integration of graph transformation and temporal logic for the specification of distributed

160

Upload: others

Post on 11-Sep-2021

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

����������� ������� �� � ���� � � ���� ������� � ���������� � � � � � ���"! # �$���&% �'� ��� �

( � �)%*�,+ %-�.������� �� / �&�0�1��32 45��� � (76 �0��� � �

8:9:;=<:>@?A>@<CB'8C9:DEGFIH ?A9:JLKNMODQPR9:;=JTSUB FIV >@;W SCDYXZ>[?�\]9_^a`SCXQbdce>@;f? F DgKih H SCDQjkSCX

l 9:J�mnSU^a`_on>@;=> F ^a`�prqsKeMODQPR9:;=JTStB FIV KjZ>@;�uv>@^a`ZD F bf^a`Q>@D�wxD F 8C>@;fb F BrySUBdcz>@;=? F D

{@XQ;d|};=?~SCDZ<CXZDZ<LjZ>@bxS V SCjQ>@J F bf^a`Q>@D0��;fSCjZ>@bE 9 V Bf9:;'jZ>[;xMODQ<:>@D F >@XZ;=b=� F bfbf>[DZbf^a`ZSUP�B�>[D

K E ;@�ZMODZ<Q�3K<:>@DQ>@`ZJ F <CBf> EGF b=bf>@;�BaSUB F 9:D

� ;=9:J�9CB F 9:DZb�SUXZbfb=^a`_XQ�Z�l 9C;fb F B�{[>@DZjZ>[;@� � ;=9CPi� E ;@��\��n�Gon>@;fJ�>[�C>@;ce>@; F ^a`�B�>@;[� � ;f9CPi� E ;[������|}`Z; F <ce>@; F ^a`�B�>@;[� � ;f9CPi� E ;[������K��Q��\];f>[9���b VYFce>@; F ^a`�B�>@;[� � ;f9CPi� E ;[��mz� � SU; F b F K � ;=>@b F ^@^[>u3SC<LjZ>[;'� F bfb=>@DZb=^a`kSUP�Bf? F ^a`Q>@D0�dXZbfb H ;�SU^a`Z>C�zq:�Q��hg> H B�>[J�o�>[;�pr�:�:�

���g�t� �¢¡¤£n¥¦¥¦¥§©¨¦ª

Page 2: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

«­¬ ®�¯ °�±²°

Page 3: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

³�´vµ@¶k·­·1¸_¹,ºN¶kµ»µ@´�¹,¼

EGF >½8:9C;f? F >@<:>[DZjZ>²�¾;=o�> F BLb�B�>@?A?ABL> F DZ>¿PR9:;=JTSC?A>²h H >@{ FAÀkV SUB F 9:DZb=JÁ>ÂB�`Z9_jZ>¿PÃyXZ;�8:>[;=Bf> F ?ÄB�>Åh_�_b�B�>@J�>8:9:;[�ÇÆ F >[?I>0jQ>@;²�¾;=o�> F B¿b F DZjÈj F > V 9:J H 9:DZ>@D�Bf>@D��z> F b=> W 9_jZ>@?A? F >@;fXQDZ<­jZ>[b l >[;f`kSU?AB�>[DZb½8:>[;=Bf> F ?ÄB�>[;h_�_b=B�>[JÁ>UÉZj F >Gh H >@{ FAÀkV SUB F 9:D�8:9:D²| F <:>@DZb=^a`kSUP�Bf>@D½8:>[;=Bf> F ?ÄB�>[;'h_�_b=Bf>@J�>GXZDZj¿j F >GwxD�B�>@;=b=BCyXgB�{@XQDZ<�{@XZJÊ SCXQBf9:JÁSUB F bf^a`Z>[D�Ë ywdon>@; H ;UyXQPR>[DÅj F >@b=>@;x| F <:>[DZbf^a`ZSUP�B�>[D¦�wdJ j F >@b=>dÆ F >@?A>z{[X�>[;f;=> F ^a`Q>@D¦É_bf^a`Z?ISC<:> F ^a`�> F DZ>[D F D�B�>[<:; F >@;=Bf>@D��dDZb�SUBf{�{[�e> F >[;}PR9:;fJÁSC?I>[; W >[B�`Q9UK

jZ>@D½8C9:;@�'ÌCÍÂÎÃÏOÍÂÐ�ÑÒÏiÍ�ÓÔÎ=ÕÂÖk×_Ï¢Î=ÕCØQÙRÚ»ÛtÎÃÜ�ÕCϢРÛtØ�XQDZj©ÏOÍÂܾÖkÛtÎfÕCÑIÍxÝ,ÛfÞCÐIßt� l >@;�B�> F ?ABf>]�];�S H `YBf;�SCDQb=PR9:;=JTSUB F 9:D� F ;fj�{@XZ; W 9gjQ>@?I? F >[;fXZDZ<ÅjZ>[b l >@;=`kSC?ABf>@DZbà8:>[;=B�> F ?ÄB�>@;sh_�_b=Bf>@J�>½> F DZ<:>[bf>[Bf{[B@É�| F <:>@DQbf^a`kSUP�Bf>@D­�e>@;=jZ>@DJ F B�Bf>@J H 9:;fSC?I>[;sáâ9:< FIV b H >@{ FAÀ { F >@;�B»� E >[; V 9CJ�o F D F >@;�B�>Á�¾DZbfSUB�{ H ;f9 À B F >[;=Bs8C9:DãjZ>@D�hYB�ySC; V >@DãjZ>[;> F DQ{@>@?ADZ>@DÅ�¾DQbrySUBf{@>�XZDZjÅb=Bf>@?I?ÄB�> F DZ>]<:>@> F <:DQ>[B�> W >ÂB�`Z9_jZ>�{@XQ; l >[;=PayXZ<:XQDZ<ZÉZ�db H > V B�>�8:>[;=B�> F ?ÄB�>@;xhY�gbiKB�>@J�>GPR9:;=JTSC?äXZDZjÅ<:;�S H ` F b=^a`Å{[X0J�9gjQ>@?I? F >[;f>@Dä�MO^a`½`kSCon>d> F DZ>[D¿h F DZ<:?A>ÂK � XZb=`Z9:XQB Ê h � ��Ë}�¾DZbfSUB�{xPÃyXZ;}8:>@;�B�> F ?ABf>d��;fS H `�B�;fSCDZb=PR9C;fJÁSUB F 9:DL>@D�BO� F ^ V K

>@?AB@ÉZjZ>[;xb=9r�z9:`Q?vj F >]uv9 H 9C?I9:< F >]SC?Ab'SCXZ^a`åj F >]?A9 V SC?I>[D E SUB�>[DZ{@XZb�B�ySCDQjZ>�b H >[{ FÄÀ { F >@;=B@� EGF >[bf>@;��dDZb�SUBf{?OySC�CB&> F DQ> lGF >[?I{@SC`Z?g8C9:DTh H >[{ FÄÀkV SUB F 9:DZb=Bf>@^a`ZD FIV >[D�PayXZ;3j F >'?A9 V SC?I>[D�ÆäXZb=BrySCDZjZ>'{[X¦��| F D��¾SCX H B�on> F B�;�SU<JÁ> F DZ>[b]�¾DZbfSUB�{[>@b F b=B�j F > V 9CJ H 9:b F B F 9:DkSC?A>s9 H >@;fSUB F 9:DkSC?A>�hg>[JTSCD�B FIV Éâ�z>[?I^a`Z>ÁSCXQPejZ>@D�8:9CD W SU;=B F D��;=9:�:>ÂKOæx`Q9gjZ>¾>@D�BO� F ^ V >@?ABf>@DèçQÎ=ÕCØQÙRÚ»ÛtÎÂÜ�ÕCÏéРÛtØQÙaÙÂêrÙÂÏiÍÂÜTÍÂØ�okSUb F >[;=B@�MO^a` F D�B�>@<C; F >[;f>GjQ>@D0h � ���¾DQb�SUBf{GPÃyXQ;z8:>[;=B�> F ?ÄB�>��];�S H `YBf;�SCDQb=PR9:;=JTSUB F 9:DTXZDZj²> F DZ>]SCXZb=b�SC<C>@DZ?A9:< F K

bf^a`Z>LB�>[J H 9:;�SU?I>�áâ9:< FIV � EGF >�MOD�B�>@<C;�SUB F 9:D©8C9:?I?A{ F >[`�B]b F ^a`-yXZon>@;G> F DZ> � ;=>ÂK��G;=jZDYXZDZ< Ê > F DZ>�;f>Âëk>Âì F 8:>XZDZjTBf;�SCDZb F B F 8:>xæ�>@?ISUB F 9:D�˾yXZon>@;�8:>@;�B�> F ?ABf>@D½��;fS H `Z>[DTXZDZjT;f>@b=XZ?AB F >[;=B F D�<:;�S H ` F D�Bf>@; H ;f>[B F >[;=B�>[DÁBf>@J�KH 9:;fSC?I>[D�m�9C;fJ�>@?ID�XQDZjÁBf>@J H 9:;fSC?I>[DÁ��;fS H `ZJ�9gjQ>@?I?A>@D¦���];�S H ` F D�B�>[; H ;=>[B F >@;�B�>xmk9:;fJ�>@?AD�>@;=?~SCXZon>@D�j F ><:;�S H ` F b=^a`Z>åh H >[{ FÄÀkV SUB F 9:D�B�>@J H 9:;�SC?A>@;�| F <:>@DZb=^a`kSUP�Bf>@D¦ÉÔb=9�jZSC��j F >åh H >@{ FAÀkV SUB F 9:DãjZ>[bL8C>@;�B�> F ?ABf>@Dh_�_b=B�>[JÁbxXZDZjÅj F >àh H >[{ FÄÀkV SUB F 9:D¿jZ>@;dh_�_b�B�>@J�> F <:>@DQbf^a`kSUP�Bf>@D F J�b=>@?Ion>@Dåmk9:;fJÁSC? F bfJsXZbe<C>@bf^a` F >@`�B@�E SCD V jQ>@;�MOD�B�>@<C;�SUB F 9:D½8C>@;=Bf> F ?AB�>[;x��;fS H `�B�;fSCDZb�PR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:D½XZDQjÅBf>@J H 9:;fSC?I>[;Ôáâ9:< FAVÁV y9:DQDZ>@DÅ8:9:;iK`kSCDZjZ>[DZ>ã\]9:DZ{[> H Bf> F J cz>[;f> F ^a`íjZ>@;0Bf>@J H 9C;�SC?A>@D*áâ9:< FIV {@XZJ î¾SU^a`Y�e> F b�<:;�S H ` F D�B�>[; H ;=>[B F >@;�B�>[;m�9C;fJ�>@?ID�oQ{@<:?¢�¦> F DZ>@b�J F BG8C>@;=Bf> F ?AB�>[;à��;fS H `�B�;fSCDZb�PR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:D�J�9gjZ>[?I? F >@;�B�>[D�h_�_b=Bf>@J�bà<C>@DYXQB�{ÂB��e>@;iKjZ>@D¦�3MODZbfon>@b=9:DZjZ>[;f>�jkSCb�\]9:DZ{[> H B&jZ>@b W 9_jZ>[?ÄK�ïz`Q>@^ V >[DZb�� F ;fj F D�j F >@bf>[;&�¾;=o�> F B3{@XZ;�SCXgB�9:JÁSUB F bf^a`Z>[Dl >@; FÄÀkV SUB F 9:Då8C9:D�<:;�S H ` F D�Bf>@; H ;f>[B F >[;=B�>[D�mk9:;fJ�>@?AD0on>[Bf;�SC^a`�B�>ÂB»�àMO^a`�b=B�>[?I?A>sj F >�\]9:DZb�B�;fX V B F 9:D�> F DZ>[bÏ¢êaÖnÐIÙrða×kÍÂØÅñòÛ@ó_ÍÂÑ�ÑôÙ�8:9:;[Ég�e>@?A^a`Z>]> F D½J©y9C<:? F ^a`Z>@;��z> F bf>dXZDZ>[DZjZ? F ^a`Z>@bÔBf>@J H 9C;�SC?A>@bz��;fS H `ZJ�9gjQ>@?I? Ê j¦�õ`ä�> F D W 9gjQ>@?I?gJ F B3XQDZ>@DZjQ? F ^a`�8 F >@?A>@D�ÆäXZb�B�ySCDZjQ>@D�Ë�{[X�> F DZ>@J�>@DZjQ? F ^a`Q>@D��];�S H `QJÁ9_jZ>@?A?Y{@XZbfSCJÁJ�>@DgPéSC�CB»�E SCbzBO� HZF b=^a`Z> W 9_jZ>@?A?¦` F ?ÄP�B»ÉY8:9:D²?A9 V SC?I>[;Ô|};=PayXZ?A?IokSC; V > F Be?I9 V SC?A>@;Ômk9:;=JÁ>[?ID F D¿> F DZ>@Jöu�> F ?Ab=�_b=Bf>@J�jQ>@b8:>@;�B�> F ?ABf>@D÷h_�_b=Bf>@J�bÅSCXQPàj F >�<C?I9:okSU?I>©|};�PÃyXQ?I?IoZSC; V > F BÁ<:?A9:okSC?A>@;½mk9:;=JÁ>[?ID F J <C>@b�SUJsB�>[DÈ8C>@;�B�> F ?ABf>@Dh_�_b=B�>[J"{@XÅbf^a`Z? F >[�:>@D¦�

Page 4: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

ø½ù µ[ú»ût¶ZüCú

u'` F b��z9C; V²H ;f9r8 F jQ>@bGS�JÁ>ÂB�`Z9_jZ9:?A9:<C�½PR9C;xBf`Z>�b H >[^ FÄÀ ^»SUB F 9:Då9CP}j F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j0b=�_b�B�>@J�b¾oZSCbf>[j�9:DPR9:;fJÁSC?¦J�>[Bf`Z9gjQb@� W S�ý=9:;dS F J�b�SC;f>]Bf`Z>�^[9:J H 9:b F B F 9:DkSU?äJ�9gjZ>[? F DZ<�9CP3Bf`Z>ào�>[`kS»8 F 9:;�9CP&j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jb=�_b=Bf>@J�b@É�Bf`Z>�b H >@^ FÄÀ ^»StB F 9CDò9UPÔj F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@jòb=�_b�B�>@J H ;=9 H >@;=B F >[b�SUDZj�Bf`Z>LbfX HZH 9:;�Bs9CPeB�`Z> F ; Ê SCXQB�9tKJTSUB F ^»Ë�8:>[; FAÀ ^»SUB F 9:D¦�u�9ò;f>@SC^a`þB�` F bL<:9�SC?¢ÉeM H ;f9 H 9:b=>0SUD F D�Bf>@<:;fSUB�>[jþS HQH ;f9�SU^a`þ9CPdBO�z9òPR9:;fJÁSC?ÔJ�>[Bf`Z9gjQb@ÉzDZSCJÁ>[?A�

óCÐIÙÂÏ¢ÎÃÐéÿ��_ÏiÍfó�ÞCÎ=ÕÂÖk×�ÏéÎfÕCØQÙRÚ»ÛtÎÃÜ�ÕCÏéРÛtØ1SUDZjèÏOÍÂܾÖkÛtÎ=ÕCÑ'ÑIÛfÞCРðÂ� EGF b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�<:;�S H `�Bf;�SCDQb=PR9:;=JTSUB F 9:D F bF D�B�>[DZjZ>@jLPR9:;}J�9gjQ>@? F DZ<¾Bf`Z>�o�>[`kS»8 F 9:;}9CP�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jLb=�_b�B�>@J�b@ÉY��`Z>[;f>»SUbej F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j�b��_b=B�>[J H ;f9 H K>@;=B F >[b'SC;f>]b H >[^ FÄÀ >@j²o��TBf>@J H 9:;fSC?ä?A9:< F ^C�3u'`Q>]^@9:J�o F DZ>[j²S HZH ;=9�SC^a`²o�>[DZ> À B�b'PR;f9:JÇB�`Q>]b=B�;=>@DZ<UB�`²9CP>»SC^a`åb F DQ<:?I>�S HQH ;f9�SU^a`0SCDQj H ;=9�8 F jZ>@bxSLbfX F BaSCoZ?A>]JÁ>ÂB�`Z9_jZ9:?A9:<C�ÁB�9LJÁ9_jZ>[?¦PR9:;fJÁSC?I?Ä�LB�`Z>�SCb H >@^ÂB�bx9CPj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j²b=�_b=Bf>@J�b@�MGjZ>[8C>@?A9 H Såb F DZ<C?I>ÂK H XZb=`Z9:XQB�S HZH ;f9�SC^a`òB�9åj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j1<C;�S H `òB�;fSCDZb=PR9C;fJÁSUB F 9:D©B�`kStBsb H >[^ FAÀ >@b

B�`Z>zBf9 H 9:?I9:<U�]9CPkB�`Q>Ôj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�b��_b=B�>[J SCbv�z>[?I?QSCb F B�b3?A9g^@SC?YjkSUB�S¾b=B�SUB�>[b@� W �sS HZH ;f9�SC^a` H >@;=J F B�b�S8CSU; F >ÂBO��9CP,b H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:DTB�>[^a`ZD F�� XQ>@bÔPR9:;e?I9_^»SC?�jkSUB�Ssb=B�SUB�>[b@ÉQ��`Q>@;f>¾M F D�8:>@b�B F <�SUB�>xB�`Z>¾;f> � X F ;f>[JÁ>[DYBfbPR9:;'B�`Z>�b H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:D²B�>@^a`QD F�� XZ>[bdB�`ZSUBx^»SCDÅo�>àXZb=>@jåPR9C;�Bf`Z>�?I9_^»SC?äjkSUBaSg�e�íJÁS F D²^@9CDYBf; F oZXQB F 9:D²9CPJs�àS HZH ;=9�SC^a`sBf9¾j F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j�<:;�S H `�Bf;�SCDZb�PR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:D F b,B�`Q>z^@9CJ H 9:b F B F 9:DkSC?:9 H >[;�SUB F 9:DkSU?�bf>@JÁSCD�B F ^@b[�u'` F b�bf>[JTSUDYB F ^ F b'okSCbf>[j09:D¿Bf;�SCDZb�PR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:D½b��_b=B�>[JÁb F D�Bf;f9_jZXZ^@>[jåo��å�];f9:�C>ÂKiæ�`Z9_jZ>C�M F D�B�>@<C;�SUBf>zB�`Z>zb F DQ<:?I>ÃK H XZb=`Z9:XQB&S HZH ;=9�SC^a`�B�9¾j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�<:;fS H `�B�;fSCDZb�PR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:D�SUDZjLS H ;=9 H 9tK

b F B F 9:DZSC?_Bf>@J H 9C;�SC?g?I9:< F ^C�,u'`Z> F D�Bf>@<:;fSUB F 9:DsBaS V >@b H ?ISC^@>'9r8C>@;�S H ;f>ÃKO9:;=jZ>@;};=>@?ISUB F 9:D�9r8:>[;�j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j<:;�S H `Zb©SCDQj¤;f>@b=XZ?ABfb F D÷<:;�S H `gK F D�B�>@; H ;f>ÂB�>[j*B�>@J H 9:;�SC?]PR9:;=J�XZ?ISCb0SUDZjèB�>[J H 9:;fSC?�<:;�S H `¤JÁ9_jZ>@?Ab@���;fS H `gK F D�B�>[; H ;=>[B�>[j�PR9C;fJ�XZ?ISCb H ;=9�8 F jZ>ÅSòJ�>[Bf`Z9gjQ9:?I9:<U�1B�9òb H >@^ F P���Bf>@J H 9:;fSC? H ;=9 H >@;=B F >[b�<C;�S H `_KF ^»SU?I?A�CÉ F D¿B�`Z>�b�SUJÁ>]�zSr�¿SCb'B�`Z>�j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j²b��gb�B�>[J F B�b=>@?AP F b'b H >@^ FÄÀ >@jä�u'`Z> F D�B�>[<:;�StB F 9CD09CP�j F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j�<:;�S H `0B�;fSCDZb=PR9C;fJÁSUB F 9:D©SCDQj©B�>@J H 9:;�SC?v?I9C< F ^�SC?I?A9r��bdB�9TJTS V >

XZbf>�9CP�B�`Q>©8CSU; F >ÂBO�þ9UP�8C>@; FÄÀ ^»StB F 9CD ^@9:DZ^[> H Bfb F D B�`Q>�SC;f>@S­9CP�Bf>@J H 9C;�SC?x?I9:< F ^åBf9�^a`Z>@^ V <C;�S H `_KF D�B�>[; H ;=>[B�>[j-Bf>@J H 9C;�SC?xPR9:;fJ�XQ?~SCbT� F B�`È;f>[b H >@^ÂBåBf9 S­Bf>@J H 9:;fSC?¾<C;�S H `ÈJ�9gjQ>@? �)MÁPR9_^@XZb F D B�` F b�z9:; V >[b H >@^ F SC?A?A�ò9:D1Bf`Z>½^@9CDZ^@> H BL9CP�J�9gjZ>[?ÄKN^a`Z>@^ VYF DQ<0PR9:;�Bf`Z>¿SCXgB�9:JÁSUB F ^�8:>@; FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:D­9CP�<C;�S H `_KF D�B�>[; H ;=>[B�>[j Bf>@J H 9:;fSC?zPR9:;=J�XZ?ISCb@�ãM H ;f9r8 F jZ>²B�`Z>Å^@9CDZb=Bf;fXZ^ÂB F 9CD 9CPGS�BO� HZF ^»SC?'<C;�S H `�J�9gjZ>[?ÔB�`kStB^@9:?A?~S H b=>@b�S H 9Cbfb F oZ?A� F D À D F Bf>GB�>@J H 9:;�SC?äJÁ9_jZ>@?¦Bf9�S À D F B�>�9:DQ>�SUDZjÅBf`kSUBxbfX HZH 9C;=B�b�B�`Q>à;=>»SCb=9:D F DZ<PR;f9:J B�`Z>¿?A9g^@SC?zbfSUB F b=PéSC^ÂB F 9CD­9CPd?I9_^»SC?�PR9:;fJ�XQ?~SCb F DãS�bfXZo_KOb=�_b�B�>@J 9UPdBf`Z>¿j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jãb=�_b�B�>@J Bf9<:?I9:oZSC?äbfSUB F b=PéSC^ÂB F 9CD¿9CP3<C?I9:okSU?äPR9:;fJsXZ?~SCb F D¿B�`Z>�^[9:J H ?I>[Bf>]j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j²b=�_b�B�>@JÅ�

Page 5: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

� ������ ��

� ; F B F DZ<½S � ` E u'`Z>[b F b F bG? FAV > À <:`�B F DQ<½PéSC^@>sBf9½PéSC^@>�PR9C;Gbf>Â8:>@;fSC?&�:>@SC;fbàSC<:S F DZb�B]SCD Ê S HZH SU;f>@D�Bf?A�QËXZDZ;f>@SC^a`kSCoQ?I>CÉ�XQDZ^»SUBf^a`kSCoZ?A>�SCDZj�XZD�B�SCDZ< F oZ?I>e<:`Z9:b�B»�&u'`kStB&B�`Z>'<C`Z9:b=B À DkSC?A?A�àJTStB�>@; F SC? F {[>@j�SCDZj�B�`kStBM�SCJ$b=BaSUDZj F DQ<½SUBxB�`Z>s>@DZj©9CDZ>sb�B�> H ` F <:`Z>[;d9CD0B�`Z> H >[jZ>@b�BaSC?vB�`kSUD0B�`Z>�<:`Z9:b�B¾�zSCb H 9:bfb F oZ?A>�9CDZ?A�jZXZ>]B�9�B�`Q>àJ�9CB F 8USUB F DZ<sPR9:?A?I9r� F DQ<s� F DZj²oZ?A9r��Dåo��¿JÁSCD�� H >@9 H ?A>C�m F ;=b=B�9CP3SC?I?¢ÉZSCDQjåJ�9:b=B F J H 9:;�BaSCD�B»ÉgJs�½PéSCJ F ?Ä�:ÉYB�`kStBd<:Sr8C>�J�>GB�`Q>àon>@b�B F JTSU< F DkSUoZ?I>x>@D�8 F ;=9:DZJ�>@D�BSCDZj¿SC?A?kB�`Z>d^@9:DZj F B F 9:DZb�B�9�^@9:DZ^[>@D�B�;fSUB�>¾9:DT��; F B F DZ<àBf`Z>¾u'`Q>@b F b@� �ÈF Bf`Z9:XQB�B�`Q>@JÅÉ_Bf` F b��z9:; V �e9:XZ?Aj`kS»8:>àDZ>[8C>@;xo�>[>@D H 9:b=b F oZ?I> Ê SC?Ib=9LPR;=9:J�S�DZ9CDåo F 9:?I9C< F ^@SC? H 9 F DYBÔ9CP�8 F >[�dËÂ��]D©Bf`Z>��zSr�0B�9½��; F B F DZ<TB�`Q>�u'`Z>@b F b@ÉâPR;=9:J�on>@< F DZD F DZ<½B�9¿>[DZj¦É,æ�> FAV 9²�d>[^ V >[?��zSCbàS H SUB F >[DYB]SCDZjJÁ9CB F 8USUB F DZ<à^@9:J H SCD F 9:D½��`Z9�<:Sr8C>�JÁ>G^[9:DZb�B�;fXQ^[B F 8:>àSCDZb��z>[;fbxSCDZj²`Z>[? H B�9�JÁSCD�� � XQ>@b=B F 9:DQbxM��zSCb^@9:DQPR;=9:D�B�>[jþ� F Bf`þ9:DþBf`Z>å�zS»�:�-u'`kSCD V b½<C9�SC?Ib=9òBf9�h F ? V >0SCDQj W Stì���`Z9­`ZSCjþB�9�o�>@SC;�JÁ>å9:DSC?I?ÔBf`Z>Å8 F b F BfbTSU;f9:XZDQj B�`Q>Å�e9:;f?Aj¦�Ècz>[b F jQ>0æ�> FAV 9ZÉÔJÁS F D�8 F ^ÂB F JÁb�9CPGJs� � XZ>@b�B F 9CDZbÁ�e>@;=>©m�SCo F 9�àSCjQjZXZ^@^ F SCDZj W SC;�B F D0�];f9C�:>ÂKOæx`Z9_jZ>U�&MÔSCJö<:;f>@SUBfPRXQ?äB�9L`kS»8:>àJ�>[B�SC?A?¦9CP,B�`Q>@J"SCDQjÅBf9�`ZSr8C>�`kSCjB�`Z>�^a`kSCDZ^[>�Bf9å?A>»SC;=DòPR;=9:J�Bf`Z>@J Ê >[8:>[D F PeM¾b�B F ?I?&jZ9ÅDZ9CBàXZDQjZ>@;=b=BaSUDZj1��`���jZ;=��^@S V >[bsb=`Z9:XZ?Aj�on>BaSCb�B F >[;aËÃ� W 9:;=>@9r8:>[;@ÉkSC?A?�9CPâB�`Z>[JöJ�9CB F 8USUB�>[jÁJ�>dPR9C;eB�`Q>dB�; FIH B�9�MNB�SC?A��^@9CDQPR;f9:D�B F DZ<�JÁ>x� F B�`ÁJTSUDY�F D�B�>[;f>@b�B F DZ<0>Ãì H >@; F >[DZ^@>[b@�Å�ÔBsB�` F b H 9 F D�B»ÉvMGB�`kSCD V MN8USCDQ9�hQSC?Ä8:9ÅPR9:;�` F b H SUB F >@D�BàB�>»SU^a` F DZ<å9CPÔBf`Z>MNBaSC? F SCD½?ISCDZ<:XZSC<:>�SCDZjÅ^@XQ?AB�XQ;f>C�M�SCJ <:;=>»SUB=PRXZ?ÔB�9òJs��SCjg8 F bf9:; � ;f9UPi� �¾SU;=B�JsXQBÁ|�`Q; F <�SCDZjãB�`Q>å<:;fSCjZXkStB�>²^@9:?A?I>@SC<:XZ>��f\]9:J�J�XgKD FIV SUB F 9:DZb=okSCb F >@;�B�>àh_�_b�B�>@J�>��Á?I>@SCjZ>@jåo�� � ;=9CPi�Ô�x9:J�JÁ>[? ÉQBf`kSUBx<�S»8:>�JÁ>]B�`Q>�^a`kSUDZ^@>�B�9���; F Bf>]B�` F bu'`Z>@b F b@��M}B�`ZSCD V SC?Ib=9 � ;f9CPi���dSCDZbiK��ky9:;=<�\];f>@9r��b V_F SUDZj � ;f9CPi��mk;fSCDZ^@>[bf^[9 � SC; F b F K � ;f>[b F ^@^@>dPR9:;eBf`Z> F ;� F ?I? F DZ<CDZ>@b=bzB�9L;f> H 9C;=B�9:D²B�` F b'u'`Z>@b F b[�u'`kSCD V b�<:9ÅB�9�SC?A?}B�`Z>½J�>@Jso�>[;fbs9UPÔB�`Z>T;f>@b=>»SC;=^a`�<:;f9CX H b�SUB�B�`Z>Áu�w�cz>[;f? F D­SCDQj1B�`Z>½m�; F >[jZ; F ^a`�¾?I>ÃìQSCDZjZ>[;�wxD F 8C>@;=b F BrySUB�|};f?ISCDZ<:>[DgKiî�yXZ;fDYon>@;f<½��`Q>@;f>�Mxb H >@D�BàJs�©�e9:; VYF DQ<²B F J�>C��h H >[^ F SC?�Bf`kSCD V bB�9�JÁ>[J�on>@;fb}9UP�Bf`Z>@b=>xBO�e9�<C;f9:X H b}<:9]B�9àæx> FIV 9�SUDZj W SC;=B F D Ê M V DZ9r�þB�`ZSUB�M�`kS»8C>dJ�>@D�B F 9:DZ>[jLBf`Z>@JSC?I;=>»SCjQ��SCon9�8C>CÉYoZXQB F B F b&�e9:;=Bf`�Bf9�JÁ>[DYB F 9:D�Bf`Z>@J BO� F ^@>»ËÂÉ�B�9�MODZ<:; F j�m F bf^a`Z>[; Ê PR9:;&B�>@SC^a` F DZ<�JÁ>ÔBf`Z>XZbf>ÂPRXZ?IDZ>[bfb�9CP�>@JÁS F ?3^@9CJÁJ�XQD F ^@SUB F 9:D©SCDQj�PR9C;G9g^[^»SCb F 9:DZSC?�PR9_9gj�b=X HZH 9:;=BaËGSCDZj WåF ^a`kSC>@?&cz>@;�B�`Z9:?AjÊ DZ9CBeSàJÁ>[J�o�>[;�9CPäBf`Z>@b=>¾<:;=9:X H b[ÉgoZXgBÔSCD F J H 9:;=B�SCD�B�JÁ>[J�o�>[;�9CP¦Js�L;=>@b=>»SC;=^a`¿SC^[B F 8 F B F >[baËÂÉ:Bf9sæ�9:b FcÔSC;fjQ9:`Z? Ê SCDZj©cz>@;=D F >àPR9:; F D�B�;f9_jZXZ^ F DZ<ÁJÁ>�B�9 F D�B�>[;f>@b�B F DZ<ÁBf9 HZF ^[b¾on>@b F jZ>àB�`Z>àB�`Z>[b F b�ËÂÉnB�9 WåF ^a`kSC>[?æxXZjQ9:?AP Ê PR9:; F DYBf>@;=>@b=B F DZ<xj F bf^@XQbfb F 9:DZb�SC;f9CXZDZjsMNB�SC? F SCD�^ F DZ>@JÁSCbvSCDZj�SxJ�9:;=> F DZDZ9r8USUB F DZ<'�ÔS»�à9CPQXZb F DZ<SCDT9���^[>rËÂÉYB�9 W >@;=^��>¾á,?ISCoZ;��>@b Ê ��`Z9�<�S»8:>¾J�>�bfXZ; H ; F b F DZ<s>ÂB�`ZDZ9C?I9:< F ^»SC?Q` F D�B�b�B�9�bfJÁSC?I? F bf?ISCDZjZb�Ë}SCDZjB�9L�¾? À 9 W SC;=B F D F Ê 9:DZ>�J F DYXQBf>G9CP&` F b'? F PR>G^»SUDÅBf>@?I? F DZ^[;f>@j F oZ?A>Gb=Bf9:; F >@baËÃ�u�9�BaS V >sJs�²J F DZj²9_^@^@SCb F 9:DkSC?A?A�½9��òBf`Z> � ` E >���9:;=BfbGSCDQjåB�9�;f>[b=Bf9:;f>�Js� H 9r�e>@;dMÔ`kS»8:>àB�9ÁBf`kSCD VJTSCD�� H >[9 H ?I>UÉeb=XZJ�JTSC; F {[>@j F D­Bf`Z>¿PR9:?I?A9r� F DZ<©<C;f9:X H b@�½B�`Q>Å9C?Ij­PR; F >@DZjQb�PR;f9:J bf^a`Z9_9:? É�Js���CXZjZ9B�>»SUJåÉQBf`Z>�h_B�>[DZ{@>[?,oZ;f9CBf`Z>@;=b@É � SCXZ?I>àSCDQj0cz>[DZD F �

Page 6: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

� ���! � �� �"

# $ ¹�úrû&%('v´vüCú&)*%n¹ #pC�Ap æ�> � X F ;f>[JÁ>[DYBfb'B�9�S�h H >[^ FÄÀ ^»SUB F 9:D²uv>@^a`ZD F�� XZ>�PR9:; EGF b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jÅh_�_b=Bf>@J�b �à���à�à� +

pC�Ap:�Äp EGF b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jÅ�];�S H `Åuv;�SUDZb=PR9:;=JTStB F 9CD ���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� +pC�Ap:�,+ uv>@J H 9:;fSC?âáâ9:< F ^¤���à�à���à���à�����à�à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� q

pC�-+ W S F DÅæ�>@bfXQ?AB�b �����à���à���à�à���à���à�����à�à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� qpC�-+g�Äp ïz9:DZ^[> H BfXkSC?,;f>[bfXZ?ÄB�b �à���à���à�����à�à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� qpC�-+g�,+ W S F D²u'`Z>@9:;=>[B F ^»SU?,æx>[bfXZ?ÄB�b����à�����à�à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� .

pC�ôq �G;=<�SCD F {»SUB F 9:D½9UP�Bf`Z>�u'`Z>@b F b �à���à���à�����à�à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� /0 1 )é¹v¼32R¸54s´vµ768%�´âú ø�9:9 û&%�¶kü;6-ú<%>=?)éµ[úrû;) ù ´âúr¸�'A@¿û�¶ 9 6ABzû�¶k¹vµ@ºC%�ût·1¶Qú&)D%n¹FEHGIGKJMLON�PRQ

S LOTVU S T�PXWYL[Z S]\ LO^`_ Sba;ced TfURgihj_ \ P S LOTVUlkmPfUnPfh a�opa U Srqts Z Sua`o #3#+_�Ap EGF b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[jÅïz9:D À <:XQ;�SUB F 9:D W SCDZSC<:>@J�>@D�B��à�à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� prq+_�-+ 1 úr¸ 9 # ��u'`Z>�u�9 H 9:?A9:<C�T9CP�Bf`Z> EGF b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jÅh_�_b=Bf>@J �à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� p&v+_�ôq 1 úr¸ 9 0 ��u'`Z>àáâ9g^@SC? E SUB�SL�db H >@^ÂB�bx9CP&S EGF b=B�; F oZXgB�>@jåh_�_b�B�>@J����à���à�à���à���à�à� p</+_�xw 1 úr¸ 9zy �eïz9:J H 9:DQ>@D�BO� F b=>sh H >[^ FAÀ ^»SUB F 9:D²9CP EGF b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jÅh_�_b=Bf>@J�b �à�à���à���à�à� +gp

+_�xwZ�Äp EGF b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jà�];�S H `]u�;fSCDZb=PR9C;fJÁSUB F 9:D|{¾MODYBf>@<:;fSUB F DZ<'uv9 H 9C?I9:< F ^»SC?USCDZjàáâ9_^»SC?E SUB�S��¾b H >@^ÂB�b7�à���à�à���à���à�����à�à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� +`++_�xwZ�,+ EGF b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jÅ�];�S H `Åuv;�SUDZb=PR9:;=JTStB F 9CD½PR9:; EGF b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jåh_�_b=Bf>@J�b����à���à�à� +`}

+_�-v 1 úr¸ 9!~ �eh_�_DZ^a`Z;=9:D F {@SUB F 9:D²9CP � ;=9g^[>@b=bf>@b¾SCDZj EGF b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jÅ� H >[;�SUB F 9:DZSC?âhg>[JTSUDYB F ^[b q�v+_�-vg�Äp u'`Z>�h_�_DZ^a`Z;=9:D F {»SUB F 9:Dåæx>[?~SUB F 9:D ���à�à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� q�v+_�-vg�,+ � H >[;�SUB F 9:DZSC? EGF b=B�; F oZXgB�>@jÅh_>@JÁSCD�B F ^[b ���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� q�}

y 1 9 ¸_ü�)éº��8)¢¹,¼�¶k¹�'��r6,¸_ü;��)¢¹,¼�@½û�¶ 9 6�� $ ¹�ú»¸_û 9 û�¸Yú»¸�'�Bz¸_· 9 %�ût¶f2��(%�ût·ò´:2R¶kµ�)é¹�=?)¢µb�ú»û�) ù ´,úr¸�' 1 �,µ[ú»¸g·1µ ~Iyqg�Ap u'`Q> W S F D � ;f9 H >@;�B F >@b�9CPvB�`Z>�ïÔSCb=>shYB�XZjQ�È�à�à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� w`wqg�-+ �];�S H `gK F D�B�>@; H ;f>ÂB�>[jÅuv>@J H 9:;�SC?¦m�9C;fJ�XZ?ISCb �à�à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� w�v

qg�-+g�Äp �d9r�÷B�9Áh H >@^ F P��Å�];�S H `_K F D�Bf>@; H ;f>[Bf>@j²uv>@J H 9:;fSC?âmk9:;=J�XZ?~SUbÔ���à�à���à���à�à� w�vqg�-+g�,+ hQSUB F b�PéSC^[B F 9:D¿9CP&�];�S H `_K F D�Bf>@; H ;f>[Bf>@jÅmk9:;fJsXZ?~SCbÅ�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� vC�

qg�ôq ïz`Q>@^ VYF DZ<ThQSUB F b�PéSC^[B F 9:D¿9CP&�];�S H `_KOMOD�B�>[; H ;=>[B�>[j0uv>@J H 9C;�SC?âmk9:;=J�XZ?ISCbe�à�à���à���à�à� vCqqg�ôqQ�Äp u'`Z>�u�� HQF ^»SU?3�];�S H `²u�;fSCDZb F B F 9:DÅh_�_b=Bf>@J ���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� vCqqg�ôqQ�,+ ïz`Z>[^ V_F DZ<LB�`Z>�JÁS F D H ;=9 H >@;=B F >[bx9UP�Bf`Z>�^»SCb=>àb�B�XZjg� �����à���à�à���à���à�à� v�.

~ �(%�ût·1¶V2�=¿¸_µ»ü:û;) 9 ú&)D%n¹�%�º5=?)¢µ[ú»û�) ù ´,úr¸�'�@½û�¶ 9 6�Bzû�¶k¹vµ@ºC%�ût·1¶Qú&)D%n¹�)¢¹�ú<6v¸ 1 )¢¹,¼32é¸4�´vµ76:%n´âú ø�9:9 û;%�¶kü;6 � #wQ�Ap u�� H >[j��];�S H `Åuv;�SUDZb=PR9:;=JTStB F 9CD �à���à�����à�à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� .�+wQ�-+ W 9gjZ>[?Ib�SCDQj W 9_jZ>[? W 9:; H ` F b=JÁbÔPR9:;�æ�> À DZ>@J�>@D�B ���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� .�w

wQ�-+g�Äp W 9_jZ>@?Ab�SCDZjÅu�9UBaSC? W 9gjZ>[? W 9:; H ` F b=JÁb �à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� .�wwQ�-+g�,+ W 9_jZ>@?Ab�SCDZj � SC;�B F SC? W 9_jZ>@? W 9:; H ` F bfJ�bG�à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� }gp

wQ�ôq EGF b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[jL��;fS H `�uv;�SCDQb=PR9:;=JTSUB F 9:D F D�B�`Q>xh F DZ<C?I> � XZb=`Z9:XQB�� HZH ;=9�SC^a`L� F B�`�?A9g^@SC?� KOb�BaSUBf>@b ���à�à�����à���à���à�à���à���à�����à�à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� }C�wQ�ôqQ�Äp u'`Z>�^»StB�>@<C9:;=�¿9UP EGF b=B�; F oZXgB�>@jå�];�S H `Zb�SCDZj EGF b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j W 9:; H ` F bfJ�b-�à�à� /:�wQ�ôqQ�,+ ïz9:DZj F B F 9:DkSC?�u�;fSCDZb�PR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:D¿9CP EGF b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jÅ�];�S H `Qb'���à���à�à���à���à�à� /:qwQ�ôqQ�õq ïz9:J H 9CDZ>@D�BO� F b=>�h H >[^ FÄÀ ^»SUB F 9:D²9CP EGF b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jÅh_�_b�B�>@J�b ���à�à���à���à�à� /`.

M

Page 7: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

wQ�ôqQ��w �þïz9:J H 9:b F B F 9:DkSC?�� H >@;fSUB F 9:DkSC?_h_>@JÁSCD�B F ^[b�oZSCbf>[j�9:D�uv;�SCDQb=PR9:;=JTSUB F 9:D�h_�_biKB�>[JÁb��à�����à���à���à�à���à���à�����à�à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� ��+

wQ�ôqQ�,v �¾JÁSC?A<�SCJÁSUB F 9:DTSUDZj EGF b=Bf; F oQXQB F 9:D)�à�à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� p»�:qwQ�xw EGF b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j¿u�;fSCDZb=PR9C;fJÁSUB F 9:D¿9CP��ÔBfB�; F oZXgB�>@j0�];�S H `Qb��à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� pCpr�

wQ�xwZ�Äp �ÔBfBf; F oZXQB�>[jå��;fS H `Åu�;fSCDZb=PR9C;fJÁSUB F 9:D*�à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� pCpr�wQ�xwZ�,+ u'`Z>GïÔSUB�>[<:9:;=�L9UP EGF b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jT��;fS H `Zb�� F Bf`T�ÔBfBf; F oZXQB�>[j¿�];�S H `ZbzSUbzáâ9_^»SC?

h_B�SUB�>[b �����à���à���à�à���à���à�����à�à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� pCp7wwQ�xwZ�õq EGF b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j1��;fS H `­uv;�SUDZb=PR9:;=JTStB F 9CD�� F B�`­�ÔB=B�; F oZXQBf>@jã�];�S H `Zb�SCb�áâ9_^»SC?E SUB�S)�à�����à���à���à�à���à���à�����à�à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� pCp</

� �(%�ût·1¶V2R=¿¸_µ»ü:û;) 9 ú&)D%�¹�%�º�@½û�¶ 9 6�� $ ¹�ú»¸_û 9 û�¸Yú»¸�'YBz¸_· 9 %�û�¶V2R�8%�ût·�´�2R¶kµ�)¢¹�=?)¢µ[ú»û�) ù ´,úr¸�'1 �,µ[ú»¸g·1µ�¶k¹:'þú&6,¸�)éû���6v¸_ü&�()¢¹,¼ #�08#v_�Ap � ;=9 H 9Cb F B F 9:DZSC?�uv>@J H 9:;�SC?¦á,9C< F ^ �à���à�����à�à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� p<+gpv_�-+ � ;=9 H 9Cb F B F 9:DZSC?�uv>@J H 9:;�SC?¦á,9C< F ^�|}DZ; F ^a`Z>[jåo�� � ;f>ÃK��G;fjZ>[;fb]�à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� p<+Cq

v_�-+g�Äp u'`Z>�u�� HQF ^»SU? � ;=>ÂKO9C;fjZ>[; W 9gjQ>@? ���à�à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� p<+�wv_�ôq �];�S H `gKOMOD�Bf>@; H ;f>[Bf>@j � ;f9 H 9:b F B F 9:DkSC?�u�>[J H 9:;�SU?âáâ9:< F ^��à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� p<+�.

v_�ôqQ�Äp |}J�on>@jZj F DZ<�æx>[?~SUB F 9:D ���à���à�����à�à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� p<+�/v_�ôqQ�,+ uv>@J H 9:;fSC?,�];�S H ` W 9gjZ>[?Ib����à�����à�à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� p»qQpv_�ôqQ�õq ïz9:J H 9Cb F B F 9:DZSC? l >[; FÄÀ ^»SUB F 9:D.�à�����à�à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� p»q:q

� �T¸�2R¶Qúr¸�'���%�û&� # ~ #.g�Ap u'`Q>àMOD�Bf>@<:;fSUB�>[j0� HQH ;f9�SU^a`å9CP&�];�S H `²uv;�SCDQb=PR9:;=JTSUB F 9:D²SUDZjåuv>@J H 9:;�SC?¦á,9C< F ^½�à�à� p�w�+.g�-+ �];�S H `²u�;fSCDZb=PR9C;fJÁSUB F 9:D²cÔSCb=>@jÅ� HZH ;=9�SC^a`Z>[b��à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� p�w�+

.g�-+g�Äp u'`Z> E]� �)� HQH ;f9�SU^a`ÅBf9 EGF b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j0�];�S H `²u�;fSCDZb=PR9C;fJÁSUB F 9:D ���à���à�à� p�w�+.g�-+g�,+ �];�SCJ�JTSU;fbePR9C; EGF b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jåh_�_b=B�>[JÁb����à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� p�w�q.g�-+g�õq � H >[D©�];�S H `²u�;fSCDZb=PR9C;fJÁSUB F 9:DÅh_�_b=Bf>@J�b��à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� p�w`w

.g�ôq uv>@J H 9:;�SC?¦á,9C< F ^[b �à���à���à�à���à���à�����à�à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� p�w�v.g�xw � ;=9g^[>@bfbdSC?A<:>@oZ;fSCbG���à���à���à�à���à���à�����à�à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� p�w�v.g�-v �Go_ý=>[^[B�K��G; F >@D�B�>[j W 9_jZ>[? F DQ<�u�>[^a`ZD F�� XZ>[bdPR9:; EGF b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[jÅh_�_b=B�>[JÁb¤�à�à���à���à�à� p�w�v

� ��%n¹vü�2¢´vµ7)D%�¹vµ # ~ �}_�Ap ��h � �)� F <C`åáâ>Â8:>@?,� HZH ;f9:SC^a`ÅBf9Áj F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j²<:;�S H `²Bf;�SCDQb=PR9:;=JTSUB F 9:D ���à���à�à� p�w�}}_�-+ MODQ^@9:; H 9:;fSUB F DZ< EGF b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j¿uv>@J H 9C;�SC?âáâ9:< F ^@b0���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� p�w�/}_�ôq MODQ^@9:; H 9:;fSUB F DZ<�B�`Q>s�];�SUJÁJÁSC; F D¿B�`Z>�u�� HQF ^»SU? W 9gjQ>@? �à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� p�w�/}_�xw uv9_9:?,hgX HQH 9:;�B �����à���à���à�à���à���à�����à�à���à���à�à���à�����à���à�à���à���à�à� p�w�/

M=M

Page 8: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

� � �ö� ���� �

� �! � �F� � �¡��!�

MOD²Bf`Z>�o�>[< F DQD F DZ<CbÔ9CP�JÁ9_jZ>@;=D²^@9:J H XQBf>@;fb F D�pr��w�vgÉg^@9:J H XQBf>@;=b��e>@;=>�`_XQ<:>àSCDZjÅ>Âì H >[DZb F 8:>U�eMODZb�B F KB�XQB F 9:DZb3`kSCjL9:DZ?Ä��PR>Â� ^@9CJ H XgB�>@;=b@É:�e9:; VYF DZ< F DZjZ> H >[DZjZ>[DYB�9CPn>@SC^a`Á9UB�`Z>[;@�&MOD�B�`Q>'J F jZjZ?I>e9CP�B�`Z>¢/C�CbB�` F b]b F BfXkSUB F 9:D�^a`kSUDZ<:>@jä�½ïz9:J H XQBf>@;=bàon>@^@SCJ�>�b=JTSU?I?I>[;]SCDZj�^a`Z>@S H >@;àjZXZ>�B�9²BO�z9ÅjZ>Â8:>@?A9 H J�>@D�B�b[�9:D�B�`Z>'9CDZ>'`kSCDZj H 9r�z>[;=PRXZ?kJ F ^[;f9 H ;=9g^[>@b=bf9:;=b@É�9:D�Bf`Z>'9CB�`Q>@;}`kSCDQjLBf`Z>'b=B�SC;=B&9CPä?A9g^@SC?gSC;f>@SGDZ>[BO�e9:; V bÊ áâ�Gî¾ËÂ�äu'`Q>@bf>�Bf>@^a`ZDQ9:?I9:< F >@bd>@DkSUoZ?I>�;=>@?ISUB F 8:>@?Ä�²b F J H ?A>àBf9½^@9CDZb=Bf;fXZ^ÂB�^@9:J H XQBf>@;Gb��gb�B�>[JÁb]^[9:DZb F b=B�KF DZ<²9CPÔSÅ` F <:`�DYXZJ�on>@;à9CP H ;=9g^[>@b=bf9:;=b�^[9:DZDZ>[^[B�>[j18 F S²` F <C`gKOb H >[>@jòDZ>[Bfb@��Bf`Z>Lo F ;�B�`ò9CPGóCÐIÙÂÏ¢ÎÃÐéÿ��_ÏiÍfóÙÂê�ÙÂÏOÍÂÜsÙÂ��ïz9:J H SC;=>@jT� F B�`T^[>@D�B�;fSC?äb��_b=B�>[JÁb[ÉZj F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@jÁb=�_b=Bf>@J�bÔ`kS»8:>GS�DYXZJ�on>@;Ô9UP,SCjQ8USCD�BaSU<:>@b[�B�`Z>Â��SC;f>�J�9:;f>�>@^[9:DZ9:J F ^@SC? ÉUPéSCb=Bf>@;@É_SC;=>dJ�9:;=>'bfX F BaSCoZ?A>ÔPR9:; F DZ`Q>@;f>[D�Bzj F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[jÁS HZH ? F ^»SUB F 9:DQb@É�SC;=>JÁ9:;=>�;f>[? F SCoZ?I>UɦSCDQj�SU;f>�>»SUb=�©>Ãì H SCDZjkSUoZ?I>U��u'`Z>@b=>TSUjQ8USCD�BaSC<:>[b]JTSUjZ>�bfXQ;f>�B�`kStB�9:XZ;GjkS F ?A�å? F PR> F b^@9:DQPR;=9:D�B�>[jÅ� F B�`ÅS�<C;f9r� F DZ<LDYXZJ�on>@;'9UP&j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j²b��gb�B�>[JÁb[�czXQBGBf`Z>�JÁ9C;f>sBf`Z>�bf9_^ F >[BO�©jQ> H >@DZjZb�9:D©Bf`Z>�DZ>Â�)Bf>@^a`ZDZ9C?I9:<C�CɦB�`Z>sJÁ9:;=> F BdPR>@>[?Ib F Bfb¾�e>»S V DZ>[bfbf>[b@��¾<�S F D©SCDQj�SC<�S F DåPéS F ?IXZ;=>@bx`kS HZH >@D¦É�B�`kSUB¾^»SCD�`ZSr8C>LSÁ8USC; F >[BO�Å9CP�;=>»SCb=9:DZb@�xPéSCXZ?ÄBO�åb=9CP�BO�zSC;f>Uɦ9r8:>@;iK?I9�SCjQ>@j©^[9:JÁJsXZD F ^@SUB F 9:DÅDZ>[Bfb�SCb¾�e>@?I?3SCbG9r8:>[;f?A9�SCjZ>[j�9:;dPéS F ?I>[j0bf>[;=8C>@;fb[��h_9:JÁ>ÂB�` F DZ<½9CP}Bf`kSUB VYF DZj� F ?I?e9g^[^@XZ;LJ�9:;f>²SUDZjãJÁ9:;=>½PR;f> � XQ>@D�B�?Ä�:É F PdBf`Z>²DZ>[Bfb�PR9:;�okSCD V b[Ézbf^a`Q9g9:?Ab@É�^@9:J H SCD F >@b[Ée>ÂB�^U�ã� F ?I?o�>[^@9:J�>�o F <C<:>@;]SUDZj�o F <:<:>[;@� �ÈF B�`�?AXZ^ V S½PéS F ?IXZ;=>s^@9Cb=B�bà9:DZ?Ä�åB F J�>�SCDZj�Bf`Z>LDZ>@;�8:>@bà9CP�B�`Z>�XQbf>@;[�MNPàS1^»SCb=` j F b H >@DZb=>@; F bTjZ>ÂPR>@^[B@É�JÁ9:b�B�?Ä�ã9:DZ>©^@SCD À DZjþ9:DZ>©DZ>@SC;ÁBf`kSUBT9 H >[;�SUBf>@b[�èu'`Z>©^[;�SCb=` 9CPB�`Z>L^@9CJ H XgB�>@;�b��gb�B�>[J 9UPÔS²b=Bf9g^ V JÁSC; V >[Bà^@SCXZbf>[bsSU?I;f>@SCjQ��J�9:;=>�^@9:DZb=> � XZ>[DZ^@>[b@�¿u'`Z>L�¾J�>@; F ^@SCD^@9:J H XQBf>@;Ôb�B�9_^ V JÁSC; V >[B�îx�]h E �¤£ F D©pr�:��ws9:;zB�`Q>]b=B�9_^ V JÁSC; V >[B F D¿mk;�SUD V PRXZ;=B F D�pr�:�`/sSC;f>G9CDZ?A�BO�z9¿>ÃìZSUJ H ?A>@b[�¾MOD�pr�:�C�TSÁPéS F ?IXZ;=>�9UP}B�`Z>àB�>@?A> H `Q9:DZ>�DZ>ÂB]9CP��}u¢¥]uí;f>[bfXZ?ÄB�>@j F D5.:�C�:�:��Bf>@?A> H `Z9CDZ>^@9:DZDQ>@^[B F 9:DQbzB�`kStBz^[9:XZ?IjTDZ9CBÔon>¾XQbf>@jÅSCD��_J�9:;f>¾SCDZj½?A9:DZ<sj F b=B�SCDZ^[>¾^»SU?I?Ib��e>@;f>¾DZ9CB H 9:b=b F oQ?I>GStBÔSC?A? ��ÔBsB�`Q>½?~SUBf>@b�B»É F PÔB�`Q>T`Z>@SC?ABf`­9:;à>[8:>[D�B�`Z>Á? F PR>�9CP H >@9 H ?I> F bà^@9:DZ^[>@;=DZ>@jão��­SÅPéSCXZ?ABO��b��_b=B�>[JåÉ&PR9C;F DZb�BaSCDZ^[> F D�S0`Z9:b HZF B�SC?�9:;�S H ?~SCDZ>�^@;fSCbf`äÉ&PéS F ?AXZ;f>[b�^@SCDZDZ9CB�o�>�B�9:?A>@;�StB�>@jä��hg9ZÉ F B F bsDQ90�z9CDZjZ>@;[ÉB�`kSUB�B�`Q>@;f> F b�S�<C;f9r� F DZ<�>@^[9:DZ9:J F ^@SC?�SCDZjÁbf>@^[XZ; F BO� F D�B�>[;f>@b�B F DÁjZ>Â8:>[?I9 HZF DZ< H ;f9CBf>@^[B F 9:DTSC<�S F DZb=B�Bf`Z>B�`Z;=>»SUBx9CPvPéSCXZ?ÄBO�½j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j²b��gb�B�>[JÁb[�u�9 F J H ;=9�8C>0B�`Q>ò^[9:;f;=>@^ÂB�DZ>[bfbÅ9CPàj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jÈb=�_b=Bf>@J�b@É]SUD 9:DZ<:9 F DZ<�>���9:;�B F b¿jZ9CDZ>©B�9ãjZ>Â8:>@?A9 HJÁ>ÂB�`Z9_jZb0Bf`kSUB�b=X HZH 9:;=B�Bf`Z>­b H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:DíSCDZj*8C>@; FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:D¤9CPLj F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j¤b��_b=B�>[JÁb[� |3ìQSCJ�KH ?I>[b�9CPxJÁ9_jZ>[? F DQ<©SCDZj�b H >[^ FÄÀ ^»SUB F 9:D­Bf>@^a`ZD F�� XZ>@bLXZb=>@j�PR9:;�j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j�b=�_b=Bf>@J�bLSC;f> H ;f9_^@>@b=bLSC?ÄK<:>@oZ;fSCb�? FAV >àï'ï'h§¦ WåF ?M/:�;¨¦9:;'B�`Q>i©�KO^»SU?I^@XQ?IXZbi¦ W0�ª� ��+;¨¢É � >ÂB�; F DQ>[B�b�¦ � >[BO.�+gÉõæx> F /�}&¨ ÉQBf>@J H 9C;�SC?�?I9:<UKF ^@bH¦ h_B F ��+gÉõ|}JÁ>@�:��¨¢Éä<:;fS H `�B�;fSCDZb�PR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:D«¦ |�\ W æd�C�QÉôæ�9:{@��}gÉ u3SC>@�`.�¨¢Éâ9:o_ý=>[^[B=KN9:; F >@D�B�>[j�JÁ9_jZ>@? F DZ<B�>@^a`QD F�� XZ>[bd? FIV >à� W u¬¦ æxc �®­ �Qp�¨ É���� E ¦ cz9_9���w�¨âSCDZjÅw W á�¦ ædSUB���};¨¦SCDZjÅJTS»�½J�9:;=>C�}u'`Z>�b H >@^ÃKFAÀ ^@SUB F 9:DòBf>@^a`ZD F�� XZ>@bLSUjZjZ;f>[bfb�Bf`Z>½b H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:D19UPxS0j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�b=�_b=Bf>@J5PR;=9:J7j F ��>@;=>@D�B H 9 F D�Bfb9CP38 F >Â����hg9:J�>�9CP3Bf`Z>@J$? FIV > H ;=9g^[>@b=bGSC?A<:>@oZ;fSCb�9:;�B�>@J H 9:;�SC?â?A9:< F ^@b'`kS»8:>sSÁJ�9:;f>]PR9:;=JTSU?â9:; F >@D�BaStKB F 9CD¦É H ;=9�8 F j F DZ<]JÁSUBf`Z>@JÁSUB F ^»SC?_J�9gjZ>[?Ib&PR9:;�B�`Z>xSCDkSU?A�_b F b}SCDZjL8:>[; FAÀ ^»SUB F 9:D�9CP�b=�_b�B�>@J�b@���¾Bf`Z>@;=b�? FIV >w W áãPR9g^[XZb�JÁ9:;=>�9:D�B�`Q>�jZ>@b F <:DòSCb H >[^[B�b�9CPzS¿j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�b��gb�B�>[Jå���dDZj�bf9:J�>�B�>[^a`ZD F�� XZ>[b�? FIV ><:;�S H `©B�;�SUDZb=PR9:;=JTStB F 9CDZb¾B�;��0Bf9 H ;f9r8 F jZ>�on9CBf`�S¿Bf`Z>@9C;f>[B F ^@SC?3okSUb F b]b=X F B�SCoZ?A>sPR9:;¾Bf`Z>LSCDkSC?Ä�_b F bGSCDZjB�`Z>]8:>[; FÄÀ ^»SUB F 9:DÅSCb'�e>@?A?,SCbxSCD F D�B�X F B F 8:>G�zSr�¿Bf9LjZ>@b F <:DÅSLb=�_b=Bf>@JÅ��Mej F b=^@XZb=bdDQ9��èoZ; F >[ëZ�¿SCb H >@^ÂB�bB�`kSUB�`ZSr8C>àBf9Lo�>�^@9r8C>@;f>[j©o��²S�b H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:DÅBf>@^a`ZD F�� XZ>]PR9:;�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j²b=�_b�B�>@J�b@�

p

Page 9: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

#R¯*# �½¸�°¦´�)Rû�¸_·1¸_¹�ú�µsú<%�¶ 1 9 ¸_ü�)D±3ü:¶Qú&)D%n¹!Bz¸_ü�6v¹:)�°¦´,¸0º²%nû³=?)¢µ[ú»û�) ù ´,úr¸�' 1 �,µÂúr¸_·­µu'`Z>TPR9:?A?I9r� F DZ<²? F b=B�bf`Q9���b�B�`Z>½;=> � X F ;f>@J�>@D�Bfb�B�9©S0b H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:D�Bf>@^a`ZD F�� XZ>½PR9:;àj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j­b��gbiKB�>@J�b@�3u'`Z>@b=>G;f> � X F ;f>[JÁ>[D�B�bz`Q>@? H SC?Ib=9àBf9sJ�9CB F 8USUB�>ÔBf`Z> F DYBf>@<:;fSUB F 9:DL9CPâ<:;fS H `LB�;fSCDZb=PR9C;fJÁSUB F 9:D�SCDZjB�>@J H 9:;�SC?�?I9:< F ^GjZ9CDZ> F D¿B�` F bÔ�z9C; V SCDZj²b V >[Bf^a`Z>@bdB�`Z>]BaSU;f<:>ÂB�<:;f9:X H 9CP�Js�½S HZH ;=9�SC^a`¦�1 úrût´vüCú�´,ût¶f2 ø µ 9 ¸_üCú�µ�´ u'`Q>@bf>©SCb H >@^ÂB�b¿SC;=>0^[9:DZ^@>[;fDZ>[j � F Bf` B�`Q>0jZ>[bf^@; FIH B F 9:D 9CPàS�j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j

b=�_b=Bf>@J�µõb¿b�BaSUBf>C�*MOD H SC;=B F ^@XQ?~SC;[ÉzB�` F b F DZ^@?AXZjZ>@bÁB�`Z>©^[XZ;f;=>@D�B½Bf9 H 9C?I9:<C�ã9UP]B�`Z>©j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jb=�_b=Bf>@JÅÉ F � >C� F B�b�b F B�>[b@É H ;f9_^@>[bfb=>@b@Éx^@9CJ H 9:DZ>[DYBfb@ÉxSCDZj B�`Z> F ;T^[9:DZDZ>[^[B F 9:DZb[�*u'` F b½SCb H >[^[B F b>Âì H ;=>@bfb=>@j H ;=>[PR>[;�SCoZ?Ä�È<:;�S H ` F ^@SC?I?Ä�:� áâ9g^@SC?]b=B�SUB�>[b09CPsb F B�>@b[É H ;f9_^@>[bfb=>@b@ÉàSCDQjè^@9CJ H 9:DZ>[DYBfbB�9:<C>[B�`Q>@;L� F B�`ãB�`Q> F ;L;=>@?~StB F 9CDZb�8 F S�bf`kSC;=>@j jkSUBaS�PR9:;=J5B�`Z>Åbf>[^@9:DQj H SC;�BT9CPGSòj F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jb=�_b=Bf>@J"b�BaSUBf>C�

Bzû�¶k¹�µ[ºC%�ûU·�¶Qú&)D%�¹,¶V2 ø µ 9 ¸_üCú�µ�´ �þj F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jsb��gb�B�>[J F b�SCD�>[8:9C?A8 F DZ<QÉCjQ�_DkSCJ F ^�b=Bf;fXZ^ÂB�XZ;=>C�}|&8C9UK?IXQB F 9:D�BaS V >@b H ?ISC^@> F D¿>»SC^a` H SU;=B'9CP,Bf`Z>]b=�_b=Bf>@JÅ��u�9 H 9:?A9:< F ^@SC?�;f>[^@9:D À <:XZ;�StB F 9CD¦É F � >C�_B�`Z>¾^@;f>ÃKSUB F 9:D�SCDZjò;f>[JÁ9r8USC?}9CPeb F B�>[b@É H ;f9_^@>[bfbf>[b@É3SCDZjò^@9:J H 9CDZ>@D�B�b�SCb]�e>@?I?�SUbà^[9:DZDZ>[^[B F 9:Dò^a`kSCDZ<C>@bSC;f>�S]^[;fXZ^ F SC? H ;f9 H >@;�BO��9CP�b=�_b=Bf>@J�b F DZ^@9:; H 9C;�SUBf>@j F D�SCDL>Â8:9:?Ä8 F DZ<�>@D�8 F ;=9:DZJ�>@D�B»�}ce>@b F jZ>@b}Bf`Z>DZ>@^[>@b=b�SC;�� b�BaSUBf>ÅBf;�SCDQb=PR9:;=JTSUB F 9:DQb�9CP¾Bf`Z> H ;f9_^@>[bfb=>@b½;=>@b H ��?A9g^@SC?Ô^[9:J H 9:DZ>[D�B�b�B�`Z>[JÁb=>@?Ä8:>@b[É^@9:J�J�XZD F ^»StB F 9CD¿SCDZj F D�B�>[;f^[9:DZDZ>[^[B F 9:DåSCb H >@^ÂB�b@ÉnSCb�;=> H ? F ^»StB F 9CD¦ÉQJ F <:;fSUB F 9:D¦É_SCDZjÅ;f>[JÁ9UB�> F DgKB�>[;�SC^ÂB F 9CDZb@ÉZ`ZSr8C>àBf9Lo�>�jZ>[bf^@; F on>@j0SCbÔ�z>[?I?¢�

��%n· 9 %nµ7)�ú&)D%n¹v¶V2 ø µ 9 ¸_üCú�µ�´ � j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�b��gb�B�>[J ^@9CDZb F b=B�b39CP�bf>Â8:>@;fSC? F DYBf>@;fSC^[B F DZ<G^[9:J H 9:DQ>@D�B�b[�u'`Z>@;=>[PR9:;=>CÉeS©DZ9CB F 9:D�9CPdS�^@9CJ H 9:DZ>[DYB�SCDZj�B�`Z> F ;�^[9:J H 9:b F B F 9:D­`ZSCb�B�9�on>¿jZ> À DZ>@j F D­Bf`Z>b H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:DåBf>@^a`ZD F�� XZ> F DÅ9:;=jZ>@;xB�9Tb=X HZH 9:;=BdB�`Z>�^@9:J H 9:b F B F 9CDÅ9UP}j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j©b��_b=B�>[JÁb¾oY�B�`Z> F ;'^[9:J H 9:DZ>[D�B�b@�

ø ¹v¶V2¶�,µ7)éµ ø µ 9 ¸_üCú�µ�´·� `Q>@;f>@SCbÅSCDkSC?Ä�_b F bÁB�>@^a`QD F�� XZ>[bÅPR9:;TDZ9:DgKNj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j b=�_b�B�>@J�b@É H ;f>ÂPR>@;fSCoZ?A�B�9_9:?ÄKNbfX HQH 9:;�B�>[j¦ÉZSC;=>]SC?A;f>»SUjQ�¿S�` F <:`Z?Ä�TjZ>[b F ;�SCoZ?A>¾PR>»StB�XZ;=>�SCDZj¿PR9g^[XZb'9CP�;f>[bf>»SU;f^a` F D½B�`Q>]?~SCb�BjZ>@^@SCjZ>[b@ÉeBf`Z>¿DkSUBfXZ;�SU? F DZ^[;f>@SCbf>[j ^[9:J H ?I>Âì F BO�­9CPxj F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@jãb��gb�B�>[JÁbLJÁS V >²bfXQ^a`�PR>@SUB�XZ;=>>[8C>@D0J�9:;=>]jZ>@b F ;�SUoZ?I> F D²Bf`Z>àSC;f>@S�9CP3j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j²b=�_b=Bf>@J�b@�

îd9:DZ>�9CPvB�`Q>àb H >[^ FÄÀ ^»SUB F 9:D¿Bf>@^a`ZD F�� XZ>@b�PR9:;'j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j²b��gb�B�>[JÁbxJÁ>[D�B F 9CDZ>@jÅSCon9r8:>�b�SUB F b À >@bdSC?I?�9CPB�`Z>'SUb H >@^[Bfb}^@9:J H ?A>[B�>[?A�C�3mk9:; F DZb�BaSCDQ^@>CÉ H ;f9_^@>@b=b�SC?I<C>@oZ;fSCb&SC;=>e�e>@?A?QbfX F B�>[j�B�9GJ�9_jZ>@?_^@9:J H 9:b F B F 9CDkSC?SCDZj�SCDZSC?A�_b F bsSUb H >@^[Bfb@É&oQXQB�SC;=>T?A>@bfb�bfX F BaSCoQ?I>LPR9:;�b�B�;=XZ^[BfXZ;�SC?eSCb H >[^[B�b[É}>@b H >[^ F SU?I?A�0B�`Z>Á?I9_^»SC?�jkSUB�SSCb H >@^ÂB�b�9CPxS H ;=9g^[>@b=b@��MOD�^@9:D�Bf;�SCb�B»É�w W á-b=X HZH 9:;=Bfb�D F ^[>@?A��Bf`Z>½jZ>Â8:>@?A9 H J�>@D�BL9CP�b�BaSUB F ^½b��gb�B�>[Jb=B�;=XZ^[BfXZ;f>[bGSCDQjåB�`Q>sjZ>[bf^@; FIH B F 9:DÅ9CP3bf> � XZ>[D�B F SU?3SCDQj0^@9CDZ^@XZ;=;f>[DYBGo�>[`kS»8 F 9:;@�Ô�d9r�z>Â8:>[;@É�8C>@; FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:DSCDZj�SCDkSC?Ä�gb F bGBf>@^a`ZD F�� XZ>@bsSC;f>L;�SU;f>@?Ä��jZXZ>LB�9ÅS²?I>[bfb�PR9:;fJÁSC?3oZSCb F b@��Md� F ?A?&j F bf^@XQbfb F DòJÁ9:;=>�jZ>[B�S F ?F D ïz`kS H Bf>@;�.ò`Q9���PéSC;�>Âì F b�B F DZ<�b H >[^ FÄÀ ^»SUB F 9:D�Bf>@^a`ZD F�� XZ>@b�PR9:;Lj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jãb=�_b=Bf>@J�bTbfSUB F b=P��­Bf`Z>SCb H >@^ÂB�b���`Z>@D­Md;f>[?~SUBf>�Js� F D�B�>[<:;�StB�>@j�S HZH ;f9�SC^a`ò9CPz<:;�S H `òBf;�SCDZb�PR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:D�SCDQjòBf>@J H 9:;fSC?&?A9:< F ^� F B�`å>Âì F b�B F DZ<Tb H >[^ FAÀ ^»SUB F 9:DÅB�>@^a`QD F�� XZ>[b¾PR9:;xj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j0b��_b=B�>[JÁb[�dM'`ZSr8C>s^a`Z9Cbf>@D�SÁ^@9:J�o F DkSUB F 9:D9CPG<:;fS H `ãB�;fSCDZb=PR9C;fJÁSUB F 9:D�SCDZjãB�>@J H 9:;�SC?'?A9:< F ^TPR9:;�B�`Z>Åb H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:D�9CP]S�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�b=�_b=Bf>@JÅÉb F DQ^@>�<:;fS H `©Bf;�SCDZb�PR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:DåbfX HZH 9:;�B�bGB�`Q>�b=B�SUB F ^»SC?3SCb¾�e>@?I?3SCbGB�`Q>sB�;fSCDZb=PR9C;fJÁSUB F 9:DkSC?vSCb H >[^[B�b F DSCD F D�BfX F B F 8:>UÉ�<C;�S H ` F ^»SU?3SCDQj0PR9:;fJÁSC?â�zSr�©SCDZj0Bf`Z>�;=>@bf>@SC;f^a` F D0B�>[J H 9:;�SU?v?A9:< F ^ H ;=9r8 F jZ>@b¾XZb¾� F Bf`8CSU; F 9CXZb�SCDkSC?Ä�_b F bÔBf>@^a`ZD F�� XZ>@bdSCDZj²B�9_9:?AbzB�9Lb H >@^ F P��²SUDZjå^a`Q>@^ V²H ;f9 H >[;=B F >@b'9CP3SLb=�_b=Bf>@JÅ�#R¯*#V¯*# =?)éµ[úrû;) ù ´âúr¸�'z@¿û�¶ 9 6�Bzû�¶k¹vµ@ºC%�ût·1¶Qú&)D%n¹u'`Z>xSC?I<:>[oZ;�S F ^ÔS HZH ;f9:SC^a`L9CPä<C;�S H `�Bf;�SCDQb=PR9:;=JTSUB F 9:Ds`kSCb}on>@>@D�jZ>Â8:>@?A9 H >@j F D�B�`Q>'>»SC;=?A��bf>[8C>@D�B F >@beoY�|�`Q; F <QÉ � PR>@DZjQ>@;�SCDZjÅh_^a`ZDZ> F jZ>@;xSCbÔS�<:>@DZ>[;�SC? F {@SUB F 9:DT9CP�ïz`Q9:JÁb V �¿<:;�SUJÁJÁSC;fbeSCDZj½Bf>@;=J�;f>Â��; F B F DQ<

+

Page 10: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

¦ | � hf}CqQÉõæ�9:{»��}&¨ �Å�];�S H `1<:;fSCJÁJÁSC;=b H ;f9r8 F jZ>ÁSCD F D�B�X F B F 8C>LjZ>@b=^@; FAH B F 9:D�PR9C;àBf`Z>ÁJÁSCD FAH XZ?ISUB F 9:D�9CP<:;�S H `ZbTSUDZj <:;fS H ` F ^»SC?'b�B�;fXQ^[B�XQ;f>@b½SCb�Bf`Z>[��9_^@^[XZ; F D H ;=9:<:;fSCJÁJ F DQ<�?~SCDZ<CXkSC<:>²bf>[JTSUDYB F ^[b@É'jkSUB�SokSCbf>[b@ÉZ9 H >[;�SUB F DZ<àb=�_b=Bf>@J�b@ÉZ;=XZ?I>dokSCb=>@j½b��gb�B�>[JÁb�SCDQjT8USC; F 9:XZb V_F DZjZbe9CP,bf9CP�BO�zSC;=>]SCDZj¦É_?~SUb=BeoZXQB'DZ9UB?I>»SUb=B»É_j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@jTb=�_b=Bf>@J�b@� W S F DZ?A�CÉ_Bf`Z>¾<:;fS H `TBf;�SCDQb=PR9:;=JTSUB F 9:DÁJÁ9_jZ>[?Ib�PR9:;ej F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j½b=�_b�B�>@J�b^@9:DZ^[>@D�B�;fSUB�>s9:DåBf9 H 9C?I9:< F ^»SC?¦SCb H >@^ÂB�bG9CP&j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j0b��_b=B�>[JÁb¸¦ E�W /`}gÉ �:æx�Qp:Éõ\�áv�à�QpCÉ W0� æx�:��¨¢�ÔMOD¦ u�SC>»��.�¨ É'u�SC>[DYBf{@>[;¿^@9:J�o F DZ>[j b=Bf;fXZ^ÂB�XZ;=>@jÈ<:;�S H `þB�;fSCDZb�PR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:D�9:DþBO�e9�?I>[8C>@?Ab@�èMOD B�` F bÁ�zSr�CÉSC?I?A9g^@SUB F 9:D�9CPâ9Co_ý=>@^ÂB�bÔSUDZjTBaSUb V b@Ég9:o_ý=>@^ÂBz;=> H ? F ^@SUB F 9:D�SCDZjTJ F <C;�SUB F 9:D¦ÉC;f>@J�9CBf> F DYBf>@;fSC^[B F 9:DZb[ÉYJ�XZ?AB F KH ?I>]B�`Q;f>»SUjZb¾9CP3^@9:D�Bf;f9:?�SCDZjÅjQ�_DkSCJ F ^àDZ>[BO�e9:; V Bf9 H 9:?I9:< F >@b'^@SCD0on>àb H >@^ FÄÀ >@j F DåS�;=XZ?I>ÃKOokSCb=>@j0SCDZj<:;�S H ` F ^@SC?ä�zSr�C�#R¯*#V¯�0 Bz¸_· 9 %�û�¶V2n¹®%�¼3)¢üu�>[J H 9:;�SU?�á,9C< F ^ F bsS²b H >@^ F SC?&BO� H >T9CP¾ÜTÛ@ó�ÕCÑ}ÑIÛfÞCР𺦠h_B F ��+gÉõ|}JÁ>@�:��¨¢� W 9_jkSC?}?A9:< F ^��zSCbà9:; F < F DZSC?I?Ä�jZ>[8C>@?I9 H >[j©o�� H ` F ?A9:bf9 H `Z>@;=bxBf9Tb=BfXZjQ�Åj F �ä>[;f>@D�B¾JÁ9_jZ>@?Ab�9CP&B�;=XQB�`ä� � `Z>@;=>»SCb]SUD©SCb=bf>@;�B F 9:D0^@SCD0on>B�;fXQ> F Då9:DQ>»�i�z9:;=?Ijf�ÅÉ F B�^[9:XZ?IjÅon>àPéSC?Abf> F DåSCDZ9UB�`Z>[;x9CDZ>C�ÔMODÅB�>[J H 9:;�SU?¦?I9:< F ^GB�`Q>àBf;fXQBf`å8USC?IXQ>@b�9CPSCbfb=>@;=B F 9:DQb�^a`ZSCDZ<:>�9r8:>[;�B F J�>C� l SC; F 9:XZb3Bf>@J H 9:;fSC?Q9 H >[;�SUBf9:;fb�SC;=> H ;f9r8 F jZ>[j�Bf9�jZ>@b=^@; F o�>xSCDQj�;=>»SCb=9:DSCo�9CXQBL`Z9r��B�;=XQB�`ã8USC?IXQ>@bL9CP¾SCbfb=>@;=B F 9:DQbL8USC;��­� F Bf`�B F J�>C��MNBL�zSCb � DYXZ>[? F�F D�Bf`Z>²?~SUBf>¿bf>[8C>@D�B F >@b¦ � DYXR}`};¨]��`Q9þSC;=<:XZ>[j-Bf`kSUB²B�>[J H 9:;�SU?¾?I9C< F ^©^[9:XZ?Aj-on>òS�XZbf>ÂPRXZ?]PR9:;fJÁSC? F bfJ PR9:;¿b H >[^ F P�� F DZ<�SCDZj8:>@; F P�� F DQ<à^[9:;f;=>@^ÂB�DZ>[bfb�9CPä^[9:J H XQB�>[; H ;f9C<:;�SCJ�b@��u�>[J H 9:;fSC?Z?I9C< F ^ F b&>@b H >[^ F SC?I?Ä��bfX F BaSUoZ?I>zPR9C;'ÎaÍfÕ_ðÂÏéÐ�ÌCÍÙÂê�ÙÂÏOÍÂÜsÙÂÉ F �õ>U��b=�_b=Bf>@J�b@Éä��` F ^a`�jZ9TDQ9CB�ý=XZb�BG^[9:J H XQB�>sS�PRXZDZ^ÂB F 9:DåPR;=9:JSÁ< F 8:>@D F D H XgB»ÉnoZXQB¾��` F ^a`^@9:D�B F DYXZ9:XZb=?A��SCDZj F Ds<:>[DZ>@;fSC?QDQ9:D�B�>@;=J F DkSUB F DZ< F D�B�>[;�SC^ÂB3� F B�`�SUD�>@D�8 F ;=9:DZJ�>@D�B»�&h_BaSC;�B F DZ<dPR;=9:J¤B�` F bokSCb F ^ F jQ>»SQÉâST8USC; F >ÂBO�09CP�Bf>@J H 9:;fSC?3?A9:< F ^@b¾`ZSr8C>�o�>[>@DòjZ>[8C>@?A9 H >[j¦�]á F DQ>»SC;xB F J�>CÉ�oZ;�SUDZ^a` F DQ<²B F J�>CÉ;f>»SU?�B F J�>CÉv?I9:< F ^@b]� F B�`­SUDZj�� F B�`Z9:XgB H SUb=B�9 H >[;�SUBf9:;fb[É3?A9:< F ^[b�;f>[PR>[;f; F DZ<ÅB�9 F D�B�>@;�8USC?Ib�;�StB�`Z>[;àBf`kSCDJÁ9:J�>@D�Bfbe9CP�B F JÁ>�>[Bf^C� l >[; FAÀ ^»SUB F 9:DLB�>[^a`ZD F�� XZ>[bzPR9:;�^a`Z>[^ V_F DZ<�B�>[J H 9:;fSC?ZPR9:;fJsXZ?~SCb}� F B�`�;f>@b H >[^[BÔBf9S�Bf>@J H 9C;�SC?¦J�9_jZ>@?âSU;f> H ;=9�8 F jZ>@j¦Ék9UP�B�>@DÅbfX HZH 9C;=B�>[jåo��ÅS�B�9_9:?¢�

#R¯�0 ¼ ¶f)¢¹!�½¸_µ»´:2�ú�µM H ;=>@b=>@D�B¾DQ9��÷B�`Z>]JÁS F D½;f>[bfXZ?ÄB�b�9CPvB�` F bz�z9C; V ÉZB�`kStBxSC;f>]j F 8 F jZ>[j F D�B�90ðaÛtØäðaÍOÖnÏ*�ZÕCÑgSCDZj�Ï�×kÍaÛtÎaÍÂÏéРðfÕCÑ;f>@b=XZ?ABfb@�#R¯�0�¯*# ��%n¹�ü:¸ 9 ú�´,¶V2Ôû�¸gµ@´�2�ú�µ#R¯�0�¯*#V¯�# ¼ %�'v¸�2*)¢¹,¼½=?)éµ[úrû;) ù ´âúr¸�' 1 �,µ[úr¸_·­µ ù �p=?)¢µÂúrû;) ù ´,ú»¸�'�@¿û�¶ 9 6�Bzû�¶k¹vµ@ºC%�ût·1¶Qú&)D%n¹MNBzb=XZ<:<:>[b=B�b F Bfbf>@?ÄP�Bf9sjZ>[bf^[; F on>�B�`Z>�B�9 H 9:?A9:<C��9CP¦Sàj F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jTb��gb�B�>[J <C;�S H ` F ^»SU?I?A�C��u'` F beS HZH ;=9�SC^a`9g^[^@XZ;=b F DåJTSCD��Å>Âì F b=B F DZ<½S HZH ;f9:SC^a`Z>@bdB�9½<:;fS H `0Bf;�SCDQb=PR9:;=JTSUB F 9:DQb�PR9C;¾J�9gjZ>[? F DZ<Lj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j©b��gbiKB�>@J�b¾¦ Wå� æx�:�QÉ u�SC>»�`.gÉ hg^a`Z�:qQÉ E�W /�};¨àSCDQjèSC?Abf9�Js� S HZH ;=9�SC^a`ÈPR9:?I?A9���b½Bf`Z> F jZ>@S�9CP�S�<:;fS H ` F ^»SC?;f> H ;f>@b=>@D�BaStB F 9CD�9CPeB�`Z>�Bf9 H 9C?I9:<C�C��MdPR9C?I?I9r� F D H SU;=B F ^@XZ?ISC;º¦ W0� æd�C��¨}��`Z>@;=>TS¿j F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j�b��gb�B�>[J^@9:DZb F b�B�bT9UP]^@9:DQ^@XZ;=;f>@D�B H ;f9_^@>[bfbf>[b½^@9CJÁJ�XQD F ^@SUB F DZ<�9�8C>@;Ábf`kSC;=>@j H 9:;�B�b@�Èu'`Z>åj F ��>@;=>@D�B H ;f9_^@>[bfbSCDZj H 9:;=BxBO� H >[bGB�`kStBG^»SUD©9g^[^@XZ; F D0SCD�SC^ÂB�XkSC?vj F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j0b=�_b=Bf>@J�SU;f>sJ�9_jZ>@?A>@j F D©S0ÏéêaÖkÍ�ÞCÎ=ÕÂÖkצõïÔ|�á � �`.�¨¢�u�9�<:9�SC?A9:DZ<�� F B�`F¦ u�SC>@�`.�¨do�9CBf` Bf`Z>åBf9 H 9C?I9:< F ^»SC?ÔSCb��e>@?A?¾SUbÁB�`Q>0?I9_^»SU?'?I>[8C>@?d9CP�S�j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jb=�_b=Bf>@J SU;f> F D�B�>@<C;�SUBf>@j F D19:DQ>Tb=Bf;fXZ^ÂB�XZ;=>C�©MOD�B�` F bsb=Bf;fXZ^ÂB�XZ;=>TB�`Q>½SC?A?I9_^»SUB F 9:D�9CP'jZSUBaSåSCDZj1B�SCb V bB�9 H ;f9_^@>@b=bf>[b F bs>Ãì H ? F ^ F Bf?A�0JÁ9_jZ>@?A>@j¦� � `Z>[;f>»SUb?¦ u�SC>@�`.�¨�B�;f>@SUB�b�9:DZ?Ä� H ?~S F D�<C;�S H `Qb�PR9:;�B�`Z>T?I9_^»SC??I>[8C>@?¢ÉgJs��S HZH ;f9:SC^a` F beJ�9:;f>dSCoZb�B�;fSC^[B F D�B�`Z>xbf>[DZbf>¾Bf`kSUBzS�b H >[^ FAÀ ^»SUB F 9:D�B�>@^a`QD F�� XZ>GJ�9:b�Beb=X F B�SCoZ?A>PR9:;dJ�9_jZ>@? F DZ<L?I9_^»SU?vb�BaSUBf>@bG9UP H ;f9_^@>[bfb=>@b]^»SUD©o�>�^a`Z9:b=>@D¦�]�x9r�z>Â8:>@;[ɦB�`Z>�jZ>@b F <:DZSUB�>[j©b H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:D

q

Page 11: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

B�>@^a`QD F�� XZ>�`kSCb&Bf9 À B F D�B�9GBf`Z>ÔPR;�SUJÁ>Â�z9:; V 9CP�^»StB�>@<C9:;=��B�`Z>[9:;=��¦ c � �`v;¨�SCDZjL`kSUb�Bf9]o�>'^[9g^[9:J H ?I>ÂB�>C�u�9sBf;f>@SUBzBf`Z>Gb H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:DÁBf>@^a`ZD F�� XZ>]XZb=>@j½PR9:;�B�`Z>db H >@^ FÄÀ ^»StB F 9CD½9CPâ?A9g^@SC?�b=BaStB�>@bzJÁ9:;=>GSCoQb=B�;fSC^[Bf?A�SC?I?A9���bGBf9å;=>@XZb=>T>Ãì F b=B F DZ<²b H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:D�B�>@^a`QD F�� XZ>[b@�¿u'`Z>�;f>[XZbf>Á9CPÔb H >[^ FAÀ ^»SUB F 9:D�B�>[^a`ZD F�� XQ>@bs? F >[bF D H ;�SC^ÂB F ^@SC? F D�B�>[;f>[b=B»É F D H SC;=B F ^@XQ?~SC;���`Z>@D�>Ãì F b=B F DZ<åb H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:D�Bf9g9:?AbàSCDZj­DZ>Â�ÇB�9_9:?Ibà`kS»8:>TBf9o�> F D�Bf>@<:;fSUB�>[j F D�Bf9åSUD�>Ãì F b=B F DZ<Å>@D�8 F ;=9:DZJ�>@D�B�¦ á�y9C�x�`/�¨¢�T�d?I?}SU^[B F 9:DZb F D�B�`Q>Áj F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j�b��gb�B�>[JSC;f>àjZ>@b=^@; F on>@j©;=XZ?I>ÃKOokSCb=>@j0SCDZj F DZ^@?AXZjZ>UÉ�PR9C; F DZb=B�SCDZ^@>UÉnBf`Z>à>[8:9C?IXQB F 9:DÅ9CP&Bf`Z>àBf9 H 9:?I9:<U�:ÉZB�`Q>�B�;fSCDZbiKPR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:D¿9CP}?A9g^@SC?âb=B�SUB�>[b@É�B�`Z>à;f> H ? F ^»SUB F 9:D²9CP&jkSUBaS�SCDZjåB�`Z> F ;�J F <:;�StB F 9CD¿9:;'B�`Z>�^@9:J�J�XZD F ^»SUB F 9:D9�8C>@;xbf`kSU;f>@jÅjkSUB�SQ�MOD­Js��S HZH ;=9�SC^a`¦É�B�`Z>Áj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j1b��_b=B�>[J F b�b H >[^ FAÀ >@j­^[9:J H 9:DZ>[D�BO� F bf>ToY�òJ�9gjQ>@? F DZ<²B�`Z>Á?I9_^»SC?o�>[`kS»8 F 9:;�PR9C; H ;=9g^[>@bfb=>@bLbf> H SC;fSUB�>[?A��PR9:;s>@SC^a` H ;f9_^@>[bfb�BO� H >TB�`kStB�JÁSr��9_^@^@XQ; F D�B�`Z>½j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jb=�_b=Bf>@JÅ�Ôu'`Z>s?A9g^@SC?¦on>@`kS»8 F 9C;d9CP&S H ;f9_^@>@b=b¾9CP&S�^[>@;�BaS F DåBO� H > F b�b H >[^ FAÀ >@j©o��ÅS�ÖnÎaÛrðaÍaÙaÙ¾ÞCÎ=ÕCÜ�Ü�ÕCÎPR9:;�Bf` F b�BO� H >d^@9:D�B�S F D F DZ<�Ssbf>ÂBÔ9CPäÖnÎ�ÛrðaÍaÙaÙ�ÖnÎ�Û@ó���ðÂÏéРÛtØQÙ}Bf`kSUBejZ>@b=^@; F o�> F D�B�X F B F 8:>[?A�LSCDQj½<:;�S H ` F ^@SC?I?Ä�B�`Z>TSC^[B F 9:DZbsS H ;=9g^[>@b=b�9CPÔBf` F bàBO� H >½JÁS»� H >[;=PR9:;=Jå�²u'`Z> F D�B�>@;fSC^[B F 9:D�o�>ÂBO�z>[>@D�B�`Q> H ;=9g^[>@bfb=>@b F bb H >@^ FÄÀ >@j�o���SåÙÂêtØäða×_Î�ÛtØkÐÀ¿rÕCϢРÛtØòÎ�ÍÂÑÄÕCϢРÛtØkÉ�B�`kSUBGjZ>[Bf>@;fJ F DQ>@b¾��` F ^a`òSC^[B F 9:DZbd9CPeS H ;f9_^@>[bfb]`kS»8C>LBf9o�>xb=�_DZ^a`Z;=9:D F {@>@j½� F B�`TSC^[B F 9:DZb�9CPâ9UB�`Z>[; H ;=9g^[>@b=bf>@b[��u'` F be^@9:J H 9CDZ>@D�BO� F b=>d?A9g^@SC?kb H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:DT9UP,Sj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j¿b=�_b�B�>@J F bÔj F �ä>[;f>@D�B�B�9�Bf`Z>]<:?A9:okSC?�b H >@^ FÄÀ ^»StB F 9CD¿9CP&S�j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j¿b=�_b=Bf>@J F DYBf;f9_jZXZ^[>@jF D¾¦ u�SC>@�`.�¨¢�u'`Z>sj F �ä>[;f>[DZ^@>�o�>ÂBO�z>[>@D�SÁ?A9g^@SC?âb H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:D09UP H ;f9_^@>[bfb=>@b]SCDQjåB�`Q>s<:?A9:okSC?âb H >[^ FAÀ ^»SUB F 9:D F bxSC?Ib=9;f>[ëZ>@^[Bf>@j F D©Bf`Z>�9 H >@;fSUB F 9:DkSC?,b=>@JÁSCD�B F ^[bG9CP�B�`Q>�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�b��gb�B�>[Jå��M H ;f9r8 F jQ>�S½^@9:J H 9:b F B F 9CDkSC?9 H >[;�SUB F 9:DZSC?3j F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j�b=>@JÁSCD�B F ^[b@ÉâB�`ZSUB F b]^@9CJ H 9:bf>[jòPR;=9:J�Bf`Z>L9 H >[;�SUB F 9:DZSC?&bf>[JTSUDYB F ^[bà9UPeBf`Z>b F DQ<:?I> H ;=9g^[>@b=bf>@b�SC^[^@9:;=j F DZ<²B�9¿Bf`Z>Lb=�_DZ^a`Z;=9:D F {@SUB F 9:Dò;f>@?ISUB F 9:D¦��u'`Q>Á9 H >@;fSUB F 9:DkSC?�bf>[JTSCD�B F ^@b�9CPÔSb F DQ<:?I> H ;=9g^[>@bfbdjZ>@b=^@; F on>@bdBf`Z>à?I9_^»SC?âon>@`kS»8 F 9C;x9UP�S H ;f9_^@>@b=bd��`Z>[;f>�SU?Ibf9�SC?A? H 9Cbfb F oZ?I>�>Á�ä>[^[B�b¾9CP3Bf`Z>>@D�8 F ;f9CDZJÁ>[D�B�SC;=>T^[9:DZb F jZ>@;=>@j1Bf`kSUBsSC;f>L8 F b F oZ?A>LPR9C;�Bf`Z> H ;f9_^@>@b=b@�Åu'`Z>T9 H >[;�SUB F 9:DkSU?}bf>@JÁSCD�B F ^@bà9CPS H ;f9_^@>[bfb]jZ>[bf^[; F on>@b]9CDZ?A�²B�`Q>�?I9_^»SC?,b�BaSUBf>@bG9CP�Bf`Z> H ;=9g^[>@bfb�¦B�`Z>[;f>�jQ9g>[bGDZ9CB]>Ãì F b=BGS½<:?I9CokSC?,b=B�SUB�>U�u'`Z>T^[9:J H 9:b=>@j1j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j�b=>@JÁSCD�B F ^@bà^@9:D�BaS F DZb�B�`Z>Á<:?I9CokSC?&b�BaSUBf>@bs^[9:DZb�B�;fXQ^[B�>[j­PR;f9:J�B�`Z>Á?I9_^»SC?b=BaStB�>@b�9CPvB�`Q> H ;f9_^@>@b=bf>[b@�u'`Z>s^[9:J H 9:b F B F 9:DkSC?ä9 H >[;�SUB F 9:DZSC?¦bf>[JTSUDYB F ^[bd^@SCD©on>�b F J�XZ?ISUB�>[jåo��åSÁ<C?I9:okSU?¦bf>[JTSCD�B F ^@bd9 H >@;�StB F DQ<9:DÁ<C?I9:okSU?kb=BaStB�>@b�o��LXZb F DZ<�SUJTSC?A<�SCJÁSUB F 9:Ds9UP H ;=9g^[>@bfb H ;=9gjZXQ^[B F 9:DZb[�&u'` F beSC?A?I9r��b}B�9à^@9:DZb F jZ>[;e>@SC^a`j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jT^[9:J H XQBaStB F 9CDÁ^[9:J H 9:b=>@jÁPR;=9:J B�`Q>¾?I9_^»SU?k^@9:J H XQB�SUB F 9:DZb}PR;f9:J Sà<:?I9:oZSC? H 9 F D�B�9CP¦8 F >Â���lGF ^[>�8:>@;=b�SQÉ�S²<:?I9:oZSC?&b=Bf> H ^»SCDòo�>Lb H ? F B F D�B�9²?I9_^»SU?&^@9:J H XQB�SUB F 9:DZb F P�Bf`Z>�<:?I9:oZSC?&^@9CJ H XgBaSUB F 9:D F b^@9:J H SUB F oZ?A>d� F Bf`ÅBf`Z>�j F b�B�; F oZXQB F 9:DT9CP�Bf`Z> H ;f9_^@>[bfb=>@b@�

#R¯�0�¯*#V¯�0 @¿û�¶ 9 6(�O)¢¹núr¸Yû 9 û�¸�úr¸�'Bz¸_· 9 %�û�¶V2I¹®%�¼Ã)éü�ºC%�ûdú&6,¸ 1 9 ¸_ü�)D±3ü:¶Qú&)D%n¹å¶k¹:'Ä�¸Yû;)¶±&ü:¶Qú<)*%n¹%nº¤=?)éµ[úrû;) ù ´âúr¸�' 1 �,µ[úr¸_· 4�û&% 9 ¸Yûrú&)é¸_µ

u�9ã;f>@SCbf9CDèSCon9:XQB²b��_b=B�>[J H ;f9 H >@;�B F >@b@Éd^@9:DQb F jQ>@;�SUoZ?I>�>Á�ä9:;�BÅ`kSCb²o�>[>@D F D�8:>[b=Bf>@j F D B�`Z>òSC;=>»S�9CPÏiÍÂܾÖkÛtÎ=ÕCÑâÑIÛfÞCРðÂ�'hYBaSC;�B F DQ<L� F B�` � D_XQ>@? F SLDYXZJ�on>@;x9CP&^[9:DZ^@> H B�b¾SC;f>àjZ>Â8:>@?A9 H >@jåBf9T^a`Z>[^ V B�>@J H 9:;�SC??I9:< F ^�b H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:DZb[�T�GDZ>L9CP�B�`Q>�J�9:b�B�b=B�XQj F >[j1^@9CDZ^@> H B F bLÜTÛ@ó_ÍÂÑ�ða×kÍaðaßtÐ�Ø_Þ�¦ |}J�>»�:�gÉ h_B F ��+&¨ ��uv9bfX HZH 9:;�B�Bf`Z>ejQ>@b F <:DZ>[;�9CPZSdj F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j�b��gb�B�>[J�XQb F DQ<¾j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@jà<:;fS H `�Bf;�SCDQb=PR9:;=JTSUB F 9:D�SU?Ibf9�� F Bf`B�`Z> H 9:bfb F o F ? F B F >[bz9���>@;=>@j F D¿Bf`Z> À >@?Aj²9CP�Bf>@J H 9C;�SC?�?I9:< F ^CÉ_M F D�B�;f9_jZXZ^[>�ÞCÎfÕÂÖk×�ÅOÐ�ØkÏOÍÂÎNÖnÎ�ÍÂÏiÍfóLÏiÍÂܾÖkÛtÎ=ÕCÑÑIÛfÞCРð'SCb�SLb H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:D¿B�9_9:?âSC^[^@9:J H SCD�� F DQ<�;=XZ?I>ÃKOokSUbf>@j²j F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[jÅ<C;�S H `²B�;fSCDZb�PR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:D¦�� ;=9 H >@;=B F >[b�9UPGS�j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j�b=�_b�B�>@J SU;f>²b H >@^ FAÀ >[jþ<:;fS H ` F ^»SC?A?A�òo�� ÞCÎfÕÂÖk×�ÅOÐ�ØkÏOÍÂÎNÖnÎ�ÍÂÏiÍfó�ÏiÍÂܾÖkÛtÎ=ÕCÑÚ»ÛtÎÂܸ�_ÑÄÕtÙÂ� u'`Q>@bf>�PR9:;=J�XZ?~SUb½SC;=>©B�>@J H 9:;�SC?xPR9:;fJsXZ?~SCbÁ��`Z>@;=>�Bf`Z>©8USC; F SCoZ?A>@b¿SC;=> F D�B�>[; H ;=>[Bf>@j-oY�ÞCÎfÕÂÖk×_РðfÕCѾðaÛtØQÙÂÏéÎ=ÕCÐ�ØkÏRÙÂ��hgXZ^a` ^[9:DZb=Bf;�S F D�B F bGý=XZb�B¿S�j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jþ<:;fS H ` > � X FIHZH >@j � F B�`�8USC; F SCoZ?I>SCbfb F <:DZJ�>@D�BfbL��` F ^a` F bLb�SUB F b À >@jþo���S�bf>[^@9:DZj j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�<:;�S H ` F PdBf` F b H ;=9r8 F jZ>@bÁSUB�?I>@SCb=BLBf`Z>b�SCJ�>]b=Bf;fXZ^ÂB�XZ;=>�9CPvB�`Q> À ;fb=B@�

w

Page 12: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

m�9C;�^a`Z>@^ VYF DZ<òBf>@J H 9C;�SC?�PR9:;fJ�XQ?~SCb F DãS�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�b=�_b�B�>@J BO�e9òJTS F D H ;=9:oZ?I>[JÁb�9_^@^[XZ;@�½m F ;=b=B»ÉJÁ9:b�Bz9UP¦B�`Z>¾SCXQBf9:JTStB�>@j�B�>[^a`ZD F�� XZ>[bzPR9:;�8:>[; F P�� F DZ<�Bf>@J H 9:;fSC? H ;f9 H >[;=B F >@b�9CP,b=�_b�B�>@J�b'SCb=bfXZJ�> À D F Bf>b=�_b=Bf>@J�b@�3u'` F bâ^@9CDZj F B F 9:D F b¦9CP�Bf>@D�DZ> F B�`Z>[;âb�SUB F b À >@j F D]j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j]b=�_b=Bf>@J�b�DQ9:; F D]DQ9:DgKOj F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jb=�_b=Bf>@J�b@�xhg>[^@9:DZjäÉnBf`Z>@;=> F bxDQ9Á<:?A9:okSC?âb�BaSUBf>à��`Q>@;f>�PR9:;=J�XZ?~SUbx^@SCDÅo�>à^a`Z>@^ V >@j¦�xu'` F b F bd>[b H >@^ F SC?A?A�S H ;f9CoZ?I>[JåÉ3��`Q>@D­B�`Q>½^a`Z>@^ VYF DZ<�9CPxS©<:?I9CokSC?}PR9:;fJsXZ?~S F bs9UP F D�B�>[;f>@b�B»��M H ;=9r8 F jZ> F D1B�` F b��e9:; V S^@9:DZb�B�;=XZ^[B F 9:D�9CPzS À D F Bf>�J�9gjZ>[?&oZX F ?Ij�X H PR;=9:J�S¿bf>ÂBà9CP�<:;�S H `gK F DYBf>@; H ;f>ÂB�>@j�B�>[J H 9:;fSC?�PR9:;=J�XZ?ISCb@ÉB�`kSUB�bfX HZH 9C;=B�b�B�`Z>Á^a`Z>@^ VYF DQ<�9CP'B�>[J H 9:;�SU?&PR9:;fJ�XQ?~SCb F D1S H 9:bfb F oZ?Ä� F D À D F B�>�j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j�b=�_b=Bf>@JÅ�u'` F b�^@9CDZb=Bf;fXZ^ÂB F 9CDå`Z>[? H b'Bf9�b=9:?A8C>]B�`Z>]BO�e9 H ;=9:oZ?A>@J�b'b=BaStB�>@j0SCon9�8C>C��u'`Z>à^@9:DQb=B�;=XZ^[B F 9:DÅ^@9C?I?~S H bf>[bB�`Z> H 9:bfb F oZ?Ä� F D À D F Bf>�JÁ9_jZ>@?�PR9:;àS²j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j�b��_b=B�>[J7B�9ÅS À D F Bf>�J�9_jZ>@?&o�� F jZ>@D�B F P�� F DZ<²b=B�SUB�>[b��` F ^a`�SC;f>�?A9:< F ^@SC?I?Ä� F DZj F b=B F DZ<CX F b=`kSCoZ?A>�� F Bf`�;=>@b H >[^[BvB�9xS'< F 8C>@Dàbf>[B�9CPg<:;�S H `gK F D�B�>@; H ;f>ÂB�>[jàPR9:;=J�XZ?ISCb@�m�9C;z^a`Z>[^ V_F DZ<�SsPR9:;fJsXZ?~S F D½B�`Q>G^@9:?A?~S H bf>@j À D F Bf>GJ�9gjZ>[?¦SCD�� VYF DZj¿9CPvJ�9gjQ>@?ÄKN^a`Z>@^ V >@;'^@SCD¿o�>¾XZbf>[j¦�MNP&SsPR9:;=J�XZ?IS F b'bfSUB F b À >[j F D½B�`Z>�^[9:?I?IS H bf>[j À D F B�>]J�9gjZ>[? F B F bÔbfSUB F b À >[j0SU?Ibf9 F D½B�`Z> F D À D F B�>G9CDZ>C��MNPB�`Z>�PR9:;fJsXZ?~S F bxDQ9CBxb�SUB F b À >@j F D¿B�`Z> À D F B�>�^@9:?A?~S H bf>@jÅ9:DZ>UÉ�`Z9r�z>Â8:>@;[É�Bf`Z>]PR9:;fJ�XQ?~S�JTS»�¿on>�B�;fXQ> F DB�`Z> F D À D F B�>�9:DQ>C�àMOD�Bf` F bG�zS»�:ɦBf`Z>�^@9:DQb=B�;=XZ^[B F 9:D�9CP�Bf`Z> À D F B�>�J�9gjZ>[?3b=X HZH 9:;=BfbGB�`Z>�^a`Z>[^ VYF DZ<Å9CPB�>@J H 9:;�SC?nPR9:;fJsXZ?~SCb F D F D À D F Bf>]b=�_b=Bf>@J�b@É�oZXQBxjZ9_>@b�DZ9CB H ;f9r8 F jZ>àSL^@9:J H ?I>ÂB�>Gb=9:?IXgB F 9CD¦�m�XQ;=B�`Q>@;fJ�9:;=>CÉrB�`Z>�^@9C?I?~S H bf>[j À D F Bf>�J�9_jZ>@?�b=X HZH 9:;=BfbvBf`Z>�bf>@^[9:DZj H 9 F DYB,9UPZ^a`Z>[^ V_F DZ<¾<C?I9:okSU?CPR9:;fJsXZ?~SCbF D©S�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j©b��_b=B�>[J�SUbd�e>@?I?¢�xm�9C;xBf`kSUB»É�B�`Q>�<:?I9CokSC?¦PR9:;=J�XZ?~S F bxj F 8 F jZ>@j F D�B�9Á?I9_^»SC?âPR9:;=J�XZ?ISCb@�á,9_^»SU?nPR9:;=J�XZ?ISCb�SC;f>xB�>@J H 9:;�SC?kPR9:;=J�XZ?ISCb�Bf`kSUBz^»SCD½on>¾^a`Q>@^ V >[jÅ� F B�`½;=>@b H >[^[BÔBf9�9:DZ>d?I9_^»SC? H ;=9g^[>@bfb[�u'`Z> À D F B�>�JÁ9_jZ>[?e^[9:DZb=Bf;fXZ^ÂB�>[j­� F B�`1;f>@b H >[^[B�Bf9åBf`Z>½<:?A9:okSC?�SCDQj1B�`Z>Á?I9_^»SC?}PR9:;=J�XZ?ISCb F bsXQbf>@j­Bf9;f>»SUbf9:D1PR;=9:J�?A9g^@SC?}b�SUB F b�PéSC^[B F 9:Dò9CPÔBf`Z>T?A9g^@SC?&PR9:;fJsXZ?~SCbGBf9åBf`Z>T<:?A9:okSC?}bfSUB F b=PéSC^ÂB F 9:D�9CPÔB�`Q>T<:?A9:okSC?PR9:;fJ�XQ?~SLoY�åJ�>»SCDZbd9CP�STJ�9gjQ>@?v^a`Z>@^ V >@;@���d<�S F DäÉ F P&B�`Z>�JÁ9_jZ>[?�^a`Z>[^ V >[;à< F 8:>[b]S H 9:b F B F 8:>sSCDZb=�e>@;[ÉB�`Z>�<C?I9:okSU?¦PR9:;fJ�XQ?~S F bdbfSUB F b À >[j¦É F P F B¾SCDZb��z>[;fb]DZ>[<�SUB F 8:>UÉ�B�`Q>�<:?I9CokSC?âPR9:;fJsXZ?~SCb�^@SCD�b=B F ?I?,on>�8USC? F j¦�m�9C;eB�`Q>]?I9_^»SC?nb�SUB F b�PéSC^[B F 9:D½9UPvBf`Z>]?I9_^»SU?nPR9:;=J�XZ?ISCb@É_Me^@SCD²XZbf>�SU<�S F DÁB�`Z>]^[9:DZb=Bf;fXZ^ÂB F 9:D¿9CP,B�`Z> À D F Bf>JÁ9_jZ>@?ä9:;'9CB�`Q>@;�>Âì F b�B F DZ<�8:>@; FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:D¿B�>[^a`ZD F�� XZ>[b@�

#R¯�0�¯*#V¯ y 1 ´v·­·1¶Zû<�X%�º ¼ ¶f)¢¹Æ��%n¹�ü:¸ 9 ú�´,¶V2Ç�½¸_µ»´:2RúrµÈ �í^@9:J H 9CDZ>@D�BO� F b=>�b H >[^ FÄÀ ^»SUB F 9:DÅ9CP�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jÅb=�_b=Bf>@J�b¾o��ÅS�BO� H >à<:;�S H `ÅPR9:;'Bf`Z> H ;f9_^@>[bfbSCDZj H 9:;=B�BO� H >[bxBf`kSUB�JÁS»�½9_^@^@XQ; F D¿B�`Z>�j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j²b��gb�B�>[JåÉnS H ;f9_^@>[bfbx<:;�SUJÁJÁSC;ePR9C;x>@SC^a`H ;f9_^@>[bfb½BO� H >CÉdBf`kSUB¿b=`Z9r��b²`Z9r� H ;f9_^@>@b=bf>[bå9CP]Bf` F bÁBO� H >�on>@`kS»8:>òSCDQjÈS­b=�_DZ^a`Z;=9:D F {@SUB F 9:D;f>[?~SUB F 9:D¦É_B�`kStB�bf`Z9r��b���` F ^a` H ;f9_^@>[bfbdSC^[B F 9:DQb'`kS»8:>�B�9Lo�>�b��gDQ^a`Z;f9:D F {@>[j¦�

È �"^@9:J H 9:b F B F 9CDkSC?�9 H >@;�StB F 9CDkSC?zb=>@JÁSCD�B F ^@b�^@9CJ H 9:bf>[j�PR;f9:J B�`Z>²?I9_^»SU?e9 H >@;fSUB F 9:DkSC?ebf>[JTSCD_KB F ^@b½9CP]Bf`Z> H ;=9g^[>@bfb=>@bÅSC^[^@9:;=j F DZ<­Bf9­B�`Z>0b=�_DZ^a`Z;=9:D F {@SUB F 9:D ;f>[?~SUB F 9:Dä�¤u'`Z>�^@9:J H 9:b F B F 9CDkSC?9 H >@;�StB F 9CDkSC?vbf>@JÁSCD�B F ^@bG^@SCD�o�>s^@9:DZb F jZ>[;f>[j1SC?Abf9TPR;=9:J�S½<:?I9:oZSC? H 9 F DYBG9CP�8 F >[��o���S½<:?A9:okSC?bf>[JTSCD�B F ^@b�XZb F DZ<�SCJÁSC?A<�SCJÁSUB�>[j H ;=9g^[>@bfb H ;=9gjZXQ^[B F 9:DZb[�

È ��;fS H ` F ^»SC?gb H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:DL9CPäj F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jLb=�_b=Bf>@J H ;f9 H >[;=B F >@b}o��L<:;fS H `gK F D�B�>[; H ;=>[B�>[j�B�>@J H 9:;�SC?PR9:;fJsXZ?~SCb[�

È ïz9:DZb�B�;fXQ^[B F 9:D²9CP�S À D F Bf>GB�>[J H 9:;�SU?�<:;fS H `²J�9gjZ>[?�PR9:;�S�b=>[Bx9CPv<:;fS H `gK F D�B�>[; H ;=>[B�>[j¿B�>@J H 9:;�SC?PR9:;fJsXZ?~SCb�PR9C;�b=X HZH 9:;=B F DZ<�Bf`Z>0SUXQB�9:JÁSUB F ^T8C>@; FÄÀ ^»StB F 9CD 9CP¾<:;�S H `gK F D�B�>@; H ;f>ÂB�>[j PR9:;=J�XZ?~SUb�oY�JÁ>@SCDZb'9CP3SLJÁ9_jZ>@? KO^a`Z>[^ V >[;@�

È �.^»SCb=>Lb=B�XQjQ��9CPzS¿j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�^@9:D À <:XZ;fSUB F 9:D�JTSUDkSC<:>[JÁ>[DYBGb=�_b=Bf>@J�PR9:;GBf>@b=B F DZ<ÅSCDQj�8USC? F KjkSUB F DZ<�Bf`Z>�^@9:DZ^[> H BfXkSC?,;f>[bfXZ?ÄB�b�9CPvB�`Z>]Bf`Z>@b F b@�

v

Page 13: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

#R¯�0�¯�0 ¼ ¶V)é¹�B�6,¸�%nû�¸�ú&)éü:¶V2��T¸gµ@´�2�ú�µ#R¯�0�¯�0�¯�# =�)éµ[úrû;) ù ´âúr¸�'!@¿û�¶ 9 6�Bzû�¶k¹�µ[ºC%�ûU·�¶Qú&)D%�¹u'`Z>¾B�9 H 9:?A9:< F ^»SC?Zb�B�;=XZ^[BfXZ;f>�SCDQj F Bfbe>Â8:9:?AXQB F 9:DT^@SCD¿o�>djZ>@b=^@; F on>@j¿o��T<C;�S H `ÁB�;�SUDZb=PR9:;=JTStB F 9CDZb@��u'`Z>XZbf>'9CP�<C;�S H `�Bf;�SCDQb=PR9:;=JTSUB F 9:DàPR9:;3Bf`Z>Ôb H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:D��zSCb&BaSC^ V ?A>@j F D�Bf`Z>É/:��µõb&o�� E >@<�SCDQ9]SCDZj W 9:D_KBaSCDkSU; F ¦ E�W /�};¨¢��u'`Z>Â��J�9gjZ>[?3B�`Q>LBf9 H 9:?I9:< F ^»SU?�SUDZj�B�>@J H 9:;�SC?&SCb H >@^ÂB�b�9CPzS²j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j�b=�_b=Bf>@JÅÉoZXQB]SUoZb=Bf;�SC^ÂBGPR;f9:J"Bf`Z>�SC^ÂB�XkSU?�b�BaSUBf>@bG9CP H ;f9_^@>@b=bf>[b@�]u'`Z> F jZ>»SUb¾`kS»8:>�on>@>[D©>Âì_Bf>@DZjZ>[j�o�� W 9:D�BaS�KDkSC; F SCDZj­æx9:b=b F�F Dz¦ W0� æx�:��¨�B�9©SÅ8:>@;=b F 9:D­on> F DQ<©JÁ9C;f>ÁS HZH ? F ^»SUoZ?I>�B�90j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j1b��_b=B�>[JÁb[�©MOD¦ u�SC>»��.�¨ ÉUu3SU>@D�B�{[>@;�B�S V >[b&X H B�`Z> F jZ>@SCb,9CP�Sd<C;�S H ` F ^»SU?�jZ>@b=^@; FAH B F 9:D�SUDZj�Bf;�SCDZb�PR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:D�9CPQo�9CBf`�Bf`Z>B�9 H 9:?I9C<C�ÅSCDZj�?A9g^@SC?,b=BaStB�>@b�SUDZj©^@9CJ�o F DQ>@bGon9CB�`0?I>[8C>@?Ab¾B�9¿SUD�S HZH ;=9�SC^a`�^»SU?I?I>[j�óCÐIÙÂÏéÎÃÐéÿ��gÏOÍfóTÞCÎ=ÕÂÖk×Ï¢Î=ÕCØQÙRÚ»ÛtÎÃÜ�ÕCϢРÛtØk�©�d>@;�S HZH ;=9�SC^a` F b�JÁ9C;f>Tb=X F B�SCoZ?A>ÁPR9:;sSCD�>»SC;=?A�òb=B�SC<:>½9UP�b=�_b=Bf>@J jZ>Â8:>[?I9 H J�>@D�B@É��`Z>@;=>sS�<:?A9:okSC?n8 F >[�è9:DÅBf`Z>]��`Z9:?A>]b=�_b=Bf>@J F b'jZ>[b F ;�SCoZ?A>GB�9L<:>ÂBxSCDå9r8C>@;=8 F >[���M]<:>[B�J�� F DZb HQF ;�StB F 9CD1JÁS F DZ?Ä�©PR9:;=J Bf`Z>@b=>½BO�z9�S HZH ;f9:SC^a`Z>@b�Bf9©jZ>Â8:>@?A9 H S0DZ>Â��S HZH ;f9:SC^a`�^»SC?A?I>[jóCÐIÙÂÏ¢ÎÃÐéÿ��_ÏiÍfó�ÞCÎ=ÕÂÖk× Ï¢Î=ÕCØQÙRÚ»ÛtÎÃÜ�ÕCϢРÛtØkÉeB�9_9ZÉ'>[8C>@D F PGJs� S HZH ;=9�SC^a` <:9_>@bÁo�>Â�:9:DZj Bf`Z>©S HZH ;f9:SC^a` 9CPu3SC>[D�B�{@>[;@���d9r�e>[8C>@;@É�M V >@> H Bf`Z>GDZ9CB F 9:DT9CP,j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j½<C;�S H `ÁB�;�SUDZb=PR9:;=JTStB F 9CDTon>@^»SUXZbf>]9CP,` F b=Bf9:;�KF ^»SU?¦;f>@SCbf9:DQb@��CXZb=BLSUb?¦ Wå� æx�:��¨¢É}M�^@9:DQb F jQ>@;�S0j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j�b=�_b=Bf>@J ^@9:DZb F b�B F DQ<©9CPx^@9:DQ^@XZ;=;f>@D�B H ;=9g^[>@b=bf>@bL^[9:JLKJ�XZD F ^»SUB F DZ<Á9�8C>@;]b=`kSC;f>[j H 9:;�B�b[�à�CXZb=BàSCb¸¦ u�m&\ l �:�QÉ u3SC>@�`.�¨¢É¦M F D�B�>[<:;�StB�>sBf`Z>�?I9_^»SU?�b�BaSUBf>@b F DåB�` F bB�9 H 9:?I9C< F ^@SC?�jQ>@bf^[; FAH B F 9:D¦���d9r�e>[8C>@;@É F D²^[9:D�B�;�SUb=B�B�9Y¦�u�m&\ l �:�QÉ u�SC>»�`.;¨ ÉZ?A9g^@SC?¦b�BaSUBf>@b�^»SCDÅon>àb H >[^ F KÀ >@jÅo��²9:o_ý=>@^ÂB�b�9CP&SCDÅSC;fo F B�;fSC;=�T^@9_^@9:J H ?I>ÂB�>G^@SUB�>[<:9:;��:�u'`Z>�b H >@^ FÄÀ ^»StB F 9CD�9CP¦SGj F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jLb=�_b=Bf>@J.^@9CDYB�S F DQb�SLØäÍÂÏ*ÊzÛtÎ�ß�ÏéêÃÖkÍzÞCÎ=ÕÂÖk×_É:B�`ZSUB F b[ÉYSGBO� H >�<:;�S H `¦õïÔ|�á � �`.�¨¦;=> H ;=>@b=>@D�B F DZ<�B�`Z> H ;f9_^@>[bfb�SCDZj H 9:;�BzBO� H >@bÔB�`ZSUBÔJÁS»�Á9_^@^[XZ; F DTB�`Z>¾j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j½b��gb�B�>[JSCDZj�B�`Z>�^[9:DZDZ>[^[B F 9:DZb�SU?I?I9r�e>@j¦��u'`Z>�B�9 H 9:?A9:<C�Å9CP�B�`Z>�j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j�b=�_b=Bf>@J F b¾JÁ9_jZ>@?A>@j�o��0BO� H >@j<:;�S H `Zbd� F B�`©;=>@b H >@^ÂBGB�9ÁB�`Z>�DZ>[BO�e9:; V BO� H >�<C;�S H `ä�¾mk9:;x>»SC^a` H ;f9_^@>@b=b¾BO� H > F D0Bf`Z>sDZ>ÂBO�z9C; V BO� H ><:;�S H `¦ÉnSLÖnÎ�ÛrðaÍaÙaÙGÞCÎfÕCÜ�Ü�ÕCÎ F bx< F 8C>@D¦�'� H ;f9_^@>[bfbG<C;�SCJ�JTSU;zPR9:;dS H ;=9g^[>@bfbxBO� H > H ;f9r8 F jZ>[bGS�bf>[B¾9CPÖnÎaÛrðaÍaÙaÙ�ÖnÎ�Û@ó��kðÂϢРÛtØQÙdSCDQj�SÅÙÂÏ ÕCÎÂÏvÖnÎaÛ@ó��kðÂÏéРÛtØk� � ;f9_^@>[bfb H ;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:DZbdb H >@^ F P��ÅB�`Z> H 9:b=b F oZ?I>�JÁ9r8:>[b9CP,B�`Z> H ;=9g^[>@b=bdSUDZj¿B�`Z>]b�BaSC;�B H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CD¿b=BaSU;=B�bÔBf`Z> H ;=9g^[>@bfbxSCDQj F D F B F SC? F {[>@b F B@�&� H ;f9_^@>[bfb�J�9�8C>JTS»�0S��ä>[^[B]Bf`Z>�B�;fSCDZb=PR9C;fJÁSUB F 9:D09CP�Bf`Z>�B�9 H 9:?A9:<C�Å9:;¾Bf`Z>�B�;fSCDZb=PR9C;fJÁSUB F 9:D09CP F B�bG?A9g^@SC?3b�BaSUBf>C��m�9C;B�`Z>]S HZH ? F ^»SUB F 9:DÁ9CPvS H ;=9g^[>@bfb H ;f9_jZXZ^[B F 9:D¿9CDZ?A�LB�`Q>G?I9_^»SC?nb=B�SUB�>]9UP,9:DZ> H ;=9g^[>@b=b F bzDZ>[^@>[bfb�SU;=�:É F �õ>U�gMjZ9�DZ9CBzDZ>@>[jåS�<C?I9:okSU?n8 F >Â�-9:D½B�`Z>¾j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j½b��gb�B�>[J�PR9:; F B�bÔS HZH ? F ^»SUB F 9:Dä�3mk;f9CJ Bf`Z>¾8 F >Â� H 9 F D�B9CP�9:oYý=>@^[B�KO9:; F >[DYBf>@j*J�9_jZ>@? F DZ<ZÉdS H ;f9_^@>[bfb©<:;fSCJ�JTSC;T^»SCD÷o�>òbf>[>@D¤SCbåS ^[?~SCb=b@�"|�SC^a` F DZb�BaSCDZ^[>9CPGS H ;=9g^[>@b=bÁ<:;fSCJ�JTSC;�<:>[Bfb�B�`Z>�� H ;=9:<:;fSCJ��0b H >@^ FÄÀ >@j F D­Bf`Z> H ;f9_^@>[bfb�<:;�SCJ�JÁSC;@�òM H ;=9r8 F jZ>ÅSDkSCJ�>àb H SC^[>�PR9:;'B�`Q> H ;=9g^[>@b=b F DQb=BaSUDZ^@>[bdPR9:;�>»SU^a` H ;f9_^@>[bfbxBO� H >C�'u'`Q>�b��gDQ^a`Z;f9:D F {»StB F 9CD09CP H ;f9_^@>[bfbF DZb�BaSCDZ^[>@b F bG< F 8C>@D�o���S0ÙÂêtØäða×_Î�ÛtØkÐÀ¿rÕCϢРÛtØ�ÙÂê�ÙÂÏOÍÂÜ�ÉäBf`kSUB]jZ>ÂB�>[;fJ F DZ>[b¾��` F ^a` H ;=9g^[>@b=b H ;f9_jZXZ^[B F 9:DQb9CP¦��` F ^a` H ;=9g^[>@bfb F DZb�BaSCDZ^[>@be`kS»8:>¾Bf9son>db��gDQ^a`Z;f9:D F {@>[j²SCDZj½9r8C>@;e��` F ^a`½jkStBaSàBf`Z>xb=�_DZ^a`Z;=9:D F {@SUB F 9:DBaS V >@b H ?ISC^@>U�3�¾?ÄB�9:<C>[B�`Q>@;@É:SGj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�b=�_b�B�>@J F b&b H >[^ FAÀ >@jLo���SLóCÐIÙÂÏéÎÂÐéÿ��_ÏOÍfó�ÙÂê�ÙÂÏOÍÂÜ)ÙOÖkÍaðÂÐ ËÔðfÕCÏéРÛtØ^@9:DZb F b�B F DQ<½9CPeS½DZ>[BO�e9:; V BO� H >�<:;fS H `¦É¦S H ;f9_^@>[bfb�<:;fSCJÁJÁSC;dSCDZj�S½DkSUJÁ>�b H SC^[>�PR9:;¾>@SC^a` H ;f9_^@>[bfbBO� H > F D¿B�`Q>àDQ>[BO�e9:; V BO� H >�<:;fS H `ÅSCDZjåS�b=�_DZ^a`Z;=9:D F {»SUB F 9:DÅ;f>[?~SUB F 9:D¦�M¾jZ> À DZ>ÁBf`Z>Lbf>[JTSCD�B F ^@bà9CPzSÅj F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j�b��_b=B�>[J b H >@^ FÄÀ ^»StB F 9CD�o��ãÏéÎfÕCØQÙRÚ»ÛtÎÃÜ�ÕCÏéРÛtØ�ÙÂêrÙÂÏiÍÂÜsÙÂÉ F DgKB�;f9_jZXZ^[>@j F DƦõ��æx�`/QÉô�àæx�:��¨¢�ãu�;fSCDZb=PR9C;fJÁSUB F 9:Dãb=�_b=Bf>@J�b½SC;=>åS�^@9CJÁJ�9:Dãbf>[JTSCD�B F ^»SU?ÔPR;�SCJ�>[�e9:; VF Dã��` F ^a` b H >[^ FÄÀ ^»SUB F 9:DãB�>[^a`ZD F�� XQ>@b½^@SCDþon> F DYBf>@; H ;f>ÂB�>@jäÉ F D H SC;=B F ^[XZ?~SC;LSU?Ibf9òj F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j <:;�S H `B�;�SUDZb=PR9:;=JTStB F 9CD¦�su'` F bGPéSC^[B�>[DkSCoZ?A>@b]B�9²XZb=>�Bf`Z>�;f>[bfXZ?ÄB�b]PR9:;GBf`Z>L^@9:J H 9Cb F B F 9:D09CPeBf;�SCDQb=PR9:;=JTSUB F 9:Db=�_b=Bf>@J�bGB�9½b H >[^ F P��0S½^@9CJ H 9:b F B F 9:DkSC?âb=>@JÁSCD�B F ^[b¾PR9:;¾STj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�b��gb�B�>[Jå�]u'`Z>�j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j©bf>ÃKJTSCD�B F ^@bePR9:;'S�j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j²b��gb�B�>[J�b H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:D F bÔ^[9:J H 9:b=>@j¿PR;f9CJ Bf`Z>]B�;�SUDZb=PR9:;=JTStB F 9CDTb=�_b�B�>@J�bPR9:;'B�`Z>àb F DZ<:?I> H ;=9g^[>@b=b F DQb=BaSUDZ^@>[b@Én^»SC?A?I>@j­ÛaÖkÍÂØTÖnÎ�ÛrðaÍaÙaÙ]ÙrÍÂÜ�ÕCØkÏéРðaÙÂ�zu'`Z>�9 H >[D H ;f9_^@>@b=b¾b=>@JÁSCD�B F ^[b9CP'S H ;=9g^[>@bfb F DZb�BaSCDQ^@> F DZ^[?IXZjQ>@b]B�`Z>�on>@`kS»8 F 9:;�9CPzS H ;f9_^@>[bfb F DZb�BaSCDZ^[>Á<C>@DZ>[;�SUBf>@j1o���Bf`Z> H ;f9_^@>[bfb

.

Page 14: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CDZb�9UP'B�`Z>Á^@9:;=;f>@b H 9CDZj F DQ< H ;f9_^@>[bfb�<C;�SCJ�JTSU;�SCDZj�SC?A? H 9:b=b F oZ?I>�>���>@^ÂB�b�9CPzB�`Z>½>[D�8 F ;f9:D_KJÁ>[DYB¾9:D H 9:;�B�b@�xu'`Z>�^[9:J H 9:b F B F 9:DÅ9CP&Bf`Z>�Bf;�SCDZb�PR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:DÅb=�_b=Bf>@J�b¾PR9:;�B�`Z> H ;f9_^@>[bfb F DZb=B�SCDZ^[>@b F bF DZjZXQ^@>@jòo��©B�`Q>�b��_DZ^a`Z;f9CD F {@SUB F 9:D�;=>@?ISUB F 9:D¦�su'` F b];f>[?~SUB F 9:D�jQ>[B�>[;fJ F DZ>[b�`Z9r� B�`Q>LBf;�SCDQb=PR9:;=JTSUB F 9:Db=�_b=Bf>@J�b¾SC;=>]^@9:DQDZ>@^ÂB�>@jä�MOD H ;f>[8 F 9:XZb½�e9:; V b¿B�9�j F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j-<C;�S H ` Bf;�SCDQb=PR9:;=JTSUB F 9:D̦ u�m&\ l �:�QÉ u3SC>@�`.�¨¢ÉxBf`Z>�9 H >@;fSUB F 9:DkSC?bf>@JÁSCD�B F ^@bÁ9CPGB�`Q>0j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j b=�_b=Bf>@J F b�< F 8C>@D o��ãB�`Z>©S HZH ? F ^»StB F 9CD�9UP]<:?I9CokSC? H ;=9gjZXQ^[B F 9:DZbÁ9:D<:?I9:oZSC?ej F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j�b=�_b=Bf>@J b�BaSUBf>@b[��Mà;f>[?~SUBf>ÁB�` F b�S HQH ;f9�SU^a`�9UP¾S©<C?I9:okSU?�9 H >[;�SUB F 9:DkSU?eb=>@JÁSCD�B F ^[bB�9½B�`Q>�^@9:J H 9Cb F B F 9:DZSC?â9 H >@;�StB F 9CDkSC?vbf>@JÁSCD�B F ^@b[ɦ��`Z>@;=>LSC?I?�S HZH ? F ^@SUB F 9:DZb¾9UP H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CDZb]SC;=>�?I9_^»SC?B�9T?A9g^@SC?,b=B�SUB�>[b@�¾u'`Q>�<:?I9CokSC?,9 H >@;�StB F 9CDkSC?âbf>[JTSUDYB F ^[bdPR9:;dSTj F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@jåb=�_b=Bf>@J�b H >@^ FÄÀ ^»StB F 9CD F b¾SB�;�SUDZb=PR9:;=JTStB F 9CDòb��_b=B�>[J <:>@DZ>[;�SUBf>@j­o���SCJÁSC?I<:SCJTStB�>@j H ;f9_^@>[bfb H ;f9_jZXZ^[B F 9:DäÉv��`Z>[;f>�B�`Z>�b=�_DZ^a`Z;=9UKD F {@SUB F 9:D�;f>@?ISUB F 9:D F DZjQXZ^@>[bà��` F ^a` H ;=9g^[>@b=b H ;=9gjZXQ^[B F 9:DZb�9CPÔ��` F ^a` H ;f9_^@>@b=b F DZb=B�SCDZ^@>[b�`ZSr8C>ÁBf9åon>SCJTSU?I<�SCJÁSUBf>@j¦� u'`Q>0B�;fSCDZb=PR9C;fJÁSUB F 9:D b��_b=B�>[JÁbÁPR9:;�Bf`Z>0<C?I9:okSU?x9 H >[;�SUB F 9:DkSU?'bf>@JÁSCD�B F ^@bTSCDZjþBf`Z>^@9:J H 9Cb F B F 9:DZSC?&9 H >@;fSUB F 9:DkSC?}b=>@JÁSCD�B F ^[b�SC;=> F bf9:J�9:; H ` F ^UÉ F PzB�`Q>T<:?A9:okSC?�9 H >@;fSUB F 9:DkSC?}b=>@JÁSCD�B F ^[b F b;f>@b�B�; F ^[Bf>@j Bf91B�`Z9Cbf>©^[9:J H XQBaSUB F 9:DQb�Bf`kSUB½^@SCD on>©b H ? F B F Dþ?I9_^»SC?�^@9CJ H XgBaSUB F 9:DZbLPR9:;�B�`Z> H ;f9_^@>[bfbF DZb�BaSCDZ^[>@b[�]u'`Z>@;=>[PR9:;=>CÉâ>»SU^a`�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j©^[9:J H XQBaSUB F 9:Då^@9:J H 9:bf>[j©PR;f9:J"B�`Q>�?I9_^»SC?v^@9CJ H XgBaSUB F 9:DZb^»SCD²on>G;f>[<�SC;fjQ>@j¿PR;f9:JöS�<:?A9:okSC? H 9 F D�B'9CP,8 F >Â�*SCbÔS�<:?I9:oZSC?¦S HQH ? F ^»SUB F 9:D�9CP�SCDÅSCJÁSC?I<�SUJTSUBf>@j H ;f9tKjZXZ^[B F 9:D0SCbd�e>@?A? � lGF ^@>�8C>@;=b�SQÉâS�<:?I9CokSC?,b=Bf> H ^»SUD©o�>�b H ? F B F D�Bf9T?I9_^»SU?v^[9:J H XQBaStB F 9CDZb F P&B�`Q>s<:?A9:okSC?^@9:J H XQB�SUB F 9:D F b'^[9:J H SUB F oZ?I>¾� F B�`¿B�`Q>àj F b=Bf; F oZXQB F 9:D½9CP�B�`Z> H ;=9g^[>@b=b F DZb=B�SCDZ^[>@b@�

#R¯�0�¯�0�¯�0 $ ¹�ú»¸_¼�û�¶Qú&)D%n¹�%�º·@¿û�¶ 9 6zBzû�¶k¹�µ[ºC%�ûU·�¶Qú&)D%�¹�¶k¹:'ÍBe¸g· 9 %nû�¶V2�¹Î%�¼3)éü��;fS H `gK F D�B�>[; H ;=>[B�>[j©B�>[J H 9:;�SU?v?A9:< F ^�b H >[^ F SU? F {[>@b H ;f9 H 9:b F B F 9:DkSC?âBf>@J H 9:;fSC?v?I9:< F ^�o�� F D�B�>[; H ;=>[BaStB F 9CD9:D ÞCÎ=ÕÂÖk×ãÏéÎ=ÕCØQÙÂÐ�ϢРÛtØþÙÂêrÙÂÏiÍÂÜsÙLSCDZj Bf`Z> F ;Lb H >@^ FÄÀ ^»StB F 9CD o��ãB�>[J H 9:;�SU?'?I9:< F ^½PR9:;fJsXZ?~SCb[�þ�<:;�S H `B�;�SUDZb F B F 9CD1b=�_b�B�>@J F bsSåB�;fSCDZb F B F 9:D�b��_b=B�>[J5��`Z>[;f>TBf`Z>½b=B�SUB�>[b�SC;=>Tj F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j1<:;�S H `Zb�> � X FAHZH >@j� F B�`�8CSU; F SUoZ?I>�SCb=b F <CDZJÁ>[D�B�b@�©��;fS H `1Bf;�SCDQb F B F 9:Dòb=�_b�B�>@J�b�`kS»8:>ÁB�`Z>½bfSCJ�>Tj F bf^@; F J F DkStB F DQ< H 9r�z>[;? FIV >]<:>@DQ>@;�SU?¦B�;�SUDZb F B F 9CD¿b=�_b=Bf>@J�b@�m�9C;¾B�`Z>LbfS V >�9CPzS²XQD F PR9:;=J H ;f>@b=>@D�BaStB F 9CD¦ÉvBf`Z>�8USC; F SCoZ?A>@b¾PR9:;=J7S¿<:;�S H `òSCbG�z>[?I?�SCDQj�Bf`Z>�SCbfb F <:D_KJÁ>[DYBfbzSU;f>�;f> H ;f>[bf>@D�Bf>@j¿o��Lj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�<:;�S H `ÁJ�9:; H ` F b=JÁb[�3u'`Z>xb�SUJÁ> F jQ>»S F b�XZbf>[jÁPR9:;�b H >[^ F P�� F DZ<H ;f9 H >@;�B F >@b¾9UP�b=BaStB�>@b]o��©ÞCÎ=ÕÂÖk×_РðfÕCÑ}ðaÛtØQÙÂÏéÎ=ÕCÐ�ØkÏRÙ:�dhgXZ^a`�^@9:DQb=B�;fS F D�B F b�ý=XQb=B�S H SUBfBf>@;fD�b�BaSUBf> Ê F �õ>U�AÉäSj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j¿J�9:; H ` F bfJTË���` F ^a` F bÔbfSUB F b À >[jåo��¿S�b=>@^@9CDZjåb�BaSUBf> F P,B�` F b H ;=9�8 F jZ>@b�SUB�?A>»SCb�BÔB�`Q>àbfSCJ�>b=B�;=XZ^[BfXZ;f>'9UPnBf`Z> À ;=b=B�9:DZ>U�3MOD�B�` F b3�zS»�:É_SG;f>[?~SUB F 9:D�9:D�<:;�S H ` F ^@SC?Q^[9:DZb�B�;�S F D�B�b}^@SCD�o�>'jQ> À DZ>[j¦É�B�`kStBB�XZ;=DZb�9CXQB�SCbsS H ;=>ÂKO9C;fjZ>[;à9CD1<:;fS H ` F ^»SC?&^[9:DZb�B�;�S F D�B�b[�½u'` F b�^[9:DZ^@> H B�`ZSCb�9:; F < F DkSU?I?A�Åon>@>[D1jZ>Â8:>@? K9 H >[j F D¦ � � ��v;¨n��`Z>@;=>]<:;�S H ` F ^@SC?�^@9:DQb=B�;fS F D�Bfbe�e>@;f>]XQbf>@j F DT9:;=jZ>@;�B�9�>Ãì H ;f>[bfb'b=B�SUB F ^¾^[9:DZb F b=Bf>@DZ^Â�H ;f9 H >@;�B F >@b@�}MOD½¦ \�9_^»��.QÉô�d| � ïÔ��}&¨ F BÔ�zSCbx^@9:J�o F DZ>[j²� F B�` H ;=9 H 9Cb F B F 9:DZSC?nBf>@J H 9C;�SC?�?I9:< F ^CÉQSCoZ?I>GBf9>Âì H ;f>[bfb¾SC?Ib=9�jQ�_DkSCJ F ^ H ;=9 H >[;=B F >@b�9CP�b=�_b�B�>@J�b@�W 9:b=Bz9CP¦Bf`Z>¾SUXQB�9:JÁSUBf>@jÁBf>@^a`ZD F�� XZ>@bePR9:;�8C>@; F P�� F DZ<àB�>[J H 9:;�SU? H ;f9 H >@;�B F >@bz9UP¦b=�_b�B�>@J�b'SCb=bfXZJ�>dBf;�SCD_Kb F B F 9:D²b��gb�B�>[JÁb¾� F B�` À D F Bf>�bf>[BfbG9CP3b=BaStB�>@b[�x�d>@DQ^@>CÉnPR9:;xS HZH ?Ä� F DZ<�bfXZ^a`©Bf>@^a`ZD F�� XZ>@b F B F b�DZ>[^@>@b=b�SC;��B�9L^@9:?A?~S H bf> F D À D F Bf>GB�;fSCDZb F B F 9:D¿b=�_b=Bf>@J�bxBf9 À D F Bf>]9:DZ>@b�o�� F jQ>@D�B F P�� F DZ<�b=B�SUB�>[bx��` F ^a`åSC;f>�?I9C< F ^@SC?I?Ä�F DZj F b=B F DZ<:X F bf`ZSCoZ?I>U�å� B�;fSCDZb F B F 9:D1b��gb�B�>[J F b�^»SC?A?I>[j0Úb�gÑ�ÑÒê�Õ�ÿÂÙÂÏ¢Î=Õ_ðÂÏ F P F B F b�^@9:J H ?A>[B�>[?A��^[9:?I?IS H bf>[jF D�B�` F b�b=>@DZb=>CÉ F � >C�ÄÉ F P'SCD���BO�e9 F DZj F b=B F DZ<CX F b=`kSCoZ?A>�b=BaStB�>@bsSC;f> F jQ>@D�B FÄÀ >@j F DòBf`Z>Tb��_b=B�>[Jå�0�GD�Bf`Z>9CB�`Z>[;s`kSUDZj¦É&S²B�;fSCDZb F B F 9:D�b��_b=B�>[J5JÁS»��;f> H ;f>@b=>@D�BLSå��`Q9:?I>�^@?ISCbfb�9CP'b=�_b�B�>@J�b F P F B F bÁÏéêÃÖnРðfÕCÑÔPR9C;B�`kSUBÔ^@?~SUbfb F D½B�`Z>Gb=>@DZb=>]B�`kSUB F B'bfSUB F b À >[b�SsPR9:;fJ�XQ?~S F PvSCDZj¿9:DQ?A� F PâB�` F bzPR9:;=J�XZ?IS F bzb�SUB F b À >@j²o���ÕCÑ�ÑB�;�SUDZb F B F 9CDåb��gb�B�>[JÁbG9UP&B�`kStB¾^[?~SCb=b@�xM H ;f>[bf>[DYBàS�^@9:DQb=B�;=XZ^[B F 9:DåB�`kSUB@ÉnPR9C;¾S�< F 8C>@D F D�B�>@; H ;f>ÂBaSUB F 9:Då9CPB�`Z> H ;f9 H 9:b F B F 9:DkSU?�8USC; F SCoZ?A>@b�SCbà<:;�S H ` F ^@SC?}^@9CDZb=Bf;�S F DYBfb@É H ;f9_jZXZ^[>@bsS²Bf;�SCDZb F B F 9:D�b=�_b�B�>@J7��` F ^a` F bo�9CBf`�BO� HQF ^»SU?�SCDZj�PRXZ?I?Ä�©SCoQb=B�;fSC^[B@� W 9:;f>L>ÂìQSC^ÂB�?Ä�:É,M H ;=9r8 F jZ>�B�`Z>L^[9:DZb=Bf;fXZ^ÂB F 9:D�9UPeBf`Z>�B�;�SUDZb F B F 9CDb=�_b=Bf>@J PR9C;TSCD�� H ;=>ÂKO9C;fjZ>[;ÁB�`ZSUB½`kSUbT?I>@SCb=BÁX HZH >@;Áo�9CXZDZjZb¿SUDZjþM�b=`Z9r�Bf`kSUBÁB�`Z> H ;f>ÃKO9:;=jZ>@;Á9:D

}

Page 15: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

<:;�S H ` F ^@SC?�^[9:DZb�B�;�S F D�B�bÔ`ZSCbÔ?I>@SCb=BÔX HZH >@;Ôon9:XZDZjQb@�}M�SC;f<CXZ>¾B�`ZSUBÔB�`Q>@bf>GBO�e9 H ;=9 H >[;=B F >@b[ÉgBO� HZF ^»SC?äSCDZjPRXZ?I?Ä�0SUoZb=Bf;�SC^ÂB»É,^@9:;=;f>[b H 9:DZj�B�9¿B�`Q>�>Âì F b�B�>@DQ^@>�SCDZj�XZD F�� XZ>@DZ>[bfbà9CP�B�;fSCDZb F B F 9:D©b=�_b�B�>@J7J�9:; H ` F b=JÁbPR;f9:JÇSC?A?QB�;fSCDZb F B F 9:D�b=�_b=Bf>@J�bz9CP�B�`Z>d^@?~SUbfb�B�9�B�`Z>xBO� HQF ^»SU? É�PRXZ?I?Ä��SCoQb=B�;fSC^[Be9:DZ>U�}MODT9CBf`Z>@;��e9:;fjZb[ÉgBf`Z>^@9:DZb�B�;=XZ^[Bf>@j�b=�_b�B�>@J F bdS À DkSC?,9:o_ý=>[^[B F D0S�bfX F BaSCoZ?A>�^@SUB�>[<:9:;��²9CP&B�;fSCDZb F B F 9:DÅb=�_b=Bf>@J�b@� W 9:;f>[9r8:>@;[ÉB�`Z>xb=�_b=Bf>@J F b À D F B�> H ;=9r8 F jZ>@j�B�`kStBzM�9:DZ?A��XZbf> À D F B�>@?Ä��JÁSCD��Lj F ��>@;=>@D�B�^@9:DZb�B�;fS F D�B�b F DLB�`Q>xBf>@J H 9UK;�SC?¦b H >[^ FÄÀ ^»SUB F 9:Dä�}u'`Z>@D¦ÉZBf`Z>]BO� HZF ^@SC?¦b=�_b�B�>@J$^@SCD²o�>�XZb=>@j²B�9L>ÂìQSCJ F DZ>GBf`Z>G8USC? F j F BO� Ê >[D�BaS F ?IJ�>@D�B»ÉBaSCXQBf9:?I9C<C�:É�>[Bf^C�ôËÇ9UP¾PR9:;=J�XZ?~SUbsPR9:;�B�`Q>²��`Q9:?I>²^@?ISCbfbL9CPdb=�_b�B�>@J o���^a`Z>[^ VYF DZ<òB�`Z>Å^@9:;=;f>[b H 9:DZj F DZ<H ;f9 H >@;�BO� F D¿Bf`Z>]BO� HQF ^»SU?¦B�;�SUDZb F B F 9CD¿b=�_b=Bf>@J"9:DZ?Ä�:�Màb=`Z9r��`Q9��ö<:?A9:okSC?}PR9:;=J�XZ?~SUbs^»SUD�o�>½^a`Q>@^ V >[jþo��­J�>»SUDZb�9CP'Bf`Z>½BO� HZF ^@SC?zJ�9gjQ>@? �åu'` F b F bsjZ9CDZ>oY�©j F 8 F j F DZ<TBf`Z>L<:?I9CokSC?�PR9C;fJ�XZ?IS F D�?A9g^@SC?�PR9:;=J�XZ?ISCb]SCDZj�Bf`Z>L<:?I9:oZSC?3j F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[jòb��_b=B�>[J�B�9²bfXQogKb=�_b=Bf>@J�b@ÉG��`Z>[;f>�B�`Z>�?A9g^@SC?¾PR9:;=J�XZ?~SUb½^»SCD-on>�^a`Z>@^ V >@j¦��u'`Q>òb=XZogKNb=�_b=Bf>@J�b©SC;=>�^@9:DZb�B�;=XZ^[Bf>@j F DbfXZ^a`�Så�zS»�:É&B�`ZSUBsBf`Z>½b�StB F b�PéSC^[B F 9:D�9CPxS0?A9g^@SC?}PR9:;fJ�XQ?~S F D1Bf`Z>Tb=XZogKOb��_b=B�>[J F J H ? F >@b�bfSUB F b=PéSC^ÂB F 9CDF DåBf`Z>s<C?I9:okSU?vb��_b=B�>[Jå�GwdDZjZ>[;dBf`Z>�SCb=bfXZJ H B F 9:D09UP}B�`Z>�b�SUB F b=PéSU^[B F 9:D09UP&B�`Z>s?I9_^»SC?¦PR9:;=J�XZ?ISCb F DåBf`Z>^@9:;=;f>@b H 9CDZj F DQ<åb=XZogKOb��_b=B�>[JÁb[É�Bf`Z>L<:?I9:oZSC?�PR9:;=J�XZ?IS½^»SCD�B�`Z>[D�on>L^a`Z>@^ V >@j�o��òS¿JÁ9_jZ>[?}^a`Z>@^ V >@; F DB�`Z>]BO� HZF ^@SC?âJ�9gjZ>[? �#R¯�0�¯�0�¯ y 1 ´v·­·1¶Zû<�X%�º ¼ ¶f)¢¹�B�6v¸�%�û�¸Yú<)¢ü:¶V2Î�½¸_µ»´:2Rú�µu'`Z>�JTS F D¿9:; F < F DZSC?ä^[9:D�B�; F oZXQB F 9:DZbÔBf9�B�`Z>]PR9:;=JTSC? F {@SUB F 9:DTSU;f>C�

È u'`Z>GjZ>Â8:>[?I9 H J�>@D�B�9CPvS�b F DZ<C?I> H XZbf`Q9:XQBxS HZH ;f9�SC^a`½Bf9�^@9:DQj F B F 9:DkSU?nj F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j½<:;fS H `½B�;fSCDZbiKPR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:D½��`Z>[;f>�?A9g^@SC?âb=B�SUB�>[bGSC;=>�b H >[^ FÄÀ >@j©o��Å9:o_ý=>[^[BfbG9CP}S�^@9_^@9:J H ?A>[B�>à^»StB�>@<C9:;=� � � Ê ^ÂPi�hg>@^ÂB F 9:D?wZ�ôq:ËÂ�

È u'`Z> F DYBf>@<:;fSUB F 9:D�9CPâB�`Z>db F DZ<:?I> H XZb=`Z9:XQB'S HZH ;=9�SC^a`TBf9�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j½<C;�S H `�B�;fSCDZb=PR9C;fJÁSUB F 9:D F DB�`Z>&PR;fSCJ�>[�e9:; V 9CPgBf;�SCDQb=PR9:;=JTSUB F 9:D¾b=�_b=Bf>@J�b�9CP W SU;=B F D���;=9:�:>ÂKOæx`Q9gjZ> Ê ^[Pi� E > À D F B F 9:D·wZ�õqQ�,+`+:ËÂ�

È �*^@9CJ H 9:b F B F 9:DkSC?�9 H >@;fSUB F 9:DkSC?nbf>[JTSCD�B F ^@bÔPR9C;'S�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j¿b��gb�B�>[J�b H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:D¿okSCb=>@jÅ9:DB�`Z>e^@9:J H 9:b F B F 9CDà9UPZB�;fSCDZb=PR9C;fJÁSUB F 9:D�b=�_b=Bf>@J�b Ê ^ÂPi�:hgXQoZbf>[^[B F 9:DrwZ�õqQ��wYË,SCDZj�Bf`Z>z;=>@?ISUB F 9:DàBf9dBf`Z><:?I9CokSC?�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j¿b=>@JÁSCD�B F ^[bÔokSCb=>@j²9:D¿SUJTSC?A<�SCJÁSUB�>[j H ;f9_jZXZ^[B F 9:DQb Ê ^ÂPi�Qu'`Z>[9:;f>[J�wZ�õqQ�õq`.�ËÂ�

È MOD�B�>@<C;�SUB F 9:D�9CPeB�>@J H 9:;�SC?3?I9:< F ^�� F Bf` H ;f>ÂKN9:;fjQ>@;fb�SCDZjòB�`Z>L^[9:DZb=Bf;fXZ^ÂB F 9:D19CPzS À D F Bf>�BO� HQF ^»SU?SCDZj¿PRXZ?A?A�¿SUoZb=Bf;�SC^ÂBxBf;�SCDQb F B F 9:DTb=�_b=Bf>@J Ê ^ÂPi�nhg>@^ÂB F 9CD»v_�-+:ËÃ�

È E > À D F B F 9:Dþ9UPàS H ;f>ÃKO9:;=jZ>@;½9r8C>@;¿j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@jþ<:;�S H `Zb@É���`Z>@;=>�?I9_^»SC?�b�BaSUBf>@b²SC;=>�SUBfBf; F oZXQB�>[j<:;�S H `Zb@ÉZBf`kSUB�`kSUbx?A>»SCb�B�X HZH >@;�on9:XZDZjZb Ê ^ÂPi��hg>[^[B F 9:D»vg�ôq:ËÂ�

È ïz9:J H 9:b F B F 9:DkSU?¦8:>@; FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:D0PR9:;d;f>@SCbf9:D F DZ<½PR;=9:J$?I9_^»SC? H ;f9 H >[;=B F >@bxB�9¿<:?A9:okSC? H ;=9 H >[;=B F >@b¾oY�JÁ>@SCDZb�9CPÔB�`Q>ÁBO� HZF ^@SC?ÔSUDZj1PRXZ?A?A��SCoQb=B�;fSC^[B�B�;fSCDZb F B F 9:D1b��gb�B�>[J PR9:;àB�`Z> H ;f>ÃKO9:;=jZ>@;�9r8:>@;sj F biKB�; F oZXQBf>@j²<:;fS H `Zb Ê ^ÂPi�ku'`Z>@9C;f>@J�v_�ôqQ�Äpr��ËÃ�

#R¯ y Ï û�¼n¶Z¹�)DÐ�¶Qú&)D%n¹p%�º�ú<6v¸5B�6v¸_µ7)éµu'`Z>Á;=>@JÁS F DQjZ>@;]9CPeB�` F b]B�`Z>[b F b F b]j F 8 F jZ>[j F D�B�9²BO�z9ÅJTS F D H SC;�B�b@�½ïz`kS H Bf>@;�+¿SCDZj­q²>Âì H ?IS F D�Bf`Z>^@9:DZ^[> H Bfb F DgPR9:;fJÁSC?I?Ä�:É_��`Z>@;=>»SCbGïz`kS H Bf>@;ÑwTSCDZj�ïz`ZS H B�>[;Òv H ;f9r8 F jZ>�B�`Q>�PR9:;=JTSC?¦Bf;f>@SUB�J�>@D�Bd9CP&Js�S HZH ;=9�SC^a`¦�åu'`Z>TBO�e9 H SC;=Bfbs^@SCD­on>T;f>@SCj F DQjZ> H >@DZjQ>@D�B�9CP'>@SC^a`�9CBf`Z>@;[�0��;=>»SCjQ>@;@É&��`Q9:bf> F D�B�>@D_KB F 9CD F b¾b F J H ?A�½Bf9TXZb=>�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jå<:;�S H `0B�;fSCDZb=PR9C;fJÁSUB F 9:D¿PR9:;xBf`Z>sb H >[^ FÄÀ ^»SUB F 9:Då9CP�SÁj F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jb=�_b=Bf>@J bf`Q9:XZ?Ijã;=>»SCj ïz`kS H B�>@;�+�SCDZj�qQ�1u'`Z>²;f>»SUjZ>@; F D�Bf>@;f>[b=Bf>@j F D­B�`Q>²PR9C;fJÁSC?zokSU^ V <C;f9:XZDQj F b

/

Page 16: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

;f>[PR>[;f;=>@jÁBf9�ïz`ZS H B�>[;Çw�SCDZj�vg�&�x9��e>[8C>@;[ÉkSC?Ib=9àPR9C;�`Q>@;uÓt` F J Bf`Z> F DQPR9:;=JTSU?Q^a`kS H B�>@;=bzJÁS»�Lo�>�XZb=>[PRXZ?¢Éb F DQ^@> F B H ;=9�8 F jZ>@bLSCjQj F B F 9:DkSU?�>ÃìQSCJ H ?I>@b[��u'`Z> F DQPR9C;fJÁSC?�SCb��z>[?I?zSCbsB�`Q>½PR9:;fJÁSC? H SC;�B F b�j F 8 F jZ>[jSC<�S F D F D¿S H SC;=B'^[9:DZ^[>@;fD F DZ<�Bf`Z>]b F DZ<:?I> H XZb=`Z9:XQBxS HQH ;f9�SU^a`½B�9�j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j¿<C;�S H `½Bf;�SCDQb=PR9:;=JTSUB F 9:DÊ ïz`kS H B�>@;¸+ F DQPR9C;fJÁSC? É�ïz`kS H B�>@;¸wåPR9:;fJÁSC?�Ë]SCDQj�S H SC;�B�^[9:DZ^@>[;fD F DZ<©B�`Q>½<:;�S H ` F ^@SC?�b H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:D9CP'j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j�b=�_b=Bf>@J H ;f9 H >[;=B F >@b�oY�ò<:;fS H `gK F D�B�>[; H ;=>[Bf>@j1Bf>@J H 9:;fSC?}?I9C< F ^ Ê ïz`ZS H B�>[;�q F DQPR9:;=JTSU? Éïz`kS H Bf>@;|v�PR9C;fJÁSC?�ËÃ��¾bsJ�>@D�B F 9:DZ>[j1SUo�9r8:>UÉ3B�`Q> F D�Bf;f9_jZXZ^[B F 9:D F D1ïz`kS H B�>@;r+åSCDQj­q F b F D�B�>@DQjZ>@j1PR9C;sSÅ;f>»SUjZ>@;���`Z9 F bDZ9CBà�:>[BsPéSCJ F ? F SC;d� F B�`1<C;�S H `òB�;fSCDZb=PR9C;fJÁSUB F 9:D�9:;�Bf>@J H 9:;fSC?}?I9C< F ^UÉv`Q9��e>[8C>@;[É���`Q90�z9CXZ?Ij�? FIV >�Bf9XZbf>�Bf`Z>�S HZH ;f9�SC^a`©PR9C;¾B�`Z>sb H >@^ FÄÀ ^»StB F 9CD©9CP�S½j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j0b=�_b=Bf>@JÅ��u'`Z>[;f>ÂPR9:;f>UɦB�`Z> H ; F JÁSC;��ÅS F J9CPÔB�`Q>@bf>�BO�z90^a`kS H Bf>@;fb F b�B�90>Ãì H ?~S F DòBf`Z>TJÁS F D�^[9:DZ^@> H B�bs9CP'Js�òS HQH ;f9�SU^a` F DòbfXZ^a`ãS²�ÔS»�òB�`kStBF Bd>@DkSCoQ?I>@b¾SÁjZ>[b F <:DZ>@;dB�9TXQbf>sBf`Z>s^[9:DZ^@> H B�b[� E XZ>àB�9ÁBf` F bdJÁ9UB F 8USUB F 9:DäÉZM'jZ9½DZ9UBG<:9 F DåPRXQ?I?,jZ>[B�S F ?F D�SC?I?z^@9:DZ^[> H Bfb H 9:b=b F oQ?I>CÉ�oZXQBÁM�PR9_^@XQb�9CD�Bf`Z>²JÁ9:b�BLDZ>@>[jZ>@jþ9:DZ>@b[� M H ;f9r8 F jQ>0S�^»SUbf>ÂKNb=BfXZjQ��9CPSòj F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j ^[9:D À <:XQ;�SUB F 9:DãJÁSCDkSC<:>[JÁ>[D�BÁb��_b=B�>[J B�`Z;=9:XZ<:`Z9CXQBLB�`Z>²BO�z9 F DQPR9C;fJÁSC?z^a`kS H B�>[;fbÁBf9bfX HZH 9:;�BxBf`Z>�>Âì H ?ISCDkSUB F 9:DZb'o��¿^[9:DZ^[;f>[Bf>�>ÃìQSCJ H ?I>@b[�ïz`kS H Bf>@;Ô+ À ;=b=B�?Ä�0< F 8:>[b�S½oZ; F >[P F DYBf;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CD0B�9½Bf`Z>�^»SCb=>�b=BfXZjQ�:��ce�0JÁ>@SCDZbG9CP�Bf` F bG^@SCbf>�b�B�XZjg�M F D�Bf;f9_jZXZ^@>¿Bf`Z>²b H >@^ FÄÀ ^»StB F 9CD 9CP¾S�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jãb=�_b=Bf>@J o��ãj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�<:;�S H `�Bf;�SCDQb=PR9:;=JTSUB F 9:DF D­PR9:XZ;�b�B�> H b@��|�SC^a`�b=B�> H H ;f9r8 F jZ>[bLBf`Z>²^@9:DQ^@> H B�b�DZ>@^[>@bfbfSC;=��Bf9 H >[;=PR9:;=J SCDZjãXZDQjZ>@;=b=BaSUDZj Bf`Z>b=B�> H �Th_B�> H pLjZ>@SC?Ib]� F Bf`�B�`Z>�B�9 H 9:?A9:<C�å9CPzSÅj F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[jòb��_b=B�>[J SCDZj F D�B�;=9gjQXZ^@>[b�BO� H >@j�<:;�S H `ZbPR9:; F B�b�b H >[^ FAÀ ^»SUB F 9:D¦�}h_B�> H + F b�^@9:DZ^[>@;=DZ>@j½� F B�`LB�`Z>x?I9_^»SC?kjZSUBaS�b=B�SUB�>[bz9CP�B�`Z>xj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�b=�_b=Bf>@JÅ�MOD�Bf` F b H SC;=B�?A9g^@SC?vjkSUBaS¿b�BaSUBf>@b�SC;=>�b H >@^ FÄÀ >@jòo���SUB=B�; F oZXQBf>@j�<:;fS H `Zb[Éâb F DQ^@>�B�`Q>[� À BGo�>[b=B�PR9:;¾Bf`Z>^»SCb=>¿b=B�XQjQ�:�1h_B�> H q F bs^[9:DZ^[>@;fDQ>@jã� F B�`�j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j­<:;fS H `ZbLSCDQj�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j H ;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:DZb�SCDZjB�`Z>�^@9CJ H 9:DZ>[DYBO� F bf>�b H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:D¿9CPvB�`Z>�on>@`kS»8 F 9C;�SC?âSUb H >@^[Bfb F DÅS�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j²b=�_b=Bf>@JÅ��u'`Z>�?~SCb�Bb=B�> H jZ>»SC?Abs� F Bf`­B�`Z>Tb=�_DZ^a`Z;=9:D F {@SUB F 9:Dã9CP H ;=9g^[>@bfb=>@b�SCDZjãon9CB�`­Bf`Z>½<:?A9:okSC?�9 H >@;fSUB F 9:DkSC?eSCDZj­Bf`Z>^@9:J H 9Cb F B F 9:DZSC?�9 H >[;�SUB F 9:DkSU?äbf>[JTSUDYB F ^[b@�ïz`kS H Bf>@;Ôq F b�^@9CDZ^@>[;fDZ>[j½� F B�`�B�`Z>xb H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:DT9UP¦jQ�_DkSCJ F ^xb=�_b�B�>@J H ;=9 H >[;=B F >@b�PR9:;�S�j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jb=�_b=Bf>@J�b H >[^ FAÀ >@j²o��½j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j¿<C;�S H `ÁB�;�SUDZb=PR9:;=JTStB F 9CD¦�3M F D�Bf;f9_jZXZ^@>]<C;�S H `_K F D�Bf>@; H ;f>[Bf>@j½Bf>@J H 9UK;�SC?¦PR9:;=J�XZ?ISCbÔB�`kStB¾SU;f>�okSCb=>@j09CDåj F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[jå<:;fS H `ZbdSCDZjÅj F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@jÅJ�9:; H ` F bfJ�b F D�Bf;f9_jZXZ^@>[j F Dïz`kS H Bf>@;�+g�TMODòB�` F b��zS»�:ÉvB�`Z>�b H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:DòBf>@^a`ZD F�� XZ>ÁPR9C;�Bf`Z>�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jòb=�_b=Bf>@J SCDZjòB�`Z>�;f>ÃK� X F ;f>[JÁ>[D�B�bzBf9 F Bfbzon>@`kS»8 F 9:;e^@9 F DZ^ F jZ>C�3M�>Ãì H ?~S F D¦É_`Z9r�÷<C;�S H `_K F D�Bf>@; H ;f>[Bf>@jTBf>@J H 9C;�SC?kPR9:;=J�XZ?~SUbzSC;=>b H >@^ FÄÀ >@jåSCDZj F D�Bf;f9_jZXZ^@>GBf`Z> F ;'bf>[JTSCD�B F ^@b[É F � >C�QBf`Z> � XZ>@b�B F 9CD¦ÉZ��`Z>@D0S�<:;�S H `gK F DYBf>@; H ;f>ÂB�>@j¿PR9:;=J�XZ?ISF b]b�StB F b À >@j�o���SÅJ�9_jZ>@?¢��u'` F b F DQ^@?IXQjZ>@b�S²oZ; F >[P F D�B�;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:D F D H ;=9 H 9:b F B F 9CDkSC?,B�>@J H 9:;�SC?3?I9:< F ^C�u'`Z>x8C>@; FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:DL9CP¦<:;fS H `gK F D�B�>[; H ;=>[Bf>@jLB�>@J H 9:;�SC?gPR9:;fJ�XQ?~SCb F b�SCjZjZ;=>@bfb=>@bzSCb��e>@?A? ��u'`Z>dJÁS F D�PR9g^[XZb? F >[bd9CD0B�`Z>�^@9:DQb=B�;=XZ^[B F 9:D09CP}B�`Z>àBO� HZF ^@SC?3J�9gjQ>@? ÉkBf`kSUB F b F D�B�;f9_jZXZ^[>@j©o��0SCD©>ÃìZSUJ H ?A>�B�S V >[D©PR;f9:JJs�²^»SCb=>sb�B�XZjQ�C�du'` F b¾>ÃìQSCJ H ?I>�� F ?I?âon>�SC?Ib=9TXZb=>@j0PR9:;x^a`Z>[^ V_F DZ<²SÁ<C;�S H `_K F D�Bf>@; H ;f>[Bf>@jÅPR9:;fJ�XQ?~SLoY�JÁ>@SCDZb�9CP3SLJ�9_jZ>@?¦^a`Q>@^ V >[;dPR9:; H ;f9 H 9:b F B F 9:DkSC?nB�>@J H 9:;�SC?�?I9:< F ^C��¾bÅJÁ>[DYB F 9:DQ>@j÷SCo�9r8C>CÉàïz`kS H B�>@;�w SCDZjÌv H ;=9�8 F jZ>�B�`Z>�PR9:;fJÁSC?GoZSC^ V <:;f9:XQDZj*9CPsJs�ÈS HZH ;f9�SC^a`ä�ïz`kS H Bf>@;¢w�jZ> À DZ>@b�B�`Z>]b F DZ<C?I> H XQbf`Z9:XgB¾S HZH ;f9:SC^a`ÅBf9�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j²<:;fS H `¿B�;fSCDZb=PR9C;fJÁSUB F 9:DT� F Bf`¿?I9UK^»SC? � KNb=B�SUB�>[b@��M�bf`Z9r�)`Z9r� STj F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j�b=�_b=Bf>@J F b¾b H >[^ FAÀ >@j�^@9:J H 9:DZ>@D�BO� F bf>�o���S½j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jb=�_b=Bf>@J b H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:D ^[9:DZb F b=B F DZ<ò9CPGSòDZ>ÂBO�z9C; V BO� H >Å<:;�S H `¦ÉÔS H ;=9g^[>@bfbÁ<:;�SUJÁJÁSC;�SCDQj S�DkSCJ�>b H SC^[>¿PR9:;�>»SC^a` H ;f9_^@>[bfbLBO� H > F D�Bf`Z>²DZ>[BO�e9:; V BO� H >²<:;�S H `þSCDQj S�b��gDQ^a`Z;f9:D F {»StB F 9CD ;=>@?~StB F 9CD¦�1MF D�B�;=9gjZXQ^@>©B�;fSCDZb�PR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:D b��gb�B�>[JÁbÅSCDZj Bf`Z> F ;¿^@9:J H 9Cb F B F 9:D�B�9ãjZ> À DZ>�B�`Z>�^[9:J H 9:b F B F 9:DkSC?�9 H K>@;�StB F 9CDkSC?xbf>@JÁSCD�B F ^@b½PR9:;Tj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j <:;fS H ` B�;fSCDZb�PR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:D¦�¤MLbf`Q9���`Z9r��j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j <:;�S H `B�;�SUDZb=PR9:;=JTStB F 9CD À B�b F D�B�9²B�`Z>�PR;�SCJ�>[�e9:; V 9UPÔB�;fSCDZb=PR9C;fJÁSUB F 9:D�b=�_b=Bf>@J�b�bfXZ^a`­Bf`kSUB�^@9:J H 9:b F B F 9CDkSC?;f>@b=XZ?ABfb]� F B�`�;=>@b H >@^ÂB�Bf9ÅBf;�SCDQb=PR9:;=JTSUB F 9:D0b=�_b=Bf>@J�bs^»SUD�on>LXZbf>[j F DòJ���^»SCb=>TSUb��e>@?A? ��Md^@9:J H SC;=>B�`Z>d^@9:J H 9Cb F B F 9:DZSC?k9 H >@;�StB F 9CDkSC?kbf>[JTSUDYB F ^[be� F Bf`TB�`Q>¾<:?A9:okSC?�9 H >@;fSUB F 9:DkSC?�bf>[JTSUDYB F ^[bz<:>[DZ>@;fSUB�>[j¿oY�SCJTSU?I<�SCJÁSUBf>@j H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CDZb�SCDZj�^[9:DZ^@?AXZjZ>�Bf` F bG^a`ZS H B�>[;�oY�©S¿^@9:DZ^[;f>ÂB�>�^»StB�>@<C9:;=� � XZb=>@j F D©Bf`Z>

Page 17: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

^»SCb=>àb�B�XZjg�²9CP}ïz`ZS H B�>[;·+_ÉQB�`kStB F b@ÉZBf`Z>�^»SUBf>@<:9C;=�½9UP}SUB=B�; F oZXQBf>@j²<:;�S H `Zb@�ïz`kS H Bf>@;¢v�^[9:DZb F jZ>[;fbÔB�`Q> F D�Bf>@<:;fSUB F 9:DT9CP,j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j½<:;fS H `TBf;�SCDZb�PR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:DTSCDZj¿S H ;f9 H 9:b F B F 9:DkSC?B�>@J H 9:;�SC?�?I9:< F ^C��u'`Z>[;f>ÂPR9:;f>UÉvMxb=B�SC;=B]Bf` F b]^a`ZS H B�>[;�oY��S½oZ; F >[P F D�B�;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:D F D©B�>@J H 9:;�SC?�?I9:< F ^C��MjZ> À DQ>�SÁb=? F <:`�B�?A�½j F ��>@;=>@D�B¾DQ9CB F 9:Då9UP�S�Bf>@J H 9:;fSC?âJ�9gjZ>[?,okSCbf>[j©9:D0S H ;=>ÂKO9C;fjZ>[;¾SCDQj H ;f9r8 F jQ>àBf`Z>^@9:DZb�B�;=XZ^[B F 9:DÅ9CP3Bf`Z>]BO� HZF ^@SC?,SCDZj²PRXZ?I?Ä�¿SCoQb=B�;fSC^[B�Bf;�SCDZb F B F 9:D²b=�_b�B�>@J"� F B�`Å;f>@b H >[^[BxB�9�S H ;f>ÃKO9:;=jZ>@;[�u'`Z>@D¦ÉCM¦^@9:DQb F jQ>@;vj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@js<C;�S H `QbvBf9:<:>[Bf`Z>@;,� F Bf`�S�8CSU; F SUoZ?I>�SCb=b F <:DZJ�>@D�B&SUDZjsjZ> À DZ>zS H ;=>ÂKO9_jZ>[;9�8C>@;�B�`Z>[JSCDZjÅbf`Z9r�¤B�`ZSUB�B�` F b H ;=>ÂKN9:;fjZ>[;�`kSCbx?I>»SUb=BxX HZH >@;xo�9CXZDZjZb[�ÔMÔ^@9CDZ^@?AXZjZ>�� F B�`åSCb H >[^[B�bd9CP^@9:J H 9Cb F B F 9:DZSC?¦8:>[; FAÀ ^»SUB F 9:D�SCDQj�bf`Z9r�)`Z9r�)?A9g^@SC? H ;f9 H >@;�B F >@bGSU;f> H ;=>@b=>@;=8C>@j�oY�åB�`Z>s^@9:J H 9Cb F B F 9:D9CP'j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j1b=�_b=Bf>@J ^@9:J H 9CDZ>@D�B�b�SCDZj1`Q9��ÇBf`Z>ÁBO� HZF ^»SC?�JÁ9_jZ>[?�^@SCD­on>TXZb=>@j­Bf90;f>@SCbf9CD­PR9:;fJ?I9_^»SC?�b�SUB F b=PéSU^[B F 9:D½B�9�<:?A9:okSC?�b�SUB F b=PéSU^[B F 9:D¦�ïz`kS H Bf>@;®.Gj F bf^@XQbfbf>[b�Bf`Z>';f>[?~SUBf>@j��e9:; V SCDZjLMv^@?I9Cbf>Ôo�� H ;f>@b=>@D�B F DZ<�B�`Z>'^[9:DZ^@?AXZb F 9:DZb}SUDZj F D�B�>[DYB F 9:DQbPR9:;ÔPRXZ;=Bf`Z>@;'�e9:; V �

pr�

Page 18: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

� � �ö� ���� Õ

ÖF¡j�Ì×�Ø � � ��"ÔÙe�!�Ì Ú Û�Û � � �� Ù i� Ü ¡�"Ñ � ¡�Ý �Ì � �Þ �r� Û¬Ù ß �r� �l" � �¸à � �¡���� á âÆâäã`åKæ�çzè�å®é�ê èÎé çë å:ì�è�í?åÎî�ïðè�ñHò ó é�ê>ô õ«ïlíºçzè�åKépê ö çpê�ç«õ�ñ�÷ ñ�ê�èø�ù ì�è�ñY÷

u'` F be^a`kS H Bf>@; H ;=>@b=>@D�B�b'B�`Q>G^@9:DQ^@> H B�bÔ9CPeóCÐIÙÂÏéÎÃÐéÿ��gÏOÍfósÞCÎ=ÕÂÖk×TÏ¢Î=ÕCØQÙRÚ»ÛtÎÃÜ�ÕCÏéРÛtØ F DTBf`Z>¾b F DZ<C?I> H XZbf`Z9CXQBS HZH ;=9�SC^a`sPR9:;,B�`Q>zb H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:Ds9UP�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jsb��_b=B�>[JÁb[�&u'`Z> F D�B�;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:D H ;f9r8 F jZ>[b3B�`Z>e^@9:DQ^@> H B�bF DQPR9:;=JTSU?I?A�CÉ�bfX HZH 9:;�B�>@jLo��sSG^@9:DZ^[;f>ÂB�>'j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j�b��_b=B�>[J.SCDZj F b&<:X F jZ>@jsoY��SGjZ>@b F <:DQ>@;@É:��`Q9]jZ9g>[bDZ9CB V DZ9r�­<:;fS H `]B�;fSCDZb�PR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:D¾�C>[B�SCDZj F bäDZ9CB,DZ>[^@>@b=b�SC; F ?Ä� F D�B�>[;f>[b=B�>[j F DGB�`Z>}PR9:;=JTSU?UokSU^ V <C;f9:XZDQj¦�u'`Z>¾PR9:;=JTSC?kjQ>@bf^[; FAH B F 9:D½9CPâ9CXZ;ÔS HQH ;f9�SU^a`½^»SCDTo�>d?I9_9 V >[j½X H½F D¿ïz`kS H B�>@;Çw F PâS�^@?A9:bf>[;z?A9g9 V�F DÁBf`Z>^@9:DZ^[> H Bfb F b'jZ>@b F ;=>@j¦�� >d^@9:DZb F jZ>[; F DÁB�` F b��z9:; V j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jTb��gb�B�>[JÁbÔ^[9:DZb F b=B F DZ<�9CPvS�DYXZJso�>[;z9CPâ^[9:DZ^[XZ;f;=>@D�B H ;=9g^[>@bfb=>@bB�9:<:>ÂB�`Z>[;�� F B�`1Bf`Z> F ;s?I9_^»SU?�b�BaSUBf>@b[É���`Q>@;f>T^@9:J�J�XZD F ^»SUB F 9:Dòon>[BO�e>@>@D H ;=9g^[>@b=bf>@b�B�S V >[b H ?~SU^@>T9r8C>@;^@9:J�JÁ9CD H 9:;�B�b@�3u'`Z>xBf9 H 9:?I9:<U��9CP�B�`Z>�j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j�b=�_b�B�>@JÇJÁS»��^a`kSCDZ<C>¾jQ�_DkSCJ F ^@SC?I?Ä��Bf`Z;f9CXZ<:`Z9:XgBF B�b¿? F PR>ÃKNB F JÁ>UÉÔB�`kStB F b@ÉdDZ>[� H ;f9_^@>[bfbf>[bå^@SCD-o�>òSCjZjQ>@j-9:;²;f>@J�9r8:>[j¦ÉGDZ>Â� H 9C;=B�b¿>[b=B�SCoZ? F bf`Z>[j÷9C;>Âì F b�B F DQ< H 9:;=BfbzJÁSr��on>G^@XgB»�}u'` F b F beb F J F ?~SC;3Bf9sB�`Q>GjQ�_DkSCJ F ^x;f>[^@9:D À <:XZ;�StB F 9CD H 9Cbfb F o F ? F B F >@b F DÁBf`Z>©äKO^@SC?I^[XZ?IXZbǦ W0�ª� ��+;¨¢� � >z^»SC?A?_Bf` F b V_F DZj�9CP�S¾j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j�b=�_b�B�>@J$ÛaÖkÍÂØ]b F DZ^@>'SUD F D�B�>[;�SC^ÂB F 9:Ds� F Bf`B�`Z>�>@D�8 F ;=9:DZJ�>@D�BsjQXZ; F DZ<0;=XZDgKNB F J�> F b H 9:bfb F oZ?A>C�¿áâ9_^»SC?}b�BaSUBf>ÁB�;fSCDZb�PR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:DZb]9CPeB�`Z> H ;=9g^[>@bfb=>@bSCDZjTBf`Z>¾jkStBaSsb=>@D�B'9r8:>[; H 9C;=B�beSC;=> F D�B�`Z>d8 F >[� H 9 F D�Be9CPâ9:XQ;zb H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:DÁBf>@^a`ZD F�� XZ>�SCb��z>[?I? �3u'`Z>^@9:J�J�XZD F ^»SUB F 9:DTJTS»�TB�S V > H ?ISC^@>�SCb��_DZ^a`Z;f9CDZ9:XZb=?A�²9:;'b��gDQ^a`Z;f9:DQ9:XZbf?Ä�:�u�9�b H >@^ F P��²S�j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j²b��gb�B�>[JåÉkB�`Q>àjQ>@b F <:DZ>[;'`kSCb'B�9ÁSCDZb��z>[;¾S�? F b=B'9UP � XZ>[b=B F 9:DZb[�

úY%�ûü':%ä¸gµ�ú&6,¸åú<% 9 %32D%n¼V�X%�ºxú<6v¸0µ��,µ[úr¸_· 2D%�%R��2*)D�n¸fý u'`Z> � XZ>[b=B F 9:DLjZ>@SC?Ibv� F B�`�Bf`Z>ÔBO� H >[b}9CPH ;f9_^@>[bfb=>@bGB�`ZSUB H SC;=B F ^ FAH SUBf> F DåBf`Z>sj F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j©b=�_b=Bf>@J�SCDZj0Bf`Z> H 9:b=b F oQ?I> H 9:;�B�b F DZj F ^»SUB F DZ<^@9:J�J�XZD F ^»StB F 9CD H StB�`Zb[�3MNB}`kSUb3B�9Gon>zjQ>[B�>[;fJ F DZ>[j F P�DQ>[� H ;f9_^@>[bfb=>@b}^»SUDdý=9 F DàB�`Z>Ôj F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jb=�_b=Bf>@J�SCDZj¦É F P F B F b H 9:b=b F oZ?I>UÉ�`Z9r��B�` F b¾b=`kSC?I?v`kS HQH >[D¦�]�¾b¾�e>@?A?�Bf`Z>�jZ>[?I>[B F 9:Då9CP H ;=9g^[>@bfb=>@b`kSCb'B�9Lon>GBaSC^ V ?A>@jåSCDZj²B�`Z>�^@;=>»SUB F 9:DÅSCDQjÅjQ>@?I>ÂB F 9:D²9CP H 9:;�B�b@�}�d?ABf9:<:>[Bf`Z>@;[ÉQB�`Q>àjQ>@b F <:DZ>[;x`ZSCbB�9½jQ>[B�>[;fJ F DZ>àB�`Z>�b=B�SUB F ^»SC?�SCb¾�e>@?A?3SCbdB�`Z>�jg�gDZSCJ F ^»SC?vSCb H >[^[BfbGB�`kSUB¾9g^[^@XZ;x� F Bf`©;f>[b H >@^[B]Bf9B�`Z>]Bf9 H 9C?I9:<C�Á9CPvB�`Z>�j F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[jÅb��_b=B�>[Jå�

�þ6:)éü�6X�()¢¹:'!%�º¤'v¶Qú»¶�¶Zû�¸�´vµ@¸�'ªýÈ� ;f9_^@>[bfbf>[b3`kS»8C>�?A9g^@SC?:jkStBaS'b=B�SUB�>[bv9CDà��` F ^a`àBf`Z>[�G9 H >[;�SUBf>C�vMNB`kSCb,B�9xo�>�b H >@^ FAÀ >[j�`Z9r�­Bf` F bvjkSUB�Sx?A9g9 V ? FIV >�SCDZj���` F ^a`sb H >[^ FÄÀ ^»SUB F 9:D�B�>[^a`ZD F�� XQ>zbf>[>@J�b�Bf9don>JÁ9Cb=BebfX F BaSCoZ?A>C� E SUBaS�JTS»�Lon>¾b H >[^ FAÀ >@j½o���<:;�S H `Zb@É H SC;�B F SU?�SC?I<:>[oZ;�SUbe9:;�9CBf`Z>@;�b H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:DB�>[^a`ZD F�� XZ>[b@�'u'`Z>�jkSUB�SLBO� H >@b F D H 9:;�B�bx`kS»8:>�Bf9Áon>àb H >@^ FÄÀ >@j©SCbx�e>@?A? F DÅ9:;fjZ>[;'B�9 H ;f9r8 F jZ>�S^@9:J�J�XZD F ^»StB F 9CD F D�B�>[;=PéSC^[>�o�>ÂBO�z>[>@D H ;f9_^@>@b=bf>[b@�

úY%�ûü':%ä¸gµL¶�µ7)¢¹,¼32é¸ 9 û;%¦ü:¸gµ@µ ù ¸�6,¶�ÿn¸fý MNB&`kSCb3Bf9Go�>e�z9:; V >[j�9CXQB&��` F ^a`LSC^[B F 9:DZb3S H ;=9g^[>@bfb}^@SCDH >[;=PR9:;=J79:D1?A9g^@SC?}b=B�SUB�>[b�9:;�B�`Z>LB�9 H 9:?A9:<C��SUDZj­XZDZjQ>@;���` F ^a`­^[9:DZj F B F 9CDZb]B�`Z> H ;f9_^@>[bfbs^@SCDH >[;=PR9:;=JöBf`Z>@b=>sSC^ÂB F 9:DZb@�p:p

Page 19: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

úY%�ûü':%ä¸gµ�ü`%n·­·�´�¹:)éü:¶Qú&)D%�¹�úr¶f��¸ 9 2R¶kü:¸fý � H ;=9g^[>@b=bGSC^ÂB F 9CDÅJÁS»�¿on>�DZ9UB F DZjZ> H >[DZjZ>@D�BdPR;f9:JF Bfb�>[DY8 F ;f9:DZJ�>@D�B@É:oZXQB F B�`kSCb�Bf9 H >@;�PR9:;fJ¤B�` F b�SC^[B F 9:DàB�9:<:>ÂB�`Z>[;�� F B�`�9CBf`Z>@; H ;f9_^@>[bfb=>@b@�}u'`Q>@;f>ÃKPR9:;f>UÉ�b=�_DZ^a`Z;=9:D F {@SUB F 9:D F bxDZ>@^[>@bfbfSC;=�Å� F Bf` H 9:b=b F oQ?A�¿b=>[8:>[;�SC?�9CB�`Q>@; H ;f9_^@>[bfbf>[b@��u'`Z>àb=�_DZ^a`Z;=9UKD F {@SUB F 9:D²9CP H ;=9g^[>@b=b]SC^[B F 9:DQbd`kSUbxBf9Ton>sb H >@^ FAÀ >[j�SCbx�z>[?I?vSCbdBf`Z>��ÔS»�å`Z9r�í^@9:J�J�XZD F ^»SUB F 9:Dbf`kSU?I?ZBaS V > H ?~SC^[> F D�B�`Z>xb=�_DZ^a`Q;f9:D F {»SUB F 9:D�^»SUbf>CÉ F � >C��9r8C>@;���` F ^a`Áb=B�;=XZ^[BfXZ;f>[beBf`Z>db��_DZ^a`Z;f9CD F {@StKB F 9:D F b H >@;�PR9:;fJ�>@j¦�

