jooth
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/25/2019 Jooth
1/19
twB1
&ftrsUnz
folkfj;k&^^Lkheks! rw esjk fookl dj] eSa rq>s dHkh /kkskk "ha
nw#$k% ksjk Hkjkslk jfk;ks''''%((
)**kok+ ls ,+rs "q- .ls ;"h d"k kk 0kSj lheks Hkh .ls Hkjh
0k#k Lsk rd fonk djs 0k23 kh% Lsk 4ks56s .lds
lkk 7k)w 0kSj 4ksk Hkk23 0k;k kk] +sfd .dh t6j 7,kdj
lheks Hkh 8+s9kk3 )j ,+h 0k23 kh% 7qd :"h+j )j k56s"ksdj eSth )+rs "q- .ldh f$k"sa nsj rd] nwj rd .ls "h
nskrh j"h kha% r7 Hkh t7 o" 0)s 7k)w ds )Sj 4wdj f5k;k
Hkh kk&^^kS e"hs dh "h rks Csfa$ "S% 7kn esa l7 dq4
Bhd "ks tk-$k% estj f5C+ 0kSj )h'h' djokrs "q- 2rk kdk nsrk
"S] fd eSl esa kkk kks dk Hkh e "ha djrk% f7Lrj )j f$jrk
rks f9j "ksk "ha j"rk% lq7" f9j o"h dke% tjk lk f5l0kD53j
1
-
7/25/2019 Jooth
2/19
"q- fd +kn fn;k EBw%'''eSa ;k djrk lheks] eq>s ekSdk "h
"ha fe+rk rq>ls 7kr djs dk'''F t7 7kr djk ,k"w# r7 rw# Gkj
esa 0ds+h "ha "ksrh% ek#&7k)w] rk;k] nknh 0kSj nqf;k Hkj
ds 5j%''' eSasa d23 7kj ek+w ds a7j ls Hkh 7kr djh,k"ha] )j .lls rks rw# kq@ ls "h 7kr "ha djk ,k"rh kh% oks
7kr djokrkF r7 Hkh rw# 7kr djrh%''''lheks! 07 rw# "h 7rk eSa
;k djrk'''%(( f7Lrj )j )56s&)56s .ls han "ha 0k j"h kh%
.l )j fn esa 0kt estj s Hkh .ls .ldh 2l 7skqnh )j d23 7kj
dlk kk&^^rj] rq"kjh "k+r 7rk j"h "S fd rq"kjk
fn+ks&fnek$ Bhd "ha "S] sCaf$ esa 2l rj" dh +k)jok"h0I4h "ha "ksrh'''07 dh kks56h es"r ftUn$h Hkj dk
0kjke%(( J)j ls lkk esa f5C+ dj j"s ,a7+ ds -d lkkh ja$@ s
.l )j -d 0+$ f96djk dlk kk&^^Hk23 tK ljnkj "S! jk#>s ds
nsk dk'''t@j o"k# 0)h dks23 "hj 4ks56 0k;k "S''''rHkh rks
.ldk e ;"k# saCfa$ esa "ha +$rk''' +s d"ks jk2 eq56
tkrk "S?(( o" J)jh rkSj )j $qLlk fnkkrs "q-] e "h e eqLdjk dj
j" $;k kk%
1' twB M)atk7hN
saCfa$ dk Hkh 07 -d "h e"hk 7,k kk% 0kB e"hs
)"+s nsk ds fofHkUUk Hkk$ksa ls Hkrh3 "ksdj 0k- rj"&rj" dh
k+ks&lwjr 0kSj 7ks+h&okf;ksa ok+s +56dksa esa ls] d23
07 .lds ft6$jh nksLr 7 $- ks% f9j Hkh lheks dh k+ o" -d
)+ ds f+- Hkh "ha Hkw+k kk% .lds f+- -d&-d fn ok3 0kSjjkr lfn;ksa ds lek $qt6j j"h kh% ftl Gkj dks .ls dHkh nl fn
ds f+- "ha 4ks56k kk% f"k+ 0kSj nj7kj lkf"7 0eOrlj ds
0+kok .ls dks23 nwljh t$" "ha nskh kh% 2l 7kj o" )"+h
2
-
7/25/2019 Jooth
3/19
)"+ Gkj ls "tkjksa fd'eh' nwj leqnz ds fdkjs 7ls 2l eqa723
-;j)ks3 )j lfo3l djs ,+k 0k;k kk% o" tkrk kk fd Gkj esa 0kSj
dks23 .ldh f,ark djs djs] )j ek# t6@j ;kn djrh "ks$h% +sfd
Bhd .ls ek# ;"k# oSls "h ;kn 0krh] tSls GkGkksj Gkk0ksa ds7h, dHkh&dHkkj ,eds ok+h f7t+h'''] 0kSj lheks'''.lds f+-
-d -slk 6ok7] tks .ldh 0k#kksa )j fn&jkr ,L)k# j"rk "S% -d
-slk kk] -d -slk kqekj tks "ha .rjrk%'''
07 ;k "q0k lheks dks] .ldk fnek$ "eskk ,dj&Hk#ojh
)j j"rk% 9ks +$k0ks rks dHkh .Brk "ha] .B Hkh tkrk "S
rks .ls 0sa5 djs ok+k P93 jkss dsF dks23 tok7 "hansrk% ;" +56dh rks .ldh ftUna$h 7j7kn djds jk ns$h! dHkh
.ls $qLlk Hkh 0k tkrk'''%
.ls tSls&rSls -d e"hk 0kSj fdk+k% ftl fn lh'
0k23'-l'-9 dh sCafa$ 0kSj dle&)js5 lek8r "q23 l7ds
lkk&lkk o" Hkh kqk kkF 2lf+- "ha fd .ls 0)h lfo3l ds
