I .~,..U- ..,-,,.,. ,, <";T} .. ~ •:.T,...,, .. ,, •'• ~;.··'H'•J<l'IL~'""-'..H'O'.<<l("-,"T<' ... ..:'.UI.'• (., .......... ~ ·~~~~ .. i'l.,~M ..... 1"""' l">-.,tt"#.lo'<~-·.v ........ ~;:i.~,,;'..-.,."""'"'~--. ..... ,.,,,.,.~-.v~~"\. .. ,.,,.., .>I"''....._., .... ':.,!"..¥.."""' ............. ,.,.:»:;,,·.-.,~~~ ... ,.,,,_,~....:;.,,.., .. -...,~~ ... -.;;i.~·T-~'V"1'"1<' ~J.'NT~-'<L"' ..... ·'PY1~, .... .,._.,,1W~-~~-~...,.~ ... ,...,.,.'f_~ llY<'t ........... ~ ... -"V>1"~-.,, i.r ........ ·.ct; W.f~~"l:l' ~ .... ~.L ... "i>'<~~....-.... n ....... ,.

, ,; ,,_:·· ~--·f:;~:;. ·-/;. ~:~~~.~iL.;·;,.:.E~;:~~.i,~i£~~2~Ll~ ·,.:-

A 7

s l

APPLICANT:

· .. 'r, •

J.,i?:. :"NOA R ITEM

voe

REtREATIONAL PIER PERMIT

09/27/90 W 1124.38 PRC 7459 J. Ludlow

Jam~s T. English and Sarah Jean ~nglish P. 0. Do>< 483 K~ntfield, Californ~a 94904

ARE~. TYPE LAND· AND LOCATION:

l-ONO USE:

A parcel cif submerged land· iocated in La~e Tahoe at Moana Be~ch~ Placer Coynty.

Retention. reconstruction. and a 22-foot extension to an existing pier including the installation of a low leue) boatlift and the retention of two mooring buoys.

TERMS ·of PROPOSED 'PERMIT:

In';i tial period·: Five year~ beginning September '1. 1990.

CONSIDERATION: R;·nt-f'ree pursuc.'nt to Sectior. 6503. 5 of the P. R .C.

BASIS ·fOR CONSIOERATION: Pursuant to 2 Cal. Code Reg~. 2003.

APPLICANT STATUS: Applicant is owner 0r upland.

PREREQUISITE CONOITIONS, FEES, ANO c;\P.f.l'JSES: Fil~n9 fee and processing costs haue been received.

-1-

f~~~.GE 6~ i f MtNtrrt: ~4.GE . -2-14_....2 __ ' • .......

I ...... i;-. • ..r>HY ...... ,.:;.-,,,...,~ •• t- •.\~!; ;:,./'u;>ttt-; • • 'l-':t~.i'W• .i",.'!.•·r•""""•"'l""'Jl.'•..:oill' ,,,. .. ......,...,. .... A~U1 ....... .!- .... "'"'""''""'">'l" .. ~17'~ •'!<.'l'•'f'"M'>'l;" ...... ~\"'-~"·~vl"il.""-"-~"'·"'1~"'o.>. ''L~~V:f ... .<'"'l'..>'!o-;>l., ...... •.iooN'«::. ...... ~P._~11;"'>'.' ..... ':0.~,.. ~ .... ~ ... ~A...-v...-~ ... .o.~- '.-0.li""f~~· .. ;itP.-,.-A.•i.wi.•.lf-~~,"'!f"~.D--~"..?\-~ ....... '1.•\r,t.,..,,,.._-'lf',,-.r,,•~it<l..' ...... ' ,.,..,.~.,:>~-.l'L:';.~·"" ·,~.,.....,,.. __ ,I' ~..,

' '

' .... ' ".

CALENDAR ITEM NO. c () fj (CONT'D)

. STATUTORY ANO OTHER REFERENCES:

AB 884:

A. P.R.C.: Oiu. ,5, Parts land 2; Div. 13.

8. Cal. Code Regs .. Title 2~ Div. 3; Title 14, Div. 6.

01/26/91.

OTHER PERTINENT INFOR_MATION: 1. Pursuant to the Commjssion's delegation of

authority and the State CEQA Guide1ines, (14 Cal. Code 'Regs. 15025), the staff haf prepared a Proposed Negative Declaration identified as EIR ND 491, State Clearinghouse No. 89091114. Such Proposed· Negative Declaration was prepared and circulated for public r,eview pursuant to the pro~isiohs of C~QA.

,Based upon the Initial Study, the Proposed Negative Declaration, and thP comments received in respon~e thereto, there is no substantial evidenc6 that the project wil~ have a significant effect on the environment. (14 Cal. Code Regs. 15074~~))

2. This activity involves lands identified as .possessing significant environmental values ·pursuant to P.R.C. 6370, et seq. Based upon the staff's consultation with the persons nominating such lands and through the CtQA review process, it is the staff's opinion that the proj~ct, as proposed, is consistent w:ith its us~ classification.

3, The Department of Fish and Game has determined that the shorezone at this location is unsuitable habitat for Tahoe Yellow Cress (Rorippa) and has issued, pursuant to consultation under the California End~ngered Species Act (CESA), a letter of "no jeopardy 11 for ,the proposed pr·ojec t:.

