limson.doc

8/10/2019 Limson.doc

1/5

THIRD DIVISION

[G.R. No. 188802. February 14, 2011.]

REVELINA LISON, !e"#"#o$er, %&. 'A() 'A() (ONDOINI* (OR+ORATION, re&!o$e$".

DE(ISION

(AR+IO ORALES, - !

O$ -a$uary 22, 1//, Re%e#$a L#&o$ 1 3Re%e#$a !ur56a&e 7ro (o$56#"a e$#"e9 a$ a!ar"e$"

u$#" 3*$#" :0; a" 'a5< 'a5< A!ar"e$"&, 'a5< 'a5< Roa, a$auyo$= (#"y.

*!o$ o%#$= #$, Re%e#$a $o"#5e e7e5"& #$ "6e ee5"r#5a a#$ !a$e o5a"e #$e "6e u$#", ra>#$=

6er "o re!or" "6e, by e""er o7 February 22, 1//, "o "6e 'a5< 'a5< (o$o#$#u (or!ora"#o$

3re&!o$e$", a $o$?&"o5< 5or!ora"#o$ or=a$#9e 7or "6e !ur!o&e o7 6o#$= "#"e "o a$ a$a=#$= "6e5oo$ area& o7 'a5< 'a5< A!ar"e$"&.

Ra5@ue Go$9ae9, >6o "& a& eber o7 re&!o$e$"& oar o7 D#re5"or&, re!#e by e""er o7

February 2;, 1// "6a" u$er Se5"#o$ ; o7 "6e Hou&e Rue& a$ Re=ua"#o$&, #" #& "6e u"y o7 "6e u$#"o>$er "o a#$"a#$ "6e ee5"r#5a a$ !ub#$= &y&"e& a" 6#&B6er eC!e$&e.

y &"# a$o"6er e""er a"e February 28, 1//, Re%e#$a #$7ore re&!o$e$" "6a" "6e &>#"56 boar #&&u56 "6a" No. 12 >#re #& !ro"e5"e by ;0 a!ere 7u&e a$ "6a" 7#%e a!!#a$5e& re7r#=era"or, 7ree9er,

#ro$, ryer a$ >a&6#$= a56#$e are 5o$$e5"e "o o$y o$e 7u&e.

Re%e#$a a"er &ou=6" !ro7e&o$a a&&"a$5e 7ro a !r#%a"e ee5"r#5a 5o$&u"a$", Roa=o,

I$5or!ora"e. I" >a& 5o$5ue "6a" "6e >#r#$=& #$ *$#" :0; are u$&a7e, 6a9arou& a$ # $o" 5o!y

>#"6 "6e +6##!!#$e Ee5"r#5a (oe.

O$ Re%e#$a& re@ue&", "6e (#"y u##$= O77#5e 5o$u5"e a$ #$&!e5"#o$ o7 *$#" :0; 7oo>#$= >6#56 a

Re!or" a"e -a$uary 21, 1//: >a& a55o!#&6e >#"6 "6e 7oo>#$= 7#$#$=& a$ re5oe$a"#o$&

F#$#$=&

1. T6e oa 5e$"er 5o$&"& o7 100 A 2 !&" a#$ &>#"56 a$ 7ube 5u" ou" o5#"6 1 5#r5u#"&.

T6e 7ube 5u" ou" bo5< e$5o&ure #& $o" !ro%#e >#"6 5o%er, eC!o$= ee5"r#5a #%e !ar" "6a" a#"56 "o 7ube 5u"?ou" bo5#re 3(a!". 0

a! !er !6a&e. T6#& #& u$ere a$ >ou o%er6ea".;. T6e 7ube 5urre$" !ro"e5"#%e e%#&e >6ere a ;0 A!., &!., 240 % FOR 2 12 T' 320 A+.

(a!a5#"y >#re "6#& oe& $o" 5o!y >#"6 "6e !ro%#o$ o7 "6e +6##!!#$e Ee5"r#5a (oe "6a" &"#!ua"e&

ra"#$= o7 "6e !ro"e5"#%e e%#&e &6a be "6e &ae a& "6e 5o$u5"or a!a5#"y e&!e5#ay o$ a u"# ou"e"

5#r5u#".4. +o>er &u!!y 7or >a"er 6ea"er& >a& "a!!e "o &a a!!#a$5e 7or 5o$%e$#e$5e ou"e" 5#r5u#".

