kerr - how to read a legal opinion

8/13/2019 Kerr - How to Read a Legal Opinion

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerr-how-to-read-a-legal-opinion 1/16

Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1160925

!"#$%& !"()"* + ,-.-/% 0112 3$4-/" 55 + 6-/7"( 5

Published by The Green Bag, Inc., in cooperation with the George Mason University School of Law.

HOW TO READ A LEGAL OPINION

A GUIDE FOR NEW LAW STUDENTS

Orin S. Kerr

Copyright © 2007 Orin S. Kerr



Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1160925

!! "#$$% &'" () *!

+,- ., #$') ' /$"'/ ,01%1,%

' "21)$ 3,# %$- /'- 4.2)$%.4 !"#$ &' ()"" *

+,#- )--./ #- 0)-#1$)0 23 ,)45 $)6 4.6 -270)$2- 5")5.") 83" 2,)

8#"-2 8)6 6))9- 38 :4.--' ;2 )<54.#$- 6,.2 =70#:#.4 35#$#3$- .")>

,36 2,)/ .") -2"7:27")0> .$0 6,.2 4.6 -270)$2- -,3740 4339

83" 6,)$ ").0#$1 2,)?'

15 -+'.64 1% ' /$"'/ ,01%1,%7 !"# %&' ("'()" *+,-./"" -#* %!-% *+,-./""0"#% )"-*, %' -)-&,1+%2 %!" )-&,1+% &+)) ,'0"%+0", "#* &+%! - /1)+#. 34 -

51*." +# 6-7'/ '6 '#" ,+*"8 9!" 51*." &+)) ":()-+# %!" /1)+#. +# -&/+%%"# *';10"#% /"6"//"* %' -, -# <'(+#+'#8= 9!" '(+#+'# ":()-+#,&!-% %!" ;-," +, -3'1%2 *+,;1,,", %!" /")"7-#% )".-) (/+#;+()",2 -#*%!"# -(()+", %!" )-& %' %!" 6-;%, %' /"-;! - /1)+#. +# 6-7'/ '6 '#" ,+*"-#* -.-+#,% %!" '%!"/8

>'*"/# 51*+;+-) '(+#+'#, /"6)";% !1#*/"*, '6 4"-/, '6 !+,%'/4 -#*

(/-;%+;"8 9!"4 1,1-))4 6'))'& - ,+0()" -#* (/"*+;%-3)" 6'/01)-8 9!+,

? !"#$ ()"" #- . 5"38)--3" 38 4.6 .2 2,) @)3"1) A.-,#$123$ B$#C)"-#2/ D.6 &:,334' +,#- )--./

:.$ E) 8"))4/ 0#-2"#E72)0 83" $3$F:3??)":#.4 7-)- 7$0)" 2,) G").2#C) G3??3$- H22"#E72#3$F

I3$G3??)":#.4FI3J)"#C- K'L B$53"2)0 4#:)$-)' M3" 2,) 2)"?- 38 2,) 4#:)$-)> C#-#2 :").2#C)F

:3??3$-'3"1N4#:)$-)-NE/F$:F$0NK'LN4)1.4:30)'

@



!"#$ %& '(""

*( !! "#$$% &'" ()

,";%+'# %-A", 4'1 %!/'1.! %!" 3-,+; 6'/01)-8 B% ,%-/%, &+%! %!" +#%/'C

*1;%'/4 0-%"/+-), -% %!" %'( '6 -# '(+#+'# -#* %!"# 0'7", '# %' %!" 3'*4 '6 %!" '(+#+'#8

)*( +,-.#/$ 9!" 6+/,% (-/% '6 %!" ;-," +, %!" %+%)" '6 %!" ;-,"2 A#'&# -, %!" <;-(C%+'#8= D:-0()", +#;)1*" O"36$ C' O3."0 38 P07:.2#3$ -#* Q#".$0. C'

H"#R3$.8 9!" ;-(%+'# 1,1-))4 %")), 4'1 %!" )-,% #-0", '6 %!" ("/,'#&!' 3/'1.!% %!" )-&,1+% -#* %!" ("/,'# &!' +, 3"+#. ,1"*8 9!","

%&' ,+*", -/" '6%"# /"6"//"* %' -, %!" <(-/%+",= '/ -, %!" <)+%+.-#%,= +#%!" ;-,"8 E'/ ":-0()"2 +6 >,8 F0+%! ,1", >/8 G'#",2 %!" ;-," ;-(%+'#0-4 3" &?#2, C' S3$)- H'/2 *"("#*+#. '# %!" ;'1/%2 S3$)- C' &?#2,I8

B# ;/+0+#-) )-&2 ;-,", -/" 3/'1.!% 34 .'7"/#0"#% (/',";1%'/, '# 3"!-)6 '6 %!" .'7"/#0"#% +%,")68 9!+, 0"-#, %!-% %!" .'7"/#0"#% +,%!" #-0"* (-/%48 E'/ ":-0()"2 +6 %!" 6"*"/-) .'7"/#0"#% ;!-/.", G'!# J'" &+%! - ;/+0"2 %!" ;-," ;-(%+'# &+)) 3" B$#2)0 &2.2)- C' J3)8

B6 - ,%-%" 3/+#., %!" ;!-/.", +#,%"-*2 %!" ;-(%+'# &+)) 3"&2.2) C' J3)

2T)354) C' J3)2 '/ G3??3$6).42, C' J3)2 *"("#*+#. '# %!" (/-;%+;", '6%!-% ,%-%"8K

)*( +,0( +#.,.#/$ L")'& %!" ;-," #-0" 4'1 &+)) 6+#* ,'0" )"%%"/, -#* #103"/,8 9!",")"%%"/, -#* #103"/, -/" %!" )".-) ;+%-%+'# 6'/ %!" ;-,"8 M ;+%-%+'#%")), 4'1 %!" #-0" '6 %!" ;'1/% %!-% *";+*"* %!" ;-,"2 %!" )-& 3''A

+# &!+;! %!" '(+#+'# &-, (13)+,!"*2 -#* %!" 4"-/ +# &!+;! %!" ;'1/%*";+*"* %!" ;-,"8 E'/ ":-0()"2 <N8F8 F1(/"0" O'1/%2 PQR N8F8 SRTHKTQQI= /"6"/, %' - N8F8 F1(/"0" O'1/% ;-," *";+*"* +# KTQQ %!-%-(("-/, +# U')10" PQR '6 %!" B$#2)0 &2.2)- U)53"2- ,%-/%+#. -% (-."SRT8

