liberi v taitz plaintiffs opposition to intelius' motion summary judgement doc 459-1
TRANSCRIPT
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 1/35
m
RHLAE IJ KIGREGR[
Thne({-
RHLAE IJ KIGREGR[…………………………………………………'……''m/mm
RHLAE IJ HUR@I\MRME[…………………………………………………'''mmm/zm
H\NUOEGR………………………'''………………………………………''''=/<5
M' MGR\IBUKRMIG……………''''…………………………………'''…''''8/<
MM' [RHREOEGR IJ JHKR[………………………………………………''</=
MMM' [RHGBH\B IJ \EZME^……………………………………………''''''''=
MZ' MGREAMU[ M[ GIR MOOUGE UGBE\ [EKRMIG <;4
IJ R@E KIOOUGMKHRMIG[ BEKEGK] HKR!2> U'['K'®<;4……………………………………………………………=/8=
Z' MGREAMU[ M[ H KIG[UOE\ \ETI\RMGN
HNEGK] NIZE\GEB L] R@E JK\H L]
H' Mgreamu{ Zmiahreb r`e JK\H! KK\HH! hgb
MK\HH l} {eaamgn Tahmgrmjj{ Kig{uoe| \eti|r{
L' Tahmgrmjj{ Girmjmeb Mgreamu{! ~`i m{ r`e K|ebmr\eti|rmgn Hnegk}! ij r`e ^|ign Mgji|ohrmig
K' Tahmgrmjj{ \exue{r{ ji| r`em| \eti|r{
B' Mgreamu{ h{{e|rmig{ hliur r̀ em| ‑Re|o{ hgb
R@EM\ I^G HBOM[[MIG[…………………………………………'''8=/<5
ri Ughur`i|mveb mgbmzmbuha{……………………………………''''<4/<<
Kigrhmgeb mg Tahmgrmjj{ Jmae{……………………………………'''<</<2
hgb Jmae{…………………………………………………………''…'<2
Kigbmrmig{‟ Jhma…………………………………………………''<2/<5
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25=/8 Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne 8 ij : Thne MB+68452<
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 2/35
mm
RHLAE IJ KIGREGR[ / KIGRMGUEB
Thne({-
MZ' KIGKAU[MIG……………………………………………………'…'''''''<5
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25=/8 Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne < ij : Thne MB+68452;
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 3/35
mmm
RHLAE IJ HUR@I\MRME[
KH[E[ Thne({-
Lh|ge{ z' ]h`ii(! Mgk'! 5>4 J';b 84=: (=r` Km|'<44=-………………………''8<! 8;
Lhrvea z' [omr`! ;;; J';b 8480 (=r` Km|' <44;-…………………………………'''8>
Leg Ev|h! ^emg{remg! * Ki'! Mgk' z' Ho' Igamge Mgk'!
<4: J';b =04 (84r` Km|' <444-……………………………………………………'8>
Kh|hjhgi z' Oer|i{tah{`'Kio' Mgk'!
;;= J';b 888= (=r`
Km|' <44;-…………………………………………88! 8<! 85! 8=
Km{ge|i{ z' U'B' \enm{r|}! Mgk'! ;= Kha' Htt' 2r`
520!2: Kha' \tr|' <b <;; (Kr' Htt' 8==5-……………………………………………''<2
BeHgb|hbe z' R|hg{ Ugmig AAK ! 5<; J';b :8! :> (8{r Km|' <440-………………''<2
Beggm{ z' LE@/M! AAK ! 5<4 J';b 84:: (=r` Km|' <440-…………………………'''<2
Jhm| @iu{mgn Kiugkma ij [hg Je|ghgbi Zhaae} z' \iioohre{! Kio! AAK 5<8 J';b 885> (=r` Km|'<440-……………………………'''…'88! 8<! 8;! 8:! 8>! 80
JMH Kh|b [e|z{'! G'H' z' Ni|ohg! 8;8 [' Kr' >8! 8>0 A' Eb' <b <; (<484-………<;
r`
JRK z' Tula.n Kaeh|mgn @iu{e! Mgk'! 842 J';b 88:0 (=r` Km|' 8==>-…………'…''=
Nibbh|b z' Niinae! Gi' K 40/<>;0 FJ (TZR-!
Numoigb z' R|hg{ Ugmig K|ebmr Mgji' Ki'!
25 J';b 8;<= (=r` Km|' 8==5-…………'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''<<
Kiook”g{ [}{'! Mgk' z' A}ki{! Mgk'! 2>0 J';b 28; (8{r Km|' <44>-………………'''8>
JRK z' Hkku{eh|k`! 5>4 J';b 880> (84 Km|' <44=-………………………'''82! 8:
<440 ^A 5<252=4 (G'B' Kha' Bek' 8>! <440-……………………''''''8<! 8;! 85! 80
Ni|ohg z' ^iatijj * Hl|ho{ig! 502 J';b 882> (=r` Km|' <44=-……………<;! <2
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25=/8 Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne ; ij : Thne MB+684522
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 4/35
mz
RHLAE IJ HUR@I\MRME[ / Kigrmgueb
KH[E[ Thne({-
Gea{ig z' K`h{e Ohg`hrrhg Oi|rnhne Ki|t'!
\egi z' Hoe|mkhg Kmzma Amle|rme{ Ugmig(8==>- 5<8 U'[' 022! 88> ['Kr' <;<=! 8;0 A'Eb'<b 0>2………………………8<! 8=
R\^ Mgk' z' Hgb|e~{! 5;2 U'[' 8=!
8<< [' Kr' 228! 858 A' Eb' <b ;;= (<448-…………………………………''…<8! <<
^`mre z' R|hg{ Ugmig! 2:< J' [utt' <b 84>= (K'B' Kha' <44:-………………'<;! <2
Ve|hg z' Ho' Igamge! Mgk'! 8<= J';b ;<> (2r` Km|' 8==>-…………………………8>
JEBE\HA [RHRURE[ Thne({-
5 U'['K' ® 55<……………………………………………………………'''………5
85 U'['K' ® 8:08h(b-……………………………………………………'''84! <4! <5
85 U'['K' ®8:08e(l-………………………………………………8<! <4! <8! <<! <2
85 U'['K' ®8:08n………………………………………………………………''''<<
<0< J';b 845> (=r` Km|' <44<-………………………………………………''''<;! <2
Gugev z' Bugkhg! 5=8 J' ;b 8<8> (=r` Km|' <484-…………………………………'=
85 U'['K' ® 8:08h(b-(8-……………………………………………………'''……'2
85 U'['K' ® 8:08h(j-………………………………………………………''8! <4! <5
85 U'['K' ® 8:08l……………………………………………………''''''''8<! <4! <8
85 U'['K' ®8:08k………………………………………………………………'…<<
85 U'['K' ® 8:08e(h-…………………………………………………………''8<! <8
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25=/8 Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne 2 ij : Thne MB+684525
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 5/35
z
RHLAE IJ HUR@I\MRME[ / Kigrmgueb
KH[E[ Thne({-
JEBE\HA [RHRURE[ Thne({-
85 U'['K' ®8:08n(h-(8-…………………………………………………………'' <2
85 U'['K' ®8:08m……………………………………………………………'''<<! <2
85 U'['K' ®8:08f…………………………………………………………………'<2
85 U'['K' ®8:08g……………………………………………………………''<8! <<
85 U'['K' ®8:08i………………………………………………………………''''<<
85 U'['K' ®8:08{/<l………………………………………………………………<;
2> U'['K'H' ® <;4(j-(;-………………………………………………………'88! 8:
KHAMJI\GMH [RHRURE[ Thne({-
Kha' Kmz' Kibe ®8>05'8………………………………………………………'84! <2
Kha' Kmz' Kibe ®8>05';(k-………………………………………………………''84
Kha' Kmz' Kibe ®8>05'88……………………………………………………'''<4! <8
® 8:08{/<(l-(8-(B-………………………………………………………………'''<2
2> U'['K' ® <<<………………………………………………………………''''5! 82
2> U'['K' ® <;4………………………………………………''<! ;! =! 8<! 82! 8>! <5
2> U'['K' ® <;4(k-(8-……………………………………………………………'''8<
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25=/8 Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne 5 ij : Thne MB+68452:
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 6/35
zm
RHLAE IJ HUR@I\MRME[ / Kigrmgueb
KHAMJI\GMH [RHRURE[ Thne({-
Kha' Kmz' Kibe ®8>05'82……………………………………………………'''<4! <8
Kha' Kmz' Kibe ®8>05'82(l-………………………………………………………<2
Kha' Kmz' Kibe ®8>=0';……………………………………………………………'5
JEBE\HA \UAE[ IJ KMZMA T\IKEBU\E Thne({-
Kha' Kmz' Kibe ®8>05'8=……………………………………………………''''<4! <8
Kha' Kmz' Kibe ®8>05'<<……………………………………………………''''<4! <<
Kha' Kmz' Kibe ®8>05'<5(h-………………………………………………………'<2
Kha' Kmz' Kibe ®8>0:'<(k-………………………………………………………'''84
Kha' Kmz' Kibe ®8>0:'8<……………………………………………………''''<4! <8
Kha' Kmz' Kibe ®8>0:'<4……………………………………………………''''<4! <8
Jeb' \' Kmz' T' 5:(k-……………………………………………………………'''=
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25=/8 Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne : ij : Thne MB+68452>
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 7/35
Amle|m! er ha! Tahmgrmjj{ Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bej' Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr 8
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
T`mamt F' Le|n! E{xum|e (TH M'B' =0:>-
E/ohma6 t`mafle|nDnohma'kio
AH^ IJJMKE[ IJ T@MAMT F' LE\N
555 Hgbi||h Naeg Kiu|r! [umre 8<
Ahjh}erre @maa! TH 8=222/<5;8
Reaet`ige6 (:84- 0<5/;8;2 Jhp6 (:84- 0;2/>:5=
Hrri|ge} ji| Tahmgrmjj{
UGMREB [RHRE[ BM[R\MKR KIU\R
JI\ R@E KEGR\HA BM[R\MKR IJ KHAMJI\GMH!
[IUR@E\G BMZM[MIG
AM[H AMLE\M! er ha!
Tahmgrmjj{!
z{'
I\A] RHMRV! er ha!
Bejegbhgr{'
666666666666666
6
KMZMA HKRMIG GUOLE\6
0688/kz/44205/HN (HF^-
TAHMGRMJJ[ OEOI\HGBUO
L\MEJ MG ITTI[MRMIG RI
BEJEGBHGR MGREAMU[! MGK'”[
OIRMIG JI\ [UOOH\]
FUBNOEGR
Bhre ij @eh|mgn6 Oh|k` 8<! <48<Rmoe ij @eh|mgn6 84644 h'o'
Aikhrmig6 Kiu|r|iio 84B
M' MGR\IBUKRMIG6
Tahmgrmjj{ Am{h Amle|m S‑Amle|m‟_! Am{h I{reaah S‑I{reaah‟_! Ni Epkea Nailha
S‑NEN‟_! T`mamt F' Le|n! E{xum|e S‑Le|n‟_ hgb r`e Ah~ Ijjmke{ ij T`mamt F' Le|n
S‑AITFL‟_ l} hgb r`|iun` r`em| ugbe|{mngeb Kiug{ea `e|el} {ulomr r`em|
Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bejegbhgr! Mgreamu{! Mgk' S‑Mgreamu{‟_ Oirmig ji|
[uooh|} Fubnoegr' R`e n|iugb{ ji| |eamej kmreb l} Mgreamu{ jhma h{ h ohrre| ij ah~
Lekhu{e Mgreamu{ m{ h Kig{uoe| \eti|rmgn hgb h ‑Ke|rmjmeb K|ebmr \eti|rmgn Hnegk}
nize|geb l} r`e Jhm| K|ebmr \eti|rmgn Hkr S‑JK\H‟_! l} r`em| i~g hbom{{mig{3 hgb
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25= Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne 8 ij <5 Thne MB+68458>
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 8/35
Amle|m! er ha! Tahmgrmjj{ Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bej' Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr <
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
Mgreamu{ m{ gemr`e| h ‑tulam{`e|‟ gi| ‑r|ehreb‟ h{ h tulam{`e| l} r`e Tahmgrmjj{ khu{e{ ij
hkrmig! [ekrmig <;4 ij r`e Kioougmkhrmig{ Bekegk} Hkr S‑KBH6‟_! 2> U'['K' ® <;4
bie{ gir htta} ri mr{ t|hkrmke{' R`u{ Bejegbhgr{ h|e gir moouge j|io amhlmamr} ji|
zmiahrmgn r̀ e JK\H' Mgreamu{ {rmaa ri r m̀{ bhre m{ {eaamgn Tahmgrmjj{ t|mzhre bhrh' R`e|e
h|e {ujjmkmegr jhkr{ mg bm{ture r`hr [uooh|} Fubnoegr ig emr`e| n|iugb m{
mghtt|it|mhre'
Mgreamu{” Oeoi|hgbuo! BG 255/8! m{ r~egr}/jmze S<5_ thne{ mg 8< timgr jigr!