Re5oe$a"#o$1. Re!a5ee$" o7 7ube oa 5e$"er >#"6 !a$e boar a$ 5#r5u#" breaa"er 6ea"er a.

4. +ro%#e &e!ara"e 5#r5u#" 7or >a"er 6ea"er a.

. Sub#" a& u#" Ee5"r#5a +a$ =$e a$ &eae by a +ro7e&o$a Ee5"r#5a E$=#$eer "o=e"6er


2/5

>#"6 "6e !re%#ou& a!!ro%e Ee5"r#5a +a$. 3e!6a& a$ u$er&5or#$= &u!!#e

T6e Re!or" >a& &e$" by "6e$ ayor e$a#$ Abao&, Sr. "o re&!o$e$" by e""er a"e -a$uary ;1,

1//:. O$ February ;, 1//:, re&!o$e$", "6rou=6 Ar56#"e5" Eu=e$#o Go$9ae9, >ro"e Re%e#$a "oea$ "6a" re!a#r& #$ #$e >#"6 "6e abo%e?&"a"e re5oe$a"#o$ o7 "6e (#"y u##$= O77#5e be

u$er"a#"6#$ "e$ 310 ay&.

e7ore "6e ea#$e, re&!o$e$"& oar o7 D#re5"or& 5o$%e$e o$ February :, 1//: a$ re&o%e "o

#!o&e a a#y 7#$e o7 +1,000.00 o$ Re%e#$a a$ 6er 6u&ba$ e$a#$, "o 5oe$5e o$ February 14,

1//:, &6ou "6e a""er 7a# "o 5o!y.

Re%e#$a a$ 6er 6u&ba$ re7u&e "o u$er"a#&e eC!re&&y !ro%#e #$ "6e e$ab#$= or a&"er ee or "6e e5ara"#o$ o7

re&"r#5"#o$&, "6e #$5#e$"& o7 a 5o$o#$#u =ra$" are a& 7oo>&a. . . . T6e 7oo>#$= are $o" !ar" o7 "6e u$#" bear#$= >a&, 5ou$&, 7oor&, roo7&, 7ou$a"#o$&,

a$ o"6er 5oo$ &"ru5"ura eee$"& o7 "6e bu##$=&J obb#e&, &"a#r>ay&, 6a>ay& a$ o"6er area& o7

5oo$ u&e, ee%a"or e@u#!e$" a$ &6a7"&, 5e$"ra 6ea"#$=, 5e$"ra re7r#=era"#o$ a$ 5e$"ra a#r5o$#"#o$#$= e@u#!e$", re&er%o#r, "a$#re& a$ o"6er u"##"y #$&"aa"#o$&, >6ere%er o5a"e, eC5e!" "6e ou"e"& "6ereo7

>6e$ o5a"e >#"6#$ "6e u$#". 3e!6a& a$ u$er&5or#$= &u!!#e

T6ey ar=ue "6a" a$ ee5"r#5a a#$ !a$e #& #$ "6e $a"ure o7 a u"##"y #$&"aa"#o$.

ea$>6#e, Re%e#$a a$ 6er 6u&ba$ !ur56a&e a$ o%ere >6#r!oo. I$ "6e !ro5e&& o7 #$&"aa"#o$,"6e :"6 7oor u"##"y roo >6#56 #& aa5e$" "o *$#" :0; >a& aa=e.

Re%e#$a 5a#e "6a" a$ a=reee$" 6a bee$ rea56e u$er >6#56 re&!o$e$" >ou "aou b# 6er 7or "6e 5o&" #$5urre "6ere7or bu" re&!o$e$" 7a#e "o o &o.

Ke" "6e oar o7 D#re5"or& a&&e&&e 6er a$ 6er 6u&ba$ a 7#$e o7 +1,000.00 !er ay u$"# "6e u"##"y

roo #& re!a#re.