)*( 12.*/" /3 .*( !-#$#/$ 9!" #":% +#6'/0-%+'# +, %!" #-0" '6 %!" 51*." &!' &/'%" %!" '(+#C

+'#8 >',% '(+#+'#, -,,+.#"* +# )-& ,;!'') &"/" +,,1"* 34 ;'1/%,

K D#.)+,! ;/+0+#-) ;-,", #'/0-))4 &+)) 3" U)< C' J3) '/ U)1#$. C' J3)8 V": -#*V".+#- -/"#W% %!" 7+;%+0,X %!" &'/*, -/" Y-%+# 6'/ <Z+#.= -#* <[1""#8= J1/+#.%!" /"+.# '6 - Z+#.2 D#.)+,! ;'1/%, 1," <V":=\ *1/+#. %!" /"+.# '6 - [1""#2 %!"4,&+%;! %' <V".+#-8=



4/5 ./ 6(,7 , 8(9,: !-#$#/$

'2.28% (99: *;

&+%! 01)%+()" 51*.",8 9!" #-0" %")), 4'1 &!+;! 51*." &/'%" %!-%

(-/%+;1)-/ '(+#+'#8 B# ')*"/ ;-,",2 %!" '(+#+'# '6%"# ,+0()4 ,%-%", -)-,% #-0" 6'))'&"* 34 %!" +#+%+-) <G8= ]'2 51*.", *'#W% -)) !-7" %!"6+/,% +#+%+-) <G8= 9!" )"%%"/ ,%-#*, 6'/ <G1*."= '/ <G1,%+;"2= *"("#*+#.'# %!" ;'1/%8 ^# ';;-,+'#2 %!" '(+#+'# &+)) 1," %!" Y-%+# (!/-,"<("/ ;1/+-0= +#,%"-* '6 - 51*."W, #-0"8 _"/ ;1/+-0 0"-#, <34 %!";'1/%8= B% ,+.#-), %!-% %!" '(+#+'# /"6)";%, - ;'00'# 7+"& -0'#. -))%!" 51*.", /-%!"/ %!-# %!" &/+%+#., '6 - ,(";+6+; 51*."8

)*( ;,<.0 /3 .*( +,0( ]'& )"%W, 0'7" '# %' %!" '(+#+'# +%,")68 9!" 6+/,% (-/% '6 %!" 3'*4'6 %!" '(+#+'# (/","#%, %!" 6-;%, '6 %!" ;-,"8 B# '%!"/ &'/*,2 &!-%!-(("#"*` 9!" 6-;%, 0+.!% 3" %!-% M#*4 (1))"* '1% - .1# -#* ,!'%L'38 ^/ 0-43" E/"* -./""* %' .+7" F-))4 aKbb -#* %!"# ;!-#."* !+,0+#*8 F1/(/+,+#.)42 %!"/" -/" #' (-/%+;1)-/ /1)", 6'/ &!-% 6-;%, - 51*." 01,% +#;)1*" +# %!" 6-;% ,";%+'# '6 -# '(+#+'#8 F'0"%+0", %!"

6-;% ,";%+'#, -/" )'#.2 -#* ,'0"%+0", %!"4 -/" ,!'/%8 F'0"%+0",%!"4 -/" ;)"-/ -#* -;;1/-%"2 -#* '%!"/ %+0", %!"4 -/" 7-.1" '/ +#C;'0()"%"8

>',% *+,;1,,+'#, '6 %!" 6-;%, -),' ;'7"/ %!" <(/';"*1/-) !+,%'/4='6 %!" ;-,"8 9!" (/';"*1/-) !+,%'/4 ":()-+#, !'& %!" )".-) *+,(1%"&'/A"* +%, &-4 %!/'1.! %!" )".-) ,4,%"0 %' %!" ;'1/% %!-% +, +,,1+#.%!" '(+#+'#8 B% &+)) +#;)1*" 7-/+'1, 0'%+'#,2 !"-/+#.,2 -#* %/+-), %!-%

';;1//"* -6%"/ %!" ;-," &-, +#+%+-))4 6+)"*8 c'1/ ;+7+) (/';"*1/" ;)-,,+, -)) -3'1% %!-% A+#* '6 ,%166\ 4'1 ,!'1)* (-4 7"/4 ;)'," -%%"#%+'# %'%!" (/';"*1/-) !+,%'/4 '6 ;-,", &!"# 4'1 /"-* -,,+.#0"#%, 6'/ 4'1/;+7+) (/';"*1/" ;)-,,8 9!" (/';"*1/-) !+,%'/4 '6 ;-,", 1,1-))4 &+)) 3")",, +0('/%-#% &!"# 4'1 /"-* - ;-," 6'/ 4'1/ '%!"/ ;)-,,",8

)*( 8,5 /3 .*( +,0( M6%"/ %!" '(+#+'# (/","#%, %!" 6-;%,2 +% &+)) %!"# *+,;1,, %!" )-&8>-#4 '(+#+'#, (/","#% %!" )-& +# %&' ,%-.",8 9!" 6+/,% ,%-." *+,C;1,,", %!" ."#"/-) (/+#;+()", '6 )-& %!-% -/" /")"7-#% %' ;-,", ,1;! -,%!" '#" %!" ;'1/% +, *";+*+#.8 9!+, ,";%+'# 0+.!% ":()'/" %!" !+,%'/4'6 - (-/%+;1)-/ 6+")* '6 )-& '/ 0-4 +#;)1*" - *+,;1,,+'# '6 (-,% ;-,",HA#'&# -, <(/";"*"#%,=I %!-% -/" /")-%"* %' %!" ;-," %!" ;'1/% +, *"C



!"#$ %& '(""

*< !! "#$$% &'" ()

;+*+#.8 9!+, (-/% '6 %!" '(+#+'# .+7", %!" /"-*"/ 3-;A./'1#* %' !")(

1#*"/,%-#* %!" ;'#%":% -#* ,+.#+6+;-#;" '6 %!" ;'1/%W, *";+,+'#8 9!",";'#* ,%-." '6 %!" )".-) ,";%+'# -(()+", %!" ."#"/-) )".-) (/+#;+()",%' %!" (-/%+;1)-/ 6-;%, '6 %!" *+,(1%"8 M, 4'1 0+.!% .1",,2 %!+, (-/% +,+# 0-#4 &-4, %!" !"-/% '6 %!" '(+#+'#X B% ."%, %' %!" 3'%%'0 )+#" '6&!4 %!" ;'1/% +, /1)+#. 6'/ '#" ,+*" -#* -.-+#,% %!" '%!"/8