mg{rehb ij r`e |exum|eb 82 timgr jigr! haai~mgn r`eo jh| oi|e thne{ ij h|nuoegr mg
zmiahrmig ij Aikha \uae S‑ A'\'‟_ 88/;'8'8' Mgreamu{” jhmau|e ri kiota} ~mr` r`m{ Kiu|r”{
|uae {ulfekr{ r`eo ri [hgkrmig{' [ee Aikha \uae 88/= hgb 0;/>'
MM' [RHREOEGR IJ JHKR[6
Ig [etreole| 8:! <488! Mgreamu{ l|iun`r h Oirmig ri Bm{om{{ S‑ORB‟_
Bikcer Gi' S‑BG‟_ 255' Mg {utti|r ij Mgreamu{” ORB! ~h{ r`e Bekah|hrmig ij
Legfhomg Gea{ig! Mgreamu{” Ku{ribmhg ij \eki|b{' O|' Gea{ig mgkaubeb bikuoegr{ mg
`m{ Bekah|hrmig! kahmomgn r`eo ri le ‑h r|ue hgb ki||ekr kit} ij ~`hr Amle|m hgb
Bejegbhgr I|a} Rhmrv S‑Rhmrv‟_ tu|k`h{eb! SBJ! ºM! tt' ;/0! Gi' <8! tt' 25/2: hgb t
:0_! ~`mk` ~h{ moti{{mlae h{ Mgreamu{ bie{ gir ohmgrhmg |eti|r{ {iab ri r`em|
ku{rioe|{! BJ! Gi' 82! tt' ;;/;5_' R`e Kiu|r bmb gir kig{mbe| Mgreamu{ ORB! lur bmb
n|hgr Mgreamu{” Fimgbe| ~mr` r̀ e \eeb Bejegbhgr{ ORB' R`e Kiu|r bm{om{{eb eaezeg
(88- ij Tahmgrmjj{ kahmo{ hnhmg{r Mgreamu{! {rhrmgn r`e} ~e|e t|eeotreb l} r`e JK\H'
R`e Kiu|r begmeb r`e ORB h{ ri Kiugr{ R~eaze r`|iun` [mpreeg! ~`mk` h|e kiugr{
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25= Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne < ij <5 Thne MB+684580
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 9/35
Amle|m! er ha! Tahmgrmjj{ Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bej' Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr ;
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
hnhmg{r Mgreamu{ ji| JK\H zmiahrmig{' R`m{ Kiu|r khurmigeb r`e Mgreamu{ hgb \eeb
Bejegbhgr{ mg l|mgnmgn ji|r` h Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr' R`e Kiu|r ha{i
Begmeb Mgreamu{” \exue{r ri [rh} Bm{kize|} tegbmgn r`e jmamgn ij r`em| Oirmig ji|
[uooh|} Fubnoegr' Tahmgrmjj{ {e|zeb Mgre||inhri|me{! \exue{r ji| Hbom{{mig{ hgb
\exue{r ji| T|ibukrmig ij Bikuoegr{ ig Mgreamu{ Fhguh|} 8:! <48<' Tahmgrmjj{ `hze
gir |ekemzeb Mgreamu{” Bm{kize|} \e{tig{e{ h{ ij r̀ m{ bhre' SBJ! t' <_'
R`e egrm|e holmr ij Mgreamu{” lh{m{ ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr m{ r`em| jha{e
h{{e|rmig{ r`hr r`e |eti|r{ r`e} {iab ig r`e Tahmgrmjj{ h|e gir ‑kig{uoe| i| k|ebmr
|eti|r{‟3 r`hr r`e} h|e gir h k|ebmr |eti|rmgn hnegk}! har`iun` r`e} hbomr mr mg r`em|
[EK jmamgn{ hgb ig r`em| ~el{mre3 r`hr r`e} h|e gir nize|geb l} r`e JK\H! hgb gir
|exum|eb ri jiaai~ r`e JK\H3 hgb `hze moougmr} ugbe| [ekrmig <;4 ij r`e KBH
Gige ij ~`mk` htta} hgb Mgreamu{ `h{ jhmaeb ri {utti|r r`em| Oirmig ji| [uooh|}
Fubnoegr S‑O[F‟_ ~mr` hg} kioteregr ezmbegke i| l} t|ite| kmrhrmig{ ri r`e \eki|b
Tahmgrmjj{ mgki|ti|hre l} |eje|egke{ haa h|nuoegr{ hgb ezmbegke t|e{egreb mg r`em|
Kigkm{e [rhreoegr{ ij Bm{tureb Ohre|mha Jhkr{ S‑BJ‟_ h{ mj juaa} taeb `e|e hr aegnr`'
Mg Oh|k` <44= r`|iun` Ht|ma <484! Mgreamu{ ite|hreb haa ij r`em| {e|zmke{
r`|iun` ~~~'mgreamu{'kio! ~`mk` m{ Mgreamu{! Mgk' SBJ! Gi' <! tt' 84/8<! Gi' 2! tt
8;/82! Gi' <<! tt' 2:/2>! Gi' <2! tt' 2=/58_' Rhaegr^m{e ~h{ gir mgr|ibukeb ugrma
Jel|uh|} =! <484 hgb gir motaeoegreb l} Mgreamu{ ugrma Ht|ma <484' Mgreamu{
Rhaegr^m{e ~h{ gir mg ite|hrmig! i| motaeoegreb hr r`e rmoe r`e Rhmrv hgb [hgce}
Bejegbhgr{ ilrhmgeb Tahmgrmjj{ lhkcn|iugb kig{uoe| |eti|r{! ~`mk` ~h{ mg i| hliur
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25= Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne ; ij <5 Thne MB+68458=
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 10/35
Amle|m! er ha! Tahmgrmjj{ Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bej' Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr 2
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
eh|a} Oh|k` <44=' [ee Tahmgrmjj{ SBJ! Gi' <! tt' 84/8<! Gi' 2! tt' 8;/82! Gi' <<! tt
2:/2>! Gi' <2! tt' 2=/58_ hgb Tahmgrmjj{ \exue{r ji| Fubmkmha Girmke S‑\FG‟_! Epl
‑<‟! tt' 2;/2>'
R`e |eti|r{ {iab l} Mgreamu{ r`|iun` r`em| ~el{mre h|e ‐te|{ig {tekmjmk” |eti|r{
r`hr mgkaube r`e mgbmzmbuha{ ghoe! juaa lm|r` bhre! `ioe zhaue! hze|hne `iu{e mgkioe!
{tiu{e mgji|ohrmig! |eahrmze{! hamh{”! mgkaubmgn ohmbeg ghoe{! hbb|e{{e{! reaet`ige
guole|{ (mgkaubmgn ugam{reb hgb ugtulam{`eb-! oh||mhne |eki|b{! k|momgha |eki|b{
fubnoegr{! erk' Haa ij r̀ e ji|enimgn ~`mk` kig{rmrure ‑kig{uoe| |eti|r{‟ h{ bejmgeb
l} r`e JK\H! 85 U'['K' ®8:08h(b-(8-! SBJ! Gi' 0! tt' <4/<<! Gi' 88! tt' <0/;4! Gi
8:! tt' ;>/;=! Gi' <4! tt' 2;/25! Gi' <2! tt' 2=/58! Gi' ;8! tt' ::/:0_'
Mgreamu{ tu|k`h{e{ mgji|ohrmig j|io r`m|b th|rme{! nize|goegr hnegkme{ hgb
kiooe|kmha egrmrme{! ~`mk` mgkaube kigjmbegrmha mgji|ohrmig! m'e' urmamr} lmaa{! t`ige
|eki|b{! k|ebmr |eti|r{! erk' Mgreamu{ k|ehre{ |eti|r{ j|io r̀ e bhrh r`e} |ekemze hgb {eaa{
r`eo ize| r`e Mgre|ger ri r`em| ku{rioe|{” ji| h jee! mgkaubmgn mg mgre|{rhre kiooe|ke'
R`e JK\H ~h{ eghkreb ri t|irekr kig{uoe|{ j|io r`e{e r}te{ ij zmiahrmig{' Mgreamu{
m{ r`e bezeaite| ij r`e kigregr nmzmgn |m{e ri r`m{ {umr hgb ji| r`e `h|o mr khu{eb
Mgreamu{ m{ ‑|e{tig{mlae! mg ~`iae i| mg th|r! ji| r`e k|ehrmig i| bezeaitoegr ij
mgji|ohrmig'‟ Mgreamu{ m{ hgb ~h{ |e{tig{mlae ji| r`e bezeaitoegr ij r̀ hr kigreg
(Tahmgrmjj{ kig{uoe| hgb k|ebmr |eti|r{- / ji| r`e kigze|{mig ij r̀ e aenhaa} t|irekreb
|eki|b{ j|io kigjmbegrmha ohre|mha ri tulamka} epti{eb mgji|ohrmig! l} {eaamgn
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25= Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne 2 ij <5 Thne MB+6845<4
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 11/35
Amle|m! er ha! Tahmgrmjj{ Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bej' Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr 5
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
Tahmgrmjj{ kig{uoe|)k|ebmr |eti|r{ ri ughur`i|mveb r`m|b th|rme{' [ee SBJ Gi' >! tt' 8>/
<4! Gi' 84! tt' <2/<0! Gi' <>! tt' 55/:8! Gi' ;4! tt' :2/::! Gi' ;8! tt' ::/:0_'
Mgreamu{ kahmo{ r`e} ilrhmg tulamk |eki|b{ j|io nize|goegrha hnegkme{
Jebe|ha! {rhre i| aikha nize|goegr |eki|b{ khggir kigrhmg mgji|ohrmig r`hr mbegrmjme{
r`e mgji|ohrmig ri h ‐{tekmjmk te|{ig”' [ee Kha' Kmz' Kibe ®8>=0';! Jebe|h
Nize|goegr m{ nize|geb l} r`e T|mzhk} Hkr ij 8=>2! 5 U'['K' ®55<' Reaet`ige
kiggekr hgb bm{kiggekr |eki|b{ h|e ohmgrhmgeb l} r`e reaet`ige kiothgme{ mg
kigjmbegke hgb h|e gir tulamk |eki|b{' [ee ®>4< ij ‑R`e Reaekioougmkhrmig{ Hkr ij
8==:‟! 2> U'['K' ® <<< (<44:-' Mgreamu{” lhkcn|iugb |eti|r{ {iab ri kig{uoe|{ bi
gir iga} kigrhmg tulamk mgji|ohrmig' [ee SBJ Gi' :! tt' 85/8>! Gi' 84! tt' <2/<0! Gi'
<>! tt' 55/:8_'
Mgreamu{”! hbomr{ r`e} h|e h ‑ke|rmjmeb k|ebmr |eti|rmgn hnegk}‟! hgb {eaa{ te|{ig
{tekmjmk |eti|r{! ~`mk` m{ {utti|reb l} r`e jhkr }iu khg tu|k`h{e h |eti|r ig h te|{ig
l} [ikmha [eku|mr} guole|' [ikmha [eku|mr} guole|{ h|e ‐te|{ig {tekmjmk” hgb bi gir
te|rhmg ri h nege|ha ghoe i| {momah| ghoe{' [ee SBJ Gi' ;! tt' 88/8<! Gi' >! tt' 8>/
<4! Gi' 84! tt' <2/<0! Gi' <>! tt' 55/:8! Gi' <0! tt' :8/:<! Gi' ;4! tt' :2/::! Gi'
;8! tt' ::/:0_! fu{r amce Tahmgrmjj{ |eti|r{ Mgreamu{ {iab ri r`e ughur`i|mveb r`m|b
th|rme{! mgkaubmgn r`e ir`e| Bejegbhgr{' R`e |eti|r{ ~e|e ‐te|{ig {tekmjmk” hg
te|rhmgeb {iaea} ri Amle|m hgb I{reaah' Mgreamu{ mg r`em| |eti|r jmaeb ~mr` r`e [eku|mrme{
hgb Epk`hgne Kioom{{mig S‑[EK‟_ hbomr r`e} k|ehre r`e |eti|r{ r`hr r`e} {eaa! r`e
|eti|r{ h|e ‐te|{ig {tekmjmk” hgb r`e} h|e liugb l} r`e JK\H' [ee SBJ! Gi' ;! tt' 88/
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25= Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne 5 ij <5 Thne MB+6845<8
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 12/35
Amle|m! er ha! Tahmgrmjj{ Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bej' Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr :
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
8<! Gi' :! tt' 85/8>! Gi' >! tt' 8>/<4! Gi' 84! tt' <2/<0! Gi' <>! tt' 55/:8! Gi' <0!