fof/kor )zkjaHk djs dk -d ,jAk l9+rk )wo3d "kP+ dj f+;k "S]
7fQd 2lf+- fd 07 -;j)ks3 )j 5K;wh ,=6s ls )"+s o" Hkh 0U;
fjRwksa ds lkk dq4 fn ds f+- 0)s Gkj tk;s$k& onh3 esa%
.ldh 2I4k "S fd onh3 esa l7ls )"+s .ls lheks "h nsksF nsks
fd .ldk ^tq$w( 07 fdrk 756k 0kneh 7 $;k "S% ft t"ktksa
dks o" 0)s $k#o ds J)j ls .56rs "q- nwj rd nskrh j"rh "S]
. t"ktksa esa 07 .ldk ^tq$w( 0krk&tkrk Hkh "S%
0kSj r7 ;" E4+s fnla7j dh 7kr "S% ekSle dh Ba5d ls "h
.ls e"lwl dj f+;k kk fd ^dBq0k( ds 0kl)kl rks 0Hkh Hk;adj
793okjh "ks j"h "ks$h% nknj&0eOrlj -l)zsl esa 7SBrs "q- .ls
2rh .rko+h "ks j"h kh] fd js+ d"ha 8+s "ks tk- 0kSj o"
3
-
7/25/2019 Jooth
4/19
ftrh tQnh "ks lds 0)h lheks ds )kl tk )"q#,s% .lds 2rs djh7]
2rsF fd ftrs djh7 0Hkh dks23 0kSj )"q#,k "ks% o" .lds )kl
tkdj d"k ,k"rk kk&^^nsk lheks] eSa 0k $;k ! 9ks )j
rw# 9k+rw esa jksrh kh% l7ls )"+s eSa rsjs "h )kl 0k;k "w#'''rw# esjk fookl djrh "S '''?((
+sfd t7 o" .lds )kl )"q#,k rks +$k fd o" .ldh lheks
"ha] dks23 0kSj "S% .ldh 0k#kksa esa dks23 ,ed kh%
.lk" rks ja,ekT Hkh "ha% 793 tSlh ln3 kkekskh% >qdh
t6j% nk#r ls 0#$wBs dk kkw dqrjrsF .nkl] fdUrq 0ksaBksa)j -d 9hdh eqLdk ds lkk .ldk .ls Lok$r fd;k kk&^^d7
0k;s''?((
&^^0kt] 0Hkh rks 0k;kF nskks eSas onh3 Hkh "ha
.rkjh''' ek# ls >wB 7ks+ 0k;k "w# fd $qVkjs ekk sds tk
j"k "w#] rw# dSlh "S'''?((
&^^,a$h "w#'''] 0kSj rqe dSls "ks'''?(( .ls )s&rq+s
k
-
7/25/2019 Jooth
5/19
Hkjdj 0)s lhs ls +$k +s$k% 0kB&nl ek" dh lkjh nwfj;ksa dh
kk23 dks o" -d "h XkAk esa )k ns$k% .ldh 0k#kksa esa 7lh
rU"k23 dks nwj dj] kqfk;ksa dh ,ed Hkj ns$k%''')j ;" ;k]
lheks dk ;" @8k nsk .lds Hkhrj dh lkjh kqkh0Unj&"h&0Unj Gkqdj j" $23 kh% ftl 0jek ls o" .ls th Hkjdj
8;kj nsk ,k"rk kk] os "kk .ls 4ws ls j" $- ks% 0,kd .ls
tks ;ksa e"lwl "q0k fd ;" .ldh 0kf/kdkj ,sk "ks$h%
t7fd -slk )"+s dHkh "ha "q0k kk% Ldw+ esa o" rks .ls
tks fd&fd 7"kksa ls 4ws 0kSj 7kr djs dh dksfkk djrk
kk] ftlesa dHkh o" h,j dh 5k# kkrk rks dHkh Lo;a^lheks( "h .ls f>56d nsrh kh% )j 0kt tks ;ksa .ls 2l
)zfR;k esa )jk;k) e"lwl "q0k kk%
2l rj" 7"qr nsj "ks $23 kh] dks23 fdlh ls dq4 d" "ha
)k;k% o" nksksa 7k#"sa 7k#/ks 7h, jkLrs )zok,d eqnzk esa
dq4 2l rj" k56k kk] tSls )w4 j"k "ks&^0kfkj "q0k ;k "S?(
0kSj o" Hkh $qVkjs ds 7$+ ls $qtjs ok+h $+h ds .l -dkar
esa )Sj ds 0a$wBs ls t6eh )j
-
7/25/2019 Jooth
6/19
kk&^^lkSa" j7 nh lheks! l, 7rk rsjs lkk ;k "q0k "S'''?((
0kSj .ls kha,dj 0)s lhs ls +$k f+;k kk% tSls dIIkh
feKh dh nhokj tjk lh 7jlkr esa HkjHkjk dj f$j )56rh "S% tSls
nh dh 7k=6 esa detksj 7k#/k 9wdj 7" fd+rk "S% Bhd oSls"h .lds $+s +$krs lheks] f"+fd;k# +s 9w&9wdj jks )56h
kh%
t7 kkar "q23 0kSj .ls tks 7rk;k .ls lqdj -slk +$k] tSls
.lds )Sjksa r+s t6eh "ha% Pj )j 0klek "ha% 0k#kksa esa
0a/ksjk 0kSj e ls -dk-d lks,s dh kfr lek8r "ks $23 "ks%'''
kfLrd dk Hkh 0)k -d Hkjkslk "ksrk "S] .ldk 0)k ^0ke7+(!8kj o" kfLrd "ha!! ek# 0kSj $q0ksa ls *;knk ftl )j Hkjkslk
fd;k] 0)k fookl 0kSj 0ke7+ ekkF 0kt lhs ls +$dj Pldrs "q-]
.lh s 7rk;k fd o" .ldk Hkjkslk 7kdj "ha jk )k;h "S!!!