Re&!o$e$" "6ereu!o$ 7#e a 5o!a#$" 7or &!e5#7#5 !er7ora$5e a$ aa=e& a=a#$&" Re%e#$a a$

e$a#$ be7ore "6e Se5ur#"#e& a$ EC56a$=e (o#&o$ 3SE( u!o$ "6e 7oo>#$= 5au&e& o7 a5"#o$1. To 5o!e "6e e7e$a$"& 3S!ou&e& L#&o$ "o u$er"a#r#$= o7 "6e#r *$#" :0; #$ a55ora$5e >#"6 "6e re!or" a$

re5oe$a"#o$ o7 "6e O77#5e o7 "6e u##$= O77#5#a o7 a$auyo$= (#"yJ

2. To &ee< !aye$" o7 #@u#a"e aa=e& 7ro "6e e7e$a$"& #$ a55ora$5e >#"6 "6e Re&ou"#o$o7 "6e oar o7 D#re5"or& o7 !a#$"#77 3re&!o$e$" 6ere#$, &"ar"#$= February 1, 1//: u$"# "6e

e7e$a$"& &6a 6a%e 5o!#e >#"6 "6e a7ore&"a"e re!or" a$ re5oe$a"#o$ o7 "6e bu##$=

o77#5#a&J a$;. To &ee< !aye$" o7 [] 7ro "6e e7e$a$"& 7or "6e aa=e& "6ey 6a%e 5au&e "o "6e 5oo$

area o7 'a5< 'a5< A!ar"e$"& ue "o "6e#r #$&"e$5e "o #$&"a #$ "6e#r u$#" a$ o%er?e >6#r!oo. ;

+ur&ua$" "o A.. No. 00?11?0;, 4 "6e 5o!a#$" >a& "ra$&7erre "o "6e Re=#o$a Tr#a (our" 3RT( o7

a$auyo$= (#"y 7or #&!o"#o$.


3/5

A& o7 -u$e ;0, 1//:, "6e a&&e&&e$"& a$ !e$a"#e& 56ar=e a=a#$&" "6e &!ou&e& 6a rea56e

+/,:;./4. O$ -uy 1:, 1//:, re&!o$e$" 7#e a No"#5e o7 A&&e&&e$" >#"6 "6e Re=#&"er o7 Dee&,

a$auyo$= (#"y >#"6 a!!#5a"#o$ 7or 7ore5o&ure a$ !ub#5 au5"#o$ o7 *$#" :0;.

A" "6e !ub#5 au5"#o$ 6e o$ Au=u&" 28, 1//:, re&!o$e$" eer=e a& 6#=6e&" b#er a$ "6ereu!o$

!ur56a&e *$#" :0; #$ "6e aou$" o7 +/,:;./4, o$ a55ou$" o7 >6#56 #" >a& #&&ue a (er"#7#5a"e o7

Sae o$ Se!"eber 1, 1//:.

y De5#o$ o7 De5eber 22, 200;, ra$56 214 o7 "6e a$auyo$= RT( #&&e re&!o$e$"&

5o!a#$" 7or a5< o7 er#" #$ "6#& >#&e

Guided by the findings and recommendation of the building official of Mandaluyong City, it would

appear that the questioned electrical installations are to be considered as part of the common area and

not of Unit 703, though the same are necessarily found inside the said unit. s contained in !ection ",par. # of the Condominium ct$ %a& 'he boundary of the Unit granted are the interior surfaces of the

perimeter walls, floors, ceilings, windows and doors thereof. 'he following are not part of the unit$

bearing walls, columns, floors, roofs, foundations, and other common structural elements of thebuildings( lobbies, stairways, hallways and other areas of common use, ele)ator equipment and shafts,

central heating, central refrigeration and central air conditioning equipment, reser)oir, tan*s, pumps

and other central ser)ices and facilities, pipes, ducts, flues, chutes, conduits wires and other utilityinstallations, where)er located, e+cept the outlets thereof when located within the unit. underscoring

supplied( emphasis in the original& -

O$ a!!ea, "6e (our" o7 A!!ea&, by De5#o$ o7 De5eber 1/, 2008, re%er&e "6e e5#o$ o7 "6e "r#a

