kuliah 7 ahp cartoon.pptx

7/24/2019 kuliah 7 AHP Cartoon.pptx

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kuliah-7-ahp-cartoonpptx 1/53

1

Kuliah ke-7

1. Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP)

2. Consistency Ratio (CR)



2

AN ILL!"RA"#$ %I$#"& "H#

ANALYTIC HIERARCHY PROCESS

"H# ANAL'"IC !CI#NC#! C&RP&RA"I&N

5001 Baum Blvd.

Suite 650

Pittsburgh, PA 15213412.682.3844

www.exert!h"i!e.!"m



$& '&R $#CI!I&N C&N#R#NC#! "RN &" LIK# "HI! *

+# +AN"PR&%RA, A

"&& A$+# +AN"

PR&%RA,

&R $&#! "HI! HAPP#N*

C&,# &N IN "H# +A"#R I!

IN#

!#A & IN$#CI!I&N



/

" &!!..."HA" +A! ,'

#!" %#!!

%#!! A%AIN

$& '&R R#C&,,#N$A"I&N!"RN &" LIK# "HI!*

,A'# '& N##$ AN#+ APPR&ACH



0

I "HINK I LL "R' "H#ANAL'"IC HI#RARCH'

PR&C#!! (AHP)



&KA' "#LL !A&" AHP

$R "H&,A! L.!AA"' $#3#L&P#$"H# PR&C#!! IN"H# #ARL' 14756!

AN$...



"H# PR&C#!! HA! ##N !#$ "&A!!I!" N,#R&! C&RP&RA"# AN$%&3#RN,#N" $#CI!I&N ,AK#R!.

"H# IN&R,A"I&N I! "H#N!'N"H#!I#$ "& $#"#R,IN#R#LA"I3# RANKIN%! &AL"#RNA"I3#!

IN&R,A"I&N I! $#C&,P&!#$IN"& A HI#RARCH' & CRI"#RIAAN$ AL"#RNA"I3#!

&"H 8ALI"A"I3# AN$8AN"I"A"I3# CRI"#RIA CAN# C&,PAR#$ !IN%IN&R,#$ 9$%,#N"! "&$#RI3# +#I%H"! AN$PRI&RI"I#!


http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kuliah-7-ahp-cartoonpptx 8/53:

"HI! AHP !" !&N$!IN"#R#!"IN%. H&+ A&" AN#;A,PL# & H&+ I" +&RK!.

&KA'< H#R#6! A$#CI!I&N +# AC#IN &R P#R!&NAL

LI3#!



I +AN" "& 'A N#+ CAR



• !"A"# "H# &9#C"I3#= – !#L#C" A N#+ CAR

• $#IN# "H# CRI"#RIA= – !"'L#< R#LIAILI"'< #L #C&N&,'

• PICK "H# AL"#RNA"I3#!= –

CI3IC C&P#< !A"RN C&P#< &R$ #!C&R"<,A$A ,IA"A

AN I,P&R"AN" PAR" & "H# PR&C#!!I! "& ACC&,PLI!H "H#!# "HR## !"#P!

+HA" A&" C&!"*

(# 8I#"< +#6LL "ALK A&" "HA" LA"#R)!K#P"IC-%A"&R



!elect ane> car

!tyle Relia?ilityuel

#cono@y

Ciic

!aturn#scort,iata

Ciic

!aturn#scort,iata

Ciic

!aturn#scort,iata

"HI! IN&R,A"I&N I! "H#N ARRAN%#$ IN AHI#RARCHICAL "R##

&9#C"I3#

CRI"#RIA

AL"#RNA"I3#!



H&+ $& '& $#"#R,IN# "H# R#LA"I3#I,P&R"ANC# & "H# CRI"#RIA*

Here6s one >ay !"'L#

R#LIAILI"'

#L #C&N&,'



H,,<I "HINK R#LIAILI"' I! "H# ,&!"I,P&R"AN" &LL&+#$ ' !"'L# AN$ #L#C&N&,' I! L#A!" I,P&R"AN".

1. R#LIAILI"' I! 2 "I,#! A! I,P&R"AN" A! !"'L#

. R#LIAILI"' I! / "I,#! A! I,P&R"AN" A! #L #C&N&,'

2. !"'L# I! "I,#! A! I,P&R"AN" A! #L #C&N&,'

H#R#6! AN&"H#R +A'=

!# RA"I&! "& 9$%#"H# I,P&R"ANC# & "H#CRI"#RIA< IN PAIR!< "& '&.

