2~fUR~J+JifI~ -j-~m=W3 m1-22

4

~Jft~ rJilllIj~amm J Jft(tg ~ ~1fJe Bfillfj(tgbt~

MftfrlJ ~

ifkk i2fJf~~

j~ yen4 fEJyenJmWWjU~zft rp~~J~fj rLL~J B9f1tM yenJlrifR

~ r~ J I fPB9m~tE 0 ~7 ~UC51$~fiXB9lJMipound~ rp~illtt rWd

~t~fJJfflamp~P~J B9mlt3 sJtd~~iZHipoundB9~Ji~tItJ 1~yenli7ilJftB9m 1 _ -~ I 1-- l r I t Jlj gtltIl-z ~ - ) 1yen 0

I~lf~ ~ ~lt~~ ffJfEtamp$B9~m rp rp ~WWiJyenJm-~ 1IDWsect F3li-lfliB9~lJifj~ II

~ it~ ~ ~t 1Ar tl~ Ml1re~B9fE1 ~jrmB9~ft 0 ~7~HEPJli-fj~~ rp~fIamp

S 1 rilJ~ 7[9JjHE~B9mnm sectB9~~~~~ilampB9tfufJL 0

~r Id)lf I~f I~ yentl sectWi~Jl rp~MlJ7 tWiJyenJmB9ft11 iij7tM1MHJTB9lJ~ 0 ~ ~~~~~PJ$~ur~~~_WJB9~~o~~~~ft~

fEIB9~ft ~HE1Erp~~NlJHC51$ ~ ~~=fraB9mf fP~WAIi 0

I1IUiiJ iUtllgft ifoplusmnplusmn~lJmllfiyenit ~plusmnIVpfttJ l~3~~alll n~ ~iIlpailft

tJ

~ -=shya

--lLlLJif+=fj+JS cPJt r~~plusmnFrWJ YItlR fEcpJt~e~ litIyenJ r +---CP31t J t3rm=+JEUi=fPJT~fJiyenJ1t1 ~~T-cmJt1

~

2

IyenJflM~15 0 1I$mtEflM~l5tp retp~=+4lyenJc)tJOOfi(fOij1~1t~~~~ ~~M~+-~hOOtp~amp~~slyenJ$~U$m~~

r~~~~~~bullbull~~D~~a~~bullbullbull~~~ ~o~~+bullbullA~m~htt-~~~~~~ amp~tl~~~plusmn~~tl~bullbull~tt-~~ ~ampm ~D~+~~Tma~~~~~~~~~m

~~~A~ t~~~~~~~~I~~~~~

~~~_~middot~~~T~~~ro~~~~~m ~middotm~middot~~plusmnW~~~~amp~~~~IAM foamp 5tJ Ilfti jIt bull JIb 5L~ bull ~ 1~~1ft ~plusmn( plusmnt~A ~ mU-~

~~~~~~~~~~~~bullbullbull~Mh~~~ ~~bullbull ~ltt~~~m~~middot~ 1f~FJ~h bull J I

rIyenJ~~ J rft~rJ J fO r1t-~~ J -rtJ~~ipound~~tp~~

liiampffllyenJ r -==-fidlf J bull ulyenJ~~I5M~ tEtp~~ijAij1~1tlyenl~~~ tp~1JJti~ii~jljJ r~ J IyenJllt~t1 WlltlTIlB1 tp~15]i~At2~ipound~3ilJc5ltJOO

fi(iamp~IyenJDffi B~r1x~7tp~~IyenJ[g$i-$m ~amp~JtI3~~tffrJ 5 OOf-jfrfl~IyenJ~~~middot ~~ rtEamp4-tp~~~tEjft~~W]~tEffiplusmn~

-=t~f)]ampIPampf~ J 2 IyenJB~~IJ ~lt~giSnJ(rj]tiliJltH1~JTIyenJ~~~ B~f~c5ltJ OOfi(iampm~iH~tJII~flJffH=rlyenJroIm 8BfDm3iUM(lmtp~ r LL~ J IyenJ iW~~Im rfM(jU~ J tEillhOOmf~7~~UIyenJ~Wl bull0

PJT~Jj rfM(lU~J ill~tt-tLJtL400~i11yenJ~1t ~~tp~~~~ ~Ua~AIyenJ~$ rtEc5ltJIyenJmOOiW fM(~~ampWlyenJtLf~ffdWt-=t~~ -WJ~-~tili~plusmn7M~ r1xtj7~lfIyenJ~Ji~ fi(~7Jif~5ifEl-=t~lyenJf3j ~jfrplusmn~-=t~ J ~jU~lyenJh~yenij7fltUIyenJ~~ ff~Ja~~~~ rfNro~lmtfjtEyenttiampIyenJ~lflt[gg~ bull ~~ illlJtt~WlyenJjjIt~-=t~~1E~ plusmnjll~tJiW 11m~~lflt-ltyenttiamp 1EillflifIJfitlT yenttiampltlyenJyentpWff1 ~NlyenJffl1J bull t2iE~~tlDllt ~lfIyenJ~15Gt2~~rR5EiflyenJllfi~ ~

I ARSfil CmmtED 1998 if 12 B 198 m 21lFi 2 ItlL 0

I i

~I I

ffiijjtp~ rfdfrE~1nampIltli~J tplyenJ~~ftJ5-~jtl~lyenJamp1G 3

~

IyenJffiJ~fOffdttt~G5I$JJlyenJffiJ~ 0 J 3

CP~~Im8IyenJffiJ~rQ~ lpoundit~j~~~1amp CP~f7J$RPiJfRjtl2~ iBjU~fjCP ~I~~iiJ~ggfpoundIyenJ~bullbull fi~~j[~~mjU~ttfrcp~1yenJ ~7G fmJjJiMfj~ r1i~~fh fO r1i~mf~gJ lltRP r~yenf1yenJ

i fj][~ mf~gf~~fM ~MfAIpoundIpoundtWJj( mf~gf~[sectJjIyenJ~ttllampm ~M~5Vi~tt~IyenJH~~jJiill mf~gi~t~~lisectHtJIyenJ~Ttft ~Mfi1ffM IyenJjtl21ft mf~gf~fl1fft ~M~ff[I~IyenJ~f-tfj][~ mf~gi~lI~~1yenJ fi~pftJl fi~pllampmftJl 0 J 4~cp ~M~fj][~m IUi~1yenJUJampjJi1ll

~ ~r~~m~$~~~~~~~lIamp~illfOampfO~~~~~IyenJ~~ ~ J llf~tr~lyenJff~ 0 lZ9~ riftfjCP~AIpoundIyenJ1f1fmi1lyenJ~

ffr~ ~~~S-~1euror1euror1pound3]1rQ~JJ[rJ~~~ 0 J 5

CP~~DfilJOO~~ ~9M8~ ~)(~iBlyenJmli lpoundtt~1r~)t5$0

~JtiJ 1pound~iBlyenJ~~CP ~1re1plusmn~yen~cp~I~w~llY~ ~ 1poundt~1i$middott ~JfflpoundlyenJi~jlfd1 lZ9llt ~$~w~~pound1yenJ~1t Mzfamp~ttamp~lpoundCP ~fif7J$middotllt~~~fu~cp~mr1fcp~M~ttt~JlyenJffl j ~lilJE-f~Jm~~alyenJ~ mJf~IyenJ~~Jtff1ft~IyenJV]i1 1pound0

~JlIJ~~1amp i~1r1ff~CP~1yenJ25lt$~ffifiif025lt$~fjCPOOf-tIyenJ~~r~~ ~ illfBftlf~5l r1pj1ifsect~J 1yenJ~1t bull ift~)(t1DJ r~jtl~IyenJampJilJ ift-MU~~8JJjjlZ9 fu~CP~fIT5$~J~c1amp~wlllyenJ~EE 0

it $ ttaiyen~~saHtttltJ tr-J-g-HHt

~gfAm-m-ij Iffl7U~ ramp1f$ffiJlyenJ~~~ Ztamp1f$ffiJlyenJ~iJJ J miD - EJ5 ~Iyen1~~~w1TiJJlyenJfsect1Llmf 0 W1iff~rQ~IyenJ~~~~1fjlIt$WT~

(Zbigniew K Brzezinski) gg~ ~~W~lpoundif-tllampmCPlyenJmJtt t ~fOjD~lyenJttamp ffdtt~~IyenJ1JD~~iJJ t)ampIpoundJRf-t~Jj(miplusmn~1JlyenJttt1JD

3 ~lwIIJa~AtY1itlt1 If(JfJlUliJMWlffl=fI~~ m-~~A~reJfl41JmIm7~jftY1M tlJ]m~fEl52 m=~~A~llf~51jjmWJamplMilft~1l ia~~W~~~~tH~tI

~Di1tIl~IJ m~~A~llf~lMiilplusmnHtU1j~~5GI47~ lMiEltlitttY1~JIJit61~ ~tIJ~ lJ ~~xtlr~~~~~n~~~~-W~~~~~~~fi~~tY1~~middotM~~~a~mmiddot

UtIlCllyensa (~lfjj A~tHlampJfi 1997 if 6 Fl) g 17middot

4 jilmrm tiIlpound B1IltlHf jiIijlfilJJlB9~9E~-~2Jgt~U~~2Jgt~ (~tg Wsect)(~lli lt5i~i 1991 if 12 Fl) g 202middot

5 1iJ~g 200-201 bull ~

4

1f1Bl illreg2Slf~1~ilampmJ1XmltAIBl1l11yenr~m 0 m71f)jtl~5jjWdwflyenJ~

~~~~m~~~~~plusmn~$5~plusmn~~~~plusmn~~~m-~r~ ~IyenJ$-arr~~7f3~ J (modern revolutionary ideology) bull tZEV+_LAEolOOl)

~IT~~~middotill~~~~msect-reg~~~$m~~ffl~IyenJreg~ jJ~jJ~~sect lWffrplusmn1fI~yen5tIyenJ~pff1FlyenJaJ1~plusmn~iJDtJ~~ 0 6

tE~$fifjlyenJjJf~rp ~~~t~fl]fIJJppJ~ra~lyenJlBl1 ~~-Iij I AiplusmnsectIyenJ~ 0 ~m~~~s~middot ~~~7f3~mmfiUplusmn~~~jU8~

middot 8tElff~jjTIfi~~~7f1JJIyenJ~1fftjrPJ 0 ~~~~mflJJlyenJjm~lH~

MLllyenR~fIJJf~mlyenJjjrPJ 0 1f~fl~ middot ~~7f3t~PJjJ~WJfIJJlyenJirfI tfDfIj1t MLlltEfIJJ1tmfl~IyenJ~~ ~~~~~~J1X7f1JJIyenJ -ff~fr 0 7

rp~ilampfI~VJJ1~ 1f1Bl~~7f3~IyenJ~~L~ Ml~[Iji~fIJJFJ~ ffi)fITJigiiff 0 tp~Dfga5l$~fampilamp1~ PJf~J1j~sfil1)iUI]m~Lr~lyenJ~ifB

