lewp-rceg (chair forerunner/broadband) vice … publicsafety situation on mobile (data)...

European PublicSafety situation

on mobile (data) communications

Mobidig March Catwick

Hans Borgonjen

LEWP-RCEG (Chair Forerunner/Broadband)

Vice-Chairman TCCA

Chairman TCCA-CCBG User&operator group

Platforms / Agenda • LEWP - RCEG

(Law Enforcement Working Party – Radio Communication Expert Group)

- Forerunner Group

‘LEWP Matrix’

• CEPT-FM-PT49 Frequency (allocation) studies/advice

• European Commission - RSPG + RSPP text

• TCCA - CCBG (Tetra & Critical Communication Association)

(Critical Communication Broadband Group)

- CCBG user+operator requirement group: ‘umbrella document’

- ‘Time line’ (Roadmap)

- ‘Strategic Case’ (Business Case)

Vision on Mobile working

Society is changing

PublicSafety work is changing

• PublicSafety officer is confronted with new

possibilities.

• The public is expecting that PublicSafety

follows the trends in society.

• PublicSafety work is time and place

independent

Three pillars

Fully in connection

• Always the possibility to get and find the right

information

Rich in observation

• Different sources; from databases, maps, pictures to

(real time) video

The right information, at the right moment, for the

right person

• who needs what, when and how detailed?

• different persons/functions different needs

• different locations different needs

Key

Nationwide TETRA

Regional TETRA

Nationwide TETRAunder construction

Project in progresslikely to be TETRA

Tetrapol

No project known

Digital voice networks – Public Safety Q1 2013

ItalyIrelandPolandEstoniaGreeceBulgariaPortugalSloveniaRomaniaLithuaniaIsle of ManVatican StateAirwave - UKIRJA - IcelandVIRVE - FinlandPro-M - HungaryRAKEL- SwedenNodnett - NorwayASTRID - BelgiumTetraNet - DenmarkDigitalfunk - AustriaC2000 - NetherlandsBOS Digitalfunk – Germany

All in 380-400 MHz band

1

Mission critical communication for Public Safety

‘Mission critical mobile voice’ – lessons learned

1 common standard.

1 harmonised frequency band: 2x5 MHz in 380-400 MHz

BUT: We need more data in the field

‘Mission critical mobile Broadband’

1 common standard: LTE + specific extra’s

1 harmonised frequency band

Goal: Being part of the ‘worldwide LTE ECO system’

The Public Safety World

- Mission critical operations, information and communication

- Working under stress + high risks

- Mobile communication is often the only ‘lifeline’

- It has to work ALWAYS,

especially when everything else fails

frontline officers must trust the solution.

PPDR cannot operate with ‘Best Effort networks’

House Committee on

Homeland Security

Boston Police Commissioner Edward Davis III agreed that law enforcement can’t

rely on commercial carriers for public-safety emergency communications.

“In the minutes immediately following the attacks, cell-phone communication was

ineffective and virtually non-existent,” Davis said. “For this reason, radio

communications for first responders became the only means to deploy forces and

manage the operations. These frequencies play a critical role during a major

incident and allow us to do our jobs properly.”

Train crash Halle Belgium - Feb 2010

Case study: the London Royal wedding

CEPT-FM-PT49 is looking for Broadband PPDR spectrum

Explanation made by LEWP-RCEG

for the frequency discussion

- Approved in LEWP-RCEG 11 May 2012

- Used in CEPT-FM-PT49

‘Moving overload’

- In the past: photo’s stored on film

- Last years: photo’s stored on memory chip

- Today: photo’s send directly by I-phone’s

Where? Close to the coach !!

