letter relief defense us vs viktor bout

8/2/2019 Letter Relief Defense US vs Viktor Bout

1/14

FCJDZP X+ @FXFK >2,2: Idw Gfz`dk} Z`+# - 82:# Idw Gfz`dk}# K+X+ 66064


2/14

Hkpze`tmphek

Hk pnh} metkpzx# wd zdgfz` pnd t}d ea eaahmhfc rewdz pe errzd}} ez hkphlh`fpdrzhqfpd hk`hqh`tfc} f} f `d}rhmfjcd fjt}d ea ftpnezhpx dkphzdcx fchdk pe etz }x}pdl ea f

geqdzkldkp ea cfw}+ Pnd fzmnhpdmp} ea etz Mek}phptphek ldphmtcet}cx dzdmpd` f }x}pdl ea}drfzfpd` rewdz}# fk` mndmi} fk` jfcfkmd}# rzdmh}dcx hk ez`dz pe hknhjhp pnd d~dzmh}d eapxzfkkhmfc rewdz jx geqdzkldkp eaahmhfc}+ Rze}dmtpezhfc rewdz h} zhgh`cx mek}pzfhkd`fk` ot`hmhfccx }trdzqh}d` }e pnfp geqdzkldkp lfx kep fmmt}d rzhqfpd rdz}ek} ea mzhld}ez hkqd}phgfpd pndl whpnetp gee` mft}d+ Fk`# gee` mft}d mdzpfhkcx ed} kep hkmct`dqhk`hmphqdkd}}# }rhpd# qdkgdfkmd aeldkpd` jx pnd rhvtd ea f geqdzkldkpfc d~dmtphqdwne addc} rdz}ekfccx ez rechphmfccx dljfzzf}}d` ke lfppdz pnd ceaphkd}} ea nh} re}hphek+

Pnd qdzx kephek pnfp eaahmhfc} ea pnd ]pfpd @drfzpldkp ez pnd @drfzpldkp ea@dadk}d ez dqdk pnd Wnhpd Net}d mfk rzdqfhc trek pnd Ot}phmd @drfzpldkp pe rtz}td fk`rze}dmtpd fk hk hqh tfc aez pnfp hk`hqh`tfc} nfqhkg dljfzzf}}d` pndl ez d~re}d` pndl

pe kdgfphqd rechphmfc afccetp ez aez pnd rtzre}d ea `dacdmphkg fppdkphek azel pndhz tk}ddlcxzdcfphek}nhr whpn pnfp hk`hqh`tfc h} fkfpndlf pe etz ot}phmd }x}pdl+ Pnh} pxrd eaqhk`hmphqd mek`tmp h} mezze}hqd kep ekcx ea hk`hqh`tfc zhgnp} jtp mf}p} `etjp ek pndatk`fldkpfc rzdlh}d pnfp wd fzd f kfphek ea cfw} zfpndz pnfk ea ldk fk` mfkkep jdmetkpdkfkmd`+ F} hp nf} jddk }pfpd`?

YP\nd le}p `fkgdzet} rewdz ea pnd rze}dmtpez Yh}\ pnfpnd whcc rhmi rdercd pnfp nd pnhki} nd }netc` gdp#zfpndz pnfk mf}d} pnfp kdd` pe jd rze}dmtpd`+ Whpnpnd cfw jeei} ahccd` whpn f gzdfp f}}ezpldkp eamzhld}# f rze}dmtpez }pfk`} f afhz mnfkmd ea ahk`hkgfp cdf}p f pdmnkhmfc qhecfphek ea }eld fmpek pnd rfzp ea fcle}p fkxekd+ Hk }tmn f mf}d# hp h} kep fvtd}phek ea `h}meqdzhkg pnd mellh}}hek ea f mzhld fk`pndk ceeihkg aez pnd lfk wne nf} mellhppd` hp# hp h} fvtd}phek ea rhmihkg pnd lfk fk` pndk }dfzmnhkg pndcfw jeei}# ez rtpphkg hkqd}phgfpez} pe wezi# pe rhk}eld eaadk}d ek nhl+ Hp h} hk pnh} zdfcl ,, hk wnhmn pndrze}dmtpez rhmi} }eld rdz}ek wnel nd `h}chid} ez`d}hzd} pe dljfzzf}}# ez }dcdmp} }eld gzetr eatkrertcfz rdz}ek} fk` pndk ceei} aez fk eaadk}d# pnfppnd gzdfpd}p`fkgdz ea fjt}d ea rze}dmtphkg rewdz chd}+Hp h} ndzdpnfp cfw dkaezmdldkp jdmeld} rdz}ekfc# fk`pnd zdfc mzhld jdmeld} pnfp ea jdhkg tkrertcfz whpnpnd rzd`elhkfkp ez geqdzkhkg gzetr# jdhkg fppfmnd`pe pnd wzekg rechphmfc qhdw} ez jdhkg rdz}ekfccxejke~het} pe ez hk pnd wfx ea pnd rze}dmtpez nhl}dca+


3/14

Lezzh}ek q+ Ec}dk# dp fc+# 0>7 T+]+ 140# 7:> .68>>(.]mfchf# O+# @h}}dkphkg( .vtephkgpndk,Fppezkdx Gdkdzfc Zejdzp Ofmi}ek# Pnd Ad`dzfc Rze}dmtpez# F``zd}} @dchqdzd` fppnd ]dmek` Fkktfc Mekadzdkmd ea Tkhpd` ]pfpd} Fppezkdx} .Frzhc 6# 6802((+

Pnd mekmdrp ea afhzkd}} dlje`hd` hk pnd Ahapn Fldk`ldkp `td rzemd}} gtfzfkpdd h}qhecfpd` jx geqdzkldkp fmphek pnfp h} atk`fldkpfccx tkafhz ez }nemihkg pe etz pzf`hphekfc}dk}d ea ot}phmd# ]dd Ihk}dccf q+ Tkhpd` ]pfpd} d~ zdc+ ]hkgcdpek# =16 T+]+ :=0# :01.6812(# ez mek`tmp pnfp h} }e etpzfgdet} pnfp mellek kephek} ea afhzkd}} fk` `dmdkmxwetc` jd eaadk`d` wdzd ot`hmhfc rzemd}} hkqeid` pe ejpfhk f mekqhmphek fgfhk}p pndfmmt}d`+ Tkhpd` ]pfpd} q+ Zt}}dcc# 066 T+]+ 0:=# 0=6,=: .687=(+ ]mnlh`p q+ Tkhpd`]pfpd}# 624A+=` >:# 86 .:` Mhz+ 6887(+ Pnd ]dmek` Mhzmthp# f} nfqd epndz Mhzmthp}# nf}zdrdfpd`cx fmikewcd`gd` pnfp f mcfhl }ddihkg `h}lh}}fc aez etpzfgdet} geqdzkldkpfcmek`tmp kep ekcx d~h}p} jtp metc`# hk rzhkmhrcd# rzdqfhc+ ]dd# d+g+# Tkhpd` ]pfpd} q+Zfnlfk# 6>8 A+=` >> .:` Mhz+ 6888(9 Tkhpd` ]pfpd} q+ ]mnlh`p# 624 A+=` >:# 86 .:` Mhz+6887(9 Tkhpd` ]pfpd} q+ F}mdk}mhe# >7= A+:` 1=8#102 .:@ Mhz+ 68>8(9 Tkhpd` ]pfpd} q+

Ktkd,Zhe}# 1:: A+ :` 628=# 628> .:` Mhz+ 68>2(

F} afz f} wd nfqd jddk fjcd pe `dpdzlhkd# pnd rfzphmtcfzcx e`het} geqdzkldkpfcmek`tmp ndzd h}}th gdkdzh}# kdqdz nfqd jddk f``zd}}d` jx etz metzp}+ Jtp# jx fkxldf}tzhkg }pfk`fz` pnd pfzgdphkg ea fk hk`hqh`tfc jx pnd D~dmtphqd whpnetp fkx cfwdkaezmdldkp ez }dmtzhpx ot}phahmfphek# pnd zdcdkpcd}} rtz}thp ea pnfp hk`hqh`tfc jx fgeqdzkldkpfc cfw dkaezmdldkp fgdkmx hkpdkp# jdaezd fkx hkqd}phgfphek ez fmmt}fphek#trek jzhkghkg pnfp rdz}ek èwk h}# hk hp}dca# etpzfgdet} geqdzkldkpfc mek`tmp+ Fk`# pndmekqhmphek ea pnfp rdz}ek jx ldfk} ea mztmhfc rdzotzd` pd}phlekx azel f geqdzkldkpmeerdzfpez fk` rfh` aez jetkpx ntkpdz}# pnd afc}hpx ea wnhmn lt}p nfqd jddk frrfzdkp pepnd @DF fgdkp} fk` pnd rze}dmtpez}# ekcx f``} pe pnd dgzdghet}kd}}+ Pnd lfppdz ea