+/$<2""#$9 ,$7=/" >#00($.#$9 !-#$#/$0 >',% '6 %!" '(+#+'#, 4'1 /"-* -, - )-& ,%1*"#% -/" <0-5'/+%4= '(+#C

+'#,8 @!"# - ./'1( '6 51*.", ."% %'."%!"/ %' *";+*" - ;-,"2 %!"47'%" '# &!+;! ,+*" ,!'1)* &+# -#* -),' %/4 %' -./"" '# - )".-) /-C%+'#-)" %' ":()-+# &!4 %!-% ,+*" !-, &'#8 M 0-5'/+%4 '(+#+'# +, -#'(+#+'# 5'+#"* 34 %!" 0-5'/+%4 '6 51*.", '# %!-% ;'1/%8 M)%!'1.!0',% *";+,+'#, -/" 1#-#+0'1,2 ,'0" ;-,", -/" #'%8 F'0" 51*.",0-4 *+,-./"" -#* &+)) &/+%" - ,"(-/-%" '(+#+'# '66"/+#. - *+66"/"#%-((/'-;!8 9!'," '(+#+'#, -/" ;-))"* <;'#;1//+#. '(+#+'#,= '/ <*+,C

,"#%+#. '(+#+'#,2= -#* %!"4 -(("-/ -6%"/ %!" 0-5'/+%4 '(+#+'#8 M<;'#;1//+#. '(+#+'#= H,'0"%+0", 51,% ;-))"* - <;'#;1//"#;"=I ":C()-+#, - 7'%" +# 6-7'/ '6 %!" &+##+#. ,+*" 31% 3-,"* '# - *+66"/"#%)".-) /-%+'#-)"8 M <*+,,"#%+#. '(+#+'#= H,'0"%+0", 51,% ;-))"* - <*+,C,"#%=I ":()-+#, - 7'%" +# 6-7'/ '6 %!" )',+#. ,+*"8

115 =,88,% /$"'/ .$#84 3,2%) 1% ,01%1,%4

'& %!-% 4'1 A#'& &!-%W, +# - )".-) '(+#+'#2 +%W, %+0" %' )"-/#,'0" '6 %!" ;'00'# &'/*, 4'1W)) 6+#* +#,+*" %!"08 L1% 6+/,% -

!+,%'/4 )",,'#2 6'/ /"-,'#, %!-% ,!'1)* 3" ;)"-/ +# - 0+#1%"8B# Kbdd2 @+))+-0 %!" O'#e1"/'/ ;-0" -;/',, %!" D#.)+,! O!-#C

#") 6/'0 &!-% +, #'& E/-#;" -#* ;'#e1"/"* %!" )-#* %!-% +, %'*-4;-))"* D#.)-#*8 9!" ;'#e1"/+#. ]'/0-#, ,('A" E/"#;! -#* %!" *"C

6"-%"* F-:'#, ,('A" ^)* D#.)+,!8 9!" ]'/0-#, %''A '7"/ %!" ;'1/%,4,%"02 -#* %!"+/ )-#.1-." 3";-0" %!" )-#.1-." '6 %!" )-&8 E'/ ,"7C"/-) ;"#%1/+", -6%"/ %!" E/"#;!C,("-A+#. ]'/0-#, %''A '7"/ D#.C)-#*2 )-&4"/, -#* 51*.", +# D#.)+,! ;'1/%, ,('A" +# E/"#;!8 @!"#D#.)+,! ;'1/%, "7"#%1-))4 /"%1/#"* %' 1,+#. D#.)+,!2 %!"4 ;'#%+#1"*%' 1," 0-#4 E/"#;! &'/*,8

]



4/5 ./ 6(,7 , 8(9,: !-#$#/$

'2.28% (99: **

@!4 ,!'1)* 4'1 ;-/" -3'1% %!+, -#;+"#% !+,%'/4` 9!" M0"/+;-#

;')'#+,%, ;'#,+*"/"* %!"0,")7", D#.)+,!0"#2 ,' %!"4 1,"* %!" D#.C)+,! )".-) ,4,%"0 -#* -*'(%"* +%, )-#.1-."8 9!+, 0"-#, %!-% M0"/+C;-# )".-) '(+#+'#, %'*-4 -/" )+%%"/"* &+%! &"+/* E/"#;! %"/0,8 D:C-0()", +#;)1*" ()-+#%+662 *"6"#*-#%2 %'/%2 ;'#%/-;%2 ;/+0"2 51*."2-%%'/#"42 ;'1#,")2 ;'1/%2 7"/*+;%2 (-/%42 -(("-)2 "7+*"#;"2 -#* 51/489!"," &'/*, -/" %!" "7"/4*-4 )-#.1-." '6 %!" M0"/+;-# )".-) ,4,C%"08 M#* %!"4W/" -)) 6/'0 %!" E/"#;!2 3/'1.!% %' 4'1 34 @+))+-0%!" O'#e1"/'/ +# Kbdd8

9!+, 0"-#, %!-% &!"# 4'1 /"-* - )".-) '(+#+'#2 4'1W)) ;'0"-;/',, - )'% '6 6'/"+.#C,'1#*+#. &'/*, %' *",;/+3" %!" ;'1/% ,4,%"08c'1 #""* %' )"-/# -)) '6 %!"," &'/*, "7"#%1-))4\ 4'1 ,!'1)* /"-*;-,", &+%! - )".-) *+;%+'#-/4 #"-/34 -#* ,!'1)* )''A 1( "7"/4 &'/*4'1 *'#W% A#'&8 L1% %!+, ,";%+'# &+)) .+7" 4'1 - !"-* ,%-/% 34 +#%/'C*1;+#. 4'1 %' ,'0" '6 %!" 0',% ;'00'# &'/*,2 0-#4 '6 &!+;!H31% #'% -))I -/" E/"#;! +# '/+.+#8

)?-(0 /3 >#0-2.(0 ,$7 .*( @,A(0 /3 B,".#<#-,$.0 9!"/" -/" %&' 3-,+; A+#*, '6 )".-) *+,(1%",X ;+7+) -#* ;/+0+#-)8 B# -;+7+) ;-,"2 '#" ("/,'# 6+)", - )-&,1+% -.-+#,% -#'%!"/ -,A+#. %!" ;'1/%%' '/*"/ %!" '%!"/ ,+*" %' (-4 !+0 0'#"4 '/ %' *' '/ ,%'( *'+#.,'0"%!+#.8 M# -&-/* '6 0'#"4 +, ;-))"* <*-0-.",= -#* -# '/*"/ %'*' ,'0"%!+#. '/ %' /"6/-+# 6/'0 *'+#. ,'0"%!+#. +, ;-))"* -# <+#C

51#;%+'#8= 9!" ("/,'# 3/+#.+#. %!" )-&,1+% +, A#'&# -, %!" <()-+#%+66=-#* %!" ("/,'# ,1"* +, ;-))"* %!" <*"6"#*-#%8=B# ;/+0+#-) ;-,",2 %!"/" +, #' ()-+#%+66 -#* #' )-&,1+%8 9!" /')" '6

