LEWP-RCEGDublin April 2013

Hans Borgonjen

Platforms / Agenda• LEWP - RCEG

(Law Enforcement Working Party – Radio Communication Expert Group) - Forerunner Group

‘LEWP Matrix’ + ‘3-scenario document’

• CEPT-PT49 Frequency allocation studies

• European Commission - RSPP text

• TCCA - CCBG (Tetra & Critical Communication Association) (Critical Communication Broadband Group)

- CCBG user+operator requirement group: ‘umbrella document’

- ‘Time line’ (Roadmap)- ‘Strategic Case’ (Business Case)

LEWP user requirement matrix high speed data• Known as the “LEWP Matrix”

• Use it for your internal discussions

• Basis for CEPT PT49

• Basis for ETSI for technology discussion - ETSI adds detailed figures

- CEPT PT49 uses this ETSI figures- Now also ‘ETSI frequency calculation tool’

(LEWP-ETSI Matrix)

PublicSafety highspeed user requirementsType of application + services

throughput p/s per session

use per month per user

Number of users

mobility (using while moving)

quality of experience (can there be a hiccup in the connection)

Availability/start-up time

timeliness continuous operational availability (mission critical level)

LOCATION DATA                

A(V)LS data to CCC low high high high medium ready high high

A(V)LS data return medium high medium high medium ready high high

MULTI MEDIA

Video from/to CCC for following + intervention

high low medium high low ready when vehicle is ready

medium high

Video for fixed observation

medium (high on hdd)

high low low low low medium medium

Video on location (disaster or event area)

high low low low medium Take along on ad hoc basis

medium high; availability at Golden Hour essential

Video conferencing operations

medium low low low low low medium low

Type of application + services

throughput p/s per session

use per month per user

Number of users

mobility (using while moving)

quality of experience (can there be a hiccup in the connection)

Availability/start-up time

timeliness continuous operational availability (mission critical level)

Photo broadcast medium low medium high low ready low medium

Photo to select group medium low low high low ready low medium

OFFICE APPLICATIONS

PDA PIMsync medium high low high low ready low low

Mobile workspace + (incl public internet)

medium medium low high low ready low low

DOWNLOAD OPERATIONAL INFORMATION

Incident information download (text + images) from CCC to fieldunits + Netcentric working

medium low medium low high ready medium high

LEWP-RCEG meeting 24 october

Letter LEWP to ECC, CEPT-FM, PT49

- Many references to earlier documents- Stating the importance of PT49- Offer to continue to cooperate- Stating the earlier LEWP inputs

(Matrix + 3-scenario document)

RSPP Radio Spectrum Policy Program

RSPP Art. 8(3), Quote <<The Commission shall, in cooperation with the

Member States seek to ensure that sufficient spectrum is made available under harmonised conditions to support the development of safety services and the free circulation of related devices as well as the development of innovative interoperable solutions for public safety and protection, civil protection and disaster relief.>>

Presentation on behalf of the TETRA + Critical Communications Association

CCBG

• There is a TCCA-CCBG Roadmap See presentation Emmanuelle

• There is an “umbrella document” with all user requirements + system requirements Based on all kind of existing URS’s

• There is a discussion on architecture: what in the LTE core + what in an “upper application layer”

Event Calendar1. PT49:

25+26 April Paris13+14 June Oslo

2. TCCA-CCBGCCBG 17 April BudapestTCCA-CCW 21-23 May Paris (World Congress)

With posibility for joining President of Interpol + EC CCBG 27 June AmsterdamCCBG 8 Oct. London

3. ECGeneral frequency conference 25+26 June BrusselsEC PPDR workshop 11 July Brussels

4. SeveralsLTE summit 25-26 June AmsterdamIIR + CCBG ‘professional LTE + spectrum Forum’ 9-11 Oct. LondonIIR Controlroom 10-12 Dec. Vienna

CEPT-FM PT49• PT49: special working group for PPDR mobile broadband

• Participation of Public Safety is essential• PT49 wants close relationship with LEWP

• LEWP Matrix is basis for frequency demand discussion in PT49

• ‘Report A’ with LEWP Matrix + German study as basis

• Extra explanation by ‘3 Operational Scenario’s’ document

+ Get in contact with you national administration

Roadmap of the FM49 work

• FM49 main task: find harmonised radio spectrum for the future European broadband PPDR system

• The concept of the future European broadband PPDR system: Wide Area Network (WAN) + Ad-Hoc networks

• ECC Report ”A” (requirements) – 2012 ECC Report ”B” (solutions) – 2013

• FM49 also supports the CEPT/ECC preparatory work for the World Radio Conference 2015 (WRC-15) Agenda Item 1.3 on the spectrum requirements for PPDR

FM49#04 meeting (14-15 June, Berlin) (1)

• The “Catalogue of PPDR Applications Related Requirements” was approved by FM49 and created a basis for the work on the ECC Report “A” (requirements)

• The work on the assessment of the necessary overall spectrum bandwidth for a BB PPDR Wide Area Network (WAN) was started based on the following assumptions:o applications: LEWP/RCEG-ETSI “Matrix of applications” o scenarios: LEWP/RCEG PP1 and PP2 scenarioso technology: LTEo frequency ranges: 400 MHz and 700 MHz (other candidate

frequency bands are also under discussion)

Result PT49ECC report A

In report A the ‘requirements’ en in report B the ‘solutions’.

In report A: • General description PPDR ‘operational framework’, • Concept future PPDR BB (WAN + ad-hoc networks), • PPDR Application related requirements (LEWP/RCEG-ETSI Matrix +

scenarios), • Operational requirements for WAN (‘terrestrial fixed network’), • Spectrum demands for WAN (from correspondence Group + ETSI calculation

tool)• Chapters on ‘non-WAN’ services: DMO, AGA, Ad-hoc networks• Chapter on voice (consequences if in future voice goes over the LTE network)

+ annex from ETSI with calculation on spectrum consequences of it• Rapport A also contains definition of terminologies

Report A

For the WAN there are several calculations made (uplink, downlink, optimistic + pessimistic link-budget, users at edge of a cell etc.)

• Overall result is (minimum) 2x 10 MHz needed as harmonised ‘core band’, with the possibility to have more (or less) on a national basis.

• This is without AGA, DMO, ‘voice over LTE’, extra capacity for ad-hoc networks.

• ETSI calculation for ‘voice over LTE’ gives an estimation that an other 2x3,2 MHz is needed (based on comparable functionality with Tetra).

• Hybrid solution is mentioned as a good mix between partly dedicated and partly using commercial operator. In Report A is this flexibility clearly indicated.