~~fu~tptE~~rp~~AfflTIfi~IyenJ=I~~~~~m

- W-fL-tJ1ftpmIli~~ilij I~Jtplusmn~IyenJ~iM1amp rp~jJ-yen~dZ~ ~8lyenJa5l$~fampilamp m~-IirE1t~ir$I1IyenJ~~ m= tp~ill~ fsectRmJtplusmn~~1151Jffi)1JJ sect mmffrplusmn1fplusmn~~IyenJ~$~]~$ ~Jtij~ffiM~ ~m-rp~BTIfi~7-jjTIfi~~~~1fplusmn~IyenJ~fIm~-jjTIfix~

~~~yentlJt~~Kamp~1tlfl~pJf~lyenJjfJsectlro~ 0 8 m7~yenR~~=I1Eillt

fl~llBl~amp~IyenJ~~~fl~ro~ ~1La5l$~fampIyenJfIWii~f14 ~~1ft~flyenJdZ ~111 0

- flii -l fJ1 $a ~f~ jpoundl

~~rtpm~~~~JIyenJ~~tp~mmr~1fplusmn~mKamp~~J ~1f~9UppJ~~~ m- rpmIyenJJfd1fB~~Wd1ft~Jfd1f MltdZ~~M ffi)fij~iE~Wd~plusmn~ m= tpmIyenJJfd1fplusmn~ffrplusmn~~J1KtEf)]Kamp~~ MltdZ ~Will~~tfj~ ffi)fij~m~illlrJi~ 0 ~11ffi)sect illM~f9~~~9U 1yenJ~~li

6 Zbigniew K Brzezinski The Soviet Bloc Unity and Conflict (Cambridge Harvard University Press

1979) pp 485-486

7 Ibid p 488

8 James C F Wang Contemporary Chinese Politics (Englewood Cliffs New Jersey Prentice Hall Inc

1995) pp 55-56

r ~

r I ) iAfI

5 ~rp~ rjfdtttJifJ]~~~J rpEiJ~jfJ~-jHfti~EiJamp~

(l)1pound~fI~FtiH~Jfflrr~j1lfyenJ1JDL~ ~ff~i~~~7f3stfD~~15st ~~~~

(2)fa~UfflU~B~m~ fE~ff1poundlf~poundfyenJJiI1ffl~lIJlsectmt (3)fTfjnlrjfyenJ1ffidM~~ 1J~~1ffi61~ipoundfD1ffi615Cw (4)ffJJt1(~5t~BmjIlfyenJ~m5t~c15stiftff (5)IAl f~~~ 1l1J~IIJWB~1J~lIJzFa~fyenJJflLBm~ fE1JJ~ff1pound

lf~5jU (6)ffplusmn~j~m1fr$3tBJ3~~BfjfEl~1il 1El~rH~ (7)ffplusmn~j~~fl1JmyenU-JE~~ fE~~ZPfD~flWplusmn~1tfyenramp~~

~~tt~j~~~amp~~lil~~~~o

m~~~~~~~~OOm~fyenJj~~~~ rA~8~~~fyenJ ~~3t1tjjit~~mrampfyenJtt~~lfzFa~fyenJ~~ J ffijm~~~fyenJj~15$~P0

~~J~~lf1J JJte~~il3fDmramp 90

- 1 t ~~~m~~~ift~fjJftt~j~tt~~ff~ftfyenJm~~5t~OO

FlI~1mzpJTJJ iJ mAfr~fyenJJJyenztt~ ~fDn~j~~~fyenJ~~llffitlaz1j1ifj Isectm fN~~~~~==tffyenJ$ 0

r~~~~ftl~~~I~M~~ftJ~~~~~~~~ft

$~ 0 i~AI1$~~fAAIllt ~ 11 I ~I1tM ~Hyen~ilamp~~

~ t ~~mdeg11~fAAIllt~W~I~Ifu~ bullbullft~~

1

_~B~~~ilio~M~A~~ampbullbullbull~~~ ~ftl~~amp~_~ft~~~~~I~~~~amp~ak~~

WAbullbull~~~~KA~~~bullbull~mampamp~~~~ ~~ft~~ilamp~yen~~bullbullampbullbullI~~ ft~~

~iWmJ~~ilamp~~~bullbull middotJW

1pound~~fyenJm~ M~~~~Ji~A~~ (NS Khrushchev) 1poundyenA iamp~mlHfyenJ~lfj~ r~rnJ~~~lfli J ~P1~~T fi1poundf~~~~~J~Utm

fyenJ~~o~~1pound~~=+IsectmUt~~~~fyenJ~~~mlH~r1pound~~

j mt~~MP3J r1poundt1(ADn~fyenJlfl115rnJ~JiftJm~lll~llfyenJ~j~

~~middotJ-ftEt~+-~1pound~~rmt~~~J~~JfyenJ~~

9 Ilt~t~ rp1il~1I~ltft (~tJP- rpIJIJ~~fltllllEiiilplusmn 1991 ~ 5 ~) bull J 377-378 bull

4middot 10 ~1Ji~ UtUNJililiHAIfIa~bullbull (3r~ AFtllIlEiffltplusmn 1988 ~ 3 ~) J 2 bull

6

Milt~K3ZfE~11l rmt~a~rE~ J ~mJEm+1i1f -h1ih1f~-Fl it-t E3 1Ei-+-8Jyen~~rp MjltjlE~g1fj ri~~A-11l$f 8J tiYim~8J~M- -~OOUft~plusmn~jfd~9~8J~M ~11la~M8Jplusmn0

~ff~~9ft~plusmn~8J~~amp~pound~1E-h-1f+FlB~8Ji

=+-~middotMiltKfE~~~~plusmn~~8J~mgR~bullbull middot r1E=+1fI7Jfkfr~~pound~9~~plusmn~ffrplusmn~ J 110

-~~mmiddotMiltK~~~fNsect8J~eplusmn~m$middot~~~~~a8J -11lm~JJRrzsJ 0 ~8Jltff~1fjmn1lEK (LI Brezhnev) ~-h-t1f 1E-~ rffrplusmn~plusmn~f1tWJfU8J1i+1f J 8J~~rp sect~mthi~~B r9~ g~jfd~plusmn~ J 8JllflilT rp~~~gmi1i11lJtllfli1Ejfd~plusmn~jfd~~Jf~IIJ7t0

mth 7 -J)Slfj1~tl~8J~I7JG aJE7~B~M8Jt5gt~~~~~plusmn~~8Jel~ ~M1

5$~jfd~plusmn~~Jf~8J~M)[~ - m~mth7ffd~plusmn~~K~IU7tr~~

~= mth7ffrplusmn~plusmn~fJtt3fHIpound~8Jllflil~ ~jZg mth71Egiffrplusmn~plusmn~~Jf~~9lI~~~tampffrplusmn~8J~m 120

fkfr~fJJtEEifsectw rp rffd~plusmn~fJJ~~~~llfli J 8Jmth ifsect~$fr~ ~7i~~~8JgRbullbull o~~m~~~fJrWtampJwrgiJ8J~ ~ 0 rp~~mMfk~ trfJJfamp~Jf~8Jm~~~~rptUd~plusmn~mUltfbJ~ 7G~8Jm$~~~1E-m iliJ~ rp~~~11it3t1ttt~~1ampfDa)~~~~ 1amp)jjt5l$~~~~M~tJ8J1t~t~~~~1E-m J30

pound~~~~Jffii1t~t rp fEgRjfd~~~tJ1Fm~[j1WJf ~~8JfNff ~middot~~~~ampfJtiffrplusmn~plusmn~~~8JE7t~thbullbull middottt~~~~plusmn

middot fpmf3f7rp5$~gR~~tJ8JJj~Mtt1J~ 0 rp~~5$sectffiJ r~~~ ~plusmn~fE--Il1ffrplusmn~rDl1m$~~~~rDl1 bull te~~rDl1M~~~~tJgR8J ~lt bull 1tfffl~Afr~fJUJ~8JfNfI~7tifJTA~jfd~gR8J1JU$ J 140

-=- t1f~ if)1] jJ~ lftrDlr~m~l8Jgllflipound~~mm~~~~mreg-~middot IJiJ$tf1E r ~~W1fi1fp J 8Jllfli~rptlDllt~7F

11 fil]J ~ 110 Il3

12 fil]J ~ 119-122

13 fil]J ~ 177-179 bull

14 fil]J ~ 193 0

-- 7 flj

~tfB9=T~ r ffttlfft_H]JampIl~~Ji J 9=TlyenJjtfElts-~JjU~IyenJNJE

-fj

-fampffi rW~~M~~m~~k~bullbull~ar~JW f$t ~aIW~I~r~ J~~~~~~~~ ~t ~~ ~I~~bullbullbullW~o~~Mamp~W k~IIJ ~a~I~ r~fi~tJ W ~bullbull~~~~

rt r j~ bull J 0 ~~1~ ~ ~ qb~ ~ ~~ ~g P~Hl ~I rf$ Iamp I bull J J 150

~~lyenJ[1Jrpound~ W1Hjt1J~~f1t~~~~ffitJlyenJ jfd1t3~~lyenJ0fiX ~Jmm9~lfl)3 fJitt~~3t~ rsectf=rmt J lyenJ~JGI ~WM~~iPampt6ampBshy)iG~~fpoundjElyenJtt~$JJt lli~~~~~WilamplyenJffitJ 0 tErpttlyenJHNrp M

J if~~tt~]tfIDXB~~ (MS Gorbachev) lyenJc5lt~ ~-fI r sect miJitrJJ J q

lyenJFY E~D~fr~-f~Wf~ftglyenJlW~fDfT~ ~fr~~~mxB~~lyenJ~0

$fD-~ilampmfDggilamp~lyenJ~~f~Bf~~~~if~lyenJ~tJ~~~

~jtpound$I~JlU Tffl~~ r~tid1t3~ MzfYjt~~mtIJfDilampm~~ 0 J

016 ~~Z xB~~slf[~~~ffitJlyenJn~ if~iampramp5trtJ r sect fTmt J

~jt~~fftElyenJ~yenffttlo rptti~lli~3t~ r sectf=rmt J lyenJn~ ~sect15U~ ~te rjfd~3~tnamp0

~~~~lfll J lyenJ[sectlyenJz- gt~~~fEljttlyenJJCmffitJ t~yentl-lt5-YI~lyenJ pound~ 0 F~c5lt~OO~ r Jril~HSijj J lyenJfr~j ZjI 1Wfl)3 81~te r73t~lyenJ~]t

gtamp~m~rp~lyenJ-Wamp~lyenJbullbull gtamp~-~RlyenJilampmM ~ ~3t~lyenJ~]t gtY3t~~AIIlElyenJilampmrnireg Y5i~lyenJ~]t mEgU ~lyenJmm$gttflsectfm ~3t~lyenJ~]t ~~5ZI5ZW ~jU~~~U~~D ~5fDW~~gtJlyenJ~ffilliyenJLfm 0 iat~ jfd~3~IL9M1J~t~~ fftsect

I ~lyenJJC- ampBffi3~lyenJrl~ lli~Y5i~-MtJI~~~1y~a~fT 0 J 17

tJra~rpttlyenJc5lt~~EElyenJ r+-ftfL=rp~~ J f$jOOjjyenlyenJ ttlutrp~ tt~~flU~~ rc5lt~$~lyenJ~tIJ~5fD~]t~ J -1Srp~~~lyenJ~~ 0

~~ttfpoundjElyenJm~[1 fF7J)TlyenJflmt

)p 15 )1IJ r IIJ~W1itfif J bull ~gliH (m=~) (~Wff4 $~3tIUilplusmnllamprnJElJff 1949 if)

175 0

16 M Gorbachev Perestroika i Novae Myshlenie Dlya Nashei Strany i dlya Vsevo Mira (Moskva lzdatmiddot

elstvo Politcheskoi Literatury 1987) p 51

17 InJ2jS r EljllnjlJJt3~fGlif)J J bull llJJZfIliH (m=~) UtJ AJ~lplusmnllampjjiplusmn 1994 if 10 Fl) ~266

5 ~rp~ rjfdtttJifJ]~~~J rpEiJ~jfJ~-jHfti~EiJamp~

(l)1pound~fI~FtiH~Jfflrr~j1lfyenJ1JDL~ ~ff~i~~~7f3stfD~~15st ~~~~

(2)fa~UfflU~B~m~ fE~ff1poundlf~poundfyenJJiI1ffl~lIJlsectmt (3)fTfjnlrjfyenJ1ffidM~~ 1J~~1ffi61~ipoundfD1ffi615Cw (4)ffJJt1(~5t~BmjIlfyenJ~m5t~c15stiftff (5)IAl f~~~ 1l1J~IIJWB~1J~lIJzFa~fyenJJflLBm~ fE1JJ~ff1pound

lf~5jU (6)ffplusmn~j~m1fr$3tBJ3~~BfjfEl~1il 1El~rH~ (7)ffplusmn~j~~fl1JmyenU-JE~~ fE~~ZPfD~flWplusmn~1tfyenramp~~

~~tt~j~~~amp~~lil~~~~o

m~~~~~~~~OOm~fyenJj~~~~ rA~8~~~fyenJ ~~3t1tjjit~~mrampfyenJtt~~lfzFa~fyenJ~~ J ffijm~~~fyenJj~15$~P0

~~J~~lf1J JJte~~il3fDmramp 90

- 1 t ~~~m~~~ift~fjJftt~j~tt~~ff~ftfyenJm~~5t~OO

FlI~1mzpJTJJ iJ mAfr~fyenJJJyenztt~ ~fDn~j~~~fyenJ~~llffitlaz1j1ifj Isectm fN~~~~~==tffyenJ$ 0

r~~~~ftl~~~I~M~~ftJ~~~~~~~~ft

$~ 0 i~AI1$~~fAAIllt ~ 11 I ~I1tM ~Hyen~ilamp~~

~ t ~~mdeg11~fAAIllt~W~I~Ifu~ bullbullft~~

1

_~B~~~ilio~M~A~~ampbullbullbull~~~ ~ftl~~amp~_~ft~~~~~I~~~~amp~ak~~

WAbullbull~~~~KA~~~bullbull~mampamp~~~~ ~~ft~~ilamp~yen~~bullbullampbullbullI~~ ft~~

~iWmJ~~ilamp~~~bullbull middotJW

1pound~~fyenJm~ M~~~~Ji~A~~ (NS Khrushchev) 1poundyenA iamp~mlHfyenJ~lfj~ r~rnJ~~~lfli J ~P1~~T fi1poundf~~~~~J~Utm

fyenJ~~o~~1pound~~=+IsectmUt~~~~fyenJ~~~mlH~r1pound~~

j mt~~MP3J r1poundt1(ADn~fyenJlfl115rnJ~JiftJm~lll~llfyenJ~j~

~~middotJ-ftEt~+-~1pound~~rmt~~~J~~JfyenJ~~

9 Ilt~t~ rp1il~1I~ltft (~tJP- rpIJIJ~~fltllllEiiilplusmn 1991 ~ 5 ~) bull J 377-378 bull

4middot 10 ~1Ji~ UtUNJililiHAIfIa~bullbull (3r~ AFtllIlEiffltplusmn 1988 ~ 3 ~) J 2 bull

6

Milt~K3ZfE~11l rmt~a~rE~ J ~mJEm+1i1f -h1ih1f~-Fl it-t E3 1Ei-+-8Jyen~~rp MjltjlE~g1fj ri~~A-11l$f 8J tiYim~8J~M- -~OOUft~plusmn~jfd~9~8J~M ~11la~M8Jplusmn0

~ff~~9ft~plusmn~8J~~amp~pound~1E-h-1f+FlB~8Ji

=+-~middotMiltKfE~~~~plusmn~~8J~mgR~bullbull middot r1E=+1fI7Jfkfr~~pound~9~~plusmn~ffrplusmn~ J 110

-~~mmiddotMiltK~~~fNsect8J~eplusmn~m$middot~~~~~a8J -11lm~JJRrzsJ 0 ~8Jltff~1fjmn1lEK (LI Brezhnev) ~-h-t1f 1E-~ rffrplusmn~plusmn~f1tWJfU8J1i+1f J 8J~~rp sect~mthi~~B r9~ g~jfd~plusmn~ J 8JllflilT rp~~~gmi1i11lJtllfli1Ejfd~plusmn~jfd~~Jf~IIJ7t0

mth 7 -J)Slfj1~tl~8J~I7JG aJE7~B~M8Jt5gt~~~~~plusmn~~8Jel~ ~M1

5$~jfd~plusmn~~Jf~8J~M)[~ - m~mth7ffd~plusmn~~K~IU7tr~~

~= mth7ffrplusmn~plusmn~fJtt3fHIpound~8Jllflil~ ~jZg mth71Egiffrplusmn~plusmn~~Jf~~9lI~~~tampffrplusmn~8J~m 120

fkfr~fJJtEEifsectw rp rffd~plusmn~fJJ~~~~llfli J 8Jmth ifsect~$fr~ ~7i~~~8JgRbullbull o~~m~~~fJrWtampJwrgiJ8J~ ~ 0 rp~~mMfk~ trfJJfamp~Jf~8Jm~~~~rptUd~plusmn~mUltfbJ~ 7G~8Jm$~~~1E-m iliJ~ rp~~~11it3t1ttt~~1ampfDa)~~~~ 1amp)jjt5l$~~~~M~tJ8J1t~t~~~~1E-m J30

pound~~~~Jffii1t~t rp fEgRjfd~~~tJ1Fm~[j1WJf ~~8JfNff ~middot~~~~ampfJtiffrplusmn~plusmn~~~8JE7t~thbullbull middottt~~~~plusmn

middot fpmf3f7rp5$~gR~~tJ8JJj~Mtt1J~ 0 rp~~5$sectffiJ r~~~ ~plusmn~fE--Il1ffrplusmn~rDl1m$~~~~rDl1 bull te~~rDl1M~~~~tJgR8J ~lt bull 1tfffl~Afr~fJUJ~8JfNfI~7tifJTA~jfd~gR8J1JU$ J 140