- ()-+#%+66 +, ';;1(+"* 34 - .'7"/#0"#% (/',";1%'/8 B#,%"-* '6 6+)+#.- )-&,1+% H'/ "e1+7-)"#%)42 <,1+#.= ,'0"'#"I2 %!" (/',";1%'/ 6+)",;/+0+#-) <;!-/.",8= B#,%"-* '6 -,A+#. 6'/ *-0-.", '/ -# +#51#;%+'#2%!" (/',";1%'/ -,A, %!" ;'1/% %' (1#+,! %!" +#*+7+*1-) %!/'1.! "+%!"/ 5-+) %+0" '/ - 6+#"8 9!" .'7"/#0"#% (/',";1%'/ +, '6%"# /"6"//"* %'-, <%!" ,%-%"2= <%!" (/',";1%+'#2= '/ ,+0()4 <%!" .'7"/#0"#%8= 9!"("/,'# ;!-/."* +, ;-))"* %!" *"6"#*-#%2 51,% )+A" %!" ("/,'# ,1"* +# -;+7+) ;-,"8

B# )".-) *+,(1%",2 "-;! (-/%4 '/*+#-/+)4 +, /"(/","#%"* 34 - )-&C4"/8 Y".-) '(+#+'#, 1," ,"7"/-) *+66"/"#% &'/*, 6'/ )-&4"/,2 +#;)1*C



!"#$ %& '(""

*> !! "#$$% &'" ()

+#. <-%%'/#"4= -#* <;'1#,")8= 9!"/" -/" ,'0" !+,%'/+;-) *+66"/"#;",

-0'#. %!"," %"/0,2 31% 6'/ %!" )-,% ;"#%1/4 '/ ,' %!"4 !-7" -))0"-#% %!" ,-0" %!+#.8 @!"# - )-&4"/ -**/",,", - 51*." +# ;'1/%2,!" &+)) -)&-4, -**/",, %!" 51*." -, <4'1/ !'#'/2= 51,% )+A" )-&4"/,*' +# %!" 0'7+",8 B# )".-) '(+#+'#,2 !'&"7"/2 51*.", &+)) 1,1-))4/"6"/ %' %!"0,")7", -, <%!" O'1/%8=

)("A0 #$ 1--(::,.( 8#.#9,.#/$ >',% '(+#+'#, %!-% 4'1 /"-* +# )-& ,;!'') -/" -(("))-%" '(+#+'#,2

&!+;! 0"-#, %!-% %!"4 *";+*" %!" '1%;'0" '6 -(("-),8 M# <-(("-)= +,- )".-) (/';""*+#. %!-% ;'#,+*"/, &!"%!"/ -#'%!"/ ;'1/%W, )".-) *";+C,+'# &-, /+.!% '/ &/'#.8 M6%"/ - ;'1/% !-, /1)"* 6'/ '#" ,+*"2 %!")',+#. ,+*" 0-4 ,""A /"7+"& '6 %!-% *";+,+'# 34 6+)+#. -# -(("-) 3"C6'/" - !+.!"/ ;'1/%8 9!" '/+.+#-) ;'1/% +, 1,1-))4 A#'&# -, %!" %/+-);'1/%2 3";-1," %!-%W, &!"/" %!" %/+-) ';;1/, +6 %!"/" +, '#"8 9!"!+.!"/ ;'1/% +, A#'&# -, %!" -(("))-%" '/ -(("-), ;'1/%2 -, +% +, %!"

;'1/% %!-% !"-/, %!" -(("-)8M ,+#.)" 51*." (/",+*", '7"/ %/+-) ;'1/% (/';""*+#.,2 31% -((")C

)-%" ;-,", -/" *";+*"* 34 (-#"), '6 ,"7"/-) 51*.",8 E'/ ":-0()"2 +#%!" 6"*"/-) ;'1/% ,4,%"02 /1# 34 %!" N#+%"* F%-%", .'7"/#0"#%2 -,+#.)" %/+-) 51*." A#'&# -, - J+,%/+;% O'1/% 51*." '7"/,"", %!" %/+-),%-."8 O-,", ;-# 3" -(("-)"* %' %!" #":% !+.!"/ ;'1/%2 %!" O'1/% '6M(("-),2 &!"/" ;-,", -/" *";+*"* 34 (-#"), '6 %!/"" 51*.", A#'&#

-, O+/;1+% O'1/% 51*.",8 M ,+*" %!-% )',", 3"6'/" %!" O+/;1+% O'1/%;-# ,""A /"7+"& '6 %!-% *";+,+'# -% %!" N#+%"* F%-%", F1(/"0"O'1/%8 F1(/"0" O'1/% ;-,", -/" *";+*"* 34 -)) #+#" 51*.",8 F1C(/"0" O'1/% 51*.", -/" ;-))"* G1,%+;", +#,%"-* '6 51*.",\ %!"/" +,'#" <O!+"6 G1,%+;"= -#* %!" '%!"/ "+.!% -/" 51,% ()-+# <G1,%+;",=H%";!#+;-))4 %!"4 -/" <M,,';+-%" G1,%+;",2= 31% "7"/4'#" 51,% ;-)),%!"0 <G1,%+;",=I8

J1/+#. %!" (/';""*+#., 3"6'/" %!" !+.!"/ ;'1/%2 %!" (-/%4 %!-%

)',% -% %!" '/+.+#-) ;'1/% -#* +, %!"/"6'/" 6+)+#. %!" -(("-) +, 1,1-))4A#'&# -, %!" <-(("))-#%8= 9!" (-/%4 %!-% &'# +# %!" )'&"/ ;'1/% -#*01,% *"6"#* %!" )'&"/ ;'1/%W, *";+,+'# +, A#'&# -, %!" <-(("))""=

H-;;"#% '# %!" )-,% ,4))-3)"I8 F'0" ')*"/ '(+#+'#, 0-4 /"6"/ %' %!"-(("))-#% -, %!" <()-+#%+66 +# "//'/= -#* %!" -(("))"" -, %!" <*"6"#*-#%



4/5 ./ 6(,7 , 8(9,: !-#$#/$

'2.28% (99: *:

+# "//'/8= E+#-))42 ,'0" ;'1/%, )-3") -# -(("-) -, - <("%+%+'#2= -#*

/"e1+/" %!" )',+#. (-/%4 %' ("%+%+'# %!" !+.!"/ ;'1/% 6'/ /")+"68 B#%!"," ;-,",2 %!" (-/%4 %!-% )',% 3"6'/" %!" )'&"/ ;'1/% -#* +, 6+)+#.%!" ("%+%+'# 6'/ /"7+"& +, ;-))"* %!" <("%+%+'#"/8= 9!" (-/%4 %!-% &'# 3"6'/" %!" )'&"/ ;'1/% -#* +, /",('#*+#. %' %!" ("%+%+'# +# %!"!+.!"/ ;'1/% +, ;-))"* %!" </",('#*"#%8=

