labrel cases batch 1

108
7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1 http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 1/108 !"#$%&'() &+,#"( '!-(& .#))#"- /+&0+&(1#+" 234 &%"% /(,(1#5 "#$%$%&'#()* +), 6%&7#"("7 (/#,+5 &+,%&1+ (-!#)(&5 %77#% ,()7+8(5 &%"% (,%))(&5 7#+.%7%' ()#/+'5 .#-!%) ()#/+'5 &+-%)#+ (.(9#15 )(&&: (.('/+5 6%)#0% ,()("'(-5 &+.%+ ,()("'(-5 .("!%) ,("-+15 ("7: ,(";(+5 7#+"#'#+ ,%"7#;+5 ;&<5 ;+$%"1#"+ ,&+/%5 %"&#/+ )#1%&()5 &+7-%& &(.#&%85 ,#%"$%"#7+ &+7&#-!%85 7#+/#1+ 0()(-1#=5 %&"#% '(,)("5 &#/9(&7 0("/9+5 &+7&#-+ %'1&(,%)(5 7("": >(7!'()% 234 ()):&+,:) +)0!'5  -#).&'/#'$), 0 1 2 3 4 3 5 6 ,&#+"5 !"# 7# (#)&8+# %' $9%) .#$%$%&' :&( (#+%#; &' <#($%&(=(% >  $9# <9=88#'?# $& $9# 6&+#@A#( BC* BDDE /#<%)%&' B  ='/ $9# F='G=(H BB* BDDC (#)&8G$%&' I  &: $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) K2JL %' 2JMN,-, 21OM4" 6&, DBDBP, Q9%) 2J /#<%)%&' =::%(@#/ ;%$9 @&/%:%<=$%&' $9# FG8H BB* BDDR /#<%)%&' S  ='/ $9# J.(%8 BP* BDDT (#)&8G$%&' R  &: $9# 6=$%&'=8 U=A&( -#8=$%&') 2&@@%))%&' K6U-2L %' 6U-2 2=)# 6&, VMDDDDTMDI ;9%<9* %' $G('* (#+#()#/ $9# 5<$&A#( C* BDDB /#<%)%&' T  &: $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( KUJL, Q9# UJW) /#<%)%&' /%)@%))#/ $9# <&@.8=%'$ :%8#/ AH <&@.8=%'='$) X#(/%'='/ J<%A&* #$ =8, E  =?=%')$ .#$%$%&'#() Y'%+#()=8 -&A%'= 4G?=( Z%88%'? 2&(.&(=$%&' KY-4YZ25L ='/ -#'# 2=A=$%, Q9# X=<$G=8 J'$#<#/#'$) Y-4YZ25 %) = /&@#)$%< <&(.&(=$%&' #'?=?#/ %' $9# )G?=( <='# @%88%'? AG)%'#))[ 2=A=$% %) Y-4YZ25W) OG)%'#)) Y'%$ N#'#(=8 Z='=?#(, Q9# <&@.8=%'='$) ;#(# #@.8&H##) &: Y-4YZ25, Q9#H ;#(# 9%(#/ &' +=(%&G) /=$#) KA#$;##' X#A(G=(H >CPP ='/ J.(%8 >CCTL ='/ &' /%::#(#'$ <=.=<%$%#)* P  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 $9# <&@.8=%'='$) :%8#/ A#:&(# $9# UJ <&@.8=%'$) :&( (#?G8=(%^=$%&'* #'$%$8#@#'$ $& $9# A#'#:%$) G'/#( $9# #_%)$%'? 2&88#<$%+# O=(?=%'%'? J?(##@#'$ K2OJL*='/ =$$&('#HW) :##), 3' $9# /#<%)%&' >D  /=$#/ 5<$&A#( C* BDDB* $9# UJ /%)@%))#/ $9# <&@.8=%'$ :&( 8=<\ &: @#(%$, Q9# UJ 9#8/ $9=$ $9# <&@.8=%'='$) ;#(# )#=)&'=8 &( .(&`#<$ ;&(\#() ='/ '&$ (#?G8=( #@.8&H##) &: Y-4YZ25, Q9# UJ .&%'$#/ &G$ $9=$ $9# <&@.8=%'='$) ;#(# (#]G%(#/ $& .#(:&(@* :&( = /#:%'%$# .#(%&/* .9=)#) &: Y-4YZ25W) )#+#(=8 .(&`#<$) $9=$ ;#(# '&$ =$ =88 /%(#<$8H (#8=$#/ $& $9# 8=$$#(W) @=%' &.#(=$%&'), J) $9# <&@.8=%'='$) ;#(# .(&`#<$ #@.8&H##)* $9#H <&G8/ '&$ A# (#?G8=(%^#/ )%'<# $9#%( (#).#<$%+# #@.8&H@#'$) ;#(# <&$#(@%'&G) ;%$9 $9# .9=)# &: $9# ;&(\ &( ).#<%=8 .(&`#<$ $& ;9%<9 $9#H ;#(# =))%?'#/ ='/ ;9%<9 #@.8&H@#'$) #'/ G.&' $9# <&@.8#$%&' &: #=<9 .(&`#<$, J<<&(/%'?8H* $9# <&@.8=%'='$) ;#(# '&$ #'$%$8#/ $& $9# A#'#:%$) ?(='$#/ G'/#( $9# 2OJ $9=$* =) .(&+%/#/* <&+#(#/ &'8H $9# (#?G8=( #@.8&H##) &: Y-4YZ25, 5: $9# $;#'$HM$;& &(%?%'=8 <&@.8=%'='$) A#:&(# $9# UJ* )#+#' =..#=8#/ $9# UJW) (G8%'? A#:&(# $9# 6U-2* '=@#8Ha (#).&'/#'$) X#(/%'='/ J<%A&* 1//%# O=8/&^=* J'/H O='`=&* 0%&'%)%& O#'/%`&* F(,* -&/?#( -=@%(#^* 0%&<%$& "=8=?$%;* 0=''H b=/G)=8# ='/ J88H(&AH8 58.G), Q9# -G8%'? &: $9# 6U-2 3' %$) /#<%)%&' >>  &: FG8H BB* BDDR* $9# 6U-2 (#+#()#/ $9# UJW) (G8%'?[ %$ /#<8=(#/ $9# <&@.8=%'='$) =) (#?G8=( Y-4YZ25 #@.8&H##) ='/ ?(='$#/ $9#%( @&'#$=(H <8=%@) G'/#( $9# 2OJ, Q9# 6U-2 .&%'$#/ &G$ $9=$ $9#

Upload: andrea-nicole-paulino-rivera

Post on 04-Mar-2016

240 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

A

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 1/108

!"#$%&'() &+,#"( '!-(& .#))#"- /+&0+&(1#+" 234 &%"% /(,(1#5 "#$%$%&'#()*

+),

6%&7#"("7 (/#,+5 &+,%&1+ (-!#)(&5 %77#% ,()7+8(5 &%"% (,%))(&5 7#+.%7%' ()#/+'5 .#-!%)

()#/+'5 &+-%)#+ (.(9#15 )(&&: (.('/+5 6%)#0% ,()("'(-5 &+.%+ ,()("'(-5 .("!%) ,("-+15

("7: ,(";(+5 7#+"#'#+ ,%"7#;+5 ;&<5 ;+$%"1#"+ ,&+/%5 %"&#/+ )#1%&()5 &+7-%& &(.#&%85

,#%"$%"#7+ &+7&#-!%85 7#+/#1+ 0()(-1#=5 %&"#% '(,)("5 &#/9(&7 0("/9+5 &+7&#-+ %'1&(,%)(5

7("": >(7!'()% 234 ()):&+,:) +)0!'5 -#).&'/#'$),

0 1 2 3 4 3 5 6

,&#+"5 !"# 

7# (#)&8+# %' $9%) .#$%$%&' :&( (#+%#; &' <#($%&(=(%> $9# <9=88#'?# $& $9# 6&+#@A#( BC* BDDE /#<%)%&'

B ='/

$9# F='G=(H BB* BDDC (#)&8G$%&'I &: $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) K2JL %' 2JMN,-, 21OM4" 6&, DBDBP, Q9%) 2J /#<%)%&'

=::%(@#/ ;%$9 @&/%:%<=$%&' $9# FG8H BB* BDDR /#<%)%&'S ='/ $9# J.(%8 BP* BDDT (#)&8G$%&'

R &: $9# 6=$%&'=8

U=A&( -#8=$%&') 2&@@%))%&' K6U-2L %' 6U-2 2=)# 6&, VMDDDDTMDI ;9%<9* %' $G('* (#+#()#/ $9# 5<$&A#( C*

BDDB /#<%)%&'T &: $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( KUJL, Q9# UJW) /#<%)%&' /%)@%))#/ $9# <&@.8=%'$ :%8#/ AH <&@.8=%'='$)

X#(/%'='/ J<%A&* #$ =8,

E

 =?=%')$ .#$%$%&'#() Y'%+#()=8 -&A%'= 4G?=( Z%88%'? 2&(.&(=$%&' KY-4YZ25L ='/-#'# 2=A=$%,

Q9# X=<$G=8 J'$#<#/#'$)

Y-4YZ25 %) = /&@#)$%< <&(.&(=$%&' #'?=?#/ %' $9# )G?=( <='# @%88%'? AG)%'#))[ 2=A=$% %) Y-4YZ25W)

OG)%'#)) Y'%$ N#'#(=8 Z='=?#(,

Q9# <&@.8=%'='$) ;#(# #@.8&H##) &: Y-4YZ25, Q9#H ;#(# 9%(#/ &' +=(%&G) /=$#) KA#$;##' X#A(G=(H

>CPP ='/ J.(%8 >CCTL ='/ &' /%::#(#'$ <=.=<%$%#)*P %,#,* /(%+#()* <(='# &.#(=$&()* AG<\#$ 9&&\#()* ;#8/#()*

@#<9='%<)* 8=A&(=$&(H =$$#'/='$) ='/ =%/#)* )$##8 ;&(\#()* 8=A&(#()* <=(.#'$#() ='/ @=)&')* =@&'?

&$9#(), J$ $9# )$=($ &: $9#%( (#).#<$%+# #'?=?#@#'$)* $9# <&@.8=%'='$) )%?'#/ <&'$(=<$) &: #@.8&H@#'$ :&(

= .#(%&/ &: &'# K>L @&'$9 &( :&( = ?%+#' )#=)&', Y-4YZ25 (#.#=$#/8H 9%(#/ $9# <&@.8=%'='$) $& .#(:&(@

$9# )=@# /G$%#) ='/* :&( #+#(H #'?=?#@#'$* (#]G%(#/ $9# 8=$$#( $& )%?' '#; #@.8&H@#'$ <&'$(=<$) :&( $9#

)=@# /G(=$%&' &: &'# @&'$9 &( = ?%+#' )#=)&',

5' JG?G)$ BI* BDDB*C $9# <&@.8=%'='$) :%8#/ A#:&(# $9# UJ <&@.8=%'$) :&( (#?G8=(%^=$%&'* #'$%$8#@#'$ $& $9#

A#'#:%$) G'/#( $9# #_%)$%'? 2&88#<$%+# O=(?=%'%'? J?(##@#'$ K2OJL*='/ =$$&('#HW) :##),

3' $9# /#<%)%&'>D

 /=$#/ 5<$&A#( C* BDDB* $9# UJ /%)@%))#/ $9# <&@.8=%'$ :&( 8=<\ &: @#(%$, Q9# UJ 9#8/ $9=$

$9# <&@.8=%'='$) ;#(# )#=)&'=8 &( .(&`#<$ ;&(\#() ='/ '&$ (#?G8=( #@.8&H##) &: Y-4YZ25, Q9# UJ

.&%'$#/ &G$ $9=$ $9# <&@.8=%'='$) ;#(# (#]G%(#/ $& .#(:&(@* :&( = /#:%'%$# .#(%&/* .9=)#) &: Y-4YZ25W))#+#(=8 .(&`#<$) $9=$ ;#(# '&$ =$ =88 /%(#<$8H (#8=$#/ $& $9# 8=$$#(W) @=%' &.#(=$%&'), J) $9# <&@.8=%'='$)

;#(# .(&`#<$ #@.8&H##)* $9#H <&G8/ '&$ A# (#?G8=(%^#/ )%'<# $9#%( (#).#<$%+# #@.8&H@#'$) ;#(#

<&$#(@%'&G) ;%$9 $9# .9=)# &: $9# ;&(\ &( ).#<%=8 .(&`#<$ $& ;9%<9 $9#H ;#(# =))%?'#/ ='/ ;9%<9

#@.8&H@#'$) #'/ G.&' $9# <&@.8#$%&' &: #=<9 .(&`#<$, J<<&(/%'?8H* $9# <&@.8=%'='$) ;#(# '&$ #'$%$8#/ $&

$9# A#'#:%$) ?(='$#/ G'/#( $9# 2OJ $9=$* =) .(&+%/#/* <&+#(#/ &'8H $9# (#?G8=( #@.8&H##) &: Y-4YZ25,

5: $9# $;#'$HM$;& &(%?%'=8 <&@.8=%'='$) A#:&(# $9# UJ* )#+#' =..#=8#/ $9# UJW) (G8%'? A#:&(# $9# 6U-2*

'=@#8Ha (#).&'/#'$) X#(/%'='/ J<%A&* 1//%# O=8/&^=* J'/H O='`=&* 0%&'%)%& O#'/%`&* F(,* -&/?#( -=@%(#^*

0%&<%$& "=8=?$%;* 0=''H b=/G)=8# ='/ J88H(&AH8 58.G),

Q9# -G8%'? &: $9# 6U-2

3' %$) /#<%)%&'>> &: FG8H BB* BDDR* $9# 6U-2 (#+#()#/ $9# UJW) (G8%'?[ %$ /#<8=(#/ $9# <&@.8=%'='$) =) (#?G8=(

Y-4YZ25 #@.8&H##) ='/ ?(='$#/ $9#%( @&'#$=(H <8=%@) G'/#( $9# 2OJ, Q9# 6U-2 .&%'$#/ &G$ $9=$ $9#

Page 2: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 2/108

<&@.8=%'='$) .#(:&(@#/ =<$%+%$%#) ;9%<9 ;#(# G)G=88H '#<#))=(H ='/ /#)%(=A8# %' $9# G)G=8 $(=/# &(

AG)%'#)) &: Y-4YZ25* ='/ 9=/ A##' (#.#=$#/8H 9%(#/ :&( $9# )=@# G'/#($=\%'? #+#(H )#=)&', Q9G)*

.G()G='$ $& J($%<8# BPD &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#* $9# 6U-2 /#<8=(#/ $9=$ $9# <&@.8=%'='$) ;#(# (#?G8=(

#@.8&H##), J) (#?G8=( #@.8&H##)* $9# 6U-2 9#8/ $9=$ $9# <&@.8=%'='$) ;#(# #'$%$8#/ $& $9# A#'#:%$)

?(='$#/* G'/#( $9# 2OJ* $& $9# (#?G8=( Y-4YZ25 #@.8&H##),

Q9# .#$%$%&'#() @&+#/ $& (#<&')%/#( $9%) 6U-2 (G8%'? ;9%<9 $9# 6U-2 /#'%#/ %' %$) J.(%8 BP* BDDT

(#)&8G$%&',>B

 Q9# .#$%$%&'#() #8#+=$#/ $9# <=)# $& $9# 2J +%= = .#$%$%&' :&( <#($%&(=(%,>I

 

Q9# -G8%'? &: $9# 2J

3' %$) 6&+#@A#( BC* BDDE /#<%)%&'*>S

 $9# 2J ?(='$#/ %' .=($ $9# .#$%$%&'[ %$ =::%(@#/ $9# 6U-2W) (G8%'?

:%'/%'? $9# <&@.8=%'='$) $& A# (#?G8=( #@.8&H##) &: Y-4YZ25* AG$ /#8#$#/ $9# ?(='$ &: @&'#$=(H

A#'#:%$) G'/#( $9# 2OJ,

Q9# 2J .&%'$#/ &G$ $9=$ $9# .(%@=(H )$='/=(/ :&( /#$#(@%'%'? (#?G8=( #@.8&H@#'$ %) $9# (#=)&'=A8#

<&''#<$%&' A#$;##' = .=($%<G8=( =<$%+%$H .#(:&(@#/ AH $9# #@.8&H## +%)McM+%) $9# G)G=8 $(=/# &( AG)%'#))

&: $9# #@.8&H#(, Q9%) <&''#<$%&'* %' $G('* <=' A# /#$#(@%'#/ AH <&')%/#(%'? $9# '=$G(# &: $9# ;&(\

.#(:&(@#/ ='/ $9# (#8=$%&' &: $9%) ;&(\ $& $9# AG)%'#)) &( $(=/# &: $9# #@.8&H#( %' %$) #'$%(#$H,

3' $9%) (#?=(/* $9# 2J 9#8/ $9=$ $9# +=(%&G) =<$%+%$%#) $9=$ $9# <&@.8=%'='$) ;#(# $=)\#/ $& /& ;#(#

'#<#))=(H* %: '&$ %'/%).#')=A8#* $& $9# '=$G(# &: Y-4YZ25W) AG)%'#)), J) $9# <&@.8=%'='$) 9=/ A##'

.#(:&(@%'? $9#%( (#).#<$%+# $=)\) :&( =$ 8#=)$ &'# H#=(* $9# 2J 9#8/ $9=$ $9%) (#.#=$#/ ='/ <&'$%'G%'? '##/

:&( $9# <&@.8=%'='$)W .#(:&(@='<# &: $9#)# )=@# $=)\)* (#?=(/8#)) &: ;9#$9#( $9# .#(:&(@='<# ;=)

<&'$%'G&G) &( %'$#(@%$$#'$* <&')$%$G$#) )G::%<%#'$ #+%/#'<# &: $9# '#<#))%$H* %: '&$ %'/%).#')=A%8%$H* &: $9#

=<$%+%$H $& Y-4YZ25W) AG)%'#)),

XG($9#(* $9# 2J '&$#/ $9=$ $9# .#$%$%&'#() :=%8#/ $& .(&+# $9=$ $9#H ?=+# $9# <&@.8=%'='$) &..&($G'%$H $&

;&(\ #8)#;9#(# /G(%'? $9# &::M)#=)&'* ;9%<9 &..&($G'%$H <&G8/ 9=+# ]G=8%:%#/ $9# 8=$$#( =) )#=)&'=8

;&(\#(), 4$%88* $9# 2J .&%'$#/ &G$ $9=$ #+#' /G(%'? $9%) &::M)#=)&' .#(%&/* )#=)&'=8 ;&(\#() =(# '&$

)#.=(=$#/ :(&@ $9# )#(+%<# AG$ =(# )%@.8H <&')%/#(#/ &' 8#=+# G'$%8 $9#H =(# (#M#@.8&H#/, Q9G)* $9# 2J

<&'<8G/#/ $9=$ $9# <&@.8=%'='$) ;#(# (#?G8=( #@.8&H##) ;%$9 (#).#<$ $& $9# =<$%+%$H $9=$ $9#H 9=/ A##'

.#(:&(@%'? ='/ ;9%8# $9# =<$%+%$H <&'$%'G#/,

5' $9# <8=%@ :&( 2OJ A#'#:%$)* $9# 2J* 9&;#+#(* (G8#/ $9=$ $9# <&@.8=%'='$) ;#(# '&$ #'$%$8#/ $& (#<#%+#

$9#@, Q9# 2J .&%'$#/ &G$ $9=$ ;9%8# $9# <&@.8=%'='$) ;#(# <&')%/#(#/ (#?G8=(* =8A#%$ )#=)&'=8* ;&(\#()*

$9# 2OJM<&+#(#/ (#?G8=( #@.8&H##) &: Y-4YZ25 ;#(# .#(:&(@%'? $=)\) '##/#/ AH $9# 8=$$#( :&( $9#

#'$%(# H#=( ;%$9 '& (#?=(/ $& $9# <9='?%'? )G?=( @%88%'? )#=)&', d#'<#* $9# <&@.8=%'='$) /%/ '&$ A#8&'? $&

='/ <&G8/ '&$ A# ?(&G.#/ $&?#$9#( ;%$9 $9# (#?G8=( #@.8&H##) &: Y-4YZ25* :&( <&88#<$%+# A=(?=%'%'?.G(.&)#)[ $9#H <&')$%$G$# = A=(?=%'%'? G'%$ )#.=(=$# ='/ /%)$%'<$ :(&@ $9# (#?G8=( #@.8&H##),

2&')#]G#'$8H* $9# 2J /#<8=(#/ $9=$ $9# <&@.8=%'='$) <&G8/ '&$ A# <&+#(#/ AH $9# 2OJ,

Q9# .#$%$%&'#() :%8#/ $9# .(#)#'$ .#$%$%&' =:$#( $9# 2J /#'%#/ $9#%( @&$%&' :&( .=($%=8 (#<&')%/#(=$%&'>R

 %'

$9# 2JW) F='G=(H BB* BDDC (#)&8G$%&',>T

 

Q9# 3))G#)

Q9# .#$%$%&' #))#'$%=88H .(#)#'$) $9# :&88&;%'? %))G#) :&( $9# 2&G($W) (#)&8G$%&'a K>L ;9#$9#( $9#

(#).&'/#'$) =(# (#?G8=( #@.8&H##) &: Y-4YZ25[ ='/ KBL ;9#$9#( =::%(@=$%+# (#8%#: <=' A# ?%+#' $& $9#:%:$##' K>RL &: $9# <&@.8=%'='$) ;9& /%/ '&$ =..#=8 $9# UJW) /#<%)%&',

>E 

Q9# 2&G($W) -G8%'?

Page 3: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 3/108

7# (#)&8+# $& .=($%=88H N-J6Q $9# .#$%$%&',

5' $9# %))G# &: $9# )$=$G) &: $9# (#).&'/#'$)W #@.8&H@#'$

Q9# .#$%$%&'#() @=%'$=%' $9=$ $9# (#).&'/#'$) =(# <&'$(=<$G=8 &( .(&`#<$e)#=)&'=8 ;&(\#() ='/ '&$ (#?G8=(

#@.8&H##) &: Y-4YZ25, Q9#H $9G) =(?G# $9=$ $9# 2J #((#/ %' =..8H%'? $9# 8#?=8 .=(=@#$#() ='/

?G%/#8%'#) :&( (#?G8=( #@.8&H@#'$ $& $9# (#).&'/#'$)W <=)#, Q9#H <&'$#'/ $9=$ $9# 8#?=8 )$='/=(/) f

8#'?$9 &: $9# #@.8&H##W) #'?=?#@#'$ ='/ $9# /#)%(=A%8%$H &( '#<#))%$H &: $9# #@.8&H##W) ;&(\ %' $9# G)G=8$(=/# &( AG)%'#)) &: $9# #@.8&H#( f =..8H &'8H $& (#?G8=( #@.8&H##) G'/#( .=(=?(=.9 >* J($%<8# BPD &: $9#

U=A&( 2&/#* ='/* G'/#( .=(=?(=.9 B &: $9# )=@# =($%<8#* $& <=)G=8 #@.8&H##) ;9& =(# /##@#/ (#?G8=( AH

$9#%( 8#'?$9 &: )#(+%<#,

Q9# (#).&'/#'$)* $9# .#$%$%&'#() .&%'$ &G$* ;#(# ).#<%:%<=88H #'?=?#/ :&( = :%_#/ ='/ .(#/#$#(@%'#/

/G(=$%&' &:* &' $9# =+#(=?#* &'# K>L @&'$9 =$ = $%@# $9=$ <&%'<%/#) ;%$9 = .=($%<G8=( .9=)# &: $9#

<&@.='HW) AG)%'#)) &.#(=$%&') &( )G?=( @%88%'? )#=)&', OH $9# '=$G(# &: $9#%( #'?=?#@#'$* $9#

(#).&'/#'$)W #@.8&H@#'$ 8#?=88H #'/) G.&' $9# #'/ &: $9# .(#/#$#(@%'#/ .#(%&/[ $9G)* Y-4YZ25 ;=)

G'/#( '& 8#?=8 &A8%?=$%&' $& (#9%(# $9# (#).&'/#'$),

3' $9#%( <&@@#'$*>P

 $9# (#).&'/#'$) @=%'$=%' $9=$ $9#H =(# (#?G8=( #@.8&H##) &: Y-4YZ25, -#8H%'? &'

$9# 6U-2 ='/ $9# 2J (G8%'?)* $9#H .&%'$ &G$ $9=$ $9#H 9=+# A##' <&'$%'G&G)8H ;&(\%'? :&( Y-4YZ25 :&(

@&(# $9=' &'# H#=(* .#(:&(@%'? $=)\) ;9%<9 ;#(# '#<#))=(H ='/ /#)%(=A8# $& Y-4YZ25W) AG)%'#)), d#'<#*

G'/#( $9# =A&+#M)$=$#/ 8#?=8 .=(=@#$#()* $9#H =(# (#?G8=( #@.8&H##),

7# /%)=?(## ;%$9 $9# .#$%$%&'#()W .&)%$%&',!"#$%&! 7# :%'/ $9# (#).&'/#'$) $& A# (#?G8=( )#=)&'=8

#@.8&H##) &: Y-4YZ25,

J) $9# 2J 9=) #_.8=%'#/ %' %$) <9=88#'?#/ /#<%)%&'* J($%<8# BPD &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# .(&+%/#) :&( $9(## \%'/) &:

#@.8&H@#'$ =((='?#@#'$)* '=@#8Ha (#?G8=(* .(&`#<$e)#=)&'=8 ='/ <=)G=8, -#?G8=( #@.8&H@#'$ (#:#() $&

$9=$ =((='?#@#'$ ;9#(#AH $9# #@.8&H## g9=) A##' #'?=?#/ $& .#(:&(@ =<$%+%$%#) ;9%<9 =(# G)G=88H

'#<#))=(H &( /#)%(=A8# %' $9# G)G=8 AG)%'#)) &( $(=/# &: $9# #@.8&H#(h,ig>C

 Y'/#( $9# /#:%'%$%&'* $9#

.(%@=(H )$='/=(/ $9=$ /#$#(@%'#) (#?G8=( #@.8&H@#'$ %) $9# (#=)&'=A8# <&''#<$%&' A#$;##' $9#

.=($%<G8=( =<$%+%$H .#(:&(@#/ AH $9# #@.8&H## ='/ $9# G)G=8 AG)%'#)) &( $(=/# &: $9# #@.8&H#([BD

 $9#

#@.9=)%) %) &' $9# '#<#))%$H &( /#)%(=A%8%$H &: $9# #@.8&H##W) =<$%+%$H, Q9G)* ;9#' $9# #@.8&H## .#(:&(@)

=<$%+%$%#) <&')%/#(#/ '#<#))=(H ='/ /#)%(=A8# $& $9# &+#(=88 AG)%'#)) )<9#@# &: $9# #@.8&H#(* $9# 8=;

(#?=(/) $9# #@.8&H## =) (#?G8=(,

OH ;=H &: =' #_<#.$%&'* .=(=?(=.9 B* J($%<8# BPD &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# =8)& <&')%/#() (#?G8=( = <=)G=8

#@.8&H@#'$ =((='?#@#'$ ;9#' $9# <=)G=8 #@.8&H##W) #'?=?#@#'$ 9=) 8=)$#/ :&( =$ 8#=)$ &'# H#=(*

(#?=(/8#)) &: $9# #'?=?#@#'$W) <&'$%'G%$H, Q9# <&'$(&88%'? $#)$ %' $9%) =((='?#@#'$ %) $9# 8#'?$9 &: $%@#/G(%'? ;9%<9 $9# #@.8&H## %) #'?=?#/,

J .(&`#<$ #@.8&H@#'$* &' $9# &$9#( 9='/* <&'$#@.8=$#) &' =((='?#@#'$ ;9#(#AH g$9# #@.8&H@#'$ 9=)

A##' :%_#/ :&( = ).#<%:%< .(&`#<$ &( G'/#($=\%'? ;9&)# <&@.8#$%&' &( $#(@%'=$%&' 9=) A##' /#$#(@%'#/ =$

$9# $%@# &: $9# #'?=?#@#'$ &: $9# #@.8&H##h,igB>

 Q;& (#]G%(#@#'$)* $9#(#:&(#* <8#=(8H '##/ $& A#

)=$%):%#/ $& (#@&+# $9# #'?=?#@#'$ :(&@ $9# .(#)G@.$%&' &: (#?G8=(%$H &: #@.8&H@#'$* '=@#8Ha K>L

/#)%?'=$%&' &: = ).#<%:%< .(&`#<$ &( G'/#($=\%'? :&( ;9%<9 $9# #@.8&H## %) 9%(#/[ ='/ KBL <8#=(

/#$#(@%'=$%&' &: $9# <&@.8#$%&' &( $#(@%'=$%&' &: $9# .(&`#<$ =$ $9# $%@# &: $9# #@.8&H##W)

#'?=?#@#'$,BB Q9# )#(+%<#) &: $9# .(&`#<$ #@.8&H##) =(# 8#?=88H ='/ =G$&@=$%<=88H $#(@%'=$#/ G.&' $9#

#'/ &( <&@.8#$%&' &: $9# .(&`#<$ =) $9# #@.8&H##W) )#(+%<#) =(# <&$#(@%'&G) ;%$9 $9# .(&`#<$,

Y'8%\# %' = (#?G8=( #@.8&H@#'$ G'/#( J($%<8# BPD &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#* 9&;#+#(* $9# 8#'?$9 &: $%@# &: $9#

=))#($#/ g.(&`#<$g #@.8&H##W) #'?=?#@#'$ %) '&$ <&'$(&88%'? =) $9# #@.8&H@#'$ @=H* %' :=<$* 8=)$ :&( @&(#

Page 4: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 4/108

$9=' = H#=(* /#.#'/%'? &' $9# '##/) &( <%(<G@)$='<#) &: $9# .(&`#<$, 6#+#($9#8#))* $9%) 8#'?$9 &: $%@# K&(

$9# <&'$%'G&G) (#9%(%'? &: $9# #@.8&H## #+#' =:$#( $9# <#))=$%&' &: $9# .(&`#<$L @=H )#(+# =) = A=/?# &:

(#?G8=( #@.8&H@#'$ ;9#' $9# =<$%+%$%#) .#(:&(@#/ AH $9# .G(.&($#/ g.(&`#<$g #@.8&H## =(# '#<#))=(H

='/ %'/%).#')=A8# $& $9# G)G=8 AG)%'#)) &( $(=/# &: $9# #@.8&H#(,BI 3' $9%) 8=$$#( <=)#* $9# 8=; ;%88 (#?=(/

$9# =((='?#@#'$ =) (#?G8=( #@.8&H@#'$,BS 

4#=)&'=8 #@.8&H@#'$ &.#(=$#) @G<9 %' $9# )=@# ;=H =) .(&`#<$ #@.8&H@#'$* =8A#%$ %$ %'+&8+#) ;&(\ &(

)#(+%<# $9=$ %) )#=)&'=8 %' '=$G(# &( 8=)$%'? :&( $9# /G(=$%&' &: $9# )#=)&',BR

 J) ;%$9 .(&`#<$ #@.8&H@#'$*=8$9&G?9 $9# )#=)&'=8 #@.8&H@#'$ =((='?#@#'$ %'+&8+#) ;&(\ $9=$ %) )#=)&'=8 &( .#(%&/%< %' '=$G(#* $9#

#@.8&H@#'$ %$)#8: %) '&$ =G$&@=$%<=88H <&')%/#(#/ )#=)&'=8 )& =) $& .(#+#'$ $9# #@.8&H## :(&@ =$$=%'%'?

(#?G8=( )$=$G), Q& #_<8G/# $9# =))#($#/ g)#=)&'=8g #@.8&H## :(&@ $9&)# <8=))%:%#/ =) (#?G8=( #@.8&H##)*

$9# #@.8&H#( @G)$ )9&; $9=$a K>L $9# #@.8&H## @G)$ A# .#(:&(@%'? ;&(\ &( )#(+%<#) $9=$ =(# )#=)&'=8 %'

'=$G(#[ ='/ KBL 9# 9=/ A##' #@.8&H#/ :&( $9# /G(=$%&' &: $9# )#=)&',BT

 d#'<#* ;9#' $9# g)#=)&'=8g

;&(\#() =(# <&'$%'G&G)8H ='/ (#.#=$#/8H 9%(#/ $& .#(:&(@ $9# )=@# $=)\) &( =<$%+%$%#) :&( )#+#(=8 )#=)&')

&( #+#' =:$#( $9# <#))=$%&' &: $9# )#=)&'* $9%) 8#'?$9 &: $%@# @=H 8%\#;%)# )#(+# =) A=/?# &: (#?G8=(

#@.8&H@#'$,BE

 3' :=<$* #+#' $9&G?9 /#'&@%'=$#/ =) g)#=)&'=8 ;&(\#()*g %: $9#)# ;&(\#() =(# <=88#/ $&

;&(\ :(&@ $%@# $& $%@# ='/ =(# &'8H $#@.&(=(%8H 8=%/ &:: /G(%'? $9# &::M)#=)&'* $9# 8=; /&#) '&$ <&')%/#(

$9#@ )#.=(=$#/ :(&@ $9# )#(+%<# /G(%'? $9# &::M)#=)&' .#(%&/, Q9# 8=; )%@.8H <&')%/#() $9#)# )#=)&'=8;&(\#() &' 8#=+# G'$%8 (#M#@.8&H#/,BP

 

2=)G=8 #@.8&H@#'$* $9# $9%(/ \%'/ &: #@.8&H@#'$ =((='?#@#'$* (#:#() $& ='H &$9#( #@.8&H@#'$

=((='?#@#'$ $9=$ /&#) '&$ :=88 G'/#( ='H &: $9# :%()$ $;& <=$#?&(%#)* %,#,* (#?G8=( &( .(&`#<$e)#=)&'=8,

3'$#(#)$%'?8H* $9# U=A&( 2&/# /&#) '&$ @#'$%&' ='&$9#( #@.8&H@#'$ =((='?#@#'$ f <&'$(=<$G=8 &( :%_#/

$#(@ #@.8&H@#'$ K&( #@.8&H@#'$ :&( = $#(@L f ;9%<9* %: '&$ :&( $9# :%_#/ $#(@* )9&G8/ :=88 G'/#( $9#

<=$#?&(H &: (#?G8=( #@.8&H@#'$ %' +%#; &: $9# '=$G(# &: $9# #@.8&H##W) #'?=?#@#'$* ;9%<9 %) $& .#(:&(@

=' =<$%+%$H G)G=88H '#<#))=(H &( /#)%(=A8# %' $9# #@.8&H#(W) AG)%'#)),

3' O(#'$ 4<9&&8* 3'<, +, j=@&(=*BC $9# 2&G($* :&( $9# :%()$ $%@#* (#<&?'%^#/ ='/ (#)&8+#/ $9# ='&@=8H <(#=$#/

AH = '=((&; ='/ 8%$#(=8 %'$#(.(#$=$%&' &: J($%<8# BPD &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# $9=$ =..#=() $& (#)$(%<$ $9#

#@.8&H##W) (%?9$ $& :(##8H )$%.G8=$# ;%$9 9%) #@.8&H#( &' $9# /G(=$%&' &: 9%) #'?=?#@#'$, 3' $9%) <=)#* $9#

2&G($ G.9#8/ $9# +=8%/%$H &: $9# :%_#/M$#(@ #@.8&H@#'$ =?(##/ G.&' AH $9# #@.8&H#(* O(#'$ 4<9&&8* 3'<,*

='/ $9# #@.8&H##* 0&(&$%& J8#?(#* /#<8=(%'? $9=$ $9# (#)$(%<$%+# <8=G)# %' J($%<8# BPD g)9&G8/ A# <&')$(G#/

$& (#:#( $& $9# )GA)$='$%+# #+%8 $9=$ $9# 2&/# %$)#8: _ _ _ )%'?8#/ &G$a =?(##@#'$) #'$#(#/ %'$& .(#<%)#8H $&

<%(<G@+#'$ )#<G(%$H &: $#'G(#, 3$ )9&G8/ 9=+# '& =..8%<=$%&' $& %')$='<#) ;9#(# h$9#i :%_#/ .#(%&/ &:

#@.8&H@#'$ ;=) =?(##/ G.&' \'&;%'?8H ='/ +&8G'$=(%8H AH $9# .=($%#) _ _ _ =A)#'$ ='H _ _ _ <%(<G@)$='<#)

+%$%=$%'? h$9# #@.8&H##W)i <&')#'$* &( ;9#(# h$9# :=<$) )=$%):=<$&(%8H )9&;i $9=$ $9# #@.8&H#( ='/ h$9#i

#@.8&H## /#=8$ ;%$9 #=<9 &$9#( &' @&(# &( 8#)) #]G=8 $#(@)h,igID Q9# %'/%).#')=A%8%$H &( /#)%(=A%8%$H &: $9#

=<$%+%$H .#(:&(@#/ AH $9# #@.8&H## ;%88 '&$ .(#<8G/# $9# .=($%#) :(&@ #'$#(%'? %'$& =' &$9#(;%)# +=8%/:%_#/ $#(@ #@.8&H@#'$ =?(##@#'$[ = /#:%'%$# .#(%&/ &: #@.8&H@#'$ /&#) '&$ #))#'$%=88H <&'$(=/%<$ $9#

'=$G(# &: $9# #@.8&H##) /G$%#)I>

 =) '#<#))=(H ='/ /#)%(=A8# $& $9# G)G=8 AG)%'#)) &( $(=/# &: $9#

#@.8&H#(,

6#+#($9#8#))* g;9#(# $9# <%(<G@)$='<#) #+%/#'$8H )9&; $9=$ $9# #@.8&H#( %@.&)#/ $9# .#(%&/ .(#<%)#8H $&

.(#<8G/# $9# #@.8&H## :(&@ =<]G%(%'? $#'G(%=8 )#<G(%$H* $9# 8=; ='/ $9%) 2&G($ ;%88 '&$ 9#)%$=$# $& )$(%\#

/&;' &( /%)(#?=(/ $9# .#(%&/ =) <&'$(=(H $& .GA8%< .&8%<H* @&(=8)* #$<,gIB

 3' )G<9 = <=)#* $9# ?#'#(=8

(#)$(%<$%+# (G8# G'/#( J($%<8# BPD &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# ;%88 =..8H ='/ $9# #@.8&H## )9=88 A# /##@#/ (#?G8=(,

28#=(8H* $9#(#:&(#* $9# '=$G(# &: $9# #@.8&H@#'$ /&#) '&$ /#.#'/ )&8#8H &' $9# ;%88 &( ;&(/ &: $9##@.8&H#( &( &' $9# .(&<#/G(# :&( 9%(%'? ='/ $9# @=''#( &: /#)%?'=$%'? $9# #@.8&H##, -=$9#(* $9# '=$G(#

&: $9# #@.8&H@#'$ /#.#'/) &' $9# '=$G(# &: $9# =<$%+%$%#) $& A# .#(:&(@#/ AH $9# #@.8&H##* <&')%/#(%'?

Page 5: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 5/108

$9# '=$G(# &: $9# #@.8&H#(W) AG)%'#))* $9# /G(=$%&' ='/ )<&.# $& A# /&'#*II

 ='/* %' )&@# <=)#)* #+#' $9#

8#'?$9 &: $%@# &: $9# .#(:&(@='<# ='/ %$) <&'$%'G#/ #_%)$#'<#,

3' 8%?9$ &: $9# =A&+# 8#?=8 .=(=@#$#() 8=%/ /&;' AH $9# 8=; ='/ =..8%<=A8# `G(%).(G/#'<#* $9# (#).&'/#'$)

=(# '#%$9#( .(&`#<$* )#=)&'=8 '&( :%_#/M$#(@ #@.8&H##)* AG$ (#?G8=( )#=)&'=8 ;&(\#() &: Y-4YZ25, Q9#

:&88&;%'? :=<$G=8 <&')%/#(=$%&') :(&@ $9# (#<&(/) )G..&($ $9%) <&'<8G)%&'a

X%()$* $9# (#).&'/#'$) ;#(# @=/# $& .#(:&(@ +=(%&G) $=)\) $9=$ /%/ '&$ =$ =88 .#($=%' $& ='H ).#<%:%< .9=)#&: Y-4YZ25W) )$(%<$ @%88%'? &.#(=$%&') $9=$ ;&G8/ G8$%@=$#8H <#=)# G.&' <&@.8#$%&' &: = .=($%<G8=( .9=)#

%' $9# @%88%'? &: )G?=([ (=$9#(* $9#H ;#(# $=)\#/ $& .#(:&(@ /G$%#) (#?G8=(8H ='/ 9=A%$G=88H '##/#/ %'

Y-4YZ25W) &.#(=$%&') /G(%'? $9# @%88%'? )#=)&', Q9# (#).&'/#'$)W /G$%#) =) 8&=/#( &.#(=$&()* 9&&\#()*

<(='# &.#(=$&() ='/ /(%+#() ;#(# '#<#))=(H $& 9=G8 ='/ $(=').&($ $9# )G?=(<='# :(&@ $9# .8='$=$%&' $& $9#

@%88[ 8=A&(=$&(H =$$#'/='$)* ;&(\#() ='/ 8=A&(#() $& @%88 $9# )G?=([ ='/ ;#8/#()* <=(.#'$#() ='/ G$%8%$H

;&(\#() $& #')G(# $9# )@&&$9 ='/ <&'$%'G&G) &.#(=$%&' &: $9# @%88 :&( $9# /G(=$%&' &: $9# @%88%'? )#=)&'*

=) /%)$%'?G%)9#/ :(&@ $9# .(&/G<$%&' &: $9# )G?=(<='# ;9%<9 %'+&8+#) $9# .8='$%'? ='/ (=%)%'? &: $9#

)G?=(<='# G'$%8 %$ (%.#') :&( @%88%'?, Q9# .(&/G<$%&' &: )G?=(<='#* %$ @G)$ A# #@.9=)%^#/* (#]G%(#) =

/%::#(#'$ )#$ &: ;&(\#() ;9& =(# #_.#(%#'<#/ %' :=(@ &( =?(%<G8$G(=8 ;&(\, 6##/8#)) $& )=H* $9#H .#(:&(@

$9# =<$%+%$%#) $9=$ =(# '#<#))=(H ='/ /#)%(=A8# %' )G?=(<='# .(&/G<$%&', J) %' $9# @%88%'? &: )G?=(<='#* $9#.8='$=$%&' ;&(\#() .#(:&(@ $9#%( /G$%#) &'8H /G(%'? $9# .8='$%'? )#=)&',

4#<&'/* $9# (#).&'/#'$) ;#(# (#?G8=(8H ='/ (#.#=$#/8H 9%(#/ $& .#(:&(@ $9# )=@# $=)\) H#=( =:$#( H#=(,

Q9%) (#?G8=( ='/ (#.#=$#/ 9%(%'? &: $9# )=@# ;&(\#() K$;& /%::#(#'$ )#$)L :&( $;& )#.=(=$# )#=)&') 9=) .G$

%' .8=<#* .(%'<%.=88H $9(&G?9 `G(%).(G/#'<#* $9# )H)$#@ &: (#?G8=( )#=)&'=8 #@.8&H@#'$ %' $9# )G?=(

%'/G)$(H ='/ &$9#( %'/G)$(%#) ;%$9 = )%@%8=( '=$G(# &: &.#(=$%&'),

Y'/#( $9# )H)$#@* $9# .8='$=$%&' ;&(\#() &( $9# @%88 #@.8&H##) /& '&$ ;&(\ <&'$%'G&G)8H :&( &'# ;9&8#

H#=( AG$ &'8H :&( $9# /G(=$%&' &: $9# ?(&;%'? &: $9# )G?=(<='# &( $9# @%88%'? )#=)&', Q9#%( )#=)&'=8 ;&(\*

9&;#+#(* /&#) '&$ /#$(=<$ :(&@ <&')%/#(%'? $9#@ %' (#?G8=( #@.8&H@#'$ )%'<# %' = 8%$='H &: <=)#)* $9%)

2&G($ 9=) =8(#=/H )#$$8#/ $9=$ )#=)&'=8 ;&(\#() ;9& =(# <=88#/ $& ;&(\ :(&@ $%@# $& $%@# ='/ =(#

$#@.&(=(%8H 8=%/ &:: /G(%'? $9# &::M)#=)&' =(# '&$ )#.=(=$#/ :(&@ $9# )#(+%<# %' )=%/ .#(%&/* AG$ =(# @#(#8H

<&')%/#(#/ &' 8#=+# G'$%8 (#M#@.8&H@#'$,IS

 O# $9%) =) %$ @=H* (#?G8=( )#=)&'=8 #@.8&H##)* 8%\# $9#

(#).&'/#'$) %' $9%) <=)#* )9&G8/ '&$ A# <&':G)#/ ;%$9 $9# (#?G8=( #@.8&H##) &: $9# )G?=( @%88 )G<9 =) $9#

=/@%'%)$(=$%+# &( &::%<# .#()&''#8 ;9& .#(:&(@ $9#%( $=)\) :&( $9# #'$%(# H#=( (#?=(/8#)) &: $9# )#=)&', Q9#

6U-2* $9#(#:&(#* ?(=+#8H #((#/ ;9#' %$ /#<8=(#/ $9# (#).&'/#'$) (#?G8=( #@.8&H##) &: Y-4YZ25 ;%$9&G$

]G=8%:%<=$%&' ='/ $9=$ $9#H ;#(# #'$%$8#/ $& $9# A#'#:%$) ?(='$#/* G'/#( $9# 2OJ* $& Y-4YZ25W4 (#?G8=(

#@.8&H##),

Q9%(/* ;9%8# $9# .#$%$%&'#() =))#($ $9=$ $9# (#).&'/#'$) ;#(# :(## $& ;&(\ #8)#;9#(# /G(%'? $9# &::M

)#=)&'* $9# (#<&(/) /& '&$ )G..&($ $9%) =))#($%&', Q9#(# %) '& #+%/#'<# &' (#<&(/ )9&;%'? $9=$ =:$#( $9#<&@.8#$%&' &: $9#%( $=)\) =$ Y-4YZ25* $9# (#).&'/#'$) )&G?9$ ='/ &A$=%'#/ #@.8&H@#'$ #8)#;9#(#,

2&'$(=(H $& $9# .#$%$%&'#()W .&)%$%&'* Z#(<=/&* 4(, +, 6U-2* I(/ 0%+,IR

 %) '&$ =..8%<=A8# $& $9# (#).&'/#'$)

=) $9%) <=)# ;=) (#)&8+#/ A=)#/ &' /%::#(#'$ :=<$G=8 <&')%/#(=$%&'), 3' Z#(<=/&* $9# ;&(\#() ;#(# 9%(#/ $&

.#(:&(@ .9=)#) &: $9# =?(%<G8$G(=8 ;&(\ %' $9#%( #@.8&H#(W) :=(@ :&( = /#:%'%$# .#(%&/ &: $%@#[ =:$#(;=(/)*

$9#H ;#(# :(## $& &::#( $9#%( )#(+%<#) $& ='H &$9#( :=(@ &;'#(, Q9# ;&(\#() ;#(# '&$ 9%(#/ (#?G8=(8H ='/

(#.#=$#/8H :&( $9# )=@# .9=)#K)L &: =?(%<G8$G(=8 ;&(\* AG$ &'8H %'$#(@%$$#'$8H :&( ='H )%'?8# .9=)#, J'/*

@&(# %@.&($='$8H* $9# #@.8&H#( %' Z#(<=/& )G::%<%#'$8H .(&+#/ $9#)# :=<$G=8 <%(<G@)$='<#), Q9# 2&G($

(#%$#(=$#/ $9#)# )=@# &A)#(+=$%&') %' d/=, X=$%@= +, 6=$W8 X#/, &: 4G?=(<='# 7&(\#()MX&&/ ='/ N#',

Q(=/#IT ='/ d=<%#'/= O%'&ed&($#'<%= 4$=(\#* 3'<, +, 2G#'<=,IE 

J$ $9%) .&%'$* ;# (#%$#(=$# $9# )#$$8#/ (G8# $9=$ %' $9%) `G(%)/%<$%&'* &'8H ]G#)$%&') &: 8=; =(# =88&;#/ %' =

.#$%$%&' :&( (#+%#; &' <#($%&(=(%,IP Q9%) 2&G($W) .&;#( &: (#+%#; %' = -G8# SR .#$%$%&' %) 8%@%$#/ $& (#)&8+%'?

Page 6: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 6/108

@=$$#() .#($=%'%'? $& ='H .#(<#%+#/ 8#?=8 #((&()* ;9%<9 $9# 2J @=H 9=+# <&@@%$$#/ %' %))G%'? $9# =))=%8#/

/#<%)%&',IC

 3' (#+%#;%'? $9# 8#?=8 <&((#<$'#)) &: $9# 2JW) -G8# TR /#<%)%&' %' = 8=A&( <=)#* ;# #_=@%'# $9#

2J /#<%)%&' %' $9# <&'$#_$ $9=$ %$ /#$#(@%'#/* %,#,* $9# .(#)#'<# &( =A)#'<# &: ?(=+# =AG)# &: /%)<(#$%&' %'

$9# 6U-2 /#<%)%&' A#:&(# %$ ='/ '&$ &' $9# A=)%) &: ;9#$9#( $9# 6U-2 /#<%)%&' &' $9# @#(%$) &: $9# <=)#

;=) <&((#<$,SD 3' &$9#( ;&(/)* ;# 9=+# $& A# \##'8H =;=(# $9=$ $9# 2J G'/#($&&\ = -G8# TR (#+%#;* '&$ =

(#+%#; &' =..#=8* &: $9# 6U-2 /#<%)%&' <9=88#'?#/ A#:&(# %$,S>

 

V%#;#/ %' $9%) 8%?9$* ;# :%'/ $9# '##/ $& .8=<# $9# 2JW) =::%(@=$%&'* =8A#%$ ;%$9 @&/%:%<=$%&'* &: $9# 6U-2/#<%)%&' &: FG8H BB* BDDR %' .#().#<$%+#, Q& (#<=88* $9# 6U-2 /#<8=(#/ $9# (#).&'/#'$) =) (#?G8=( #@.8&H##)

&: Y-4YZ25,SB

7%$9 )G<9 = /#<8=(=$%&'* $9# 6U-2 %' #::#<$ ?(='$#/ $9# (#).&'/#'$)W .(=H#( :&(

(#?G8=(%^=$%&' ='/* <&'<&@%$='$8H* $9#%( .(=H#( :&( $9# ?(='$ &: @&'#$=(H A#'#:%$) G'/#( $9# 2OJ :&(

Y-4YZ25W) (#?G8=( #@.8&H##), 3' %$) <9=88#'?#/ (G8%'?* $9# 2J <&'<G((#/ ;%$9 $9# 6U-2 :%'/%'?* AG$ ;%$9

$9# (#).&'/#'$) <9=(=<$#(%^#/ =) (#?G8=( )#=)&'=8 #@.8&H##) &: Y-4YZ25,

Q9# 2J @%)=..(#<%=$#/ $9# (#=8 %@.&($ &: $9# 6U-2 (G8%'?, Q9# 8=A&( =?#'<H /%/ '&$ /#<8=(# $9#

(#).&'/#'$) =) (#?G8=( )#=)&'=8 #@.8&H##)* AG$ =) (#?G8=( #@.8&H##), Q9%) %) $9# &'8H <&'<8G)%&' $9=$ <='

A# /(=;' :(&@ $9# 6U-2 /#<%)%&'W) /%).&)%$%+# .&($%&'* $9G)a

7d1-1X5-1* .(#@%)#) <&')%/#(#/* $9# =..#=8 %) 9#(#AH N-J6Q10, 2&@.8=%'='$) =(# /#<8=(#/ (#?G8=(

#@.8&H##) &: (#).&'/#'$,!"#$%&! J) )G<9* $9#H =(# #'$%$8#/ $& $9# @&'#$=(H A#'#:%$) ?(='$#/ $& (#?G8=(

#@.8&H##) &: (#).&'/#'$ <&@.='H A=)#/ &' $9# 2OJ* (#<\&'#/ $9(## KIL H#=() A=<\ :(&@ $9# :%8%'? &: $9#

=A&+#M#'$%$8#/ <=)# &' BI JG?G)$ BDDB G. $& $9# .(#)#'$ &( $& $9#%( #'$%(# )#(+%<# ;%$9 (#).&'/#'$ =:$#(

$9# /=$# &: :%8%'? &: $9# )=%/ <&@.8=%'$ %: $9#H =(# '& 8&'?#( <&''#<$#/ ;%$9 (#).&'/#'$ <&@.='H,SI

 

3$ %)* $9#(#:&(#* <8#=( $9=$ $9# %))G# A(&G?9$ $& $9# 2J :&( (#)&8G$%&' %) ;9#$9#( $9# 6U-2 ?(=+#8H =AG)#/ %$)

/%)<(#$%&' %' /#<8=(%'? $9# (#).&'/#'$) (#?G8=( #@.8&H##) &: Y-4YZ25 ='/* =) )G<9* #'$%$8#/ $& $9#

A#'#:%$) G'/#( $9# 2OJ :&( $9# (#?G8=( #@.8&H##),

O=)#/ &' $9# #)$=A8%)9#/ :=<$)* ;# :%'/ $9=$ $9# 2J ?(&))8H @%)(#=/ $9# 6U-2 (G8%'? ='/ @%))#/ $9#

%@.8%<=$%&') &: $9# (#).&'/#'$)W (#?G8=(%^=$%&', Q& (#%$#(=$#* $9# (#).&'/#'$) =(# (#?G8=( )#=)&'=8

#@.8&H##)* =) $9# 2J %$)#8: &.%'#/ ;9#' %$ /#<8=(#/ $9=$ g.(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$) ;9& =(# (#?G8=( ;&(\#()

;%$9 (#).#<$ $& $9#%( )#=)&'=8 $=)\) &( =<$%+%$%#) ='/ ;9%8# )G<9 =<$%+%$%#) #_%)$* <=''&$ =G$&@=$%<=88H A#

?&+#('#/ AH $9# 2OJ A#$;##' .#$%$%&'#( Y-4YZ25 ='/ $9# =G$9&(%^#/ A=(?=%'%'? (#.(#)#'$=$%+# &: $9#

(#?G8=( ='/ .#(@='#'$ #@.8&H##),gSS

 2%$%'? `G(%).(G/#'$%=8 )$='/=(/)*SR

 %$ $9#' .(&<##/#/ $& #_.8=%' $9=$

$9# (#).&'/#'$) <=''&$ A# 8G@.#/ ;%$9 $9# (#?G8=( #@.8&H##) /G# $& $9# /%::#(#'<#) %' $9# '=$G(# &:

$9#%( /G$%#) ='/ $9# /G(=$%&' &: $9#%( ;&(\ +%)M=M+%) $9# &.#(=$%&') &: $9# <&@.='H,

Q9# 6U-2 ;=) ;#88 =;=(# &: $9#)# /%)$%'<$%&') =) %$ =<\'&;8#/?#/ $9=$ $9# (#).&'/#'$) ;&(\#/ &'8H

/G(%'? $9# @%88%'? )#=)&'* H#$ %$ %?'&(#/ $9# /%)$%'<$%&') ='/ /#<8=(#/ $9#@ (#?G8=( #@.8&H##)* = @=(\#//#.=($G(# :(&@ #_%)$%'? `G(%).(G/#'<#, Q9%)* $& G)* %) ?(=+# =AG)# &: /%)<(#$%&'* =) %$ ?=+# '& (#=)&' :&(

/%)$G(A%'? $9# )H)$#@ &: (#?G8=( )#=)&'=8 #@.8&H@#'$ =8(#=/H %' .8=<# %' $9# )G?=( %'/G)$(H ='/ &$9#(

%'/G)$(%#) ;%$9 )%@%8=( )#=)&'=8 &.#(=$%&'), X&( G.9&8/%'? $9# 6U-2W) :8=;#/ /#<%)%&' &' $9# (#).&'/#'$)W

#@.8&H@#'$ )$=$G)* $9# 2J <&@@%$$#/ = (#+#()%A8# #((&( &: `G/?@#'$,

3' )G@* ;# :%'/ $9# <&@.8=%'$ $& A# /#+&%/ &: @#(%$, Q9# %))G# &: ?(='$%'? =::%(@=$%+# (#8%#: $& $9#

<&@.8=%'='$) ;9& /%/ '&$ =..#=8 $9# 2J (G8%'? 9=) A#<&@# =<=/#@%<,

7d1-1X5-1* .(#@%)#) <&')%/#(#/* $9# .#$%$%&' %) "J-Q3JUUk N-J6Q10, 1_<#.$ :&( $9# /#'%=8 &: $9#

(#).&'/#'$)l <8=%@ :&( 2OJ A#'#:%$)* $9# 6&+#@A#( BC* BDDE /#<%)%&' ='/ $9# F='G=(H BB* BDDC (#)&8G$%&'&: $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) =(# 41Q J4301, Q9# <&@.8=%'$ %) 034Z34410 :&( 8=<\ &: @#(%$,

45 5-01-10,

Page 7: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 7/108

 

;(#.% "< -(0(:(+5 "#$%$%&'#(*

+),

&+'(&#+ 6!)+5 '+/#() '%/!&#1: ':'1%. 234 '+/#() '%/!&#1: /+..#''#+"5 -#).&'/#'$),

0 1 2 3 4 3 5 6

'%&%"+5 $!"# 

Q9%) %) = -G8# SR "#$%$%&'> =))=%8%'? $9# 0#<%)%&'

B ='/ -#)&8G$%&'

I &: $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) K2JL %' 2JMN,-, 4",

6&, >D>TPP* =::%(@%'? $9# -#)&8G$%&'S &: $9# 4&<%=8 4#<G(%$H 2&@@%))%&' K442L, Q9# 442 9#8/ .#$%$%&'#(

F=%@# 6, N=.=H=& 8%=A8# $& .=H $9# G'.=%/ )&<%=8 )#<G(%$H <&'$(%AG$%&') /G# $& $9# /#<#=)#/ F=%@# XG8&*

='/ $9# 4&<%=8 4#<G(%$H 4H)$#@ K444L $& .=H .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ -&)=(%& U, XG8&* $9# ;%/&; &: $9# /#<#=)#/*

$9# =..(&.(%=$# /#=$9 A#'#:%$) .G()G='$ $& $9# 4&<%=8 4#<G(%$H U=;,

Q9# ='$#<#/#'$ :=<$) =(# =) :&88&;)a

5' S 6&+#@A#( >CCE* F=%@# XG8& K/#<#=)#/L /%#/ &: g=<G$# (#'=8 :=%8G(# )#<&'/=(H $& >)$ /#?(## AG(' EDm

)#<&'/=(H #8#<$(&<G$%&'gR ;9%8# /&%'? (#.=%() =$ $9# (#)%/#'<# ='/ AG)%'#)) #)$=A8%)9@#'$ &: .#$%$%&'#(

8&<=$#/ =$ 4=' FG8%='* 3(&)%'* 4&()&?&',

J88#?#/8H @&+#/ AH 9%) 29(%)$%=' :=%$9* .#$%$%&'#( #_$#'/#/ )&@# :%'='<%=8 =))%)$='<# $& .(%+=$#

(#).&'/#'$, 5' >T 6&+#@A#( >CCE* $9# 8=$$#( #_#<G$#/ =' J::%/=+%$ &: 0#)%)$='<#T )$=$%'? $9=$ )9# ;=) '&$

9&8/%'? $9#@ 8%=A8# :&( $9# /#=$9 &: 9#( 8=$# 9G)A='/* F=%@# XG8&* ='/ ;=) $9#(#AH ;=%+%'? 9#( (%?9$ ='/

/#)%)$%'? :(&@ :%8%'? ='H <(%@%'=8 &( <%+%8 =<$%&' =?=%')$ .#$%$%&'#(,

5' >S F='G=(H >CCP* A&$9 .=($%#) #_#<G$#/ = 2&@.(&@%)# J?(##@#'$*E $9# (#8#+='$ .&($%&' &: ;9%<9 %)

]G&$#/ A#8&;a

7#* $9# G'/#()%?'#/ G'$& $9%) d&'&(=A8# -#?%&'=8 5::%<#e0%)$(%<$ 5::%<#e"(&+%'<%=8 J?#'<H 5::%<#

(#).#<$:G88H )$=$#a

>, Q9# G'/#()%?'#/ #@.8&H#(* 9#(#AH =?(##) $& .=H $9# )G@ &: X5-Qk Qd5Y4J60 "1454

K"SD*DDD,DDL $& $9# )G(+%+%'? ).&G)# &: FJ3Z1 "5U5* =' #@.8&H## ;9& /%#/ &: =' =<<%/#'$* =) =

<&@.8#$# ='/ :G88 .=H@#'$ :&( =88 <8=%@) /G# $9# +%<$%@,

B, 5' $9# &$9#( 9='/* $9# G'/#()%?'#/ )G(+%+%'? ).&G)# &: $9# +%<$%@ 9=+%'? (#<#%+#/ $9# )=%/

=@&G'$ /& h)%<i 9#(#AH (#8#=)# ='/ /%)<9=(?# $9# #@.8&H#( :(&@ ='H ='/ =88 <8=%@) $9=$ @=HA# /G#$9# +%<$%@ %' <&''#<$%&' ;%$9 $9# +%<$%@W) #@.8&H@#'$ $9#(#=$,

Q9#(#=:$#(* .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ :%8#/ = <8=%@ :&( )&<%=8 )#<G(%$H A#'#:%$) ;%$9 $9# 4&<%=8 4#<G(%$H 4H)$#@

K444Lf4&(&)&?&' O(='<9,P d&;#+#(* G.&' +#(%:%<=$%&' ='/ #+=8G=$%&'* %$ ;=) /%)<&+#(#/ $9=$ $9# /#<#=)#/

;=) '&$ = (#?%)$#(#/ @#@A#( &: $9# 444,C 

Y.&' $9# %')%)$#'<# &: .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ $9=$ 9#( 8=$# 9G)A='/ 9=/ A##' #@.8&H#/ AH .#$%$%&'#( :(&@

F='G=(H >CPI G. $& 9%) G'$%@#8H /#=$9 &' S 6&+#@A#( >CCE* $9# 444 <&'/G<$#/ = :%#8/ %'+#)$%?=$%&' $&

<8=(%:H 9%) )$=$G) &: #@.8&H@#'$, 3' %$) :%#8/ %'+#)$%?=$%&' (#.&($*>D

 %$ #'G@#(=$#/ %$) :%'/%'?) =) :&88&;)a

3' <&''#<$%&' ;%$9 $9# <&@.8=%'$ :%8#/ AH Z(), -&)=(%& XG8&* 9#(#G'/#( =(# $9# :%'/%'?) .#( %'$#(+%#; ;%$9

Z(, U#&'&( 0#8?(=* 4='$%=?& O&8='&) ='/ J@=/& N=<#8&a

>, Q9=$ Z(, F=%@# XG8& ;=) =' #@.8&H## &: F=%@# N=.=H=& =) :=(@ 8=A&(#( :(&@ >CPI $& >CCE,

Page 8: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 8/108

B, Z(, U#&'&( 0#8?(= ='/ 4='$%=?& O&8='&) =(# <&M#@.8&H##) &: F=%@# XG8&,

I, Z(, F=%@# XG8& (#<#%+#) <&@.#')=$%&' &' = /=%8H A=)%) (='?%'? :(&@ "R,DD $& "TD,DD :(&@ >CPI $&

>CCE,

"#( %'$#(+%#; :(&@ Z(), 1)$#8= N=.=H=&* .8#=)# A# %':&(@#/ $9=$a

>, F=%@# XG8& %) =' #@.8&H## &: Z(, n Z(), F=%@# N=.=H=& &' =' #_$(= A=)%),

B, 4&@#$%@#) F=%@# XG8& %) =88&;#/ $& ;&(\ %' $9# :=(@ =) =A=<= 9=(+#)$#( ='/ #=(' >eI )9=(# &: %$)

9=(+#)$ =) 9%) %'<&@#,

I, Z(, n Z(), N=.=H=& 9%(#/ $9# )#(+%<#) &: F=%@# XG8& '&$ &'8H %' $9# :=(@ =) ;#88 =) %' /&%'?

9&G)# (#.=%() ;9#'#+#( %$ %) =+=%8=A8#, Z(, XG8& (#<#%+#) 9%) (#@G'#(=$%&' G)G=88H %' $9# =:$#('&&'

=:$#( /&%'? 9%) `&A,

S, Z(, n Z(), N=.=H=& 9%(#) RDM>DD .#()&') ;9#' '#<#))=(H $& ;&(\ %' $9#%( :=(@ =) 8=A&(#( ='/

F=%@# XG8& %) &'# &: $9#@, F=%@# XG8& (#<#%+#) @&(# &( 8#)) "RD,DD = /=H, [email protected]=)#) %' $9# &(%?%'=8L

2&')#]G#'$8H* $9# 444 /#@='/#/ $9=$ .#$%$%&'#( (#@%$ $9# )&<%=8 )#<G(%$H <&'$(%AG$%&') &: $9# /#<#=)#/,

79#' .#$%$%&'#( /#'%#/ $9=$ $9# /#<#=)#/ ;=) 9%) #@.8&H##* $9# 444 (#]G%(#/ .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ $&

.(#)#'$ /&<G@#'$=(H ='/ $#)$%@&'%=8 #+%/#'<# $& (#:G$# .#$%$%&'#(W) =88#?=$%&'),>>

 

3')$#=/ &: .(#)#'$%'? #+%/#'<#* .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ :%8#/ = "#$%$%&'>B

 A#:&(# $9# 442 &' >E X#A(G=(H BDDI,

3' 9#( "#$%$%&'* )9# )&G?9$ )&<%=8 )#<G(%$H <&+#(=?# ='/ .=H@#'$ &: <&'$(%AG$%&') %' &(/#( $& =+=%8 9#()#8:

&: $9# A#'#:%$) =<<(G%'? :(&@ $9# /#=$9 &: 9#( 9G)A='/,

5' T Z=H BDDI* .#$%$%&'#( :%8#/ =' J');#(>I

 /%)<8=%@%'? ='H 8%=A%8%$H &' $9# .(#@%)# $9=$ $9# /#<#=)#/ ;=)

'&$ $9# :&(@#(W) #@.8&H##* AG$ ;=) (=$9#( =' %'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&( ;9&)# $=)\) ;#(# '&$ )GA`#<$ $&.#$%$%&'#(W) <&'$(&8 ='/ )G.#(+%)%&',>S J))G@%'? =(?G#'/& $9=$ $9# /#<#=)#/ ;=) .#$%$%&'#(W) #@.8&H##*

9# ;=) )$%88 '&$ #'$%$8#/ $& A# .=%/ 9%) 444 .(#@%G@) :&( $9# %'$#(+#'%'? .#(%&/ ;9#' 9# ;=) '&$ =$ ;&(\*

=) 9# ;=) =' g%'$#(@%$$#'$ ;&(\#( ;9& ;=) &'8H )G@@&'#/ #+#(H '&; ='/ $9#' =) $9# '##/

=(&)#,g>R

 d#'<#* .#$%$%&'#( %')%)$#/ $9=$ 9# ;=) G'/#( '& &A8%?=$%&' $& (#.&($ $9# :&(@#(W) /#@%)# $& $9#

444 :&( )&<%=8 )#<G(%$H <&+#(=?#,

4GA)#]G#'$8H* &' ID FG'# BDDI* $9# 444 :%8#/ = "#$%$%&'M%'M3'$#(+#'$%&'>T A#:&(# $9# 442* &G$8%'%'? $9#

:=<$G=8 <%(<G@)$='<#) &: $9# <=)# ='/ .(=H%'? $9=$ `G/?@#'$ A# (#'/#(#/ A=)#/ &' $9# #+%/#'<# =//G<#/

AH $9# .=($%#),

5' >S Z=(<9 BDDE* $9# 442 (#'/#(#/ = -#)&8G$%&'*>E $9# /%).&)%$%+# .&($%&' &: ;9%<9 .(&+%/#)a

7d1-1X5-1* "-1Z3414 2564301-10* $9%) 2&@@%))%&' :%'/)* ='/ )& 9&8/)* $9=$ F=%@# XG8&* $9# 8=$#

9G)A='/ &: .#$%$%&'#(* ;=) #@.8&H#/ AH (#).&'/#'$ F=%@# 6, N=.=H=& :(&@ F='G=(H >CPI $& 6&+#@A#( S*

>CCE* ;&(\%'? :&( '%'# KCL @&'$9) = H#=( (#<#%+%'? $9# @%'%@G@ ;=?# $9#' .(#+=%8%'?,

J<<&(/%'?8H* $9# (#).&'/#'$ %) 9#(#AH &(/#(#/ $& .=H "SR*I>R,CR (#.(#)#'$%'? $9# G'.=%/ 44 <&'$(%AG$%&')

/G# &' A#9=8: &: /#<#=)#/ F=%@# XG8&* $9# =@&G'$ &: "B>E*E>D,II =) Im .#( @&'$9 .#'=8$H :&( 8=$#

(#@%$$='<# $9#(#&:* <&@.G$#/ =) &: Z=(<9 ID* BDDT* ;%$9&G$ .(#`G/%<# $& $9# <&88#<$%&' &: =//%$%&'=8

.#'=8$H =<<(G%'? $9#(#=:$#(* ='/ $9# )G@ &: "BID*RSB,BD K444L ='/ ">TT*DDD,DD K12L =) /=@=?#) :&( $9#:=%8G(# &: $9# (#).&'/#'$ $& (#.&($ $9# /#<#=)#/ F=%@# XG8& :&( 44 <&+#(=?# .(%&( $& 9%) /#=$9 .G()G='$ $&

4#<$%&' BSK=L &: $9# 44 U=;* =) =@#'/#/,

Page 9: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 9/108

Q9# 444 %) 9#(#AH /%(#<$#/ $& .=H .#$%$%&'#( -&)=(%& XG8& $9# =..(&.(%=$# /#=$9 A#'#:%$* .G()G='$ $&

4#<$%&' >I &: $9# 44 U=;* =) =@#'/#/* =) ;#88 =) %$) .(#+=%8%'? (G8#) ='/ (#?G8=$%&')* ='/ $& %':&(@ $9%)

2&@@%))%&' &: %$) <&@.8%='<# 9#(#;%$9,

45 5-01-10,

5' >P Z=H BDDE* .#$%$%&'#( :%8#/ = Z&$%&' :&( -#<&')%/#(=$%&'*>P

 ;9%<9 ;=) /#'%#/ %' =' 5(/#(>C

 /=$#/ >T

JG?G)$ BDDE,

J??(%#+#/* .#$%$%&'#( =..#=8#/ $& $9# 2J &' >C 0#<#@A#( BDDE,BD 5' >E Z=(<9 BD>D* $9# 2J (#'/#(#/ =

0#<%)%&'B>

 %' :=+&( &: .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$* =) :&88&;)a

3' :%'#* .GA8%< (#).&'/#'$ 442 9=/ )G::%<%#'$ A=)%) %' <&'<8G/%'? $9=$ .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$W) 9G)A='/ ;=) ='

#@.8&H## &: .#$%$%&'#( ='/ )9&G8/* $9#(#:&(#* A# #'$%$8#/ $& <&@.G8)&(H <&+#(=?# G'/#( $9# 4&<%=8

4#<G(%$H U=;,

d=+%'? (G8#/ %' :=+&( &: $9# #_%)$#'<# &: #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. A#$;##' .#$%$%&'#( ='/ $9# 8=$#

F=%@# XG8&* %$ %) '& 8&'?#( '#<#))=(H $& /;#88 &' $9# &$9#( %))G#) (=%)#/,

-#)G8$='$8H* :&( 9%) :=%8G(# $& (#.&($ F=%@# XG8& :&( <&@.G8)&(H )&<%=8 )#<G(%$H <&+#(=?#* .#$%$%&'#( )9&G8/

A#=( $9# <&')#]G#'<#) $9#(#&:, Y'/#( $9# 8=;* =' #@.8&H#( ;9& :=%8) $& (#.&($ 9%) #@.8&H## :&( )&<%=8

)#<G(%$H <&+#(=?# %) 8%=A8# $& h>i .=H $9# A#'#:%$) &: $9&)# ;9& /%#* A#<&@# /%)=A8#/* ?#$ )%<\ &( (#=<9

(#$%(#@#'$ =?#[ hBi .=H =88 G'.=%/ <&'$(%AG$%&') .8G) = .#'=8$H &: $9(## .#(<#'$ .#( @&'$9[ ='/ hIi A# 9#8/

8%=A8# :&( = <(%@%'=8 &::#')# .G'%)9=A8# AH :%'# ='/e&( %@.(%)&'@#'$, OG$ =' #@.8&H## %) )$%88 #'$%$8#/ $&

)&<%=8 )#<G(%$H A#'#:%$) #+#' %) K)%<L 9%) #@.8&H#( :=%8) &( (#:G)#) $& (#@%$ 9%) <&'$(%AG$%&' $& $9# 444,

7d1-1X5-1* .(#@%)#) <&')%/#(#/* $9# -#)&8G$%&' =..#=8#/ :(&@ %) JXX3-Z10 %' $&$&,

45 5-01-10,

3' 9&8/%'? $9G)* $9# 2J ?=+# <(#/#'<# $& $9# :%'/%'?) &: $9# 442, Q9# =..#88=$# <&G($ 9#8/ $9=$ %$ g/&#) '&$

:&88&; $9=$ = .#()&' ;9& /&#) '&$ &A)#(+# '&(@=8 9&G() &: ;&(\ <=''&$ A# /##@#/ =' #@.8&H##,gBB

 X&(

&'#* %$ %) '&$ #))#'$%=8 :&( $9# #@.8&H#( $& =<$G=88H )G.#(+%)# $9# .#(:&(@='<# &: /G$%#) &: $9# #@.8&H##[ %$

%) )G::%<%#'$ $9=$ $9# :&(@#( 9=) = (%?9$ $& ;%#8/ $9# .&;#(, 3' $9%) <=)#* .#$%$%&'#( #_#(<%)#/ 9%) <&'$(&8

$9(&G?9 =' &+#()##( %' $9# .#()&' &: J@=/& N=<#8&* $9# $#'='$ &' .#$%$%&'#(W) 8='/,BI

 Z&)$ %@.&($='$*

.#$%$%&'#( #'$#(#/ %'$& = 2&@.(&@%)# J?(##@#'$ ;%$9 .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ ='/ #_.(#))8H =/@%$$#/ $9#(#%'

$9=$ 9# ;=) $9# #@.8&H#( &: $9# /#<#=)#/,BS

Q9# 2J %'$#(.(#$#/ $9%) =/@%))%&' =) = /#<8=(=$%&' =?=%')$

%'$#(#)$* .G()G='$ $& 4#<$%&' BT* -G8# >ID &: $9# -G8#) &: 2&G($,BR

 

d#'<#* $9%) .#$%$%&',

"GA8%< (#).&'/#'$) 444BT

 ='/ 442BE

 :%8#/ $9#%( 2&@@#'$) &' I> F='G=(H BD>> ='/ BP X#A(G=(H BD>>*

(#).#<$%+#8H* ;9%8# .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ :%8#/ 9#( 2&@@#'$ &' >S Z=(<9 BD>>,BP

 5' T Z=(<9 BD>B*

.#$%$%&'#( :%8#/ = g2&')&8%/=$#/ -#.8H $& $9# 2&@@#'$) &: $9# "GA8%< -#).&'/#'$) 444 ='/ 442 ='/ "(%+=$#

-#).&'/#'$ -&)=(%& XG8&,gBC

 

344Y1

Q9# )&8# %))G# .(#)#'$#/ A#:&(# G) %) ;9#$9#( &( '&$ $9#(# #_%)$) A#$;##' $9# /#<#=)#/ F=%@# XG8& ='/.#$%$%&'#( =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. $9=$ ;&G8/ @#(%$ =' =;=(/ &: A#'#:%$) %' :=+&( &: .(%+=$#

(#).&'/#'$ G'/#( )&<%=8 )#<G(%$H 8=;),

Qd1 25Y-QW4 -YU36N

Page 10: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 10/108

3' =))#($%'? $9# #_%)$#'<# &: =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%.* .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ =88#?#) $9=$ 9#( 8=$#

9G)A='/ 9=/ A##' %' $9# #@.8&H &: .#$%$%&'#( :&( >S H#=()* :(&@ >CPI $& >CCE,ID

 0G(%'? $9=$ .#(%&/* 9#

;=) @=/# $& ;&(\ =) = 8=A&(#( %' $9# =?(%<G8$G(=8 8='/9&8/%'?)* = 9=(+#)$#( %' $9# =A=<= .8='$=$%&'* ='/ =

(#.=%(@='eG$%8%$H ;&(\#( %' )#+#(=8 AG)%'#)) #)$=A8%)9@#'$) &;'#/ AH .#$%$%&'#(,I> Q& .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$*

$9# g<&')%/#(=A8# 8#'?$9 &: $%@# /G(%'? ;9%<9 h$9# /#<#=)#/i ;=) ?%+#' /%+#()# $=)\) AH .#$%$%&'#( ;=) =

<8#=( %'/%<=$%&' &: $9# '#<#))%$H ='/ %'/%).#')=A%8%$H &: 9#( 8=$# 9G)A='/W) )#(+%<#) $& .#$%$%&'#(W)

AG)%'#)),gIB

 Q9%) +%#; %) A&8)$#(#/ AH $9# =/@%))%&' &: .#$%$%&'#( 9%@)#8: %' $9# 2&@.(&@%)# J?(##@#'$

$9=$ 9# ;=) $9# /#<#=)#/W) #@.8&H#(,II

 

"(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$W) .&)%$%&' %) )%@%8=(8H #).&G)#/ AH $9# 442* ;9%<9 <&'$#'/) $9=$ %$) :%'/%'?) =(# /G8H

)G..&($#/ AH #+%/#'<# &' (#<&(/,IS

 3$ %')%)$) $9=$ .=\H=; ;&(\#() =(# <&')%/#(#/ #@.8&H##)* =) 8&'? =) $9#

#@.8&H#( #_#(<%)#) <&'$(&8 &+#( $9#@, 3' $9%) <=)#* $9# #_#(<%)# &: <&'$(&8 AH $9# #@.8&H#( ;=) /#8#?=$#/

$& $9# <=(#$=\#( &: 9%) :=(@* J@=/& N=<#8&, Q9# 442 :G($9#( =))#($) $9=$ $9# /#<#=)#/ (#'/#(#/ )#(+%<#)

#))#'$%=8 :&( $9# .#$%$%&'#(W) 9=(+#)$, 79%8# $9#)# )#(+%<#) ;#(# '&$ (#'/#(#/ <&'$%'G&G)8H K%' $9# )#')#

$9=$ $9#H ;#(# '&$ (#'/#(#/ #+#(H /=H $9(&G?9&G$ $9# H#=(L* )$%88* $9# /#<#=)#/ 9=/ '#+#( )$&..#/

;&(\%'? :&( .#$%$%&'#( :(&@ H#=( $& H#=( G'$%8 $9# /=H $9# :&(@#( /%#/,IR

 3' :=<$* $9# /#<#=)#/ ;=) (#]G%(#/

$& ;&(\ %' $9# &$9#( AG)%'#)) +#'$G(#) &: .#$%$%&'#(* )G<9 =) $9# 8=$$#(W) A=\#(H ='/ ?(&<#(H )$&(#,IT

 Q9#

2&@.(&@%)# J?(##@#'$ #'$#(#/ %'$& AH .#$%$%&'#( ;%$9 .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ )9&G8/ '&$ A# = A=( $& ='#@.8&H## /#@='/%'? ;9=$ %) 8#?=88H /G# $9# 8=$$#(,IE

 

Q9# 444* ;9%8# <8=(%:H%'? $9=$ %$ %) g'#%$9#( =/+#()=(%=8 '&( :=+&(%'? ='H &: $9# .(%+=$# .=($%#) _ _ _ =) %$ %)

&'8H $=)\#/ $& <=((H &G$ $9# .G(.&)#) &: $9# 4&<%=8 4#<G(%$H U=;*gIP

 =?(##) ;%$9 A&$9 .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$

='/ 442, 3$ )$(#))#) $9=$ :=<$G=8 :%'/%'?) &: $9# 8&;#( <&G($)* ;9#' =::%(@#/ AH $9# =..#88=$# <&G($* =(#

?#'#(=88H <&'<8G)%+# ='/ A%'/%'? G.&' $9# 2&G($,IC

 

"#$%$%&'#(* &' $9# &$9#( 9='/* %')%)$) $9=$ $9# /#<#=)#/ ;=) '&$ 9%) #@.8&H##, 4G..&)#/8H* $9# 8=$$#(*

/G(%'? $9# .#(:&(@='<# &: 9%) :G'<$%&'* ;=) '&$ G'/#( .#$%$%&'#(W) <&'$(&8, 2&'$(&8 %) '&$ '#<#))=(%8H

.(#)#'$ #+#' %: $9# ;&(\#( ;&(\) %')%/# $9# .(#@%)#) &: $9# .#()&' ;9& 9=) #'?=?#/ 9%)

)#(+%<#),SD N(='$%'? ;%$9&G$ =/@%$$%'? $9=$ .#$%$%&'#( ?=+# (G8#) &( ?G%/#8%'#) $& $9# /#<#=)#/ %' $9#

.(&<#)) &: $9# 8=$$#(W) .#(:&(@%'? 9%) ;&(\* $9# )%$G=$%&' <=''&$ A# %'$#(.(#$#/ =) <&'$(&8* A#<=G)# %$ ;=)

&'8H %'$#'/#/ $& .(&@&$# @G$G=88H /#)%(#/ (#)G8$),S> 

J8$#('=$%+#8H* .#$%$%&'#( %')%)$) $9=$ $9# /#<#=)#/ ;=) 9%(#/ AH J/&8:& N=@A=* $9# <&'$(=<$&( ;9&@ 9# 9=/

9%(#/ $& <&')$(G<$ $9#%( AG%8/%'?[SB

 ='/ AH J@=/& N=<#8&* $9# $#'='$ ;9&@ .#$%$%&'#( %')$(G<$#/ $&

@='=?# $9# 8=$$#(W) :=(@,SI

 X&( $9%) (#=)&'* .#$%$%&'#( A#8%#+#) $9=$ = $#'='$ %) '&$ A#9&8/#' $& $9#

8='/8&(/ ='/ %) '&$ G'/#( $9# 8=$$#(W) <&'$(&8 ='/ )G.#(+%)%&', 4& %: = ;&(\#( %) 9%(#/ $& ;&(\ &' $9# 8='/ &:

= $#'='$ f )G<9 =) .#$%$%&'#( f $9# :&(@#( <=''&$ A# $9# ;&(\#( &: $9# 8='/8&(/* AG$ &: $9# $#'='$W),SS 

J'#'$ $9# 2&@.(&@%)# J?(##@#'$* .#$%$%&'#( <8=(%:%#) $9=$ %$ ;=) #_#<G$#/ $& AGH .#=<#* A#<=G)#g(#).&'/#'$ \#.$ &' .#)$#(%'? $9#@ AH =)\%'? :&( @&'#H,g

SR "#$%$%&'#( =88#?#/8H (#<#%+#/ $9(#=$) $9=$ %:

$9# @=$$#( ;=) '&$ )#$$8#/* .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ ;&G8/ (#:#( $9# @=$$#( $& $9# 6#; "#&.8#)W

J(@H,ST J88#?#/8H* $9# 2&@.(&@%)# J?(##@#'$ ;=) g#_$&($%&' <=@&G:8=?#/ =) =' =?(##@#'$,gSE U%\#;%)#*

.#$%$%&'#( @=%'$=%') $9=$ 9# )9&G8/#(#/ $9# 9&).%$=8%^=$%&' ='/ AG(%=8 #_.#')#) &: $9# /#<#=)#/ $& #_.(#))

9%) g<&@.=))%&' ='/ )H@.=$9H $& = /%)$(#))#/ .#()&' ='/ 9%) :=@%8H*g ='/ '&$ $& =/@%$ 8%=A%8%$H,SP

 

U=)$8H* .#$%$%&'#( =88#?#) $9=$ $9# /#<#=)#/ %) = :(##8='<# ;&(\#(, 4%'<# 9# ;=) #'?=?#/ &' = .=\H=; A=)%)

='/ ;&(\#/ :&( = )9&($ .#(%&/ &: $%@#* %' $9# '=$G(# &: = :=(@ ;&(\#( #+#(H )#=)&'* 9# ;=) '&$ .(#<8G/#/

:(&@ ;&(\%'? ;%$9 &$9#( .#()&') ='/ %' :=<$ ;&(\#/ :&( $9#@, Y'/#( J($%<8# BPD &: $9# U=A&(

2&/#*SC )#=)&'=8 #@.8&H##) =(# '&$ <&+#(#/ AH $9# /#:%'%$%&') &: (#?G8=( ='/ <=)G=8#@.8&H##),

RD "#$%$%&'#( <%$#) Z#(<=/&* 4(, +, 6U-2*

R> %' ;9%<9 $9# 2&G($ 9#8/ $9=$ )#=)&'=8 ;&(\#() /& '&$

A#<&@# (#?G8=( #@.8&H##) AH $9# @#(# :=<$ $9=$ $9#H 9=+# (#'/#(#/ =$ 8#=)$ &'# H#=( &: )#(+%<#* ;9#$9#(

<&'$%'G&G) &( A(&\#',RB

 

Page 11: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 11/108

7# )## '& <&?#'$ (#=)&' $& (#+#()# $9# 2J,

3

X%'/%'?) &: :=<$ &: $9# 442 =(# ?%+#' ;#%?9$ ='/ <(#/#'<#,

J$ $9# &G$)#$* %$ %) )#$$8#/ $9=$ $9# 2&G($ %) '&$ = $(%#( &: :=<$) ='/ ;%88 '&$ ;#%?9 #+%/#'<# =88 &+#( =?=%',

X%'/%'?) &: :=<$ &: =/@%'%)$(=$%+# =?#'<%#) ='/ ]G=)%M`G/%<%=8 A&/%#)* ;9%<9 9=+# =<]G%(#/ #_.#($%)#A#<=G)# $9#%( `G(%)/%<$%&' %) <&':%'#/ $& ).#<%:%< @=$$#()* =(# ?#'#(=88H =<<&(/#/ '&$ &'8H (#).#<$ AG$

:%'=8%$H ;9#' =::%(@#/ AH $9# 2J,RI X&( =) 8&'? =) $9#)# :%'/%'?) =(# )G..&($#/ AH )GA)$='$%=8 #+%/#'<#*

$9#H @G)$ A# G.9#8/,RS

 

33

X=(@ ;&(\#() @=H A# <&')%/#(#/ (#?G8=( )#=)&'=8 #@.8&H##),

J($%<8# BPD &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# )$=$#)a

J($%<8# BPD, -#?G8=( ='/ 2=)G=8 [email protected]&H@#'$, o Q9# .(&+%)%&') &: ;(%$$#' =?(##@#'$ $& $9# <&'$(=(H

'&$;%$9)$='/%'? ='/ (#?=(/8#)) &: $9# &(=8 =?(##@#'$ &: $9# .=($%#)* =' #@.8&H@#'$ )9=88 A# /##@#/ $&

A# (#?G8=( ;9#(# $9# #@.8&H## 9=) A##' #'?=?#/ $& .#(:&(@ =<$%+%$%#) ;9%<9 =(# G)G=88H '#<#))=(H &(

/#)%(=A8# %' $9# G)G=8 AG)%'#)) &( $(=/# &: $9# #@.8&H#(* #_<#.$ ;9#(# $9# #@.8&H@#'$ 9=) A##' :%_#/ :&(

= ).#<%:%< .(&`#<$ &( G'/#($=\%'? $9# <&@.8#$%&' &( $#(@%'=$%&' &: ;9%<9 9=) A##' /#$#(@%'#/ =$ $9# $%@#

&: $9# #'?=?#@#'$ &: $9# #@.8&H## &( ;9#(# $9# ;&(\ &( )#(+%<#) $& A# .#(:&(@#/ %) )#=)&'=8 %' '=$G(#

='/ $9# #@.8&H@#'$ %) :&( $9# /G(=$%&' &: $9# )#=)&',

J' #@.8&H@#'$ )9=88 A# /##@#/ $& A# <=)G=8 %: %$ %) '&$ <&+#(#/ AH $9# .(#<#/%'? .=(=?(=.9a "(&+%/#/*

Q9=$* ='H #@.8&H## ;9& 9=) (#'/#(#/ =$ 8#=)$ &'# H#=( &: )#(+%<# ;9#$9#( )G<9 )#(+%<# %) <&'$%'G&G) &(

A(&\#'* )9=88 A# <&')%/#(#/ = (#?G8=( #@.8&H## ;%$9 (#).#<$ $& $9# =<$%+%$H %' ;9%<9 9# %) #@.8&H#/ ='/ 9%)#@.8&H@#'$ )9=88 <&'$%'G# ;9%8# )G<9 =<$G=88H #_%)$),

FG(%).(G/#'<# 9=) %/#'$%:%#/ $9# $9(## $H.#) &: #@.8&H##) @#'$%&'#/ %' $9# .(&+%)%&'a K>L (#?G8=(

#@.8&H##) &( $9&)# ;9& 9=+# A##' #'?=?#/ $& .#(:&(@ =<$%+%$%#) $9=$ =(# G)G=88H '#<#))=(H &( /#)%(=A8# %'

$9# G)G=8 AG)%'#)) &( $(=/# &: $9# #@.8&H#([ KBL .(&`#<$ #@.8&H##) &( $9&)# ;9&)# #@.8&H@#'$ 9=) A##'

:%_#/ :&( = ).#<%:%< .(&`#<$ &( G'/#($=\%'?* $9# <&@.8#$%&' &( $#(@%'=$%&' &: ;9%<9 9=) A##' /#$#(@%'#/ =$

$9# $%@# &: $9#%( #'?=?#@#'$* &( $9&)# ;9&)# ;&(\ &( )#(+%<# %) )#=)&'=8 %' '=$G(# ='/ %) .#(:&(@#/ :&(

$9# /G(=$%&' &: $9# )#=)&'[ ='/ KIL <=)G=8 #@.8&H##) &( $9&)# ;9& =(# '#%$9#( (#?G8=( '&( .(&`#<$

#@.8&H##),RR

 

X=(@ ;&(\#() ?#'#(=88H :=88 G'/#( $9# /#:%'%$%&' &: )#=)&'=8 #@.8&H##), 7# 9=+# <&')%)$#'$8H 9#8/ $9=$

)#=)&'=8 #@.8&H##) @=H A# <&')%/#(#/ =) (#?G8=( #@.8&H##),RT

 -#?G8=( )#=)&'=8 #@.8&H##) =(# $9&)#

<=88#/ $& ;&(\ :(&@ $%@# $& $%@#, Q9# '=$G(# &: $9#%( (#8=$%&')9%. ;%$9 $9# #@.8&H#( %) )G<9 $9=$ /G(%'? $9#

&:: )#=)&'* $9#H =(# $#@.&(=(%8H 8=%/ &::[ AG$ (##@.8&H#/ /G(%'? $9# )G@@#( )#=)&' &( ;9#' $9#%( )#(+%<#)

@=H A# '##/#/,RE

 Q9#H =(# %' (#?G8=( #@.8&H@#'$ A#<=G)# &: $9# '=$G(# &: $9#%( `&A*='/ '&$ A#<=G)# &:

$9# 8#'?$9 &: $%@# $9#H 9=+# ;&(\#/,RP

 

Q9# (G8#* 9&;#+#(* %) '&$ =A)&8G$#, 3' d=<%#'/= X=$%@= +, 6=$%&'=8 X#/#(=$%&' &: 4G?=(<='# 7&(\#()MX&&/

n N#'#(=8 Q(=/#*RC

 $9# 2&G($ 9#8/ $9=$ )#=)&'=8 ;&(\#() ;9& 9=+# ;&(\#/ :&( &'# )#=)&' &'8H @=H '&$ A#

<&')%/#(#/ (#?G8=( #@.8&H##), 4%@%8=(8H* %' Z#(<=/&* 4(, +, 6U-2*TD

 %$ ;=) 9#8/ $9=$ ;9#' )#=)&'=8#@.8&H##) =(# :(## $& <&'$(=<$ $9#%( )#(+%<#) ;%$9 &$9#( :=(@ &;'#()* $9#' $9# :&(@#( =(# '&$ (#?G8=(

#@.8&H##),

Page 12: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 12/108

X&( (#?G8=( #@.8&H##) $& A# <&')%/#(#/ =) )G<9* $9# .(%@=(H )$='/=(/ G)#/ %) $9# (#=)&'=A8# <&''#<$%&'

A#$;##' $9# .=($%<G8=( =<$%+%$H $9#H .#(:&(@ ='/ $9# G)G=8 $(=/# &( AG)%'#)) &: $9# #@.8&H#(,T>

 Q9%) $#)$

9=) A##' #_.8=%'#/ $9&(&G?98H %' 0# U#&' +, 6U-2*TB

 +%^a

Q9# .(%@=(H )$='/=(/* $9#(#:&(#* &: /#$#(@%'%'? = (#?G8=( #@.8&H@#'$ %) $9# (#=)&'=A8# <&''#<$%&'