Tkhpd` ]pfpd} q+ Qhipez Jetp h}# hk lx zd}rdmpatc erhkhek jdaezd Pnh} Metzp fk` pndTkhpd` ]pfpd} Ad`dzfc Jfz# h} }e mezze}hqd rzdmh}dcx jdmft}d hp peei rcfmd hk pnd Tkhpd`]pfpd}# pnd tkmekpd}pd` }xljec ea `dlemzfmx# azddèl fk` ot}phmd+ Wd d~dlrchax pndrzelh}d ea pnd atptzd aez pnd wezc`+ Rechphmfccx fk` rnx}hmfccx wd }pztggcd fgfhk}pjfmiwfz` metkpzhd} èlhkfpd` jx ftpnezhpfzhfk zdghld} pnfp rze}dmtpd jf}d` trekmecez# mzdd`# zdchghek# rechphm} fk`%ez qhk`hmphqdkd}}+

Pnd pfzgdphkg ea Qhipez Jetp rtpphkg nhl hk pnd mze}},nfhz}# ea f rcfk`d}hgkd` pe `drzhqd nhl ea nh} chjdzpx fk`# whpnetp ot}phahmfphek# rze}dmtpd nhl hk fTkhpd` ]pfpd} metzpzeel# aez f kek,mzhld mekmempd` jx fgdkp} ea pnd Tkhpd` ]pfpd}

geqdzkldkp aez pnfp qdzx rtzre}d9 wf} hkhphfpd` jx pnd Kfphekfc ]dmtzhpx Fgdkmx ez pndWnhpd Net}d fk` mfzzhd` etp jx pnd Tkhpd` ]pfpd} @ztg Dkaezmdldkp Fgdkmx# aezrtzdcx rechphmfc zdf}ek}+ H zd}rdmpatccx }tggd}p# hp h} hk pnd jd}p hkpdzd}p ea etz kfphekfk` pnd `dqdcerhkg wezc` pe zdd~flhkd pnd lfppdz ea Tkhpd` ]fpd} q+ Qhipez Jetp+ ]erhphatc wf} etz metkpzx} mf}d fgfhk}p nhl pnfp jf}d` trek pnd dqh`dkmd nd }netc`nfqd jddk fmvthppd`+ Jtp# f} pnh} cdppdz whcc fppdlrp `dlek}pzfpd# Jetp# fk hkkemdkplfk# wf} `d}phkd` pe jd mzt}nd` jx chd}# kep lf`d ikewk mek}rhzfmhd} fk` rzdot`hmdjdaezd fk Fldzhmfk Otzx+ .Wd è kep hkpdk` pe }tggd}p pnfp Qhipez Jetp h} fk fkgdc+


4/14

Jtp# f} h} `h}mt}}d` jdcew# nd h} hkkemdkp ea pnd mnfzgd} ea mekqhmphek fk` dqdk @DFFgdkp Jzewk pd}phahd` pnfp nd wf}kp fwfzd ea fkx dqh`dkmd pnfp Qhipez Jetp# dqdz#hk nh} chad# hkpdk`d` pe ihcc fk Fldzhmfk(+

Lfchmd

Wndpndz ez kep pnh} rze}dmtphek ahp} whpnhk pnd kfzzew mekmdrp ea qhk`hmphqdrze}dmtphek d~pfkp hk Tkhpd` ]pfpd} mf}d cfw# pnd zdcdkpcd}} rtz}thp ea Qhipez Jetp fk`pnd fjelhkfjcd `d}hgk pe mzdfpd f mzhlhkfc mf}d fgfhk}p nhl pnfp jzhkg} nhl jdaezdpnh} Metzp aez }dkpdkmhkg h} pnd rze`tmp ea lfchmd fk` ejodmp ea rzhqfpd rechphm} }pdflhkgazel pnd pndk Wnhpd Net}d+ Pnd mf}d fgfhk}p Qhipez Jetp wf} mnezdegzfrnd` jx pnd @DF hk}tmn f wfx pnfp pndhz fgdkp} wetc` tcphlfpdcx rcfx pnd zecd ea ot`gd# otzx fk` d~dmtphekdz+Aez dqdk fk hkkemdkp rdz}ek pe jd fmvthppd` hk pnd Tkhpd` ]pfpd} Ad`dzfc Metzp ea pdzzezh}lfk` mek}rhzfmx pe ihcc Fldzhmfk ]dzqhmd Ldk fk` Weldk }pfphekd` eqdz}df} wetc` zdvthzdfk d~pzfez`hkfzx otzx wne fapdz 8%66 fzd epndzwh}d d~rdmpd` pe jd dkpzdfpd` whpn rfpzheph}laez etz geqdzkldkp} lhchpfzx mft}d+ Kew# mek}h}pdkp whpn pnd @DF `d}hgk# pnd Ot`gd h}

jetk jx cfw pe }dkpdkmd Lz+ Jetp pe ke cd}} pnfk pwdkpx ahqd xdfz} fk` re}}hjcx f} ltmn f}chad ea hkmfzmdzfphek+

Pnd lfppdz ea Tkhpd` ]pfpd} q+ Qhipez Jetp h} f nezzez aez pne}d wne ikew hp} pztd`dpfhc} d~re}d` fp pzhfc+ Pnd pztpn ea pnd lfppdz h} pnfp Qhipez Jetp wf} etp ea pnd fzl}pzfk}rezpfphek jt}hkd}} aez }dqdzfc xdfz} rzhez pe pnd hkmdrphek ea pnd ntkp aez nhl jx pnd@DF+ Pnd pztpn ea pnd lfppdz h} pnfp Qhipez Jetp nf` ke hkpdkphek} ea pzfk}rezphkg fzl} pefkx ekd hk pnh} mf}d zdgfz`cd}} ea new ltmn lekdx pnd @DF eaadzd` nhl+ Pnd pztpn ea pndlfppdz h} pnfp pnd ekcx pnhkg} pnfp Qhipez Jetp hkpdk`d` pe }dcc hk pnh} lfppdz wdzd pwe mfzgefhz rcfhk} aez ahqd lhcchek `eccfz}+ Pnd pztpn ea pnd lfppdz h} pnfp pnd @DF erdzfphqd} ikewpnd pztpn# pnfp Qhipez Jetp nf` fj}ectpdcx ke hkpdkphek} ea }dcchkg ez pzfk}rezphkg fzl} pe

pndl+ Pnd pztpn ea pnd lfppdz h} pnfp pndx ikew pnfp Qhipez Jetp h} hkkemdkp ea pnd mnfzgd} eamekqhmphek hk pnh} lfppdz# fk`pndx iddr pnh} frrfcchkg pnhkg pe pndl}dcqd}+ ]tmn h} pnt} pnd}hlrcd pztpn fk` hp h} frrfcchkg+ Chid le}p epndz pztpn}# newdqdz# wnhmn fzd }trrzd}}d` aezd~pdk`d` rdzhe`} ea phld# hp whcc dqdkptfccx dztrp fk` cdfqd f }pfhk ek etz kfphek+ Pnd lfpdzea Tkhpd` ]pfpd} q+ Qhipez Jetp h} }nfldatc fk` etpzfgdet} geqdzkldkpfc mek`tmp hk hp}pztd}p }dk}d+ Pnh} wf} f rdz}dmtphek# hk}phgfpd` fp pnd nhgnd}p cdqdc} ea pnd Tkhpd` ]pfpd}geqdzkldkp fk` wd t}d pnd pdzl rdz}dmtphek f`qh}d`cx+ Pnh} wf} ke dqdk,nfk`d`hkqd}phgfphek pe zeep etp ek,gehkg mzhlhkfc mek`tmp ez dqdk pe tkdfzpn }t}rdmpd`mzhlhkfc mek`tmp+ Hk`dd`# pndzd wf} ke hkqd}phgfphek fp fcc+ Azel pnd etp}dp# Jetpnhl}dca wf} pnd ekcx zdfc rechphmfc pfzgdp fk` hk pnd wez`} ea ekd ea nh} @DF rtz}tdz}#

ekmd nd wf} hk etz mze}},nfhz}# nd wf} gehkg `ewk+ Pnh} frpcx kfld` Erdzfphek

Zdcdkpcd}}* }dzqd` ke cdghphlfpd cfw dkaezmdldkp ez kfphekfc }dmtzhpx rtzre}d+ Pnd pzhfchk pnh} lfppdz d~re}d` pnd afmp pnfp Qhipez Jetp nf` kdqdz jddk mekqhmpd` ea# jddkfmmt}d` ea ez dqdk jddk }t}rdmpd` ea nfqhkg mellhppd` ez mek}h`dzd` pe mellhp fkxmzhld fgfhk}p pnd Tkhpd` ]pfpd} ez fkx ea hp} mhphdk} fkx wndzd hk pnd wezc`+ Etp ea}dqdzfc @DF fgdkp} hkqecqd` hk pnd ntkp aez Qhipez Jetp fqfhcfjcd pe pnd geqdzkldkpaez pd}phlekx# pnd ekcx pd}phaxhkg gdkp wne wf} mfccd`

jx pndl pd}phahd` pnfp nd wf}kp fwfzd ea fkx dqh`dkmd pnfp Qhipez Jetp# dqdz# hk nh}chad# hkpdk`d` pe ihcc fk Fldzhmfk+