tt' :8/:8! Gi' ;8! tt' ::/:0_'
Mgreamu{ kahmo{ gi {eh|k`e{ ~e|e kigbukreb ig i| |eti|r{ {iab ig I{reaah ri hg}
ij r`e Bejegbhgr{3 gi mgji|ohrmig `h{ eze| leeg t|izmbeb ri hg}ige |enh|bmgn
I{reaah3 hgb I{reaah bmb gir tu|{ue `e| mgxum|me{ ~mr` Mgreamu{ hgb geze| |exue{reb h
|emgze{rmnhrmig' SO[F! ºMMH! t' 5_ Le|n {egr h aerre| ri Mgreamu{ ig Ht|ma 82! <484
|enh|bmgn mgki||ekr mgji|ohrmig Mgreamu{ ohmgrhmgeb ig I{reaah hgb Amle|m3 |exue{rmgn
I{reaah hgb Amle|m”{ |eti|r{3 hgb beohgbmgn r`hr I{reaah hgb Amle|m le itreb iur ij
Mgreamu{” bhrhlh{e{' Le|n geze| |ekemzeb h |e{tig{e j|io Mgreamu{' Ig Ikrile| <=
<484! I{reaah {egr hgir`e| aerre| ri Mgreamu{! |exue{rmgn `e| hgb `e| `u{lhgb”{ |eti|r{
mgji|omgn Mgreamu{ {`e ~h{ r`e zmkrmo ij k|moe{ te|rhmgmgn ri `e| |eti|r{3 hgb
|exue{rmgn r`e ghoe{! hbb|e{{e{ ij ehk` te|{ig i| egrmr} r`hr |exue{reb hgb)i|
tu|k`h{eb |eti|r{ ig `e| hgb `e| `u{lhgb3 hgb r`e te|om{{mlae tu|ti{e ji| r`e {eaamgn
ij I{reaah”{ |eti|r{' I{reaah geze| |ekemzeb h |e{tig{e lhkc' Mgreamu{ kahmo{ r`e} {egr
I{reaah h aerre| ig Bekeole| :! <484 {rhrmgn r`e} kiuab gir ju|gm{` r`e mgji|ohrmig
|exue{reb ~mr`iur h [ultiegh i| Kiu|r I|be|' I{reaah geze| |ekemzeb {hmb aerre|' [ee
SBJ Gi'”{ 8>/8=! tt' 24/2;! Gi' <;! tt' 20/2=_' Mgreamu{ ~iuab gir cgi~ mj hg}ige
{eh|k`eb ji| I{reaah i| gir' Mgreamu{ hbomr{ r`e} bi gir |erhmg kitme{ ij |eti|r{ {iab
hgb r`e {eh|k` mgji|ohrmig m{ iga} ohmgrhmgeb ji| ji|r}/jmze S25_ bh}{! h{ iuramgeb ig
r`em| |ekemtr{' [ee SBJ Gi'”{ 82/8:! tt' ;;/;=! Gi' <5! tt' 58/5;! Gi' <>! tt' 55/:8_'
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25= Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne : ij <5 Thne MB+6845<<
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 13/35
Amle|m! er ha! Tahmgrmjj{ Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bej' Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr >
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
Mgreamu{ hbomr{ Amle|m |hg {eh|k`e{ ig `e|{eaj hgb tu|k`h{eb |eti|r{ ig `e|{eaj
ig Ht|ma 84! <484' Mgreamu{ hbomr{ |ekemzmgn Le|n”{ Ht|ma 82! <484 aerre| |enh|bmgn
Tahmgrmjj{ bm{ture{ hgb kahmo{ Le|n {rhreb Amle|m tu|k`h{eb h Rhaegr^m{e |eti|r ~`mk`
kigrhmgeb haa r`e mgki||ekr mgji|ohrmig' SO[F! ºMM L! tt' 5/:_' Gi~`e|e mg Le|n”{
aerre| m{ r`e ghoe ‑Rhaegr^m{e‟ oegrmigeb' Le|n {rhreb Amle|m tu|k`h{eb hgir`e|
|eti|r ~`mk` kigrhmgeb r`e mgki||ekr mgji|ohrmig' Amle|m tu|k`h{eb `e| hbbmrmigh
|eti|r r`|iun` U'[' [eh|k`! i~geb hgb ite|hreb l} Mgreamu{! Mgk' [ee SBJ Gi' 8=! tt
2</2;! Gi' <;! tt' 20/2=_' Mgreamu{ kahmo{ Amle|m hbomrreb `e| |eti|r{ tu|k`h{eb j|io
Mgreamu{! Mgk' ~e|e hkku|hre' Hr gi rmoe bmb Amle|m eze| {h} r`e |eti|r{ tu|k`h{eb j|io
Mgreamu{ ~e|e hkku|hre' [ee SBJ! Gi' 8=! tt' 2</2;! Gi' <;! tt' 20/2=! Gi' <2! 2=/58_'
Ig Gizeole| 8! <484! Amle|m {egr h aerre| ri Mgreamu{! Mgk' iuramgmgn haa r`e mgki||ekr
mgji|ohrmig r`e} ohmgrhmgeb hgb {iab ig `e|' [ee SBJ Gi' 8>! tt' 24/28! Gi' <=! tt
:;/:2_'
Mgreamu{ kahmo{ le{mbe{ Amle|m! I|a} Rhmrv m{ r`e iga} te|{ig ~`i tu|k`h{eb h
|eti|r ig Amle|m' [ee SO[F! ºMM L! t' :_' Mgreamu{” i~g ezmbegke kigr|hbmkr{ r`m{
{rhreoegr' Gea{ig! Mgreamu{” Ku{ribmhg ij \eki|b{! mg `m{ Bekah|hrmig! BG ;04/;
{rhreb Chr|mgch Ah~{ig3 Re|e{h Ainnmh3 hgb Fuamegh K`i} ha{i tu|k`h{eb |eti|r{ ig
Amle|m' [ee SBJ Gi' 82! tt' ;;/;5_' Amle|m tu|k`h{eb h |eti|r ig `e|{eaj ig [etreole|
80! <4883 hgb I{reaah kigbukreb {eh|k`e{ hgb tu|k`h{eb |eti|r{ ig Amle|m hgb I{reaah
ig Gizeole| ;4! <488' [ee SBIJ Gi”{ 82/8:! tt' ;;/;=_' Mgreamu{ {rhreoegr{ h|e
bm|ekr ame{ ri r`m{ Kiu|r'
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25= Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne > ij <5 Thne MB+6845<;
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 14/35
Amle|m! er ha! Tahmgrmjj{ Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bej' Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr 0
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
R`ugeg hgb Gea{ig jmaeb Bekah|hrmig{ ~mr` te|fu|eb re{rmoig} hgb ge~a}
k|ehreb bikuoegr{! kahmomgn r`hr r`e bikuoegr{ ~e|e r`e {hoe h{ ~`hr Rhmrv hgb
Amle|m |ekemzeb' [ee SBJ! ºM! tt' ;/0! Gi' <8! tt' 25/2: hgb t' :0_' R`ugeg mg `m{
bekah|hrmig {rhre{! ‑Mgreamu{ bie{ gir |erhmg kitme{ ij r`e hkruha |eti|r{ mr {eaa{ ri
u{e|{ ij mr{ ~el{mre‟ Seot`h{m{ hbbeb_' [ee SBJ Gi' 82! ;;/;5_' \eti|r{ {iab ri
Mgreamu{ ku{rioe|{ hgb r`e hkruha {eh|k` re|o{ u{eb h|e iga} ohmgrhmgeb ji| ji|r}/jmze
S25_ bh}{' [ee SBJ Gi'”{ 82/8:! tt' ;;/;=! Gi' <5! tt' 58/5;! Gi' <>! tt' 55/:8_
Mgreamu{ kahmo{ gige ij r`e [hgce}”{ |hg {eh|k`e{ ig i| tu|k`h{eb |eti|r{ ig hg} ij
r`e Tahmgrmjj{' [ee SO[F! ºMMM! t' :_' R`e [hgce}”{ kigbukreb r`em| {eh|k`e{ hgb
tu|k`h{eb |eti|r{ ig r`e Tahmgrmjj{ mg i| hliur eh|a} Oh|k` <44=3 hgb Mgreamu{ ~h{ gir
hbbeb ri r`e ~mr`mg {umr ugrma Fuge <488' Mgreamu{ bie{ gir `hze hg} ~h} ij cgi~mgn
~`i r`e} {iab |eti|r{ ri hgb)i| ~`i kigbukreb {eh|k`e{ ig r`e Tahmgrmjj{ mg <44= hgb
<484'
Mgreamu{ kahmo{ Rhmrv tu|k`h{eb h nege|ha lhkcn|iugb |eti|r ig r`e ghoe ‑Am{h
Amle|m‟3 hgb Rhmrv hn|eeb ri le liugb l} r`em| Re|o{ hgb Kigbmrmig{' Mg {utti|r
r`e|eij! Mgreamu{ kmre{ ri Rhmrv”{ Bekah|hrmig' [ee SO[F! ºMZ_' Gi~`e|e mg Rhmrv”{
Bekah|hrmig m{ r`e|e hg} oegrmig ij tu|k`h{mgn h |eti|r! hgb iga} {rhre{ {`e kigbukreb
{eh|k`e{' Gi| ~h{ r`e|e hg} oegrmig r`hr Rhmrv ~h{ |exum|eb ri hn|ee i| bmb hn|ee ri
le liugb l} Mgreamu{” Re|o{ hgb Kigbmrmig{' R`e |eti|r{ {iab ri Rhmrv hgb r`e ir`e
Bejegbhgr{ hgb r̀ e |eti|r{ tu|k`h{eb l} Tahmgrmjj{ ~e|e ‐te|{ig {tekmjmk” kig{uoe|
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25= Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne 0 ij <5 Thne MB+6845<2
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 15/35
Amle|m! er ha! Tahmgrmjj{ Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bej' Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr =
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
|eti|r{' [ee SBJ! Gi' 0! tt' <4/<<! Gi”{ 88/8<! tt' <0/;8! Gi' 8:! tt' ;>/;=! Gi' <4!
