islam men fiqh by rashid shaz

158

Upload: rashid-shaz

Post on 30-Mar-2016

224 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

DESCRIPTION

Rashid Shaz, Fiqu, Islamic Jurisprudence, Muslim Mind, Islamic Reform

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz
Page 2: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

������

Page 3: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

���

Page 4: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

ISBN 978-93-81461-04-4

��������

���

� �

� (Rs.140/-) � �

�� �

������

Milli Times Building, Abul Fazl Enclave,Jamia Nagar, New Delhi-25

Tel:. +91-11-26945499, 26946246Fax: +91-11-26945499

Email:[email protected]

Page 5: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz
Page 6: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�����

���

���

����

��

�����

���������

��

Page 7: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�� �

� � �

� � � � �

�� � �

Page 8: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

��

�� paradigm � deconstruction

���

Page 9: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�����

�������

�����

Page 10: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�������

���

����

�����

�� ������ ������

������� �

��

��

Page 11: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

����

�������

��

����������

��������������

����

����������� �

Page 12: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

������

��������

Page 13: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

� � �

� � � ���

��

�������

���

��

Page 14: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� ����

� �

����

logical essence � willing submission

(ratio � �� legis)

�����

���

������

�����

Page 15: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

����

� � � � paradigm �

�� (destruction) �

divine sparks �� phenomenon

�����

���

��

���

��

����������

� ��

�� ���

Page 16: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� (Diaspora)

����

vicious �

�� �� circle

��������

���

�� �

��������

���

Page 17: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�� �

��

�� � � �� ���

�� �

� �� ��

��� �� �

�������

���

Page 18: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�� ��

�������

� � ��

� � �

� ���

Page 19: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

����

�������

��

��

� � � �

��

� �

���

extension

Page 20: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

����� �

� � �� role-model

��������

�� �

���� legend

����

���

applied modelpossible

� only authentic

pattern ���

Page 21: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

���

��� response

�� canonization

����

�������

����

�������

�����

��� (mini-prophet) �

���

� � �

��

Page 22: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��������

�� ���

���

� �

���

�������

��

�� ��

��

Page 23: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

� ��

����

� ���

����

� revelation � reason ����

��

��

� � canonization ��

Page 24: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

�� �

���

������

� �

�������

� ��

Page 25: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

���

��

��

��

� � � � �

� �

��� �

�����

Baba Metzia � ����

Page 26: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��� � ����

��

� �� �

� � � �� �� ��

perogative �

�� ���

����

�����

��� � ���

��� � � �

��� �

Page 27: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� ���

��

� � �

� �

��

���

� ��

� � �

� ��

Page 28: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��� �

������

����

� � � � ���

� � �

� �

��� � �

���� ������

�� �

� �

Page 29: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

���

���� ������

� �

������

���

��������

����������

��

�� ��

Page 30: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

��

� �

���

��

functional revelation �

� �

���

��

����

� �

���

� �� � �

Page 31: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� � �

��

� ��

���

� hair-splitting �

Page 32: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

��

�� canonization

��

������

����

� ...

� �

Page 33: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� �

��� antidote

����

� �

��

����

���

(synthesis) �

� � �

�� ����

��

���

Page 34: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

������

�� �

� �

recognition ���������

��� operate �

��

� (functional revelation)