-=- t1f~ if)1] jJ~ lftrDlr~m~l8Jgllflipound~~mm~~~~mreg-~middot IJiJ$tf1E r ~~W1fi1fp J 8Jllfli~rptlDllt~7F

11 fil]J ~ 110 Il3

12 fil]J ~ 119-122

13 fil]J ~ 177-179 bull

14 fil]J ~ 193 0

-- 7 flj

~tfB9=T~ r ffttlfft_H]JampIl~~Ji J 9=TlyenJjtfElts-~JjU~IyenJNJE

-fj

-fampffi rW~~M~~m~~k~bullbull~ar~JW f$t ~aIW~I~r~ J~~~~~~~~ ~t ~~ ~I~~bullbullbullW~o~~Mamp~W k~IIJ ~a~I~ r~fi~tJ W ~bullbull~~~~

rt r j~ bull J 0 ~~1~ ~ ~ qb~ ~ ~~ ~g P~Hl ~I rf$ Iamp I bull J J 150

~~lyenJ[1Jrpound~ W1Hjt1J~~f1t~~~~ffitJlyenJ jfd1t3~~lyenJ0fiX ~Jmm9~lfl)3 fJitt~~3t~ rsectf=rmt J lyenJ~JGI ~WM~~iPampt6ampBshy)iG~~fpoundjElyenJtt~$JJt lli~~~~~WilamplyenJffitJ 0 tErpttlyenJHNrp M

J if~~tt~]tfIDXB~~ (MS Gorbachev) lyenJc5lt~ ~-fI r sect miJitrJJ J q

lyenJFY E~D~fr~-f~Wf~ftglyenJlW~fDfT~ ~fr~~~mxB~~lyenJ~0

$fD-~ilampmfDggilamp~lyenJ~~f~Bf~~~~if~lyenJ~tJ~~~

~jtpound$I~JlU Tffl~~ r~tid1t3~ MzfYjt~~mtIJfDilampm~~ 0 J

016 ~~Z xB~~slf[~~~ffitJlyenJn~ if~iampramp5trtJ r sect fTmt J

~jt~~fftElyenJ~yenffttlo rptti~lli~3t~ r sectf=rmt J lyenJn~ ~sect15U~ ~te rjfd~3~tnamp0

~~~~lfll J lyenJ[sectlyenJz- gt~~~fEljttlyenJJCmffitJ t~yentl-lt5-YI~lyenJ pound~ 0 F~c5lt~OO~ r Jril~HSijj J lyenJfr~j ZjI 1Wfl)3 81~te r73t~lyenJ~]t

gtamp~m~rp~lyenJ-Wamp~lyenJbullbull gtamp~-~RlyenJilampmM ~ ~3t~lyenJ~]t gtY3t~~AIIlElyenJilampmrnireg Y5i~lyenJ~]t mEgU ~lyenJmm$gttflsectfm ~3t~lyenJ~]t ~~5ZI5ZW ~jU~~~U~~D ~5fDW~~gtJlyenJ~ffilliyenJLfm 0 iat~ jfd~3~IL9M1J~t~~ fftsect

I ~lyenJJC- ampBffi3~lyenJrl~ lli~Y5i~-MtJI~~~1y~a~fT 0 J 17

tJra~rpttlyenJc5lt~~EElyenJ r+-ftfL=rp~~ J f$jOOjjyenlyenJ ttlutrp~ tt~~flU~~ rc5lt~$~lyenJ~tIJ~5fD~]t~ J -1Srp~~~lyenJ~~ 0

~~ttfpoundjElyenJm~[1 fF7J)TlyenJflmt

)p 15 )1IJ r IIJ~W1itfif J bull ~gliH (m=~) (~Wff4 $~3tIUilplusmnllamprnJElJff 1949 if)

175 0

16 M Gorbachev Perestroika i Novae Myshlenie Dlya Nashei Strany i dlya Vsevo Mira (Moskva lzdatmiddot

elstvo Politcheskoi Literatury 1987) p 51

17 InJ2jS r EljllnjlJJt3~fGlif)J J bull llJJZfIliH (m=~) UtJ AJ~lplusmnllampjjiplusmn 1994 if 10 Fl) ~266

6

Milt~K3ZfE~11l rmt~a~rE~ J ~mJEm+1i1f -h1ih1f~-Fl it-t E3 1Ei-+-8Jyen~~rp MjltjlE~g1fj ri~~A-11l$f 8J tiYim~8J~M- -~OOUft~plusmn~jfd~9~8J~M ~11la~M8Jplusmn0

~ff~~9ft~plusmn~8J~~amp~pound~1E-h-1f+FlB~8Ji

=+-~middotMiltKfE~~~~plusmn~~8J~mgR~bullbull middot r1E=+1fI7Jfkfr~~pound~9~~plusmn~ffrplusmn~ J 110

-~~mmiddotMiltK~~~fNsect8J~eplusmn~m$middot~~~~~a8J -11lm~JJRrzsJ 0 ~8Jltff~1fjmn1lEK (LI Brezhnev) ~-h-t1f 1E-~ rffrplusmn~plusmn~f1tWJfU8J1i+1f J 8J~~rp sect~mthi~~B r9~ g~jfd~plusmn~ J 8JllflilT rp~~~gmi1i11lJtllfli1Ejfd~plusmn~jfd~~Jf~IIJ7t0

mth 7 -J)Slfj1~tl~8J~I7JG aJE7~B~M8Jt5gt~~~~~plusmn~~8Jel~ ~M1

5$~jfd~plusmn~~Jf~8J~M)[~ - m~mth7ffd~plusmn~~K~IU7tr~~

~= mth7ffrplusmn~plusmn~fJtt3fHIpound~8Jllflil~ ~jZg mth71Egiffrplusmn~plusmn~~Jf~~9lI~~~tampffrplusmn~8J~m 120

fkfr~fJJtEEifsectw rp rffd~plusmn~fJJ~~~~llfli J 8Jmth ifsect~$fr~ ~7i~~~8JgRbullbull o~~m~~~fJrWtampJwrgiJ8J~ ~ 0 rp~~mMfk~ trfJJfamp~Jf~8Jm~~~~rptUd~plusmn~mUltfbJ~ 7G~8Jm$~~~1E-m iliJ~ rp~~~11it3t1ttt~~1ampfDa)~~~~ 1amp)jjt5l$~~~~M~tJ8J1t~t~~~~1E-m J30

pound~~~~Jffii1t~t rp fEgRjfd~~~tJ1Fm~[j1WJf ~~8JfNff ~middot~~~~ampfJtiffrplusmn~plusmn~~~8JE7t~thbullbull middottt~~~~plusmn

middot fpmf3f7rp5$~gR~~tJ8JJj~Mtt1J~ 0 rp~~5$sectffiJ r~~~ ~plusmn~fE--Il1ffrplusmn~rDl1m$~~~~rDl1 bull te~~rDl1M~~~~tJgR8J ~lt bull 1tfffl~Afr~fJUJ~8JfNfI~7tifJTA~jfd~gR8J1JU$ J 140

-=- t1f~ if)1] jJ~ lftrDlr~m~l8Jgllflipound~~mm~~~~mreg-~middot IJiJ$tf1E r ~~W1fi1fp J 8Jllfli~rptlDllt~7F

11 fil]J ~ 110 Il3

12 fil]J ~ 119-122

13 fil]J ~ 177-179 bull

14 fil]J ~ 193 0

-- 7 flj

~tfB9=T~ r ffttlfft_H]JampIl~~Ji J 9=TlyenJjtfElts-~JjU~IyenJNJE

-fj

-fampffi rW~~M~~m~~k~bullbull~ar~JW f$t ~aIW~I~r~ J~~~~~~~~ ~t ~~ ~I~~bullbullbullW~o~~Mamp~W k~IIJ ~a~I~ r~fi~tJ W ~bullbull~~~~

rt r j~ bull J 0 ~~1~ ~ ~ qb~ ~ ~~ ~g P~Hl ~I rf$ Iamp I bull J J 150

~~lyenJ[1Jrpound~ W1Hjt1J~~f1t~~~~ffitJlyenJ jfd1t3~~lyenJ0fiX ~Jmm9~lfl)3 fJitt~~3t~ rsectf=rmt J lyenJ~JGI ~WM~~iPampt6ampBshy)iG~~fpoundjElyenJtt~$JJt lli~~~~~WilamplyenJffitJ 0 tErpttlyenJHNrp M

J if~~tt~]tfIDXB~~ (MS Gorbachev) lyenJc5lt~ ~-fI r sect miJitrJJ J q

lyenJFY E~D~fr~-f~Wf~ftglyenJlW~fDfT~ ~fr~~~mxB~~lyenJ~0

$fD-~ilampmfDggilamp~lyenJ~~f~Bf~~~~if~lyenJ~tJ~~~

~jtpound$I~JlU Tffl~~ r~tid1t3~ MzfYjt~~mtIJfDilampm~~ 0 J

016 ~~Z xB~~slf[~~~ffitJlyenJn~ if~iampramp5trtJ r sect fTmt J

~jt~~fftElyenJ~yenffttlo rptti~lli~3t~ r sectf=rmt J lyenJn~ ~sect15U~ ~te rjfd~3~tnamp0

~~~~lfll J lyenJ[sectlyenJz- gt~~~fEljttlyenJJCmffitJ t~yentl-lt5-YI~lyenJ pound~ 0 F~c5lt~OO~ r Jril~HSijj J lyenJfr~j ZjI 1Wfl)3 81~te r73t~lyenJ~]t

gtamp~m~rp~lyenJ-Wamp~lyenJbullbull gtamp~-~RlyenJilampmM ~ ~3t~lyenJ~]t gtY3t~~AIIlElyenJilampmrnireg Y5i~lyenJ~]t mEgU ~lyenJmm$gttflsectfm ~3t~lyenJ~]t ~~5ZI5ZW ~jU~~~U~~D ~5fDW~~gtJlyenJ~ffilliyenJLfm 0 iat~ jfd~3~IL9M1J~t~~ fftsect

I ~lyenJJC- ampBffi3~lyenJrl~ lli~Y5i~-MtJI~~~1y~a~fT 0 J 17

tJra~rpttlyenJc5lt~~EElyenJ r+-ftfL=rp~~ J f$jOOjjyenlyenJ ttlutrp~ tt~~flU~~ rc5lt~$~lyenJ~tIJ~5fD~]t~ J -1Srp~~~lyenJ~~ 0

~~ttfpoundjElyenJm~[1 fF7J)TlyenJflmt

)p 15 )1IJ r IIJ~W1itfif J bull ~gliH (m=~) (~Wff4 $~3tIUilplusmnllamprnJElJff 1949 if)

175 0

16 M Gorbachev Perestroika i Novae Myshlenie Dlya Nashei Strany i dlya Vsevo Mira (Moskva lzdatmiddot

elstvo Politcheskoi Literatury 1987) p 51

17 InJ2jS r EljllnjlJJt3~fGlif)J J bull llJJZfIliH (m=~) UtJ AJ~lplusmnllampjjiplusmn 1994 if 10 Fl) ~266

-- 7 flj

~tfB9=T~ r ffttlfft_H]JampIl~~Ji J 9=TlyenJjtfElts-~JjU~IyenJNJE

-fj

-fampffi rW~~M~~m~~k~bullbull~ar~JW f$t ~aIW~I~r~ J~~~~~~~~ ~t ~~ ~I~~bullbullbullW~o~~Mamp~W k~IIJ ~a~I~ r~fi~tJ W ~bullbull~~~~

rt r j~ bull J 0 ~~1~ ~ ~ qb~ ~ ~~ ~g P~Hl ~I rf$ Iamp I bull J J 150

~~lyenJ[1Jrpound~ W1Hjt1J~~f1t~~~~ffitJlyenJ jfd1t3~~lyenJ0fiX ~Jmm9~lfl)3 fJitt~~3t~ rsectf=rmt J lyenJ~JGI ~WM~~iPampt6ampBshy)iG~~fpoundjElyenJtt~$JJt lli~~~~~WilamplyenJffitJ 0 tErpttlyenJHNrp M