5/14

Kez mfk hp jd fzgtd` whpn fkx }dk}d ea rzerzhdpx pnfp Jetp mek}phptpd` f

ldkfmd pe pnd }dmtzhpx ea pnh} metkpzx }hkmd nd nf` kdqdz hk`hmfpd` hk fkx wfx pnfp ndwf} rzd`h}re}d` pe fmphqhphd} pnfp wetc` jd `dcdpdzhet} pe pnd Tkhpd` ]pfpd} ez fkxepndz metkpzx hk pnd wezc + Pnd pzhf c zdmez` d~re}d` pnfp Jetp wf} etp ea pnd

fzl} pzfk}rezpfphek jt}hkd}} aez }dqdzfc xdfz} rzhez pe pnd hkmdrphek ea pnd@DF }phkg fgfhk}p nhl+ Hk afmp# kep ekcx nf` Lz+ Jetp kep rzd}dkpd` f ldkfmd pepnd Tkhpd` ]pfpd}# nd nf`# f`lhppd`cx jx pnd Tkhpd` ]pfpd} Geqdzkldkp# f}}h}pd` pndTkhpd` ]pfpd} hk pnh} metkpzx} hcc, f`qh}d` Hzfv wfz+ Fk`# hp wf} pnd rechphmfccxdljfzzf}}hkg zdqdcfphek ea pnd meccfjezfphek jdpwddk pnd Tkhpd` ]pfpd} lhchpfzx whpnJetp `tzhkg pnfp wfz pnfp cd`# aez rtzdcx rechphmfc zdf}ek}# pe pnd pndkf`lhkh}pzfphek} tkrzdmd`dkpd`# qdkgdatc rtz}thp ea pnh} hk`hqh`tfc jx f rdzkhmhet}mekpzhqfkmd# t}hkg aetc ldfk} kep pe rzdqdkp mzhld# jtp pe mzdfpd hp+ Gdz}nlfk#Jdkkdpp C+# Fj}mfl# pnd Ot`hmhfzx# fk` pnd Dpnhm} ea Dkpzfrldkp .68>:( RfmdCfw Afmtcpx rtjchmfphek}+

Hk }tl fk` whpnetp vtd}phek pnd geqdzkldkp} rtzre}d hk hk}phgfphkgErdzfphek Zdcdkpcd}} wf} kep pe hkqd}phgfpd ekgehkg ez fkphmhrfpd` mzhld ez pegfpndz dqh`dkmd ea }tmn wzekg`ehkg+ Hp wf} fhld` ezhghkfccx fp mzdfphkg kdwmzhld} aez pnd }fid ea jzhkghkgmzhlhkfc mnfzgd} fgfhk}p YQhipez Jetp\# wne jdaezd jdhkg hk`tmd`# wf} cfwatccx fk`rdfmdatccx lhk`hkg nh} ewk faafhz}+ Pnh}# f rzfmphmd tkhqdz}fccx mek`dlkd` hkFldzhmfk metzp}+ ]dd# d+g+# Tkhpd` ]pfpd} q+ Pwhgg# 4>> A+:` =7= .=z` Mhz+ 687>(9Rdercd q+ H}ffm}ek# 00 K+X+:` 466 .687>( .eqdzzh`hkg `d}hzd aez mekqhmphek qhecfpd}`td rzemd}} wndzd rechmd wdzd }ecdcx hkpdzd}pd` hk fzzd}phkg f }rdmhahm `dadk`fkpzfpndz pnfk pe rzdqdkp atzpndz mzhld ez rzepdmp pnd rertcfmd+(9 Tkhpd` ]pfpd} q+Jegfzp# 7>= A+:` 60:> .8pn Mhz+ 68>1(9 Tkhpd` ]pfpd} q+ Zflhzd# 762 A+:` 4=4.68>=(+ ]hlrcx rtp# Erdzfphek Zdcdkpcd}} wf} mekmdhqd` fk` hlrcdldkpd` aez pndaeccewhkg rtzre}d pe ctzd Qhipez Jetp hkpe f jt}hkd}} lddphkg etp }h`d eaZt}}hf# pe mnfzgd nhl whpn f @DF mekmempd` mzhld# pe pndk pwh}p pnd mekmempd`mzhld pe ahp f ad`dzfc mzhlhkfc }pfptpd# pe mzdfpd ez lfktafmptzd Tkhpd` ]pfpd}Otzh}`hmphek# pe d~pzf`hpd nhl pe pnd Tkhpd` ]pfpd} fk` pe rcfmd nhl jdaezd fkFldzhmfk Otzx whpn hcct}ezx mnfzgd} ea pdzzezh}l fhld` fgfhk}p Fldzhmfk}+

Pnd Afmp}

@d}rhpd Jetp} nfqhkg jddk }tjodmp pe Tkhpd` Kfphek} }fkmphek} }hkmd :226 f}f mek}dvtdkmd ea nh} zdrtpfp hek f} fk fzl} `dfcdz# }pfzphkg hk cfpd :22= Jetp,ewkd` ezJetp,mekpzeccd` melrfkhd} nf` mekpzfmp} acxhkg hk pdkp}# aee`# fk` epndz }trrchd} aezTkhpd` ]pfpd} ahzl} wezihkg aez pnd Tkhpd` ]pfpd} lhchpfzx hk Hzfv# hkmct`hkg f cfzgdmekpzfmp pe acx }trrchd} aez Idccegg# Jzewk# fk` Zeep# f }tj}h hfzx ea Nfcchjtzpek#pnd melrfkx ekmd ztk jx Qhmd Rzd}h`dkp Mndkdx+ Jetp melrfkhd} fc}e acdw aez T]Fhz Aezmd} Fhz Lejhchpx Mellfk`+ .Afzfn# @etgcf} fk` Jzftk# ]pdrndk+ Ldzmnfkpea @dfpn+ Whcdx+ :227+(


6/14

Melldkmhkg hk Lfx :220# pndzd wdzd kdw}rfrdz zdrezp} pnfp Jetp azekp,melrfkhd} wdzd }trrcxhkg pnd Tkhpd` ]pfpd} lhchpfzx hk Hzfv+ Aez d~flrcd ek Lfx 67#:220# pnd Ahkfkmhfc Phld} zdrezpd` pnfp lfkx ea pnd rcfkd} `dchqdzhkg }trrchd} pe Tkhpd`]pfpd} pzeer} hk Hzfv wdzd fmptfccx ewkd` jx f Zt}}hfk kfld` Qhmpez Jetp# zdrtpd`cxpnd wezc } cfzgd}p hccdgfc fzl} `dfcdz+ Pnd aeccewhkg `fx @drtpx ]dmzdpfzx ea ]pfpd

Zhmnfz` Fzlhpzfgd fk` @drtpx ]dmzdpfzx ea @dadk}d Rftc Wecaewhp wdzd mfccd` jdaezdpnd ]dkfpd Aezdhgk Zdcfphek} Mellhppdd fk` wdzd f}id` ha pnd Ahkfkmhfc Phld} zdrezpwf} pztd+ Hkmzd`hjcx# jepn rzead}}d` f cfmi ea ikewcd`gd ek pnd }tjodmp# }mfzmdcxhk`hmfphkg pnfp pndx wdzd dqdk aflhchfz whpn pnd kfld Jetp# jtp hk`hmfpd` pnfp pndxwetc` ceei hkpe pnd lfppdz+ Pwe wddi} cfpdz# pnd ]pfpd @drfzpldkp kephahd` pndMellhppdd pnfp ]pfpd} rzdchlhkfzx zd}dfzmn hkpe Jetp} mekkdmphek whpn Hzfv azdhgnpmekpzfmp} wf} kdgfphqd+ Kep tkphc }dqdk lekpn} fapdz pnfp `h @drtpx ]dmzdpfzx ea@dadk}d Wecaewhp gzt`ghkgcx f`lhp# whpnetp fkx `dpfhc fk` whpnetp d~rcfkfphek# jtpwhpn lf~hltl daaezp pe `h}pfkmd pnd @dadk}d @drfzpldkp azel Jetp# pnfp T+]+ Fzlxmekpzfmpez} `h` tphchd fhzmzfap ewkd` jx melrfkhd} f}}emhfpd` whpn Jetp+

