kleffman v. vonage (california supreme court) - response to brief of amici curiae

66
S169195 In the Supreme Court of California CRAIG E. KLEFFMAN, Plaintiff and Appellant, v. VONAGE HOLDINGS CORP., a New Jersey Corporation, et aI., Defendants and Appellants. On Request Pursuant to California Rules of Court, Rule 8.548, that this Court Decide a Question of California Law Presented in a Matter Pending in the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit PLAINTIFF-APPEL LANT'S ANSWER TO BRIEF OF AMICUS CURIAE EMAIL SENDER AND PROVIDER COALITION AND V ALUECLICK, INC. IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS-APPELLANTS SHAPIRO LLP. STEVE W. BERMAN 1301 FIFTH AVENUE, SUITE 2900 SEATTLE, WASHINGTON 98101 . (206) 623-7292 · FAX (206) 623-0594 steve~hbssiaw.com HAGENS BERMN SOBOL SHAPIROLLP REED R. KATHREIN (SBN 139304) ELAINE T. BYSZEWSKI (SBN 222304) 700 SOUTH FLOWER ST., SUITE 2940 Los ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90017 (213) 330-7150 · FAX (213) 330-7152 reed~hbssiaw.com eiaine~hbssiaw .com Attorneys for Plaintiff and Petitioner Craig E. Kleffman

Upload: venkat-balasubramani

Post on 30-May-2018

220 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 1/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 2/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 3/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 4/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 5/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 6/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 7/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 8/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 9/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 10/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 11/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 12/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 13/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 14/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 15/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 16/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 17/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 18/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 19/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 20/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 21/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 22/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 23/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 24/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 25/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 26/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 27/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 28/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 29/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 30/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 31/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 32/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 33/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 34/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 35/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 36/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 37/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 38/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 39/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 40/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 41/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 42/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 43/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 44/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 45/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 46/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 47/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 48/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 49/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 50/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 51/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 52/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 53/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 54/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 55/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 56/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 57/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 58/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 59/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 60/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 61/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 62/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 63/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 64/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 65/66

8/9/2019 Kleffman v. Vonage (California Supreme Court) - Response to brief of Amici Curiae

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kleffman-v-vonage-california-supreme-court-response-to-brief-of-amici 66/66