4. The property was physically inspected by staff for purposes of evaluating the impact of' the proposed acti i~i ty on the pub] ic trust.

-2-

1' 0 i CALEN~AR ~~~M,~O: v , (CONT'D)

5. In order to ~etermine the other =Potential trust uses in the area of the proposed project. 'the staFf contacted representatives of the following agencies: TRPA, Department of Fish and Game. County of Placer. and the Tahoe Conservancy. None of these agencies expressed a concern that the proposed project would have a significant effect on trust uses in the area. The agencies did ~ot identify any trust needs which were not ~ein~ met by existing facilities in the area. Identified trust uses in this area woulQ include swimming. boating. walking along the beach. and views oF the lake.

6. All permits :issµod at Lako Tnhoc inc)udQ special lariguage in which the permittee/lessee agrees to protect and replace or restore. if required. the ha bi tat of' Rorippa subumbel lat a. •commonly called the Tahoe Yellow Cress. a State-liited end~ngefed plant species.

7. If any structure hereby authorized is found to be in nonconformance with the Tahoe Regional Planning Agency's Shorezone ordinance. and if any alterations. repairs. or removal required pursuant to sajd ordinance are not accomplished with~n the design~ted time ~eriod. then this ledse is a6,omatically terminated. effective upon notice by the S~~te. and the site shall be cleared pursuant t~~h~ terms thereof. If the locaiio~. size. or nu~~er of any structure her~e!.;:!I .·author:ized is to be altered. purstiant to order of the Tahoe Regional ~lanning Agency. Less~e shall .request the consent of State to make ~uch alteration.

a. The Applicants h~ve been notiFied that the public has a right to pa~s alor.g the shoreline and the permitt6e must prouide a reasonable means for public passage along the shor~zone area occupied by the permitted struct~re.

-3-

CAl:ENOAR ITEM NO. c 0 5 (CONT'D>.

APPROVAL~ OBTAINED: Tahoe Regional Planning Agency. Department o~ Fish and Game. and Placer County.

FURTHER APPROVALS REQUIRED:

E'Xfil81TS~

United States Army Corp-s of Engineers.

A. Land Description. ,o. Location Map. C. Placer County Letter of Approval. 0. Negative Declaration E. Fish and Game Letter of N~ Jeopardy.

IT IS RECOMMENDED THAT TH~ COMMISSiON:

1. CERTIFY THAT A NEGATIVE DECLARATION. EIR ND 491. STATE CLEARINGHOUSE NO. 89091114. WAS -PREPARED FOR THIS PROJECT PURSU~NT TO tHE PROUISIONS OF THE CEQA AND THAT THE COMMISSiOrJ HAS REVIEWED ANO CO.NSID(RED THE INFORMfiTJON CONtAtNEO THEREIN.

2. OElERMlNE THAT THE PROJECT. AS APPROVEti. WILL NOT HAVE A SIGNIFICANT EFFECT ON THE ENVIRONMENT.

3. AUTHORIZE ISSUANCE TO JAMES T. ENGLISH ~ND SARAH JEAN ENGLISH Of A FIVE-YEAR RECREATIONAL PIER PERMIT. BEGINNING SEPTEMBER 27. 1990 FOR TUE 'RETENTION. RECONSTRUCTION, AND 1 1A 22-FOOT EXTENSION Of AN EXISTING PIER INCLUDING THE lNSTP.l.l.ATlON or A LOW LEVEL eoni·LIFT ANO THE RETENTJO~J Of-

\, - ~ ; ' ' ' nm M"'0R1NG BUOYS ON THE LAND DESCRIBED ON EXHIBIT ::fi'!!·

ATTAc'~:EO, A-NO BY REFERENCE MADE A PART HEREOF.

-4-

llr.-•i•·" '·~'!., ·~-... .... ~.~-, ~"""~""'•'-'~'""'.:~..nt~•' ""'"' <'<~' .,. ..... ~J'-'.V<'...,.>&M..~r,.n~ ~._...._, •• ..,.~_,,.11i'frlVJv ~r~"'<._._.....,,'l"f~ 'ru.;..•~'""''" ,~ .. \o..~ -"''"~~"~.i-"l'<'°' ......... .....,..-1,,,l.r;.:J<U.,.~•~,....,,_""'-'V,..,,,~(),.,._._.._.,_,~vn,. -4''-<Ud..,~1~.,..w>;.~t"i ·~"'-..,......,,KR,.,. _,_~ry~'.v".'" ............... ""ll"""'t-.......,...~~....,_,_.,,._.,..,~~>·V-...,.if"'lt,...1i ~, ,,.., ~~iv.;.....-,.....,.~ ..... ......-.. ~";!:i. • 4.,. "'

LAND DESCRIPTION ~

!Ke>'~ -bl':$7 <1}6'SJMl-l41!e:._ ~,~ '/.1'~~"'11

~~ -~-- ---)'}(Al...l<W~r: ~

, .,

REV!SE!l' .!!$/#d/

': . .

EXHIBIT "A" w 1124. 38

I-A/$~ Prepared by Judy ;t..udl'cw · '. on 9/12/89

, I

~ ' ' ' I ' "~

.fXHlBir .. B .. w~·t24.380.:

Sunnysld<>

-. a.\ a:

\

T.14N.

