns }cehjcdh y}np}hm wfhd }fh rljcisfljmhp acjhm n ijnce alp XE,XCE ilqhpngh wc}f }fh cdyxphp$ Dlw }fh }cehjcdh mlhydl} `hgcd xd}cj na}hp }fh rljcisfljmhp }nohy }fh cdyxphp }l ilxp} ndm l`}ncdy n kxmgehd} }fn} }fn} }fhcdyxphp exy} rns$

]fcy dhw rljcis gcqhy cdyxphpy n y}pldg cdihd}cqh }l mhds ijncey alp XE,XCE ilqhpngh nyrljcisfljmhpy wcjj dl jldghp `h n`jh }l philqhp }fhcp jhgnj ahhy ca }fhs nph alpihm }l }noh }fhcp cdyxphp

}l ilxp}$ ]fxy hqhd ca n rljcisfljmhp mlhy wcd n kxmgehd} }fn} }fh cdyxphp exy} rns }fh XE,XCE`hdhac}y* }fh cdyxphp wcjj fnqh }l rns dl elph }fnd ca c} fnm rncm }fh ijnce wfhd c} wny lpcgcdnjjs acjhm$ ]fh rpni}cinj phyxj} cy }fn} cdyxphpy nph jhyy jcohjs }l rns qnjcm ijncey$

]fh }phdm }lwnpm np`c}pnps rpl}hi}cldy alp cdyxphpy cy hyrhicnjjs mcy}xp`cdg cd jcgf} la cdyxphpy–ild}cdxhm hdiplnifehd} ld ildyxehpy– pcgf}y cd }fhcp fndmjcdg la hqhpsmns cdyxpndih ijncey$Rljcisfljmhpy hvrhi} }fn} wfhd }fhs nph anihm wc}f fnqcdg }l acjh n jhgc}cen}h ijnce wc}f }fhcpcdyxpndih ilernds }fhs wcjj `h ancpjs ilerhdyn}hm? flwhqhp* ny n phyxj} la }fh Ilxp}–y mhicycld%enocdg }fn} cy dl jldghp n ynah nyyxer}cld$ Rphmci}n`js* cdyxphpy nph yhhocdg phjcha }fplxgf }fh ilxp}y`hinxyh }fh nd}c%ildyxehp* rpl%cdyxpndih cdmxy}ps dn}xph la }fh fcgf ilxp} cy whjj odlwd }l cdmxy}ps cdycmhpy* ndm exif elph la}hd }fnd dl} }fh Ilxp} yxrrlp}y }fh nggphyycqh nd}c%ijncend} `hfnqclp la

cdyxpndih ilerndchy cd }fcy y}n}h$

Ildijxycld ]hvndy fnqh anihm n acqh shnp nyynxj} ld }fhcp cdyxpndih pcgf}y dl} ldjs `s }fh cdyxpndih cdmxy}ps* `x}`s }fhcp lwd y}n}h glqhpdehd}$ Na}hp dhnp ilerjh}h mhphgxjn}cld* }fh cdmxy}ps fny x}}hpjs ancjhm }lrljcih c}yhja ny rplecyhm* ndm fny cdy}hnm iflyhd }l pxd plxgf yflm lqhp ]hvny rljcisfljmhpy$Cdyxphpy fnqh ix} }fhcp jhqhjy la ilqhpngh wfcjh ifnpgcdg ildyxehpy elph eldhs$ ]fh ]hvnyYxrpheh Ilxp} fny rx} }fh cicdg ld }fcy eljms inoh ̀ s fniocdg xr wfn} jc}}jh ildyxehp rpl}hi}cldyphencd$

Mhphgxjn}cld la }fh `ndocdg ndm elp}gngh cdmxy}ps fny jhm }l n ipcycy ld }fh dn}cldnj jhqhj$