Overload around the coach

security camera’s on coach blocked

Information to and from security workers blocked

Commercial networks a risk for PPDR

LEWP-RCEG

Law Enforcement Working Party (LEWP)

Radiocommunication Expertgroup (RCEG)

Broadband + Frequencies

Connecting existing networks

Radio experts from all countries

Governmental operators, police, MoI / Justice

Lot of expertise from national radio projects

RCEG: 2 subgroups

ISI + Forerunner Group

Expert group on radio technology + frequencies

Task Forerunner Group: long term solution mobile broadband data

Harmonised technical solution

Harmonised frequency band(s)

ISITEP Kick-off meeting

15 million FP7 project with 10 million subsidies

3 years project

Technical + operational

Different operational trials

Brussels 29+30 October

PublicSafety mobile data user requirements Type of application +

services

throughput

p/s per

session

use per

month per

user

Number

of users

mobility

(using while

moving)

quality of

experience (can

there be a

hiccup in the

connection)

Availability/

start-up

time

timeliness continuous

operational

availability

(mission

critical level)

LOCATION DATA

A(V)LS data to CCC low high high high medium ready high high

A(V)LS data return medium high medium high medium ready high high

MULTI MEDIA

Video from/to CCC for

following + intervention

high low medium high low ready when

vehicle is

ready

medium high

Video for fixed

observation

medium

(high on hdd)

high low low low low medium medium

Video on location

(disaster or event

area)

high low low low medium Take along

on ad hoc

basis

medium high; availability

at Golden Hour

essential

Video conferencing

operations

medium low low low low low medium low

Type of application +

services

throughput

p/s per

session

use per

month per

user

Number

of users

mobility

(using while

moving)

quality of

experience (can

there be a

hiccup in the

connection)

Availability/

start-up

time

timeliness continuous

operational

availability

(mission

critical level)

Photo broadcast medium low medium high low ready low medium

Photo to select group medium low low high low ready low medium

OFFICE

APPLICATIONS

PDA PIMsync medium high low high low ready low low

Mobile workspace +

(incl public internet)

medium medium low high low ready low low

DOWNLOAD

OPERATIONAL

INFORMATION

Incident information

download (text +

images) from CCC to

fieldunits + Netcentric

working

medium low medium low high ready medium high

Council - COMIX recommendation

Effective cross-border cooperation requires adequate

communication capabilities including interoperable

radio communication systems in border areas and

between operational services from different Member States

In the long term, law-enforcement and public-safety radio

communication systems will need to support and to be able

to exchange high-speed mobile data information;

current law-enforcement, public-safety and commercial

networks may not be able to support this

Frequencies

CEPT-FM-PT49

• PT49: special working group for PPDR mobile broadband

• PT49 has a close relationship with LEWP

• LEWP Matrix is basis for frequency demand discussion

• ‘Report A / CEPT-199’ with LEWP Matrix + German study

as basis is ready. Result: minimum 2x10 MHz needed

• Now working on ‘Report B’: which frequency band(s)?

2 options: 400 + 700 MHz band

PPDR prefers 700 MHz band

RSPP

Radio Spectrum Policy Program RSPP Art. 8(3), Quote <<The Commission shall, in cooperation with the

Member States seek to ensure that sufficient spectrum is made available under harmonised conditions to support the development of safety services and the free circulation of related devices as well as the development of innovative interoperable solutions for public safety and protection, civil protection and disaster relief.>>

Consider our needs

2 x 10 MHz – minimum for terrestrial network

- ‘Harmonised’ model

- At least in CEPT

- Globally in 700 MHz

- Allows flexible model: real use on National basis

- LTE combined with 700 MHz choice

- commercial technology

- roaming to commercial networks

WRC15 gives an unique opportunity for (worldwide)

PPDR Broadband solutions

Does it make socio-economic sense? • PPDR offers more socio-economic benefit than IMT

• WIK-Consult: “if improved disaster response could reduce property

losses by a mere three per cent (ignoring the value of any lives

saved), the cost benefit analysis proves out”

• LSE: estimates a consolidated annual socioeconomic value of £5

billion from the use of 2x10 MHz in the 700MHz band for public safety

in the UK and across EU28 countries, an annual value of

approximately €34 billion is computed.

• To auction or Not to Auction?