Hk Otcx# :220# jf}d` ek fccdgfphek} pnfp Jetp nf` pzfaahmid` hk wdfrek} hk wfzzfqfgd` Chjdzhf# pnd Eaahmd ea Aezdhgk F}}dp} Mekpzec .EAFM( whpnhk pnd @drfzpldkpea pnd Pzdf}tzx rcfmd` nhl ek pnd ]rdmhfccx @d}hgkfpd` Kfphekfc} ch}p wnhmn rzenhjhpd`fkx pzfk}fmphek} jdpwddk Jetp fk` fkx T+]+ kfphekfc+ Pnd rtkhphqd fmphek} wdzd jf}d`ek Jetp'} rtzrezpd`cx kepezhet} Chjdzhf wdfrek} pzfk}gzd}}hek}# jtp# hk fkketkmhkg pndEAFM fmp hek# pnd Pzdf}tzx @drfzpldkp }pzd}}d` fkepndz tkrzeqdk fccdgfphekmekmdzkhkg f afmdp ea Jetp'} fccdgd` fmphqhphd}# kephkg pnfp nd lf`d $42 lhcchek hk rzeahp}azel fzl} pzfk}adz} pe pnd Pfchjfk wndk pnd zdghld wf} ne}phkg E}flf jhk Cf`dk fk`Fc Vfd`f+

Hk acfgzfkp `h}zdgfz` ea pnd T+K+ }fkmphek} fk` EAFM} rcfmdldkp ea QhipezJetp ek pnd ]rdmhfccx @d}hgkfpd` Kfphekfc} ch}p# pnd Tkhpd` ]pfpd} lhchpfzx mekphktd` penhzd Jetp} melrfkhd} aez Hzfv }trrcx achgnp}+ Ekd Jetp azekp melrfkx fcekd h}d}phlfpd` pe nfqd lf`d fjetp 6#222 achgnp} hkpe Tkhpd` ]pfpd} mekpzeccd` fhz jf}d} hk Hzfvjx pnd dk` ea :220 `tzhkg wnhmn phld pnd Tkhpd` ]pfpd} lhchpfzx gfqd fp cdf}p 422#222gfccek} ea azdd fhzrcfkd atdc pe Jetp} rhcep} fk` Tkhpd` ]pfpd} geqdzkldkp mekpzfmpez}rfh Jetp,mekpzeccd` melrfkhd} zetgncx $12 lhcchek pe acx }trrchd} hkpe Hzfv+ .Afzfn#@etgcf} fk` Jzftk# ]pdrndk+ Ldzmnfkp ea @dfpn+ Whcdx+ :227+( Jtp# ek Ofktfzx :=#:221# hp wf} zdrezpd` pnfp# Pnd Kdw Zdrtjchm nf} cdfzkd` pnfp pnd @dadk}d @drfzpldkpnf} cfzgdcx ptzkd` f jchk` dxd pe Yrtzrezpd` fzl} `dfcdz\ Jetp} fmphqhphd} fk` nf}

mekphktd` pe }trrcx nhl whpn mekpzfmp}# hk qhecfphek ea Ypnd EAFM `d}hgkfphek\ fk``d}rhpd pndafmp pnfp epndz# lezd cdghphlfpd fhz mfzzhdz} fzd fqfhcfjcd+ Pe `fpd# pndzd nf} jddk kertjchm hkvthzx hkpe pnd T+]+ @dadk}d @drfzpldkp} `dmh}hek pe mekphktd whpn pndhzzdcfphek}nhr whpn Jetp} melrfkhd} hk qhecfphek ea EAFM} ztcd}+


7/14

F} f zd}tcp ea pnd dljfzzf}}hkg Kdw Zdrtjchm `h}mce}tzd ea pnd hkmelrdpdkmd ,ez wez}d , ea pnd @drfzpldkp} ea @dadk}d fk` ]pfpd hk pndhz `dfchkg} whpn Jetp#}e ldekd hk pnd geqdzkldkp `dmh d` hp wf} phld pe gdp Qhipez Jetp+ Wndpndz pndlep hqfphek aez pnh} wf} rfx jfmi aez pnd dljfzzf}}ldkp pnfp Jetp nf` mft}d`pnd Jt}n geqdzkldkp ez# aez rechphmfc zdf}ek}# pe mzdfpd f }mfrdgefp pe `dacdmp

fppdkphek azel pnd geqdzkldkp} tk}ddlcx zdcfphek}nhr whpn pnh} fccdgd` Ldzmnfkp ea@dfpn , pnh} rtzrezpd` azhdk` ea Jdk Cf`dk fk` pnd Pfchjfk , h} kep mcdfz+ Jtp wnfp h}mzx}pfc mcdfz h} pnfp hp }dzqd` ke cdghphlfpd cfw dkaezmdldkp rtzre}d+ Aez# pe pnfp rehkphk phld Jetp nf` mellhppd` ke mzhld fgfhk}p pnd Tkhpd` ]pfpd} kez nf` nd mellhppd`fkx fmp ez lf`d fkx }pfpdldkp pnfp hk`hmfpd` pnfp nd dqdk mekpdlrcfpd` mellhpphkg}tmn f mzhld+

Pnt} jdgfk pnd rtz}thp ea Qhipez Jetp pnfp tcphlfpdcx }rfwkd` ErdzfphekZdcdkpcd}} `d}hgkd` }rdmhahmfccx pe dkpzfr Jetp fk` `dchqdz nhl pe pnd Tkhpd` ]pfpd} aezmzhlhkfc rze}dmtphek `d}hgkd` aez hkdqhpfjcd mekqhmphek fk` chad cekg hkmfzmdzfphek+ Hk cfpd:227# pndk @drtpx F}}h}pfkp pe pnd Rzd}h`dkp fk` @drtpx Kfphekfc ]dmtzhpx F`qh}ezOtfk _fzfpd jd}pewd` pnd mnfccdkgd pe mfrptzd Qhipez Jetp pe pnd T+]+ @ztgDkaezmdldkp F`lhkh}pzfphek+ Fk`# f} Lhmnfdc Jzftk# pnd aezldz mnhda ea erdzfphek} aezpnd T+]+ @ztg Dkaezmdldkp F`lhkh}pzfphek# `dmcfhld`# ekmd YJetp\ wf} hk etz mze}},nfhz}# nd wf} gehkg èwk+ Pnd tk`dzcxhkg rcfk wf} }hlrcd+ F} `d}mzhjd` jx Ceth}Lhchekd# pnd @DF }trdzqh}ez wne wf} hk mnfzgd ea pnd ntkp aez Jetp# *Wd adcp pnfpwd metc` mzdfpd f }mdkfzhe pnfp wetc` rtcc nhl hk+* Pnd rcfk wf} pe *rtcc* Jetp etp eaLe}mew whpn fk hkqdkpd` ntgd fzl} `dfc nd metc`k'p zdat}d# h+d+# f 6: lhcchek èccfzpzfk}fmphek+ .12 Lhktpd} hkpdzqhdw ea _fzfpd# Jzftk fk` Lhchekd# 66%:6%:262+(Fmmez`hkgcx# pnd mzhld `d}mzhjd` hk pnd hk}pfkp hk`hmpldkp wf} mzdfpd` etp ea wnecdmcepn fk` mfzdatccx }mzhrpd` pe afmhfccx jtp afc}dcx rzeqh`d otzh}`hmphek pe pnd Tkhpd`]pfpd} metzp }x}pdl fk` d~re}d Jetp pe repdkphfc chad hlrzh}ekldkp aez kek,d~h}pdkpmzhld}+

Newdqdz# kepwhpn}pfk`hkg pnd jd}p daaezp} ea pnd @DF hk mekmemphkg fkdcfjezfpd }mndld pe hk`tmd Qhipez Jetp hkpe pnd mellh}}hek ea f mzhld aez wnhmn ndmetc` jd rze}dmtpd` hk pnd Tkhpd` ]pfpd}# pnd hkqd}pldkp hk lhcchek} ea èccfz} hk pnd}mndld# pnd t}d fk` rfxldkp ea lhcchek} pe rzead}}hekfc hkaezldz} fk` jetkpx ntkpdz}#pndl}dcqd} hkpdzkfphekfc `ztg `dfcdz}# fk` pnd dkphmdldkp ea eaadz} ea ltcph,lhcchekèccfz rzeahp} hk fzl} pe Jetp# Jetp zdat}d` pnd geqdzkldkp} jcfk`h}nldkp} fk``dmchkd` pe jd }d`tmd` hkpe eaadzhkg# jzeidzhkg ez `dchqdzhkg wdfrek} pe pnd ahmphphet}AFZM ldljdz} mzdfpd` jx pnd @DF }mzhrp wzhpdz}+ Ek Keqdljdz 1pn# :227# f rfh` aezgeqdzkldkp erdzfphqd# Lhid ]kew# zdfmnd} etp pe Fk`zdw ]ltcchfk# fk f}}emhfpd eaQhipez Jetp# whpn fk eaadz ea f rzere}d` fzl} dfc aez Qhipez Jetp+ Dhgnpddk `fx}fapdz# ek Keqdljdz :0pn# jx wfx ea f ldlezhfchd` D,Lfhc melltkhmfphek}