tt' 2;/25! Gi' <2! tt' 2=/58! Gi' <0! tt' :8/:<! Gi' ;8! tt' ::/:0_'
MMM' [RHGBH\B IJ \EZME^6
[uooh|} Fubnoegr m{ htt|it|mhre iga} mj r`e hbom{{mlae ezmbegke {`i~{
‑r`e|e m{ gi negumge m{{ue h{ ri hg} ohre|mha jhkr hgb r`hr r`e oizmgn th|r} m{ egrmraeb
ri h Fubnoegr h{ h ohrre| ij ah~‟! Jeb' \' Kmz' T' 5:(k-' ^`eg bekmbmgn h Oirmig ji|
[uooh|} Fubnoegr! r`e Kiu|r zme~{ r`e ezmbegke mg r`e amn`r oi{r jhzi|hlae ri r`e
gig/oizmgn th|r} hgb b|h~mgn haa |eh{ighlae mgje|egke{ mg jhzi| ij r`hr th|r}! mj gi
negumge m{{ue ij ohre|mha jhkr epm{r{ r`e oizhgr m{ egrmraeb ri fubnoegr h{ h ohrre| ij
ah~' R`e lu|beg ij {`i~mgn r`hr gi negumge m{{ue ij ohre|mha jhkr epm{r{ m{ li|ge l}
r`e oizmgn th|r}' [ee Gugev z' Bugkhg! 5=8 J' ;b 8<8>! 8<<</<; (=r` Km|' <484-' H
,kigkau{i|}! {eaj/{e|zmgn hjjmbhzmr! ahkcmgn berhmaeb jhkr{ hgb hg} {utti|rmgn
ezmbegke, m{ mg{ujjmkmegr ri k|ehre h negumge m{{ue ij ohre|mha jhkr' [ee JRK z' Tula.n
Kaeh|mgn @iu{e! Mgk'! 842 J';b 88:0! 88>8 (=r` Km|' 8==>-'
MZ' MGREAMU[ m{ GIR MOOUGE UGBE\ [EKRMIG <;4 ij r`e
KIOOUGMKHRMIG[ BEKEGK] HKR S‑KBH‟_ 6
Mgreamu{” lu{mge{{ t|hkrmke{! mg {eaamgn Kig{uoe| \eti|r{! bi gir jhaa ~mr`mg r`e
|ul|mk ij [ekrmig <;4 ij r`e KBH oe|ea} lekhu{e r`e} `htteg ri le kigbukreb igamge
i| lekhu{e r`e} mgziaze r|hjjmk mg r`e kiooibmr} ij mgji|ohrmig' Tahmgrmjj{ Jm|{r
Hoegbeb Kiotahmgr S‑JHK‟_ m{ {r|hmn`rji|~h|b3 Mgreamu{ m{ mg r`e lu{mge{{ ij
h{{eolamgn! ezhauhrmgn hgb {eaamgn kig{uoe| hgb k|ebmr |eti|r{! haign ~mr̀ ir`e|
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25= Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne = ij <5 Thne MB+6845<5
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 16/35
Amle|m! er ha! Tahmgrmjj{ Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bej' Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr 84
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
te|{igha mgji|ohrmig ilrhmgeb j|io Nize|goegrha! [rhre hgb ir`e| egrmrme{! mg ~`mk`
r`e} {eaa ri r`m|b th|rme{ hgb i|nhgmvhrmig{ ji| t|ijmr' STahmgrmjj{ JHK! t' :8_' Mgreamu{
i~g{! ti{{e{{ hgb ohmgrhmg{ kioture| bhrhlh{e{ ij kig{uoe| mbegrmr} hgb k|ebmr
mgji|ohrmig! ji| u{e mg nege|hrmgn hgb t|izmbmgn lhkcn|iugb hgb k|ebmr |eti|r{'
Mgreamu{” bhrhlh{e{ mgkaube r`e te|{igha mbegrmj}mgn bhrh ij omaamig{ ij mgbmzmbuha{
mgkaubmgn k|ebmr hkrmzmr}' [ee STahmgrmjj{ JHK! t' :<_'
Mgreamu{ ilrhmg{ mgji|ohrmig ig mgbmzmbuha{ j|io Nize|goegr Egrmrme{
Kiooe|kmha Egrmrme{! ir`e| Bhrh L|ice| hgb K|ebmr \eti|rmgn Hnegkme{! erk
STahmgrmjj{ JHK t' :<_' Mgreamu{ k|ehre{ r̀ em| |eti|r{ hgb {eaa{ r`em| |eti|r{ ri r`m|b S;|b_
th|rme{' [hmb |eti|r{ |eahre ri kig{uoe|{ k|ebmr~i|r`mge{{! k|ebmr khthkmr}! k`h|hkre|
|eturhrmig! k`h|hkre|m{rmk{! jhoma} rme{! oibe ij amzmgn! erk' STahmgrmjj{ JHK tt' :8/:<_'
R`e kig{uoe| |eti|r{ k|ehreb l} Mgreamu{ kigrhmg mgji|ohrmig r`hr kig{rmrure{ r`eo
‑kig{uoe| |eti|r{‟ ~mr`mg r`e oehgmgn ij r`e Jhm| K|ebmr \eti|rmgn Hkr S‑JK\H‟_!
85 U'['K' ®8:08h(b-3 ~mr`mg r`e oehgmgn ij r`e Kig{uoe| K|ebmr \eti|rmgn Hnegkme{
Hkr S‑KK\HH‟_3 Khamji|gmh Kmzma Kibe S‑Kha' Kmz' Kibe‟_ ®8>05';(k- hgb
‑Mgze{rmnhrmze Kig{uoe| \eti|r{ ~mr`mg r`e oehgmgn ij r`e Khamji|gmh Mgze{rmnhrmze
Kig{uoe| \eti|rmgn Hnegkme{ Hkr S‑MK\HH‟_! Kha' Kmz' Kibe ®8>0:'<(k- [ee
STahmgrmjj{ JHK! t' :;_' Mgreamu{ k|ehre{ hgb {eaa{ r`em| kig{uoe| |eti|r{ ri hg}ige
~mr` h k|ebmr kh|b! mg mgre|{rhre kiooe|ke! ji| oigerh|} jee{ hgb bue{' Mgreamu{ m{ h
‑Kig{uoe| \eti|rmgn Hnegk}‟ l} r`em| i~g hbom{{mig{! JK\H! 85 U'['K
®8:08h(j-' Har`iun` Mgreamu{ begme{ lemgn nize|geb l} r`e JK\H! mr m{ ti{reb ig
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25= Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne 84 ij <5 Thne MB+6845<:
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 17/35
Amle|m! er ha! Tahmgrmjj{ Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bej' Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr 88
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
r`em| ~el{mre! hgb Mgreamu{ `h{ {erraeb ir`e| Jebe|ha ah~{umr{ hgb hbomrreb Tahmgrmjj{ mg
r`i{e kh{e{ ~e|e r`e t|ezhmamgn th|rme{' SBJ Gi';! tt' 88/8<! Gi' ;4! tt' :2/::_'
R`e t|izmbe| ij hg mgre|hkrmze kioture| {e|zmke haai~mgn u{e|{ ~mr`mg h
th|rmkuah| ,kioougmr}, ri ti{r t|ijmae{ hgb kioougmkhre ~mr` ehk` ir`e| ~h{ hg
,mgji|ohrmig kigregr t|izmbe|!, th|ra} |e{tig{mlae ji| r`e k|ehrmig i| bezeaitoegr ij h
jha{e t|ijmae ij hg hkr|e{{ k|ehreb l} h r`m|b th|r}! hgb r`u{ ~h{ gir egrmraeb ri
moougmr} ugbe| r`e Kioougmkhrmig{ Bekegk} Hkr' [ee Kh|hjhgi z
Oer|i{tah{`'Kio' Mgk'! ;;= J';b 888= (=r` Km|' <44;-'
Mgreamu{ m{ hg ‑mgji|ohrmig kigregr t|izmbe|!‟ gir moouge ugbe| r`e KBH' R`e
re|o ,mgji|ohrmig kigregr t|izmbe|, ji| tu|ti{e{ ij r`e Hkr! oehg{ hg} te|{ig i|
egrmr} r`hr m{ |e{tig{mlae! mg ~`iae i| mg th|r! ji| r`e k|ehrmig i| bezeaitoegr ij
mgji|ohrmig t|izmbeb r`|iun` r`e Mgre|ger i| hg} ir`e| mgre|hkrmze kioture| {e|zmke
[ee 2> U'['K'H' ® <;4(j-(;-! Jhm| @iu{mgn Kiugkma ij [hg Je|ghgbi Zhaae} z
\iioohre{! Kio! AAK \iioohre{-! 5<8 J';b 885>! 88:>/:0 (=r` Km|'<440-'
Mgreamu{ m{ h ‑Ke|rmjmeb K|ebmr \eti|rmgn Hnegk}‟ l} r`em| i~g hbom{{mig hgb
nize|geb l} r`e JK\H' Mgreamu{ {eec{ t|mzhre bhrh j|io iur{mbe {iu|ke{' Mgreamu{
r`eg {egb{ r`em| mgze{rmnhri|{ i| |e{eh|k`e|{ ri tu|k`h{e r`e mgji|ohrmig' Mgreamu{
k|ehre{ hgb bezeait{ r`e kig{uoe|)k|ebmr |eti|r{ ~mr` t|mzhre mgji|ohrmig te|rhmgmgn
ri mgbmzmbuha{! mgkaubmgn Tahmgrmjj{ hgb mg ru|g! {eaa{ mr ri r`e nege|ha tulamk! mg
mgre|{rhre kiooe|ke ri hg} th}mgn ku{rioe|! ~mr`iur hg} r}te ij ze|mjmkhrmig mj r`e
te|{ig tu|k`h{mgn r`e |eti|r{ `h{ hg} r}te ij te|om{{mlae tu|ti{e i| aenh
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25= Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne 88 ij <5 Thne MB+6845<>
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 18/35
Amle|m! er ha! Tahmgrmjj{ Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bej' Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr 8<
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
egrmraeoegr' R`m{ m{ mg zmiahrmig ij r`e JK\H hgb maaenha' [ee [ekrmig <;4 ij r`e
Kioougmkhrmig{ Bekegk} Hkr S‑KBH‟_ r`hr bie{ gir moouge maaenha hkrmzmr}' [ee
\egi z' Hoe|mkhg Kmzma Amle|rme{ Ugmig! (8==>- 5<8 U'[' 022! 058! 88> ['Kr' <;<=
8;0 A'Eb'<b 0>23 Jhm| @iu{mgn Kiugkma ij [hg Je|ghgbi Zhaae} z' \iioohre{! Kio
AAK \iioohre{-! 5<8 J';b 885>! 88:>/:0 (=r` Km|'<440-' R`e KBH bie{ gir
moouge Mgreamu{ j|io r`em| maaenha hkr{ ij urmamvmgn mgbmzmbuha{” t|mzhre mgji|ohrmig
k|ehrmgn |eti|r{ ig r`e mgbmzmbuha{ hgb |e{eaamgn r`e t|mzhre bhrh mg zmiahrmig ij r`e
JK\H'
Tahmgrmjj{ kiotahmgr hnhmg{r Mgreamu{ m{ Mgreamu{” kigbukr mg zmiahrmgn r`e Jebe|h
ah~{! JK\H! ~`mk` t|irekr mgbmzmbuha{! j|io r`e maaenha hkke{{ hgb bm{{eomghrmig ij
t|mzhre mgji|ohrmig' [ee 85 U'['K' ®8:08l3 85 U'['K' ®8:08e(h-3 85 U'['K
®8:08e(l-3 erk'! h{ iuramgeb mg Tahmgrmjj{ JHK' R`e t|ebmkhre ji| KBH moougmr}
te|rhmgmgn ri Mgreamu{ m{ r`e r`m|b |exum|eoegr ugbe| r`e KBH' H t|izmbe| ij hg
mgre|hkrmze kioture| {e|zmke oh} kahmo KBH moougmr} iga} ~mr` |e{tekr ri
‑mgji|ohrmig t|izmbeb l} hgir`e| mgji|ohrmig kigregr t|izmbe|'‟ [ee 2> U'['K' ®
<;4(k-(8-' Lur! hg Mgre|hkrmze kioture| {e|zmke r`hr m{ ha{i hg mgji|ohrmig kigregr
t|izmbe| m{ gir moouge j|io amhlmamr} h|m{mgn j|io tulamkhrmig ij r`e kigregr' [ee
\iioohre{'kio! 5<8 J';b hr 88:<3 Lh|ge{ z' ]h`ii(! Mgk'! 5>4 J';b 84=:! 884: (=r`
Km|'<44=-3 Nibbh|b z' Niinae! Gi' K 40/<>;0 FJ (TZR-! <440 ^A 5<252=4 (G'B
Kha' Bek' 8>! <440-3 Kh|hjhgi z' Oer|i{tah{`'kio! ;;= J';b 888=! 88<</<; (=r` Km|
<44;-'
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25= Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne 8< ij <5 Thne MB+6845<0
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 19/35
Amle|m! er ha! Tahmgrmjj{ Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bej' Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr 8;
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
H ~el{mre)lain i~ge|)ite|hri| lekioe{ amhlae h{ hg ‑mgji|ohrmig kigregr
t|izmbe|‟ ~`eg r`e} kigr|mlure ri mr{ ‑haaeneb ugah~juage{{‟' [ee 5<8 J';b hr 88:>/
:0' [ee ha{i Lh|ge{ z' ]h`ii(! Mgk'! 5>4 J';b 84=:! 884: (=r` Km|'<44=-3 Nibbh|b z
Niinae! Gi' K 40/<>;0 FJ (TZR-! <440 ^A 5<252=4 (G'B'Kha' Bek' 8>! <440-
Har`iun` gir tulam{`eb ig r`e Mgre|ger! Mgreamu{ k|ehreb r`e |eti|r{ te|rhmgmgn ri r`e
Tahmgrmjj{! r`u{ r`e} bmb oi|e r`hg ‑kigr|mlure ri mr{ ugah~juage{{‟ hgb r`e|eji|e h|e
GIR moouge ugbe| r`e KBH'
Tahmgrmjj{ haaene r`hr Mgreamu{ bie{ oi|e r`hg ‑hunoegr‟ r`e bhrh r`hr mr |ekemze{
Mgreamu{! l} r`em| i~g hbom{{mig{! ohre|mhaa} kigr|mlure kigregr mg r`e ji|o ij
kig{uoe| k|ebmr mgji|ohrmig' Mgreamu{ ilrhmg{ r`e mgji|ohrmig! kaehg{e{ r`e
mgji|ohrmig! mgre|t|er{ r`e mgji|ohrmig! hunoegr{ r`e mgji|ohrmig! hgb {rmrk`e{ r`e
mgji|ohrmig riner`e| mgri |eti|r{ te|rhmgmgn ri {tekmjmk mgbmzmbuha{! ‐te|{ig {tekmjmk”
|eti|r{' [ee Jhm| @iu{mgn Kiugkma ij [hg Je|ghgbi Zhaae} z' \iioohre{! Kio! AAK!