T 13 N

UJ UJ ,..., tO

a:: ex:

T 12 N

OPtJU.rN<;~~ .__,aw.ft r...-..~ ~........_~. ~.t4...0~1-t', s-...~ ~ Tr--

,PLACER COUNTY

,JU,ciy t-udlov Cal!forraia State ·1.anda Cou.niaission 1807 - l~th Street Sncra~~ri~o~ ~A· 95814

RE: !!ER - SBOREZOHg CONSTRUCTION

EXHIBIT "C .. w 1:124. 38'

D~PARTMENT OF,PUBLIC WORKS n

JACK WARREN. Di~or JAN WITTER. Assistt.nt D:tKtor LARRY ODDO. Deputy Directot , Al.AN RO'r·. Deputy OJtectO.-

March 3, l989

Th~' County of Placer has reviewed thP. helt'V· referenced\ rec.uects for construction activities wit~in the Sho~ezone of Lnke i~ho~: Ye have no object ion. to the construction acd.'v.i ties described in the belov.appltcsticns contingent upon approval by y~ur office.

1. ,E. S. Bertagnolli PRC 3209 .• 9 2. Charlotte and ~obert Angell w 24144 3. Sueet/Avane'BaiaP PRC 5.022 4. Vic kl and PRC 35,99 s. Lyons/Hawkins WP 5884 6. Hein - 83-1.62-28 PRC 6714 7 .. Hein - 83-t62-31

"' 24134 a. McFarland PRC 3659 9. t;tbb WP 3652 10 .. Crabtree u 21445 11. ~ng'l1sh 1l 1124.38 12. Wallis PRC 4314 13. Meta a: y 24103 1, 4. ·Barrow PRC 71,67.9 1 s .. Nahas PRC 4066 16:. Hicks w 21665

Should you ha;.-~ any qu~stions or if I can be of further assis­tance• ?lease· e.10i·l at you:- convenience.

COUNTY OF PLACErt or.:eA'atuENT -or eu»t1c JACK ~ARREN, DIRECTO_.. __ __

,.. .... , ' \ - .. . ,

E..'CHIBIT "D"

~An~C'Al.'.IFOtUM ============'=============='=============~aeoAGE~~DE~~~llt!E:;:M~M~~~=~=-= n•============-'·======-..: STATE 'LANDS COMMl3SION LECIT.McCARYHY. LAu~~ GRAY DAVJS. Comrot»i'

£XEa.imfE OFFICE , 007 ~ 13$ $tr\?fl

~-C;A~tl CWAALES WARREN ~~· JE3SE R. «tiff. ii~{tl Fiiwti:8

Project Title:

Project Proponent:

Project Location:

Project DCscription::

Contact Person:

English Pier Reconstruction/Extension

James T. English

EIR ND: 491

File Ref.: W -U~~ja

SCH., _NO.: 89091114

4~ Tahoe. Plileer County adJ~t to APN: 98-191-17, 36 Moona Circle ·

Pier reconstru~on/exte~on and installation of one-low-level boatlift. The project aiso involves the permitting of the pi~r and two mooring buoys which· are currentfy unauthorized

Judy.Brown ,Telepho~: (916) 3244715

This document is prepared pursuant to the rt~iremcnts of the Califomiit EnVi:onmental Quality Act (Section 21000 et seq., Publk Resc~urces Code}. the State CEQA Guideliiles (Section 15000 et seq .• Title 14, Califoreia ·Code ~egulations), and the Stzte Lands Comm~ion regulations (~ction 2901 ct seq., TitJe 2, California Code Regulations}.

Based upon the attached Initial Study.·it has been found that:

LX/ tlaat project will not have a ·significant~ effect on the environmenL

LI mitigation metiUres included in the project will ~vcid potentially significant effects.

FORM 13.17 (4/90)

' ' ' '

' ' ;>' _,, ~ ,. '~ '

.·' ii ~,.-,.. • 't -: ,~',' ,','~,t,·:~5 .<'!:2 z::~2'' ; .. :M::~~@Mi;h~~;~ :}

STATE LANDS q>Al!MlSSION

E~Y~RO~ENTAL l~ACT ASS1!...m1Em' CHEC_~LiST - P~AT If Form, l3J!O (Jl!J2)

w 1124.38 Fife Ref.:.__ ______ .__

I. BACKGROUND INFORMATION

A. ~-s>P!ieatat: __ J_ame_··_s_t_. _£n_g1_.t_·s_h _________________________ _

P.O. Box 483 Kentfield, CA 949()9

B. O!Kklist Oatit: 07 I 2i I 99. c. Coniact Person: Ju~ Drown

~~--~~---~-,-~-~-----~~~

Teftphooe: ( 916 ) 324-4715 1

o. ~~~- To bring under.Permit, an ~xisting unauthori~ed pier and two moorir9 buoys. The project will also involve some ~:odifica~ions to the existing pier.

E. Location: In la~~Tahoe adjacent to Moana Circle ~- MCKinney Bay northwesterly of Tahoma, :Placer County.

F. :Description: Pier recohstructio~xt~nsion and installation ~f one low lev~~ boat1ift. The project also invo1'ies· the permitting of the pier ·

· · , · rv:a .. _. ·nr= ·t' c- ..,- r:==ir==rn:::::z=; _., .. ••... -- ...