R&, "H#!# RA"I&! $#RI3#"H#IR &3#RALL R#LA"I3#I,P&R"ANC#.


http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kuliah-7-ahp-cartoonpptx 14/531/

"H# ANAL'"IC HI#RARCH' PR&C#!!A #""#R +A'

!"'L#

R#LIAILI"'

#L #C&N&,'

!"'L# R#LIAILI"' #L #C&N&,'

1B1 1B2 B1

2B1 1B1 /B1

1B 1B/ 1B1

!IN% PAIR+I!# C&,PARI!&N!< "H# R#LA"I3# I,P&R"ANC# & &N# CRI"#RI&N &3#R AN&"H#R CAN # #;PR#!!#$

1 #8AL ,&$#RA"# 0 !"R&N% 7 3#R' !"R5N% 4 #;"R#,#



!"'L#

R#LIAILI"'

#L #C&N&,'


H&+ $& '& "RN "HI! ,A"RI;IN"& A RANKIN% & CRI"#RIA*

1B1 1B2 B1

2B1 1B1 /B1

1B 1B/ 1B1



#I%#N3#C"&R

$R "H&,A! L. !AA"'< CRR#N"L' +I"H "H# NI3#R!I"' &PI""!R%H< $#,&N!"RA"#$ ,A"H#,A"ICALL' "HA" "H##I%#N3#C"&R !&L"I&N +A! "H# #!" APPR&ACH.

H&+ $& '& %#" A RANKIN% & PRI&RI"I#! R&, APAIR+I!# ,A"RI;*

AN$ "H#!R3#' !A'!

AC"ALL'...

R##R#NC# = "H# ANAL'"IC HI#RARCH' PR&C#!!< 1445< "H&,A! L. !AA"'



17

#6! H&+ "& !&L3# &R "H# #I%#N3#C"&R=

!H&R" C&,P"A"I&NAL +A' "& &"AIN "HI! RANKIN%"& RAI!# "H# PAIR+I!# ,A"RI; "& P&+#R! "HA" AR#CC#!!I3#L' !8AR#$ #ACH "I,#.# R&+ !,! AR# "H#N CALCLA"#$ AN$ N&R,ALI#$.

# C&,P"#R I! IN!"RC"#$ "& !"&P +H#N "H##R#NC# #"+##N "H#!# !,! IN "+& C&N!#C"I3#LCLA"I&N! I! !,ALL#R "HAN A PR#!CRI#$ 3AL#.!A' +HA"

!H&+ ,# AN#;A,PL#



1:

!"'L#

R#LIAILI"'

#L #C&N&,'


1.5555 5.0555 .5555

2.5555 1.5555 /.5555

5. 5.2055 1.5555

&R N&+< L#"6! R#,&3# "H# NA,#! AN$ C&N3#R" "H# RAC"I&N! "& $#CI,AL! =

I"6! ,A"RI; AL%#RA "I,#

1B1 1B2 B1

2B1 1B1 /B1

1B 1B/ 1B1



14

1.5555 5.0555 .5555

2.5555 1.5555 /.5555

5. 5.2055 1.5555

1.5555 5.0555 .5555

2.5555 1.5555 /.5555

5. 5.2055 1.5555

!"#P 1= !8ARIN% "H# ,A"RI;

.5555 1.7055 :.5555

0.2 .5555 1/.5555

1.1 5.7 .5555

"HI! "I,#!

"HI!

R#!L"!IN "HI!

I.#. (1.5555 1.5555) D (5.0555 2.5555) D(.5555 5.) E .5555



25

.5555 D 1.7055 D :.5555

0.2 D .5555 D 1/.5555

1.1 D 5.7 D .5555

!"#P 2 = N&+< L#"6! C&,P"# &R IR!" #I%#N3#C"&R ("& &R $#CI,AL PLAC#!)

E 12.7055 5.14/

E 22.2 5.0040

E /.: 5.1211

4.410 1.5555

IR!"< +# !, "H# R&+!

!#C&N$< +# !, "H# R&+ "&"AL!

INALL'< +# N&R,ALI# ' $I3I$IN%"H# R&+ !, ' "H# R&+ "&"AL!