5<8 J';b 885>! (=r` Km|'<440-! hr 88>< (‑T|izmbmgn moougmr} eze|} rmoe h ~el{mre
u{e{ bhrh mgmrmhaa} ilrhmgeb j|io r`m|b S;|b_ th|rme{ ~iuab ezm{ke|hre r`e epketrmig ri
{ekrmig <;4 ji| ‐bezeaitSmgn_ ugah~jua kigregr ‐mg ~`iae i| mg th|r'”‟-'
Kiu|r{ r`hr `hze kig{mbe|eb [ekrmig <;4 kahmo{ ij moougmr} `hze nege|haa}
bige {i ~`e|e mgji|ohrmig kigregr `h{ leeg tulam{`eb! ti{reb! i| ir`e|~m{e ohbe
~mbea} hzhmahlae ig r`e Mgre|ger' [ee Kh|hjhgi! ;;= J';b 88=3 Lh|ge{ z' ]h`ii(! Mgk'!
5>4 J';b 84=:! 884: (=r` Km|'<44=-3 Nibbh|b z' Niinae! Gi' K 40/<>;0 FJ (TZR-
<440 ^A 5<252=4 (G'B' Kha' Bek' 8>! <440-'
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25= Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne 8; ij <5 Thne MB+6845<=
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 20/35
Amle|m! er ha! Tahmgrmjj{ Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bej' Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr 82
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
[ekrmig <;4 ij r`e KBH bie{ gir htta} ri r`e t|mzhre r|hg{om{{mig ij
mgji|ohrmig gir oehgr ji| tulamkhrmig ig r`e Mgre|ger i| ir`e| mgre|hkrmze kioture|
{e|zmke! ezeg mj r`e oehg{ ij r|hg{om{{mig mgziaze{ r`e Mgre|ger' [ee Lhrvea z' [omr`
;;; J';b hr 84;;/;5' \hr`e|! [ekrmig <;4 kigke|g{ r`e tulamk ti{rmgn i| tulam{`mgn ij
mgji|ohrmig ig r`e Mgre|ger'
Kig{mbe|mgn {momah| jhkr{ ri r`m{ kh{e! r`e Regr̀ Km|kumr bere|omgeb r`hr r`e
Bejegbhgr! Hkku{eh|k !̀ ~h{ hg mgji|ohrmig kigregr t|izmbe| hgb r`u{ gir moouge
j|io amhlmamr} ugbe| r`e KBH mg JRK z' Hkku{eh|k`! 5>4 J';b 880>! 8<44 (84r` Km|
<44=-'
Mg Hkku{eh|k !̀ r`e Bejegbhgr i~geb hgb ite|hreb h ~el{mre! Hlmch'kio ~`mk`
haai~eb r`em| ku{rioe|{ ri {eh|k` ‑mgji|ohrmig nege|haa} kigrhmgeb mg nize|goegr
|eki|b{! {uk` h{ ‐kiu|r bikcer{!” ‐{ep ijjegbe| |eki|b{!” hgb ‐Rhp ' ' ' Ameg{'” ' ' ' Shgb
ir`e|_ mgrmohre te|{igha mgji|ohrmig! {uk` h{ ‐\iohgrmk T|eje|egke{!” ‐Te|{ighamr}
r|hmr{!” hgb ‐\uoi|{'”‟ Mb' hr 88=8' Hkku{eh|k` ha{i ilrhmgeb reaet`ige |eki|b{! hgb
`hb r`em| |e{eh|k`e|{ tu|k`h{e r`e |eki|b{ mg zmiahrmig ij ®>4< ij ‑R`e
Reaekioougmkhrmig{ Hkr ij 8==:‟! 2> U'['K' ® <<< (<44:-' R`e Kiu|r ephomgeb r`e
re|o ‑bezeait‟!‟ jmgbmgn r`hr r`e ‑bmkrmigh|} bejmgmrmig{ ji| bezeait ki||e{tigbmgna}
|eziaze h|iugb r`e hkr ij b|h~mgn {ioer m̀gn iur! ohcmgn mr ‐zm{mlae!” ‐hkrmze!” i|
u{hlae'”‟ Mb' hr 88=0' R`e Kiu|r bere|omgeb r`hr r`e Bejegbhgr ~h{ |e{tig{mlae ji|
r`e bezeaitoegr ij r`e mgji|ohrmig htteh|mgn ig mr{ ~el{mre lekhu{e mr ‑cgi~mgna}
{iun`r ri r|hg{ji|o zm|ruhaa} ugcgi~g mgji|ohrmig mgri h tulamka} hzhmahlae
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25= Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne 82 ij <5 Thne MB+6845;4
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 21/35
Amle|m! er ha! Tahmgrmjj{ Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bej' Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr 85
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
kiooibmr}'‟ Mb' hr 8===' Mgreamu{ bezeait{ r`e t|mzhre mgji|ohrmig r`hr mr ilrhmg{
j|io iur{mbe {iu|ke{! fu{r amce Hkku{eh|k !̀ mgkaubmgn kiooe|kmha hgb nize|goegrha
hnegkme{! hgb r|hg{ji|o{ mr mgri |ehbma} zm{mlae hgb `mn`a} u{hlae ji|ohr{ r`hr haai~
thmb {ul{k|mle|{ ri h{{e{{ h kig{uoe|”{ ~ehar`! k`h|hkre|! |eturhrmig! oibe ij amzmgn!
k|ebmr ~i|r`mge{{! hgb t|izmbe{ r`eo ~mr` r`e mgbmzmbuha{ t|mzhre kigjmbegrmha
mgji|ohrmig mg zmiahrmig ij r`e JK\H' R`e kigregr k|ehreb l} Mgreamu{ nie{ jh|
le}igb r`hr ~`mk` ~h{ hr m{{ue mg r`e kh{e{ kmreb l} Mgreamu{' Ji| ephotae! m
Kh|hjhgi z' Oer|i{tah{`'kio! Mgk'! ;;= J';b 888=! 88<2 (=r̀ Km|' <44;- h bhrmgn
~el{mre `hb KBH moougmr} j|io amhlmamr} ji| mgji|ohrmig ti{reb ig hg mgbmzmbuha”{
igamge t|ijmae lekhu{e r`e ‑{eaekrmig ij r`e kigregr Sij r`e t|ijmae_ ~h{ aejr epkau{mzea}
ri r`e u{e|‟ ij r`e mgre|hkrmze ~el{mre! ~`i k|ehreb r`e t|ijmae' Mb ' hr 88<2'
[momah|a}! mg Nibbh|b z' Niinae! Mgk'! :24 J' [utt' <b 88=; (G'B' Kha' <44=-
Bejegbhgr Niinae haai~eb hbze|rm{e|{ ri k|ehre ‑hb~i|b{‟ r`hr khu{eb haaeneba}
j|hubuaegr hbze|rm{eoegr{ ri le bm{tah}eb mg |e{tig{e ri u{e| {eh|k` xue|me{' R`e
Kiu|r jiugb r`hr KBH moougmr} ~h{ htt|it|mhre lekhu{e Niinae”{ Ce}~i|b Riia
~h{ h ‑geur|ha riia!‟ hgb r`e {eaekrmig ij kigregr ‑m{ aejr epkau{mzea} ri r`e u{e|‟ ‛
lir` r`e hbze|rm{e| {eaekrmgn htt|it|mhre ce}~i|b{! hgb r`e u{e| |uggmgn h th|rmkuah|
{eh|k` xue|}! Mb' hr 88=>'
Mgreamu{ kahmo{ r`e} h|e gir hg mgji|ohrmig kigregr t|izmbe| lekhu{e r`e} bmb
gir k|ehre i| bezeait r`e mgji|ohrmig! {momah| ri r`e Hkku{eh|k` kh{e' Lur! mg
Hkku{eh|k`! 5>4 J';b 880>! r`e Regr` Km|kumr kig{mbe|eb ~`er̀ e| r`e kigjmbegrmh
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25= Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne 85 ij <5 Thne MB+6845;8
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 22/35
Amle|m! er ha! Tahmgrmjj{ Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bej' Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr 8:
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
|eki|b{ ~e|e ‑bezeaiteb‟ ~mr`mg r`e oehgmgn ij r`e KBH' R`e KBH u{e{ r`e t`|h{e
‑k|ehrmig i| bezeaitoegr ij mgji|ohrmig‟ 2> U'['K' ® <;4(j-(;-! hgb r`e KBH bie{
gir bejmge r`e re|o bezeaitoegr '
R`e Regr` Km|kumr mg Hkku{eh|k` `eab r`hr ~`eg kigjmbegrmha mgji|ohrmig ~h{
epti{eb ri tulamk zme~ r`|iun` Hlmch'kio r`hr mgji|ohrmig ~h{ ‑bezeaiteb‟ Mb hr
88=0' R`e Regr` Km|kumr r`eg ru|geb ri ~`er`e| i| gir Hkku{eh|k` ~h{ ‑|e{tig{mlae
mg ~`iae i| mg th|r! ji| r`e…bezeaitoegr ij r`e ijjegbmgn kigregr'‟ xuirmgn
\iioohre{'kio! 5<8 J';b hr 88:< (xuirmgn ® <;4(j-(;--' ‑R`hr m{! ~h{ mr |e{tig{mlae
ji| r`e bezeaitoegr ij r`e {tekmjmk kigregr r`hr ~h{ r`e {iu|ke ij r`e haaeneb
amhlmamr}9‟ R`e Regr` Km|kumr hg{~e|eb r`e xue{rmig mg r`e hjjm|ohrmze' R`e Regr`
Km|kumr kigkaubeb r`hr h {e|zmke t|izmbe| m{ ‑|e{tig{mlae‟ ji| r`e bezeaitoegr ij
ijjeg{mze kigregr iga} mj mr mg {ioe ~h} {tekmjmkhaa} egkiu|hne{ bezeaitoegr ij ~`hr
m{ ijjeg{mze hliur r`e kigregr' Mg r`e mg{rhgr kh{e! Mgreamu{! amce Hkku{eh|k`
bezeaiteb r`e ijjegbmgn kigregr! ~`mk` ~h{ r`e bm{kai{eb kigjmbegrmha mgji|ohrmig
mr{eaj' R`e Regr` Km|kumr jiugb r`hr r`e} bmb gir geeb ri kig{r|ue r`e ~i|b
‑|e{tig{mlae‟ ri epregb le}igb mr{ ki|e oehgmgn mg r`e kigrepr ri kigkaube r`hr
Hkku{eh|k`! fu{r amce Mgreamu{ `e|emg! ~h{ |e{tig{mlae ji| r`e bezeaitoegr ij r`e
kigregr ‛ ji| r`e kigze|{mig ij r̀ e aenhaa} t|irekreb |eki|b{ j|io kigjmbegrmha ohre|mh
ri tulamka} epti{eb mgji|ohrmig' Fu{r amce Hkku{eh|k !̀ Mgreamu{ {iamkmreb |exue{r{ ji|
{uk` kigjmbegrmha mgji|ohrmig hgb r`eg thmb |e{eh|k`e|{! kiothgme{ hgb ir`e|”{ ri
ilrhmg mr! l} r`em| i~g hbom{{mig{' Mgreamu{! amce Hkku{eh|k !̀ cgi~mgna} {iun`r ri
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25= Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne 8: ij <5 Thne MB+6845;<
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 23/35
Amle|m! er ha! Tahmgrmjj{ Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bej' Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr 8>
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
r|hg{ji|o ‑zm|ruhaa} ugcgi~g mgji|ohrmig mgri h tulamka} hzhmahlae kiooibmr}'‟ R`e
Regr` Km|kumr”{ `iabmgn mg Hkku{eh|k` ~h{ r`hr Hkku{eh|k` ~h{ gir moouge ugbe|
[ekrmig <;4 ij r`e KBH lekhu{e Hkku{eh|k` ~h{ hg mgji|ohrmig kigregr t|izmbe| ~h{
{utti|reb l} hur`i|mr} j|io ir`e| km|kumr{' [ee Jhm| @iu{' Kiugkma z
\iioohre{'kio! AAK ! 5<8 J';b 885>! 88:; (=r` Km|' <440-3' Ve|hg z' Ho' Igamge!