5our", 6o#$= #$ "6e a#$ "6a" 7or "6e ee5"r#5a a#$ !a$e "o be 5o$ere a& !ar" o7 "6e 5oo$

area&, #" &6ou 6a%e bee$ #$"e$e 7or 5ou$a u&e a$ be$e7#". T6e &ube5" ee5"r#5a a#$ !a$e

be#$= o5a"e #$e "6e u$#" a$ #"& !r#$5#!a 7u$5"#o$ be#$= "o 5o$"ro "6e 7o> o7 ee5"r#5#"y #$"o "6eu$#", "6e a!!ea"e 5our" 5o$5ue "6a" 56ar=e& 7or #"& re!a#r 5a$$o" be 7or re&!o$e$"& a55ou$".

O$ "6e #!o"#o$ o7 7#$e o$ "6e &!ou&e& L#&o$ 7or 7a#ure "o 5orre5" "6e 7au"y ee5"r#5a >#r#$=

e&!#"e $o"#5e, "6e a!!ea"e 5our" u!6e re&!o$e$"& au"6or#"y "o e$7or5e "6e &ae. F#$#$=, 6o>e%er,"6a" "6e aou$" o7 +1,000 7#$e !er ay >a& eC5e&%e, #" reu5e "6e &ae "o +200.

Re&!e5"#$= re&!o$e$"& #!o"#o$ o7 a 7#$e o7 +1,000 !er ay o$ "6e &!ou&e& ae=e 7a#ure "o re!a#r

"6e :"6 7oor u"##"y roo, "6e a!!ea"e 5our" #&ao>e "6e &ae, 6o>e%er, #" 6o#$= "6a" re&!o$e$"# $o" 7#r&" &ee< re#bur&ee$" 7ro "6e be7ore a&&e&&e$".

F#$ay, "6e a!!ea"e 5our" e$#e re&!o$e$"& !rayer 7or a5"ua aa=e& #$ "6e aou$" o7 +,000re!re&e$"#$= re!a#r eC!e$&e& o$ "6e u"##"y roo, #" 6a%#$= 7a#e "o !re&e$" re5e#!"& "6ere7or.

Her o"#o$ 7or Re5o$era"#o$ 6a%#$= bee$ e$#e, Re%e#$a 7#e "6e !re&e$" !e"#"#o$ 7or re%#e>.

T6e (our" 7#$& 7or Re%e#$a.

T6e !er"#$e$" !ro%#o$& o7 "6e 'a5< 'a5< A!ar"e$"& a&"er Dee 7oo>

Se5"#o$ . T6e (oo$ Area&. T6e 5oo$ eee$"& or area& o7 "6e +roe5" 36ere#$ re7erre "o

a& "6e (oo$ Area& &6a 5o!r#&e a !ar"& o7 "6e +roe5" o"6er "6a$ "6e *$#"&, #$5u#$= >#"6ou"

##"a"#o$ "6e 7oo>#$=CCC CCC CCC

3e A 5e$"ra a$ a!!ur"e$a$" e@u#!e$" a$ #$&"aa"#o$& 7or 5oo$ 7a5##"#e& a$ u"##"#e& &u56

a& !o>er, #=6", &e>era=e, ra#$a=e, =arba=e 56u"e, a$ >a"er 5o$$e5"#o$& 3#$5u#$= a ou"e"&, !#!e&,


4/5

u5"&, >#re&, 5abe& a$ 5o$u#"& u&e #$ 5o$$e5"#o$ "6ere>#"6, >6e"6er o5a"e #$ (oo$ Area& or #$

*$#"&J a ee%a"or&, ee%a"or &6a7"&, "a$6#56 are 7or5oo$ u&e or $e5e&&ary or 5o$%e$#e$" 7or "6e eC#&"e$5e, a#$"e$a$5e o7 &a7e"y o7 "6e +roe5".