-and two moorini buo1s which are currently unauthorized.

ii. ENVIRONMENTAL lM?.ACTS. IE~ln 11ll "1iw"' Dnd ~m~·· aMWlU'S}

A. &nh. Will the Pf~ mutt in: Yu r.btbt nlo

0 0 , ry 1. \:.::ist.lbie emh ccnditiom Qt dian9" in 'OIO'O!Jic sumtn.1<;:ura?. . • • • . • • • • • • • • • • • . • • • • • • • • U\

2. OiuU$)tlons. d®llalrncrnu. eompect~n. or owcrcoVillins of tho 111•''" • • • • • • • • . • • • • • . • • • • • • • • • • . ,0 0 IJ D D r::

3. 0\&!1911 in top~y or grcund surfico relief featuresL ...••••.••••.•••. ~ • • . . . • . • • • • . • . . . _. LA

4. Tha d~truetion. cowrin<J. or modifla ticn of any uniquo geotogie er ph-.,siad features? • • • • • . • • • . • • • • 0 0 [j s. An-1 Uicre~ in wind or vntw erosicm C?f soilli, oi~~ O!I or utf the si1e1 .••••••• '" .•••••• : • • • • • • . • 0 0 fX

' "

1. Substantial air emmiui~~' 01 ~lff1ot~1ton of ~b~nt1ti1 quality? .•••••••••••••••••••••••.•••

2. The cre.ation of nbj:ctionJi~le od~s?. • • • • • • • • • •••••••••• ~ •••••••••.•••••.••••••••••

3. Afteraticn of air movement. moi~ture or tempetilh.'fe. or any ch~n9t in climate. eittier locally er regionally?.

C. f~otrr. Will ~he propm.-tJ ruull in:

0 o· [xi· 0 [] t~i f] I. i t

I. ·Ch.t.ns~s in thl' cuuetit1, ot tht cC:m~ c! ~1rf!ction of water mo~ments.1n tither marine or frnh w1tt1s7 • • LJ f · IX I 2. Changl!s in .lbsOrption ratts. diainag~ p:tterns, <:>r tht! rate .and ,11mounl of surbce w.ater runoff1 ••••••.•• · r1

·,' ··1 3. Alterations to the! course 01 flow of llood waters?. • • • • . . ..•..••. , ..•••••..••.•••.•..•..•

4; Change in th!i ;mount ~f surf~ Wl>'tltt in any wate-1 bod~? .•...•••..•.•••.•.••. ~ ... ~. • • • . • • {] I . I . I

'x' I :

b(I

ix: S. Ot.charcje-into, amflic"~ .~;itori, or in lov ~lttuitlnn of surf~! water qu.,lltv. including but no.t limir1td to

Jltf'nl'C!f.ltur~. di~:~t"d ! •V~ or ~mbiditv1. • • • . • • • • . ••••••••••••• ·-•·•·- _ .... ,.=·!-~ •.• , •. LJ lxl· I I ~. Alt!.'t"ation of the du~ct em or rate of flow of ~oum watets> •• , •••••••••••••••••••••••••••••

' . [] 1 · i ix I 7. Change in the quinri1y of ground waters. either through d11Kt additions or withdrawals. or thro•J;h inter·

ception oS an aqu11ef' b-1 c-.1u er exC41Vations7 • • . . • • • ••.•••••••• , •••••••••• ,. ••••••••••••

3. $ub$i<tnti,iJ r«fuclion in dl<r amount Qf W"llU OlhltrWtSt. &Yii~lc for public \V~lt.f $UppJio\? , •••••••••• . 9. ExposUti: or Pt?OPl:t or properiv to watti·relatw haurds such.,, floodin~ or tidal wavH? •.••..••••••••

10, Si9-">ifiQn~-~anr',Jes l;\, the ti!mper?ture. flow or chemical content of surfoce ther~I ~r\r.;s? ••••••.••••

0. l'/11111 I.if-... V/111 tht- PfO!K>J;tl 1f'Su!t in:

1. Chtinge io 1h~ clivetsity of sPl?O't!S. ct nun~r of anv SPKies or plints (including trees. s,~rubs. gr~s. c:tOPi. •md~UJ:tt;cpt.,nts}?~ •••••• ~·,· •• ,'\ ••••••••••• ; •••• • ••• ;~·· ••••••.••••••••••••• · •••

< •

2. Recluc:llun of th« numb1rn ahny ~nique~·rM• or end~ttv.hpocici of pli.its? •••••••••••••.••••••

J. inttuductioo"of new sp"'in "of plants.into bn area. or, in; barrier to l~ normal replenishtntnt of existing s~ies? •••• , •••••• ~ ~ .' ••••••••. .' •••••.••• • • • • • • · • • • • • • • • ~ • ~ • • • • • • • • .,. ·: : • '·· · ·

4. ~,edm:.rion in acre~ of .any agrit:uhurzl ~n>p? · ••••••••••.•••• ~ •••••••••••••••••••••••.•