A#$;##' $9# .=($%<G8=( =<$%+%$H .#(:&(@#/ AH $9# #@.8&H## %' (#8=$%&' $& $9# G)G=8 AG)%'#)) &( $(=/# &: $9#

#@.8&H#(, Q9# $#)$ %) ;9#$9#( $9# :&(@#( %) G)G=88H '#<#))=(H &( /#)%(=A8# %' $9# G)G=8 AG)%'#)) &( $(=/# &:

$9# #@.8&H#(, Q9# <&''#<$%&' <=' A# /#$#(@%'#/ AH <&')%/#(%'? $9# '=$G(# &: $9# ;&(\ .#(:&(@#/ ='/ %$)(#8=$%&' $& $9# )<9#@# &: $9# .=($%<G8=( AG)%'#)) &( $(=/# %' %$) #'$%(#$H, J8)& %: $9# #@.8&H## 9=) A##'

.#(:&(@%'? $9# `&A :&( =$ 8#=)$ &'# H#=(* #+#' %: $9# .#(:&(@='<# %) '&$ <&'$%'G&G) &( @#(#8H %'$#(@%$$#'$*

$9# 8=; /##@) $9# (#.#=$#/ ='/ <&'$%'G%'? '##/ :&( %$) .#(:&(@='<# =) )G::%<%#'$ #+%/#'<# &: $9#

'#<#))%$H %: '&$ %'/%).#')=A%8%$H &: $9=$ =<$%+%$H $& $9# AG)%'#)), d#'<#* $9# #@.8&H@#'$ %) =8)& <&')%/#(#/

(#?G8=(* AG$ &'8H ;%$9 (#).#<$ $& )G<9 =<$%+%$H ='/ ;9%8# )G<9 =<$%+%$H #_%)$),

J (#=/%'? &: $9# (#<&(/) (#+#=8) $9=$ $9# /#<#=)#/ ;=) %'/##/ = :=(@ ;&(\#( ;9& ;=) %' $9# (#?G8=(

#@.8&H &: .#$%$%&'#(, X(&@ H#=( $& H#=(* )$=($%'? F='G=(H >CPI G. G'$%8 9%) /#=$9* $9# /#<#=)#/ 9=/ A##'

;&(\%'? &' .#$%$%&'#(W) 8='/ AH 9=(+#)$%'? =A=<= ='/ <&<&'G$* .(&<#))%'? <&.(=* ='/ <8#=(%'? ;##/), d%)

#@.8&H@#'$ ;=) <&'$%'G&G) %' $9# )#')# $9=$ %$ ;=) /&'# :&( @&(# $9=' &'# 9=(+#)$%'? )#=)&',Z&(#&+#(* '& =@&G'$ &: (#=)&'%'? <&G8/ /#$(=<$ :(&@ $9# :=<$ $9=$ $9#)# $=)\) ;#(# '#<#))=(H &(

/#)%(=A8# %' $9# G)G=8 AG)%'#)) &: .#$%$%&'#(,

Q9# &$9#( $=)\) =88#?#/8H /&'# AH $9# /#<#=)#/ &G$)%/# 9%) G)G=8 :=(@ ;&(\ &'8H A&8)$#( $9# #_%)$#'<# &:

=' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%., J) :&G'/ AH $9# 442* $9# /#<#=)#/ ;=) = <&')$(G<$%&' ;&(\#( %' $9#

AG%8/%'? ='/ = 9#8.#( %' $9# A=\#(H* ?(&<#(H* 9=(/;=(#* ='/ .%??#(H f =88 &;'#/ AH .#$%$%&'#(,TI

 Q9%) :=<$

&'8H .(&+#) $9=$ #+#' /G(%'? $9# &:: )#=)&'* $9# /#<#=)#/ ;=) )$%88 %' $9# #@.8&H &: .#$%$%&'#(,

Q9# @&)$ $#88%'? %'/%<%= &: $9%) (#8=$%&')9%. %) $9# 2&@.(&@%)# J?(##@#'$ #_#<G$#/ AH .#$%$%&'#( ='/

.(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$, 3$ %) = +=8%/ =?(##@#'$ =) 8&'? =) $9# <&')%/#(=$%&' %) (#=)&'=A8# ='/ $9# #@.8&H##

)%?'#/ $9# ;=%+#( +&8G'$=(%8H* ;%$9 = :G88 G'/#()$='/%'? &: ;9=$ 9# &( )9# ;=) #'$#(%'? %'$&,TS J88 $9=$ %)

(#]G%(#/ :&( $9# <&@.(&@%)# $& A# /##@#/ +&8G'$=(%8H #'$#(#/ %'$& %) .#()&'=8 ='/ ).#<%:%< %'/%+%/G=8

<&')#'$,TR

 5'<# #_#<G$#/ AH $9# ;&(\#() &( #@.8&H##) ='/ $9#%( #@.8&H#() $& )#$$8# $9#%( /%::#(#'<#)* ='/

/&'# %' ?&&/ :=%$9* = 2&@.(&@%)# J?(##@#'$ %) /##@#/ +=8%/ ='/ A%'/%'? =@&'? $9# .=($%#),TT

 

"#$%$%&'#( #'$#(#/ %'$& $9# =?(##@#'$ ;%$9 :G88 \'&;8#/?# $9=$ 9# ;=) /#)<(%A#/ =) $9# #@.8&H#( &: $9#

/#<#=)#/,TE

Q9%) \'&;8#/?# <=''&$ )%@.8H A# /#'%#/ AH = )$=$#@#'$ $9=$ .#$%$%&'#( ;=) @#(#8H :&(<#/ &(

$9(#=$#'#/ %'$& )G<9 =' =?(##@#'$,!"#$%&! d%) A#8=$#/ =$$#@.$ $& <%(<G@+#'$ $9# =?(##@#'$ )9&G8/ '&$

A# ?%+#' ='H <&')%/#(=$%&' &( ;#%?9$ AH $9%) 2&G($,

333

"=\H=; ;&(\#() =(# (#?G8=( #@.8&H##)*

.(&+%/#/ $9#H =(# )GA`#<$ $& $9# <&'$(&8 &: .#$%$%&'#(,

"=\H=; ;&(\#() =(# <&')%/#(#/ #@.8&H##) :&( =) 8&'? =) $9#%( #@.8&H#() #_#(<%)# <&'$(&8 &+#( $9#@, 3'

U#?#'/ d&$#8 Z='%8= +, -#=8GH&*TP

 $9# 2&G($ 9#8/ $9=$ g$9# .&;#( &: $9# #@.8&H#( $& <&'$(&8 $9# ;&(\ &:

$9# #@.8&H## %) <&')%/#(#/ $9# @&)$ )%?'%:%<='$ /#$#(@%'='$ &: $9# #_%)$#'<# &: =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H##

(#8=$%&')9%., Q9%) %) $9# )&M<=88#/ <&'$(&8 $#)$ ='/ %) .(#@%)#/ &' ;9#$9#( $9# .#()&' :&( ;9&@ $9#

)#(+%<#) =(# .#(:&(@#/ (#)#(+#) $9# (%?9$ $& <&'$(&8 A&$9 $9# #'/ =<9%#+#/ ='/ $9# @=''#( ='/ @#=')G)#/ $& =<9%#+# $9=$ #'/,g 3$ )9&G8/ A# (#@#@A#(#/ $9=$ $9# <&'$(&8 $#)$ @#(#8H <=88) :&( $9# #_%)$#'<# &:

$9# (%?9$ $& <&'$(&8* ='/ '&$ '#<#))=(%8H $9# #_#(<%)# $9#(#&:,TC

 3$ %) '&$ #))#'$%=8 $9=$ $9# #@.8&H#( =<$G=88H

Page 13: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 13/108

)G.#(+%)#) $9# .#(:&(@='<# &: /G$%#) AH $9# #@.8&H##, 3$ %) #'&G?9 $9=$ $9# :&(@#( 9=) = (%?9$ $& ;%#8/ $9#

.&;#(,ED

 

3' $9%) <=)#* ;# =?(## ;%$9 $9# 2J $9=$ .#$%$%&'#( ;%#8/#/ <&'$(&8 &+#( $9# /#<#=)#/ %' $9# /%)<9=(?# &: 9%)

:G'<$%&'), O#%'? $9# &;'#( &: $9# :=(@ &' ;9%<9 $9# 8=$$#( ;&(\#/* .#$%$%&'#( f &' 9%) &;' &( $9(&G?9 9%)

&+#()##( f '#<#))=(%8H 9=/ $9# (%?9$ $& (#+%#; $9# ]G=8%$H &: ;&(\ .(&/G<#/ AH 9%) 8=A&(#(), 3$ @=$$#() '&$

;9#$9#( $9# /#<#=)#/ <&'/G<$#/ 9%) ;&(\ %')%/# .#$%$%&'#(W) :=(@ &( '&$ A#<=G)# .#$%$%&'#( (#$=%'#/ $9#

(%?9$ $& <&'$(&8 9%@ %' 9%) ;&(\* ='/ %' :=<$ #_#(<%)#/ %$ $9(&G?9 9%) :=(@ @='=?#( J@=/& N=<#8&, Q9#8=$$#( 9%@)#8: $#)$%:%#/ $9=$ .#$%$%&'#( 9=/ 9%(#/ $9# /#<#=)#/ =) &'# &: $9# .=\H=; ;&(\#() ;9&)# )=8=(%#)

;#(# /#(%+#/ :(&@ $9# ?(&)) .(&<##/) &: $9# 9=(+#)$,E>

 

7# /& '&$ ?%+# <(#/#'<# $& $9# =88#?=$%&' $9=$ $9# /#<#=)#/ ;=) =' %'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&( 9%(#/ AH =

<#($=%' J/&8:& N=@A=* $9# <&'$(=<$&( ;9&@ .#$%$%&'#( 9%@)#8: 9=/ 9%(#/ $& AG%8/ = AG%8/%'?, Q9# =88#?=$%&'

;=) A=)#/ &' $9# )#8:M)#(+%'? $#)$%@&'H &: F&H<# N=.=H 0#@=$#*EB

 $9# /=G?9$#( &: .#$%$%&'#(, Q9# 8=$$#(

9=) '&$ &::#(#/ ='H &$9#( .(&&: =.=($ :(&@ 9#( $#)$%@&'H $& .(&+# $9# <&'$#'$%&',

Q9# (%?9$ &: =' #@.8&H## $& A# <&+#(#/ AH $9# 4&<%=8 4#<G(%$H J<$ %) .(#@%)#/ &' $9# #_%)$#'<# &: ='

#@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%.,

EI

 Q9=$ 9=+%'? A##' #)$=A8%)9#/* $9# 2&G($ 9#(#AH (G8#) %' 9>+&( &:.(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$,

7d1-1X5-1* $9# "#$%$%&' :&( -#+%#; &' 2#($%&(=(% %) 9#(#AH 016310, Q9# =))=%8#/ 0#<%)%&' ='/ (#)&8G$%&'

&: $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) %' 2JMN,-, 4", 6&, >D>TPP /=$#/ >E Z=(<9 BD>D ='/ >I JG?G)$ BD>D* (#).#<$%+#8H*

=(# 9#(#AH JXX3-Z10,

45 5-01-10,

Page 14: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 14/108

 

&+: 7< 0 ('+'5 "#$%$%&'#(*

+),

09#)#00#"% "(1#+"() /+"'1&!/1#+" /+&0+&(1#+"5 -#).&'/#'$,

0 1 2 3 4 3 5 6

$#))(&(.(5 ;&<5 !"# 

O#:&(# G) %) = .#$%$%&' :&( (#+%#; &' <#($%&(=(% G'/#( -G8# SR &: $9# >CCE -G8#) &: 2%+%8 "(&<#/G(#* =)

=@#'/#/* =))=%8%'? $9# Z=(<9 BT* BD>D 0#<%)%&'> ='/ Z=H BT* BD>D -#)&8G$%&'

B &: $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8)

K2JL %' 2JMN,-, 4" 6&, >DEPDR, Q9# =..#88=$# <&G($ 9=/ =::%(@#/ $9# 0#<%)%&'I &: $9# 6=$%&'=8 U=A&(

-#8=$%&') 2&@@%))%&' K6U-2L /%)@%))%'? $9# %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8 <&@.8=%'$ :%8#/ AH .#$%$%&'#( -&H 0, "=)&)

=?=%')$ (#).&'/#'$ "9%8%..%'# 6=$%&'=8 2&')$(G<$%&' 2&(.&(=$%&' K"622L,

Q9# ='$#<#/#'$ :=<$) :&88&;a

"#$%$%&'#( -&H 0, "=)&) )$=($#/ ;&(\%'? :&( (#).&'/#'$ "622 &' J.(%8 BT* >CCT, O=)#/ &' $9# "622l)

g"#()&''#8 J<$%&' X&(@ J..&%'$@#'$ :&( "(&`#<$ [email protected]&H@#'$g /=$#/ J.(%8 ID* >CCT*S .#$%$%&'#( ;=)

/#)%?'=$#/ =) g28#(\ 33 KJ<<&G'$%'?Lg ='/ ;=) =))%?'#/ $& $9# g6J3J f 33 "(&`#<$,g 3$ ;=) 8%\#;%)# )$=$#/

$9#(#%'a

"J-Q32YUJ-4a "(&`#<$ #@.8&H@#'$ )$=($%'? &' J.(%8 BT* >CCT $& FG8H BR* >CCT, Q9%) <&'$(=<$ @=HA#

$#(@%'=$#/ =$ ='H$%@# :&( <=G)# =) .(&+%/#/ :&( AH 8=; ='/e&( #_%)$%'? 2&@.='H "&8%<H, Q9%) @=HA#

$#(@%'=$#/ %: )#(+%<#) =(# G')=$%):=<$&(H* &( ;9#' %$ )9=88 '& 8&'?#( '##/#/* =) /#$#(@%'#/ AH $9#

2&@.='H, 3: )#(+%<#) =(# )$%88 '##/#/ A#H&'/ $9# +=8%/%$H &: $9%) <&'$(=<$* $9# 2&@.='H )9=88 #_$#'/ H&G(

)#(+%<#), J:$#( )#(+%<#) =(# $#(@%'=$#/* $9# #@.8&H## )9=88 A# G'/#( '& &A8%?=$%&' $& (#M#@.8&H ;%$9 $9#

2&@.='H '&( )9=88 $9# 2&@.='H A# &A8%?#/ $& (#M#@.8&H $9# #@.8&H##,R [email protected]=)%) )G..8%#/,L

"#$%$%&'#(W) #@.8&H@#'$* 9&;#+#(* /%/ '&$ #'/ &' FG8H BR* >CCT AG$ ;=) #_$#'/#/ G'$%8 JG?G)$ S* >CCP* &(

@&(# $9=' $;& H#=() 8=$#(* A=)#/ &' $9# g"#()&''#8 J<$%&' X&(@ f "(&`#<$ [email protected]&H@#'$g /=$#/ FG8H E*

>CCP,T 

O=)#/ &' "622W) gJ..&%'$@#'$ :&( "(&`#<$ [email protected]&H@#'$g /=$#/ 6&+#@A#( >>* >CCP*E .#$%$%&'#( ;=)

(#9%(#/ &' #+#' /=$# =) gJ<<&G'$%'? 28#(\ K-#8%#+#(Lg ='/ =))%?'#/ $& $9# g"245 f p,3, "(&`#<$,g 3$ ;=)

)$=$#/ $9#(#%' $9=$ 9%) #@.8&H@#'$ )9=88 #'/ &' X#A(G=(H >>* >CCC ='/ @=H A# $#(@%'=$#/ :&( <=G)# &( %'

=<<&(/='<# ;%$9 $9# .(&+%)%&') &: J($%<8# BPB &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#* =) =@#'/#/, d&;#+#(* )=%/ #@.8&H@#'$

/%/ '&$ =<$G=88H #'/ &' X#A(G=(H >>* >CCC AG$ ;=) #_$#'/#/ G'$%8 X#A(G=(H >C* >CCC A=)#/ &' $9#g"#()&''#8 J<$%&' X&(@M"(&`#<$ [email protected]&H@#'$g /=$#/ X#A(G=(H >E* >CCC,

5' X#A(G=(H BI* >CCC* .#$%$%&'#( ;=) =?=%' 9%(#/ AH "622 =) gJ<<&G'$%'? 28#(\g ='/ ;=) =))%?'#/ $& $9#

g4ZM"(&`#<$g A=)#/ &' $9# gJ..&%'$@#'$ :&( "(&`#<$ [email protected]&H@#'$g /=$#/ X#A(G=(H >P* >CCC,C 3$ /%/ '&$

).#<%:H $9# /=$# ;9#' 9%) #@.8&H@#'$ ;%88 #'/ AG$ %$ ;=) )$=$#/ $9#(#%' $9=$ %$ ;%88 A# g<&M$#(@%'G) ;%$9

$9# <&@.8#$%&' &: $9# .(&`#<$,g 4=%/ #@.8&H@#'$ )G..&)#/8H #'/#/ &' JG?G)$ >C* >CCC .#( g"#()&''#8

J<$%&' X&(@ f "(&`#<$ [email protected]&H@#'$g /=$#/ JG?G)$ >P* >CCC*>D ;9#(# %$ ;=) )$=$#/* g$#(@%'=$%&' &:

.#$%$%&'#(W) .(&`#<$ #@.8&H@#'$ /G# $& <&@.8#$%&' &: =))%?'#/ .9=)#e)$=?# &: ;&(\ &( .(&`#<$ #::#<$%+# =$

$9# <8&)# &: &::%<# 9&G() &' >C JG?G)$ >CCC,g d&;#+#(* %$ =..#=() $9=$ )=%/ #@.8&H@#'$ ;=) #_$#'/#/ .#(

gJ..&%'$@#'$ :&( "(&`#<$ #@.8&H@#'$g /=$#/ JG?G)$ BD* >CCC>>

 =) .#$%$%&'#( ;=) =?=%' =..&%'$#/ =)gJ<<&G'$%'? 28#(\g :&( g4Z "(&`#<$ K"=<\=?# 33L,g 3$ /%/ '&$ )$=$# = ).#<%:%< /=$# G. $& ;9#' 9%) #_$#'/#/

#@.8&H@#'$ ;%88 A#* AG$ %$ .(&+%/#/ $9=$ %$ ;%88 A# g<&M$#(@%'G) ;%$9 $9# _ _ _ .(&`#<$,g 3' g"#()&''#8 J<$%&'

X&(@ f "(&`#<$ [email protected]&H@#'$g /=$#/ 5<$&A#( >E* BDDD*>B

 %$ =..#=() $9=$ )G<9 #_$#')%&' ;&G8/ #+#'$G=88H

#'/ &' 5<$&A#( >C* BDDD,

Page 15: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 15/108

0#).%$# $9# $#(@%'=$%&' &: 9%) #@.8&H@#'$ &' 5<$&A#( >C* BDDD* .#$%$%&'#( <8=%@) $9=$ 9%) )G.#(%&(

%')$(G<$#/ 9%@ $& (#.&($ :&( ;&(\ $9# :&88&;%'? /=H* %'$%@=$%'? $& 9%@ $9=$ 9# ;%88 =?=%' A# #@.8&H#/ :&(

$9# )G<<##/%'? 4Z .(&`#<$), X&( .G(.&)#) &: (##@.8&H@#'$* 9# $9#' G'/#(;#'$ = @#/%<=8 #_=@%'=$%&'

;9%<9 =88#?#/8H (#+#=8#/ $9=$ 9# 9=/ .'#G@&'%$%), "#$%$%&'#( ;=) =/+%)#/ AH "622W) .9H)%<%='* 0(, J($9G(

2, 5A#'=* $& $=\# = >SM/=H )%<\ 8#=+#,

5' 6&+#@A#( BE* BDDD* =:$#( )#(+%'? 9%) )%<\ 8#=+#* .#$%$%&'#( <8=%@) $9=$ 9# ;=) =?=%' (#:#((#/ :&(

@#/%<=8 #_=@%'=$%&' ;9#(# %$ ;=) (#+#=8#/ $9=$ 9# <&'$(=<$#/ b&<9W) /%)#=)#, d# ;=) $9#' (#]G%(#/ $&$=\# = TDM/=H 8#=+# &: =A)#'<#,>I Q9# :&88&;%'? /=H* 9# )GA@%$$#/ 9%) =..8%<=$%&' :&( )%<\ 8#=+# AG$ "622W)

"(&`#<$ "#()&''#8 5::%<#(* Z(, -,4, 4='<9#^* $&8/ 9%@ $9=$ 9# ;=) '&$ #'$%$8#/ $& )%<\ 8#=+# A#<=G)# 9# ;=)

'&$ = (#?G8=( #@.8&H##,

"#$%$%&'#( )$%88 )#(+#/ = TDM/=H )%<\ 8#=+# ='/ G'/#(;#'$ ='&$9#( @#/%<=8 #_=@%'=$%&' &' X#A(G=(H >T*

BDD>, d# ;=) $9#' ?%+#' = <8#=' A%88 &: 9#=8$9 ='/ ;=) ?%+#' = @#/%<=8 <8#=(='<# AH 0(, 5A#'= $9=$ 9# ;=)

:%$ $& ;&(\,

"#$%$%&'#( <8=%@) $9=$ =:$#( 9# .(#)#'$#/ 9%) @#/%<=8 <8#=(='<# $& $9# "(&`#<$ "#()&''#8 5::%<#( &' #+#'

/=$#* 9# ;=) %':&(@#/ $9=$ 9%) )#(+%<#) ;#(# =8(#=/H $#(@%'=$#/ &' 5<$&A#( >C* BDDD ='/ 9# ;=) =8(#=/H(#.8=<#/ /G# $& #_.%(=$%&' &: 9%) <&'$(=<$, Q9%) .(&@.$#/ .#$%$%&'#( &' X#A(G=(H >P* BDDI $& :%8# =

<&@.8=%'$>S :&( %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8 =?=%')$ "622 ;%$9 = .(=H#( :&( (#%')$=$#@#'$ ='/ A=<\ ;=?#), d# =(?G#/

$9=$ 9# %) /##@#/ = (#?G8=( #@.8&H## &: "622 /G# $& 9%) .(&8&'?#/ #@.8&H@#'$ =) = .(&`#<$ #@.8&H## =)

;#88 =) $9# :=%8G(# &' $9# .=($ &: "622 $& (#.&($ 9%) $#(@%'=$%&' #+#(H $%@# = .(&`#<$ %) <&@.8#$#/, d#

:G($9#( <&'$#'/#/ $9=$ 9%) $#(@%'=$%&' ;%$9&G$ $9# A#'#:%$ &: =' =/@%'%)$(=$%+# %'+#)$%?=$%&' ;=)

$='$=@&G'$ $& =' %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8,

"622 <&G'$#(#/ $9=$ .#$%$%&'#( ;=) 9%(#/ =) = .(&`#<$ #@.8&H## %' )#+#(=8 .(&`#<$) ;%$9 ).#<%:%< /=$#) &:

#'?=?#@#'$ ='/ $#(@%'=$%&' ='/ 9=/ :G88 \'&;8#/?# ='/ <&')#'$ $9=$ 9%) =..&%'$@#'$ ;=) &'8H :&( $9#

/G(=$%&' &: #=<9 .(&`#<$, 3$ :G($9#( <&'$#'/#/ $9=$ %$ 9=/ )G::%<%#'$8H <&@.8%#/ ;%$9 $9# (#.&($&(%=8

(#]G%(#@#'$) $& $9# 0#.=($@#'$ &: U=A&( ='/ [email protected]&H@#'$ K05U1L, 3$ )GA@%$$#/ .9&$&<&.%#) &: $9(##

1)$=A8%)9@#'$ Q#(@%'=$%&' -#.&($) %$ .G(.&($#/8H :%8#/ ;%$9 $9# 05U1, Q9#H ;#(# :&(a K>L $9# g"245p,3,

"(&`#<$g :&( X#A(G=(H >CCC[>R

 KBL g4Z "(&`#<$g :&( JG?G)$ >CCC[>T

 ='/ KIL g4Z "(&`#<$g :&( 5<$&A#(

BDDD*>E

 =88 &: ;9%<9 %'<8G/#/ .#$%$%&'#( =) =@&'? $9# =::#<$#/ #@.8&H##), Q9# )GA@%))%&' &: $#(@%'=$%&'

(#.&($) AH "622 ;=) 9&;#+#( /%).G$#/ AH .#$%$%&'#( A=)#/ &' $9# +#(%:%<=$%&')>P

 %))G#/ AH $9# 05U1 62-

&::%<# $9=$ 9# ;=) '&$ =@&'? $9# =::#<$#/ #@.8&H##) 8%)$#/ %' $9# (#.&($) :%8#/ AH "622 %' JG?G)$ >CCP*

X#A(G=(H >CCC* JG?G)$ >CCC ='/ 5<$&A#( BDDD,

5' Z=(<9 BP* BDDT* $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( (#'/#(#/ = 0#<%)%&'>C

 %' :=+&( &: .#$%$%&'#(, Q9# :=88& (#=/)a

7d1-1X5-1* .(#@%)#) <&')%/#(#/* $9# <&@.8=%'='$ 9=/ =$$=%'#/ (#?G8=( #@.8&H@#'$ $9#(#AH @=\%'? 9%)$#(@%'=$%&' :(&@ #@.8&H@#'$ %88#?=8 )%'<# %$ ;=) '&$ :&( ='H +=8%/ &( =G$9&(%^#/ <=G)#), 2&')#]G#'$8H*

-#).&'/#'$ %) &(/#(#/ $& .=H <&@.8=%'='$ 9%) :G88 A=<\;=?#) 8#)) )%_ KTL @&'$9) <&@.G$#/ =) :&88&;)a

O=<\;=?#)a

X#A, >P* BDDD f Z=(<9 BP* BDDT q EI,II @&),

"T*BEE,DD _ EI,II q "STD*BCB,S>

U#))a

"T*BEE,DD r T @&), q IE*TTB,DD

"SBB*TID,S>

Page 16: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 16/108

Q9# (#%')$=$#@#'$ <&G8/ '&$ =) ;#88 A# &(/#(#/ /G# $& $9# )$(=%'#/ (#8=$%&') A#$;##' $9# .=($%#)* $9=$ %'

8%#G $9#(#&:* )#.=(=$%&' .=H %) &(/#(#/ .=%/ $& <&@.8=%'='$ %' $9# =@&G'$ &: "IE*TTB,DD h"T*BEE,DD _ Ti,

45 5-01-10,BD

 

Q9# U=A&( J(A%$#( (G8#/ $9=$ .#$%$%&'#( =$$=%'#/ (#?G8=( #@.8&H@#'$ )$=$G) ;%$9 $9# (#.#=$#/ 9%(%'? ='/

(#9%(%'? &: 9%) )#(+%<#) @&(# )& ;9#' $9# )#(+%<#) 9# ;=) @=/# $& (#'/#( ;#(# G)G=8 ='/ '#<#))=(H $&

"622W) AG)%'#)), Q9# U=A&( J(A%$#( 8%\#;%)# :&G'/ $9=$ :(&@ $9# $%@# .#$%$%&'#( ;=) 9%(#/ %' >CCT G'$%8 9#;=) $#(@%'=$#/* 9# ;=) 9%(#/ ='/ (#9%(#/ AH "622 ='/ @=/# $& ;&(\ '&$ &'8H %' $9# .(&`#<$ 9# 9=/ )%?'#/

$& ;&(\ &' AG$ &' &$9#( .(&`#<$) =) ;#88* %'/%<=$%'? $9=$ 9# %) %' :=<$ = (#?G8=( #@.8&H##, d# =8)& '&$#/

.#$%$%&'#(W) )GA)#]G#'$ <&'$(=<$) /%/ '&$ ='H@&(# %'/%<=$# $9# /=$# &: <&@.8#$%&' &: $9# <&'$(=<$ ='/ $9#

:=<$ $9=$ 9%) :%()$ <&'$(=<$ ;=) #_$#'/#/ ;=H A#H&'/ $9# )G..&)#/ <&@.8#$%&' /=$#, J<<&(/%'? $& $9#

U=A&( J(A%$#(* $9#)# <%(<G@)$='<#) %'/%<=$# $9=$ $9# #@.8&H@#'$ %) '& 8&'?#( = .(&`#<$ #@.8&H@#'$ AG$

9=) ?(=/G=$#/ %'$& = (#?G8=( &'#, d=+%'? =$$=%'#/ (#?G8=( )$=$G)* $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( (G8#/ $9=$ .#$%$%&'#(

)9&G8/ 9=+# A##' =<<&(/#/ 9%) (%?9$ $& )#<G(%$H &: $#'G(#,

O&$9 "622 ='/ .#$%$%&'#( =..#=8#/ $9# U=A&( J(A%$#(W) /#<%)%&', "622 %')%)$#/ $9=$ .#$%$%&'#( ;=) `G)$ =

.(&`#<$ #@.8&H## ='/ 9%) $#(@%'=$%&' ;=) A(&G?9$ =A&G$ AH $9# <&@.8#$%&' &: $9# <&'$(=<$ ='/ $9#(#:&(#9# ;=) '&$ %88#?=88H /%)@%))#/, "#$%$%&'#(* &' $9# &$9#( 9='/* =(?G#/ $9=$ 9%) (#%')$=$#@#'$ )9&G8/ 9=+#

A##' &(/#(#/ AH $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( )%'<# $9#(# ;=) '& .(&&: $9=$ $9#(# ;#(# )$(=%'#/ (#8=$%&') A#$;##'

$9# .=($%#), d# =8)& ]G#)$%&'#/ $9# /#/G<$%&' &: )%_ @&'$9) .=H :(&@ $9# A=<\ ;=?#) =;=(/#/ $& 9%@ ='/

$9# :=%8G(# &: $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( $& =;=(/ 9%@ /=@=?#) ='/ =$$&('#HW) :##), "#$%$%&'#( 8%\#;%)# @&+#/ $&

/%)@%)) "622W) =..#=8 <&'$#'/%'? $9=$ $9# )G.#()#/#=) A&'/ %' $9# =@&G'$ &: "SBB*TID,S> :%8#/ AH $9#

8=$$#( ;=) %')G::%<%#'$ <&')%/#(%'? $9=$ $9# U=A&( J(A%$#(W) @&'#$=(H =;=(/ %) "STD*BCB,S>, d# =8)& =(?G#/

$9=$ $9# .#()&' ;9& +#(%:%#/ $9# =..#=8* X#8%_ Z, 1(#<#* F(,* "#()&''#8 4#(+%<#) 0#.=($@#'$ d#=/ &: "622*

9=) '& =G$9&(%$H $& :%8# $9# )=@# :&( ='/ %' A#9=8: &: "622,

5' 5<$&A#( I>* BDDP* $9# 6U-2 (#'/#(#/ %$) 0#<%)%&' ?(='$%'? "622W) =..#=8 AG$ /%)@%))%'? $9=$ &:

.#$%$%&'#(, Q9# /%).&)%$%+# .&($%&' (#=/)a

7d1-1X5-1* .(#@%)#) <&')%/#(#/* $9# =..#=8 &: (#).&'/#'$ %) N-J6Q10 ='/ $9# 0#<%)%&' /=$#/ BP

Z=(<9 BDDT %) -1V1-410 ='/ 41Q J4301,

J '#; 0#<%)%&' %) 9#(#AH %))G#/ &(/#(%'? (#).&'/#'$ "9%8%..%'# 6=$%&'=8 2&')$(G<$%&' 2&(.&(=$%&' $& .=H

<&@.8#$%&' A&'G) $& <&@.8=%'='$ -&H 0&@%'?& "=)&) %' $9# =@&G'$ &: "BR*DDD,

2&@.8=%'='$W) =..#=8 %) 034Z34410 :&( 8=<\ &: @#(%$,

45 5-01-10,B> 

J) $& $9# .(&<#/G(=8 %))G#) (=%)#/ AH .#$%$%&'#(* $9# 6U-2 (G8#/ $9=$ $9#(# ;=) )GA)$='$%=8 <&@.8%='<# ;%$9

$9# (#]G%(#@#'$ &: =' =..#=8 A&'/ ='/ $9=$ Z(, 1(#<#* F(,* =) 9#=/ &: $9# "#()&''#8 4#(+%<#) 0#.=($@#'$*

%) $9# .(&.#( .#()&' $& (#.(#)#'$ "622, J) $& $9# )GA)$='$%+# %))G#)* $9# 6U-2 :&G'/ $9=$ .#$%$%&'#( ;=)

#@.8&H#/ %' <&''#<$%&' ;%$9 <#($=%' <&')$(G<$%&' .(&`#<$) ='/ 9%) #@.8&H@#'$ ;=) <&M$#(@%'G) ;%$9 #=<9

.(&`#<$ =) #+%/#'<#/ AH $9# "#()&''#8 J<$%&' X&(@) ='/ $9# Q#(@%'=$%&' -#.&($ )GA@%$$#/ $& $9# 05U1, 3$

8%\#;%)# '&$#/ $9# .(#)#'<# &: $9# :&88&;%'? .(&`#<$ #@.8&H@#'$ %'/%<=$&() %' $9# %')$='$ <=)#* '=@#8H*

$9# /G(=$%&' &: $9# .(&`#<$ :&( ;9%<9 .#$%$%&'#( ;=) #'?=?#/ ;=) /#$#(@%'=A8# ='/ #_.#<$#/ <&@.8#$%&'

;=) \'&;' $& .#$%$%&'#([ $9# ).#<%:%< )#(+%<# $9=$ .#$%$%&'#( (#'/#(#/ %' $9# .(&`#<$) ;=) $9=$ &: ='

=<<&G'$%'? <8#(\ ='/ $9=$ ;=) @=/# <8#=( $& 9%@ ='/ $9# )#(+%<# ;=) <&''#<$#/ ;%$9 $9# .(&`#<$)[ ='/"622 )GA@%$$#/ $#(@%'=$%&' (#.&($) $& $9# 05U1 ='/ .#$%$%&'#(W) '=@# ;=) %'<8G/#/ %' $9# 8%)$ &: =::#<$#/

#@.8&H##),

Page 17: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 17/108

"#$%$%&'#( #8#+=$#/ $9# <=)# $& $9# 2J +%= = .#$%$%&' :&( <#($%&(=(% AG$ $9# =..#88=$# <&G($ /%)@%))#/ $9#

)=@# :&( 8=<\ &: @#(%$,

d#'<# $9%) .#$%$%&', "#$%$%&'#( =(?G#) $9=$ $9# 2J #((#/ ;9#' %$a

3,

4Y4QJ3610 QdJQ Qd1 JZ5Y6Q 5X Qd1 O560 "54Q10 Ok Qd1 -14"56016Q4 X5- "Y-"5414 5X J""1JU7J4 4YXX32316Q 65Q73Qd4QJ6036N QdJQ Qd1 4JZ1 34 U144 QdJ6 Qd1 J0FY0N10 JZ5Y6Q,

33,

4Y4QJ3610 QdJQ X1U3r Z, 1-121* F-,* d1J0 5X -14"56016Q "622W4 "1-45661U 41-V321 01"J-QZ16Q*

34 0YUk JYQd5-3j10 Q5 -1"-1416Q -14"56016Q 36 Qd34 2J41 65Q73Qd4QJ6036N Qd1 JO41621 5X

J6k O5J-0 -145UYQ356 5- 412-1QJ-kW4 21-Q3X32JQ1 5X Qd1 -14"56016Q 4QJQ36N QdJQ 360110 d1

7J4 0YUk JYQd5-3j10 Q5 364Q3QYQ1 Qd141 "-5211036N4,

333,

4Y4QJ3610 QdJQ "1Q3Q3561- 7J4 J "-5F12Q 1Z"U5k11 014"3Q1 Qd1 XJ2Q QdJQ -14"56016Q "622

dJ0 65Q 4YOZ3QQ10 Qd1 -1pY343Q1 Q1-Z36JQ356 -1"5-Q4 36 JUU 5X Qd1 JUU1N10 "-5F12Q4 7d1-1

Qd1 "1Q3Q3561- 7J4 J443N610,

3V,

4Y4QJ3610 QdJQ Qd1 "1Q3Q3561- 34 J "-5F12Q 1Z"U5k11 014"3Q1 Qd1 23-2YZ4QJ621 QdJQ Qd1

J2QYJU 75-b Y601-QJb16 Ok Qd1 "1Q3Q3561- 7J4 65Q U3Z3Q10 Q5 Qd1 75-b 0142-3O10 36 d34

JUU1N10 J""536QZ16Q J4 J "-5F12Q 1Z"U5k11,

V,

XJ3U10 Q5 X360 QdJQ JQ 45Z1 Q3Z1* Qd1 1Z"U5kZ16Q 5X Qd1 "1Q3Q3561- 7J4 Y6-1J456JOUk

1rQ16010 O1k560 Qd1 0JQ1 5X 3Q4 25Z"U1Q356 J60 JQ 5Qd1- Q3Z14 Qd1 4JZ1 030 65Q O1J- J

0JQ1 5X 25Z"U1Q356 5- QdJQ Qd1 4JZ1 7J4 -1J03Uk 01Q1-Z36JOU1 JQ Qd1 Q3Z1 5X "1Q3Q3561-W4

16NJN1Z16Q Qd1-1Ok 36032JQ36N QdJQ d1 7J4 65Q d3-10 J4 J "-5F12Q 1Z"U5k11,

V3,

XJ3U10 Q5 5-01- Qd1 -1364QJQ1Z16Q 5X Qd1 "1Q3Q3561- Ok X36036N QdJQ Qd1-1 7J4 4Q-J3610-1UJQ3564 O1Q7116 Qd1 "J-Q314 65Q73Qd4QJ6036N QdJQ Qd1 -14"56016Q 61V1- 1V16 JUU1N10

65- "-5V10 36 3Q4 "U1J036N4 Qd1 23-2YZ4QJ621 5X 4Q-J3610 -1UJQ3564,

V33,

4Y4QJ3610 Qd1 XJ3UY-1 5X Qd1 6JQ356JU UJO5- -1UJQ3564 25ZZ344356 Q5 -12Q3Xk Qd1 1--5-

25ZZ3QQ10 Ok UJO5- J-O3Q1- U3O5M56 36 010Y2Q36N Qd1 1pY3VJU16Q 5X 43r Z56Qd4 "Jk 5X

OJ2b7JN14 014"3Q1 Qd1 ZJ60JQ1 5X Qd1 UJO5- 2501 QdJQ 7d16 Qd1-1 34 J X36036N 5X 3UU1NJU

034Z344JU* Qd1 "JkZ16Q 5X XYUU OJ2b7JN14 X-5Z 0JQ1 5X 03Z344JU Y" Q5 J2QYJU

-1364QJQ1Z16Q 4d5YU0 O1 J7J-010,

V333,

Page 18: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 18/108

4Y4QJ3610 Qd1 XJ3UY-1 5X Qd1 6JQ356JU UJO5- -1UJQ3564 25ZZ344356 Q5 -12Q3Xk Qd1 1--5-

25ZZ3QQ10 Ok UJO5- J-O3Q1- U3O5M56 36 XJ3U36N Q5 J7J-0 0JZJN14 J60 JQQ5-61kW4 X114 Q5 Qd1

"1Q3Q3561-,BB

 

"#$%$%&'#( <&'$#'/) $9=$ "622W) =..#=8 :(&@ $9# U=A&( J(A%$#(W) /#<%)%&' )9&G8/ '&$ 9=+# A##' =88&;#/

)%'<# $9# =..#=8 A&'/ :%8#/ ;=) %')G::%<%#'$, d# 8%\#;%)# =(?G#) $9=$ $9# =..#88=$# <&G($ #((#/ %' 9#=+%8H

(#8H%'? %' $9# <=)# &: 2=?=H=' V=88#H 0(G? 2&(.&(=$%&' +, 2&@@%))%&'#( &: 3'$#('=8 -#+#'G#BI

 ;9%<9

#'G@#(=$#/ $9# &::%<%=8) ='/ #@.8&H##) ;9& <=' )%?' $9# +#(%:%<=$%&' ='/ <#($%:%<=$%&' ;%$9&G$ '##/ &: =A&=(/ (#)&8G$%&', d# <&'$#'/) $9=$ %' )=%/ <=)#* $9#(# ;=) )GA)$='$%=8 <&@.8%='<# ;%$9 $9# (#]G%(#@#'$

)%'<# = A&=(/ (#)&8G$%&' ;=) )GA@%$$#/ =8A#%$ A#8=$#/8H G'8%\# %' $9# %')$='$ <=)# ;9#(# '& A&=(/

(#)&8G$%&' ;=) #+#( )GA@%$$#/ #+#' A#8=$#/8H,

J) $& $9# )GA)$='$%+# %))G#* .#$%$%&'#( )GA@%$) $9=$ $9# 2J #((&'#&G)8H <&'<8G/#/ $9=$ 9# ;=) = .(&`#<$

#@.8&H## ;9#' $9#(# =(# %'/%<=$&() ;9%<9 .&%'$ &$9#(;%)#, d# <&'$#'/) $9=$ #+#' %: 9# ;=) `G)$ 9%(#/ :&(

$9# 6J3J B "(&`#<$ :(&@ J.(%8 BT* >CCT $& FG8H BR* >CCT* 9# ;=) @=/# $& ;&(\ G'$%8 JG?G)$ S* >CCP, d# =8)&

=+#() $9# 05U1 9=/ <#($%:%#/ $9=$ 9# ;=) '&$ =@&'? $9# #@.8&H##) 8%)$#/ %' $9# $#(@%'=$%&' (#.&($)

)GA@%$$#/ AH "622 ;9%<9 A#8%#) $9# .9&$&<&.%#) &: $#(@%'=$%&' (#.&($) =$$=<9#/ AH "622 $& %$) .8#=/%'?)

8%)$%'? .#$%$%&'#( =) &'# &: $9# =::#<$#/ #@.8&H##), "#$%$%&'#( .&%'$) &G$ $9=$ )=%/ $#(@%'=$%&' (#.&($)=$$=<9#/ $& "622W) .8#=/%'?) =(# @#(# .9&$&<&.%#) ='/ ;#(# '&$ #+#' <#($%:%#/ AH $9# 05U1M62- =) $(G#

<&.%#) &: $9# &(%?%'=8) &' :%8# ;%$9 )=%/ &::%<#, XG($9#(* 9# =(?G#) $9=$ %' +%&8=$%&' &: $9# (#]G%(#@#'$ &:

0#.=($@#'$ 5(/#( 6&, >C $9=$ $9# /G(=$%&' &: $9# .(&`#<$ #@.8&H@#'$ %) (#=)&'=A8H /#$#(@%'=A8#* 9%)

<&'$(=<$) :&( $9# 4Z .(&`#<$) /%/ '&$ ).#<%:H $9# /=$# &: <&@.8#$%&' &: $9# .(&`#<$ '&( ;=) $9# <&@.8#$%&'

/#$#(@%'=A8# =$ $9# $%@# $9=$ .#$%$%&'#( ;=) 9%(#/,

"622 <&G'$#() $9=$ /&<G@#'$=(H #+%/#'<# ;&G8/ )9&; $9=$ .#$%$%&'#( ;=) <8#=(8H = .(&`#<$ #@.8&H## ='/

(#@=%'#/ =) )G<9 G'$%8 9%) 8=)$ #'?=?#@#'$, 3$ =(?G#) $9=$ $9# (#.#=$#/ (#9%(%'? &: .#$%$%&'#( =) =<<&G'$%'?

<8#(\ %' /%::#(#'$ .(&`#<$) /%/ '&$ @=\# 9%@ = (#?G8=( #@.8&H##, 3$ =8)& %')%)$) $9=$ %$ <&@.8%#/ ;%$9 $9#

(#.&($&(%=8 (#]G%(#@#'$) ='/ $9=$ %$ :%8#/ ='/ (#.&($#/ $9# $#(@%'=$%&' &: .#$%$%&'#( G.&' #+#(H

<&@.8#$%&' &: .(&`#<$ $& ;9%<9 9# ;=) #@.8&H#/,

3' )G@* $9(## @=%' %))G#) =(# .(#)#'$#/ A#:&(# $9%) 2&G($ :&( (#)&8G$%&'a K>L 49&G8/ =' =..#=8 A# /%)@%))#/

&G$(%?9$ %: $9# =..#=8 A&'/ :%8#/ %) 8#)) $9=' $9# =/`G/?#/ =@&G'$s KBL 2=' $9# 9#=/ &: $9# .#()&''#8

/#.=($@#'$ )%?' $9# +#(%:%<=$%&' ='/ <#($%:%<=$%&' &' A#9=8: &: $9# <&(.&(=$%&' )=') ='H A&=(/ (#)&8G$%&' &(

)#<(#$=(HW) <#($%:%<=$# =G$9&(%^%'? )G<9 &::%<#( $& /& $9# )=@#s ='/ KIL 3) .#$%$%&'#( = (#?G8=( #@.8&H## ='/

'&$ = @#(# .(&`#<$ #@.8&H## ='/ $9G) <=' &'8H A# /%)@%))#/ :&( <=G)#s

4GA)$='$%=8 <&@.8%='<# ;%$9 =..#=8

A&'/ (#]G%(#@#'$

Q9# .#(:#<$%&' &: =' =..#=8 ;%$9%' $9# (#?8#@#'$=(H .#(%&/ ='/ %' $9# @=''#( .(#)<(%A#/ AH 8=; %)

 `G(%)/%<$%&'=8* ='/ '&'<&@.8%='<# ;%$9 )G<9 8#?=8 (#]G%(#@#'$ %) :=$=8 ='/ #::#<$%+#8H (#'/#() $9# `G/?@#'$

:%'=8 ='/ #_#<G$&(H, J) .(&+%/#/ %' J($%<8# BBI &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#* =) =@#'/#/* %' <=)# &: = `G/?@#'$

%'+&8+%'? = @&'#$=(H =;=(/* =' =..#=8 AH $9# #@.8&H#( @=H A# .#(:#<$#/ &'8H G.&' $9# .&)$%'? &: = <=)9

&( )G(#$H A&'/ %))G#/ AH = (#.G$=A8# A&'/%'? <&@.='H /G8H =<<(#/%$#/ AH $9# 2&@@%))%&' %' $9# =@&G'$

#]G%+=8#'$ $& $9# @&'#$=(H =;=(/ %' $9# `G/?@#'$ =..#=8#/ :(&@,

d&;#+#(* '&$ &'8H %' &'# <=)# 9=) $9%) 2&G($ (#8=_#/ $9%) (#]G%(#@#'$ %' &(/#( $& A(%'? =A&G$ $9#

%@@#/%=$# ='/ =..(&.(%=$# (#)&8G$%&' &: <=)#) &' $9# @#(%$),BS

 3' pG%=@A=& +, 6=$%&'=8 U=A&( -#8=$%&')2&@@%))%&'*

BR $9%) 2&G($ =88&;#/ $9# (#8=_=$%&' &: $9# (#]G%(#@#'$ ;9#' $9#(# %) )GA)$='$%=8 <&@.8%='<#

;%$9 $9# (G8#, U%\#;%)#* %' 5'? +, 2&G($ &: J..#=8)*BT

 $9# 2&G($ 9#8/ $9=$ $9# A&'/ (#]G%(#@#'$ &' =..#=8)

@=H A# (#8=_#/ ;9#' $9#(# %) )GA)$='$%=8 <&@.8%='<# ;%$9 $9# -G8#) &: "(&<#/G(# &: $9# 6U-2 &( ;9#' $9#

Page 19: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 19/108

=..#88='$ )9&;) ;%88%'?'#)) $& .&)$ = .=($%=8 A&'/, Q9# 2&G($ 9#8/ $9=$ g;9%8# $9# A&'/ (#]G%(#@#'$ &'

=..#=8) %'+&8+%'? @&'#$=(H =;=(/) 9=) A##' (#8=_#/ %' <#($=%' <=)#)* $9%) <=' &'8H A# /&'# ;9#(# $9#(#

;=) )GA)$='$%=8 <&@.8%='<# &: $9# -G8#) &( ;9#(# $9# =..#88='$)* =$ $9# +#(H 8#=)$* #_9%A%$#/ ;%88%'?'#)) $&

.=H AH .&)$%'? = .=($%=8 A&'/,g

3' $9# %')$='$ <=)#* $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( %' 9%) /#<%)%&' &(/#(#/ "622 $& .=H .#$%$%&'#( A=<\ ;=?#) =@&G'$%'?

$&"SBB*TID,S> ='/ )#.=(=$%&' .=H &: "IE*TTB &( = $&$=8 &: "STD*BCB,S>, 79#' "622 :%8#/ =' =..#=8 A&'/

=@&G'$%'? $& "SBB*TID,S> &( =$ 8#=)$ CDm &: $9# =/`G/?#/ =@&G'$* $9#(# %) '& ]G#)$%&' $9=$ $9%) %))GA)$='$%=8 <&@.8%='<# ;%$9 $9# (#]G%(#@#'$ $9=$ =88&;) (#8=_=$%&' &: $9# (G8#),

V=8%/%$H &: $9# +#(%:%<=$%&' ='/

<#($%:%<=$%&' )%?'#/ AH = <&(.&(=$#

&::%<#( &' A#9=8: &: $9# <&(.&(=$%&'

;%$9&G$ $9# (#]G%)%$# A&=(/

(#)&8G$%&' &( )#<(#$=(HW) <#($%:%<=$#

3$ 9=) A##' $9# <&')$='$ 9&8/%'? &: $9%) 2&G($ %' <=)#) %')$%$G$#/ AH <&(.&(=$%&') $9=$ =' %'/%+%/G=8

<&(.&(=$# &::%<#( <=''&$ #_#(<%)# ='H <&(.&(=$# .&;#( .#($=%'%'? $& $9# <&(.&(=$%&' ;%$9&G$ =G$9&(%$H

:(&@ $9# A&=(/ &: /%(#<$&() .G()G='$ $& 4#<$%&' BI* %' (#8=$%&' $& 4#<$%&' BR &: $9# 2&(.&(=$%&' 2&/# ;9%<9<8#=(8H #'G'<%=$#) $9=$ =88 <&(.&(=$# .&;#() =(# #_#(<%)#/* =88 AG)%'#)) <&'/G<$#/* ='/ =88 .(&.#($%#)

<&'$(&88#/ AH $9# A&=(/ &: /%(#<$&(), d&;#+#(* ;# 9=+# %' @='H <=)#) (#<&?'%^#/ $9# =G$9&(%$H &: )&@#

<&(.&(=$# &::%<#() $& )%?' $9# +#(%:%<=$%&' ='/ <#($%:%<=$%&' =?=%')$ :&(G@M)9&..%'?, 4&@# &: $9#)# <=)#)

;#(# #'G@#(=$#/ %' 2=?=H=' V=88#H 0(G? 2&(.&(=$%&' +, 2&@@%))%&'#( &: 3'$#('=8 -#+#'G#BE

 ;9%<9 ;=)

<%$#/ AH $9# =..#88=$# <&G($a

3' Z=<$='M2#AG 3'$#('=$%&'=8 J%(.&($ JG$9&(%$H +, 2J* ;# (#<&?'%^#/ $9# =G$9&(%$H &: = ?#'#(=8 @='=?#( &(

=<$%'? ?#'#(=8 @='=?#( $& )%?' $9# +#(%:%<=$%&' ='/ <#($%:%<=$# =?=%')$ :&(G@ )9&..%'?[ %' ":%^#( +, N=8='*

;# G.9#8/ $9# +=8%/%$H &: = +#(%:%<=$%&' )%?'#/ AH =' g#@.8&H@#'$ ).#<%=8%)$g ;9& 9=/ '&$ #+#' .(#)#'$#/

='H .(&&: &: 9#( =G$9&(%$H $& (#.(#)#'$ $9# <&@.='H[ %' 6&+#8$H "9%8%..%'#)* 3'<, +, 2J* ;# (G8#/ $9=$ =

.#()&''#8 &::%<#( ;9& )%?'#/ $9# .#$%$%&' AG$ /%/ '&$ =$$=<9 $9# =G$9&(%$H :(&@ $9# <&@.='H %) =G$9&(%^#/

$& )%?' $9# +#(%:%<=$%&' ='/ '&'M:&(G@ )9&..%'? <#($%:%<=$#[ ='/ %' U#.='$& 2&')&8%/=$#/ Z%'%'? 2&@.='H

+, 7Z2 -#)&G(<#) 3'$#('=$%&'=8 "$H, U$/, KU#.='$&L* ;# (G8#/ $9=$ $9# 29=%(.#()&' &: $9# O&=(/ ='/

"(#)%/#'$ &: $9# 2&@.='H <=' )%?' $9# +#(%:%<=$%&' ='/ <#($%:%<=$# =?=%')$ '&'M:&(G@ )9&..%'? #+#'

;%$9&G$ $9# )GA@%))%&' &: $9# A&=(/W) =G$9&(%^=$%&',

3' )G@* ;# 9=+# 9#8/ $9=$ $9# :&88&;%'? &::%<%=8) &( #@.8&H##) &: $9# <&@.='H <=' )%?' $9# +#(%:%<=$%&' ='/

<#($%:%<=$%&' ;%$9&G$ '##/ &: = A&=(/ (#)&8G$%&'a K>L $9# 29=%(.#()&' &: $9# O&=(/ &: 0%(#<$&()* KBL $9#

"(#)%/#'$ &: = <&(.&(=$%&'* KIL $9# N#'#(=8 Z='=?#( &( J<$%'? N#'#(=8 Z='=?#(* KSL "#()&''#8 5::%<#(* ='/

KRL =' [email protected]&H@#'$ 4.#<%=8%)$ %' = 8=A&( <=)#,

79%8# $9# =A&+# <=)#) /& '&$ .(&+%/# = <&@.8#$# 8%)$%'? &: =G$9&(%^#/ )%?'=$&(%#) $& $9# +#(%:%<=$%&' ='/

<#($%:%<=$%&' (#]G%(#/ AH $9# (G8#)* $9# /#$#(@%'=$%&' &: $9# )G::%<%#'<H &: $9# =G$9&(%$H ;=) /&'# &' = <=)#

$& <=)# A=)%), Q9# (=$%&'=8# =..8%#/ %' $9# :&(#?&%'? <=)#) %) $& `G)$%:H $9# =G$9&(%$H &: <&(.&(=$# &::%<#() &(

(#.(#)#'$=$%+#) &: $9# <&(.&(=$%&' $& )%?' $9# +#(%:%<=$%&' &( <#($%:%<=$# =?=%')$ :&(G@ )9&..%'?* A#%'? g%' =

.&)%$%&' $& +#(%:H $9# $(G$9:G8'#)) ='/ <&((#<$'#)) &: $9# =88#?=$%&') %' $9# .#$%$%&',gBP

 K2%$=$%&') &@%$$#/,L

79%8# ;# =?(## ;%$9 .#$%$%&'#( $9=$ %' 2=?=H=' V=88#H* $9# (#]G%)%$# A&=(/ (#)&8G$%&' ;=) )GA@%$$#/

$9&G?9 A#8=$#/8H G'8%\# %' $9# %')$='$ <=)#* $9%) 2&G($ )$%88 (#<&?'%^#) $9# =G$9&(%$H &: Z(, 1(#<#* F(, $& )%?'

$9# +#(%:%<=$%&' ='/ <#($%:%<=$%&' &' A#9=8: &: "622 )=') = A&=(/ (#)&8G$%&' &( )#<(#$=(HW) <#($%:%<=$# =) ;#

9=+# =88&;#/ %' ":%^#(* 3'<, +, N=8='*BC &'# &: $9# <=)#) <%$#/ %' 2=?=H=' V=88#H, 3' ":%^#(* $9# 2&G($ (G8#/ =)+=8%/ $9# +#(%:%<=$%&' )%?'#/ AH =' #@.8&H@#'$ ).#<%=8%)$ =) )9# ;=) %' = .&)%$%&' $& +#(%:H $9# $(G$9:G8'#))

='/ <&((#<$'#)) &: $9# =88#?=$%&') %' $9# .#$%$%&'ID

 /#).%$# $9# :=<$ $9=$ '& A&=(/ (#)&8G$%&' =G$9&(%^%'? 9#(

;=) #+#( )GA@%$$#/ AH ":%^#(* 3'<, #+#' A#8=$#/8H, 7# A#8%#+# $9=$ 8%\# $9# #@.8&H@#'$ ).#<%=8%)$ %' ":%^#(*

Page 20: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 20/108

Z(, 1(#<#* F(, $&&* =) 9#=/ &: $9# "#()&''#8 4#(+%<#) 0#.=($@#'$ &: "622* ;=) %' = .&)%$%&' $& =))G(# $9=$

$9# =88#?=$%&') %' $9# .8#=/%'? 9=+# A##' .(#.=(#/ %' ?&&/ :=%$9 ='/ =(# $(G# ='/ <&((#<$,

1+#' =))G@%'? $9=$ $9# +#(%:%<=$%&' %' $9# =..#=8 :%8#/ AH "622 %) /#:#<$%+#* %$ %) ;#88 )#$$8#/ $9=$ (G8#) &:

.(&<#/G(# %' 8=A&( <=)#) @=HA# (#8=_#/, J) .(&+%/#/ %' J($%<8# BB> &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#* =) =@#'/#/* g(G8#)

&: #+%/#'<# .(#+=%8%'? %' <&G($) &: 8=; &( #]G%$H )9=88 '&$ A# <&'$(&88%'? ='/ %$ %) $9# ).%(%$ ='/ %'$#'$%&' &:

$9%) 2&/# $9=$ $9# 2&@@%))%&' ='/ %$) @#@A#() ='/ $9# U=A&( J(A%$#() )9=88 G)# #+#(H ='/ =88 (#=)&'=A8#

@#=') $& =)<#($=%' $9# :=<$) %' #=<9 <=)# ).##/%8H ='/ &A`#<$%+#8H ='/ ;%$9&G$ (#?=(/ $& $#<9'%<=8%$%#) &:8=; &( .(&<#/G(#* =88 %' $9# %'$#(#)$ &: /G# .(&<#)),g Z&(#&+#(* $9# (#]G%(#@#'$ &: +#(%:%<=$%&' %) @#(#8H

:&(@=8 ='/ '&$ `G(%)/%<$%&'=8, J) 9#8/ %' "=<]G%'? +, 2&<=M2&8= "9%8%..%'#)* 3'<,I>

a

J) $& $9# /#:#<$%+# +#(%:%<=$%&' %' $9# =..#=8 @#@&(='/G@ A#:&(# $9# 6U-2* $9# )=@# 8%A#(=8%$H =..8%#),

J:$#( =88* $9# (#]G%(#@#'$ (#?=(/%'? +#(%:%<=$%&' &: = .8#=/%'? %) :&(@=8* '&$ `G(%)/%<$%&'=8, 4G<9

(#]G%(#@#'$ %) )%@.8H = <&'/%$%&' =::#<$%'? $9# :&(@ &: .8#=/%'?* $9# '&'<&@.8%='<# &: ;9%<9 /&#) '&$

'#<#))=(%8H (#'/#( $9# .8#=/%'? :=$=88H /#:#<$%+#, V#(%:%<=$%&' %) )%@.8H %'$#'/#/ $& )#<G(# =' =))G(='<#

$9=$ $9# =88#?=$%&') %' $9# .8#=/%'? =(# $(G# ='/ <&((#<$ ='/ '&$ $9# .(&/G<$ &: $9# %@=?%'=$%&' &( = @=$$#(

&: ).#<G8=$%&'* ='/ $9=$ $9# .8#=/%'? %) :%8#/ %' ?&&/ :=%$9, Q9# <&G($ &( $(%AG'=8 @=H &(/#( $9# <&((#<$%&' &:

$9# .8#=/%'? %: +#(%:%<=$%&' %) 8=<\%'? &( =<$ &' $9# .8#=/%'? =8$9&G?9 %$ %) '&$ +#(%:%#/* %: $9# =$$#'/%'?<%(<G@)$='<#) =(# )G<9 $9=$ )$(%<$ <&@.8%='<# ;%$9 $9# (G8#) @=H A# /%).#')#/ ;%$9 %' &(/#( $9=$ $9# #'/)

&: `G)$%<# @=H $9#(#AH A# )#(+#/,IB

 

0G(=$%&' &: .(&`#<$ #@.8&H@#'$

)9&G8/ A# /#$#(@%'#/ =$ $9# $%@# &:

9%(%'?

3' $9# %')$='$ <=)#* $9# =..&%'$@#'$) %))G#/ $& .#$%$%&'#( %'/%<=$#/ $9=$ 9# ;=) 9%(#/ :&( ).#<%:%< .(&`#<$),

Q9%) 2&G($ %) <&'+%'<#/ 9&;#+#( $9=$ =8$9&G?9 9# )$=($#/ =) = .(&`#<$ #@.8&H##* 9# #+#'$G=88H A#<=@# =

(#?G8=( #@.8&H## &: "622,

Y'/#( J($%<8# BPD &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#* =) =@#'/#/* = .(&`#<$ #@.8&H## %) &'# ;9&)# g#@.8&H@#'$ 9=)

A##' :%_#/ :&( = ).#<%:%< .(&`#<$ &( G'/#($=\%'? $9# <&@.8#$%&' &( $#(@%'=$%&' &: ;9%<9 9=) A##'

/#$#(@%'#/ =$ $9# $%@# &: $9# #'?=?#@#'$ &: $9# #@.8&H## &( ;9#(# $9# ;&(\ &( )#(+%<#) $& A#

.#(:&(@#/ %) )#=)&'=8 %' '=$G(# ='/ $9# #@.8&H@#'$ %) :&( $9# /G(=$%&' &: $9# )#=)&',g Q9G)* $9# .(%'<%.=8

$#)$ G)#/ $& /#$#(@%'# ;9#$9#( #@.8&H##) =(# .(&`#<$ #@.8&H##) %) ;9#$9#( &( '&$ $9# #@.8&H##) ;#(#

=))%?'#/ $& <=((H &G$ = ).#<%:%< .(&`#<$ &( G'/#($=\%'?* $9# /G(=$%&' &( )<&.# &: ;9%<9 ;=) ).#<%:%#/ =$ $9#

$%@# $9# #@.8&H##) ;#(# #'?=?#/ :&( $9=$ .(&`#<$,II

 

3' $9# <=)# =$ A=(* .#$%$%&'#( ;&(\#/ <&'$%'G&G)8H :&( @&(# $9=' $;& H#=() =:$#( $9# )G..&)#/ $9(##M

@&'$9 /G(=$%&' &: 9%) .(&`#<$ #@.8&H@#'$ :&( $9# 6J3J 33 "(&`#<$, 79%8# 9%) =..&%'$@#'$ :&( )=%/ .(&`#<$=88&;#/ )G<9 #_$#')%&' )%'<# %$ ).#<%:%<=88H .(&+%/#/ $9=$ %' <=)# 9%) g)#(+%<#) =(# )$%88 '##/#/ A#H&'/ $9#

+=8%/%$H &: $9# <&'$(=<$* $9# 2&@.='H )9=88 #_$#'/ 9%) )#(+%<#)*g $9#(# ;=) '& )GA)#]G#'$ <&'$(=<$ &(

=..&%'$@#'$ $9=$ ).#<%:%#/ = .=($%<G8=( /G(=$%&' :&( $9# #_$#')%&', d%) )#(+%<#) ;#(# `G)$ #_$#'/#/

%'/#:%'%$#8H G'$%8 g"#()&''#8 J<$%&' X&(@ f "(&`#<$ [email protected]&H@#'$g /=$#/ FG8H E* >CCP ;=) %))G#/ $& 9%@

;9%<9 .(&+%/#/ $9=$ 9%) #@.8&H@#'$ ;%88 #'/ = :#; ;##\) 8=$#( &( &' JG?G)$ S* >CCP, 79%8# :&( :%()$ $9(##

@&'$9)* .#$%$%&'#( <=' A# <&')%/#(#/ = .(&`#<$ #@.8&H## &: "622* 9%) #@.8&H@#'$ $9#(#=:$#(* ;9#' 9%)

)#(+%<#) ;#(# #_$#'/#/ ;%$9&G$ ='H ).#<%:%<=$%&' &: =) $& $9# /G(=$%&'* @=/# 9%@ = (#?G8=( #@.8&H## &:

"622, J'/ 9%) )$=$G) =) = (#?G8=( #@.8&H## ;=) '&$ =::#<$#/ AH $9# :=<$ $9=$ 9# ;=) =))%?'#/ $& )#+#(=8

&$9#( .(&`#<$) ='/ $9#(# ;#(# %'$#(+=8) %' A#$;##' )=%/ .(&`#<$) )%'<# 9# #'`&H) )#<G(%$H &: $#'G(#,

X=%8G(# &: =' #@.8&H#( $& :%8#

$#(@%'=$%&' (#.&($) =:$#( #+#(H

Page 21: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 21/108

.(&`#<$ <&@.8#$%&' .(&+#) $9=$ ='

#@.8&H## %) '&$ = .(&`#<$ #@.8&H##

J) = (G8#* $9# :%'/%'?) &: :=<$ &: $9# 2J =(# :%'=8 ='/ <&'<8G)%+# ='/ $9%) 2&G($ ;%88 '&$ (#+%#; $9#@ &'

=..#=8,IS

 Q9# (G8#* 9&;#+#(* %) )GA`#<$ $& $9# :&88&;%'? #_<#.$%&')a

Q9# `G(%)/%<$%&' &: $9# 2&G($ %' <=)#) A(&G?9$ A#:&(# %$ :(&@ $9# =..#88=$# <&G($ %) 8%@%$#/ $& (#+%#;%'?

#((&() &: 8=;* ='/ :%'/%'?) &: :=<$ &: $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) =(# <&'<8G)%+# G.&' $9# 2&G($ )%'<# %$ %) '&$ $9#2&G($W) :G'<$%&' $& ='=8H^# ='/ ;#%?9 $9# #+%/#'<# =88 &+#( =?=%', 6#+#($9#8#))* %' )#+#(=8 <=)#)* $9# 2&G($

#'G@#(=$#/ $9# #_<#.$%&') $& $9# (G8# $9=$ :=<$G=8 :%'/%'?) &: $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) =(# A%'/%'? &' $9#

2&G($a K>L ;9#' $9# :%'/%'?) =(# ?(&G'/#/ #'$%(#8H &' ).#<G8=$%&')* )G(@%)#) &( <&'`#<$G(#)[ KBL ;9#' $9#

%':#(#'<# @=/# %) @='%:#)$8H @%)$=\#'* =A)G(/ &( %@.&))%A8#[ KIL ;9#' $9#(# %) ?(=+# =AG)# &: /%)<(#$%&'[

KSL ;9#' $9# `G/?@#'$ %) A=)#/ &' = @%)=..(#9#')%&' &: :=<$)[ KRL ;9#' $9# :%'/%'?) &: :=<$ =(# <&':8%<$%'?[

KTL ;9#' %' @=\%'? %$) :%'/%'?) $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) ;#'$ A#H&'/ $9# %))G#) &: $9# <=)#* &( %$) :%'/%'?) =(#

<&'$(=(H $& $9# =/@%))%&') &: A&$9 $9# =..#88='$ ='/ $9# =..#88##[ KEL ;9#' $9# :%'/%'?) =(# <&'$(=(H $&

$9=$ &: $9# $(%=8 <&G($[ KPL ;9#' $9# :%'/%'?) =(# <&'<8G)%&') ;%$9&G$ <%$=$%&' &: ).#<%:%< #+%/#'<# &' ;9%<9

$9#H =(# A=)#/[ KCL ;9#' $9# :=<$) )#$ :&($9 %' $9# .#$%$%&' =) ;#88 =) %' $9# .#$%$%&'#(W) @=%' ='/ (#.8H

A(%#:) =(# '&$ /%).G$#/ AH $9# (#).&'/#'$[ K>DL ;9#' $9# :%'/%'?) &: :=<$ =(# .(#@%)#/ &' $9# )G..&)#/=A)#'<# &: #+%/#'<# ='/ <&'$(=/%<$#/ AH $9# #+%/#'<# &' (#<&(/[ &( K>>L ;9#' $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8)

@='%:#)$8H &+#(8&&\#/ <#($=%' (#8#+='$ :=<$) '&$ /%).G$#/ AH $9# .=($%#)* ;9%<9* %: .(&.#(8H <&')%/#(#/*

;&G8/ `G)$%:H = /%::#(#'$ <&'<8G)%&',IR

 

3' $9%) <=)#* (#<&(/) <8#=(8H )9&; $9=$ "622 /%/ '&$ (#.&($ $9# $#(@%'=$%&' &: .#$%$%&'#(W) )G..&)#/ .(&`#<$

#@.8&H@#'$ :&( $9# 6J3J 33 "(&`#<$ $& $9# 05U1, 0#.=($@#'$ 5(/#( 6&, >C* &( $9# gNG%/#8%'#) N&+#('%'?

$9# [email protected]&H@#'$ &: 7&(\#() %' $9# 2&')$(G<$%&' 3'/G)$(H*g (#]G%(#) #@.8&H#() $& )GA@%$ = (#.&($ &: ='

#@.8&H##W) $#(@%'=$%&' $& $9# '#=(#)$ .GA8%< #@.8&H@#'$ &::%<# #+#(H $%@# =' #@.8&H##W) #@.8&H@#'$ %)

$#(@%'=$#/ /G# $& = <&@.8#$%&' &: = .(&`#<$, "622 )GA@%$$#/ =) #+%/#'<# &: %$) <&@.8%='<# ;%$9 $9#

(#]G%(#@#'$ )G..&)#/ .9&$&<&.%#) &: %$) $#(@%'=$%&' (#.&($)* #=<9 8%)$%'? .#$%$%&'#( =) =@&'? $9#

#@.8&H##) =::#<$#/, Y':&($G'=$#8H* '&'# &: $9# (#.&($) )GA@%$$#/ .#($=%' $& $9# 6J3J 33 "(&`#<$,

Z&(#&+#(* 05U1 62- +#(%:%#/ $9=$ .#$%$%&'#( %) '&$ %'<8G/#/ %' $9# 8%)$ &: =::#<$#/ ;&(\#() A=)#/ &' $9#

$#(@%'=$%&' (#.&($) :%8#/ AH "622 &' JG?G)$ >>* >E* BD ='/ BS* >CCP :&( .#$%$%&'#(W) )G..&)#/ /%)@%))=8

:(&@ $9# 6J3J 33 "(&`#<$ #::#<$%+# JG?G)$ S* >CCP, Q9%) <#($%:%<=$%&' :(&@ 05U1 ;=) '&$ (#:G$#/ AH "622, 3'

Q&@=) U=& 2&')$(G<$%&' +, 6U-2*IT

 ;# #@.9=)%^#/ $9# %'/%).#')=A%8%$H &: $9# (#.&($&(%=8 (#]G%(#@#'$a

Z&(#&+#(* %: .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$) ;#(# %'/##/ #@.8&H#/ =) g.(&`#<$ #@.8&H##)*g .#$%$%&'#() )9&G8/ 9=+#

)GA@%$$#/ = (#.&($ &: $#(@%'=$%&' $& $9# '#=(#)$ .GA8%< #@.8&H@#'$ &::%<# #+#(H $%@# $9#%( #@.8&H@#'$

;=) $#(@%'=$#/ /G# $& <&@.8#$%&' &: #=<9 <&')$(G<$%&' .(&`#<$, Q9# (#<&(/) )9&; $9=$ $9#H /%/ '&$, "&8%<H

3')$(G<$%&' 6&, BD %) #_.8%<%$ $9=$ #@.8&H#() &: .(&`#<$ #@.8&H##) =(# #_#@.$#/ :(&@ $9# <8#=(='<#

(#]G%(#@#'$ AG$ '&$ :(&@ $9# )GA@%))%&' &: $#(@%'=$%&' (#.&($, 7# 9=+# <&')%)$#'$8H 9#8/ $9=$ :=%8G(# &:$9# #@.8&H#( $& :%8# $#(@%'=$%&' (#.&($) =:$#( #+#(H .(&`#<$ <&@.8#$%&' .(&+#) $9=$ $9# #@.8&H##) =(# '&$

.(&`#<$ #@.8&H##), 6&;9#(# %' $9# 6#; U=A&( 2&/# %) %$ .(&+%/#/ $9=$ $9# (#.&($&(%=8 (#]G%(#@#'$ %)

/%).#')#/ ;%$9, Q9# :=<$ %) $9=$ 0#.=($@#'$ 5(/#( 6&, >C )G.#()#/%'? "&8%<H 3')$(G<$%&' 6&, BD #_.(#))8H

.(&+%/#) $9=$ $9# (#.&($ &: $#(@%'=$%&' %) &'# &: $9# %'/%<=$&() &: .(&`#<$ #@.8&H@#'$,IE

 

J (#?G8=( #@.8&H## /%)@%))#/ :&( =

<=G)# &$9#( $9=' $9# `G)$ &(

=G$9&(%^#/ <=G)#) .(&+%/#/ AH 8=; %)

%88#?=88H /%)@%))#/

"#$%$%&'#(W) (#?G8=( #@.8&H@#'$ ;=) $#(@%'=$#/ AH "622 /G# $& <&'$(=<$ #_.%(=$%&' &( .(&`#<$

<&@.8#$%&'* ;9%<9 =(# A&$9 '&$ =@&'? $9# `G)$ &( =G$9&(%^#/ <=G)#) .(&+%/#/ %' $9# U=A&( 2&/#* =)

=@#'/#/* :&( /%)@%))%'? = (#?G8=( #@.8&H##, Q9G)* .#$%$%&'#( ;=) %88#?=88H /%)@%))#/,

Page 22: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 22/108

J($%<8# BEC &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#* =) =@#'/#/* .(&+%/#) $9=$ =' %88#?=88H /%)@%))#/ #@.8&H## %) #'$%$8#/ $&

(#%')$=$#@#'$* :G88 A=<\ ;=?#)* %'<8G)%+# &: =88&;='<#)* ='/ $& 9%) &$9#( A#'#:%$) &( $9#%( @&'#$=(H

#]G%+=8#'$ :(&@ $9# $%@# 9%) <&@.#')=$%&' ;=) ;%$99#8/ :(&@ 9%@ G. $& $9# $%@# &: 9%) =<$G=8

(#%')$=$#@#'$,

7# =?(## ;%$9 .#$%$%&'#( $9=$ $9#(# ;=) '& A=)%) :&( $9# U=A&( J(A%$#(W) :%'/%'? &: )$(=%'#/ (#8=$%&') ='/

&(/#( &: )#.=(=$%&' .=H %' 8%#G &: (#%')$=$#@#'$, Q9%) ;=) '#%$9#( =88#?#/ '&( .(&+#/, Z&(#&+#(* %$ 9=) 8&'?

A##' )#$$8#/ $9=$ $9# /&<$(%'# &: )$(=%'#/ (#8=$%&') )9&G8/ A# )$(%<$8H =..8%#/ )& =) '&$ $& /#.(%+# ='%88#?=88H /%)@%))#/ #@.8&H## &: 9%) (%?9$ $& (#%')$=$#@#'$, J) 9#8/ %' N8&A#MZ=<\=H 2=A8# ='/ -=/%&

2&(.&(=$%&' +, 6U-2aIP

 

5A+%&G)8H* $9# .(%'<%.8# &: g)$(=%'#/ (#8=$%&')g <=''&$ A# =..8%#/ %'/%)<(%@%'=$#8H, 5$9#(;%)#*

(#%')$=$#@#'$ <=' '#+#( A# .&))%A8# )%@.8H A#<=G)# )&@# 9&)$%8%$H %) %'+=(%=A8H #'?#'/#(#/ A#$;##' $9#

.=($%#) =) = (#)G8$ &: 8%$%?=$%&', Q9=$ %) 9G@=' '=$G(#,

O#)%/#)* '& )$(=%'#/ (#8=$%&') )9&G8/ =(%)# :(&@ = +=8%/ ='/ 8#?=8 =<$ &: =))#($%'? &'#W) (%?9$[ &$9#(;%)# ='

#@.8&H## ;9& )9=88 =))#($ 9%) (%?9$ <&G8/ A# #=)%8H )#.=(=$#/ :(&@ $9# )#(+%<#* AH @#(#8H .=H%'? 9%)

)#.=(=$%&' .=H &' $9# .(#$#_$ $9=$ 9%) (#8=$%&')9%. ;%$9 9%) #@.8&H#( 9=/ =8(#=/H A#<&@# )$(=%'#/,

IC

 

J) $& $9# A=<\ ;=?#) /G# .#$%$%&'#(* $9#(# %) 8%\#;%)# '& A=)%) %' /#/G<$%'? $9#(#:(&@ A=<\ ;=?#)

#]G%+=8#'$ $& )%_ @&'$9) g(#.(#)#'$%'? $9# @=_%@G@ .#(%&/ &: <&':%'#@#'$ "622 <=' (#]G%(# 9%@ $&

G'/#(?& @#/%<=8 $(#=$@#'$,g O#)%/#)* .#$%$%&'#( ;=) '&$ /%)@%))#/ &' $9# ?(&G'/ &: /%)#=)# AG$

#_.%(=$%&' &: $#(@ &: .(&`#<$ #@.8&H@#'$,

-#?=(/%'? @&(=8 ='/ #_#@.8=(H /=@=?#)* $9%) 2&G($ (G8#) $9=$ .#$%$%&'#( %) '&$ #'$%$8#/ $&

$9#@,!"#$%&! 7&($9 (#%$#(=$%'? %) $9# (G8# $9=$ @&(=8 /=@=?#) =(# (#<&+#(=A8# ;9#(# $9# /%)@%))=8 &: $9#

#@.8&H## ;=) =$$#'/#/ AH A=/ :=%$9 &( :(=G/ &( <&')$%$G$#/ =' =<$ &..(#))%+# $& 8=A&(* &( ;=) /&'# %' =

@=''#( <&'$(=(H $& @&(=8)* ?&&/ <G)$&@)* &( .GA8%< .&8%<H, U%\#;%)#* #_#@.8=(H /=@=?#) @=H A# =;=(/#/

%: $9# /%)@%))=8 ;=) #::#<$#/ %' = ;='$&'* &..(#))%+# &( @=8#+&8#'$ @=''#(,SD J.=($ :(&@ 9%) =88#?=$%&')*

.#$%$%&'#( /%/ '&$ .(#)#'$ ='H #+%/#'<# $& .(&+# $9=$ 9%) /%)@%))=8 ;=) =$$#'/#/ ;%$9 A=/ :=%$9 &( ;=)

/&'# &..(#))%+#8H,

"#$%$%&'#( %) =8)& #'$%$8#/ $& =$$&('#Hl) :##) @ $9# =@&G'$ &: $#' .#(<#'$ K>DmL &: 9%) $&$=8 @&'#$=(H

=;=(/* 9=+%'? A##' :&(<#/ $& 8%$%?=$# %' &(/#( $& )##\ (#/(#)) &: 9%) ?(%#+='<#)* =) .(&+%/#/ %' J($%<8# >>>

&: $9# U=A&( 2&/#* =) =@#'/#/* ='/ :&88&;%'? $9%) 2&G($l) .(&'&G'<#@#'$ %' 1_&/G) 3'$#('=$%&'=8

2&')$(G<$%&' 2&(.&(=$%&' +, O%)<&<9&,S> 

3' 8%'# ;%$9 <G((#'$ `G(%).(G/#'<#* $9# =;=(/ &: A=<\ ;=?#) )9=88 #=(' 8#?=8 %'$#(#)$ =$ $9# (=$# &: )%_

.#(<#'$ K TmL .#( =''G@ :(&@ $9# /=$# &: .#$%$%&'#(l) /%)@%))=8 G'$%8 $9# :%'=8%$H &: $9%)/#<%)%&',

SB Q9#(#=:$#(* %$ )9=88 #=(' >Bm 8#?=8 %'$#(#)$ G'$%8 :G88H .=%/

SI %' =<<&(/='<# ;%$9 $9# ?G%/#8%'#) %'

1=)$#(' 49%..%'? U%'#)* 3'<, +, 2&G($ &: J..#=8),SS

 

7d1-1X5-1* $9# .#$%$%&' %) N-J6Q10, Q9# =))=%8#/ Z=(<9 BT* BD>D 0#<%)%&' ='/ Z=H BT* BD>D -#)&8G$%&'

&: $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) %' 2JN,-, 4" 6&, >DEPDR =(# 9#(#AH -1V1-410, Q9# /#<%)%&' &: $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( %)

9#(#AH -1364QJQ10 ;%$9 $9# :&88&;%'? Z503X32JQ3564a

>L (#).&'/#'$ "622 %) 03-12Q10 $& .=H .#$%$%&'#( -&H 0, "=)&) :G88 A=<\ ;=?#) :(&@ $9# $%@# &: 9%)

%88#?=8 /%)@%))=8 &' 5<$&A#( >C* BDDD G. $& $9# :%'=8%$H &: $9%) 0#<%)%&'* ;%$9 %'$#(#)$ =$ Tm .#(

=''G@* ='/ >Bm 8#?=8 %'$#(#)$ $9#(#=:$#( G'$%8 :G88H .=%/[

BL (#).&'/#'$ "622 %) 5-01-10 $& (#%')$=$# .#$%$%&'#( "=)&) $& 9%) :&(@#( .&)%$%&' &( $& =

)GA)$='$%=88H #]G%+=8#'$ &'#* ;%$9&G$ 8&)) &: )#'%&(%$H (%?9$) ='/ &$9#( A#'#:%$) =$$#'/='$ $& $9#

.&)%$%&'[ ='/

Page 23: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 23/108

IL (#).&'/#'$ "622 %) 03-12Q10 $& .=H .#$%$%&'#( "=)&) =$$&('#Hl) :##) #]G%+=8#'$ $& >Dm &: 9%)

$&$=8 @&'#$=(H =;=(/,

6& .(&'&G'<#@#'$ =) $& <&)$),

Page 24: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 24/108

 

;+/%):" 9%&&%&(?.("(+#'* '()&)&*+(, * -. '1< '/9+)('1#/(@' /+))%-%* /(0$*+1(+) ,

7 % / # ' # + " 

'%&%"+5 $"!"A 

Q9# .(#)#'$ <=)# <&'<#(') $9# =<=/#@%< ]G=8%:%<=$%&') (#]G%(#/ %' =$$=%'%'? $9# )$=$G) &: = .#(@='#'$ :G88f

$%@# :=<G8$H @#@A#( %' $9# $#($%=(H 8#+#8 &: = .(%+=$# #/G<=$%&'=8 %')$%$G$%&', "#$%$%&'#( F&<#8H' d#((#(=f

Z='=&%) KZ='=&%)L =))=%8) $9# `G/?@#'$)> &: $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) K2JL* ;9%<9 (#+#()#/ $9# -#)&8G$%&'

B &:

$9# 6=$%&'=8 U=A&( -#8=$%&') 2&@@%))%&' K6U-2L ='/ (G8#/ $9=$ (#).&'/#'$ 4$, 4<9&8=)$%<=W) 2&88#?# K442L

;=) '&$ ?G%8$H &: %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8, 442 /%/ '&$ #_$#'/ $& Z='=&%) $9# .&)%$%&' &: .#(@='#'$ :G88f$%@#

:=<G8$H @#@A#( ;%$9 $9# (='\ &: %')$(G<$&( A#<=G)# )9# :=%8#/ $& =<]G%(# = @=)$#(W) /#?(## ='/ A#<=G)#

9#( ).#<%=8%^=$%&' <&G8/ '& 8&'?#( A# @=_%@%^#/ AH $9# %')$%$G$%&' /G# $& $9# <9='?#) %' %$) <G((%<G8G@ ='/

)$(#=@8%'%'?,

1BC 62DEF 

442* )%$G=$#/ %' $9# 2%$H &: Z='%8=* %) = .(%+=$# #/G<=$%&'=8 %')$%$G$%&' &::#(%'? #8#@#'$=(H* )#<&'/=(H* ='/

$#($%=(H #/G<=$%&', Z='=&%) ?(=/G=$#/ :(&@ 442 %' 5<$&A#( >CCB ;%$9 = /#?(## %' O=<9#8&( &: J($) %'

1'?8%)9, 3' >CCS* )9# (#$G('#/ $& 9#( =8@= @=$#( =) = .=($f$%@# 1'?8%)9 $#=<9#(, J:$#( $=\%'? = 8#=+# &:

=A)#'<# :&( &'# H#=(* )9# ;=) =?=%' (#9%(#/ AH 442 :&( $9# )=@# .&)%$%&', X&G( H#=() %'$& $9# )#(+%<#* )9#

;=) 8=$#( &' (#<&@@#'/#/ AH 9#( 0#.=($@#'$ 29=%(.#()&' $& A#<&@# = :G88f$%@# :=<G8$H @#@A#( &: $9#

1'?8%)9 0#.=($@#'$,

Z='=&%) $9G) =..8%#/ :&( = .&)%$%&' =) :G88f$%@# %')$(G<$&( :&( )<9&&8 H#=( BDDDfBDD>, 49# @#'$%&'#/ %'

9#( =..8%<=$%&' 8#$$#(I $9=$ )9# 9=/ A##' $=\%'? $9# <&G()# Z=)$#( &: J($) %' 1'?8%)9 4$G/%#)* Z=`&( %'

2(#=$%+# 7(%$%'?* =$ $9# Y'%+#()%$H &: $9# "9%8%..%'#)* 0%8%@=' KY"L[ $9=$ )9# ;=) <&@.8#$%'? 9#( @=)$#(W)$9#)%)[ ='/ $9=$ 9#( &(=8 /#:#')# ;=) )<9#/G8#/ :&( FG'# BDDD, 3' = (#.8H 8#$$#(

S /=$#/ >E J.(%8 BDDD* $9#

0#=' &: J($) ='/ 4<%#'<#) %':&(@#/ 9#( &: $9# 442 J/@%'%)$(=$%+# 2&G'<%8W) =..(&+=8 &: 9#( =..8%<=$%&', 49#

;=) $9#' =/+%)#/ $& @=%'$=%' $9# ?&&/ .#(:&(@='<# $9=$ )9# 9=/ )9&;' :&( $9# .=)$ H#=() ='/ $& )GA@%$

$9# '#<#))=(H .=.#() .#($=%'%'? $& 9#( @=)$#(W) /#?(##, J<<&(/%'?8H* 442 9%(#/ 9#( =) = .(&A=$%&'=(H :G88f

$%@# :=<G8$H @#@A#( ;%$9 $9# =))%?'#/ (='\ &: %')$(G<$&( :&( $9# )<9&&8 H#=( BDDDfBDD>,R d#(

.(&A=$%&'=(H #@.8&H@#'$ <&'$%'G#/ :&( = $&$=8 &: $9(## <&')#<G$%+# H#=(), Q9(&G?9&G$ 9#( )#(+%<# =) =

.(&A=$%&'=(H :G88f$%@# :=<G8$H @#@A#( ;%$9 '& /#(&?=$&(H (#<&(/* )9# ;=) ?%+#' =A&+#f)=$%):=<$&(H

(=$%'?) AH A&$9 $9# 0#.=($@#'$ 29=%(.#()&' ='/ $9# 0#=' &: J($) ='/ 4<%#'<#),

O#<=G)# &: $9# :&($9<&@%'? <&@.8#$%&' &: 9#( $9%(/ H#=( &: .(&A=$%&'=(H #@.8&H@#'$* Z='=&%) ;(&$# $9#0#=' &: J($) ='/ 4<%#'<#) (#]G#)$%'? =' #_$#')%&' &: 9#( $#=<9%'? 8&=/ :&( $9# )<9&&8 H#=( BDDIfBDDS, 49#

=?=%' @#'$%&'#/ %' 9#( 8#$$#( $9=$ )9# ;=) = <='/%/=$# :&( = @=)$#(W) /#?(## %' 1'?8%)9 4$G/%#)[ $9=$ $9#

)<9#/G8# &: 9#( &(=8 /#:#')# @=H =<$G=88H @=$#(%=8%^# ='H$%@# ;%$9%' $9# :%()$ =<=/#@%< )#@#)$#( &: BDDI[

='/ $9=$ )9# %'$#'/#/ $& :G88H #=(' 9#( /#?(## $9=$ H#=(, 49# =8)& :G('%)9#/ $9# )<9&&8 ;%$9 = 2#($%:%<=$%&'

:(&@ Y"* )$=$%'? $9=$ )9# 9=/ =8(#=/H :%'%)9#/ 9#( <&G()#;&(\ %' 9#( @=)$#(W) )$G/%#), XG($9#(@&(#* )9#

%'/%<=$#/ $9=$ %$ ;=) 9#( 8&'?f$#(@ ?&=8 $& =..8H :&( = (#$G(' $& :G88f$%@# :=<G8$H )$=$G) AH $9#' ='/ :&( 442

$& <&')%/#( $9# =:&(#)=%/ @=$$#(),T 

Z='=&%) #+#'$G=88H (#<#%+#/ = 8#$$#( :(&@ $9# 0#=' &: 2&88#?# ='/ 29=%(.#()&' &: $9# "(&@&$%&') ='/

"#(@='#'<H O&=(/ &::%<%=88H %':&(@%'? 9#( &: $9# A&=(/W) /#<%)%&' '&$ $& (#'#; 9#( <&'$(=<$, Q9# 8#$$#(.(&+%/#) =) :&88&;)a

Q9# "#(@='#'<H O&=(/ (#+%#;#/ H&G( <=)# ='/ =:$#( = $9&(&G?9 /#8%A#(=$%&'* $9# @#@A#() /#<%/#/ '&$ $&

(#'#; H&G( <&'$(=<$ :&( )<9&&8 H#=( BDDIfBDDS,

Page 25: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 25/108

 

7%$9 /G# <&')%/#(=$%&' $& H&G( )#(+%<#)* $9# %')$%$G$%&' 9=/ ?(='$#/ H&G( (#]G#)$ :&( = $9(##fH#=(

#_$#')%&' $& :%'%)9 H&G( @=)$#(W) /#?(##, d&;#+#(* H&G :=%8#/ $& <&@.8H ;%$9 $9# $#(@) ;9%<9 H&G H&G()#8:

9=/ (#]G#)$#/, 3' =//%$%&'* H&G( ).#<%=8%^=$%&' <=''&$ A# @=_%@%^#/ =$ 442 /G# $& $9# <&88#?#W) <G((%<G8G@

<9='?#) ='/ )$(#=@8%'%'?,

3$ %) ;%$9 H&G( A#)$ %'$#(#)$ %' @%'/ ='/ /##. (#?(#$ &' &G( .=($ $9=$ ;# 9=+# $& 8#$ H&G ?&, J '#;

#'+%(&'@#'$ @=H A# =A8# $& .(&+%/# H&G @&(# =+#'G#) ='/ &..&($G'%$%#) ;9#(# H&G <=' G$%8%^# H&G(?(=/G=$# )$G/%#) %' 2(#=$%+# 7(%$%'? $& $9# :G88#)$,

Z='=&%) )&G?9$ <8=(%:%<=$%&' ='/ (#<&')%/#(=$%&' &: $9# /#<%)%&' &: 442 $& $#(@%'=$# 9#( )#(+%<#), 442

/#'%#/ 9#( (#]G#)$ %' = 8#$$#( /=$#/ >> FG8H BDDI, 2&')#]G#'$8H* )9# :%8#/ = <&@.8=%'$ :&( %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8*

.=H@#'$ &: >I$9

 @&'$9 .=H* /=@=?#)* ='/ =$$&('#HW) :##) =?=%')$ 442,

442 #_.8=%'#/ $9=$ G.&' <&')%/#(=$%&' &: $9# ;(%$$#' =..8%<=$%&' &: Z='=&%)* $9# 0#=' &: J($) ='/ 4<%#'<#)

;(&$# $9# :&88&;%'? '&$=$%&' =$ $9# A&$$&@ &: 9#( 8#$$#( &: =..8%<=$%&' f tJ""-5V10a &' $9# A=)%) $9=$ )9#

:%'%)9#) 9#( ZJ,uP Q9# <&88#?# <8=(%:%#/ $9=$ $9# =..8%<=$%&' :&( :G88f$%@# :=<G8$H )$=$G) &: Z='=&%) ;=)

=<<#.$#/ ;%$9 $9# ).#<%:%< ]G=8%:%<=$%&' $9=$ )9# ;&G8/ )GA@%$ $9# '#<#))=(H .=.#() .#($=%'%'? $& 9#(

@=)$#(W) /#?(##, 3$ )$(#))#/ $9=$ .#(@='#'<H @=H &'8H A# #_$#'/#/ $& :G88f$%@# :=<G8$H @#@A#() %: $9#H9=/ :G8:%88#/ $9# <(%$#(%= .(&+%/#/ %' $9# 442 X=<G8$H Z='G=8, J<<&(/%'? $& 442* $9# 29=%( &: $9# 1'?8%)9

0#.=($@#'$ /%/ '&$ #'/&()# $9# =..8%<=$%&' :&( .#(@='#'<H &: Z='=&%)* )%'<# $9# 8=$$#( 9=/ '&$ :%'%)9#/

9#( @=)$#(W) /#?(## ;%$9%' $9# $9(##fH#=( .(&A=$%&'=(H .#(%&/, 442 $9#' (#:G$#/ $9# )G..&)#/

.#(:&(@='<# (=$%'?) &: Z='=&%) ='/ %')$#=/ .&%'$#/ &G$ $9=$ )9# 9=/ @#(#8H (#<#%+#/ =' =+#(=?# (=$%'?