Mgk'! 8<= J';b ;<>! ;;4‛;8 (2r` Km|' 8==>-3 Kiook”g{ [}{'! Mgk' z' A}ki{! Mgk'! 2>0
J';b 28;! 28= (8{r Km|' <44>-3 Lhrvea z' [omr !̀ ;;; J';b 8480! 84;4 (=r` Km|' <44;-3
Leg Ev|h! ^emg{remg! * Ki'! Mgk' z' Ho' Igamge Mgk'! <4: J';b =04! =05 g'2 (84r` Km|
<444-'
Mgreamu{ {iamkmr{ r`e t|mzhre mgji|ohrmig ig mgbmzmbuha{ hgb urmamve{ mr{ thmb
|e{eh|k`e|{ ri ilrhmg r`e ohre|mha! fu{r amce mg Hkku{eh|k '̀ Mgreamu{ Oh|cer{ hgb
Hbze|rm{e{ r`em| ‑kig{uoe| |eti|r{‟ ~`mk` r`e} k|ehre' [ee SBJ Gi' 84! tt' <2/<0
Gi' <>! 55/:8_' Mg i|be| ri tu|k`h{e hg} t|ibukr j|io Mgreamu{! }iu ou{r {mng ut ji|
hg Mgreamu{ Hkkiugr' Hg} |eti|r tu|k`h{eb j|io Mgreamu{ m{ t|izmbeb l} Mgreamu{ ri r`e
ku{rioe| mg r`em| th{{~i|b t|irekreb hkkiugr hgb l} ~h} ij eohma bm|ekra} ri r`em|
ku{rioe|' Mgreamu{ m{ ‑ouk` oi|e r`hg h th{{mze r|hg{omrre| ij r`e mgji|ohrmig
t|izmbeb l} ir`e|{‟3 mr lekShoe_ r`e bezeaite|…ij r`e mgji|ohrmig‟' [ee
\iioohre{'kio! 5<8 J';b hr 88::' \iioohre{ {uooh|mveb ‑SH_ ~el{mre `eat{ ri
bezeait ugah~jua kigregr! hgb r`u{ jhaa{ ~mr`mg r`e epketrmig ri [ekrmig <;4! mj mr
kigr|mlure{ ohre|mhaa} ri r`e haaeneb maaenhamr} ij r`e kigbukr‟' [ee Mb ' Hr 88:0'
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25= Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne 8> ij <5 Thne MB+6845;;
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 24/35
Amle|m! er ha! Tahmgrmjj{ Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bej' Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr 80
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
Mgreamu{ mg r`em| \eti|r ri r`e [EK {rhre{! ‑^e `hze bezeaiteb hbzhgkeb
t|it|merh|} rek`giainme{ r`hr hkke{{! kiaaekr hgb gi|ohamve h l|ihb |hgne i
kig{uoe|…mgji|ohrmig' Iu| hgha}rmk{ rek`giainme{ ze|mj} hgb hunoegr ouarmtae
re|hl}re{ ij bhrh! u{uhaa} mg bm{th|hre ji|ohr{ hgb ~mr` zh|}mgn ben|ee{ ij hkku|hk}
hgb kiotaerege{{! j|io h o}|mhb ij {iu|ke{ mg i|be| ri ohce mgje|egke{ hgb
t|ebmkrmig{ lh{eb ig r`m{ bhrh' Ji| ephotae! iu| rek`giainme{ eghlae u{ ri kig{r|ukr h
{mgnae mbegrmr} t|ijmae ji| h te|{ig ~`i `h{ k`hgneb `m{ i| `e| ah{r ghoe! hbb|e{{ i|
t`ige guole|'‟ Mgreamu{” \eti|r jmaeb ~mr` r`e [EK! Tahmgrmjj{ \FG! Ep`mlmr ‑8‟! tt
82! ;8! ;<! ;5! ;:' Mg Eb Tere|{ig! Epekurmze Zmke T|e{mbegr ij Mgreamu{” Teitae
[eh|k` hgb Teitae Jmgbe| Mgre|zme~! `e {rhre{ ‑…~`hr ~e r|} ri bi m{ u{e h rig ij
`eu|m{rmk t|ike{{e{ hgb r`e Mgreamu{ rek`giain} r`hr haai~{ u{ ri ohrk` mgji|ohrmig
riner`e|! {rmrk` mgji|ohrmig riner`e| ri t|e{egr h ze|} hkku|hre |eti|r ji| iu|
ku{rioe|{‟' Mgreamu{ m{ ugxue{rmighla} r`e bezeaite| ij r`e mgji|ohrmig! r`e
mgji|ohrmig kigregr t|izmbe|' Mgreamu{” hkrmig{ ~e|e mgregbeb ri nege|hre r`e kigregr
mg ~`mk` mr {eaa{ hgb r`e {hae ij ~`mk` `h|oeb r`e Tahmgrmjj{! r`u{ Mgreamu{ m{
|e{tig{mlae' Mgreamu{ m{ hgb ~h{ |e{tig{mlae ji| r̀ e bezeaitoegr ij r`hr kigregr / ji|
r`e kigze|{mig ij r`e aenhaa} t|irekreb |eki|b{ j|io kigjmbegrmha ohre|mha ri tulamka}
epti{eb mgji|ohrmig'
Ji| r`e |eh{ig{ iuramgeb! Mgreamu{ m{ gir moouge ugbe| r`e KBH! Jhm| @iu{mgn
Kiugkma ij [hg Je|ghgbi Zhaae} z' \iioohre{! Kio! AAK! 5<8 J';b 885>! (=r`
Km|'<440-3 Nibbh|b z' Niinae! Mgk'! :24 J' [utt' <b 88=; (G'B' Kha' <44=-3 Kh|hjhgi
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25= Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne 80 ij <5 Thne MB+6845;2
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 25/35
Amle|m! er ha! Tahmgrmjj{ Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bej' Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr 8=
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
z' Oer|i{tah{`'kio! Mgk'! ;;= J';b 888=! 88<2 (=r` Km|' <44;3 \egi z' Hoe|mkhg Kmzma
Amle|rme{ Ugmig (8==>- 5<8 U'[' 022! 88> ['Kr' <;<=! 8;0 A'Eb'<b 0>2'-'
Z' MGREAMU[ m{ h KIG[UOE\ \ETI\RMGN HNEGK]
NIZE\GEB l} r`e JK\H L] R@EM\ I^G HBOM[[MIG[6
Tahmgrmjj{ mgki|ti|hre r`em| JHK hr tt' 8<>/828! ºº;;5/;04 h{ mj juaa {er ji|r`
`e|e hr aegnr`'
Tahmgrmjj{ haaene hgb Mgreamu{ hbomr{! r`e} h|e h ‑kig{uoe| |eti|rmgn hnegk}‟
hgb r`e |eti|r{ Mgreamu{ k|ehre{ hgb {eaa{ h|e ‑kig{uoe| |eti|r{‟ h{ bejmgeb l} r`e
JK\H! ~mr` o}|mhb {utti|reb jhkr{' [ee Tahmgrmjj{ BJ! Gi'”{ ‑8‟ r`|iun` ‑;8‟! tt' 8/
::' Mgreamu{ ~mr` r`em| {rhreoegr{ ig r`em| ~el{mre hr ~~~'mgreamu{'kio! r`e \eti|r
r`e} jmaeb ~mr` r`e [EK! r`em| Epekurmze Zmke T|e{mbegr”{ mgre|zme~{! r`em|
hbze|rm{eoegr{! hgb r`e ir`e| Jebe|ha Kh{e{ r`e} `hze {erraeb ji| JK\H zmiahrmig{!
hbomr r`e} h|e h ‑ke|rmjmeb k|ebmr |eti|rmgn hnegk}‟ |enuahreb l} r`e JK\H'
R`e JK\H bejmge{ h ‑kig{uoe| |eti|rmgn hnegk}‟ h{6
‑hg} te|{ig ~`mk`! ji| oigerh|} jee{! bue{! i| ig h kiite|hrmze gigt|ijmr
lh{m{! |enuah|a} egnhne{ mg ~`iae i| mg th|r mg r`e t|hkrmke ij h{{eolamgn i|
ezhauhrmgn kig{uoe| mgji|ohrmig i| ir`e| mgji|ohrmig ig kig{uoe|{ ji| r`e
tu|ti{e ij ju|gm{`mgn kig{uoe| |eti|r{ ri r`m|b th|rme{! hgb ~`mk` u{e{ hg}
oehg{ i| jhkmamr} ij mgre|{rhre kiooe|ke ji| r`e tu|ti{e ij t|eth|mgn i|
ju|gm{`mgn kig{uoe| |eti|r{'‟ 85 U'[' K' ®8:08h(j-'
R`e JK\H bejmge{ h ‑kig{uoe| |eti|r‟ h{ jiaai~{6
‑R`e re|o ‑kig{uoe| |eti|r‟ oehg{ hg} ~|mrreg! i|ha i| ir`e|
kioougmkhrmig ij hg} mgji|ohrmig l} h kig{uoe| |eti|rmgn hnegk} leh|mgn
ig h kig{uoe|”{ k|ebmr ~i|r`mge{{! k|ebmr {rhgbmgn! k|ebmr khthkmr}! k`h|hkre|!
nege|ha |eturhrmig! te|{igha k`h|hkre|m{rmk{! i| oibe ij amzmgn ~`mk` m{ u{eb i|
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25= Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne 8= ij <5 Thne MB+6845;5
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 26/35
Amle|m! er ha! Tahmgrmjj{ Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bej' Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr <4
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
eptekreb ri le u{eb i| kiaaekreb mg ~`iae i| mg th|r ji| r`e tu|ti{e ij {e|zmgn
h{ h jhkri| mg e{rhlam{`mgn r`e kig{uoe|”{ eamnmlmamr} ji| ‑k|ebmr i| mg{u|hgke ri
le u{eb t|moh|ma} ji|6
H'te|{igha! jhoma} i| `iu{e`iab tu|ti{e{3
L' eotai}oegr tu|ti{e{3 i|
K' hg} ir`e| tu|ti{e hur`i|mveb ugbe| {ekrmig :42 S®8:08l_'‟
85 U'['K' ®8:08h(b-'
R`u{! h ‑kig{uoe| |eti|r‟ mgkaube{ ‑hg}‟ kioougmkhrmig ij ‟hg} mgji|ohrmig‟
ri h r`m|b th|r}! ‑leh|mgn ig‟ jehru|e{ ij h te|{ig”{ mbegrmr} h{ l|ihb h{ ‑k`h|hkre|
nege|ha |eturhrmig Shgb_ te|{igha k`h|hkre|m{rmk{'‟ [ee 85 U'['K' ®®8:08h(b- hgb
8:08l'
R`e|e m{ gi xue{rmig r`hr Mgreamu{ m{ h Ke|rmjmeb K|ebmr \eti|rmgn Hnegk} hgb
{iab kig{uoe| |eti|r{ ig Tahmgrmjj{ ri ughur̀ i|mveb r`m|b th|rme{'
H' Mgreamu{ Zmiahreb r`e JK\H! KK\HH! hgb MK\HH l} {eaamgn
Tahmgrmjj{ Kig{uoe| \eti|r{ ri Ughur`i|mveb Mgbmzmbuha{6
Mgreamu{hbomr{
{eaamgn Tahmgrmjj{ kig{uoe| |eti|r{ ri r`e Rhmrv hgb [hgce}
Bejegbhgr{' Mgreamu{ ha{i hbomr{ r`e} {iab |eti|r{ ig Amle|m ri hbbmrmigha
ughur`i|mveb mgbmzmbuha{! Chr|mgch Ah~{ig3 Re|e{h Ainnmh3 hgb Fuamegh K`i}
Mgreamu{ hbomrreb r`e} bmb gir |exum|e hg} te|om{{mlae tu|ti{e j|io r`e{e th|rme3! r`e}
bmb gir ze|mj} r`e te|om{{mlae tu|ti{e i| aenha egrmraeoegr3 hgb r`e} fu{r {iab
Tahmgrmjj{ |eti|r{ hgb t|mzhre mgji|ohrmig ji| h t|ijmr! mg zmiahrmig ij r`e JK\H' [ee 85
U'['K' ®8:08l! 85 U'['K' ®8:08e(l-! hgb Kha' Kmz' Kibe ®® 8>05'88! 8>05'82
8>05'8=! 8>05'<<! 8>0:'8< hgb 8>0:'<4' [ee SBJ! Gi' ;!tt' 88/8<! Gi' :! tt' 85/8>!