(I.#. 12.7055 $I3I$#$ ' 4.410 #8AL! 5.14/)5.14/ 5.0040

5.1211

"H# R#!L" I! &R #I%#N3#C"&R( A LA"#R !LI$# +ILL #;PLAIN "H#,#ANIN% IN "#R,! & &R #;A,PL#)



21

"HI! PR&C#!! ,!" # I"#RA"#$ N"IL "H# #I%#N3#C"&R!&L"I&N $&#! N&" CHAN%# R&, "H# PR#3I&! I"#RA"I&N(R#,#,#R "& &R $#CI,AL PLAC#! IN &R #;A,PL#)

.5555 1.7055 :.5555

0.2 .5555 1/.5555

1.1 5.7 .5555

27.0 10.:5 72./4:/

/:.11 27.2 12./2

15.00/7 .5/1/ 27.0

C&N"ININ% &R #;A,PL#<A%AIN< !"#P 1= +# !8AR# "HI! ,A"RI;

+I"H "HI! R#!L"



22

27.0 D 10.:5 D 72./4:/

/:.11 D 27.2 D 12./2

15.00/7 D .5/1/ D 27.0

E 110.447 5.14

E 252.10 5.00:/

E //.21/ 5.1225

2.414 1.5555

A%AIN !"#P 2 = C&,P"# "H# #I%#N3#C"&R ("& &R $#CI,AL PLAC#!)

"&"AL!C&,P"# "H# $I#R#NC# & "H# PR#3I&! C&,P"#$ #I%#N3#C"&R"& "HI! &N#=

5.14

5.00:/

5.1225

5.14/

5.0040

5.1211

E - 5.5552

E 5.5511

E - 5.5554

"& &R $#CI,AL PLAC#! "H#R#6! N&" ,CH $I#R#NC#H&+ A&" &N# ,&R# I"#RA"I&N*



2

I !RR#N$#R $&N6" ,AK# ,# C&,P"#

AN&"H#R #I%#N3#C"&R

&KA'<&KA'AC"ALL'< &N# ,&R#

I"#RA"I&N +&L$ !H&+N& $I#R#NC# "& &R

$#CI,AL PLAC#!

L#"6! N&+ L&&K A""H# ,#ANIN% & "H##I%#N3#C"&R



2/

!"'L#

R#LIAILI"'

#L #C&N&,'


H#R#6! &R PAIR+I!#,A"RI; +I"H "H# NA,#!

5.14

5.00:/

5.1225

!"'L#

R#LIAILI"'

#L #C&N&,'

AN$ "H# C&,P"#$ #I%#N3#C"&R %I3#! ! "H# R#LA"I3#RANKIN% & &R CRI"#RIA

"H# ,&!" I,P&R"AN" CRI"#RI&N

"H# L#A!" I,P&R"AN" CRI"#RI&N

"H# !#C&N$ ,&!" I,P&R"AN" CRI"#RI&N

N&+ ACK "& "H# HI#ARCHICAL "R##...

1B1 1B2 B1

2B1 1B1 /B1

1B 1B/ 1B1



20

!elect a ne>car 1.55

!tyle.14

Relia?ility.00:/

uel #[email protected]

Ciic

!aturn#scort,iata

Ciic

!aturn#scort,iata

Ciic

!aturn#scort,iata

CRI"#RIA

H#R#6! "H# "R##+I"H "H# CRI"#RIA

+#I%H"!

AL"#RNA"I3#!

&9#C"I3#

+HA" A&" "H# AL"#RNA"I3#!*

!K#P"IC-%A"&R

I6, %LA$ '& A!K#$...



2

IN "#R,! & !"'L#< PAIR+I!# C&,PARI!&N!$#"#R,IN#! "H# PR##R#NC#

& #ACH AL"#RNA"I3# &3#R AN&"H#R

CI3IC 1B1 1B/ /B1 1B

!A"RN /B1 1B1 /B1 1B/

#!C&R" 1B/ 1B/ 1B1 1B0

,IA"A B1 /B1 0B1 1B1

CI3IC !A"RN #!C&R" ,IA"A

!"'L#

AN$...