E. :lt~in1al l.ifr. Will the prop~ iesult in:

f .• . . LJ 0 l.·l

'-, I I

IJ

IJ f.J

I ix i iX i

I ix: 1 · ! I , :

.X ~

l :x'i I I :xi

I iX'j

r ix I

I. 0!$"<1(' io lhe d;tt'friity of ~P!f..~. ~' nuntMtl of tllil\HPK•ei of Mlim,,IJ (~rdi, c:and 11nirnoi, including f. -. J f ttptUitt. f1\h and'itifllfish. b!nttitc crganiims. 01 imKh)? •• , , •••••••.••••. ''" ............ , ••• :x J

,, I :X . 2. Rec:«tion of tt.e numb-its. Oi any uniqU., r.are Or endit1gt11!\1 S~iH of ~imah? •. ,,. . • . • • • . . • . • . • • • t ~} ,f 3. Jntroduc1ion of n-tw sp.:cies t.r CMima!s into an ~rea. 01 t4n.ul1 in a baniu to die migration cu mo'!~tmmt of

·"1ima1s? ...•.•.•..• .; ..••. , .•. ·~~ ......................... '-..... ~ ...... : .......... : 4. Deterioration to uii1ine1 fiSh or wildlife habilat7 ••••••••••••••••••••••• : •••••..••••••.•.••

F. ,\'r1iV!. W~U the.> snoposnr retult in:

t. tnaeo.:sC 10 uis~ing noise levels?. •L• ••••••••••••••••.•••••••••

2. Exc>osure of p:op!.e to s~re.noisc !e~ls7 •••••••••••••••••••••

G. Ll~ht am! Clu.·,.. ~II lh'l prof)OScl riHult in:

. ..... ·-~ ................... .

. ........ "' ..... ~· ...... .

1~ The p:oducrion cf ne. fivbt c1 nl&1u7 ••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••• ~ •••••

If. /.11ml U.U". \V•lt th't' proP.~a! rnU:i ill:

t. A subs"nt!.al afwr~ticn of,the prnenr or planmcllamt iJSe of an areul? •••••••••••.••..••• ~ •..•••

I. Naturol Hf'Wt1TC'J'+ Wilt the prnpnut re~li in:

'[J' .(~fj: 'i . i . r.1 k i ~~ i

f..,, r ·J ·1x 1· ·-' l. '

1. fn<:rel$Se in the rate of ..n~ o"lin!f nar1.iraJ rCSC>Utc:esl ••• ~ •••••••••• , ••••••• , •• •••••••• •'.,. ••• ; •

2. ~ubs~anti.ll d~plttion of "'8'/ nonrr.i&wM>l•.r1t®rc~? ••••••••••••••••••••••••••••• ·: •••• , ,',

0 l] ~!. ·f:l·.· · I -1 ~ ·:

- • • a.iC:x7·· < <' ' ' 4

~~~;15'C--· 2-

) ·,

'

J. RIV. 11l ('~t. Con t~ pto-p~ rnult'in:

t. A r~ nf .an explosion or the re!e~c of h.azlltdous wb$tMces {inch.ICSing, tiut Mt lirrntDd to. oil. p,nticides. .::hemit:als. Of radiation) in the event ofan ~e:M:!attt Qr UtntJt cond;~ions? ••••••.•••••••.••••••••.•

2. Possible in!trfc-rim.ze ~ith ~m~ rei.ponw pl=n or an ~rgancy e.acuati~ plan? •••••••••.•••••

K. 1•np11kti1m, :Wiil lhtt propouil r~ul1 in:

1. Tha 1>t~t<lfiO.:~. d~tributitm~/~nsiiy, or growth ~ate of b'le human pc)pulatiM of tf!e arta7 ..••.•••.•••

L :llouliJR. wm tt.e prripcsa! r~t in:

l. Affec~irig ~~!ing ~. ~ ett<l~ a dimmtf f~1 ~iticnal housing? •••••..•.•••••.••••• ~-.- •••

M. Tnur..pc;ittitianf<."in:a'4!it11t. wm.~.e JK"~f rimJtt ii]:

'Yes M&ybe No

·O 0 00 'P D l!l

D 0 00

0 0 00

1. ~•lma:io!1 ct .s~iantial ~itioMhotik.-uw ~nt? •••...•••.••..••...•.••....•.. , . • • • CJ 0- [] 1; ·~ffCC:ling ctAiStifli1 pa.tkin, V~.litm, Of Ct64tC <l ~C!Nnd for ne"N parking?, • , ••••.•• , , .••• , •••• , , • 0 LJ oct 3. Substant~~I imJm:t u:;>on existing transpcrution rtstems?.... • •. • • • • • • • • . • • • . • • • • • • • • • . ..•• ,0 Q, ,I!] ~- AlteratiOl1:l to Pt'C'Mmt ~tt4rns of cirwl&~., or mo~1t of ~e Md/or ~7 . • • • • • • • • • • • . • • • EJ 0 [KJ 5. Alt'Jt.iltt0ft5 to ~air:.l>Qme, r&il. or einr&ff.ic? •• ; .••.•.•••••••.••• ,. • • • • • • • • • . • • . . • • ... • • • 0 0 ~]

6. ·fricfHS4! in t•~ffic ha;;u<fs to motor wtlkt~. bkyc.llst;, or pel!:o-ttricns? •••••.••••••••••••••••••• ·O. 0 l!J . •

f.J l'ublif' -~-n:1i:n. ~-II· thllt'pro~ Juve an eficct upon, or result in a med for new M aJ;e~ gowmmentill wvice in .my of the fr.ltlUwin~jarem:

1. Fire ?t~te-:tion? ••••••••••• , ............................. ~ •.•••..•. ., .•.....•• \

2. Po!it:e.r.JOC~tion? ••••••••••• .' ••••• , • • • . • • • • • • • • ••••••••••••••••••••••• , ••••• . .

J: 'Sd'tC>Ott1 •••••••••••• .; ............................. ;. ........................... .

4. Patlu ~J other recrea;tional f~tit~7. . • • •. • . • . • . • . . . • • . • • • • • • . • . . • . • • . • .. • • . . • . . ....

5. rdaint~ of ~bH.:: facilities, inctuding roam? •••••••••••••.•••••••••••••.••••.•••••••

6. Other 90vernmffitaf SIUV~1 •••••••••••• . ................ ·-. . . . . . . .. . . . . . ........ -0. f.~rrx.•·· \YIU tlw ,~ropos.al mu!J in:

•

[J tJ !iJ D 0, lil [j [j Iii tJ D liJ 0 [j !!J 0 0 .OCI

0 D r;i 1, u.e of t.tib~U.Oti:ai &11'110W1ts of f~t or cn~flWr ••.••••....•••• ,. . . . . . . • • • . • • • . . . • . . . • . ... . . l~

2. Subst<ll'lr:al inaeisil W. d~ UfJCI\ existi.'lg S9 .... ,~cs of energy, or requue th.u dlS".-elopnent of naww\rrM1 • tJ 0 00' P .. U1ili1in. ·~li•I tha pro~..oil result in .a need fen new systerm, 01 ?Jbst.w'lti.2l al-.~tlilt1om to t:te foll~ utilities:

1. Power ~ natura.'l 9§? . • • . .. • • • . . • • • . . . • . • • . . • . . . . • • . . . • . . . • • . . . • . • . . . . • • • . .. . . . . .

?· C'ommuniQtiun 1i'.flt1HnS1 • • • .. • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • ••••••••••••••••••••••••••••

'3. \Vat~?. • . • • • •••••••...•.•••••••.•.••••••••••..•• _ ••••••...••••.••••...•.•. :

4. $ew(.'f' ~ ~~ie ~ks? ••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••• ~ ••••••••••• ~ ............. .

'S. Storm water_dqun;ga? • • • • • • • • • . • ••••.••••••..•••••. ~ •.••••.••••••• _ .• ~ •••••••••

6. :;,,lid \oYUte ant1 d~7 ••••• , • , • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • , •••••••••.••• ,,, •• • • , , , • ,• ••.• •

0.- 'lltt_m=Jl Ht"Ollh. Will ~ ~J rcwlt Sn:

'. CN.tti~n ot UI\' h'Ul'lh Juurd Ct' PQ,t:ntiai hudtl\ hu&Sd (oxduding mental health) 1 ••••••.••.•••.•.

2. Exp.cs~• of S»oi:>le to potcn\tS! hedt!li.'~1 ••••••••••••••••••••••••••..•••••••••.•• R. Aa:hl!litt Will tho propoul nnuit ~:

Q [) 00 0 CJ 00 D 0 i~J 0 D. t!J 0 .0 00 q 0 !Kl

[j '0 i&'.:. o· .o ,OCJ

1 -n,_ o"'-t~-;- of &n"''S<:!nic vista er view ,, .... n to the nublic. or will the proposal result in the creat?on of """ .,,. ·-~""' • ..~ .. - o- ''x'_ ['J &n illCSthelic~Uy offctr4iwuite ~ to public view? •••••.•.••••.••••••••...•••••••• • • •.• • l~J

~ 77:.:, ::.:=::::~:Utvol .. kbng-••UOO'lopPW••M•~'-[~~~f llJ j

-3-

.,.c... .. ' , .. ·,·~ .. ~ ' ~ 'O' \':..•;_ t~:,> '\ '. ' 'tf, ~,

Y~ M~-;~ ~o

t. W" '"" ..., ..... ..,,., .,, ""' """''"" ol !" ... ...,....,""'of a.,..,,. .... or hi"oric .,...,,1ogial si"?.

0 ~-1 l~. '?', Cu/liltal Rnimrtts.