0,kd .lds Hkhrj dIIks /kk$s dh rj" dq4 ,&,kd
"ksdj wk 0kSj o" 0)s dks l#Hkk+ "ha )k;k% +$k tSls 0k#k
"h "ha lkjk 7n ;"k# rd fd .lds lkjs jkse&jkse esa rj tSlk
dq4 ,qHkk "S] .ldh )d56 =h+h "ks $23% nksksa "kkksa
dh .#$f+;k# fe+kdj l56lh ds 0kdkj esa 0)k )$56h lf"r Pj
n7krk] )h4s 0kSj )h4s $qVkjs dh nhok+ ls tk fdk
kk&^^lheks! +ks$ rks dq4 nsj eqns3 dk Hkh 2artkj djrs
"Sa] eSa rks nkrs nh es"j ftUnk kk? dq4 fn esjk -r7kj 0kSj dj
+srh'''eSaw tkrs o6r ;d6h fn+k;k kk fd rw esjk Hkjkslk
jfk;ks] f9j rsw -slk dh djk#Z''';ksa dh esjs )s -slh
7s-r7kjh''?(( d+stk ,kd Plfd;k# 0kSj 0k#lq0ksa ls ,s"jk
fHka$ksrk o"] 07 rd 0)s dsk ksa,s dh fLkfr esa 0k $;k
kk% )j o" kkeksk kh% -dne )kkkAkor% +sfd o" ,q) "ha
6
-
7/25/2019 Jooth
7/19
j"k&^^2lls 0I4k "ksrk eSa o"ha fdlh jks5 -lh5sU esa
ekjk tkrk] de ls de eq>s rq"kjk ;s @8k nsks dks rks "ha
fe+rk'''Cs )j ,=6rs esjh 0k#kksa esa rq"kjk o"ha
0k#lq0ksa Hkjk ,s"jk 4k;k kk] ftls eSa 2 kS e"hksaesa -d 8k+ ds f+- Hkh "ha Hkw+k'''esjh "j jkst6] "j )+ ;"h
dksfkk j"h fd d7 eq>s 2l Csfa$ ls 4qKh fe+s 0kSj d7
eSa tQn ls tQn )**kok+ )"q#, 0)h lheks dk "#lrk "q0k ,s"jk
nskw#['''')j rqes rks eq>s +"w ds 0k#lw +k fn-] rq"sa
"#lkk rks nwj ft6an$h esa f9j dHkh kqn )"+s tSlk kq+dj
eqLdjk Hkh "ha )kJ#$k'''eq>s 0)s ls *;knk rsjs )j Hkjkslkkk&lhek's?((
&^^'''''''''!(( o" 07 Hkh k6keksk kh% )j o" r7 Hkh kkar
"ha "q0kk% 0)h kkdh k3 dh 7k#"ksa ls 0k#ksa )ksa4
t6eh )j 7wksa dh 0kokt6 djrk] rdj k56k "ks $;k kk%
.ldh 0k#kksa esa 2l 7kj nhrk "ha Rks/k kk% 8;kj "ha
f"alk kh% +$Hk$ nk#r )j nk#r ,=6k] kqs 9q+kdj k3 dh
7k#" Pdks56 .Bk kk&^^eSa .l dkh "hj ds ekek dks
4ks56w#$k "ha[[?((
&^^'''.ls ekjs tks ls )"+s -d 7kj eq>ls ;" "ha )w4ks$s fd
.ls esjs lkk -slk ;ksa fd;k] ;ksa dh eSas rq"kjs lkk
-slh 7s-r7kjh'''?(( o" t7 "e+s dh eqnzk esa .lds 7$+ ls tks
dks "qq0k] rks +56dh s Pj >qdk- "q- "h et7wrh ls .ldk
"kk )d56 f+;k kk% .ldk $qLlk Hkh lkrosa 0klek )j
kk&^^oks rsjh tkr dk "S[ 2lf+- rw 07 .ldh rj96nkjh
djs$h'''?(( 07 o" )wjh rj"] 0)s tK ljnkjksa ok+s jkS7 esa
kk%
7
-
7/25/2019 Jooth
8/19
&^^''''%(( .ls 0LohdOfr esa "kk )d56s&)d56s "h Pj f"+k
fn;k kk%
&^^rks ;k[ rq>s .lls 8;kj''?(( et7wrh ls .ls 0)k "kk
4q56k .ldh d+k23 )d56h 0kSj 0k#kksa esa 0k#k 5k+dj -dnwljk "h )z t56 fn;k kk%
&^^"ha['''!(( 2l 7kj .ls Hkh kks56s )zfrjks/k ds lkk
0)h d+k23 4q56kdj] lafXk8k fdUrq eqkj .\kj fn;k kk%
&^^f9j'''?(( .ls )z fd;k%
&^^'''fjUdw eq>s ,k"rk kk 0kSj rq"kjk nksLr ek+w Hkh] )j
eSaw k rks ek+w dks 0)k 7sf+;k 7k;k k "h fjUdw dks'''')j k tks dSls fjUdw ;" ek 7SBk fd ek+w ds 7"dks )j "h