EGF b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j]<:;�S H `àBf;�SCDQb=PR9:;=JTSUB F 9:D¾bfX HZH 9:;�B�bâB�`Z>�jZ>[b F <:DZ>@;,9CPQS'j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�b=�_b�B�>@J¤� F B�`�^@9:DQ^@> H B�bB�9½SUDZb=�e>@;¾Bf`Z>@b=> � XZ>@b�B F 9:DZb@�du�9 H 9:?A9:< F ^»SC?âSUb H >@^[BfbG^»SUD©o�>àb H >@^ FAÀ >[j�o���ÏéêaÖkÍfóÁÞCÎ=ÕÂÖk×åÏ¢Î=ÕCØQÙRÚ»ÛtÎÃÜ�Õ�ÅϢРÛtØkÉ_��`Z>@;=>�Bf`Z>]b=B�SUB F ^»SC?äSCb H >@^ÂB F bÔ^[9r8:>@;=>@jåoY�½S½ØäÍÂÏ�ÊzÛtÎ�ßLÏéêaÖkÍdÞCÎ=ÕÂÖk×�SUDZj½B�`Z>]jg�gDZSCJ F ^»SC?äSCb H >@^ÂBoY�åØäÍÂÏ*ÊzÛtÎaßdÖnÎ�Û@ó���ðÂÏéРÛtØQÙÂ�&u'`Z>Gb H >[^ FÄÀ ^»SUB F 9:DT9CP,?I9_^»SC?njkSUB�S�SCDZjÁB�`Z> F ;zJÁSCD FAH XZ?ISUB F 9:D F bzb=X HZH 9:;=Bf>@joY� ÕCÏéÏéÎÂÐéÿ��_ÏOÍfóÅÞCÎ=ÕÂÖk×�ÏéÎ=ÕCØQÙRÚ»ÛtÎÃÜ�ÕCϢРÛtØÅB�`kSUB F DZ^@?AXZjZ>@b]Bf`Z>Áb H >[^ FÄÀ ^»SUB F 9:Dò9CP�B�`Z>�jkSUB�SÅXQbf>@j F D H ;f9tK^@>@b=bf>[bzSCDQj H 9:;�B�b�SCb��z>[?I?kSCb&Bf`Z> F ;&;fXQ?I>ÂKNokSCb=>@j�B�;fSCDZb�PR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:D¦� ��u�9 H 9:?A9:< F ^»SC?_SCb3�e>@?A?kSCb}?A9g^@SC?gb�BaSUBf>SCb H >@^ÂB�b]SC;=> F D�Bf>@<:;fSUB�>[j F D­óCÐIÙÂÏ¢ÎÃÐéÿ��_ÏiÍfó�ÞCÎ=ÕÂÖk×�Ù���` F ^a`�b H >[^ F P��²Bf`Z>sB�9 H 9:?A9:<C�ÅSCDQj0B�`Z>s?I9_^»SC?,b=B�SUB�>[b9CPÔj F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j�b��gb�B�>[J b�BaSUBf>@b F Dò9:DZ>L^@9CJÁJ�9:D�b=Bf;fXZ^ÂB�XZ;=>C�½u'`Z> F ;�B�;fSCDZb=PR9C;fJÁSUB F 9:D F b�jZ> À DZ>@j1oY�óCÐIÙÂÏ¢ÎÃÐéÿ��_ÏiÍfóTÖnÎ�Û@ó���ðÂÏéРÛtØQÙ F DZ^[?IXZj F DZ<²B�9 H 9:?A9:<C�òSCbà�z>[?I?ÔSUbs?I9_^»SU?�b�BaSUBf>TB�;fSCDZb�PR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:DZb[�åu'`Z>To�>ÃK`kS»8 F 9:;Ô9CP3S H ;=9g^[>@bfb F bz< F 8C>@D²o��²SsÖnÎaÛrðaÍaÙaÙ�ÞCÎ=ÕCÜ�Ü�ÕCÎ�Bf`kSUB�^@9CDYB�S F DQbÔB�`Z>]j F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j H ;f9_jZXZ^[B F 9:DQbPR9:; F Bfb]SC^ÂB F 9CDZb@��� H ;=9g^[>@bfb]<C;�SCJ�JTSU;d^@SCD�o�>�b=>@>@DòSCb�S H SUBfBf>@;fDäɦB�`kSUBGjZ>@b=^@; F o�>[b�`Z9r� F DZb=B�SCDZ^@>[b9CPeBf`Z> H ;f9_^@>[bfbào�>[`kS»8:>C�½h_�_DZ^a`Z;=9:D F {@SUB F 9:Dò^@9:DZb�B�;fS F D�B�bàon>[BO�e>@>@D H ;f9_^@>[bfb�SC^[B F 9:DZb�SU;f>L< F 8C>@D F DòSÙÂêUØäða×_Î�ÛtØkÐÀ¿rÕCÏéРÛtØ©Î�ÍÂÑÄÕCϢРÛtØ�;f>[b=B�; F ^ÂB F DQ<�B�`Z>�on>@`kS»8 F 9:;�9CP H ;=9g^[>@bfb=>@b[�M F D�B�;=9gjZXQ^@>�B�`Z>�^@9:DZ^[> H Bfb]JÁ>[D�B F 9CDZ>@j0SCo�9r8C>�o��åJ�>»SUDZb¾9CP}ST^»SCb=>sb�B�XZjQ�å9CP�S©óCÐIÙÂÏ¢ÎÃÐéÿ��_ÏiÍfó0ðaÛtØ7Ë�Þ�Å�gÎ=ÕCÏéРÛtØ Ü�ÕCØnÕrÞ_ÍÂÜTÍÂØkÏ'ÙÂê�ÙÂÏOÍÂÜ"XZb=>@j F D�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j­b=9CP�BO�zSC;f>½jQ>[8:>[?I9 H JÁ>[DYB@��h F DZ^@>ÁMG�z9CXZ?Ij­? FIV >B�90PR9_^@XZb F D1Bf` F bà�z9:; V ;fSUB�`Q>@;�9:D­Bf`Z>½^[9:DZ^@> H B�b�9UP�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j­<:;fS H `1Bf;�SCDQb=PR9:;=JTSUB F 9:DòB�`kSUD�9:DB�`Z>LjZ>ÂBaS F ?I>@j©PR>@SUB�XQ;f>@b�9CP�B�`Q>�^»SCb=>�b�B�XZjg�òSCDZj F D�9:;=jZ>@;GBf9åSU^a` F >Â8:>�S¿JÁ9:;=>�?I>[< F oZ?A> F DYBf;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CDMÔ;f>[b=B�; F ^ÂBdJ��gb=>@?ÄP3B�9�B�`Z>àJÁS F D½PR>@SUB�XZ;=>@bd9CP3Bf`Z>�^@SCbf>àb=BfXZjQ�C�'��J�9:;=>àjQ>[BaS F ?I>[jå>Ãì H ?~SCDZSUB F 9:D²9CP3Bf`Z>j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�^@9CD À <:XZ;fSUB F 9:D�JÁSCDkSC<:>[JÁ>[D�BGb=�_b�B�>@J7^@SCD�on>�?I9_9 V >[j�X H�F DX¦�u�m&\ l �:�QÉ l 9:?I��};¨¢���d9r�ÔK>[8:>[;@Éâ>Â8:>@D�Bf`Z9:XZ<:`©Bf`Z>�^@SCbf>�b�B�XZjg� F b¾;f>@b�B�; F ^[Bf>@j F D0B�` F bd�e9:; V É F B H ;=9r8 F jZ>@bGSC?I?,B�`Z>�PR>»SUBfXZ;f>[b]9CP�Sj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j²b=�_b=Bf>@J"B�`ZSUB'�z>��e9:XZ?Ij²? FIV >GBf9Lb H >@^ F P��:�u'`Z>àPR9C?I?I9r� F DZ<�? F b=B'b=`Z9r��b¾9:D²B�`Q>à9CDZ>�`kSCDZj²B�`Z>�9:;=<�SCD F {»SUB F 9:D¿9UP�Bf`Z>�;=>@JÁS F DQjZ>@;Ô9UP3B�` F b'^a`kS H B�>@;[É9:D�Bf`Z>T9CBf`Z>@;�`kSCDZj F B H ;f9r8 F jZ>[b�SÅ^a`Z>@^ V KO? F b�B�9CPÔ�e9:; V_F DZ<©b�B�> H b�SåjZ>[b F <:DZ>@;�`kSCbàB�90jQ9 F Pzbf`Z>7ÓU`Z>b H >@^ FÄÀ >@bdS�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j²b=�_b�B�>@J$o��¿j F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[jÅ<C;�S H `²B�;fSCDZb�PR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:D¦��u'`Z>�b=B�> H bdSC;f>U�p:�dh H >@^ F P��TBf`Z>GB�9 H 9:?A9:<C��9CP,B�`Z>�j F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j¿b=�_b=Bf>@J F D²S�b=9UKO^@SC?I?A>@j�ØäÍÂÏ*ÊzÛtÎ�ß�ÏéêÃÖk;ÞCÎ=ÕÂÖk×_�&u'` F b<:;�S H ` H ;f9r8 F jZ>[bàBf`Z> H ;f9_^@>@b=b�SCDQj H 9:;=B�BO� H >[b�9UPzB�`Q>Áj F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j�b��gb�B�>[J5SCb��e>@?I?�SUbàBf`Z> F ;SCjZJ F b=b F oQ?I>¾^[9:DZDZ>[^[B F 9:DZb[�

+g�dh H >@^ F P��TBf`Z>�jkSUBaSLXZb=>@j²PR9:;ÔB�`Z>�?A9g^@SC?¦b=B�SUB�>[b�9CP H ;f9_^@>@b=bf>[bGSCDZj H 9:;=Bfb@�qQ�dh H >@^ F P���B�`Q>xon>@`ZSr8 F 9:;&PR9:;�>»SC^a` H ;=9g^[>@bfb�BO� H >��½< F 8:>[D F D�B�`Z>�DZ>ÂBO�z9:; V BO� H >�<:;�S H `Áo���J�>»SUDZb9CPâSGÖnÎ�ÛrðaÍaÙaÙzÞCÎ=ÕCÜ�Ü�ÕCÎ&9CPäBO� H >�� H ;f9r8 F j F DZ<àSàb=>[Be9CP�ÖnÎ�ÛrðaÍaÙaÙ�ÖnÎ�Û@ó���ðÂÏéРÛtØQÙ39CPäBO� H >��¿SUDZjÁBf`Z>F D F B F SC?3b�BaSUBf>T9CPÔS H ;=9g^[>@bfb�9CPÔBO� H >��,�²mk;f9:J�Bf`Z>�9:o_ý=>@^ÂB=KN9:; F >@D�B�>[j�8 F >Â� H 9 F D�B»É�Bf`Z> H ;f9_^@>[bfb<:;�SUJÁJÁSC;�^»SCDÈon>©bf>[>@D÷SCb²S­^@?ISCbfb½PR9:; H ;f9_^@>[bfbf>[b²9CP�BO� H >��,� u'`Q>�DkSCJ�>�b H SC^[>©PR9:;TBf`Z>

��� ���������������������� �"!$#�%&� ��')(*���,+ -� � �*� �/.0���"12�,�"!$�*�)!3�)�" !$����4�,+&� �5���"!3�4�6�7!3����%�+ +4���������"��8���*�"�8�/� % '&9��,.:�'�!$���"� !3# %&�"�';�6���&< (*% � �,�"!$�*�=12�,� �*(*��1>�����?��9&���"��1@#A������BDCE��FG�5���5�HI�*�"����>�"+4��6!3<4�5�,�"!$�*�=� ������ !$J�%���K�*�?(*���,+ �:�*�+4�,�"�"!L�,MN�*M3(��5#����*�:���,�=#A��������"�5�=���OFG�5M$MPB7QR�����'&1�!$� �"!3#�M$���5M$���"�:�*.E��+A���5!S<4����� !3���T� ������ !$J�%���:.0�*�?M3�&���,MN��� �,�"���K!$�'�!$� �6% � �"��'�!3�8UV��W�"!$�*��X BZY&B

p&+

Page 20: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

F DZb�BaSCDQ^@>@b�9CP�BO� H >=��B�`kSUB�JÁS»�©9_^@^[XZ; F D©B�`Q>�j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j�b=�_b=Bf>@J F b]< F 8:>[D F D�B�` F b]b=Bf> H SCb�z>[?I?¢�

wZ�dh H >@^ F P��¿B�`Z>àb=�_DZ^a`Q;f9:D F {»SUB F 9:DÅ^@9CDZb=Bf;�S F DYBfbdon>[BO�e>@>[D©B�`Z> H ;=9g^[>@bfb F DZb�BaSCDQ^@>@b[É F �õ>U�Z��` F ^a` H ;f9tK^@>[bfbxJÁ9r8:>[b�`kS»8:>�B�9�o�> H >@;�PR9:;fJ�>@j²b=�_DZ^a`Q;f9:DZ9CXZbf?Ä�\[

u'`Z>�;f>@b=XZ?AB�9UP�Bf`Z>@b=>�PR9CXZ;&�z9C; VYF DZ<�b�B�> H b F b�SLóCÐIÙÂÏ¢ÎÃÐéÿ��_ÏiÍfóàÙÂêrÙÂÏOÍÂÜ ÙOÖkÍaðÂÐ ËÔðfÕCϢРÛtØ�^@9CDZb F b=B F DZ<]9CPäS]DZ>[B�K�z9:; V BO� H >]<:;�S H `¦ÉZS�j F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j½<:;�SUJÁJÁSC;�^@9:DZb F b�B F DQ<�9CPvS H ;f9_^@>[bfb'<:;fSCJ�JTSC;eSCDZj²S�DZSCJÁ>db H SU^@>PR9:; H ;=9g^[>@b=b F DZb�BaSCDZ^[>@bÔPR9:;e>»SC^a` H ;=9g^[>@b=bÔBO� H > F DÁB�`Z>GDQ>[BO�e9:; V BO� H >G<:;fS H `²SCDZj²S�b=�_DZ^a`Z;=9:D F {@SUB F 9:D;f>@?ISUB F 9:D¦�cz>[PR9:;=>�M�oZ;=>»SUBf`Z>�? F PR> F D�B�9'Bf`Z>@b=> H 9 F D�Bfb@É�M F DYBf;f9_jZXZ^[>&B�`Z>�^»SUbf>�b=BfXZjQ��9CPQS'j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�^@9:D À <:XZ;fSUB F 9:DJTSCDZSC<:>@J�>@D�B�b��gb�B�>[Jå�

0(¯*# =�)éµ[úrû;) ù ´âúr¸�'z��%n¹(±3¼n´,ût¶gú&)*%n¹ ¼ ¶k¹,¶Z¼�¸_·1¸_¹�úu'`Z>�DQ>@^@>[bfb F BO�Å9CP&j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jå^[9:D À <CXZ;�SUB F 9:DÅJÁSCDkSC<:>[JÁ>[D�B F b�JÁ9UB F 8USUBf>@j²o��¿B�`Z>àb=Bf;fXZ^ÂB�XZ;=>�9UP3B�9tKjkS»�õ bsb=9CP�BO�zSC;f> H ;f9tý=>[^[Bfb@�Åîd9CB�9:DZ?Ä�©B�`ZSUB�Bf`Z>[��SC;=>Lo�>[^@9:J�>Áo F <:<:>[;�DZ9r�ÔSCjZSr�_b�oQXQB�SU?Ibf9Åb=Bf; F ^[B�>[;� XZSC? F BO�s;=> � X F ;=>@J�>@D�B�b�JÁS V > F B}>[8C>@D�JÁ9:;=>'j F ��^[XZ?AB&Bf9 H ?~SCDLSUDZj�B�9�^@9_9:;fj F DkSUBf>'S H ;f9�ý=>@^[B@�}u'`Z>�;f>ÃKbfXZ?ÄB�9UPkSdjQ>[8:>[?I9 H JÁ>[DYB H ;=9g^[>@bfb�9CP�B�>[D�`ZSCb�DQ9CB3JsXZ^a` F D�^[9:JÁJ�9:D]� F Bf`àBf`Z>�9:; F < F DkSU?:^@9:DQ^@> H B»�3�djZj F KB F 9CDkSC?I?Ä�:É�BO�z9�B�` F ;fjL9CP�Bf`Z>�^@9:J H ?I>ÂB�>'SUJÁ9:XQDYB�9UPnB F J�>'SCDZjLJ�9:DZ>Â�LSC;f>'b H >[D�B�PR9C;&JTS F D�B�>[DkSCDZ^[>�SCDZjPRXZ;=Bf`Z>@;�jZ>Â8:>@?A9 H J�>@D�B�bàSUP�Bf>@;]B�`Q> F D F B F SC? H ;=9tý=>@^ÂB��zSCb�^@9CJ H ?A>[Bf>@j�¦ ce9g>�/�}gÉ lÑ� /:q�¨¢�LmkXZ;=Bf`Z>@;=JÁ9C;f>CÉB�`Z> V DZ9r��?I>@jQ<:>�Bf9¾^[9:J H ?I>[Bf>�Sdo F < H ;f9tý=>[^[B F b,`kSC;=jZ?A��S»8US F ?~SCoZ?A> F D�S�b F DQ<:?I>}^[9:J H SCD��:�&�x>@DZ^[>CÉ:>Ãì_B�>@;iKDkSC? H ;f9tý=>[^[B H SC;=BfDZ>@;=b}J�XZb=B3^@9:D�Bf; F oQXQB�>U� W 9:;=>z9CP�Bf>@D F B F b3SC?Ib=9G>@^[9:DZ9:J F ^@SC?I?Ä�]bf>[DZb F oZ?I>�B�9 H SCbfb&�e9:; VB�9�>Âì_B�>[;fDkSC?,b=XZo�^[9:D�B�;fSC^[Bf9:;fb[� �ÈF Bf`0SCDÅ>[8C>@;d<:;f9r� F DQ<ÁjZ>[JTSUDZjå9CDåj F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[jåb=9CP�BO�ÔSU;f>àjZ>[8C>@?I9 H KJÁ>[DYB¾B�`Z> H ;=9:oZ?A>@J�bG9CP�^@9:J�J�XZD F ^»StB F 9CD¦É�^[9g9C;fj F DkSUB F 9:D©SUDZj � XZSC? F BO�åJÁSCDkSU<:>@J�>@D�B]<:;=9r� SCbd�z>[?I? �m�9C; F DZb�BaSCDQ^@>CÉ_SC?A? H ;=9tý=>@^ÂB�b F Bf>@b�J�XZb�B�`kS»8:>dSC^@^[>@b=b�Bf9�S]^[9:DZb F b=Bf>@D�B�X H Bf9�jkSUB�>'b=>[B�9CP H ;f9�ý=>@^[B�jZ9_^@X_KJÁ>[DYBfb@� � `Z>@D�9:DZ> H ;f9tý=>[^[B�b F B�>�^a`kSCDZ<:>[b3SxjZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B»É F BvJ�XQb=Bvo�>[^@9:J�> V DQ9���D�B�9dSC?I?:9UB�`Z>[; H ;=9tý=>@^ÂBb F Bf>@b[ÉtBf9g9Z�,u'` F b F bâ>[b H >@^ F SC?I?Ä�GS H ;=9:oZ?A>@J÷��`Q>@D�B�`Z>[;f> F bâDZ9�^[>@D�B�;fSC?YSC;f^a` F 8:>�S»8US F ?ISCoZ?A>�PR9:;,SC?A? H ;=9tý=>@^ÂBH SC;=BfDZ>@;=b@�¿uv90^[9 H >L� F Bf`òBf`Z>@b=> H ;=9:oZ?A>@J�b@Évbf>[8C>@;fSC?e^[9:DZ^[> H Bfb�9CP�óCÐIÙÂÏéÎÃÐéÿ��gÏOÍfó�ðaÛtØ7Ë�Þ��gÎ=ÕCÏéРÛtØ­Ü�ÕCØVÅÕrÞ_ÍÂÜTÍÂØkϦSC;=> H ;f9 H 9:b=>@j F DTBf`Z>�? F B�>@;fSUB�XQ;f>¸¦�u F ^@��wZÉõ|}b=Ba�`vgÉ h_9:JT��.QÉ ïz9CDk��}gÉ 8_jk�¾� � �`.QÉôï � ��}gÉ l 9:?~��}&¨ �M�PR9C?I?I9r� F D½B�` F be�e9:; V B�`Z>]j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j¿^@9:D À <:XZ;fSUB F 9:D½JÁSCDkSC<:>[JÁ>[D�BÔb=�_b�B�>@J H ;f>[bf>@D�Bf>@j F D§¦ l 9:?~��}&¨ �

=?%¦ü�´�·1¸_¹�úrµA]��T¸�ÿ()¢µ7)D%n¹�µ EGF b=B�; F oZXgB�>@jåbf9CP�BO�zSC;=> H ;f9tý=>[^[Bfb�SC;f>�^»SC;=; F >[j©9:XQBGoY�åbf>Â8:>[;�SC? H ;=9tý=>@^ÂBH SC;=BfDZ>@;=b@É�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j09r8C>@;¾j F ��>@;f>[D�BGb F B�>[b@�x|�SC^a` H ;=9tý=>@^ÂB H SC;�B�DZ>[;d�e9:; V bG9CD©SÁDYXZJso�>[;¾9CPxó_ÛrðÁ��ÅÜTÍÂØkÏRÙvPR9:;=J F DZ<]S H SC;�B�9CP�B�`Z>�bf9UP�BO�ÔSC;=> H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB}B�`kSUB F b&<:9 F DZ<GB�9]on>'jZ>Â8:>@?A9 H >@j F D�B�`Z>'j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jbf9CP�BO�zSC;f> H ;f9�ý=>@^[B@��� jZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�BdJTS»�²on>sSLB�>ÃìgB À ?I>UÉäSUD0>Âìg>[^@XQB�SCoZ?I> À ?I>UÉnSÁ^@9_jZ> À ?I>à>[Bf^C��JTSUD FIH KXZ?~SUBf>@j�oY�1S H ;=9tý=>@^ÂB H SC;�B�DZ>[;@� E 9g^[XZJÁ>[D�B�bs>Â8:9:?Ä8:>½jQXZ; F DZ<åBf`Z>½jZ>Â8:>@?A9 H J�>@D�B H ;f9_^@>@b=b�SCDZj�>@SC^a`b=BaStB�>]9CP�SCD¿>Â8:9:?Ä8 F DZ<�jZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B'� F >[?IjZbÔS�DZ>[�-8:>[;fb F 9:D¦ÉZ^@SC?I?A>@j²S½Î�ÍÂÌrÐIÙÂРÛtØk�}æ�>[8 F b F 9:DQbÔ9CP,B�`Z>]bfSCJ�>jZ9g^[XZJ�>@D�Bz`ZSr8C>¾B�`Q>¾b�SUJÁ>só_ÛrðÁ�gÜTÍÂØkÏ�Ðéó_ÍÂØkϢРËÔðfÕCÏéРÛtزØV�gÜ�ÿÂÍÂÎ�SUDZj½SC;=>¾;=>@?~StB�>@jÁo��TS�Î�ÍÂÌrÐIÙÂРÛtØÅØV�_ܸÅÿÂÍÂÎGB�`kSUBàb=`Z9r��bsB�`Z>LB�>[J H 9:;fSC?}9:;fjQ>@;à9:D�Bf`Z>Á8C>@;fb F 9:DQbs9CPÔSåjZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�BsSCDZjòB�`Z> F ;�jZ> H >@DQjZ>@DZ^ F >[b@�æx>Â8 F b F 9:DZbvJTS»��`kS»8:>zbf>[8C>@;fSC?ZSCjQj F B F 9:DkSU?YSUBfBf; F oQXQB�>[b@�âB�`Z>�ðaÛtØkÏiÍÂØkÏ�Ù,9CPkSd;f>Â8 F b F 9:Dsb=`Z9r��b3B�`Q>zb=B�SUB�>e9CPB�`Z>�jZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B�8:>[;fb F 9:D¦É_S�Î�ÍÂÌrÐIÙÂРÛtØ¿ØnÕCÜTÍ�`Z>@? H b}B�9�j F b�B F DZ<:X F bf`L;f>Â8 F b F 9:DZb}DZ9CB�9:DQ?A��o���Bf`Z>�;f>Â8 F b F 9:DD_XQJ�o�>[;@ÉYB�`Z>'ÖnÎ�Û6^»ÍaðÂÏ�ÖQÕCÎÃÏéØäÍÂÎ}bf`Z9r��b���`Z9�^[;f>@SUB�>[jTB�` F b}8:>@;=b F 9:D¦ÉYB�`Z>�ðÂÎ�ÍfÕCϢРÛtØ¿ÏéÐ�ÜTÍ�SCDZj0ó�ÕCÏOÍ}bf`Q9����`Z>@D½Bf`Z>d8C>@;fb F 9:DÁ�ÔSCbz^@;f>@SUB�>[j¿>[Bf^C��mk9:;�B�`Z>db�S V >G9CP,b F J H ? F ^ F BO�CÉ:M};f>[b=B�; F ^ÂBÔJs�_bf>[?AP F DÁB�` F b��z9:; V Bf9B�`Z>�jZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B F jQ>@D�B FÄÀ ^»SUB F 9:D¿DYXZJso�>[;@ÉZB�`Q>à;=>[8 F b F 9:D²DYXZJ�on>@;xSCDQj²Bf`Z>�^@9:D�Bf>@D�B�bd9CP&S�;=>[8 F b F 9:D¦�

prq

Page 21: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

�½¸�ÿ8)¢µ�)*%n¹ ø ûtü;6�)¶ÿn¸gµ�¶k¹:'��½¸ 9 2*)éü:¶Qú&)D%�¹ u'`Z>�jZ9g^[XZJ�>@D�B�bx9CP�9:DZ> H ;f9tý=>[^[B H SC;�B�DZ>[;d`kS»8C>àBf9Áon>JTSCjQ>LSC^@^[>@bfb F oZ?A>�PR9:;];f>[JÁ9CBf> H ;f9�ý=>@^[B H SU;=B�DQ>@;fb F P�Bf`Z>[��DQ>@>@j�B�`Q>�jQ9g^[XZJÁ>[D�B�b]B�9²^@9CDZb=Bf;fXZ^ÂB�Bf`Z> F ;9���DÁbf9CP�BO�zSC;=>¾^@9CJ H 9:DZ>[DYB@�&MODT9C;fjZ>[;�Bf9 H ;=>@b=>@D�BzBf`Z>djQ9g^[XZJÁ>[D�B�bzjQ>[8:>[?I9 H >@j F D�9:DZ>xb F B�>�B�9à;f>@J�9CBf>H ;f9tý=>[^[B H SC;�B�DZ>[;fb[Év>@SC^a` H ;f9tý=>[^[B H SC;�B�DZ>[;]`kSCb�S�Î�ÍÂÌrÐIÙÂРÛtØ�ÕCÎ�ða×_Ð�ÌCÍxB�`kStB�^@9:D�BaS F DZbGBf`Z>L;f>[8 F b F 9CDZb]9CPB�`Z>àjZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B�bd9CP&Bf`Z> H ;f9tý=>[^[B H SC;=BfDZ>@;[�'u'`Z> H ;=9tý=>@^ÂB H SC;=BfDZ>@;=b¾9CP�B�`Z>�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j H ;f9tý=>[^[B¾`kS»8:>SC^@^[>@bfb�B�9¿Bf`Z>L;f>[8 F b F 9CD�SC;f^a` F 8:>[b�9CPe;f>[JÁ9UB�> H ;=9tý=>@^ÂB H SC;=BfDZ>@;=b@É,bfXZ^a`òB�`kStBàS²^[9:DZDZ>[^[B F 9:D�on>[BO�e>@>@D;f>[8 F b F 9CD½SC;=^a` F 8C>@bz9UPâBO�z9 H SC;=BfDZ>@;=bz^»SUD½o�>x>@b�BaSCoQ? F b=`Z>@j F PâS�jkSUBaSà;f> H ? F ^»SUB F 9:D F b F D�Bf>@DZjZ>[j½on>[BO�e>@>@DB�`Z>[Jå�àu'`Z>�^@9CDZDZ>@^ÂB F 9:D F bGXZb=XkSC?A?A�åj F ;=>@^[Bf>@j F DåB�`Z>�b=>@DZb=>�Bf`kSUB]9:DQ> H ;f9tý=>[^[B H SU;=B�DQ>@;]>Âì H 9:;=Bfb F BfbjZ9g^[XZJ�>@D�B�b¾SCDZj0Bf`Z>s9CBf`Z>@;d9:DZ> F J H 9:;�B�b'B�`Q>sjZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�Bfb@�¾uv9T;=> H ? F ^@SUB�>àjZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B�b F DÅB�`Z>�9CB�`Z>[;j F ;=>@^[B F 9:DäÉQSCDT9���D¿^[9:DZDZ>[^[B F 9:D½`ZSCbzB�9�o�>¾>@b=B�SCoZ? F bf`Q>@j¦��ce��J�>»SCDQbÔ9CP,Ss^[9:DZDZ>[^[B F 9:D¦Ég;f>Â8 F b F 9:DZbz^@SCDo�>L;f> H ? F ^»SUBf>@j�PR;f9:J�9:DZ> H ;f9�ý=>@^[B H SC;�B�DZ>[;àBf9ÅBf`Z>L9CB�`Q>@;à9:DZ>CÉ H >@;=PR9C;fJ�>@j F D�B�9²BO�e9 H `kSUbf>@b[� À ;=b=B@É9:DZ>]b F B�>]>Ãì H 9:;�B�b F BfbÔjZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B�b[Ékbf>[^@9:DZjäÉ�Bf`Z>]9CBf`Z>@;�b F B�> F J H 9:;=BfbeBf`Z>@b=>àjQ9g^[XZJÁ>[D�B�b F D�B�9 F B�b'9r��D;f>[8 F b F 9CD�SC;f^a` F 8:>U��u'`Z>@b=>�BO�e9Åb=B�> H bàSC;f>�XQbfXkSC?A?A� H >[;=PR9:;=JÁ>[j�SCb=�_DZ^a`Q;f9:DZ9CXZbf?Ä�:�LMNP�B�`Z>L;f> H ? F ^»SUB F 9:DF b À D F bf`Z>[j¦É,B�`Z>L^@9CDZDZ>@^ÂB F 9:D�JTS»��on>L^@XQB�SC<�S F D¦��MOD�B�` F bG�zSr�CÉvBf`Z>Lb=Bf;fXZ^ÂB�XZ;=>Á9CP�B�`Q>�j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jbf9CP�BO�zSC;f> H ;f9tý=>[^[B3^a`kSCDZ<:>[b&jQ�_DkSCJ F ^@SC?I?Ä�:É�b F DZ^@>zSC?Ib=9dDQ>[� H ;f9�ý=>@^[B H SC;�B�DZ>[;fb&^@SCDxý=9 F D�9:;v9:?Ajs9:DZ>eJTS»�?I>»S»8C>¾B�`Z> H ;f9�ý=>@^[B@���d9r�e>[8:>[;@Ék>Â8:>@D F P,S H ;=9tý=>@^ÂB H SC;�B�DZ>[;z?I>@S»8:>@beB�`Z> H ;f9tý=>[^[B@ÉQB�`Z>djZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B�bz`kS»8:>B�9½on> H ;f>[bf>[;=8:>[jò� F B�` F D0B�`Q> H ;f9�ý=>@^[B@��u'` F b F b¾okSCb=>@j�9:D�9:DQ>�9CP�B�`Z>sJÁ9:b�B F J H 9:;=B�SCD�B H ;=9 H >@;=B F >[b9CP]S�;f>Â8 F b F 9:DþSU;f^a` F 8:>C�1ØäÛòÎaÍÂÌrÐIÙÂРÛtØþÐIÙåÕCÑ�ÑIÛ;ÊzÍfó�ÏOÛ�ÿÂÍÅó_ÍÂÑIÍÂÏiÍfó�ÍÂÌCÍÂÎ]ÚÃÎ�ÛtÜ Ï�×kÍÅÎaÍÂÌrÐIÙÂРÛtØ ÕCÎaða×_Ð�ÌCÍÂ�u'` F bd;fXZ?A> F bdJ�9CB F 8USUB�>[jÅo��ÅB�`Z> H ;�SU^[B F ^@>UÉn��`Z>[;f>�^[? F >@D�Bx;f> � X F ;f>[JÁ>[DYBfbG^»SUD0JÁS V >àB�`Z>�DZ>@>[j©9CP}9:?Aj;f>[8 F b F 9CDZb'DZ>@^[>@b=b�SC;��:�

� %�û&�âµ 9 ¶kü:¸_µA]���6,¸_ü;�Ã�O)é¹�¶k¹:'ü��6,¸_ü;�Ã� %n´,úX%�º��½¸�ÿ8)¢µ�)*%n¹vµ � H ;f9�ý=>@^[B H SC;=BfDZ>@; F B�b=>@?AP F b F D<:>@DZ>[;�SC?A?A�å;f> H ;f>[bf>@D�Bf>@j1o���SUDò>[D�B F ;=>�jZ>[8C>@?A9 H >[;GB�>@SCJ�^[9:DZb F b=B F DZ<²9CP�bf>Â8:>[;�SC?}jZ>Â8:>[?I9 H >@;=bà�e9:; VYF DZ<SUBsBf`Z>TbfSCJÁ>Áb F B�>C� � `Z>@DãSÅjZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B�9CPzB�`Z>½b F Bf> F bà^a`kSCDQ<:>@j�9:;sS0DZ>Â�öjQ9g^[XZJÁ>[D�B F b�^@;=>»SUBf>@joY�²9CDZ>�9CP�Bf`Z>�jZ>[8C>@?A9 H >[;fb[É�Bf` F b F b'DZ9CBxj F ;=>@^ÂB�?A�TjZ9:DZ> F D²Bf`Z>�;f>Â8 F b F 9:DÅSC;f^a` F 8:>àoZXQBxo��²JÁ>@SCDZb'9CP&SÊzÛtÎaßrÙOÖQÕ_ðaÍÂ�3�*�z9:; V b H SC^[> F bÔjZ>[b F <CDkSUB�>[jÅBf9LS�jZ>[8C>@?I9 H >[;@É F D½��` F ^a`Åbf`Z>7ÓU`Z>]�z9C; V b@ÉkB�`ZSUB F b[ÉQ��`Z>[;f>jZ9g^[XZJ�>@D�B�bsSC;f>�JTSUD FIH XQ?~SUBf>@j¦�½MNP'SåjZ>Â8:>@?A9 H >@;��e9:XZ?Aj­? FAV >�B�9å^a`kSCDZ<C>½SCD­>Ãì F b=B F DZ<Å;f>Â8 F b F 9:D19UP�SjZ9g^[XZJ�>@D�B»É�b=`Z><ÓU`Q> À ;fb=Bf?A�s^@9:DZDQ>@^[Bfb�`Z>@;OÓU` F b��z9:; V b H SC^[>x� F B�`�Bf`Z>';f>Â8 F b F 9:DLSC;f^a` F 8:>xSCDQj�^@9 HZF >@b&Bf`Z>^@9:;=;f>@b H 9CDZj F DQ<Å;=>[8 F b F 9:D©PR;=9:J�Bf`Z>L;f>Â8 F b F 9:DòSC;f^a` F 8:> F DYBf9²`Z>@;OÓU` F bG�e9:; V b H SC^[>C�Lu�9 H XgBsS¿^[9 H ��9CPSÁ;f>Â8 F b F 9:D²PR;f9:J�Bf`Z>�SU;f^a` F 8:> F D�B�9�B�`Z>��z9C; V b H SU^@> F bx^@SC?I?A>@j²B�`Z>¿ða×kÍaðaß;ÅfÛ;�_Ïv9UP3B�`Q>�;=>[8 F b F 9:D¦�'h F DZ^[>;f>[8 F b F 9CDZbàSC;f>LDZ9CB�SC?A?I9r�e>@j�B�9Åo�>LjZ>[?I>[Bf>@jòPR;f9:J�Bf`Z>L;f>Â8 F b F 9:D1SU;f^a` F 8:>CÉ,B�`Q>Á;=>[8 F b F 9:D�^a`Z>[^ V >@jã9:XgBF bLS�^@9 H �ã9CPxB�`Z>Å;f>Â8 F b F 9:D F D�B�`Q>0SC;=^a` F 8C>C��u'`Z>åSC^[BfXkSC?'^a`kSCDQ<:>å9UPdBf`Z>²jZ9g^[XZJ�>@D�BÁB�S V >[b H ?~SC^[>� F B�` F D©B�`Q>��z9:; V b H SC^[>Á9C;�S½DZ>[� jZ9g^[XZJ�>@D�B�JTS»�0o�>�^[;f>»StB�>@jä� � `Z>@D�B�`Z>��e9:; V©F b À D F b=`Z>@j¦ÉâBf`Z>^a`kSCDZ<:>[jå9C;�Bf`Z>�DZ>[�èjZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B�b�`kS»8C>àBf9�on> H XQBxokSC^ VTF D�B�9�B�`Q>à;=>[8 F b F 9:DÅSC;=^a` F 8C>C��u'` F b F b'^»SC?A?I>[jB�`Z>åða×kÍaðaß;ÅOÐ�Ø¿9UP�Bf`Z>�jZ9_^@XQJÁ>[DYBfb@�àu'`Z>�^a`Z>[^ V K F Dò9CP�S½jZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B F D�B�9½B�`Q>�;f>Â8 F b F 9:D�SC;f^a` F 8:>�jQ>»SC?AbSC?Ib=9s� F Bf`½B�`Z>]^@SC?I^[XZ?~SUB F 9:DÁ9CPâB�`Q>];f>[8 F b F 9CD¿D_XQJ�o�>[;zPR9:;zBf`Z>G8:>[;fb F 9:D²9CP,B�`Q>GjZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B�^a`Z>[^ V >@j F D¦�MNP}SÁDQ>[�¤jZ9_^@XQJÁ>[DYB F b�^a`Z>[^ V >[j F D�B�9LB�`Z>à;f>Â8 F b F 9:D0SU;f^a` F 8:>CÉkBf` F b�^»SUD0on>�jZ9CDZ>à� F B�`Z9CXQB H ;f9:oQ?I>@J�b@Éb F DQ^@>]B�`Z>[;f>�jZ9_>@bxDZ9CB�>Ãì F b=BdS H ;f>[jZ>@^[>@bfb=9:;d8C>@;=b F 9CD¦��u'`Z>�^a`Q>@^ V²F D²9CP3S�^a`kSCDZ<:>[j0;=>[8 F b F 9:D F b'J�9:;=>^@9:J H ? F ^»SUBf>@j¦É_b F DZ^@>GBf`Z>G^a`kSUDZ<:>@jÅ;f>Â8 F b F 9:D½J�XQb=B�on> F DZb=>@;�B�>@jÅSCb�S�b=XZ^@^[>@b=bf9:;�9CP,B�`Q>];f>[8 F b F 9CD½PR;f9:J��` F ^a` F BL�ÔSCbT^a`Z>@^ V >@j-9:XQB»�Èu'`Z>[;f>ÂPR9:;f>UÉ�Bf`Z>0;=>[8 F b F 9:D DYXZJ�on>@;�9CP]B�`Z>å;f>Â8 F b F 9:D�PR;=9:J B�`kStBÁBf`Z>^a`kSCDZ<:>[j�;f>Â8 F b F 9:D��zSCb�^a`Z>[^ V >[j 9:XgB F DQëkXZ>[DZ^@>[bsB�`Z>T^»SC?A^@XZ?ISUB F 9:D�9CPÔB�`Q>T;f>Â8 F b F 9:D­DYXZJ�on>@;�9CPÔBf`Z>^a`kSCDZ<:>[j0;=>[8 F b F 9:D¦�E >[8:>[?I9 H >@;=be^@SCD½^[9:DZDZ>[^[Bz�e9:; V b H SC^[>@bÔB�9�;f>Â8 F b F 9:DTSU;f^a` F 8:>@b F DTSC;fo F B�;fSC;=��DYXZJso�>[;zSCDQj½^»SCDÁj F b=^@9:D_KDZ>@^ÂBxBf`Z>@JÅÉZ��`Z>[DZ>[8C>@;GS�jZ>Â8:>[?I9 H >@;�jZ>[^ F jQ>@b�B�9L^@XQBdS�^@9CDZDZ>@^ÂB F 9:D¦�

p7w

Page 22: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

0(¯�0 1 úr¸ 9 # ´ÔB�6,¸5BÇ% 9 %32*%�¼V�>%�ºxú<6v¸»=�)éµ[úrû;) ù ´âúr¸�' 1 �,µ[ú»¸g·MOD B�`Q>0on>@< F DZD F DQ<�9CPdB�`Z>åjZ>[8C>@?A9 H J�>@D�B H ;=9g^[>@b=bÁPR9:;ÁS�j F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[jþb=�_b�B�>@J F B F bÁ;=>»SCb=9:DkSCoZ?A>ÅBf9^@9:DZb F jZ>[; F B�bGBf9 H 9:?I9:< F ^»SU?3SCb H >[^[Bfb@��u'`Z> F jZ>»S¿9CPeXZb F DZ<²<:;fS H `Zb]PR9:;]jZ>[bf^[; F o F DZ<¿B�`Q>LBf9 H 9:?I9:<U�©9CPzSj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�b��gb�B�>[J �ÔSUb�SC?I;=>»SCjQ� H XgB F D H ;�SC^ÂB F ^[> Ê >U�õ<Q� F D�¦ W0� æx�:�QÉ u3SU>»�`.�¨~ËÂ�3�¾?Ib=9¾B�` F b��e9:; V J�9gjgK>@?Ib�B�`Q>xBf9 H 9C?I9:<C��9CP¦B�`Q>dj F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[jTb=�_b�B�>@J o��ÁS�<:;fS H `¦ÉYJ�9:;f>x>ÂìQSC^ÂB�?A��S�Ï¢êaÖkÍfóàÞCÎfÕÂÖk×H¦õïÔ|�á � �`.�¨¢É��`Z>@;=>�DZ9_jZ>[bdSUDZjå>[jZ<:>[bx9UP&SL<:;�S H `ÅSC;f>�> � X FAHZH >@jåSCjZj F B F 9CDkSC?I?Ä�Lo��¿BO� H > F DQPR9C;fJÁSUB F 9:DZb@� _� BO� H >@j�<:;fS H ` Ê E >ÂPi�IwZ�Äp:�,+:Ëd^[9:DZb F b=Bfb]9CPeS½bf>[Bà9CP�DZ9_jZ>[b�SCDZj�S¿bf>ÂB�9CP�>@jZ<:>[b@��|}jZ<C>@b]9CPeS¿<:;�S H `SC;f>xj F ;=>@^ÂB�>@jäÉ F �õ>U�:B�`Z>Â�Á;=XZDTPR;=9:J 9:DZ>xDZ9_jZ> Ê B�`Q>àÙrÛ;�_ÎaðaÍ&9CP¦Bf`Z>d>[jZ<:>»Ë�B�9�S�DQ9gjZ> Ê Bf`Z>àÏNÕC΢Þ_ÍÂÏn9CPäBf`Z>>@jZ<:>»ËÂ�'�dD0>@jQ<:>�`ZSCb¾SU?A�zSr�_bdSÁXZD F�� XZ>àbf9:XZ;=^@>sSCDZjåB�SC;f<C>[BxDZ9_jZ>CÉnDZ9CBdSC?A?I9r�z>[j0SU;f>à>@jZ<:>[bd� F B�`Z9:XgBbf9:XZ;=^@>à;f>[b H �Z� F B�`Z9:XgBxB�SC;f<C>[B�DZ9_jZ>CÉ�SUb��e>@?A?,SCb�>@jZ<C>@b�o�>ÂBO�z>[>@D©>[jZ<:>[b@�e|�SU^a`0DZ9_jZ>�SCDZjÅ>»SU^a`0>@jQ<:>`kSCbxS¿Ï¢êaÖkÍÂ�ehg>[8C>@;�SU?vDQ9gjZ>[b�;f>@b H ��>@jZ<C>@b�9CP3Bf`Z>�b�SCJ�>GBO� H >�JÁS»�¿9g^[^@XZ; F D¿9:DZ>�<:;�S H `¦�`�aâ¶k· 9 2R¸ 0�¯*#cb úb� 9 ¸�'þ¼�û�¶ 9 6:du'`Z>©BO� H >[j <:;�S H ` F D m F <:XZ;=>5+g�Äp©J�9gjZ>[?IbÁS H 9Cbfb F oZ?I>åDZ>[BO�e9:; V 9CP�S1j F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j ^@9:D À <:XZ;fSUB F 9:DJTSCDZSC<:>@J�>@D�B�b��gb�B�>[Jå��MzJ�9gjQ>@?¦;=>[8 F b F 9:DÅSC;=^a` F 8C>@bdSCDZj²�z9:; V b H SC^[>@bdoY�½oZ?~SC^ V b � XkSC;=>�DZ9_jZ>[b@ÉkB�`kStB

PortRAWSPortRA

PortRA

PortRA

RA WSRA

RA

m F <:XQ;f>�+g�Äp:�Èç¦×kÍÅØäÍÂÏ�ÊzÛtÎ�ß­ÛiÚåÕ­óCÐIÙÂÏéÎÃÐéÿ��gÏOÍfó ðaÛtØ7Ë�Þ��gÎ=ÕCÏéРÛtØ Ü�ÕCØnÕrÞ_ÍÂÜTÍÂØkϾÙÂêrÙÂÏiÍÂÜ ÜTÛ@ó_ÍÂÑIÍfó­ÿ@ê1ÕÏ¢êaÖkÍfó�ÞCÎ=ÕÂÖk×fe

`kS»8:>�B�`Z>ÔBO� H >�gih PR9:;};=>[8 F b F 9:DLSU;f^a` F 8:>@beSCDZj�jlk�PR9C;&�z9:; V b H SC^[>@b[ÉQ;f>[b H >@^ÂB F 8C>@?Ä�:�&u'`Z>x;f> H ? F ^»SUB F 9:D9CPkjZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�Bfb3on>[BO�e>@>@D�;=>[8 F b F 9:DsSC;f^a` F 8:>[b�B�S V >[b H ?~SU^@>�9�8C>@;3Sd^@9CJÁJ�9:D H 9:;�B»��u'`Z> H 9:;=B F bvJ�9gjZ>[?I>[joY�sSdDQ9gjZ>e9CPZBO� H >2mTn�o�p5gihsÉUBf`kSUB F bv^@9:DZDQ>@^[Bf>@j�Bf9]Sd;=>[8 F b F 9:D�SU;f^a` F 8:>zo��sSdjkSUbf`Z>[j�9:;&Sxbf9:? F js>[jZ<:>U�u'`Z>½^@9CDZDZ>@^ÂB F 9:D­� F Bf`�S0jkSCb=`Z>@jã>[jZ<:>½J�>»SCDQb@É&B�`ZSUBsBf`Z> H 9:;=Bso�>[?I9:DZ<Cb�B�9åB�`Z>½;=>[8 F b F 9:D­SC;f^a` F 8:>U�|�SU^a`�;f>[8 F b F 9CD�SC;f^a` F 8:>¿`ZSCb F Bfbs9r��D�XZD F�� XZ> H 9:;=Bs9CP'BO� H >qmrn o�p5gihs�0MNPxBf`Z>½;=>[8 F b F 9:D�SU;f^a` F 8:> F b^@9:DZDQ>@^[Bf>@j©� F B�`åS H 9:;=B�mrn o�p5gih)o��åSÁb=9:? F jÅSC;f;=9���É�B�`Q>�;=>[8 F b F 9:D0SC;f^a` F 8:>àXZbf>[b¾B�`Q>�;=>@J�9CB�> H 9C;=B»�hg>[8C>@;�SU?â;f>[8 F b F 9CD¿SC;f^a` F 8:>[b�JTS»�ÁXZbf>�S H 9:;=BÔ9CP�S�;f>@J�9CBf>¾;f>Â8 F b F 9:D²SC;=^a` F 8C>�SUBÔB�`Q>]b�SCJ�>¾B F JÁ>U�&MNB F bSC?Ib=9 H 9:b=b F oZ?I>UÉ:B�`kSUB�DZ9�;=>[8 F b F 9:D�SC;=^a` F 8C>xXQbf>@beS H 9C;=B�9CPäSCDÁSC;f^a` F 8:>U�&u'`Z>xjkSCbf`Q>@jÁSCDZj�bf9:? F jLSC;=;f9r��bbf`Z9r�÷SCjZj F B F 9:DkSC?A?A�sBf`Z>¾;=> H ? F ^@SUB F 9:DÁj F ;f>[^[B F 9:D�o�>ÂBO�z>[>@DåSC;f^a` F 8:>[b@�}jZ9_^@XQJÁ>[DYBfb'SC;=>¾;f> H ? F ^»SUBf>@j�PR;f9:JB�`Z>LSC;=^a` F 8C>CÉäBf`kSUB F b¾B�`Q>�BaSC;=<:>[B]9UP}B�`Z>�jkSUbf`Z>[j�SU;f;f9r��B�9½Bf`Z>�SC;=^a` F 8C>CɦB�`ZSUB F bdB�`Z>sB�SC;f<C>[B]9CP�Bf`Z>bf9:? F j�SC;f;=9r���}u'`Z> H 9:;=B�9CP�BO� H >�mTn�o p5gihijlk F b�XZb=>@jTPR9:;�B�`Q>d^[9:JÁJsXZD F ^@SUB F 9:DLo�>ÂBO�z>[>@D¿Sà;f>Â8 F b F 9:DSC;f^a` F 8:>åSCDZjþSò�e9:; V b H SC^@>U�è�¾8C>@;ÁBf`Z>@b=> H 9:;=Bfb@ÉzBf`Z>ÅjZ9g^[XZJ�>@D�B�bTSC;f>Å^a`Z>@^ V >@j F Dþ;f>[b H ��^a`Z>[^ V >[j9:XQB»�'h F DZ^[>]B�`Z>[;f>sjQ9g>[bdDZ9UBd>Ãì F b=B¾SÁjQ>@b F <:DkSUBf>@jåj F ;=>@^[B F 9:D¿PR9:;�B�`Q>�^a`Z>[^ V 9CXQBdSCDZjåBf`Z>à^a`Z>@^ VÅF DÅ9CPjZ9g^[XZJ�>@D�B�b[ÉkMz`kS»8:>à9:DZ?Ä�½b=9:? F j²SC;f;=9���b[� s�¾bsJ�>@D�B F 9:DZ>[j F D�B�`Q> F D�B�;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:Dò9CPÔBf` F b�^a`kS H Bf>@;@É3M]^@9:DZb F jZ>[;�SÅj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j­b��gb�B�>[J Bf9©o�>TSb=�_b=Bf>@J ^[9:DZb F b=B F DZ<©9UP�^@9:DZ^[XZ;f;=>@D�B H ;=9g^[>@bfb=>@bL^@9CJÁJ�XQD F ^@SUB F DZ<Å8 F S0^@9:J�J�9:D H 9:;=Bfb@��mk9:;�Så< F 8C>@Dj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j b=�_b�B�>@JÅÉ�B�`Z>©BO� H >@b¿9CP H ;=9g^[>@bfb=>@bÅSCDZj Bf`Z>0BO� H >[b²9CP H 9:;�B�bTBf`kSUB¿^@SCD 9_^@^@XQ; F DþBf`Z>

t�u (��5����� �*MA!$���"� �&'&% �W� !3�����"��(*���,+���"���,�4�/.0���"12��� !3����!L�R(*!$�*����!$�=v wx��y�zV{|}Bp&v

Page 23: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j²b=�_b=Bf>@JSC;=>àJ�9_jZ>@?A>@j F DÅSLbf9UKN^»SC?A?I>@j�ØäÍÂÏ*ÊzÛtÎ�ßLÏ¢êaÖkÍGÞCÎ=ÕÂÖk× Ê E >[Pi�VwZ�õqQ�Äp�ËÂ��u'`Z>àDZ>[BO�e9:; VBO� H >L<:;�S H ` F b�S¿<:;�S H `�B�`kSUB�^[9:D�BaS F DZb]PR9:;G>@SC^a` H ;f9_^@>@b=bsSUDZj H 9:;�B]BO� H >L9:DZ>LDZ9_jZ>LSCDQjòPR9:;]>@SC^a`>@jZ<:>åBO� H >�SCD >[jZ<:>C�¤ML;=> � X F ;=>0B�`ZSUB H ;=9g^[>@bfb=>@b²^»SUD o�>©9CDZ?A��^@9CDZDZ>@^ÂB�>[j-8 F S H 9:;�B�b[�¤��j F ;=>@^ÂB^@9:DZDQ>@^[B F 9:D1o�>ÂBO�z>[>@D H ;f9_^@>[bfb=>@b F b�DZ9CB H 9:b=b F oZ?I>U�åu'`Z>Tbf9:XZ;=^@>¿SUDZj1B�`Q>ÁBaSU;f<:>ÂB�DZ9_jZ>T9UPxSCD­>@jQ<:>F D0Bf`Z>�DZ>ÂBO�z9:; V BO� H >�<C;�S H `0b H >@^ F P��0Bf`Z>�DZ9_jZ>sBO� H >@b@Éâon>[BO�e>@>[DòBf`kSUB F DZb=B�SCDZ^[>@bG9CP�Bf`Z>�>@jQ<:>�JTS»�>Âì F b�B»�}u'`Z>xDZ>[BO�e9:; V BO� H >¾<:;fS H `T^@SCDTon>xbf>@>[D²SCbeS H SUB=B�>[;fDÁPR9C;zS]��`Z9:?A>d^[?~SCb=be9CP¦<:;�S H `Zb@�}�-<:;�S H `b�SUB F b À >@b�B�`Z> H SUB=B�>[;fDò< F 8C>@DòoY��Bf`Z>�DZ>[BO�e9:; V BO� H >Á<C;�S H `äÉ F P F B�`kSCbà9:DZ?Ä�0BO� H >[b H ;f9r8 F jZ>[j F D�Bf`Z>BO� H >s<C;�S H `0SCDZjå^@9:DZDQ>@^[BfbGDZ9_jZ>@b�� F Bf`0>[jZ<:>@bd9CP&Bf`Z>�^[9:;f;=>@^ÂB¾BO� H >�9:DZ?Ä�:�'MÔ^@SC?I?¦Bf`Z>s<:;fS H ` F D²B�` F b^»SCb=>�S²ØäÍÂÏ*ÊzÛtÎaßàÞCÎfÕÂÖk×�� F Bf`²;f>@b H >[^[BxB�9�B�`Q>àDQ>[BO�e9:; V BO� H >�<:;fS H ` Ê E >ÂPi�VwZ�õqQ�-+CËÂ�`�aâ¶k· 9 2R¸ 0�¯�0~b ¹,¸�úÁû�%�û;��úb� 9 ¸å¼nû�¶ 9 6 ºC%�ûTú&6,¸©ü:¶Zµ@¸�µ[ú�´:'(��du'`Z>LDZ>[BO�e9:; V BO� H >L<:;�S H `ò9UPeBf`Z>L^»SCb=>�b�B�XZjg��9CPzS²j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j�^@9:D À <:XZ;�StB F 9CD�JTSCDZSC<:>@J�>@D�B�b��gbiKB�>@J F bÁb=`Z9r��D F D m F <:XZ;f>Y+g�,+g� u'`Q>0>ÂìQSCJ H ?A> F D!+_�Ap F D�B�;=9gjZXQ^@>@jþSC?I;=>»SCjg�­B�`Z>ÅBO� H >[bTDZ>[^@>@b=b�SC;��

PortRAWS

PortRA

RAWS

m F <:XZ;=>Ô+g�-+_��ç¦×kÍ�ØäÍÂÏ�ÊzÛtÎ�ßLÏéêaÖk;ÞCÎfÕÂÖk×�ÛiÚGÏR×kÍ�ðfÕtÙrÍGÙÂÏ*�QóCê�ePR9:;�JÁ9_jZ>@? F DZ<²SÅj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jò^@9:D À <:XZ;fSUB F 9:D�JÁSCDkSU<:>@J�>@D�Bàb=�_b=Bf>@JÅ�¿u'`Z>@;=> F bsS H ;f9_^@>[bfbàBO� H >ÁPR9C;;f>[8 F b F 9CD¿SC;f^a` F 8:>[b@ÉZBf`kSUB F bzBO� H >8gih�ÉZS H ;=9g^[>@bfbÔBO� H >]PR9:;e�e9:; V b H SC^@>[b@ÉkB�`ZSUB F b2j�kÔÉQSCDZj½B�`Q>GDZ9_jZ>BO� H >@bGPR9C;dB�`Q>�BO�z9¿j F �ä>[;f>[DYB H 9:;�B�b[ÉäB�`kStB]SC;=>=mTn�o�p5gih)PR9:; H 9:;�B�b¾on>[BO�e>@>[D�;=>[8 F b F 9:D©SC;f^a` F 8:>[b�SCDZjmTn�o p5gihijlk�PR9:; H 9:;�B�b}on>[BO�e>@>@DÁ;f>Â8 F b F 9:D�SC;f^a` F 8:>[beSUDZj��z9:; V b H SC^[>@b[��u'`Q>xBO� H >@bKgih-SCDZj�jlkòSC;=>B�`Z> H ;f9_^@>@b=b¾BO� H >[b�SCDZj0Bf`Z>�mrn�o p5gih SCDZj�mrn o�p5gih7jlk SC;=>�Bf`Z> H 9:;=BdBO� H >@b[�]u'`Z>�DZ>ÂBO�z9C; V BO� H ><:;�S H `0;f>Âëk>@^ÂB�bG9CXZ;x8 F >[�¤9CP}SÁj F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@jåb=�_b=Bf>@JÅÉ�b F DZ^[>�Bf`Z> H ;=9g^[>@b=bf>@bGSC;f>à^@9:DQDZ>@^ÂB�>@j©8 F S H 9:;=Bfb9�8C>@;'��` F ^a`²Bf`Z>]^@9CJÁJ�XQD F ^@SUB F 9:DÁB�S V >[b H ?~SC^[>C��h F DZ^@>GM��e9:XZ?Ij²? FIV >dB�9�b H >@^ F P��CÉQ��` F ^a` H 9:;=BÔ9CP�BO� H >mTn�o p5gih.on>@?A9:DZ<:b]Bf9²��` F ^a`1;=>[8 F b F 9:DòSC;=^a` F 8C>TSUDZjò��` F ^a` H 9:;�B�bàSC;=>�9CDZ?A�0XZbf>[j­o���SCD�SC;f^a` F 8:>UÉ�MF D�B�;=9gjZXQ^@>dBO�e9�BO� H >[b'9CPâ>[jZ<:>@b'on>[BO�e>@>[D H 9:;�B�be9CPâBO� H >7mrn�o p5gihèSCDZj½;=>[8 F b F 9:DTSC;f^a` F 8:>[b@ÉZDkSUJÁ>[?A�ÁSjkSCbf`Q>@j©SUDZj0S�b=9:? F j¿9:DZ>C���íjkSCb=`Z>@j0SC;f;=9r�*bf`Q9���b�B�`ZSUB�B�`Z> H 9:;=B�on>@?A9:DZ<:bÔBf9�Bf`Z>àSC;f^a` F 8:>UÉ�S�b=9:? F j9:DZ>]B�`kStB'B�`Z>àSC;=^a` F 8C>àXQbf>@b�B�`Q> H 9:;�B»�u'`Z>�<:;�S H ` F DÈm F <:XZ;f>+g�Äp F b¿S­DZ>ÂBO�z9C; V <:;fS H ` � F Bf` ;f>[b H >@^[B²Bf9­B�`Z>�DZ>ÂBO�z9C; V BO� H >ò<C;�S H ` F Dm F <:XQ;f>�+_�-+gÉ�b F DZ^[> F B�XQbf>@bL9:DQ?A�òBO� H >@bL< F 8:>[D F D­B�`Q>¿DZ>[BO�e9:; V BO� H >¿<:;fS H `ãSCDZj�Bf`Z>¿^@9:DQDZ>@^ÂB F 9CDZb9:o�>Â�½B�`Q>àDQ>[BO�e9:; V BO� H >�<:;fS H `ÅSCb'�e>@?I?¢� sîd>[BO�e9:; V <C;�S H `Qbà� F B�`ò;f>@b H >[^[BàB�90SÅDZ>ÂBO�z9C; V BO� H >�<:;�S H `�;=> H ;=>@b=>@D�B�B�`Q> H 9:bfb F oZ?A>�B�9 H 9:?I9C< F >[bG9CPB�`Z>xj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jÁb=�_b=Bf>@JÅ�}u�9�b H >@^ F P��LB�`Z>d;f>@^[9:D À <CXZ;�SUB F 9:D�9CP,S�< F 8:>@DÁB�9 H 9:?I9C<C�:É F �õ>U�YBf`Z>�B�;�SUDZb F B F 9CDPR9:;fJ79:DQ>ÁB�9 H 9:?A9:<C�©Bf9©SCDQ9CB�`Z>[;s9:DQ>CÉ3M F D�B�;f9_jZXZ^[>åØäÍÂÏ*ÊzÛtÎ�ßLÖnÎaÛ@ó��kðÂÏéРÛtØQÙ�< F 8C>@D­o���ÖQÕCÎÃÏ¢ÐéÕCÑ�ÞCÎ=ÕÂÖk×ÜTÛtÎOÖk×_ÐIÙÂÜsÙro��O��� g$on>[BO�e>@>@D�<:;fS H `Zb;�)SCDZj�g Ê E >[Pi�twZ�ApC�-+:ËÃ��� H SC;=B F SC?e<:;�S H `�JÁ9C; H ` F bfJo��?��� g$^@9:DZb F b�B�bL9CPdS H S F ;s9CP H SC;=B F SC? F Dtý=>[^[B F 8:>¿JÁS HZHZF DZ<:b�on>[BO�e>@>[D Bf`Z>¿bf>ÂBÁ9UP¾DZ9_jZ>[bLSCDZjB�`Z>�bf>ÂBs9CPz>@jZ<C>@bs9UP2�¤SCDZj�g�ÉvBf`kSUB�SC;=>Á^[9:J H SUB F oZ?I>�� F B�`�B�`Z>�<:;�S H `�b�B�;=XZ^[BfXZ;f>TSCDZj�Bf`Z>LBO� H >@b[�ïz9:J H SUB F oZ?I>'� F Bf`TB�`Q>G<:;�S H `½b=Bf;fXZ^ÂB�XZ;=>GJ�>»SCDZb�B�`kStBz��`Z>[DZ>[8C>@;'B�`Z>¾JTS HQHZF DZ<�PR9:;e>@jZ<:>[b F bejZ> À DZ>@jPR9:;ÔSCD¿>[jZ<:>UÉQB�`Z>[D¿B�`Z>GJÁS HZHQF DZ<sPR9C;zDZ9_jZ>@b F bÔjZ> À DZ>@j¿PR9:;eB�`Z>Gb=9:XZ;=^@>�SCDZj½Bf`Z>GBaSU;f<:>ÂBÔDZ9_jZ>G9CP,Bf`Z>

p<.

Page 24: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

>@jZ<:>U� W 9:;=>@9r8:>[;@É,B�`Z>�b=9:XZ;f^[>LDZ9gjQ> Ê BaSC;=<:>[BGDZ9gjQ>r˾PR9:;¾Bf` F b]>[jZ<:>L`kSCbGBf9Åon>LJTS HZH >[j�9:D�B�`Z>�Bf`Z>bf9:XZ;=^@>�DZ9_jZ> Ê BaSU;f<:>ÂBGDZ9_jZ>rËx9CP}B�`Z> F JÁSC<:>à9CP}B�`Z>s>@jZ<:>U��ïz9:J H SUB F oZ?I>]� F Bf`©B�`Z>�BO� H >�J�>»SCDQb¾B�`kStBDZ9gjQ>@b'SCDQj½>@jZ<C>@b�SC;=>¾JÁS HZH >@j½9:DQ?A��9:D½DZ9_jZ>[b'SCDZj½>[jZ<:>[b'9CP¦B�`Q>Gb�SCJ�>dBO� H >C��MNPâB�`Q>GJTS HZHZF DQ<:b�PR9C;DZ9gjQ>@bxSCDZjÅ>@jZ<C>@bxSC;f>]Bf9CBaSC?¢ÉQMe^»SC?A?äB�`Z>�<:;fS H `²J�9:; H ` F bfJ�ÏiÛtÏ ÕCÑÒ�u'`Z>�<C;�S H `��þ9CP�B�`Z>àDZ>[BO�e9:; VÅH ;f9_jZXZ^[B F 9:D F b�^@SC?I?A>@j�ÑIÍRÚÃÏ�Å ×QÕCØnó�ÙÂÐéó_Í'SCDZjåjZ>@b=^@; F o�>[bx��` F ^a`09Co_ý=>@^ÂB�bSTDZ>[BO�e9:; V <:;�S H `�J�XZb�BG^@9CDYB�S F D�b=XZ^a`�B�`kStBGB�`Z> H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CD©^»SCD�on>�S HQH ? F >@j¦�Gu'`Q>�9:o_ý=>@^ÂB�b F D��'É��`Z>@;=>�Bf`Z> H SC;�B F SC?g<C;�S H `LJ�9:; H ` F b=J F b&jZ> À DZ>@j¦É_SC;=> F D�B�>[DZjZ>[jLBf9]o�> H ;f>@b=>@;�8:>@jÁo���B�`Z>�S HZH ? F ^»SUB F 9:D9CPeBf`Z> H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CD¦É¦B�`Z>L9CBf`Z>@;�9:DQ>ÁSU;f>LjZ>@b F <:DZSUB�>[jòPR9:;�jZ>[?I>ÂB F 9CD¦��u'`Z>�<:;�S H `�g 9CPzBf`Z>LDZ>[BO�e9:; VH ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CD F b]^»SC?A?I>[j�ÎÃÐÄÞt×_Ï*Å ×QÕCØnó²ÙÂÐéó_ÍÂ���¾?A?&9:o_ý=>[^[Bfb�9CPeB�`Z>L; F <:`�B=KN`kSCDZj�b F jZ>�B�`ZSUBàSC;f>L9:XgB�b F jZ>L9CPB�`Z> F JÁSC<:>¾9CP�o Ê ��ËÔSC;=>àSCjZjZ>[jÅBf9LBf`Z> H ;f>[bf>[;=8:>[j©9:o_ý=>[^[Bfb@�`�aâ¶k· 9 2R¸ 0�¯ y b ¹,¸�úÁû�%�û;� 9 û&%('�´vüCú&)D%n¹:dm F <:XQ;f>¢+g�õqGbf`Q9���beSCD�>ÃìZSUJ H ?A>'9CP�S]DZ>[BO�e9:; VsH ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CD�PR9:;&B�`Z>';=>@^[9:D À <:XQ;�SUB F 9:D�9CPnB�`Q>ÔB�9 H 9:?I9C<C�:�u'`Z>�?I>[P�B�KO`kSUDZj�b F jZ>'^@9:DQb F b�B�b�9CP�S];f>Â8 F b F 9:DLSC;f^a` F 8:>UÉ�B�`kSUB�XQbf>@b�S H 9:;=BOmrn�o p5gih 9CP�SCDQ9CB�`Z>[;};f>Â8 F b F 9:DSC;f^a` F 8:> Ê F DZj F ^@SUB�>[jåo��¿Bf`Z>�b=9:? F jÅSC;f;=9��dËÃ�zu'`Z>àB�9 H 9:?A9:<C�½b=`kSC?A?âo�>�^a`kSCDQ<:>@j F DÅBf` F b'�zS»�:É�B�`kSUB�Bf`Z>^@9:DZDQ>@^[B F 9:D�B�9�B�`Z> H 9:;=B F b�^@XgBÔSCDQj½S�DZ>[� �e9:; V b H SC^@> F b�^@9:DQDZ>@^ÂB�>@j½Bf9àBf`Z>x;f>[8 F b F 9CDTSC;=^a` F 8C>C�}u'` F b

PortRA PortRA

PortRAWS

RAL

RA

r

WSR

m F <:XZ;=>i+g�õqQ�>���YÕCܾÖnÑIÍ�ÛiÚ�ÕÁØäÍÂÏ*ÊzÛtÎ�ß]ÖnÎaÛ@ó��kðÂÏéРÛtØNeF D�B�>[DZjZ>@jsJÁ>@SCD F DQ< F b�J�9gjQ>@?I>[jso���B�`Z> H SC;�B F SU?_<C;�S H `�JÁ9C; H ` F bfJ*PR9:;,B�`Q> H ;=9gjZXQ^[B F 9:D F Dsm F <:XZ;=>n+_�ôqQ�u'`Z>ÁJÁS HZHQF DZ<¿PR9:;�DZ9_jZ>@b F b]Bf9CBaSC?¢É,b F DQ^@>LB�`Z>�;f>Â8 F b F 9:DòSC;f^a` F 8:>TSCb]�z>[?I?�SCb�B�`Z> H 9C;=B F D��*`kS»8:>TS^@9:XZD�Bf>@; H SC;=B F D-g Ê F DZj F ^»StB�>@jLo���B�`Q>dSU;f;f9r��b�PR;f9:J��1B�9rg�ËÂ�3u'`Z>@;=>[PR9:;=>CÉYB�`Z>dSC;f^a` F 8:>dSCDZjLB�`Q> H 9:;�BSC;f> H ;f>[bf>[;=8:>[jãoY��Bf`Z> H ;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:D¦�Tu'`Z>TJÁS HZHZF DZ<²PR9:;àBf`Z>�>@jZ<:> F b H SC;�B F SU? É,b F DZ^@>LB�`Z>ÁJTS HZHZF DQ<F bsDQ9CB�jZ> À DZ>[jãPR9C;�B�`Q>T>@jQ<:> F D����0u'`Z>@;=>[PR9:;=>CÉ&B�`Q> H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:D­jZ>[?I>[Bf>@bsBf` F b�>@jZ<C>¿SCDZj­^[XQB�Bf`Z>^@9:DZDQ>@^[B F 9:DÅon>[BO�e>@>@DÅB�`Z> H 9:;=BxSUDZjÅBf`Z>àSC;f^a` F 8:>U��u'`Z>�JÁS HZHQF DZ<:bÔSC;f>]BO� H >�^[9:J H SUB F oZ?I>UÉQb F DZ^@>]Bf`Z>DZ9gjQ>@bx9CP&B�`Q>�?A>[P�B=KN`kSCDZjÅb F jZ>�SC;f>àJTS HZH >[jå9CD0DZ9_jZ>@bx9CP&Bf`Z>à; F <C`YB�KO`kSUDZjåb F jZ>�B�`ZSUBx`kS»8:>�Bf`Z>sbfSCJ�>BO� H >C��u'`Q>�^[9:J H SUB F o F ? F BO�¿� F B�`�;f>[b H >@^[B�Bf9²Bf`Z>L<:;�S H `�b=B�;=XZ^[BfXZ;f>�PR9:?A?I9r��b F JÁJ�>@j F SUB�>[?A�¿PR;=9:J�Bf`Z>PéSC^[B@É:B�`kSUB3B�`Z>'JÁS HZHZF DZ<¾PR9:;3>@jZ<:>[b F b&XZDQjZ> À DQ>@j¦��h F DZ^@>ÔBf`Z>Ô�e9:; V b H SC^@>dSCDZj�B�`Q> H 9:;�BOmrn o�p5gih7jlk9CP�Bf`Z>�; F <:`�B=KO`ZSCDZj²b F jZ>�SC;f>�DZ9UB F D¿B�`Z> F JTSC<C>G9CPvB�`Z>�J�9:; H ` F bfJÅÉgBf`Z>[�¿SC;f>�DZ>Â��?A�¿^[;f>»StB�>@jä� s� H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:D�o����c��g¤^»SUD¿o�>�S HQH ? F >@jTBf9LSsDZ>[BO�e9:; V <:;�S H `q� F PâB�`Z>]9:oYý=>@^[Bfb'9CP,B�`Z>¾?I>[P�B�KO`kSUDZjb F jQ>D� 9CP3B�`Z> H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:D09_^@^[XZ; F D��L�'u'` F bd9_^@^[XZ;f;=>@DZ^[> F b�^a`kSC;fSC^[Bf>@; F {@>[j©o��²B�`Z>�>Âì F b�B�>@DQ^@>s9UP�SB�9CB�SC?,<:;�S H `©JÁ9C; H ` F bfJ�PR;=9:J�� F DYBf9��LÉnBf`kSUBd�z>�^@SC?I?�Ü�ÕCÏOða× F DÅB�`Z>sPR9C?I?I9r� F DZ<Z�'u'`Z>�S HZH ? F ^»SUB F 9:D9CP�B�`Z> H ;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:D F b H >[;=PR9:;=JÁ>[j�o���SCjZj F DZ<©Bf`Z>¿DZ>[��>@?A>@J�>@D�B�b�9CP�Bf`Z>¿; F <:`�B=KO`ZSCDZj­b F jZ>¿9CP�Bf`Z>H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CD Ê B�`Z9:b=>CÉ3Bf`kSUBsSC;f>�DZ9CB F DòB�`Z> F JÁSC<:>L9CPzB�`Z> H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:D1J�9:; H ` F b=J½ËGSCDQj­jZ>@?A>[Bf>�Bf`Z>9:o_ý=>@^ÂB�b¾Bf`kSUBGSC;f>àjZ>@b F <:DZSUB�>[j©PR9:;djQ>@?I>ÂB F 9:D0o��²B�`Z> H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CD©SCDZjåB�`Z>�JTSUBf^a` Ê B�`Z9:b=>�9:o_ý=>[^[BfbG9CP�öB�`kStB�`ZSr8C>TS H ;=>ÂK F JÁSC<:>�XZDQjZ>@;8� Bf`kSUB F b]9:XQB�b F jZ>L9CP�B�`Q>�jQ9:JTS F D�9CP?o:ËÃ��MNPeBf`Z>L;f>[bfXZ?ÄB�9UPeBf`Z>jZ>@?A>[B F 9:D F b�DQ9CB}S¾<C;�S H `�SCD��gJ�9:;=>CÉ F �õ>U��Bf`Z>@;=>'SC;=>zbf9CJÁ>e>@jZ<:>[b3� F Bf`Z9:XQB�BaSC;=<:>[B�9:;�bf9:XZ;=^@>ÔDQ9gjZ>UÉCB�`Q>@DjZ>@?A>[B�>¾SC?Ib=9sB�`Q>G>@jZ<C>@b@� � >¾^@SC?I?�B�`Z>GS HZH ? F ^»StB F 9CDÁ9CPâS H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CDÁB�9�Ss<:;�S H `¿S²óCÐ�Î�ÍaðÂÏ�ó_ÍÂÎÃÐ�ÌtÕCϢРÛtØk�`�aâ¶k· 9 2R¸ 0�¯ ~ b ':)éû�¸_üCúH',¸_û;)¶ÿZ¶Qú<)*%n¹�du'`Z>L>ÂìQSCJ H ?I> F D�m F <CXZ;f>º+_�xw¿b=`Z9r��bàBf`Z> H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:D F D�m F <:XZ;=>º+g�õqTB�9:<:>ÂB�`Z>[;G� F Bf`�S½JÁSUBf^a` F D�SDZ>[BO�e9:; V <:;�S H `��L�¾u'`Z>�DQ>[BO�e9:; V <:;�S H `�� b=`Z9r��b�S H 9:bfb F oZ?A>�B�9 H 9:?A9:<C�¿9UP�STj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j©^[9:D À <tK

p&}

Page 25: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

XZ;�SUB F 9:D0JTSCDZSC<:>@J�>@D�B¾b=�_b=Bf>@J�^[9:DZb F b=B F DZ<½9UP}B�`Z;=>@>�;f>Â8 F b F 9:D�SC;=^a` F 8C>@b]^[9:DZDZ>[^[B�>[jò8 F S H 9C;=B�b[��u'`Z>JTSUBf^a`Áb H >[^ FÄÀ >@b[É_Bf`kSUB�B�`Z> H ;=9gjZXQ^[B F 9:D�bf`kSC?A?ko�>xS HQH ? F >@jLB�9�B�`Z>xSC;=^a` F 8C> F D�Bf`Z>dX HZH >[;�; F <C`YB�^[9:;fDZ>[;SCDZj½B�`Q>GX HZH >@; H 9:;=B�mTn�o�p5gihs��mk9:;zoQX F ?Aj F DZ<àB�`Z>¾j F ;=>@^[BÔjZ>@; F 8USUB F 9:D¦ÉYB�`Z>¾DZ>[�-�z9C; V b H SU^@>àSCDZj½Bf`Z>

PortRA

PortRA

PortRAWSPortRA

PortRA

PortRA

PortRA

PortRAWSPortRA

PortRA

RARA

RA

RA WSRA

RA

LRA

r

WSR

G

RA

match

m F <CXZ;f>Ô+g��wZ�>���YÕCܾÖnÑIÍ�ÛiÚàÕ¿óCÐ�Î�ÍaðÂÏzó_ÍÂÎÃÐ�ÌtÕCϢРÛtØNe

DZ>[� H 9:;�Be9UPäBO� H >�mTn�o�p5gih7jlk�SC;=>xSCjZjZ>[jÁB�9�B�`Q>d;=>[8 F b F 9:DÁSC;f^a` F 8:> F D��*< F 8:>@DÁo���B�`Z>xJTStB�^a`ÁSCDZjjZ>@?A>[B�>]Bf`Z>�>@jZ<:>�on>[BO�e>@>[D0B�`Z>�;=>[8 F b F 9:D²SC;=^a` F 8C>sSUDZj¿B�`Z> H 9:;=B@� s

0(¯ y 1 úr¸ 9 0 ´ÔB�6,¸5¹®%âü:¶V2n=¿¶Qúr¶ ø µ 9 ¸_üCú�µ¸%�ºd¶§=?)éµ[úrû;) ù ´âúr¸�' 1 �,µ[úr¸_·

�dP�B�>[;]`kS»8 F DZ<¿b H >[^ FAÀ >@j�B�`Z>�Bf9 H 9C?I9:< F ^»SC?vSCb H >[^[Bfbà9UPeBf`Z>�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�b��gb�B�>[J7oY��S½DZ>[BO�e9:; V BO� H ><:;�S H `¦ÉnBf`Z>s?A9g^@SC?,jkSUB�STSCb H >[^[B�b¾9CP H ;f9_^@>[bfb=>@b]SCDQj H 9C;=B�b¾SC;f>�^@9:DQb F jQ>@;f>[j�SCDZjåB�`Z> F ; H 9:b=b F oQ?I>à?I9_^»SC?b=BaStB�>@bLSU;f>½jZ>ÂB�>[;fJ F DZ>[j¦��u'`Z>¿?I9_^»SU?�jZSUBaS©9CPxS H ;f9_^@>@b=b�^»SCD�on>½b H >[^ FAÀ >@j F D­j F ��>@;f>[D�B�b H >@^ FAÀ ^@StKB F 9CDòBf>@^a`ZD F�� XZ>@b�SUb�<:;fS H `Zbà9:; H SC;�B F SU?}SC?I<C>@oZ;fSCb@Év` F >[;�SC;=^a` F ^@SC?�<:;�S H `Zb@Év>[Bf^C�²u'`Z>Á^a`Z9 F ^[>�PR9C;à9CDZ>b H >@^ FÄÀ ^»StB F 9CD�B�>[^a`ZD F�� XQ> F bàjZ; F 8:>[D­o��òBf`Z>½S HZH ? F ^»SUB F 9:Dä�½�¾b�JÁ>[DYB F 9:DQ>@j­SUo�9r8:>UÉ&MGXZb=>�ÕCÏéÏ¢ÎÃÐéÿ��_ÏiÍfóÞCÎfÕÂÖk×�ÙdPR9:;];=> H ;=>@bf>[D�B F DQ<0?I9_^»SU?3b=B�SUB�>[b@��u'`Z>@;=>TSU;f>Lbf>Â8:>@;fSC?�S HZH ;=9�SC^a`Z>[bàPR9C;�SUBfBf; F oQXQB�>[jò<C;�S H `Qb F DB�`Z>x? F B�>@;fSUB�XQ;f>Ô¦ � SC<:��}gÉôïÔáv�`vgÉôá�y9C�x�CqQÉ h_^a`k��+;¨¢�&M&XZb=>dBf`Z>¾S HZH ;f9:SC^a`T9CPK¦õïÔá,��v&¨ É_b F DZ^@>�B�` F b�S HZH ;=9�SC^a`À B�b�on>@b=B�Bf9�9CXZ;�^»SCb=>àb�B�XZjg�:��¾DàSUBfBf; F oZXQB�>[j�<:;�S H ` F b,S'<:;�S H `�SUbv>Ãì H ?~S F DZ>@j F DGB�`Z> H ;=>[8 F 9:XQbvb=>@^ÂB F 9CD���`Q>@;f>�DZ9_jZ>@b,SUDZj�>[jZ<:>[bv^@SCDo�>�SCjQj F B F 9:DkSU?I?A��> � X FIHZH >@j�o���SUB=B�; F oZXQBf>@b[���ÔB=B�; F oZXQBf>@b,JTS»�do�>}DZSUB�XZ;fSC?:DYXZJ�on>@;=b@Étb=Bf; F DQ<:b@É�on9g9:?A>»SCDQb9:;3>[?I>@J�>@D�Bfb&9CPnJÁ9C;f>z^[9:J H ?I>Ãì�SU?I<:>[oZ;�S F ^eb�B�;=XZ^[BfXZ;f>[b@���GDZ>ÔDZ9_jZ>Ô;=>@b H �:9:DZ>z>@jZ<:>zJTS»��^»SC;=;=��bf>[8C>@;fSC?SUBfBf; F oQXQB�>[b}SUB3Bf`Z>ÔbfSCJÁ>eB F J�>C�vu'`Z>�SUB=B�; F oZXQBf> F DQPR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:D¦É F �õ>U�tBf`Z> H 9Cbfb F oZ?I>zSUBfBf; F oZXQB�>[b�PR9:;&S¾DZ9_jZ>;f>@b H �USCDs>[jZ<:>CÉ F b,< F 8:>@DàPR9:;fJÁSC?A?A�Go��àSCD½ÕCÏ¢ÏéÎÃÐéÿ��gÏOÍfó¾ÞCÎ=ÕÂÖk×�ÙÂÐÄÞCØnÕCÏ*�gÎ�Í Ê E >[Pi�<wZ��wZ�Äp�ËÂ�3h F DQ^@>eBf`Z>�;f>»SUjZ>@;[É>@b H >@^ F SC?A?A�òS0;=>»SCjQ>@;���`Q9 F bàDZ9CBsPéSUJ F ? F SU;¾� F Bf`1B�`Z>ÁPR9:;fJÁSC?}okSC^ V <:;=9:XZDZjäÉ&� F ?I?�S HQH ;f>[^ F StB�>½Så?I>@b=bPR9:;fJÁSC? F D�Bf;f9_jZXZ^[B F 9:DäÉnM H ;f9r8 F jZ>àB�`Z>sSUBfBf; F oZXQB�> F DgPR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:D F DåSTb=9T^»SU?I?I>[j�ÕCÏéÏ¢ÎÃÐéÿ��_ÏiÍ]ÞCÎ=ÕÂÖk×_��u'`Z>SUBfBf; F oQXQB�>]<:;fS H ` F b�b F J F ?~SC;�B�9ÁSLBO� H >�<C;�S H `åSCDZjÅbf`Q9���bxB�`Z>�SUB=B�; F oZXQBf>]DkSCJ�>@bxSCDZjÅB�`Z>àSUB=B�; F oZXQBf>BO� H >@bàS¿DZ9_jZ>�9:;�SCD�>[jZ<:>�JÁSr�0^»SC;=;=�C�Lh F DQ^@>�DZ9CBàSU?I?3DQ9gjZ>[bàSCDZj�>@jZ<C>@b�`kS»8:>�B�9²^@SC;f;��0B�`Q>�bfSCJ�>SUBfBf; F oQXQB�>[b@ÉUBf`Z>ÔStBfB�; F oZXgB�>�<:;�S H `s`kSCbvPR9:;3>@SC^a`�j F �ä>[;f>[DYB3DZ9_jZ>z;=>@b H �U>[jZ<:>'SUB=B�; F oZXQB F 9:DàS¾b F DZ<C?I>�DZ9_jZ>SCDZj©S�b F DZ<:?I>�>[jZ<:>CÉn;f>[b H >@^ÂB F 8C>@?Ä�:���¾D0SUBfBf; F oQXQB�>[jå<:;fS H ` F bdSCD©SUB=B�; F oZXQBf>@jÅ<:;�S H `å� F B�`0;=>@b H >[^[B¾Bf9SCD©SUB=B�; F oZXQBf>�<C;�S H `äÉ F P F BfbdDQ9gjZ>[bGSCDQj©>@jZ<C>@b¾^@SC;f;��Å9:DZ?A�ÅStBfB�; F oZXgB�>@bdjZ> À DZ>@j F D09:DQ>s9CP&Bf`Z>sDQ9gjZ>[b

p</

Page 26: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

;f>@b H �Z>[jZ<:>@b F DTBf`Z>�SUBfBf; F oZXQB�>d<:;�S H `¦Ég��`Q>@;f>GBf`Z>]SUB=B�; F oZXQBf>@be`kS»8:>]^@9CDZ^@;=>[B�>G8USC?AXZ>@beBaS V >@D¿PR;f9:J.Bf`Z>jZ9:JÁS F D¿9CPvB�`Q>à^[9:;f;=>@b H 9:DQj F DZ<�SUB=B�; F oZXQBf>GBO� H >U�`�aâ¶k· 9 2R¸ 0�¯��~b B�6v¸å¶Qú»úrû;) ù ´âúr¸Å¼nû�¶ 9 6�%�º�ú<6v¸�ü:¶Zµ@¸�µ[ú�´:'(��dMOD�Bf`Z>�^»SUbf>�b=BfXZjQ��9UPzS¿j F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j�^@9:D À <:XZ;�StB F 9CD�JTSCDZSC<:>@J�>@D�B¾b=�_b=Bf>@JÅÉvMx`kS»8:>�Bf9¿b H >@^ F P��0Bf`Z>?I9_^»SC?_jkSUB�S F D�;f>Â8 F b F 9:D�SC;=^a` F 8C>@b�SCDZj��e9:; V b H SC^[>@b@��u'`Z>�?A9g^@SC?gb�BaSUBf>Ô9CP�SG;f>Â8 F b F 9:DLSC;=^a` F 8C>�SCb&�z>[?I?QSCbB�`Z>d?I9_^»SC?�b=B�SUB�>¾9CP,S��e9:; V b H SC^@> F bz< F 8:>[D½o��½Sàbf>[BÔ9CP,;f>Â8 F b F 9:DZb@�3MOD½B�`Z>d^»SCb=>G9CPvS�;=>[8 F b F 9:D½SC;f^a` F 8:>UÉB�`kSUBeSC;=>xBf`Z>x;f>[8 F b F 9CDZb�jZ>[8C>@?I9 H >[j F DLB�`Q>db F B�>UÉ F DLB�`Z>x^»SCb=>d9UPâS]�z9:; V b H SC^[>CÉQBf`kSUBeSC;=>xBf`Z>d;=>[8 F b F 9:DQbB�`Z>�jZ>Â8:>@?A9 H >@;}�z9C; V b�9:D¦�&M F D�B�;=9gjQXZ^@>[j�Bf`Z>xSUBfBf; F oQXQB�>[b}9CPä;=>[8 F b F 9:DQb F D�B�`Q>xjQ>@bf^[; FAH B F 9:DL9CP�Bf`Z>�^»SCb=>b=B�XQjQ� F Dåhg>[^[B F 9:D»+g�ApC��Me^@9:DQb F jQ>@; F D¿B�` F b'�z9C; V Bf`Z>sStBfB�; F oZXgB�>@bàó_ÛrðÁ�_ÜTÍÂØkÏ�Ðéó_ÍÂØkϢРËÔðfÕCÏéРÛtØ©ØV�_Ü�ÿÂÍÂÎÂÉÎaÍÂÌrÐIÙÂРÛtØÁØV�gÜ�ÿÂÍÂÎ�SCDZj�Bf`Z>sðaÛtØkÏiÍÂØkÏ�Ù�9CP�B�`Z>';=>[8 F b F 9:Dä�3u'`Z>'jZ9_^@XQJÁ>[DYB F jZ>@D�B FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:D�DYXZJ�on>@;[É�bf`Z9:;�B� n4�,� � É F DZj F ^»StB�>@b¦Bf9'��` F ^a`àjZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B,B�`Z>�;=>[8 F b F 9:D�on>@?I9CDZ<:b@�vu'`Z>�;f>Â8 F b F 9:D�DYXZJ�on>@;@Étbf`Q9:;=B�o4�V����ogÉF DZj F ^»SUBf>@bv��` F ^a`�8C>@;fb F 9:D�9UPkB�`Z>ÔjQ9g^[XZJÁ>[D�B&B�`Z>z;f>[8 F b F 9CD F b[�3u'`Z>'^[9:D�B�>@D�Bfb}bf`Z9r��b&B�`Q>Ô^@XZ;=;f>[DYB�b�BaSUBf>9CP¦B�`Q>¾jZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B F DLB�`Z>x8:>@;=b F 9:D½9CP¦Bf`Z>¾;=>[8 F b F 9:Dä�}m F <CXZ;f>Ñ+g�,vàbf`Q9���beB�`Z>d^@9:;=;f>@b H 9CDZj F DQ<�SUB=B�; F oZXQBf><:;�S H `�PR9:;&;f>Â8 F b F 9:DZb&9CDLBf`Z>'?I>ÂP�B=KN`kSCDZj�b F jZ>U��h F DZ^@>'SU?I?_;f>[8 F b F 9CDZb}9CPnjZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B�b F D�;f>Â8 F b F 9:DLSC;=^a` F 8C>@b

Attribute Graph AG

Attributed Graph with respect to AG

DocID = Natrevnr = STRINGcontent = STRING

Document

DocID = 14revnr = 1.5.4content = public class Foo....

Document

DocID = 7revnr = 2.5content = static class Bla....

Document

m F <:XZ;f>Ò+g�-v_��ç¦×kÍsÕCÏ¢ÏéÎÃÐéÿ��gÏO;ÞCÎ=ÕÂÖk×�Ú»ÛtÎàó_ÛrðÁ�gÜTÍÂØkÏ�ÙsÕCØnó½ÕCØ�ÕCÏéÏ¢ÎÃÐéÿ��_ÏiÍfóLÞCÎ=ÕÂÖk×fe

SCbx�e>@?A?3SUb F D F DÅ�z9C; V b H SU^@>@b]`ZSr8C>�Bf`Z>sbfSCJÁ>�SUB=B�; F oZXQBf>@b@ÉnMÔ`kS»8C>�9:DZ?Ä�²9:DZ>àDZ9gjQ> F D²B�`Q>�SUB=B�; F oZXQBf><:;�S H `¦� W 9C;f>@9r8C>@;@É�M,`kS»8C>'DZ9G>@jQ<:>@b F D�B�`Q>Ô?I9_^»SC?Yb�BaSUBf>@b}9CPnS¾;=>[8 F b F 9:D�SC;f^a` F 8:>Ô9C;&Sd�e9:; V b H SC^@>U��u'`Z>SUBfBf; F oQXQB�>àBO� H >�9CP�Bf`Z>�jZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B F jZ>@D�B FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:D0DYXZJ�on>@; � n4�,� ��F bG< F 8C>@D©o��0DkSUB�XQ;�SC?vDYXZJ�on>@;fb[�u'`Z>¾StBfB�; F oZXgB�>ÔBO� H >'PR9:;}Bf`Z>�;f>[8 F b F 9CD�DYXZJso�>[; F b�S�b�B�; F DZ<ZÉ�b F DZ^[>¾S];=>[8 F b F 9:DLDYXZJ�on>@; F b};=> H ;=>@bf>[D�B�>@joY�åS�bf> � XZ>[DZ^@>�9UP&DYXZJ�on>@;=b¾bf> H SC;fSUB�>[j©o��0S H 9 F D�B»��ïz9CDZb F jZ>@;¾SCbd>ÃìQSCJ H ?I>�B�`Z>à;f>Â8 F b F 9:D0DYXZJ�on>@;=b9CP,B�`Z>]jZ9_^@XQJÁ>[DYBfb F D½Bf`Z>]; F <:`�B'`kSCDZj²b F jZ>]9CP,Bf`Z> À <:XZ;=>C�}u'`Z>�X HQH >[;'jZ9g^[XZJ�>@D�B�`kSCbÔBf`Z>];f>Â8 F b F 9:DD_XQJ�o�>[;Tp� ,vI �wZÉ3Bf`Z>T?A9��e>@;�jZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B�`kSUb�B�`Q>TDYXZJ�on>@;º+� -vg�Åu'`Z>½J�>»SUD F DZ<å9CPÔBf` F b�b=�_D�BaStì F b�SCbPR9:?I?A9���b[��u'`Z> À ;=b=BsD_XQJ�o�>[;�9CP'Bf`Z>½bf> � XZ>@DZ^[> F DZj F ^»SUBf>@b�B�`Z>TD_XQJ�o�>[;�9CPÔBf`Z>½jZ9_^@XQJÁ>[DYB�SCDZj1Bf`Z>À ;fb�B�8C>@;fb F 9:D19CP'SÅjZ9g^[XZJ�>@D�Bs`ZSCbs9:DQ?A��SÅb F DQ<:?I>LDYXZJ�on>@;�SCbs;=>[8 F b F 9:DòDYXZJ�on>@;[É�PR9:;à>ÂìQSCJ H ?I>�Bf`Z>D_XQJ�o�>[;Lp:��MNP�B�` F b À ;fb�B�;=>[8 F b F 9:D F b]^a`kSCDZ<:>[j¦ÉvS¿DZ>[�.;=>[8 F b F 9:D F b]<:>@DQ>@;�StB�>@jò`kS»8 F DZ<¿Bf`Z>LD_XQJ�o�>[;p� ApC��Bf`Z>�DZ>Âì_Bx8:>[;fb F 9:DÅ`kSCb�B�`Z>�DYXZJ�on>@;�p� ,+�SUDZj²bf9T9CD¦��MNP3B�`Q>à;=>[8 F b F 9:D�p� ,+ F b'^a`kSCDQ<:>@j¦Ék�e>�<C>[BdS;f>[8 F b F 9CD¿p� -+� Ap:�vMNPn�z>'^a`kSUDZ<:>ÔB�`Q>';f>[8 F b F 9CD½p� ,+GSC<�S F D¦ÉU�e>�<:>[B�SGDQ>[� ;f>[8 F b F 9CD¿p� -+� -+¾SUDZjLbf9]9:D¦�3u'`Z>^@9:D�B�>[D�B�b�9CPeS½;f>Â8 F b F 9:D F bGS½b=B�; F DZ<²SUb¾�z>[?I?¢�àu'`Q>LSUBfBf; F oQXQB�>[j�<:;�S H `�b F <CDkSUB�XQ;f>sPR9:;xB�` F b]SUB=B�; F oZXQBf><:;�S H ` F b'< F 8C>@D F DÅ|3ìQSCJ H ?I>ÒwZ�Äpr�Q�u'`Z>T?A9g^@SC?}b=B�SUB�>�9CP�S²;f>Â8 F b F 9:D­SC;=^a` F 8C>Á9C;sS²�z9:; V b H SC^[>½^@9CDYB�S F DQb�b=>[8:>[;�SC?eDZ9_jZ>@b[É�B�`ZSUBs`ZSr8C>ÁBf`Z>SUBfBf; F oQXQB�>[bG< F 8C>@D F DåB�`Z>LSUB=B�; F oZXQBf>�<:;fS H `¦Éä��`Q>@;f>�Bf`Z>LSUBfBf; F oZXQB�>[bG`kS»8:>L^[9:DZ^@;=>[Bf>L8USC?AXZ>@b[���GD©Bf`Z>; F <C`YB�KO`kSUDZj�b F jQ>�9UPeBf`Z>�m F <:XQ;f>H+g�,vTBO�z9å;f>[8 F b F 9CDZb]9CPÔjQ9g^[XZJÁ>[D�B�b]� F Bf`ò;=>@b H >[^[BsBf9¿B�`Z>�SUB=B�; F oZXQBf><:;�S H `Å9CDÅBf`Z>�?I>[P�B�KO`kSUDZj¿b F jZ>àSC;f>�bf`Q9���Dä� s

pr�

Page 27: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

m�9C;�Bf`Z>xb H >@^ FÄÀ ^»StB F 9CDÁ9CP�B�`Z>x^»SUbf>xb=B�XQjQ� F DLB�` F b��e9:; V É_B�`Z>dSUB=B�; F oZXQBf>@b}PR9:;�;f>Â8 F b F 9:DZb�9CP¦jZ9_^@XQJÁ>[DYBfb^@9 F DZ^ F jZ> F D�;=>[8 F b F 9:D©SC;f^a` F 8:>[b@Éâ�z9C; V b H SU^@>@b�SCDZj�Bf`Z> H 9C;=B�b[��u'`Q>@;f>ÂPR9:;f>UÉâB�`Z>�b H >[^ FAÀ ^»SUB F 9:D�9CP�Bf`Z>?I9_^»SC?ejkSUBaS F b�^@9:J H ?A>[B�>[?A��< F 8C>@Dão��­B�`Q>åStBfB�; F oZXgB�>½<:;fS H ` F Dãm F <:XZ;=>?+g�,vg�­MNPxB�`Z>²StBfB�; F oZXgB�>@b�PR9C;;f>[8 F b F 9CDZbsb=`kSC?I?�j F �ä>[; F D1;f>[8 F b F 9CD�SC;f^a` F 8:>[b@É}�e9:; V b H SC^@>[bÁSUDZj H 9:;=Bfb@É&B�`Q>¿SUBfBf; F oZXQB�>[bs`kS»8C>½B�9©on>b H >@^ FÄÀ >@jåbf> H SC;�StB�>@?Ä�¿PR9:;'B�`Z>�SC;=^a` F 8C>CÉ�B�`Z>��z9C; V b H SU^@>�SCDQjåB�`Q> H 9:;=Bfb@�eu'` F b F b�J�>»SCD F DZ<CPRXZ?¢ÉZ>@b H >ÃK^ F SU?I?A� F PzSUjZj F B F 9:DZSC?3StBfB�; F oZXgB�>@bdPR9:;];f>Â8 F b F 9:DZb�SC;=>�^@9:DZb F jZ>[;f>[j¦��h F DQ^@>�B�`Q>�PR9g^[XZb]9CP�B�` F bG�z9:; V SC;=>B�`Z>à^@9:DQ^@> H B�bG9CP3j F b�B�; F oZXQB F 9:DåSCDZjåDZ9CBxB�`Z>àjZ>Â8:>@?A9 H J�>@D�BG9UP}SÁb=9 H ` F b=B F ^»StB�>@j0SUBfBf; F oZXQB�>�b�B�;fXQ^[B�XQ;f>SCDZj�PR9:;GB�`Z>LbfS V >�9CPÔb H SC^[>CÉvM¾`kS»8:>�^a`Z9:b=>@D1Bf` F b]b F J H ?I>[;G^»SUbf>C��u'`Z>�^»SCb=>CÉ,��`Z>@;=>�Bf`Z>ÁSUBfBf; F oQXQB�>[b9CP�;f>[8 F b F 9CDZb F D0;f>[8 F b F 9CD�SC;f^a` F 8:>[bàSCDZj©�e9:; V b H SC^@>[b�j F �ä>[; F b H 9Cbfb F oZ?I> F D�9:XQ;¾PR;�SCJ�>[�e9:; V SCbd�z>[?I? �u'` F b�JÁ9:;=>zjZ>ÂBaS F ?I>[jsb H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:D�9CPQB�`Z>'StBfB�; F oZXgB�>@bvPR9:;�Bf`Z>z?A9g^@SC?YjkSUB�S F b H ;f>[bf>@D�Bf>@j F D?¦�u�m&\ l �C��¨ �MODà^[9:D�B�;fSCb=B,B�9ÔBO� H >@b[ÉUB�`ZSUB,SC;=> À ìg>@j�B�`Z;=9:XZ<:`Z9CXQBâB�`Z>}>Ãì F b=Bf>@DZ^[>�9CPgBf`Z>}DZ9_jZ>@bvSCDQj]>@jZ<:>[b@ÉCSUBfBf; F oQXQB�>[b^»SCD ^a`kSCDZ<:>ÅB�`Z> F ;L8USC?IXZ>U� u'` F b�>@DZSCoZ?I>[b@ÉÔPR9:;�>ÂìQSCJ H ?A>CÉeBf91J�9gjQ>@?'B�`Z>Å^a`kSCDQ<:>09CP¾B�`Z>å^@9:D�B�>[D�B�b9CPGS©;=>[8 F b F 9:Dä���d9r�"SUD StBfB�; F oZXgB�>½b=`kSC?I?zo�>¿^a`kSUDZ<:>@j F b�b H >[^ FÄÀ >@j�o��ãSCDèÕCÏ¢ÏéÎÃÐéÿ��gÏOÍfó²ÖnÎ�Û@ó���ðÂÏéРÛtØÊ E >[Pi�<wQ�xwZ�,v:ËÃ�vMODsS À ;fb=Bvb�B�> H ÉC9:DZ>�^»SUD�^[9:DZb F jZ>@;�SCD�SUBfBf; F oZXQB�>[j H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CD�on>[BO�e>@>[DsBO�z9¾SUBfBf; F oZXQB�>[j<:;�S H `Zb¾SUb¾S H SC;=B F SC?ä<:;�S H `0J�9:; H ` F bfJ�o�>ÂBO�z>[>@D�<:;fS H `Zb¾SCbd>Ãì H ?~S F DZ>@j F DÅb=Bf> H pC�'�d9r�e>[8:>[;@ɦb F DZ^[>�z>åjZ91DZ9UBÁ�zSCD�BÁBf9 H ;=9r8 F jZ>²PR9:;Á>@SC^a` H 9:b=b F oQ?I>Å^@9:D�B�>[D�B�bT9UP�S�;=>[8 F b F 9:D�9:DZ>Å9:; H 9:b=b F oZ?A��J�9:;=>H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CDZb@ÉvB�`kSUB�J�9gjZ>[?&B�`Z>Á^a`kSCDZ<C>T9CP�SÅ^@9:DQ^@;f>ÂB�>½^[9:D�B�>[DYBfb@É&�e> F DYBf;f9_jZXZ^[>åÌtÕCÎÃÐéÕ�ÿ@ÑIÍaÙGPR9C;àBf`Z>SUBfBf; F oQXQB�>[b F DÅBf`Z>sStBfB�; F oZXgB�>@jÅ<:;fS H `Zbd9CP3Bf`Z> H ;f9_jZXZ^[B F 9:Dä�Ôu'`Z>�StBfB�; F oZXgB�>@bx9CP H ;f>[bf>@;�8:>[jòDQ9gjZ>[b F DB�`Z>x?I>ÂP�B=KO`ZSCDZj�b F jQ>x9UP,SCDÁSUBfBf; F oQXQB�>[j H ;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:D�JTS»�Lon>d^a`ZSCDZ<:>[j½o���B�`Z> H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:D¦É���`Z>@;=>dBf`Z>DZ>[�.8USC?AXZ>L^»SCD�o�>�^»SC?A^@XZ?ISUB�>[j�o���S²^@>@;�BaS F D19 H >@;fSUB F 9:D H 9Cbfb F oZ?A�©okSCbf>[j­9:DòB�`Z>L8USC; F SCoZ?I>[b�9CPzBf`Z>?I>[P�B�KO`kSUDZj�b F jZ>C��MODòb=XZ^a`�ST�ÔS»�:ÉâBf`Z>�8USC; F SCoZ?I>[b]SC?A?I9r�¤B�9¿b H >[^ F P��0B�`Z>�^a`kSUDZ<:>�9CPzSUBfBf; F oZXQB�>�8CSU?IXZ>[bJÁ9:;=>�SCoZb=Bf;�SC^ÂB�?Ä�:�¿MG`kS»8C>ÁB�9åJÁ>[D�B F 9CD¦É�`Q9��e>[8C>@;[É&B�`kSUB�Bf`Z>T^a`kSUDZ<:>T9UP'SUB=B�; F oZXQBf>@b F b�DZ9CBsSCbà>»SCb��SCb F B F bd>Ãì H ?~S F DZ>@j©`Q>@;f>U�¾uv9½<:>ÂB]STJ�9:;f>àjZ>ÂBaS F ?I>@jå>Âì H ?ISCDkSUB F 9:Då9CP&B�`Q>s^a`kSCDQ<:>�9CP�SUB=B�; F oZXQBf>@b[ÉnBf`Z>;f>»SUjZ>@;�JTS»��`kS»8:>½S0?I9_9 V©F D�B�`Q>ÁPR9:;=JTSC? H SC;=B F D­hg>@^ÂB F 9CD�wZ��wZ�ApÁ9:; F D�Bf`Z>T? F Bf>@;�StB�XZ;=>�J�>@D�B F 9:DZ>[jB�`Z>[;f>C��¾DàSUBfBf; F oZXQB�>[j H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:D]^»SCD�on>�S HZH ? F >[jGB�9�SCDàSUB=B�; F oZXQBf>@j]<:;fS H `�o�� À DZj F DZ<�S'JÁSUB�^a` Ê E >[Pi�7wZ��wZ�x.�ËPR9:;eBf`Z>]?I>ÂP�B=KO`ZSCDZj½b F jZ>G9UPvBf`Z> H ;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:D²SCbz>Âì H ?~S F DZ>[j F D½Bf`Z> H ;=>[8 F 9:XQb'bf>@^ÂB F 9:D½PR9:;eBO� H >@jÅ<:;�S H `B�;�SUDZb=PR9:;=JTStB F 9CD¦�TceXQB F D1SUjZj F B F 9:DäÉ,Bf`Z>�JTSUBf^a`�b=XZoZb�B F BfXQB�>[b�Bf`Z>Á8USC; F SCoZ?A>@b]9CPeB�`Z>Á?I>ÂP�B=KO`ZSCDZj�b F jZ>� F B�`�^[9:DZ^@;=>[Bf>�8USC?AXZ>@b,< F 8:>@D F D]Bf`Z>�SUBfBf; F oQXQB�>[j�<:;fS H `¦Ér��`Z>[;f>�B�`Z>�SUB=B�; F oZXQBf>@j H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:D F bvS HZH ? F >[jB�9Z�u'`Z>ÔS HQH ? F ^»SUB F 9:D�9CP�SUD�SUB=B�; F oZXQBf>@j H ;f9_jZXZ^[B F 9:D�SUB3Sd< F 8:>[D�JTStB�^a` F b�< F 8:>[Dso���B�`Z>ej F ;=>@^ÂB3jZ>[; F 8CStB F 9CDSCb²>Âì H ?~S F DZ>[j F D÷b�B�> H pòPR9C;½BO� H >@j÷<:;�S H `Zb Ê E >[Pi�ÉwQ�xwZ�x.�ËÃ� MOD-B�`Z>ò^»SUbf>ò9CP�StBfB�; F oZXgB�>@j-<:;fS H `Zb[ÉB�`Z>T8USC?AXZ>@b�9CP'B�`Q>½SUB=B�; F oZXQBf>@bs9UP'B�`Z>½jQ>@; F 8:>[j�<:;�S H `�SC;f>TSCjZj F B F 9:DkSC?A?A�©^@SC?I^[XZ?~StB�>@j1okSCbf>[j�9:D1Bf`Z>SCbfb F <:DZJ�>@D�B�9CPv8USC; F SCoZ?A>@b'< F 8:>@D²o��¿B�`Q>àJÁSUBf^a`¦�`�aâ¶k· 9 2R¸ 0�¯ � b ¶Qú@úrû;) ù ´,ú»¸�' 9 û&%('v´vüCú&)*%n¹þ¶Z¹�'�':)éû�¸_üCúH',¸_û;)¶ÿZ¶Qú<)*%n¹�d�ÔB&B�`Z>eB�9 H 9CPnm F <:XZ;=>É+g�x.dBf`Z>�SUBfBf; F oZXQB�>[j H ;=9gjZXQ^[B F 9:DsPR9:;vB�`Z>z^a`kSCDZ<:>'9UPkB�`Z>'^[9:D�B�>@D�Bfb}9CP�S¾;f>Â8 F b F 9:DF D1Bf`Z>T�e9:; V b H SC^@> F bsbf`Q9���Dä�òu'`Q>²SUBfBf; F oQXQB�>[j H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:D­`kSCbs9:DZ>½jZ9_^@XQJÁ>[DYB F D F B�b�?I>[P�B�KO`kSUDZjb F jQ>CÉâ��`Z>@;=>�B�`Z>�SUB=B�; F oZXQBf>@b]jZ9_>@b�DZ9CB�`ZSr8C>Á^[9:DZ^[;f>[Bf>�8USC?AXZ>@b]oQXQB]8USC; F SCoZ?I>[bi�,p:É�¡:p�SCDZj�¡;+_��u'`Z>SUBfBf; F oQXQB�>[j H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:D H ;=>@bf>[;=8C>@b¿B�`Z>0;f>[8 F b F 9CD 9CP]B�`Q>©jZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B»É�oZXgB½^a`kSCDQ<:>@b½Bf`Z>�SUB=B�; F oZXQBf>ðaÛtØkÏiÍÂØkÏ�ÙÂ�Lu'`Z>TStBfB�; F oZXgB�>�8USC?IXQ>�9CPzBf`Z>�SUBfBf; F oQXQB�>�^[9:D�B�>@D�Bfb F D�Bf`Z>ÁjQ9g^[XZJÁ>[D�B�9UPeBf`Z>L; F <C`YB�KO`kSUDZjb F jQ> F b'^»SC?A^@XZ?ISUB�>[j²oY�¿SCDå9 H >[;�SUB F 9:Dq�q¢�£f��¤¦¥§o4¨"��¢©p5�:��u'`Z> F D�Bf>@DZjZ>[j0J�>»SCD F DZ<�9CPvB�` F b�9 H >@;�StB F 9CDPR;f9:J Bf`Z>Å8 F >[� H 9 F D�BÁ9CP]9:o_ý=>[^[B�KO9:; F >@D�Bf>@j H ;f9:<:;fSCJ�J F DZ<�?~SCDZ<CXkSC<:>[b F b@ÉzBf`kSUB F B�jZ>[^@?~SU;f>@bÁS�^[?~SCb=bB�9©on>½S H ; F 8USUBf>T^[?~SCb=b@�©u'`Z>T9 H >[;�SUB F 9:D�<:>[BsB�`Z>½9C?Ij1^[9:D�B�>[DYBfb@É}B�`ZSUB F b�S0^[?~SCb=b F DòB�`Z>½>ÃìQSCJ H ?I>CÉSCb F D H XQB@�Gu'`Z>�;=>[8 F b F 9:DåD_XQJ�o�>[;]SCDZj©Bf`Z>sjQ9g^[XZJÁ>[D�B F jZ>[D�B FAÀ ^»SUB F 9:DÅDYXZJ�on>@;G;=>@JÁS F DåXZDZ^a`kSCDQ<:>@j

+C�

Page 28: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

oY��Bf`Z> H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:D¦��u'` F b F b F DZj F ^»SUBf>@j�o���B�`Q>ÅbfSCJ�>²8USC; F SCoQ?I>TPR9:; � n4�,� � SUDZjªo4�V���Go©9CD�Bf`Z>?I>[P�B�KO`kSUDZj1b F jZ>TSCDZj�Bf`Z>½; F <:`�B=KN`kSCDZjòb F jZ>T9UP'B�`Z> H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CD¦�²u'` F b H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CD F bsS HZH ? F >[jòBf9�S

DocID = x1

content = s2

DocID = x1revnr = s1content = make-private(s2)

DocID = 2revnr = 2.3content = public class Bla...

DocID = 1revnr = 1.5.4content = private class Foo ...

L R

r

G H

Document

revnr = s1

Document

DocID = 2revnr = 2.3content = public class Bla...

DocID = 1

content = public class Foo...

Document

revnr = 1.5.4

Document

DocumentDocument

m F <:XZ;f>Ò+g�,.g�T«�×QÕCØ_ÞCÐ�Ø_ÞLÏR×kÍ�ðaÛtØkÏOÍÂØkÏ�Ù�ÛiÚ�Õ¿ó_ÛrðÁ�gÜTÍÂØkÏ e<:;�S H `��¤^@9:DQb F b�B F DZ<�9UP¦BO�z9�jZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B�b�B�`kStBzJÁS»�L;f> H ;f>@b=>@D�BÔBf`Z>db=>[Bz9CP¦;=>[8 F b F 9:DZb F DTS��e9:; V b H SC^[>C�u'`Z>�JÁSUB�^a`ÅPR9:;xBf`Z> H ;f9_jZXZ^[B F 9:Då^a`Z9_9:bf>[bG9:DZ>�9CP}B�`Z>�jZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B�bxB�9½^a`ZSCDZ<:> F B�bx^@9CDYBf>@D�B�b[�GMOD0Bf`Z>>ÂìQSCJ H ?I>UÉnBf`Z>sJÁSUB�^a`å^a`Z9_9:bf>[b¾B�`Z>�X HZH >@;djZ9g^[XZJ�>@D�B¾� F B�` � n4�,� �­¬ p:�xcz>[^»SCXQbf>�9CP3B�` F b¾JÁSUB�^a`¦ÉB�`Z>�8USC; F SCoZ?A>r�,p F b¾bfXQoZb=B F B�XgB�>@j�� F Bf`©B�`Z>�8CSU?IXZ>½pCÉäB�`Z>�8USC; F SCoQ?I>D¡�p�� F B�`�p� ,vI �w²SCDZj©Bf`Z>�8USC; F SCoZ?I>¡;+s� F B�`½Ö3�Zÿ@ÑÒРð�ðÂÑÄÕtÙaÙ�®�ÛrÛAe¯e¯eI�u'`Z>Lj F ;=>@^[B�jQ>@; F 8USUB F 9:D�9CP�B�`Z>�SUB=B�; F oZXQBf>@j H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:DòSUB]B�` F b]JTStB�^a`�jZ9_>@b�DZ9CB�jZ>[?I>ÂB�>L9:;]^@;=>»SUBf>SCD���DZ9_jZ>CÉ�b F DZ^[>ÔB�`Z>�StBfB�; F oZXgB�>@j H ;f9_jZXZ^[B F 9:DsjZ9g>[b}DZ9CB�^a`kSUDZ<:>ÔB�`Q>'<:;�S H ` F ^@SC?gb�B�;=XZ^[BfXZ;f>U���d9r�z>Â8:>[;@É��`Z>@;=>»SCbTBf`Z>©<:;fS H ` F ^»SC?�b�B�;fXQ^[B�XQ;f> F b H ;=>@b=>@;=8C>@j¦ÉxB�`Z>0SUBfBf; F oZXQB�>ãðaÛtØkÏiÍÂØkÏ�9CP]Bf`Z>0jQ9g^[XZJÁ>[D�B©p F b^a`kSCDZ<:>[jåPR;=9:J Ö3�Qÿ@ÑÒРð�ðÂÑÄÕtÙaÙi®vÛrÛAe¯e¯e}Bf9�ÖnÎÂÐ�ÌtÕCÏOÍ�ðÂÑÄÕtÙaÙi®vÛrÛAe¯e¯eI� s

0(¯ ~ 1 úr¸ 9Íy ´r��%�· 9 %�¹,¸_¹�úbû�)¢µ@¸ 1 9 ¸gü�)¶±3ü:¶Qú&)D%�¹�%nº|=?)¢µÂúrû;) ù ´,ú»¸�' 1 �,µ[úr¸_·­µMOD�b=B�> H p:É�Bf`Z>sB�9 H 9:?A9:< F ^»SC?,SCb H >[^[Bfb]9CPeSTj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j©b��_b=B�>[J��e>@;f>�b H >[^ FÄÀ >@j�o���STDQ>[BO�e9:; V BO� H ><:;�S H `LBf`kSUB H ;=9�8 F jZ>@b}B�`Q>�BO� H >@b�9CP H ;f9_^@>[bfbf>[bÔSCDQj H 9:;=Bfb&B�`kStBeJÁS»��9_^@^[XZ; F D�S]j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jLb=�_b=Bf>@JÅ�MOD�b=B�> H +gÉCBf`Z>Ô?I9_^»SU?_jZSUBaSGb�BaSUBf>@b}SC;=>Ôb H >@^ FAÀ >[j�o���SUB=B�; F oZXQBf>@j�<:;fS H `Zb3;f> H ;f>@b=>@D�B F DZ<GB�`Q>Ô?I9_^»SC?_b=B�SUB�>[b9CP H ;f9_^@>@b=bf>[bGSCDZj H 9:;=Bfb@�MODãBf`Z> À ;=b=B H SC;�B�9CP�B�` F b�b=Bf> H É�M F D�B�;=9gjQXZ^@>òóCÐIÙÂÏéÎÃÐéÿ��gÏOÍfó0ÞCÎ=ÕÂÖk×�ÙàB�`kStB F D�B�>[<:;�StB�>TBf`Z>½B�9 H 9:?A9:< F ^@SC?SCDZj­B�`Q>¿?I9_^»SC?�jkSUB�S�SCb H >@^ÂB�b F D�9:DZ>½^[9:JÁJ�9:D­b�B�;=XZ^[BfXZ;f>U��M�bf`Q9��ö`Z9r�öj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�<:;fS H `Zb�^@SCDo�>LJÁSCD FIH XZ?~SUBf>@j�o�� óCÐIÙÂÏ¢ÎÃÐéÿ��_ÏiÍfó�ÖnÎ�Û@ó��kðÂϢРÛtØQÙGSCDZj F D�B�;=9gjQXZ^@>åóCÐIÙÂÏéÎÂÐéÿ��_ÏOÍfó¿ÞCÎfÕÂÖk×�Ï¢Î=ÕCØQÙRÚ»ÛtÎÃÜ�ÕCϢРÛtØk�� >½� F ?I?�bf>@>UÉ�Bf`kSUB�Bf` F b À ;fb=B�S HZH ;f9:SC^a`ãjZ9g>[b�DZ9CBL;=>[ëk>[^[BLB�`Z>¿?A9g^@SC? F BO�òSCb H >@^ÂB�b F DãS©j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jb=�_b=Bf>@J 8C>@;��þ�e>@?I?¢�èMOD 9:;=jZ>@;ÁB�9­XZb=>©j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@jþ<:;�S H `þB�;fSCDZb=PR9C;fJÁSUB F 9:D�PR9C;ÁB�`Q>©b H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:D9CPzj F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j�b=�_b=Bf>@J�b@ÉvM F D�Bf;f9_jZXZ^@> F D�B�`Z>Lbf>[^@9:DQj H SU;=Bà9CP�B�` F b]b=B�> H ^[9:DZ^[> H BfbàPR9:;]j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j

+gp

Page 29: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

<:;�S H `LBf;�SCDQb=PR9:;=JTSUB F 9:Ds;f>[ëZ>@^[B F DZ<à?I9_^»SU? F BO��SCb H >[^[Bfb@�}u'`Z>[bf>x^@9:DZ^[> H BfbzSU;f>'JÁS F DZ?Ä�soZSCbf>[jÁ9:D�ÖnÎ�ÛrðaÍaÙaÙÖnÎaÛ@ó��kðÂÏéРÛtØQÙÂÉzB�`kStB½SC;=>0;=>@b=Bf; F ^[B�>[j j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:DZb�JÁ9_jZ>@? F DZ<òSCD SC^[B F 9:D 9CP]9:DZ>åb F DZ<:?I>H ;f9_^@>[bfbs� F B�`Z9:XgB V DZ9r��?I>[jZ<:>Á9CP'9CBf`Z>@; H ;f9_^@>[bfbf>[b@�0m�9C;�>@SC^a` H ;=9g^[>@bfb�BO� H > F DòBf`Z>TDZ>ÂBO�z9C; V BO� H ><:;�S H `¦É3�e> H ;f9r8 F jZ>½SÅÖnÎ�ÛrðaÍaÙaÙ�ÞCÎ=ÕCÜ�Ü�ÕCÎÃ�0� H ;f9_^@>[bfb�<:;fSCJÁJÁSC;�9CPxS0^[>@;�BaS F D1BO� H >½b H >[^ FÄÀ >@b�Bf`Z>o�>[`kS»8 F 9:;x9CP�S H ;=9g^[>@b=bG9CP}B�` F b�BO� H >�SCDQj©^@9:D�B�S F DZb¾SÁb=>[B]9CP H ;f9_^@>[bfb H ;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:Då9CP&B�`Q>sBO� H >sSCDZjSòÙÂÏNÕCÎÃÏeÖnÎ�Û@ó��kðÂϢРÛtØåB�9©^[;f>»StB�>TBf`Z> H ;=9g^[>@b=b@�©� H ;f9_^@>[bfb�<:;fSCJ�JTSC;�^@SCD­on>Tbf>[>@D�SCbsS0^@?ISCbfb[É3B�`kStBjZ>@b=^@; F o�>[b]`Z9r� F DZb�BaSCDZ^[>@bGon>@`ZSr8C>C���$óCÐIÙÂÏéÎÃÐéÿ��gÏOÍfóTÞCÎ=ÕCÜ�Ü�ÕCÎ'^@9CDYB�S F DQb]S H ;=9g^[>@bfb]<C;�SCJ�JTSU;dSUDZj�SDkSCJ�>'b H SC^[>xPR9C; H ;f9_^@>@b=b F DZb=B�SCDZ^[>@b}PR9:;�>»SC^a` H ;=9g^[>@bfb�BO� H >x< F 8:>@D F D�Bf`Z>dDQ>[BO�e9:; V BO� H >d<:;fS H `¦�3u'`Z>DkSCJ�>]b H SC^[>�;=> H ;=>@b=>@D�B�bxB�`Z>�DkSCJ�>@b�S»8US F ?~SCoZ?A>dPR9:; H ;f9_^@>@b=b F DZb=B�SCDZ^[>@bx9CP&S�^[>@;=B�S F D¿BO� H >C�0(¯ ~ ¯*# =?)éµ[úrû;) ù ´âúr¸�'�@¿û�¶ 9 6¬Bzû�¶k¹vµ@ºC%�ût·1¶Qú<)*%n¹l° $ ¹�ú»¸_¼�û�¶Qú&)é¹,¼ABÇ% 9 %32D%n¼3)éü:¶V2�¶k¹�'ð¹®%âü:¶V2

=¿¶Qúr¶ ø µ 9 ¸_üCú�µwdD�B F ?�DZ9r�-�z>�SU;f>GSUoZ?I>¾Bf9�jZ>[bf^@; F on>¾B�`Q>GB�9 H 9:?I9C<C�L9CPvS�j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@jTb=�_b=Bf>@J�o���BO� H >@j²<:;fS H `ZbÔSCDZjB�`Z>¿?A9g^@SC?zb�BaSUBf>@bLo��ãSUBfBf; F oZXQB�>[j�<:;�S H `Zb@�1MsSCJ <:9 F DZ<0B�9 F DYBf>@<:;fSUB�>TDZ9r��on9CB�`ã^@9CDZ^@> H B�b F D�9CDZ>^@9:J�JÁ9CDÅb�B�;=XZ^[BfXZ;f>UÉä^»SU?I?I>[jÅS�j F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j0<:;fS H ` Ê E >[Pi�VwQ�ôqQ�õq�ËÃÉ�Bf9ÁjQ>@bf^[; F o�>sSCDå>[D�B F ;=>�j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jb=�_b=Bf>@J�µõb]b�BaSUBf>C�àu'`Z> F D�B�>[<:;�StB F 9CD F b H ;f9r8 F jZ>[j�o���S½JÁS HZHZF DZ<ÁBf`kSUB�SCb=b F <:DZbGB�9T>»SC^a`�DZ9_jZ>�9CP�Bf`Z>DZ>[BO�e9:; V <C;�S H `ÅSCDÅSUB=B�; F oZXQBf>@j¿<:;fS H `¦Ék^@SC?I?A>@j�ÑIÛrðfÕCÑ�ÙÂÏNÕCÏOÍÂÉ�SCDZj¿B�9L>@SC^a`å>[jZ<:>àSCDÅSUB=B�; F oZXQBf>@j²<:;�S H `JÁ9:; H ` F bfJÅÉgB�`ZSUB F b'^[9:J H SUB F oZ?I>¾� F B�`¿B�`Q>àDQ9gjZ>àSCb=b F <:DZJ�>@D�B�b[�`�aâ¶k· 9 2R¸ 0�¯ � b ':)¢µÂúrû;) ù ´,ú»¸�'�¼�ût¶ 9 6�dïz9:DZb F jZ>@;�B�`Z>'m F <:XZ;=>n+_�-}dPR9:;3SCD�>ÃìZSUJ H ?A>z9CPnSdj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�<:;fS H `¦��u'`Z>ÔDZ>ÂBO�z9:; V <:;fS H `�^[9:DZb F b=Bfb&9CPSs;f>Â8 F b F 9:D²SC;f^a` F 8:>GSCDZj F Bfb H 9:;=B�mTn�o p5gih��&u'`Z>]?A9g^@SC?�b�BaSUBf>G9CPâBf`Z>];f>Â8 F b F 9:D¿SC;=^a` F 8C>Gbf`kSU?I?ä^[9:D�BaS F DBO�z9²;f>Â8 F b F 9:DZbd9CP�jZ9g^[XZJ�>@D�B�b[ɦ��`Z>@;=>�9:DZ>�;=>[8 F b F 9:D F b H XQB F D�B�9TBf`Z> H 9:;=B@�]u'` F bG;=>[8 F b F 9:D�b=`kSC?A?�on>B�`Z>�9:DZ?Ä��jZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B F D�B�`Z> H 9:;=BTmrn o�p5gihs�Áu'`Z>T?A9g^@SC?&b=B�SUB�>[bàPR9C;�Bf`Z>�;f>[8 F b F 9CD1SC;=^a` F 8C>TSUDZj�Bf`Z>H 9:;�B�SC;f>¿J�9_jZ>@?A>@jão��­B�`Z>ÅSUB=B�; F oZXQBf>@jã<:;fS H `Zb�SUB�Bf`Z>²o�9CB=B�9:J 9CPxB�`Z> À <:XQ;f>C�ãu'`Z>åSCb=b F <CDZJÁ>[D�B

PortRA

content = public class Foo...revnr = 1.4.5content = public class Foo...

revnr = 6.4.1content = public class Bla...

Document Document

Document

revnr = 1.4.5

DocID = 6

DocID = 1 DocID = 1

RA

m F <:XZ;f>Ò+g�-}_�K±�óCÐIÙÂÏéÎÂÐéÿ��_ÏOÍfó�ÞCÎ=ÕÂÖk×ÅÐ�ØkÏiÍ ÞCÎ=ÕCÏOÍaÙ�ÏR×kÍàÏOÛaÖkÛtÑIÛfÞCêTÕCØnóÁÑIÛrðfÕCÑ�ÙÂÏ ÕCÏiÍaÙ�e9CP�B�`Z>�?A9g^@SC?�b�BaSUBf>@bGBf9½B�`Z>�;=>[8 F b F 9:D�SC;=^a` F 8C>LSCDZj�B�`Q> H 9C;=B F bGbf`Z9r��Dòo��0B�`Q>�jkSCbf`Q>@j�SC;f;=9���b[��uv9F DZj F ^»SUBf>'<:;�S H ` F ^@SC?I?Ä��Bf`kSUB�B�`Q>xjQ9g^[XZJÁ>[D�B F D�Bf`Z> H 9C;=B�^@9:J�>@b}PR;=9:J B�`Q>x;=>[8 F b F 9:DÁSC;=^a` F 8C>CÉ�B�`Z>x>@jQ<:>

+`+

Page 30: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

9CP3Bf`Z>sDZ>ÂBO�z9C; V <:;�S H ` F b�;=> À DZ>[j0B�9TSCD©StBfB�; F oZXgB�>@jå<:;�S H `åJ�9:; H ` F b=JåÉZBf`kSUBdJTS H bxBf`Z>àjZ9g^[XZJ�>@D�B9CP�Bf`Z> H 9C;=B'B�9�Bf`Z>�jZ9g^[XZJ�>@D�B F D¿B�`Z>�;=>[8 F b F 9:DÅSC;=^a` F 8C>C� s²Y%kúr¶Qú&)D%n¹X%�º¢':)¢µÂúrû;) ù ´,ú»¸�'ã¼�û�¶ 9 6®´ M F D�B�;=9gjZXQ^@>GDZ9r�-B�`Z>]DQ9CBaSUB F 9:DT9CPvj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j¿<:;fS H `Zb'XZb=>@jF D Bf`Z>åPR9C?I?I9r� F DZ< H SC;=BfbÁ9UP]B�` F b��e9:; V ÉÔ��`Z>[;f>0Bf`Z>0DQ>[BO�e9:; V <:;�S H ` SCDZj B�`Z>0SCbfb F <:DZJ�>@D�BÁ9CPGBf`Z>SUBfBf; F oQXQB�>[j­<:;�S H `Zb�SUDZjãSUBfBf; F oZXQB�>[j­<:;fS H `­J�9:; H ` F b=JÁb�B�90Bf`Z>½DZ>ÂBO�z9C; V <C;�S H ` F bsDQ9CB�>Ãì H ? F ^ F Bf?A�bf`Z9r��D¦�dïz9:DZb F jZ>[;xBf`Z>s>ÃìQSCJ H ?I> F Dåm F <CXZ;f>�+g�x/QÉkB�`kStB¾b=`Z9r��b¾B�`Z>àj F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@jå<:;�S H `å9UP�m F <CXZ;f>�+g�,}F D�B�`Q>ÔDZ9CB�SUB F 9:D�XZb=>@j F D�B�`Q>zPR9:?I?A9r� F DZ<Z�,u'`Z>[;f> F b&SGo�9»ì�PR9C;&>»SC^a` H ;=9g^[>@b=beSUDZj H 9C;=B}9CP�Bf`Z>'DZ>[BO�e9:; V

RA PortRA

revnr = 1.5.4content = public class Foo...

content = public class Bla...

revnr = 1.5.4content = public class Foo...

Document Document

Document

DocID = 6revnr = 6.2.5

DocID = 1 DocID = 1

m F <:XQ;f>i+g�x/Q�>³àÛtÏNÕCÏéРÛtØ­ÛiÚàóCÐIÙÂÏéÎÂÐéÿ��_ÏOÍfó�ÞCÎfÕÂÖk×�Ù�e

<:;�S H `¦Ég��`Z>[;f>]B�`Q>]?I9_^»SC?nb=B�SUB�>G9UPvBf`Z> H ;=9g^[>@bfb';=>@b H �QB�`Q> H 9:;�B F b F DZ^[?IXZjZ>[j¦�&u'`Z>�on9»ì F bÔJTSU; V >[j²oY�B�`Z>]DkSUJÁ>]9CPvB�`Q>]^@9:;=;f>@b H 9CDZj F DQ<�DQ>[BO�e9:; V DZ9_jZ>U�}u'`Z>àSUBfBf; F oQXQB�>[jÅ<C;�S H `²J�9:; H ` F b=JÁb�PR9:;'DZ>[BO�e9:; V>@jZ<:>[b¾SU;f>�>Âì H ? F ^ F B�?Ä�½jZ;fSr��D F D¿B�` F b�DZ9CB�SUB F 9:D¦ÉZoZXgB¾DZ9UBxBf`Z>�DZ>[BO�e9:; V >[jZ<:> F Bfbf>@?ÄPi���d9r�z>Â8:>[;@É�Bf`Z>@;=>F b�S0DQ>[BO�e9:; V >[jZ<:> F D1B�`Z>¿DQ>[BO�e9:; V <C;�S H ` F P'B�`Z>[;f> F b�SCDãSUB=B�; F oZXQBf>@j�<:;fS H `�J�9:; H ` F b=Jå�©MNP�Bf`Z>SUBfBf; F oQXQB�>[j�<C;�S H `LJ�9:; H ` F b=J)PR9:;�S]DZ>ÂBO�z9:; V >@jZ<C> F b&B�9CB�SC?I?Ä�sXQDZjZ> À DZ>@j¦É_M3jQ;�S»�þBf`Z>�DZ>[BO�e9:; V >[jZ<:>U�u'`Z>LJTSCD FIH XZ?ISUB F 9:D09UPzj F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[jò<C;�S H `Qb F b]J�9gjZ>[?I>[j�oY�ãóCÐIÙÂÏ¢ÎÃÐéÿ��_ÏiÍfó�ÖnÎ�Û@ó��kðÂϢРÛtØQÙ Ê Bf`Z>L<:>@DQ>@;�SU?jZ> À D F B F 9:D F bÁ< F 8:>[D F DpwZ�õqQ�,}gÉÔPR9:;LB�`Z>å^»SCb=>0b=BfXZjQ� F D�wZ�xwQ�Ap:prËÂÉzBf`kSUBTSC;f>­óCÐIÙÂÏ¢ÎÃÐéÿ��_ÏiÍfó­ÜTÛtÎNÖk×_ÐIÙÂÜsÙÊ E >[Pi�ÇwZ�ôqg�xwYËÁ� F B�`Èbf9CJÁ>�b H >[^ F SU? H ;f9 H >[;=B F >@b[�.�7j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jÈJÁ9C; H ` F bfJ ^@9:DZb F b�B�b²9CPsS H SC;=B F SC?<:;�S H ` J�9:; H ` F b=J o�>ÂBO�z>[>@D Bf`Z>åDQ>[BO�e9:; V <:;fS H `Zb[ÉÔ^»SC?A?I>[j-ØäÍÂÏ*ÊzÛtÎ�ßòÜTÛtÎNÖk×_ÐIÙÂÜ F D�Bf`Z>ÅPR9C?I?I9r� F DZ<ZÉSCDZj�SCD�StBfB�; F oZXgB�>@j0<:;�S H `©JÁ9C; H ` F bfJ"PR9:;d>»SC^a`�DZ9_jZ> F DåBf`Z>�jZ9:JÁS F D09CP}Bf`Z>�DZ>ÂBO�z9:; V J�9:; H ` F b=JåÉ^»SC?A?I>@j0ÑIÛrðfÕCÑäÜTÛtÎNÖk×_ÐIÙÂÜ�Égon>[BO�e>@>[DÅBf`Z>]?I9_^»SU?�b�BaSUBf>¾PR9:;zBf` F bÔDQ9gjZ>GSCDZj¿B�`Z>¾?I9_^»SC?nb=B�SUB�>]9CP,Bf`Z> F JÁSC<:>9CP¦B�` F b�DZ9gjQ>¾XZDZjQ>@;zBf`Z>¾DZ>ÂBO�z9C; V JÁ9:; H ` F bfJÅ�3u'`Z>d?I9_^»SC?�J�9:; H ` F bfJ�b�`kS»8:>¾Bf9son>¾^[9:J H SUB F oZ?I>'� F Bf`B�`Z>]SUbfb F <:DZJ�>@D�BÔ9UPvSUBfBf; F oQXQB�>[j½<:;�S H `¿JÁ9C; H ` F bfJ�b�PR9C;zDZ>ÂBO�z9:; V >[jZ<:>@b F DTBf`Z>¾PR9:?A?I9r� F DZ<àbf>[DZbf>U��m�9C;>»SC^a`©DQ>[BO�e9:; V >@jZ<C>CÉ�B�`kSUB F b F DÅB�`Z>�jZ9:JÁS F D²9CP3B�`Z>�DZ>[BO�e9:; V J�9:; H ` F bfJÅÉZB�`Q>�^[9:J H 9:b F B F 9:D²9CP&Bf`Z>SUBfBf; F oQXQB�>[jòJ�9:; H ` F b=J�PR9:;GBf`Z>LDZ>[BO�e9:; V >[jZ<:>�SCDZj�B�`Q>�?A9g^@SC?&J�9:; H ` F b=JPR9:; F B�bGBaSU;f<:>ÂB�DZ9gjQ>�`ZSCbB�9�on>G> � XkSC?¦Bf9�B�`Z>¾^@9:J H 9Cb F B F 9:DÁ9CP,B�`Z>]?A9g^@SC?nJÁ9:; H ` F bfJ.PR9:; F B�bÔb=9:XZ;f^[>]DZ9_jZ>�SCDZj½Bf`Z>�SUBfBf; F oZXQB�>[j<:;�S H `ÅJ�9:; H ` F b=JöPR9:;ÔBf`Z> F JÁSC<:>GDQ>[BO�e9:; V >[jZ<:>C�� j F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j H ;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:D F b�Sdj F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j�J�9:; H ` F b=JåÉr��`Z>[;f>ÔSU?I?�?I9_^»SU?:JÁ9C; H ` F bfJ�bvSC;f>eSUBfBf; F oZXQB�>[jH ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CDZbvSCb�>Ãì H ?~S F DZ>@j F Dshg>[^[B F 9:D�+g�ôqg�&h F DZ^@>�B�`Q>eDZ>ÂBO�z9C; V JÁ9C; H ` F bfJ÷9CPkSxj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j H ;f9_jZXZ^ÃKB F 9CD F b¾SÁDZ>ÂBO�z9C; V0H ;f9_jZXZ^[B F 9:D©SCb¾>Ãì H ?~S F DZ>@j F D�hg>[^[B F 9:D +_�-+gÉ�STj F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:D0b H >[^ FAÀ >@bB�`Z>GBf;�SCDZb�PR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:D½9UPvBf`Z>]B�9 H 9:?A9:<C�LB�9:<C>[B�`Q>@;Ô� F Bf`½B�`Z>]Bf;�SCDZb�PR9:;fJÁSUB F 9:DÁ9CP3?A9g^@SC?nb=BaStB�>@bxSUB�9CDZ^@>U�

+Cq

Page 31: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

`�aâ¶k· 9 2R¸ 0�¯P´~b ':)¢µÂúrû;) ù ´,ú»¸�' 9 û&%('v´vüCú&)*%n¹�du'`Z>G>ÂìQSCJ H ?A>d9CPâSsj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CD F DTm F <CXZ;f>Ñ+g�õ��J�9gjZ>[?Ib�B�`Z>d;f> H ? F ^»SUB F 9:DL9CPvSàjZ9g^[XZJ�>@D�B9CPx9:DZ>²;f>Â8 F b F 9:DãSC;f^a` F 8:>¿Bf9�S©^[9:DZDZ>[^[Bf>@jþ;=>@J�9CB�>¿;=>[8 F b F 9:DãSU;f^a` F 8:>C��u'`Q>Å?A>[P�B�KO`kSCDQj�b F jQ>¿bf`Z9r��bSåj F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j1<:;�S H `�� F Bf`1BO�e9©;f>Â8 F b F 9:D­SC;=^a` F 8C>@b�^[9:DZDZ>[^[Bf>@j�8 F S0S H 9C;=BDmTn�o p5gih��©�GDZ>Á9CPÔBf`Z>;f>[8 F b F 9CD­SC;=^a` F 8C>@b�^[9:D�BaS F DZb�S0jQ9g^[XZJÁ>[D�B»�0u'`Q>½; F <:`�B=KO`ZSCDZj1b F jZ>Á9CPÔBf`Z>½j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:Dbf`Z9r��b�B�`kSUBzB�`Z>�jZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B F b';f> H ? F ^@SUB�>[j F D�B�9�Bf`Z>�?I9r�e>@;';f>Â8 F b F 9:DÅSC;f^a` F 8:>UÉZ��`Z>@;=>]B�`Z>]^[9:DZDZ>[^[B F 9:Do�>ÂBO�z>[>@DTBf`Z>d9C; F < F DkSC?gSCDZjLB�`Q>d;=> H ? F ^»StB�>@jLjZ9_^@XQJÁ>[DYB F b}< F 8:>[DÁo���Bf`Z>djQ9g^[XZJÁ>[D�B F D�Bf`Z> H 9C;=B»�3u'`Z>

revnr = s1content = s2

1.1: Document

DocID = x1revnr = s1content = s2

1.1: Document

DocID = x1

1: RA 2 : PortRA

3: RA

1: RA 2 : PortRA

3: RA

revnr = s1content = s2

DocID = x1

Document

revnr = s1content = s2

DocID = x1

Document

m F <:XZ;=>i+g�õ�Q�K±�óCÐIÙÂÏéÎÃÐéÿ��gÏOÍfóàÖnÎ�Û@ó���ðÂÏéРÛtØsÚ»ÛtÎ�Ï�×kÍàÎaÍOÖnÑÒРðfÕCÏéРÛtØ�ÛiÚàó_ÛrðÁ�_ÜTÍÂØkÏ�Ù�e

DZ>[BO�e9:; V J�9:; H ` F b=Jö9UPvBf`Z>�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j¿J�9:; H ` F b=J F b F DZj F ^»SUBf>@j¿o��½Bf`Z>�D_XQJ�o�>[;fbxSUBÔBf`Z>�DZ>[BO�e9:; VDkSCJ�>@b@��u'`Q>½DZ9_jZ>@b�9UP'B�`Z>¿?A>[P�B=KN`kSCDZj�b F jZ>¿SC;=>TJÁS HZH >@j­B�90DZ9gjQ>@b�9CP'Bf`Z>½; F <:`�B=KN`kSCDZj1b F jQ>TB�`kStB`kS»8:>'B�`Z>'bfSCJ�>'D_XQJ�o�>[;@�&u'`Q>xDQ>[BO�e9:; V J�9:; H ` F b=J F b&B�9CB�SC? F D�B�` F b&^»SUbf>CÉ F �õ>U�CB�`Z>';=>[8 F b F 9:DLSU;f^a` F 8:>@b[ÉB�`Z> H 9:;�B'SCDZj½Bf`Z> F ;z^[9:DZDZ>[^[B F 9:D¿SC;=> H ;=>@bf>[;=8C>@jÅoY��B�`Q> H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:D¦��h F DZ^@>dB�`Z>GDQ>[BO�e9:; V DZ9gjQ>@b'SC;=>H ;f>[bf>@;�8:>[j¦ÉC�e>e`kS»8C>�Bf`Z;f>[>�?A9g^@SC?:J�9:; H ` F b=JÁb[�¦u'`Z>�?I9_^»SC?UJÁ9:; H ` F bfJ÷PR9C;¦B�`Z>�;f>Â8 F b F 9:DàSC;f^a` F 8:>�pà�©gihF bÔSUD¿SUBfBf; F oZXQB�>[j H ;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:DTBf`kSUBejZ9_>@bÔDZ9UBÔ^a`kSCDQ<:>¾B�`Q>G?I9_^»SC?kb�BaSUBf>C��u'`Z>]StBfB�; F oZXgB�>@j H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:DPR9:;}B�`Z> H 9C;=BeSCb��z>[?I?nSCb�B�`Z>xbf>[^@9:DZjT;f>[8 F b F 9CDTSC;=^a` F 8C>¾qL��gih-^@;f>@SUB�>[bzSàDZ>[� jZ9g^[XZJ�>@D�B»ÉY��`Z>@;=>dBf`Z>SUBfBf; F oQXQB F 9:D F b}BaS V >@D�PR;f9:J)B�`Z>xjZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B F D²p���gih��&u'`Z>x?I9_^»SC?QJÁ9:; H ` F bfJ�b�SC;f>x^@9:J H SUB F oZ?A>z� F Bf`B�`Z>]SUbfb F <:DZJ�>@D�B'9CPvStBfB�; F oZXgB�>@jT<:;�S H `¿JÁ9:; H ` F bfJ�b�Bf9sB�`Z>¾DZ>[BO�e9:; V >@jZ<:>[b@ÉZb F DZ^[>¾PR9:;eo�9CBf`¿DZ>[BO�e9:; V>@jZ<:>[b F D�B�`Q>T?I>ÂP�B=KN`kSCDZjòb F jZ>T9CPzB�`Z> H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CD�`Z9C?IjZb[��MNB F bàBf`Z>ÁbfSCJ�>Á��`Z>ÂB�`Z>[;sM]<:9ÅPR;f9:J�Bf`Z>?I9_^»SC?vb=B�SUB�>�9UP�Bf`Z> H 9:;=B F D0Bf`Z>�?I>ÂP�B=KO`ZSCDZj©b F jZ>sBf9½B�`Z>�?A9g^@SC?vb=BaStB�>�9CP�Bf`Z>�;f>Â8 F b F 9:D�SC;=^a` F 8C> F D0Bf`Z>?I>[P�B�KO`kSUDZj©b F jZ>�SUDZj©B�`Z>[D�8 F SÁB�`Q>�?I9_^»SC?,J�9:; H ` F b=J$Bf9½B�`Z>s?I9_^»SC?,b=B�SUB�>s9CP�B�`Z>�;=>[8 F b F 9:D©SC;f^a` F 8:> F DB�`Z>x; F <:`�B=KO`ZSCDZjLb F jZ>�9:; F P¦M�<:9�B�9�B�`Z>x?I9_^»SC?Qb=BaStB�>x9CPäBf`Z> H 9:;�B F DLB�`Z>�; F <:`�B=KN`kSCDZj�b F jZ>'8 F S�Bf`Z>x?I9_^»SC?JÁ9:; H ` F bfJ�SUDZj¿B�`Z>[DåB�9�Bf`Z>�?I9_^»SC?�b=BaStB�>�9CPvB�`Z>�;f>Â8 F b F 9:DÅSC;f^a` F 8:>�9CP�B�`Z>�; F <:`�B=KN`kSCDZj¿b F jZ>U� s� óCÐIÙÂÏéÎÃÐéÿ��gÏOÍfó�Ü�ÕCÏiða× Ê <C>@DZ>[;�SC? E >[Pi��wZ�ôqg�,/àSCDZj�^»SCb=>db�B�XZjg�ºwZ�xwQ�Ap:prË�PR9:;�Sàj F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j H ;f9_jZXZ^[B F 9:D F b< F 8C>@DàoY�]Sxj F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[jàJ�9:; H ` F b=JåÉ»��`Q>@;f>�B�`Q>�DQ>[BO�e9:; V <:;fS H `àJÁ9C; H ` F bfJèSCDZj�SC?I?U?I9_^»SC?:J�9:; H ` F b=JÁbSC;f>�B�9CB�SC? �zu'` F bx>@DZb=XZ;f>[b¾B�`ZSUBdBf`Z>sDQ>[BO�e9:; V JÁ9C; H ` F bfJ�9UP&B�`Z>�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jÅJTStB�^a` F b¾S�JTStB�^a`åPR9C;B�`Z>ÔDQ>[BO�e9:; V�H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CD�9CPkB�`Q>Ôj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j H ;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:D�SUDZjs�e>'`kS»8:>�S¾JÁSUB�^a`�PR9C;�B�`Q>'SUBfBf; F oZXQB�>[jH ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CDZb'9CPvB�`Z>�j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j H ;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:D²< F 8:>@DÅo��¿B�`Z>]Bf9CBaSC?ä?I9_^»SC?�JÁ9:; H ` F bfJ�bÔ9CPvB�`Z>�JÁSUB�^a`¦�u'`Z>�S HZH ? F ^@SUB F 9:Ds9CP�SGj F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:DLSUB�SGj F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j�JTSUBf^a`�^»SCD�on>'^@9CDZb=Bf;fXZ^ÂB�>@j H 9 F D�B=K� F bf>ToY�òB�`Q>½j F ;=>@^ÂB�jZ>@; F 8USUB F 9:Dò9CP�B�`Z>TDZ>[BO�e9:; V�H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:D�SCDZj�B�`Z>½j F ;f>[^[B�jQ>@; F 8USUB F 9:D�9UPd>@SC^a`?I9_^»SC?�SUBfBf; F oZXQB�>[j H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CD¦��u'`Q>�J�9:; H ` F b=JÁbdo�>ÂBO�z>[>@D�?I9_^»SC?vb=B�SUB�>[b F D©B�`Z>�jQ>@; F 8:>[j�<:;fS H `�SC;=>B�`Z>[D½XZD F�� XQ>@?A��< F 8:>[D½o���Bf`Z>¾jQ>@; F 8:>[j¿<:;�S H `ZbePR9:;�B�`Q>¾?I9_^»SU?kb=BaStB�>@b Ê <:>[DZ>@;fSC? E >ÂPi��wZ�ôqg�ô�QÉ_^»SUbf>¾b�B�XZjg�E >[Pi�fwZ��wZ�Äprq�ËÃ�

+�w

Page 32: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

`�aâ¶k· 9 2R¸ 0�¯Pµ~b ':)¢µÂúrû;) ù ´,ú»¸�'�'�)Rû�¸_üCúH'v¸Yû;)DÿQ¶Qú&)D%n¹:dMOD�B�`Z>e>ÂìQSCJ H ?I>e9CPnS¾j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@jsj F ;=>@^[B&jZ>@; F 8USUB F 9:D F D�m F <:XZ;=>n+g�Äpr�QÉUB�`Z>Ôj F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j H ;=9gjZXQ^[B F 9:D F Dm F <:XQ;f>i+g�õ� F b�S HQH ? F >@j¿B�9�S�^@XZ;=;f>[DYBdj F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j²b��gb�B�>[J"b=BaStB�>C��u'`Z>]Bf9CBaSC?äj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j²JÁ9C; H ` F bfJ9:D�B�`Z>z?I>[P�B�KO`kSUDZj�b F jZ>Ô9CPkBf`Z>'j F SU<:;�SCJ F b�B�`Q>'j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�JÁSUB�^a`�PR9:;vB�`Z> H ;f9_jZXZ^[B F 9:Dä��u'`Z>'^[XZ;f;=>@D�Bj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j¿b=�_b�B�>@J"b�BaSUBf>]^@9:DQb F b�B�b�9CP,BO�e9�;=>[8 F b F 9:DÅSC;=^a` F 8C>@b�^@9CDZDZ>@^ÂB�>[jåo��²S H 9:;=B@���GDZ>];f>Â8 F b F 9:D

revnr = s1content = s2

1.1: Document

DocID = x1revnr = s1content = s2

1.1: Document

DocID = x1

1: RA 2 : PortRA

3: RA

revnr = 1.5content = public class Foo...

1.1: Document

DocID = 1revnr = 1.5content = public class Foo...

1.1: Document

DocID = 1

revnr = 1.5content = public class Foo...

1.1: Document

DocID = 1

1: RA 2 : PortRA

3: RA

revnr = s1content = s2

DocID = x1

Document

revnr = s1content = s2

DocID = x1

Document

1: RA 2 : PortRA

3: RA

revnr = 1.5content = public class Foo...

1.1: Document

DocID = 1

revnr = 6.2.5content = private class Bla...

DocID = 6

revnr = 2.1content = public class Haa...

DocID = 2

Document

1: RA 2 : PortRA

3: RA

revnr = 6.2.5content = private class Bla...

DocID = 6

revnr = 2.1content = public class Haa...

DocID = 2

Document

Document Document

m F <:XQ;f>i+g�Äpr�Q�K± óCÐ�Î�ÍaðÂÏÔóCÐIÙÂÏéÎÃÐéÿ��gÏOÍfó¿ó_ÍÂÎÃÐ�ÌtÕCϢРÛtØNe

SC;f^a` F 8:>'^[9:D�BaS F DZb3BO�e9à;=>[8 F b F 9:DQb@É:B�`Q>'9CB�`Z>[;&9:DZ>'^[9:D�BaS F DZb&9:DQ>';f>[8 F b F 9CD¦�3wxD�B F ?gDZ9r��É�B�`Z>[;f>'jZ9_>@b}DZ9UBBaS V > H ?~SC^[>�S�;=> H ? F ^»StB F 9CD½9CP�jZ9g^[XZJ�>@D�B�bxo�>ÂBO�z>[>@DÅB�`Z>[bf>�BO�z9ÁSC;f^a` F 8:>[b@É�b F DZ^@>]Bf`Z> H 9:;�B F b'>[J H BO�C�u'`Z>'j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�JÁSUB�^a` F DZj F ^@SUB�>[b Ê o���B�`Z>'bfSCJÁ>zD_XQJ�o�>[;'p� Äp�SUB&B�`Q>'jZ9g^[XZJ�>@D�BÃË�Bf`kSUB&Bf`Z>';f>Â8 F b F 9:D� F B�` B�`Z>©;=>[8 F b F 9:DþD_XQJ�o�>[;0p� ,v�b=`kSC?I?xon>©;f> H ? F ^»SUBf>@jþBf91B�`Z>å;f>[JÁ9CBf>0;=>[8 F b F 9:D SU;f^a` F 8:>�qè��gih��u'`Z>²S HZH ? F ^@SUB F 9:D­9CP�B�`Q>¿j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j H ;=9gjZXQ^[B F 9:D À ;=b=B�?Ä��S HQH ? F >@b�Bf`Z>¿DZ>ÂBO�z9:; V�H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:D­B�`kStBjZ9g>[bdDQ9CBx^a`kSCDZ<:>�SCD��²B�9 H 9:?A9:< F ^@SC?nb=B�;=XZ^[BfXZ;f> F DÅ9:XZ;�>ÂìQSCJ H ?A>C�zu'`Q>@D¦É�B�`Z>�B�`Q;f>@>à?I9_^»SU?âSUBfBf; F oZXQB�>[jH ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CDZb�SC;f>xS HQH ? F >@j¦�vu'`Z>dSUBfBf; F oQXQB�>[j H ;f9_jZXZ^[B F 9:D�PR9:;}Bf`Z>�;f>[8 F b F 9CDÁSU;f^a` F 8:>àpà��gih H ;=>@b=>@;=8C>@bB�`Z>�;f>Â8 F b F 9:DÅp� -v F DLBf`Z>dSC;f^a` F 8:>�pà�©gihs� E XQ>�Bf9àBf`Z>�?I9_^»SC?QJTSUBf^a`�PR9C;&B�` F beStBfB�; F oZXgB�>@j H ;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:D¦ÉB�`Z>�8USC; F SCoZ?A>@b��,p:É�¡:pLSCDZj�¡&+T<:>[B]Bf`Z>s8USC?IXQ>@b�p:É&pA -v½SCDQj�Ö3�Qÿ@ÑÒРðTðÂÑÄÕtÙaÙT®�ÛrÛAe¯e¯eIÉ�;f>[b H >@^[B F 8C>@?A�C�su'` F b8CSU; F SUoZ?I>�SCb=b F <:DZJ�>@D�B F bvXZbf>[j F D�B�`Q>ÔSUB=B�; F oZXQBf>@j H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CDZbâPR9:;âB�`Z> H 9:;�B�SCDZj�Bf`Z>�;f>[8 F b F 9CDsSC;=^a` F 8C>q��Rgihs�½ce9CB�`�SUBfBf; F oZXQB�>[j H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CDZb�^@;f>@SUB�>ÁS²;f>[8 F b F 9CDò� F B�`�B�`Z>L8USC?IXQ>@b�9CPzBf`Z>L;f>Â8 F b F 9:D pA -vg�u'`Z>�;f> H ? F ^@SUB�>[j²jZ9g^[XZJ�>@D�BdSCDZj²B�`Z>�9:; F < F DkSC?�SC;f>�^@9CDZDZ>@^ÂB�>[j0o��½B�`Q>à;=>[8 F b F 9:D F D²Bf`Z> H 9C;=B»� su'` F b H 9 F D�BO� F bf>Á^@9:DQb=B�;=XZ^[B F 9:D19CP'B�`Z>Áj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j­j F ;f>[^[BsjZ>@; F 8USUB F 9:D F bàDZ9CB H 9:b=b F oQ?I> F D1<:>[DZ>@;fSC? �h F DZ^[>x�e>GXZb=>GSUB=B�; F oZXQBf>@jÁ<:;�S H `ZbÔSCb�?I9_^»SU?nb�BaSUBf>@b[Ég��`Z>[;f> F D H SU;=B F ^@XZ?ISC;�SUB=B�; F oZXQBf>@jTJ�9:; H ` F b=JÁb�SC;=>H SC;=B F SC?¢É3�e>Å^@SCD�S HZH ?Ä��S�j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j H ;f9_jZXZ^[B F 9:D�SUB�S�< F 8:>[Dãj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jãJTStB�^a`­� F Bf`Z9:XQB�SUDY�

+`v

Page 33: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

^@9:DZj F B F 9:DZb Ê ^[Pi��u'`Z>@9:;=>@J wQ�xwZ�Äprq�ËÃ��uv9�>@DZb=XZ;f>ÅS H 9 F D�BO� F bf>½^[9:DZb=Bf;fXZ^ÂB F 9:Dã9CP�B�`Z>¿j F ;f>[^[BLjZ>[; F 8UStKB F 9CD0PR9:;GSU;fo F B�;�SU;=�Åb H >@^ FAÀ ^@SUB F 9:D©B�>[^a`ZD F�� XZ>[b]PR9:;dBf`Z>�?I9_^»SU?�b�BaSUBf>@b Ê >U�õ<Q�ä<:;fS H `ZbG� F B�`0Bf9CBaSC?�<:;�S H `JÁ9:; H ` F bfJ�baËÂÉv�z> H ;f9r8 F jZ>TS�ÞCÑ �_Ð�Ø_Þ1ðaÛtØnóCÐ�ÏéРÛtØ0Bf`kSUB�`ZSCb�Bf9©o�>Áb�SUB F b À >@j�o��1S0< F 8C>@D­j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jH ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CDãSCDZjãS�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�JÁSUB�^a` Ê ^[Pi� E > À D F B F 9CD�wZ�õqQ�,/:ËÂ�òu'`Z>@b=>Å^[9:DZj F B F 9:DZbs�e>@;=>åSU?I;f>@SCjQ�F D�B�;=9gjZXQ^@>@jòo���u�SC>@D�B�{[>@; F D�¦�u3SC>@�`.�¨�XZDQjZ>@;]B�`Q>�DQ9CB F 9:D�9CP�Ö3��Ùa×kÛ;�_Ï�ðaÛtØnóCÐ�ÏéРÛtØQÙ¾SCDZjò>@DZb=XZ;f>LB�`kStBB�`Z>�j F ;f>@^ÂB�jZ>@; F 8USUB F 9:D¿^@SCDåon> H >[;=PR9:;=JÁ>[j H 9 F D�BO� F bf>U�

0(¯ ~ ¯*#V¯�# ²å¸Y¼�¶Qú&)¶ÿ�¸ ø�9:9 2*)¢ü:¶gú&)*%n¹!��%�¹:':)Rú&)D%n¹�µEGF b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j H ;f9_jZXZ^[B F 9:DQbÁjZ>[bf^[; F on> F D�B�X F B F 8C>@?Ä��`Z9r�$< F 8C>@D j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jþ<:;fS H `Zb�bf`ZSC?I?�on>åB�;fSCDZbiKPR9:;fJ�>@j F D�B�9ÁjZ>@; F 8:>[j�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jå<:;�S H `Zb@�d� j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:D F b¾S HQH ? F ^»SCoZ?A> F P&Bf`Z>@;=> F b¾Sj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j©JÁSUB�^a` F D�ST< F 8:>[D�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j©<C;�S H `ä�GM F D�B�;=9gjQXZ^@>�DQ9���ØäÍ Þ�ÕCÏéÐ�ÌCÍ�ÕÂÖ�ÖnÑÒРðfÕCϢРÛtØ­ðaÛtØnóCжÅϢРÛtØQÙ�PR9:;zS�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j H ;=9gjZXQ^[B F 9:DTBf`kSUB';=>@b=Bf; F ^[BÔBf`Z>]S HZH ? F ^@SUB F 9:DT9UP,j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j H ;=9gjZXQ^[B F 9:DZbzBf9Så^@>[;=B�S F Dò^@9:D�Bf>Âì_B»�²MG^[9:DZb F jZ>@;à`Z>[;f>T9CDZ?A��DZ>[<�SUB F 8:>ÁS HZH ? F ^@SUB F 9:D�^@9CDZj F B F 9:DQb�Bf`kSUBàPR9:;fo F jò^@>@;�BaS F Db=B�;=XZ^[BfXZ;f>[b F D©B�`Q>�^@9:D�B�>Ãì_B�9UPzS½JÁSUBf^a`¦��u'`Q>�JÁ9:;=>�<:>[DZ>@;fSC?&^»SUbf> F bG< F 8:>[D F Dòhg>[^[B F 9:D5wZ�õqQ�,+g��m�9C;JÁ9:;=> F DQPR9:;=JTStB F 9CDZbGSCon9:XQB�S HQH ? F ^»SUB F 9:D�^[9:DZj F B F 9CDZb�bf>@>ÁSC?Abf9½¦ m F b��`/gÉô�d�du��`.QÉõ� W u � ��v;¨¢�TM¾b�BaSC;�BoY�¿SCDå>ÃìQSCJ H ?I>GB�9LJ�9CB F 8USUB�>¾Bf`Z>�XZbf>�9CP3DZ>@<:SUB F 8:>�S HZH ? F ^@SUB F 9:D½^[9:DZj F B F 9CDZb@�`�aâ¶k· 9 2R¸ 0�¯*#�¶·b ¹,¸_¼�¶Qú<)Dÿn¸0¶ 9�9 2�)éü:¶Qú&)D%n¹þü`%n¹:'�)�ú&)D%�¹�dïz9:DZb F jZ>@;dB�`Z>�j F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:D F D©m F <:XQ;f>¸+_�Ap:p�Bf`kSUB¾MdSU?I;f>@SCjQ� F D�B�;=9gjQXZ^@>[j F D�m F <:XZ;=>¸+g�õ�SCDZj½B�`ZSUB';f> H ? F ^»SUBf>@b'S�;=>[8 F b F 9:DÁPR;f9:J 9:DZ>�SC;=^a` F 8C>GB�9LSCDQ9CB�`Z>[;Ô9:DZ>U�}u'`Z>];f> H ? F ^»SUB F 9:DÁ9CP�S�;f>Â8 F b F 9:Dbf`kSC?A?}BaS V > H ?~SU^@>�9:DZ?A� F PÔB�`Q>T;f>Â8 F b F 9:D F b�DQ9CB�SC?A;f>@SCjQ��;f> H ? F ^»SUBf>@jòB�90Bf`Z>T9CBf`Z>@;�;f>Â8 F b F 9:D­SC;=^a` F 8C>9�8C>@;sBf`Z>½^[9:DZDZ>[^[B�>[j H 9:;�B»�åu'` F b�DZ>@<�StB F 8C>½^@9CDZj F B F 9:D F bàb H >@^ FAÀ >[j�o��1S0j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j1<:;�S H `1B�`kStB

revnr = s1content = s2

1.1: Document

DocID = x1revnr = s1content = s2

1.1: Document

DocID = x1

1: RA 2 : PortRA

3: RA

revnr = s1content = s2

DocID = x1

Document

revnr = s1content = s2

DocID = x1

Document

revnr = s1content = s2

1.1: Document

DocID = x1

1: RA 2 : PortRA

3: RA

revnr = s1content = s2

DocID = x1

Document

revnr = s1content = s2

DocID = x1

Document

1: RA 2 : PortRA

3: RA

m F <CXZ;f>Ô+g�Äp:p:�K±.ØäÍ Þ�ÕCÏéÐ�ÌCÍ�ÕÂÖ�ÖnÑÒРðfÕCϢРÛtØòðaÛtØnóCÐ�ϢРÛtØNe+�.