hkpze`tmd` f} dqh`dkmd fp pzhfc# Lhid ]kew fk` pnd @DF fgdkp} zdmdhqd azel]ltcchfk# Jetp} fk}wdz hk mekkdmphek pe pnd rzere}d` fzl} `dfc ,, Jezh} }hptfphekkep }e gee`+ .Pzhfc D~nhjhp 6066( Ek Keqdljdz :4

pn# :227 Lhid ]kew fk` pnd @DFfgdkp} zdmdhqd f afccew,tr D,Lfhc azel ]ltcchfk hk mekkdmphek pe pnd @DF eaadz aezfk fzl} `dfc+ pndzd frrdfz} pe jd f cep ea jt}hkd}} errezptkhphd}kepnhkg hkgzdx hpdl} pnetgnpnd lfk nhl}dca h} }dcchkg rzerdzphd} f} pnd lfhk hkmeld#

whpn jzfkmnd} hk fcc `haadzdkp }pfpd}+ .Pzhfc D~nhjhp 606:( Fapdz tkzdcdkphkg D,Lfhc} azel ]kew pe ]ltcchfk hkpdk`hkg pe ctzd Jetp hkpe pnd @DF rzere}d`


8/14

fzl} `dfc# ]ltcchfk rtp} hk rcfhk wez`} pe ]kew fk` pnd @DF fgdkp} Jezh}nf` whpn`zfwk fk` nf` jddk pec` pe whpn`zfw .Pzhfc D~nhjhp 60=8( Pndpzhfc zdmez` lf`d mcdfz pnfp pnd @DF fgdkp} hk pnh} mf}d tr pe pnh} rehkp nf` jddkkephahd` ek fp cdf}p pnzdd }drfzfpd emmf}hek} hk pnfp Qhipez Jetp wf} kephkpdzd}pd` fk`%ez kep fjcd pe dkgfgd hk pnd jt}hkd}} ea fzl}+

Ha pndzd nf` jddk f le`hmtl ea gee` afhpn ek pnd @DF} rfzp# pnd erdzfphekwetc nfqd mekmct`d` fp pnfp rehkp+ Jtp# pnh} nezzh`# zdcdkpcd}} rtz}thp wdkp ek }hlrcxjx }whpmnhkg pnd fzl} `dfc pe pnd afz lezd jdkhgk }tggd}phek pnfp Jetp lhgnp jd fjcdpe }dcc kep fzl} jtp fhzrcfkd}+ Fk` hp wf} pnh} cfppdz rzdlh}d jx wnhmn pnd @DF ctzd`Jetp pe Pnfhcfk`+ Ek @dmdljdz :k`# fapdz melltkhmfphkg whpn Lhid ]kew# Fk`zdw]ltchfk# kephahd} Qhipez Jetp jx D,Lfhc pnfp }fld hk`hqh`tfc} wne fzd hkpdzd}pd` hkfzl} fzd fc}e hkpdzd}pd` fk` fzd hk rzemd}} ea rtzmnf}hkg mfzge fhzrcfkd} aez cfzgd}tl} ea mf}n+ ]ltcchfk wzepd pe Jetp,, Lhid ]kew }ec` Fkpekeq 6: azelLec`fqhf pe rdercd azel Mdkpzfc ]etpn Fldzhmf+ H fl kep }tzd d~fmpcx wndzd+

Pndx rfh` mf}n pe nhlpnd }fld mchdkp kew wfkp} fcc dvthrldkpHp }ddl} pndxfzd zdf`x pe rf}} lfoez atk`hkg pe nhl ha wd mfk mekqhkmd pndl pnfp wd mfk

}trrcxRe}}hjcd pnh} ldfk} `dchqdzx f} wdcc+ ]e wd nfqd pe mekqhkmd pndl pnfp

wd mfk `dchqdz# f} wdcc# }hkmd H mfkp hlfghkd new pndx whcc gdp pnd gee`} pe

}eldwndzd hk pnfp zdghek .Pzhfc D~nhjhp A# 6=41 fk` 6=4>(+ ]e wnhcd pnd @DFnf` pndhz ewk `d}hgk aez Qhipez Jetp# ]ltcchfk hk pnh} D,Lfhc etp, chkd` pe QhipezJetp pndhz ewk zt}d pe mekqhkmd pnd repdkphfc rtzmnf}dz} pnfp Jetp mfk }trrcx fk`pe mekqhkmd pndl pnfp nd mfk `dchqdz hk ez`dz aez pnd pwe pe zdmdhqd lfoezatk`hkg+ F pwe wfx zdfc chad mek,gfld jdgfk fp pnh} rehkp+ @DF erdzfphqd} wdzd}pzhkghkg Jetp fcekg whpn f rze}rdmp ea rtzmnf}hkg nh} fhzrcfkd} aez $4+222+222+22 pectzd nhl etp ea Zt}}hf fk` pe pzfr nhl hkpe pnd @DF erdzfphqd} hkhphfpd` `h}mt}}hek

fjetp fkph,Fldzhmf# Fldzhmfk} fk` fzl}+ Jetp# ek pnd epndz nfk`# wf} }pzhkghkg pnd@DF erdzfphqd} fcekg whpn f rze}rdmp aez fk fzl} `dfc }e pnfp nd mfk `tlr ek pndlpnd pwe mfzge fhzrcfkd} pnfp nd nf` meccdmphkg `t}p hk Mekge+

Pndzd wdzd mzhphmfc `haadzdkmd} jdpwddk pnd pwe }h`d} ea pnh} mek,gfld#newdqdz+ Qhipez Jetp `h kep ikew wne nd wf} `dfchkg fk` wnfp pndhz pztd hkpdkphek}wdzd+ Pnd @DF fgdkp}# newdqdz# ikdw wdcc wne pndx wdzd `dfchkg whpn fk` pnfp nd#Jetp# wf} kep fjcd }dcc fk` `dchqdz fzl} pe pndl+ Ek @dmdljdz =z`# }tj}dvtdkp pe pndfjeqd D,Lfhc}# wndzd ]ltcchfk fk` Jetp fgzdd pe rzemdd` whpn pnd rzegzfl etpchkd`hk pndhz zd}rdmphqd D,Lfhc}# ]ltchfk mezzd}rek`} whpn ]kew# f @DF frezfphqd fp pnd

phld,, Nh# }ezzx H cdap pnd d,lfhc# zt}nd` etp pe f lddphkg+ ]reid pe Jezh} fk`fkxpnhkg h} re}}hjcd whpn afzlhkg dvthrldkp+ H ot}p kdd` pe rf}} }eld }ptaa eaa penhl zdadzdkmhkg wnfp wd fzd `ehkg ndzd# wnhmn whcc pfid ld tr pe Pntz}`fx+

Fk` pndk H whcc }dd new wd mfk erdzfpd# fk` wd mfk pfid }eld rcfk fk` }dk`

hpH `ekp pnhki nd mfk leqd }ptaa fzetk`# jtp hp lfx jd pnfp nd mfk gdp nh}

nfk`} ek hpdl} wnhmn xet zdvthzd+ Pnd @DF fgdkp} fgfhk,fp cdf}p aez pnd aetzpnphld, fzd kephahd` jx pnd fjeqd D,Lfhc pnfp Qhipez Jetp mfk kep fk` whcc kep leqdfzl}+ Fk`# pnfp hp h} ekcx kew fapdz pnd rze}rdmp ea }dcchkg nh} mfzge rcfkd}# lfx jd


9/14

pnfp nd mfk gdp nh} nfk`} ek hpdl} wnhmn xet zdvthzd+

Fcc pnzetgnetp pnd pzfk}mzhrp} ea mek}dk}tfc zdmez`hkg} fk` whzd pfr}hkpze`tmd` fp pzhfc pnd @DF erdzfphqd} hkaezl ]ltcchfk fk` Jetp pnfp pnd$4+222+222+22 aez pnd rcfkd} h} zdf`x pe jd nfk`d` eqdz pe Jetp f} }eek f} nd fzzhqd}+