J if~~tt~]tfIDXB~~ (MS Gorbachev) lyenJc5lt~ ~-fI r sect miJitrJJ J q

lyenJFY E~D~fr~-f~Wf~ftglyenJlW~fDfT~ ~fr~~~mxB~~lyenJ~0

$fD-~ilampmfDggilamp~lyenJ~~f~Bf~~~~if~lyenJ~tJ~~~

~jtpound$I~JlU Tffl~~ r~tid1t3~ MzfYjt~~mtIJfDilampm~~ 0 J

016 ~~Z xB~~slf[~~~ffitJlyenJn~ if~iampramp5trtJ r sect fTmt J

~jt~~fftElyenJ~yenffttlo rptti~lli~3t~ r sectf=rmt J lyenJn~ ~sect15U~ ~te rjfd~3~tnamp0

~~~~lfll J lyenJ[sectlyenJz- gt~~~fEljttlyenJJCmffitJ t~yentl-lt5-YI~lyenJ pound~ 0 F~c5lt~OO~ r Jril~HSijj J lyenJfr~j ZjI 1Wfl)3 81~te r73t~lyenJ~]t

gtamp~m~rp~lyenJ-Wamp~lyenJbullbull gtamp~-~RlyenJilampmM ~ ~3t~lyenJ~]t gtY3t~~AIIlElyenJilampmrnireg Y5i~lyenJ~]t mEgU ~lyenJmm$gttflsectfm ~3t~lyenJ~]t ~~5ZI5ZW ~jU~~~U~~D ~5fDW~~gtJlyenJ~ffilliyenJLfm 0 iat~ jfd~3~IL9M1J~t~~ fftsect

I ~lyenJJC- ampBffi3~lyenJrl~ lli~Y5i~-MtJI~~~1y~a~fT 0 J 17

tJra~rpttlyenJc5lt~~EElyenJ r+-ftfL=rp~~ J f$jOOjjyenlyenJ ttlutrp~ tt~~flU~~ rc5lt~$~lyenJ~tIJ~5fD~]t~ J -1Srp~~~lyenJ~~ 0

~~ttfpoundjElyenJm~[1 fF7J)TlyenJflmt

)p 15 )1IJ r IIJ~W1itfif J bull ~gliH (m=~) (~Wff4 $~3tIUilplusmnllamprnJElJff 1949 if)

175 0

16 M Gorbachev Perestroika i Novae Myshlenie Dlya Nashei Strany i dlya Vsevo Mira (Moskva lzdatmiddot

elstvo Politcheskoi Literatury 1987) p 51

17 InJ2jS r EljllnjlJJt3~fGlif)J J bull llJJZfIliH (m=~) UtJ AJ~lplusmnllampjjiplusmn 1994 if 10 Fl) ~266

bull

I I

8

r~ ~bullbull~~_bullbull ~mwa~~~~~bullbull ~ ~ ~1f~~fiUIi sect ~ 0 BXX 31 ftJVfU i1 fmi ~ ~~~~~~M~~~fr~~I~amp~~~~ ~~MM~~~~~~~i1~o~~I~~I~ bull bull ~~~~~~-~~~ili~~~~~~~m ili~AW~~fi~~~~W-W~~T~~~~ ~~bullbull o~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~a

~I~~~~~~~a~~~~pound~~~I~pound ~~~o~-Wl~A~m~~ ~M~~bullbull~~ ~~~~~~bullbullK~~~W~oJ~

JilltCP~~~~IB~$ Jlf~ffsectampIB~fi 0 CP~~AO~~ ttCPtn-3ZEffD50~flB J~lBttjJm~~Y Q ~lllt ~ffilmlBftl

g~~~tt~m- ~1l~1Bf cp~~WjtH~-~iamp ~JU1~t~m0

iiiplusmn1ltlBmlji~ FiUAtfoJilmlBrJiEiWJ 0 ft~z~~]HyenIBf~r5rf fX ~m~aW~lBmiWJfD~ff~~MH~o~~~~tt~~ 11 c5l~ampIBFJIJmxf~DlttJJitz ~DJ1tfl~ ~~itEc5l~fjcpt~ iU-amptlEffftlBftO MLEimmiUHl1E~rHglBlEEE 0 ~D~1i~lItfffd~ ~~ffflifplusmn r g 1TmL J lBgrtu 0

CP~lE~~~E~mcp~~IB~~plusmn~~fffttf~~nshyftn-A~IB73ffBYJsect mftf r A~73$tHifIJ~f~rni IJ~~IB~~ ~fDil-amptffij5 fllilB~fi~[tIJn~lBfltifo~ 0 J ~-1JiID~g r ~ 739filtlM~nlBf1liiiJL Q J 19 Mtn-ffiMC5l$~ r ~iWJ~ J fD r ~~~~ J JEjtglB~fffl1sect ~reg~lln~JZt~t~RX7tJtilt ffij~Di1J~1tJtilt ~U0

~11ifl~MJc5llBtm=ampI[~Jrjmff m~~~IBfInfDjiBflL 0 ftllt fXfr~re ~iID~lBtJtilt ampiJ~ffl73ftfD9fft~1il$51- Q

18 ~ 1II~yenB9iM~~ (~ A~plusmnlllampffplusmn 1992 f 4 Fl) ]lt241

19 ~Js Ut~yenM ]It 364

fRlirp~ r jfrplusmn~plusmn~jltn~~~5t J rpB9~Wfijt5-illU~8lt]N~ 9

gt

- ~-tfa~~t~

9J~ r +~-=9J~tfJ pffmltJlyenJc)($n$ pg~~FmJJipound

ll rnH11yenJ~~ ~pffamp 1t~sectlyenJr~~m fu13-37~m ~m ~tfOft

1Hm~~1iIJ1fOO -tLtL1i1fhJ3 it E3 9J~9JR~if~i3rr~~1E IyenJ r+IZ9J~1i9J~tf J IyenJM~9J ~~7 r1E~~ffd1fplusmn~JJH-Itij ~9JIyenJsrmkUl1J ~~i5 0 yenI~~(pound~gi59J)1U~1yenJ rmk1m1J 1Mt ~-~$~~~~IyenJIm~~=~~fO~~IyenJUl~~~

Igt ~mij~~Ao~~$~IyenJIm~~IZ9~-==~~IyenJIm~

~1i$~f09Jsect$~IyenJIm~~~mbullbullbullfOR~1yenJ1m

f ~t 0ffftU~mfO1tftl1~m~f5tlyenJlmf 1ampA5tggc9J~~ 1E~f1J f~AIyenJ1m1 ~tL f1Ikft1HmtDIfIJ~M~ fJJsect1yenJ1m1 ~+ 9JRf1J j~nIyenJIm ~+- ~IWij~fO~mij~lyenJlmf m+= toJJif~aAij

~ ~fOmm$~aAij~IyenJIm~ 0 20

~9J~IyenJ~~~rr~~~mlyenJr+=kIm~J ~~+=liImk ~mfu~M~m~$~tDI~9J~OOftIyenJ+=~~~offi~~1E~$ ~fi9JFrnlyenJfFffl yenI~mlyenJ+=k1m1 B~nlG7~IyenJDmfJ~~ 0 ~i5 ~Rm yenJt~~sectt1EC)($9J~sect1yenJ~1t fu~sect7J7Wf~DmlyenJr~~m

~~Imtl1lyenJm~~ 0

Ui5~mlyenJr~m~9JRm~lyenJ~uamp~fO~J1fflJlIyenJ~~ 0 fW~~m1E ~m~~~~~W9JR~~~~~rBJ~~~~~~r BJ famp~~Ij~~M~~HgFrn3sectU~Ji2JfOmmilyenJfFffl 0 A1t~~H fO~Jff~H~IyenJJFeuroi~ftbLk fI~~fJ~amp~ 0 21 flIJi5IyenJ~$ fu~~rr~~1E r + =krulf J 9Jm3sectUIyenJ9JRfIJ~n1yenJ rulfr~5m 0 tI~~flilm r C)($~tDlt~ JrfImfJTtDI ~nUt~]jtt1~ 3sectUJB5t~tJj fffJjtEmItJ7C)($fIJ~~ 0 ~-f~m~~~ ffampJB5t1JD j)tsectt~ 0 191E1iI~fliI9J fumm7 -reg$JfIyenJ~~fOr~5m 0 fflyenJj~nfOil~

r~~~j~~I1~ il~r~lyenJrnJ$frj~ j1fr(tMI9JRIyenJnfO~~ ~ fJ ftyenmm 7 -tff~ TffW fffJ~fr ff~~IfIyenJJJt~ 0 J 22

20 yenIltreisectii~rfE=ffilft 3t3tl1 EI~taJl~tllll JQbullbullic~tgt (~tJjt cp~ifrplusmn~f4~tllltampifrplusmn 1996

~ 0 Fl) J 1-17 bull

~ 21 ~Ja fplusmntill1li~ J 377 bull

22 ~~aJl bullbulllCifM J 14 bull

I

10

It1TN~cp~~~ftt~Jjtk$M~IyenJ~~rmsect ~o~amp1ifJiHcp9lt~ili 1J1yenJ~~ lilfJt~yentilampgiID~IyenJ-JJU~~~ 0 cP~~~~g1E~g1~~

JgLIyenJ~fj~ secttt8it~yenU~lrJjJil fltfr~~pound~~~tpoundOfF-tmlm ~~~ ~cp9ltmj]~-ilif~lfili~n~ f~~~~J~~~~fj[-1t~IyenJ~~ 0

g1JO~ttfDmlyenJtffli~i5~ 8frtR~~UpMcp9lt rm~~~~gjJf~ ~lyenJmj] 0 iampfamp~3ampjtB1Jwcp9ltzrafflij]fDflj~IyenJY~fD~~ 0 239 tJ1amp1yenJ~~~~Ii~A ~C)riJlyenJm~~z-~p~1ampxfflij]TtampIyenJlttrjffi 0 ~~J

Xgg~7 CP9ltfflimt~U~~1yenJ1amplJtfE 0 tJM~~x~fsecttJ fit sect1E1JD~ttfD ~~mffli~NlyenJc)riJ~~fflfjlyenJ~~ r ElEf3M$jfC~ZfflJIyenJ6t~fD3tT ~~~m~~cp~~~IyenJ~cp~fflij]Ttamp~~~~~7CP~lt~ m~~ ili1Jt~ T~t~poundifi ~~~mlplusmnm71EMiJL 0 J 24

-~~m~~~Jil~~3amp~~MRIyenJt~~~El~~~~~~~ m~IyenJIt~~ ~fr~~~~jlCP~Wf~1J~~~~JijJPJTjfpoundIyenJ~rJFffl 0 ~

J WfJiilampm~~fJi~iflilyenJ~g fu7t~yentJ~lrJtJil 0 fltfr~tllplusmn r ilamp~Jt 1(amp J (Policy-Penetrat ion) IyenJ~~ j ~PilampJM1EjtI1JilamptJ~ ~D~~ZJt1(amp ~ftIyenJT~ampm~~bullbullbullIyenJ~Mo~ilampJM~m~~- Jil~ooR~bullbull~mlyenJmj]D~-~mMlyenJr~J (C~ sis) MilampJampiID~ rilamp~Jt1(ampJ ~IyenJB~f~ ~~~9rfu7Wampitf1t~~O0

r gj ~~poundPJ J r 1E1C15~ J r ilampm~WJ r j$t~fJifDT~c J tJ amp r m~15J ~~bullbull 25 ~IE9 r~ J IyenJffJl~ [jJtJtlft~fr~Tffi~~ Ef3~rm3ltIyenJfJiIDIi~fiyenjmiddot

~7J~~JtftlyenUlyenJcp~fflimt~~~fD~JfiUft~~~51 ~fr~~pound~tt 1il~IyenJ~-~1EtJ~~~IyenJJl9f1trJtJil bull pJT~fjfflij]f~AJl9f1t ~ltlyenJfflij]~U ~3amp~ltIyenJJl9f1t bull mr~~tt1E~~ilampieuroift1tUCP ~Wl~mfflij] M1t 1yenJm~~p~~ttrffl~it bull -1tJOfFf-ttltn M~11fL~mlyenJfX1M~~JJT (Konstantin M Simis) bull 1tf1HffltmJfIyenJ~ bull ~7-lt$i5m r~~ JI9f

1tlyenJftJ (USSRThe Corrupt Society) WiJ bull ~WT1EiJCP1aHi~~~ffd Jl9f1tlyenJm~J1I1T~ r IAtJti(Kyen1JoyenrJHlfHm~jm sect 1yenJ~1yenU~TIyenJI fF ilampw~lyenJfl~fm~~~~~~~x mf~ttBTj~ ~13fijt(n~x~fiMt yen~+1Il1ll1tJ ~riJMfijtL~ mrx1t$~tJi~Jg~JmIyenJ~~BHJjUr bull

23 ~1i~1~ filJlIIcfDUttlilJll Utg ~IplusmnIIlamp~plusmn 1999lf I Fl) bull fi 241 bull

24 IiLt fi 247-248 bull

25 li~7IiMil~~ iEt)s~M (a~t JiXxft$~rpL ~~ 65lf 10 Fl) Ji 4-5 0

fRlirp~ r jfrplusmn~plusmn~jltn~~~5t J rpB9~Wfijt5-illU~8lt]N~ 9

gt

- ~-tfa~~t~

9J~ r +~-=9J~tfJ pffmltJlyenJc)($n$ pg~~FmJJipound

ll rnH11yenJ~~ ~pffamp 1t~sectlyenJr~~m fu13-37~m ~m ~tfOft

1Hm~~1iIJ1fOO -tLtL1i1fhJ3 it E3 9J~9JR~if~i3rr~~1E IyenJ r+IZ9J~1i9J~tf J IyenJM~9J ~~7 r1E~~ffd1fplusmn~JJH-Itij ~9JIyenJsrmkUl1J ~~i5 0 yenI~~(pound~gi59J)1U~1yenJ rmk1m1J 1Mt ~-~$~~~~IyenJIm~~=~~fO~~IyenJUl~~~

Igt ~mij~~Ao~~$~IyenJIm~~IZ9~-==~~IyenJIm~

~1i$~f09Jsect$~IyenJIm~~~mbullbullbullfOR~1yenJ1m

f ~t 0ffftU~mfO1tftl1~m~f5tlyenJlmf 1ampA5tggc9J~~ 1E~f1J f~AIyenJ1m1 ~tL f1Ikft1HmtDIfIJ~M~ fJJsect1yenJ1m1 ~+ 9JRf1J j~nIyenJIm ~+- ~IWij~fO~mij~lyenJlmf m+= toJJif~aAij

~ ~fOmm$~aAij~IyenJIm~ 0 20

~9J~IyenJ~~~rr~~~mlyenJr+=kIm~J ~~+=liImk ~mfu~M~m~$~tDI~9J~OOftIyenJ+=~~~offi~~1E~$ ~fi9JFrnlyenJfFffl yenI~mlyenJ+=k1m1 B~nlG7~IyenJDmfJ~~ 0 ~i5 ~Rm yenJt~~sectt1EC)($9J~sect1yenJ~1t fu~sect7J7Wf~DmlyenJr~~m

~~Imtl1lyenJm~~ 0

Ui5~mlyenJr~m~9JRm~lyenJ~uamp~fO~J1fflJlIyenJ~~ 0 fW~~m1E ~m~~~~~W9JR~~~~~rBJ~~~~~~r BJ famp~~Ij~~M~~HgFrn3sectU~Ji2JfOmmilyenJfFffl 0 A1t~~H fO~Jff~H~IyenJJFeuroi~ftbLk fI~~fJ~amp~ 0 21 flIJi5IyenJ~$ fu~~rr~~1E r + =krulf J 9Jm3sectUIyenJ9JRfIJ~n1yenJ rulfr~5m 0 tI~~flilm r C)($~tDlt~ JrfImfJTtDI ~nUt~]jtt1~ 3sectUJB5t~tJj fffJjtEmItJ7C)($fIJ~~ 0 ~-f~m~~~ ffampJB5t1JD j)tsectt~ 0 191E1iI~fliI9J fumm7 -reg$JfIyenJ~~fOr~5m 0 fflyenJj~nfOil~

r~~~j~~I1~ il~r~lyenJrnJ$frj~ j1fr(tMI9JRIyenJnfO~~ ~ fJ ftyenmm 7 -tff~ TffW fffJ~fr ff~~IfIyenJJJt~ 0 J 22

20 yenIltreisectii~rfE=ffilft 3t3tl1 EI~taJl~tllll JQbullbullic~tgt (~tJjt cp~ifrplusmn~f4~tllltampifrplusmn 1996

~ 0 Fl) J 1-17 bull

~ 21 ~Ja fplusmntill1li~ J 377 bull

22 ~~aJl bullbulllCifM J 14 bull

I

10

It1TN~cp~~~ftt~Jjtk$M~IyenJ~~rmsect ~o~amp1ifJiHcp9lt~ili 1J1yenJ~~ lilfJt~yentilampgiID~IyenJ-JJU~~~ 0 cP~~~~g1E~g1~~

JgLIyenJ~fj~ secttt8it~yenU~lrJjJil fltfr~~pound~~~tpoundOfF-tmlm ~~~ ~cp9ltmj]~-ilif~lfili~n~ f~~~~J~~~~fj[-1t~IyenJ~~ 0

g1JO~ttfDmlyenJtffli~i5~ 8frtR~~UpMcp9lt rm~~~~gjJf~ ~lyenJmj] 0 iampfamp~3ampjtB1Jwcp9ltzrafflij]fDflj~IyenJY~fD~~ 0 239 tJ1amp1yenJ~~~~Ii~A ~C)riJlyenJm~~z-~p~1ampxfflij]TtampIyenJlttrjffi 0 ~~J

Xgg~7 CP9ltfflimt~U~~1yenJ1amplJtfE 0 tJM~~x~fsecttJ fit sect1E1JD~ttfD ~~mffli~NlyenJc)riJ~~fflfjlyenJ~~ r ElEf3M$jfC~ZfflJIyenJ6t~fD3tT ~~~m~~cp~~~IyenJ~cp~fflij]Ttamp~~~~~7CP~lt~ m~~ ili1Jt~ T~t~poundifi ~~~mlplusmnm71EMiJL 0 J 24

-~~m~~~Jil~~3amp~~MRIyenJt~~~El~~~~~~~ m~IyenJIt~~ ~fr~~~~jlCP~Wf~1J~~~~JijJPJTjfpoundIyenJ~rJFffl 0 ~

J WfJiilampm~~fJi~iflilyenJ~g fu7t~yentJ~lrJtJil 0 fltfr~tllplusmn r ilamp~Jt 1(amp J (Policy-Penetrat ion) IyenJ~~ j ~PilampJM1EjtI1JilamptJ~ ~D~~ZJt1(amp ~ftIyenJT~ampm~~bullbullbullIyenJ~Mo~ilampJM~m~~- Jil~ooR~bullbull~mlyenJmj]D~-~mMlyenJr~J (C~ sis) MilampJampiID~ rilamp~Jt1(ampJ ~IyenJB~f~ ~~~9rfu7Wampitf1t~~O0

r gj ~~poundPJ J r 1E1C15~ J r ilampm~WJ r j$t~fJifDT~c J tJ amp r m~15J ~~bullbull 25 ~IE9 r~ J IyenJffJl~ [jJtJtlft~fr~Tffi~~ Ef3~rm3ltIyenJfJiIDIi~fiyenjmiddot

~7J~~JtftlyenUlyenJcp~fflimt~~~fD~JfiUft~~~51 ~fr~~pound~tt 1il~IyenJ~-~1EtJ~~~IyenJJl9f1trJtJil bull pJT~fjfflij]f~AJl9f1t ~ltlyenJfflij]~U ~3amp~ltIyenJJl9f1t bull mr~~tt1E~~ilampieuroift1tUCP ~Wl~mfflij] M1t 1yenJm~~p~~ttrffl~it bull -1tJOfFf-ttltn M~11fL~mlyenJfX1M~~JJT (Konstantin M Simis) bull 1tf1HffltmJfIyenJ~ bull ~7-lt$i5m r~~ JI9f

1tlyenJftJ (USSRThe Corrupt Society) WiJ bull ~WT1EiJCP1aHi~~~ffd Jl9f1tlyenJm~J1I1T~ r IAtJti(Kyen1JoyenrJHlfHm~jm sect 1yenJ~1yenU~TIyenJI fF ilampw~lyenJfl~fm~~~~~~~x mf~ttBTj~ ~13fijt(n~x~fiMt yen~+1Il1ll1tJ ~riJMfijtL~ mrx1t$~tJi~Jg~JmIyenJ~~BHJjUr bull

23 ~1i~1~ filJlIIcfDUttlilJll Utg ~IplusmnIIlamp~plusmn 1999lf I Fl) bull fi 241 bull

24 IiLt fi 247-248 bull

25 li~7IiMil~~ iEt)s~M (a~t JiXxft$~rpL ~~ 65lf 10 Fl) Ji 4-5 0

I

10

It1TN~cp~~~ftt~Jjtk$M~IyenJ~~rmsect ~o~amp1ifJiHcp9lt~ili 1J1yenJ~~ lilfJt~yentilampgiID~IyenJ-JJU~~~ 0 cP~~~~g1E~g1~~

JgLIyenJ~fj~ secttt8it~yenU~lrJjJil fltfr~~pound~~~tpoundOfF-tmlm ~~~ ~cp9ltmj]~-ilif~lfili~n~ f~~~~J~~~~fj[-1t~IyenJ~~ 0

g1JO~ttfDmlyenJtffli~i5~ 8frtR~~UpMcp9lt rm~~~~gjJf~ ~lyenJmj] 0 iampfamp~3ampjtB1Jwcp9ltzrafflij]fDflj~IyenJY~fD~~ 0 239 tJ1amp1yenJ~~~~Ii~A ~C)riJlyenJm~~z-~p~1ampxfflij]TtampIyenJlttrjffi 0 ~~J

Xgg~7 CP9ltfflimt~U~~1yenJ1amplJtfE 0 tJM~~x~fsecttJ fit sect1E1JD~ttfD ~~mffli~NlyenJc)riJ~~fflfjlyenJ~~ r ElEf3M$jfC~ZfflJIyenJ6t~fD3tT ~~~m~~cp~~~IyenJ~cp~fflij]Ttamp~~~~~7CP~lt~ m~~ ili1Jt~ T~t~poundifi ~~~mlplusmnm71EMiJL 0 J 24

-~~m~~~Jil~~3amp~~MRIyenJt~~~El~~~~~~~ m~IyenJIt~~ ~fr~~~~jlCP~Wf~1J~~~~JijJPJTjfpoundIyenJ~rJFffl 0 ~

J WfJiilampm~~fJi~iflilyenJ~g fu7t~yentJ~lrJtJil 0 fltfr~tllplusmn r ilamp~Jt 1(amp J (Policy-Penetrat ion) IyenJ~~ j ~PilampJM1EjtI1JilamptJ~ ~D~~ZJt1(amp ~ftIyenJT~ampm~~bullbullbullIyenJ~Mo~ilampJM~m~~- Jil~ooR~bullbull~mlyenJmj]D~-~mMlyenJr~J (C~ sis) MilampJampiID~ rilamp~Jt1(ampJ ~IyenJB~f~ ~~~9rfu7Wampitf1t~~O0

r gj ~~poundPJ J r 1E1C15~ J r ilampm~WJ r j$t~fJifDT~c J tJ amp r m~15J ~~bullbull 25 ~IE9 r~ J IyenJffJl~ [jJtJtlft~fr~Tffi~~ Ef3~rm3ltIyenJfJiIDIi~fiyenjmiddot

~7J~~JtftlyenUlyenJcp~fflimt~~~fD~JfiUft~~~51 ~fr~~pound~tt 1il~IyenJ~-~1EtJ~~~IyenJJl9f1trJtJil bull pJT~fjfflij]f~AJl9f1t ~ltlyenJfflij]~U ~3amp~ltIyenJJl9f1t bull mr~~tt1E~~ilampieuroift1tUCP ~Wl~mfflij] M1t 1yenJm~~p~~ttrffl~it bull -1tJOfFf-ttltn M~11fL~mlyenJfX1M~~JJT (Konstantin M Simis) bull 1tf1HffltmJfIyenJ~ bull ~7-lt$i5m r~~ JI9f

1tlyenJftJ (USSRThe Corrupt Society) WiJ bull ~WT1EiJCP1aHi~~~ffd Jl9f1tlyenJm~J1I1T~ r IAtJti(Kyen1JoyenrJHlfHm~jm sect 1yenJ~1yenU~TIyenJI fF ilampw~lyenJfl~fm~~~~~~~x mf~ttBTj~ ~13fijt(n~x~fiMt yen~+1Il1ll1tJ ~riJMfijtL~ mrx1t$~tJi~Jg~JmIyenJ~~BHJjUr bull

23 ~1i~1~ filJlIIcfDUttlilJll Utg ~IplusmnIIlamp~plusmn 1999lf I Fl) bull fi 241 bull

24 IiLt fi 247-248 bull

25 li~7IiMil~~ iEt)s~M (a~t JiXxft$~rpL ~~ 65lf 10 Fl) Ji 4-5 0

-- 11

tlj

~rp~ r fplusmntttf_HJJampI~$~ J rp8g~fllsect il~nIU~8gampJlSt

RJiJitf3

0N-gImp ~z ~-1ilAifBsrtmtl~~1t J 26 tE3t~~7E~ (LY Andropov) tAt1E iT ~ ~~C~ ~tCAW~~~tt1yenJ~1trl=l~ iamp5iWWJ~JyenPDc$lyenJm~t1 0

~~ 0 -arltftlampampIyenJ~rlOfamp9R ~1t~7kti1E~~$M~IyenJ1famp1~ 0

1lffffs ~tt~~fuft~~tt$amp~IyenJ~1ilm$~degtE~tt~amplli~

~k 1yenJ-JfHtT~ 1W~PO~IyenJ~i11 ~fiT1

r~~I~~~ ~~m~~middotA~~~~5fO 7J A 7G PJ 1amptl1E~ iii ~ tfHt ~~jpoundIt Jr ~t)d- 0 lAiIt ~lQ--rcft

