june 15literature review1 work for projects the literature study the literature survey the...

Apr 18, 2023 Literature review 1

Work for projects

The literature study

The literature survey

The literature review


Literature Review

Overview of relevant technologies and ideas (but don’t rewrite textbook material – just summarize!)

Identifies your project topic by placing it in a wider context.

Focussed discussion on one or more specific topics (your choice) from the wider context.


Why do a review? To support your reasons for the project

Confirm that your project idea is from a recognised problem area (identification)

Show where it fits into the overall subject area (relatedness)

Make it clear it is a worthwhile problem to solve (valuation)

To improve your presentation of your project By reading and understanding work in related areas By listening to current debates in the Computing

community, academic and professional.


What will a literature review achieve?

A Distinction project must have a LR and show how the project has been influenced by it.

It will show evidence of awareness of current developments in technology and ideas.

It will evaluate the project implementation against current developments

It will show evidence of a professional approach in some focussed areas.


Development projects

Identify currently available software tools that support this type of development, not just the one you chose.

Consider the alternatives and evaluate the trade-offs. Find journal articles that discuss the most recent approaches and speculate on the future trends.

Not just How to Do It; but Why Do It This Way. Do = design, code, build, develop


How to go about LR

Type your project title into the ACM database or similar

Browse the references looking for readable and relevant material. Usually practical, but theory may sometimes be close to practice.

Look out for keywords that identify specific topics and try adding these to your search string.


Define search

Perform searchSift material

Write notes

Redefine search

Breadth of focus

The literature survey process


Refining your search

To begin with you will find that around 10% of your “hits” are relevent (sometimes less)

Focus on an article that is relevent and note its list of keywords

Decide which keywords are of most interest and add them to your search terms

Repeat until your hit rate is > 50% and you like what you see


Out of date reference?

If it is published more than 3-4 years ago then it may be obsolete

If it looks interesting then find out what has happened since it was published by: Type the article title in to the search box and

search Change the sort order to publication date


How to read journal articles Start with abstract – anything of interest? If yes then go to the conclusion – did they

deliver anything of specific interest to you? If yes then find it within the journal article (use

the headings – don’t read all the text!) and make some notes

Now check out the introduction for anything helpful in the way of context

Now go to the references – chase up any article that also looks useful e.g. the original idea, related ideas or applications.


Writing it up (1)After you have read 5-10 articles and 5-10 books and made

simple notes Decide what are the key ideas Then organise your material into a catalogue

Put related articles together e.g. (Jones 1998) and (Smith 2001)describe how technology change has …

Follow a timeline (e.g. if it helps understand some current controversy) e.g. Moore’s law goes back to (Moore …) … but recent articles (Hussein 2004) have questioned whether the limit

Compare and contrast - work out whether a different approach Agrees with the first one Is complementary to it (looks at different issues, same topic) whether it extends it, (looks in more depth at the same issues) or is head to head (disagrees with an alternative view)


Writing it up (2)

Look for a specific focus that could take you from one idea to the next e.g. an overall aim like standardisation, or performance, or efficiency

Now you should do some further reading to fill in the gaps or to follow up a topic in greater detail

You may want to look for more recent articles, that reference the articles that you have found useful, so that you be sure you are up to date. This is called a citation search.


Grammar and syntax … Simply re-state what the author said: X

found, argued, believed that …. Comment from your point of view:

Y’s approach has become the standard, is controversial, …

Stay neutral: Z reports that …, concludes that …,

proposes that … Cheerleader:

X makes a convincing case …, Y’s excellent description is …, in a well-argued study Z shows that

…


And … Be sceptical - Is the article superficial or is it

really setting out some useful ideas. In depth – check

Assumptions (realistic?, specialised …) Credentials – check the list of references for

previous papers by the same author (and also the ACM database)

Everyone makes the best of their results – keep an open mind until you have seen a few more papers with anything similar

The conclusion is where they have to be honest – what did they really do that was different.


Citing References

All quoted material, from any source, must have a reference immediately following, crediting the source, and italicised.

Where you have written another person’s ideas in your own words, taken from published or unpublished literature the you must include a reference crediting the original source.

The Harvard System should be used.


References… “a good project always pays attention to the aims and objectives”

Dawson (2000).The use of the internet (Campbell & Campbell, 1995) is generally

agreed to be a good thing.

6.0 ReferencesBell, J. (1999) Doing Your Research Project (3/E), Open University

Press, Baxter et al. (1996) How to Research, Open University PressCampbell, D & Campbell, M. (1995) The Student’s Guide to Doing

Research on the Internet, Addison-WesleyDawson, C.W. (2000) The Essence of Computing Projects: A

Student’s Guide, Prentice HallGash, S. (1989) Effective Literature Searching for Students, GowerSaunders et al. (1997) Research Methods for Business Students,

Pitman


Conclusion

The project proposal must have a summary literature review

LR will eventually form one or more chapters in the final report

Review key areas related to your work Does not review textbooks! Should include a discussion about the

implications for your work.

june 15literature review1 work for projects the literature study the literature survey the...

Documents