Page 34: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

^@9:D�BaS F DZb�B�`Z>©?A>[P�B�KO`kSCDQjþb F jZ>©9CP¾B�`Z>©j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j H ;=9gjZXQ^[B F 9:D SUDZj B�`Z>åPR9:;fo F jZjZ>[Dþb=Bf;fXZ^ÂB�XZ;=>C�¤MF DZj F ^»SUBf>�Bf`Z>½j F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j­<:;�S H `­9CP'Bf`Z>½DZ>[<�SUB F 8:>TS HZH ? F ^»StB F 9CD�^[9:DZj F B F 9CD1o��c¸O¹ä��u'`Z>TDZ>@<�StB F 8C>S HZH ? F ^»StB F 9CD�^@9:DQj F B F 9:D�9UP�Bf`Z>�>ÂìQSCJ H ?I> F b}bf`Z9r��D F D�m F <CXZ;f>¢+_�Ap:pC�3u'`Z>'PR9:;=o F jZjQ>@DL^@9:D�Bf>Âì_Bz^[9:DZb F b=Bfb9CP3Bf`Z>sjZ9_^@XQJÁ>[DYBfb F DÅBf`Z>s;=>[8 F b F 9:DåSC;f^a` F 8:>sSCDZjÅB�`Z> H 9:;�B»� � >s^@SCD©S HZH ?A�ÅS H ;=9gjZXQ^[B F 9:Då� F B�`0SCDS HZH ? F ^»StB F 9CD©^@9:DQj F B F 9:D�SUBàS¿< F 8:>[D�JÁSUB�^a`�9:DQ?A� F PeBf`Z>LJTStB�^a`�b�SUB F b À >@b]B�`Q>�DQ>@<�SUB F 8C>ÁS HZH ? F ^»SUB F 9:D^@9:DZj F B F 9:D F D B�`Z>�b=>@DZb=>�Bf`kSUB¿Bf`Z>�b F B�XkSUB F 9:Dþb H >@^ FÄÀ >@j F D B�`Z>�S HQH ? F ^»SUB F 9:D ^@9:DZj F B F 9:D jZ9_>@b¿DZ9UB9g^[^@XZ; F D²B�`Z>à^@9CDYBf>Âì_Bd9CP&B�`Q>�JÁSUB�^a`ä�zu'`Z>àJTStB�^a`0< F 8:>[D F D0m F <:XZ;=>�+g�Ap»��bfSUB F b À >[bxBf`Z>sS HZH ? F ^»SUB F 9:D^@9:DZj F B F 9:D¦ÉUb F DQ^@>zBf`Z>@;=>ÔjZ9_>@b&DZ9UB}>Âì F b�B�S¾jZ9_^@XQJÁ>[DYB3� F B�` � n4�,� �º¬ p:É�o4�V���Go ¬ pA -v¾SUDZj0ðaÛtØkÏiÍÂØkÏW»Ö3�Zÿ@ÑÒРð�ðÂÑÄÕtÙaÙ�®�ÛrÛAe¯e¯e F D¿B�`Q>à;=>[8 F b F 9:DÅSC;=^a` F 8C>àq���gih*Bf9LBf`kSUB��e>�S HZH ?A�TB�`Z> H ;=9gjZXQ^[B F 9:D¦� sm�9C;fJÁSC?I?Ä�:ÉYSsDZ>[<�SUB F 8:>GS HZH ? F ^»StB F 9CDÁ^[9:DZj F B F 9CD F be< F 8C>@D¿o��¿Ssj F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j½J�9:; H ` F bfJ.PR;=9:J Bf`Z>G?A>[P�B=K`kSCDZjåb F jQ>à9UP3B�`Q> H ;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:D¿B�9LB�`Q>�j F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[jå<:;fS H `²B�`kStBd^[9:D�BaS F DZb'B�`Z>�PR9:;=o F jZjQ>@DÅb=B�;=XZ^[BfXZ;f>U��¾?Ib=9¾B�`Q>zb�StB F b�PéSC^[B F 9:D�9CPnSCD�S HZH ? F ^»SUB F 9:Dà^@9CDZj F B F 9:Dà� F Bf`s;f>[b H >@^ÂB}B�9]S¾JÁSUBf^a` F b�^a`kSC;�SU^[B�>[; F {@>@j�o��sSj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j½J�9:; H ` F b=Jå��u'`Z>@b=> H 9 F DYBfbÔSC;=>G>Âì H ?IS F DQ>@j¿jZ>ÂBaS F ?I>@j F DTBf`Z>GPR9:;=JTSC? H SU;=B'9CPvS HZH ? F ^»SUB F 9:D^@9:DZj F B F 9:DZb F DÅhg>@^ÂB F 9CDYwZ�õqQ�,+g�0(¯ ~ ¯�0 =?)éµ[úrû;) ù ´âúr¸�'z@¿û�¶ 9 6�Bzû�¶k¹vµ@ºC%�ût·1¶Qú&)D%n¹þºC%�û�=?)éµ[úrû;) ù ´âúr¸�' 1 �,µ[úr¸_·­µ� j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j�b=�_b=Bf>@J ^@9:DQb F b�B�b�9CPzj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j H ;f9_^@>[bfb=>@bs^[9:J�J�XZD F ^»SUB F DZ<½9r8C>@;à^@9:J�JÁ9CD H 9:;�B�b[�m�9C;�>@SC^a` H ;f9_^@>[bfb F B�b3?A9g^@SC?YjkSUB�S¾b=B�SUB�> F b�8 F b F oZ?A>�PR9C; F Bfbf>[?APiÉCoQXQB F B F b F D�8 F b F oZ?A>�PR9C;3;f>[JÁ9UB�> H ;f9_^@>@b=bf>[b@�MNP,S H ;=9g^[>@b=bz�ÔSUDYBfbzB�9�JTS V >�8 F b F oZ?I>dS H SU;=Be9CP F Bfbe?A9g^@SC?kb=B�SUB�> F D�9:;fjQ>@;eBf9s^[9:JÁJsXZD F ^@SUB�>UÉ�B�`Z>d?I9_^»SC?jkSUBaS�SC;=>���; F B=B�>@D F D�B�9�S H 9C;=B»�eu'`Z>à?I9_^»SC?¦jZSUBaSL9CP H 9:;�B�bdSC;f>]8 F b F oZ?A>GPR9:;xSC?I? H ;f9_^@>@b=bf>[b@�'u'`Z>�?I9_^»SC?jkSUBaS�^@SCDÅBf`Z>@DÅon>àXQbf>@jÅPR9:;ÔB�`Q>à^[9:J�J�XZD F ^»SUB F 9:D½on>[BO�e>@>[DåBO�e9 H ;=9g^[>@b=bf>@b[�MNPZ�z>�^@9CDZb F jZ>@;vB�` F b H ; F DQ^ FIH ?I>}9CPZ8 F b F o F ? F BO� F DsS�j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j�b=�_b=Bf>@JÅÉUBf`Z>ejQ> À D F B F 9:D�9UPkSdj F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[jH ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CD¿SCDZj F B�bÔS HZH ? F ^»SUB F 9:DLB�9LS�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j½<:;fS H `¿jZ9_>@bzDZ9CB';=>[ëk>[^[B'B�` F b H ; F DQ^ FIH ?I>��:>[B@��m�9C;F DZb�BaSCDZ^[>CÉxB�`Z>�?A>[P�B=KN`kSCDZj b F jZ>�9UPàBf`Z>�j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j H ;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:D F DÈm F <:XQ;f> +g�Äpr�­^[9:DZb F b=Bfb¿9CP�BO�e9;f>[8 F b F 9CDãSC;f^a` F 8:>[bÅp��Ogih$SCDQj qã�Ogihs�òMODã9:;fjQ>@;�B�9�S HZH ?A�òB�` F b H ;=9gjZXQ^[B F 9:D1Bf9�S©j F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j<:;�S H `¦ÉQ�e>�`kS»8C>àBf9 À DZjÅPR9C;'o�9CBf`²;f>[8 F b F 9CDåSU;f^a` F 8:>@bdS�;f>Â8 F b F 9:DÅSC;f^a` F 8:> F D¿Bf`Z>�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j²<:;�S H `bfXZ^a`©Bf`kSUBxB�`Z>�?I9_^»SC?âb�BaSUBf>@b¾9UP&B�`Z>�;f>Â8 F b F 9:D©SC;=^a` F 8C>@b F DåBf`Z> H ;f9_jZXZ^[B F 9:Då9g^[^@XZ;dSCbd?I9_^»SC?âb�BaSUBf>@b F DB�`Z>]j F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[j¿<:;�S H `¦�&uv9 À DZj¿B�` F bÔ9g^[^@XZ;=;f>[DZ^@>GPR9:;zo�9CBf`²SC;f^a` F 8:>[bxSUBÔB�`Q>]b�SCJ�>¾B F JÁ>d;f> � X F ;f>[b�S<:?I9:oZSC?n8 F >[�-9:D½B�`Q>]j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j½b��gb�B�>[Jå��mk9:;zBf`Z>]S HZH ? F ^@SUB F 9:DT^[9:DZj F B F 9:D F D²m F <:XQ;f>Ò+_�Ap:pd�z>]DZ>[>@jS½<:?I9:oZSC?�8 F >Â� 9CD�Bf`Z>�j F b=B�; F oZXgB�>@j�b��gb�B�>[J SCbG�z>[?I?¢É¦b F DZ^@> F BGPR9:;fo F jZb¾Bf`Z>L>Âì F b�B�>[DZ^@>L9CPzS½;f>Â8 F b F 9:DF D²B�`Z>à?I9_^»SC?äb=BaStB�>à9CP}SL;f>[JÁ9CBf>�;f>[8 F b F 9CD0SC;=^a` F 8C>C�'uv9Á^a`Q>@^ V B�` F bxDQ>@<�SUB F 8C>sS HQH ? F ^»SUB F 9:D¿^[9:DZj F B F 9CD;f> � X F ;f>[b¾B�`Z> V DZ9r��?I>@jQ<:>�9CP&Bf`Z>�?A9g^@SC?âb=B�SUB�>�9UP&BO�z9¿;=>[8 F b F 9:D0SC;f^a` F 8:>[b¾B�`ZSUB F bd9:DQ?A� H 9Cbfb F oZ?I>�� F Bf`SL<C?I9:okSU?�8 F >Â�*9:D²B�`Z>�j F b=Bf; F oQXQB�>[jÅb��_b=B�>[Jå�h F DZ^[>�bfXZ^a`TSà<:?A9:okSC?_8 F >[�þjZ9_>@b�DZ9CB�>Âì F b=B F D�S�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@jLb=�_b=Bf>@JÅÉgM�;f>[b=B�; F ^ÂB�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j H ;f9_jZXZ^ÃKB F 9CDZbâB�9xbf9UKN^»SC?A?I>@jGÖnÎ�ÛrðaÍaÙaÙâÖnÎ�Û@ó���ðÂÏéРÛtØQÙ Ê E >[Pi�<wZ�õqQ�Äprq�ËÃ��u'`Z>�?I>ÂP�B=KN`kSCDZj�b F jZ>�9CPkS H ;f9_^@>[bfb H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:D^@9:D�BaS F DZbd9:DZ>�SUDZj�9:DZ?Ä�²9:DZ> H ;=9g^[>@b=bGDZ9_jZ> H 9:bfb F oZ?Ä�²B�9:<:>ÂB�`Z>[;d� F B�`©b=9:JÁ> H 9C;=B�b[�]h F DZ^@>àB�`Z>s?I9_^»SC?b=BaStB�>@b�9CP H 9:;�B�b�SC;f>²8 F b F oZ?A>½PR9:;�SC?I? H ;=9g^[>@b=bf>@b[É'B�`Z> H ;f9_^@>[bfb H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CD JÁS»��;f>ÂPR>@;ÁSC?Ib=9òBf9òBf`Z>?I9_^»SC?}b�BaSUBf>@b�9CP H 9:;�B�b[�Åu'`Q>T; F <:`�B=KN`kSCDZj�b F jQ>Á9CPzB�`Z> H ;f9_^@>[bfb H ;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:D�^@9:D�BaS F DZb�SUB�JÁ9:b�Bs9CDZ>H ;f9_^@>[bfbxDZ9gjQ>CÉ F � >C�ZS H ;f9_^@>@b=bd^@SCDÅo�>�jZ>[?I>[Bf>@jåSCb'�z>[?I?¢�}MNP3B�`Q>à; F <:`�B�KO`kSCDQj¿b F jQ>à^[9:D�BaS F DZbxS H ;f9_^@>[bfbDZ9gjQ>CÉZB�`Q>@D F B F bÔBf`kSUB�9:DQ>à9UP�Bf`Z>�?I>[P�B�KO`kSUDZj²b F jQ>C��u'`Z>]BO� H >à9CPvB�`Z> H ;=9g^[>@bfb F D¿Bf`Z>�?I>[P�B�KO`kSUDZj¿b F jZ>jZ>[Bf>@;fJ F DQ>@b�B�`Z>LBO� H >Á9CPÔB�`Q> H ;=9g^[>@b=b H ;=9gjZXQ^[B F 9:D¦� E XQ>�Bf9åB�` F b�;f>[b=B�; F ^ÂB F 9CD¦ÉvBf`Z>�?I9_^»SC? F DQPR9:;fJÁStKB F 9CDå9CP&9:DZ> H ;f9_^@>@b=b F bxbfX��Á^ F >[DYB¾B�9 À DZj�STJÁSUB�^a`ÅPR9:;dS H ;=9g^[>@bfb H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CD¦��u�9Á>@DZb=XZ;f>�SÁ?I9_^»SC?S HZH ? F ^»StB F 9CDò9UPxS H ;=9g^[>@bfb H ;f9_jZXZ^[B F 9:DäÉ F BfbsS HZH ? F ^»SUB F 9:Dò^@9CDZj F B F 9:Dò`kSCb�B�90on>T;=>@b�B�; F ^[Bf>@jãSCbà�z>[?I? �u'`Z>@;=>[PR9:;=>CÉâB�`Z>�b�B�;=XZ^[BfXZ;f>[b�^a`Z>[^ V >[j F D�S H ;=9g^[>@b=b�S HZH ? F ^»SUB F 9:Då^@9:DQj F B F 9:D�;=>[PR>@;]9CDZ?A�ÅB�9¿B�`Q>�?I9_^»SC?b=BaStB�>T9UP'B�`Z> H ;f9_^@>[bfb F B�bf>[?AP�SUDZj1B�9 H 9C;=B�b[É&oZXQBsDZ9CB�B�9©9CBf`Z>@; H ;f9_^@>[bfb=>@b@�0�¾?ABf9:<:>ÂB�`Z>[;@É}S H ;f9_^@>[bfb

+`}

Page 35: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CD¿>@DZb=XZ;f>[bxBf`kSUB'B�`Q>àon9:XZDQjkSC; F >@b'9CP,8 F b F o F ? F BO�Á9UP3S H ;=9g^[>@b=b F D²SLj F b=Bf; F oZXQB�>[j¿b=�_b=Bf>@J$SC;=>DZ9CB'8 F 9:?ISUB�>[j²oY� À DZj F DZ<�SCDå9_^@^[XZ;f;=>@DZ^[>àPR9C; F B�b�S HZH ? F ^»SUB F 9:Dä�|&ìQSCJ H ?A>@b'9CP H ;f9_^@>[bfb H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:DZb'� F ?A?äon>à< F 8:>[D F D²m F <CXZ;f>Ô+g�ÄprqtK�m F <:XQ;f>Ô+g�,+`vs��`Z>@DåM F D�B�;f9_jZXZ^[>B�`Z> H ;=9g^[>@bfb H ;=9gjZXQ^[B F 9:DZbÔPR9:;ÔBf`Z>�^»SCb=>�b�B�XZjg�:��]DQ> H ;=9g^[>@b=b H ;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:Dò9CPzBO� H >-�­b H >@^ FÄÀ >@b�9:DZ> H 9:bfb F oZ?A>ÁSU^[B F 9:Dò9CP'S H ;f9_^@>[bfbà9CPzBO� H >��,�Á�¾?I?H 9:b=b F oZ?I>zSC^[B F 9:DZbvPR9:;&S H ;f9_^@>[bfb&9CPkBO� H >��ÁSC;f>eb H >@^ FÄÀ >@j F D�SxÖnÎ�ÛrðaÍaÙaÙ�ÞCÎ=ÕCÜ�Ü�ÕCÎâ9CPkBO� H >>��^@9:DQb F b�B F DZ<9CPvSsbf>ÂB'9CP H ;=9g^[>@b=b H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:DZbz9UPâB�` F beBO� H >GSCDZj²S�ÙÂÏ ÕCÎÃÏäÖnÎaÛ@ó��kðÂÏéРÛtØ�PR9:;zb�BaSC;�B F DQ<�SCD F DZb=B�SCDZ^[>G9CPB�` F b H ;=9g^[>@bfbÔBO� H > Ê E >ÂPi��wZ�õqQ�Äp&v:ËÃ�&�*b=B�SC;=B H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:D Ê E >ÂPi�jwZ�õqQ�Äp7wYË F b'S�j F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j H ;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:D¦É��`Z>@;=>sB�`Z>à?I>ÂP�B¾`ZSCDZj©b F jZ>àJTS»�²^[9:D�BaS F D0bf9CJÁ> H 9C;=B�b¾SCDZjÅB�`Z>�; F <C`YBx`kSUDZj©b F jZ>s^[9:D�BaS F DZb H 9:b=b F oZ?A�bf9:J�> H 9:;�B�bxSCDZjÅ9:DZ> H ;=9g^[>@b=b¾DZ9_jZ>�9CP3BO� H >r�,��u'`Z>à; F <:`�B=KO`ZSCDZj²b F jZ>�;=> H ;=>@b=>@D�B�bxB�`Z> F D F B F SC?�b�BaSUBf>9CP�B�`Z> H ;=9g^[>@b=b@É�B�`Z>�?A>[P�B=KN`kSCDZjsb F jQ>ÔB�`Z>';=> � X F ;=>@jL>@D�8 F ;=9:DZJ�>@D�B�PR9:;&b�BaSC;�B F DQ<]S H ;f9_^@>[bfb�9CP�B�` F b3BO� H >U�|&ìQSCJ H ?A>@b�9CP H ;f9_^@>@b=bs<:;fSCJ�JTSC;=b]SC;=>Á< F 8:>[D F DòBf`Z>LDZ>Âì_BsBO�e90b=XZoZb=>@^[B F 9:DQb@É���`Q>@;f>ÁM H ;=>@b=>@D�BsBf`Z>H ;f9_^@>[bfb�<:;�SUJÁJÁSC;fbe9CP,B�`Z>]^@SCbf>�b�B�XZjQ�C�eh F DZ^[>GB�`Z>�DZ>ÂBO�z9C; V BO� H >à<C;�S H `¿9UP�Bf`Z>]^»SCb=>]b=BfXZjQ� F D²m F <UKXZ;f>|+g�,+�^[9:D�BaS F DZb}BO�z9 H ;f9_^@>[bfb�BO� H >[b@É_DkSCJ�>@?A�=gihÈPR9C;};f>[8 F b F 9CDTSC;=^a` F 8C>@beSCDZj)jlk�PR9:;}�e9:; V b H SC^@>[b@ÉMzb H >@^ F P��²S H ;=9g^[>@b=bd<:;fSCJ�JTSC;�PR9:;';f>Â8 F b F 9:DÅSC;f^a` F 8:>[b¾SUDZj²9:DZ>]PR9:;Ô�e9:; V b H SC^@>[b@�0(¯ ~ ¯�0�¯�# 4�û&%âü:¸_µ»µ³@¿û�¶k·1·1¶ZûTº²%nû��½¸�ÿ8)éµ7)*%n¹ ø ûUü;6:)Dÿn¸_µu'`Z>�b=BaSU;=B H ;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:D�PR9:;�B�`Z> H ;=9g^[>@bfb}<C;�SCJ�JTSU;39CP�BO� H >i¼�± F b&bf`Z9r��D F DLm F <Z��+g�Ap<+g�3MNBfb}?I>[P�B�KO`kSUDZjb F jQ> F b3Bf`Z>'>@J H BO�sj F b�B�; F oZXQBf>@j�<:;fS H `¦É F �õ>U�UBf`Z>'^@;=>»SUB F 9:D�9UPäSG;=>[8 F b F 9:DLSU;f^a` F 8:>'jZ9_>@b&DQ9CB�;f> � X F ;f>z>ÂìYKF b=B F DZ< H 9:;=Bfb@�}�ÔBzBf`Z>¾bfSCJ�>dB F JÁ>dSCb�B�`Z>d;f>[8 F b F 9CD½SC;=^a` F 8C>7gih F be^[;f>»StB�>@jäÉkS H 9:;=Bz9CP¦BO� H >7mTn�o�p5gihF b�<:>[DZ>@;fSUB�>[jã^@9:DZDQ>@^[Bf>@j�o��ãS©jkSCb=`Z>@j�SC;=;f9r��b F DZ^[>¿>»SC^a`�SC;=^a` F 8C>¿`kSCb�Bf9�`kS»8:> F Bfb�9r��D H 9:;�B�9CPBO� H >�mTn�o p5gih��Tu'`Z>Á;f>Â8 F b F 9:D1SU;f^a` F 8:>�XZbf>[b�B�` F b H 9C;=BàB�9Å;f> H ? F ^@SUB�> F B�b�jZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�Bfb@�¿M F D�B�;f9_jZXZ^[>SCD F D F B F SC?kjZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B F DTB�`Q>GDZ>[��?Ä�½^[;f>»StB�>@j¿;=>[8 F b F 9:D½SC;f^a` F 8:>UÉZb F DZ^@> F BÔb F J H ? FÄÀ >@beSCDZj¿;=>@jZXZ^[>@bÔBf`Z>PR9:?I?A9�� F DZ<¿bf>ÂB�9CP H ;f9_^@>[bfb H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CDZbàPR9C;àBf`Z>�BO�e9 H ;=9g^[>@b=bs<:;fSCJÁJÁSC;=b@�Tu'`Q>TjZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B F jZ>[D�B F KÀ ^»SUB F 9:D�DYXZJ�on>@;�9CPeB�`Z>LjZ9_^@XQJÁ>[DYB F b]^»SC?A^@XZ?ISUB�>[jòo���Bf`Z>L9 H >[;�SUB F 9:DãØäÍÁÊ�½�¾íB�`kSUBà^[;f>»StB�>@b�S²DZ>[�XZD F�� XZ>�DYXZJ�on>@;dPR9C;dB�`Q>sDZ>Â�)jQ9g^[XZJÁ>[D�B»�xu'`Z>�9 H >@;fSUB F 9:D1ØäÍÁÊ�¼�ÍÂÌ�³¾Î'^@;f>@SUB�>[b¾B�`Q>�^@9:;=;f>[b H 9:DZj F DZ<;f>[8 F b F 9CDÅDYXZJso�>[;@�

RA

Document

DocID = newIDrevnr = newRevNrcontent = empty

PortRA

m F <:XZ;=>Ô+g�Ap<+g�sç¦×kÍ]ÙÂÏ ÕCÎÂÏâÖnÎ�Û@ó���ðÂÏéРÛtØ�¿�ÀfÁ©Â©ÀfÃAÄ�ÅÁÚ»ÛtÎ]Î�ÍÂÌrÐIÙÂРÛtØ�ÕCÎ�ða×_Ð�ÌCÍaÙ�e

MNPGS�DZ>Â� H ;=9tý=>@^ÂB H SC;=BfDZ>@;��e9:XZ?Aj�? FIV >½B�9Tý=9 F D­Bf`Z> H ;=9tý=>@^ÂB»ÉÔS©DQ>[�";=>[8 F b F 9:DãSC;=^a` F 8C>²`kSCb�B�9�on>^@;f>@SUB�>[j¦�zu'` F b�^»SCDåo�>�jZ9CDZ>�oY�¿Bf`Z>àb=BaSU;=B H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:DÆ¿�ÀfÁ�©À\ÃAÄ�Å���MOD²B�` F b�^»SCb=>CÉkB�`Q> F DYBf;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CD9CP&B�`Q>sDZ>Â� H ;f9tý=>[^[B H SC;=BfDZ>@; F b�B�; F <:<:>[;f>[jåo��ÅB�`Z>�>@D�8 F ;f9CDZJÁ>[D�B¾9CP3B�`Z> H ;f9tý=>[^[B@�dMNP�S�DZ>[� H ;=9tý=>@^ÂBH SC;=BfDZ>@; F b F DYBf;f9_jZXZ^[>@j�oY��>Ãì F b=B F DZ<�J�>@J�on>@;=be9CP�B�`Z> H ;=9tý=>@^ÂB»ÉYB�`Z> H ;f9_^@>[bfb H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:DÈÇ ÂIÉ�ÁAÀ\É�ÃAÄ�ÅPR9:;Ô^@;=>»SUB F DZ<�S�DZ>[�÷;f>Â8 F b F 9:D²SC;f^a` F 8:> F D²m F <:XZ;f>·+g�Äprq F bzXZbf>[j¦��u'` F b H ;=9g^[>@b=b H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CD½^@;=>»SUBf>@bxSDZ>[� H 9C;=B}9CP�BO� H >�mrn�o p5gih SUDZj�^@9:DQDZ>@^ÂB�b F Bfbf>@?ÄP F J�JÁ>[j F SUBf>@?Ä�GB�9GBf` F b&DQ>[��?A�s^@;=>»SUBf>@j H 9:;�B F Ds9:;fjZ>[;B�9¿oZX F ?Ij0S½^@9:DZDQ>@^[B F 9:D©PR9C;dB�`Q>�;f> H ? F ^@SUB F 9:D09UP H ;f9tý=>[^[B�jZ9_^@XQJÁ>[DYBfb@��u'`Z>�DZ>Â� H 9:;�B F b¾^@9:DZDQ>@^[Bf>@j

+�/

Page 36: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

PortRA

RARA

m F <:XZ;=>i+g�ÄprqQ��Ç ÂIÉ�Á�ÀfÉ�ÃAÄ�Ån�?«&Î�ÍfÕCÏiÍsÕ�ØäÍÁÊ Î�ÍÂÌrÐIÙÂРÛtØ�ÕCÎ�ða×_Ð�ÌCÍ�e

oY�åS�bf9:? F jåSC;f;=9��èB�9 F DZj F ^»SUBf>�Bf`kSUBxB�`Z>àDZ>Â� H 9:;�B F b¾S H 9C;=Bx9CP�S�;f>@J�9CBf>�;=>[8 F b F 9:DåSC;f^a` F 8:>U�dh F DZ^[>H ;f9_^@>[bfb H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:DZbG^[9:D�BaS F Dò9CDZ?A�ÅB�`Z>�8 F >[�)9CP�9:DZ> H ;=9g^[>@bfb[ÉâB�`Z> H ;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:D�jZ9_>@b]DQ9CB F DZ^[?IXZjQ>SCD >Ãì H ? F ^ F BL^[;f>@SUB F 9:Dã9CP¾Bf`Z>²;f>@J�9CBf>Å;=>[8 F b F 9:D�SC;=^a` F 8C>C� MOD 9:;=jZ>@;LB�9�b H >[^ F P���Bf`kSUBLB�`Q>Å^[;f>@SUB F 9:D9CP}B�`Z>�mTn�o p5gih�K H 9:;=B F J H ? F >@bxS½DZ>Â�);=>[8 F b F 9:D©SC;f^a` F 8:>�DZ9_jZ>�SUb¾�z>[?I?¢É�B�`Q> H ;f9_^@>[bfb H ;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:D F Dm F <:XQ;f>?+g�Äprq�`kSCb�Bf9òon>²b=�_DZ^a`Z;=9:D F {@>@j�� F Bf`ãBf`Z>²b=B�SC;=B H ;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:D�PR9:;�;=>[8 F b F 9:D�SC;=^a` F 8C>@b@�ãu'` F b� F ?I?}on>�>Âì H ?~S F DZ>[j F D�JÁ9C;f>LjZ>[B�S F ?�?ISUB�>[;à9CD¦É F PÔM¾Bf;f>»StB�Bf`Z>Tb��gDQ^a`Z;f9:D F {»StB F 9CD19CP H ;f9_^@>@b=bf>[b@�ÅM]jZ9DZ9CB H ;f9r8 F jZ> H ;=9g^[>@bfb H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CDZbxPR9C;�Bf`Z>sjQ>@?I>ÂB F 9:Då9UP};f>Â8 F b F 9:D0SU;f^a` F 8:>@b[�du'` F bx>@DZb=XZ;f>[b¾B�`kStBdBf`Z>H ;f9tý=>[^[B H SC;�B�DZ>[;fbx`kS»8:>àSC?Ä�ÔS»�_b¾SU^@^@>[bfb�B�9�B�`Q>àjQ9g^[XZJÁ>[D�B�b H ;f9r8 F jQ>@jÅoY�²;=>[8 F b F 9:DÅSC;=^a` F 8C>@b[�� `Z>@DÁS H ;f9:<:;fSCJ�JÁ>[; F b}b�BaSC;�B F DZ<]B�9]�z9C; V 9:D�S H ;f9�ý=>@^[BzSUB�S]^@>[;=B�S F DLb F B�>UÉgSG�e9:; V b H SC^@>xon>@?I9CDZ< F DQ<B�9ÁBf` F b H ;=9:<:;fSCJÁJ�>@;�J�XQb=Bdo�>�SCjZjZ>[j0B�9�B�`Z>à^@9C;f;f>[b H 9:DZj F DZ<T;=>[8 F b F 9:DåSC;=^a` F 8C>C��u'`kSUBdJÁ>@SCDZb[ÉnBf`Z>^@;f>@SUB F 9:D09UP}DZ>[�í�e9:; V b H SC^@>[b F b�B�; F <:<:>[;f>[j0o��åBf`Z>s;=>[8 F b F 9:D0SC;f^a` F 8:>U�¾u'` F b¾^@SCD©on>sjZ9:DQ>�� F Bf`åBf`Z>`Z>@? H 9CP'B�`Q> H ;f9_^@>[bfb H ;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:DÊÇ ÂIÉ�ÁAÀ\É�Ã4Ë\Ì F D1m F <CXZ;f>�+g�Ap�w0B�`kStB�^@;=>»SUBf>@bLS0DQ>[� H 9C;=B�9CP'BO� H >mTn�o p5gihijlk'�&�CXZb=BeSCb}Bf`Z> H ;f9_^@>@b=b H ;f9_jZXZ^[B F 9:D�PR9:;�^[;f>»StB F DQ<�S]DZ>Â� ;f>Â8 F b F 9:DÁSC;f^a` F 8:>UÉYBf`Z> H ;f9_jZXZ^ÃKB F 9CD¿jZ9g>[bdDQ9CB�^@;=>»SUBf>�SLDZ>Â�è�e9:; V b H SC^@>�DZ9gjQ>àjQXZ>]B�9L?I9_^»SC? F BO��;f>@SCbf9CDZb@��u'`Z> H ;f9_^@>[bfb H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:DF D�m F <:XQ;f>�+g�Äp7wd`ZSCbvBf9don>�b=�_DZ^a`Z;=9:D F {[>@j�� F B�`�Bf`Z>�b=BaSU;=B H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9CDàPR9:;â�e9:; V b H SC^@>[b F D�m F <:XZ;f>�+g�,+gp:�

PortRAWS

RA RA

m F <:XZ;f>Ô+_�Ap7wQ��Ç4ÂIÉ�ÁAÀfÉ�Ã4Ë\ÌZ�>«&Î�ÍfÕCÏOÍ�ÕTØäÍÁÊ!ÊzÛtÎ�ßrÙOÖQÕ_ðaÍ�e� `Z>@DåS H ;f9�ý=>@^[B H SU;=B�DQ>@;Ô�zSCD�B�b'B�9�^[9:DZDZ>[^[B�B�9�SCDZ9UB�`Z>[;Ô;f>Â8 F b F 9:DÅSC;f^a` F 8:> F D¿9:;fjZ>[;ÔB�9�>[b=BaSUoZ? F bf`ÅSDZ>[��;f> H ? F ^»SUB F 9:Då>@jZ<C>Cɦ`Z>s^@9:DZDQ>@^[Bfb F Bfbf>@?ÄP}B�9TBf`Z>�^[9:;f;=>@b H 9:DZj F DZ< H 9:;�B»�]u'` F b¾`kSCbdB�9¿on>sjZ9:DQ>�oY�SÁbf9C? F jåSC;=;f9r�¤b F DZ^@>àB�`Z> H 9C;=Bdo�>[?I9:DZ<CbxBf9½SÁ;=>@J�9CB�>à;f>Â8 F b F 9:D©SU;f^a` F 8:>C��u'`Z>�DZ>@<:SUB F 8:>�S HZH ? F ^»SUB F 9:D^@9:DZj F B F 9:DZbx9CP}B�`Q> H ;f9_^@>[bfb H ;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:DqͧÉAÎfÃ�ÂIÉAÏÑÐIÒ©ÇAÁ�ÀNÒ�Ó�Í�>@DZb=XZ;f>�Bf`kSUB¾Bf`Z> H ;=9g^[>@b=b H ;f9_jZXZ^ÂB F 9:D^»SCD�on>LS HZH ? F >@j�9CDZ?A� F P�B�`Q> H 9:;�B]jZ9_>@b�DZ9CBGo�>[?I9:DZ<½Bf9¿B�`Z>�;=>[8 F b F 9:D�SC;=^a` F 8C>�SCDZj�B�`Z>[;f>�jZ9_>@b�DZ9UB>Âì F b�BxS�;f> H ? F ^@SUB F 9:D½>[jZ<:>GB�9�Bf` F b H 9:;�B�SC?I;=>»SCjg�:�}u'` F b H ;f>Â8:>@D�Bfbd;=>[8 F b F 9:D²SC;=^a` F 8C>@b'PR;f9CJ F J H 9:;=B F DZ<F B�b'9r��DÅjZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B�b[�æx>Â8 F b F 9:D½SC;=^a` F 8C>@b'^@SCD½;f>[JÁ9r8C>G;f> H ? F ^»SUB F 9:D�>@jZ<C>@b'SUBÔSCD��LB F J�>C�3u'`Z>G^@9C;f;f>[b H 9:DZj F DZ< H ;=9g^[>@b=b H ;f9tKjZXZ^[B F 9:DqÂIÉ Ô§Ã©ÂIÉ4ÏÑÐIÒ�ÇAÁAÀNÒ�Ó Í F b'b=`Z9r��D F D²m F <:XZ;=>Ô+g�Äp<.Q�MNP�S H ;f9tý=>[^[B H SC;=BfDZ>@;G;=> H ? F ^@SUB�>[bGSTjZ9_^@XQJÁ>[DYB@ÉäB�`Q>�jZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B F b H XQB F D�B�9�B�`Z> H 9:;�B]9CP}B�`Q>�^@9:;=;f>ÃKb H 9:DZj F DZ<0;=>[8 F b F 9:D�SC;f^a` F 8:>U�åïz9:DZDZ>[^[B�>[j�;f>Â8 F b F 9:D1SU;f^a` F 8:>@bsSC;f>LB�`Q>@D�SCoQ?I>�B�9å<:>[BsSC^@^[>@b=bsB�9ÅB�` F bjZ9g^[XZJ�>@D�B»��u'`Z> H ;=9g^[>@b=b H ;=9gjZXQ^[B F 9:DDÂIÉ4ÏÑÐIÒ�ÇAÁAÀfÉ]PR9C;vBf`Z>z;=> H ? F ^»StB F 9CD F b,bf`Z9r��D F D�B�`Q>Ôm F <:XZ;f>�+g�Äp&}g�u'`Z>�SUB=B�; F oZXQBf>@bx9CP&Bf`Z>s;=> H ? F ^»StB�>@jåjZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B¾SC;f>�DZ9CBd^a`kSCDZ<:>[j©o��åBf`Z>s;=> H ? F ^@SUB F 9:D¦�zu'`Q>@;f>ÂPR9:;f>UÉäMjZ> HZF ^[B'Bf`Z>]jZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B F D²S�J�9:;f>GSCoZb=Bf;�SC^ÂB�;f> H ;f>[bf>@D�B�SUB F 9:D¦��M�� F ?I?nXZbf>]Bf` F bÔ;=> H ;=>@b=>@D�BaSUB F 9:D²��`Z>[DgK

+C�

Page 37: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

PortRA

PortRA PortRA

PortRA

RA RA

RA RA

m F <:XZ;f>Ò+g�Ap<vg��Í\É�ÎfÃ�ÂIÉ4ÏNÐIÒ©ÇAÁAÀ�Ò�Ó�Í���± ØäÍÁÊþÎaÍOÖnÑÒРðfÕCÏéРÛtØ©ÐIÙ�ÍaÙÂÏ Õ�ÿ@ÑÒÐIÙa×kÍfó©e

PortRA PortRA

RARA

m F <:XZ;=>i+g�Äp<.Q�:ÂIÉ ÔÑÃ�ÂIÉ4ÏÑÐfÒ©ÇAÁAÀNÒ©Ó�Í���¾�ÍÂÑIÍÂÏéРÛtØ�ÛiÚàÕTÎ�ÍOÖnÑÒРðfÕCÏéРÛtØ�ÍfórÞ_Í�e

>[8:>[;�Bf`Z>xSUBfBf; F oZXQB�>[b�SC;f>�DZ9CB�^a`ZSCDZ<:>[jTo���B�`Z>xS HQH ? F ^»SUB F 9:D�9UPäB�`Q> H ;f9_^@>@b=b H ;f9_jZXZ^[B F 9:Dä�3MNPâS�^a`kSCDQ<:>F b H >@;�PR9:;fJ�>@j�9:D�StBfB�; F oZXgB�>@b[ÉâM�jZ>@DZ9UB�>�B�`Z>LStBfB�; F oZXgB�>@b¾>Âì H ? F ^ F B�?A�C�]u'`Z>�S HZH ? F ^@SUB F 9:D0^[9:DZj F B F 9CD©9CPB�`Z> H ;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:DcÂIÉ4ÏÑÐfÒ©ÇAÁAÀfÉ1>@DZb=XZ;f>[b�Bf`kSUB�S©jZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B F b�DZ9CB�;=> H ? F ^»StB�>@j F P�B�` F b�SC?I;=>»SCjg�­`kS H KH >[DZ>@j¦��u'`Z>�jkSCb=`Z>@j�SC;=;f9r��o�>ÂBO�z>[>@D�Bf`Z>�;f>Â8 F b F 9:D�SC;=^a` F 8C>LSCDZj�B�`Q> H 9:;�B]>@DQbfXZ;=>@b]B�`kStBGB�`Z> H 9:;�Bo�>[?I9:DZ<CbÔB�9�B�`Z>àSC;=^a` F 8C>C�

PortRA

PortRA

PortRA RA

RA

RA

m F <:XZ;f>Ò+g�Ap<}g�:ÂIÉAÏÑÐIÒ©ÇAÁ�ÀfÉZ��¼�ÍOÖnÑÒРðfÕCÏOÍ�Õ¿ó_ÛrðÁ�_ÜTÍÂØkÏ�ÛtÌCÍÂÎ]Ð�Ï�Ù'ÖkÛtÎÃÏ�e� `Z>@DåS�;f>[8 F b F 9CDåSU;f^a` F 8:> H XQBfbxSLjQ9g^[XZJÁ>[D�B F D F Bfb H 9:;�B»ÉZ;=>@J�9CB�> H ;f9_^@>@b=bf>[bd^@SCD¿�z9:; V � F Bf`¿B�`Z>[bf>jZ9g^[XZJ�>@D�B�b]o�� F J H 9:;=B F DZ<LB�`Q>@JÅ�su'` F b F b H 9:bfb F oZ?A>�9:DZ?Ä� F P�B�`Z>[;f> F bGS²;=> H ? F ^@SUB F 9:D0>[jZ<:>�on>[BO�e>@>@DB�`Z>²;f>Â8 F b F 9:D SC;f^a` F 8:>åSCDZjãB�`Z> H 9:;=B@��u'`Q>0>@jQ<:>²`kSCbLB�9òo�>²bf9C? F jäÉeb F DZ^[>Å9CDZ?A��jQ9g^[XZJÁ>[D�B�bLPR9:;fJ;f>@J�9CBf>Á;=>[8 F b F 9:D1SC;f^a` F 8:>[b�bf`kSU?I?�o�> F J H 9:;=Bf>@j�SCDZj­DZ9UB�Bf`Z>T9r��D­9:DQ>C�Åu'`Z> H ;=9gjQXZ^[B F 9:DªÒVÔ�ÏÑÓ4©ÀF D­m F <:XZ;=>�+g�Äp</Åb H >@^ FÄÀ >@b�Bf` F b�JÁ9r8C>C��mk9:;�B�`Z>Tb�S V >¿9CP�b F J H ? F ^ F BO�:É,MàSC?A?I9r� Bf`kSUB�jQ9g^[XZJÁ>[D�B�b�SC;=>F J H 9:;�B�>[j¿bf>[8C>@;fSC?âB F J�>@b[�E 9g^[XZJÁ>[D�B�b}SC;=>'DZ> F B�`Z>[;}SC?A?I9r�z>[jsB�9]on>'jZ>[?I>[Bf>@jLDZ9:;�B�9]on>Ô^a`kSCDZ<C>@j F D�;=>[8 F b F 9:DLSC;=^a` F 8C>@b[��ïz`kSCDZ<C>@b9CP,jZ9_^@XZJ�>@D�B�b'`ZSr8C>GB�9�on>GjZ9:DQ> F DT�e9:; V b H SC^[>@bdSCDZj F PvSà�z9:; V b H SC^[> F bÔ^[9:DZDZ>[^[B�>[j¿B�9�B�`Q>G;f>Â8 F b F 9:DSC;f^a` F 8:>Ôo��sSimrn o�p5gih7jlk�K H 9:;=B@ÉCSdjZ9g^[XZJ�>@D�B}^»SUD�o�>e^a`Z>@^ V >@jT9CXQB F DsB�`Z>e�z9:; V b H SC^[>ÔPR9:;3^a`ZSCDZ< F DZ<

q:�

Page 38: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

PortRAPortRA RA RA

Õ�ÖP×�Ø\Ù�Ú +IÛPÜ7/Q��Ò�Ô�ÏNÓ4©Àn�2½ÃܾÖkÛ Ý*Þ?ß½ó�àrðÁ��á)â*ã§ÞÑä,Ý�à áåßræ§à Ý*Þ e

ÖPç Ûéè2ê Ú�ë\Ù�ìIí�Ú�î�î�ë\Ùì�ï\Ø\í*ç�ÖðìAñ Ç&ò§ÉfÇ�ófôIÓ õ�ÀfôAÄ�Å Öðñ·ÕöÖð×�Ø\Ù�Ú +�ÛPÜ&÷Æø ÙÖPçÚ�î-ç ê Ú�ïfìIí�Ø\ù�Ú�ñ©ç�ú/Ùì�ùûç ê ÚÙÚ�ü�ÖPîÖðìAñþýAÙí ê Öÿü�Ú Öðñ~ç ê Ú�ëNì�Ù�ç mrn o�p5gih7jlk�Û�è2ê Öðî�ç�ý � Ú�î¦ë��ðýAí�Ú�ì�ñ����ÊÖPú8ç ê Ú�ï\ìIí�Ø\ù-Ú�ñ©çqÖðî�ñ\ì4çý��ðÙ�ÚVýAï�� ÖPñªç ê Ú�ëNì�Ù�ç��Ú�ñ\î�Ø\ÙÚ�ï����ç ê Ú�ñ\Ú�שý4ç�Öÿü�Ú�ýAë\ë��PÖðíVý ç�ÖðìAñªí�ì�ñ\ï\Öÿç�ÖðìAñ Û ÕÑÙ�ì�ù�ç ê Öðî-ë�ì�Ù5ç ��ç ê Úï\ìIí�Ø\ù-Ú�ñ©ç�íVýAñ��Ú7ëfØfç�Öðñ©ç�ì=ç ê Ú ø ì�Ù � î�ë§ýAí�Ú Û

PortRAWS PortRAWS

PortRAWS

RA

RA

RA

ÕöÖð×�Ø\Ù�Ú�� ÛÿÜ&÷Q��Ç&ò\É\Ç�ófôIÓ�õIÀfôAÄ�Å���«��§â������¯ã���à���Þ>ß���à����Iá)â*ã§Þ e

��úöç ê Ú8ë\Ùì�×AÙ�ýAù-ù�Ú�Ù ê ý4î�í ê ýAñ\×�Ú�ï¦ç ê Ú7ï\ìIí�Ø\ù-Ú�ñ©ç �§î ê Ú Ó4ê ÚTí ê Ú�í � î�Öðñqý=ñ\Ú ø ÙÚ*ü�ÖðîÖPì�ñ�ìAú�ç ê Ú8ï\ì�í�Ø� ù�Ú�ñ�ç�ÖPñ�ç ê Ú8Ù�Ú�ü�Öðî�Öðì�ñqýAÙ�í ê ÖPüAÚ ÛOè2ê Ú8ë\Ù�ìIí�Ú�îî�ë\Ù�ìIïfØ\í�çÖðì�ñ Ç&ò\É\Ç�ófô\ÒVͧô4Ë\Ì ÖðñqÕ�ÖP×�Ø\Ù�Ú!� Û �#"=ï\Ú�î�í�Ù�Ö$NÚ�îç ê ÖPî;ýAí�çÖðì�ñ�ú/Ù�ì�ù ç ê Ú�ü�ÖðÚ ø ëNì�ÖPñ�ç�ìAú�ç ê Ú ø ì�Ù � îë\ýAí�Ú#�>ç ê Ú�ëfÙì�í�Ú�î�î;ë\Ùì�ï\Ø\í*ç�ÖðìAñ Ç�ò\ÉfÇ�ófô§ÒVÍ\ôAÄ�Å ÖPñÕ�Öð×�ØfÙÚ%� Û �#&�ú/Ùì�ùåç ê ÚTü�ÖðÚ ø ë�ìAÖðñ©çiìAú:ç ê ÚDÙ�Ú�ü�Öðî�Öðì�ñ�ýAÙí ê Öÿü�Ú Ûiè2ê Ú�ë\Ù�ìIïfØ\í�çÖðì�ñ�í�ÙÚ�ý4ç�Ú�î7ý)ñ\Ú ø ïfìIí'

RARA

PortRAWS

content = zrevnr = next(y,x)DocID = y

Document

PortRAWS

content = zrevnr = next(y,x)DocID = y

Document

Õ�Öð×�ØfÙÚ�� Û ��& ��Ç&ò\ÉfÇ ófô\ÒVÍ\ô�Ä�Å��?«��§â������¯ã��(�¯ã ß���à�����á)â*ã§Þ)�¯ã§ÞWà-Þ*�§ârÝ�â�+��$,�� à ã�ßAÝ������*+Aâ�eØ\ù�Ú�ñ©ç=Öðñ�ç ê Ú�ÙÚ*üIÖPîÖPì�ñ ýAÙí ê ÖPü�Úqý4ñ\ï�ç ê Ú�ëNì�Ù5ç mTn�o�p5gih7jlk ç ê ý4ç�í�ì�ÖPñ\í�ÖPï\Ú�Öðñ�ç ê Ú�ÖPÙ=ý4ç�ç�ÙÖ�\ØfçÚ�î Û

- Ü

Page 39: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

è ý���ðÚ.� ÛÿÜ:�0/1�§â�æNÝ�à���â�,�,2�AÝ�ßAá=á-ßAÝ�äVà Ý8Ý�â�+��$,�� à ã�ßAÝ������*+Aâ�,�e3�46587:9:;�<6=>5@? 3:A�BDC E�B@9:46CÇ ÂfÉ�ÁAÀfÉ�ô�Ä�Å � ÷ � ÛÿÜ -Ç ÂfÉ�ÁAÀfÉ�ôAË\Ì � ÷ � ÛÿÜ "Í\É�Îfô�ÂIÉ4ÏNÐIÒ©ÇAÁAÀ�Ò�Ó�Í - & � ÛÿÜ6FÂIÉ4Ô§ô�ÂIÉ4ÏNÐIÒ©ÇAÁAÀ�Ò�Ó�Í - & � ÛÿÜ�GÂIÉAÏÑÐIÒ©ÇAÁ�ÀfÉ - & � ÛÿÜ6HÒ�ÔIÏÑÓ4©À - Ü � ÛÿÜ�IÇ&ò§ÉfÇ�ófôIÓ õ�ÀfôAÄ�Å - Ü � ÛÿÜ&÷Ç&ò§ÉfÇ�ófô\Ò&Í\ôAÄ�Å - Ü � Û ��&

è2ê Ú�ÙÚ*üIÖPîÖPì�ñcñ�Ø\ù0NÚ�Ùî=ì4ú2ç ê Ú�ñ\Ú ø ����í�ÙÚ�ý4ç�Ú�ï ï\ìIí�Ø\ù-Ú�ñ©ç�î=ÖPîDíVý#�ðí�Ø��}ý4çÚ�ïJK�cýAñcìAë�Ú�Ù�ý4çÖðì�ñ ãGâ���Þç ê ý4ç�ï\Ú*ç�Ú�Ù�ù�ÖPñ\Ú�î�ç ê ÚTñ\Ú�L�ç7Ù�Ú�ü�Öðî�Öðì�ñ¦ñ�Ø\ù0NÚ�Ù ø Öÿç ê ÙÚ�î�ë�Ú�í�çiçì�ý-×�ÖPüAÚ�ñ�ï\ì�í�Øfù�Ú�ñ�çiýAñ\ï�ý-ÙÚ*üIÖPîÖPì�ññ�Øfù0�Ú�Ù Ûè2ê Ú�ë\Ù�ìIï\Øfí�ç�ÖPì�ñ�ù�ý �Èí�ì�ñfú/ØfîÚ=ý4ç�ç ê ÖPî�ëNì�Öðñ©ç��î�Öðñ\í�ÚTç ê Ú�ë\Ùì�ï\Ø\í*ç�ÖPì�ñ�í�ÙÚVý ç�Ú�î7ñfÚ ø ï\ì�í�Ø\ù-Ú�ñ©ç�îM��ÖPç�î�Ú�ÿú ÛON ç)ýQP§Ùî5ç)×R�ðýAñ\í�Ú��>Öÿç ø ìAØ��ðïO�ÚÈù-ì�ÙÚqÙÚ�ýAîìAñ§ý���PÚÈÖÿú�ç ê Ú�Ù�Ú¦ÖPî-ýÆï\ì�í�Øfù�Ú�ñ�ç�Öðñcç ê Ú¦ëNì�Ù5çìAú�ç ê ÚS�ðÚ*ú¯çT ê ýAñ\ïcîÖPï\Ú�ç ê ý4ç;Öðî=ÖPù�ëNì�Ù�çÚ�ïcÖPñ�çì�ç ê Ú�Ù�Ú�ü�Öðî�Öðì�ñ�ýAÙ�í ê ÖPüAÚ ÛOU ì ø Ú�ü�Ú�Ù�>çì Ú�ñ\î�Ø\ÙÚqç ê ý çç ê ÚÈí ê Ú�í � Öðñ ìAú�í ê ýAñ\×AÚ�ï~ï\ì�í�Øfù�Ú�ñ�çî-ú/Ù�ì�ù ç ê Ú ø ì�Ù � î�ë§ýAí�Ú�Öðñ©ç�ì ç ê ÚÈÙ�Ú�ü�Öðî�Öðì�ñªýAÙ�í ê ÖPüAÚ�Ú�ñfîØ\Ù�Ú�îýÈí�ì�ÙÙ�Ú�í�çDíVý��Pí�Ø��ðý4ç�ÖPì�ñ�ìAú�ç ê Ú-ÙÚ�ü�ÖPîÖðìAñ�ñ�Ø\ù0NÚ�Ù�î��ç ê Ú�ë\Ùì�í�Ú�îîDëfÙì�ï\Ø\í�çÖðì�ñ Ç&ò\É\Ç�ófô\ÒVͧôAÄ�Å�ê ýAîrçì�ÚiîV��ñ\í ê ÙìAñ\Ö$W�Ú�ï ø ÖPç ê ç ê Úië\Ù�ìIí�Ú�î�î2ë\Ùì�ï\Ø\í*ç�ÖðìAñ Ç�ò\ÉfÇ�ófô§ÒVÍ\ô4Ë\Ì ú/ì�Ù ø ì�Ù � î�ë§ýAí�Ú�î ÛYX ��ñ\í ê ÙìAñ\Ö$W�ý4ç�ÖPì�ñÙÚZ�Ø\ÖPÙÚ�ù�Ú�ñ�çî ø Ö��$�RÚ�ñ\îØ\Ù�ÚTç ê ý4ç�ç ê Úrï\ì�í�Ø\ù-Ú�ñ©ç�Öðî�í ê Ú�í � Ú�ï Öðñqú/Ùì�ùºç ê Ú ø ì�Ù � îë§ýAí�Ú�Öðñ©çì-ç ê ÚTëNì�Ù5çýAñ\ï ú/Ùì�ù�ç ê Ú-ë�ìAÙ�ç8Öðñ©çìqç ê Ú;ÙÚ*üIÖPîÖPì�ñ�ý4Ùí ê Öÿü�Ú-ý4ç8ç ê Ú;îýAù�Ú=çÖðù-Ú��Rî�Ø\í ê ç ê ý4ç7ç ê Ú-ï\ì�í�Ø\ù-Ú�ñ©çîrÖPñ�ìAç ê ü�ÖðÚ ø îTí�ì�Öðñfí�ÖðïfÚ Û �7Ú'Lfë��}ýAÖPñÆç ê Ú�îV��ñ\í ê ÙìAñ\Ö$W�ý4ç�ÖPì�ñ�ìAú�ë\Ùì�í�Ú�îîDëfÙì�ï\Ø\í�çÖðì�ñfîTÖPñÆú/Ø����:ï\Ú�ç�ýAÖ$�:ÖPñî�ç�Ú�ë["-ìAú�ç ê ÖPî2í ê ýAëfçÚ�Ù Û

�>í�ìAñ\í�PØ\ï\Ú ø ÖPç ê ç ê Ú è ý#��ðÚ�� ÛÿÜ ú/ì�Ù�ç ê ÚrëfÙì�í�Ú�î�î�×AÙ�ýAù-ù)ý4ÙY\]\_^ giha` ú/ì�Ù2ÙÚ*üIÖPîÖPì�ñÈýAÙí ê Öÿü�Ú�î Û

b8cedfc�b1c$b g 4658;RC�h hji�46AlkmkmA�4jno5@4qpr5D46s8h3:Al;RC�hè2ê ÚTî5ç�ýAÙ5ç�ëfÙì�ï\Ø\í�çÖðì�ñ�ú/ì�Ù2ç ê ÚTëfÙì�í�Ú�î�î�×AÙ�ýAù-ù)ý4Ù>ú/ì�Ù ø ìAÙ � îë§ý4í�Ú�î�Öðî�î ê ì ø ñ¦Öðñ¦Õ�Öð×�ØfÙÚ�� Û � Ü�Û?è2ê Úí�ÙÚ�ý4ç�ÖPì�ñ ìAú=ý ø ì�Ù � îë§ýAí�Ú�ï\ì�Ú�îÈñ\ìAç¦ÙÚtZ�Ø\ÖðÙ�Ú�ëNì�Ù�çî Û è ì�×�Ú*ç ê Ú�Ù ø Öÿç ê ýAñ@Ú�ù�ëIçu� ø ì�Ù � îë§ýAí�Ú��Týí�ì�ñ\ñfÚ�í�çÚ�ï m.v�o p5gihijlk �ë�ìAÙ�ç2ÖPî2í�ÙÚ�ý4ç�Ú�ï Û

PortRAWS

WS

Õ�ÖP×�Ø\ÙÚw� Û � Ü:�Yx6y�zR{Kyfô#|l}D~a/1�§âa,*Þ ßAÝ*ÞEæNÝ�à���D�*Þ>� à ã�à6äTßj�>à Ý���,Wæfß���â�

��úxý7ë\ÙìA×�Ù�ýAù-ù-Ú�Ù ø ì�Ø��Pï(�PÖ � Ú�çìTí ê ýAñ\×�Ú�ý8ï\ìIí�Ø\ù-Ú�ñ©ç ��î ê Ú�� ê Ú�í ê Ú�í � î>ì�Øfç:ç ê Ú�ïfìIí�Ø\ù�Ú�ñ©çKú/Ù�ì�ù�ç ê ÚÙÚ�ü�ÖPîÖðìAñ�ýAÙí ê ÖPü�Ú ÛOè2ê Ú7ÙÚ*üIÖPîÖPì�ñ�ýAÙ�í ê ÖPüAÚ ê ýAî>çì��ÚiëfØfç�ç ê Ú7ï\ìIí�Ø\ù-Ú�ñ©ç2Öðñ�ç ê Ú7ëNì�Ù�ç?ç ê ý ç2í�ì�ñfñ\Ú�í*ç�îç ê Ú ø ì�Ù � îë§ýAí�Ú ø ÖPç ê ç ê Ú�ÙÚ*üIÖPîÖPì�ñ�ýAÙ�í ê ÖPüAÚaNÚ�ú/ì�Ù�Ú�� ø�ê ý4ç�í�ýAñ�NÚ�ï\ì�ñfÚaK��ç ê Ú�ë\Ù�ìIí�Ú�î�î�ë\Ùì�ï\Ø\í*ç�ÖPì�ñ� ò�� � ófô��6��yfô���� ú/ì�ÙKÙÚ�ü�ÖPîÖðìAñ�ýAÙ�í ê ÖPüAÚ�î>î ê ì ø ñ�Öðñ)Õ�Öð×�ØfÙÚ2� ÛÿÜ&÷fÛ�è2ê Ú�ÙÚ*ú/ì�ÙÚ#�Iç ê Ú�ë\Ù�ìIí�Ú�îî?ë\Ùì�ï\Ø\í*ç�ÖPì�ñ

- �

Page 40: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

� ò�� � ófô��6��yfô#|l} ÖðñÆÕ�ÖP×�Ø\ÙÚ(� Û �R��ÙÚtZ�ØfÖðÙÚ�îDýqï\ì�í�Ø\ù-Ú�ñ©çTÖðñ ç ê Ú-ëNì�Ù�çrìAú>ÖPç�î!�PÚ�ú¯çT ê ýAñ\ï î�Öðï\Ú Û ��ú>ç ê Ú

PortRAWS PortRAWS

PortRAWS

WS

WS

WS

Õ�ÖP×�Ø\ÙÚ�� Û �R� � � ò�� � ófô��6��yfô#|l}Z�����§â������¯ã���à���Þ�ß���à�����á)â*ã§Þ��¯ã�Þ��§â��>à Ý���,Wæfß���â�

ï\ìIí�Ø\ù-Ú�ñ©ç�ÖPîöñ\ì4ç�ý��PÙÚ�ýAï��8Öðù-ëNì�Ù�çÚ�ï8ú/Ùì�ù ç ê Ú>ëNì�Ù�ç�4ÖPñ\ï\Öðí�ý4ç�Ú�ï%K�rç ê Ú?ñ\Ú�שý ç�ÖPüAÚ>ý4ë\ë��ðÖPíVý4çÖðì�ñ8í�ì�ñ\ï\Öe ç�ÖðìAñ1�Aç ê Ú2ï\ìIí�Ø\ù-Ú�ñ©çOÖðî:ë\ØIçOÖðñ©ç�ìiç ê Ú ø ìAÙ � îë§ý4í�Ú�ýAñ\ï;íVýAñqNÚ2í ê ýAñ\×�Ú�ï�ñfì ø ú/ÙìAù ç ê Ú2ë\Ùì�×AÙ�ýAù-ù�Ú�Ù Û

è2ê Ú8ë\Ùì�í�Ú�îî�ë\Ùì�ï\Ø\í*ç�ÖðìAñ � ò�z#������ôR��� � ���l�#��y ú/ìAÙ2í ê ýAñ\×�ÖPñ\×-ý=ï\ìIí�Ø\ù-Ú�ñ©ç�Öðî2×�Öÿü�Ú�ñÈÖPñÈÕ�Öð×�ØfÙÚ!� Û � - Ûè2ê ÚDí ê ý4ñ\×�ÚDì4ú:ý�ïfìIí�Ø\ù�Ú�ñ©çiÖðù-ë��PÖðÚ�î?ç ê ÚT×�Ú�ñ\Ú�Ù�ý4çÖðì�ñÈìAúOý;ñ\Ú ø ï\ìIí�Ø\ù-Ú�ñ©ç7ýAñfï�ÙÚ*ú/Ú�Ù�î�ì�ñ�����ç�ì�ÖPçî

WSWS

content = crevnr = xDocID = y

Document

content = c’revnr = xDocID = y

Document

content = crevnr = xDocID = y

Document

Õ�Öð×�ØfÙÚ�� Û � - � � ò�z#������ôR��� � �K�l�#��yn�����fßAã����¯ã��;Þ��§â���à ã§ÞWâ*ã§Þ2à6äTß���à����Iá)â*ã§Þ�Û

í�ì�ñ©ç�Ú�ñ©ç�î Û:è2ê Ú2ý4ççÙÖ�\Øfç�Ú�î������'��� ýAñ\ï0�#� ������ÙÚ�ù)ýAÖPñDØ\ñfí ê ýAñ\×�Ú�ï Û �þê Ú�ÙÚ�ýAî�ç ê Ú���������� Ù�Ú�ù�ýAÖðñfîØ\ñ\í ê ýAñf×�Ú�ï�ý�� ø ý ��î�Rç ê Ú=ÙÚ�ü�ÖPîÖðìAñ�ñ�Øfù0�Ú�Ù7Öðî7í ê ý4ñ\×�Ú�ï¡K� ý�ëNì�îî�Ö$��PÚ�í ê Ú�í � Öðñ�ìAúOç ê Ú=ï\ìIí�Ø\ù-Ú�ñ©çÖðñ©ç�ì=ç ê ÚrÙ�Ú�ü�Öðî�Öðì�ñÈýAÙ�í ê ÖPüAÚ Û

��ú>ý�ëfÙì�×�ÙýAù-ù�Ú�Ù ê ý4î7í ê ýAñ\×�Ú�ïÆý)ï\ì�í�Ø\ù-Ú�ñ©ç8Öðñ¦ç ê Ú ø ì�Ù � î�ë§ýAí�Ú#�Eî ê Ú � ê Ú=íVý4ñÆïfÚ�í�ÖPï\ÚDçì�í ê Ú�í � ÖPñç ê Úrï\ì�í�Ø\ù-Ú�ñ©çiÖPñ©ç�ì;ç ê ÚTÙÚ�ü�ÖPîÖðìAñ�ýAÙ�í ê ÖPüAÚ Û_¢ ì4çiý����xìAú�ç ê ÚTïfìIí�Ø\ù�Ú�ñ©ç�î�ÖPñ¦ç ê Ú ø ì�Ù � î�ë§ýAí�Ú ê ýVü�ÚDçì�Ú�í ê Ú�í � Ú�ïÈÖðñ�ýA×�ýAÖðñ1��î�Öðñ\í�Ú�ç ê Ú ø ìAÙ � îë§ý4í�Ú7ù�ý��-í�ì�ñ©ç�ýAÖPñ�ý��ðî�ìDÖPñ�çÚ�Ù�ù�Ú�ï\Ö}ý4çÚ�üAÚ�Ù�îÖðìAñ\î Û Õ§ì�Ù?í ê Ú�í � Öðñ\×�ÖPñ ý�ï\ì�í�Ø\ù-Ú�ñ©ç �Rç ê Ú�ë\Ù�ì�×�ÙýAù�ù-Ú�Ù ø ÙÖÿç�Ú�îiç ê Ú�ï\ì�í�Øfù�Ú�ñ�ç8ÖPñ�ç ê ÚDë�ì�Ù5ç7Ø\î�Öðñ\×�ç ê Ú=ë\Ùì�ï\Ø\í*ç�ÖPì�ñ� ò�� � ófôl£ �\ô#|�} ìAú>Õ�ÖP×�Ø\ÙÚq� Û �#" Û�è2ê Ú-ñ\Ú ø ����í�ÙÚVý ç�Ú�ï�ï\ì�í�Ø\ù-Ú�ñ©çTÖðñ�ç ê Ú;ëNì�Ù�ç ê ý4îTýqñ\Ú ø ÙÚ*üIÖPîÖPì�ññ�Øfù0�Ú�Ù>í�ý��ðí�Ø��}ý4çÚ�ï-ú/Ùì�ù�ç ê Ú�ì�ëNÚ�Ùý4ç�ÖPì�ñ ãGâT¤�Þ ýAëfë��ðÖPÚ�ï�çìTç ê Ú�ï\ì�í�Øfù�Ú�ñ�ç>Öðï\Ú�ñ©ç�Ö�P\íVý4çÖðì�ñ-ñ�Ø\ù0NÚ�Ù�¥ýAñ\ïqç ê Ú8ìR�Pï�ÙÚ�ü�ÖPîÖðìAñÈñ�Ø\ù%�Ú�Ù§¦ Û

�þê Ú�ñ�ýrëfÙì�×�ÙýAù-ù�Ú�Ù�P§ñ\ÖPî ê Ú�î��ç ê Ú ø ì�Ù � î�ë§ýAí�Ú�Öðî:ïfÚ�ðÚ*ç�Ú�ï(K�=ç ê Ú�ëfÙì�í�Ú�î�îOë\Ùì�ï\Ø\í*ç�ÖðìAñ ����¨R��y���ô#|�}ÖðñÆÕ�Öð×AØ\ÙÚq� Û � F � ø�ê Ú�ÙÚ-ç ê Ú;ï\Út�ðÚ�çÖðì�ñ ìAú?ç ê Ú ø ì�Ù � îë\ýAí�Ú)ý��ðî�ìÈÖPñ\í�PØ\ï\Ú�î8ç ê Ú-ï\Ú�PÚ�ç�ÖPì�ñ ìAúKç ê Ú-ë�ìAÙ�ç Û©��PÚVýAî�Ú8ñ\ìAç�ÖPí�Ú#�fç ê ý ç�ý#�ðîì;ý#�$�Rï\ì�í�Øfù�Ú�ñ�çî�Öðñ�ç ê Ú ø ì�Ù � î�ë§ýAí�ÚTýAñ\ïqç ê ÚrëNì�Ù5ç�ýAÙÚ8ï\Út�ðÚ�çÚ�ï¦ýAî ø Ú�$� Û�>í�ìAñ\í�PØ\ï\Ú ø ÖPç ê ç ê Ú è ý#��ðÚ�� Û �Dú/ì�Ù�ç ê ÚrëfÙì�í�Ú�î�î�×AÙ�ýAù-ù)ý4ÙY\]\_^oª¬« ` ú/ì�Ù ø ì�Ù � îë\ýAí�Ú�î Û

-R-

Page 41: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

WSWS

PortRAWSPortRAWS

content = zrevnr = xDocID = y

Document

content = zrevnr = xDocID = y

Document

content = zrevnr = next(y,x)DocID = y

Document

­ ®�¯R°�±T²!��³´�#"�µ � ò�� � ófô�£ �§ô#|�} µ ���§â������¯ã��¶�¯ãÆß���à����Iá)â*ã§Þ)�¯ã§ÞWà;Þ��§ârÝ�â�+��$,�� à ã ßAÝ������*+Aâ ³

PortRAWS

WS

­�®$¯R°�±T²!��³´� F µ ����¨R�Ry���ô#|�} µ8· â�¸ðâ*Þ>�¯ã���ßj�>à Ý���,Wæfß���â ³

b8cedfc�b1c$¹ º =>ht<�4�=�» 98<�C�7¼i�46Alk½kmA�4N î�î ê ì ø ñ�ý#�ì&üR²#��ç ê ²¾@² ê ý&ü�®PìR±�ìAúNýië�±ì�í²�î�î:ìAúNýií²t±�ç�ý�®ðñDçu��ë@²¾®ðîöîë@²�í®�Pl²�ï¶K�Dýië�±ì�í²�îî]¯R±ýAù�ù�ý�±í�ì�ñ©ç�ý#®ðñ�®Pñ�¯ ý�*ç¦ì4úDë�±�ìIít²�î�îÈë�±ì�ï�°\í�ç¿®ðì�ñfîqýAñ\ï ýcî�ç�ý#±�çqë�±�ìIï�°fí�ç�®Pì�ñþìAú8ç ê ®Pî�çu��ëÀ²#³ N ë�±ì�í²�îî¯R±�ýAù-ù�ý�±�ì4úKçu��ë@²�¦�í�ýAñ¡À²=îT²²�ñ�ýAî7ý�ë§ý çç�²t±ñ�ú/ìR±ië�±ì�í²�î�î!®ðñ\î5ç�ýAñ\ít²�î7ìAúOçu��ë@²¶¦f³%ÁOýAí ê ë�±ì�í²�îî®ðñ\î5ç�ýAñ\ít² ê ýAî�ç ê ²¡Â5ë�±ìR¯�±�ýAùqÃj¯R®ÿüR²�ñQ®ðñ�ç ê ²=ë�±ì�í²�îîw¯R±ýAù-ù)ý�±t�D®o³Ä²�³@®Pç�î�ë�±ì�í²�îî7ë�±�ìIï�°fí�ç�®Pì�ñ\î�ýAñ\ïç ê ²;î�ç�ý�±�çrë�±�ìIï�°\í�ç¿®ðì�ñ1³ è ì ê ýVüR²�ý4í�í²�îî8ç�ìqç ê ²;ï�®�Å�²t±¿²�ñ�çrë�±�ìIít²�î�î.®Pñ\î�ç�ýAñ\í²�îTì4ú>ì�ñ�²;çu��ë@²)ý4ñ\ïÆçìï�®ðî5ç�®ðñ�¯R°�®ðî ê ç ê ²�ù[� ø ²�ë�±�ì&ü�®Pï�²�ý ãNßAá)â0,Wæfß���â ú/ìR±7ç ê ²�ë�±�ìIít²�î�î.®Pñ\î�ç�ýAñ\í²�îTì4úY²Vý4í ê ë�±�ìIít²�îî8çu��ëÀ²#³è2ê ²7ñ§ýAùq²7îë§ý4í²7í�ìAñ�ç�ý�®ðñfî�ç ê ²7ñ§ý4ù(²�î>ú/ìR±�ë�±�ìIít²�î�î_®Pñ\î�ç�ýAñ\ít²�î2ç ê ý ç2ù)ý ��ìIí�í°�±¾®Pñ�ç ê ²7ï�®ðî�翱¿®��°fç�²�ïîT��î�翲�ù�³ è2ê ²-ñ§ýAùq²=îë\ýAí²q®ðîaP�L�²�ï1� ø�ê ý ç.®Pî7ñ\ìAçTýS±¿²�î5ç�±T®ðí�ç¿®ðì�ñ��xî¿®ðñfí² ø ²-íVý4ñ�í ê ì�ì�îT²-ç ê ²;ñ§ýAùq²îë§ýAít²-ý�±¿�®ÿç�±ý�±¿®����R³a­D±�ì�ù­ç ê ²�ü�®$² ø ë�ì�®ðñ©ç8ìAúKìR�ÆT²�í�çT �ìR±¿®�²�ñ©ç�²�ï ë�±ìR¯�±�ýAù-ù(®Pñ�¯���ý�ë�±ì�í²�îî!¯R±ýAù�ù�ý�±íVýAñÇÀ²;t²�ñcý4îTýqí�ðýAîîTýAñ\ï ç ê ²�ñ§ý4ù(²;îë\ýAí²-í�ì�ñ©ç�ý�®ðñ\î8ç ê ²�ñ§ý4ù(²�î8ú/ì�±rëNì�î�î¿®$��$²=ìR�ÆT²�í�çîDìAú?ç ê ®Pîí�}ý4îî³� ²Tí�ì�ù0�®ðñ�²rç ê ²Të�±ì�í²�îîa¯R±ýAù-ù)ý�±�ýAñfï�ç ê ²Dñ§ýAùq²Tî�ë§ýAí²DìAú�²VýAí ê ë�±ì�í²�î�î�çu��ëÀ²DìAú�ç ê ²�ñ�²�ç ø ìR± �çu�Ië@²q¯R±�ýAë ê ®Pñ�ý ���$,*Þ>È'�>É�IÞWâ¿����È�ßAá=á-ß�È ^ËÊa²*ú̳8"�³ - ³�Í FR` ³ è2ê ²-ë�±�ìIít²�îîrë�±�ìIï�°fí�ç�®Pì�ñ\îrýAñ\ï ç ê ²-î5ç�ý�±5çë�±ì�ï�°\í*ç�®ðìAñ·ìAúTý�ë�±ì�í²�îî�®ðñfî�ç�ý4ñ\í²�ìAú8çu��ë@²Î¦ ø ®ÿç ê ñ§ýAùq²ÎÏ�ç�ý � ²�ñþú�±�ì�ù ç ê ²�ñ§ý4ù(²�î�ë§ýAít² ú/ì�±ë�±ì�í²�î�î�ìAú�çu�Ië@²2¦�ý�±¿²_®ðñ\ï�²�L�²�ï(��;ç ê ²�ñ\ýAù(²_ÏöýAî ø ²���D®ðñ-ìR±ï�²t±KçìTï�®ðî�ç¿®ðñ�¯�°�®ðî ê ç ê ²�ë�±ì�ï�°\í�ç¿®ðì�ñfîìAúöç ê ²!®ðñ\î5ç�ýAñfí²�ît³ÐMÑ Alkm3�Ò�C b1c>ÓDÓJÔ 7:=Ëht< 4#=�»�9f<�C�7OB@46AlkmkmA�4RÕè2ê ²Tï�®ðî�翱¿®��°fç�²�ï[¯�±�ýAù-ù)ý#±2ìAú�ç ê ²Tí�ýArî�ç¿°\ï��ÈìAú�ý-ï�®Pî�翱¿®$�°fç�²�ï¦í�ì�ñ�Pl¯R°�±�ý4ç¿®ðì�ñÈù)ý4ñ§ý�¯R²�ù(²�ñ�ç�îV�IîÌ ç�²�ù�í�ìAñ�ç�ý�®ðñfî�ç ê ²Tç ø ì�ë�±ì�í²�îîw¯R±ýAù�ù�ý�±�î2\]\§^>Öa× ` ý4ñ\ïQ\]\§^oª¬« ` ®Pñ è ý����²���³�Í=ýAñ\ï è ý���$²���³Ø���±¿²�î�ëÀ²�í�ç¿®PüR²t����³ è2ê ²�ñ§ýAùq²2îë§ýAít²2ú/ìR±]±¿²*ü�®Pî¿®Pì�ñ;ý�±í ê ®PüR²�îÙ®Pî]¯R®Pü�²�ñ¶K�����1Ú@^ËÖa× `�Û¬Ü ÍRÝ'��Ý -�Þ ��ß ê ²�ñ§ýAùq²îë§ýAít²�ú/ìR± ø ìR± � îë\ýAí²�î0K�Ç����ÚÀ^˪¬« `!ÛàÜ Í Þ ³ è2ê ²±T²�ú/ìR±T²���ìR°�±Tï�®PîTß¿±¿®$�°�ß�²�ï�îT��îVß�²�ù ù�ý�� í�ì�ñKß�ý�®Pñý#ß�ù�ì�îVß§ß ê ±T²²�±¿²�ü�®Pî¿®ðìAñ¦ý#±í ê ®ÿüR²�î�ýAñ\ï¦ý#ß�ù�ìAîTß�ì�ñ�² ø ì�± � îë§ý4í²�³ � ² ê ýVüR²Tí ê ì��ñ�ú/ìR±¾ß ê ²rîý � ²TìAúî¿®ðù-ë���®ðí®�ßu�%ß ø ì=îù�ý��$��P\ñ�®�ß¿²��ß�ît³ U ì ø ²*üR²±t�ÑýAñK�-ì�ß ê ²t±w^/ë�ì�î�î¿®�����q®ðñ�P§ñ�®�ß¿² ` �ßY®ðî?ë�ìAîî¿®���$²�ýAî ø ²t�$�o³á

- "

Page 42: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

âöý���$²���³Ø��µ /1�lã¾ä@È�å���ã�,�,2��ÈTæ�ç�çqæ�È�è å�Èw��å�È���,uä�æ���ã�,�3�46587:9:;�<6=>5@? 3:A�BDC E�B@9:46Cx6y�zR{Ky�é#|l} - � ��³´��Í��ê � �6ë é�����y�é#|�} -�- ��³´�R���ê z#������éK��� � �K�D�#��y -�- ��³´� -��ê � �6ë é�£���é#|�} - " ��³´�#"����¨R��y���é�|�} - " ��³´� F

b8c�ì í <�C�3 dfî0í�ï ?�;�ð:465@?:=>ñKA�<�=>5@?ò5Dn g 4658;RC�h htC�h¶Al?:7 º =Ëht< 4#=�»�9f<�C�7ôó¶3]C�4�A�<6=>5@?fAlÒ í C�kmAl?1õ<6=Ë;Kh

ö2÷Kß�®��w÷�ø�ù!�aß�ú�²üû¿ý@²þt®�Plþÿ#ß�®�øR÷�ø��%ß¿ú�²���®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²�� û���ûTß�²� ��ø�²tû[÷�ø�ß�þøR÷�ûT®��²t±�ß¿ú�²ü®$÷Kß�²t±�ÿ�þ�ß�®$ø�÷�À²�ßuù�²t²÷½ý�±Tø�þt²ûTû.®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²tû³ U ø�ù�²��R²t±� �þt²±Tß�ÿ�®$÷¡ý�±Tø�þt²ûTû.®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²qý�±Tø���°�þtß�®�øR÷�û!úlÿ��R²¶ß�ø��@²qû���÷� þ�ú�±¿øR÷�®$W²���ß�øw²÷�û¿°�±T²2ÿaþtøR±¿±T²þ�ß�û���ûTß¿²���@²úlÿ���®$ø�±³]­løR±�®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²� Rß¿ú�²¾ûTß�ÿ�±Tß]ý�±¿ø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷ x6y�zR{Ky�é#|�}��ø���ß¿ú�²wù�ø�±���û¿ýlÿ#þ²%®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þt²%ª¬«YÍ!ø��:ß�ú�²!þ ÿ#û¿²�ûTß�°�����úlÿ�û¾ß¿ø��@²!û���÷�þ�ú�±TøR÷�®$Wt²���ù§®�ß�ú�ÿ¶ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û_®$÷� ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²!ý�±Tø���°�þtß�®�øR÷ � {���z�y���é#|l}�£ ø��:øR÷�²wø��fß�ú�²!±¿²���®$û¿®�øR÷Sÿ�±Tþ�ú�®���²w®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²û_ÖaÏ_^>Ï Û ÍRÝ�����Ý - ` �ûT®$÷�þt²ù�øR±���û¿ýlÿ�þt²û_ÿ�±T²wÿ����ø�ù�²��jß�ø��@²aþt±¿² ÿ�ß�²��SøR÷�������±¿ø ÿ�÷�²'L�®$ûTß¿®$÷�¯%±¿²���®�û¿®$ø�÷�ÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²#³ N ÷�ø�ß¿ú�²±�²�L�ÿ�� ý!�$²0®�ûMß�ú�²qû���÷�þ�ú�±¿ø�÷�®$Wÿ#ß�®�øR÷QþøR÷�ûTß�±¿ÿ�®$÷Kß"��øR±2ß�ú�²0ùÙøR±���ûTýlÿ�þ²q®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²�ý�±Tø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷ ��ê � ��ë é�£ ��é�|�}��ù§®�ß�ú ÿαT²���®$ûT®$øR÷ ÿ#±¿þ�ú�®��R²�®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²�ý�±Tø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷ ��ê � �6ë é�£ ��é����D£ ^>Ï Û Í������ - ` ß�øQ²t÷�û¿°�±T²�ÿÎþøR±T±¿²þ�ß±¿²���®�û¿®$ø�÷�÷�°!#�À²t±_ø$��ß¿ú�²!±¿²���®�û¿®$ø�÷�þ�ú�²þ%��²��Q®$÷1³]�ÙþøR÷Kß¿®$÷�°�²wß�ú�®�û¾û¿²tþtß�®�øR÷Sù§®�ß�ú�ß¿ú�²!û���÷�þ�ú�±TøR÷�®$Wÿ#ß�®�øR÷ø��Yý�±Tø�þt²ûTû%®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²qý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷�û� :²�L�ý!�$ÿ�®$÷Qù§ú�²t÷½ý�±Tø�þt²û¿û.ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷�û�ÿ�±¿²qû���÷�þ�ú�±¿øR÷�®�W ÿ����$²(ÿ�÷!�®$÷Kß�±Tø���°�þ².ß¿ú�² ,�&('�����È�å('l��)�æ�*Ë�oå('¡È�ã�¸�æ�*>�oå(' øR÷ ß¿ú�²0ý�±Tø�þt²û¿ûM®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²%ý�±Tø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�û2ø���ÿ+��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��¯R±�ÿ�,(ÿ�±� Rß¿úlÿ#ßÙû¿ú�ø�ù§û�ù§ú�®�þ�ú�ý�±Tø�þt²û¿ûÙ®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þ²Mý�±¿ø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�ûÙúlÿ���²Mß�ø-�À²_û���÷�þ�ú�±TøR÷�®�W²���ù§®�ß�új²ÿ�þ�úø�ß�ú�²t±³üâ¾ú�²�²tÅÀ²þ�߶ø��§ß�ú�²�û���÷�þ�ú�±¿ø�÷�®$Wÿ#ß�®�øR÷J±¿²�� ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷½ø�÷½ß�ú�² ���$,�*>È'�>É��*uã¿�Jå�älã�ÈTæ�*>�oå('@æ�¸�,�ã�çqæ�'.*>�o��,®$û/��®�û¿þt°�û¿ûT²��Çÿ$�*ß�²t±Tù�ÿ�±���ût³%�§®$÷Kß¿±¿ø���°�þ²0ÿ ��¸$å�É�æ�¸8,�ã�çqæ�'.*>�o��, ß�úlÿ#ßaøRýÀ²t±�ÿ#ß¿²ûwøR÷¡ÿ�¯ ��ø �lÿ��:ûTß�ÿ#ß�²0ÿ�÷!�°�û¿²tû�¯ �$ø ��ÿ��0��®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²��½ý�±Tø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�û%ÿ�÷!�Jÿ ��å�çMälå�,��1*Ë�oå('@æ�¸�,�ã�çqæ�'.*>�o��, ß�úlÿ�ß0®$û.þø qý@øRû¿²��2��±¿ø ß�ú�²���ø�þÿ��fû¿²�jÿ�÷Kß¿®$þûMø���² ÿ�þ�ú¡ý�±Tø�þt²ûTûw®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²0°�ûT®$÷�¯�ý�±¿ø�þ²ûTûwý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷�û2ù§®�ß�ú�ø�°�ßMß¿ú�²0÷�²t²��¡ø��¯ �$ø ��ÿ���ûVß�ÿ#ß¿²û³

b8c�ì1c>Ó 3 ð:C íÀï ?:;#ðf465@?�=�ñKA�<6=�5@?54�C�Ò>A�<6=>5@?©�±Tø�þt²ûTû¾®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²aý�±Tø���°�þtß�®�øR÷�û¾ÿ#±¿²aû���÷�þ�ú�±¿øR÷�®$W ÿ$�!�$²a®��8ß�ú�²���úlÿ���²aß�ú�²aû¿ÿ�q² älå�È6*�ä@È�å���l��*>�oå(' ³]â¾ú�²ýÀøR±Vß¾ý�±Tø���°�þtß�®�øR÷ü^ËÊa²��̳�"�³ - ³�Í GK` ø���ÿ�ý�±Tø�þt²û¿û§ý�±Tø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�®�û¾þøR÷�ûVß�±T°�þtß¿²����7�8��²���²tß�®�÷�¯0ß�ú�²wý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û÷�ø���²9��±¿ø ÿ����:��®�ûTß�±T®��°�ß�²�� ¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�û�ø��!ß�ú�²Qý�±¿ø�þ²ûTû�ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷; §®o³Ä²�³�ÿ��$ûTø2��±¿ø ß�ú�² ¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�û�ø��ÿ[ý@øRû¿ûT®�!��²(ÿ#ý�ý!�$®�þ ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷¡þtøR÷!��®�ß�®$ø�÷1³�â¾ú�²t±¿²���ø�±¿²�  ®$÷¡ß�ú�²���®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²��m¯�±�ÿ�ý�ú�û.ø��YýÀøR±Vß%ý�±¿ø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�ûø�þtþ°�±�øR÷!���QýÀø�±Tß.÷�ø���²û� <��°�ß.÷�ø ý�±¿ø�þ²ûTû%÷�ø���²#³ X ��÷�þ�ú�±¿ø�÷�®$Wÿ��!�$²qý�±Tø�þt²û¿û.®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þ²jý�±¿ø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�ûýÀ²t±���øR±� ß¿ú�²0û¿ÿ�(²0ÿ�þtß¿®$øR÷�û2øR÷ ß¿ú�²0ý@øR±Tß¿û³wâ¾ú�²��=��®�Å�²t±MøR÷!����®$÷[ß¿ú�²%ß¿±�ÿ�÷�û���øR±�(ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷[ø��]ß�ú�²#�$ø�þ ÿ��ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û_ûTß�ÿ�ß�²�³

ÐMÑ Alkm3�Ò�C b1c>Ó�b¼Ô 3]5D4�<(3:46587:9�;�<6=�5@?]Õâ¾ú�²[ý@øR±Vß(ý�±¿ø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷òÿ#ß�ß¿ú�²�ß¿øRýOø��Mß¿ú�² ­�®$¯R°�±T²���³´� G ®�û�ß�ú�²Sý@øR±Tßqý�±Tø���°�þtß�®�øR÷Oø��Mß¿ú�²Sý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²�ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷�û � {���z�y���é#|l}�� � {���z�y���é#|�}7> ÿ�÷!� � {���z�y���é�|�}@? ø��)ß�ú�²�±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷¡ÿ#±¿þ�ú�®��R²¶®$÷� ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²tû�Öa×.Í �Öa×w�a±¿²tû¿ý1³�Öa× - ÿ�÷!��ß¿ú�²§ûTß�ÿ#±Tß)ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷ x�y�zR{Ky�é�|�}�� ø��@ß�ú�²¾ùÙøR±���û¿ý�ÿ�þ²2®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²ª «YÍR³]â¾ú�²±¿²���øR±¿²$ �ß�ú�²tû¿²�ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷�û_ÿ�±¿²wû���÷�þ�ú�±¿ø�÷�®$Wÿ��!�$²#³

- F

Page 43: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

PortRAWS

PortRAWSPortRAWS

content = zrevnr = next(y,x)DocID = y

Document

­�®$¯R°�±T²!��³´� G µBA ¤�æ�çMä@¸$ã�,0åÌèYälå�È6*8ä@È�å���l��*>�oå('�,�â¾ú�²§ýÀøR±Vß]ý�±Tø���°�þtß�®�øR÷qÿ#ß]ß�ú�²C�Àø�ßTß�ø ø��Dß�ú�²¾Pl¯�°�±¿²¾®�û�ÿ!ý@øR±Vß]ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷D��øR± ß�ú�²_ý�±¿ø�þ²ûTû�®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷�û ��ê � �6ë é�£ ��é����D£ ��ø�±ÙÏ Û ÍRÝ���Ý - ®$÷�­�®$¯R°�±T²2��³Ø�#&0ÿ�÷!�qß�ú�²2ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿ûY®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²2ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷�6ê � �6ë él£ ��é#|�}E� ®�÷¡­ ®$¯�°�±¿²0��³Ø��"�³.â¾ú�ÿ#ß!®$û� �ß�ú�²%þ�ú�²þ%�Q®�÷Qø��Ùÿ�±¿²���®�û¿®$ø�÷¡ÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²�®�ûaû���÷�þ�ú�±TøR÷�®�W ÿ��!��²ù§®�ß�ú�ß¿ú�²!þ�ú�²þ%�S®$÷Sø�� ÿ0ù�ø�±���û¿ýlÿ#þ²�³ áN û���÷�þ�ú�±¿øR÷�®�W ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷ ±¿²��$ÿ#ß�®�øR÷m^ËÊa²��̳@"�³ - ³�Í HR` ��ø�±Mÿj¯�®��R²t÷=��®�ûTß�±T®��°�ß�²�� ¯R±�ÿ�,(ÿ�±F��²tß¿²±�q®$÷�²û2ù§ú�®$þ�úý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷�ûSø���ý�±Tø�þt²û¿û[®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þ²û�úlÿ��R²üß�øG�À²üû���÷�þ�ú�±TøR÷�®�W²���³IHw÷�����û���÷�þ�ú�±¿øR÷�®�W ÿ����$²üý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²Sý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷�ûqÿ�±¿²�±¿²�� ÿ#ß¿²��1³O©J�$²ÿ�û¿²�÷�ø�ß¿®$þ²$ Ùß¿úlÿ#ß�ß�ú�²[û���÷�þ�ú�±¿øR÷�®$W ÿ�ß�®$ø�÷ò±T²�� ÿ�ß�®$ø�÷O±T²��$ÿ#ß�²tûý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷�û¾øR÷Sß�ú�²!®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²K�$²��R²��L !��°�ß_÷�ø#ß2ø�÷�ß¿ú�²M�$²���²��8ø���ß�ú�²!ý�±Tø�þt²ûTû2¯R±¿ÿ�,jÿ�±Tû³�â¾ú�²±¿²���øR±¿²$ ß�ú�²¾û¿ÿ�(²�ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û]ý�±Tø���°�þtß�®�øR÷D(ÿN�-�@²¾û���÷�þ�ú�±TøR÷�®$Wt²��q®$÷0ø�÷�²¾®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þ²§ÿ�÷!�D(ÿ��#�@²¾÷�ø�ß�®$÷�ÿ�÷�ø�ß�ú�²t±øR÷�²�³ X ��÷�þ�ú�±¿øR÷�®$W²��Çý�±¿ø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�ûMúlÿ��R²0ß¿øO�À²0ÿ�ý�ý!��®$²�� ÿ#ßaß¿ú�²0û�ÿ$(²�ß�®q²0ÿ#÷!�QþøR÷�þ²±T÷Îß�ú�²�û¿ÿ�q²ýÀøR±Vß�û§ÿ�÷��[ý@²±���øR±� ß¿ú�²!û�ÿ�q²wý@øR±T߾߿±�ÿ�÷�û���øR±�(ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷1³ÐMÑ Alkm3�Ò�C b1c>Ó�¹¼Ô h ï ?:;�ð:465@?�=�ñKA�<6=�5@?ò46C�Ò>A�<6=>5@?�Õâ¾ú�²�û���÷�þ�ú�±¿øR÷�®�W ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷m±¿²��$ÿ#ß�®�øR÷P��øR±%øR°�±%þ ÿ#û¿²�ûVß�°!���Ç®$û-��²tP�÷�²��½ù§®�ß�ú½±T²û¿ý@²þ�ß�ß�ø�ß�ú�²8��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��¯R±�ÿ�,(ÿ�±�®�÷[Á L�ÿ�qý!�$²���³�ÍRÍ�ÿ�÷��[®�û¾¯R®���²÷��7�

QKR Û Ü ^ � {���z�y��-S½���T� Ý x6y�zR{�y�Sm����>�` Ý�^ � {���z�y��#Sm����> Ý x�y�zR{KyDS½����?�` Ý^ � {���z�y��-Sm|�}@? Ý x�y�zR{KyDSm|�}���` Ý6^ ��ê � �6ë Sô£ ��Sm����? Ý ��ê � �6ë Sô£ ��SÇ|�}��#` Þ

â¾ú�²¾û���÷�þ�ú�±TøR÷�®�W ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷�ø��lß¿ú�²¾ý�±Tø�þt²û¿û]ý�±¿ø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�û � {���z�y���éR���U� ø��@®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²YÖa×%ͧÿ�÷!� x6y�zR{Ky�é�����>ø��1®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²2Öa×w�w±¿²tZ�°�®$±T²û� �ß�ú�ÿ#ßÙß¿ú�²_þ±¿²ÿ#ß�®�øR÷qø���ß¿ú�²2ý@øR±VßBV��6�(WVÖa×X�@�qÖa×%Í2úlÿ�û]ß�ø-�À²¾ß�ÿ$��²Mý�� ÿ�þt²ÿ#ßjß¿ú�²Îû�ÿ$(²�ß�®q²[ÿ�û(ß¿ú�²Îþ±T² ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷ ø��wß�ú�²[÷�²tùà®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ² Öa×w�mÿ�÷��¼ß�ú�²Îý@øR±Vß8V����YWVÖa×%³ â¾ú�²û���÷�þ�ú�±TøR÷�®$Wÿ#ß�®�øR÷m±T²��$ÿ#ß�®�øR÷DZT²Z�°�®�±¿²û�ß�úlÿ�ß.ß¿ú�²qßuùÙøÎý�±Tø�þt²ûTû0ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷�û�ýÀ²t±���øR±� ß�ú�²(û�ÿ�q²(ý@øR±Vßß�±�ÿ#÷�û���øR±�jÿ�ß�®$ø�÷%ß�øwß�ú�²_û¿ÿ�q²¾ýÀøR±Vß�ût³ U ²t÷�þ²$ �ß¿ú�²§ýÀøR±VßZV.�6�YWVÖa×ôþ±¿²ÿ#ß�²����@�¶Öa×.Í2®�û�ß�ú�²§û¿ÿ�(²¾ý@øR±Vßÿ�û2ß¿ú�²0ý@øR±Tß/V.�6�(WVÖa× þ±T² ÿ#ß¿²��[�@� ß¿ú�²%ûVß�ÿ�±Vßaý�±Tø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷Îø$�)Öa×w��³2â¾ú�²±T²���øR±T²� �ß¿ú�²0®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²�Öa×.Íþ±¿²ÿ#ß�²tû�ß¿ú�²¶®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þ²(Öa×w��³¶�M²'L�ý!� ÿ�®�÷üß¿ú�²¶²tÅÀ²þ�ß�û�®$÷!��°�þ²����@�Qß�ú�²¶û���÷�þ�ú�±¿øR÷�®�W ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷ü±¿²�� ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷Q®�÷(øR±T²/��²�ß�ÿ�®���®$÷�ß¿ú�²w÷�²�L�ß_û¿²tþtß¿®$øR÷; �ù§ú�²÷��Ù®�÷Kß�±¿ø���°�þt²aß�ú�²wø�ýÀ²t±�ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷lÿ$��û¿²�jÿ#÷�ß¿®$þtû¾ø���ÿ���®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��û���ûTß¿²� û¿ý@²þt®�Plþÿ#ß�®�øR÷1³\[øR±¿²tøN�R²±� �ß¿ú�²¶û���÷�þ�ú�±TøR÷�®$Wÿ#ß�®�øR÷ü±¿²��$ÿ#ß�®�øR÷Q±¿²tZ�°�®$±T²û!ß�úlÿ#ß!ß¿ú�²¶ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û%®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þt²(Öa×a�Sþt±¿²ÿ#ß�²tû�ß¿ú�²ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿ûj®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þt²ÎÖa× - ³ â¾ú�² þ±T² ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷òø��aß¿ú�²[ùÙøR±���ûTýlÿ�þ² ®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²Qª¬«YÍ[®�ûqß¿±¿®�¯R¯R²±T²��G�7� ß¿ú�²ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û:®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²)Öa× - �@�!°�û¿®�÷�¯¾ß�ú�²)ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û:ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷ � {���z�y���é#|�}@? ³�â¾ú�²±T²���øR±T²� �ß�ú�²]ùÙøR±���û¿ý�ÿ�þ²

- G

Page 44: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²a®$û�þøR÷�÷�²þtß¿²��Sß�ø0ß¿ú�²a±¿²���®$û¿®�øR÷Sÿ�±Tþ�ú�®���²w®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²wÖa× - ³]â¾ú�²wý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷�û ��ê � ��ë é�£ ��éR����?ÿ�÷!� ��ê � �6ë é�£���é#|�}�� ú�ÿN��²)ß¿øC�À²�û���÷�þ�ú�±¿øR÷�®$W²��.®�÷!øR±���²t±1ß�ø§²÷�û¿°�±T²Ùÿ¾þtøR±¿±T²þtß:±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷w÷�°!��@²±8ø$��ß¿ú�²±¿²���®�û¿®$ø�÷�û§þ�ú�²þ%�#²��Q®$÷�³ N ��1ø�ß¿ú�²±§ý�±Tø�þt²ûTûM®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²!ý�±Tø���°�þtß�®�øR÷�ûF��øq÷�ø�ß_÷�²t²��Îÿ¶û���÷�þ�ú�±¿øR÷�®�W ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷�³­Dø�±:®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þt²� #ß¿ú�²)ûTß�ÿ#±Tß�ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷ x6y�zK{Ky�é����T� ��øR±fûTß�ÿ�±Tß¿®$÷�¯§ß�ú�²�®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²ÙÖa×%ÍÙþ ÿ�÷-�À²)ýÀ²t±���øR±�(²��ù§ú�²÷�²��R²t±2ß�ú�²�ý�±¿ø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷S®�û§ÿ�ý�ý!��®$þ ÿ$�!�$²#³ á

b8c�ì1c�b ó¶3]C�46A�<6=�5@?:A�Ò º =Ëht< 4#=�»�9f<�C�7 í C�kmAl?@<6=Ë;Kh�qþtøR÷�ûT®��²t±�®$÷ ß¿ú�®$û(û¿²tþtß�®�øR÷¼ß�ú�²QøRýÀ²t±�ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷�ÿ��§û¿²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®�þû�ø$��ÿ2��®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²��¼û���ûVß�²� û¿ý@²þt®�Plþÿ#ß�®�øR÷þøR÷�ûT®$ûVß�®$÷�¯(ø���ÿ,��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��[¯�±�ÿ�,jÿ#±§ÿ�÷!�[ÿ(û���÷�þ�ú�±¿øR÷�®�W ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷�±¿²�� ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷�³Ù��ù§®���1²'L�ý!� ÿ�®�÷; lú�ø�ù ß¿ú�²û���÷�þ�ú�±TøR÷�®$Wÿ#ß�®�øR÷%±T²��$ÿ#ß�®�øR÷!®$÷�]l°�²÷�þt²û�ß¿ú�²)þøR÷�÷�²þtß¿®$øR÷�û^�@²tßuùÙ²²÷�ý�±¿ø�þ²ûTû ®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²tû�ÿ�÷��.ß�ú�²®$±f®�÷�ß¿²±Ì ÿ�þtß¿®$øR÷1³ N ß]Pl±TûTß� K�:þø�÷�û¿®���²±]ÿ ��¸$å�É�æ�¸Då�älã�È¿æ�*>�oå('@æ�¸�,�ã�çqæ�'.*>�o��, ÿ�û]®�÷�ß¿±¿ø���°�þt²���®$÷�_ ⧭a`/b"c�c� ´­^`!âFc I$d ù§ú�²±T²Ù�1þtøR÷�ûT®��²t±e��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��.û���ûTß�²�(ûfù§®�ß¿ú.¯��$ø �lÿ$�RûTß�ÿ#ß�²tû³ â¾ú�²Z��øR±�jÿ$�R®$÷Kß�±Tø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷!ø���ß�ú�²)¯ ��ø �lÿ��û¿²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®�þû2®$û_¯R®���²÷ή�÷ X ²þ�ß�®�øR÷ "�³ - ³ F ³ N �*ß�²t±Tù�ÿ�±���û� 1�¾®�÷�ß¿±¿ø���°�þt²0ÿ ��å�çMälå�,��1*>�oå('@æ�¸ å�älã�ÈTæ�*Ë�oå('@æ�¸1,�ã�fçqæ�'.*Ë�o��, ß�úlÿ�ß�®$û]²Z�°�®��#ÿ��$²t÷�ß]ß¿ø�ß¿ú�²§¯ �$ø��lÿ���ø�ýÀ²t±�ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷lÿ$��û¿²�jÿ#÷�ß¿®$þtûM^�þ��̳Râ¾ú�²øR±T²� "�³ - ³ - GK` @��°�ßZ��ø�²tû÷�ø�ß.øRýÀ²t±�ÿ#ß¿²(ø�÷½ÿ[¯��$ø �lÿ$��ûTß�ÿ#ß�²jÿ�÷!�g��ø�²tû%÷�ø�ß.°�ûT²j¯ ��ø �lÿ���ø�ýÀ²t±�ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷�ût³�� ß�ûM��øR±�(ÿ��]®�÷�ß¿±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷þ ÿ�÷��À²"��øR°�÷!�S®$÷ X ²þ�ß�®�øR÷S"�³ - ³ "�³´��³b8c�ì1c�b1cËÓ h i�Ò>5D»:AlÒ í C�kmAl?À<6=>;Kh�» ïGh kmAlÒ�BDAlkmA�<�C�7 g 46587:9�;�<6=�5@?�hâ¾ú�²a¯ ��ø �lÿ��DøRý@²±¿ÿ#ß�®�øR÷lÿ��Dû¿²�jÿ#÷�ß¿®$þ:��ø�±�ÿ���®�ûTß¿±¿®��°�ß�²���û���ûTß¿²� û¿ý@²þ®�Plþ ÿ�ß�®$ø�÷�®$ûi�lÿ�û¿²���øR÷�ß�ú�² æ�çqæ�¸jf�Kæ�çqæ�*Ë�oå(' ø��Ùý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û�®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þ²�ý�±Tø���°�þtß�®�øR÷�ûq^>Êa²��̳1"�³ - ³ - & ` ³0â¾ú�²qþøR÷�þt²ý�ß�ø���ÿ�(ÿ��$¯Rÿ�jÿ�ß�²��[ý�±¿ø� ��°�þtß¿®$øR÷�û ®$û:®$÷Kß¿±¿ø���°�þ²��0®$÷8_lkC\nmpoqc H â�ÿ�²�c H(d ÿ�÷!�0ûTýÀ²tþ®�P�²û ß¿ú�²�¯ ��°�®$÷�¯2ø���²��$²�(²t÷Kß�ÿ�±��.ý�±¿ø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�ûù!³ ±t³Äß³1ÿjþtø �qøR÷[û¿°!��ý�±¿ø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�³"ri�n��²tPl÷�®�ß�®�øR÷ ø$�]ß�ú�²0û���÷�þ�ú�±¿ø�÷�®$Wÿ#ß�®�øR÷α¿²�� ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷T @±T²��$ÿ#ß�²��Îý�±¿ø(sþ²ûTû�®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þ²�ý�±Tø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�û.úlÿ��R²SÿÎþtø �qøR÷ÇýÀøR±Vß0ý�±Tø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷; �ß�úlÿ#ß%®$û%ÿÎû¿°!��ý�±¿ø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷mø��2ÿ���ýlÿ�±Tß¿®$þt®$ýlÿ#ß¿®$÷�¯qý�±Tø�þt²û¿ûM®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²0ý�±Tø���°�þtß�®�øR÷�ût³aâ¾ú�²¶ÿ�(ÿ��$¯Rÿ�jÿ�ß�®$ø�÷�ø���ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿ûw®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²%ý�±¿ø���°�þ6sß�®$ø�÷�ûYøN�R²t±2ÿ�þtø �qøR÷�ý@øR±TßYý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷�¯ �$°�²tûYß�ú�²!ý�±Tø�þt²ûTû_®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þt²wý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷�û§ÿ��$ø�÷�¯0ß�ú�²wý@øR±Vßý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷1³�â¾ú�²2ÿ�(ÿ��$¯Kÿ$jÿ#ß¿²��¶ý�±Tø���°�þtß�®�øR÷qû¿ý@²þ®�Pl²û)ß�ú�²t÷jß�ú�²2û���÷�þ�ú�±¿øR÷�®$W²��Sÿ�ý�ý!��®$þÿ#ß�®�øR÷�ø��1ß¿ú�²û¿®$÷�¯ �$²aý�±¿ø�þ²ûTû2®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þt²�ý�±¿ø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�û³ÐMÑ Alkm3�Ò�C b1c>ÓKd�Ô AlkmA�Ò>BDAlkmA�<�C�7 3�46587:9:;�<6=>5@?:h�Õ­ ®$¯R°�±¿²"t�³ut H û¿ú�ø�ù§û¾ß�ú�²aÿ�jÿ$�$¯Kÿ�(ÿ#ß¿²��qý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷�ûYþø�÷�ûTß¿±¿°�þ�ß�²��O��øR±� ß¿ú�²wý�±Tø�þt²û¿û¾®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þt²aý�±¿ø(s��°�þtß¿®$øR÷�û � {���z�y���é����U� ÿ#÷!� x6y�zK{Ky ����> ^Ëÿ#ß_ß�ú�².ß�øRý ` ÿ�÷!� � {���z�y���é#|�}@? ÿ�÷!� x6y�zR{Ky�é#|�}�� ^>ÿ#ßMß¿ú�²�Àø�ßTß�ø ` ³�â¾ú�²aý�±Tø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�ûÙÿ�±T²M¯ ��°�²���ÿ$�$øR÷�¯!ß�ú�²®$±)þø��qøR÷jý@øR±Vß�ý�±Tø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷1³ â¾ú�²a°�ý�ý@²±�ÿ�(ÿ���s¯Kÿ�(ÿ#ß�²��Qý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷Qû¿ú�ø�ù§ûwß�úlÿ�ßwß�ú�²�®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²¶Öa×.Ͷþ±¿²ÿ#ß�²tûaß�ú�²¶®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²¶Öa×/t�ÿ�÷!�Qß�ú�²D�$ø�ù�²t±ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷�ûTú�ø�ù§û_ß¿úlÿ#߾߿ú�²!®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²�Öa× - þ±¿²ÿ#ß�²tû¾ß�ú�²wùÙøR±���û¿ý�ÿ�þ².®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt².ª «YÍR³â¾ú�²Oÿ�jÿ$�$¯Kÿ�(ÿ#ß¿²�� ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷v��øR± ��ê � �6ë é�£ �lé�����? ÿ�÷!� ��ê � �6ë é�£���é#|�}�� ®�û=��²tý�®$þ�ß�²�� ®$÷ ­ ®$¯$s°�±¿²�t�³ut H ³2â¾ú�²�ÿ�(ÿ��$¯Kÿ$jÿ#ß¿²���ý�±Tø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷[û¿ú�ø�ù§ûaß�ú�²%û���÷�þ�ú�±¿øR÷�®�W²��üþ�ú�²þ%� su®�÷Qø���ÿj±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷���±¿ø ß�ú�²wùÙøR±���û¿ý�ÿ�þ².®$÷Kß�ø0ß¿ú�²!±¿²���®�û¿®$ø�÷[ÿ#±¿þ�ú�®��R²�³ á­Dø�±¶ß¿ú�²S¯ �$ø��lÿ��¾øRý@²±¿ÿ#ß�®�øR÷lÿ��YûT²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®�þû¶ø��wÿw��®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²��Oû���ûTß¿²� û¿ý@²þt®�Plþÿ#ß�®�øR÷OþøR÷�ûT®$ûVß�®$÷�¯Çø��aÿ��®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²��ü¯R±�ÿ�,(ÿ�±!ÿ�÷!�mÿ�û���÷�þ�ú�±¿øR÷�®$W ÿ�ß�®$ø�÷m±¿²�� ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷T 1ù�²(þøR÷�ûT®��²t±�ß¿ú�²qû¿²tß%ø��¾ÿ$��]ý�±Tø�þt²û¿û.®$÷�sûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²�ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷�ûD�>ÿ�þtß¿øR±¿®�W²��G�@� ß�ú�²S²tZ�°�®��#ÿ��$²t÷�þ²�±¿²�� ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷J®�÷!��°�þt²��G�7� ß¿ú�²Sû���÷�þ�ú�±TøR÷�®$Wÿ#ß�®�øR÷±¿²��$ÿ#ß�®�øR÷ ^ËÊa²��̳ex�³ - ³ - Í ` ³ ­løR±%²ÿ�þ�úJ²Z�°�®���ÿ$�$²÷�þ²jþ�� ÿ�ûTû� �ùÙ²�þø�÷�ûTß¿±¿°�þ�ß�ß�ú�²jÿ�jÿ$�$¯Kÿ�(ÿ#ß¿²��üý�±¿ø���°�þ6sß�®$ø�÷y�7�Jÿ�jÿ$�$¯Kÿ�(ÿ#ß¿®$÷�¯[ÿ���)ß�ú�²Oq²�#�À²t±¿û�ø��_ß�ú�²�²tZ�°�®��#ÿ���²÷�þt²�þ�� ÿ�ûTû¶ÿ��$ø�÷�¯Îß�ú�²t®$±0þtø ,(øR÷Jý@øR±Vßý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷1³�â¾ú�²w¯ ��ø �lÿ��@øRý@²±¿ÿ#ß�®�øR÷lÿ��@û¿²�jÿ�÷Kß¿®$þû�®$û�ß¿ú�²÷�¯R²t÷�²±¿ÿ#ß�²��z�7�(ß�ú�²"��²±¿®��#ÿ#ß�®�øR÷jûT²Z�°�²÷�þ²ûûTß�ÿ#±Tß�®�÷�¯�ÿ#ß2ß�ú�²%²�qý�ß{�9��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��ίR±¿ÿ�ý�úQ°�ûT®$÷�¯jß¿ú�²�ÿ�(ÿ���¯Kÿ�(ÿ#ß�²��[ý�±Tø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�û|��øR±2ß¿ú�²0²tZ�°�®��@sÿ��$²t÷�þ²qþ��$ÿ�û¿ûT²û³ U ø�ù�²��R²±� ]û¿®�÷�þ²qß�ú�²qûTß�ÿ�±Tß.ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷Çþt±¿²ÿ#ß�²tû0ÿ[÷�²tù ®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²(ÿ�÷!�üù�²���ø ÷�ø#ß

- H

Page 45: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

PortRA

PortRAWS

RA1 RA2

WS1RA3RA3

RA1

­ ®$¯R°�±¿²Ot�³ut H µO} çqæ�¸�~Kæ�çqæ�*uã���ä@È�å����.��*L�oå('�,2è å�È � {���z�y���é����U�Oæ�'E�¡x6y�zR{�y�é�����>ôÈ�ã�,uä�� � {���z�y���é#|�}@?æ�'E�(x6y�zK{Ky�é#|�}E���

RA3RA3

PortRAWS

WS1

content = zrevnr = xDocID = y

Document

WS1

content = zrevnr = xDocID = y

Document

content = zrevnr = next(y,x)DocID = y

Document

PortRAWS

content = zrevnr = next(y,x)DocID = y

Document

­ ®�¯R°�±T²Mt�³�t I µZ} çqæ�¸�~Kæ�çqæ�*uã��!ä@È�å�������*��oå('%è å�È ��ê � �6ë é�£���é�����?Jæ�'E� ��ê � �6ë é�£ �lé#|�}����ÿ����ø6ù ßuù�ømøR±+qøR±¿²S®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²tûjù§®�ß¿úòß¿ú�² û¿ÿ�(²[÷lÿ�q²� �ùٲαT²Z�°�®$±T²[ß¿úlÿ#ßqß�ú�²[ûTß�ÿ#±Tß�ý�±¿ø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�ûø��a®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²tû(±T²ûTý1³�ÿ$jÿ���¯Kÿ�(ÿ#ß�²��½ý�±Tø���°�þtß�®�øR÷�û¶þø�÷�ß�ÿ�®$÷�®$÷�¯üÿÇûVß�ÿ�±Vßqý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷òø��aÿ�÷O®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²ÿ�±¿²�ÿ#ý�ý!�$®�²��½®�÷JøR÷�²O��²t±¿®���ÿ�ß�®$ø�÷mû¿²tZ�°�²÷�þt² ÿ�ßD(ø�ûTß�øR÷�þ²�³üâ¾ú�²t±¿²���ø�±¿²� Ùÿ���û¿øQÿ�����ý�±Tø�þt²ûTû�®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷�û¾û���÷�þ�ú�±TøR÷�®�W²��[ù§®�ß�ú�ÿ�ûTß�ÿ�±Tß_ý�±Tø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷Sþ ÿ#÷��@²�ÿ�ý�ý!��®$²��[ÿ�ßF(øRûVߧøR÷�þt²�³N (ÿ��$¯Kÿ$jÿ#ß¿²��aý�±¿ø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�û�ÿ#±¿²�®$÷!¯R²t÷�²±¿ÿ���¯ �$ø ��ÿ�����®�ûTß¿±¿®��°�ß�²��.ý�±Tø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�û� #ûTýÀ²tþ®��1��®�÷�¯¾ß�ú�²�ß�±¿ÿ�÷�û�s��øR±�(ÿ#ß�®�øR÷Sø��]ûT²��R²t±�ÿ�� ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿ûa®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²tû³_â¾ú�²�ÿ�(ÿ���¯Kÿ�(ÿ#ß�²���ý�±¿ø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�ûMÿ�±T²0ÿ�ý�ý!�$®�²��Sß�ø�ÿ,��®$û�sß�±¿®���°�ß¿²�� ¯�±�ÿ�ý�ú ±¿²ý�±¿²ûT²÷Kß�®�÷�¯½ß�ú�² ¯ ��ø �lÿ��¾ûVß�ÿ#ß¿² ø��aß¿ú�²=��®�ûTß¿±¿®��°�ß�²�� û���ûVß�²� þø�÷�ß�ÿ�®$÷�®$÷�¯Çû¿²���²±¿ÿ��ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿ûS®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þ²ût³��q±¿²Z�°�®�±¿²=��øR±(ß�ú�²[(ÿ#ß�þ�ú�ø��.ÿ�÷ ÿ�(ÿ���¯Kÿ�(ÿ#ß�²�� ý�±Tø���°�þtß�®�øR÷ô®$÷¼ß¿ú�²Q¯ ��ø �lÿ����®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²��ôû���ûVß�²� ûTß�ÿ�ß�²� _ß�úlÿ�ß�ß�ú�²[(ÿ#ß¿þ�úô®$û�þtø (ý�ÿ#ß�®��!�$²Sù§®�ß¿ú¼ß�ú�²Q®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²tûü^ËÊa²��̳Bx�³ - ³ - x ` ³k�ø (ý�ÿ#ß�®��!�$²¾ù§®�ß¿újß�ú�²a®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þ²ûCq² ÿ#÷�û� �ß�úlÿ#ßÙß�ú�²:jÿ#ß¿þ�ú+��øR±�ÿ�÷�ÿ�(ÿ��$¯Rÿ�jÿ�ß�²��¶ý�±Tø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷; �ß�úlÿ�ß®$û�þøR÷�ûTß�±T°�þtß¿²��+��±Tø rß¿ú�²2ý�±¿ø�þ²ûTû�®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²_ý�±Tø���°�þtß�®�øR÷�ûJ��øR±�®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²!Í2ß¿ø-�< �þ ÿ�÷��À²2ÿ�ý�ý!��®$²��qø�÷!���ß�ø[ß¿ú�²qý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û0®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²tûjÍqß�ø�� ®$÷¡ß�ú�²j¯ ��ø �lÿ���û���ûTß�²� ¯R±¿ÿ�ý�úÇû¿°�þ�úmß¿úlÿ#ß�ß�ú�²(ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û.®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²÷�ø���² Ï0ø��wß¿ú�²Qÿ�(ÿ���¯Kÿ�(ÿ#ß�²��Oý�±¿ø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷ ®$û+(ÿ�ý�ý@²��òß�ømß¿ú�²Îý�±Tø�þt²û¿ûj®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²Î÷�ø���²ÎÏ.®$÷ ß¿ú�²¯ �$ø ��ÿ��J��®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²��Çû���ûTß¿²� ¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú1³Sâ¾ú�®$û.²÷�ûT°�±¿²tû� �ß�ú�ÿ#ß.ùÙ²�þÿ�÷mûTý!�$®�ß�ß¿ú�²�ÿ$jÿ���¯Kÿ�(ÿ#ß�²��Pjÿ#ß¿þ�ú

- I

Page 46: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

®$÷Kß�øn�$ø�þ ÿ��Zjÿ�ß�þ�ú�²tû#��øR±!ß�ú�²�®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þt²û³Qâ¾ú�²÷; �ß¿ú�²�¯ ��ø �lÿ��0��®�ûTß�±T®��°�ß�²��mû¿²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®�þû0®�û%²tZ�°�®��#ÿ��$²t÷Kßß�ømß¿ú�²Qþø qý@øRû¿®�ß�®$ø�÷lÿ��¾øRý@²±¿ÿ#ß�®�øR÷lÿ��§û¿²�jÿ#÷�ß¿®$þtûjß�úlÿ�ßO��ù§®��§®�÷�ß¿±¿ø���°�þt²Î®$÷ ß¿ú�²Q÷�²'L�ß�û¿²þ�ß�®�øR÷ ^>þ��̳â¾ú�²øR±T²��x�³ - ³ - GK` ³ÐMÑ Alkm3�Ò�C b1c>Ó�ì¼Ô B@Ò>5D»:AlÒÙ5D3]C�46A�<6=�5@?:AlÒ�hC�kmAl?À<6=>;Kh�Õâ¾ú�²�­ ®�¯R°�±¿²8t�³�t�c û¿ú�ø6ù§û¶ÿÎý�ÿ�±Tß%ø��¾ß�ú�²j¯ �$ø ��ÿ��Ùø�ýÀ²t±�ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷lÿ$�)ûT²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®�þû0ø��¾ß¿ú�²�þÿ�û¿²�ûVß�°!����³¡â¾ú�²��²±T®��#ÿ#ß�®�øR÷mûT²Z�°�²t÷�þ²�ûTß�ÿ�±Tß¿û�ÿ#ß0ß¿ú�²�²�qý�ß{����®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²��J¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú; ]®Ë³ ²#³�®�÷mß�ú�²8�À²t¯R®$÷�÷�®$÷�¯[ß�ú�²t±¿²�ÿ�±T²÷�øQý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿ûT²û�®$÷Çß�ú�²O��®�ûTß¿±¿®��°�ß�²��½û���ûTß¿²��³¡â¾ú�²÷; ]ß¿ú�²�ûTß�ÿ�±Tß0ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷g��øR±.ß¿ú�²�®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²SÖa×.Í

PortRA PortRA

PortRA PortRA

PortRA RA1

RA1 RA2

RA1 RA2

start-RA1

create-RA1 + start-RA2

replicate2

­ ®�¯R°�±¿²Kt�³ut�c�µi� æ�È�*§åÌè"*1�lã:~�¸$å�É�æ�¸������*ËÈ6�>É���*Ìã��,��ã�çqæ�'.*����%��®$û�ÿ�ý�ý!�$®�²��1³¡â¾ú�®�û0ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û¶®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²�ý�±¿ø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷Jþÿ�÷��À²�ÿ�ý�ý!��®$²��Çù§®�ß�ú�øR°�߶ÿ�÷@�mû���÷�þ�ú�±TøR÷�®�ÿ#ß�®�øR÷þøR÷�ûVß�±¿ÿ�®$÷Kß�ût³Z��®$÷�þ²§ß�ú�²2±¿²���®�û¿®$ø�÷�ÿ�±Tþ�ú�®���²M®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²MÖa×%ÍMûTúlÿ����@ø�þþt°�±�ø�÷!����ø�÷�þ²2®$÷(ß¿ú�²:��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��û���ûTß¿²�� �ß�ú�²wûVß�ÿ�±Vߧý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷8��øR±§Öa×%Í!þ ÿ#÷�÷�ø�ßF�À²!ÿ#ý�ý!�$®�²��Sÿ�÷@��qøR±¿²#³]â¾ú�²÷; �ß¿ú�²!ÿ�(ÿ��$¯Rÿ�jÿ�ß�²��¯ �$ø ��ÿ��1ý�±Tø���°�þtß�®�øR÷ � {���z�y���éR���U�N��x�y�zR{Ky�éR����> ®$û_ÿ�ý�ý!�$®�²��SøR÷Sß�ú�²K��®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²���û���ûTß¿²� ¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú1³Ùâ¾ú�²ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷QûTß�ÿ#±Tß�ûaß¿ú�²�®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²¶Öa×/tSÿ#÷!�¡þøR÷�÷�²þtß¿û!®�ßaù§®�ß�úQ®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²¶Öa×.ÍR³ ¢ ø6ùM 8ø�÷�²�þ ÿ�÷¡ûT²²ß�úlÿ#ßfß¿ú�²Ùþt±¿²ÿ#ß�®�øR÷.ø$��ß�ú�²Ùý@øR±Tße�@�Mq² ÿ�÷�ûfø���ß�ú�²)ý�±Tø���°�þtß�®�øR÷ � {���z�y���é����U� ÿ#÷!�.ß¿ú�²�û���÷�þ�ú�±TøR÷�®�ÿ#ß�®�øR÷þøR÷�ûVß�±¿ÿ�®$÷KßYø�÷ � {���z�y���éR���U� ®�÷!��°�þt²û�ß¿ú�²Mþt±¿² ÿ�ß�®$ø�÷�ø��8ß�ú�²M÷�²�ù ®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þt²wÖa×"t�³ â¾ú�²wÿ�(ÿ��$¯Rÿ�jÿ�ß�²��ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷ � {���zRy���é����T�N��x6y�zK{Ky�é�����> þÿ�÷j÷�ø#ßB�@²Mÿ#ý�ý!�$®�²��(ÿ�¯Kÿ�®�÷; Kû¿®�÷�þ²2®�ß�ùÙøR°!��(þ±T² ÿ#ß¿²Mÿ�û¿²þtøR÷!�ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û�®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²ÎÖa×"t�³ â¾ú�²Î¯ ��ø �lÿ��F��®�ûTß¿±¿®��°�ß�²��¼û���ûTß¿²� ûTß�ÿ�ß�² þtøR÷�ûT®$ûTß¿û�÷�ø�ù ø��aßuùÙøJ±¿²���®�û¿®�øR÷ÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²tû�ù§®�ß¿ú(ß�ú�²®$±ÙýÀø�±Tß�ûiV����YWVÖa×%³ � ²wÿ�ý�ý!���¶÷�ø�ù�ß�ú�²Mý�±Tø�þt²û¿û�®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²Mý�±Tø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷ È�ãuä@¸j���¿æ�*uã��ß�ø�ß�ú�²q®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þt²¶Öa×"tjß�ø�ý�°�ß�ÿz��ø�þt°!(²t÷Kß!®$÷Kß�ø�ß¿ú�²�ýÀø�±Tß ³%Áa�R²÷ü®���ß¿ú�²�ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷Qþ ÿ�÷üÿ���û¿øO�@²ÿ�ý�ý!��®$²��(ß�ø%ß¿ú�²a®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²wÖa×.Í ��J��øR±���®�(ß�ú�®�û¾ÿ�ý�ý!��®$þÿ#ß�®�øR÷; Kû¿®�÷�þ²2ß�ú�²!ÿ�(ÿ���¯Kÿ�(ÿ#ß�²��,(ÿ#ß¿þ�ú�²û¾ûTúlÿ����À²§þø�(ýlÿ�ß�®���$²Ùù§®�ß�ú�ß�ú�²_®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þt²û³�­l°�±Vß�ú�²t±�ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷�û]þ ÿ�÷q÷�ø�ù��@²_ÿ�ý�ý!��®$²��0ß�øwß�ú�²§÷�²�ùô¯ ��ø �lÿ����®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²��Sû���ûTß¿²� ûTß�ÿ#ß�²#³ á

� c

Page 47: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

�q��ì;���;�� h�� 5E�g�]5E���1�Y�>5E�� lÒYó��J¡7¢( ��Y�>5E�� lÒ í ¡��g .�U�Y��£@�â¾ú�²§¯ �$ø ��ÿ���øRý@²±¿ÿ#ß�®�øR÷lÿ���û¿²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®�þ¾°�û¿²tûÙ¯��$ø �lÿ$��ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷�û]¯Rø�ß0�@��ß¿ú�²_ÿ�jÿ$�$¯Kÿ�(ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷�ø��Àý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²!ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷�û� lß�ú�ÿ#ß2ÿ�±¿²�ÿ�ý�ý��$®$²��SøR÷ ÿ¶¯ ��ø �lÿ��;��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��Sû���ûTß¿²� ¯R±�ÿ#ý�ú1³C��®$÷�þt².ÿ¶¯ ��ø �lÿ����®�²tùrøR÷mÿz��®�ûTß�±T®��°�ß�²��üû���ûVß�²�¤��ø�²û!÷�ø#ß.²6¥�®$ûTß� <�2±¿²tûTß�±T®$þ�ß�²��ǯ �$ø��lÿ��^��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��Çý�±¿ø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�û!ß¿øý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿ûYý�±Tø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�û� Kß�úlÿ#ß�þ ÿ�÷��À²Mÿ�ý�ý!��®$²�����ø�þÿ�����R³e�u÷�øR±���²±�ß�ø%ý�±¿²���²÷Kß_ÿ���û¿ø!ß�ú�²2¯ �$ø ��ÿ��!��®$²tù¦��ø�±ß�ú�²_¯R²÷�²±�ÿ�ß�®$ø�÷(ø��Àß�ú�²_øRý@²±¿ÿ#ß�®�øR÷lÿ���ûT²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®�þû�ø��8ÿK��®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²��qû���ûTß¿²� û¿ý@²þt®�§lþÿ#ß�®�øR÷; 7� ®�÷Kß�±¿ø���°�þt²ÿ[þø�(ý@øRû¿®�ß�®�øR÷lÿ��]øRý@²±¿ÿ#ß�®�øR÷lÿ��]ûT²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®�þû.ß¿úlÿ#ß%®$û�þøR÷�ûVß�±T°�þtß¿²��2��±¿ø� ß¿ú�²+��ø�þÿ���û¿²�jÿ�÷Kß¿®$þû.ø��Yß¿ú�²ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û�®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²tû�ýlÿ�±Tß¿®$þt®$ýlÿ#ß¿®$÷�¯[®$÷mß¿ú�²8��®�ûTß¿±¿®��°�ß�²��Jû���ûTß¿²��³Çâ¾ú�®�û0þø�(ý@øRû¿®�ß�®�øR÷lÿ���øRý@²±¿ÿ#ß�®�øR÷lÿ��û¿²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®�þûS®$û�²�¨�°�®��#ÿ���²÷KßSß�øJß�ú�²ü¯ ��ø �lÿ��2øRýÀ²t±�ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷�ÿ��MûT²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®$þtû³©�u÷ ß¿ú�²¡û¿²�¨�°�²��� "�(®$÷���ø�±�(ÿ�����®$÷Kß�±Tø���°�þ²Yß�ú�²Cjÿ�®�÷0®��² ÿ�û]ø��@ß�ú�²¾þø qýÀø�û¿®�ß¿®$øR÷�ÿ���øRýÀ²t±�ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷�ÿ���ûT²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®$þtûa��øR±]ÿ"��®�ûTß�±T®��°�ß�²��¶û���ûVß�²�û¿ý@²þ®�§lþ ÿ�ß�®$ø�÷1³�ª©��²�ß�ÿ�®��$²��[��øR±�jÿ$��²�¥�ý!�$ÿ�÷lÿ#ß¿®$øR÷¡þ ÿ#÷g�@²,��ø�ø���²��ü°�ýÇ®$÷���²þ�ß�®�øR÷gx�³ � ³�x�³qâ¾ú�²�(ÿ�®�÷��² ÿ#ß¿°�±¿²tû_ø$�^#��ÿ�ý�ý�±TøKÿ�þ�ú�ø���ÿ#÷[øRý@²±¿ÿ#ß�®�øR÷lÿ��Àû¿²�jÿ�÷Kß¿®$þû§ÿ#±¿²ÍR³¾ß�ú�²P��²tû¿þt±¿®$ý�ß�®$ø�÷ ø���ß�ú�²���ø�þÿ��MøRý@²±¿ÿ#ß�®�øR÷lÿ��Mû¿²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®�þûO��øR±�²ÿ�þ�ú ý�±Tø�þt²ûTû ®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²¡®$÷ôß¿ú�²

��®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²��S¯R±¿ÿ��(ÿ�±i�7�S®�ß�û å�älã�'(ä@È�åN��ã%�%�/��ã�çqæ�'.*����%�/« Êa²��̳.x�³ � ³ut ¬�­�ÿ�÷!�t�³¾ß�ú�²�þtø (ý@øRûT®�ß�®�øR÷aø���ß�ú�²�øRý@²÷�ý�±Tø�þt²û¿û:û¿²�jÿ#÷�ß¿®$þtû�ÿ#þþø�±���®�÷�¯¾ß�ø¾ß�ú�²)û���÷�þ�ú�±¿øR÷�®�� ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷!±T²�� ÿ�ß�®$ø�÷

« Êa²��̳!x�³ � ³ut�® ­�³

ó��J¡��°¯-¢65q£ ¡���� í ¡��g .�U�N�L£@� �±��ù�²�ú�ÿN��²�¯R®���²÷¡ÿ+��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��Qû���ûTß¿²� ¯�±�ÿ�,jÿ#±_þtøR÷Kß�ÿ�®�÷�®$÷�¯�ÿý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û ¯�±�ÿ�,jÿ#±fÿ�÷!�0ÿ§÷lÿ�q²)û¿ýlÿ�þt²i��øR±f²ÿ�þ�ú0ý�±Tø�þt²û¿û:ß{��ýÀ²Ù®$÷!ß�ú�²)÷�²tßuùÙøR±���ß{��ý@²�¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú; (�1ý�±TøY��®���²��øR±(²ÿ�þ�ú¼ý@øRû¿ûT®�!��²Sý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿ûj®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þt² ®�ß¿û���ø�þÿ��YøRý@²±¿ÿ#ß�®�øR÷lÿ��¾ûT²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®�þû³�â¾ú�®�û���ø�þÿ��¾øRý@²±¿ÿ#ß�®�øR÷lÿ��û¿²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®�þû0��øR±Ùÿ�ý�±Tø�þt²ûTû�®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²p��²ûTþ±¿®��À²tû�øR÷����0ß¿ú�²:��ø�þÿ��lûTß�ÿ#ß�²_ø���ß¿ú�²Mý�±¿ø�þ²ûTû�®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²2ÿ�÷!�+��ø÷�ø�ß_þøR÷Kß�ÿ�®$÷�ÿ�÷@�S¯ ��ø �lÿ��1ûVß�ÿ#ß¿²�³Z� ß_®$û¾þ ÿ$��$²�� å�älã�'jä@È�åN��ã%�%�:��ã�çqæ�'.*L���%� �ûT®$÷�þt²!®�ߧþø�÷�û¿®���²±Tû2÷�ø#ß2ø�÷!���ß�ú�²�²tÅÀ²þ�ß�ûM¯�²÷�²t±�ÿ#ß¿²��9�@��ß¿ú�².ý�±¿ø�þ²ûTûMý�±Tø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�û§ø���ß�ú�²�ý�±Tø�þt²û¿û_®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²$ U��°�ßMÿ$�$û¿ø(ÿ����1²tÅÀ²þ�ß�ûøR÷¶ýÀøR±Vß�û�ß¿úlÿ#ß�þ ÿ#÷,�@²§þ ÿ�°�û¿²��,�@��ý@øR±Tß�ý�±Tø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�û]ø$�Àø#ß�ú�²t±]ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û)®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²û�ø��Dß�ú�²|��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��¯R±�ÿ�,(ÿ�±³â¾ú�²%øRý@²÷�ý�±Tø�þt²û¿û2û¿²�jÿ�÷Kß¿®$þûF��øR±_ÿ(ý�±¿ø�þ²ûTûM®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²�®$û§¯R²t÷�²±¿ÿ#ß�²��9�@�Sß�ú�²K��²t±¿®��#ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷SûT²�¨�°�²÷�þ²ûûTß�ÿ#±Tß�®�÷�¯wÿ#ß�ß�ú�²�²�qý�ß{�#��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��0¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�°�ûT®$÷�¯Mß¿ú�²Yý�±Tø�þt²ûTû]ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷�û ø��lß¿ú�²Yý�±Tø�þt²ûTû]®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²ÿ�÷!�¶ß�ú�²_ýÀø�±Tß�ý�±Tø���°�þtß�®�øR÷�û�ø��Àß�ú�²§ý�±Tø�þt²û¿ûÙý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷�û�ø��@ß�ú�²_ø�ß�ú�²±�®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þ²û)®$÷�ß¿ú�²p��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��¯R±�ÿ�,(ÿ�±³q�ÀûTß�ÿ#±Tß�ÿ#ß8ß�ú�²)²�(ý�ß{�M��®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²��!¯R±�ÿ#ý�ú; �û¿®$÷�þ²)ÿ�÷�®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²�þ ÿ�÷K�À²�þt±¿² ÿ�ß�²��%ÿ#ß:ÿ�÷@�wß�®�(²��°�±¿®�÷�¯�ß�ú�²üÂ��$®���²6s ß¿®q²Ãjø$�YÿO��®�ûTß�±T®��°�ß�²��¡û���ûVß�²�[³��u÷üýlÿ�±Tß¿®$þt°!� ÿ�±� 1®$÷¡ÿ#÷7�ÎýÀøRûTû¿®��!�$²�²t÷7��®�±¿øR÷!q²÷Kß� ß�úlÿ#ß:û¿ÿ#ß�®�û�§l²tû:ß¿ú�²�þøR÷!��®�ß�®�øR÷�û;��øR±8ß¿ú�²Ùþt±¿²ÿ#ß�®�øR÷!ø���ß¿ú�²�®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²�³�â¾ú�²Ùý�±¿ø�þ²ûTû ®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²tû:ÿ�±¿²)þ±T² ÿ#ß¿²���7�¡ß¿ú�²jÿ#ý�ý!�$®�þ ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷¡ø���ß�ú�²t®$±!ûTß�ÿ�±Tß.ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷1³�²�°�ûVß�ÿ�û�®$÷¡ß�ú�²(þ ÿ�ûT²jø���ß�ú�²q¯ �$ø��lÿ��]øRý@²±¿ÿ#ß�®�øR÷lÿ��û¿²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®�þû� a�w±¿²�¨�°�®$±¿²(ß�úlÿ#ß.ß�ú�²(ûTß�ÿ�±Tß�ý�±¿ø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷Çø��§² ÿ#þ�úJý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û0®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²j®$û.ÿ�ý�ý!��®$²��mÿ#ß�qøRûVßøR÷�þ²$ §û¿®$÷�þ²9�0ù�ÿ�÷Kß�ß¿ø2��²ûTþ±T®�@² ß�ú�²n�$ø�þ ÿ��F�@²úlÿ���®$ø�±jø��!ÿÇû¿®$÷�¯ �$²�ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û�®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þt² øR÷!���R³ â¾ú�²��®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²���¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�û¾ø��fß¿ú�²wøRý@²÷Sý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û§û¿²�jÿ#÷�ß¿®$þtû³��øR±¾ÿ�ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û§®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²wþtøR÷Kß�ÿ�®�÷Sÿ#ßCqøRûTß¾ø�÷�²ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û¾÷�ø���²� �÷lÿ�q²����(ß¿úlÿ#ßYø�÷�²:��øR±�ß¿ú�²aþtøR±¿±T²û¿ý@øR÷!��®$÷�¯�®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²#³Jª:��ß�øR¯R²�ß�ú�²t±� �ß�ú�²aø�ýÀ²t÷�ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿ûû¿²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®�þû/��øR±!ÿ�ý�±Tø�þt²ûTû�®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þt²,��²û¿þt±¿®��À²tû!ß¿ú�²���®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²��Qû���ûVß�²�´��±¿ø ß�ú�²��$ø�þ ÿ$�<��®$²�ù§ýÀøR®�÷Kßø���ß�ú�®�ûaû¿®�÷�¯ �$².ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û!®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²$ 1ù§ú�²±T²(ÿ8(ÿ(¥�®(ÿ��f²÷@��®$±TøR÷!q²÷Kß!®$ûaÿ�û¿ûT°!(²��¡®$÷Îß�ú�²0û¿²t÷�û¿²¶ß�úlÿ�ßÿ���ÀýÀøRûTû¿®��!�$²w²�Å�²tþtß�û_øR÷�ýÀø�±Tß�û§ÿ#±¿²!þøR÷�û¿®��²±¿²��1³ÐMÑ  .�g��Òµ¡ �;�>Ó�¶¼Ô 5��J¡����<¢65q£ ¡����,��¡��g .�U�N�L£@��Õ�u÷%ß�ú�²i��®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²��.û���ûTß¿²�r¯�±�ÿ�,jÿ#±8ø��DøR°�±:þ ÿ�ûT²YûTß¿°!���� �ù�²�úlÿ��R²�ß¿ú�±¿²t²�±¿²���®$û¿®�øR÷0ÿ#±¿þ�ú�®��R²Y®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²tûÖa×%Í fÖa×/t�ÿ�÷!�üÖa× � ÿ�ûMùÙ²����]ÿ�û!ÿ�ùÙøR±���û¿ý�ÿ�þ²¶®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²qª¬«YÍR³�â¾ú�²��$²��*ß�suúlÿ#÷!�Îû¿®���²�ø���ß�ú�²¶­ ®$¯$s°�±¿²�t�³ ��· û¿ú�ø6ù§û!ÿqýÀø�û¿û¿®��!�$²�û¿²�¨�°�²÷�þt²�ø��]ß�±¿ÿ�÷�û���øR±�(ÿ#ß�®�øR÷�û§®$÷�ß�ú�².øRý@²÷Îý�±Tø�þt²ûTûaû¿²�jÿ�÷Kß¿®$þû2ø���ß¿ú�²

x ·

Page 48: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

±¿²���®�û¿®$ø�÷�ÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²¾®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þt²§Öa×%Í Rø�÷0ß�ú�²¾±T®$¯RúKß�s úlÿ�÷!�%û¿®��²�ß�ú�²t±¿²¾®�û�ÿaý@øRû¿ûT®�!��²Yû¿²�¨�°�²÷�þt²2ø��lß¿±�ÿ�÷�û���øR±�sjÿ#ß¿®$øR÷�û]®$÷¶ß�ú�²2øRýÀ²t÷jý�±Tø�þt²ûTû�û¿²�jÿ#÷�ß¿®$þtûÙø���ß�ú�²_±¿²���®�û¿®�øR÷jÿ#±¿þ�ú�®��R²M®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þt²MÖa×/t�³Jr�ø�ß¿újûT²�¨�°�²÷�þ²û

PortRAPortRA

PortRA PortRA

PortRA PortRA PortRA PortRA

PortRA PortRA

G0 H0

G1 H1RA1

RA1

RA1

¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸¹ ¹ ¹ ¹ ¹¹ ¹ ¹ ¹ ¹¹ ¹ ¹ ¹ ¹¹ ¹ ¹ ¹ ¹¹ ¹ ¹ ¹ ¹¹ ¹ ¹ ¹ ¹¹ ¹ ¹ ¹ ¹¹ ¹ ¹ ¹ ¹¹ ¹ ¹ ¹ ¹

º º º º ºº º º º ºº º º º ºº º º º ºº º º º ºº º º º ºº º º º ºº º º º ºº º º º ºº º º º º» » » » »» » » » »» » » » »» » » » »» » » » »» » » » »» » » » »» » » » »» » » » »

¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼½ ½ ½ ½ ½½ ½ ½ ½ ½½ ½ ½ ½ ½½ ½ ½ ½ ½½ ½ ½ ½ ½½ ½ ½ ½ ½½ ½ ½ ½ ½½ ½ ½ ½ ½½ ½ ½ ½ ½

¾ ¾ ¾ ¾ ¾ ¾¾ ¾ ¾ ¾ ¾ ¾¾ ¾ ¾ ¾ ¾ ¾¾ ¾ ¾ ¾ ¾ ¾¾ ¾ ¾ ¾ ¾ ¾¾ ¾ ¾ ¾ ¾ ¾¾ ¾ ¾ ¾ ¾ ¾¾ ¾ ¾ ¾ ¾ ¾¾ ¾ ¾ ¾ ¾ ¾¾ ¾ ¾ ¾ ¾ ¾¿ ¿ ¿ ¿ ¿¿ ¿ ¿ ¿ ¿¿ ¿ ¿ ¿ ¿¿ ¿ ¿ ¿ ¿¿ ¿ ¿ ¿ ¿¿ ¿ ¿ ¿ ¿¿ ¿ ¿ ¿ ¿¿ ¿ ¿ ¿ ¿¿ ¿ ¿ ¿ ¿

À À À À À ÀÀ À À À À ÀÀ À À À À ÀÀ À À À À ÀÀ À À À À ÀÀ À À À À ÀÀ À À À À ÀÀ À À À À ÀÀ À À À À ÀÀ À À À À ÀÁ Á Á Á Á ÁÁ Á Á Á Á ÁÁ Á Á Á Á ÁÁ Á Á Á Á ÁÁ Á Á Á Á ÁÁ Á Á Á Á ÁÁ Á Á Á Á ÁÁ Á Á Á Á ÁÁ Á Á Á Á Á

    Â    Â    Â    Â    Â    Â    Â    Â    Â    Âà à à à Ãà à à à Ãà à à à Ãà à à à Ãà à à à Ãà à à à Ãà à à à Ãà à à à Ãà à à à Ã

start-RA1port production of productionstart-RA1

create-RA1 start-RA2

port production of productionreplicate2

replicate2

G2

G3 RA2

H3

RA2

H2

­ ®$¯R°�±¿²pt�³ � · µZ� æ�È6*1�%åÌè|*µ�lã�å�älã�'0ä@È�åN��ã%�%�|��ã�çqæ�'.*����%�!åÌè:*1�lãMÈ�ã�ÄN����oå('[æ�ÈÅ�%���1Ä�ãp�1'���* æ�'T��ã%� Öa×.ÍnÆ ¸$ã�è6*�f��æ�'E�D������ã{Ç(æ�'E� Öa×"twÆ È���~(��*�f���æ�'E��������ã{Ç��

ûTß�ÿ#±Tߧÿ#ßÙß�ú�²M²�qý�ß{�+��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²���¯R±�ÿ#ý�ú1³a�u÷�ß¿ú�²/§l±¿ûVß¾ûTß¿²ý�ø��fß¿ú�²Mß�±¿ÿ�÷�û���øR±�(ÿ#ß�®�øR÷qû¿²�¨�°�²t÷�þ²�ø��8ß¿ú�²±¿²���®�û¿®$ø�÷�ÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²!Öa×.Í �ß¿ú�²w®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²a®�ûYþ±T² ÿ#ß¿²��O�@�jß¿ú�²wûTß�ÿ�±TßYý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷ x6y�zR{Ky�é����U� ³Ù­D±Tø ß�ú�®�ûýÀøR®�÷Kß� fß�ú�²qûTß�ÿ�±Tß.ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷Çþÿ�÷�÷�ø#ß#�@²(°�û¿²��½ÿ�÷@��qøR±T²,��øR±"��°�±Vß�ú�²t±�ß¿±�ÿ�÷�û���øR±�jÿ#ß¿®$øR÷�û!ß¿ø[²t÷�û¿°�±¿²ÿ9�$ø�þ ÿ��J��®$²�ù ø��¾®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²�Öa×.ÍR³=�u÷Jÿ[û¿²þtøR÷!� ûTß¿²ý; �ß¿ú�²�®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²�Öa×%Í�þt±¿² ÿ�ß�²û0ÿ ÷�²tù ý@øR±Tß#�7�ß�ú�²(ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷ � {���z�y���é����U� ³Îâ¾ú�²(ß�ú�®�±��mûVß�²tý½ø��§Öa×.Í�ÿ�ý�ý!��®$²tû%ÿ�ýÀøR±Vß%ý�±¿ø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷Çø��§ÿ�÷�ø�ß�ú�²t±®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²� Y÷�ÿ�(²����Çß�ú�²�ýÀø�±Tßqý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷òø$�a�#��È�É*Ï ��Ê@WV�Yt�³ôâ¾ú�®$ûqýÀø�±Tßqý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷ þ±¿²ÿ#ß�²tû�ÿü÷�²tù��ø�þt°!q²÷KßM®�÷�ß�ú�²�ýÀø�±Tß2øR÷�ß¿ú�²�±¿®$¯�ú�ß�suúlÿ#÷!�[ûT®��²#³�â¾ú�®�ûMÿ#ý�ý!�$®�þ ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷�ø$��ý@øR±Tß_ý�±Tø���°�þtß�®�øR÷�û§ø�� ø�ß�ú�²t±®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²û-(ø�ß¿®��#ÿ#ß¿²ûaß�ú�²j÷lÿ�q² å�älã�' �ûT®$÷�þt²qß¿ú�²jþt±¿² ÿ�ß�®$ø�÷Çø��¾ÿ���ø�þ°�(²t÷�ß%®$÷¡ß�ú�²qý@øR±Tß.®$ûK�lÿ�ûT²��øR÷Îß�ú�²�²t÷@��®�±¿øR÷�(²t÷�ßwÿ�÷!�Q÷�ø�ßaø���ß�ú�²0®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þt²¶Öa×%Í�®�ß¿û¿²����̳wâ¾ú�²�®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²¶Öa×.Í�þ ÿ�÷Îß¿ú�²÷üÿ�ý�ý!�����°�±Tß¿ú�²±§ý�±Tø�þt²û¿û_ý�±Tø���°�þtß�®�øR÷�û§ÿ�÷��[ý@øR±Tߧý�±¿ø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�û³â¾ú�²aß�±¿ÿ�÷�û���ø�±�(ÿ#ß�®�øR÷jûT²�¨�°�²÷�þ²"��øR±�ß¿ú�²a®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²wÖa×/t0ÿ�ý�ý!��®$²tû�®$÷(ß�ú�²/§l±TûTß¾ûVß�²týSß¿ú�²aý@øR±TßYý�±¿ø���°�þ6sß�®$ø�÷Çø�� x�y�zR{Ky�éR���U� ÿ�÷!�½þt±¿² ÿ�ß�²û%ÿ[ý@øR±Tß³�â¾ú�®$û.û¿ú�ø�ù§û�  ß�úlÿ�ß0ÿ�ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û0®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²,��ø�²û.÷�ø�ß.úlÿ��R²ß�øP�À²�ÿ�þ�ß�®��R²O��±¿ø ß�ú�²z�@²¯R®�÷�÷�®$÷�¯Qø��Mß¿ú�²z��®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²�� û���ûTß¿²��³òâ¾ú�²[ý�±Tø�þt²ûTû(®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²�Öa×/t¡®�ûÿ�þtß¿®��#ÿ#ß�²��j®�÷qß¿ú�²MûT²þø�÷!��ûTß¿²ý1³J�u÷jß¿ú�²2ß¿ú�®$±��jûVß�²ýT �ß�ú�²M®$÷�®�ß�®$ÿ��!��ø�þ°�(²t÷�ßÙ®$û)±¿²tý!�$®�þ ÿ#ß¿²��qß�ø.ß¿ú�²Mý@øR±Vß�7�jß�ú�²!ý�±Tø���°�þtß�®�øR÷ {���ËD¨�£ � zRy��7> ³â¾ú�²���®�ûTß�±T®��°�ß�²��[¯R±�ÿ#ý�ú�ûM®�÷[ß¿ú�²%øRý@²÷ ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿ûaûT²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®$þtûp��øR±2Öa×%Í%û¿ú�ø�ù øR÷!����ß�ú�²-�$ø�þ ÿ��fûTß�ÿ#ß�².ø��ß�ú�²!ý�±Tø�þt²û¿û_®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²�Öa×%Í�ÿ�÷���ß¿ú�²!ýÀøR±Vߧ²÷@��®$±TøR÷!q²÷Kß� �ß¿úlÿ#ߧ®$û³��®�û¿®���$²:��øR±§ÿ$��1ý�±Tø�þt²ûTû2®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²tû®$÷¡ß�ú�²���®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²��üû���ûTß¿²��³�â¾ú�²+��®�ûTß�±T®��°�ß�²��ǯR±�ÿ#ý�ú�û�ø��Yß�ú�²(øRý@²÷Çý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û0ûT²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®�þûM��øR±%Öa×/tû¿ú�ø�ù øR÷����jß¿ú�²M�$ø�þ ÿ��ÀûTß�ÿ#ß�²!ø�� Öa×"t¶ÿ�÷!��ß�ú�²�ý@øR±Vߧ²÷@��®$±¿ø�÷!(²t÷Kß ³ á

�¾û¿ú�ø�ù ÷�²�¥�ß� �ú�ø�ù ß�ú�²0ø�ýÀ²t÷Qý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿ûaûT²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®$þtûp��øR±2² ÿ�þ�úQ®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þt²0®$÷�ß�ú�²���®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��ίR±¿ÿ��(ÿ�±þ ÿ�÷��À²!°�ûT²��Sß�ø¶þø�÷�ûTß¿±¿°�þ�ß2ß¿ú�²!þø qýÀø�û¿®�ß¿®$øR÷�ÿ��U��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��Sû¿²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®�þût³

x�Í

Page 49: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

º �����N¢(��»^Ìq�N¡�Í í ¡��g .�U�N�L£@� î9� 5E�g�]5E���1�Y��5U� 5�ÎK�6ð�¡OóD�J¡��v¯K¢65q£ ¡���� í ¡��g .�E�Y�L£@� â¾ú�²¶þtø �sýÀøRûT®�ß¿®$øR÷lÿ$��øRý@²±�ÿ�ß�®$ø�÷lÿ���ûT²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®$þtûÙø$�8ÿ-��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��(û���ûTß�²�n �û¿ý@²þt®�§l²��+�@�(ÿK��®�ûTß¿±¿®��°�ß�²��j¯R±¿ÿ��(ÿ�±ÿ�÷!�Îÿ(û���÷�þ�ú�±TøR÷�®�ÿ#ß�®�øR÷ ±T²��$ÿ#ß�®�øR÷; l®$û_þø�(ý@øRû¿²��9��±¿ø� ß�ú�².øRýÀ²t÷Îý�±Tø�þt²û¿ûMû¿²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®�þû_ø��]®�ß�û_ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²ût³â¾ú�²2þtø qýÀøRûT®�ß¿®$øR÷0ø$�ÀßuùÙø%øRý@²÷¶ý�±Tø�þt²ûTûÙûT²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®$þtû]ù§®�ß�úq±¿²tû¿ý@²þ�ßÙß¿ø�ý�±¿ø�þ²ûTûÙ®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þt²ûiVqͧÿ�÷��+V-tþø qýÀø�û¿²û_ß�ú�²-��®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²��ί�±�ÿ�ý�ú�ûaÿ�÷!�[ß�ú�²�ß�±�ÿ#÷�û���øR±�jÿ�ß�®$ø�÷�ûF�À²�ßuù�²t²÷P��®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²��[¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�û³2â¾ú�²þø qýÀø�û¿®�ß¿®$øR÷P��ø�²û%÷�ø�ß.÷�²þt²û¿û¿ÿ�±¿®����DZ¿²�]l²þ�߶ÿ���0��®�ûTß¿±¿®��°�ß�²��m¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�û.±¿²ûTý1³�ß¿±�ÿ�÷�û���øR±�jÿ#ß¿®$øR÷�û�ø$�_ÿ�÷®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²�ÿ�÷!� ®$ûMý@²±���øR±�q²��Îÿ�û:��ø ���$ø�ù§û « þ��̳�Êa²��̳Ex�³ � ³ut ®�­�µFªÏ��®�ûTß¿±¿®��°�ß�²��ίR±�ÿ#ý�ú¤ÐÑ ø$�ZVqÍ0þÿ�÷=�@²þø qýÀø�û¿²��(ù§®�ß�úSÿ-��®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²���¯R±¿ÿ�ý�úÒÐÓàø��eV#t�®��1ß¿ú�²/��®�ûTß�±T®��°�ß�²��j¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�ûY±¿²tûTß¿±¿®$þ�ß�²��jß�ø0ß¿ú�²Mý@øR±Tß¿ûÿ�±¿²Ù²�¨�°lÿ��˳�â¾ú�²Yÿ�þtß¿°lÿ���þø qýÀø�û¿®�ß¿®$øR÷�ø���ß¿ú�²ÙßuùÙø"��®�ûTß�±T®��°�ß�²��.¯R±�ÿ#ý�ú�û ®�û:ß¿ú�²®�±^��®�û�ÆTøR®�÷Kß�°�÷�®$øR÷T #ù§ú�²t±¿²ß�ú�²wý@øR±Tß¿û¾ÿ�±T²w®��²t÷�ß¿®�§l²��Sÿ$�*ß�²t±Tù�ÿ�±���û³�â¾ú�²!û���÷�þ�ú�±TøR÷�®�� ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷�±T²�� ÿ�ß�®$ø�÷�®$÷�]�°�²÷�þt²û¾ß�ú�²wþø qýÀø�û¿®�ß¿®$øR÷ø�� ß¿ú�²�ß¿±�ÿ�÷�û���øR±�jÿ#ß¿®$øR÷�ûVß�²tý�û³Cª¬ß�±¿ÿ�÷�û���ø�±�(ÿ#ß�®�øR÷�ûTß¿²ý=�@²tßuùÙ²²t÷ ßuù�ø+��®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²���¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�ûÔÐÑDÕ ÿ�÷!�ÐÑKÖ ù§®�ß¿úSß¿ú�²wý�±Tø���°�þtß�®�øR÷DÈ Õ ÿ#ßFjÿ�ß�þ�ú Ð× Õ ®�÷�VqÍwþÿ�÷n�@²!þø qý@øRû¿²��Sù§®�ß�ú�ÿ0ß�±¿ÿ�÷�û���ø�±�(ÿ#ß�®�øR÷�ûTß¿²ý�À²�ßuù�²t²÷ ßuùÙø���®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²�� ÐÓ Õ ÿ�÷!� ÐÓ Ö ù§®�ß�ú�ß¿ú�²!ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷�È Ö ÿ#ßF(ÿ#ß¿þ�ú Ð× Ö ®$÷�V-t�®��

Ø ß�ú�²M��®�ûTß¿±¿®��°�ß�²���¯�±�ÿ�ý�ú�ûÙÐÑ�Õ ÿ�÷!�ÚÐÓ Õ ÿ�û¾ùÙ²����fÿ�ûÙÐÑKÖ ÿ�÷!�ÚÐÓ Ö þÿ�÷��À²wþtø (ý@øRûT²��; Ø ®��³È Õ ÿ�÷!�gÈ Ö ÿ�±¿²[ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û�®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ² ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷�û(ß¿ú�²÷ ß¿ú�²�� ÿ�±T²Î®$÷Oß�ú�²[û���÷�þ�ú�±TøR÷�®�ÿ#ß�®�øR÷±¿²�� ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷; �®��EÈ Õ ®�û2ÿqýÀø�±Tß_ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷�ß¿ú�²÷,È Õ ®�û¾ß�ú�²�ýÀø�±Tß_ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷[ø$�TÈ Ö D®��TÈ Ö ®$û_ÿqý@øR±Vßý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷�ß�ú�²t÷,È Ö ®$ûYß¿ú�²!ýÀø�±Tߧý�±Tø���°�þtß�®�øR÷Sø��EÈ Õ Dÿ�÷!�

Ø ß�ú�²M(ÿ#ß�þ�ú�²û Ð× Õ ÿ#÷!� Ð× Ö ±¿²tûTß¿±¿®$þ�ß�²���ß¿øqß¿ú�²!ýÀøR±Vß�û§ÿ�±T²!²�¨�°lÿ��˳©�±Tø�þt²ûTûY®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þ²Mý�±¿ø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�û�þ ÿ#÷8�À²2±¿²�� ÿ#ß¿²��8�@�¶ß�ú�²Mû���÷�þ�ú�±TøR÷�®�ÿ#ß�®�øR÷j±T²��$ÿ#ß�®�øR÷(®��1ß�ú�²��(úlÿ��R²Mß¿ú�²û�ÿ�q²�ýÀø�±Tß!ý�±Tø���°�þtß�®�øR÷1³D�±�Ùß�ú�²�(ÿ#ß�þ�ú�²tû!ø���±T²��$ÿ#ß�²��Çý�±Tø�þt²ûTû�®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þt²qý�±¿ø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�û.ÿ$�!��®�ß¿®$øR÷�ÿ�����þøR®�÷�þ®���²¾øR÷¶ß�ú�²_ýÀø�±Tß�û)ÿ�÷��qß¿ú�²2ý@øR±Vß�¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�û�ø���ß¿ú�²_ß¿±�ÿ�÷�û���øR±�jÿ#ß¿®$øR÷�û]ÿ�±¿²§²�¨�°�ÿ��� Kß�ú�²§ßuùÙø.ß¿±�ÿ�÷�û���øR±�sjÿ#ß¿®$øR÷�ûVß�²tý�û�®�÷+V¶Í_ÿ�÷!�8V-taþøR®�÷�þ®���²§®$÷�ß�ú�²2ý@øR±Tß�ß¿±�ÿ�÷�û���øR±�(ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷; �®o³Ä²�³Rß�ú�²���ß�±¿ÿ�÷�û���øR±� ß¿ú�²2û¿ÿ�q²²��$²�(²t÷Kß�û0®�÷Çß�ú�²�û�ÿ�q²jý@øR±Vß�û0®�÷Çß�ú�²�û�ÿ�q²(ù�ÿ��R³Qâ¾ú�²�þtø qýÀøRûT®�ß¿®$øR÷üø��¾ß�ú�²jßuù�øÎß¿±�ÿ�÷�û���øR±�jÿ#ß¿®$øR÷ûTß�²tý�û!þø qý@øRû¿²tûaß�ú�²D��®�ûTß¿±¿®��°�ß�²��Q¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�ûÛÐÑDÕ ÿ�÷��ÜÐÓ Õ ÿ�ûaùÙ²�����ÿ�ûÝÐÑMÖ ÿ�÷!�ÞÐÓ Ö ³�â¾ú�²¶þø qýÀø�û¿®�ß¿®$øR÷ø��aß�ú�²[ß�±¿ÿ�÷�û���øR±�(ÿ#ß�®�øR÷�û¶®$û(ÿ�¯Kÿ#®$÷ ß�ú�²t®$±,��®$û*ÆTøR®$÷Kßq°�÷�®�øR÷; �ù§ú�²t±¿² ß¿ú�² ý@øR±Vß�û�ÿ#±¿²�®��²t÷�ß¿®�§l²��1³ â¾ú�²þø qýÀø�û¿²��qß�±¿ÿ�÷�û���ø�±�(ÿ#ß�®�øR÷�ûTß¿²ýjø�÷(ß�ú�²2ý@øR±Tß¿û�®$û�²�¨�°lÿ��Dß�ø!ß�ú�²_ß¿±�ÿ�÷�û���øR±�(ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷�®�÷+V¶ÍMÿ#÷!�8V-twÿ�÷!�ß�ú�²wß�±¿ÿ�÷�û���øR±�(ÿ#ß�®�øR÷�øR÷Sß�ú�²�ý�±¿ø�þ²ûTû¿²tû2þtøR®$÷�þt®��²w®�÷�VqÍ!±¿²tû¿ý1³�V-t�³ÐMÑ  .�g��Òµ¡ �;�>Ó�ßòÔ £R5E�g�]5E���1�Y�>5E��Õ�.þtøR÷�û¿®���²±�ß¿ú�²Sþø qýÀø�û¿®�ß¿®$øR÷mø��2ß¿ú�²�ßuù�ø¡ß�±¿ÿ�÷�û���øR±�(ÿ#ß�®�øR÷Jû¿²�¨�°�²÷�þt²û(®$÷O­ ®$¯�°�±¿²zt�³ � · ³Jâ¾ú�²z��®$û�sß�±¿®���°�ß¿²��q¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�ûGÐÑ"à ÿ�÷!�áÐÓ à ��øR±�Ï Û · Ý�����Ý � þ ÿ�÷��À²§þtø (ý@øRûT²��; �û¿®�÷�þ²¾ß�ú�²��(ÿ�±¿²§²�¨�°�ÿ��DøR÷(ß¿ú�²§ýÀøR±Vß�ût³�1úlÿ��R²Y®�÷!��®�þ ÿ#ß¿²��.ß¿ú�²�ý@øR±Vß�û:²�¨�°lÿ���®$÷-�Àø�ß¿ú#��®�ûTß¿±¿®��°�ß�²��%¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�û ÐÑMà ÿ�÷!� ÐÓ à �@��ß¿ú�²�þtø ,(øR÷�ýlÿ#ßTß�²t±¿÷« ¯R±T²��¶ÿ�÷��(ù§ú�®�ß�²� �±T²û¿ý@²þ�ß�®��R²�����­�³J�u÷(ÿ��!��®�ß�®$ø�÷; �ß�ú�²2ûT®$÷�¯ ��²Yß�±¿ÿ�÷�û���ø�±�(ÿ#ß�®�øR÷0ûTß¿²ý�ûÙø���Öa×%Í2ÿ�÷!��Öa×/tþ ÿ�÷,�À²§þtø (ý@øRûT²��; �û¿®�÷�þ²¾ß¿ú�²¾ß�±�ÿ#÷�û���øR±�jÿ�ß�®$ø�÷�û]øR÷�ß�ú�²_ý@øR±Tß¿û�ÿ�±¿²§²�¨�°lÿ$�Àÿ#û�ùÙ²����o³�â¾ú�²2û���÷�þ�ú�±¿ø�÷�®�ÿ(sß�®$ø�÷j±¿²�� ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷(®$ûÙû�ÿ#ß¿®$û�§�²���®$÷(ß�ú�²Mß¿±�ÿ�÷�û���øR±�jÿ#ß¿®$øR÷(ûTß¿²ý�ûwÍwÿ#÷!� � û¿®�÷�þ²MøR÷�²a®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²M°�û¿²tûYß�ú�²aý@øR±Vßý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷qø$��ß�ú�²_ý�±¿ø�þ²ûTûÙ®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þt²2ý�±Tø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷¶°�ûT²��j®�÷�ß�ú�²_ø�ß�ú�²±�®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þ²�³^�u÷(ß�ú�²§ß¿±�ÿ�÷�û���øR±�jÿ(sß�®$ø�÷�ûTß�²týOt� Rß¿ú�²§®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þ²§Öa×%Í_°�ûT²û]ß�ú�²§ý�±Tø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷ � {���z�y���é����U� ÿ�÷!��ß¿ú�²§®$÷�ûVß�ÿ�÷�þt²_Öa×"twÿ�ý�ý!��®$²tûß�ú�²§ûTß�ÿ�±Tß�ý�±¿ø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷ x6y�zR{�y�é���� ³�â¾ú�®�û�ýlÿ�®$± ®$û]®$÷�ß¿ú�²§û���÷�þ�ú�±TøR÷�®�ÿ#ß�®�øR÷¶±¿²�� ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷�ø��@ß�ú�²_þÿ�û¿²§ûVß�°!���� û¿°�þ�úüß�úlÿ#ßwß¿ú�²�ß�±¿ÿ�÷�û���ø�±�(ÿ#ß�®�øR÷ÎûTß¿²ý�û�þ ÿ#÷��@²�þø qý@øRû¿²��1³�â¾ú�²,jÿ#ß¿þ�ú�²û!±T²ûTß¿±¿®�þtß�²��üß¿ø�ß�ú�²�ý@øR±Tß¿ûþøR®�÷�þ®���²!®$÷�ÿ���1ß¿±�ÿ�÷�û���øR±�jÿ#ß¿®$øR÷�ûVß�²tý�û³¾â¾ú�²�þø�(ý@øRû¿®�ß�®�øR÷�ø�� ß¿ú�²�û¿²�¨�°�²t÷�þ²tûa®$û§®�û¿ø qøR±¿ý�ú�®$þaß¿øqß¿ú�²¯ �$ø ��ÿ��T��®�ûTß¿±¿®��°�ß�²���ûT²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®�þû§®$÷�ß�ú�².­�®$¯R°�±T²Mt�³�t�c�³ á

x7t

Page 50: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

â ã äæå ç�èêé ë

ì°í©î=ï�ð�ñEòÝð�óÝô õyóêö ÷ øÝî[ï�ù°ð�óÛô ú û#õ2í�øÔüiý"ó�þMî[û�íÿû-înþMî=ö� î�� í��5û�õ�����5û� ����õ� ð�ó � ð� :þ-ûDð����vþMî[ö ìXò� :þMî��

â¾ú�®$ûYþ�ú�ÿ�ý�ß�²t±¾®$ûYþtøR÷�þt²±¿÷�²��Sù§®�ß�ú(ß�ú�²w¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�®�þ ÿ��@û¿ý@²þt®�§lþÿ#ß�®�øR÷�ø��fý�±TøRý@²±Tß¿®$²tûYø���ÿ���®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²���û���û�sß�²� ÿ�÷��[ß�ú�²%ý@øRû¿ûT®��®��$®�ß¿®$²tûB��øR±§ß�ú�²t®$±§þ�ú�²þ%��®�÷�¯�³_â¾ú�²%ý�±TøRý@²±Tß¿®$²tû2þtøR÷�û¿®���²±T²��Q®�÷�ß¿ú�®$û§ù�ø�±��S®$÷�þ��$°!��²û�ÿ$��²�ß{�Qÿ�ûMùÙ²�����ÿ�û:�$®���²÷�²tû¿ûwý�±TøRý@²±Tß¿®$²tû³-��ÿ$��²�ß{� ý�±TøRý@²±Tß¿®$²tûa²÷�ûT°�±¿²0ß¿úlÿ#ßw÷�ø�ß�ú�®�÷�¯8�lÿ$�Qúlÿ�ý�ý@²÷�ûw®�÷ß�ú�²,��®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²��¡û���ûVß�²��³�â¾ú�®�ûM(²ÿ�÷�û"��øR±!øR°�±!þ ÿ#û¿²� :ß�úlÿ�ß�ß¿ú�²���®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²��ü¯R±�ÿ#ý�ú�û!±¿²tý�±¿²tû¿²÷Kß¿®$÷�¯ß�ú�²_ûTß�ÿ#ß�²tû�ø��1ß¿ú�²Mû���ûTß�²� ú�ÿN��²aÿ���ùYÿ���ûYÿ�þ²t±Tß�ÿ#®$÷qûTß�±T°�þtß¿°�±¿²#³��f®��R²t÷�²ûTûYý�±¿ø�ýÀ²t±Tß�®�²û)²÷�ûT°�±¿²_ß�úlÿ�ßÙß¿ú�²û���ûTß¿²�á�À²túlÿ��R²tû2ùÙ²���˳�â¾ú�®$ûFq² ÿ�÷�û§®�÷[øR°�±_þÿ�û¿²$ lß�úlÿ#ß2ÿ�þ²t±Tß�ÿ�®$÷���®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²���¯R±�ÿ#ý�úS®$û§²���²÷Kß�°lÿ$����þøR÷�ûVß�±T°�þtß¿²��1³,��ÿ(��²tß{�¡ÿ�÷��w��®���²÷�²tû¿ûwý�±TøRýÀ²t±Tß¿®$²û!ÿ#±¿²�²�¥�ý�±T²ûTû¿²����@� *Ìã�çMälå�ÈTæ�¸�è å�È�çD��¸�æ(� ³%â:²�qý@øR±�ÿ���$øR¯R®�þÙ®�û�ÿ2ùÙ²�����²tûTß�ÿ$�!�$®�û¿ú�²���þøR÷�þt²ý�ß]ß¿øaû¿ý@²þt®��1��ß�ú�ø�û¿²¾ý�±TøRýÀ²t±Tß¿®$²û ÿ�÷!�0ß¿øw±¿² ÿ#û¿øR÷¶ÿ��@øR°�ß�ß�ú�²B����÷lÿ�Ds®$þ ÿ$�<�@²úlÿ���®$ø�±Mø���û���ûVß�²�(ût³�â¾ú�²±¿²�²6¥�®$ûTß¿û!ÿ��#ÿ�ûTßwÿ�(ø�°�÷Kßaø��]ùÙøR±���®$÷[ß�ú�²�ÿ#±¿² ÿ�ø$�]ß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ�����øR¯R®$þß�úlÿ#ß2þ ÿ#÷9�@².°�ûT²��9��ø�±_þ�ú�²þ%��®$÷�¯���øR±�0°�� ÿ�ût³�â:ø+(ÿ���²�°�û¿².ø�� ß¿ú�²ûT²%±T²û¿°���ß�ûp�Yþø����®$÷�²K��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú¶ß¿±�ÿ�÷�û���øR±�jÿ#ß¿®$øR÷.ù§®�ß�ú¶ý�±TøRý@øRû¿®�ß�®$ø�÷lÿ���ß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ����$øR¯�®$þ�³:â¾ú�®�û]þø ���®$÷lÿ#ß¿®$øR÷�²t÷lÿ��!��²û�ß¿ø�¯�±�ÿ�ý�ú�s®$þ ÿ$����jû¿ý@²þt®��1��ß�ú�²�ß¿²�qýÀøR±¿ÿ��;��øR±�0°!� ÿ#ûF��ø�±§ß¿ú�²K��®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²�� ¯�±�ÿ�ý�ú�qø���²��o³Ùâ¾ú�²#(ÿ�®$÷S®���² ÿqø�� ß¿ú�²þø ���®$÷lÿ#ß¿®$øR÷q®$û�ß�ø-jÿ$��²M°�û¿²aø���ß�ú�²2±¿²ûT°!��ß¿ûi��øR±Ùþ�ú�²þ%��®�÷�¯0ß�²�(ý@øR±�ÿ$����ø�±�0°!�$ÿ�û)ÿ�÷!��÷�ø�ßÙß¿ø���²��R²���øRý÷�²tù ß¿²þ�ú�÷�®¨�°�²û_²ûTýÀ²tþ®$ÿ������þ°�ûTß�ø�(®��²��Sß�ø,��®�ûTß�±T®��°�ß�²��S¯R±¿ÿ�ý�úSß�±¿ÿ�÷�û���ø�±�(ÿ#ß�®�øR÷1³�â¾ú�²�þø�÷�þ²tý�ßp��ø�±þ�ú�²þ%��®$÷�¯+��øR±�%°!� ÿ�û�øR÷[ù§ú�®�þ�ún�Ùù§®���®$÷Sýlÿ�±Vß�®$þt°!� ÿ#±³��ø�þt°�û§®$÷Sß�ú�®�û§ùÙøR±���®$ûF(ø���²��1þ�ú�²þ%��®�÷�¯�³Yâ:ø�ø��$û� û¿ø�þ ÿ$��$²��8qø���²��Àþ�ú�²þ%��²t±¿û� �ÿ�±T²aý�±TøY��®���²���ß¿ø�²�¥�ÿ�q®$÷�²a®��fÿ0þ²t±Tß�ÿ�®$÷�ß¿²�qýÀøR±¿ÿ�����øR±�0°�� ÿ.®�ûi�#ÿ���®��®�÷�ÿ¯R®���²÷%ß¿²�qýÀøR±¿ÿ��@qø���²��o³<\[øRûVß�ø���ß�ú�²i(ø���²���þ�ú�²tþ%��²t±]±¿²�¨�°�®�±¿²�ÿ|§l÷�®�ß�²)ß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ��@qø���²��˳:â¾ú�²±¿²���øR±¿²$ �)ý�±¿øN��®��²Mÿ%þøR÷�ûTß�±T°�þtß¿®$øR÷�ß¿ø0þø��� ÿ#ý�û¿²Mÿ%ýÀø�û¿û¿®��!���q®�÷�§l÷�®�ß�²§ß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ��Eqø���²��@ß¿ø�ÿ-§l÷�®�ß�²2øR÷�²$ �þ ÿ����$²��*L&�äE���¿æ�¸ çjå���ã�¸ ³M­Dø�±�0°!�$ÿ�û� Dß�ú�ÿ#ß!ÿ�±T².ß�±T°�²0®�÷ ß�ú�².ß{��ý�®$þ ÿ$�^qø���²�� ÿ#±¿²%ß¿±¿°�²0®�÷ ß�ú�²0øR±¿®�¯R®$÷�ÿ��8®$÷�§�÷�®�ß¿²(ø���²���ÿ�û_ù�²���o³ � ú�²÷¡ÿ���ø�±�0°!�$ÿ(®�ûp�>ÿ���û¿²%®�÷ ß�ú�²%ß{��ý�®$þÿ��<qø���²��L Àú�ø�ùÙ²���²±� 8ß¿ú�²-��øR±�0°!�$ÿ�(ÿN���@²ß�±¿°�²0®$÷�ß�ú�²0ø�±¿®$¯�®$÷lÿ��qqø���²��˳p�u÷Îß¿ú�®$û2þ ÿ�ûT²� �ß¿ú�²0þ�ú�²tþ%��®�÷�¯�ø��]ß¿ú�²#��øR±�0°!� ÿqúlÿ�û_ß�ø8�@²���øR÷�²��@�[ß¿ú�²��²ûT®$¯R÷�²t±³k�ú�²þ%��®$÷�¯0ø��1ý�±¿øRý@²±Vß�®$²tûÙ®�÷jÿM��®�ûTß�±T®��°�ß�²��qû���ûVß�²� ®$û�®�÷(ýlÿ#±Tß�®�þ°!�$ÿ�±�ÿ.ý�±¿ø �!��²� ûT®$÷�þt²M÷�ø�¯ ��ø �lÿ��lû���û�sß�²� ûVß�ÿ#ß¿²%þ ÿ#÷9�@²0ÿ�ûTû¿°!q²��ή�÷�ß¿úlÿ#ß_ß�ú�².ý�±¿ø�ýÀ²t±Tß{��þ ÿ�÷9�À²�þ�ú�²þ%�#²��1³��2ø�ù�²��R²t±� 8¯ ��ø �lÿ��8ý�±TøRý@²±Tß¿®$²tûjÿ��D�@²2ø$�1®$÷Kß¿²±¿²tûTß)ß�ø.²÷�ûT°�±¿²_ß�ú�²|��²ûT®$±T²��+�@²ú�ÿN��®�øR±�ø��1ß�ú�²p��®�ûTß¿±¿®��°�ß�²��(û���ûVß�²�[³J� ù§®����ûTú�ø�ùM �ú�ø�ùß�ú�²�ß{��ý�®$þÿ��Jqø���²���þ ÿ#÷��@²¶°�û¿²��Çß�øS±T² ÿ�ûTøR÷w��±Tø ´��ø�þÿ�� û¿ÿ#ß�®�û��>ÿ�þ�ß�®$ø�÷Qø��³��ø�þÿ��<��øR±�0°!�$ÿ�ûMß�ø�¯ ��ø �lÿ��û�ÿ#ß¿®$û��>ÿ#þtß�®�øR÷ ø$��¯ �$ø ��ÿ��e��ø�±�0°!�$ÿ�û³��8ø�þÿ��e��ø�±�0°!�$ÿ�û2ÿ�±¿²%ß¿²�qýÀø�±�ÿ��q��øR±�0°!� ÿ#û� Dß�úlÿ#ßaþ ÿ�÷[�@²%þ�ú�²tþ%��²���$ø�þ ÿ���������øR±¾øR÷�²!ý�±Tø�þt²ûTû³â¾ú�²S±¿²�(ÿ�®�÷!��²±�ø$�2ß¿ú�®$û�þ�úlÿ#ý�ß�²t±(®�û�øR±¿¯Kÿ#÷�®�t²��Oÿ�û���ø ���$ø�ù§ûµ�â¾ú�²[þÿ�û¿²SûTß¿°!��� ø��_ß�ú�²���®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��þøR÷�§�¯R°�±�ÿ�ß�®$ø�÷2jÿ#÷lÿ�¯R²�(²t÷�ß0ÿ�û0®�÷�ß¿±¿ø���°�þt²��J®$÷Çß�ú�²�ý�±T²���®$ø�°�û0þ�úlÿ�ý�ß�²±0ù§®���0�@²�°�û¿²�� ß¿ú�±¿ø�°�¯Rú�øR°�ßß�ú�²�þ�úlÿ�ý�ß¿²±qß�øm®����°�ûTß¿±�ÿ#ß¿²�ß�ú�²�þøR÷�þ²ý�ß�û³�â¾ú�²t±¿²���øR±¿²$ C��ûTß�ÿ#±Tßqù§®�ß�ú ß�ú�² þ ÿ#û¿²�ûTß�°����¼ÿ#÷!� ®�÷�ß¿±¿ø$s��°�þ²�ß¿ú�²�ý�±¿ø�ýÀ²t±Tß�®�²ûaß¿úlÿ#ß"�2ÿ� ¯�øR®$÷�¯�ß¿ø�þ�ú�²þ%�D³�ªp�*ß¿²±VùYÿ�±���û� 8ß¿ú�²�þøR÷�þ²ý�ß�ûM��øR±aû¿ý@²þt®��1��®$÷�¯Sÿ�÷!�þ�ú�²þ%��®$÷�¯Sß¿ú�²ûT²�ý�±¿ø�ýÀ²t±Tß�®�²ûwÿ#±¿²0®�÷�ß¿±¿ø���°�þt²��1³wâ¾ú�²�¯�±�ÿ�ý�ú�®$þ ÿ$��ûTýÀ²tþ®�§�þ ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷Qø��]ß¿²�qýÀø�±�ÿ�����øR±�%°!� ÿ�û±¿²�¨�°�®�±¿²tû/��÷�ø�ùF�$²���¯R²0®$÷[ý�±¿ø�ýÀøRûT®�ß¿®$øR÷lÿ$�1ß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ�����øR¯R®$þ$ Dû¿°�þ�úÎß¿úlÿ#ß/�¾®�÷Kß�±¿ø���°�þt²%®�ß:�@²���øR±T²�³pªp�*ß�²t±:�úlÿ��R²�²6¥�ý�� ÿ�®�÷�²��½ú�ø6ù ß¿²�qýÀø�±�ÿ���ý�±TøRýÀ²t±Tß¿®$²û.þ ÿ�÷g�À²(¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�®$þÿ�����Qû¿ý@²þt®�§l²��y�7�ü¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�s ®$÷Kß�²t±¿ý�±T²tß¿²��ß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ��<��øR±�0°�� ÿ�û� ;�Mý�±TøN��®���²�ß�ú�²¶þtøR÷�ûTß¿±¿°�þ�ß�®�øR÷Çø$�Ùß¿ú�²qß{��ý�®�þ ÿ��^(ø���²��˳D�MþtøR÷�þ���°!��²��@�Q°�ûT®$÷�¯[ÿ(ø���²���þ�ú�²þ%�#²±p��ø�±¾þ�ú�²þ%��®$÷�¯�ÿ�¯ �$ø��lÿ���ß¿²�qýÀøR±¿ÿ��U��ø�±�0°!�$ÿ0ø���øR°�±§þ ÿ�ûT²!ûTß�°����R³

x �

Page 51: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

¹q�>Ó 3 ð�¡��Ý .�L�G¯-¢65��J¡7¢Y�N��¡���5�ÎF��ðe¡ �  .��¡ í �NÌ<Í ïHw÷�²üø$�.ß¿ú�²�qøRûVßS®qýÀøR±Vß�ÿ�÷Kß�±T°!�$²tû�®$÷X��®�ûTß�±T®��°�ß�²�� þø�÷�§l¯R°�±¿ÿ#ß�®�øR÷Xjÿ#÷lÿ�¯R²�(²t÷�ßSû¿ÿ���ûSß�ú�ÿ#ß�÷�ø®$÷���øR±�jÿ�ß�®$ø�÷a¯R²tß¿û�²��R²t±<��øRûTß³�â¾ú�®�û�®�ûq�lÿ�ûT²��0øR÷�ý�±¿ÿ�þtß¿®$þ ÿ$�K±¿²�¨�°�®�±¿²�(²t÷�ß¿û:ù§ú�²±¿²)þ°�ûTß�ø�(²t±¿ûejÿ��w÷�²t²��ø ��O�R²t±¿ûT®$øR÷�û2ø���ý�±¿øR¯R±¿ÿ�qûYß�úlÿ#ߧ߿ú�²��z�@øR°�¯RúKß|�R²ÿ�±¿û2ÿ�¯RøqøR±¾ß�ø,��²tß¿²þ�ßa²±T±¿øR±Tû§®$÷Sß�ú�²K��²���²���øRý!q²÷Kßý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û³ â:ø½²t÷�û¿°�±T²Îß�ú�²ÎÿN�#ÿ�®�� ÿ���®�$®�ß{�mø$�M��ø�þt°!q²÷Kß�û� §ß¿ú�²��¼ÿ�±¿²[÷�ø�ß�ÿ����ø6ùÙ²��òß�ø2�@²9��²��$²�ß�²��ô®�÷±¿²���®�û¿®$ø�÷(ÿ#±¿þ�ú�®��R²ût³Z\[øR±T²øN�R²t±� �ß�ø�ý�±¿øN��®��²_ÿwþø�÷�û¿®�ûTß�²t÷KßYÿ�÷��(þt°�±¿±T²÷Kß�ûT²tß)ø��Àý�±¿ø6ÆT²þtßi��ø�þ°!q²÷Kß¿û0��ø�±² ÿ�þ�ú�ý�±¿ø�ÆT²tþtßYý�ÿ�±Tß¿÷�²±� ���ø�þ°!q²÷Kß¿û�úlÿ��R²2ß�ø#�@²_±¿²ý��$®$þÿ#ß�²��(ß¿ø.ß�ú�²M±¿²���®$û¿®�øR÷(ÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²tûYø��1ß¿ú�²Mý�±Tø�ÆT²þ�ßýlÿ�±Tß¿÷�²±Tû_ÿ�ûYù�²���˳]â¾ú�²±T²���øR±T²� l² ÿ#þ�ú[ý�±Tø�ÆT²þ�ß_ýlÿ�±Tß¿÷�²±F0°�ûTߧ²���²÷Kß�°�ÿ������û¿²t÷�ß_®�ß�ûC��ø�þ°!q²÷Kß¿û_øN��²±_ÿýÀøR±Vß¾ß�øqÿ�±¿²�(ø�ß¿²!ý�±¿ø�ÆT²tþtß_ýlÿ�±Vß�÷�²t±¾ß�úlÿ#ߧ±T²þt²®���²û§ß�ú�²M��ø�þ°�(²t÷�ß¿û³â¾ú�²¶ý�±¿øRý@²±Vß�®�²ûaß�ú�ÿ#ß"�aÿ$ ¯RøR®�÷�¯jß¿ø�ý�±¿øN�R²D��øR±Mß¿ú�²���®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²��Q¯R±¿ÿ�ý�úPqø���²�� ø��³k�úlÿ�ý�ß�²±-t�ÿ�±T²ß�ú�²t±¿²���ø�±¿²�µ

�Ý .���5�<¢65��J¡7¢N�Y��¡�� îÍR³§Á�ÿ�þ�ú���ø�þ°�(²t÷�ß�®$û ý�±¿²ûT²±��R²��(®$÷�ß�ú�²C��®�ûTß¿±¿®��°�ß�²��0û���û�sß¿²��³

t�³§Á�ÿ�þ�úP��ø�þ°�(²t÷�ßa®$÷Qÿj±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷Îÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²0®�ûa±¿²tý!�$®�þ ÿ#ß¿²��ß¿øjÿ�±T²�qø�ß�²w±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷�ÿ�±Tþ�ú�®���²

©0��² ÿ�ûT²a÷�ø�ß¿®$þt²� �ß¿úlÿ#ßYß¿ú�²ûT²!ý�±¿øRý@²±Vß�®�²û¾ÿ�±T²a¯ ��ø �lÿ��L �ûT®$÷�þt²Mß�ú�²���±T²���²t±Yß�ø0ß�ú�²Mù§ú�ø ��²/��®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²���û���û�sß�²� ±¿²ûTýÀ²tþtß¿®��R²�����ß¿øqûT²���²±�ÿ$�e��ø�þÿ���þtø qýÀøR÷�²÷Kß�ût³�u÷Îß�ú�²0ûT²�¨�°�²��a�§û¿ú�ø�ù ú�ø�ù ß¿ú�²�(ÿ�®$÷[ý�±¿ø�ýÀ²t±Tß�®�²ûMÿ�±¿²0²6¥�ý�±¿²tû¿û¿²����@� ¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�su®�÷�ß¿²±Tý�±¿²�ß�²��[ß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ����øR±�0°�� ÿ�û�ÿ�÷��qù§úlÿ�ßÙú�ÿ�û)ß¿ø-�@²F��øR÷�²§ß�ø�þ�ú�²tþ%�¶ß¿ú�²��³aª�¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�s ®$÷Kß�²t±¿ý�±T²tß�²�����øR±�0°!�$ÿa®$û)ÿaß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ����øR±�0°�� ÿ� 8ù§ú�²t±¿²jß¿ú�²jý�±TøRý@øRû¿®�ß�®$ø�÷lÿ��a�#ÿ�±¿®$ÿ��!��²û�ÿ�±¿²(®$÷Kß�²t±¿ý�±T²tß¿²��2�@����®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²��m¯�±�ÿ�ý�ú�û%²�¨�°�®�ý�ý@²���7���#ÿ�±¿®$ÿ��!��².ÿ#û¿û¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß�ût³aâ¾ú�²���ÿ�û¿®�þ%®��² ÿjø���þ�ú�²þ%��®$÷�¯[ÿ « ¯ ��ø �lÿ�� ­i��øR±�0°�� ÿ(þÿ�÷=�@²0û¿°��(ÿ�±¿®��²��ÿ�ûC��ø ���ø6ù§ûtµÍR³|m_²���°�þt®$÷�¯�ß�ú�²�¯��$ø �lÿ$��ý�±TøRýÀ²t±Tß{��ß¿ø,��ø�þÿ���ý�±¿øRý@²±Vß�®$²tû³t�³|m_²���°�þt®$÷�¯Îß¿ú�²O��®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²��Jû���ûVß�²� ß�ø¡û¿°���suû���ûVß�²�(û¶®$÷Çù§ú�®$þ�úJß�ú�²O�$ø�þ ÿ��Z��øR±�0°�� ÿ�û.þ ÿ�÷y�@²þ�ú�²þ%�#²�����ø�þÿ�����R³üâ¾ú�²Sû�ÿ#ß¿®$û��>ÿ�þtß¿®$øR÷Jø��2ÿ[�$ø�þ ÿ$�i��øR±�0°!� ÿ[®$÷Jß�ú�²�ûT°!��s û���ûTß¿²� úlÿ�û�ß�øQ®�(ý����û�ÿ#ß¿®$û��>ÿ�þtß¿®$øR÷�ø��:ß�ú�²K��ø�þÿ��U��ø�±�0°!�$ÿ0®$÷�ß�ú�²K��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��Sû���ûTß¿²��³

� ³pk�ú�²þ%��®�÷�¯qß¿ú�²M�$ø�þ ÿ��U��øR±�0°�� ÿ�ûY®�÷�ß�ú�²!þø�±¿±¿²tû¿ý@øR÷!��®�÷�¯¶û¿°!��suû���ûVß�²�qû³x�³|m_²ÿ�û¿ø�÷���±Tø ��ø�þÿ���û¿ÿ#ß�®�û��>ÿ�þ�ß�®$ø�÷Sß¿ø¶¯ �$ø ��ÿ���û¿ÿ#ß�®�û��>ÿ�þ�ß�®$ø�÷1³

� ú�²÷�²��R²t±_ß¿ú�²w°�÷!��²t±�����®�÷�¯�qø���²���ø$�:ß¿ú�²"��®�ûTß�±T®��°�ß�²���û���ûTß�²� ®$ûi§l÷�®�ß¿²� �®Ë³ ²#³�ß¿ú�²w÷�°!��@²±¾ø��:ûTß�ÿ#ß�²tû®$÷�ß�ú�²K��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²���û���ûTß¿²� ®�û³§l÷�®�ß¿²� �²ÿ�þ�ú�¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�su®�÷�ß¿²±Tý�±¿²�ß�²��O��øR±�0°!�$ÿ%þ ÿ�÷z�@²wþ�ú�²þ%�#²��=�@�Oq² ÿ#÷�ûø��)ÿ8(ø���²�� þ�ú�²tþ%��²± « û¿²²¶²#³ ¯�³À®$÷�_ ÁJ(²�c · d ­�³M�§ý�±¿²tû¿²t÷�ßM�$ÿ#ß�²t±aøR÷Qÿ8qø���²���þ�ú�²þ%�#²±� fþÿ����²��¡«��2�NV, ®$÷Kß�±Tø���°�þ²��m®$÷¦_�\ ÿ�÷!c�x d ]ÿ�û�ÿ�þøR÷�þt±¿²�ß�²Oqø���²���s þ�ú�²þ%�#²±0°�ûT²��2��øR±�þ�ú�²tþ%��®�÷�¯üÿ[¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�s ®$÷Kß�²t±¿ý�±T²tß¿²��ß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ��E��øR±�%°!� ÿ0ø��:ß�ú�²�þÿ�û¿²�ûTß¿°!����³�±�]ß�ú�².°�÷!��²t±�����®�÷�¯+qø���²��f®$û2®$÷�§l÷�®�ß�²$ �(øRûVßMø$�]ß�ú�².þ�ú�²þ%��®$÷�¯�ß�²þ�ú�÷�®¨�°�²tû!ÿ�±¿².÷�ø�ßMÿ�ý�ý!��®$þ ÿ$�!�$²�ÿ�÷@�@s(øR±T²�³Ým§²ûT² ÿ�±Tþ�ú�®$÷òß¿ú�®$û�ÿ�±¿²ÿÇùYÿ#û�ÿ�÷!�ô®�û+��øR÷�² ß�ø½±T²���°�þ²Îß�ú�²Îþø qý!��²�¥�®�ß{�Oø��wß¿ú�²=qø���²��2ø�±

x x

Page 52: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

ß�øQ±¿²tûTß¿±¿®$þ�߶®$÷�§�÷�®�ß¿²8(ø���²��$û.ß¿ø[§l÷�®�ß¿²�øR÷�²tûn_�r�±¿ÿ c@t� lrC��c · �r³kC\ Ê"c · d ³���ý�±TøY��®���²�®$÷½ß¿ú�®$û%ùÙøR±��JÿþøR÷�ûVß�±T°�þtß¿®$øR÷g��ø�±.þtø ��$ÿ�ý�û¿®�÷�¯�ÿ�÷½®�÷�§l÷�®�ß�²�(ø���²���ß¿øQÿ�§�÷�®�ß¿²(øR÷�²(ù§®�ß¿úm±T²û¿ý@²þ�ß0ß�øÎÿ[¯R®��R²÷mû¿²tß%ø��ß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ��i��øR±�0°�� ÿ�ût³Oâ¾ú�®$û�§l÷�®�ß¿²z(ø���²���®$û�ß{��ý�®$þÿ��³��øR±�ß�ú�²�û¿²�ßjø$�:��øR±�0°!� ÿ#û0®$÷ ß�ú�²�û¿²t÷�û¿²�ß�úlÿ�ßù§ú�²÷�²��R²t±¾ÿK��øR±�0°!�$ÿ!®�û�û�ÿ#ß¿®$û�§�²���®�÷qß¿ú�²_ß{��ý�®�þ ÿ���qø���²���ß�ú�²÷�®�ßÙ®�û�û�ÿ#ß¿®$û�§�²��j®�÷(ß¿ú�²2®�÷�§l÷�®�ß�²§øR±T®$¯R®�÷lÿ��(ø���²��˳J�±� ß¿ú�²"��øR±�0°�� ÿ0®$û§÷�ø#ߧû�ÿ#ß¿®$û�§�²�� ®�÷�ß�ú�²wß{��ý�®$þÿ��qqø���²��� �ß¿ú�²"��øR±�%°!� ÿ0þtøR°!����@²�û¿ÿ#ß�®�û�§l²��[®�÷ß�ú�²Y®�÷�§l÷�®�ß�²³qø���²��˳e�u÷�ß¿ú�®$û:ùYÿ�� Kß¿ú�²Yß{��ý�®$þÿ���qø���²���û¿°�ý�ý@øR±Vß�û�ß�ú�²¾þ�ú�²þ%��®$÷�¯�ø$�@ß¿²�qýÀø�±�ÿ��7��øR±�%°!� ÿ�û®$÷Jÿ�÷m®$÷�§l÷�®�ß�²�(ø���²��� ^��°�ßD��ø�²û0÷�ø�ß0ý�±TøN��®���²�ÿ�÷J²6¥�úlÿ�°�ûVß�®���²�þ�ú�²þ%��®�÷�¯P(²�ß�ú�ø��1³��_ø6ùÙ²���²±� )ß¿ú�²ß{��ý�®$þ ÿ$�a(ø���²�� þ ÿ#÷w�@²�°�ûT²��P��øR±aþ�ú�²tþ%��®�÷�¯9��ø�þÿ��fß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ��e��øR±�%°!� ÿ�û2®$÷Qß�ú�²�±¿²���°�þ²��ÇûT°!��suû���ûTß�²�ÿ�ûwù�²���)ÿ�û"��øR±wß�ú�²¶±T² ÿ�ûTøR÷�®$÷�¯���±Tø ´�$ø�þ ÿ$��û�ÿ#ß¿®$û��>ÿ�þtß¿®$øR÷Qß�øS¯ ��ø �lÿ�� û�ÿ#ß¿®$û��>ÿ#þtß�®�øR÷1³¶â¾ú�²,� ÿ#ßTß�²t±wýÀøR®�÷Kßù§®��q�@²%ß¿ú�²%²6¥�ÿ$(ý!��²K��ø�±M²�¥�ý!�$ÿ�®$÷�®$÷�¯¶ß�ú�²�ß{��ý�®$þÿ��<qø���²��L @ûT®$÷�þt²%®�ßMú�²��$ý�û_ß�ø�ûTø ����².ß¿ú�²%ý�±Tø �!��²� ø��ß�ú�²!÷�øR÷�su²�¥�®�ûTß�²t÷�þ²�ø�� ÿ�¯ �$ø ��ÿ���ûVß�ÿ#ß¿²�³¹q��� � ¢Y !��ð8õÅ�L�E�N¡7¢(�e¢Y¡@�N¡�Í 3 ¡��g�]5�¢( �Ò �85�¢$�PÌ:Ò� !�� ®$÷Kß¿±¿ø���°�þ²_÷�ø�ù¼¯�±�ÿ�ý�ú�su®$÷Kß¿²±¿ý�±¿²tß¿²��qß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ�����øR±�0°�� ÿ�û� Rß�úlÿ#ßÙÿ�±T²_ÿKq®�¥�ß�°�±¿²§ø��@ß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ��!��ø�±�0°�s� ÿ�û)®$÷ ¸j�1'�ã¿æ�È6f{*��*çjãÙä@È�å�älåN���1*��oå('@æ�¸�*Ìã�çMälå�ÈTæ�¸�¸$å�~���� ÿ�÷!�8��®�ûTß¿±¿®��°�ß�²���¯R±�ÿ#ý�ú�ûY²�¨�°�®$ý�ý@²��O�@�jÿ-�#ÿ�±¿®$ÿ��!�$²ÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷!q²÷Kß³��u÷��$®�÷�² ÿ�±�s ß¿®q²0ý�±¿ø�ýÀøRûT®�ß¿®$øR÷lÿ$��ß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ��J��øR¯R®�þ¶ß¿ú�²j÷�øR÷Kß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ��]ý�ÿ�±Tß%ø��Yß�ú�²���øR¯R®$þ®$û2ÆT°�ûV߶þ�� ÿ#û¿û¿®�þ ÿ���ý�±¿øRý@øRûT®�ß�®�øR÷lÿ��Z�$ø�¯R®$þ(øY��²±qÿQû¿²�ß(ø$�Mý�±TøRý@øRû¿®�ß�®$ø�÷lÿ��0��ÿ#±¿® ÿ$�!�$²tû�ÿ�÷!�Jß�ú�²�þtøR°�±Tû¿²Sø��ß�®q²�®$û:��®$÷�²ÿ�±_®$÷ ß¿ú�²0û¿²t÷�û¿²�ß¿úlÿ#ß:��ø�±M² ÿ#þ�úwqø q²÷KßMß¿ú�²±T²0®$û2øR÷!���[ø�÷�²0ý@øRû¿ûT®�!��²-��°�ß¿°�±¿²�qø q²÷Kß ³b)ÿ�±¿®�øR°�ûYø�ß¿ú�²±F��®$÷���û¾ø��:ß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ��T�$øR¯R®�þû�ÿ�±¿²!®$÷Kß¿±¿ø���°�þ²��S®$÷�ß�ú�²"��®�ß¿²±�ÿ�ß�°�±T²�³aª¬û¿°�±��R²��S®$û¾¯R®��R²t÷�®�÷_ÄÁJq²�c · ���ß¿® c@t d ³! È¿æ�ä.��f{�1'.*uã�È ä@È�ã�*Ìã���*uã�çMälå�ÈTæ�¸�è å�È'çD��¸�æ(� ÿ�±T²wý�±¿ø�ýÀøRûT®�ß¿®$øR÷lÿ$�@ß¿²�qýÀøR±¿ÿ��T��øR±�0°!�$ÿ�û� �ù§ú�²±T²!ß¿ú�²wý�±TøRýÀø(sû¿®�ß¿®$øR÷�ÿ����#ÿ�±T® ÿ����$²û ø��Dß�ú�²³��øR±�0°!�$ÿaÿ�±¿²¾ûT°!��ûVß�®�ß¿°�ß�²����7����®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²���¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�û�²�¨�°�®�ý�ý@²����@�¶ÿ:�#ÿ�±¿®$ÿ��!�$²ÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷!q²÷Kß� �ß�ú�ÿ#ß%®�û� �ÿn��®�ûTß¿±¿®��°�ß�²��gqøR±¿ý�ú�®$û�àù§®�ß�úÇû¿øR°�±¿þ²(¯R±�ÿ#ý�ú Ð"J³�â¾ú�²+��®�ûTß�±T®��°�ß�²��ǯR±�ÿ#ý�úÐ" ±T²ý�±T²ûT²÷Kß�û_ß�ú�² ~�ÈTæ�ä.�����¿æ�¸TÄ�æ�È6�>æKɸ$ã%� ø���ß¿ú�²w¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�s ®$÷Kß�²t±¿ý�±T²tß�²���ß¿²�qýÀø�±�ÿ��E��øR±�0°�� ÿ�ÿ�÷!��ß¿ú�²M��®$û�sß�±¿®���°�ß¿²���(øR±Tý�ú�®�û�æ��±Tø ß¿ú�².¯�±�ÿ�ý�úÜÐ" ®$÷[ÿ,��®�ûTß¿±¿®��°�ß�²���¯�±�ÿ�ý�ú�®$û§þÿ����²�� æ(�%����~�'lçjã�'.*@è å�È Ð"J³Z�u÷ß�ú�²Z��ø ���ø6ù§®�÷�¯YùÙ²�²�¥�ý!�$ÿ�®$÷�ß�ú�²Zq² ÿ�÷�®�÷�¯_ø��l¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�s ®$÷Kß�²t±¿ý�±T²tß�²��.ß¿²�qýÀøR±¿ÿ��@��øR±�%°!� ÿ�û8®�÷���øR±�jÿ�������³8â¾ú�²��øR±�(ÿ�����²�§l÷�®�ß�®�øR÷�ø��Dß�ú�²¾ß¿²�qýÀøR±¿ÿ�����øR¯R®�þ�°�ûT²��q®$÷�ß�ú�®�û]ýlÿ�±Vß�ÿ�÷!�¶ß�ú�²¾¯�±�ÿ�ý�ú�su®$÷Kß¿²±¿ý�±¿²tß�ÿ#ß�®�øR÷�®$û ¯R®���²÷®$÷g��²þ�ß�®$ø�÷y¬�³�ÍR³�â¾ú�®�û%®�÷���øR±�(ÿ���ý�ÿ�±Tß�û¿ú�ÿ���0�@²(°�ûT²��mß¿ø ²t÷lÿ��!��²jÿ�û¿ø��*ßuù�ÿ�±¿²���²���²���øRýÀ²t±�ß¿ø ûTýÀ²tþ®��1�¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�®$þÿ������ß¿ú�²qý�±¿øRý@²±Vß�®�²ûwø���ú�²±��#ú�®$ûM��®�ûTß¿±¿®��°�ß�²��üû���ûTß�²�¤�7�ίR±�ÿ�ý�ú�su®�÷�ß¿²±Tý�±¿²�ß�²��P��øR±�0°!� ÿ#û³D�u÷ýlÿ�±Tß¿®$þt°!� ÿ�±� ���ÿ�÷�ûTùÙ²±§ß�ú�²M��ø���$ø�ù§®�÷�¯.ßuùÙø+¨�°�²tûTß�®�øR÷�ûtµÍR³#�2ø�ù þÿ�÷��)ù§±T®�ß�²�ÿ�¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�s ®$÷Kß�²t±¿ý�±T²tß�²���ß¿²�qýÀø�±�ÿ��E��øR±�0°�� ÿ%$t�³ � úlÿ#ßF��ø�²û_ÿ¶¯R±�ÿ#ý�ú�su®�÷Kß�²±Tý�±¿²�ß�²��Sß¿²�qýÀø�±�ÿ��T��ø�±�0°!�$ÿ�(²ÿ�÷; �®Ë³ ²#³�ù§ú�²÷[®$û¾®�ß¾û�ÿ#ß¿®$û�§l²��&$

¹q���;�>Ó ' 5�( � 5 í �J¡�£@�µÎ ï)� ¢Y !��ð8õÅ���U�N¡7¢Y�<¢Y¡@�N¡�Í 3 ¡��g�]5�¢Y lÒ*�85�¢(�wÌ:Òµ .�â¾ú�®$û(û¿²þ�ß�®�øR÷5��²ÿ��$ûqù§®�ß¿úòß�ú�² û���÷Kß�ÿY¥¼ø��a¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�su®�÷�ß¿²±Tý�±¿²�ß�²��G��øR±�0°�� ÿ�û�ß�ú�ÿ#ß�ÿ#±¿²9��°�®���ò°�ýG��±¿ø ß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ��<��øR±�0°�� ÿ�ûw®�÷üý�±¿øRý@øRû¿®�ß�®�øR÷lÿ��:ß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ��^�$øR¯R®�þ�ÿ�÷!�Çÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷Kß�û"��øR±�ÿ�¯�®��R²t÷���®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú Ð" ø$�l¯R±�ÿ#ý�ú�®$þÿ�� �#ÿ�±¿®$ÿ��!��²û³e�T§l±TûTß þøR÷�ûT®��²t±�ÿ�ûTû¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß�û�ÿ�÷!�0¯�®��R²�ß�ú�²÷�ÿ|��±¿®�²��l®�÷�ß¿±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷®$÷Kß�ø!ß�ú�²_û���÷Kß�ÿY¥�ø��Àß�²�(ý@øR±�ÿ$�!��øR±�0°�� ÿ�û)ÿ�÷!�(þøR÷�þ��$°���²_ù§®�ß�úqß�ú�²_þø #��®$÷lÿ�ß�®$ø�÷qø$�8ÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷Kß�ûÙÿ�÷!�ß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ��E��øR±�%°!� ÿ�û¾±T²ûT°!��ß¿®$÷�¯�®�÷�¯�±�ÿ�ý�ú�su®$÷Kß¿²±¿ý�±¿²tß¿²��Sß�²�(ý@øR±�ÿ$�U��øR±�0°!� ÿ#û³¹q���;�>Ó.�ËÓ h �����,+U�e�g¡��U�Y�ªM÷ æ(�%����~�'lçjã�'.*p« Êa²��̳a¬�³ � ³�ÍY­/��øR±0ÿ�¯R±�ÿ#ý�ú Ð" ®�û0ÿn��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��½¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú2qøR±¿ý�ú�®$û� ÿ�û%®�÷�ß¿±¿ø���°�þt²��®$÷Jß�ú�²Sý�±T²���®$ø�°�û¶þ�úlÿ�ý�ß¿²±�ù§®�ß¿úOûTøR°�±Tþ²�¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú Ð"½³ ��°�þ�ú¼ÿ[��®�ûTß¿±¿®��°�ß�²�� qøR±Tý�ú�®$û� þÿ�÷��À²Sû¿²t²÷

x7¬

Page 53: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

ÿ�ûaÿqýlÿ#ß¿ß¿²±T÷9��øR±aÿ¶ù§ú�ø ��²%þ��$ÿ�û¿û2ø��J��®�ûTß¿±¿®��°�ß�²��=(ø�±¿ý�ú�®�û�qû³¾â¾ú�®�ûMþ�� ÿ�ûTûMþø�÷�ß�ÿ�®$÷�ûaÿ����e��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��(øR±Tý�ú�®�û�qûMß�úlÿ�ß!úlÿ��R²�ß�ú�²¶û¿ÿ�(²�ûTøR°�±Tþ²¶¯R±�ÿ#ý�ú Ð" ÿ#÷!�Qß�ú�²�ß�ÿ#±¿¯R²�ß!¯R±�ÿ�ý�úüý�±¿øN��®��²tû!ÿ#ßM�$²ÿ�ûTßwß¿ú�²ûTß�±T°�þtß¿°�±¿²!ß�ú�ÿ#ߧ®$û¾¯R®��R²t÷[®�÷Sß¿ú�²wß�ÿ�±T¯R²tߧ¯�±�ÿ�ý�úSø��:ß�ú�².ÿ#û¿û¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß ³ÐMÑ  .�g��Òµ¡ ¹;�>ÓJÔ  .�����-+E�e�g¡��U��Õ�u÷�­ ®$¯R°�±¿² � ³�ÍÎÿ�÷ô²�¥�ÿ�qý!�$²[ø���ÿ�÷�ÿ�ûTû¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß ÐÊy��øR±�ÿ���®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²��¼¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú Ð" ®�ûjûTú�ø�ù§÷1³¬â¾ú�²

PortRARARA PortRARARA

PortRARARA

a a

fg

RA

^^

X

G

X^

^

^

^

^

H

AA^

­ ®$¯R°�±¿² � ³�ÍRµM} '½æ(�%����~�'lçjã�'.*C��qæ¶ä�æ�*�*uã�È�'(è å�È,�����*ËÈ6�>É���*Ìã��8~�ÈTæ�ä.�Îçjå�Èuä.�����ç#�~/.;�lã0çjå�Èuä.�����ç Ð0å('=*1�lã�¸$ã�è6*�f���æ�'E��������ãM��K�1'=*1�lãD��¸�æ(�%�210*1��æ�*§å('�ã�å('=*1�lã�È6��~(��*Lf���æ�'E�D������ãM��K'�å(* �

��®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²��½¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú Ð" þtøR÷Kß�ÿ�®�÷�û�ÿ ±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷½ÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²�ß¿øR¯R²tß¿ú�²±.ù§®�ß�úmøR÷�²8��ø�þ°�(²t÷�ß³Qâ¾ú�²�ß�ÿ#±¿¯R²�߯R±�ÿ�ý�úÒÐ× ø$� ÐÊ���²ûTþ±T®�@²û�ß¿ú�²Mýlÿ�ß¿ß�²t±¿÷+��ø�±)ß¿ú�²_ß�ÿ�±¿¯�²tßY¯�±�ÿ�ý�ú�ûÙø���ß�ú�²2þ�� ÿ#û¿û³J� ßÙ±¿²�¨�°�®$±T²û¾ÿ�þøR÷�÷�²þtß¿²��ýÀøR±Vß!ß�øR¯R²�ß�ú�²t±�ù§®�ß�úÇÿ���ø�þt°!(²t÷Kß ³OHa÷üß�ú�²,�$²��*ß�suú�ÿ�÷!�¡û¿®���²(ø$��ß�ú�²,§l¯�°�±¿²�ùÙ²júlÿ��R²jÿ���®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú[(øR±Tý�ú�®�û� Ð0 ß�ú�ÿ#ßwû�ÿ�ß�®$û�§l²û2ß�ú�²�ýlÿ�ß¿ß�²t±¿÷Qø��]ß¿ú�²�ÿ�ûTû¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß ³KHa÷Îß�ú�²�±¿®$¯�ú�ß�suúlÿ#÷!�Îû¿®���².ùÙ²úlÿ��R²0ÿ,��®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²���¯R±�ÿ#ý�ú9qøR±¿ý�ú�®$û� ß�úlÿ�ßM®�û_÷�ø�ßM®�÷�ß¿ú�²�þ�� ÿ#û¿û_ø��J��®�ûTß�±T®��°�ß�²���¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú9qøR±Tý�ú�®$û�(û��²�§l÷�²��+�@��ß¿ú�²_ÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷!q²÷Kß� �ûT®$÷�þt²¾ß�ú�²¾ß�ÿ#±¿¯R²�ßÙ¯�±�ÿ�ý�ú,��ø�²û�÷�ø�ß)û¿ÿ#ß�®�û��1�%ß¿ú�²_ýlÿ#ß¿ß¿²±T÷(ø���ÿ!þøR÷�÷�²þtß¿²��ýÀøR±Vß ³ áªMû�øR÷�²�þÿ�÷Jû¿²t²� 0��øR±%ß¿ú�²O(²���@²±¿ûTú�®$ýJø$�Mÿ=��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��y(ø�±¿ý�ú�®�û� ß�øÎß¿ú�²�þ��$ÿ�û¿û0¯�²÷�²t±�ÿ#ß¿²�� �7�ÿ�÷Qÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷Kßa®�ßM®$û2÷�²þt²û¿û¿ÿ�±�� ß�ø+§l÷��¡ÿ�÷β�#�À²��!��®$÷�¯+��±¿ø ß¿ú�²�ÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷Kßa®$÷[ß�ú�²���®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú+qøR±¿ý�ú�®$û��³^�u÷(ß�ú�®�û)ù�ÿ��+�J��²�§l÷�²Mÿ%±¿²�� ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷¶øR÷8��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��+qøR±¿ý�ú�®$û�(û� �þÿ����²�� ã�çqÉ�ã��@���1'�~È�ã�¸�æ�*��oå('�« Êa²��̳<¬�³ � ³u¬�­�  ®�÷üß¿ú�²jûT²÷�ûT²�ß�úlÿ�ß0ÿ���®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²��gqøR±Tý�ú�®$û� Ðʽµ5Ð" 3 Ð× ®�û.±T²��$ÿ#ß�²��Çß�ø ÿ��®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²��P(ø�±¿ý�ú�®�û� Ð4 µ Ð" 3 Ð5 ®�� ÐÊ[þ ÿ�÷��À²¶²�#�À²��!��²��Ç®$÷ Ð4 ³jÁJ��@²�����®$÷�¯Sø�� ÐÊ ®$÷ Ð4 q² ÿ#÷�ûß�øm²���@²��òß¿ú�²9��ø jÿ#®$÷ ø�� Ðʽ®�÷òß�ú�²n��ø�jÿ�®�÷òø$� Ð4 Y®o³Ä²�³ Ð4 ®$û,��²�§l÷�²��¼ÿ#ß+��² ÿ�ûVß���ø�±qß¿ú�²[²��$²�(²t÷�ß¿ûù§ú�²±T² ÐÊÇ®$û#��²�§l÷�²��; Ùÿ�÷!�½ß¿ø=§l÷!�Oÿ ß�ø�ß�ÿ��Z��®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²��yqøR±¿ý�ú�®$û� Ð0 µ5Ð×�3 Ð5 þtø �%°�ß�®�÷�¯[ß¿ú�²±¿²ûT°!��ß¿®$÷�¯M��®$ÿ�¯R±¿ÿ�n �®o³Ä²�³ Ð4 ý�±TøN��®���²ûÙÿ#ßZ�$²ÿ�ûTß�ß¿ú�²2²��$²�(²t÷�ß¿û�ø�þtþ°�±T±¿®$÷�¯�®�÷qß¿ú�²¾ß�ÿ�±T¯R²tß)¯R±¿ÿ�ý�úqø�� ÐÊ%ÿ�÷!�ýÀøRûTû¿®��!���SûTø (²-(ø�±¿²�³_â¾ú�²0²���@²��!��®�÷�¯j±T²��$ÿ#ß�®�øR÷[ø�÷=��®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²��[¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú=(ø�±¿ý�ú�®�û�qû_ù§®���q�@²%°�ûT²����øR±C(ø���²��$®$÷�¯0û�ÿ#ß¿®$û��>ÿ�þtß¿®$øR÷�ø��:ß�²�(ý@øR±¿ÿ��T��øR±�0°!� ÿ#û³� ÿ#ß¿²±¾øR÷�³ÐMÑ  .�g��Òµ¡ ¹;���¼Ô ¡��Q»J¡�Í<Íe�L�6+g¢Y¡�Òµ ��Y��5U��ÕÁa¥�ÿ�qý!��²ûC��øR±¾ß�ú�²�²�#�À²��!��®$÷�¯q±T²��$ÿ#ß�®�øR÷�ÿ�±¿²�ÿ���±¿² ÿ$����û¿ú�ø6ù§÷[®$÷[­ ®$¯�°�±¿² � ³�ÍR³B��®$÷�þ².ÿ���;��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��(øR±Tý�ú�®�û�qû ÐÊE Ð0 ÿ�÷!� Ð7 ÿ�±T²�ß�ø�ß�ÿ��� ]ß�ú�²®$±���ø�jÿ�®�÷�û0þtøR®$÷�þt®��²#³ â¾ú�²�ÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷!q²÷Kß ÐÊm®�û�±¿²��$ÿ#ß�²��Oß¿øÐ0 �û¿®�÷�þ²�ùÙ²�þÿ�÷y§l÷!� ÿ�÷J²���À²��!��®�÷�¯Îø��ÝÐ× ®�÷ÞÐÑ J��°�ß ÐÊ¡®$û.÷�ø�ß�±T²�� ÿ�ß�²��Çß�ø Ð7 û¿®�÷�þ²jß¿ú�²±T²�®$û%÷�ø²���@²��!��®$÷�¯qø��5Ð× ®$÷ÚÐÓm³Ùâ¾ú�®$û_²�¥�ÿ�qý!�$²!ûTú�ø�ù§ûMß�ú�²�û¿ý@²þt® ÿ��8þÿ�û¿².ø��]ÿ¶ß�ø�ß�ÿ��fÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷KßMÿ#÷!�[ß¿ø�ß�ÿ����®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²��z(ø�±¿ý�ú�®�û�qû Ð0 ÿ�÷!� Ð7 ³]â¾ú�²�­ ®�¯R°�±¿² � ³ut0ûTú�ø�ù§ûMÿ�÷S²6¥�ÿ$(ý!��²aù§®�ß¿ú�ýlÿ�±Tß¿® ÿ���ÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷�(²t÷�ß¿û��øR± ÿ|��®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²��.¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�Ð" ß¿úlÿ#ß þøR÷Kß�ÿ#®$÷�û�ÿ2±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷%ÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²�ÿ�÷!��ÿ_ýÀøR±Vß�ù§®�ß�ú%ÿp��ø�þ°!q²÷Kß ®$÷%²ÿ�þ�ú

x%8

Page 54: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

ø�� ß¿ú�²!÷�²tßuùÙøR±��S÷�ø���²tû³Yâ¾ú�²K��®�ûTß�±T®��°�ß�²���¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�(øR±Tý�ú�®�û�qû§ÿ�±¿²!û¿ú�ø6ù§÷Îÿ�û§û¿ýlÿ�÷�û Ð":9<; Ð">=�3 Ð×ÿ�÷!� Ð" 9?;áÐ">@A3 Ð58 2ù§ú�²±¿²¡ß�ú�²���ø�jÿ�®�÷ôø���ß�ú�²P��®�ûTß�±T®��°�ß�²��ÙqøR±¿ý�ú�®$û� ÐÊ ®$û�¯�®��R²t÷Ô�@�ôß¿ú�²��®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²��ίR±¿ÿ�ý�ú Ð">=0ÿ#÷!�Îß�ú�²#��ø (ÿ�®$÷Îø$� Ð4 �@� ß¿ú�²���®�ûTß�±T®��°�ß�²��Q¯�±�ÿ�ý�ú Ð"?@�³!â¾ú�²0ÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷!q²÷Kß ÐÊ

p

PortRARA

p

PortRARA

d p

PortRARA

p

PortRARA

d

X^

d p

PortRARA

a

b

X

X

a

b

^

^

^

=

­ ®$¯R°�±¿² � ³�t�µ .;�lãK��äKälã�È#�����*ËÈ6�>É���*Ìã���çjå�È ä.�����ç �¿æ�'üÉ�ã¶ã�çqÉ�ã��@��ã����1'P*µ�lã.¸$å���ã�È0å('�ã21YÉ���*i'�å(*BÄN����ãÄ�ã�ÈÅ�æK�

þ ÿ�÷w�À²�²���@²��!��²��m®�÷ Ð4 û¿®�÷�þ²ÒÐ">=0®$û!ÿ�ûT°!��¯R±¿ÿ�ý�úüø��vÐ">@2ÿ�÷!�¡ß�ú�²t±¿²¶®$û!ÿ�ß¿ø�ß�ÿ��^��®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²��¡¯R±�ÿ#ý�ú(øR±Tý�ú�®�û����±¿ø� ß�ú�²Mß�ÿ�±¿¯�²tßÙ¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�ø�� ÐÊ�®$÷qß�úlÿ�ßYøR÷�²2ø�� Ð4 û¿°�þ�úSß¿úlÿ#ß)ß�ú�²:��® ÿ�¯�±�ÿ�qû�þø ,0°�ß¿²û³^ªM÷²���@²��!��®$÷�¯�ø�� Ð4 ®�÷Kß�ø ÐÊή$û!÷�ø�ß.ýÀø�û¿û¿®��!�$²$ fû¿®$÷�þ²q÷�²®�ß�ú�²t± Ð">@M®�û�ÿ�ûT°!��¯R±¿ÿ�ý�úmø$�êÐ">=�÷�øR±wß�ú�²t±¿²(®$û�ÿß�ø�ß�ÿ��;��®�ûTß�±T®��°�ß�²��S¯R±¿ÿ�ý�úzqøR±¿ý�ú�®$û�©��±¿ø ß�ú�²wß�ÿ#±¿¯R²�ߧ¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�ø$� Ð4 ß¿ø�ß�úlÿ#ß_øR÷�²�ø$� ÐÊl³¹q���;�>Ó.�� � 5E�Q»<�L�� ��Y��5E�O5�Î � ¢Y !��ð 3 ¢Y .�<��Î 5�¢$�� ��Y��5U�G .�<Í 3 ¡����]5E¢Y lÒ B)5&+E�L£â�²�(ý@øR±�ÿ$����ø�±�0°!�$ÿ�û�û¿ý@²þt®��1�,�@��q² ÿ#÷�ûÙø$�8û¿ý@²þt® ÿ�� *Ìã�çMälå�ÈTæ�¸1å�älã�ÈTæ�*Ìå�ÈÅ� ú�ø6ùôß¿±¿°�ß¿ú+�#ÿ��$°�²û)ø��fÿ�ûTû¿²±�sß�®$ø�÷�û¾þ�úlÿ�÷�¯�²�øN��²±§ß�®q²�³ â¾ú�²�ß¿²�qýÀø�±�ÿ��ÀøRýÀ²t±�ÿ#ß¿øR±¿û§°�ûT²���®$÷�ß�ú�®$ûYùÙøR±�� « þ��̳DÊa²��̳.¬�³�Í�³�ÍY­�®�÷�þ���°!��²

ØDCFE l±¿²ÿ���ÿ�û ��å�çjã�*L�*çjã%� E �ù§ú�®�þ�ú[®�ûYß�±¿°�²�÷�ø6ù ®��fß�ú�²±¿²�®$û§ÿ���°�ß¿°�±¿²Mqø q²÷Kß_ÿ#ß¾ù§ú�®�þ�ú�ß¿ú�²ß�²�(ý@øR±�ÿ$�U��øR±�0°!� ÿ E �À²tþø q²û¾ß¿±¿°�²$

ØHGIE l±¿²ÿ��[ÿ�û æ�¸ �)æ�&Y� E �ù§ú�®$þ�ú�®$ûYß¿±¿°�²!÷�ø�ù ®�� E ®$ûYß¿±¿°�²�ÿ#ß_ÿ$��U��°�ß�°�±T²Kqø q²÷Kß�û§ÿ#÷!�ØDJKE �±¿²ÿ��[ÿ�û '�ãT¤ * E �ù§ú�®$þ�ú[®$ûYß¿±¿°�²!÷�ø�ù ®�� E ®$ûYß¿±¿°�²!®�÷Sß¿ú�²!÷�²�¥�ßp(ø�(²t÷�ß³

â¾ú�²O��ø ���ø6ù§®�÷�¯n§�¯R°�±¿²�ûTú�ø�ù§û�ß�ú�²�®�÷�ß¿°�®�ß¿®$øR÷mø��§ß�ú�²�ß¿²�qýÀøR±¿ÿ���ø�ýÀ²t±�ÿ#ß¿øR±¿û�ÿ#¯Kÿ�®$÷m®$÷ ÿQ¯R±�ÿ#ý�ú�®$þÿ�����ùYÿ��R³0� ß_û¿ú�ø6ù§û§ß�ú�²�þtøR°�±Tû¿²�ø���ß¿®q²wÿ�÷!��ß¿ú�²M(²ÿ�÷�®$÷�¯�ø���ß¿ú�²wß�²�(ý@øR±�ÿ$�1øRý@²±�ÿ�ß�øR±Tû� �ù§ú�²t±¿².ÿD�!� ÿ�þ%�þ®$±Tþ���²wû¿ú�ø�ù§û§ß�úlÿ#߾߿ú�²"��øR±�%°!� ÿ E ®$ûYß�±T°�²�³

â¾ú�²�û¿²�߶ø�� ~�È¿æ�ä.��f{�1'.*uã�È ä@È�ã�*Ìã��[*Ìã�çMälå�ÈTæ�¸Dè å�È'çD��¸�æ(� øN�R²t±IÐ"y �û¿ú�øR±Vß���øR±�0°!� ÿ#û� �®�û%ß�ú�²O��² ÿ�ûVß�û¿²�߶ø����øR±�0°�� ÿ�ûY¯�²÷�²t±�ÿ#ß¿²����7��ß¿ú�²"��ø ���ø�ù§®$÷�¯0±T°!�$²tû « þ��̳DÊa²��̳�¬�³�ÍR³�Í�ÿ�÷!�9��°!��ûT²þtß¿®$øR÷9¬�³ � ³lc@­�µ

Ø ² ÿ�þ�ú[ÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷Kß|��ø�±êÐ" ®�û§ÿ���øR±�0°�� ÿ� Ø ®�� E ®�û§ÿ���ø�±�0°!�$ÿ.ß�ú�²÷/L E ®$û§ÿ���øR±�%°!� ÿ� Ø ®�� E Õ ÿ#÷!� E Ö ÿ�±T²/��øR±�0°�� ÿ�û�ß¿ú�²÷ E Õ6M E Ö ®�û§ÿD��ø�±�0°!�$ÿ�ÿ�÷!�

x7®

Page 55: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

CNEDO û¿ø q²tß¿®q²û E

GIEKO ÿ���ùYÿ���û E

JKEDO ÷�²6¥�ß E­ ®$¯�°�±¿² � ³ � µ�P '.*L���1*��oå('0è å�È�¸j�1'�ã¿æ�È6f{*��*çjã0å�älã�ÈTæ�*Ìå�ÈÅ��

Ø ®�� E ®�û§ÿ���ø�±�0°!�$ÿ.ß�ú�²÷ CFE ÿ�÷�� JKE ÿ�±¿²/��øR±�0°!�$ÿ�û³â¾ú�²�øRý@²±�ÿ�ß�øR±TûQL�ÿ�÷!� M ÿ#±¿².ß¿ú�²�°�ûT°lÿ�� ý�±¿øRý@øRû¿®�ß�®�øR÷lÿ��føRý@²±¿ÿ#ß�øR±Tû:��øR±2÷�²¯Kÿ�ß�®$ø�÷Qÿ�÷!�QþtøR÷�ÆT°�÷�þ�ß�®�øR÷ÿ�÷!� E ÕSR E Ö µ Û L « L E Õ%M L E Ö ­�ÿ�÷!� E Õ 3 E Ö µ Û L E Õ%R E Ö ÿ�±¿²Yß¿ú�²§°�û¿°lÿ$�lþ�� ÿ#û¿û¿®�þ ÿ���ÿ��!��±T²���® ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷�û��øR±B��®�û�ÆT°�÷�þtß�®�øR÷�ÿ#÷!��®qý!��®$þ ÿ�ß�®$ø�÷; R±¿²tû¿ý@²þ�ß�®���²����R³)­l°�±Tß¿ú�²±�(øR±T²� GIE µ Û L C L E ��²�§�÷�²ûYß¿ú�²wÿ���ùYÿ���ûøRýÀ²t±�ÿ#ß¿øR±³]â¾ú�²K��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��S¯R±�ÿ�ý�úÜÐ" ®$û¾þtøR÷�ûT®��²t±¿²�� ÿ�û§ÿ¶û¿²tß_ø���¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�®�þ ÿ��T�#ÿ�±T® ÿ����$²ût³ÐMÑ  .�g��Òµ¡ ¹;��¹¼Ô +�¢Y !��ð8õÅ�L�E�N¡7¢(�e¢Y¡@�N¡�ÍG�N¡��g�]5�¢Y lÒiÎ 5�¢(�PÌ�Òµ ÀÕ�%û¿ý@²þt®��1� ÷�ø�ù ß�ú�²�jÿ#®$÷Jý�±TøRýÀ²t±Tß¿®$²û¶ø��MøR°�±¶þ ÿ#û¿²�ûTß�°������@�ò¯�±�ÿ�ý�ú�su®$÷Kß¿²±¿ý�±¿²tß¿²�����øR±�%°!� ÿ�ût³ â¾ú�²§l±¿ûVß0ý�±TøRýÀ²t±Tß{�ü±¿²�¨�°�®$±T²û%ß¿úlÿ#ß%ÿ9��ø�þ°!q²÷Kß.¯R²tß¿û%÷�²��R²±D��øRûTß�®�÷Çß�ú�²+��®�ûTß�±T®��°�ß�²��mû���ûTß¿²��³[â¾ú�®�û%®�û²÷�ûT°�±¿²��5�@�Jß�ú�²�¯�±�ÿ�ý�ú�su®$÷Kß¿²±¿ý�±¿²tß¿²�����øR±�%°!� ÿή�÷ò­�®$¯R°�±T² � ³�x�³Jâ¾ú�²Sû¿ø�°�±¿þt²[¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú Ð" þøR÷�ûT®$ûVß�û¶ø��ßuù�ø�±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷[ÿ�±Tþ�ú�®���²%÷�ø���²û2ÿ�÷!�[øR÷�²-V.�6�YWVÖa×|su÷�ø���²#³¾Á�ÿ�þ�úÎø�� ß�ú�²�÷�²tßuùÙøR±��[÷�ø���²tû2þtøR÷Kß�ÿ�®�÷�û2ø�÷�²��ø�þt°!q²÷Kß ³¾â¾ú�².ÿ#ß¿ø (®�þ�ÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷!q²÷Kß¿û|��øR± Ð" ��±¿ø ß¿úlÿ#ß_ß�ú�²�¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�s ®$÷Kß�²t±¿ý�±T²tß�²��n��øR±�0°!�$ÿ¶®�ûp��°�®���°�ý; ]ÿ�±T²<T Õ ÿ�÷!��T Ö ³ â¾ú�²�ÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷!q²÷KßNT Õ ®�û#��²�§l÷�²��2��ø�±�ß¿ú�²8�$²��*ß%±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷mÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²jø��êÐ" ÿ�÷��½®�ß¿û��ø�þt°!q²÷Kß� Ù°�÷!��²�§l÷�²��òø�ß�ú�²±Tù§®�û¿²#³òâ¾ú�²[ÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷Kß?T Ö ®�û���²�§l÷�²�� ø�÷!������øR±0ß�ú�²�÷�²�ßuù�øR±��J÷�ø���²ø���ß�ú�²�±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷¡ÿ�±Tþ�ú�®���²� q��°�ß!÷�ø�ßwß�ú�²D��ø�þt°!q²÷Kß!ÿ�÷!�Qß¿ú�²�ø�ß�ú�²±w÷�²�ßuù�øR±��Î÷�ø���²ût³%â¾ú�²¶®�÷�ß¿²÷!��²��

d

q1 q2

PortRAX

RA RA

RA

d p b

RA

­ ®$¯R°�±¿² � ³�x�µ0} È�ã�ÄN����oå('Qæ�ÈÅ�%���1Ä�ã"���æ�¸ �)æ�&Y�Ùä@È�ã%��ã�È6Ä�ã��(æ�'E��æ�¸*¸q��åN����çjã�'.*µ�"�1'ÎÈ�ã�ÄN����oå('Qæ�ÈÅ�%���1Ä�ã�æ�È�ãä@È�ã%��ã�È6Ä�ã���æ(����ã�¸*¸��

(²ÿ�÷�®$÷�¯(ø�� ß�ú�²M��øR±�%°!� ÿ¶®$û� Dß¿úlÿ#ßMÿ���ø�þ°�(²t÷�ß2®$÷�ß�ú�²�±¿²���®$û¿®�øR÷Îÿ#±¿þ�ú�®��R²%®�ûMÿ$��ù�ÿN��û2ý�±¿²tû¿²±��R²��¡ÿ�÷!�ß�ú�²�ÿ�±Tþ�ú�®���².®�û_ý�±¿²ûT²±��R²��Îÿ�û_ùÙ²����o³�â¾ú�²M��øR±�%°!� ÿ0®�û_ûTú�ø�ù§÷Îÿ�¯Rÿ�®$÷�ÿ#ߧß�ú�²!ß¿øRý�ø��]­ ®�¯R°�±T² � ³u¬�®$÷�ß¿ú�²÷�ø�ß�ÿ�ß�®$ø�÷�°�û¿²��[°�ý[ß¿ø(÷�ø6ù°��øR±§¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�su®�÷�ß¿²±Tý�±¿²�ß�²��z��øR±�0°!� ÿ#û³Z�u÷�ß¿ú�²K��ø���$ø�ù§®�÷�¯! ��Yÿ�û¿ûT°!(²wß¿úlÿ#ßMÿ���¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�®$þÿ�� þtøR÷�ûTß¿±�ÿ�®�÷Kß�û!ÿ�±T²0¯R±�ÿ#ý�ú�®$þÿ�� þtøR÷�ûVß�±�ÿ#®$÷Kß�ûwøN�R²t±wß�ú�²D��®�ûTß¿±¿®��°�ß�²��Q¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú Ð" ®�÷¡­ ®$¯�°�±¿² � ³lx�³â¾ú�²±T²���øR±T²� !�]ø q®�ß)ß�ú�²M²�¥�ý!��®$þt®�ßÙ±¿²ý�±¿²ûT²÷Kß�ÿ�ß�®$ø�÷�ø��8ß�ú�²M¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú¤Ð" ÿ�÷!�j÷�ø�ß�ÿ�ß�²2ß¿ú�²/��²�§l÷�®�ß�®$ø�÷jø��8ß¿ú�²ÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷!q²÷Kß¿û|�@��ß¿ú�²!®$÷!��®$þ²tû_ÿ#ß¾ß�ú�²!ø ��ÆT²þtß¿û2®�÷�ß�ú�²wß�ÿ�±¿¯R²�ß_¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�û§ø���ß¿ú�²�ÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷�(²t÷�ß¿û³

x%U

Page 56: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

d

RA

q1

RA

q2

RAq1 RA PortRA RA

b b

q3

dp

­ ®$¯R°�±¿² � ³�¬�µ0} È�ã�ÄN����oå('Qæ�ÈÅ�%���1Ä�ã"���æ�¸ �)æ�&Y�Ùä@È�ã%��ã�È6Ä�ã��(æ�'E��æ�¸*¸q��åN����çjã�'.*µ�"�1'ÎÈ�ã�ÄN����oå('Qæ�ÈÅ�%���1Ä�ã�æ�È�ãä@È�ã%��ã�È6Ä�ã���æ(�.��ã�¸*¸�� } ¸*¸^��åN����çjã�'.*1�K�1'mæ�È�ã�ÄN����oå('üæ�ÈÅ�%���1Ä�ã%æ�È�ãqã�Ä�ã�'.*���æ�¸*¸j&jÈ�ãuä@¸j���¿æ�*Ìã��+*uå�æ�È�ã�çjå(*uã

æ�ÈÅ�%���1Ä�ãâ¾ú�²aû¿²tþøR÷��Ojÿ�®�÷jý�±TøRý@²±Tß{�(±¿²�¨�°�®$±T²ûÙß¿úlÿ#ßYÿ������ø�þ°!q²÷Kß¿û¾ÿ�±¿²2²���²÷Kß�°lÿ$����(±¿²tý!�$®�þ ÿ#ß¿²��1³ â¾ú�®$ûÙý�±¿øRý�s²±Tß{�S®�û§û¿ý@²þ®�§l²��n�@��ß�ú�²�¯R±�ÿ#ý�ú�su®�÷Kß�²±Tý�±¿²�ß�²��n��øR±�0°!� ÿ�ÿ�ß_ß¿ú�²K�Àø�ßTß�ø ø��]­�®$¯R°�±T² � ³u¬�³i� ß¿û2®�÷�ß¿²÷!��²��(²ÿ�÷�®$÷�¯�®$û!ÿ�û"��ø ���$ø�ù§ûµ � ú�²÷�²��R²±�ß�ú�²t±¿²¶®$û!ÿz��ø�þ°!q²÷Kß!®�÷Çÿ�±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷üÿ�±Tþ�ú�®���²qß¿ú�²÷¡ß�ú�²���ø�þ°�s(²t÷�ß.®$û.²���²÷Kß�°lÿ$����üûT²÷Kß0øN�R²t±%ß�ú�²jý@øR±Tß.ø��Yß¿ú�²j±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷mÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²qß�øÎÿ[±¿²�qø�ß¿²(±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷mÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²#³â�øq²�¥�ý�±T²û¿û2ß�úlÿ#ߧ߿ú�²M�$²��*ß_±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷[ÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R² « ù§®�ß�úS®$÷���²�¥[Ú�­¾ÿ�÷!�Sß�ú�²�±¿®�¯RúKߧ±¿²���®�û¿®�øR÷ ÿ#±¿þ�ú�®��R² « ù§®�ß¿ú®$÷!��²6¥ 4 ­¾ÿ�±¿²"��®�Å�²t±¿²t÷�ß� .��®�÷�û¿²t±Tß�²���ßuùÙøq±¿²���®�û¿®$ø�÷[ÿ#±¿þ�ú�®��R²û_®$÷Kß¿ø¶ß¿ú�²M��®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²��S¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú Ð"J³ á

¹q���;�>Ó.�$¹ � Ò�5@»e lÒZ .�<ÍKB�5q£  lÒ 3 ¡����]5E¢Y lÒV�85E¢(�PÌ:Ò� .�â¾ú�²0þ�ú�²tþ%��®�÷�¯Sø��]ß�²�(ý@øR±¿ÿ��e��ø�±�0°!�$ÿ�û_®$÷Îÿ8��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��Îû���ûVß�²�à®$û2²û¿ý@²þt® ÿ������[ÿjý�±Tø �!��²�á�À²tþ ÿ�°�û¿²ø��fß�ú�²"�$ÿ�þ%�(ø$� ÿ�¯ ��ø �lÿ��@ûTß�ÿ#ß�²#³]â¾ú�²±T²���øR±T²� .�@²���øR±T²"��ÿ$ ¯Rø�®$÷�¯%ß¿ø�ß�±¿²ÿ#ßYß¿ú�²wû�ÿ#ß¿®$û��>ÿ�þtß¿®$øR÷�ø$��¯�±�ÿ�ý�ú�s®$÷Kß�²t±¿ý�±T²tß�²���ß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ��7��øR±�0°!� ÿ#û ÿ�÷��0ß�ú�²¾ý@øRû¿ûT®��®��$®�ß�®$²tû8ß�øaþ�ú�²tþ%�%ß�ú�²�� �<��®$ûTß¿®$÷�¯�°�®$ûTú#�@²tßuùÙ²²÷ ¸$åN�¿æ�¸ÿ�÷!� ~�¸$å�É�æ�¸ ¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�s ®$÷Kß�²t±¿ý�±T²tß�²��Çß¿²�qýÀøR±¿ÿ��a��øR±�0°!� ÿ#û « Êa²��̳e¬�³ � ³�ÍY® ­'³W�8ø�þ ÿ���ß¿²�qýÀøR±¿ÿ��^��øR±�0°!�$ÿ�ûM��ø÷�ø�ß�±¿²�¨�°�®$±T²2ÿw¯ ��ø �lÿ���ûTß�ÿ#ß�²C��øR±�ß¿ú�²®�±]þ�ú�²þ%��®$÷�¯�³]â¾ú�²§ý�±¿ø�ýÀ²t±Tß�®�²û�û¿ý@²þt®�§l²����@�¶ÿ"��ø�þÿ�����øR±�0°!� ÿ2±¿²���²t±øR÷!���[ß�øSøR÷�²¶ý�±Tø�þt²ûTû%ÿ�÷��Ç®�ß�û/��®$ûT®�!��²0²÷@��®$±TøR÷!q²÷Kß ³,ª ¯ �$ø��lÿ��^��øR±�0°!�$ÿj®$û�ÿ8��øR±�%°!� ÿ� Àù§ú�²±T²qß¿ú�²®$÷���øR±�jÿ�ß�®$ø�÷jø���øR÷�²M�$ø�þ ÿ$�1û���ûTß¿²� ®�û¾÷�ø�ß_û¿°YXqþt®$²÷Kߧß�øqþ�ú�²tþ%��ß�ú�²"��øR±�0°!� ÿ�³�Yþ��$ÿ�±¿®��1��ß�ú�²tû¿²�ßuù�øqß�²±�(û|�@�Sß�ú�².¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�su®�÷�ß¿²±Tý�±¿²�ß�²�����øR±�%°!� ÿ�û¾ø$��ß�ú�²�þ ÿ#û¿²%ûVß�°!��� ®�÷ ­ ®�¯R°�±T² � ³u¬�³â¾ú�²-��øR±�0°!�$ÿ�ÿ#ß2ß¿ú�²!ß�øRý[ø�� ß¿ú�²K§�¯R°�±¿²�®$û_ÿ,�$ø�þ ÿ��T��ø�±�0°!�$ÿ� �ûT®$÷�þt²%®�ߧ±T²�¨�°�®�±¿²ûMÿqý�±¿øRý@²±Vß{����ø�±_ø�÷!���øR÷�²¶±¿²���®�û¿®�øR÷üÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²#³�� ß!®�û�ý@øRûTû¿®���$²0ß�øz��²tþ®���²��$ø�þ ÿ������z��øR±w² ÿ#þ�úm®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²¶ø���ÿ�±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷üÿ�±Tþ�ú�®���²®$÷Çß¿ú�²8��®�ûTß¿±¿®��°�ß�²��mû���ûVß�²� ®��§ÿn��ø�þt°!q²÷Kß0®�û0ÿ���ùYÿ���û0®$÷üß�ú�²jÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²�ÿ�÷!�½®��§ÿ�÷Jÿ�±Tþ�ú�®���²�ÿ���ùYÿ���û²�¥�®$ûVß ³]â¾ú�²M�$ø�þ ÿ$�Àþ�ú�²tþ%��ø��:û�ÿ#ß¿®$û��>ÿ�þtß¿®$øR÷�®�ûY÷�ø�ßYýÀøRûTû¿®��!�$²:��ø�±�ß�ú�²aß¿²�qýÀø�±�ÿ�����øR±�%°!� ÿ0ÿ�ßYß�ú�²"�@ø�ßTß�ø ø��¾ß�ú�²�­ ®$¯R°�±¿² � ³u¬�³Qâ¾ú�®$ûK��øR±�0°�� ÿ[±T²�¨�°�®�±¿²û.ß�ú�²�²6¥�®$ûTß¿²÷�þt²�ø��_ÿα¿²�(ø#ß�²j±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷½ÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²�ÿ#÷!� ÿ��ø�þt°!q²÷Kß�®�÷%®�ß¿û<��ø�þÿ��KûTß�ÿ#ß�²#³J��®�÷�þ²�ÿ2±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷%ÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²Y®�û�ø�÷!����ÿ����$²�ß�øM¯�²tß]ÿ#þþ²tû¿û ß¿øMø�ß¿ú�²±�±¿²���®�û¿®�øR÷ÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²tûÙøN�R²t±�ý@øR±Tß¿û)ÿ�÷!�(ÿ�±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷(ÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²_®$û�÷�ø#ß�ÿ$��$ø�ùÙ²��¶ß�ø�û¿²t²p��ø�þÿ���ûTß�ÿ#ß�²tûÙø$�1±¿²�(ø#ß�²§±¿²���®�û¿®�øR÷ÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²tû� �ß¿ú�²/�$ø�þ ÿ$�@®�÷���øR±�jÿ#ß¿®$øR÷¶ø��fø�÷�²M±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷�ÿ#±¿þ�ú�®��R²a®�û�÷�ø�ß�û¿°YXqþt®$²÷Kß_ÿ�÷@��(ø�±¿²F��øR±�þ�ú�²tþ%��®$÷�¯ß�ú�®�û³��øR±�0°�� ÿ�³�2ø�ù�²��R²t±� 1ß�ø(þ�ú�²þ%� ¯ �$ø ��ÿ��8ý�±¿ø�ýÀ²t±Tß�®�²û2®$û|��²ûT®$±¿²��Îß�ø�²t÷�û¿°�±¿²�ÿjþtøR±¿±T²þ�ß/�@²úlÿ���®$øR±2ø���ÿ+��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��û���ûTß¿²��³Ùâ¾ú�²t±¿²���øR±¿²$ @ß¿ú�²!¯ �$ø ��ÿ��T��øR±�0°!� ÿ0®�ûC��®���®���²���®$÷Kß�ø¶ûT²��R²t±�ÿ�����ø�þÿ��T��øR±�0°!� ÿ#û³]â¾ú�®�û_±T²���°�þtß�®�øR÷ß�ø��$ø�þ ÿ��a��øR±�0°!�$ÿ�ûwúlÿ�û!ß�øn�À²,��øR÷�²,�@�¡ß�ú�²,��²ûT®$¯R÷�²±³Z�_ø�ù�²��R²±� a�aý�±TøN��®���²(ÿ[þø�÷�ûTß¿±¿°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷Çù§®�ß¿ú±¿²ûTýÀ²tþtßwß¿ø�ÿjû¿²�ßwø���¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�s ®$÷Kß�²t±¿ý�±T²tß¿²��9��øR±�0°!�$ÿ�û_ß¿úlÿ#ßw²t÷lÿ��!��²û_ß�ø�þ�ú�²tþ%�Qÿ�°�ß¿ø (ÿ#ß�®�þ ÿ������jù§ú�²tß�ú�²±ß�ú�²w¯ ��ø �lÿ��E��øR±�%°!� ÿ-��ø���$ø�ù§ûB��±Tø ß¿ú�²!û�ÿ#ß¿®$û��>ÿ�þtß¿®$øR÷�ø$��ß¿ú�²M�$ø�þ ÿ��E��øR±�0°�� ÿ�ût³ � ²!ù§®���Àþø q²"�lÿ�þ%�jß¿ø

x@c

Page 57: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

ß�ú�®�ûYþøR÷�ûTß�±T°�þtß¿®$øR÷O�$ÿ#ß�²t±�øR÷�®�÷z��²tþtß�®�øR÷ � ³ � ³[�_²±¿²$ !�)ý�±¿²tû¿²÷K߾߿ú�²w±¿²���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�ø$�8ß�ú�²w¯ ��ø �lÿ��.��øR±�0°!�$ÿø�� ø�°�±¾þ ÿ�ûT².ûVß�°!����ß�ø��$ø�þ ÿ��E��øR±�%°!� ÿ�ût³ÐMÑ  .�g��Òµ¡ ¹;�]\�Ô B�5q£  lÒ*�85�¢(�PÌ�Òµ .��Õâ¾ú�²Î¯ ��ø �lÿ��C��øR±�0°!� ÿÇÿ#ßjß¿ú�²9�@ø�ßTß�ø ø���­ ®�¯R°�±T² � ³�¬Ç®$ûq±¿²���°�þt²��ôß�ømß¿ú�² ßuùÙøy�$ø�þ ÿ��C��øR±�0°!�$ÿ�û(®�÷­ ®$¯R°�±¿² � ³^8�³Îâ¾ú�²�°�ý�ýÀ²t±��$ø�þ ÿ��J��øR±�0°!�$ÿ[±¿²�¨�°�®$±T²û%ß¿úlÿ#ß0²ÿ�þ�ú���ø�þ°!q²÷Kß0®�÷Jÿ ±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷Jÿ#±¿þ�ú�®��R²�®�û

RAq1 PortRA

pb

q4 RA

b

p

PortRARA

p

PortRARA

q5 q6

d

­ ®$¯R°�±¿² � ³_8�µiA æ��%�z��åN����çjã�'.*^��MÈ�ãuä@¸j���¿æ�*Ìã��(ã�Ä�ã�'.*���æ�¸*¸j&�æ�'E��ã¿æ��%�!ä@È�ã%��ã�'.*Ìã��,��åN����çjã�'.*^��:�*çMälå�È�*uã��ã�Ä�ã�'.*���æ�¸*¸j&R�

²��R²t÷Kß�°lÿ������j±¿²ý��$®$þÿ#ß�²��S®$÷�ß�ú�²wýÀøR±VßF�À²��$øR÷�¯R®$÷�¯.ß�ø�ß�ú�²!ÿ#±¿þ�ú�®��R² « ®�÷!��®$þÿ#ß�²��O�@��ß�ú�²"��ÿ�û¿ú�²�� ²���¯R²N­�®�÷ß�ú�²p��®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²���¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�÷�²�¥�ßYß�øNTa`�³Z\[ø�±¿²øN��²±� �®��1ß¿ú�®$û)ß�ø�ø �¶ý!� ÿ�þt²� �ß�ú�²p��ø�þ°!q²÷Kß¾±T²�(ÿ�®$÷�ûÙÿ���ùYÿ���û®$÷Sß�ú�²�ýÀø�±Tߧß�øq²÷�ûT°�±¿².ß�úlÿ#ß2ÿ����8±¿²�(ø�ß¿²�ÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²tûMúlÿ��R²%ÿ�þþt²ûTû2ß�øqß�ú�®�ûF��ø�þt°!q²÷KßM®�÷�þ���°!��®�÷�¯�ß�ú�øRûT²øR÷�²wß�úlÿ�ß_ÿ�±¿²!ý@øRû¿ûT®�!����þ±T² ÿ#ß¿²���®$÷�ß�ú�²M��°�ß�°�±T²�³â¾ú�²/�$ø�ùÙ²±i�$ø�þ ÿ��.��øR±�0°!� ÿ!±¿²�¨�°�®$±T²û�ß¿úlÿ#ß¾ÿ.±¿²���®�û¿®$ø�÷�ÿ�±Tþ�ú�®���²a®qýÀø�±Tß�û)ÿ#��ø�þt°!(²t÷KßY®��1®�ßÙ®$û�ý@øRûTû¿®���$²�³â¾ú�®$û§²÷�û¿°�±T²û§ß�úlÿ#ߧ±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷�ÿ�±Tþ�ú�®���²û_¯R²tß2ÿ����T��ø�þ°�(²t÷�ß¿û_ß¿úlÿ#ß_ÿ�±T²!±¿²ý��$®$þÿ#ß�²��1³ á

¹q���;��� í  ��Y����α .£��N�>5E� 5�Î � ¢Y !��ð8õÅ�L�E�N¡7¢(�e¢Y¡@�N¡�ÍD�85E¢(�PÌ:Ò� .�� ²2úlÿ��R²aûT²²÷�®�÷qß¿ú�²Mý�±¿²���®�øR°�û�ûT²þ�ß�®$ø�÷; �ß¿úlÿ#ß)ß�ú�²Mÿ#ß�ø q®$þF��°�®���®$÷�¯M�!��ø�þ%��û�ø$�fÿ.¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�s ®$÷Kß�²t±¿ý�±T²tß¿²����øR±�0°�� ÿ�ÿ�±¿²�ÿ#û¿û¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß�ûK��øR±0ÿn��®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²��½¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú Ð"½³Îâ¾ú�²�û¿ÿ#ß�®�û��>ÿ�þ�ß�®$ø�÷mø��§¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�s ®$÷Kß�²t±¿ý�±T²tß¿²����øR±�0°�� ÿ�û�®$û ÷�ø6ùG��²�§l÷�²���ù§®�ß�ú�±¿²tû¿ý@²þ�ß)ß¿ø È6��'�� Rß¿úlÿ#ß�ÿ#±¿²Y®�÷�§l÷�®�ß�²�ûT²�¨�°�²t÷�þ²tûÙø��Àÿ�ûTû¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß�û^��ø�±XÐ"« Êa²��̳�¬�³�t�³�t0ÿ�÷!�SÊa²��̳�¬�³ � ³�¬ ­�³�â¾ú�²û¿²!ûT²�¨�°�²÷�þ²�ø��:ÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷�(²t÷�ß¿ûYþ ÿ#÷O�À²a¯�²÷�²t±�ÿ#ß¿²��z�@��ÿ#��²t±¿®���ÿ�ß�®$ø�÷û¿²�¨�°�²t÷�þ² « û¿²t²=��°!��û¿²tþtß¿®$øR÷ � ³ut�³ut�³�ÍY­6 i��°�ß(®�߶úlÿ�û¶÷�ø�߶߿ø��@²S÷�²þt²û¿û¿ÿ�±¿®�����³ â¾ú�²Sû�ÿ�ß�®$û��>ÿ�þtß¿®$øR÷ ø��aÿ¯R±�ÿ�ý�új®$÷Kß¿²±¿ý�±¿²tß¿²��+��ø�±�0°!�$ÿ"�7�(ÿ�±¿°�÷(®$ûZjÿ�®�÷!���#�lÿ�ûT²���øR÷qß�ú�²_²�#�À²��!��®$÷�¯%±¿²�� ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷¶®�÷�ß¿±¿ø���°�þt²��j®�÷ß�ú�²!ý�±T²���®$øR°�û_ûT²þ�ß�®$ø�÷ « û¿²²�ÿ���û¿ø�ß�ú�².Á^¥�ÿ�qý!�$² � ³ut ­'³�f²�ßcb ÛI«6ÐÊ%d ÐÊ Õ ÐÊ Ö �������u­/�@²qÿS±T°�÷mø$�Yÿ�ûTû¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß�û"��øR± Ð"y 8ù§ú�²t±¿²�Ê à µ�Ð" 3 Ð× à « Ï�eG� �¢ ­'³¶â¾ú�²÷; fbû�ÿ#ß¿®$û�§�²û2ÿq¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�®$÷Kß�²t±¿ý�±T²tß¿²�� ß¿²�qýÀøR±¿ÿ��T��øR±�0°!�$ÿ E U��²t÷�ø�ß¿²��9�@�Zbhg Û E D®���øR÷�²!ø���ß�ú�²M��ø ���$ø�ù§®$÷�¯þ ÿ�ûT²û_®$û³�R²t±¿®�§l²��1µ

Ø ®�� E ®$û2ÿ(û¿®�÷�¯ ��²%ÿ�ûTû¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß ÐÊ8��øR±ÏÐ" ß¿ú�²÷/bDg Û ÐÊ�®��]ÿ�÷!� ø�÷!���S®�� ÐÊ�þ ÿ�÷9�À².²���@²��!��²��ή�÷�ß¿øÐÊ%dMÿ�þtþøR±���®$÷�¯¶ß¿ø�ß�ú�²!²�#�À²��!��®$÷�¯q±T²��$ÿ#ß�®�øR÷;

Ø b�g Û L E ®�� ÿ�÷!��øR÷!����®��ibkjg Û E Ø b�g Û E Õ6M E Ö ®���ÿ�÷��[øR÷�����®���b�g Û E Õ ÿ�÷!�lbhg Û E Ö Ø b�g Û JKE ®���ÿ�÷��[øR÷�����®��fß�ú�²!û¿°�X�¥lbVg Õ Û�«6ÐÊ Õ ÐÊ Ö ������­Yû�ÿ#ß¿®$û�§�²û E ÿ�÷��

¬ ·

Page 58: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

Ø bKg Û CFE ®��]ÿ�÷!�QøR÷!���S®���ß¿ú�²±T²0®$ûMÿ�÷ÎÏIe2� �¢ ûT°�þ�úÎß�úlÿ�ßMß�ú�²0û¿°YXD¥Ab g à Ûæ«6ÐÊ à ÐÊ à o Õ �����u­2û¿ÿ#ß�®�û�§l²tûE ³ÐMÑ  .�g��Òµ¡ ¹;��ì¼Ô �� ��Y�L��α .£��Y��5E�ò5�Îm+�¢Y !��ð8õÅ���U�N¡7¢Y�<¢Y¡@�N¡�Í5Î 5�¢(�PÌ�Òµ .��ÕªMû.ÿ�÷m²6¥�ÿ$(ý!��²�ù�²(þøR÷�ûT®��²t±�ß¿ú�²q±¿°�÷nb Û´«%ÐÊ%d ÐÊ Õ ÐÊ Ö ÐÊ Ö ������­w¯R®���²÷ü®$÷Ç­ ®$¯R°�±¿² � ³�®�ÿ�÷��Çß�ú�²,��øR±�0°!�$ÿÿ#ß!ß�ú�²,�Àø#ß¿ß�ø� ø��¾­ ®�¯R°�±T² � ³u¬z��°�®���¡°�ý���±Tø ß¿ú�²jÿ#û¿û¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß�ûcT Õ ÿ�÷!�oTqp�³�â¾ú�²(ÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷Kß ÐÊ%d®$ûD��²�§l÷�²��òøR÷!���2��øR±0ß�ú�²�±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷Oÿ�±Tþ�ú�®���²�ù§®�ß�ú���ø�þ°!q²÷Kß 4 ÐÊ Õ ®$û�ß�ø�ß�ÿ��� ]®Ë³ ²#³]®�߶®�ûD��²�§l÷�²��G��ø�±ß�ú�²0±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷Îÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²tûaù§®�ß�ú9��ø�þt°!q²÷Kß 4 ÿ�÷!�¡ÚSÿ�ûMùÙ²�����ÿ�ûMß¿ú�²0ý@øR±Tß2ù§®�ß¿ú=��ø�þ°!q²÷Kß³Èq �ÿ�÷!�Îß¿ú�²ÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷!q²÷Kß ÐÊ Ö ®$û¾°�÷!��²�§l÷�²��n��øR±Yÿ���1÷�ø���²tû¾®$÷ Ð"J³]â¾ú�²!ý�±T²�q®$ûT²wø���ß¿ú�²!®qý!�$®�þ ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷qø��fß�ú�²�¯�±�ÿ�ý�ú�s

p

a1

PortRA

RA

RA

RA

b

PortRA

RA

RA

a a^ ^

X^

d

0 2

b

b

d

p

­�®$¯R°�±T² � ³�®�µi} È6��'måÌè.æ(�%����~�'lçjã�'.*µ��®$÷Kß�²t±¿ý�±T²tß�²��9��øR±�0°!� ÿ¶ÿ#ß2ß�ú�²K�@ø�ß¿ß¿ø ø���­ ®�¯R°�±T² � ³�¬q®�û§û�ÿ#ß¿®$û�§�²��; Àû¿®$÷�þ².ß¿ú�².ÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷!q²÷Kß�T Õ þÿ�÷9�@²²���@²��!��²���®$÷Kß¿ø.ß�ú�²:§l±¿ûVß¾ÿ�ûTû¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß ÐÊ%dYø��8ß¿ú�²M±T°�÷rb�³�â¾ú�²/��ø (ÿ�®$÷�ûÙø��qÊSd§ÿ#÷!�WT Õ ÿ#±¿²M²�¨�°lÿ��Àÿ�÷!�ß�ú�²�ÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷Kß:Ê%d_ý�±¿øN��®��²û§ß�ú�²!±¿²���®$û¿®�øR÷�ÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²!ù§®�ß¿úz��ø�þt°!q²÷Kß 4 ±¿²�¨�°�®$±¿²��9�@�rT Õ ³)â¾ú�²±¿²���øR±¿²$ ù�²§úlÿ��R²§ß�ø!þ�ú�²tþ%��ß�ú�²§®qý!��®$þ ÿ�ß�®$ø�÷.ø��@ß�ú�²³��øR±�0°�� ÿ:��øR±]®�ß�û]û�ÿ�ß�®$û��>ÿ�þtß¿®$øR÷T R®o³Ä²�³�ùÙ²tß¿ú�²±�ùÙ²_þÿ�÷�§l÷!�(ÿ�÷ÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷!q²÷Kߧ®�÷Sß¿ú�²!±¿°�÷T �ù§ú�²±T²�ß¿ú�²�ÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷�(²t÷�ßsTap2þÿ�÷��À²w²���À²��!��²��1³Ùâ¾ú�²�ûT² ÿ�±Tþ�ú ®�û¾û¿°�þtþ²ûTû���°!�L û¿®$÷�þ²>Tqp0þÿ�÷g�@²(²���@²��!��²��½®$÷Kß¿ø ÐÊ Õ ³�â¾ú�²���ø (ÿ�®$÷¡ø��ITap%®�û.²�¨�°�ÿ��]ß�ø[ß¿ú�²,��ø (ÿ�®$÷üø��CÊ Õ ÿ#÷!�2Ê Õý�±¿øN��®��²tû�ß¿ú�²¶ûTß¿±¿°�þ�ß�°�±T²(±T²�¨�°�®$±T²��w�@��Tqp�³¶â¾ú�²±T²���øR±T²� :ß�ú�²¶±¿°�÷nbOû�ÿ#ß¿®$û�§l²û!ß�ú�²¶¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�s ®$÷Kß�²t±¿ý�±T²tß¿²��ß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ��E��øR±�%°!� ÿ�ÿ#߾߿ú�²M�Àø#ß¿ß�ø� ø�� ­ ®$¯R°�±¿² � ³�¬�³ á

¹q���;���;�ËÓ � ¢Y !��ð 3 ¢Y .�<���µ�Y��5E� íÀï ���N¡��2�D .�eÍ5�6ð�¡���¢ � ¡��e¡7¢Y ��Y��5E� » ï)� ¢Y !��ð � ¢Y .�2�� !¢(��u÷%¯R²t÷�²±¿ÿ��� #±¿°�÷�û<��øM÷�ø�ß ¯�±¿ø�ùJøR÷%ß¿±¿²t²û� ���°�ß ÿ�±¿²)¯R®���²÷0®�÷%ÿ *Ìã�çMälå�ÈTæ�¸�~�ÈTæ�ä.�#*>ÈTæ�'����1*L�oå('D��&N��*Ìã�ç øN��²±Ð" « Êa²��̳E¬�³ � ³lc@­�³Jª ß¿²�qýÀøR±¿ÿ��1¯R±¿ÿ�ý�úSß�±¿ÿ�÷�û¿®�ß�®�øR÷�û���ûTß¿²� øN�R²t±ÏÐ" þø�÷�û¿®�ûTß�û_ø�� ÿ�û¿²tß2ø�� ÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷�(²t÷�ß¿û��øR±ÿÐ"y Dþ ÿ����$²�� ��*oæ�*Ìã%� @ÿ¶ß�±�ÿ#÷�û¿®�ß�®$ø�÷�±T²��$ÿ#ß�®�øR÷SøR÷�ß¿ú�²�ûTß�ÿ�ß�²ûMÿ�÷!� ÿqûT²tßaø$��±¿°�÷�û³Yâ¾ú�²%û¿²�ßMø$�]±¿°�÷�û2®�û��°�®���¶°�ý,��±Tø rß¿ú�²2ûVß�ÿ#ß¿²û)ø���ß¿ú�²¾ß�²�(ý@øR±�ÿ$��¯R±�ÿ#ý�úqß¿±�ÿ�÷�û¿®�ß¿®$øR÷¶û���ûVß�²� ÿ#÷!�qß¿ú�²§ß�±�ÿ#÷�û¿®�ß�®$ø�÷�±¿²��$ÿ#ß�®�øR÷1³­Dø�±�(ÿ����� �ÿ ß¿²�qýÀø�±�ÿ��)¯R±�ÿ#ý�úJß�±�ÿ#÷�û¿®�ß�®$ø�÷½û���ûTß¿²� ®�û�ÿ ß�±¿ÿ�÷�ûT®�ß�®�øR÷½û���ûVß�²� ù§®�ß�ú ÿÎûTýÀ²tþ®$ÿ��Yû¿²�߶ø��ûTß�ÿ�ß�²û « þ��̳Bk�úlÿ�ý�ß�²±O¬ ­�³Ùª ¯R±¿ÿ�ý�úòß¿±�ÿ�÷�û¿®�ß¿®$øR÷òû���ûTß¿²� û�ÿ#ß¿®$û�§�²û�ÿü¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�su®�÷�ß¿²±Tý�±¿²�ß�²��òß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ����øR±�0°�� ÿ0®��:²ÿ�þ�ú[ø$��®�ß¿û¾±¿°�÷�û_û¿ÿ#ß�®�û�§l²tû¾ß�ú�²"��øR±�0°!� ÿ�³Á)ÿ#þ�úJ¯R±�ÿ�ý�úm¯R±¿ÿ��(ÿ�±� �þtøR÷�û¿®�ûTß¿®$÷�¯[ø��§ÿ ûT²tß0ø$�§ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷�û%ÿ#÷!�Jÿ�÷½®�÷�®�ß¿® ÿ�� ¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú; �¯R²t÷�²±¿ÿ#ß�²tû�ÿß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ��_¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú¼ß�±¿ÿ�÷�ûT®�ß�®�øR÷¼û���ûVß�²� øN�R²± Ð" ù§®�ß�úô±T²û¿ý@²þ�ßSß�ø ÿ�÷�ÿ�ûTû¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß8��øR±ÚÐ" ®�÷Kß�ømß¿ú�²®$÷�®�ß�® ÿ$�³��®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²��¼¯�±�ÿ�ý�ú�³ â¾ú�²QûT²tß�ø��/��²±T®��#ÿ#ß�®�øR÷ ûT²�¨�°�²t÷�þ²tû�ø$�wß�ú�²Î¯�±�ÿ�,jÿ#±q¯�²÷�²t±�ÿ#ß¿²ûjß¿ú�²¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú ß�±¿ÿ�÷�û¿®�ß�®�øR÷ û���ûVß�²� ÿ�û,��ø ���ø6ù§û « Êa²��̳³¬�³ � ³�ÍYt ­'µ[�±�!ù�²Îú�ÿN��²Q¯R®���²÷ôÿ���²±T®��#ÿ#ß�®�øR÷ ûT²�¨�°�²t÷�þ²

¬�Í

Page 59: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

t ÛÚ« ÐÑ du ÐÑ�Õ u ÐÑKÖ u ������­!ûVß�ÿ�±Vß�®$÷�¯Îÿ#ß�ß�ú�²q®$÷�®�ß�®$ÿ��a��®�ûTß¿±¿®��°�ß�²��m¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú ÐÑ d� :ù�²(þøR÷Kß�®�÷�°�²(ß¿ú�²ÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷!q²÷Kß�®$÷ ÐÑ d�ß¿ø�ÿ�÷�ÿ�ûTû¿®�¯R÷!q²÷KßY®�÷ ÐÑ�Õ ÿ��$øR÷�¯�ß¿ú�²/��®�±¿²þ�ß³��²t±¿®���ÿ�ß�®$ø�÷æÐÑ d*u ÐÑ�Õ ³ � ²MþøR÷Kß�®�÷�°�²ß�ú�²�ÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷Kߧ®$÷IÐÑDÕ ß�øqÿ�÷[ÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷Kߧ®$÷IÐÑKÖ ÿ���øR÷�¯ ÐÑMÖ u ÐÑ p_²tß¿þ�³ªM÷Jÿ�ûTû¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß Ð4 µ5Ð" 3 ÐÓ ®�û%ÿ�þøR÷Kß¿®$÷�°lÿ#ß¿®$øR÷Çø��§ÿ�÷Jÿ#û¿û¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß ÐÊ µ�Ð" 3 ÐÑ ÿ���øR÷�¯[ÿ9��®$±T²þ�ß��²±T®��#ÿ#ß�®�øR÷ ÐÑ u ÐÓ ®�� Ð4 ®�û�þø�(ýlÿ�ß�®���$²¾ù§®�ß¿úO��²���²tß�®�øR÷; �ý�±¿²tû¿²t±��#ÿ#ß�®�øR÷�ÿ�÷���þ±¿²ÿ#ß�®�øR÷�ø��f®�ß�²�(ûÙ®$÷jß¿ú�²��ø ���ø6ù§®�÷�¯MûT²÷�ûT² « Êa²��̳ ¬�³ � ³�Í�ÍY­�µ ÐÊ%ÿ�÷�� Ð4 úlÿ��R²¾ß¿ø.ÿ#¯R±¿²t²YøR÷qÿ����²���²�q²÷Kß�û�ß¿úlÿ#ß)ÿ�±T²Yý�±T²û¿²t±���²�����±Tø ÐÑß�ø ÐÓg �øR÷!���0²���²�q²÷Kß�û�ø�� ÐÑ ß�ú�ÿ#ßÙÿ�±¿²F��²��$²tß¿²��,�@��ß�ú�²§ûTß¿²ý�jÿ����@²C��øR±¿¯�ø�ß¿ß¿²÷���±¿ø ÐÊ.ß�ø Ð4 �ÿ#÷!�(ø�÷!���ß�ú�øRûT²2²��$²�(²t÷�ß¿ûÙß¿úlÿ#ßÙÿ�±¿²_÷�²�ù�®$÷�ÐÓI(ÿ����À²_°�û¿²��jß�ø.²�¥�ß�²t÷!�jß¿ú�²Mÿ#û¿û¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß Ð4 ù§®�ß�ú(±¿²tû¿ý@²þtßÙß�ø ÐÊl³�u÷�ß�ú�®�û�ùYÿ��� �ß�ú�²:��®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²���¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú Ð"Ú�#²²ý�û§ß¿±�ÿ�þ%�(ø��8ß�ú�²wø ��ÆT²þ�ß�ûC��°�±¿®$÷�¯%ß�ú�²:��®$±T²þtß³��²±T®��#ÿ#ß�®�øR÷1³

ÐMÑ  .�g��Òµ¡ ¹;��¶¼Ô £R5E�U�Y���;Ì� ��Y��5E�]Õâ¾ú�²Q²�¥�ÿ�qý!�$²[®$÷ô­�®$¯R°�±T² � ³_U½û¿ú�ø6ù§û�ß¿ú�²Îþø�÷�ß¿®$÷�°lÿ#ß¿®$øR÷ ø��wß�ú�²¡ÿ#û¿û¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß ÐÊOÿ��$ø�÷�¯Çß¿ú�²[��®$±T²þ�ß��²±T®��#ÿ#ß�®�øR÷æÐÑ u ÐÓm³ â¾ú�²/��®�±¿²þ�ß³��²t±¿®���ÿ�ß�®$ø�÷(ý�±T²ûT²±���²û¾ß�ú�²a±¿²���®�û¿®�øR÷�ÿ�±Tþ�ú�®���²wÿ�÷!�j®�ß�ûZ��ø�þ°!q²÷KßYÿ�û

d

RA PortRARA

d

PortRA

ba

d

X^

p

p

p

1

2

G^

H^

b

­ ®�¯R°�±¿² � ³^U�µZ} ��å('.*��1'.��æ�*��oå('måÌè�æ�'üæ(�%����~�'lçjã�'.*)æ�¸$å('�~�æO���*È�ã%��*B��ã�È��1Ä�æ�*��oå('@�

ù�²���]ÿ�ûaß¿ú�²,V.�6�YWVÖa×|su÷�ø���²$ �ù§ú�²t±¿²¶ßuù�øS÷�²�ù���ø�þ°!q²÷Kß¿û.ÿ#±¿²¶ÿ��!��²��1³,��®�÷�þ² ÐÊ�®$û"��²�§l÷�²��ÇøR÷Qß¿ú�²±¿²���®�û¿®$ø�÷Îÿ�±Tþ�ú�®���²0ÿ�÷!� ®�ß�û|��ø�þ°!q²÷Kß� Àß�ú�²%þø�÷�ß¿®$÷�°lÿ#ß¿®$øR÷ Ð4 úlÿ�û2ß¿ø8�@²-��²�§l÷�²��üø�÷[ß�ú�²û¿²%ø ��ÆT²þ�ß�ûa®�÷ß�ú�²wû¿ÿ�(²aù�ÿ��R³)­løR±�ß¿ú�²wû�ÿ�q²w±¿²ÿ�û¿ø�÷; Ð4 ú�ÿ�û¾ß�øD�@²"��²�§l÷�²���øR÷�ß�ú�²MV����YWVÖa×|s ÷�ø���²�³�â¾ú�²!ßuùÙøq÷�²tù��ø�þt°!q²÷Kß�û�®�÷.ß¿ú�²³V����YWVÖa×|s ÷�ø���²i(ÿ��K�À²Ù°�û¿²��0ß�ø/��²�§l÷�²�ß¿ú�²Yÿ#û¿û¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß Ð4 øR÷.ß�ú�²i��ø�þt°!q²÷KßTÈ�®�÷ß�ú�²2¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú Ð"½³J�u÷jß¿ú�²M²6¥�ÿ�(ý��$²� �ß�ú�²:��ø�þ°!q²÷Kß<È�®$÷ Ð" ®$ûZ(ÿ�ý�ý@²��jß¿øpÈ Õ ³[�_ø�ù�²��R²±� .jÿ#ý�ý�®$÷�¯�ß¿ú�²��ø�þt°!q²÷KßiÈ ®$÷ÜÐ" ß¿øKÈ Ö ®$û_ÿ��$ûTøjÿ��#ÿ��$®���þtøR÷Kß�®�÷�°�ÿ#ß�®�øR÷1³�â¾ú�²0ÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷Kß:(ÿ��z�À².ÿ��$ûTø(°�÷!��²�§�÷�²����øR±qÈ8³�â¾ú�²t±¿²���ø�±¿²� �øR÷�²2ÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷�(²t÷�ß)þÿ�÷j¯R²t÷�²±¿ÿ#ß�²2ÿ.ûT²tßÙø��8ÿ#û¿û¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß�û0��øR±�®�ß¿û�þøR÷Kß�®�÷�°lÿ#ß�®�øR÷(ÿ��$øR÷�¯øR÷�²M��®$±T²þ�ßF��²±T®��#ÿ#ß�®�øR÷1³ á

â¾ú�²j¯R±¿ÿ�ý�úmß¿±�ÿ�÷�û¿®�ß¿®$øR÷üû���ûVß�²� ¯R²t÷�²±¿ÿ#ß�²��2�@�½ÿ�¯R±�ÿ�ý�úm¯R±¿ÿ��(ÿ�±�ÿ�÷!�mÿ�÷Jÿ�ûTû¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß ÐÊ%d0®�÷Çß¿ú�²®$÷�®�ß�® ÿ$�;��®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²��[¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú ø��]ß¿ú�²%¯R±¿ÿ�,jÿ�±¾ú�ÿ�ûaÿ�û2ûTß�ÿ#ß�²tûwÿ���fÿ#û¿û¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß�û2¯Rø�ßp�@�[ß¿ú�²%þtøR÷Kß�®$÷�°lÿYsß�®$ø�÷üø$� ÐÊ%d%ø�÷¡ß¿ú�²,��²±T®��#ÿ#ß�®�øR÷Qû¿²�¨�°�²÷�þt²û0ø$�Ùß¿ú�²(¯�±�ÿ�,jÿ#±³0â¾ú�²t±¿²q®$û!ÿ�ß�±¿ÿ�÷�û¿®�ß�®�øR÷[�À²�ßuù�²t²÷mßuùÙøÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷!q²÷Kß¿û� 8®��)øR÷�²¶ÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷!q²÷Kßw®�û!ÿ�þøR÷Kß¿®$÷�°lÿ#ß¿®$øR÷Qø���ß¿ú�²¶ø�ß�ú�²t±wøR÷�²¶ÿ���øR÷�¯�ÿ8��®$±¿²tþtßM��²t±¿®���ÿ�ß�®$ø�÷þøR÷Kß�ÿ#®$÷�²��(®�÷jÿM��²±T®��#ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷¶û¿²�¨�°�²÷�þt²�³)â¾ú�²_û¿²tßÙø���±¿°�÷�û)ø��Àß�ú�²§¯R²t÷�²±¿ÿ#ß�²���¯R±�ÿ#ý�úqß¿±�ÿ�÷�û¿®�ß¿®$øR÷¶û���ûVß�²�®$ûF��°�®���S°�ýn��±Tø ß¿ú�².þtøR÷Kß�®�÷�°�ÿ#ß�®�øR÷�û§ø�� ÐÊ%d2øR÷�ß¿ú�²K��²±T®��#ÿ#ß�®�øR÷Sû¿²�¨�°�²÷�þt²û³:��®�÷�þ²!±¿°�÷�û2ú�ÿN��².ß¿ø��@²®$÷�§l÷�®�ß�²aÿ�÷!��ÿD��²±T®��#ÿ#ß�®�øR÷�ûT²�¨�°�²÷�þ²#(ÿ��8�@²/§l÷�®�ß�²� �ù�²!²�¥�ß¿²÷!��ß�ú�²wûT²�¨�°�²÷�þ²%ø$��ÿ�ûTû¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß�û¾¯Rø#ß�7��ÿD§l÷�®�ß�²"��²t±¿®���ÿ�ß�®$ø�÷�ûT²�¨�°�²t÷�þ²%ß¿øqÿ�÷[®�÷�§l÷�®�ß�²!øR÷�²M�@�S±¿²týÀ²ÿ#ß�®�÷�¯�ß�ú�²K� ÿ#ûTß_ÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷Kß2®�÷�§l÷�®�ß�²����ø��*ß�²t÷1³

¬ t

Page 60: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

¹q��¹ � ð�¡�£wv;�L�6+ í  ��Y����α .£��N�>5E� 5�Î � ¢Y !��ð8õyx��U�N¡7¢Y�<¢Y¡@�N¡�Í 3 ¡��g�]5�¢( �Ò �85�¢$�PÌ:Ò� !�â¾ú�®$û]ûT²þtß¿®$øR÷¶®�û]þøR÷�þt²±T÷�²��qù§®�ß�ú0ß¿ú�²C�R²t±¿®�§�þ ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷�ø��U��®�ûTß�±T®��°�ß�²���û���ûTß�²�(û)û¿ý@²þt®�§l²����@�D��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�ß¿±�ÿ�÷�û���øR±�(ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷1³^�u÷[ß�ú�®$ûYùÙøR±��� E�Yÿ� (ÿ�®�÷!���(®$÷Kß�²t±¿²tûTß�²�� ®�÷Sß¿ú�² çjå���ã�¸jf��%�lã%�2z(�1'�~ ÿ�ý�ý�±TøKÿ�þ�úß�úlÿ#ß)ù�ÿ�û³�@²¯R°�÷+�7�8kB� ÿ#±���²2ÿ�÷!��Á0q²±Tû¿øR÷[_lkYÁ{U�Í �kYÁZ�YU|8 d ÿ�ûÙùÙ²�����ÿ#ûI}a°�®$²����²§ÿ�÷!�z��®��>ÿ���®$û:__}M�YU�Í d ³â¾ú�²¾®��²ÿ:qø���²���s þ�ú�²þ%��®$÷�¯a®$û<�lÿ�û¿²��¶øR÷0®$û:ß�øwþtøR÷�û¿®���²±�ÿMû���ûTß¿²� ÿ#û]ÿ:qø���²�����ø�± ß�ú�²Ùß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ��7��øR¯R®$þÿ�÷!�mþ�ú�²þ%�Çù§ú�²tß�ú�²±.ß¿ú�²+qø���²���û�ÿ�ß�®$û�§l²û%ÿ[¯R®��R²t÷���øR±�0°!� ÿ�³�â¾ú�²j²�(ý�úlÿ�û¿®��²qø��Cqø���²���s þ�ú�²þ%��®�÷�¯�$®$²tû�øR÷�ß�ú�²¾þ�ú�²þ%��®$÷�¯%ÿ�ûTýÀ²tþtßµ�±�ÿ#ß¿ú�²±�ß¿úlÿ�÷¶ý@²±���ø�±�q®$÷�¯aý�±¿ø�ø���û� KøR÷�²¾úlÿ�û�ÿ�÷qÿ���¯RøR±¿®�ß�ú! ù§ú�®�þ�ú�ß�ÿ��#²ûß�ú�²K(ø���²���ÿ#÷!�[ß¿ú�²K��ø�±�0°!�$ÿ(ÿ#û2®�÷�ý�°�ß2ÿ�÷!� ±¿²tß¿°�±¿÷�ûaÿD�R²û��#÷�øSÿ�÷�ûTùÙ²±³_­ ®�±¿ûVßpqø���²�� suþ�ú�²tþ%��²±Tûaÿ�±T²¯R®���²÷q®$÷n_lkYÁ{U�Í� ukYÁZ�YU|8 d �� þtøR÷�û¿®���²±)ÿM(ø���²���þ�ú�²þ%�#²±Yþÿ����²��q«��2�NV « ��ß�ÿ�÷���ø�±��qâ�²�(ý@øR±�ÿ$�l©]±¿øN�R²t±%­��²���²��$ø�ýÀ²��9�@��ß�ú�²!¯R±TøR°�ý�ø��0\[ÿ�÷�÷lÿ¶®$÷Kß�±Tø���°�þ²��[®�÷g_�\ ÿ�÷!c�x d ³Ùâ¾ú�²K¨�°�²ûVß�®�øR÷; D®�� ÿD(ø���²��8û¿ÿ#ß�®�û�§l²tûÿ¶¯�®��R²t÷O��øR±�0°�� ÿ0®$ûC��²þ®��lÿ��!��²/��øR±Yý�±TøRý@øRû¿®�ß�®$ø�÷lÿ��Àß¿²�qýÀø�±�ÿ��U�$øR¯R®�þaÿ�÷��nqø���²��$ûÙù§®�ß�ú�ÿ�§l÷�®�ß�²wûT²tß_ø��ûTß�ÿ�ß�²û� �û¿®$÷�þ²§øR÷�²¾þÿ�÷���ø.ÿ#÷q²6¥�úlÿ�°�ûVß�®���²2ûT² ÿ�±Tþ�úqß¿ú�±¿ø�°�¯Rú�ß�ú�²§ýlÿ�ß�ú�û�ø��@ß�ú�²³§�÷�®�ß¿²C(ø���²��˳<ª2÷!�¶ß�ú�®�û®$û|jÿ�®�÷!���(ß�ú�²�®��² ÿ(ú�ø6ùv(ø���²�� suþ�ú�²tþ%��²t±¿ûMùÙøR±���ß¿øR¯R²tß¿ú�²±§ù§®�ß¿ú ûTø (²�û¿ø�ý�ú�®$ûVß�®�þ ÿ#ß¿²�� ø�ý�ß�®�(®�� ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷ûTß�±¿ÿ#ß�²t¯R®$²tûÙß¿ø0±¿²���°�þ²aß¿ú�²aûVß�ÿ#ß¿²Mû¿ý�ÿ�þ²#³V�_ø�ù�²��R²±� �ß�ú�²:(ø���²��@þ�ú�²tþ%��²±Tû§þ ÿ�÷�÷�ø#ß³�@²a°�û¿²��Sÿ�÷@�+qøR±T²��øR±¾®$÷�§�÷�®�ß¿²"(ø���²���û³\[øR±¿²tøN�R²±� 8ß�ú�²Dqø���²�� þ�ú�²þ%��²t±¿û.²�¥�ýÀ²tþtß!ß�ú�²D(ø���²�� ÿ�ûw®$÷�ý�°�ß ³.ö2÷���øR±Tß¿°�÷lÿ#ß¿²����� 1®$÷Îß¿ú�²�þø�÷�ß¿²�¥�ß�ø����®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²��Sû���ûTß¿²�qû_ùÙ²K��ø¶÷�ø�ß_úlÿ��R²�ÿ¶¯ �$ø ��ÿ��Tqø���²��T��øR±Yß¿ú�²wù§ú�ø ��²"��®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²��Sû���ûTß¿²��³â¾ú�²±T²���øR±T²� Rß�ú�²±¿²Yÿ�±¿²)ßuù�øaý�±¿ø �!��²�qû³�â¾úlÿ#ß]ÿ#±¿²�®�÷�§l÷�®�ß�²Z(ø���²��$û�ÿ�÷!�%ß¿ú�²Y÷�øR÷�su²�¥�®�ûTß�²t÷�þ²�ø��@ÿM¯ ��ø �lÿ��(ø���²��˳³�Yý�±TøRý@øRû¿²�ß�ú�²�þøR÷�ûTß�±T°�þtß¿®$øR÷ ø���ÿ(ûTø$suþÿ����²�� *�&'äE���¿æ�¸T~�ÈTæ�ä.�9*>ÈTæ�'����1*L�oå('=��&N��*Ìã�ç ®$÷!��°�þ²��9�7�ÿ�û¿²tßaø��)¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�su®�÷�ß¿²±Tý�±¿²�ß�²��Îß¿²�qýÀø�±�ÿ�����øR±�%°!� ÿ�û� Àß¿úlÿ#ßaþtø ��$ÿ�ý�ûT²ûwÿ�ý@øRû¿ûT®�!����®$÷�§l÷�®�ß�².û���ûTß¿²� ß¿øSÿ§l÷�®�ß¿²¾øR÷�²_ÿ�÷!�¶ß�ú�ÿ#ßÙÿ����ø6ù§û�ß�ø�±¿² ÿ#û¿øR÷���øR±�ÿ�$ø�þ ÿ���û�ÿ#ß¿®$û��>ÿ#þtß�®�øR÷0ß�ø�¯ ��ø �lÿ���û�ÿ#ß¿®$û��>ÿ#þtß�®�øR÷1³�â¾ú�²¾ß{��ý�®$þ ÿ$�¯R±�ÿ�ý�úÇß�±¿ÿ�÷�ûT®�ß�®�øR÷üû���ûTß¿²� û¿°�ý�ý@øR±Vß�û%ß¿ú�²jþ�ú�²tþ%��®$÷�¯Îý�±¿ø�þ²ûTû0ø��³��ø�±�0°!�$ÿ�û!®$÷���®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²��mû���ûTß�²�(û� ��°�ßZ��ø�÷�ø�ßÙû¿ø ���R²¾ß�ú�²§ßuùÙø%ý�±Tø �!�$²�(û]þtø qý!�$²�ß�²����R³^r�²���øR±T²F�]ÿ� ¯Rø�®$÷�¯!®$÷�qøR±¿²F��²�ß�ÿ�®���ù§®�ß¿ú(±T²ûTýÀ²tþtßß�ø.ß¿ú�®$û)ûTß�ÿ#ß�²�(²t÷Kß� ��a§�±¿ûTß����q®$÷Kß¿±¿ø���°�þ²§ß�ú�²Mþø�÷�ûTß¿±¿°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷�ø��1ß¿ú�²2ß{��ý�®�þ ÿ��@¯R±�ÿ#ý�ú(ß¿±�ÿ�÷�ûT®�ß¿®$øR÷qû���ûTß¿²��³

¹q��¹;�>Ó 3 ðe¡ 3Mï �^��£  lÒ � ¢Y !� ð 3 ¢( !�<���1�Y��5E� íÀï ���N¡��� ²[úlÿ��R² ûT²²t÷ô®$÷¼ÿüý�±¿²���®$øR°�ûqû¿²tþtß¿®$øR÷; Yß¿úlÿ#ßjÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷�(²t÷�ß¿û���øR±qÿg��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��ò¯�±�ÿ�ý�ú Ð" ÿ�±T²�ß¿ú�²ÿ#ß�ø q®$þ#��°�®����®$÷�¯O�!�$ø�þ%��û.ø���ÿS¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�su®�÷�ß¿²±Tý�±¿²�ß�²��üß�²�(ý@øR±�ÿ$�^��øR±�%°!� ÿ�³D�±�Ùù�²qúlÿ��R²(¯R®���²÷Çÿ�ûT²tß.ø��¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�su®�÷�ß¿²±Tý�±¿²�ß�²��O��øR±�0°!�$ÿ�û� �ù�²!úlÿ���².ÿ$�$û¿ø0ÿ¶ûT²tߧø���ÿ�ûTû¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß�û³��øR± Ð"y �÷lÿ$(²����qß�ú�øRûT²wøR÷�²w°�ûT²����øR±a��°�®����®�÷�¯2ß¿ú�²³��øR±�0°!� ÿ#û³�­Dø�±�ß�ú�®$û�ûT²tß�ø��Àÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷Kß�ûJ�fþøR÷�ûTß�±T°�þtßÙÿMß¿²�qýÀøR±¿ÿ���¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú0ß�±�ÿ#÷�û¿®�ß�®$ø�÷û���ûTß¿²� ß�ú�ÿ#ß�®$û *�&'äE���¿æ�¸ ��øR±aß�ú�²qûT²tß�ø���ÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷�(²t÷�ß¿ûw®$÷Qß�ú�²qûT²÷�ûT²qß¿úlÿ#ß!®�ß!û�ÿ#ß¿®$û�§�²û!²�¥�ÿ�þ�ßÅ��� ß�ú�øRûT²¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�su®�÷�ß¿²±Tý�±¿²�ß�²��X��øR±�0°!� ÿ#û�ß�úlÿ#ß[ÿ�±T²P��°�®����°�ýÔ��±Tø ÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷Kß�ûSø��%ß¿ú�®$ûSûT²tß ÿ�÷!��ß�úlÿ#ß[ÿ�±T²û�ÿ#ß¿®$û�§�²����7��ÿ����ß¿²�qýÀø�±�ÿ��À¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�ß¿±�ÿ�÷�ûT®�ß¿®$øR÷�û���ûVß�²�(û « þ��̳Ek�øR±¿ø ��� ÿ�±��+¬�³ut�³^8@­'³

� 5E�e���N¢(Ìe£��Y�>5E�½5�ÎVBZ¡7 .���~z�e�J¡7¢��05EÌ<�eÍ<� � ®��R²t÷�ÿ.ûT²tß�ø��fÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷Kß�û� �ß�ú�²M®��² ÿ.ø$�1ß�ú�²2þøR÷�sûTß�±T°�þtß¿®$øR÷(ø��1ß¿ú�²_ß{��ý�®�þ ÿ��Eqø���²��!��øR±�ß�ú�®�ûÙûT²tßY®�û)ß¿ø-��°�®���,��øR±)²���²±��jý@øRû¿ûT®�!��²2ûT°!��ûT²tßYø$�fÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷�(²t÷�ß¿ûÿ���®$ûTß¿®$÷�¯�°�®$ûTú�²��Sÿ�ûTû¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß¾ù§ú�®$þ�úS®�(ý!��²�q²÷Kß�ûÙß�ú�®�ûYû¿°!��û¿²tß� D®o³Ä²�³� �ß�ú�²"��®$ûTß¿®$÷�¯�°�®$ûTú�²���ÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷Kßþ ÿ�÷��À²!²���À²��!��²��[®�÷�²6¥�ÿ�þtß�����ß�ú�øRû¿²�ÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷Kß�û� �ù§ú�²±¿².ÿ�����ß�ú�²�ÿ�ûTû¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß�û§ø��:ß�ú�²!ûT°!��û¿²�ßMþÿ�÷�À²§²�#�À²��!��²���³]â¾ú�²p��®$ûTß¿®$÷�¯�°�®$ûTú�²��qÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷KßZ��ø�±Ùÿ!û¿²�ß)ø��8ÿ�ûTû¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß�û�®$û�þÿ����²���ß�ú�² ¸$ã¿æ(��*<�6äKälã�ÈÉ�å(��'E� ��øR±aß�ú�®$ûwû¿²�ß ³�â¾ú�²q÷lÿ�q²�®$û"qø�ß¿®��#ÿ#ß�²��[�@�Îß�ú�²D�>ÿ�þ�ß� 1ß¿úlÿ#ßwß�ú�²q²���@²��!��®�÷�¯S±¿²�� ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷Q®�÷�ß¿±¿ø$s��°�þ²���®$÷+��²tþtß�®�øR÷ � ³ut�³�ÍR³�Í|��ø�±�qûÙÿ!ý�±T²�suø�±���²t± « þ��̳�©]±¿øRý1³�¬�³ � ³_8@­]ÿ�÷!�qß�ú�²p��®$ûVß�®$÷�¯R°�®$ûTú�²��(ÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷Kß®$ûM®�÷9�>ÿ�þ�ßaß�ú�²#�$² ÿ#ûTßw°�ý�ýÀ²t±/�Àø�°�÷!�=��øR±wÿ(û¿²tß!ø$�)ÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷!q²÷Kß¿ûaù§®�ß�ú ±¿²ûTýÀ²tþtßwß¿ø�ß�ú�®�ûMý�±T²�suø�±���²t± « þ��̳©�±TøRý1³^¬�³ � ³^U ­�³Sâ¾ú�²�þtøR÷�ûTß¿±¿°�þ�ß�®�øR÷½ø��Yß¿ú�²+��² ÿ�ûVß%°�ý�ýÀ²t±#�@øR°�÷!����øR±%ÿ[û¿²tß%ø��§ÿ�ûTû¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß�û.®$û�¯R®���²÷�7�jß�ú�²!°�÷�®�øR÷Sø��:ß�ú�²M��ø (ÿ�®�÷�ûYø��:ß�ú�²�ÿ�ûTû¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß�û_ÿ�÷!��ß¿ú�²!°�÷�®$ø�÷�ø$��ß¿ú�²wß�ø�ß�ÿ��;��®�ûTß�±T®��°�ß�²��zqøR±�s

¬ �

Page 61: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

ý�ú�®$û�(û/��±Tø ß¿ú�²���ø (ÿ�®$÷�ût³�â¾ú�²qþøR÷�ûVß�±T°�þtß¿®$øR÷üø���ß¿ú�²��$²ÿ�ûTß!°�ý�ýÀ²t±-�@øR°�÷!�ü®$ûw¯�®��R²t÷w��ø�±�(ÿ�����[®�÷©�±TøRý@øRû¿®�ß�®$ø�÷�¬�³ � ³^U�³wªYß�ß¿ú�®$û%ýÀøR®�÷Kß� J��ý�±¿²tû¿²÷KßqøR÷!���½ÿ#÷J²�¥�ÿ�qý!�$²�ø$�_ß¿ú�²�þø�÷�ûTß¿±¿°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷Jû¿°YXqþ®�²÷Kß��øR±M°�÷���²±TûTß�ÿ#÷!��®$÷�¯jß�ú�²-��ø ���ø6ù§®�÷�¯¶²�¥�ý!�$ÿ�÷lÿ#ß¿®$øR÷�ûMÿ�÷!�9��ø�±aÿ�ý�ý�����®$÷�¯qß�ú�².þøR÷�ûTß�±T°�þtß¿®$øR÷Îß¿ø�øR°�±2þ ÿ�ûT²ûTß�°����R³ÐMÑ  .�g��Òµ¡ ¹;� ßòÔ Òµ¡7 .���,Ì��<�J¡7¢�»]5EÌ<�eͼ5�Îp !�����,+U�e�g¡��U�Y�6Õk�øR÷�û¿®���²±�ß¿ú�²Qßuù�øòÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷Kß�ûrTa` ÿ�÷!��Tq�S®�÷ ­�®$¯R°�±T² � ³lc½ß�ÿ��#²÷X��±¿ø ß�ú�²Q¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�s ®$÷Kß�²t±¿ý�±T²tß¿²����øR±�0°�� ÿ�û0®�÷ � ³^8�³½â¾ú�²z§l¯R°�±T²�ûTú�ø�ù§ûqß¿ú�²�þø�÷�ûTß¿±¿°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷òø��2®�ß¿ûD�$²ÿ�ûT߶°�ý�ýÀ²t±,�@øR°�÷��; i��²÷�ø�ß¿²��G�7�Ta`��NTa��³]â¾ú�²p��ø jÿ#®$÷¶ø��1ß¿ú�²Mÿ#û¿û¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß�Ta`¾®�û�¯R®���²÷+�@�¶ß�ú�²p��®�ûTß¿±¿®��°�ß�²��(¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú´Ð"?�-��ß�úlÿ#ß)þtøR÷Kß�ÿ�®�÷�û

PortRA

p

RA

b

q4PortRA

p

q4X^

q4X^

q4

p

Y^

Y^

q4

Y^

RA

p d

p d

p d

d

d

PortRA

p

X

RA

b

PortRARA

b

Xq6

q6

q6

Xq6

q6

b

PortRA RA

RA

PortRA RA

PortRA

RA

RA

b

RA

­ ®�¯R°�±¿² � ³�c�µ .;�lãw¸$ã¿æ(��*Z��äKälã�È.É�å(��'E��åÌè/*µ�lã%æ(�%����~�'lçjã�'.*1� Ta` æ�'E� Tq� �ß�ú�²�Öa×Fsu÷�ø���²%ù§®�ß�ú[��ø�þ°�(²t÷�ß 4 ÿ�÷!�Îß¿ú�²DV����YWVÖa×|s ÷�ø���².ù§®�ß�ú[��ø�þ°!q²÷Kß³È1³�â¾ú�²D��ø (ÿ�®$÷[ø���Tq�þøR÷Kß�ÿ#®$÷�û1ß¿ú�²]ø�ß�ú�²±fÖa×|s ÷�ø���²�ù§®�ß¿ú!ß¿ú�²J��ø�þ°!q²÷Kß�Ú_ÿ�÷!��ÿ��$ûTøYß�ú�²ZV����YWVÖa×|s ÷�ø���²�³fâ¾ú�²)ÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷KßTa`��lTq�_®$û§þtøR÷�ûTß¿±¿°�þ�ß�²�� ®$÷�ß¿ú�±¿²t²�ûVß�²tý�ûµÍR³§â¾ú�²�°�÷�®$ø�÷�ø$� ß�ú�²K��ø jÿ#®$÷�û¾ø���Ta`Mÿ�÷!�lTq�2®$û§þøR÷�ûTß�±T°�þtß¿²��1³Ùâ¾ú�²K��ø (ÿ�®$÷¤Ð">� � �ÜÐ"?�-�§®$û§²�¨�°lÿ$�ß�øÒÐ" û¿®�÷�þ²!² ÿ#þ�ú ²���²�q²÷Kߧø���Ð" ø�þþt°�±¿û§²t®�ß�ú�²±¾®$÷ Ð">� � ø�±êÐ"?�-�³

t�³§â¾ú�²:��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��j¯R±¿ÿ�ý�úÿÐ� ®$û)þøR÷�ûTß�±T°�þtß¿²��O�@�qß�ú�²2°�÷�®$ø�÷jø��1ß¿ú�²:��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��j¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�ûPÐ��� � ÿ�÷!�Ð��� � lù§ú�²t±¿²�ß�ú�²#V.�6�(WVÖa×Fsu÷�ø���²!®$û§®���²÷Kß�®�§l²��T ÀûT®$÷�þt².®�ß2®�û_ß¿ú�²�û�ÿ�q².®�÷n�@ø�ß¿ú ¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�ûyÐ���-�_ÿ�÷!�Ð��� � ³]â¾ú�²�ßuùÙø(±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷�ÿ�±Tþ�ú�®���²û_®$÷ÏÐ� ÿ�±T²�þtøR÷�÷�²tþtß¿²�� øN��²±§ß�ú�®�û¾ýÀøR±Vß ³

� ³§â¾ú�²0ß�ø#ß�ÿ��<��®$ûVß�±¿®���°�ß¿²��¡¯R±�ÿ#ý�ú[(ø�±¿ý�ú�®�û�á��±¿ø ß�ú�²D��ø (ÿ�®$÷�Ð">� � � Ð">���Mß¿ø�ß�ú�²�¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú Ð� ®�ûß�ú�²!°�÷�®$øR÷�ø��:ß�ú�²!ß¿ø�ß�ÿ$�;��®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²��zqøR±¿ý�ú�®$û�©��±¿ø Ð">� � ß¿øÝÐ�&� � ÿ#÷!��ß�ú�²wß�ø#ß�ÿ��;��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��(ø�±¿ý�ú�®�û�©��±¿ø Ð"?�-�¾ß�ø Ð�&���t³

� ßÙ®�û�² ÿ�û���ß�ø�û¿²²$ �ß¿úlÿ#ß�ù§ú�²t÷�²���²± T�`¾ÿ�÷��?Ta��þ ÿ#÷��@²2²���@²��!��²��j®�÷�ß¿ø�ÿ�÷jÿ#û¿û¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß� �ÿ���û¿øwß�ú�²p��² ÿ�ûVß°�ý�ý@²±F�Àø�°�÷!�lTa`��lTq�_þ ÿ#÷n�@²!²���@²��!��²��1³ á

¬$x

Page 62: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

� 5E�e���N¢(Ìe£��Y�>5E� 5EÎM�6ð�¡ 3Mï �<��£  lÒ�� 5qÍ�¡�Ò â¾ú�²¶þøR÷�ûVß�±T°�þtß¿®$øR÷¡ø���ß�ú�²0ß{��ý�®$þ ÿ$��¯R±�ÿ#ý�úQß�±�ÿ#÷�û¿®�ß�®$ø�÷û���ûTß¿²� ù§®�ß¿úq±T²ûTýÀ²tþtß�ß¿ø�ÿ�ûT²tßÙø��1ÿ#û¿û¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß�û)×�®$ûJ�lÿ#û¿²��(øR÷¶ß�ú�²§þø�÷�ûTß¿±¿°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷(ø��Àß�ú�²F��² ÿ�ûVßÙ°�ý�ýÀ²t±�ÀøR°�÷!��ûwø���ûT°!��û¿²�ß�û!ø��)× « k�øR÷�ûTß¿±³�¬�³ut�³ � ­'³�â¾ú�²�û¿°!��ûT²tß¿û.ÿ#±¿²�ÿ�����ûT°!��ûT²tß�ûc5 ø��)×rß¿úlÿ#ß!ÿ#±¿²0þ��$øRûT²��°�÷!��²t±w²÷Kß�ÿ�®��q²÷Kß� �®o³Ä²�³Àù§ú�²÷�²��R²±%ÿ�÷¡ÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷Kß!ø��)× þ ÿ�÷P�@²�²���@²��!��²��ü®$÷Kß�øjß¿ú�²��$²ÿ�ûTßw°�ý�ýÀ²t±�ÀøR°�÷!�¼ø���5 ß�ú�²t÷ ß�ú�² ÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷�(²t÷�ßj®$û(ÿ��$±T² ÿ���� ®$÷òß¿ú�² ûT²tßW5j³ ­løR±(ÿ�÷¼²6¥�ÿ�(ý��$²� �þøR÷�ûT®��²t±(ß¿ú�²ÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷!q²÷Kß¿û�T�`0ÿ�÷���T Õ ß�ÿ��#²÷w��±¿ø ß¿ú�²q¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�su®�÷�ß¿²±Tý�±¿²�ß�²��P��øR±�0°!� ÿ#ûw®$÷Ç­ ®$¯R°�±¿² � ³_8�³jâ¾ú�²���² ÿ�ûVß°�ý�ý@²±:�@øR°�÷��Îø���ß¿ú�²%ûT²tßwþtøR÷Kß�ÿ�®�÷�®$÷�¯qøR÷!���ZTa`w®�ûmT�`!®�ß¿û¿²����̳¾â¾ú�²�ÿ�ûTû¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß�T Õ þ ÿ�÷9�À²�²���@²�����²��®$÷Kß�øwß�ú�®$û0�$²ÿ�ûTß�°�ý�ýÀ²t±i�@øR°�÷!�T �ûT®$÷�þt²_ß¿ú�²F��ø (ÿ�®$÷�ø$��T Õ ®$û�ÿ!û¿°!��¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú(ø��Àß�ú�²F��ø�jÿ�®�÷¶ø���T�`¾ÿ�÷��qß¿ú�²ß�ÿ�±T¯R²tß_¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú ø$��T Õ ®$û2ÿqûT°!��¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú[ø���ß�ú�²�ß�ÿ�±¿¯R²�ß_¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú ø���Ta`�³Yâ¾ú�²±¿²���øR±¿²$ @ß¿ú�²%ûT°!��ûT²tßaþtøR÷Kß�ÿ�®�÷�®$÷�¯øR÷!���/Ta`.®$ûa÷�ø�ß�þ��$ø�û¿²��¡°�÷���²±!²÷Kß�ÿ�®��(²t÷�ß� 1û¿®�÷�þ²�ù§ú�²t÷�²���²±�Ta`.®$ûw®$÷Îß¿ú�²¶û¿²�ß%ÿ$�$û¿ørT Õ ú�ÿ�ûwß�øz�À²�®�÷ß�ú�²!û¿²�ß ³� ®��R²÷Sÿ.û¿²tߧø$�:ÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷!q²÷Kß¿û¾×# �ß¿ú�²Mß{��ý�®�þ ÿ��1¯�±�ÿ�ý�ú(ß�±�ÿ#÷�û¿®�ß�®$ø�÷�û���ûTß¿²� ù§®�ß�ú�±T²ûTýÀ²tþtß¾ß�ø�× úlÿ�û�ß¿ú�²�$² ÿ#ûTßw°�ý�ýÀ²t±K�@øR°�÷���û/��øR±!ÿ�����ûT°!��û¿²�ß�û�5 ø���× ÿ�ûwûTß�ÿ#ß�²tû!ß¿úlÿ#ß�ÿ�±T²�þ���øRû¿²��ü°�÷!��²±w²t÷Kß�ÿ�®��q²÷Kß ³.â¾ú�²ß�±�ÿ#÷�û¿®�ß�®$ø�÷j±¿²�� ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷j®$ûi��°���@®$÷�ß�ú�²aû¿²t÷�û¿²wß�ú�ÿ#ßYß�ú�²±¿²w®�û¾ÿ.ß¿±�ÿ�÷�ûT®�ß¿®$øR÷+��ø�±� ² ÿ�þ�úSûTß�ÿ#ß�²2ß�ø�² ÿ#þ�ú�ûVß�ÿ#ß¿²ÿ�÷!�!ß�ú�²)û¿²�ß ø���±¿°�÷�û�þtøR÷Kß�ÿ�®�÷�û�ÿ���R®�÷�§l÷�®�ß�²]ýlÿ�ß�ú�ûfß�ú�±TøR°�¯Rú!ß�ú�²�ß¿±�ÿ�÷�û¿®�ß¿®$øR÷!û���ûVß�²�[³�â¾ú�²ÙþtøR÷�ûVß�±¿°�þtß�®�øR÷ø���ß¿ú�²wß{��ý�®$þÿ��8¯R±�ÿ#ý�ú�ß�±�ÿ#÷�û¿®�ß�®$ø�÷�û���ûTß¿²� ®$û³��øR±�jÿ$����¶¯�®��R²t÷[®�÷�ß�ú�²-k�øR÷�ûVß�±T°�þtß¿®$øR÷9¬�³�t�³ � ³â¾ú�²]ß{��ý�®$þ ÿ$�#ß�±¿ÿ�÷�ûT®�ß�®�øR÷wû���ûVß�²� ®$û;§l÷�®�ß�²$ ù§ú�²÷�²��R²t±�ß�ú�²]û¿²tßfø$��ÿ#û¿û¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß�û8®�û;§l÷�®�ß�² « þ��̳�©]±¿ø�ý1³Y¬�³�t�³�x7­�³�u÷0ÿ2ý�±�ÿ�þ�ß�®$þÿ���û¿ý@²þt®�§lþÿ#ß�®�øR÷; #ß¿ú�²)û¿²tß ø��Dÿ�ûTû¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß�û�®$ûf®$÷!��°�þ²����@��ß¿ú�²Yÿ#û¿û¿®�¯R÷!q²÷Kß�û�ø���ß¿ú�²�¯�±�ÿ�ý�ú�s®$÷Kß�²t±¿ý�±T²tß�²��Îß�²�(ý@øR±�ÿ$�e��øR±�0°!�$ÿ�û2ø$�)ß¿ú�²0ûTýÀ²tþ®�§�þ ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷1³"��®$÷�þt²%ß�ú�®$ûMûT²tß!ø��J��ø�±�0°!�$ÿ�û_ø��Ùÿjý�±�ÿ#þtß�®�þ ÿ��û¿ý@²þ®�§lþ ÿ�ß�®$ø�÷�®�û³§l÷�®�ß�²� �ß�ú�²!¯R±¿ÿ�ý�úSß�±�ÿ#÷�û¿®�ß�®$ø�÷�û���ûTß¿²� ®$û³§�÷�®�ß¿²M��ø�±¾ý�±�ÿ�þ�ß�®�þ ÿ��1ûTýÀ²tþ®�§lþ ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷�û³ªMû³q²÷Kß�®�øR÷�²��Sÿ��ÀøN��²� �ß¿ú�²Mß{��ý�®$þÿ���¯�±�ÿ�ý�ú�ß¿±�ÿ�÷�û¿®�ß¿®$øR÷(û���ûTß¿²� ��ø�±Yÿ0û¿²�ß¾ø���ÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷Kß�ûY× û¿ÿ#ß�®�û�§l²tû²�¥�ÿ�þtß�����ß¿ú�øRû¿²�¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�s ®$÷Kß�²t±¿ý�±T²tß�²��n��øR±�0°!�$ÿ�ûYß�úlÿ�ßMÿ#±¿²M��°�®����°�ý���±Tø ÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷Kß�û_ø���× ÿ�÷!��ß�úlÿ�ßÿ�±¿²Sû�ÿ�ß�®$û�§l²�� �@�Oÿ���)ß�²�(ý@øR±�ÿ$�Y¯R±�ÿ#ý�úOß¿±�ÿ�÷�û¿®�ß¿®$øR÷Jû���ûTß�²�(û « þ��̳Zk�øR±¿ø��� ÿ#±���¬�³ut�³_8@­'³Jâ¾úlÿ#ß,(²ÿ�÷�û� ®��¾ùÙ²�ú�ÿN��²�¯R®���²÷Oÿ ß�²�(ý@øR±¿ÿ���¯R±¿ÿ�ý�úyqø���²���¯�²÷�²t±�ÿ#ß¿²����@�Jÿ[��®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²��Jû���ûVß�²� û¿ý@²þt®�§lþÿ#ß�®�øR÷ÿ�÷!�(ß¿ú�²§ß{��ý�®$þ ÿ$�À¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú,(ø���²��Dù§®�ß�úq±¿²tû¿ý@²þtß�ß�ø!ß�ú�²2¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�su®�÷�ß¿²±Tý�±¿²�ß�²��qß�²�(ý@øR±�ÿ$�!��øR±�0°�� ÿ�û]ø���ß�ú�®�ûû¿ý@²þ®�§lþ ÿ�ß�®$ø�÷; 1ß�ú�²t÷üÿS¯�±�ÿ�ý�ú�su®$÷Kß¿²±¿ý�±¿²tß¿²��Qß�²�(ý@øR±¿ÿ��<��øR±�0°!�$ÿj®$ûaß¿±¿°�²�®�÷Îß�ú�²�ß�²�(ý@øR±¿ÿ��^qø���²��<��ø�±ß�ú�²2¯R±�ÿ�,(ÿ�±]®��Àß�ú�²|��øR±�0°�� ÿ!®$û�ß�±¿°�²M®$÷qß�ú�²_ß{��ý�®$þÿ��D¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú8(ø���²��o³^�±��ß�ú�²|��øR±�0°�� ÿ!®$û)÷�ø�ßÙû�ÿ#ß¿®$û�§�²��®$÷mß¿ú�²�ß{��ý�®$þÿ���¯R±¿ÿ�ý�úyqø���²��� �ú�ø�ù�²��R²t±� �®�ß0þÿ�÷y�À²(ß�±¿°�²�®$÷mß¿ú�²jß�²�(ý@øR±¿ÿ��Ù¯�±�ÿ�ý�úyqø���²��Z��øR±.ß¿ú�²¯R±�ÿ�,(ÿ�±³,�u÷Çß¿ú�®$û!þ ÿ#û¿²�  ø�ß�ú�²t±.þ�ú�²þ%��®$÷�¯[ß�²þ�ú�÷�®¨�°�²tû%úlÿ��R²qß�øn�À²qþøR÷�û¿®��²±¿²��1³O�u÷Çß¿ú�®$ûwù�ÿ��  ß¿ú�²ß{��ý�®$þ ÿ$� ¯R±¿ÿ�ý�úÎß�±¿ÿ�÷�ûT®�ß�®�øR÷ û���ûTß�²� û¿°�ý�ýÀø�±Tß�ûwø�÷!���Sß�ú�²�þ�ú�²þ%��®$÷�¯�ý�±¿ø�þ²ûTû� q��°�ß"��ø�²ûw÷�ø�ßaû¿ø ���R²%ß¿ú�²þ�ú�²þ%��®$÷�¯jý�±Tø �!�$²� ®�÷�®�÷�§l÷�®�ß�²"qø���²��$û�þø qý!�$²�ß�²����R³ÐMÑ  .�g��Òµ¡ ¹;���¼Ô � ï �<�L£  �Ò�+�¢Y !��ðÙ�Ç5qÍe¡�Ò Õ�ÙþtøR÷�ûTß¿±¿°�þ�ߧß�ú�²wß{��ý�®$þÿ��1¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�ß�±¿ÿ�÷�ûT®�ß�®�øR÷�û���ûVß�²� ��ø�±Yß�ú�²w¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�s ®$÷Kß�²t±¿ý�±T²tß¿²��Sß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ��E��øR±�%°!� ÿ�ûø��%ß¿ú�²mþÿ�û¿²üûTß¿°!��� ¯R®���²÷ ®$÷ ­ ®$¯R°�±¿² � ³�¬òÿ�÷!� ­ ®$¯�°�±¿² � ³_8�³ â¾ú�²mû¿²�ßÎø��0ÿ�û¿ûT®$¯R÷�(²t÷�ß¿û[®�ûS¯R®���²÷�7� ß¿ú�²Îþø�÷�ûTß¿±�ÿ�®�÷�ß¿û<T Õ Ý�������Ý�Tq�jø�þtþ°�±T±¿®$÷�¯m®$÷Oß�ú�²tû¿²9��ø�±�0°!�$ÿ�û³ôâ¾ú�²ÎûTß�ÿ#ß�²tû�ø��aß¿ú�²[ß{��ý�®�þ ÿ��_¯R±�ÿ#ý�úß�±�ÿ#÷�û¿®�ß�®$ø�÷Qû���ûTß¿²� ÿ�±¿²�þtøR÷�ûVß�±¿°�þtß�²��Jÿ�ûM�$²ÿ�ûTß!°�ý�ýÀ²t±M�ÀøR°�÷!��ûM��øR±!ÿ��� û¿°!��ûT²tß¿û%ø�� Ü T Õ Ý�������ÝyTq� Þ 8ß�úlÿ�ßÿ�±¿²¶þ���øRû¿²��¡°�÷!��²t±.²t÷�ß�ÿ�®��(²t÷Kß « ûT²²(­ ®$¯R°�±¿² � ³�Í · ­'³�â¾ú�²¶ß�±�ÿ#÷�û¿®�ß�®$ø�÷Qû���ûTß¿²� úlÿ�û¶ÍYt�ûVß�ÿ#ß¿²û� fù§ú�²t±¿²�_ú�ÿN��²�²�¨�°�®�ý�ýÀ²��Q² ÿ�þ�úQûVß�ÿ#ß¿²D�@�[ß¿ú�²0û¿²�ßwø��Ùÿ�ûTû¿®$¯�÷!(²t÷Kß�û:��±Tø ß�úlÿ#ß2ß�ú�²#�$² ÿ#ûTßw°�ý�ýÀ²t±/�Àø�°�÷!�Îù�ÿ�ûþøR÷�ûVß�±T°�þtß¿²��1³Z��ø q®�ßTß�²���ß�ú�²wß�±¿ÿ�÷�ûT®�ß�®�øR÷�±¿²�� ÿ#ß¿®$øR÷T �û¿®�÷�þ²!®�ß¾®$û³��°!���o³ á

¹q��¹;�>Ó.�ËÓ ��¢65E� Ò�5q£  lÒZ� 5�+@Ò>5D»e lÒB�e¢65E�J¡7¢N�Y�µ¡��� ²�úlÿ���²�û¿²²t÷üß¿úlÿ#ßaß¿ú�²0ß{��ý�®$þÿ��aqø���²��:þø ��� ÿ�ý�ûT²ûwÿ�ý@øRû¿ûT®�!����®$÷�§l÷�®�ß�²#(ø���²��:ß�øSÿ+§l÷�®�ß�²%øR÷�²�³K�u÷ß�ú�®�ûqûT²þ�ß�®$ø�÷5�%ùÙøR°!���5�$®���²�ß�øwq²÷Kß�®�øR÷ ÿ#÷�ø�ß�ú�²±qýÀøRûTû¿®���®��®�ß{�ǯR®���²÷5�@� ß�ú�²�ß{��ý�®�þ ÿ��Fqø���²��� �ß�úlÿ�ß®$û� �ß�øü±¿²ÿ�û¿ø�÷G��±¿ø�Þ�$ø�þ ÿ���û�ÿ#ß¿®$û��>ÿ#þtß�®�øR÷Jß�ø¡¯ ��ø �lÿ��Yû¿ÿ#ß�®�û��>ÿ�þ�ß�®�øR÷1³�ªMû,(²t÷Kß�®$ø�÷�²��O®$÷Jß�ú�²[ý�±T²���®$ø�°�ûþ�úlÿ�ý�ß¿²±� ��8ý�±¿øN��®��²0��øR±:² ÿ�þ�ú%ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û�®�÷�ûTß�ÿ�÷�þ²)ß�ú�²ÙøRý@²÷%ý�±¿ø�þ²ûTû�û¿²�jÿ#÷�ß¿®$þtûe��øR±�ÿ2ý�±¿ø�þ²ûTû�®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²$

¬ ¬

Page 63: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

RA

q2

q1, q4

RA PortRA

b p

b

RA RA

q1,q2

RA PortRA

b p

RA

q1, q2, q4

b

RA

b

RA RA PortRA

p

q1, q2, q5

q2, q5

RA PortRA

p

RA

q2, q5, q6

d

PortRA

p

RA RA

b

RA

b

PortRA

p

RA

q1, q2, q4, q5

RA

b

RA

q1

d

PortRA

p

q1, q2, q5, q6

PortRA

p

q1, q2, q3, q4, q5, q6

d

­ ®�¯R°�±T² � ³�Í · µ .;�lãM*�&'äE���¿æ�¸8çjå���ã�¸#è å�ÈK*1�lã:~�ÈTæ�ä.��f{�1'.*Ìã�È ä@È�ã�*uã��_è å�È'çD��¸�æ(�M�1'A�S����æ�'E�<�S�-���ß�úlÿ#ß���²ûTþ±¿®��À²tû�ß�ú�²O�@²úlÿ���®$ø�±0ø��2ÿÎý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û¶®$÷�ûTß�ÿ#÷�þ²�®�÷JÿÎþø qý!��²tß�²j²÷@��®$±¿ø�÷!(²t÷K߶®$÷½ß�ú�²�û¿²÷�û¿²ß�úlÿ#ßaÿ��$ûTø�ÿ�����ý@øRû¿ûT®�!��²%²�Å�²tþtß�ûwø�÷ÎýÀø�±Tß�ûaÿ�±¿²0þtøR÷�ûT®��²t±¿²���³wâ¾ú�²�øRý@²÷Qý�±Tø�þt²û¿ûwûT²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®�þ%®$÷���°�þ²tû!ÿ¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú[ß�±¿ÿ�÷�ûT®�ß�®�øR÷ û���ûTß�²�n @ù§ú�²±T²��$ø�þ ÿ$�;��øR±�0°�� ÿ�û_þ ÿ�÷9�À².þ�ú�²þ%�#²��1³"�u÷Îâ¾ú�²øR±T²� ¬�³ � ³�Í�Uq®$û_û¿ú�ø�ù§÷ß�úlÿ#ß�ß�ú�²jû�ÿ�ß�®$û��>ÿ�þtß¿®$øR÷üø��C��ø�þÿ��J��øR±�%°!� ÿ�û!®�÷Çß�ú�²jøRý@²÷Çý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û0ûT²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®$þtû%þÿ�÷2�@²(°�ûT²��½ß¿ø û¿ú�ø6ùß�ú�²qû�ÿ#ß¿®$û��>ÿ�þtß¿®$øR÷Qø��Ùß�ú�²,�$ø�þ ÿ$�^��øR±�%°!� ÿ�ûw®�÷Qß�ú�²qþø qý!��²tß�²D��®$ûTß¿±¿®���°�ß�²��Çû���ûTß�²�[³+�u÷üß¿ú�®$ûwù�ÿN�� �ß¿ú�²þ�ú�²þ%��®$÷�¯.ø��E��ø�þÿ�����ø�±�0°!�$ÿ�û�þÿ�÷��À²Y±T²���°�þ²��qß�ø!ÿ/��ø�þÿ���û���ûVß�²� ûTß�ÿ#ß�²§ÿ�÷��¶ùÙ²F��øw÷�ø�ß�÷�²²��qÿw¯ ��ø �lÿ��ûTß�ÿ�ß�²�³Ùö2÷���²±¾ß�ú�²%ÿ�ûTû¿°!qý�ß¿®$øR÷Sø��<�$ø�þ ÿ���û�ÿ#ß¿®$û��>ÿ#þtß�®�øR÷�®$÷�ß¿ú�².ø�ýÀ²t÷[ý�±Tø�þt²ûTû2ûT²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®$þtû� �ß¿ú�²wß{��ý�®$þ ÿ$�(ø���²��@¯R®��R²ûÙß�ú�²wý@øRû¿ûT®��®��$®�ß{��ß�ø0þ�ú�²tþ%��¯ ��ø �lÿ�����øR±�%°!� ÿ�û�ù§®�ß¿ú�øR°�ßYþøR÷�ûVß�±T°�þtß¿®$÷�¯¶ÿ0¯ ��ø �lÿ��DûVß�ÿ#ß¿² « ûT²²â¾ú�²øR±T²�Þ¬�³ � ³�ÍNc ­�³[\�øR±¿²8��²tß�ÿ#®�$û�þ ÿ#÷y�À²,��øR°�÷!�J®�÷y��²tþtß�®�øR÷ ¬�³ � ³ � ³9�wùÙøR°!��g�$®�#²(ß¿øÎþ��$ÿ�±¿®��1�Qß�ú�®�ûý�±¿øRý@²±Vß{��ø���ß�ú�²�ß{��ý�®�þ ÿ��e(ø���²��8®$÷[ß¿ú�²�÷�²�¥�ßwûT²þtß¿®$øR÷T @ù§ú�²t±¿²-�Yþ�ú�²þ%��ß�ú�²-jÿ#®$÷Sý�±¿ø�ýÀ²t±Tß�®�²û_ø���ß¿ú�²þ ÿ�ûT²�ûVß�°!���R³¹q��¹;��� � ð�¡�£�vq���i+w�6ð�¡[�g .���G�e¢65E�J¡7¢N�Y�µ¡��¶5�ÎF�6ð�¡=£  .��¡=���YÌeÍ ï�]þ�ú�²þ%��÷�ø6ù�ß¿ú�²2ßuùÙøDjÿ#®$÷jý�±¿øRý@²±Vß�®$²tû�ø��8ß¿ú�²Mþÿ�û¿²MûTß�°���� �ß¿úlÿ#ßYÿ�±¿²2²�¥�ý�±¿²tû¿ûT²����7�(ß�ú�²_ßuù�ø�¯�±�ÿ�ý�ú�s®$÷Kß�²t±¿ý�±T²tß�²��9��øR±�0°!� ÿ#û¾®$÷[­ ®$¯R°�±¿² � ³�¬�³Yâ¾ú�²K§l±¿ûVßp��øR±�0°!�$ÿ¶ûTýÀ²tþ®�§l²ûMß¿úlÿ#ß2ÿ(±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷[ÿ�±Tþ�ú�®���²0ÿ�÷!� ÿ��ø�þt°!q²÷KßM®�÷Îÿ¶±¿²���®�û¿®�øR÷Îÿ�±Tþ�ú�®���²0ÿ�±T²%ÿ$��ù�ÿN��û_ý�±¿²tû¿²t±��R²��1³Mâ¾ú�²#�$ø�ùÙ²±F��øR±�%°!� ÿ�û¿ý@²þt®�§l²tûMß�ú�ÿ#ßM²ÿ�þ�ú��ø�þt°!q²÷Kßa®�û2²��R²÷Kß¿°lÿ������±¿²ý��$®$þÿ#ß�²��[ß¿ø�ÿ(±T²�qø�ß�².ÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²#³m��ú�²t±¿²ÿ�ûMß�ú�²-§l±TûTß:��ø�±�0°!�$ÿq®�ûMÿ��$ø�þ ÿ����øR±�0°�� ÿ� Kß�ú�ÿ#ß¾þ ÿ#÷��@²aþ�ú�²tþ%��²��9�$ø�þ ÿ$����0®$÷jß¿ú�²wøRý@²÷�ý�±Tø�þt²û¿û¾ûT²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®�þû³��øR±Ù±¿²���®�û¿®$ø�÷�ÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²tû� �ß¿ú�²�$ø�ù�²t±C��øR±�0°�� ÿ0®$û¾¯��$ø �lÿ$�o³ â¾ú�²±¿²���øR±¿²$ ��B��®���®���²���ß¿ú�®$û§¯ ��ø �lÿ��E��øR±�0°�� ÿ0®$÷Kß¿ø¶ß¿ú�²wßuù�ø,�$ø�þ ÿ$�T��øR±�%°!� ÿ�û

¬�8

Page 64: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

¯R®���²÷�®$÷S­ ®�¯R°�±¿² � ³^8�³â¾ú�²!¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�su®�÷�ß¿²±Tý�±¿²�ß�²��z��øR±�0°!� ÿ#ûY®$÷�­ ®�¯R°�±¿² � ³u¬0ø��:ß�ú�²!þÿ�û¿²!ûTß¿°!����ÿ�±T²!þ�ú�²þ%�#²��ή�÷SßuùÙøqûTß�²tý�ûµÍR³Fª:�����$ø�þ ÿ$����øR±�0°!� ÿ#û�ÿ�±T²¾þ�ú�²þ%�#²��jù!³Ä±³ ß ³�ß¿ú�²§øRý@²÷¶ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û�û¿²�jÿ#÷�ß¿®$þtû]ø��@±¿²���®�û¿®$ø�÷¶ÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²tû³J�u÷ß�ú�®�û_ùÙøR±�����þ�ú�²þ%��ß�ú�²t®$±_û�ÿ#ß¿®$û��>ÿ#þtß�®�øR÷�®$÷���øR±�jÿ$�����³³Ha÷�²K(ÿN�[ÿ�ý�ý!����ß¿ú�²�ß{��ý�®�þ ÿ��eqø���²��fÿ��$ûTø��øR±Ùß¿ú�²/��ø�þÿ��Àþÿ�û¿²$ �ú�ø�ùÙ²��R²t±� .��ø q®�ßTß�²��qß�ú�®�ûYûTß¿²ý; �û¿®$÷�þ²Mß¿ú�²/�$ø�þ ÿ$�Àý�±TøRý@²±Tß¿®$²tû�þ ÿ#÷O�À²a²ÿ�û¿®����þ�ú�²þ%�#²����@�ü±¿²¯Rÿ�±���®�÷�¯[ß¿ú�²qý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û0ý�±Tø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷�ût³�\[øR±T²øN�R²t±� �ß�ú�²(ß{��ý�®$þÿ��0(ø���²��Ùÿ#÷!�Çß¿ú�²ÿ�°�ß¿ø jÿ�ß�®$þ/��²±T®�§lþÿ#ß�®�øR÷[ø$�]ÿ¶¯R±�ÿ�ý�ú�su®�÷�ß¿²±Tý�±¿²�ß�²�����øR±�%°!� ÿD�@�[ÿ,qø���²���s þ�ú�²þ%�#²±2®$û§²�¥�ý!�$ÿ�®$÷�²��®$÷�ß�ú�²�÷�²�¥�ß_ûTß�²tý1³

t�³F�]ý�±¿øN��²aß�úlÿ#ßÙß�ú�²2û�ÿ#ß¿®$û��>ÿ�þtß¿®$øR÷(ø��8ß�ú�²p�$ø�þ ÿ��.��øR±�0°!�$ÿ�ûÙ®�÷�­ ®�¯R°�±¿² � ³_8.®�(ý!��®$²tû�ß¿ú�²aû¿ÿ#ß�®�û��>ÿ�þ�ß�®$ø�÷ø���ß¿ú�²(ß¿ú�²q¯ �$ø ��ÿ��a��øR±�%°!� ÿ�®$÷Ç­ ®�¯R°�±¿² � ³�¬�³�â¾ú�®$û�®$ûM��øR÷�²��@��q² ÿ#÷�û.ø$��ß�ú�²(ß{��ý�®$þÿ���¯R±�ÿ#ý�úß�±¿ÿ�÷�û¿®�ß�®�øR÷Îû���ûVß�²� ¯R®��R²t÷ü®�÷ü­ ®$¯R°�±¿² � ³�Í · ³%â¾ú�®$ûwûVß�²ýÇû¿ú�ø�ù§û.ÿ�ûaùÙ²���L 8ú�ø�ùrß¿ø�°�û¿²qÿO(ø���²��þ�ú�²þ%�#²±_ß�øqÿ�°�ß¿ø jÿ�ß�®$þÿ�����qþ�ú�²þ%��¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�s ®$÷Kß�²t±¿ý�±T²tß¿²��Sß�²�qý@øR±�ÿ��U��øR±�0°�� ÿ�ût³

¹q��¹;���;�ËÓ � ð�¡�£wv;�L�6+��6ð�¡ÎÒ�5q£  lÒZÎ 5�¢(�wÌ:Òµ .�â¾ú�²Qû�ÿ#ß¿®$û��>ÿ�þtß¿®$øR÷¼ø$��ß¿ú�²[�$ø�þ ÿ$�|��øR±�0°!�$ÿ�ûjþÿ�÷¦�À²Qþ�ú�²þ%��²�� ®�÷¼ß�ú�²Îø�ýÀ²t÷ ý�±¿ø�þ²ûTûSû¿²�(ÿ�÷Kß�®�þû+��ø�±±¿²���®�û¿®$ø�÷[ÿ#±¿þ�ú�®��R²û|�@��±¿²t¯Kÿ�±���®$÷�¯�ß¿ú�²!ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û§ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷�û§®$÷Kß�±Tø���°�þ²��[®�÷�k�úlÿ�ý�ß¿²±:t� �â�ÿ��!�$²Kt�³�ÍR³

Ø â¾ú�²#��ø�þÿ��;��øR±�0°!� ÿ¶ÿ#ߧ߿ú�²#�@ø�ß¿ß¿ø ø��]­ ®$¯R°�±¿² � ³�¬q®$û§û¿ÿ#ß�®�û�§l²��Îû¿®�÷�þ²!ß�ú�²t±¿²-��ø�²tûM÷�ø#ß2²6¥�®$ûTßaÿý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û2ý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®$ø�÷z��ø�±_±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷[ÿ�±Tþ�ú�®���²û2ß¿úlÿ#ß|��²��$²tß¿²û2ÿ(±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷[ÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²�øR±_ÿ���ø�þt°!q²÷Kß®$÷�ÿ#÷�ÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²#³�â¾ú�²±T²���øR±T²� �±T²���®$ûT®$øR÷Sÿ�±Tþ�ú�®���²û§ÿ�ûÙù�²���1ÿ#û³��ø�þ°!q²÷Kß�û�®$÷�ÿ�±Tþ�ú�®���²û§ÿ�±T²wÿ���ùYÿ���ûý�±¿²tû¿²t±��R²��1³

Ø â¾ú�²¡°�ý�ý@²±O��ø�þÿ��p��øR±�0°!�$ÿm®$÷ ­ ®�¯R°�±¿² � ³^8½±T²�¨�°�®�±¿²û�ß¿úlÿ#ß�ÿy��ø�þ°!q²÷KßS®$û�²��R²t÷�ß¿°lÿ������¼ý�°�ß®$÷�ß�ú�²0ý@øR±Vßaø���ÿ(±¿²���®�û¿®$ø�÷Qÿ�±¿þ�ú�®��R²0ÿ�÷!�αT²�(ÿ�®$÷�û§ß�ú�²±¿²#³wâ�øj²÷�ûT°�±¿²%ß¿ú�²ûT²�ý�±¿ø�ýÀ²t±Tß{����øR±MøR°�±��®$ûVß�±T®��°�ß¿²��!û���ûVß�²�� 6ù�²)÷�²²���ß¿ú�²�÷�ø�ß¿®$øR÷wø�� ètæ��*È6'�ã%�%� ®�÷aß�ú�²�ûT²÷�ûT²)ß¿úlÿ#ß:ÿ§ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿ûfý�±¿ø���°�þ�ß�®�øR÷ß�úlÿ�ßÙþÿ�÷,�À²2ÿ�ý�ý!��®$²��q®�û�÷�ø�ß)®$÷�§�÷�®�ß¿²����.ø��*ß¿²÷+��²�� ÿ���²��1³]â¾ú�®�û�þ ÿ�÷��À²_ÿ#ßTß�ÿ�®�÷�²����@�¶ß�ÿ���®$÷�¯�ø�÷!���ß�ú�ø�û¿²�±¿°�÷�û2®$÷Kß�ø¶ß�ú�².¯R±¿ÿ�ý�ú�ß�±�ÿ#÷�û¿®�ß�®$ø�÷�û���ûTß�²� ß¿úlÿ#ß_û�ÿ�ß�®$û��1��ß�ú�²M�>ÿ�®�±¿÷�²tû¿û_þøR÷�ûVß�±¿ÿ�®$÷Kß ³�â¾ú�²÷ß�ú�²+�$ø�þ ÿ��J��øR±�0°!� ÿS®$û.û�ÿ#ß¿®$û�§l²��JûT®$÷�þt²jß�ú�²(ý�±¿ø�þ²tû¿û�ý�±Tø���°�þtß¿®$øR÷���  Ë&¡�¢S£�¤�¥  o¦�÷�§�¦©¨�ª¬«y­+t�®�ÍY®þ ÿ�÷���­sª�ûy­��(ß�ø!ý¬ª�ß{­ ÿ�þ�ú���ø�þaª!>­÷Kß{¦$÷�ß�úY­_ý@ø|«V߯®J��¦$÷�þa­C�^��ø!÷�ø�ß�ú�ÿN��­2ýY«¿ø�þq­ûTûÙýY«¿ø��¬ª�þtßy¦$øR÷�û��ø|«Mß¿ú¬­��¬­���­tß�¦�øR÷Qø��i��ø�þqª!>­÷Kß�û�¦�÷QýÀø|«Vß�ûwø��)ß{��ý°­,Vc±w²�³VÖa×# 1ß¿ú¬­D��ø�þqª!>­÷Kßc«y­�jÿ´¦$÷�ûMß¿ú¬­q«µ­ÿ���ù�ÿ���ûq®

Ø â�ø?­÷�ûµª¬«y­�ß�ú¬­�û�ÿ�ß�¦$û��>ÿ�þtßy¦$øR÷�ø���ß�ú¬­K�$ø�þ ÿ��;��ø�«�Fª!�$ÿ¶ÿ#ߧß�ú¬­K�Àø#ß¿ß�ø� ø�� ß¿ú¬­N§f¦©¨|ª¬«µ­ � ®^8��Y÷¬­a­��ÿ�¨Kÿ�¦�÷G�>ÿ�¦�«¿÷¬­tû¿ûa®¬ö2÷!�¬­a«jß�úY¦$û�ÿ#û¿ûyª�(ý�ßy¦$øR÷T ¾ú�ø�ù ­��|­q«� �¦�ß?¦$û?­ ÿ�û�� ß¿ø½ûy­a­Îß�úlÿ#ß(ß�ú¬­ ý¬«¿ø�þq­tû¿ûý¬«¿ø��¬ª�þ�ß�¦�øR÷ ¢¯¶�·&¸ � ¥ ¦$÷l§�¦©¨�ª¬«y­Mt�®�¹�U¦�û§ÿ���ù�ÿ���û_ÿ�ý�ý!�©¦�þ ÿ��!��­�®

ºq��º;���;�� � ð�¡�£wv;�L�6+��6ð�¡/+�»�5&¼< ½»ZÎ 5�¢(�wÌi»µ �¾þ�ú¬­þ%�[÷�ø�ù ß�ú¬­�¨ �$ø ��ÿ��;��ø|«�Nª!� ÿ�¦$÷/§�¦©¨¬® � ®u¬�ùs¦�ß�ú�ø|ª�ß2þøR÷�ûVß�«µª�þtßy¦$÷¬¨�ÿ>¨ �$ø��lÿ��fûTß�ÿ#ß�­´®p�Y÷Y­q­��Qø�÷!���ß�ú¬­Îû¿ÿ#ß�¦�û��>ÿ�þ�ß�¦�øR÷¼ø��!ß�úY­=�$ø�þ ÿ��F��ø|«�Fª!� ÿ#û<¦$÷D§�¦©¨¬® � ®_8½ÿ�÷!�ôß¿ú¬­ ß{��ý¬¦$þÿ��:qø��¬­��m¦$÷K§�¦�¨¬® � ®�¹ · « þ��¾®â¾ú¬­ø|«µ­� ¬�® � ®¿¹Nc@­�®¦�%þ�ú¬­þ%�Oß�ú¬­l¨ �$ø��lÿ��³��ø|«�Fª!� ÿP�@� ?­ÿ�÷�ûqø��aß�úY­nqø��Y­��§þ�ú¬­þ%�´­q«lÀ��mÁNV « ûµ­q­_l\ ÿ#÷.c�x d ­_ß�ú�ÿ#ß�¨|­tß¿û!ÿjß�«¿ÿ�÷�ûy¦�ß�¦�øR÷Îû���ûVß�­� ÿ#÷!�üÿjß�­�qý@ø|«�ÿ�����ø|«�Fª!� ÿjÿ�ûQ¦$÷�ýYª�߯®K� ß�ÿ�÷�ûVù ­a«¿ûÃÂ��|­tûyĦ��¾ß�úY­�ß�«�ÿ#÷�ûy¦�ß�¦$ø�÷mû���ûVß�­� û�ÿ#ßy¦$û�§¬­û0ß�úY­�ß�­�qý@ø|«�ÿ��0��ø|«�Fª!� ÿ� �¨|¦���­û�ÿÎþtø|ª�÷Kß�­a«y­6¥�ÿ$(ý!��­�ø�ß�úY­q«Tùs¦�ûy­´®��¦$÷�þa­aß�ú¬­wßy«�ÿ�÷�ûµ¦�ßy¦$øR÷�û���ûVß�­��¦�÷Z§�¦©¨Y® � ®¿¹ · ¦$û³§l÷Y¦�ß�­$ �ß�úY­Kqø��¬­�� suþ�ú¬­tþ%��­q«§ß�­a«�>¦$÷lÿ�ß�­ûa®a�u÷ç�¦©¨¬® � ®¿¹|¹�%úlÿ��|­�û¿ú�ø6ù§÷òß�ú¬­z(ÿ�¦$÷Jùs¦$÷���ø�ù ø��2ß�ú¬­zqø��¬­���s þ�ú¬­þ%�´­q«q®Å§�¦©¨�ª¬«y­ � ®¿¹YtÎû¿ú�ø6ù§û « ÿ¡ýlÿ�«Vß(ø$�%­.ß¿ú¬­

¬ ®

Page 65: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

§�¦©¨�ª¬«y­ � ®�¹|¹�Æ .;�lã!çjå���ã�Çjf��%�lã%�2zKã�È À��mÁNV �É «�ÿ#÷�ûy¦ É ¦$ø�÷½û���û É ­�l®�ª ÉÉ ú¬­ É ø�ýJø�� É ú¬­Oqø��Y­���þ�úY­þ%��­a« É ú¬­ É ­�(ý@ø|«¿ÿ��Z��ø�«�Fª!�$ÿæ�û0û¿ú�ø�ù§÷�®mâ¾ú¬­ÿ�û¿ûµ¦©¨R÷!>­÷ É û T Õ�Ê ����� Ê Tq�Yø�� É ú¬­m¨|«�ÿ�ý�ú�s˦�÷ É ­q«Tý¬«y­ É ­�����ø|«�Fª�� ÿ�ûÙÿ�«y­_÷�ø É ¦$÷�ûµ­q« É ­���ÿ�ûB�¬¦�û É «y¦�Yª É ­��W¨|«�ÿ#ý�ú(ø|«Tý�ú¬¦�û�qû<�¬ª É ÿ�«y­V«y­tý¬«y­tûy­÷ É ­��,�7� É ú¬­i��ÿ´«y¦ ÿ$�!�©­tûfT�¹ Ê ����� Ê T´8Y®:â¾ú¬­Yû É ÿ É ­tû]ø�� É úY­ É «¿ÿ�÷�ûy¦ É ¦�øR÷%û���û É ­�¦$÷Z§�¦�¨|ª¬«y­ � ®�¹ · ÿ�«y­Q«µ­ý¬«µ­ûy­t÷ É ­��n�@� É ú¬­wûµ­ É û_ø$�e�#ÿ�«µ¦ ÿ����©­ûB�¬­ý¬¦�þ É ­��S÷¬­�¥ ÉsÉ ø É ú¬­�¨|«�ÿ#ý�ú¬¦$þÿ��@û É ÿ É ­ûa®â¾ú¬­(÷�ø É ÿ É ¦$øR÷�TwÌ#Í�¹�>­ ÿ�÷�û É úlÿ É�É ú¬­(ÿ É ø ?¦�þ#��ø|«�Fª!� ÿWTwÌC��ø|«�Ì#Í�¹ �����^8Z¦$ûwû¿ÿ É ¦�û�§½­���¦$÷üÿSû É ÿ É ­´®§Dø�«�­�¥�ÿ�qý!��­� É ú¬­«y­tý¬«y­tûy­÷ É ÿ É ¦�øR÷Qø�� É ú¬­¨�«�ÿ�ý�úY¦$þ ÿ$��û É ÿ É ­T�¹ Ê T t?¦�÷�§�¦�¨|ª¬«y­ � ®¿¹ · ¦$û�T�¹NÍ�T t>Íιÿ�÷!��T � Í�T(xoÍ�T�¬�Í�T´8�Í · ®�Ͼú¬­r¦�÷ É ­÷��¬­��y>­ ÿ�÷Y¦$÷¬¨Îø$� É ú¬­8��ø|«�Fª!�$ÿ[û¿ú�ø6ù§÷Ц�÷ É ú¬­+(ø��¬­��þ�ú¬­þ%�´­q«N¦�û É úlÿ É ù§úY­÷¬­��|­q« É ú¬­���ø�þÿ��<��ø|«�Fª!�$ÿ�ûwÿ ÉQÉ ú¬­ É øRý¡ø�� É ú¬­�§�¦�¨|ª¬«µ­ � ®u¬�ÿ�÷��n¦�÷�§�¦©¨|ªY«y­ � ®_8ÿ�«y­.û�ÿ É ¦$û�§¬­�� É ú¬­÷ É ú¬­N¨��$ø �lÿ$����ø�«�Fª!�$ÿ>¦�û2û¿ÿ É ¦�û�§½­���®|ªMý�ý!����¦$÷¬¨ É ú¬­-(ø��¬­�� suþ�ú¬­tþ%��­a«�«y­tûyª!� É û�¦�÷ É ú¬­ÿ�÷�ûTùV­q«>¦$÷Чf¦©¨|ª¬«µ­ � ®¿¹ � ÆWϾú¬­O��ø|«�Fª!�$ÿÎþø|ª!�����°­�ûµª�þþa­û¿û��,ª!���� þ�ú¬­þ%�´­���®kϾú¬­q«µ­���ø|«µ­� É ú¬­Z¨ ��ø �lÿ����ø|«�Fª�� ÿA¦$û¶û¿ÿ É ¦�û�§½­�� « ÿ#þþø�«��¬¦�÷¬¨ É ønϾúY­ø|«µ­� ¬�® � ®¿¹Nc@­� �¦Ñ®Ò­�®[­ÿ�þ�ú���ø�þqª�?­t÷ É ¦�÷òø|ªY«,�Y¦$û É «y¦��¬ª É ­��û���û É ­�Ó¦$ûs­��|­÷ É ªlÿ�����r«y­tý!�©¦�þ ÿ É ­�� É øjÿ«y­�(ø É ­!ÿ�«Tþ�ú¬¦���­�®

¬�U

Page 66: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

§�¦©¨�ª¬«y­ � ®¿¹Yt�Æ .;�½Ô"*�ÈTæ�'����1*��ÑÕ('9��&Y��*ËÔ�Ö×ÕÌèM*1�½ÔD�yØ(��Ô/��*L����&��

¬�c

Page 67: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

§�¦©¨|ªY«y­ � ®�¹ � Æ .;�½Ô>Õ(��*]ÙE��*mØTè6*¾Ô�È��%�½Ô%�2z(�1'�~8*1�½ÔYè¯ÕwÈÚÖD��Ç¿Ø%Û#*µ�½ÔFÖ<Õ���Ô�Çjf��%�½Ô%�2z%Ô�È À��mÁNV È�Ô%�ËÙ½Õ('E��Ô��ZÜ�&Ý Á�Þ �

8 ·

Page 68: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

â ã äæå ç�èêé ß

��5û� õ��à� î� MïzûDð�íÛþ#ðS��ó ��ñá� ð� /þ-û�ð����vþMî[ö ú û�õ2íÏø� û�õyóâ Kñ���û� õwþ#ð%�¦ó ð�ó þ#øÝî ì°ð�óÛôD�7î ã �â Køä�D�Ýþå íÿíÏû��5õ2ï,ø

ÏI欦©ç>è2æ½é�ê É ­q«>¦©ç>èqë|ìYèq­q«µì¬­qíkîs¦ É æ É æY­lï,ë|«µð<é´ñIí¬­qçµèq«y¦�ê É ¦�ë|ìhë�ï É æ¬­Ã給©ì¬¨�ñ©­Zꬪ¬çµæ¬ë|ª É é�ê¬ê¬«µë%é�è2æ É ëí¬¦©ç É «y¦�ò¬ª É ­qíh¨|«�é�êYæ É «yé�ì¬çóï,ë|«yð?é É ¦�ë|ì�®hô�¦©ç É «µ¦©ò¬ª É ­qíh¨|«�é´ê¬æ¬ç?é�«y­Zò½é�çµ­qíDë�ì Ö<Õqõ�Ô�Ç�� ¦©ìkéoèqé É ­a¨|ë|«µö�<÷ É æ½é É é�«µ­ É ë É é´ñ[¨|«�é�êYænð>ë|«yêY欦©çµð?çQ«µ­�§½ì¬¦�쬨ÃéZ¨�«�é�ê¬æoò%ö�ë|ò�øµ­aè É ç�ë�ï É æ¬­�è¯é É ­q¨|ë�«µö � é�ìYí É æ¬­­qí¬¨|­açQò%ö ��ù ð>ë|«yêY欦©çµð?ça®�ús¦©ì%û|­aç É ¦©¨%é É ­ É æY­è¯é É ­q¨|ë|«óö/ë´ï{ð?ë�í¬­qñ�ç�é�ìYí�ê½é�« É ¦üé�ñið>ë�í¬­añfð>ë|«µê¬æ¬¦©çµð?çé�ì¬íZꬫyë�û�¦©íY­Q­�¥�¦©ç É ­qìYèq­�èqë|ìYí¬¦ É ¦©ë|ì¬çVï,ë|«Iꬪ¬çµæ¬ë|ª É ç#¦�ì É æ¬¦�ç*è¯é É ­q¨�ë|«µö�®B��¦©ì¬èa­Qí¬¦©ç É «y¦�ò¬ª É ­qír¨|«yé�ê¬æ¬çsé�«µ­í¬­�§½ìY­qíAò%öÃð?ë�í¬­qñ�çIîs¦ É æÃé�ì/é�í¬í¬¦ É ¦©ë�ì½é�ñ É ö�ê°­�¦©ìYï,ë�«yð?é É ¦�ë|ì ÷ É æ¬­qçµ­F«y­açyª¬ñ É çmé�«y­cª¬çµ­qí É ë?í¬­�§¬ì¬­ É æ¬­É «�é´ì¬çµï,ë|«µð<é É ¦©ë�ìWë�ïfí¬¦©ç É «y¦�ò¬ª É ­qíl¨|«�é�êYæ¬çI¦©ì É æY­c給©ì¬¨�ñ©­ ù ꬪ¬çµæ¬ë|ª É é�êYꬫyë%é´è2æ�®úýèqë|ì¬çµ¦©í¬­a«�émí¬¦©ç É «y¦�ò¬ª É ­qíNçóö�ç É ­aðþèaë|ì¬çµ¦©ç É ¦©ì¬¨më�ï½èaë|ì¬èqªY«y«y­aì É ê¬«yë�èq­açyçµ­qç[èqë�ð?ðFªY쬦©èqé É ¦�쬨së�û�­q«�çµæ½é�«µ­qíê°ë|« É ça®[ÏI欭 õ�ÿ���-ÈÚÿ-Ü����ËÔyõ����N���¾Ô�Ö �ËÙ½Ô���ÿ ��yØ�-ÿÑÕ�� èqë|ìYçy¦©ç É çsë�ï�é ��Ô��� ÕwÈ�z����ÚÙ½Ô���ȵØ�Ù.� ÷ é Ù�È�Õ��2Ô%�%����ȵØ�Ö��Ö>Ø�È é�ìYí�é ��Ø�Ö<ÔB�ËÙYØ��2Ô ï,ë|«f­¯é�è2æ�ꬫµë�èa­qçyç É ö�ê�­I¦©ì É æ¬­*쬭 É î ë|«�� É ö�ê°­I¨�«�é�ê¬æ�é´ì¬í�é �������%��È�Õ��½ÿ���Ø�-ÿÑÕ��È2Ô�Ç¿Ø�-ÿÑÕ�� ®+ª�ꬫµë�èa­qçyç�¨|«�é´ð?ð?é�«Qꬫµë�û�¦�í¬­qç�éÃçµ­ É ë�ï Ù�È�Õ��2Ô%�%��Ù�È�Õqõ�����-ÿÑÕ���� é´ì¬í�é ��� Ø�È���Ù�È�Õqõ� ����ÿÑÕ�� ®ÏI欭�ꬫµë�èa­qçµç*ꬫyë�í¬ª¬è É ¦�ë|ì¬ç�çyê�­qèq¦¿ï�ö É æ¬­mê°ë|çµçy¦�ò¬ñ©­mé�è É ¦©ë|ìYçVë�ï É æ¬­mꬫyë�èq­açyçIé�ìYí É æ¬­mç É é�« É ê¬«yë�í¬ª¬è É ¦�ë|ìç É é´« É ç É æ¬­�ꬫyë�èq­açyça®V§½«µë|ð É æ¬­�û�¦©­aîsê�ë|¦�ì É ë´ïfë�ò�øµ­qè É ù ë�«y¦©­aì É ­qílð>ë�í¬­añ©¦�쬨 ÷ éꬫyë�èq­açyçs¨|«�é´ð?ð?é�« èqé�ìò°­�çy­a­qì�é´ç�é�èqñ©é�çyça®!{é�è2æ/¦�ì¬ç É é�ì¬èa­�ë�ï�é?êY«yë�èq­qçµçm¨�«�é�ð>ð<é´«*¨|­ É ç É æ¬­/µꬫyë�¨|«�é�ð>Äçyê�­qèa¦�§½­aí/¦�ì É æ¬­ê¬«yë�èq­açyç�¨�«�é�ð>ð<é´«q®[ÏI欭 ��Ø�Ö<Ô/�ËÙYØ��2Ô ê¬«µë�û�¦�í¬­qç É æY­�¦�í¬­qì É ¦�§½­q«Iï,ë|« É æ¬­�êY«yë�èq­qçµçm¦�ì¬ç É é�ì¬èa­qçmï,ë�«#­qé�è2æꬫyë�èq­açyç É ö�ê°­´®�ÏI欭Fçµö�ì¬è2æY«yë|쬦��¯é É ¦©ë|ì�«µ­qñ©é É ¦�ë|ì/í¬­ É ­a«yð>¦©ì¬­aç�îs欦©è2æ�êY«yë�èq­qçµçQꬫyë�í¬ª¬è É ¦�ë|ì¬ç�ë�ï[îsæY¦©è2æꬫyë�èq­açyçs¦©ì¬ç É é�ìYèq­qçIæ¬é�û�­ É ë�ò°­�çµö�ì¬è2欫µë|쬦�a­qí/é�ì¬íZë�û|­q«*îsæY¦©è2ælí½é É éFçóö�ì¬è2欫yë�쬦�qé É ¦�ë|ì É é�´­qçsê¬ñüé´èq­�®ú í¬­�§½ì¬­ É æ¬­�çy­að<é´ì É ¦©èaç#ë´ï[éí¬¦©ç É «µ¦©ò¬ª É ­qílçµö�ç É ­qðàçyê�­qèa¦�§½èqé É ¦�ë|ìZò%ö ��ȵØ���#"¯ÕwÈÚÖ>Ø��ÿÑÕ������Y���ËÔ�Ö#� ÷ É æ½é Éé�«y­�¦©ì É «µë�í¬ªYèq­qí�¦�ì%$ �'&)(*(�+ ®�Ïi«�é�ìYçµï,ë|«µð<é É ¦©ë|ìlçµö�ç É ­qð>ç�é�«µ­é<èqë�ð?ð>ë|ì/çµ­qð?é�ì É ¦�è¯é�ñ6ï,«�é�ð>­aîVë|«��l¦�ìîs欦©è2æ�çyê�­qèa¦�§½èqé É ¦�ë|ì É ­aè2æ¬ì¬¦¨Sª¬­aç�èqé�ì�ò°­�¦�ì É ­q«µê¬«y­ É ­qí�®Fú�çµæ¬ë�î É æY­¦©ì É ­a«yꬫµ­ É é É ¦©ë�ì�ë�ï íY¦©ç É «y¦�ò¬ª É ­aí¨|«�é�êYæ É «yé�ì¬çóï,ë|«yð?é É ¦�ë|ìZ¦©ì É ë É æ¬¦�ç#ï,«yé�ð>­aîVë|«,�&®sÏI欦©ç#­qì¬é�ò¬ñ©­aç É ë<ª¬çµ­ É æY­N«y­açyª¬ñ É ç#ï,ë|« É æ¬­cèqë|ð>ê°ë�çy¦ ùÉ ¦©ë�ì?ë�ï É «�é´ì¬çµï,ë|«µð<é É ¦©ë�ì?çóö�ç É ­að?ç É ëFçµê°­aèq¦�ï�ö>é�èqë|ð>ê°ë�çy¦ É ¦©ë|ì¬é�ñ¬çy­að<é´ì É ¦©èaçVë�ïýé�í¬¦�ç É «µ¦©ò¬ª É ­qí?çµö�ç É ­qðl®ÏI欭míY¦©ç É «y¦�ò¬ª É ­aí<çµ­qð?é�ì É ¦©èaç[ï,ë|«�é�í¬¦�ç É «µ¦©ò¬ª É ­qí>çµö�ç É ­qð çµê°­aèq¦�§¬è¯é É ¦©ë|ì?¦©ç{èqë|ð>ê�ë|çy­aí>ï,«µë|ð É æ¬­ É «yé�ì¬ç ùï,ë|«yð?é É ¦�ë|ì<çóö�ç É ­að?çIï,ë|« É æ¬­Q給©ì¬¨|ñ�­�ꬫµë�èa­qçyçI¦�ì¬ç É é�ì¬èa­qç ÷ èqé�ñ©ñ�­qí Õ2Ù½Ô��>Ù�È2Õ��2Ô%�%�p��Ô�Ö>Ø� ��ÿ-�%� ®�ÏI欭Që|ê�­qìꬫyë�èq­açyç�çy­qð?é�ì É ¦�èqç{ë�ï�écêY«yë�èq­qçµçV¦�ì¬ç É é�ì¬èa­#¦�ì¬èqñ�ª¬í¬­aç É æ¬­sò°­aæ½é¯û�¦©ë|«{ë�ï�éQꬫyë�èq­açyç ¦�ì¬ç É é�ì¬èa­#¨�­q쬭a«�é É ­qíòSö É æ¬­Qꬫµë�èa­qçµç#êY«yë�í¬ª¬è É ¦©ë|ìYçIë�ï É æ¬­Qèaë|«y«µ­qçyê�ë|ì¬íY¦©ì¬¨�ꬫµë�èa­qçyçs¨|«yé�ð>ð<é�« é�ì¬ílé�ñ�ñ�ê�ë|çy給©ò¬ñ�­�­/.°­qè É çsë�ïÉ æ¬­�­qì%û�¦©«µë|ì¬ð>­qì É ë|ìoê°ë�« É ça®ÏI欭�èqë|ð>ê�ë|çy¦ É ¦©ë�ìAë�ï É æ¬­ É «yé�ì¬çóï,ë|«yð?é É ¦�ë|ìAçóö�ç É ­að?ç�ï,ë|« É æ¬­�ꬫyë�èq­açy禩ì¬ç É é�ì¬èa­qç[¦�ç�¦©ìYí¬ª¬èq­aíò%ö É æY­*çµö�ì¬è2欫µë|쬦��¯é É ¦©ë|쫵­qñüé É ¦©ë�ì�®fÏIæY¦©ç�«µ­qñüé É ¦©ë�ìNí¬­ É ­q«µð?¦�쬭qç�æ¬ë�î É æ¬­ É «yé�ì¬ç ùï,ë|«yð?é É ¦�ë|ìlçµö�ç É ­qð>ç�é´«y­Fèaë|ì¬ì¬­aè É ­aí�®cúmèaë|ð?ê¬é�«y­ É æ¬­èaë|ð?ê�ë|給 É ¦�ë|ì½é�ñýë�ê°­a«�é É ¦©ë|ì½é´ñfçµ­qð?é�ì É ¦©èaç�îs¦ É æÉ æ¬­ ��Ç©Õ�Ü2Ø�ÇfÕ2Ù½Ô�ȵØ�-ÿÑÕ���Ø�ÇU��Ô�Ö>Ø� ��ÿ-�%� ¨|­a쬭q«yé É ­aí/ò%ö É æ¬­cé�ê¬ê¬ñ�¦©è¯é É ¦©ë�ìWë�ï�é�ð<é´ñ©¨%é�ð?é É ­qíWꬫµë�íYª¬è É ¦©ë|ì¬ça®

úQç É é´« É ò%ö�é�ì�¦�ì É «yë�í¬ª¬è É ¦©ë�ì É ë É ö�ê�­qí�¨�«�é�ê¬æ É «�é´ì¬çµï,ë|«µð<é É ¦©ë�ì ÷ çy¦©ìYèq­ É ö�ê�­qí�¨|«yé�ê¬æ¬çé´«y­<ªYçy­qí É ëð?ë�í¬­qñ É æ¬­�í¬¦�.�­a«y­qì É ê¬«µë�èa­qçyç É ö�ê�­qç#ë�ï�é�í¬¦�ç É «µ¦©ò¬ª É ­qíZçóö�ç É ­aðÓñüé É ­q«Ië|ì�®

8Y¹

Page 69: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

\e��0 1�2 �J¡�Í � ¢Y !�43 1 ¢( !�<��Î-5E¢(�g ��Y��5E�ª ��ȵØ�Ù.� Ñ Í « Ñ'6[Ê%Ñ87�Ê Þ�9 Ê ³:9q­Fèaë|ì¬çy¦�ç É ç>ë´ïQé�çy­ É ë�ï�ì¬ë�í¬­qç Ñ;6 ÷ éoçµ­ É ë�ïm­qí¬¨|­aç Ñ87 é´ì¬í É îVëð<é�êYꬦ©ì¬¨�ç�Þ�9ÐÆ Ñ'7 3 Ñ'6 é�ì¬íA³:9ÐÆ Ñ'7 3 Ñ;6 ®�ÏI欭 ��Õ���È<�2ÔFÖ>Ø�Ù%Ù�ÿ=��� Þ>9�¦�ì¬í¬¦�è¯é É ­qç É æ¬­Nçµë|ª¬«µèq­ì¬ë�íY­ë�ïVé�ì�­qí¬¨�­ ÷ É æY­ � Ø�È���Ô��sÖ>Ø�Ù%Ù�ÿ=��� ³:9�¦ É ç É é�«µ¨|­ É ìYë�í¬­´®?![í¬¨|­açcÁ�ë´ï ér¨|«yé�ê¬æ Ñ îs¦ É æ�çµë|ª¬«µèq­ì¬ë�íY­lÞ>9 « ÁY­�Í Ì�é�ì¬í É é´«y¨|­ É ì¬ë�í¬­W³:9 « ÁY­>ÍA@né�«y­rë�ï É ­qì�«µ­qꬫµ­qçy­aì É ­qíÅòSö�Á�Æ[ÌN3 @½®CBêYñ É ¦�ê¬ñ©­­qí¬¨|­aç*ò�­ É îV­q­qì É îVëFì¬ë�í¬­qç*é�«y­#ê°ë�çyçy¦�ò¬ñ©­mò%ö É æ¬¦©çVí¬­�§¬ì¬¦ É ¦©ë|ì�®<ª �ËÕ�� Ø�ÇD��ȵØ�Ù.�<Ö<ÕwÈ Ù.��ÿ��Ö 0 Æ Ñ 3 Óò°­ É î ­a­qì�¨�«�é�ê¬æYç Ñ Í « Ñ'6�Ê%Ñ'7[Ê Þ>9 Ê ³:9q­�é�ìYígÓ Í « Ó 6[Ê Ó 7�Ê Þ>E Ê ³:Ei­�¦©ç�érê½é�¦�« « 0�6[ÊÚ0�7 ­�ë´ï É ë É é�ñð<é�êYꬦ©ì¬¨�ç 0�6 Æ Ñ'6 3 Ó 6 ò�­ É îV­q­aì É æ¬­çy­ É ë�ï�ì¬ë�íY­qç�é�ì¬í 0>7 Æ Ñ'7 3 Ó 7 ò�­ É îV­q­aì É æ¬­çy­ É ë�ï­qí¬¨|­aç ÷ çyª¬è2æ É æ½é É 0 ë|ò�­aö�ç É æ¬­c¨|«�é�êYæÃç É «yªYè É ªY«y­ ÷ ¦Ñ®Ò­�® 0�6GF Þ 9 ÍÞ E F�0>7 é�ìYí 0�6GF ³ 9 Í ³ E F�0�7 ®ª ÙYØ�È���ÿ-Ø�ÇH��ȵØ�Ù.��Ö<ÕwÈ Ù.��ÿ��Ö 0 Æ ÑJI Ó ¦�çFé É ë É é�ñV¨|«�é´ê¬æ�ð>ë|«yê¬æY¦©çyð K0 ÆMLS± × « 0 ­N3 Ó ï,«yë|ðéÃçyªYò¬¨|«�é´ê¬æCLS± × « 0 ­?N Ñ É ë=Ó�®POfé�« É ¦üé�ñ[¨�«�é�ê¬ænð?ë�«yê¬æ¬¦�çyð>çcé�«y­>ë�ï É ­aì�«µ­qꬫµ­qçy­aì É ­qíÐò%önéÃçµê½é�ì$ Ì-Q�ÆRLS± × « 0 ­MS 3 Ñ�Ê K0 ÆRLS± × « 0 ­[3 Ó + ®

T ¡VU^�<�1�Y�#5E� \���0���0CW £  ��N¡S+�5E¢ 2K� ¢Y !�43� .�eÍ � ¢Y !�43YX[Zª�ñ©ñY¨|«�é�êYæ¬ç�é�ì¬í?é�ñ©ñ�ê½é�« É ¦üé�ñY¨|«�é�êYæ>ð>ë|«µê¬æ¬¦©çµð?çfï,ë|«yð éQèqé É ­a¨|ë|«µö � ¢Y !�43YX ®��n­sí¬­qì¬ë É ­sò%ö � ¢Y !�43É æ¬­�çyªYò°èqé É ­a¨|ë|«µöWë�ï � ¢Y !�H3 X îs欭a«y­�¨|«yé�ê¬ælð?ë|«µê¬æ¬¦�çyð>çIé�«y­ É ë É é�ñ�® \

ÏI欭?èqé É ­a¨|ë|«óö � ¢Y !�43YX æ½é�ç�ò�­q­qìoç É ª¬í¬¦�­qío¦©ì É æ¬­>é�ñ�¨|­qòY«�é�¦�èFçy¦�쬨|ñ©­êYª¬çyæ¬ë�ª É é�ê¬ê¬«µë%é�è2æ]$ �_^ë�î ( � +é�ì¬íŦ�ç?èaë|ð>ê¬ñ©­ É ­lé�ì¬íDèaë ù èaë|ð>ê¬ñ©­ É ­�®Åú É ç>çyª¬ò�è¯é É ­q¨|ë�«µö � ¢Y !�43 ¦�ç`�Sì¬ë�îsì É ë�ò�­Ãèaë|ð?êYñ©­ É ­lé�ì¬íèqë ù èqë|ð>ê¬ñ©­ É ­Qé´çsîV­qñ�ñÑ®

amë�í¬­qç�é�ì¬íN­aí¬¨|­aç�ë�ï&é#¨|«�é�êYæNè¯é´ìFò°­�­�¨Sª¬¦�ê¬ê�­qíFò%ö�ñüé�ò�­qñ�ç6ï,ë�«ièqé�«y«óö�¦©ì¬¨#ï,ª¬« É æ¬­q«�é�ê¬ê¬ñ�¦©è¯é É ¦©ë�ìcçµê°­aèq¦�§½è¦©ìYï,ë|«µð<é É ¦©ë�ì�®i�ié´ò°­añ©¦©ìY¨cèqé�ì<ò�­#ꬫyë�û�¦©í¬­aí<ò%ö?écçµê°­aèq¦©é�ñ&ñüé�ò�­qñ½çµ­ É é�ì¬í<ñ©é�ò�­qñ©¦�쬨Qð?é�ê¬ê¬¦�쬨|ç[ï,ë|«{ì¬ë�í¬­é�ì¬í­qíY¨|­*çy­ É ç ÷ É æ½é É é�çy給©¨|ì�é�ñ©é�ò�­qñ É ëQ­¯é´è2æë�ï É æ¬­*ìYë�í¬­aç[é�ì¬í É ëQ­¯é�è2æë´ï É æ¬­*­aí¬¨|­qç[ë´ï�é�¨|«�é�êYæ « çµ­q­è2æ½é�ê É ­q«`$b!���c8d ( ® + ¦�ì%$ & ë � ( ® + ­�®Kª ð?ë�«y­Nê�ë�î ­a«µï,ª¬ñ[èaë|ì¬èa­qê É ï,ë|«�ñüé�ò�­qñ�¦©ì¬¨<é�«y­ ���2Ù½Ô;��ȵØ�Ù.�@� ÷ É æ½é Éè¯é�ì�ò�­Wª¬ì¬íY­q«yç É ë�ë�íÐé´çée�S¦©ì¬í�ë�ïs­aì É ¦ É ögf´«µ­qñ©é É ¦�ë|ì¬çyæY¦©ê�í¬¦©é�¨|«yé�𠦩ì�èaë|ì¬èa­qê É ª½é�ñ*í½é É éAð>ë�í¬­añ©¦�쬨¬®h ë|ð?ê¬é�«y­aí<îs¦ É æWñüé�ò�­qñ�¦©ì¬¨�ð?é�ê¬ê¬¦�쬨|ç ÷ ���ÚÙ½Ôyõ'��ȵØ�Ù.�i�-ȵØ���#"¯ÕwÈÚÖ>Ø��ÿÑÕ�� $ h !{�jO ( 8 + æ½é´ç É æ¬­�é�íYû´é�ì É é´¨|­É ë�ò�­Wç É «yª¬è É ª¬«µ­qíЦ©ì É æ¬­Wçy­aì¬çy­ É æ½é ÉFÉ ö�ê�­qçí¬¦�ç É ¦�쬨|ª¬¦�çyæ�ò�­ É îV­q­aìhû�­q« É ¦©èa­qç�é�ìYíh­aí¬¨|­aç�é�ì¬í�­qíY¨|­É ö�ê�­qçIêY«y­qçµèq«µ¦©ò�­�çyë|ªY«yèq­�é´ì¬í É é´«y¨|­ É É ö�ê°­aç*ï,ë|« É æ¬­�çµë|ª¬«yèa­�é�ì¬í É é�«y¨|­ É û�­q« É ¦©èa­qçIë�ï É æ¬­�¦©ìYç É é´ì¬èq­aç*ë�ïÉ æ¬­�­qí¬¨|­ É ö�ê°­´®mÏI欭 É ö�ê°­F¦�ìYï,ë|«µð<é É ¦©ë|ìr¦�çm«µ­qꬫµ­qçµ­qì É ­aío¦�ìAé�§�¥�­qí�¨|«yé�ê¬æÃ� Ñ ÷ èqé�ñ©ñ�­qí ���2Ù½Ôk��ÈyØ�Ù.� ®ÏI欭 É ö�ꬦ�쬨<ë�ï[é?¨|«yé�ê¬æ Ñ ¦©ìZ� Ñ ¦©ç#¨|¦�û�­qìAò%öÃé É ë É é�ñ6¨|«yé�ê¬æÃð?ë|«µê¬æ¬¦�çyðγ 9 Æ Ñ 3 � Ñ ®*�n­Nèqé�ñ©ñ³ 9 é ���2Ù½ÔyõP��ÈyØ�Ù.�oÿ=� � Ñ ®?ú ïsé É ö�ê�­?¨�«�é�ê¬æn¦©ç"§�¥�­qí�é�ì¬í�ìYëÃèaë|ìYï,ª¬çµ¦©ë|ìn¦©ç�ê°ë�çyçy¦�ò¬ñ©­ ÷ î ­?«y­aï,­a« É ëé É ö�ê�­qí�¨�«�é�ê¬æ�³ 9 Æ Ñ 3 � Ñ çµ¦©ð>ê¬ñ�öÃò%ö Ñ é´ì¬ínçyé¯ö Ñ ¦�ç�é É ö�ê�­qí�¨�«�é�ê¬æo¦©ì�� Ñ ®?ÏI欭?¨|«�é´ê¬æð?ë|«µê¬æ¬¦�çyð ³ 9 æ½é�ç É ë>ò�­ É ë É é�ñ�給©ì¬èa­�îV­�«y­�¨�ªY¦©«y­�­qé�è2æ/ì¬ë�í¬­�é�ìYííqé�è2æíaí¬¨|­ É ë�æ½é¯û|­�é É ö�ê°­´®úËìl$ h !{�YO ( 8 ÷ � h !�� ( 8 + É æ¬¦©ç�ê½é�çµçy¦�쬨oï,«µë|𠪬ì É ö�ê�­qíD¨|«yé�ê¬æ¬ç É ë É ö�ê°­aíŨ|«yé�ê¬æ¬ç>¦©ç�­6¥YêY«y­qçµçy­aíKòSöê½é�çy給©ì¬¨Ðï,«yë�ð É æY­nèqé É ­a¨|ë|«µö � ¢Y !�43 É ë É æ¬­�èqë�ð?ð?é�è¯é É ­q¨|ë|«óö « � ¢Y !�H3nm � Ñ ­�®po�ò�øµ­qè É çlë�ïÉ æ¬¦�ç*èqë|ð>ð?é�è¯é É ­q¨�ë|«µöWé�«y­ É ö�ê�­qíZ¨|«yé�ê¬æ¬ç ³ 9 Æ Ñ 3 � Ñ ¦©ì<� Ñ é�ì¬írð>ë|«yê¬æY¦©çyð>ç ò�­ É îV­q­aìÃë�ò�øµ­qè É ç³ 9 Æ Ñ 3 � Ñ é�ì¬í�³ E Æ7Ó�3 � Ñ é�«y­ É ë É é�ñ%¨|«yé�ê¬æNð>ë|«µê¬æ¬¦©çµð?ç 0 Æ Ñ 3 Ó ÷ çyæ¬ë|« É � Ñ ù ���ÚÙ½Ôyõq��ȵØ�Ù rÖ<ÕwÈËÙ r�ÿts�Öus ÷ çyªYè2æ É æ½é É*É ö�ê�­qç#é�«µ­�ꬫy­açy­a«µû|­aí ÷ ¦Ñ®Ò­�®�³ 9 Í)³ E F*0 ®�ÏIæY­Qèqë|ì¬èa­qê É ë�ïý� Ñ ù É ö�ê�­qíZ¨|«�é´ê¬æð?ë|«µê¬æ¬¦�çyð>ç�èqé�ì�ò°­<¨|­q쬭a«�é�ñ�¦tva­qí É ë/� Ñ ù ���2Ù½ÔyõWÙYØ�È��-ÿ-Ø�Ç[��ȵØ�Ù r�Ö<ÕwÈ Ù r�ÿts�Öus Æ�wÎ� Ñ ù É ö�ê�­qí�ê¬é�« É ¦üé�ñ¨|«�é�êYæð?ë|«µê¬æ¬¦�çyð䦩ç�é�ê½é�« É ¦üé�ñS¨|«yé�ê¬æð>ë|«yêY欦©çµð 0 Íx$ ÌyQ�ÆVLS± ×{z 0}| S 3 Ñ�Ê K0 ÆVLS± ×{z 0}| 3 Ó + îs欭a«y­Ñ>Ê LS± ×{z 0}| é�ìYíOÓ×é´«y­ É ö�ê�­qíW¨�«�é�ê¬æYç ¦©ì É æY­�ç�é´ð?­ É ö�ê°­m¨|«�é�êYæ<� Ñ ®�ÏIæY­ É ë É é�ñ&¨|«yé�ê¬æ<ð>ë|«µê¬æ¬¦©çµð?ç

8V~

Page 70: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

ÌyQNé´ì¬ípK0 é�«µ­Q� Ñ ù É ö�ê�­qíZ¨|«yé�ê¬ælð?ë|«µê¬æ¬¦�çyð>ç ÷ ¦�®_­´® É æ¬­�í¬¦©é�¨|«yé�ðÑ

��� �� ���������

LS±�� z 0}|������� �Q ��

���

����� � � � � � �� � �

���¦©ì��i���g� 3 èqë|ð>ðFª É ­qçq®���� ù É ö�ê�­qíAê¬é�« É ¦üé�ñi¨|«�é´ê¬æAð>ë|«yê¬æY¦©çyð>ç#ꬫy­açy­q«óû|­ É ö�ê°­aç�ë�ï{ë|òSøµ­qè É ç ÷ ª¬ìYñ©­qçµçÉ æ¬­�öZé�«y­�ë|ª É çy¦�í¬­�ë�ïf¦ É çIíYë|ð<é´¦©ì�®TP� UH�4�= >�#5¡�£¢j¤ 0 ¤¦¥ W�§ �   �R¨ 5 � 2 5�©ª  2 �M��«¬¨��>�D� 34­>Z§&ë�«6é�ì%ö�¨|«�é�êYæ'���D¦©ì��G�>�D� 3 ÷ ú�íY­qì¬ë É ­ É æ¬­�è¯é É ­q¨|ë|«óö�ë�ï É ö�ê�­qí�¨|«�é�êYæ¬çf¦�ìk��� z É æ½é É é´«y­{ë|ò�øµ­aè É çfë�ïÉ æ¬­�èqë|ð>ð?é#èqé É ­a¨|ë|«µö z �G�>�D� 3em ��� |,| é�ì¬í;��� ù É ö�ê�­qíNê¬é�« É ¦üé�ñ%¨|«yé�ê¬æ�ð?ë|«µê¬æ¬¦�çyð>çiò%ö��G�>�D� 3j®�¯ 9 ®h ë|ð?ê�ë|給 É ¦�ë|ìl¦©ç�íY­/°½ì¬­aínò%öÃèqë|ð>ê�ë|çy¦ É ¦©ë�ì/¦©ì±�G�>�D� 3 ® é�ì¬í/¦©í¬­aì É ¦ É ¦©­qç#ï,ë|«�­qé�è2æ�³ 9 Æ��³² ����¦�çÉ æ¬­�¦©íY­qì É ¦ É öi´yL 9 ÆR�µ² �âï,ë|«I¨|«�é´ê¬æ¶�þ¦©ìe�G�>�D� 3 ® ® \ÏI欭*è¯é É ­q¨�ë|«µö��G�>�D� 3Y® ¯ 9 ¦�ç�ì¬ë É øµª¬ç É é�èqë|ð>ð?émè¯é É ­q¨�ë|«µö ÷ çy¦�ì¬èq­Ié É ë É é�ñ É ö�ꬦ�쬨�¦�ç�«y­/·Sª¬¦©«µ­qí�®H¸më�î ù­aû|­a« ÷ ¦ É ¦�ç#òYª¬¦©ñ�ílªYêlï,«µë|ð É æY­�èaë|ð?ð?éè¯é É ­q¨|ë�«µö z �G�>�D� 3±m ��� | ®º¹�¦�ì¬èq­ É æ¬­�èqé É ­a¨|ë|«µöe�i�>�D� 3 ¦�çèqë|ð>ê¬ñ©­ É ­mé�ì¬íWèaë ù èaë|ð>ê¬ñ©­ É ­ É æ¬­mèqë|ð>ð<é�è¯é É ­q¨�ë|«µö z �i�>�D� 3em ��� | æ½é�ç*é´ñ©ñ&ñ©¦�ð?¦ É ç[é�ìYíWèqë|ñ�¦©ð>¦ É ç{é�çî ­añ©ñ ÷ é�ì¬í É æ¬­ èaë|ì¬ç É «yªYè É ¦�ë|ìë�ï½êYª¬çyæ¬ë�ª É ç{é�ìYíFꬪ¬ñ�ñ©ò½é�è��Sçfèqë|¦�ì¬èq¦�í¬­qçf¦©ì`�i�>�D� 3 é�ì¬í z �G�>�D� 3¶m ��� |ª¬ê É ë/é�í¬í¬¦ É ¦�ë|ì½é�ñ É ö�ꬦ�쬨/¦�ìYï,ë|«µð<é É ¦©ë|ìAîsæY¦©è2æ�¦�ç�ª¬ìY¦t·Sª¬­qñ¿öo¦©ì¬í¬ªYèq­qínò%ö�ð>­qí¬¦©é É ¦�쬨Zð?ë�«yê¬æ¬¦�çyð:¦�ìÉ æ¬­#è¯é�çµ­�ë�ï�èqë|ñ�¦©ð>¦ É ç�é�ì¬í?ð?ë�«yê¬æ¬¦�çyð�èaë|ð>ê°ë|給 É ¦©ë|ì¦�ì É æ¬­mèqé�çy­më�ï�ñ�¦©ð>¦ É çq®6Ïfë�¨|­ É æ¬­q«{îs¦ É æ É æY­mèaë|ð ùê¬ñ©­ É ­qìY­qçyç�é�ì¬íAèaë ù èaë|ð?êYñ©­ É ­q쬭açyçmë�ï[è¯é É ­q¨�ë|«µö»�G�>�D� 3j® ÷ É æY­Nè¯é É ­q¨�ë|«µö»�G�>�D� 3j®�¯ 9 æ½é�ç�é´ñ©ñ6ñ©¦�ð?¦ É çé�ì¬ílèqë|ñ�¦©ð>¦ É çVé�çIîV­qñ©ñ�®O{ªYçyæ¬ë|ª É ç�é�«y­ É æ¬­Iò½é�給©èIè¯é É ­q¨�ë|«y¦�è¯é�ñ�èqë|ì¬ç É «µª¬è É ¦©ë|ì�¦©ì É æ¬­*ï,ë|ñ©ñ�ë�îs¦©ì¬¨mèqë|ì¬çµ¦©í¬­a«�é É ¦©ë|ìYç[çy¦©ìYèq­ É æ¬­�öFí¬­ ù°½ì¬­Vé#«µ­aîs«y¦ É ¦�쬨sç É ­aêN¦�ì É æ¬­V«µ­aîs«µ¦ É ­{çóö�ç É ­aðîfÏI欭q«µ­aï,ë|«µ­ ÷ ú°ê¬«y­açy­qì É æ¬­q«µ­ É æ¬­VêYª¬çyæ¬ë�ª É èaë|ì¬ç É «yªYè É ¦�ë|즩ìe�G�>�D� 3 ®�¯ 9 ®¼ 5¡�Y­/  ��½ §  >��5¡�¾¢Y¤ 0 ¤ º¬W �4½ ­�3Y5 ½  >­�Z¿}À�Á'ÂVÃ-Ä>Å<ÆÇ���;È�É�ÊVË[Å�ÌÍË}Î�ÁÏÉ�Ã=Î�ÐMÂVÁ<Î�Ë�ÑÇÒGÀ>Á-Ë�ÑDÃtÓ�ÒÔÓuÕ Æ4Ö I × Î�ÆØÌ»ÙÐÆHÖ I Ú É�ÑØÅ8Ë[ÛÓ,Ñ¡À�ÛDÉ�æÓÜ À>ÆDÓ�É�Á�Û Ü ÉÝÅ�ÌÞÎ�Ó)ß-À�ÐtÐ�À�àMÓ�á

â*ã'ä À>ÆDÓ�É�ÁÏÛ Ü É8É�ÑØÅ�ËHÛÓ,ÑØÀRÛDÉ�À>ßåÕ¾Î�ÆØÌÞÙ¶Ã¦Æ Ü ÎgÉÝÅ<ÂgÀ>ÁÝÊæ�i���g� 3j®èçêé'ëÀRàìí�î ãÍïñð ÑØÅ Ü À>Æ Ü Á�Å�ÉñÅ Ü À>ÆDÈÓÏÉ�ÁÏÛ Ü É�Ã�À�Æ�æÓ8Â*ÃyÄ>Å<ÆÇÐòÎgÉñÅ<Á�À�Æ�æÆÇóMÁ�À�ËMÀ>Ó�ÃyÉ�Ã�À>Ææô ãöõgã�â÷ ß-À>Á`É�ÑØÅ Ü À>ÆgÓÏÉ�Á�Û Ü É�Ã�À>Æ%À>ߪÎ�Ë[ÛÓ�ÑØÀ�ÛDÉkÀ>ßËøÎ�Á�É�Ã=Î�ЪÒPÀ�ÌDÅ�ÐqÒGÀ>ÁyËØÑDÃtÓ�ÒÔÓñù ã¬ú Ü Å�Æ¡É�Á�Î�Ð�Á�Å�Ó�ÛÐyÉ8ÃtÆ çûé'ëÀRàì�í�î8ÓÏÉyÎ�ÉñÅ�Ó¶É�Ñ�Î�É ï=õ ùPÎ�Æ¡Ì ï í�ùPÎ�Á�ÅË[ÛЦÐÝü*Î Ü:ý Ó)Î�Æ¡Ì ï ôÏù)ÃtÓ)Î8Ë[ÛÓ�ÑØÀ�ÛDÉMÃtÆe�i���g� 3 ãÖ

þÿ�����

L�±>� z Õ |������Q ��� �� ��� ×

�L�>� z ٠|� ��� � �

�� �� ������� �

��

���������

L��� z �� |� �� ��� �

�� � �����

��

L�>� z�� � |� �� � ��� �Q ��� �

!