~~~I~~It~~~~wa~~~~~~f1ffiJif

ro~ a~~~~~~~~ I~~~~~ft~ 1ft ( Jf ~ ftjjJlfif11ijlUHI1 ~~ ffl it Itx 5f6 ~L iliu 1lt 7G ~ it

~~ ~7G~ ilimr ~~+~~~~~7G ~~A ~

~r~ttu~bullbull ~~~r~~~~~~~o~7G ~~bullbull~mmiddot~Rti~~~t~~~~~~

f(N ~~~~~~ ~~R~~I~~~bullbull~~$~

~ ~~4~ ~H~~bullbull~~~~~~~~~~H~ i- bullbull I middot bullbull middot~A~ ~~~H~~~~~R~~J

I1E~1T~1T~X ~~~ l~m~~~Rbullbull ~ ~~~m~ifm~~_middot bullbull~~middotX~~~ ~

1~l ~u ~ IA 0J ~~~~ ~jpound TlU 8i BY I ~fl1lJU~ itt t9)I~ tlJ ~1Ta~Wabullbull~~~oJn

45-rptt~yenti~JJlIyenJ~ 1yenJ~JampijL~f~tm~fIfItJlyenJJnipff$ ffi)~lli~tE-rJ~JffJ1ti 0 IJa~~~ r~tE~f~~JampfJU~rleurol~-rJ

~JffJ1ti~sectf~1~freg~mmrH1ff1yenJ 0 PO-rJ~~jhpound~ (ijltE~dB~~rp

1pound~fu~7) ffampmtI1FA~ffAA~tEAt~~cfJasectm~~~~1TlyenJnpound ttfEAtf-tttfElt1TAA ttfEltrtilttfEltnfJ8t1(1ffisfll bull ~-~ti~filamp1f Ii -=shyBiJJ bull Ir1iBiJl lfElfilJ7 0 ~t~ffi[iE45-Aijt~IyenJ~Jamp J 28

~ bull 7~1pound t1j t~~

1pound~$~m1ilf[l[~ttl~1amp ~rJiZsect1JAplusmn1iiJnt~rpttWrEeuro~Ziamp

26 Konstantin M Simis USSR The Corrupt Society (New York Simon and Schuster 1982) p 297

27 =EKi7f BpoundaJl~~ff _IyenJflU flIyenJEi$-Ull~IiJ$ifmplllilt~ppoundllt1) +JiJ1F_JlyenJmiiS (jiiJ~t cp~cp~~lplusmnlltampffd 1991 5f 7 FI) f 175-176