O'#61,"* 4"%` c'1 (/'3-3)4 -/"2 31% *'#W% &'//48 c'1W)) /"-* ,'0-#4 ;-,", +# %!" #":% 6"& &""A, %!-% 4'1W)) ."% 1,"* %' -)) '6 %!+,7"/4 ,''#8

1115 -+'. ?,2 %$$) ., /$'#% 3#,8 #$')1%" ' ='4$

A-42 ,' 4'1W7" 51,% /"-* - ;-," 6'/ ;)-,,8 c'1 %!+#A 4'1 1#*"/C,%-#* +%2 31% 4'1W/" #'% ,1/" +6 4'1 )"-/#"* &!-% 4'1/ (/'6",C

,'/ &-#%"* 4'1 %' )"-/#8 f"/" +, &!-% (/'6",,'/, &-#% ,%1*"#%, %'

A#'& -6%"/ /"-*+#. - ;-," -,,+.#"* 6'/ ;)-,,X'$/5 .*( ;,<.0

Y-& (/'6",,'/, )'7" %!" 6-;%,8 @!"# %!"4 ;-)) '# ,%1*"#%, +# ;)-,,2%!"4 %4(+;-))4 3".+# 34 -,A+#. ,%1*"#%, %' ,%-%" %!" 6-;%, '6 - (-/%+;1C)-/ ;-,"8 E-;%, -/" +0('/%-#% 3";-1," )-& +, '6%"# !+.!)4 6-;%C,"#,+%+7"2 &!+;! +, - 6-#;4 &-4 '6 ,-4+#. %!-% %!" (/'("/ )".-) '1%C;'0" *"("#*, '# %!" ":-;% *"%-+), '6 &!-% !-(("#"*8 B6 4'1 *'#W%

A#'& %!" 6-;%,2 4'1 ;-#W% /"-))4 1#*"/,%-#* %!" ;-," -#* ;-#W% 1#C*"/,%-#* %!" )-&8

>',% )-& ,%1*"#%, *'#W% -((/";+-%" %!" +0('/%-#;" '6 %!" 6-;%,&!"# %!"4 /"-* - ;-,"8 F%1*"#%, %!+#A2 <BW0 +# )-& ,;!'')2 #'% 6-;%,;!'')\ B &-#% %' A#'& &!-% %!" )-& +,2 #'% 51,% &!-% !-(("#"* +#%!+, '#" ;-,"8= L1% %/1,% 0"X %!" 6-;%, -/" /"-))4 +0('/%-#%8g

g B6 4'1 *'#W% 3")+"7" 0"2 4'1 ,!'1)* %-A" - )''A -% - 6"& )-& ,;!'') ":-0,8 B%%1/#, '1% %!-% %!" 0',% ;'00'# 6'/0 '6 )-& ,;!'') ":-0 e1",%+'# (/","#%, -)'#. *",;/+(%+'# '6 - 7"/4 (-/%+;1)-/ ,"% '6 6-;%,8 B% %!"# -,A, %!" ,%1*"#% %' <,('%=-#* -#-)4h" %!" )".-) +,,1", (/","#%"* 34 %!'," 6-;%,8 9!"," ":-0 e1",%+'#, -/"A#'&# -, <+,,1"C,('%%"/,2= -, %!"4 %",% %!" ,%1*"#%W, -3+)+%4 %' 1#*"/,%-#* %!" 6-;%,-#* ,('% %!" )".-) +,,1", %!"4 /-+,"8 M, 4'1 0+.!% +0-.+#"2 *'+#. &")) '# -# +,,1"C

^



!"#$ %& '(""

*@ !! "#$$% &'" ()

'$/5 .*( %-(<#3#< 8(9,: 1"92A($.0 C,7( D? .*( B,".#(0 Y-&,1+%, -/" *+,(1%",2 -#* 51*.", '#)4 +,,1" '(+#+'#, &!"# %&' (-/C%+", %' - *+,(1%" *+,-./"" '# - (-/%+;1)-/ )".-) e1",%+'#8 9!+, 0"-#,%!-% )".-) '(+#+'#, 6';1, '# /",')7+#. %!" (-/%+",W 7"/4 ,(";+6+; *+,C-./""0"#%8 9!" )-&4"/,2 #'% %!" 51*.",2 %-A" %!" )"-* /')" +# 6/-0C+#. %!" +,,1", /-+,"* 34 - ;-,"8

B# -# -(("-)2 6'/ ":-0()"2 %!" )-&4"/ 6'/ %!" -(("))-#% &+)) -/C%+;1)-%" ,(";+6+; &-4, +# &!+;! %!" )'&"/ ;'1/% &-, &/'#.8 9!" -(C

("))-%" ;'1/% &+)) %!"# )''A -% %!'," -/.10"#%, -#* "+%!"/ -./"" '/*+,-./""8 H]'& 4'1 ;-# 1#*"/,%-#* &!4 ("'()" (-4 3+. 31;A, 6'/%'( )-&4"/,\ %!" 3",% )-&4"/, -/" !+.!)4 ,A+))"* -% +*"#%+64+#. -#*-/%+;1)-%+#. %!"+/ -/.10"#%, %' %!" ;'1/%8I L";-1," %!" )-&4"/, %-A"%!" )"-* /')" +# 6/-0+#. %!" +,,1",2 4'1 #""* %' 1#*"/,%-#* ":-;%)4&!-% -/.10"#%, %!" %&' ,+*", &"/" 0-A+#.8

'$/5 .*( >#0-/0#.#/$ 9!" <*+,(',+%+'#= '6 - ;-," +, %!" -;%+'# %!" ;'1/% %''A8 B% +, '6%"#-##'1#;"* -% %!" 7"/4 "#* '6 %!" '(+#+'#8 E'/ ":-0()"2 -# -(("-),;'1/% 0+.!% <-66+/0= - )'&"/ ;'1/% *";+,+'#2 1(!')*+#. +%2 '/ +%0+.!% </"7"/,"= %!" *";+,+'#2 /1)+#. 6'/ %!" '%!"/ ,+*"8 M)%"/#-C%+7")42 -# -(("-), ;'1/% 0+.!% <7-;-%"= %!" )'&"/ ;'1/% *";+,+'#2&+(+#. %!" )'&"/C;'1/% *";+,+'# '66 %!" 3''A,2 -#* %!"# </"0-#*=%!" ;-,"2 ,"#*+#. +% 3-;A %' %!" )'&"/ ;'1/% 6'/ 61/%!"/ (/';""*+#.,8

E'/ #'&2 4'1 ,!'1)* A""( +# 0+#* %!-% &!"# - !+.!"/ ;'1/% <-6C6+/0,= +% 0"-#, %!-% %!" )'&"/ ;'1/% !-* +% /+.!% H+# /",1)%2 +6 #'% +#/"-,'#+#.I8 @'/*, )+A" </"7"/,"2= </"0-#*2= -#* <7-;-%"= 0"-#,%!-% %!" !+.!"/ ;'1/% %!'1.! %!" )'&"/ ;'1/% !-* +% &/'#.8

