led lighting parking lot case study
DESCRIPTION
LED lighting offers the opportunity to reduce costs in parking lot lighting. This case study shows how replacing HPS pole fixtures with LED parking lot lights is more economical than re-lamping and changing ballasts. Paybacks are very rapid, rebates on the LED fixtures are available, and no maintenance will be needed are all achieved by upgrading from HPS pole fixtures to LED lighting.TRANSCRIPT
Page: 1
Parking Lot Lighting - A Case Study New LED Fixtures or Re-lamping HID Fixtures
Rapid Payback from LED Fixture Replacements & Retro-fits
LED outdoor lighting fixtures in parking lots offer numerous advantages, including lower
energy costs and no maintenance for the life the LED fixture. First costs have been
perceived to be higher, thus there is the economic hurdle to seek paybacks from the
savings to support the replacement with new fixtures. In this Case Study of LED Parking
Lot Lighting, the replacement of high pressure sodium (HPS) fixtures with LED fixtures
is shown to be the compelling choice instead of re-lamping and replacing of ballasts.
Commercial Outdoor Office Park Lighting Issues
This Class A, Commercial Office Building, is part of a 1.7 million square foot property
development outside of Albany, N.Y. The property management company was examin-
ing whether to do a periodic re-lamping and maintenance of existing HPS parking lot
fixtures or install LED fixtures. These new LED luminaires would have to light the park-
ing lot, driveway, building façade, and flag poles. The planned maintenance activities
would have replaced the HPS lamps, ballast and starter components. The HPS fixtures
were approximately ten years old, and were in acceptable condition.
Existing HPS Parking Lot Lighting System
At this office building, there were eighteen pole fixtures for the parking lots, consuming
440 watts each, two entrance shoe box fixtures, at 195 watts each, and six façade
flood lights, and flag pole lights, using 150 watts each. The total installed load was 9.2
kilowatts (KW), and it is estimated that 41,106 kilowatt-hours (kWh) of electricity is
used per year.
Parking Lot Lighting - Engineering, Audit and Life-Cycle Analysis
The site was surveyed and an audit was prepared of the lighting conditions, and costs.
The Parking Lot lighting was engineered using AGI32 to fully simulate the proposed
lighting. The lighting analysis used photometric data generated from the LM-79 report
from a certified test lab. All the LED Parking Lot Fixtures are from Evolucia Lighting.
Based upon the lighting solution engi-
neered, the fixture count was increased
to 32 luminaires. The parking lot used
21 IES Type III ESB LED Shoebox fix-
tures from Evolucia Lighting at 85 watts
each, instead of the 440 watt HPS lumi-
naires. For the driveway, three IES Type
II ESB LED Shoebox Fixtures replaced
the HPS legacy fixtures, and two 55 watt
ESB Shoeboxes, were used at the build-
ing entrance instead of the 150 watt
existing lamps. The building façade and
flag poles were illuminated with 30 watt
landscape flood lighting, replacing the
old 150 watt, HPS Flood Lights.
© 2012 Metro LED Lighting, All specifications subject to change without notice.
Class ‘A’, Office Park, Albany, N.Y. -
The Property Manager conducted an analysis of
whether to re-lamp HPS lighting or replace with
new LED fixtures.
Contact Information:
1.518.409.8090
www.MetroLEDLighting.com
Page: 2
Parking Lot Lighting - A Case Study (Cont.)
Re-Lamping and Ballast Replacement Costs
To maintain the HPS lighting system, required skilled electricians, the use of a bucket
truck and replacement lamps, ballasts and starters. The costs of labor and the bucket
truck was roughly equal to installing the new LED Parking Lot fixture. The cost per fix-
ture for routine maintenance, was quoted at approximately $255 per fixture, including
parts.
New LED Fixtures v. Re-lamping in the Parking Lot
The new LED lighting system for the parking lots and accessory fixtures, installed cost
was approximately $15,800. The outdoor lighting system upgrade used fixtures from
Evolucia Lighting, which are DesignLights™ Consortium (DLC) listed and qualified for
rebates of $3,000. Most importantly, the reduction in electric costs was reduced by an
estimated $3,207 in the first year. After accounting for re-lamping, ballast replace-
ments, electrician labor and the savings in electric costs, the net differential was
$2,930 additional for the LED lighting system v. the HPS lights. Substantial future
benefits accrue from lower operating costs, and no maintenance costs. Using electric
savings only, the payback period is 1 year and 10 months, for the LED fixtures.
