islam men hadith by rashid shaz

129

Upload: rashid-shaz

Post on 06-Mar-2016

234 views

Category:

Documents


4 download

DESCRIPTION

Rashid Shaz on Hadith, Islamic Reform, Muslim Mind

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz
Page 2: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�������

Page 3: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

���

Page 4: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

ISBN 978-93-81461-03-7

��������

��

� � �

(Rs.110/-) � �� �

��

������

Milli Times Building, Abul Fazl Enclave,Jamia Nagar, New Delhi-25

Tel:. +91-11-26945499, 26946246Fax: +91-11-26945499

Email:[email protected]

Page 5: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz
Page 6: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�����

��� � �����

� ������������� ���������

��� � ���� discourage ��

��

Page 7: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

� �� ��

� ����� �� ��

� � �� � �

Page 8: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�� �

� tradition �

���

Page 9: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

������

������

�����

����

Page 10: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�������

����

����

����

�� ������ �����

�������� �

��

��

Page 11: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�����

�����

��

���������

�������

�������

���

������������ �

Page 12: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

����

� re-create

- ��

Page 13: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

����

�����

�������

Page 14: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��� �

��

������

� ������

��

����

��

����

Page 15: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�����

���

��

��

������

marginalize periphery operate

morgue ���

trash can �� �

��� � �

paradox ���

�������

��� � thinline �

��

Page 16: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

� � defeat �����

����

���� temptation

�������

� ��

����� �

human human perception revelatory perception Human Recording perception

���� ��

��������

��

Page 17: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

������

����������

���

������

�����

� �����

���

����������� ���

Page 18: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

� ��

��

� � �

���� ��

�� precedent

����

������

perception

sparks of authentic fossilized information history

� �

Page 19: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

���

� vision �

���

re-create �

������������

re-create �-

�����

� � �

Page 20: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

� � �

Archetypal History

��

��

����

���

���������� ����

�������

���

fossilized

- �� �

��

�����

Page 21: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

� spatial

�����

����

��

�����

��� �

�� �

����� ��

��

��������

Page 22: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��

����

����� ���

�����

���� �

Page 23: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

����

��

���

��

� �����

���

�����

discourage �

�����

���

���

�� ���

� ���

Page 24: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��������

� ����

� �� ���

���

���������

���

� � ����

����������

������

Page 25: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

������

� ��

�� � �

�� �

����

���������

������������

� �

Page 26: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��� ��

�����

�� ���� �

����

�� balance

� transmission �

Page 27: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��

�� ��

�� �����

����

� �

���

���

� imaginative recreation ��

� (Lax) ����

���

��

��

Page 28: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

���

�� �

���

�����

��� ��

����

� ���

������������

��

��������

Page 29: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�������

��

balance ����� �

���������

worldview �������������

����� �

��� �

��

���

Page 30: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�����

��

� � �� � �

�� �� �

� tradition

����

����

��

������

���

Page 31: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

������

� ��

� �

� ���

���������

���

���

����

Page 32: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

����������

��������������

�����

� � ��

�����

����

��

Page 33: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��

��

�� � �

��

� �� �

�� ����

��

� �������������

Page 34: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

���

���

�� �

���

��

�� � ��

�����

�� �����

�����

Page 35: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�������

������

���

�����

������

�� ��

���

��

� �

��

Page 36: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�������

����

����

����

� ��

��� � � ���

� �

����

� �� ������

�� � � �

Chief Executive ��

��� �

Page 37: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

� � �

����������

����

� � ������

��

��������

��

� � epistemology �

- � ��

� �� � �

� �

����

Page 38: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��� � �

� ��

����

��

� ��

���

��

� ��

Page 39: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

� �� �

� �

��

��

����

� ������

���

��

��� �

��

Authenticated ��

Page 40: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

� History

� ��

��

���������

� ��

� �

� � ���

����� ��

�������

���

Page 41: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

� ���

���

� ��� ��

����

���

�� ���

��

�� �

�������

� �

Page 42: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

���

�� ���� �

��� �

���

��

�� � ���

� ����

��� �

� �

� ����

���

���

Page 43: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

���� �����

��

��� �

������

��

� �

�����

� � conclusive �

��

��

Page 44: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�����

��

���

������ �

�� � �

�������

��

����conclusive

�� ��

Page 45: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

������

��

� � �����

� � �

���

�� � ��

� � ��

����

�������

� �

� ���

Page 46: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

������

������

��

���

���

������

� � ����

marginalize �

������

��

� �� �

Page 47: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

� ��

�����������

�����

����

������

����

� (Authenticated History)

