is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?

24
Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?

Upload: wilbur

Post on 22-Jan-2016

25 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?. CP 1996. AR 33 Barbara M Smith (up to 2001). Chen & van Beek 2001. Chen & van Beek. Random problems, no structure. cbj a waste of time. Chen & van Beek. Chen & van Beek. Chen & van Beek. 10 cases where GAC beat GAC-CBJ. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?

Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?

Page 2: Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?

CP 1996

Page 3: Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?
Page 4: Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?
Page 5: Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?
Page 6: Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?
Page 7: Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?
Page 8: Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?

AR 33 Barbara M Smith(up to 2001)

Page 9: Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?
Page 10: Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?

Chen & van Beek 2001

Page 11: Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?

Chen & van Beek

cbj a waste of time

Random problems, no structure

Page 12: Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?

Chen & van Beek

Page 13: Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?

Chen & van Beek

Page 14: Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?

10 cases where GAC beat GAC-CBJ

When cbj gets beaten it gets beaten by a very small amounti.e. cbj has a small overhead

Chen & van Beek

Page 15: Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?

When cbj wins it canwin by a HUGE margin cbj is robust

Chen & van Beek

Page 16: Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?

The bottom line

Chen & van Beek

Page 17: Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?

Bayardo & Schrag

SAT: relsat(i) uses cbj + relevance bounded learning, retaining conflict sets of size ≤ i as clauses,

Page 18: Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?
Page 19: Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?
Page 20: Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?
Page 21: Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?
Page 22: Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?
Page 23: Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?
Page 24: Is conflict directed backjumping a waste of time?

IJCAI 2007