E$7("0.,$7 .*( 6(,0/$#$9 /3 .*( C,F/"#.? !-#$#/$ 9' 1#*"/,%-#* %!" /"-,'#+#. '6 -# '(+#+'#2 4'1 ,!'1)* 6+/,% +*"#%+64

%!" ,'1/;" '6 %!" )-& %!" 51*." -(()+"*8 F'0" '(+#+'#, +#%"/(/"% %!"O'#,%+%1%+'#2 %!" 6'1#*+#. ;!-/%"/ '6 %!" .'7"/#0"#%8 ^%!"/ ;-,",

,('%%"/ /"e1+/", *"7")'(+#. - ;-/"61) -#* #1-#;"* 1#*"/,%-#*+#. '6 %!" +0('/C%-#;" '6 %!" 6-;%,8 9!" 3",% &-4 %' (/"(-/" 6'/ %!-% +, %' /"-* %!" 6-;% ,";%+'#, '64'1/ ;-,", 7"/4 ;-/"61))48



4/5 ./ 6(,7 , 8(9,: !-#$#/$

'2.28% (99: *A

+#%"/(/"% <,%-%1%",2= &!+;! +, - 6-#;4 #-0" 6'/ &/+%%"# )-&, (-,,"*

34 )".+,)-%+7" 3'*+", ,1;! -, O'#./",,8 F%+)) '%!"/ ;-,", +#%"/(/"%<%!" ;'00'# )-&2= &!+;! +, - %"/0 %!-% 1,1-))4 /"6"/, %' %!" 3'*4 '6(/+'/ ;-," *";+,+'#, %!-% *"/+7" 1)%+0-%")4 6/'0 (/"CKSSd D#.)+,!)-& %!-% %!" O')'#+,%, 3/'1.!% '7"/ 6/'0 D#.)-#*8i

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

M6%"/ 4'1 !-7" +*"#%+6+"* %!" ,'1/;" '6 )-&2 4'1 ,!'1)* #":%+*"#%+64 %!" 0"%!'* '6 /"-,'#+#. %!-% %!" ;'1/% 1,"* %' 51,%+64 +%,*";+,+'#8 @!"# - ;-," +, .'7"/#"* 34 - ,%-%1%"2 6'/ ":-0()"2 %!"

;'1/% 1,1-))4 &+)) ,+0()4 6'))'& &!-% %!" ,%-%1%" ,-4,8 9!" ;'1/%W,/')" +, #-//'& +# ,1;! ,"%%+#., 3";-1," %!" )".+,)-%1/" !-, ,"%%)"* %!")-&8 F+0+)-/)42 &!"# (-,% ;'1/%, !-7" -)/"-*4 -#,&"/"* ,+0+)-/e1",%+'#, 3"6'/"2 - ;'1/% 0-4 ;'#;)1*" %!-% +% +, /"e1+/"* %' /"-;! -(-/%+;1)-/ /",1)% 3";-1," +% +, 3'1#* 34 %!" (-,% (/";"*"#%,8 9!+, +,-# -(()+;-%+'# '6 %!" 51*+;+-) (/-;%+;" '6 <,%-/" *";+,+,2= -# -33/"7+-C%+'# '6 - Y-%+# (!/-," 0"-#+#. <9!-% &!+;! !-, 3""# -)/"-*4 *";+*"*

,!'1)* /"0-+# ,"%%)"*8=B# '%!"/ ,"%%+#.,2 ;'1/%, 0-4 51,%+64 %!"+/ *";+,+'#, '# (13)+; (')C+;4 ./'1#*,8 9!-% +,2 %!"4 0-4 (+;A %!" /1)" %!-% %!"4 %!+#A +, %!" 3",% /1)"2 -#* %!"4 0-4 ":()-+# +# %!" '(+#+'# &!4 %!"4 %!+#A %!-%/1)" +, 3",%8 9!+, +, (-/%+;1)-/)4 )+A")4 +# ;'00'# )-& ;-,", &!"/" 51*.", -/" #'% 3'1#* 34 - ,%-%1%" '/ ;'#,%+%1%+'#-) /1)"8 ^%!"/;'1/%, &+)) /")4 '# 0'/-)+%42 6-+/#",,2 '/ #'%+'#, '6 51,%+;" %' 51,%+64

i 9!" (!/-," <;'00'# )-&= ,%-/%"* 3"+#. 1,"* -3'1% - %!'1,-#* 4"-/, -.' %' /"6"/%' )-&, %!-% &"/" ;'00'# %' -)) D#.)+,! ;+%+h"#,8 9!1,2 %!" &'/* <;'00'#= +#%!" (!/-," <;'00'# )-&= 0"-#, ;'00'# +# %!" ,"#," '6 <,!-/"* 34 -))2= #'%;'00'# +# %!" ,"#," '6 <#'% 7"/4 ,(";+-)8= 9!" <;'00'# )-&= &-, -##'1#;"* +# 51*+;+-) '(+#+'#,8 M, - /",1)%2 4'1 &+)) ,'0"%+0", !"-/ %!" (!/-," <;'00'# )-&=1,"* %' /"6"/ %' -/"-, '6 51*."C0-*" )-& -, '((',"* %' )".+,)-%+7")4C0-*" )-&8



!"#$ %& '(""

>9 !! "#$$% &'" ()

%!"+/ *";+,+'#,8 >-#4 ;'1/%, &+)) 0+: -#* 0-%;!2 /")4+#. '# ,"7"/-)

'/ "7"# -)) '6 %!"," 51,%+6+;-%+'#,8E$7("0.,$7 .*( %#9$#3#<,$<( /3 .*( C,F/"#.? !-#$#/$

F'0" '(+#+'#, /",')7" %!" (-/%+",W )".-) *+,(1%" 34 -##'1#;+#. -#*-(()4+#. - ;)"-/ /1)" '6 )-& %!-% +, #"& %' %!-% (-/%+;1)-/ ;-,"8 9!-%/1)" +, A#'&# -, %!" <!')*+#.= '6 %!" ;-,"8 f')*+#., -/" '6%"# ;'#C%/-,%"* &+%! <*+;%-= 6'1#* +# -# '(+#+'#8 J+;%- /"6"/, %' )".-) ,%-%"C0"#%, +# %!" '(+#+'# #'% #""*"* %' /",')7" %!" *+,(1%" '6 %!" (-/C%+",\ %!" &'/* +, - ()1/-)+h"* -33/"7+-%+'# '6 %!" Y-%+# (!/-," <'3+%"/*+;%102= &!+;! 0"-#, <- /"0-/A 34 %!" &-48=

@!"# - ;'1/% -##'1#;", - ;)"-/ !')*+#.2 4'1 ,!'1)* %-A" - 0+#C1%" %' %!+#A -3'1% !'& %!" ;'1/%W, /1)" &'1)* -(()4 +# '%!"/ ,+%1-C%+'#,8 J1/+#. ;)-,,2 (/'6",,'/, )+A" %' ('," <!4('%!"%+;-),2= #"& ,"%,'6 6-;%, %!-% -/" *+66"/"#% 6/'0 %!'," 6'1#* +# %!" ;-,", 4'1 !-7"/"-*8 9!"4 *' %!+, 6'/ %&' /"-,'#,8 E+/,%2 +%W, !-/* %' 1#*"/,%-#* %!"