:(&@ 9#( )$G/#'$), X%'=88H* %$ =))#($#/ $9=$ 9#( ).#<%=8%^=$%&' ;=) $9# )GA`#<$ &: ;(%$%'? ='/ '&$ 1'?8%)9

U%$#(=$G(#* ;9%<9 ;=) $9# )GA`#<$ =(#= $9=$ $9#H '##/#/ = :=<G8$H @#@A#( :&(,

1BC )2GHI (IGJECI &KLJ3M 

5' >T FG8H BDDS* $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#( (#'/#(#/ = 0#<%)%&'C :%'/%'? $9# /%)@%))=8 &: .#$%$%&'#( $& A# %88#?=8, 3'

=//(#))%'? $9# %))G#)* 9# :%()$ '&$#/ $9# $;& (#=)&') ?%+#' AH 442 :&( '&$ (#'#;%'? $9# <&'$(=<$ &:

Z='=&%)a K>L $9# :=%8G(# &: .#$%$%&'#( $& :%'%)9 9#( @=)$#(W) /#?(## ;%$9%' $9# $9(##fH#=( .(&A=$%&'=(H

.#(%&/[ ='/ KBL 442W) %'=A%8%$H $& @=_%@%^# .#$%$%&'#(W) ).#<%=8%^=$%&' /G# $& <G((%<G8G@ <9='?#) ='/

)$(#=@8%'%'?,

7%$9 (#).#<$ $& $9# :%()$ (#=)&'* $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#( (#%$#(=$#/ $9=$ $9# =88#?#/ 9='/;(%$$#' '&$=$%&' &'

Z='=&%)W) #@.8&H@#'$ =..8%<=$%&' )9&;%'? $9=$ $9# =..(&+=8 $9#(#&: ;=) .(#@%)#/ &' 9#( <&@.8#$%&' &:

= @=)$#(W) /#?(## 9=/ '&$ A##' /%)<8&)#/ &( @=/# \'&;' $& 9#( =$ $9# )$=($ &: 9#( #'?=?#@#'$, 3' :=<$*

)9# ;=) '&$ ?%+#' = <&.H &: $9# =..(&+=8 G'$%8 %$ ;=) =$$=<9#/ $& $9# .&)%$%&' .=.#( &: 442, Q9# 8=A&(

=(A%$#( =?(##/ ;%$9 Z='=&%) $9=$ $9# &'8H <(#/%A8# #+%/#'<# $9=$ = .(#<&'/%$%&' 9=/ A##' )#$ :&( $9#

=<<#.$='<# &: 9#( #@.8&H@#'$ =..8%<=$%&' ;=) 442W) 8#$$#( #_.(#))8H )$=$%'? $9=$ )9# @G)$ K=L @=%'$=%' =?&&/ .#(:&(@='<# ='/ KAL )GA@%$ $9# '#<#))=(H .=.#() .#($=%'%'? $& 9#( @=)$#(W) /#?(##, -#?=(/%'? $9#)#

.(#<&'/%$%&')* $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#( '&$#/ $9=$ $9# =88#?=$%&' <&'<#('%'? $9# @#(# =+#(=?# .#(:&(@='<# (=$%'?

&: Z='=&%) ?%+#' AH $9# )$G/#'$) ;=) '#%$9#( @=/# \'&;' $& 9#( '&( /G8H )GA)$='$%=$#/ ;%$9

/&<G@#'$=(H .(&&:, 1+#' )&* $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#( =($%<G8=$#/ $9=$ =$ $9# +#(H 8#=)$* $9# .#(:&(@='<# &:

Z='=&%) /G(%'? 9#( $9(##fH#=( .(&A=$%&'=(H #@.8&H@#'$ ;=) )=$%):=<$&(H* =) =/@%$$#/ AH 442 %$)#8:*

$9#(#AH )=$%):H%'? $9# :%()$ <&'/%$%&' @#'$%&'#/ %' $9# 8#$$#(, Q9# 8=A&( =(A%$#( $9#' <&')%/#(#/ $9#

2#($%:%<=$%&' %))G#/ AH Y" =) )G::%<%#'$ #+%/#'<# &: Z='=&%)W) <&@.8%='<# ;%$9 $9# )#<&'/ <&'/%$%&' )#$ AH

442,

6#_$* $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#( '&$#/ $9=$ G'/#( $9# 442 X=<G8$H Z='G=8* $9# @%'%@G@ (#]G%(#@#'$) :&( $9# (='\&: %')$(G<$&(* :&( ;9%<9 .#$%$%&'#( 9=/ A##' 9%(#/ G'/#( $9# #@.8&H@#'$ <&'$(=<$* ;=) = A=<9#8&(W) /#?(##

;%$9 =$ 8#=)$ BRm G'%$) &: @=)$#(W) )$G/%#) <&@.8#$#/, d# $9#' :&G'/ $9=$ $9# (#]G%(#@#'$ :&( = @=)$#(W)

/#?(## =<$G=88H .#($=%'#/ $& $9# (='\ &: =))%)$='$ .(&:#))&(* = .&)%$%&' $9=$ 9=/ '&$ A##' =..8%#/ :&( AH

Page 26: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 26/108

Z='=&%), Q9G)* 9# (G8#/ $9=$ :=%8G(# $& :%'%)9 = @=)$#(W) /#?(## <&G8/ '&$ A# G)#/ #%$9#( =) = ?(&G'/ :&(

/%)@%))%'? .#$%$%&'#( &( =) A=)%) :&( (#:G)%'? $& #_$#'/ $& 9#( = .#(@='#'$ $#=<9%'? )$=$G),

J'#'$ (#).&'/#'$W) =(?G@#'$ <%$%'? $9# Z='G=8 &: -#?G8=$%&') :&( "(%+=$# 4<9&&8)* $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#( (G8#/

$9=$ $9# .(&+%)%&') $9#(#%' ;#(# %'=..8%<=A8# %')&:=( =) $9# #@.8&H@#'$ )$=$G) &: .#$%$%&'#( ;=)

<&'<#('#/, d# #_.8=%'#/ $9=$ $9# @='G=8 @#(#8H (#:#((#/ $& $9# (#]G%(#@#'$) :&( $#($%=(H )<9&&8) $& A#

=<<(#/%$#/ ='/ '&$ $& $9# #@.8&H@#'$ <&'/%$%&') &: $9# =<=/#@%< .#()&''#8, Q9G)* 9# .(&'&G'<#/ $9=$

4#<$%&') SSK<L ='/ SR &: $9# @='G=8* ;9%<9 (#]G%(#/ $#($%=(H )<9&&8) $& 9%(# $#=<9#() ;9& ;#(# 9&8/#() &:@=)$#(W) /#?(##)* <&G8/ '&$ A# G)#/ =) A=)%) :&( /%)@%))%'? Z='=&%),

Q9# 8=A&( =(A%$#( $9#' :&<G)#/ &' $9# )#<&'/ (#=)&' &: 442 =) = (#:8#<$%&' &: $9# $(G# @&$%+# A#9%'/ $9#

/%)@%))=8 &: Z='=&%), J<<&(/%'? $& $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#(* $9# <8#=( %@.&($ &: $9# )$=$#@#'$ tH&G( ).#<%=8%^=$%&'

<=''&$ A# @=_%@%^#/ =$ 442 /G# $& $9# <&88#?#W) <G((%<G8G@ <9='?#) ='/ )$(#=@8%'%'?u ;=) $9=$ 442 9=/

=8(#=/H /#<%/#/ $& $#(@%'=$# 9#( )#(+%<#)* (#?=(/8#)) &: $9# <&@.8#$%&' &: 9#( @=)$#(W) /#?(##, Q9# 8=A&(

=(A%$#( <&')#]G#'$8H (G8#/ $9=$ $9%) (#=)&' ;=) '&$ = +=8%/ <=G)# :&( /%)@%))%'? = .(&A=$%&'=(H #@.8&H##*

(#%$#(=$%'? $9=$ .(&A=$%&'#() @=H &'8H A# $#(@%'=$#/ #%$9#( K=L :&( = `G)$ <=G)#* &( KAL :&( :=%8G(# $& ]G=8%:H

=) = (#?G8=( #@.8&H## %' =<<&(/='<# ;%$9 (#=)&'=A8# )$='/=(/) @=/# \'&;' =$ $9# $%@# &: #'?=?#@#'$,

Y8$%@=$#8H* $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#( .(&'&G'<#/ $9=$ Z='=&%) 9=/ =$$=%'#/ .#(@='#'$ )$=$G) ='/ $9=$ 442W)'&'(#'#;=8 &: 9#( <&'$(=<$ @G)$ A# /##@#/ =) = /%)@%))=8 ;%$9&G$ `G)$ <=G)#,

1BC ")&/ &KLJ3M 

5' BE FG8H BDDE* $9# 6=$%&'=8 U=A&( -#8=$%&') 2&@@%))%&' K6U-2L %))G#/ = -#)&8G$%&'>D

G.9&8/%'? $9# 8=A&(

=(A%$#(W) 0#<%)%&', Q9# 6U-2 (#%$#(=$#/ $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#(W) :%'/%'? $9=$ $9# :=%8G(# &: .#$%$%&'#( $& :%'%)9 9#(

@=)$#(W) /#?(## ;%$9%' $9# $9(##fH#=( .(&A=$%&'=(H .#(%&/ ;=) '&$ = +=8%/ ?(&G'/ :&( $9# $#(@%'=$%&' &:

#@.8&H@#'$* =) $9# <&'/%$%&' ;=) '&$ @=/# \'&;' $& 9#( =$ $9# $%@# &: #'?=?#@#'$, XG($9#(@&(#* %$

(#=)&'#/ $9=$ =' =+#(=?# (=$%'? ;=) '&$ &'# &: $9# `G)$ <=G)#) :&( /%)@%))=8 G'/#( $9# U=A&( 2&/#,

2&')#]G#'$8H* %$ =::%(@#/ $9# 0#<%)%&' &: $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#( &+ )*)*,

1BC /( &KLJ3M 

5' BE X#A(G=(H BDDC* $9# 2J %))G#/ $9# .(#)#'$8H =))=%8#/ 0#<%)%&' (#+#()%'? $9# 6U-2 `G/?@#'$ &' $9#

?(&G'/ &: ?(=+# =AG)# &: /%)<(#$%&' ='/ $9G) /%)@%))%'? $9# <&@.8=%'$ &: Z='=&%), J<<&(/%'? $& $9#

=..#88=$# <&G($* %$ ;=) <&@.#88#/ $& <&'/G<$ %$) %'/#.#'/#'$ #+=8G=$%&' &: $9# :=<$) &: $9# <=)#* )%'<# $9#

:=<$G=8 :%'/%'?) &: $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#( ='/ $9# 6U-2 ;#(# <&'$(=(H $& $9# #+%/#'<# &' (#<&(/,

X%()$* $9# 2J (G8#/ $9=$ +=(%&G) .%#<#) &: #+%/#'<# )9&;#/ $9=$ Z='=&%) 9=/ A##'* =$ $9# $%@# &:

#'?=?#@#'$* =;=(# ='/ \'&;8#/?#=A8# $9=$ .&))#))%&' &: = @=)$#(W) /#?(## ;=) = <(%$#(%&' :&(

.#(@='#'<H =) = :G88f$%@# :=<G8$H @#@A#( =$ 442, J) #=(8H =) J.(%8 BDDD* ;9%<9 ;=) $9# .#(%&/ /G(%'?;9%<9 Z='=&%) =..8%#/ $& A#<&@# = :G88f$%@# :=<G8$H @#@A#(* )9# 9=/ =8(#=/H )#'$ = 8#$$#( %'/%<=$%'? $9=$

)9# ;=) <&@.8#$%'? 9#( @=)$#(W) /#?(##* ='/ $9=$ $9# &(=8 /#:#')# &: 9#( $9#)%) ;=) )<9#/G8#/ :&( FG'#

BDDD, J<<&(/%'? $& $9# =..#88=$# <&G($* $9%) :=<$ (#=)&'=A8H %@.8%#/ $9=$ )9# ;=) :G88H =;=(# &: $9#

'#<#))%$H &: = @=)$#(W) /#?(## %' &(/#( :&( 9#( $& =$$=%' .#(@='#'$ )$=$G) =$ 442, XG($9#(@&(#* %$ '&$#/

$9=$ Z='=&%) )GA@%$$#/* $&?#$9#( ;%$9 9#( =..8%<=$%&' 8#$$#(* = 2#($%:%<=$%&' :(&@ Y" )$=$%'? $9=$ )9# 9=/

=8(#=/H :%'%)9#/ 9#( <&G()# ;&(\ :&( 9#( @=)$#(W) /#?(##, 3$ $9#' /#/G<#/ $9=$ $9%) )GA@%))%&' ;=) .(&&:

$9=$ )9# 9=/ #'/#=+&(#/ $& )GA)$='$%=88H <&@.8H ;%$9 &'# &: $9# (#]G%(#@#'$) :&( .#(@='#'<H,

Q9# 2J $9#' `G_$=.&)#/ 9#( 8#$$#( ;%$9 $9# (#.8H &: 442W) 0#=' &: J($) ='/ 4<%#'<#)* ;9& )=%/ $9=$

.#$%$%&'#( @G)$ )GA@%$ $9# '#<#))=(H .=.#() .#($=%'%'? $& $9# 8=$$#(W) @=)$#(W) /#?(##* =) (#.(#)#'$#/ %'9#( =..8%<=$%&' 8#$$#(, 3$ $(#=$#/ $9%) (#.8H =) %'/GA%$=A8# .(&&: &: 442W) =..(=%)=8 &: $9# (#]G%(#@#'$ $&

&A$=%' = @=)$#(W) /#?(##, 2&')#]G#'$8H* $9# =..#88=$# <&G($ (#=)&'#/ $9=$ $9# /%)<8&)G(# &: $9# '&$=$%&'

&' .#$%$%&'#(W) =..8%<=$%&' 8=$$#( ;=) =8(#=/H %'<&')#]G#'$%=8* )%'<# &'# &: $9# $&.%<) &: $9# #_<9='?# &:

Page 27: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 27/108

<&((#).&'/#'<#) A#$;##' $9# .=($%#) %' J.(%8 BDDD ;=) $9# )GA@%))%&' &: .#$%$%&'#(W) .=.#() :&( 9#(

@=)$#(W) /#?(##, Q9%) /%(#<$%+# .(&::#(#/ '& &$9#( %'$#(.(#$=$%&' $9=' $9=$ $9# <&@.8#$%&' &: = @=)$#(W)

/#?(## 9=/ A##' = .(#<&'/%$%&' :&( $9# <&':#(@#'$ &: Z='=&%)W) .#(@='#'$ #@.8&H@#'$ )$=$G),

Q9# 2J =8)& '&$#/ $9=$ $9# #@.8&H@#'$ <&'$(=<$ &: .#$%$%&'#( %'<&(.&(=$#/ $9# <&'/%$%&') )#$ %' $9# 442

X=<G8$H Z='G=8, Q9# @='G=8 #_.8%<%$8H )$=$#/ $9=$ $9# <(%$#(%= :&( .#(@='#'<H %'<8G/#/ $9# <&@.8#$%&' &: =

@=)$#(W) /#?(##, J<<&(/%'? $& $9# 2J* $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#( ?(=+#8H #((#/ ;9#' 9# )&8#8H (#8%#/ &' $9#

@%'%@G@ (#]G%(#@#'$) .(&+%/#/ :&( $9# (='\ &: %')$(G<$&(, 3$ )$(#))#/ $9=$ $9# <(%$#(%= <%$#/ :&( $9# (='\ &:%')$(G<$&( (#:#((#/ $& $9# A=)%) &' ;9%<9 :G88f$%@# ='/ .=($f$%@# :=<G8$H @#@A#() ;#(# (='\#/* ='/ '&$ $&

$9# (#]G%(#@#'$) $& A# :G8:%88#/ %' &(/#( $& A#<&@# = .#(@='#'$ :=<G8$H @#@A#(, 3')$#=/* $9# =..#88=$#

<&G($ =?(##/ ;%$9 442 $9=$ ;9=$ 9=..#'#/ %' $9%) <=)# ;=) @#(#8H $9# #_.%(=$%&' &: =' #@.8&H@#'$

<&'$(=<$ ='/ $9# '&'(#'#;=8 $9#(#&:, 3$ .&%'$#/ &G$ $9=$* %' ).%$# &: $9# (#]G#)$) &: Z='=&%) :&( $9#

#_$#')%&' &: 9#( #@.8&H@#'$ %' &(/#( :&( 9#( $& :%'%)9 9#( @=)$#(W) /#?(##* )9# :=%8#/ $& /& )&, 3' :=<$* )9#

%':&(@#/ 442 $9=$ $9#(# ;=) )$%88 '& :%_#/ )<9#/G8# :&( 9#( &(=8 /#:#')#,

Q9G)* %' $9# 8%?9$ &: $9# :&(#?&%'? .%#<#) &: #+%/#'<#* $9# 2J (G8#/ $9=$ $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#( ='/ $9# 6U-2

<&@@%$$#/ ?(=+# =AG)# &: /%)<(#$%&' %' (G8%'? $9=$ .#$%$%&'#( 9=/ '&$ A##' @=/# =;=(# &: $9# (#=)&'=A8#

)$='/=(/) &: #@.8&H@#'$ =$ $9# $%@# &: 9#( #'?=?#@#'$, O=)#/ &' 9#( &;' =<$)* Z='=&%) \'#; &: $9#'#<#))%$H &: &A$=%'%'? = @=)$#(W) /#?(## %' &(/#( $& =$$=%' .#(@='#'$ #@.8&H@#'$ )$=$G), 442 ;=) $9G)

;#88 ;%$9%' %$) (%?9$) '&$ $& (#'#; 9#( #@.8&H@#'$ <&'$(=<$ :&( 9#( :=%8G(# $& ]G=8%:H =) = .#(@='#'$ :G88f

$%@# :=<G8$H @#@A#(, 2&')#]G#'$8H* 9#( <&@.8=%'$ ;=) /%)@%))#/,

1BC #FFKC 

79#$9#( $9# <&@.8#$%&' &: = @=)$#(W) /#?(## %) (#]G%(#/ %' &(/#( :&( = $#($%=(H 8#+#8 #/G<=$&( $& #=(' $9#

)$=$G) &: .#(@='#'<H %' = .(%+=$# #/G<=$%&'=8 %')$%$G$%&',

+KI &KLJ3M 

"(&A=$%&'=(H #@.8&H@#'$ (#:#() $& $9# $(%=8 )$=?# &( .#(%&/ /G(%'? ;9%<9 $9# #@.8&H#( #_=@%'#) $9#

<&@.#$#'<H ='/ ]G=8%:%<=$%&') &: `&A =..8%<='$)* ='/ /#$#(@%'#) ;9#$9#( $9#H =(# ]G=8%:%#/ $& A#

#_$#'/#/ .#(@='#'$ #@.8&H@#'$ )$=$G),>>

 4G<9 =' =((='?#@#'$ =::&(/) =' #@.8&H#( $9# &..&($G'%$H f

A#:&(# $9# :G88 :&(<# &: $9# ?G=(='$## &: )#<G(%$H &: $#'G(# <&@#) %'$& .8=H f $& :G88H )<(G$%'%^# ='/ &A)#(+#

$9# :%$'#)) ='/ ;&($9 &: .(&A=$%&'#() ;9%8# &' $9# `&A ='/ $& /#$#(@%'# ;9#$9#( $9#H ;&G8/ A#<&@#

.(&.#( ='/ #::%<%#'$ #@.8&H##),>B

 3$ =8)& ?%+#) $9# .(&A=$%&'#() $9# <9='<# $& .(&+# $& $9# #@.8&H#( $9=$

$9#H .&))#)) $9# '#<#))=(H ]G=8%$%#) ='/ ]G=8%:%<=$%&') $& @##$ (#=)&'=A8# )$='/=(/) :&( .#(@='#'$

#@.8&H@#'$,>I J($%<8# BP> &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#* =) =@#'/#/* .(&+%/#) =)

:&88&;)a<9='-&A8#)+%($G=8U=;8%A(=(H

(IE< NOP< 0IHG2EJH32IQ CRSLHQRC3E< "(&A=$%&'=(H #@.8&H@#'$ )9=88 '&$ #_<##/ )%_ KTL @&'$9) :(&@ $9#/=$# $9# #@.8&H## )$=($#/ ;&(\%'?* G'8#)) %$ %) <&+#(#/ AH =' =..(#'$%<#)9%. =?(##@#'$ )$%.G8=$%'? =

8&'?#( .#(%&/, 1BC FCITJDCF HU 23 CRSLHQCC VBH B2F GCC3 C3M2MC4 H3 2 SIHG2EJH32IQ G2FJF R2Q GC

ECIRJ32EC4 :&( = `G)$ <=G)# &( VBC3 BC U2JLF EH WK2LJUQ 2F 2 ICMKL2I CRSLHQCC J3 2DDHI423DC VJEB

IC2FH32GLC FE2342I4F R24C X3HV3 GQ EBC CRSLHQCI EH EBC CRSLHQCC 2E EBC EJRC HU BJF C3M2MCRC3E, J'

#@.8&H## ;9& %) =88&;#/ $& ;&(\ =:$#( = .(&A=$%&'=(H .#(%&/ )9=88 A# <&')%/#(#/ = (#?G8=( #@.8&H##,

K34$%50(0 06$$7&(1 L<9='(&A8#)+%($G=8=;8%A(=(H

7# =?(## ;%$9 $9# 2J %' )#$$%'? =)%/# $9# 6U-2 0#<%)%&' ='/ %' (G8%'? $9=$ $9# (#]G%(#@#'$ $& &A$=%' =

@=)$#(W) /#?(## ;=) @=/# \'&;' $& Z='=&%), Q9# <&'$(=<$ )9# )%?'#/ <8#=(8H %'<&(.&(=$#) $9# (G8#)*

(#?G8=$%&')* ='/ #@.8&H@#'$ <&'/%$%&') <&'$=%'#/ %' $9# 442 X=<G8$H Z='G=8* -&8a>S 

3, 1Z"U5kZ16Q

J,  _ _ _

Page 28: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 28/108

O,  J:$#( 9=+%'? (#=/ ='/ G'/#()$&&/ %' :G88 $9# <&'$#'$) &: $9# 25UU1N1 Y63QW) <G((#'$ XJ2YUQk

ZJ6YJU* EBC 6(/!)1: .%.,%& 2MICCF EH :=%$9:G88H .#(:&(@ =88 $9# /G$%#) ='/ (#).&')%A%8%$%#)

=$$#'/='$ $& 9#( .&)%$%&' =) "-5OJQ356J-k XYUUfQ3Z1 XJ2YUQk Z1ZO1- ='/ DHRSLQ VJEB 2LL EBC

IKLCF5 ICMKL2EJH3F 234 CRSLHQRC3E DH34JEJH3F HU EBC '/9++)5 2F SIHTJ4C4 J3 F2J4 6(/!)1:

.("!() J3DLK4J3M 23Q 2RC34RC3EYF SCIEJ3C3E EH BCI SHFJEJH3 2F R2Q GC BCICJ32UECI

J3DHISHI2EC4 EBCICJ3,

_ _ _

3V, 1XX12Q3V3Qk

J,  Q9# '/9++) B2F EBC IJMBE EH ECIRJ32EC EBC 6(/!)1: .%.,%&@' FCITJDCF UHI `G)$ <=G)# )G<9 =)*

=@&'? &$9#()* U2JLKIC EH DHRSLQ VJEB 23Q HU EBC SIHTJFJH3F HU EBC 6(/!)1: .("!() SCIEJ3C3E EH

BCI FE2EKF =) XYUUfQ3Z1 "-5OJQ356J-k XJ2YUQk Z1ZO1-, K34$%50(0 06$$7&(1 L

Q9# 442 X=<G8$H Z='G=8 %' $G(' .(&+%/#) :&( $9# :&88&;%'? <&'/%$%&') %' &(/#( :&( = :=<G8$H @#@A#( $&

=<]G%(# .#(@='#'$ #@.8&H@#'$ )$=$G)a>R

 

O, "1-ZJ6162k

>,  "(%&( $& $9# #'/ &: $9# .(&A=$%&'=(H .#(%&/* $9# :=<G8$H @#@A#( :&(@=88H =..8%#) :&( .#(@='#'<H $&

9#(e9%) 0#.=($@#'$ 29=%(e2&&(/%'=$&(, Q9# 0#.=($@#'$ 29=%(e2&&(/%'=$&(* %' <&')G8$=$%&' ;%$9

$9# :=<G8$H @#@A#(* (#+%#;) $9# =..8%<='$W) &+#(f=88 .#(:&(@='<#, 3: $9# (#<&(/) )9&; $9=$ $9#

<(%$#(%= :&( .#(@='#'<H =(# @#$* $9# =..8%<='$ %) (#<&@@#'/#/ :&( .#(@='#'<H $& $9# "(&@&$%&')

='/ "#(@='#'<H O&=(/ AH $9# 0#.=($@#'$ 29=%(e2&&(/%'=$&(, 3' <#($=%' %')$='<#) K%,#,* ;9#' $9#

0#.=($@#'$ 29=%(e2&&(/%'=$&( /&#) '&$ ?%+# = (#<&@@#'/=$%&' :&( .#(@='#'<HL* $9# J<=/#@%<

0#=' <=' #_#(<%)# 9#( .(#(&?=$%+# $& (#<&@@#'/ $9# =..8%<='$,

_ _ _

2-3Q1-3J X5- "1-ZJ6162k

>,  1BC U2DKLEQ RCRGCI RKFE B2TC DHRSLCEC4 2E LC2FE 2 R2FECI@F 4CMICC< 

B,  Q9# :=<G8$H @#@A#( @G)$ @='%:#)$ A#9=+%&( (#:8#<$%+# &: $9# )<9&&8W) @%))%&'f+%)%&' ='/ ?&=8),

I,  Q9# :=<G8$H @#@A#( @G)$ 9=+# <&')%)$#'$8H (#<#%+#/ =A&+# =+#(=?# (=$%'? :&( $#=<9%'?

.#(:&(@='<# =) #+=8G=$#/ AH $9# J<=/#@%< 0#='* 0#.=($@#'$ 29=%(e2&&(/%'=$&( ='/ $9# )$G/#'$),

S,  Q9# :=<G8$H @#@A#( @G)$ 9=+# @='%:#)$#/ @&(# $9=' )=$%):=<$&(H :G8:%88@#'$ &: /G$%#) ='/

(#).&')%A%8%$%#) =) #+%/#'<#/ AH &::%<%=8 (#<&(/) #).#<%=88H %' $9# =(#=) &:a _ _ _

R,  Q9# :=<G8$H @#@A#( @G)$ @='%:#)$ =;=(#'#)) &: ='/ =/9#(#'<# $& $9# )<9&&8W) <&/# &: #$9%<) :&(

:=<G8$H,

T,  Q9# :=<G8$H @#@A#( @G)$ A# %' ?&&/ .9H)%<=8 9#=8$9 ='/ @='%:#)$ .&)%$%+# ;#88 A#%'?, K34$%50&0

06$$7&(1 L

V%#;#/ '#_$ $& $9# )$=$#@#'$) ='/ =<$%&') &: Z='=&%) f &.(.* $9# (#:#(#'<#) $& &A$=%'%'? = @=)$#(W) /#?(##

%' 9#( =..8%<=$%&' 8#$$#(* %' $9# )GA)#]G#'$ <&((#).&'/#'<#) A#$;##' 9#( ='/ 442* ='/ %' $9# 8#$$#(

)##\%'? $9# #_$#')%&' &: = $#=<9%'? 8&=/ :&( $9# )<9&&8 H#=( BDDIfBDDS[ ='/ 9#( )GA@%))%&' &:

<#($%:%<=$%&') :(&@ Y" ='/ :(&@ 9#( $9#)%) =/+%)#( f ;# :%'/ $9=$ $9#(# %) %'/##/ )GA)$='$%=8 #+%/#'<#.(&+%'? $9=$ )9# \'#; =A&G$ $9# '#<#))=(H =<=/#@%< ]G=8%:%<=$%&') $& &A$=%' $9# )$=$G) &: .#(@='#'<H,

7# =8)& =?(## ;%$9 $9# 2J $9=$ $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#( ='/ $9# 6U-2 ?(=+#8H @%)%'$#(.(#$#/ $9# )#<$%&' %' $9#

Page 29: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 29/108

442 X=<G8$H Z='G=8* ;9%<9 .G(.&($#/8H .(&+%/#/ :&( = 8&;#( =<=/#@%< (#]G%(#@#'$ :&( :G88f$%@# :=<G8$H

@#@A#() ;%$9 $9# (='\ &: %')$(G<$&(* (#?=(/8#)) &: ;9#$9#( $9#H 9=+# =$$=%'#/ .#(@='#'<H &( =(# )$%88 &'

.(&A=$%&', Q9# 8=A&( =(A%$#( (#:#() $& $9# :&88&;%'? )#<$%&' %' $9# 442 Z='G=8a>T

 

O, (//+&7#"- 1+ &("> 

+3LQ UKLL?EJRC 234 B2LU?EJRC U2DKLEQ RCRGCIF 2IC I23XC4< 4GA)%/%=(H :=<G8$H @#@A#() :&88&; = )#.=(=$#

(='\%'? )H)$#@, O=)#/ &' =<=/#@%< .(#.=(=$%&'* :G8:%88@#'$ &: /G$%#) ='/ (#).&')%A%8%$%#)* .#(:&(@='<#*

(#)#=(<9* &G$.G$ ='/e&( <&@@G'%$H )#(+%<#* = :G88f$%@# &( 9=8:f$%@# :=<G8$H @#@A#( @=H A# =..&%'$#/ $&='H &: $9# :&88&;%'? (='\)a

>, 364Q-Y2Q5-

Q9#(# =(# Z SIHG2EJH32IQ I23XF ='/ O SCIR23C3E I23XF 

2< .J3JRKR &CWKJICRC3EF 

>,  J A=<9#8&(W) /#?(## ;%$9 2E LC2FE N[\ R2FECI2L K3JEF DHRSLCEC4 

B, 

J$ 8#=)$ B H#=() &: $#=<9%'? #_.#(%#'<# &( %$) #]G%+=8#'$ K%,#,* > H#=( )G.#(+%)&(H &( .(&:#))%&'=8

#_.#(%#'<#L

A, "(&@&$%&' ;%$9%' $9# -='\

>,  J @%'%@G@ &: > H#=( %' $9# .(#)#'$ 8#+#8 :&( .(&@&$%&' $& 3')$(G<$&( B* I* S* ='/ R[ = @%'%@G@ &: B

H#=() :&( .(&@&$%&' $& 3')$(G<$&( T* E ='/ P,

B,  J' 3')$(G<$&( =$ ='H 8#+#8 @=H A# .(&@&$#/ $& $9# (='\ &: J))%)$='$ "(&:#))&( G.&' :G8:%88@#'$ &: =88

$9# ]G=8%:%<=$%&') ='/ (#]G%(#@#'$) &: $9# )=%/ (='\, K34$%50(0 06$$7&(1 L

J) <&((#<$8H .&%'$#/ &G$ AH $9# 2J* $9# =:&(#<%$#/ @%'%@G@ (#]G%(#@#'$) .(&+%/#/ :&( $9# (='\ &:

%')$(G<$&( @#(#8H (#:#( $& 9&; %')$(G<$&() =(# (='\#/* ='/ '&$ $& $9# =<=/#@%< ]G=8%:%<=$%&') (#]G%(#/ $&

=$$=%' .#(@='#'<H, 3$ @G)$ A# '&$#/ $9=$ $9# )#<$%&' %' $9# 442 X=<G8$H Z='G=8 &' $9# (='\%'? &:

%')$(G<$&() <&+#( $9&)# ;9& =(# )$%88 &' .(&A=$%&'=(H #@.8&H@#'$ ='/ $9&)# ;9& 9=+# =8(#=/H =$$=%'#/

.#(@='#'<H, 3$ ;&G8/ $9#(#:&(# A# #((&'#&G) $& )%@.8H (#=/ $9# )#<$%&' &' $9# (='\%'? &: %')$(G<$&() f

;%$9&G$ $=\%'? %'$& <&')%/#(=$%&' $9# .(#+%&G)8H ]G&$#/ )#<$%&' &' .#(@='#'<H f %' &(/#( $& /#$#(@%'#

$9# =<=/#@%< ]G=8%:%<=$%&') :&( $9# .&)%$%&' &:  %&'()*&*+  9677:)&4( 95;67)< 4(4=(, #&)% )%( ,5+>

*9 ,*-+'./+0' , Q9G)* $& .(&.#(8H =((%+# =$ $9# <(%$#(%=* $9# )#<$%&') &' A&$9 $9# .#(@='#'<H ='/ $9# (='\%'?

&: =' %')$(G<$&(* =) .(&+%/#/ %' $9# 442 Z='G=8* @G)$ A# (#=/ %' <&'`G'<$%&' ;%$9 #=<9 ='&$9#(,

J$ $9%) `G'<$G(#* ;# (#%$#(=$# $9# (G8# $9=$ @#(# <&@.8#$%&' &: $9# $9(##fH#=( .(&A=$%&'* #+#' ;%$9 ='

=A&+#f=+#(=?# .#(:&(@='<#* /&#) '&$ ?G=(='$## $9=$ $9# #@.8&H## ;%88 =G$&@=$%<=88H =<]G%(# =

.#(@='#'$ #@.8&H@#'$ )$=$G),>E

 3$ %) )#$$8#/ `G(%).(G/#'<#>P

 $9=$ $9# .(&A=$%&'#( <=' &'8H ]G=8%:H G.&'

:G8:%88@#'$ &: $9# (#=)&'=A8# )$='/=(/) )#$ :&( .#(@='#'$ #@.8&H@#'$ =) = @#@A#( &: $9# $#=<9%'?

.#()&''#8, 3' 8%'# ;%$9 =<=/#@%< :(##/&@ ='/ <&')$%$G$%&'=8 =G$&'&@H* =' %')$%$G$%&' &: 9%?9#( 8#=('%'?

9=) $9# /%)<(#$%&' ='/ .(#(&?=$%+# $& %@.&)# )$='/=(/) &' %$) $#=<9#() ='/ /#$#(@%'# ;9#$9#( $9#)# 9=+#

A##' @#$, Y.&' <&'<8G)%&' &: $9# .(&A=$%&' .#(%&/* $9# <&88#?# &( G'%+#()%$H* A#%'? $9# #@.8&H#(* 9=) $9#

)&8# .(#(&?=$%+# $& @=\# = /#<%)%&' &' ;9#$9#( &( '&$ $& (#f9%(# $9# .(&A=$%&'#(, Q9# .(&A=$%&'#( <=''&$

=G$&@=$%<=88H =))#($ $9# =<]G%)%$%&' &: )#<G(%$H &: $#'G(# ='/ :&(<# $9# #@.8&H#( $& (#'#; $9#

#@.8&H@#'$ <&'$(=<$, 3' $9# <=)# =$ A=(* Z='=&%) :=%8#/ $& <&@.8H ;%$9 $9# )$=$#/ =<=/#@%< ]G=8%:%<=$%&')(#]G%(#/ :&( $9# .&)%$%&' &: = .#(@='#'$ :G88f$%@# :=<G8$H @#@A#(,

6&$;%$9)$='/%'? $9# #_%)$#'<# &: $9# 442 X=<G8$H Z='G=8* Z='=&%) )$%88 <=''&$ 8#?=88H =<]G%(# = .#(@='#'$

)$=$G) &: #@.8&H@#'$, "(%+=$# #/G<=$%&'=8 %')$%$G$%&') @G)$ )$%88 )G..8#@#'$=(%8H (#:#(>C

 $& $9# .(#+=%8%'?

Page 30: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 30/108

)$='/=(/)* ]G=8%:%<=$%&')* ='/ <&'/%$%&') )#$ AH $9# =..(&.(%=$# ?&+#('@#'$ =?#'<%#) K.(#)#'$8H $9#

0#.=($@#'$ &: 1/G<=$%&'* $9# 2&@@%))%&' &' d%?9#( 1/G<=$%&'* ='/ $9# Q#<9'%<=8 1/G<=$%&' ='/ 4\%88)

0#+#8&.@#'$ JG$9&(%$HL, Q9%) 8%@%$=$%&' &' $9# (%?9$ &: .(%+=$# )<9&&8)* <&88#?#)* ='/ G'%+#()%$%#) $& )#8#<$

='/ /#$#(@%'# $9# #@.8&H@#'$ )$=$G) &: $9#%( =<=/#@%< .#()&''#8 9=) A##' %@.&)#/ AH $9# )$=$# %' +%#;

&: $9# .GA8%< %'$#(#)$ '=$G(# &: #/G<=$%&'=8 %')$%$G$%&')* )& =) $& #')G(# $9# ]G=8%$H ='/ <&@.#$#'<H &: &G(

)<9&&8) ='/ #/G<=$&(),

Q9# =..8%<=A8# ?G%/#A&&\BD

 =$ $9# $%@# .#$%$%&'#( ;=) #'?=?#/ =) = .(&A=$%&'=(H :G88f$%@# %')$(G<$&( :&($9# )<9&&8 H#=( BDDD $& BDDI %) $9# >CCB Z='G=8 &: -#?G8=$%&') :&( "(%+=$# 4<9&&8) K>CCB Z='G=8L,

B> 3$

.(&+%/#) $9# :&88&;%'? <&'/%$%&') &: = .(&A=$%&'=(H #@.8&H@#'$a<9='-&A8#)+%($G=8U=;8%A(=(H

4#<$%&' PC, 2&'/%$%&') &: [email protected]&H@#'$, 1+#(H .(%+=$# )<9&&8 )9=88 .(&@&$# $9# %@.(&+#@#'$ &: $9#

#<&'&@%<* )&<%=8 ='/ .(&:#))%&'=8 )$=$G) &: =88 %$) .#()&''#8,

#3 ICDHM3JEJH3 HU EBCJI FSCDJ2L CRSLHQRC3E FE2EKF 234 EBCJI FSCDJ2L IHLC J3 EBC 24T23DCRC3E HU

X3HVLC4MC5 EBC CRSLHQRC3E HU EC2DBJ3M 234 3H3?EC2DBJ3M 2D24CRJD SCIFH33CL FB2LL GC MHTCI3C4 GQ

FKDB IKLCF 2F R2Q UIHR EJRC EH EJRC GC SIHRKLM2EC45 J3 DHHI4J32EJH3 VJEB H3C 23HEBCI5 GQ EBC

7CS2IERC3E HU %4KD2EJH35 /KLEKIC 234 'SHIEF 234 EBC 7CS2IERC3E HU )2GHI 234 %RSLHQRC3E< 

2&'/%$%&') &: #@.8&H@#'$ &: '&'f=<=/#@%< '&'f$#=<9%'? )<9&&8 .#()&''#8* %'<8G/%'? <&@.#')=$%&'*

9&G() &: ;&(\* )#<G(%$H &: $#'G(# ='/ 8=A&( (#8=$%&')* )9=88 A# ?&+#('#/ AH $9# =..(&.(%=$# 8=A&( 8=;) ='/

(#?G8=$%&'),

4#<$%&' CB, "(&A=$%&'=(H "#(%&/, 'KG]CDE J3 2LL J3FE23DCF EH DHRSLJ23DC VJEB 7CS2IERC3E 234 FDBHHL

ICWKJICRC3EF* $9# .(&A=$%&'=(H .#(%&/ :&( =<=/#@%< .#()&''#8 )9=88 '&$ A# @&(# $9=' $9(## KIL

<&')#<G$%+# H#=() &: F2EJFU2DEHIQ FCITJDC :&( $9&)# %' $9# #8#@#'$=(H ='/ )#<&'/=(H 8#+#8)* FJ^ _`a

DH3FCDKEJTC ICMKL2I FCRCFECIF HU F2EJFU2DEHIQ FCITJDC UHI EBHFC J3 EBC ECIEJ2IQ LCTCL* ='/ '%'# KCL

<&')#<G$%+# $(%@#)$#() &: )=$%):=<$&(H )#(+%<# :&( $9&)# %' $9# $#($%=(H 8#+#8 ;9#(# <&88#?%=$# <&G()#) =(#

&::#(#/ &' $9# $(%@#)$#( A=)%),

4#<$%&' CI, -#?G8=( &( "#(@='#'$ 4$=$G), 1BHFC VBH B2TC FCITC4 EBC SIHG2EJH32IQ SCIJH4 FB2LL GC R24C

ICMKL2I HI SCIR23C3E< 6KLL?EJRC EC2DBCIF VBH B2TC F2EJFU2DEHIJLQ DHRSLCEC4 EBCJI SIHG2EJH32IQ SCIJH4

FB2LL GC DH3FJ4CIC4 ICMKL2I HI SCIR23C3E< K34$%50(0 06$$7&(1 L<9='(&A8#)+%($G=8=;8%A(=(H

2&')%/#(%'? $9=$ .#$%$%&'#( G8$%@=$#8H )&G?9$ :&( $9# .&)%$%&' &: = .#(@='#'$ :G88f$%@# %')$(G<$&(* ;# @G)$

:G($9#( 8&&\ %'$& $9# :&88&;%'? .(&+%)%&') G'/#( $9# >CCB Z='G=8* ;9%<9 )#$ &G$ $9# @%'%@G@

(#]G%(#@#'$) :&( )G<9 )$=$G)a<9='-&A8#)+%($G=8U=;8%A(=(H

4#<$%&' SS, Z%'%@G@ X=<G8$H pG=8%:%<=$%&'), Q9# @%'%@G@ ]G=8%:%<=$%&') :&( :=<G8$H :&( $9# /%::#(#'$ ?(=/#)

='/ 8#+#8) &: %')$(G<$%&' 4KLQ FKSSHIEC4 GQ 2SSIHSIJ2EC DIC4C3EJ2LF H3 UJLC %' $9# )<9&&8 )9=88 A# =) :&88&;)a

_ _ _

<, Q#($%=(H

K>L X&( G'/#(?(=/G=$# <&G()#)* &$9#( $9=' +&<=$%&'=8a

K=L 9HL4CI HU 2 R2FECI@F 4CMICC5 EH EC2DB L2IMCLQ J3 BJF R2]HI UJCL4[ &(* :&( .(&:#))%&'=8 <&G()#)* 9&8/#( &:

$9# =..(&.(%=$# .(&:#))%&'=8 8%<#')# (#]G%(#/ :&( =$ 8#=)$ = A=<9#8&(W) /#?(##, J'H /#+%=$%&' :(&@ $9%)

(#]G%(#@#'$ ;%88 A# )GA`#<$ $& (#?G8=$%&' AH $9# 0#.=($@#'$,

4#<$%&' SR, XG88f$%@# ='/ "=($f$%@# X=<G8$H, J) = ?#'#(=8 (G8#* =88 .(%+=$# )<9&&8)FB2LL CRSLHQ UKLL?EJRC

2D24CRJD SCIFH33CL DH3FJFEC3E VJEB EBC LCTCLF HU J3FEIKDEJH3,

6KLL?EJRC 2D24CRJD SCIFH33CL 2IC EBHFC RCCEJ3M 2LL EBC UHLLHVJ3M ICWKJICRC3EFA 

=, =BH SHFFCFF 2E LC2FE EBC RJ3JRKR 2D24CRJD WK2LJUJD2EJH3F.(#)<(%A#/ AH $9# 0#.=($@#'$ K34CI EBJF

.23K2L UHI 2LL 2D24CRJD SCIFH33CL[

Page 31: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 31/108

 

A, 79& =(# .=%/ @&'$98H &( 9&G(8H* A=)#/ &' $9# (#?G8=( $#=<9%'? 8&=/) =) .(&+%/#/ :&( %' $9# .&8%<%#)*

(G8#) ='/ )$='/=(/) &: $9# 0#.=($@#'$ ='/ $9# )<9&&8[

<, 79&)# $&$=8 ;&(\%'? /=H &: '&$ @&(# $9=' #%?9$ 9&G() = /=H %) /#+&$#/ $& $9# )<9&&8[

/, 79& 9=+# '& &$9#( (#@G'#(=$%+# &<<G.=$%&' #8)#;9#(# (#]G%(%'? (#?G8=( 9&G() &: ;&(\ $9=$ ;%88 <&':8%<$

;%$9 $9# ;&(\%'? 9&G() %' $9# )<9&&8[ ='/

#, 79& =(# '&$ $#=<9%'? :G88f$%@# %' ='H &$9#( #/G<=$%&'=8 %')$%$G$%&',

(LL EC2DBJ3M SCIFH33CL VBH 4H 3HE RCCE EBC UHICMHJ3M WK2LJUJD2EJH3F 2IC DH3FJ4CIC4 S2IE?EJRC<

_ _ _

4#<$%&' SE, X=<G8$H 28=))%:%<=$%&' ='/ -='\%'?, J$ $9# $#($%=(H 8#+#8* $9# 2D24CRJD EC2DBJ3M SHFJEJH3F FB2LL

GC DL2FFJUJC4 J3 2DDHI423DC VJEB 2D24CRJD WK2LJUJD2EJH3F* $(=%'%'? ='/ )<9&8=()9%. .(#:#(=A8H %'$&

=<=/#@%< (='\) &: "(&:#))&(* J))&<%=$# "(&:#))&(* J))%)$='$ "(&:#))&(* ='/ 3')$(G<$&(* ;%$9&G$ .(#`G/%<# $&

= @&(# )%@.8%:%#/ &( #_.='/#/ )H)$#@ &: :=<G8$H (='\%'?* =$ $9# &.$%&' &: $9# )<9&&8,

J'H =<=/#@%< $#=<9%'? .#()&''#8 ;9& /&#) '&$ :=88 G'/#( ='H &: $9# <8=))#) &( (='\) %'/%<=$#/ %' $9#

.(#<#/%'? .=(=?(=.9 )9=88 A# <8=))%:%#/ .(#:#(=A8H =) .(&:#))&(%=8 8#<$G(#(* ?G#)$ 8#<$G(#(* &( ='H &$9#(

)%@%8=( =<=/#@%< /#)%?'=$%&' &' $9# A=)%) &: 9%) ]G=8%:%<=$%&'), K34$%50(0

06$$7&(1 L<9='(&A8#)+%($G=8=;8%A(=(H

Q9G)* .G()G='$ $& $9# >CCB Z='G=8* .(%+=$# #/G<=$%&'=8 %')$%$G$%&') %' $9# $#($%=(H 8#+#8 @=H #_$#'/ t:G88f

$%@# :=<G8$Hu )$=$G) &'8H $& $9&)# ;9& .&))#))* &+)(, 57&5* = @=)$#(W) /#?(## %' $9# :%#8/ &: )$G/H $9=$ ;%88 A#

$=G?9$, Q9%) @%'%@G@ (#]G%(#@#'$ %) '#%$9#( )GA`#<$ $& $9# .(#(&?=$%+# &: $9# )<9&&8 '&( $& $9# =?(##@#'$

A#$;##' $9# .=($%#), X&( =88 %'$#'$) ='/ .G(.&)#)* $9%) ]G=8%:%<=$%&' @G)$ A# /##@#/ %@.8%#/8H ;(%$$#' %'

$9# #@.8&H@#'$ <&'$(=<$) A#$;##' .(%+=$# #/G<=$%&'=8 %')$%$G$%&') ='/ .(&).#<$%+# :=<G8$H @#@A#(), Q9#%))G# &: ;9#$9#( .(&A=$%&'#() ;#(# %':&(@#/ &: $9%) =<=/#@%< (#]G%(#@#'$ A#:&(# $9#H ;#(# #'?=?#/ =)

.(&A=$%&'=(H #@.8&H##) %) $9G) '& 8&'?#( @=$#(%=8* =) $9&)# ;9& =(# )##\%'? $& A# #/G<=$&() =(#

.(#)G@#/ $& \'&; $9#)# @='/=$#/ ]G=8%:%<=$%&'), Q9G)* =88 $9&)# ;9& :=%8 $& @##$ $9# <(%$#(%= G'/#( $9#

>CCB Z='G=8 <=''&$ 8#?=88H =$$=%' $9# )$=$G) &: .#(@='#'$ :G88f$%@# :=<G8$H @#@A#()* #+#' %: $9#H 9=+#

<&@.8#$#/ $9(## H#=() &: )=$%):=<$&(H )#(+%<#,

3' $9# 8%?9$ &: $9# :=%8G(# &: Z='=&%) $& )=$%):H $9# =<=/#@%< (#]G%(#@#'$) :&( $9# .&)%$%&'* )9# @=H &'8H A#

<&')%/#(#/ =) = .=($f$%@# %')$(G<$&( .G()G='$ $& 4#<$%&' SR &: $9# >CCB Z='G=8, 3' $G('* =) ;# 9=+#

#'G'<%=$#/ %' = 8%'# &: <=)#)*BB = .=($f$%@# @#@A#( &: $9# =<=/#@%< .#()&''#8 <=''&$ =<]G%(#

.#(@='#'<# &: #@.8&H@#'$ ='/ )#<G(%$H &: $#'G(# G'/#( $9# Z='G=8 &: -#?G8=$%&') %' (#8=$%&' $& $9#

U=A&( 2&/#, 7# $9G) ]G&$# $9# (G8%'? &: $9%) 2&G($ %' ?5;6(0)5@ -&8aBI 

4#<$%&' CI &: $9# >CCB Z='G=8 &: -#?G8=$%&') :&( "(%+=$# 4<9&&8) .(&+%/#) $9=$ :G88f$%@# $#=<9#() ;9&

9=+# )=$%):=<$&(%8H <&@.8#$#/ $9#%( .(&A=$%&'=(H .#(%&/ )9=88 A# <&')%/#(#/ (#?G8=( &( .#(@='#'$,

Z&(#&+#(* :&( $9&)# $#=<9%'? %' $9# $#($%=(H 8#+#8* $9# .(&A=$%&'=(H .#(%&/ )9=88 '&$ A# @&(# $9=' )%_

<&')#<G$%+# (#?G8=( )#@#)$#() &: )=$%):=<$&(H )#(+%<#, 1BC ICWKJFJECF EH 2DWKJIC SCIR23C3E CRSLHQRC3E5

HI FCDKIJEQ HU EC3KIC5 2IC _Pa EBC EC2DBCI JF 2 UKLL?EJRC EC2DBCIb _Na EBC EC2DBCI RKFE B2TC IC34CIC4 EBICC

DH3FCDKEJTC QC2IF HU FCITJDCb 234 _ca FKDB FCITJDC RKFE B2TC GCC3 F2EJFU2DEHIQ< 

J) .(#+%&G)8H 9#8/* = .=($f$%@# $#=<9#( <=''&$ =<]G%(# .#(@='#'$ )$=$G), +3LQ VBC3 H3C B2F FCITC4 2F 2

UKLL?EJRC EC2DBCI D23 BC 2DWKJIC SCIR23C3E HI ICMKL2I FE2EKF< Q9# .#$%$%&'#( ;=) = .=($f$%@# 8#<$G(#(

A#:&(# )9# ;=) =..&%'$#/ =) = :G88f$%@# %')$(G<$&( &' .(&A=$%&', (F 2 S2IE?EJRC LCDEKICI5 BCI CRSLHQRC3E

2F FKDB B24 C34C4 VBC3 BCI DH3EI2DE C^SJIC4< Q9G)* EBC EBICC FCRCFECIF FBC FCITC4 2F S2IE?EJRC

LCDEKICI DHKL4 3HE GC DIC4JEC4 EH BCI %' <&@.G$%'? $9# 'G@A#( &: H#=() )9# 9=) )#(+#/ $& ]G=8%:H 9#( :&(

.#(@='#'$ )$=$G),

Page 32: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 32/108

 

"#$%$%&'#( .&)%$) $9=$ =:$#( <&@.8#$%'? $9# $9(##fH#=( h:G88f$%@# %')$(G<$&( &'i .(&A=$%&' ;%$9 =' =A&+#f

=+#(=?# .#(:&(@='<#* )9# =8(#=/H =<]G%(#/ .#(@='#'$ )$=$G), 5' $9%) .&%'$* ;# =(# G'=A8# $& =?(## ;%$9

.#$%$%&'#(,

/HRSLCEJ3M EBC SIHG2EJH3 SCIJH4 4HCF 3HE 2KEHR2EJD2LLQ WK2LJUQ BCI EH GCDHRC 2 SCIR23C3E CRSLHQCC

HU EBC K3JTCIFJEQ< 0CEJEJH3CI DHKL4 H3LQ WK2LJUQ EH GCDHRC 2 SCIR23C3E CRSLHQCC KSH3 UKLUJLLJ3M EBC

IC2FH32GLC FE2342I4F UHI SCIR23C3E CRSLHQRC3E 2F U2DKLEQ RCRGCI< 2&')%)$#'$ ;%$9 =<=/#@%< :(##/&@='/ <&')$%$G$%&'=8 =G$&'&@H* =' %')$%$G$%&' &: 9%?9#( 8#=('%'? 9=) $9# .(#(&?=$%+# $& .(&+%/# )$='/=(/) :&(

%$) $#=<9#() ='/ /#$#(@%'# ;9#$9#( $9#)# )$='/=(/) 9=+# A##' @#$, (E EBC C34 HU EBC SIHG2EJH3 SCIJH45

EBC 4CDJFJH3 EH IC?BJIC 23 CRSLHQCC H3 SIHG2EJH35 GCLH3MF EH EBC K3JTCIFJEQ 2F EBC CRSLHQCI

2LH3C< K34$%50(0 06$$7&(1 L<9='(&A8#)+%($G=8=;8%A(=(H

X&( $9# :&(#?&%'? (#=)&')* ;# (G8# $9=$ $9#(# %) '& 8#?=8 &A8%?=$%&' &' $9# .=($ &: 442 $& (#=..&%'$ Z='=&%)

=:$#( $9# 8=.)# &: 9#( $#@.&(=(H =..&%'$@#'$, 7# $9G) =::%(@ &+ )*)* $9# :%'/%'?) &: :=<$ &: $9# 2J ='/ (G8#

$9=$ 442 %) '&$ ?G%8$H &: %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8,

=9%&%6+&%* $9# .#$%$%&' %) 7%"#%7 :&( 8=<\ &: @#(%$, J<<&(/%'?8H* $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) 0#<%)%&' /=$#/ BE

X#A(G=(H BDDC ='/ $9# -#)&8G$%&' /=$#/ BB FG8H BDDC %' 2JfN,-, 4", 6&, >D>IPB =(#9#(#AH (66#&.%7,<9='(&A8#)+%($G=8=;8%A(=(H

'+ +&7%&%7< 

Page 33: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 33/108

 

;+'% :< '+"8(5 %&+,+,0*&' 5 1-< (,'d/," ,&+(7/('1#"- /+&0+&(1#+"5 '&-%0*2&*+ <

7 % / # ' # + "

/(&0#+5 ! <A

1BC /2FC

O#:&(# $9%) 2&G($ %) = .#$%$%&' :&( (#+%#; &' ;(,)&*,5,& h>i

 =))=%8%'? $9# BT Z=(<9 >CCC 0#<%)%&'hBi

 &: $9#

2&G($ &: J..#=8) %' 2JMN,-, 4" 6&, SC>CD /%)@%))%'? $9# .#$%$%&' :%8#/ AH F&)# k, 4&'^= K456jJL, Q9# 2&G($

&: J..#=8) =::%(@#/ $9# :%'/%'?) &: $9# 6=$%&'=8 U=A&( -#8=$%&') 2&@@%))%&' K6U-2L* ;9%<9 =::%(@#/ $9#

U=A&( J(A%$#() /%)@%))=8 &: $9# <=)# :&( 8=<\ &: `G(%)/%<$%&',

1BC 62DEF

3' Z=H >CCS* (#).&'/#'$ JO4M2O6 O(&=/<=)$%'? 2&(.&(=$%&' KJO4M2O6L )%?'#/ =' J?(##@#'$

KJ?(##@#'$L ;%$9 $9# Z#8 ='/ F=H Z='=?#@#'$ ='/ 0#+#8&.@#'$ 2&(.&(=$%&' KZFZ02L, JO4M2O6 ;=)

(#.(#)#'$#/ AH %$) <&(.&(=$# &::%<#() ;9%8# ZFZ02 ;=) (#.(#)#'$#/ AH 456jJ* =) "(#)%/#'$ ='/ N#'#(=8

Z='=?#(* ='/ 2=(@#8= Q%='?<& KQ3J6N25L* =) 1V" ='/ Q(#=)G(#(, -#:#((#/ $& %' $9# J?(##@#'$ =) JN16Q*

ZFZ02 =?(##/ $& .(&+%/# 456jJ) )#(+%<#) #_<8G)%+#8H $& JO4M2O6 =) $=8#'$ :&( (=/%& ='/ $#8#+%)%&', Q9#

J?(##@#'$ 8%)$#/ $9# )#(+%<#) 456jJ ;&G8/ (#'/#( $& JO4M2O6* =) :&88&;)a

=, 2&M9&)$ :&( Z#8 n F=H (=/%& .(&?(=@* PaDD $& >DaDD =,@,* Z&'/=H) $& X(%/=H)[

A, 2&M9&)$ :&( Z#8 n F=H $#8#+%)%&' .(&?(=@* RaID $& EaDD .,@,* 4G'/=H),hIi 

JO4M2O6 =?(##/ $& .=H :&( 456jJ) )#(+%<#) = @&'$98H $=8#'$ :## &: "I>D*DDD :&( $9# :%()$ H#=(

='/"I>E*DDD :&( $9# )#<&'/ ='/ $9%(/ H#=( &: $9# J?(##@#'$, JO4M2O6 ;&G8/ .=H $9# $=8#'$ :##) &' $9#

>D$9

 ='/ BR$9

 /=H) &: $9# @&'$9,

5' > J.(%8 >CCT* 456jJ ;(&$# = 8#$$#( $& JO4M2O6) "(#)%/#'$* 1G?#'%& U&.#^ 333* ;9%<9 (#=/)a

0#=( Z(, U&.#^*

7# ;&G8/ 8%\# $& <=88 H&G( =$$#'$%&' $& $9# J?(##@#'$ /=$#/ Z=H >CCS #'$#(#/ %'$& AH H&G( ?&&/)#8: &'

A#9=8: &: JO4M2O6 ;%$9 &G( <&@.='H (#8=$%+# $& &G( $=8#'$ F541 k, 456jJ,

J) H&G =(# ;#88 =;=(#* Z(, 4&'^= %((#+&<=A8H (#)%?'#/ %' +%#; &: (#<#'$ #+#'$) <&'<#('%'? 9%) .(&?(=@)

='/ <=(##(, 7# <&')%/#( $9#)# =<$) &: $9# )$=$%&' +%&8=$%+# &: $9# J?(##@#'$ ='/ $9# )$=$%&' =) %' A(#=<9

$9#(#&:, 3' $9%) <&''#<$%&'* ;# 9#(#AH )#(+# '&$%<# &: (#)<%))%&' &: )=%/ J?(##@#'$ =$ &G( %')$='<#

#::#<$%+# =) &: /=$#,

Z(, 4&'^= %':&(@#/ G) $9=$ 9# %) ;=%+%'? ='/ (#'&G'<%'? (#<&+#(H &: $9# (#@=%'%'? =@&G'$ )$%.G8=$#/ %'

.=(=?(=.9 E &: $9# J?(##@#'$ AG$ (#)#(+#) $9# (%?9$ $& )##\ (#<&+#(H &: $9# &$9#( A#'#:%$) G'/#( )=%/

J?(##@#'$,

Q9='\ H&G :&( H&G( =$$#'$%&',

V#(H $(G8H H&G()*

Page 34: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 34/108

K4?/,L

F541 k, 456jJ

"(#)%/#'$ ='/ N#', Z='=?#(hSi

 

5' ID J.(%8 >CCT* 456jJ :%8#/ = <&@.8=%'$ =?=%')$ JO4M2O6 A#:&(# $9# 0#.=($@#'$ &: U=A&( ='/

[email protected]&H@#'$* 6=$%&'=8 2=.%$=8 -#?%&' %' pG#^&' 2%$H, 456jJ <&@.8=%'#/ $9=$ JO4M2O6 /%/ '&$ .=H 9%)

)=8=(%#)* )#.=(=$%&' .=H* )#(+%<# %'<#'$%+# 8#=+# .=H* >I$9

 @&'$9 .=H* )%?'%'? A&'G)* $(=+#8 =88&;='<# ='/

=@&G'$) /G# G'/#( $9# [email protected]&H##) 4$&<\ 5.$%&' "8=' K145"L,

5' >D FG8H >CCT* JO4M2O6 :%8#/ = Z&$%&' $& 0%)@%)) &' $9# ?(&G'/ $9=$ '& #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H##

(#8=$%&')9%. #_%)$#/ A#$;##' $9# .=($%#), 456jJ :%8#/ =' 5..&)%$%&' $& $9# @&$%&' &' >C FG8H >CCT,

Z#=';9%8#* JO4M2O6 <&'$%'G#/ $& (#@%$ 456jJ) @&'$98H $=8#'$ :##) $9(&G?9 9%) =<<&G'$ =$ "23O='\*

pG#^&' J+#'G# O(='<9* pG#^&' 2%$H, 3' FG8H >CCT* JO4M2O6 &.#'#/ = '#; =<<&G'$ ;%$9 $9# )=@# A='\

;9#(# JO4M2O6 /#.&)%$#/ 456jJ) $=8#'$ :##) ='/ &$9#( .=H@#'$) /G# 9%@ G'/#( $9# J?(##@#'$,

3' 9%) 5(/#( /=$#/ B 0#<#@A#( >CCT* $9# U=A&( J(A%$#(hRi

 /#'%#/ $9# @&$%&' $& /%)@%)) ='/ /%(#<$#/

$9# .=($%#) $& :%8# $9#%( (#).#<$%+# .&)%$%&' .=.#(), Q9# U=A&( J(A%$#( (G8#/a

3' $9%) %')$='$ <=)#* <&@.8=%'='$ :&( 9=+%'? %'+&\#/ = <8=%@ $9=$ 9# ;=) =' #@.8&H## &: (#).&'/#'$<&@.='H G'$%8 J.(%8 >R* >CCT ='/ $9=$ 9# ;=) '&$ .=%/ <#($=%' <8=%@)* %$ %) )G::%<%#'$ #'&G?9 =) $& <&':#(

 `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( $9# %')$='$ <=)# %' $9%) 5::%<#, J'/ =) $& ;9#$9#( &( '&$ )G<9 <8=%@ ;&G8/ #'$%$8#

<&@.8=%'='$ $& (#<&+#( G.&' $9# <=G)#) &: =<$%&' =))#($#/ %) = @=$$#( $& A# (#)&8+#/ &'8H =:$#( ='/ =) =

(#)G8$ &: = 9#=(%'?, Q9G)* $9# (#).&'/#'$) .8#= &: 8=<\ &: #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. @=H A# .8#=/#/

&'8H =) = @=$$#( &: /#:#')#, 3$ A#9&&+#) G.&' %$ $9# /G$H $& .(&+# $9=$ $9#(# (#=88H %) '& #@.8&H#(M

#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. A#$;##' %$ ='/ $9# <&@.8=%'='$,

Q9# U=A&( J(A%$#( $9#' <&')%/#(#/ $9# <=)# )GA@%$$#/ :&( (#)&8G$%&', Q9# .=($%#) )GA@%$$#/ $9#%(

.&)%$%&' .=.#() &' BS X#A(G=(H >CCE,

5' >> Z=(<9 >CCE* 456jJ :%8#/ = -#.8H $& -#).&'/#'$) "&)%$%&' "=.#( ;%$9 Z&$%&' $& 1_.G'?#

-#).&'/#'$) J''#_ S ='/ J''#_ R :(&@ $9# -#<&(/), J''#_#) S ='/ R =(# =::%/=+%$) &: JO4M2O6) ;%$'#))#)

4&<<&(& V%/='#) ='/ -&8='/& V, 2(G^, Q9#)# ;%$'#))#) )$=$#/ %' $9#%( =::%/=+%$) $9=$ $9# .(#+=%8%'? .(=<$%<#

%' $9# $#8#+%)%&' ='/ A(&=/<=)$ %'/G)$(H %) $& $(#=$ $=8#'$) 8%\# 456jJ =) %'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&(),

Q9# U=A&( J(A%$#( (#'/#(#/ 9%) 0#<%)%&' /=$#/ P FG8H >CCE /%)@%))%'? $9# <&@.8=%'$ :&( 8=<\ &:

 `G(%)/%<$%&',hTi

Q9# .#($%'#'$ .=($) &: $9# /#<%)%&' (#=/ =) :&88&;)a

_ _ _

79%8# "9%8%..%'# `G(%).(G/#'<# 9=) '&$ H#$* ;%$9 <#($=%'$H* $&G<9#/ &' $9# $(G# '=$G(# &: $9# <&'$(=<$ &: =$=8#'$* %$ )$='/) $& (#=)&' $9=$ = $=8#'$ =) =A&+#M/#)<(%A#/ <=''&$ A# <&')%/#(#/ =) =' #@.8&H## AH (#=)&'

&: $9# .#<G8%=( <%(<G@)$='<#) )G((&G'/%'? $9# #'?=?#@#'$ &: 9%) )#(+%<#),

3$ @G)$ A# '&$#/ $9=$ DHRSL2J323E V2F C3M2MC4 GQ ICFSH34C3E GQ IC2FH3 HU BJF SCDKLJ2I FXJLLF 234 E2LC3E

2F 2 1$ BHFE 234 2 I24JH GIH24D2FECI< !3LJXC 23 HI4J32IQ CRSLHQCC5 BC V2F UICC EH SCIUHIR EBC FCITJDCF

BC K34CIEHHX EH IC34CI J3 2DDHI423DC VJEB BJF HV3 FEQLC< Q9# A#'#:%$) <&':#((#/ $& <&@.8=%'='$ G'/#(

$9# Z=H >CCS J?(##@#'$ =(# <#($=%'8H +#(H @G<9 9%?9#( $9=' $9&)# ?#'#(=88H ?%+#' $& #@.8&H##), X&( &'#*

<&@.8=%'='$ 4&'^=) @&'$98H $=8#'$ :##) =@&G'$ $& = )$=??#(%'? "I>E*DDD, Z&(#&+#(* 9%) #'?=?#@#'$ =) =

$=8#'$ ;=) <&+#(#/ AH = ).#<%:%< <&'$(=<$, U%\#;%)#* 9# ;=) '&$ A&G'/ $& (#'/#( #%?9$ KPL 9&G() &: ;&(\ .#(

/=H =) 9# ;&(\#/ &'8H :&( )G<9 'G@A#( &: 9&G() =) @=H A# '#<#))=(H,

Q9# :=<$ $9=$ .#( $9# Z=H >CCS J?(##@#'$ <&@.8=%'='$ ;=) =<<&(/#/ )&@# A#'#:%$) '&(@=88H ?%+#' $& ='

#@.8&H## %) %'<&')#]G#'$%=8, =B2ECTCI GC3CUJEF DHRSL2J323E C3]HQC4 2IHFC UIHR FSCDJUJD 2MICCRC3E GQ

EBC S2IEJCF 234 3HE GQ IC2FH3 HU CRSLHQCIdCRSLHQCC ICL2EJH3FBJS< J) <&((#<$8H .G$ AH $9# (#).&'/#'$* J88

Page 35: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 35/108

$9#)# A#'#:%$) =(# @#(#8H $=8#'$ :##) ='/ &$9#( <&'$(=<$G=8 A#'#:%$) ='/ )9&G8/ '&$ A# /##@#/ =) )=8=(%#)*

;=?#) ='/e&( &$9#( (#@G'#(=$%&' =<<&(/#/ $& =' #@.8&H##* '&$;%$9)$='/%'? $9# '&@#'<8=$G(# =..#'/#/

$& $9#)# A#'#:%$), J.(&.&) $& $9%) %) $9# (G8# $9=$ $9# $#(@ &( '&@#'<8=$G(# ?%+#' $& = )$%.G8=$#/ A#'#:%$ %)

'&$ <&'$(&88%'?* AG$ $9# %'$#'$ &: $9# .=($%#) $& $9# J?(##@#'$ <&':#((%'? )G<9 A#'#:%$,

1BC U2DE EB2E DHRSL2J323E V2F R24C FKG]CDE EH ICFSH34C3EF &KLCF 234 &CMKL2EJH3F5 LJXCVJFC5 4HCF 3HE

4CEI2DE UIHR EBC 2GFC3DC HU CRSLHQCIdCRSLHQCC ICL2EJH3FBJS, J) 9#8/ AH $9# 4G.(#@# 2&G($* Q9# 8%'#

)9&G8/ A# /(=;' A#$;##' (G8#) $9=$ @#(#8H )#(+# =) ?G%/#8%'#) $&;=(/) $9# =<9%#+#@#'$ &: $9# @G$G=88H/#)%(#/ (#)G8$ ;%$9&G$ /%<$=$%'? $9# @#=') &( @#$9&/) $& A# #@.8&H#/ %' =$$=%'%'? %$* ='/ $9&)# $9=$

<&'$(&8 &( :%_ $9# @#$9&/&8&?H ='/ A%'/ &( (#)$(%<$ $9# .=($H 9%(#/ $& $9# G)# &: )G<9 @#='), Q9# :%()$*

;9%<9 =%@ &'8H $& .(&@&$# $9# (#)G8$* <(#=$# '& #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. G'8%\# $9# )#<&'/* ;9%<9

=//(#)) A&$9 $9# (#)G8$ ='/ $9# @#=') $& =<9%#+# %$, K3')G8=( U%:# J))G(='<# 2&,* U$/, +), 6U-2* #$ =8,* N,-,

6&, PSSPS* 6&+#@A#( >R* >CPCL,

_ _ _ [email protected]=)%) )G..8%#/LhEi 

456jJ =..#=8#/ $& $9# 6U-2, 5' BS X#A(G=(H >CCP* $9# 6U-2 (#'/#(#/ = 0#<%)%&' =::%(@%'? $9# U=A&(

J(A%$#() /#<%)%&', 456jJ :%8#/ = @&$%&' :&( (#<&')%/#(=$%&'* ;9%<9 $9# 6U-2 /#'%#/ %' %$) -#)&8G$%&'/=$#/ I FG8H >CCP,

5' T 5<$&A#( >CCP* 456jJ :%8#/ = ).#<%=8 <%+%8 =<$%&' :&( <#($%&(=(% A#:&(# $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8)

=))=%8%'? $9# /#<%)%&' ='/ (#)&8G$%&' &: $9# 6U-2, 5' BT Z=(<9 >CCC* $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) (#'/#(#/ =

0#<%)%&' /%)@%))%'? $9# <=)#,hPi

 

d#'<#* $9%) .#$%$%&',

1BC &KLJ3MF HU EBC ")&/ 234 /HKIE HU (SSC2LF

Q9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) =::%(@#/ $9# 6U-2) :%'/%'? $9=$ '& #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. #_%)$#/

A#$;##' 456jJ ='/ JO4M2O6, J/&.$%'? $9# 6U-2) /#<%)%&'* $9# =..#88=$# <&G($ ]G&$#/ $9# :&88&;%'?

:%'/%'?) &: $9# 6U-2a

_ _ _ $9# Z=H >CCS J?(##@#'$ ;%88 (#=/%8H (#+#=8 $9=$ ZFZ02 #'$#(#/ %'$& $9# <&'$(=<$ @#(#8H =) =' =?#'$

&: <&@.8=%'='$ 4&'^=* $9# .(%'<%.=8, OH =88 %'/%<=$%&' ='/ =) $9# 8=; .G$) %$* $9# =<$ &: $9# =?#'$ %) $9# =<$ &:

$9# .(%'<%.=8 %$)#8:, Q9%) :=<$ %) @=/# .=($%<G8=(8H $(G# %' $9%) <=)#* =) =/@%$$#/8H ZFZ02 %) = @='=?#@#'$

<&@.='H /#+&$#/ #_<8G)%+#8H $& @='=?%'? $9# <=(##() &: Z(, 4&'^= ='/ 9%) A(&=/<=)$ .=($'#(* Z(),

2=(@#8= 2, Q%='?<&, K5..&)%$%&' $& Z&$%&' $& 0%)@%))L

28#=(8H* $9# (#8=$%&') &: .(%'<%.=8 ='/ =?#'$ &'8H =<<(G#) A#$;##' <&@.8=%'='$ 4&'^= ='/ ZFZ02* ='/ '&$

A#$;##' JO4M2O6 ='/ ZFZ02, Q9%) %) <8#=( :(&@ $9# .(&+%)%&') &: $9# Z=H >CCS J?(##@#'$ ;9%<9

).#<%:%<=88H (#:#((#/ $& ZFZ02 =) $9# JN16Q, J) = @=$$#( &: :=<$* ;9#' <&@.8=%'='$ 9#(#%' G'%8=$#(=88H

(#)<%'/#/ )=%/ Z=H >CCS J?(##@#'$* %$ ;=) ZFZ02 ;9%<9 %))G#/ $9# '&$%<# &: (#)<%))%&' %' A#9=8: &: Z(,

4&'^=* ;9& 9%@)#8: )%?'#/ $9# )=@# %' 9%) <=.=<%$H =) "(#)%/#'$,

Z&(#&+#(* .(#+%&G) <&'$(=<$) A#$;##' Z(, 4&'^= ='/ JO4M2O6 (#+#=8 $9# :=<$ $9=$ 9%)$&(%<=88H* $9# .=($%#)

$& $9# )=%/ =?(##@#'$) =(# JO4M2O6 ='/ Z(, 4&'^=, J'/ %$ %) &'8H %' $9# Z=H >CCS J?(##@#'$* ;9%<9 %) $9#

8=$#)$ J?(##@#'$ #_#<G$#/ A#$;##' JO4M2O6 ='/ Z(, 4&'^=* $9=$ ZFZ02 :%?G(#/ %' $9# )=%/ J?(##@#'$

=) $9# =?#'$ &: Z(, 4&'^=,

7# :%'/ %$ #((&'#&G) $& =))#($ $9=$ ZFZ02 %) = @#(# 8=A&(M&'8H <&'$(=<$&( &: JO4M2O6 )G<9 $9=$ $9#(#

#_%)$h)i #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. A#$;##' $9# 8=$$#( ='/ Z(, 4&'^=, 5' $9# <&'$(=(H* 7# :%'/ %$

Page 36: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 36/108

%'/GA%$=A8#* $9=$ ZFZ02 %) =' =?#'$* '&$ &: JO4M2O6* AG$ &: $9# $=8#'$e<&'$(=<$&( Z(, 4&'^=* =) #_.(#))8H

=/@%$$#/ AH $9# 8=$$#( ='/ ZFZ02 %' $9# Z=H >CCS J?(##@#'$,

3$ @=H '&$ A# =@%)) $& )$=$# $9=$ `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( $9# %')$='$ <&'$(&+#()H %'/##/ A#8&'?) $& $9# (#?G8=(

<&G($)* $9# )=@# A#%'? %' $9# '=$G(# &: =' =<$%&' :&( =88#?#/ A(#=<9 &: <&'$(=<$G=8 &A8%?=$%&' &' $9# .=($ &:

(#).&'/#'$M=..#88##, J) )]G=(#8H =..=(#'$ :(&@ <&@.8=%'='$M=..#88='$) "&)%$%&' "=.#(* 9%) <8=%@) :&(

<&@.#')=$%&' :&( )#(+%<#)* >I$9

 @&'$9 .=H* )%?'%'? A&'G) ='/ $(=+#8 =88&;='<# =?=%')$ (#).&'/#'$M

=..#88## =(# '&$ A=)#/ &' $9# U=A&( 2&/# AG$ (=$9#( &' $9# .(&+%)%&') &: $9# Z=H >CCS J?(##@#'$* ;9%8#9%) <8=%@) :&( .(&<##/) G'/#( 4$&<\ "G(<9=)# J?(##@#'$ =(# A=)#/ &' $9# 8=$$#(, J .&($%&' &: $9# "&)%$%&'

"=.#( &: <&@.8=%'='$M=..#88='$ A#=() .#(G)=8a

Y'/#( h$9# Z=H >CCS J?(##@#'$i ;%$9 (#).&'/#'$ JO4M2O6* $9# 8=$$#( <&'$(=<$G=88H A&G'/ %$)#8: $& .=H

<&@.8=%'='$ = )%?'%'? A&'G) <&')%)$%'? &: )9=(#) &: )$&<\);%$9 X3V1 dY60-10 Qd5Y4J60 "1454

K"RDD*DDD,DDL,

4%@%8=(8H* <&@.8=%'='$ %) =8)& #'$%$8#/ $& A# .=%/ >I$9

 @&'$9 .=H A=)#/ &' =' =@&G'$ '&$ 8&;#( $9=' $9#

=@&G'$ 9# ;=) (#<#%+%'? .(%&( $& #::#<$%+%$H &: K$9#L J?(##@#'$,

Y'/#( .=(=?(=.9 C &: K$9# Z=H >CCS J?(##@#'$L* <&@.8=%'='$ %) #'$%$8#/ $& = <&@@G$=A8# $(=+#8 A#'#:%$

=@&G'$%'? $& =$ 8#=)$ 5'# dG'/(#/ X%:$H Q9&G)='/ "#)&) K">RD*DDD,DDL .#( H#=(,

Q9G)* %$ %) .(#<%)#8H A#<=G)# &: <&@.8=%'='$M=..#88='$) &;' (#<&?'%$%&' &: $9# :=<$ $9=$ 9%) <&'$(=<$G=8

(#8=$%&') ;%$9 JO4M2O6 =(# :&G'/#/ &' $9# 6#; 2%+%8 2&/#* (=$9#( $9=' $9# U=A&( 2&/#* $9=$ %')$#=/ &:

@#(#8H (#)%?'%'? :(&@ JO4M2O6* <&@.8=%'='$M=..#88='$ )#(+#/ G.&' $9# 8=$$#( = '&$%<# &: (#)<%))%&' &:

J?(##@#'$ ;%$9 $9# )$=$%&'* .#( 9%) 8#$$#( /=$#/ J.(%8 >* >CCT* ;9%<9 =))#($#/ $9=$ %')$#=/ &: (#:#((%'? $&

G'.=%/ #@.8&H## A#'#:%$)* 9# %) ;=%+%'? ='/ (#'&G'<%'? (#<&+#(H &: $9# (#@=%'%'? =@&G'$ )$%.G8=$#/ %'

.=(=?(=.9 E &: $9# J?(##@#'$ AG$ (#)#(+#) $9# (%?9$ $& )G<9 (#<&+#(H &: $9# &$9#( A#'#:%$) G'/#( )=%/

J?(##@#'$, KJ''#_ I &: $9# (#).&'/#'$ JO4M2O6) Z&$%&' $& 0%)@%)) /=$#/ FG8H >D* >CCTL,

1+%/#'$8H* %$ %) .(#<%)#8H AH (#=)&' &: $9# =88#?#/ +%&8=$%&' &: $9# Z=H >CCS J?(##@#'$ ='/e&( $9# 4$&<\

"G(<9=)# J?(##@#'$ AH (#).&'/#'$M=..#88## $9=$ <&@.8=%'='$M=..#88='$ :%8#/ 9%) <&@.8=%'$, 2&@.8=%'='$M

=..#88='$) <8=%@) A#%'? ='<9&(#/ &' $9# =88#?#/ A(#=<9 &: <&'$(=<$ &' $9# .=($ &: (#).&'/#'$M=..#88##*

$9# )=@# <=' A# (#)&8+#/ AH (#:#(#'<# $& <%+%8 8=; ='/ '&$ $& 8=A&( 8=;, 2&')#]G#'$8H* $9#H =(# ;%$9%' $9#

(#=8@ &: <%+%8 8=; ='/* $9G)* 8%# ;%$9 $9# (#?G8=( <&G($), J) 9#8/ %' $9# <=)# &: 0=%M29% 18#<$(&'%<)

Z='G:=<$G(%'? +), V%88=(=@=* BIP 42-J BTE* B> 6&+#@A#( >CCS* 23 2DEJH3 UHI GIC2DB HU DH3EI2DEK2L

HGLJM2EJH3 JF J3EIJ3FJD2LLQ 2 DJTJL 4JFSKEC,hCi [email protected]=)%) )G..8%#/L

Q9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) (G8#/ $9=$ $9# #_%)$#'<# &: =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. A#$;##' 456jJ

='/ JO4M2O6 %) = :=<$G=8 ]G#)$%&' $9=$ %) ;%$9%' $9# `G(%)/%<$%&' &: $9# 6U-2 $& (#)&8+#,h>Di J ).#<%=8 <%+%8=<$%&' :&( <#($%&(=(% #_$#'/) &'8H $& %))G#) &: ;='$ &( #_<#)) &: `G(%)/%<$%&' &: $9# 6U-2,

h>>i 4G<9 =<$%&'

<=''&$ <&+#( =' %']G%(H %'$& $9# <&((#<$'#)) &: $9# #+=8G=$%&' &: $9# #+%/#'<# ;9%<9 )#(+#/ =) A=)%) &: $9#

6U-2) <&'<8G)%&',h>Bi

Q9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) =//#/ $9=$ %$ <&G8/ '&$ (#M#_=@%'# $9# .=($%#) #+%/#'<# ='/

)GA)$%$G$# $9# :=<$G=8 :%'/%'?) &: $9# 6U-2 ;%$9 %$) &;',h>Ii

 

1BC #FFKC

3' =))=%8%'? $9# /#<%)%&' &: $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8)* 456jJ <&'$#'/) $9=$a

Qd1 25Y-Q 5X J""1JU4 N-JV1Uk 1--10 36 JXX3-Z36N Qd1 6U-24 01234356 J60 -1XY436N Q5 X360

QdJQ J6 1Z"U5k1-M1Z"U5k11 -1UJQ3564d3" 1r34Q10 O1Q7116 456jJ J60 JO4M2O6* 014"3Q1 Qd1

713NdQ 5X 256Q-5UU36N UJ7* FY-34"-Y01621 J60 1V301621 Q5 4Y""5-Q 4Y2d J X36036N,h>Si

 

Page 37: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 37/108

1BC /HKIEF &KLJ3M

7# =::%(@ $9# =))=%8#/ /#<%)%&',

6& <&'+%'<%'? (#=)&' #_%)$) $& ;=((='$ = (#+#()=8 &: $9# /#<%)%&' &: $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) =::%(@%'? $9#

6U-2 (G8%'? ;9%<9 G.9#8/ $9# U=A&( J(A%$#() /%)@%))=8 &: $9# <=)# :&( 8=<\ &: `G(%)/%<$%&',

Q9# .(#)#'$ <&'$(&+#()H %) &'# &: :%()$ %@.(#))%&', J8$9&G?9 "9%8%..%'# 8=A&( 8=;) ='/ `G(%).(G/#'<#

/#:%'# <8#=(8H $9# #8#@#'$) &: =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%.* $9%) %) $9# :%()$ $%@# $9=$ $9# 2&G($ ;%88

(#)&8+# $9# '=$G(# &: $9# (#8=$%&')9%. A#$;##' = $#8#+%)%&' ='/ (=/%& )$=$%&' ='/ &'# &: %$) $=8#'$), Q9#(# %)

'& <=)# 8=; )$=$%'? $9=$ = (=/%& ='/ $#8#+%)%&' .(&?(=@ 9&)$ %) =' #@.8&H## &: $9# A(&=/<=)$ )$=$%&',

Q9# %')$='$ <=)# %'+&8+#) A%? '=@#) %' $9# A(&=/<=)$ %'/G)$(H* '=@#8H F&)# F=H 4&'^=* = \'&;'

$#8#+%)%&' ='/ (=/%& .#()&'=8%$H* ='/ JO4M2O6* &'# &: $9# A%??#)$ $#8#+%)%&' ='/ (=/%& '#$;&(\) %' $9#

<&G'$(H,

456jJ <&'$#'/) $9=$ $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( 9=) `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( $9# <=)# A#<=G)# 9# ;=) =' #@.8&H## &:

JO4M2O6, 5' $9# &$9#( 9='/* JO4M2O6 %')%)$) $9=$ $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( 9=) '& `G(%)/%<$%&' A#<=G)# 456jJ ;=)

=' %'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&(,

3(%405&& 0' 7*2&%&*2&*+ $0*+')/+0'8  

Q9# #_%)$#'<# &: =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. %) = ]G#)$%&' &: :=<$, J..#88=$# <&G($) =<<&(/ $9#

:=<$G=8 :%'/%'?) &: $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( ='/ $9# 6U-2 '&$ &'8H (#).#<$ AG$ =8)& :%'=8%$H ;9#' )G..&($#/ AH

)GA)$='$%=8 #+%/#'<#,h>Ri

  4GA)$='$%=8 #+%/#'<# @#=') )G<9 (#8#+='$ #+%/#'<# =) = (#=)&'=A8# @%'/ @%?9$

=<<#.$ =) =/#]G=$# $& )G..&($ = <&'<8G)%&',h>Ti

 J .=($H <=''&$ .(&+# $9# =A)#'<# &: )GA)$='$%=8 #+%/#'<#

AH )%@.8H .&%'$%'? &G$ $9=$ $9#(# %) <&'$(=(H #+%/#'<# &' (#<&(/* /%(#<$ &( <%(<G@)$='$%=8, Q9# 2&G($ /&#)

'&$ )GA)$%$G$# %$) &;' `G/?@#'$ :&( $9=$ &: $9# $(%AG'=8 %' /#$#(@%'%'? ;9#(# $9# ;#%?9$ &: #+%/#'<# 8%#)

&( ;9=$ #+%/#'<# %) <(#/%A8#,h>Ei 

456jJ @=%'$=%') $9=$ =88 #))#'$%=8 #8#@#'$) &: =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. =(# .(#)#'$ %' $9%)

<=)#, 2=)# 8=; 9=) <&')%)$#'$8H 9#8/ $9=$ $9# #8#@#'$) &: =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. =(#a K=L $9#

)#8#<$%&' ='/ #'?=?#@#'$ &: $9# #@.8&H##[ KAL $9# .=H@#'$ &: ;=?#)[ K<L $9# .&;#( &: /%)@%))=8[ ='/ K/L

$9# #@.8&H#() .&;#( $& <&'$(&8 $9# #@.8&H## &' $9# @#=') ='/ @#$9&/) AH ;9%<9 $9# ;&(\ %)

=<<&@.8%)9#/,h>Pi

 Q9# 8=)$ #8#@#'$* $9# )&M<=88#/ DH3EIHL ECFE* %) $9# @&)$ %@.&($='$ #8#@#'$,h>Ci

 

 9" :&4&/+,0* )*2 3*;);&(&*+ 0< 3(%405&& 

JO4M2O6 #'?=?#/ 456jJ) )#(+%<#) $& <&M9&)$ %$) $#8#+%)%&' ='/ (=/%& .(&?(=@) A#<=G)# &: 456jJ)

.#<G8%=( )\%88)* $=8#'$ ='/ <#8#A(%$H )$=$G), 456jJ <&'$#'/) $9=$ $9# /%)<(#$%&' G)#/ AH (#).&'/#'$ %'

).#<%:%<=88H )#8#<$%'? ='/ 9%(%'? <&@.8=%'='$ &+#( &$9#( A(&=/<=)$#() &: .&))%A8H )%@%8=( #_.#(%#'<# ='/

]G=8%:%<=$%&' =) <&@.8=%'='$ A#8%#) (#).&'/#'$) <8=%@ &: %'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&()9%.,

3'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&() &:$#' .(#)#'$ $9#@)#8+#) $& .&))#)) G'%]G# )\%88)* #_.#($%)# &( $=8#'$ $&

/%)$%'?G%)9 $9#@ :(&@ &(/%'=(H #@.8&H##), Q9# ).#<%:%< )#8#<$%&' ='/ 9%(%'? &: 456jJ* =&/).-& 0< >,-

.*,?.& -@,44-A +)4&*+ )*2 /&4&=',+5 -+)+.- *0+ %0--&--&2 =5 0'2,*)'5 &(%405&&- * %) = <%(<G@)$='<#

%'/%<=$%+#* AG$ '&$ <&'<8G)%+#* &: =' %'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$G=8 (#8=$%&')9%., 3: 456jJ /%/ '&$ .&))#)) )G<9

G'%]G# )\%88)* $=8#'$ ='/ <#8#A(%$H )$=$G)* JO4M2O6 ;&G8/ '&$ 9=+# #'$#(#/ %'$& $9# J?(##@#'$ ;%$9 456jJAG$ ;&G8/ 9=+# 9%(#/ 9%@ $9(&G?9 %$) .#()&''#8 /#.=($@#'$ `G)$ 8%\# ='H &$9#( #@.8&H##,

Page 38: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 38/108

3' ='H #+#'$* $9# @#$9&/ &: )#8#<$%'? ='/ #'?=?%'? 456jJ /&#) '&$ <&'<8G)%+#8H /#$#(@%'# 9%)

)$=$G), 7# @G)$ <&')%/#( =88 $9# <%(<G@)$='<#) &: $9# (#8=$%&')9%.* ;%$9 $9# <&'$(&8 $#)$ A#%'? $9# @&)$

%@.&($='$ #8#@#'$,

B" C)5(&*+ 0< D);&- 

JO4M2O6 /%(#<$8H .=%/ 456jJ 9%) @&'$98H $=8#'$ :##) ;%$9 '& .=($ &: 9%) :##) ?&%'? $& ZFZ02, 456jJ

=))#($) $9=$ $9%) @&/# &: :## .=H@#'$ )9&;) $9=$ 9# ;=) =' #@.8&H## &: JO4M2O6, 456jJ =8)& .&%'$) &G$

$9=$ JO4M2O6 ?(='$#/ 9%@ A#'#:%$) ='/ .(%+%8#?#) ;9%<9 9# ;&G8/ '&$ 9=+# #'`&H#/ %: 9# ;#(# $(G8H $9#

)GA`#<$ &: = +=8%/ `&A <&'$(=<$,

J88 $9# $=8#'$ :##) ='/ A#'#:%$) .=%/ $& 456jJ ;#(# $9# (#)G8$ &: '#?&$%=$%&') $9=$ 8#/ $& $9#

J?(##@#'$, 3: 456jJ ;#(# JO4M2O6) #@.8&H##* $9#(# ;&G8/ A# '& '##/ :&( $9# .=($%#) $& )$%.G8=$# &'

A#'#:%$) )G<9 =) 444* Z#/%<=(#* _ _ _ ='/ >I$9

 @&'$9 .=HhBDi

 ;9%<9 $9# 8=; =G$&@=$%<=88H %'<&(.&(=$#) %'$&

#+#(H #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## <&'$(=<$,hB>i

  79=$#+#( A#'#:%$) 456jJ #'`&H#/ =(&)# :(&@ <&'$(=<$ ='/ '&$

A#<=G)# &: =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%.,hBBi

 

456jJ) $=8#'$ :##)* =@&G'$%'? $& "I>E*DDD @&'$98H %' $9# )#<&'/ ='/ $9%(/ H#=(* =(# )& 9G?# ='/ &G$&: $9# &(/%'=(H $9=$ $9#H %'/%<=$# @&(# =' %'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$G=8 (#8=$%&')9%. (=$9#( $9=' =' #@.8&H#(M

#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%., JO4M2O6 =?(##/ $& .=H 456jJ )G<9 9G?# $=8#'$ :##) .(#<%)#8H A#<=G)# &: 456jJ)

G'%]G# )\%88)* $=8#'$ ='/ <#8#A(%$H )$=$G) '&$ .&))#))#/ AH &(/%'=(H #@.8&H##), 5A+%&G)8H* 456jJ =<$%'?

