Literary Criticism

And the Dead Poet’s Society

Step 1: Explore the various "levels of the mind" as they relate to characters

or mass psychology in the literature. Freud separated the mind's force into a trinity: id (instinct of character), ego (realistic part of the character) and superego (moralizing part of the character). The way characters use these three mental powers to navigate life's events is central to a Freudian analysis.

Step 2: Look at the "mental energy" of a character, in other words, the motivation of the character. Freud used the word "libido" in a general sense to illustrate use of mental energy. We tend to use libido and it's inherent "mojo" as a sexual references, but that's not the only application of the term.

Step 3: Look at the way characters handle or express repression. Repression is a theme in Freudian work as a necessary aspect of psychology mediating action.

Step 4: Examine psychic conflicts in the literature. If a character grapples with himself it can represent a conflict between two "Freudian entities" and can be analyzed as such. (look at internal conflicts and the reasoning behind them)

Freudian Theory

Step 1: Approach the text with an eye for how the characters interact. Marxist

thought relies on relationships between individuals, and even those aspects of relationships that are 'social' can be part of a Marxist critique.

Step 2: Evaluate the vocational roles of all characters. The Marxist critique includes a focus on a "class system" where the vocations of characters provide the most direct reference to their place within this system. Look at the level of luxury that each individual has and how much they have to work.

Step 3: Look at how characters use their free time. Part of the Marxist critique is based on the argument that individuals can use free time productively. Examining the free choices of individuals is actually a large part of Marxist literary criticism.

Step 4: Assess the role of government in the piece of literature. Is it draconian? Laissez-faire? Marxist thought relies on government as a model for liberty and also for communalism: look at the tools that government uses. Does the government, in soliciting citizenship, appeal to the capitalist tendencies of individuals or to their innate love of community? (if the governmental role is not stated, consider what rule they would have been under. For example, the American West during this time was practically under no governmental control at all. What did this lead to? Etc.)

Marxist Theory

Step 1: Consider the roles and situations of female characters (or lack thereof).

Make lists of different aspects of the female character's place in the overall story. Include anecdotal scenarios that will back up a holistic thesis.

Step 2: Look at the relationship of female characters to each other. Examine any discrepancies that might shed light on the overall role of females in the book.

Step 3: Review the role of female characters in relation to their male counterparts. Literary criticism has its famous set of contrasts, for example, man vs. nature, nature vs. society, that set up points of inquiry. In this case, your fundamental contrast would be woman vs. man.

Step 4: Look at the vocational roles of women in the literature. Much of literary criticism can be applied to the workplace. Studying the work that each character does provides a great starting point for analyzing the whole of the work.

Step 5: Consider the attitudes of characters and how their world-views contribute to the eventual outcomes in the story. The goals of characters may or may not cause outcomes. Evaluate how "powerful" each character becomes.

Feminist Theory

understanding a story written exactly as it is presented within narrative

conventions. Examine relationship b/t form and meaning in a work Metaphor Plot Setting Characterization Symbolism Diction Irony Paradox

Formalist critics read literature as an independent piece of work or art object and so do not place any kind of importance on the author or the time it was written in.

Anything outside of the work is ignored (not examined or given attention to).

Formalist Theory

Archetypes determine the form and function of literary works, that a text's

meaning is shaped by cultural and psychological myths. recurring images, symbols, or patterns the quest or the heavenly ascent, recognizable character types such as the trickster or the hero, symbols such as the apple or snake, or images such as crucifixion

Archetypal criticism gets its impetus from psychologist Carl Jung, who postulated that humankind has a "collective unconscious," a kind of universal psyche, which is manifested in dreams and myths and which harbors themes and images that we all inherit. Literature, therefore, imitates not the world but rather the "total dream of humankind."

Archetypal images and story patterns encourage readers (and viewers of films and advertisements) to participate ritualistically in basic beliefs, fears, and anxieties of their age.

These archetypal features not only constitute the intelligibility of the text but also tap into a level of desires and anxieties of humankind.

Archetypal Theory

Write ONE question for each of the theories

that might help you to analyze The Dead Poet’s Society on a more critical level.

Example: Historical Theory The 1950s mark a time of McCarthyism and

Communist witch hunts in Congress—how does the conformity encouraged within the school reflect the terror of the time period?

Questions

Compare your questions Decide on a theory to work with based on the

2 best questions that you have as a group. Write this theory in box 2

Group Work

In box 3 write the first question that your

group picked. Together come up with a basic answer and a

least two examples from the movie that help to support your answer

Group Work

In box 4 write the second question that your

group picked. Together come up with a basic answer and a

least two examples from the movie that help to support your answer

Group Work

Does literature reflect history

Or does history reflect literature?

In box 5 answer the question with your group.. Does literature reflect history or does history

reflect literature? Explain your response.

Group work

History and Literature Literature reflects

history List which theories

support this answer Explain

History reflects literature

List which theories support this answer

Explain

The Dead Poet’s Society was…

produced in the 1990s set in the 1950s about the philosophies of the 1890s

Does the movie reflect history, or is history reflected in the movie?

Explain your response.

Considering…