27

IN "#R,! & R#LIAILI"'< PAIR+I!# C&,PARI!&N!$#"#R,IN#! "H# PR##R#NC#

& #ACH AL"#RNA"I3# &3#R AN&"H#R

CI3IC 1B1 2B1 0B1 1B1

!A"RN 1B2 1B1 B1 2B1

#!C&R" 1B0 1B 1B1 1B/

,IA"A 1B1 1B2 /B1 1B1

CI3IC !A"RN #!C&R" ,IA"A

R#LIAILI"'

I"! ,A"RI; AL%#RA "I,#



2:

C&,P"IN% "H# #I%#N3#C"&R$#"#R,IN#! "H# R#LA"I3#

RANKIN% & A"#RNA"I3#! N$#R#ACH CRI"#RI&N

CI3IC .115

!A"RN .2/75 #!C&R" .555

,IA"A .0775

!"'L#

CI3IC .745

!A"RN .2455 #!C&R" .57/5

,IA"A .2075

R#LIAILI"'

2

/

1

1

2

/

RANKIN% RANKIN%

!K#P"IC-%A"&R

+HA" A&" #L #C&N&,'*

AN&"H#R %&&$ 8#!"I&N...



24

A! !"A"#$ #ARLI#R<AHP CAN C&,IN# &"H 8ALI"A"I3#

AN$ 8ANI"A"I3# IN&R,A"I&N

#L #C&N&,' IN&R,A"I&N I! &"AIN#$ &R #ACHAL"#RNA"I3#=

#L #C&N&,'(,IL#!B%ALL&N)

/ / B 11 E .515

27 27 B 11 E .245

2/ 2/ B 11 E .2125

2: 2: B 11 E .2/:5

11 1.5555

CI3IC

!A"RN

#!C&R"

,IA"A

N&R,ALIIN% "H# #L #C&N&,' IN&

ALL&+! ! "& !# I" +I"H &"H#R RANKIN%!



5

!elect a ne>car 1.55

!tyle.14

Relia?ility.00:/

uel #[email protected]

Ciic .745

!aturn .2455#scort .57/5,iata .2075

Ciic .115

!aturn .2/75#scort .555,iata .0775

Ciic .515

!aturn .245#scort .2125,iata .2/:5

CRI"#RIA

H#R#6! "H# "R##+I"H ALL "H#

+#I%H"!

AL"#RNA"I3#!

&9#C"I3#

&KA'< N&+ +HA" * I "HINK +#6R# R#A$'&R "H# AN!+#R...



1

CI3IC .115

!A"RN .2/75

#!C&R" .555 ,IA"A .0775

!"'L#

.745 .515

.2455 .245

.57/5 .2125 .2075 .2/:5

R#LI-AILI"'

#L#C&N&,'

5.14

5.00:/

5.1225

!"'L#

R#LIAILI"'

#L #C&N&,'

CRI"#RIARANKIN%

I.#. &R "H# CI3IC (.115 .14) D (.745 .00:/) D (.515 .1225) E .55

CI3IC .55

!A"RN .2725 #!C&R" .54/5

,IA"A .2:5

E

A LI""L# ,&R# ,A"RI; AL%#RA %I3#! ! "H# !&L"I&N=

"H# ,IA"A I! "H# HI%H#!" RANK#$ CAR

AN$ "H# +INN#R I!



2

IN !,,AR'< "H# ANAL'"IC HI#RARCH' PR&C#!!PR&3I$#! A L&%ICAL RA,#+&RK "& $#"#R,IN#

"H# #N#I"! & #ACH AL"#RNA"I3#

1. ,IA"A .2:5

2. CI3IC .55

. !A"RN .2725 /. #!C&R" .54/5

!K#P"IC-%A"&R

+HA" A&" C&!"!*

+#LL< I6LL "#LL '&...



AL"H&%H C&!"! C&L$ HA3# ##N INCL$#$<IN ,AN' C&,PL#; $#CI!I&N!< C&!"! !H&L$ #

!#" A!I$# N"IL "H# #N#I"! & "H#AL"#RNA"I3#! AR# #3ALA"#$

&"H#R+I!# "HI! C&L$ HAPP#N...

'&R PR&%RA, C&!" "&& ,CH I$&N6" CAR# A&" I"! #N#I"!

$I!C!!IN% C&!"!"&%#"H#R +I"H #N#I"!CAN !&,#"I,#! RIN% &R"H,AN' P&LI"ICAL AN$#,&"I&NAL R#!P&N!#!