=8&'# .&))#))#/ #'&G?9 A=(?=%'%'? .&;#( $& /#@='/ ='/ (#<#%+# )G<9 9G?# $=8#'$ :##) :&( 9%)

)#(+%<#), Q9# .&;#( $& A=(?=%' $=8#'$ :##) ;=H =A&+# $9# )=8=(H )<=8#) &: &(/%'=(H #@.8&H##) %) =

<%(<G@)$='<# %'/%<=$%+#* AG$ '&$ <&'<8G)%+#* &: =' %'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$G=8 (#8=$%&')9%.,

Q9# .=H@#'$ &: $=8#'$ :##) /%(#<$8H $& 456jJ ='/ '&$ $& ZFZ02 /&#) '&$ '#?=$# $9# )$=$G) &: 456jJ

=) =' %'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&(, Q9# .=($%#) #_.(#))8H =?(##/ &' )G<9 @&/# &: .=H@#'$, Y'/#( $9#

J?(##@#'$* ZFZ02 %) $9# JN16Q &: 456jJ* $& ;9&@ ZFZ02 ;&G8/ 9=+# $& $G(' &+#( ='H $=8#'$ :##

=<<(G%'? G'/#( $9# J?(##@#'$,

$" C0E&' 0< F,-(,--)4  

X&( +%&8=$%&' &: ='H .(&+%)%&' &: $9# J?(##@#'$* #%$9#( .=($H @=H $#(@%'=$# $9#%( (#8=$%&')9%., 456jJ

:=%8#/ $& )9&; $9=$ JO4M2O6 <&G8/ $#(@%'=$# 9%) )#(+%<#) &' ?(&G'/) &$9#( $9=' A(#=<9 &: <&'$(=<$* )G<9 =)

(#$(#'<9@#'$ $& .(#+#'$ 8&))#) =) .(&+%/#/ G'/#( 8=A&( 8=;),hBIi

 

0G(%'? $9# 8%:# &: $9# J?(##@#'$* JO4M2O6 =?(##/ $& .=H 456jJ) $=8#'$ :##) =) 8&'? =) JN16Q ='/ F=H

4&'^= )9=88 :=%$9:G88H ='/ <&@.8#$#8H .#(:&(@ #=<9 <&'/%$%&' &: $9%) J?(##@#'$,hBSi  1+#' %: %$ )G::#(#/

)#+#(# AG)%'#)) 8&))#)* JO4M2O6 <&G8/ '&$ (#$(#'<9 456jJ A#<=G)# JO4M2O6 (#@=%'#/ &A8%?=$#/ $& .=H

456jJ) $=8#'$ :##) /G(%'? $9# 8%:# &: $9# J?(##@#'$, Q9%) <%(<G@)$='<# %'/%<=$#) =' %'/#.#'/#'$

<&'$(=<$G=8 (#8=$%&')9%. A#$;##' 456jJ ='/ JO4M2O6,

456jJ =/@%$) $9=$ #+#' =:$#( JO4M2O6 <#=)#/ A(&=/<=)$%'? 9%) .(&?(=@)* JO4M2O6 )$%88 .=%/ 9%@ 9%)

$=8#'$ :##), "8=%'8H* JO4M2O6 =/9#(#/ $& %$) G'/#($=\%'? %' $9# J?(##@#'$ $& <&'$%'G# .=H%'? 456jJ)

$=8#'$ :##) /G(%'? $9# (#@=%'%'? 8%:# &: $9# J?(##@#'$ #+#' %: JO4M2O6 <='<#88#/ 456jJ) .(&?(=@)

$9(&G?9 '& :=G8$ &: 456jJ,hBRi

 

456jJ =))=%8) $9# U=A&( J(A%$#() %'$#(.(#$=$%&' &: 9%) (#)<%))%&' &: $9# J?(##@#'$ =) =' =/@%))%&' $9=$

9# %) '&$ =' #@.8&H## &: JO4M2O6, Q9# U=A&( J(A%$#( )$=$#/ $9=$ %: %$ ;#(# $(G# $9=$ <&@.8=%'='$ ;=) (#=88H=' #@.8&H##* 9# ;&G8/ @#(#8H (#)%?'* %')$#=/, 456jJ /%/ =<$G=88H (#)%?' :(&@ JO4M2O6 AG$ 9# =8)&* =)

.(#)%/#'$ &: ZFZ02* (#)<%'/#/ $9# J?(##@#'$, 456jJ) 8#$$#( <8#=(8H A#=() $9%) &G$,hBTi

 d&;#+#(* $9#

@=''#( AH ;9%<9 456jJ $#(@%'=$#/ 9%) (#8=$%&')9%. ;%$9 JO4M2O6 %) %@@=$#(%=8, 79#$9#( 456jJ

Page 39: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 39/108

(#)<%'/#/ $9# J?(##@#'$ &( (#)%?'#/ :(&@ ;&(\ /&#) '&$ /#$#(@%'# 9%) )$=$G) =) #@.8&H## &(

%'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&(,

F" C0E&' 0< $0*+'04  

4%'<# $9#(# %) '& 8&<=8 .(#<#/#'$ &' ;9#$9#( = (=/%& ='/ $#8#+%)%&' .(&?(=@ 9&)$ %) =' #@.8&H## &( ='

%'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&(* ;# (#:#( $& :&(#%?' <=)# 8=; %' ='=8H^%'? $9# .(#)#'$ <=)#, Q9# Y'%$#/

4$=$#) 2&G($ &: J..#=8)* X%()$ 2%(<G%$* (#<#'$8H 9#8/ %' 94=&'+5GH4&I 1" $0'%0')/,* F& C.&'+0 J,/0 C)') K)

F,<.-,* C=4,/) LD7CJMhBEi

 $9=$ = $#8#+%)%&' .(&?(=@ 9&)$ %) =' %'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&(, 7# ]G&$# $9#

:&88&;%'? :%'/%'?) &: $9#Y,4, <&G($a

4#+#(=8 :=<$&() :=+&( <8=))%:H%'? J8A#($H =) =' %'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&(, 6JIFE5 2 ECLCTJFJH3 2DEICFF JF 2 FXJLLC4

SHFJEJH3 ICWKJIJ3M E2LC3E 234 EI2J3J3M 3HE 2T2JL2GLC H3dEBCd]HG, _ _ _ 3' $9%) (#?=(/* J8A#($H .&))#))#) =

@=)$#() /#?(## %' .GA8%< <&@@G'%<=$%&') ='/ `&G('=8%)@[ %) $(=%'#/ %' /='<#* )%'?%'?* ='/ @&/#8%'?[

$=G?9$ ;%$9 $9# /(=@= /#.=($@#'$ =$ $9# Y'%+#()%$H &: "G#($& -%<&[ ='/ =<$#/ %' )#+#(=8 $9#=$#( ='/

$#8#+%)%&' .(&/G<$%&') .(%&( $& 9#( =::%8%=$%&' ;%$9 0#)/# Z% "G#A8&, 'CDH345 (LGCIEQ SIHTJ4C4 EBC EHHLF

234 J3FEIKRC3E2LJEJCF 3CDCFF2IQ UHI BCI EH SCIUHIR, 4.#<%:%<=88H* )9# .(&+%/#/* &( &A$=%'#/ ).&')&() $&.(&+%/#* $9# <&)$G@#)* `#;#8(H* ='/ &$9#( %@=?#M(#8=$#/ )G..8%#) ='/ )#(+%<#) '#<#))=(H :&( 9#(

=..#=(='<#, J8A#($H /%).G$#) $9=$ $9%) :=<$&( :=+&() %'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&( )$=$G) A#<=G)# 73"- .(&+%/#/

$9# #]G%.@#'$ '#<#))=(H $& $=.# $9# )9&;, J8A#($H) =(?G@#'$ %) @%).8=<#/, Q9# #]G%.@#'$ '#<#))=(H :&(

J8A#($H $& <&'/G<$ %(, A*= =) 9&)$ &: 0#)/# Z% "G#A8& (#8=$#/ $& 9#( =..#=(='<# &' $9# )9&;, 5$9#()

.(&+%/#/ #]G%.@#'$ :&( :%8@%'? ='/ .(&/G<%'? $9# )9&;* AG$ $9#)# ;#(# '&$ $9# .(%@=(H $&&8) $9=$ J8A#($H

G)#/ $& .#(:&(@ 9#( .=($%<G8=( :G'<$%&', 3: ;# =<<#.$#/ $9%) =(?G@#'$* %'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&() <&G8/

'#+#( ;&(\ &' <&88=A&(=$%+# .(&`#<$) A#<=G)# &$9#( %'/%+%/G=8) &:$#' .(&+%/# $9# #]G%.@#'$ (#]G%(#/ :&(

/%::#(#'$ =).#<$) &: $9# <&88=A&(=$%&', _ _ _

1BJI45 =#0& DHKL4 3HE 2FFJM3 (LGCIEQ VHIX J3 244JEJH3 EH UJLRJ3M 7CF4C .J 0KCGLH, J8A#($H) <&'$(=<$) ;%$973"- ).#<%:%<=88H .(&+%/#/ $9=$ 73"- 9%(#/ 9#( .(&:#))%&'=8 )#(+%<#) =) d&)$#)) :&( $9# "(&?(=@ 0#)/# Z%

"G#A8&, Q9#(# %) '& #+%/#'<# $9=$ 73"- =))%?'#/ J8A#($H $=)\) %' =//%$%&' $& ;&(\ (#8=$#/ $& $9#)#

$=.%'?), _ _ _hBPi

 [email protected]=)%) )G..8%#/L

J..8H%'? $9# DH3EIHL ECFE $& $9# .(#)#'$ <=)#* ;# :%'/ $9=$ 456jJ %) '&$ =' #@.8&H## AG$ ='

%'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&(, Q9# <&'$(&8 $#)$ %) $9# RHFE JRSHIE23E $#)$ &G( <&G($) =..8H %' /%)$%'?G%)9%'? ='

#@.8&H## :(&@ =' %'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&(,hBCi

 Q9%) $#)$ %) A=)#/ &' $9# #_$#'$ &: <&'$(&8 $9# 9%(#( #_#(<%)#)

&+#( = ;&(\#(, Q9# ?(#=$#( $9# )G.#(+%)%&' ='/ <&'$(&8 $9# 9%(#( #_#(<%)#)* $9# @&(# 8%\#8H $9# ;&(\#( %)

/##@#/ =' #@.8&H##, Q9# <&'+#()# 9&8/) $(G# =) ;#88 $9# 8#)) <&'$(&8 $9# 9%(#( #_#(<%)#)* $9# @&(# 8%\#8H

$9# ;&(\#( %) <&')%/#(#/ =' %'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&(,

hIDi

 B&,0) * 456jJ <&'$#'/) $9=$ JO4M2O6 #_#(<%)#/ <&'$(&8 &+#( $9# @#=') ='/ @#$9&/) &: 9%) ;&(\,

456jJ) =(?G@#'$ %) @%).8=<#/, JO4M2O6 #'?=?#/ 456jJ) )#(+%<#) ).#<%:%<=88H $& <&M9&)$ $9# Z#8 n

F=H .(&?(=@), JO4M2O6 /%/ '&$ =))%?' ='H &$9#( ;&(\ $& 456jJ, Q& .#(:&(@ 9%) ;&(\* 456jJ &'8H '##/#/

9%) )\%88) ='/ $=8#'$, d&; 456jJ /#8%+#(#/ 9%) 8%'#)* =..#=(#/ &' $#8#+%)%&'* ='/ )&G'/#/ &' (=/%& ;#(#

&G$)%/# JO4M2O6) <&'$(&8, 456jJ /%/ '&$ 9=+# $& (#'/#( #%?9$ 9&G() &: ;&(\ .#( /=H, Q9# J?(##@#'$

(#]G%(#/ 456jJ $& =$$#'/ &'8H (#9#=()=8) ='/ $=.%'?) &: $9# )9&;)* =) ;#88 =) .(#M ='/ .&)$M.(&/G<$%&'

)$=:: @##$%'?),hI>i  JO4M2O6 <&G8/ '&$ /%<$=$# $9# <&'$#'$) &: 456jJ) )<(%.$, d&;#+#(* $9# J?(##@#'$

.(&9%A%$#/ 456jJ :(&@ <(%$%<%^%'? %' 9%) )9&;) JO4M2O6 &( %$) %'$#(#)$),hIBi  Q9# <8#=( %@.8%<=$%&' %) $9=$

456jJ 9=/ = :(## 9='/ &' ;9=$ $& )=H &( /%)<G)) %' 9%) )9&;) .(&+%/#/ 9# /%/ '&$ =$$=<\ JO4M2O6 &( %$)

%'$#(#)$),

7# :%'/ $9=$ JO4M2O6 ;=) '&$ %'+&8+#/ %' $9# =<$G=8 .#(:&(@='<# $9=$ .(&/G<#/ $9# :%'%)9#/ .(&/G<$

&: 456jJ) ;&(\,hIIi JO4M2O6 /%/ '&$ %')$(G<$ 456jJ 9&; $& .#(:&(@ 9%) `&A, JO4M2O6 @#(#8H (#)#(+#/ $9#

Page 40: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 40/108

(%?9$ $& @&/%:H $9# .(&?(=@ :&(@=$ ='/ =%($%@# )<9#/G8# :&( @&(# #::#<$%+# .(&?(=@@%'?,hISi

 JO4M2O6)

)&8# <&'<#(' ;=) $9# ]G=8%$H &: $9# )9&;) ='/ $9#%( )$='/%'? %' $9# (=$%'?), 28#=(8H* JO4M2O6 /%/ '&$

#_#(<%)# <&'$(&8 &+#( $9# @#=') ='/ @#$9&/) &: .#(:&(@='<# &: 456jJ) ;&(\,

456jJ <8=%@) $9=$ JO4M2O6) .&;#( '&$ $& A(&=/<=)$ 9%) )9&;) .(&+#) JO4M2O6) .&;#( &+#( $9#

@#=') ='/ @#$9&/) &: $9# .#(:&(@='<# &: 9%) ;&(\, J8$9&G?9 JO4M2O6 /%/ 9=+# $9# &.$%&' '&$ $&

A(&=/<=)$ 456jJ) )9&;* JO4M2O6 ;=) )$%88 &A8%?=$#/ $& .=H 456jJ) $=8#'$ :##), Q9G)* #+#' %: JO4M2O6 ;=)

<&@.8#$#8H /%))=$%):%#/ ;%$9 $9# @#=') ='/ @#$9&/) &: 456jJ) .#(:&(@='<# &: 9%) ;&(\* &( #+#' ;%$9 $9#

]G=8%$H &( .(&/G<$ &: 9%) ;&(\* JO4M2O6 <&G8/ '&$ /%)@%)) &( #+#' /%)<%.8%'# 456jJ, J88 $9=$ JO4M2O6 <&G8/

/& %) '&$ $& A(&=/<=)$ 456jJ) )9&; AG$ JO4M2O6 @G)$ )$%88 .=H 9%) $=8#'$ :##) %' :G88,hIRi

 

28#=(8H* JO4M2O6) (%?9$ '&$ $& A(&=/<=)$ 456jJ) )9&;* AG(/#'#/ =) %$ ;=) AH $9# &A8%?=$%&' $&

<&'$%'G# .=H%'? %' :G88 456jJ) $=8#'$ :##)* /%/ '&$ =@&G'$ $& <&'$(&8 &+#( $9# @#=') ='/ @#$9&/) &: $9#

.#(:&(@='<# &: 456jJ) ;&(\, JO4M2O6 <&G8/ '&$ $#(@%'=$# &( /%)<%.8%'# 456jJ #+#' %: $9# @#=') ='/

@#$9&/) &: .#(:&(@='<# &: 9%) ;&(\ M 9&; 9# /#8%+#(#/ 9%) 8%'#) ='/ =..#=(#/ &' $#8#+%)%&' M /%/ '&$ @##$

JO4M2O6) =..(&+=8, Q9%) .(&+#) $9=$ JO4M2O6) <&'$(&8 ;=) 8%@%$#/ &'8H $& $9# (#)G8$ &: 456jJ) ;&(\*

;9#$9#( $& A(&=/<=)$ $9# :%'=8 .(&/G<$ &( '&$, 3' #%$9#( <=)#* JO4M2O6 @G)$ )$%88 .=H 456jJ) $=8#'$ :##) %'

:G88 G'$%8 $9# #_.%(H &: $9# J?(##@#'$,

3' H).;>)*A &+ )4" 1" D)'*&'A &+ )4"*hITi $9# Y'%$#/ 4$=$#) 2%(<G%$ 2&G($ &: J..#=8) (G8#/ $9=$ +=G/#+%88#.#(:&(@#() ;#(# %'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&() =8$9&G?9 $9# @='=?#@#'$ (#)#(+#/ $9# (%?9$ $& /#8#$#

&A`#<$%&'=A8# :#=$G(#) %' $9#%( )9&;), 4%'<# $9# @='=?#@#'$ /%/ '&$ 9=+# <&'$(&8 &+#( $9# @=''#( &:

.#(:&(@='<# &: $9# )\%88) &: $9# =($%)$)* %$ <&G8/ &'8H <&'$(&8 $9# (#)G8$ &: $9# ;&(\ AH /#8#$%'?

&A`#<$%&'=A8# :#=$G(#),hIEi 

456jJ :G($9#( <&'$#'/) $9=$ JO4M2O6 #_#(<%)#/ <&'$(&8 &+#( 9%) ;&(\ AH )G..8H%'? =88 #]G%.@#'$ ='/

<(#;, 6& /&GA$* JO4M2O6 )G..8%#/ $9# #]G%.@#'$* <(#; ='/ =%($%@# '##/#/ $& A(&=/<=)$ $9# Z#8 n F=H

.(&?(=@), d&;#+#(* $9# #]G%.@#'$* <(#; ='/ =%($%@# =(# '&$ $9# $&&8) ='/ %')$(G@#'$=8%$%#) 456jJ

'##/#/ $& .#(:&(@ 9%) `&A, 79=$ 456jJ .(%'<%.=88H '##/#/ ;#(# 9%) $=8#'$ &( )\%88) ='/ $9# <&)$G@#)

'#<#))=(H :&( 9%) =..#=(='<#, hIPi

 1+#' $9&G?9 JO4M2O6 .(&+%/#/ 456jJ ;%$9 $9# .8=<# &: ;&(\ ='/ $9#

'#<#))=(H #]G%.@#'$* 456jJ ;=) )$%88 =' %'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&( )%'<# JO4M2O6 /%/ '&$ )G.#(+%)# ='/

<&'$(&8 9%) ;&(\, JO4M2O6) )&8# <&'<#(' ;=) :&( 456jJ $& /%).8=H 9%) $=8#'$ /G(%'? $9# =%(%'? &: $9#

.(&?(=@),hICi 

J (=/%& A(&=/<=)$ ).#<%=8%)$ ;9& ;&(\) G'/#( @%'%@=8 )G.#(+%)%&' %) =' %'/#.#'/#'$

<&'$(=<$&(,hSDi

 456jJ) ;&(\ =) $#8#+%)%&' ='/ (=/%& .(&?(=@ 9&)$ (#]G%(#/ ).#<%=8 )\%88) ='/ $=8#'$* ;9%<9

456jJ =/@%$$#/8H .&))#))#), Q9# (#<&(/) /& '&$ )9&; $9=$ JO4M2O6 #_#(<%)#/ ='H )G.#(+%)%&' ='/ <&'$(&8

&+#( 9&; 456jJ G$%8%^#/ 9%) )\%88) ='/ $=8#'$ %' 9%) )9&;),

C(;*+1 * 456jJ G(?#) G) $& (G8# $9=$ 9# ;=) JO4M2O6) #@.8&H## A#<=G)# JO4M2O6 )GA`#<$#/ 9%@ $& %$)

(G8#) ='/ )$='/=(/) &: .#(:&(@='<#, 456jJ <8=%@) $9=$ $9%) %'/%<=$#) JO4M2O6) <&'$(&8 '&$ &'8H h&+#(i 9%)

@=''#( &: ;&(\ AG$ =8)& $9# ]G=8%$H &: 9%) ;&(\,

Q9# J?(##@#'$ )$%.G8=$#) $9=$ 456jJ )9=88 =A%/# ;%$9 $9# (G8#) ='/ )$='/=(/) &:

.#(:&(@='<# DHTCIJ3M E2LC3EFhS>i

 &: JO4M2O6, Q9# J?(##@#'$ /&#) '&$ (#]G%(# 456jJ $& <&@.8H ;%$9 $9#

(G8#) ='/ )$='/=(/) &: .#(:&(@='<# .(#)<(%A#/ :&( #@.8&H##) &: JO4M2O6, Q9# <&/# &: <&'/G<$ %@.&)#/

&' 456jJ G'/#( $9# J?(##@#'$ (#:#() $& $9# Q#8#+%)%&' ='/ -=/%& 2&/# &: $9# b=.%)='=' '? @?=

O(&=/<=)$#( )= "%8%.%'=) KbO"L* ;9%<9 9=) A##' =/&.$#/ AH $9# 25Z"J6k KJO4M2O6L =) %$) 2&/# &:

1$9%<),hSBi

 Q9# bO" <&/# =..8%#) $& A(&=/<=)$#()* '&$ $& #@.8&H##) &: (=/%& ='/ $#8#+%)%&'

)$=$%&'), O(&=/<=)$#() =(# '&$ '#<#))=(%8H #@.8&H##) &: (=/%& ='/ $#8#+%)%&' )$=$%&'), 28#=(8H* $9# (G8#) ='/

)$='/=(/) &: .#(:&(@='<# (#:#((#/ $& %' $9# J?(##@#'$ =(# $9&)# =..8%<=A8# $& $=8#'$) ='/ '&$ $&

#@.8&H##) &: JO4M2O6,3' ='H #+#'$* '&$ =88 (G8#) %@.&)#/ AH $9# 9%(%'? .=($H &' $9# 9%(#/ .=($H %'/%<=$# $9=$ $9# 8=$$#( %) ='

#@.8&H## &: $9# :&(@#(,hSIi

 3' $9%) <=)#* 456jJ :=%8#/ $& )9&; $9=$ $9#)# (G8#) <&'$(&88#/ 9%) .#(:&(@='<#,

7# :%'/ $9=$ $9#)# ?#'#(=8 (G8#) =(# @#(#8H MKJ4CLJ3CF $&;=(/) $9# =<9%#+#@#'$ &: $9# @G$G=88H /#)%(#/

Page 41: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 41/108

(#)G8$* ;9%<9 =(# $&.M(=$%'? $#8#+%)%&' ='/ (=/%& .(&?(=@) $9=$ <&@.8H ;%$9 )$='/=(/) &: $9# %'/G)$(H, 7#

9=+# (G8#/ $9=$a

XG($9#(* '&$ #+#(H :&(@ &: <&'$(&8 $9=$ = .=($H (#)#(+#) $& 9%@)#8: &+#( $9# <&'/G<$ &: $9# &$9#( .=($H %'

(#8=$%&' $& $9# )#(+%<#) A#%'? (#'/#(#/ @=H A# =<<&(/#/ $9# #::#<$ &: #)$=A8%)9%'? =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H##

(#8=$%&')9%., Q9# :=<$) &: $9%) <=)# :=88 )]G=(#8H ;%$9 $9# <=)# &: 3')G8=( U%:# J))G(='<# 2&,* U$/, +), 6U-2, 3'

)=%/ <=)#* ;# 9#8/ $9=$a

U&?%<=88H* $9# 8%'# )9&G8/ A# /(=;' A#$;##' (G8#) $9=$ @#(#8H )#(+# =) ?G%/#8%'#) $&;=(/) $9# =<9%#+#@#'$

&: $9# @G$G=88H /#)%(#/ (#)G8$ ;%$9&G$ /%<$=$%'? $9# @#=') &( @#$9&/) $& A# #@.8&H#/ %' =$$=%'%'? %$* ='/

$9&)# $9=$ <&'$(&8 &( :%_ $9# @#$9&/&8&?H ='/ A%'/ &( (#)$(%<$ $9# .=($H 9%(#/ $& $9# G)# &: )G<9 @#='), Q9#

:%()$* ;9%<9 =%@ &'8H $& .(&@&$# $9# (#)G8$* <(#=$# '& #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. G'8%\# $9# )#<&'/*

;9%<9 =//(#)) A&$9 $9# (#)G8$ ='/ $9# @#=') G)#/ $& =<9%#+# %$,hSSi

 

Q9# H).;>)*  <=)# =8)& 9#8/ $9=$ &'# <&G8/ )$%88 A# =' %'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&( =8$9&G?9 $9# 9%(#(

(#)#(+#/ <#($=%' )G.#(+%)%&' $& %')G(# $9# =$$=%'@#'$ &: $9# /#)%(#/ (#)G8$, Q9# 9%(#(* 9&;#+#(* @G)$ '&$

/#.(%+# $9# &'# 9%(#/ :(&@ .#(:&(@%'? 9%) )#(+%<#) =<<&(/%'? $& 9%) &;' %'%$%=$%+#,hSRi

 

?50)7< * 456jJ %')%)$) $9=$ $9# #_<8G)%+%$H <8=G)# %' $9# J?(##@#'$ %) $9# @&)$ #_$(#@# :&(@ &: <&'$(&8;9%<9 JO4M2O6 #_#(<%)#/ &+#( 9%@,

Q9%) =(?G@#'$ %) :G$%8#, O#%'? =' #_<8G)%+# $=8#'$ /&#) '&$ AH %$)#8: @#=' $9=$ 456jJ %) =' #@.8&H## &:

JO4M2O6, 1+#' =' %'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&( <=' +=8%/8H .(&+%/# 9%) )#(+%<#) #_<8G)%+#8H $& $9# 9%(%'? .=($H, 3'

$9# A(&=/<=)$ %'/G)$(H* #_<8G)%+%$H %) '&$ '#<#))=(%8H $9# )=@# =) <&'$(&8,

Q9# 9%(%'? &: #_<8G)%+# $=8#'$) %) = ;%/#).(#=/ ='/ =<<#.$#/ .(=<$%<# %' $9# #'$#($=%'@#'$

%'/G)$(H,hSTi

  Q9%) .(=<$%<# %) '&$ /#)%?'#/ $& <&'$(&8 $9# @#=') ='/ @#$9&/) &: ;&(\ &: $9# $=8#'$* AG$

)%@.8H $& .(&$#<$ $9# %'+#)$@#'$ &: $9# A(&=/<=)$ )$=$%&', Q9# A(&=/<=)$ )$=$%&' '&(@=88H ).#'/)

)GA)$='$%=8 =@&G'$) &: @&'#H* $%@# ='/ #::&($ %' AG%8/%'? G. %$) $=8#'$) =) ;#88 =) $9# .(&?(=@) $9#H

=..#=( %' ='/ $9G) #_.#<$) $9=$ )=%/ $=8#'$) (#@=%' #_<8G)%+# ;%$9 $9# )$=$%&' :&( = <&@@#')G(=$# .#(%&/&: $%@#,hSEi 6&(@=88H* = @G<9 9%?9#( :## %) .=%/ $& $=8#'$) ;9& =?(## $& ;&(\ #_<8G)%+#8H :&( = .=($%<G8=(

(=/%& &( $#8#+%)%&' )$=$%&', 3' )9&($* $9# 9G?# $=8#'$ :##) .=($%=88H <&@.#')=$#) :&( #_<8G)%+%$H* =) %' $9#

.(#)#'$ <=)#,

N!NF$ )- 9;&*+ 0< :OPQ9 

456jJ .(&$#)$) $9# U=A&( J(A%$#() :%'/%'? $9=$ 9# %) = $=8#'$ &: ZFZ02* ;9%<9 <&'$(=<$#/ &G$ 9%)

)#(+%<#) $& JO4M2O6, Q9# U=A&( J(A%$#( (G8#/ $9=$ =) = $=8#'$ &: ZFZ02* 456jJ %) '&$ =' #@.8&H## &: JO4M

2O6, 456jJ %')%)$) $9=$ ZFZ02 %) = 8=A&(M&'8H <&'$(=<$&( ='/ JO4M2O6 %) 9%) #@.8&H#(,

3' = 8=A&(M&'8H <&'$(=<$* $9#(# =(# $9(## .=($%#) %'+&8+#/a K>L $9# 8=A&(M&'8H <&'$(=<$&([ KBL $9#

#@.8&H## ;9& %) &)$#')%A8H G'/#( $9# #@.8&H &: $9# 8=A&(M&'8H <&'$(=<$&([ ='/ KIL $9# .(%'<%.=8 ;9& %)

/##@#/ $9# (#=8 #@.8&H#(, Y'/#( $9%) )<9#@#* EBC L2GHIdH3LQ DH3EI2DEHI JF EBC 2MC3E HU EBC SIJ3DJS2L. Q9#

8=; @=\#) $9# .(%'<%.=8 (#).&')%A8# $& $9# #@.8&H##) &: $9# 8=A&(M&'8H <&'$(=<$&( =) %: $9# .(%'<%.=8 %$)#8:

/%(#<$8H 9%(#/ &( #@.8&H#/ $9# #@.8&H##),hSPi

 Q9#)# <%(<G@)$='<#) =(# '&$ .(#)#'$ %' $9%) <=)#,

Q9#(# =(# #))#'$%=88H &'8H $;& .=($%#) %'+&8+#/ G'/#( $9# J?(##@#'$* '=@#8H* 456jJ ='/ JO4M2O6,

ZFZ02 @#(#8H =<$#/ =) 456jJ) =?#'$, Q9# J?(##@#'$ #_.(#))8H )$=$#) $9=$ ZFZ02 =<$#/ =) $9# JN16Q

&: 456jJ, Q9# (#<&(/) /& '&$ )9&; $9=$ ZFZ02 =<$#/ =) JO4M2O6) =?#'$, ZFZ02* ;9%<9 )$='/) :&( Z#8

='/ F=H Z='=?#@#'$ ='/ 0#+#8&.@#'$ 2&(.&(=$%&'* %) = <&(.&(=$%&' &(?='%^#/ ='/ &;'#/ AH 456jJ ='/Q3J6N25, Q9# "(#)%/#'$ ='/ N#'#(=8 Z='=?#( &: ZFZ02 %) 456jJ 9%@)#8:, 3$ %) =A)G(/ $& 9&8/ $9=$

ZFZ02* ;9%<9 %) &;'#/* <&'$(&88#/* 9#=/#/ ='/ @='=?#/ AH 456jJ* =<$#/ =) =?#'$ &: JO4M2O6 %'

Page 42: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 42/108

#'$#(%'? %'$& $9# J?(##@#'$ ;%$9 456jJ* ;9& 9%@)#8: %) (#.(#)#'$#/ AH ZFZ02, Q9=$ ;&G8/ @=\#

ZFZ02 $9# =?#'$ &: A&$9 JO4M2O6 ='/ 456jJ,

J) 456jJ =/@%$)* ZFZ02 %) = @='=?#@#'$ <&@.='H /#+&$#/ C^DLKFJTCLQ $& @='=?%'? $9# <=(##() &:

456jJ ='/ 9%) A(&=/<=)$ .=($'#(* Q3J6N25, ZFZ02 %) '&$ #'?=?#/ %' ='H &$9#( AG)%'#))* '&$ #+#' `&A

<&'$(=<$%'?, ZFZ02 /&#) '&$ 9=+# ='H &$9#( :G'<$%&' =.=($ :(&@ =<$%'? =) =?#'$ &: 456jJ &( Q3J6N25 $&

.(&@&$# $9#%( <=(##() %' $9# A(&=/<=)$ ='/ $#8#+%)%&' %'/G)$(H,hSCi

 

C04,/5 7*-+'./+,0* P0" RS  

456jJ =(?G#) $9=$ "&8%<H 3')$(G<$%&' 6&, SD %))G#/ AH $9#' Z%'%)$#( &: U=A&( O8=) 5.8# &' P F='G=(H

>CEC:%'=88H )#$$8#/ $9# )$=$G) &: ;&(\#() %' $9# A(&=/<=)$ %'/G)$(H, Y'/#( $9%) .&8%<H* $9# $H.#) &:

#@.8&H##) %' $9# A(&=/<=)$ %'/G)$(H =(# $9# )$=$%&' ='/ .(&?(=@ #@.8&H##),

"&8%<H 3')$(G<$%&' 6&, SD %) = @#(# #_#<G$%+# %))G='<# ;9%<9 /&#) '&$ 9=+# $9# :&(<# ='/ #::#<$ &:

8=;,Q9#(# %) '& 8#?=8 .(#)G@.$%&' $9=$ "&8%<H 3')$(G<$%&' 6&, SD /#$#(@%'#) 456jJ) )$=$G), J @#(#

#_#<G$%+# %))G='<# <=''&$ #_<8G/# %'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&() :(&@ $9# <8=)) &: )#(+%<# .(&+%/#() $& $9#

A(&=/<=)$ %'/G)$(H,Q9# <8=))%:%<=$%&' &: ;&(\#() %' $9# A(&=/<=)$ %'/G)$(H %'$& &'8H $;& ?(&G.) G'/#("&8%<H 3')$(G<$%&' 6&, SD %) '&$ A%'/%'? &' $9%) 2&G($* #).#<%=88H ;9#' $9# <8=))%:%<=$%&' 9=) '& A=)%) #%$9#(

%' 8=; &( %' :=<$,

 9<<,2)1,+- 0< 9B:G$BP- D,+*&--&- 

456jJ =8)& :=G8$) $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( :&( =/@%$$%'? $9# =::%/=+%$) &: 4&<&((& V%/='#) ='/ -&8='/& 2(G^

;%$9&G$ ?%+%'? 9%) <&G')#8 $9# &..&($G'%$H $& <(&))M#_=@%'# $9#)# ;%$'#))#), 456jJ A(='/) $9#)#

;%$'#))#) =) %'<&@.#$#'$ $& =$$#)$ &' $9# .(#+=%8%'? .(=<$%<# %' $9# (=/%& ='/ $#8#+%)%&' %'/G)$(H, 456jJ

+%#;) $9# =::%/=+%$) &: $9#)# ;%$'#))#) =) @%)8#=/%'? ='/ %((#8#+='$,

79%8# 456jJ :=%8#/ $& <(&))M#_=@%'# JO4M2O6) ;%$'#))#)* 9# ;=) '#+#( .(#+#'$#/ :(&@ /#'H%'? &(

(#:G$%'? $9# =88#?=$%&') %' $9# =::%/=+%$), Q9# U=A&( J(A%$#( 9=) $9# /%)<(#$%&' ;9#$9#( $& <&'/G<$ = :&(@=8

K$(%=8M$H.#L 9#=(%'? =:$#( $9# )GA@%))%&' &: $9# .&)%$%&' .=.#() &: $9# .=($%#)* $9G)a

4#<$%&' I, 4GA@%))%&' &: "&)%$%&' "=.#()eZ#@&(='/G@

_ _ _

Q9#)# +#(%:%#/ .&)%$%&' .=.#() )9=88 <&+#( &'8H $9&)# <8=%@) ='/ <=G)#) &: =<$%&' (=%)#/ %' $9# <&@.8=%'$#_<8G/%'? $9&)# $9=$ @=H 9=+# A##' =@%<=A8H )#$$8#/* ='/ )9=88 A# =<<&@.='%#/ AH =88 )G..&($%'?

/&<G@#'$) %'<8G/%'? $9# =::%/=+%$) &: $9#%( (#).#<$%+# ;%$'#))#) ;9%<9 )9=88 $=\# $9# .8=<# &: $9# 8=$$#()

/%(#<$ $#)$%@&'H, _ _ _

4#<$%&' S, 0#$#(@%'=$%&' &: 6#<#))%$H &: d#=(%'?, 3@@#/%=$#8H =:$#( $9# )GA@%))%&' &: $9# .=($%#) &: $9#%(

.&)%$%&' .=.#()e@#@&(='/G@* $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( )9=88 @&$G .(&.%& /#$#(@%'# ;9#$9#( $9#(# %) '##/ :&( =

:&(@=8 $(%=8 &( 9#=(%'?, J$ $9%) )$=?#* 9# @=H* =$ 9%) /%)<(#$%&' ='/ :&( $9# .G(.&)# &: @=\%'? )G<9

/#$#(@%'=$%&'* =)\ <8=(%:%<=$&(H ]G#)$%&') $& :G($9#( #8%<%$ :=<$) &( %':&(@=$%&'* %'<8G/%'? AG$ '&$ 8%@%$#/ $&

$9# )GA.&#'= &: (#8#+='$ /&<G@#'$=(H #+%/#'<#* %: ='H :(&@ ='H .=($H &( ;%$'#)),hRDi 

Q9# U=A&( J(A%$#( <=' /#<%/# = <=)# A=)#/ )&8#8H &' $9# .&)%$%&' .=.#() ='/ $9# )G..&($%'? /&<G@#'$)

;%$9&G$ = :&(@=8 $(%=8,hR>i

  Q9# 9&8/%'? &: = :&(@=8 9#=(%'? &( $(%=8 %) )&@#$9%'? $9=$ $9# .=($%#) <=''&$

/#@='/ =) = @=$$#( &: (%?9$,hRBi

 3: $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( %) <&':%/#'$ $9=$ 9# <=' (#8H &' $9# /&<G@#'$) A#:&(#

9%@* 9# <=''&$ A# :=G8$#/ :&( '&$ <&'/G<$%'? = :&(@=8 $(%=8* G'8#)) G'/#( $9# .=($%<G8=( <%(<G@)$='<#) &:

Page 43: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 43/108

$9# <=)#* $9# /&<G@#'$) =8&'# =(# %')G::%<%#'$, Q9# .(&<##/%'?) A#:&(# = U=A&( J(A%$#( =(# '&'M8%$%?%&G) %'

'=$G(#, 4GA`#<$ $& $9# (#]G%(#@#'$) &: /G# .(&<#))* $9# $#<9'%<=8%$%#) &: 8=; ='/ $9# (G8#) &A$=%'%'? %' $9#

<&G($) &: 8=; /& '&$ )$(%<$8H =..8H %' .(&<##/%'?) A#:&(# = U=A&( J(A%$#(,

T)4&*+- )- 7*2&%&*2&*+ $0*+')/+0'- 

JO4M2O6 <8=%@) $9=$ $9#(# #_%)$) = .(#+=%8%'? .(=<$%<# %' $9# A(&=/<=)$ ='/ #'$#($=%'@#'$ %'/G)$(%#) $&

$(#=$ $=8#'$) 8%\# 456jJ =) %'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&(), 456jJ =(?G#) $9=$ %: )G<9 .(=<$%<# #_%)$)* %$ %) +&%/ :&(

+%&8=$%'? $9# (%?9$ &: 8=A&( $& )#<G(%$H &: $#'G(#,

Q9# (%?9$ &: 8=A&( $& )#<G(%$H &: $#'G(# =) ?G=(='$##/ %' $9# 2&')$%$G$%&'hRIi

 =(%)#) &'8H %: $9#(# %) ='

#@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. G'/#( 8=A&( 8=;), 6&$ #+#(H .#(:&(@='<# &: )#(+%<#) :&( = :## <(#=$#) ='

#@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%., Q& 9&8/ $9=$ #+#(H .#()&' ;9& (#'/#() )#(+%<#) $& ='&$9#( :&( = :## %) ='

#@.8&H## M $& ?%+# @#='%'? $& $9# )#<G(%$H &: $#'G(# <8=G)# M ;%88 8#=/ $& =A)G(/ (#)G8$),

3'/%+%/G=8) ;%$9 ).#<%=8 )\%88)* #_.#($%)# &( $=8#'$ #'`&H $9# :(##/&@ $& &::#( $9#%( )#(+%<#) =)

%'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&(), Q9# (%?9$ $& 8%:# ='/ 8%+#8%9&&/ ?G=(='$##) $9%) :(##/&@ $& <&'$(=<$ =)

%'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&(), Q9# (%?9$ &: 8=A&( $& )#<G(%$H &: $#'G(# <=''&$ &.#(=$# $& /#.(%+# =' %'/%+%/G=8*.&))#))#/ ;%$9 ).#<%=8 )\%88)* #_.#($%)# ='/ $=8#'$* &: 9%) (%?9$ $& <&'$(=<$ =) =' %'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&(, J'

%'/%+%/G=8 8%\# =' =($%)$ &( $=8#'$ 9=) = (%?9$ $& (#'/#( 9%) )#(+%<#) ;%$9&G$ ='H &'# <&'$(&88%'? $9# @#=')

='/ @#$9&/) AH ;9%<9 9# .#(:&(@) 9%) =($ &( <(=:$, Q9%) 2&G($ ;%88 '&$ %'$#(.(#$ $9# (%?9$ &: 8=A&( $&

)#<G(%$H &: $#'G(# $& <&@.#8 =($%)$) ='/ $=8#'$) $& (#'/#( $9#%( )#(+%<#) &'8H =) #@.8&H##), 3: (=/%& ='/

$#8#+%)%&' .(&?(=@ 9&)$) <=' (#'/#( $9#%( )#(+%<#) &'8H =) #@.8&H##)* $9# )$=$%&' &;'#() ='/ @='=?#()

<=' /%<$=$# $& $9# (=/%& ='/ $#8#+%)%&' 9&)$) ;9=$ $9#H )=H %' $9#%( )9&;), Q9%) %) '&$ <&'/G<%+# $& :(##/&@

&: $9# .(#)),

F,<<&'&*+ T)U T'&)+(&*+ 0< T)4&*+- )*2 B'0)2/)-+&'- 

Q9# 6=$%&'=8 3'$#('=8 -#+#'G# 2&/# K63-2LhRSi %' (#8=$%&' $& -#.GA8%< J<$ 6&, EE>T*hRRi =) =@#'/#/ AH

-#.GA8%< J<$ 6&, PBS>*hRTi  $(#=$) $=8#'$)* $#8#+%)%&' ='/ (=/%& A(&=/<=)$#() /%::#(#'$8H, Y'/#( $9# 63-2*

$9#)# .(&:#))%&'=8) =(# )GA`#<$ $& $9# >Dm +=8G#M=//#/ $=_ KVJQL &' )#(+%<#) $9#H (#'/#(, 1_#@.$#/ :(&@

$9# VJQ =(# $9&)# G'/#( =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%.,hREi

 Q9%) /%::#(#'$ $=_ $(#=$@#'$ =<<&(/#/ $&

$=8#'$) ='/ A(&=/<=)$#() A&8$#() &G( <&'<8G)%&' $9=$ $9#H =(# %'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&()* .(&+%/#/ =88 $9#

A=)%< #8#@#'$) &: = <&'$(=<$G=8 (#8=$%&')9%. =(# .(#)#'$ =) %' $9%) <=)#,

P)+.'& 0< :OPQ9- $4),(- 

456jJ )##\) $9# (#<&+#(H &: =88#?#/8H G'.=%/ $=8#'$ :##)* >I$9

  @&'$9 .=H* )#.=(=$%&' .=H* )#(+%<#

%'<#'$%+# 8#=+#* )%?'%'? A&'G)* $(=+#8 =88&;='<#* ='/ =@&G'$) /G# G'/#( $9# [email protected]&H## 4$&<\ 5.$%&' "8=',

7# =?(## ;%$9 $9# :%'/%'?) &: $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( ='/ $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) $9=$ 456jJ) <8=%@) =(# 2LL G2FC4

H3 EBC .2Q PeeZ (MICCRC3E 234 FEHDX HSEJH3 SL235 234 3HE H3 EBC )2GHI /H4C< 28#=(8H* $9# .(#)#'$ <=)#

/&#) '&$ <=88 :&( =' =..8%<=$%&' &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# .(&+%)%&') AG$ =' %'$#(.(#$=$%&' ='/ %@.8#@#'$=$%&' &:

$9# Z=H >CCS J?(##@#'$, 3' #::#<$* 456jJ) <=G)# &: =<$%&' %) :&( A(#=<9 &: <&'$(=<$ ;9%<9 %) %'$(%')%<=88H =

<%+%8 /%).G$# <&?'%^=A8# AH $9# (#?G8=( <&G($),hRPi

 

=9%&%6+&%* ;# 016k $9# .#$%$%&', Q9# =))=%8#/ 0#<%)%&' &: $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) /=$#/ BT Z=(<9>CCC%' 2JMN,-, 4" 6&, SC>CD %) JXX3-Z10, 2&)$) =?=%')$ .#$%$%&'#(,

'+ +&7%&%7<

Page 44: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 44/108

D5-&1(@ E,.@ F.E.@ GF%5&,45+H@ '5+I5+&=5+@ J+5,(0KC5+)&5I*@ ='/ L8;6+5@ EE.@ <&'<G(.

Page 45: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 45/108

 

(&#%) )< 7($#75 7+#"- ,!'#"%'' !"7%& 19% "(.% ("7 '1:)% f:#%)' 9+- 7%()%&5g 0%1#1#+"%&5 $'<

;+9" -< .(/('#+* /(0$*+1(+). 

7 % / # ' # + " 

,&#+"5 !"A 

7# (#)&8+# %' $9%) .#$%$%&' :&( (#+%#; &' ;(,)&*,5,& > $9# <9=88#'?# $& $9# 6&+#@A#( BB* BD>D /#<%)%&'

B ='/

$9# F='G=(H I>* BD>> (#)&8G$%&'I &: $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) GFLH %' 2JMN,-, 4" 6&, >>TDDI, Q9# 2J /#<%)%&'

=''G88#/ ='/ )#$ =)%/# $9# Z=H BT* BD>D /#<%)%&'S &: $9# 6=$%&'=8 U=A&( -#8=$%&')

2&@@%))%&' GM?/FHR ;9%<9* %' $G('* =::%(@#/ $9# J.(%8 ID* BDDC /#<%)%&'

T &: $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( G?LH, Q9# UJW)

/#<%)%&' /%)@%))#/ (#).&'/#'$ F&9' N, Z=<=)%&W) @&'#$=(H <8=%@),

1BC 62DEK2L (3ECDC4C3EF 

3' F='G=(H BDDC* Z=<=)%& :%8#/ A#:&(# $9# UJ = <&@.8=%'$E =?=%')$ .#$%$%&'#( J(%#8 U, 0=+%/* /&%'? AG)%'#))

G'/#( $9# '=@# ='/ )$H8# tk%#8) d&? 0#=8#(*u :&( '&'M.=H@#'$ &: HTCIEJRC S2Q5 BHLJ42Q

S2Q ='/ PcEB

 RH3EB S2Q<  d# =8)& <8=%@#/ .=H@#'$ :&( RHI2L 234 C^CRSL2IQ 42R2MCF ='/ 2EEHI3CQ@F

UCCF, Z=<=)%& =8)& <8=%@#/ .=H@#'$ :&( FCITJDC J3DC3EJTC LC2TCGCN?H,P 

Z=<=)%& =88#?#/C A#:&(# $9# UJ $9=$ 9# 9=/ A##' ;&(\%'? =) = AG$<9#( :&( 0=+%/ )%'<# F='G=(H T*

>CCR, Z=<=)%& <8=%@#/ $9=$ 0=+%/ #_#(<%)#/ #::#<$%+# <&'$(&8 ='/ )G.#(+%)%&' &+#( 9%) ;&(\* .&%'$%'? &G$

$9=$ 0=+%/a K>L )#$ $9# ;&(\ /=H* (#.&($%'? $%@# ='/ 9&?) $& A# <9&..#/* =) ;#88 =) $9# @=''#( AH ;9%<9

9# ;=) $& .#(:&(@ 9%) ;&(\[ KBL /=%8H .=%/ 9%) )=8=(H &: "EDD,DD* ;9%<9 ;=) %'<(#=)#/ :(&@ "TDD,DD %' BDDE*

"RDD,DD %' BDDT ='/ "SDD,DD %' BDDR[ ='/ KIL =..(&+#/ ='/ /%)=..(&+#/ 9%) 8#=+#), Z=<=)%& =//#/ $9=$

0=+%/ &;'#/ $9# 9&?) /#8%+#(#/ :&( <9&..%'?* =) ;#88 =) $9# ;&(\ $&&8) ='/ %@.8#@#'$)[ $9# 8=$$#( =8)&

(#'$#/ $9# ;&(\.8=<#, Z=<=)%& :G($9#( <8=%@#/ $9=$ 0=+%/ #@.8&H) =A&G$ $;#'$HM:%+# KBRL AG$<9#() ='//#8%+#(H /(%+#(),

3' 9%) /#:#')#*>D

 0=+%/ <8=%@#/ $9=$ 9# )$=($#/ 9%) 9&? /#=8#( AG)%'#)) %' BDDR ='/ $9=$ 9# &'8H 9=) $#'

#@.8&H##), d# =88#?#/ $9=$ 9# 9%(#/ Z=<=)%& =) = AG$<9#( &( <9&..#( &' t $5><5# u &( $=)\ A=)%) ;9& %)*

$9#(#:&(#* '&$ #'$%$8#/ $& &+#($%@# .=H* 9&8%/=H .=H ='/ >I$9

 @&'$9 .=H .G()G='$ $& $9# .(&+%)%&') &: $9#

[email protected]#@#'$%'? -G8#) ='/ -#?G8=$%&') GN//H &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#, 0=+%/ .&%'$#/ &G$ $9=$ Z=<=)%&a K>L G)G=88H

)$=($) 9%) ;&(\ =$ >DaDD .,@, ='/ #'/) =$ BaDD =,@, &: $9# :&88&;%'? /=H &( #=(8%#(* /#.#'/%'? &' $9#

+&8G@# &: $9# /#8%+#(#/ 9&?)[ KBL (#<#%+#/ $9# :%_#/ =@&G'$ &: "EDD,DD .#( #'?=?#@#'$* (#?=(/8#)) &: $9#

=<$G=8 'G@A#( &: 9&G() $9=$ 9# ).#'$ <9&..%'? $9# /#8%+#(#/ 9&?)[ ='/ KIL ;=) '&$ #'?=?#/ $& (#.&($ :&(

;&(\ ='/* =<<&(/%'?8H* /%/ '&$ (#<#%+# ='H :## ;9#' '& 9&?) ;#(# /#8%+#(#/,

Z=<=)%& /%).G$#/ 0=+%/W) =88#?=$%&'),>>

  d# =(?G#/ $9=$* 9&,0)@ 0=+%/ /%/ '&$ )$=($ 9%) AG)%'#)) &'8H %'

BDDR, d# .&%'$#/ $& $9# 2#($%:%<=$# &: [email protected]&H@#'$>B

 $9=$ 0=+%/ %))G#/ %' 9%) :=+&( ;9%<9 .8=<#/ $9# /=$#

&: 9%) #@.8&H@#'$* =8A#%$ #((&'#&G)8H* %' F='G=(H BDDD, C(;*+1@ 9# (#.&($#/ :&( ;&(\ #+#(H /=H ;9%<9 $9#

.=H(&88 &( $%@# (#<&(/ <&G8/ 9=+# #=)%8H .(&+#/ 9=/ 0=+%/ )GA@%$$#/ $9#@ %' #+%/#'<#,

-#:G$%'? Z=<=)%&W) )GA@%))%&')*>I

 0=+%/ <8=%@) $9=$ Z=<=)%& ;=) '&$ 9%) #@.8&H## =) 9# 9%(#/ $9# 8=$$#(

&' t $5><5#O  &( $=)\ A=)%), d# =8)& <8=%@#/ $9=$ 9# %))G#/ $9# 2#($%:%<=$# &: [email protected]&H@#'$* G.&' Z=<=)%&W)

(#]G#)$* &'8H :&( &+#()#=) #@.8&H@#'$ .G(.&)#), d# .&%'$#/ $& $9# t'&+5I0545+I C&+64$55+I

C575<05< *u>S

 #_#<G$#/ AH "(#)A%$#(& 4&8='& ='/ 29(%)$&.9#( KJ'$&'%& Z=<=)%&W) <&MAG$<9#()L* $&<&((&A&(=$# 9%) <8=%@),

3' $9# J.(%8 ID* BDDC /#<%)%&'*>R

 $9# UJ /%)@%))#/ Z=<=)%&W) <&@.8=%'$ :&( 8=<\ &: @#(%$, Q9# UJ ?=+#

Page 46: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 46/108

<(#/#'<# $& 0=+%/W) <8=%@ $9=$ 9# #'?=?#/ Z=<=)%& &' t $5><5# u &( $=)\ A=)%), Q9# UJ '&$#/ $9# :&88&;%'?

:=<$) $& )G..&($ $9%) :%'/%'?a K>L Z=<=)%& (#<#%+#/ $9# :%_#/ =@&G'$ &: "EDD,DD :&( #+#(H ;&(\ /&'#*

(#?=(/8#)) &: $9# 'G@A#( &: 9&G() $9=$ 9# ).#'$ %' <&@.8#$%'? $9# $=)\ ='/ &: $9# +&8G@# &( 'G@A#( &:

9&?) $9=$ 9# 9=/ $& <9&. .#( #'?=?#@#'$[ KBL Z=<=)%& G)G=88H ;&(\#/ :&( &'8H :&G( 9&G()* A#?%''%'? :(&@

>DaDD .,@, G. $& BaDD =,@, &: $9# :&88&;%'? /=H[ ='/ KIL $9# "EDD,DD :%_#/ ;=?# :=( #_<##/) $9# $9#'

.(#+=%8%'? /=%8H @%'%@G@ ;=?# &: "IPB,DD, Q9# UJ =//#/ $9=$ $9# '=$G(# &: 0=+%/W) AG)%'#)) =) 9&? /#=8#(

)G..&($) $9%) t $5><5#O  &( $=)\ A=)%) =((='?#@#'$,

Q9# UJ <&'<8G/#/ $9=$ =) Z=<=)%& ;=) #'?=?#/ &' t $5><5# u &( $=)\ A=)%)* 9# %) '&$ #'$%$8#/ $& &+#($%@#*

9&8%/=H* 43U ='/ >I$9

 @&'$9 .=H,

T>& PKJ$V- J.4,*; 

3' %$) Z=H BT* BD>D /#<%)%&'*>T

 $9# 6U-2 =::%(@#/ $9# UJ (G8%'?,>E

 Q9# 6U-2 &A)#(+#/ $9=$ 0=+%/ /%/ '&$

(#]G%(# Z=<=)%& $& &A)#(+# =' #%?9$M9&G( ;&(\ )<9#/G8# $& #=(' $9# :%_#/ "EDD,DD ;=?#[ ='/ $9=$ Z=<=)%&

9=/ A##' .#(:&(@%'? = '&'M$%@# ;&(\* .&%'$%'? &G$ $9=$ Z=<=)%& ;=) .=%/ = :%_#/ =@&G'$ :&( $9#

<&@.8#$%&' &: $9# =))%?'#/ $=)\* %((#).#<$%+# &: $9# $%@# <&')G@#/ %' %$) .#(:&(@='<#, 4%'<# Z=<=)%& ;=)

.=%/ AH (#)G8$ ='/ '&$ %' $#(@) &: $9# $%@# $9=$ 9# ).#'$ %' $9# ;&(\.8=<#* Z=<=)%& %) '&$ <&+#(#/ AH $9#U=A&( 4$='/=(/) 8=;) &' &+#($%@#* 43U ='/ 9&8%/=H .=H* ='/ >I

$9 @&'$9 .=H G'/#( $9# -G8#) ='/

-#?G8=$%&') [email protected]#@#'$%'? $9# >I$9 @&'$9 .=H 8=;,>P

 

Z=<=)%& @&+#/ :&( (#<&')%/#(=$%&'>C

 AG$ $9# 6U-2 /#'%#/ 9%) @&$%&' %' %$) JG?G)$ >>* BD>D

(#)&8G$%&'*BD

 .(&@.$%'? Z=<=)%& $& #8#+=$# 9%) <=)# $& $9# 2J -&5 = .#$%$%&' :&( ;(,)&*,5,& ,B>

 

T>& $9V- J.4,*; 

3' %$) 6&+#@A#( BB* BD>D /#<%)%&'*BB

 $9# 2J .=($8H ?(='$#/ Z=<=)%&W) ;(,)&*,5,& .#$%$%&' ='/ (#+#()#/ $9#

6U-2W) (G8%'? :&( 9=+%'? A##' (#'/#(#/ ;%$9 ?(=+# =AG)# &: /%)<(#$%&',

79%8# $9# 2J =?(##/ ;%$9 $9# UJ ='/ $9# 6U-2 $9=$ Z=<=)%& ;=) = $=)\ A=)%) #@.8&H##* %$ '#+#($9#8#))

:&G'/ Z=<=)%& #'$%$8#/ $& 9%) @&'#$=(H <8=%@) :&88&;%'? $9# /&<$(%'# 8=%/ /&;' %'C(,,5+* -. C(-(,&+*

C5+)*0 P,5+0&).BI

 Q9# 2J #_.8=%'#/ $9=$ =) = $=)\ A=)%) #@.8&H##* Z=<=)%& %) #_<8G/#/ :(&@ $9# <&+#(=?# &:

9&8%/=H* 43U ='/ >I$9

 @&'$9 .=H *+7< &9  9# %) 8%\#;%)# = t:%#8/ .#()&''#8,u J) /#:%'#/ AH $9# U=A&( 2&/#* =

t:%#8/ .#()&''#8u %) &'# ;9& .#(:&(@) $9# ;&(\ =;=H :(&@ $9# &::%<# &( .8=<# &: ;&(\ ='/ ;9&)# (#?G8=(

;&(\ 9&G() <=''&$ A# /#$#(@%'#/ ;%$9 (#=)&'=A8# <#($=%'$H, 3' Z=<=)%&W) <=)#* $9# #8#@#'$) $9=$

<9=(=<$#(%^# = t:%#8/ .#()&''#8u =(# #+%/#'$8H 8=<\%'? =) 9# 9=/ A##' ;&(\%'? =) = AG$<9#( =$ 0=+%/W) tk%#8)

d&? 0#=8#(u AG)%'#)) %' 4$=, Z#)=* Z='%8= G'/#( 0=+%/W) )G.#(+%)%&' ='/ <&'$(&8* ='/ :&( = :%_#/ ;&(\%'?

)<9#/G8# $9=$ )$=($) =$ >DaDD .,@,

J<<&(/%'?8H* $9# 2J =;=(/#/ Z=<=)%&W) <8=%@ :&( 9&8%/=H* 43U ='/ >I$9

 @&'$9 .=H :&( $9(## H#=()* ;%$9 >Dm

=$$&('#HW) :##) &' $9# $&$=8 @&'#$=(H =;=(/, Q9# 2J* 9&;#+#(* /#'%#/ Z=<=)%&W) <8=%@ :&( @&(=8 ='/

#_#@.8=(H /=@=?#) :&( 8=<\ &: A=)%),

0=+%/ :%8#/ $9# .(#)#'$ .#$%$%&' =:$#( $9# 2J /#'%#/ 9%) @&$%&' :&( (#<&')%/#(=$%&'BS

 %' $9# 2JW) F='G=(H I>*

BD>> (#)&8G$%&',BR

 

Q9# "#$%$%&'

3' $9%) .#$%$%&'*BT 0=+%/ @=%'$=%') $9=$ Z=<=)%&W) #'?=?#@#'$ ;=) &' = t $5><5# u &( $=)\ A=)%), d#'<#* $9#8=$$#( %) #_<8G/#/ :(&@ $9# <&+#(=?# &: 9&8%/=H* 43U ='/ >I

$9 @&'$9 .=H,

0=+%/ (#%$#(=$#) 9%) )GA@%))%&') A#:&(# $9# 8&;#( $(%AG'=8)BE

 ='/ =//) $9=$ 9# '#+#( 9=/ ='H <&'$(&8 &+#(

Page 47: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 47/108

$9# @=''#( AH ;9%<9 Z=<=)%& .#(:&(@#/ 9%) ;&(\ ='/ 9# )%@.8H 8&&\#/ &' $& $9# t#'/M(#)G8$,u d# =8)&

<&'$#'/) $9=$ 9# '#+#( <&@.#88#/ Z=<=)%& $& (#.&($ :&( ;&(\ ='/ $9=$ G'/#( $9#%( =((='?#@#'$* Z=<=)%&

;=) =$ 8%A#($H $& <9&&)# ;9#$9#( $& (#.&($ :&( ;&(\ &( '&$ =) &$9#( AG$<9#() <&G8/ <=((H &G$ 9%) $=)\), d#

.&%'$) &G$ $9=$ 4&8='& ='/ J'$&'%& 9=/* %' :=<$* =$$#)$#/ $& $9#%( K0=+%/ ='/ Z=<=)%&W)L #)$=A8%)9#/

t $5><5#5+u =((='?#@#'$ $9=$ (#'/#(#/ = ;(%$$#' <&'$(=<$ G''#<#))=(H, 3' =) @G<9 =) Z=<=)%& %) = $=)\

A=)%) #@.8&H## f ;9& %) .=%/ $9# :%_#/ =@&G'$ &: "EDD,DD .#( #'?=?#@#'$ (#?=(/8#)) &: $9# $%@#

<&')G@#/ %' $9# .#(:&(@='<# f 0=+%/ =(?G#) $9=$ Z=<=)%& %) '&$ #'$%$8#/ $& $9# A#'#:%$) 9# <8=%@), J8)&*

9# .&)%$) $9=$ A#<=G)# 9# #'?=?#/ Z=<=)%& &' t $5><5# u &( $=)\ A=)%) $9#' '& #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H##(#8=$%&')9%. #_%)$) A#$;##' $9#@,

X%'=88H* 0=+%/ =(?G#) $9=$ :=<$G=8 :%'/%'?) &: $9# UJ* ;9#' =::%(@#/ AH $9# 6U-2* =$$=%' :%'=8%$H #).#<%=88H

;9#'* =) %' $9%) <=)#* $9#H =(# )G..&($#/ AH )GA)$='$%=8 #+%/#'<#, d#'<#* 0=+%/ .&)%$) $9=$ $9# 2J #((#/ %'

(#+#()%'? $9# 8=A&( $(%AG'=8)W :%'/%'?) ='/ ?(='$%'? $9# .(=H#/ @&'#$=(H <8=%@),

1BC /2FC UHI EBC &CFSH34C3E 

Z=<=)%& <&G'$#() $9=$ 9# ;=) '&$ = $=)\ A=)%) #@.8&H## &( = t:%#8/ .#()&''#8u =) 0=+%/ ;&G8/ 9=+# $9%)

2&G($ A#8%#+#,BP

 d# (#%$#(=$#) 9%) =(?G@#'$) A#:&(# $9# 8&;#( $(%AG'=8) ='/ =//) $9=$* <&'$(=(H $& 0=+%/W)

.&)%$%&'* $9# "EDD,DD :## $9=$ 9# ;=) .=%/ :&( #=<9 /=H $9=$ 9# (#.&($#/ :&( ;&(\ /&#) '&$ %'/%<=$# =

t $5><5# u &( $=)\ A=)%) #@.8&H@#'$ =) $9%) =@&G'$ ;=) .=%/ /=%8H* (#?=(/8#)) &: $9# 'G@A#( &( .%#<#) &:

9&?) $9=$ 9# 9=/ $& <9&., -=$9#(* %$ %'/%<=$#) = /=%8HM;=?# @#$9&/ &: .=H@#'$ ='/ =::%(@) 9%) (#?G8=(

#@.8&H@#'$ )$=$G), d# .&%'$) &G$ $9=$ 0=+%/ /%/ '&$ =88#?# &( .(#)#'$ ='H #+%/#'<# =) (#?=(/) $9# ]G&$=

&( 'G@A#( &: 9&?) $9=$ 9# 9=/ $& <9&. =) A=)%) :&( $9# t $5><5# u &( $=)\ A=)%) .=H@#'$[ '#%$9#( /%/ 0=+%/

.(#)#'$ $9# $%@# (#<&(/ &( .=H(&88 $& .(&+# $9=$ 9# ;&(\#/ :&( 8#)) $9=' #%?9$ 9&G() #=<9 /=H, Z&(#&+#(*

0=+%/ /%/ '&$ .(#)#'$ ='H <&'$(=<$ $& .(&+# $9=$ 9%) #@.8&H@#'$ ;=) &' $=)\ A=)%), J) 0=+%/ :=%8#/ $&

.(&+# $9# =88#?#/ $=)\ A=)%) &( t $5><5#5+u =?(##@#'$* Z=<=)%& <&'<8G/#) $9=$ 9# ;=) 0=+%/W) #@.8&H##,

"(&<#/G(=88H* Z=<=)%& .&%'$) &G$ $9=$ 0=+%/W) )GA@%))%&') %' $9# .(#)#'$ .#$%$%&' (=%)# .G(#8H :=<$G=8 %))G#)

$9=$ =(# '&$ .(&.#( :&( = .#$%$%&' :&( (#+%#; &' ;(,)&*,5,&.  Q9#)# %))G#) f ;9#$9#( 9# KZ=<=)%&L ;=) .=%/

AH (#)G8$ &( &' t $5><5# u A=)%)[ ;9#$9#( 9# ;=) = t:%#8/ .#()&''#8u[ ;9#$9#( =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H##

(#8=$%&')9%. #_%)$#/ A#$;##' 9%@ ='/ 0=+%/[ ='/ ;9#$9#( 0=+%/ #_#(<%)#/ <&'$(&8 ='/ )G.#(+%)%&' &+#( 9%)

;&(\ f =(# =88 :=<$G=8 %' '=$G(# ='/ =(#* $9#(#:&(#* .(&)<(%A#/ %' = -G8# SR .#$%$%&', d# =(?G#) $9=$ $9# 2JW)

:=<$G=8 :%'/%'?) A%'/ $9%) 2&G($* =A)#'$ = )9&;%'? $9=$ )G<9 :%'/%'?) =(# '&$ )G..&($#/ AH $9# #+%/#'<# &(

$9# 2JW) `G/?@#'$ ;=) A=)#/ &' = @%)=..(#9#')%&' &: :=<$), d# =//) $9=$ $9# %))G# &: ;9#$9#( ='

#@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. #_%)$#/ A#$;##' 9%@ ='/ 0=+%/ 9=/ =8(#=/H A##' )#$$8#/ AH $9# UJBC

 ='/

$9# 6U-2ID

 K=) ;#88 =) AH $9# 2J .#( Z=<=)%&W) @='%:#)$=$%&' A#:&(# $9%) 2&G($ /=$#/ 6&+#@A#( >R*

BD>BL*I> %' 9%) :=+&(* %' $9# )#.=(=$# %88#?=8 <=)# $9=$ 9# :%8#/ =?=%')$ 0=+%/,

Q9# 3))G#

Q9# %))G# (#+&8+#) =(&G'/ $9# .(&.#( =..8%<=$%&' ='/ %'$#(.(#$=$%&' &: $9# 8=A&( 8=; .(&+%)%&') &' 9&8%/=H*

43U ='/ >I$9

 @&'$9 .=H $& = ;&(\#( #'?=?#/ &' t $5><5# u &( $=)\ A=)%), 3' $9# <&'$#_$ &: $9# -G8# TR

.#$%$%&' A#:&(# $9# 2J* $9# %))G# %) ;9#$9#( $9# 2J <&((#<$8H :&G'/ $9# 6U-2 %' ?(=+# =AG)# &: /%)<(#$%&' %'

(G8%'? $9=$ Z=<=)%& %) #'$%$8#/ $& $9#)# 8=A&( )$='/=(/) A#'#:%$),

1BC /HKIE@F &KLJ3M 

7# S2IEJ2LLQ MI23E $9# .#$%$%&',

C'&4,(,*)'5 /0*-,2&')+,0*-# +>&

N0*+05) '.4,*; )*2 +>& <)/+.)4G

,--.&G=)' '.4& 

Page 48: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 48/108

3' $9%) -G8# SR .#$%$%&' :&( (#+%#; &' ;(,)&*,5,&  &: $9# 2JW) /#<%)%&' (#'/#(#/ G'/#( = -G8# TR .(&<##/%'?*

$9%) 2&G($W) .&;#( &: (#+%#; %) 8%@%$#/ $& (#)&8+%'? @=$$#() .#($=%'%'? $& ='H .#(<#%+#/ 8#?=8 #((&() $9=$ $9#

2J @=H 9=+# <&@@%$$#/ %' %))G%'? $9# =))=%8#/ /#<%)%&', Q9%) %) %' <&'$(=)$ ;%$9 $9# (#+%#; :&( `G(%)/%<$%&'=8

#((&()* ;9%<9 ;# G'/#($=\# %' =' &(%?%'=8 ;(,)&*,5,& =<$%&', 3' (#+%#;%'? $9# 8#?=8 <&((#<$'#)) &: $9# 2J

/#<%)%&'* ;# #_=@%'# $9# 2J /#<%)%&' A=)#/ &' 9&; %$ /#$#(@%'#/ $9# .(#)#'<# &( =A)#'<# &: ?(=+# =AG)#

&: /%)<(#$%&' %' $9# 6U-2 /#<%)%&' A#:&(# %$ ='/ '&$ &' $9# A=)%) &: ;9#$9#( $9# 6U-2 /#<%)%&' &' $9#

@#(%$) &: $9# <=)# ;=) <&((#<$,IB

  3' &$9#( ;&(/)* ;# 9=+# $& A# \##'8H =;=(# $9=$ $9# 2J G'/#($&&\ = -G8#

TR (#+%#;* '&$ = (#+%#; &' =..#=8* &: $9# 6U-2 /#<%)%&' <9=88#'?#/ A#:&(# %$,II

 

Z&(#&+#(* $9# 2&G($W) .&;#( %' = -G8# SR .#$%$%&' 8%@%$) G) $& = (#+%#; &: ]G#)$%&') &: 8=; (=%)#/ =?=%')$

$9# =))=%8#/ 2J /#<%)%&',IS

 

3' $9%) .#$%$%&'* 0=+%/ #))#'$%=88H =)\) $9# ]G#)$%&' f ;9#$9#( Z=<=)%& %) #'$%$8#/ $& 9&8%/=H* 43U ='/

>I$9

 @&'$9 .=H, Q9%) &'# %) = ]G#)$%&' &: 8=;, Q9# /#$#(@%'=$%&' &: $9%) ]G#)$%&' &: 8=; 9&;#+#( %)

%'$#($;%'#/ ;%$9 $9# 8=(?#8H :=<$G=8 %))G# &: ;9#$9#( Z=<=)%& :=88) ;%$9%' $9# (G8# &' #'$%$8#@#'$ $& $9#)#

<8=%@) &( ;%$9%' $9# #_<#.$%&', 3' #%$9#( <=)#* $9# (#)&8G$%&' &: $9%) :=<$G=8 %))G# .(#)G..&)#) ='&$9#(

:=<$G=8 @=$$#(* $9=$ %)* $9# .(#)#'<# &: =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. A#$;##' 0=+%/ ='/ Z=<=)%&,

3' %')%)$%'? A#:&(# $9%) 2&G($ $9=$ Z=<=)%& ;=) '&$ 9%) #@.8&H##* 0=+%/ =(?G#) $9=$ 9# #'?=?#/ $9# 8=$$#(

&' t $5><5# u &( $=)\ A=)%), V#(H '&$%<#=A8H* 0=+%/ <&':G)#) #'?=?#@#'$ &' t $5><5# u &( $=)\ A=)%) ;%$9

$9# 8=<\ &: #@.8&H@#'$ (#8=$%&')9%., [email protected]%#/8H* 0=+%/ =))#($) $9=$ $9#%( t $5><5#5+u &( $=)\ A=)%)

=((='?#@#'$ '#?=$#) $9# #_%)$#'<# &: #@.8&H@#'$ (#8=$%&')9%.,

J$ $9# &G$)#$* ;# (#`#<$ $9%) =))#($%&' &: $9# .#$%$%&'#(, 1'?=?#@#'$ &' t $5><5# u &( $=)\ A=)%) /&#) '&$

<9=(=<$#(%^# $9# (#8=$%&')9%. $9=$ @=H #_%)$ A#$;##' $9# .=($%#)* &.(.@ ;9#$9#( &'# &: #@.8&H@#'$ &(

%'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&()9%., J($%<8# CEKTL &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# /#:%'#) ;=?#) =) t___ $9# ICRK3CI2EJH3 HI

C2I3J3MF* 9&;#+#( /#)%?'=$#/* <=.=A8# &: A#%'? #_.(#))#/ %' $#(@) &: @&'#H* VBCEBCI UJ^C4 HI

2FDCIE2J3C4 H3 2 EJRC5 E2FX5 SJCDC5 HI DHRRJFFJH3 G2FJF5 HI HEBCI RCEBH4 HU D2LDKL2EJ3M EBC F2RC* ;9%<9%) S2Q2GLC GQ 23 CRSLHQCI EH 23 CRSLHQCCG'/#( = ;(%$$#' &( G';(%$$#' <&'$(=<$ &: #@.8&H@#'$ :&( ;&(\

/&'# &( $& A# /&'#* &( :&( )#(+%<#) (#'/#(#/ &( $& A# (#'/#(#/h,iuIR

  3' (#8=$%&' $& J($%<8# CEKTL* J($%<8#

>D>IT

 &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# ).#=\) &: ;&(\#() .=%/ AH (#)G8$) &( $9&)# ;9&)# .=H %) <=8<G8=$#/ %' $#(@) &: $9#

]G='$%$H &( ]G=8%$H &: $9#%( ;&(\ &G$.G$ ;9%<9 %'<8G/#) t $5><5# u ;&(\ ='/ &$9#( '&'M$%@# ;&(\,

Z&(# %@.&($='$8H* AH %@.8%<%$8H =(?G%'? $9=$ 9%) #'?=?#@#'$ &: Z=<=)%& &' t $5><5# u &( $=)\ A=)%) '#?=$#)

#@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%.* 0=+%/ ;&G8/ ;='$ $9# 2&G($ $& #'?=?# &' = :=<$G=8 =..#88=$# (#+%#; &:

$9# #'$%(# <=)# $& /#$#(@%'# $9# .(#)#'<# &( #_%)$#'<# &: $9=$ (#8=$%&')9%., Q9%) =..(&=<9 9&;#+#( %) '&$

=G$9&(%^#/ G'/#( = -G8# SR .#$%$%&' :&( (#+%#; &: $9# 2J /#<%)%&' (#'/#(#/ G'/#( = -G8# TR .(&<##/%'?,

B&,0) * $9# UJ ='/ $9# 6U-2 /#'%#/ Z=<=)%&W) <8=%@ +*)  A#<=G)# &: $9# =A)#'<# &: =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H##

AG$ A#<=G)# &: %$) :%'/%'? $9=$ )%'<# Z=<=)%& %) .=%/ &' $5><5#  &( $=)\ A=)%)* $9#' 9# %) '&$ #'$%$8#/ $& 43U*

9&8%/=H ='/ >I$9

 @&'$9 .=H, C(;*+1 * ;# <&')%/#( %$ <(G<%=8* $9=$ %' $9# )#.=(=$# %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8 <=)#

Z=<=)%& :%8#/ ;%$9 $9# UJ* $9# UJ* $9# 6U-2 ='/ $9# 2J G'%:&(@8H :&G'/ $9# #_%)$#'<# &: =' #@.8&H#(M

#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%.,IE

 

3' &$9#( ;&(/)* =)%/# :(&@ A#%'? :=<$G=8 %' '=$G(#* $9# #_%)$#'<# &: =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. %)

%' :=<$ = '&'M%))G# %' $9%) <=)#, Q& (#%$#(=$#* %' /#<%/%'? = -G8# SR .#$%$%&' :&( (#+%#; &: = 8=A&( /#<%)%&'

(#'/#(#/ AH $9# 2J G'/#( TR* $9# '=((&; )<&.# &: %']G%(H %) ;9#$9#( $9# 2J <&((#<$8H /#$#(@%'#/ $9#

.(#)#'<# &( =A)#'<# &: ?(=+# =AG)# &: /%)<(#$%&' &' $9# .=($ &: $9# 6U-2, 3' <&'<(#$# ]G#)$%&' :&(@* t/%/

$9# 6U-2 ?(=+#8H =AG)# %$) /%)<(#$%&' %' /#'H%'? Z=<=)%&W) <8=%@) )%@.8H A#<=G)# 9# %) .=%/ &' = '&'M$%@#

A=)%)su

J$ ='H (=$#* #+#' %: ;# %'/G8?# $9# .#$%$%&'#(* ;# :%'/ 9%) <8=%@ $9=$ '& #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%.

Page 49: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 49/108

#_%)$) A=)#8#)), [email protected]&H%'? $9# <&'$(&8 $#)$*IP

 ;# :%'/ $9=$ )G<9 = (#8=$%&')9%. #_%)$ %' $9# .(#)#'$ <=)#,

31&* ) <)/+.)4 '&1,&E ->0E- +>)+

N)/)-,0 ,- F)1,2V- &(%405&& 

Q& /#$#(@%'# $9# #_%)$#'<# &: =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%.* :&G( #8#@#'$) ?#'#(=88H '##/ $& A#

<&')%/#(#/* '=@#8Ha K>L $9# )#8#<$%&' ='/ #'?=?#@#'$ &: $9# #@.8&H##[ KBL $9# .=H@#'$ &: ;=?#)[ KIL $9#

.&;#( &: /%)@%))=8[ ='/ KSL $9# .&;#( $& <&'$(&8 $9# #@.8&H##W) <&'/G<$, Q9#)# #8#@#'$) &( %'/%<=$&()<&@.(%)# $9# )&M<=88#/ t:&G(M:&8/u $#)$ &: #@.8&H@#'$ (#8=$%&')9%., Z=<=)%&W) (#8=$%&')9%. ;%$9 0=+%/

)=$%):%#) $9%) $#)$,

B&,0) * 0=+%/ #'?=?#/ $9# )#(+%<#) &: Z=<=)%&* $9G) )=$%):H%'? $9# #8#@#'$ &: t)#8#<$%&' ='/ #'?=?#@#'$ &:

$9# #@.8&H##,u 0=+%/ <=$#?&(%<=88H <&':%(@#/ $9%) :=<$ ;9#'* %' 9%) tC&+64$55+I C575<05<@u 9# )$=$#/ $9=$

t'=? =..8H .& )%H= )= =\%' =$ \%'G9= \& )%H= '= <9&..#(h,iuIC

  J8)&* 4&8='& ='/ J'$&'%& )$=$#/ %' $9#%(

t'&+5I0545+I C&+64$55+I C575<05< uSD

$9=$ th\i=@% .& =H '=?$(=$(=A=9& )= k%#8) ___ '= .=?M==(% '% J(%#8

0=+%/ A%8='? AG$<9#(u ='/ t\%8=8= '=@%' )% ___ Z=<=)%& '= %)= (%'? AG$<9#( ___ '% ___ 0=+%/ =$ \=)=@= '=@%'

)%H= )= =@%'? $(=A=9&,u

4#<&'/* 0=+%/ .=%/ Z=<=)%&W) ;=?#), O&$9 0=+%/ ='/ Z=<=)%& <=$#?&(%<=88H )$=$#/ %' $9#%( (#).#<$%+#

.8#=/%'?) A#:&(# $9# 8&;#( $(%AG'=8) ='/ #+#' A#:&(# $9%) 2&G($ $9=$ $9# :&(@#( 9=/ A##' .=H%'? $9# 8=$$#(

"EDD,DD #=<9 /=H =:$#( $9# 8=$$#( 9=/ :%'%)9#/ $9# /=HW) $=)\, 4&8='& ='/ J'$&'%& =8)& <&':%(@#/ $9%) :=<$

&: ;=?# .=H@#'$ %' $9#%( t'&+5I0545+I C&+64$55+I C575<05<.uS>

 Q9%) )=$%):%#) $9# #8#@#'$ &: t.=H@#'$

&: ;=?#),u

P%&,1 * 0=+%/ 9=/ A##' )#$$%'? $9# /=H ='/ $%@# ;9#' Z=<=)%& )9&G8/ (#.&($ :&( ;&(\, Q9%) .&;#( $&

/#$#(@%'# $9# ;&(\ )<9#/G8# &A+%&G)8H %@.8%#) .&;#( &: <&'$(&8, OH 9=+%'? $9# .&;#( $& <&'$(&8

Z=<=)%&W) ;&(\ )<9#/G8#* 0=+%/ <&G8/ (#?G8=$# Z=<=)%&W) ;&(\ ='/ <&G8/ #+#' (#:G)# $& ?%+# 9%@ ='H

=))%?'@#'$* $9#(#AH #::#<$%+#8H /%)@%))%'? 9%@,

J'/ 9*6,)%* 0=+%/ 9=/ $9# (%?9$ ='/ .&;#( $& <&'$(&8 ='/ )G.#(+%)# Z=<=)%&W) ;&(\ =) $& $9# @#=') ='/

@#$9&/) &: .#(:&(@%'? %$, 3' =//%$%&' $& )#$$%'? $9# /=H ='/ $%@# ;9#' Z=<=)%& )9&G8/ (#.&($ :&( ;&(\*

$9# #)$=A8%)9#/ :=<$) )9&; $9=$ 0=+%/ (#'$) $9# .8=<# ;9#(# Z=<=)%& 9=/ A##' .#(:&(@%'? 9%) $=)\),

Z&(#&+#(* Z=<=)%& ;&G8/ 8#=+# $9# ;&(\.8=<# &'8H =:$#( 9# 9=/ :%'%)9#/ <9&..%'? =88 &: $9# 9&? @#=$)

?%+#' $& 9%@ :&( $9# /=HW) $=)\, J8)&* 0=+%/ ;&G8/ )$%88 #'?=?# Z=<=)%&W) )#(+%<#) ='/ 9=+# 9%@ (#.&($ :&(

;&(\ #+#' /G(%'? $9# /=H) ;9#' &'8H :#; 9&?) ;#(# /#8%+#(#/ :&( AG$<9#(%'?,

Y'/#( $9%) &+#(=88 )#$G.* =88 $9&)# ;&(\%'? :&( 0=+%/* %'<8G/%'? Z=<=)%&* <&G8/ '=$G(=88H A# #_.#<$#/ $&

&A)#(+# <#($=%' (G8#) ='/ (#]G%(#@#'$) ='/ 0=+%/ ;&G8/ '#<#))=(%8H #_#(<%)# )&@# /#?(## &: <&'$(&8 =)

$9# <9&..%'? &: $9# 9&? @#=$) ;&G8/ A# )GA`#<$ $& 9%) ).#<%:%<=$%&'), J8)&* )%'<# Z=<=)%& .#(:&(@#/ 9%)

$=)\) =$ 0=+%/W) ;&(\.8=<#* 0=+%/ <&G8/ #=)%8H #_#(<%)# <&'$(&8 ='/ )G.#(+%)%&' &+#( $9#

:&(@#(, J<<&(/%'?8H* ;9#$9#( &( '&$ 0=+%/ =<$G=88H #_#(<%)#/ $9%) (%?9$ &( .&;#( $& <&'$(&8 %) A#)%/# $9#

.&%'$ =) $9# 8=; )%@.8H (#]G%(#) $9# #_%)$#'<# &: $9%) .&;#( $& <&'$(&8SBSI

 &(* =) %' $9%) <=)#* $9# #_%)$#'<#

&: $9# (%?9$ ='/ &..&($G'%$H $& <&'$(&8 ='/ )G.#(+%)# Z=<=)%&,SS

 

3' )G@* $9# $&$=8%$H &: $9# )G((&G'/%'? <%(<G@)$='<#) &: $9# .(#)#'$ <=)# )G::%<%#'$8H .&%'$) $& ='

#@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. #_%)$%'? A#$;##' 0=+%/ ='/ Z=<=)%&,

N)/)-,0 ,- &*;);&2 0* W%)@5)EX 0' +)-@ =)-,- 

J$ $9%) .&%'$* ;# '&$# $9=$ =88 $9(## $(%AG'=8) f $9# UJ* $9# 6U-2 ='/ $9# 2J f :&G'/ $9=$ Z=<=)%& ;=)

#'?=?#/ &( .=%/ &' t $5><5# u &( $=)\ A=)%), Q9%) :=<$G=8 :%'/%'? A%'/) $9# 2&G($ G'/#( $9# (G8# $9=$ :=<$G=8

:%'/%'?) &: 8=A&( $(%AG'=8) ;9#' )G..&($#/ AH $9# #)$=A8%)9#/ :=<$) ='/ %' =<<&(/ ;%$9 $9# 8=;)* #).#<%=88H

Page 50: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 50/108

;9#' =::%(@#/ AH $9# 2J* %) A%'/%'? &' $9%) 2&G($,

J /%)$%'?G%)9%'? <9=(=<$#(%)$%< &: t $5><5# u &( $=)\ A=)%) #'?=?#@#'$* =) &..&)#/ $& )$(=%?9$M9&G( ;=?#

.=H@#'$* %) $9# '&'M<&')%/#(=$%&' &: $9# $%@# ).#'$ %' ;&(\%'?, 3' = $=)\MA=)%) ;&(\* $9# #@.9=)%) %) &'

$9# $=)\ %$)#8:* %' $9# )#')# $9=$ .=H@#'$ %) (#<\&'#/ %' $#(@) &: <&@.8#$%&' &: $9# ;&(\* '&$ %' $#(@) &:

$9# 'G@A#( &: $%@# ).#'$ %' $9# <&@.8#$%&' &: ;&(\,SR

5'<# $9# ;&(\ &( $=)\ %) <&@.8#$#/* $9# ;&(\#(

(#<#%+#) = :%_#/ =@&G'$ =) ;=?#* ;%$9&G$ (#?=(/ $& $9# )$='/=(/ @#=)G(#@#'$) &: $%@# ?#'#(=88H G)#/ %'

.=H <&@.G$=$%&',

3' Z=<=)%&W) <=)#* $9# #)$=A8%)9#/ :=<$) )9&; $9=$ 9# ;&G8/ G)G=88H )$=($ 9%) ;&(\ =$ >DaDD

.,@, Q9#(#=:$#(* (#?=(/8#)) &: $9# $&$=8 9&G() $9=$ 9# ).#'$ =$ $9# ;&(\.8=<# &( &: $9# $&$=8 'G@A#( &: $9#

9&?) =))%?'#/ $& 9%@ :&( <9&..%'?* Z=<=)%& ;&G8/ (#<#%+# $9# :%_#/ =@&G'$ &: "EDD,DD &'<# 9# 9=/

<&@.8#$#/ 9%) $=)\, 28#=(8H* $9#)# <%(<G@)$='<#) )9&; = t $5><5# u &( $=)\ A=)%) #'?=?#@#'$ $9=$ =88 $9(##

$(%AG'=8) G'%:&(@8H :&G'/,

3' )G@* $9# #_%)$#'<# &: #@.8&H@#'$ (#8=$%&')9%. A#$;##' $9# .=($%#) %) /#$#(@%'#/ AH =..8H%'? $9# t:&G(M

:&8/u $#)$[ #'?=?#@#'$ &' t $5><5# u &( $=)\ A=)%) /&#) '&$ /#$#(@%'# $9# .=($%#)W (#8=$%&')9%. =) %$ %)

)%@.8H = @#$9&/ &: .=H <&@.G$=$%&', J<<&(/%'?8H* Z=<=)%& %) 0=+%/W) #@.8&H##* =8A#%$ #'?=?#/ &'t $5><5# u &( $=)\ A=)%),

J) =' #@.8&H## &: 0=+%/ .=%/ &' $5><5#  &( $=)\ A=)%)* ;# '&; ?& $& $9# <&(# %))G# &: ;9#$9#( Z=<=)%& %)

#'$%$8#/ $& 9&8%/=H* >I$9 @&'$9* ='/ 43U .=H,

O* +>& ,--.& 0< N)/)-,0V-

&*+,+4&(&*+ +0 >04,2)5A :7K

)*2 YZ+> (0*+> %)5  

Q9# UJ /%)@%))#/ Z=<=)%&W) <8=%@) .G()G='$ $& J($%<8# CS &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# %' (#8=$%&' $& 4#<$%&' >* -G8# 3V&: $9# 3-- &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#* ='/ J($%<8# CR &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#* =) ;#88 =) "(#)%/#'$%=8 0#<(## K"0L 6&,

PR>, Q9# 6U-2* &' $9# &$9#( 9='/* (#8%#/ &' J($%<8# PB &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# ='/ $9# -G8#) ='/ -#?G8=$%&')

[email protected]#@#'$%'? "0 6&, PR>, Y'%:&(@8H* $9#)# .(&+%)%&') #_#@.$ ;&(\#() .=%/ &' t $5><5# u &( $=)\ A=)%)

:(&@ $9# <&+#(=?# &: 9&8%/=H* 43U ='/ >I$9 @&'$9 .=H,

3' (#+#()%'? $9# 8=A&( $(%AG'=8)W (G8%'?)* $9# 2J )%@%8=(8H (#8%#/ &' $9#)# .(&+%)%&')* =) ;#88 =) &' 4#<$%&' >*

-G8# V &: $9# 3-- &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# ='/ $9# 2&G($W) (G8%'? %' C(,,5+* -. C(-(,&+* C5+)*0 P,5+0&) ,ST

  Q9#)#

8=A&( 8=; .(&+%)%&')* ;9#' (#=/ $&?#$9#( ;%$9 $9# 4#((='& (G8%'?* #_#@.$ $9&)# #'?=?#/ &' t $5><5# u &(

$=)\ A=)%) &'8H %: $9#H ]G=8%:H =) t:%#8/ .#()&''#8,u

3' &$9#( ;&(/)* ;9=$ ;# 9=+# A#:&(# G) %) 8=(?#8H = ]G#)$%&' &: 8=; (#?=(/%'? $9# <&((#<$ %'$#(.(#$=$%&' &:

$9#)# 8=A&( <&/# .(&+%)%&') ='/ $9# %@.8#@#'$%'? (G8#)[ =8$9&G?9* $& <&'<8G/# $9=$ $9# ;&(\#( %)

#_#@.$#/ &( <&+#(#/ /#.#'/) &' $9# :=<$) ='/ %' $9%) )#')#* %) = ]G#)$%&' &: :=<$a :%()$* ;9#$9#( Z=<=)%& %)

= t:%#8/ .#()&''#8u[ ='/ 0(;*+1 * ;9#$9#( $9&)# #'?=?#/ &' t $5><5# u &( $=)\ A=)%)* AG$ ;9& =(# '&$ t:%#8/

.#()&''#8*u =(# #_#@.$#/ :(&@ $9# <&+#(=?# &: 9&8%/=H* 43U ='/ >I$9 @&'$9 .=H,

Q& .G$ &G( /%)<G))%&' ;%$9%' $9# .#().#<$%+# &: = -G8# SR .#$%$%&' :&( (#+%#; &: = 2J /#<%)%&' (#'/#(#/

G'/#( -G8# TR ='/ :(=@#/ %' ]G#)$%&' :&(@* $9# 8#?=8 ]G#)$%&' %) ;9#$9#( $9# 2J <&((#<$8H (G8#/ $9=$ %$ ;=)

?(=+# =AG)# &: /%)<(#$%&' &' $9# .=($ &: $9# 6U-2 $& /#'H Z=<=)%&W) @&'#$=(H <8=%@) )%@.8H A#<=G)# 9# %)

.=%/ &' = '&'M$%@# A=)%) ;%$9&G$ /#$#(@%'%'? ;9#$9#( 9# %) = :%#8/ .#()&''#8 &( '&$,

Q& (#)&8+# $9#)# %))G#)* ;# '##/ $& (#M+%)%$ $9# .(&+%)%&') %'+&8+#/,

C'01,-,0*- ;01&'*,*; :7K )*2 >04,2)5 %)5  

Page 51: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 51/108

 

J($%<8# PB &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# .(&+%/#) $9# (Q;760&*+0 9,*4 )%( ;*-(,5I( &: Q%$8# 3* O&&\ 333 &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#

M .(&+%)%&') ?&+#('%'? ;&(\%'? <&'/%$%&') ='/ (#)$ .#(%&/),

J($, PB, 2&+#(=?#, o 1BC SIHTJFJH3F HU h1JELC #i FB2LL 2SSLQ $& #@.8&H##) %' =88 #)$=A8%)9@#'$) ='/

G'/#($=\%'?) ;9#$9#( :&( .(&:%$ &( '&$* GKE 3HE EH ?&+#('@#'$ #@.8&H##)* @='=?#(%=8 #@.8&H##)* UJCL4

SCIFH33CL* @#@A#() &: $9# :=@%8H &: $9# #@.8&H#( ;9& =(# /#.#'/#'$ &' 9%@ :&( )G..&($* /&@#)$%<

9#8.#()* .#()&') %' $9# .#()&'=8 )#(+%<# &: ='&$9#(* 234 VHIXCIF VBH 2IC S2J4 GQ ICFKLEF 2F 4CECIRJ3C4GQ EBC 'CDICE2IQ HU )2GHI J3 2SSIHSIJ2EC ICMKL2EJH3F< 

____

tB&(71 $(,0*++(7 u )9=88 (#:#( $& '&'M=?(%<G8$G(=8 #@.8&H##) ;9& (#?G8=(8H .#(:&(@ $9#%( /G$%#) =;=H :(&@

$9# .(%'<%.=8 .8=<# &: AG)%'#)) &( A(='<9 &::%<# &: $9# #@.8&H#( ='/ ;9&)# =<$G=8 9&G() &: ;&(\ %' $9# :%#8/

<=''&$ A# /#$#(@%'#/ ;%$9 (#=)&'=A8# <#($=%'$H, h#@.9=)#) ='/ G'/#()<&(#) &G()i

J@&'? $9# Q%$8# 3 .(&+%)%&') =(# $9# .(&+%)%&') &' 9&8%/=H .=H KG'/#( J($%<8# CS &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#L ='/ 43U

.=H KG'/#( J($%<8# CR &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#L, Y'/#( J($%<8# PB* t:%#8/ .#()&''#8u &' &'# 9='/ ='/ t;&(\#()

;9& =(# .=%/ AH (#)G8$)u &' $9# &$9#( 9='/* 5,( +*) ;*-(,(1 AH $9# Q%$8# 3 .(&+%)%&'), Q9# ;&(/%'?) &:

J($%<8# PB &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# =//%$%&'=88H <=$#?&(%^# ;&(\#() t.=%/ AH (#)G8$)u ='/ t:%#8/ .#()&''#8u =)

)#.=(=$# ='/ /%)$%'<$ $H.#) &: #@.8&H##) ;9& =(# #_#@.$#/ :(&@ $9# Q%$8# 3 .(&+%)%&') &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#,

Q9# .#($%'#'$ .&($%&' &: J($%<8# CS &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# ='/ %$) <&((#).&'/%'? .(&+%)%&' %' $9#

3--SE

 (#=/)a<9='(&A8#)+%($G=88=;8%A(=(H

J($, CS, -%?9$ $& 9&8%/=H .=H, K=L 1+#(H ;&(\#( )9=88 A# .=%/ 9%) (#?G8=( /=%8H ;=?# /G(%'? (#?G8=( 9&8%/=H)*

#_<#.$ %' (#$=%8 ='/ )#(+%<# #)$=A8%)9@#'$) (#?G8=(8H #@.8&H%'? 8#)) $9=' K>DL ;&(\#()h,i h#@.9=)%) &G()i

____

412Q356 >, 2&+#(=?#, f Q9%) -G8# )9=88 =..8H $& =88 #@.8&H##) #_<#.$a

____

K#L 6JCL4 SCIFH33CL 234 HEBCI CRSLHQCCF VBHFC EJRC 234 SCIUHIR23DC JF K3FKSCITJFC4 GQ EBC

CRSLHQCI ,*/4.2,*; EBHFC VBH 2IC C3M2MC4 H3 E2FX HI DH3EI2DE G2FJF* .G(#8H <&@@%))%&' A=)%)* &( $9&)#

;9& =(# .=%/ = :%_#/ =@&G'$ :&( .#(:&(@%'? ;&(\ %((#).#<$%+# &: $9# $%@# <&')G@#/ %' $9# .#(:&(@='<#

$9#(#&:, h#@.9=)#) &G()i

5' $9# &$9#( 9='/* J($%<8# CR &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# ='/ %$) <&((#).&'/%'? .(&+%)%&' %' $9# 3--SP

.#($%'#'$8H

.(&+%/#)a<9='(&A8#)+%($G=88=;8%A(=(H

J($, CR, -%?9$ $& )#(+%<# %'<#'$%+#, K=L 1+#(H #@.8&H## ;9& 9=) (#'/#(#/ =$ 8#=)$ &'# H#=( &: )#(+%<# )9=88

A# #'$%$8#/ $& = H#=(8H )#(+%<# %'<#'$%+# 8#=+# &: :%+# /=H) ;%$9 .=H,

KAL Q9%) .(&+%)%&' )9=88 '&$ =..8H $& $9&)# ;9& =(# =8(#=/H #'`&H%'? $9# A#'#:%$ 9#(#%' .(&+%/#/* $9&)#

#'`&H%'? +=<=$%&' 8#=+# ;%$9 .=H &: =$ 8#=)$ :%+# /=H) ='/ $9&)# #@.8&H#/ %' #)$=A8%)9@#'$) (#?G8=(8H

#@.8&H%'? 8#)) $9=' $#' #@.8&H##) &( %' #)$=A8%)9@#'$) #_#@.$#/ :(&@ ?(='$%'? $9%) A#'#:%$ AH $9#

4#<(#$=(H &: U=A&( ='/ [email protected]&H@#'$ =:$#( <&')%/#(%'? $9# +%=A%8%$H &( :%'='<%=8 <&'/%$%&' &: )G<9

#)$=A8%)9@#'$, h#@.9=)#) &G()i

____

Page 52: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 52/108

 

4#<$%&' >, 2&+#(=?#, f Q9%) (G8# )9=88 =..8H $& =88 #@.8&H##) #_<#.$a

____

K#L 6JCL4 SCIFH33CL 234 HEBCI CRSLHQCCF VBHFC SCIUHIR23DC JF K3FKSCITJFC4 GQ EBC

CRSLHQCI ,*/4.2,*; EBHFC VBH 2IC C3M2MC4 H3 E2FX HI DH3EI2DE G2FJF5 SKICLQ DHRRJFFJH3 G2FJF* &( $9&)#

;9& =(# .=%/ = :%_#/ =@&G'$ :&( .#(:&(@%'? ;&(\ %((#).#<$%+# &: $9# $%@# <&')G@#/ %' $9# .#(:&(@='<#$9#(#&:, h#@.9=)%) &G()i

Y'/#( $9#)# .(&+%)%&')* EBC MC3CI2L IKLC %) $9=$ 9&8%/=H ='/ 43U .=H .(&+%)%&') <&+#( =88 #@.8&H##), Q& A#

#_<8G/#/ :(&@ $9#%( <&+#(=?#* =' #@.8&H## @G)$ A# &'# &: $9&)# $9=$ $9#)# .(&+%)%&') #_.(#))8H #_#@.$*

)$(%<$8H %' =<<&(/='<# ;%$9 $9# #_#@.$%&',

Y'/#( $9# 3--* #_#@.$%&' :(&@ $9# <&+#(=?# &: 9&8%/=H ='/ 43U .=H (#:#( $& t:%#8/ .#()&''#8='/ &$9#(

#@.8&H##) ;9&)# $%@# ='/ .#(:&(@='<# %) G')G.#(+%)#/ AH $9# #@.8&H#( %'<8G/%'? $9&)# ;9& =(#

#'?=?#/ &' $=)\ &( <&'$(=<$ A=)%)h,iu 6&$# $9=$ .*4,@& 9'+,/4& [\ 0< +>& K)=0' $02&* $9# 3-- &' 9&8%/=H ='/

43U .=H /& '&$ #_<8G/# #@.8&H##) t#'?=?#/ &' $=)\ A=)%)u =) = )#.=(=$# ='/ /%)$%'<$ <=$#?&(H :(&@

#@.8&H##) <8=))%:%#/ =) t:%#8/ .#()&''#8,u -=$9#(* $9#)# #@.8&H##) =(# =8$&?#$9#( @#(?#/ %'$& &'#

<8=))%:%<=$%&' &: #_#@.$#/ #@.8&H##),

O#<=G)# &: $9%) /%::#(#'<#* %$ @=H A# =(?G#/ $9=$ $9# U=A&( 2&/# @=H A# %'$#(.(#$#/ $& @#=' $9=$ $9&)#

;9& =(# #'?=?#/ &' $=)\ A=)%)* .#( )#* =(# #_<8G/#/ :(&@ $9# 43U ='/ 9&8%/=H .=H@#'$ )%'<# $9%) %) ;9=$

$9# U=A&( 2&/# .(&+%)%&')* %' <&'$(=)$ ;%$9 $9# 3--* )$(&'?8H )G??#)$, Q9# =(?G=A8# %'$#(.(#$=$%&' &: $9%)

(G8# @=H A# <&'<#/#/ $& A# ;%$9%' $9# /%)<(#$%&' ?(='$#/ $& $9# UJ ='/ 6U-2 =) $9# ]G=)%M`G/%<%=8 A&/%#)

;%$9 #_.#($%)# &' 8=A&( @=$$#(),

d&;#+#(* =) #=(8H =) >CPE %' $9# <=)# &: F(=6 N+0)&)6)( *9 P(;%+*7*I< -. R$7(SC

 $9# .9(=)# t$9&)# ;9& =(#

#'?=?#/ &' $=)\ &( <&'$(=<$ A=)%)u %' $9# (G8# 9=) =8(#=/H A##' %'$#(.(#$#/ $& @#=' =)

:&88&;)a<9='(&A8#)+%($G=88=;8%A(=(H

h$9# .9(=)#i )9&G8/ 9&;#+#(* A# (#8=$#/ ;%$9 g 9&(71 $(,0*++(7 g =..8H%'? $9# (G8# &'(A601(4 I(+(,&0 $9=$

?#'#(=8 ='/ G'8%@%$#/ $#(@) =(# (#)$(=%'#/ ='/ 8%@%$#/ AH $9# .=($%<G8=( $#(@) $9=$ $9#H :&88&; ___ 28#=(8H*

.#$%$%&'#(l) $#=<9%'? .#()&''#8 <=''&$ A# /##@#/ :%#8/ .#()&''#8 ;9%<9 (#:#() g$& '&'M=?(%<G8$G(=8

#@.8&H##) ;9& (#?G8=(8H .#(:&(@ $9#%( /G$%#) =;=H :(&@ $9# .(%'<%.=8 .8=<# &: AG)%'#)) &( A(='<9 &::%<# &:

$9# #@.8&H#( ='/ ;9&)# =<$G=8 9&G() &: ;&(\ %' $9# :%#8/ <=''&$ A# /#$#(@%'#/ ;%$9 (#=)&'=A8# <#($=%'$H,

h"=(, I* J($%<8# PB* U=A&( 2&/# &: $9# "9%8%..%'#)i, "#$%$%&'#(l) <8=%@ $9=$ .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$) =(# '&$

#'$%$8#/ $& $9# )#(+%<# %'<#'$%+# 8#=+# A#'#:%$ <=''&$ $9#(#:&(# A# )G)$=%'#/,

3' )9&($* $9# .=H@#'$ &: =' #@.8&H## &' $=)\ &( $5><5#  A=)%) =8&'# %) %')G::%<%#'$ $& #_<8G/# &'# :(&@ $9#

<&+#(=?# &: 43U ='/ 9&8%/=H .=H, Q9#H =(# #_#@.$#/ :(&@ $9# <&+#(=?# &: Q%$8# 3 K%'<8G/%'? $9# 9&8%/=H ='/

43U .=HL &'8H %: $9#H ]G=8%:H =) t:%#8/ .#()&''#8,u Q9# 3-- $9#(#:&(# +=8%/8H ]G=8%:%#) ='/ 8%@%$) $9# ?#'#(=8

#_<8G)%&' &: t;&(\#() .=%/ AH (#)G8$)u :&G'/ %' J($%<8# PB :(&@ $9# <&+#(=?# &: 9&8%/=H ='/ 43U .=H, Q9%) %)

$9# &'8H (#=)&'=A8# %'$#(.(#$=$%&' )%'<# $9# /#$#(@%'=$%&' &: #_<8G/#/ ;&(\#() ;9& =(# .=%/ AH (#)G8$)

:(&@ $9# <&+#(=?# &: Q%$8# 3 %) t/#$#(@%'#/ AH $9# 4#<(#$=(H &: U=A&( %' =..(&.(%=$# (#?G8=$%&'),u

Q9# F(=6 N+0)&)6)( P(;%+*7*I<  (G8%'? ;=) (#%$#(=$#/ %' BDDR %' L6)* S60 P,5+0$*,) C<0)(40@ N+;.@ -.