28 WIJfimiddot u_tlleiyenia f 370-371

bull 12

mffttttW~-OO1yenrFBJ1t~ ~~BJtp~r~~JU1JTIYD (Kenneth0

Liberthal) ~t5lNPtBjf( ~~~Affi~tp~~~~iH~ABJ1yenIj-Eltfil ~-OO3 EE~plusmnBJrampm ttFmt~1Jpoundtp~mmBJ~ft 29 Bf~ ftpound-1L1L0

2]poundfJR ~~I~~~f1P~1j-JJi~Imtp~tpound-tpoundfPliif~~~~fPJftMJ rpoundBJ1itf~ 0 ~-1itf~~JE ftl)yzptttiampill~~fRA~f)f 0 ~ tpound~W1itf ~BJ+-tjl~~1f~B-fJTamp~~Mtp ~~lli~SgAfsect1a tp~~ tpound~7~Wjra~~~~t~ft1fABJ rB-~ J Jtiif~~ti~fJ5CPtpound-~JE~WjPl

1~~1WlJjt~tJfL ~tlmJfBJttf1fplusmn~ JJyen7t~1Wm fsect113cp~~ W-1L1L2]poundfBJ~J(~IJ~~~~=B-z-BJA ffi]sect)jPJTffi~tlmBJ r 13 EE1tO)($llf~ J JUfBi~2ff~ftJiif~M5~BJ$ 0 30

CP~~~illamp~B-MilfWT fELL~-P31fBJ rWj~J 0

sectP~~tEt~mM~JfHlJIJmBJ~~ ~fu~tp~yen4JJtpoundrEGD~ rampfDZP~0

~F~ J BJplusmn~JJjUZg 0 tpoundcp~BJfi~~lf ~iampi1iU~BJ2SJ~ ~7pg~ sect1lBJ~1t9 P31ftiffdtfplusmn~~~1jBJfDZP~~~~ m7fsect~BJ ~fflffi]~~~~ftpound~~mWj~e~~~7omBftp~Sg~$ffi ~j1ij rfDzp~~~~ J ~~J~t~ r~-ftsecttpound~~ramp1i1 ~~ i CT+

-1f-fE___ ~F~jJBJ fi fOZP1fAn 1L1WfD1m~ffiplusmntfplusmn~~ n~iIIBJ ~]i~ m~~~fiplusmn~tpound~~-~~TBJ~Sg~~liI~ J 310

tpoundtp~HFtp P31ftiffiplusmntfplusmn~~~BJfDZP~~~ ifEt)i1i~~fO ~ffm~~ EIill2SJlttf1tp~~~-OO 0 tp~~7f rtpoundtp~A~~fD~ ~~m~~~ff~SgP31famp~~jJ~~ffl~~1m~WfDZP~~amp$~~

=Frampf111tp~ ~liIlm~iIBJ~~fDfX~ffdtfplusmn~1ttl1l 0 ~amp$~ lfiXij~=F ~~~B~fjfg xBffffl 1~ ~i=F~ID~BJ~1t tpound1 ~B~MJtJWmjZJj~pJT1~ 0 J 32

tp~M~~E~~Sg~EEMtp~~amp~~BTP31fAplusmnffifflMSg m~1L1WSg~ilB~ fXffi]1-ZBJ~ r-oo~mcpBJ~ J mfQ~ cP~~2~

~-il1fQil)WJe~8mffP31f ~5JU~~~BJmtpound~ljfffrilampA 0 pJT~ r tp~BJ~ mJ Jtplusmn~SgmBf~tp~Sg~~m~e~iamp~OO~~~jJBJmnocp~

29 Kenneth Lieberthal A New China Strategy Foreign Affairs Nov Dec 1995 p 37

30 31 3~t)fPif ll1f1E~ IIIfJljpoundfJ(Jilii IJ~fJ(Jmtl (ft BJl~ililtiiiitf 1997lf 10 Fl) ffi 347 0

31 ~51~tt~ilIfijCyenf~~j(f J litlffll ilsectjIll~fJ(J~ljpoundiJiUamp (~t ~~yenJ(1filiJlfgti)jiplusmn

32 fPJJmiddot ffi 52-53

th feuro 1 f ( ~

g

~

IDibljt( r ifrplusmnltplusmnilif)]ampllfsectf~ J ljt1yenJ(fEl5-iU~U~IyenJampJEt 13

~rg~1f5IillllH0~fDtltW~Nf1iyenJm~tlfflJ r =OO1iifCP~iyenJ~~1 ~m~~~B~mm=~~~~-O-O~=O=Oif~~ CP~iyenJ~~1gtm~OO~$V~f~)G ~~~~TmflfE~tltW]Hv J ~~1f5ffig)ijJ tt~~iyenJIsect cP cP ~PVffi~iyenJifI~ r amp4f~~~I~~Ufuft fD)Xffm~1~t5fD3if1il3tfjlliyenJg)ijJ~ 0 J 33 ~rmttjipJ~MffijlJM~

~iyenJ~jyentfuftfDEJfyen~~~ff~~TtJ5~ -~Fm~~~EJ~~~ cP ~iyenJPVffi~~~Ttfu~Damp1iltJ~~ -~Fmffl~tamppoundJt~1mfyeniyenJffd1Wtji1 ~ cp~iyenJIJ(~~~ Jt~~j1fUfi~1Jlf~li~fD1frsect1fa f1~TmiyenJ ~if cp~ijpoundm ~-yJW~ r cp~~ftlfnlf J iyenJplusmn~IcflIl1t(~ tamp-f0

JW ~U~~~A9i-XiyenJIcflIlfH1Jllt 0 34

f1~ cp ~5ffi~JWJr fFIHI m cp ~~~l1J~ffitampiiJij~gt1iyenJ1[$5i ftJirtu [Il]fl~1f~$U~Ic 0 ~1f~~W6m CP~tt21fH~5ffiiyenJtfu ft 1Wyen$Jr8fD~~iyenJ5fIJ~1ti~ 1Z9~ ~~iyenJretJE2NHDampmsect flrr~ jff~tfu1ilP9tbJjtHiiJ1~fJt1JiyenJ~~ 0 jsect1f~~5ffig)ijJ tt4tamp- +ifP9 cp~ooriiJjff~tfutt~~llitZP~jfu1il ~-l~-~~ct1tfu ftiyenJtl1Jft3-e 0 IZ9Ift ~Cp~iElIJ~1J~E-Ef ~~J)1[$-yenf~m~8FJT sectfflJiyenJilJcp~ij~jplusmn~lliffiB~ ~~Wcp~iaxJsect_~iyenJiiJij~I~7tru u7R

ttcp~1[1J BtjiyenJ[1fyen5lLlm~ 0 35

~-fLfL1iif~$UfL71+fJ]iyenJ-Efij$~~ ~~tflamp1~frAiyenJff llW illLWcp~~~~UW~5iiyenJ~Nffi 0 fSiitamp fOJifij[~MtWYI$~iiifMEEL3i f1T f~MIDJro~ illLsect~m1te-~ r9tg9tEiyenJ~~~IUJJ mcp~Jt~ ~iyenJ7JX1f1illLmfl Q Jr~J tt~tIDJCP~Jt9i-IUJ~J$ t~$UiyenJ-JN EP~~ rp~ijpound~~~Jtrp~iyenJ~~sect~~ltag1[ti~~ JJJ)mllW rfDzp~

~J ~~mm~iyenJsectflll 0

~JtfJ~J1ltm

fIDJtt3 P9)iyenJtJ~~ cp~tflampiyenJ[3J~Jtm~fr5l7U~~~ m- J)

33 $ftdt rlHiJiiliU~1t~fNJElijil-E1l rrrstit~~ ]~Ji1jlllrp~rHHJ tp~Mlii (~ tf) bull 1998 iF I F~ bull J 38-39

34 ~~ rstjfIi~fampcp~lBlf~~jtf5~JlCamp~J tp~llfii 1998 iF lOFilItf bull J 24

35 Richard Bernstein and Ross H Munro The Coming Conflict With America Foreign Affairs March

I April 1997 p 21

0

14

I

m~U$t~iyenJ~t~cpijjU)Jj~rJ C)(~iyenJ~j~ W1r~iyenJlI~ ~ - 1JD~ilampmi5~g~ff ~JjU~ r J ~ff ~= jJYiim~ nJJifrplusmn ttiyenJ~B~n5mtJ ~JjU~~iijiJtiyenJJfJfAArtl~~ ~QY fij]~ft51g1 m~ lffrjiyenJ~~$fji 0

- ti-1 ~t ~ tp ~~

1iff~re~~~~9iyenJAtBttIlfM 9amp1ltn~1riyenJlfdttt~ijjU jt lampiyenJyen-flUi~m~711lAiyenJ1I~1tm ~j~AlItJ~cp1tiyenJftJrQ] ft~U$0

t~iyenJ~t~cpijjrJ~UIDRI~)( 0 xE~I~g~1trft 1poundilampmc)($7JIffijRJf5l ~liiffliyenJFYii - fLfL--middot iFgtt jj ~Jt cpR3ttjj~jELffiiyenJ~Jt~~jlj[~ ~U~lJ)j~BjG31iY~7~t~cpijj~ 0 1Z9~ ~iyenJ~~jlj[~~fij] ~fD ~Ji r 1I1rfsect J flJiyenJ~mJl~ r JJirzfsectm J El]lt~iyenJ]At

r rg~plusmniyenJ~~ J fM-11lJl~tBf1~~~1iY~ftlfsect ciyenJ ill~MIJsectfrp~~~rwftBiyenJ]A1n5 ft8f~ r ImH~jfsect El3fiifd J ~p

lEiC~~P31JjUn5WJ 0 illfl[wbl ~~~~~m7fj~ltmiyenJ1t IZ90

1lt 1tm~iyenJrg1m~~ CP~~1~teiyenJ~liHi~

rfplusmntplusmn~~a9~~~~~ff~plusmnlfUa9~~U iL~~1ff ~~~a9~~~amp~~~~~~~~ ~a9

bullbull ~~Iff~~V~~~plusmnR~~lf ~~

Al~M~ra9bullbullv~~yenftamp~~~~ ~PV~plusmn~lr~ lf~~o~M~a9~ ~~oJ36

hsect~IrI+ttgtr+tCflrnrIfiSsectrr rt1plusmnttJ0~I-=ltsectl)2i bullr) I U~~r~I rpHlJT-7~ 1 ~ J-~13 r1U~ bull

~-lE~~Mreg~~~tW~Cp~~o~plusmniyenJ~~~P3-17J~i=3El33bullbulljtIi~jj~1~~1pound-$2f~f~lfr~~ iyenJFfflf~

~j2yenrrxjtreg~tii=3El3~~Ji1 jEllpoundjamprQ]3bullbull~yenampEIF Ii ~ti~jEQJ~J~fJ El11l~=lmfjg1llzttB~~fsectaiyenJ~~ 0

~CPiyenJ~~~iyenJ~~tt~iyenJlamp~lItJ~gcpR~~tt ~~JfBm~j~IFiyenJlamp~~g 3pound~amplf1t-s~yenfj poundi~~~iyenJ mc$ 3poundjamp~f~lfttB~amp1ttiyenJ~~ ji~gamp1tt~~ -Fampgamptt1~ 0

~=middot~~~t~~cp~fiiyenJ~~o~~~~~~cpfi~

15 ~rp~ r iiiplusmnfr1JjHJJfampIPamp~Jt J rp~~Pl-E ~JU~~ampJ0

t yenAI=r~fjcpl=r~cp 0

~~1fi7t~~P9~t0 ~12B CPR~~I=r~tiI~JllJ$U 0 37

cp 59iIDijJ~t~CP$tllyenJt~ sect IyenJ~W11amp~IyenJ~JllJm~ ~~MMrr~ ~tiI$tl~~ff~m~~~ 0yenI~~~~~IlBJJZjSIyenJ1i~rrumjJcpJ f

ITWIlBJZjSf~ ~~5E~IyenJ~~1159i~jJlyenJ~JllJm~ ~DIfl ~0

3WilampIyenJJIWJ~Uml1JlJ~J5JTamp~ 0 ~759ityenI~~IyenJ~JlJmjJ WJZjStWm te r ~J J IyenJ~~

r~M-bullbullbullbullbull~-~~~~~~laquo~~I~ft~o -~laquo~bullbull~~~~~o~A~ ~I~laquo~~ r~fu~~~~~bullbullho~~w~a~~ ~ AfintilE FP1t1 m1~1fJ~dtJ if)) ~~~1a1rl ~~ ~~~~~ ~o~A~~~~~bullbull~~

~J~ -i~~gt ~6rJt~(poundi ~ ~ ~bullbull ~A ~ Jt~ sect ft1JIUI M~~~bullbull~bullbull-ft~~~~~(pound~~a ~~~oJ38

IlBJZjSmte r ~J J IyenJtl1t sect 1yenJ~1l~yenI~~lyenJmjJtgft m~~ m~IyenJ~mtglliompound~~R~$~IyenJ~I1Jcp~~mJU~7W

11~JllJ~~~~m~ ~JllJ~~JsectIyenJF$mffiM7 rimft1~ftjs 0 lZ9 Ifl cp~~mmte7-f)1U=6poundlyenJf=r~mfB

~- 1l]sdiiJj45-9~ mZt~~m~iampIyenJ-ltt1 l1fE~IplusmnI~~~H~0

rpoundIyenJ~11J ~~amp~FH1iampIyenJIDijJ~ iBpound)jrru~fra~~D- CP~1t~0

Wj45-9a~lyenJfiIj$ mg~4~JU~JllJ~lUllyenJm~ ~= ~~=f~jffflyenJ~lJ~~~~JA~~N1fsect~ii f~g1fsectfff

Lgt 0t=I

39 ~J~~~Iamp59iIyenJ1iAJt gfli~lJt~g~1iAdb~ 0

- JJllJ J~ 1- t 1S ~ ~ qx rJJtJ - ~ 10 I~

~DiWpJT~ U1ltt~f]amp~~~~ill m17CP~~fEcplJH=r~J~

37 [Q)J ~ 353-355 bull

38 iIlJZPY~ ~=~ ~ 309-310 bull 51 Er~fr~ mltttll tilJamp~fI~ldI (1ftili aA~tfjltlii U 1997 if un f 4 bull