Gi' >! tt' 8>/<4! Gi' 84! tt' <2/<0! Gi' <>! tt' 55/:8! Gi' <0! tt' :8/:8! Gi' ;8! tt'
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25= Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne <4 ij <5 Thne MB+6845;:
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 27/35
Amle|m! er ha! Tahmgrmjj{ Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bej' Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr <8
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
::/:0_' Hgb! Mgreamu{ hbomrreb ri {eaamgn Tahmgrmjj{ \eti|r{ r`hr kigrhmgeb r`e
mgki||ekr mgji|ohrmig ri Rhmrv! Re|e{h Ainnmh! hgb Fuamegh K`i}' Tahmgrmjj{ `hze oer
r`em| lu|beg ugbe| 85 U'['K' ®8:08e(l-! hgb Kha' Kmz' Kibe ®® 8>05'88! 8>05'82
8>05'8=! 8>05'<<! 8>0:'8< hgb 8>0:'<4'
‑Eze|} kig{uoe| |eti|rmgn hnegk} {`haa ohmgrhmg |eh{ighlae t|ikebu|e{
be{mngeb ri hzimb zmiahrmig{ ij {ekrmig 8:08k ij r`m{ rmrae hgb ri amomr r`e ju|gm{`mgn ij
kig{uoe| |eti|r{ ri r`e tu|ti{e{ am{reb ugbe| {ekrmig 8:08l ij r`m{ rmrae' R`e{e
t|ikebu|e{ {`haa |exum|e r`hr t|i{tekrmze u{e|{ ij r`e mgji|ohrmig mbegrmj} r`eo{eaze{
ke|rmj} r`e tu|ti{e ji| ~`mk` r`e mgji|ohrmig m{ {iun`r! hgb ke|rmj} r`hr r`e
mgji|ohrmig ~maa le u{eb ji| gi ir`e| tu|ti{e' [ee 85 U'['K' ®8:08e(h- SEot`h{m{
hbbeb_'
Mgreamu{ ~maajuaa} jhmaeb ri kiota} ~mr̀ r`e JK\H l} cgi~mgna} hgb
mgregrmighaa} bm{kai{mgn kig{uoe| |eti|r{ hgb ir`e| te|{igha mbegrmj}mgn mgji|ohrmig
ri ughur`i|mveb r`m|b S;|b_ th|rme{! mg kig{kmiu{ bm{|enh|b ij r`e Tahmgrmjj{ |mn`r{ ugbe|
r`e JK\H! KK\HH! MK\HH! 85 U'['K' ®8:08g! ®® 8>05'88! 8>05'82! 8>05'8=
8>05'<<! 8>0:'8< hgb 8>0:'<4 l} bm{kai{mgn! {eaamgn hgb bm{r|mlurmgn Tahmgrmjj{ k|ebmr
jmghgkmha hgb ir`e| t|mzhre bhrh ri ughur`i|mveb r`m|b th|rme{! r`e|el} khu{mgn hkruha
bhohne{ ri r`e Tahmgrmjj{! ji| ~`mk` r`e} h|e amhlae' [ee Tahmgrmjj{ R~eajr` S8<r`
_ Khu{e
ij Hkrmig mg r`em| JHK hr tt' 8<>/8;4! ºº;;5/;2:3 hgb Jmjreegr` S85 r`_ Khu{e ij
Hkrmig! tt' ;:5/;>;! ºº8;0/8243 hgb [mpreegr̀ S8:r`_ Khu{e ij Hkrmig! tt' 824/828
ºº;>2/;04' [ee R\^ Mgk' z' Hgb|e~{! 5;2 U'[' 8=! <;! 8<< [' Kr' 228! 858 A' Eb' <b
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25= Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne <8 ij <5 Thne MB+6845;>
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 28/35
Amle|m! er ha! Tahmgrmjj{ Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bej' Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr <<
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
;;= (<448-3 r`e JK\H ,|exum|Se{_ k|ebmr |eti|rmgn hnegkme{ ri ohmgrhmg |eh{ighlae
t|ikebu|e{ be{mngeb ri h{{u|e ohpmouo ti{{mlae hkku|hk} ij r`e mgji|ohrmi
kigrhmgeb mg k|ebmr |eti|r{', [ee Hgb|e~{! 5;2 U'[' hr <; (kmrhrmig{ hgb mgre|gh
xuirhrmig oh|c{ iomrreb-' ‑R`e JK\H te|omr{ hnegkme{ ri ju|gm{` k|ebmr |eti|r{ iga}
ji| ,ke|rhmg {rhruri|ma} eguoe|hreb tu|ti{e{', Mb ' Numoigb z' R|hg{ Ugmig K|ebm
Mgji' Ki'! 25 J';b 8;<=! 8;;; (=r` Km|' 8==5-'
L' Tahmgrmjj{ Girmjmeb Mgreamu{! ~`i m{ r`e K|ebmr \eti|rmgn Hnegk}
ij r`e ^|ign Mgji|ohrmig kigrhmgeb mg Tahmgrmjj{ jmae{6
Tahmgrmjj{ ~|ire ri Mgreamu{ ig Ht|ma 82! <484 r`|iun` Le|n3 I{reaah ~|ire ri
Mgreamu{ ig Ikrile| <=! <4843 hgb Amle|m ~|ire ri Mgreamu{ ig Gizeole| 8! <484! haa ij
~`mk` m{ ugbm{tureb' Amle|m iuramgeb eze|} mgki||ekr ghoe! [ikmha [eku|mr} guole|
Bhre ij Lm|r`! k|momgha |eki|b{! {tiu{e mgji|ohrmig! erk' Mgreamu{ |eju{eb ri |e{tigb
|eju{eb ri mgze{rmnhre! |eju{eb ri ki||ekr r`e mgki||ekr mgji|ohrmig3 hgb jhmaeb ri
{utta} Tahmgrmjj{ ~mr` hg utbhreb |eti|r! mg{rehb mngi|mgn r`e Tahmgrmjj{! mg zmiahrmig ij
85 U'['K' ®8:08M' Mgreamu{ jhmaeb ri kigbukr t|ite| hgb |eh{ighlae mgze{rmnhrmig
kigke|gmgn r`e mghkku|hre mgji|ohrmig mg Tahmgrmjj{ jmae{! hjre| |ekemzmgn girmke
Mgreamu{ jhmaeb ri t|eth|e Tahmgrmjj{ |eti|r{ l} jiaai~mgn t|ikebu|e{ r`hr h{{u|eb
ohpmouo ti{{mlae hkku|hk} mg zmiahrmig ij 85 U'['K' ®8:08e(l-3 Mgreamu{ jhmaeb ri
kiota} ~mr` r`e JK\H mg eze|} ir`e| httamkhlae |e{tekr! mgkaubmgn 85 U'['K
®®8:08k hgb 8:08n' R`e|eji|e! Mgreamu{ m{ amhlae ri Tahmgrmjj{ tu|{uhgr ri 85 U'['K
®8:08g hgb 85 U'['K' ®8:08i'
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25= Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne << ij <5 Thne MB+6845;0
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 29/35
Amle|m! er ha! Tahmgrmjj{ Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bej' Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr <;
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
Mgreamu{ jha{ea} kahmo{ I{reaah geze| h{ceb ji| h |emgze{rmnhrmig! lur r`m{ m{
mghkku|hre h{ Le|n {egr r`e jm|{r aerre| ig le`haj ij I{reaah hgb I{reaah {egr `e| {ekigb
aerre| hnhmg |exue{rmgn ig Ikrile| <=! <484' Mgreamu{” h|nuoegr{ jhma{' [ee Ni|ohg z
^iatijj * Hl|ho{ig! 502 J';b 882>! 88:; (=r` Km|' <44=-3 ^`mre z' R|hg{ Ugmig
2:< J' [utt' <b 84>=! 840; (K'B' Kha' <44:-3 Gea{ig z' K`h{e Ohg`hrrhg Oi|rnhne
Ki|t'! <0< J';b 845>! 84:4 (=r` Km|' <44<-'
Mgreamu{ jha{ea} kahmo{ Tahmgrmjj{ h|e gir egrmraeb ri |eamej lekhu{e Mgreamu{ bmb
gir |ekemze girmjmkhrmig ij h bm{ture j|io h kig{uoe| |eti|rmgn hnegk}' Mgreamu{ kmre{
85 U'['K' ®8:08{/<l' SO[F! t' 8:_ Mgreamu{ m{ r`e kig{uoe| |eti|rmgn hnegk} hgb
Mgreamu{ hbomrreb ri |ekemzmgn Tahmgrmjj{ aerre|{ ij bm{ture{' SBJ Gi' <=! tt' :;/:2_ [ee
Ni|ohg z' ^iatijj * Hl|ho{ig! AAT ! 502 J';b 882>! 8852 (=r̀ Km|' <44=- (burme{
ugbe| ® 8:08{/<(l- h|m{e igke r`e k|ebmr |eti|rmgn hnegk} |ekemze{ r`e bm{ture-! ke|r
begmeb! JMH Kh|b [e|z{'! G'H' z' Ni|ohg! 8;8 [' Kr' >8! 8>0 A' Eb' <b <; (<484-' Mr m{
ugcgi~g ri Tahmgrmjj{ ~`e|e Mgreamu{ ilrhmg{ r`e mgji|ohrmig mg ~`mk` r`e} |eti|r'
Mgreamu{ jha{ea} kahmo{ Tahmgrmjj{ jhmaeb ri mbegrmj} r`e mgki||ekr mgji|ohrmig
Mgreamu{ jha{ea} kahmo{ Amle|m”{ kiotahmgr ij mghkku|hre mgji|ohrmig {reooeb j|io `e|
Rhaegr^m{e |eti|r' SO[F t' 80_' R`m{ m{ hg iur|mn`r ame' Mgreamu{ hbomrreb ri |ekemzmgn
Amle|m”{ Gizeole| 84! <484 aerre| ~`mk` {rhreb eze|} mgki||ekr mreo kigrhmgeb mg
Amle|m”{ |eti|r{ ~mr` Mgreamu{ hgb r`em| hjjmamhre{' [ee Amle|m Beka' Ep`mlmr ‑O‟' Amle|m
geze| {rhreb r`e mgki||ekr mgji|ohrmig ~h{ kigrhmgeb mg `e| Rhaegr^m{e \eti|r gi| bmb
Le|n' Tahmgrmjj{ h{{e|reb r`em| Mgreamu{ |eti|r{! ~`mae rek`gmkhaa} ki||ekr hgb lh{eb ig
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25= Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne <; ij <5 Thne MB+6845;=
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 30/35
Amle|m! er ha! Tahmgrmjj{ Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bej' Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr <2
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
tulamk mgji|ohrmig! ~e|e om{aehbmgn hgb mgkiotaere' [ee Tahmgrmjj{ JHK! R~eajr`
r`|iun` [mpreegr` Khu{e{ ij Hkrmig{! tt' 8<>/828! ºº;;5/;04' Tahmgrmjj{ `hze oer
r`em| lu|beg' [ee Ni|ohg z' ^iatijj * Hl|ho{ig! 502 J';b 882>! 88:; (=r` Km|
<44=-3 ^`mre z' R|hg{ Ugmig! 2:< J' [utt' <b 84>=! 840; (K'B' Kha' <44:-3 Gea{ig z
K`h{e Ohg`hrrhg Oi|rnhne Ki|t'! <0< J';b 845>! 84:4 (=r` Km|' <44<-'
K' Tahmgrmjj{” \exue{r{ ji| r`em| \eti|r{ hgb Jmae{6