S56)&0)5a<9='(&A8#)+%($G=88=;8%A(=(H

J <=(#:G8 .#(G)=8 &: )=%/ .(&+%)%&') &: 8=; ;%88 (#)G8$ %' $9# <&'<8G)%&' $9=$ $9# ?(='$ &: )#(+%<# %'<#'$%+#

8#=+# 9=) A##' /#8%@%$#/ AH $9# [email protected]#@#'$%'? -G8#) ='/ -#?G8=$%&') &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# $& =..8H &'8H $&

$9&)# #@.8&H##) '&$ #_.8%<%$8H #_<8G/#/ AH 4#<$%&' > &: -G8# V, J<<&(/%'? $& $9# [email protected]#@#'$%'? -G8#)*

4#(+%<# 3'<#'$%+# U#=+# )9=88 '&$ =..8H $& #@.8&H##) <8=))%:%#/ =) t:%#8/ .#()&''#8,u Q9# .9(=)# t&$9#(

Page 53: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 53/108

#@.8&H##) ;9&)# .#(:&(@='<# %) G')G.#(+%)#/ AH $9# #@.8&H#(u @G)$ '&$ A# G'/#()$&&/ =) = )#.=(=$#

<8=))%:%<=$%&' &: #@.8&H##) $& ;9%<9 )#(+%<# %'<#'$%+# 8#=+# )9=88 '&$ A# ?(='$#/, -=$9#(* %$ )#(+#) =) ='

[email protected]%:%<=$%&' &: $9# %'$#(.(#$=$%&' &: $9# /#:%'%$%&' &: :%#8/ .#()&''#8 G'/#( $9# U=A&( 2&/# =) $9&)#

t;9&)# =<$G=8 9&G() &: ;&(\ %' $9# :%#8/ <=''&$ A# /#$#(@%'#/ ;%$9 (#=)&'=A8# <#($=%'$H,u

Q9# )=@# %) $(G# ;%$9 (#).#<$ $& $9# .9(=)# t)%*0( #%* 5,( (+I5I(1 *+ )50> *, ;*+),5;) =50&0@ $6,(7<

;*44&00&*+ =50&0.u 4=%/ .9(=)# )9&G8/ A# (#8=$#/ ;%$9 t:%#8/ .#()&''#8*u =..8H%'? $9# (G8# &' (A601(4

I(+(,&0 $9=$ ?#'#(=8 ='/ G'8%@%$#/ $#(@) =(# (#)$(=%'#/ ='/ 8%@%$#/ AH $9# .=($%<G8=( $#(@) $9=$ $9#H:&88&;,

Q9# L6)*=60 (G8%'? ;=) %' $G(' $9# A=)%) &: C(,,5+* -. C5+)*0 P,5+0&) ;9%<9 $9# 2J <%$#/ %' )G..&($ &:

?(='$%'? Z=<=)%&W) .#$%$%&',

3' C(,,5+** $9# 2&G($* =..8H%'? $9# (G8# &' (A601(4 I(+(,&0RD

 /#<8=(#/ $9=$ fCRSLHQCCF C3M2MC4 H3 E2FX HI

DH3EI2DE G2FJF ^^^ 2IC 3HE 2KEHR2EJD2LLQ C^CRSEC4 UIHR EBC MI23E HU FCITJDC J3DC3EJTC LC2TC5 K3LCFF5 EBCQ

U2LL K34CI EBC DL2FFJUJD2EJH3 HU UJCL4 SCIFH33CL<gR>

  Q9# 2&G($ #_.8=%'#/ $9=$ $9# .9(=)# t&+;761&+I )%*0(

#%* 5,( (+I5I(1 *+ )50> *, ;*+),5;) =50&0@ $6,(7< ;*44&00&*+ =50& )u :&G'/ %' 4#<$%&' >K/L* -G8# V &: O&&\

333 &: $9# 3-- )9&G8/ '&$ A# G'/#()$&&/ =) = )#.=(=$# <8=))%:%<=$%&' &: #@.8&H##) $& ;9%<9 43U )9=88 '&$ A#?(='$#/, -=$9#(* =) ;%$9 %$) .(#<#/%'? .9(=)# M t&$9#( #@.8&H##) #%*0( $(,9*,45+;( &0 6+06$(,-&0(1 =<

)%( (4$7*<(, u M $9# .9(=)# t&+;761&+I )%*0( #%* 5,( (+I5I(1 *+ )50> *, ;*+),5;) =50&0u )#(+#) $& [email protected]%:H

$9# %'$#(.(#$=$%&' &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# /#:%'%$%&' &: t:%#8/ .#()&''#8u =) $9&)# t;9&)# =<$G=8 9&G() &: ;&(\

%' $9# :%#8/ <=''&$ A# /#$#(@%'#/ ;%$9 (#=)&'=A8# <#($=%'$H,u

3' <&'$(=)$ ='/ %' <8#=( /#.=($G(# :(&@ )#$$8#/ <=)# 8=;* $9# UJ ='/ $9# 6U-2 )$%88 %'$#(.(#$#/ $9# U=A&(

2&/# .(&+%)%&') ='/ $9# 3-- =) #_#@.$%'? =' #@.8&H## :(&@ $9# <&+#(=?# &: Q%$8# 3 &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#

A=)#/ )%@.8H ='/ )&8#8H &' $9# @&/# &: .=H@#'$ &: =' #@.8&H##, 1BC ")&/@F KEECI 4JFICM2I4 HU EBJF

DH3FJFEC3E ]KIJFSIK4C3EJ2L IKLJ3M JF 2 DLC2I 2DE HU MI2TC 2GKFC HU 4JFDICEJH3,RB

 3' &$9#( ;&(/)* AH /%)@%))%'?

Z=<=)%&W) <&@.8=%'$ ;%$9&G$ <&')%/#(%'? ;9#$9#( Z=<=)%& ;=) = t:%#8/ .#()&''#8u &( '&$* $9# ")&/SIHDCC4C4 G2FC4 H3 2 FJM3JUJD23ELQ J3DHRSLCEC DH3FJ4CI2EJH3 HU EBC D2FC, Q9%) =<$%&' <8#=(8H )@=<\) &:

?(=+# =AG)# &: /%)<(#$%&',

3*+,+4&(&*+ +0 >04,2)5 %)5  

1+%/#'$8H* $9# C(,,5+* (G8%'? ).#=\) &'8H &: 43U .=H, d&;#+#(* %: $9# UJ ='/ $9# 6U-2 9=/ &'8H $=\#'

<&G')#8 :(&@ 4#((='& ='/ #=(8%#( <=)#)* $9#H ;&G8/ 9=+# <&((#<$8H (#=<9#/ = )%@%8=( <&'<8G)%&' (#?=(/%'?

$9# .=H@#'$ &: 9&8%/=H .=H )%'<# $9# (G8# #_#@.$%'? t:%#8/ .#()&''#8u :(&@ $9# ?(='$ &: 9&8%/=H .=H %)

%/#'$%<=88H ;&(/#/ ;%$9 $9# (G8# #_#@.$%'? t:%#8/ .#()&''#8u :(&@ $9# ?(='$ &: 43U .=H, Q& A# <8#=(* $9#

.9(=)# t(4$7*<((0 (+I5I(1 *+ )50> *, ;*+),5;) =50&0u :&G'/ %' $9# 3-- &' A&$9 43U .=H ='/ 9&8%/=H .=H

)9&G8/ A# (#=/ $&?#$9#( ;%$9 $9# #_#@.$%&' &: t:%#8/ .#()&''#8,u

3' )9&($* %' /#$#(@%'%'? ;9#$9#( ;&(\#() #'?=?#/ &' t $5><5# u &( $=)\ A=)%)u %) #'$%$8#/ $& 9&8%/=H ='/ 43U

.=H* $9# .(#)#'<# K&( =A)#'<#L &: #@.8&H#( )G.#(+%)%&' =) (#?=(/) $9# ;&(\#(W) $%@# ='/ .#(:&(@='<# %)

$9# \#Ha %: $9# ;&(\#( %) )%@.8H #'?=?#/ &' $5><5#  &( $=)\ A=)%)* $9#' $9# MC3CI2L IKLC %) $9=$ 9# %) #'$%$8#/

$& = 9&8%/=H .=H ='/ 43U .=H G'8#)) #_#@.$#/ :(&@ $9# #_<#.$%&') ).#<%:%<=88H .(&+%/#/ G'/#( J($%<8# CS

K9&8%/=H .=HL ='/ J($%<8# CR K43U .=HL &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#, d&;#+#(* %: $9# ;&(\#( #'?=?#/ &' $5><5# &( $=)\

A=)%) =8)& :=88) ;%$9%' $9# @#='%'? &: t:%#8/ .#()&''#8u G'/#( $9# 8=;* $9#' 9# %) '&$ #'$%$8#/ $& $9#)#

@&'#$=(H A#'#:%$),

N)/)-,0 20&- *0+ <)44 .*2&' +>&

/4)--,<,/)+,0* 0< W<,&42 %&'-0**&4X

O=)#/ &' $9# /#:%'%$%&' &: :%#8/ .#()&''#8 G'/#( J($%<8# PB* ;# =?(## ;%$9 $9# 2J $9=$ Z=<=)%& /&#) '&$ :=88

Page 54: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 54/108

G'/#( $9# /#:%'%$%&' &: t:%#8/ .#()&''#8,u Q9# 2JW) :%'/%'? %' $9%) (#?=(/ %) )G..&($#/ AH $9# #)$=A8%)9#/

:=<$) &: $9%) <=)#a 9&,0) * Z=<=)%& (#?G8=(8H .#(:&(@#/ 9%) /G$%#) =$ 0=+%/W) .(%'<%.=8 .8=<# &:

AG)%'#))[ 0(;*+1 * 9%) =<$G=8 9&G() &: ;&(\ <&G8/ A# /#$#(@%'#/ ;%$9 (#=)&'=A8# <#($=%'$H[ ='/* )%&,1 * 0=+%/

)G.#(+%)#/ 9%) $%@# ='/ .#(:&(@='<# &: /G$%#), 4%'<# Z=<=)%& <=''&$ A# <&')%/#(#/ = t:%#8/ .#()&''#8*u

$9#' 9# %) '&$ #_#@.$#/ :(&@ $9# ?(='$ &: 9&8%/=H* 43U .=H #+#' =) 9# ;=) #'?=?#/ &' t $5><5# u &( $=)\

A=)%),

6&$ A#%'? = t:%#8/ .#()&''#8*u ;# :%'/ $9# 2J $& A# 8#?=88H <&((#<$ ;9#' %$ (#+#()#/ $9# 6U-2W) (G8%'?/%)@%))%'? Z=<=)%&W) <&@.8=%'$ :&( 9&8%/=H ='/ 43U .=H :&( 9=+%'? A##' (#'/#(#/ ;%$9 ?(=+# =AG)# &:

/%)<(#$%&',

3*+,+4&(&*+ +0 YZ+>

 (0*+> %)5  

7%$9 (#).#<$ $& $9# .=H@#'$ &: >I$9

 @&'$9 .=H 9&;#+#(* ;# :%'/ $9=$ $9# 2J 8#?=88H #((#/ %' :%'/%'? $9=$

$9# 6U-2 ?(=+#8H =AG)#/ %$) /%)<(#$%&' %' /#'H%'? $9%) A#'#:%$ $& Z=<=)%&,

Q9# ?&+#('%'? 8=; &' >I$9

 @&'$9 .=H %) "0 6&, PR>,RI

 J) ;%$9 9&8%/=H ='/ 43U .=H* >I$9

@&'$9 .=H A#'#:%$)

?#'#(=88H <&+#( =88 #@.8&H##)[ =' #@.8&H## @G)$ A# &'# &: $9&)# #_.(#))8H #'G@#(=$#/ $& A##_#@.$#/, 4#<$%&' I &: $9# -G8#) ='/ -#?G8=$%&') [email protected]#@#'$%'? ",0, 6&, PR>

RS #'G@#(=$#) $9#

#_#@.$%&') :(&@ $9# <&+#(=?# &: >I$9

 @&'$9 .=H A#'#:%$), Y'/#( 4#<$%&' IK#L* t#@.8&H#() &: $9&)# ;9&

=(# S2J4 H3 ^^^ E2FX G2FJF5 234 EBHFC VBH 2IC S2J4 2 UJ^C4 2RHK3E UHI SCIUHIRJ3M 2 FSCDJUJD VHIX5

JIICFSCDEJTC HU EBC EJRC DH3FKRC4 J3 EBC SCIUHIR23DC $9#(#&:uRR

 =(# #_#@.$#/,

6&$# $9=$ G'8%\# $9# 3-- &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# &' 9&8%/=H ='/ 43U .=H* 4#<$%&' IK#L &: $9# -G8#) ='/

-#?G8=$%&') [email protected]#@#'$%'? "0 6&, PR> #_#@.$) #@.8&H##) t.=%/ &' $=)\ A=)%)u ;%$9&G$ ='H (#:#(#'<# $&

t:%#8/ .#()&''#8,u Q9%) <&G8/ &'8H @#=' $9=$ %')&:=( =) .=H@#'$ &: $9# >I$9 @&'$9 .=H %) <&'<#('#/* $9#

8=; /%/ '&$ %'$#'/ $& ]G=8%:H $9# #_#@.$%&' :(&@ %$) <&+#(=?# ;%$9 $9# (#]G%(#@#'$ $9=$ $9# $=)\ ;&(\#(

A# = t:%#8/ .#()&''#8u =$ $9# )=@# $%@#,

=9%&%6+&%* %' 8%?9$ &: $9#)# <&')%/#(=$%&')* ;# 9#(#AH 0(&1#()): -&("1 $9# .#$%$%&' %')&:=( =) $9#

.=H@#'$ &: >I$9

 @&'$9 .=H $& (#).&'/#'$ %) <&'<#('#/, 3' =88 &$9#( =).#<$)* ;#(66#&. $9# /#<%)%&' /=$#/

6&+#@A#( BB* BD>D ='/ $9# (#)&8G$%&' /=$#/ F='G=(H I>* BD>> &: $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) %' 2JMN,-, 4" 6&,

>>TDDI,

'+ +&7%&%7< 

Page 55: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 55/108

 

/#1#,(">5 "< (<5 %&+,+,0*&'-A 1-" /+!&1 +6 (00%()' _1BJI4 7JTJFJH3a5 ("7 /#1#,("> #"1%-&(1%7

-!(&7' )(,+& ())#("/% _/#-)(a '%-(1!0('Y6'. )+/() /9(01%& "H< PceZ5 '&-%0*2&*+-<

7 % / # ' # + "

0(&7+5 ! <A

1BC /2FC 

Q9# <=)# A#:&(# $9# 2&G($ %) = .#$%$%&' :&( (#+%#; &' ;(,)&*,5,&  )##\%'? $& (#+#()# ='/ )#$ =)%/# $9#

/#<%)%&' &: $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8)h>i

 ='/ %$) (#)&8G$%&' /#'H%'? (#<&')%/#(=$%&'hBi

* (G8%'? $9=$ %$ %) $9# 8=A&(

$(%AG'=8* '&$ $9# (#?%&'=8 $(%=8 <&G($* $9=$9=) ̀ G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( $9# <&@.8=%'$ :&( %'`G'<$%&' ='/ /=@=?#)

:%8#/ AH .#$%$%&'#( ;%$9 $9# (#?%&'=8 $(%=8 <&G($,

1BC 62DEF 

3' >CPI* 2%$%A='\ ='/ 18 Q&(& 4#<G(%$H J?#'<H* 3'<, K9#(#=:$#( 18 Q&(&L #'$#(#/ %'$& = <&'$(=<$ :&( $9#

8=$$#( $& .(&+%/# )#<G(%$H ='/ .(&$#<$%+# )#(+%<#) $& )=:#?G=(/ ='/ .(&$#<$ $9# A='\l) .(#@%)#)* )%$G=$#/ =$

PES> "=)#& /# -&_=)* Z=\=$%* Z#$(& Z='%8=, Y'/#( $9# <&'$(=<$* 18 Q&(& &A8%?=$#/ %$)#8: $& .(&+%/# $9#

)#(+%<#) &: )#<G(%$H ?G=(/) $& )=:#?G=(/ ='/ .(&$#<$ $9# .(#@%)#) ='/ .(&.#($H &: 2%$%A='\ =?=%')$ $9#:$*

(&AA#(H &( ='H &$9#( G'8=;:G8 =<$) <&@@%$$#/ AH ='H .#()&' &( .#()&')* ='/ =))G@#/ (#).&')%A%8%$H :&(

8&))#) ='/e&( /=@=?#) $9=$ @=H A# %'<G((#/ AH 2%$%A='\ /G# $& &( =) = (#)G8$ &: $9# '#?8%?#'<# &: 18 Q&(&

&( ='H &: %$) =))%?'#/ .#()&''#8,I 

2%$%A='\ (#'#;#/ $9# )#<G(%$H <&'$(=<$ ;%$9 18 Q&(& H#=(8H G'$%8 >CCD, 5' J.(%8 BB* >CCD* $9# <&'$(=<$A#$;##' 2%$%A='\ ='/ 18 Q&(& #_.%(#/,

5' FG'# E* >CCD* (#).&'/#'$ 2%$%A='\ 3'$#?(=$#/ NG=(/) U=A&( J88%='<#M41NJMQY"J4eX4Z K9#(#=:$#(

23NUJL :%8#/ ;%$9 $9# 6=$%&'=8 2&'<%8%=$%&' ='/ Z#/%=$%&' O&=(/ K62ZOL = (#]G#)$ :&( .(#+#'$%+#

@#/%=$%&' <%$%'? 2%$%A='\ =) (#).&'/#'$ $9#(#%' ?%+%'? =) %))G#) :&( .(#+#'$%+# @#/%=$%&' $9# :&88&;%'?a

=L Y':=%( 8=A&( .(=<$%<#[

AL 0%)@%))=8 &: G'%&' &::%<#()e@#@A#()[ ='/

<L Y'%&' AG)$%'?,

5' FG'# >D* >CCD* .#$%$%&'#( 2%$%A='\ )#(+#/ &' 18 Q&(& = ;(%$$#' '&$%<# $9=$ $9# A='\ ;&G8/ '&$

(#'#; ='H@&(# $9# )#(+%<# =?(##@#'$ ;%$9 $9# 8=$$#(, 4%@G8$='#&G)8H* 2%$%A='\ 9%(#/ ='&$9#( )#<G(%$H=?#'<H* $9# N&8/#' "H(=@%/ 4#<G(%$H J?#'<H* $& (#'/#( )#<G(%$H )#(+%<#) =$ 2%$%A='\l) .(#@%)#),

5' $9# )=@# /=$#* FG'# >D* >CCD* (#).&'/#'$ 23NUJ :%8#/ = @='%:#)$=$%&' ;%$9 $9# 62ZO $9=$ %$ ;=)

<&'+#($%'? %$) (#]G#)$ :&( .(#+#'$%+# @#/%=$%&' %'$& = '&$%<# &: )$(%\# :&( :=%8G(# &: $9# .=($%#) $& (#=<9 =

@G$G=88H =<<#.$=A8# )#$$8#@#'$ &: $9# %))G#)* ;9%<9 %$ :&88&;#/ ;%$9 = )G..8#@#'$=8 '&$%<# &: )$(%\#

=88#?%'? =) )G..8#@#'$=8 %))G# $9# @=)) /%)@%))=8 &: =88 G'%&' &::%<#() ='/ @#@A#(),

5' FG'# >>* >CCD* )#<G(%$H ?G=(/) &: 18 Q&(& ;9& ;#(# (#.8=<#/ AH ?G=(/) &: $9# N&8/#' "H(=@%/

4#<G(%$H J?#'<H <&')%/#(#/ $9# '&'M(#'#;=8 &: 18 Q&(&l) )#(+%<# =?(##@#'$ ;%$9 2%$%A='\ =) <&')$%$G$%'? =

8&<\&G$ ='/e&( = @=)) /%)@%))=8, Q9#H $9(#=$#'#/ $& ?& &' )$(%\# =?=%')$ 2%$%A='\ ='/ .%<\#$ %$) .(#@%)#),

3' :=<$* )#<G(%$H ?G=(/) :&(@#(8H =))%?'#/ $& 2%$%A='\ G'/#( $9# #_.%(#/ =?(##@#'$ 8&%$#(#/ =(&G'/

='/ '#=( $9# 2%$%A='\ .(#@%)#) %' 8=(?# ?(&G.) &: :(&@ $;#'$H KBDL ='/ =$ $%@#) :%:$H KRDL .#()&'),

Page 56: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 56/108

5' FG'# >S* >CCD* (#).&'/#'$ 23NUJ :%8#/ = '&$%<# &: )$(%\# /%(#<$#/ =$ $9# .(#@%)#) &: $9# 2%$%A='\

@=%' &::%<#,

X=<#/ ;%$9 $9# .(&).#<$ &: /%)(G.$%&' &: %$) AG)%'#)) &.#(=$%&')* &' FG'# R* >CCD* .#$%$%&'#( 2%$%A='\

:%8#/ ;%$9 $9#-#?%&'=8 Q(%=8 2&G($* Z=\=$%* = <&@.8=%'$ :&( %'`G'<$%&' ='/ /=@=?#),S Q9# <&@.8=%'$ )&G?9$

$& #'`&%' 23NUJ ='/ ='H .#()&' <8=%@%'? @#@A#()9%. $9#(#%' :(&@ )$(%\%'? &( &$9#(;%)# /%)(G.$%'? $9#

&.#(=$%&') &: $9# A='\,

5' FG'# >P* >CCD* (#).&'/#'$ 23NUJ :%8#/ ;%$9 $9# $(%=8 <&G($ = @&$%&' $& /%)@%)) $9# <&@.8=%'$, Q9#@&$%&' =88#?#/ $9=$a

=L Q9# 2&G($ 9=/ '& `G(%)/%<$%&'* $9%) A#%'? 8=A&( /%).G$#,

AL Q9# ?G=(/) ;#(# #@.8&H##) &: $9# A='\,

<L Q9#(# ;#(# .#'/%'? <=)#)e8=A&( /%).G$#) A#$;##' $9# ?G=(/) ='/ $9# A='\ =$ $9# /%::#(#'$

=?#'<%#) &: $9# 0#.=($@#'$ &: U=A&( ='/ [email protected]&H@#'$ K05U1L,

/L Q9# A='\ ;=) ?G%8$H &: :&(G@ )9&..%'? %' :%8%'? $9# <&@.8=%'$ ;%$9 $9# -#?%&'=8 Q(%=8 2&G($

=:$#( )GA@%$$%'? %$)#8: +&8G'$=(%8H $& $9# `G(%)/%<$%&' &: $9# /%::#(#'$ =?#'<%#) &: $9# 05U1,

OH &(/#( /=$#/ JG?G)$ >C* >CCD* $9# $(%=8 <&G($ /#'%#/ (#).&'/#'$ 23NUJl) @&$%&' $& /%)@%)), Q9#

(#8#+='$ .&($%&' &: $9# &(/#( (#=/) =) :&88&;)ag"8=%'$%:: %' %$) 5..&)%$%&' =88#?#/ $9=$ `G(%)/%<$%&' &: $9# <&G($ %) /#$#(@%'#/ AH $9# =88#?=$%&') &:

$9# <&@.8=%'$),3' $9# .8=%'$%::l) <&@.8=%'$ $9#(# =(# =88#?=$%&')* ;9%<9 '#?=$# ='H #@.8&H#(M

#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. A#$;##' %$ ='/ $9# 23NUJ @#@A#()[ 9&;#+#( $9# 2&G($ <&G8/ '&$ /%)@%))

$9# <=)# ='/ 8%:$ $9# (#)$(=%'%'? &(/#( ;%$9&G$ :%()$ $9(#)9%'? &G$ $9# )=@# =$ $9# $(%=8 &: $9# <=)#,

Q9# 2&G($ :%'/%'? $9# ?(&G'/) =88#?#/ %' $9# /#:#'/='$l) @&$%&' ;#88 $=\#'* $9# @&$%&' %) 9#(#AH

/#'%#/,

45 5-01-10,g

3' /G# $%@#* (#).&'/#'$ 23NUJ :%8#/ ;%$9 $9# $(%=8 <&G($ = @&$%&' :&( (#<&')%/#(=$%&' &: $9# =A&+#M

@#'$%&'#/ &(/#(, 5' 5<$&A#( >* >CCD* $9# $(%=8 <&G($ /#'%#/ $9# @&$%&',

4GA)#]G#'$8H* (#).&'/#'$ 23NUJ :%8#/ ;%$9 $9# $(%=8 <&G($ %$) =');#( $& $9# <&@.8=%'$* ='/ =+#((#/ =)

).#<%=8 ='/ =::%(@=$%+# /#:#')# 8=<\ &: `G(%)/%<$%&' &: $9# <&G($ &+#( $9# )GA`#<$ @=$$#( &: $9#

<=)#, Q(#=$%'? $9# =+#(@#'$ =) @&$%&' $& /%)@%))* &' J.(%8 BE* >CC>* $9# 8&;#( <&G($ %))G#/ =' &(/#(

/#'H%'? $9# @&$%&', Q9# 8&;#( <&G($ )$=$#/a

gQ9# 2&G($ '&$#/ %' /#:#'/='$l) Z#@&(='/G@ &: JG$9&(%$%#) $9=$ $9#H @=/# '& @#'$%&' ;9&

=@&'? $9# .=($%#) M $9# .8=%'$%:: A='\ &( $9# /#:#'/='$) G'%&' M .=%/ $9#%( ;=?#) &( )=8=(%#) ='/

;9& 9=) $9# .&;#( $& /%)@%)) $9#@,

0#:#'/='$) =8)& =88#?#/ $9=$ $9# <&@.8=%'$ )$=$#) '& +=8%/ <=G)# &: =<$%&' =) .8=%'$%::l) =88#?=$%&')=(# .G(#8H ='<9&(#/ &' <&'`#<$G(#) ='/ <&'<8G)%&') ='/ '&$ A=)#/ &' G8$%@=$# :=<$),

"8=%'$%:: %' %$) 5..&)%$%&' =88#?#/ $9=$ %$ %) = ;#88M)#$$8#/ (G8#* $9=$ %' = @&$%&' $& /%)@%)) A=)#/ &'

$9# ?(&G'/ $9=$ $9# <&@.8=%'$ :=%8) $& )$=$# = <=G)# &: =<$%&'* $9# ]G#)$%&' )GA@%$$#/ $& $9# <&G($

:&( /#$#(@%'=$%&' %) $9# )G::%<%#'<H &: $9# =88#?=$%&' %' $9# <&@.8=%'$ %$)#8:, "8=%'$%:: =8)& =88#?#/

$9=$ $9# /#:#'/='$) /%).G$#/ $9# `G(%)/%<$%&' &: $9# <&G($* $9# .=($%#) 9=+%'? #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H##

(#8=$%&')9%.[ $9%) @#(# =88#?=$%&' /%/ '&$ )#(+# $& =G$&@=$%<=88H /#.(%+# $9# <&G($ &: %$)

 `G(%)/%<$%&' /G8H <&':#((#/ AH $9# =88#?=$%&') &: $9# <&@.8=%'$[ %' $9# &.%'%&' &: $9# /#:#'/='$)* =

8=A&( /%).G$# #_%)$)* $9# <&G($ %) /G$H A&G'/ $& :%'/ &G$ %: )G<9 <%(<G@)$='<#) (#=88H #_%)$,

Q9# 2&G($ ;#%?9%'? $9# #+%/#'<# ='/ `G(%).(G/#'<# %' )G..&($ &: $9# (#).#<$%+# <&'$#'$%&' &: $9#.=($%#)* ='/ :%'/%'? $9=$ %' $9# <=)# =$ A=(* .8=%'$%:: )##\) $& (#<&+#( .#<G'%=(H /=@=?#)* $9# 2&G($

?%+#) @&(# <(#/#'<# $& $9# /#<%)%&') <%$#/ AH $9# .8=%'$%::* 9#'<# $9# ).#<%=8 ='/ =::%(@=$%+#

/#:#')#) =88#?#/ %' $9# =');#( $(#=$#/ =) = lZ&$%&' $& 0%)@%))l %) 9#(#AH /#'%#/,g

Page 57: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 57/108

5' Z=H BS* >CC>* (#).&'/#'$ 23NUJ :%8#/ ;%$9 $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) = .#$%$%&' :&( <#($%&(=(% ;%$9

.(#8%@%'=(H %'`G'<$%&'R =))=%8%'? $9# +=8%/%$H &: $9# .(&<##/%'?) 9=/ A#:&(# $9# (#?%&'=8 $(%=8 <&G($,

J:$#( /G# .(&<##/%'?)* &' Z=(<9 I>* >CCB* $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) .(&@G8?=$#/ %$) /#<%)%&' %' 23NUJl)

:=+&(* $9# /%).&)%$%+# .&($%&' &: ;9%<9 )$=$#)a

g7d1-1X5-1* $9# 7(%$ &: 2#($%&(=(% %) N-J6Q10* ='/ $9# .(&<##/%'?) A#:&(# (#).&'/#'$ FG/?#

@&(# .=($%<G8=(8H $9# <9=88#'?#/ &(/#() =(# /#<8=(#/ 'G88 ='/ +&%/ ='/ (#).&'/#'$ FG/?# %)

#'`&%'#/ :(&@ $=\%'? ='H :G($9#( =<$%&' %' 2%+%8 2=)# 6&, CDM>T>B #_<#.$ :&( $9# .G(.&)# &:/%)@%))%'? %$, X&88&;%'?* 9&;#+#(* $9# /%).&)%$%&' %' 4=' Z%?G#8 2&(.&(=$%&' [email protected]&H##) Y'%&' +),

O#()=@%(=* $9# )$=$G) ]G& ='$# /#<8=(=$%&' &: )$(%\# )9=88 A# &A)#(+#/ .#'/%'? $9# .(&<##/%'?) %'

$9# 6=$%&'=8 2&'<%8%=$%&' ='/ Z#/%=$%&' O&=(/* 0#.=($@#'$ &: U=A&( ='/ [email protected]&H@#'$* 6=$%&'=8

2=.%$=8 -#?%&' KJ''#_ J &: "#$%$%&'L, 6& 2&)$),

45 5-01-10,g

5' J.(%8 BC* >CCB* .#$%$%&'#( 2%$%A='\ :%8#/ = @&$%&' :&( (#<&')%/#(=$%&' &: $9# /#<%)%&', 5' X#A(G=(H

>B* >CCI* $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) /#'%#/ $9# @&$%&'* :%'/%'? $9=$ $9# =(?G@#'$) %' $9# @&$%&'

:&( (#<&')%/#(=$%&' =(# AG$ = (#9=)9* %: '&$ = (#.#$%$%&'* &: $9# =(?G@#'$) %' %$) <&@@#'$)* ;9%<9 9=/ A##'

<&')%/#(#/ AH $9# 2&G($ %' %$) /#<%)%&',d#'<#* $9# .#$%$%&'#(l) (#<&G()# $& $9%) 2&G($,

1BC #FFKC 

Q9# A=)%< %))G# %'+&8+#/ %) ;9#$9#( %$ %) $9# 8=A&( $(%AG'=8 &( $9# (#?%&'=8 $(%=8 <&G($ $9=$ 9=)

 `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( $9# )GA`#<$ @=$$#( &: $9# <&@.8=%'$ :%8#/ AH 2%$%A='\ ;%$9 $9# $(%=8 <&G($,

0CEJEJH3CIjF 'KGRJFFJH3 

"#$%$%&'#( 2%$%A='\ <&'$#'/) $9=$ $9#(# %) '& #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. A#$;##' 2%$%A='\ ='/

$9# )#<G(%$H ?G=(/) (#.(#)#'$#/ AH (#).&'/#'$ 23NUJ ='/ $9=$ $9#(# %) '& g8=A&( /%).G$#g %' $9# )GA`#<$

<&'$(&+#()H, Q9# )#<G(%$H ?G=(/) ;#(# #@.8&H##) &: 18 Q&(& )#<G(%$H =?#'<H* '&$ &: 2%$%A='\, 3$) )#(+%<#

<&'$(=<$ ;%$9 2%$%A='\ 9=/ #_.%(#/ ='/ '&$ (#'#;#/,

1BC /HKIEjF &KLJ3M 

7# )G)$=%' $9# .#$%$%&'#(l) <&'$#'$%&', Q9%) 2&G($ 9=) 9#8/ %' @='H <=)#) $9=$ g%' /#$#(@%'%'? $9#

#_%)$#'<# &: =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%.* $9# :&88&;%'? #8#@#'$) =(# ?#'#(=88H <&')%/#(#/a >L $9#

)#8#<$%&' ='/ #'?=?#@#'$ &: $9# #@.8&H##[ BL $9# .=H@#'$ &: ;=?#)[ IL $9# .&;#( &: /%)@%))=8[ ='/ SL $9#

#@.8&H#(l) .&;#( $& <&'$(&8 $9# #@.8&H##

;%$9(#).#<$ $& $9# @#=') ='/ @#$9&/) AH ;9%<9 $9# ;&(\ %) $& A# =<<&@.8%)9#/g,T 3$ 9=) A##' /#<%/#/

=8)& $9=$ $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( 9=) '& `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( = <8=%@ :%8#/ ;9#(# '& #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%.

#_%)$#/ A#$;##' = <&@.='H ='/ $9# )#<G(%$H ?G=(/) =))%?'#/ $& %$ AH = )#<G(%$H )#(+%<# <&'$(=<$&(,E 3' $9%)

<=)#* %$ ;=) $9# )#<G(%$H =?#'<H 18 Q&(& $9=$ (#<(G%$#/* 9%(#/ ='/ =))%?'#/ $9# ;=$<9@#' $& $9#%( .8=<# &:

;&(\, 3$ ;=) $9# )#<G(%$H =?#'<H $9=$ ;=) =');#(=A8# $& 2%$%A='\ :&( $9# <&'/G<$ &: %$) ?G=(/),

Q9# ]G#)$%&' =(%)#), 3) $9#(# = 8=A&( /%).G$# A#$;##' 2%$%A='\ ='/ $9# )#<G(%$H ?G=(/)* @#@A#() &:

(#).&'/#'$ 23NUJ* (#?=(/8#)) &: ;9#$9#( $9#H )$='/ %' $9# (#8=$%&' &: #@.8&H#( ='/ #@.8&H##)s J($%<8#

B>B* .=(=?(=.9 8 &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# .(&+%/#) $9# /#:%'%$%&' &: = gL2GHI 4JFSKECg, 3$ g%'<8G/#) ='H

<&'$(&+#()H &( @=$$#( <&'<#('%'? $#(@) &( <&'/%$%&') &: #@.8&H@#'$ &( $9# =))&<%=$%&' &( (#.(#)#'$=$%&'

Page 58: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 58/108

&: .#()&') %' '#?&$%=$%'?* :%_%'?* @=%'$=%'%'?* <9='?%'? &( =((='?%'? $9# $#(@) ='/ <&'/%$%&') &:

#@.8&H@#'$* (#?=(/8#)) &: ;9#$9#( $9# /%).G$='$) )$='/ %' $9# .(&_%@=$# (#8=$%&' &: #@.8&H#( ='/

#@.8&H##,g

3: =$ =88* $9# /%).G$# A#$;##' 2%$%A='\ ='/ 18 Q&(& )#<G(%$H =?#'<H %) &'# (#?=(/%'? $9# $#(@%'=$%&' &(

'&'M(#'#;=8 &: $9# <&'$(=<$ &: )#(+%<#), Q9%) %) = <%+%8 /%).G$#P, 18 Q&(& ;=) =' %'/#.#'/#'$ <&'$(=<$&(,

Q9G)* '& #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. #_%)$#/ A#$;##' 2%$%A='\ ='/ $9# )#<G(%$H ?G=(/ @#@A#() &: $9#

G'%&' %' $9# )#<G(%$H =?#'<H ;9& ;#(# =))%?'#/ $& )#<G(# $9# A='\l) .(#@%)#) ='/ .(&.#($H, d#'<#* $9#(#

;=) '& 8=A&( /%).G$# ='/ '& (%?9$ $& )$(%\# =?=%')$ $9# A='\,

3$ %) = A=)%< (G8# &: .(&<#/G(# $9=$ g`G(%)/%<$%&' &: $9# <&G($ &+#( $9# )GA`#<$ @=$$#( &: $9# =<$%&' %)

/#$#(@%'#/ AH $9# =88#?=$%&') &: $9# <&@.8=%'$* %((#).#<$%+# &: ;9#$9#( &( '&$ $9# .8=%'$%:: %) #'$%$8#/ $&

(#<&+#( G.&' =88 &( )&@# &: $9# <8=%@) =))#($#/ $9#(#%', Q9# `G(%)/%<$%&' &: $9# <&G($ <=' '&$ A# @=/# $&

/#.#'/ G.&' $9# /#:#')#) )#$ G. %' $9# =');#( &( G.&' $9# @&$%&' $& /%)@%))* :&( &$9#(;%)#* $9# ]G#)$%&'

&: `G(%)/%<$%&' ;&G8/ =8@&)$ #'$%(#8H /#.#'/ G.&' $9# /#:#'/='$,gC g79=$ /#$#(@%'#) $9# `G(%)/%<$%&' &:

$9# <&G($ %) $9# '=$G(# &: $9# =<$%&' .8#=/#/ =) =..#=(%'? :(&@ $9# =88#?=$%&') %' $9# <&@.8=%'$, Q9#

=+#(@#'$) $9#(#%' ='/ $9# <9=(=<$#( &: $9# (#8%#: )&G?9$ =(# $9# &'#) $& A# <&')G8$#/,g>D

 

3' $9# <&@.8=%'$ :%8#/ ;%$9 $9# $(%=8 <&G($* .#$%$%&'#( =88#?#/ $9=$ %' >CPI* %$ #'$#(#/ %'$& = <&'$(=<$

;%$9 18 Q&(&* = )#<G(%$H =?#'<H* :&( )#<G(%$H ='/ .(&$#<$%&' )#(+%<#, Q9# .=($%#) (#'#;#/ $9# <&'$(=<$ H#=(8HG'$%8 J.(%8 BB* >CCD, "#$%$%&'#( :G($9#( =88#?#/ $9=$ :(&@ FG'# >>* >CCD* G'$%8 $9# :%8%'? &: $9# <&@.8=%'$* 18

Q&(& )#<G(%$H ?G=(/) :&(@#(8H =))%?'#/ $& ?G=(/ 2%$%A='\ .(#@%)#) 8&%$#(#/ =(&G'/ $9# A='\l) .(#@%)#) %'

8=(?# ?(&G.) ='/ $9(#=$#'#/ $& )$=?# = )$(%\#* ;9%<9 ;&G8/ 9=@.#( %$) &.#(=$%&') ='/ $9# '&(@=8 <&'/G<$

&: %$) AG)%'#)) ='/ $9=$ $9# A='\ ;&G8/ )G::#( /=@=?#) )9&G8/ = )$(%\# .G)9 $9(&G?9,

5' $9# A=)%) &: $9# =88#?=$%&') &: $9# <&@.8=%'$* %$ %) )=:# $& <&'<8G/# $9=$ $9# /%).G$# %'+&8+#/ %) = <%+%8

&'#* '&$ = 8=A&( /%).G$#,>>

 2&')#]G#'$8H* ;# (G8# $9=$ `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( $9# )GA`#<$ @=$$#( &: $9# <&@.8=%'$

8%#) ;%$9 $9# (#?%&'=8 $(%=8 <&G($,

&CLJCU  

=9%&%6+&%* $9# 2&G($ 9#(#AH N-J6Q4 $9# .#$%$%&' :&( (#+%#; &' <#($%&(=(%, 7# -1V1-41 ='/ 41Q

J4301 $9# /#<%)%&' &: $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) ='/ %$) (#)&8G$%&' /#'H%'? (#<&')%/#(=$%&' %' 2JMN, -, 4" 6&,

BRRPS* ='/ -1ZJ60 $9# (#<&(/) &: $9# <=)# $& $9# -#?%&'=8 Q(%=8 2&G($* Z=\=$%* :&( :G($9#( .(&<##/%'?) %'

8%'# ;%$9 $9# (G8%'? 9#(#%' $9=$ `G(%)/%<$%&'&+#( $9# )GA`#<$ @=$$#( &: $9# <&@.8=%'$ %' 2%+%8 2=)# 6&, CDM

>T>B* %) +#)$#/ $9#(#%',

6& .(&'&G'<#@#'$ =) $& <&)$),

'+ +&7%&%7<

Page 59: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 59/108

 

09#)#00#"% (#&)#"%'5 #"/<5 %&+,+,0*&'A 1-<5 "(1#+"() )(,+& &%)(1#+"' /+..#''#+"5 6%&7#"("7

0#"%7( 234 -+7+6&%7+ /(,)#"-5 '&-%0*2&*+-<

7 % / # ' # + "

.(&1#"%85 ! <A

2=' $9# 6=$%&'=8 U=A&( -#8=$%&') 2&@@%))%&' K6U-2L* #+#' ;%$9&G$ = <&@.8=%'$ :&( %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8

:%8#/ A#:&(# $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#(* #'$#($=%' =' =<$%&' :&( %'`G'<$%&' ='/ %))G# )G<9 ;(%$ #'`&%'%'? .#$%$%&'#(

"9%8%..%'# J%(8%'#)* 3'<, :(&@ #':&(<%'? %$) 5(/#() &: /%)@%))=8 =?=%')$ .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$)* ='/ &(/#(%'?

.#$%$%&'#( $& (#%')$=$# $9# .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$) $& $9#%( .(#+%&G) .&)%$%&')s

Q9%) %) $9# .%+&$=8 %))G# .(#)#'$#/ A#:&(# G) %' $9%) .#$%$%&' :&( <#($%&(=(% G'/#( -G8# TR &: $9# -#+%)#/

-G8#) &: 2&G($ ;9%<9 )##\) $9# 'G88%:%<=$%&' &: $9# %'`G'<$%+# ;(%$ /=$#/ J.(%8 I*>CCR %))G#/ AH $9# 6U-2

='/ $9# 5(/#( /#'H%'? .#$%$%&'#(l) @&$%&' :&( (#<&')%/#(=$%&' &' $9# ?(&G'/ $9=$ $9# )=%/ 5(/#() ;#(#

%))G#/ %' #_<#)) &: `G(%)/%<$%&',

"(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$) =(# :8%?9$ )$#;=(/) &: $9# .#$%$%&'#(, O&$9 ;#(# /%)@%))#/ :(&@ $9# )#(+%<# :&($9#%( =88#?#/ %'+&8+#@#'$ %' $9# J.(%8 I* >CCI <G((#'<H )@G??8%'? %' d&'? b&'?,

J??(%#+#/ AH )=%/ /%)@%))=8* .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$) :%8#/ ;%$9 $9# 6U-2 = .#$%$%&'h>i

 :&( %'`G'<$%&' .(=H%'?

$9=$a

g3, Y.&' :%8%'? &: $9%) "#$%$%&'* = $#@.&(=(H (#)$(=%'%'? &(/#( A# %))G#/* .(&9%A%$%'? (#).&'/#'$) K.#$%$%&'#(

9#(#%'L :(&@ #::#<$%'? &( #':&(<%'? $9# 0#<%)%&' /=$#/ X#A, BB* >CCR* &( $& (#%')$=$# .#$%$%&'#()

$#@.&(=(%8H ;9%8# = 9#=(%'? &' $9# .(&.(%#$H &: $9# %))G='<# &: = ;(%$ &: .(#8%@%'=(H %'`G'<$%&' %) A#%'?

G'/#($=\#'[

g33, J:$#( 9#=(%'?* = ;(%$ &: .(#8%@%'=(H @='/=$&(H %'`G'<$%&' A# %))G#/ &(/#(%'? (#).&'/#'$ $& (#%')$=$#.#$%$%&'#() $& $9#%( :&(@#( .&)%$%&') .#'/%'? $9# 9#=(%'? &: $9%) <=)#* &(* .(&9%A%$%'? (#).&'/#'$ :(&@

#':&(<%'? %$) 0#<%)%&' /=$#/ X#A(G=(H BB*>CCR ;9%8# $9%) <=)# %) .#'/%'? =/`G/%<=$%&'[

g333, J:$#( 9#=(%'?* $9=$ $9# ;(%$ &: .(#8%@%'=(H %'`G'<$%&' =) $& $9# (#8%#:) )&G?9$ :&( A# @=/# .#(@='#'$*

$9=$ .#$%$%&'#() A# =;=(/#/ :G88 A=<\;=?#)* @&(=8 /=@=?#) &: "d" RDD*DDD,DD #=<9 ='/ #_#@.8=(H

/=@=?#) &: "d" RDD*DDD,DD #=<9* =$$&('#H) :##) #]G%+=8#'$ $& $#' .#(<#'$ &: ;9=$#+#( =@&G'$ %)

=;=(/#/* ='/ $9# <&)$) &: )G%$,g

5' J.(%8 I* >CCR* $9# 6U-2 %))G#/ = $#@.&(=(H @='/=$&(H %'`G'<$%&'hBi

 #'`&%'%'? .#$%$%&'#( $& <#=)#

='/ /#)%)$ :(&@ #':&(<%'? %$) X#A(G=(H BB* >CCR Z#@&(='/G@ &: /%)@%))=8, 3' ?(='$%'? $9# ;(%$* $9# 6U-2<&')%/#(#/ $9# :&88&;%'? :=<$)* $& ;%$a

_ _ _ $9=$ =8@&)$ $;& KBL H#=() =?&* %,#, &' J.(%8 >R* >CCI* $9# .#$%$%&'#() ;#(# %')$(G<$#/ $& =$$#'/ ='

%'+#)$%?=$%&' AH (#).&'/#'$) 4#<G(%$H ='/ X(=G/ "(#+#'$%&' 4GAM0#.=($@#'$ (#?=(/%'? =' J.(%8 I* >CCI

%'<%/#'$ %' d&'?\&'? =$ ;9%<9 F&)#.9 JA=<=* (#).&'/#'$) J+%&'%<) Z#<9='%< %' d&'?\&'? ;=) %'$#(<#.$#/

AH $9# d&'?\&'? J%(.&($ "&8%<# =$ N=$# DR ___ $9# (=@. =(#= &: $9# b=% Q=\ 3'$#('=$%&'=8 J%(.&($ ;9%8# ___

=A&G$ $& #_%$ )=%/ ?=$# <=((H%'? = ___ A=? )=%/ $& <&'$=%' )&@# B,R @%88%&' .#)&) %' "9%8%..%'#

2G((#'<%#), Q9=$ =$ $9# "&8%<# 4$=$%&'* Z(, JA=<= <8=%@#/ $9=$ 9# `G)$ :&G'/ )=%/ .8=)$%< A=? =$ $9# 4\HA#/

4#<$%&' &: $9# =((%+=8 :8%?9$ "-IDDeDI J.(%8 CI* ;9#(# .#$%$%&'#() )#(+#/ =) :8%?9$ )$#;=(/) &: )=%/ :8%?9$

"-IDD[ _ _ $9# .#$%$%&'#() )&G?9$ = @&(# /#$=%8#/ =<<&G'$ &: ;9=$ $9%) dbN %'<%/#'$ %) =88 =A&G$[ AG$

%')$#=/* $9# .#$%$%&'#() ;#(# =/@%'%)$(=$%+#8H <9=(?#/* = 9#=(%'? &' ;9%<9 /%/ '&$ .G)9 $9(&G?9 G'$%8

=8@&)$ $;& KBL H#=() =:$#(* %,#, &' F='G=(H BD* >CCR ___ ;9#(# = <&':(&'$=$%&' A#$;##' Z(, JA=<= ='/

.#$%$%&'#() 9#(#%' ;=) <&@.G8)&(%8H =((='?#/ AH $9# (#).&'/#'$) /%)<%.8%'=(H A&=(/ =$ ;9%<9 9#=(%'?*

JA=<= ;=) @=/# $& %/#'$%:H .#$%$%&'#() =) <&M<&').%(=$&()[ $9=$ /#).%$# $9# :=<$ $9=$ $9# .(&<#/G(# &:

Page 60: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 60/108

%/#'$%:%<=$%&' =/&.$#/ AH (#).&'/#'$) 0%)<%.8%'=(H O&=(/ ;=) ='&@=8&G) =) $9#(# ;=) '& &'# #8)# %' $9#

8%'#MG. K;9%<9 <&G8/ '&$ A# <=88#/ &'#L AG$ .#$%$%&'#() ___ F&)#.9 JA=<= )$%88 9=/ /%::%<G8$H %' %/#'$%:H%'?

.#$%$%&'#( "%'#/= =) 9%) <&M<&').%(=$&(* ='/ =) $& .#$%$%&'#( 2=A8%'?* 9# ;=) %@.8%<=$#/ ='/ .&%'$#/ AH

JA=<= &'8H =:$#( (#).&'/#'$) J$$H, 2=A=$G='/& .(#))#/ $9# :&(@#( $& %/#'$%:H .#$%$%&'#( 2=A8%'? =) <&M

<&').%(=$&([ $9=$ ;%$9 $9# 9#=(%'? (#)#$ $& F='G=(H BR* >CCR* Z(, F&)#.9 JA=<= :%'=88H ?=+# #_<G8.=$%'?

)$=$#@#'$) $& $9# A&=(/ %' $9=$ 9# <8#=(#/ .#$%$%&'#() :(&@ ='H .=($%<%.=$%&' &( :(&@ A#%'? $9# &;'#() &:

$9# <G((#'<%#)* ='/ =$ ;9%<9 9#=(%'? Z(, F&)#.9 JA=<= +&8G'$##(#/ $9# %':&(@=$%&' $9=$ $9# (#=8 &;'#( &:

)=%/ @&'#H ;=) &'# ;9& :(#]G#'$#/ 9%) 9#=/]G=($#() %' d&'?\&'? $& ;9%<9 %':&(@=$%&'* $9# 0%)<%.8%'=(HO&=(/ 29=%(@='* Z(, 3)@=#8 b9='* &.%'#/ :&( $9# '##/ :&( ='&$9#( 9#=(%'? $& ?& $& $9# A&$$&@ &: $9#

%'<%/#'$[ $9=$ :(&@ )=%/ )$=$#@#'$* %$ =..#=(#/ $9=$ Z(, F&)#.9 JA=<= ;=) $9# <&G(%#(* ='/ 9=/ ='&$9#(

@#<9='%< %' Z='%8= ;9& 9%/ $9# <G((#'<H =$ $9# .8='#) )\HA#/ :&( JA=<= $& (#$(%#+# %' d&'?\&'?* ;9%<9

:%'/%'?) &: 9&; $9# @&'#H ;=) :&G'/ ;=) .(#+%&G)8H <&':%(@#/ AH Z(, F&)#.9 JA=<= 9%@)#8: ;9#' 9# ;=)

:%()$ %'+#)$%?=$#/ AH $9# d&'?\&'? =G$9&(%$%#)[ $9=$ `G)$ =) .#$%$%&'#() $9&G?9$ $9=$ $9#H ;#(# =8(#=/H :G88H

<8#=(#/ &: $9# <9=(?#)* =) $9#H '& 8&'?#( (#<#%+#/ ='H )G@@&')e'&$%<#) &' $9# %'$#'/#/ =//%$%&'=8

9#=(%'?) @='/=$#/ AH $9# 0%)<%.8%'=(H O&=(/* $9#H ;#(# )G(.(%)#/ $& (#<#%+# &' X#A(G=(H BI* >CCR ___ =

Z#@&(='/G@ /=$#/ X#A(G=(H BB* >CCR $#(@%'=$%'? $9#%( )#(+%<#) :&( =88#?#/ +%&8=$%&' &: (#).&'/#'$)

2&/# &: 0%)<%.8%'# #::#<$%+# %@@#/%=$#8H[ $9=$ )&@#$%@# ___ :%()$ ;##\ &: Z=(<9* >CCR* .#$%$%&'#( "%'#/=

(#<#%+#/ ='&$9#( Z#@&(='/G@ :(&@ (#).&'/#'$ Z(, FG=' "=(=%)&* =/+%)%'? 9%@ &: 9%) $#(@%'=$%&'#::#<$%+# X#A(G=(H I* >CCR* 8%\#;%)# :&( +%&8=$%&' &: (#).&'/#'$) 2&/# &: 0%)<%.8%'#[ _ _ _g

3' )G..&($ &: $9# %))G='<# &: $9# ;(%$ &: $#@.&(=(H %'`G'<$%&'* $9# 6U-2 =/&.$#/ $9# +%#; $9=$a K>L

.(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$) <=''&$ A# +=8%/8H /%)@%))#/ &' $9# )$(#'?$9 &: .#$%$%&'#(l) 2&/# &: 0%)<%.8%'# ;9%<9

;=) /#<8=(#/ %88#?=8 AH $9%) 2&G($ %' $9# <=)# &: "JU* 3'<, +), 6U-2* KN,-, 6&, PRCPRL* .(&@G8?=$#/ JG?G)$

>I* >CCI* :&( $9# (#=)&' $9=$ %$ ;=) :&(@G8=$#/ AH $9# .#$%$%&'#( ;%$9&G$ $9# .=($%<%.=$%&' &: %$) #@.8&H##)

=) (#]G%(#/ %' -,J, TE>R* =@#'/%'? J($%<8# B>> &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#[ KBL $9# ;9%@)%<=8* A=)#8#)) ='/

.(#@=$G(# /%)@%))=8) &: .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$) ;9%<9 g<=G)#/ $9#@ ?(=+# ='/ %((#.=(=A8# %'`G(Hg %)

#'`&%'=A8# =) .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$) =(# 8#:$ g;%$9 '& ).##/H ='/ =/#]G=$# (#@#/H =$ 8=;lg#_<#.$ $9#

%))G='<# &: = $#@.&(=(H @='/=$&(H %'`G'<$%&'[ KIL $9# 6U-2 %) #@.&;#(#/ G'/#( J($%<8# B>P K#L &: $9#

U=A&( 2&/# '&$ &'8H $& (#)$(=%' ='H =<$G=8 &( $9(#=$#'#/ <&@@%))%&' &: ='H &( =88 .(&9%A%$#/ &( G'8=;:G8

=<$) AG$ =8)& $& (#]G%(# $9# .#(:&(@='<# &: = .=($%<G8=( =<$ %' ='H 8=A&( /%).G$#* ;9%<9* %: '&$ (#)$(=%'#/ &(

.#(:&(@#/ :&($9;%$9* @=H <=G)# ?(=+# &( %((#.=(=A8# /=@=?# $& ='H .=($H[ ='/ KSL $9# $#@.&(=(H

@='/=$&(H .&;#( &: $9# 6U-2 ;=) (#<&?'%^#/ AH $9%) 2&G($ %' $9# <=)# &: 29#@&MQ#<9'%<)9# Z:?,* 3'<,

[email protected]&H##) Y'%&'*0XJ* #$,=8, +), 29#@&MQ#<9'%)<9# Z:?,* 3'<, hN,-, 6&, >DEDI>* F='G=(H BR*>CCIi,

5' Z=H S*>CCR* .#$%$%&'#( @&+#/ :&( (#<&')%/#(=$%&'hIi

 =(?G%'? $9=$ $9# 6U-2 #((#/a

>, %' ?(='$%'? = $#@.&(=(H %'`G'<$%&' &(/#( ;9#' JE B2F 3H ]KIJF4JDEJH3 EH JFFKC 23 J3]K3DEJH3 HI ICFEI2J3J3M

HI4CI FJ3DC EBJF R2Q GC JFFKC4 H3LQ K34CI (IEJDLC NPO HU EBC )2GHI /H4C JU EBC D2FC J3THLTCF HI 2IJFCF UIHR

L2GHI 4JFSKECFb 

B, %' ?(='$%'? = $#@.&(=(H %'`G'<$%&' &(/#( ;9#' $9# $#(@%'=$%&' &: .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$) 9=+# 8&'? A##'

<=((%#/ &G$[

I, ,,%' &(/#(%'? $9# (#%')$=$#@#'$ &: .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$) &' $9# A=)%) &: $9#%( @#(# =88#?=$%&')* %' +%&8=$%&'

&: "JUl) (%?9$ $& /G# .(&<#))[

S, ,,%' =((&?=$%'? G'$& %$)#8: @='=?#@#'$ .(#(&?=$%+# $& /%)<%.8%'# %$) #@.8&H##) ='/ 4JTCFEJ3M EBC L2GHI

2IGJECI HU JEF HIJMJ32L 234 C^DLKFJTC ]KIJF4JDEJH3 HTCI JLLCM2L 4JFRJFF2L D2FCFb 

R, ,,%' )G).#'/%'? $9# #::#<$) &: $#(@%'=$%&' ;9#' )G<9 =<$%&' %) #_<8G)%+#8H ;%$9%' $9# `G(%)/%<$%&' &: $9#

4#<(#$=(H &: U=A&([

Page 61: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 61/108

T, ,,J3 JFFKJ3M EBC ECRSHI2IQ J3]K3DEJH3 J3 EBC 2GFC3DC HU 23Q JIICS2I2GLC HI FKGFE23EJ2L J3]KIQ EH GHEB

SIJT2EC ICFSH34C3EF,

5' Z=H I>*>CCR* $9# 6U-2 /#'%#/ .#$%$%&'#(l) @&$%&' :&( (#<&')%/#(=$%&'* (G8%'?a

1BC ICFSH34C3E _3HV SCEJEJH3CIa5 UHI H3C5 D233HE T2LJ4LQ DL2JR EB2E VC D233HE C^CIDJFC HKI J3]K3DEJTC

SHVCI K34CI (IEJDLC NPO _Ca HU EBC )2GHI /H4C H3 EBC SICEC^E EB2E VB2E VC B2TC BCIC JF 3HE 2 L2GHI

4JFSKEC 2F LH3M 2F JE DH3DC4CF EB2E 2F 4CUJ3C4 GQ L2V5 2_La )2GHI 7JFSKEC J3DLK4CF 23Q DH3EIHTCIFQ HIR2EECI DH3DCI3J3M ECIRF HI DH34JEJH3F HU CRSLHQRC3E< , 3: )#<G(%$H &: $#'G(#* ;9%<9 9=) A##' A(#=<9#/

AH (#).&'/#'$ ='/ ;9%<9* .(#<%)#8H* %) )&G?9$ $& A# .(&$#<$#/ AH &G( $#@.&(=(H @='/=$&(H %'`G'<$%&' K$9#

<&(# &: <&'$(&+#()H %' $9%) <=)#L %) '&$ = $#(@ &( <&'/%$%&' &: #@.8&H@#'$* ;9=$ $9#' %)s

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

(3C3E ICFSH34C3EF FCDH34 2IMKRC3E _ _ _* (IEJDLC NPO _Ca HU EBC )2GHI /H4C _ _ _ CRSHVCIC4 EBC

/HRRJFFJH3 3HE H3LQ EH JFFKC 2 SIHBJGJEHIQ J3]K3DEJH35 GKE 2 R2342EHIQ _EH ICWKJIC EBC SCIUHIR23DCa

H3C 2F VCLL< ,CFJ4CF5 2F C2ILJCI 4JFDKFFC45 VC 2LIC24Q C^CIDJFC4 _H3 (KMKFE Nc5PeePa EBJF ECRSHI2IQ

R2342EHIQ J3]K3DEJTC SHVCI J3 EBC D2FC HU /BCRHd1CDB3JFDBC .UM<5 #3D< %RSLHQCCF !3JH3d76( CE<2L< TF<

/BCRHd1CDB3JFBC .UM<5 #3D<5 CE< 2L< _FKSI2a 234 CUUCDEJTCLQ C3]HJ3C4 H3C _Pa RH3EB HL4 4JFRJFF2LF GQ

/BCRHd1CDB3JFDBC 234 EB2E HKI 2UHICF2J4 R2342EHIQ C^CIDJFC HU J3]K3DEJTC SHVCI5 VBC3 WKCFEJH3C4

EBIHKMB 2 SCEJEJH3 UHI DCIEJHI2IJ5 V2F FKFE2J3C4 GQ EBC 1BJI4 7JTJFJH3 HU EBC 'KSICRC DHKIE SCI JEF

&CFHLKEJH3 42EC4 ;23K2IQ N[5Peec,

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

&CFSH34C3EF UHKIEB 2IMKRC3E EB2E SCEJEJH3CIjF ICRC4Q UHI EBCJI 4JFRJFF2LF JF jEH UJLC 23 JLLCM2L 4JFRJFF2L

D2FC 2M2J3FE 0() VBJDB D2FCF 2IC VJEBJ3 EBC HIJMJ32L 234 C^DLKFJTC ]KIJF4JDEJH3 HU EBC )2GHI (IGJECIj JF

JM3HI23E, 3' (#]G%(%'? =) = <&'/%$%&' :&( $9# %))G='<# &: = l$#@.&(=(H &( .#(@='#'$ %'`G'<$%&'lM lKSL Q9=$

<&@.8=%'='$ 9=) '& =/#]G=$# (#@#/H =$ 8=;[j (IEJDLC NPO _Ca HU EBC )2GHI /H4C DLC2ILQ

C3TJFJH3C4 24CWK2DQ5 234 3HE SL2J3 2T2JL2GJLJEQ HU 2 ICRC4Q 2E L2V 2F 23 2LECI32EJTC G2I EH EBC JFFK23DC

HU 23 J3]K3DEJH3< (3 JLLCM2L 4JFRJFF2L FKJE _VBJDB E2XCF5 H3 JEF C^SC4JEJHKF FJ4C5 EBICC _ca QC2IF GCUHIC JE

D23 GC 4JFSHFC4 HUa VBJLC 2T2JL2GLC 2F 2 ICRC4Q K34CI (IEJDLC NPk _2a HU EBC )2GHI /H4C5 JF DCIE2J3LQ 3HE

23 j24CWK2ECb ICRC4Q 2E L2V< %IMH5 JE D233HE5 2F 23 2LECI32EJTC ICRC4Q5 G2I HKI C^CIDJFC HU EB2E

J3]K3DEJTC SHVCI MJTC3 KF GQ (IEJDLC NPO _Ca HU EBC /H4C< 

___ ___ ___

Q9G)* J($%<8# B>P K#L* =) #=(8%#( /%)<G))#/ h;9%<9 #@.&;#() $9%) 2&@@%))%&' l$& (#]G%(# $9# .#(:&(@='<# &:

= .=($%<G8=( =<$l K)G<9 =) &G( (#]G%(%'? (#).&'/#'$ l$& <#=)# ='/ /#)%)$ :(&@ #':&(<%'?l %$) ;9%@)%<=8@#@&(='/= &: /%)@%))=8) ='/ l%')$#=/ $& (#%')$=$# .#$%$%&'#() $& $9#%( (#).#<$%+# .&)%$%&' 9#8/ .(%&( $&

$9#%( )GA`#<$ /%)@%))=8)lL %' l='H 8=A&( /%).G$# ;9%<9* %: '&$ ___ .#(:&(@#/ :&($9;%$9* @=H <=G)# ?(=+# ='/

%((#.=(=A8# /=@=?# $& ='H .=($Hli )$='/) =) $9# )&8# l=/#]G=$# (#@#/H =$ 8=;l :&( .#$%$%&'#() 9#(#,

X%'=88H* $9# (#).&'/#'$* %' %$) )%_$9 =(?G@#'$ <8=%@) $9=$ #+#' %: %$) =<$) &: /%)@%))%'? .#$%$%&'#() l@=H A#

?(#=$* )$%88 $9# )=@# %) <=.=A8# &: <&@.#')=$%&'l* ='/ $9=$ <&')#]G#'$8H* l%'`G'<$%&' '##/ '&$ A# %))G#/

;9#(# =/#]G=$# <&@.#')=$%&' =$ 8=; <&G8/ A# &A$=%'#/l, J<$G=88H* ;9=$ (#).&'/#'$ "JU =(?G#) 9#(# %)

$9=$ ;# '##/ '&$ %'$#(:#(# %' %$) ;9%@)%<=8 /%)@%))=8) &: .#$%$%&'#() =)* =:$#( =88* %$ <=' .=H $9# 8=$$#( %$)

A=<\;=?#), _ _ _

OG$ `G)$ $9# )=@#* ;# 9=+# $& )$(#)) $9=$ J($%<8# BEC /&#) '&$ ).#=\ =8&'# &: A=<\;=?#) =) =' &A$=%'=A8#

(#8%#: :&( %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8[ $9=$ (#%')$=$#@#'$ =) ;#88 %) $9# <&'<#(' &: )=%/ 8=;* #':&(<#=A8# ;9#'

'#<#))=(H* $9(&G?9 J($%<8# B>P K#L &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# K;%$9&G$ '##/ &: =' %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8 )G%$ G'/#( J($%<8#

Page 62: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 62/108

B>E K=L &: $9# 2&/#L %: )G<9 ;9%@)%<=8 ='/ <=.(%<%&G) =<$ &: %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8 ;%88 l<=G)# ?(=+# &( %((#.=(=A8#

%'`G(H $& = .=($Hl, _ _ _ ghSi

 

d#'<#* $9# .(#)#'$ (#<&G()#,

N#'#(=88H* %'`G'<$%&' %) = .(#)#(+=$%+# (#@#/H :&( $9# .(&$#<$%&' &: &'#l) )GA)$='$%+# (%?9$) &( %'$#(#)$,

3$ %) '&$ = <=G)# &: =<$%&' %' %$)#8: AG$ @#(#8H 2 SIHTJFJH32L ICRC4Q5 23 24]K3DE EH 2 R2J3 FKJE, 3$ %) (#)&($#/

$& &'8H;9#' $9#(# %) = .(#))%'? '#<#))%$H $& =+&%/ %'`G(%&G) <&')#]G#'<#) ;9%<9 <=''&$ A# (#@#/%#/

G'/#( ='H )$='/=(/ &: <&@.#')=$%&', Q9# =..8%<=$%&' &: $9# %'`G'<$%+# ;(%$ (#)$) G.&' $9# #_%)$#'<# &: ='

#@#(?#'<H &( &: = ).#<%=8 (#=)&' A#:&(# $9# @=%' <=)# A# (#?G8=(8H 9#=(/, Q9# #))#'$%=8 <&'/%$%&') :&(

?(='$%'? )G<9 $#@.&(=(H %'`G'<$%+# (#8%#: =(# $9=$ $9# <&@.8=%'$ =88#?#) :=<$) ;9%<9 =..#=( $& A# )G::%<%#'$

$& <&')$%$G$# = .(&.#( A=)%) :&( %'`G'<$%&' ='/ $9=$ &' $9# #'$%(# )9&;%'? :(&@ $9# <&'$#'/%'? .=($%#)* $9#

%'`G'<$%&' %) (#=)&'=A8H '#<#))=(H $& .(&$#<$ $9# 8#?=8 (%?9$) &: $9# .8=%'$%:: .#'/%'? $9#

8%$%?=$%&',hRi

 3'`G'<$%&' %) =8)& = ).#<%=8 #]G%$=A8# (#8%#: ?(='$#/ &'8H %' <=)#) ;9#(# $9#(# %) '& .8=%'*

=/#]G=$# ='/ <&@.8#$# (#@#/H =$ 8=;,hTi

 

3' 8=A&( <=)#)* J($%<8# B>P &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# #@.&;#() $9# 6U-2M

gK#L Q& #'`&%' &( (#)$(=%' ='H =<$G=8 &( $9(#=$#'#/ <&@@%))%&' &: ='H &( =88 .(&9%A%$#/ &( G'8=;:G8 =<$) &($& (#]G%(# $9# .#(:&(@='<# &: = .=($%<G8=( =<$ J3 23Q L2GHI 4JFSKEC ;9%<9* %: '&$ (#)$(=%'#/ &( .#(:&(@#/

:&($9;%$9*@=H <=G)# ?(=+# &( %((#.=(=A8# /=@=?# EH 23Q S2IEQ HI IC34CI J3CUUCDEK2L 23Q 4CDJFJH3 J3 U2THI

HU FKDB S2IEQ[ _ _ _,g [email protected]=)%) 5G()L

2&@.8#@#'$%'? $9# =A&+#M]G&$#/ .(&+%)%&'* 4#<, >* -G8# r3 &: $9# 6#; -G8#) &: "(&<#/G(# &: $9#

6U-2* .#($%'#'$8H .(&+%/#) =) :&88&;)a

g4#<$%&' >, N+A6+;)&*+ &+ R,1&+5,< ?5=*, D&0$6)(,MJ .(#8%@%'=(H %'`G'<$%&' &( = (#)$(=%'%'? &(/#( @=H A#

?(='$#/ AH $9# 2&@@%))%&' $9(&G?9 %$) /%+%)%&') .G()G='$ $& $9# .(&+%)%&') &: .=(=?(=.9 K#L &: J($%<8# B>P

&: $9# U=A&( 2&/#* =) =@#'/#/* ;9#' %$ %) #)$=A8%)9#/ &' $9# A=)#) &: $9# );&(' =88#?=$%&') %' $9# .#$%$%&'

$9=$ $9# =<$) <&@.8=%'#/ &:* J3THLTJ3M HI 2IJFJ3M UIHR 23Q L2GHI 4JFSKEC GCUHIC EBC /HRRJFFJH35 ;9%<9* %:

'&$ (#)$(=%'#/ &( .#(:&(@#/ :&($9;%$9* @=H <=G)# ?(=+# &( %((#.=(=A8# /=@=?# $& ='H .=($H &( (#'/#(

%'#::#<$G=8 ='H /#<%)%&' %' :=+&( &: )G<9 .=($H,

___ ___ ___

Q9# UHICMHJ3M 23DJLL2IQ SHVCI @=H A# #_#(<%)#/ AH $9# U=A&( J(A%$#() &'8H =) =' %'<%/#'$ $& $9# <=)#)

.#'/%'? A#:&(# $9#@ %' &(/#( $& .(#)#(+# $9# (%?9$) &: $9# .=($%#) /G(%'? $9# .#'/#'<H &: $9# <=)#* AG$

#_<8G/%'? 8=A&( /%).G$#) %'+&8+%'? )$(%\#) &( 8&<\&G$,hEi

 [email protected]=)%) 5G()L

X(&@ $9# :&(#?&%'? .(&+%)%&') &: 8=;* $9# .&;#( &: $9# 6U-2 $& %))G# =' %'`G'<$%+# ;(%$ &(%?%'=$#) :(&@g23Q L2GHI 4JFSKECg G.&' =..8%<=$%&' AH = .=($H $9#(#&:* ;9%<9 =..8%<=$%&' %: '&$ ?(='$#/ g@=H <=G)# ?(=+#

&( %((#.=(=A8# /=@=?# $& ='H .=($H &( (#'/#( %'#::#<$G=8 ='H /#<%)%&' %' :=+&( &: )G<9 .=($H,g

Q9# $#(@ g8=A&( /%).G$#g %) /#:%'#/ =) g='H <&'$(&+#()H &( @=$$#( <&'<#('%'? $#(@) ='/ <&'/%$%&') &:

#@.8&H@#'$ &( $9# =))&<%=$%&' &( (#.(#)#'$=$%&' &: .#()&') %' '#?&$%=$%'?* :%_%'?* @=%'$=%'%'?* <9='?%'?*

&( =((='?%'? $9# $#(@) ='/ <&'/%$%&') &: #@.8&H@#'$ (#?=(/8#)) &: ;9#$9#( &( '&$ $9# /%).G$='$) )$='/ %'

$9# .(&_%@=$# (#8=$%&' &: #@.8&H#() ='/ #@.8&H##),ghPi

 

Q9# $#(@ g<&'$(&+#()Hg %) 8%\#;%)# /#:%'#/ =) g= LJEJM2EC4 WKCFEJH3[ 24TCIF2IQ SIHDCC4J3M J3 2 DHKIE HU

L2Vb 2 DJTJL 2DEJH3 HI FKJE* #%$9#( =$ 8=; &( %' #]G%$H[ 2 ]KFEJDJ2GLC 4JFSKEC<ghCi 

J g`G)$%<%=A8# <&'$(&+#()Hg %) g&'# %'+&8+%'? =' =<$%+# ='$=?&'%)$%< =))#($%&' &: = 8#?=8 (%?9$ &' &'# )%/#='/ = /#'%=8 $9#(#&: &' $9# &$9#( <&'<#('%'? = (#=8* ='/ '&$ = @#(# $9#&(#$%<=8 ]G#)$%&' &( %))G#,g

h>Di 

Q=\%'? %'$& =<<&G'$ $9# :&(#?&%'? /#:%'%$%&')* %$ %) =' #))#'$%=8 (#]G%(#@#'$ $9=$ $9#(# @G)$ :%()$ A# =

8=A&( /%).G$# A#$;##' $9# <&'$#'/%'? .=($%#) A#:&(# $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#(, 3' $9# .(#)#'$ <=)#* $9#(# %) '&

Page 63: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 63/108

8=A&( /%).G$#A#$;##' $9# .#$%$%&'#( ='/ .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$) =) $9#(# 9=) H#$ A##' '& <&@.8=%'$ :&( %88#?=8

/%)@%))=8 :%8#/ ;%$9 $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#( AH $9# .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$) =?=%')$ $9# .#$%$%&'#(,

Q9# .#$%$%&' :&( %'`G'<$%&' /%(#<$8H :%8#/ A#:&(# $9# 6U-2 %) %' (#=8%$H =' =<$%&' :&( %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8, Q9%)

%) <8#=( :(&@ $9# =88#?=$%&') %' $9# .#$%$%&' ;9%<9 .(=H) :&(a (#%')$=$#@#'$ &: .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$)[ =;=(/ &:

:G88 A=<\;=?#)* @&(=8 ='/ #_#@.8=(H /=@=?#)[ ='/ =$$&('#Hl) :##), J) )G<9* $9# .#$%$%&' )9&G8/ 9=+# A##'

:%8#/ ;%$9 $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#( ;9& 9=) $9# &(%?%'=8 ='/ #_<8G)%+# `G(%)/%<$%&' $& 9#=( ='/ /#<%/# $9# :&88&;%'?

<=)#) %'+&8+%'? =88 ;&(\#()* ;9#$9#( =?(%<G8$G(=8 &( '&'M=?(%<G8$G(=8a

K>L Y':=%( 8=A&( .(=<$%<#[

KBL 1CIRJ32EJH3 4JFSKECFb 

KIL #U 2DDHRS23JC4 VJEB 2 DL2JR UHI ICJ3FE2ECRC3E5 EBHFC D2FCF EB2E VHIXCIF R2Q UJLC J3THLTJ3M V2MCF5

I2ECF HU S2Q5 BHKIF HU VHIX 234 HEBCI ECIRF 234 DH34JEJH3F HU CRSLHQRC3Eb 

KSL /L2JRF UHI 2DEK2L5 RHI2L5 C^CRSL2IQ 234 HEBCI UHIRF HU 42R2MCF 2IJFJ3M UIHR EBC CRSLHQCIdCRSLHQCC

ICL2EJH3Fb 

KRL 2=)#) =(%)%'? :(&@ ='H +%&8=$%&' &: J($%<8# BTS &: $9%) 2&/#* %'<8G/%'? ]G#)$%&') %'+&8+%'? $9# 8#?=8%$H &:

)$(%\#) ='/ 8&<\&G$)[ ='/

KTL 1_<#.$ <8=%@) :&( #@.8&H##) <&@.#')=$%&'* )&<%=8 )#<G(%$H* @#/%<=(# ='/ @=$#('%$H A#'#:%$)* =88 &$9#(

<8=%@) =(%)%'? :(&@ #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')* %'<8G/%'? $9&)# &: .#()&') %' /&@#)$%< &( 9&G)#9&8/

)#(+%<#* %'+&8+%'? =' =@&G'$ #_<##/%'? :%+# $9&G)='/ .#)&) K" R*DDD,DDL* ;9#$9#( &( '&$ =<<&@.='%#/

;%$9 = <8=%@ :&( (#%')$=$#@#'$,h>>i

 

Q9# `G(%)/%<$%&' <&':#((#/ AH $9# :&(#?&%'? 8#?=8 .(&+%)%&' $& $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#( %)

A&$9 HIJMJ32L ='/ C^DLKFJTC* @#='%'?* '& &$9#( &::%<#( &( $(%AG'=8 <=' $=\# <&?'%^='<# &:* 9#=( ='/ /#<%/#='H &: $9# <=)#) $9#(#%' #'G@#(=$#/, Q9# &'8H #_<#.$%&') =(# ;9#(# $9# 4#<(#$=(H &: U=A&( ='/

[email protected]&H@#'$ &( $9# 6U-2 #_#(<%)#) $9# .&;#( &: <&@.G8)&(H =(A%$(=$%&'* &( $9# .=($%#) =?(## $& )GA@%$ $9#

@=$$#( $& +&8G'$=(H =(A%$(=$%&' .G()G='$ $& J($%<8# BTI K?L &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#* $9# .#($%'#'$ .&($%&') &:

;9%<9 (#=/)a

gK?L 79#'* %' 9%) &.%'%&'* $9#(# #_%)$) = 8=A&( /%).G$# <=G)%'? &( 8%\#8H $& <=G)# = )$(%\# &( 8&<\&G$ %' ='

%'/G)$(H %'/%).#')=A8# $& $9# '=$%&'=8 %'$#(#)$* $9# 4#<(#$=(H &: U=A&( ='/ [email protected]&H@#'$ @=H =))G@#

 `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( $9# /%).G$# ='/ /#<%/# %$ &( <#($%:H $9# )=@# $& $9# 2&@@%))%&' :&( <&@.G8)&(H

=(A%$(=$%&', 4G<9 =))G@.$%&' &( <#($%:%<=$%&' )9=88 9=+# $9# #::#<$ &: =G$&@=$%<=88H #'`&%'%'? $9# %'$#'/#/

&( %@.#'/%'? )$(%\# &( 8&<\&G$ =) ).#<%:%#/ %' $9# =))G@.$%&' &( <#($%:%<=$%&' &(/#(, 3: &'# 9=) =8(#=/H$=\#' .8=<# =$ $9# $%@# &: =))G@.$%&' &( <#($%:%<=$%&'* =88 )$(%\%'? &( 8&<\#/ &G$ #@.8&H##) )9=88

%@@#/%=$#8H (#)G@# &.#(=$%&') ='/ (#=/@%$ =88 ;&(\#() G'/#( $9# )=@# $#(@) ='/ <&'/%$%&') .(#+=%8%'?