39 Ji~~ lttt1l2lljJtI9iUi~iJ f 271 0

16

~~~~~mn~~~~~of8~$~~~m~~~~~~m eOOii7 r~mfDlli~j ~rll~ 0 1I~~1Ec~~~mJL-t+Jffl]if~ -~~~1l~1f-tt8 rlf~[rlJ~WWd1fplusmnllM~HlfH~W~J5JmiU~amp~~Jmjj

plusmn~W~~lf~~~Btt1fplusmn~~M~~~-t~~7~~~~~~ fpound lf~$$~~~~ JiStJti1lffI ttmi1Rffi~WJiijg ~yenUM~~FafDft ftj5~~ff~~amp~mffi$tt lf~fl~~1li 1En~plusmn~OOMjijfl~~ ~1t PJyentfjffllTlmllmz~yeni~ ~sectjaiyenlpJTm~1amp~ j 4deg~~~[lf~0

1~~~~9Ct~J~JJJampmI1F~m~ lZSI~ tlD[rlJ1I~~pJTm r~fr~

~~ijgtlD~~~ampf~m1amp16~J[ 1F~~~ampJ~m~amp~1famp16~J[ f1t0

fr~amp~Jil1Epoundt-~t~fD~cmz~fi1ff~~~~~~wll 0 j 41

W~~~~~~~~m~~-M~~~~~~~~~olZSlmr~

~~muwrlli~~JmyenUalE~~-t+ifffd1fplusmn~~~~m~ 1Efftm fDfH~~s 1~1Hk2~ ~filG~~IlffI~plusmn~fDJ~Jsectt1~L fOJ~ttW~jGI ~~mI~~~7~k~~middotj r_reg1~m~bullbull middotMm~~~ tiL W~~fDjfd1fplusmn~=ampFa iTIi~~ttlZSIL=amp~~n ~rJ no j 41shy

~75R1tl~~~mI1F ~~1E~9C~tm~T e1E~tampPJJ~J[ ~mT~~~ff$~JmOO~r~~~~~m~~~j~plusmn~~~~ 11m~Wmiddotft~ r~~~ j fBtjf~~~JJil~WI~~m-~~ lZSI0

m ~~~~ r~1~~ ~~ttflJEl TIfH~H1yenUfflf4~~~~ Jlj~ ~~faAt~~ H1yenU~IDlm~~lIWmn H1yenUfjllT7f3~ 51WX~ ffjj 1C~ll~~IF~g~n Hyen~~Hamp~~J[~ffft~yenR~~~~5R~fDyenR i6uJltZP~~~ -1DliIi H1yen~l(f~lIU~amJ]ijgm m~ m g~ a~~~yenRilampttMlL ga~~~lf~~~Biiiplusmn1fplusmn~1ik$~~~1 $ ~ttTI[M j 430

~~~ff$ r~~~ j ~plusmn~Pg~~WJZP~Jl 0 ~~~~JZPf]lllfH~

kfJ1t fjWJ1R1If$H~1l~tt11L~~ MzPJ~~~mff~~~ilampm ~ ampW~ r~sectPJW j Jlt9i- 1i1RxB~xm~ r000f1j pJT~~~1amp~0

fiE ~~~ffjjW1Rsect~fDtplusmnlItamp~sectj EE tt1mzfsect~~ampifiU~lr~ ~Y~m

40 Aft 13 1999~7F11 El m21iEi 41 i6J-t 42 ~ bullbullbullJlt~Ubull IfIIbullbull J 384 bull

43 rilfll~m J (iitplusmn~) bull lJtiiIll6 1999 ~m 5 M J 9middot

17 ~rpj1( r Wrplusmn~plusmnJif)]Hamp~WJ rpBgj1(ifEl jfjl~JlU~BgRm

flfli$i-mJsectJ13ttlhw 0

-=- fflfb iti111 -tLtLJ1f+=Ji cpftJ7mWr=5R1yenJ r~~iamprIF~~J

reWiamp$I~~mcp~MiampIyenJ~o~cp~lyenJr+liJ

cp r1tlt$mm ~~ffd~plusmn~$m~~J ~PfEVilm-~rsect~7Jsm Iq]

Wyen~UACP~IyenJ rtLliJ ~tIUfO=O-01fIyenJjIlsectfj cp~~m~~~0

J1fCP~ r+-JOO=cP~~ J fDtL=1fr~fJ2JSgi~1yenH~lJl~J5famp ~=-IyenJ lisfampmw 0

cp~m1tJtremtWiamp$IFFmMiampryenJ~6n~ miJf~1rIMMmt cP~1sectj~pg9fjE~IyenJB-fJT ttW~-arlJmiffmmT~U~~li

sect~m7~m~~~mnlyenJ~~o~mcp~~=~ryenJ~~~

IT1l~4-5R1sectj~IyenJ-1~~~~DiUfiamp~f~~~AryenJ5cfJfIF IT1l ~~~f~tI1 r1tlt$m~ gt~IJiA~f1l~~IyenJ~~~T t(~]I$fO $$m~~~~~~~fOA~~~~$~~~~m~~$~~~

~~$~~~~~~~I~~1tlt$~fi~~m~~plusmn~~plusmnIyenJ~~ 1t $$1t f~~~ijjU~fO$$=1l2Sl~~~AIyenJG~fffiG~ =1l2Sl~~~Af1 $fmt~nlyenJc~~fffiG~ 0 J 44

~gZm7~~~flfJf~~CP~~~~~A~~~tI1miamp~

ramptWIyenJjflt rI1l~=1f~=1~[lijJtJ$m1~tfArsect mcp~IyenJ~~~iampm ~ JL~IyenJj[ft~jiJUW 0 cP~-m--m-lyenJSfnaiHfijU~ryenJ-1pg~l2Sl ~1~1FlElitf~ flJIr~~ fugt~r~1Fiamp~fflJIAIyenJ~mIF 0 mr~nlyenJlm-art1E=1~

flfJfAIyenJ~m~~l2Slmcp~fOtreg~~plusmn~~~-~fu~z-~m~

~r~~IyenJ~$ JllEgi~ronlyenJ~~15~~Amfamp JL~U~~JtIyenJ~ ftfOtJmmA ffiamp~~~=1fj~IyenJtk~ 0

~l c~~rfflWfampryenJJifftffdwr~Jm BfJEf~CP~Jaj~~fpf~~Ji~~~ ~7JAfDyenAiamp7J~JFtI1[IijJJif tt1EJJ1t~IyenJ~~ 0 ffiJ1tlt$m~WH~~J

mt~~~7JAfO~Jtiamp7J~ryenJ~ ~P1fpoundfJ]IyenJplusmn~1tlt~iamp ~yenU0

ret1tltiamp3Z1tlt~$1$ ~~yenUIyenJplusmn~~$$ 1fpoundcp~~kMIyenJ~ ~6~ 1yenJiampfO$$zra fyen~~T~UlyenJlpoundlm

m-IyenJiamp~~~~lyenJftm~~~IyenJ~J-ar~~0rffl

44 _U~i r~YflI1fJ ~rutirt~~YflI1fJ~~ sJtlUI~ 19971f-~24Wl J9 r

0

0

r

18

IyenJ ttr5JP)J~ r ~~ J IyenJ ffij7f$jrjij~3~(Ji~~lyenJmf1t ~fJ~J~Efruj~ 11Jl~~$tE~mfDfjJyenf1UtE8JjJrnrj 811~amp~w000 mirOJHwr01P8J

- lyenJiIamprftE~Ef3JjiJjIJtt8JmJEfJi~ fjJ1tEfj-m8J~mmj1j $f$jrjijPJmjumt f~g~N~Jljj1Jt4JJ1tE 1sectjiJ mflJ~~~W~Nf SA PJ1gfjflj~l1Jl1fDjfdwrlmit1DPJ1[~~~

= 8JiIamp~t~~W~WfDJlMclmW1ifi i1lcRiiffl~ pg ffi]$f$jIJijPJ~if1IJj]1yenlmW1ifi1yenJ 1fiiJ~amp~W1ifif1U~ ~~ jttff~lyenJiiffl[

~rzg lyenJiIamp~~1[~8Jpoundlm[ l8J~iIamp~tt11m~~~8J ~1tffi]ml1if~~ 1sectjfjmf~MttiQ~)tl1if8Jt~~Fffl ffiJ$l$jrj~1[~~1yenJ ttltE1[ $l$-~1E~~~~pg1yen~f~ PJl~~$l$~~8Jjfdwrl1Jl1 8JttltE 0 45

jtJz ~$m~ij~7~iii~Ji~~~~8J1tyen5~1tr~M rp~ltB~isectij0

amp~F~IyenJ-llI~~tmfjflyenJ1JJf$ 0 rp~ r rpC~=Jz~wr J tW1iIamp~11Jl

~~~JJ~Ji~~~~frlJIJIyenJ~ ~- f1fU~i1i1JJfiE~ f~$1[fiaJrpflmIW fflJffl~mm

~C~ T~~~~R~i1i1JJfiE~~f3Hf1iiJfllf~tf m- f1Eg~~~Wrp~ (sectt2i~W~) llIJjU~Ht

~IyenJ ft~affiiJ~~ Tyenrj-F~~lrfDjtftiE~$~~lr~m~Ef3 llIASZi18JgflJtffl

m-=T~Jfmi~ ~rzg T1E0~mlJJrpli~~3JZ~gfl1[1Ji~~~ fli~-r~~

lrfDjtftiE~$~~lrWM~lyenJlliffl tLfte~lrffl0~1JJffJIIyenJEsectffl Ef3ll1Afreffl

~li fffl0~~Iampgfj~J8JJt~~~wr~~f~ tLfffl0~w w~m8J~~mlJJo46

~~isectregmtE~g1sect~W 1~~regwW~i~HB~IyenJiIamp~~ffi]~ 9m7sectM8J~lHFffl 0

1amp1amp ~$m~~~~~m~Jt-$l$ll 0

rpjtIIampaj(1fiOO1Jj(iIamp~ flHtEIWryenpg~8J~~m~t tL1JD1~7

45 ~xlft r ~$ramW~jiff[JQ91lfll9ilJil--yen~JmJzprr~JjIHI~Y11$dJll1Il9~iltJ iIU~ 1998 ~rfj 14 M ]i 26-27middot

46 flJ1fP~ rlti(jt~9filJi~llflIl9tI3~J iiltiamp 1993 ~rfj 20 M N 2middot

19 MaCP~ rffd1ft~_H)J1famp~~J CPreg~iEJeuro=-lr~t~~reg1RfGl

~~ftlyenJf~ m7 fJm-~~1Ii1WIyenJJIWl5fU~fJ middot ~~~lzJWTIyenJ$~C~m0

JJa bull ~OJJtt~~gampij fJ~1yenJ1i-3jf91i 0

EJ ~~1t HHHf

aM~~ti~aIyenJ~sect~m~~m~-m~~IyenJ~~ ~~~fu~k~~~m~IyenJ~~~ti~~~mfirreg~ ~J IyenJ~~ ~~jIJ~ft mJ~itmtJj rXt~Iil~ flWHW tt~0

~f1 fmJllfJtj ~pfifFm J IyenJ~~ 47 ~frgiampm LMmJZfSmtJjlyenJ~0

~ tim-~~lyenJti~a ~7tElaIyenJ~~t~~fFffl 0 ~~JZfSmtJj~~~~IyenJ~~ aamp~~yenu~11i~IyenJ~ ~~~tf0

~1jUP)~E5~~IyenJ~3( r~FGt~J mf9J ~Bjlft~ r~~~iJRregg1m~ fH~~IyenJfllr~~~ts pfi~~~L~fHlfHJ1~~1yenJ ~~ftl~1il ~IyenJ-~~~IyenJfll~Iil~f~~~~~~~~regam~$~ffi ~~~ji(~~~pfi5flJffl ~IilL~Ctl7~~~m1J1yenJ U ru~~n ~~ ifE~7~IyenJIJU~ 1JDi7~~~lyenJmR0 J JBjJiiitfQ~ r~~~~Ji

~AfJ~~~m~ru tlfF fJ~~JI9(1iE~~m1il~~m ~ ft1t3(a~-JEflitIjfL~jfiUm-~~ 0 J 48

~~~IyenJIil~iig j(E5~~pfi3EIyenJ~~~ ~m~m-f1gti~~~~lyenJgB ~fm ~~yenmft~IyenJy~rmfreg~ampIig 0 ft5IItt ~~~JEBIyenJ~ 3(~~~ ~1jUmiJtim-~~~~lyenJlEiiiwp~ f9IJ~[1 ~~~~rIl51mW0

t~tJj rXt~~PJtltW~~ftlyenJm~rum1jU~1EIiJ~~tltW$~1yenJ U yen~n ftJIrPJLFsIyenJFJE3gtJj ~maM~~~y~FJIyenJ1AA~ii ~L~~bullbullbullIyenJFJregffi~~IyenJbullbull ~~~~my~BM IyenJ J 49 PJT~1l r ~~ft J m~ ft~R~~~~~IyenJMIli~ru~MIyenJ~-0

tl ffi ryen~J ftJrPJ~Ut~~~IirftXt~ftllfE-m5$1yenJtili1ll gliJ~~ tltW~ffkFjIyenJ~lz 0

11H~~~tim-~~~~IyenJ~m ~fr~JJlIT$~m~~aM~3(IfF mtJjlyenJ-~m~poundLm~~wlyenJ~~g~oIT$~~mm-~M

) ~~Rffa~~~~~~~L~IyenJ~~~-mafflyenJ~~~

47 31 E31l1is~ r tft~tEtttJfl[yeni~lli ~lltIt~~tAl~IHJif~ImRi~ J 1fIIIWPIa 1998 Sf 10

Fll ~ 15 0

48 ~fljsect iUIRtlIIUplusmnBWll ~ 331-332middot ~ 49 1lIisect~ r tft~tpoundttwm~~UlJ ~ 10-11 0