õgãªú ÌDÌeÉ�Ñ¡Å?É�Ê*Ë�æÆgÂGÀ>ß � Î�Ó8Û�ÆDÃ#"gÛ�Å8Å%$�ÉÝÅ�ÆDÓ�Ã�À>ÆDÓkÀ>ßåÉ�ÑØÅ�Á�Å�ÓÏÛ�ÐyÉ�æÆgÂGÌRÃ=Î>ÂVÁ�Î�Ò`Ó ã\

&('

Page 71: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

¢Y¤¦¥ ) 5 «Y�+* ­ � � « )µ5 «j��* )µ5 �>� 3Y��­-,æ­?©y5 �/.i� UH� � , � �Ø ú10�ì3254yë�í76¬è98:0�ì;2�æ70�ç*ç%8aè92%0©ë|ìrð>ë�í<8qñ©çVé�ì¬írð>ë�í78qñ�ð?ë=4yê¬æ70�çyð>ç?>[w@2º°A4yç�2 ÷ úB0�ìSû=8qç�250DC|éE258:2yæ78�èqéE2589C|ë(4µöë�ï6ð?ë�í78añ©çVé�ì¬í �GF���H=I ð>ë�í78qñ�ð?ë=4yê¬æ70�çyð>ç�é�ì¬írçyæYë�îJ0K2�ç�èqë ù èqë|ð>ê¬ñD8L258aì78qçµç?>1M*é�çN8qírë|ì;2yæ78qçN8O4%8aç%6¬ñK2�ç ÷úí78/°½ì<8P2�æ78/è¯éE2%8?C|ë(4óöhë�ï�ð?ë�í78añ©ç?é�ì¬íRQ H=S��-ÿ#H=I ð?ë�í78qñ#ð>ë(4yê¬æ<0©çyð>ç>é�ì¬íKçµæ¬ë�îT2yæ78P8VU�0©çN2%8qì¬è98�ë�ïê76¬çyæYë(6<2�ç9>

¢Y¤¦¥}¤ 0 )µ5 «j�+* ­ � � « 1 5   �A* )µ5 «j�+* )µ5 �>� 34��­-,æ­W 4yé�ê¬æ¬çQéE4%8�îX8qñ�ñ�çN670�2%8qíAï,ë(4:2yæ78FçµêY8aè?0¦°¬è¯éE2%0©ë|ìAë´ï[û�éE4%0©ë=6¬ç���0©ìYí�ë�ïBC(4�é´ê¬æ70©èqé�ñiçN254N6¬è92%674%8aç ÷ é�ç:2yæ78aöë�èaè?674Z0©ì[8qì3250K2Ëö ù 4%8añüéE2%0©ë|ìYçyæ70�êoí<0üé=C(4yé�ð>ç ÷ çN2�éE258aè2æ½é=4N2yç ÷ O\892%4%0�ì7892yç ÷ ì�6¬ð]8?4µë(6¬ç�í70üé=C=4�é�ð>ç^0©ì`_ BPañD0t�E8/èaë|ñ©ñ©é�ò°ë=4�éE2%0©ë|ìhí70üéEC(4�é�ð>ç ÷ çN8�·�678aì¬è?8oí70üéEC(4�é�ð>ç;8L2�èE>x¸#ë�îX8aû=8?4 ÷ C(4�é�êYæ70©èqé�ñmí<8qçyè94%0�ê<250�ë|ì¬çré=4N8òY8aèqë|ð]0©ì7Clèqë�ìYïb6¬ç%8aíc0�ïX2�æ78?çyêd8qè90¦°½èqéE250�ë|ì�òd8qèaë|ðe8açNò70�C(C(894?>/fIæ7894%8�ï,ë(4%8 ÷ éÃì¬ëE250©ë�ìnë�ïIé�ò¬çN2%4�é�èL250�ë|ìé�ì¬íP4N8/°½ì<8qð]8qì32O0�ç#í<8qç%0�4�é�òYñD8^2�ëÔ�=8?8aêP2�æ<8�èañüé=4N0�2Ëörë�ï�ò70DC>çyêd8qè90¦°½èqéE250�ë|ì¬ç9>hg½ë(4i0©ì¬ç�22é�ì¬è98 ÷ é>ç�22éE2%8j0�ìé�ç�22éE2%8qè2æ½éE4N2#í70üéEC(4�é�ð�ð?é�ö<òY8^4N8/°½ì<8qík2�ë>é�ìk8qì3250�4%8Qç�22éE2%8qè2æ½é=4�2mé=C%é=0�ìrë(4*çN2�éE258açi0©ìZí70üéEC(4�é�ð>ç èqé�ìòY8/4N8/°½ì<8qíc2�ë/ç%6¬ò ù í70üéEC(4�é�ð>ç?>mlO0�è?8?û=8?4µç�é ÷ 8qì32%0D4%8?çN2�éE258Wè2æ¬é=4N2yç�é=4%8<é�ò¬çN2%4�é�èL258aíc2�ëAë|ì<8WçN2�éE258Wë=4ç%6¬ò ù í70üéEC(4�é�ð>çIé=4N8�ç%8?8aìAé�çIë�ì78cé�ò¬çN2%4�é�èL2#çN22én258o0©ìléæ70DC�æ78?4 ù ñD8�û(8añ�í70üéEC(4�é�ðm>g&ë�ñ©ñ©ë�îi0�ì7Cp2�æ78aç%8p0�í78¯é>ë�ïq4N8/°½ì78aðe8aì32Qú@0©ì32%8qì¬íP2yë;4N8/°½ì78Nì¬ë�í<8qç�ë´ï{éeC(4yé�ê¬æAò%ölë|ò�øN8aè92yç�ë�ï{é]C(0�û=8qìè¯éE2%8?C|ë(4óö ¼ é�ì¬ír2�æ<8s8qí7C(8açò%ö ¼ ù ð>ë(4yêYæ70©çµð?ç9>`g½ë(4µð<é´ñ©ñ�ö ÷ 2yæ78s4%8�°½ì78aðe8aì�2]0�çpC(0�û=8qì�ò%öÐéP2yë=22é�ñC(4�é�êYælð>ë(4µê¬æ70©çµðutv0�2yç*í¬ë|ð?é=0©ì;C(4�é�êYæm0�ç@2�æ78^C=4�é�ê¬æs2yæ½éE2Iæ½é´çi2yëòY8^4N8/°½ì<8qí ÷ 0�2yç*èqë ù í¬ë|ð?é=0�ì/C(4�é´ê¬æ4%8qê<4%8qçN8qì32�çh2yæ78�é�íYðe0�çyç%0�ò¬ñD8sç�22éE2%8qç*ï,ë(4B2�æ78:4%8/°¬ì78qð]8qì32->BfIæ78�èqë ù í¬ë|ð?é=0©ì]C(4�é´ê¬æ<ï,ë(412�æ78w4%8/°¬ì78qð]8qì32çyê½é�è98^0©çx2yæ78 ����õ+yLSVIû�´ÿ=���;�=S%H Q r �Zz�ë�ï{2yæ78Qè¯éE2%8?C|ë=4µö ¼ ÷ 2�æ½én2h0©çIé�ñüé�òd8qñ�8qí/C(4yé�ê¬æ/2yæ½éE2Iæ½é´çIéFì¬ë�í78îi0�2�æZñ©é�òY8añ�Ö�ï,ë(4x8¯é�è2ælë|ò�øN8aè92)Ö|0©ì ¼ é�ì¬íÃé�ìk8qí7C(8�îi0K2�æZñüé´òY8añ���òY8L2Ëîx898qì�éFì¬ë�í78Qîi0�2yærñüé�òd8qñØÖé�ì¬íÃé�ìYë�í78Qîi0K2�æZñüé�òd8qñ × ï,ë=4h8¯é�è2æÃð?ë(4µê¬æ70�çyð �}0©ìk~����z z Ö�� ×?| >ú>èqé�ñ©ñ�2�æ78u2�ë=2�é�ñ:C(4yé�ê¬æKð>ë(4yêYæ70©çµð ï,ë=4;2�æ78P4%8/°¬ì78qð]8qì32lé�� Fqõ+yLI 0©ì)é´ì½é�ñ©ë=C�ö�2�ëc2�æ<8P2�æ78aë(4µöÅë�ïç,�=8L2�è2æ78aç?>núËì�ï-é�è92 ÷ 2�æ78/C=4�é�ê¬ææ�×è¯é´ì�òY8/6Yì¬í78?4µçN2yë�ë�íÐé�çéÃû=8?4óö�ç%0�ð?ê¬ñ�8?ç��=8L2�è2æ ÷ 2�æ½én2Fí¬ë+8qçì¬ëE2èqë|ì322éE0©ì�é´ìSöní70©é=C(4�é´ð ÷ èqë|ì<8Wë(4cèqë�èqë|ì78E>�Mx8aè¯é=6¬çN8Wë�ïh2yæ70©çcç%0�ð?ê¬ñ�8?èqé�ç%8 ÷ úQë|ð]0�2%2%8qíoæ78?4N8;2�æ<8/0©ì ù254yë�í76¬èL250�ë|ì�0©ì�2yæ78p2�æ78aë(4µöAë�ï�ç,�=8L2�è2æ78aç?> BÃë(4N8që�û(894 ÷ í7678�2�ërê¬é=4N2%0üé�ñv4%8qñ©éE250�ë|ì¬çmòY8L2Ëîx898qì�ð>ë�í78qñ�ç ÷ úñD8¯é¯û=8Z2yæ78Qïb4�é�ð]8aîVë(4,�<ë�ï�ç��=892yè2æ78qç�é�çi0©ì3254µë�í76Yè?8qíu0©ì�$�MX� (3��+ >º¸#ë�îx8�û(8?4 ÷ 2yæ78o0©ì325894%8qç�258aíP4%8qé�í7894w0�ç4%8aïb894%4N8qík2�ë¶$�MX� ((��+ >TP� UH�4�= >�#5¡�£¢j¤¦¥ø¤ 0CW ,Ç5 «j��* ­�Zw�� Fqõ+yLI ë�û=8?4FéuC(4�é�êYææ��0©ìnè¯éE2%8?C|ë(4óö ¼ 0©ç�ém2�ëE22é�ñBC(4yé�ê¬æ�ð>ë(4µê¬æ70©çµð���tY� ² �ZzKïb4yë|ð�2yæ78C(4�é�êYæG��2yë�2�æ<8:6¬ì¬í<8?4yñ¿ö+0©ì7CpC=4�é�ê¬æi�jzoë�ï{2�æ78�è¯éE2%8?C|ë(4óö ¼ >��`8�èqé�ñ©ñ�2�æ<8:C(4yé�ê¬æG�|2�æ78�� H�s�yq�=SNH Q rë�ï�2yæ78mð>ë�í78qñ��@>Bg½ë(4B8¯é´è2æ<ì¬ë�í78���0©ìÔ� 6 îX8�èqé�ñ©ñ�� z � | 2yæ78 S5y#� ��yyõk�=SNH Q r ï,ë=4X�é´ì¬í?ï,ë(4B8qé�è2æ/8qí<C(8� 0©ìP� 7 îx8cè¯é�ñ�ñ{� z�� | 2yæ78 S�y#� ��yyõ � FnS Q r�ÿts �ï,ë(4 � > \BÃë(4yêYæ70©çµð?ç{òd892ËîX8?8qì<ð?ë�í78qñ�çB��é�ìYí]�Îë�û=8?4�ò½é�çN8wC(4yé�ê¬æ¬çå��4%8açyê�>��Óèqë�ì¬ç%0�çN2Vë�ïY2ËîVëNèaë|ð>ê°ë|ì<8qì32�ç9tfIæ78º°A4µçN2[èaë|ð?ê�ë|ì78aì32�0©çvC(0�û=8qìFò%öNéw2�ëE22é�ñ+C(4�é´ê¬æFð>ë(4yê¬æ<0©çyð � tR�µ² �Îòd892ËîX8?8qì�2yæ78*ò½é�çN8@C(4yé�ê¬æ¬ç ÷2�æ78lç%8aèqë|ì¬íÅèqë|ð>ê°ë�ì78qì32?èqë|ì¬çN0©ç�2�ç<ë´ïQéoï-é´ðe0�ñ�önë�ï ¼ ù ð>ë(4yêYæ70©çµð?çp2yæ½éE2>èqë|ì32�é=0©ì¬ç?é ¼ ù ð?ë(4µê¬æ70�çyð z � | òd892ËîX8?8aì`2yæ78¡4%8/°¬ì78qí[C(4�é´ê¬æ[� z � | é�ì¬í�2�æ<8]4N8/°½ì<8qí[C(4�é�êYæ¢� z��[z � |�| ï,ë(4^8¯é´è2ænì¬ë�í78��u0©ì±�¡>fIæ78?4N8<í¬ë+8qçcì¬ë=2Z8LU�0�çN2Né�ì%ö�í70D4N8qè92j4%8añüéE2%0©ë|ì�òd892ËîX8?8aìr4%8�°½ì78qí�ð?ë(4µê¬æ70�çyð>ç�ï,ë(4o8qí7C(8aç ÷ ò76<2Z2�æ78 ¼ ùð?ë(4µê¬æ70�çyð>çQòY8L2Ëîx898qìr4%8�°½ì78aícC(4�é´ê¬æ¬çcæ½é¯û(8e2yëÃë�òY8�ö�2�æ78]4%8�°½ì78qð]8qì32Në�ï@8aí7C(8qçZ0©ì¢2�æ<8?çN8qì¬çN8;2�æ½én2ï,ë(4�8qé�è2æ�ê74%8aç%894µû(8aí�8qí7C(8 � ïb4yë|ð�£:2yëG@�ë|ì78<æ¬é�ç�� z��Hz�� |,|MF  z £ |j¤  ºz @ |[F � z#� | >uffë=2�é�ñ�ð?ë�í78qñð?ë(4µê¬æ70�çyð>ç*è¯é�ìÃé�ñ�çyë�òY8QçN8?8aìAé�çiC(8aì78?4yé�ñD0¦v?8qíZì½én25674yé�ñ�254yé�ì¬çµï,ë=4yð?éE250�ë|ì¬çk$b!_BP¥ � ÷ M W fi¥ (�+ >

&=¦

Page 72: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

TP� UH�4�= >�#5¡�£¢j¤¦¥ø¤¦¥ W  �5   �A* ,�5 «Y�+* ,Ç5 ��� 3Y��­-,%Zw �GF���H=I � Fqõ+yLI � FnS Q r�ÿts ��òY8L2Ëîx898qìWð>ë�í78qñ�çB��é�ì¬í¡� ë�û=8?4å��4%8qçµê�>��T0�ì ¼ 0©ç{é�ê½é=0�4�§� ¤©¨ � �   Q�ª t�µ² � îsæ7894%8 � tH� ² � 0©ç�ém2�ëE22é�ñBC(4yé�ê¬æ�ð>ë(4µê¬æ70©çµð ÷ è¯é´ñ©ñD8aí�� H�s�y � FnS Q r�ÿts � ÷ é�ì¬í   Q 0©ç�éï-é�ðe0�ñ�ö�ë�ïið>ë(4yêYæ70©çµð?ç@0�ì ¼ ÷�«   Q z £ | t�� z £ | ²¬� z��[z £ |,|�­ £B®»� 6�¯ ç%6Yè2æm2yæ½éE2Iï,ë(4Ié´ñ©ñ�8aí7C(8aç � t(£4² @0©ìÞ� 7 ÷ � z��[z#� |,|øF   Q z £ |B¤   Q z @ |øF � z#� | >

£° ��

� z £ |©± � � � ���² � ° � ��

� z��[z £ |,|³ � Q � ° �K���@ � z @ | ± � � ´%�

�� � z��[z @ |,|\

BÃë�í<8qñ©ç:0©ì ¼ é´ì¬í�2�ë=2�é�ñ�ð>ë�í<8qñ�ð>ë(4µê¬æ70©çµð?ç#ï,ë(4yð×érè¯éE2%8?C|ë=4µö )µ5 « ¯ z >jfIæ78 ��F �:Q F�s�ÿ=�-ÿ�F�� ë´ï12ËîVë2�ë=2�é�ñmð>ë�í78qñ#ð?ë=4yê¬æ70�çyð>絧� ¤ ¨ � �   Q�ª t:� ² � é´ì¬í §Ù ¤ ¨ Ùd�   � ª tw� ² ¶·0©ç?í78/°½ì<8qí�òSö§Ù F §� ¤ ¨ Ù F � �   �N¸ Q�ª th�n² ¶ îsæ78?4N8   �N¸ Q z £ | t ¤   � z��[z £ |,|_F   Q z £ | ï,ë=4e8qé�è2æ�£s® � 6 >¹fIæ78é�çyçµë�è90üéE2%0�û+0�2Ëöë´ï�èqë�ð?ê�ë|ç%0K250�ë|ì�æ¬ë|ñ©íYçVí76<8w2�ëZ2�æ78mé�çµçyë�è?0üén250�û+0K2Ëöë�ï�2yæ78mèaë|ð>ê°ë|çN0�2%0©ë|ì¡0©ìG�G�>�D� 3 é�ì¬í0©ì ¼ >wº õ+y�� �-ÿ=�-ÿ�y�s ï,ë(4#ð?ë�í78qñ�ç��Ké=4%8jC(0�û=8qì/ò%ö §£yL ² ¤µ¨ £yL 9 �   �¼» � ª t7�¾² �Åîsæ78?4N8   �¼» � z £ |@¤ £yL ² � � �ï,ë(4h8¯é�è2æm£B®»� 6 >½:¾ø� , �v*#� ¢j¤ 0CW ,Ç5 «Y�+* ­����J¿ �  ZúËì<ë(4µí78?4q2�ëZ8LU�ê¬ñ©é=0©ì¡2�æ<8mèaë|ì¬è?8aê<2�çVë�ï�ð>ë�í78qñ�çq0©ì3254µë�í76Yè?8qí?ì¬ë�î)é�ì¬í?ñüéE2%8?4[ë|ì ÷ úv0©ì%û(8açN250�C%éE2%8mð>ë�í<8qñ©ç0©ì¡2�æ78#è¯éE2%8?C|ë=4µö ¿ �   ë�ï�çN892�ç é�ì¬í]2�ë=2�é�ñ&ð<é�êYê70©ì7C�ç?>ÀfIæ<8qç%8�ð?ë�í78qñ�çB4%8/°¬ì78w2yæ78mìYë�í78aç ë�ï�éjC(4yé�ê¬æ?òSöç%892yç�é´ì¬íu0K2�çh8aí7C(8qç#ò%ös2�ë=2�é�ñýð?é�ê¬ê70�ì7C|ç?>Mwäê�ë|çyçN0©ò¬ñ�8Qð?ë�í78añýë�ïv2yæ78�è¯éE2%8?C|ë=4µö )µ5 « ¯ Á?Â�à 0�çsí78qê70�è92%8qí0©ì�2�æ<8egv0DC(674N8 ¦ >KÄ(>Fú�2yçcò¬é�ç%8¡C(4yé�ê¬æ�èqë|ìYç%0©ç�2�ç�ë�ï12Ëî ëlì¬ë�í78qç�èaë|ì¬ì78aè9258aí�ò%ö�é�ì¢8aí7C(8=>�fIæ<8>çµë(674µè?8

base graph G

gÀ0�C(674N8 ¦ >�Ä=t1ÅÆ� Fqõ+yLI�ÿ=� ¿ �  ì¬ë�í<8e0�çj4N8/°½ì78aí�ò%önéÃç%8L2Fèaë|ì¬ç%0�çN2%0©ì7Clë�ï@2ËîVë�8qñ�8qð]8qì32�ç ÷ 2yæ78e2�é=4%C(8L2cì¬ë�í<8<ò%önéÃç%8L2Nèaë|ì¬çN0©çN2%0©ì7CÃë�ïï,ë(674@8añD8qð]8qì32yç?>BfIæ78o4%8�°½ì78qím8qí<C(8o0©ç@C(0¿û(8aìlò%öZép2yë=22é�ñ°ð<é´ê¬ê70©ì<CòY8L2Ëîx898qìu2yæ78O2ËîVë?çN892�ç9> wð?ë�í78qñð?ë(4µê¬æ70�çyð�0�ç�çµæ¬ë�îsìr0©ì`gÀ0DC(6<4%8 ¦ > ~�>kfIæ78<ð>ë(4yêYæ70©çµð:ç�éE2%0©ç:°A8qçZ2�æ78?èqë|ð>ðp6<2�éE250¿û�0K2Ëö�4N8�·�670D4N8qí�ï,ë=42�æ78o4%8�°½ì78aðe8aì�2më�ïv8qí7C=8qç?> \

=

gÀ0�C(674%8 ¦ >ê~+txÅ �GF���H=I � Fqõ+yLI � FnS Q r�ÿts � ÿ=� ¿ �  & �

Page 73: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

úËìo2yæ78q4%8að<éE0©ì¬í7894�ë�ï�2�æ<0©çýç%8aè92%0©ë|ì ÷ úd0©ì%û(8açN2%0DC%éE2%8�8LU�0�çN258aì¬è?8�èqë�ì¬í70�2%0©ë|ìYç°ï,ë(4ýèaë|ê74yë�í76¬èL2�ç6é�ìYícê<6¬çyæ¬ë=6<2�ç0©ìe2yæ78#è¯éE2%8?C|ë(4óö ) 5 « ¯ z >ÀfIæ78qçN8Qèqë|ì¬í<0�250�ë|ì¬ç�é=4N8�ò½é�çN8qíWë�ìe2�æ<8:4%8aç%6¬ñK2�ç�ï,ë(412yæ78�èaë ù èaë|ð>ê¬ñD8L258qì<8qçyçVë�ïÇ éE2%2%8qì78aík0©ì¬í78VU�8qíZè¯éE2%8?C|ë=4%0D8aç@0©ì»$�M W fi¥ (�+ >_¹�0�ì¬è?8:2yæ78�èqéE2589C|ë(4µö )µ5 « ¯ z è¯é�ìZòd8�ç%898qìlé�çséNçµêY8aè?0üé´ñÇ éE2%2%8qì78aík0©ì¬í78VU�8qílè¯éE2%8?C|ë(4óö;2yæ78^4%8aç%6¬ñK2�çIè¯é´ìlòd8^6¬çN8qí�>_¸më�îX8aû=8?4 ÷ ç%0�ì¬è?8�îX8Qæ½é¯û(8céèqë�ì¬è?4N89258�èqéE258 ùC|ë(4µö ÷ îX8�èqé�ìÃçN0©ð>ê¬ñD0¿ï�ö¡2�æ78�èqë�ì¬í70�2%0©ë|ìYç ï,ë(4h2�æ78o8VU<0�çN2%8qì¬è98�ë�ïfèqë�ñD0©ð]0�2yçXC=0�û(8aìlï,ë=4@2�æ78oC(8aì78?4yé�ñýè¯é�çN8=>fIæ78e8VU�0©çN2%8qì¬è98<ë�ï èqë|ê<4yë�í76¬è92yç�0�ì[2yæ78�è¯éE2%8?C|ë(4óö )µ5 « ¯ z 0©ço0�ì¬í78qêd8qìYí78qì32Fë´ïx2�æ<8?èqéE2589C|ë(4µö ¼ é�ì¬íï,ë|ñ©ñ�ë�îsçVí70D4N8qèL2�ñ�ö>ïb4yë�ðÈ2yæ78^8LU�0©ç�258aì¬è?8�ë�ïièqë�ê74yë�í76¬èL2�çh0©ì/2yæ78Qè¯én258?C�ë(4µöP�G�>�D� 3 >qfIæ70�çh0©ç*í<678O2�ëp2yæ78èqë|ì¬ç�254N6¬è92%0©ë|ì?ë�ïY2yæ78#èqë|ê74µë�í<6¬è92Vë�ï�C=4�é�ê¬æYçVò%ö�2�æ<8?0D4{í70�ç,øµë(0�ì32B6¬ì70©ë�ì�>�fIæ70�çVèaë|ì¬çN2%4%6¬èL250�ë|ìe0�ç{í70D4N8qè92yñ�öñD0�ïÉ2%8qí[6¬êÊ2yëu2�æ<8<è¯én258?C�ë(4µö )µ5 « ¯ z ÷ 0�>�8=>{2yæ78<èaë|ê74yë�í76¬èL2Fë�ïIélï-é�ð]0©ñ¿ö�ë�ïIð>ë�í<8qñ©ço0�çj2�æ<8?0D4cí70�ç,øµë(0�ì�26¬ì70©ë�ìÃé´çsîX8qñ�ñ�>Ë;� 5 � 5¡­Ï�# ���5¡�%¢Y¤¦¥}¤�Ì W,§ 5 �Y� 5 «4½ §  Zð ÑØÅ Ü ÎgÉÝÅ<ÂgÀ>ÁÝÊ )µ5 « ¯ z Ñ Î�Ó�Î�ÐtÐ Ü À�Ë�Á�À�Ì¡Û Ü É�Ó ã \Í S5F�Fñ"W 0¿û(8qìNémï-é�ð]0©ñ¿ö�ë�ï½ð>ë�í78qñ�ç z � � | �DÎ?Ï ÐÑ ë�û(894M� � ÷ ñ�892H�Dîi0�2�æ�0©ìwøN8aè9250�ë|ì¬ç\£�Ò � tR� � ² �Kòd8X2yæ78 èaë|ê74yë�í76¬èL2ë�ïv2yæ78o� � 0©ìe�i���g� 3 >qfIæ78qì ÷ îX8�í78/°½ì<8���tR� ² �Zz�ï,ë(4sé�ñ�ñYÓP0©ìP� z ìYë�í78aç#é�ç*îx8añ©ñ6é�çh8aí7C(8aç | òSö� z Ó | t ¤ � � z Ó | 0¿ï1Ó[0�ì±� � >ZfIæ<8>èaë|ê74µë�í76Yè92Qð>ë(4yêYæ70©çµð §£�Ò � ¤Ô¨ £�Ò � �   ��Õ-Ö ª tY� � ² �¹0©ç�í78/°½ì<8qíoòSö  ��Õ?Ö z Ó |1¤ £yL ² Ö ��×L� ï,ë(4h8¯é´è2æuÓ�0�ìu� �ÙØ >1�Ê8�èqñ©é=0©ðÈ2�æ½én2 ¨ �@� z §£�Ò � | �DÎ-Ú ª 0©çh2�æ<8�èaë|ê74yë�í76¬èL2#ë�ïÀ2yæ78�� � 0�ì) 5 « ¯ z >¹�0©ì¬è98q�Û0�ç�2�æ78Ií70�ç,øµë(0�ì32�6¬ì70�ë|ì�ë�ï�2�æ78q� � ÷ 2yæ78Ií70�çN254N0©ò76�258qí¡C(4yé�ê¬æ¡�oé�ì¬í�2�æ<8Ið?ë�í78qñ�ð?ë=4yê¬æ70�çyð>ç §£�Ò �ï,ë(4x8qé�è2æs£B®Aú ña é=4%8#îx8añ©ñ ù í78/°¬ì78qí�>Bg½ë(4VéNð>ë�í<8qñdÜKé�ì¬írð>ë�í<8qñ&ð?ë=4yê¬æ70�çyð>çR§� � ¤�¨ � � �   Q Ö ª t�� � ²¬Üï,ë(4�£�® ú ñaÈ2yæ78?4N8/0©çNé�6¬ì70¦·+6<8;2�ë=2�é�ñ1C(4�é�êYæ�ð?ë(4µê¬æ70�çyðÞÝJtM� ² ß×çN6¬è2æà2yæ½éE2�Ý F £�Ò � ¤ � � ï,ë=48¯é�è2æu£x®�ú ñaç%0�ì¬è?8;��0©çsèaë|ê74yë�í76¬èL2�ë´ïÀ2�æ<8u� � 0�ì±�i�>�D� 3 >@fIæ78aì ÷ í78/°½ì<8�ï,ë(4i8¯é´è2æuÓ¢®{� 6 2�æ78 ¼ ùð?ë(4µê¬æ70�çyð  âá�z Ó | t�� z Ó | ² Ü z Ý z Ó |,| ò%ö  âá�z Ó |X¤   Q Ö z Ó | 0¿ïÀÓ¢®{� � >hfIæ78qì ÷ §Ý ¤Æ¨ Ýâ�  âá ª t��%² Ü0©ç*é�ð?ë�í78qñ�ð>ë(4yê¬æ<0©çyð çN0©ì¬è98k�ã0�çX2yæ78�í70�ç,øµë(0�ì�2x6¬ì70�ë|ìWë�ï{2yæ78k� � >qgA674�2�æ7894yð>ë(4%8 ÷   á z Ó |�F   ��Õ-Ö z Ó |B¤  Q Ö z Ó |ØF £-L ² Ö ��×L� ¤   Q Ö z Ó | ï,ë(4Ié´ñ©ñd£q®¢ä:é�ì¬í/ÓP®±� �ÙØ >qfIæ7894%8aï,ë=4%8 ÷ §Ý F §£�Ò � ¤ §� � ï,ë(4*é�ñ©ñd£B®Aú ñaZ>qfIæ78ð?ë�í78qñ°ð?ë=4yê¬æ70�çyð §Ýu0�ç@6¬ì70¦·�678Qç%0�ì¬è?8^Ýu0©ç@6¬ì<0t·�678�é�ì¬í   á z Ó | 0�çh6¬ì70t·�678�ï,ë=4@8¯é�è2æsÓ�®e� 6 òY8aè¯é=6Yç%8ë�ïv2yæ78o6¬ì70¦·+6<8qì78açyç�ë´ïv2yæ78o0©í78aì�2%0�2Ëö;£yL ² Ö ��×L� > åMVöm4%8qç�254N0©è92%0©ì7C¡2�æ<8�èqéE2589C|ë(4µö )µ5 « ¯ z ë|ìÃð?ë�í78añ©çsë�û(8?4�é`°<U�8aíAò½é�çN8�C(4yé�ê¬æe� é�ìYíu2�æ<8Nò½é�çN8Nð>ë(4 ùê¬æ70©çµð|2�ë�òd8x2�æ<8@0©í78aì3250�2Ëöcë|ì?��úié�è2æ70�8aû=8*è¯éE2%8?C|ë=4µö ) 5 « ¯ z z � | ÷ 2yæ½éE2�0�çÀ0�çyë|ð>ë(4yêYæ70©èB2�ë:2yæ78Vïb6Yì¬è92yë(4è¯éE2%8?C|ë(4óöÃïb4µë|ðæ2�æ78çµð<é�ñ�ñfèqéE2589C|ë(4óö�0©ìYí76¬è?8aí�ò%ö»� é�ìYí�è¯éE2%8?C|ë(4óö ¼ >ZfIæ78�8LU�0�çN258aì¬è?8�ë�ï{èaë|ñD0�ðe0K2�ç0©ì�2�æ<8Fè¯éE2%8?C|ë=4µö )µ5 « ¯ z z � | 0�ç�ò½é�çN8qí�ë|ì�2�æ<8�8LU�0©ç�258qìYè?8�ë�ï�èqë|ñ�0©ð]0�2yç�0�ì ¼ é´ì¬í�èqë|ñ�0©ð]0�2�ç#é=4N8èqë|ì ùçN254N6¬è92%8qírê�ë(0©ì32Ëîi0�ç%8�0©ì<èqéE2589C|ë(4óö ¼ >qfIæ78w4%8açN254N0©èL258qí<è¯éE2%8?C|ë(4N0D8aç )µ5 « ¯ z z � | éE4%8�6¬ç%8aí/2�ëNèaë|ì¬ç�254%6Yè92é�ê<6¬çyæ¬ë=6<2:0�ì )µ5 « ¯ z ñüén258?4 ë|ì�>Ë;� 5 � 5¡­Ï�# ���5¡�%¢Y¤¦¥}¤�¢ð ÑØÅ Ü ÎgÉñÅ,ÂgÀ>ÁñÊ )µ5 « ¯ z z � | À>ß[ÒGÀ�ÌDÅ<ÐtÓkÀÄ>Å�Á�� æÆæÉ�ÑØÅ Ü ÎgÉñÅ,ÂgÀ>ÁñÊ ¼ Ã¦Ó Ü À�È Ü À>ÒuËØÐ�Å>ÉÝŠæßÉ�ÑØÅ Ü ÎgÉñÅ,ÂgÀ>Áñʼ ÃtÓ Ü À�È Ü À>Ò;Ë�Ð�Å�ÉñÅ ã \Í S5F�Fñ"h ë|ñD0�ðe0K2�ç�é=4%8rèaë|ì¬çN2%4%6¬èL258aíkê�ë(0©ì32Ëîi0�ç%8<ï,ë(4p2yæ78Wï-é�ð]0©ñ¿ö�ë�ï ¼ ù ð?ë=4yê¬æ70�çyð>ç?>¢fIæ78Zèqë�ñD0©ð]0�2cë|òSøN8qè92]0�çí78/°½ì<8qí/ò%ös6Yì70t·�678o8LU+2%8qì¬çN0©ë|ì¬ç�C(8aì78?4yéE258aí/ò%ö/2�æ<8Z4N8qçN6¬ñ�2%0©ì7C�í70©é=C(4�é´ð?ç9> å¹�îi0�2yè2æ70©ì7C>ïb4yë|ðàé>è¯éE2%8?C|ë=4µö )µ5 « ¯ z z � | ë�û(894�é<ò½é´ç%8�C=4�é�ê¬æ¶�ç2yëWé?èqéE2589C|ë(4óö )µ5 « ¯ z z � | ë�û(894Qéò½é�ç%8]C(4yé�ê¬ææ��0�ç�é´ñ�î é�ö�çcê°ë�çyç%0�ò¬ñD8¡0¿ïx2�æ<8?4%8]8LU�0�çN2�çNék2yë=22é´ñqC(4�é�êYæ�ð>ë(4yê¬æ<0©çyð � tj� ² �Ê>;fIæ70�ç

&(&

Page 74: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

çµîi0�2yè2æ70©ì<Cm0�çOC(0¿û(8qì�ò%ö�éWïb6¬ì¬èL2�ë(4Zß�Qst )µ5 « ¯ z z � | ² )µ5 « ¯ z z � | ÷ è¯é�ñ�ñD8qí �#SNH�gsLIKH��ÿ�F��`"��������GFnS 0�ì2�æ78�ï,ë|ñ©ñ�ë�îi0©ì7C ÷ 2�æ½éE2w6¬çN8qçw2yæ78Z4%8/°¬ì78qí�C=4�é�ê¬æYçw� z � | ë�ï[ìYë�í78açw�s0�ìm2yæ78Z0©ð?é=C(8Që�ï � ï,ë(4sí78/°¬ì70©ì7C<éð?ë�í78qñ�0©ìÞ�]> & 8/°¬ì78qíuC(4�é�êYæ¬çh� z � | ë�ïfì¬ë�í<8qçi�;0�ìÍ��è �Hz � | ÷ æ¬ë�îX8aû(894 ÷ é=4%8QìYë=2#èqë|ì¬çN0©í7894%8aí�>TP� UH�4�= >�#5¡�£¢j¤¦¥ø¤�é W   �>� �4­ *��  ���5¡�£© ½ � §  �5 � ZW 0¿û(8qì)éÊ2yë=22é´ñwC(4yé�ê¬æKð>ë(4yêYæ70©çµð � t�� ² � ÷ 2yæ78 �#S%H�gsLIKH�-ÿ�F��±"��������GFnS ß�Q¹t )µ5 « ¯ z z � | ²) 5 « ¯ z z � | 0©ç�í78�°½ì78aí>ï,ë(4[ð>ë�í78qñ�çv�µ0©ì )µ5 « ¯ z z � | òSö�ß¡Q z � |q¤ � F � é�ì¬íFï,ë(4[ð>ë�í<8qñYð>ë(4µê¬æ70©çµð?ç§ê ¤ë¨ £-L E �  \ì ª òSökß¡Q z §ê |B¤�¨ £yL 9 �Vß�Q z� \ì | ª ÷ îsæ78?4N8pß�Q z� \ì | z £ |q¤  vìVz��[z £ |,| ï,ë(4h8qé�è2æm£1®e� 6 > \!�é´è2ækð>ë�í<8qñ*ð>ë(4yêYæ70©çµð §� ¤¬¨ � �   Q ª tX�³² � 0©ì )µ5 « ¯ z 0©ì¬í76Yè?8qç?é�ð?ë�í78añ*ð?ë=4yê¬æ70�çyð §�dí ¤¨ £yL 9 �   Q5îïª t��Dz ß�Q z � | îsæ7894%8   Q5î z Ó |B¤   Q z Ó | ï,ë(4h8¯é�è2ækÓ�®e� 6 >½:¾ø� , �v*#� ¢j¤¦¥ W   �>� �Y­ *#�  >�#5¡�£© ½ � §  Ï5 � ©y5 � ,Ç5 «j�+* ­����J¿ �  ZfIæ78^8LUYé�ð>ê¬ñD8w0©ìsgv0DC(674N8 ¦ > ' çµæ¬ë�îsçIæ¬ë�îHéFð>ë�í78qñ&îi0�2yæWò½é�çN8^C(4�é�êYæG�}0©ç1254yé�ì¬çyñ©éE258aíZé�ñ©ë�ì7C � 2yë�éð?ë�í78qñ�ë�û(8?4�ò½é�çN8iC(4�é�êYæÔ�¡>ÀfIæ<8�4N8/°½ì<8qí;C=4�é�ê¬æï,ë(4�é�ìYë�í78h��ë�ïd2�æ78sð>ë�í78añ7��ë�û(8?4å�ð0�ç�è¯é�ñ�è?6¬ñ©éE258aíé�çmï,ë|ñ�ñ©ë�îsç?t h ë�ì¬ç%0�í78?4:2yæ78p0�ð<é=C=8 �Hz � | ë�ïq2yæ78Fì¬ë�í78j�m0�ì»�Ê>wf�é�E8p2�æ78�4%8/°¬ì78qí�C(4yé�ê¬æAë´ï �[z � | 2yë4%8/°¬ì78^2�æ78�ì¬ë�í78o�;0�ìÍ�¡>BfIæ78�ç�é�ð]8o0©çIêd8?4óï,ë(4yð]8qírï,ë(4@2yæ78o8qí7C(8E> \

G Hf

HG Vf

gÀ0�C(674%8 ¦ > ' tpñ SNH�gsLIKH��ÿ=��� � Fqõ+yLI sjH=IDF����Ô�GF���H=I¡�=SNH Q r � FnS Q r�ÿts � s?òúËìkèaë|ì3254�é´çN2¡2�ë�2�æ<8m8VU�0©çN2%8qì¬è98Ãë´ïmèaë|ê74µë�í76Yè92�ç ÷ 2yæ78k8LU�0©ç�258qìYè?8lë�ï�èaë|ñD0�ðe0K2�çZ0©ìr2�æ<8lèqéE2589C|ë(4óö ¼ 0�ç4%8�·�670�4%8aíÃï,ë(4#ê76¬çµæ¬ë(6<2yç:0©ìk2�æ<8�èqéE2589C|ë(4µö )µ5 « ¯ z >IúËì/é�í¬í70K250©ë�ì ÷ 2�æ<8Nê76¬çµæ¬ë(6<2mèqë�ì¬çN2%4%6¬èL250©ë�ì/ë�ï�2ËîVëð?ë�í78qñ°ð?ë=4yê¬æ70�çyð>ç@0©ì )µ5 « ¯ z 6¬ç%8açmñ�8aïÉ2sé´íwøµë(0©ì32yç*îi0�2�æk4N8qçyêd8qèL2i2�ë�254yé�ì¬çyñ©éE250�ë|ì<ïb6¬ìYè92�ë=4yç?>Bf\4�é�ìYçyñüé ù250©ë�ì�ïb6Yì¬è92yë(4yç�í¬ëNìYë=2�æ½é¯û(8:0�ìeC=8qì7894�é�ñ&ñD8�ïÉ2�é�íwøµë(0�ì32�ç ÷ 2yæ78?0�418VU�0©çN2%8qì¬è98�í78aêY8aì¬í¬çVë|ìe2yæ78mèqéE2589C|ë(4óö ¼ >úËìÇ$ B/é�ìAó & + 0©ç çyæ¬ë�îsìu2yæ½éE2sñ�8aïÉ2sé�í�øµë(0©ì32�çh8VU�0©çN2 ÷ 0�ïâ2�æ<8cèqéE2589C|ë(4óö ¼ 0�çsé�ñDC=8qò74yé=0©èqé�ñ©ñ¿ö(>iúËìYï,ë(4yð?éE2%0©ë|ì¬çé�ò°ë=6<2sñD8�ïÉ2#é�íwøµë(0�ì�2yçh0©ìkC(8aì78?4yé�ñýè¯é�ìZòd8Qï,ë(6¬ì¬ím0©ì�$b!åBu¥ � ÷ MX� (3��+ >fIæ78@0©í<8¯émë´ï72�æ78Vê76¬çµæ¬ë(6<2�èqë|ì¬ç�254N6¬è92%0©ë|ìFë´ïA2Ëî ë�ð>ë�í78qñSð>ë(4yê¬æ<0©çyð>ç §� é�ì¬í §Ùo0©ì ) 5 « ¯ z 0�ç�é´çfï,ë|ñ�ñ©ë�îsç?tgÀ0D4µçN2 ÷ 2�æ<8Vê76Yçyæ¬ë(6�2�ë�ï�2�æ7812�ë=2�é�ñ%ò½é�çN8 ð>ë(4yê¬æ<0©çyð>ç � é´ì¬í;Ùo0�çièaë|ì¬ç�254%6Yè9258aí�0©ìo2�æ78�è¯én258?C�ë(4µö��G�>�D� 3 >fIæ78?0�4�ê76¬çµæ¬ë(6<2�ë|ò�øN8aè92 ÷ è¯é�ñ�ñD8aí � 0�ìu2yæ78�ï,ë|ñ�ñ©ë�îi0©ì<C ÷ 0©çi2�æ78�ò½é�çN8�C(4yé�ê¬æAë�ïÀ2�æ78�ê76¬çyæYë(6<2Që|òSøN8qè92�ë�ï§� é�ì¬í §Ù[0©ì )µ5 « ¯ z >�úËì�ë(4µí78?4p2yëAí78�°½ì78s0�2yçp4%8�°½ì78aðe8aì�2 ÷ úo2%4�é�ìYçyñüén258e2yæ78rð>ë�í78añVð>ë(4µê¬æ70©çµð?çã§�é�ì¬í §Ù/0�ì�2yëð?ë�í78añ�ð>ë(4yê¬æ<0©çyð>ç*ë�ï\2�æ<8cèqéE2589C|ë(4óö )µ5 « ¯ z z � | ÷ îsæ7894%8�úVèqé�ìlèqë|ì¬ç�254N6¬è92i2�æ<8cê<6¬çyæ¬ë=6<2ê°ë(0�ì32Ëîi0©ç%8�é�èaèqë(4µí70©ì7C¡2�ë Oq4yë|ê�ë|ç%0K250�ë|ì ¦ >ê~�> ¦ >@fIæ<8j254yé�ì¬çµñüéE2%0©ë|ìlë�ïÀ2yæ78Nð>ë�í78qñýð>ë(4yêYæ70©çµð?ç §� é´ì¬í §Ù22é�E8qçFê¬ñ©é�è?8>ò%ö�ð]8¯é´ì¬çNë�ïx2�æ78?ñD8aïÉ2Né�íwøµë=0©ì32�çcîi0�2�æ`4%8açyêd8qè92�2�ëu2yæ78;2%4�é�ì¬çµñüéE2%0©ë|ì�ïb6¬ì¬èL2�ë(4µç�0�ì¬í76¬è98qíòSö¢2yæ78?ê<6¬çyæ¬ë=6<2Fð>ë(4yêYæ70©çµð?çQë�ïx2�æ78>ê76¬çµæ¬ë(6<2Në�ï � é�ì¬í�Ù�0©ìC�G�>�D� 3 >ka{892j6¬çNé�çyçN6¬ðe8 zbô � §Óâ� §õ |0©çj2yæ78rê76¬çµæ¬ë(6<2�ë´ïh2�æ78/2%4�é�ì¬çµñüéE2%8qí�ð>ë(4µê¬æ70©çµð?çj0©ì )µ5 « ¯ z z � | ÷ 2�æ<8qìc2�æ<8rê76¬çyæYë(6<2�ë|ò�øN8aè92 ô 0�ç0©ð>ðe8aí70üéE2%8qñ¿ö]2yæ78�ê76¬çµæ¬ë(6<2më|ò�øN8aè92#ë�ïʧ� é�ìYí §Ù;0©ì )µ5 « ¯ z >1fIæ<8�ê76Yçyæ¬ë(6�2�ð>ë(4yêYæ70©çµð?ç ï,ë=4ö§� é�ìYí §Ù

& ó

Page 75: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

é=4%8èaë|ì¬çN2%4%6¬èL258aí�ïb4yë|ðT2�æ78�ê76Yçyæ¬ë(6�2�ð>ë(4µê¬æ70©çµð?ç §Ó�é�ì¬í §õ é�ìYí¢2yæ78¡6¬ì70¿û(8?4µç�é�ñ{ð>ë(4yêYæ70©çµð?ç�ë´ïX2yæ78ïb4%8?8�èaë|ì¬çN2%4%6¬èL250�ë|ì¬ç?>Ë;� 5 � 5¡­Ï�# ���5¡�%¢Y¤¦¥}¤�÷ W �4½ ­�3Y5 ½  >­�Zð ÑØÅ Ü ÎgÉÝÅ<ÂgÀ>ÁÝÊ )µ5 « ¯ z Ñ Î�Ó�Î�ÐtÐ ËHÛÓ,ÑØÀRÛDÉ�Ó)Ãtß

â*ã É�ÑØÅ Ü ÎgÉñÅ,ÂgÀ>ÁñÊ ¼ Ñ�Î�Ó�Î�ЦРË[ÛÓ�ÑØÀ�ÛDÉ�Ó Î�ÆØÌõgã Ð�Å<ßñÉ ÎRÌVø�À>æơÉ�Ó{ù4Qjt )µ5 « ¯ z z � | ² )µ5 « ¯ z z � | Å%$�æÓÏÉDß-À>ÁMÉ�Á�Î�ÆgÓ,Ð=Î�É�Ã�À�Æ ßñÛÆ Ü ÉñÀ>Á�Ó\ß¡QZt ) 5 « ¯ z z � | ²)µ5 « ¯ z z � | à ã Á ã É ã ÎPÉÝÀ�ÉyÎ�Ð�ÂVÁ�Î/Ë�ÑÍÒGÀ>Á-Ë�ÑDÃtÓ�Ò � tR�µ² � ã

\Í S5F�Fñ"W 0¿û(8qì¢2ËîVë/ð>ë�í78añ[ð?ë=4yê¬æ70�çyð>ç�§� ¤�¨ � �   Q�ª t�ú ² ûâé�ì¬í §Ù ¤}¨ ÙY�   � ª t�ú ² ü ÷ 2yæ78?ê<6¬çyæ¬ë=6<2zbô � §ý �?§þ | ë�ï`§� é´ì¬í §Ù;0©ì )µ5 « ¯ z 0�çIèqë|ìYçN254N6¬è92%8qí/é�çIï,ë|ñ©ñ�ë�îsç9tÿ h ë|ì¬ç�254%6Yè92o2�æ78ê<6¬çyæ¬ë=6<2 z � � ý t Ú ² � � þ t × ² � | ë�ïX2yæ78ð>ë(4yê¬æ<0©çyð>ç � é�ì¬í»Ùu0©ì�2yæ78è¯éE2%8?C|ë=4µö¶�i���g� 3 >

ÿ a{892 §� �X¤ ¨ £yL � �   Q � ª t�ùHQ z ú | ² û)òY8^2�æ<8j6¬ì<0t·�678�ð?ë�í78añýð?ë(4µê¬æ70�çyð ï,ë=4hûHé�ìYím2yæ78�ð?ë�í78qñð?ë=4yê¬æ70�çyð §� í ¤Æ¨ £yL��\�   Q î ª t+ú ² ß¡Q z û | 0©ì¬í<6¬è?8aíAò%öT§� é�ì¬í §Ù�� ¤Æ¨ £yL��À�   � � ª t7ù � z ú | ² üòY8j2�æ78p6Yì70t·�678ð>ë�í<8qñið?ë(4µê¬æ70�çyðÓï,ë(4wühé´ì¬í�2�æ78Nð?ë�í78qñið>ë(4yê¬æ<0©çyð §Ù í ¤�¨ £yL��â�   � îDª t�ú ²ß¡Q z ü | 0�ì¬í76¬è98qíZò%ö §Ù�>qfIæ78aì ÷ èqë�ì¬çN2%4%6¬èL2h2�æ78�ê<6¬çyæ¬ë=6<2 zbô � §Óâ� §õ | ë�ï\ùf@ z §� � | é�ìYíkù�� z §Ù�� | 0©ì;2yæ78è¯éE2%8?C|ë=4µö )µ5 « ¯ z z � | >

ùi@ z ù4Q z ú |,|�K���� ���� � � ���� � �Q � � �� ùf@ z û |

����ù�� z ü | �×�� ô

O[ñD8¯é´ç%8�ì¬ë=2%0©è?8 ÷ 2�æ¬éE2�ùf@ z ùHQ z ú |�|�� ¤ ù�� z ù � z ú |�| >ÿ ôO8/°½ì<8o2yæ78�ð?ë�í78añ�ð>ë(4yê¬æ<0©çyð §ý t=üe² ß�� zbô | ò%ö §ý ¤ ß�� z §Ó |øF�� �� é�ìYím2yæ78Qð?ë�í78añ�ð?ë=4yê¬æ70�çyð§þ t3û£² ô ò%ö�§þ ¤ ß½@ z §õ |øF�� @� >

amë�îHîX8�æ¬é�û=8Z2yë�ê74yë�û(8o2�æ¬éE2 zbô � §ý � §þ | 0©çh0�ì¬í7898qíÃé�ê<6¬çyæ¬ë=6<2�ë´ï §� é�ì¬í §Ùe0©ì )µ5 « ¯ z >èqë|ð>ðp6<2�éE250¿û+0�2Ëödt��`8Væ½é¯û=8x2�ë#çyæ¬ë�îr2yæ½éE2 §ý F §Ù ¤ §þ F §� ÷ 0�>�8=> ¨ ý F Ùd�Vß � z�  � |/F   � ª ¤�¨ þ F � �Vß¡Q z#  @ |�F   Qnª >MVöhèqë|ìYçN254N6¬è92%0©ë|ì þ F � ¤ ý F Ùhé�ì¬íDîX8Aí78/°¬ì78 ê t ¤ ý F Ùd>Hú�2/4N8qð?é=0©ìYç]2yë�çyæ¬ë�îT2�æ½én2

ß � z#  � |jF   � ¤ ß¡Q z#  @ |jF   Q ÷ 0�>�8=>@2yæ½éE2:ß¡Q z#  @ |jF   Q ¤ ß¡Q z ß&@ z#  � |jF�� @� |jF   Q ¤ ß¡Q z ß½@ z#  � |,|jFß¡Q z � @� |[F   Q ¤ ß ì z�  � |[F ß¡Q z � @� |[F   Q ¤ ß ì z�  × |[F ß � z � �� |HF   � ¤ ß � z�  � |[F   � ë=4O2�æ½éE2o2yæ78í70üéEC(4�é�ð z ~ | òY8añ©ë�î�èaë|ð?ð�6<258aç?>ß�Q z û | 6 � ��� � ��� ß ì z ùf@ z û |�| 6�� � ±�� �� !!!!!!!

!!!ú± �#" $%%%%%%%%%± &' ((((((((( ����� ß ì zbô |

ß � z ü |*) ��� + ��� ß ì z ù�� z ü |�|

) � � ±�, �- .//////////

& ¥

Page 76: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

021�3X8547686N6:9e8z2; | ß ì z#  � |=< ß?> z �

@� |=<   > ¤ ß ì z�  � |@< ß ì z ùi@ z� > � |�|=<A� ìB

2DC78FEGCIHKJML:6�L<678^2DH¡2DC78o6:E70ON(89486D4PJ=Q748HKQd8?4�2SRTH71U4V1b4N8?8XWYH7E:6N2%4%6:WL250MH7Ez ß ì z#  × |=< ß�> z �

@� |=<   > | � ¤   � < ùf@ z�  > � |[Z¹�0MEIW?8VL70M4=C(4D4P9 z Ä | 0M6\4]Q<6:68C:H=6<2547E:L^WYHK9_9p6<2%8Y6\3X8¡C(892 z ß ì z#  × |�< ß?> z � @� |`<   > | � ¤   � <ùf@ z#  > � |B¤   × < ù�� z#  � � |q¤ z ß ì z#  × |=< ß � z � �� |=<   � | � 6N6:WaCu28C�4E2AL70M4=C(48479 z ~ | WYHK9_9p6<2%8Y69>0�2i4%8F9b4=0cE:6@2DHd6eC:H�3�2DC�4n2 zSf | 0M6@2%4%678Pg:3AC78?4N8o0�2i0M6h8FE:H(67C7Cm28H_6eC:H�3�2DC:4E2

ß�> z � @� |=<   > ¤ ß ì z ùf@ z# > � |,|=<�� ìB Z

g�H(4h6eC:H�3i0ME7CP28C�4E2Yg�WYHKE:6N0ML7894�2DC<8/6:E70K2 � @ t�i�«kjXlm�no � � � ² ß&@ < ùi@XH71h2DC78p47LrqN6:E:WL250cHKErùf@8g3AC78?4N85s�RTWFHKE:6�254%6IW9250cHKEtH71v28C78o6:E70K2h2DC78u1�HKJcJMH�3i0ME7ChL70v4=C=4D479wWYHK9_9p6<2%8Y69>ù�> z ú | ± � � ��

� � � � � B �K� ��û� � � ���ß½@ z ùf@ z ù�> z ú |�|,|) � �� � ± � � ���

�� ß½@ z ùi@ z û |,|Mx8YWY4=6:6N85H71 � ìB ¤ ß�> z � @ z ù�> z ú |,|�|x<A� > 28C78XH(6<2%8?4�L70M4=C(4D4P9ysd8YJMH�3zWYHK9_9p6<2%8Y69>

ß ì z ù ì z ú |�|) � � �� � ± � � ����� ß ì z ùf@ z û |�|

ß�> z ù�> z ú |�|) � ��� � � � � B ���K� � � ) � � ± � � � ��{

ß?> z û |) � �|� � �� �

ú� �} � � ± ��~��������������

f�C78?4N8F1�H(4N87gYß�> z � @� |=<   > ¤ ß ì z ùf@ z#  > � |,|=<�� ìB >6:E70ON(8?4e6D47J@Q74eHKQY894N2SRdtha{892 §� ¤Æ¨ � �  �� ª t�ü±² ��47E:L §� t+û ² ��sd8Z2S3�Hp9_H�L78FJ=9�H=48Q:C70c689_6A6%6:WaC

2DC�4n2 §� < §� ¤ §� < §Ù�g70�>�8=> � < � ¤ � < ÙT47EILPß�> z�  = |=<   > ¤ ß � z� @� |=<   � >¹�0MEIW?8 z � � ý � þ | 0c6�Q76:68CIH(6<2�H71 � �,Ù/0cEs2DC78XW4n258?C7H(4eR¶�i�>�D�`��gA2DC7894%8o0M6�4�6:E70¦·�678^2DH=2D47J{C(4D4PQ:C9�H=48Q:C70c689ãÝ�t � ² ��6N6:WaC]28C�4E21Ý < ý ¤ � 4PE:LeÝ < þ ¤ � >qa{892  @� � t�ù@� z ü | ² ß á z � | sY8h28C786:E70¦·+6<8�9�H=48Q:C70c689�H71q28C78h1b4N8?8�WFHKE:6N2%4%6:WL250cHKE�1�H(4  �� t<üæ² ß�� z ß á z � |�| 47E:Lu2DC78�2%4D47EI68Jv4n250MH7E1b6:E:WL2DH(4/ß���> w�E�47JcH(C:g�J�892   = � t�ùf@ z û | ² ß á z � | sY8m2DC78�6IE70t·�678G9�H(4eQ:C70c689 H71O28C78�1b4%898WYHKEI6N254N6:W92%0MHKE]1�H(4   = t(û£² ß½@ z ß á z � |,| 4PE:Ls2DC78^254847E:6eJv4E2%0MHKEp1b6:EIW92DH=4:ß½@5>ùf@ z ù`> z ú |,|

������ ���� � � ���� � �> � � �� ùi@ z û |

���� ±� ��� ����

��������

���ù��[�Éük� �×

��

±�� � ��            

         ô

±�¡�¢£ (((((

((((�

&K¤

Page 77: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

�Ê8¥476e6%6:9]8XE:H�3� ;�; �u��ß?>¦�   = � <   > � � ¤   = � < ùf@a�   > � ��47E:L§��ß � �   � � <   � � � ¤   � � < ù��[�   � � �

¹�0MEIW?8wß?>��   = � <   > ¤ ß � �   � � <   � s�RdQ<4%8Y9]0M6N8Xg�3X8�C(892   = � < ùf@��   > � � ¤   � � < ù��[�   � � �L>M¹�0ME:W98��Ä��:0c6XQ76:68CIH(6<2j0ME )�¨ « ¯ z � � ��gâ28C78?4N8¡0M6¥4m6IE70t·�678d9_H(48Q:C<0M689   á t ô ² ß á ���U��6%6IWaCÊ2DC�4n2  á <   � ¤   = � 47E:L   á <   × ¤   � � >Zf�C78YE©1�HKJcJMH�3A6^ß��[�   á � <   � ¤ ß��[�   á � < ß��[�   × � <�� �� ¤ß��a�   á <   × � <�� �� ¤ ß��[�   � � � <A� �� ¤   � 47E:LG47E�4PJMH(C]ß½@��   á � <   @ ¤   = >f�C78?4N8F1�H(4N87g:1�H(4 §Ý ¤�¨ Ýâ�   á ª t ô ²ª�«C:HKJcL:6 §Ý < §ý ¤ §� 47EIL §Ý < §þ ¤ §� >qf�C78Z6:E70t·�678FE78Y6e6�HP1 §Ý1�HKJMJcH�3A6¬1b48HK9È2DC78o6:E<0t·�678YE<8Y686�H71vÝ�47E:L   á >0�2�4N8Y9�4=0ME:6â2DH�68C:H�3�2DC:4E2A� fKf �{0M6v2%4%678Et\�`8¬C:4�N=8x2DH�68C:H�3�2DC�4n2Bß�>���ß½@��   = � < ùi@��   > � �8�8� <�� @ ¸ >B ¤ß?>��   = � <   > 4N8Y6eQ�>7ß�>���ß½@��   � � < ù��[�   � � �8�e� <�� @ ¸ >B ¤ ß � �   � � <   � g�6N0ME:W98�28C78�WYJv4E0M9­1�H7JMJMH�3A6q2DC<8YE1b48HK9J2DC78q6IE70cN=8?486847J�Q74eHKQY894N2SRuHP1:4�1b4%898�WYHKE:6�254N6:W92%0MHKE�>â�`8�C�4N(8xß?>���ß&@��   = � < ùi@��   > � �e�8� <K� @ ¸ >B ¤ß?>���ß&@a�   = � �8� < ß�>¦��ß½@���ùi@[�   > � �e�8� <®� @ ¸ >B ¤ ß�>���ß½@��   = � �e� < ß�>¦� � @� � <   > ¤ ß�>���ß½@��   = � � <®� @� � <   > ¤ß?>��   = � <   > >Bf�C78XW4P6%8jß?>���ß&@a�  �� � < ù��a�   � � �e�8� <�� @ ¸ >B ¤ ß � �  �� � <   � 0M6�6eC:H�3AE�47E:47JMH(C7H(6:68JOR(>

å½:¾ø� , �v*#� ¢j¤�Ì°¯ �4½ ­ � ¨ ½   ©2¨ � ,±¨ «j��* ,±¨ ����� ��­-,Ç­����J¿ �  7²³ HKE:6%0cL78?4/28C78�2S3�H´9_H¦L78YJ�9�H(4eQ:C70c689_6Ô§� 47E:L §ÙR0MEögÀ0�C(674%8 ¦ > ¦ >ëf�C78�2S3�H´9b4=0cE°6N2%8YQ:6]H71o28C78

BA

α f

f

g

αgC

gÀ0�C(674%8 ¦ > ¦ tpñkµ F � FY¶+yLI � FnS Q�·¦¸M¹L�h¹X¸»º ¿ �  \¼ S5F ��½�· H ½¾½�· y Q?¿�¹a· F ¿¦½�¹a· H=IÉI � y���F ºI¹[½ S ¿ � ½ y8¶3òQ76:68CIH(6<2¥WYHKEI6N254N6:W92%0MHKE§4=4N8_6eC:H�3AEÊ0cE`gv0DC(674N8 ¦ > � tof�C78�°A486�2¥6N258FQxg@68C:H�3AE±H7E[28C78dJD8F1É2ÁÀSC�4PE:L©6%0cL78H71h2DC78Ô°AC(674N87gq0M6j2DC78pQ<6:68C:H=6<2VWYH7E:6N2%4%6:WL250MH7E«H71i2DC78ps:476%8p9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9�6Z0ME`2DC78TWY4E2589CKH(4eR%�G�>�D���B>f�C78YExg�3x8m254D4PE:68JM4E258s2DC<8GL70M4=C(48479 0cE gÀ0�C(674N8 ¦ > ¦ 0ME328H±4^L70v4EC(4D479 0ME�2DC78]W4n258?C7H(4eR )�¨ «vz�� � �N�0M4u2DC<8pJD8[1É2�47L�qeH(0ME32�28HP2DC<8;254847E:68JM4E250cHKE§1b6IE:W928H(4�0cE:L76:W98YL«s�RÊ28C78/C(4847Q:CÂ9_H(48QIC70M6e9 þ < � 4N8Y6eQ�>ý < Ùd>�f�C<8O4%8F6%6:JK250ME<ChL70M4=C(4D4P9 0M6¬6eC:H�3AETHKE;28C78O4%0�CKC32eÀ2C�47E:L�6%0ML<8=>�Ã�JD8Y476%8�E:H=250cW?8Pg+28C�4E2x2%4D47EI68Jv4n250MH7EH71:28C78G9_H¦L78YJhûµ0ME32DH§4*9_H¦L78YJ�H�N(894 � C(8YE<8?4D4n258Y6_1b4%898YJcR´4PE 8YJ�8Y9]8YE32¡2DH§L78/°�E<8u2DC<8G9�47Q:Q70cE7C7>f�C78YExgX2DC78tQ76:6eC:H(6<2e0ME )�¨ « Á?Â�à � � �p0c6VWYHKE:6�254N6:W92%8YL°s�R�WYH7E:6N2%4%6:WL250ME<C`2DC<8tQ<6:68C:H=6<2;0cE ¿ �   1�H=4847WaC�WFHK9_Q®HKE<8YE32->hf�C78j4%8F6%6:JK250ME<C�9_H�L<8YJkH�N(8?4 � 0c6�28C785Q<6:68C:H=6<2\HKs�qN8YW92�H71 §� 47E:L §Ù�>if�C78¥3AC:HKJ�8Q76:68CIH(6<2�0ME:WFJD6:L<0ME7Cp28C78XQ76:68CIH(6<2�9�H(4eQ:C70c689_6@0M6�6eC:H�3AEP0MEmgÀ0�C(674N8 ¦ > & >Ä �j� ¨ �>� , ¢Y¤¦¥}¤vÅ�¯ § ¨:Æ § ¨Y, �À*#�   � � � ­Ï­�¨�©w)Ǩ « ¯ z ²ð ÑØÅ Ü ÎgÉñÅ,ÂgÀ>ÁÝÊ )Ǩ « ¯ z ÃtÓ Ü À�È Ü À>ÒuËØÐ�Å>ÉÝÅ_Ãtß ¼ ÃtÓ Ü À�È Ü À>ÒuËØÐ�Å>ÉÝźÎ�ÆØÌuÐ�Å<ßñÉ4ÎVÌVø�À>ÃtÆ¡É�ÓºÅ%$�ÃtÓ�ÉYß-À>ÁqÉ�Á�Î�ÆgÓ,Ð=Î�É�Ã�À�ÆßñÛÆ Ü ÉÝÀ>Á,Ówß�>jt )�¨ « ¯ z �ÉÈ©�M² )�¨ « ¯ z ���h� à ã Á ã É ã ÂVÁ<Î�Ë�ÑPÒPÀ�ÁyË�ÑDæÓ,Ò`Ó � tR�µ² È ã Ê

ó7Ë

Page 78: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

C D

c

Af

B

g b

PO

F (B)bF (F (A))

F (C) Dg

b f

PO

gÀ0DC(6<4%8 ¦ > � tZñx· y Q?¿�¹a· F ¿¦½ F ¼ ½»· y¬Ì=SNH Q�·]� FnS Q�·¦¸M¹L�h¹A¸»º �G�>�D��� H º ¶ ½»· y Q?¿�¹a· F ¿¦½ F ¼ ½»· y ½ S%H ºI¹ IKH ½ y8¶¶ ¸ H�Ì=SNH �͸»º )�¨ «`Î °ÐÏ �� � ò

A

α f

αc

f

g

C

B

αg

c

b

D

αb

gÀ0�C(674N8 ¦ > & txͬ¿�¹a· F ¿¦½�¸»º )�¨ « Á?Â�à òÍ S5F�F ¼f�C78hWFJv4=0c9Ñ1�HKJcJMH�3A6�L70D4N8YWL2DJcRb1b48HK9ÒÃq48H7Q®HK6N0�2%0MHKE ¦ >|Ó�> ' 47EIL�Ãq48HKQ?HK6N0�250cHKE ¦ >|Ó�> & 47E:Lm2DC78X1É47WL2�28C�4E2�4W4E2%8?CKH(4ÁR/2DC:4E2AC�476�47JcJxWYHKQ<48H¦L76:W9286�47E:LG47JMJ®Q76:68CIH(6<2D6�C�476�47JcJxWYH7JD0M9]0�286?> å¢Y¤¦¥}¤¦¥ )�¨ «j�+* ­ � � «�Ë �D�  >� �A* )�¨ «j�+* )�¨ �>��� ��­-,æ­_�E3250cJxE:H�3Xg�0x4N8�·�670D4N8YLG4p2DH=2D47J�C(4847Q:C]9�H=48Q:C70c689w1�H(4@2DC78Xs�4P6%8X9�H=48Q:C70c689ÑH71U4V9_H�L<8YJx9_H(48QIC70M6e9u>0uWYHKE:6N0ML7894hE:H�3 Q H=S ½Ð¸ H=I � FY¶+yLI � FnS Q�·¦¸M¹L�h¹[g@3AC<8?4%8/28C78bs:476%8p9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9Þ0M6¥Q�4=4�250v4PJ�>mg�H(45Q:4=4N2%0v47J9�H¦L78YJ�9�H=48Q:C70c689_6YgÔ3X8¡4%8/·+6<0D4%8d4 ¼ ÀS9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9ÒHKE:JcRG1�H(4:28C78dE:H�L<8Y6^0ME�28C78dL:HK9�4=0ME�H71B2DC78ds�476N89�H(4eQ:C70c689m>ÕP��Ö �4�= >��¨¡�£¢j¤¦¥ø¤c×°¯ �4�D�  >� �A* ,±¨ «j��* ,±¨ �>�`� ��­?,´²Ø Q H=S ½É¸ H=I � FY¶+yLI � FnS Q�·¦¸M¹L� §� ¤ ¨ � �   >�ª ti�n² � sd892S3X8?8FEÙ9�H¦L78YJc6]�ÚH�N=8?4 �Û4PE:LR� H�N=8?4È 0M6jC(0cN=8YEÂs�R±4�Q�4=4�250M47JBC(4D47QICÂ9�H=48Q:C70c689 � tH�ÝÜ È 47E:LÂ4G1É479]0MJcR�H71 ¼ ÀS9_H(48QIC70M6e9�6   > ¤«   > �#£2�[tw�A�#£2�¶² �§� � �#£S�e� ­ £u®ÑÞ�rß*� � � ) ¯ gA6%6IWaCö28C�4E2p1�H=4p47JcJ�8FL7C(8F6 � tw£i² à�0cEÙÞ�rß*� � �Áá`g�§� � � � �8� <   > �#£2� ¤   > �Oà¦� < �A� � �L> ÊâGH�L<8YJM6b47E:L°Q:4=4N2%0v47JA9_H�L78FJA9�H(4eQ:C70c689_6�L78�°�E78©4§W4E2%8?CKH(4ÁR )Ǩ «ÀzB>ðf�C78�WY4E2589CKH(4ÁR )�¨ «vz©0c647E¢8LU+258FE:6%0cHKE§HP1128C78VW4n258?C7H(4eR )�¨ « ¯ z s�R^47L:L<0ME7C/28C78dQ�4=4N2%0v47J@9_H�L78FJU9_H(48Q:C<0M689_6?>¥0SL78FE�2%0�2%0D8Y6^0cE)Ǩ «Àz´4=4%8jC(0cN=8YE�s�Rm0ML78FE3250�2%0D8F6w0cE )�¨ « ¯ z >�f�C78 ��F �:Q F ¹[¸»½É¸ F ºbH71�2S3�HpQ�4E4N250M47Jk9�H¦L78FJ@9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9�6

ó�Ä

Page 79: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

§� ¤ ¨ � �   > ª td�]² �ã47E:L §Ù ¤ ¨ ÙY�   � ª t�� ² ¶ 0c6\L78/°:E78YL^s�R §Ù < §� ¤�¨ Ù < � �   �N¸ > ª td� ² ¶3AC78?4N8   �N¸ > �#£S�xt ¤   � � � �b£S�8� <   > �#£S��1�H(4@84PWaCm£B®©Þ��ß*�#Ù < � � ) >qf�C78X476e68H¦W?0M4E250ON�0K2SR_H71@WYHK9_Q®H76%0�2%0MHKEC:HKJMLI6�L7678^2DH¡2DC78¥476e68H¦W?0M4E250ON�0K2SRbHP1v28C78XWYHK9_Q®H76%0�2%0MHKE;0MEe�G�>�D����ä*47E:Lm0ME ¼ >f�C785WFHKE:6�254%6IW9250cHKEtH71`Q<6:68C:H=6<2D6�476i0ME3254eH�L<6:W?8FLu0cEk28C78XQ748H¦H71�H71 ¦ >åÓ�>KÄu1�H(4�9_H�L78FJx9_H(48Q:C<0M689_6�3i0�28C2DH=2D47Jks�476%859�H=48Q:C70c689_6�WY47E:E:HE2\sd85J�0c1É258FLu6IQP2DH;28C78hWY4E2589CKH(4ÁR )�¨ « ¯ z 6N0ME:W98j2%4D47E:6eJv4E2%0MHKE]1b6:E:WL2DH(4e63i0�2DCJ4%8F68Qd8YWL2u28H�Q�4E4N250M47JOC(4847Q:Cæ9�H=48Q:C70c689_6TL:H´E:H=2tC�4N(8§JD8F1É2t4PLrqeH(0ME3286?>Èf�C70M6m0M6TL76<8[28Hà28C781É47W92Yg@2DC�4E2e2DC78P4%8/°:E78YLöC(4847Q:C:6_1�H(4bE:H¦L78F6pH(6<286%0ML<8�H71^28C78�L:HK9�4=0cE�3�H(6:JMLçE:H=2psd8�4N8 Ç 8FW9258FLès�R2DC78�2%4D47EI68Jv4n250MH7Et1b6:EIW92DH=486YgÔ6%6:WaC�2DC:4E2:28C70M6w0MEI1�H(4e9b4n250MH7EtWY47E�E:HE2\sd8p4%8FWYHKE:6�254N6:W92%8YL©1b48HK9�28C78h1b4%898WYHKE:6�254N6:W92%0MHKE�4=C�4=0cE�>@_�EI1�H(4N2%6:E�4E2%8YJORKg�E:H=2�HKE:JORs2DC�4E2i28C78hQ76I68C:H(6�2\WYH7E:6N2%4%6:WL250MH7E�W4PE:E:H=2�sY8¥JD0O1É258FL6:Qxg�2DC<8pQ76:6eC:H(6<2VHP1h2DH=2D47J�9_H¦L78YJ�9_H(48Q:C<0M689_6�0cE )�¨ « ¯ z 0M6j0MEcC=8YE7894D47J�E78?0K2DC7894j2DC<8pQ76:6eC:H(6<2�0cE)Ǩ «Àz«476h2DC<8X1�H7JMJMH�3i0cE7C�WYH=6:E3258?4N8LUI479_Q:JD8X6eC:H�3A6?>½:¾ø� , �v*#� ¢j¤�¢è¯ § ¨ ½ �Ø  �R�>��¾}� , �v*�� ²f�C78j8VUI479�QIJD8^0MEmgÀ0�C(674N8 ¦ >�óV68CIH�3A6i2DC<8¥Q<6:68C:H=6<2�HP1À2DC<8o2S3�He28H=2a4PJx9�H¦L78FJx9�H=48Q:C70c689_6 §� t�ú ² ü47E:LÛ§þ t@ú ² ûÈ0ME�2DC<8GWY4E2589CKH(4eR )�¨ « ¯ Á?Â�à >¹f�C78ts�476N8PC(4847Q:C:6_H71w2DC78t9�H¦L78FJM6_4=4%8tL7484�3AEçs�RW?0D4eWYJ�8Y6YgA28C78?0�4w4N8/°�E78FL�E:H¦L78Y6�4=4%8¥L78FQ70MWL258YLP0ME:6N0ML78E>�é�H¦L78Y6�4=4%8Z4%8�°�E78FL�2DH_6%89286u47E:Lu8YL7C=8Y6w28He28H=2a47J9b47QIQ70ME7C76?>xf�C<85s�4P6%8h9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9�6�HP1�2DC78¥9_H�L78FJ=9�H=48Q:C70c689_6�9b4PQGE:H¦L78F6�HKEk2DC78¥E:H¦L78Y6�3i0�28Cm28C786D479]8AE+6I9�sY894?>qf�C78�Q76:6eC:H(6<2�H71 §� 47E:L §þ 0ME )Ǩ « ¯ Á?Â�à 0M6�E:H=2¬4XQ76:68CIH(6<2X0ME )Ǩ « Á?Â�à t ³ HKE:6N0ML7894128C78

d^

1

1

?

a

b

q

p

c

^

1

1 2

2

2

A

C

B

D

^

^

^

^

E

gÀ0�C(674%8 ¦ >�ó�t¬ê F ½ y%H�� ·�Q?¿�¹a· F ¿¦½�¸»º )Ǩ « ¯ z ¸M¹xQ?¿�¹a· F ¿¦½¬¸»º )�¨ «vz ò9�H¦L78YJ�9�H=48Q:C70c689_6 §ë 47E:L §ì gK3AC78?4N8 §ë 0M6�WYH79�Q:J�892%8YJcRZ6:EIL78/°�E<8YLp4PE:L §ì 0M6`L78/°�E<8YLbH7E:JcR¥1�H(4À28C78�E:H¦L78Ó�>�0�2�W4PEhsd8X8Y476%0cJcRXWaC78FWaí=8YLÔg(2DC�4E2 §ë < §� ¤ §ì < §þ g76%0cE:W?8�Þ�rß*� ë < � � ¤ Þ��ß*� ì < þ � ¤ïî >[¹+0ME:W98�Q76I68C:H(6�2D60ME��i���g�`��4=4%8V4PJM68H�Q76:6eC:H(6<286^0ME��i���g�`� ä 2DC7894%8p0c6\4/6:E<0t·�678�9_H(48QIC70M6e9�Ýct � ² �y6N6:WaC�2DC�4n22DC78¡4%8/·�670D4N8YL^L70v4EC(4D479_6\WFHK9�9�6<258E>�Mx6<2Ygk3X8dC�4N(8¡2S3¬HtQ?HK686N0Ms70cJD0�2%0D8F6�28HtL<8/°�E78¡2DC<8 ¼ À29�H(4eQ:C70c689  á �ðÓ7�L> Êf�C70M6�WYH(6:E32%8?4%8VUI479�QIJD8�J�847LI6e2DH[2DC78GWYHKE�qN8YW92%674%8u2DC�4E2e2DC78GW4E2%8?CKH=4eR )�¨ «ÀzñL:H�8F6bE:HE2bC�4N=8^47JMJQ76:68CIH(6<2D69>¹+0ME:W98uQ�4=4N2%0v47J®9�H¦L78FJx9�H=48Q:C70c689_6�WYH7E:6%0c6N2AH71`4VQ�4=4N2%0v47JYC(4D4PQ:C]9�H(4eQ:C70c689Í4P6�s�476%8X9_H(4ÁÀQ:C70M6e9Ú47EIL�4 ¼ À29�H(4eQ:C70c689_6�1�H(4À28C78AE:H¦L78Y6q0cEp2DC78�L:H79b4=0cE�H71�2DC<8�s:476%8�9_H(48QIC70M6e9Ggn2DC78AQ76:6eC:H(6<2B0cE)Ǩ «Àz�1�H(4q2DC<8�s:476%8�9�H=48Q:C70c689_6�C�476q2DH¥sd8�WFHKE:6�254%6IW9258FL/0MEi�i���g�`� ä >�f�C7894%8[1�H(4%8Pg+28C78�s:476%8�C(4D4PQ:CH71�2DC<8\Q76:6eC:H(6<2¬HKs¦qN8YWL2h0ME;gÀ0DC=674%8 ¦ >�ó¥WYH7E�2D4=0MEI6X2DC<8w2S3�HVE:H�L<8Y6�47EILe2DC<8O8YL7C=8=>Bg�H(410�2D614%8�°�E78F9e8FE�2Yg

óKÓ

Page 80: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

3x8�L:HhEIH=2¾C�4N(8\4PE�RdL<0còY8?4%8FE32�WaCIH(0MW98�28C�47E¡2DC�4E210cE]28C78w8VUI479�QIJD8h2DHZ8YE:6N674%8�2DC78AWFHK9�9�6<2a4E2%0cN+0�2SRhH712DC785L70v4=C=4D479Ò47EILP2DC7853x8FJMJOÀ2L78/°:E70�2%0MHKEtH71�28C78�9�47Q:Q70cE7C_1�H=4w2DC<8�4%8�°�E78FL�8YL7C(8E>^Mx6<2Ygx476w8LU�Q:JM4=0ME78FL0MEs2DC78o8VU:4P9�Q:J�87g<28C70M6h0c6�E:H=2i2DC<8¥Q<6:68C:H=6<2�0ME )�¨ «Àz1>ó�N=8YEÛ0c1Z2DC78^W4n258?C7H(4eRÙ9�4R°E:HE2GC:4�N=8±4PJMJ�Q<6:68C:H=6<2D6Fgu0bQ74eH�N+0cL78^WYHKE:L<0�250cHKE:6p1�H(4TQ:4=4N2%0v47J�9�H¦L78YJ9�H(4eQ:C70c689_6w6:EIL78?4\3AC70cWaC�2DC78hQ76:68CIH(6<2o8LU�0c6N2D69>of�C78Y6N8_WFHKE:L70K250cHKE:6�8YE:6N674%8�2DC:4E2:28C78VQ76:6eC:H(6<2uWY47EsY8�WFHKE:6�254%6IW9258FL§Q?H(0cE�2S3i0c6%8Pg�0�>�8=>�2DC7894%8d4=4N8�E:HTQ74eHKQ�4=CK4E250cE7C/8FòY8YWL2D6X476�1�H(4O0MEI6N2a4PE:W?8�28C78�CKJ�670ME7C�H712DC78i8YJ�8Y9]8YE32D610MEdE:H¦L78�Ó^0MEegÀ0DC(6<4%8 ¦ >�ó�> Ø 2_°A4e6N2g�3X8:0cE�2%48H¦L76:W98i28C78AQ®H=0ME32S3i0M6N8�WFHKE:6�254%6IW9250cHKE_H71�28C78Q76:68CIH(6<2¾1�H(4q2DH=2D47J�9�H¦L78FJ�9�H(4eQ:C70c689_6?>\f�C70M6¾WYHKEI6N254N6:W92%0MHKEe0M6�H(4N0DC(0cE�47JMJORoC(0cN=8YEe0MEGô�f�4=8 ¤(&Põ 47E:L�47JM6eH6:6%8FL�0ME]ô figUöOl ¤K¤rõ >ÀM�476%8FLVHKE�28C70M6�Q®H(0cE32S3i0M6%8¬Q76:68CIH(6<2�WFHKE:6N2%4%6:WL250cHKEh1�H(4\2DH=2D47J�9_H¦L78YJ¦9�H=48Q:C70c689_6Yg2DC78XQ76:6eC:H(6<2A1�H(4�Q:4=4N2%0v47Jx9_H¦L78YJx9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9�6x0M6�WYH7E:6N2%4%6:WL258YL�>¼ ¨¡�Y­/  ��½ §  >�ɨ¡�¾¢Y¤¦¥}¤c÷°¯ � ¨¡���Ø �ø ��­ �P�4½ ­ � ¨ ½   § ¨¡�4­/  ��½ §  >��¨¡��²ù Ã-Ä>Å�ƱÉyàMÀiÉñÀ�É-Î�Ð�æÆ-ø�Å Ü É�ÃyÄ�ÅqÒGÀ�ÌDÅ<Ð�ÒGÀ>ÁyËØÑDÃtÓ�ÒÔÓ §� t(ú ² §Ú Î�ÆØÌm§þ t §Ö ² §×_ú É�ÑØÅåË[ÛÓ�ÑØÀ�ÛDÉ�� ô � §ý �q§Þ¦�À>ß §� Î�ÆØÌP§þ ÃtÆ )�¨ « ¯ z ÃtÓ Ü À�ÆDÓÏÉ�ÁÏÛ Ü ÉñÅ�ÌÞÎ�Óªß-À>ÐtÐ#À�àMÓÏá

â*ã'ä À>ÆDÓ�É�ÁÏÛ Ü É)É�ÑØźË[ÛÓ�ÑØÀ�ÛDɺÀ>ß � Î�Æ¡Ì þ æƶ�G�>�D��� ãÖ=:ûü

@�ýþ ×»ûüÚ � ýþ �

õgãuð ÑØÅuÒPÀ�ÌDÅ�Ð ô ÀÄ>Å<Á � ÃtÓ Ü À>ÆDÓÏÉ�ÁÏÛ Ü ÉñÅ/Ì{Î�Ó'ß-À>ÐtÐ#À�àMÓÏák¿�À>Á'Î�ЦÐÀÓ ® � ) É�ÑØÅ<Á�ÅuÃtÓ'ÎgɪÒGÀ>ÓÏÉ�À�ÆØÅõ ®eÖ ) àMÃ-É�Ñ ý ) < � ) � õ � ¤ ÓÞÓ�ÃtÆ Ü Å � Î�ÆØÌ þ Î�Á�ŪÃtÆ-ø�Å Ü É�Ã-Ä>Å ã�ð ÑØÅ�Æ ú àMÅ Ü Î�ƱÛ�ÆDÃ#"gÛ�Å<Ð�ÊeÌgÅ�ÆØÀ�ÉÝÅÉ�ÑØÅqË[ÛÓ,Ñ¡À�ÛDÉ�À>ß   = � õ ��Î�ÆØÌ   @ � õ �)ÃtÆ ¼ ü�Ê*ÿ�� × Î�ÆØÌæü�Ê   � � � � õ �8�Ot7ü¾� � � õ �8�)² ô �bÓ®��Î�ÆØÌ  » � þ � õ �e�xt3ûu� þ � õ �e�M² ô �ÉÓ®� É�ÑØźË[ÛÓ�ÑØÀ�ÛDÉMÒGÀ>ÁyËØÑDÃtÓ�ÒÔÓ ã�ð ÑØÅ�Æ ú àMÅ'ÌDÅ��DÆ¡Å ô ß-À>Á)Î�ЦÐ�Ó�® � á

ô �bÓ®�xt ¤�������� �������ÿ�� × �<Ãtß� õ ®eÖ ) t ý ) < � ) � õ � ¤ Óü¾���� �<Ãtß��¡® Ú ) è � ) ��Ö ) �@t ý ) � �� ¤ Óûu���� �<Ãtß��¡® × ) è þ ) ��Ö ) �xt�Þ ) � K� ¤ Ó�+ä � �Éÿ���� ��×L� �Dÿ�� Ï ��×L� � �<Ãtß� � ®¶Ö�á[t ý á < � á¾� � � ¤ Ó  � ���F� � �e� < ü�� � � <   � ����� � �8��� � �)æß� � ® Ú ámè � á���Ö�á@�ht ý á¾� � � ¤ Ó  » ���F� � �e� < û\� � � <   » ����� � �e� � � �)æß� � ® × ámè þ á¾��Ö�á@�xt�Þ�á�� � � ¤ Ó

àMÑØÅ�Á�Å��ä � �Ðÿ�� � ��×L� �aÿ�� Ï ��×L� ��ÃtÓ É�ÑØÅ4ÒPÀ�ÁyË�ÑDæÓ,ÒèÃtÆØÌ�Û Ü Å/Ì�ü�ÊÔÉ�ÑØźÛÆDÃyÄ�Å�Á�Ó�Î�Ð>Ë[Û�Ó,ÑØÀ�ÛgÉ�Ë�Á�À�Ë[Å�ÁÏÉ�ÊÀ>ß�Ë[ÛÓ,Ñ¡À�ÛDÉ@ÿ���� ��×L� Ó�ÃtÆ Ü Å   » � þ ���F� � �8� < ûu� þ � � �8� <   @ ����� � �e� ¤   � � � ���F� � �e�8� < ü�� � � � �e� <   = ����� � �8� ãð ÑØźË[ÛÓ�ÑØÀ�ÛDÉ ÒPÀ�ÁyË�ÑDæÓ,Ò`Ó §ý tEüe² ô Î�ÆØÌ §Þet3û£² ô Î�Á�Å8ÌDÅ��gÆØÅ�ÌPÎ�Óqß-À>ÐtÐ#ÀàMÓ�á

  � �ÉÓ®�@t ¤�� £ðÞ � ��×L� �,Ãtß{Ó�® Ú ) è � ) �#Ö ) �ó��ªÈ�ÒGÀ>ÁyËØÑDÃtÓ�Ò   � � � � õ �8�)À>ß�ÿ�� � ��×L� �,Ãtß{Ó ¤ � � õ �  » �ÉÓ®�ht ¤�� £2Þ � ��×L� �<æß\ÓP® × ) è þ ) ��Ö ) �ó��ªÈ�ÒGÀ>ÁyË�ÑgÃtÓ,Ò   » � þ � õ �8�)À>ß�ÿ�� » ��×L� �<æß\Ó ¤ þ � õ �

Êó '

Page 81: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

Ø 2�°A4e6N2gd2DC78hW4E2%8?CKH(4ÁR ¼ C:476w28HpC�4N(8�Q<6:68C:H=6<2D6:28HpQd8?4e1�H=489�2DC70c6�WFHKE:6�254%6IW9250cHKE�>�¸�H�3x8[N(894Yg{8FN=8YE0c1 ¼ 0M6�WYH¦WYHK9_Q:J�89258Pg@2DC70c6bWFHKE:6N2%4%6:WL250cHKE°L:H+8Y6pEIH=2bR+0D8FJMLÙ4PJc3¬4�R¦6T4§Q76:68CIH(6<2s0cE )�¨ « ¯ z g�476e28C788LUI479_Q:JD8w0MEsgÀ0�C(674N8 ¦ >�ó568CIH�3A69t�021@3X8\3�H(6:JMLTWFHKE:6�254%6IW92@28C78uQ76:6eC:H(6<2�HP1 §� 47EIL¢§þ 47WFWYH(4eL70ME<Cp2DH�28C78WYHKE:6�254N6:W92%0MHKE]0ME ¦ >|Ó�> ¤ g�3X8�L:HhE:HE2XC=89212DC78AQ76:6eC:H(6<2¬H71 §� 47E:L §þ 0cE )Ǩ « ¯ z g�6N0ME:W98�28C78�2S3�H�8FJD8F9e8FE�2860ME]E:H¦L78¥ÓV3�H(6:JcL]E:H=2�sY8^C7JD678FL�>�âGH(4%8FH�N(8?4Fg ô 3�H(6:JcLtEIH=2�sY8¥4V9�H¦L78FJ�0ME )�¨ « ¯ z >0�1�H(4e9p6:Jv4n258�E:H�3Ù6eHPÀSWY47JMJ�8YL IDF��%H=I ¸»½ �`��F º ¶ ¸»½É¸ F ºI¹`1�H(4q28H=2a47JI9�H¦L78YJ�9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9�6Fg(2DC�4n2B8YE:6N674%8�2DC�4E2B28C78WYHKE:6�254N6:W92%0MHKEk0ME ¦ >åÓ�> ¤ R+0D8FJML:6�4�Q<6:68C:H=6<2�0ME )�¨ « ¯ z >Bf�C78Y6N8XWYHKE:L<0�250cHKE:6�4E4%8\H(4N0DC(0cE�47JcJcR�0cE�2%48H¦L76:W98YL0ME§ô�f�4=8 ¤(&Põ 1�H(4@28C78XW4E2%8?CKH=4eR ¼ ¤ �G�>�D���¾g:3AC7894%8o2DC78[R]4=4N8¥WY47JMJ�8YLTQ76I68C:H(6�2�WFHKE:L70K250MH7E:6?>ÕP��Ö �4�= >��¨¡�£¢j¤¦¥ø¤����Ù¯ * ¨ § �A* �=  � § ¨¡� « �# ��ɨ¡�Y­r²f�3¬H�2DHE2a47J®9�H¦L78YJ?9_H(48Q:C<0M689_6 §� ¤ë¨ � �   =?ª t3úx² ü§47EIL�§þ ¤�¨ þ �   @�ª t3ú ²¬ûÙ6D4E2%0M6Á1»Re28C78 IDF��%H=I ¸»½ ���F º ¶ ¸»½Ð¸ F ºI¹X0c1Ä(> � 47EIL þ 4E4%8o0MErqN8FW92%0cN(8PgÓ�>�1�H(4A47JcJ � ® Ú áuè � �#Ö�á@�[g � � õ � ¤ �¦� � �@0M9_Q:JD0�8Y6X28C�4E2   @ � õ �x0M6A47Ek0c68HK9_H(48QIC70M6e9Í47E:L' >�1�H(4A47JcJ � ® × áuè þ �#Ö�á@�[g þ � õ � ¤ �¦� � �@0M9_Q:JD0�8Y6X28C�4E2   = � õ �x0c6A47Em0M68H79�H(4eQ:C70c689m>

Êf�C78;2DHE2a47J¾9�H¦L78FJ¾9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9�6Z0MEÊgÀ0DC=674%8 ¦ >�óGL:H�E:HE2�6D4n250M6Á1»R¢2DC78pJcH�WY47JD0K2SR�WFHKE:L70K250MH7E:6Yg�6%0MEIW?8;28C78¼ À29�H=48Q:C70c689Ú1�H(4 §� 0M6�E:H=2�s70 qN8FW9250ON(8E>�0�2D6¬EIHKE�ÀG0cErqN8YWL250ON�0K2SR¡0M612DC78w4%84P68HKExg+2DC�4n2x2DC<8w2S3�H�8YJD8F9e8FE32D6x0cEE:H�L<8�Ó�4=4%810ML78FE3250¦°78YL�0cEj28C78�Q<6:68C:H=6<2"!ç4PE:Lj28C�4E2@3x8�WY47E:E:HE24°�EILV4w6:E<0t·�678¾9e8FL70v4E2%0ME7CA9_H(48QIC70M6e9u>021�2S3�HZ28H=2a47J�9_H¦L78YJ:9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9�6�684E250c6e1»Rp28C78AJMH¦W47J�0�2SR¥WYH7E:L70�2%0MHKEI6Yg(2DC<8�Q76I68C:H(6�2¬WY47E�sd8AWYHKEI6N254N6:W92%8YLQ®H(0cE32S3i0M6%8Pgâ0�>�8=>�2DC<8_WFHKE:6�254%6IW9250cHKE[0ME ¦ >|Ó�> ¤ R+0D8FJML:6¥4]Q76:6eC:H(6<2Z0ME )�¨ « ¯ z >]f�C70M6u1É47WL2o0M6XQ748H�N=8YEÊ0cEô�f�4=8 ¤=&Põ 1�H(4�28C78¥68Qd8YW?0M47JkW476N87g�3AC78?4N8�2DC<85WY4E2589CKH(4eR ¼ 0c6�28C78¥W4E2%8?CKH(4ÁR»�G�>�D���X>q¹�0cE:W?8Z2DC70c6AQ748H¦H716:6%8F6�HKE:JOR�2DC78�1É47W9212DC�4n2)�i���g�`�^C�476�Q76:68CIH(6<2D6Fg<2DC<8�Q74eH�H71ÔW47EbsY8wC(8YE7894D47J�0$#98YL�>�f�C<8:4%8/·�670D4N8Y9]8YE32H71h0M6eHK9_H(48Q:C<0M689_6^0ME¢2DC<8bJMH¦W4PJD0�2SR�WYHKEIL70�2%0MHKE:6o0c65E78FW?8F686D4E4eR[2DHP8FE:6%6<4%8;28C78_3X8YJcJOÀ2L78/°�E<0�250cHKE^H71@28C789�H¦L78YJ ô 0cE ³ HKE:6�254%6IW9250cHKE ¦ >|Ó�> ¤ >cg�H(4p2DC<8TL78/°�E32%0MHKE�H71�2DC78T9_H¦L78YJ�9�H(4eQ:C70c9�6e9 §ý 4PE:Lç§Þ�gq28C78Q748HKQd8?4�2SRTH71`4_WFH(4%8L254847W92%0MHKET3�H(6:JML]sd8X6%6&%_W?0�8YE32->Ë;� ¨ � ¨¡­Ï�# ��ɨ¡�%¢Y¤¦¥}¤��'�«¯ * ¨ § �A*å�4½ ­ � ¨ ½  7²(YÆØÌDÅ<Á?É�ÑØÅ8ÆØÀ�É-ÎgÉ�Ã#À>ÆDÓkÀ>ß ä À>ÆgÓÏÉ�Á�Û Ü É�Ã�À>Æ{ô ã õ�ã ì ú Ãtß §� Î�ÆØÌ §þ Ó�ÎgÉ�ÃtÓ�ߦÊCÉ�ÑØÅkÐ#À Ü Î�ÐtÃ-É�Ê Ü À>ÆØÌRÃ-É�Ã�À�ÆDÓ�æÆ*);Å<ß#ÈÃtÆDÃ-É�Ã�À�Æ%ô ãöõgã�â,+ Î�Æ¡Ì£É�ÑØÅ Ü ÎgÉñÅ,ÂgÀ>ÁñÊ ¼ Ñ�Î�ÓkË[Û�Ó,ÑØÀ�ÛgÉ�Ó ú É�Ñ¡Å�Æz� ô � §ý � §Þ��'ÃtÓ�Î ËHÛÓ,ÑØÀRÛDÉ;À>ß §� Î�ÆØÌ §þ æÆ)Ǩ « ¯ z ã ÊÍ S5F�F ¼ô 0M654G9_H¦L78YJ�H�N(894 � 6%0MEIW?8]847WaCÂEIH�L78]0M6o4N8/°�E78FLc2DHG47E ¼ À2HKs¦qN8YWL2�4PE:LÊ8Y47WaCc8YL<C(8 � 0c6o4%8/°:E78YL2DH«4 ¼ ÀS9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9¬0ME:L<6:W?8FLæs�Rà2DC78�6IE70cN=8?486847J�Q<6:68C:H=6<2]Q748H7QY894N2SR°H=4e2DC<8 ¼ ÀS9_H(48Q:C<0M689_6]C(0cN=8YE0MEÊüÛ4%8F68Q�>qûw>´0SEr28C78G°A486�2�WY476%8PgX28C78 ¼ À29�H=48Q:C70c689ç0M6�3X8YJcJOÀSL<8/°�E78FL�s�Rr28C78s6:E70ON(89486D4PJ�Q<6:68C:H=6<2Q748HKQd8?4�2SR(>�0SE/2DC<8u6%8YWFHKE:LtW476N87g<28C78 ¼ ÀS9_H(48QIC70M6e9È0c6¬3X8YJMJ ÀSL78�°�E78FLtL<678O2DHp28C78\JMH¦W4PJD0�2SRdWFHKE:L70K250cHKE:6?t021 � ® Ú á�è � á¾�#Ö�á@��47EIL-�¦� � �/.® � á¾�#Ö�á@��28C78YE   � ����� � �e�w0M6:28C78p0cL78YE3250K2SR�4PE:L   �10,2 ����� � �e�w8LU�0M6�2D69>021 � ® Ú ámè � á��#Ö�á@��47E:L*��� � �h® � á¾�#Ö�ák�@2DC78FE   � ����� � �e�@0M6�47EP0c68HK9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9yL76<8Z28H]28C785JcH�WY47JD0K2SRWYHKE:L<0�250cHKE:69>UÃ�JD8Y476%8�E:H=250cW?8Pg�28C�4E2X0�2�3�H(6:JML�E:H=2�sY8w8YE:H=67CKCe28H�4N8�·�670D4N8�HKEIJcRd4¥WYH(4N89254847W92%0MHKE]0MEI6N258Y47LH71®47E¡0M68H79�H(4eQ:C70c689�0MEp28C78�JMH¦W47J�0�2SRXWFHKE:L70K250MH7E:6À2DH^8FE:6%6<4%8h2DC78�3X8YJcJOÀ2L78/°�E<0�250cHKEhHP1Y28C78 ¼ ÀS9_H(48Q:C<0M689m>f�C78�68479]8VW47E*sY8d6eC:H�3AE§1�H(4o8YL<C(8Y6Z0ME � ® × á¢è þ á¾�#Ö�á@�V>]f�C<8�9_H(48QIC70M6e9�6 §ý 4PE:L�§ÞG4=4%8�28H=2a47J9�H¦L78YJ�9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9�6Fg�6N0ME:W98G1�H(4¡8Y47WaC � tx£`² àÛ® Ú á`g   � �Oà¦� < ü�� � � ¤ ô � ý � � �8� <   � �b£S��1�H(4�47JMJ� ® � ��Ö�á@�¾L76<8w2DHj2DC78\Q<6:68C:H=6<2�Q74eHKQY894N2SR_H71@ÿ�� � �43Ù� 4PE:L]ÿ�� � � ´%� 47EILb1�H(4�47JMJ � ® Ú áeè � �#Ö�á@�¾L<678

ó ¦

Page 82: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

2DHtWYHKE:6�254N6:W92%0MHKE*6%0cE:W?8   � �b£S�O0M6^28C78¡0ML78FE�2%0�2SR=> Ø E�47JMH=CKH(6:6eJcR�0K2XW47E§sY8d6eC:H�3AE`2DC:4E2   » 0c6X4k28H=2a47J9�H¦L78YJÔ9�H(4eQ:C70c689m>f�C78pWYH79�9p6�2a4E2%0cN+0�2SR §ý < §� ¤ §Þ < §þ 1�HKJMJcH�3A6¥L70�4%8YWL2DJOR*1b4eHK9Þ2DC78bWYHKE:6�254N6:W92%0MHKE«4PE:Lr0�2j4%8F9b4=0cE:6j28H68C:H�3ð28C78o6:E70ON(8?4e6D47J=Q<6:68C:H=6<2�Q<48HKQd8?4�2SR(> W 0ON(8FEG4V9_H�L<8YJ65�H�N(8?4i�ã47E:Ls2DHE2a47Jx9_H¦L78YJx9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9�6§� t7üC² 5Û4PE:L §Ù�t�ûl² 5 3i0K2DC�§� < §� ¤ §Ù < §þ >;¹�0cE:W?8 ý < � ¤ Þ < þ 0M6�4pQ76:68CIH(6<2XL70M4=C(4D4P9T0cE�G�>�D���¾g�28C78?4N8�0M6u4/6:E<0t·�678pC(4847Q:C^9_H(48Q:C<0M689æÝct � ² � 6%6:WaC�28C�4E2^Ý < Þ ¤ Ù�47E:L�Ý < ý ¤ � >f�C78s2DH=2D47J�9_H�L78FJ¬9_H(48QIC70M6e9 §Ý ¤¬¨ Ýâ�   á ª t ô ² 5 0M6VL<8/°�E78FL´1�H=4d47JMJX�¹® ý � � �#Ö ) �8�hs�Rc28C786:E70cN=8?4e6D47JU9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9�0cE:L76:W98YL*s�R©ÿ�� × 0ME ¼ >{g�H(4O��® � ) 3i0K2DC ý � �� ¤ Ó°�#4N8Y6eQ�>kÞ?� �� ¤ Ó®��1�H=4`® Ú ) è � ��Ö ) �_�#4N8Y6eQ�>7`® × ) è þ ��Ö ) �e�[gk3x8�L78/°:E78   á �#��� ¤   > ����_�#4%8F68Q�>   á �b��� ¤   � ����8�V>�Ê8X68CIH�3ïE78LU+2�2DC78u3X8YJcJ=L78/°�E<0�250cHKETH71 §Ýât   á 0M6�L78�°�E78YLt1�H(4A47JcJ�Ó�® � ) 6%0MEIW?8 ý 47E:LtÞb4E4%8¬qeH(0ME328JcR6%674»qN8YW92%0cN=8X47E:Lb1�H(4X847WaCs8FL7C(8 � t3£4²Ûà;® � á`g   á �Oà¦� < ô � � � ¤ 5*�bÝ�� � �8� <   á �b£S��1�H(4X28C78�1�HKJcJMH�3i0ME7C4%84P68HKE:69tÄ(> � ® ý � � ��Ö�á@�8�Lt   á �b£S�54PE:L   á �cà¦�X4=4%8 ¼ À29�H=48Q:C70c689_6^0ME:L<6:W?8FLÂs�R±4tQ76:6eC:H(6<2�47E:L`28C78?4N8;0c647E�8FL7C(8 � � ti�è² 8 ® × á 3i0�28CÙÞ?� � � � ¤ � 47E:LÙ47E 8YL7C(8 � �µt õ ² ð® Ú á 3i0�28Cý � � �=� ¤ � > f�C78FEzC:H7JML:6  âá �cà¦� < 5^� � � <   » �#��� ¤  \á �Oà¦� <   » ��8u� < ûu� � � � ¤   � ��8u� <ûu� � � � ¤ 5^�#Ý�� � �8� <   � �b�I� ¤ 5^�#Ý�� � �8� <   á �b£S� <   » �#���L>u�Ê8pWY47EÂ6eC:H�3Í47E:47JMH(C7H(6:68JOR�2DC�4n2  á �Oà¦� < 5^� � � <   � � õ � ¤ 5*�bÝ�� � �8� <   á �#£2� <   � � õ �L>x¹�0cE:W?8   � � õ ��47EIL   » �#���b4=4N8�qeH(0ME328JcR8YQ70c9�H=48Q:Cxg¦3x8¥C�4N(8   á �Oà¦� < 5^� � � ¤ 5*�bÝ�� � �8� <   á �#£2�L>

Ó�> � ® ý � Ú áRè � �#Ö�ák�e�Lt aâ8L2 � �}® Ú á­3i0K2DC ý � � �=� ¤ � 2DC<8YE   á �cà¦� < ô � � � ¤   á �cà¦� <  � ���F� � �k�e� < ü¾� � �k� <   � � ��� � �=�e� � � ¤   > ���F� � �=�e� < ü¾� � �k� <   � � �¦� � �=�8� � � ¤ 5*�bÝ�� � �8� <   > � �¦� � �k�8� <  � � ��� � �=�e� � � ¤ 5^�#Ý�� � �e� <  \á �#£2��sd8YWY4=6:6%8VHP1q2DC78�L<8/°�E70K250cHKE�H71 ô � � �A3AC7894%8  \á �cà¦�w0M6w8?0K2DC78940ME:L<6:W?8FL§H(4^8/·�6�47J�2DH   > ���F� � �x�8��Qd8?4XL78/°:E70�2%0MHKE�>�âGH(4N8YH�N(894Yg   � ����� � �=�8�:0c6X47E¢0M68H79�H(4eQ:C70c68947WYWFH(48L<0ME7C�2DH�28C78XJMH¦W47J�0�2SR_WYHKEIL70�2%0MHKE:69>

' >�g�H(4�47JMJ � ®§Þ®� × áPè þ ��Ö�á@�8�Vt   á �Oà�� < ô � � � ¤ 5^�#Ý�� � �e� <   á �#£S��1�HKJcJMH�3A6�47E�47JcH(CKH(6:6eJcR/28He28C78Q74%8[N+0MH(6:6AWY476%8E>éw8LU+2�3x8¥C�4N(8Z2DH_68C:H�3�28C�4E2 §Ý < §ý ¤ §� 47E:L §Ý < §Þ ¤ §Ù�>xÝ < ý ¤ � C:HKJcL:6AsY8FW4=6I6%8¥H71À28C785Q<6:68C:H=6<2Q748HKQd8?4�250�8Y6¬HP1 � >qg�H(4�47JMJd�;® Ú ) 3X8\C�4N(8   á � ý �#���e� <   � �#��� ¤   > �b���¾47WFWYH(4eL70ME<C�2DH�28C78�L<8/°�E70K250cHKEH71   á > §Ý < §Þ ¤ §þ W47E]sd8¥6eC:H�3AE�47E:47JMH(C7H(6:68JOR(>�f�C<8Z6IE70t·�678FE78Y6e6�H71 §Ý�C:H7JML:6�s�R]L78�°�E70�2%0MHKE�> å021:2S3�HÊ2DH=2D47J�9_H�L78FJ�9�H=48Q:C70c689_6V6D4E2%0M6Á1»Rr2DC78tJMH¦W47J�0�2SR§WYHKEIL70�2%0MHKE:6FgX28C78GQ?H(0cE�2S3i0c6%8]Q76:6eC:H(6<2bWYHKE¦À6N254N6:W92%0MHKE¢0cE ¦ >åÓ�> ¤ R+0D8YJcL:6X47JO3�4R¦6¥4]Q<6:68C:H=6<2Z0ME�2DC78dWY4E2589CKH(4eR )�¨ « ¯ z >�¸�H�3x8[N(894Ygv28C78dQ®H=0ME32S3i0M6N8Q76:68CIH(6<25WYHKE:6�254N6:W92%0MHKE*9b4R^4PJM68HTR+0D8FJML*4TQ76:6eC:H(6<2j0c112DC78d9_H�L<8YJ�9_H(48Q:C<0M689_6\L:HtE:H=2¥684E250c6e1»R�28C78JMH¦W47J�0�2SRtWYHKEIL70�2%0MHKE:69>¡f�C70M6XL78FQY8FE:L:6hH7E[28C78¡6:E:L78948JcR+0cE7C]W4E2%8?CKH(4ÁR ¼ >_0�68C:H�3 JM4E25894uHKE¢2DC�4E2o28C78Q®H(0cE32S3i0M6%8dQ76I68C:H(6�2�WYH7E:6N2%4%6:WL250MH7EÊ0ME ¦ >|Ó�> ¤ R+0�8YJMLI6h47Jc68Ht4GQ<6:68C:H=6<251�H=4¥9_H¦L78YJ�9_H(48QIC70M6e9�6^0cE[28C78W4E2%8?CKH(4ÁR:9i�G��H71x4n2%254N0Ms76�258YL¡C(4847Q:C:6�4PE:Lb4n2%254N0Ms76�258YL¡C(4847Q:Cd9_H(48Q:C<0M689_6�6:6N8YLd1�H(4�H(674�WY476%8A6�256:LIR7g2DC�4E2ALIH�E:HE2A6D4E2%0M6e1»R;2DC78XJMH¦W4PJD0�2SR_WFHKE:L70K250MH7E:6X�ÉW[1�>�Ãq48HKQ?HK6%0K250cHKE ¦ > ¦ >�Ä�ÓK�L>021Z28C78©Q76:6eC:H(6<2T1�H=4;2DH=2D47J�9_H¦L78YJ�9�H(4eQ:C70c689_6bW4PEæsd8�WFHKE:6N2%4%6:WL258FLzQ?H(0ME32S3i0c6%8�0MER2DC78©WY4E2589CKH(4eR)Ǩ « ¯ z gA28C78hQ?H(0ME32S3i0c6%8¥Q76:68CIH(6<2O0c6�47JM6eHb4_Q76:68CIH(6<2O0cEu28C785WY4E2589CKH(4ÁR )�¨ «\zX>if�C70c6w0c6AL7678j28He28C781É47W92Yg=2DC�4n2�4\Q76:6eC:H(6<2�HP1d28H=2a4PJ�C(4847Q:CV9_H(48QIC70M6e9�6v0M6U4PJM68H\4\Q76:68CIH(6<2B0MEj2DC78�WY4E2589CKH(4ÁR�H71�C(4847Q:C:6U47E:LQ�4=4N2%0v47JdC(4847Q:CT9_H(48Q:C<0M689_6�ô�a<;H73 ¤('rõ 47E:L/28C78uQ?H(0ME32S3i0M6N8\Q76:6eC:H(6<2�WYHKE:6�254N6:W92%0MHKEt47JcJMH�3A6X28C78O6:E70¦·�678L78/°�E<0�250cHKETH71v2DC78o6:E70ON(89486D4PJ=Q76:68CIH(6<2�9�H=48Q:C70c689m>Ë;� ¨ � ¨¡­Ï�# ��ɨ¡�%¢Y¤¦¥}¤���¥°¯: �¨   �A*X* ¨ § �A*å�4½ ­ � ¨ ½  i��­ �H½ ­ � ¨ ½   ����)�¨ «vz ²é Å�É;ÌRÃ=Î>ÂVÁ�Î�Ò ï-â ùÍügÅ�Ð�À�à Ü À>ÆgÓÏÉ�Á�Û Ü ÉÝÅ�ÌeËMÀ�ÃtÆ¡ÉyàMÃtÓ�ÅÔÎ Ü�Ü À>Á�ÌVÃtÆg£ÉñÀ ä À�ÆDÓÏÉ�ÁÏÛ Ü É�Ã�À�Æ]ô ã õgã ì ã>= ß ïyâ ù`æÓ�ÎË[ÛÓ,Ñ¡À�ÛDÉ�ÌVÃ=Î�ÂVÁ<Î�Ò Ã¦Æ É�ÑØÅ Ü ÎgÉñÅ,ÂgÀ>ÁñÊ )�¨ « ¯ z ú É�ÑØÅ�Æ ïyâ ù ÃtÓ ÎPË[ÛÓ,Ñ¡À�ÛDÉ�ÌVÃ=Î�ÂVÁ<Î�Ò Ã¦ÆlÉ�Ñ¡Å Ü ÎgÉñÅ,ÂgÀ>ÁñÊ

ó �

Page 83: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

)Ǩ «Àz ãú

������@�ýþ

�= ûüû�» ûü �?A@B CCCCCCCC

CCCCCCü ���ýþ�D � EEEEEEEEEEEEEEô �á&FG HHHHHHHH �

ÊÍ S5F�F ¼f�C78\L70M4=C(4D4P9Ò��Ä���WYHK9_9p6<2%8Y6�6%0MEIW?8:0K2x0c6¬45Q76:68CIH(6<2�L70M4=C(48479 0ME )Ǩ « ¯ z >��Ê8�47686N6:9e8�E:H�3è9�H¦L78YJ9�H(4eQ:C70c689_6 §ë 47E:L §ì 6%6:WaC/28C�4E2 §ë < §� ¤ §ì < §þ > ¹�0MEIW?8�45Q76:6eC:H(6<2X0MEG�G�>�D���¢0M6�Q76:6eC:H(6<2x0MEG�G�>�D��� ®ô�a<;H73 ¤('rõ gB2DC7894%8k0M6d4�6:E<0t·�678]Q�4=4�250v4PJxC(4847Q:C�9�H=48Q:C70c689·Ý|t � ² � 6%6IWaCR2DC:4E2¡Ý < ý ¤ ë 47E:LÝ < Þ ¤ ì >wf�C78FExgÔ3X8�L78�°�E78h1�H(4�47JcJâÓ`®«Þ��ß*�#Ý®�h28C78 ¼ À29�H(4eQ:C70c689   á �bÓ®�:t ô �ÉÓ®�ª² ���#Ý��ÉÓ®�8�A4761�HKJMJcH�3A69tÄ(>A021AÓ�®©Þ?� × �JI ý � Ú �{2DC7894%8@0c6À8VU:4PW92DJORhH7E78 õ ®»Ö�6%6:WaC�28C�4E2�Þ?� þ � õ �e� ¤ ý � � � õ �8�@47E:L ô �ÉÓ®�k3i0�28C  � � � � õ �8�=47E:L   » � þ � õ �e��0M6kQ76:6eC:H(6<2`H71   = � õ �x4PE:L   @ � õ ��0ME ¼ >EM¾RXQ74%8F9e0c6%87g   ? � þ � õ �8� <   @ � õ � ¤  D � � � õ �8� <   = � õ ��47EILp3x8XL78�°�E78   á �ÉÓ®��476x28C78^6:E70ON(8?4e6D47JÔQ76:68CIH(6<2A9_H(48Q:C<0M689wH71 ô �bÓ®�¾6%6:WaC2DC�4n2   á �bÓ®� <   � � � � õ �8� ¤   D � � � õ �e��47E:L   á �ÉÓ®� <   » � þ � õ �8� ¤   ? � þ � õ �e�L>

Ó�>A021�Ó�®©Þ?� × ��K ý � Ú ��g�2DC7894%810M6{8LUI47WL2DJORuHKE78 õ ® × K þ ��Öu�=6%6IWaCj2DC:4E2@Þ?� õ � ¤ Óâ>�M¾RuWYHKEI6N254N6:W92%0MHKEÔg  » � õ � ¤ £2Þ � � � � 4PE:Lt3X8XL78/°:E78   á �bÓ®� ¤   ? � õ ��g:6%6:WaCm2DC�4n2   á �bÓ®� <   » � õ � ¤   ? � õ �L>

' >A021<ÓP® ý � Ú �LK þ � × �[gn2DC7894%810M6â8LUI47WL2DJORXHKE78 õ ® Ú K � �#Öu�=6%6:WaCj2DC�4E2 ý � õ � ¤ Óâ>vM�RXWYHKEI6N254N6:W92%0MHKEÔg  � � õ � ¤ £2Þ � � � � 47E:L]3X8¥L<8/°�E78   á �ÉÓ®� ¤   D � õ ��gI6N6:WaCu28C�4E2   á �ÉÓ®� <   � � õ � ¤   D � õ �L>

f�C78YExgx1�H=4 §Ý ¤ ¨ Ý\�   á ª t ô ² �çC:H7JML:6 §Ý < §ý ¤ §ë 47E:L §Ý < §Þ ¤ §ì >Zf�C<8p6:E70¦·+6<8YE78F686XH71 §Ý^1�HKJMJcH�3A61b48HK9È2DC78o6:E70¦·�678YE78F686�H71À0K2D6�WFHK9�Q?HKE78FE32D6?> å¹�0ME:W98q2DC78¾JMH¦W47J�0�2SR�WYHKEIL70�2%0MHKE:6â8FE:6%674N87gn2DC�4E2\2DC<8¾Q?H(0cE�2S3i0c6%8¾Q76:6eC:H(6<2�WYHKEI6N254N6:W92%0MHKEXR+0D8FJML:6@4�Q<6:68C:H=6<20ME )�¨ « ¯ z ��WF1�>�Ãq48HKQ?HK6N0�250cHKE ¦ >|Ó�>KÄ(Ä���g<2DC78u1�HKJcJMH�3i0ME<C�WYH(4eHKJMJM4=4eR_1�HKJcJMH�3A6@0M9_9]8YL70M4E258FJcR(>¼ ¨ � ¨ *�*#�D� �%¢j¤¦¥ø¤��+Ì°¯ * ¨ § �A* �=  � § ¨¡� « �# ��ɨ¡�Y­ � �Y­ ½j�>�e�H½ ­ � ¨ ½   ��� )Ǩ «Àz ²é Å�É'ÌRÃòÎ�ÂVÁ�Î�Ò ï-â ùÞügÅ�Ð#À�à Ü À>ÆDÓ�É�ÁÏÛ Ü ÉñÅ/̶ËMÀ>æơÉyàMÃtÓ�Å`Î Ü�Ü À>Á�ÌRæÆgÂ%ÉÝÀ ä À>ÆDÓÏÉ�ÁÏÛ Ü É�Ã#À>Æ ô ãöõgã ì ã*= ß §� Î�ÆØÌ�§þÓ�ÎgÉ�ÃtÓ,ߦÊlÉ�ÑØÅGÐ#À Ü Î�ÐtÃ-É�Ê Ü À>Æ¡ÌRÃyÉ�Ã�À>ÆDÓ`ÃtÆM);Å��DÆgÃyÉ�Ã#À>Æ]ô ã õ�ã¦â,+ ú É�ÑØÅ<Æ ïyâ ù ÃtÓiÎÍË[Û�Ó,ÑØÀ�ÛgÉ`ÌRÃ=Î>ÂVÁ�Î�Ò Ã¦ÆlÉ�ÑØÅÜ ÎgÉÝÅ<ÂgÀ>ÁÝÊ )�¨ «Àz ã

ú������@�ýþ

�= ûüû�» ûü �?A@B CCCCCCCC

CCCCCCü ���ýþ�D � EEEEEEEEEEEEEEô �á FG HHHHHHHH �

Êó &

Page 84: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

Í S5F�F ¼021 §� 47E:L�§þ 6D4n250M6Á1»Re28C78\JcH�WY47JD0K2SRVWYHKEIL70�2%0MHKE:6Fg�28C78\Q?H(0ME32S3i0M6N8\Q76:6eC:H(6<2AWFHKE:6�254%6IW9250cHKEs0M6¬4hQ76:6eC:H(6<2i0cE)Ǩ « ¯ z 47WYWFH(48L70cE7Ce28HpÃq48H7Q®HK6N0�2%0MHKE ¦ >|Ó�>�Ä=Ä(> Ø WYWFH(48L<0ME7C]2DHpÃq4eHKQ®H76%0�2%0MHKE ¦ >|Ó�>KÄ�Ód1�HKJcJMH�3A6h2DC�4n2d��Ä��i0c6Q76:68CIH(6<2�0ME )�¨ «Àz1> å0xQ748H�N+0ML<8�E:H�3c28C78¬Q<6:68C:H=6<2`WFHKE:6�254%6IW9250cHKE51�H=4�Q�4E4N250M47JK9_H�L<8YJ�9_H(48Q:C<0M689_6Ygr9�4=0ME:JOR�L<0cN+0ML78FL�0cE�28H�2S3�H6N258FQ:6?t�0SE�2DC<8å°A4e6N2U6�258FQxg(2DC78�Q�4=4�250v4PJ�9�H¦L78YJ�9_H(48QIC70M6e9�6�4=4%8X4%8F6N254N0MWL258YLj2DHw28H=2a4PJ�9_H�L<8YJ�9�H=48Q:C70c689_6Yg0ME�28C78¬6N8YWYH7E:Ld6N258FQ�2DC78�Q76:68CIH(6<2�H71A28C78x2DHE2a47J¦9�H¦L78FJ¦9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9�0M6`WFHKE:6�254%6IW9258FL�>qf�C78�WFHKE:6�254%6IW9250cHKE4%8YQ<4%8Y6N8YE3258FL§sd8YJcH�3�R�0�8YJcL:6\4bQ<6:68C:H=6<2o0ME )�¨ «\z 0O1�2DC78hQ76:68CIH(6<2uH71q28C78�28H=2a47J@9_H�L78FJ�9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9�60ME )�¨ « ¯ z CKHE2As�R;2DC78o4%8F6N2%4%0MWL250cHKE]H71v28C78XQ�4=4�250v4PJÔHKE78F6w0c6A47JM6eHd4_Q<6:68C:H=6<2�0ME )�¨ «Àz1>¼ ¨¡�Y­/  ��½ §  >�ɨ¡�¾¢Y¤¦¥}¤��V¢è¯ �4½ ­ � ¨ ½   ����)�¨ «vz ²ù Ã-Ä>Å�ÆÍÎ ËøÎ�ÃtÁ�À>ßYÒGÀ�ÌDÅ<Ð�ÒGÀ>ÁyËØÑDÃtÓ�ÒÔÓ §� ¤ë¨ � �   =?ª t(ú ² ûèÎ�Æ¡ÌP§þ ¤©¨ þ �   @Gª t3úx²¬ü ú É�Ñ¡ÅËHÛÓ,ÑØÀRÛDÉ� ô � §ý ��§Þ¦�)À>ß §� Î�ÆØÌu§þ Ã¦Ó Ü À>ÆDÓ�É�Á�Û Ü ÉÝÅ�ÌGæÆPß-À�ÛÁªÓÏÉÝÅñË�Ó�á

â*ã é Å>É �ON þ ügÅ;É�Ñ¡Å�ÐòÎ�Á�Â�Å�ÓÏÉ[Ó�Û ü�ÂVÁ<Î�Ë�ѱÀ>ß4Ö àMÑgÃ Ü ÑÞÓ�ÎgÉ�ÃtÓP�¡Å�ÓÏáï Î>ù �ON þRQ Þ��ß*� � �SI�Þ��ß*� þ �ªÎ�ÆØÌï ü>ùÍß-À>Á)Î�ЦÐ�Ó�® �'N þ Î�Æ¡Ì õ ®¶Ö ú � �bÓ®� ¤ � � õ �)À>Á þ �ÉÓ®� ¤ þ � õ �ºÃ¦ÒuËØÐtÃ�Å<Ó õ ® �'N þ ãð ÑØÅ�Æ ú àMÅ8ÌDÅ��gÆØÅO¶ t �ON þ ² �jz ú Ü Î�ЦÐ�Å�ÌÍÉ�ÑØÅwCKJD6<0ME7CVHKs�qN8YW92 ú ü�Êu¶ ¤ ú ­ =�T�@ ã

õgã'ä À>ÆDÓ�É�ÁÏÛ Ü É�Ã#À>Æ»À>ߺÉ�ÑØÅ8ÌDÀ>Ò Î�ÃtÆgÓ�À>ß §ý Î�ÆØÌ §Þ ãï Î>ù ð ÑØÅ�ÌDÀ>Ò Î�ÃtÆdÞ��ß*� ý �ºÀ�ß[É�Ñ¡Å[Ë}Î�ÁÏÉ�Ã=Î�ÐgÂ*Á�Î�Ë�Ñ`ÒGÀ>ÁyË�ÑgÃtÓ,Ò ý ÃtÓ)É�ÑØÅåÐòÎ�Á�ÂgÅ<ÓÏÉøÓÏÛDü�ÂVÁ�Î/Ë�ÑÞÀ>ß Ú�úàMÑØÀ`Ã¦Ó Ü À>Æ¡É-Î�ÃtÆØÅ/ÌPÃtÆ«� Ú è þ �#Öu�8�U þ � �ON þ � ãið Ñ¡Å�Æ úWVüRt�Þ�rß*� ý �ª² �jz¾ÃtÓ8ÌDÅ��DÆ¡Å�ÌCü/ÊVü`t ¤ ü ­ »YX�Z � � � Î�ÆØÌ §þ ­ [�¤©¨ þ ­ =�T�@��   @]\ ^ ª ÃtÓ�ÌDÅ_�DÆØÅ�̱ü�Ê   @]\ ^ �ÉÓ®� ¤   @ �ÉÓ®�ªß-À�Á)Î�ÐtÐdÓ�® �ON þ ãï ü>ù*`VÊgÒ`ÒPÅ�É�Á,Ã Ü Î�ЦÐ�Ê ú Þ��ß*�ÐÞ¦�'æÓiÉ�Ñ¡Å�Ð=Î�Á:ÂgÅ�Ó�É)Ó�Û ü�ÂVÁ<Î�Ë�Ñ À>ß ×dú àMÑØÀPÃtÓ Ü À>Æ¡É-Î�ÃtÆØÅ/Ì{ÃtÆè� × è

� ��Ö\�8�aU � � �ON þ � ãqð ÑØÅ�Æ Vûöt ¤ û ­ »YX�Z � » � Î�ÆØÌ §� ­ [u¤�¨ � ­ =LT�@%�   = \ ^ ª ÃtÓ_ÌDÅ��DÆ¡Å�Ìiü�Ê   = \ ^ �bÓ®� ¤  = �bÓ®�ß-À>Á)Î�ÐtÐYÓP® �ON þ ã

í ã'ä À>ÆDÓ�É�ÁÏÛ Ü É)É�ÑØźË[ÛÓ�ÑØÀ�ÛDÉ�� ô � §Óâ� §õ �)À>ß §� ­ [ Î�ÆØÌP§þ ­ [ ÃtÆ{É�Ñ¡Å Ü ÎgÉñÅ,ÂgÀ>ÁÝÊ )�¨ « ¯ z ãô ã'ä À>ÆDÓ�É�ÁÏÛ Ü É�Ã#À>Æ»À>ßÉ�ÑØŪËHÛÓ,ÑØÀRÛDÉ_ÒGÀ>Á-Ë�ÑDÃtÓ�ÒÔÓ §ý ¤ ¨ ý �   �Gª t(ü»² ô Î�ÆØÌ §Þ ¤ ¨ ÞA�   » ª t�û¬² ô áý ¤ ô ÚcbWd Þ�rß*� ý � ײ � õ Î�ÆØÌ   � �#��� ¤   × �b�I�)ß-À>Á8Î�ЦÐÀ��®�Þ�rß*� ý � ) ã'ú Æ�Î�Ð�ÀÏ ú Þ ¤ ô � bedÞ�rß*�ÉÞ�� �² � õ Î�Æ¡Ì   » �#��� ¤   � �b���ºß-À>Á)Î�ÐtÐ��;®©Þ��ß*�ÐÞ¦� ) ã

Ö@ûü

= ýþ × ú �= ýþ

�@ ûü

û

��

fg hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

hhhhhh�ON þä'ijklm n n n n n n n n n =o\ �qp ýþ

@]\ �qp ûü Þ+�ß*�ÐÞ¦�r� � ��ûü

Þ��ß*�#ÙI�srtu vwxy z z z z z z z z z z z

ûü

¶ä'i{|}~ � � � � � � � � �= \ ^ ýþ

�@]\ ^ ûü Vû r� � ���ûüÚ Þ+�ß*� ý �srtu ×

ýþ �á �� zzzzzzzzzzzz

ü�> �� ���������������������

Vüsrtu �× ýþ ôÞ��ß*� � �r� � �jklm n n n n n n n n n ýþ � �

Êó(ó

Page 85: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

ÕP��Ö �4�= >��¨¡�£¢j¤¦¥ø¤��+é°¯ �>� ­/  � � §   ��« ,§¨ �>��� ��­-,æ­�²0¬W4PJMJY28C78^2DH=2D47Jx9_H�L<8YJx9_H(48QIC70M6e9�6 §� ­ [ 4PE:L[§þ ­ [ 28C78 S5y ¹[½ S ¸ � ½ y8¶ � FnS Q�·¦¸M¹L�h¹ F ¼ §� 47E:L[§þ > ÊË;� ¨ � ¨¡­Ï�# ��ɨ¡�%¢Y¤¦¥}¤��+÷°¯ �4½ ­ � ¨ ½   ����)�¨ «Àz ²(YÆØÌDÅ<ÁkÉ�ѡŪÆØÀ�É-ÎgÉ�Ã#À>ÆDÓªÀ>ß É�Ñ¡Å ä À>ÆDÓ�É�Á�Û Ü É�Ã�À>ƶô ãöõgã�â ô ú � ô � §ý � §Þ�� ÃtÓÎ�Ë[ÛÓ�ÑØÀ�ÛDÉ À>ß §� Î�ÆØÌ §þ ÃtÆ )Ǩ «Àz�æßÉ�ÑØÅMË[ÛÓ,Ñ¡À�ÛDÉ_À>ß É�ÑØŪÁ�Å�Ó�É�Á,Ã Ü ÉÝÅ�Ì�ÒGÀ>ÁyËØÑDÃtÓ�ÒÔÓ §� ­ [ Î�ÆØÌ §þ ­ [ ÃtÆ )�¨ « ¯ z æӪÎ�ЦÓ�ÀqËHÛÓ,ÑØÀRÛDÉHÃtÆ )�¨ «vz ã�ÊÍ S5F�F ¼³ HK9�9�6<2a4E2%0cN+0�2SRdtBf�C78¥L70v4EC(4D479 ý < þ ¤ Þ < � 0M6�4dQ76:68CIH(6<2O0cE±�i�>�D�`� ä g�6%6IWaCP2DC�4n2\Þ < � ¤ ý < þ3i0�2DC*Þ��ß*�ÐÞ < � � ¤ Þ��ß*� ý < þ � ¤ �ON þ �ÉW[1�>¾ô�a<;H73 ¤('rõ �V>¡g�H=4O847WaC[Óà® �ON þ g   » � � �bÓ®�8� <   = �bÓ®� ¤  � � � �bÓ®�e� <   =o\ ^ �ÉÓ®� ¤   × � þ �bÓ®�e� <   @]\ ^ �ÉÓ®� ¤   � � þ �bÓ®�8� <   @ �bÓ®�L>_�E70ON(8?4e6D47J�Q748H7QY894N2SRdtÊa{8L2Ô§� ¤ ¨ � �   >�ª t@ü ² �­47EIL §Ù ¤ ¨ Ùd�   � ª tiûJ² �­sd8u2S3�H«9�H¦L78YJ9�H(4eQ:C70c689_6@0ME )�¨ «ÀzÂ6N6:WaCu28C�4E2ö§� < §þ ¤ §Ù < §� >021�3X8h4P686%6I9e8

� ; � §� < §þ ­ [�¤ §Ù < §� ­ [ �2DC7894%8p0c6\4/6:E70¦·�678�9_H�L78FJ�9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9 §Ý ¤ ¨ Ýâ�   á ª t ô ² �ç6N6:WaC�2DC�4n2 §Ý < §Ó ¤ §� 47E:L §Ý < §õ ¤ §ÙL7678j28He28C785Q<4%8Y9]0M6N8Z28C�4E2�2DC785Q76:6eC:H(6<2�H71 §� [ 4PE:Lʧþ [ 0c6�4_Q76:6eC:H(6<2:0ME )�¨ «\zX>�M�R]WFHKE:6�254%6IW9250cHKEH71 §ý 47E:L §Þ�g�3x8ZC(892 §Ý < §ý ¤ §� 4PE:L §Ý < §Þ ¤ §Ù�>f�HpQ<48H�N(8t� f ��3X8VE7898YL�Ó`®«Þ�rß*� � < þ ��� Óc® �ON þ t�021qÓÊ®ÂÞ��ß*� � < þ ��2DC78FE�ÓÊ®ÂÞ+�ß*� þ ��47E:Lþ �ÉÓ®�;® Þ��ß*� � �V>{¹�0ME:W98TÞ�rß*� � � Q Þ��ß*� ý �b�eô�a<;H73 ¤('rõ ��gU3x8sC(8L2 þ �bÓ®�/®ïÞ+�ß*� ý �L>�021�3X8]476e6%6:9]8Ó�.® �ON þ 2DC<8YE þ �ÉÓ®��.® þ � �ON þ �V>;f�C78FExg þ �bÓ®��.®�� Ú è þ ��Öu�e��U þ � �ON þ �O2DC�4E2Z0c9�Q:J�0D8F6:Ó�.®°Þ+�ß*� ý �[g3AC�4E2w0M6�4_WFHKE3254847L70MWL250cHKE�>B�Ê8¥W47EG68C:H�3Ç4PE�47JMH=CKH(6:6eJcR;28C�4E2iÓ¢®*Þ�rß*�=Ù < � �<� Ó¢® �ON þ >�!O678Z28H2DC70c6�1É47W92Yg:3x8¥4=4N854Ps:JD8O28H_Q<48H�N(8b� f �Vt

ÿ Ó ®ÒÞ��ß*� � < þ ­ =LT�@Á�*� þ �ÉÓ®��®ÒÞ��ß*� � �p4PE:L¹Ó�® �ON þ � Ó�®ÒÞ�rß*� � < þ ��� Ó�®Þ�rß*�=Ù < � ��� Ó�®�Þ+�ß*�#Ù < � ­ =LT�@S�L>g�H(4h847WaCkÓ�®�Þ+�ß*� � < þ ­ =�T�@Á�[gI3X8¥C�4N(8 � � þ ­ =�T�@��ÉÓ®�8� ¤ � � þ �bÓ®�e� ¤ Ùx� � �bÓ®�8� ¤ Ùx� � ­ =�T�@a�ÉÓ®�8�L>

ÿ g�H(4À8Y47WaC�Ó�®©Þ��ß*� � < þ =�T�@Á��g   > � þ ­ [ �bÓ®�e� <   @]\ ^ �ÉÓ®� ¤   > � þ �ÉÓ®�8� <   @ �ÉÓ®� ¤   � � � �ÉÓ®�8� <   = �bÓ®� ¤  � � � ­ [ �ÉÓ®�8� <   = \ ^ �bÓ®�L>

å021x2DC<8]4N8Y6�254%0cW92%8YL*9�H(4eQ:C70c689_6u6D4E2%0M6e1»RP2DC78dJMH¦W4PJD0�2SRtWFHKE:L70K250MH7E:6Yg{2DC<8?0D4uQ<6:68C:H=6<2�0cE )Ǩ « ¯ z W4PE§sd8WYHKE:6�254N6:W92%8YL�Q®H=0ME32S3i0M6N8p47E:Lr0c6�4�Q76I68C:H(6�2�0ME )�¨ «vzï47653x8FJMJ�>uf�C78?4N8F1�H(4N87gq2DC<8pQ76:6eC:H(6<2dH71h2S3�HQ�4=4N2%0v47J`9�H¦L78YJ`9�H(4eQ:C70c689_6^8LU�0M6�2�0cE )�¨ «vz�g\0c112DC7890D4^4N8Y6N2%4%0cW9258FL±9_H(48QIC70M6e9�6u684E250c6e1»R�28C78�JcH�WY47JD0K2SRWYHKE:L<0�250cHKE:69>5Ã�J�8476N8VE:H=250cW?8Pg�2DC�4n2O2DC78VJcH�WY47JD0K2SR]WYHKEIL70�2%0MHKE:6�L:HTE:H=2XC:4�N=8p2DHTsd8V6D4E2%0M6:°A8YL©1b48H79T28C78Q�4=4N2%0v47J®9�H¦L78FJx9�H=48Q:C70c689tg<8E>�C7>728C78XQ�4=4�250v4PJÔs�476N859_H(4eQ:C70M6e9Ñ9�4RTsd8uE:HKE�À�0MErqN8FW9250ON(8E>Ä �j� ¨ �>� , ¢Y¤¦¥}¤��IÅ�¯ �4½ ­ � ¨ ½   ��� )�¨ «Àz ²(YÆØÌDÅ<Á'É�ÑØÅ�ÆØÀ�É-ÎgÉ�Ã#À>ÆDÓ�À>ßåÉ�Ñ¡Å ä À�ÆDÓÏÉ�ÁÏÛ Ü É�Ã�À�Ʊô ãöõgã�â ô ú � ô � §ý ��§Þ��ÃtÓ Ë[Û�Ó,ÑØÀ�ÛgÉÀ�ß §� Î�ÆØÌP§þ ÃtÆ )�¨ «vzCæß

â*ã É�ÑØÅqËMÀ>æơÉyàMÃtÓ�ÅqË[ÛÓ,Ñ¡À�ÛDÉ Ü À�ÆDÓÏÉ�ÁÏÛ Ü É�Ã�À�Æ»ÃtÆÇô ãöõgã ì�ß-À>Á�É�ÑØÅ8Á�Å<ÓÏÉ�Á,Ã Ü ÉñÅ/̶ÒGÀ>Á-Ë�ÑDÃtÓ�ÒÔÓ §� ­ [ Î�Æ¡Ì[§þ ­ [ÊgÃ�Å�Ð#ÌRÓ)ÎkË[ÛÓ�ÑØÀ�ÛDÉ ÃtÆ )�¨ « ¯ z úõgã É�ÑØÅ[Á�Å<ÓÏÉ�Á�Ã Ü ÉñÅ�Ì'ÒGÀ>Á-Ë�ÑDÃtÓ�ÒÔÓ §� ­ [ Î�ÆØÌ¡§þ ­ [ Ó�ÎgÉ�ÃtÓ,ߦÊiÉ�ÑØÅMÐ#À Ü Î�ÐtÃ-É�Ê Ü À>Æ¡ÌRÃyÉ�Ã�À>ÆDÓYÃtÆ�);Å��DÆDÃ-É�Ã#À>Æ�ô ã õgã�â,+Vã

Êó=¥

Page 86: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

Í S5F�F ¼f�C78 °A4e6N2VQ?H(0ME3251�HKJMJcH�3A6¥1b48HK9ÛÃq48H7Q®HK6N0�2%0MHKE ¦ >åÓ+>�Ä�ÓG47E:L«Ãq48H7Q®HK6N0�2%0MHKE ¦ >åÓ+>�Ä & >�f�C78p6N8YWYH7E:L�Q®H(0cE321�HKJMJcH�3A6�1b48HK9 ³ H=48HKJcJv4=4ÁR ¦ >åÓ�>KÄ ' 47E:LGÃq48HKQ?HK6N0�250cHKE ¦ >|Ó�>KÄ & > å

½:¾ø� , �v*#� ¢j¤�é°¯ �4½ ­ � ¨ ½   ©2¨ �Ô�4�D�  >� �A* ,±¨ «j��* ,±¨ ����� ��­-,Ç­����J¿ �  7²_�6%0cE7C©Q�4=4�250M47J�s:476%8T9_H(48QIC70M6e9�6Fg�2DC78pQ<6:68C:H=6<2_W47Q<2%674%8F6VE:H=2dHKEIJcR[2DC78/0cE325670K250cN=8/0ML<84�H71�CKJ�670ME<Cs76<2547L:L70K250cHKE�47JcJcRs2DC:4E2XH71�L78YJ�89250cHKExg=6eC:H�3AEÊ0ME[gÀ0�C(674N8 ¦ >�¥�>�f�C78dQ74%8F6%8YE32D4E250cHKE§HP1�9_H�L78FJM6O0cE�2DC70c6°AC(674N8V68C:H�3A6¥HKE:JcRu2DC78¡4N8/°�E78FL`C=4D47Q:CI6X47E:L[4%8/°:E78YL[C(4D4PQ:C^9�H(4eQ:C70c689_6�1�H(4:28C78ds�476%8¡C(4847Q:Cxg=s<6<2E:H=2Z2DC78ps:476%8eC(4D47QIC:6j28C78Y9_6%8FJcN(8F6?>uf�C78ps�476N8;C(4847Q:C:6FgUC:H�3X8FN(894Yg�W4PEÂsY8�WYHKEI6N254N6:W92%8YLÂ1�H(4e9Þ2DC70c64%8YQ<4%8Y6N8YE32a4n250MH7E�>sf�C78;C7JD670cE7C]HKs¦qN8YWL2p¶ÒWYH7E�2D4=0MEI65HKEIJcR�2DC<8e4N8/°�E78FLcC(4847Q:C§1�H=4o28C78bEIH�L78 ' 0cE`úTg

PO

ü

Äú

ô

§þ

�� û

'

Ó

gv0DC(674N8 ¦ >�¥<t1Å�Q?¿�¹a· F ¿¦½ F ¼ � FY¶+yLI � FnS Q�·¦¸M¹L�h¹\µ�¸»½�·�Q H=S ½É¸ H=I � H ¹ y � FnS Q�·¦¸M¹L�h¹ ò6%0MEIW?8pE:H¦L78�Ä;0M6�E:HE2p0ME`2DC78/0cE3258?4e6%8FW9250cHKE«H71h28C78pL:HK9�4=0cE:651b4eHK9 � 47EIL þ 47EIL«E:H�L<8]Óu0M6hE:H=2p0cE2DC78pC7JD670cE7C�H7s¦qN8YWL2X6%0MEIW?8;Ä�0c6�E:HE2O0MEu2DC78jCKJD670cE7CbH7s¦qN8YWL2X47E:L þ 9b4PQ:6�ÄV4PE:L*Ó�HKEP28C78�68479e85E:H¦L780ME Ú >�f�C78¡4%8Y6�254N0MW92%8YL*9�H=48Q:C70c689_6 §� ­ [ 47EIL §þ ­ [ H7E[¶Ò4E4%8p2DHE2a47JU9_H¦L78YJ�9�H(4eQ:C70c689_6:2DC�4n2X6D4E2%0M6e1»R2DC78VJcH�WY47JD0K2SR]WYHKE:L<0�250cHKE:69>hÃ�JD8Y476%8VEIH=250cW?87g�28C�4E2O28C78VQ�4=4�250M47J`9_H�L<8YJ`9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9�6�3¬H=6:JML^E:H=2\6D4E2%0M6e1»R2DC78_JMH¦W47J�0�2SRGWYHKEIL70�2%0MHKE:6Fg�6N0ME:W98 þ 0c6XE:H=2j0MErqN8FW9250ON(8_47E:L[2DC78_9�47Q:Q70cE7Ct1b4eHK9 E:H¦L78bÓk0cE`ú�2DHsü�0c6E:H=2�s70 qN8FW92%0cN(8E>Bf�C78XQ76:68CIH(6<2�9�H(4eQ:C70c689_6A4=4%8^C(0ON(8FEGs�Rs2DC<8¥9_H¦L78YJx9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9�6�3i0K2DC]Q�4=4�250M47Jxs�476N89�H(4eQ:C70c689_6¬1b48HK9Æü[2DH ô 4N8Y68Q�>:1b48HK9 û¹28H ô > Ê

¢Y¤�Ì Õ ��­/  � ��� ½   ��« �G�>�D��� Ä �>� �Y­�©2¨ � , �  >��¨¡� ���   �j� ¿ø��� ¨d*#��Ëu½ ­ � ¨ ½   9i�4�Y� ¨ � § � ø �=  �* ¨ § �7* Ú Æ�­/  �   � ­f�C70M6@6%8FW9250cHKEhQ<4%8Y6N8YE32D6v2DC78�6%0ME<CKJD8�Q76:6eC:H(6<2��-¹IÃ<�X�k47Q:Q74eH�47WaC�28H�L70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FL�C(4847Q:Cj2%4D47EI6e1�H(4e9b4E2%0MHKE3i0�2DC_JMH¦W4PJ ¼ À26N2D4E258F6X0cE�2%8YE:L<8YL�1�H=4B28C78�6eQY8FW?0�°�W4E2%0MHKE_H71ÔL70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YL_6eR¦6N2%8Y9_6�47E:L]2DC7890D4B4%6IJD8[À2s�476N8YL9b47E<0MQ76:JM4E250cHKE�>4¹+2D4E258F6¬H71�28C78�L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FLb6ÁR�6�258F9Í4=4N8�6eQY8FW?0¦°78YLps�R�9�H¦L78YJc6B0ME ¼ g�3AC78?4N8:2DC<8�s�476N8

ó ¤

Page 87: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

C(4D47QIC/0M6X8�·�670MQIQY8FLTs�Rp47ET47LIL70�2%0MHKE�4PJ�2SR¦Qd8O0ME�1�H(489�4E250cHKE�>\f�C78:2SR¦Qd8YL]s�476N8OC(4D4PQ:CpH71@4�9_H�L<8YJd4%8YQ¦À4%8Y6N8YE32D6h28C78:2DH7Q®HKJcH(C7R_H71{28C78uL70M6�254N0Ms76<2%8YLp6ÁR¦6N258F9�47E:L/28C78u9_H�L78FJY4N8/°�E<8Y6@2DC<8uWYHK9_Q®H7E78YE32D6¬H71â2DC70c62DHKQ?HKJMH=C7Re28H�H7s¦qN8YWL2D6�H71v28C78XW4E2%8?CKH=4eR ¼ 4N8YQ74N8Y6N8YE3250cE7Ce28C78?0�4�JMH¦W47Jx6�2a4E2%8Y69>¹+2D4E258^2%4D47E:6Á1�H(489�4E2%0MHKE:64=4%8�6eQY8FW?0�°A8YL*s�R ¶ ¸M¹[½ S ¸#�Y¿¦½ y8¶ Q S5FY¶ ¿ � ½É¸ F ºI¹[g�2DC:4E2X4=4N8VQ�4=4N2%0v47J@9_H�L78FJ`9_H(48QIC70M6e9�6w0ME ¼ Q<4%8Y6N8?4ÁN�0cE7C2DC78i2SR¦QY8�0MEI1�H=489�4E250cHKE�H71d2DC78�s�476N8wC=4D47Q:CI6?>�f�C78�47Q:Q:J�0MWY4E250cHKE�H71ÔL70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YL_Q748H¦L76:WL250MH7E:6B0M6�s�476N8YLHKEt4_Q76I68C:H(6�2w0cEs2DC78XW4n258?C7H(4eR )�¨ «vzX>¢Y¤�Ì}¤�� Ä �Y� § �   �R¨ ¨ � �´¨�© Õ ��­/  � ��� ½   ��« �G�>�D��� ­ � � «èÕ ��­/  � ��� ½   ��« )�¨ �>��� ��­-,æ­0SEe2DC<0M6U3�H(48í�gI0�WYHKEI6%0ML<8?4�4¥L70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FL�6ÁR�6�258F9wWFHKE:6N0M6N2%0ME7CXH71ÔWYHKEIW?674N4%8YE32¬Q748H¦W?8F686%8F6¬WFHK9�9�6:E70MWY4E2eÀ0ME7CpN+0v4T6eC�4=4%8FL±Q?H(4N286_�ÉH(4uWaC:47E:E78FJM6Yg\0ME32%8?4e1É4PW?8Y6D�L>¡f�C78¡2DHKQ?HKJcH(C(0MWY47JkL78Y6eW?4N0MQ<2%0MHKE*H71¬4]L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FL6eR¦6N2%8Y9 WYHKE:6N0M6�250ME<CbH71�Q<48H¦W?8Y6e6%8F6u47E:L�Q?H(4�2D6A1�HKJMJcH�3A6h28C78�47QIQ748H�4PWaC�H71�� SNH ��� H=S ¹ ¼ FnS�� ¸M¹[½ S ¸#�Y¿�½ y8¶� � ¹[½ y �h¹¾� W !8¹:�ÔHP1�âGHKE32D47E�4=4N0�47E:L���HK6e6%0®ô â�Ã"� ¤K¤rõ >\�èC78?4N8476`âGHKE32a4PE�4=4%0�4PE:L��AHK686N0�L78Y6eW?4N0Msd8128C782DHKQ?HKJMH=C7Rhs�RVC�R¦Qd8?4%8FL7C(8F6Yg�3AC<8?4%8AC�R¦QY894%8FL7C(8Y6¬4=4%8�Q<48H¦W?8Y6e6%8F6�47E:LdE:H¦L78F6�4E4%8AQ®H=4N2D6Fg�0À4N8YQ74N8Y6%8FE32X28C782DHKQ?HKJMH=C7RVH71x45L70c6N254N0Ms76�258YL�6eR¦6N2%8Y9ws�Rb4o2SR¦QY8FL/C(4D4PQ:C;0cEe2DC<8�2SR¦Qd8OC(4D4PQ:C ��� 1�H(4�L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FLb6ÁR�6 À258Y9_6U6eC:H�3AEe0cE¡gÀ0DC(6<4%8 ¦ > ¤ >vf�C78@2SR¦QY8iC(4847Q:C ��� Q748H�N+0ML<8Y6�2S3�HZ2SR¦Qd8Y6�H71®E:H¦L78Y6Fg�E�479]8YJcRoQ S5F���y ¹a¹ y ¹

Process Port

gÀ0DC=674%8 ¦ > ¤ tpñ � Q y�Ì=S%H Q�· ��� ¼ FnSh¶ ¸M¹[½ S ¸#�Y¿�½ y8¶ ¹ � ¹[½ y �h¹ ò47E:LuQ FnS ½»¹L>\ó�L7C(8F6X4=4%85Q®H(0cE3250ME<C_1b4eHK9ÒQ®H(4�2D6:28HbQ74eH�W98Y6e6%8Y6Fg=6%6:WaC�28C�4E2\WFHKE:E78FW92%0MHKE:6�sY8L2S3x898YE^Q748HrÀW?8Y6e6%8F6�4=4%8�Q?HK686N0Ms:J�8�H7E:JcR�N+0M4¥Q?H(4N286?>�f�R¦QY8FLsC(4D4PQ:C:610ME ��� W4PEbsd8�6N8?8YEp476�C�R¦Qd8?4%C=4D47Q:CI6Yg�3AC<8?4%8Y476Q�4=4N2%0v47J ��� À�2SR¦Qd8YL�C(4D4PQ:C�9�H(4eQ:C70c689_6�4=4N8T9�H(4N8sC(8YE<8?4D4PJx2DC�4PE´C�R¦Qd8?4%C=4D47Q:C´9_H(48Q:C<0M689_6�L76<8k28H2DC7890D4AQ�4=4�250v4PJD0�2SR=>BgA674N28C78?4e9�H(4N87g728C785L<8YJD8L250cHKEGHP1UQ?H(4N286�0c6AE:H=2�Q®H7686%0cs:JD8o0cEÂô â�Ã"� ¤7¤Põ g�3AC7894%8Y476�H(6<447Q:Q74eH�47WaCG47JMJcH�3A6�4=4es70�2%4D4=4ÁRpE78L2S3¬H=48íTWYH7Eg°AC(67484E250cHKE:69>�0SE�47L:L70K250MH7Exg�28C785WFHKE:W98YQ<2�H71À2SR¦Qd8YLuC(4D47QIC:61�H(4�L<8Y68W94%0cs70ME7Ce2DC78Z2DHKQ?HKJMH=C7R]H71�4bL<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FL�6eR¦6�258Y9�6%0c9�Q:J�0¦°A8F6h2DC78Z2DC78FH(4%8L250MWY47J@WYHKE:6N0ML7894D4E2%0MHKEI6Jv4E2%8?4�HKE�>ÃB4eH�W98Y6e6%8Y6�47E:L]Q?H(4N286�3i0�28C70MET4VL70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FLT6eR¦6N2%8Y9�9�4�RbsY8uHP1�L<0còY8?4%8FE32h2SR�Qd8¥476�3X8YJMJ�>qf�C70M6@2SR¦Qd80MEI1�H(4e9b4n250MH7E]0c6X4N8YQ74N8Y6N8YE3258FLGs�Rb4bº y ½Ðµ FnS_� ½ � Q y�Ì=SNH Q�·jäP���dg�2DC�4E2x0M6¬4�C(4D4PQ:C;2SR¦QY8FLs0ME ��� >qf�C782SR�Q<0ME7Ce0ME ��� 8YE:6N674%8F6:2DC:4E2i2DC785E7892S3�H(48ís2SR¦Qd8�C(4847Q:C�äP��� C:476w28C7856�254N6:W92%674%8�HP1�4�L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FL6eR¦6N2%8Y9 WFHKE:6%0c6N2%0ME7C«H71¥Q74eH�W98Y6e6%8Y6]WFHKE:E78FW9258FLæN+0M4ÂQ®H(4�2D69>©f�C7894%8[1�H(4%8Pg:84PWaCJ2SR¦Qd8YLöC(4D4PQ:C¹0ME�28C78E7892S3�H(48í�2SR¦Qd8¡C(4D47QIC`äP��� 0M6X47Jc68H]4/2SR¦QY8FLÊC(4847Q:C¢0ME ��� >�M�R�L78/°�E<0ME7Cs2DC<0M6uí�0ME:L*H7112S3¬HrÀSJD8[N(8FJ2SR�Q<0ME7CV3X8h47WaC<0D8FN=8h4Ví�0MEILtHP1U9]892a4�À�2SR¦Q70ME<Cd476AQ74%8F6%8YE32%8YL�0cE*ô�a<;H73 ¤ ¥ õ >ÕP��Ö �4�= >��¨¡�£¢j¤�Ìø¤��«¯�� �  �ø�¨ �J�  L� �M�e¨��>�D�`� ­r²ó¾4PWaC�2SR�Qd8YL�C=4D47Q:C�� Ú ¯&� tAäÞ��� ² ��� H71q28C78hWY4E2589CKH(4ÁR{�i���g�`� ®6� Î 0M6�4�º y ½Ðµ FnS_� ½ � Q yuÌ=S%H Q�·+>�Ê8]L78�°�E78]s�R´ÿ8� õ�ë�� ��äP���5� ¤ « Ó�®ãäÞ��� ) ­ � Ú ¯&� �bÓ®� ¤ ë �E ýL� �J� ¯ 2DC<8t6N892_H71iQ S5F���y ¹a¹T½ � Q y ¹H71XäÞ����47E:L^s�R^ÿZn�J�Ý� õrë�� �#äÞ���5� ¤ « Ó�®RäÞ��� ) ­ � Ú ¯&� �bÓ®� ¤ ë n�J� ¯ 28C78V6%8L2¥H711Q FnS ½A½ � Q y ¹�H71äÞ���]>T0�3i4%0�2%8�6eC:H(4�2DJcR*ÿk� õrëA� 4N8Y68Q�>GÿZ��a�Ý� õ�ë�� 0O1x28C78]2SR¦Qd8YLcC=4D47Q:CÊäÞ����0M68°<U�8YL«4PE:L±WFJD84E41b48HK9È2DC78XWYH7E�2%8LU+2-> Êg�H=4X2DC<8�1�HKJMJcH�3i0ME7CZ4%8FQ74%8F6%8YE32D4E250cHKETH71@E7892S3�H(4eíe2SR¦QY8^C=4D47Q:CI6�� Ú ¯&� t�äÞ���µ² ��� g�3X8uL78YQ70cW92�H7E:JcR2DC78wC(4D47QIC/äÞ���¡>qf�C78:2SR¦Q70cE7C�0cE ��� WY47Epsd8:4%8FWYHKEI6N254N6:W92%8YLT1b48H79�2DC78wC(4D47QIC70MWY47J�Jv4RKH(6�2�H71=EIH�L78F647E:Lm8YL7C(8F6?>

¥KË

Page 88: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

½:¾ø� , �v*#� ¢j¤�÷°¯,� �  [øh¨ �a�  L� �M�ͨ¡�>�D��� ²f�C78uE7892S3�H(4eíe2SR¦QY8^C=4D47Q:CkäP���©0MEe2DC78^gv0DC(674N8 ¦ >KÄ�ËhH7E/2DC78\J�8F1É2ÁÀSC�47EILp6%0cL78\WYH7E:6%0c6N2D6¬H71â2S3¬Hp2SR¦Qd8Y61�H(4�Q<48H¦W?8Y6e6%8F6Yg�E�479]8YJORdQ748H¦W?8F686x2SR¦Qd8 Ö 4PE:L × >qf�C7894%8O8VU�0M6N286�HKE78�Q®H=4N2x2SR¦Qd8u47E:L;0�2�W47Epsd8:8Y476%0cJcRWaC78YWaíE8YLk2DC�4E212DC<8:C(4847Q:C/äP���ã0c6¬4o2SR�Qd8YLsC=4D47Q:Ce0ME ��� >"�\E;2DC78w4%0�CKC32eÀSC:47E:L_6%0ML<8�H71�28C78�°7C(674%8�42SR�Qd8YLmC(4847Q:Ck0MEmäÞ���ë0c6�68C:H�3AE�>�0�2�WYH7E:6%0c6N2D6AH71â2S3�H�Q<48H¦W?8Y6e6%8F6�H71\2SR¦QY88Öñ47E:LT1�H(6<4 × ÀSQ74eH�W98Y6e6%8Y69>Ø 6h2DC70c6hC(4D4PQ:Cu0c6A4p2SR�Qd8YLuC(4D4PQ:Ck0MEmäÞ���dgA0�2h0c6A476�3x8FJMJk4p2SR¦QY8FLPC(4847Q:Ck0ME ��� > Ê

A

B

A B

B

B

A

network type graph NTG

B

gÀ0DC(6<4%8 ¦ >KÄ�Ë<t1Å º y ½Éµ FnS�� ½ � Q y�Ì=S%H Q�·¡äÞ��� H º ¶sH ½ � Q y8¶VÌ=SNH Q�·t¸»ºsäÞ��� ò021:3x8�68Qd8YW90c1»R¥4�WFHKE:W94%892%8¬L70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FLh6eR¦6�258Y9tg�4�E7892S3�H(48í^2SR¦Qd8xC(4847Q:CpäP���ö0c6Y°�U<8FL�>qg�H(4â0MEI6N2a4PE:W?8Pg2DC78�E7892S3�H(48ío2SR¦QY8XC(4D4PQ:C�0cE�óÀUI479�QIJD8�Ó�>|Ó�68CIH�3A6v2DC78�E7892S3�H(48ío2SR¦QY8XC(4D4PQ:C51�H(4â2DC<8¬L70c6N254N0Ms76�258YL5WYHKE¦À°AC(67484E250cHKE�9�47E�4EC(8Y9]8YE32�6eR¦6N2%8Y9yHP1=H(674�W476N8�6N2%6:LIR=>1f�C<8\W4E2%8?CKH=4eRG�G�>�D��� ® Ú ¯&� �ÉW[1�>"!O8F1�> ¦ >KÄ(>åÓ7�H71x2SR¦Qd8YLcC(4847Q:C:6Z0ME[äP���Ò47EIL±Q�4=4�250M47JqäÞ���\À�2SR¦Qd8YLÂ9_H(48QIC70M6e9�6uQ74eH�N�0cL78Y6o2DC<8�Q?HK686N0Ms:J�8¡C(4D47QIC:61�H(4@2DC78^28HKQ®H7JMH(C7Rb47E:Lk2DC<8¥Q?HK6e6%0MsIJD8^4%8FJv4E2%0MHKEI6�sY8L2S3x898YEm2DHKQ?HKJMH=C(0D8F6?>ÕP��Ö �4�= >��¨¡�£¢j¤�Ìø¤¦¥°¯ § �   �R¨ ¨ � �´¨�©)� �  �ø�¨ �J�%¨¡�>�D��� ­r²W 0ON(8YE�4�E78L2S3¬H(4eíj2SR¦Qd8@C(4D4PQ:C�� Ú ¯�� t�äÞ��� ² ��� gE28C78�W4n258?C7H(4eR��G�>�D��� ® Ú ¯&� 0M6�W47JcJD8FL �%H ½ yðÌ+FnS��F ¼ º y ½Ðµ FnS_�5Ì=SNH Q�·�¹�3i0�2DCm4%8F68Qd8YWL2w28H;äP���¡>��\s¦qN8YWL2D6�H71å�i���g�`� ® Ú ¯&� 4=4%8XW4PJMJD8FL^º y ½Ðµ FnS_�5Ì=SNH Q�·�¹47E:L]9�H=48Q:C70c689_6�4=4N8uW47JcJD8FL�º y ½Ðµ FnS_�5Ì=SNH Q�·/� FnS Q�·¦¸M¹L�h¹L>`021v28C78uE7892S3�H(4eí;2SR¦QY8oC(4847Q:Cs0M6å°<U�8YLG47E:LE:HdWYHKEI1b6I6%0MH7Eu0c6�Q®HK6e6%0cs:JD8Pg:0¬L78FE:H=2%8¥E<892S3�H(48ísC(4847Q:C:6 � � tR�µ² äP��� 68C:H=4N2DJORTs�RP�¡> Êg�H=4�2DC78p1�H7JMJMH�3i0cE7C�WYH7E:6%0cL78?484E250cHKE:6�0547686N6:9]8G4¶°�U<8FLçE78L2S3¬H=48íÊ2SR¦Qd8mC=4D47Q:CàäP���¡>Â0Z0M9_Q:JD0cW?0K2DJcR47686N6:9e8]2DC�4n2�8Y47WaCÂE78L2S3¬H(4eí`C=4D47Q:CÂ47E:LÊ8Y47WaC«E78L2S3¬H(4eí§9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9 H¦WYW?6<4%4%0cE7CP0cE`28C78�6N8�·�678FJ@0M654E7892S3�H(48ísC=4D47Q:Cm4%8F68Q�>�E<892S3�H(48íT9_H(48QIC70M6e9Ñ3i0�28Ck4%8Y6eQY8FW92�2DH]äÞ���¡>g�H=4�2DC78b68Qd8YW?0�°�W4n250MH7E«H71�JMH¦W47J�6N2a4n258Y6VHP1�Q<48H¦W?8Y6e6%8F6Yg¬H7s¦qN8YWL2D6dH71�4�W4E2%8?CKH=4eR ¼ 4=4N8;2a47íE8YE�>Êf�C78WaC:H(0MW98uH71\2DC78¥47WL256�47JÔW4E2%8?CKH(4ÁRpL78FQY8FE:L:6�HKEs2DC78¥47QIQ:JD0cW4E2%0MHKE]2DC78XL78F6%0DC7E78?4�C�4P6�0cET9e0cE:L�>�Ã@HK686N0Ms:J�8W4E2%8?CKH(4N0D8F6�9�4R5sd8xC=4D47Q:CI6Yg7Q:4=4N2%0v47J¦47J�C(8Ys748476Yg Ø a6��ÀGC(4847Q:C:6v8928W=>Àf�C<8�W4E2%8?CKH=4eRX1�H(4â2DC78�JMH¦W47J�6N2D4E258F6H71q2DC78VWY476%8V6�256:L�R�0ME»¹�8YWL250MH7E*Ó�> ' 4E4%8 H ½É½ S ¸#�Y¿¦½ y8¶bÌ=S%H Q�·�¹L>O�`8h3i0cJMJ\8LU�Q:Jv4E0MEP28C70M6\WY4E2589CKH(4ÁRP0cE�1b6:JMJL7892D4=0MJ\0MEe¹�8YWL250MH7E ¦ > ¦ > ¸�H�3X8FN=8?4Fg=E:H=2uHKEIJcRs2DC<8�Q748H¦W?8F686N8Y6^C(8L2X4�JcH�WY47Jk6N2a4n2587gÔs76<2u4PJM68He2DC785Q®H(4�2D69>f�C78bJcH�WY47J�6N2D4E258F6�H71�Q?H(4N286j0cE:L70cW4E2%8]28C78bL�4n2a4u6I6%8YLÊ0ME`28C78bWFHK9_9p6:E70cW4E2%0MHKE^sd892S3X8?8YE«Q<48H¦W?8Y6e6%8F6?>f�C78O2DHKQ?HKJcH(C7R¡4%8FQ74%8F6%8FE�2%8YLGs�Rp4�E7892S3�H(4eí;C(4847Q:C]47E:L/28C78uJMH¦W4PJ?6�2a4E2%8Y6h4N8YQ74N8Y6%8FE3258YLGs�R ¼ ÀSHKs�qN8YW92864=4%8^0cE�2%8?C(484E258FLu0cEt4 ¶ ¸M¹[½ S ¸#�Y¿�½ y8¶VÌ=SNH Q�· §�¡>ÕP��Ö �4�= >��¨¡�£¢j¤�Ìø¤�Ì°¯ « ��­/  � ��� ½   ��«¾¨��>�D��� ²W 0ON(8YE�4pE7892S3�H(48ím2SR¦QY8pC=4D47Q:C¢äP���Ñ47EIL^4bW4E2%8?CKH=4eR ¼ gÔ4 ¶ ¸M¹[½ S ¸#�Y¿¦½ y8¶bÌ=SNH Q�· Fa¡=yLS � µ�¸»½�· IDF��%H=I¼W¢ ¹[½ H ½ y ¹o0M6¥4GQ:4=0D4 §� ¤Þ¨ � � ��� ª g@3AC7894%8/� � tj� ² äÞ���æ0M6¥4GE<892S3�H(48í[C(4D4PQ:C§3i0K2DC[4%8Y6eQY8FW92p28HäÞ��� 47E:Lm�RtR� ² �Zzc0M6A4d9�H¦L78YJ�0ME ¼ > Ê

¥<Ä

Page 89: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

Ø ¶ ¸M¹[½ S ¸#�Y¿¦½ y8¶ � FnS Q�·¦¸M¹L�çsd892S3X8?8FE�2S3¬H\L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FL�C(4847Q:C:6v0M6�4�Q�4E4N250M47J�9�H¦L78FJ¦9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9 sd892S3X8?8YE2DC78*9�H¦L78FJM6TH71Z2DC78*L70c6N254N0Ms76�258YLJC(4847Q:C:6§�ÉW[1�>�!O8/°�E70K250cHKE ¦ >|Ó�>�¥K�L>Èf�C78§Q:4=4N2%0v47J\s:476%8*9�H=48Q:C70c689sY8L2S3x898YEP28C78XE7892S3�H(48ísC=4D47Q:CI6�C:476h2DHdQ74%8F6%894eN(8h47L:L70K250cHKE�47JcJcR�2DC<8¥Q<48H¦W?8Y6e6�4PE:L]Q®H(4�2i2SR�Qd8Y69>ÕP��Ö �4�= >��¨¡�£¢j¤�Ìø¤�¢è¯ « ��­/  � ��� ½   ��« ,§¨ �>��� ��­-,´²W 0ON(8YE±4tE<892S3�H(48í¢2SR¦QY8eC(4D47QICcäÞ���dgU4]W4E2%8?CKH=4eR ¼ 47E:L[2S3¬H�L70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YLÊC=4D47Q:CI6©§� ¤Þ¨ � � ��� ª47E:L §È ¤ç¨ �¤£w�%� ª H�N=8?4��æ4%8F68Q�>�ȧg�4 ¶ ¸M¹[½ S ¸#�Y¿¦½ y8¶ � FnS Q�·¦¸M¹L� §� t §� ² §È 0c6�4�Q�4=4�250M47J�9�H¦L78YJ9�H(4eQ:C70c689 §� ¤È¨ � �   >�ª t<�£² ��0cE ¼ sd892S3X8?8FE�2DC7859�H¦L78YJc6��Ù47E:Lu� 6N6:WaCP28C�4E2 � tD�ÚÜ È·0c64_E78L2S3¬H=48íkC(4D4PQ:C�9_H(48QIC70M6e9Ñ3i0�28CP4N8Y68Qd8YWL2w28H/äP���¡> Ø L70c6N254N0Ms76�258YLt9_H(48Q:C<0M689 §� 0c6�WY47JMJ�8YL^½ F ½ H=I0c1â2DC78X9_H�L<8YJx9_H(48QIC70M6e9 §� 0M6@28H=2a47J�> Êó�UI479_Q:J�8Y6¾H71=L70c6N254N0Ms76�258YLeC(4D4PQ:C:6�4PE:LbL70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FLb9_H(48Q:C<0M689 WY47Ebsd8�1�H=6:E:L;0cEbH(6<4�WY476%8\6�256:L�Re0cE¹�8YWL250MH7E*Ó�> ¦ >�ÄV4PE:L�2DC78�4N8Y9�4=0MEIL78?4�H71 ³ C�47Q<2%8?4¥Ó�>�!O0c6N254N0Ms76�258YLuC(4D4PQ:C:6X47E:L©9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9�6�4=4N8V47JM6eH6:6%8FLP0ME ³ C:47Q<25894 ' >Ø JMJ�L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FLjC=4D47Q:CI6�4PE:LhL70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FL59_H(48QIC70M6e9�6x3i0K2DCZ4%8Y6eQY8FW92v2DH�4�E78L2S3¬H=48í^2SR¦QY81C(4D4PQ:C�äP���47E:LG4_WY4E2589CKH(4eR ¼ 1�H(489y4_WY4E2589CKH(4eRtÕ¶�i�Ez¬��äP���5�L> ³ HK9_Q®H76%0�2%0MHKETHP1`L70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FLG9_H(48QIC70M6e9�6h0c6L78/°�E<8YL«s�R*WYHK9_Q®H76%0�2%0MHKE©HP1�9�H¦L78FJ¾9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9�6o0cE§WY4E2589CKH(4eR )�¨ «\zz4PE:Lc0ML<8YE3250K250D8F6¥4=4%8_L78/°:E78YL476�0cL78YE3250K250�8Y6Z0ME )�¨ «\z�gU6N0ME:W98/0ML<8YE3250K250D8F65Q<4%8Y6N8?4ÁN(8s2SR¦QY8F6�HKs�N+0MH(6:6eJcR=>�0SEÊ28C78/4%8F9b4E0ME:L78945HP1h2DC70c6WaC�47Q<2%8?4Yg�3X8¥47686N6:9e8¥4dWYH¦WYHK9_Q:J�89258�W4E2%8?CKH(4ÁR ¼ >ÃB6I68C:H(6�2D6_H71�L70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YL�9�H=48Q:C70c689_6p0MEr28C78TW4E2%8?CKH=4eR�Õ¶�G�nz¬��äÞ���5��4=4%8TWFHKE:6�254%6IW9258FLçs�Rc28C78Q76:68CIH(6<2AH71â2DC<8uQ�4=4N2%0v47J?9_H�L78FJÔ9_H(48QIC70M6e9�6X0ME/2DC<8uW4E2%8?CKH(4ÁR )�¨ «vzX>qf�C78O2SR¦Q70cE7CdH71â2DC78uQ<6:68C:H=6<2HKs¦qN8YWL2^4%8F6%6:JK2D6u4P6:6:E70¦·�678p8LU+2%8YE:6N0MHKE�>��\1�WFH(674e6%87gY2DC78�Q<6:68C:H=6<2uH71�L70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FL�9�H=48Q:C70c689_6w8VU�0M6N286HKE:JcR;0c1â2DC<8¥Q<6:68C:H=6<2:8VU�0M6N286�1�H(4@2DC78XQ�4E4N250M47Jx9_H�L<8YJx9_H(48QIC70M6e9�6@0cE )Ǩ «vz1>Ë;� ¨ � ¨¡­Ï�# ��ɨ¡�%¢Y¤�Ì}¤�é°¯ �4½ ­ � ¨ ½  >­Ô��� Õ¶�G�nz¬��äÞ���5� ²ð ÑØÅ�ÌRÃtÓ�É�Á�ÃÝügÛDÉÝÅ�ÌÍÒGÀ>ÁyË�ÑgÃtÓ,Ò`Ó §� t §Ö ² §Ú Î�ÆØÌ §þ t §Öx² §× Ñ�ÎVÄ>Å?Î�Ë[ÛÓ�ÑØÀ�ÛDÉæÆ^Õ¶�G�nz��#äÞ���h��æßÉ�ÑØÅuÛÆØÌgÅ�Á,ÐûÊgÃtÆgÂ;ËøÎ�Á�É�ÃòÎ�Ð�ÒGÀ�ÌgÅ�Ð}ÒGÀ>ÁyËØÑDÃtÓ�ÒÔÓ §� Î�ÆØÌ §þ Ñ�ÎVÄ>ÅkÎkË[ÛÓ,Ñ¡À�ÛDÉ ÃtÆ )�¨ «Àz ã ÊÍ S5F�F ¼f�C78�Q76I68C:H(6�2pH71w2DC78tL70M6�254N0Ms76<2%8YL�9�H(4eQ:C70c689_6 §� 47E:L §þ 0c6_WFHKE:6�254%6IW9258FLÙ476]2DC78tQ76:6eC:H(6<2bH71:28C786:E:L78948JcR+0cE7C]Q�4=4N2%0v47J`9�H¦L78YJ�9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9�6 §� 47E:L §þ 0ME�2DC78dWY4E2589CKH(4eR )�¨ «vzñ�ÉWF1�>{f�C<8YH(4N8Y9 ¦ >|Ó�>KÄ�óK�L>f�C7812SR¦Q70cE7C�H71�28C78�s�476N8XC(4847Q:C¥H71+2DC78¾Q76:6eC:H(6<2@HKs¦qN8FW92v4%8F6%6:JK2D6@476\6:E70t·�678B8VU�2%8YE:6N0MHKE5H71+2DC78B4%8F6%6:JK250cE7CL70v4=C=4D479_6jC7H=2Vs�RÊ28C78TQ76:6eC:H(6<2dWFHKE:6N2%4%6:WL250cHKE §� 47EIL¹§þ 0cE )Ǩ «ÀzX>¢f�C78TQ<6:68C:H=6<2dQ748H7QY894N250�8Y6p0cEÕe�i�nz���äP���h��1�HKJcJMH�3è1b48HK9È2DC78XQ76I68C:H(6�2�Q74eHKQd8?4N2%0D8F6h0ME )�¨ «Àz1> å

¼ ¨ � ¨ *�*#�D� �%¢j¤�Ìø¤�÷ð ÑØÅ�ÌRÃtÓ�É�Á�ÃÝügÛDÉÝÅ�ÌÍÒGÀ>ÁyË�ÑgÃtÓ,Ò`Ó §� t §Ö ² §Ú Î�ÆØÌ[§þ t §Öx² §× Ñ�ÎVÄ>Å?Î�Ë[ÛÓ�ÑØÀ�ÛDÉæÆ^Õ¶�G�nz��#äÞ���h��æßÉ�ÑØÅuÁ�Å<ÓÏÉ�Á�Ã Ü ÉñÅ�Ì»ÒPÀ>Á-Ë�ÑDæÓ,Ò`Ó §� ­ [ Î�ÆØÌr§þ ­ [ À>ß §� Î�ÆØÌc§þ ï Ü ß ã );Å��DÆgÃyÉ�Ã#À>ÆCô ã õ�ã¦â¦¥ ùuÓ<ÎgÉ�æÓ,ß¦Ê É�ÑØÅ?Ð#À Ü Î�ÐtÃ-É�ÊÜ À>ÆØÌVÃyÉ�Ã#À>ÆDӪæÆ�);Å��DÆDÃ-É�Ã#À>ƶô ãöõgã¦â¦+ Î�ÆØÌ Ü ÎgÉñÅ,ÂgÀ>ÁÝÊ ¼ Ñ�Î�ÓåËHÛÓ,ÑØÀRÛDÉ�Ó ã ÊÍ S5F�F ¼g�H7JMJMH�3A6�L<0D4%8FW928JcRb1�H=489ÍÃq4eHKQ®H76%0�2%0MHKE ¦ > ' > � 47E:Lmf�C78YH=4%8Y9 ¦ >åÓ�>KÄ�ó�> å

¥�Ó

Page 90: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

¢Y¤�Ì}¤¦¥ ¼ ¨¡� « �= >�ɨ¡� �A* Ä ��� �4­�©ð¨ � , �  >�ɨ¡�ç¨�© Õ ��­�  � ��� ½   ��«]�G�>�D��� ­0]0cE32548H¦L76:W98�E:H�3æ2DC<8�254D4PE:6e1�H(4e9b4n250MH7E�H71XL<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FL�C(4847Q:C:6ps�R ¶ ¸M¹[½ S ¸#�Y¿¦½ y8¶ Q S5FY¶ ¿ � ½É¸ F ºI¹�� ë t§§ �¨² §©X�_WYH7E:6%0c6N250cE7CÂH71¥4¢Q S�FY¶ ¿ � ½É¸ F ºzº H � y ë 47E:Lè4±L70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FL°9�H=48Q:C70c689 §�§476bL78�°�E78FLJ0cE!O8/°�E70K250cHKE ¦ > ' > ¦ >\f�C78�L70M6�254N0Ms76<2%8YLpC=4D47Q:C §§[0c6`W4PJMJD8FL IDy ¼ ½ ¢ · H º ¶ ¹[¸ ¶+y gn2DC78¬L70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YLpC(4847Q:C�§© 28C78S ¸ Ì ·¦½ ¢ · H º ¶ ¹[¸ ¶+y H71�28C78hQ<48H¦L76:W92%0MHKE�>�f�C<8hJD8[1É2eÀ2C�47E:LG6%0ML<8hL78F68W?4N0Msd8Y6�3AC<0MWaC�HKs�qN8YW9286u4�L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FLC(4D47QIC«9p6:6N2dWFHKE32a4=0cE«6%6:WaC�2DC:4E2�2DC78TQ<48H¦L76:W92%0MHKE«WY47E«sd8]47Q:Q:J�0D8YL�>`f�C78TL<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FL«9�H=48Q:C70c689§�u0cE:L70MWY4E258F6¥3AC<0MWaCÂHKs�qN8YW9286�0ME[2DC78�JD8F1É2ÁÀSC�4PE:L±6N0ML78�WYH(4N4%8Y6eQ®H7E:Lc2DH�3AC<0MWaCÂHKE<8/0ME[2DC78e4%0DC7C�2ÁÀSC�4PE:L6%0ML<8=>/�\s¦qN8YWL2D6X3AC78?4N8]28C78dL70M6�254N0Ms76<2%8YL^9_H(48Q:C<0M689�0M6^6:EIL78/°�E<8YLÂ4E4%8dL78YJ�892%8YL�> Ø JMJUHKs�qN8YW9286¥3AC<0MWaC4=4%8uQ74N8Y6N8?4eN=8YL�s�R/28C78X9�H=48Q:C70c689w1�H(489È2DC78¥47Q:QIJD0MWY4E250cHKEpWFHKE3258LU+2?>¾021U47E]HKs¦qN8FW92�0MEs2DC<8^4%0DC7C�2ÁÀSC�4PE:L6%0ML<8¥HP1v28C78XQ748H¦L76:WL250MH7EtC:476�E:H_Q74%8�ÀG0M9�4=C(8:6:E:L7894i28C78X9�H=48Q:C70c689tg<0K2i0M6A47L:L<8YL�>ÕP��Ö �4�= >��¨¡�£¢j¤�Ìø¤vÅ�¯ « ��­/  � ��� ½   ��«¾�Y� ¨ «Y½ §  >��¨¡��²Ø ¶ ¸M¹[½ S ¸#�Y¿�½ y8¶ Q S5FY¶ ¿ � ½Ð¸ F º ë t�� §§ �¨² §©X��WYHKE:6N0M6�2D6_H71\4PQ S5FY¶ ¿ � ½Ð¸ F º°º H � y ë 47E:L´4*L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FL9�H(4eQ:C70c689 §��> Êó�UI479_Q:J�8Y6�H71�L70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FL«Q748H¦L76:WL250MH7E:6V4=4N8/C(0cN=8YE�0ME±H(674�WY476%8]6N2%6:LIRÊ0ME¾¹�8FW9250cHKE´Ó�> ¦ gU3AC78FE�3X80ME3254eH�L76IW?8pL70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FL´Q<48H¦L76:W92%0MHKEI6p0ME¾¹�6Is:6%8FW9250cHKE�Ó�> ¦ >�Ä]4PE:L«3AC78YE«3X8m0cE32548H¦L76:W98;2DC<8TQ748H¦W?8F686C(4D479_9�4=486�HP1v28C78XW476N8¥6�256:L�Rk0ME͹�6:s:6N8YWL250MH7E�Ó�> ¦ >|Ó�>KÄ54PE:Le¹+6:s:6%8FW92%0MHKE�Ó�> ¦ >åÓ+>åÓ�>f�H«4PQ:Q:JcR´4*L70M6�254N0Ms76<2%8YL°Q<48H¦L76:W92%0MHKEà2DH±4§L70c6N254N0Ms76�258YL C(4D47QIC §�dg�HKE78�C:476e28H±9�47í=8G6%674N8P2DC�4n2§� WFHKE32a4=0cE:6t4E2GJD84P6N2G47JMJuH7s¦qN8YWL2D6�E<8YW?8F68684=4eRæ1�H(4]QY894e1�H(4e9e0cE7Cr2DC78*L78F6%0D4N8YLzHKQY894D4E2%0MHKEI6G4PE:LÛ28C7847Q:Q:J�0MW4n250MH7E�WFHKE3258LU+2?>ãf�C<8Y6%8^4E4%8�8VU:4PW92DJORR28C78�HKs�qN8YW9286pH71^28C78�Q74eH�L76IW9250cHKE«ª 6pJD8[1É2eÀ2C�47E:L�6%0ML<8 §§h>¸w8YEIW?8*0;0ME32%48H¦L76:W?8�28C78^E:H=2%0MHKEèH71h4¹� H ½ � ·«476]4�28H=2a4PJ\L70M6�254N0Ms76<2%8YLè9_H(48Q:C<0M689 §ß t §§ ² §�9b4E28WaC70ME<Ce2DC<8�JD8[1É2eÀSC:47E:L�6N0ML785H71q2DC<8�Q748H¦L76:WL250cHKEG3i0K2DC©4bQ:4=4N2�H71à§�]>wf�C78�9�4E2DWaC�9p6:6N2�sY8j2DH=2D47JðgH=2DC7894e3i0c6%8]E:H=2�47JcJ¬E7898YL78FL°HKs¦qN8FW92D6_H71�2DC78]J�8F1É2eÀ2C�47E:L�6N0ML78]C�4N(8G4©WYH(4N4%8F68Q?HKE:L70cE7C`0c9b4EC(8/0MEr28C78L70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YLkC(4D4PQ:C §�]>�0SEt47L:L<0�250cHKExg�0X4N8�·�670D4N8^2DC�4E2h28C78^4%8F6N2%4%0MWL258FLG9_H(48QIC70M6e9�6�HP1v28C78uQ748H¦L76:WL250cHKE9�H(4eQ:C70c689 §�b4PE:LP2DC<8�9b4n2DWaC §ß 6D4n250M6Á1»Rk2DC78�JcH�WY47JD0K2SRTWYH7E:L70�2%0MHKEI6w2DH;8YE:6N674%8p28C78hWaC�4E4D47WL258?4N0$#Y4E250cHKEH71{2DC78�Q748H¦L76:WL250cHKET47Q:QIJD0MWY4E250cHKEds�RT4hQ76I68C:H(6�2h0ME]2DC78\WY4E2589CKH(4ÁRbÕ¶�i�Ez¬��äP���5�L>qf�C<0M6¬WFHKE:L70K250cHKE;0c6W47JcJD8YL Ì=I ¿¦¸»º ÌP��F º ¶ ¸»½É¸ F º_1�HKJcJMH�3i0ME<C�2DC78XE:HE2a4E2%0MHKE]H71\2DC78oCKJ�670ME<CVWYHKE:L<0�250cHKEk0MEs2DC<8¥LIH(6:s:J�8¥Q<6:68C:H=6<247Q:Q74eH�47WaC 28HÊC(4847Q:CR2%4D47EI6e1�H(4e9b4E2%0MHKEïô ³ â¬�®­ ¤ ó õ gX2DC�4E2b47Jc68HÊ8FE:6%6<4%8Y6e2DC78u8LU�0M6�258YEIW?8�H71u4±L70D4N8YWL2L78?4N0cNP4E250cHKE�>ÕP��Ö �4�= >��¨¡�£¢j¤�Ìø¤c×°¯ ¨Y*�½ ��� ¨ § ¨¡� « �= >��¨¡�<¯v, �   § � ²Ø 2DH=2D47J�L70c6N254N0Ms76�258YL�9_H(48QIC70M6e9 §ß t §§³² §�Ý684E250c6�°A8F6�2DC78 Ì=I ¿¦¸»º ÌC��F º ¶ ¸»½É¸ F º^1�H=4d4^L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FLQ748H¦L76:WL250MH7E ë t�� §�|t §§ ² §©X�;0c1Z2DC<8`4N8Y6N2%4%0cW9258FLz9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9�6 §ß ­ [ 47E:L §� ­ [ H71 §ß 47E:L §�è�ÉW[1�>!O8/°�E70K250cHKE ¦ >|Ó�>�Ä � ��6D4n250M6Á1»R/2DC<8¥JcH�WY47JD0K2SR_WYHKE:L<0�250cHKE:6h0cE�!O8�°�E70K250MH7E ¦ >|Ó�>�ÄË<>Ø � H ½ � ·p1�H=454]L70c6N254N0Ms76�258YL^Q74eH�L<6:W92%0MHKE ë t¾� §§ �¨² §©X�^0ME^68HK9]8dL70M6�254N0Ms76<2%8YL[C(4D4PQ:C §� 0c6¥4k28H=2a47JL70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YL]9�H=48Q:C70c689 §ß}t@§§C² §�©2DC:4E2�6D4E2%0M6�°78Y6h2DC78oCKJ�670ME<CVWYHKE:L<0�250cHKE�> Êf�C78p47QIQ:JD0cW4E2%0MHKE©H71�4tL70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FL±Q74eH�L76IW9250cHKE ë t�� §§ �¨² §©X�¥4n2h4t9b4n2DWaC §ß t §§ ² §��0M6XWaC�4=4 À47W92%8?4%0°#?8FLæs�R�28C78^Q76:6eC:H(6<2tH71o2DC<8*Q<48H¦L76:W92%0MHKEÙ9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9 §�Â47E:L¹2DC78^9�4E2DWaC¹0cE¹2DC78©WY4E2589CKH(4eRÕe�i�nz���äP���h�V>|f�C78�8LU�0c6N258FE:W?8^H71^28C78�Q76I68C:H(6�2k0M6;8FE:6%6<4%8YLæs�RR28C78�CKJ�670ME7C*WYH7E:L70�2%0MHKE�1�H(4e28C789b4E28WaC±4PE:L ³ H=48HKJcJv4=4ÁR ¦ > ' > & >]f�C78e4N8Y6N6:J�2Z0M6X4]L7894%0cN=8YL§L70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YL[C(4D47QIC §È§gâ28C78_Q76:68CIH(6<25L70v4rÀC(4D479Þ0c6XW47JcJD8YL§4 ¶ ¸ S5y�� ½ ¶+yLS ¸ ¡nH ½Ð¸ F ºA>/f�C<8bL7894%0cN=8YLcC=4D47Q:C*9�4�R^sd8]6:6%8FL±1�H(4X1b674N28C78?4¥Q748H¦L76:WL250cHKE47Q:Q:J�0MW4n250MH7E:686�6N6:WaCu28C�4E2�3X8jC=892�4d6%8�·�678FE:W?85H71�L70D4N8YW92�L7894%0ON74n250MH7E:6?>

¥ '

Page 91: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

ÕP��Ö �4�= >��¨¡�£¢j¤�Ìø¤c÷°¯ « � �>� §   «Y�R� ��± �  >��¨¡�<¯ «Y�R� ��± �  >��¨¡��²aâ8L2 ë t�� §§ �¨² §©X�=sY8�4AL70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YLhQ<48H¦L76:W92%0MHKE547E:L §ß}t §§C² §�ÙsY8�4�9�4E28WaCxgn28C78 ¶ ¸ S5y�� ½ ¶+yLS ¸ ¡nH ½É¸ F º1b48HK9 §�ë2DH §È 3i0�2DC ë 4E2 §ß©g:3i4%0K2%2%8YE §� D³² �Z¤ � §È±gA0M6A4VQ76:6eC:H(6<2�H71 §�V47E:L §ß�0MEtÕ¶�G�nz��#äÞ���h�V>aâ8L2�� ë t §�K� D Î ä sY8�4�ÿ\ÀG0cE:L78VU<8FLh6N892�H71�L70c6N254N0Ms76�258YL¥Q74eH�L76IW9250cHKE:6@47E:L � � �I�Ðÿ5� ¤ « §� D´² �Z¤ � §È ­ ë ®©ÿ ¯sY8;28C78p6N892dH71�47JcJ�Q?HK6e6%0MsIJD8bL<0D4%8FW92VL<8?4%0ONP4E250cHKE:6Z6:6%0cE7C©Q748H¦L76:WL250cHKE:6hHP1�ÿdg�4 ¶+yLS ¸ ¡nH ½É¸ F º«¹ yPµ ¿ y º ��yH(4]68C:H(4�2 ¶+yLS ¸ ¡nH ½É¸ F ºR0c6t4�28H=2a47Ju9�47Q:Q<0ME7C·¶ t�� ² � � �I�Ðÿ5�p1b4eHK9 4�Q®H7686%0cs:JcR�0MEg°�E<0�258©Q<4%8/°�U� ¤ « Ë<�-Ä=� ZcZOZÙ¯ H71¬0 Jé 2DH � � �:�Éÿh��gk6%6:WaCc28C�4E2X1�H(4¥47JMJq£N�SàÊ®¸��3i0K2DC-¶?�#£S� ¤ � §� 3 D Ö ² �ZÀÖ¤ � §È 3 ��g¶?�Oà¦� ¤� §� ´ Dq¹_² �Z ¹¤ � §È ´ �uC:HKJMLI6Z28C�4E2�à ¤ £7º�Äe0M9_Q:JD0�8Y6 §� ´ ¤ §È 3 >/�`8�L<8YE:H=2%8p4]L78?4N0cNP4E2%0MHKE*6%8/·+6<8YE:W98Ts�R¶ ¤ � §��» DL¼P² �Z ¼¤ � §� � D 2 ² �Z 2¤ � ZOZOZ �V> Ê021�3X8TWYH79�Q�4E4%8;28C78Y6N8tL<8/°�E70K250cHKE:6h3i0K2DCc2DC<8/8LU�Q:JM47E�4E2%0MHKE:6hH71i2DC78pL<0D4%8FW92dL7894%0ON74n250MH7EÊ0ME ³ C:47Q<25894Ó�gø¹�8FW92%0MHKE*Ó�> ¦ >KÄKg�3x8V6N8?8p2DC:4E2:28C78�9�4E2DWaC�0cE±¹�8YWL250cHKE^Ó�> ¦ >KÄ�L:H+8Y6\E:HE2uC�4N(8�28HT6D4E2%0M6Á1»Rm28C78pCKJ�670ME<CWYHKE:L<0�250cHKE�>�f�C<0M6h0M6�s:476%8FL�HKEs2DC<8X1É4PW92h2DC:4E2�3x8XQ74eH�N�0cL78o0ME�!O8�°�E70�2%0MHKE ¦ > ' >�¥d47E:L½!O8/°:E70�2%0MHKE ¦ > ' > ¤8LU�0M6�258YEIW?8hWFHKE:L70K250cHKE:6�1�H(4�4_L<0D4%8FW92�L7894%0cNP4E2%0MHKEk0cEGWY4E2589CKH(4eRtÕ¶�i�Ez¬��äP���5�¬1�H(4�47E�4E48s70K254D4E4eRTWY4E258�ÀCKH(4eR ¼ 47E:L ³ C:47Q<25894\Ó�6:6N8Y6\4_WYHKEIW?4%8L258¥W4E2%8?CKH=4eR ¼ g�E�479]8YJcR;2DC78¥W4E2%8?CKH=4eR½9i�G��H71U4E2%2%4%0cs76<258FLC(4D47QIC:6?>�0SE]2DC70c6¬W4P6%87g+2DC78�L70D4N8YWL2¬L7894%0ON74n250MH7Ee8VU<0c6N286�47Jc68HZ0c1�28C78�9�4E2DWaC�L:H+8Y6¬EIH=2¬684E250c6e1»R¡2DC<8wCKJ�670ME<CWYHKE:L<0�250cHKE�>À�`8u3i0MJcJÔ68CIH�3ð2DC70c6h0ME͹�8YWL250cHKE ¦ > ¦ gAf�C78YH(4N8Y9 ¦ > ¦ >KÄ ' >

¢Y¤�Ì}¤¦¥}¤ � 9i�4�v* � § �  >��¨¡� ¼ ¨¡� « �= >��¨Ø�Y­?©2¨ �pÕ ��­/  � ��� ½   ��«RË'� ¨ «4½ §  >��¨¡�4­!O0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FL�Q<48H¦L76:W92%0MHKEI6�L78F68W94%0Msd8P0cE325670K250cN=8YJOR«C:H�3æC(0cN=8YE°L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FL C(4847Q:C:6_68C:47JMJAsd8u254847E:6 À1�H(489]8YLu0ME32DH�L78?4N0cN(8FL©L70M6�254N0Ms76<2%8YLuC(4D47QIC:6?> Ø L70c6N254N0Ms76�258YLGQ748H¦L76:WL250cHKEP0c6�47QIQ:JD0cW47s:J�8o0c1�28C78?4N8�0M6�49b4E28WaC�H71q28C78�JD8[1É2eÀ2C�47E:L�6N0ML78j0MEP28C78pC(0ON(8FE©L70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YL�C(4847Q:CxgY0�>�8=>�3X8�C�4N=8p2DH °�EIL�2DC78�H7s¦qN8YWL2D6H71â2DC78uJ�8F1É2eÀ2C�47E:LT6N0ML78^0cE/2DC78^C=0cN(8FE]L70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YLsC(4847Q:C�>�010ME3254eH�L<6:W?8\EIH�3Û2DC78uQ?HK6e6%0Ms<0MJD0K2SR¡2DHV68Qd8YW�À0c1»R]47LIL70�2%0MHKE�4PJ H Q3Q I ¸ �%H ½É¸ F º ��F º ¶ ¸»½Ð¸ F ºI¹�1�H(4i847WaCGQ�4=4�250MW96:Jv4E4�L70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YLtQ748H¦L76:WL250MH7Ek28C�4E2�4%8F6N2%4%0MWL22DC78�47Q:Q:J�0MWY4E250cHKE©H71�Q748H¦L76:WL250MH7E:6?> Ø Q:Q:J�0MWY4E250cHKE©WYHKEIL70�2%0MHKE:6u1�H(4XQ74eH�L<6:W92%0MHKE:6u3X8?4N8;0ME32%48H¦L76:W?8FL`0cEô ¸�¸wf ¤(& gö¸\âmf@� ¤ � õ gd0cE§ô�gÀ0c6 ¤ ¥ õ 2DC<8FRt4=4N8^C(0cN=8YEm0MEt47EÞ¸:a6��À 47Q:Q<48H�47WaC�>Ø E*47Q:Q:J�0MWY4E250cHKEGWFHKE:L70K250cHKE�1�H(4u4pL<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FL©Q748H¦L76:WL250cHKE©WYHKEI6%0M6�2D6uH71�4i°�E70K258�6N892XH71 ��F º ¶ ¸»½É¸ F º H=I��F ºI¹[½ SNH ¸»º�½»¹�H�N(8?4�45L70c6N254N0Ms76�258YL;C(4D47QIC�>�f�C78O0cL784¥H71k4hWFHKE:L70K250cHKE�47J�WFHKE:6N2%4D4=0cE32@0M6B2DC<8:4%8/·�670D4N8Y9]8YE32H71�6N2%4%6:WL25674N8Y6�0cEÂ4�L70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FLÊC(4847Q:C §�æ6:E:L7894�2DC<8p476e6%6:9_Q<250cHKE±HP1h2DC78e8LU�0M6�258YEIW?8TH71A4GW?8?4�2a4=0cE6%6:s�À26N2%4%6:WL25674N8j0cE §�¡>ÕP��Ö �4�= >��¨¡�£¢j¤�Ìø¤����Ù¯ § ¨¡� « �= >��¨¡� �A* § ¨¡�4­�  �>� ���¡ ¾¯ �g�4�v* � § �  >��¨¡� § ¨¡� « �= >��¨Ø�U²Ø ��F º ¶ ¸»½É¸ F º H=IY��F ºI¹[½ SNH ¸»º�½ ýLý �¿ ¤ � §Ó�t@§§C² §�r� ý �À �¬H�N=8?4�4VL70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YLkC(4D4PQ:C㧧´WYHKEI6%0M6�2D6�H71

ÿ 4p2DH=2D47JxL70c6N254N0Ms76�258YL]9_H(48QIC70M6e9 §Ó�t §§æ² §�#47E:Lÿ 47E*�KÀG0cE:L78VU<8FL©6%8L2uH71q2DHE2a47J@L70M6�254N0Ms76<2%8YL�9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9�6 ý �À ¤ � §ý 3 t §� ² §Ú 3 � 3 ÎÂÁ gÔ3AC7894%8��t9b4RsY8o8F9�Q<2SRT476�3x8FJMJ�>

Ø 2DH=2D47J?L70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YLp9_H(48QIC70M6e9 §ß�t §§C² §� ¹ H ½É¸M¹�à y ¹�4�WYHKEIL70�2%0MHKE�4PJ?WFHKE:6�254D4E0ME32 ýLý �¿ H�N(8?4 §§�g�68C:H(4�2§ß ­ ¤ ýLý �¿ g�0c1`1�H=4w8Y47WaCP2DHE2a47J=L70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FL�9_H(48Q:C<0M689 §ë t §� ² §�Ú3i0K2DC §ë < §Ó ¤ §ß�28C78?4N8j0c6�47Eu£X0cE¥ ¦

Page 92: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

�p47E:LG4p2DH=2D47JxL70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FLt9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9 §ì t�§Ú 3 ² §�Ú6%6:WaCm2DC�4n2 §ì < §ý 3 ¤ §ë >§Ú 3

�? � !!!!!!!!!!!!!!§��� Ötu �D�ÄÅ HHHHHHHH

§§�×tu�Zûü §�

Ø E H Q3Q I ¸ �%H ½Ð¸ F º ��F º ¶ ¸»½Ð¸ F º�Ö �¿ H�N(894 §§´WYHKEI6%0M6�2D6�H71�4u°�E<0�258u6N892AH71@WFHKE:L70K250MH7E�47J?WYHKE:6�25484=0ME32D6�H�N=8?4 §§h>Ø 2DHE2a47J@L70M6�254N0Ms76<2%8YL�9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9 §ß·t §§]² §�͹ H ½Ð¸M¹�à y ¹)Ö �¿ g®68C:H(4�2 §ß ­ ¤ Ö �¿ g�0c1 §ß ­ ¤ ýLý �¿ 1�H(4:8Y47WaCý9ý �¿ 0MEGÖ �¿ > Ê0@4%8/·+6<0D4%8o2DC:4E2i2DC78¥9�H¦L78FJ=9�H(4eQ:C70c689_6�H71�4_WYHKE:L<0�250cHKE�47JÔWYHKE:6�25484=0ME32�4=4%8o2DHE2a47JÐg:6%0cE:W?854�WFHKE:6N2%4D4=0cE3268C�47JcJY8VU�Q74%8F686h2DC78:4%8�·�670�4%8F9e8FE�2�H71kW?894N2a4E0MEp6�254%6IW9256<4%8Y6i0cET4hL70c6N254N0Ms76�258YL;C(4D47QICT6%0M9]0MJM4=4�2DH�4�9b4E28WaC1�H(4d4*L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FL�Q748H¦L76:WL250MH7E�>«021�3X8T3¬H(6IJML�47JMJcH�3wL70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FL�9_H(48QIC70M6e9�6h3i0K2DC�Q�4=4�250M47J�s�476N89�H(4eQ:C70c689_6x2DC70c6h4%8/·+6<0D4%8F9e8FE32�3�H(6:JcLGsd8u3x8Y47í=8FE78YL�>½:¾ø� , �v*#� ¢j¤vÅ�¯ �D�Y�v* � § �  >��¨¡� § ¨¡� « �= >�ɨ¡�U²0\WYHKEI6%0ML<8?4X1�H(4^2DC70c6j8VU:4P9�Q:J�8�2DC78�W4E2%8?CKH(4ÁR*Õ¶�G� Á?Â�à �#äÞ���h��g@3AC<8?4%8;äÞ����0M6o2DC78_E78L2S3¬H(4eí[2SR¦Qd8C(4D47QICs0MEkgÀ0�C(674%8 ¦ >KÄ�ËV47E:LTJcH�WY47JÔ6�2a4E2%8Y6A4=4N8\9�H¦L78FJD8YLTs�Rb6%89286A47E:Lk4%8FJv4E2%0MHKEI6¬sd892S3X8?8YEtJMH¦W4PJÔ6N2D4E258F6s�R¡28H=2a47J�9�47Q:Q70cE7CK69>Àf�C78�47Q:Q:J�0MW4n250MH7E_WFHKE:L70K250cHKEe0cE/gÀ0�C(674N8 ¦ >�Ä(Ä�WYHKEI6%0M6�2D6�H71xHKE<8�WYH7E:L70�2%0MHKE:47J�WYHKE¦À6N25484=0ME32�H�N(894¾4\L70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YL¡C(4D4PQ:C §§i>`0�C�4N=8�WaCIHK6%8FEp4^4%8FQ74%8F6%8YE32D4E250cHKE_3AC<8?4%8h28C78�s�476N8�C=4D47Q:CI6�47E:Ls�476%8¬9�H(4eQ:C70c689_6`4=4N8�E:H=2�8LU�Q:JD0cW?0K2DJcR\68C:H�3AExg�s76<2UHKE:JcRo28C78@4%8�°�E78FL�C(4D47QIC:6�47E:L�4N8/°�E<8YLd9�H=48Q:C70c689_6?>f�C78XL70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YLsC(4847Q:C §§�WFHKE:6%0c6N286�HP1�H7E78XQ748H¦W?8F6865�ÉH71�47Et4=4es70�2%4D4=4ÁRe2SR¦Qd8��¬3AC7894%8^2DC78uJcH�WY47JÔ6�2a4E2%8

LXC

c x

G^

^^^

mm

12

^^

^ ^

q1 p1p2^ ^^

gÀ0DC=674%8 ¦ >�Ä(Ä=t1Å�º H Q3Q I ¸ �%H ½Ð¸ F º ��F º ¶ ¸»½Ð¸ F º ��F ºI¹[¸M¹[½É¸»º ÌkF ¼ F º y?��F º ¶ ¸»½É¸ F º H=I4��F ºI¹[½ SNH ¸»º�½ ò0M6X28C78^8Y9_Q<2SRb6%892?>qf�C78^C(4847Q:C70cW47J®WYHKE:6�25484=0ME32�H�N(894 §§à0cE;2DC<8 °AC(674N8O4%8/·+6<0D4%8F6@2DC�4n2�3AC78YE<8FN(894�28C78?4N80M6V4�WFHKE:E78FW9258FL�Q?H(4�2d47E:L�47Er8FJD8F9e8FE�2p0MEc2DC<8TJMH¦W47J¾6N2D4E258pHP1�28C78TQ74eH�W98Y686¡0cE�§§�g�28C78s8YJ�8Y9]8YE32�0c647JM6eH;0MEm2DC785JMH¦W47Jk6�2a4E2%8�H71�28C78hQ?H(4N2?> ³ HKEI6%0ML<8?4�EIH�3�28C78hL70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FLPC(4847Q:C §� WYHKEI6%0M6�250cE7CbH71q2S3�HQ748H¦W?8F686%8F6�WFHKE:E78FW92%8YL�s�Rb9e8Y47E:6�H71`4VQ®H(4�2->À�`8XW47EG°�EILk2S3�H¡2DH=2D47JxL70c6N254N0Ms76�258YLT9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9�6�1b48HK9§§Û2DH §�Ô2DC:4E254=4%8¡0MEIL70MWY4E258FL[0cE�2DC78�°AC(6<4%8ds�R�2DC78d9_H(48Q:C<0M689_6 §ß � 47E:L §ß � >]f�C<8�9_H(48QIC70M6e9 §ß �6D4E2%0M6�°78Y6@2DC<8\WYHKEI6N25484=0ME32A6N0ME:W98:2DC7894%8^8VU<0c6N286�HKE:JcR�HKE78w2DH=2D47JÔL70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FLT9�H(4eQ:C70c689 §ë � 47E:L]4�28H=2a47JL70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YL]9�H=48Q:C70c689 §ì � 6%6:WaCm2DC�4E2i28C78XL70v4=C=4D479_6�WYH79�9p6�258=>Bg�H(4@28C78X9�H=48Q:C70c689 §ß � g�C:H�3x8[N(894Yg3x8_4=4N8V47s:J�8�2DHG°�E:L�28C74%898VL70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YL^9�H=48Q:C70c689_6�1b4eHK9 §�¬28H §�y6%6:WaC¢2DC:4E2^2DC78�4N0DCKC32uL<0v4=C(48479WYHK9_9p6<2%8Y6?>xg�H(4h2S3¬H�H71À28C78Y9 28C78?4N85L:H+8Y6�E:H=2�8VU<0c6N2�4_L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FLG9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9y1b48H79 §Ú 2DH §�Ú6%6:WaC2DC�4E2:2DC78VJ�8F1É2uL70M4=C(48479ÒWYHK9_9p6<2%8Y6?>jf�C78?4N8F1�H(4N87g{2DC<8VL70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YL©9_H(48Q:C<0M689 §ß � L:H+8Y6uE:H=2\6D4E2%0M6e1»R2DC78XWYH7E:L70�2%0MHKE:47JÔWFHKE:6N2%4D4=0cE32i4%8Y6eQ�>A2DC78¥47QIQ:JD0cW4E2%0MHKEpWFHKE:L70K250cHKE�> ÊØ ��F º ¶ ¸»½É¸ F º H=I�¶ ¸M¹[½ S ¸#�Y¿�½ y8¶ Q S�FY¶ ¿ � ½É¸ F ºj0c6�4uL70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FL�Q74eH�L<6:W92%0MHKE�2DH=C(8928C78?4�3i0�28C_47Eb4PQ:Q:JD0cW4E2%0MHKEWYHKE:L<0�250cHKE�H�N(8?4]2DC78tJD8[1É2eÀ2C�47E:L´6%0cL78]H71O2DC<8GQ74eH�L<6:W92%0MHKE�>çóÀU:4P9�Q:J�8Y6_H71\WFHKE:L70K250cHKE�47J�L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FL