LED Parking Lot Lighting – Property Benefits
The LED Parking Lot lights require no maintenance as
opposed to the HPS fixtures which have continuing
replacements requirements. The ten year savings from
maintenance is estimated to be $19,180. The LED
lights save substantial energy was estimated to save
$36,150 over ten years. Additionally studies have
shown that green office buildings rent at a premium,
and achieve higher occupancy to their competitors.
Further, these building demonstrate superior income
potential in the rental market.
© 2012 Metro LED Lighting, All specifications subject to change without notice.
HPS Fixtures require periodic replacement of
electrical components by skilled electricians
and the use of costly bucket trucks.
HPS Fixtures components replaced during
maintenance.
Contact Information:
1.518.409.8090
www.MetroLEDLighting.com
HPS Fixture Re-Lamping New LED Fixtures
Lamps
($30 x 26) $780 LED Fixtures Installed $15,800
Ballasts
($65 x 26) $1,690 Rebate <$3,000>
Electrician & Truck $4,160
Year 1 - Electricity $5,640 Year 1 - Electricity $2,433
Year 1 Costs $12,270 Year 1 Costs $15,233
Year 1 Difference $2,963, 1 Yr.— 10 Months Payback
Green Labeled Buildings:
Achieve 7.3% to 17.3% higher
rents
Sell at a significant premium
Unique visual appeal attracts
tenants driving occupancy
Reduction in operating ex-penses support more competi-
tive rents
Page: 3
Parking Lot Lighting - A Case Study (Cont.)
The Case for LED Parking Lot Lighting
In general, multi-tenant office properties, have 56% of their costs related to utilities,
repairs and maintenance. Upgrading parking lots with LED lighting is an efficient use of
funds. It lowers operating costs, and is an economical means to drive energy costs
lower. There are next to no impacts on building tenants during installation. Utility bills
will be reduced, and replacing the costly components of outdoor lighting fixtures will be
an activity of the past. The property’s appearance will be improved, and tenant satisfac-
tion is increased. The one-time costs for re-lamping and maintaining old legacy high
intensity discharge (HID) parking lot fixtures are now cost-comparable to replacing
them with new LED fixtures. New LED Parking Lot lighting installation is a very compel-
ling activity to be undertaken when routine maintenance is being considered on any
legacy lighting system in outdoor lighting.
© 2012 Metro LED Lighting, All specifications subject to change without notice.
Contact Information:
1.518.409.8090
www.MetroLEDLighting.com
Driveway Lighting :
80W LED Shoe Box
Entrance Lighting :
80W LED Shoe Box
Page: 4
Parking Lot Lighting - A Case Study (Cont.)
© 2012 Metro LED Lighting, All specifications subject to change without notice.
Contact Information:
1.518.409.8090
www.MetroLEDLighting.com
Front Parking Area :
80W LED Shoe Box
Handicap Parking Lighting :
80W LED Shoe Box
Driveway & Entrance:
55W LED Shoe Box
Page: 5
Parking Lot Lighting - A Case Study (Cont.)
© 2012 Metro LED Lighting, All specifications subject to change without notice.
Contact Information:
1.518.409.8090
www.MetroLEDLighting.com
Side Parking Area :
80W LED Shoe Box
About Metro LED Lighting
Back Parking Lot:
80W LED Shoe Box
Metro Luminescent Technologies is the company behind MetroLEDLighting.com. We are
experts in LED core technologies, outdoor lighting engineering and design, life-cycle eco-
nomic analysis, and how to build outdoor lighting systems that perform well in commer-
cial or institutional settings. We constantly are investigating and analyzing LED lighting
offerings that meet commercial, municipal, and institutional requirements for reliable,
high performing, at the lowest cost of ownership for outdoor lighting.
We build product partnerships with innovative and inventive solid-state lighting compa-
nies that bring superior product benefits to our Clients. Our product partners have exten-
sive expertise in the development of lighting products, and typically hold patents on these
devices. We address the needs of property owners for better and more efficient lighting.