/

+A'! "& HAN$L# #N#I"! AN$C&!"! INCL$# "H# &LL&+IN%=

1. %RAPHIN% #N#I"! AN$ C&!"! & #ACH AL"#RNA"I3#

C&!"!

#N#I"! ..

.

2. #N#I" "& C&!" RA"I&!

. LIN#AR PR&%RA,,IN%

/. !#PARA"# #N#I" AN$ C&!" HI#RARCHICAL "R##!AN$ "H#N C&,IN# "H# R#!L"!

CH&!# AL"#RNA"I3# +I"H L&+#!"C&!" AN$ HI%H#!" #N#I"

IN &R #;A,PL#...

.



0

L#"6! !# #N#I" "& C&!" RA"I&!

1. ,IA"A 1:<555 . .2:5 B . E .4:/5

2. CI3IC 12<555 .2222 .55 B .2222 E 1.771

. !A"RN 10<555 .277: .2725 B .277: E .4741

/. #!C&R" 4<555 .17 .54/5 B .17 E .04

0/<555 1.5555

N&R,ALI#$C&!" F C&!"! #N#I" - C&!" RA"I&!

"H# CI3IC I! "H# +INN#R +I"H "H# HI%H#!" #N#I" "& C&!" RA"I&

(R#,#,#R "H# #N#I"! +#R# $#RI3#$#ARLI#R R&, "H# AHP)

AN$...



AHP CAN # !#$ &R 3#R'C&,PL#; $#CI!I&N!

%&AL,AN' L#3#L! & CRI"#RIAAN$ !CRI"#RIA CAN# INCL$#$

H#R#6! !&,# #;A,PL#!



7

AHP CAN # !#$ &R A +I$# 3ARI#"'& APPLICA"I&N!

!"RA"#%IC PLANNIN%

R#!&RC# ALL&CA"I&N

!&RC# !#L#C"I&N

!IN#!!BPLIC P&LIC'

PR&%A, !#L#C"I&N

AN$ ,CH ,CH ,&R#...



:

I $&N6" HA3# "I,# &R ALL"HA" ,A"RI; AL%#RA

A"&,A"#$ "&&L! AR#A3AILAL# "& H#LP '&



4

#;P#R" CH&IC# I! &N# !CH PACKA%#

#;P#R" CH&IC# A"&,A"#! "H#ANAL'"IC HI#RARCH' PR&C#!!

$&#! ALL "H# ,A"H &R '&

'& CAN !A3# AN$ I"#RA"# "H# R#!L"!

'& CAN P#R&R, !#N!I"I3I"' ANAL'!I!

#;P#R" CH&IC# PRIN"! %RAPH! AN$ "AL#!

H&+#3#R< R#,#,#R...



/5

I ,AK# "H# $#CI!I&N! AR&N$ H#R#

A%%H

"H# ANAL'"IC HI#RARCH' PR&C#!!I! N&" "HI!



/1

AHP I! A L&%ICAL +A' &R P#&PL#"& ,AK# $#CI!I&N!

AHP IL$! C&N!#N!!

PR&3I$#! AN A$I" "RAIL

CAN # I"#RA"#$

AN$ I"! N



/2

I '&6R# H&&K#$H#R#6! !&,# &&K!

&R R"H#R R#A$IN% I LIK# AHP

AN$ +I"H ALL "HI! KN&+L#$%#

'& +ILL # AL# "&...

$#CI!I&N ,AKIN% &R L#A$#R!<1445< "H&,A! L. !AA"'(3#R' %&&$ &&K & CA!# !"$I#!)

"H# ANAL'"IC HI#RARCH' PR&C#!!<1445< "H&,A! L. !AA"'(AN IN$!"RIAL !"R#N%"H ,A"H &&K)

"H# HI#RARCH&N< A $IC"I&NAR'& HI#RARCHI#!< 144< "H&,A! L. !AA"'

AN$ #RN#!" H. &R,AN(A H%# &R#!" & HI#RARCHICAL "R##!)



/

ANAL'"ICHI#RARCH'PR&C#!!