������

Page 35: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

���

� ��

� ���

� �

����

�����

�������

��

Page 36: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�� �� ��

�� ���

�� � ��

�����

���� �

���

� � ��

������������

Page 37: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

���

��� canonization

���

�� ����

��

��

���

����

��� �

���� ��

Page 38: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

����������� �

� �

� �

� ���

������ liaison �

��

��

��

��� � �

Page 39: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

����

�� � �� �

��� ��� � �

� ��

�� �

�� �

����

�����

� �

��������

� � �� �

� � ��

� ��

Page 40: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� �

�� overlap �

�����

�� �

� �� ���

� � � � � � inconclusive ��

�� ��

Page 41: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� ���

���

��

����

���

����

�� � � � �

paradigm � �� operate

� �� �

� ��� �

��

Page 42: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

� � �

��

���

���

���

��

���

Page 43: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��� �

����

� ��

��������

����

�����

� � ��

Page 44: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�� �

� �� �

�� � ��

� � ���

������

�� —

�����

� � �

��

��� ���

Page 45: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

trash �� can

���� canonization

��

���� ���������

��

�� �

������

����������

���

Page 46: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�������

��� �

� �� �� �

���

��

��

������

������

����

�����

��

Page 47: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

���

������

����������

� � �

� � �

� �

cross current � overlap �

(independent) ���

��

Page 48: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�������

��

� �

� ��

� ��

� ���

����

��

Page 49: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� �

mainstream thinking ��

����

� � � �

� �

�����

�� ���

���

����

Page 50: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� �

��

� �� ��

��

���

�������

�����

���� �

����� �

��

Page 51: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

������

�� ��

���

���

� � �

� ��

���

������

Page 52: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� �� ��

� �

����

� � �� operate

� � � �

� � �

� context text

����

appreciation �

Page 53: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�����������

��

��

��

����

�� ����

����

Page 54: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��������

����

� (implications) �

����

����

���������

���

Page 55: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

���� ��

��

� �� �

�������

�������������

���

�� �context �text

��

Page 56: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

����

����

��

� ����

� ��� �

��

���

��

��

��� ����

��

���

Page 57: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

(ratio legis) ���

�� � �

� permissiveness

� methodology ��

� �������

��

��

��

productive

��

Page 58: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��� confusion

��

� paradigm � �

���

�� operate ��� �

���� �

��

���

� ��

��

��

Page 59: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� � ���

���

� �

� ��

� ��

��

�� ���

��� (paradigm) ���

� (essential)

����

Page 60: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

������

�������

� � ��

��

����

��

����

� ���

�����

���

��� � �

Page 61: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�� �

��� � ��

������

���

�����

� �� X ����

� ������

� � ��

�� �

� ��

��

Page 62: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

������

��

� �

� ��

����

�����

� �����

� �

���

���

�� � ���

�����

����

Page 63: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

��� �

�� ��

��

� discourage � ��

���

�� �

� � � ��

� �

� � � �

Page 64: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

����

��� ��� � � ��

� � permissiveness

� � �

� � � � �

��� �

� �������

��

�� �����

� �

�� �

�� � �

Page 65: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��� � �

�����

��

����

���

����

��

��� �

Page 66: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

���� ��

� �

� �

��

���

�������

���

���� responsive

�����

canonization ������

��� ����

Page 67: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

� ��

� �� �

� �

�� �

� �� ���

� ��� �� �

�� � �

����� ��

����

��

��

� ��

Page 68: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

�����

���

��

��

���� �

� �

��

� �

� �

Page 69: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

����

��

�� �

��

��

� �

� ��

����

���

����

�������

����

Page 70: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

���������

�� � � �

� �

��

�������

���

� (compromise formula)

����

Page 71: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� � � way-out � �

� � �� �

����

���

���

���������

���

���

�����

����

����

� �

��

Page 72: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

������

� � � � �

� �� �

� � � ���� �

� (weltanschauung)�� �

� � ��

� ��

��

� ����

Page 73: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� ��

����

�� implications

� �� �

����

� � �� � ��

� way-out �����

�� ����� ����

��� �

��� �

�� �

Page 74: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

����

� ��

���

�� �

��

� � ���

�� �

�� �

� � �

��

Page 75: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� �

� ��

� ��

� � �� ��

� �� ����

� �

� � �

��� ��

�� ����� ���

� � ��

�����

� �

Page 76: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

� ��� �

��

�� �

� �

���

� �� ��

����

�� ��

����

���

��

���

Page 77: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

�����

������

���

���

����

� �������

(tension) ����������� ������

Page 78: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� ������

� �

������

��

� �

� � canonization

�����

���

�� �����

� ��

Page 79: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

��

���� canonization

������

����

����

���

���

�� �

�������

Page 80: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

����

�������

�� � �

� � ��

���������

��

����

�� canonization �

�����

Page 81: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� ��

��

� ������

��

� �

�����

������

�����

� paradigm

���� ��

���

Page 82: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

�����

��� ���

�����

��� ���

��

��� ��

�����

Page 83: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�������

� �

��

����

��

����

��������

Page 84: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

���

��

����

���� brain-storming

�����

����

��

share

���

���

��

������

��

���

Page 85: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

����������

paradigm deconstruction

������

���

���������

�������

��� ��

Page 86: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��������

����� �

���������

��

��

���

���

� � �

� �

����

Page 87: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��� �

��

��

���

� �

������

��

��������

worldview � �

Page 88: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�����

��

��

� ��

� � � �

����� ���

� ��

� � � �

��

Page 89: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� �

� �� �

���� �

������

� �

� �

� � � �

��� �

�� ��

���

���

������

Page 90: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�����

���

�������

� �

��

� �� �

� �

Page 91: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� ��

� �� � � � � �

� ��

�� �����

�����

� � ����

���

Page 92: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�� independent

��

���

����

(re-reading) �� � �

� �

���

���

� ��

Page 93: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�� ��

paradigm � � paradigm

���

� �

� �

� �� �

����

���

���

��

� �

� � � � � �

Page 94: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� �

Qura'nic legaldicta basic impulse

� � �

� chronological order

� paradigm �

��� �������

� sublime �

Page 95: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�� � �

(submission) ���� �

� ���

(shell) ���

��

� full-fledged ���

���

��

�� �������

Page 96: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

engulf receptive sublime

����

� � �� (officials)