,+.#+6+;-#;" '6 - )".-) /1)" 1#)",, 4'1 %!+#A -3'1% !'& +% 0+.!% -(()4%' )'%, '6 *+66"/"#% ,+%1-%+'#,8 M /1)" 0+.!% )''A .''* +# '#" ,"%%+#.2 31% -#'%!"/ ,"% '6 6-;%, 0+.!% /"7"-) - 0-5'/ (/'3)"0 '/ -03+.1+%48F";'#*2 51*.", '6%"# /"-,'# 34 <-#-)'.42= &!+;! 0"-#, - #"& ;-,"0-4 3" .'7"/#"* 34 -# ')*"/ ;-," &!"# %!" 6-;%, '6 %!" #"& ;-," -/",+0+)-/ %' %!'," '6 %!" ')*"/ '#"8 9!+, /-+,", %!" e1",%+'#2 &!+;! -/"%!" )".-))4 /")"7-#% 6-;%, 6'/ %!+, (-/%+;1)-/ /1)"` 9!" 3",% &-4 %'

"7-)1-%" %!+, +, %' ;'#,+*"/ #"& ,"%, '6 6-;%,8 c'1W)) ,("#* - )'% '6%+0" *'+#. %!+, +# ;)-,,2 -#* 4'1 ;-# ."% - !"-* ,%-/% '# 4'1/ ;)-,,*+,;1,,+'#, 34 -,A+#. %!" !4('%!"%+;-), '# 4'1/ '&# 3"6'/" ;)-,, 3".+#,8

E+#-))42 4'1 ,!'1)* -;;"(% %!-% ,'0" '(+#+'#, -/" 7-.1"8 F'0"C%+0", - ;'1/% &'#W% ":()-+# +%, /"-,'#+#. 7"/4 &"))2 -#* %!-% 6'/;",1, %' %/4 %' 6+.1/" '1% &!-% %!" '(+#+'# 0"-#,8 c'1W)) )''A 6'/ %!"!')*+#. '6 %!" ;-," 31% 3";'0" 6/1,%/-%"* 3";-1," 4'1 ;-#W% 6+#*'#"8 B%W, #'% 4'1/ 6-1)%\ ,'0" '(+#+'#, -/" &/+%%"# +# - #-//'& &-4,' %!-% %!"/" +, #' ;)"-/ !')*+#.2 -#* '%!"/, -/" 51,% (''/)4 /"-,'#"*'/ &/+%%"#8 V-%!"/ %!-# %/4+#. %' 6+)) +# %!" -03+.1+%4 &+%! 6-)," ;"/C%-+#%42 %/4 "03/-;+#. %!" -03+.1+%4 +#,%"-*8 ^#" '6 %!" ,A+)), '6 %'(C6)+.!% )-&4"/, +, %!-% %!"4 A#'& &!-% %!"4 *'#W% A#'&X %!"4 A#'&



4/5 ./ 6(,7 , 8(9,: !-#$#/$

'2.28% (99: >!

&!"# %!" )-& +, 1#;)"-/8 B#*""*2 %!+, ,A+)) '6 +*"#%+64+#. &!"# -

(/'3)"0 +, "-,4 -#* &!"# +% +, !-/* H+# %!" ,"#," '6 3"+#. 1#,"%%)"*'/ 1#/",')7"* 34 %!" ;'1/%,I +, '#" '6 %!" A"4, %' *'+#. 7"/4 &")) +#)-& ,;!'')8 9!" 3",% )-& ,%1*"#%, -/" %!" '#", &!' /";'.#+h" -#*+*"#%+64 %!"," 1#,"%%)"* +,,1", &+%!'1% (/"%"#*+#. %!-% %!"4 -/" "-,48

E$7("0.,$7 1$? +/$<2""#$9 ,$7=/" >#00($.#$9 !-#$#/$0 c'1 (/'3-3)4 &'#W% 3")+"7" 0" -% 6+/,%2 31% ;'#;1//"#;", -#* *+,C,"#%, -/" 7"/4 +0('/%-#%8 c'1 #""* %' /"-* %!"0 ;-/"61))48 9' 1#C*"/,%-#* &!42 4'1 #""* %' -((/";+-%" %!-% )-& +, 0-#C0-*"2 -#*M#.)'CM0"/+;-# )-& !-, '6%"# 3""# 51*."C0-*"8 Y"-/#+#. %' <%!+#A)+A" - )-&4"/= '6%"# 0"-#, )"-/#+#. %' %!+#A )+A" - 51*."2 &!+;!0"-#, )"-/#+#. !'& %' "7-)1-%" &!+;! /1)", -#* ":()-#-%+'#, -/",%/'#. -#* &!+;! -/" &"-A8 O'1/%, ';;-,+'#-))4 ,-4 %!+#., %!-% -/",+))42 &/'#.!"-*"*2 '/ ;'#61,"*2 -#* 4'1 #""* %' %!+#A +#*"("#*C"#%)4 -3'1% &!-% 51*.", ,-48

O'#;1//+#. -#* *+,,"#%+#. '(+#+'#, '6%"# *' %!+, &'/A 6'/ 4'18O-,"3''A -1%!'/, "*+% '1% -#4 1#+0('/%-#% ;'#;1//"#;", -#* *+,C,"#%, %' A""( %!" '(+#+'#, ,!'/%8 @!"# ;'#;1//"#;", -#* *+,,"#%,-(("-/ +# - ;-,"3''A2 +% ,+.#-), %!-% %!"4 '66"/ ,'0" 7-)1-3)" +#,+.!%,-#* /-+," +0('/%-#% -/.10"#%,8 J+,-./""0"#% 3"%&""# %!" 0-5'/+%4'(+#+'# -#* ;'#;1//+#. '/ *+,,"#%+#. '(+#+'#, '6%"# 6/-0", %!" A"4+,,1" /-+,"* 34 %!" ;-,"\ %' 1#*"/,%-#* %!" ;-,"2 4'1 #""* %' 1#*"/C