3e!6a& a$ u$er&5or#$= &u!!#e

Se5"#o$ ;. a#$"e$a$5e, Re!a#r& a$ A"era"#o$&. 3a A a#$"e$a$5e o7 a$ re!a#r& o7 a$y *$#"3o"6er "6a$ "6e a#$"e$a$5e o7 a$ re!a#r& "o a$y o7 "6e (oo$ Area& 5o$"a#$e "6ere#$ $o"

$e5e&"a"e by "6e a5" or $e=#=e$5e o7 "6e o>$er, "e$a$" or o55u!a$" o7 &u56 *$#" &6a be ae [by],

a$ a" "6e eC!e$&e o7, "6e o>$er o7 &u56 u$#". Ea56 *$#" o>$er &6a be re&!o$be 7or a aa=e& "oa$y o"6er *$#" a$ "o "6e (oo$ Area& re&u"#$= 7ro 6#& 7a#ure "o e77e5" &u56 a#$"e$a$5e a$

re!a#r&. Ea56 *$#" o>$er &6a a&o be re&!o$be 7or !ro!"y re!or"#$= "o "6e (o$o#$#u

(or!ora"#o$ a$y e7e5" or $ee 7or re!a#r& #$ a$y o7 "6e (oo$ Area& #$ 6#& *$#". 3e!6a& a$u$er&5or#$= &u!!#e

CCC CCC CCC

Se5"#o$ ; 3e o7 R.A. 4:2 e7#$e& 5oo$ area& a& "6e e$"#re !roe5" eC5e!" a u$#"& &e!ara"ey

=ra$"e or 6e or re&er%e. Se5"#o$ 3a o7 "6e &ae a> !ro%#e&a. . . . T6e 7oo>#$= are $o" !ar" o7 "6e u$#" bear#$= >a&, 5ou$&, 7oor&, roo7&, 7ou$a"#o$&,

a$ o"6er 5oo$ &"ru5"ura eee$"& o7 "6e bu##$=&J obb#e&, &"a#r>ay&, 6a>ay& a$ o"6er area& o7

5oo$ u&e, ee%a"or e@u#!e$" a$ &6a7"&, 5e$"ra 6ea"#$=, 5e$"ra re7r#=era"#o$ a$ 5e$"ra a#r5o$#"#o$#$= e@u#!e$", re&er%o#r, "a$#re& a$ o"6er u"##"y #$&"aa"#o$&, >6ere%er o5a"e, eC5e!" "6e ou"e"& "6ereo7

>6e$ o5a"e >#"6#$ "6e u$#". 3e!6a& a$ u$er&5or#$= &u!!#eT6e ee5"r#5a !a$e& o5a"#o$ #$e "6e u$#" $o">#"6&"a$#$=, #" #& $o" au"oa"#5ay 5o$ere a& !ar"

o7 #". T6e abo%e?@uo"e !er"#$e$" !ro%#o$& o7 "6e a> a$ "6e a&"er ee 5o$"e!a"e "6a" 5oo$

area&, e.=., u"##"y #$&"aa"#o$&, ay be "ua"e >#"6#$ "6e u$#".

'6ere a &"a"u"e #& 5ear, !a#$ a$ 7ree 7ro ab#=u#"y, #" u&" be =#%e$ #"& #"era ea$#$= a$ a!!#e>#"6ou" a""e!" "o #$"er!re". : Verba e=#& $o$ e&" re5ee$u, #$eC a$## &ero e&". T6ere &6ou be

$o e!ar"ure 7ro "6e >or& o7 "6e &"a"u"e, 7or &!ee56 #& "6e #$eC o7 #$"e$"#o$.

A$ eC!a$a"#o$ o7 "6e A!ar"e$"& ee5"r#5a &u!!y &y&"e >a& !re&e$"e by re&!o$e$", %#9.a. . . . [T]6e ee5"r#5a &y&"e o7 "6e A!ar"e$"& 5oe$5e& >#"6 a 5oo$ a#$ ee5"r#5a #$e

3a#$ #$e !ro%#e by "6e A!ar"e$"&, 5o$$e5"e "o a era5o #$e ou"e "6e bu##$=. T6#&

5oo$ a#$ #$e ru$& "o "6e =rou$ 7oor o7 "6e bu##$=, >6ere "6e 5oo$ e"er &"a"#o$ #& o5a"eJ7ro >6ere #$#%#ua &e5o$ary #$e&, are "a!!e "o "6e 5oo$ a#$ #$e. T6ere are a& a$y