¥ �

Page 93: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

Q748H¦L76:WL250MH7E:6dW47E�sY8]1�H(6:E:Là0ME ³ C�47Q�258?4bÓ�g¹�6:s:6N8YW92%0MHKE°Ó�> ¦ >�Ä=>�ÄG47E:LR0ME�2DC78tQ748H¦W?8F686]C(4D4P9�9�4=486H71h2DC78TWY476%8T6�256:L�Rc0ME¾¹+6:s:6%8FW92%0MHKE´Ó�> ¦ >|Ó�>KÄ]47E:L¾¹�6:sI6%8YWL250cHKE�Ó�> ¦ >åÓ�>|Ó�>�f�C78F6%8k8LUI479_Q:J�8Y6�6eC:H�3µ28C7868Qd8YW?0M47J�W4P6%8�H71Uº yðÌ3H ½É¸ ¡=y:H Q3Q I ¸ �%H ½Ð¸ F º ��F º ¶ ¸»½Ð¸ F ºI¹v2DC�4n2¾1�H=48s70cL_W98?4�2a4=0cE�6�254%6IW9256<4%8Y6X0ME�2DC<8�WFHKE3258LU+2�H714b9b4n2DWaC�> Ø E789C�4E2%0cN(8h47Q:Q:J�0MWY4E250cHKEGWFHKE:L70K250cHKEGWFHKE:6N0M6N286\H71�WFHKE:L70K250MH7E�47J=WYH7E:6N2%4D4=0cE�286 ýLý �¿ ¤ � §Ó\� ý �À �3i0�2DC ý �À ¤ � §ý 3 � 3 ÎÂÁ 3AC78?4N8�2DC78j0ME:L<8LUG6%8L2��k0M6�8Y9_Q<2SR(> Ø WYH7E:L70�2%0MHKE:47J=Q748H¦L76:WL250cHKE�WY47E©sY8h47Q:Q:J�0D8FL2DH©4�L70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FLcC(4D4PQ:C §��0O1�HKE78bW47Eæ°�EIL�4G9b4E28WaC §ß 0ME §��47E:L §ß 6D4n250M6:°A8Y6j2DC78T4PQ:Q:JD0cW4E2%0MHKEWYHKE:L<0�250cHKETH71\2DC78XQ74eH�L<6:W92%0MHKE�>ÕP��Ö �4�= >��¨¡�£¢j¤�Ìø¤��'�«¯ § ¨¡� « �= >��¨¡� �A*_« ��­/  � ��� ½   ��«¾�4� ¨ «Y½ §  ��ɨ¡�U²Ø ��F º ¶ ¸»½É¸ F º H=I®¶ ¸M¹[½ S ¸#�Y¿¦½ y8¶ Q S5FY¶ ¿ � ½É¸ F ºp0c6¬4XQ�4=0�4 ë t?� §���<Ö�� ë �e��WFHKE:6N0M6N2%0ME7C5H71=4¥L70M6�254N0Ms76<2%8YL�Q748H¦L76:W�À250MH7E ë t?� §§ �¨² §©X��47EILG4PE�47QIQ:JD0cW4E2%0MHKEpWFHKE:L70K250cHKEGÖV� ë �¬H�N(8?4 §§h>f�C78uWYHKEIL70�2%0MHKE�4PJ®Q74eH�L<6:W92%0MHKEs0c6 H Q3Q I ¸ �%H � IDy 2DHd4�L70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FLsC(4D47QIC §�­4E2�9�4E2DWaC §ß�t §§C² §�ë0c1 §ß6D4E2%0M6�°78Y6Ö�� ë �V>�0SE;2DC70c6¬WY476%8Pg<2DC78 ��F º ¶ ¸»½Ð¸ F º H=IÔ¶ ¸ S5y�� ½ ¶+yLS ¸ ¡nH ½Ð¸ F ºp0c6xC(0ON(8FEps�Re28C78\L70�4%8YWL2�L7894%0ON74n250MH7E§� D³² �Z� §È HP1v28C78XL70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YL]Q748H¦L76:WL250cHKE ë 4n2 §ß�> ʹ�8FN=8?4D4PJ_�ÉWYH7E:L70�2%0MHKE:47J»�VL70M6�254N0Ms76<2%8YLèQ74eH�L76IW9250cHKE:6T4E4%8©WYH79�s70ME<8YLö0MEè4 Ì=SNH ��� H=S ¼ FnS�¶ ¸M¹[½ S ¸#�Y¿¦½ y8¶Ì=S%H Q�·�¹]28C�4E2t47L:L<0�250cHKE�47JcJcR�WFHKE32a4=0cE:6]47Eö0ME70K250M47J�L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FLöC(4D47QIC�>Ú0_WYHKE:6N0ML7894/2DC78^L7894%0ON74n250MH7E6%8�·�678FE:W?8F6b6�2a4=4�250ME<C©4E2�2DC<8s0ME70K250v4PJqC(4D47QIC�3AC<0MWaC�W47E�sd8sC(8YE<8?4D4n258YL�s�Rc28C78TQ748H¦L76:WL250cHKE:6�H71i28C78C(4D479_9�4=4?>Rf�C70M6�6%892bH71uL7894%0ON74n250MH7E´6N8�·�678FE:W?8F6]3i0cJMJ�sd8u6I6%8YL°1�H=4_6eQY8FW?0O1»R�0cE7C`28C78�sd8YC:4�N+0cH(4�HP1X46eR¦6N2%8Y9�Jv4n258?4�H7E�>ÕP��Ö �4�= >��¨¡�£¢j¤�Ìø¤���¥°¯ ¨��>� ,c, �D� ©ð¨ �i« ��­/  � ��� ½   ��«¾¨��>�D��� ­�²Ø Ì=S%H ��� H=S ¼ FnS]¶ ¸M¹[½ S ¸#�Y¿¦½ y8¶�Ì=SNH Q�·�¹j0M6V4�Q�4E0D4��q� ¤ ¨ §� 3 Õ 3 Ï ��� ë t�� §���<Ö�� ë �e�8� D Î ä ª 3AC7894%8 §� 3 Õ 3 Ï 0c64§L70c6N254N0Ms76�258YLRC(4D4PQ:C°47EIL�� ë t¥� §���<Ö�� ë �e�8� D Î ä 0M6�47E°ÿ\ÀG0cE:L78LU�8FLç6%8L2pH71\WYHKE:L<0�250cHKE�47J�L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FLQ748H¦L76:WL250MH7E:6?>]0uL78FE:H=258bs�R � � �I���q��� ¤ « ¶ ¤ � §�Æ» DL¼� §� � D 2� ZcZOZ � ­ §�Æ» ¤ §� 3 Õ 3 Ï � ë 3 ®æÿ ¯ 2DC<8b6%8L2H71X47JcJ�L78?4N0cNP4E250cHKE�6%8/·+6<8YE:W98Y6�¶ðt��]² � � �:�Éÿh��6�2a4=4�250ME<C±4E2 §�Æ»/6:6%0cE7C*WYHKE:L<0�250cHKE�47J�L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FLQ748H¦L76:WL250MH7E:6�H71`ÿ]> Ê¢Y¤�Ì}¤�Ì ¼ ¨d, � ¨¡� � �Ø �øÔ��­ � ¿ �M� § � Ö § �  >��¨¡�ç¨�© Õ ��­/  � ��� ½   ��« ¿Ç�j­/  � ,æ­0uWYHKE:6N0ML7894�0cE`2DC<0M6¥6%8YWL250cHKEÊ2DC<8bWYH79�Q?HKE78FE�2S3i0c6%8p6eQY8FW?0�°�W4E2%0MHKE§H71�L70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FLÂ6eR¦6N2%8Y9_6?>Pg�H=4Z28C781�HKJMJcH�3i0cE7C_WYHKE:6N0ML7894D4E2%0MHKEI6YgÔ0°�U©4pE78L2S3¬H=48íu2SR¦Qd8pC(4847Q:C¢äÞ���w47E:L^476e6%6:9]8p0c9�Q:J�0MW90�2DJORe28C�4E2^8Y47WaCL70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YL]C(4D47QICbH¦WYW?6<4%4%0cE7CZ0ME¡2DC78A1�HKJMJcH�3i0ME7C^0c6�4XL70c6N254N0Ms76�258YLeC(4D4PQ:Cxg�3AC78?4N8w28C78�E<892S3�H(48í]C(4D4PQ:C0M6�4�E<892S3�H(48ípC=4D47Q:C�3i0K2DC�4N8Y68Qd8YWL2q2DHoäP���¡>U0@47s:s<4%8FN+0M4E258x28C78�6%8L2�H71?Q74eH�W98Y686�2SR¦Qd8Y6¾ÿk� õ�ë�� �#äÞ���h�H71v28C78XE7892S3�H(4eí/2SR�Qd8ZC(4D47QICuäP���Ús�RTÿ8� õ�ë�� >0u6N2a4E4N2�s�R[2DC78�L78/°:E70�2%0MHKE§H71A4�L70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FL±Q74eH�L76IW9250cHKE±6eJD0�CKC32DJcR^L<0còY8?4%8FE32h1b48H79�2DC�4E2hHKE78eC(0cN=8YE0ME·!O8/°:E70�2%0MHKE ¦ > ' >�ó�gq2DC:4E2d05WY47JMJ1Q S�F���y ¹a¹ZQ S5FY¶ ¿ � ½É¸ F ºA> Ø Q74eH�W98Y6e6_Q<48H¦L76:W92%0MHKE�0cE:WYH(4eQ®H=4D4E2%8Y6�28C78JMH¦W47J�0�2SR�47E:L^N�0c6%0cs70MJ�0�2SRG4768Qd8YWL2D65H71�4]L70c6N254N0Ms76�258YL*6eR¦6�258Y9�0cE[28C78V1�HKJMJcH�3i0cE7CT6%8FE:6%8Et�ó�47WaC§Q748H¦W?8F686C�476:0K2D6�H�3AE©JMH¦W47J=6�2a4E2%8j2DC:4E2O0c6w0cE�N+0c6%0MsIJD8u1�H(4�H=2DC7894�Q74eH�W98Y6e6%8Y69>:�èC78FE^4�Q74eH�W98Y686�3�47E3286:2DH�í¦EIH�3Q�4=4N286XH71x28C78�JcH�WY47JU6�2a4E2%8_HP1�47E:HE2DC78945Q74eH�W98Y6e6YgÀ0K2XC�476^2DHtWYH79�9p6IE70MWY4E258�3i0K2DC¢2DC78_Q748H¦W?8F686¥H�N(8?4h4WYHK9_9�H7EVQ®H(4�2-> ³ HK9�9�6:E70MWY4E250cHKE�2D47í=8F6¾QIJv47W98�s�Rh3i4%0�2%0ME7CO28C78AL�4E2D4o0cE32DHO2DC<8�Q?H(4�2->Àf�C<8�JcH�WY47JI6�2a4E2%8H71`Q?H(4�2D6h0M6�N+0c6%0MsIJD8�1�H(4�47JMJxQ<48H¦W?8Y6e6%8F6w0cE/2DC78XL70c6N254N0Ms76�258YL]6ÁR�6�258F9u>�021@3x8¥WYHKEI6%0ML<8?4@2DC<0M6�Q74N0ME:W90MQ:J�8\H71N�0c6%0cs70MJ�0�2SRXH71?JMH¦W4PJI6N2D4E258F6Yg32DC<8�L78/°�E<0�250cHKEVH71Ô4\L70M6�254N0Ms76<2%8YLdQ74eH�L76IW9250cHKEd476qC(0ON(8FE]0cE:!O8/°�E<0�250cHKE ¦ > ' >�ó0M6q6:E:684E250c6e1É47WL2DH(4ÁRKg�6N0ME:W98i28C78�JD8[1É2eÀ2C�47E:LV6N0ML78�9�4R�WYH7E�2D4=0MEd6N8FN(894D47J�Q74eH�W98Y6e6¾EIH�L78F6��É6%898h2DC78i8LUI479_Q:J�80MEugÀ0DC(6<4%8 ¦ >KÄ�Ód4E2i2DC78Xs?H=2%28HK9p�V>Xf@H�47Q:Q:JORT6%6:WaC�4_Q74eH�L<6:W92%0MHKEk2DH�4_L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FLuC=4D47Q:CÔg�3X8¥C�4N(82DHÍ°:E:L§1�H(4Z84PWaCÂQ748H¦W?8F686p0cE[28C78bJ�8F1É2ÁÀSC�47EIL§6N0ML78�4GQ74eH�W98Y6e6�0ME[2DC78_L70c6N254N0Ms76�258YL`C(4D4PQ:C±6N6:WaCc2DC�4n2

¥ &

Page 94: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

2DC78XJMH¦W4PJx6N2D4E258F6�HP1v28C785Q<48H¦L76:W92%0MHKE]Q74eH�W98Y6e6%8Y6�9�4E2DWaCk2DC78XJcH�WY47Jx6N2D4E258F6i0MEs2DC78XL70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FLuC(4847Q:C�>f�HÇ°:E:L 2DC<0M6b9�4E28WaCç1�H(4_6%8FN=8?4847J\Q74eH�W98Y686N8Y6]4E2]2DC<8�6D479]8k250M9]8m4%8�·�670�4%8F6T4`CKJcHKs�47J�N+0D8[3ÒHKE 28C78L70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YLd6eR¦6N2%8Y9m>_¹�0MEIW?8�6%6IWaCp4^CKJMH7s�47JIN+0D8[3çLIH�8F6¾EIH=218LU�0M6�2B0ME_4uL70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YLd6eR¦6N2%8Y9tg�0\4%8F6N2%4%0MWL2L70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YL�Q<48H¦L76:W92%0MHKEI6�28HpQ748H¦W?8F686\Q<48H¦L76:W92%0MHKEI6?>if�C78�J�8F1É2eÀ2C�47E:Lt6%0cL78hHP1�4�Q74eH�W98Y6e6\Q748H¦L76:WL250cHKEWYHKE32a4E0ME:6�HKE78�47EIL�HKEIJcRVHKE<8�Q<48H¦W?8Y6e6�EIH�L78AQ?HK686N0Ms:JORp2DH=C(8928C78?4�3i0�28C�6eHK9]8�Q?H(4�2D6?>Àf�HZ8YE:6N674%8�4XJMH¦W47J47Q:Q:J�0MW4n250MH7E*HP1�4GQ74eH�W98Y686VQ<48H¦L76:W92%0MHKEÔgÀ0�286h4PQ:Q:JD0cW4E2%0MHKE*WYH7E:L70�2%0MHKE*C�476j2DH�sd8;4N8Y6�254%0cW92%8YL�476¥3x8FJMJ�>f�C78u6N2%4%6:WL25674N8Y6�WaC78FWaí=8YLu0MET4�Q<48H¦W?8Y6e6A47Q:Q:J�0MWY4E250cHKE�WFHKE:L70K250cHKE/4%8[1b8?4�H7E:JcR¡2DHp28C78\JcH�WY47J�6N2a4n258uH71{28C78Q748H¦W?8F686¡0�286%8YJO1�47E:L�2DH^Q®H=4N2D6Fg�s<6<2dE:H=2�28H*HE2DC7894_Q<48H¦W?8Y6e6%8F6?> Ø JK2DH(C(8L2DC7894Yg�4©Q748H¦W?8F686dQ748H¦L76:WL250cHKE8YE:6N674%8F6Z28C�4E2^2DC<8Vs®H(6IE:L�4=4ÁR©H71�N+0M6%0cs70MJ�0�2SR]H71¬4TQ748H¦W?8F686o0ME^4TL70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FL©6eR¦6N2%8Y9Þ0M6uEIH=2uN+0MHKJM4E258FLs�Rp6%84E48WaC70cE7Cb4d9�4E2DWaCT1�H(4h0K2D6A47Q:QIJD0MWY4E250cHKE�>ÕP��Ö �4�= >��¨¡�£¢j¤�Ìø¤��+Ì°¯ § ¨¡� « �= >��¨¡� �A* �Y� ¨ § � ­�­ �Y� ¨ «4½ §  >��¨¡��²Ø WYHKE:L<0�250cHKE�47J?L70c6N254N0Ms76�258YLTQ<48H¦L76:W92%0MHKE ë t?� §§ �¨² §©p�<Ö�� ë �e�¾3i0�28C §§ ¤ë¨ � ¿ �_È ª 4PE:L §© ¤�¨ �¤Éâ�PÊ ª 0c64 ��F º ¶ ¸»½É¸ F º H=I Q S5F���y ¹a¹@Q S5FY¶ ¿ � ½Ð¸ F º_H71\2SR�Qd8oÓ�®©ÿk� õrë�� 0O1`4PE:LGH7E:JcR;0c1

ÿ §æWFHKE32a4=0cE:6\HKE<8V47E:L©HKEIJcRGHKE78�Q74eH�W98Y6e6uE:H�L<87g{0�>�8=>�2DC<8?4%8�0c6\4/��®·§ ) 3i0�28C*� Ú ¯&� ��� ¿ �#���8� ¤ë �E ýL� �J�547E:L]1�H(4h8Y47WaCGEIH�L78o� í ®�§ ) 3i0K2DC�� Ú ¯&� ��� ¿ �#� í �8� ¤ ë �E ý9� �J�X1�H7JMJMH�3A6h� ¤ � í gÿ 2DC78XQ74eH�W98Y6e6�E:H¦L78^�/0c6�H71\2SR�Qd8^ÓkgA0�>�8=>&� ¿ �#��� ¤ Ókgÿ �TL:H+8Y6hEIH=2¥W?4%8Y4E258�E78F3 Q<48H¦W?8Y6e6hE:H¦L78F6YgÀ0�>�8E>â0c112DC7894%8;0c6¥4u� í í ®¸© ) 3i0�28C-� Ú ¯�� ���¤ÉU�b� í í �e� ¤ë �E ýL� �J�o2DC<8YEm� í í ¤ �:�b����47E:Lÿ 1�H(4�847WaC©WFHKE:L70K250MH7E�47JkWYHKEI6N25484=0ME32 ý9ý �¿ ¤ � §Ó`t §§¬² §�c��� §ý 3 t §� ² §Ú 3 � 3 ÎÂÁ �:®ÇÖ�� ë ��gY� í í ®Ê� )3i0�28CË� Ú ¯&� ��� À �#� í í �8� ¤ ë �E ýL� �J�k0c9�QIJD0D8F6�� í í ¤ Ó��b�I��4PE:LÂ1�H(4p8Y47WaCR£]®���gB� í í ® Ú 3 Ø 3i0�28C� Ú ¯&� ���Á� Ö �b� í í �e� ¤ ë �E ýL� �J�Z0M9_Q:J�0D8Y6x� í í ¤ ý 3 �bÓ��b�I�e�L>

ÊØ Q74eH�W98Y6e6\Q748H¦L76:WL250cHKEGWY47E�E:HE2�L70�4%8FW92DJORTW?4N84E2%8hE78[3ÇQ748H¦W?8F686N8Y6\s�RGW?4%8Y4E250cE7C_E78F3ÇQ74eH�W98Y6e6\E:H¦L78Y69>f�C78�W?4N84E2%0MHKEVH71?4\E<8F3°Q<48H¦W?8Y6e6�E:H¦L78x2a4Pí=8Y6�Q:JM47W?8¬s�Rj2DC78�6ÁR¦E:WaC748H7E70$#Y4E250cHKEVH71®4\Q®H=4N2�W94%84n250ME<C\Q748HrÀW?8Y6e6\Q74eH�L76IW9250cHKE�4PE:L©4�6eQY8FW?0M47JkL70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YL�Q<48H¦L76:W92%0MHKEÔg®WY47JMJ�8YL©¹[½ H=S ½vQ S5FY¶ ¿ � ½Ð¸ F º�g�2DC�4n2�WFHKE32a4=0cE:62DC78AE78[3ÙQ748H¦W?8F686�E:H¦L78=>�0k3i0MJcJ:WYH79e8�s�4PWaíp2DH^2DC70c6�Q®H=0ME32�Jv4E2%8?4�HKE�>U0�3i0cJMJIQ<48H�N+0ML78AE78VU�2�47E]8LUI479_Q:J�8H71=4XQ748H¦W?8F686�Q748H¦L76:WL250MH7E�>�âGH(4N8w8VUI479�QIJD8Y6�WY47Ebsd8�1�H=6:E:L;0cE ³ C�47Q<2%8?4�Ó^0ME¡2DC<8 ¹�6Is:6%8FW9250cHKE:6DÓ�> ¦ >åÓ�>KÄ47E:L�Ó�> ¦ >åÓ�>|Ó�>½:¾ø� , �v*#� ¢j¤c×°¯ �Y� ¨ § � ­Ï­ �4� ¨ «Y½ §  ��ɨ¡�U²gÀ0DC(6<4%8 ¦ >KÄ�Ó�68CIH�3A6¡2S3�H§L70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FL´Q<48H¦L76:W92%0MHKEI6?>cf�C78tQ74eH�L76IW9250cHKE�4E2�28C78k6:Q:Qd8?4dC�47JO1�HP1w28C78°AC(674N8:0M6�45WFHKE:L70K250cHKE�47J:Q<48H¦W?8Y6e6�Q74eH�L76IW9250cHKEbHP1�2SR¦QY8�Öhg�3AC78?4N8:2DC78�47Q:QIJD0MWY4E250cHKEdWYHKEIL70�2%0MHKEd1�H(4B2DC70c6Q748H¦L76:WL250MH7E«WYHKE:6N0M6�2D6VH71�HKE78bWYHKE:L<0�250cHKE�47J¾WYH7E:6N2%4D4=0cE�2dH�N=8?4 §§i>`f�C78TQ<48H¦W?8Y6e6dQ748H¦L76:WL250MH7EÂW?4N84E2%8Y64pE78F3­Q®H=4N2\EIH�L78p28H(C(8L2DC7894�3i0�28C^4bE78F3©8YJ�8Y9]8YE32^0cE�0�2D6�JMH¦W47J@6N2D4E258E>of�C78d47Q:Q:J�0MWY4E250cHKE�WFHKE:L70K250MH7E4%8�·�670�4%8F6À2DC�4n2À2DC<0M6@W?4%8Y4E250cHKE�WY47E�sd8¬Qd8?4e1�H=489]8YL�HKEIJcRo0c1<2DC7894%8�L:H+8Y6`E:H=2v8LU�0M6�2�47JD4N847L�R¥47Ep8YJ�8Y9]8YE32�0cE2DC78^8VU<0c6N2%0ME7C�Q?H(4�2�H71YÖ�>qf�C70c6�Q74eH�L76IW9250cHKEs0M6�4�Q748H¦W?8F686�Q74eH�L76IW9250cHKExg�6%0MEIW?8X47JcJ®L70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FLsC(4D47QIC:6H71X28C78dQ748H¦L76:WL250cHKE*476u3x8FJMJ�476^2DC<8�4PQ:Q:JD0cW4E2%0MHKE�WYHKE:L<0�250cHKE^WYHKE32D4=0ME¢8LUI47WL2DJOR©HKE78dQ74eH�W98Y686¥E:H¦L78dH712SR�Qd8kÖ�>qf�C<0M6�Q74eH�L<6:W92%0MHKE/0c6�47QIQ:JD0cW47s:J�8�3i0K2DC:H=6<2�í�E:H�3AJD8FL7C(8uH71kJcH�WY47J?6N2a4n258Y6�HP1â4%8Y9_H=2%8�Q74eH�W98Y686N8Y6H�WFW?674N4%0ME<Cp0ME;28C78uL70c6N254N0Ms76�258YLb6eR¦6N2%8Y9m>1f�C<8uL70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YLpQ74eH�L<6:W92%0MHKE]4E2X2DC78us?H=2N2DHK9 H71â2DC<8�°AC(674N80M6hEIH=2d4�Q74eH�W98Y686VQ<48H¦L76:W92%0MHKE�>�f�C78TL70M6�254N0Ms76<2%8YLrC(4847Q:C:6hH71i2DC70c6�Q748H¦L76:WL250cHKEÂWYH7E�2D4=0ME�4GQ748H¦W?8F686E:H�L<8�H71X2SR¦QY8`Öy4PE:L × >b0SE§H(4eL78?4o2DH�47Q:Q:JOR�2DC<0M6XQ748H¦L76:WL250cHKExgâ2DC78_JMH¦W47J`6N2a4n258Y65H71�4]Q74eH�W98Y6865H712SR�Qd88ÖÇ47E:LtH71`4dQ<48H¦W?8Y6e6AH71v2SR¦Qd8 × C:476h2DHdsY8uí�E:H�3AE�4E2h2DC78X68479e8O2%0M9]87g¦3AC�4E2i0M6h0c9�Q?HK6e6%0MsIJD8:0cE4dL<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FL]6eR¦6N2%8Y9m> Ê

¥3ó

Page 95: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

A A A

A

A conditional process production of type A

A global distributed production

rx

X L R

rA BB

gÀ0DC(6<4%8 ¦ >KÄ�Ó�t�ÌÎÍ H �:Q IDypF ¼ H Q S5F���y ¹a¹@Q S5FY¶ ¿ � ½Ð¸ F º F ¼ ½ � Q y Ö H º ¶/HVÌ=IDF � H=I Q S�FY¶ ¿ � ½É¸ F º òØ Q S�F���y ¹a¹ Ì=SNH ��� H=S H71B2SR¦Qd8¡Ó§68Qd8YW90¦°A8F6¥47JMJ�Q®HK6e6%0cs:JD8�9_H�N(8F6¥HP1�Q<48H¦W?8Y6e6o0ME:6�2a47E:W98Y6XH7112SR¦QY8pÓ±s�R4t6N8925H71�Q74eH�W98Y686¥Q74eH�L76IW9250cHKE:6¥H71x28C70M6^2SR¦Qd8=>T0SE:6�2584PL±H71�4G6N2D4=4N2ZC(4847Q:Cxg@0u47LILÂ4]68HPÀ2W47JcJD8YL¹[½ H=S ½Q S�FY¶ ¿ � ½É¸ F º F ¼ ½ � Q y Ó�28He28C785Q<48H¦W?8Y6e6OC(48479�9�4=49> Ø 6�2a4=4�2�Q<48H¦L76:W92%0MHKEGH71�2SR¦Qd8jÓ¢0M6�4�L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FLQ748H¦L76:WL250MH7ExgK3AC78?4N8i0�2D6�J�8F1É2ÁÀSC�47EIL_6N0ML78�WFHKE32a4=0cE:6q2DC78�Q?H(4�2D6�E78YW98Y6e6D4=4ÁR_1�H=4U6N2D4=4N2%0ME7C^2DC<8�Q<48H¦W?8Y6e6¾47E:L2DC78p4N0DCKC32ÁÀSC�47EIL�6%0cL78�WYH7E�2D4=0MEI6w2DC<8�Q748H¦W?8F686uH71B2SR¦Qd8�Ó[8Y9�sd8YL:L<8YL¢0ME32DHe2DC78�Q?H(4�2D6YgY2DC�4E2�L78Y6eW?4N0Msd8Y62DC78�0cE70�2%0v47JA6N2D4E258©HP1h4«Q74eH�W98Y6e6tHP1Z2SR¦Qd8�Óâ> Ø 6�2a4=4�2]Q748H¦L76:WL250MH7E¹4%8 Ç 8YW9286]sY8L2%25894/2DC�4PEz4Â6�2a4=4�2C(4D47QIC�2DC78�1É47WL2g�28C�4E2^0cE:6N2D47E:W?8F6uH71¾Q748H¦W?8F686N8Y6¥W47E^sd8VW?4%8Y4E258FL^LIR¦E�479]0MW4PJMJcRt4PE:L^L:H]E:H=2uC�4N=8¡28H8LU�0M6�2�E<8YW?8F68684=4%0cJcRp1b4eHK9µ28C78XsY89C(0ME:E<0ME7CdH71\2DC78XL70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FLt6ÁR¦6N258F9u>�Ã�JD8Y476%8XE:H=2%0MW987g<28C�4E2h2DC<8¥6�2a4=4�2Q748H¦L76:WL250MH7E]0c6UE:H=2�4uQ74eH�W98Y686�Q74eH�L<6:W92%0MHKExg�6N0ME:W98h2DC7894%8AL:H+8Y6�E:H=2B0c6�4XQ<48H¦W?8Y6e6�EIH�L78h0cE¡0�2D6`JD8F1É2ÁÀSC�4PE:L6%0ML<8=>tóÀU:4P9�Q:J�8Y6¥H71�6�2a4=4�2hQ74eH�L<6:W92%0MHKE:654=4N8�6eC:H�3AEr0ME`gÀ0DC(6<4%8 ¦ >KÄ ' 47EILcgÀ0�C(674%8 ¦ >KÄ ¦ 47E:Lc0cE[28C78W476N8�6�256:L�R�0ME ³ C�4PQ<25894¾Ó_�#gÀ0DC=674%8AÓ+>�Ä�Ó\4PE:L]gÀ0DC(6<4%8�Ó+>åÓ�Ä��L>M¹�2a4=4�2�Q748H¦L76:WL250MH7E:6`3i0MJcJ:47Jc68Husd8h6:6%8FL]28HL78Y6eW?4%0csY8w2DC78OC=8YE7894D4E2%0MHKEpHP1=Q748H¦W?8F686N8Y6i0ME;28C78�L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FLp6eR¦6�258Y9m>�021�47E/8LU�0c6N250cE7C�Q74eH�W98Y6e6�W?4N84E2%8Y64pE78F3­Q748H¦W?8F686Fg{0�2uW94%84n258Y6uH7E:JcRm2DC78hE78YW98Y68684=4eR^Q?H(4�2D6?> Ø 6ÁR�EIWaC748HKE<0$#4n250MH7E©H71B2DC70c6�Q?H(4N2uW94%8Y4E250cE7CQ748H¦L76:WL250MH7ET47E:Ls2DC<8\6N2D4=4N2AQ74eH�L<6:W92%0MHKE/4N8Y6N6:J�286h0ME;28C78uW?4N84E2%0MHKETH71â28C78\Q74eH�W98Y686i0cE;2DC78uL<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FL6eR¦6N2%8Y9tg+28C�4E210M6q254N0DC(C=8?4%8FLds�R�28C78�Q748H¦W?8F686B2DC�4E2¾C�4P6�W94%84n258YL]2DC78�Q?H(4N2?>v�`8�3i0cJMJ:WFHK9e8As�4PWaíp2DHo2DC70c6Q®H(0cE32AJv4E2%8?4�HKE�>ÕP��Ö �4�= >��¨¡�£¢j¤�Ìø¤��V¢è¯,­�  �D�   �4� ¨ «Y½ §  >�ɨ¡�U²W 0ON(8YE§4GE<892S3�H(48í�2SR¦QY8]C(4847Q:CcäP���_g�4©¹[½ H=S ½1Q S5FY¶ ¿ � ½Ð¸ F ºGH71@2SR¦QY8¡Ó�®èÿk� õrëA� ��äÞ���5�:0M6¥4]L70M6 À254%0cs76<2%8YL*Q748H¦L76:WL250MH7EË�Â�F�bÓ®�pt¾� §§ �¨² §©X�u476¥L78�°�E78YLÊ0ME ¦ > ' >�ó�g=3AC7894%8 §§ Q §©yWYH7E�2D4=0MEI6¥H7E:JcR©Q?H(4�2E:H�L<8Y6�47E:L §©ÇWYHKE32a4E0ME:6A47LIL70�2%0MHKE�4PJMJcRdH7E78XQ748H¦W?8F686AE:H¦L78uH71\2SR�Qd8^Óâ>Bf�C78XQ748H¦L76:WL250MH7ET9�H(4eQ:C70c689 §�0M6@2DC<8Z0cE:WYJ�6:6%0cHKEp1b48H79 §§ 0cE §©p> ÊØ 6u9]8YE3250cHKE78YL*47s?H�N(8Pgk4]Q<48H¦W?8Y6e6oC(4D479_9�4=4�1�H=4X4pW?8?4�2a4=0cE©Q748H¦W?8F686^2SR¦QY8dWFHKE:6%0c6N286¥HP1¬4p6�2a4=4�2XQ748HrÀL76:W92%0MHKE�47E:L�4�6%8L2�HP1�Q748H¦W?8F686�Q748H¦L76:WL250MH7E:6�HP1�2DC78¥WYH=4%4%8F68Q?HKE:L70cE7Ce2SR¦Qd8=>�gA48HK9 28C78XN�0�8F3AQ?H(0ME32�H71HKs¦qN8YWL2eÀ2H(4%0�8YE3258FLtQ<48H(C(48479_9e0cE7C:g32DC78uQ<48H¦W?8Y6e6iC(4D479_9�4=4�HP1`4VW98?4N2D4=0ME/2SR¦Qd8uW47E]sd8u6%898YEG476A4�WYJM476869>ÃB4eH�W98Y6e6%8Y6¥H7112DC70c6O2SR¦QY8¡0ME^4TL70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FL*6ÁR¦6N258F9 4=4%8�0cE:6N2D47E:W98Y6XH7112DC70c6uWYJv4P686Yg�28C�4E2XC�4N=8b4pWFHKQ�RH71i2DC78ÐÏeQ<48H(C(48479/Ñ��#0�>�8E>v2DC<8TQ748H¦W?8F686dQ748H¦L76:WL250cHKE:6d47E:Lc28C78T6N2D4=4N2dQ<48H¦L76:W92%0MHKE��5Q748H�N+0ML<8YL�0MEc28C78

¥(¥

Page 96: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

Q748H¦W?8F686iC(4D4P9�9�4=4?> Ø ¶ ¸M¹[½ S ¸#�Y¿¦½ y8¶hÌ=S%H ��� H=S 3i0�28Ck4%8Y6eQY8FW92i2DH_4�E78L2S3¬H=48í/2SR¦QY8oC(4847Q:CkäP���­C�476�4Q748H¦W?8F686qC(48479�9�4=4@47E:Ld4\6N892�HP1�0ME:L70cW?8F6`1�H(4À8Y47WaCdQ748H¦W?8F686�2SR¦Qd8@0ME�äP���]>�f�C<8h0ME:L78VU�6N892q4N8YQ74N8Y6N8YE32D62DC78XE�479]8u68Q:47W?8X1�H(4h0MEI6N2a4PE:W?8F6�HP1v28C78XQ748H¦W?8F686i2SR�Qd8o2DC�4E2A9�4RpH¦WYW9674i0MEs2DC78XL70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FLt6ÁR¦6N258F9u>ÕP��Ö �4�= >��¨¡�£¢j¤�Ìø¤��+é°¯ �Y� ¨ § � ­Ï­ ¨���� ,c, �D� ¯ « ��­/  � ��� ½   ��«£¨��>� ,c, �D� ²W 0ON(8YEp4hE7892S3�H(4eíe2SR¦QY8^C=4D47Q:C/äÞ���_gI4ZQ S5F���y ¹a¹ Ì=SNH ��� H=S H71{2SR¦Qd8:Ó�®©ÿk� õrëA� 0M6¬4hQ�4=0�4x�q���bÓ®� ¤¨ �Â�F�bÓ®�L��� ë t §�K� D Î ä , ª gx3AC7894%8G� ë t §�K� D Î ä , 0c6u47E*ÿ × ÀG0MEIL78LU�8YL^6N892¥H71�Q748H¦W?8F686XQ748H¦L76:WL250cHKE:6uH71B2SR¦QY8�Ó47E:L¬�´�F�ÉÓ®�@0M6A4V6N2D4=4N2�Q74eH�L76IW9250cHKETH71v2SR�Qd8^Óâ>Ø ¶ ¸M¹[½ S ¸#�Y¿¦½ y8¶§Ì=SNH ��� H=S �q� ¤ ���q���ÉÓ®�L�_��ÒxÞ?�ÉÓ®�8� × Î ä ¯ ��DV° 3i0�28C�4%8F68Qd8YWL2/2DHräP���ãWYH7E:6%0c6N2D6bH71¥4Q748H¦W?8F686mC(4D479_9�4=4/�q�A�ÉÓ®�]4PE:Læ47EÛ0cE:L78VUè6%8L2���ÒÔÞ®�ÉÓ®�[g�W47JcJD8YL�28C78�º H � y ¹GQ H���y`F ¼ Ókg�1�H(4s8Y47WaCÓ�®©ÿk� õrë�� > Êf�C78�L70M6�254N0Ms76<2%8YLpC=4D479_9b4E4�H71�H=674UW4P6%8�6N2%6:LIR�0ME ³ C�4PQ<25894¾Ó:0M6ÀC=0cN(8FE�0MEdóÀUI479_Q:JD8�Ó�>�Ä=Ä(>`0�2�WFHKE:6N0M6N286H71�2DC<85Q74eH�W98Y6e6OC(4D4P9�9�4=486i0cEuf�47s:J�8�Ó�>KÄ�4PE:LPf�47s:J�8VÓ�>|Ó�>)¹�0cE:W?8o2DC78F6%8�Q<48H¦W?8Y6e6:C(48479_9b4=4e6�4=4%8o2DH¦H8LU+258FE:6%0ON(87g?010ME3254eH�L76IW?8¥4V689�47JMJ�8?4@8VU:4P9�Q:J�8^6:6%8FLu0cEs2DC78o4%8F9b4E0ME:L7894�H71\2DC70c6�WaC�47Q<2%8?4?>½:¾ø� , �v*#� ¢j¤c÷°¯ « ��­�  � ��� ½   ��«¾¨���� ,c, �D� ²0¾Q<48H�N+0ML78u4�L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FL/C(48479�9�4=4X�q� ¤ �#�q�A��Ö\�L�_��ÒxÞ?�#Öu�L�5�q��� × �V�_��ÒxÞ?� × �8�¾3i0K2DC/4N8Y68Qd8YWL2h2DHp28C78E7892S3�H(48íp2SR¦Qd8wC=4D47Q:C]0ME]gÀ0�C(674N8 ¦ >�ÄË<>`0v6:6%8i2DC78AWY4E2589CKH(4eRVÕe�i�rÎ °ÉÏ ��äP���5�`3AC78?4N8�JcH�WY47JM6`6N2a4n258Y6¾4=4N86%89286¥3i0K2DC¢2DH=2D47J�9�47Q:Q70cE7CK6?> ¹�0cE:W?8�2DC<8�E78L2S3¬H=48í�2SR¦QY8]C(4D4PQ:C§C:476Z28C78¡2S3¬HGQ748H¦W?8F686o2SR�Qd8Y6;Öw47E:L× g�3x8¥C�4N(8Z2DHd68Qd8YW90c1»Rt4dQ748H¦W?8F686:C=4D479_9b4E4h�q�A��Ö\�A4PE:L�4dQ748H¦W?8F686�C(4D4P9�9�4=4h�q��� × �L>1f�C7856�2a4=4�2Q748H¦L76:WL250MH7ETH71v28C78uQ74eH�W98Y686iC(48479_9b4=4x�q�A��Ö\�x0MEmgÀ0DC=674%8 ¦ >�Ä ' 0c6@8Y9_Q<2SRTH7Em0K2D6�J�8F1É2ÁÀSC�47EILT6%0ML<8X47E:LW?4%8Y4E258F6V4GQ<48H¦W?8Y6e6�E:H¦L78_H71h2SR¦QY8ÔÖyWYH7E�2D4=0ME<0ME7Ck2S3¬HP8YJD8F9e8FE32D6?>mf�C7894%8F1�H=4%87g�28C78bQ<48H¦W?8Y6e6uÖÑL:H�8F6E:H=2�E<8?8YLÂ47E�R±Q?H(4N286j28H�6N2D4=4N2�47E:Lc0K2D6Z0ME70K250M47JU6N2D4E258�C�476Z2S3¬H�8FJD8Y9]8YE3286?>mf�C78?4N8T4=4%8]2S3¬H�Q748H¦W?8F686Q748H¦L76:WL250MH7E:6¥1�H=4¥Q<48H¦W?8Y6e6uÖjtpf�C78bQ<48H¦W?8Y6e6hQ74eH�L<6:W92%0MHKE ë W94%84n258Y6�4tE78[3 Q®H=4N2Z2DC�4E2*ÏeWFHK6N286PÑ�H7E78H71�0K2D6h8YJ�8Y9]8YE32D6�0MEs28C785JcH�WY47Jx6�2a4E2%8=>xf�C<85Q74eH�W98Y6e6�Q74eH�L76IW9250cHKE ë7í Q76<2D6�47Em8YJ�8Y9]8YE32A1b48HK9Ô28C78¥JMH¦W47J6N2a4n258XH71\2DC78XQ74eH�W98Y686�0ME328H¡28C78XQ®H=4N2->

START PRODUCTION st(A)

PROCESS PRODUCTION p

A

A

PROCESS PRODUCTION p’

A AA

gÀ0DC=674%8 ¦ >�Ä ' txÍ S5F���y ¹a¹ Ì=SNH ��� H=S ¼ FnS Ö òf�C78p6N2D4=4N2�Q748H¦L76:WL250MH7EÂH71h2DC<8pQ748H¦W?8F686�C(48479_9b4=4j�q�A� × �j0MErgv0DC(674N8 ¦ >�Ä ¦ L:H�8F6�E:H=2p4%8�·�670�4%8T4PE�RQ®H(4�2D6�HKE¡0K2D6UJ�8F1É2eÀ2C�47E:LV6N0ML78A4P6U3x8FJMJ�47EIL�W94%84n258Y6¾47E¡8F9�Q<2SRhQ748H¦W?8F686�E:H¦L78�H71d2SR¦QY8 × 2DH(C=892DC<8?4U3i0�28C4�WYHKE:E<8YW92%8YLGQ®H(4�2->�f�C<8?4%8o0c6�HKE:JORbHKE<8uQ748H¦W?8F686AQ748H¦L76:WL250cHKE ì 1�H(4X2DC78XQ74eH�W98Y686 × g<2DC�4n2AW?4%8Y4E258F6�47E8YJD8F9e8FE32i0MEt4VQ®H(4�2�47E:Lk2DC78XQ74eH�W98Y6e6 × 4E2h2DC<8¥68479]8O250M9]8=>f�C78o0ME:L78VUT6N892AH71\2DC78uE:479e8u6eQ�47W98X1�H=4�Q748H¦W?8F686i0MEI6N2a4PE:W?8F6�HP1\2SR¦Qd88Ö|0M6@C(0ON(8FEts�R���ÒÔÞ®�#Öu� ¤ « ÖjÄ ¯47E:L�1�H=4B28C78�Q748H¦W?8F686 × s�R:�+ÒÔÞ?� × � ¤ « × Ä ¯ >qg�H(4q2DC78�6D4Pí=8�HP1=6%0c9�Q:J�0MW90�2SRKgP0UC�4N(8�WaC:HK6N8YET6%0cE7CKJ�892DH7E0ME:L78VU�6N89286?>^f�C70c6�C78FJMQ:6:28HpQ74N8Y6%8FE32^2DC78h1�H7JMJMH�3i0cE7C�WFHKE:W98YQ<286u9�H(4N8hJ�8?C(0cs:JD8E>�¸�H�3X8FN=8?4Fgk47E�R�s70�C(C(8946%892h��Q®HK6e6%0cs:JcR;0MEg°�E<0�258�x0M6�Q?HK686N0Ms:J�8X476�3X8YJMJ�> Ê

¥ ¤

Page 97: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

START PRODUCTION st(B)

PROCESS PRODUCTION q

B

B B

gv0DC(674N8 ¦ >KÄ ¦ txÍ S5F���y ¹a¹ Ì=SNH ��� H=S ¼ FnS�Òsò0@0ME3258FE:Lu28H;6:6N8hQ74eH�W98Y6e6�Q74eH�L76IW9250cHKE:6i2DH�9�H¦L78YJ�28C78hsd8YC:4�N+0cH(4�HP1UL70c6N254N0Ms76�258YLG6eR¦6N2%8Y9_6�3i0K2DC�6ÁR¦E�ÀWaC748HKE<0$#4n250MH7Exg�3AC78?4N8¢28C78©6eR¦E:WaC<48HKE70°#?8FLïWYH79�9p6IE70MWY4E250cHKEçsd892S3X8?8FEïQ74eH�W98Y686N8Y6k2a47íE8Y6]Q:JM47W?8�H�N=8?4WYHK9_9�H7E�Q?H(4N286?>Bg�H(4B2DC�4n2g+847WaCTH71�2DC78\Q<48H¦W?8Y6e6�Q74eH�L76IW9250cHKE:6X0ME�NKHKJON(8FL/0ME]2DC78�6eR¦E:WaC74eHKE70$#98YL]9_H�N=8C�476i2DHbQd8?4Á1�H(489µ2DC7856D479]8¥47W92%0MHKE:6�HKEm2DC78¥Q®H=4N2D6Fg�0�>�8=>�Q748H¦W?8F686�Q748H¦L76:WL250MH7E:6AW47E�sd8¥6eR¦E:WaC74eHKE70$#98YL0c1�28C78FR_WFH(0ME:W90ML78i0cEe2DC<8?0D4�Q?H(4N2¬47WL250MH7E:6?>�f�C<0M614%8ÂÓ�670�4%8F9e8FE�2X0M6¾WaC�4=4847W92%8?4N0$#?8FLps�R¡2DC78�8LU�0M6�258FE:W?8\HP1k4WYHK9_9�H7EmQ FnS ½vQ S5FY¶ ¿ � ½É¸ F ºA> Ø Q®H=4N2\Q<48H¦L76:W92%0MHKE�H71�4bQ74eH�W98Y6e6uQ748H¦L76:WL250MH7EP0M6�2DC78h6%6:s�À2Q748H¦L76:WL250cHKECKH=2As�Rs4%8F6N2%4%0MWL250cE7C�2DC78XQ74eH�W98Y686�Q74eH�L76IW9250cHKE]HKEs2DC78XQ?H(4N286?>Õ�Ô�ÖÎÕÖ�×JÖ ¨ ÕÙØ6Ú Ì Ú �+÷°¯qÛ�¨'Ü ×/Ý ÜaÞ&Û � ¯�Û�¨'Ü × Û7Ü�¨Sß7àá ×JÖ ¨ Õ ²aâ8L2}§â ¤ ¨ � � ��� ª sd8§4´L70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FLÛC(4847Q:CæH�N(8?4 â gO0�286sQ FnS ½ Ì=SNH Q�·c0c6k28C78*s70DC(C=8Y6N2t6N6:s7C(4847Q:Cÿj��a�F� §â � ¤�¨ � ä X ¨2Ï � � � �aÿj��J�F����� ª Q §â H�N(894VÿZn�J�F� â �[g@3AC78?4N8;2DC78�E7892S3�H(4eí`C(4847Q:C«ÿZ��a�F� â �uWYHKE¦À2a4=0cE:6�HKEIJcRtQ®H=4N2\EIH�L78F6Yg�0�>�8E>?1�H=4:84PWaC©E:H�L<8jÓ[0ME©ÿZ��a�F� â � ) C:HKJMLI6ã� Ú6ä � ��� ä X ¨2Ï � � � �ÉÓ®�8� ¤ ë ��J��47E:Lÿj��a�F�#��� ¤ � ­ ä X ¨2Ï � � � 0M6@2DC<8Z4N8Y6�254%0cW92%0MHKETH71��´H7E�ÿZn�J�F� â �L>f�C78pQ FnS ½qQ S5FY¶ ¿ � ½É¸ F ºtH71�4TWFHKE:L70K250MH7E�47J`L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FL^Q748H¦L76:WL250MH7E ë tU� §�mt §§æå §©p�_çV� ë �8�:0c6^C(0cN=8YEs�R ë ��a�F� ë �Pt5� §� ­ ä X ¨ðÏ � �¿ � tAÿj��a�F� §§¾�½å ÿj��J�F� §©u�V�_çV� ë n�J�F� ë �8�8��g¬3AC7894%8*ç�� ë ��a�F� ë �8�VC�476_1�H(4;8Y47WaCWYHKE:L<0�250cHKE�47J=WFHKE:6�254D4E0ME32 ýLý �¿ ¤ � §Ó`t §§èå §�c��� §ý 3 t §�éå §ê 3 � 3 δÁ �w®ëçV� ë ��4_WYHKE:L<0�250cHKE�47JkWFHKE:6N2%4D4=0cE32ë n�J�F� ýLý �¿ � ¤ � §Ó ­ ä X ¨ðÏíì �¿,î t�ÿj��J�F� §§¾��å ÿZn�J�F� §�©�L��� §ý 3 ­ ä X ¨2Ïíì �À�î t�ÿj��J�F� §�^��å ÿj��J�F� §ê 3 �8� 3 δÁ �V> ʽ:¾ ÞA,ïÛ *�Ô�Ø6Ú ���Ù¯qÛ�¨'Ü × Û7Ü�¨Sß7àá ×JÖ ¨ Õ ²gÀ0DC(6<4%8 ¦ >KÄ � 68CIH�3A6k2DC<8©Q®H(4�2]Q748H¦L76:WL250cHKE:6TH71Z2DC78©Q<48H¦W?8Y6e6GQ<48H¦L76:W92%0MHKEI6sC(0cN=8YEö0ME¹2DC<8©Q748H¦W?8F686C(4D479_9�4=486w�q����çu��47E:L¢�q�A� Ò �w0ME^óÀUI479_Q:JD8 ¦ > ¤ >Zf�C<8VQ748H¦L76:WL250MH7E:6 ë 47E:Lë�Â�F� Ò ��476�3X8YJcJ�476:28C78Q748H¦L76:WL250MH7E:6 ë í 47E:L ì C�4N(8o2DC<8¥68479]8uQ®H(4�2AQ748H¦L76:WL250cHKExg70�>�8E><2DC78[Rt4=4%8u6ÁR¦E:WaC748H7E70$#Y47s:JD8E> Ø JMJ®H=2DC7894Q748H¦L76:WL250MH7E:6A4=4%8XE:HE2A6eR¦E:WaC74eHKE70$#Y47s:J�8=>ó�UI479_Q:J�8Y6�1�H(4�Q®H(4�2¾Q748H¦L76:WL250MH7E:6�HP1�2DC<8�Q74eH�W98Y686�Q748H¦L76:WL250cHKE:6¾H71�28C78�WY476%8�6N2%6:LIR]0ME ³ C�47Q<2%8?4�Ó¥4=4N8C(0cN=8YEm0ME]óÀUI479�QIJD8¥Ó�>KÄ�Ó�> ÊØ 6p9]8YE3250cHKE78FLÙ47s?H�N=87gAQ74eH�W98Y686bQ748H¦L76:WL250MH7E:6p4=4N8�6eR¦E:WaC<48HKE70°#47sIJD8P0O1^2DC78[RçC:4�N=8P2DC<8�6D479]8�Q?H(4�2Q748H¦L76:WL250MH7E�>�ð�H�3x8[N(8?4FgÔE:HE2�4PJMJxQ74eH�W98Y6e6�Q74eH�L<6:W92%0MHKE:6h28C�4E2�C�4N(8Z2DC78¥6D479]8XQ®H=4N2�Q748H¦L76:WL250cHKE]C�4N(82DH±sd8t6eR¦E:WaC74eHKE70$#98YL�>Ûf�C78?4N8F1�H(4N87gA0p0cE�2%48H¦L76:W98�4�¹ � º � · S5F º�¸òñ H ½Ð¸ F º S�yLIKH ½É¸ F ºÂHKEà2DC78GQ748H¦L76:WL250cHKEE�479]8Y6VH71i2DC<8tQ<48H¦W?8Y6e6¡0ME:6�2a47E:W98Y6�C(0ON(8FER0cE�4�L70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YL�C(4D4P9�9�4=4o2DH¢0ME:L<0MW4n258b3AC70cWaC�Q748H¦W?8F686Q748H¦L76:WL250MH7E:6�H71\0MEI6N2a4PE:W?8F6�C:4�N=8^2DHVsd8u6eR¦E:WaC74eHKE70$#98YL�>1f�C78u6ÁR�EIWaC748HKE<0$#4n250MH7Em4N8YJM4E250cHKE/4%8FJv4E2%8Y6�H7E:JcRQ748H¦L76:WL250MH7EpE�479]8Y6FgI3AC78?4N8O2DC78uQ?H(4�2�Q74eH�L76IW9250cHKE:6�4E4%8O8oÓ+6:47J�>qf�C70c6@8YEI6%674N8Y6YgA28C�4E2h4N8YJv4n258YLbQ748H¦W?8F686Q748H¦L76:WL250MH7E:65WFH(0MEIW?0ML<8]0cE`28C78bQ?H(4N2¥Q74eH�L<6:W92%0MHKE±47E:LÂ4E4%8_6eR¦E:WaC74eHKE70$#Y47s:J�87g�0�>�8E>â28C78FR*Qd8?4Á1�H(489�28C786D479]8t47W92%0MHKE:6VH7Eà28C78]Q®H(4�2D69>àf�C<8GQ74eH�W98Y6e6�9_H�N(8Y6dH71�6eR¦E:WaC74eHKE70°#?8YL�Q748H¦L76:WL250cHKE:6_4=4%8k0cE�2%8YE:L<8YL2DH�2a4Pí=8]Q:Jv4PW?8T4E2�2DC78T68479e8/2%0M9]8=>¢f�C78T6ÁR�EIWaC748HKE<0$#4n250MH7Eà4N8YJM4E250cHKEc0M6hL78oó�E<8YL´HKEr2DC78s0cE:6N2D47E:W?8F6

¤ Ë

Page 98: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

port(st(A))

port(p’)

port(p) port(q)

port(st(B))

gÀ0�C(674N8 ¦ >KÄ � tpñx· y Q FnS ½{Q S�FY¶ ¿ � ½É¸ F ºI¹ F ¼ �q����çu� H º ¶ �q�A� Ò �H71@2DC<8bQ74eH�W98Y686hQ748H¦L76:WL250MH7E:6Ygv0�>�8=>â2DC78�6D479]8�Q<48H¦W?8Y6e6�Q74eH�L76IW9250cHKEÊ0cE`28C78bQ74eH�W98Y6e6pC(4D4P9�9�4=4X9b4RC�4N(8^4Â6eR¦E:WaC<48HKE70°#4E2%0MHKEÙWFHKE:6�254D4E0ME32s0MEÙH7E78�Q74eH�W98Y686s0cE:6N2D47E:W987gA3AC78?4N8476k0�2bW47EÙ9_H�N(8�3i0K2DC:H(6�26eR¦E:WaC74eHKE70$#Y4E250cHKEm0ME]47E:HE2DC7894�0cE:6N2D47E:W98=>Õ�Ô�ÖÎÕÖ�×JÖ ¨ ÕÙØ6Ú Ì Ú �IÅ�¯Pô � Õ á � Ür¨ Õ7Ö�õ Þ ×JÖ ¨ Õ Ü Ô+* Þ ×JÖ ¨ Õ ²W 0ON(8YE�45L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FLeC=4D479_9b4E4q�q� ¤ �#�q�A�bÓ®�V�_��ÒxÞ?�bÓ®�e� × Î ä ä � DV° 3i0�28C/�q�A�ÉÓ®� ¤ë¨ �Â�F�bÓ®�L��� ë t §�P� D Î ä , ª1�H(4/84PWaCöÓµ®Íÿ�ö õrëA� >�aâ8L2tÿ 3× ¤ « �Â� 3 �bÓ®� ¯ Uz� ë 3 � D Î ä , sY8u2DC78©6N892]H71¥Q74eH�L76IW9250cHKE:6pE:479e8F6TH71Q748H¦W?8F686/0cE:6N2D47E:W?8P£u®÷��ÒxÞ?�ÉÓ®�d1�H(4e847WaC�Ó ® ÿ�ö õrëA� 47E:LÙÿ ²�² ¤ùø × Î ä ä ��DV°Y² 3 δÁGÕ?» ì × î ÿ 3× sd8u28C786%8925H71@28C78_Q748H¦L76:WL250MH7E§E�4P9e8F65H71�47JMJ�Q<48H¦W?8Y6e6j0cE:6N2D47E:W98Y6�0cE[28C78_L70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YL[C(4D479_9�4=4?>]f�C78YEÔg�4¹ � º � · S5F º�¸òñ H ½É¸ F º S5yLIKH ½É¸ F º � Î Q ÿ ²�²¬ú ÿ ²n² 0c6�4P4N8YJM4E250cHKE±HKEÂÿ ²�² g�6%6IWaC�28C�4E2 ë 3 � Î ë ´ 0M9_Q:JD0�8Y6ë'û �J�F� ë 3 � ¤ ë'û �J�F� ë ´ �L> ʽ:¾ ÞA,ïÛ *�Ô�Ø6Ú �'�«¯Pôo� Õ á � Ü�¨ ÕÖ�õ Þ ×JÖ ¨ Õ Ü Ô+* Þ ×JÖ ¨ Õ ²Ø 6eR¦E:WaC<48HKE70°#4E2%0MHKE;4%8YJM4E250cHKEd1�H(4X28C78\L70c6N254N0Ms76�258YLeC(4D4P9�9�4=4B0MEbó�UI479_Q:J�8 ¦ > ¤ 9�4�RdJcH�H7íd476¬1�HKJcJMH�3A6?të � Î��Â�F� Ò ��4PE:L ë í � Î ì >�ü+0ME:W98�3x8AC�4N(8AHKEIJcR�H7E78h0ME:6�2a47EIW?8�1�H(4�8Y47WaC�Q<48H¦W?8Y6e6q2SR�Qd87g�0@68í�0MQIQY8FL]28C780ME:L78VUu1�H(4{2DC<810cE:6N2D47E:W98¬4E2{28C78¾Q748H¦L76:WL250MH7E¥E:479e8F6?>vf�C78X0cE3258YEIL78YL59e8Y47E70ME<C�H71<28C78�6eR¦E:WaC74eHKE70$#Y4E250cHKEWYHKE:6�25484=0ME32k1�H(4â2DC78¾Q748H¦L76:WL250cHKE:6 ë 47EILý�Â�F� Ò ��0c6Yg�2DC�4E2\2DC<8�Q74eH�W98Y6e6À0MEI6N2a4PE:W?8<ç�ľW?4N84E2%8Y6v28C78¾Q748H¦W?8F6860ME:6�2a47E:W98 Ò ÄO0O1Sç�ÄuW94%8Y4E258F6x2DC78�Q®H(4�2->�f�C<8^0ME3258FE:L78YLT9]84PE70ME7C5H71{2DC<8\6eR¦E:WaC74eHKE70°#4E2%0MHKETWFHKE:6N2%4D4=0cE321�H(4Z28C78bQ<48H¦L76:W92%0MHKEI6 ë í 47E:L ì 0M6Fgv28C�4E2Z2DC78e8YJD8F9e8FE32�H71@28C78bQ<48H¦W?8Y6e6p0MEI6N2a4PE:W?8eç�Äb6eC�47JcJ¾sd8b6N8YE326eR¦E:WaC74eHKE:H(6:6eJcRe2DHVQ74eH�W98Y686h0cE:6N2D47E:W98 Ò Ä(>�f�C<8^0ME3258FE:L78YLT9]84PE70ME7ChsY8FWYHK9]8Y6�WFJD8Y4=4%894x0c1k0q0cE32548H¦L76:W982DC78XHKQd8?484E250cHKE�47J®6%8Y9�47E3250cWY6�1�H(4A4VL70c6N254N0Ms76�258YLkC(48479_9b4=49>f�C78X6eR¦E:WaC74eHKE70$#Y4E250cHKEm4%8YJM4E250cHKEp1�H(4@28C78XW476N8¥6�256:L�Rk0ME ³ C�47Q<2%8?4�Ó�0M6hC(0ON(8YEk0cEGóÀUI479_Q:JD8¥Ó+>�Ä ' > Êf�H^6%6I9 6:Qxg¾4©L70c6N254N0Ms76�258YL«6ÁR¦6N258F9 0M6h68Qd8YW?0òóA8YL´s�R«4©E78L2S3¬H(4eíÊ2SR¦QY8kC(4847Q:Cc28C�4E2VL78F68W94%0Msd8Y6�28C78Q®HK6e6%0cs:JD85Q748H¦W?8F686u47EIL©Q®H(4�2:2SR¦Qd8Y6X47E:L�28C78?0�4�WFHKE:E78FW9250cHKE:6Fg=4bQ74eH�W98Y686^C=4D479_9b4E4A1�H=4:84PWaC©Q748H¦W?8F6862SR�Qd8xC=0cN(8FEp0MEo2DC<8¬E78L2S3¬H(4eíZ2SR¦Qd8@C(4847Q:Cxg74�E�479]8¾68Q�47W98�1�H(4â2DC<8x0MEI6N2a4PE:W?8F6`H71A8Y47WaC�Q74eH�W98Y6e6À2SR¦QY8¬47E:L456eR¦E:WaC<48HKE70°#4E2%0MHKEe4%8FJv4E2%0MHKEd1�H(410ME:L70cW4E2%0ME7C^28C78�6ÁR¦E:WaC748H7E70$#Y4E250cHKEpWYH7E:6N2%4D4=0cE�286�H7EpQ748H¦W?8F686X0ME:6�2a47E:W989�H�N(8F6?>Õ�Ô�ÖÎÕÖ�×JÖ ¨ ÕÙØ6Ú Ì Ú �¦×°¯Pß Ö ô × Ü Ö �à ×³Ô ßÙôo�Sô ×³Ô , ôÂÛ Ô á Ö�Ö áþÞ ×JÖ ¨ Õ ²Ø ¶ ¸M¹[½ S ¸#�Y¿�½ y8¶ ¹ � ¹[½ y �ѹGQ y�� ¸ à �%H ½É¸ F º ��� ÿ ¤ �#ä½ö â �5�q�@� � Φ�¬WFHKE:6%0c6N286�HP1Ä(>�4VE7892S3�H(48í/2SR¦Qd8jC=4D47Q:Cmä�ö â 4P6�L<8oó�E78FLP0cE�!O8oó�E70K250cHKE ¦ > ' >�Ä7g

¤ Ä

Page 99: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

Ó�>�4�L70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FLPC(48479�9�4=4h�q� ¤ ���q�A�ÉÓ®�L�_��ÒxÞ?�ÉÓ®�8� × Î ä ä ��DV° 3i0K2DCP4N8Y6eQY8FW92:28H/ä�ö â 476�L78oó:E78YL0ME½!O8oó:E70�2%0MHKE ¦ > ' >KÄ � 47E:L

' >�4V6eR¦E:WaC74eHKE70$#Y4E250cHKEm4%8YJM4E250cHKET476AL78 ó�E78FLP0ME½!O8 ó�E70�2%0MHKE ¦ > ' >KÄ�ó�>ÊØ7Ú Ì ÚÿØ 9 � ¨d,ïÛ�¨ ô Ö�×JÖ ¨ Õ Þ *�� Û Ô ÜJÞ ×JÖ ¨ Õ Þ * ¿ Ô ,ïÞ ÕÇ×JÖ á¾ô>�ÞOô Ô ßw¨ Õ Ä ÜJÞ Õ ô��2¨'Ün,ïÞ ×JÖ ¨ Õ ¿ �6ô�Æ×³Ô ,Ëô

f�C70M6�6%8FW9250cHKE�Q<48H�N+0ML78F6w2DC<85WFHK9�Q?HK6N0�250cHKE�47JÔHKQY894D4E2%0MHKE:47Jx6%8F9b4PE�2%0MWF6�H71�4_L70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FL�6eR¦6�258Y9Ò3i0�28C4%8Y6eQY8FW92e2DH§4*L70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FL�6ÁR�6�258F9 6eQY8FW?0°ó:W4E2%0MHKE�>Rf�C78tHKQY894D4E2%0MHKE:47J�6%8F9b4PE�2%0MWF6e0c6_WFHK9_Q®HK6N8YL�s�R2DC78¥HKQd8?4D4n250MH7E�47J=6%8F9b4PE�2%0MWF6�H71À2DC78¥Q748H¦W?8F686w0ME:6�2a47E:W98Y69>�f�C<8hs�476N0M6A1�H(4h2DC785HKQd8?4D4n250MH7E�47Jx6N8Y9�47E3250MWF647E:Lr2DC78]WFHK9�Q?HK6N0�250cHKEÂ4E4%8^½ SNH ºI¹ ¼ FnS � H ½É¸ F º�¹ � ¹[½ y �h¹L>Êfv4847E:6e1�H=489�4E250cHKE«6eR¦6N2%8Y9_6_4=4%8s0cE�2%48H¦L76:W98YLs�R W 48H��(8�ÀY�AC:H¦L78o0ME«ô W � ¤ ¥�g W � ¤7¤Põ 476�WFHK9_9�HKEG6%8F9b47E32%0MW4PJk1b48479]8F3�H(48ík0MEt3AC70MWaC©6eQY8FW?0òó�W4E2%0MHKEI63i4%0�2N258FE/0ME�L70còY8?4N8YE32�JM47E7C(6�4EC(8Y6¾W47EbsY8w0ME3258948Q74N89258FL�>�0�68CIH�3ö28C�4E2�L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FL;C(4847Q:C;2%4D47EI6e1�H(4e9b4rÀ250MH7E©W47E^sd8�0ME3258948Q74N89258FL¢0ME�2DC<0M6\1b4D4P9e8[3¬H(4eí�476\3X8YJcJ�>Zf�C70M6^4N8YJM4E250cHKE�8YE:47s:JD8F6^6:6^2DHT9�47í=8�6I6%8dH712DC78dWYH79�Q?HK6%0K250cHKE�H711254847E:6e1�H=489�4E250cHKE�6eR¦6�258Y9_65476XL78oó�E<8YLÊ0cE´ô W � ¤ ¥Ig W � ¤K¤Põ >�0SE�2DC78V1�HKJcJMH�3i0ME<C:gÔ0C(0cN=8h47Eu0ME3254eH�L<6:W92%0MHKEm0MEm254D4PE:6e1�H(4e9b4n250MH7Et6ÁR¦6N258F9�6\47E:Lu28C78?0�4�WFHK9_Q®HK6N0�2%0MHKEt47E:LG68C:H�3­4P1É2%8?4e3¬4=4eL:6C:H�3 L70c6N254N0Ms76�258YLkC(4847Q:Ck254847E:6e1�H=489�4E250cHKEWó7286�0cE32DH�2DC70c6�1b4D479]8F3�H(4eíd>Ø7Ú Ì ÚÿØ6Ú � Ä ÜJÞ Õ ô��2¨'ÜE,ëÞ ×JÖ ¨ Õ ¿ �Sô ×³Ô ,Ëô:Þ Õ ß ×��7Ô Ö Ü � ¨d,ïÛ�¨ ô Ö�×JÖ ¨ ÕØ 254847E:6Á1�H(489�4E250cHKE¥6eR¦6N2%8Y9ë0c6U4w2S3�HuJv4R=8?4%8FL�6N2%4%6:WL25674N87g3C(0ON(8FEVs�Rh4 ��F º�½ S5FnI�iF µ Ì=SNH Q�·i2DC:4E2U9_H�L<8YJM62DC78@2%8Y9_Q®H(4847J:H(4eL78?4N0ME7CuHP1x47WL250cHKE:6YgK47E:L�4\L�4E2a4uJ�8FN(8FJðg3C(0ON(8FE_s�RVL:4E2a4u6N2D4E258F6¾47E:LdL�4E2D4^2%4D47EI6e1�H(4e9b4rÀ250MH7E:6X28C�4E2A4=4N8u476e68H¦W?0v4n258YL/28Hp2DC78�6N2a4n258Y6A4PE:L/254847E:6%0K250cHKE:6¬HP1{2DC78uWFHKE32548H7J Ç H�3ÛC(4D47QIC/4%8F68Qd8YW92%0cN=8YJcR=>lO0v4�28C70M6A6N8YQ�4=484E250cHKEs2DC78XWFHKE32548H7J Ç H�3�C(4847Q:CtL78oó�E<8Y6�C:H�3�4E28HK9e0cW\L�4E2D4¡2%4D47EI6e1�H(4e9b4E2%0MHKEI6�4=4%8uQ<6<22DH(C(8L2DC7894O2DHTQ74eH�W98Y6e6%8Y69>�f�C78VQ�4E28C:6^0ME�28C78VWYH7E�2%48HKJ Ç H�3ëC(4847Q:C^9_H�L78FJv28C78V6%8oÓ+6<8YE3250M47Jq8LU�8YW96<250cHKEH71U4PW9250cHKE:6Fg:s74D4PE:WaC70ME<Ce0cE:L70MWY4E258F6�E:HKE:L<892589489]0ME70c6N2%0MW\WaC:H=0MW?8E>f�C78�WYH7E�2%48HKJ Ç H�3ëC=4D47Q:CP0M6\4PE�8YL7C(8�ÀSJM47sY8FJD8FLPC(4847Q:C�3i0�28C�HKE78hL70M6�250ME<C(670M6eC78YL�E:H�L<87gxWY47JMJ�8YL±¸»º�¸»½É¸ H=I¹[½ H ½ y >�f�C78_E:H�L<8Y6XH7112DC78dWYH7E�2%48HKJ Ç H�3ëC(4D4PQ:C*4=4%8dW4PJMJD8FL ��F º�½ S5FnI ¹[½ H ½ y ¹^0ME�28C78V1�HKJMJcH�3i0ME7C7>�âGH(4 ÀQ:C70M6e9�6hsY8L2S3x898YE´WYHKE3254eHKJ Ç H�3µC(4D4PQ:C:6d4=4N8/C(0cN=8YE�s�RÊ28H=2a47JXC(4D4PQ:C«9�H=48Q:C70c689_6j28C�4E2d9�47Qc0ME<0�250M47J6N2a4n258Y6AHKEm0ME<0�250M47J?6N2a4n258Y6�47EIL�4=4N8uWYHK9_Q�4E2%0Ms:J�8�3i0�28Cs2DC78XJv4PsY8FJM6?>Õ�Ô�ÖÎÕÖ�×JÖ ¨ ÕÙØ6Ú Ì Ú �¦÷°¯PáK¨ ÕÇ× Ür¨ *� ¨¦ø Ý ÜJÞ�Û � ²Ø ��F º�½ S�FnI��iF µ Ì=SNH Q�·XWYH7E:6%0c6N2D6¬H71k4j2%6:Q:JD8 ê�â�¤�¨�â ��§h�� G�5£�ÒY£ � ª 3AC7894%8 â 0M6�4�C(4847Q:Cxg&§r0M6�4h6%8L2�H71Jv47sd8YJc6Yg� vt â á¬å §R0M6A4dJv47sd8YJ�0ME7C59b47QIQ70ME7CV1�H(4h8FL7C(8F6�4PE:Lu£�Ò�£��h® â ) 0M6@28C78d¸»º�¸»½Ð¸ H=I ¹[½ H ½ y >Ø ��F º�½ S5FnI��iF µ Ì=SNH Q�·s� FnS Q�·¦¸M¹L��sd892S3X8?8YEGWYHKE32%48HKJ Ç H�3ðC(4D4PQ:C:6 ê�â|¤�¨�â ��§h�� G�5£�ÒY£ � ª 47E:L ê�â í ¤¨�â í ��§ í �� í �5£�ÒY£ � í ª 0M6]4«Q�4E0D4 ê � � ¤ ¨ ê � � ê ¿ ª t ê�â å ê�â í 3AC7894%8 ê � t â å â í 0M6T4c28H=2a47JC(4D47QIC*9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9�6N6:WaC`28C�4E2 ê � �b£�Ò�£��e� ¤ £�ÒY£ � í 47E:L ê ¿ t § å § í 0M6\4s28H=2a4PJU9b4PQ:Q70ME<Cp6%6:WaC[2DC�4n2ê ¿ �� Á� � �8� ¤ í � ê � � � �8�¬1�H(4h8Y47WaCm8YL7C(8 � ® â á�> Êf�C78GL:4E2a4^6N2D4E258F6�H71\4¢2%4D47EI6e1�H(4e9b4E2%0MHKE«6ÁR¦6N258F9 W47E�sY8]WaC:HK6N8YEç1b4eHK9 47E�4=4es70�2%4D4=4ÁRÂWYH¦WYH79�Q:J�892%8W4E2%8?CKH(4ÁR��bgÀ8=>�C7>`Q�4E4N250M47J¾47JDC=8Ys748476Z28H©4PC(0ON(8FE«47JDC=8Ys7484=0MW_6%0�CKE�4E2%674%8E>Pf�C78pL:4E2a4u2%4D47EI6e1�H(4e9b4E2%0MHKE0M6:C=0cN(8FE�s�R�4��¥À29�H=48Q:C70c689m>wf�C<8V47686eH�W90v4E2%0MHKEtH71�L�4n2a4b6�2a4E2%8Y6u47EIL©L�4E2a4]254D4PE:6e1�H(4e9b4n250MH7E:6h2DH;28C78WYHKE3254eHKJ�6N2D4E258F6¾47E:L¡8YL7C=8Y6¾H71Y28C78AWYHKE32%48HKJ Ç H�3 C(4D4PQ:Ce0c6UL78 ó�E78YL_N+0v4X4O2DH=2D47J7C(4847Q:Cd9�H=48Q:C70c689ñ1b48HK92DC78�WYHKE3254eHKJ Ç H�3öC(4D4PQ:C;0cEe2DC<8:6:E:L<8?48JOR+0ME7CZC(4D4PQ:CpH71��©28C�4E2�6%894eN(8F6�47612DC78�L:HK9�4=0MEdH71k4PJMJ�Q?HK686N0Ms:J�8L�4E2a4V6�2a4E2%8Y6�47E:L]L�4E2D4�2%4D47EI6e1�H(4e9b4E2%0MHKEI6?>

¤ Ó

Page 100: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

Õ�Ô�ÖÎÕÖ�×JÖ ¨ ÕÙØ6Ú Ì Ú�� �Ù¯ × ÜaÞ Õ ô��ð¨ Ün,ïÞ ×JÖ ¨ Õ ôo�6ô ×³Ô ,´²aâ8L2�� sd8]4�W4n258?C7H(4eR7g�4½ SNH ºI¹ ¼ FnS � H ½Ð¸ F º�¹ � ¹[½ y �æ0ME��}0M6V4©Q�4=0�4Aç ¤ ¨�ê�â � � ª gU3AC78?4N8 ê�â�¤¨�â �_§i�� ��%£�Ò�£�� ª 0c6\4�WFHKE3254eHKJ Ç H�3©C=4D47Q:C�47E:L � t â å â z�0M6�4e28H=2a47JâC(4847Q:CG9�H(4eQ:C70c689Í1b48H79 â 0cE2DC78o6:E:L<8?48JOR+0ME7C¡C(4847Q:C â z«H71\2DC<8¥WY4E2589CKH(4ÁR��e>Ø ½ SNH ºI¹ ¼ FnS � H ½Ð¸ F º�� FnS Q�·¦¸M¹L��sd892S3X8?8YEZ254847E:6e1�H=489�4E250cHKE\6eR¦6�258Y9_67ç ¤©¨�ê�â � � ª 47E:LÆç í ¤ë¨�ê�â í � � í ª0M6A4VQ�4=0�4 ê ¤�¨ ê � � �  \ì ª t¾ç å ç í g:3AC78?4N8 ê � � t ê�â í å ê�â 0c6A4_WFHKE32548H7J Ç H�3�C(4847Q:C]9�H=48Q:C70c68947E:L   ì t\ß ì� � � �Æå � í 0M6¥4T1É479e0cJcRGH71��XÀ29�H(4eQ:C70c689_6 «   ì �b£S�pt � � ê � �#£2�8�Æå � í �#£S� ­ £o® â í ) ¯ 3i0�28Cß ì� � � � ¤ � < ê � > ÊÃ�J�8476N8pE:H=2%0MW987gÀ28C�4E2�28C78p9_H(48QIC70M6e9   ì tqß ì�� � � �ýå � í 0M6�4�9_H(4eQ:C70M6e9 H71h2DC<8p9�H¦L78FJ�WY4E2589CKH(4eR)Ǩ«ß ä z � â í ��47EIL;2DC78�L70D4N8YW92%0MHKEI6¬H71{28C78\WYH7E�2%48HKJ Ç H�3JC(4D4PQ:Cp9_H(48Q:C<0M689w47EIL;2DC78�9�H(4eQ:C70c689 HKE;28C78L�4E2a4XJD8[N(8FJ®4E4%8AHKQ:Q?HK6%0K258E>�f�C70M6�1É47WL2¬QIJv4R¦6�4PE;0M9_Q?H(4N2D47E32q48HKJ�8�1�H(4�2DC78�WYH79�Q?HK6%0K250cHKEVH71�2%4D47EI6e1�H(4e9b4rÀ250MH7EV6eR¦6N2%8Y9_6�s�RdJD0c9e0K2D6�47E:L_WYHKJ�0M9]0�286?t ³ HKE:6N0ML7894q2DC78AW4P6%8AH71d2S3¬Ho254847E:6e1�H=489�4E250cHKE�6eR¦6�258Y9_6<ç��U47E:Lç �q2DC�4n2�68C�4PJMJIsd8�WFHK9�Q?HK6N8YL�>�f�C<8�6eR¦E:WaC74eHKE70$#Y4E250cHKEVWYH7E:6N2%4D4=0cE�286U1�H(4À28C78�WYH79�Q?HK6%0K250cHKEhH71�28C78Y6N8i2S3�H254D4PE:6e1�H(4e9b4n250MH7Eb6eR¦6�258Y9_6A4=4N8OC(0cN=8YETs�Rb47E]4=6�U�0MJ�0v4=4ÁR�254847E:6e1�H=489�4E250cHKE�6ÁR¦6N258F9 çã»�g+2DC78\47W92%6�47JÔ6ÁR¦E�ÀWaC748HKE<0$#4n250MH7Ej0c6\28C78YEp8VU�Q74%8F686%8FLds�Ro2%4D47E:6Á1�H(489�4E2%0MHKEX9_H(48Q:C<0M689_6 ê �@t¾ç®» å ç��@4PE:L ê �:t,çã» å ç �?>f�C785WFHKE3254eHKJ Ç H�3|C(4847Q:C]9�H=48Q:C70c689_6 ê � �� t ê�â � 2 å ê�â � ¼ 47E:L ê � �� t ê�â �"!<å ê�â � ¼ 0cE:L70MWY4E2582DC78]254D4PE:6%0K250MH7E:6Z28C�4E2h68C�47JcJ�sd8bQd8?4Á1�H(489]8YL§6eR¦E:WaC74eHKE:H(6I68JcR=>�f�C78Y6N8]4=4%8e8LUI47WL2DJcR¢28C:HK6%8e254D4PE:6%0K250MH7E0ME ê�â � 2 47E:L ê�â �"!Yg�2DC:4E2d4=4N8T9b47QIQY8FL«HKE32DH�2DC<8p6D479]8;2%4D47E:6N0�2%0MHKEc0cEc2DC78bWYHKE3254eHKJ Ç H�3µC(4D4PQ:Cê�â � ¼ >ef�C78_JD0c9e0K2�HP1 ê � �� 47E:L ê � �� 1�H(4e9�6O28C78�WFHKE3254eHKJ Ç H�3�C(4847Q:Cxgk3AC7894%8�47JMJ�6eR¦E:WaC74eHKE70$#Y4E250cHKEWYHKE:6�25484=0ME32D6A4E4%8\684E250c6qóA8FL�>Bf�C78uL�4E2D4d6�2a4E2%8Y6A47EILtL:4E2a4�2%4D47E:6Á1�H(489�4E2%0MHKE:6�H71â2DC78uWFHK9_Q®HK6N8YLTWFHKE32548H7JÇ H�3�C(4847Q:CG4=4%8^C(0ON(8FEGs�R/28C78XWYHKJ�0M9]0�2�H71À28C78X9�H(4eQ:C70c689_6   ì 2 47E:L   ì ! >Õ�Ô�ÖÎÕÖ�×JÖ ¨ ÕÙØ6Ú Ì Ú�� �«¯PáK¨d,ïÛ�¨ ô Ö�×JÖ ¨ Õ ¨#� × ÜJÞ Õ ô��2¨'Ün,ïÞ ×JÖ ¨ Õ ôo�6ô ×´Ô ,ïôr²W 0ON(8YE¢254847E:6Á1�H(489�4E250cHKE©6eR¦6�258Y9_6�ç 3 ¤�¨ ê�â � Ö � � 3 ª 0cE��Í3i0�2DC ê�â � Ö ¤�¨�â 3 ��§ 3 �� 3 �5£�Ò�£ � 3 ª 1�H(4^£ ¤Ë<�-Ä(� ZOZOZ �5Ò�4PE:L`2%4D47E:6Á1�H(489�4E2%0MHKE©9_H(48QIC70M6e9�6 ê ´ ¤�¨ ê � � ¹ �   ì ¹ ª tSç®»�å ç ´ 1�H(4�à ¤ Ä=� ZcZOZ �5ÒÀ>ef�C78��F �:Q F ¹[¸»½Ð¸ F º*H71�2DC78½ç ´ N+0v4 ê ´ 1�H(4¥à ¤ Ä=� ZcZOZ �5Òö0M6¡C(0cN=8YE´s�Rr2DC78k254847E:6e1�H=489�4E250cHKE«6eR¦6N2%8Y9 ç ¤¨�ê�â � � ª 47E:L¢2DC78¡254847E:6e1�H=489�4E250cHKE^9�H(4eQ:C70c689_6 ê í´ ¤�¨ ê í � � ¹ �   ì î ¹ ª t«ç ´ å ç5g`6N6:WaCÊ2DC:4E2 ê�â椨�â �_§i�� ��%£�Ò�£�� ª 3i0K2DC ê í � � ¹ t ê�â å ê�â � ¹ 0c6@2DC78XJ�0M9]0�2�H71v28C78 ê � � ¹ >ê�â � ¼ê�â � 2ì�$ � 2 !%%%%%%%%% ZcZOZ ê�â �'&ì�$ � &() * * * * * * * * *

ê�âì î $ � 2() * * * * * * * * * ì î $ � & !%%%%%%%%%

f�C78�C(4D47QIC­9_H(48QIC70M6e9 � t â å â z�0M6©L<8oó�E78FLÚ476�28C78�WYHKJ�0M9]0�2GH71e28C78�9�H=48Q:C70c689_6   ì ¹ tß ì î �¹ ¸ ì �¹ � � »[��å ß ì î �¹ � � ´ �x0cEs2DC78XW4n258?C7H(4eR )�¨Sß ä z � â �V>

ß ì î �Ö ¸ ì �Ö � � »[�±� 2

+, - - - - - -- - - - - ±

� &� EEEEEEEEEEEß ì î � 2 � � �e�

±� î 2 ./ EEEEEEEEEEEEE

ZcZOZ ß ì î �& � � Õ �±� î &

01 - - - - - -- - - - - -

-�

ʤ('

Page 101: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

f�C78hWFHK9�Q?HK6N0�250cHKE]H71À2%4D47EI6e1�H(4e9b4E2%0MHKE]6ÁR�6�258F9�6�N+0M4¡2%4D47E:6Á1�H(489�4E2%0MHKE]9_H(48Q:C<0M689_6AW47E�sY8¥W4E2%8?CKH=4%0OÀW47JcJcRVWaC�4E4D47WL258?4N0$#98YLT47612DC78�WYHKJ�0M9]0�2q0cEe28C78�WY4E2589CKH(4eRdHP1�254847E:6e1�H=489�4E250cHKE�6ÁR¦6N258F9�6�47E:Le2%4D47EI6e1�H(4e9b4rÀ250MH7ET9�H(4eQ:C70c689_6?>¾âGH(4N8XL7892D4=0MJc6¬3i0�28Cm4N8Y6eQY8FW92�2DH�2DC70c6h2DHKQ70cW\W4PEGsd8u1�H(6:E:Lm0ME*ô W � ¤ ¥ õ >0¾6eC:H�3ïEIH�3J2DC:4E2�L70c6N254N0Ms76�258YLsC=4D47Q:Ce254D4PE:6e1�H(4e9b4n250MH7Eeó7286h0ME32DH�28C78\1b4D4P9e8[3¬H(4eí�HP1\2%4D47EI6e1�H(4e9b4E2%0MHKE6eR¦6N2%8Y9_6?>©0SEc2DC<8pW476N8pH71AL70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FLcC(4D4PQ:Cc254847E:6e1�H=489�4E250cHKExgâ2DC78pWY4E2589CKH(4ÁR§1�H(4o2DC<8pL:HK9�4=0ME§H7147JMJ�Q?HK686N0Ms:J�8]L�4E2a4*6N2D4E258F6p47E:L�L�4E2D4¢2%4D47E:6Á1�H(489�4E2%0MHKE:6¡0c6]C=0cN(8FEçs�R�2DC78tW4n258?C7H(4eR�Õ�2 Ü z���ä½ö â �H71�L70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FLÛC(4847Q:C:6G47E:LzL70M6�254N0Ms76<2%8YLæ9�H=48Q:C70c689_6p3i0�28CïJMH¦W4PJ3�XÀS6N2D4E258F6?> f�C<8±WYH7E�2%48HKJ Ç H�3C(4D47QIC�H71\4¢2%4D47EI6e1�H(4e9b4E2%0MHKE«6ÁR¦6N258F9 9_H¦L78YJc6p2DC78k258F9�Q?H(4D4PJ�H(48L<8?4%0cE7C*H71u47WL250cHKE:6_47E:L´L78Y6eW?4N0Msd8Y6C:H�3Ô254847E:6Á1�H(489�4E250cHKE:65H71�L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FL�C(4D47QIC:6d4=4%8TQ<6<2¡2DH(C(8L2DC7894?> !O8FQY8FE:L70cE7C^HKEr2DC78T6�254%6IW9256<4%8H71w28C78]WYHKE32%48HKJ Ç H�3ÔC(4D47QIC�4PE:Là28C78t47686N0DCKEI9e8FE�2dHP1�L�4n2a4©6N2D4E258F6�4PE:L�L:4E2a4�254847E:6Á1�H(489�4E250cHKE:6�28H2DC78]E:H¦L78Y6]4%8F68Q�>B8FL7C(8Y6�H71�2DC78tWYHKE32%48HKJ Ç H�3�C=4D47Q:CÔg�4^L70còY8?4N8YE32_sY8FC�4N�0cH(4¡0M6d9_H�L78FJD8FL�>�0h68CIH�3E:H�3 2DC78]WFHKE:6N2%4%6:WL250cHKE�HP1u4�254D4PE:6e1�H(4e9b4n250MH7EÂ6eR¦6N2%8Y9¬2DC:4E2]4%8YQ<4%8Y6N8YE32D6e2DC78]sd8YC�4N+0MH(4dH71\4�C(0cN=8YE6%892XHP1�L78?4N0cNP4E250cHKE�6N8ÂÓ�678YEIW?8Y6 � C(8FE78?484E258FL*s�R�4/C(4D479_9�4=4:�q�@>Zf�C78VWFHKE32548H7J Ç H�3©C(4D47QIC©H71B2DC70c6254D4PE:6e1�H(4e9b4n250MH7E56ÁR�6�258F9�0MEhÕ42 Ü z���ä�ö â �kC�476�476`WYHKE3254eHKJI6�2a4E2%8Y6�4PJMJ�L70M6�254N0Ms76<2%8YLpC=4D47Q:CI6UH�WFW?674N4%0cE7C0ME�2DC78_L7894%0cNP4E2%0MHKE^6N8ÂÓ�678YEIW?8Y6�47E:L`28C78?4N8e0c6¥47E`8FL7C(8d1b48HK9 4tWFHKE32548H7J¾6�2a4E2%8 §â 2DHG4tWFHKE32548H7J¾6�2a4E2%8§È#Jv47sd8YJ�8YLGs�R�4bQ�4E0D4V� ë � §ß]��0c1�28C78?4N8p0M6�4bL70D4N8YWL2\L7894%0cNP4E2%0MHKEt1b48HK9 §â 2DH §ÈÛ3i0�2DCu2DC78�L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FLQ748H¦L76:WL250MH7E ë 4E2�2DC<8�9b4E28WaC §ßÑH¦WYW9674%4N0ME7C^0cEV4uL78?4N0cNP4E2%0MHKE56%8ÂÓ�678FE:W?8E>Xf�C<8�L�4E2a4\6�2a4E2%8�1�H(4�4\WFHKE32548H7J6N2a4n258Ô§â 0c6Z28C78_L70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YLÊC=4D47Q:C §â 0�2D6N8YJO1�47EILÊ2DC78_L�4E2D4m2%4D47E:6Á1�H(489�4E2%0MHKE©1�H(4¥47E`8YL7C(8_1b48HK9 §â2DH §È 3i0K2DCk2DC78¥Jv47sd8YJ�� ë � §ßt�h0M6h28C78¥Õ42 Ü z���ä�ö â �2ÀS9_H(48Q:C<0M689w1b48HK9 §â 28H §È�C(0ON(8YEts�Rk2DC78¥L70D4N8YWL2L78?4N0cNP4E250cHKEd1b48HK9 §â 2DH §ÈÒ3i0K2DC ë 4E2 §ß�>qf�C<8�6%8L2�H71=JM47sd8YJM6�1�H(4B2DC<8�WYH7E�2%48HKJ Ç H�3JC(4847Q:C;0c6128C78?4N8F1�H(4N8C(0cN=8YE´s�RÊ2DC78]6%8L2bHP1�Q74eH�L<6:W92%0MHKE�E�479]8Y6d4PE:Là28C78]9b4n2DWaC78F6_HP1:2DC<8tL<8?4%0ONP4E250cHKE«6%8oÓ+6<8YE:W98Y6?> f�C780ME70K250v4PJ®6�2a4E2%8Z0c6hC(0cN=8YEts�R/2DC78o0cE70�2%0v47JdC(4D4PQ:C]H71v28C78oC(4D4P9�9�4=4?>Õ�Ô�ÖÎÕÖ�×JÖ ¨ ÕÙØ6Ú Ì Ú��#� ¯ × ÜaÞ Õ ô��ð¨ Ün,ïÞ ×JÖ ¨ Õ ôo�6ô ×³Ô , �2¨'ÜWÞëô Ô¾× ¨5��ß Ô Ü Ö ±�Þ ×JÖ ¨ Õ ô Ô76 à Ô Õ á Ô ôr²aâ8L2]�q� ¤¬¨ §â »-��� ë t §�P� D Î ä ª sY8t4�C(48479_9b4=4¥1�H(4�L70c6N2%4%0Ms<6<258FLàC=4D47Q:CI6d47E:L � Q � � �I���q���hsd8]46%892\H71�L78?4N0cNP4E2%0MHKEG6%8ÂÓ�678FE:W?8F6?>jf�C78�254847E:6Á1�H(489�4E250cHKE�6ÁR¦6N258F9}0cE©Õ�2 Ü z��#ä½ö â ��1�H(4 � 0c6:C(0ON(8FE©s�RçV� � � ¤�¨�ê�â �â� � ª 3i0�2DC ê�â � ¤�¨�â ��§h�� G�h§â » ª gI3AC7894%8

ÿ §æWFHKE32a4=0cE:6\4PJMJ@Q�4=0D4e6V� ë � §ßt��6N6:WaC¢2DC�4E2 ë ®ÂÿÑ47EIL�2DC7894%8p0c6u4bL7894%0cNP4E2%0MHKEG6%8oÓ+6<8YE:W98/¶u® �47E:Lt47Em£B®�0 Jé 6N6:WaCu28C�4E2�¶?�#£2� ¤ �\§â D´² �Z� §È��[g

ÿ â ) ¤ « §â/­ ¶ ¤ � §â »/� ZOZcZ � §â � ZcZOZ �¡® � ¯ 0M6o2DC78b6%892hH71A47JcJ�L70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YLcC(4847Q:C:6Z2DC�4n2H�WFW?674i0cE]4_L7894%0ON74n250MH7ETH71 � 47EILÿ 2DC7894%8e0M6547Ec8YL<C(8 ��8 ì 3 î t §â å §È 3i0K2DC9 e� ��8 ì 3 î � ¤ � ë � §ßt�^0ME â á�0O1�47E:L±HKE:JcR¢0O1x28C78?4N8/0M654L78?4N0cNP4E2%0MHKET6N8ÂÓ�678YEIW?8A¶e® � 47E:LG47Ek£B®©0 Jé 6%6IWaCu2DC:4E2�¶?�#£2� ¤ � §â D´² �Z� §È©�V>

f�C78jC=4D47Q:C]9_H(48QIC70M6e9 � t â å â�:<;>= o ì ÚSä � î 0c6�L78oó:E78YLGs�R � � §â � ¤ §â 1�H=4h847WaC §â ® â ) 47E:Lts�R� � � 8 ì 3 î � ¤ §� � 0O1À2DC<85L70�4%8FW92�L78?4N0cNP4E250cHKE�¶?�#£2� ¤ � §â D³² �Z¤ � §È���1b48HK9 §â 28H §È 3i0�28C ë tÔ� §§ �¨å §©p�_ç�� ë �e�0M6hC(0ON(8YEts�R/2DC<8X1�H7JMJMH�3i0cE7C�Q76:6eC:H(6<2�L70M4=C(4D4P9µ0cEGÕ�2 Ü z���ä�ö â �V>

§§�Z ûü

�¨ ýþ §©�Z �ûü§â �¨ � ýþ §È

ʤ=¦

Page 102: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

Ø7Ú Ì ÚÿØ6Ú?� � ¨d,ïÛ�¨ ô Ö�×JÖ ¨ Õ Þ *@� Û Ô ÜJÞ ×JÖ ¨ Õ Þ * ¿ Ô ,ïÞ Õ ×JÖ á¾ô�¨#� Õ�Ö ô × Ü Ö �à ×³Ô ß�¿ �Sô ×³Ô ,Ëôf�C70M6\Q:4=4N2:6:6%8F6O254D4PE:6e1�H(4e9b4n250MH7E�6eR¦6�258Y9_6\1�H(4�2DC78�L<8Y68W94%0cQ<250cHKE�H71B2DC<8�WYHK9_Q?HK6%0K250MH7E�47J=HKQd8?484E250cHKE�47J6%8Y9�47E3250cWY65H71A4GL<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FL±6ÁR�6�258F9#68Qd8YW90°ó�WY4E250cHKE�>mg�H(4¥6%0ME<CKJD8_Q748H¦W?8F686j0ME:6�2a47E:W98Y6Fg�0O0ME�N(8F6N2%0DC�4E2%82S3¬H�L<0còY8?4%8FE32hí�0MEIL:6hH71¬HKQd8?4D4n250MH7E�47J�6%8F9b4PE�2%0MWF6Z28C�4E25L78YQd8YE:L±HKE`28C78p47WL256�4PJ18FE�N�0�48HKEI9e8FE�2?>kf�C78¸M¹ FnIKH ½ y8¶ Q S5F���y ¹a¹G¹ y � H º�½É¸ � ¹�68Qd8YW?0òóA8Y6s28C78©sY8FC�4N+0MH(4pHP1�47E¹0c68HKJM4E258FLÙQ748H¦W?8F686Fg�3AC7894%8^E:H�8FòY8YWL2D6H71o2DC78�8FE�N+0�48HKE:9]8YE32tH¦WYW?6<4?>�_�E:JD0cí=8P28C78 F Q y º�Q S5F���y ¹a¹t¹ y � H º�½Ð¸ � ¹[gh28C�4E2t476e6%6:9]8Y6t4ÂWYH79�Q:J�892%88YE�N+0D48H7E:9e8FE32e0cEà28C78]6%8FE:6%8m2DC�4E2�47JcJ�Q?HK686N0Ms:J�8s8FòY8YW9286�H7E�Q?H(4N286_4=4%8]WYH7E:6%0cL78?4N8YLR28C�4E2_W4PE�H¦WYW9674L7678�28HT47W92%0MHKEI6�H71�HE2DC7894\Q748H¦W?8F686O0cE:6N2D47E:W98Y6O0cEP2DC785L70M6�254N0Ms76<2%8YL�6ÁR¦6N258F9u>oM�H=2DCxgd2DC78j0M6eHKJv4E2%8YL�47E:L2DC78tHKQd8YE´Q748H¦W?8F686_6%8Y9�47E3250cWY6�4=4%8kC(0ON(8FE�s�R�254847E:6e1�H=489�4E250cHKE«6eR¦6N2%8Y9_6?>¹M¾R«WYHK9_Q?HK6%0K250MH7E«H71:28C78HKQY8FE]Q748H¦W?8F686�6%8F9b4PE�2%0MWF6�1�H(4x2DC<8uQ748H¦W?8F686i0ME:6�2a47EIW?8Y6hC=0cN(8FEk0ME/2DC<8uL70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YLsC(48479�9�4=4¾0XC=892@28C78HKQY894D4E2%0MHKE:47JÔ6N8Y9�47E3250MWF6AH71v28C78XL70M6�254N0Ms76<2%8YL]6eR¦6�258Y9m>0^0MJMJ�6:6N2%4D4E2%8p2DC78bWYHKE:W98YQ<286�9�4=0ME:JOR©s�R¢2DC78�L70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YLcC(48479_9b4=4^0cEÂóÀUI479_Q:JD8 ¦ > ¤ 47E:LÊ28C78b6ÁR¦E�ÀWaC748HKE<0$#4n250MH7E�4%8YJM4E250cHKE�0ME_óÀUI479_Q:JD8 ¦ >KÄ(Ä(>vf�C78�Q�4=4N286�H71Y28C78AWYHK9_Q?HK6%0K250MH7E�47J¦HKQY894D4E2%0MHKE:47JI6N8Y9�47E3250MWF6H71v28C78XW476N8X6N256ILIR]68C:H�3AEu0ME�ü�6:s:6N8YWL250MH7E�Ó�> � >|Ó�>|ÓV6N8?4ÁN(8�4P6A47L:L70K250MH7E�47J�8VUI479�QIJD8Y69>f�C78j0c68HKJM4E258FLGQ<48H¦W?8Y6e6�6N8Y9�47E3250cW¥1�H(4A4_Q748H¦W?8F686�0ME:6�2a47EIW?8¥WYHKE:6N0ML789486�47JMJxL<8?4%0ONP4E250cHKE]6%8ÂÓ�678FE:W?8F6O2DC�4n26:6%85Q748H¦W?8F686\Q74eH�L<6:W92%0MHKE:6�H71�28C70M6�0MEI6N2a4PE:W?8¥6N2D4=4N2%0ME7C_3i0�2DCm2DC78¥6N2D4=4N2�Q748H¦L76:WL250cHKE�>hf@H;8YEI6%674N8�2DC�4n23x8�L<8Y68W94%0csY85HKE:JcRs28C78�6N8Y9�47E3250MWF6�H71UHKE78hQ<48H¦W?8Y6e6O0MEI6N2a4PE:W?8PgY2DC<8h6N2D4=4N2�Q748H¦L76:WL250cHKEP0c6�E:H=2�47JcJMH�3x8FL2DHdsY8o6:6N8YLm2S3i0MW?8E>Õ�Ô�ÖÎÕÖ�×JÖ ¨ ÕÙØ6Ú Ì Ú�� Ì°¯ Ö ôY¨ * Þ ×³Ô ßÙÛ7Ü�¨Sá Ô ô´ôeô Ô ,ëÞ ÕÇ×JÖ á¾ôr²W 0ON(8YE�45L<0M6N2%4%0cs76<258FLeC=4D479_9b4E4q�q� ¤ �#�q�A�bÓ®�V�_��ÒxÞ?�bÓ®�e� × Î ä ä � DV° 3i0�28C/�q�A�ÉÓ®� ¤ë¨ �Â�F�bÓ®�L��� ë t §�P� D Î ä , ª47E:L �Â�F�bÓ®�ct_� §§�»ïå §©ã»[��1�H=4s847WaCöÓ ®�ÿ�ö õrëA� >©f�C78FExg:28C78�¸M¹ FnIKH ½ y8¶ Q S�F���y ¹a¹t¹ y � H º�½É¸ � ¹�1�H=42DC78tQ748H¦W?8F686e0ME:6�2a47E:W98u£k® �+ÒÔÞ?�bÓ®��0M6¡C(0cN=8YE�s�R�28C78m2%4D47EI6e1�H(4e9b4E2%0MHKE�6ÁR�6�258F9 ç�� � �h1�H(4�2DC<8�6%8L2� ¤ « ¶ ¤ � §§�» � Ïíì × î� §©ã» D 2� §â � D !� ZOZcZ � ­ ë ´ ®©ÿ 3× �Sàe®�0 Jé ¯ > ʽ:¾ ÞA,ïÛ *�Ô�Ø6Ú � � ¯ Ö ôY¨ * Þ ×´Ô ßÐÛÜ�¨Sá Ô ô´ô/ô Ô ,ïÞ Õ ×JÖ á¾ô�²0=WYHKE:6N0ML7894U4=CK4=0MEZ2DC78�L70M6�254%0cs76<2%8YL�C=4D479_9b4E4\C=0cN(8FEp0MEZ2DC78�ó�UI479_Q:J�8 ¦ > ¤ gn2DC�4E2`WYHKE32D4=0ME:6\2S3¬H�Q748H¦W?8F6860ME:6�2a47E:W98Y6�çjÄd47E:L Ò ÄVH71q2SR¦Qd8:ç 47E:L Ò g�4%8Y6eQY8FW92%0cN(8FJcR=>jf�C78�0c68HKJM4E258FL�Q74eH�W98Y686u6N8Y9�47E3250cWY6\H71B28C78Q748H¦W?8F686x0cE:6N2D47E:W98®çjÄ:0M6�6eC:H�3AE/0MEegÀ0DC=674%8 ¦ >KÄ & HKE]28C78�JD8F1É2ÁÀSC�4PE:L�6N0ML78E>qf�C78�óAC(674N8�6eC:H�3A6x2DC78�L�4E2D4JD8FN=8YJUHP1128C78p254847E:6Á1�H(489�4E250cHKE�6ÁR¦6N258F9Gg{28C�4E2X4=4N8p2DC78VL<8?4%0ONP4E250cHKE�6%8oÓ�678YE:W98Y69>V0SE¢28C78�óA4e6N2X6N2%8YQxgx3X847Q:Q:JOR[28C78p6�2a4=4�2�Q74eH�L76IW9250cHKE·�Â�F��ç\�¥HKE`2DC78/0cE70�2%0v47J�6�2a4E2%8bH71h28C78/0c68HKJM4E258FL±Q74eH�W98Y686h6%8Y9�47E3250cWY6h1�H=4ç�Ä]�É2DC�4E2w0M6�2DC78j8Y9_Q<2SRtL70M6�254N0Ms76<2%8YL�C=4D47Q:CÔg®6N0ME:W98�2DC785JD8[1É2eÀSC:47E:L�6N0ML785H71�28C78�6N2D4=4N2�Q748H¦L76:WL250cHKEP0c68Y9_Q<2SRI�L>xf�C<0M6�6N258FQ�W94%84n258Y6�2DC78Z0MEI6N2a4PE:W?8Æç�Ä=>X�`8h4=4N85EIH=2�47s:JD8^28H�W94%84n258¥9�H(4N8o0ME:6�2a47E:W98Y6Fg?6N0ME:W982DC78�6N2a4E4N2UQ<48H¦L76:W92%0MHKEhW47E:EIH=2Usd8�47QIQ:JD0�8YL�4EC�4=0ME�>\f�C<8YExg�HKEIJcRo2DC78�Q748H¦L76:WL250cHKE ë 0c6U47QIQ:JD0cW47s:J�87g�2DC�4n2W?4%8Y4E258F6A4�E78F3zQ?H(4N2�47E:LTL78FJD892%8Y6�HKE<8O8YJ�8Y9]8YE32�H71{28C78uJMH¦W47J?6N2D4E258�H717ç�Ä(>�é�H�3Xg<2DC78uQ<48H¦L76:W92%0MHKEI6 ë47E:L ë í 4=4%8h47Q:Q:J�0MWY47s:JD8E> Ø 1É25894u47Q:QIJD0MWY4E250cHKE]H71q2DC<8hQ74eH�L76IW9250cHKE ë 4N8Y6eQ�> ë í g®3X8�W4PE:E:H=2\47Q:Q:JOR�4PE�RQ748H¦L76:WL250MH7Exg:6%0cE:W?8^28C78?4N8¥LIH�8F6�EIH=2�8LU�0M6�2�47Eu8FJD8F9e8FE�2i0cEs2DC78XJMH¦W4PJÔ6N2D4E258XH71Îç�Ä(>0SE�2DC78X254D4PE:6e1�H(4e9b4n250MH7E56ÁR�6�258F9­1�H(4 Ò Ä�HKEj2DC78@4N0DCKC32ÁÀSC�47EILh6%0cL78¬HP1A2DC78<óAC(674N87g(2DC<8¬6N2D4=4N2`Q748H¦L76:WL250cHKE�´�F� Ò �:0M6Ró7486N28JcR�47Q:Q:J�0D8YL�28HTW?4N84E2%8¡28C78�0MEI6N2a4PE:W?8 Ò Ä(>�ðw8?4N84P1É2%8?4Fg�2DC78dQ74eH�W98Y686XQ74eH�L<6:W92%0MHKE ì WY47EsY8d47QIQ:JD0�8YL�0ME ó�E70�2%8YJOR�H71É2%8YE�2DH]W94%84n258dE78F3ë8YJ�8Y9]8YE32D6o0ME�28C78dJMH¦W47J�6N2D4E258VH7112DC<8_Q<48H¦W?8Y6e6 Ò Ä_47E:L2DC78XQ?H(4N2?>f�C78AHKQY8FEdQ748H¦W?8F686�6%8F9b47E32%0MWY6�HP1x4uQ74eH�W98Y686B0cE:6N2D47E:W?8�WFHKE:6N0ML789486�E:H=2�HKEIJcRZ2DC78AH�3AEdQ748H¦W?8F686¾Q748H¦L76:W�À250MH7E:6YgPs76<2�47LIL70�2%0MHKE�4PJMJcRw2DC78�Q®H=4N2UQ<48H¦L76:W92%0MHKEI6`H71�H=28C78?4�Q748H¦W?8F686q0cE:6N2D47E:W?8F6?>�f�C<8�Q®H=4N2UQ<48H¦L76:W92%0MHKEI6H71U4dQ74eH�W98Y686�0MEI6N2a4PE:W?8¥L78Y6eW?4N0Msd8Z28C78¥47W92%0MHKE:6h28C78XQ748H¦W?8F686�0ME:6�2a47E:W9859�4RTQd8?4e1�H=489ÍHKEs28C785Q?H(4�2D6AH71

¤ �

Page 103: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

A1

A1 B1

B1

B1A1 A1

st(A)

p

p

st(B)

q

p’ q

q

A>B?C�D"EGF H"I�JLK'MONx·QP\¸M¹LRTSVU7½WP ¶YX5Z R � Pa¹a¹�¹LP[�U7º�½Ð¸ � ¹�R ¼ ¸»ºI¹[½\U7º � P ç3J�]^S?P ¼ ½ ¢ ·"U7º ¶ ¹[¸ ¶ PW_�U7º ¶ ¸»ºI¹[½^U7º � P Ò J] Z ¸ Ì ·¦½ ¢ ·"U7º ¶ ¹[¸ ¶ PW_�`a C�FAL�Bc6 a EbBMs�D a FYL_6eR¦6 a FY9cI<ü'BcE:W�FAQ?H�E a 6�4dEGF�N7BM6GBcs:J?F�1�H�E�47JMJ:Q"E8H¦W�FY6e6eBcE:6 a 47E:W�FY6Yg a C"F�Q?H�E a Q"E8H¦L�D:W a BMHKEI61�H�E89 a C"F�Q�4�E a H71 a C�F\Q�EeH�W�FY6e6�47W a BMHKEI6Yg a C�4 a 4�EGF�N7BM6GBcs:J?FA1�H�E a C�F�FYE�N7B?E8H7E:9fFFE a I�021=3eFuWYHKE:6bBML�F�E a C�FQ®H�E a Q"E8H¦L�D:W a BMHKEI6�H71�47JMJ�Q�EeH�W�FY686<BME:6 a 47EIW�FY6>C�BcN�FYEOBcE a C�F¬L�Bc6 a EGBMs"D a FFLOC�E8479�9�4�EFg�3eFgC�F a 4PJMJ�Q?HK686bBMs:J�F47W a BMHKE:6 a C:4 a WY47ETH�WFW�D�E�HKEpQ?H�E a 6�IU0�WFHKJMJ�FYW a 47JcJ?Q?H�E a Q�EeH�L"D:W a BMHKE:6�H71k4hL"BM6 a EGBcs�D a FFL�C�E8479�9�4�E�BcET46GF a g:W4PJMJ?FFL a C"F X R Z ½ehPa·"U ¡ ¸\R Z H71 a C"F\L�BM6 a EbBMs�D a FYLiC�E8479_9b4�E�I>j�C�FuQ?H�E a skFFC�4N7BMH�E�HP1`4�L"BM6 a EGBcs�D a FFLC�ED479_9�4�E�WY47E©s5F�6GF�FYE§476 a C"F�9b4�l"Bc9b4PJ�FFE�N'B�E8HKEI9fFFE a BcE a C"F�6GFFE:6GF a C:4 a F4PWaC§4PW a BcHKE�HKE^4pQ?H�E aBMEt4_W�D�EGEbFYE a FFE�N'B�E8HKEI9fFFE a H71U4_Q"E8H¦W�FY6e6�BcE:6 a 47E:W�F5WY47EGs5FX68Q5FYW�B°óQFFL�s�RG4dQ?H�E a Q"E8H¦L�D:W a BMHKEcBME a C�FQ®H�E a s5FYC�4N7BMH�E�Imj�C�F�EGFpL:H7FY6hE:H a Fnl"Bc6 a 4PW a BcHKE:65HKE«Q®H�E a 6Fg a C:4 a W4PE:E:H a s5Fp6eQkFFW�B°ó�FYL«s�R«4�Q?H�E aQ�E8H¦L�D:W a BMH7EtHP1 a C�FXQ®H�E a skFFC�4N7BMH�E�I0oBML�FFE a Bc1»R�Q®H�E a Q�E8H¦L�D:W a BMH7E:6XH71�Q�EeH�W�FY6e6hQ�EeH�L�DIW a BcHKE:6 a C:4 a 4�EGF�EGFFJv4 a FYL*s�R a C�F_6eR¦E:WaC�EeHKE�B$#Y4 a BcHKEEGFYJM4 a BcHKExg�6GBMEIW�FpEGFYJM4 a FFLïQ�EeH�W�FY6e6�Q�EeH�L�DIW a BcHKE:6]C�4N�F a C�F§6D479�F^Q®H�E a Q�E8H¦L�D:W a BMH7Eï47EILï9_H�N�F±4 aa C�F�6D479�F a BM9�F�I�j�C�F�EbFF1�H�EbF7g a C�F�B�E3F[òqFFW a H7E a C�FfFYE�N7B?EeHKE:9�FYE a BM6¥WYH79�Q:J�F a FYJcR^L"FY68W�EGBcskFFLÂs�R a C�FBML�FFE a B°óQFFL]Q®H�E a Q�E8H¦L�D:W a BcHKErIÕ�Ô�ÖÎÕÖ�×JÖ ¨ ÕÙØ6Ú�sSÚ���Ø ¯qÛ�¨'Ü × � Ô¦� Þ¾± Ö ¨'Üt�2¨'Ü�Þ-ß Ö ô × Ü Ö �à ×³Ô ßÙôo�6ô ׳Ô7u ôÂÛ Ô á Ö»Ö áþÞ ×³Ö ¨ Õ ²v BON�FYE±4GL�Bc6 a EGBMs"D a FFL§6ÁR�6 a FF9ã6eQkFFW�B°ó:W4 a BMHKE9w � ÿyx ��z�ö â|{�}�}@{n~ Φ�u3�B a C ~ Î Q ÿ<��� ú ÿ<����476L�Foó�E"FYL�BME:!oFoó:E�B a BMHKE�H"I��"IVJ��'I>��F a ÿ<�����d�Q�\skF a C�F�6GF a ÿ<���u1É47W a H�EGB°#�FYLds�R a C�F�FÂÓ�D�BONP47J?FFE:W�F�EbFYJv4 a BMH7E� Î9BcE:L�D:W�FYL�s�R ~ Î�g a C�F X R Z ½OhPa·"U ¡ ¸\R Z ¼ R Z w � ÿ�BM6 a C�Ftÿ��T�7�d�Q��ÀWBcE:L�Fnl"FFL�6bF a H71\Q"E8H¦L�D:W a BMHKEI6�8ô ë õ M ë'û�� �F�7�§¾���¨^�å ë'û�� �F���©X�8��� D���� äL�����W� � gI3AC"F�EGF ���� x ��5� ä X ¨2Ïíì��¿þî 1�H�E ë M�� �� M@�§ å �©X�I Ê� � Þ u Û<� Ô�Ø6Ú � s ¯qÛ�¨'Ü × � Ô¦� Þ¾± Ö ¨'ÜK²j�C�FXQ®H�E a Q�E8H¦L�D:W a BcHKE:6�H71 a C�FXL�Bc6 a EGBMs"D a FFLcC�ED479_9b4dEgBME]ó>lI479_Q:J?FYH"I ¤ 4�EbFu68C:H�3AE�BcEcA>B?C�D"EGFoH�IVJ� 'I!oD�F a H a C"F�6eR¦E:WaC"E8HKE�B°#4 a BMHKEtEGFYJM4 a BcHKE�BMEpó>lI479_Q:J?F¡H�IVJ�JKg a C�F�Q®H�E a skFFC�4N'BcH�E¬WFHKE:6bBM6 a 6¬H71 a C�F a C�EGF�FQ®H�E a Q"E8H¦L�D:W a BMHKEI6 BME�A>B?C�D�EGF�H�IVJ��'I¡j�C�F�Q?H�E a Q�E8H¦L�D:W a BMH7E:6Vô ë õ 47E:L�ô �Â�F� Ò � õ EbFY68QqI�ô ë�� õ 47E:L´ô ì õ 4�EbFBML�FFE a B°óQFFLxg:6bBME:W�F ë ~ Îý�Â�F� Ò �@EGFF68QrI ë"� ~ Î ì I ÊA�H�E a C"F�HKQkFFEVQ�E8H¦W�FF686�6GFF9b4PE a BMWF6UH71®4�Q�EeH�W�FY686¢BcE:6 a 47E:W�FPg�0kWYHKE:6bBML�F�E�L�F�EbBcNP4 a BMHKE56GFÂÓ�D�FFE:W�FF6�6 a 4�E a BcE�C4 a�a C�F£FY9_Q a R�C�E847Q:CcD:6GBcE�C a C�FXQ�EeH�W�FY686�Q�E8H¦L�D:W a BcHKE:6AH71 a C�F¥Q�E8H¦W�FF686¡BME:6 a 47EIW�F547E:LtQ®H�E a Q�E8H¦L�D:W�Àa BMH7E:6�H71 a C�FAQ®H�E a skFFC�4N7BMH�E�IU0`L:H¥E:H a WFHKE:6GBcL�F�E a C�F�Q?H�E a Q�E8H¦L�D:W a BMH7E:6�H71 a C�FAQ�E8H¦W�FF686¬Q"E8H¦L�D:W a BMHKEI6H71 a C�F3BcE:6 a 47E:W�F7g�6GBcE:W�F a C�F¥WYH79�Q:J�F a F¥Q"E8H¦W�FY6e6�Q�EeH�L"D:W a BMHKEtW47EGskF547Q:QIJ?B?FFL a H�47WaC�B?F[N�F a C�F�FFòkFYW a 6

¤ K

Page 104: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

[st(A)] [p]=[st(B)] [p’]=[q]

A>B?C�D�EGFoH"I�J��7M�Nx·QP X R Z ½ X5Z R ¶ ¿Q¤[½Ð¸\RrºI¹¥R ¼ ½»·QP X R Z ½@hPa·"U ¡ ¸\R Z `HKE a C�FTQ?H�E a 6�I*0SE´47L:L�B a BcHKExgU0¥L:H©E:H a WYHKE:6bBML�F�E a C�FTQ?H�E a Q�E8H¦L�D:W a BcHKE:6�H71�Q�EeH�W�FY6e6_Q"E8H¦L�D:W a BMHKEI6H71�H a C�F�E5Q�E8H¦W�FF6863BME:6 a 47E:W�FY6Fg a C:4 a C:4�N�F a Hts5Fb6eR¦E:WaC"E8HKE�B°#�FFL±3�B a CÂ4GQ"E8H¦W�FY6e6hQ�EeH�L"D:W a BMHKE*H71 a C�FBME:6 a 47E:W�F7g:6bBME:W�Fu6eR¦E:WaC�EeHKE�B°#�FYLGQ�E8H¦L�D:W a BcHKE:6�C�4N�F a C�Fu6D4P9fF\Q?H�E a Q�E8H¦L�D:W a BcHKE]47E:L]C�4N�F a HVskFX47Q¦ÀQ:J?B�FYL§4 aOa C�Fb68479fF a Bc9fFdI�j�C�FtEbFY9�4�BME�BcE�CtQ®H�E a Q"E8H¦L�D:W a BMHKEI65H71 a C�F�Q®H�E a s5FYC�4N7BMH�E56eQkFFW�Bc1»R a C�FFFòkFYW a 6\HKE©Q?H�E a 6Yg a C�4 a W47EIE:H a s5F�9_H�L"FYJ?FFL�s�R a C�F�Q"E8H¦W�FY6e6\Q�EeH�L�DIW a BcHKE:6�H71 a C�FOBME:6 a 47E:W�F�I\0�WY47JMJa C�Bc6�6GF a H71�Q?H�E a Q�EeH�L�DIW a BcHKE:6 a C�F Z P[tRr½WP X R Z ½ghPa·"U ¡ ¸\R Z H71 a C�F£BcE:6 a 47E:W�FdI0�6 a 4�E a¡a C�FuL�F�EGBcNP4 a BMHKET6bFÂÓ�D�FFE:W�FF6u4 a�a C"FYFY9_Q a RiC�E847Q:Cxg:6bBME:W�F¥4dQ"E8H¦W�FY6e6�BcE:6 a 47E:W�FuC�476AE:H a E�FFW�FF6ÁÀ6D4�EbBMJcR5¦ R a HuskF�W�EGFY4 a FFLfBcE a C�F ó�E86 a 6 a FYQÔg�s�D a W4PE_s5F�W�EbF4 a FYL�BME�F[N�F�EeRdQ?HK686bBMs:J�F�Q®H�E a FFE�N7B�E8HKE:9�FYE a g3AC�F�EbF a C"F�E�FFW�FF686D4dEeR�Q®H�E a 6�1�H�E a C�F�Q�EeH�W�FY686�6 a 4�E a Q�E8H¦L�D:W a BcHKE�H¦WYW�D�E�I�j�C"BM6�1É47W a BM6¾4¥W�EGDIW�Bv4PJ�Q®H�BcE a1�H�E\L�FF68W�EbBMs�BcE�C a C"FVWYHK9_Q®H76GB a BMHKE:47J�H7QkF�ED4 a BMHKE�4PJ�6bFY9�47E a BMWF6\1�H�Eu4pL�Bc6 a EGBMs"D a FFL©6eR¦6 a FY9tgk3AC"F�EGF a C�Fa HKQ?HKJMH�C7RpWY47E�WaC�4PE�C�F¥LIR¦E�479�BMW4PJMJcR�Ie§�D:6 a 476�BME a C�F¥W4P6GF¥H71 a C�F3Bc68HKJM4 a FFL]Q�E8H¦W�FF686�6bFY9�47E a BcWY6Yg a C�F6 a 4dE a Q�E8H¦L�D:W a BcHKE^W47E*skF_47QIQ:J?B�FYL*4 a 9�H76 a HKE:W�F�IbâGH�EbFYH�N�F�EYg>FY47WaC±Q"E8H¦W�FY6e65Q"E8H¦L�D:W a BMHKEÔg a C�4 a Bc66eR¦E:WaC�EeHKE�B$#�FYLp3�B a C�456 a 4�E a Q�EeH�L�DIW a BcHKEtBc6¾47JMJcH�3eFYL a H5skF�47Q:QIJ?B?FFLb4 a 9_HK6 a HKEIW�F7g a H¦H�I>j�C"BM6¨BM6¾9�HPÀa BcNP4 a FYLGs�R a C"Fh1É47W a g a C�4 a 6eR¦E:WaC�EeHKE�B$#�FYL^Q�EeH�W�FY686uQ"E8H¦L�D:W a BMHKEI6�C�4N�F a Hp9_H�N�F�4 a a C"F�6D479�F a BM9�F�I021 a C�Fu6 a 4�E a Q"E8H¦L�D:W a BMHKETWY47E]skFX4PQ:Q:J?B�FYLpH7E:JcR�HKE:W�F7g�47Jc68H�FY47WaCGQ"E8H¦W�FY6e6AQ�E8H¦L�D:W a BMH7ET6eR¦E:WaC�EeHKE�B$#�FYL3�B a C a C�FX6 a 4dE a Q�E8H¦L�D:W a BcHKE]W47E]9_H�N�FXHKE:JcRbHKE:W�F�IÕ�Ô�ÖÎÕÖ�×JÖ ¨ ÕÙØ6Ú�sSÚ��#© ¯e¨'Û Ô Õ Û7Ür¨«á Ô ôÂô/ô Ô'u Þ ÕÇ×JÖ á¾ôr²�ªF a w � ÿ x ��z�ö â|{�}�}�{n~ Î��_3�B a C }�} x � }�} �¬«®� { ��­xÞ?�¬«®�e�¯® � ä ä7° Dn± skF�4±L�BM6 a EbBMs�D a FYLÙ6ÁR�6 a FF968Q5FYW�Bòó�W4 a BMH7E±47EIL°�eô ë õ M ���� � � D���� äL����� � � s5F a C�F�Q?H�E a s5FYC:4�N7BcH�Eu1�H�E�w � ÿ�I�j�C�FYEÔg a C"F Z P[tRr½WP X R Z ½hPa·"U ¡ ¸\R Z 1�H�E a C�F¥BcE:6 a 47E:W�F¥² ³·��­xÞ?�¬«®� Bc6oC�BcN�FYE^s�R a C�FV6GF a ©uÿ Ò �¬²S� Q ÿ��T�´��� � 6GD:WaC a C:4 a ô ë õ ³©uÿ Ò �¬²S�oBc1�47E:L§HKE:JcR4Bc1 a C�F�EbFbL:H7FY6¥E:H a Fl'Bc6 a 4tQ�EeH�W�FY6e6hQ�EeH�L�DIW a BcHKE ë 3 ³èÿ 3® HP1 a C�F�BMEI6 a 4PE:W�F�²3�B a C ë 3 ³�ô ë õ Ij�C�FµR X P[º X5Z RL¤�Pa¹a¹�¹LP[�U7º�½É¸\¤a¹_1�H�E a C�F¶BcE:6 a 47E:W�Fm²¶³ ��­xÞ?�·«®�tBM6iC�BON�FYEæs�R a C"F a ED47EI6e1�H�Ee9b4 a BMHKE6eR¦6 a FY9 � � �¸²2�ex çV�¸wT�¬1�H�E a C�Fh6bF a H71�L�F�EGBON74 a BMH7Et6bFÂÓ�D�FFE:W�FF63w¹x»ºJ¶�x � î D 2� �â � D !� �â � ZOZcZ � � ë�¼ ³ÿ 3® U�©uÿ Ò �¸²2� { àm³�0 J飽�gx6GD:WaC a C�4 a 1�H�EX47JcJ¶¶³¾w�gS¶?� � � xÒ���â � � Ï� �È � ��47E:L>¶?�cà¦��x ���â ¼ � Ï� �È ¼ �BM9_Q:J?B�FY6 � x´à�BO17�Â�¢x��Â� 3 �¬«®�eBc6 a C"F\6 a 4�E a Q"E8H¦L�D:W a BMHKEbH71 a C�F BME:6 a 47E:W�Fo²8g��Â�¢x ë ³©ÿ 3® BM6�45Q�E8H¦W�FF686Q�E8H¦L�D:W a BMH7E�H71 ² a C�4 a C�476 a H§skFt6eR¦E:WaC�EeHKE�B°#�FYL°3�B a C�4§6 a 4�E a Q�EeH�L"D:W a BMHKE´H71u4PE:H a C"F�E�BME:6 a 47E:W�F࿳ ��­xÞ?�¸ÀI� { ÀÁ³ïÿ�ö¡À ëQ g<B�IÃFdI ë � Î-�Â� ¼ �¬À:��g`H�E��´�3x ô ë õ ³æ©uÿ Ò �¸²2��Bc6h4�Q?H�E a Q�EeH�L"D:W a BMHKE§H71�4Q�E8H¦W�FF686\Q�EeH�L"D:W a BMHKE ë a C�4 a C�476 a Hbs5F�6ÁR�EIWaC�E8HKE"B$#�FFL©3�B a C�4b6 a 4�E a Q�E8H¦L�D:W a BcHKExg5B\IÄF�I ë � Î��Â� ¼ �¸ÀI�IÊ� � Þ u Û<� Ô�Ø6Ú � Ø ¯e¨'Û Ô Õ ÛÜ�¨Sá Ô ô´ô/ô Ô7u Þ ÕÇ×³Ö á¾ôr²Å9FpWFHKE:6bBML�F�EV4�C�4�BcE a C"FpL�BM6 a EbBMs�D a FYLÁC�ED479_9b4dE3BcE«ó>l:4P9�Q:J�FtH�I ¤ ¦¨B a 6hQ?H�E a skFFC�4N'BcH�E�Bc6OC�BON�FYE�BcEóÆlI479_Q:J�FcH"I�JL�'I°é�H7E�FGHP1 a C"FGQ?H�E a Q�EeH�L�DIW a BcHKE:6|BME a C"FGQ?H�E a s5FYC�4N7BMH�EfBc6�BcE a C�FcEGFY9_H a FtQ?H�E askFFC�4N'BcH�E]H71 a C�FpBME:6 a 47EIW�F>çOJKg�6GBMEIW�F¶F47WaCzQ®H�E a Q�E8H¦L�D:W a BcHKEÇBME a C�F*Q?H�E a s5FYC�4N7BMH�EcBc6]4´Q?H�E aQ�E8H¦L�D:W a BMH7EçH71X4*Q�E8H¦W�FF686pQ"E8H¦L�D:W a BMHKE�H71�ç3J�IÇj�C�F�EbFF1�H�EbF7g a C"F�HKQ5FYE°Q"E8H¦W�FY6e6p6GFF9b4PE a BMWF6bH71�ç3JD:6GFF6tH7E:JcR a C�F©H�3AEæQ�E8H¦W�FF686]Q�E8H¦L�D:W a BcHKE:6��Â�F��ç\�[g ë 4PE:L ë�� Iȧ�DI6 a 476iBcE a C�F¶BM6eHKJv4 a FYLçQ�E8H¦W�FF6866GFY9�47E a BcWY6Fg a C"FG6 a 4�E a Q"E8H¦L�D:W a BMHKEM�Â�F��ç\�VWY47Eçs5Ft47Q:Q:J�B?FFLç4 a 9_HK6 a H7E:W�FdIèâGH�EbFYH�N�F�EYg�6bBME:W�F a C�FQ�E8H¦W�FF686AQ�E8H¦L�D:W a BcHKE ë BM6�6ÁR�EIWaC�E8HKE"B$#�FFLG3�B a C a C"Fu6 a 4dE a Q�EeH�L�DIW a BcHKE½�Â�F� Ò ��g�47Jc68H ë W47E]s5FX47Q:Q:J�B?FFL

¤ �

Page 105: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

4 a 9�H76 a HKE:W�F�I�j�C�F�EGF[1�H�EGFPg a C�FAHKQ5FYE_Q�E8H¦W�FF686¾6GFY9�47E a BcWY6�H71 a C�F�BcE:6 a 47E:W�F�ç3J�H7E a C�FAJ?FF1 a ÀSC�4PE:LV6GBcL�FH71rA<B?C�D�EbF@H�IVJLÉoBM6�EbFY6 a EGBcW a FYLd3�B a C|EbFY68Q5FYW a¢a H a C�F�Bc68HKJM4 a FFLVQ�E8H¦W�FF686�6GFF9b47E a BMWY6¢BcE|A>B?C�D"EGF@H�IVJLK"I>j�C�F

A1

A1 B1

A1

B1

B1

B1

q

q

B1

B1

B1

q

q

B1

B1

B1

st(A)

p

[st(A)]

st(B)

p’

st(B)

[st(A)]

q

q

q

[st(A)]

q

q

A>B�C�D�EbFoH�IVJLÉ"M�Nx·QP¥R X P[º X5Z RL¤�Pa¹a¹\¹LP[�U7º�½É¸\¤a¹ ¼ R Z çOJ4]^S?P ¼ ½ ¢ ·"U7º ¶ ¹[¸ ¶ PW_�U7º ¶AÒ Jm] Z ¸ Ì ·¦½ ¢ ·"U7º ¶ ¹[¸ ¶ PW_�`EGFY9_H a F5Q?H�E a s5FYC�4N7BMH�E�H71 a C�F5Q�E8H¦W�FF686oBcE:6 a 47E:W�F Ò J5WYHKE a 4dBME:6 a C�F5Q®H�E a Q�E8H¦L�D:W a BMH7E«ô �´�F��çOJ�� õ g5B\IÄF�Ia C�F\H7QkFFETQ�E8H¦W�FF686A6GFF9b47E a BMWY6¬H71 Ò JKg�68C:H�3AEtHKE a C�F EGB?C7C a ÀSC�4PE:Lp6GBcL�F\H71<A>B�C�D�EbF�H�IVJLÉIg'BM6@C�FYE�F�ED4 a FYLs�R a C"F�Q�E8H¦L�D:W a BcHKE:6"�Â�F� Ò � { ì 47E:L]ô �Â�F��ç\� õ IÆj�C�F�Q�EeH�L"D:W a BMHKE:6��´�F� Ò ��4PE:Ltô �Â�F��çu� õ W47EVs5F�4PQ:Q:J?B�FYLV4 a9�HK6 a HKE:W�F�I�j�C�F�EGFF1�H�EGF7g a C"F�H7QkFFE�Q�EeH�W�FY6e6�6bFY9�47E a BMWF6�L�BcòkF�Ee6U1¬E8HK9 a C�F�BM6eHKJv4 a FYLVQ�EeH�W�FY6e6�6bFY9�47E a BMWF6H71 Ò J3BcEÊA<B?C�D�EbFYH�IVJLK�BcE]6GD:WaC�4d3¬4RKg a C�4 a BcEt47E�4dE8s�B a ED4dEeRp6 a FFQ�H71 a C�FX6bFÂÓ�D�FYEIW�F�BcEÊA<B?C�D�EbFYH�IVJLKa C�FXQ?H�E a Q�EeH�L"D:W a BMHKE§ô �´�F��çu� õ W47EtskFX4PQ:Q:J?B�FYL]HKE:W�F�I Êj�C�F�ó>lI479_Q:J?F¬Ó'IVJLK�H71 ³ C�47Q a F�E�ÓA68C:H�3A6UQ:4�E a 6�H71 a C�F�HKQkFFEhQ�EeH�W�FY6e6U6GFF9b47E a BMWY6k1�H�E�EGF[N'Bc6GBcHKE�4�EeWaC�BcN�FBME:6 a 47E:W�FY6AH71�H�D�EAW4P6GFX6 a D:LIR�Ij�C�FVHKQ5F�ED4 a BMH7E�47J@6GFY9�47E a BcWY6uH71¾4pL"BM6 a EGBcs�D a FFL©6eR¦6 a FY9ËC�BON�FFE©s�R�4pL�BM6 a EbBMs�D a FYL©6ÁR�6 a FF9 68Q5FYW�B°ó�WY4rÀa BMH7E4BM6�WYHK9_Q®H76GFYL©s�R a C�FhHKQkFFE©Q�E8H¦W�FF686u6bFY9�47E a BMWF6\H71 a C�F�Q�EeH�W�FY686YBcE:6 a 47E:W�FY6YBME a C�F�L"BM6 a EGBcs�D a FFLC�ED479_9�4�E�Iªj�C�F�WFHK9�Q?HK6bB a BcHKE a 47í�FF6�Q:Jv47W�F�H�N�F�E�47E_4�D'l'BMJ�Bv4�EÁR a ED4PE:6e1�H�Ee9b4 a BMH7Eh6eR¦6 a FY9Ú476�Fl�Q:JM4�BME�FFLBME�!oF ó�E�B a BMHKEÊH�IÃ�"IåÓ7J�I£j�C�BM6u4dD'l'BMJ?BM4�EeR a ED47EI6e1�H�Ee9b4 a BMHKEG6eR¦6 a FY9ÌBc6 C�FFE�F�E84 a FFL^s�R a C�FhQ®H�E a s5FYC�4N�ÀBMH�EuH71 a C"F�L�Bc6 a EGBMs"D a FFL*6ÁR¦6 a FF9 68Q5FYW�Bòó�W4 a BMH7E±47EILÍEbFYQ�EbFY6GFFE a 6 a C�FdskFFC�4N7BMH�EXHKE a C�F_Q?H�E a 6¥HP1 a C�FL�BM6 a EGBcs�D a FYL]6eR¦6 a FY9cI¾ó¾4PWaCGHKQ5FYEtQ�EeH�W�FY686A6bFY9�47E a BMWF6�EGFY6 a EbBMW a FYL a H a C�FXQ®H�E a 6�Bc6 a C�FFEÊEbFYQ�EbFY6GFFE a FYLBME a H a C"F¥Q?H�E a�a ED4PE:6e1�H�Ee9b4 a BMH7Ep6eR¦6 a FY9cIÕ�Ô�ÖÎÕÖ�×JÖ ¨ ÕÙØ6Ú�sSÚ��#Î ¯qÛ�¨'Ü ×:× ÜJÞ Õ ô��2¨'Ü u Þ ×JÖ ¨ Õ ôo�6ô ׳Ô7u ²v BON�FYE±4GL�Bc6 a EGBMs"D a FFL±6eR¦6 a FY9ã68Q5FYW�B°ó�WY4 a BcHKEÁw � ÿÏx �¸z½ö â�{�}�}@{n~ Φ��g a C"F X R Z ½�½ Z U7ºI¹ ¼ R Z [�U7½É¸\Rrº¹Ð�¹[½WP[ 1�H�E@w � ÿÑBc6 a C"F a E847E:6Á1�H�E89�4 a BcHKE_6eR¦6 a FY9Íÿ û�� �F�¸w � ÿh�Æx çV��wp��1�H�E a C�F�6GF a H71kL�F�EbBcNP4 a BMHKE:6wyxÒºJ¶tx � î � D 2 �� �â � � D ! �� �â � � DnÓ��� ZOZcZ � � ô ë 3 õ ³§ÿ<������� � { ²@³*0 JéY½�g?3AC"F�EGFp�8ô ë õ M ���� �n� D���� äL�����W� � Bc6 a C�FhQ?H�E askFFC�4N'BcH�E�1�H�E�w � ÿ|I Ê� � Þ u Û<� Ô�Ø6Ú � © ¯qÛ�¨'Ü ×/× ÜaÞ Õ ô��ð¨ Ü u Þ ×JÖ ¨ Õ ôo�6ô ׳Ô7u ²Å9F�D:6GF a C�F_Q?H�E a Q�EeH�L�DIW a BcHKE:6bô �Â�F��çu� õ { ô �Â�F� Ò � õ 4PE:LÙô ì õ H71 a C�F_Q?H�E a s5FYC�4N7BMH�E�BME§ó>lI479�QIJ?F|H�IVJL�a H©WYH7E:6 a EGD:W a¥a C�FpQ?H�E a�a E847E:6e1�H�E89�4 a BcHKE±6ÁR�6 a FF9#1�H�E a C�FpL�Bc6 a EbBMs�D a FYL�C�ED479_9b4dE3BcE«ó>l:4P9�Q:J�F�H�I ¤

¤ É

Page 106: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

47E:L a C�F¥6eR¦E:WaC�EeHKE�B$#Y4 a BcHKE�EbFYJM4 a BcHKE�BME�ó>lI479_Q:J?F£H�IVJ�J�Igj�C�FhQ?H�E a�a ED47E:6Á1�H�E89�4 a BMHKE]6eR¦6 a FY9#�Ð4_Q�4�E aH71a��BM6T68CIH�3AEz4 a�a C�F a HKQÙHP1 a C�F¶A>B?C�D�EGF4H"I�J ¤ I 0SEèWYHKE a ED476 aia H a C�F©H7QkFFEæQ"E8H¦W�FY6e6]6GFY9�47E a BcWY6Fg

A1

A1

A1

st(A)

p

p’

Open Process Semantics A1

B1

B1

B1

B1

q

q

B1

B1

B1

B1

B1

Open Process Semantics B1[st(A)]

st(B)

st(B)

[st(A)]

q

q

q

[st(A)]

q

q q

q

B1

Port Transformation System

[q]

[q]

[st(A)]

[q]

[q]

[st(A)]

[q]

[q]

[st(B)]

[q]

[st(A)]

[st(B)]

[q]

[q]

[st(B)]

[st(A)]

[st(B)]

[st(B)] [st(A)]

A>B?C�D�EGFoH"I�J ¤ M�Nx·QP X R Z ½�½ Z U7ºI¹ ¼ R Z [�U7½É¸\RrºG¹Ð�¹[½¯P[�`a�Ô F�ÕkÖ�E a Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù�Ú3ÖdÛ@Ú a�Ü E a Õ�EbÖ'×�D"Ø a B�Ö�Ù�Ú Ü EGF Ü Õ�Õ"Ý?B?F�× Ü Ú3Ö�Û a F�Ù Ü Ú3Õ5Ö�ÚbÚGB?Þ"Ý?F�I�ü'B?Ù�Ø�F aGÔ FfÕ5Ö�E aa E Ü Ù�ÚbÛ¬Ö�Ebß ÜTa B?Ö�Ù¾Ú�à7Ú a F�ß B�ÚfD"ÚGF�×áÛ¬Ö�E aGÔ FcØ�Ö�ß�ÕkÖ�ÚGB a B?Ö�Ùqâ aGÔ F Ü ×�×�B a B?Ö�Ù Ü Ý�B?Ù"Û¬Ö�EGß Üda B�Ö�Ù�B?Ú Ü Ý�Ý?ÖLãgF�×Ô F�EbF�I�j Ô F¥Õ5Ö�E aYa E Ü Ù�ÚbÛ¬Ö�Ebß ÜTa B?Ö�Ù�Úbà7Ú a F�ßËEbF�Õ�EbF�ÚbF�Ù a Ú Ü Ý?Ý a�Ô F¥F[òqF�Ø a Ú�Ö�ÙpÕ5Ö�E a Ú�â aGÔQÜda£Ü EGF¥Õ5Ö�ÚGÚbB?Þ�Ý�Fã�B a�Ô�a�Ô F3Õ�EbÖ'Ø�F�ÚbÚ Õ�EbÖ'×�D"Ø a B�Ö�Ù�Ú�Ö�ÛÎçOJ Ü Ù�× Ò J�IgäWÙÊÕ Ü E a B?Ø�D�Ý Ü E�â a�Ô F3Õ5Ö�E a Þ5F ÔQÜ�å B?Ö�E�Ö�ÛÎçOJ Ü Ù�× Ò JB?Ú�EGF�Õ�EGF�ÚGF�Ù a F�×4B�Ù a�Ô F£Õ5Ö�E a�a E Ü Ù�Ú�Û¬Ö�EGß Üda B?Ö�Ù�Ú�à7Ú a F�ßçæ¸B?Ù"×�B?Ø Üda F�×cÞ´à aGÔ F£× Ü Ú Ô F�×ÊÞkÖ�l'F�Ú�èI ÊØ Ú|ßfF�Ù a B?Ö�Ù�F�× Ü Þ5Ö å F�â a�Ô F�Ø�Ö�ßfÕ5Ö�ÚGB a B�Ö�Ù�Ö�Û a�Ô F�Ö�Õ5F�Ù¾Õ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚ�ÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B?Ø�Ú¥Û¬Ö�E¥F Ü Ø Ô B�Ù�Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�FcB�Ùa�Ô Fo×"B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�×iC�E Ü ßfß Ü E a�Ü ídF�Ú�Õ�Ý Ü Ø�FoÖ å F�E a�Ô FoÕkÖ�E a@a E Ü Ù�Ú�Û¬Ö�EGß Üda B?Ö�ÙfÚbà7Ú a F�ßcI¨j Ô FYØ�Ö�ß�ÕkÖ�ÚGB a B?Ö�ÙÔQÜ Ú a Ö�Û¬Ö�Ý?Ý?ÖLã aGÔ F¥Úbà7Ù�Ø Ô EGÖ�Ù�B°# Üda B?Ö�Ù¶EbF�Ý ÜTa B?Ö�Ù�B?Ù aGÔ FOÛ¬Ö�Ý�Ý?ÖLã�B?Ù"CtÚGF�Ù�ÚGFdMYä^Û Ü Ù¶F�×�C�F  MÊ�â D´² �Zå �ÈéÖ�Ûa�Ô F3Ø�Ö�Ù a EbÖ�ݪêQÖLãëC�E Ü Õ Ô Ö�Û aGÔ FOÖ�Õ5F�ÙÊÕ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚoÚbF�ß Ü Ù a B�Ø�Ú B�Ú�ß Ü Õ�Õ5F�×�Ö�Ù Ü Ù�F�×�C�F Â�� M��â � � D � � ² �Z �å �È �B?Ù a�Ô FfÕkÖ�E a Ø�Ö�Ù a EbÖ�Ý�êQÖLãÈC�E Ü Õ ÔÍa�Ô F�Ù ë ³­ô ë�� õ â<B?ÙpÕ Ü E a B?Ø�D�Ý Ü Ebô ë�� õ B�Ú aGÔ FtÕ5Ö�E a Õ"EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�ÙÍÖ�Û ë IâÊÖ�EGF�Ö å F�E�â a�Ô F�ÕkÖ�E a Ú Ü Ù�×ÊB a Ú�Ý?Ö7Ø Ü ÝqÚ a�Üda F�Ú�B�Ù a�Ô F£×�B�Ú a EbB?Þ�D a F�×cC�E Ü Õ Ô ÚÇ�â Ü Ù�×ì�â � EbF�ÚbÕrI4�È Ü Ù�×í�È �ÔQÜ�å F a Ö|Þ5F a�Ô F£Ú Ü ßfFdâ�B\IÄF�I ë'û�� ��æ��â è�x �â � Ü Ù�× ë'ûT� ��æ��È4è�x �È � I¨äWÙ Ü ×"×�B a B?Ö�Ùrâ'ÚGB�Ù�Ø�F_ô ë�� õ B�Ú a�Ô F�Õ5Ö�E aÕ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù¾ÖdÛ ë â¢ãeFÊEbFÂÓ�D�B?EbF a�ÔQÜdafÜ Ý�ÚGÖ a�Ô FcEbF�Ú a EGB�Ø a F�×¾× Üda�Ü4a E Ü Ù�Ú�Û¬Ö�EGß Üda B?Ö�ÙÁÛ¬EbÖ�ß ë'û�� ��æ �â è a Öë'ûT� ��æ��È�è¢B�Ù aGÔ F Ö�ÕkF�ÙtÕ�EbÖ'Ø�F�ÚGÚeÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B?Ø�ÚeB?Ú a�Ô F Ú Ü ßfF Ü Ú a�Ô F¡× Üda�Ü�a E Ü Ù�Ú�Û¬Ö�EGß Üda B�Ö�Ù¥Û¬EGÖ�ß â � a Ö�È �B?Ù aGÔ FOÕ5Ö�E a�a E Ü Ù�Ú�Û¬Ö�EGß Üda B?Ö�ÙcÚbà7Ú a F�ßìÕkF�EbÛ¬Ö�EbßfF�×4Ö�Ù a�Ô F3Ú Ü ß�FOF�Ý?F�ß�F�Ù a Ú�âqB�IÃFdI �ß � x �ß D X ¨2Ïíì �¿¾î ã�B aGÔë M#æ �� M@�§ å �©£èI Ø Ý?Ý aGÔ F�ÚbF@Ø�Ö�Ù"×�B a B?Ö�Ù�Ú�F�Ù"ÚGD�EbF a�ÔQÜTa<aGÔ F a E Ü Ù�ÚbB a B?Ö�Ù Â�� Ü Ù"×OB a Ú<× Üda�Ü�a E Ü Ù"ÚbÛ¬Ö�Ebß Üda B?Ö�Ù

î�î

Page 107: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

Ø Ü Ù�ÞkF�F�ß�ÞkF�×�×�F�×tB?Ù a Ö aGÔ F�Ö�Õ5F�Ù�Õ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚ¨ÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B�Ø�Ú¢B?Ù aGÔ F�ÚGF�Ù"ÚGF aGÔQÜda Ö�Ù�ÝVà aGÔ F�Õ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚ¨B?Ù�Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�FÖ'Ø�Ø�D�EbÚ Ü ×�×�B a B?Ö�Ù Ü Ý?ÝVà�âqÞ"D a£a�Ô F|Õ5Ö�E a Ú Ü Ù�× a�Ô F�B?E a E Ü Ù�Ú�Û¬Ö�EGß Üda B�Ö�Ù Ü EbF|Fl Ü Ø a Ý�à aGÔ F|Ú Ü ß�F Ü Ú£B?Ù aGÔ FÖ�ÕkF�ÙÊÕ"EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚbÚ�ÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B�Ø�Ú�IÕ�Ô�ÖÎÕÖ�×JÖ¬ï ÕÙØ6Ú�sSÚ�� ÅáðPß Ö ô × Ü Ö �à ×³Ô ßÙô Ô7u Þ ÕÇ×JÖ á¾ôTñ�ªF a w ��ò x»æ�z�ö â�{�}�}@{�~�ó è@ÞkF Ü ×�B?Ú a EbB?Þ�D a F�×�Úbà7Ú a F�ßÏÚbÕkF�Ø�B°ó�Ø Üda B?Ö�Ù Ü Ù�×Êô � 渲¸®�è¢x»õ ê�âYö�÷�{�ø�ö�÷�ùÞkF aGÔ F¥Ö�Õ5F�ÙmÕ�EbÖ'Ø�F�ÚbÚYÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B�Ø�ÚoÖdÛ aGÔ F¥B?Ù"Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�F�²¡³�ú�­rû5欫kè�Û¬Ö�E�«¿³ ò ö¡ÀTü  I j Ô F�ÙrârãeF¥×�F óQÙ�Fa�Ô F a E Ü Ù�Ú�Û¬Ö�EGß Üda B�Ö�Ù�ß�Ö�EGÕ Ô B?Úbßyý ö ÷ x»õ^ýQþ ��ÿ ÷ {���� ÿ ÷ ù M ò û���� æ¸w�� ò èå ô���渲�®�è Ü Ú�Û¬Ö�Ý?Ý�Ö�ã�Ú�M

AQÖ�E aGÔ F4Ø�Ö�Ù a EGÖ�Ý�êQÖLãìC�E Ü Õ Ô ß�Ö�EGÕ Ô B?ÚGß ý þ� ÿ ÷ x õ^ý ÿ ÷ { ý � ÿ ÷ ù MOõ âYö�÷�{��Æö�÷d{ ö�÷d{ ²\­k² � ö�÷Lù åõ â|{���{ { ²\­k² � ù B?Ú

� ý � ÿ ÷ M �Æö�÷ å � ×�F óQÙ�F�×�Þ´àý � ÿ ÷ æ ü { �� è�x � æ�� ü � { ��Á� ������� ì �� î è { B�Û#ü�M5æ7�� ��å �� { ç¥æ�ü5èGèg³ ò ö®

æ�ü { �� è { B�Û#ü�³�� ò Ò æ¬²WèÛ¬Ö�E Ü Ý�Ý¢æ ü { �� èg³ �Æö â

� ý ÿ ÷� æ��â è x ü û���� æ��â è�Û¬Ö�E F Ü Ø Ô �â ³ â£ö ÷ Ü Ù�×Íý ÿ ÷� æ  è�M7ü ûT� � æ��â è ��! ÿ ÷ ì �#" �$ îå ü û�� � æ��%4è�Û¬Ö�EF Ü Ø Ô Â M¥�â ì �#" �$ îå �%9I

j Ô F�ßfÖ�EbÕ Ô B�ÚGß � � ÿ ÷ M�& � � ÿ ÷ æ ø èÆå ø�ö B?Ú£×�F óQÙ�F�×9Û¬Ö�E Ü Ý?Ý�ý ÿ ÷ æ��â èO³ â � { �â ³ â£ö ÷ Þ´à aGÔ FB?Ù�Ø�Ý?D�ÚbB?Ö�Ù � � ÿ ÷ æ\ý ÿ ÷ æ��â èbègM�ü ûT� � æ��â è(' å �â I

j Ô F*),+.-�/ Z +¸h102/¯P3)*-LP[�U,4�/5+\¤�-rw6�¡æ¸w�� ò èQÛ¬Ö�Eªw�� ò B�Ú�C�B å F�Ù£Þ´à a�Ô F�Ø�Ö�ß�ÕkÖ�ÚbB a B?Ö�ÙoÖdÛ aGÔ F¢Ö�ÕkF�Ù£Õ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B�Ø�Ú�æ�ô���渲�®�èGè ö �#798#:_ì ® î " ® �1; ä7° � ± å B ÜYaGÔ F a E Ü Ù�ÚbÛ¬Ö�Ebß ÜTa B?Ö�Ù¥ßfÖ�EbÕ Ô B�ÚGß�Ú¡æ\ý ö ÷ è ö �#7981:�ì ® î " ® �#; ä7° � ± I=<ä ÔQÜ�å F a Ö�Ú Ô ÖLã a�ÔQÜTa3aGÔ F a E Ü Ù"ÚbÛ¬Ö�Ebß Üda B?Ö�Ù¶ß�Ö�EGÕ Ô B?ÚbßfÚ Ü EbF�ãeF�Ý�ݨ×"FoóQÙ�F�×râ>ã ÔQÜTa B?Ú£Þ Ü ÚGF�×9Ö�Ù aGÔ FãgF�Ý?Ý¡×�FoóQÙ"B a B�Ö�Ù�ÖdÛ a�Ô FÊØ�Ö�Ù a EbÖ�Ý�êQÖLã�C�E Ü Õ Ô ßfÖ�EbÕ Ô B�ÚGß�Ú�IÇä a Ú�ãgF�Ý?Ý ×"FoóQÙ�B a B�Ö�ÙáÛ¬Ö�Ý�Ý?ÖLã�Ú¥Û¬EGÖ�ß aGÔ FÕ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�ÙcÙ Ü ßfF Ü Ù�× aGÔ F£ß ÜTa Ø Ô C�B å F�Ù�Û¬Ö�E a�Ô F�Ý Ü Þ5F�ÝqÖdÛÆF�×"C�F�Ú�B?Ù aGÔ F£Ø�Ö�Ù a EbÖ�ÝrêQÖLã C�E Ü Õ Ô I> Ü ï Û ï ô Ö�׳ָï Õ·Ø7Ú�s«Ú��@?A�BDC EGFIH�JDELK�M3M#NPO�QRH5S5T BUMVKPBDCWBDT2HXKUH�SYT B MZT []\^EG_ B S�H5S5T Ba`2bdcebgfDh�i*H�JDEjH5F�KPB M�[XT F3OLKUH5S5T BkO�T FXQlJ S.M�OZMæ\ý ö ÷ xÒõ^ýQþ� ÿ ÷ {���� ÿ ÷ ù M ò û�� � æ�w�� ò è�å ô���渲�®LèGè ö �#7981:�ì ® î " ® �#; ä7° � ± KPF�Enm(E�oporqsCUE�_ BDEtCub <v Z RLRswxeàm×�F óQÙ�B a B?Ö�Ù¶Ö�Û a�Ô F a E Ü Ù�Ú�Û¬Ö�EGß Üda B?Ö�Ùmß�Ö�EGÕ Ô B?ÚbßËý ö ÷ x õ\ý þ� ÿ ÷ {�� � ÿ ÷ ù M ò û���� æ¸w�� ò è®å ô���渲�®�èÛ¬Ö�EtF Ü Ø Ô ²�³ ú�­rû5欫kè { « ³ ò ö¡À�ü  â�ý ö ÷ B�ÚfãeF�Ý?ÝzyW×�F óQÙ�F�× B�Û aGÔ F4Ø�Ö�Ù a EGÖ�Ý¡êQÖLãìC�E Ü Õ Ô ßfÖ�EGÕ Ô B�ÚGßý þ� ÿ ÷ x õ\ý ÿ ÷ { ý � ÿ ÷ ù B�Ú�ãeF�Ý?ÝzyW×�F óQÙ�F�×rIoä a Ø Ü ÙmÞ5FOF Ü ÚGB?ÝVàcØ Ô F�Ø�{dF�× a�ÔQÜda ý�� ÿ ÷ B?Ú�ãgF�Ý?ÝzyW×�F óQÙ�F�×qIYj Ô Fß Ü Õ"Õ�B?Ù�CÍý ÿ ÷ Û¬Ö�E|Ù�Ö7×�F�ÚtB?Ú|ãeF�Ý?Ý�×�F óQÙ�F�×râ�ÚGB�Ù�Ø�F a�Ô F�EGFc×�Ö9Ù�Ö a Fnl"B�Ú a�a ãgÖ9Ù�Ö'×"F�ÚfÛ¬Ö�E aGÔ F�Ú Ü ß�F×�B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�×cC�E Ü Õ Ô B?Ù a�Ô F3Ø�Ö�Ù a EGÖ�ݪê�Ö�ã C�E Ü Õ Ô Ö�Û a�Ô F�ÕkÖ�E a¡a E Ü Ù�ÚbÛ¬Ö�Ebß ÜTa B?Ö�ÙiÚbà7Ú a F�ßìÞ�à�×"FoóQÙ�B a B�Ö�ÙÖ�Û Ü|a E Ü Ù�ÚbÛ¬Ö�Ebß ÜTa B?Ö�ÙiÚbà7Ú a F�ßÏÛ¬Ö�E Ü ÚbF a ÖdÛÆ×�F�EGB ådÜda B?Ö�Ù�ÚbFÂÓ�D�F�Ù"Ø�F�Ú�æ¬Ø�Û¯Iu|oF�Û¯IQH"I��"Ig}~}�ènIgj Ô F3ß Ü Õ�Õ�B?Ù"Cý ÿ ÷ Û¬Ö�E£F�×�C�F�ÚOB�Ú�ãeF�Ý�Ý¢×�FoóQÙ"F�×Á×�D"F a Ö a�Ô FfEbFÂÓ�D�B?EbF�ß�F�Ù a â a�ÔQÜTa3aGÔ FfÕ5Ö�E a�a E Ü Ù"ÚbÛ¬Ö�Ebß Üda B?Ö�Ù¶B�Ù aGÔ FÖ�ÕkF�Ù�Õ�EbÖ'Ø�F�ÚGÚ>ÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B�Ø�ÚÆB�Ú aGÔ F@Ú Ü ßfF Ü Ú>B�Ù aGÔ F@Õ5Ö�E a�a E Ü Ù�ÚbÛ¬Ö�EGß Üda B�Ö�Ù3Ú�à7Ú a F�ß Ü Ù"× a�Ô F a E Ü Ù�ÚbÛ¬Ö�EbßfF�×F�Ý?F�ßfF�Ù a ÚªB?Ù a�Ô F¨Õ5Ö�E a Ú Ü EbF aGÔ F¢Ú Ü ß�F Ü Ú�ãeF�Ý?Ý�I<j Ô�Üda�a�Ô F¨Ú Ü ßfF�F�Ý?F�ß�F�Ù a Ú Ü EGF a E Ü Ù�Ú�Û¬Ö�EGß�F�×�B?Ú�F�Ù�ÚGD�EbF�×Þ�à a�Ô F|EGFoÓ�D�B?EbF�ß�F�Ù a£a�ÔQÜdaYaGÔ F|ß ÜTa Ø Ô D�ÚGF�×9B�Ù aGÔ F¥Õ5Ö�E aYa E Ü Ù�Ú�Û¬Ö�EGß Üda B?Ö�ÙmÚ�à'Ú a F�ßËB?Ú a�Ô F�Ú Ü ß�F Ü Úa�Ô F£EGF�Ú a EGB?Ø a B�Ö�Ù�Ö�Û aGÔ F£ß ÜTa Ø Ô B?Ù a�Ô F�Ö�ÕkF�ÙÊÕ�EbÖ'Ø�F�ÚbÚ¡ÚbF�ß Ü Ù a B�Ø�Ú�I �

J#�~�

Page 108: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

� � Þ u Û<� Ô�Ø6Ú5�7Î ðPß Ö ô × Ü ÖY� à���� ßÙô1� u Þ��D� ��á¾ôTñÅ9F|Ø�Ö�Ù�Ú a EGD�Ø a3aGÔ Ff×"B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�׶ÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B�Ø�ÚYÛ¬Ö�E a�Ô F�×"B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�×ÍÚ�à7Ú a F�ßËÚGÕ5F�Ø�B°óQØ Üda B�Ö�ÙÍØ�Ö�Ù a�Ü B�Ù�B?Ù"Ca�Ô F£×�B�Ú a EbB?Þ�D a F�×�C�E Ü ß�ß Ü EgB?Ù��>l Ü ßfÕ�Ý�FYH�I î Ü Ù"× aGÔ F£Úbà7Ù�Ø Ô EbÖ�Ù�B.� Üda B�Ö�ÙcEGF�Ý Üda B�Ö�ÙiB?Ù��>l Ü ß�Õ�Ý?FYH�IVJ�J�Ij Ô Fe×"B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�×£C�E Ü ß�ß Ü ErØ�Ö�Ù a�Ü B?Ù"Ú aGÔ F a ãgÖ�B?Ù�Ú a�Ü Ù"Ø�F�Ú7çOJ Ü Ù�×^�tJ�â a�Ô F�B?E�Ö�ÕkF�Ù3Õ�EbÖ'Ø�F�ÚbÚ<ÚbF�ß Ü Ù a B?Ø�ÚãgF�EGF�B�Ù a EGÖ7×�D�Ø�F�×ÁB�Ùk�>l Ü ßfÕ"Ý?F�H�I�J�H�IÊj Ô F�Ø�Ö�ß�Õ5Ö�ÚGB a B?Ö�ÙpÖdÛ a�Ô FfÖ�Õ5F�ÙÁÕ�EbÖ'Ø�F�ÚbÚ�ÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B?Ø�Ú�Û¬Ö�EAç3JÜ Ù�×j�tJ a�Ü {dF�Ú¡Õ�Ý Ü Ø�FYÖ å F�E a�Ô F�Õ5Ö�E a�a E Ü Ù�ÚbÛ¬Ö�Ebß ÜTa B?Ö�Ù�Úbà7Ú a F�ßÏØ�Ö�Ù�Ú a EGD�Ø a F�×ÊB?ÙcA>B�C�D�EGF H�I�J î I

A1

st(A)

p

p’

(st(A),[st(A)])

(p, st(B))

A1

Distributed Semantics

B1

B1

A1

(p’,q)

A1

A1

[st(A)]

st(B)

q

B1

B1

[q]

[st(B)]

[st(A)]

A1

A>B�C�D�EbFoH�Ig},�"M�N��QP�¤�R�4U-�/ Z 0#¤�/5+\R�49Rsw�/Y�QPn),+.-�/ Z +¸h102/¯P3)V-LP[�U,4�/5+\¤�-�`ä^ÛgãeF�EbF�Ú a EGB�Ø a F Ü Ø Ô ×�B�Ú a EbB?Þ�D a F�׶C�E Ü Õ ÔÍÜ Ù�×pF Ü Ø Ôpa E Ü Ù�ÚbÛ¬Ö�EGß Üda B�Ö�Ù4Ú a F�ÕÍB?Ù a�Ô F|Ö�Õ5F�ÙpÕ�EbÖ'Ø�F�ÚGÚ�ÚGF�yß Ü Ù a B?Ø�Ú a Ö a�Ô F¥ÕkÖ�E a Ú�â�B\IÄF�IkãeF¥×�F�Ý?F a F Ü Ý?Ý<Õ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚYB�Ù�Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�F¥Ù"Ö'×�F�Ú�ârãeF|C�F aYaGÔ F¥ÕkÖ�E a Þ5F ÔQÜ�å B?Ö�EoÖ�Ûa�Ô F|Õ�EbÖ'Ø�F�ÚGÚ�B?Ù"Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�FdIZx¨àmØ�Ö�Ù"Ú a EbD�Ø a B?Ö�ÙpÖ�Û a�Ô F|Õ5Ö�E aYa E Ü Ù"ÚbÛ¬Ö�Ebß Üda B?Ö�Ù�Úbà7Ú a F�ßcâ�ãeFfØ Ü Ù��QÙ�× a�Ô B�ÚÕkÖ�E a ÞkF ÔQÜ�å B�Ö�E¢Ö�Û aGÔ F�Õ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚeB?Ù�Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�F�B�Ù a�Ô F¡ÕkÖ�E a¢a E Ü Ù�ÚbÛ¬Ö�EGß Üda B�Ö�Ù¥Úbà7Ú a F�ßcI�äWÙ�A>B�C�D�EbF�H�I�J î â a�Ô B�ÚB?Ú B�Ù�×�B�Ø Üda F�×�Þ´à a�Ô FO× Ü Ú Ô F�×mÞ5ÖLl'F�Ú�IYj Ô F�B�Ù a F�EbÚGF�Ø a B�Ö�Ù4Ö�Û aGÔ FOÕ5Ö�E a Þ5F ÔQÜ�å B?Ö�E�Ö�Û aGÔ F�B?Ù"Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�F��3JÜ Ù�×��fJ�Û¬Ö�EbßfÚ aGÔ F3Ú a F�Õ�Ú Ö�Û a�Ô F�×�B?Ú a EbB?Þ�D a F�×cÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B?Ø�Ú�I@äWÙ aGÔ F3A>B?C�D"EGF£H�IVJ î â a�Ô F3B�Ù a F�EbÚGF�Ø a B�Ö�Ù�B�Úa�Ô F�Ø�Ö�ß�Õ�Ý?F a F¡ÕkÖ�E a Þ5F Ô�ÜLå B�Ö�EeÖdÛ a�Ô F B?Ù�Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�F��3J�IÆj Ô F�EGF�Û¬Ö�EGF�â Ü Ý?Ý#Ú a F�Õ�ÚgÖ�Û a�Ô F B?Ù"Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�F��3J Ö7Ø�Ø�D�EÜ Ý?ÚbÖ�B?Ù aGÔ F¥×�B�Ú a EbB?Þ�D a F�×�ÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B�Ø�Ú�â�Þ�D a ÚbF å F�E Ü Ý�Ú a F�Õ�ÚYÖ�Û a�Ô FOB?Ù�Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�F��tJ Ü EbF¥EGF�ßfÖ å F�×mÛ¬Ö�E aGÔ F×�B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�×ÁÚbF�ß Ü Ù a B?Ø�Ú�Imj Ô FiEbF�ß�Ö å F�×�Ú a F�Õ�Ú¥Ö�Û*�tJ Ü EbF a�Ô Ö�ÚGFdâ a�ÔQÜda EGF�Õ"EGF�ÚbF�Ù a�Ü Õ�Õ"Ý?B?Ø Üda B�Ö�Ù�Ú�Ö�Û

J#�"J

Page 109: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù�Ú�â a�ÔQÜTagÔQÜ�å F a Ö�Þ5F¡Úbà7Ù�Ø Ô EbÖ�Ù�B.��F�×râQÞ"D a ã Ô F�EGF Ü Ø�Ö�EbEGF�ÚGÕ5Ö�Ù�×�B�Ù�COÚ a F�Õi×"Ö'F�ÚgÙ�Ö a Fl'B�Ú a B�Ù�OJ�IR��Ú¢ßfF�Ù a B?Ö�Ù"F�×râ a�Ô F¡Ú a F�Õ�ÚgÖ�Û a�Ô F�×�B�Ú a EGB?Þ"D a F�×�ÚbF�ß Ü Ù a B�Ø�Ú Ü EGF�C�B å F�ÙfÞ´à a�Ô F�B�Ù a F�EbÚGF�Ø a B�Ö�ÙfÖdÛ aGÔ FÕkÖ�E a Ú a F�Õ�Ú¡B?Ù aGÔ FYÕ5Ö�E a�a E Ü Ù�Ú�Û¬Ö�EGß Üda B?Ö�Ù�Ú�à7Ú a F�ßÊI¢j Ô F£Ý�Ö'Ø Ü Ýk× Üda�Ü Ö�Û a�Ô FYÚ a F�Õ�Ú�B?Ù a�Ô FY×"B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�×Úbà7Ú a F�ß Ü EbFoØ�Ö�Ù�Ú a EGD�Ø a F�×�Þ´à aGÔ FYÕ�D�Ú Ô Ö�D a Ö�Û a�Ô FoØ�Ö�EGEbF�ÚbÕkÖ�Ù"×�B?Ù�C¥× Üda�Ü Ú a�Üda F�Ú�B?Ù a�Ô FoÖ�ÕkF�ÙiÕ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B�Ø�Ú�Iij Ô FtÕ5Ö�E a Ú3B�Ù aGÔ FfÕ5Ö�E a3a E Ü Ù�Ú�Û¬Ö�EGß Üda B?Ö�Ù¶Úbà7Ú a F�ß ÚGF�E å F Ü Ú a�Ô FfC�Ý?D�B�Ù�C�Ö�Þ2�bF�Ø a Ú�IcA>B?CPyD�EGF�H�I�}P��Ú Ô ÖLã�Ú a�Ô F�Ø�Ö�Ù"Ú a EbD�Ø a B?Ö�ÙtÖ�Û a�Ô F Ý?Ö7Ø Ü ÝQ× Üda�Ü Ú a F�Õ�Ú�I¨ä ÔQÜ�å FoÚ Ô ÖLã�ÙiÖ�Ù�Ý�à a�Ô Ö�ÚbF Õ Ü E a ÚeÖ�Û aGÔ FÕkÖ�E a�a E Ü Ù�ÚbÛ¬Ö�EGß Üda B�Ö�Ù¥Úbà7Ú a F�ß Ü Ù�× a�Ô F�Ö�Õ5F�Ù�Õ�EbÖ'Ø�F�ÚGÚ¨ÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B?Ø�ÚeÖ�ÛD�OJ Ü Ù�×V��} a�Ô�ÜdaeÜ EGF�Ù�F�Ø�F�ÚbÚ Ü E�àÛ¬Ö�E a�Ô F£Ø�Ö�Ù�Ú a EGD�Ø a B�Ö�ÙÊÖdÛ aGÔ F£Ý?Ö7Ø Ü Ýk× Üda�Ü Ú a�Üda F�Ú¡Ö�Û aGÔ F a�Ô EbF�F£Ú a F�Õ�Ú¡Ö�Û a�Ô F£×�B�Ú a EGB?Þ"D a F�×cÚbF�ß Ü Ù a B�Ø�Ú�Ij Ô F@×�B�Ú a EbB?Þ�D a F�×OÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B�ØgB�Ù a�Ô F@Fl Ü ß�Õ�Ý?F¨Ø�Ö�Ù�ÚGB�Ú a Ú>Ö�Û a�Ô EbF�F@Ú a F�Õ�Ú�IR� a �QEGÚ a â aGÔ F@Õ�EbÖ'Ø�F�ÚGÚ>B?Ù�Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�F�OJOB�Ú�Ø�EGF Üda F�×rI�j Ô F�Ùqâ a�Ô F3B�Ù�Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�F^�tJ3B?Ú¡Ø�EGF Üda F�× Ü Ù�×ÊB?Ú�Ø�Ö�Ù�Ù�F�Ø a F�×mÞ�à Ü ÕkÖ�E a�a Ö aGÔ F�B?Ù�Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�F�OJ�I<j Ô F@Úbà7Ù�Ø Ô EGÖ�Ù�Bp� Üda B?Ö�ÙOÖ�Û a�Ô FgÕ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚ�Õ�EbÖ'×�D"Ø a B�Ö�Ù�ü Ü Ù�×V� � æ��¥è ÔQÜ ÚÆF�Ù�ÚGD"EGF�×qâ a�ÔQÜda>a�Ô FeÕ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚB?Ù�Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�F��OJOC�F�Ù�F�E Üda F�Ú aGÔ F�Õ�EbÖ'Ø�F�ÚGÚ��fJ�Þ´à�Ø�EGF ÜTa B?Ù"C a�Ô FOÕkÖ�E a IoäWÙ aGÔ F�Ý Ü Ú a Ú a F�Õrâ Ü ÙmF�Ý?F�ßfF�Ù a Ö�Ûa�Ô FoÝ�Ö'Ø Ü Ý#Ú a�Üda FoÖdÛ��OJYB?ÚeÚGF�Ù a Úbà7Ù�Ø Ô EbÖ�Ù�Ö�D�ÚbÝ�àiÖ å F�E aGÔ FoÕ5Ö�E aea Ö a�Ô FoÕ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚ@B�Ù�Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�F��tJ�â7ã ÔQÜda B�ÚF�Ù�ÚbD�EGF�×�Þ´à a�Ô F£Ú�à'Ù"Ø Ô EGÖ�Ù"B.� ÜTa B?Ö�ÙcØ�Ö�Ù�Ú a E Ü B?Ù a Û¬Ö�E�Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B�Ö�Ù¥ü � Ü Ù�×��'I <j Ô F��>l Ü ß�Õ�Ý?F�}7I�J��4Ú Ô ÖLã�Ú a�Ô FcØ�Ö�ß�ÕkÖ�ÚbB a B?Ö�ÙÁÖdÛ a�Ô FcÖ�ÕkF�ÙáÕ�EbÖ'Ø�F�ÚbÚfÚbF�ß Ü Ù a B?Ø�Ú¥Û¬Ö�E a ãgÖpEGF å B�ÚGB�Ö�ÙÜ EGØ Ô B å F�B?Ù"Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�F�ÚeÖ�ÛkÖ�D�E�Ø Ü ÚGF¡Ú a D�×"à|B�ÙV� ÔQÜ Õ a F�E }'I¡��Ú aGÔ F�Fl Ü ß�Õ�Ý?F�B�ÙfA<B?C�D�EbF@H�Ig},�YÚ Ô ÖLã�Ú�â'Õ5Ö�E a ÚEGF�ß Ü B�ÙÊD�Ù"Ø ÔQÜ Ù�C�F�× Ü Ù�×ÊÕ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚ�B?Ù�Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�F�Ú Ü EGF Ü ×�×�F�×4Þ´à a�Ô F�Ø�Ö�ß�Õ5Ö�ÚGB a B?Ö�ÙcÖdÛ a�Ô F�Ö�Õ5F�ÙÊÕ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B�Ø�Ú�I>^¢�ï@£�ïu¤ �Y��� ï �¦¥�§ s §p¨@©ªRE�HÆw���æ�w6� ò è«m(S�H�Jpæ�ý �ö ÷ M�ô���渲¸®�è­¬ w���æ�w�� ò èGè ö �#798#:G® ®�¯ " ® �1;U° ° � ±]± E^H�JDE�CeS.M1H�F3S ± N H9E1C�M�E�OLKPBuH�S5²GMm(S�H�J³F�E�MXQ(Et² H�HsT�H�JuE´CeS.M1H�F3S ± N H9E1CjMsµUM#H9E�O¶MXQ(Et²�Sp_D²�KUH5S5T Bpw�� ò xyæ�zI·*¸ {�}�}�{n~£ó è�²1T�O�QRT M�EtCº¹ SrKH�JDEVH5F�KPBUM3[XT F�O6KUH5S5T B�O�T F�QlJUS.M3OVMOæ\ý ö�÷ M òn» � � æ�w�� ò è ¬ ô���渲¸®�èbè ö �1798#:G® ®�¯ " ® �1;U° ° � ± bV¼�JDE�Bui�[XT FnE�Ke²½JBDT¾CUEÒ�¸¿S.B¦H�JuEV²tT BuH�F�T o(ÀDTPmÂÁÃFGK1QlJkT [ew���æ�w�� ò è�iÄH5JDE´CeSpM#H�F�S ± NUHsE1CjO�T F�QDJ S.M�O � � � ÿ ÷ æ�ý � ö�÷ æ��¸3èGèoxõ�Å �ö�÷ {��¡Æ��ÿ ÷ ù M7ý � ö�÷ æ �¸Oè­¬ �¸ÇJ@KPMnH5JDE*[XT o.oYT,m(SpBUÁ�QlF�T�QRE�F#H5S5EGM#È

É bʪ¡E H¨ý � ö ÷ æ��¸3è¨x �¸ � iËH�JDEGB�Å �ö ÷ Me¸ � ¬ ¸ÌS.M«SpB#Í1E1²�H�S�¹�E�KPBDC�Å �ö ÷ � ���X��� ® � ¯<M�ü » � � æ�¸ � è(¬Ëü » ��� æ5¸Oè SpM± S Í1Et² H5S�¹ E�K�BDCfUb«[XT F�E�Kò½JjÎ�³�¸ � � i �ËÆ��ÿ ÷ æ5Î'è SpM]KPBjSpM�T O�T FXQlJ S.M�O�b

<v Z RLRswxeà|Ø�Ö�Ù"Ú a EbD�Ø a B?Ö�Ùqâ7Û¬Ö�E¢F Ü Ø Ô Ù�Ö7×�F �¸ÑB?Ù a�Ô F¡Ø�Ö�Ù a EGÖ�ÝQêQÖLã C�E Ü Õ Ô Ö�Û�w6�¡æ¸w�� ò ènâ a�Ô F¡×�B Ü C�E Ü ß»ÞkF�Ý?ÖLãB?Ú Ü Ø�Ö�Ý�B?ß�B a B?Ù a�Ô F�Ø Üda F�C�Ö�E�àIÏ�Ð�¢�Ñ@æ¸z�·*¸OènI

ý ö�÷ æ\ý � ö�÷ æ��¸OèbèÒ Ó3ÔG® �tÕ Ô ® � � Õ Ô ® � ¯Ö¯p¯×Ø Ò ÓsÙ ® � ÕÙ ® � � ÕÙ ® � ¯Ö¯p¯ÚÛÜÝÜÝÜý � Þ æ��¸OèÒ Ó � Ô�® � � Õ Ô ® � ¯p¯ ßà ááááááááááá

áá ý � 8 æ<�¸OèÒ Ó � Ù ® � � ÕÙ ® � ¯Ö¯âã ä ä ä ä ä ä ä ä ä ä ä

ä ä�¸

j Ô FißfÖ�EGÕ Ô B�ÚGß � � ÿ ÷ æ�ý ö�÷ æ�ý � ö�÷ æ��¸OèbèGè¥x õXÅ ö�÷d{�� Æ ÿ ÷ ù M¨ý ö ÷ æ\ý � ö�÷ æ<�¸Oèbè´' ¬ ý � ö�÷ æ<�¸3è3B?Ú Ü Ù�B?Ù�Ø�Ý?D�ÚbB?Ö�Ù9Þ�à×�Ft�QÙ"B a B�Ö�Ù�Ö�Û a�Ô Fc×"B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�×�ÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B?Ø�Ú|w6�¡æ¸w�� ò ènIÍj Ô F�EGFÛ¬Ö�EGFdâgÚbB?Ù�Ø�F a�Ô Fi×�B Ü C�E Ü ß Ü ÞkÖ å F�B�ÚJ#�Ã}

Page 110: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

Ü Ø�Ö�Ý?B�ßfB a ×�B Ü C�E Ü ß B?Ù¦Ï�Ð�¢�Ñgæ�z�·*¸3è Ü Ù�×åÅ ö ÷ EGF�Ú a EbB?Ø a F�× a Ö a�Ô FiÕkÖ�E a Ú¥B�Ú¥Þ�Bæ�bF�Ø a B å Fdâ aGÔ F�C�E Ü Õ ÔßfÖ�EbÕ Ô B�ÚGßçÅ �ö�÷ B?Ú�B�Ù��bF�Ø a B å F Ü Ù�×cB a B�Ú�Þ�Bæ�bF�Ø a B å F£EbF�Ú a EGB�Ø a F�× a Ö a�Ô F£Õ5Ö�E a Ú�I�ªF a Î4³¦¸ � � Þ5F Ü Õ5Ö�E a Ù�Ö7×�F¥B?Ù³¸ � � â a�Ô F�Ù a�Ô F�EGF¥B�Ú Ü6è ³¦¸ � �� ã�B a�Ô Å ö ÷ æ è è�xÇÎ#I�xeà�×"Ft�QÙ�B a B�Ö�ÙÖ�Û a�Ô FOØ�Ö�ß�ÕkÖ�ÚGB a B?Ö�Ù � Æ ÿ ÷ æ è è¡B?Ú a�Ô FOB?×�F�Ù a B a à�ârÚGD�Ø ÔmaGÔQÜda � Æ �ÿ ÷ æYÎ"è�B?Ú Ü ÙmB?ÚbÖ�ßfÖ�EGÕ Ô B�ÚGßyÞ´à4Õ"D�Ú Ô Ö�D aØ�Ö�Ù�Ú a EbD�Ø a B?Ö�ÙÁB�ÙéÏ�Ð�¢�Ñ@æ¸z�·*¸3èI4ä^ÛÊÎÂê³ëÅ ö�÷ æ5¸ � �� è aGÔ F�ÙéζB�Ú Ü Õ�EbÖ'Ø�F�ÚbÚ¥Ù�Ö'×"F Ü Ù�× �ËÆ��ÿ ÷ æYÎ"è£B?Ú Ü ÙB?ÚGÖ�ßfÖ�EbÕ Ô B�ÚGß¹×�D"F a Ö a�Ô F3Û Ü Ø a¡aGÔQÜda¡a�Ô F3Ø�Ö�Ý�B?ß�B a ×"Ö'F�Ú�Ù�Ö a Û¬EbF�F�ÝVà�C�F�Ù"F�E ÜTa F�Ú�Ù�F�ãëF�Ý?F�ßfF�Ù a Ú B�Ù aGÔ FÕ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚGF�Ú�â5ÚGB�Ù�Ø�F a�Ô F�Õ5Ö�E a Ú�EGF�ß Ü B?ÙiD�Ù�Ø Ô�Ü Ù�C�F�×rI �

¥�§ s § © ìiuºí �5î íQuºí � � ï � í �Ëï Ï � ¤ � ¢ � �¡ð � � ï �äWÙ aGÔ FmÕ�EbF å B?Ö�D"ÚiÚGF�Ø a B�Ö�ÙÇäfØ�Ö�Ù�ÚGB�×�F�EbF�× Õ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚ�Õ�EbÖ'×�D"Ø a B�Ö�Ù�Ú aGÔQÜda�Ü EbF Ü Õ�Õ�Ý�B?F�× Ý?Ö7Ø Ü Ý�Ý�à a Ö�Ö�Ù�FÕ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚ�B?Ù"Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�F a Ö�C�F�Ù"F�E ÜTa F a�Ô FYÖ�ÕkF�ÙiÕ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚ�ÚbF�ß Ü Ù a B?Ø�ÚgÛ¬Ö�E aGÔ B?ÚgÕ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚ�B?Ù"Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�FdI�j Ô FYÖ�Õ5F�ÙÕ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚ¡ÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B�ØYØ�Ö�Ù a�Ü B?Ù�Ú aGÔ F£Ý?Ö7Ø Ü ÝkÚ a�ÜTa F�Ú Ü Ù�× aGÔ F a E Ü Ù�ÚGB a B?Ö�Ù�Ú@Û¬Ö�E�Ö�Ù�F£Õ�EbÖ'Ø�F�ÚbÚ�B�Ù�Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�FdI¢j Ô FØ�Ö�ß�ÕkÖ�ÚGB a B?Ö�Ù¶Ö�Û a�Ô FfÖ�ÕkF�ÙÁÕ�EbÖ'Ø�F�ÚGÚOÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B�Ø�Ú a Ö aGÔ Ft×"B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�×9ÚbF�ß Ü Ù a B?Ø�ÚOB�Ú3Ø�Ö�Ù a EGÖ�Ý?Ý?F�×ÍÞ´à ÜÚbà7Ù�Ø Ô EbÖ�Ù�B.� Üda B�Ö�Ù�EGF�Ý Üda B?Ö�Ùqâ a�Ô�Üda ×�F a F�EGß�B?Ù�F�ÚOã Ô B?Ø Ô Õ"EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚbÚ¥B?Ù�Ú a�Ü Ù"Ø�FiÚ a F�Õ�Ú Ô�ÜLå F a Ö a�Ü {�FiÕ"Ý Ü Ø�FÚbà7Ù�Ø Ô EbÖ�Ù�B.��F�×rI�AQÖ�E aGÔ B?ÚYØ�Ö�ß�ÕkÖ�ÚbB a B?Ö�Ù Ü Ý Ü Õ�Õ�EGÖ Ü Ø Ô Ù"ÖcC�Ý?Ö�Þ Ü Ý>Õ�EbÖ'×�D"Ø a B�Ö�Ù�Ú Ü Ù"×pÙ"ÖcC�Ý?Ö�Þ Ü Ý>Ú a�Üda F�ÚÜ EGFYÙ�F�Ø�F�ÚGÚ Ü Ebà�I� Ù�Ö aGÔ F�E Ü Õ�Õ�EGÖ Ü Ø Ô B?ÙiC�E Ü Õ Ô�a E Ü Ù�Ú�Û¬Ö�EGß Üda B�Ö�Ù a Ö|ßfÖ7×�F�Ý a�Ô FYÚbà7Ù�Ø Ô EbÖ�Ù�B.� Üda B�Ö�Ù�Ö�Û�Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B�Ö�Ù�Ú Ü EbFU�[�U�Sòñ´U�[�U,/¯P3) X5Z R1),0Q¤�/5+\R�4U-��ò�«ó�ô]õ î �'âÄj Ü F î �'âÄj�ARö�÷ î�î �\I­ø¡F�EGFdâQ×�B?Ú a EbB?Þ�D a F�×cÚbà7Ú a F�ß�Ú¡ã�B a�Ô C�Ý�Ö�Þ Ü ÝÚ a�ÜTa F�Ú Ü Ù�׶C�Ý?Ö�Þ Ü Ý<Õ"EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù"Ú Ü EGF¥Ø�Ö�Ù�ÚbB?×�F�EGF�×qIOäWÙ a�Ô B?ÚYÚGF aGa B?Ù�C�â a�Ô F¥Ú�à'Ù"Ø Ô EGÖ�Ù"B.��F�× Ü Õ�Õ�Ý?B�Ø Üda B?Ö�ÙÖ�Û a ãgÖ|Õ�EbÖ'×�D"Ø a B�Ö�Ù�Ú�B�Ú@×�F�ÚbØ�EbB?Þ5F�×cÞ�à a�Ô FYC�Ý?Ö�Þ Ü Ý Ü Õ�Õ"Ý?B?Ø Üda B�Ö�ÙtÖdÛ aGÔ F Ü ß Ü Ý?C Ü ß ÜTa F�×fÕ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B�Ö�ÙiÖ�Ûa�Ô F£Õ�EbÖ'×�D"Ø a B�Ö�Ù�Ú aGÔQÜda Ú ÔQÜ Ý?ÝrÞ5F£Úbà7Ù�Ø Ô EbÖ�Ù�B.��F�×rIäWÙ aGÔ B?Ú�ÚbF�Ø a B?Ö�Ùqâ´ä>EGF�Ý Üda F@ßOà Ü Õ�Õ�EGÖ Ü Ø Ô¥a Ö a�Ô F Ü Õ"Õ�EGÖ Ü Ø Ô ã�B a�Ô�Ü ß Ü Ý?C Ü ß Üda F�×3Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù�Ú�IÆä�Ú Ô Ö�ãa�ÔQÜda�aGÔ F£Ø�Ö�ß�Õ5Ö�ÚGB a B?Ö�Ù Ü Ý5×�B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�×�ÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B?Ø�Ú�Ø Ü ÙcÞkFYÚbB?ß�D�Ý Üda F�×iÞ´à a�Ô F£C�Ý�Ö�Þ Ü Ýk×�B?Ú a EbB?Þ�D a F�×�ÚGF�yß Ü Ù a B?Ø�Ú>C�B å F�Ù|Þ´à a�Ô F Ü ß Ü Ý�C Ü ß Üda F�×OÕ�EbÖ'×�D"Ø a B�Ö�Ù�Ú�IË÷oB�Ø�F å F�EGÚ Ü â a�Ô F�C�Ý�Ö�Þ Ü Ý'×�B?Ú a EbB?Þ�D a F�×¥ÚbF�ß Ü Ù a B?Ø�ÚC�B å F�ÙpÞ�à aGÔ F Ü ß Ü Ý?C Ü ß Üda F�×4Õ"EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù"Ú�Ø Ü ÙpÞkF|ÚGB�ß�D�Ý Üda F�×mÞ�à aGÔ F�Ø�Ö�ß�ÕkÖ�ÚGB a B?Ö�Ù Ü Ý<×"B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�×ÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B�Ø�Ú�âeBVÛ aGÔ F�ß ÜTa Ø Ô F�Ú|Û¬Ö�E a�Ô F�C�Ý�Ö�Þ Ü Ý Ü ß Ü Ý?C Ü ß Üda F�×ÍÕ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù�Ú¥Ø Ü Ù¾Þ5FiÚGÕ�Ý�B a B�Ù a Ö¶Ý?Ö7Ø Ü Ýß Üda Ø Ô F�Ú�Û¬Ö�E aGÔ F£B?Ù�Ú a�Ü Ù"Ø�F�Ú�I¢j Ô B?Ú�B?Ú�ÚbB?ß�B?Ý Ü E a Ö aGÔ FZ),+.-�/ Z +¸h102/�+\R�49¤�R�4u),+ù/5+\R�4|B?ÙW�ò�«ó�ô*õ î ���\Ij Ô F Ü ß Ü Ý?C Ü ß Üda B?Ö�ÙpÖ�Û¡×�B?Ú a EbB?Þ�D a F�׿Õ�EbÖ'×�D"Ø a B�Ö�Ù�Ú a�Ü {�F�Ú�Õ"Ý Ü Ø�FiÖ å F�E Ü Ø�Ö�ß�ß�Ö�Ùú-�0�h1û X5Z R1),0Q¤�/�+\R�4QI��×�B�Ú a EGB?Þ"D a F�×�Õ�EbÖ'×�D"Ø a B�Ö�ÙÍü üÍM�æ7�� ü ��Xý¬ ��*üè¥ã�B a�Ôáa Ö a�Ü Ý¡×"B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�×�ß�Ö�EGÕ Ô B?ÚbßfÚ �²\­ � M¶�� ü³¬�� Ü Ù�× �²\­lþyMë���üé¬ �� B�Ú Ü ÚbD�Þ¾y^Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù ÖdÛ Ü ×�B?Ú a EbB?Þ�D a F�×ÇÕ�EbÖ'×�D"Ø a B�Ö�ÙÁü M�æ7�� ��¬ ��£èiBVÛ�²\­�þ�ÿ �� üÍx �� ÿ �²�­ � IÒä�B?Ù a EbÖ'×�D"Ø�F Ô F�EGF¶Ö�Ù�ÝVà aGÔ F Ü ß Ü Ý?C Ü ß Üda B?Ö�Ù¿Ö�Û�×�B�Ú a EGB?Þ"D a F�× Õ"EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù"Úã�B a�Ô Ö�D a�Ü Õ"Õ�Ý?B�Ø Üda B?Ö�ÙfØ�Ö�Ù�×"B a B�Ö�Ù�Ú�IÆj Ô F Ü ß Ü Ý?C Ü ß ÜTa B?Ö�Ù�ÖdÛ<Ø�Ö�Ù�×�B a B�Ö�Ù Ü Ý5Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B�Ö�Ù�Ú@Ø Ü Ù�ÞkF Û¬Ö�D�Ù�×B?ÙW�òø¡F�Ø î  ���â a�Ô F£C�F�Ù�F�E Ü Ý?Bp� Üda B?Ö�Ù a Ö|Ø�Ö�Ù�×"B a B�Ö�Ù Ü Ýk×�B?Ú a EbB?Þ�D a F�×�Õ�EbÖ'×�D"Ø a B�Ö�Ù�Ú�B?ÙW� j�ARö�÷ î�î �\IÏ ���¡�Ë�ù� � ï �å¥�§ s § s�� ð í�uºí �Yî í�uºí ���2ï £�¢�ï ï ð�� � � ï ��� íQuºí �Yî íQuºí ���2ï ï�� ¢ �� í � � ï �Æñ�ªF a ü üµM�æ7�� ü ���ý¬ ���ünè�ã�B a�Ô �²\­ ö � M¿�� üa¬ ��Æö Ü Ù"× �²^­ ö þ M ���ü¦¬ �� ö ÞkF Ü ÚGD�Þ�Õ"EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù Ö�Ûa�Ô FÊ×�B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�×�Õ"EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù"Ú�ü ö M�æ7���ö �� ÿ¬ �� ö è�Û¬Ö�E�²tx J�� Ä­>IÇj Ô F Ü ß Ü Ý�C Ü ß Üda F�×�Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B�Ö�Ùü Þ�� �� � ü 8 Mqæ7�� ��¬ ��£è@Û¬Ö�E¨ü ö Ö å F�Egü�ü�B?Ú a�Ô F3×�B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�×cÕ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�ÙrâQã Ô F�EbF a�Ô F�×�B Ü C�E Ü ßfÚ3æ�JLèÜ Ù�×�æ�}�è Ü EGF a�Ô F3Ø�Ö�Ý�B?ß�B a Ú�Ö�Û�æ �²^­ ö � è ö�� Þ ÜÝÜÝÜ 8 EbF�ÚbÕrIÆæ �²^­ ö þ è ö�� Þ ÜÝÜÝÜ 8 B�Ù aGÔ FOØ Üda F�C�Ö�E�à�Ï�Ð6¢�Ñ@æ�zI·*¸Oè Ü Ù�× ��

J#���

Page 111: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

B?Ú�B?Ù"×�D�Ø�F�×ÊÞ´à aGÔ F£D�Ù�B å F�EbÚ Ü Ý�Õ�EbÖ�Õ5F�E a à�Ö�Û�æ¯J�èI�� ü ���ý ��

�ö 8 Ô!�� � � �� � �� � �� � �� � � �ö 8 Ù !�� ��������

���ü�ö 8 Ù !�� �������ö 8 Ô�

�� � � �� � �� � �� � �� � �

æ�J�è �� 8ö 8 Ù��!