Mhphgxjn}cld la }fh cdyxpndih cdmxy}ps cd ]hvny fny jhm }l yosplioh}cdg pn}hy wc}f jhyy ilqhpngh$Mhphgxjn}cld ijhnpjs cy dl} }fh ndywhp }l gphn}hp ildyxehp rpl}hi}cld lp }l n fhnj}fs enpoh}rjnih ’ haahi}cqh phgxjn}cld cy $



>2

Yljx}cldy ]hvny Wn}if fny rplrlyhm yhqhd phalpey }fh Jhgcyjn}xph ind enoh }fn} wcjj fhjr }l ph}xpdrpl}hi}cldy }l ildyxehpy ndm phcgd cd }fh cdmxy}ps$

Wc}flx} qcglplxy lqhpycgf} la pn}hy `s ]MC* }fhph cy dl wns la nifchqcdg }fh `njndihdhihyynps alp n qcglplxy enpoh}$ Gcqhd }fn} ends cdyxpndih rplmxi}y nph ph~xcphm `s jnw lpjhdmcdg rpni}cih ndm l}fhpy nph dhihyynps }l hdyxph n fhnj}fs rlrxjn}cld* c} cy ipxicnj }fn} ]MC whcgf cd }l hdyxph }fn} pn}hy nph ancp alp ildyxehpy ndm rplac}y nph phnyldn`jh alpcdmxy}ps$

Ph~xcph Phnj Pn}h Lqhpycgf} `s Cerjhehd}cdg n Rpclp Nrrplqnj Ysy}he

Na}hp }fh cdyxpndih phalpe la 0229* cdyxphpy whph njjlwhm }l mhqcn}h aple y}ndmnpm rljcichyndm }l laahp nd xdjcec}hm dxe`hp la rljcichy wc}f mcaahphd} jhqhjy la ilqhpngh$ ]fh phyxj}*flwhqhp* cy }fn} ildyxehpy ind dl jldghp yflr ld rpcih njldh ny ilqhpngh qnpchy wcmhjs aple rljcis }l rljcis$ Cd lpmhp }l ph}xpd rlwhp }l }fh fndmy la ildyxehpy }l rcio }fh `hy}rljcis* ]MC exy} ph~xcph cdyxphpy }l laahp y}ndmnpm alpey }fn} laahp xdcalpe ilqhpngh$

Ph~xcph Y}ndmnpmc{hm Flehlwdhpy Rljcichy

]fh cdyxpndih cdmxy}ps fny cdiphnycdgjs `hhd xycdg iphmc} yilphy }l mh}hpecdh rljcisfljmhpy–pn}hy$ Iphmc} yilphy nph mh}hpecdhm `nyhm ld n rhpyld–y rnsehd} fcy}lps* nelxd}y lwhm*jhdg}f la iphmc} fcy}lps* dhw iphmc}* ndm }srhy la iphmc}$ Dldh la }fhyh ipc}hpcn mcphi}js phjn}h}l n rljcisfljmhp–y cdyxpndih pcyo$ Cd ani}* ends ildyxehpy wfl fnqh dhqhp acjhm ndcdyxpndih ijnce acdm }fhcp cdyxpndih pn}hy pcycdg `nyhm yljhjs ld }fhcp iphmc} yilph$

@nd Iphmc} Yilpcdg

]fh ileecyycldhp–y mx}s cy }l hdyxph ancp }phn}ehd} alp flehlwdhpy* mpcqhpy* rn}chd}y ndmyenjj `xycdhyy lwdhpy$ Hqhd }flxgf }fh ileecyycldhp–y mhicycldy }lxif hqhps ]hvnd* fh cy

fhjm niilxd}n`jh s̀ ldjs ldh rhpyld; }fh glqhpdlp wfl nrrlcd}hm fce$

Enoh }fh Cdyxpndih Ileecyycldhp nd Hjhi}hm Rlyc}cld

Xdmhp ixpphd} jnw* cdyxpndih ilerndchy nph n`jh }l qnps pn}hy wc}fcd n ilxd}s `s nds nelxd} }fhs ind ni}xnpcnjjs kxy}cas$ ]fcy fny jhm }l n jnpgh mcyrnpc}s cd }fh nelxd} }fn}rhlrjh wc}fcd n ycdgjh ilxd}s ’ hqhd rhlrjh ld }fh yneh `jlio ’ exy} rns alp cdyxpndih$ ]fh phyxj} cy }fn} cdyxphpy nph inpqcdg xr ilxd}chy ndm ifnpgcdg pn}hy }fn} qnps `s [CR ilmh$ ]l rphqhd} }fcy* }fhph yflxjm `h n envcexe >8( pn}cdg qnpcndih njjlwhm rhp ilxd}s$