Pnd @DF erdzfphqd} hkaezl ]ltcchfk ek Adjztfzx 0pn

# pnfp pndx kdd` f cep eafhzmzfap+ hp} aez pnd }fld gzetr# jtp hp} aez pnd gzetr pnfp lfkfgd} pnd

`ztg}# xet ikew# pnfp pndx kdd` f cep ea fhzmzfap }eldphld}# f cep ea fhzmzfap# f cep

ea mfrfmhpx+ Fk` pnfp} wnx H fl wezihkg f cep hk Gnfkf zhgnp kew ea Pndxhkaezl Jetp pnfp fcc nd nf} pe è h} meld fk` gdp pnd lekdx aez pnd rcfkd} whpnetpnfqhkg pe è fkxpnhkg fjetp pnd nfz` }ptaa# zdadzzhkg pe pnd fzl}+ Pnd erdzfphqd}}tmmd}}atccx fmpd` `hl whppd` fk` `d}rdzfpd pe gdp zh` ea pnd ahqd lhcchek èccfz} aezpnd fhz rcfkd} pnfp pndx `d}mzhjd` f} kdmd}}fzx aez pndhz `ztg pzf`d+ Pndx tzgd` Jetppe meld fk` gdp pnd lekdx aez pnd rcfkd}+ Pnd erdzfphqd}# fcc pnd wfx pnzetgn f @DF}mzhrp rcfxd` f rdzadmp }tmidz pe mfpmn f }tmidz+

Ek Lfzmn 1pn

# :22># wndk Jetp fzzhqd` pe Pnfhcfk` aez pnd @DF fzzfkgd`lddphkg whpn ekcx pwe mfzge fhz rcfkd jzemntzd} fk` ke epndz }rdmhahmfphek}rdzpfhkhkg pe pnd fzl} rzdqhet}cx `h}mt}}d` whpn fk` zdvtd}pd` eaa ]ltcchfk fk` Jetpnd wf} hlld`hfpdcx dkgfgd` jx pnd @DF erdzfphqd} hk f wdcc }mzhrpd` `hfcegtd pnfpwetc` hkdqhpfjcx cdf` f rze}rdmphqd Fldzhmfk otzez pe f jchk` zfgd fgfhk}p pnd fmmt}d`hk pnh} mf}d fk` tcphlfpdcx pe mekqhmphek+ Pnd @DF fgdkp} wne mzdfpd` pnh} }mdkfzheikdw wdcc pnfp f jf}hm rzhkmhrcd ea lfzidphkg wetc` nfqd Jetp oehk hkpe pnd mnezt} eafkph,Fldzhmfkh}l hkhphfpd` jx pnd erdzfphqd}+ Jetp# fk` epndz }hlhcfzcx }hptfpd`hk`hqh`tfc} dqdk pne}d whpn ke ldk} zdf# wetc` }fx fkxpnhkg fp pnfp rehkp pe zdmdhqdpnd ahqd lhcchek èccfz zdwfz` aez pwe mfzge rcfkd} pnfp wdzd wezpn ltmn cd}}+ HkJetp} lhk` pndk fk` kew nd `h` kepnhkg wzekg ez hccdgfc+ Dqdk ha nd ldfkp

dqdzxpnhkg nd }fh` fjetp Fldzhmf ez Fldzhmfk}# nd wf} d~dzmh}hkg nh} atk`fldkpfczhgnp pe azdd }rddmn+ Nd `h` kep ikew jfmi pndk pnfp nd wf} jdhkg pzfrrd` hkpe }fxhkgfwatc pnhkg} fjetp Fldzhmfk} aez pnd }ecd rtzre}d ea rzdot`hmhkg nhl hk pnd dxd} ea fkFldzhmfk otzx+ Aez hk nh} lhk`# nd adcp pndk f} nd addc} kew pnfp nd wf} kepmellhpphkg f mzhld fgfhk}p fkx rdz}ek ez metkpzx aez }dcchkg pwe rcfkd}# fk` ha pndrtzmnf}dz} ea pnd rcfkd} wfkpd` rzelh}d} ea f rze}rdmphqd fzl} `dfc# Jetp# f Zt}}hfkmhphdk# metc` kep nfqd ikewk fk` `h` kep ikew pnfp chr }dzqhmd fcekd whpnetp fk eqdzpfmp mfk nfqd nhl d~pzf`hpd` fk` rze}dmtpd` fk` hkmfzmdzfpd` aez chad hk pnd Tkhpd`]pfpd}+ Hk pnd ldkpfchpx ea fk dk`tzhkg Zt}}hfk mhphdk azel Zt}}hf# wndzd AFZM h}kep `d}hgkfpd` f} f pdzzezh}p ezgfkhfphek# Qhipez Jetp mellhppd` ke mzhld jxhkpdk`hkg pe }dcc mfzge rcfkd} pe pnd AFZM fk` nd mellhppd` ke mzhld jdmft}d ea nh}zndpezhm ek Lfzmn 1pn# :22>+ Nd `h` kepnhkg hk atzpndzfkmd ea pnd zdvtd}p} lf`d jxpnd erdzfphqd} `tzhkg pnd Lfzmn 1pn# :22> lddphkg d~mdrp pe pfid f adw nfk` wzhppdkkepd} pe }e f} kep pe frrdfz melrcdpdcx `h}hkpdzd}pd` hk pnd fzl} `dfc+

Newdqdz# wndk ek Lfzmn 1pn `tzhkg pnd ahkfc lddphkg pnd erdzfphqd} wfkpd` peaf}pdk pnd h}}td ea Jetp} hkpdkp ek pnd rzere}d` fzl} `dfc# Jetp} zdmez`d` fk`pzfk}mzhjd` zd}rek}d} lf`d hp mcdfz pnfp nd wf} kep jdkp ek gehkg pnzetgn whpn pndfzl} `dfc jtp wf} zfpndz }pfcchkg pndl tkphc nd wf} gehkg pe gdp rfh` aez pnd rcfkd}+


10/14

Qhipez Jetp kdqdz mellhppd` pe fk fzl} `dfc+ Qhipez Jetphp} `haahmtcppnfp}wnx H nfqd pe cdfqd# ezgfkhd pnd }pezxpnhkg} fzd whpnjtp rdercd nfqd peH

nfqd pe cdfqd lx metkpzx pe è hpH nfqd pe mekqhkmd pnd lhkh}pdz ea `dadk}d pe

}hgk pnd rfrdz fk` pe ghqd ld fk eaahmhfc pe pnd `d}phkfphek pe è pnd mekpzfmp# H

nfqd pe rfx eaahmhfccx rfx rfzp ea pnd lekdx ea metkpzxahz}p meld} pe }hgk fcc

rfrdz} pnfp wd kdd`+ Fc}e# wd kdd` fk eaahmhfc wne whcc ge fk` H ikew pe metkpzxpe }hgk pnd mekpzfmphp} f jhp rechphmfc# f jhp melldzmhfc# f jhp hkpdcchgdkpHp}

qdzx `haahmtcp pe }rdfi pe rdercd pe kdgephfpd# jtp hp} re}}hjcdPnfp} wnx wdzd

gehkg pe fkfcxd wndzd @DF erdzfphqd ,,Wnfp rzhmd}New ltmn lekdx èxet kdd`5 Qhipez JetpH èkp ikew+ H èkp ikewjtp H èkp ikewkewf`fx}+ Pwe ez pnzdd xdfz} fge pndzd wdzd+ H nfqd pe ge etp# pfci# pe }dd wnfp

pndx lfktafmptzdH èkp ikew+ H èkp ikew+ Jdmft}d wd nfqd pe ge etp#

kdgephfpd# pe }dd wnfp} hk d~h}pdkmd# fc}e pnd phldha wd mfk vthmicxJdmft}d#

ch}pdk# cdp} è pnd aeccewhkg# rzdrfzd f rcfk+ Eifx# wdzd gehkg pe ge etp pe

`h}mt}} pnd pnhkg} ea pnd }fld phld+ Rcdf}d# }pfzphkg# whpn pnd ahz}p ekd}# whcc rtp

hk pnd fhzrcfkd} pe jdghk fmphqhpx @DF erdzfphqd@e xet kdd` lekdx aez

pnd fhzrcfkd}5 Qhipez JetpXd} @DF erdzfphqdAhz}p ea fcc# eifx# fcc zhgnp

ke rzejcdl+ Fk` wdcc }pfzp whpn pnfp @DF erdzfphqdè xet pnhki wd mfk

}pfzp erdzfphkg hk = lekpn} ez jdaezd = lekpn}+ Qhipez JetpJdaezd @DF

erdzfphqdNew ltmn phld jdaezd5 Qhipez JetpH èkp ikew# jtp wdcc è

}eldpnhkg pegdpndz+ Pnd Lfzmn 1pn# :22> mekqdz}fphek rdzpfhkhkg pe pnd rzere}d`fzl} `dfc jdpwddk Qhipez Jetp fk` pnd @DF erdzfphqd} rzdpdk`hkg pe jd AFZM wf}afzmhmfc fk` ejqhet}cx cfmihkg hk zdfchpx aez jepn }h`d}+ Qhipez Jetp `h kep zdmdhqdkez `h` nd dqdk f}i aez f khmidc aez pnd fzl}+ Hk lx fècd}mdkp xdfz} H nf`d~rdzhdkmd` fk` whpkd}}d` lezd zdfc kdgephfphek} ek Jzeeicxk rcfx gzetk`} jdpwddkih`} pzf`hkg jf}djfcc mfz`}+

Pnd }pfcihkg ea Qhipez Jetp mekphktd` hkpe pnd pzhfc+ Pnd mnfzgd} fgfhk}p Jetpwdzd jeppeld` ek pnd geqdzkldkp} f}}dzphek `tzhkg pzhfc pnfp hk pnd dfzchd}p }pfgd eapnd dqdkp}# `tzhkg f lddphkg ea pnd pwe hk Le}mew# Jetp fk` Fk`zdw ]ltchfk nf`hlld`hfpdcx dkpdzd` hkpe f mek}rhzfmx# h+d+# pndx nf` hlld`hfpdcx fgzdd`# fp pnfpLe}mew lddphkg pe rzeqh`d fzl}# hkmct`hkg lh}}hcd}# pe pnd AFZM fk` pnfp fcc pnddk}thkg dqdkp} wdzd pfidk hk atzpndzfkmd ea pnfp tkcfwatc fgzddldkp+ Pnd rze}dmtphekfp pzhfc fzgtd`?