�� � � �� � �� � �� � �� � �

�� Ù �� �� 8ö 8 Ù���

�� � � �� � �� � �� � �� � �

�� Þö 8 Ô �! �� ����

������ Ô �� �� Þ

ö 8 Ô �� �� ��������æX}�è

�� �� �� ��� ×"B?EGF�Ø a ×�F�EGB ådÜda B?Ö�ÙË�¸ ��" �$� �% D"ÚGB?Ù"C aGÔ F Ü ß Ü Ý?C Ü ß Üda F�×4Õ�EbÖ'×"D�Ø a B?Ö�Ùiü9xëü Þ�� � � ü 8 B?Ú£Ø Ü Ý�Ý?F�×U�[�U�Sòñ´U�[�U,/¯P3)Z),+ Z P�¤�/ )7P Z + �TU,/�+\R�4QI <� � íQuº£ �Y�j¥�§ �"! ð íQuºí �5î íQuºí ���2ï £Ë¢�ï ï ð�� � � ï � ¤ ñ#<Ö�E a Õ�EbÖ'×�D"Ø a B�Ö�Ù�Ú Ü EGF¨ÚGD"Þ�Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B�Ö�Ù�Ú>ÖdÛQÕ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚÆÕ"EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù"Ú Ü Ù"×�Õ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚ<Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù�Ú Ü EGFgÚ�à7Ù¾yØ Ô EGÖ�Ù"B.� Ü Þ�Ý?Fdâ'BVÛ a�Ô Fà ÔQÜ�å F aGÔ FoÚ Ü ßfF¡ÕkÖ�E a Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ùrâ'B�IÃFdI aGÔ F�à ÔQÜ�å F Ü Ø�Ö�ßfß�Ö�Ù�ÚGD�Þ�Õ"EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�ÙqIj Ô F�EbF�Û¬Ö�EbF�ârãeF�Ø Ü ÙmØ�Ö�Ù�Ú a EGD�Ø a�aGÔ F Ü ß Ü Ý?C Ü ß ÜTa F�×cÕ�EbÖ'×�D"Ø a B�Ö�Ù�Û¬Ö�E a�Ô F¥Õ�EbÖ'Ø�F�ÚbÚ�Õ"EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù"Ú a�ÔQÜTaÜ EGF¥EbF�Ý ÜTa F�׶޴à aGÔ F¥Úbà7Ù�Ø Ô EbÖ�Ù�Bp� Üda B?Ö�Ù¶EGF�Ý Üda B?Ö�Ù�Ö�Û Ü ×�B�Ú a EGB?Þ"D a F�×mÚbà7Ú a F�ßËÚGÕ5F�Ø�Bp�QØ Üda B�Ö�ÙrI�j Ô F�Ú�à7Ù¾yØ Ô EGÖ�Ù"B.� ÜTa B?Ö�Ù�EbF�Ý Üda B�Ö�Ù£B?Ù^�Æl Ü ß�Õ�Ý�F¨H"I�J�J¢EbF�Ý ÜTa F�Ú a�Ô FeÕ�EbÖ'Ø�F�ÚbÚ<Õ�EbÖ'×"D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù�Ú#ü Ü Ù�×´� � æ5�¥èrEGF�ÚbÕrInü � Ü Ù�×�'I£j Ô F¥A<B?C�D�EbFOH�Ig}'J¥Ú Ô ÖLã�Ú a�Ô F¥Ø�Ö�EGEbF�ÚGÕ5Ö�Ù�×"B?Ù�C Ü ß Ü Ý�C Ü ß Üda F�×ÊÕ�EbÖ'×"D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù�Ú�I£j Ô F Ü ß Ü Ý?C Ü ß ÜTa F�×

PRODUCTION p + st(B)

A1 A1 B1

PRODUCTION p’ + q

A1 B1 A1 B1

A>B?C�D"EGFYH�Ig}'J�M�N��QP3U�[�U�Sòñ´U�[�U,/WP3) X5Z R1),0Q¤�/�+\R�4U-­w�R Z /ù�QP�),+.-�/ Z +¸h102/WP3)V-Ð -�/WP[ - X P�¤�+ $@¤GU,/�+\R�45`Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù�Ú Ü EGF�C�Ý�Ö�Þ Ü Ýe×�B?Ú a EbB?Þ�D a F�׿Õ�EbÖ'×�D"Ø a B�Ö�Ù�Ú�âeÚbB?Ù�Ø�F aGÔ F�à�EbF�Û¬F�E a Ö a ãgÖÍÕ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚ�B?Ù�Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�F�Ú�Ij Ô F Ü ß Ü Ý?C Ü ß Üda F�×�Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù Üda�a�Ô F a Ö�Õ�Ö�Û a�Ô F���C�D�EGFYÚ Ô ÖLã�Ú aGÔ FYÚbà7Ù�Ø Ô EGÖ�Ù�Bp� Üda B?Ö�Ù�Ö�Û aGÔ FYÕ�EGÖ�yØ�F�ÚbÚ�Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù�ü Ü Ù�× a�Ô FYÚ a�Ü E a Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù�� � æ5�¥èI�j Ô F�Ø�EGF Üda B�Ö�ÙiÖ�Û a�Ô FYÙ"F�ã Õ"EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚbÚ�B?Ù�Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�F�tJYB?Ú@×"Ö�Ù�FYÞ´à a�Ô FYÕ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚ�B?Ù�Ú a�Ü Ù"Ø�F��OJ�I�j Ô F Ü ß Ü Ý?C Ü ß Üda F�×fÕ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù Üda�a�Ô FYÞkÖ aba Ö�ß Ú Ô Ö�ã�Ú�âa�ÔQÜda¡a�Ô F�×�F�Ý�F a B?Ö�ÙcÖ�Û a�Ô FOF�Ý�F�ß�F�Ù a Ö�Û a�Ô F3Ý?Ö7Ø Ü Ý�Ú a�Üda FOÖ�Û­�3JOB�Ù�×�D�Ø�F�Ú Ü Úbà7Ù�Ø Ô EbÖ�Ù�B.��F�׶Ø�EbF Üda B?Ö�ÙÊÖ�ÛÜ Ù�F�Ý?F�ßfF�Ù a B�Ù a�Ô F£Ý?Ö7Ø Ü ÝqÚ a�Üda F£Ö�Û¡�tJ Ü Ù�× a�Ô F�Õ5Ö�E a I�Æl Ü ß�Õ�Ý�Fn}'I�J�H�Ú Ô ÖLã�Ú Ü ß Ü Ý�C Ü ß Üda F�×�Õ�EbÖ'×�D"Ø a B�Ö�Ù�Ú@Û¬Ö�E aGÔ F£Ø Ü ÚbF3Ú a D�×'àiB?Ùj� ÔQÜ Õ a F�E�}'I <� Ü Ø Ô ×�B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�×�Ú�à7Ú a F�ß ÚbÕkF�Ø�Bp��Ø Üda B?Ö�ÙáB?Ù�×�D"Ø�F�Ú Ü ÚGF a Ö�Û Ü ß Ü Ý�C Ü ß Üda F�×�Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B�Ö�Ù�ÚtÞ´àáØ�Ö�Ù2yÚ a EbD�Ø a B?Ù�C aGÔ F Ü ß Ü Ý?C Ü ß Üda F�×�Õ"EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�ÙmÛ¬Ö�E aGÔ F|Õ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚ�Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B�Ö�Ù�Ú a�Ô�Üda�Ü EGF|EbF�Ý ÜTa F�׶޴à aGÔ FÚbà7Ù�Ø Ô EbÖ�Ù�B.� Üda B�Ö�Ù¾EGF�Ý Üda B�Ö�ÙrIÍj Ô F�ñ�S?R�h�U�S ),+.-�/ Z +¸h102/¯P3) -LP[�U,4�/5+\¤�-3B?Ú¥C�B å F�ÙáÞ´à a�Ô F a E Ü Ù"ÚbÛ¬Ö�Ebß Üda B?Ö�ÙÚbà7Ú a F�ßyÛ¬Ö�E Ü Ý�Ýr×�F�EbB ådÜda B?Ö�ÙiÚbF&%�D�F�Ù"Ø�F�Ú Ú a�Ü E a B�Ù�C Üda�a�Ô F�F�ßfÕ a ài×�B?Ú a EbB?Þ�D a F�×cC�E Ü Õ Ô D�ÚGB�Ù�C aGÔ F Ü ß Ü ÝÖyC Ü ß Üda F�×cÕ"EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù"Ú�B?Ù�×�D"Ø�F�×cÞ´à a�Ô F�×"B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�×ÊÚ�à7Ú a F�ßyÚGÕ5F�Ø�Bp�QØ Üda B�Ö�ÙrI

J#��H

Page 112: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

Ï ���¡�Ë�ù� � ï �å¥�§ s § s � ð�î5� ï@�Ëí �=ïË� ¤ � ¢ � �¡ð ���2ï ¤ � uWí �D� � �ä ñv B å F�Ù Ü ×�B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�× Úbà7Ú a F�ß ÚGÕ5F�Ø�BÖ�QØ ÜTa B?Ö�Ù w6� ò x æ¸z�·*¸ {�}�}�{�~�ó ètã�B aGÔ ~£ó�' ò �T�)( ò ���Ü Ú|×�Ft�QÙ"F�×�B�Ù¦|oFt�QÙ"B a B�Ö�Ù�H�IÃ�"IVJ��'I¿��F a ò �����d� � Þ5F a�Ô FiÚbF a ò ���¶Û Ü Ø a Ö�EGBp��F�׿޴à aGÔ F�F&%�D�B ådÜ Ý�F�Ù�Ø�FEGF�Ý Üda B�Ö�Ù � ó B?Ù�×�D"Ø�F�×¾Þ´à ~�ó IáA#Ö�E¥F Ü Ø Ô � ü �O³ ò ���7��� � ã�B a�Ô � ü �£xéº�ü Þ � ü 8 ½�âgÝ�F a � ü �rõ ÞkF aGÔ FÜ ß Ü Ý?C Ü ß Üda F�×iÕ�EbÖ'×�D"Ø a B�Ö�Ù�Û¬Ö�E¨ü Þ { � { ü 8 Ö å F�E a�Ô F3Õ5Ö�E a Õ�EbÖ'×�D"Ø a B�Ö�Ù|ü » � � æ ü ö è�渲g³¿º�J { �� { ­�½dè Ü Ù�×� � ø æ�w�� ò è�x º¾� ü � õ � � ü ��³ ò �T�7�d�Q�7½¡ÞkF aGÔ F�ÚGF a Ö�Û Ü ß Ü Ý?C Ü ß Üda F�×3Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù�ÚÆB?Ù"×�D�Ø�F�×|Þ�à¥w�� ò Ij Ô F�Ùrâ aGÔ F�ñ�S?R�h�U�S¡),+.-�/ Z +¸h102/¯P3)L-LP[�U,4�/5+\¤�-¡B?Ú aGÔ F a E Ü Ù�Ú�Û¬Ö�EGß Üda B?Ö�ÙÊÚbà7Ú a F�߶¸^��æ�w�� ò è�x �¥æ¸wiè�Û¬Ö�Ea�Ô F£ÚGF a Ö�Û>×"F�EGB ådÜda B�Ö�Ù�Ú�w x º+*Ox»æ-, � Ô� �¸ Þ � Ô� �¸/. �10� ��è � ü ö ³�� � ø æ�w�� ò è { ²�³�ä Ý2�½�I <j Ô F C�Ý�Ö�Þ Ü Ý"×�B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�×tÚbF�ß Ü Ù a B�Ø�Ú¢Û¬Ö�E a�Ô F¡×�B?Ú a EbB?Þ�D a F�×fÚbà7Ú a F�ßÈÚGÕ5F�Ø�Bp�QØ Üda B�Ö�ÙtC�B å F�ÙtB?Ù a�Ô F��>l Ü ß´yÕ�Ý?F�H�I î Ü Ù�×��>l Ü ß�Õ�Ý?F�H�I�J�JoB?ÚeB?ÚGÖ�ßfÖ�EbÕ Ô B�Ø a Ö a�Ô Fo×�B?Ú a EbB?Þ�D a F�×�ÚbF�ß Ü Ù a B�Ø�Ú@C�B å F�Ù�B?ÙiA<B?C�D�EbF�H"I�},�'IR�Õ Ü E a ÖdÛ aGÔ F£C�Ý?Ö�Þ Ü ÝrÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B?Ø�Ú�Ö�Û aGÔ F£Ø Ü ÚbF3Ú a D�×'à�B?Ùj� ÔQÜ Õ a F�E*}�B?Ú�C�B å F�ÙÊB�Ùj�>l Ü ß�Õ�Ý?Fn}7I�J� 7IÅ9FfÚ a�Ü E aOaGÔ FtØ�Ö�ß�Õ Ü EGB�ÚGÖ�ÙÍÞkF a ãgF�F�Ù a�Ô FtØ�Ö�ßfÕ5Ö�ÚGB a B�Ö�Ù Ü ÝÆÖ�ÕkF�E Üda B?Ö�Ù Ü Ý¨ÚbF�ß Ü Ù a B�Ø�Ú Ü Ù�× a�Ô FtC�Ý�Ö�Þ Ü Ý×�B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�×cÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B�Ø�Ú�ã�B aGÔcaGÔ F3Ö�Þ�ÚGF�E ådÜda B�Ö�Ùrâ a�Ô�Üda F Ü Ø Ô Ú a F�Õ�B?Ù a�Ô F3×�B�Ú a EGB?Þ"D a F�×ÊÚbF�ß Ü Ù a B?Ø�Ú�Ø Ü ÙÞkF�ÚGB�ß�D�Ý Üda F�×�Þ�à aGÔ F�×�B?EbF�Ø a ×"F�EGB ådÜda B�Ö�Ù�Ö�Û Ü Ù Ü ß Ü Ý�C Ü ß Üda F�×ÁÕ�EbÖ'×�D"Ø a B�Ö�ÙrI¿j Ô F Ü ß Ü Ý?C Ü ß ÜTa F�×Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�ÙµD�ÚGF�× Û¬Ö�E a�Ô B?Ú�ÚbB?ß�D�Ý Üda B�Ö�Ù¾B?Ú�Ø�EGF ÜTa F�× Û¬EbÖ�ß aGÔ F4Õ�EbÖ'Ø�F�ÚbÚcÕ"EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù"Ú�Ö�Û a�Ô FmÝ?Ö7Ø Ü ÝÚ a F�Õ�Ú�Ö�Û a�Ô FYÖ�ÕkF�ÙiÕ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚ�ÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B?Ø�Ú�â"Û¬EGÖ�ß aGÔQÜda@aGÔ F a E Ü Ù�ÚGB a B�Ö�Ù�B?Ù a�Ô FY×�B�Ú a EGB?Þ"D a F�×iÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B�Ø�Ú�B�ÚØ�Ö�Ù�Ú a EbD�Ø a F�×rI�AQÖ�EYB?Ù"Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�Fdâ aGÔ F a E Ü Ù�ÚGB a B�Ö�Ù4Ý Ü ÞkF�Ý?F�×¾æ�ü { � � æ���èGè B?Ù aGÔ F|×�B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�׶ÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B?Ø�ÚYB�ÙA>B?C�D"EGF�H�Ig},�3D�ÚbF�Ú aGÔ F Ý�Ö'Ø Ü Ý#Õ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚ@Õ"EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù"Ú�ü Ü Ù�×I� � æ���èI�j Ô F a E Ü Ù�ÚGB a B?Ö�ÙfØ Ü Ù�Þ5F ÚGB�ß�D�Ý Üda F�×Þ�à a�Ô F Ü ß Ü Ý?C Ü ß ÜTa F�×tÕ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù�� � � � æ��¥ènI

>^¢�ï@£�ïu¤ �Y��� ï �¦¥�§ s § s ¨µð ��ï5uº£�ïu¤ �2ï ï�� ¤ � ¢ � �Ëð ���2ï ¤ ��� £¡¤�í ¢ � íQuWí �5î íQuWí ���2ï ¤ ��� £Ë¤ ñªRE�H�w���æ�w�� ò è�xÏõ43^¸65 ó�{�ø 5 ó�ù m(S�H5J¾æ\ý �ö�÷ Mqô���渲¸®�è*¬ w���æ�w�� ò èGè ö �#7981:�® ®�¯ " ® �#;U° ° � ± ± EVH�JuE´CeS.M3qH�F3S ± N H9E1CLM�E�OLKPBuH�SY²�MÊ[XT F]KLCeS.M1H�F�S ± N H9E1CZMsµUM1HsE�O MXQ(Et²�S._u²�KUH5S5T Bcw�� ò x»æ¸z�·*¸ {�}�}�{n~�ó è]²tT O�QRT M�E1C¹ SrK H5JDEIH5F�KPBUM3[XT F�O6KUH5S5T B�O�T F�QDJ S.M�OZMfæ\ý ö ÷ M ò^» ��� æ¸w�� ò è�¬ ô���渲¸®�èbè ö �1798#:G® ®�¯ " ® �1;U° ° � ± bk¼�JuE�BDi­[XT�FE�Ke²½JkE1C~ÁUE  M ø ¬ 7�³83n¸65 ó m(SXH�J:9�æ  è�xyæGæ ü Þ { �� Þ è { � { æ ü 8 { �� 8 èGèGiÄH�JDE´CÃS.M#H5F3S ± N HsEtC�OIT�F�QlJ SpM3Oø 5 ó æ  è�x ��<; S.M Á~S�¹ EGB ± µºH5JDE�CeS.F�E1²�H­KPO6K�opÁ2KPOLKUH9E1C6C EGF3SX¹tK¾H�S5T�B

�� ® Þ ¯�$>=?

�� �� ���$ �=?ø 5 ó æ ø è �� � �� ø 5 ó æ-7è

m(S�H�JaH5JDE�KPOLKPopÁ2K�O6KUH9E1C´QlF�T2CuN2²�H�S5T�BA@ 8ö�� Þ ü ö M �� KUH�H�JuEnO6KUH9²½J �� SpBDCuN2²tE1C ± µaH�JDEnOLKUHs²½JuE�M �� öKPBDC�H�JDE�N,B SX¹ EGF3M�K�o@QlF�T�QRE�F1HÖµ³T [=H�JDE�²tT o.SpOZSXH­T ± Í1Et² H���CB M�E1E�KPopM�TLH�JuEnCÃSùK�ÁÃFGKPO ± EGo5TPm�D b <v Z RLRsw

J#�´ 

Page 113: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

�gÖ�Ù�ÚGB�×�F�E aGÔ F£×�B Ü C�E Ü ß ÞkF�Ý?ÖLã Û¬Ö�E a�Ô FYÛ¬Ö�Ý�Ý?ÖLã�B?Ù�COFl'Õ�Ý Ü Ù Üda B�Ö�Ù�Ú�I

ü » � � æ7��Æö�÷ èö 8 ÿ ÷!

EF G G GG G G

G G GG G G

G G GG �$ ý=?

��Xý �� ü » ��� æ��� ö�÷ è

HI J J J JJ J J J

J J J JJ J J J

J J �$ �ý=?ü » � � æ��¸ ö�÷ è

EF G G GG G G

G G GG G G

G G GG �� �ý �� ü » ��� æÆ�% ö ÷ è

Ò Ó ÿ ÷ ® ������� ® �K ÿ ÷ ¯p¯HI J J J J

J J J JJ J J J

J J J JJ J

��Æö�÷

LM NNNNNN

NNNNNN

NNNNN�$ ÿ ÷ =?

�� ÿ ÷ �� �� ö�÷ö 8 ÿ ÷ ��

OP QQQQQQQQ

QQQQQQQQ

QQ�$ �ÿ ÷ =?�¸ ö�÷Ò Ó � ÿ ÷ ® � ÿ ÷ ¯

LM NNNNNN

NNNNNN

NNNN

�� �ÿ ÷ �� �% ö�÷

OP QQQQQQQQ

QQQQQQQQ

QQ�� ® Þ ¯�$=? �� �� ��

�$ � =? ��RS NNN

NNNNNN

NNNNNN

N�¸

�T UV WWWWWWWW

WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW

W �� � �� �%�X

YZ [[[[[[[[[[

[

�% �Å9F Ô�ÜLå F a ãgÖ¥Ú Ô ÖLã aGÔQÜda ×�B�C�E Ü ß æ¯J�è Ü Þ5Ö å FYB�Ú Ü Õ�D�Ú Ô Ö�D a ×"B Ü C�E Ü ßcI<j Ô FY×"B Ü C�E Ü ßÈØ�Ö�ß�ß�D a F�ÚgÛ¬Ö�EÛ¬Ö�Ý?Ý�Ö�ã�B�Ù�C|EGF Ü ÚGÖ�Ù"Ú�M�A#Ö�E�F Ü Ø Ô ²�³9ú�­rû5欫kè { «Á³ ò ·¡À�ü  â �� ; ÿ �� ÿ�²�­ ö�÷ �� x �� ; ÿ � � � ÿ ÷ æ �¸ ö ÷ è�ÿ �� ö ÷ x� � � ÿ ÷ æ��% ö�÷ è�ÿ �� ;ö�÷ ÿ �� ö�÷ x � � � ÿ ÷ æÆ�% ö�÷ è�ÿ �� ;ö ÷ ÿ �� ö�÷ x �� ; ÿ¡²�­ ö�÷ �þ ÿ �� ö�÷ x �� ; ÿ �� ÿ�²\­ ö�÷ �� I]\'B�Ù�Ø�F�²\­ ö�÷ ��Û¬Ö�E�²¢³4ú�­rû5欫kè { «4³ ò ·¡ÀTü Â Ü EGF �bÖ�B?Ù a Ý�àfÚGD�Eù�bF�Ø a B å F�âQãgF ÔQÜ�å F �� ; ÿ �� x �� ; ÿ �� Iv B å F�Ù Ü ×�B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�×cC�E Ü Õ Ô �% � Ü Ù�×c×�B�Ú a EbB?Þ�D a F�×cß�Ö�EGÕ Ô B?ÚGß�Ú �� Ü Ù�× �ü�ã�B a�Ô �ü�ÿ �� x ��Êÿ �� I^\'B?Ù�Ø�F��(ÿ � � � ÿ ÷ æ��¸ ö�÷ èUÿ �� ö ÷ x ��­ÿ �� ÿƲ�­ ö�÷ �� x �ü�ÿ �� ÿƲ\­ ö�÷ �� x �ü*ÿ�²�­ ö�÷ �þ ÿ �� ö�÷ â aGÔ F�EbF B?Ú Ü D�Ù"B_%�D�F ×"B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�×ßfÖ�EbÕ Ô B�ÚGßa` ö�÷ M �% ö�÷ ¬ �% � ÚGD"Ø ÔÊa�Ô�Üda ` ö�÷ ÿ ��b;ö ÷ x ��Êÿ �Ë� � ÿ ÷ æ �¸ ö�÷ è Ü Ù"×c` ö�÷ ÿ ��d;ö ÷ x �ü�ÿ�²\­ ö ÷ �þ IóÊÖ�EGF�Ö å F�E�âb` ö�÷ ÿ �Ë� ÿ ÷ æ�ü » � � æ �% ö�÷ èGè�ÿ ��<;ü xe` ö�÷ ÿ ��<;ö�÷ ÿ �Ë� ÿ ÷ æ�ü » � � æ �¸ ö�÷ èGè�x ��,ÿ �Ë� � ÿ ÷ æ �¸ ö�÷ è�ÿ �Ë� ÿ ÷ æ�ü » ��� æ �¸ ö�÷ èGè�x��Ãÿ2ÿ � � � fhg æ��¸ ¼ g è�ÿ � � fhg æ�ü » � � æ��¸ ¼ g èGè¢xi` ¼ g ÿ � � fhg æ ü » � � æÆ�% ¼ g èGè�ÿ �� ;ü Û¬Ö�E Ü Ý?Ýd²¨³�ú7­qû5欫kè {kj ³4ú�­rû5æ¸À"è { « { Àf³ò ·¡À�ü  ItÅÍFtØ Ü Ù9Ú Ô Ö�ã Ü Ù Ü Ý?Ö�C�Ö�D�ÚGÝVàl` ö ÷ ÿ �Ë� ÿ ÷ æ�ü » ��� æÆ�% ö ÷ èbè(ÿ ��d;ü xa` ¼ g ÿ � � fhg'æ ü » � � æ��% ¼ g èGèRÿ ��d;üÛ¬Ö�E Ü Ý?Ýq²¨³�ú7­qû5欫kè {kj ³4ú�­rû5æ¬À�è { « { Àt³ ò ·¡À�ü  Im\'B�Ù�Ø�F ��b;ü Ü Ù"× ��d;ü Ü EGF=�bÖ�B?Ù a ÝVà�ÚGD"EY�bF�Ø a B å F�â�ãeF ÔQÜ�å F` ö ÷ ÿ � � ÿ ÷ æ ü » � � æ �% ö ÷ èGè�xa` ¼ g ÿ � � f g æ ü » � � æ �% ¼ g èGèoÛ¬Ö�E Ü Ý�Ý�²O³ ú�­rû5欫kè {nj ³ ú�­rû5æ¸À"è { « { ÀÁ³ ò ·�À�ü  Ij Ô F�EbF�Û¬Ö�EbF�â a�Ô F�EGF�Fl'B?Ú a Ú Ü D�Ù�B %7D"F¡×"B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�×|ßfÖ�EbÕ Ô B�ÚGß �`�Mt�% ¬ �% � ÚbD�Ø ÔfaGÔQÜda �` ÿ � � � ÿ ÷ æ��% ö ÷ è¢x` ö ÷ Û¬Ö�E Ü Ý?Ýq²�³mú7­qû5欫kè { «�³ ò ·¡ÀTü  Ij Ô F�Ù Ô Ö�Ý?×"Ú �`Zÿ �� ; ÿ � � � ÿ ÷ æ��¸ ö�÷ èYx �`Lÿ � � � ÿ ÷ æÆ�% ö ÷ è¡ÿ �� ;ö ÷ xo` ö�÷ ÿ �� ;ö ÷ x ���ÿ � � � ÿ ÷ æ>�¸ ö�÷ ènIp\'B�Ù�Ø�F aGÔ F� � � ÿ ÷ æ��¸ ö�÷ è Ü EbF �bÖ�B?Ù a ÝVàtÚbD�EY�bF�Ø a B å FdâQãgF ÔQÜ�å F �`�ÿ �� ; x ���I�ÅÍF�Ø Ü ÙcÚ Ô ÖLã Ü Ù Ü Ý?Ö�C�Ö�D�ÚbÝ�à �`´ÿ �� ; x �ürIj Ô F3D"Ù�B_%�D�F�Ù�F�ÚbÚ Ö�Û �`4Ø Ü ÙÊÞkF£F Ü ÚGB�Ý�àiÚ Ô ÖLã�Ù�Þ´à a�Ô F�D�Ù�B %�D�F�Ù�F�ÚGÚ�Ö�Û aGÔ F3ß�Ö�EbÕ Ô B?ÚbßfÚ �` Ü Ù�×c` ö ÷ Û¬Ö�E²¨³�ú7­qû5欫kè { «4³ ò ·¡ÀTü  I �ä3Ø Ü Ý?Ý a�Ô F Ü ß Ü Ý�C Ü ß Üda F�×9Õ�EbÖ'×"D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù @ 8ö�� Þ ü ö M �� Ö�Ûq#¢EbÖ�Õ5Ö�ÚGB a B?Ö�Ù9H�IÃ�"IÃ�Ã}ÊÛ¬Ö�E Ü Ù¿F�×�C�F  B?Ù aGÔ FØ�Ö�Ù a EbÖ�Ý"êQÖLã�C�E Ü Õ Ô ÖdÛ aGÔ F�×�B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�×¥ÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B?Ø�Ú aGÔ F�U�[�U�Sòñ´U�[�U,/WP3) X5Z R1),0#¤�/5+\R�4�w�R Z Â Ü Ù�×f×"F�Ù�Ö a Fa�Ô FoÕ"EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�ÙtÞ�à ø � ø æ  è@M �� IÆj Ô FYB?Ù�×�D"Ø�F�×iß Üda Ø Ô �� B�ÚgØ Ü Ý?Ý�F�× aGÔ F|U�[�U�Sòñ´U�[�U,/WP3)|[�U,/W¤��£Û¬Ö�E  I|oD�F a Ö a�Ô FoÕ"EGF å B�Ö�D�ÚgÕ"EGÖ�Õ5Ö�ÚGB a B�Ö�Ùrâ7F Ü Ø Ô Ú a F�ÕiB�Ù a�Ô Fo×�B?Ú a EbB?Þ�D a F�×�ÚbF�ß Ü Ù a B�Ø�Ú@Ø Ü ÙiÞkF�ÚGB�ß�D�Ý ÜTa F�×tÞ�àÜ Ù Ü ß Ü Ý�C Ü ß Üda F�×4×�B�EGF�Ø a ×�F�EbB ådÜda B�Ö�ÙrI|j Ô F�EGF�Û¬Ö�EGF�â a�Ô F�×�B�Ú a EbB?Þ�D a F�×pÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B?Ø�Ú�Ø Ü Ù9Þ5F|F�ß�Þ5F�×"×�F�×B?Ù a Ö a�Ô F�C�Ý?Ö�Þ Ü ÝqÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B?Ø�Ú�I

J#��K

Page 114: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

>^¢�ï@£�ïu¤ �Y��� ï �¦¥�§ s § s#s ð�î5� ï@��í � ¤ � uWí �D� � �ä ��� � � ð ï�� ¤ ï�� ¤ � ¢ � �Ëð ���2ï ¤ � uºí �u� � �ä ñªRE�H<w6�¡æ¸w�� ò è>xÒõ43n¸r5 óQ{�ø 5 ó�ù ± E�H�JDE]CeSpM#H�F�S ± NUHsE1C�M�EGO6KPBuH5S5²�MÄ[XT F]H�JuE�CeSpM#H�F�S ± NUHsE1C�MsµUM1HsE�O M�QRE1²�qS._D²�KUH�SYT B¿w�� ò x æ¸z�·*¸ {�}�}@{n~£ó è�KPBuCé¸^��æ�w�� ò èfx õ43n¸ ó�{�ø ó7ù ± E�H5JDEZÁÃo5T ± KPo M�E�OLKPBuH�S5²GM[XT F�w�� ò b ¼�JDE�BDi^H5JDE�F�EjEts¾S.M#H5M�K¦H�FGKPB M3[XT�F3OLKUH�SYT B¦OIT FXQlJ SpM3O ý x õ^ý þ� {G� � ù M«¸^��æ�w�� ò èL¬w���æ�w�� ò è�i(M1N2²½J H�J@K¾HYý þ� Mu3^¸65 ó ¬ 3n¸ ó S.M^S.B#Í1Et² H5S�¹ EVKPBDC � � M­& � Õ æ ø ó è´¬ ø 5 ó S.M´KPBS.M�T�OIT FXQlJ SpM3Ojb <v Z RLRswÅ9F£×�F��QÙ�F a�Ô F a E Ü Ù�Ú�Û¬Ö�EGß Üda B�Ö�Ù�ß�Ö�EGÕ Ô B?Úbßyý�x õ^ý þ� {�� � ù ã�B a�Ô ý þ� x õ^ý { ý � ù B?Ù"×�D�Ø a B å F�Ý�à5M

ý 渲�­q² � 5 ó è�x ²�­q² � ó Ü Ù�× � � 欲\­q² � ó è¢xe, ��F a ý�¢æ5Îb5 ó è4x Î ó Û¬Ö�E6Îb5 ó ³ ¸r5 ó Ü Ù�× Â 5 ó M�Îb5 ó ¬ è 5 ó Ü ÙÇF�×�C�FmB�Ù ¸r5 ó ã�B aGÔ

9�æ  5 ó è�xÏæbæ ü Þ { �� Þ è { � { æ�ü 8 { �� 8 èbèIO�ªF a ø � ø æ  5 ó è¡EGF�ÚbÕrI �� ÞkF aGÔ F Ü ß Ü Ý?C Ü ß Üda F�×ÊÕ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø�ya B�Ö�Ù¾Û¬Ö�E  5 ó EbF�ÚGÕqI aGÔ F Ü ß Ü Ý�C Ü ß Üda F�×¾ß Üda Ø Ô Û¬Ö�E  5 ó Iv\'B?Ù�Ø�F aGÔ F�Õ�EbÖ'×"D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù�Ú£ü Þ âVIVI�IVâ ü 8ß Ü àÇÞ5F9Õ5Ö�E a Õ�EbÖ'×�D"Ø a B�Ö�Ù�Ú a�ÔQÜda�Ü EbF9F&%�D Ü Ý a Ö a�Ô F9ÚGD"Þ�Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B�Ö�Ù D�ÚbF�× Û¬Ö�E a�Ô F Ü ß Ü ÝÖyC Ü ß Üda B�Ö�Ù9ÖdÛ¨ü Þ I�IVI ü 8 Þ´à�×�F��QÙ�B a B?Ö�Ùrâ a�Ô F Ü ß Ü Ý?C Ü ß Üda F�×pÕ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù ø � ø æ  5 ó è3B�Ú�B?ÚbÖ�ß�Ö�E½yÕ Ô B�Ø a Ö a�Ô F Ü ß Ü Ý�C Ü ß Üda F�׶Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù�ü�æ  5 ó èOxw@ ¼ �#; ó ® ±4x � ¯ ü ¼ M �� â>ã Ô F�EGF ò ��æ  5 ó è�xº�² � ²YxËJ� �Ä­ { ü ö B�Ú�Õ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚ�Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B�Ö�Ùq½�I�j Ô F�Ùrâ aGÔ F�EbF�Fl'B?Ú a Ú Ü ÙÁF�×�C�F  ó M�Î ó ¬ è óã�B aGÔ 9�æ  ó è¥xçæ�ü�æ  5 ó è { �� è3B?Ùy3n¸ ó ÚbB?Ù�Ø�FtãgF Ô�ÜLå F Ü ß ÜTa Ø Ô �� Û¬Ö�E aGÔ F Ü ß Ü Ý?C Ü ß ÜTa F�×Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B�Ö�Ùiü�æ  5 ó èIZ|oD�F a Öc#�EGÖ�Õ5Ö�ÚbB a B�Ö�Ù¶H�IÃ�"I��~}'â a�Ô F�×�B?Ú a EbB?Þ�D a F�׶C�E Ü Õ Ô Ú ø ó æ è ó è Ü Ù�×ø 5 ó æ è 5 ó è Ü EGF|B�ÚGÖ�ß�Ö�EGÕ Ô B?ØdI�j Ô F�EbF�Û¬Ö�EbF�âªãgF|×�F��QÙ�Ftý��æ è 5 ó èox è ó Ü Ù"×9ý�¢æ  5 ó èYx  óÜ Ù�× � � æ è ó è@M ø ó æ è ó èĬ ø 5 ó æ è 5 ó è@B?Ú aGÔ F£B?ÚGÖ�ßfÖ�EbÕ Ô B�ÚGß ÞkF a ãgF�F�Ù è ó Ü Ù�× è 5 ó I

j Ô F�Ø�Ö�Ù a EGÖ�Ý"ê�Ö�ã¾ß�Ö�EGÕ Ô B?Úbß»ýQþ��B?Ú a Ö a�Ü Ý\âdÚGB?Ù"Ø�F@F Ü Ø Ô Ø�Ö�Ù a EbÖ�Ý"Ú a�Üda F�B?Ù aGÔ F a�Ô FgØ�Ö�Ù a EbÖ�Ý"êQÖLãáC�E Ü Õ Ô3^¸65 ó EbF�ÚGÕqIz3n¸ ó B?Ú�EbF Ü Ø Ô�Ü Þ�Ý?FYÛ¬EbÖ�ß aGÔ F£B?Ù�B a B Ü ÝkÚ a�Üda F�Ij Ô F|ßfÖ�EbÕ Ô B�ÚGßËý þ� xìõ^ý { ý � ù B�ÚYB?Ù��bF�Ø a B å F�Û¬Ö�EoÛ¬Ö�Ý?Ý?ÖLã�B�Ù�C�EGF Ü ÚGÖ�Ù�Ú�MYÅÍF Ü ÚGÚGD"ßfFfý ��æ{9bæ  5 ó èGèoxý��qæ-9�æ Â�� 5 ó èbèex æ�ü { �� è@Û¬Ö�E  5 óQ{ Â�� 5 ó ³A3n¸r5 ó Ü Ù�×|9bæ  5 ó èex»æbæ ü Þ { �� Þ è { �� { æ�ü 8 { �� 8 èGè Ü Ù�×}9bæ Â�� 5 ó èexæGæ ü � Þ { ���� Þ è { � { æ ü �8 { ����8 èGènIIxeà¶Ø�Ö�Ù"Ú a EbD�Ø a B?Ö�Ù9Ö�Û�ý �qâªãeF ÔQÜ�å F3ü�æ  5 ó è£x ü�æ Â�� 5 ó ènIIxeàp×�Ft��Ù�B a B?Ö�ÙpÖ�Ûa�Ô F�Ø�Ö�ß�Õ5Ö�ÚGB a B?Ö�ÙmÖ�Û a�Ô FfÖ�Õ5F�ÙÍÕ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚ3ÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B�Ø�Ú�â aGÔ FfÕ5Ö�E a Õ�EbÖ'×"D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù�Ú£B�Ù)9�æ  5 ó è Ü Ù�×)9bæ Â�� 5 ó èÔQÜ�å F a Ö�Ø�Ö�B�Ù�Ø�B�×�F�I�äWÙ4Ö�Eb×�F�E a Ö Ü Ø Ô B?F å F a�Ô F3Ú Ü ß�FOß Üda Ø Ô �� Û¬Ö�E aGÔ F�Ú Ü ßfF3Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B�Ö�Ù�Ú D"ÚGF�×4Û¬Ö�Ea�Ô F Ü ß Ü Ý?C Ü ß ÜTa B?Ö�Ùrâ a�Ô FcÝ�Ö'Ø Ü Ý@ß Üda Ø Ô F�Ú �� ö Ü Ù"× ����ö Û¬Ö�E|²|xéJ { � { ­ ÔQÜ�å F a Ö¶Ø�Ö�B�Ù�Ø�B�×�F Ü Ú¥ãgF�Ý?Ý\Ij Ô F�EbF�Û¬Ö�EbF�â#ãgF ÔQÜ�å F  5 ó x  � 5 ó Igj Ô F�ßfÖ�EGÕ Ô B�ÚGßÏý B?Ú�B?Ù �bF�Ø a B å F£Û¬Ö�E¡F�×�C�F�Ú�ÚbB?Ù�Ø�F�ý � B?Ú�B?Ù �bF�Ø a B å FÜ Ù�×ÁÞ´àÁØ�Ö�Ù�Ú a EGD"Ø a B�Ö�ÙÁÖ�Û�ý�ÆI4j Ô F�ßfÖ�EGÕ Ô B�ÚGßçý��B?Ú3B?Ù��bF�Ø a B å FfÛ¬Ö�EOÙ�Ö7×�F�Ú�â�ÚGB�Ù�Ø�FtÙ�Ö�Ù¾y^B?Ù��bF�Ø a B å B a àãgÖ�D"Ý?×�EbF&%�D�B?EbF�â a�ÔQÜda<a�Ô FeÚ Ü ß�F Ü ß Ü Ý?C Ü ß Üda F�×£Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B�Ö�Ù Üda�a�Ô F@Ú Ü ß�F¨ß Üda Ø Ô à7B?F�Ý?×�Ú a ãgÖ ×�B ~kF�EbF�Ù a×�F�EbB å F�×ÊC�E Ü Õ Ô Ú�I �j Ô F�Õ"EGF å B�Ö�D�Ú¨Õ�EGÖ�Õ5Ö�ÚbB a B�Ö�Ù¥Ú Ô Ö�ã�Ú a�ÔQÜTa¨aGÔ F¡×�B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�×�Ø�Ö�ß�ÕkÖ�ÚGB a B?Ö�Ù Ü Ý"ÚbF�ß Ü Ù a B?Ø�Ú¢Ø Ü ÙfÞkF¡F�ß�Þ5F�×2y×�F�×iD�Õ a Ö�B�ÚGÖ�ß�Ö�EGÕ Ô B?Úbß B?Ù a Ö a�Ô FoC�Ý?Ö�Þ Ü Ý5ÚbF�ß Ü Ù a B�Ø�Ú�I�j Ô FoÖ a�Ô F�Eg×"B?EGF�Ø a B?Ö�ÙfB?ÚgÙ"Ö aga EGD�FoB�ÙtC�F�Ù�F�E Ü Ý\âB\IÄF�I aGÔ FYC�Ý?Ö�Þ Ü ÝqÚbF�ß Ü Ù a B�Ø�Ú�Ø�Ö�Ù"Ú a EbD�Ø a F�×ÊÞ�à a�Ô F Ü ß Ü Ý�C Ü ß Üda F�×�Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B�Ö�Ù�Ú�Ø Ü Ù�Ù�Ö a Þ5FYF�ß�Þ5F�×"×�F�×D�Õ a Ö�B�ÚGÖ�ß�Ö�EbÕ Ô B?Úbß B?Ù a Ö a�Ô Fo×"B?Ú a EGB�Þ�D a F�×�ÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B?Ø�Ú�I�j Ô B�Ú@B?ÚeÞ Ü ÚGF�×�Ö�Ù a�Ô F Û Ü Ø a â aGÔQÜda@aGÔ FoC�Ý�Ö�Þ Ü ÝÚGF�ß Ü Ù a B�Ø�Ú�Ö�Õ5F�E Üda F�Ú¢Ö�Ù Ü C�Ý�Ö�Þ Ü Ý'C�E Ü Õ Ô�Ü Ù�× a�Ô F�EGF¡×�Ö7F�Ú�Ù�Ö a Fnl"B�Ú a¨Ü Ù�Fl'Õ�Ý�B?Ø�B a ÚbF�Õ Ü E Üda B�Ö�Ù¥Þ5F a ãeF�F�Ùa�Ô F�Õ"EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚbÚoB?Ù"Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�F�ÚoÛ¬Ö�E aGÔ F Ü ß Ü Ý�C Ü ß Üda F�×Êß Üda Ø Ô F�Ú�I j Ô F�EbF�Û¬Ö�EbF�ârÕ�EbÖ'Ø�F�ÚbÚYÕ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù�Ú Ö�Û¢Ö�Ù�FB?Ù�Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�F£Ø Ü ÙcÞkF Ü Õ�Õ�Ý?B�F�× a Ö|Ö aGÔ F�E�Õ�EbÖ'Ø�F�ÚbÚ�B�Ù�Ú a�Ü Ù�Ø�F�Ú�I� � íQuº£ �Y�j¥�§ �2? ð�î5� ï@��í � ¤ � uWí �D� � �ä>��ð�¢ � ¤ �5� ¤ � í � � � ��ïuð ��ï í ¢ �5� ¤ ñA#Ö�E a�Ô B?Ú Fnl Ü ßfÕ"Ý?FOãeF¥Ø�Ö�Ù"ÚGB?×"F�E Ü Õ"EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚbÚYC�E Ü ßfß Ü E�Û¬Ö�E Õ�EbÖ'Ø�F�ÚbÚGF�Ú£Ö�Û a à7Õ5F ò aGÔQÜda Ø�Ö�Ù a�Ü B�Ù�Ú aGÔ FÕ�EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚGÚ�Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B�Ö�Ù ø Ú Ô ÖLã�Ù Üdata�Ô F a Ö�Õ Ö�Û�A<B?C�D�EbF�H�Ig}~}'I j Ô B?ÚiÕ"EGÖ7Ø�F�ÚbÚ�Õ�EGÖ7×�D�Ø a B?Ö�Ù ×�F�Ý�F a F�Ú

J#�´�

Page 115: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

P2P1

P3

P2P1

process production a

P P

P2P1

m

P3

P2P1

a1+a2

���_���"�������g}~}�����4��<���<�òñ��<���,/n�3)ú)��1��+ ���,/5+4��4"�Z/Y�"�,/p���,4�4���/��1��-�+ �´0����,/��3)8�&�a/ù��� �¡���£¢���-�+ù/5+4��4¤�<�),+.-�/{��+{�10¾/n�3)V-¥�1���,4�/�+4��-&¦Ö�Ù��c��Ý_��ß���Ù�§fÛ�bÖ�ߨ§ Ô �ÊÝ?Ö7Ø Ü Ý�Ú©§ Ü §���Ö�Ûq§ Ô �ÊÕ��GÖ7Ø&��ÚGÚª�v« Ô �Ê×��?Ú©§��t�?Þ��"§���×���� Ü ßfß Ü �¥Ú Ô�Ü Ý?Ý�Õ��bÖ å ��×��§ Ô �t�&�6�?Ù�Ú©§ Ü Ù�ت��Ú¡Ö�Û�§Wà'Õ¤� ò âQÙ Ü ß���Ý�ଧ Ô �£Õ��GÖ7Ø&��ÚGÚq�?Ù�Ú©§ Ü Ù�ت� ò�­ â ò } Ü Ù�× òr® �=x¨ài×��t��Ù�� §��?Ö�Ùrâ�� Ü Ø ÔÕ��GÖ7Ø&��ÚGÚ¯��Ù�Út§ Ü Ù�Ø&�fØ�Ö�Ù�§ Ü �?Ù�Ú Ü Ù ��Ù�Út§ Ü Ù�ت�fÖ�Û°§ Ô ��Õ��GÖ7Ø&��ÚGÚ�Õ��bÖ'×"��ت§��?Ö�Ù ø â>×���Ù�Öb§���×9Þ�à ø ­ â ø } Ü Ù�×ø ® �±« Ô �|Úbà7Ù�Ø Ô �bÖ�Ù��.� Ü §���Ö�ÙA����Ý Ü §���Ö�ÙmÚ Ô�Ü Ý?Ýu�t�&%²��� ���¯§ Ô�Ü §/§ Ô �|Õ��bÖ'×��"ت§���Ö�Ù�Ú ø ­ Ü Ù�× ø } Ü ��� Ü Õ�Õ�Ý �_��×Úbà7Ù�Ø Ô �bÖ�Ù�Ö���ÚbÝ�à<�éxeàÁ×"�t�QÙ���§���Ö�Ù�Ö�Û³§ Ô �´��Ý?Ö�Þ Ü ÝeÚt��ß Ü Ù�§��?Ø�Ú�â�ãµ� Ü ß Ü Ý � Ü ß Ü §��±§ Ô �iÕ��GÖ7×���Ø1§���Ö�Ù�Ú ø ­Ü Ù�× ø }3Ö å �ª�^§ Ô �oÕ5Ö��©§@Õ��bÖ'×��"ت§���Ö�Ù¬§GÖ¶§ Ô � Õ��GÖ7×���Ø1§��?Ö�Ù ø ­ � ø }3Ú Ô ÖLã�Ùd�?Ù¬§ Ô �������"���£§GÖ�ßfÖ7×���ݤ§ Ô �Úbà7Ù�Ø Ô �bÖ�Ù��.�ª��× Ü Õ�Õ�Ý �?Ø Ü §��?Ö�Ù�Ö�Û ø ­ Ü Ù�× ø }���gÖ�Ù�Ú���×��&��Ù�ÖLã·§ Ô ��Ú�� §�� Ü §��?Ö�Ù´��� å ��Ù}��Ùd§ Ô ��×��?Ú©§�����Þ��"§���×c��� Ü Õ Ô ��Ùc§ Ô �£Ý?ÖLãµ�&��Ý_�Û §�y Ô�Ü Ù�×�Ú���×��£Ö�Û�§ Ô ��������t��ⲧ ÔQÜ §¨Ú Ô ÖLã�Ú Ü ×��?Ú©§�����Þ��"§���×�Úbà7Út§���ßc¸ÃÚeÚt§ Ü §���â�ã Ô �ª���q§ Ô �°§ Ô �t�&��Õ��GÖ7Ø&��ÚGÚ��?Ù�Ú©§ Ü Ù�ت��Ú ò�­ â ò } Ü Ù�×òr® Ü ���OØ�Ö�Ù�Ù���ت§���×¶Ö å �&� Ü Ø�Ö�ß�ßfÖ�Ù4ÕkÖ<�t§¹�]º)� Ü Õ�Õ�ÝVà}§ Ô � Ü ß Ü Ý_� Ü ß Ü §���×�Õ��bÖ'×"��ت§��?Ö�Ù ø ­ � ø }�§GÖ§ Ô ��Ú���� Ü Õ Ô¥Ü §»§ Ô �¼��� å ��Ù�ß Ü §�Ø Ô�½� �»« Ô �@ß Ü §�Ø ÔOÔ �"�t§�Úu§ Ô �¼��Ù�Út§ Ü Ù�ت�@ÞkÖ<��Ù�× Ü �t�_��Ú�â�Út�?Ù�ت�^� §<ß Ü Õ�Ú»§ Ô �Õ��GÖ7Ø&��ÚGÚ�Ù�Ö7×�� ò }�Ö�Û�§ Ô � Ü ß Ü Ý � Ü ß Ü §���×3Õ��bÖ'×"��ت§��?Ö�Ù6§�Ö¾§ Ô �@Õ��GÖ7Ø&��ÚGÚu��Ù�Út§ Ü Ù�ت� ò�­ ��« Ô � Ü Õ�Õ�Ý_��Ø Ü §��?Ö�ÙÖ�Û�§ Ô � Ü ß Ü Ý_� Ü ß Ü §���×�Õ��GÖ7×���Ø1§���Ö�ÙO×���Ý_�1§���Ú>ÞkÖ<§ Ô ��Ý ��ß���Ù�§�Ú�Û�GÖ�ß¿§ Ô �@Ý?Ö7Ø Ü Ý�Ú©§ Ü §��@Ö�Û#Õ��bÖ'ت��ÚGÚ��?Ù�Ú©§ Ü Ù�ت�ò�­ �« Ô �?ÚÀ§�� Ü Ù�Út� §���Ö�Ù�Ø Ü Ù�Ù�Ö<§¨Þ¤��Ú��?߶��Ý Ü §���ץ޴௧ Ô ��Ø�Ö�ß�ÕkÖ�Ú�� §��?Ö�Ù Ü Ý'Ö�Õz�ª� Ü §��?Ö�Ù Ü Ý�Ú���ß Ü Ù�§��?Ø�Ú�â´Ú���Ù�Ø&�³�?Ù±§ Ô �Ø�Ö�ß�ÕkÖ�Ú�� §��?Ö�Ù Ü ÝqÖ�Õ¤�&� Ü §���Ö�Ù Ü Ý�Út��ß Ü Ù�§���Ø�Ú¡Õ��GÖ7Ø&��ÚGÚoÕ��bÖ'×"��ت§��?Ö�Ù�Ú�Ö�Û Ü Ù|��Ù�Út§ Ü Ù�Ø&� Ü �t� Ü Õ"Õ�Ý_� ��×cÖ�Ù�Ý�à´§GÖ§ Ô �¡Ø�Ö��t����ÚGÕ5Ö�Ù�×���Ù���Õ��bÖ'ت��ÚGÚµ�?Ù�Ú©§ Ü Ù"Ø&�<�À« Ô �&���Û¬Ö����dâ"��§µ��ÚeÙ"Ö<§gÕ5Ö�ÚbÚ��?Þ"Ý_�°§�Ö3×���Ý �ª§��³§WãeÖ¯��Ý ��ß���Ù�§�Ú¨Û�GÖ�ßò�­ ��ÙÁÖ�Ù��tÚt§���Õrâ¢Ú���Ù�Ø&�p§ Ô �&�t��×�Ö���Ú¥Ù�Ö<§¶�1Á�� § Ü Õ��GÖ7Ø&��ÚGÚ¥Õ��bÖ'×��"ت§���Ö�Ù9Û¬Ö��O×���Ý �ª§���Ù��}§WãeÖ:��Ý ��ß���Ù�§�Úª�« ÔQÜ §�ß�� Ü Ù�Ú�â�ãµ�tØ Ü Ù�Ù�Ö<§�ÚbÕ�Ý_��§Â§ Ô ��ß Ü §�Ø Ô Û¬Ö��§ Ô � Ü ß Ü Ý_� Ü ß Ü §���×mÕ"�GÖ7×���ت§��?Ö�Ù:��Ù Ü Ý?Ö7Ø Ü Ý>ß Ü §GØ ÔÛ¬Ö��]§ Ô ��Õ��GÖ7Ø&��ÚGÚoÕ��bÖ'×"��ت§��?Ö�Ù ø ­ §�Ö�§ Ô �3Õ��GÖ7Ø&��ÚGÚ¾��Ù�Út§ Ü Ù�ت� ò>­ Ü Ù"× Ü Ý�Ö'Ø Ü Ý�ß Ü §�Ø Ô Û¬Ö��]§ Ô ��Õ��GÖ7Ø&��ÚGÚÕ��GÖ7×���Ø1§��?Ö�Ù ø }¶§�Ö±§ Ô �£Õ��GÖ7Ø&��ÚGÚ]�?Ù�Ú©§ Ü Ù�ت� ò }�� <ä^Û�ãµ�Â����Út§����?Ø1§^§ Ô �Â��Ý?Ö�Þ Ü ÝkÚt��ß Ü Ù�§���Ø�Ú¼§GÖ¯§ Ô Ö�Út�¾§�� Ü Ù�Ú���§���Ö�Ù�Ú�â�ã Ô �ª���§ Ô � Ü ß Ü Ý � Ü ß Ü §���×fÕ"�GÖ7×���ت§��?Ö�Ù"ÚÜ ��� Ü Õ�Õ"Ý_�_��×|Ö�Ù�Ý�ට�Ö/§ Ô �¡Ø�Ö��t����ÚGÕ5Ö�Ù�×���Ù��3Õ"�GÖ7Ø&��ÚbÚ¼��Ù�Út§ Ü Ù�Ø&��Ú�â²�-�Ã�b��§ Ô �¡ß Ü §�Ø Ô Û¬Ö��À§ Ô � Ü ß Ü Ý_� Ü ß Ü §���×Õ��GÖ7×���Ø1§��?Ö�ÙcØ Ü ÙcÞz�£ÚGÕ"Ý_� §^�?Ù�§�Ö|Ý?Ö7Ø Ü Ýrß Ü §�Ø Ô ��Ú�Û¬Ö<�^§ Ô �£Õ��bÖ'ت��ÚGÚ]�?Ù"Út§ Ü Ù�Ø&��Ú�â�§ Ô �/��Ý�Ö�Þ Ü ÝkÚ���ß Ü Ù�§��?Ø�Ú³��Ú�?ÚGÖ�ßfÖ��bÕ Ô ��Ø£§�Ö±§ Ô ��×"�?Út§�����Þ��"§���×�Ú���ß Ü Ù�§���Ø�Úª�Ï ���¡�Ë�ù� � ï �å¥�§ Ä § Ä ¥Çð ¢ � ¤ � ¢ � � ���2ïaî¤Å ï@�Ëí Å ¤ ��Æ í �D� � �ä ñÇÈ�1§qÉ�� ò Þz� Ü ×��?Ú©§��t�?Þ��"§���×�Úbà7Ú©§���ßÏÚbÕz��Ø&�p��Ø Ü §��?Ö�Ù Ü Ù�×�� � ø æ{É�� ò è@Þ¤�/§ Ô �£Ú��1§ Ö�Û Ü ß Ü Ý_� Ü ß Ü §���×­ ��Ê

Page 116: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

Õ��GÖ7×���Ø1§��?Ö�Ù�Ú£��Ù�×���ت��×mÞ´à�É�� ò æ¸Út�&��|¾���QÙ�� §��?Ö�Ùc��� ® � ®"­ è1�£« Ô ��Ùrâz§ Ô �p����-�/{��+4��/��3)Zñ<�_�<�¡�<��-¥�1���,4�/5+4��-�?Ú�§ Ô �}§�� Ü Ù"ÚbÛ¬Ö��bß Ü §��?Ö�Ù¾Úbà7Ú©§���ß ��¸���æ{É�� ò èdË �¥æ{Éiè�Û¬Ö���§ Ô ��Út�ª§iÖ�Û£×"�&��� ådÜ §���Ö�Ù�Ú�É Ë Ì+*iËæ-, � Ô "kÍ$ Ô� ½¸ Þ �10½"�Í$ 0� ½¸/. �ÏÎ3"kÍ$ Î� � �è+Ð ü ö£Ñ � � ø æ{É�� ò èÏÒ�Ó Ñ ä Ý26Ô�â»Õ���Ö¡× §�× Ü §6ØÙ�� Ü Ý?Ým* Ñ É�â�ÓtÒ jyÑ ä Ý2£âÓ´Ú j ã³� §�×Û*5æ{Ó^è´Ë æ ½¸ ö � ÿ "nÍ$ ÿ� ½% ö è Ü<Ü�Ý *5æ j è´Ë æ ½¸qÞ � f "nÍ$ f� ½%6Þè±×�Ù�Ý Ý Õ&�}� بü ö Ò\ü²Þ Ñ ò/ß

à ØÙ���á Ñú�âqû¤ãäzå1Òtä Ñ ò ·]æ�üèç�ézê<���¯ë"��Ù�Ö&�&ÕtÕ/ë���Ù Ý ��Ö1§��_Ù Ü Õ¾Ù<ØÀ§�×��±Õ�ê<ì��¯ë��tÙ�Öª�&ÕtÕÂ� Ü Õ©§¡ê Ü Öª��á|Ù<ØÀ§ní�ëz�¯äA§�×"� Ü� Þ<ãYÎ"åÀËeî ;Þ Ô ÿ � ÿ°î ;ö ÿ � ö ã5Î�åµØÙ��^§�×��/ë���Ù�Ö&�ªÕ�Õ Ü Ù Ý �nÎ�Ù<Ø�§�×��/ë��tÙ�Öª�&Õ�Õ]ë��tÙ Ý �"Öª§�� Ù Ü ÕÆü ö ê Ü"Ý ü²Þ¥�´<ïk§d�_Õ´�¹êbÕtíð§�ÙyÕ��&�b飧�×�êb§´§�×��:�t�&Õt§���� Öª§�� Ý ��ñ_Ù�ò�ê<ñ£Õt�&ì�ê Ü §��_ÖªÕ´�_ÕdêyÕ��"ò¾yk§���ê Ü Õ©ØÙ���ì�êb§��_Ù Ü Õ©í�Õt§��ªì Ù<ا�×��r��ñ_Ù�ò�ê<ñÈÕ��&ì�ê Ü §�� Ö&Õ£ê<Õ Ý ��� Ü � Ý � Ü |¾��� Ü ��§��_Ù Ü ��� ® � ®"­ éèÕ�� Ü Ö&�¶§�×��¶�t�&Õ©§���� Öª§�� Ý ��ñ Ù�ò�ê<ñÈÕt�&ì�ê Ü §��_ÖªÕ£� Õ��� Ü �ª��êb§�� Ý ò�ícê>Õt��ò�Õt�ª§qÙ<Ø Ý �&����óbêb§�� Ù Ü Õ°��Õt� Ý ØÙ��°§�×��/��� Ü �&��êb§�� Ù Ü Ù<Ø�§�×��/��ñ_Ù<ò�ê<ñ�Õt�&ì�ê Ü §�� Ö&Õ&�ïkØ"ôµ��ÖªÙ�ì�ë�ê<���À§�×�� Ý �_Õ©§���� ò��"§�� Ý Õ��ªì¬ê Ü §��_Ö&Õõô³��§�×/§�×��m���ªÕt§����_Ö1§�� Ý ��ñ Ù�ò�ê<ñbÕ��ªì¬ê Ü §��_Ö&Õªé�ôµ��Ö¹ê Ü Ö¹ê Ü Õ�×"Ù+ô§�×�êb§¼òzÙb§�×pÕt�&ì�ê Ü §��_ÖªÕ&é��4�ö�<��§�×��&� ��§���ê Ü ÕtØÙ��tì¬êb§��_Ù Ü Õtí�Õt§��&ì�Õ&é�êb���¾� Õ�Ù�ì�Ù���ë"×��_Öb��«°×�� Õ¼ì��¹ê Ü Õªé�§�×�êb§¼ôµ�Ö¹ê Ü Ö&Ù Ü Õt� Ý �ª�³�¹ê<Ö¡× Ý �_Õt§���� ò��"§�� Ý ÖªÙ�ì�ë��"§¡ê�§��_Ù Ü � Ü §�×�� Ý �_Õ©§��t�_ò��"§�� Ý Ö&Ù�ì�ë¤Ù�Õ���§��_Ù Ü ê<ñ�Õt�&ì�ê Ü §�� Ö&Õ³Ø��Ù�ìê���ñ Ù�ò�ê<ñ÷ë¤Ù�� Ü §]Ù<Ø�ó�� �ªô¿�<� ó�� Ü � Ü §�×��r�t�&Õ©§���� Öª§�� Ý ��ñ Ù�ò�ê<ñ�Õ��&ì�ê Ü §�� Ö&Õª� ÷¾�_Öª�6ó<�&�tÕ�ê"é¤�¹ê<Ö¡×|��ñ_Ù�ò�ê<ñõÕt§��&ë� Ü §�×��/�t�&Õt§���� Öª§�� Ý �<ñ_Ù�ò�êbñ�Õ��ªì¬ê Ü §��_ÖªÕ]Ö&ê Ü òz�ÂÕtë�ñ_��§³� Ü §�Ù>ñ_Ù�Ö¹êbñ�Õt§��&ë�Õª�«°×���ØÙ�ñ ñ_Ù¥ô³� Ü �´ë���Ù�ë¤Ù�Õt� §�� Ù Ü Õt§�êb§��ªÕ&é�§�×�êb§6§�×���§���ê Ü ÕtØÙ��tì¬ê�§��_Ù Ü ì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ì ý Ý ��� Ü � Ý � Ü #À�tÙ�ëzÙ<Õ��Öy§��_Ù Ü ��� ® � ®�® � Õ>ê Ü �_Õ�Ù<ì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ìcéÀ� سô¼�c���ªÕt§����_Ö1§±§�×��d��ñ Ù�ò�ê<ñµÕ��ªì¬ê Ü §��_Ö&Õ±§�Ù:§�×��d���ªÕt§��t�_Ö1§�� Ý ��ñ Ù�ò�ê<ñÕ��&ì�ê Ü §�� Ö&Õª�>^¢+ø@£Àøu¤ �Y��� ø �¦¥�§ Ä�§ ÄèùªRE�H ý)ËÌõ^ýQþ��Ò ����ù ��¸^�³ã-É�� ò å�¬ É6� ± E6H�JuE�H5F�KPB M�[XT F3OLKUH5S5T B³O�T F�QDJ S.M�O C E�_UBDE1C�SpB)ú(F�T�Q(T qM3S�H5S5T Bé`2b�c2b�c~c ± E H�m(E1EGBÂH5JDELCÃS.M#H5F3S ± N HsEtC³M�E�OLKPBuH�S5²GM¯É��³ã{É�� ò å/Ëíõ43n¸r5 ó Ò ø 5 ó7ù K�BDCaH�JuE�ÁÃoYT ± KPoM�E�OLKPBuH�SY²�M�¸��³ã-É6� ò å¼Ë õ43n¸ ó Ò ø ó�ù [XT F�KICeSpM#H5F3S ± N HsEtCIMsµUM#H9E�O M�QRE1²�Sp_D²�K¾H�S5T�BlÉ�� ò KPBDCÊý þ Ëõ^ý þ þ� Ò � � � ù �e��¸��³ã-É6� ò åR¬ É��³ã-É�� ò å ± E*H�JDE�H�FGKPB M�[XT F3OLKUH�SYT B�O�T FXQlJ S.M�O ý�F�E�M1H�F�S5² H9E1CLHsT�H5JDEF�E�M1H�F�S5² H9E1CZÁÃo5T ± KPo�M�E�OLKPBuH�S5²GMÊ��¸��³ã{É�� ò åÀË»õ��Â3^¸>Ò ø þ þ� ù b�¼�JuE�BDirý þ þ� �²3^¸65 ó ¬ �Â3^¸ ó SpM± S Í1Et² H�SX¹ E�KPBuC � � � �2& � � Õ ã ø þ ó åĬ ø 5 ó SpM�K�B�SpM�T O�T FXQlJ S.M�O�b <v¼���¥�swxµícÖ&Ù Ü Õ©§��t��Öª§��_Ù Ü ÙbØÀ§�×��rÖ&Ù Ü §��tÙ�ñÈû�Ù¥ô�����ê<ë"×lì�Ù<��ë�×�� Õ�ììý þ� � Ü #À��Ù�ë¤Ù�Õt� §�� Ù Ü ��� ® � ®�® 餧�×��¶ÖªÙ Ü §���Ù<ñû�Ù¥ôü����ê<ë"×ð3n¸r5 ó � Õ�ì�ê<ë�ë¤� Ý §�Ù:§�×�Ù<Õ��|ë�ê<�t§�Õ¬Ù<ؾ3^¸ ó 鼧�×�ê�§pê<ë"ë�ñ íýë��tÙ Ý ��Öª§��_Ù Ü Õ�Ù<Ø£ë���Ù�Ö&�ªÕ�Õ� Ü Õ©§¡ê Ü Öª�&ÕdÙ Ü ñ�í8§�Ùy§�×���ÖªÙ����t�&Õ�ë¤Ù Ü�Ý � Ü �ýë��tÙ�Öª�&Õ�Õc� Ü Õt§¡ê Ü Ö&�b�þ«°×��_Õ´� Õ Ý ���l§�Ùý§�×���Ø{ê<Öª§&é]§�×�êb§´§�×��ê<ì¬êbñ_��ê<ì�êb§�� Ý ì�êb§�Ö¡×A�_Õ/� Ü�Ý ��Öª� Ý ò�í�§�×��>ñ_Ù�Ö¹ê<ñuì�êb§�Ö¡×��&Õ/ØÙ��§�×���ë��tÙ�Öª�&Õ�Õ6� Ü Õt§¡ê Ü Ö&�ªÕ&�¬«°×"�&���1ØÙ����bé§�×��µ���&Õ©§��t�_Öª§��_Ù Ü ý þ þ� �²3^¸65 ó ¬ �Â3^¸ ó �_Õȧ�Ùb§¡ê<ñ-�¡xµír#À��Ù<ëzÙ�Õt� §��_Ù Ü ��� ® � ®�® ØÙ�ñ ñ_Ù¥ô³Õõ§�×��µ� Ü �t�ªÖª§�� ó�� §níÙ<Ø5ý þ þ�u�Ⱥ)�µÕ�×�Ù¥ôý� Ü�Ý ��Ö1§�� ó<�&ñ�í�éb§�×�êb§Æý þ þ�¬� Õ»Õt���Y�t�ªÖª§���ó��°êbÕ�ôµ�&ñ ñ4�»�èÙ<�»Ó-â�Ó � þ þ� �_Õ>ý þ þ�ÀãÓ4â�Ó � 5 ó åmËÓ4â�Ó � þ ó �°Çõ�ª§*Î,þ ó´Ñ �Â3n¸>éuÎPþ ó êË·Ó4âzÓ � þ ó é�§�×"�&���r�1Á��_Õ©§�Õqê Ü � Ý ���rç¯� è þ ó ¬ ÎPþ ó � Ü �Â3^¸ò²í¬Ö&Ù Ü Õt§��t��Öª§��_Ù Ü Ù<ØË�Â3n¸��­x�íp� Ü"Ý ��Öª§��_Ù Ü ë����ªì�� Õ��<é�§�×��ª���Â�_Õ^ê è 5 ó�Ñ 3n¸r5 ó ô³� §�×cý þ þ� ã è 5 ó åmËè þ ó �ÀÇõ�ª§^9tã{ç+åmËCã ü÷Ò ½� åÀô³��§�×�ü´Ë�ü Þ"� � ü ß é"á Ñ ï ñ2r�R|¾���q§�Ù6§�×��£�t�&Õt§���� Öª§�� Ù Ü §�Ùr§�×��£�t�&Õ©§���� Öª§�� ÝÝ �_Õ©§���� ò��"§�� Ý Õt�&ì�ê Ü §�� Ö&Õ&é°§�×��|ì�êb§�Ö¡× ½� Ö&ê Ü ò¤�|Õtë�ñ_��§¬� Ü §�Ù)ì�êb§�Ö¡×"�&Õ ½� Þ Ò¹�� Ò ½� ß ØÙ���§�×��}ë���Ù�Ö&�ªÕ�Õë���Ù Ý ��Ö1§��_Ù Ü Õ�ü Þ Ò¹� Ò\ü ß �«x�ídÖ&Ù Ü Õ©§��t��Öª§��_Ù Ü Ù<ØÀ3n¸r5 ó §�×��ª���6�1Á��_Õ©§�Õ¾ê Ü � Ý ���¯ç¥5 ó � è 5 ó ¬ Îb5 ó ô³� §�×9tã{ç¥5 ó å¶Ëÿã�ã�ü�� Þ Ò ½� Þ åÏÒ¹ ��Ò+ã ü��8 Ò ½� 8 å�åÂÕ���Ö¡×y§�×�êb§¬Ì�ü Þ Ò¹� Ò\ü ß Ô ' Ì�ü�� Þ Ò¹� ü��8 Ôcê Ü"Ý ê<ñ_ñmë��tÙ Ý ��Öª§��_Ù Ü Õ¡ü��ö êÑÌ�ü Þ Ò¹� Ò�ü ß Ô¯ê<���/ë¤Ù��t§]ë��tÙ Ý ��Öª§��_Ù Ü Õ°ØÙ���ü Þ Ò¹ �Ò\ü ß �=xµí Ý �t� Ü � §��_Ù Ü Ù<Ø�ý þ þ�ué�ô¼�6×�ê¹ó���ý þ þ�Àã{ç¥5 ó å�Ë çê Ü�Ý §�×��ª���ªØÙ<���3ý þ þ� ã5Îb5 ó åmË ÎPþ ó �«°×��¯Ø{ê<ì��_ñ ípÙ<Ø�ì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ì�Õ � � � � Õ¾ê Ü � Õ�Ù�ì�Ù��të�×��_Õtì}é¤Õ�� Ü Ö&�¶�¹ê<Ö¡×:Ö&Ù<ì�ë¤Ù Ü � Ü §¾�_Õ¾ê Ü �_Õ�Ù<ì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ìê<Ö&ÖªÙ�� Ý � Ü �±§�Ù�#À��Ù�ë¤Ù�Õt� §�� Ù Ü ��� ® � ®�® � �

­ ���

Page 117: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

� � � ø@¢ ��Æ ¥�§ Ä�§ Ä��µð ¢ � ¤ � ¢ � � �#�¾ï¦î¤Å ø@��í Å í ��ï ï�� ¤ � ¢ � �Ëð ���2ï ¤ ��Æ í �D� � �ä�í ¢ �³� ¤&ø Æ ø@¢ £�� � � ñ� SX¹ E�B�K�CeSpM#H5F3S ± N HsEtC�MsµUM1HsE�O M�QRE1²GS._D²�KUH�SYT BlÉ6� ò i¡H�JDE�F�EGM#H�F�S5²�HsE1CLÁÃo5T ± KPo M�EGO6K�BDH5S5²GM���¸^�]ã{É�� ò åKPMnC EG_ BDEtC�SpB³\^E�_UB S�H5S5T B³`2b�c2bdc,`ZKPBDC H5JDE�CeSpM#H5F3S ± N HsEtC�M�EGO6K�BDH5S5²GMÂÉ��³ã-É�� ò åÊKPM^C EG_ BDE1C�SpB³\^E�_ qB S�H5S5T B�`2b�c2b fDh*KPF�E]SpM�T O�T FXQlJ S5²�b <v¼���¥�sw�èÙ<ñ_ñ_Ù¥ô³Õ¼Ø�tÙ�ì §�×��/�1Á��_Õ©§�� Ü Ö&�6Ù<Ø�§�×��/�_ÕtÙ�ì�Ù���ë�×"�_Õ�ì ��� ó<� Ü � Ü #À��Ù<ëzÙ�Õt� §��_Ù Ü ��� ® � ® � �¥�§z¥ Ï � ¤ � ¢ � �¡ð ���2ï � ¢�í � ¤��4øu¢ Æ í � � ø � ø �*ì �#� ¢ � �Ëð ���2ï Ð�¢ í £»��¤«°×��_Õ¾Õt�&Ö1§��_Ù Ü �_Õ£ÖªÙ Ü Öª�&� Ü � Ý ô³� §�×lêpÖ&Ù Ü Öª���1§��±� Ü Õt§¡ê Ü Ö&�¯ÙbØÀ§�×��¯Ö&êb§��ª��Ù��©í���é�§�×�êb§Â� Õ&éz§�×��¯Ö&êb§��ª��Ù��tíì�Ð6¢�ã��°å¾Ù<Ø/�,/5/{��+{�102/n�3)�ñ<���1¢��Ã-£� Ü §���Ù Ý ��Ö&� Ý � Ü �ò�^Ç�� �-�>ï£×�ê¹ó���Ö¡×�Ù�Õt� Ü §�×��_ÕÂÖ&êb§��ª��Ù��©í�é�Õ�� Ü Ö&�>� §/� Õ��Õ�� Ý ØÙ��^§�×��/Ö¹ê<Õt�6Õ©§�� Ý ídÙ<Ø»§�×�� Ý �_Õ©§��t�_ò��"§�� Ý Ö&Ù Ü ��������êb§�� Ù Ü ì¬ê Ü ê<���ªì�� Ü §³� Ü �¼×�ê<ë"§��&��}���^§Ä����Õt§&é²ï�����ó��]êÂò���� �ªØ÷� Ü §���Ù Ý ��Ö1§�� Ù Ü � Ü êb§t§���� ò��"§�� Ý ����êbë�×�§���ê Ü ÕtØÙ��tì¬êb§��_Ù Ü ê Ü�Ý Õ�×�Ù¥ôð§�×�� Ü §�×��³Ö&Ù�yÖ&Ù�ì�ë�ñ_�1§�� Ü �&ÕtÕ�ÙbØ�§�×��mì�Ù Ý �&ñbÖ¹êb§��&��Ù<�tí��¿ø ï ° ����� ®�� ¯ ��Õ�� Ý §�Ù³Ö&Ù Ü Õ©§��t��Öª§�§�×��Àë"��Õ�×�Ù<�"§�� Ü §�×��mÖ&êb§��ª��Ù��tíÏ�Ð6¢ ����� ®�� ¯ ã���·*¸rå1�lïÂÖªÙ Ü Ö&ñ � Ý �¬ô³��§�×)§�×��p� Ü §���Ù Ý ��Ö1§��_Ù Ü §�Ù Ý �_Õ©§���� ò��"§�� Ý ����ê<ë�×)§���ê Ü ÕtØÙ��tì¬êb§��_Ù ÜØÙ�� Ý �_Õ©§��t�_ò��"§�� Ý ����ê<ë�×�Õ°ô³� §�×cêb§�§����_ò"�"§�� Ý �<��ê<ë�×"ÕqêbÕ]ñ Ù�Ö&ê<ñ�Õ©§¡êb§��&Õª�

¥�§z¥�§ � ì �#� ¢ � �¡ð ���2ï Ð6¢�íU£�� � ¢ í � ¤��kø@¢ Æ í ��� ø �«�í�ë¤�&Õ6ê<ñ_ñ Ù¥ô¿§�Ù Ý �_Õ©§�� Ü ����� Õ�× Ü Ù Ý �ªÕÂÙ��¾� Ý ���&ÕÂô³� §�×�� Ü êd�<��ê<ë�×���ø]Ù+ôµ�ªó<�&�ªé�§�×��¯§ní�ëz�ªÕ6Ùbص�ªñ_�ªì�� Ü §�Õì¯��Õt§uòz�^ë"���&Õt�&�©ó�� Ý ò�í¯ì�Ù���ë�×"�_Õ�ì�Õ&��ïkØè§ní�ëz�ªÕÀÕ�×�Ù��"ñ Ý §¡êP{<�^§�×"�^��Ù�ñ �^Ù<Øèë�êb��ê<ì��ª§��&��Õ°ã{��� Ü �&�t�_Ö¼§ní�ë¤�&Õ¡åÏé§�×�� Õ¼Õt§���� Öª§¼§ní�ë�� Ü �¯�t�&%²���_�t�&Õ°ê Ü �"ì¯òz�ª�¼Ù<ØÈì�Ù��të�×��_Õtì�Õªé²Ù Ü �£ØÙ��µ�¹ê<Ö¡×´ÖªÙ�ì¯ò�� Ü êb§��_Ù Ü Ù<Ø÷§ní�ë¤�&Õ&é�§�Ù Ý ��yÕ�Ö&�t�_ò¤�¯§�×�� Õ¾Õ���§���ê�§��_Ù Ü �rï Ü Ù�� Ý �&�¾§�Ù Ý �&Öª���¹êbÕ��>§�×��>ê<ì�Ù�� Ü §/Ù<Ø�ì�Ù���ë"×��_Õtì�ÕÂêp×"�_��×��ª�Âñ_�1ó��&ñ¡{�� Ü�Ý Ù<اní�ë"� Ü ��Ö&Ù Ü Ö&�&ë�§£� Õ]� Ü §���Ù Ý ��Öª� Ý éèÖ&ê<ñ_ñ � Ý �,/�/{��+{�10¾/n�3)�ñ<�t�1¢���/-�t�,4U-Yw¹���Ï���,/�+4��4�é�ô³×��&�t�r×�� ��×¾ykñ_�ªó<�&ñ÷§ní�ë¤�&Õê<���°Ö&ê<ñ_ñ � Ý �,/5/-��+{�102/���-1�À«°×��³ò�êbÕ��_Ö°� Ý �¹êÂÙ<Øzêb§t§��t�_ò��"§��&ÕÀ� Õu§�Ù6ê<ñ_ñ Ù¥ô�§�×��°×�ê Ü"Ý ñ_� Ü �ÂÙ<ؤ§ní�ë¤�&Õµê<ò�Õ©§���ê<Öª§�ñ í��«°×��_ÕÂ� ÕÂ���¹êbñ_�.�ª� Ý ò�íl§�×��±ë����ªÕ�� Ü Ö&��Ù<صÖ&Ù��t���&ÕtëzÙ Ü�Ý � Ü �dóbê<�t�hê<ò"ñ_�&Õ¾ê Ü�Ý êpÖ&Ù Ü Ö&�&ë�§¶Ù<صê<ÕtÕ�� � Ü ì�� Ü §/Ù<ا�×��ªÕ��>ó<êb���hêbò�ñ_�ªÕÂ� Ü ê Ü êbÖª§���ê<ñÀÕ���§���êb§��_Ù Ü �V�^§t§��t�_ò��"§�� Ý ����ê<ë"×�Õ/� Ü §��ª����êb§��>Õt§��t��Öª§�����êbñ£ã�4�ö�<������êbë�×��ÖyÖ¹ê<ñhå£ê<Õ�ë¤�&Ö1§�Õ/Ù<صê´Õtí�Õt§��&ì ô³��§�× Ý êb§�꬧ní�ëz��ê<Õtëz�ªÖª§�Õ�ã�4�ö�<�6Ö¹ê<ñ Ö&��ñ_êb§�� Ù Ü Õ£ÙbØ�óbê<ñ ���&Õ�å1�r«°×��_ÕÂñ �¹ê Ý Õ¾§�ÙÖ&Ù�ì�ë�ê<Ö1§ Ý �ªÕ�Öª���_ë�§��_Ù Ü Õ¼� Ü ô³×�� Ö¡×´�<�ö���uô¼�ªñ_ñu{ Ü Ù¥ô Ü ê<����§�×�ì��ª§��_Ö³Ù�ë¤�&��ê�§��_Ù Ü Õ Ü �&� Ý´Ü Ù<§°ê<�©§��Ö��Ö&�_ê<ñ_ñ�í¶ò¤�Ö&Ù Ý � Ý � Ü §�Ù>����ê<ë�×�� Ö¹ê<ñ�Õt§��t��Öª§������ªÕ&�

�^§�§��t�_ò���§�� Ý ����ê<ë�×�Õ/êb��� Ý ��� Ü � Ý ò�í�ë�ê<�©§��_ê<ñuê<ñ ���&ò"��ê<Õª�¶ï]Õt§¡êb�t§Âô³� §�×:ê´ò���� �ªØ�� Ü §��tÙ Ý ��Öª§��_Ù Ü � Ü §�×�� Õ§�Ù�ë�� Ö<é�ê±ì�Ù���� Ý �ª§¡êb�_ñ_� Ý §����&êb§�ì�� Ü §³� Õ°��� ó<� Ü � Ü �òxµ����� ® égô³�&�_Ê<�,�-�� -�+Öñ,4¤�,/50��¡���ðË ãX��Ò�ô ò å¼ÖªÙ Ü Õt�_Õt§�ÕqÙbØÀê>Õ��ª§£Ù<ØuÕtÙ��t§ Ü êbì��ªÕ��Ûê Ü�Ý ê±Ø{ê<ì��_ñ�í¬Ù<Ø�Ù�ë¤�&��ê�§��_Ù ÜcÜ ê<ì��ªÕô ò Ëüã�ô ò Ô ÜÝÜÝÜ Ù " å Ô " ÜÝÜÝÜ " Ù " "! ó � Ü�Ý �1Á�� Ý ò�í�§�×��&� �Âê<����§�� �&Õ&�$#¾ëz�ª��êb§��_Ù Ü�Ü êbì��ªÕ » ü Ñ ô ò Ô " ÜÝÜÝÜ " Ù " ê<�t�Ý � Ü Ùb§�� Ý ò²í » üc�2� Þ ���� 8 ¬ ���¡� -�0"�1ûX-�+Öñ,4¤�,/�0����mÙ<Ø��Û�_Õ�êrÕt�_� Ü ê�§����t�%�&�"Ëþã��'�_Ò�ô ò � åÀô³×��ª�����'� ' �ê Ü�Ý ô ò � Ë ã¸ô ò � Ô ÜÝÜÝÜ Ù " å Ô " ÜÝÜÝÜ " Ù " (! ó*) �_ÕrêcØ{êbì�� ñ í}Ù<Ø°Ù�ë¤�&��êb§�� Ù Ü Õ/Õ���Ö¡× §�×�êb§r�¹ê<Ö¡×)Õ��ª§�ô ò � Ô ÜÝÜÝÜ Ù " � Üô ò � �_Õ³ê>Õ���ò"Õ��ª§qÙ<Ø>ô ò Ô ÜÝÜÝÜ Ù " � Ü ô ò �� ¢"�<��/5+{�<�+��û©�<�òñ��&�&�t���ÿË ãtã5� å (! ó ҥ㠻 ü-,÷å �r� !*.�; å±� Õ±��� ó<� Ü ò²í�ê Ü �Ëyn� Ü�Ý �ÏÁ"� Ý Ø{êbì�� ñ íAÙ<ؾÖ&ê<���t�_�ª�Õ��ª§�Õ�ã5� å "! ó ê Ü"Ý ØÙ��¾�¹êbÖ¡×AÙ<ëz�ª��êb§��_Ù ÜlÜ ê<ì�� » ü)�l� Þ � g� 8 ¬ �±§�×��&�t�±�_ÕÂêpë�ê<�t§��hê<ñ�ì¬êbë�ë�� Ü � » ü�,y�� Ô (ð��õ(k� Ù ¬ � �dº � Ý � Ü Ù<§��¬ò²íÍû » � ã » ü-,÷å§�×���)������,+ù4lÙ<سê}ë�ê<�t§��hê<ñÀì�ê<ë�ë"� Ü � » ü�,»����Äy�ê<ñ ���&ò���ê¯�_Õ�/n��/k�<��� Ø » ü�,l�_ճꯧ�Ùb§¡ê<ñ÷ì�ê<ë�ë"� Ü �¯ØÙ��°�&ê<Ö¡× » üc� Ü ô ò ��èÙ<�¼ê¶�<� ó�� Ü ë�ê<�©§��hêbñ/�Äynê<ñ_�<�&ò���ê^�¶é�ñ_�1§ � Ëþã�� å "! ó òz�£ê´�ËynÕ��"ò�Õ��1§³Ù<Ø �vËþã5� å "! ó é"�-�Ã�b�(� ' � ØÙ��¼�&ê<Ö¡×´Õ�Ù��©§]� Ñ �°�À«°×"� Ü �þ�_ÕµÖ¹ê<ñ ñ_� Ý êc�1�_��-¥�3)�-�0���-¥��/¤Ù<Ø��ré"� Ø�ê Ü�Ý Ù Ü ñ�í�� Ø÷ØÙ��¼ê<ñ_ñ » ü|�2� Þ ���� 8 ¬

­<­ �

Page 118: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

� Ñ ô ò ê Ü"Ý ê<ñ_ñ»ã ø Þ Ò¹�� Ò ø 8 å Ñ ã�� Ô (:��²(�� Ù å 0�û » � ã » ü , åµÙ Ü �¾ê<ñ_ÕtÙ¯×�ê¹ó�� » ü , ã ø Þ Ò¹� �Ò ø 8 å Ñ � �� ë�ê<�t§��hê<ñ1�Äy�ê<ñ ���&ò���ê´� � Õ^§�×�� Ü êL-�0"�¡�<�òñ��&�&�t�/Ù<Ø�§�×"�6ë�ê<�t§��hê<ñ��Äynê<ñ_�<�&ò���ê��¶é�� Ø»ê Ü"Ý Ù Ü ñ íp��Ø

ã�� å (! ó �_Õ³ê±Ö&ñ Ù�Õ�� Ý Õt��ò�Õt�ª§qÙ<Ø¡� ØÙ��£�&ê<Ö¡× » ü ��� Þ ���� 8 ¬ � Ñ ô ò é » ü�2ý�_Õ]§�×��±�t�&Õt§���� Öª§�� Ù Ü Ù<Ø » ü-, §�ÙAã�� Ô (ý �z(W� Ù åÏé÷�4�ö�<�

Ù Ü �/×�ê<Õ¡û » � ã » ü 2 åmË û » � ã » ü , å�0 ã�� Ô ( ���(³� Ù åÏ��èÙ<�¾ê´��� ó<� Ü �Äynê<ñ_���ªò���êZ�oê Ü�Ý êpÕ��"ò¾ynÕt�_� Ü ê�§����t�3� � Ù<Ø4�£é�§�×��3� � ûn�¡�3),0���/£��4I� �_Õ£§�×��5� � ynê<ñ_�<�&ò���ê� � ô³×��&�t�^� � ËÂ� ØÙ��°�¹êb֡׳� Ñ � � ê Ü"Ý » ü-, ) Ë » ü-,lØÙ��°�¹êbÖ¡× » ü Ñ ô ò � ��Â/n��/k�<����ûX�����¬���¬���k¢��2+.-1� Ål�Ã�¬ �vòz�1§nô¼�ª� Ü ë�ê<�©§��_ê<ñ6�Äy�ê<ñ ���&ò"��ê<Õ��Ûê Ü�Ý � � ÕÈ��� ó<� Ü ò�írê]Ø{ê<ì��_ñ�íÙ<Ø�§�Ù<§¡ê<ñÈì�ê<ë�ë�� Ü ��Õ*ÅlËoãXÅ �2� ¬ � å (! ó Õt��Ö¡×l§�×�êb§qØÙ<�]�1ó��ª�tí}Ù�ëz�ª��êb§��_Ù Ü » ü�� � Þ ���� 8 ¬ �¯ê Ü�ÝØÙ��³�¹ê<Ö¡× ã ø Þ Ò¹� �Ò ø 8 å^� Ü ãY� Ô ( � è(�� Ù å^×�Ù�ñ Ý Õ³§�×�êb§³ô³×�� Ü �ªó<�&�>ã ø Þ Ò& � Ò ø 8 å^�_Õ³� Ü û » � ã » ü , 弧�×"� ÜãXÅ Ô ã ø Þ åÏÒ¹� �Ò�Å Ù ã ø 8 åtåp�_Õ´� Ü û » � ã » ü�2Èå´ê Ü�Ý » ü�2mã�Å Ô ã ø Þ åÏÒ¹ ��Ò�Å Ù ã ø 8 åtå Ë Å ã » ü�,uã ø Þ Ò& � Ò ø 8 åtå1� �¢"�<��/5+{�<����ûX�����¬���¬���k¢��2+.-1� Å8�u�87 � � ÕÂêp§�Ù<§�ê<ñ+�Äyn×"Ù�ì�Ù<ì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ì 9Å8�rû » � ã5�¾å�¬ � Ø��Ù�ì êÖ&ñ_Ù<Õ�� Ý Õ��"ò¾y�ê<ñ ���&ò"��ê¥û » � ãY�Âå ' �¿§�ÙV�¬�: ��ó�� Ü ê Ü �Ëyn� Ü"Ý �1Á�� Ý Õ��1§<; Ëwã=; å "! ó Ùbؾ���<��+{���&�_��-1é÷§�×���Õ�Ù<�t§�� Ý Õt�ª§n· � ã>;AåÂË ãù· � ã>;Aå å (! ó Ù<Ø/��1�Ï��-°� Õ Ý �t� Ü � Ý � Ü"Ý ��Öª§�� ó<�&ñ í¤�=�mê<Ö¡×|óbê<���_ê<ò�ñ �¾ä�Ù<Ø�; � Õqê>§��ª��ì Ù<Ø�Õ�Ù��©§��¶ê Ü�Ý ØÙ��]ê<ñ ñõÙ�ë¤�&��ê�§��_Ù ÜÜ ê<ì��&Õ » ü|�e� Þ � g� 8 ¬ ��ê Ü�Ý ê<ñ ñ � Þ Ñ · � ã>;Aå Ô Ò¹� �Ò � 8 Ñ · � ã=;:å Ù ê<ñ_ÕtÙ » üÈã � Þ Ò¹�� Ò � 8 å��_ÕÈ꼧��&�tì·Ù<Ø�Õ�Ù��©§���»«°×���/n�1�1� �<�òñ��&�&��� · � ã=;AåÈô/�Ã�ª�ö§&�?�ÛË ãX��Ò�ô ò å�ê Ü�Ý ;ü×�ê<ÕuØÙ<�u�¹ê<Ö¡×>ÕtÙ��t§ Ü ê<ì��«�³� Ü ��§�×��°Õ��1§mÙ<ا��&�tì�ÕR· � ã=;:å ê<ÕmÖ&ê<���t�_�&��Õ��ª§mØÙ��ÀÕtÙ��t§ �]ê Ü�Ý ØÙ��À�¹êbÖ¡×�Ù�ë¤�&��êb§�� Ù Ü±Ü ê<ì�� » ü|�e� Þ � g� 8 ¬ �]ê Ü�Ý §��ª��ì�Õ� ö � Ü · � ã=;Aå ÿ ØÙ<�»Ó»Ë ­ Ò¹ �öâ�ôµ� Ý ��� Ü � » ü °�@îBA ¯ ã � Þ Ò¹ ��Ò � 8 å¼� Ë » ü�ã � Þ Ò¹ ��Ò � 8 åÏ�¡� Ü ��-�-�+Öñ,4��¬��4�/�Ù<Ø�ó<êb���Öyê<ò�ñ_�ªÕ�; ËCã=; å "! ó � Ü ê³ë�ê<�©§��_ê<ñ?�Äy�êbñ_���ªò���ê«�ý�_Õ�ê°Ø{ê<ì�� ñ íqÙ<Ø�§�Ù<§�ê<ñ�ì¬êbë�ë�� Ü ��Õ�ã ø � � �C; ¬ � å "! ó �«°×��c�1���<�d0"�,/�+4��4�Ù<Ø�§��&�tì�Õ]� Ü�Ý �ª�¾ê Ü ê<ÕtÕ��_� Ü ì�� Ü §±ã ø � � �?; ¬ � å (! ó � Ü ê>ë�ê<�©§��_ê<ñD�Äy�ê<ñ ���&ò"��ê´��_ÕmêÂë�ê<�©§��hêbñ��Äyn×�Ù<ì�Ù�ì�Ù��të�×��_Õtì ø � � , �~· � ã=;AåE7 � Õ��"Ö¡×�§�×�êb§ ø � � , ãäzåmË ø � � ã äzåuØÙ<�mê<ñ_ñ�ä Ñ ; �ï Ü §�×��¬Õ��&%²���ªñ^ïÂ� Ü §���Ù Ý ��Ö&�¬êb§�§���� ò��"§�� Ý ����ê<ë�×�Õ¶ê<Õ¶§�×��ªí)ê<����ë����ªÕ�� Ü §�� Ý ò�íé�¼ñ_êCF�� Ü ê Ü�Ý Ç&GÙbô¼�p� Ü� �^Ç�� �-� � Ü �,/5/{��+{�102/n�3)Wñ<�t�1¢��A�_Õ¬ê ë�ê<�©§��hêbñqêbñ_���ªò���êAÙ+ó<�&�dê)Õt�_� Ü êb§����t�lÖ&Ù Ü Õ�� Õt§�� Ü � Ù<اnôµÙyÕ��"ò¾yÕ��_� Ü êb§��"���&ÕqÖ&Ù Ü"Ü �&Ö1§�� Ý ò�í}� Ü ê<�©í|Ù�ë¤�&��êb§�� Ù Ü Õª�H# Ü �¯Õt��ò¾ynÕt�_� Ü êb§����t� Ý �ªÕ�Öª���_ò¤�&Õq§�×��¯�<��ê<ë�×"�_Ö¹êbñ»ë�êb�t§¹é§�×��/Ù<§�×��&�³Ù Ü �/§�×"�rê�§�§��t�_ò���§��/ë�ê<�©§¹�m«°×��6� Ü ê<�©ídÙ�ëz�ª��êb§��_Ù Ü Õ°Ö&Ù Ü�Ü �&Öª§qÕ�Ù<ì��/Õ�Ù<�t§�Õ³Ù<Ø»§�×��/����ê<ë�×�� Ö¹ê<ñë�ê<�t§Àô³��§�×�Õ�Ù��©§�ÕmÙ<ؤ§�×�� Ý ê�§¡ê/ë�ê<�t§&��«°×��1í�� Ü�Ý � Ö¹êb§��¼ô³×�� ֡׬����ê<ë�×�� Ö¹ê<ñ�Õ�Ù��©§µÕt×�ê<ñ ñ�òz�³Ö¹êb���tí±êb§�§����_ò"�"§��ªÕê Ü�Ý ô³×�� Ü é<ô³×�� Ö¡×´{²� Ü�Ý Ù<ؤêb§�§���� ò��"§��b�»«°×"�_Õ¡{²� Ü�Ý Ù<ØèÕt�_� Ü êb§����t�µ� Õ�Ö&ê<ñ_ñ � Ý �,/�/{��+{�10¾/n�3)�ñ<�t�1¢��^-�+Öñ,4¤�,/50��¡�1�Ï ���¡�Ë�ù� � ø �å¥�§z¥�§ � ð í �#� ¢ � �¡ð ���2ïåî ¢ í £»� ¤ �5îu� í � ð�¢ �Qñ� Ü �,/5/-��+{�102/��3)Wñ<���1¢��¦-�+Öñ,4¤�,/50����I�4J"K Ë � ó � �^5 ó �ML J �d�d� ÖªÙ Ü Õ�� Õt§�ÕpÙ<Ørê Õ�� � Ü êb§������N� ó ËãX� ó Ò�ô ò ó å�ô³×��&�t�¡ô ò ó Ö&Ù Ü §�ê<� Ü ÕÀ� Ü ê<�tí¯Ù�ëz�ª��êb§��_Ù Ü ÕÀÙ Ü ñ í<é�Ö¹êbñ_ñ_� Ý ñ<���1¢���-�+Öñ,4¤�,/�0����1é�êÂÕt�_� Ü ê�§����t��^5 ó Ëoã��÷5 ó Ò�ô ò 5 ó å1éèÖ¹ê<ñ ñ_� Ý )��,/4�Z-�+Öñ,4¤�,/�0����1ézê Ü�Ý ê Ü � ó (��÷5 ó yn� Ü�Ý �1Á�� Ý Ø{ê<ì��_ñ�ípÙ<Ø�Ù�ëz�ª��êb§��_Ù Ü ÕL J �d�d� Ë ã L J �d�d�POPQ O ) å (! ó ÕSR " ) ! ó x R � <TVU í Æ £ ÅY�j¥�§ � ©µð í �#� ¢ � �Ëð ���2ïaî ¢ í £»� ¤ �Yîu� í � ð�¢ ��ñ«°×��6êb§�§����_ò"�"§�� Ý �<��ê<ë�×cÕ�� � Ü êb§������Â�"Õ�� Ý ØÙ��^§�×"�6Ö&ê<Õ��/Õ©§�� Ý íd� Õ°��� ó<� Ü òz�ªñ_Ù¥ô/�

� ó Ë ¤ªøu¢ � ¤/É » W Ò¡3 ø î�îbÓ4ç¹îø@£ � ¤ � �²3 ø îbî�Ókç¹în¬ É » W

­<­�­

Page 119: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

�^5 ó ˤ � ¢ �5��î � � í � �ø@£ � ¤6ç � ü � æ´�g¬ � � î�Ó4âYX

â�ç&ä � ��â ø � � � î�Ó4âYX´¬ � � î�Ó4âYX� ø á"ç�Z4ü�î�ÓXÎ ø � çr�e� � î�Ó4âYX�¬ � � î�Ó4âYXL J �d�d� Ë

ø@£ � ¤rÉ » W ú�Éü�²3 ø îbî�Ókç¹î�¬ â ø �îbç#βâ�î¯�²3 ø îbî�Ókç¹î�¬ � � îbÓ-âYXW » â � ç¹â �6�²3 ø î�îbÓ4ç¹î�¬ � � î�Ó4âYX

«°×��Â����êbë�×dÕ��_� Ü êb§��"���¾ÖªÙ Ü §¡ê<� Ü Õ°ê¯Õ�Ù<�t§]É » W ØÙ��µ§�×�� Ý Ù�Ö&�"ì�� Ü §�Õ³ê Ü�Ý ê¯ÕtÙ��t§]3 ø îbî�Ókç¹î6ØÙ��^Ö¹êb���tí�� Ü �§�×��±ê�§�§��t�_ò���§��&Õ£Ù<Ø�ê Ý Ù�Ö&��ì�� Ü §&�«°×��_ÕÂê�§�§��t�_ò���§��¶Ö&ê<���t�_�ª�£�_Õ Ü �&Öª�&Õ�Õ�ê<�tí|§�ÙpÖ¡×�ê Ü ���>êb§t§���� ò��"§��&Õ&�¾�èÙ<�ì�Ù��t�¼� Ü ØÙ���ì�êb§��_Ù Ü Õ��ª�n�öÇ�ö¾º[� ® �-��«°×"� Ý êb§�ê£Õ�� � Ü êb§������^ÖªÙ Ü Õt�_Õt§�ÕuÙ<Ø�§�×��^��Õt��ê<ñ"Õt�_� Ü êb§����t�¼ØÙ��»Õt§��t� Ü �<Õê Ü�Ý�Ü êb§��"��ê<ñ Ü ��ì¶òz�ª��Õ&�Àï»ê Ý�Ý Õ�Ù<ì��°Õtëz�ªÖ&�hêbñ�Ù�ëz�ª��êb§��_Ù Ü Õ�§�Ù/§�×�� Ý êb§¡ê/Õ�� � Ü êb§������ Ü �ª� Ý � Ý � Ü §�×��³Ö¹ê<Õt�Õt§�� Ý í��·«°×"��êb§�§���� ò��"§�� Ù Ü Ù�ëz�ª��êb§��_Ù Ü Õ�� Ü L J �d�d� ê Ý�Ý §�×���ê<Ö1§���ê<ñqêb§t§���� ò��"§��&ÕpÉ » W ú�É|é^îbç#Î�âzîAê Ü�ÝW » â � ç¹â � §�Ù>§�×"�rê�§�§��t�_ò���§��ÂÖ¹êb����� �&�^ÙbØÀê Ý Ù�Ö&��ì�� Ü §¹� <�8ë�êb�t§��_ê<ñ6�4J"K y�êbñ_���ªò���êÊ��ØÙ<�»ê Ü êb§t§���� ò��"§�� Ý �<��ê<ë�×rÕ�� � Ü êb§������&�4J"K ë��tÙ+ó�� Ý �&Õ�êqë�ê<�©§��_ê<ñø^�¡ynê<ñ_�<�&ò���ê� ó ØÙ��°§�×"�¶����ê<ë�×|Õt�_� Ü êb§����t�n¸��Ûò�íd§�×���¸��Ëyk��� Ý ��Öª§qÙ Ü �ré¤ê�ë�ê<�©§��_ê<ñÈÉ��Ëy�ê<ñ ���&ò"��ê´� 5 ó ØÙ��°§�×��Ý êb§¡ê´Õt�_� Ü ê�§����t�>É��eò�íl§�×���É��Ëyn��� Ý ��Ö1§/Ù Ü �oê Ü�Ý ë�ê<�t§��hê<ñ»ì¬êbë�ë�� Ü ��Õ ø �9� î , ØÙ<�Â�¹ê<Ö¡×AÙ�ë¤�&��ê�§��_Ù ÜÜ ê<ì�� ø �9� î¬� Ü L J �d�d� �6\�� Ü Öª�¯ï Ý Ù Ü Ùb§¾� Ü §�� Ü�Ý §�Ù Ý �¹êbñ»ô³� §�×lë�ê<�©§��_ê<ñÈ����ê<ë"×�Õt§��t��Öª§������ªÕ&é÷ôµ�¯���ªÕt§����_Ö1§§�×���¸^�Ëy�ê<ñ ���&ò���êL� ó §�Ùdò¤�¯§�Ù<§�ê<ñ4�n�£Õ¾ôµ�&ñ ñu§�×��±Ù�ë¤�&��êb§�� Ù Ü Õ£ØÙ<�ÂÙ�ëz�ª��êb§��_Ù Ü|Ü ê<ì��&ÕÂ� Ü L J �d�d� ×�ê¹ó��§�Ùdòz�±§�Ù<§¡ê<ñ�Õ�� Ü Ö&�±ô¼�>�t�&%²���_�t��ê´§�Ù<§¡êbñÀêb§�§���� ò��"§�� Ù Ü Ù<ص����ê<ë�×�� Ö¹ê<ñuÙ<ò2�t�&Ö1§�Õ&��«°×��ª���ªØÙ<���<é�ê Ý ì�� Õ�Õ�� ò�ñ_��4J\K ynê<ñ_�<�&ò���ê<Õ³ê<���6ë�ê<�©§��_ê<ñ��4J"K y�ê<ñ ���&ò"��ê<Õ^ô³×��ª���6§�×��^¸��Ëyk��� Ý ��Öª§q�_Õ°§�Ùb§¡ê<ñÈê Ü"Ý �¹êbÖ¡×lÙ�ë¤�&��ê�§��_Ù Ü ØÙ<�ê Ü Ù�ëz�ª��êb§��_Ù ÜdÜ êbì��Â� Ü L J �d�d� �_ճꯧ�Ù<§�ê<ñ÷ì�ê<ë�ë�� Ü ���Ï ���¡�Ë�ù� � ø �å¥�§z¥�§p¨µð í �#� ¢ � �¡ð ���2ïåî ¢ í £»� ñ: ��ó�� Ü ê Ü ê�§�§��t�_ò���§�� Ý �<��ê<ë�×�Õt�_� Ü êb§����t�5�4J"K éõê Ü �,/5/-��+{�102/��3)6ñ<�t�1¢���ô/�ö�&� §¹���4J"K �_ÕÂêpë�ê<�t§��hê<ñ��4J\K yê<ñ_���ªò���ê��·ô³×"�&���6� §�Õʸ��Ëyk��� Ý ��Öª§]ê<ñ ���&ò"��ê��� ó �_Õ^§�Ù<§¡ê<ñ÷ê Ü�Ý §�×�� L J �d�d� Ù<ëz�ª��êb§��_Ù Ü Õ³êb���¾§�Ùb§¡ê<ñ÷ì�ê<ë¾yë�� Ü �<Õ&�rº �±Ö¹êbñ_ñ»§�×���¸^�¡yk��� Ý ��Öª§��� ó ñ<�t�1¢��2+4���<���<�òñ��&�&���<éz§�×���É��Ëyn�t� Ý �"Öª§�� 5 ó )��,/4�|�<�òñ��&�&�t�±ê Ü�ݧ�×���Ø{ê<ì�� ñ í|Ù<Ø^§�Ùb§¡ê<ñmì�ê<ë�ë�� Ü ��Õ ø �9� î , �Ë� ó ¬ � 5 ó ) ØÙ��rê<ñ_ñ ø �9� îA�¡�I¬ � � Ñ L J �d�d� �,/5/-��+{�102/�+4��4�¡¢��1���,/5+4��4U-1� <� ���&ñ_êb§�� Ù Ü ò¤�ª§nôµ�&� Ü êb§t§���� ò��"§�� Ý ����ê<ë�×�Õ�� Þ ê Ü�Ý �£.Âô/�Ã�ª�ö§&�Èê Ü êb§t§���� ò��"§�� Ý ����êbë�×�Õ�� � Ü êb§������3�4J"K �_Õ¾����ó�� Ü ò�í:êpë�êb�t§��_ê<ñE�4J"K yk×�Ù�ì�Ù�ì�Ù<��ë�×�� Õ�ì Å8�u� Þ 7 �£.¹�´ø]Ù¥ô¼�1ó��&�ªé�ï]� Ü §�� Ü�Ý êp§�Ù<§�ê<ñ��t�&ñhê�§��_Ù Üòz�1§nô¼�ª� Ü §�×�� Ý êb§¡ê}ê<ñ_�<�&ò���ê<Õ&éuÕt��Ö¡× §�×�êb§¯�&ê<Ö¡×y�&ñ �&ì�� Ü §¯Ù<ØÊ� 5 óÞ ×�ê<Õ¯ê Ü �_ì�ê<����� Ü � 5 ó. �|«°×�� Õ¶� Õì�Ù<§�� óbêb§�� Ý ò�íA§��ªÖ¡× Ü �_Ö&ê<ñ¼�t�¹ê<ÕtÙ Ü Õ¯§�×�êb§¯�t�&%²��� ���¬§�Ù<§¡ê<ñ�×�Ù�ì�Ù�ì�Ù���ë"×��_Õtì�ÕÂØÙ��¶§�×�� Ý ê�§¡ê|ë�êb�t§¯Õt� Ü Öª�Ö&Ù�ñ �_ì�� §�ÕµÙ<Ø�ê<��ò���§���ê<�tí�ë�ê<�©§��hêbñõê<ñ_�<�&ò���ê<Õ°ê Ü�Ý ë�ê<�©§��_ê<ñ�×�Ù<ì�Ù�ì�Ù��të�×��_Õtì�Õ Ý Ù Ü Ù<§]�1Á��_Õ©§]� Ü ��� Ü �&��ê<ñ4�Ï ���¡�Ë�ù� � ø �å¥�§z¥�§ ĵð í �#� ¢ � �¡ð ���2ïåî ¢ í £»� Æ ø@¢�£»� � ¤ Æ¿ñ� Ü �,/5/-��+{�102/��3)*ñ<�t�1¢��¶�¬���k¢��2+.-1�µý}�Ã� Þ ¬ �q.�ô/�ö�&� §¹�bê Ü êb§t§��t�_ò��"§�� Ý ����ê<ë"׶Õ�� � Ü êb§������4�4J"K ò¤�ª§nôµ�&� ܧnô¼Ù êb§�§���� ò��"§�� Ý ����êbë�×�Õ�� Þ ê Ü�Ý �£.±ô/�ö�&� §¹�]�4J"K �_Õ±ê�ë�ê<�©§��_ê<ñ^�4J"K yn×�Ù�ì�Ù�ì�Ù���ë"×��_Õtìÿô³×"�&���´§�×�����&Õ©§��t�_Öª§��_Ù Ü ý 5 ó �Ã� 5 óÞ ¬ � 5 ó. §�Ù±§�×�� Ý êb§�ê±ë�ê<�t§]� ճ걧�Ù<§¡êbñõÉ��Ëyn×�Ù<ì�Ù�ì�Ù��të�×��_Õtì}� <�uÁ"ê<ì�ë�ñ �&Õ´Ù<Ørêb§t§���� ò��"§�� Ý ����êbë�×�Õdê Ü�Ý êb§t§��t�_ò��"§�� Ý ����ê<ë�×iì�Ù<��ë�×�� Õ�ì�Õ�ô³��§�×i���ªÕ�ë¤�&Öª§d§�Ùý§�×��:êb§½y§���� ò��"§�� Ý ����êbë�×ýÕ��_� Ü êb§��"���´Ù<Ø]§�×��´Ö&ê<Õ��dÕ©§�� Ý íý� Ü ��Á�êbì�ë�ñ �´��� ­ �:ê<���´����ó�� Ü � Ü �¼×�ê<ë"§��&�Z}�éµ\��&Ö�y§��_Ù Ü }�� ® ê Ü�Ý ØÙ�ñ ñ_Ù¥ô³� Ü �¯Õ��ªÖª§�� Ù Ü Õª�

­<­ }

Page 120: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

�£ñ_ñ²ê�§�§��t�_ò���§�� Ý ����ê<ë�×�Õ»ê Ü�Ý êb§t§���� ò��"§�� Ý ����ê<ë"×rì�Ù���ë"×��_Õtì�Õõô/�ö�&� §¹�_�4J"K ØÙ��tì�ê]Ö&êb§��ª��Ù��©í�ì Å5î ã��&`badc�åÏ�ï Ü §�×"��ØÙ�ñ ñ_Ù¥ô³� Ü �´ï*�"Á)ê Ü êb§�§���� ò��"§�� Ý �<��ê<ë�× Õ�� � Ü êb§������e�4J"K ê Ü"Ý ê<ÕtÕ���ì���§�×�êb§6�¹êbÖ¡×yêb§�§���� ò��"§�� Ý����ê<ë"ׯ�_Õ�ê Ü êb§t§���� ò��"§�� Ý ����ê<ë�׶ô/�ö�&� §¹�C�4J"K ê Ü�Ý �&ê<Ö¡×>êb§�§���� ò��"§�� Ý ����ê<ë�ׯì�Ù���ë"×��_Õtì¿�_Õuê Ü êb§�§���� ò��"§�� Ý����ê<ë"× ì�Ù<��ë�×�� Õ�ì ô/�ö�&� §¹�E�4J"K �|ï Ý � Ü Ù<§��¬§�×"�pÖ¹êb§��&��Ù<�tíºì Å5î ã��&`badc�å6� Ü §�×"�¬ØÙ�ñ_ñ Ù¥ô³� Ü �dÕ�×"Ù��t§�ñ í ò²íì�Ð6¢��

>^¢+ø@£Àøu¤ �Y��� ø �¦¥�§z¥�§z¥¼�JDE�²�KUH9EGÁUT F9µjì6Ð�¢�J�KPM*KPo.o˲tT o.SpOZSXH�M1b <v¼���¥�sw«°×��´ë���Õt×�Ù��"§>ÖªÙ Ü Õt§�����Ö1§�� Ù Ü �_Õ¯����ó�� Ü � Ü �ò�^ÇD� �4� : ��ó�� Ü §nô¼Ù êb§�§���� ò��"§�� Ý ����ê<ë�×ýì�Ù<��ë�×�� Õ�ì�Õ¥ýi�� ¬ � ê Ü�Ý Xp�Ã�¬ 3�é�§�×��/ë���Õ�×"Ù��"§]�_Õ°ÖªÙ Ü Õt§�����Ö1§�� Ý � Ü §�×����ª�rÕ©§��&ë"Õ&�

­ �*�¼Ù Ü Õ©§����"Öª§]§�×��6ë���Õt×�Ù��"§qÙ<Ø¢ý� ó �e�� ó ¬ �� ó ê Ü�Ý X¾ ó �e�� ó ¬ 3n ó � Ü §�×��6Ö¹êb§��&��Ù��©ídÙ<ا�Ù<§�ê<ñ ¸^�Ëy�ê<ñ ���&ò���ê<Õ°ê Ü"Ý ë�êb�t§��_ê<ñ�¸^�Ëyn×�Ù<ì�Ù�ì�Ù��të�×��_Õtì�Õ��öÇ]GÙ<ô�� ® �4�

}��*�¼Ù Ü Õ©§����"Öª§°§�×"�Âë���Õ�×"Ù��"§]Ù<Ø>ý 5 ó �Ã� 5 ó ¬ � 5 ó ê Ü�Ý X 5 ó �Ã� 5 ó ¬ 3 5 ó � Ü §�×��ÂÖ&êb§��ª��Ù��tí¬Ù<Øë�ê<�©§��hêbñ÷É��Ëy�êbñ_���ªò���ê<Õ^ê Ü�Ý §�Ù<§�ê<ñõÉ��Ëyn×"Ù�ì�Ù<ì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ì�Õ��æx¼����Ê�fP�-�

® �Ê� Ý�Ý §�×"�rê�§�§��t�_ò���§��/ê<ÕtÕ��_� Ü ì�� Ü §�Õ]ê<Õ°� Ü � %²���/�1Á�§�� Ü Õ�� Ù Ü Õ��öÇ�ö¾º[� ® �-�«°×��/Ö&Ù�ë��tÙ Ý ��Öª§]Ù<Ø�ê>Ø{êbì�� ñ í�Ù<Ø�êb§�§����_ò"�"§�� Ý �<��ê<ë�×"Õ¶ãY� ö å ö !17 � Õ°Ö&Ù Ü Õ©§��t��Öª§�� Ý ê Ü ê<ñ_Ù<��Ù���Õtñ í�� �«°×��>�1Á��_Õ©§�� Ü Ö&�>Ù<Ø�Ö&Ù�ñ �_ì�� §�Õq� Ü ì Å5î ã��4J"K åq� ÕÂò�ê<Õt� Ý Ù Ü §�×��±�t�&Õ©§���� Öª§��_Ù Ü Õ£ïqì�ê Ý �¯Ù Ü ë�ê<�t§��hê<ñ��4J\K yê<ñ_���ªò���êbÕu§�Ù6òz�qê Ü êb§�§����_ò"�"§�� Ý �<��ê<ë�×����ªÕ�ë÷��Ù Ü ë�ê<�©§��hêbñ��4J\K yn×�Ù<ì�Ù�ì�Ù��të�×��_Õtì�Õ»§�Ù6òz�]ê Ü êb§�§���� ò��"§�� Ý����ê<ë"×8ì�Ù���ë"×��_Õtì}��ï Ü � Ç]GÙ<ô�� ® �]�_Õ>Õt×�Ù¥ô Ü §�×�ê�§�§�×��cÖ¹êb§��&��Ù��©íaì Å5î ãP�°å±ØÙ���êAÕ��_� Ü êb§��"���g� ô³� §�ק�Ù<§�ê<ñh�Äy�ê<ñ ���&ò"��ê<Õdê Ü"Ý ë�êb�t§��_ê<ñ��Äyk×�Ù�ì�Ù�ì�Ù<��ë�×�� Õ�ì�Õp×�ê<ÕcÖ&Ù<ñ_�_ì�� §�Õ¬��دê Ü"Ý Ù Ü ñ�í � Ø$� ×�ê<Õ}� Ü ê<�tíÙ�ëz�ª��êb§��_Ù Ü:Ü êbì��ªÕ6Ù Ü ñ í<��«°×"�&���1ØÙ����bé»ï]§¡ê,{b��§�Ù<§¡êbñu� Ü ê<�©í ¸��Ëynê<ñ_���ªò���êbÕ¾� Ü Ù�� Ý �&�§�Ùcê<ñ ñ_Ù¥ôCë�ê<�t§��hê<ñ×�Ù�ì�Ù�ì�Ù<��ë�×�� Õ�ì�Õrò¤�ª§nôµ�&� Ü ¸^�Ëy�ê<ñ ���&ò"��ê<Õª�lï Ü �òxµ����� ® �¼§�×"�p�1Á��_Õ©§�� Ü Ö&�dÙ<س֪Ù�ñ_� ì���§�ÕÂØÙ��¯ë�êb�t§��_ê<ñ4�Äyê<ñ_���ªò���êbÕ±ê Ü�Ý §�Ùb§¡ê<ñi�Äyk×�Ù�ì�Ù�ì�Ù���ë�×"�_Õ�ì�Õ/ØÙ��>ê<��ò"� §���ê<�tí Õ�� � Ü êb§������ªÕ3�o� Õ±Õ�×�Ù¥ô Ü �y«°×"�&���1ØÙ����bé�ôµ����&Õ©§��t�_Öª§�§�Ù§�Ù<§�ê<ñ"×"Ù�ì�Ù<ì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ì�Õ»ò¤�ª§nôµ�&� Ü §�×�� Ý êb§�ê6êbñ_���ªò���ê<Õª�»«°×"� Ü é�ôµ�]ÖªÙ Ü Õ©§����"Öª§m§�×��°ë"��Õ�×�Ù<�"§� Ü ì ÅYî ãP�4J\K å�Ö&Ù�ì�ëzÙ Ü � Ü §nô³�_Õt�°ØÙ��u§�×��°�<��ê<ë�×�ê Ü"Ý ØÙ��»§�×�� Ý êb§�êÂë�ê<�t§&��«°×��]êb§t§��t�_ò��"§��_Ù Ü Ù�ëz�ª��êb§��_Ù Ü Õê<���Â����ó�� Ü ò�í´§�×"�6� Ü � ó<�&��Õ�ê<ñõë��tÙ�ëz�ª�t§ní´ÙbØuë���Õt×�Ù��"§�Õ&�«°×�� §���ê Ü ÕtØÙ<��ì�êb§�� Ù Ü Ù<Ø�ê Ü êb§�§����_ò"�"§�� Ý ����ê<ë"×·�_Õ Ý �t� Ü � Ý ò²í·ê Ü �,/5/-��+{�102/��3) ¢¤�¡�1),0���/5+4��4�� � Üêb§�§����_ò"�"§�� Ý ë��tÙ Ý �"Öª§�� Ù Ü ÖªÙ Ü Õ�� Õt§�ÕpÙ<Ø/ê)ë"��Ù Ý ��Öª§��_Ù Ü8Ü ê<ì��lê Ü"Ý ê Ü êb§t§��t�_ò��"§�� Ý ����ê<ë"×ðì�Ù<��ë�×�� Õ�ìî¯� � ¬ �e§�×�êb§�×�ê<Õm§�Ù6Õ�êb§��_ÕtØ í¯Õ�Ù�ì��]ê Ý�Ý ��§��_Ù Ü ê<ñ"ÖªÙ Ü�Ý ��§�� Ù Ü Õ&��«°×�� Ý êb§�êrê<ñ ���&ò"��êÂÙ<ؤ§�×��qêb§�§���� ò��"§�� Ý����ê<ë"×�Õ � ê Ü�Ý �C� Õ]§�×��V/��1�Ï�w�<�òñ��&�&�t�/ØÙ��°§�×"� Ý êb§�ê�Õt�_� Ü êb§����t�¶É6�Ûê Ü�Ý §�×��rÉ��Ëyn×�Ù<ì�Ù�ì�Ù��të�×��_ÕtìÙ<ؾ§�×"�}ë��tÙ Ý ��Öª§��_Ù Ü ì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ì î��_Õ>§�×"�|� Ý � Ü §���§níýÙ Ü §�×��}§��&��ì ê<ñ ���&ò"��êAê<Õ¬ï Ý Ù Ü Ù<§�� Ü §�� Ü�Ý §�Ù���ªô³�t� §��6§�×�� Ý êb§¡ê�ê<ñ_�<�&ò���ê"� |¾���/§�Ù>§�×"�_Õ³���ªÕt§��t�_Ö1§��_Ù Ü §�Ù¬êb§t§��t�_ò��"§�� Ý ����ê<ë"×�Õ£ê Ü�Ý ê�§�§��t�_ò���§�� Ý ����êbë�×ì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ì�Õ^ﵧ���ê Ü Õ©ØÙ���ì ê<Öª§���ê<ñ_ñ�ípÙ Ü ñ íp� Ü ê<�tí´ê<ñ_���ªò���êbÕ&�m«°×��/§���ê Ü ÕtØÙ��tì¬ê�§��_Ù Ü Ù<Øu� Ü ê<�tí´ê<ñ_���ªò���êbÕ�_Õ°Õt§�� Ý � � Ý � Ü �öÇ]GÙ<ô�� ® �4�ïkØ£§�×"� Ý êb§¡êAê<ñ_�<�&ò���êlÕ�×�Ù��"ñ Ý òz�d���1ô³����§�§�� Ü êbÕ>ôµ�&ñ ñ4éµêAì�Ù��t�´��� Ü �ª��ê<ñ^§�×��&Ù<�tíýÙ<Øqë�ê<�©§��hêbñ°ê<ñ_�<�&ò���ê§���ê Ü ÕtØÙ��tì¬ê�§��_Ù Ü �_ÕÂ�t�&%²���_�t� Ý ����Ù��£§�×��±§���ê Ü ÕtØÙ��tì¬ê�§��_Ù Ü Ù<Ø^êb��ò���§���êb�tílë�ê<�t§��hê<ñ�ê<ñ_���ªò���êbÕ¾ô³� §�×�§�Ù<§¡ê<ñ×�Ù�ì�Ù�ì�Ù<��ë�×�� Õ�ì�Õ¼� Ü §�×��n|Â#]# ê<ë�ë"��Ù�ê<Ö¡×cï¼�t�ªØ�ª�³§�Ùj�öÇ�ô���ÊP�-�Ï ���¡�Ë�ù� � ø �å¥�§z¥�§ ùµð í �#� ¢ � �¡ð ���2ï £�¢+ø ï ð�� � � ø ��ñ: ��ó�� Ü ê Ü êb§t§���� ò��"§�� Ý ����ê<ë�×ðÕt�_� Ü êb§����t�j�4J"K ê<Õ Ý �t� Ü � Ý � Ü �"�Ã��� ­ ê Ü"Ý ê Ü �÷5 ó yn� Ü�Ý �ÏÁ"� Ý Õ��1§´Ù<Øó<êb���hêbò�ñ_�ªÕ�; Ë ã=; å (! ó x R ��� Ü �,/5/{��+{�102/n�3)I�4J\K û_¢¤�¡�1),0���/5+4��4l�_Õ6ê}ë�ê<�_��ã üÛ� � �¬ �/åÂô³×"�&����ü � Õ

­<­¥®

Page 121: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

ê´¢¤���1),0���/�+4��4¦4¤�<�¬�/ê Ü�Ý î�� � ¬ � �_Õrê Ü êb§�§����_ò"�"§�� Ý ����ê<ë�× ì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ì ô/�ö�&� §¹�k�4J"K Õt��Ö¡× §�×�ê�§î 5 ó Ë Ó^û °&x R ®lA ¯ �_Õ¶§�×��d� Ý � Ü §�� §ní Ù Ü §�×��p§��&�tì ê<ñ_�<�&ò���êj·÷5 ó ã>;Aårô/�Ã�ª�ö§&�ÀÉ���ê Ü�Ý ; ê Ü�Ý î ó � Õ� Ü �t�ªÖª§���ó��b�¼ï¼Ö&ê<ñ_ñ � §�×����_�Yw�/�ûX�"�,4u)V-�+5)��°ê Ü�Ý � §�×�����+Öñ��2/5ûX�"�,4u)V-�+5)��°Ù<Ø»§�×��6êb§t§��t�_ò��"§�� Ý ë���Ù Ý ��Ö1§�� Ù Üüõ� <� Ü ê�§�§��t�_ò���§�� Ý ë��tÙ Ý �"Öª§�� Ù Ü ã üc� � �¬ �/åmÖ&ê Ü ò¤�£êbë�ë�ñ_� � Ý §�Ùrê Ü êb§�§����_ò"�"§�� Ý ����ê<ë�×Z¸¿� ؤ§�×��ª���]�_Õµê ÜÙ�ÖªÖ&���t��� Ü Ö&�±Ù<Øu§�×��¯ñ �ªØ §�yk×�ê Ü�Ý Õ�� Ý � � � Ü ¸�éz��� ó<� Ü ò�í|ê�§�Ù<§�ê<ñ»êb§�§����_ò"�"§�� Ý ì�Ù���ë�×"�_Õ�ì � � � ¬ ¸>�«°×��¼êbë�ë�ñ_� Ö¹êb§��_Ù Ü �_ÕõÖ¡×�ê<��ê<Öª§��&�t�.�&� Ý ò�í§�×��më���Õ�×"Ù��"§»Ù<Ø"ë"��Ù Ý ��Öª§��_Ù Ü ì�Ù���ë"×��_Õtì î°ê Ü"Ý §�×��mÙ�ÖªÖ&���t��� Ü Ö&�� � Ü Ö&êb§��ª��Ù��tí6ì�Ð6¢²�Ï ���¡�Ë�ù� � ø �å¥�§z¥�§m�µðtÆ í � ��� �Ëï�� ¢ � � �Vï�� ¢ � � í � � ø ��ñ: ��ó�� Ü ê Ü êb§t§���� ò��"§�� Ý ����êbë�×�Õt�_� Ü êb§����t���4J\K ê Ü"Ý ê Ü êb§t§���� ò��"§�� Ý ë���Ù Ý ��Ö1§�� Ù Ü ã ü}� � �¬ �/åÏ�¡� /n��/k�<�êb§�§����_ò"�"§�� Ý ����êbë�×pì�Ù���ë�×"�_Õ�ì � � � ¬ ¸�ô/�ö�&� §¹���4J\K é²ô³×��ª��� � ó �_Õµ� Ü �t�ªÖª§���ó��bé�� Õ¼Ö¹êbñ_ñ_� Ý ê¬���,/n���ØÙ��Æüc� Ü ¸��� ),+ �¡�¡��/=)��1��+ ���,/5+4��4>ó��_ê ücêb§ � Ø�tÙ�ì ¸ §�Ù�%)é Ý � Ü Ùb§�� Ý ò�íI¸ �#" $� %)é�Ö&Ù Ü Õ��_Õ©§�Õ³Ù<Øȧ�×"�Âë���Õ�×"Ù��"§]Ù<Øî±ê Ü�Ý � � Ü ì�Ð6¢�� <�uÁ"ê<ì�ë�ñ �&ÕõÙ<Ø�êb§t§���� ò��"§�� Ý ë���Ù Ý ��Ö1§�� Ù Ü Õõê Ü"Ý §�×��&� �õê<ë�ë�ñ �_Ö&êb§�� Ù Ü ê<�t�À��� ó<� Ü � Ü �¼×�êbë"§��ª��}�éb\��&Ö1§��_Ù Ü }�� ® �

¥�§z¥�§p¨ � � � �^í ���eî ø@¢onCø���Ï � ¤ � ¢ � �Ëð ���2ï Ð6¢ í £���¤qp �Y� � ì �#� ¢ � �Ëð ���2ï Ð6¢ í £���¤kí�¤srmøõ�~í Åt � í ��� ¤ï¶��Õt�}§�×"�}Ö&êb§��ª��Ù��tíéì Å5î ã��4J"K å±Ù<ØÂê�§�§��t�_ò���§�� Ý ����ê<ë�×�Õ�ê Ü�Ý êb§�§���� ò��"§�� Ý �<��ê<ë�×�ì�Ù���ë�×"�_Õ�ì�Õ¯ô³� §�×���&Õtëz�ªÖª§°§�Ù>ê Ü êb§t§���� ò��"§�� Ý ����ê<ë�×pÕt�_� Ü ê�§����t���4J\K ØÙ<�µ§�×"�¾Ö¹êb§��&��Ù<�tí�Ù<Ø�ñ_Ù�Ö¹ê<ñ¤Õt§�êb§��ªÕ&�(�£Õ°ì�� Ü §��_Ù Ü � Ýê<òzÙ¥ó<�<é¼ï¶ê<ò�ò��t�ªó��hê�§���ì Å5î ã��4J"K å¯ò�íaì6Ð�¢lê Ü�Ý ê<ÕtÕ���ì��´§�×�ê�§��&ê<Ö¡×ðê�§�§��t�_ò���§�� Ý ����ê<ë�×��_Õ>ê Ü êb§½y§���� ò��"§�� Ý �<��ê<ë�×|Ù+ó<�&���4J"K �q��Ù��]§�×�� Ý �t� Ü ��§�� Ù Ü Ù<Ø�§�×��rÖ¹êb§��&��Ù��©íjÏ�Ð6¢ ����� ã���·*¸rå]Ù<Ø Ý �_Õt§���� ò��"§�� Ý����ê<ë"×�Õ°ô³� §�×}êb§t§���� ò��"§�� Ý ����êbë�×�Õ]ê<Õ]ñ_Ù�Ö¹ê<ñzÕt§¡ê�§��&Õ¶ã{Ö1Ø��¤\��&Ö1§�� Ù Ü �"� ® å^ïµ��Õ��/§�×�� Ü �1§nô¼Ù<�3{´§ní�ëz�6����êbë�×��·*¸þ� Ü ��� �����t�n}���}��«°×��¾Ö¹ê�§��&�<Ù��tíLÏ�Ð�¢ ����� ãP�I·�¸rå�� Õ¼ò�êbÕ�� Ý Ù Ü §�×��£ì�Ù Ý �&ñèÖ&êb§��ª��Ù��tíu�¿ø ï ° ����� �À«°×"� Ý �t� Ü � §��_Ù Ü Ù<Ø�ê���ªô³�t� §��ÂÕt§��ªë|� Ü Ï�Ð6¢ �1��� ã���·*¸rå Ý �&ë¤� Ü�Ý Õ]Õt§���Ù Ü ��ñ í¬Ù Ü §�×��/Ö&Ù�Ö&Ù�ì�ë�ñ �ª§�� Ü �&ÕtÕ³Ù<Ø'�¿ø ï ° ����� �«°×��/Ö¹êb§��&��Ù��©ív�¿ø ï ° �1��� �_Õ°ÖªÙ�ÖªÙ�ì�ë�ñ_�1§��Â� ØËì6Ð�¢r�_Õ^ÖªÙ�ÖªÙ�ì�ë"ñ_�ª§��/ê Ü�Ý ñ_�1Ø §]ê Ý �tÙ�� Ü §�Õ^ØÙ��¼§���ê Ü Õ�ñhê�§��_Ù ÜØ� Ü Öª§�Ù���Õ¬ê<Õ Ý �t� Ü � Ý � Ü ���g}�� �1Á�� Õt§:ãÖªØ���#À��Ù�ë¤Ù�Õt� §�� Ù Ü ����}��Bf�åÏ� «°×��|ÖªÙ�ÖªÙ�ì�ë�ñ_�1§�� Ü �&Õ�Õ�Ù<Ø�ì6Ð�¢�� ÕÕ�×�Ù¥ô Ü � Ü #À��Ù<ëzÙ�Õt� §��_Ù Ü �"�Ã���ö��émÕ��"Ö¡×ý§�×�êb§>Ù Ü ñ íA§�×��´�ÏÁ"� Õt§�� Ü Öª�cÙbØqñ �ªØ §¯ê Ý �tÙ�� Ü §�Õ¯���ªì¬êb� Ü Õª� ï/Õ�×"Ù+ô§�×��ª�_�°�1Á�� Õt§�� Ü Ö&�6� Ü §�×����ª�6Õ©§��ªë�Õ&�

­ �³ï�ë��tÙ¥ó��m§�×����1Á��_Õ©§�� Ü Ö&��Ù<Ø�ñ �ªØ §�ê Ý �tÙ�� Ü §�Õ÷ØÙ<�ȧ���ê Ü Õ�ñhê�§��_Ù Ü Ø� Ü Öª§�Ù���Õõô³��§�×6���&Õtëz�ªÖª§�§�Ù³§�×��mÖ&êb§��ª��Ù��tíwIì Å5î ã��°å]Ù<ØÀ§�Ù<§�ê<ñ»ê<ñ_���ªò���êbÕ¾ê Ü�Ý ë�ê<�t§��hê<ñÈ×�Ù<ì�Ù�ì�Ù��të�×��_Õtì�Õ°§�Ùdê¬� Ü ê<�©í|Õt�_� Ü êb§����t�x�£�¾ï«�"Á� Ü §�×"�6Õt�&%²���ªñ»ê±� Ü ê<�tí´Õt�_� Ü êb§����t�<�vê Ü�ÝdÝ � Ü Ù<§��6§�×��/Ö¹êb§��&��Ù��©í´Õ�×"Ù��t§�ñ ípò�ívwIì ÅYî �

}��³ï�ë��tÙ¥ó��m§�×����1Á��_Õ©§�� Ü Ö&��Ù<Ø�ñ �ªØ §�ê Ý �tÙ�� Ü §�Õ÷ØÙ<�ȧ���ê Ü Õ�ñhê�§��_Ù Ü Ø� Ü Öª§�Ù���Õõô³��§�×6���&Õtëz�ªÖª§�§�Ù³§�×��mÖ&êb§��ª��Ù��tí> ì ÅYî ã��°å°Ù<Øuë�ê<�t§��hê<ñõêbñ_���ªò���ê<Õ³ê Ü�Ý ë�êb�t§��_ê<ñ÷×�Ù<ì�Ù�ì�Ù��të�×��_Õtì�Õµ§�Ù�ê Ü êb��ò���§���êb�típÕt�_� Ü êb§����t�<�£��£��êb� Ü é�ï=�"Ád� Ü §�×��/Õ��ª%²���&ñ»ê±Õ��_� Ü êb§��"���h�vê Ü�Ý}Ý � Ü Ù<§��§�×��/Ö¹ê�§��&�<Ù��tí´Õt×�Ù��©§�ñ í¬ò�íI> ì ÅYî �® �³ïmÖ&Ù�ì¯ò"� Ü �]§�×��¾ñ �ªØ §^ê Ý �tÙ�� Ü §�Õ^��Ù<§¼ò�í¬§�×"�¾ë����1ó��_Ù���Õ^§nôµÙ±ë¤Ù�� Ü §�Õµ§�Ù¯ÖªÙ Ü Õt§�����Ö1§°§�×��£ñ_�ªØ §^ê Ý �tÙ�� Ü §

ØÙ��^§���ê Ü Õtñhêb§��_Ù Ü Ø� Ü Öª§�Ù<��Õ°ô³� §�×c�t�&Õtëz�ªÖª§]§�Ù±§�×��/Ö&êb§��ª��Ù��típÙ<Øuê�§�§��t�_ò���§�� Ý ����ê<ë�×�Õª�«°×��°ñ_�1Ø §Àê Ý �tÙ<� Ü §�Õu� Ü ë¤Ù�� Ü § ­ ê Ü�Ý }£ì¬êb� Ü ñ�í Ý � ~z�&� Ý ���^§�Ù£§�×�� Ý ��~��ª��� Ü § Ü Ù<§�� Ù Ü Ù<ؤ×�Ù�ì�Ù�ì�Ù���ë"×��_Õtì�Õòz�1§nô¼�ª� Ü ê<ñ ���&ò"��ê<Õª�u«°×��³§�Ù<§�ê<ñ_��§ní¯Ù<Ø�×�Ù�ì�Ù�ì�Ù<��ë�×�� Õ�ì�Õuì�ê,{<�ªÕ�§�×��]Ø�t�&�]Ö&Ù Ü Õt§��t��Öª§��_Ù Ü Õ�ñ �_��×�§�ñ í¯ì�Ù��t�Ö&Ù�ì�ë�ñ_� Ö¹êb§�� Ý é³Õt� Ü Öª� Ü �ªô �ªñ_�ªì�� Ü §�Õd×�ê<ÕpØ���ª�&ñ�íð§�Ùýò¤����� Ü �ª��êb§�� Ý §�Ùý����êb��ê Ü §��ª��§�×��l§�Ù<§¡ê<ñ � §ní8Ù<Ø

­<­ �

Page 122: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

×�Ù�ì�Ù�ì�Ù<��ë�×�� Õ�ì�Õ&��«°×�� Õ¯�_Õ Ü Ù<§ Ü �ªÖ&�ªÕ�Õ�êb�tíý� Ü §�×��´ë�ê<�©§��_ê<ñµÖ&ê<Õ��b�kø]Ù+ôµ�ªó<�&�ªé^ê Ü � Ý � Ü §��Ö��Ö¹ê�§��_Ù Ü Ù<Ø�&ñ_�ªì�� Ü §�Õ³×�ê<Õ°§�Ù>ò¤�/Ö&Ù Ü Õt� Ý �ª��� Ý � Ü ò¤Ù<§�×cÖ&êb§��ª��Ù��t�_�&Õª�

¥�§z¥�§p¨�§ � r � � � í ï6y ø ���u� ¤3�4øu¢ � ¢ í � ¤ Å í � � ø � �9ð � � � ø@¢�¤ �5� wIì ÅYî: ��ó�� Ü ê}§�Ù<§�ê<ñ�����ê<ë"× ì�Ù<��ë�×�� Õ�ì Åv�¡¸¶¬ % ê Ü�Ý ê|ì�Ù Ý �&ñ]z¿� Ü wIì ÅYî éu§�×���� Ý �&ê|Ù<Ø^§�×��¬Ø���ª�Ö&Ù Ü Õ©§��t��Öª§��_Ù Ü �_Õr§�Ù:����� Ü �cê<ñ_ñ Ü Ù Ý �&Õ±Ù<Ø]§�×"�´ì�Ù Ý �&ñµÙ¥ó��&�V% ò�í)§�×��d�&ì�ë"§níyê<ñ ���&ò"��êýã§�×��´� Ü � §��_ê<ñÙ�ò2�t�&Ö1§Â� Ü §�×��¯Ö&êb§��ª��Ù��©íNwIì ÅYî å³� ØÀ§�×"� Ü Ù Ý �¶� Õ Ü Ù<§£� Ü §�×��¯�_ì�ê<���6Ù<Ø=Å»���£ñ_ñ Ü Ù Ý �&Õ£� Ü §�×��¯�_ì�ê<���Ù<Ø�Åeê<���d����� Ü � Ý ê<Ö&ÖªÙ�� Ý � Ü �:§�ÙA§�×��}ê<ñ_�<�&ò���êAÙ<Øq§�×��d§�×"�}�t�t� Ü � ÝðÜ Ù Ý �cÙ<ØÂ� §�Õ>ë�����yn�_ì�ê<���ªÕ&�8«°×�����t� Ü �&ì�� Ü §¾ÙbØu� Ý ���&Õq� Ü % Ý �ªëz� Ü�Ý Õ£Ù Ü §�×"�r�t�t� Ü �ªì�� Ü §¾Ù<Øu§�×��6� Ý ���ªÕ£� Ü ¸>� � Ü � Ý � Ü §��p��Ö&êb§�� Ù Ü Ù<Ø�&ñ_�ªì�� Ü §�Õ³�_Õ Ü �ªÖ&�ªÕ�Õ�êb�tíc� Øȧ�×"�rêbÕ�Õ�� � Ü ì�� Ü §�Õ°ØÙ��^§�×��/� Ý �<�6�<� ó�� Ü ò�ívz8ê<��� Ü Ùb§³� Ü �_%²���b�>^¢+ø@£Àøu¤ �Y��� ø �¦¥�§z¥�§ ! ð�ÅY� � � í ï6y ø ���D� ¤5p § ¢ §z�~§ wIì Å5î ãP�°å ñ¼�JDE H�FGKPB M�oùKUH5S5T Bå[sN,BD² H9T FI& Æ �V�¿ø ï ° {D�k| a ã�%�åj¬ �¿ø ï ° {D�D| a ã�¸råVSpBDCuN2²tE1C ± µ H5JDE HsTeH�KPoÊÁÃF�KtQlJOIT FXQlJ SpM3OçÅl�e¸ ¬ % J@KPM*K�o5E�[sH­KÃC�Í1T S.BuH'} Æ ��¿ø ï ° {k�D| a ã5¸¶å­¬ ��ø ï ° {D�k| a ã�%�å�b <v¼���¥�swÇÈ�1§+z Ñ ��ø ï ° {D�k| a ã�¸rå1é<§�×��^Ø���ª�°Ö&Ù Ü Õ©§��t��Öª§��_Ù Ü õ�} Æ ãPzmåÏÒ�~ Æ� ù Ù¥ó��ª�+z:ô/�ö�&� §¹�~& Æ �_Õ Ý �t� Ü � Ý ê<ÕuØÙ�ñ ñ_Ù¥ô³Õ&��èÙ<�´�¹ê<Ö¡×ÂÎ Ñ % � éV� ü ãYÎ�åý� Ë � à�! Æ�� Ô� ®l� ¯ z³ãäzå¬ô³� §�×v� Ü �t�&Ö1§��_Ù Ü Õ´Ó4â à �hz³ãäzå ¬ � ü ã5Î�å¬�_Õ´§�×��Ö&Ù�ë��tÙ Ý ��Öª§°ÙbØõ§�×��¾Ø{ê<ì��_ñ�ícãPz³ã äzå�å à�! Æ�� Ô� ®l� ¯ � Ü wIì Å5î �m��Ù��¼�&ê<Ö¡×d� Ý ���¾ç Ñ % � é�� ü ã-ç+å ' � ü ãX�²ã-ç+åtåÀ(� ü ã � ã{ç+å�åõÖ&Ù Ü §¡êb� Ü Õ�ê°ë�ê<� ��ã ø Ò¡71å÷� Ø"ê Ü�Ý Ù Ü ñ í¾� Ø�§�×��ª���m�_Õ�ê Ü � Ý �<�¼ç�� Ñ Å�� Þ� ã-ç+å÷Õ���Ö¡×6§�×�ê�§�z³ã{ç���å&ã ø åÀË 7¥�«°×�� Ü éÈôµ� Ý �t� Ü ��ê´���ªñhêb§��_Ù Ü�� � ' � ü ãYÎ"åq(�� ü ãYÎ"åqØÙ<�Â�¹ê<Ö¡× Î Ñ % � ò�í�ã ø Ò�7ªå Ñ � � ��Ø^ê Ü"Ý Ù Ü ñ í� س§�×��ª���d�_Õ>ê Ü � Ý ���cç Ñ % � Õ���Ö¡×�§�×�êb§ � ã{ç+å�Ë Î)ê Ü�Ý ãäÈÒ ø åÏÒ+ãäÈÒ¡71å Ñ � ü ã-ç+åÏ�ýÇÈ�1§e� � òz�p§�×��ñ_�¹êbÕt§/Ö&Ù Ü �����"� Ü Öª�¬���ªñhêb§��_Ù Ü Ù Ü � ü ãYÎ�åqô/�Ã�ª�ö§&�ȧ�×��>� Ü Öªñ_��Õt�_Ù Ü §�×�êb§6�_Õ/��� Ü �&��êb§�� Ý ò�í � � ê Ü�Ý ô³×��ª���� ã-ç+å ' � üd�C� OP���>� (�� üd�C��� ����� Ý �t� Ü � Ý ò�ívã3� ø �4Ò��ö7G�hå Ñ � ã{ç+å>��ؾê Ü�Ý Ù Ü ñ íy��رã ø Ò¡71å Ñ � ü ã{ç+å¯�_Õ�ê×�Ù�ì�Ù�ì�Ù<��ë�×�� Õ�ìc�«°×�� Ü éD} Æ ã�zmå&ãYÎ"åqË�� ü ã5Î�å �C��� ØÙ��Â�¹êbÖ¡×WÎ Ñ % � ê Ü�Ý } Æ ã�zmå&ã-ç+åqË�� ã{ç+åqØÙ��Â�¹êbÖ¡×)ç Ñ % � �±«°×��� Ü � ó<�&�tÕ�ê<ñèì�Ù���ë�×"�_Õ�ì�~ Æ� ËÒõ-Ó\û Ò �D���� ù �zº¬ & Æ ãP} Æ ãPzmå�åu� Õ Ý �t� Ü � Ý ØÙ��À�&ê<Ö¡×�ä Ñ ¸ � ò²í ������ ãäzåmËâ ø � Æ ® à ¯ ÿ¼Ó4â à é"ô³×��&�t�/â ø � Æ ® à ¯ �C� ü ã�Åuãäzåtå(¬ � ü ã�Åuãäzåtå �C� � � ÷ � �_Õ¼§�×�� Ü êb§�����ê<ñ�×�Ù�ì�Ù�ì�Ù<��ë�×�� Õ�ì ô³� §�×���&Õtëz�ªÖª§]§�Ùe� Æ ®Ãà ¯��º)�´Õt×�Ù¥ô Ü Ù¥ô §�×��´� Ü � ó<�&��Õ�ê<ñ^ë��tÙ�ë¤�&�t§ní)Ù<ØOõ�} Æ ã�zmå1Ò�~ Æ� ù ��ÇÈ�1§x� � ò¤�dêlì�Ù Ý �&ñ�Ù¥ó��ª�Z% ê Ü�Ý ½XýËõ-Ó^û Ò � K ù ��z¦¬ & Æ ã>� � å³ò¤�rê�ì�Ù Ý �ªñõì�Ù<��ë�×�� Õ�ì � Ü �¿ø ï ° {k�D| a ã5¸¶åÏ�°«°×�� Ü éè§�×"�¶ì�Ù Ý �ªñõì�Ù<��ë�×�� Õ�ì½X ; Ë õ-Ó\û K Ò � K � ù �]} Æ ã�zmåZ¬ � � � Õ Ý ��� Ü � Ý ê<Õ¯ØÙ�ñ ñ_Ù¥ô³Õ&�¬�èÙ<�¯�¹ê<Ö¡×aÎ Ñ % � ém§�×��&�t�d�_Õ±ê�� Ü � %²���×�Ù�ì�Ù�ì�Ù<��ë�×�� Õ�ì W � �?� ü ã5Î�åĬ � � ã5Î�å Ý ���6§�Ù>§�×��6� Ü ��ó��ª��Õ�êbñ»ÖªÙ�ë���Ù Ý ��Ö1§£ë"��Ù�ë¤�&�©§nídÙ<Ø'� ü ãYÎ"åÏéèÕ���֡ק�×�êb§ W � ÿ]Ó4â à Ë � K ãäzå°ØÙ��q�&ê<Ö¡×|ä Ñ Å�� Þ� ã5Î�å1�]|¾���6§�Ù�§�×��r×�Ù�ì�Ù�ì�Ù<��ë�×�� Õ�ìa§�×��&Ù<���&ì ãÖªØ��¡�ò�Äó|Ê �ë�ê<���e�C��åÏé÷§�×��ª���>�_Õ/êd� Ü � %²���>ì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ìÌû � �Y� ü ãYÎ�å �C� � ¬ � � ã5Î�å¾Õ��"Ö¡× §�×�êb§�û � ÿ¾â ø � � Ë W � ØÙ<��¹ê<Ö¡×IÎ Ñ % � �uº � Ý �t� Ü �ÂØÙ��¼�&ê<Ö¡×jÎ Ñ % � é � K � ãYÎ"åÀË û � ê Ü�Ý �<�ª§*& Æ ã ½X ; åDÿ&~ Æ� Ë ½X�Õ�� Ü Ö&�¾ØÙ��^�&ê<Ö¡×ä Ñ ¸ � é,& Æ ã � K � å&ãäzå3ÿ~ Æ� ãäzåmË � K � ã�ÅuãäzåtåGÿ�â ø � Æ ® à ¯sÿ�Ó-â à Ë û Æ ® à ¯Xÿ�â ø � Æ ®Ãà ¯sÿ�Ó4â à Ë W Æ ®Ãà ¯9ÿ�Ó4â à Ë � K ãäzåÏ�«°×��Â� Ü � %��"� Ü �ªÕ�Õ]Ù<Ø�~ Æ� ØÙ�ñ_ñ Ù¥ô³ÕµØ��Ù<ì §�×��Â� Ü � %��"� Ü �ªÕ�Õ³Ù<Øȧ�×��Â×"Ù�ì�Ù<ì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ì�Õgû � ê Ü�Ý W � ØÙ��^�&ê<Ö¡×Î Ñ % � � �TVU í Æ £ ÅY�j¥�§p¨ ��� ÅY� � � í ï�y ø �5�D� p § ¢ §d�ç wIì Å5î��� Ü �1Á"ê<ì�ë�ñ_�µØÙ���§�×"�°ñ_�ªØ §uê Ý �tÙ�� Ü §À�_Õu�<� ó�� Ü � Ü ��� �����t�^���g} ® ��«°×��°§�Ù<§�ê<ñ"����ê<ë�×±ì�Ù���ë"×��_ÕtìÌŬ� ÕuÕ�×�Ù¥ô Üêb§À§�×��°§�Ù�ë>Ù<Øz§�×��«�������t�<�u«°×"�]ì�ê<ë�ë"� Ü �Â� ÕÀ� Ü�Ý � Ö¹êb§�� Ý ò�í±§�×"�°Ö¡×�ê<��êbÖª§��ª��Õµêb§À§�×"� Ü Ù Ý �ªÕ&�uïnì�ë¤Ù��t§�ê Ü §ØÙ��§�×����1Á"ê<ì�ë�ñ_�>� Õ/§�×���� Ý � Ü §��p��Ö&êb§�� Ù Ü Ù<ؼ§�×���� Ý ���ªÕrØ�tÙ�ì ø §�Ù}7¯� Ü ¸a§�Ùc§�×���ñ_Ù�Ù�ë:� Ü %)��«°×��ì�Ù Ý �&ñkziÙ+ó<�&��¸ �_Õ Ý �ªë��_Ö1§�� Ý Ù Ü §�×��±ñ �ªØ §�yk×�ê Ü�Ý Õ�� Ý �¯Ù<Øm§�×������������b�rï Ü §�×��±�1Á"ê<ì�ë�ñ �<é�ôµ�±��Õ��¯ØÙ<�

­<­o

Page 123: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

Ff

21

34

56

G

G

a b c f

H

12

[3,4] [5,6]

a b c

Hca,b

a,b c

��� �����t�¾���g} ® �$�����(wÏ���¡�±�¡��4U-�/{��0���/5+4��4�w¹���iw�ì ÅYîw�ì ÅYî §�×��rÖ&êb§��ª��Ù��©í t �Ã� ; Ù<Ø�Õ��ª§�Õ]ô³��§�×cë�ê<�©§��hêbñ�ì�ê<ë�ë�� Ü ��Õ&�µ\��1§�Õqê<���/� Ü ê<�tícê<ñ ���&ò"��ê<Õªé�ô³×��&�t�6§�×��Õ��_� Ü êb§��"���¾ÖªÙ Ü §¡ê<� Ü Õ^Ù Ü ñ�í¬Ù Ü �¾Õ�Ù<�t§°ò���§ Ü Ù±Ù�ë¤�&��ê�§��_Ù Ü Õ&�u«°×"� Ü Ù Ý � ø Ù<Ø�¸ �_Õ^�t�t� Ü � Ý §�Ù>ê¯Õt�ª§°ô³� §�ק�×��±�ªñ_�&ì�� Ü §�Õ ­ ê Ü�Ý }�é�§�×�� Ü Ù Ý �>76×�ê<Õ£§�×��±�&ñ �&ì�� Ü §�Õ ® é��dê Ü�Ý�Ü Ù Ý � W ×�ê<Õ¾§�×�� Ü Ù Ý �&Õ ê Ü�Ý f"�«°×��±§nô¼Ù}� Ý ���ªÕ/� Ü ¸ ê<���±�t�t� Ü � Ý §�Ù´§nô¼Ùcë�ê<�©§��hêbñuì¬êbë�ë�� Ü ��Õ>ã§�×�êb§rê<�t�¯§�Ù<§�ê<ñu� Ü §�×��_ÕÂÖ&ê<Õ��¹å1�6«°×��Ù Ü �¯ì�ê<ë�ë�� Ü ��ì¬ê<ë"Õ ­ Ù Ü §�Ù¬�´ê Ü�Ý }�Ù Ü §�Ù ® 餧�×��rÙ<§�×��ª�¾Ù Ü �¶ì¬ê<ë"Õ ­ Ù Ü §�Ù ® ê Ü�Ý }�Ù Ü §�Ùp���£«°×��Ý � ~z�&�t� Ü §rô¼ê¹í)ÙbØ°ì¬êbë�ë�� Ü �}�ªñ_�&ì�� Ü §�ÕrÖ&ê<��Õ��ªÕ±ê Ü � Ý � Ü §��p��Ö&êb§�� Ù Ü Ù<Ø^§�×"�¬�&ñ �&ì�� Ü §�Õ ® ê Ü"Ý �|� Ü §�×�����t� Ü � Ý Õt�ª§£Ù<Ø Ü Ù Ý � ø Ò�7/� Ü % �°\�� Ü Ö&�/§�×��rñ_Ù�Ù�ëc� Ü % �_Õ³�t�t� Ü � Ý ê<Ö&ÖªÙ�� Ý � Ü �>§�Ù�§�×��6§nô¼Ùpì�ê<ë�ë"� Ü ��ÕØÙ��§�×���ë�����yn� ì¬ê<�<�±� Ý ���ªÕ¶� Ü ¸>é»ôµ�¬×�ê¹ó<��§�Ùcì�ê<ë ­ Ù Ü §�Ù ® ò���§¯ê<ñ Õ�Ù ­ Ù Ü §�Ù}���¬«°×��&�t�ªØÙ��t�<é�§�×���&ñ_�ªì�� Ü §�Õ ® ê Ü�Ý �dì¯�"Õt§Âò¤�±� Ý � Ü §��p��� Ý �r#Àñ_�¹êbÕ�� Ü Ù<§��_Öª�<é�§�×�êb§Â§�×"�¯ì¬êbë�ë�� Ü �p�_Õ¾� Ü�Ý �t� Ü � Ý Ù Ü ® Ò����\�� Ü Öª�§�×��6�&ñ �&ì�� Ü §�Õ ® ê Ü�Ý �¬ê<�t�/� Ý � Ü §��p��� Ý éèê<ñ Õ�Ù>§�×��/�&ñ �&ì�� Ü §�Õ ê Ü�Ý f�×�ê¹ó<�6§�Ù�ò¤�/� Ý � Ü §��p��� Ý � ÜÙ�� Ý �ª�°§�Ù�ê<Ö¡×�� �ªó��rê¯ô¼�ªñ_ñzy Ý ��� Ü � Ý ë�ê<�©§��_ê<ñ�ì�ê<ë�ë�� Ü �¯ØÙ��^§�×��/� Ý ���/ò¤�ª§nôµ�&� Ü ø Ò¡7¾ê Ü�Ý W � Ü % � <¥�§z¥�§p¨�§.¨ r � � � í ï6y ø ���u� ¤3�4øu¢ � ¢ í � ¤ Å í � � ø � �9ð � � � ø@¢�¤ �5� > ì Å5î«°×��´�1Á��_Õ©§�� Ü Ö&�dÙ<س§�×"�´ñ_�ªØ §±ê Ý �tÙ�� Ü §rØÙ��¶§���ê Ü Õtñhêb§��_Ù Ü Ø� Ü Öª§�Ù���Õ±ò¤�ª§nôµ�&� Ü ì�Ù Ý �&ñµÖ¹êb§��&��Ù��t�_�ªÕ¯� Ü §�×��Ö¹êb§��&��Ù��©í³> ì ÅYî Ö&ê Ü ò¤�>ñ_��Ø §�� Ý §�Ùd§�×����1Á��_Õ©§�� Ü Ö&��Ù<Ø^ì�Ù Ý �&ñuÖ&êb§��ª��Ù���� �&Õ/� Ü Ö&êb§��ª��Ù��tí t �Ã� ��«°×��_Õ/� ÕëzÙ�ÕtÕ�� ò�ñ_�ÂÕt� Ü Öª�/§�Ù<§¡êbñ÷×�Ù�ì�Ù�ì�Ù���ë�×"�_Õ�ì�Õ¼ò¤�ª§nôµ�&� Ü ê<ñ ���&ò���ê<Õ³ê<�t�Â���&%²��� ��� Ý �>^¢+ø@£Àøu¤ �Y��� ø �¦¥�§z¥�§ ? � ÅY� � � í ï6y ø ���D� ¤3�kø@¢Z> ì ÅYî ãP�°å �¼�JDE�H5F�KPBUM3oùK¾H�S5T�BV[sNPBD² H9T F & Æ �?��ø ï ° ¡C�D| a ®�� ¯ ã5%�å(¬ �¿ø ï ° ¡C�D| a ã��°åªã�¸råRS.BDCuNe²1E1C ± µ³H5JDE�HsT2HXKPo ÁÃF�KtQlJOIT FXQlJ SpM3OçÅl�e¸ ¬ % J@KPM*K�o5E�[sH­KÃC�Í1T S.BuH'} Æ ��¿ø ï ° ¡C�D| a ®¢� ¯ ã�¸rå­¬ �¿ø ï ° ¡C�D| a ®¢� ¯ ã�%�å�b <v¼���¥�sw«°×��dÖ¹êb§��&��Ù��©í£�¿ø ï ° ¡C�D| a ®¢� ¯ ã�¸rå¶�_Õ±�_ÕtÙ�ì�Ù���ë�×"�_Ö�§�Ù�§�×��´Ø� Ü Ö1§�Ù��±Ö&êb§��ª��Ù��©í �Ý· ýÈã�¸råV¬ > ì ÅYî ã��°å9�ô³×��&�t�=· ýÈã�¸råõ� Õõ§�×��m§�×��ªÙ��tí6Ù<Ø ¸��»�����t§�×��&�tì�Ù<���<é�> ì ÅYî ã��°åõ�_ÕÈ�_ÕtÙ�ì�Ù���ë�×"�_Öu§�Ù³§�×"��Ø� Ü Öª§�Ù<�»Ö&êb§��ª��Ù��tí�Ý· ýÈã��°å­¬ t �Ã� �÷ô³×"�&����· ýÈã��°åµ� Õ¼§�×"�/§�×��&Ù<�típÙbØ'�£�À«°×"� Ü é��¿ø ï ° ¡C�D| a ®¢� ¯ ã�¸råµ�_Õ^� Õ�Ù�ì�Ù��të�×��_Ö]§�Ù¯§�×��Ø� Ü Öª§�Ù��6Ö¹êb§��&��Ù��©íå�Ý· ýÈã�¸rån¬ ãY· ýÈã��°å�¬ t �Ã� å9��§�×�êb§r�_Õ6�_ÕtÙ�ì�Ù<��ë�×�� Ö¯§�Ù¥¤þã�¸>Ò¦�°å6Ë � ãù· ý�ã5¸¶åq(·oýÈãP�°å�å ¬ t �e� �4�]«°×��¶�ÏÁ��_Õt§�� Ü Öª�±Ù<Ømê�ñ_�ªØ §£ê Ý �tÙ<� Ü §qØÙ<�]§�×��rØ� Ü Öª§�Ù<��& ��¤Cã�%}Òb�°å«¬ ¤Cã�¸>Ò¦�°å]� Õ��� ó<� Ü � Ü �ò�¼Ù����~���4é�§�×�êb§³�_Õ³êbñ_Õ�Ù�ê±ñ_�1Ø §]ê Ý �tÙ�� Ü §°ØÙ��]& Æ � �TVU í Æ £ ÅY�j¥�§p¨ ��� ÅY� � � í ï�y ø �5�D� p § ¢ §d�ç > ì ÅYî1�º)�°��Õt�°§�×��°Ö&êb§��ª��Ù��tí t �Ã� ô³��§�×±§�Ù<§�ê<ñ"ì�ê<ë�ë"� Ü ��Õ�ØÙ���§�×��³Ö¹êb§��&��Ù��©í�> ì Å5î � Ü §�×��°�1Á"ê<ì�ë�ñ_� Ý �&ë�� Öª§�� Ý� Ü ��� �������r���g}b���/º)�±ÖªÙ Ü Õ�� Ý �&�q§�×��±Õt� §���êb§�� Ù Ü ê<ñ ���¹ê Ý í|�<� ó�� Ü � Ü ��� �������r���g} ® é÷�-�Ã�b�6§�×��±Õ�ê<ì��¶§�Ù<§¡ê<ñ����ê<ë"×´ì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ì Ålê Ü�Ý §�×��ÂÕ�ê<ì��¾ì�Ù Ý �ªñ1zýÙ+ó<�&�ʸ>é"ô³×��ª���6ê<ñ_ñ¤� Ý ���&Õ]ê<�t�Â���t� Ü � Ý §�Ù±§�Ù<§¡ê<ñz����êbë�×

­<­ f

Page 124: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

ì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ì�Õ&�d«°×��¬�ªñ_�ªì�� Ü §�Õ ® ê Ü�Ý �|�t�&Õtë÷� ê Ü�Ý f|×�ê¥ó<�¬§�Ù}òz��� Ý � Ü §��p��� Ý ê<��ê<� Ü ØÙ��/§�×��pÕ�ê<ì��

Ff

21

34

56

G

G

a b c f

H

[3,4]

a b c

Hca,b

a,b c

789102

17’8’ 9’

10’[5,6]

�»�_�����t�Â���g}b���$�����(wÏ���¡�¯�¡��4U-�/{��0è��/5+4��4�w¹���Ê> ì ÅYî���¹êbÕ�Ù Ü Õqê<Õ]�1Á�ë�ñ_ê<� Ü � Ý � Ü §�×��^��Á�êbì�ë�ñ �/����}P�"� ø]Ù¥ô¼�1ó��&�ªé�Õt� Ü Öª�6§�×��r� Ý ���ªÕq×�ê¹ó<�r§�Ù�ò¤�6�t�t� Ü � ÝlÜ Ù¥ôò²í�§�Ù<§¡êbñÀì¬ê<ë"ë�� Ü �<Õ&éõô¼��×�ê¹ó���§�Ù Ý �t� Ü ��§�×"��ì�ê<ë�ë�� Ü �´ØÙ��§�×���ñ_Ù�Ù�ëAê<ñ Õ�ÙdØÙ��§�×����&ñ �&ì�� Ü §L� ® Ò��,�4�«°×��_ÕÀô¼ê<Õ Ü Ùb§ Ü �&Ö&�ªÕ�Õ�ê<�tí�� Ü §�×"����Á"ê<ì�ë�ñ_�³���g},�/òz�ªÖ¹ê<��Õt�qÙbØ�§�×"�që�êb�t§��_ê<ñ_��§ní¶ÙbØ÷ì�ê<ë�ë�� Ü ��Õ&�»«»Ù Ý ��� Ü �§�×��´ì�ê<ë�ë�� Ü ��Ù Ü � ® Ò��,�³ê Ü �ªô �ªñ_�ªì�� Ü §>� Õ±��� Ü �&��ê�§�� Ý �y«»Ù Ý ��� Ü �´§�×��dì�ê<ë�ë�� Ü �lØÙ��¶§�×��_Õ Ü �ªô³ñ í��� Ü �ª��êb§�� Ý �&ñ �&ì�� Ü §¹é²ê Ü �1ôð�&ñ �&ì�� Ü §m�_ÕÀ�<� Ü �ª��êb§�� Ý ê<��ê<� Ü �ª§�Öb�u«�Ù Ý ��� Ü �°§�×"�]ì�ê<ë�ë"� Ü �£ØÙ<�u§�×��³� Ý ���òz�1§nô¼�ª� Ü ø Ò¡7Âê Ü�Ý W Ü �ªô��ªñ_�&ì�� Ü §�Õq×�ê¹ó<�r§�Ù�ò¤�¶��� Ü �&��êb§�� Ý � Ü §�×"�¶Õ��1§qØÙ<� Ü Ù Ý � W ê<Õ³ô¼�ªñ_ñ4� |¾���6§�Ù§�×�� Õ^Ø���&�/��� Ü �&��êb§�� Ù Ü Ù<Ø»�&ñ_�ªì�� Ü §�Õ&é�ôµ�6���ª§³� Ü � Ü ��§��ÂÕ��1§�Õ³ØÙ��^§�×"� Ü Ù Ý �ªÕ ø Ò�7¾ê Ü�Ý W � <¥�§z¥�§p¨�§_Ä r � � � í ï6y ø ���u� ¤3�4øu¢ � ¢ í � ¤ Å í � � ø � �9ð � � � ø@¢�¤ �5� ì6Ð�¢� Ü ê�§�§��t�_ò���§�� Ý ����ê<ë�×cÕ��_� Ü êb§��"���§�4J\K Ëë¸�� � É�� �¨L J �d�d� � Õ³ì¬ê Ý �6�"ë|Ù<Øuê�Õt�_� Ü ê�§����t��¸^��ô³� §�×� Ü ê<�©í±Ù�ë¤�&��ê�§��_Ù Ü Õ©í�ì¯òzÙ<ñ_ÕmÙ Ü ñ�í�é²ê Ü ê<��ò"� §���ê<�tí¶Õ�� � Ü êb§������]É��Aê Ü�Ý ê6Õt�ª§µÙ<Ø�� Ü ê<�tí>Ù<ëz�ª��êb§��_Ù Ü Õ L J �d�d�ã{ÖªØ��Ë|¾�t� Ü � §��_Ù Ü ���ö��� ­ å1�I� Ü êb§t§��t�_ò��"§�� Ý ����ê<ë"×)Ö&Ù Ü Õ�� Õt§�Õ¶Ù<سê|� Ü ê<�tí:§�Ùb§¡ê<ñ�ê<ñ ���&ò���ê}Ù¥ó��ª�´¸^�·ê Ü�Ýê}ë�ê<�©§��_ê<ñmê<ñ_�<�&ò���ê}Ù¥ó��ª�¯É��·ê Ü"Ý §�Ùb§¡ê<ñmì�ê<ë�ë�� Ü ��Õ/ØÙ�� L J �d�d� ���^§�§����_ò"�"§�� Ý ����ê<ë�×)ì�Ù��të�×��_Õtì�Õ6ê<�t�ë�ê<�t§��hê<ñèò¤�ª§nôµ�&� Ü §�×��q§�Ù<§¡êbñz� Ü ê<�tí�ê<ñ ���&ò���ê<Õµê Ü�Ý §�Ùb§¡ê<ñèò¤�ª§nôµ�&� Ü §�×��£ë�êb�t§��_ê<ñ¤ê<ñ_�<�&ò���ê<Õ&�(|¾�"�q§�Ùr§�×�� ÕÖ&Ù�ì¯ò"� Ü êb§��_Ù Ü Ù<ØÀ§�Ù<§¡ê<ñ � §nícê Ü"Ý ë�ê<�©§��hêbñ_� §níp���&Õtë÷�÷� Ü ê<�tí|ê Ü�ÝlÜ Ù Ü yn� Ü ê<�tí}Õ�� � Ü êb§������ªÕ&é¤ô¼�±Ö&ê ÜlÝ ��� Ü �§�×��µñ_�ªØ §�ê Ý �tÙ<� Ü §»ØÙ<��§���ê Ü Õtñhêb§��_Ù Ü Ø� Ü Ö1§�Ù��tÕ�� Ü ì6Ð�¢°Ù Ü §�×��¼ò�ê<Õ�� Õ�Ù<Ø�§�×��¼ñ �ªØ §�ê Ý �tÙ�� Ü §�ÕÈØÙ���§���ê Ü Õ�ñhê�§��_Ù ÜØ� Ü Öª§�Ù���Õ³� Ü wIì ÅYî ê Ü�Ý > ì ÅYî �ï Ü §�×��ÂÕ��ª%²���&ñ-é�ô¼� Ý � Ü Ù<§��¾§�×��ÂÖ¹ê�§��&�<Ù��tí6ì�Ð6¢"ãP�4J\K å¼Õ�×�Ù<�t§�ñ�í¬ò�íIì6Ð�¢�é�§�×��ÂÖ&êb§��ª��Ù��tíIwIì Å5î ã�¸^�måò²í©w�ì ÅYî ê Ü"Ý §�×��/Ö¹êb§��&��Ù��©í�> ì ÅYî ã-É��måµÕt×�Ù��©§�ñ ípò²í6> ì ÅYî �>^¢+ø@£Àøu¤ �Y��� ø �¦¥�§z¥�§p© � ÅY� � � í ï6y ø ���D� ¤3�kø@¢Lì�Ð6¢ �¼�JDE�H5F�KPB M�oùKUH5S5T BI[sN,Bu² HsT�F�& Æ ���¿ø ï ° ����� ã�%�åĬ �¿ø ï ° ���k� ã5¸¶å«S.BDC@N2²1EtC ± µºH�JDE´HsT2HXKPo�ÁÃF�KtQlJ�O�T FGqQlJ S.M�O Ål�e¸ ¬ % J@K�M�K�oYE�[sH­KeC�Í1T�S.BuH'} Æ ��¿ø ï ° ���k� ã�¸rå(¬ �¿ø ï ° ����� ã�%�å�b <v¼���¥�swÇÈ�1§Hz Ñ �¿ø ï ° ����� ã�¸rå1éèô¼� Ý �t� Ü �$z ócÑ �¿ø ï ° {D�D| a ã�¸rå³ò�í¥z ó ã5Î�å^ËMz³ã5Î�å ó ØÙ��]�¹êbÖ¡×³Î Ñ ¸ �ê Ü�Ý z ó ã-ç+å�˪z³ã-ç+å ó ØÙ��°�¹êbÖ¡×lç Ñ ¸ � �Ä� Ü ê<ñ Ù���é-z�5 ó¬Ñ �¿ø ï ° ¡S�k| a ã�¸rå°� Õ Ý �t� Ü � Ý ò�í«z÷5 ó ãYÎ"åmËz³ã5Î�å 5 ó ØÙ<�°�¹ê<Ö¡×�Î Ñ ¸ � ê Ü"Ý z÷5 ó ã-ç+å�ˬz³ã-ç+å 5 ó ØÙ��³�¹êbÖ¡×lç Ñ ¸ � �^Çõ�ª§�õ�} Æ ÕSR ãPz(¸^��åÏÒ�~ Æ� Õ_R ù ê Ü�Ýõ�} Æ x R ã�zÀÉ��Àå1Ò�~ Æ� x R ù ò¤�À§�×��ÀØ�t�&�mÖ&Ù Ü Õt§��t��Öª§��_Ù Ü Õ»Ù¥ó��ª�Dz ó ���ªÕ�ë÷�oz�5 ó ô/�Ã�ª�ö§&��& óÆ �?�¿ø ï {k�D| a�ã5%�å(¬��ø ï ° {D�k| a ã�¸rå¼���&Õtë÷�D& 5 óÆ ����ø ï ° ¡C�D| a ã5%�å(¬ �¿ø ï ° ¡C�D| a ã5¸¶åÏ�«°×�� Ü é�§�×��ÂØ���&�/ÖªÙ Ü Õt§�����Ö1§�� Ù Ü õ�} Æ ãPzmåÏÒ�~ � ù Ù¥ó��ª��z�ô/�ö�&� §�& Æ � Õ Ý �t� Ü � Ý ê<Õ°ØÙ�ñ_ñ Ù+ô³Õª�

­<­ �

Page 125: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

­ �]��Ù��u�¹êbÖ¡×ZÎ Ñ % � é?} Æ ãPzmå&ãYÎ�å� ó Ë[} Æ Õ_R ãPz ó åªã5Î�å�ê Ü"Ý ØÙ<�À�¹ê<Ö¡×>� Ý ���]ç Ñ % � é6} Æ ã�zmå&ã{ç+å� ó Ë} Æ Õ_R ã�z ó å&ã-ç+åÏ���Ù��»�&ê<Ö¡×´Î Ñ % � éC} Æ ãPzmåªã5Î�å 5 ó Ë­} Æ x R ãPz÷5 ó å&ãYÎ�å�ê Ü"Ý ØÙ����&ê<֡ׯ� Ý ���°ç Ñ % � é} Æ ã�zmå&ã{ç+å 5 ó Ë} Æ x R ã�z÷5 ó å&ã{ç+å1���Ù����&ê<Ö¡×�Î Ñ % � ê Ü�Ý » ü|�2�*¬ � � Ñ L J �d�d� ôµ� Ý �t� Ü � » ü�® � ® � ¯ ®B� ¯ ê<Õ»ØÙ�ñ_ñ Ù+ô³Õª��xµí¶ÖªÙ Ü Õ©§����"Öª§�� Ù ÜÙ<ؾ§�×��}Ø�t�&�|ÖªÙ Ü Õ©§����"Öª§�� Ù Ü õP} Æ ãPz ó åÏÒ�~ Æ� ÕSR é � � �� ÕSR ãäzåcË â ø � Æ ®Ãà ¯¡ÿ¯Ó4â à ØÙ����¹êbÖ¡×ðä Ñ ¸ � éô³×��&�t�¯Ó4â à �-z³ãäz嫬 � ãXÅ�ãäzå�å³�_Õ£ê�Ö&Ù<ë���Ù Ý ��Ö1§¾ì�Ù���ë�×"�_Õ�ì ê Ü"Ý â ø � Æ ® à ¯ ��� ãäz嫬 } Æ ã�z ó å�_Õ³§�×�� Ü êb§�����ê<ñ�×�Ù�ì�Ù�ì�Ù���ë"×��_ÕtìaØÙ��qê¬Ö&Ù Ü ������� Ü Ö&�¶���&ñ_êb§�� Ù Ü ã{ÖªØ��è§�×"�¶ë��tÙ�Ù<ØuÙ<Øm#À��Ù�ë��z���ö���B��å1�«°×�� Ü é"§�×��ª���¾�ÏÁ��_Õt§�հ궧�Ùb§¡ê<ñ¤ì¬êbë�ë�� Ü � W ��� ã5Î�å ¬ } Æ ã�zmå&ãYÎ"å ) ê<Õ¼§�×��¾� Ü � ó��ª��Õ�ê<ñ�ÖªÙ�ë���Ù Ý ��Ö1§ì�Ù<��ë�×�� Õ�ì � Ü�Ý �"Ö&� Ý ò�íð§�×"�:§�Ù<§¡êbñÂì¬ê<ë"ë�� Ü �<Õ:ã � ���� Õ_R ãäzå ) ÿ » ü � ® à ¯ å à�! Æ � Ô ®l� ¯ � |¾����§�Ùy§�×��×�Ù�ì�Ù�ì�Ù���ë�×"�_Õ�ì §�×��ªÙ����ªì}é�§�×��&�t�r� Õ£ê>� Ü � %��"�rì�ê<ë�ë�� Ü �fû ��} Æ ã�zmå&ã5Î�å ¬ } Æ ãPzmåªã5Î�å ) Õ���֡ק�×�ê�§¡û ÿ³â ø � à O�Ë W �Àº)� Ý ��� Ü �/§�×�� Ü » ü ® � ® � ¯ ®l� ¯ Ë û �}��°º)� Ý �t� Ü �¶§�×��¶� Ü � ó<�&�tÕ�ê<ñ»ì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ì¯~ Æ� Ë õ-Ó\û Ò �D� �� ù ��zå¬ & Æ ãP} Æ ã=�}åtå]ØÙ��]�¹ê<Ö¡×�ä Ñ ¸ �ò�í �D� �� ã äzå ó � Ë � � �� Õ_R ã äzå^ê Ü�Ý �D� �� ã äzå 5 ó � Ë � � �� x R ã äzå1�

«°×��¾� Ü ��ó��ª��Õ�êbñ÷ë���Ù<ëz�ª�t§ní�Ù<Øeõ�} Æ ã�zmå1Ò�~ Æ� ù ØÙ�ñ ñ_Ù¥ô³Õ�Ø�tÙ�ì §�×��£� Ü � ó<�&�tÕ�ê<ñ÷ë"��Ù�ë¤�&�©§ní¬Ù<ØeõP} Æ ãPz ó åÏÒ�~ Æ� Õ_R ùê Ü�Ý õ�� �5 ó Ò ½X �5 ó ù � ��è�tÙ�ìü§�×��¯�ÏÁ��_Õt§�� Ü Öª�>Ù<Ø�ñ_�ªØ §Âê Ý �tÙ�� Ü §�Õ¾ê Ü"Ý §�×��±Ö&Ù�ynÖ&Ù<ì�ë�ñ �ª§�� Ü �ªÕ�Õ¾Ù<Øm§�×��±Ö¹êb§��&��Ù<���_�ªÕHwIì Å5î é�> ì Å5îê Ü�Ý ì�Ð6¢6ØÙ�ñ ñ_Ù¥ô³Õ^§�×"�6ÖªÙPynÖªÙ�ì�ë�ñ_�1§�� Ü �&Õ�Õ³Ù<Ø�§�×"�6ì�Ù Ý �&ñ÷Ö&êb§��ª��Ù��t�_�&Õª��¶ø@¢+ø Å-Å í ¢*n ¥�§z¥�§ �²������ø�°���ø Æ £ ÅY�Ã� ��� ¤1¤ �¼�JDE�²�KUH9EGÁUT F�S5EGM±�¿ø ï ° {D�k| a i���ø ï ° ¡C�D| a KPBDCI�¿ø ï ° �1��� KPF�E�²tT�qs²tT O�QDo5E H9E b <v¼���¥�sw«°×��£Öªñhê<� ìCØÙ�ñ_ñ Ù¥ô³ÕmØ�tÙ�ìþ«°×��ªÙ����ªì �"��}��B��é²Õ�� Ü Ö&�]§�×��q#À��Ù�ë¤Ù�Õt� §�� Ù Ü Õm���ö���B��é��"�Ã���ÃÊ/���&Õtë÷�m���ö���B�/ë��tÙ+ó�� Ý �ñ_�ªØ §]ê Ý �tÙ�� Ü §�Õ³ê Ü�Ý §�×��/Ö&êb§��ª��Ù���� �&Õ�wIì Å5î é�> ì Å5î ê Ü�Ý ì�Ð6¢¯ê<�t�ÂÖ&ÙPykÖ&Ù�ì�ë�ñ_�1§��b� �¥�§z¥�§ Ä Ï � ¤ � ¢ � �Ëð ���2ï Ð�¢ í £»� � ¢ í � ¤²�kø@¢ Æ í � � ø � p �ù� ��ì �#� ¢ � �¡ð ���2ï Ð6¢�íU£���¤*í�¤±r�ø÷�~í Å Ï�í � í|¾�_Õt§���� ò��"§�� Ý ����êbë�×y§���ê Ü ÕtØÙ��tì¬ê�§��_Ù Ü ô³� §�×8ê�§�§��t�_ò���§�� Ý �<��ê<ë�×"Õ�êbÕ±ñ_Ù�Ö¹ê<ñµÕt§¡ê�§��&Õ>� Õ±ê Ü � Ü Õ©§¡ê Ü Ö&�dÙ<ØÝ �_Õ©§���� ò��"§�� Ý ����ê<ë�× §���ê Ü ÕtØÙ<��ì�êb§�� Ù Ü ô³� §�× ñ_Ù�Ö¹ê<ñ���ynÕt§�êb§��ªÕAã{Ö1Ø��³\��&Ö1§�� Ù Ü ��� ® ��}�åÏé]ô³×"�&���s�¨�_Õ¬§�×��Ö¹êb§��&��Ù��©í�ì�Ð6¢¯Ù<Øuêb§�§����_ò"�"§�� Ý ����ê<ë�×�Õª�«øqÙ¥ôµ�ªó<�&�&ézï Ý Ù Ü Ù<§]Ö&Ù Ü Õ�� Ý �&�qê<ñ_ñ Ý �_Õt§���� ò��"§�� Ý ë"��Ù Ý ��Öª§��_Ù Ü Õê Ü�Ý¶Ý �_Õt§���� ò��"§�� Ý ì�êb§�Ö¡×"�&Õ»§�×�êb§�ê<����ë¤Ù�Õ�Õt�_ò�ñ �µêbÖ&Ö&Ù<� Ý � Ü �q§�Ù�|¾��� Ü � §��_Ù Ü ��� ® �B�]ê Ü"Ý |¾�t� Ü � §�� Ù Ü ��� ® � Ê��»ï���&Õ©§��t�_Öª§õ§�×�� Ý � Õt§��t�_ò���§�� Ý ë"��Ù Ý ��Öª§��_Ù Ü Õ÷§�Ù^§�×"Ù�Õ��mÙ Ü �bé¥ô³×��&�t�m§�×��mñ_Ù�Ö¹ê<ñ�ì�Ù���ë�×"�_Õ�ì�Õ÷Ù<ز§�×��Àë���Ù Ý ��Ö1§�� Ù Üì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ìvê<���mêb§t§��t�_ò��"§�� Ý ë��tÙ Ý �"Öª§�� Ù Ü ÕÈê<ÖªÖ&Ù�� Ý � Ü �^§�Ù]|¾�t� Ü � §�� Ù Ü ���ö��� ��ï Ü §�×��mÕ�ê<ì��uô¼ê¥í<ébï¤���ªÕt§����_Ö1§ì¬êb§�Ö¡×��&Õ�§�Ù³§�Ù<§�ê<ñ Ý �_Õ©§��t�_ò��"§�� Ý ì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ì�Õ&é¥ô³×��&�t�¼§�×"�µñ Ù�Ö&ê<ñ�ì�Ù<��ë�×�� Õ�ì�ÕÈÙ<Ø"§�×��¼ì�êb§�֡׶ê<����ì�êb§�Ö¡×��ªÕê<Ö&ÖªÙ�� Ý � Ü �±§�ÙV|¾�t� Ü � §��_Ù Ü ���ö���lf"�Ï ���¡�Ë�ù� � ø �å¥�§z¥�§ �@��� ï�� ¤ � ¢ � �Ëð ���2ï í �1� ¢ � �Ëð �#�¾ï £Ë¢+ø ï ð»� ��� ø � í ��ï Æ í � �b� �� ),+.-�/{��+{�102/n�3)��,/5/-��+{�102/��3)¾¢¤���1),0è��/5+4��4¯�_Õµê¶ÖªÙ Ü�Ý ��§��_Ù Ü ê<ñ Ý � Õt§��t�_ò���§�� Ý ë���Ù Ý ��Ö1§�� Ù Ü ü}�¤ã ½� Í�¬ ½�¯ÒG�¯ã ü¤åtåê<Ö&ÖªÙ�� Ý � Ü �§�Ù^|¾�t� Ü � §�� Ù Ü ��� ® � ­�­ � Ü Ö¹êb§��&��Ù��©í�Ï�Ð�¢ ����� ãP�I·�¸rå1é²Õt��Ö¡×�§�×�êb§m§�×�� Ü �1§nô¼Ù���{±ì�Ù<��ë�×�� Õ�ìîc� Õ¶� Ü �t�&Ö1§�� ó<�pê Ü"Ý � � ãäzå/�_Õ¯ê Ü êb§t§���� ò��"§�� Ý ë��tÙ Ý ��Öª§��_Ù Ü ê<Ö&ÖªÙ�� Ý � Ü �}§�Ù³|¾�t� Ü � §��_Ù Ü ���ö��� ØÙ��¶�&ê<Ö¡×ä Ñ û » � ã{î<å � �

­<­ Ê

Page 126: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

� ),+.-�/-��+{�102/��3)8�,/�/{��+{�10¾/n�3)����,/n���AØÙ��dê Ý �_Õ©§��t�_ò��"§�� Ý êb§t§��t�_ò��"§�� Ý ë��tÙ Ý �"Öª§�� Ù Ü üi�_Õpê Ý �_Õt§���� ò��"§�� Ýì¬êb§�Ö¡× ½� � ½� ¬ ½¸ ê<Ö&ÖªÙ�� Ý � Ü � §�Ùa|¾��� Ü � §��_Ù Ü ��� ® � Ê � Ü §�×��:Ö¹ê�§��&�<Ù��tí Ï�Ð6¢ ����� ãP��·*¸rå1éqÕ���֡ק�×�êb§/§�×�� Ü �ª§nôµÙ��3{Aì�Ù<��ë�×�� Õ�ì � �_Õ/� Ü �t�&Öª§�� ó<�¬ê Ü"Ý � $ ã äzå/� Õrê Ü êb§t§��t�_ò��"§�� Ý ì¬ê�§�Ö¡× êbÖ&Ö&Ù<� Ý � Ü �c§�Ù|¾�t� Ü ��§�� Ù Ü ���ö���Bf¯ØÙ��°�&ê<Ö¡×dä Ñ�� � � <\�� Ü Öª�¶ï°�t�&Õt§���� Öª§�� Ý §�×��rÖ&Ù�ì�ë¤Ù Ü � Ü §�Õ£Ù<Ø�ê Ý �_Õt§���� ò��"§�� Ý ë��tÙ Ý ��Öª§��_Ù Ü §�Ùpò¤�¯êb§t§��t�_ò��"§�� Ý ë"��Ù Ý ��Öª§��_Ù Ü Õê Ü�Ý §�×��]Ö&Ù�ì�ë¤Ù Ü � Ü §�Õ�ÙbØõê Ý �_Õ©§���� ò��"§�� Ý ì¬êb§�Ö¡×±§�Ù6òz�qêb§�§���� ò��"§�� Ý ì¬êb§�Ö¡×��&Õªé�ï»Ö¹ê Ü ê<ñ ô¼ê¹í�Õ�ÖªÙ Ü Õ©§����"Öª§§�×��¯ë"��Õ�×�Ù<�"§/Ù<صê¬����ó�� Ü�Ý �_Õt§���� ò��"§�� Ý ë���Ù Ý ��Ö1§�� Ù Ü ã ü � ½î�å]ê Ü�Ý ê¬§�Ù<§¡ê<ñ Ý � Õt§��t�_ò���§�� Ý ì�Ù��të�×��_Õtì ½� �«°×��_Õ/�_ÕÂò�ê<Õ�� Ý Ù Ü §�×��±Ø{ê<Öª§&éȧ�×�êb§Â§�×��>ë���Õ�×"Ù��"§rÙ<ص§�×��>���ªÕt§��t�_Ö1§�� Ý ì�Ù���ë�×"�_Õ�ì�Õ¾Ù<Ø�§�×"� Ý �_Õt§���� ò��"§�� Ýë���Ù Ý ��Ö1§��_Ù Ü ê Ü�Ý §�×��dì�êb§�Ö¡×ýÖ&ê Ü òz�´ÖªÙ Ü Õt§�����Ö1§�� Ý ë¤Ù�� Ü §nô³�_Õt�<� ï Ü ë�êb�t§�� Ö&��ñ_ê<�&éÀï Ý Ù Ü Ù<§>×�ê¥ó<�c§�ÙÖ¡×��&Ö�{´§�×"�6ñ Ù�Ö&ê<ñ_��§ní�Ö&Ù Ü�Ý � §�� Ù Ü Õ¼ØÙ<�qê±ì�êb§�Ö¡×��>^¢+ø@£Àøu¤ �Y��� ø �¦¥�§z¥�§ � ¨ ��£Àø ���u� p � ¤ � £¡ð�¤¹�ÈøDð � ��ø � ¤ � ¢�ð�� � � ø �'�ªRE�H ½îe�i³ ¬ ´ KPBuC ½� �±³¶¬ z ± E HsT2HXKPo]S.B#Í1Et² H�SX¹ E6OIT2C E�o]O�T F�QlJUS.M3OVMVS.B �¿ø ï ° ����� M#N2²½JH�J@KUH � � ã äzå�S.M�KPBWKUH�H�F�S ± N H9E1CLQlF�T¾CuNe² H�SYT B Ke²t²1T F�CeS.BUÁWH9TZ\^E�_ B SXH�SYT Bº`2b�`2b¶µ�[XT�F�E�Ke²½J:ä Ñ û » � ã{î<å �KPBDC � $ ãäzå�SpMVKPB K¾H3H�F�S ± NUHsE1CWOLKUHs²½JåKe²t²1T F�CeS.B¾ÁúH9T�\^E�_ B SXH�SYT Bú`2b�`2b¸·I[XT FLE�Ke²½Jýä Ñ � � b¼�JDEGBDiH�JDE^QRT S.BuH�m(SpM�EnQRNPM3JDT2NUH^²1T B M1H�F1N2² H5S5T B¦S.B�¹ÄT B M#H5F#N2²�H�SYT B `2bgf¾b¶ºLµUS5EGo5CeM´K6QRN,M3JuT2N H^T [ ½î³K�BDC ½� SpB��ø ï ° ����� b <v¼���¥�swÇÈ�1§±ã>»dÒ ½W Ò ½û�å³ò¤�6Ö&Ù Ü Õ©§��t��Öª§�� Ý ØÙ�� ½î>ê Ü�Ý ½� ê<Ö&ÖªÙ�� Ý � Ü �>§�Ù6�¼Ù Ü Õt§�����Ö1§�� Ù Ü ���g}��l�"�¼º �r×�ê¥ó<�¶§�Ù�Õ�×"Ù+ô§�×�êb§h» � Õ¶êcì�Ù Ý �&ñÀ� Ü �¿ø ï ° ����� �c«°×"�¬���ªÕt§¶Ù<Ø^§�×"�¬ë��tÙ�Ù<Ø^�_Õ§�×�� Ü ê Ü êbñ_Ù���Ù<��Õ�ñ�íl§�Ùc§�×���ë���Ù�Ù<Ø^� Ü����}�� ­�­ �À«°×��/Ù Ü ñ ípë���Ù�ò"ñ_�&ì ØÙ��^§�×"�6ÖªÙ Ü Õ©§����"Öª§�� Ù Ü Ù<Øk»aê<�t�/§�×��6êb§�§���� ò��"§�� Ý ����ê<ë"×}ì�Ù���ë"×��_Õtì�Õ¼ØÙ<�� Ý ���ªÕ/ç�� Ñ É � Õ���Ö¡×�§�×�êb§¾§�×"�&���¶�1Á��_Õ©§�ÕÂê´ç Ñ ¸ � Z � � ã � � å³ô³� §�× W � ã-ç+å³ËCç��õÙ��]§�×��ª���¯�ÏÁ��_Õt§�Õ/êç Ñ � � Zýî � ã � � å³ô³��§�×mû � ã{ç+å³Ë ç��h�qº)�¯×�ê¥ó<�¶§�Ù¬Õ�×�Ù¥ô §�×�� Ü éz§�×�êb§ �D¼ ã � ã{ç+å�å�ÿVz³ã-ç+å�ÿ �k¼ ãX�²ã-ç+åtå � Þã{���ªÕ�ë÷� � : ã � ã-ç+åtå¾ÿD´:ã-ç+å2ÿ � : ã���ã{ç+å�å � Þ åu�_Õ�ê Ü ê�§�§��t�_ò���§�� Ý ����ê<ë�×�ì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ìc��ïkØ��²ã{ç+å Ñ ¸ � Z � � ã � � å§�×�� Ü � ¼ ãX�²ã-ç+åtå¼�_Õ^§�×"�r� Ý � Ü §���§ní´ê Ü"Ý »}ã{ç � å^�_Õ³ê Ü êb§t§���� ò��"§�� Ý ����êbë�×dì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ìc�ÀïkØ(�²ã-ç+åmË � ãæ�åµØÙ<�êræ ѳ� � §�×"� Ü �k¼ ãX�²ã-ç+åtå��_Õµê¶ë��"Õ�×�Ù���§^ì�Ù���ë�×"�_Õ�ìc�Rx�í�ÖªÙ Ü Õ©§����"Öª§�� Ù Ü Ù<ØÈë"��Õ�×�Ù<�"§�Õ^� Ü §�×��£Ö&êb§��ª��Ù��tíì�Ð6¢cã{Õ��ª�±#À��Ù�ë¤Ù�Õt� §�� Ù Ü ���Ã�"�Ã�²åÏé � ¼ ãX�²ã{ç+å�å 5 ó � Õ]§�×��¯� Ý � Ü §���§nídÕ�� Ü Ö&� � � ãæ�å 5 ó �_Õ³§�×"�¯� Ý � Ü §�� §ní<�q\�� Ü Öª�� � ãæ�å ó �_Õõ� Ü �t�&Öª§�� ó<�<é�ê<ñ_ÕtÙ � ¼ ã��²ã-ç+å�å�� Õ÷� Ü �t�&Öª§�� ó<�]ã3� Ç&GÙbô�� ® �hå1��«°×��&�t�ªØÙ��t�<é � ¼ ãX�²ã{ç+å�å � Þ � Õõê Ü êb§�§���� ò��"§�� Ý����ê<ë"×cì�Ù��të�×��_Õtì ê Ü"Ý ÕtÙ3»}ã{ç � å^�_Õ³ê Ü êb§t§��t�_ò��"§�� Ý ����ê<ë�×cì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ìc�R� Ü êbñ_Ù���Ù<��Õ�ñ�í¬Ö&ê Ü ò¤�/Õ�×�Ù¥ô ܧ�×�êb§ � : ã � ã{ç+å�å�ÿ^´:ã-ç+å ÿ � : ãX�²ã{ç+å�å � Þ �_Õ³ê Ü êb§t§��t�_ò��"§�� Ý ����ê<ë�×dì�Ù<��ë�×�� Õ�ìc� �«°×��_Õqë���Ù�ë¤�&�©§nícÙ<Ø Ý �_Õ©§��t�_ò��"§�� Ý ë���Ù Ý ��Ö1§��_Ù Ü Õ¾ê Ü"ÝlÝ �_Õ©§��t�_ò��"§�� Ý ì¬êb§�Ö¡×��&Õ¾ê<ñ_ñ Ù+ô³Õ°§�×��±ê<ë�ë"ñ_�_Ö&êb§�� Ù Ü Ù<ØÝ �_Õ©§���� ò��"§�� Ý ë"��Ù Ý ��Öª§��_Ù Ü Õ�ô³� §�×�Ù��"§�Ö¡×��ªÖ�{�� Ü �ýÙ<ØÂñ Ù�Ö&ê<ñ_��§níyÖ&Ù Ü"Ý � §��_Ù Ü Õª�i«°×�� Ý � ���&Ö1§ Ý �ª����ó<ê�§��_Ù Ü � ÕÖ&Ù Ü Õ©§��t��Öª§�� Ý ë¤Ù�� Ü §nô³� Õ��6ê<Õ°�ÏÁ"ë"ñhê<� Ü � Ý � Ü �¼×�êbë"§��ª��}�é�\��&Ö1§��_Ù Ü }��ö��� ­ �� � � ø@¢ ��Æ ¥�§z¥�§ � Ä � ï�� ¢ � � ��ï�� ¢ � � í ��� ø �'�¼�JDEWCÃS.F�Et² HZC EGF3SX¹tK¾H�S5T�B T [�KkÁÃSX¹ E�B CeSpM#H�F�S ± NUHsE1CºQlF�T¾C@N2² H5S5T B�ü ��ã ½î¿� ½� ¬ ½�/å�KPBDC KéO6KUH9²½J½� � ½� ¬ ½¸ [XT F¢üºE�s¾SpM#H�M�KPoXm¡K�µ M�KPBDC�SpM�²½J@K�F�Ke²�HsE�F�S¾½ E1C ± µ¦H5JDEÊQ¡N,M3JDTeN H]T [ ½îZKPBDC ½� SpB ²�KUHsE3ÁUT FsµÏ�Ð6¢ ����� ãP��·*¸råtb <v¼���¥�sw«°×��¾ë���Õt×�Ù��"§³ÙbØ ½� ê Ü�Ý8½îr�ÏÁ��_Õt§�Õ^� Ü §�×��¾Ö&êb§��ª��Ù��©í6Ï�Ð�¢ ���k� ã���·*¸¶å�� Ø÷§�×��¾ë���Õt×�Ù��"§³ÙbØõ§�×��¾� Ü�Ý �&�syñ í�� Ü �´ì�Ù Ý �&ñ»ì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ì�Õ ½� � ³ ¬ z ê Ü�Ý ½î}�Y³ ¬ ´ � Ü §�×��>Ö¹ê�§��&�<Ù��tí��¿ø ï ����� �ÏÁ��_Õt§&�±«°×��&� �ë���Õ�×"Ù��"§/�1Á�� Õt§Â� Ü �¿ø ï ���k� é÷��ØÀ§�×��¶ëzÙ�� Ü §nô³�_Õ��rë���Õt×�Ù��"§/ÖªÙ Ü Õt§�����Ö1§�� Ù Ü � Ü �"��}��l��ØÙ��q§�×��¯�t�&Õ©§���� Öª§�� Ýì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ì�Õ ½î¤Ð ¿)ê Ü�Ý ½� Ð ¿Aí�� �&ñ Ý Õqê�ë���Õt×�Ù��"§q� Ü �¿ø ï ° ���k� ãÖªØ���«°×��ªÙ����ªìü����}�� ­ �±ë¤Ù�� Ü § ­ åÏ�¼«°×�� Õq� Õ