rqes eq>s 0)k ;kj 7k;k "SF ;" lks,dj fd ^Hk$rksa( dh ;"
$ksjh&f,Kh dq56h] eq>s "ha rks rsjs k+ "h 9#l tk-'''
%((
&^^dq rkS+rk "S Llk+k['''ok"s $q@ nh dle lheks! eSas fdlh
ek+w ds d"s )j rq>ls ;kjh "ha dh] ;" esjk j
-
7/25/2019 Jooth
9/19
dks "ha Hkw+k fd o" detkr "SF dks23 dq4 Hkh d"s] .ls
rq"kjs )h4s "h j"k "S''')j ;" 7kr -d +56dh ;k 0kSjr ds 7kjs
esa >w#B )56 tkrh "S] .ls "j dks23 0)s ls h, 0kSj )Sjk# dh
twrh le>rk "S! eSa fjUdw dh tkr dh +56dh "kss okLrs] o"rqels )"+s eq> )j 0)k *;knk "d6 ekrk kk!! )j eSa knk]
.ldh ;" ,k+ tk k ldh 0kSj'''%((
&^^oks esjs lkk -slk "ha dj ldrk&lheks! .ls eq>s Hkjkslk
fn;k kkF rq"kjh f"96kt6r] rqels fe+ks 0kSj 7kr djkrs j"s
dk'''oks -slk dSls dj ldrk "S'''?(( 0fookl ds ekjs .ldh 0k#ksa
,kSa56h "ks $2a3 0kSj ekks )j 7+ )56 $;k kk% .ls LeOfr )jtksj 5k+k rks dq4 e"hs )h4s ,+k $;k] t7 nks&rh ek" rd
fjUdw s Csfa$ ds nkSjk lheksa ls .ldh 7kr 0I4h rj"
djok23 kh% o" -d nks fn esa dks23 dks23 ekSdk fdk+dj]
lheksa ls .ldh 7kr djk "h nsrk kk% r7 fjUdw dh fBk 0kSj
lheks dh 8;kj Hkjh 7krsa .lds fn Hkj dhs Csafa$ dh lkjh
kdk "j +srha kha] .ls 0)h nksLrh 0kSj 8;kj )j $o3 0krk%
&^^fjUdw kk;n esjs lkk -slk djrk 0kSj rq"kjk Hkjkslk Hkh
7k;s jkrk] )j''''%((
&^^)j ;k lheks?'''eq>s 0Hkh Hkh fookl "ha "ks j"k fd
fjUdw rsjs k+ -slk dSls dj ldrk "S] d"ha rqe eq>s'''?((
&^^k'''%(( -dk-d 7kr dk k )+rk nsk +56dh s t6j
>qdk- "ks+h ds ekS 2kkjs ls .lds .rko+s) )j fojke +$k;k]
rks .lk#l Hkjrs ^k( esa .lds Hkh 0ksaB kq+s j" $- ks% ;
E ;" +56dh dh 0ksj ls rks dks23 lkaok "h kh] k "h
dks23 l9k23] fdUrq .lds ,s"js )j -dk-d 0th7 lh kkafr 0kSj
0k#kksa esa -d fof,T ls lqk dh )zfr4k;k .Hkj 0k;h kh% kk;n
9
-
7/25/2019 Jooth
10/19
;" . XkAkksa dk lqk kk t7 "ekjs fookl dks ,kjks 0ksj ls Bsl
+$s] e "esa 0)s "h ,qko )j f/kdkj .Bs 0kSj dso+ GkOAkk ds
0frfjr "ekjs )kl dq4 ksk j"s%''' r7 -sls esa +kk lh l"h
+hd lh "h dks23 Hkjksls dh 5ksj "ekjs "kk +$ tk-s 0kSj .ldsl"kjs "e .l 0fookl] f/kdkj -oa GkOAkk dk leqnz rj tk-#% .ls
Hkh -slk "h +$k kk% .ls f9j -d 7kj Hkjksls dh 5ksj kkers
"q- e "h e ^k( esa $n3 >dh 0kSj 0k$s dk 7kd;k tks
ds f+- +56dh ds 0k$s f9j 0)h ft_klk _kEr dj nh
kh&^^;k ;kjh rs tkr 2kh 756h "S &lheks? fd .lds 9sj
f7, +ks$ 0)s ;kj w "h'''?(( +56dh 07 rd kk;n 2lh 2Urtkj esa .lds lkes $n3
>qdk;s k56h kh% da/ks )j ljd 0k;s h+s lk+w ls nq7kjk Pj
=#dk 0kSj nwljk 4ksj da/ks ds )h4s .4k+rs "q-] )"+s 0U;eLd
lh f9j r56)rh lh 0)h 7kr )j 0k $23 kh&^^"haZ'''.ls .dlk;k
$;k kk] ojk oks esjs k+ -slk h djrk'''rq"kjs tks ds 7kn
dq4 fn rd rks .ls "ekjh $+ 0I4h rj" djok;h] lk;s dh rj" esjs