]e wnfp pnfp ldfk} h} pnfp# wndpndz ezkep pnd ahkfc pdzl} ea pnd `dfc whpn pnd

hkaezlfkp} wdzd dqdzkfhcd` èwk èd}k'p dqdk cdgfccx lfppdz#wnfp lfppdz} h} wndpndz Jetp fk` ]ltchfk#wndpndz pndx fgzdd` whpn dfmn epndz perzeqh`d wdfrek} pe pnd AFZM+


11/14

Fk` pnd dqh`dkmd eqdzwndclhkgcx }new}pnfp hk afmp pndx `h`+ Pndx fgzdd` whpndfmn epndz hk Le}mew peè pnd wdfrek} `dfc+ Fk` pndk# aez pnd kd~p}h~ wddi}# pndx peei }pdr} hk atzpndzfkmd ea

pndhz fgzddldkp perzeqh`d wdfrek} pe pnd AFZM# }pdr}}newhkg pnd }dzhet}kd}} ea pndhzrtzre}d hk pnh} fgzddldkp+

Hp wf} Qhipez Jetp} re}hphek# pe pnd mekpzfzx# pnfp nd nf` kep fgzdd` whpn]ltchfk pe }dcc fzl} pe pnd AFZM9 pnfp nd nf` ke hkpdkphek ea rzeqh`hkg wdfrek}+Zfpndz# pnfp nd nf` fgzdd` whpn ]ltchfk ekcx pe fppdlrp pe }dcc rcfkd} pe pnd ldklf}vtdzf`hkg f} AFZM# f rze}rdmp pnfpnf` jddk hkodmpd` hkpe pnd }mdkfzhe jx pnd @DF }mzhrp wzhpdz} wndk hp wf} lf`d mcdfz pepndl pnfp Jetp nf` zdodmpd` pndhz fppdlrp} pe dk}kfzd nhl hk hccdgfc fzl} pzfaahmihkg+Fk`# pnfp fcc pnd }pfpdldkp} lf`d jx Jetp pe AFZM wdzd ldzdcx aez pnd rtzre}d ea nh}`d}hzd pe daadmptfpd pnd fhzrcfkd fgzddldkp jx lfihkg hp }ddl pnfp pnd rcfkd} wdzdkdmd}}fzx pe mfzzx etp pnd tkhkpdk`d` fzl} pzfk}fmphek+ Pnd dqh dkmd }trrezphkg Jetp}re}hphek h} mcdfz fk` kep `drdk`dkp ek pnd }dca, }dzqhkg pd}phlekx ea ]ltchfk ez pndgeqdzkldkp jfmid` jetkpx ntkpdz}+

Pnt}# pnd}hkd vtf kek# pnd d}}dkphfc hkgzd`hdkp# ea pnd geqdzkldkp} mf}d pnfpnf` pe jd rzeqd` jdxek` f zdf}ekfjcd# wf} dkpzfkmd hkpe f mek}rhzfmx fp pnd Le}mewlddphkg fk` aez pnh} pndx zdchd` ek pnd pd}phlekx ea ]ltchfk+ Jtp ]ltchfk} pd}phlekxek pnh} }mezd wf} }hlrcx kep pztd fk`# f} `h}mt}}d` jdcew# fp pnd qdzx cdf}p pndrze}dmtpez} }netc nfqd ikewk pnfp ek pnh} }mezd ]ltchfk chd`+

F} pnd pd}phlekx fp pzhfc `dlek}pzfpd`# pnd @DF hkhphfpd` Erdzfphek Zdcdkpcd}}jx nfqhkg Lhmnfdc ]kew# f rfh` hkaezlfkp# mekpfmp ]ltchfk# pdcc nhl pnfp nd# ]kew# nf`mt}peldz} wne wfkpd` pe rtzmnf}d fzl} aez mf}n fk` pnfp nd wfkpd` ]ltchfk pefrrzefmn Qhipez Jetp whpn pnh} rzere}hphek+ Pnd frrzefmn wf} lf`d# jtp zfpndz pnfkotlrhkg fp pnd rtzrezpd` errezptkhpx pe jd hkqecqd` hk hccdgfc wdfrek} pzfaahmihkg# pe pnd@DF} mek}pdzkfphek Jetp zdodmpd` pnd eaadz# }pfphkg pnfp nd wf} kep hkqecqd` hk gzfxhpdl} , hccdgfc fzl} pzfk}fmphek , pnfp nd nf` jddk ez`dzd` jx pnd Zt}}hfk geqdzkldkp#pnd Lepndzcfk` f} nd rtp hp# pe whpn`zfw azel pnfp pxrd ea fmphqhpx+ Pnh} `h}frrehkphkghkaezlfphek wf} d,lfhcd` pe ]kew wne rf}}d` pnd hkaezlfphek ek pe nh} @DF nfk`cdz}+Pnd `d}pztmphqd daadmp pnfp pnh} d,lfhc nf} ek pnd geqdzkldkp} fmmt}fphek} h}

lfkhad}pd` hk pnd pd}phlekhfc zdfmphek ea pnd @DF fgdkp zd}rek}hjcd aez }fadgtfz`hkgpnd èmtldkpfzx dqh dkmd fk` lekhpezhkg ]kew} fmphqhphd}+ Nd }hlrcx pd}p hahd`#tkjdchdqfjcx# pnfp nd nf` kdqdz }ddk hp# pnfp nd wf} tkfwfzd ea hp} mekpdkp}+Lezdeqdz# pnd rze}dmtpez} zdmegkhphek ea pnd `dqf}pfphkg daadmp pnfp pnh}èmtldkpfzx dqh`dkmd metc` nfqd ek pnd geqdzkldkp} mf}d fgfhk}p Jetp h} wdcc`dlek}pzfpd` jx pnd afmp pnfp pnh} d,lfhc nf` kep jddk }tjlhppd` hk dqh`dkmd jx pndgeqdzkldkp kepwhpn}pfk`hkg pnfp hp wf} hk pndhz re}}d}}hek+ Hp wf} cdap pe pnd`dadk`fkp pe mekazekp pnd @DF fgdkp whpn hp} mekpdkp} fk` eaadz hp hk dqh`dkmd+


12/14

Jetp} zdodmphek ea pnd hkqhpfphek pe jdmeld hkqecqd` hk fk hccdgfc fzl} `dfc `h`kep }cew èwk nh} rtz}thp jx pnd @DF+ F} `h}mt}}d` fjeqd# whpnhk f wddi pnd @DFmfld tr whpn f kdw fhz rcfkd} }mdkfzhe pe ctzd Jetp etp ea Zt}}hf }e pnfp nd metc` jd

fzzd}pd`+ Pnt}# pnd frrdfchkg kephek pnfp ]kew} mt}peldz} wdzd hkpdzd}pd` hkrtzmnf}hkg fhzrcfkd} wf} pzeppd` etp pe ]ltchfk aez aezwfz`hkg pe Jetp+ Hp h} hkpdzd}phkgpe kepd pnfp pnd d,lfhc hk wnhmn ]kew jzefmnd` pnd fhzrcfkd h}}td wf} fgfhk ekd pnfp pndpd}phaxhkg @DF cdf` fgdkp metc` kep zdmfcc dqdz nfqhkg }ddk+ Pndk pnzetgn nh} pd}phlekxpnd fgdkp cfpdz hkmzd`tcet}cx fppdlrpd` pe mcfhl pnfp hp wf} pnd @DF rfh` aez fkàezldzcx mekqhmpd` `ztg ihkg rhk} hk`drdk`dkp h`df pe hkpdzodmp pnd rcfkd} hkpepnd }mdkfzhe pe rtcc Jetp hkpe pnd lddphkg+ Pnd cdf` Fgdkp pd}phahd` Fzd xetf}ihkg ld }rdmhahmfccx ha H pec` Mfzce} pe }fx f cep ea fhzmzfap5+++KE Pnd

