loa - democratic alliance v acting ndpp-head of dso-jg zuma (review 19577-09) [part d]

4
C:/2015/ZUMA/LOA - Page 1 of 4 Democratic Alliance v Acting NDPP-Head of DSO-JG Zuma (Review 19577/09) [PART D] IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA, NORTH GAUTENG HIGH COURT, PRETORIA CASE NO.: 19577/2009 In the matter between: DEMOCRATIC ALLIANCE Applicant and THE ACTING NATIONAL DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS First Respondent THE HEAD OF THE DIRECTORATE OF SPECIAL OPERATIONS Second Respondent JACOB GEDLEYIHLEKISA ZUMA Third Respondent THIRD RESPONDENT’S LIST OF AUTHORITIES PART “D1. BATO STAR FISHING (PTY) LTD 2004 (4) SA 490 (CC) 2. BEINASH v WIXLEY 1997 (3) SA 721 (SCA) 3. CABINET OF THE TRANSITIONAL GOVERNMENT OF SWA v EINS 1988 (3) SA 369 (A)

Upload: encacom

Post on 05-Nov-2015

1.466 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

DESCRIPTION

3RD RESP'S HEADS OF ARGUMENT including CHRONOLOGY, LIST OF MAIN JUDGMENTS & LIST OF AUTHORITIES : DA//NDPP/DSO/JGZ

TRANSCRIPT

  • C:/2015/ZUMA/LOA - Page 1 of 4 Democratic Alliance v Acting NDPP-Head of DSO-JG Zuma (Review 19577/09) [PART D]

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA,

    NORTH GAUTENG HIGH COURT, PRETORIA

    CASE NO.: 19577/2009

    In the matter between:

    DEMOCRATIC ALLIANCE Applicant

    and

    THE ACTING NATIONAL DIRECTOR OF

    PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS First Respondent

    THE HEAD OF THE DIRECTORATE OF

    SPECIAL OPERATIONS Second Respondent

    JACOB GEDLEYIHLEKISA ZUMA Third Respondent

    THIRD RESPONDENTS LIST OF AUTHORITIES

    PART D

    1. BATO STAR FISHING (PTY) LTD 2004 (4) SA 490 (CC)

    2. BEINASH v WIXLEY 1997 (3) SA 721 (SCA)

    3. CABINET OF THE TRANSITIONAL GOVERNMENT OF SWA v EINS

    1988 (3) SA 369 (A)

  • C:/2015/ZUMA/LOA - Page 2 of 4 Democratic Alliance v Acting NDPP-Head of DSO-JG Zuma (Review 19577/09) [PART D]

    4. CARMICHELE v MINISTER OF SAFETY AND SECURITY AND

    ANOTHER (CENTRE FOR APPLIED LEGAL STUDIES

    INTERVENING) 2001 (4) SA 938 (CC)

    5. CTP LTD AND OTHERS v INDEPENDENT NEWSPAPERS

    HOLDINGS LTD 1999 (1) SA 452 (W)

    6. DEMOCRATIC ALLIANCE AND OTHERS v ACTING NATIONAL

    DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS AND OTEHRS 2012 (3) SA

    489 (SCA)

    7. DEMOCRATIC ALLIANCE v PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC OF

    SOUTH AFRICA AND OTHERS 2013 (1) SA 248 (CC)

    8. FERREIRA v LEVIN NO AND OTHERS 1996 (1) 984 (CC)

    9. FOUCHER v FRANCE 1997 25 EHRR 234

    10. GAUTENG GAMBLING BOARD AND ANOTHER v MEC FOR

    ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT, GAUTENG 2013 (5) SA 24 (SCA)

    11. GIANT CONCERTS CC V RINALDO INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD [2012]

    ZACC 28, 2013 (3) BCLR 251 (CC)

    12. GLENISTER v PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC OF SOUTH AFRICA

    AND OTHERS 2011 (3) SA 347 (CC)

    13. JESPERS v BELGIUM 1981 27 DR 61

    14. JUSTICE ALLIANCE OF SOUTH AFRICA v PRESIDENT OF THE

    REPUBLIC OF SOUTH AFRICA AND OTHERS 2011 (5) SA 388 (CC)

    15. KAUNDA AND OTHERS v PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC OF

    SOUTH AFRICA AND OTHERS 2005 (4) SA 235 (CC)

    16. MOEVA v DEPARTMENT OF LABOUR 1981 NZLR 464 482 (New

  • C:/2015/ZUMA/LOA - Page 3 of 4 Democratic Alliance v Acting NDPP-Head of DSO-JG Zuma (Review 19577/09) [PART D]

    Zealand).

    17. MOLAPE v DPP (18 June 1997) CRI/T/1/97

    18. NATIONAL DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS v FREEDOM

    UNDER LAW 2014 (4) SA 298 (SCA)

    19. NDPP v ZUMA 2009 (2) 277 (SCA)

    20. PHARMACEUTICAL MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION OF SOUTH

    AFRICA AND ANOTHER: IN RE EX PARTE PRESIDENT OF THE

    REPUBLIC OF SOUTH AFRICA AND OTHERS 2000 (2) SA 674 (CC)

    21. R v BECKFORD 1996 1 Cr App R 94

    22. R v BLACKLEDGE 1996 1 Cr App Rep 326

    23. R v CONWAY 1989 (1) SCR 59 67 (Canada)

    24. R (CORNER HOUSE RESEARCH) v DIRECTOR OF SFO [2008] 4 All

    ER HL 927

    25. R v EARLY AND OTHERS 2003 1 Cr App R 19

    26. R v GELL 2003 (1) Cr App R 295

    27. R v H and C 2004 (2) AC 13 (also 2004 (2) Cr App R 10)

    28. R v HORSEFERRYS 1994 AC 42 61 (England)

    29. R v KEANE 1994 (2) ALL ER 478 484

    30. R v PATEL 2001 EWCA 2505

    31. R v STINCHCOMBE (1991) 18 CCR 2d 210

    32. R v TAYLOR 1994 98 Cr App R361

    33. R v UDDIN, ALI, BAIG, CHANDOO, GOLECHHA, 25 May 2005,

    Southwark Crown Court

    34. R v WARD 1993 (2) ALL ER 577

  • C:/2015/ZUMA/LOA - Page 4 of 4 Democratic Alliance v Acting NDPP-Head of DSO-JG Zuma (Review 19577/09) [PART D]

    35. S v AGLIOTTI 2011 (2) SACR 437 (GSJ)

    36. S v CROSSBERG 2008 (2) SACR 317 SCA

    37. S v EBRAHIM 1991 (2) SA 553 (A)

    38. S v ROWAND 2009 (2) SACR 450 (W)

    39. S v ROZANI; ROZANI v DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS,

    WESTERN CAPE AND OTHERS 2009 (1) SACR 540 (C)

    40. S v VAN DER WESTHUIZEN 2011 (2) SACR 26 (SCA)

    41. S v ZUMA 2006 (2) SACR 191 (W)

    42. SMYTH v USHEWOKUNZE AND ANOTHER 1998 (3) SA 1125 (ZS)

    43. TURNBULL-JACKSON v HIBISCUS COAST MUNICIPALITY AND

    OTHERS 2014 (6) SA 592 (CC)

    44. VAN ECK, NO, AND VAN RENSBURG, NO, V ETNA STORES 1947

    (2) SA 984 (A).

    KJ KEMP SC

    AA GABRIEL SC

    HS GANI

    T KHUZWAYO

    Chambers Durban

    22nd June 2015.