A#:&(# $9# )$(%\# &( 8&<\&G$, Q9# 4#<(#$=(H &: U=A&( ='/ [email protected]&H@#'$ &( $9# 2&@@%))%&' @=H )##\ $9#

=))%)$='<# &: 8=; #':&(<#@#'$ =?#'<%#) $& #')G(# <&@.8%='<# ;%$9 $9%) .(&+%)%&' =) ;#88 =) ;%$9 )G<9

&(/#() =) 9# @=H %))G# $& #':&(<# $9# )=@#,

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ g

5' $9# &$9#( 9='/* $9# 6U-2 )9=88 9=+# #_<8G)%+# 2SSCLL2EC `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( =88 <=)#) /#<%/#/ AH 8=A&(

=(A%$#() =) .(&+%/#/ %' J($%<8# B>EKAL &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#, 3' )9&($* $9# `G(%)/%<$%&' &: $9# 6U-2 %' %88#?=8

/%)@%))=8 <=)#) %) =..#88=$# %' '=$G(# ='/* $9#(#:&(#* %$ <=''&$ #'$#($=%' $9# .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$)l .#$%$%&'

:&( %'`G'<$%&' ;9%<9 <9=88#'?#) $9# /%)@%))=8 &(/#() &: .#$%$%&'#(, J($%<8# B>PK#L &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# /&#) '&$

.(&+%/# A8='\#$ =G$9&(%$H $& $9# 6U-2 &( ='H &: %$) /%+%)%&') $& %))G# ;(%$) &: %'`G'<$%&'* <&')%/#(%'? $9=$

Page 64: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 64/108

4#<$%&' > &: -G8# r3 &: $9# 6#; -G8#) &: "(&<#/G(# &: $9# 6U-2 @=\#) %'`G'<$%&' &'8H =' ='<%88=(H (#@#/H

%' &(/%'=(H 8=A&( /%).G$#)gh>Bi

 

Q9G)* $9# 6U-2 #_<##/#/ %$) `G(%)/%<$%&' ;9#' %$ %))G#/ $9# =))=%8#/ 5(/#( ?(='$%'? .(%+=$#

(#).&'/#'$)l .#$%$%&' :&( %'`G'<$%&' ='/ &(/#(%'? $9# .#$%$%&'#( $& (#%')$=$# .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$),

Q9# =(?G@#'$ &: $9# 6U-2 %' %$) =))=%8#/ 5(/#( $9=$ $& :%8# =' %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8 )G%$ ;%$9 $9# 8=A&(

=(A%$#( %) '&$ =' g=/#]G=$#g (#@#/H )%'<# %$ $=\#) $9(## KIL H#=() A#:&(# %$ <=' A# /%).&)#/ &:* %) .=$#'$8H

#((&'#&G), J' g=/#]G=$#g (#@#/H =$ 8=; 9=) A##' /#:%'#/ =) &'# g$9=$ =::&(/) (#8%#: ;%$9 (#:#(#'<# $& $9#@=$$#( %' <&'$(&+#()H* ='/ ;9%<9 %) =..(&.(%=$# $& $9# .=($%<G8=( <%(<G@)$='<#) &: $9# <=)#,g

h>Ii  3$ %) =

(#@#/H ;9%<9 %) #]G=88H A#'#:%<%=8* ).##/H ='/ )G::%<%#'$ ;9%<9 ;%88 .(&@.$8H (#8%#+# $9# .#$%$%&'#( :(&@

$9# %'`G(%&G) #::#<$) &: $9# =<$) <&@.8=%'#/ &:,h>Si

 

Y'/#( $9# U=A&( 2&/#* $9# &(/%'=(H ='/ .(&.#( (#<&G()# &: =' %88#?=88H /%)@%))#/ #@.8&H## %) $& :%8# =

<&@.8=%'$ :&( %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8 ;%$9 $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#(, h>Ri 3' $9# <=)# =$ A=(* .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$) /%)(#?=(/#/

$9%) (G8# ='/ /%(#<$8H ;#'$ $& $9# 6U-2 $9(&G?9 = .#$%$%&' :&( %'`G'<$%&' .(=H%'? $9=$ .#$%$%&'#( A# #'`&%'#/

:(&@ #':&(<%'? %$) /%)@%))=8 &(/#(), 3' ?54= -0. '%&$$0*h>Ti

 ;# (G8#/ $9=$ %: $9# (#@#/H %) ).#<%:%<=88H

.(&+%/#/ AH 8=;* %$ %) .(#)G@#/ $& A# =/#]G=$#, Z&(#&+#(* $9# .(#8%@%'=(H @='/=$&(H %'`G'<$%&' .(=H#/

:&( AH $9# .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$) %' $9#%( .#$%$%&' A#:&(# $9# 6U-2 <=' =8)& A# #'$#($=%'#/ AH $9# 8=A&(

=(A%$#( ;9&* =) )9&;' #=(8%#(* 9=) $9# ='<%88=(H .&;#( $& %))G# .(#8%@%'=(H %'`G'<$%&') &( (#)$(=%'%'? &(/#()=) =' %'<%/#'$ %' $9# <=)#) .#'/%'? A#:&(# 9%@ %' &(/#( $& .(#)#(+# $9# (%?9$) &: $9# .=($%#) /G(%'? $9#

.#'/#'<H &: $9# <=)#,h>Ei

 

XG($9#(@&(#* =' #_=@%'=$%&' &: .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$)l .#$%$%&' :&( %'`G'<$%&' (#+#=8) $9=$ %$ 9=) '& A=)%)

)%'<# $9#(# %) '& )9&;%'? &: ='H G(?#'<H &( %((#.=(=A8# %'`G(H ;9%<9 $9# .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$) @%?9$ )G::#(,

J' %'`G(H %) <&')%/#(#/ %((#.=(=A8# %: %$ %) &: )G<9 <&')$='$ ='/ :(#]G#'$ (#<G((#'<# $9=$ '& :=%( ='/

(#=)&'=A8# (#/(#)) <=' A# 9=/ $9#(#:&( %' = <&G($ &: 8=;*h>Pi

 &( ;9#(# $9#(# %) '& )$='/=(/ AH ;9%<9 $9#%(

=@&G'$ <=' A# @#=)G(#/ ;%$9 (#=)&'=A8# =<<G(=<H* $9=$ %)* %$ %) '&$ )G)<#.$%A8# &: @=$9#@=$%<=8

<&@.G$=$%&', 3$ %) <&')%/#(#/ %((#.=(=A8# %'`G(H ;9#' %$ <=''&$ A# =/#]G=$#8H <&@.#')=$#/ %' /=@=?#)

/G# $& $9# '=$G(# &: $9# %'`G(H %$)#8: &( $9# '=$G(# &: $9# (%?9$ &( .(&.#($H %'`G(#/ &( ;9#' $9#(# #_%)$) '&

<#($=%' .#<G'%=(H )$='/=(/ :&( $9# @#=)G(#@#'$ &: /=@=?#),h>Ci

 

3' $9# <=)# =$ A=(* $9# =88#?#/ %'`G(H ;9%<9 .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$) )$='/ $& )G::#( AH (#=)&' &: $9#%(

=88#?#/ %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8 <=' A# =/#]G=$#8H <&@.#')=$#/ ='/ $9#(#:&(#* $9#(# #_%)$) '& g%((#.=(=A8# %'`G(H*g

=) /#:%'#/ =A&+# ;9%<9 ;&G8/ '#<#))%$=$# $9# %))G='<# &: $9# %'`G'<$%&' )&G?9$ :&(, J($%<8# BEC &: $9#

U=A&( 2&/# .(&+%/#) $9=$ =' #@.8&H## ;9& %) G'`G)$8H /%)@%))#/ :(&@ #@.8&H@#'$ )9=88 A# #'$%$8#/ $&

(#%')$=$#@#'$* ;%$9&G$ 8&)) &: )#'%&(%$H (%?9$) ='/ &$9#( .(%+%8#?#)* ='/ $& $9# .=H@#'$ &: :G88

A=<\;=?#)* %'<8G)%+# &: =88&;='<#)* ='/ $& &$9#(A#'#:%$) &( $9#%( @&'#$=(H #]G%+=8#'$ <&@.G$#/ :(&@ $9#

$%@# 9%) <&@.#')=$%&' ;=) ;%$99#8/ :(&@ 9%@ G. $& $9# $%@# &: 9%) =<$G=8 (#%')$=$#@#'$,

Q9# (G8%'? &: $9# 6U-2 $9=$ $9# 4G.(#@# 2&G($ G.9#8/ %$) .&;#( $& %))G# $#@.&(=(H @='/=$&(H

%'`G'<$%&' &(/#() %' $9# <=)# &: 29#@&MQ#<9'%)<9# Z:?,* 3'<, [email protected]&H##) Y'%&'M0XJ* #$,=8, +), 29#@&M

Q#<9'%)<9# Z:?,* 3'<, #$,=8,* /&<\#$#/ =) N,-, 6&, >DEDI>* %) @%)8#=/%'?, J) <&((#<$8H =(?G#/ AH $9#

.#$%$%&'#(* '& )G<9 .(&'&G'<#@#'$ ;=) @=/# AH $9%) 2&G($ %' )=%/ <=)#, 5' F='G=(H BR*>CCI* ;# %))G#/ =

Z%'G$# -#)&8G$%&' %' $9# )GA`#<$ <=)# )$=$%'? =) :&88&;)a

g2&')%/#(%'? $9# =88#?=$%&') <&'$=%'#/* $9# %))G#) (=%)#/ ='/ $9# =(?G@#'$) =//G<#/ %' $9# .#$%$%&' :&(

<#($%&(=(% * =) ;#88 =) $9# <&@@#'$) &: A&$9 .GA8%< ='/ .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$) $9#(#&'* ='/ $9# (#.8H &: $9#

.#$%$%&'#() $& .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$l) @&$%&' $& /%)@%)) $9# .#$%$%&'* $9# 2&G($ -#)&8+#/ $& 016k $9# )=@#

:&( A#%'? .(#@=$G(#,g

3$ %) <8#=( :(&@ $9# =A&+# (#)&8G$%&' $9=$ ;# /%/ '&$ %' ='H;=H )G)$=%' $9# =<$%&' &: $9# 6U-2 %' %))G%'?)G<9 $#@.&(=(H @='/=$&(H %'`G'<$%&' AG$ (=$9#( ;# /%)@%))#/ $9# .#$%$%&' =) $9# 6U-2 9=/ H#$ $& (G8#

G.&' $9# @&$%&' :&( (#<&')%/#(=$%&' :%8#/ AH .#%$%&'#(, Q9G)* $9# @%'G$# (#)&8G$%&' /#'H%'? $9# .#$%$%&'

:&( A#%'? .(#@=$G(#8H :%8#/,

Page 65: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 65/108

X%'=88H* =' %'`G'<$%&'* =) =' #_$(=&(/%'=(H (#@#/H* %) '&$ :=+&(#/ %' 8=A&( 8=; <&')%/#(%'? $9=$ %$

?#'#(=88H 9=) '&$ .(&+#/ $& A# =' #::#<$%+# @#=') &: )#$$8%'? 8=A&( /%).G$#),hBDi

 3$ 9=) A##' $9# .&8%<H &: $9#

4$=$# $& #'<&G(=?# $9# .=($%#) $& G)# $9# '&'M`G/%<%=8 .(&<#)) &: '#?&$%=$%&' ='/ <&@.(&@%)#* @#/%=$%&'

='/ =(A%$(=$%&',hB>i Q9G)* %'`G'<$%&') @=H A# %))G#/ &'8H %' <=)#) &: #_$(#@# '#<#))%$H A=)#/ &' 8#?=8

?(&G'/) <8#=(8H #)$=A8%)9#/* =:$#( /G# <&')G8$=$%&') &( 9#=(%'? ='/ ;9#' =88 #::&($) =$ <&'<%8%=$%&' =(#

#_9=G)$#/ ;9%<9 :=<$&()* 9&;#+#(* =(# <8#=(8H =A)#'$ %' $9# .(#)#'$ <=)#,

=9%&%6+&%* $9# .#$%$%&' %) 9#(#AH N-J6Q10, Q9# =))=%8#/ 5(/#() /=$#/ J.(%8 I*>CCR ='/ Z=H

I>*>CCR* %))G#/ AH $9# 6=$%&'=8 U=A&( -#8=$%&') 2&@@%))%&' KX%()$ 0%+%)%&'L* %' 6U-2 62- 32 6&, DDDRTIMCR*

=(# 9#(#AH -1V1-410 ='/ 41Q J4301,

'+ +&7%&%7<

/(I5751* GF%5&,45+H@ T(7*@ '6+*@ ='/ T(+1*85@ EE.@ <&'<G(, 

Page 66: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 66/108

 

;!)#!' >(=(/9# 234 -(:)% >(=(/9#5 "#$%$%&'#()*

+),

7+.#"#% 7%) l!%&+ 234 9+"< ;!7-% .("!%) &< 1(&+5 .CEIHSHLJE23 1IJ2L /HKIE5 ,I23DB Zc5 lKCmH3

/JEQ5 -#).&'/#'$),

0 1 2 3 4 3 5 6

1#"-(5 !"# 

Q9%) %) = .#$%$%&' :&( (#+%#; &' <#($%&(=(% G'/#( -G8# SR &: $9# -G8#) &: 2%+%8 "(&<#/G(#* =))=%8%'? $;&

(#)&8G$%&') &: $9# -#?%&'=8 Q(%=8 2&G($ K-Q2L* O(='<9 BBT* pG#^&' 2%$H ;9%<9 =::%(@#/ $9# `G(%)/%<$%&' &:

$9# Z#$(&.&8%$=' Q(%=8 2&G($ KZ#Q2L* O(='<9 SB* pG#^&' 2%$H &+#( .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$W) =<$%&' :&( /=@=?#)

=?=%')$ .#$%$%&'#(,

Q9# :&88&;%'? :=<$G=8 ='$#<#/#'$) =(# @=$$#() &: (#<&(/,!U--$%&!.+V)  

3' =' J::%/=+%$M2&@.8=%'$ /=$#/ >S JG?G)$ BDDB* .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ 0&@%'%# 0#8 pG#(& <9=(?#/ JeF

-=H@G'/& "=;')9&.* 3'<,* V%(?%8%& b=;=<9% ='/ .#$%$%&'#( FG8%G) b=;=<9% ;%$9 %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8* '&'M

#_#<G$%&' &: = <&'$(=<$ &: #@.8&H@#'$* +%&8=$%&' &: $9# @%'%@G@ ;=?# 8=;* ='/ '&'M.=H@#'$ &: &+#($%@#

.=H, Q9# <&@.8=%'$ ;=) :%8#/ A#:&(# $9# 6=$%&'=8 U=A&( -#8=$%&') 2&@@%))%&' K6U-2L,> 

Q9# <&@.8=%'$ #))#'$%=88H =88#?#/ $9=$ V%(?%8%& b=;=<9% 9%(#/ .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ =) = <8#(\ &: $9# .=;')9&.

='/ $9=$ &' <#($=%' &<<=)%&')* )9# ;&(\#/ A#H&'/ $9# (#?G8=( ;&(\%'? 9&G() AG$ ;=) '&$ .=%/ $9#

<&((#).&'/%'? &+#($%@# .=H,

Q9# <&@.8=%'$ =8)& '=((=$#/ =' %'<%/#'$ &' >D JG?G)$ BDDB* ;9#(#%' .#$%$%&'#( FG8%G) b=;=<9% )<&8/#/

.(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ %' :(&'$ &: @='H .#&.8# =A&G$ $9# ;=H )9# $(#=$#/ $9# <G)$&@#() &: $9# .=;')9&. ='/=:$#(;=(/) $#(@%'=$#/ .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$W) #@.8&H@#'$ ;%$9&G$ =::&(/%'? 9#( /G# .(&<#)),

5' E 6&+#@A#( BDDB* .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ 0&@%'%# 0#8 pG#(& :%8#/ =' =<$%&' :&( /=@=?#) =?=%')$

.#$%$%&'#() FG8%G) b=;=<9% ='/ N=H8# b=;=<9% A#:&(# $9# Z#Q2 &: pG#^&' 2%$H,B Q9# <&@.8=%'$* ;9%<9 ;=)

/&<\#$#/ =) 2%+%8 2=)# 6&, BCRBB* =88#?#/ $9# :&88&;%'?a

B, Q9=$ $9# "8=%'$%:: ;=) #@.8&H#/ =) = <8#(\ %' $9# .=;')9&. AG)%'#)) &::%<# &: $9# 0#:#'/='$)

&$9#(;%)# \'&;' =) $9# JeF -JkZY605 "J764d5"* 362, 8&<=$#/ K)%<L ='/ ;%$9 .(%'<%.=8 &::%<#

=//(#)) =$ Y'%$ J V%(\= O8/?, 1/)= 2&('#( -&&)#+#8$h*i pG#^&' 2%$H* :(&@ Z=H BE* BDDB $& JG?G)$

>D* BDDB[

I, Q9=$ &' JG?G)$ >D* BDDB =$ &( =A&G$ >>aID JZ* $9# "8=%'$%:: ;=) =/@&'%)9#/ AH $9# 0#:#'/='$)

FG8%G) b=;=<9% ='/ N=H8# b=;=<9% ;9& =(# =<$%'? =) @='=?#( ='/ =))%)$='$ @='=?#( (#).#<$%+#8H &:

$9# .=;')9&. AG)%'#)) ='/ =8$#('=$#8H =<<G)#/ 9#( &: 9=+%'? <&@@%$$#/ =' =<$ ;9%<9 )9# 9=/ '&$

/&'# ='/ ;=) )<&8/#/ %' = 8&G/ +&%<# %' :(&'$ &: @='H #@.8&H##) ='/ <G)$&@#() %' $9#%( &::%<#)[

S, Q9=$ :G($9#( :&( '& =..=(#'$ (#=)&' $9# "8=%'$%:: ;=) &(/#(#/ $& ?#$ &G$ ='/ 8#=+# $9# .=;')9&.

&::%<# ='/ ;=) $&8/ $& ;=%$ :&( 9#( )=8=(H &G$)%/# $9# &::%<# ;9#' )9# $(%#/ $& #_.8=%' $9=$ )9# 9=/

'& :=G8$ %' $9# <&@.8=%'$ &: $9# <G)$&@#(* K)%<L hdi&;#+#(h*i 9#( #_.8='=$%&' :#88 &' /#=: #=()[

R, Q9=$ )9# ;=) %')$='$8H /%)@%))#/ :(&@ 9#( `&A ;%$9&G$ /G# .(&<#))[

Page 67: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 67/108

T, Q9=$ $9# %'<%/#'$ 9=..#'#/ %' :(&'$ &: @='H .#&.8# ;9%<9 <=G)#/ $9# "8=%'$%:: $& )G::#( )#(%&G)

#@A=((=))@#'$ ='/ )9=@# )& $9=$ )9# <&G8/ '&$ /& ='H$9%'? AG$ <(H A#<=G)# &: $9# )9=@#8#)) ;=H

AH ;9%<9 )9# ;=) $#(@%'=$#/ :(&@ $9# )#(+%<#[ _ _ _I 

Q9# <&@.8=%'$ :&( /=@=?#) ).#<%:%<=88H )&G?9$ $9# (#<&+#(H &: @&(=8 /=@=?#)* #_#@.8=(H /=@=?#) ='/

=$$&('#HW) :##),

"#$%$%&'#() @&+#/ :&( $9# /%)@%))=8 &: $9# <&@.8=%'$ &' $9# ?(&G'/) &: 8=<\ &: `G(%)/%<$%&' ='/ :&(G@M)9&..%'? &( ).8%$$%'? <=G)#) &: =<$%&', J$ :%()$* $9# Z#Q2 ?(='$#/ .#$%$%&'#()W @&$%&' ='/ &(/#(#/ $9#

/%)@%))=8 &: $9# <&@.8=%'$ :&( 8=<\ &: `G(%)/%<$%&' %' =' 5(/#( /=$#/ B F='G=(H BDDI,S Y.&' .(%+=$#

(#).&'/#'$W) @&$%&'* $9# Z#Q2 (#<&')%/#(#/ ='/ )#$ =)%/# $9# &(/#( &: /%)@%))=8 %' =' 5(/#( /=$#/ I

Z=(<9 BDDI,R 3$ (G8#/ $9=$ '& <=G)=8 <&''#<$%&' =..#=(#/ A#$;##' .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$W) <=G)# &: =<$%&'

='/ $9# #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&') A#$;##' $9# .=($%#), Q9# Z#Q2 =8)& (#`#<$#/ .#$%$%&'#()W @&$%&' :&(

(#<&')%/#(=$%&' %' =' 5(/#( /=$#/ BB J.(%8 BDDI,T 

Q9G)* .#$%$%&'#() #8#+=$#/ $9# Z#Q2W) =:&(#)=%/ $;& &(/#() $& $9# -Q2* O(='<9 BBT &: pG#^&' 2%$H* -&5 =

"#$%$%&' :&( 2#($%&(=(% K7%$9 "(=H#( :&( Q#@.&(=(H -#)$(=%'%'? 5(/#( ='/e&( "(#8%@%'=(H 3'`G'<$%&'L, J:$#(

/G# 9#=(%'?* $9# -Q2 /#<8%'#/ .#$%$%&'#()W .(=H#( :&( = $#@.&(=(H (#)$(=%'%'? &(/#(, X&( 9#( .=($* .(%+=$#(#).&'/#'$ :%8#/ = Z&$%&' $& 0%)@%)) "#$%$%&',

5' BD 5<$&A#( BDDI* $9# -Q2 %))G#/ $9# =))=%8#/ -#)&8G$%&'* G.9&8/%'? $9# `G(%)/%<$%&' &: $9# Z#Q2 &+#(

.(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$W) <&@.8=%'$ :&( /=@=?#),E 

Q9# -Q2 9#8/ $9=$ .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$W) =<$%&' :&( /=@=?#) ;=) A=)#/ &' $9# =88#?#/ $&($%&G) =<$)

<&@@%$$#/ AH 9#( #@.8&H#() ='/ /%/ '&$ )##\ ='H (#8%#: G'/#( $9# U=A&( 2&/#, Q9# -Q2 <%$#/ $9#

.(&'&G'<#@#'$ %' T(1&+5@ () 57. -. W*+. F50),*KS5,)*7*4(* ();.@ () 57.P ;9#(# $9# 2&G($ 9#8/ $9=$ $9#

#@.8&H##W) =<$%&' :&( /=@=?#) A=)#/ &' $9# )8='/#(&G) (#@=(\) G$$#(#/ AH $9# #@.8&H#( ;=) ;%$9%' $9#

(#?G8=( <&G($)W `G(%)/%<$%&' )%'<# $9# <&@.8=%'$ /%/ '&$ =88#?# ='H G':=%( 8=A&( .(=<$%<# &' $9# .=($ &: $9#

#@.8&H#(,

5' BC Z=(<9 BDDS* $9# -Q2 /#'%#/ .#$%$%&'#()W @&$%&' :&( (#<&')%/#(=$%&',C d#'<#* $9# %')$='$ .#$%$%&' :&(

(#+%#; &' <#($%&(=(%* (=%)%'? $9# )&8# %))G# &: `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$W) <&@.8=%'$ :&( /=@=?#),

"#$%$%&'#() =(?G# $9=$ $9# 6U-2 9=) `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( $9# =<$%&' :&( /=@=?#) A#<=G)# $9# =88#?#/ %'`G(H %)

;&(\M(#8=$#/, Q9#H =8)& <&'$#'/ $9=$ .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ )9&G8/ '&$ A# =88&;#/ $& ).8%$ 9#( <=G)#) &:

=<$%&' AH :%8%'? $9# =<$%&' :&( /=@=?#) )#.=(=$#8H :(&@ $9# 8=A&( <=)#,

"(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ @=%'$=%') $9=$ $9#(# %) '& <=G)=8 <&''#<$%&' A#$;##' 9#( <=G)# &: =<$%&' ='/ $9#

#@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&') &: $9# .=($%#),

Q9# .#$%$%&' %) @#(%$&(%&G),

Q9# `G(%)/%<$%&'=8 <&'$(&+#()H &: $9# )&($ .(#)#'$#/ %' $9%) <=)# 9=) 8&'? A##' )#$$8#/ AH $9%) 2&G($,

J($%<8# B>EK=L &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#* =) =@#'/#/* <8#=(8H A#)$&;) G.&' $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( &(%?%'=8 ='/ #_<8G)%+#

 `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( <8=%@) :&( /=@=?#) =(%)%'? :(&@ #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&') o%' &$9#( ;&(/)* $9# U=A&(

J(A%$#( 9=) `G(%)/%<$%&' $& =;=(/ '&$ &'8H $9# (#8%#:) .(&+%/#/ AH 8=A&( 8=;)* AG$ =8)& /=@=?#) ?&+#('#/ AH

$9# 2%+%8 2&/#,>D

 

3' $9# >CCC <=)# &: C5+ T&I6(7 F*,$*,5)&*+ -. 3);6=5+@>>

 $9# 2&G($ '&$#/ ;9=$ ;=) $9#' $9# <G((#'$ $(#'/*

='/ )$%88 %)* $& (#:#( ;&(\#(M#@.8&H#( <&'$(&+#()%#) $& 8=A&( <&G($)* G'8#)) G'@%)$=\=A8H .(&+%/#/ AH $9#

8=; $& A# &$9#(;%)#, O#<=G)# &: $9# $(#'/* $9# 2&G($ '&$#/ :G($9#(* `G(%).(G/#'<# 9=) /#+#8&.#/ $9#

g(#=)&'=A8# <=G)=8 <&''#<$%&' (G8#,g Y'/#( $9%) (G8#* %: $9#(# %) = (#=)&'=A8# <=G)=8 <&''#<$%&' A#$;##'

Page 68: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 68/108

$9# <8=%@ =))#($#/ ='/ $9# #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')* $9#' $9# <=)# %) ;%$9%' $9# `G(%)/%<$%&' &: &G(

8=A&( <&G($), 3' $9# =A)#'<# &: )G<9 '#_G)* %$ %) $9# (#?G8=( <&G($) $9=$ 9=+# `G(%)/%<$%&',>B

 

3' C5+ T&I6(7 F*,$*,5)&*+*>I

 $9# 2&G($ G.9#8/ $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#(W) `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( $9# #@.8&H##)W )#.=(=$#

=<$%&' :&( /=@=?#)* ;9%<9 =8)& )&G?9$ $9# 'G88%:%<=$%&' &: $9# )&M<=88#/ g<&'$(=<$ &: $#(@%'=$%&'g ='/ '&$#/

$9=$ $9# =88#?=$%&') %' $9# <&@.8=%'$ ;#(# )& <=(#:G88H :&(@G8=$#/ =) $& =+&%/ = )#@A8='<# &: #@.8&H#(M

#@.8&H## (#8=$%&'),

3' )=%/ <=)#* $9# #@.8&H##) &: 4=' Z%?G#8 2&(.&(=$%&' K4Z2L =+=%8#/ &: $9# g-#$(#'<9@#'$ $& "(#+#'$ U&))

"(&?(=@,g J:$#( $9#%( %'<8G)%&' %' $9# (#$(#'<9@#'$ .(&?(=@* $9# #@.8&H##) ;#(# ?%+#' $9#%( $#(@%'=$%&'

8#$$#() ='/ )#.=(=$%&' .=H, 3' (#$G('* $9# #@.8&H##) #_#<G$#/ g(#<#%.$ ='/ (#8#=)#g /&<G@#'$) %' :=+&( &:

$9# <&@.='H, 4GA)#]G#'$8H* $9# #@.8&H##) 8#=('#/ $9=$ $9# <&@.='H ;=) '#+#( %' :%'='<%=8 /%)$(#)) ='/

;=) #'?=?#/ %' 9%(%'? '#; #@.8&H##), Q9G)* $9#H :%8#/ = <&@.8=%'$

A#:&(# $9# 6U-2 :&( $9# /#<8=(=$%&' &: 'G88%$H &: $9# (#$(#'<9@#'$ .(&?(=@ ='/ .(=H#/ :&( (#%')$=$#@#'$*

A=<\;=?#) ='/ /=@=?#), J:$#( $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#( /%)@%))#/ $9# <&@.8=%'$* $9# #@.8&H##) :%8#/ =' =<$%&' :&(

/=@=?#) A#:&(# $9# -Q2* =88#?%'? $9# /#<#.$%&' #@.8&H#/ G.&' $9#@ AH 4Z2 ;9%<9 8#/ $& $9#%(

)#.=(=$%&' :(&@ $9# <&@.='H, Q9#H )&G?9$ $9# /#<8=(=$%&' &: 'G88%$H &: $9#%( )&M<=88#/ <&88#<$%+# g<&'$(=<$&: $#(@%'=$%&'g ='/ $9# (#<&+#(H &: =<$G=8 ='/ <&@.#')=$&(H /=@=?#)* @&(=8 /=@=?#)* #_#@.8=(H

/=@=?#)* ='/ =$$&('#HW) :##),

Q9# 2&G($ 9#8/ $9=$ $9# #@.8&H##)W <8=%@ :&( /=@=?#) ;=) %'$#($;%'#/ ;%$9 $9#%( 9=+%'? A##' )#.=(=$#/

:(&@ $9#%( #@.8&H@#'$ ;%$9&G$ `G)$ <=G)# ='/* <&')#]G#'$8H* 9=/ = (#=)&'=A8# <=G)=8 <&''#<$%&' ;%$9

$9#%( #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&') ;%$9 .#$%$%&'#(, Q9# 2&G($ #_.8=%'#/ %' $9%) @=''#(a

_ _ _ X%()$* $9#%( <8=%@ :&( /=@=?#) %) ?(&G'/#/ &' $9#%( 9=+%'? A##' /#<#%+#/ %'$& )#(+%'? $9#%(

#@.8&H@#'$ /G# $& 4Z2W) <&'<&<$#/ :%'='<%=8 /%)$(#)) ='/ :(=G/G8#'$ (#$(#'<9@#'$ .(&?(=@o= <8#=(

<=)# &: %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8, 4#<&'/* = <&@.=(%)&' &: (#).&'/#'$)W <&@.8=%'$ :&( $9# /#<8=(=$%&' &: 'G88%$H &:

$9# (#$(#'<9@#'$ .(&?(=@ A#:&(# $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#( ='/ $9# <&@.8=%'$ :&( $9# /#<8=(=$%&' &: 'G88%$H &: $9#%(

g<&'$(=<$ &: $#(@%'=$%&'g A#:&(# $9# -Q2 (#+#=8) $9=$ $9# =88#?=$%&') ='/ .(=H#( &: $9# :&(@#( =(# =8@&)$

%/#'$%<=8 ;%$9 $9&)# &: $9# 8=$$#( #_<#.$ $9=$ $9# .(=H#( :&( (#%')$=$#@#'$ ;=) '& 8&'?#( %'<8G/#/ ='/ $9#

<8=%@ :&( A=<\;=?#) ='/ &$9#( A#'#:%$) ;=) (#.8=<#/ ;%$9 = <8=%@ :&( =<$G=8 /=@=?#), Q9#)# =(# $#88$=8#

)%?') $9=$ (#).&'/#'$)W <8=%@ :&( /=@=?#) %) %'$#($;%'#/ ;%$9 $9#%( 9=+%'? A##' )#.=(=$#/ :(&@ $9#%(

#@.8&H@#'$ ;%$9&G$ `G)$ <=G)# ='/* <&')#]G#'$8H* 9=) = (#=)&'=A8# <=G)=8 <&''#<$%&' ;%$9 $9#%(

#@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&') ;%$9 4Z2, J<<&(/%'?8H* %$ <=''&$ A# /#'%#/ $9=$ (#).&'/#'$)W <8=%@ :=88)

G'/#( $9# `G(%)/%<$%&' &: $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#( =) .(&+%/#/ %' .=(=?(=.9 S &: J($%<8# B>E,>S

 

Q9# g(#=)&'=A8# <=G)=8 <&''#<$%&' (G8#g #@#(?#/ %' $9# >CPE <=)# &: ',&4(,* -. N+)(,4(1&5)( L$$(775)(

F*6,) *>R;9#(# $9# 2&G($ (#<&?'%^#/ $9# `G(%)/%<$%&' &: $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#() &+#( <8=%@) :&( /=@=?#) %'<&''#<$%&' ;%$9 $#(@%'=$%&' &: #@.8&H@#'$* $9G)a

3$ %) <8#=( $9=$ $9# ]G#)$%&' &: $9# 8#?=8%$H &: $9# 5;) *9 1&04&0057 %) %'$%@=$#8H (#8=$#/ $& $9# %))G# &: $9#

8#?=8%$H &: )%( 45++(, =< #%&;% )%5) 5;) *9 1&04&0057 #50 $(,9*,4(1 , OG$ ;9%8# $9# U=A&( 2&/# $(#=$) &: $9#

'=$G(# &:* ='/ $9# (#@#/H =+=%8=A8# =)

(#?=(/) $9# :%()$ f $9# #@.8&H##W) )#.=(=$%&' :(&@ #@.8&H@#'$ f %$ /&#) '&$ =$ =88 /#=8 ;%$9 $9# )#<&'/ f

$9# @=''#( &: $9=$ )#.=(=$%&' f ;9%<9 %) ?&+#('#/ #_<8G)%+#8H AH $9# 2%+%8 2&/#, 3' =//(#))%'? $9# :%()$

%))G#* $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( =..8%#) $9# U=A&( 2&/#[ %' =//(#))%'? $9# )#<&'/* $9# 2%+%8 2&/#, J'/ $9%) =..#=()

$& A# $9# .8=%' ='/ .=$#'$ %'$#'/@#'$ &: $9# 8=;, X&( =.=($ :(&@ $9# (#8%#:) #_.(#))8H )#$ &G$ %' $9# U=A&(2&/# :8&;%'? :(&@ %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8 :(&@ #@.8&H@#'$* '& &$9#( 1545I(0 @=H A# =;=(/#/ $& =' %88#?=88H

/%)@%))#/ #@.8&H## &$9#( $9=' $9&)# ).#<%:%#/ AH $9# 2%+%8 2&/#, d#'<#* $9# :=<$ $9=$ $9# %))G#o&:

;9#$9#( &( '&$ @&(=8 &( &$9#( /=@=?#) ;#(# )G::#(#/ AH =' #@.8&H## ='/ %' $9# =::%(@=$%+#* $9# =@&G'$

Page 69: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 69/108

$9=$ )9&G8/ .(&.#(8H A# =;=(/#/ $& 9%@ %' $9# <%(<G@)$='<#)o%) /#$#(@%'#/ G'/#( $9# .(&+%)%&') &: $9#

2%+%8 2&/# ='/ '&$ $9# U=A&( 2&/#* &A+%&G)8H ;=) '&$ @#='$ $& <(#=$# = <=G)# &: =<$%&' %'/#.#'/#'$ &:

$9=$ :&( %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8 ='/ $9G) .8=<# $9# @=$$#( A#H&'/ $9# U=A&( J(A%$#(W) `G(%)/%<$%&',>T

 

3' $9# %')$='$ <=)#* $9# =88#?=$%&') %' .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$W) <&@.8=%'$ :&( /=@=?#) )9&; $9=$ 9#( %'`G(H ;=)

$9# &::)9&&$ &: .#$%$%&'#()W %@@#/%=$# 9=()9 (#=<$%&' =) 9#( =/@%'%)$(=$%+# )G.#(%&() $& $9# )G..&)#/8H

)8&..H @=''#( AH ;9%<9 )9# 9=/ /%)<9=(?#/ 9#( /G$%#),

"#$%$%&'#()W (#=<$%&' <G8@%'=$#/ %' .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$W) /%)@%))=8 :(&@ ;&(\ %' $9# +#(H )=@# %'<%/#'$, Q9#

%'<%/#'$ &' >D JG?G)$ BDDB =88#?#/ %' $9# <&@.8=%'$ :&( /=@=?#) ;=) )%@%8=(8H '=((=$#/ %' .(%+=$#

(#).&'/#'$W) J::%/=+%$M2&@.8=%'$ )G..&($%'? 9#( =<$%&' :&( %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8 A#:&(# $9# 6U-2, 28#=(8H* $9#

=88#?#/ %'`G(H %) /%(#<$8H (#8=$#/ $& $9# #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&') &: $9# .=($%#),

79#(# $9# #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. %) @#(#8H %'<%/#'$=8 ='/ $9# <=G)# &: =<$%&' .(&<##/) :(&@ =

/%::#(#'$ )&G(<# &: &A8%?=$%&'* $9# 2&G($ 9=) '&$ 9#)%$=$#/ $& G.9&8/ $9# `G(%)/%<$%&' &: $9# (#?G8=(

<&G($), 79#(# $9# /=@=?#) <8=%@#/ :&( ;#(# A=)#/ &' $&($* @=8%<%&G) .(&)#<G$%&'* &( A(#=<9 &: <&'$(=<$*

=) ;9#' $9# <8=%@='$ )##\) $& (#<&+#( = /#A$ :(&@ = :&(@#( #@.8&H## &( )##\) 8%]G%/=$#/ /=@=?#) %' $9#

#':&(<#@#'$ &: = .(%&( #@.8&H@#'$ <&'$(=<$*>E

 $9# `G(%)/%<$%&' &: (#?G8=( <&G($) ;=) G.9#8/, Q9# )<#'=(%&

$9=$ &A$=%') %' $9%) <=)# %) &A+%&G)8H /%::#(#'$, Q9# =88#?=$%&') %' .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$W) <&@.8=%'$

G'@%)$=\=A8H (#8=$# $& $9# @=''#( &: 9#( =88#?#/ %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8,

X&( = )%'?8# <=G)# &: =<$%&'* $9# /%)@%))#/ #@.8&H## <=''&$ A# =88&;#/ $& )G# %' $;& :&(G@)a &'#* A#:&(#

$9# 8=A&( =(A%$#( :&( (#%')$=$#@#'$ ='/ (#<&+#(H &: A=<\ ;=?#) &( :&( )#.=(=$%&' .=H* G.&' $9# $9#&(H $9=$

$9# /%)@%))=8 ;=) %88#?=8[ ='/ $;&* A#:&(# = <&G($ &: `G)$%<# :&( (#<&+#(H &: @&(=8 ='/ &$9#( /=@=?#)* G.&'

$9# $9#&(H $9=$ $9#

@=''#( &: /%)@%))=8 ;=) G'/G8H %'`G(%&G) &( $&($%&G), 4G%'? %' $9# @=''#( /#)<(%A#/ %) \'&;' =) g).8%$$%'?

= <=G)# &: =<$%&'*g = .(=<$%<# #'?#'/#(%'? @G8$%.8%<%$H &: =<$%&'), 3$ %) <&')%/#(#/ .(&<#/G(=88H G')&G'/ ='/

&A'&_%&G) $& $9# &(/#(8H =/@%'%)$(=$%&' &: `G)$%<#,>P

 

3' $9# %')$='$ <=)#* $9# 6U-2 9=) `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$W) <&@.8=%'$ :&( %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8 ='/

/=@=?#) =(%)%'? $9#(#:(&@, 49# <=''&$ A# =88&;#/ $& :%8# = )#.=(=$# &( %'/#.#'/#'$ <%+%8 =<$%&' :&(

/=@=?#) ;9#(# $9# =88#?#/ %'`G(H 9=) = (#=)&'=A8# <&''#<$%&' $& 9#( $#(@%'=$%&' :(&@ #@.8&H@#'$,

2&')#]G#'$8H* $9# =<$%&' :&( /=@=?#) :%8#/ A#:&(# $9# Z#Q2 @G)$ A# /%)@%))#/,

7d1-1X5-1* $9# .#$%$%&' :&( (#+%#; &' <#($%&(=(% %) N-J6Q10, Q9# $;& -#)&8G$%&') /=$#/ BD 5<$&A#( BDDI

='/ BC Z=(<9 BDDS &: $9# -#?%&'=8 Q(%=8 2&G($* O(='<9 BBT* pG#^&' 2%$H =(# -1V1-410 ='/ 41Q J4301,

2&)$) =?=%')$ .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$,

45 5-01-10,

7("1% +< 1#"-( 

J))&<%=$# FG)$%<#

Page 70: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 70/108

 

09#)#00#"% "(1#+"() ,(">5 %&+,+,0*&'A 1-< 6)+&%"/% +< /(,("'(-5 '&-%0*2&*+" 

7 % / # ' # + "

0("-("#,("5 ! <A

Q9# 2&G($ (#%$#(=$#) $9# A=)%< .&8%<H $9=$ =88 X%8%.%'& ;&(\#()* ;9#$9#( #@.8&H#/ 8&<=88H &( &+#()#=)*#'`&H $9# .(&$#<$%+# @='$8# &: "9%8%..%'# 8=A&( ='/ )&<%=8 8#?%)8=$%&'), 5G( 8=A&( )$=$G$#) @=H '&$ A#

(#'/#(#/ %'#::#<$%+# AH 8=;) &( `G/?@#'$) .(&@G8?=$#/* &( )$%.G8=$%&') =?(##/ G.&'* %' = :&(#%?' <&G'$(H,

1BC /2FC

O#:&(# G) %) = "#$%$%&' :&( -#+%#; &' F(,)&*,5,& h>i

  G'/#( -G8# SR &: $9# -G8#) &: 2&G($* )##\%'? $&

(#+#()# ='/ )#$ =)%/# $9# FG8H >T* BDDB 0#<%)%&'hBi

 ='/ $9# F='G=(H BC* BDDI -#)&8G$%&'hIi

 &: $9# 2&G($ &:

J..#=8) K2JL %' 2JMN- 4" 6&, TPSDI, Q9# =))=%8#/ 0#<%)%&' /%)@%))#/ $9# 2J "#$%$%&' K:%8#/ AH 9#(#%'

.#$%$%&'#(L* ;9%<9 9=/ )&G?9$ $& (#+#()# $9# 6=$%&'=8 U=A&( -#8=$%&') 2&@@%))%&' K6U-2L) FG'# BC* BDD>-#)&8G$%&'*

hSi =::%(@%'? U=A&( J(A%$#( F&#8 4, UG)$(%=) F='G=(H >P* BDDD 0#<%)%&',

hRi 

Q9# =))=%8#/ 2J -#)&8G$%&' /#'%#/ 9#(#%' .#$%$%&'#() Z&$%&' :&( -#<&')%/#(=$%&',

1BC 62DEF

Q9# :=<$) =(# '=((=$#/ AH $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) =) :&88&;)a

3' 8=$# >CCP* h9#(#%' -#).&'/#'$ X8&(#'<# 2=A=')=?i =((%+#/ %' 4%'?=.&(# =) = $&G(%)$, 49# =..8%#/:&( #@.8&H@#'$* ;%$9 $9# 4%'?=.&(# O(='<9 &: $9# "9%8%..%'# 6=$%&'=8 O='\* = .(%+=$# A='\%'? <&(.&(=$%&'

&(?='%^#/ ='/ #_%)$%'? G'/#( $9# 8=;) &: $9# "9%8%..%'#)* ;%$9 .(%'<%.=8 &::%<#) =$ $9# "6O X%'='<%=8 2#'$#(*

-&_=) O&G8#+=(/* Z='%8=, J$ $9# $%@#* $9# 4%'?=.&(# "6O O(='<9 ;=) G'/#( $9# 9#8@ &: -GA#' 2, Q&A%=)* =

8=;H#(* =) N#'#(=8 Z='=?#(* ;%$9 $9# (='\ &: V%<#M"(#)%/#'$ &: $9# O='\, J$ $9# $%@#* $&&* $9# O(='<9

5::%<# 9=/ $;& KBL $H.#) &: #@.8&H##)a K=L #_.=$(%=$#) &( $9# (#?G8=( #@.8&H##)* 9%(#/ %' Z='%8= ='/

=))%?'#/ =A(&=/ %'<8G/%'? 4%'?=.&(#* ='/ KAL 8&<=88H K/%(#<$L 9%(#/, 49# =..8%#/ :&( #@.8&H@#'$ =) O(='<9

2(#/%$ 5::%<#(* =$ = $&$=8 @&'$98H .=<\=?# &: v4NS*RDD,DD* #::#<$%+# G.&' =))G@.$%&' &: /G$%#) =:$#(

=..(&+=8, -GA#' 2, Q&A%=) :&G'/ 9#( #@%'#'$8H ]G=8%:%#/ ='/ ;(&$# &' 5<$&A#( BT* >CCP* = 8#$$#( $& $9#

"(#)%/#'$ &: $9# O='\ %' Z='%8=* (#<&@@#'/%'? $9# =..&%'$@#'$ &: X8&(#'<# 5, 2=A=')=?* :&( $9# .&)%$%&',

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

Q9# "(#)%/#'$ &: $9# O='\ ;=) %@.(#))#/ ;%$9 $9# <(#/#'$%=8) &: X8&(#'<# 5, 2=A=')=? $9=$ 9# =..(&+#/

$9# (#<&@@#'/=$%&' &: -GA#' 2, Q&A%=), 49# $9#' :%8#/ =' J..8%<=$%&'* ;%$9 $9# Z%'%)$(H &: Z='.&;#( &:

$9# N&+#('@#'$ &: 4%'?=.&(#* :&( $9# %))G='<# &: =' [email protected]&H@#'$ "=)) =) =' #@.8&H## &: $9# 4%'?=.&(#

"6O O(='<9, d#( =..8%<=$%&' ;=) =..(&+#/ :&( = .#(%&/ &: $;& KBL H#=(),

5' 0#<#@A#( E* >CCP* -GA#' 2, Q&A%=) ;(&$# = 8#$$#( $& X8&(#'<# 5, 2=A=')=? &::#(%'? 9#( = $#@.&(=(H

=..&%'$@#'$* =) 2(#/%$ 5::%<#(* =$ = A=)%< )=8=(H &: 4%'?=.&(# 0&88=() S*RDD,DD* = @&'$9 ='/* G.&' 9#(

)G<<#)):G8 <&@.8#$%&' &: 9#( .(&A=$%&' $& A# /#$#(@%'#/ )&8#8H* AH $9# O='\* )9# @=H A# #_$#'/#/ =$ $9#

/%)<(#$%&' &: $9# O='\* = .#(@='#'$ =..&%'$@#'$ ='/ $9=$ 9#( $#@.&(=(H =..&%'$@#'$ ;=) )GA`#<$ $& $9#

:&88&;%'? $#(@) ='/ <&'/%$%&')a

Page 71: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 71/108

>, k&G ;%88 A# &' .(&A=$%&' :&( = .#(%&/ &: $9(## KIL <&')#<G$%+# @&'$9) :(&@ $9# /=$# &: H&G( =))G@.$%&'

&: /G$H,

B, k&G ;%88 &A)#(+# $9# O='\) (G8#) ='/ (#?G8=$%&') ='/ $9&)# $9=$ @=H A# =/&.$#/ :(&@ $%@# $& $%@#,

I, k&G ;%88 \##. %' )$(%<$#)$ <&':%/#'<# =88 @=$$#() (#8=$#/ $& $(=')=<$%&') A#$;##' $9# O='\ ='/ %$) <8%#'$),

S, k&G ;%88 /#+&$# H&G( :G88 $%@# /G(%'? AG)%'#)) 9&G() %' .(&@&$%'? $9# AG)%'#)) ='/ %'$#(#)$ &: $9# O='\,

R, k&G ;%88 '&$* ;%$9&G$ .(%&( ;(%$$#' <&')#'$ &: $9# O='\* A# #@.8&H#/ %' ='H;=H :&( ='H .G(.&)#

;9=$)&#+#( &G$)%/# AG)%'#)) 9&G() AH ='H .#()&'* :%(@ &( <&@.='H,

T, Q#(@%'=$%&' &: H&G( #@.8&H@#'$ ;%$9 $9# O='\ @=H A# @=/# AH #%$9#( .=($H =:$#( '&$%<# &: &'# K>L /=H

%' ;(%$%'? /G(%'? .(&A=$%&'* &'# @&'$9 '&$%<# G.&' <&':%(@=$%&' &( $9# #]G%+=8#'$ &: &'# K>L /=H) &(

@&'$9) )=8=(H %' 8%#G &: '&$%<#,

X8&(#'<# 5, 2=A=')=? =<<#.$#/ $9# .&)%$%&' ='/ =))G@#/ &::%<#, 3' $9# @#='$%@#* $9# "9%8%..%'# 1@A=))H

%' 4%'?=.&(# .(&<#))#/ $9# #@.8&H@#'$ <&'$(=<$ &: X8&(#'<# 5, 2=A=')=? ='/* &' Z=(<9 P* >CCC* )9# ;=)

%))G#/ AH $9# "9%8%..%'# 5+#()#=) [email protected]&H@#'$ J/@%'%)$(=$%&'* =' 5+#()#=) [email protected]&H@#'$ 2#($%:%<=$#*

<#($%:H%'? $9=$ )9# ;=) = A&'= :%/# <&'$(=<$ ;&(\#( :&( 4%'?=.&(#,

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

O=(#8H $9(## KIL @&'$9) %' &::%<#* X8&(#'<# 5, 2=A=')=? )GA@%$$#/ $& -GA#' 2, Q&A%=)* &' Z=(<9 C* >CCC*

9#( %'%$%=8"#(:&(@='<# -#.&($, -GA#' 2, Q&A%=) ;=) )& %@.(#))#/ ;%$9 $9# -#.&($ $9=$ 9# @=/# = '&$=$%&'

='/* &' )=%/ -#.&($aN550 75-b, d&;#+#(* %' $9# #+#'%'? &: J.(%8 >S* >CCC* ;9%8# X8&(#'<# 5, 2=A=')=?

;=) %' $9# :8=$* ;9%<9 )9# ='/ 2#<%8%= J]G%'&* $9# J))%)$='$ V%<#M"(#)%/#'$ ='/ 0#.G$H N#'#(=8 Z='=?#( &:

$9# O(='<9 ='/ -&)=''= 4=(@%#'$&* $9# 29%#: 0#=8#( &: $9# )=%/ O(='<9* (#'$#/* )9# ;=) $&8/ AH $9# $;&

KBL $9=$ -GA#' 2, Q&A%=) 9=) =)\#/ $9#@ $& $#88 X8&(#'<# 5, 2=A=')=? $& (#)%?' :(&@ 9#( `&A, X8&(#'<# 5,2=A=')=? ;=) .#(.8#_#/ =$ $9# )G//#' $G(' &: #+#'$) ='/ $9# (G'=A&G$ ;=H -GA#' 2, Q&A%=) .(&<G(#/ 9#(

(#)%?'=$%&' :(&@ $9# O='\, Q9# '#_$ /=H* X8&(#'<# 5, 2=A=')=? $=8\#/ $& -GA#' 2, Q&A%=) ='/ %']G%(#/ %:

;9=$ 2#<%8%= J]G%'& ='/ -&)=''= 4=(@%#'$& 9=/ $&8/ 9#( ;=) $(G#, -GA#' 2, Q&A%=) <&':%(@#/ $9# +#(=<%$H

&: $9# %':&(@=$%&'* ;%$9 $9# #_.8='=$%&' $9=$ 9#( (#)%?'=$%&' ;=) %@.#(=$%+# =) = <&)$M<G$$%'? @#=)G(# &:

$9# O='\, -GA#' 2, Q&A%=)* 8%\#;%)#* $&8/ X8&(#'<# 5, 2=A=')=? $9=$ $9# "6O 4%'?=.&(# O(='<9 ;%88 A# )&8/

&( $(='):&(@#/ %'$& = (#@%$$='<# &::%<# ='/ $9=$* %' #%$9#( ;=H* X8&(#'<# 5, 2=A=')=? 9=/ $& (#)%?' :(&@

9#( #@.8&H@#'$, Q9# @&(# X8&(#'<# 5, 2=A=')=? ;=) .#(.8#_#/, 49# $9#' =)\#/ -GA#' 2, Q&A%=) $9=$ )9#

A# :G('%)9#/ ;%$9 = X&(@=8 J/+%<# :(&@ $9# "6O d#=/ 5::%<# %' Z='%8=, d&;#+#(* -GA#' 2, Q&A%=) :8=$8H

(#:G)#/, X8&(#'<# 5, 2=A=')=? /%/ '&$ )GA@%$ ='H 8#$$#( &: (#)%?'=$%&',

5' J.(%8 >T* >CCC* -GA#' 2, Q&A%=) =?=%' )G@@&'#/ X8&(#'<# 5, 2=A=')=? $& 9%) &::%<# ='/ /#@='/#/ $9=$

)9# )GA@%$ 9#( 8#$$#( &: (#)%?'=$%&'* ;%$9 $9# .(#$#_$ $9=$ 9# '##/#/ = 29%'#)#M).#=\%'? 2(#/%$ 5::%<#( $&

.#'#$(=$# $9# 8&<=8 @=(\#$* ;%$9 $9# %':&(@=$%&' $9=$ = 29%'#)#M).#=\%'? 2(#/%$ 5::%<#( 9=/ =8(#=/H A##'

9%(#/ ='/ ;%88 A# (#.&($%'? :&( ;&(\ )&&', 49# ;=) ;=('#/ $9=$* G'8#)) )9# )GA@%$$#/ 9#( 8#$$#( &:

(#)%?'=$%&'* 9#( #@.8&H@#'$ (#<&(/ ;%88 A# A8#@%)9#/ ;%$9 $9# '&$=$%&'034Z34410 ).(#=/ $9#(#&',

7%$9&G$ ?%+%'? ='H /#:%'%$%+# =');#(* X8&(#'<# 5, 2=A=')=? =)\#/ -GA#' 2, Q&A%=) $9=$ )9# A# ?%+#'

)G::%<%#'$ $%@# $& 8&&\ :&( ='&$9#( `&A, -GA#' 2, Q&A%=) $&8/ 9#( $9=$ )9# )9&G8/ A# &G$ &: 9#( #@.8&H@#'$

AH Z=H >R* >CCC,

d&;#+#(* &' J.(%8 >C* >CCC* -GA#' 2, Q&A%=) =?=%' )G@@&'#/ X8&(#'<# 5, 2=A=')=? ='/ =/=@='$8H&(/#(#/ 9#( $& )GA@%$ 9#( 8#$$#( &: (#)%?'=$%&', 49# (#:G)#/, 5' J.(%8 BD* >CCC* )9# (#<#%+#/ = 8#$$#( :(&@

-GA#' 2, Q&A%=) $#(@%'=$%'? 9#( #@.8&H@#'$ ;%$9 $9# O='\,

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

Page 72: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 72/108

5' F='G=(H >P* BDDD* $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( (#'/#(#/ `G/?@#'$ %' :=+&( &: $9# 2&@.8=%'='$ ='/ =?=%')$ $9#

-#).&'/#'$)* $9# /#<(#$=8 .&($%&' &: ;9%<9 (#=/) =) :&88&;)a

7d1-1X5-1* <&')%/#(%'? $9# :&(#?&%'? .(#@%)#)* `G/?@#'$ %) 9#(#AH (#'/#(#/ :%'/%'? (#).&'/#'$) ?G%8$H

&: 388#?=8 /%)@%))=8 ='/ /#+&%/ &: /G# .(&<#))* ='/ =(# 9#(#AH &(/#(#/a

>, Q& (#%')$=$# <&@.8=%'='$ $& 9#( :&(@#( &( )GA)$='$%=88H #]G%+=8#'$ .&)%$%&' ;%$9&G$ 8&)) &:

)#'%&(%$H (%?9$)* A#'#:%$) ='/ .(%+%8#?#)[

B, 4&8%/=(%8H 8%=A8# $& .=H <&@.8=%'='$ =) :&88&;)a

=L Q& .=H <&@.8=%'='$ 9#( A=<\;=?#) :(&@ >T J.(%8 >CCC G. $& 9#( =<$G=8 (#%')$=$#@#'$, d#(

A=<\;=?#) =) &: $9# /=$# &: $9# .(&@G8?=$%&' &: $9%) /#<%)%&' =@&G'$#/ $& 4N0

SD*RDD,DD &( %$) #]G%+=8#'$ %' "9%8%..%'# 2G((#'<H =$ $9# $%@# &: .=H@#'$[

AL Z%/MH#=( A&'G) %' $9# =@&G'$ &: 4N0 B*BRD,DD &( %$) #]G%+=8#'$ %' "9%8%..%'# 2G((#'<H =$

$9# $%@# &: .=H@#'$[

<L J88&;='<# :&( 4G'/=H A='\%'? %' $9# =@&G'$ &: 4N0 >BD,DD &( %$) #]G%+=8#'$ %' "9%8%..%'#

2G((#'<H =$ $9# $%@# &: .=H@#'$[

/L Z&'#$=(H #]G%+=8#'$ &: 8#=+# <(#/%$) #=('#/ &' 4G'/=H A='\%'? %' $9# =@&G'$ &: 4N0

>*RRE,TE &( %$) #]G%+=8#'$ %' "9%8%..%'# 2G((#'<H =$ $9# $%@# &: .=H@#'$[

#L Z&'#$=(H #]G%+=8#'$ &: G'G)#/ )%<\ 8#=+# A#'#:%$) %' $9# =@&G'$ &: 4N0 >*>RD,TD &( %$)

#]G%+=8#'$ %' "9%8%..%'# 2G((#'<H =$ $9# $%@# &: .=H@#'$,

:L Z&'#$=(H #]G%+=8#'$ &: G'G)#/ +=<=$%&' 8#=+# A#'#:%$) %' $9# =@&G'$ &: 4N0 I>C,PR &( %$)

#]G%+=8#'$ %' "9%8%..%'# 2G((#'<H =$ $9# $%@# &: .=H@#'$,

?L >I$9

 @&'$9 .=H %' $9# =@&G'$ &: 4N0 S*RDD,DD &( %$) #]G%+=8#'$ %' "9%8%..%'# 2G((#'<H =$ $9#

$%@# &: .=H@#'$[

I, 4&8%/=(%8H $& .=H <&@.8=%'='$ =<$G=8 /=@=?#) %' $9# =@&G'$ &: 4N0 >*CEP,DD &( %$) #]G%+=8#'$ %'

"9%8%..%'# 2G((#'<H =$ $9# $%@# &: .=H@#'$* ='/ @&(=8 /=@=?#) %' $9# =@&G'$ &: "9"

BDD*DDD,DD* #_#@.8=(H /=@=?#) %' $9# =@&G'$ &: "9" >DD*DDD,DD[

S, Q& .=H <&@.8=%'='$ $9# =@&G'$ &: 4N0 R*DIC,P> &( %$) #]G%+=8#'$ %' "9%8%..%'# 2G((#'<H =$ $9#

$%@# &: .=H@#'$* (#.(#)#'$%'? =$$&('#H) :##),

45 5-01-10, hTi [email protected]=)%) %' $9# &(%?%'=8,i

"6O =..#=8#/ $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#() 0#<%)%&' $& $9# 6U-2, 3' = -#)&8G$%&' /=$#/ FG'# BC* BDD>* $9#

2&@@%))%&' =::%(@#/ $9=$ 0#<%)%&'* AG$ (#/G<#/ $9# @&(=8 /=@=?#) $& ">DD*DDD ='/ $9# #_#@.8=(H

/=@=?#) $&"RD*DDD, 3' = )GA)#]G#'$ -#)&8G$%&'* $9# 6U-2 /#'%#/ "6O) Z&$%&' :&( -#<&')%/#(=$%&',

&KLJ3M HU EBC /HKIE HU (SSC2LF

3' /%).&)%'? &: $9# "#$%$%&' :&( F(,)&*,5,& * $9# 2J '&$#/ $9=$ .#$%$%&'#( A='\ 9=/ :=%8#/ $& =//G<# %'

#+%/#'<# $9# 4%'?=.&(#=' 8=; )G..&)#/8H ?&+#('%'? $9# 8=$$#() #@.8&H@#'$ 2&'$(=<$ ;%$9 (#).&'/#'$,

Q9# =..#88=$# <&G($ :&G'/ $9=$ $9# 2&'$(=<$ 9=/ =<$G=88H A##' .(&<#))#/ AH $9# "9%8%..%'# 1@A=))H %'

Page 73: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 73/108

4%'?=.&(# ='/ =..(&+#/ AH $9# "9%8%..%'# 5+#()#=) [email protected]&H@#'$ J/@%'%)$(=$%&' K"51JL* ;9%<9 $9#' G)#/

$9=$ 2&'$(=<$ =) = A=)%) :&( %))G%'? =' 5+#()#=) [email protected]&H@#'$ 2#($%:%<=$# %' :=+&( &: (#).&'/#'$,

J<<&(/%'? $& $9# 2J* #+#' $9&G?9 (#).&'/#'$ )#<G(#/ =' #@.8&H@#'$ .=)) :(&@ $9# 4%'?=.&(#

Z%'%)$(H &: [email protected]&H@#'$* )9# /%/ '&$ $9#(#AH ;=%+# "9%8%..%'# 8=A&( 8=;)* &( $9# `G(%)/%<$%&' &: $9# 8=A&(

=(A%$#( &( $9# 6U-2 &+#( 9#( 2&@.8=%'$ :&( %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8, 3' )& /&%'?* '#%$9#( /%/ )9# )GA@%$ 9#()#8:

)&8#8H $& $9# Z%'%)$(H &: Z='.&;#( &: 4%'?=.&(#) `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( /%).G$#) =(%)%'? :(&@ 9#( #@.8&H@#'$,

Q9# =..#88=$# <&G($ :G($9#( '&$#/ $9=$ = <G()&(H (#=/%'? &: $9# Z%'%)$(H) 8#$$#( ;%88 (#=/%8H )9&; $9=$ '&

)G<9 ;=%+#( &( )GA@%))%&' %) )$=$#/ &( %@.8%#/,

X%'=88H* $9# 2J 9#8/ $9=$ .#$%$%&'#( 9=/ :=%8#/ $& #)$=A8%)9 = `G)$ <=G)# :&( $9# /%)@%))=8 &: (#).&'/#'$,

Q9# A='\ 9=/ =8)& :=%8#/ $& ?%+# 9#( )G::%<%#'$ '&$%<# ='/ =' &..&($G'%$H $& A# 9#=(/ ='/ $& /#:#'/ 9#()#8:,

Q9# 2J (G8#/ $9=$ )9# ;=) <&')#]G#'$8H #'$%$8#/ $& (#%')$=$#@#'$ ='/ A=<\ ;=?#)* <&@.G$#/ :(&@ $9#

$%@# &: 9#( /%)@%))=8 G. $& $9# $%@# &: 9#( (#%')$=$#@#'$,

d#'<#* $9%) "#$%$%&',hEi 

#FFKCF

"#$%$%&'#( )GA@%$) $9# :&88&;%'? %))G#) :&( &G( <&')%/#(=$%&'a

>, 79#$9#( &( '&$ $9# =(A%$(=$%&' A(='<9 &: $9# 6U-2 %' $9# 6=$%&'=8 2=.%$=8 -#?%&' 9=) `G(%)/%<$%&'

&+#( $9# %')$='$ <&'$(&+#()H[

B, 79#$9#( &( '&$ $9# =(A%$(=$%&' &: $9# 6U-2 %' $9# 6=$%&'=8 2=.%$=8 -#?%&' %) $9# @&)$ <&'+#'%#'$

+#'G# &( :&(G@ $& 9#=( ='/ /#<%/# $9# %')$='$ <&'$(&+#()H[ ='/

I, 79#$9#( &( '&$ $9# (#).&'/#'$ ;=) %88#?=88H /%)@%))#/* ='/ $9#(#:&(#* #'$%$8#/ $& (#<&+#( @&(=8

='/ #_#@.8=(H /=@=?#) ='/ =$$&('#H) :##),hPi 

3' =//%$%&'* (#).&'/#'$ =))=%8)* %' 9#( 2&@@#'$*hCi

 $9# .(&.(%#$H &: -G8# SR =) $9# .(&<#/G(=8 @&/# :&(

)##\%'? = (#+%#; &: $9# 2J 0#<%)%&' =::%(@%'? $9# 6U-2 -#)&8G$%&', 4G<9 %))G# /#)#(+#) )<='$

<&')%/#(=$%&', -#).&'/#'$ @%)<&@.(#9#'/) $9# 2&G($) /%)<&G()# %' C). T5,)&+ B6+(,57 W*4( -.

M?/F@h>Di

  ;9%<9 9=) %'/##/ =::%(@#/ $9=$ $9# .(&.#( @&/# &: (#+%#; &: 6U-2 /#<%)%&')* (#)&8G$%&') &(

&(/#() %) AH = ).#<%=8 <%+%8 =<$%&' :&(;(,)&*,5,&  G'/#( -G8# TR &: $9# -G8#) &: 2&G($, Q9# 4G.(#@# 2&G($ ='/

$9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) 9=+# ;*+;6,,(+)*,&I&+57  `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( )G<9 .#$%$%&') :&( ;(,)&*,5,& , Q9G)* %'

&A)#(+='<# &: $9# /&<$(%'# &' $9# 9%#(=(<9H &: <&G($)* $9#)# .#$%$%&') )9&G8/ A# %'%$%=88H :%8#/ ;%$9 $9#

2J,h>>i

 

-%?9$8H* $9# A='\ #8#+=$#/ $9# 6U-2 -#)&8G$%&' $& $9# 2J AH ;=H &: = "#$%$%&' :&( F(,)&*,5,& , 3' )##\%'?

= (#+%#; AH $9%) 2&G($ &: $9# 2J 0#<%)%&' MM &' ]G#)$%&') &: `G(%)/%<$%&'* +#'G# ='/ +=8%/%$H &: #@.8&H@#'$

$#(@%'=$%&' MM .#$%$%&'#( %) 8%\#;%)# <&((#<$ %' %'+&\%'? -G8# SR,h>Bi

 

3$ %) $(G#* 9&;#+#(* $9=$ %' = .#$%$%&' :&( (#+%#; &' ;(,)&*,5,& * $9# )<&.# &: $9# 4G.(#@# 2&G($) `G/%<%=8

(#+%#; &: /#<%)%&') &: $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) %) ?#'#(=88H <&':%'#/ &'8H $& #((&() &: 8=;, 3$ /&#) '&$ #_$#'/ $&

]G#)$%&') &: :=<$, Q9%) /&<$(%'# =..8%#) ;%$9 ?(#=$#( :&(<# %' 8=A&( <=)#), X=<$G=8 ]G#)$%&') =(# :&( $9# 8=A&(

$(%AG'=8) $& (#)&8+#, h>Ii

 3' $9# .(#)#'$ <=)#* $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#( ='/ $9# 6U-2 9=+# =8(#=/H /#$#(@%'#/ $9#

:=<$G=8 %))G#), Q9#%( :%'/%'?)* ;9%<9 =(# )G..&($#/ AH )GA)$='$%=8 #+%/#'<#* ;#(# =::%(@#/ AH $9# 2J, Q9G)*

$9#H =(# #'$%$8#/ $& ?(#=$ (#).#<$ ='/ =(# (#'/#(#/ <&'<8G)%+# G.&' $9%) 2&G($* =A)#'$ = <8#=( )9&;%'? &:

.=8.=A8# #((&( &( =(A%$(=(H /%)(#?=(/ &: #+%/#'<#,h>Si 

1BC /HKIEF &KLJ3M

Page 74: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 74/108

Q9# "#$%$%&' 9=) '& @#(%$,

6JIFE #FFKCA

 !.',-2,/+,0* 

Q9# `G(%)/%<$%&' &: 8=A&( =(A%$#() ='/ $9# 6U-2 %) ).#<%:%#/ %' J($%<8# B>E &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# =) :&88&;)a

J-Q, B>E, FG(%)/%<$%&' &: U=A&( J(A%$#() ='/ $9# 2&@@%))%&', K=L 1_<#.$ =) &$9#(;%)# .(&+%/#/ G'/#( $9%)

2&/# $9# U=A&( J(A%$#() )9=88 9=+# &(%?%'=8 ='/ #_<8G)%+# `G(%)/%<$%&' $& 9#=( ='/ /#<%/#* ;%$9%' $9%($H KIDL

<=8#'/=( /=H) =:$#( $9# )GA@%))%&' &: $9# <=)# AH $9# .=($%#) :&( /#<%)%&' ;%$9&G$ #_$#')%&'* #+#' %' $9#

=A)#'<# &: )$#'&?(=.9%< '&$#)* $9# :&88&;%'? <=)#) %'+&8+%'? =88 ;&(\#()* ;9#$9#( =?(%<G8$G(=8 &( '&'M

=?(%<G8$G(=8a

>, Y':=%( 8=A&( .(=<$%<# <=)#)[

B, Q#(@%'=$%&' /%).G$#)[

I, 3: =<<&@.='%#/ ;%$9 = <8=%@ :&( (#%')$=$#@#'$* $9&)# <=)#) $9=$ ;&(\#() @=H :%8# %'+&8+%'?

;=?#* (=$#) &: .=H* 9&G() &: ;&(\ ='/ &$9#( $#(@) ='/ <&'/%$%&') &: #@.8&H@#'$

S, 28=%@) :&( =<$G=8* @&(=8* #_#@.8=(H ='/ &$9#( :&(@) &: /=@=?#) =(%)%'? :(&@ $9# #@.8&H#(M

#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')[

R, 2=)#) =(%)%'? :(&@ ='H +%&8=$%&' &: J($%<8# BTS &: $9%) 2&/#* %'<8G/%'? ]G#)$%&') %'+&8+%'? $9#

8#?=8%$H &: )$(%\#) ='/ 8&<\&G$)[ ='/

T, 1_<#.$ <8=%@) :&( [email protected]&H##) 2&@.#')=$%&'* 4&<%=8 4#<G(%$H* Z#/%<=(# ='/ @=$#('%$H A#'#:%$)*=88 &$9#( <8=%@)* =(%)%'? :(&@ #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')* %'<8G/%'? $9&)# &: .#()&') %'

/&@#)$%< &( 9&G)#9&8/ )#(+%<#* %'+&8+%'? =' =@&G'$ &: #_<##/%'? :%+# $9&G)='/ .#)&)

K"R*DDD,DDL (#?=(/8#)) &: ;9#$9#( =<<&@.='%#/ ;%$9 = <8=%@ :&( (#%')$=$#@#'$,

KAL Q9# <&@@%))%&' )9=88 9=+# #_<8G)%+# =..#88=$# `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( =88 <=)#) /#<%/#/ AH U=A&( J(A%$#(),

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _,

Z&(# ).#<%:%<=88H* 4#<$%&' >D &: -J PDSB (#=/) %' .=($a

412Q356 >D, T*+(< F75&40. 6&$;%$9)$='/%'? ='H .(&+%)%&' &: 8=; $& $9# <&'$(=(H* $9# U=A&( J(A%$#() &: $9#6=$%&'=8 U=A&( -#8=$%&') 2&@@%))%&' K6U-2L )9=88 9=+# $9# &(%?%'=8 ='/ #_<8G)%+# `G(%)/%<$%&' $& 9#=( ='/

/#<%/#* ;%$9%' '%'#$H KCDL <=8#'/=( /=H) =:$#( $9# :%8%'? &: $9# <&@.8=%'$* $9# <8=%@) =(%)%'? &G$ &: ='

#@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. &( AH +%($G# &: ='H 8=; &( <&'$(=<$ %'+&8+%'? X%8%.%'& ;&(\#() :&( &+#()#=)

/#.8&H@#'$ %'<8G/%'? <8=%@) :&( =<$G=8* @&(=8* #_#@.8=(H ='/ &$9#( :&(@) &: /=@=?#),

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

O=)#/ &' $9# :&(#?&%'? .(&+%)%&')* 8=A&( =(A%$#() <8#=(8H 9=+# *,&I&+57 5+1 (Q;760&-( `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#(

<8=%@) =(%)%'? :(&@ #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')* %'<8G/%'? )(,4&+5)&*+ 1&0$6)(0 %'+&8+%'? 577  ;&(\#()*

=@&'? ;9&@ =(# &+#()#=) X%8%.%'& ;&(\#() K5X7L,h>Ri

 

7# =(# '&$ G'@%'/:G8 &: $9# :=<$ $9=$ (#).&'/#'$ ;=) /%(#<$8H 9%(#/* ;9%8# &' = $&G(%)$ )$=$G) %'

4%'?=.&(#* AH $9# "6O A(='<9 %' $9=$ <%$H )$=$#, "(%&( $& #@.8&H%'? (#).&'/#'$* .#$%$%&'#( 9=/ $& &A$=%' ='

#@.8&H@#'$ .=)) :&( 9#( :(&@ $9# 4%'?=.&(# Z%'%)$(H &: Z='.&;#(, 4#<G(%'? $9# .=)) ;=) = (#?G8=$&(H

(#]G%(#@#'$ .G()G='$ $& $9# %@@%?(=$%&' (#?G8=$%&') &: $9=$ <&G'$(H,h>Ti

 

Page 75: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 75/108

4%@%8=(8H* $9# "9%8%..%'# ?&+#('@#'$ (#]G%(#) '&'MX%8%.%'&) ;&(\%'? %' $9# <&G'$(H $& :%()$ &A$=%' =

8&<=8 ;&(\ .#(@%$ %' &(/#( $& A# 8#?=88H #@.8&H#/ 9#(#, Q9=$ .#(@%$* 9&;#+#(* /&#) '&$ =G$&@=$%<=88H

@#=' $9=$ $9# '&'M<%$%^#' %) $9#(#AH A&G'/ AH 8&<=8 8=;) &'8H* =) =+#((#/ AH .#$%$%&'#(, 3$ /&#) '&$ =$ =88

%@.8H = ;=%+#( &: &'#) '=$%&'=8 8=;) &' 8=A&(, JA)#'$ ='H <8#=( ='/ <&'+%'<%'? #+%/#'<# $& $9# <&'$(=(H*

)G<9 .#(@%$ )%@.8H @#=') $9=$ %$) 9&8/#( 9=) = 8#?=8 )$=$G) =) = ;&(\#( %' $9# %))G%'? <&G'$(H,

6&$#;&($9H %) $9# :=<$ $9=$ (#).&'/#'$ 8%\#;%)# =..8%#/ :&( ='/ )#<G(#/ =' 5+#()#=) [email protected]&H@#'$

2#($%:%<=$# :(&@ $9# "51J $9(&G?9 $9# "9%8%..%'# 1@A=))H %' 4%'?=.&(#, Q9# 2#($%:%<=$#* %))G#/ &' Z=(<9 P*

>CCC* /#<8=(#/ 9#( = A&'= :%/# <&'$(=<$ ;&(\#( :&( 4%'?=.&(#, Y'/#( "9%8%..%'# 8=;* $9%) /&<G@#'$

=G$9&(%^#/ 9#( ;&(\%'? )$=$G) %' = :&(#%?' <&G'$(H ='/ #'$%$8#/ 9#( $& =88 A#'#:%$) ='/ .(&<#))#) G'/#( &G(

)$=$G$#), Q9G)* #+#' =))G@%'? 5,I6(+1* $9=$ )9# ;=) <&')%/#(#/ =$ $9# )$=($ &: 9#( #@.8&H@#'$ =) = /%(#<$

9%(# ?&+#('#/ AH ='/ )GA`#<$ $& $9# 8=;)* <&@@&' .(=<$%<#) ='/ <G)$&@) .(#+=%8%'? %' 4%'?=.&(# h>Ei )9#

)GA)#]G#'$8H A#<=@# = <&'$(=<$ ;&(\#( &( =' 5X7 ;9& ;=) <&+#(#/ AH "9%8%..%'# 8=A&( 8=;) ='/ .&8%<%#)

G.&' <#($%:%<=$%&' AH $9# "51J, J$ $9# $%@# 9#( #@.8&H@#'$ ;=) %88#?=88H $#(@%'=$#/* )9# =8(#=/H

.&))#))#/ $9# "51J #@.8&H@#'$ 2#($%:%<=$#,

Z&(#&+#(* .#$%$%&'#( =/@%$) $9=$ %$ %) = "9%8%..%'# <&(.&(=$%&' /&%'? AG)%'#)) $9(&G?9 = A(='<9 &::%<#

%' 4%'?=.&(#,h>Pi 4%?'%:%<='$8H* (#).&'/#'$) #@.8&H@#'$ AH $9# 4%'?=.&(# A(='<9 &::%<# 9=/ $& A# =..(&+#/

AH O#'`=@%' ", "=8@= N%8*

h>Ci

 $9# .(#)%/#'$ &: $9# A='\ ;9&)# .(%'<%.=8 &::%<#) ;#(# %' Z='%8=, Q9%)<%(<G@)$='<# @%8%$=$#) =?=%')$ .#$%$%&'#() <&'$#'$%&' $9=$ (#).&'/#'$ ;=) 8&<=88H 9%(#/[ ='/ $&$=88H

?&+#('#/ AH ='/ )GA`#<$ $& $9# 8=;)* <&@@&' .(=<$%<#) ='/ <G)$&@) &: 4%'?=.&(#* '&$ &: $9# "9%8%..%'#),

3')$#=/* ;%$9 @&(# (#=)&' /&#) $9%) :=<$ (#%':&(<# $9# .(#)G@.$%&' $9=$ (#).&'/#'$ :=88) G'/#( $9# 8#?=8

/#:%'%$%&' &: 4&I,5+) #*,>(, * %' $9%) <=)# &'# /#.8&H#/ %' 4%'?=.&(#, d#'<#* .#$%$%&'#( <=''&$ #)<=.# $9#

=..8%<=$%&' &: "9%8%..%'# 8=;) &( $9# `G(%)/%<$%&' &: $9# 6U-2 ='/ $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#(,

3' ='H #+#'$* ;# (#<=88 $9# :&88&;%'? .&8%<H .(&'&G'<#@#'$ &: $9# 2&G($ %' /*<57 F,*#+ N+)(,+5)&*+57(

-. M?/FXhBDi

 

_ _ _, 79#$9#( #@.8&H#/ 8&<=88H &( &+#()#=)* =88 X%8%.%'& ;&(\#() #'`&H $9# .(&$#<$%+# @='$8# &: "9%8%..%'#

8=A&( ='/ )&<%=8 8#?%)8=$%&'* <&'$(=<$ )$%.G8=$%&') $& $9# <&'$(=(H '&$;%$9)$='/%'?, Q9%) .(&'&G'<#@#'$ %) %'\##.%'? ;%$9 $9# A=)%< .GA8%< .&8%<H &: $9# 4$=$# $& =::&(/ .(&$#<$%&' $& 8=A&(* .(&@&$# :G88 #@.8&H@#'$*

#')G(# #]G=8 ;&(\ &..&($G'%$%#) (#?=(/8#)) &: )#_* (=<# &( <(##/* ='/ (#?G8=$# $9# (#8=$%&') A#$;##'

;&(\#() ='/ #@.8&H#(), X&( $9# 4$=$# =))G(#) $9# A=)%< (%?9$) &: =88 ;&(\#() $& )#8:M&(?='%^=$%&'* <&88#<$%+#

A=(?=%'%'?* )#<G(%$H &: $#'G(#* ='/ `G)$ ='/ 9G@='# <&'/%$%&') &: ;&(\ hJ($%<8# I &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# &: $9#

"9%8%..%'#)[ C(( 570* 4#<$%&' >P* J($%<8# 33 ='/ 4#<$%&' I* J($%<8# r333* >CPE 2&')$%$G$%&'i, Q9%) (G8%'? %)

8%\#;%)# (#'/#(#/ %@.#(=$%+# AH J($%<8# >E &: $9# 2%+%8 2&/# ;9%<9 )$=$#) $9=$ 8=;) ;9%<9 9=+# :&( $9#%(

&A`#<$ .GA8%< &(/#(* .GA8%< .&8%<H ='/ ?&&/ <G)$&@) )9=88 '&$ A# (#'/#(#/ %'#::#<$%+# AH 8=;) &( `G/?@#'$)

.(&@G8?=$#/* &( AH /#$#(@%'=$%&' &( <&'+#'$%&') =?(##/ G.&' %' = :&(#%?' <&G'$(H,

'CDH34 #FFKCA

C'0%&' H&*.& 

4#<$%&' >K=L &: -G8# 3V &: $9# 6U-2 -G8#) &: "(&<#/G(# (#=/)a

4#<$%&' >, V#'G# K=L J88 <=)#) ;9%<9 U=A&( J(A%$#() 9=+# =G$9&(%$H $& 9#=( ='/ /#<%/# @=H A# :%8#/ %' $9#

-#?%&'=8 J(A%$(=$%&' O(='<9 9=+%'? `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( $9# ;&(\.8=<# &: $9# <&@.8=%'='$e.#$%$%&'#([

"(&+%/#/* 9&;#+#( $9=$ <=)#) &: 5+#()#=) X%8%.%'& 7&(\#( K5X7L )9=88 A# :%8#/ A#:&(# $9# -#?%&'=8

J(A%$(=$%&' O(='<9 ;9#(# $9# <&@.8=%'='$ (#)%/#) &( ;9#(# $9# .(%'<%.=8 &::%<# &: $9#

(#).&'/#'$e#@.8&H#( %) )%$G=$#/* =$ $9# &.$%&' &: $9# <&@.8=%'='$,

X&( .G(.&)#) &: +#'G#* ;&(\.8=<# )9=88 A# G'/#()$&&/ =) $9# .8=<# &( 8&<=8%$H ;9#(# $9# #@.8&H## %)

(#?G8=(8H =))%?'#/ ;9#' $9# <=G)# &: =<$%&' =(&)#, 3$ )9=88 %'<8G/# $9# .8=<# ;9#(# $9# #@.8&H## %)

Page 76: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 76/108

)G..&)#/ $& (#.&($ A=<\ =:$#( = $#@.&(=(H /#$=%8* =))%?'@#'$ &( $(=+#8, 3' $9# <=)# &: :%#8/ #@.8&H##)* =)

;#88 =) =@AG8='$ &( %$%'#(='$ ;&(\#()* $9#%( ;&(\.8=<# %) ;9#(# $9#H =(# (#?G8=(8H =))%?'#/* &( ;9#(# $9#H

=(# )G..&)#/ $& (#?G8=(8H (#<#%+# $9#%( )=8=(%#)e;=?#) &( ;&(\ %')$(G<$%&') :(&@* ='/ (#.&($ $9# (#)G8$) &:

$9#%( =))%?'@#'$ $& $9#%( #@.8&H#(),

Y'/#( $9# Z%?(='$ 7&(\#() ='/ 5+#()#=) X%8%.%'&) J<$ &: >CCR K-J PDSBL* = 4&I,5+) #*,>(,  (#:#() $& =

.#()&' ;9& %) $& A# #'?=?#/* %) #'?=?#/ &( 9=) A##' #'?=?#/ %' = (#@G'#(=$#/ =<$%+%$H %' = )$=$# &: ;9%<9

9# &( )9# %) '&$ = 8#?=8 (#)%/#'$[ $& A# G)#/ %'$#(<9='?#=A8H ;%$9 &+#()#=) X%8%.%'& ;&(\#(,hB>i

 Y'/#'%=A8H*(#).&'/#'$ ;=) #@.8&H#/ AH .#$%$%&'#( %' %$) A(='<9 &::%<# %' 4%'?=.&(#, J/@%$$#/8H* )9# %) = X%8%.%'& ='/

'&$ = 8#?=8 (#)%/#'$ &: $9=$ )$=$#, 49# $9G) :=88) ;%$9%' $9# <=$#?&(H &: @%?(='$ ;&(\#( &( &+#()#=) X%8%.%'&

;&(\#(,

J) )G<9* %$ %) 9#( &.$%&' $& <9&&)# $9# +#'G# &: 9#( 2&@.8=%'$ =?=%')$ .#$%$%&'#( :&( %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8,

Q9# 8=; ?%+#) 9#( $;& <9&%<#)a K>L =$ $9# -#?%&'=8 J(A%$(=$%&' O(='<9 K-JOL ;9#(# )9# (#)%/#) &( KBL =$ $9#

-JO ;9#(# $9# .(%'<%.=8 &::%<# &: 9#( #@.8&H#( %) )%$G=$#/, 4%'<# 9#( /%)@%))=8 AH .#$%$%&'#(* (#).&'/#'$

9=) (#$G('#/ $& $9# "9%8%..%'#) MM ).#<%:%<=88H $& 9#( (#)%/#'<# =$ X%8%'+#)$ 33* pG#^&' 2%$H, Q9G)* %' :%8%'? 9#(

2&@.8=%'$ A#:&(# $9# -JO &::%<# %' pG#^&' 2%$H* )9# 9=) @=/# = +=8%/ <9&%<# &: .(&.#( +#'G#,

1BJI4 #FFKCA

744&;)4 F,-(,--)4  

Q9# =..#88=$# <&G($ ;=) <&((#<$ %' 9&8/%'? $9=$ (#).&'/#'$ ;=) =8(#=/H = (#?G8=( #@.8&H## =$ $9# $%@#

&: 9#( /%)@%))=8* A#<=G)# 9#( $9(##M@&'$9 .(&A=$%&'=(H .#(%&/ &: #@.8&H@#'$ 9=/ =8(#=/H #'/#/, Q9%)

(G8%'? %) %' =<<&(/='<# ;%$9 J($%<8# BP> &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#a J' #@.8&H## ;9& %) =88&;#/ $& ;&(\ =:$#( =

.(&A=$%&'=(H .#(%&/ )9=88 A# <&')%/#(#/ = (#?G8=( #@.8&H##, 3'/##/* .#$%$%&'#( (#<&?'%^#/ (#).&'/#'$ =)

)G<9 =$ $9# $%@# %$ /%)@%))#/ 9#(* AH ?%+%'? 9#( &'# @&'$9) )=8=(H %' 8%#G &: = &'#M@&'$9 '&$%<#* <&')%)$#'$

;%$9 .(&+%)%&' 6&, T &: 9#( #@.8&H@#'$ 2&'$(=<$,

P0+,/& )*2 ]&)',*; 

P0+ $0(%4,&2 D,+> 

J) = (#?G8=( #@.8&H##* (#).&'/#'$ ;=) #'$%$8#/ $& =88 (%?9$)* A#'#:%$) ='/ .(%+%8#?#) .(&+%/#/ G'/#(

&G( 8=A&( 8=;), 5'# &: 9#( :G'/=@#'$=8 (%?9$) %) $9=$ )9# @=H '&$ A# /%)@%))#/ ;%$9&G$ /G# .(&<#)) &: 8=;,

Q9# $;%' (#]G%(#@#'$) &: '&$%<# ='/ 9#=(%'? <&')$%$G$# $9# #))#'$%=8 #8#@#'$) &: .(&<#/G(=8 /G# .(&<#))*

='/ '#%$9#( &: $9#)# #8#@#'$) <=' A# #8%@%'=$#/ ;%$9&G$ (G''%'? =:&G8 &: $9# <&')$%$G$%&'=8 ?G=(='$##,hBBi

 

3' /%)@%))%'? #@.8&H##)* $9# #@.8&H#( @G)$ :G('%)9 $9#@ $;& ;(%$$#' '&$%<#)a >L &'# $& =..(%)# $9#@&: $9# .=($%<G8=( =<$) &( &@%))%&') :&( ;9%<9 $9#%( /%)@%))=8 %) )&G?9$[ ='/ BL $9# &$9#( $& %':&(@ $9#@ &:

$9# /#<%)%&' $& /%)@%)) $9#@, J) $& $9# (#]G%(#@#'$ &: = 9#=(%'?* %$) #))#'<# 8%#) )%@.8H %' $9# &..&($G'%$H

$& A# 9#=(/,hBIi

 

Q9# #+%/#'<# %' $9%) <=)# %) <(H)$=8M<8#=(, -#).&'/#'$ ;=) '&$ '&$%:%#/ &: $9# ).#<%:%< =<$ &( &@%))%&'

:&( ;9%<9 9#( /%)@%))=8 ;=) A#%'? )&G?9$, 6#%$9#( ;=) )9# ?%+#' ='H <9='<# $& A# 9#=(/* =) (#]G%(#/ AH

8=;, J$ ='H (=$#* #+#' %: )9# ;#(# ?%+#' $9# &..&($G'%$H $& A# 9#=(/* )9# <&G8/ '&$ 9=+# /#:#'/#/ 9#()#8:

#::#<$%+#8H* :&( )9# \'#; '& <=G)# $& =');#( $&,

J88 $9=$ .#$%$%&'#( $#'/#(#/ $& (#).&'/#'$ ;=) = '&$%<# &: 9#( #@.8&H@#'$ $#(@%'=$%&' #::#<$%+# $9#

+#(H )=@# /=H* $&?#$9#( ;%$9 $9# #]G%+=8#'$ &: = &'#M@&'$9 .=H, Q9%) 2&G($ 9=) =8(#=/H 9#8/ $9=$ '&$9%'?%' $9# 8=; ?%+#) =' #@.8&H#( $9# &.$%&' $& )GA)$%$G$# $9# (#]G%(#/ .(%&( '&$%<# ='/ &..&($G'%$H $& A# 9#=(/

;%$9 $9# @#(# .=H@#'$ &: ID /=H) )=8=(H,hBSi

 

Page 77: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 77/108

7#88M)#$$8#/ %) $9# (G8# $9=$ $9# #@.8&H#( )9=88 A# )='<$%&'#/ :&( '&'<&@.8%='<# ;%$9 $9#

(#]G%(#@#'$) &:* &( :&( :=%8G(# $& &A)#(+#* /G# .(&<#)) $9=$ @G)$ A# &A)#(+#/ %' /%)@%))%'? ='

#@.8&H##,hBRi

 

P0 H)4,2 $).-& 

 <0' F,-(,--)4  

Z&(#&+#(* J($%<8#) BPB*hBTi

 BPIhBEi

 ='/ BPShBPi

 &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# .(&+%/# $9# +=8%/ ?(&G'/) &( <=G)#) :&(

=' #@.8&H##) /%)@%))=8, Q9# #@.8&H#( 9=) $9# AG(/#' &: .(&+%'? $9=$ %$ ;=) /&'# :&( ='H &: $9&)# `G)$ &(

=G$9&(%^#/ <=G)#), Q9# :=%8G(# $& /%)<9=(?# $9%) AG(/#' @#=') $9=$ $9# /%)@%))=8 ;=) '&$ `G)$%:%#/* ='/ $9=$

$9# #@.8&H## %) #'$%$8#/ $& (#%')$=$#@#'$ ='/ A=<\ ;=?#),hBCi

 

6&$=A8H* .#$%$%&'#( 9=) '&$ =))#($#/ ='H &: $9# ?(&G'/) .(&+%/#/ AH 8=; =) = +=8%/ (#=)&' :&(

$#(@%'=$%'? $9# #@.8&H@#'$ &: (#).&'/#'$, 3$ @#(#8H %')%)$) $9=$ 9#( /%)@%))=8 ;=) +=8%/8H #::#<$#/

.G()G='$ $& $9# .(&+%)%&') &: 9#( #@.8&H@#'$ 2&'$(=<$* ;9%<9 )9# 9=/ +&8G'$=(%8H =?(##/ $& A# A&G'/ $&,

Q(G8H* $9# <&'$(=<$%'? .=($%#) @=H #)$=A8%)9 )G<9 )$%.G8=$%&')* <8=G)#)* $#(@) ='/ <&'/%$%&') =) $9#H

;='$* ='/ $9#%( =?(##@#'$ ;&G8/ 9=+# $9# :&(<# &: 8=; A#$;##' $9#@, d&;#+#(* .#$%$%&'#( &+#(8&&\) $9#]G=8%:%<=$%&' $9=$ $9&)# $#(@) ='/ <&'/%$%&') =?(##/ G.&' @G)$ '&$ A# <&'$(=(H $& 8=;* @&(=8)* <G)$&@)*

.GA8%< .&8%<H &( .GA8%< &(/#(,hIDi

  J) #_.8=%'#/ #=(8%#(* $9# #@.8&H@#'$ 2&'$(=<$ A#$;##' .#$%$%&'#( ='/

(#).&'/#'$ %) ?&+#('#/ AH "9%8%..%'# 8=A&( 8=;), d#'<#* $9# )$%.G8=$%&')* <8=G)#)* ='/ $#(@) ='/ <&'/%$%&')

&: $9# 2&'$(=<$ @G)$ '&$ <&'$(=+#'# &G( 8=A&( 8=; .(&+%)%&'),

Z&(#&+#(* = <&'$(=<$ &: #@.8&H@#'$ %) %@AG#/ ;%$9 .GA8%< %'$#(#)$, Q9# 2&G($ 9=) $%@# ='/ $%@# =?=%'

(#@%'/#/ .=($%#) $9=$ $9#H =(# '&$ =$ 8%A#($H $& %')G8=$# $9#@)#8+#) ='/ $9#%( (#8=$%&')9%.) :(&@ $9# %@.=<$

&: 8=A&( 8=;) ='/ (#?G8=$%&') AH )%@.8H <&'$(=<$%'? ;%$9 #=<9 &$9#(,hI>i

  J8)&* ;9%8# = <&'$(=<$ %) $9# 8=;

A#$;##' $9# .=($%#)* $9# .(&+%)%&') &: .&)%$%+# 8=; $9=$ (#?G8=$# )G<9 <&'$(=<$) =(# /##@#/ %'<8G/#/ ='/

)9=88 8%@%$ ='/ ?&+#(' $9# (#8=$%&') A#$;##' $9# .=($%#),hIBi

 

O=)%< %' &G( `G(%).(G/#'<# %) $9# .(%'<%.8# $9=$ ;9#' $9#(# %) '& )9&;%'? &: ='H <8#=(* +=8%/* ='/ 8#?=8

<=G)# :&( $9# $#(@%'=$%&' &: #@.8&H@#'$* $9# 8=; <&')%/#() $9# @=$$#( = <=)# &: %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8,hIIi

 

 9E)'2- <0' F)();&- 

 !.-+,<,&2  

X%'=88H* @&(=8 /=@=?#) =(# (#<&+#(=A8# ;9#' $9# /%)@%))=8 &: =' #@.8&H## %) =$$#'/#/ AH A=/ :=%$9 &(

<&')$%$G$#) =' =<$ &..(#))%+# $& 8=A&( &( %) /&'# %' = @=''#( <&'$(=(H $& @&(=8)* ?&&/ <G)$&@) &( .GA8%<

.&8%<H,hISi J;=(/) :&( @&(=8 ='/ #_#@.8=(H /=@=?#) ;&G8/ A# .(&.#( %: $9# #@.8&H## ;=) 9=(=))#/ ='/

=(A%$(=(%8H /%)@%))#/ AH $9# #@.8&H#(,hIRi

 

3' =::%(@%'? $9# =;=(/) &: @&(=8 ='/ #_#@.8=(H /=@=?#)* ;# ]G&$# ;%$9 =..(&+=8 $9# :&88&;%'?