L' &3#R IN$#CI!I&N

I HA"# AHP

!#A & IN$#CI!I&N

"H# #N$



//

Rasio Konsistensi

baha# dari materi $uliah Pr"% &arimi#



/045

,e@ilih Ko@Guter 1.55

Ko@Gati?il

5.14

nuk

kera

5.00:/

Purna ual

5.1225

• I, (5.115)

• AC#R (5.2/75)

• HG (5.555)

• Co@Ga (5.0755)

• I, (5.745)

• AC#R (5.2455)

• HG (5.57/5)

• Co@Ga (5.2075)

• I, (5.515)

• AC#R (5.245)

• HP (5.2125)

• Co@Ga (5.2/:5)

%a@?ar = Hasil Akhir !eluruh o?ot



/46

$ari hasil analisa Ji atas< @aka a>a?an JaGat kita Geroleh

Jenan alan @enalikan @atrik nilai eien Jari alternati Jenan

@atrik ?o?ot @atrik=

'"matibilita

s

(#)u$

$er)a

Pur#a)ual B"b"t 'riteria

*B& 0.1160 0.3+0 0.3010 0.316

A-/ 0.24+0 0.200 0.230 0.5584

0.0600 0.0+40 0.2120 0.1220

-"ma! 0.5++0 0.25+0 0.2480



/747

Hasilnya =

I,

Acer

HG

Co@Ga

= 5.55

= 5.2725

= 5.54/5

= 5.2:5

9aJi rankin yan JiGeroleh =

Co@Ga = 5.2:5

I, = 5.55

Acer = 5.2725

HG = 5.54/5



/:48

Consistency Ratio (CR)

Consistency Ratio @eruGakan Gara@eter yan Jiunakan untuk

@e@eriksa aGakah Ger?anJinan ?erGasanan telah JilakukanJenan kosek>en atau tiJak.

CR ME 5.1 = Konsisten

5.1 M CR ME 5.10 Aak Konsisten

CR 5.10 "iJak Konsisten

Kasus !ensiti=

CR ME 5.1 = Konsisten

CR 5.1 = "iJak Konsisten



/449

Consistency Ration (CR)

Consistency Ratio @eruGakan Gara@eter yan Jiunakan untuk

@e@eriksa aGakah Ger?anJinan ?erGasanan telah JilakukanJenan kosek>en atau tiJak.

!e?aai @isal untuk Kriteria Ko@Gati?ilitas

'"matibilitas *B& A-/ -"ma

*B& 11 14 41 16

A-/ 41 11 41 14

14 14 11 15

-"ma 61 41 51 11



0550

$ari nilai aktor (nilai eien) Jari kriteria ko@Gati?ilitas aJalah=

I,

Acer

HG

Co@Ga

= 5.115

= 5.2/75

= 5.555

= 5.0775

Kita JaGat +eihteJ !u@ 3ector Jenan alan @enalikan ke Jua

@atrik ts?.

11 14 41 16 0.1160 0.513

41 11 41 14 0.24+0 1.053

14 14 11 15 0.0600 0.2662

61 41 51 11 0.5++0 2.5610



0151

Ke@uJian kita @enhitun Consistency 3ector Jenan

@enentukan nilai rata-rata Jari >eihteJ su@ ector=

5.014 B 5.115 /./5

1.540 B 5.2/75 /.//2

5.22 B 5.555 E/./0:

2.015 B 5.0775 /./:0Nilai rata-rata Jari Consistency 3ector aJalah =

E (/./5 D /.//2 D /./0: D /./:0) B / E /.//7

Nilai Consistency InJeO JaGat Jihitun Jenan @enunakan

ru@us =

CI E (

- n) B (n 1) Q n = ?anyak alternati

E (/.//7 /) B (/ 1)

E 5.1//4



0252

ntuk @enhitun Consistency Ratio< Ji?utuhkan nilai RI< yaitu

RanJo@ InJeO yan JiJaGat Jari ta?el ?erikut=

# /*

2 0.00

3 0.58

4 0.05 1.12

6 1.24

+ 1.32

8 1.41



Nilai Consistency Ratio Jari Ger@asalahan Ji atas< Jenan nE/

JiGeroleh nilai RI E 5.45 < aJalah se?esar

CR E CI B RI

E 5<1//4B5<4

E 5<11

Karena CR 5<10 @aka Jisi@Gulkan ?ah>a @asih terJaGat

Genilaian kriteria kinera yan kurang konsisten.

kuliah 7 ahp cartoon.pptx

Documents