,%-#* %!" -/.10"#%, '66"/"* +# ;'#;1//+#. -#* *+,,"#%+#. '(+#+'#,8

1B5 -+? ), /'- 0#,3$44,#4 24$ .+$ ='4$ 8$.+,)7

W)) ;'#;)1*" 34 ,%"((+#. 3-;A -#* ":()-+#+#. &!4 )-& (/'6",,'/, 3'%!"/ &+%! %!" ;-," 0"%!'*8 D7"/4 )-& ,%1*"#% e1+;A)4 /"-)+h",

%!-% )-& ,;!'') ;)-,,", -/" 7"/4 *+66"/"#% 6/'0 ;'))"." ;)-,,",8 c'1/

;'))"." (/'6",,'/, (/'3-3)4 ,%''* -% %!" ('*+10 -#* */'#"* '#&!+)" 4'1 ,-% 3-;A +# 4'1/ ;!-+/2 ,-6" +# 4'1/ ;';''#8 c'1W/" #'&,%-/%+#. )-& ,;!'')2 -#* +%W, 7"/4 *+66"/"#%8 c'1W/" /"-*+#. -3'1%-;%1-) ;-,",2 /"-)C)+6" *+,(1%",2 -#* 4'1W/" %/4+#. %' )"-/# -3'1% %!")-& 34 (+;A+#. 1( 3+%, -#* (+";", '6 +% 6/'0 &!-% %!" '(+#+'#, %"))

B



!"#$ %& '(""

>( !! "#$$% &'" ()

4'18 D7"# &"+/*"/2 4'1/ (/'6",,'/, -/" -,A+#. 4'1 e1",%+'#, -3'1%

%!'," '(+#+'#,2 ."%%+#. "7"/4'#" %' 5'+# +# - *+,;1,,+'# -3'1% %!"08@!4 %!" *+66"/"#;"`2 4'1 0-4 3" &'#*"/+#.8 @!4 *' )-& ,;!''),1," %!" ;-," 0"%!'* -% -))`

B %!+#A %!"/" -/" %&' 0-5'/ /"-,'#,2 '#" !+,%'/+;-) -#* %!" '%!"/(/-;%+;-)8

)*( 4#0./"#<,: 6(,0/$ 9!" )".-) ,4,%"0 %!-% &" !-7" +#!"/+%"* 6/'0 D#.)-#* +, )-/.")4

51*."C6';1,"*8 9!" 51*.", !-7" 0-*" %!" )-& &!-% +% +, %!/'1.!%!"+/ &/+%%"# '(+#+'#,8 9' 1#*"/,%-#* %!-% )-&2 &" #""* %' ,%1*4%!" -;%1-) *";+,+'#, %!-% %!" 51*.", !-7" &/+%%"#8 E1/%!"/2 &" #""*%' )"-/# %' )''A -% )-& %!" &-4 %!-% 51*.", )''A -% )-&8 B# '1/ ,4,C%"0 '6 .'7"/#0"#%2 51*.", ;-# '#)4 -##'1#;" %!" )-& &!"# *";+*C+#. /"-) *+,(1%",X %!"4 ;-#W% 51,% !-7" - (/",, ;'#6"/"#;" -#* -#C#'1#;" - ,"% '6 )".-) /1)",8 H9!+, +, ,'0"%+0", /"6"//"* %' -, %!"

<;-," '/ ;'#%/'7"/,4= /"e1+/"0"#%\ - ;'1/% !-, #' ('&"/ %' *";+*"-# +,,1" 1#)",, +% +, (/","#%"* 34 -# -;%1-) ;-," '/ ;'#%/'7"/,4 3"C6'/" %!" ;'1/%8I 9' )''A -% %!" )-& %!" &-4 %!-% 51*.", *'2 &" #""*%' ,%1*4 -;%1-) ;-,", -#* ;'#%/'7"/,+",2 51,% )+A" %!" 51*.",8 B# ,!'/%2&" ,%1*4 /"-) ;-,", -#* *+,(1%", 3";-1," /"-) ;-,", -#* *+,(1%", !+,C%'/+;-))4 !-7" 3""# %!" (/+0-/4 ,'1/;" '6 )-&8

)*( B",<.#<,: 6(,0/$ M ,";'#* /"-,'# (/'6",,'/, 1," %!" ;-," 0"%!'* +, %!-% +% %"-;!", -#",,"#%+-) ,A+)) 6'/ (/-;%+;+#. )-&4"/,8 Y-&4"/, /"(/","#% ;)+"#%,2 -#*;)+"#%, &+)) &-#% %' A#'& !'& )-&, -(()4 %' %!"08 9' -*7+," - ;)+C"#%2 - )-&4"/ #""*, %' 1#*"/,%-#* ":-;%)4 !'& -# -3,%/-;% /1)" '6)-& &+)) -(()4 %' %!" 7"/4 ,(";+6+; ,+%1-%+'#, - ;)+"#% 0+.!% "#;'1#C%"/8 9!+, +, 0'/" *+66+;1)% %!-# 4'1 0+.!% %!+#A2 +# (-/% 3";-1," -)".-) /1)" %!-% ,'1#*, *"6+#+%" -#* ;)"-/ +# %!" -3,%/-;% 0-4 (/'7"

01/A4 +# -(()+;-%+'#8 HE'/ ":-0()"2 +0-.+#" 4'1 .' %' - (13)+; (-/A-#* ,"" - ,+.# %!-% ,-4, <]' 7"!+;)", +# %!" (-/A8= 9!-% ()-+#)4 6'/C 3+*, -# -1%'0'3+)"2 31% &!-% -3'1% 3+;4;)",2 &!"");!-+/,2 %'4-1%'0'3+)",` @!-% -3'1% -+/()-#",` M031)-#;",` M/" %!"," <7"!+C;)",= 6'/ %!" (1/('," '6 %!" /1)" '/ #'%`I M, - /",1)%2 .''* )-&4"/,



4/5 ./ 6(,7 , 8(9,: !-#$#/$

'2.28% (99: >;

#""* - 7+7+* +0-.+#-%+'#\ %!"4 #""* %' +0-.+#" !'& /1)", 0+.!% -(C

()42 &!"/" %!"4 0+.!% 3" 1#;)"-/2 -#* &!"/" %!"4 0+.!% )"-* %'1#":(";%"* '1%;'0",8 9!" ;-," 0"%!'* -#* %!" 6/"e1"#% 1," '6!4('%!"%+;-), &+)) !")( %/-+# 4'1/ 3/-+# %' %!+#A %!+, &-48 Y"-/#+#.%!" )-& +# )+.!% '6 ;'#;/"%" ,+%1-%+'#, &+)) !")( 4'1 *"-) &+%! (-/C%+;1)-/ 6-;%, 4'1W)) "#;'1#%"/ -, - (/-;%+;+#. )-&4"/8

j''* )1;Ak

kerr - how to read a legal opinion

Documents