LOKPAL BILL LOKPAL BILL

DIFFERENT VERSIONS

DIFFERENT VERSIONS

KEY DIFFERENCES

TEAM ANNA

SHOULD THE PM COME UNDER THE AMBIT OF LOKPAL?

GOVERNMENT

YES, IS ACCOUNTABLE TO LOKPAL YES, BUT ONLY WHENTHE PM DEMITS OFFICE

LOKSATTA ARUNA ROY

NO,CAN’T BE ACCOUNTABLE TO ANY EXTRA PARLIAMENTARYAUTHORITY

YES, BUT SUPREME COURT NOD IS REQUIRED

SHOULD LOWER BUREAUCRACY BE UNDER AMBIT OF LOKPAL?

TEAM ANNA GOVERNMENT

YES, IT SHOULD COME NO, IT WILL DEAL ONLY WITH GROUP- A OFFICERS

LOKSATTA ARUNA ROY

YES, BUT FOCUS ON HIGHERLEVEL CORRUPTION

NO, STRONGER CENTRAL VIGILANCE COMMISSION (CVC)TO DEAL WITH LOWER OFFICERS

SHOULD JUDICIARY BE BROUGHT UNDER LOKPAL?

TEAM ANNA GOVERNMENT

YES, IT SHOULD COME NO, ALREADY INTRODUCING JUDICIAL ACCOUNTABILITY BILL

LOKSATTA ARUNA ROY

NO, CREATE NATIONAL JUDICIAL PANEL BY EX-JUDGES

NO, JUDCIAL ACCOUNTABLE BILL NEEDS TO BE STRENGTHENED

TEAM ANNA

SHOULD CENTRE LAW SET UP LOKAYUKTAS IN STATES?

GOVERNMENT

YES, IT SHOULD COME NO, IT VIOLATES FEDERAL STRUCTURE

LOKSATTA ARUNA ROY

YES, ITS ALREADY DONE FOR RTI

YES, PARLIAMENT CAN PASS SUCH A LAW

SHOULD EACH DEPT HAVE A CITIZEN CHARTER FOR GRIEVANCE REDRESSEL ?

TEAM ANNA GOVERNMENT

YES, IT SHOULD COME CITIZEN CHARTER OF CENTRALGOVT ALREADY IN PLACENEEDS TO BE STRENGTHENED.

LOKSATTA ARUNA ROY

NO, IT SHOULDN’T BE BURDENED WITH GRIEVANCES

NO, SEPARATE GRIEVANCES PANEL UNDER DIFFERENT LAW

MERGER OF CBI WITH LOKPAL

TEAM ANNA GOVERNMENT

YES, IT SHOULD BE MERGED TOACT INDEPENDENT

NO, LOKPAL WILL HAVE ITS OWN INVESTIGATION WING

LOKSATTA ARUNA ROY

NO, BUT CBI ANTI-GRAFT UNIT MUST REPORT TO LOKPAL

NO, LOKPAL AND CVC WILL HAVE SEPARATE PROBE BODIES

LET PARLIAMENT

DEBATE!

LET PARLIAMENT

DEBATE!