Mgreamu{ hbomr{ r`e} |ekemzeb Tahmgrmjj{ aerre|{ |exue{rmgn r`em| jmae{ hgb |eti|r{
lur Mgreamu{ |eju{eb ri kiota}! mg zmiahrmig ij 85 U'['K' ® 8:08m! 85 U'['K' ® 8:08{
<(l-(8-(B-! 85 U'['K' ® 8:08e(l-3 Kha' Kmz' Kibe ®® 8>05'8 er {ex! 8>05'82(l-
8>05'<5(h-! ® 8>0: er {ex3 85 U'['K' ®®8:08f hgb 8:08n(h-(8-3 [ee Tahmgrmjj{ JHK
R~eajr` r`|iun` [mpreegr` Khu{e{ ij Hkrmig! tt' 8<>/828! ºº;;5/;04' [ee Tahmgrmjj{
kiotameb ~mr` haa r`e |exum|eoegr{ {er iur mg r`e JK\H! KK\HH hgb MK\HH
BeHgb|hbe z' R|hg{ Ugmig AAK ! 5<; J';b :8! :> (8{r Km|' <440-3 Beggm{ z' LE@/M
AAK ! 5<4 J';b 84:: (=r` Km|' <440-! Km{ge|i{ z' U'B' \enm{r|}! Mgk'! ;= Kha' Htt' 2r`
520! 2: Kha' \tr|' <b <;; (Kr' Htt' 8==5-3 Ni|ohg z' ^iatijj * Hl|ho{ig! AAT ! 502
J';b 882>! 8852 (=r` Km|' <44=-'
B' Mgreamu{ H{{e|rmig{ hliur r`em| ‑Re|o{ hgb Kigbmrmig{‟ Jhma6
Mgreamu{! kahmo{ Rhmrv hgb Amle|m hn|eeb ri r`em| re|o{ hgb kigbmrmig{ r`hr {rhre
r`e |eti|r{ khggir le u{eb ji| JK\H tu|ti{e{! ~`mk` m{ ugr|ue' Rhmrv gi| Amle|m eze|
ohbe hg} {uk` {rhreoegr' Mgreamu{” Re|o{ hgb Kigbmrmig{ bm{kahmoe| m{ epr|eoea}
{ohaa hgb bmjjmkuar ri {ee' R`e ku{rioe| ou{r jmgb hgb kamkc{ ig h gig/ohgbhri|} amgc
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25= Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne <2 ij <5 Thne MB+684524
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 31/35
Amle|m! er ha! Tahmgrmjj{ Oeoi|hgbuo mg Itti{mrmig ri Bej' Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr <5
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
r`hr m{ `}te|/amgceb' R`e ‑re|o{‟ amce~m{e h|e mg ze|} {ohaa t|mgr' R`e ze|} epm{regke
ij r`e bm{kahmoe| ‑Re|o{ hgb Kigbmrmig{‟ {`i~{ Mgreamu{ cgi~{ r`hr r`e mgji|ohrmig mr
kiotmae{ mgri |eti|r{ ig rh|nereb kig{uoe|{ h|e ‑eptekreb ri le u{eb i| kiaaekreb mg
~`iae i| mg th|r‟ ji| JK\H tu|ti{e{! 85 U'['K' ®8:08(h-(b-' R`e iga} kigkemzhlae
|eh{ig ri mgkaube r`m{ bm{kahmoe| m{ ri r|} ri e{khte r`e JK\H ‛ r`u{ ~maajuaa}
r`~h|rmgn r̀ e JK\H”{ tu|ti{e{' H `}te|amgc bie{ gir epku{e Mgreamu{ j|io JK\H
|e{tig{mlmamrme{ h|m{mgn ~`eg {utta}mgn mgji|ohrmig ‑eptekreb ri le u{eb i| kiaaekreb
mg ~`iae i| mg th|r‟ ji| tu|ti{e{ |enuahreb l} r`e JK\H! 85 U'['K' ®8:08h(b-3 85
U'['K' ®8:08h(j-'
ZM' KIGKAU[MIG6
Mgreamu{ m{ gir egrmraeb ri moougmr} ugbe| [ekrmig <;4 ij r`e Kioougmkhrmig{
Bekegk} Hkr3 hgb m{ liugb l} r`e JK\H! KK\HH! hgb MK\HH' Tahmgrmjj { bm{ture
Mgreamu{” k`h|hkre|mvhrmig ij r`e jhkr{ hgb r`em| ‑T|iti{eb Ugkigr|ize|reb Jhkr{‟ mg
r`em| egrm|er}' Tahmgrmjj{ `hze e{rhlam{`eb h negumge m{{ue ij ohre|mha jhkr{' Ji| r`e
hlize/{rhreb |eh{ig{! Bejegbhgr{” Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr {`iuab le Begmeb
mg mr{ egrm|er} hgb Tahmgrmjj{ h~h|beb Hrri|ge} Jee{ hgb Ki{r{'
\e{tekrjuaa} {ulomrreb!
Bhreb6 Jel|uh|} <4! <48< ){) T`mamt F' Le|n
T`mamt F' Le|n! E{xum|e
Hrri|ge} ji| Tahmgrmjj{
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25= Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne <5 ij <5 Thne MB+684528
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 32/35
8
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
UGMREB [RHRE[ BM[R\MKR KIU\R
JI\ R@E KEGR\HA BM[R\MKR IJ KHAMJI\GMH!
[IUR@E\G BMZM[MIG
AM[H AMLE\M! er ha!
Tahmgrmjj{!
z{'
I\A] RHMRV! er ha!
Bejegbhgr{'
6666
6666666666
KMZMA HKRMIG GUOLE\6
0688/kz/44205/HN (HF^-
T\ITI[EB I\BE\ BEG]MGN
BEJEGBHGR MGREAMU[! MGK'”[
OIRMIG JI\ [UOOH\]
FUBNOEGR
Bhre ij @eh|mgn6 Oh|k` 8<! <48<Rmoe ij @eh|mgn6 84644 h'o'Aikhrmig6 Kiu|r|iio 84B
I\BE\
Ig Oh|k` YYYYYY! <48<! Bejegbhgr! Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|}
Fubnoegr khoe ig ji| @eh|mgn' R`e Kiu|r `hzmgn |ezme~eb hgb kig{mbe|eb r`e
oizmgn thte|{! Tahmgrmjj{ Itti{mrmig r`e|eri! r`e |eki|b{ ig jmae ~mr` r`m{ Kiu|r
`hzmgn `eh|b I|ha H|nuoegr hgb ji| NIIB KHU[E [@I^G! MR M[ @E\EL]
I\BE\EB hgb BEK\EEB6
Bejegbhgr! Mgreamu{! Mgk'”{ Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr m{ BEGMEB'
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25=/< Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne 8 ij < Thne MB+684520
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 33/35
<
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
MR M[ [I I\BE\EB6
Bhreb6 Oh|k` YYY! <48< YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY Hgb|e~ F' Numaji|b
Fubne ij r`e Ugmreb [rhre{ Bm{r|mkrKiu|r! Kegr|ha Bm{r|mkr ij Khamji|gmh!
[iur`e|g Bmzm{mig\e{tekrjuaa} {ulomrreb l}6
T`mamt F' Le|n! E{xum|eE/ohma6 t`mafle|nDnohma'kio
Tegg{}azhgmh M'B' =0:>AH^ IJJMKE[ IJ T@MAMT F' LE\N
555 Hgbi||h Naeg Kiu|r! [umre 8<
Ahjh}erre @maa! TH 8=222/<5;8Reaet`ige6 (:84- 0<5/;8;2
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25=/< Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne < ij < Thne MB+68452=
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 34/35
Amle|m! er ha ‛ Tahmgrmjj{ Ke|rmjmkhre ij [e|zmke ij Tahmgrmjj{ L|mej mg Iti' ri Mgreamu{ O[F 8
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
T`mamt F' Le|n! E{xum|e (TH M'B' =0:>-E/ohma6 t`mafle|nDnohma'kio
AH^ IJJMKE[ IJ T@MAMT F' LE\N
555 Hgbi||h Naeg Kiu|r! [umre 8<Ahjh}erre @maa! TH 8=222/<5;8
Reaet`ige6 (:84- 0<5/;8;2 Jhp6 (:84- 0;2/>:5= Hrri|ge} mg t|i {e hgb ji| Tahmgrmjj{
UGMREB [RHRE[ BM[R\MKR KIU\R
JI\ R@E KEGR\HA BM[R\MKR IJ KHAMJI\GMH!
[IUR@E\G BMZM[MIG
AM[H AMLE\M! er ha!
Tahmgrmjj{!
z{'
I\A] RHMRV! er ha!Bejegbhgr{'
6
6666666666
KMZMA HKRMIG GUOLE\60688/kz/44205/HN (HF^-
TAHMGRMJJ[ KE\RMJMKHRE IJ
[E\ZMKE
M! T`mamt F' Le|n! E{xum|e! `e|el} ke|rmj} h r|ue hgb ki||ekr kit} ij Tahmgrmjj{
Oeoi|hgbuo L|mej mg Itti{mrmig ri Mgreamu{” Oirmig ji| [uooh|} Fubnoegr ~h{ {e|zeb
eaekr|igmkhaa} r`|iun` r`e EKJ jmamgn {}{reo r`m{ <4r` bh} ij Jel|uh|} <48<! utig r`e
jiaai~mgn6
Fi`g H Zinr! F|'! E{xum|e
Eb~h|b [hg K`hgn! E{xum|e
Fige{ Bh}
;8:8 Omk`ea{ig B|mze [umre 044
M|zmge! KH =<:8<Eohma6 fhzinrDfige{bh}'kio
Eohma6 ek`hgnDfige{bh}'kio
Hrri|ge} ji| Bejegbhgr Mgreamu{! Mgk'
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25=/; Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne 8 ij < Thne MB+684554
8/3/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Opposition to Intelius' Motion Summary Judgement Doc 459-1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-opposition-to-intelius-motion-summary-judgement 35/35
8
<
;
2
5
:
>
0
=
84
88
8<
8;
82
85
8:
8>
80
8=
<4
<8
<<
<;
<2
<5
<:
<>
<0
Oh|k [rezeg Kiaeg! E{xum|e
Ah~ Ijjmke{ ij Oh|k [rezeg Kiaeg
5>;> Chghg \ihb! [umre ;2>Hniu|h @maa{! KH =8;48
Eohma6 okiaegDkiaegah~'kio
Hrri|ge} ji| Bejegbhgr{6 Gema [hgce}3 Ribb [hgce}3
[hgce} Mgze{rmnhrmig{! Mgk' hgb R`e [hgce} Jm|o! Mgk'
Fhoe{ J OkKhle! E{xum|e
Oi||m{ig * Jie|{re|
2<5 Oh|cer [r|eer[hg J|hgkm{ki! KH =2845/<20<
Eohma6 fokkhleDoiji'kio
Hrri|ge} ji| Bejegbhgr{6 \eeb Ea{ezme|! Mgk'! Aepm{Gepm{ N|iut! Mgk'!
Aepm{Gepm{! Mgk'! Aepm{Gepm{ \m{c hgb Mgji|ohrmig Hgha}rmk{ N|iut! Mgk'! A
Aepm{Gepm{ \m{c [iaurmig{! Mgk'! [em{mgr! Mgk' b)l)h Hkku|mgr! K`imketimgr! Mgk'
){) T`mamt F' Le|n
T`mamt F' Le|n! E{xum|e
Kh{e 0688/kz/44205/HN/HF^ Bikuoegr 25=/; Jmaeb 4<)<4)8< Thne < ij < Thne MB+684558