)h4s&)h4s +$k j"k%''' d23 7kj o" Ldw+ esa esjs )h4s 0k;s
tKksa&7keAkksa ds +56dksa ls ekj Hkh kk23 0kSj eq>s
.dh 7qjh t6j ls 7,k;k Hkh''')j o" 0)h "h f7jknjh ds 0k$s
"kj $;k&.ls dq4 B"j dj -d Ba5h 0k" Hkjh&^esjs Gkj ls nks G
kj )js lh7ks rk23 dk ks56h eqa5k "S &djethr] oks rq"kjs
tks ds 7kn fnQQkh 0)s rk;s ds ;"k# ls )=6k23 4ks56dj Gkj
+kS 0k;k "S%''' -d fn .lh ek# ds ;kj s fjUdw dks] rqels esjh
7kr djkrs osk f+;k kk% djethr s "h fjUdw dks Hk56dk;k
kk&^ljnkjksa ds 4ksjksa ds f+-] rw# 0)h tkr nh dq56h dh
Hk56qok$hjh djrk "S?&^$qLls ls .lds $q+k7h "ksaB 956d
10
-
7/25/2019 Jooth
11/19
.Bs 0kSj ekks )j )lhs dh 7w#nsa 4+&4+k 0k23 kha% lhs
esa /kk56&/kk56 7trs fn+ dh /k56dksa )j dk7w )krs "q-] tjk
lk B"j -d 7kj f9j .ls 7kr 0k$s 7=6k23&djethr fnQ+h ls 7"qr
lh 23&23 7krsa lhk 0k;k "S% $+h ds 0kokjk eqa5ksa dks0)s ,kS7kjs )j 2dKBk djds le>krk f9jrk "S&"e
tK&7keAkksa ls 2rs eans 2lf+- "Sa] ;ksafd "ekjh 0kSjrsa
0kSj dqf56;k# 96k"kk-# "ksrh "Sa! .U"sa "es 0)s dk7w
esa "has jkk!! t7 rd "e . )j tksj 0kt6ek2k "ha
djsa$sF .U"sa )ns3 esa "ha jksa$s] r7 rd "e lIIks Pa"
)q`kj "ha 7 ldrs!!! '''o" rks ;"k# rd d"rk "S&t7 "ekjs Gkj7IIkk "ks rks .ldk 5h'-'-' sL djkk ,kf"-] ;ksafd nks$+h
0kS+knsa dnh 2d )k+s foIIk k5s6 j"dj jAk "ha ft\kk djrha!!!
''' fjUdw t7 ls djethr dh la$r esa )56k] r7 ls esjs r23a .ldh
t6j 7n+ $2 kh%''' /khjs&/khjs .ls esjh rqels 7kr djokk 7an
dj fn;k''' 0kSj 2l rj" rq"kjk t7 dHkh 0ks ok+k 9ks Hkh esjs
f+- )wjh rj" 7an "ks $;k kk!((
&^^eSas tk&7w>dj rq"sa 9ks djk de "ha fd;k
kk&lheks! rqe "ha tkrh eSa o"k# fdrk kd tkrk
kk%''';"k# 7k)w 0kSj ek# s dHkh 2rh es"r "ha djs nh]
lnk "h +k56 +56k;k 0kSj .ks''' Csfa$ esa d3+ es"r
ds 0k$s /kw)&4k#o dq4 Hkh "ha nsks nsrk kk% +k2
esa -d lwks k dh t56 .Bokrs rks esjk nk#;k )Sj "h 7qjh
rj" t6eh "ks $;k kk 0kSj eSa d23 fnksa rd 7s"kskh dh
"k+r esa d)h "kDL)h+ esa -5fe j"k kk] f9j eSa rqels
dSls 7kr djrk?(( .lds ^t7&dHkh( ok; )j 0,kd o" r5696
11
-
7/25/2019 Jooth
12/19
.Bk 0kSj .ldh 0k#ksa 4+&4+k 0k23a] 7ks+rs "q- .ldk $+k
Hkjk3 $;k%'''
)"+s t"k# 7kr&7kr )j @Bk ekk "ksrk% jkLrs esa ,+rs "q-
fdlh -d dks +$h tjk lh Bsl )j nwljs dk e /kd djds j" tkrk kk%dks23 dq4 d" ns] rks e .ls 9k56 kks dks .rko+k "ks
.Brk%''' )j 0kt tSls l7 dq4 B"j lk $;k kk% lkes tks d"k tk j"k
kk] oks -slk +$ j"k kk tSls ;" l7 rks dkks s )"+s "h ls lq
jkk "S 0kSj 07 ftldh 0koOf`k "ksk ksk "S% +56dh s $n3
.Bkdj ;aTor -d lwh f$k" .lds ,s"js )j 5k+h] f9j 0k#k )j
0kdj B"j $23 0)h Gkq#Gkjk+h L;k" + Bhd dh 0kSj )q, 0)h$n3 >qdk +h kh&^^djeohj dh 7krksa )j eSaw dHkh ;d6h
j"k +sfd fjUdw )j eq>s Hkjkslk kk] oks Hkh rq"kjh 7t6"