Imaginative History

Page 48: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

���

� trash can �����

������

��������

���

���

��

� �

�� �

� � � � �

Page 49: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�� ������

� ��� (specialized ulema)

��

� � � �

(religious � �

authority)

� ���

��

�� �

��� �

���

Page 50: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

����

�� �

��

���

���

���

� ���

�� � �� � � �� �

Page 51: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��

�� �

�� �

���

����

��� �����

� ��

����� ���

��

��

Page 52: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

����

��

��

����

�� �

���

� �

�����

��

Page 53: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

����� worldview

����

�������� worldview �

��������

� �����

� � � � � �� �

����

����

�������

��������������������

Page 54: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�������������

��

���� ��

�� ��

����

�����

�� ���

����

�������� ���������

Page 55: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�������

���������������

������������

����

�� ��������

���

��

Page 56: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��

������

���

����

�����

�����

�����������

���������

�����

���������

Page 57: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��

��

������������

���

�� �

�������

�� �����

casual ��� ��

��

������

Page 58: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

����

���

��

������

��������

process ����

���

����� balance

���

Page 59: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��

���������

�� �

��� �over �

�� simplification

��� � ��

������� �

�����

��

��

Page 60: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

����

� �

��� ��

��

��

� ���

����

���

���

��

��

Page 61: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

� legitimate ��

���

��

��

������

� � shock

����� version � �

���

���

���

��

������

Page 62: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��� ��� ������ � ��

� �

���

���������������

� ���� )

� versions

Page 63: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

� (intellectual diaspora)

��

� strategy legitimate �

����

����

���

������

��

����

���

��

��

Page 64: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

���

� ���

���

������

��

��

���������

��

Page 65: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��������

��

����

���

��

���

��

��

���������

Page 66: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�������

���

����

�����

���

��

��

���

����

��

Page 67: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�����

��

��

����� �����

�� � � ���

�� �

���

� �

�� � ��

Page 68: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�� ���������

�����

��

���

��

����

���

���

��

Page 69: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��

������

� � �

� � �

���

��

�� �

Page 70: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�������������

� � �

��

� �

��

� (changing perceptions) �����

�����

���

����

��

� � �

Page 71: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

���������

� �

(canonization)

����

���

Page 72: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

����

��

���

�����

� ���

��

��

����

���

� ���

� ��

Page 73: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

����

��

���� � � �

�� � �

�� canonization

��

�� � �

� ���

�������

�� �

�����

Page 74: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��

���

� ���

����

��

��

����

��

��������

�� � � � �

Page 75: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

���������

� �������� ���

�����

��

� ����

�� limitations ��

� ����

Page 76: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

����

� ��

�� �� � discourage ��

�� �� �

�� �

� � � � unfold

� � �

� � � �

� ��

� ��

��

Page 77: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

represent ��

����

�� �

� � ��

� theory � over simplify

��

����

�� theory ����

���

� �

� — �

— �

� �������

Page 78: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

����

����� (place)

���������

���

�����

��������� ����

��

� ������ ���

reference book

Page 79: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�� reference book �

�� �

�� �

�� ambitious project

� �

�� encyclopedic ��

��

�������

Page 80: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

����

��

� appreciate �

�����������

� �

���

Page 81: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

������

���

�����

���

��

��

���

� ��

�� ��

� ��

Page 82: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��

����� �

����

��������

�����

��

��

���������

Page 83: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

���

�� (implication) ����

� �������

���

� ����

� ��

� ��

��� �

� myth ���

������ myth

��

Page 84: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�����

���

�� �

���

� �

���

�� �

� �

��

��

Page 85: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�����

�� (reference book)

�������

���

� (ejection) �

� (cynicism) �

� � �

��� �

Page 86: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��balanced ��

���

��

cult-making �

��� polimics

��

�� �

���

��

���

misleading ����

Page 87: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

� �

��

� �

���

�� ��

����

����������

��

� ��������

��������

���� �

Page 88: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�����

������������

circumstantial evidence ���� ��

���������

� � �

�� � �

����

��

�����

Page 89: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�� rituals ���� precision

�����

�� � �

extra � ��� scriptural

�� �

���� independent

� ��

extra-scriptural

����

��� ���

������ �

������

Page 90: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�� �����������

�������

�� ��������������

��������

Page 91: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

The embellishment of the law by the Pharisees and Sadducees (rabbis of Jesus' day) were condemned by Jesus in Matthew 15:6,

Luke 11:46,52 and in other similar verses.