#$#%#ua &e5o$ary #$e& "a!!e "o "6e 5oo$ a#$ #$e, a& "6ere are u$#"&. EVERK SE(ONDARK

LINE TRAVELS VERTI(ALLK TO ITS DESIGNATED FLOOR AND LEADS TO ANINDIVID*AL *NIT.

b. T6e 5o$&"ru5"#o$ #& &u56, "6a" e%ery &e5o$ary #$e #& ebee >#"6#$ "6e >a o7 a u$#", u$"# #"

&ur7a5e& 7ro "6e >a, reay "o &u!!y ee5"r#5#"y "o "6a" u$#"J "6e *NIT, #$ "6#& 5a&e, 6a& ">o 32 e"a

boCe&, #$e "6e *NITJ bo"6 a""a56e "o "6e >a o7 "6e *NIT. T6e 7#r&" o7 "6e ">o 32 e"a boCe& #&"6e a#$ &>#"56 boC. 3A$$eCe& a$ ?1. T6e a#$ &>#"56 boC 6a& a 6oe, "6rou=6 >6#56 "6e

&e5o$ary #$e e$"er& a$ #& a""a56e "o "6e u!!er e$ o7 ">o 32 b#= 7u&e&, o5a"e #$ "6e a#$ &>#"56

boC 3A$$eC ?1?a. T6e u!!er e$ o7 "6e ">o 32 b#= 7u&e&, >6ere "6e &e5o$ary #$e 3"a!!e "o "6ea#$ #$e e$& are #$#5a"e a$ arer e$ o7 "6e&e ">o 32 b#= 7u&e&, "6ere are &e!ara"e ee5"r#5a >#re& 3"e56$#5ay 5ae

u!er 5abe&. T6e u!er 5abe& or#=#$a"e #$ "6e *NIT& &e5o$ e"a boC >6#56 #& "6e 7ube5u"ou" boC 37u&e boC, a$ "6e u!er 5abe& are 5o$$e5"e "o "6e o>er e$ o7 "6e ">o 32 b#= 7u&e& #$

"6e a#$ &>#"56 boC "o ra> ee5"r#5#"y "o 7ee "6e 7u&e boC. . . . 8 35a!#"a#9a"#o$ a$ u$er&5or#$= #$

"6e or#=#$a


5/5

I$ a u"#?o55u!a$5y >e#$= &u56 a& A!ar"e$"&, ##"a"#o$& are #!o&e u$er R.A. 4:2 / #$

a55ora$5e >#"6 "6e 5oo$ #$"ere&" a$ &a7e"y o7 "6e o55u!a$"& "6ere#$ >6#56 a" "#e& ay 5ur"a# "6e

eCer5#&e o7 o>$er&6#!. To a#$"a#$ &a7e, 6aro$#ou& a$ &e5ure #%#$= 5o$#"#o$&, 5er"a#$ &"#!ua"#o$&

are ebo#e #$ "6e uy re=#&"ere ee o7 re&"r#5"#o$&, #$ "6#& 5a&e "6e a&"er Dee, a$ #$ 6ou&erue& >6#56 "6e 5o$o#$#u 5or!ora"#o$, ##"6 o"6er u$#" o>$er&. 10*$@ue&"#o$aby, "6e 7u&e boC 5o$"ro& "6e &u!!y o7 ee5"r#5#"y #$"o "6e u$#". +o>er #& &our5e "6rou=6

u!er 5abe& a""a56e "o "6e a#$ &>#"56 >6#56 5o$$e5"& "6e u$#"& ee5"r#5a #$e "o "6e A!ar"e$"&

5oo$ ee5"r#5a #$e. I" #& a$ #$"e=ra 5o!o$e$" o7 a !o>er u"##"y #$&"aa"#o$. Re&!o$e$" 5a$$o"#&5a# re&!o$b##"y 7or "6e a#$"e$a$5e o7 "6e A!ar"e$"& ee5"r#5a &u!!y &y&"e &oey be5au&e a

5o!o$e$" "6ereo7 #& !a5e #$e a u$#".