empire distinction �

� cohesive force � ��� � �

sublime soul

� �� �� time space (climax)

�� (eternity) ��

� ��

(vision) ����

Page 97: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� ���

suffocating system closed � �� �

(essential) �

���

�� codified law ���

� �

� � �

� ��

��

� ��

� � �

�� �� �

� �

Page 98: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�� �

����

� � ��

��

���� � (catalyst)

� � � �

� ��

linear direction Space Time phase

��

(dimension) ���

��

(impression) ��� ��

������ �� �

Page 99: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

���

����� ��

�� � �

�� (institutions)

���� � ��

� ���

� ���

�����

���

����

��

Page 100: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�� �

: � ���

Woe to you Pharisees! For how you love the seats of honor in the

synagogues and the respectful greetings from everyone as you walk

through the markets! Yes, awesome judgment is awaiting you. For

you are like hidden graves in a field. Men go by you with no

knowledge of the corruption they are passing. (Luke 11:43,44)

I have a question for you. Is it right to do good on the Sabbath day, or

to do harm? To save life, or to destroy it. (Luke 6:9)

What good is it for one blind man to lead another? He will fall into a

ditch and pull the other down with him. (Luke 6:39)

A tree from good stock doesn't produce scrub fruit nor do tree from

poor stock produce choice fruit. A tree is identified by the kind of

fruit it produces. Figs never grow on thorns, or grapes on bramble

bushes. (Luke 6:43,44)

Page 101: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

My yoke is ����� easy and my burden is light

���Wa tch ou t ! bew are of t h e yea s t of t h e Ph a ri s ees a n d

Sadducees.(Matthew 16:6)

How could you even think I was talking about food? But again I say,

'Beware of the yeast of the Pharisees and Sadducees.' (Matthew 16:11)

����Woe to you, Pharisees, and you other religious leaders. Hypocrites!

For you wont't let others enter the Kingdom of Heaven, and won't go

in yourselves. And you pretend to be holy, with all your long, public

prayers in the streets, while you are evicting widows from their

homes. Hypocrites! (Matthew 23 :13-15)

����������

o o o

�� �

Page 102: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

����

� ���

���

���

���

��

����

��

� �

���

��������

Page 103: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�����

identify

� � ��

� � � �

����� ���

���

����

�� ���

� �� �

���

���

Page 104: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� �

� �

� � �

��

� �

� ���

���

���

Page 105: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

���� ����

� ���

���

��� � ��

��� perceptions

������

���������

prominent scholar �

��

Page 106: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�����

����

�����

��

�� �

���

� ����

�canonization ��

����������

���

������

Page 107: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��canonization �

����

�� extension

Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam, Edited & Annotated by M.Saeed Sheikh Lahore 1989

��

� versions ��� �

������

�����

� � �

��

��

Page 108: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��(labels) ��

����

� �

��

��������

��������

��

��

��

������

����

Page 109: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

���������

���

���

������

���

���

��

� �������

Page 110: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��� �

��

�������

��������

�� �

��

Page 111: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

������ �

��

� �

���

�����

������������

Page 112: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

� �

��

���

� canonization

���

��

�����������

��

���� �

��

Page 113: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

������

��

���

. . . ��

��

��

���

� . . .

��� . . .