(=$%&<%'=$%&' &: $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#(a

Q9# (#<&(/) =8)& )9&; $9=$ h(#).&'/#'$)i /%)@%))=8 ;=) #::#<$#/ AH h.#$%$%&'#()i <=.(%<%&G) ='/ 9%?9M

9='/#/ @=''#(* ='$%M)&<%=8 ='/ &..(#))%+#* :(=G/G8#'$ ='/ %' A=/ :=%$9* ='/ <&'$(=(H $& @&(=8)* ?&&/

<G)$&@) ='/ .GA8%< .&8%<H, O=/ :=%$9 ='/ :(=G/ =(# )9&;' %' $9# =<$) <&@@%$$#/ AH h.#$%$%&'#()i A#:&(#*

/G(%'? ='/ =:$#( h(#).&'/#'$)i /%)@%))=8 %' =//%$%&' $& $9# @=''#( AH ;9%<9 )9# ;=) /%)@%))#/, X%()$*

h(#).&'/#'$i ;=) .(#))G(#/ $& (#)%?' :&( $;& /%::#(#'$ ='/ <&'$(=/%<$&(H (#=)&')* '=@#8H* <&)$M<G$$%'? ='/$9# '##/ :&( = 29%'#)#hMi).#=\%'? <(#/%$ &::%<#(* :&( ;9%<9 '& ;(%$$#' =/+%<# ;=) ?%+#' /#).%$#

<&@.8=%'='$) (#]G#)$, 4G<9 ;=+#(%'? )$='<# &( +=<%88=$%'? .&)%$%&' %'/%<=$#) A=/ :=%$9 ='/ = /%)9&'#)$

.G(.&)#, 4#<&'/* )9# ;=) #@.8&H#/ &' =<<&G'$ &: 9#( ]G=8%:%<=$%&')* #_.#(%#'<# ='/ (#=/%'#)) :&( $9#

.&)%$%&' &: <(#/%$ &::%<#( ='/ .(#))G(#/ $& (#)%?' = @&'$9 =:$#( )9# ;=) <&@@#'/#/ :&( 9#( ?&&/ ;&(\,

Page 78: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 78/108

Q9%(/* $9# /#@='/ :&( h(#).&'/#'$)i %')$='$ (#)%?'=$%&' &' >C J.(%8 >CCC $& ?%+# ;=H $& 9#( (#.8=<#@#'$

;9& ;=) =88#?#/8H (#.&($%'? )&&'#)$* %) ;9%@)%<=8* :(=G/G8#'$ ='/ %' A=/ :=%$9* A#<=G)# &' >T J.(%8 >CCC

)9# ;=) ?%+#' = .#(%&/ &: h)%<i G'$%8 >R Z=H >CCC ;%$9%' ;9%<9 $& 8#=+#, X&G($9* $9# .(#))G(#) @=/# &' 9#(

$& (#)%?' ;#(# 9%?98H &..(#))%+#* ='$%M)&<%=8 ='/ <=G)#/ 9#( =A)&8G$# $&($G(#* =) h.#$%$%&'#()i /%)(#?=(/#/

9#( )%$G=$%&' =) =' &+#()#=) ;&(\#( =;=H :(&@ 9&@# ='/ :=@%8H* ;%$9 '& .(&).#<$ :&( ='&$9#( `&A, 49# ;=)

'&$ #+#' .(&+%/#/ ;%$9 = (#$G(' $(%. :=(#, X%:$9* $9# '&$%<# &: $#(@%'=$%&' %) =' G$$#( @='%:#)$=$%&' &: A=/

:=%$9 ='/ ;9%@ =) %$ $&$=88H /%)(#?=(/) h(#).&'/#'$)i (%?9$ $& )#<G(%$H &: $#'G(# ='/ /G# .(&<#)), 4G<9

'&$%<# $&?#$9#( ;%$9 $9# /#@='/) :&( h(#).&'/#'$)i (#)%?'=$%&' <&'$(=+#'#) $9# :G'/=@#'$=8 ?G=(='$##='/ .GA8%< .&8%<H &: $9# "9%8%..%'# ?&+#('@#'$ &' )#<G(%$H &: $#'G(#,

h-#).&'/#'$i 8%\#;%)# #)$=A8%)9#/ $9=$ =) = .(&_%@=$# (#)G8$ &: 9#( /%)@%))=8 ='/ .(%&( /#@='/) :&(

(#)%?'=$%&'* )9# )G::#(#/ ='/ <&'$%'G#) $& )G::#( @#'$=8 ='?G%)9* :(%?9$* )#(%&G) ='_%#$H* A#)@%(<9#/

(#.G$=$%&'* ;&G'/#/ :##8%'?)* @&(=8 )9&<\ ='/ )&<%=8 9G@%8%=$%&', d#( )$='/%'? %' $9# )&<%=8 ='/ AG)%'#))

<&@@G'%$H =) ;#88 =) .(&).#<$) :&( #@.8&H@#'$ ;%$9 &$9#( #'$%$%#) 9=+# A##' =/+#()#8H =::#<$#/ AH 9#(

/%)@%))=8, h"#$%$%&'#()i =(# $9G) 8%=A8# :&( @&(=8 /=@=?#) G'/#( J($%<8# BB>E &: $9# 2%+%8 2&/#,

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

h"#$%$%&'#()i 8%\#;%)# =<$#/ %' = ;='$&'* &..(#))%+# &( @=8#+&8#'$ @=''#( %' $#(@%'=$%'? h(#).&'/#'$)i

#@.8&H@#'$ ='/ =(# $9#(#:&(# 8%=A8# :&( #_#@.8=(H /=@=?#), Q9%) )9&G8/ )#(+#/ h)%<i =) .(&$#<$%&' $&

&$9#( #@.8&H##) &: h.#$%$%&'#(i <&@.='H* ='/ AH ;=H &: #[email protected]# &( <&((#<$%&' :&( $9# .GA8%< ?&&/ )& $9=$

.#()&') )%@%8=(8H @%'/#/ =) h.#$%$%&'#()i ;&G8/ A# /#$#((#/ :(&@ <&@@%$$%'? $9# )=@# =<$),hITi

 

Q9# 2&G($ =8)& =::%(@) $9# =;=(/ &: =$$&('#H) :##), 3$ %) )#$$8#/ $9=$ ;9#' =' =<$%&' %) %')$%$G$#/ :&( $9#

(#<&+#(H &: ;=?#)* &( ;9#' #@.8&H##) =(# :&(<#/ $& 8%$%?=$# ='/ <&')#]G#'$8H %'<G( #_.#')#) $& .(&$#<$

$9#%( (%?9$) ='/ %'$#(#)$)* $9# ?(='$ &: =$$&('#H) :##) %) 8#?=88H `G)$%:%=A8#,hIEi 

=9%&%6+&%* $9# "#$%$%&' %) D3MN3D ='/ $9# =))=%8#/ 0#<%)%&' ='/ -#)&8G$%&' LBBN/T3D, 2&)$) =?=%')$

.#$%$%&'#(,

'+ +&7%&%7<

C5+1*-57KY6)&(,,(8@ F*,*+5@ F5,$&*KT*,57(0@ ='/ Y5,;&5@ EE.@ <&'<G(.

Page 79: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 79/108

 

19% .("#)( 9+1%) /+&0< ("7 .("#)( 9+1%) #"1)< )17<5 .#$%$%&'#()*

+),

"(1#+"() )(,+& &%)(1#+"' /+..#''#+"5 (&,#1%& /%6%&#"( ;< 7#+'("( ("7 .(&/%)+ -<

'("1+'5 (#).&'/#'$),

0(&7+5 ! <A 

Q9# <=)# A#:&(# $9# 2&G($ %) = .#$%$%&' :&( <#($%&(=(%> $& =''G8 $9# :&88&;%'? &(/#() &: $9# 6=$%&'=8 U=A&(

-#8=$%&') 2&@@%))%&' K9#(#%'=:$#( (#:#((#/ $& =) g6U-2gL :&( 9=+%'? A##' %))G#/ ;%$9&G$ &( ;%$9 #_<#))

 `G(%)/%<$%&' ='/ ;%$9 ?(=+# =AG)# &: /%)<(#$%&'aB 

K>L R,1(, *9 T5< Z!@ ![[Z,I -#+#()%'? ='/ )#$$%'? =)%/# %$) #=(8%#( (#)&8G$%&' &: JG?G)$ BP*

>CCB,S Q9# ]G#)$%&'#/ &(/#( /#<8=(#/ $9=$ $9# 6U-2* '&$ $9# "9%8%..%'# 5+#()#=) [email protected]&H@#'$

J/@%'%)$(=$%&' K9#(#%'=:$#( (#:#((#/ $& =) g"51JgL* 9=/ `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$l)

<&@.8=%'$[

KBL D(;&0&*+ *9 D(;(4=(, !\@ ![[],R 0%(#<$%'? .#$%$%&'#() $& `&%'$8H ='/ )#+#(=88H .=H .(%+=$#

(#).&'/#'$ $;#8+# $9&G)='/ ='/ )%_ 9G'/(#/ /&88=() KY4v >B*TDD,DDL (#.(#)#'$%'? )=8=(%#) :&( $9#

G'#_.%(#/ .&($%&' &: 9%) <&'$(=<$[ $9(## $9&G)='/ )%_ 9G'/(#/ /&88=() KY4vI*TDD,DDL =) #_$(= :&G(

@&'$9) )=8=(H :&( $9# $;& KBL H#=( .#(%&/ &: 9%) <&'$(=<$* $9(## $9&G)='/ )%_ 9G'/(#/ /&88=()

KY4vI*TDD,DDL =) g>S$9 @&'$9 .=Hg &( = $&$=8 &: '%'#$##' $9&G)='/ ='/ #%?9$ 9G'/(#/ /&88=()

KY4v>C*PDD,DDL &( %$) .#)& #]G%+=8#'$ ='/ =$$&('#Hl) :##) =@&G'$%'? $& $#' .#(<#'$ K>DmL &: $9#

$&$=8 =;=(/[ ='/

KIL R,1(, *9 T5,;% Z^@ ![[\,T 0#'H%'? $9# @&$%&' :&( (#<&')%/#(=$%&' &: $9# .#$%$%&'#(),

3' Z=H* >CPP* .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ Z=(<#8& 4='$&) K9#(#%'=:$#( (#:#((#/ $& =) g4='$&)gL ;=) =' &+#()#=)

;&(\#( #@.8&H#/ =) = .(%'$#( =$ $9# Z=^&&' "(%'$%'? "(#))* 4G8$='=$# &: 5@=', 4GA)#]G#'$8H* %' FG'#

>CPP* 9# ;=) /%(#<$8H 9%(#/ AH $9# "=8=<# d&$#8* O#%`%'?* "#&.8#l) -#.GA8%< &: 29%'= ='/ 8=$#( $#(@%'=$#/

/G# $& (#$(#'<9@#'$,

"#$%$%&'#() =(# $9# Z='%8= d&$#8 2&(.&(=$%&' K9#(#%'=:$#( (#:#((#/ $& =) gZd2gL ='/ $9# Z='%8= d&$#8

3'$#('=$%&'=8 2&@.='H* U%@%$#/ K9#(#%'=:$#( (#:#((#/ $& =) gZd32UgL,

79#' $9# <=)# ;=) :%8#/ %' >CCD* Zd2 ;=) )$%88 = ?&+#('@#'$M&;'#/ ='/ <&'$(&88#/ <&(.&(=$%&' /G8H

&(?='%^#/ ='/ #_%)$%'? G'/#( $9# 8=;) &: $9# "9%8%..%'#),

Zd32U %) = <&(.&(=$%&' /G8H &(?='%^#/ ='/ #_%)$%'? G'/#( $9# 8=;) &: d&'? b&'?,E Zd2 %) ='

g%'<&(.&(=$&(g &: Zd32U* &;'%'? RDm &: %$) <=.%$=8 )$&<\,P 

OH +%($G# &: = g@='=?#@#'$ =?(##@#'$gC ;%$9 $9# "=8=<# d&$#8 K7='? XG 2&@.='H U%@%$#/L*

Zd32U>D

 $(=%'#/ $9# .#()&''#8 ='/ )$=:: &: $9# "=8=<# d&$#8 =$ O#%`%'?* 29%'=,

6&; $9# :=<$),

0G(%'? 9%) #@.8&H@#'$ ;%$9 $9# Z=^&&' "(%'$%'? "(#)) %' $9# 4G8$='=$# &: 5@='* (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&)

(#<#%+#/ = 8#$$#( /=$#/ Z=H B* >CPP :(&@ Z(, N#(9=(/ -, 49@%/$* N#'#(=8 Z='=?#(* "=8=<# d&$#8* O#%`%'?*29%'=, Z(, 4<9@%/$ %':&(@#/ (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) $9=$ 9# ;=) (#<&@@#'/#/ AH &'# 6#)$&( OG#'%&* = :(%#'/

&: 9%),

Page 80: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 80/108

Z(, 49@%/$ &::#(#/ (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) $9# )=@# .&)%$%&' =) .(%'$#(* AG$ ;%$9 = 9%?9#( @&'$98H )=8=(H ='/

%'<(#=)#/ A#'#:%$), Q9# .&)%$%&' ;=) )8=$#/ $& &.#' &' 5<$&A#( >* >CPP,>>

 

5' Z=H P* >CPP* (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) ;(&$# $& Z(, 49@%/$ ='/ )%?'%:%#/ 9%) =<<#.$='<# &: $9# &::#(,

5' Z=H >C* >CPP* $9# "=8=<# d&$#8 Z='=?#(* Z(, d=') F, d#'\ @=%8#/ = (#=/H $& )%?' #@.8&H@#'$ <&'$(=<$

$& (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&), Z(, d#'\ =/+%)#/ (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) $9=$ %: $9# <&'$(=<$ ;=) =<<#.$=A8#* $& (#$G('

$9# )=@# $& Z(, d#'\ %' Z='%8=* $&?#$9#( ;%$9 9%) .=)).&($ ='/ $;& =//%$%&'=8 .%<$G(#) :&( 9%) +%)= $&29%'=,

5' Z=H ID* >CPP* (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) (#)%?'#/ :(&@ $9# Z=^&&' "(%'$%'? "(#))* #::#<$%+# FG'# ID* >CPP*

G'/#( $9# .(#$#_$ $9=$ 9# ;=) '##/#/ =$ 9&@# $& 9#8. ;%$9 $9# :=@%8Hl) .%??#(H ='/ .&G8$(H AG)%'#)),

5' FG'# S* >CPP* (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) ;(&$# $9# "=8=<# d&$#8 ='/ =<\'&;8#/?#/ Z(, d#'\l) 8#$$#(,

-#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) #'<8&)#/ :&G( KSL )%?'#/ <&.%#) &: $9# #@.8&H@#'$ <&'$(=<$ K/=$#/ FG'# S* >CPPL ='/

'&$%:%#/ $9#@ $9=$ 9# ;=) ?&%'? $& =((%+# %' Z='%8= /G(%'? $9# :%()$ ;##\ &: FG8H >CPP,

Q9# #@.8&H@#'$ <&'$(=<$ &: FG'# S* >CPP )$=$#/ $9=$ 9%) #@.8&H@#'$ ;&G8/ <&@@#'<# 4#.$#@A#( >*

>CPP :&( = .#(%&/ &: $;& H#=(),>B

 3$ .(&+%/#/ :&( = @&'$98H )=8=(H &: '%'# 9G'/(#/ /&88=() KY4vCDD,DDL '#$

&: $=_#)* .=H=A8# :&G($##' K>SL $%@#) = H#=(,>I 

5' FG'# ID* >CPP* (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) ;=) /##@#/ (#)%?'#/ :(&@ $9# Z=^&&' "(%'$%'? "(#)),

5' FG8H >* >CPP* (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) =((%+#/ %' Z='%8=,

5' 6&+#@A#( R* >CPP* (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) 8#:$ :&( O#%`%'?* 29%'=, d# )$=($#/ $& ;&(\ =$ $9# "=8=<# d&$#8,>S 

4GA)#]G#'$8H* (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) )%?'#/ =' =@#'/#/ g#@.8&H@#'$ =?(##@#'$g ;%$9 $9# "=8=<# d&$#8*

#::#<$%+# 6&+#@A#( R* >CPP, 3' $9# <&'$(=<$* Z(, 49@%/$ (#.(#)#'$#/ $9# "=8=<# d&$#8, Q9# V%<# "(#)%/#'$K5.#(=$%&') ='/ 0#+#8&.@#'$L &: .#$%$%&'#( Zd32U Z%?G#8 0, 2#(?G#/= )%?'#/ $9# #@.8&H@#'$

=?(##@#'$ G'/#( $9# ;&(/ g'&$#/g,

X(&@ FG'# P $& BC* >CPC* (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) ;=) %' $9# "9%8%..%'#) &' +=<=$%&' 8#=+#, d# (#$G('#/ $& 29%'=

='/ (#=))G@#/ 9%) .&)$ &' FG8H >E* >CPC,

5' FG8H BB* >CPC* Z(, 49@%/$l) 1_#<G$%+# 4#<(#$=(H* = <#($=%' F&=''= )G??#)$#/ %' = 9='/;(%$$#' '&$# $9=$

(#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) A# ?%+#' &'# K>L @&'$9 '&$%<# &: 9%) (#8#=)# :(&@ #@.8&H@#'$,

5' JG?G)$ >D* >CPC* $9# "=8=<# d&$#8 %':&(@#/ (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) AH 8#$$#( )%?'#/ AH Z(, 49@%/$ $9=$ 9%)#@.8&H@#'$ =$ $9# "=8=<# d&$#8 .(%'$ )9&. ;&G8/ A# $#(@%'=$#/ /G# $& AG)%'#)) (#+#()#) A(&G?9$ =A&G$

AH $9# .&8%$%<=8 G.9#=+=8 %' 29%'=,>R

 7# ]G&$# $9# 8#$$#(a>T

 

gJ:$#( $9# G':&($G'=$# 9=..#'%'?) %' 29%'= ='/ #).#<%=88H O#%`%'? K(#:#((%'? $& Q%=''=@#' 4]G=(#

%'<%/#'$)L* &G( AG)%'#)) 9=) A##' )#+#(#8H =::#<$#/, Q& (#/G<# #_.#')#)* ;# ;%88 '&$ &.#'e&.#(=$#

.(%'$)9&. :&( $9# $%@# A#%'?,

g7# )%'<#(#8H (#?(#$ $9=$ = /#<%)%&' 8%\# $9%) 9=) $& A# @=/#* AG$ (#)$ =))G(#/ $9%) /&#) %' '& ;=H

(#:8#<$ H&G( .=)$ .#(:&(@='<# ;9%<9 ;# :&G'/ G. $& &G( #_.#<$=$%&'),g

g49&G8/ = $G('=(&G'/ %' $9# AG)%'#)) 9=..#'* ;# ;%88 <&'$=<$ H&G /%(#<$8H ='/ ?%+# H&G .(%&(%$H &'

:G$G(# =))%?'@#'$,g

Page 81: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 81/108

5' 4#.$#@A#( R* >CPC* $9# "=8=<# d&$#8 $#(@%'=$#/ $9# #@.8&H@#'$ &: (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) ='/ .=%/ =88

A#'#:%$) /G# 9%@* %'<8G/%'? 9%) .8='# :=(# A=<\ $& $9# "9%8%..%'#),

5' 5<$&A#( I* >CPC* (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) ;=) (#.=$(%=$#/ $& $9# "9%8%..%'#),

5' 5<$&A#( BS* >CPC* (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&)* $9(&G?9 9%) 8=;H#(* J$$H, 1/'=+# ;(&$# Z(, 49@%/$* /#@='/%'?

:G88 <&@.#')=$%&' .G()G='$ $& $9# #@.8&H@#'$ =?(##@#'$,

5' 6&+#@A#( >>* >CPC* Z(, 49@%/$ (#.8%#/* $& ;%$a>E 

d%) )#(+%<# ;%$9 $9# "=8=<# d&$#8* O#%`%'? ;=) '&$ =A(G.$8H $#(@%'=$#/ AG$ ;# :&88&;#/ $9# &'#M

@&'$9 '&$%<# <8=G)# ='/ Z(, 4='$&) (#<#%+#/ =88 A#'#:%$) /G# 9%@,

gX&( H&G( %':&(@=$%&' $9# "(%'$ 49&. =$ $9# "=8=<# d&$#8 %) )$%88 '&$ &.#(=$%&'=8 ='/ ;%$9 = 8&;

AG)%'#)) &G$8&&\* (#$(#'<9@#'$ %' +=(%&G) /#.=($@#'$) &: $9# 9&$#8 %) ?&%'? &' ;9%<9 %) = '&(@=8

@='=?#@#'$ .(=<$%<# $& <&'$(&8 <&)$),

g79#' ?&%'? $9(&G?9 $9# 8=$#)$ .#(:&(@='<# (=$%'?)* .8#=)# =8)& A# =/+%)#/ $9=$ 9%) .#(:&(@='<#

;=) A#8&; =+#(=?# ='/ = 29%'#)# 6=$%&'=8 ;9& %) /&%'? 9%) `&A '&; )9&;) = A#$$#( =..(&=<9,

g3' <8&)%'?* ;9#' Z(, 4='$&) (#<#%+#/ $9# 8#$$#( &: '&$%<#* 9# 9=(/8H )9&;#/ G. :&( ;&(\ AG$ )$%88

#'`&H#/ :(## =<<&@@&/=$%&'e8=G'/(He@#=8) G. $& $9# /=H &: 9%) /#.=($G(#,g

5' X#A(G=(H BD* >CCD* (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) :%8#/ = <&@.8=%'$ :&( %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8 ;%$9 $9# J(A%$(=$%&' O(='<9*

6=$%&'=8 2=.%$=8 -#?%&'* 6=$%&'=8 U=A&( -#8=$%&') 2&@@%))%&' K6U-2L, d# .(=H#/ :&( =' =;=(/ &: '%'#$##'

$9&G)='/ '%'# 9G'/(#/ ='/ $;#'$H $9(## /&88=() KY4v>C*CBI,DDL =) =<$G=8 /=@=?#)* :&($H $9&G)='/ .#)&)

K"SD*DDD,DDL =) #_#@.8=(H /=@=?#) ='/ =$$&('#Hl) :##) #]G%+=8#'$ $& BDm &: $9# /=@=?#) .(=H#/ :&(, Q9#

<&@.8=%'$ '=@#/ Zd2* Zd32U* $9# "=8=<# d&$#8 ='/ Z(, 49@%/$ =) (#).&'/#'$),

Q9# "=8=<# d&$#8 ='/ Z(, 49@%/$ ;#(# '&$ )#(+#/ ;%$9 )G@@&') ='/ '#%$9#( .=($%<%.=$#/ %' $9#

.(&<##/%'?) A#:&(# $9# U=A&( J(A%$#(,>P 

5' FG'# BE* >CC>* U=A&( J(A%$#( 2#:#(%'= F, 0%&)='=* /#<%/#/ $9# <=)# =?=%')$ .#$%$%&'#()* $9G)a>C

 

g7d1-1X5-1* `G/?@#'$ %) 9#(#AH (#'/#(#/a

g>, /%(#<$%'? =88 $9# (#).&'/#'$) $& .=H <&@.8=%'='$ `&%'$8H ='/ )#+#(=88H[

g=L vBD*PBD Y4 /&88=() &( %$) #]G%+=8#'$ %' "9%8%..%'# <G((#'<H =) G'#=('#/ )=8=(%#)[

gAL "RD*DDD,DD =) @&(=8 /=@=?#)[

g<L "SD*DDD,DD =) #_#@.8=(H /=@=?#)[ ='/

g/L Q#' K>DL .#(<#'$ &: $9# $&$=8 =;=(/ =) =$$&('#Hl) :##),

g45 5-01-10,g

5' FG8H BI* >CC>* .#$%$%&'#() =..#=8#/ $& $9# 6U-2* =(?G%'? $9=$ $9# "51J* '&$ $9# 6U-2 9=/ `G(%)/%<$%&'

&+#( $9# <=)#,

5' JG?G)$ BP* >CCB* $9# 6U-2 .(&@G8?=$#/ = (#)&8G$%&'* )$=$%'?aBD 

Page 82: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 82/108

g7d1-1X5-1* 8#$ $9# =..#=8#/ 0#<%)%&' A#* =) %$ %) 9#(#AH* /#<8=(#/ 'G88 ='/ +&%/ :&( ;='$ &:

 `G(%)/%<$%&', 2&@.8=%'='$ %) 9#(#AH #'`&%'#/ $& :%8# 9%) <&@.8=%'$ ;%$9 $9# "51J,

g45 5-01-10,g

5' 4#.$#@A#( >P* >CCB* (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) @&+#/ :&( (#<&')%/#(=$%&' &: $9# =:&(#M]G&$#/ (#)&8G$%&', d#

=(?G#/ $9=$ $9# <=)# ;=) '&$ <&?'%^=A8# AH $9# "51J =) 9# ;=) '&$ =' g&+#()#=) <&'$(=<$ ;&(\#(,gB>

 

5' Z=H I>* >CCI* $9# 6U-2 ?(='$#/ $9# @&$%&' ='/ (#+#()#/ %$)#8:, Q9# 6U-2 /%(#<$#/ U=A&( J(A%$#(

1@#()&' QG@='&' $& 9#=( $9# <=)# &' $9# ]G#)$%&' &: ;9#$9#( .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ ;=) (#$(#'<9#/ &(

/%)@%))#/,BB

 

5' F='G=(H >I* >CCS* U=A&( J(A%$#( QG@='&' <&@.8#$#/ $9# .(&<##/%'?) A=)#/ &' $9# $#)$%@&'%=8 ='/

/&<G@#'$=(H #+%/#'<# .(#)#'$#/ $& ='/ 9#=(/ AH 9%@,BI 

4GA)#]G#'$8H* U=A&( J(A%$#( QG@='&' ;=) (#M=))%?'#/ =) $(%=8 J(A%$#( &: $9# 6=$%&'=8 2=.%$=8 -#?%&'*

J(A%$(=$%&' O(='<9* ='/ $9# <=)# ;=) $(='):#((#/ $& U=A&( J(A%$#( F&)# N, /# V#(=,BS

 

5' 6&+#@A#( BR* >CCS* U=A&( J(A%$#( /# V#(= )GA@%$$#/ 9%) (#.&($,BR d# :&G'/ $9=$ (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&)

;=) %88#?=88H /%)@%))#/ :(&@ #@.8&H@#'$ ='/ (#<&@@#'/#/ $9=$ 9# A# .=%/ =<$G=8 /=@=?#) #]G%+=8#'$ $&

9%) )=8=(%#) :&( $9# G'#_.%(#/ .&($%&' &: 9%) <&'$(=<$,BT

 

5' 0#<#@A#( >R* >CCS* $9# 6U-2 (G8#/ %' :=+&( &: .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$* $& ;%$aBE

 

g7d1-1X5-1* :%'/%'? $9=$ $9# (#.&($ ='/ (#<&@@#'/=$%&') &: J(A%$#( /# V#(= =(# )G..&($#/ AH

)GA)$='$%=8 #+%/#'<#* `G/?@#'$ %) 9#(#AH (#'/#(#/* /%(#<$%'? $9# (#).&'/#'$) $& `&%'$8H ='/

)#+#(=88H .=H <&@.8=%'='$ $9# :&88&;%'? <&@.G$#/ <&'$(=<$G=8 A#'#:%$)a K>L Y4v>B*TDD,DD =)

)=8=(%#) :&( $9# G'#_.%(#/ .&($%&' &: $9# .=($%#)l <&'$(=<$[ KBL Y4vI*TDD,DD =) #_$(= :&G( KSL @&'$9)

)=8=(H :&( $9# $;& KBL H#=() .#(%&/ K)%<L &: $9# .=($%#)l <&'$(=<$[ KIL Y4vI*TDD,DD =) g>S$9 @&'$9.=Hg :&( $9# =:&(#)=%/ $;& KBL H#=() <&'$(=<$ )$%.G8=$#/ AH $9# .=($%#) &( = $&$=8 &: Y4v>C*PDD,DD &(

%$) .#)& #]G%+=8#'$* .8G) KSL =$$&('#Hl) :##) &: >Dm &: <&@.8=%'='$l) $&$=8 =;=(/,

g45 5-01-10,g

5' X#A(G=(H B* >CCR* .#$%$%&'#() :%8#/ = @&$%&' :&( (#<&')%/#(=$%&' =(?G%'? $9=$ U=A&( J(A%$#( /# V#(=l)

(#<&@@#'/=$%&' 9=/ '& A=)%) %' 8=; ='/ %' :=<$,BP 

5' Z=(<9 ID* >CCR* $9# 6U-2 /#'%#/ $9# @&$%&' :&( (#<&')%/#(=$%&',BC

 

d#'<#* $9%) .#$%$%&',ID

 

5' 5<$&A#( C* >CCR* .#$%$%&'#() :%8#/ ;%$9 $9%) 2&G($ =' G(?#'$ @&$%&' :&( $9# %))G='<# &: = $#@.&(=(H

(#)$(=%'%'? &(/#( ='/e&( ;(%$ &: .(#8%@%'=(H %'`G'<$%&' ='/ = @&$%&' :&( $9# =''G8@#'$ &: $9# #'$(H &:

 `G/?@#'$ &: $9# 6U-2 /=$#/ FG8H I>* >CCR,I>

 

5' 6&+#@A#( BD* >CCR* $9# 2&G($ /#'%#/ .#$%$%&'#(l) G(?#'$ @&$%&', Q9# 2&G($ (#]G%(#/ (#).&'/#'$) $&

:%8# $9#%( (#).#<$%+# <&@@#'$)* ;%$9&G$ ?%+%'? /G# <&G()# $& $9# .#$%$%&',IB 

5' Z=(<9 P* >CCT* $9# 4&8%<%$&( N#'#(=8 :%8#/ = @='%:#)$=$%&' )$=$%'? $9=$ =:$#( ?&%'? &+#( $9# .#$%$%&' ='/%$) =''#_#)* $9#H <=' '&$ /#:#'/ ='/ )G)$=%' $9# .&)%$%&' $=\#' AH $9# 6U-2 %' %$) =))=%8#/ /#<%)%&' ='/

&(/#(), Q9# 4&8%<%$&( N#'#(=8 .(=H#/ $9=$ 9# A# #_<G)#/ :(&@ :%8%'? = <&@@#'$ &' A#9=8: &: $9# 6U-2II

 

5' J.(%8 ID*>CCT* .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) :%8#/ 9%) <&@@#'$,IS

 

Page 83: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 83/108

5' FG'# BT* >CCT* $9# 2&G($ ?(='$#/ $9# @='%:#)$=$%&' &: $9# 4&8%<%$&( N#'#(=8 ='/ (#]G%(#/ $9# 6U-2 $&

:%8# %$) &;' <&@@#'$ $& $9# .#$%$%&',IR

 

5' F='G=(H E* >CCE* $9# 6U-2 :%8#/ %$) <&@@#'$,

Q9# .#$%$%&' %) @#(%$&(%&G),

N. B*,64 M*+KF*+-(+&(+0 

Q9# 6U-2 ;=) = )#(%&G)8H %'<&'+#'%#'$ :&(G@,

7# '&$# $9=$ $9# @=%' =).#<$) &: $9# <=)# $(=').%(#/ %' $;& :&(#%?' `G(%)/%<$%&') ='/ $9# <=)# %'+&8+#)

.G(#8H :&(#%?' #8#@#'$), Q9# &'8H 8%'\ $9=$ $9# "9%8%..%'#) 9=) ;%$9 $9# <=)# %) $9=$ (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) %) =

X%8%.%'& <%$%^#', Q9# "=8=<# d&$#8 ='/ Zd32U =(# :&(#%?' <&(.&(=$%&'), 6&$ =88 <=)#) %'+&8+%'? &G( <%$%^#')

<=' A# $(%#/ 9#(#,

P%( (4$7*<4(+) ;*+),5;) , o -#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) ;=) 9%(#/ /%(#<$8H AH $9# "=8=<# d&$#8* = :&(#%?'

#@.8&H#(* $9(&G?9 <&((#).&'/#'<# )#'$ $& $9# 4G8$='=$# &: 5@='* ;9#(# (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) ;=) $9#'

#@.8&H#/, d# ;=) 9%(#/ ;%$9&G$ $9# %'$#(+#'$%&' &: $9# "51J &( ='H =G$9&(%^#/ (#<(G%$@#'$ =?#'<H &: $9#

?&+#('@#'$,IT

 

Y'/#( $9# (G8# &: 9*,64 +*+ ;*+-(+&(+0* = "9%8%..%'# <&G($ &( =?#'<H @=H =))G@# `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( $9#

<=)# %: %$ <9&&)#) $& /& )& $,*-&1(1 a K>L $9=$ $9# "9%8%..%'# <&G($ %) &'# $& ;9%<9 $9# .=($%#) @=H

<&'+#'%#'$8H (#)&($ $&[ KBL $9=$ $9# "9%8%..%'# <&G($ %) %' = .&)%$%&' $& @=\# =' %'$#88%?#'$ /#<%)%&' =) $& $9#

8=; ='/ $9# :=<$)[ ='/ KIL $9=$ $9# "9%8%..%'# <&G($ 9=) &( %) 8%\#8H $& 9=+# .&;#( $& #':&(<# %$)

/#<%)%&',IE

 Q9# <&'/%$%&') =(# G'=+=%8%'? %' $9# <=)# =$ A=(,

M*) F*+-(+&(+) , o 7# :=%8 $& )## 9&; $9# 6U-2 %) = <&'+#'%#'$ :&(G@ ?%+#' $9=$ =88 $9# %'<%/#'$) &: $9#

<=)# o :(&@ $9# $%@# &: (#<(G%$@#'$* $& #@.8&H@#'$ $& /%)@%))=8 &<<G((#/ &G$)%/# $9# "9%8%..%'#), Q9#%'<&'+#'%#'<# %) <&@.&G'/#/ AH $9# :=<$ $9=$ $9# .(&.#( /#:#'/='$)* $9# "=8=<# d&$#8 ='/ Zd32U =(# '&$

'=$%&'=8) &: $9# "9%8%..%'#), 6#%$9#( ,=(# $9#H g/&%'? AG)%'#)) %' $9# "9%8%..%'#),g U%\#;%)#* $9# @=%'

;%$'#))#)* Z(, 49@%/$ ='/ Z(, d#'\ =(# '&'M(#)%/#'$) &: $9# "9%8%..%'#),

M* $*#(, )* 1()(,4&+( 5$$7&;5=7( 75# , o 6#%$9#( <=' =' %'$#88%?#'$ /#<%)%&' A# @=/# =) $& $9# 8=;

?&+#('%'? $9# #@.8&H@#'$ <&'$(=<$ =) )G<9 ;=) .#(:#<$#/ %' :&(#%?' )&%8, Q9%) <=88) $& :&(# $9# =..8%<=$%&'

&: $9# .(%'<%.8# &: 8#_ 8&<% <&'$(=<$G) K$9# 8=; &: $9# .8=<# ;9#(# $9# <&'$(=<$ ;=) @=/#L,IP

 

Q9# #@.8&H@#'$ <&'$(=<$ ;=) '&$ .#(:#<$#/ %' $9# "9%8%..%'#), -#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) )%?'%:%#/ 9%) =<<#.$='<#

AH ;(%$%'? = 8#$$#( ;9%8# 9# ;=) %' $9# -#.GA8%< &: 5@=', Q9%) 8#$$#( ;=) )#'$ $& $9# "=8=<# d&$#8 %' $9#"#&.8#l) -#.GA8%< &: 29%'=,

M* $*#(, )* 1()(,4&+( )%( 95;)0, o 6#%$9#( <=' $9# 6U-2 /#$#(@%'# $9# :=<$) )G((&G'/%'? $9# =88#?#/

%88#?=8 /%)@%))=8 =) =88 =<$) <&@.8=%'#/ &: $&&\ .8=<# %' O#%`%'?* "#&.8#l) -#.GA8%< &: 29%'=, Q9# 6U-2 ;=)

'&$ %' = .&)%$%&' $& /#$#(@%'# ;9#$9#( $9# Q%=''=@#' 4]G=(# %'<%/#'$ $(G8H =/+#()#8H =::#<$#/ &.#(=$%&')

&: $9# "=8=<# d&$#8 =) $& `G)$%:H (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&)l (#$(#'<9@#'$,

',&+;&$7( *9 (99(;)&-(+(00@ +* $*#(, )* (Q(;6)( 1(;&0&*+, o 1+#' =))G@%'? $9=$ = .(&.#( /#<%)%&' <&G8/ A#

(#=<9#/ AH $9# 6U-2* )G<9 ;&G8/ '&$ 9=+# ='H A%'/%'? #::#<$ =?=%')$ $9# #@.8&H#(* $9# "=8=<# d&$#8, Q9#

"=8=<# d&$#8 %) = <&(.&(=$%&' %'<&(.&(=$#/ G'/#( $9# 8=;) &: 29%'= ='/ ;=) '&$ #+#' )#(+#/ ;%$9)G@@&'), FG(%)/%<$%&' &+#( %$) .#()&' ;=) '&$ =<]G%(#/,

Q9%) %) '&$ $& )=H $9=$ "9%8%..%'# <&G($) ='/ =?#'<%#) 9=+# '& .&;#( $& )&8+# <&'$(&+#()%#) %'+&8+%'?

:&(#%?' #@.8&H#(), 6#%$9#( =(# ;# )=H%'? $9=$ ;# /& '&$ 9=+# .&;#( &+#( =' #@.8&H@#'$ <&'$(=<$

Page 84: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 84/108

#_#<G$#/ %' = :&(#%?' <&G'$(H. N9 C5+)*0 #(,( 5+ _*-(,0(50 ;*+),5;) #*,>(,_@ 5 '%&7&$$&+( 9*,64@ 0$(;&9&;577<

)%( 'R3L@ +*) )%( M?/F@ #*671 $,*)(;) %&4,IC

 d# %) '&$ =' g&+#()#=) <&'$(=<$ ;&(\#(g = :=<$ ;9%<9 9#

=/@%$) ;%$9 <&'+%<$%&',SD

 

1+#' =))G@%'? $9=$ $9# 6U-2 ;=) $9# .(&.#( :&(G@* #+#' &' $9# @#(%$)* $9# 6U-2l) /#<%)%&' <=''&$ A#

)G)$=%'#/,

NN. TWF M*) ?&5=7( 

1+#' %: ;# =))G@# $;& $9%'?)a K>L $9=$ $9# 6U-2 9=/ `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( $9# <=)#* ='/ KBL $9=$ Zd32U ;=)

8%=A8# :&( 4='$&)l (#$(#'<9@#'$* )$%88 Zd2* =) = )#.=(=$# ='/ /%)$%'<$ `G(%/%<=8 #'$%$H <=''&$ A# 9#8/ 8%=A8#,

Q(G#* Zd2 %) =' %'<&(.&(=$&( &: Zd32U ='/ &;') :%:$H .#(<#'$ KRDmL &: %$) <=.%$=8 )$&<\, d&;#+#(* $9%) %)

'&$ #'&G?9 $& .%#(<# $9# +#%8 &: <&(.&(=$# :%<$%&' A#$;##' Zd32U ='/ Zd2,

"%#(<%'? $9# +#%8 &: <&(.&(=$# #'$%$H %) =' #]G%$=A8# (#@#/H, 3$ %) (#)&($#/ $& ;9#' $9# <&(.&(=$# :%<$%&' %)

G)#/ $& /#:#=$ .GA8%< <&'+#'%#'<#* `G)$%:H ;(&'?* .(&$#<$ :(=G/ &( /#:#'/ = <(%@#, S> 3$ %) /&'# &'8H ;9#'

= <&(.&(=$%&' %) = @#(# =8$#( #?& &( AG)%'#)) <&'/G%$ &: = .#()&' &( ='&$9#( <&(.&(=$%&',

3' P,51(,0 /*<57 S5+> -. F*6,) *9 L$$(570*SB

 ;# 9#8/ $9=$ g$9# @#(# &;'#()9%. AH = )%'?8# )$&<\9&8/#( &(

AH ='&$9#( <&(.&(=$%&' &: =88 &( '#=(8H =88 &: $9# <=.%$=8 )$&<\ &: = <&(.&(=$%&' %) '&$ &: %$)#8: = )G::%<%#'$

(#=)&' :&( /%)(#?=(/%'? $9# :%<$%&' &: )#.=(=$# <&(.&(=$# .#()&'=8%$%#),g

Q9# $#)$) %' /#$#(@%'%'? ;9#$9#( $9# <&(.&(=$# +#%8 @=H A# .%#(<#/ =(#a B&,0) * $9# /#:#'/='$ @G)$ 9=+#

<&'$(&8 &( <&@.8#$# /&@%'=$%&' &: $9# &$9#( <&(.&(=$%&'l) :%'='<#)* .&8%<H ='/ AG)%'#)) .(=<$%<#) ;%$9

(#?=(/ $& $9# $(=')=<$%&' =$$=<\#/, Q9#(# @G)$ A# .(&&: $9=$ $9# &$9#( <&(.&(=$%&' 9=/ '& )#.=(=$# @%'/*

;%88 &( #_%)$#'<# ;%$9 (#).#<$ $9# =<$ <&@.8=%'#/ &:, C(;*+1 * <&'$(&8 @G)$ A# G)#/ AH $9# /#:#'/='$ $&

<&@@%$ :(=G/ &( ;(&'?, P%&,1 * $9# =:&(#)=%/ <&'$(&8 &( A(#=<9 &: /G$H @G)$ A# $9# .(&_%@=$# <=G)# &: $9#

%'`G(H &( 8&)) <&@.8=%'#/ &:, Q9# =A)#'<# &: ='H &: $9# #8#@#'$) .(#+#'$) $9# .%#(<%'? &: $9# <&(.&(=$#

+#%8,SI

 

3$ %) A=)%< $9=$ = <&(.&(=$%&' 9=) = .#()&'=8%$H )#.=(=$# ='/ /%)$%'<$ :(&@ $9&)# <&@.&)%'? %$ =) ;#88 =)

:(&@ $9=$ &: ='H &$9#( 8#?=8 #'$%$H $& ;9%<9 %$ @=H A# (#8=$#/,SS

 28#=( ='/ <&'+%'<%'? #+%/#'<# %) '##/#/ $&

.%#(<# $9# +#%8 &: <&(.&(=$# :%<$%&',SR

 3' $9%) <=)#* ;# :%'/ '& #+%/#'<# $& )9&; $9=$ Zd32U ='/ Zd2 =(#

&'# ='/ $9# )=@# #'$%$H,

NNN. TWNF? +*) ?&5=7( 

-#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) .(#/%<=$#) Zd32Ul) 8%=A%8%$H &' $9# :=<$ $9=$ Zd32U g)%?'#/g 9%) #@.8&H@#'$ <&'$(=<$;%$9 $9# "=8=<# d&$#8, Q9%) :=<$ :=%8) $& .#()G=/# G),

B&,0) * ;# '&$# $9=$ $9# V%<# "(#)%/#'$ K5.#(=$%&') ='/ 0#+#8&.@#'$L &: Zd32U* Z%?G#8 0, 2#(?G#/= )%?'#/

$9# #@.8&H@#'$ <&'$(=<$ =) = @#(# ;%$'#)), d# @#(#8H )%?'#/ G'/#( $9# ;&(/ g'&$#/g,

79#' &'# g'&$#)g = <&'$(=<$* &'# %) '&$ #_.(#))%'? 9%) =?(##@#'$ &( =..(&+=8* =) = .=($H

;&G8/,ST

 3' C&;%5+I;* -. S*5,1 *9 F*44&00&*+(,0 *9 N44&I,5)&*+*SE

 $9# 2&G($ (#<&?'%^#/ $9=$ $9# $#(@

g'&$#/g @#=') $9=$ $9# .#()&' )& '&$%'? 9=) @#(#8H $=\#' <&?'%^='<# &: $9# #_%)$#'<# &: =' =<$ &(

/#<8=(=$%&'* ;%$9&G$ #_#(<%)%'? = `G/%<%&G) /#8%A#(=$%&' &( (#'/#(%'? = /#<%)%&' &' $9# @=$$#(,

Z(, 2#(?G#/= @#(#8H )%?'#/ $9# g;%$'#))%'? .=($g &: $9# /&<G@#'$, Q9# g;%$'#))%'? .=($g &: $9#

/&<G@#'$ %) $9=$ ;9%<9* g%' = /##/ &( &$9#( :&(@=8 %')$(G@#'$ %) $9=$ .=($ #%&;% ;*4(0 59)(, )%( ,(;&)570*

&( ;9#(# $9#(# =(# '& (#<%$=8)* 59)(, )%( $5,)&(0 K(4$%50&0 *6,0L,gSP J) &..&)#/ $& = .=($H $& = <&'$(=<$* =

;%$'#)) %) )%@.8H &'# ;9&* gA#%'? .(#)#'$* .#()&'=88H )##) &( .#(<#%+#) = $9%'?[ = A#9&8/#(* = ).#<$=$&(* &(

Page 85: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 85/108

#H#;%$'#)),gSC

 5'# ;9& g'&$#)g )&@#$9%'? `G)$ @=\#) = gA(%#: ;(%$$#' )$=$#@#'$gRD

 = @#@&(='/G@ &(

&A)#(+=$%&',

C(;*+1 * ='/ @&(# %@.&($='$8H* $9#(# ;=) '& #_%)$%'? #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. A#$;##' 4='$&) ='/

Zd32U, 3' /#$#(@%'%'? $9# #_%)$#'<# &: =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%.* $9# :&88&;%'? #8#@#'$) =(#

<&')%/#(#/aR>

 

gK>L $9# )#8#<$%&' ='/ #'?=?#@#'$ &: $9# #@.8&H##[

gKBL $9# .=H@#'$ &: ;=?#)[

gKIL $9# .&;#( $& /%)@%))[ ='/

gKSL $9# .&;#( $& <&'$(&8 #@.8&H##l) <&'/G<$,g

Zd32U /%/ '&$ 9=+# ='/ /%/ '&$ #_#(<%)# ='H &: $9# =:&(#@#'$%&'#/ .&;#(), 3$ /%/ +*)  )#8#<$ (#).&'/#'$

4='$&) =) =' #@.8&H## :&( $9# "=8=<# d&$#8, d# ;=) (#:#((#/ $& $9# "=8=<# d&$#8 AH 9%) :(%#'/* 6#)$&(

OG#'%&, Zd32U /%/ '&$ #'?=?# (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) $& ;&(\, Q9# $#(@) &: #@.8&H@#'$ ;#(# '#?&$%=$#/ ='/

:%'=8%^#/ $9(&G?9 <&((#).&'/#'<# A#$;##' (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&)* Z(, 4<9@%/$ ='/ Z(, d#'\* ;9& ;#(#

&::%<#() ='/ (#.(#)#'$=$%+#) &: $9# "=8=<# d&$#8 ='/ '&$ Zd32U, 6#%$9#( /%/ (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) =//G<# ='H

.(&&: $9=$ Zd32U 9=/ $9# .&;#( $& <&'$(&8 9%) <&'/G<$, X%'=88H* %$ ;=) $9# "=8=<# d&$#8* $9(&G?9 Z(,

4<9@%/$ ='/ +*)  Zd32U $9=$ $#(@%'=$#/ (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&)l )#(+%<#),

6#%$9#( %) $9#(# #+%/#'<# $& )G??#)$ $9=$ Zd32U ;=) = g8=A&(M&'8H <&'$(=<$&(,gRB

 Q9#(# %) '& .(&&: $9=$

Zd32U g)G..8%#/g (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&) &( #+#' (#:#((#/ 9%@ :&( #@.8&H@#'$ $& $9# "=8=<# d&$#8,

U%\#;%)#* $9#(# %) '& #+%/#'<# $& )9&; $9=$ $9# "=8=<# d&$#8 ='/ Zd32U =(# &'# ='/ $9# )=@# #'$%$H, Q9#

:=<$ $9=$ $9# "=8=<# d&$#8 %) = @#@A#( &: $9# gZ='%8= d&$#8 N(&G.g %) '&$ #'&G?9 $& .%#(<# $9# <&(.&(=$#

+#%8 A#$;##' Zd32U ='/ $9# "=8=<# d&$#8,

N`. Y,5-( L=60( *9 D&0;,()&*+ 

2&')%/#(%'? $9=$ $9# 6U-2 ;=) 9*,64 +*+K;*+-(+&(+0 ='/ <&')%/#(%'? :G($9#( $9=$ '& #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H##

(#8=$%&')9%. #_%)$#/ A#$;##' Zd32U* Zd2 ='/ (#).&'/#'$ 4='$&)* U=A&( J(A%$#( 2#:#(%'= F, 0%&)='= <8#=(8H

9=/ '& `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( (#).&'/#'$l) <8=%@ %' 6U-2 62- 2=)# 6&, DDMDBMD>DRPMCD,

U=A&( J(A%$#() 9=+# #_<8G)%+# ='/ &(%?%'=8 `G(%)/%<$%&' &'8H &+#( $9# :&88&;%'?aRI

 

g>, Y':=%( 8=A&( .(=<$%<# <=)#)[

gB, Q#(@%'=$%&' /%).G$#)[

gI, 3: =<<&@.='%#/ ;%$9 = <8=%@ :&( (#%')$=$#@#'$* $9&)# <=)#) $9=$ ;&(\#() @=H :%8# %'+&8+%'?

;=?#)* (=$#) &: .=H* 9&G() &: ;&(\ ='/ &$9#( $#(@) ='/ <&'/%$%&') &: #@.8&H@#'$[

gS, 28=%@) :&( =<$G=8* @&(=8* #_#@.8=(H ='/ &$9#( :&(@) &: /=@=?#) =(%)%'? :(&@ #@.8&H#(M

#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')[

gR, 2=)#) =(%)%'? :(&@ ='H +%&8=$%&' &: J($%<8# BTS &: $9%) 2&/#* %'<8G/%'? ]G#)$%&') %'+&8+%'? 8#?=8%$H

&: )$(%\#) ='/ 8&<\&G$)[ ='/

gT, 1_<#.$ <8=%@) :&( [email protected]&H##) 2&@.#')=$%&'* 4&<%=8 4#<G(%$H* Z#/%<=(# ='/ @=$#('%$H A#'#:%$)*

=88 &$9#( <8=%@)* =(%)%'? :(&@ #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')* %'<8G/%'? $9&)# &: .#()&') %' /&@#)$%<

Page 86: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 86/108

&( 9&G)#9&8/ )#(+%<#* %'+&8+%'? =' =@&G'$ #_<##/%'? :%+# $9&G)='/ .#)&) K"R*DDD,DDL (#?=(/8#)) &:

;9#$9#( =<<&@.='%#/ ;%$9 = <8=%@ :&( (#%')$=$#@#'$,g

3' =88 $9#)# <=)#)* =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. %) =' %'/%).#')=A8# `G(%)/%<$%&'=8 (#]G%(#@#'$,

Q9# `G(%)/%<$%&' &: 8=A&( =(A%$#() ='/ $9# 6U-2 G'/#( J($%<8# B>E &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# %) 8%@%$#/ $& /%).G$#)

=(%)%'? :(&@ =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. ;9%<9 <=' A# (#)&8+#/ AH (#:#(#'<# $& $9# U=A&( 2&/#* &(

&$9#( 8=A&( )$=$G$#)* &( $9#%( <&88#<$%+# A=(?=%'%'? =?(##@#'$),RS

 

gQ& /#$#(@%'# ;9%<9 A&/H 9=) `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( $9# .(#)#'$ <&'$(&+#()H* ;# (#8H &' $9# )&G'/ `G/%<%=8

.(%'<%.8# $9=$ `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( $9# )GA`#<$ @=$$#( %) <&':#((#/ AH 8=; ='/ %) /#$#(@%'#/ AH $9# =88#?=$%&')

&: $9# <&@.8=%'$ %((#).#<$%+# &: ;9#$9#( $9# .8=%'$%:: %) #'$%$8#/ $& =88 &( )&@# &: $9# <8=%@) =))#($#/

$9#(#%',gRR

 

Q9# 8=<\ &: `G(%)/%<$%&' &: $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( ;=) &A+%&G) :(&@ $9# =88#?=$%&') &: $9# <&@.8=%'$, d%) :=%8G(#

$& /%)@%)) $9# <=)# =@&G'$) $& ?(=+# =AG)# &: /%)<(#$%&',RT

 

`. P%( B577* 

7d1-1X5-1* $9# 2&G($ 9#(#AH N-J6Q4 $9# .#$%$%&' :&( <#($%&(=(% ='/ J66YU4 $9# &(/#() ='/ (#)&8G$%&')

&: $9# 6=$%&'=8 U=A&( -#8=$%&') 2&@@%))%&' /=$#/ Z=H I>* >CCI* 0#<#@A#( >R* >CCS ='/ Z=(<9 ID* >CCR

%' 6U-2 62- 2J 6&, DDB>D>MC> K6U-2 62- 2=)# 6&, DDMDBMD>DRPMCDL,

6& <&)$),

45 5-01-10,

D5-&1(@ E,.@ F .E .@ '6+*@ a5$6+5+@ '5,1* 5+1 J+5,(0KC5+)&5I*@ EE .@ <&'<G(,

Page 87: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 87/108

 

0('1+& 7#+"#'#+ $< (!'1&#(5 %&+,+,0*&'A 1-< 9+"< "(1#+"() )(,+& &%)(1#+"' /+..#''#+" _6HKIEB

7JTJFJH3a5 /%,! /#1:5 /%"1&() 09#)#00#"% !"#+" .#''#+" /+&0+&(1#+" +6 19% '%$%"19d7(:

(7$%"1#'15 %)7%& 9%/1+& $< -(:(&%'5 0('1+&' &%!,%" .+&()7%5 +'/(& )< ()+)+&5

=#))#(. !< 7+"(1+5 ;+%) =()%'5 %): '(/(:5 -#7%+" ,!9(15 #'(/9(& -(&'!)(5 %)#'%+

7+,)%5 0&+6#&#+ ,()(/:5 7($#7 &+7&#-+5 )+&%1+ .(:0(5 .&< &!6+ -('(0+5 .&<

%!6&+"#+ #,%'(1%5 .&'< 1%''#% ,()(/:5 .&< 8+'#.+ >(&(d("5 234 .&< %)%!1%&#+

)+,#1("(5 '&-%0*2&*+-<

7 % / # ' # + "

>(0!"("5 ! <A

4GA`#<$ $& $9# %')$='$ .#$%$%&' :&( ;(,)&*,5,&  G'/#( -G8# TR &: $9# -G8#) &: 2&G($ %) $9# -#)&8G$%&'h>i

 &:

.GA8%< (#).&'/#'$ 6=$%&'=8 U=A&( -#8=$%&') 2&@@%))%&' K$9# 6U-2L* (#'/#(#/ &' BI F='G=(H >CCT* %' 6U-2

2=)# 6&, VMD>BDMCI* #'$%$8#/ "=)$&( 0%&'%)%& V, JG)$(%= -0, 2#'$(=8 "9%8%..%'# Y'%&' Z%))%&' 2&(.&(=$%&' &:

4#+#'$9 0=H J/+#'$%)$)* (). 57 ,* ;9%<9 /%)@%))#/ $9# <=)# :&( %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8 :%8#/ AH $9# .#$%$%&'#( =?=%')$

.(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$) :&( 8=<\ &: `G(%)/%<$%&',"(%+=$# -#).&'/#'$ 2#'$(=8 "9%8%..%'# Y'%&' Z%))%&' 2&(.&(=$%&' &: $9# 4#+#'$9M0=H J/+#'$%)$)

K9#(#%'=:$#( (#:#((#/ $& =) $9# 40JL %) = (#8%?%&G) <&(.&(=$%&' /G8H &(?='%^#/ ='/ #_%)$%'? G'/#( "9%8%..%'#

8=; ='/ %) (#.(#)#'$#/ %' $9%) <=)# AH $9# &$9#( .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$)* &::%<#() &: $9# 40J, "#$%$%&'#(* &' $9#

&$9#( 9='/* ;=) = "=)$&( &: $9# 40J G'$%8 I> 5<$&A#(>CC>* ;9#' 9%) )#(+%<#) ;#(# $#(@%'=$#/,

Q9# (#<&(/) )9&; $9=$ .#$%$%&'#( "=)$&( 0%&'%)%& V, JG)$(%= ;&(\#/ ;%$9 $9# 40J :&( $;#'$H #%?9$ KBPL

H#=() :(&@ >CTI $& >CC>,hBi

  d# A#?=' 9%) ;&(\ ;%$9 $9# 40J &' >R FG8H >CTI =) = 8%$#(=$G(# #+='?#8%)$*

)#88%'? 8%$#(=$G(# &: $9# 40J &+#( $9# %)8='/ &: 6#?(&), X(&@ $9#' &'* .#$%$%&'#( ;&(\#/ 9%) ;=H G. $9#

8=//#( ='/ ?&$ .(&@&$#/ )#+#(=8 $%@#), 3' F='G=(H* >CTP* .#$%$%&'#( A#<=@# $9# J))%)$='$ "GA8%)9%'?

0%(#<$&( %' $9# 7#)$ V%)=H=' Z%))%&' &: $9# 40J, 3' FG8H* >CEB* 9# ;=) #8#+=$#/ $& $9# .&)%$%&' &: "=)$&( %'

$9# 7#)$ V%)=H=' Z%))%&' <&+#(%'? $9# %)8='/ &: "='=H* ='/ $9# .(&+%'<#) &: -&@A8&' ='/

NG%@=(=), "#$%$%&'#( 9#8/ $9# )=@# .&)%$%&' G. $& >CPP, X%'=88H* %' >CPC* .#$%$%&'#( ;=) .(&@&$#/ =)

0%)$(%<$ "=)$&( &: $9# 6#?(&) Z%))%&' &: $9# 40J ='/ ;=) =))%?'#/ =$ 4=?=H* O=8%'$=;=\ ='/ Q&A&)&* 6#?(&)

5<<%/#'$=8* ;%$9 $;#8+# K>BL <9G(<9#) G'/#( 9%) `G(%)/%<$%&', 3' F='G=(H* >CC>* .#$%$%&'#( ;=) $(='):#((#/ $&

O=<&8&/ 2%$H, d# 9#8/ $9# .&)%$%&' &: /%)$(%<$ .=)$&( G'$%8 9%) )#(+%<#) ;#(# $#(@%'=$#/ &' I> 5<$&A#( >CC>,

5' +=(%&G) &<<=)%&') :(&@ JG?G)$ G. $& 5<$&A#(* >CC>* .#$%$%&'#( (#<#%+#/ )#+#(=8

<&@@G'%<=$%&')hIi

  :(&@ Z(, 1G:(&'%& 3A#)=$#* $9# $(#=)G(#( &: $9# 6#?(&) Z%))%&' =)\%'? 9%@ $& =/@%$

=<<&G'$=A%8%$H ='/ (#).&')%A%8%$H :&( $9# <9G(<9 $%$9#) ='/ &::#(%'?) <&88#<$#/ AH 9%) ;%:#* Z(), Q9#8@=

JG)$(%=* %' 9%) /%)$(%<$ ;9%<9 =@&G'$#/ $& ">R*DEP,>D* ='/ $& (#@%$ $9# )=@# $& $9# 6#?(&) Z%))%&',

3' 9%) ;(%$$#' #_.8='=$%&' /=$#/ >> 5<$&A#( >CC>*hSi .#$%$%&'#( (#=)&'#/ &G$ $9=$ 9# )9&G8/ '&$ A#

@=/# =<<&G'$=A8# :&( $9# G'(#@%$$#/ <&88#<$%&') )%'<# %$ ;=) .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$) "=)$&( N%/#&' OG9=$ ='/

Z(, 1G:(&'%& 3A#)=$# ;9& =G$9&(%^#/ 9%) ;%:# $& <&88#<$ $9# $%$9#) ='/ &::#(%'?) )%'<# 9# ;=) +#(H )%<\ $& /&

$9# <&88#<$%'? =$ $9=$ $%@#,

Q9#(#=:$#(* &' >T 5<$&A#( >CC>* =$ =(&G'/ EaID =,@,* .#$%$%&'#( ;#'$ $& $9# &::%<# &: "=)$&( OG9=$* $9#

.(#)%/#'$ &: $9# 6#?(&) Z%))%&', 0G(%'? )=%/ <=88* .#$%$%&'#( $(%#/ $& .#()G=/# "=)$&( OG9=$ $& <&'+#'# $9#

1_#<G$%+# 2&@@%$$## :&( $9# .G(.&)# &: )#$$8%'? $9# /%).G$# A#$;##' 9%@ ='/ $9# .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$*

"=)$&( 0=+%/ -&/(%?&, Q9# /%).G$# A#$;##' "=)$&( -&/(%?& ='/ .#$%$%&'#( =(&)# :(&@ =' %'<%/#'$ %' ;9%<9

.#$%$%&'#( =))%)$#/ 9%) :(%#'/* 0=''H 0%=@=/=* $& <&88#<$ :(&@ "=)$&( -&/(%?& $9# G'.=%/ A=8='<# :&( $9#

(#.=%( &: $9# 8=$$#() @&$&( +#9%<8# ;9%<9 9# :=%8#/ $& .=H $& 0%=@=/=,

hRi

 0G# $& $9# =))%)$='<# &: .#$%$%&'#(%' <&88#<$%'? "=)$&( -&/(%?&) /#A$* $9# 8=$$#( 9=(A&(#/ %88M:##8%'?) =?=%')$ .#$%$%&'#(, 79#' '#;) (#=<9#/

.#$%$%&'#( $9=$ "=)$&( -&/(%?& ;=) =A&G$ $& :%8# = <&@.8=%'$ =?=%')$ 9%@ ;%$9 $9# 6#?(&) Z%))%&'* 9#

%@@#/%=$#8H .(&<##/#/ $& $9# &::%<# &: "=)$&( OG9=$ &' $9# /=$# =A&+#@#'$%&'#/ ='/ =)\#/ $9# 8=$$#( $&

<&'+#'# $9# 1_#<G$%+# 2&@@%$$##, "=)$&( OG9=$ /#'%#/ $9# (#]G#)$ &: .#$%$%&'#( )%'<# )&@# <&@@%$$##

Page 88: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 88/108

@#@A#() ;#(# &G$ &: $&;' ='/ $9#(# ;=) '& ]G&(G@, Q9#(#=:$#(* $9# $;& #_<9='?#/ 9#=$#/

=(?G@#'$), "#$%$%&'#( $9#' 8#:$ $9# &::%<# &: "=)$&( OG9=$, 79%8# &' 9%) ;=H &G$* .#$%$%&'#( &+#(9#=(/

"=)$&( OG9=$ )=H%'?* "=)$&( /=; %'%)&? '= %'= %H= K"=)$&( H&G =(# $=8\%'? $&G?9L,hTi

 3(\#/ AH )G<9 (#@=(\*

.#$%$%&'#( (#$G('#/ $& $9# &::%<# &: "=)$&( OG9=$* ='/ $(%#/ $& &+#($G(' $9# 8=$$#() $=A8#* $9&G?9

G')G<<#)):G88H* )%'<# %$ ;=) 9#=+H, Q9#(#=:$#(* .#$%$%&'#( A='?#/ $9# =$$=<9# <=)# &: "=)$&( OG9=$ &' $9#

$=A8#* )<=$$#(#/ $9# A&&\) %' 9%) &::%<#* ='/ $9(#; $9# .9&'#,hEi

 X&($G'=$#8H* .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$) "=)$&()

k&'%8& U#&.&8/& ='/ 28=G/%& Z&'$=& ;#(# =(&G'/ ='/ $9#H .=<%:%#/ A&$9 "=)$&( OG9=$ ='/ .#$%$%&'#(,

5' >E 5<$&A#( >CC>* .#$%$%&'#( (#<#%+#/ = 8#$$#( hPi  %'+%$%'? 9%@ ='/ 9%) ;%:# $& =$$#'/ $9# 1_#<G$%+#

2&@@%$$## @##$%'? =$ $9# 6#?(&) Z%))%&' 2&':#(#'<# -&&@ &' B> 5<$&A#( >CC>* =$ '%'# %' $9#

@&('%'?, Q& A# /%)<G))#/ %' $9# @##$%'? ;#(# $9# '&'M(#@%$$='<# &: <9G(<9 <&88#<$%&' ='/ $9# #+#'$) $9=$

$(=').%(#/ &' >T 5<$&A#( >CC>, J :=<$M:%'/%'? <&@@%$$## ;=) <(#=$#/ $& %'+#)$%?=$# .#$%$%&'#(, X&( $;& KBL

/=H)* :(&@ 5<$&A#( B> ='/ BB* $9# :=<$M:%'/%'? <&@@%$$## <&'/G<$#/ =' %'+#)$%?=$%&' &:

.#$%$%&'#(, 4#')%'? $9=$ $9# (#)G8$ &: $9# %'+#)$%?=$%&' @%?9$ A# &'#M)%/#/* .#$%$%&'#( %@@#/%=$#8H ;(&$#

"=)$&( -G#A#' Z&(=8/#* .(#)%/#'$ &: $9# 40J ='/ <9=%(@=' &: $9# :=<$M:%'/%'? <&@@%$$##* (#]G#)$%'? $9=$

<#($=%' @#@A#() &: $9# :=<$M:%'/%'? <&@@%$$## A# #_<8G/#/ %' $9# %'+#)$%?=$%&' ='/ (#)&8G$%&' &: $9#

<=)#,hCi

 5G$ &: $9# )%_ KTL @#@A#() (#]G#)$#/ $& %'9%A%$ $9#@)#8+#) :(&@ $9# %'+#)$%?=$%&' ='/ /#<%)%&'M

@=\%'?* &'8H $;& KBL ;#(# =<$G=88H #_<8G/#/* '=@#8Ha "=)$&( OG9=$ ='/ "=)$&( -&/(%?&, 4GA)#]G#'$8H* &'

BC 5<$&A#( >CC>* .#$%$%&'#( (#<#%+#/ = 8#$$#( &: /%)@%))=8 h>Di  <%$%'? @%)=..(&.(%=$%&' &: /#'&@%'=$%&'=8:G'/)* ;%88:G8 A(#=<9 &: $(G)$* )#(%&G) @%)<&'/G<$* ?(&)) ='/ 9=A%$G=8 '#?8#<$ &: /G$%#)* ='/ <&@@%))%&' &:

=' &::#')# =?=%')$ $9# .#()&' &: #@.8&H#() /G8H =G$9&(%^#/ (#.(#)#'$=$%+#* =) ?(&G'/) :&( $9# $#(@%'=$%&'

&: 9%) )#(+%<#),

-#=<$%'? =?=%')$ $9# =/+#()# /#<%)%&' &: $9# 40J* .#$%$%&'#( :%8#/ = <&@.8=%'$h>>i

  &' >S 6&+#@A#(

>CC>* A#:&(# $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( :&( %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8 =?=%')$ $9# 40J ='/ %$) &::%<#() ='/ .(=H#/ :&(

(#%')$=$#@#'$ ;%$9 A=<\;=?#) ='/ A#'#:%$)* @&(=8 ='/ #_#@.8=(H /=@=?#) ='/ &$9#( 8=A&( 8=; A#'#:%$),

5' >R X#A(G=(H >CCI* U=A&( J(A%$#( 2#)=( 0, 4%/#& (#'/#(#/ = /#<%)%&' %' :=+&( &: .#$%$%&'#(* $9#

/%).&)%$%+# .&($%&' &: ;9%<9 (#=/) $9G)a

7d1-1X5-1* "-1Z3414 2564301-10* (#).&'/#'$) 216Q-JU "d3U3""361 Y6356 Z344356 25-"5-JQ356

5X Qd1 41V16QdM0Jk J0V16Q34Q4 K2"YZ240JL ='/ %$) &::%<#()* (#).&'/#'$) 9#(#%'* =(# 9#(#AH &(/#(#/

$& %@@#/%=$#8H (#%')$=$# <&@.8=%'='$ "=)$&( 0%&'%)%& JG)$(%= $& 9%) :&(@#( .&)%$%&' =) "=)$&( &: O(?H,

Q=<G8%'?* "(&?(#)& ='/ O='=?&* O=<&8&/ 2%$H* ;%$9&G$ 8&)) &: )#'%&(%$H ='/ &$9#( (%?9$) ='/ A=<\;=?#) %'

$9# =@&G'$ &: 561 dY60-10 X3XQ116 Qd5Y4J60 13NdQ dY60-10 Qd3-Qk "1454 K">>R*PID,DDL ;%$9&G$

/#/G<$%&') ='/ ]G=8%:%<=$%&&'),

-#).&'/#'$ 2"YZ240J %) :G($9#( &(/#(#/ $& .=H <&@.8=%'='$ $9# :&88&;%'?a

J, >I$9 @&'$9 .=H M "B>*DTD,DD

O, J88&;='<# M " S*EED,PI

2, 4#(+%<# 3'<#'$%+#

U#=+# "=H M " I*ST>,PR

0, Z&(=8 0=@=?#) M "RD*DDD,DD

1, 1_#@.8=(H

0=@=?#) M "BR*DDD,DD

X, J$$&('#H) X## M "BB*D>B,BE

45 5-01-10,h>Bi

 

Page 89: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 89/108

Q9# 40J* $9(&G?9 %$) &::%<#()* =..#=8#/ $9# /#<%)%&' &: $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( $& $9# 6=$%&'=8 U=A&(

-#8=$%&') 2&@@%))%&'* X&G($9 0%+%)%&'* 2#AG 2%$H, 3' = /#<%)%&'* /=$#/ BT JG?G)$ >CCS* $9# 6U-2 +=<=$#/

$9# :%'/%'?) &: $9# U=A&( J(A%$#(, Q9# /#<(#$=8 .&($%&' &: $9# 6U-2 /#<%)%&' )$=$#)a

7d1-1X5-1* $9# 0#<%)%&' =..#=8#/ :(&@ %) 9#(#AH VJ2JQ10 ='/ = '#; &'# 16Q1-10 /%)@%))%'? $9%) <=)#

:&( ;='$ &: @#(%$,

45 5-01-10,h>Ii

 

"#$%$%&'#( :%8#/ = @&$%&' :&( (#<&')%/#(=$%&' &: $9# =A&+#M'=@#/ /#<%)%&', 5' >P FG8H >CCR* $9# 6U-2

%))G#/ = -#)&8G$%&' (#+#()%'? %$) &(%?%'=8 /#<%)%&', Q9# /%).&)%$%+# .&($%&' &: $9# (#)&8G$%&' (#=/)a

7d1-1X5-1* .(#@%)#) <&')%/#(#/* 5G( /#<%)%&' /=$#/ JG?G)$ BT* >CCS %) VJ2JQ10 ='/ $9# /#<%)%&' &: $9#

U=A&( J(A%$#( /=$#/ X#A(G=(H >R* >CCI %) -1364QJQ10,

45 5-01-10,h>Si

 

3' +%#; &: $9# (#+#()=8 &: $9# &(%?%'=8 /#<%)%&' &: $9# 6U-2* $9# 40J :%8#/ = @&$%&' :&( (#<&')%/#(=$%&'

&: $9# =A&+# (#)&8G$%&', 6&$=A8# %' $9# @&$%&' :&( (#<&')%/#(=$%&' :%8#/ AH .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$) %) $9#%(

%'+&<=$%&'* :&( $9# :%()$ $%@# &' =..#=8* $9=$ $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( 9=) '& `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( $9# <&@.8=%'$ :%8#/

AH .#$%$%&'#( /G# $& $9# <&')$%$G$%&'=8 .(&+%)%&' &' $9# )#.=(=$%&' &: <9G(<9 ='/ )$=$# )%'<# $9# <=)#

=88#?#/8H %'+&8+#/ ='/ #<<8#)%=)$%<=8 =::=%( $& ;9%<9 $9# 4$=$# <=''&$ %'$#(:#(#,

Q9# 6U-2* ;%$9&G$ (G8%'? &' $9# @#(%$) &: $9# <=)#* (#+#()#/ %$)#8: &'<# =?=%'* )G)$=%'#/ $9# =(?G@#'$

.&)#/ AH .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$) ='/* =<<&(/%'?8H* /%)@%))#/ $9# <&@.8=%'$ &: .#$%$%&'#(, Q9# /%).&)%$%+#

.&($%&' &: $9# 6U-2 (#)&8G$%&' /=$#/ BI F='G=(H >CCT* )GA`#<$ &: $9# .(#)#'$ .#$%$%&'* %) =) :&88&;)a

7d1-1X5-1* %' +%#; &: =88 $9# :&(#?&%'?* $9# %')$='$ @&$%&' :&( (#<&')%/#(=$%&' %) 9#(#AH

?(='$#/, J<<&(/%'?8H* $9%) <=)# %) 9#(#AH 034Z34410 :&( 8=<\ &: `G(%)/%<$%&',

Page 90: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 90/108

 

(&'%"#+ 8< )+/'#"* 

"#$%$%&'#(*

M +#()G) M

"#''(" /(& )%('% 09#)'<5 #"/< 234 )!#'

,("'+"5 

-#).&'/#'$),

-<&< "H< PO[[`k

"(#)#'$a

w2J-"35* E.*

ww6J2dY-J @ 

www

O-356 @ L;)&+I F%5&,$(,0*+*wwwwZ1605jJ* ='/

41-165* EE. 

"(&@G8?=$#/a

5<$&A#( BD* BD>D

^dddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddd^

7 % / # ' # + "

,&#+"5 !"A 

Q9(&G?9 = .#$%$%&' :&( (#+%#; &' ;(,)&*,5,&@h>i

 .#$%$%&'#( J()#'%& j, U&<)%' K?*;0&+L )##\) $9# (#+#()=8 &: $9#

0#<%)%&'hBi

 &: $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) KFLL /=$#/ JG?G)$ BP* BDDP*hIi

 %' L,0(+&* b. ?*;0&+ -. M&005+ F5, ?(50(

'%&70.@ N+;. 5+1 ?6&0 S5+0*+@ /&<\#$#/ =) 2JMN,-, 4" 6&, >DIEBD ='/ $9# -#)&8G$%&' /=$#/ 0#<#@A#( C*

BDDP*hSi

 /#'H%'? U&<)%') Z&$%&' :&( -#<&')%/#(=$%&', Q9# =))=%8#/ (G8%'? &: $9# 2J (#+#()#/ ='/ )#$ =)%/#

$9# 0#<%)%&'hRi &: $9# d&', U=A&( J(A%$#( Q9#8@= 2&'<#.<%&' K?5=*, L,=&)(, F*+;($;&*+L ;9%<9 /#'%#/

6%))=' U#=)# "9%8), 3'<,) KMF?'NL ='/ UG%) Q, O=')&') KS5+0*+L Z&$%&' $& 0%)@%)),

19% 6(/1!() ("1%/%7%"1'

5' F='G=(H >* >CCB* U&<)%' ;=) #8#<$#/ 1_#<G$%+# V%<# "(#)%/#'$ ='/ Q(#=)G(#( K3`'cP,(506,(, L &:

62U"3, J) 1V"eQ(#=)G(#(* 9%) /G$%#) ='/ (#).&')%A%8%$%#) %'<8G/#/a K>L $9# @='=?#@#'$ &: $9# :%'='<#) &: $9#

<&@.='H[ KBL <=((H%'? &G$ $9# /%(#<$%&') &: $9# "(#)%/#'$ ='/e&( $9# O&=(/ &: 0%(#<$&() (#?=(/%'? :%'='<%=8

@='=?#@#'$[ ='/ KIL $9# .(#.=(=$%&' &: :%'='<%=8 (#.&($) $& =/+%)# $9# &::%<#() ='/ /%(#<$&() &: $9#

:%'='<%=8 <&'/%$%&' &: 62U"3,hTi

 U&<)%' 9#8/ $9%) .&)%$%&' :&( >I H#=()* 9=+%'? A##' (#M#8#<$#/ #+#(H H#=( )%'<#

>CCB* G'$%8 F='G=(H B>* BDDR* ;9#' 9# ;=) '&@%'=$#/ ='/ #8#<$#/ 29=%(@=' &: 62U"3) O&=(/ &: 0%(#<$&(),hEi 

5' JG?G)$ R* BDDR* = 8%$$8# &+#( )#+#' KEL @&'$9) =:$#( 9%) #8#<$%&' =) 29=%(@=' &: $9# O&=(/* $9#62U"3 O&=(/ 9#8/ = ).#<%=8 @##$%'? =$ $9# Z='%8= "&8& 28GA, 5'# &: $9# %$#@) &: $9# =?#'/= ;=) $9#

#8#<$%&' &: = '#; )#$ &: &::%<#(), Y':&($G'=$#8H* U&<)%' ;=) '#%$9#( (#M#8#<$#/ 29=%(@=' '&( (#%')$=$#/ $&

9%) .(#+%&G) .&)%$%&' =) 1V"eQ(#=)G(#(,hPi

 

J??(%#+#/* &' FG'# >C* BDDE* U&<)%' :%8#/ = <&@.8=%'$ :&( %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8 ;%$9 .(=H#( :&( (#%')$=$#@#'$*

.=H@#'$ &: A=<\;=?#)* /=@=?#) ='/ =$$&('#H) :##) A#:&(# $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( =?=%')$ 62U"3 ='/ O=')&'*

;9& ;=) $9#' "(#)%/#'$ &: 62U"3,hCi

 

T>& $0(%.4-0'5 9'=,+')+,0* C'0/&&2,*;- =&<0'& +>& K)=0'

 9'=,+&'" 

5' FG8H >>* BDDE* %')$#=/ &: :%8%'? $9#%( .&)%$%&' .=.#(* 62U"3 ='/ O=')&' :%8#/ = Z&$%&' $& 0%)@%))*h>Di

&' $9#

?(&G'/ $9=$ $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( /%/ '&$ 9=+# `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( $9# <=)# )%'<# $9# %))G# &: U&<)%') (#@&+=8 =)

1V"eQ(#=)G(#( %'+&8+#) =' %'$(=M<&(.&(=$# /%).G$#,

Page 91: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 91/108

 

5' JG?G)$ >T* BDDE* U&<)%' )GA@%$$#/ 9%) &..&)%$%&' $& $9# @&$%&' $& /%)@%))* @=%'$=%'%'? 9%)

.&)%$%&' $9=$ 9# %) =' #@.8&H## &: 62U"3,

5' Z=(<9 >D* BDDP* U=A&( J(A%$#( 2&'<#.<%&' %))G#/ =' 5(/#( /#'H%'? $9# Z&$%&' $& 0%)@%))*

9&8/%'? $9=$ 9#( &::%<# =<]G%(#/ `G(%)/%<$%&' $& =(A%$(=$# ='/e&( /#<%/# $9# %')$='$ <&@.8=%'$ :%'/%'? #_$='$

%' $9# <=)# =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%.,h>>i

 

62U"3* &' FG'# I* BDDP* #8#+=$#/ $9# <=)# $& $9# 2J $9(&G?9 = "#$%$%&' :&( F(,)&*,5,& G'/#( -G8# TR

&: $9# -G8#) &: 2&G($,h>Bi

 62U"3 (=%)#/ $9# %))G# &' ;9#$9#( $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( <&@@%$$#/ ?(=+# =AG)# &:

/%)<(#$%&' AH /#'H%'? $9# Z&$%&' $& 0%)@%)) ='/ 9&8/%'? $9=$ 9#( &::%<# 9=/ `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( $9# /%).G$#,

T>& $9 F&/,-,0* G K0/-,* E)- ) /0'%0')+& 0<<,/&'^ +>& ,--.& 0<

>,- '&(01)4 )- 3HC_T'&)-.'&' ,- )* ,*+')G/0'%0')+& 2,-%.+&

.*2&' +>& JT$- `.',-2,/+,0*" 

5' JG?G)$ BP* BDDP*

h>Ii

 $9# 2J (#+#()#/ ='/ )#$ =)%/# $9# U=A&( J(A%$#() 5(/#( /#'H%'? $9# Z&$%&'$& 0%)@%)) ='/ (G8#/ $9=$ U&<)%' ;=) = <&(.&(=$# &::%<#(,

2%$%'? "0 CDBMJ* $9# 2J /#:%'#/ <&(.&(=$# &::%<#() =) $9&)# &::%<#() &: = <&(.&(=$%&' ;9& =(# ?%+#'

$9=$ <9=(=<$#( #%$9#( AH $9# 2&(.&(=$%&' 2&/# &( AH $9# <&(.&(=$%&') AHM8=;), 3' $9%) (#?=(/* $9# 2J 9#8/a

4<(G$%'%^%'? $9# (#<&(/)* 7# 9&8/ $9=$ .#$%$%&'#() )G<<#)):G88H /%)<9=(?#/ $9#%( *+60 &:

#)$=A8%)9%'? $9=$ .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ ;=) = <&(.&(=$# &::%<#( ;9& 9#8/ $9# .&)%$%&' &:

1_#<G$%+# V%<#M"(#)%/#'$eQ(#=)G(#( =) .(&+%/#/ %' $9# AHM8=;) &: .#$%$%&'#( <&(.&(=$%&' ='/

$9=$ 9# 9#8/ )G<9 .&)%$%&' AH +%($G# &: #8#<$%&' AH $9# O&=(/ &: 0%(#<$&(),

Q9=$ .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ %) = <&(.&(=$# &::%<#( <=''&$ A# /%).G$#/, Q9# .&)%$%&' &: 1_#<G$%+#V%<#M"(#)%/#'$eQ(#=)G(#( %) ).#<%:%<=88H %'<8G/#/ %' $9# (&)$#( &: &::%<#() .(&+%/#/ :&( AH $9#

KJ@#'/#/L OHMU=;) &: .#$%$%&'#( <&(.&(=$%&'* 9%) /G$%#) ='/ (#).&')%A%8%$%#)* =) ;#88 =)

<&@.#')=$%&' =) )G<9 &::%<#( =(# 8%\#;%)# )#$ :&($9 $9#(#%',h>Si

 

J($%<8# BPD &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#* $9# (#<#%.$ &: )=8=(%#) AH U&<)%'* 444 /#/G<$%&') &' $9=$ )=8=(H* ='/

$9# #8#@#'$ &: <&'$(&8 %' $9# .#(:&(@='<# &: ;&(\ /G$%#) %'/%<%= G)#/ AH $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( $& <&'<8G/# $9=$

U&<)%' ;=) = (#?G8=( #@.8&H## ;#(# 9#8/ %'=..8%<=A8# AH $9# 2J,h>Ri

 Q9# 2J '&$#/ $9# U=A&( J(A%$#() :=%8G(#

$& =//(#)) $9# :=<$ $9=$ $9# .&)%$%&' &: 1V"eQ(#=)G(#( %) ).#<%:%<=88H #'G@#(=$#/ =) =' &::%<# %' $9#

<&(.&(=$%&') AHM8=;),h>Ti 

XG($9#(* $9# 2J .&%'$#/ &G$ U&<)%') :=%8G(# $& )$=$# ='H <%(<G@)$='<# AH ;9%<9 62U"3 #'?=?#/ 9%)

)#(+%<#) =) = <&(.&(=$# &::%<#( $9=$ ;&G8/ @=\# 9%@ =' #@.8&H##, Q9# 2J :&G'/* %' $9%) (#?=(/* $9=$ U&<)%')

=))G@.$%&' ='/ (#$#'$%&' =) 1V"eQ(#=)G(#( ;=) A=)#/ &' 9%) #8#<$%&' ='/ )GA)#]G#'$ (#M#8#<$%&') :(&@

>CCB G'$%8 BDDR, XG($9#(* 9# .#(:&(@#/ &'8H $9&)# :G'<$%&') $9=$ ;#(# ).#<%:%<=88H )#$ :&($9 %' $9# OHMU=;)

&( (#]G%(#/ &: 9%@ AH $9# O&=(/ &: 0%(#<$&(),h>Ei

 

7%$9 (#).#<$ $& $9# )G%$ U&<)%' :%8#/ ;%$9 $9# U=A&( J(A%$#(* $9# 2J 9#8/ $9=$a

"(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$* %' A#8=$#/8H :%8%'? $9%) )G%$ A#:&(# $9# U=A&( J(A%$#(* ]G#)$%&'#/ $9#

8#?=8%$H &: 9%) /%)@%))=8 GKE J3 CFFC3DC5 BC I2JFCF EBC JFFKC HU VBCEBCI HI 3HE EBC ,H2I4 HU

7JICDEHIF B24 EBC 2KEBHIJEQ EH ICRHTC BJR UIHR EBC DHISHI2EC HUUJDC EH VBJDB BC V2F

CLCDEC4 SKIFK23E EH EBC ,Qd)2VF HU EBC SCEJEJH3CI DHISHI2EJH3, 3'/##/* 9=/ .(%+=$#

(#).&'/#'$ A##' =' &(/%'=(H #@.8&H##* =' #8#<$%&' <&'/G<$#/ AH $9# O&=(/ &: 0%(#<$&()

;&G8/ '&$ 9=+# A##' '#<#))=(H $& (#@&+# 9%@ =) 1_#<G$%+# V%<#M

Page 92: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 92/108

"(#)%/#'$eQ(#=)G(#(,d&;#+#(* %' =' &A+%&G) =$$#@.$ $& .(#<8G/# $9# =..8%<=$%&' &: )#$$8#/

 `G(%).(G/#'<# $9=$ <&(.&(=$# &::%<#() ;9&)# .&)%$%&' %) .(&+%/#/ %' $9# AHM8=;)* $9#%(

#8#<$%&'* (#@&+=8 &( /%)@%))=8 %) )GA`#<$ $& 4#<$%&' R &: ",0, 6&, CDBMJ K'&; -,J, 6&, PECCL*

.(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ ;&G8/ #+#' <8=%@ %' 9%) "&)%$%&' "=.#(* $9=$ )%'<# 9%) (#).&')%A%8%$%#)

;#(# =\%' $& $9=$ &: $9# <&@.='H) 1_#<G$%+# V%<#M"(#)%/#'$eQ(#=)G(#(* 9# ;=) 9%(#/ G'/#(

$9# .(#$#_$ $9=$ 9# ;=) A#%'? #8#<$#/ %'$& )=%/ .&)$,h>Pi

 [email protected]=)%) )G..8%#/,i

J) = <&')#]G#'<#* $9# 2J <&'<8G/#/ $9=$ U&<)%' /&#) '&$ 9=+# ='H (#<&G()# ;%$9 $9# U=A&( J(A%$#(&( $9# 6U-2 )%'<# $9# (#@&+=8 &: = <&(.&(=$# &::%<#(* ;9#$9#( #8#<$#/ &( =..&%'$#/* %) =' %'$(=M<&(.&(=$#

<&'$(&+#()H &+#( ;9%<9 $9# 6U-2 9=) '& `G(%)/%<$%&',h>Ci

 3')$#=/* =<<&(/%'? $& $9# 2J* U&<)%') <&@.8=%'$ :&(

%88#?=8 /%)@%))=8 )9&G8/ 9=+# A##' :%8#/ %' $9# -#?%&'=8 Q(%=8 2&G($ K/PFH* .G()G='$ $& -G8# T &: $9# 3'$#(%@

-G8#) &: "(&<#/G(# N&+#('%'? 3'$(=M2&(.&(=$# 2&'$(&+#()%#),hBDi

 

X%'=88H* $9# 2J =//(#))#/ U&<)%') %'+&<=$%&' &: J($%<8# S &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#, 0%)@%))%'? $9#

=..8%<=$%&' &: $9# .(&+%)%&'* $9# 2J <%$#/ 0#=' 2#)=( V%88='G#+= &: $9# J$#'#& 4<9&&8 &: U=;* =) :&88&;)a

_ _ _ $9# 3H3dDHTCI2MC HU DHISHI2EC HUUJDCIF UIHR EBC FCDKIJEQ HU EC3KIC DL2KFC K34CI EBC

/H3FEJEKEJH3 JF 3HV VCLLdCFE2GLJFBC4 SIJ3DJSLC AH 'G@#(&G) /#<%)%&') G.9&8/%'? )G<9/&<$(%'# G'/#( $9# =#?%) &: $9# >CPE 2&')$%$G$%&' %' $9# :=<# &: <&'$#@.&(=(H /#<%)%&') &:

$9# )=@# 4G.(#@# 2&G($ 8%\#;%)# <&':%(@%'? $9=$ )#<G(%$H &: $#'G(# <&+#() =88 #@.8&H##) &(

;&(\#() %'<8G/%'? @='=?#(%=8 #@.8&H##),hB>i

 

19% 0%1#1#+"%&' (&-!.%"1'

X=%8%'? $& &A$=%' = (#<&')%/#(=$%&' &: $9# 2J) /#<%)%&'* U&<)%' :%8#/ $9# .(#)#'$ .#$%$%&' &' F='G=(H

BP* BDDC* (=%)%'? $9# :&88&;%'? .(&<#/G(=8 ='/ )GA)$='$%+# %))G#)aK>L 79#$9#( $9# 2J 9=) &(%?%'=8 `G(%)/%<$%&' $& (#+%#; /#<%)%&' &: $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( G'/#( -G8#

TRs

KBL 79#$9#( 9# %) = (#?G8=( #@.8&H## &: 62U"3 G'/#( $9# /#:%'%$%&' &: J($%<8# BPD &: $9# U=A&(

2&/#s ='/

KIL 79#$9#( U&<)%') .&)%$%&' =) 1_#<G$%+# V%<#M"(#)%/#'$eQ(#=)G(#( @=\#) 9%@ = <&(.&(=$#

&::%<#( $9#(#AH #_<8G/%'? 9%@ :(&@ $9# <&+#(=?# &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#s

',*;(16,577<@ U&<)%' #))#'$%=88H )GA@%$) $9=$ 62U"3 ;(&'?:G88H :%8#/ = .#$%$%&' :&( ;(,)&*,5,& A#:&(#

$9# 2J* =) $9# 8=$$#() (#@#/H %) $& .(&<##/ ;%$9 $9# =(A%$(=$%&'* ='/ $& =..#=8 $& $9# 6U-2 =:$#( $9# U=A&(

J(A%$#( )9=88 9=+# (G8#/ &' $9# @#(%$) &: $9# <=)#, U&<)%' <%$#)* %' $9%) (#?=(/* -G8# V* 4#<$%&' T &: $9#

-#+%)#/ -G8#) &: $9# 6=$%&'=8 U=A&( -#8=$%&') 2&@@%))%&' KM?/F /67(0L* ;9%<9 .(&+%/#) $9=$ = /#'%=8 &: =

@&$%&' $& /%)@%)) AH $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( %) '&$ )GA`#<$ $& =' =..#=8, U&<)%' =8)& =(?G#) $9=$ #+#' %: $9# U=A&(

J(A%$#( <&@@%$$#/ ?(=+# =AG)# &: /%)<(#$%&' %' /#'H%'? $9# 62U"3 @&$%&'* = ).#<%=8 <%+%8 =<$%&'

:&(;(,)&*,5,& * :%8#/ ;%$9 $9# 2J ;=) '&$ $9# =..(&.(%=$# (#@#/H* )%'<# $9%) ;=) = A(#=<9 &: $9# /&<$(%'# &:

#_9=G)$%&' &: =/@%'%)$(=$%+# (#@#/%#),

C6=0)5+)&-(7< * U&<)%' )GA@%$) $9=$ 9# %) = (#?G8=( #@.8&H## &: 62U"3 )%'<# M =) 9# =(?G#/ A#:&(# $9#

U=A&( J(A%$#( ='/ $9# 2J M 9%) (#8=$%&')9%. ;%$9 $9# <&@.='H @##$) $9# :&G(M:&8/ $#)$,

B&,0)@ U&<)%' <&'$#'/) $9=$ 62U"3 9=/ $9# .&;#( $& #'?=?# 9%) )#(+%<#) =) 1V"eQ(#=)G(#(, C(;*+1@9#

(#<#%+#/ (#?G8=( ;=?#) :(&@ 62U"3* :(&@ ;9%<9 9%) 444 ='/ "9%89#=8$9 <&'$(%AG$%&')* =) ;#88 =) 9%)

;%$99&8/%'? $=_#) ;#(# /#/G<$#/, P%&,1@ 62U"3 9=/ $9# .&;#( $& $#(@%'=$# 9%)

#@.8&H@#'$,hBBi

 ?50)7<@6%))=' 9=/ <&'$(&8 &+#( $9# @=''#( &: $9# .#(:&(@='<# &: 9%) :G'<$%&') =)

1V"eQ(#=)G(#(* =) )9&;' AH $9# >I H#=() &: :=%$9:G8 #_#<G$%&' &: 9%) `&A* ;9%<9 9# <=((%#/ &G$ %' =<<&(/='<#

Page 93: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 93/108

;%$9 $9# )$='/=(/) ='/ #_.#<$=$%&') )#$ AH 62U"3,hBIi

 XG($9#(* U&<)%' @=%'$=%') $9=$ #+#' =:$#( 9%) #8#<$%&'

=) 29=%(@='* 9# #))#'$%=88H .#(:&(@#/ $9# :G'<$%&') &: 1V"eQ(#=)G(#( 9='/8%'? $9# :%'='<%=8 ='/

=/@%'%)$(=$%+# &.#(=$%&') &: $9# 2&(.&(=$%&' $9G) @=\%'? 9%@ = (#?G8=( #@.8&H##,hBSi

 

Y'/#( $9#)# <8=%@#/ :=<$)* U&<)%' <&'<8G/#) $9=$ $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( ='/ $9# 6U-2 '&$ $9# -Q2 K=)

62U"3 .&)%$)L 9=) `G(%)/%<$%&' $& /#<%/# $9# <&'$(&+#()H, "=(#'$9#$%<=88H* U&<)%' <8=(%:%#) $9=$ 9# /&#) '&$

/%).G$# $9# +=8%/%$H &: 9%) #8#<$%&' =) 29=%(@=' &: $9# O&=(/ &' F='G=(H >* BDDR, 3')$#=/* 9# $9#&(%^#) $9=$

9# '#+#( 8&)$ 9%) .&)%$%&' =) 1V"eQ(#=)G(#( 9=+%'? <&'$%'G&G)8H .#(:&(@#/ $9# :G'<$%&') =..G($#'='$$9#(#$&,

hBRi  Q9G)* 9# ]G#)$%&') 9%) G'<#(#@&'%&G) (#@&+=8 =) 1V"eQ(#=)G(#( /G(%'? $9# JG?G)$ R* BDDR

).#<%=8 O&=(/ @##$%'?,

19% &%'0+"7%"1' (&-!.%"1' 

3$ %$) J.(%8 >E* BDDC 2&@@#'$*hBTi

 6%))=' .(=H) :&( $9# /#'%=8 &: $9# .#$%$%&' :&( 8=<\ &: @#(%$, 6%))=' )GA@%$)

$9=$ $9# 2J <&((#<$8H (G8#/ $9=$ $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( /&#) '&$ 9=+# `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( U&<)%') <&@.8=%'$ :&(

%88#?=8 /%)@%))=8, 3' )G..&($* 6%))=' @=%'$=%') $9=$ U&<)%' %) = <&(.&(=$# &::%<#( ='/ '&$ =' #@.8&H##, 3'

=//(#))%'? $9# .(&<#/G(=8 /#:#<$ U&<)%' (=%)#/* 6%))=' A(G)9#) $9# %))G# =)%/#* )$=$%'? $9=$ K>L $9%) %))G#

;=) A#8=$#/8H (=%)#/ %' $9# Z&$%&' :&( -#<&')%/#(=$%&'* ='/ $9=$ KBL %' ='H <=)#* -G8# V3* 4#<$%&' BK>L &: $9#6U-2 /&#) '&$ =..8H )%'<# &'8H 5$$(575=7( /#<%)%&')* (#)&8G$%&') ='/ &(/#() =(# <&+#(#/ G'/#( $9# (G8#,

19% /+!&1' &!)#"-

=C ICFHLTC EH 4C3Q EBC SCEJEJH3 UHI L2DX HU RCIJE< 

J$ $9# &G$)#$* ;# )$(#)) $9=$ $9#(# =(# $;& KBL %@.&($='$ <&')%/#(=$%&') %' $9# :%'=8 /#$#(@%'=$%&'

&: $9%) <=)#, 5' $9# &'# 9='/* U&<)%' (=%)#) = .(&<#/G(=8 %))G# $9=$* %: .(&+#' <&((#<$* ;%88 (#]G%(# $9# 2&G($

$& /%)@%)) $9# %')$='$ .#$%$%&' :&( G)%'? =' %@.(&.#( (#@#/H, 5' $9# &$9#( 9='/* $9#(# %) $9# )GA)$='$%+#

%))G# $9=$ ;%88 A# /%)(#?=(/#/ %: = )$(%<$ %@.8#@#'$=$%&' &: $9# (G8#) &: .(&<#/G(# %) G.9#8/,

"(#:=$&(%8H* ;# =?(## ;%$9 U&<)%') )GA@%))%&' $9=$ $9# 62U"3 %'<&((#<$8H #8#+=$#/ $9# U=A&( J(A%$#() /#'%=8&: $9# Z&$%&' $& 0%)@%)) $& $9# 2J, U&<)%' %) <&((#<$ %' .&)%$%'? $9=$ $9# /#'%=8 &: = @&$%&' $& /%)@%)) %)

G'=..#=8=A8#, J) = ?#'#(=8 (G8#* =' =??(%#+#/ .=($H) .(&.#( (#<&G()# $& $9# /#'%=8 %) $& :%8# 9%) .&)%$%&'

.=.#(* %'$#(.&)# $9# ?(&G'/) (#8%#/ G.&' %' $9# @&$%&' $& /%)@%)) A#:&(# $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#(* ='/ =<$%+#8H

.=($%<%.=$# %' $9# .(&<##/%'?), Q9#(#=:$#(* $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#() /#<%)%&' <=' A# =..#=8#/ $& $9# 6U-2* '&$ $&

$9# 2J,

J) = (G8#* ;# )$(%<$8H =/9#(# $& $9# (G8#) &: .(&<#/G(# ='/ /& #+#(H$9%'? ;# <='* $& $9# .&%'$ &:

.#'=8%^%'? +%&8=$&()* $& #'<&G(=?# (#).#<$ :&( $9#)# (G8#), 7# $=\# #_<#.$%&' $& $9%) ?#'#(=8 (G8#* 9&;#+#(*

;9#' = )$(%<$ %@.8#@#'$=$%&' &: $9#)# (G8#) ;&G8/ <=G)# )GA)$='$%=8 %'`G)$%<# $& $9# .=($%#),

7# )## %$ =..(&.(%=$# $& =..8H $9# #_<#.$%&' $& $9%) <=)# :&( $9# (#=)&') /%)<G))#/ A#8&;[ 9#'<#*

;# =(# <&@.#88#/ $& ?& A#H&'/ .(&<#/G(# ='/ (G8# &' $9# @#(%$) &: $9# <=)#, 3' $9# <&'$#_$ &: $9%) <=)#*

;# )## )G::%<%#'$ `G)$%:%<=$%&' $& (G8# &' $9# #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. %))G# (=%)#/ AH 62U"3* #+#'

$9&G?9 $9# U=A&( J(A%$#() %'$#(8&<G$&(H &(/#( ;=) &+;*,,(;)7< A(&G?9$ $& $9# 2J G'/#( -G8# TR,

T>& PKJ$ J.4&- )'& /4&)'# +>& 2&*,)4 =5 +>& 4)=0' )'=,+&' 0<

+>& (0+,0* +0 2,-(,-- ,- *0+ )%%&)4)=4& =&/).-& +>& 2&*,)4 ,-

(&'&45 )* ,*+&'40/.+0'5 0'2&'" 

3' T(),* D,6I -. T(),* D,6I 34$7*<((0@hBEi ;# /#:%'%$%+#8H )$=$#/ $9=$ $9# /#'%=8 &: = @&$%&' $&

/%)@%)) AH = 8=A&( =(A%$#( %) '&$ %@@#/%=$#8H =..#=8=A8#,hBPi

 

Page 94: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 94/108

Page 95: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 95/108

UIHR ICDCJSE HU FKDB 4CDJFJH3F5 2V2I4F5 HI HI4CIF, 4G<9 =..#=8 @=H A# #'$#($=%'#/ &'8H &'

='H &: $9# :&88&;%'? ?(&G'/)a

K=L 3: $9#(# %) SIJR2 U2DJC CTJ4C3DC HU 2GKFC HU 4JFDICEJH3 &' $9# .=($ &: $9#

U=A&( J(A%$#([ _ _ _ [email protected]=)%) )G..8%#/,i

"G()G='$ $& $9%) J($%<8#* ;# 9#8/ %' T(),* D,6I K<%$%'? L&, C(,-&;(0 F**$(,5)&-(@ () 57. -. F*6,) *9

 L$$(570hIRiL $9=$ $9# 6U-2 %) <8&$9#/ ;%$9 )G::%<%#'$ =G$9&(%$H $& <&((#<$ ='H <8=%@#/ #((&'#&G) =))G@.$%&'

&: `G(%)/%<$%&' AH 8=A&( =(A%$#()a

3' L&, C(,-&;(0 F**$(,5)&-(@ () 57. -. P%( F*6,) *9 L$$(570@ () 57 ,* = <=)# ;9#(# $9# `G(%)/%<$%&'

&: $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#( ;=) .G$ %' %))G# ='/ ;=) =))=%8#/ $9(&G?9 = .#$%$%&'

:&( ;(,)&*,5,&@ .(&9%A%$%&' ='/ =''G8@#'$ &: `G/?@#'$ A#:&(# = (#?%&'=8 $(%=8 <&G($* $9%)

2&G($ 9=/ $9# &..&($G'%$H $& #_.&G'/ &' $9# '=$G(# &: =..#=8 =) #@A&/%#/ %' J($%<8# BBI &:

$9# U=A&( 2&/#* $9G)a

_ _ _ J8)&* ;9%8# $9# $%$8# &: $9# J($%<8# BBI )##@) $& .(&+%/# &'8H :&(

$9# (#@#/H &: =..#=8 =) $9=$ $#(@ %) G'/#()$&&/ %' .(&<#/G(=8 8=; ='/ =)

/%)$%'?G%)9#/ :(&@ $9# &::%<# &: <#($%&(=(%* '&'#$9#8#))* = <8&)#( (#=/%'?