ls ''')j eSa knk tkAk ldh fd ;" djeft\ks dk lhk&Pkk;k "S ;k
rq"kjh 0ksj ls fe+ j"h lIIkk2;ksa dk flkAk''' eq>ls
d"rk&^lheks! kjthr "ok23 05K5s )j kSdj "ks $;k "S! oks
rq>ls e "ha ekrk!!''' 07 oks rq>ls "haF rsjs rs *;knk
)=6h&f+kh] )Sls okf+;k# tkr&f7jknj dq56h ls "h 0)k sF eSa dSls 2l /kksks ls 0)k e
jkw#$k?(( .ldk $+k @#/k $;k 0kSj "ks+h dh $fn;ksa ls 0k#ksa
ehats ds ,+rs dks-# 0kSj 5ksjs "h "ha] nn3 ds ekjs
0k#lq0ksa ls )qrk lkjk ,s"jk "h lqk36 "ks $;k kk% ftls )rk
12
-
7/25/2019 Jooth
13/19
"ha +56dh s ;ksa -d 7kj Hkh nsks dh t"er "ha
.Bk23% "ks+h dks 7kf+Lr dh k+ esa nk23a d)h ls +$kdj
$n3 >qdk-#] +$krkj t6eh Gkwjrh k56h j"h kh%
'''' f9j dq4 nsj dh ,q8)h ds 7kn -dk-d $n3 dks nwljh 0ksjdj kwU; esa -d +7h f$k" Hkjrs "q-] +56dh s .lk#l +h
kh&^^n$k rks esjs k+ "q0k "S&^rj( 0kSj k6rkokj eq>s
"h B"jk fn;k?(( 2l 7kj +56dh dks .ldh ^rqe +ks$ksa( ok+h
7kr kd $23 kh 0kSj o" Hkh -dk-d 0)s d"s )j kfe3Unk kk%
d+ rd ^0)k&0)k( 0,kd ^"ekjk&rq"kjk( dSls "ks $;k%
+56dh s ;k d"k .ls )rk "ha] fdUrq 2l 7kj .ldh 0)s d"s )jekjs ke3 ds $n3 >qd $23 kh% +sfd 07 rd 0)jk/kh dh rj"
k56h +56dh 2l 7kj ekS j" ldh% $+s esa )56s nq)Ks dk
-d dksk .#$+h esa +)s frj4k dj nk#r ls n7k- "q-] .lds dq4
0kSj djh7 0k $23 kh&^^tq$w! kkk eSa fjUdw ds d"s
.lds k+ "ks +h] )j eSas dnh 0kkk dk nkeAk h 45K5k!! -d
dq#56h "kss dk krjk 0kSj .l )j detkr "kss dk kkS96 rqe
dHkh e"lwl "ha dj ldrs&rj?'''' "esa -d 0ksj $qj7r dh ekj
fe+rh "S] rks nwljh 0ksj 2d 0kSj ;d6hh ds ke )j 96js7 0kSj
eR '''-d )+ "e lks,rs "Sa fd ;" l, "S] rks nwljs )+ o"F "ekjs
Hkjksls dh drh "eskk lqjkkksa ok+h "h ;ksa j"h'''?((
&^^)j ;" lqjkk eSaw rks h dh`kkF k "h j
-
7/25/2019 Jooth
14/19
ds )k f9j ,kSa56s "ks $- "Sa% la$e )j fe+s ls )wo3 "h nks
l"$keh fn;ksa s 0)s jkLrs 7n+] fo)jhr fnkk0ksa ds f+- )z;kAk
0kjaHk dj fn;k "S% Bhd .lh le; 7"qr nsj tks ;k lks,s ds
7kn] .ls +56dh ls /khjs ls )w4 "h f+;k&^ ;" l7 "q0kdSls''?(( 7kr dq4 2l rj" ls )w4h $23 kh fd lkes ok+s ds e )j
dks23 0kGkkr )56s 0kSj )w4s ok+s dks Hkh 7s0n7h dh
f$k" ls nskk tk-% t7ko nss ok+k Hkh 2rk 7skJj "ha
kk fd lkes ok+s dh lnkk;rk dks dkj dj] 0)s 0"a dks
.Hkkjrk%''' -d 0fookl dh ,ks ls fr+fe+k;k "q0k kk] rks
nwljk 4+ "ks tks dh "h$zafk ls Hk;Hkhr% l7U/kksa dk rkjrks56s esa nksksa "h 0lek3%'''
&^^'''.l fn 0ekol kh% ek# 7q0k ds Gkj jkoh )kj ek/kkS)qj
$23 "q23 kh% 7k)w lk#> ls "h =ksj&5a$jksa dh kSj&lqk
eks 7k7k Pb ,kkscdh lk+esa 0kjrh&0jnkl djrk] eq"QQks
ok+ksa ds lkk] fjUdw dh ,kS)k+ )j 7SBk "q0k kk%''' ks esa
/kqr 7lks+h ok+k lks"Ak ekek Vkj )j lks;k "q0k kk 0kSj eSa