Page 114: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

���

� ��

� �

� canonization ����

��

�������

Page 115: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

��

����

�����

���� ��

� ����

��

��� ��

Page 116: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

������

��� ��

�� �

���

��� ��

� ��

�� � �

�� �

���

��� � �

��

Page 117: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�� ��

���� ���

��� �

� ��� �

�� ��

�� canonization ��������

����

��

����

���

Page 118: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

������

�� �

� � �

�������

� ��

� � fabrication � �

��� � �

� ��

�����

��

�� ���

Page 119: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

��������

�����

���

�������

���

��� �

�����

����

�� �

���

Page 120: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

�� �

��� ���

� �

��

�����

���

Page 121: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�����

��� � �

� �

� �

����

������

�� Handy

Page 122: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�������

��� editing

��

������������

larger-than-life-size � (project)

extension �

�����

Page 123: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

���

��

����

������

��

��

���

�����

� � � ��

Page 124: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� �������

� � � � ��

��������

����

Law-giving �� Law-making Law-making

� ��

�����

����

��

���

Page 125: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

�� ���� ��

���

���� �

���

Page 126: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

���

����

� �

� �

�����

����������������������

��� ��

Page 127: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��������

��

��

�������

���

������ modify �

��������

���

����

���������

���

����

Page 128: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�� � �

��

�� ��

�� ���

��

. . .

��� �

��

��� ��

��

Page 129: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

���� ��

�����

����

��� ��

� �

���

��� �

�� � �

������������

Page 130: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

����

����

����

������

������

����

����

���

����

�������

��������

Page 131: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

������

�����������

sublime music

Page 132: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�� �

� �

��

�� ����

Page 133: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� time-clock ��

������

����������������

�Deyunei Halacha

� �� � ����

��� ��

��� �� �

������

�������� ��

Page 134: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

���������

������

��������������������

����

� � ��

�������

��������

���� �� � �

�� ������� �

� � ��� � ��

�� ���

��� ������������

Page 135: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�����������

������

����� ����������

������

����������

���������

������

����

�����

��������

Page 136: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�� �� � ����

���� ��

�����

������ � �� � � � � �

� �

Page 137: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� � � ��

� � �

�� �� � � � � � ���� �� ��

Page 138: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�����

���

���

� � � � �

�� �� ��

�������� ���

Page 139: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

���

����

��

������ � � �

�������� �

Page 140: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�� � ���

���

Page 141: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

����

�����

������

���� �

�� ��� � ��

���

�� �����

��

���

���� �

Page 142: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�������

���

� � �

� ���� ��

����

����If a man wows he will not have intercourse with his wife, the school

of Shammai allows him two weeks, the school of Hillel one week'

(Keth v.6) and if by the end of that period he does not annul his vow

and resume cohabitation, he is compelled to divorce her. (p.169,

Everyman's Talmud)

����

"One teacher declared: 'A man is obliged to have his daughter taught

Page 143: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

Torah' but this statement is immediately followed by the opposing

view; whoever teaches his daughter Torah is as though he taught her

obscenity' (Sot.III,4).... One Rabbi asserted, 'let the words of the Torah

rather be destroyed by fire than imparted to women' (p.Sot.19a); and

we are informed that when a woman put a question to a Rabbi in

connection with the Golden Calf, he told her, 'A woman has no

learning except in the sue of spindle' (Joma 66 b). Quoted from

Everyman's Talmud p.179

�� �������

����

� �

�������

��

�����

�������

��

Page 144: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� �

���� �

��

���

��

Page 145: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

��������

���

��� �������

��

�������

��

Page 146: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

���

�����������������������

�� �����

��

����

���

Page 147: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��������

����

�������

������

����� �����

��

��

Page 148: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

���

�����

������

�����

��

�� ������

����

���� ��� �

�� �

Page 149: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� ���� ���

� � ���������

���� �� ���

��

� ���

����

� ���

Page 150: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

��� �

��� �

�����

� ��

������

� �

Page 151: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�� ��

�������

� ���

���

���

���

� �� institutionalize

������

Page 152: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

����

� ��� ��

���

������

����� ��������

�� ���� �������

Page 153: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

������

� �

specialized agency ��

�����

�������

�����

����� �

�������

Page 154: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

� �

�� �

�����

������

�Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam Edited &

� by M.Annotated Saeed Shaikh, Lahore, 1986

�� Reconstruction Reconstruction

N.P.Aghnides� �

� Mohammadan Theories of Finance

� � � � �

����

� �� �� �

Page 155: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

���� � � � ��

� �

� ��

: Mohammed Khalid Masood, Iqbal's Reconstruction of Ijtihad

pp. 188-9

� ��� � �����

���

����

����

����

���

��� �

Page 156: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�����

��

��

��

� -- �

Page 157: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

��

Rs. 80/- �

Rs. 110/- � �

Rs. 110/- �

Rs. 140/- �

Rs. 120/- �

Rs. 200/- � �������������

Rs. 100/- � �

Rs. 80/- � ----------------------------------------

Rs. 700/- � �

Rs. 500/- � ��

www.RashidShaz.com

Page 158: Islam men Fiqh by Rashid Shaz

�����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������