Using auctions to authorise spectrum for PPDR was rejected by

Marcus on the grounds that it would not allow interoperability across

European states and that the PPDR community is too fragmented to

place bids on it that reflected its true value.

Further activities RCEG

- Continuing working on frequencies + standardisation:

CEPT-FM-PT49, ETSI, TCCA-CCBG

New initiative: umbrella group worldwide for 3GPP work

- Mobile data applications

- EC Research program:

Where can we participate (FP7) + can we make our own

proposals (Horizon 2020)?

International cooperation

Tetra & Critical Communication Association (TCCA)

Subgroup CCBG:

Critical Communication Broadband Group

Broader scope: also Railways, utilities etc.

PPDR want to be part of global LTE Eco system

There are many TCCA-CCBG activities on LTE

Basic work done in CCBG

Via CCBG input to 3GPP + ETSI

Some countries participate directly in 3GPP + ETSI

TCCA-CCBG

TCCA-CCBG activities on LTE, 3GPP etc.

See ‘landscape’

There is an “umbrella document” with all user requirements

+ system requirements

Based on all kind of existing URS’s

There is a discussion on architecture:

What in the LTE core + what in an “upper application layer”

Technical

Forum

APCO

PSCE

SFPG

Complex landscape 31

Marketing

Group

FM 49

WG FM

CEPT/ECC

Applications

WG

OUA

TCCA

ETSI TETRA

TC and WGs

RSCOM

DG INSFO LEWP of JHA

Council

European

Union

Critical

Communication

Broadband Group

Radio

Spectrum

3GPP LTE

Exact model of

cooperation

to be defined

NPST

C

NIST

TCCA + CCG

Standard-oriented bodies

Regulation

EU Bodies

US Bodies

Asia Pacific Research

Bodies

Presentation on behalf of the TETRA + Critical Communications Association

Roadmap

There is a ‘global high level Roadmap’

made to give a reference


Timescales Based on practical implementation of a harmonised European solution

TETRA/Tetrapol/P25/GSM-R mission critical Voice

Cap

acit

y

2005 < 2020 2025/30?

TETRA-1/Tetrapol/P25/GSM-R mission critical Data

NOTES • Tetra, Tetrapol, P25, GSM-R are already for years in use for

mission critical voice • Tetra-1, Tetrapol, P25 and GSM-R have limited data functionalities • TEDS is now possible and offers more data capacity

< - - - - - - - - TEDS - - - - - - - - - >

2012



mission critical voice • Tetra-1, Tetrapol, P25 and GSM-R have limited data functionalities • TEDS is now possible and offers more data capacity • Commercial networks can provide data functionalities now • The coming period will be used for preparation of a European harmonised

dedicated Broadband solution: frequencies + technology/standard • When this work is ready around 2020, dedicated networks can be realized

(without harmonisation and with frequencies available it can sooner)




Cap

acit

y

2005 < 2020 2025/30?

Next Generation Development

< - - - - - - - - TEDS - - - - - - - - - >

2012



mission critical voice • Tetra-1 and GSM-R have limited data functionalities • TEDS is now possible and offers more data capacity • Commercial networks can provide data functionalities now • The coming period will be used for preparation of a European harmonised

dedicated Broadband solution: frequencies + technology/standard • When this work is ready around 2020, dedicated networks can be realized

(without harmonisation and with frequencies available it can sooner) • Period after 2020 is unclear:

• Many existing networks will not be ready for replacement • Voice services over LTE will be limited in early implementations • Full TETRA functionality will take longer to replicate

• For many markets Tetra will still be used for voice anyhow • Commercial networks will also still be used

(e.g. for non-mission critical) in a hybrid model




Cap

acit

y

2005 2012 < 2020 2025/30?

Next Generation Development

< - - - - - - - - TEDS - - - - - - - - - >

Questions?

Thank you for your attention

[email protected]

+31-653164538

mailto:[email protected]

lewp-rceg (chair forerunner/broadband) vice … publicsafety situation on mobile (data)...

Documents