Jcec} }fh Xyh la Pn}cdg ]hppc}lpchy

Cdyxphpy mcqcmh ildyxehpy cd}l in}hglpchy ndm yx`%in}hglpchy }l mh}hpecdh wfn} pn}hy }fhs

wcjj rns$ ]fhph cy ixpphd}js dl jcec} ld }fh dxe`hp la }cehy n rhpyld ens `h yx`%in}hglpc{hm$ ]fh phyxj} cy }fn} }fhph nph yl ends in}hglpchy* }fn}* alp hvnerjh* >7 shnp ljmenjhy cd n rnp}cixjnp [CR ilmh wc}f n rnp}cixjnp iphmc} yilph mpcqcdg n rnp}cixjnp elmhj la inpenoh xr n ycdgjh in}hglps$ ]fcy hv}hdycqh xyh la in}hglpc{n}cld dhgn}hy }fh rlcd} la cdyxpndih ’ }fn} pcyo `h yfnphm$

Jcec} }fh Xyh la Pn}cdg In}hglpchy cd Nx}l Cdyxpndih

Ph~xcph ]MC }l Rhdnjc{h Y}n}h%wcmh Rxjjlx}y `s Cerlycdg n 8%Shnp @nd ld Ph%hd}ps



>>

Cdyxphpy inpps nd hdlpelxy nelxd} la rlwhp cd lxp y}n}h$ Ca ]MC }fphn}hdy }l mcynrrplqh npn}h lp n alpe* cdyxphpy ind rxjj lx} la }fh y}n}h hd}cphjs wc}f dl rhdnj}s* ldjs }l ph%hd}hp c} wc}fcd eld}fy$



>0

Nrrhdmcv >; Jcy} la ildyxehp%phjn}hm cdyxpndih inyhy `s }hpe aple}fh 0220%29 }hpe }fplxgf }fh 0227%26 }hpe

0227%2617( yxiihyy pn}h alp }fh cdyxpndih cdmxy}ps q$ 99( yxiihyy pn}h alp ildyxehpy

† Dn}cldnj Xdcld Acph Cdy$ Il$ q $ Ipliohp &21%2616# &0226# &ildyxehp jlyy#† ]hvny Ex}xnj Cdy$ Il$ q$ Jhm`h}}hp &21%26>=# &0226# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† Hvihyy Xdmhpwpc}hpy q $ Apndo–y Inycdg 0>

† Dn}cldwcmh Cdy$ Il$ q $ Hjifhfcec &21%2>21# &0226# &ildyxehp jlyy#

&20%2792# &0226# &ildyxehp wcd#

† Ancpachjm Cdy$ Il$ q $ Y}hrfhdy Enp}cd Rnqcdg* JR &2=%2706# &0226# &ildyxehp wcd#

† Elpnjhy q $ Jc`hp}s Ex}xnj Cdy$ Il$ &28%278=# &0227# &ildyxehp wcd#

† Ecm%Ihd}xps Cdy$ Il$ la ]hvny q$ Nmhenk &28%22>1# &0227# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† Y}ldh`pcmgh Jcah Cdy$ Il$ q $ Rc}}y &21%2188# &0227# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† Cd ph Ehppcjj Jsdif ]pxy} Il$ &2=%2618# &0227# &ildyxehp jlyy#

0221%2732( yxiihyy pn}h alp }fh cdyxpndih cdmxy}ps q$ >2( yxiihyy pn}h alp ildyxehpy