$9#(#&: (#+#=8) $9=$ %$ %) '&$ =) 8%@%$#/ =) G'/#()$&&/ AH $9# .#$%$%&'#() _ _ _,

(GKFC HU 4JFDICEJH3 JF 24RJEEC4LQ VJEBJ3 EBC 2RGJE HU DCIEJHI2IJ 234

JEF MI23E HU ICTJCV EBCICHU EH EBC ")&/ %'/%<=$#) $9# 8=;@=\#() %'$#'$%&' $&

A(&=/#' $9# @#='%'? &: =..#=8 =) $9=$ $#(@ %) G)#/ %' $9# 2&/#, X&( $9%)

(#=)&'* SCEJEJH3CIF D233HE 2IMKC 3HV EB2E EBC ")&/ JF 4CTHJ4 HU 23Q

DHIICDEJTC SHVCI EH ICDEJUQ 2 FKSSHFC4 CIIH3CHKF 2FFKRSEJH3 HU ]KIJF4JDEJH3

GQ EBC )2GHI (IGJECI _ _ _, h L&, C(,-&;(0 F**$(,5)&-(@ () 57. -. P%( F*6,) *9

 L$$(570@ () 57 , N,-, 6&, >>PTCI* BI FG8H >CCP* BCI 42-J >D>i

4%'<# $9# 8#?%)8=$G(# 9=/ <8&$9#/ $9# 6U-2 ;%$9 $9# =..#88=$# =G$9&(%$H $& <&((#<$ =

<8=%@#/ #((&'#&G) =))G@.$%&' &: `G(%)/%<$%&' &' $9# .=($ &: $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#( = <=)# &: ?(=+#

=AG)# &: /%)<(#$%&' M $9# ICRC4Q 2T2JLC4 HU GQ SCEJEJH3CI J3 EBJF D2FC JF S2EC3ELQ CIIH3CHKF

2F ICDHKIFC J3 EBJF D2FC JF LH4MC4* G'/#( $9# 8=;* VJEB EBC ")&/,

3' T(),* D,6I@ =) %' $9# .(#)#'$ <=)#* $9# /#:#<$ %@.G$#/ $9(&G?9 $9# 62U"3 Z&$%&' $& 0%)@%)) %) $9# 8=A&(

=(A%$#() 8=<\ &: `G(%)/%<$%&' )%'<# U&<)%' %) =88#?#/ $& A# = <&(.&(=$# &::%<#(* '&$ =' #@.8&H##, "=(=88#8%)@)

A#$;##' $9# $;& <=)#) %) G'/#'%=A8#* =) $9#H =(# )%@%8=( &' $9# :&88&;%'? .&%'$)a K>L %' T(),* D,6I@ =) %'$9%) <=)#* $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( %))G#/ =' 5(/#( /#'H%'? $9# Z&$%&' $& 0%)@%)) AH &'# &: $9# .=($%#)[ KBL $9#

A=)%) &: $9# Z&$%&' $& 0%)@%)) %) =8)& $9# =88#?#/ 8=<\ &: `G(%)/%<$%&' AH $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( $& )#$$8# $9#

/%).G$#[ ='/ KIL /%))=$%):%#/ ;%$9 $9# 5(/#( &: $9# U=A&( J(A%$#(* $9# =??(%#+#/ .=($H 8%\#;%)# #8#+=$#/ $9#

<=)# $& $9# 2J -&5 -G8# TR,

Q9# )%@%8=(%$%#) #'/ $9#(#* 9&;#+#(, Y'8%\# %' $9# .(#)#'$ <=)#* $9# 2J /#'%#/ $9# .#$%$%&'

:&(;(,)&*,5,&  ='/ $9# )GA)#]G#'$ Z&$%&' :&( -#<&')%/#(=$%&' %' T(),* D,6I[ $9# 2J <&((#<$8H :&G'/ $9=$

$9# .(&.#( =..#88=$# @#<9='%)@ ;=) =' =..#=8 $& $9# 6U-2 ='/ '&$ = .#$%$%&' :&( ;(,)&*,5,&  G'/#( -G8#

TR, 3' $9# .(#)#'$ <=)#* $9# 2J $&&\ = /%::#(#'$ .&)%$%&' /#).%$# &G( <8#=( (G8%'? %' T(),* D,6I* ='/

=88&;#/* '&$ &'8H $9# G)# &: -G8# TR* AG$ =8)& (G8#/ &' $9# @#(%$),

X(&@ $9%) .#().#<$%+#* $9# 2J <8#=(8H #((#/ %' $9# =..8%<=$%&' &: $9# .(&<#/G(=8 (G8#) AH /%)(#?=(/%'?

$9# (#8#+='$ .(&+%)%&') &: $9# 6U-2 -G8#)* =) ;#88 =) $9# (#]G%(#@#'$) :&( = .#$%$%&' :&( <#($%&(=(% G'/#(

Page 96: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 96/108

$9# -G8#) &: 2&G($, Q& (#%$#(=$#* $9# .(&.#( =<$%&' &: =' =??(%#+#/ .=($H :=<#/ ;%$9 $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#() /#'%=8

&: 9%) @&$%&' $& /%)@%)) %) $& )GA@%$ 9%) .&)%$%&' .=.#( ='/ (=%)# $9#(#%' $9# )G..&)#/ 8=<\ &:

 `G(%)/%<$%&', Q9# =??(%#+#/ .=($H <=''&$ %@@#/%=$#8H =..#=8 $9# /#'%=8 )%'<# %$ %) =' %'$#(8&<G$&(H &(/#([

$9# =..(&.(%=$# (#@#/%=8 (#<&G()# %) $9# .(&<#/G(# &G$8%'#/ %' J($%<8# BBI &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#* '&$ =

.#$%$%&' :&( ;(,)&*,5,& G'/#( -G8# TR,

 9 -+',/+ ,(%4&(&*+)+,0* 0< +>& PKJ$ J.4&- )*2 +>& J.4&- 0<

$0.'+ E0.42 /).-& ,*`.-+,/& +0 +>& %)'+,&- =&/).-& +>& K)=0' 9'=,+&' /4&)'45 >)- *0 `.',-2,/+,0* 01&' +>& %'&-&*+ ,*+')G

/0'%0')+& 2,-%.+&" 

5G( (G8%'? %' T(A&775+* -. ?6;&77*hITi

 )$='/) :&( $9# .(&.&)%$%&' $9=$ ;# )9&G8/ )$(%<$8H =..8H $9# (G8#)

&: .(&<#/G(#, 7# )=%/a

Q%@# ='/ =?=%'* ;# 9=+# (G8#/ $9=$ .(&<#/G(=8 (G8#) /& '&$ #_%)$ :&( $9# <&'+#'%#'<# &: $9#

8%$%?='$), -G8#) &: "(&<#/G(# #_%)$ :&( = .G(.&)#* ='/ $& /%)(#?=(/ )G<9 (G8#) %' $9# ?G%)# &:

8%A#(=8 <&')$(G<$%&' ;&G8/ A# $& /#:#=$ )G<9 .G(.&)#, 0IHDC4KI2L IKLCF VCIC CFE2GLJFBC4SIJR2IJLQ EH SIHTJ4C HI4CI EH 234 C3B23DC EBC CUUJDJC3DQ HU HKI ]K4JDJ2L FQFECR, [email protected]=)%)

)G..8%#/,i

J' #_<#.$%&' $& $9%) (G8# %) &G( (G8%'? %' ?585,* -. F*6,) *9 L$$(570hIEi

 ;9#(# ;# 9#8/ $9=$ $9# )$(%<$

#':&(<#@#'$ &: $9# (G8#) &: .(&<#/G(# @=H A# (#8=_#/ %' (Q;($)&*+577< 4(,&)*,&*60 ;50(0a

_ _ _ 0IHDC4KI2L IKLCF 2IC 3HE EH GC GCLJEELC4 HI 4JFRJFFC4 FJRSLQ GCD2KFC EBCJI 3H3d

HGFCIT23DC R2Q B2TC ICFKLEC4 J3 SIC]K4JDC EH 2 S2IEQjF FKGFE23EJTC IJMBEF< U%\# =88

(G8#)* EBCQ 2IC ICWKJIC4 EH GC UHLLHVC4 &U/&%+ 0*45 <0' +>& (0-+ %&'-.)-,1& 0< '&)-0*-E>&* +>&5 ()5 =& '&4)U&2 +0 '&4,&1& ) 4,+,;)*+ 0< )* ,*`.-+,/& *0+ /0((&*-.')+& E,+> +>&

2&;'&& 0< >,- +>0.;>+4&--*&-- ,* *0+ /0(%45,*; E,+> +>& %'0/&2.'& %'&-/',=&2 , Q9# 2&G($

(#%$#(=$#) $9=$ (G8#) &: .(&<#/G(#* #).#<%=88H $9&)# .(#)<(%A%'? $9# $%@# ;%$9%' ;9%<9 <#($=%'

=<$) @G)$ A# /&'#* g9=+# &:$ A##' 9#8/ =) =A)&8G$#8H %'/%).#')=A8# $& $9# .(#+#'$%&' &:

'##/8#)) /#8=H) ='/ $& $9# &(/#(8H ='/ ).##/H /%)<9=(?# &: AG)%'#)), _ _ _ Q9# (#=)&' :&(

(G8#) &: $9%) '=$G(# %) A#<=G)# $9# /%).=$<9 &: AG)%'#)) AH <&G($) ;&G8/ A# %@.&))%A8#* ='/

%'$&8#(=A8# /#8=H) ;&G8/ (#)G8$* ;%$9&G$ (G8#) ?&+#('%'? .(=<$%<# _ _ _, 4G<9 (G8#) =(# =

'#<#))=(H %'<%/#'$ $& $9# .(&.#(* #::%<%#'$ ='/ &(/#(8H /%)<9=(?# &: `G/%<%=8

:G'<$%&'),g 3'/##/* %' '& G'<#($=%' $#(@)* $9# 2&G($ 9#8/ $9=$ $9# )=%/ (G8#) R2Q GC ICL2^C4

H3LQ J3 C^DCSEJH32LLQ RCIJEHIJHKF D2FCF< [email protected]=)%) )G..8%#/,i

79#$9#( = <=)# %'+&8+#) =' (Q;($)&*+577< 4(,&)*,&*60 <%(<G@)$='<# <=' A# $#)$#/ G'/#( $9#

?G%/#8%'#) ;# #)$=A8%)9#/ %' C5+;%(8 -. F*6,) *9 L$$(570*hIPi

 =) :&88&;)a

J)%/# :(&@ R2EECIF HU LJUC5 LJGCIEQ5 BH3HI HI SIHSCIEQ ;9%<9 ;&G8/ ;=((='$ $9# )G).#')%&'

&: $9# -G8#) &: $9# @&)$ @='/=$&(H <9=(=<$#( ='/ =' #_=@%'=$%&' ='/ (#+%#; AH $9#

=..#88=$# <&G($ &: $9# 8&;#( <&G($) :%'/%'?) &: :=<$* $9# &$9#( #8#@#'$) $9=$ )9&G8/ A#

<&')%/#(#/ =(# $9# :&88&;%'?a K=L EBC C^JFEC3DC HU FSCDJ2L HI DHRSCLLJ3M DJIDKRFE23DCF* KAL

$9# RCIJEF HU EBC D2FC* K<L = D2KFC 3HE C3EJICLQ 2EEIJGKE2GLC EH EBC U2KLE HI 3CMLJMC3DC HU EBC

S2IEQ U2THIC4 GQ EBC FKFSC3FJH3 HU EBC IKLCF* K/L = L2DX HU 23Q FBHVJ3M EB2E EBC ICTJCV

FHKMBE JF RCICLQ UIJTHLHKF 234 4JL2EHIH* ='/ K#L $9# HEBCI S2IEQ VJLL 3HE GC K3]KFELQSIC]K4JDC4 EBCICGQ, [email protected]=)%) )G..8%#/,i

Y'/#( $9#)# )$='/=(/)* ;# 9&8/ $9=$ #_<#.$%&'=8 <%(<G@)$='<#) #_%)$ %' $9# .(#)#'$ <=)# $& @#(%$

$9# (#8=_=$%&' &: $9# =..8%<=A8# (G8#) &: .(&<#/G(#,

Page 97: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 97/108

 

F.& +0 &U,-+,*; &U/&%+,0*)4 /,'/.(-+)*/&-A +>& '.4,*; 0* +>&

(&',+- +>)+ K0/-,* ,- )* 0<<,/&' )*2 *0+ )* &(%405&& 0< P,--)*

(.-+ +)@& %'&/&2&*/& 01&' %'0/&2.')4 /0*-,2&')+,0*-" 

7# =((%+#/ =$ $9# <&'<8G)%&' $9=$ ;# )9&G8/ ?& A#H&'/ $9# .(&<#/G(=8 (G8#) ='/ %@@#/%=$#8H $=\# = 8&&\

=$ $9# %'$(%')%< @#(%$) &: $9# <=)# A=)#/ &' )#+#(=8 <&')%/#(=$%&'),

B&,0)@ $9# .=($%#) 9=+# )G::%<%#'$8H +#'$%8=$#/ $9#%( .&)%$%&') &' $9# /%).G$#/ #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H##

(#8=$%&')9%. ='/ 9=+#* %' :=<$* )GA@%$$#/ $9# @=$$#( :&( $9# 2J) <&')%/#(=$%&',

C(;*+1 * $9# 2J <&((#<$8H (G8#/ $9=$ '& #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. #_%)$) A#$;##' U&<)%' ='/

6%))=',

U&<)%' ;=) G'/#'%=A8H 29=%(@=' ='/ "(#)%/#'$* ='/ ;=) #8#<$#/ $& $9#)# .&)%$%&') AH $9# 6%))=' A&=(/

.G()G='$ $& %$) OHM8=;),hICi

  J) )G<9* 9# ;=) = <&(.&(=$# &::%<#(* '&$ =' #@.8&H##, Q9# 2J (#=<9#/ $9%)

<&'<8G)%&' AH (#8H%'? &' $9# )GA@%$$#/ :=<$) ='/ &' "(#)%/#'$%=8 0#<(## CDBMJ* ;9%<9 /#:%'#) <&(.&(=$#

&::%<#() =) $9&)# &::%<#() &: = <&(.&(=$%&' ;9& =(# ?%+#' $9=$ <9=(=<$#( #%$9#( AH $9# 2&(.&(=$%&' 2&/# &(

AH $9# <&(.&(=$%&') AHM8=;), U%\#;%)#* 4#<$%&' BR &: O=$=) "=@A=')= O8?, TC* &( $9# 2&(.&(=$%&' 2&/# &:

$9# "9%8%..%'#) KF*,$*,5)&*+ F*1(L .(&+%/#) $9=$ <&(.&(=$# &::%<#() =(# $9# SICFJ4C3E*

)#<(#$=(H*EIC2FKICI ='/ )G<9 HEBCI HUUJDCIF 2F R2Q GC SIHTJ4C4 UHI J3 EBC GQdL2VF,

P%&,1. 1+#' =) 1_#<G$%+# V%<#M"(#)%/#'$eQ(#=)G(#(* U&<)%' =8(#=/H =<$#/ =) = <&(.&(=$# &::%<#( A#<=G)# $9#

.&)%$%&' &: 1_#<G$%+# V%<#M"(#)%/#'$eQ(#=)G(#( %) .(&+%/#/ :&( %' 6%))=') OHMU=;), J($%<8# 3V* 4#<$%&' S &:

$9#)# OHMU=;) ).#<%:%<=88H .(&+%/#) :&( $9%) .&)%$%&'* =) :&88&;)a

J-Q32U1 3V

5::%<#()

4#<$%&' >, 18#<$%&' ='/ J..&%'$@#'$ Q9# O&=(/ &: 0%(#<$&() =$ $9#%( :%()$ @##$%'?* =''G=88H

$9#(#=:$#(* )9=88 #8#<$ =) &::%<#() &: $9# 2&(.&(=$%&' = 29=%(@=' &: $9# O&=(/* = "(#)%/#'$* 23

%^CDKEJTC $JDCd0ICFJ4C3EY1IC2FKICI* = V%<#M"(#)%/#'$eN#'#(=8 Z='=?#( ='/ = 2&(.&(=$#

4#<(#$=(H, Q9# &$9#( 4#'%&( 5.#(=$%'? 5::%<#() &: $9# 2&(.&(=$%&' )9=88 A# =..&%'$#/ AH $9#

O&=(/ G.&' $9# (#<&@@#'/=$%&' &: $9# "(#)%/#'$,

_ _ _ _

4#<$%&' S, 1_#<G$%+# V%<#M"(#)%/#'$eQ(#=)G(#( Q9# 1_#<G$%+# V%<#M"(#)%/#'$eQ(#=)G(#( )9=88

9=+# )G<9 .&;#() ='/ .#(:&(@ )G<9 /G$%#) =) =(# .(#)<(%A#/ AH $9#)# OHMU=;)* ='/ =) @=H

A# (#]G%(#/ &: 9%@ AH $9# O&=(/ &: 0%(#<$&(), J) $9# <&'<G((#'$ Q(#=)G(#( &: $9#

2&(.&(=$%&'* 9# )9=88 9=+# $9# <9=(?# &: $9# :G'/)* )#<G(%$%#)* (#<#%.$)* ='/ /%)AG()#@#'$)

&: $9# 2&(.&(=$%&', d# )9=88 /#.&)%$* &( <=G)# $& A# /#.&)%$#/* $9# <(#/%$ &: $9# 2&(.&(=$%&'

%' )G<9 A='\) &( $(G)$ <&@.='%#)* &( ;%$9 )G<9 A='\) &: &$9#( /#.&)%$&(%#)* =) $9# O&=(/ &:

0%(#<$&() @=H :(&@ $%@# $& $%@# /#)%?'=$#, d# )9=88 $#'/#( $& $9# "(#)%/#'$ &( $& $9# O&=(/

&: 0%(#<$&() ;9#'#+#( (#]G%(#/ =' =<<&G'$ &: $9# :%'='<%=8 <&'/%$%&' &: $9# <&(.&(=$%&' ='/

&: =88 9%) $(=')=<$%&') =) Q(#=)G(#(, J) )&&' =) .(=<$%<=A8# =:$#( $9# <8&)# &: #=<9 :%)<=8 H#=(*

9# )9=88 @=\# ='/ )GA@%$ $& $9# O&=(/ &: 0%(#<$&() = 8%\# (#.&($ &: )G<9 :%)<=8 H#=(, d# )9=88

\##. <&((#<$ A&&\) &: =<<&G'$ &: =88 $9# AG)%'#)) ='/ $(=')=<$%&') &: $9# 2&(.&(=$%&',

3' R>*7 -. C7&44(,0 d*,71 N+)(,+5)&*+57 *hSDi

 <%$%'? P5=5+I -. M5)&*+57 ?5=*, /(75)&*+0 F*44&00&*+*hS>i

;#

9#8/ $9=$

Page 98: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 98/108

_ _ _ =' &::%<# %) DIC2EC4 GQ EBC DB2IECI HU EBC DHISHI2EJH3 234 EBC HUUJDCI JF CLCDEC4 GQ EBC

4JICDEHIF HI FEHDXBHL4CIF, 5' $9# &$9#( 9='/* =' #@.8&H## G)G=88H &<<G.%#) '& &::%<# ='/

?#'#(=88H %) #@.8&H#/ '&$ AH =<$%&' &: $9# /%(#<$&() &( )$&<\9&8/#() AG$ AH $9# @='=?%'?

&::%<#( &: $9# <&(.&(=$%&' ;9& =8)& /#$#(@%'#) $9# <&@.#')=$%&' $& A# .=%/ $& )G<9

#@.8&H##, [email protected]=)%) )G..8%#/,i

3' $9%) <=)#* U&<)%' ;=) CLCDEC4 AH $9# 62U"3 O&=(/* %' =<<&(/='<# ;%$9 $9# (RC34C4 ,Qd)2VF&:$9# <&(.&(=$%&', Q9# :&88&;%'? :=<$G=8 /#$#(@%'=$%&' AH $9# 2J %) #8G<%/=$%'?a

Z&(# %@.&($='$* .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ :=%8#/ $& )$=$# ='H )G<9 <%(<G@)$='<# AH ;9%<9 $9#

.#$%$%&'#( <&(.&(=$%&' #'?=?#/ 9%) )#(+%<#) =) <&(.&(=$# &::%<#( $9=$ ;&G8/ @=\# 9%@ ='

#@.8&H##, 3' $9# :%()$ .8=<#* $9# V%<#M"(#)%/#'$eQ(#=)G(#( ;=) (7(;)(1 &' =' =''G=8 A=)%) =)

.(&+%/#/ %' $9# OHMU=;)* ='/ '& /G$%#) ='/ (#).&')%A%8%$%#) ;#(# )$=$#/ AH .(%+=$#

(#).&'/#'$ ;9%<9 9# /%)<9=(?#/ ;9%8# &<<G.H%'? )=%/ .&)%$%&' *)%(, )%5+ )%*0( 0$(;&9&;577<

0() 9*,)% &+ )%( S<K?5#0 *, ,(e6&,(1 *9 %&4 =< )%( S*5,1 *9 D&,(;)*,0. Q9# G'(#AG$$#/ :=<$

(#@=%') $9=$ .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ 9#8/ $9# .&)%$%&' &: 1_#<G$%+# V%<#M"(#)%/#'$eQ(#=)G(#( &:

.#$%$%&'#( <&(.&(=$%&'* = .&)%$%&' .(&+%/#/ :&( %' $9# 8=$$#() AHM8=;)* AH +%($G# &: #8#<$%&' AH$9# O&=(/ &: 0%(#<$&()* ='/ 9=) :G'<$%&'#/ =) )G<9 1_#<G$%+# V%<#M"(#)%/#'$eQ(#=)G(#(

.G()G='$ $& $9# .(&+%)%&') &: $9# )=%/ OHMU=;),"(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ \'#; +#(H ;#88 $9=$ 9#

;=) )%@.8H '&$ (#M#8#<$#/ $& $9# )=%/ .&)%$%&' /G(%'? $9# JG?G)$ R* BDDR A&=(/ @##$%'?* AG$

9# 9=/ &A`#<$#/ $& $9# #8#<$%&' &: = '#; )#$ &: &::%<#() 9#8/ =$ $9# $%@# G.&' $9# =/+%<# &:

9%) 8=;H#( $9=$ 9# <=''&$ A# $#(@%'=$#/ &( (#.8=<#/ =) 1_#<G$%+# V%<#M"(#)%/#'$eQ(#=)G(#(

=) 9# 9=/ =$$=%'#/ $#'G(%=8 )#<G(%$H,hSBi

 

7# :G88H =?(## ;%$9 $9%) :=<$G=8 /#$#(@%'=$%&' ;9%<9 ;# :%'/ $& A# )G::%<%#'$8H )G..&($#/ AH

#+%/#'<#, 7# 8%\#;%)# (G8#* A=)#/ &' 8=; ='/ #)$=A8%)9#/ `G(%).(G/#'<#* $9=$ )HDFJ3* =$ $9# $%@# &: 9%))#+#(='<# :(&@ 62U"3* ;=) $9# 8=$$#() DHISHI2EC HUUJDCI< 

2< 1BC lKCFEJH3 HU ;KIJF4JDEJH3 

N%+#' U&<)%') )$=$G) =) = <&(.&(=$# &::%<#(* $9# -Q2* '&$ $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( &( $9# 6U-2* 9=)

 `G(%)/%<$%&' $& 9#=( $9# 8#?=8%$H &: $9# $#(@%'=$%&' &: 9%) (#8=$%&')9%. ;%$9 6%))=', J) ;# =8)& 9#8/ %' R>*7@=

<&(.&(=$# &::%<#() /%)@%))=8 :(&@ )#(+%<# %) =' %'$(=M<&(.&(=$# /%).G$#a

3' = 'G@A#( &: <=)#) h30),515 -. M5)&*+57 ?5=*, /(75)&*+0 F*44&00&*+* N,-, 6&, >DTEBB* S

5<$&A#( >CCT* BTB 42-J EDC[ ?*8*+ -. M5)&*+57 ?5=*, /(75)&*+0 F*44&00&*+@  I>D "9%8, >K>CCRL[ 30$&+* -. M5)&*+57 ?5=*, /(75)&*+0 F*44&00&*+* I>D "9%8, T> K>CCRL[ B*,)6+( F(4(+)

F*,$*,5)&*+ -. M5)&*+57 ?5=*, /(75)&*+0 F*44&00&*+* N,-, 6&, ECETB* BS F='G=(H >CC>* >CI

42-J BRPi* ;# 9=+# 9#8/ $9=$ = DHISHI2EC HUUJDCIF 4JFRJFF2L JF 2LV2QF 2 DHISHI2EC 2DE* &(

=' J3EI2dDHISHI2EC DH3EIHTCIFQ ;9%<9 =(%)#) A#$;##' = )$&<\9&8/#( ='/ =

<&(.&(=$%&',hSIi [email protected]=)%) )G..8%#/,i

)& $9=$ $9# -Q2 )9&G8/ #_#(<%)# `G(%)/%<$%&' A=)#/ &' $9# :&88&;%'? 8#?=8 (#=)&'%'?a

"(%&( $& %$) =@#'/@#'$* 4#<$%&' RK<L &: "(#)%/#'$%=8 0#<(## 6&, CDBMJ K"0 CDBMJL

.(&+%/#/ $9=$ %'$(=M<&(.&(=$# /%).G$#) :=88 ;%$9%' $9# `G(%)/%<$%&' &: $9# 4#<G(%$%#) ='/

1_<9='?# 2&@@%))%&' K412La

Page 99: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 99/108

  4#<, R, 3' =//%$%&' $& $9# (#?G8=$&(H ='/ =/`G/%<=$%+# :G'<$%&') &: $9#

4#<G(%$%#) ='/ 1_<9='?# 2&@@%))%&' &+#( <&(.&(=$%&')* .=($'#()9%.) ='/

&$9#( :&(@) &: =))&<%=$%&') (#?%)$#(#/ ;%$9 %$ =) #_.(#))8H ?(='$#/ G'/#(

#_%)$%'? 8=;) ='/ /#<(##)* %$ )9=88 9=+# &(%?%'=8 ='/ #_<8G)%+# `G(%)/%<$%&' $&

9#=( ='/ /#<%/# <=)#) %'+&8+%'?a

_ _ _ _

<L 2&'$(&+#()%#) %' $9# #8#<$%&' &( =..&%'$@#'$) &: /%(#<$&()* $(G)$##)*

&::%<#() &( @='=?#() &: )G<9 <&(.&(=$%&')* .=($'#()9%.) &( =))&<%=$%&'),

4GA)#<$%&' R,B* 4#<$%&' R &: -#.GA8%< J<$ 6&, PECC* ;9%<9 $&&\ #::#<$ &' P JG?G)$ BDDD*

$(='):#((#/ $& (#?%&'=8 $(%=8 <&G($) $9# 412) `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( =88 <=)#) 8%)$#/ %' 4#<$%&' R &:

"0 CDBMJa

R,B, Q9# 2&@@%))%&') `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( =88 <=)#) #'G@#(=$#/ G'/#(

4#<$%&' R &: "(#)%/#'$%=8 0#<(## 6&, CDBMJ %) 9#(#AH $(='):#((#/ $& $9# 2&G($)&: ?#'#(=8 `G(%)/%<$%&' &( $9# =..(&.(%=$# &CMJH32L 1IJ2L /HKIE, [email protected]=)%)

)G..8%#/,i

G<  0ICDC4C3DC HU 'KGFE23EJTC .CIJEFb 

0IJR2DQ HU %LCRC3E HU ;KIJF4JDEJH3 

O=)#/ &' $9# =A&+# `G(%)/%<$%&'=8 <&')%/#(=$%&')* ;# ;&G8/ A# :&(<#/ $& (#@='/ $9# <=)# $& $9#

U=A&( J(A%$#( :&( :G($9#( .(&<##/%'?) %: ;# ;#(# $& /%)@%)) $9# .#$%$%&' &G$(%?9$ /G# $& $9# ;(&'?:G8 G)# &:

-G8# TR,

hSSi

 7# <=''&$ <8&)# &G( #H#)* 9&;#+#(* $& $9# :=<$G=8 ='/ 8#?=8 (#=8%$H* #)$=A8%)9#/ AH #+%/#'<#=8(#=/H &' (#<&(/* $9=$ U&<)%' %) = <&(.&(=$# &::%<#( ;9&)# $#(@%'=$%&' &: (#8=$%&')9%. %) &G$)%/# = 8=A&(

=(A%$#() `G(%)/%<$%&' $& (G8# G.&',

Y'/#( $9#)# <%(<G@)$='<#)* VC B2TC EH MJTC SICDC4C3DC EH EBC RCIJEF HU EBC D2FC5 234 SIJR2DQ EH

EBC CLCRC3E HU ]KIJF4JDEJH3< ;KIJF4JDEJH3 JF EBC SHVCI EH BC2I 234 IKLC H3 2 D2FC 234 JF EBC EBICFBHL4

CLCRC3E EB2E RKFE C^JFE GCUHIC 23Q WK2FJd]K4JDJ2L HUUJDCI D23 2DE< #3 EBC DH3EC^E HU EBC SICFC3E D2FC5 EBC

)2GHI (IGJECI 4HCF 3HE B2TC ]KIJF4JDEJH3 HTCI EBC ECIRJ32EJH3 4JFSKEC )HDFJ3 GIHKMBE5 234 FBHKL4 3HE GC

2LLHVC4 EH DH3EJ3KC EH 2DE H3 EBC D2FC 2UECI EBC 2GFC3DC HU ]KIJF4JDEJH3 B2F GCDHRC HGTJHKF5 G2FC4 H3

EBC ICDHI4F 234 EBC L2V< 3' @&(# .(=<$%<=8 $#(@)* = <&'$(=(H (G8%'? ;%88 &'8H <=G)# )GA)$='$%=8 /#8=H ='/

%'<&'+#'%#'<# =) ;#88 =) G''#<#))=(H #_.#')#)* $& $9# .&%'$ &: %'`G)$%<#* $& $9# .=($%#), Q9%) <&'<8G)%&'* &:

<&G()#* /&#) '&$ ?& %'$& $9# @#(%$) &: $#(@%'=$%&' &: (#8=$%&')9%. ='/ %) ;%$9&G$ .(#`G/%<# $& $9# :%8%'? &:

=' %'$(=M<&(.&(=$# /%).G$# &' $9%) .&%'$ A#:&(# $9# =..(&.(%=$# -Q2,

=9%&%6+&%* ;# 7#'.#'' $9# .#$%$%&'#() .#$%$%&' :&( (#+%#; &' ;(,)&*,5,& * ='/ (66#&. $9#

0#<%)%&' &: $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8)* %' 2JMN,-, 4" 6&, >DIEBD* .(&@G8?=$#/ &' JG?G)$ BP* BDDP* =) ;#88 =) %$)

-#)&8G$%&' &: 0#<#@A#( C* BDDP* ;9%<9 (#+#()#/ ='/ )#$ =)%/# $9# Z=(<9 >D* BDDP 5(/#( &: U=A&( J(A%$#(

2&'<#.<%&' %' 6U-2 62- 2=)# 6&, DDMDTMDT>TRMDE, Q9%) 0#<%)%&' %) ;%$9&G$ .(#`G/%<# $& .#$%$%&'#( U&<)%')

=+=%8=A8# (#<&G()# :&( (#8%#: $9(&G?9 $9# =..(&.(%=$# (#@#/H %' $9# .(&.#( :&(G@,

6& .(&'&G'<#@#'$ =) $& <&)$),

Page 100: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 100/108

 

&!&() ,("> +6 /+&+" _0()(=("a5 #"/<5 %.0#&% /+)7 '1+&(-% ("7 7%$%)+0.%"1 /+&0+&(1#+"5

/#1#8%"' 7%$%)+0.%"1 #"/+0&+&(1%75 /(&#7(7 ,< -(&/#(5 '("7&( -< %'/(15 )+&"( -(&/#(5 234

+)-( -< %'/(15 .#$%$%&'#()*

+),

(""()#'( /+&1%'5 (#).&'/#'$,

0 1 2 3 4 3 5 6

/(&0#+ .+&()%'5 ! <A 

3' >CPE* V%(?%8%& N=(<%=* g:&G'/#(g &: .#$%$%&'#( <&(.&(=$%&') K$9# <&(.&(=$%&')L* 9%(#/ $9# $9#' )$%88 )%'?8#

J''=8%)= 2&($#) K(#).&'/#'$L =) <8#(\ &: $9# -G(=8 O='\ &: 2&(&' KZ='%8= 5::%<#L,

J:$#( V%(?%8%& /%#/* 9%) )&' V%<$&( $&&\ &+#( $9# @='=?#@#'$ &: $9# <&(.&(=$%&'),

J'%$= 2&($#) KJ'%$=L* $9# ;%:# &: V%<$&( N=(<%=* ;=) =8)& %'+&8+#/ %' $9# @='=?#@#'$ &: $9# <&(.&(=$%&'),

-#).&'/#'$ 8=$#( @=((%#/ J'%$=W) A(&$9#( 1/G=(/& 2&($#),

J'%$= )&&' =))G@#/ $9# .&)%$%&' &: V%<# "(#)%/#'$ &: .#$%$%&'#( 2%$%^#') 0#+#8&.@#'$ 3'<&(.&(=$#/ K203L

='/ .(=<$%<=88H <&'$(&88#/ $9# :%'='<%=8 &.#(=$%&') &: =8@&)$ =88 &: $9# &$9#( <&(.&(=$%&') %' $9# <&G()# &:

;9%<9 )9# =88&;#/ )&@# &: 9#( (#8=$%+#) ='/ %'M8=;)* %'<8G/%'? (#).&'/#'$* $& 9&8/ )#+#(=8 \#H )#')%$%+#.&)%$%&') $9#(#=$,

-#).&'/#'$ 8=$#( A#<=@# $9# X%'='<%=8 J))%)$='$* "#()&''#8 5::%<#( ='/ 2&(.&(=$# 4#<(#$=(H &: Q9# -G(=8

O='\ &: 2&(&'* "#()&''#8 5::%<#( &: 203* ='/ =8)& "#()&''#8 5::%<#( ='/ 0%)AG()%'? 5::%<#( &: Q9# 1@.%(#

2&8/ 4$&(=?# 0#+#8&.@#'$ 2&(.&(=$%&' K12402L, 49# )%@G8$='#&G)8H (#<#%+#/ )=8=(%#) :(&@ $9#)#

<&(.&(=$%&'),

5' #_=@%'=$%&' &: $9# :%'='<%=8 A&&\) &: $9# <&(.&(=$%&') AH .#$%$%&'#( 4='/(= N=(<%= 1)<=$* = /=G?9$#( &:

V%(?%8%& N=(<%= ;9& ;=) .(#+%&G)8H (#)%/%'? %' 4.=%'* )9# :&G'/ &G$ $9=$ (#).&'/#'$ ;=) %'+&8+#/ %' )#+#(=8

='&@=8%#)*>

/(=;%'? .#$%$%&'#() $& $#(@%'=$# (#).&'/#'$W) )#(+%<#) &' 6&+#@A#( BI* >CCP %' .#$%$%&'#(<&(.&(=$%&'),B 

OH 8#$$#( &: 6&+#@A#( BR* >CCPI =//(#))#/ $& %'/%+%/G=8 .#$%$%&'#() 2=(%/=/ O, N=(<%= K;%/&; &: V%(?%8%&

N=(<%=L* 4='/(= N, 1)<=$* ='/ 58?= N, 1)<=$ K='&$9#( /=G?9$#( &: V%(?%8%& N=(<%=L* (#).&'/#'$W) <&G')#8

<&'+#H#/ (#).&'/#'$W) ;%88%'?'#)) $& =A%/# AH $9# /#<%)%&' $& $#(@%'=$# 9#( AG$ (#@%'/#/ $9#@ $9=$ )9#

;=) #'$%$8#/ $& )#.=(=$%&' .=H #]G%+=8#'$ $& >> @&'$9) )=8=(H =) ;#88 =) $& $9# &$9#( A#'#:%$) .(&+%/#/ AH

8=; %' 9#( :=+&(,

-#).&'/#'$W) <&G')#8 $9G) /#@='/#/ $9# .=H@#'$ &: (#).&'/#'$W) G'.=%/ )=8=(H :&( $9# @&'$9) &:

5<$&A#( ='/ 6&+#@A#( >CCP* )#.=(=$%&' .=H #]G%+=8#'$ $& >B @&'$9) )=8=(H*

S

 >I

$9

 @&'$9 .=H ='/ &$9#(A#'#:%$),

J) $9# /#@='/ (#@=%'#/ G'9##/#/* (#).&'/#'$ :%8#/ = <&@.8=%'$R :&( %88#?=8 /%)@%))=8 ='/ '&'M.=H@#'$ &:

)=8=(%#) ='/ &$9#( A#'#:%$)* /&<\#$#/ =) 6U-2M62- 2=)# 6&, DDMDRMDREIPMCC,

Page 101: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 101/108

"#$%$%&'#() @&+#/ :&( $9# /%)@%))=8 &: $9# <&@.8=%'$ &' $9# ?(&G'/ &: 8=<\ &: `G(%)/%<$%&'* <&'$#'/%'? $9=$

$9# <=)# ;=) =' %'$(=M<&(.&(=$# <&'$(&+#()H %'+&8+%'? $9# (#@&+=8 &: = <&(.&(=$# &::%<#(* (#).&'/#'$ A#%'?

$9# 2&(.&(=$# 4#<(#$=(H &: $9# -G(=8 O='\ &: 2&(&'* 3'<,* 9#'<#* <&?'%^=A8# AH $9# 4#<G(%$%#) ='/ 1_<9='?#

2&@@%))%&' K412L .G()G='$ $& 4#<$%&' R &: "0 CDBMJ,T 

3' (#)&8+%'? $9# %))G# &: `G(%)/%<$%&'* $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( '&$#/ =) :&88&;)a

3$ %) $& A# '&$#/ $9=$ <&@.8=%'='$* =)%/# :(&@ 9#( A#%'? 2&(.&(=$# 4#<(#$=(H &: -G(=8 O='\ &:2&(&'*DHRSL2J323E V2F LJXCVJFC 2SSHJ3EC4 2F 6J323DJ2L (FFJFE23E o 0CIFH33CL +UUJDCI HU 2LL

ICFSH34C3EF BCICJ3* ;9&)# )#(+%<#) ;h#(#i $#(@%'=$#/ &' BI 6&+#@A#( >CCP* 9#'<#* $9# %')$='$

<&@.8=%'$,

V#(%8H* 2 6J323DJ2L (FFJFE23E o 0CIFH33CL +UUJDCI JF 3HE 2 /HISHI2EC +UUJDCI HU EBC hSCEJEJH3CIF@i

DHISHI2EJH3* $9G)* .G()G='$ $& J($%<8# B>E &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#* =) =@#'/#/* $9# %')$='$ <=)# :=88)

;%$9%' $9# =@A%$ &: &(%?%'=8 ='/ #_<8G)%+# `G(%)/%<$%&' &: $9%) 5::%<#,E [email protected]=)%) ='/ G'/#()<&(%'?

)G..8%#/L,

1+#'$G=88H* $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( :&G'/ :&( (#).&'/#'$* <&@.G$%'? $9# @&'#$=(H =;=(/ /G# 9#( =) :&88&;)a

O=<\;=?#) "TRP*DDD,DD

>I$9 Z&'$9 "=H :&( >CCP* >CCC n BDDD TI*DDD,DD

"EB>*DDD,DD

4#.=(=$%&' "=H I>R*DDD,DD

Y'.=%/ 4=8=(H BR*CDD,DD

J$$&('#HW) :##) >DT*>CD,DD

">*>TP*DCD,DD

Q9G)* $9# U=A&( J(A%$#(* AH 0#<%)%&' &: FG8H >P* BDD>* /%).&)#/a

7d1-1X5-1* %' +%#; &: =88 $9# :&(#?&%'?* (#).&'/#'$) =(# 9#(#AH &(/#(#/ $& `&%'$8H ='/ )#+#(=88H

.=H <&@.8=%'='$ $9# $&$=8 =@&G'$ &: 561 Z3UU356 561 dY60-10 43rQkM13NdQ Qd5Y4J60 6361Qk

K">*>TP*DCD,DDL "1454 =) /%)<G))#/ =A&+#,P 

5' JG?G)$ >I* BDD>* $9# $#'$9 &( 8=)$ /=H &: $9# .#(%&/ &: =..#=8*C .#$%$%&'#() :%8#/ = M*)&;( *9 L$$(57 5+1

T*)&*+ 9*, /(16;)&*+ *9 S*+1 >D

 $& ;9%<9 $9#H =$$=<9#/ = T(4*,5+164 *+ L$$(57 ,>>

 3' $9#%( T*)&*+ 9*,

/(16;)&*+ *9 S*+1 * .#$%$%&'#() =88#?#/ $9=$ $9# <&(.&(=$%&') ;#(# G'/#( :%'='<%=8 /%)$(#)) ='/ $9# -G(=8O='\ &: 2&(&' ;=) G'/#( (#<#%+#()9%., Q9#H $9G) .(=H#/ $9=$ $9# =@&G'$ &: A&'/ A# )GA)$='$%=88H

(#/G<#/* .(#:#(=A8H $& &'# 9=8: $9#(#&: &( #+#' 8&;#(,>B

 

OH -#)&8G$%&' &: 5<$&A#( >T* BDD>>I

* $9# 6=$%&'=8 U=A&( -#8=$%&') 2&@@%))%&' K6U-2L* ;9%8# '&$%'? $9=$

.#$%$%&'#() $%@#8H :%8#/ $9# =..#=8* 9#8/ $9=$ $9# )=@# ;=) '&$ =<<&@.='%#/ AH =' =..#=8 A&'/* =

@='/=$&(H (#]G%(#@#'$ G'/#( J($%<8# BBI>S

 &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# ='/ 4#<$%&' T* -G8# V3 &: $9# 6U-2 6#;

-G8#) &: "(&<#/G(#, 3$ =8)& '&$#/ $9=$ $9# T*)&*+ 9*, /(16;)&*+ *9 S*+1 ;=) g.(#@%)#/ &' )#8:M)#(+%'?

=88#?=$%&'),g 3$ =<<&(/%'?8H /%)@%))#/ $9# =..#=8,

"#$%$%&'#()W Z&$%&' :&( -#<&')%/#(=$%&'>R

 ;=) /#'%#/ AH $9# 6U-2 AH 6&+#@A#( BT* BDD>

-#)&8G$%&'*>T 9#'<#* $9#H :%8#/ = "#$%$%&' :&( 2#($%&(=(%>E A#:&(# $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8),

OH 0#<%)%&' /=$#/ Z=H BT* BDDS>P* $9# =..#88=$# <&G($ /%)@%))#/ $9# .#$%$%&' :&( 8=<\ &: @#(%$, "#$%$%&'#()W

@&$%&' :&( (#<&')%/#(=$%&' ;=) =8)& /#'%#/ AH -#)&8G$%&' &: JG?G)$ >I* BDDS,>C

 

Page 102: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 102/108

d#'<#* $9%) .#$%$%&'*BD

 .#$%$%&'#() :=G8$%'? $9# =..#88=$# <&G($ :&(a

3

, , , XJ3UhY-1i Q5 -YU1 QdJQ Qd1 6U-2W4 -YU1 5X "-5210Y-1 7d32d "-5V3014 X5- Qd1 "54Q36N

5X J O560 J4 J 25603Q356 "-121016Q X5- "1-X12Q36N J6 J""1JU J4 J 25603Q356

"-121016Q X5- "1-X12Q36N J6 J""1JU 34 256Q-J-k Q5 UJ7 J60 14QJOU34d10

FY-34"-Y01621,

33

, , , 034Z344h36Ni "1Q3Q3561-4hWi "1Q3Q356 X5- h21-Q35-J-3i OJ410 56 Q12d632JU3Qk J60

XJ3UhY-1i Q5 012301 Qd1 4JZ1 OJ410 56 3Q4 Z1-3Q,

333

, , , 034Z34436N "1Q3Q3561-4W "1Q3Q356 X5- 21-Q35-J-3 X-5Z Qd1 01234356 5X Qd1 6U-2 X5-

656M"1-X12Q356 Qd1-15X,

3V

, , , 034Z34436N "1Q3Q3561-4W "1Q3Q356 X5- h21-Q35-J-3i X-5Z Qd1 01234356 5X Qd1 6U-2

73Qd5YQ -145UV36N Qd1 2J41 OJ410 56 3Q4 Z1-3Q4,

V

, , , XJ3UhY-1i Q5 012UJ-1 QdJQ 3603V30YJU "1Q3Q3561-4 J-1 65Q 45U30J-k U3JOU1 Q5 "Jk Qd1

-14"56016Q X5- d1- Z561QJ-k 2UJ3Z 36 V317 5X Qd1 JO41621 5X J6k 1V301621 4d5736N

QdJQ Qd1k 71-1 Z5Q3VJQ10 Ok 3UUM73UU 5- ZJU321 36 41V1-36N d1- 1Z"U5kZ16Q,

V3

, , , XJ3UhY-1i Q5 -145UV1 Qd1 344Y1 5X FY-34032Q356,B>

 

79%8#* %'/##/* (#).&'/#'$ ;=) $9# 2&(.&(=$# 4#<(#$=(H &: $9# -G(=8 O='\ &: 2&(&'* )9# ;=) =8)& %$)

X%'='<%=8 J))%)$='$ ='/ $9# "#()&''#8 5::%<#( &: $9# $;& &$9#( .#$%$%&'#( <&(.&(=$%&'),BB

 

T5&+75+1 F*+0),6;)&*+ F*.@ N+;. -. T*-&775BI

 %')$(G<$) $9=$ = <&(.&(=$%&' <=' #'?=?# %$) <&(.&(=$# &::%<#() $&

.#(:&(@ )#(+%<#) G'/#( = <%(<G@)$='<# ;9%<9 ;&G8/ @=\# $9#@ #@.8&H##),BS

 

Q9# U=A&( J(A%$#( 9=) $9G) `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( (#).&'/#'$W) <&@.8=%'$,

5' $9# :%()$ $9(## =))%?'#/ #((&() ;9%<9 A#=( &' ;9#$9#( .#$%$%&'#()W =..#=8 A#:&(# $9# 6U-2 ;=)

.#(:#<$#/a

J) A#:&(# $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8)* .#$%$%&'#() <%$# F*0&;*@ E,. -. M?/Ffg\h ='/ P5=(,,5% -. M?/Ffgih %' )G..&($

&: $9#%( <&'$#'$%&' $9=$ $9#%( =..#=8 A#:&(# $9# 6U-2 ;=) .#(:#<$#/, J) <&((#<$8H (G8#/ AH $9# 2&G($ &:

J..#=8)* 9&;#+#(* $9# <%$#/ <=)#) =(# '&$ %' .&%'$,

x Q9# =..#88='$ %' P5=(,,5% :%8#/ = @&$%&' $& :%_ =..#=8 A&'/ %')$#=/ &: .&)$%'? =' =..#=8 A&'/[

='/ $9# 4G.(#@# 2&G($ (#8=_#/ $9# (#]G%(#@#'$ <&')%/#(%'? $9=$ $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#(W) /#<%)%&' /%/

'&$ <&'$=%' = <&@.G$=$%&' &: $9# @&'#$=(H =;=(/, 3' F*0&;*@ $9# =..#=8 A&'/ .&)$#/ ;=)

&: %')G::%<%#'$ =@&G'$ AG$ $9# 4G.(#@# 2&G($ (G8#/ $9=$ .(&+%)%&') &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# &' (#]G%(%'? =

Page 103: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 103/108

A&'/ &' =..#=8 %'+&8+%'? @&'#$=(H =;=(/) @G)$ A# ?%+#' 8%A#(=8 %'$#(.(#$=$%&' %' 8%'# ;%$9 $9#

/#)%(#/ &A`#<$%+# &: (#)&8+%'? <&'$(&+#()%#) &' $9#%( @#(%$), d#(#%'5 3H 2SSC2L GH345 VBCEBCI

FKUUJDJC3E HI 3HE5 V2F CTCI UJLC4 GQ EBC SCEJEJH3CIF<BE

 K3$=8%<) %' $9# &(%?%'=8[ #@.9=)%) ='/

G'/#()<&(%'? )G..8%#/L

"#$%$%&'#() =//%$%&'=88H <%$# C)5, L+I(7 W5+1&;,59) -. M?/Ffgjh $& )G..&($ $9#%( .&)%$%&' $9=$ $9#(# %) =

/%)$%'<$%&' A#$;##' $9# :%8%'? &: =' =..#=8 ;%$9%' $9# (#?8#@#'$=(H .#(%&/ ='/ %$) .#(:#<$%&', 3' $9# .=(=88#8

<=)# &: F*4$6)(, N++*-5)&*+0 F(+)(, -. M5)&*+57 ?5=*, /(75)&*+0 F*44&00&*+*BC

 $9%) 2&G($ 9#)%$=$#/ $&(#%$#(=$# $9# /&<$(%'# %' C)5, L+I(7 %' $9%) ;%)#a

"#$%$%&'#() %'+&\# $9# =:&(#@#'$%&'#/ 9&8/%'? %' C)5,   L+I(7  $9=$ $9#(# %) = /%)$%'<$%&' A#$;##' $9#

:%8%'? &: =' =..#=8 ;%$9%' $9# (#?8#@#'$=(H .#(%&/ ='/ %$) .#(:#<$%&'* ='/ $9=$ $9# =..#=8 @=H A#

.#(:#<$#/ =:$#( $9# )=%/ (#?8#@#'$=(H .#(%&/, 3'/##/* C)5, L+I(7  9#8/ $9=$ $9# :%8%'? &: = @&$%&' :&(

(#/G<$%&' &: =..#=8 A&'/ '#<#))=(%8H )$=H) $9# (#?8#@#'$=(H .#(%&/ :&( =..#=8, d&;#+#(* %' $9%)

<=)#* $9# @&$%&' :&( (#/G<$%&' &: =..#=8 A&'/* ;9%<9 ;=) %'<&(.&(=$#/ %' $9# =..#=8

@#@&(='/G@* ;=) :%8#/ &'8H &' $9# $#'$9 &( :%'=8 /=H &: $9# (#?8#@#'$=(H .#(%&/, Y'/#( )G<9

<%(<G@)$='<#* EBC RHEJH3 UHI IC4KDEJH3 HU 2SSC2L GH34 D23 3H LH3MCI GC 4CCRC4 EH B2TC FE2QC4

EBC 2SSC2L5 234 EBC SCEJEJH3CI U2DCF EBC IJFX5 2F B24 B2SSC3C4 J3 EBJF D2FC5 HU FKRR2IQ 4JFRJFF2LHU EBC 2SSC2L UHI 3H3dSCIUCDEJH3< 

Z&(#&+#(* $9# (#:#(#'<# %' C)5, L+I(7  $& $9# /%)$%'<$%&' A#$;##' $9# .#(%&/ $& :%8# $9# =..#=8 ='/

$& .#(:#<$ $9# =..#=8 9=) A##' .&%'$#/8H @=/# &'8H &'<# AH $9%) 2&G($ %' Y(+0*7& -. M?/F  $9G)* %$

9=) '&$ =<]G%(#/ $9# )9##' &: +#'#(=A%8%$H (#)#(+#/ :&( (#.#=$#/8HM<%$#/ <=)#), Q9# /%)$%'<$%&'* %:

='H* %) '&$ .=($%<G8=(8H #+%/#'$ &( @=$#(%=8 %' $9# U=A&( 2&/#[ 9#'<#* $9# (#8G<$='<# &: $9# 2&G($ $&

=/&.$ )G<9 /&<$(%'#, Z&(#&+#(* EBC SICFC3E SIHTJFJH3 J3 EBC ")&/ &KLCF HU 0IHDC4KIC5 $9=$ g$9#

:%8%'? &: = @&$%&' $& (#/G<# A&'/ )9=88 '&$ )$&. $9# (G''%'? &: $9# .#(%&/ $& .#(:#<$ =..#=8g UL2ELQ

DH3EI24JDEF EBC 3HEJH3 C^SICFFC4 J3 :+)' 9*;&4  EB2E EBCIC JF 2 4JFEJ3DEJH3 GCEVCC3 EBC UJLJ3M 23

2SSC2L 234 SCIUCDEJ3M 23 2SSC2L< 

Y8$%@=$#8H* $9# /%).&)%$%&' &: C)5, L+I(7  ;=) .(#@%)#/ &' $9# (G8%'? $9=$ = @&$%&' :&( (#/G<$%&' &:

$9# =..#=8 A&'/ '#<#))=(%8H )$=H) $9# .#(%&/ :&( .#(:#<$%'? $9# =..#=8* ='/ $9=$ $9# #@.8&H#(

<=''&$ A# #_.#<$#/ $& .#(:#<$ $9# =..#=8 AH .&)$%'? $9# .(&.#( A&'/ G'$%8 )G<9 $%@# $9# )=%/

@&$%&' :&( (#/G<$%&' %) (#)&8+#/, 1BC K34KLQ FEICEDBC4dHKE 4JFEJ3DEJH3 GCEVCC3 EBC SCIJH4 EH UJLC

23 2SSC2L 234 EH SCIUCDE 23 2SSC2L V2F 3HE R2ECIJ2L EH EBC ICFHLKEJH3 HU :+)' 9*;&4 5 234 EBJF

DHKL4 GC SIHSCILQ DH3FJ4CIC4 2F 0=,+&' 2,/+.("ID

K3$=8%<) %' $9# &(%?%'=8[ #@.9=)%) ='/ G'/#()<&(%'?

)G..8%#/L

Q9# =..#88=$# <&G($ /%/ '&$ $9G) #(( %' /%)@%))%'? $9# .#$%$%&' A#:&(# %$, J'/ <&'$(=(H $& .#$%$%&'#()W

=))#($%&'* $9# =..#88=$# <&G($ /%)@%))#/ %$) .#$%$%&' '&$ g&' = @#(# $#<9'%<=8%$H,g X&( $9# '&'M.&)$%'? &: ='=..#=8 A&'/ ;%$9%' $9# (#?8#@#'$=(H .#(%&/ /%+#)$) $9# 6U-2 &: %$) `G(%)/%<$%&' $& #'$#($=%' $9# =..#=8,

Q9G)* %' $9# )=@# <=)# &: F*4$6)(, N++*-5)&*+0 F(+)(, * $9%) 2&G($ 9#8/a

"#$%$%&'#() =8)& <9=(=<$#(%^# $9# =..#=8 A&'/ (#]G%(#@#'$ =) = $#<9'%<=8 (G8#* ='/ $9=$ $9#

/%)@%))=8 &: =' =..#=8 &' .G(#8H $#<9'%<=8 ?(&G'/) %) :(&;'#/ G.&', d&;#+#(* (IEJDLC NNc5 VBJDB

SICFDIJGCF EBC 2SSC2L GH34 ICWKJICRC3E5 JF 2 IKLC HU ]KIJF4JDEJH3 234 3HE HU SIHDC4KIC< Q9#(# %) =

8%$$8# 8##;=H :&( <&'/&'%'? = 8%A#(=8 %'$#(.(#$=$%&' $9#(#&:* ='/ <#($=%'8H '&'# .(#@%)#/ &' $9#

?(&G'/ $9=$ %$) (#]G%(#@#'$) =(# @#(# $#<9'%<=8%$%#), 3$ @G)$ A# #@.9=)%^#/ $9=$ $9#(# %) '&

%'9#(#'$ (%?9$ $& =' =..#=8 %' = 8=A&( <=)#* =) %$ =(%)#) )&8#8H :(&@ ?(='$ &: )$=$G$#* '=@#8H $9# U=A&(

2&/#,

7# 9=+# %'/##/ 9#8/ $9=$ $9# ICWKJICRC3E UHI SHFEJ3M EBC FKICEQ GH34 %) '&$ @#(#8H .(&<#/G(=8

AG$ ]KIJF4JDEJH32L ='/ <=''&$ A# $(%:8#/ ;%$9, 6&'M<&@.8%='<# ;%$9 )G<9 8#?=8 (#]G%(#@#'$) %) :=$=8

Page 104: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 104/108

='/ 9=) $9# #::#<$ &: (#'/#(%'? $9# `G/?@#'$ :%'=8 ='/ #_#<G$&(H, Q9# .#$%$%&'#() <=''&$ A#

=88&;#/ $& )##\ (#:G?# %' = 8%A#(=8 =..8%<=$%&' &: (G8#) :&( $9#%( =<$ &: '#?8%?#'<#,I>

 [email protected]=)%) ='/

G'/#()<&(%'? )G..8%#/L

3$ A#=() #@.9=)%) $9=$ =88 $9=$ %) (#]G%(#/ $& .#(:#<$ $9# =..#=8 %) $9# .&)$%'? &: = A&'/ $& #')G(# $9=$ $9#

=;=(/ %) #+#'$G=88H .=%/ )9&G8/ $9# =..#=8 A# /%)@%))#/, "#$%$%&'#() )9&G8/ $9G) 9=+# .&)$#/ = A&'/* #+#'

%: %$ ;#(# &'8H .=($%=8* AG$ $9#H /%/ '&$, 6& (#8=_=$%&' &: $9# -G8# @=H $9G) A# <&')%/#(#/,IB

 

3' $9# <=)# =$ A=(* .#$%$%&'#( /%/ '&$ .&)$ = UKLL &( S2IEJ2L =..#=8 A&'/ ;%$9%' $9# .(#)<(%A#/ .#(%&/* $9G)*

'& =..#=8 ;=) .#(:#<$#/ :(&@ $9# /#<%)%&' &: $9# U=A&( J(A%$#(, X&( $9%) (#=)&'* $9# /#<%)%&' )&G?9$ $& A#

=..#=8#/ $& $9# 6U-2 9=/ A#<&@# :%'=8 ='/ #_#<G$&(H ='/ $9#(#:&(# %@@G$=A8#, 28#=(8H $9#'* $9# 6U-2

9=) '& =G$9&(%$H $& #'$#($=%' $9# =..#=8* @G<9 8#)) $& (#+#()# $9# /#<%)%&' &: $9# U=A&( J(A%$#(, J'H

=@#'/@#'$ &( =8$#(=$%&' @=/# ;9%<9 )GA)$='$%=88H =::#<$) $9# :%'=8 ='/ #_#<G$&(H `G/?@#'$ %) 'G88 ='/

+&%/ :&( 8=<\ &: `G(%)/%<$%&'* %'<8G/%'? $9# #'$%(# .(&<##/%'? 9#8/ :&( $9=$ .G(.&)#,II

 [email protected]=)%) ='/

G'/#()<&(%'? )G..8%#/L

J) $9# /#<%)%&' &: $9# U=A&( J(A%$#( 9=/ A#<&@# :%'=8 ='/ #_#<G$&(H* = /%)<G))%&' &: $9# :&G($9 ='/ :%:$9

=))%?'#/ #((&() %) '& 8&'?#( '#<#))=(H,

=9%&%6+&%* $9# .#$%$%&' %) 7%"#%7< 

45 5-01-10,

k6&064=&+I@ E.@ F%5&,$(,0*+@ F5,$&*@ P&+I5@ 5+1 `(750;*@ E,.@ EE.@ <&'<G(,

Page 105: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 105/108

 

0%+0)%' ,&+(7/('1#"- '%&$#/% _,+.,+ &(7:+

09#)'<5 #"/<a5 

"#$%$%&'#(*

M +#()G) M

19% '%/&%1(&: +6 19% 7%0(&1.%"1 +6 )(,+& ("7

%.0)+:.%"15 19% &%-#+"() 7#&%/1+&5 7+)%

&%-#+" $##5 234 ;("7%)%+" ;!%8("5 

-#).&'/#'$),

-<&< "H< Pke`[N 

"(#)#'$a

25-56J* F.E.*

2J-"35*

V1UJ425* F-,*U156J-05M01 2J4Q-5*

O-356*

"1-JUQJ*

O1-4JZ36*

01U 2J4Q3UU5*w 

JOJ0*

V3UUJ-JZJ* F-,*

"1-1j*

Z1605jJ*

41-165*-1k14* ='/

"1-UJ4MO1-6JO1* EE,

"(&@G8?=$#/a

Z=(<9 T* BD>B

_MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM_

& % ' + ) ! 1 # + " 

$%)('/+5 ;&<5 ! <A 

3' = "#$%$%&' :&( 2#($%&(=(% G'/#( -G8# TR* .#$%$%&'#( "#&.8#) O(&=/<=)$%'? 4#(+%<#* 3'<, KO&@A& -=/H&

"9%8),* 3'<,L ]G#)$%&'#/ $9# 0#<%)%&' ='/ -#)&8G$%&' &: $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) K2JL /=$#/ 5<$&A#( BT* BDDT

='/ FG'# BT* BDDE* (#).#<$%+#8H* %' 2,J, N,-, 21OM4" 6&, DDPRR,

"(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ F='/#8#&' FG#^=' :%8#/ = <&@.8=%'$ =?=%')$ .#$%$%&'#( ;%$9 $9# 0#.=($@#'$ &:

U=A&( ='/ [email protected]&H@#'$ K05U1L -#?%&'=8 5::%<# 6&, V33* 2#AG 2%$H* :&( %88#?=8 /#/G<$%&'* '&'.=H@#'$ &:

)#(+%<# %'<#'$%+# 8#=+#* >I$9 @&'$9 .=H* .(#@%G@ .=H :&( 9&8%/=H ='/ (#)$ /=H ='/ %88#?=8 /%@%'G$%&' &:

A#'#:%$)* /#8=H#/ .=H@#'$ &: ;=?#) ='/ '&'<&+#(=?# &: 444* "JNM3O3N ='/ "9%89#=8$9,h>i J:$#( $9# <&'/G<$

&: )G@@=(H %'+#)$%?=$%&')* ='/ =:$#( $9# .=($%#) )GA@%$$#/ $9#%( .&)%$%&' .=.#()* $9# 05U1 -#?%&'=8

0%(#<$&( :&G'/ $9=$ .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ ;=) =' #@.8&H## &: .#$%$%&'#(* ='/ ;=) #'$%$8#/ $& 9%) @&'#H

<8=%@),hBi

 "#$%$%&'#( )&G?9$ (#<&')%/#(=$%&' &: $9# 0%(#<$&() 5(/#(* AG$ :=%8#/, Q9# J<$%'? 05U1 4#<(#$=(H

/%)@%))#/ .#$%$%&'#() =..#=8 &' $9# ?(&G'/ $9=$ .#$%$%&'#( )GA@%$$#/ = 0##/ &: J))%?'@#'$ &: O='\

0#.&)%$ %')$#=/ &: .&)$%'? = <=)9 &( )G(#$H A&'/, 79#' $9# @=$$#( ;=) A(&G?9$ A#:&(# $9# 2J* ;9#(#

.#$%$%&'#( <8=%@#/ $9=$ %$ 9=/ A##' /#'%#/ /G# .(&<#))* %$ ;=) 9#8/ $9=$ .#$%$%&'#( ;=) =<<&(/#/ /G#

.(&<#)) =) %$ 9=/ A##' ?%+#' $9# &..&($G'%$H $& A# 9#=(/* ='/ $9=$ $9# 05U1 4#<(#$=(H 9=/ `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#(

$9# @=$$#(* =) $9# `G(%)/%<$%&'=8 8%@%$=$%&' %@.&)#/ AH J($%<8# >BC &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# &' $9# .&;#( &: $9#

05U1 4#<(#$=(H G'/#( J($, >BPKAL &: $9# 2&/# 9=/ A##' (#.#=8#/ AH -#.GA8%< J<$ 6&, K-JL EEID,hIi 

3' $9# 0#<%)%&' &: $9%) 2&G($* $9# 2J 0#<%)%&' ;=) (#+#()#/ ='/ )#$ =)%/#* ='/ $9# <&@.8=%'$ =?=%')$

.#$%$%&'#( ;=) /%)@%))#/, Q9# /%).&)%$%+# .&($%&' &: $9# 0#<%)%&' (#=/) =) :&88&;)a

Page 106: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 106/108

=9%&%6+&%* $9# .#$%$%&' %) -&("1%7, Q9# 0#<%)%&' /=$#/ BT 5<$&A#( BDDT ='/ $9#

-#)&8G$%&' /=$#/ BT FG'# BDDE &: $9# 2&G($ &: J..#=8) %' 2,J, N,-, 21OM4" 6&, DDPRR

=(# &%$%&'%7 ='/ '%1 ('#7%< Q9# 5(/#( &: $9# $9#' J<$%'? 4#<(#$=(H &: $9# 0#.=($@#'$ &:

U=A&( ='/ [email protected]&H@#'$ /=$#/ BE F='G=(H BDDR /#'H%'? .#$%$%&'#() =..#=8* ='/ $9# 5(/#()

&: $9# 0%(#<$&(* 05U1 -#?%&'=8 5::%<# 6&, V33* /=$#/ BS Z=H BDDS ='/ BE X#A(G=(H BDDS*

(#).#<$%+#8H* =(# (""!))%7< Q9# <&@.8=%'$ =?=%')$ .#$%$%&'#( %) 7#'.#''%7,hSi

 

Q9# 2&G($ :&G'/ $9=$ $9#(# ;=) '& #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. A#$;##' .#$%$%&'#( ='/ .(%+=$#

(#).&'/#'$, 3$ ;=) 9#8/ $9=$ ;9%8# $9# 05U1 @=H @=\# = /#$#(@%'=$%&' &: $9# #_%)$#'<# &: =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%.* $9%) :G'<$%&' <&G8/ '&$ A# <&M#_$#')%+# ;%$9 $9# +%)%$&(%=8 ='/ #':&(<#@#'$ .&;#(

.(&+%/#/ %' J($, >BPKAL &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#* =) =@#'/#/ AH -J EEID, Q9# 6=$%&'=8 U=A&( -#8=$%&')

2&@@%))%&' K6U-2L ;=) 9#8/ $& A# $9# .(%@=(H =?#'<H %' /#$#(@%'%'? $9# #_%)$#'<# &: =' #@.8&H#(M

#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%., Q9%) ;=) $9# %'$#(.(#$=$%&' &: $9# 2&G($ &: $9# <8=G)# %' <=)#) ;9#(# $9#

(#8=$%&')9%. &: #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## )$%88 #_%)$) %' J($, >BPKAL,hRi

 

X(&@ $9%) 0#<%)%&'* $9# "GA8%< J$$&('#H) 5::%<# K"J5L :%8#/ = Z&$%&' :&( 28=(%:%<=$%&' &: 0#<%)%&'

K;%$9 U#=+# &: 2&G($L, Q9# "J5 )&G?9$ $& <8=(%:H =) $& ;9#' $9# +%)%$&(%=8 ='/ #':&(<#@#'$ .&;#( &: $9#

05U1 A# '&$ <&')%/#(#/ =) <&M#_$#')%+# ;%$9 $9# .&;#( $& /#$#(@%'# $9# #_%)$#'<# &: =' #@.8&H#(M

#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%.,

hTi

  3' %$) 2&@@#'$*

hEi

  $9# 05U1 )&G?9$ <8=(%:%<=$%&' =) ;#88* =) $& $9# #_$#'$ &: %$)+%)%$&(%=8 ='/ #':&(<#@#'$ .&;#( G'/#( $9# U=A&( 2&/#* =) =@#'/#/,

Q9# 2&G($ $(#=$#/ $9# Z&$%&' :&( 28=(%:%<=$%&' =) = )#<&'/ @&$%&' :&( (#<&')%/#(=$%&'* ?(='$%'? )=%/

@&$%&' ='/ (#%')$=$%'? $9# .#$%$%&',hPi

 3$ %) =..=(#'$ $9=$ $9#(# %) = '##/ $& /#8%'#=$# $9# `G(%)/%<$%&' &: $9#

05U1 4#<(#$=(H +%)MM+%) $9=$ &: $9# 6U-2,

Y'/#( J($, >BC &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#* $9# .&;#( &: $9# 05U1 ='/ %$) /G8H =G$9&(%^#/ 9#=(%'? &::%<#() $&

9#=( ='/ /#<%/# ='H @=$$#( %'+&8+%'? $9# (#<&+#(H &: ;=?#) ='/ &$9#( @&'#$=(H <8=%@) ='/ A#'#:%$) ;=)

]G=8%:%#/ AH $9# .(&+%)& $9=$ $9# <&@.8=%'$ '&$ %'<8G/# = <8=%@ :&( (#%')$=$#@#'$* &( $9=$ $9# =??(#?=$#

@&'#H <8=%@) '&$ #_<##/ "9" R*DDD, -J EEID* &( =' L;) B6,)%(, C),(+I)%(+&+I )%( `&0&)*,&57 5+13+9*,;(4(+) '*#(,0 *9 )%( C(;,()5,< *9 ?5=*, * /%/ =;=H ;%$9 $9# "9" R*DDD 8%@%$=$%&'* =88&;%'? $9# 05U1

4#<(#$=(H $& #_#(<%)# %$) +%)%$&(%=8 ='/ #':&(<#@#'$ .&;#( :&( <8=%@) A#H&'/ "9" R*DDD, Q9# &'8H

]G=8%:%<=$%&' $& $9%) #_.='/#/ .&;#( &: $9# 05U1 ;=) &'8H $9=$ $9#(# )$%88 A# =' #_%)$%'? #@.8&H#(M

#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%.,

3$ %) <&'<#/#/ $9=$ %: $9#(# %) '& #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%.* ;9#$9#( %$ 9=) A##' $#(@%'=$#/

&( %$ 9=) '&$ #_%)$#/ :(&@ $9# )$=($* $9# 05U1 9=) '& `G(%)/%<$%&', Y'/#( J($, >BPKAL &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#* =)

=@#'/#/ AH -J EEID* $9# :%()$ )#'$#'<# (#=/)* 6&$;%$9)$='/%'? $9# .(&+%)%&') &: J($%<8#) >BC ='/ B>E &:

$9%) 2&/# $& $9# <&'$(=(H* ='/ %' <=)#) ;9#(# $9# (#8=$%&')9%. &: #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## )$%88 #_%)$)* $9#

4#<(#$=(H &: U=A&( ='/ [email protected]&H@#'$ &( 9%) /G8H =G$9&(%^#/ (#.(#)#'$=$%+#) )9=88 9=+# $9# .&;#( $& %))G#

<&@.8%='<# &(/#() $& ?%+# #::#<$ $& $9# 8=A&( )$='/=(/) .(&+%)%&') &: $9%) 2&/# ='/ &$9#( 8=A&( 8#?%)8=$%&'

A=)#/ &' $9# :%'/%'?) &: 8=A&( #@.8&H@#'$ ='/ #':&(<#@#'$ &::%<#() &( %'/G)$(%=8 )=:#$H #'?%'##() @=/#

%' $9# <&G()# &: %').#<$%&', 3$ %) <8#=( ='/ A#H&'/ /#A=$# $9=$ =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. @G)$

#_%)$ :&( $9# #_#(<%)# &: $9# +%)%$&(%=8 ='/ #':&(<#@#'$ .&;#( &: $9# 05U1, Q9# ]G#)$%&' '&; =(%)#)* @=H

$9# 05U1 @=\# = /#$#(@%'=$%&' &: ;9#$9#( &( '&$ =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. #_%)$)* ='/ %: )&* $&

;9=$ #_$#'$s

Q9# :%()$ .&($%&' &: $9# ]G#)$%&' @G)$ A# =');#(#/ %' $9# =::%(@=$%+#,

Q9# .(%&( /#<%)%&' &: $9%) 2&G($ %' $9# .(#)#'$ <=)# =<<#.$) )G<9 =');#(* AG$ .8=<#) = 8%@%$=$%&'

G.&' $9# .&;#( &: $9# 05U1* $9=$ %)* $9# /#$#(@%'=$%&' &: $9# #_%)$#'<# &: =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H##

(#8=$%&')9%. <=''&$ A# <&M#_$#')%+# ;%$9 $9# +%)%$&(%=8 ='/ #':&(<#@#'$ .&;#( &: $9# 05U1, OG$ #+#' %'

<&'<#/%'? $9# .&;#( &: $9# 05U1 $& /#$#(@%'# $9# #_%)$#'<# &: =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%.* $9#

Page 107: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 107/108

2&G($ 9#8/ $9=$ $9# /#$#(@%'=$%&' &: $9# #_%)$#'<# &: =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. %) )$%88 .(%@=(%8H

;%$9%' $9# .&;#( &: $9# 6U-2* $9=$ ='H :%'/%'? AH $9# 05U1 %) @#(#8H .(#8%@%'=(H,

Q9%) <&'<8G)%&' @G)$ A# (#+%)%$#/,

6& 8%@%$=$%&' %' $9# 8=; ;=) .8=<#/ G.&' $9# .&;#( &: $9# 05U1 $& /#$#(@%'# $9# #_%)$#'<# &: ='

#@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%., 6& .(&<#/G(# ;=) 8=%/ /&;' ;9#(# $9# 05U1 ;&G8/ &'8H @=\# =

.(#8%@%'=(H :%'/%'?* $9=$ $9# .&;#( ;=) .(%@=(%8H 9#8/ AH $9# 6U-2, Q9# 8=; /%/ '&$ )=H $9=$ $9# 05U1

;&G8/ :%()$ )##\ $9# 6U-2) /#$#(@%'=$%&' &: $9# #_%)$#'<# &: =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%.* &( $9=$)9&G8/ $9# #_%)$#'<# &: $9# #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. A# /%).G$#/* $9# 05U1 ;&G8/ (#:#( $9# @=$$#(

$& $9# 6U-2, Q9# 05U1 @G)$ 9=+# $9# .&;#( $& /#$#(@%'# ;9#$9#( &( '&$ =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H##

(#8=$%&')9%. #_%)$)* ='/ :(&@ $9#(# $& /#<%/# ;9#$9#( &( '&$ $& %))G# <&@.8%='<# &(/#() %' =<<&(/='<# ;%$9

J($, >BPKAL &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#* =) =@#'/#/ AH -J EEID,

Q9# 05U1* %' /#$#(@%'%'? $9# #_%)$#'<# &: =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%.* 9=) = (#=/H )#$ &:

?G%/#8%'#) $& :&88&;* $9# )=@# ?G%/# $9# <&G($) $9#@)#8+#) G)#, Q9# #8#@#'$) $& /#$#(@%'# $9# #_%)$#'<#

&: =' #@.8&H@#'$ (#8=$%&')9%. =(#a K>L $9# )#8#<$%&' ='/ #'?=?#@#'$ &: $9# #@.8&H##[ KBL $9# .=H@#'$ &:

;=?#)[ KIL $9# .&;#( &: /%)@%))=8[ KSL $9# #@.8&H#() .&;#( $& <&'$(&8 $9# #@.8&H##) <&'/G<$,hCi

 Q9# G)# &:

$9%) $#)$ %) '&$ )&8#8H 8%@%$#/ $& $9# 6U-2, Q9# 05U1 4#<(#$=(H* &( 9%) &( 9#( (#.(#)#'$=$%+#)* <=' G$%8%^# $9#)=@# $#)$* #+#' %' $9# <&G()# &: %').#<$%&'* @=\%'? G)# &: $9# )=@# #+%/#'<# $9=$ ;&G8/ 9=+# A##'

.(#)#'$#/ A#:&(# $9# 6U-2,

Q9# /#$#(@%'=$%&' &: $9# #_%)$#'<# &: =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. AH $9# 05U1 @G)$ A#

(#).#<$#/, Q9# #_.='/#/ +%)%$&(%=8 ='/ #':&(<#@#'$ .&;#( &: $9# 05U1 ?(='$#/ AH -J EEID ;&G8/ A#

(#'/#(#/ 'G?=$&(H %: $9# =88#?#/ #@.8&H#( <&G8/* AH $9# )%@.8# #_.#/%#'$ &: /%).G$%'? $9# #@.8&H#(M

#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%.* :&(<# $9# (#:#((=8 &: $9# @=$$#( $& $9# 6U-2, Q9# 2&G($ %))G#/ $9# /#<8=(=$%&' $9=$

=$ 8#=)$ = $,&45 95;&( )9&;%'? &: $9# =A)#'<# &: =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. A# @=/# $& &G)$ $9#

05U1 &: `G(%)/%<$%&', OG$ %$ %) .(#<%)#8H $9# 05U1 $9=$ ;%88 A# :=<#/ ;%$9 $9=$ #+%/#'<#* ='/ %$ %) $9# 05U1

$9=$ ;%88 ;#%?9 %$* $& )## %: $9# )=@# /&#) )G<<#)):G88H (#:G$# $9# #_%)$#'<# &: =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H##(#8=$%&')9%.,

3: $9# 05U1 @=\#) = :%'/%'? $9=$ $9#(# %) =' #_%)$%'? #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%.* %$ $=\#)

<&?'%^='<# &: $9# @=$$#(* $& $9# #_<8G)%&' &: $9# 6U-2, Q9# 05U1 ;&G8/ 9=+# '& `G(%)/%<$%&' &'8H %: $9#

#@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. 9=) =8(#=/H A##' $#(@%'=$#/* &( %$ =..#=()* G.&' (#+%#;* $9=$ '&

#@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. #_%)$#/ %' $9# :%()$ .8=<#,

Q9# 2&G($* %' 8%@%$%'? $9# .&;#( &: $9# 05U1* ?=+# $9# (=$%&'=8# $9=$ )G<9 8%@%$=$%&' ;&G8/

#8%@%'=$# $9# .(&).#<$ &: <&@.#$%'? <&'<8G)%&') A#$;##' $9# 05U1 ='/ $9# 6U-2, Q9# .(&).#<$ &:

<&@.#$%'? <&'<8G)%&') <&G8/ `G)$ =) ;#88 9=+# A##' #8%@%'=$#/ AH =<<&(/%'? (#).#<$ $& $9# 05U1 :%'/%'?)*

$& $9# #_<8G)%&' &: $9# 6U-2* ='/ $9%) 7# A#8%#+# %) $9# @&(# .(G/#'$ <&G()# &: =<$%&' $& $=\#,

Q9%) %) '&$ $& )=H $9=$ $9# /#$#(@%'=$%&' AH $9# 05U1 %) A#H&'/ ]G#)$%&' &( (#+%#;, 4G::%<# %$ $& )=H*

$9#(# =(# `G/%<%=8 (#@#/%#) )G<9 =) = .#$%$%&' :&( <#($%&(=(% G'/#( -G8# TR $9=$ @=H A# =+=%8#/ &:* )9&G8/ =

.=($H ;%)9 $& /%).G$# $9# :%'/%'?) &: $9# 05U1,

3$ @G)$ =8)& A# (#@#@A#(#/ $9=$ $9# .&;#( &: $9# 05U1 $& /#$#(@%'# $9# #_%)$#'<# &: ='

#@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. '##/ '&$ '#<#))=(%8H (#)G8$ %' =' =::%(@=$%+# :%'/%'?, Q9# 05U1 @=H ;#88

@=\# $9# /#$#(@%'=$%&' $9=$ '& #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. #_%)$)* $9G) /%+#)$%'? %$)#8: &: `G(%)/%<$%&'

&+#( $9# <=)#, 3$ @G)$ '&$ A# .(#<8G/#/ :(&@ A#%'? =A8# $& (#=<9 %$) &;' <&'<8G)%&')* '&$ AH $9# .=($%#)*

='/ <#($=%'8H '&$ AH $9%) 2&G($,

Y'/#( J($, >BPKAL &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#* =) =@#'/#/ AH -J EEID* $9# 05U1 %) :G88H #@.&;#(#/ $&

@=\# = /#$#(@%'=$%&' =) $& $9# #_%)$#'<# &: =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. %' $9# #_#(<%)# &: %$)

+%)%$&(%=8 ='/ #':&(<#@#'$ .&;#(* )GA`#<$ $& `G/%<%=8 (#+%#;* '&$ (#+%#; AH $9# 6U-2,

Page 108: LabRel Cases Batch 1

7/21/2019 LabRel Cases Batch 1

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/labrel-cases-batch-1 108/108

 

Q9#(# %) = +%#; $9=$ /#).%$# J($, >BPKAL &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#* =) =@#'/#/ AH -J EEID* $9#(# %) )$%88 =

$9(#)9&8/ =@&G'$ )#$ AH J($), >BC ='/ B>E &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# ;9#' @&'#H <8=%@) =(# %'+&8+#/* %,#,* $9=$ %:

%$ %) :&( "9" R*DDD ='/ A#8&;* $9# `G(%)/%<$%&' %) ;%$9 $9# (#?%&'=8 /%(#<$&( &: $9# 05U1* G'/#( J($, >BC* ='/

%: $9# =@&G'$ %'+&8+#/ #_<##/) "9" R*DDD* $9# `G(%)/%<$%&' %) ;%$9 $9# 8=A&( =(A%$#(* G'/#( J($, B>E,Q9#

+%#; )$=$#) $9=$ /#).%$# $9# ;&(/%'? &: J($, >BPKAL* $9%) ;&G8/ &'8H =..8H %' $9# <&G()# &: (#?G8=(

%').#<$%&') G'/#($=\#' AH $9# 05U1* =) /%::#(#'$%=$#/ :(&@ <=)#) G'/#( J($), >BC ='/ B>E* ;9%<9 &(%?%'=$#

:(&@ <&@.8=%'$), Q9#(# =(# )#+#(=8 <=)#)* 9&;#+#(* ;9#(# $9# 2&G($ 9=) (G8#/ $9=$ J($, >BPKAL 9=) A##'=@#'/#/ $& #_.='/ $9# .&;#() &: $9# 05U1 4#<(#$=(H ='/ 9%) /G8H =G$9&(%^#/ (#.(#)#'$=$%+#) AH -J

EEID, 3' $9#)# <=)#)* $9# 2&G($ (#)&8+#/ $9=$ $9# 05U1 9=/ $9# `G(%)/%<$%&'* /#).%$# $9# =@&G'$ &: $9#

@&'#H <8=%@) %'+&8+#/, XG($9#(@&(#* %' $9#)# <=)#)* $9# %').#<$%&' 9#8/ AH $9# 05U1 (#?%&'=8 /%(#<$&( ;=)

.(&@.$#/ ).#<%:%<=88H AH = <&@.8=%'$, Q9#(#:&(#* $9# %'%$%=$%&' &: = <=)# $9(&G?9 = <&@.8=%'$ /&#) '&$

/%+#)$ $9# 05U1 4#<(#$=(H &( 9%) /G8H =G$9&(%^#/ (#.(#)#'$=$%+# &: `G(%)/%<$%&' G'/#( J($, >BPKAL,

Q& (#<=.%$G8=$#* %: = <&@.8=%'$ %) A(&G?9$ A#:&(# $9# 05U1 $& ?%+# #::#<$ $& $9# 8=A&( )$='/=(/)

.(&+%)%&') &: $9# U=A&( 2&/# &( &$9#( 8=A&( 8#?%)8=$%&'* ='/ $9#(# %) = :%'/%'? AH $9# 05U1 $9=$ $9#(# %) ='

#_%)$%'? #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%.* $9# 05U1 #_#(<%)#) `G(%)/%<$%&' $& $9# #_<8G)%&' &: $9# 6U-2,3:

$9# 05U1 :%'/) $9=$ $9#(# %) '& #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%.* $9# `G(%)/%<$%&' %) .(&.#(8H ;%$9 $9#6U-2, 3: = <&@.8=%'$ %) :%8#/ ;%$9 $9# 05U1* ='/ %$ %) =<<&@.='%#/ AH = <8=%@ :&( (#%')$=$#@#'$* $9#

 `G(%)/%<$%&' %) .(&.#(8H ;%$9 $9# U=A&( J(A%$#(* G'/#( J($, B>EKIL &: $9# U=A&( 2&/#* ;9%<9 .(&+%/#) $9=$ $9#

U=A&( J(A%$#( 9=) &(%?%'=8 ='/ #_<8G)%+# `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( $9&)# <=)#) %'+&8+%'? ;=?#)* (=$#) &: .=H* 9&G() &:

;&(\* ='/ &$9#( $#(@) ='/ <&'/%$%&') &: #@.8&H@#'$* %: =<<&@.='%#/ AH = <8=%@ :&( (#%')$=$#@#'$, 3: =

<&@.8=%'$ %) :%8#/ ;%$9 $9# 6U-2* ='/ $9#(# %) )$%88 =' #_%)$%'? #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%.* $9#

 `G(%)/%<$%&' %) .(&.#(8H ;%$9 $9# 05U1, Q9# :%'/%'?) &: $9# 05U1* 9&;#+#(* @=H )$%88 A# ]G#)$%&'#/ $9(&G?9

= .#$%$%&' :&( <#($%&(=(% G'/#( -G8# TR &: $9# -G8#) &: 2&G($,

3' $9# .(#)#'$ <=)#* $9# :%'/%'? &: $9# 05U1 -#?%&'=8 0%(#<$&( $9=$ $9#(# ;=) =' #@.8&H#(M

#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. 9=) A##' )GA`#<$#/ $& (#+%#; AH $9%) 2&G($* ;%$9 $9# :%'/%'? A#%'? $9=$ $9#(# ;=) '&#@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. A#$;##' .#$%$%&'#( ='/ .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$* A=)#/ &' $9# #+%/#'<#

.(#)#'$#/, "(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ .(#)#'$#/ )#8:M)#(+%'? =88#?=$%&') =) ;#88 =) )#8:M/#:#=$%'? #+%/#'<#,h>Di

Q9#

:%'/%'?) &: $9# -#?%&'=8 0%(#<$&( ;#(# '&$ A=)#/ &' )GA)$='$%=8 #+%/#'<#* ='/ .(%+=$# (#).&'/#'$ :=%8#/ $&

.(&+# $9# #_%)$#'<# &: =' #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%., Q9# 05U1 9=/ '& `G(%)/%<$%&' &+#( $9# <=)#* =)

$9#(# ;=) '& #@.8&H#(M#@.8&H## (#8=$%&')9%. .(#)#'$, Q9G)* $9# /%)@%))=8 &: $9# <&@.8=%'$ =?=%')$

.#$%$%&'#( %) .(&.#(,

=9%&%6+&%* $9# 0#<%)%&' &: $9%) 2&G($ %' N,-, 6&, >ECTRB %) 9#(#AH (66#&.%7* ;%$9