Metzp Fhzmzfap fp fcc# pnd kdd` aez fhzmzfap5 @DF Fgdkp Lffl# nd

wf} ghqdk f zecd pe rcfx# fk` H pnhki pnfp nd azddcfkmd` ek }fxhkg pnd}d

pnhkg} wndk Fk`zdw }fh` ndx# fzd xet ceeihkg aez fhzmzfapH mfkp pdcc xetwnfp Mfzce} wf} pnhkihkg fp pnd phld pe }fx pnfp Jtp wndk fapdzwfz`}Mfzce}# pnd aezldzcx mekqhmpd` `ztg ihkg rhk pd}phahd` nd }fh` pnfp hp wf} pndfgdkp wne hk}pztmpd` nhl pe hkpdzodmp pnd rcfkd} hkpe pnd }mdkfzhe pe rtccJetp hkpe pnd Pnfhcfk` lddphkg+ ]ltchfk# wne fp pnfp rehkp pd}phahd` aez pndgeqdzkldkp chpdzfccx hk d~mnfkgd aez nh} chad# `tjhet}cx d~rcfhkd` pndhkpdzodmphek ea rcfkd} hkpe pnd }mdkfzhe f} mehkmh`dkpfc+ .Jtp# ]dd pzhfc zdmez`?]ltcchfk mek}pdkpcx hk}h}phkg pnfp Mfzce} lt}p rtzmnf}d rcfkd} hk ez`dz aezpzfk}mphek pe rzemdd`( Pnd rze}dmtphek fp pzhfc }tggd}pd` pnfp pnd @DF nfàfjzhmfpd` pnd fhzrcfkd }mdkfzhe fp f ltmn cfpdz phld }ddihkg pe }tggd}p pnfp pnd rcexwf} tkzdcfpd` pe Jetp} }pfpdldkp pnfp nd `h kep `dfc hk gzfx hpdl}+ Pnfp fppdlrpafhcd` ea metz}d }hkmd pnd ]kew fhzrcfkd d,lfhc wf} re}pd` ot}p ekd wddi fapdz pnd gzfxhpdl} d,lfhc wf} re}pd`+

Hp wf} }nezpcx pndzdfapdz pnfp ]ltchfk ldp whpn Jetp hk Le}mew+ Wnhcd pndrze}dmtphek mcfhl} pnfp hp wf} `tzhkg pnh} lddphkg pnfp Qhipez Jetp fk` ]ltchfkdkpdzd` hkpe f mek}rhzfpezhfc fgzddldkp pe rzeqh`d pnd AFZM whpn wdfrek}# pndzd h}ke èmtldkpfzx ez epndzwh}d jdchdqfjcd dqh dkmd pe }trrezp pnh} f}}dzphek+ Hk`dd`#pnd dk}thkg èmtldkpd` melltkhmfphek} jdpwddk ]ltchfk fk` epndz} rzeqd} pnfpzfpndz pnfk dkpdz hkpe fk fzl} mek}rhzfmx whpn ]ltchfk Jetp fgzdd` ekcx pe rtz}td pndfhzrcfkd }mdkfzhe+

Pnt}# hlld`hfpdcx fapdz pnd Le}mew lddphkg whpn Jetp# ]ltchfk d,lfhcd`ld}}fgd} pnfp }new# whpnetp dvthqemfphek# pnfp Qhipez `h` kep dkpdz hkpe fk fgzddldkp

whpn ]ltchfk pe rzeqh d wdfrekzx pe pnd AFZM+ Vthpd pnd erre}hpd# ]ltchfk} ewkwez`} tklh}pfifjcx }new pnfp Jetp d~rzd}}d` f pepfc cfmi ea hkpdzd}p hk fk fzl} `dfcfk` pnfp rze}dmtpez} erdkhkg }pfp dldkp fk` ]ltchfk} pzhfc pd}phlekx pnfp Jetp nf`hlld`hfpdcx fgzdd` pe pnd hccdgfc `dfc wf} melrcdpdcx tkpztd+ Aez# f} pnd d,lfhc azel]ltchfk wzhppdk ek pnd }fld `fx f} pnd Le}mew lddphkg whpn Jetp lfid} fj}ectpdcx mcdfz#zfpndz pnfk dkpnt}hf}phmfccx fgzddhkg whpn ]ltchfk} nerdatc daaezp} pe jzhkg Jetp hkpe


13/14

wnfp ]ltchfk jdchdqd` wf} f ltcph,lhcchek `eccfz fzl} pzfk}fmphek Jetp tppdzd` nh}pepfc `h}`fhk aez pnd qdkptzd+ F} Jetp rtp hp pe ]ltchfk# f} zdacdmpd` hk ]ltchfk} d,lfhc pnfp hp'} kep wezpn gdpphkg hkpe pnd fzl} `dfc fk` pnfp xet mfk'p lfid lekdx hk pndfzl} `dfc fk` pndzd h} ke rzeahp pe jd lf`d hk pnd fzl} `dfc fk` pndzd h} ot}p pee lfkx

fzl} hk pnd hk`t}pzx fk` pnd rzeahp lfzghk} fzd }chl `td pe pnd gctp ek pnd lfzidp #fk` mecezatccx pnfp pnfp Jetp wf} lezd hkpdzd}pd` hk `dfchkg whpn mf}ndw ktp}+ Wnfpwf} ]ltchfk} zd}rek}d wndk mekazekpd` whpn nh} ewk d,lfhc} }e `flfghkg pe nh} ewkmzd`hjhchpx fk` `hzdmpcx mekpzfzx pe pnd geqdzkldkp} }pfpd` pndezx ea rze}dmtphek , fmcfhld` cfmi ea zdmeccdmphek+ Fk` wnfp wf} pnd geqdzkldkp} zd}rek}d5 Pndgeqdzkldkp tk`dz}pfk`fjcx }hlrcx hgkezd` pnh} dqh`dkmd aez new mfk ekd d~rcfhk pndtkd~rcfhkfjcd5

Atzpndz# kep cekg fapdz pnd Le}mew lddphkg ]ltchfk nf` f zdmez`d`pdcdrnekd mekqdz}fphek whpn Jetp hk wnhmn hp wf} lf`d fj}ectpdcx mcdfz pnfp pndrzegzfl pnfp Jetp fk` ]ltchfk nf` wezid` etp hk pndhz Le}mew lddphkg zdcfpd`pe pnd }fcd ea rcfkd}?

]ltchfk? Zdldljdz wd wezid` etp pnd rzegzfl pnfppnd fletkp wf} 4 lhcchek fcc pegdpndz+

Jetp? Wdcc# wdcc# wdcc# aez pnd

fhzrcfkd}

]ltchfk? Xd}+

Jetp? Cdp ld mndmi , Hcc mfcc xet ot}p ghqd ld pdk

lhktpd}# ahqd lhktpd# ot}p pe lfid }tzd+ Fcczhgnp+

]ltchfk? E+I+ Ke rzejcdl+ H nfqd jddk pfcihkg pe pndlfjetp hp fk` hp }ddl} pnfp pndx fmmdrp pnd h`df+]e ,,,

Jetp? Xdfn+ Xdfn+ Xdfn+

Xdfn+ ]ltchfk?

E+I+

Pnt}# pnd qdzx mezkdz}pekd ea pnd geqdzkldkp} mf}d wf} jf}d` ek ]ltchfk}afc}d pd}phlekx wnhmn wf} jdchd` jx nh} ewk wez`} ldlezhfchd` hk nh} `emtldkpd`melltkhmfphek} pnfp wdzd hk pnd re}}d}}hek ea pnd geqdzkldkp wdcc jdaezd nd pd}phahd`+


14/14

Mekmct}hek

Pnd dkphzdpx ea pnd rze}dmtphek ea Qhipez Jetp# azel hp} hkmdrphek pnzetgn pzhfc#wf} pnd rze`tmp ea etpzfgdet}# hkd~mt}fjcd geqdzkldkp mek`tmp fk` nd h} fk hkkemdkpea pnd}d mnfzgd}+

Pnd hk hmpldkp }netc` jd `h}lh}}d`+ Pndzd h} ke fcpdzkfphqd# aez dqdk pndlhkhltl ea pwdkpx ahqd xdfz} h} wfx pee ltmn tk`dz pnd afmp} fk` mhzmtl}pfkmd} ea pnh}mf}d+ Pnd pztpn whcc lfzmn aezwfz` fk` pnd `dadk}d whcc mekphktd pe wzhpd fk` fzgtd ekpnh} h}}td+

Zd}rdmpatccx }tjlhppd`#

Fcjdzp X+ @fxfk

letter relief defense us vs viktor bout

Documents