† Ic}c{hdy Cdy$ Il$ q $ Mniinif &29%2828# &0227# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† Anpehpy Gplxr Cdi$ q $ Jx`cd &28%2>13# &0227# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† Cd ph Njjy}n}h Ilxd}s Ex}$ Cdy$ Il$ &21%2676# &0227# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† Alp}cy @hdhac}y q $ Ind}x &28%273># &0227# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† @hd @lj}%Rnjc}l Ildyljcmn}hm C$Y$M$ q$ ]hvny Rljc}cinj Yx`mcqcycldy Rplrhp}s,Inyxnj}s Klcd} Yhja%Cdy$Axdm &28%29=2# &0221# &ildyxehp wcd#

† @jxh Iplyy @jxh Yfchjm la ]hvny q $ Mxhdh{ &28%280># &0221# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† Achyy q$ Y}n}h Anpe Jjlsmy &2=%>>2=# &0221# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† @pncdnpm q $ ]pcdc}s Xdcqhpynj Cdy$ Il$ &2=%2897# &0221# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† Y}n}h Anpe Ex}$ Nx}lel`cjh Cdy$ Il$ q $ Dciohpyld &2=%2=07# &0221# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† Y}n}h Anpe Ex}$ Nx}lel`cjh Cdy$ Il$ q $ Dlppcy &2=%28>=# &0221# &ildyxehp jlyy#

0228%2169( yxiihyy pn}h alp }fh cdyxpndih cdmxy}ps q$ >7( yxiihyy pn}h alp ildyxehpy

† Cd ph Qhy}n Cdyxpndih Gplxr* Cdi$ &2=%2>=># &0221# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† Ecddhyl}n Jcah Cdyxpndih Il$ q $ Qny~xh{ &2=%2=77# &0221# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† Njjy}n}h Cdmhedc}s Il$ q $ Alp}f &28%2287# &0221# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† Acmhjc}s ! Gxnpnd}s q $ Mphwhps &28%2038# &0221# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† GxcmhLdh q$ Achjmhp Plnm @nr}cy} &2=%2130# &0221# &ildyxehp wcd#

† Rplgphyycqh q $ @lsm &2=%2288# &0228# &ildyxehp jlyy#

0> ]fh acpy} lrcdcld alp Hvihyy Xdmhpwpc}hpy q $ Apndo–y Inycdg wny mhjcqhphm cd 0228$ Xrld ph~xhy}* flwhqhp* }fh Ilxp}phildycmhphm }fh inyh ndm cyyxhm n dhw lrcdcld cd 0226$ @l}f inyhy nph ilxd}hm }lwnpm }fh }l}nj dxe`hp la cdyxpndihinyhy ndm cd }fh kxy}cihy– ildyxehp yilph ny hnif kxy}cih wny gcqhd }fh lrrlp}xdc}s }l ql}h cd hnif inyh ndm ilxjm fnqhifndghm fcy lp fhp ecdm$



>9

022=%2876( yxiihyy pn}h alp }fh cdyxpndih cdmxy}ps q$ 00( yxiihyy pn}h alp ildyxehpy

† Hvihyy Xdmhpwpc}hpy q $ Apndo–y Inycdg &20%2792# &0228# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† Njjy}n}h Cdyxpndih Ilernds q$ Fnjjend &29%2387# &0228# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† Dn}cldnj Why}hpd Jcah Cdyxpndih Il$ q $ Plwh &20%>2>2# &0228# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† Phrx`jci Xdmhpwpc}hpy Cdyxpndih Il$ q $ Ehv%]hv* Cdi$ &29%2110# &022=# &ildyxehp jlyy#† Dlp}fhpd Ilxd}s Ex}xnj Cdyxpndih Il$ q$ Mnqnjly &20%>227# &022=# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† ]hvny Anpe @xphnx Ex}xnj Cdy$ Il$ q$ Y}xpplio &20%2213# &022=# &ildyxehp wcd#