A& ear#er &"a"e, bo"6 "6e a> a$ "6e a&"er Dee re7er "o u"##"y #$&"aa"#o$& a& 7or#$= !ar" o7 "6e5oo$ area&, >6#56 re7ere$5e #& u&"#7#e by !ra5"#5a 5o$era"#o$&. Re!a#r& "o 5orre5" a$y e7e5"& #$

"6e ee5"r#5a >#r#$= &6ou be u$er "6e 5o$"ro a$ &u!er%#o$ o7 re&!o$e$" "o e$&ure &a7e"y a$

5o!#a$5e >#"6 "6e +6##!!#$e Ee5"r#5a (oe, 11 $o" "o e$"#o$ &e5ur#"y a$ !ea5e o7 #$ o7 "6e

u$#" o>$er&.'HEREFORE, "6e !e"#"#o$ #& GRANTED. T6e (our" o7 A!!ea& De5#o$ o7 De5eber 1/, 2008 #&

REVERSED a$ SET ASIDE. T6e De5#o$ o7 ra$56 214 o7 "6e a$auyo$= Re=#o$a Tr#a (our"

#&$= "6e 5o!a#$" o7 'a5< 'a5< (o$o#$#u (or!ora"#o$ a=a#$&" Re%e#$a a$ e$a#$L#&o$ #&, #$ #=6" o7 "6e 7ore=o#$= #&5u&o$&, REINSTATED.

SO ORDERED.

r#o$, +era"a, V#araa, -r. a$ e$o9a, --., 5o$5ur.Foo"$o"e&

A#"#o$a eber !er S!e5#a Orer No. /44 a"e February /, 2011 %#5e A&&o5#a"e -u&"#5e

a. Loure& +.A. Sere$o.

A#"#o$a eber %#5e A&&o5#a"e -u&"#5e Lu5a& +. er&a#$ >6o "oo< $o !ar" ue "o !r#ora5"#o$ #$ a rea"e (our" o7 A!!ea& 5a&e, !er Ra77e a"e -u$e 2, 2010.

1. T6e (o$o#$#u (er"#7#5a"e o7 T#"e #& re=#&"ere u$er "6e $ae o7 Re%e#$a R. L#&o$, o7

e=a a=e, F##!#$o, arr#e "o e$a#$ L#&o$, F##!#$o. 2. O"6er>#&e $ a& T6e (o$o#$#u A5".

;. (A roo, !. :2.

4. O"6er>#&e $ a& "6e I$"er# Rue& o7 +ro5eure 7or I$"ra?(or!ora"e (o$"ro%ere&. . (A roo, !. ::.

. +e$$e by "6e a"e A&&o5#a"e -u&"#5e E=aro F. Su$#a, >#"6 "6e 5o$5urre$5e o7 A&&o5#a"e

-u&"#5e& +a!#o A. Abar#$"o& a$ Rao$ . a"o, -r., (A roo, !!. 12?1:/. :. S#=$ey %. So5#a Se5ur#"y Sy&"e, G.R. No. 1:;82, -a$uary 28, 2008, 42 S(RA 2/.

8. (A roo, A!!ea$"& r#e7, !!. ;;?;4.

/. V#e Se5"#o$ / a$ Se5"#o$ 18.

10. T>#$ To>er& (o$o#$#u (or!ora"#o$ %. (our" o7 A!!ea&, G.R. No. 12;2, February 2:,200;, ;/8 S(RA 20;.

11. Se5"#o$ 1;01 o7 "6e Na"#o$a u##$= (oe !ro%#e& A ee5"r#5a &y&"e&, e@u#!e$" a$

#$&"aa"#o$ e$"#o$e #$ "6#& (oe &6a 5o$7or "o "6e !ro%#o$& o7 "6e +6##!!#$e Ee5"r#5a (oe, a&ao!"e by "6e oar o7 Ee5"r#5a E$=#$eer#$= !ur&ua$" "o Re!ub#5 A5" No. 184 a& ae$e by

Re!ub#5 A5" No. :/20 o"6er>#&e $ a& "6e Ne> Ee5"r#5a E$=#$eer#$= La>.

limson.doc

Documents