2. Will ,,,.,,,.. ...... mull iri ad«i .. ph,,;c.i a< .,,.;.;.1c .. •fl""' ,. • l>'•histo<ie or hi>lo•.C "'""''""· """''"". "' ... jo<t?. • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • ' • • • • • • • ., • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

0 0 ., . .

3. °"" '"' •'""°"' ,,,,,. "" poton1W 10 _.. • ohv<ical cMni' which would .um""""" othnic cull•"'' ...... , ....................... ' .. --· ...................................... . u LI I ;X.

0 L. l I

i.X !

4. Will ""' 1»•-' muicl esist"'l '""'°"'or ......, ""',.;thin IM""""'"' imP"'l ,.,.1 ........... . u. &trmdolilf')" Fil'.dints of s;,.nifirtmct.

1 O""' ""'"'"l>"""" ti"' po1on1W to .......... quol!lyolth• ...n-ment"oduc•""' hal.iUt ot a fl"'°' ,.;ldUI• ,peci«. ~•'""or wildlile poi>Ola•ion to drop bolo« ,.11...,u\ning ,,...,, mioaun to enrNo&ii ..... , ........ !""""""'"· ........... ·-"' ..... ic• ......... of ..... "'_...,.., ..... .. '"""'' o< elin>iMle-'"' .,,..p1., of ..e nilloo perk>di o• ;:.1il .. ni• hO•Ort or •'"'"'°"'? ....... .

2. 0- "'' p••io<t ,,_ lhe poton•W 10 .,... .. _,.uion. 10 lhe ~,,......,,... of·,.,...,,.m, ,..;,cnmonul ..,.,.., .......................... ' ......................................... . :J: '°"" lh•. p•oio<t .... ;,n,..ci> .... ich ... .,.-,.lduolly ......... bu> cuml'lali .. IV COMidv-l •• , ....... .

4. o- '"' •••i«• ~ """" • ......, .. etlo<U""""" ,.;11 .-"'"'''!"'w .. ,..,. ,uecU on h•""" """"'· .i-. di1oc1ly ot ;..!ir...,r? • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • ·• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

Ill. o!SCUSSION OF ENVIAO~ENTAL £VALUATION !SH C...,.;.rs Air"""')

0 r 1 1--· ,!;

0 tJ f ... ·X• ·-·

0 0 lL

0 0 oc

(SEE AT!At~a> c0MM£NTS} \-

tV. PRELlMINAIW O'T:ERM!NATIOM On wt basir; ol this in~tia1 evat~tion: @ I .... ,..,. "'"""'"' .. .;.c. COULD NOT ..... ! ,;gnmcantofl•CI ...... '" ........... """'' NEGi>.TIVE DECtAllA TION ""'

J "'"''""..!. . 0 I fiod ............... lhe ........ p«>io<t !.ould h,.. . .,;,..u;c,.ufle<t on me ,.,ironmen'I. -· vftP ""'h<·• '""''''?'' •!!«t U. this - ,_, ... 1he mi11<P1ion ,...,.r., -tilled on ... atU<!Wd """ .... "'"' ;ddod t• tM p<oil<I· A t:.EGATIVE

oectARATION .... .,. .,....e.i. . l J I r..i ............ d •••P<• MA y .,. ... ,;gnilicW>t •"OCl'°" '"' ................. "' ENVIRONMENT AL "'""C1 .n•VO"l ~ ........... ~

7 I 27.. L 90 .

·J ~-~,--~ ~---"-" ·::;·,~ :,·_.'. ~:::::J"~.~~:~~-~~,:~·:;· '·::·~·":·~·:-M~-·7· .. ,:·::~'"::··-~;-~-~;:-7~= .. ~:~:~~ .. ~~-,~- ~=>'~;::·:-:~:~----~;~~· ~~ ~:.~;~~:·r ~-I~~\ ~:·~~~~""~~:~t:~; ~~-~:·- -~: ~:y

i:~ :~.-~-';'~ ', .,~:.:..., ·~·' ~. " "~ .,, t• .. ~, "''

III. DISCUSSIGN OF ~IRON"dENTAL EVALUATION -·w 11~4.3& - ENGLISH

es. There could be a slight rise in the turbidity level d~in9 ,pile drlving, however caissons or sl$eves will be uaeil 1:0 avoid or minimize turbidity-related impacts to water.

E4. TR.PA £ish )?abitat maps indicate that this project is in a fish ~pawnin9/habitat restoration area an~ has ·the potential of adversely affecting spawning grounds. TRPA has concluded that this activity will not cause a significant i101pact to this habitat. If disturbed shoreline/laJ;ebottom sedi':zents are found due to the construction activity associated with the removal and installation of this project, the affected nr~as will be hand rolle"d and/or ~O'..:k cobble hand placed to reconsolidate the shor~iine sediments.

Fl.. A tempora~ rise in the ambient ·noise levels may ' i:i:ur during ·~onstruction which will be of short-ten.l duratiO'i..:.•

' . '

Rl. This proposal s~eks to bring under pa~it an existing pier and two mooring.buoy.s& ·an extension to the-existing pier and the-addition of a' '~~1-it_t;~ , ' ' . The applieant has obtained a TRPA permit which specifies visua~ requirements for piers.

There are many piers located in this '"'q'mcnet of shoreline, and the addition of this pier and buoys W;\.11 not ·s'ig:iificantly change the 6:xlsting ~esthetics of. this area •

• In the report, Cymµl.§tive Impacts of Sborezone peveiorunent a.t Lake~, by Phillips, Brandt, Reddick, McDonald and Grefe, public respon~es to visual aspects of shorezorie dev6loP1llent and use considered a grouping of seven boats. closely spaced to !>a· a "vii;ual dislike"~· Therefore, this propi?sal does not constitute a significant effect.

The; nearest waterward structures to this pi,~r is a pier located so :feet to the north, and another pier .lo•cated located 175 feat ·to·the south.