† Ljm Nehpcind Ilxd}s Ex}xnj Acph Cdy$ Il$ q $ Yndifh{ &20%26=9# &022=# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† Y}n}h Anpe Ex}xnj Nx}lel`cjh Cdyxpndih Il$ q $ Jlrh{ 00

† X}cin Dn}cldnj Cdy$ Il$ l a ]hvny q $ Nehpcind Cdmhedc}s Il$ &20%2232# &022=# &ildyxehp wcd#

&2>%28=2# &022=# &ildyxehp jlyy#09

0229%2=>22( yxiihyy pn}h alp }fh cdyxpndih cdmxy}ps q$ 2( yxiihyy pn}h alp ildyxehpy

† Rplgphyycqh Ilxd}s Ex}xnj Cdy$ Ilernds q$ @ncjhs &20%2776# &022=# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† Y}n}h ndm Ilxd}s Ex}xnj Acph Cdy$ Il$ q $ Enicny &20%2699# &022=# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† Ljm Nehpcind Ilxd}s Ex}xnj Acph Cdy$ Il$ q $ Phdaplw &20%>267# &022=# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† Nehpcind Endxani}xphpy Ex}xnj Cdy$ Il$ q$ Yifnhahp &20%2038# &0229# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† Rplqcmhd} Jcah ndm Niicmhd} Cdy$ Il$ q $ Odl}} &20%2=68# &0229# &ildyxehp jlyy#

0220%2996( yxiihyy pn}h alp }fh cdyxpndih cdmxy}ps q$ 19( yxiihyy pn}h alp ildyxehpy

† Rplgphyycqh Ilxd}s Ex}xnj Cdy$ Il$ q $ Ycdo &2>%289=# &0229# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† X}cin Dn}cldnj Cdy$ Il$ l a ]hvny q $ Nehpcind Cdmhedc}s Il$ &20%2232# &0229# &ildyxehp wcd#

† Qnjjhs Alpgh Cdy$ Il$ q $ Nxy}cd &20%2>22# &0229# &ildyxehp wcd#

† Pns Cdy$ Nghdis q $ Kldhy &20%2223# &0220# &ildyxehp wcd#

† Y}n}h Anpe Ex}$ Nx}l$ Cdy$ Il$ q $ Jlrh{ &2>%28=2# &0220# &ildyxehp wcd#† ]hvny Anpe @xphnx Ex}xnj Cdy$ Il$ q$ Yhnpy &2>%268># &0220# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† Ocdg q$ Mnjjny Cdy$ Il$ &22%>>80# &0220# &ildyxehp wcd#

† Cd ph Njjy}n}h Ilxd}s Ex}xnj Cdy$ Il$ &22%>92># &0220# &ildyxehp jlyy#

022>%2082( yxiihyy pn}h alp }fh cdyxpndih cdmxy}ps q$ 82( yxiihyy pn}h alp ildyxehpy

† Ild}cdhd}nj Inyxnj}s Il$ q $ Mlwdy &22%>923# &ildyxehp wcd#

† Ocdg q$ Mnjjny Acph Cdy$ Il$ &22%>>80# &0220# &ildyxehp wcd#

† Plilp Cd}hpdn}cldnj* Cdi$ q$ Dn}cldnj Xdcld Acph Cdy$ Il$ &33%2219# &0220# &ildyxehp wcd#