0ka$ esa% '''f7 ,k#Ak lwh L;k" jkr esa o +k rkjs f"kjrh
rq"kjk 9ks 0ks )j 7"qr .nkl kh% ok"s $q@ >wB
7q+kok-] eq>s ftrk Hkjkslk rqe )j kk .rk "h fjUdw )jF +sfd
eSa ;" "ha tkrh kh fd 9q56dh )SAks djethr dh 7krksa esa
0kdj -s 0)s dks 2`kk f$jk +s$k'''%(( +56dh s e ls
.e56s GkOAkk ds *okj dks Rks/k ds lkk )zd djrs 7h, esa -d
+7h .lk#l +h 0kSj f9j 0k$s 7=6 $23 kh&^^Vkj )j /khjs ls
nks 7kj dqa5h kdh% eSas lks,k ekes dks 8;kl +$h "S 0kSj
o"h )kAkh ds f+-''' )j t7 njoktk kks+k rks lkes fjUdw kk% -d
"kk esa +kBh 0kSj nwljs "kk esa dksjnk f+-% eSas
14
-
7/25/2019 Jooth
15/19
)w4k&^rw#] 2`kh jkr $-?( .ls d"k&^"k#] rsjs 7k)w s Hkstk
"S ehBk jks 0kSj ,wjek nsdj] oks jkr ds rhljs )"j ek+&5a$jksa
dh Hkkjh.rkjs ds 7kn lq7" rd "h 0k )k-$k'''%( 0kSj .ls
7=6dj dksjnk esjs "kk esa )d56k fn;k kk&^+s kk +s'''%(
eSa f$ks56h l7z dj ldh% o" dksjnk 0)h eath
MkkN )j +stkdj kks+k 0kSj .lesa ls os fefB;k# jksf;k# 0kSj
,wjek fdk+dj kqkh&kqkh t6eh )j )Sj f"+krh kk .Bh
kh% fjUdw r7 rd lkes )56h nwljh wKh eath )j 0k 7SBk
kk% dq4 nsj 7kn t7 eSas .lls d"k&^tk`kk ;w# "ha?(.ls .Bdj 0Unj ls dqa5h ,=6k nh 0kSj esjh 0ksj )+ dj
7ks+k&^"ha[ '''rk;s s d"k "S lheks Gkj )j 0ds+h "S] rw
o"ha d tkk'''%( eSas d"k&^lqIIkh?( e esa -d 0kk kh
fd rq"kjk 9ks esjs )kl l"h fjUdw ds )kl t@j 0krk "ks$k 0kSj
.lls 0kt th Hkjdj rq"kjs 7kjs esa 7kr d@#$h% ''')j ;" ;k? .ls
esjs nskrs&nskrs njo**ks dh dqa5h Hkhrj ls ,=6k nh 0kSj
0k$s 7=6dj rkks esa jkk nhok Hkh 7q>k fn;k kk%
c' dOAk dk ledk+h 8katk7 dh Hk$r M,ekjN tkfr dk -d ;ksbk 0kSj 8kkq0ksa dk
nso] ftls 0KBkj" fn eQQk;qb ds .)jkar dOAk .ls 4+ ls "h )jkLr dj )k- ks%
' okk3 rq esa 8kkq0ksa ds eq#"&kqj dh 7hekjh ls jXkk ds ffe`k "kss
ok+h -d jLe%
' lk+ ds 0fUre fn 0/k3jkfT dks =ksj&5a$jksa ds J)j ls jks$ 7k/kk "ks dk
ksdk%
eSaw kk ls .Bdj .ls "kAkk ,k"k] )j 0)s )Sjk# )j
k56h j" ldh% Pj esa -slh Gkqesj .Bh 0kSj +$k fd tSls lkjk
0ka$Ak "h .88kj&fIIks "ks j"k "S% "kk ls ,wjek Hkjk
15
-
7/25/2019 Jooth
16/19
dksjnk 4w $;k 0kSj )Sjk# dh Bksdj ls t6eh )j )kh Hkjk
4UUkk% 0$+s 7kr eSa ds k lh kk )j kh] f9j eSaw )rk
h dh "ks;k& dkf9j ,wjesa esa )"+s ls "h 7s"kskh dh nok
fe+k +k;k kk% ''''7"qr nsj $- t7 "ksk 0k;k rks nn3 ds ekjsesjk "k+&7s"k+ kk% +$k fdlh s dej ls h,s 0anj "h 0anj
)Sh fdj, ,+k nh "ks] ftlds nn3 ls eq>s 07 ftUn$h Hkj 4qdkjk
"ha fe+s$k? eSa ,k"dj Hkh kk ls .g h )k j"h kh% 0k#k
kq+ha )j tq7k ls dks23 "j96 "ha 9w j"k kk% +$rk tSls
fdlh 7sdk7w lk#56 s 0)h Bksdjk# ls lkjs 7n dk Hkqjdqk
fdk+ fn;k "ks 0kSj eSa k+ ls rks56&ejks56 dj 9sad fn- de+9qQQkk# eqj>k23] kk )j 0+$ )56h kh% lkes fjUdw )k;tkes