0

-~----------------------~p----

20

~= ~~mkmfJo5i~~ttW~P~J~rp~~j[WitfFlDlf F~9~ IfF~1LpoundE~li ~-= ~-ampc5t~m~~~~~IDl1 TEllitifsect1im ~ff~ ZP~ifsectt~ middot 1iflJitfF 0 50 tEJ~-=JjIfFm~lirp ~Jmft~1Dl ffisect~~~ lt~j[WiampJfimfJ059HNm-=ttW~lDlf ~1J~rp~~1J w~~r~~itx~~J~~~~o

P)~~47(~tJ middot iQ~~Jmft~IDl1 amp~~5(lDlrp~~plusmn~9~~rj ~o~~rp~K~tJ~W~~~Jm-~r~~tt~~~~IDl1J 0

rp~~sect~fiJampMjtf3~tlih=U9~ r~JisCmJ a~~~HN~li-fl iQfi~ 7~~fiJ~~iIi~ rp~~~59iIDijJfiJ~~ftm1f~1~9U~Mi~ 0

~- 1f~yenj(~~tE2titFrp59iftB~$~iJi P)BZP1tJrp~tE2 lH~~Fffl ffijrp~~U~~lJffl~B~)sect~nrfjg

~= 1yent~~~1Jo59ift r El~J r~~J rrp~t~~tJ J ~2 fj f~ffijfJDUrp~fEfj r ~1C- J ~~

- 1yentflUtftg~ffl ~OiffJDfllifrtEfiJrp~m1R~)sect~lM1J~1J~ ~ 0 19U$lO bull tEfyenj~Ib~~J ~~~2M1yentm7HJI5lfiJrp~~~IJ~iIi~~~ ~59ilipound1L~ ~~)sectJfJDfl~ 510

~~fiJ~~iIi~ffJnrt)it~J~~m~ttsect fJ ff~~~~fi1Jamp51 ~~it~Wftrp~lliiTi~~~Jr middot ~)Ed(~m r rp~~~~ifB J tE~~~f7J ~UJJjtk 0 amp~ middot tEiiilWfj5EfiJ~mkrp~~H~~~ rp~59i~f1f[t] litff~ rampftaiflplusmnfiml~ffiUm J ffijUiampJfim~mkfiJ~=ttW~0

lDlf ~1J~~rp~~1Lampa1t-~j~WtJ jtrp middot ~mkfiJffX1IWT~1Dl0

1fi~~~o

~~me~rpmlDl1B~-nn-~~~~~ftn~rj[W~

J ~mkyenU-nn[g~1R5E~mk rlliijq]tt-ttc~9t~ti~flDlfJ 0

-nn~[gJ1 ~m~ (Boris Eltsin) ~1CIDJIb~~tJjt~ ~1JJ~~1R Ii~mk rzp~ffiff~ lliijq]tt-ttc~~~ttMF~IDl1J ~ifBil~~0

iiJj~ rpm~1J~p1m~~ 47(~J7+iJ~1Dl1 fi~tEmpoundJftW~~ Wjo

fJE~J7+iJ~lDlf~mk~[t]1Nsectt lliiftlsect1J~~~~~~rj~ fi-Ii ~~~~o~~mft~m1lWTB~7~~tE~~~1f~~~m~tJ

50 AE3 (1ii9-IlEi) bull 1998 ~ 12 F119 a ~ 2 1lEimiddot 51 fI1I~ii 1fI111111~~J2fHIf (K~ A~lliJEiiiiplusmn 19961f 5 F1) bull 11159--160 bull

-~----------------------~p----

20

~= ~~mkmfJo5i~~ttW~P~J~rp~~j[WitfFlDlf F~9~ IfF~1LpoundE~li ~-= ~-ampc5t~m~~~~~IDl1 TEllitifsect1im ~ff~ ZP~ifsectt~ middot 1iflJitfF 0 50 tEJ~-=JjIfFm~lirp ~Jmft~1Dl ffisect~~~ lt~j[WiampJfimfJ059HNm-=ttW~lDlf ~1J~rp~~1J w~~r~~itx~~J~~~~o

P)~~47(~tJ middot iQ~~Jmft~IDl1 amp~~5(lDlrp~~plusmn~9~~rj ~o~~rp~K~tJ~W~~~Jm-~r~~tt~~~~IDl1J 0

rp~~sect~fiJampMjtf3~tlih=U9~ r~JisCmJ a~~~HN~li-fl iQfi~ 7~~fiJ~~iIi~ rp~~~59iIDijJfiJ~~ftm1f~1~9U~Mi~ 0

~- 1f~yenj(~~tE2titFrp59iftB~$~iJi P)BZP1tJrp~tE2 lH~~Fffl ffijrp~~U~~lJffl~B~)sect~nrfjg

~= 1yent~~~1Jo59ift r El~J r~~J rrp~t~~tJ J ~2 fj f~ffijfJDUrp~fEfj r ~1C- J ~~

- 1yentflUtftg~ffl ~OiffJDfllifrtEfiJrp~m1R~)sect~lM1J~1J~ ~ 0 19U$lO bull tEfyenj~Ib~~J ~~~2M1yentm7HJI5lfiJrp~~~IJ~iIi~~~ ~59ilipound1L~ ~~)sectJfJDfl~ 510

~~fiJ~~iIi~ffJnrt)it~J~~m~ttsect fJ ff~~~~fi1Jamp51 ~~it~Wftrp~lliiTi~~~Jr middot ~)Ed(~m r rp~~~~ifB J tE~~~f7J ~UJJjtk 0 amp~ middot tEiiilWfj5EfiJ~mkrp~~H~~~ rp~59i~f1f[t] litff~ rampftaiflplusmnfiml~ffiUm J ffijUiampJfim~mkfiJ~=ttW~0

lDlf ~1J~~rp~~1Lampa1t-~j~WtJ jtrp middot ~mkfiJffX1IWT~1Dl0

1fi~~~o

~~me~rpmlDl1B~-nn-~~~~~ftn~rj[W~

J ~mkyenU-nn[g~1R5E~mk rlliijq]tt-ttc~9t~ti~flDlfJ 0

-nn~[gJ1 ~m~ (Boris Eltsin) ~1CIDJIb~~tJjt~ ~1JJ~~1R Ii~mk rzp~ffiff~ lliijq]tt-ttc~~~ttMF~IDl1J ~ifBil~~0

iiJj~ rpm~1J~p1m~~ 47(~J7+iJ~1Dl1 fi~tEmpoundJftW~~ Wjo

fJE~J7+iJ~lDlf~mk~[t]1Nsectt lliiftlsect1J~~~~~~rj~ fi-Ii ~~~~o~~mft~m1lWTB~7~~tE~~~1f~~~m~tJ

50 AE3 (1ii9-IlEi) bull 1998 ~ 12 F119 a ~ 2 1lEimiddot 51 fI1I~ii 1fI111111~~J2fHIf (K~ A~lliJEiiiiplusmn 19961f 5 F1) bull 11159--160 bull

21 IDfatp~ r ifd~tftm~Illli~ J tp1yenJ~fElg-~Jf)ltl~IyenJJ3VEl

e1~DiW ffUfiHtFf1ftflg1amp1~isect1iffplusmn~EJsectIyenJ~~1iWJ Mlil~~~t0

~1yenJ_~~w~m~~~~IyenJisect1i~~~plusmnMmlyenJ~~o~~m wr ~t~A~~~ftisect1i~~f~~mwrlyenJ~~ ~llt ijg~~tJD5gHfX~ 1yenJ~~~w~~~~~~~isect1i~~mwrlyenJ~m~-W~~sm~ lKWJ~~ - rMh~lyenJ~mwr~~ r 1fm J (The Capital) ~~~ r

~~Alfm1lX~Q]JJ~3 Cplusmnff PJEdfXmwrt~flW~~IyenJ~~rmfH~ ~~t~~1~~ill~tl 0 J 52

fBJtitfu W~gY6~31U3~t1ilyenJmlG~m~1amp 8Q]J~frjmffXmwr fF ~~m~~ampJtM~IyenJ-Mhit 53 ~~rmfIyenJ5SHt ~]jU~frf1=1yenJ0

Miii 1itJff~~UjfJ ttLltisect1iIyenJ~~t~~ ~~~ffXlyenJ8Mffi] ~f~~~ijUIyenJQ]ffg 0

~amp~~~~IyenJ$nBm~~IyenJ-~m~sect~oll$~~mshy

fiIDJFo El 1yenJ~~~5C1f ~1ilyenJrmflI~rtfm~~Wfrf1=W3i~~~~ fI$n 0 ~lfmEl~~~~ r3ifSifiUJ 1yenJ~~rmf B~~~ 2~JtIJ~~lyenJm~3Zfplusmn ~It~BrmfIyenJ-~~rI~ilB~~B3ifSifiUIyenJ _ f~~~U~1EfflJiitfEWlyenJflj~ 0

~1ftm=ttJit~~ tiUtsectJJE1p~~mfEampFJ~IyenJplusmn~1ampVi hit 0 ~~81amp ~tl~~~~~lyenJjll~Hampm~~ m~DrtjJmiddotf]PI tamp~~8fr~lyenJmff~f03Ztf 0 ~~~tsect-B ~tl~~~~~1Tamp~FJ~ H~ ~~Q]ffM1iW~amp~IyenJ~mVi 0

=6Ii ~ iilll

ffm ~~~plusmnhtll$~1f1E-~~If1=~j~ ~~~~ ~~~mJ7-~83~lf4fipJf~~~ r~~~MCmt+1f - fE7U$~U xj~E3~x J IyenJ 0 ~~ifn1iffiJ ~1ft~~83~ffi]~IyenJ~~ f1=7fsect W~~ilyenJnfJTfDmill 0 ~~~JJil$OO~S~ ~Jjtl~ ~]jlj~~~m SIyenJ~~ftf 1itm~~W~fsectWttmlyenJn 0

)(1iJf~EiiHm7f ~J-~~JjU~~IiIyenJ~$fDf1=$ middot ~~~J~ ttHJJi~Q]~ 0 ~~ ~~zra~1Eff~~~JIyenJWf~fBJli tt~~m

52 Quoted in Eugene Bazhanov Russian Policy Toward China in Peter Shearman ed Russian Foreign

Policy Since 1990 (Boulder Westview Press 1995) p 166

53 Ibid p 168ishy

22 fU

~1iWjEPJpoundjji~~fFm~iEj(lyenJ~~ rmax$IyenJ~mW~+ ~jfd1tplusmn~jf5u1fIyenJ~mrm~ ~= aj($IyenJll~rnJJW ltIyenJfamp ~11ff~mjEyeniltsectrnJ mW~~aj($~mzMtmtflt1JIyenJ~$11 ~= ltftax$~l~CPOO~lyenJfj~~~fpoundL m~~~~1tIyenJMItrQ~~ 0

m~tmLlt cpamp1f~max$rmtplusmnrfJt5tFmIllfJTIyenJOO~ 0 tplusmn~IyenJJ)jUzs]

jEit1faj($Im1ampilampm r ~~~tglfi J 1yenJl~JZP mcplyenJaj($~fj~lIY r fjXE~lltl-11] J IyenJ~ tcpgfI5ilampmlyenJ~XEfOilamp~lyenJfjXE 0 ftfiXEIyenJ ~f CPPJ~JU~~m~)fG 1tXEY~51~plusmn~ll~~CPIyenJ~~~ ~ft~OO~~L-~~~~$Lm~~IyenJ~~gfI5lt~~81yenJ~

lt~~ mgtjEcpHNcplyenJ~lt5G~IfF ~~OO~llfi cplyenJilampyfJfr0

m1ft~11i1mlyenJtfu1i m1ft~MIyenJ-OO 0

1M~lt~81yenJ~1t ~Y)(PJTiffiHamplyenJcp~g~JllWfljmlDt~ ~m~~~m~lyenJjE~ll~ax$~~fO~XE=~~IyenJ~ID~~ocp

5Si~~1f~tn~M~~ltIyenJ~Ji2i f81fEcptl1flyenJmillg~UtfI ~g ~MUtMt~Ji2itfufll m~lffffl-~tnaj($ ~~fOfjXEIyenJmJI11ml~ 0

1gt

22 fU

~1iWjEPJpoundjji~~fFm~iEj(lyenJ~~ rmax$IyenJ~mW~+ ~jfd1tplusmn~jf5u1fIyenJ~mrm~ ~= aj($IyenJll~rnJJW ltIyenJfamp ~11ff~mjEyeniltsectrnJ mW~~aj($~mzMtmtflt1JIyenJ~$11 ~= ltftax$~l~CPOO~lyenJfj~~~fpoundL m~~~~1tIyenJMItrQ~~ 0

m~tmLlt cpamp1f~max$rmtplusmnrfJt5tFmIllfJTIyenJOO~ 0 tplusmn~IyenJJ)jUzs]

jEit1faj($Im1ampilampm r ~~~tglfi J 1yenJl~JZP mcplyenJaj($~fj~lIY r fjXE~lltl-11] J IyenJ~ tcpgfI5ilampmlyenJ~XEfOilamp~lyenJfjXE 0 ftfiXEIyenJ ~f CPPJ~JU~~m~)fG 1tXEY~51~plusmn~ll~~CPIyenJ~~~ ~ft~OO~~L-~~~~$Lm~~IyenJ~~gfI5lt~~81yenJ~

lt~~ mgtjEcpHNcplyenJ~lt5G~IfF ~~OO~llfi cplyenJilampyfJfr0

m1ft~11i1mlyenJtfu1i m1ft~MIyenJ-OO 0

1M~lt~81yenJ~1t ~Y)(PJTiffiHamplyenJcp~g~JllWfljmlDt~ ~m~~~m~lyenJjE~ll~ax$~~fO~XE=~~IyenJ~ID~~ocp

5Si~~1f~tn~M~~ltIyenJ~Ji2i f81fEcptl1flyenJmillg~UtfI ~g ~MUtMt~Ji2itfufll m~lffffl-~tnaj($ ~~fOfjXEIyenJmJI11ml~ 0

1gt