!i'he· buoys of this proposal are lt'#cated approximately l·S~ feet from the shoreline, and one cf the buoys will ba a1pproxlmately 50 ~cet fr.om tho end of the pier once extendeao The second buoy.is ~p~cad 50 feet south o~ the rirst buoy. (See attached exllibit}

' ThQre are many piers in this shorezone segment, and the authorization of thi's pier and buoys will not change the exist.~ng pattern of topline trolling.

----~~----~:~--

._. __ __.. _______ ......... ________ _._ ______ ,__..._...... __ __.. _____________________ __

O· 0

REVISED 4-/~

LOCATION MAP ~ ' -----

RAYMOND VAIL ANO ASSOClA1cS I~ • ~ • AllOflflCtUAt ~ SU!trt'IOIG ....-

71~-~_z-

PA em~ r a n.cf·u m

Mr. Charles ·Warren, Executive Office~ state Larids commission 1so? 3.3ta street Sacramento, CA 95814-9990

Att~t!on Dan Cohen, Environmental Cootdinator

Subi«'r &ta.~~'t.~~ier Improvement 1ind Boatlift Project,

July 13·, ~990

kEc1:1v£~ .. :uL 16 1990

tY•?• •·l•ut. u~ -.... ) Q.l'Jtr_-Placer county

The Department of Fish and Game (DFG) has reviewed the request from the\ State Lands commission for infonnal consultation pursuant to the California, Endangered Species Act to dete~~ne if the. ·· proposed English Pier Improvement and Boatlift. ·Pro)ect . APN 98-191-17 ·would jeopardize.the Tahoe yellow cress (RoriEpa subumbellata}. The Tahoe yellow·=ress is .a State-listed Endangerea species and ·a Federal candidate species that is found onty o~ ':granitic S(\ndy b~acn and sandf cobblesi;';>ne habitats on the shores of Lake Taho~. Pier construction and maintenance activities may seriously i~pact existing populations and habitat for this s:Pecies. '.

If potential or existing habitat exists on the pruject. siit·e, the DFG must make-a deterinination of jeopardy until such-time as the Roripea Habitat Management Plan has been completed ahd has 1dent1:fi~d approp.riate l?litigatiot&, m,easures whic..lt will ~ff~et adverse impacts to Roripea. Th~· English Pro1ect consists of reconstruction of the exist-ing :.>t>en piling pier, extension, of the pier and installation of a b~a~l1ft. The project site substrata consists of sand, cobbles and ... gravel lake~ard- o~ th~ mean high water,· level elevation f6,229.1 feet). The bank is marked by, a ca~ 3-fo6t rock retaining wall. ·The DFG has determined that the .z7iglish Property does not ·maintain habitat present to support ~cip~lations of Roripea. , If formally requested, the DFG would issue a determina~ion of fl0.t8sopaxdy for this project.

If we can be of further assi~+ance, please contact Ms·. Sherry TeresC', Associate ldldllfe Biologist:, or Mr. Jerry Mensch, Environmental Services Supez-Visor, tele.phol')e,,~ (916) 355-7030.

\

:-:.:·.: . - .. ·.·, ~-------... -._ .........

To Mr. Charles Warren, Execu~ive·Officer state Lruids commission · · l.807 13th street.. · , Sacrara~to, CA 95814-99Z.w?

Attention Dan Cohen, :Env:~··:>mne1.-;:a1 Coor~inatoJ;·

ExHIBI.T "E" w 1124.38~·

July 13 11 ~990

The D~partment ~f Fish.and Grune (DFG} has reviewed the request from the State Lands commission for inforual consultation pursuant tb l:he California.Endangered species Act to dete~ine i£ the proposed English pj~r Improvement and Boat~ift Project APN 98-191-17.would jeo~ardize the Tahoa yellow cress (Ror~ subumbellata). The Tahoe yellow cress is a State-listea-­Enuange~ea s~ccies and a Fegeral. candidate, species th~t is f ouna only on granitic s~~gy ~~~c· ~rid sandf cobblest~ne habitats Qn the shores o:! Lake .•ra!"'~:'; - ·pfer ~onstruction and: l'4aintenance . ~cti vi ~ies ·illif"' serious~y; impact existi'ng· ·populations and hab;_ tat for this species. ·

:If potential or existing habitat exists on the,project site, the DFG must make a determination of jeopardy until such time as the RoriEej Habitat Management.Plan has been completed and haa idan i ied appropr~ato mitigation meas~~~~ ~hich·will ~!fset adverse impacts to Roripea. The EngVish Pro~cct consists of reconstruction Of the existing open piling pier, extension Of the pier. and installation of a l:>oatlift::. Th(': project site ~ubs'trata consists of sand, cobbles and gravel lake; ard of the mean high water level elevation i6~229.l feet). Th~ 'bank is marked by a ca. 3-foot rock retaining wall. The DFG h s. deterritined that the English Property does not maintain habitat >resent :to m!pport ~opulations of ·norlp,Q~. If form,allY, requeu':.ed, tie DFG' would issue a determination of ~~.~1!$>,P~ for th~s ~roject.

If we can be of further assi'st.ance please contact Ms. Sherry Tere~a, As~ociate Hi~dllf~ Bi~logisi1. or Mr·· Jerry ·Menseµ, Environmental Services Superv sor, telephone (916) 355-7030.