dk k56k dlrk )hB 9sjdj k56k kk% .ls tSls "h esjh djk"
lqh rks o" esjh 0ksj eqkkfr7 "q0k] .l fn .ldh 0k#kksa esa
-d 0th7 7"kh)k kk&^rw# esjh tkr nh dq56h "S ] 0kSj 2l
okLrs rq> )j )"+k "d esjk "h 7rk "S? 07 rw# 0t6kn "S fdlh
tK&7keAk ls ;kjh djs okLrs'''%(( +56dh s ddj -d $"jh
.lk#l +h%
&^^7k)w ls "ha d"k?(( +56ds s dq4 EGk+rs Loj esa d"k%
&^^ek# ls d"k kk% 4wrs "h 7ks+h&,q) j" ejtkAkh[ oks
rq>ls ;kjh ekrk "S] "ks $23 "ks$h dks23 Hkw+&$6+rh%
'''0)h tkr nk )q`kj "S] 7k)w ls d"dj .lls rsjh dq56ek23 djok
nsa$s'''!((
&^^tkr! *kkr!! *kkr!!! ;" tkr ;k 7+k "S lheks[? ftlds 0k$s lkjs
$qk" ek9 "ks tkrs "Sa] 2alkf;r Hkh 0)k lj >qdk +srh "S
0kSj 8;kj&)zhr ns krs Hkh eans )56 tkrs "SaF ;k 2ldk ja$
16
-
7/25/2019 Jooth
17/19
"ekjs +"w ls Hkh $k=6k "S&lheks[?(( o" -dne f9j 9w )56k
kk%
07 )rk "ha o" Lo;a .)hf56r "kss ds 7kn Hkh lfn;ksa
ls 0)jk/kh B"jk23 tkrh j"h LTh e dh 0kk+kf kh] ;k lkesk56s Ez; Vkjk 0)k +ss ;k Bqdjk fn- tks ds 7h, dk Hk; fd
+56dh -dne ewfr3or "ks $23 kh% 2/kj 0kosk esa 0kdj tkfr
ds fojks/k esa d"s dks rks o" Hkh 7"qr dq4 d" $;k] fdUrq
.lds Hkh 0)s dq4 laLdkj ks% e esa dq4 0lq+>h $qfk;k#
kha] ftdh $k#B .ls Lo;a "ha +$k23a kh fdUrq o" .ls
7a/keqr Hkh "ha "ks )k;k kk% ftds 0qlkj 7+kdOr "q23+56dh .l twB Hkjss )`k+ ds lek "S] tks f9j fdlh ds kks
;ks; "ha j"rhF .ls dq`ks] dkSos 0kSj ,w"56s "h kkrs
"Sa%
;" fo,kj 0krs "h 8;kj fdl f,f56;k dk ke "ksrk "S] fn+
;ksa ok esa "ha j"rk "S? lk#lsa ;ksa d tkrh "S? tq7k# )j
fdlh dk ke 0krs "h ;ksa eq#" esa k"n lk Gkq+ tkrk "S?
;ksa "tkjksa dksl nwj "kss )j Hkh fdlh ds 0kl)kl "kss dk
0"lkl 7k j"rk "S% .ldk e -d 0th7 lh GkOAkk 0kSj f+tf+tk" ls
Hkj $;k kk% e "q0k fd o" o"k# -d )+ Hkh k56k j"s] +kS
tk- 0)s Gkj'''% o" eq56k 0kSj 0k$s 7=6k fdUrq )Sj fBBd $-%
+$k lheksa s dq4 d"k "S&^rj! kqe Hkh eq>s 2alk "ha
0)h fefQd;r le>s] tks 07 +q ,qdh "S''' 7jk7j nk ;kj&7s+h
"ha 7klAk Hkj khj ekk] tks 07 fdlh dk twB "S''' rks tq$w!
"e o" nksksa "h "ha ks!! *kk0ks[''' rqe Hkh tk0ks&th
+sa$s "e rq"kjs f7k!!!( o" Gk756k $;k%''' )h4s eq56dj
nskk rks +56dh 07 Hkh Pj >qdk- ,q),k) k56h kh% .ls
17
-
7/25/2019 Jooth
18/19
0k,;3 "q0k fR;k dh )zfrfR;k nskdj] tks l7 t$" kh 0kSj d"ha
"ha'''! .ls rqjar 0)h Hkw+ dk 0"lkl fd o" ;" ;k lks, 7SBk
0)h lheks ds 7kjs esa!!&&j
-
7/25/2019 Jooth
19/19
' )atk7 dh )zPb )zse$kkk ^lks"h(&ef"ok+( esa ofAk3r -d nhMf,koN] ftls Gk56s ds l"kjs rSj dj )kj djrh lks"h 0k/khjkr dks 0)s)zseh ef"ok+ ls fe+s tk;k djrh kh% -d fn lkl ds d"s )j lks"h dhn s fooklGkkr esa )ds Gk56s dh t$" dIIkk Gk56k jk fn;k 0kSjt7 o" .ls +sdj nh )kj "q23] rks .lesa 5w7 ejh kh%
19