"You Shall not add to the word which I am Commanding you, nor

take away from it, that you may keep the commandments of the Lord

your God which I command you". [Deuteronomy 4:2]

��

���

Page 92: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

� � ����

����

��������

������ ��

Page 93: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

� � � �

�� ��

����� ������

�� �

� ��

��

� �

����� �

���

��

Page 94: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��� � �������

��

���� � ���������

Page 95: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

���

� ���

�����

�����

��

Page 96: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

���

� ��

���

�� �

���

��

�� �

��

Page 97: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��

� �� � � �

��� ����

��

�� �

���� � �

��� �

�����

��� �

� ��� ��

� �

� �

Page 98: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

���

��

����

���������

����������

��� ���

���� �

Page 99: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

� �

���

���� � independent

����

����

��

��

���

ExtraQuranic ����

��������

Page 100: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

���������

����

���������������

���

��

����

��

Page 101: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��

����� ���������� �� ���

� �

�� ���

��

��

�����

Page 102: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

������

�����

��political legitimacy ���

�� �

� ��

���

� status quo

���

Page 103: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

� �

� ����

��

� � �� ���

���

��

Page 104: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��

�� ���������

� �� �

Page 105: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�� ��

������ ��

�����

��� ���

��

����

�����������������

���

�������� irrelevant

����� ���

����� comprehensive

Page 106: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��

����� situation report

�������

�������

�����

�������

�� � � ��

�����

��

����

����

� �

Page 107: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

������ �

����

���

����������

� inconclusive ���

��������

����

inconclusive ��

Page 108: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�� ���

�� ��

������ ��

��

���

����

�����

��

� ��

�� �

Page 109: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

���

���

��

���� �

Page 110: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��

��

� initiative �

������

����� ������

� � ����

������

��� ������ ���

�����

Page 111: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��� � �� �

��

������

�����

����

���� ������

��

��� �

Page 112: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�� �� ��� ��

� ��

�� ��

���

��

� canonization � ���

Page 113: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

���������� �

��� ���

����

����

����

Page 114: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

����

��

����

��

����

������

����

�����������

��

Page 115: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��

������

���

��

������

�� ��� �

���

���

���

��

Page 116: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

����������

���

����

���

�� ��

��

����������

�� ���

���� �

Page 117: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

� �

��

�� �

�������

canonization ���� �

��

���� �

��

Page 118: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

���

����

��

���

�������

�����

��

Page 119: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

���

�����

�� �

������

� ��

�����

��

�����

����

���

����

����

Page 120: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

����

������

��

�����

��������

��

�����

Page 121: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��

��

infallible � �

��

��

�����������

�����

Page 122: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

���

����������

���������� �

�� ���� �

���� �

��� ��� ���� �

��

�����

Page 123: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

������ ���� ���

(polemics) �������

�� ���

��

������

� Juynvoll Goldziher, Schacht

�� ���

�����

overlap ��������

Schacht, skept icism ������ Goldziher

���

Page 124: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

��������

��� � Schacht sweeping statement

�����������

����

������

�������

������

Justify ��

��

������

I.Goldziher, Muslim Studies, ed. S.M. Stern, trans. C.R. Barber &

S.M. Stern, 2vol. (London: Allen & Unwin, 1967-71), II, 17-251,

Joseph Schacht, The Origins of Mohammedan Jurisprudence (Oxford:

Clarendon Press 1950), G.H.A. Juynboll, Muslim Tradition: Studies in

Chronology, Provenance & Authorshinp of Early Hadith

Page 125: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

(Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1983), M.M. Azmi, On

Schacht's Origins of Mohammadan Jurisprudence New York, Jhon

Wiley, 1985), Fazlur Rahman, Islam, chapter 3

�����

������

��

�������� � ��

�������

��

�������

��

��������

Page 126: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�������

����

����

����

����������

���

���

����

��

��

�����

���

���

Page 127: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

����������

���

�� perversion

������

Page 128: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�����

����

Rs. 80/- � �����

Rs. 110/- � ����

Rs. 110/- � ��

Rs. 140/- � ���

Rs. 120/- � ��

Rs. 200/- � ��������������

Rs. 100/- � ���

Rs. 80/- � ���----------------------------------------

Rs. 700/- � � �

Rs. 500/- � ��� �

��

www.RashidShaz.com

Page 129: Islam men Hadith by Rashid Shaz

�����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������