00 ]fh acpy} lrcdcld alp Y}n}h Anpe Ex}xnj Nx}lel`cjh Cdy$ Il$ q$ Jlrh{ wny mhjcqhphm cd 0220$ Xrld ph~xhy}* flwhqhp* }fhIlxp} phildycmhphm }fh inyh ndm cyyxhm n dhw lrcdcld cd 022=$ @l}f inyhy nph ilxd}hm }lwnpm }fh }l}nj dxe`hp la cdyxpndih inyhy ndm cd }fh kxy}cihy– ildyxehp yilph ny hnif kxy}cih wny gcqhd }fh lrrlp}xdc}s }l ql}h cd hnif inyh ndmilxjm fnqh ifndghm fcy lp fhp ecdm$09 ]fh acpy} lrcdcld alp X}cin Dn}cldnj Cdy$ Il$ la ]hvny q $ Nehpcind Cdmhedc}s Il$ wny mhjcqhphm cd 0220$ Xrld ph~xhy}*flwhqhp* }fh Ilxp} phildycmhphm }fh inyh ndm cyyxhm n dhw lrcdcld cd 022=$ @l}f inyhy nph ilxd}hm }lwnpm }fh }l}njdxe`hp la cdyxpndih inyhy ndm cd }fh kxy}cihy– ildyxehp yilph ny hnif kxy}cih wny gcqhd }fh lrrlp}xdc}s }l ql}h cd hnifinyh ndm ilxjm fnqh ifndghm fcy lp fhp ecdm$



>=

† Npgldnx} Cdy$ Il$ q$ @nohp &2>%2067# &0220# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† Ecm%Ihd}xps Cdy$ Il$ la ]hvny q$ @ls}h &2>%2809# &0220# &ildyxehp jlyy#

† Nehpcind El}lpcy}y Cdy$ Il$ q $ Almgh &22%28=7# &022># &ildyxehp jlyy#



>8

Nrrhdmcv 0; ]hppc`jh ]hd Cdyxpndih Inyhy

]fhph fnqh `hhd 93 cdyxpndih lrcdcldy mhicmhm ycdih }fh 0229%2= }hpe }fn} fnqh fnm cerjcin}cldyalp ildyxehpy$ Hcgf} la }fhyh inyhy fnqh enmh lxp nddxnj jcy} ny `hcdg inyhy wc}f }fh ely} dhgn}cqhcerni} ld ildyxehpy$ N `pcha y}n}hehd} la }fh cerni} la hnif la }fhyh inyhy aljjlwy$

&Wcjjh}} 3%2# &0227#Cerni}

; Cdkxphm ildyxehpy dlw exy} phce`xpyh cdyxpndih ilernds rnsehd}y `halph }fhs indphilqhp axjj ehmcinj hvrhdyhy

&Khaahpyld 7%2# &0221#Cerni}

; Cdihd}cqc{hy }fh mhdcnj la xdcdyxphm,xdmhpcdyxphm el}lpcy} ijncey `s cdyxpndih ilerndchy

&@pcy}hp 7%0# &0221#Cerni}; Xdmhpecdhy cdyxpndih rljcisfljmhpy `s acdmcdg }fn} ild}pni}y wc}f xdijhnp jndgxngh anqlpcdyxpndih ilerndchy

&Lwhd 7%2# &0228#Cerni}; Nmlr}y Injcalpdcn jnw ndm iphn}hy nd cerjchm pcgf} la phce`xpyhehd} alp cdyxpndih inppchpy$

&Fhif} 8%0# &022=#Cerni}

; Gcqhy cdyxpndih ilerndchy nd xdancp nmqnd}ngh cd yh}}jhehd} dhgl}cn}cldy wc}frljcisfljmhpy

&Rfcjjcry 3%2# &022=#Cerni}

; @plnmhdy }fh yilrh la }fh cdyxpndih cdmxy}ps–y ild}plj lqhp jc}cgn}cld cdqljqcdg nrljcisfljmhp

&Rhp ixpcne# &022=#Cerni}; Hdn`jhy cdyxpndih ilerndchy }l np`c}pnpcjs mhds ilqhpngh alp rhpec}}hm xyh la cdyxphmilernds qhfcijhy

&L–Dhcjj 3%2# &0229#Cerni}

; Hy}n`jcyfhy n rphihmhd} }fn} phmxihy cdyxpndih ilerndchy– phyrldyc`cjc}s }l rljcisfljmhpyalp jlyy la qnjxh cd phrncphm qhfcijhy

manipulation of the market: how the insurance industry has gamed all three branches of state...

Documents