­<­ �

Page 127: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

§�×��/Ö¹êbÕ��6ê<Ö&ÖªÙ�� Ý � Ü �±§�Ù�#À��Ù�ë¤Ù�Õt� §�� Ù Ü ���ö��� ­ }�� �

­ },�

Page 128: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

À Á ÂÄÃ ÅÇÆÉÈ Ê

ËÍÌÏÎxÐ Ñ�Ò¯Ó ÔjÕ�ÖvÎx×6ØMÙ§×?Ì Ú Ì Û Ü Î§ÑsØÞÝ­ß&àHÚ Ù�ÔjÎ$Ø�Î<ÔgÙ�ÔNáâ Ô�Ð ØãÌÏÎ$Ñ�ÒäËÍÌÏÎxÐ åæÒ6ÑsÕ ×�Ú Ó ×�ÕVÙ<Îx×6çÞå¬Ù�Ôjá èêé¬ÕVÙ�Ô�Ð ÕÑ�Ú�á Ù§ÝMÔj×�Î ë ÝMÔNÖ5ìª×�ÚMí

«°×��_Õ�Ö¡×�ê<ë"§��&�^� Ü §��&�<��êb§��&Õ Ý �_Õ©§���� ò��"§�� Ý �<��ê<ë�×�§���ê Ü ÕtØÙ��tì¬ê�§��_Ù Ü ê Ü�Ý ê¶ë"��Ù�ë¤Ù�Õ���§�� Ù Ü ê<ñ"§��&ì�ëzÙ<��ê<ñ�ñ Ù����_Öò²írÖ&Ù<ì¯ò�� Ü � Ü �që����¦înÙ�� Ý �&�tÕ�ô³� §�×±ë���Ù�ë¤Ù�Õt� §�� Ù Ü ê<ñ�§��&ì�ëzÙ<��ê<ñ�ñ_Ù��<�_Ö<�Dïµírì��¹ê Ü Õ�Ù<ؤê£ë��t�dînÙ<� Ý �ª�uÙ¥ó��&� Ý �_Õ"î§���� ò��"§�� Ý ����ê<ë�×lì�Ù��të�×��_Õtì�Õ]ï Ý �t� Ü �Vñ<�t�1¢��2û(ð>ñ-ò��1�k¢¤���dò���óIòn�1�£¢����t�<�6ô¹���Ï�xõ����_öqê Ü�Ý òn�1�£¢����t�<��ñ<�t�1¢���¬��ó��1�Bö1� : ��ê<ë"×�în� Ü §��&�të����1§�� Ý ØÙ���ì¯�"ñhê<Õrê<����§��&ì�ë¤Ù���ê<ñÀØÙ��tì¯��ñ_ê<Õ&é�ô³×��&�t�¬§�×���ó<êb���hêbò�ñ_�ªÕ¶ê<�t�¬� Ü §��&�"îë����1§�� Ý ò�í Ý �_Õ©§���� ò��"§�� Ý ì�Ù���ë�×"�_Õ�ì�Õ&é�§�×�ê�§¯ØÙ���ì §�×��pÕt§�êb§��ªÕ±Ù<Ø°§��ªì�ë¤Ù���ê<ñµ�<��ê<ë�×yì�Ù Ý �&ñ Õ¶ê<Õrô¼�ªñ_ñ4�«°×��/ì¬ê<� Ü � Ý �&ê<Õ³Ù<Ø�§�×�� Õ°Ö&Ù�ì¯ò"� Ü êb§��_Ù Ü ôµ�&�t� Ý �ªó<�&ñ_Ù<ëz� Ý � ÜÇ÷ : ø*ö����é : ø*öh�<ÊSø4�ïµíýì��&ê Ü Õ>Ù<Øq§�×��cë����¦înÙ�� Ý �&��ê Ü"Ý §�×"�}�ÏÁ"� Õt§�� Ü Öª�|Ù<Ø£ñ_�¹êbÕt§���ë�ë¤�&�>ò¤Ù�� Ü�Ý Õ�ï¯ÖªÙ Ü Õt§�����Ö1§pê¨ò-�¡¢ ð4���<�ò��1�£¢����t�<�m�¬��ó��1�z§�×�êb§¯� Õ6§ní�ë�� Ö¹ê<ñmØÙ��rê|Ö&ñ_ê<Õ�Õ6Ù<Ø°§��&ì�ëzÙ���ê<ñÀì�Ù Ý �ªñ_Õ6� Ü §�×���Õ�� Ü Õ��p§�×�êb§¶��§¶Õ�êb§�� Õ����ªÕ�1Á"ê<Öª§�ñ í�§�×�Ù�Õ��>ØÙ��tì¯��ñhêbÕ£§�×�ê�§¯ê<�t�>Õ�êb§��_Õ���� Ý ò�íAê<ñ ñ�§��ªì�ë¤Ù���ê<ñuì�Ù Ý �ªñ_ÕÂÙ<ص§�×�� Õ/Ö&ñhêbÕ�Õ&��«°×��>§ní�ë"�_Ö¹êbñì�Ù Ý �&ñõ� Õ³� Ü ��� Ü �ª��ê<ñ � Ü � §��6ê Ü"Ý � Ü ê<ò�ñ_�ªÕ]§�Ù�ì�êCùb�r��Õt�¶Ù<Ø»§�×��/óbê<��� �ª§ní´Ùbسã-êb�"§�Ù�ì�êb§��_Ö¥åµó<�&�t�p��Ö&êb§�� ٠ܧ��&Ö¡× Ü �_%²���ªÕ Ý �1ó��ªñ_Ù�ë¤� Ý � Ü §�×��6ê<�t�¹ê±Ù<Ø�§��ªì�ë¤Ù���êbñ÷ñ_Ù��<�_Ö<é��<�ö����ì�Ù Ý �&ñ¸îkÖ¡×��&Öbù²� Ü ���ï Ý ��� Ü ��êcÖªÙ Ü Ö&�t�ª§���ë��t�dîkÙ�� Ý �ª�/Ù+ó<�&� Ý �_Õ©§��t�_ò��"§�� Ý ����ê<ë�×�Õ6� Ü §�×"��Ö&êb§��ª��Ù��©í�Ù<Ø Ý �_Õt§���� ò��"§�� Ý ����ê<ë"×�Õô³� §�×dê�§�§��t�_ò���§�� Ý ����ê<ë�×�Õ³êbÕ°ñ_Ù�Ö¹ê<ñ¤Õt§�êb§��ªÕqê Ü�Ý Õ�×�Ù¥ô §�×��Â�1Á�� Õt§�� Ü Ö&�/Ù<Ø�ñ �¹ê<Õ©§³��ë�ë¤�&�°ò¤Ù�� Ü�Ý Õ°ØÙ��µ§�×�� Õë����¦înÙ�� Ý �&�ª�� ì¬ê<� Ü ë�ê<�©§>Ù<Ø]§�×�� Õ±Ö¡×�ê<ë"§��&�>�_Õ±ÖªÙ Ü Ö&�ª� Ü � Ý ô³��§�×y§�×"�cÖªÙ�ì�ëzÙ�Õt� §��_Ù Ü êbñmó<�&�t�p��Ö&êb§�� Ù Ü Ù<س§��&ì�ë¤Ù���ê<ñØÙ���ì¯�"ñhê<Õª�uï¼ë��tÙ¥ó�� Ý �/Ö&Ù Ü Ö&�&ë�§�Õ³§�×�êb§]Õt��ë�ë¤Ù��t§³§�×"�6Ö¡×"�&Öbù²� Ü ��Ù<Ø»��ñ_Ù�ò�ê<ñ�ë��tÙ�ë¤�&�t§��_�ªÕ]� Ü ê Ý �_Õt§���� ò��"§�� ÝÕtí�Õt§��&ìc��«°×��µ� Ý �&ê]� Õȧ�×�� Ý � ó��_Õt�_Ù Ü Ù<Ø�ê]�<ñ_Ù�ò�êbñ�ë���Ù<ëz�ª�t§ní/� Ü §�Ùqñ Ù�Ö&ê<ñ�ë��tÙ�ëz�ª�t§��_�&Õªéb§�×�êb§�Ö¹ê Ü òz�mÖ¡×��ªÖbù<� Ý� Ü ê Ý �_Õt§�� Ü �<���_Õt×�� Ý Õt��ò�îkÕtí�Õt§��&ì Ù<Øm§�×�� Ý � Õt§��t�_ò���§�� Ý Õtí�Õt§��&ìc�6«°×"�±ñ_Ù�Ö¹ê<ñÈÕ�ê�§��_Õ©Ø{ê<Öª§��_Ù Ü Ù<Øm§�×��¶ñ_Ù�Ö¹ê<ñØÙ���ì¯�"ñhê<Õ�� Ü §�×��&Õt�³Õ���ò�îkÕtí�Õt§��&ì�Õmê Ü�Ý §�×��^§ní�ë��_Ö&ê<ñ"ì�Ù Ý �&ñ�ê<���^�"Õ�� Ý §�Ù¾���&ê<Õ�Ù Ü §�Ù¾��ñ_Ù<ò�ê<ñ�Õ�êb§��_ÕtØ{êbÖª§�� Ù Ü �

«°×��pÖ¡×�ê<ë�§��&�¶�_Õ6Ù�����ê Ü �¾úª� Ý ê<Õ6ØÙ�ñ_ñ Ù¥ô³Õ&�¯ï/Õt§�ê<�t§rô³� §�× ê|ò��t�_�1Ø°���1ó�� �ªô � Ü ë���Ù<ëzÙ�Õt� §��_Ù Ü êbñu§��&ì�ë¤Ù���ê<ññ_Ù���� Ö6ê Ü�Ý � Ü §��&����êb§��6§�×�� Õqñ Ù���� Ö/ô³��§�×lë"���dîkÙ�� Ý �&��Õª�£«°×�� Õ£� Ü §��&����êb§�� Ù Ü � Ü Ö&ñ � Ý �ªÕ]§�×��¯Ö&Ù Ü Õt§�����Ö1§��_Ù Ü Ù<ا�×��¶§ní�ë�� Ö¹ê<ñ»ì�Ù Ý �ªñ�ØÙ��q§��&ì�ë¤Ù���ê<ñ�ì�Ù Ý �ªñ_Õ³ô³� §�×�ë����¦înÙ�� Ý �&�tÕ&�/ï Ü §�×��¯ØÙ<ñ_ñ_Ù¥ô³� Ü ��Õt�&Ö1§��_Ù Ü é÷ï Ý �t� Ü �>êÖ&Ù Ü Öª���1§���ë����¦înÙ�� Ý �&�6Ù¥ó��&� Ý � Õt§��t�_ò���§�� Ý ����ê<ë�×�ÕÂô³� §�×)ê�§�§��t�_ò���§�� Ý ����ê<ë�×�Õrê<Õ/ñ_Ù�Ö¹ê<ñ�Õt§¡ê�§��&Õrê Ü�Ý Ö&Ù Ü îÕt§��t��Öª§µ� §�Õmñ_�¹êbÕt§���ë�ë¤�&�µòzÙ�� Ü�Ý Õ&��ï Ý �t� Ü �q§��&ì�ëzÙ���ê<ñ�����ê<ë�×�ì�Ù Ý �&ñ Õmê Ü�Ý §�×��ª�_�m��� Ü �&��ê�§��_Ù Ü ò�í�����êbë�×����ê<ì�ì�ê<��Õª�6«°×"�±ñhê<Õ©§ÂÕ��ªÖª§�� Ù Ü Ù<Øm§�×�� Õ¾Ö¡×�ê<ë�§��&�/� Ü ó<�&Õ©§��_��êb§��ªÕ¾§�×��¯ó<�&���Ö��Ö¹ê�§��_Ù Ü Ù<Ø�ñ_Ù�Ö¹ê<ñ»ê Ü�Ý ��ñ Ù�ò�ê<ñë���Ù�ë¤�&�©§�� �&Õ°� ÜdÝ � Õt§����_ò"�"§�� Ý Õ©í�Õt§��ªì�Õª�

ù §�û ü ¢+ø@£Àøu¤�ý=þ*ý{ø ÿ�í Å ��� Æ £Àøu¢ í Å r�ø î ý-�ï Ü §�×��_Õ°Õt�&Öª§��_Ù Ü ï¼�t�ªó��_�1ô §�×��rÖªñhê<ÕtÕ�� Ö¹ê<ñ÷Õ©í Ü §�ê�Á}ê Ü�Ý Õ��ªì¬ê Ü §��_ÖªÕ³ØÙ<�^§�×��/ë��tÙ�ëzÙ<Õ�� §��_Ù Ü ê<ñzØ��ê<��ì�� Ü §³Ù<Øñ_� Ü �¹ê<�/§��ªì�ë¤Ù���êbñ¼ñ_Ù<���_Öbéuê<ÖªÖ&Ù�� Ý � Ü �}§�Ù ÷ \�§��¾���_ø-��«°×��´Ö&ñ_ê<Õ�Õt�_Ö¹êbñ¼Õ��ªì¬ê Ü §��_ÖªÕ¯�_Õ¯ò�ê<Õ�� Ý Ù Ü §���ê Ü Õ���§��_Ù ÜÕtí�Õt§��&ì�Õ&�mïm� Ü §��tÙ Ý �"Ö&�£§��&ì�ëzÙ���ê<ñèì�Ù Ý �ªñ_Õ¼ò�í Ý �t� Ü � Ü �>ê Ü �ªóbê<ñ_��êb§�� Ù Ü ÙbØ�óbê<�t�hê<ò"ñ_�&Õµê Ü�Ý ì�Ù��të�×��_Õtì�Õòz�1§nô¼�ª� Ü §�×��_Õ°ì�Ù Ý �&ñ_ÕµØÙ���ì�� Ü �>ê±Ö&êb§��ª��Ù��tí<����� Ü êbñ_ñ í�ï Ý �t� Ü �6ô³×"� Ü ê¯ØÙ��tì¯��ñ_ê¯�_Õ°Õ�ê�§��_Õ½��� Ý �

­ � ­

Page 129: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

Ï � � ÿký>þoýø ÿ ù�§�û@§�û �"þ � Æ £Àø@¢�í Å �kø@¢ Æ ð Å í �ÇÈ�1§���òz�³ê>ãÖ&Ù�� Ü §�ê<ò�ñ_�¹å�Õ��1§mÙ<ؤ¢¤���¡¢��*ödð>ò�ð4�_ñ¤�<�"���<�¦ð{���&�_�bö1���Íò��1�£¢����t�<��ô¹���Ï�xõ����°� ÕÀ꾧��ª��ìC�<� Ü �ª��êb§�� Ýò²í¬§�×��ÂØÙ�ñ ñ_Ù¥ô³� Ü �¶Õtí Ü §¡ê�Á

�i� � Ë��´Ð��rÐ� Þ � �¼.�Ð����rÐ����

ï¼ñ_�1§��£Ò�� Þ ¹¹³��ê Ü ���ÂÙ¥ó��ª�]§�×��/Õ��ª§v��� Ù<Ø�ØÙ���ì¶��ñhê<Õª� �«°×��¯Ù�ë¤�&��êb§�Ù��tÕ� ê Ü�Ý � ê<�t�r§�×��¯��Õt��ê<ñ�Ù Ü �&ÕqØÙ�� Ü �ª��êb§��_Ù Ü ê Ü�Ý ÖªÙ Ü �t� Ü Ö1§�� Ù Ü �£«°×"�¯Ù�ë¤�&��ê�§�Ù��tÕ��ê Ü�Ý � Ö&Ù Ü Õt§�� §���§��´� Ü Õt§��&ê Ý §�×"�p§��&ì�ë¤Ù���ê<ñ�ë�ê<�©§>Ù<Ø°§�×"�´ñ_Ù���� Ö<���³Ù�����×"ñ í�éÀÕt� Ü Öª�p§�×��¬Õ��&ì�ê Ü §�� Ö&Õ±� Õ��� ó<� Ü � Ü §��&�tì�ÕÂÙ<صê Ü �1óbê<ñ_��ê�§��_Ù Ü Ù¥ó��&��ãÕ��ª%��"� Ü Öª�&Õ¶ÙbØ¡åqÕ©§¡êb§��&ÕÂÙ<صêNò{�t�Cñ�ödð>òPð4�_ñ�ö1�oödòn�1�±é÷§�×��©ñ�����ò5ûòPð �¬�(îkÙ�ëz�ª��êb§�Ù���� Ý �&ì�ê Ü�Ý Õ³§�×�êb§qê±ØÙ<��ì¯��ñ_ê±×�Ù�ñ Ý Õ°� Ü §�×��/�_ì�ì�� Ý �_êb§��¾Õt��Ö&Öª�&ÕtÕ�Ù��qÕt§¡ê�§��<é�ô³×�� ñ_�¾§�×���1�<�dñ-òPõ"�<� ���¦îkÙ�ë¤�&��ê�§�Ù����·�t�&%²���_�t�&ÕÀ§�×�êb§µêÂØÙ<��ì¯��ñ_ê£ò¤�&Ö&Ù<ì��ªÕm§������³ÕtÙ�Ù Ü �&�mÙ��Àñhê�§��&�ª�»ï Ü §�×"�³ØÙ<ñ_ñ_Ù¥ô³� Ü ��éï¼ê<ë"ë�ñ í�§�×��Â�"Õ���ê<ñÈêbò�ò����1ó��hêb§��_Ù Ü ÕµØÙ��^�_ì�ë�ñ �_Ö¹ê�§��_Ù Ü ¬ ê Ü�ÝdÝ � ÕY�t� Ü Öª§�� Ù Ü � �m«°×��ÂòzÙ�Ù�ñ �¹ê Ü ÖªÙ Ü Õt§�ê Ü §! îb`¤çrÖ&ê Ü ò¤� Ý �t� Ü � Ý êbÕ£ê>ñ_Ù��<�_Ö¹êbñz§¡êb�"§�Ù�ñ Ù��<í<é�ØÙ��³� Ü Õ©§¡ê Ü Öª�6ê<Õ*� � (�¯ØÙ<�]ë"��Ù�ë¤Ù�Õ���§�� Ù Ü ê<ñ�óbê<�t�hê<ò"ñ_�&Õ�¯� Ü �>��«°×"�/§��&ì�ëzÙ<��ê<ñm�<�#"��<�*ö�îkÙ�ë¤�&��ê�§�Ù��^� Õ Ý �t� Ü � Ý ò²í%$&�e� Ë'�����£��£Õ^ê Ü �1Á"ê<ì�ë�ñ �]§�×��q§��&ì�ëzÙ���ê<ñ�ØÙ��tì¯��ñhê�� Þ ¬ �pã(R�&. � R�*)ªåqã{Ö&Ù Ü §�ê<� Ü � Ü �§�×"�qóbê<���_ê<ò�ñ �&Õ­� Þ ÒG�ª.¹é�ê Ü�Ý�*)1å¼×�ê<Õ°§�×��ÂØÙ�ñ_ñ Ù+ô³� Ü �¯� Ü §�� Ü�Ý � Ý ì��&ê Ü � Ü ���u� ØË� Þ ×�Ù�ñ Ý Õ^§�×"� Ü �ªó�� Ü §���ê<ñ ñ í´�ª� §�×��&�Ê�&.]Ù��«��)£�_Õ^Ø{êbñ_Õ��b��£Õ³ï^ì�� Ü §�� Ù Ü � Ý é�§�×��/Ö&ñ_ê<Õ�Õt�_Ö&ê<ñõÕ��ªì¬ê Ü §��_Ö&Õ³� Õ°ò�ê<Õ�� Ý Ù Ü §���ê Ü Õt� §�� Ù Ü Õtí�Õt§��&ì�Õ&�=��§���ê Ü Õ�� §��_Ù Ü Õ©í�Õ©§��ªìÖ&Ù Ü Õt�_Õ©§�Õ³Ù<Ø�ê>Õt�ª§]Ù<Ø»Õt§�êb§��ªÕ&é�ë¤Ù�Õ�Õt�_ò�ñ�íp� Ü � Ü � §��<é�ê Ü�Ý ê>�t�&ñ_êb§�� Ù Ü Ù Ü §�×��ªÕ��/Õt§�êb§��ªÕq�t�&ë��t�&Õt� Ü §�� Ü ��Õ©§¡êb§��§���ê Ü Õ���§��_Ù Ü Õ&� «°×"�dóbê<ñ � Ý ��§níAÙ<ؾêlØÙ��tì¯��ñ_êl���ªØ�ª��Õ±§�×"� Ü §�Ùý�¦õ�ñ�ö¯��� Ü �ª��êb§�� Ý ò�íyÕ���Ö¡×Ûêl§���ê Ü Õ���§��_Ù ÜÕtí�Õt§��&ì � Ü §�� Ü�Ý � Ý êbÕµ� Ü � Ü ��§��]Õ��&%²��� Ü Ö&�ªÕ³Ù<ØõÕt§�êb§��ªÕ&�À«°×��qÕ��1§,+ Ù<Øõ�t� Ü Õ¼ØÙ<�µ�ÏÁ�êbì�� Ü � Ü �Âóbê<ñ � Ý ��§ní±�_ÕµêÝ �&Õt�_� Ü ê�§�� Ý Õt��ò�Õt�ª§�Ù<Øzê<ñ_ñ�ë¤Ù�Õ�Õt�_ò�ñ �^��� Ü Õu§�×��tÙ�����ׯ§�×��^§���ê Ü Õ���§�� Ù Ü Õ©í�Õ©§��ªì}�À«°×��^ØÙ<ñ_ñ_Ù¥ô³� Ü � Ý �t� Ü ��§�� Ù ÜÙ<Øuꯧ���ê Ü Õt� §��_Ù Ü Õ©í�Õ©§��ªì � Õ^§¡êCùb� Ü Ø��Ù�ì ÷ \�§������oø4�Ï � � ÿký>þoýø ÿ ù�§�û@§p¨ �"þ�¢ í-ÿˤ�ý=þoýø ÿå¤dn�¤²þ � ƨ��ªò{���Cñ�ödð>ò�ð4�_ñ3ö1�*ödòn�1� �_Õuê]§���� ë�ñ_�­·eË.-0/�Ò�¬ Ò1+ ù ô³×"�&���2/�� Õuê Ü Ù Ü în�ªì�ë�§ní¶Õt�ª§ÀÙ<Ø1ödò4�Còn�bö1ée¬ ' /�(�/�_Õ6ê�ò{�t�Cñ�ödð>òPð4�_ñy���1���Cò�ð4�_ñ�é�ê Ü�Ý +a�_Õ6êdÕ��43±ÁAÖ&ñ Ù�Õ�� Ý Õt�ª§rÙ<ؾ�¦õ6ñ�ö1�65 �¦õ�ñ87ðËwã97mã9:�å;7mã ­ å1�� å£ô³� §�×7mã{Ókå Ñ /Û�_Õ]ê>ì¬ê+Á"� ì¬êbñ�ñ_� Ü �<§�×|ë�êb§�×c§�×���Ù<����×}§�×��/§���ê Ü Õ���§��_Ù Ü Õ©í�Õt§��ªì}�¼ïk§�Õ]�¸îk§�×}Õt�43±Á}�_Õ³��� ó<� Ü ò²í7¼Ð ö Ëþã<7mã{Ókå;7mãÓ � ­ åÏ � å1�5 ò{�t�Cñ�ödð>òPð4�_ñsö1�*ödò��1� �¬���k¢>=6ð¾ö1�@?Û��-0/�Ò1A Ò1+ ù A -0/CBhÒ1ADBhÒ1+EB ù �_Õ6êdØ� Ü Öª§��_Ù Ü ?8�F/GA /CB»Õ���֡ק�×�êb§�?Èã9+/å ' +EBhé"ô³×��&�t��?Èã<7mãH:�åI7mã ­ åKJLJMJ åÀË'?Èã97mã9:�å�å�?Èã97mã ­ å�å�JMJLJ"ØÙ��³ê<ñ ñ�7}ËN7mã9:�å;7mã ­ åKJLJLJ Ñ +¯� �ïÂê<ñ ô¼ê¹í�Õ¶ê<ÕtÕ���ì��>§�×�êb§6�1ó��&�©í)Õ©§¡êb§���Ù�Ö&Öª����Õ6� Ü Õ�Ù<ì��>��� Ü �p«���ê Ü Õt� §��_Ù Ü Õtí�Õ©§��&ì ì�Ù���ë�×"�_Õ�ì�Õ/ê<ñ ñ_Ù¥ô§�Ù�Õ��_ì¶��ñhêb§��¾§�×��/�t� Ü Õ]Ù<Ø�§�×��rÕtÙ����tÖ&�6Õtí�Õt§��&ìüô³� §�×"� Ü §�×��/§¡êb�����1§qÕ©í�Õt§��ªì}éè� Ü Ù�� Ý �&�°§�Ù�ë��t�&Õt�&�tó<�<é�ê<ÕÕ�×�Ù¥ô Ü ñhêb§��&�&é�§�×�� Ü Ù<§��_Ù Ü ÙbØFO��<�¢ð�óCð>ò{�^Ù<Ø�ê¾ØÙ���ì¶��ñhê"�È«�Ù����1§�×��ª�mô³��§�×�ê Ü �1ó<êbñ_��êb§��_Ù Ü Ùbؤ§�×��°óbê<���_ê<ò�ñ_�ªÕ&é§�×��£§���ê Ü Õ�� §��_Ù Ü Õtí�Õ©§��&ìaÖ&Ù Ü Õ©§���§��"§��&Õ°êr§��&ì�ëzÙ<��ê<ñèì�Ù Ý �ªñ4�»«°×��Â�ªóbê<ñ ��êb§�� Ù Ü ê<Õ�Õt�_� Ü Õµ§�Ù¯�&ê<Ö¡×póbê<���_ê<ò�ñ_�ê>Õt��ò�Õt�ª§qÙ<ØP/^é�ô³×��ª���/§�×��Âóbê<�t�hê<ò�ñ �£� Õ Ý �&�&ì�� Ý §�Ù>ò¤�§����"�rê�§³�¹ê<Ö¡×c�&ñ �&ì�� Ü §]Ù<Ø»§�×��_Õ°Õt��ò�Õt�ª§¹�Q ��R ÿký>þoýø ÿ ù�S�ûTS Ä �"þ � ÆVU øTWYX Å¼Æ ø[Z � Å(�: ��ó�� Ü êq§���ê Ü Õt� §�� Ù Ü Õtí�Õt§��&ì]\eË^-0/�Ò1A Ò1+ ù ê Ü"Ý ê£Õt�ª§uÙbØ�ë���Ù<ëzÙ�Õt� §��_Ù Ü êbñ�ó<êb���hêbò�ñ_�ªÕF�>é�ê Ü �KO��<�¢õ��Cò�ð4�_ñ_w�P�`A apã(/må¶ê<ÕtÕ��_� Ü Õ¯§�Ù��&ê<Ö¡×yó<êb���hêbò�ñ_��êlÕ��1§>Ù<Ø]Õt§¡ê�§��&Õb_Âã9c<åedf/^�:«°×��´ë�êb�_�hg Ëi-9\³Òj_ ùÖ&Ù Ü Õ©§���§��"§��&Õ]ê©ò��1�£¢����t�<�õ�¬��ó��1���5þ�¬���k¢>=6ð¾ö1�k?}��g Alg B �"ôVò��1�£¢����t�<���¬��ó��1�BöPg Ë^-<\³Òm_ ù ê Ü�Ý g B Ë.-9\ B Òm_ B ù �_ռ궧���ê Ü Õ���§��_Ù ÜÕtí�Õt§��&ì ì�Ù���ë�×"�_Õ�ìn?}�o\pAl\ B Õ���Ö¡×c§�×�êb§�q Ñ _/ã9c<åsr ?ÈãHq�å Ñ _ B ã9c<å¼ØÙ��³ê<ñ ñtc Ñ �>éuq Ñ /^�«°×��>Ö¹êb§��&��Ù��©í�Ù<Ø�§��ªì�ë¤Ù���êbñuì�Ù Ý �ªñ_ÕÂê Ü"Ý §�×��&� �Âì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ì�Õ&é�ô³��§�×:§�×��±Ù�ò�ó��_Ù<��Õ/Ö&Ù�ì�ëzÙ<Õ�� §��_Ù Ü ê Ü�Ý� Ý � Ü §�� §��_�&Õªé��_Õ Ý � Ü Ù<§�� Ý ò�í � � � �

­ �o�

Page 130: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

5 Ü �ªóbê<ñ_��êb§�� Ù Ü±Ý � Ü Ù<§��ªÕ�ØÙ��m�&ê<Ö¡×�óbê<�t�hê<ò�ñ �¼§�×"Ù�Õ��]Õt§�êb§��ªÕmô³×"�&���]§�×��°óbê<�t�hê<ò�ñ �^�_Õ Ý �ª�&ì�� Ý §�Ù6òz�°§������b�º)�6×�ê¹ó�� Ü Ù¥ô ê<ñ_ñ�§�×��¶ÖªÙ�ì�ëzÙ Ü � Ü §�Õ Ü �&� Ý � Ý §�Ù¬� Ü�Ý ��Ö1§���ó��&ñ�í´� Ü §���Ù Ý ��Ö&�/§�×"� Ü Ùb§��_Ù Ü Ù<Ø]ö&�CòPð¾ö=ôª���dò�ð4�_ñÙ<Ø»§��&ì�ëzÙ<��ê<ñ�ØÙ<��ì¯��ñ_ê<Õ,� ØÙ��³ê±��� ó<� Ü ��� Ü 7u�Q ��R ÿký>þoýø ÿ ù�S�ûTSwv ��x*X�þoý9x��0X>yCþ*ý{ø ÿ8ø��iþ � ÆVU øTWzX Å �køTW Æ�{»Å X �ÇÈ�1§|g Ë^-9\³Òj_ ù ò¤�¾ê/§��&ì�ë¤Ù���ê<ñèì�Ù Ý �&ñ�Ù¥ó��ª�2��é²ô³×��ª���E\ Ëk-0/�Ò�A Ò1+ ù �C5vØÙ<��ì¯��ñ_ê��Û�_Õ�Õ�êb§��_Õ�}�� Ýò²í´ê��t� Ü 7 Ñ +¯é Ý � Ü Ù<§�� Ý ê<Õ,7�ÐË'�£é���Ø�Ù Ü �/Ù<Ø�§�×��ÂØÙ�ñ ñ_Ù¥ô³� Ü �¶Ö¹ê<Õt�&Õ]�_Õ^ó��ª���L}�� Ý �

~ 7yÐË�c�r 7mã9:�å Ñ _/ã<c�å¼ØÙ��³êbñ_ñtc Ñ �~ 7yÐË����r 7D�Ð Ë��~ 7yÐË���� � �|��r 7yÐË'���^ê Ü�Ý 7�ÐËN�|�~ 7yÐË�����r 7¼Ð��qÐË'�~ 7yÐË�����r �"Ó Ñ ï ñ�·Õ��"Ö¡×}§�×�êb§,7¼Ð ö Ð Ë��

«°×��ÂØÙ���ì¯�"ñhêb� �_Õ2g î�ò-�¦õ��1é"Õ�×"Ù��t§>ÐË����£é�� Ø�7yÐË�� ØÙ��³êbñ_ñt7 Ñ +¯�mïk§³� Õ�O��<�¢ð�ó<é Ý � Ü Ù<§�� Ý ò�í Ð Ë��£é� سРËE��� ØÙ��³ê<ñ_ñ�ì�Ù Ý �&ñ Õ&g � �«°×��¾Õ��ªì¬ê Ü §��_Ö&ê<ñ�� Ý �¹ê¶ò¤�&×"� Ü�Ý ì�Ù��të�×��_Õtì�Õ�Ù<Øõ§��&ì�ëzÙ���ê<ñ¤ì�Ù Ý �&ñ Õµ� Õ¼� Ü óbê<�t�hê Ü Ö&�£ÙbØÈÕ�êb§��_ÕtØ{êbÖª§�� Ù Ü ���èÙ<��¹ê<Ö¡×d§��ªì�ë¤Ù���êbñ�ØÙ���ì¶��ñhê��eê Ü�Ý �ªó<�&�tíc�t� Ü 7:� Ü g é47�ÐË���r ?Èã97õå¾ÐËN�£�: ��ó�� Ü ê Ü êb§�ñ_�¹êbÕt§�Ö&Ù�� Ü §�ê<ò�ñ �µÕt�ª§s/yã{�4�ö�<��é�Õ���֡׶§�×�êb§È§�×"�&�����1Á�� Õt§�Õ�ê Ü � ÜY� �ªÖª§���ó��mØ� Ü Ö1§��_Ù Ü W ��ï ñ�pA /må1é� §m�_Õ��¹êbÕtí±§�Ùr� Ü�Ý �ª��Õ©§¡ê Ü�Ý §�×�êb§môµ�£ÖªÙ���ñ Ý ���ªÕt§����_Ö1§�Ù����µêb§�§�� Ü §�� Ù Ü §�Ù6§�×��³Ø��ñ_ñ�Õt��ò�înÖ&êb§��ª��Ù��©í � ���¶Ù<Ø� � ézÖªÙ Ü §¡ê<� Ü � Ü ��Ù Ü ñ íd§�×�Ù<Õ��r§��&ì�ëzÙ<��ê<ñõì�Ù Ý �&ñ_Õ³ô³×�Ù�Õt�¯Õ��1§¾Ù<ØuÕt§¡ê�§��&Õq�_ÕqÖ&Ù Ü §¡êb� Ü � Ý � Ü /^é¤ô³��§�×�Ù���§ñ_Ù�Õt� Ü �c�1Á�ë��t�&Õ�Õt� ó<�´ëzÙ¥ôµ�&�&�cï Ü Ù<§�×��&�/ôµÙ�� Ý ÕªémêcØÙ��tì¯��ñ_ê��C� Õ6óbê<ñ � Ý éõ§�×�êb§¶� ÕcÐË��£éu��Ø°ê Ü�Ý Ù Ü ñ í:��ØÐ Ë����iØÙ<�³ê<ñ_ñzì�Ù Ý �&ñ Õ2g Ñ � �]��é Ý � Ü Ùb§�� Ý ê<Õ±ÐË � �£�� ؼÖ&Ù��"��Õ��bé»Õt��Ö¡×yê´���ªÕ���ñ�§¶Õt�_ì�ë�ñ í}Õ�ê¹í�Õr§�×�êb§/ôµ��ÖªÙ���ñ Ý �t�&Õt§���� Öª§6Ù����6êb§t§�� Ü §��_Ù Ü §�Ùd§�×�ê�§ÂØ{ê<ì�� ñ í}Ù<Øì�Ù Ý �&ñ Õ&é�ô³×�Ù�Õ��´Õt�ª§±ÙbØ°�&ñ �&ì�� Ü §�Õ¯� Õ¶ÖªÙ Ü §¡ê<� Ü � Ý � Ü ï ñ� ã{Õt�&�´ê<��ê<� Ü ÷�� §������oø åÏ���]�ªó��ª�t§�×��&ñ �&Õ�ÕªéµÕt��Ö¡×�êØÙ���ì¯�"ñhêb§��_Ù Ü êbñ_ñ_Ù¥ô³ÕÀ��Õm§�Ù/� Ü ó<�&Õ©§��_��êb§��°§�×"�qÖªñhê<ÕtÕ�ÙbØz§��&ì�ëzÙ���ê<ñ�ì�Ù Ý �ªñ_ÕuÙ¥ó<�&�^êÂ����ó�� Ü � Ü §��&�të����1§¡êb§��_Ù Ü��ê Ü�Ý §�Ù}ê<Õ�ù|ØÙ<�/§�×���Ö¡×�ê<��êbÖª§��ª���mú¹êb§��_Ù Ü Ù<Ø�§�×��c�xð>ñ-ð ���<���¬��ó��1�¤Õ�ê�§��_Õ©Ø í�� Ü �}ê´��� ó<� Ü ØÙ���ì¯�"ñhê´� Ü�Ý �ª�§�×�êb§¼� Ü §��ª��ë��t�ª§�êb§�� Ù Ü � � �"Ö¡×cÖªÙ Ü Öª�&� Ü Õ^ô³�_ñ_ñ¤ò¤�£§�×��£ò�ê<Õ�� ÕµØÙ��¼Ù���� Ü Ù<§�� Ù Ü Ù<ØF�<�t�1¢>=uð>ñ-ò��1�k¢¤���dòk�Cò�ð4�_ñ>Ù<ا��&ì�ë¤Ù���ê<ñzñ_Ù��<�_Ö<é���� ó<� Ü � Ü8� �ªÖª§�� Ù Ü ���>ê Ü�Ý�� �&Öª§��_Ù Ü � ® �

ù[SM� ü W+ø U øux�ý=þ*ý{ø ÿ X Å ��� Æ�U øuWzX Å r�øT� ýHy©THÿ W_ýHyY� � ZD�/n ü W � °���WYZ � W xï Ü §�×�� Õ¼ë�ê<�©§¹é�ïÀ� Ü ó��ªÕt§�� ��êb§��£§���ê Ü Õ���§�� Ù Ü Õ©í�Õt§��ªì�Õ³êbÕ^� Ü §��tÙ Ý ��Ö&� Ý � Ü §�×��¾ë��t�ªó��_Ù<��Õ^Õ��ªÖª§��_Ù Ü é�ô³×��&�t�Â� §�ÕÕ��ª§rÙ<صÕt§�êb§��ªÕr� Õrê Ý�Ý � §��_Ù Ü ê<ñ_ñ�í}��¡²���_ë�ë¤� Ý ò�íAê´¢¤���K¢���� ó��1�Ï�£5oë��t�dîkÙ�� Ý �ª��¤@d㤠¥�¤ Ù¥ó��ª�¶êdÕ��1§¤ �_Õrê}�t�ªû��ÏÁ"��ó��´ê Ü�Ý §���ê Ü Õt� §�� ó������ªñhêb§��_Ù Ü �pï Ü Õt§��¹ê Ý Ù<Ø°� Ü §��&��ë"���ª§�� Ü �cë��tÙ�ëzÙ<Õ�� §��_Ù Ü ê<ñuóbê<���_ê<ò�ñ_�ªÕ/ò²íêcÕt�ª§¯ÙbØ^Õt§�êb§��ªÕ6ô³×"�&����§�×��>óbê<���_ê<ò�ñ �±�_Õ Ý �&�ªì�� Ý §�Ùcò¤��§������bé�ï£� Ü §��&�të����1§¶ë"��Ù�ë¤Ù�Õ���§�� Ù Ü ê<ñ�óbê<�t�hê<ò"ñ_�&Õ� Ü ê¬§��&ì�ëzÙ<��ê<ñÈì�Ù Ý �ªñ»��¡²���_ë�ë¤� Ý ò�í|ê¬ë��t�dînÙ<� Ý �ª�¾ò�ílê¬Õt� Ü �<ñ_�6Õt§¡ê�§��¯Ù Ü ñ í��E¦¾���¶§�Ù¬§�×��¶ê Ý�Ý ��§�� Ù Ü ê<ñÕt§��t��Öª§������/Ù Ü §�×��ÂÕt§�êb§��ªÕ&é�ï Ý ��} Ü �/Õ�êb§��_ÕtØ{êbÖª§�� Ù Ü ò�í¬§�×��Âë��t�dînÙ<� Ý �ª�°���&ñ_êb§�� Ù Ü � Ü §�×��¾ØÙ�ñ ñ_Ù¥ô³� Ü �¶Õ�� Ü Õ��b�5vë��tÙ�ë¤Ù�Õ���§��_Ù Ü ê<ñ�óbê<�t�hê<ò"ñ_�°�_Õ Ý �ª�&ì�� Ý §�Ùrò¤�³§����"�q� Ü §�×��qÕ©§¡êb§��£êbÕ�Õ�� � Ü � Ý ò�í>§�×��]� Ü §��ª��ë��t�ª§�êb§�� Ù Ü ê Ü�Ýê<ñ_ñmÕt§�êb§��ªÕ¶§�Ù}ô³×��_Ö¡×)§�×��pÕ©§¡êb§��pÙ<Ø^§�×��p� Ü §��&��ë"���ª§�êb§�� Ù Ü � Õr�t�&ñ_êb§�� Ý ò�í §�×��pë��t�dînÙ<� Ý �ª�&�|ïÂÖªÙ Ü Õ©§����"Öª§ØÙ��Âê Ü � Ü §��&��ë"���ª§�êb§�� Ù Ü úlêpë"���dîkÙ�� Ý �&�¾§���ê Ü Õt� §�� Ù Ü Õ©í�Õ©§��ªì §�×�êb§/� Õ$ò{�Ï¢ ð4���<��ô¹���Yú}� Ü §�×��±Õ�� Ü Õ��>§�×�ê�§� §�Õ/� Ü�Ý ��Öª� Ý ì�Ù Ý �&ñÀÕ�ê�§��_Õ;}��&Õr�1Á"ê<Ö1§�ñ í�§�×�Ù�Õt��ØÙ��tì¯��ñhêbÕ¾§�×�êb§¶ê<�t��Õ�êb§�� Õ�}�� Ý ò�í ê<ñ_ñÀì�Ù Ý �&ñ_Õ/� Ü�Ý ��Öª� Ýò²íA§�×"��§���ê Ü Õt� §�� Ù Ü Õ6Õtí�Õt§��&ì�Õ¶ô³� §�× §�×��_Õr� Ü §��ª��ë��t�ª§¡ê�§��_Ù Ü �d«°×��¬§ní�ë��_Ö&ê<ñm§���ê Ü Õ���§��_Ù Ü Õ©í�Õ©§��ªì �_Õ/Ø��ñ ñ í

­ � ®

Page 131: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

ê<ò�Õt§���ê<Ö1§£� Ü §�×��6Õ�� Ü Õ��r§�×�êb§£ê Ü í´§nô¼Ù�Õt§�êb§��ªÕqô³×�� Ö¡×lê<�t� Ü Ùb§ Ý �_Õt§�� Ü �<���_Õt×�ê<ò�ñ �Âò²ícÖªÙ Ü Õt§���ê<� Ü §�Õ³Ø��Ù�ì§�×��±� Ü §��&�të����1§¡êb§��_Ù Ü ú}ê<���>�*¡²��êbñÀ� Ü §�×"�¯§ní�ë"�_Ö¹êbñu§���ê Ü Õ���§��_Ù Ü Õtí�Õt§��&ìc�±«°×��±§ní�ë��_Ö&ê<ñÀì�Ù Ý �ªñ��_Õ�} Ü � §��� Øu§�×��¯Õ��1§ÂÙ<ØmÕ©§¡êb§��&Õ¾��Õt� Ý ØÙ��]� Ü §��ª��ë��t�ª§�� Ü �pë"��Ù�ë¤Ù�Õ���§�� Ù Ü ê<ñ÷óbê<�t�hê<ò�ñ �&Õ]�_Õ�} Ü � §��<�¾«°×"�_Õ¾êbñ_ñ_Ù¥ô³Õ]§�Ù¬�"Õ��§�×��¾ÖªÙ Ü Öª�&ë"§�Õ°� Ü §��tÙ Ý �"Ö&� Ý � Ü §�×��£§�×"�&Ù��©í¬Ù<Øõ§��&ì�ëzÙ<��ê<ñ¤ñ_Ù��<�_Ö°ØÙ��¼Ö¡×"�&Öbù²� Ü �±§��&ì�ëzÙ���ê<ñèØÙ���ì¯�"ñhê<Õm§�×�ê�§���*¡²��� ���/ì�Ù�Õt§�ñ í¬ê�} Ü � §��ÂÕ©§¡êb§��/Õ�ë�ê<Öª�<�

ï Ü §�×"��ØÙ�ñ ñ_Ù¥ô³� Ü �´ïE}"Á êdÕ��ª§$¤ ê Ü"Ý êdë����¦înÙ�� Ý �&�£¤@dĤ ¥q¤ Ù¥ó��ª�$¤ ê Ü�Ý êbÕ�Õ��"ì���§�×�êb§/§�×��ë����¦înÙ�� Ý �&��×�ê<Õ]�_���_ödò�õ¥¢�¢��1�Â�1�_õ6ñ ó_ö1�C5eñ_�&ê<Õt§µ��ë�ë¤�&��òzÙ<� Ü�Ý ØÙ<�¼ê/Õ��1§&§]d[¤ � Õ¼ê Ü �&ñ �&ì�� Ü §�¨<©uª�ã9§¾åÙ<Ø�¤ Õt��Ö¡×´§�×�ê�§ ø ¤�¨«©uª�ã9§¾åµØÙ��°ê<ñ ñ ø¬Ñ §¿ê Ü�Ý ØÙ��¼�¹ê<Ö¡×´ä Ñ ¤ ô³��§�× ø ¤:ä}ØÙ<�^ê<ñ ñ ø�Ñ §·ØÙ�ñ_ñ Ù+ô³Õ¨<©uª�ã9§¾åC¤ äÈ�Q ��R ÿký>þoýø ÿ ù�SM�[S�û �"þ � ÆVU øTWYX Å�U W � °�øTW Z � W Æ ø[Z � Å(�5 ¢¤���K¢���� ó��1�xò{���Cñ�ödð>ò�ð4�_ñqö1�*ödò��1� ô/�Ã�ª�ö§&�»êdë��t�dînÙ<� Ý �ª�£¤@d㤠¥q¤ �_Õ6êp§���ê Ü Õt� §�� Ù Ü Õtí�Õt§��&ì¬\ ­ýË-0/�Ò�A Ò1+ ù ô³×��&�t�®/kd ¤ �85i¯ òn�1�£¢������<� °>¢¤���K¢���� ó��1���¬��ó��1�zô/�Ã�ª�ö§&�|¤ �_Õrê|ë�ê<� �±g²­8Ë`-9\ ­ÈÒ�ú ù éô³×��&�t�3ú��³�]A ¤ �_Õ³ê Ü ð>ñ-òn�1�n¢¤���dò4�CòPð4�_ñ�Ù<Ø»§�×��/ë��tÙ�ëzÙ<Õ�� §��_Ù Ü ê<ñ¤óbê<�t�hê<ò"ñ_�&Õª�5 �¬���k¢>=6ð¾ö1�^?��´g²­ A g B ­ ò¤�ª§nôµ�&� Ü ë"���dîkÙ�� Ý �&�]ì�Ù Ý �&ñ Õ,g²­c˵-9\ ­ÈÒ�ú ù ê Ü�Ý g B ­c˵-9\ B ­ÈÒGú B ù�_Õ]ê>§���ê Ü Õ�� §��_Ù Ü Õ©í�Õt§��ªìüì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ì�?|�o\ ­ A \ B ­lÕt��Ö¡×|§�×�êb§¡ú�ã<c�åC¤�q6� Ø�ê Ü�Ý Ù Ü ñ íp� Ø<ú B ã9c<åC¤D?�ãHq+åØÙ��°�¹ê<Ö¡× c±� Ü �þê Ü�Ý q/� Ü /^� �� � Ü Öª�¶ë��t�dîkÙ�� Ý �ª�]§���ê Ü Õ�� §��_Ù Ü Õtí�Õ©§��&ì�ÕÂê<�t�¶Ù Ü ñ ícê�Õtëz�ªÖ&�_ê<ñ»Ö&ê<Õ��rÙ<Øu§���ê Ü Õt� §��_Ù Ü Õtí�Õt§��&ì�Õ&é÷ì�Ù��të�×��_Õtì�Õòz�1§nô¼�ª� Ü ë��t�dînÙ<� Ý �ª�q§���ê Ü Õt� §�� Ù Ü Õtí�Õt§��&ì�Õ¾Ö¹ê Ü òz� Ý ��} Ü � Ý ê Ü ê<ñ_Ù��<Ù���Õ�ñ�ídê Ü�Ý ñ_� Ø §�� Ý ��ë|§�Ù¬ë��t�dîkÙ�� Ý �ª�ì�Ù Ý �&ñ Õ&�±¶À���dîkÙ�� Ý �&�Âì�Ù Ý �ªñ_Õ£ê Ü�Ý ì�Ù<��ë�×�� Õ�ì�ÕqØÙ��tì êpÖ&êb§��ª��Ù��tíN�^­�é÷Õ�� Ü Ö&�±ÖªÙ�ì�ë¤Ù�Õt� §�� Ù Ü Ù<Ø�ì�Ù��\îë�×��_Õtì�ÕÀò¤�ª§nôµ�&� Ü ë��t�dîkÙ�� Ý �ª�mì�Ù Ý �&ñ ÕuÖ¹ê Ü ò¤� Ý ��} Ü � Ý ò²í¶§�×��³Ö&Ù<ì�ë¤Ù�Õ���§�� Ù Ü Ù<ؤ§�×��°§���ê Ü Õt� §��_Ù Ü Õ©í�Õ©§��ªìì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ì�Õ&�)«°×"�cÖªÙ�ì�ëzÙ�Õt� Ý ì�Ù���ë�×"�_Õ�ì ë��t�&Õ��ª�tó<�&Õpê Ü�Ý ���ªû��&Öª§�Õ�§�×��dë����¦înÙ�� Ý �&�±ò¤�&Ö&ê<��Õt�cÙbØq§�×��ë����ªÕ��&�©óbêb§�� Ù Ü ê Ü�Ý ���1û��&Ö1§�� Ù Ü ��� ó<� Ü ò�í¬§�×��ÂÖ&Ù�ì�ë¤Ù Ü � Ü §�Õ&�m«°×��Â� Ý � Ü §���§��_�ªÕ°ê<�t�¾��� ó<� Ü ò�í¬§�×��Â� Ý � Ü §��¸î§��_�ªÕ°� Ü t � þ6§�×�êb§³ë����ªÕ��ª�tó��¶ê Ü�Ý ���1û��&Ö1§]§�×��/ë����¦înÙ�� Ý �&�³Ù�ò�ó��_Ù<��Õ�ñ�í��

·�êbÖ¡× ë��t�dîkÙ�� Ý �ª��ì�Ù Ý �ªñ�g²­wË -9\�­õÒ�ú ù ô³� §�×G\ ­ Ë -(/�Ò�A Ò1+ ù � Ü"Ý ��Ö&�ªÕAê §��&ì�ëzÙ<��ê<ñrì�Ù Ý �&ñ}¬ã<g²­¤å¾Ëf-9\ ­ÈÒm_ ¸ ù éõô³×��&�t��_�¸�ã<c�å£Ë Ì q Ñ /£Ð úzã<c�å�¤�q<Ô�ØÙ<�Â�¹ê<Ö¡×%c Ñ ���>«°×�� ÕÂÕ�×�Ù¥ô³Õr§�×�êb§Â§�×��ë����¦înÙ�� Ý �&�µ� Ü ê<ò"ñ_�&Õµ§�Ù¯ë��t�&Õt� Ü §]ê6ô³×�Ù<ñ_�¾Õt�ª§^ò�ípêrÕ�� Ü ��ñ �£Õt§�êb§��b�Àï Ý ��} Ü �/ê6Ø� Ü Öª§�Ù<�^}C�?�^­®A � �ô³×��&�t�4}�ã9g²­zå÷� Õȧ�×��m§��&ì�ë¤Ù���ê<ñ<ì�Ù Ý �&ñ�� Ü�Ý ��Öª� Ý ò²í¹g²­¶� Ü �^­���«°×��µì�ê<ë�ë"� Ü �³�_ÕÈ� Ý � Ü §�� Ö¹ê<ñ�Ù Ü §�×��ì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ì�Õ&�£«°×"�±ì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ìä}¬ãH?èå£��}¬ã<g²­¤å,A }�ã9g B ­ å]ô³� §�×�g²­lËn-9\ ­ÈÒ�ú ù étg B ­ Ën-<\ B­ ÒGú B ùê Ü�Ý ?��º\ ­»A \ B­ �_Õ/êdì�Ù��të�×�� Õ�ì � Ü � � éÈÕ�� Ü Ö&�±ØÙ��/�¹ê<Ö¡× Õt§�êb§��>� Ü §�×��±§���ê Ü Õ���§��_Ù Ü Õtí�Õt§��&ì¬\�­õéq Ñ _�¸�ã<c�å6�M¼¾úzã9c<å|¤�qp�L¼�úzã9c<å|¤�?Èã(q+år�L¼½?ÈãHq�å Ñ _ ¸ ) ã<c�åÏ��ïÂ��Õ��p§�×��¬Ø� Ü Ö1§�Ù��$}üØÙ��rñ_��Ø §�� Ü �c§�×��Ü Ù<§�� Ù Ü Õ°Ù<Ø»Õ�ê�§��_Õ;}èê<ò�� ñ_��§ní�Ù¥ó<�&�]ë����¦înÙ�� Ý �&�³ì�Ù Ý �ªñ_Õª�Q ��R ÿký>þoýø ÿ ù�SM�[SM� ��x*X�þoý9x��0X>yCþ*ý{ø ÿÏý�ÿ U W � °�øTWYZ � W Æ ø�Z � Å x �: ��ó�� Ü ê ë"���dîkÙ�� Ý �&�pì�Ù Ý �&ñ�g²­ Ë -<\�­ÈÒGú ù é³ê ��� Ü 7¿Ù<ع\ ­Íö&�CòPð¾ö<¾^�bö�ê)§��&ì�ëzÙ<��ê<ñ³ØÙ���ì¶��ñhêV�£éô³��� §t§�� Ü 7vÐË���¿À�£éÈ� Øm§�×"�¯ØÙ���ì¯�"ñhêp�_Õ£Õ�êb§��_Õ�}�� Ý � Ü §�×"��� Ü�Ý ��Öª� Ý §��ªì�ë¤Ù���ê<ñuì�Ù Ý �ªñ'}�ã9g²­èå1éõ§�×�ê�§�_Õ&é47�ÐË ®tÁ ��¿� �£� � � ì�� ñhê<�tñ í¯ØÙ<�³§�×�� Ü Ù<§��_Ù Ü Ù<ØFg²­�î4§�����§�×÷é�Ð Ë���¿6�£é�Ù<�,¶'îmO��<�¢ð�óCð>ò-��éuÐ Ë�Ã��£� �

ù[SM��S�û � � �j� n U ý9yoX Å&ü W � °�øTWYZ � Wu��ø�Z � Å«°×��¯� Ý �¹ê¬Ù<ØÀ§�×��uò{�¡¢ ð4���<�¤¢¤���K¢���� ó��1�r�¬��ó��1��Ù��]Õ�×"Ù��t§xò{�¡¢ ð4���<�»�¬��ó��1��� Õ]§�Ùpò���� ñ Ý ØÙ<�£�ªó<�&�©ílë¤Ù�Õ�Õt�_ò�ñ �Ö&Ù Ü }�������ê�§��_Ù Ü Ù<Ø�§�����§�×�óbê<ñ ���&Õ�Ù<Ø�ë���Ù�ë¤Ù�Õt� §�� Ù Ü ê<ñ�ó<êb���hêbò�ñ_�ªÕµê6Õt§�êb§��³ô³×��_֡׬�_ì�ë�ñ_�ªì�� Ü §�Õu§�×�� ÕµÖªÙ Ü }��_î����êb§��_Ù Ü é��-�Ã�b� é"ô³×"�&���ÂÙ Ü ñ í�Õ���Ö¡×dÖªÙ Ü Õt§���ê<� Ü §�Õ³ê<�t�¾Õ�êb§��_Õ;}�� Ý §�×�êb§°� Ü §��&��ë"���ª§°ê¶ó<êb���hêbò�ñ_�]ô³×��_Ö¡×´� Õ¼§��t���� Ü §�×��¯����ó�� Ü ÖªÙ Ü }��<����êb§��_Ù Ü � � ��Ö¡×:Õt§�êb§��ªÕ/ê<���¶Ö&Ù Ü Õ©§��t��Öª§�� Ý ê<Õ¾ñ �¹ê<Õ©§¾��ë�ë¤�&�Âò¤Ù�� Ü"Ý Õ¾Ù<ØÀ§�×��¯Õ��1§/Ù<ØÕt§¡ê�§��&Õ°ô³��§�×c���&Õtëz�ªÖª§³§�Ù>§�×"�6ë"���dîkÙ�� Ý �&��¤6�

­ �b�

Page 132: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

�¶ø ÿ�x²þÄW { yCþoý{ø ÿ ù[SM��S Ä �\þ¦n U ýHyoX Å þ � ÆVU øTWzX Å^Æ ø[Z � Å �Å�TÄÆbÇ ÈÊÉËÈuÌÎÍ1Æ0ϺÆKÍzÌ(Ç4ÌHÉYTzÈÁú8���¬A ¤]Ð�Ñ<ÍzÌ�a&¸<ã9�¶åÓÒÔÍ8Ì9ÕºÍ�ÖKÍÄÌ^T [�Ç ÑËÑ�ÖØ×ÔÒ ÖKÍÄÌHÖ6� B T�[���ÙPÕÔÉ9Ú;Õ�Ç Æ�ÍÚ1Ñ5TÄÖKÍ*ÛÜ×ÝȺÛ4Í1Æ2Í1ÈuÌ0Ç ÉMÑËÞeÍ1ÈuÌIкÌ9ÕTÇ4Ì ÉËÖ�ÐuÙPÕºÍ1Æ�Í«[XTzÆ�Ç ÑMÑÔc Ñ ��Ð�úzã<c�åÔ¤®¨«©uªbã¬úzãH� B å�åsÉËÞ±ÏtÑMÉ9Í1ÖCc Ñ � Bàß�á ÕºÍmȺÐÌHÕºÍeâní�ëÔã Ö¹ê<ñ�âmä�ê Ü ÕjãLâmã_Ù Ü Õtí�Õ;âmå&ì \�­�ã¬ú"å8æ -(/t¸¹Ò�A縥Ò1+E¸ ù ÕTÇ Ö Ç ÖÜÖ*Ì0Ç4ÌÎÍ1Ö Ç ÑMÑ�Ñ<ÍKÇ Ö*ÌÜ×ØÏÔÏsÍ1Æ%ÒUT´×ÝÈuÛ³Ö¨<©uª�ã¸úzã9� B å�å [XTzÆ2� B Ñ a2¸�ãH�rå1Ð ÌHÕºÍhÌHÆmÇ ÈÔÖ�É0ÌHÉYTzÈÜÆ�Í1Ñ«ÇèÌHÉ5TÄÈ®Aç¸�æ'/t¸�¥�/t¸�ÉËÖ�ÌHÕºÍ][I×ÝÑMÑ�Ú�Ç ÆØÌÎÍ1ÖjÉàǠȣÏtÆ�T´Ûu×´ÚÄÌǠȺÛÜ+E¸�ÉMÖ¹ÌHÕºÍ�Ö�ÍzÌ T [sÇYÑËÑÔÏ�Ç4ÌHÕÔÖ�Ì9ÕÔÆ�T´×Yé�Õ�Aç¸ ß �5 Ü åKê"ê<ì�ë�ñËå�Ù<Ø�â�×4åAÖªÙ Ü Õ;âmäjë"Ö�âmã Ù Ü Ù<رâ�×ÔåÀâní�ëÔã_Ö&ê<ñÂì�Ù Ý åªñ�ã_ÕdÕ�×"Ù+ô Ü ã Ü�ì ×�êbë4âmå�ä�íîã ÜN� ë"ò�ÕjåªÖdîâmã_Ù Ü í4ï�íèïMðoï�ñ°×Ôå/ÖªÙ Ü Õ�âjäjë�ÖKâmã Ù Ü ã Õ°ò�ê<Õ�å Ý Ù Ü ê±ëÔä�ådîkÙoä Ý å�ä³Ù+óÝå*ä Ý ã_Õ;âmä�ã_òÔë4âjå Ý®ò ä�ê<ë�×dì�ÙÝä�ë�×Ôã Õ�ì�Õ&â�×�êYâïµô,ã_ñ ñtã Ü âjä�Ù Ý ë�Ö�å�ã Ü â�×Ôå Ü å�ê´â£Õ�å&Ö�âjã_Ù Ü ïü W+ø U øux�ý=þ*ý{ø ÿ ù[SM��Swv � R ÿký>þ � þdn U ý9yoX>ó�ô)ø[Z � ó �á պͮÌLõoÏtÉ<ÚKÇ Ñ�ÌHÆmÇ ÈÔÖjÉ(ÌHÉYTzÈ�ÖÎõ4ÖØÌIÍmÞ [XTÄÆ�Ç È�ÉËÈuÌIÍmÆ0ÏtÆ�ÍzÌ(Ç4ÌHÉYTzÈÍúÊö��fA ¤ ÉMÖ±÷ÔÈ4É0ÌIÍhÉ.[�ÌHÕºÍ�ÖKÍzÌ¡úzãH�rå¹ÉMÖ÷ÔÈÔÉ0ÌÎÍ ß �

ø|ùmúÄú"ôï0ûªú�ã9�¶åPãËü�}>ýÔãLâmå<é³âmþ4åEüjåKâ�/Væ]ÿz§�� §Gd úzã9�¶å����ÝûÈê����uü�ëÔü�å�âmü�� û�ú �H����ãËü�}>ýÔãLâmåqêÝü���å����(ïsñ2þ4å*äjåKû��oäjå��ê��Ëü��,âjþÔå�üjå�â��Ýû�Må¹êÝü;â�ë��uå*ä� �oë4ý�Ôü��ÝûT/�� ¨<©uª��(/���æ]ÿY¨«©uª��9§���� §! �/"�#�YãËü[}>ýÔãLâmå ï � ãMý$*å|/t¸�dN¨«©uª��(/��%�/t¸�ãMü&}>ýÔãMâjåÝï $¦�ëÔå�â&�hâmþÔå'$��oý4ü�âmä�ë$�âjã(�oý)�Ýû[âmþÔå�ü�â�ê âmå�ü��Ýû[âmþ4åEâ+*,�Ôã($&ê��uâjä�êÝý4üjãMâjã(�oý£ü�*´ü;âmå�-aêÝü"�Må¹êÝü;â&ë�.�ºå�ä� �ÝëÔý�Ôü/�âmþÔå%*6ü�ê âmãMü�û0*bå�ê"ê�$�â&��*�âmþ�Ýüjå1$��oýÔü;âmä�êÝãËý�âmü�û<ä&��-2�,þÔã($1þ£âmþÔå%*¬ê äjå3$��oý4ü�âmä�ë$�âjå��4�4ã(ï åÝï>ú �<c5�>¤ ¨<©uª��¸ú �9� B ���ãMû»êÝý�6�oý�7*ÜãMû�c8 À� B û��oä³ê�����c9 À� êÝý.��� B ãËýea2¸��H���Kïñ2þÔå�û��5���(�:�,ãËý ò âmþÔå/�oäjå/-;$1þ�êÝä�ê�$Kâmå�äjã¾ú�å*üCâjþÔå�â+*<�4ã($¹ê�� ò ä�ê��Ôþ�âmä�ê ýÔüjãLâmã(�Ýý�ü=*´ü�âmå/-�û��Ýä<ú/êÝü»ê�}Ôý�ê��,�5 � å�$KâãËý6>^­ ï? � �,@ W � ô A SM��S ACB�D { ó9ó�EÊXÔ�Fx²þÄWzX>yCþ5þÄWzX-ÿ�x�ý>þoý @ ÿDx/E x²þ � ôGFá ÕºÍ�ÌLõoÏtÉ<ÚKÇ Ñ�Ì9Æ1Ç ÈÔÖ�É0Ì9É5TzÈ ÖIõ4ÖØÌÎÍ1Þ@\ ­H�JI<�«[XTzÆ�Ç È�ÉMȺÌÎÍ1Æ(ÏtÆKÍÄÌ0Ç4Ì9É5TzÈKIeÉËÖ,÷ÔÈ>Ç Ñ ÉËÈL>k­tÐsÌ9ÕTÇ4Ì�ÉËÖ�Ðu[XTzƹÍ�dzÚ;ÕÏtÆKÍ�MsTzÆ�ÛÔÍ1Æ�ÌHÆmÇ ÈÔÖ�É0ÌHÉYTzÈeÖIõ4Ö*ÌIÍ1Þn\ ­»ÌHÕºÍmÆK͹Í&NèÉËÖ*ÌHÖ�Ç®×ÝÈÔÉJO4×´Í�Þ�TzÆ0ϺÕÔÉËÖ�ÞQPSRY¿eöÝ\�­eA \ ­H��I.� ß �

ø|ùmúÄú"ôTU�Ýäbå¹ê�$1þV�Ôäjå¦î+�oä��Ôå*äbâmä�êÝýÔü�ãMâmã��oýÊü�*´ü�âjå�-l\ ­Næ -(/�W�AXW1+�Y�ãËýZ>^­[��å6�Ôå�}>ý4ålê\-��Ýä&�ÔþÔãMü&- PSR ¿ ö\�­8A \ ­��JI<�°êÝü�û��5�(�����,ü�ö"][åKâ�û��oäqê6ü;â¡ê âjå�q9 V/DâmþÔå±üjåKâ����(q��&æ^ÿzc^ V�_� I �9c��C¤Dq��³ï2ñ2þÔå*ý4�º���(q��ãËü`$��(�Ýüjå��VëÔý�Ôå�ähå*ý�â�êÝã(��-6å�ý³â��CãHï�å ï��C�)�Hq��8 �a2¸��H���%��êÝý�a��åb�ÔåK}>ýÔåcPSR ¿ �Hq��±æ@¨«©uª���I �H���(q��&���Kï ñ2þÔå-¬ê��.�ÔãËý ò PdR ¿ ãMü^ê9-^�oä&�4þÔãËü�- û<ä��5-�-<\�­eW&I.Y�â&� -9\ ­H�JI<�%W&I.Y�üjãËý.$*å��.#*b$��oýÔü;âmä�ë$�âjã(�oý4�<I �9c���¤Vq¹ãLû�êÝý��oý��*ÓãMû�I �9c��C¤Ê¨«©ºª���If�9�)�Hq��&�&��ïPñ2þ³ëÔü��ePSR ¿ ãËü³êg-��oä��ÔþÔãMü&-h�Ýûi�Ôä�ådîj�oä&�Ôå�ä&âmä�êÝýÔüjãLâmã��oýeü�*´ü�âjå�-£ü*ïk0âmü�ëÔýÔãM¡³ëÔå*ýÔå�üjü¹û��5�(���:�,üEû<ä&�5-�âmþ4å�û{ê�$�â�âjþ�ê â�û��oäÂêeü�å�â`�Ýûl�Ôä&��� �oü�ãMâjã(�oý�ê���mbêÝä�ãhê��Må*ü�� B � ¨«©uª��JI �H� B ���ãËü2âmþÔå��oý.��*eü;â¡ê âjå�ãMý \ ­H��I.�|âjþ�ê â�ü�ê âjãËü;}>å*ü,åKê"ê�$Kân�7*eâmþÔå`$��oý4ü�âmä�êÝãËý�âjü1� ûCâmþ4ãËü,üjåKâØï � ãËý$�å`-^�oä��ÔþÔãËü�-6ü�Ýû��4äjådîj�oä&�4å*ä2âmä�êÝýÔüjãLâmã��oýeü�*´ü�âjå�-£ü�þ�ê:mÝå�â&���4äjå*ü�å*ä=moå¯ê ý�8ä�å/o>å/$�â�âmþÔå¹ü�ê âmãMü�û{ê�$Kâmã(�Ýý_�Ýû��4ä&�5�p�oüjãLâmã��oý�ê��m<ê äjãhê��Ëå�ü��èâjþÔå�-¬ê���ÔãËý ò q�qA ¨«©uª��JI �H���(q����&�&ãËü&û��oä�$*å/�Lr*ÜâjþÔãËü�$/�oý�ÔãLâmã(�Ýý�ï $ñ2þÔåEëÔý4ãË¡³ëÔås-^�oä��ÔþÔãËü�-tPSR ¿ $/�5�(�_ê��Ôü�å*üµê��p�Ýâmå�ý³âjãhê�����*hãËý4}>ý4ãMâmå3�Ôä�ådîj�oä&�Ôå�ä�âjä�êÝý4üjãMâjã(�oý£ü�*´ü;âmå�-µ\ ­Üân�¶ê}>ýÔãMâjå��ÝýÔåÝï�TCãËý�ê��ËãMâ+*�ãËü»ê3$¹ê âjå ò �oä�ã($&ê��5�^êu*��ÝûÔü�êu*èãMý ò âjþ�ê â�\�­��JI<� ãMüe �Ýâjþ±â+*,�Ôã�$¹ê���êÝý��û<ë�(�7*/ê�Ôü;âmä�ê�$�â*öñ2þÔåÓå�ê4ãMü�âjå*ý$�å_�Ýû&âmþ4å)-^�oä&�Ôþ4ãËü&-£ügPdRz¿Dö \�­ÊA \�­H��I<��û��oärê����l�4äjådîj�oä&�4å*ä¹âmä�ê ýÔüjãLâmã(�Ýý�ü=*èü;âmå/-6üh\ ­åKê<�Ôäjå�üjü�å*ühâjþÔåbû{ê�$�â¹âmþ�ê â¹\�­H��I<��ãMü�â+*<�4ã($¹ê��(ï�ñ2þÔãËü¹ãMüv-¬ê��4å^�4äjå�$�ãËü�å6ãMý�âjþÔå^$��oä��5�(�_êÝä�*Lºå/�(�:�¹ï£ñ2þÔåëÔýÔãË¡³ëÔå�ýÔå*ü�ü��ÝûºâmþÔå�üjås-^�oä��ÔþÔãËü�-6üPã�-��.�ËãËå�üsâmþ�êYâ�\ ­��JI<�sãËüPû<ë����*>ê�Ôü�âjä�ê�$KâØöik0ûºâmþÔå�äjå¾ê äjå,â+�"���ÔãM¼ºå*ä�å*ý�âü�â¡êYâmå*ü�ãËý�4ãËü�âjãËý ò ëÔãËü�þ�ê��Måv#*®âjþÔåhãMý³âjå*ä��ÔäjåKâ¡ê âjã(�oý4�>âjþÔå*ä�åw$¹ê ýxºå�â+�"�)�ÔãM¼ºå*ä�å*ý�âs$&êÝý�Ôã���ê âjå*ü�û��Ýä�âjþÔå�Ôå�}>ý4ãMâmã��oý_�Ýû"PdRz¿ºï

ðÄ�5y

Page 133: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

z @ W @ óHó<XÔW:EVA SM�[S�{ B;\�­��JI<�%ýHx$þ|E U ýHyoXÔó�D @ W)IFá պͣÏtÆ�Í|MsTÄÆKÛÔÍmÆ�Ì9Æ1Ç ÈÔÖ�É0Ì9É5TzÈ�ÖIõ4ÖØÌÎÍ1Þ \�­H��I<�£ÉËÖ8ÌLõoÏtÉ9Ú�Ç ÑEÇ ÞITÄÈ4é½Ì9ÕºÍ�ϺÆKÍ|M9TzÆKÛ4Í1Æ�Ì9Æ1Ç È4ÖjÉ0Ì9É5TzÈ�ÖIõ4Ö*ÌIÍ1Þ£ÖÙPÉ0ÌHÕ8ÉËÈuÌIÍmÆ0ÏtÆ�ÍzÌ(Ç4ÌHÉYTzÈLIeÉMÈVÌ9ÕºÍ�Ö�Í1ÈÔÖ�Í�Ì9ÕTÇ4Ì­[XTzÆ�ÇYÑËÑ�ÌIÍmÞhÏRTzÆmÇ Ñ [XTzÆjÞÜ×ÝÑ«Ç Ö���Ð�� æw} Rz¿ Á ¸;Â0~ ¸=� ��É.[sǠȺÛ�TÄÈÔÑwõÉ.[�� æ } Rz¿.~ ¸=�[� [XTzÆ�Ç ÑËÑ4ÏtÆKÍ�MsTzÆ�ÛÔÍ1Æ�Ì9Æ1Ç ÈÔÖ�É0Ì9É5TzÈeÖÎõÔÖ*ÌIÍmÞ6Ö,\�­ ß �

ø|ùmúÄú"ôB B.� æ B B ö � ãMý$*å�\ ­��JI<�|ãMü2ãËý6>^­e�ÔâmþÔå�$/�hêÝã�- þ���(�Ôü�ïB B æ4� B B ö���å�üjþ.����âmþ�ê âÂê)�4äjådîj�oä&�4å*ä�âjä�êÝý4üjãMâjã(�oý8ü�*´ü�âjå�-f\�­Àæ -0/�W1AXW1+�Y�ãËýc>^­��,ãMâmþ½�� æ�} Rz¿.~ ¸=� �ã(-^��ËãMå*ü��� æ } Rz¿ Á ¸;Â0~ ¸=�[�Eïik0û��� æ } RY¿<~ ¸=�[�VâmþÔå�äjå&ãMüuê�äjë4ýb7� À+½ü�ë$1þ�âmþ�ê âC7ç�� æ�¸|�Eï � ãËý.$*å&ñ2þÔå/�oäjå/-�yèï��èï�y�Ôä&�:m´ã(�Ôå�ü6êK�4äjådîj�oä&�4å*ä�âmä�êÝýÔü�ãMâmã��oý\-^�oä&�Ôþ4ãËü&-�PSRY¿»öu\ ­VA \�­��JI<�%�ÈêÝý.�%ü�ë$1þa-^�oä��ÔþÔãËü�-6üs�Ôäjå�üjå*ä=moåêÝý� äjå/oÔå�$�â�ü�ê âmãMü�û{ê�$Kâmã(�Ýý_�ÝûCâjå�-^� �oä�ê��ºû��Ýä&-�ë�_êÝü�� PdRz¿��97e���� æ�¸2�pã(-^���*´ãMý ò �� æ�} Rz¿ Á ¸;Â�~ ¸�� �Eï $

A S�� � WzX U ���&��ÿ þ � W U W � þ � Z ü W @ U @ x�ý=þ*ý @ ÿ X>ó ?|� ô U @ WzX>ó�� @ � ýHykÎýVâmþÔå)�Ôäjå%mèã��oëÔü±üjå�$Kâmã��oý4�ik��ÔåK}>ýÔå��»âjä�êÝý4üjãMâjã(�oý%ü�*´ü;âmå�-£übå*ý4äjã($1þ4å���r* êL�Ôäjå¦î+�oä��Ôå*ä�ïckÎýVâjþÔãËü±üjå�$¦îâmã(�Ýý4�fk3�ÔåK}>ýÔå>êb$��Ýý$*ä�å�âmå8�4äjådîj�oä&�4å*ä��:moå�äv�ÔãËü;âmä�ã(Ôë4âjå�� ò ä�ê��ÔþÔüEãËý�âjþÔå8$¹ê âjå ò �Ýä�*�Q � W���������� \'����Ýû��ÔãËü;âmä�ã(Ôë4âjå�� ò ä�ê��ÔþÔü'�,ãMâmþlê âjâjäjã(4ë4âmå/� ò ä�ê��4þÔüÂêÝü����<$&ê�� ü�â�ê âmå�ü*ï¹ñ2þÔãËüs$¹ê âjå ò �oä=*c�¼êÝü�ãMý³âjä&�,�Ôë$�å��ãËý � å/$�âjã(�oýx�4ï��Ôï'kÎý�âmþÔå±û��5�(�����,ãMý ò ��k2}4êlê)$¹êYâmå ò �oä�*�Q � W:�����u���®\s���,û��Ýä¾êÓýÔåKâ+�"�Ýä�ù8â+*,�uå ò ä�ê��Ôþ� \'�^� �,þÔå*ä�å8�(�,$¹ê�� ü�â�ê âmå�ü/êÝäjåhäjå��4äjå*ü�å*ý�âmå/��r*lê âjâjäjã(4ë4âmå/� ò ä�ê��ÔþÔü*ï¹5'�(���ÔãËü;âmäjã�Ôë4âjå�� ò ä�ê��ÔþÔü¾êÝý��ÔãËü;âmäjã�Ôë4âjå���-��Ýä&�ÔþÔãMü&-£üb�,$�$*ë4äjäjãMý ò ãËý�âmþ4å%ü�å*¡³ëÔå/�¶êÝä�åÀüjë�.� �oü�å���ân�ZºåÀâ¡êSùÝå*ýpû<ä&��- âmþÔå�$&ê âmå¦îò �oä�*�Q � W����H�u�J� \'�w�|�Àê�4äjå/m´ã_ê âmå/��#*VQ � W�ïLkÎý»âmþÔå6üjå*¡³ëÔå/����kv$&ê��(�µêc�ÔãMü�âmä�ã(Ôëèâmå���-��Ýä&�ÔþÔãMü&-�� æµ- � Wn����Y�ö ��.A � �ãMý�Q � W:�4���:�J� \'�w�HòÎú_òj¡�¢ÔãLû � ãËü2ân� â¡ê���êÝü3�|å/�(��êÝü'���#��£.�|û��oä,å&ê�$1þx£_ ���¤ãËü&ân� â¡ê��Hïk��Ôä&�:m´ã(�Ôå£ê��ÔãMü�âjäjã(4ë4âmå/� ò ä�ê��Ôþ �¥ û��oä�âjþÔå ò ä�ê��Ôþ6îÎãËý�âjå*ä&�4äjå�âjå��Óâjå�-^� �Ýä�ê��U�(� ò ã($&âjþ�ê â&ä�å��Ôä�å*ü�å*ý�âmü&âjþÔåò ä�ê��4þÔã($&ê��,mbêÝä�ãhê�.�Ëå*üH�ÝûTâmþÔå���� ò ã�$Ýïkï�*w-£å¹ê ýÔü��Ýûzê��ÔãËü;âmä�ã(Ôë4âjå�� ò ä�ê��Ôþ8-^�oä&�4þÔãËü�-.ü;â¡êÝä;âmãËý ò ê â �¥@âjþÔåm<ê äjãhê��Ëå�ü¾êÝä�å±êÝüjü�ã ò ý4å���r*�ê�$Kâmë�ê���mbê��ËëÔå�ü*ï�ñ2þÔå8�ÔãMü�âmä�ã(Ôëèâmå��\-^�oä��ÔþÔãËü�- ãMüs$&ê��(�Må��:êÝýZ¡_öbödðL�Cñ�¦)§dñ-òôØúYù �¥îïQ ��R ÿký>þoý @ ÿCA S��[S�û B;X>xØx�ý<� ÿFô � ÿYþ�F] åKâ �¥Qºåqê��4ãËü�âjäjã�Ôë4âmå/� ò ä�ê��Ôþ4��êÝýx¡_öbödðL�Cñ�¦)§dñ-òÔû��oä �¥�ãËü�å¹ê�$1þb�ÔãËü;âmä�ã(Ôë4âjå���-��oä��ÔþÔãMü&-Q�¨ ö �¥�A �§ò ã�mÝå*ýÊãËý»âjþÔå_$¹ê âjå ò �Ýä�*îQ � W6�,ãLâmþîü&�ÝëÔä&$�å �¥»ïak��Ôå*ý.�Ýâmåeâmþ4åeüjå�âg� û£ê��(�^ê üjüjã ò ý-£å*ý�âmü�û��Ýä �¥ #*©�g«ª�¬.� �¥x�Kï �ñ2þÔå�­Cê"ê�-^��ËåEí4ïMð'�Ýû��oë4ä"$¹ê üjåEü;âmë�<*ÓãMý ì þ�ê��èâmå*ä|íhüjþ.���,ü|åKê"ê�-^��Ëå�ü��Ýû�ê üjüjã ò ý-£å*ý�âmü�ïiks}4ê6ý�:�vê�ÔãËü;âmäjã�Ôë4âjå�� ò ä�ê��Ôþ �¥üê ý�>êÝüjü�ë-£å&âmþ�ê âuê��(��êÝü�üjã ò ý-6å�ý�âmüi�,$�$�ëÔäjä�ãËý ò ãMýhâmþ4å2üjå*¡³ëÔå/��êÝä�å°êÝüjü�ã ò ý.-6å�ý³âjüû��oä �¥îï5EývêÝüjü�ã ò ý-£å*ý�âZ�¨ æ - ¨ W��H®/YÊö �¥ A �§`ãËýpâmþÔå�$&ê âmå ò �oä�*�Q � W»ãËüeý� âL�Ýý��*¯��êÝä�âjãhê����Ýý�âjþÔåýÔå�â+���oä�ù°�Ëå%moå/����4ë4â±ê��Mü&� âmþÔå�$��5-^� �ÝýÔå*ý�âmüw�H®��J£<��û��oähå&ê�$1þ±£� �¥�¤ êÝäjå���êÝä�âjãhê���� üjãËý.$*å6âjþÔå/* êÝä�åê âjâjäjã(4ë4âmå/� ò ä�ê��Ôþ�-��Ýä&�ÔþÔãMü&-£ü*ï8ñ2þÔå*ä�å�û��oä�å���k��Ôå�}>ý4åÜâmþÔå�ó´ú�¦^¡Cð>ñ\� û]êÝýyêÝü�üjã ò ý-6å�ý�âx�¨ ãMýîQ � W#*îâjþÔåK�ÔãËü;âmä�ã(Ôë4âjå�� ò ä�ê��Ôþ4���,þÔå*ä�å8âmþ4å ý4å�â+���oä�ù ò ä�ê��Ôþ�ãËü�âmþ4åL���-¬êÝãMý��ÝûEâjþÔåK��êÝä;âmãhê��&ýÔå�â+���oä ù-��oä��ÔþÔãMü&- ¨ êÝý�Àâmþ4å£ä�å�}>ý4å�� ò ä�ê��4þ%û��oäEå¹ê�$1þ�£° G¥�¤DãMü�âmþÔåg��5-�êÝãMýx�Ýû�âmþÔå�ê â�âmäjã�Ôë4âjå�� ò ä�ê��Ôþ-��oä��ÔþÔãMü&-t��®5��£<�Kï�ñ2þÔå��.�5-¬ê ãËýK�Ýû�êÝüjü�ã ò ý-£å*ý�âjü1�,ã��(�tâjþÔå*ýLºå¹ëÔü�å���â&���ÔåK}>ýÔå¹âmþÔå`�Ôä�ådî+�Ýä&�Ôå�ä1�:mÝå*äêÝüjü�ã ò ý-£å*ý�âjü*ï

ðÄ��²

Page 134: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

Q ��R ÿký>þoý @ ÿCA S��[SM� B�Z @ ôVX-ý�ÿ @ D�X-ÿ½X>xØx�ý9� ÿ�ô � ÿYþ�F] åKâ��¨ æ - ¨ W���®%YVö �¥ A �§³uå:êÝýiêÝüjü�ã ò ý.-6å�ý³âÓû��oä �¥��2âmþ4å¨ó´ú�¦^¡Cð>ñ��Ýû6�¨ ãMüÓâmþÔå\�4ãËü�âjäjã�Ôë4âmå/�ò ä�ê��4þ �¥ ® �:moå*ä'´#ª�µ°� ¨ �%���,þÔå*ä�å8¶ ® �J£<��æ·´#ª�µ°���H®���£.���|û��oä,å¹ê�$1þx£_ °´#ª�µ°� ¨ ��¤ ê ý�8û��oä,å&ê�$1þ�å�� ò å¸ öf£�A ¹t [´,ª�µ°� ¨ �»ºi�eks�ÔåK}>ýÔå�û��oä�å¹ê�$1þ°¼Z ¯¶ ® ��£<�%�H¶ ® � ¸ ���0¼ ��潶�� ¸ �/��¼ ��ãMû�¼V C´#ª�µ°��¶�� ¸ ���êÝý�c¶°� ¸ ���0¼ �" �¶��J¹v�|�ÔëÔý�4å�}>ýÔå/�c�ÝâjþÔå*ä=�,ãËü�åÝï �¾s¿[X>ô U ó � A S�û BjZ @ ôVX-ý�ÿ @ D�X�ÿ½X>xØx�ý<� ÿFô � ÿYþ�FTCã ò ë4äjå8y´ïMð9�4å��Ôã�$�âmü�â+���dêÝü�üjã ò ý-6å�ý�âmüb�¨ ö �¥lA �§ êÝý.� �ªhö �¥lA �ÀÓï�ñ2þÔåbýÔåKâ+�"�oä ù ò ä�ê��Ôþ\�ÝûPâjþÔå�ÔãËü;âmäjã�Ôë4âjå�� ò ä�ê��4þ �¥Á$��oý4üjãËü;âmü1�Ýû�â+�"�6ý�<�4å*ü1$��oýÔý4å�$�âjå��xr*cêÝý8å�� ò åÝï|ñ2þ4å�} ò ëÔäjå`��´å*ü,ý�Ýâ�üjþ.���âmþÔå£ýÔå�â+���oä ù%ý.�<�Ôå�ü±å�ê<��Ëã�$*ãMâ&��*���4ë4âw�Ýý��*ÀãLâmü¹äjåK}>ýÔå/-6å�ý³â�r* ê âjâjäjã(4ë4âmå/� ò ä�ê��ÔþÔü�ïÜ5Eý)ê âjâjäjã�Ôë4âmå/�

X A

X ÂÂÃÃÄÄÅÅÆÆÇÇ 2

3

domain of a domain of b

XX

ÈÈÉÉÊÊËË1 1

ÌÌÍÍÎÎÏÏ Ð ÐÐ ÐÑ ÑÑ Ñ Ò ÒÒ ÒÓÓ Ô ÔÔ ÔÕ ÕÕ ÕÖÖ××

Ø ØØ ØÙ ÙÙ Ù

ÚÚÛÛ ÜÜÝÝ

a11

2 21

b2

B

3

2 2

a b

3

TCã ò ë4äjå`yèïLðoö"Þ�ú�¦^¡Cð>ñ�ö±ú"ô`¡_öbödðL�Cñ�¦)§dñ-ò=ö�ßò ä�ê��4þL$/�oýÔüjãMü�âjüs�ÝûFâ+�"�b��êÝä�âjü��>âmþÔå`��ê â�ê¬êÝý.�8âmþ4å ò ä�ê��Ôþ6��êÝä;âu�Tüjë$1þ8âmþ�ê â'k��Ôä�å*ü�å*ý�âÂêÝý|ê âjâjäjã�Ôë4âmå/�ò ä�ê��4þ)r*6â+���9p�Øê4å�ü*ï�ñ2þÔå'�hê�$bùg�5 � å�$�âjü°êÝä�å ò ä�ê��ÔþÔã�$¹ê��U�5 � å/$�âjü��èâjþ�oü�ås�oýÔå1�,ãMâjþÓâmþÔå'��ê â�âmå*ä�ýpêÝä�å�5 � å�$Kâmü��Ýû|âjþÔå���ê â¡ê6��êÝä�â*ïÜñ2þÔå^-¬ê���ÔãËý ò ü�û��oä�âmþÔå¬êÝüjü�ã ò ý-£å*ý�âjü6�¨ êÝý.� �ª>êÝä�å£ãMý�Ôã�$¹ê âjå��°#*�âjþÔåý´ë.-9ºå�äjü¹ýÔå�êèâ¹â&�ÜâmþÔåg�5 � å/$�âjü*ï � � å�$Kâmü�� ò ä�ê��Ôþ4ã($¹ê��uêÝý����êYâ¡ê_�5 � å/$�âmün�ÂêÝäjå8-�ê���uå��Àân�_�� � å�$Kâmü�,ãMâmþbâjþÔå,ü�ê�-£å,ý´ë.-9ºå�ä*ïik0ûºâmþÔå�äjå3��´å*ü�ý�Ýâ�å�êèãËü�âµê¹ý³ë-9uå*ä�ê â�ê�ý�,�Ôå���âmþ4å1-�ê���4ãËý ò ãMü�ë4ý�Ôå�}ÔýÔå��û��oäFâjþÔãËüH�5 � å�$KâØïP¶��Må¹êÝü�å&ý�Ýâjã($*å��Ýâmþ�ê âCâjþÔå�-�ê���ÔãMý ò û��oäFâmþÔå���ê â¡ês��êÝä�âCþ�êÝüCâ&�vºå�ân�Ýâ�ê������,þÔå*ä�å¹êÝüsâjþÔå-¬ê��.�ÔãËý ò û��Ýä&âmþÔå ò ä�ê��ÔþÔã�$¹ê��4��êÝä�â3-�êu*buå`��êÝä�âjãhê��Hïsñ2þÔå���5-�êÝãËý �¥ ® � û'�¨ $/�oý�â¡êÝãMýÔü�p�Ýâmþ ýÔå�â+���oä ùý�<�4å*ü��[âjþÔå9�,þ�5�Må8��ê â¡ê_��ê ä�âu�[ü�ãËý$�å�âmþÔå8��ê â¡ê_-^�oä&�Ôþ4ãËü&-fþ�êÝü�â&�_ºåbân� â¡ê���êÝý��ý�K�5 � å/$�â�ãËý�âjþÔåò ä�ê��4þL��ê ä�âu�>ü�ãËý$�åK�¨ ãËü,ëÔý�4å�}>ýÔå/�x�oýcê���� ò ä�ê��ÔþÔã($&ê����5 � å/$�âjü*ï|ñ2þ4å����-¬êÝãMý �¥^à��Ýû �ªs$��Ýý³â�êÝãËý4ü1�Ýý��*�oýÔå¹ýÔå�â+���oä ùeý�<�4å��,ãLâmþeâmþ4å`$/�5-^��ËåKâmåv��ê â�ê8��êÝä�â]ê ý�L�ÝýÔå ò ä�ê��4þÔã($&ê��4�5 � å/$�â*ïñ2þÔå`­sê"ê�-^��Må¹í4ï �büjþ.���,üqê���4ãMâmã��oý�ê��uåKê"ê�-^��Må*ü3�Ýû�âmþÔå���5-�êÝãMý_�Ýûuê üjüjã ò ý-£å*ý�âmü�ï �ñ2þÔå��.�5-¬ê ãËý �¥ ® �Ýû°êÝý êÝü�üjã ò ý-6å�ý�âL�¨ ãMü6êL�ÔãMü�âmä�ã(Ôëèâmå�� ò ä�ê��Ôþ4� üjãMý$*å�âmþ4å¬ê â�âmä�ã(Ôë4âjå��°-��Ýä&�ÔþÔãMü&-�H®��J£<��á � ãËüsâ&�Ýâ¡ê��èû��oäPå¹ê�$1þ�£) \´#ª�µ°� ¨ ��¤L�ÔëÔå2ân��âmþ4å1�4å�}>ýÔãLâmã��oýg�Ýû÷ê ý¬ê â�âmä�ã(Ôë4âjå�� ò ä�ê��Ôþg-��Ýä&�ÔþÔãMü&-ãËýg�Ôïâ�Ôï�íèïsñ2þÔå*ä�å�û��oä�å��³û��oäPå¹ê�$1þ ¸ x´,ª�µ°� ¨ �»º8âmþ4åqêYâjâmä�ã(Ôëèâmå�� ò ä�ê��Ôþ^-��oä��ÔþÔãMü&-�¶ ® � ¸ �=á � ãËüPâ&�Ýâ¡ê���êÝü�|å/�(�(ïHk0â&ãMü�å&êÝü�*�â&�hüjå�å�âjþ�ê â�âmþÔå'��5-�êÝãËý �¥ ® ãËü�ê±ü�ë ò ä�ê��Ôþb�Ýû �¥ êÝý.�6âmþ4å*äjå�ãËüµê¹â&�Ýâ¡ê��p�4ãËü�âjäjã�Ôë4âmå/�-��oä��ÔþÔãMü&-ã�¨5ä ö �¥ ® A �§hï�kÎý8âmþÔãMü3�¼êu*5�p�|å ò å�â£êÝý�å�¡³ëÔã�mbê��Må*ý�âEä�å��Ôä�å*ü�å*ý�â¡ê âjã(�oýc�ÝûÀêÝü�üjã ò ý-£å*ý�âmü'#*-6å&êÝýÔü3�Ýû�ê�ü���êÝý�ï

ðÄ�5å

Page 135: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

Q ��R ÿký>þoý @ ÿCA S��[S�� B�x U X�ÿ½W � U W � x � ÿ þÄX�þoý @ ÿ @ D�X>x*x�ý9� ÿ�ô � ÿYþzx�F5Eýa¡_öbödðL�Cñ�¦)§dñ-ò�ôØúYù �¥ ð>ñgö+æ.¡Cñ�ùn§+æuùn§bö:§dñ-òj¡Cò�ð(ú_ñ6ãMü2å¹ê�$1þL��êÝãMä

�¨ æ2� �¥Qç)è �¥ ®aé®=êA �§��%W�,þÔå*ä�å �¥ ® d �¥`ãMü�âjþÔåv��5-�êÝãËý)�Ýû��¨ êÝý.���¨rä ãMü|âmþÔåEäjå*ü;âmä�ã($�âjã(�oý)�Ýû1�¨ ân� �¥ ® ï�k��Ôå*ý.�Ýâmå�âjþÔå�üjåKâ3�Ýû»ê��(�êÝüjü�ã ò ý-£å*ý�âjü,û��Ýä �¥�ãMý®ü&��êÝý äjå/�Ôäjå�üjå�ý³â�ê âmã��oý6#*_ël©�g«ª�¬� �¥��Kï �

ü W @ U @ x�ý=þ*ý @ ÿVA S���Swv Bjx U X-ÿ½W � U W � x � ÿYþÄX�þoý @ ÿ ý9x �,ì { ý0íÔXÔó � ÿYþ�Fá ÕºÍ�ÖKÍzÌ9Ö1©�g³ª�¬.� �¥°�2ÇYȺÛ)ël©�g«ª�¬� �¥��,Ç ÆKÍ�ÉMÖ�TzÞ�TzÆ(ÏtÕÔÉ9Ú ß �ø|ùmúÄú"ô�Vå��Ôå�}>ý4åÓâmþÔå�-¬ê���ÔãËý ò � ö�©�gîª�¬.� �¥°��A ël©�g«ª�¬.� �¥°��û��oä�å¹ê�$1þï�¨ ö �¥ A �§ð ¯©�gîª�¬.� �¥��#* � � ¨ �Êæ � �¥ ç�è �¥ ® é®=êA �§v�|�`�,þ4å*äjå �¥ ® ãËü âmþÔå±�.�5-¬ê ãËýX� ûbâmþÔåyê üjüjã ò ý-£å*ý�âC�¨ êÝý�t�¨5ä ãMüâmþÔåL$��oä�äjå*ü�� �Ýý�ÔãËý ò ân� â¡ê��3�ÔãMü�âmä�ã(Ôëèâmå��V-��Ýä&�ÔþÔãMü&- ïCñ�ã�$*åKmoå*ä�ü�ê.����åx�ÔåK}>ýÔå8âjþÔåc-�ê���4ãËý ò �eò � ö©�gîª�¬.� �¥\�8A ë�©�g«ª�¬� �¥��bû��oäÓå&ê�$1þ2�¨ æ � �¥ ç)è �¥ ® é® êA �§v�\ 2ë�©�g«ª�¬.� �¥°�g#* �eò � � ¨ �8æ- �eò � � ¨ �|W�� ��ó�ô Áõ®  Y�ö �¥ A �§����,þÔå*ä�åx´#ª�µ°� �eò � � ¨ ���®æ�¥ ® ê ý� �eò � � ¨ ��� ö ÷�æ ¨5ä �³êÝý�Dû��oä6å&ê�$1þ£V �¥ ® ��´#ª�µ°��� � ó�ôÎÁõ®  �J£<�&��æø¶ ® ��£<�rêÝý�±� � ó�ôÎÁ�®  �J£<�:�Sù ÷ Á�ú Â�æû�H® ê ��£.��ïxk0â9$&êÝý�uåÜå¹êÝü�ã(�7*�$1þÔå�$bù å��4�âmþ�ê â ��ò � ãMü&âmþÔå¹ãËýrmÝå*äjü�å�-�ê���4ãËý ò â&� � ï $k�ë4üjåEû��oä�âmþÔå�û��5�(�����,ãMý ò åKê<��hê ý�ê âmã��oýÔü�âmþÔås-��oü;â&ëÔü�å�û<ë�täjå��4äjå*ü�å*ý�â¡êYâmã(�Ýý_�Ýû�êÝý´êÝü�üjã ò ý-£å*ý�âØï�­Cê"ê�-xî��Ëå�ü1� ûuêÝü�üjã ò ý-£å*ý�âmü2ãMý ü���êÝý äjå/�Ôäjå�üjå*ý�â�ê âmã��oýlêÝä�å�üjþ�:�,ý8ãËý6­Cê�ê�-���Må¹í4ï��8� û ì þ�ê��4âmå�äEí4ïA S���S�û ¾�ôÀ� � Z�Zký�ÿ���ü � ó9X�þoý @ ÿk��Ôå�}ÔýÔåhý�:� êÝýG§%¦^ý%§�óóCð>ñ´�Óùn§%¢7¡CòPð(ú_ñ���mÝå*ä£êÝüjü�ã ò ý-£å*ý�âjü�û��oä]ê��4ãËü�âjäjã�Ôë4âmå/� ò ä�ê��Ôþ �¥îï25Eý|êÝüjü�ã ò ý6î-6å�ý³â^�¨ ö �¥¬A �§.ãMü,äjå��_ê âmå/�Lr*®âmþ4å±å/-9ºå/��ÔãMý ò ä�å��hêYâmã(�Ýý®â&�¬ê ýlêÝü�üjã ò ý-6å�ý�â �ª¹ö �¥`A �À ãLû'�¨ $&êÝýºå�å�-9uå��.�Ôå��8ãËý�ân� �ª�ãËýeâmþ4å±ü�å*ýÔü�å±âmþ�ê â�âjþÔå`��5-�êÝãËý_�Ýû'�¨ $¹êÝýLºå¹å/-9ºå/��Ôå/��ãËý�ân�bâjþÔå��.�5-¬ê ãËýK�Ýû�ª¯êÝý� �§��Ôä&�:m´ã(�4å*ürê â��Ëå&êÝü�â�âjþÔå�ü�âmä�ë$�âjëÔäjå^�Ýû �ÀüêÝý�°� �oü�üjã���*�ü&�5-£åg-��oä�åw�,þÔã��Ëåbäjå�ü&�uå�$KâmãËý ò âjþÔåêÝüjü�ã ò ý-£å*ý�âjü,û��Ýä �¥îïQ ��R ÿký>þoý @ ÿCA S��[S ACB � ôÀ� � Z�Zký�ÿ���W � ó<X�þoý @ ÿ�F] åKâ �¥þuå±ê)�ÔãMü�âjäjã(4ë4âmå/� ò ä�ê��Ôþ4�tâjþÔåL§%¦^ý%§�óóCð>ñ´�Üùn§%¢7¡CòPð(ú_ñÀ¤ éö dïë�©�g«ª�¬� �¥��,¥�ël©�g«ª�¬� �¥���ãMü�Ôå�}>ý4å��´êÝü�û��5���(�:�,ü*öH][å�âw�¨ æ2� �¥Qç�è �¥ ® A �§v�ÀêÝý.� �ª,æÿ� �¥îç�è �¥^àsA �À8�iºå,â+���±êÝüjü�ã ò ý.-6å�ý³âjü�û��Ýä�¥��èâjþÔå*ý��¨ ¤ éö

�ª�ãMû�êÝý�_�Ýý��*£ãMû �¥ ® d �¥^àmêÝý�ÜâjþÔå*ä�å�ãËü°êhâ&�Ýâ¡ê�� �ÔãMü�âjäjã(4ë4âmå/�_-��oä��ÔþÔãMü&- �� ö �§�A �Àüjë$1þ âmþ�ê â2âjþÔå��Ôãhê ò ä�ê�-³�;ð��"uå����:�X$/�5-�-hë4âmå�ü*ï

�¥ ®����� � � � �

� � � �����

é® ê �� �§é���¥ �¥^à����

Á �HÂ

éà ê�� �À

�¾s¿[X>ô U ó � A SM� B � ôÀ� � ZFZDýPÿ �VW � ó<X�þoý @ ÿiFì �oýÔüjã��Ôå*ä�âjþÔå�â+���|êÝü�üjã ò ý-£å*ý�âmüb�¨ æ � �¥ ç)è �¥ ® A �§��¾êÝý� �ª±æ � �¥ ç�è �¥^à,A �À9� ò ã�mÝå*ý�ãËý�âjþÔåTCã ò ë4äjå�yèï��èïKk�üjþ�:� �oý�7*ÀâmþÔå ò ä�ê��ÔþÔã($&ê�����êÝä;â9�Ýû|âmþÔå¬ê âjâjäjã(4ë4âmå/� ò ä�ê��ÔþÔü¶êÝý�yêYâjâmä�ã(Ôëèâmå�� ò ä�ê��Ôþ-��oä��ÔþÔãMü&-£ü � âmþ4å�êYâjâmä�ã(Ôëèâmå9��ê ä�â¹ãËü�âjäjå&ê âmå/� ê ý�ê��(� ò �oëÔü���*oï�ñ2þÔå�êÝüjü�ã ò ý.-6å�ý³â_�¨ $¹êÝý�uåbå�-9uå��.�Ôå��

ðÄ���

Page 136: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

X

B

Aa

b

^

^

f^

X a^

Xb^

t

t

TFã ò ëÔä�å`yèï��èö���=�§�¡_öbödðL�Cñ�¦)§dñ-ò��¨�� ¡Cñ�ý%§8§%¦^ý%§�óó,§�ó3ð>ñ �ª��"ý�õ6ò&ñtú_ò�O*ð � §¹O�§Kù�ö�¡rßãËý�ân� �ª�üjãËý.$*å¹âmþÔå���5-�êÝãËý �¥ ® �Ýûs�¨ $&êÝýxuå±å/-9ºå/��Ôå/��ãËý�ân��âmþ4åw��5-�êÝãMý �¥^à�� û �ª/êÝý� âmþÔå�äjåhå�êèãËü�âjüê®â&�Ýâ¡ê����ÔãËü;âmäjã�Ôë4âjå��°-��oä��ÔþÔãMü&- �� ö �§ A �À�üjë$1þ%âmþ�êYâ�âjþÔå^�Ôãhê ò ä�ê�-ø$��5-^-�ë4âjå*ü�ï�kÎý�û{ê�$�â���âjþÔå*ä�åãËü�-^�oäjå±âmþ�êÝý��oý4å�ân�Ýâ�ê����ÔãMü�âjäjã(4ë4âmå/�\-��oä��ÔþÔãMü&-ø$��5-^-�ë4âjãËý ò âjþÔå8�Ôã_ê ò ä�ê�-8ï��'�:��å/mÝå*ä�� âmþ4å8�ÝâmþÔå�ä�^êu*}êÝä&�ÝëÔý�4�TâmþÔå¶êÝüjü�ã ò ý.-6å�ý³â �ª�$¹ê ýÔý�Ýâsºå�å�-9uå��.�Ôå���ãMý�ân���¨ ü�ãËý$�åhýÔå�ãMâjþÔå*ä,âmþÔå`��5-�êÝãMý �¥^à"$&êÝýºå�å�-9uå��.�Ôå��ÜãMý�ân� �¥ ® ý�Ýä�âjþÔå*ä�åEåKêèãMü�âmüµê�â&�Ýâ¡ê��p�4ãËü�âjäjã�Ôë4âmå/��-^�oä��ÔþÔãËü�-^û<ä&��- �À�ân� �§hïsñ2þ4å*äjåKû��oäjå���¨ ¤ éö

�ª��4ë4â �ª���¤éö�¨ ï

ñ2þÔå�­Cê"ê�-��.�Ëå&íèï ��ãMý ì þ�ê��èâmå*äsí�üjþ�:�,ümêÝý�å�ê"ê�-��.�Ëå"� û>âmþÔå&å/-9uå���ÔãMý ò ä�å��hêYâmã(�Ýýw�ÝûU�oë4ä�$¹ê üjå&ü;âmë�.*Ýï�

k6ü�þ�:��ý�:��âjþ�ê âÜâjþÔå�å�-9uå��.�ÔãËý ò ä�å��_ê âmã��oý'¤ éö�oý�âmþÔå�üjåKâK�Ýû¶êÝüjü�ã ò ý-£å*ý�âjüÜû��oä �¥ �Ôå�}ÔýÔå*ü}ê

�Ôäjå¦î+�oä��Ôå*ä/�>ã(ï åÝï4âjþÔå¹å�-9uå���4ãËý ò äjå/�hê âjã(�oýeãMü2äjå%o>åKêèã�mÝå¶ê ý� âjä�êÝý4üjãMâjã�mÝåÝïü W @ U @ x�ý=þ*ý @ ÿVA S���S�{ B�¤ éö ýHx U W � � @ WYZ � W5F�sÍÄÌ ¤

éöÒÔÍ»ÌHÕºÍ%Í1ÞeÒÔÍ�ÛÔÛ³ÉËÈèé½ÆKÍmÑ«Ç4Ì9É��zÈpÉMȺÛu×´Ú�Í*Û�ÒKõGÇçÛ³ÉËÖ*ÌHÆjÉ0Ò4×ÔÌÎÍ*Û½éoÆ1Ç*ÏtÕ �¥ ÇYÖ8ÉMȺÌ9Æ��´Ûu×´Ú�Í*Û�ÉMÈ

�±Í1÷ÔÈÔÉ(ÌHÉ �zÈ"! ß$#´ß ! Ð�ÌHÕºÍmȺÐ�¤éöÉMÖ�Ç�ÏtÆKÍ�M%�zÆ�ÛÔÍ1Æ ß �

ø|ùmúÄú"ôñ2þÔå�äjå��_ê âmã��oý»¤

éöãËü�ä�å/o>å�êèã�moå�� üjãËý.$*å�êÝüjü�ã ò ý.-6å�ý³âjüv$¹êÝý�uåbå�-9uå��.�Ôå��%ãËýÀãLâmüjå/�Mû�r*�âjþÔåbã(�Ôå�ý�âmãMâjãËå�ü

ãËý8Q � W³ï&ñ2þÔåhä�å��_ê âmã��oý®ãËü,âmä�ê ýÔüjãLâmã�mÝå��TüjãMý$*å¹âmþ4å�$/�5-��p�oü�ãMâmã��oýK�ÝûCâ&�Ýâ¡ê����4ãËü�âjäjã�Ôë4âmå/�L-^�oä��ÔþÔãËü�-6ü,ãMüê ò êÝãMýlêÓân� â¡ê����ÔãËü;âmä�ã(Ôë4âjå��x-^�oä��ÔþÔãËü�-@âmþ�ê â�ü�ê âjãËü�}Ôå*üEâjþÔå8$��oý.�ÔãMâjã(�oýÔü1�Ýû�âmþ4å�å�-9uå��.�ÔãËý ò äjå��_ê âmã��oý�ï$ï|å�û��oä�å\k)�Ôä��:mèã��Ôå�âmþ4å°$/�oýÔü;âmäjë.$�âmã��oý��Ýû��Ëå¹ê ü�â®ë��uå*ä_p�oëÔý.�Ôü_�,ãMâmþpä�å*ü&�uå�$Kâ®ân�îâmþÔå�å/-9ºå/��ÔãMý òäjå��_ê âmã��oý4�<k�ãMý³âjä&�,�Ôë$�å¹âjþÔå5ð>ñ-ò»§Kù�ö:§ � ò�ð(ú_ñ�� ûFâjþÔå���5-�êÝãËýÔü"�Ýûuê�üjåKâ1�Ýûuê üjüjã ò ý-£å*ý�âmü�ï� � ô»ôVX�A S���S'& B�ýPÿ þ � W x � yCþ*ý @ ÿ @ D�Z @ ôVX-ý�ÿFx�F�sÍÄÌ)( d¯©�g«ª�¬.� �¥\��Ò4Í�Ç�Ö�ÍzÌ*�,+sÇYÖjÖjÉLé�ÈÔÞeÍ1ÈuÌHÖg�¨ æ - ¨ W�� ® Y2ö �¥`A �§-+.�zÆ �¥%ÐsÌ9ÕºÍEãËý�âmå�äjüjå/$�âjã(�oý6�ÝûâmþÔå���5-�êÝãMýÔü�ÙPÉ0Ì9Õ®ÆKÍ1Ö(ÏPÍ�ÚzÌ�Ì%��( ÉMÖ&é�É0/ÄÍ1ÈVÒKõ�ÌHպ͹۳ÉMÖØÌ9ÆjÉÎÒè×ÔÌIÍ�Û6éoÆ1Ç*ÏtÕ �¥21435��/zÍmÆ1¥2163£Ð ÙPÕºÍmÆKÍ~ ¥2143�æ87

é®:93 ´,ª�µ°� ¨ �FÉMÖ2ÌHÕuÍ�ÉËÈuÌIÍmÆjÖKÍ�ÚzÌ9É��zÈ;�,+ Ì9ÕºÍ�ȺÍÄÌ0Ù<�zÆ>=6Û?�zÞÓÇ ÉMȱé�ÆmÇ*ÏtÕÔÖ�´#ª�µ°� ¨ �@+.�zÆ�Í�dzÚ;Õ

�¨ ÉMÈA( ǠȺÛ

~ ¶B143_��£<�Pæ87é®C9

3 ¶ ® �J£<�D+.�zÆEÍKÇ�Ú;Õ8ÈE�´ÛÔÍ'£) L¥;163 ǠȺÛ_¶F163_� ¸ ��æG7é®:9

3 ¶ ® � ¸ � ßðÄ��H

Page 137: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

ø|ùmúÄú"ôñ2þÔå��ÔãËü;âmä�ã(Ôë4âjå�� ò ä�ê��Ôþ �¥2163]ãMüCãMý�Ôå*å/��ê��ÔãËü;âmäjã�Ôë4âjå�� ò ä�ê��Ôþ4��ü�ãËý$�å|âmþÔå2ãMý�âmå*ä�üjå/$�âmã��oý8�Ýûuüjë. ò ä�ê��ÔþÔü�Ýû�¥ ãËüÂê ò êÝãËý:êÜü�ë ò ä�ê��Ôþ��Ýû�¥ êÝý��âmþ4åbãËý�âmå�äjüjå/$�âjã(�oýI7

é®C93 ¶ ® �J£<�'�Ýû�âjþÔå8$����oüjå/�%ü�ë�înê�� ò å/Ôä�ê ü¶ ® �J£<�"�Ýûi¶��J£<�|ãËü³ê ò êÝãËýdê8$/�(�oü�å�� üjë�înê�� ò å�Ôä�êg� û�¶��J£<��ï $

¾s¿[X>ô U ó � A S�� B�ý�ÿYþ � WYx � yCþoý @ ÿ @ DEZ @ ôVX-ý�ÿFx�FTCã ò ë4äjå1yèï�í�üjþ�:�,ü�âmþÔå,ãËý�âjå*äjü�å�$Kâmã(�Ýý��Ýûuâmþ4å�â+���¶ê üjüjã ò ý-£å*ý�âmüv�¨ ê ý� �ª�üjþ�:�,ýÓãMý^TCã ò ë4äjå1yèïLðoïC5&â�âjþÔåân�5�L�ÝûCâjþÔå±} ò ëÔäjå¹âmþÔå�ãËä1��5-�êÝãËý4üqê äjå�üjþ�:�,ý4��ê â�âjþÔå` �Ýâ�ân�5-nâjþÔå�ãËý�âmå�äjüjå/$�âjã(�oýL�Ýûsâmþ4å*ãËä1��5-�êÝãMýÔü*ïñ2þÔå®ãËý�âmå�äjüjå/$�âjã(�oýG�Ýû�âmþÔåK���-¬êÝãMýÔü9$/�oý�â¡êÝãMýÔü8�oý�7*±�oýÔå®ýÔåKâ+�"�Ýä�ùîý�,�Ôå���üjãMý$*å_�Ýý��*a�oýÔå®ýÔå�â+���oä ù

domain of b

XX

domain of a

JJKKLLMM11 NNOO 2

PPQQ 2

intersection of the domain of a and the domain of b^ ^

RRSS 2

a b

3

TFã ò ëÔä�å�yèï�í4öT��=�§�ð>ñ-ò+§Kùbö:§ � ò�ð(ú_ñ�ú"ô�ò«=�§§ó´ú�¦^¡Cð>ñ�ö �¥ ® ¡Cñ ó �¥^à|ß

ý�<�4åhãËü�ãËýxp�Ýâjþx��5-�êÝãËý4ü*ïEñ2þ4å�äjåK}>ýÔå��Aê â�âmä�ã(Ôë4âjå�� ò ä�ê��4þÀãËý8âjþÔå�ãMý³âjå*ä�üjå�$Kâmã��oý�ãËü�å�-^�4â+* û��oä�âjþÔåò ä�ê��4þÔã($&ê�� ��êÝä�â��4üjãMý$*å �¥ ® ãËü�å�-^�4â+*b�oý6âmþÔå ò ä�ê��ÔþÔã�$¹ê��p��êÝä;â|û��oä�âmþÔãMü|äjåK}>ýÔå/� ý.�<�Ôå ïPñ2þÔåv��ê â�ê9��êÝä;â$��oý�â¡ê ãËýÔü2âmþ4å`��ê â¡êbý�,�Ôå��,ãMâjþ8ý³ë-wºå�äE��ü�ãËý$�å¹âjþÔãËü2ý.�<�Ôå6ê��.�ºå&êÝäjü,ãËýKp�ÝâmþK���-¬êÝãMýÔü*ï �

ñ2þÔå)�Må¹êÝü;â�ë��uå*ä� �ÝëÔý�Vû��oärê8ü�å�âw�Ýû³êÝü�üjã ò ý-6å�ý�âmüT( ãMü ò ã�moå�ýar*%âmþÔå¬êÝüjü�ã ò ý-£å*ý�â��H�,þÔå�äjåÓâjþÔå��5-�êÝãËýÀãMü�âmþÔåg$����Ëã(-£ãMâs�Ýû�âmþÔå�å�-wºå/��ÔãËý ò ü�û<ä&�5-fâmþÔå�ãËý�âjå*äjü�å�$Kâmã(�Ýý�ãMý³â&�eâmþÔåg��5-�êÝãMýÔü��Ýû�âmþÔå�êÝü"îüjã ò ý-6å�ý�âmü>êÝý�îâjþÔåÜân�Ýâ�ê����ÔãMü�âjäjã(4ë4âmå/��-��oä��ÔþÔãMü&-��Ýû�âjþÔå_�Ëå&êÝü�â�ë.��ºå�ä8 �ÝëÔý�ÊãËü�âjþÔå_-��Ýä&�ÔþÔãMü&-ãËý�Ôë.$*å��6r*Üâmþ4å`$/�5�Ëã�-6ãLâ��Ôä��5�uå*ä�â+*Ýï

ü W @ U @ x�ý=þ*ý @ ÿVA S���SVU B�¤éö��XÔx6ó � X>x²þ {�U�U � WÜ� @ { ÿ�Z�x�F

�sÍÄÌ �¥ Ò4Í�Ç�Û�ÉËÖØÌ9ÆjÉ0Ò4×ÔÌIÍ�Û é�Æ1Ç*ϺպÐ|ÌHպͣÍ1Þ®Ò4Í*Û4Û³ÉËÈ4é Æ�Í1Ñ«ÇèÌHÉ��ÄÈî¤éöÉËÈuÛu×´Ú*Í�ÛÊÒKõ �¥ Ç Ö¹ÉËÈuÌ9Æ��´Ûu×´Ú*Í�Û�ÉMÈ

�±Í1÷ÔÈÔÉ(ÌHÉ �zÈ"! ß$#´ß !�ÕTÇYÖ�Ñ<ÍKÇ Ö*Ì2×ØÏÔÏsÍ1ƱÒW�´×ÝÈºÛ³Ö ß �

ø|ùmúÄú"ôX ã7moå*ý ê®üjå�â�( d2©�g«ª�¬.� �¥\�v� û^êÝü�üjã ò ý-£å*ý�âmüK�¨ ö �¥ A �§h�:mÝå*ä �¥»ï)][å�â �¥2Y43ûuå�âjþÔå^$��5�Mã(-£ãMâ�5 � å�$Kâg�Ýû2âmþ4åÜû{ê�-6ã���*\� û�å/-9uå���ÔãMý ò üK� �¥2143[Z A �¥ ® � é®C9

3 êÝý� �\QuåÜâmþÔå)$��5�Mã(-£ãMâ`�5 � å/$�â8�Ýû,âjþÔåû{ê�-6ã���*��ÝûEâ&�Ýâ¡ê����ÔãËü;âmä�ã(Ôë4âjå��Z-��Ýä&�ÔþÔãMü&-£ü6� �¥21,]^Z A �¥ ® A �§v� ®:9 3�ãMý�Ôë$�å��V#*îâjþÔå ëÔý�Ôå�ä&��*´ãMý òân�Ýâ�ê��i-^�<�Ôå/�i-^�oä&�Ôþ4ãËü&-£ü�ãËý°> @ Z R ����� ï6ñ2þÔå�ý4� âmþÔå�äjå�åKêèãËü;âmürê®â&�Ýâ¡ê��i�ÔãËü;âmä�ã(Ôë4âjå���-^�oä&�Ôþ4ãËü&- �£Àæ-�£UW���ú/Ybö �¥2Y43�A �\�ãËý�Ôë.$*å��a#*ÀâjþÔåÓë4ýÔã�mÝå*äjü�ê��l�Ôä&�5�uå*ä;â+*��Ýû&âjþÔå�$/�5�Ëã�-6ãLâ��5 � å�$�â �¥2Y43ã�9üjå�å6âjþÔå

ðØío:

Page 138: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

�Ôãhê ò ä�ê�-hºå/�(�:��û��Ýä&âmþÔå�$¹ê üjå��Ýû_( æ]ÿ��¨ W �ªu����ï�¥2143E`� ��� ��

�¥^à

a

� ��

éà ê �� �À

éb%c�

�¥ ®aé®=ê �

` � �� �¥2Y63

éú de ffffffff

�§éb÷ �� �\

ñ2þÔå*ý4�>âjþÔåg¢(§&¡6g�h)i:æræ�§Kù�ýKú6ikjmlv�Ýû_( ãMü&âmþÔå6êÝü�üjã ò ý-6å�ý�â�¨<©uª��.(X��æonH©eW�� p�Y&ö �¥�A �\^��,þÔå*ä�å~ ©eæ2�0¥Qç)è<¥2Y43 úA �\9�^êÝý�~ � p �0¼ ��æ2��¶��J£<��ç�è�¶FY63_��£.�rqts Ávu ÂA w^��£ ��¼ �&��û��Ýä2å¹ê�$1þ ý�,�Ôåv¼x c¥2Y63Óï

kÎý��oä&�Ôå�ä±â&��üjå�åÓâmþ�êYâb¨«©uª��x(ï�hãËü�ãËý.�Ôå*å/�ýêÝý»ë��uå*äw �oë4ý�4���5Ôü�å*ä=moåÜâmþ�ê âhâjþÔå*ä�åÜãËü¶êÝý»ãËý.$��Ëë4üjã(�Ýý�¥ ® Z A �¥2Y63 û��oäEå&ê�$1þC�¨ y( êÝý�:ê6â&�Ýâ¡ê����4ãËü�âjäjã�Ôë4âmå/�x-^�oä&�Ôþ4ãËü&- �z ® ö �§�A �\ û��oä�å¹ê�$1þC�¨ {($��5-^-�ë4âjãËý ò âmþÔåhýÔå/�3�7*8û��oä�-6å/�c�Ôã_ê ò ä�ê�-6ü1�54â�êÝãËý4å��lê ü�$��5�Mã(-£ãMâ2ãMý � å�$Kâmã��oý�ïEñ2þ�ê â�¨«©uª��.(ï��ãMüs�Må¹êÝü;âë��uå*äbp�oëÔý�Dû��5�(�����,ü^r*DâjþÔå�û{ê�$KâÓâjþ�ê â �¥2Y63 êÝý� �\ êÝäjåL$��5�Mã(-£ãMâg�5 � å/$�âjü´êÝý�½âjþÔå�ëÔýÔã7moå�äjü�ê���Ôä&�5�uå*ä;â+*_�ÝûH$��5�Mã(-£ãMâjü*ï |�'�Ýâjã($*å�âmþ�ê âhû��oä¹âmþ4å)$¹ê üjå)� û2â+�"��ê üjüjã ò ý-£å*ý�âmü6�¨ ö �¥ A �§aêÝý.� �ªeö �¥ A �À)�sãMû �¥ ® æ �¥^àEâjþÔå�ÔãËü;âmäjã�Ôë4âjå�� ò ä�ê��Ôþ �\ ãËü � ëÔü�âEâmþÔå��ÔëÔüjþ.�oë4âv�Ýûv�¨5ä êÝý.� �ª ä ï � ý�âmþ4å9�Ýâmþ4å*äEþ�êÝý�4�ºãMû �¥ ® êÝý� �¥^à°êÝä�å�ÔãËü � �oãËý�âu�´âmþÔå�ý �\�æ �§~} �À ãMü&âmþÔå��ÔãMü � �oãMý�â2ëÔýÔã��oý�ï¾s¿[X>ô U ó �xA Swv Bjó �³X>x�� { UFU �³We� @ {@� ZiFk"$��ÝýÔü�âjäjë$KâEâmþ4å��Må¹êÝü;â�ë.��ºå�ä'p�oëÔý.�L�ÝûFâmþÔå¹â+���pêÝü�üjã ò ý-6å�ý�âmü^�¨ êÝý� �ªEãËý�âmä��<�4ë$*å/��ãËý6TCã ò ëÔä�åwy´ïMðoïñ2þÔå*ãMäEãËý�âjå*äjü�å�$Kâmã(�Ýýc�^ê üÂê��Ëä�å¹ê��<*L$&ê��($�ë�hêYâmå���ãËýx­Cê"ê�-^��Ëå9yèï�í.�uâjþÔå*ãMäs���-¬êÝãMýÔü �¥ ® êÝý� �¥�à2ãMýx­Cê��ê�-��.�Ëå�yèïLðoïPñ2þÔå¹ä�å¹ê��Ôå�ä3$¹êÝý6$1þÔå�$C�Üâjþ�ê â2û��oä2å&ê�$1þlê üjüjã ò ý-£å*ý�âu�<�,þÔå*ä�å6�¨ êÝý� �ªs$¹ê ýLuå�å�-9uå��.�Ôå��ê��Ëü���âjþÔå��Ëå&êÝü�â,ë�.�ºå�ä1p�oëÔý.�L�Ýû1�¨ ê ý� �ª'$¹êÝý6ºå¹å/-9ºå/��Ôå/��ï5Eý}ê���ÔãLâmã(�Ýý�ê��uåKê"ê�-^��Ëå�ãMü ò ã�moå�ý®ãËý ì þ�ê��4âjå*ä�í�ãËý í4ï�åèï �

A S���SM� ? �´ô U @ WzX>ó � WzX U �¯> @ Z��´óHx� ãËý$�å&âmþÔå2å/-9uå���ÔãMý ò äjå/�hê âjã(�oýhãËüÀê��Ôä�å��j�oä&�Ôå�ä���ãLâPãËý�4ë$*å�ümê�âjå�-^� �Ýä�ê��,�Ôäjå:�+�oä��Ôå*ä�-^�,�Ôå��"êÝü��Ôå�}ÔýÔå��ãËý�¦�å�}ÔýÔãMâjã(�oýxyèï$�´ïMð5�4�,þ4å*äjå�âjþÔåbü�â�ê âmå�ü��Ýû�âmþÔå8�Ôä�å��j�oä&�Ôå�äEâmä�êÝýÔü�ãMâmã��oý�ü=*èü;âmå/-ÿêÝäjå±ê üjüjã ò ý-£å*ý�âmü�û��Ýä�¥îïVñ2þÔå�äjåKû��oäjå���k`$¹ê�����âjþÔåcêÝüjü�ã ò ý.-6å�ý³âjü�û��oähâjþÔåeü�â�ê âmå�ü8�Ýû¾ê�âjä�êÝý4üjãMâjã(�oýVü�*´ü�âjå�- g�h�¡�h»§CgKï�5 �Ôäjå:��oä&�Ôå�äÓâmä�êÝýÔü�ãMâmã��oý½ü=*èü;âmå/- û��oä6âjþÔåÀå�-wºå/��ÔãËý ò äjå��_ê âmã��oý�¤

éöãMüb$¹ê����Ëå/�p�Ýù�¡%æ>=�h9ù�¡�jWg��'hx�(ú6j�g��,g�h+§%¦

êÝý�yêc�4äjå��j�oä&�4å*ä9-^�<�4å����,ãMâjþ»äjå�ü&�uå�$�âbâ&��âmþ4åÜå�-9uå��.�ÔãËý ò äjå/�hê âjã(�oý�ãËü¯êIh»§%¦sæ>úYù�¡�¢F�Ýù�¡%æ>=a¦Óú�l,§%¢#ïñ2þÔå°êÝü�üjã ò ý-6å�ý�âmüCë4üjå��bû��oä âmþ4å&ãËý�âmå�ä&�Ôä�å�â�ê âmã��oýw�Ýû4âmþÔå��4ä&�5�p�oüjãLâmã��oý�ê��5mbêÝä�ãhê��Må*ü»êÝäjå�$¹ê����Ëå/�b�Ýù�¡%æ>=�� � ¡�¢� ú6jWg�hHù�¡��'j�h'gKï�ñ2þ4å�ã��Ôå¹ê�� û ò ä�ê��ÔþÔã�$¹ê���$��oý4ü�âmä�êÝãËý�âjü[ãËü��oä�ã ò ãMý�ê��(�7*��Ôå%moå����5�uå���ãËý����1��Hry<�v�v�<$�H5².�d� ê ò Hrå6�ân� ò ä�ê��ÔþÔã($&ê��(�7*£åKê<�Ôäjå�üjü'�Ôä&�5�uå*ä;âmãMå*ü3�Ýû�êg$�å*ä;â¡êÝãMý6$/�hêÝü�ü3�Ýû ò ä�ê��Ôþ4ü*ïQ�� R �@� � � @ � A S��[SV� B;�uWzX U ���ÄWzX � x � � � @ � x/E x����èô X � Z��TWYX U ��ô @ Z �´ó @ ím�´W �¥�FX ã7moå*ýDâmþÔå�å/-9uå���ÔãMý ò ä�å��hêYâmã(�Ýý�¤

éö�:moå�ä �¥ �ÔåK}>ýÔå��pãMý�¦�å�}>ý4ãMâmã��oý[yèï�íèïõy<�]êî�Ýù�¡%æ>=�h9ù&¡�jWg��'h��(ú6j

g��,g�h+§%¦��:moå*ä �¥iãËü¾êb�4äjå��j�oä&�4å*ä�âjä�êÝý4üjãMâjã(�oý8ü�*´ü�âjå�-î��\ êÝü��ÔåK}>ýÔå/�%ãMýÀ¦�å�ûIïfyèï��èïLðw�,ãMâjþ�äjå�ü&�uå�$�â�â&�ðØí4ð

Page 139: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

intersection of the domains of a and b^ ^

���� 2

A

� �� �� �� � 2B

3

  ¡¡¢¢££¤¤¥¥11

2

3

¦ ¦¦ ¦§§ ¨ ¨¨ ¨© ©© © ª ªª ª« «« «1 2 ¬ ¬¬ ¬­­ ® ®® ®¯ ¯¯ ¯ ° °° °± ±± ±1 2

Xb

²²³³

´´µµ¶¶··¸¸¹¹11

a

2

2

3

3

v

=

=

b

Xa

^t

^t

TCã ò ëÔäjå`yèïâ�Ôö»º�ú6jWg�h9ù:i � h��(ú6j�ú%¼»h'½�§`¢(§&¡6g�h¾i:æræ�§Kù`ýKú6ikjmlrß

¤éöïÀ¿Áh»§%¦sæ>úYù�¡�¢C�Ýù�¡%æ�½±¦Óú�l,§%¢4�:mÝå*ä �¥ ãËü¶êx�Ôäjå:�+�oä��Ôå*äw-��,�Ôå����,þÔå�äjåÜâmþ4åb�Ôäjå:�+�oä��Ôå*ä±âmä�ê ýÔüjãLâmã(�Ýý

ü�*´ü�âjå�- ãËü�ê ò ä�ê��Ôþ£âmä�ê ýÔüjãLâmã(�Ýý£ü=*´ü�âmå/-8ï�ñ2þÔå'$¹ê âjå ò �Ýä�*g�Ýû ò ä�ê��Ôþ^-^�<�Ôå/�Ëü��:moå�ä �¥ ê ý� ò ä�ê��Ôþ�-��,�Ôå��-��oä��ÔþÔãMü&-£ü&ãËü��Ôå�ý�Ýâjå��cr*K>^­ÃÂÄ ï �� ãËý$�å6âjþÔåb�Ôä��5� �ÝüjãMâjã(�oý�ê���m<ê äjãhê��Ëå�ü±ãMý�âmå/-��p�oä�ê�� ò ä�ê��Ôþa-��,�Ôå��Mü¶ê äjåÜãMý³âjå*ä��ÔäjåKâmå����Ýý��*°r* ê8üjãËý��ò �ËådêÝü�üjã ò ý-£å*ý�â�ãËýÔü;âmå&ê��V� û¾ê�üjåKâ�� û�ü�â�ê âmå�ü���kw$¹ê ýDä�å��Ôä�å*üjå�ý�âÓâmå/-��p�oä�ê���û��oä�-�ë�_êÝü9�,ãMâjþ�ä�å*ü��ºå/$�âân�®âmå�-^�p�oä�ê�� ò ä�ê��4þ°-^�,�Ôå��Mü�ãËýAê ü��ºå/$*ã_ê��Päjå/�Ôäjå�üjå*ý�â�ê âmã��oý�ïÓñ2þ4ãËü¹äjå/�Ôäjå�üjå*ý�â�ê âmã��oýVü�þ�:�,ü±ý� â��Ýý��*âmþÔå�ü=*èý�â�ê�$�âjã($¹ê���âmå�-^�p�oä�ê��uû��oä&-hë�hê.�,Ôë4â2âjþÔå�âmå/-��p�oä�ê��ºû��oä�-�ë�_ê±ân� ò å�âmþ4å*ä��,ãMâjþeãMâjü2ãËý�âmå�ä&�Ôä�å�â¡êYâmã(�Ýý�Ýû3�Ôä&��� �oü�ãMâjã(�oý�ê��im<ê äjãhê��Ëå�ü�r*)êÝüjü�ã ò ý-£å*ý�âjü*ïÀñ2þÔåÓâjå�-^� �Ýä�ê��Pû��oä�-�ë�hê®ân� ò å�âmþ4å*ä��,ãLâmþVâjþÔåÜãMý³âjå*ä%��ÔäjåKâ¡ê âjã(�oýK�Ýû�âmþÔå��,$�$�ëÔäjä�ãËý ò �Ôä��5� �ÝüjãMâjã(�oý�ê��pmbêÝä�ãhê�.�Ëå*ü�r*dê üjüjã ò ý-£å*ý�âmü,ãMü�$¹ê����Ëå�� �Ýù�¡%æ�½´¢Å�'j�h+§Kùjæuù�§�h+§Ælh»§%¦sæ>úYù�¡�¢:¼ØúYù%¦Ti,¢7¡Ýïi­Cê"ê�-^��Ëå�ü��Ýû ò ä�ê��Ôþ��ÎãËý�âjå*ä&�4äjå�âjå��hû��Ýä&-�ë�_êÝü�$¹êÝý8uå�û��oë4ý��âmþÔä��oë ò þ.�oë4â ì þ�ê��4âmå�äíg� û��oë4ä1$&êÝüjå¹ü;âmë�.*Ýï¾s¿[X>ô U ó �xA S ACB��TWzX U ��� �x� �t�³W U W,�Ç�t�´Z��t�´ô U @ WzX>ó�D @ WYô { ó<X F] åKâ�cY� ÈÊÉçc��vºå¯ê6âmå/-��p�oä�ê���û��oä�-�ë�_ê^�,ãMâjþ�âmþÔåw�Ôä&�5�p�oü�ãMâmã��oý�ê���mbêÝä�ãhê��Må*ü�cY�£êÝý�Àc��Øï�ñ2þÔåbãMý³âjå*ä%��ÔäjåKâ¡ê âjã(�oý\�Ýû�âmþ4å*üjåbâ+���6mbêÝä�ãhê�.�Ëå*üs#*�êÝüjü�ã ò ý-£å*ý�âjüvIf�<cY���¾ê ý��I �<c*�|�EãMü�üjþ�:�,ý%ãËý�âmþ4å�TFã ò ëÔä�ågyèï�yê â¹âmþÔå�ân�5�tïÓñ2þÔå^�Ôäjå�üjå�ý³â�ê âmã��oýa� û|âmþ4å£âjå�-^� �oä�ê��sû��oä�-�ë�hêÜcz�_ÈIÉçc��¯êÝü ò ä�ê��Ôþk�ÎãMý�âmå*ä��ÔäjåKâmå/�%âjå�-T�� �oä�ê�� û��oä&-�ë.�hê�ãËü�ü�þ�:�,ý:ê â�âmþ4å9 � âjân��-ø� ûPâmþÔåh} ò ëÔäjå ï�ñ2þÔãMü�äjå/�Ôäjå�üjå*ý�â�ê âmã��oýÀãËý�âmå ò ä�êYâmå*üs�ÔãËä�å�$�â&��*âmþÔå±ê üjüjã ò ý-£å*ý�âmü�û��oä�âjþÔå�ãËý�âjå*ä&�4äjå�â�ê âmã��oýx�ÝûPâjþÔå9�Ôä��5�p�oüjãLâmã(�Ýý�ê���mbêÝäjã_ê��Ëå�ü*ï�ñ2þÔãËüÂê��(�(�:�,ü£ê ò ä�ê��ÔþÔã��$¹ê��sü��ºå/$*ãL}�$¹ê âjã(�oý��Ýûl�ÔãMü�âjäjã(4ë4âmå/�%ü=*´ü�âmå/-î�Ôä&���ºå�ä�âmãMå*ü/êÝü¹ãLâ�ãËü�ü�þ�:�,ýVãMý ì þ�ê��4âjå*ä�í4ï9kÎýÀâmþ4ãËü��¼ê:*��âmþÔå�ü&�uå�$�ãM}�$&ê âmã��oýÀâmå/$1þÔýÔãË¡³ëÔå£û��oä�âmþ4å^�4ä&�5�uå*ä;âmãËå�ü��Ýû^êK�ÔãMü�âmä�ã(Ôëèâmå���ü=*èü;âmå/- ê ý�%âjþÔå�ü&�uå�$�ãM}�$&ê âmã��oýâmå�$1þ4ýÔãË¡³ëÔå`�Ýû�âmþÔå��ÔãMü�âmä�ã(Ôëèâmå��®ü=*èü;âmå/-fãLâmü�å��Mû�$/�oãËý$�ã(�Ôå ï �k±ãMý³âjä&�,�Ôë$�å���ãËý � å/$�âmã��oýVyèï���âjþÔåK$��oý4ü�âmä�ë$�âjã(�oýG�Ýû£ê�â+*,�Ôã($&ê����Ôä�å��+�Ýä&�Ôå�ä^-^�,�Ôå��l�,ãMâmþÊä�å*ü&�uå�$Kâ6â&�ê±�Ôäjå:�+�oä��Ôå*äÜâjþ�ê âeþ�ê ü_�Ëå¹ê ü�âeë�.�ºå�ä_ �oë4ý�ÔüdêÝý�iê ò ã7moå�ý�ãËý�âmå�ä&�Ôä�å�â¡êYâmã(�Ýý¯�Ýû¹âmþÔåx�4ä&�5�p�oüjãLâmã��oý�ê��m<ê äjãhê��Ëå�ü*ï � ãËý$�å�âjþÔåEå/-9ºå/��ÔãMý ò ä�å��hêYâmã(�Ýý8¤ éö

þ�êÝü��Må¹êÝü;â|ë.��ºå�ä"p�oëÔý�4ü���å¾êÝä�å¾ê��Må2ân�w$/�oýÔü;âmäjë.$�ââmþÔå�â+*,�Ôã($&ê���âmå/-��p�oä�ê�� ò ä�ê��Ôþ6-��,�Ôå/�õê�$�$/�oä&�4ãËý ò ân� ì �oý4ü�âmä�ë$�âjã(�oýcyèï��èï�í4ï

ðØíÇ�

Page 140: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

I(q )1

X

X

X

Interpretation:

Graph-interpreted temporal formula:

I(q )2

TCã ò ëÔäjå`y´ïõyèö»Ë&ù�¡%æ�½´¢Å�'j�h+§Kùjæuù�§�h+§Æl2h+§%¦sæ>úYù�¡�¢�¼ØúYù|¦Ti<¢7¡rß

? ��� @ W,�´ô A S���S�Ì�Í BÎ�|E U@� yoX>óÏ�t�´ô U @ WzX>ó��TWzX U �pô @ Z��èójF�sÍÄÌ �¥ ÒÔÍhÇ8Û³ÉMÖØÌHÆ�ÉÎÒ4×4ÌIÍ*Û é�ÆmÇ*ÏtÕ�ǠȺÛ�¤

éöÒÔÍ6Ì9ÕºÍ�Í1Þ®Ò4Í*Û4Û³ÉËÈ4é Æ�Í1Ñ«ÇèÌHÉ��ÄÈ�Ç ÖhÛÔÍm÷ÔȺÍ*Û�ÉËÈy! ß$#´ß !ÝÐ�ÌHÕuÍ1È

ÌHÕºÍhÌLõoÏtÉ9Ú�Ç Ñ[ÞÐ�èÛÔÍmÑsÙPÉ0Ì9Õ®ÆKÍ1Ö(ÏPÍ�ÚzÌ�Ì%�6¤éöÍ&NèÉËÖ*ÌHÖ ß �

ø|ùmúÄú%¼¿ �ÔãMäjå/$�â�$��oýÔü�å*¡³ëÔå�ý$*å��Ýû ¶Pä��5� �ÝüjãMâjã(�oý�yèï�í4ïv�¶êÝý.�ÓâmþÔå1$��ÝýÔü�âjäjë$Kâmã(�Ýýb�Ýû�âjþÔå�â+*,�Ôã�$¹ê��U-^�<�Ôå/� ò ã�mÝå*ýÓãMýyèï$�´ï�í4ï |¿Eý%åKê"ê�-^��Ëå�û��oä�âjþÔåg$��oý4ü�âmä�ë$�âjã(�oý°�Ýû�âmþÔåbâ+*,�Ôã�$¹ê���-^�<�4å��Cû��oä/ê®üjåKâ`�Ýû^ê üjüjã ò ý-£å*ý�âmü¹ãMü�üjþ�:�,ýVãMý� ëÔü�å�$�âjã(�oý8í4ï�í4ïLðoï

A S���S�� z @ ô U @ x � � � @ � X>ó)Ñ��³W � R yoXW� � @ �ì þÔå�$C�³ãËý ò �4ä&�5�uå*ä;âmãËå�üÜãËý¯�4ãËü�âjäjã�Ôë4âmå/��ü�*´ü�âjå�-£üeãËüÜå�ü&�uå�$�ãhê�����*8ê±�Ôä&���Ëå/-L�2ü�ãËý$�å�âmþÔå�äjå\��´å*üeý� âåKêèãËü;âcê ò �(�5�ê���ü;â¡ê âjåÝï2k�â¡ê�$C�#�Må�âmþÔãMü_�Ôä&�5.�Ëå�- ãËý½âjþÔãËüÜü�å�$Kâmã(�Ýý r*¯-�ê��³ãËý ò ëÔüjå��Ýû¹âmþ4å�â+*<�4ã($¹ê��-��,�Ôå��TãMý³âjä&�,�Ôë$�å��ÜãMý � å�$Kâmã��oý_yèï���â&��äjå&êÝü&�oý6û<ä&�5- âmþ4åEü�êYâmãËü;û{ê�$�âjã(�oý��Ýû�¢Ëú � ¡�¢mh»§%¦sæ>úYù�¡�¢,¼ØúYù|¦Ti<¢7¡6g�ãMýâmþÔåbâmå/-��p�oä�ê�� ò ä�ê��Ôþ�-��,�Ôå/�sãËý�4ë$*å/��r*Àâmþ4å^���ºå�ý°�4ä&�,$*å*ü�ü±ü�å�-�êÝý�âmã�$*ü�ân� ò ���5�ê��sü�ê âmãMü�û{ê�$Kâmã��oý\�Ýûû��oä&-�ë.�hêÝüsãMýbâmþÔå&âjå�-^� �oä�ê�� ò ä�ê��Ôþg-^�<�Ôå/�ÔãËý.�Ôë$*å/��r*�âjþÔå3�ÔãËü;âmä�ã(Ôë4âjå���üjå/-¬ê ý³âjã($�ü�û��Ýämê��4ãËü�âjäjã�Ôë4âmå/�ü�*´ü�âjå�-�ü��ºå/$*ãL}�$¹ê âjã(�oýtïÿÿ���<$&ê��[û��oä&-hë�hê�ãËüqê6âmå/-��p�oä�ê��[û��oä&-�ë.�hê£âjþ�ê âEäjå�û<å�äjü'�oý��*®â&�b�oýÔå��Ôä&�,$*å�üjüãËýÔü;â¡êÝý$�å���ü�ë$1þNâjþ�ê âeâjþÔå�ãËý4û��oä�-¬êYâmã(�Ýý ò ã�mÝå*ýpãËý�âjþÔå��5�ºå�ý �4ä&�,$*å*ü�ü8ü�å�-�êÝý�âmã�$*üK�Ýû�âmþÔãMü_�Ôä&�,$*å�üjüãËýÔü;â¡êÝý$�å�ãËü�üjëWÒ^$�ãËå*ý�â2â&�9$1þÔå�$C�6âmþÔå����<$&ê��Tû��oä&-�ë.�hê4ï�k�$¹ê����uâjþÔåEâmå/-��p�oä�ê�� ò ä�ê��Ôþ)-��,�Ôå��uãËý.�Ôë$*å/�K#*âmþÔå8�5�uå*ý\�4ä&�,$*å*ü�ü�üjå/-¬êÝý�âjã($*ü/ê�æuùmú � §CgCgw¦Óú�l,§%¢èêÝý�Àâmþ4åhâmå/-��p�oä�ê�� ò ä�ê��Ôþ\-^�<�Ôå/�FãMý�Ôë$�å���r*�âjþÔå�ÔãËü;âmäjã�Ôë4âjå��®üjå/-¬êÝý�âjã($*ü2âjþÔå2l��Óg�hHù:�Jý�i�h»§Æl�g��tg�h»§%¦ ¦Óú�l,§%¢#ï

ðØíoí

Page 141: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

A S���S���SxÌ Ô W @ yÕ�´xØxg> @ Z��èó9xbX � Z�Q � x��ÄW � � { �t�´Z�Ö E x����èô > @ Z��´óñ2þÔå'���ºå�ý)�Ôä��<$�å*üjü�üjå/-¬êÝý�âjã($*ü�êÝü���å��(�¤êÝüPâjþÔå'�4ãËü�âjäjã�Ôë4âmå/�6ü�å�-�êÝý�âmã�$*üµêÝäjå ò ã�mÝå*ý^r*£âjä�êÝý4ü�û��oä�-¬ê âjã(�oýü�*´ü�âjå�-£ü�ãËý�Q � W4×"���®\s���Kïsk�ü�þ�:�^þ.��� ê6âjä�êÝý4ü�û��oä�-¬ê âjã(�oý ü�*´ü;âmå�-�ãËý�Q � W4×"���®\s��� ò å*ýÔå�ä�ê âjå*üê ò ä�ê��4þ�âmä�ê ýÔüjãLâmã(�Ýý�ü�*´ü;âmå�- ï�¿s�(��ý�Ýâjã(�oý4üÂêÝý�Àä�å*üjë.�Mâmüv� ûPâmþÔãMü�üjå/$�âmã��oý:êÝä�åhû{êÝãËä���* ãËý.�Ôå��uå*ý�4å*ý�â��ÝûâmþÔå'��êÝä�âjã($�ë�hêÝä ò ä�ê��ÔþÓâjä�êÝýÔü;û��oä&-�ê âjã(�oý�ê���Ôä���ê�$1þ4�èüjãMý$*å�âmþÔå�ä�å*ü�ë�Mâjü^êÝä�å��êÝü�å��_�oýÓâjä�êÝý4ü�û��oä�-¬ê âjã(�oýü�*´ü�âjå�-£ü*ï�TU�Ýä|âmþÔå�û��5���(�:�,ãËý ò $��oý4üjã(�4å*ä�êYâmã(�ÝýÔü��ÔãLâ���´å*ü�ýÙØ â1-�ê âjâjå*ä2þ�:�NâmþÔå�âjä�êÝýÔü;û��oä&-�ê âjã(�oýeü=*èü;âmå/-�^êÝü ò å�ýÔå*ä�ê âmå/��ï¿ âmä�êÝýÔü;û��oä&-�ê âmã��oýçü=*´ü�âmå/- ò å�ýÔå*ä�ê âmå�ü´ê ò ä�ê��Ôþçâjä�êÝýÔü�ãMâjã(�oýDü�*´ü�âjå�- ãMý�Ôë$Kâmã7moå��7*Z#*V-£å¹êÝýÔü)�Ýû6êò ã�mÝå*ýAêÝüjü�ã ò ý.-6å�ý³â�û��Ýä �¥ ãMý�âmþÔå�ãMýÔãMâjãhê���ü�â�ê âmå8�Ýû�âmþ4å�âjä�êÝý4ü�û��oä�-¬ê âjã(�oý�ü�*´ü�âjå�- ïbñ2þÔãËü6êÝü�üjã ò ý-6å�ý�âãËü±âjþÔåÜãMýÔãMâjãhê��sü;â¡ê âjåb�Ýû2âjþÔå ò ä�ê��ÔþVâjä�êÝýÔü�ãMâjã(�oý�ü�*´ü�âjå�- ï�ñ2þÔåeäjå/-¬ê ãËýÔãMý ò ü;â¡ê âjå*ü9� û2âmþÔå ò å*ýÔå�ä�ê âjå��ò ä�ê��4þ®âjä�êÝý4üjãMâjã(�oýeü=*´ü�âmå/- êÝäjå�âmþ4årê üjüjã ò ý-£å*ý�âmü ò å�ýÔå*ä�ê âmå/�Lr*eâjþÔå¹ãËý�Ôë.$�âmã7moå � ú6j�h��'j�i¡�h��(ú6j�� ûFâjþÔåãËýÔãLâmãhê���ü;â¡ê âjå}ê��(�oý ò ê��(�&å/� ò å*üg�Ýû�âmþ4åL$/�oý�âmä&���"o��:� ò ä�ê��ÔþG�Ýû�âmþÔåeâmä�êÝýÔü;û��oä&-�ê âmã��oýîü�*´ü;âmå�- ï�ñ2þÔå$��oý�âmãMý³ë�ê âmã��oýK�ÝûÀê�ü�â�ê âmå6ê����oý ò êÝý å�� ò å±ãMý®âjþÔå`$��oý�âmä��5�4o��:� ò ä�ê��Ôþ ãËü]êÝý}êÝüjü�ã ò ý.-6å�ý³â,û��oä �¥ âmþ�êYâãËü�$/�5-���ê âmã��Ëå1�,ãMâmþÜâjþÔåv�ÔãMäjå�$Kâ3�Ôå*ä�ã�mbê âjã(�oýÜë4üjå��®ân�bãMý�âmå*ä��ÔäjåKâ2âmþÔå�å/� ò åv�Ýû âjþÔåv$��oý�âjä&�5�fo��� ò ä�ê��ÔþãËý®âmþÔå�û��5�(�����,ãMý ò üjå�ýÔüjå ö3] åKâ �� � � �uå±âjþÔåw�ÔãMäjå/$�â'�Ôå*ä�ã�mbê âmã��oýeû��oä�ãËý�âmå�ä&�Ôä�å�âmãMý ò âjþÔå�å�� ò å��ÝûsâjþÔå$��oý�âmä��5�Ho��� ò ä�ê��Ôþ�ê ý�C�¨ ö �¥iA �� ºå¯êÜü�â¡êYâmå�ãMý ���ïvk � ú6j�h��'j�i�§,âmþÔå�ü;â¡ê âjåc�¨ ê��(�Ýý ò âmþ4å9�ÔãËä�å�$Kâ�Ôå*ä�ã�mbê âmã��oý �� � � Á#*|êÓü;â¡ê âjå �ªhö �¥²A � ��tü�ë$1þÀâmþ�êYâ)�¨ êÝý� �ª/ê ò ä�å*å9�Ýý�ê��(� å/�Ëå�-£å*ý�âjü�âmþ�ê âÂêÝä�å�Ôäjå�üjå*ä=moå/�Óû<ä&�5- ���ân� � �ï � ý�7*bå��Må�-£å*ý�âmü��Ýû ���âmþ�ê â�ê äjå3�Ôå��Må�âjå��)r*bâjþÔå3�ÔãËä�å�$�âl�Ôå�äjã7m<êYâmã(�Ýý8-¬êu*8uåû��oä ò � âjâmå�ýÓû<ä&��-��¨ ân� �ª]êÝý�_�Ýý��*�âmþ.�oüjå�å/�Ëå/-6å�ý³âjü|âmþ�ê â³êÝä�åEýÔå%��ãMý � Q-�ê:*�uå�ëÔüjå/�eân��å�êèâjå*ý�eâjþÔåü�â¡êYâmå �ª��,ãMâjþ6ä�å*ü&�uå�$Kâ|â&�6�¨ ïP¦�ëÔå,ân�¹âmþ4å,û{ê�$�âu��âjþ�ê âl�|å1-¬êu*bþ�ê:mÝå¾ê�$1þ�oã�$*å2û��oäPâmþÔå�åKê´âjå*ýÔü�ã(�oý��ÝûtâjþÔåü�â¡êYâmå �ª�ãMý®âjþÔå�$¹êÝü�å��Ýû�üjå/mÝå*ä�ê�� ýÔå/�3�7* ò å*ý4å*ä�êYâmå�� å��Må�-£å*ý�âmü/�>üjå%moå*ä�ê�� ü�â�ê âmå�ü �ª�û��oä&âmþÔåv$/�oý�âmãMý´ë�ê âmã��oýêÝäjåv�p�oüjü�ã(�Må�û��oä��oýÔå ò ã7moå�ýL�ÔãMäjå/$�â3�Ôå�äjã�mbê âjã(�oýdê ý�L�ÝýÔå¹ü�â¡êYâmå_�¨ ïQ�� R �@� � � @ � A S��[S�ÌÚÌ Bjy @ � � �x��{ XW� � @ � @ D�x��ÄXW���èx�FX ã7moå*ýpê�âmä�êÝýÔü;û��oä&-�ê âmã��oý£ü�*´ü�âjå�- §NæÛnxÜ��gW ¨ Y�ãMýÜQ � W6×��J� \'�����,ãMâjþÝÜ`�]æÛn��gWCÞ�W1¨+Wàß.áEßxâ�Y�ïi] åK⨠� ¸ �,ö ¨ ��£.��A ¨ ��¹v��ºå�âjþÔå��ÔãËü;âmäjã�Ôë4âjå��6-��oä��ÔþÔãMü&- û��Ýä ¸ ör££A ¹! ��`º êÝý�Z�¨ ö �¥¬A ¨ ��£<�"ºårêü�â¡êYâmå��ºâmþÔå � ú6j�h��'j�i.¡�hx�(ú6jÊú%¼)�¨ ú6j ¸ ãËü ò ã7moå�ý\#*8âmþÔåw�hêÝä ò å*ü;â�üjåKâ�Ü)���¨ W ¸ �1�Ýû�ü;â¡ê âjå*ü �ª�ö �¥iA ¨ �J¹��üjë$1þ âmþ�ê â ¨ � ¸ � ã9�¨;ä �ª�û��Ýä2å¹ê�$1þ �ªs ÀÜ��|�¨ W ¸ �Kï �¾s¿[X>ô U ó �xA S�{ Bjy @ � � ����{ XW� � @ � @ D�x��ÄXW�t�´x�FTCã ò ë4äjå^yèï�²eüjþ�:�,ü¹âmþÔåg$��Ýý³âjãËý³ë�ê âjã(�oý��Ýû�âmþ4å£ü;â¡ê âjå°�¨ ê��(�Ýý ò âmþÔåg�ÔãMäjå�$Kâ��Ôå*ä�ã�mbê âjã(�oý�û<ä��5- �� ân� � %ïñ2þÔå��Ôå�äjã�mbê âjã(�oý��Ôå��Må�âjå*üCâjþÔå|å�ý³âjãËä�å&ä&�oë4ý��ýÔåKâ+�"�oä>�hý�,�Ôå|û<ä��5- ��vê ý�±êÝý�å/�Ëå/-6å�ý³âCû<ä&�5-Gâmþ4å|üj¡³ë�ê äjåýÔå�â+���oäÆ�%ý�,�ÔåÝï8ñ2þÔåb�Ôå�äjã7m<êYâmã(�Ýý�$�äjå¹êYâmå*ü¯ê�ýÔå/� ä��oëÔý�»ý4å�â+���oäÆ��ý�<�4åÓãËý �  âjþ�ê â9$/�oý�â¡êÝãMýÔü±â+���ýÔå/� å/�Ëå/-6å�ý³âjü*ï£ñ2þÔåbâ+�"�8ü�â�ê âmå�ü �ª*�/ê ý� �ª1�rêÝäjåbâ+���c�p�oüjü�ã(�Må8$��oý�âjãËý³ë�ê âjã(�oýÔüv� ûw�¨ ü�ãËý$�åg��å£þ�êumoå

X

a

X

a

G G H

b b^1 2

H

TCã ò ëÔäjåvyèï�²èö��Ù½�§ � ú6j�hx�'j�i.¡�hx�(ú6j%ú%¼g�¨ ¡�¢Ëú6j´� ��åhÎú � ±ßâ+�"�9�p�oü�üjã(4ã(�ËãLâmãMå*üsân�¯êÝüjü�ã ò ý£âmþÔå'�oýÔå�å/�Ëå�-£å*ý�â��Ýû�âjþÔå�ä&�ÝëÔý�ÜýÔåKâ+�"�ÝäÆ�£ý�<�4åEãËý �¥�ân��âmþÔå�â+�"�bý4å/�3��*ò å*ýÔå�ä�ê âjå���å��Må�-£å*ý�âmüPãMýhâmþ4å2ä&�oëÔý.�býÔå�â+���oäÆ�hý�<�4å��Ýû � VïCñ2þ4ãËüPãËü�� �oü�üjã��Ëå��ÝüjãMý$*å&âjþÔå³êÝü�üjã ò ý-6å�ý�â��Ýû

ðØí��

Page 142: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

âmþÔå&å/�Ëå/-6å�ý³âsãËýhâjþÔå&ä&�ÝëÔý�býÔåKâ+�"�oä>��ý�,�Ôå&ãMý �¥�ãËüFëÔý�ÔåK}>ýÔå��£ãËýc�¨ êÝý.��âmþÔå°ê üjüjã ò ý-£å*ý�â��ÝûTå/�Ëå/-6å�ý³âjüãËý �¥ �oý%ýÔå/�3�7* ò å�ýÔå*ä�ê âmå/���5 � å�$�âjü±ãMü�ý�Ýâ¹ä�å*ü�âjäjã�$�âmå/��ïbñ2þÔå�êÝü�üjã ò ý-6å�ý�â��Ýû�âjþÔåbâ+�"� å��Må�-£å*ý�âmü�ãMýâmþÔåbü�¡´ë�êÝäjå�ýÔåKâ+�"�oä>�Àý�,�ÔåbãËý �¥ ãMü ò ã�mÝå*ý�r*C�¨ ïhñ2þÔå�ü�â�ê âmå �ª�þ�êÝü�â&�6$/�oãËý.$*ã(�4å9�oýÀâmþÔå8�4äjå*ü�å*ä=moå��å��Ëå/-6å�ý�âmü¾ê ý��þ�ê ü�ân��ºå�ëÔý�4å�}>ýÔå/���oý8âjþÔåw�Ôå/�ËåKâmå��8å��Må�-£å*ý�âmü�ï�ñ2þÔå�äjåKû��oäjå�� �ª*�]êÝý� �ª1��þ�êumoå±â&�)uåëÔý�ÔåK}>ýÔå��L�oý®âmþÔå�üjå�å��Ëå/-6å�ý�âmü��Ôâ&�<�4ï �ñ2þÔå ò å*ýÔå�ä�ê âjå�� ò ä�ê��4þ âjä�êÝýÔü�ãMâjã(�oýeü=*èü;âmå/-nû��oä]êbâjä�êÝý4ü�û��oä�-¬ê âjã(�oýeü=*´ü�âmå/-üêÝý�}êÝý ãËýÔãLâmãhê��ºü;â¡ê âjå�þ�êÝüêÝü�ü�â¡êYâmå*übâjþÔåL$/�oý�âmãMý´ë�ê âmã��oýÔü8�Ýû�âmþÔå®ãMýÔãMâjãhê���ü�â�ê âmåcê����oý ò âmþÔåK��êYâmþÔü�ãËýîâjþÔåK$��oý�âmä��5��o��:� ò ä�ê��Ôþ�ïñ2þÔå*ä�åEåKêèãMü�âmüµê�âjä�êÝý4üjãMâjã(�oýguå�â+��å*å�ýÓâ+�"�hü�â¡êYâmå*ü�ãMûf�oýÔå�ü�â�ê âmå�ãËüPâmþ4å'$/�oý�âmãËý³ë�êYâmã(�Ýý��ÝûºâmþÔå1�ÝâjþÔå*äl�oýÔå ïñ2þÔå¹üjå�â3� ûFä�ëÔýÔü]êÝä�åEû��oä&-£å��_r*dê��(�ºâjþÔåv�p�oüjü�ã(�Må���ê âjþÔü&âmþÔä��oë ò þeâjþÔå�âmä�êÝýÔüjãLâmã��oýÜäjå/�hê âjã(�oýtï � ãMý$*åvkäjå*¡³ëÔãMäjå¹ãËýè}>ýÔãMâjå���ê âjþÔü��Uk�åKê´âmå�ý�8}ÔýÔãMâjå`��ê âmþÔü3r*eãMý4}>ýÔãLâmå��7*Óä�å��uå¹ê âjãËý ò âjþÔå��hêÝü;â,ü�â¡êYâmåÝïQ�� R �@� � � @ � A S��[S�Ì´� B��Ú� � �´WzXW���èZ½�TWzX U ���ÄWzX � x � � � @ � x%E x��t�´ôZF] åKâ&§NæÛn.Ü`�gW ¨ YluåÂê�âjä�êÝýÔü;û��oä&-�ê âjã(�oý6ü�*´ü�âjå�- ãMýÜQ � W6×"��� \'�����,ãLâmþÐÜ`�GæÛn��gWCÞ�W1¨+Wàßxáæßxâ�YµêÝý��¨�ç ö �¥ è ¨ � ß.áEßxâ��`uåpê ý êÝü�üjã ò ý-6å�ý�â±ãMý�âjþÔå6ãMýÔãMâjãhê��Fü�â�ê âmå��Ýû&§±ïeñ2þÔåe�Ýù�¡%æ�½Êh9ù&¡�jWg��'h��(ú6jyg��,g�h+§%¦�,§�jf§Kù&¡�h+§Ælbý���§GãMü ò ã�mÝå*ý6#*6��\w�9§��PæÛn0éæ]eW:è�]�WCêÃ]fY/�.�,þÔå�äjåëéæ]�ãËü��ÔåK}>ýÔå/��ãËý.�Ôë$�âjã�mÝå���*uö~ �¨Çç ìéæ]

~ ãMû��¨ ö �¥íè ¨ �J£<�s ~éæ])ê ý��âmþÔå�äjå�ãMü¾êÝýÀå/� ò å ¸ ö�£Ðè ¹� ��`º»âjþÔå*ý �ª±ö �¥íè ¨ �J¹v�s ~éæ]û��oä2å¹ê�$1þ �ªs ìÜ��|�¨ W ¸ ��ï

ñ2þÔå�âmä�ê ýÔüjãLâmã(�Ýýeäjå��_ê âmã��oý�è�]�d�éæ]�¥ìéæ]x$/�oý�â¡êÝãMýÔü³ê8��êÝãMä��|�¨ W �ª/���,ãMâjþG�¨ ö �¥îè ¨ �J£<�^êÝý� �ªEö �¥Áè¨ ��¹v�FãLûzêÝý�^�oý��*±ãMûTâjþÔå*ä�å�ãMümêÝý�å�� ò å ¸ ör£Tè ¹½ãËý^��ºcêÝý� �ª� ÀÜ��|�¨ W ¸ �KïFñ2þÔå,üjåKâDêï]ÜãËüsâjþÔå,üjëWÒbê��$��(�Ýüjå�� üjåKâ1�Ýûuê��(�f��ê âmþÔü,âmþ4ä&�oë ò þAè�]��.�,þÔå�äjå��|å�äjå/��hê�$*å�å¹ê�$1þ8}>ýÔãLâmåv��êYâmþñð�æÿ��ð���òr�Îð��Ið���ó�ó�óvð�� á����#*ÓâmþÔå¹ãËýè}>ýÔãMâjåv��ê âjþôð8æ2� ð��xòr�%ð��;ð:��ó�óVóõð���á4�Îð�� á��%ð���á4��ó�óVó��Kï �� ãËý$�å�âmþÔå��5�uå*ý��Ôä��<$�å*ü�ü ü�å�-�êÝý�âmã�$*ücêÝý��âmþ4å\�ÔãËü;âmäjã�Ôë4âjå��püjå/-¬êÝý�âjã($*ü_� û¯ê��ÔãMü�âmä�ã(Ôëèâmå��pü=*èü;âmå/-ü&�uå�$*ãL}�$¹êYâmã(�Ýýrê äjåPâmä�êÝýÔü�û��Ýä&-�ê âmã��oý�ü�*´ü�âjå�-£ü����|ål$¹êÝý ò å�ýÔå*ä�ê âmå ò ä�ê��Ôþ¹âmä�ê ýÔüjãLâmã(�Ýý�ü�*´ü�âjå�-£ü*ï � ãMý$*åPâjþÔåãËýÔãLâmãhê���ü�â¡êYâmå��Ýûuå¹ê�$1þ^���ºå�ý^�4ä&�,$*å*ü�üPüjå/-¬êÝý�âjã($*üPë4üjå��bû��oäFâmþÔå�$/�5-��p�oü�ãMâmã��oýhãMüFâjþÔå2å�-^�4â+*9�4ãËü�âjäjã�Ôë4âmå/�ò ä�ê��4þ4�¼ê��Ëü&�ÀâjþÔå®ãËýÔãLâmãhê���ü;â¡ê âjå6� û�âjþÔåK�ÔãËü;âmäjã�Ôë4âjå���ü�*´ü�âjå�-lüjå/-¬ê ý³âjã($�ü£ãMübâmþÔå®å�-^�4â+*��4ãËü�âjäjã�Ôë4âmå/�ò ä�ê��4þ�ïPñ2þÔå*ä�å�û��oä�å��4âjþÔå��oý.��*£ãËýÔãLâmã_ê��èêÝüjü�ã ò ý.-6å�ý³â�û��oä �¥`ãMýÓâmþ4å�ãËýÔãLâmã_ê��Ôü�â�ê âmå�ãMü^ê±â&�Ýâ¡ê��(��*�ë4ý�Ôå�}ÔýÔå��êÝüjü�ã ò ý-£å*ý�â*ïQ�� R �@� � � @ � A S��[S�Ì,� BjZ � x��ÄW � � { �t�´ZDx/E[x��t�´ô ô @ Z��èó%ö U W @ yÕ�´xØx£ô @ Z��èójF] åKâ�÷Ðé3�x÷ÐéÏø��'uå�âmþÔå8�ÔãMü�âjäjã(4ë4âmå/�%ü�å�-�êÝý�âmã�$*ü�û��oä/ê_�ÔãMü�âmä�ã(Ôëèâmå���ü=*èü;âmå/-¬ü&�uå�$*ãL}�$¹êYâmã(�Ýýì÷ÐéÏø æ��� \'�gWCùÏù�W:ú � �`�,ãMâjþ{ùÏù^æÁ�xùÏù3�.û.�%WnI�á4´p�xû�&�%ü 9 Ã.R bxý:þ ê ü8�Ôå�}>ý4å��ÊãËýʦ�åK}>ýÔãMâjã(�oý��Ôï�í4ï$��å|êÝý��IDöÿ è ©�gîª�¬.� �¥°��uå¬êÝý%ãËý�âjå*ä&�4äjå�â�ê âmã��oý�ï£ñ2þÔå*ýf�Fâmþ4å"l��Óg�h9ù:�Jý�ikh+§Ælñg��,g�h+§%¦«¦Óú�l,§%¢ºãMü ò ã�mÝå*ýar*ÀâjþÔåâmå�-^�p�oä�ê�� ò ä�ê��4þ -^�<�4å��s©�g æ n��¹\w�x÷Ýé1��÷ÐéÏøw���%WnI<Y/���,þ4å*äjåa�¹\w��÷Ðé3�x÷ÐéÏø��&�6ãMüÜâmþÔå ò ä�ê��Ôþâmä�ê ýÔüjãLâmã(�Ýýeü�*´ü�âjå�- ò å�ýÔå*ä�ê âmå/�cr*�÷Ðé3�x÷Ýé<ø��¼êÝý.����ö �¥ è �6��ßxáæß�â��2ãMü&âmþÔå¹å/-��4â+*´êÝüjü�ã ò ý-£å*ý�â*ïñ2þÔå6æuùmú � §CgCgK¦Óú�l,§%¢�û��oä£âjþÔå6�Ôä&�,$*å�üjüÓãMýÔü�â�êÝý$�åôßxü û��oä�ß_ ÿI�áf´ �xû�%�Bû· ø¹\ z��U¸ ���®\'�w�|�|ãËübâjþÔåâmå�-^�p�oä�ê�� ò ä�ê��Ôþx-^�<�4å���g ��¼�������æ5n��¹\w��é3��¼����%���%WnI<Y/�U�,þÔå*ä�åg�¹\w��é3��¼����/�&�,ãËü�âmþÔå ò ä�ê��Ôþ�âjä�êÝý��üjãMâjã(�oý�ü�*´ü�âjå�- ò å�ýÔå*ä�ê âmå/��#*8âmþÔåw�5�ºå�ý��Ôä&�,$*å�üjü�üjå/-¬ê ý³âjã($�ü��é3��¼������£ê ý��âmþÔåbå/-��èâ+*�êÝü�üjã ò ý-6å�ý�â�£ö �¥Áè ¨ ������ßxáæß�â ���:�Kï �k�üjþ�:� ýÔå�êèâ��Câmþ�ê âhå&ê�$1þîäjë4ýVãËý%âmþÔå��ÔãËü;âmä�ã(Ôë4âjå���ü�*´ü�âjå�-�-��,�Ôå���$&êÝý±uå��Ôä�� � å�$Kâmå/���oý ê�ä�ëÔýVãMýâmþÔå9�4ä&�,$*å*ü�ü�-^�<�Ôå/�Ëü�ïEñ2þÔãMü�ãËü'�êÝüjå/�\�oý�âjþÔå9�ÔåK}>ýÔãMâjã(�oýL�ÝûPâmþ4å9$��5-^�p�oüjãLâmã(�ÝýL�ÝûPâjþÔå9�5�uå*ýc�Ôä&�,$*å�üjüüjå�-�êÝý�âmã�$*üCâ&��âmþÔå"�ÔãËü;âmäjã�Ôë4âjå��büjå/-¬ê ý³âjã($�ü����,þÔå�äjå2âmþ4å��ÔãËü;âmä�ã(Ôë4âjå��bü�å�-�êÝý�âmã($�üsãËü/�oä&�Ýë ò þ�7*±ü��ºå&ê��³ãËý ò ��oý��*´ê£ä�å*ü�âjäjã�$�âmå/�c��ê ä�â1�ÝûCâjþÔå�ëÔýÔã(�Ýý6� ûCâmþ4å��5�uå*ýL�Ôä&�,$*å�üjü�üjå/-¬êÝý�âjã($*ü�üjë.$1þ�âmþ�êYâ�âjþÔå�äjëÔýÔü1$¹ê ýLuå$��oýÔü;âmä�ë$�âjå��cr*eâjþÔå¹äjå*ü�ë�MâjãËý ò ãMý$��MëÔüjã��oýÔü�ï

ðØíry

Page 143: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

Ô W @ U @ x � � � @ � A S���S�Ì�v B U W @�� �´y�� � @ � @ D�W { � x�F�sÍÄÌB÷Ðé3�x÷ÐéÏø���æ n.Ü`�»]HW ¨ YbÒ4ÍÓÌHÕºÍbÛ³ÉMÖØÌ9ÆjÉÎÒè×ÔÌIÍ�Û�Ö�Í1ÞÓÇ ÈuÌHÉ<Ú1ÖbÙPÉ0Ì9Õ�ÆKÍ1Ö(ÏPÍ�Úz̹Ì%�ÜÇ8Û³ÉMÖØÌHÆ�ÉÎÒ4×4ÌIÍ*Û8ÖÎõÔÖ&MÌIÍ1Þ¬Ö(ÏPÍ�Ú1ÉM÷ºÚKÇ4Ì9É��zÈI÷ÐéÏø@æ³�J� \'�gWCùÏù�W:ú � �bÙPÉ0Ì9Õ�ùÏù�æ³�xùÏù3�xû�%W&I�áf´p�.û���Îü 9 Ã.R b.ý:þ ÐH©�g Ò4ÍeÌ9ÕºÍÛ³ÉËÖ*ÌHÆjÉ0Ò4×ÔÌÎÍ*Û ÖIõ4Ö*ÌIÍ1Þ¬ÞÐ�´ÛÔÍ1Ñ +.�zÆ ÷Ðé3��÷ÐéÏøw��ǠȺÛ8g ��¼����/�bÒ4Í£ÌHÕºÍ�ϺÆ��´Ú*Í1Ö�Ö¹Þ��´ÛÔÍ1Ñ@+.�zÆ ß' ZI�áf´ �xû�1ÐûV �ø¹\ z��U¸ ßVá ÕºÍ1ȺÐ)+.�ÄÆ�Í�dzÚ;ÕîÆØ×ÝÈ�ðçÉËÈ°©�g ÙPÉ0Ì9Õyð���òr��ö �¥ è ¨ ��ßxáæß�â��6ÌHÕuÍ1ÆKÍbÉËÖhÇ8ÆØ×ÝÈ�ð�� � ÉMÈg ��¼����/� ß �ø|ùmúÄú%¼X ã7moå*ý|ê6ä�ëÔýAð�æ � ð��xòr�%ð��;ð:��ó�óVó��,ãMý6©�g �,ãMâjþAð����<�,ö �¥ è ¨ � ¨�� Á � Â��2û��Ýä��K �k ���ï2ñ2þÔå*ý4�U��åw�ÔåK}>ýÔåâmþÔå¹üjå�¡³ëÔå*ý$�åëð�� � æ ��ð�� � �xòr�%ð�� � �Ið���ó�ó�óõ�|û��oäBß� xI�á4´p�xû�%W:ûb Àø�\ z���¸ r*

ð�� � ���,��æ ������� � ���! �"� � � ¨ � Á �  ��� ò � ãBð��#�,�%W�,þÔå*ä�å$�L ±k ��`�%� ���¹æ5n&� (' "��� W�� � � � � Y�ö��é3�0¼������Fè ÷Ðé3�x÷ÐéÏø��"�,ãMâmþ)� �' "��� æ5n&� "��� W*� (+��� Y�öÚÜ��»]ìèÜ��»] � � ïñ2þÔålêÝü�üjã ò ý-£å*ý�âmü�ð�� � ���,�bû��oä,� 2k �� êÝäjåK��å��(�3�ÔåK}>ýÔå/�½üjãMý$*åc� ���-� � ��� �"� � � ¨�� Á.� Â�����ãMü�ãËý � å/$�âmã7moåa�J$KûIï¶�ä��5�p�oüjãLâmã(�Ýý\�Ôï�íèï$��H5�Kï8�Vå�ü�þ�:�kâmþ�êYâ ð�� � ãËü6êeäjëÔý%ãËý%g ��¼�� � ��r*ÀãËý�4ë$�âjã(�oý��:moå�ä�âjþÔå��Må*ý ò âmþ��ÝûâmþÔå¹üjå�¡³ëÔå*ý$�åÝïx��ÄXÔWt� @ D ��� Z { y�� � @ � ö�k0û/�bæGò.� ¨ ��ßxáæß�â��^êÝý� ¨ ����� ß.áEßxâ ���:�µêÝäjåEâjþÔå�å�-^�4â+*)�ÔãËü;âmäjã�Ôë4âjå�� ò ä�ê��Ôþ0�g#*

$��oý4ü�âmä�ë$�âjã(�oýtïPñ2þÔå*ä�å�û��oä�å��Úð����5��òr�|ö �¥Áè �Ôï�x� Z { y�� � @ � x��t� U ö¯�VåVüjþ�:� ð���á�} ð��C Ü)� ð���á4�%W ¸ �G� ð����5� á } ð��C îÜ���ð����5��á4�%W*� "��� � ¸ �&��ï

ì �oýÔü�ã(�Ôå�ä�âjþÔåG�Ôãhê ò ä�ê�- ºå/�(�:�²û��Ýä�âmþÔåîû��5���(�:�,ãËý ò $��oýÔü�ã(�Ôå�ä�ê âjã(�oý4ü��9�,þÔå�äjå ¸ æ � �"� � � ¸ �|�¨ � � � Á21  æ3� �"� � � ¨ � Á21  �°êÝý� ¨ � � � Á�154 �H æ3� �"� � � ¨ � Á�154 �H ��ï

¨ � � � ¨ � � � Á�1  � ® � � Á þ � Â67 8888888

88888q�9 � � �;: ®=< � ��>@?BADC �� ¨ � ¨ � : 1 C � ® : þ C

EF GGGGGGGGGGG

¨ � � � ¨ � � � : 1H4/I C � q�9 � � � : ®=< � � >@?BJ ô A#C �� ¨ � ¨�� : 1H4/I C �

�¥� � � : 1H4/I CKL M M M M M M M M M M M� � � : 1 C

NO

� : 1 C

P.QRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR � : 1H4/I CS TUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU

¿s$/$��oä��ÔãËý ò â&�WV�åYX>ýÔãLâmã(�Ýý6yèï�íèïMðoðv��å±þ�ê:mÝå�â&��üjþ�:��âjþ�ê â ¨ � ¸ � ã*ð�� � ��á4� ä ð�� � ��á�}pð��Kö¨ � � � ¸ �<ã�ð�� � ��á4�6æ ¨ � � � ¸ �¾ã`� ���2� � � ¨ � � � : 1 C � ò I)ã»ð���á4�6æð� ���2� � � ¨ � � � : 154/I C � ò I)ã ¨ � ¸ �)ã�ð�� á�� ä� � � � � � ¨ � � � : 154/I C � ò IÙãBð���á2}�ð:�PæGð�������á2}�ð��

|

Z���[ �@� � � @ � A]\ � \ Ì ACB_^a` @!� ��b�� � @ � @ Dc`�d �ae Ff�ý�Ôå�ä�âjþÔå,ý�Ýâ�ê âmã��oýÔü��Ýû]g�ä��5�p�oüjãLâmã(�Ýý^yèï�íèïMðu�.�,kH$¹ê����4âmþ4å�ä�ëÔý2ð�� � æ2��ð�� � �xòr�%ð�� � �;ð��:óVó�óõ�CâjþÔå�æuù1úihu§ � h��(ú6jú%¼Dð�æÿ� ð��xòr�%ð��;ð:��ó�óVó��"�oýkj ��¼�� � �°êÝý�K�Ôå*ý.�Ýâmå�ð�� � r* � ¬l� � ��ð��Kï �m ãËý$�åÓâmþ4åÜüjåKâg�Ýû�äjëÔýÔühãËü�ü�ëWÒbê��j$����oüjå/�8ê ý�ýê��(��äjë4ýÔü>êÝäjå ò å*ýÔå�ä�ê âjå��îû<ä&��-�ä�ëÔýÔü�ü;â¡êÝä;âmãËý ò ê â�âjþÔåãËýÔãLâmãhê��[ü�â¡êYâmå�� k3$¹êÝý ò å*ýÔå�ä�ê��Mãon*å�âmþÔåw�Ôäjå%mèã��oëÔü��4ä&�5�p�oüjãLâmã��oý â&�Üäjë4ýÔü�âmþ�êYâ���Üý.�Ýâ�ýÔå/$*å�üjü�ê äjã(�7*�ü;â¡êÝä;âãËýeâmþÔå¹ãMýÔãMâjãhê��uü�â�ê âmå ï

ðØí5²

Page 144: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

z @ ` @ óHóqp�`:EVA]\ � \ Ì,{�srutWtwv�!yx # x#z�{}|#~�v��o~:����H��rA+.���kv��H��|&���v��Îõ��H���!~ôð�|o��©�j ��|�����ð��xò5��� �¥ è ¨ � ¨�� : ç C �0v��/�¨y� : ç Cc�� ß.áEßxâYx �

ø|ùmúÄú%¼�2þ��l�_�,�*���Ëü_�jü&û��;���&ê�$1þ�ð��Mý)©�j ê�ð �Ëýb©�j ü_�$1þ0�mþ�ê��*ð �xò5� � �¥ è ¨ ��ßxáæß�â��³ê ý�Ðð��Ëü°ê�ü_�WÒ ��Ýû)ð #*c$��oý4ü_�u�_�$¡�B�(�oý°�Ýû¢�mþ!�büB�¡�`�Ýû��B�4ýÔü»êÃ]±�Ýûl©�j �J$Kûi£¤V¥��ûi£ey�£2¦!£�§,�5�*£¨�2þ��g$/�;�&�5���hê��=*®û��5�(�����,ü�mþ���ýL���#�B�/$¡�n�7*Óûq���5-t]¤��-^-�ê�y�£2¦!£�§u�>êÝý.�k�jþ�ê��©�mþ!��ü_�¡�'�Ýû��B�ÔýÔü,þ�ê üª�&�g/�¹üB�kÒ����j$��(�ÝüB���«£ |

A¤\ � \ � \o¬ � @ b;p�­®p �a¯ � ­ @±° p�­ Ö«pW� �e D&p�b�� � @ ��©²��©�B�/-¬ê��#³���¡����´µ�u²!�o¶s¶_��$¡�B�(�;³ �#¶i$���³$l�¡�B³��/�^�ª���u²·�u²!�����B�¡¶B�¡��mbê��u���;³g��´��u²!�©¶�ê��B�o¶_´{ê�$¡�u���;³9��´µ�B��-^� �4���ê��±´��;�&-·�.�hê�¶�#*W�u²��v$/�5-^� �;¶_�#�B�(�;³���´%�u²��v�5�±�l³K�����<$¡�l¶_¶c¶_��-�ê�³��u��$l¶®�&�·�u²��v���#¶_�B�B�(!�!�u�/�¸¶B��-�ê�³��u��$l¶/���£-��£y�u²��º¹��!�l¶_�B�(�;³¸�#¶l�Hk&´a»¼�u�/-��p�;�u»��µ´����&-·��o»,�#¶®¶B»��u�#¶_X��/�½�o³¸»`���&�,$l�¡¶B¶�-^�<�!�����y�#¶¾�B²��¿´��;��-·��D»��u²!�l³¶u»��B�o¶_X����k�o³¸�u²������#¶_�B�B�(!�!�u�/��¶=*�¶=�u�/- -��,�����DÀ�fº³�´��;�_�B��³�»��B����*��!�u²!�o¶©¹y���l¶=�u���;³c$l»�³�³���1±�$»�³�¶=�®�¡�B���� �;¶_�#�B��m;�/��*W�o³0Á;�¡³��l�B»�����»�¶ª�B²���´��5�(���:�ª�o³�Á·�*�!»�-��.�o��¶B².���ª¶¡£¾s¿¤p�Â}^�­ �xA]\ & B e pk� ��e D&p�b�� � @ ���e�� @ �Ã^�`,� e �y`:íE� ¯ ° EÄb @ Â}^ @ e�� � � @ � F�©²���Á;�B»���²�¶)� I »�³�¯�$Åw�#³CTÆ�#Á;���B�cy�£�å�¶_²�»��(�3±�L��»���»}¶=��»��B�l¶���´¥�u²!�c�5�±�l³C�!�&�,$l�l¶_¶w¶_��-W»�³��u�($¡¶�é3��¼ I �ª»�³�Ç�é3��¼µÅ|��´��;�1���&�,$l�¡¶B¶¥�#³�¶_�u»�³$¡�l¶'¼ I »�³�L¼µÅ:�±�B�¡¶&�±��$¡�B��m�����*�£Ã¿'$¡�u��»��(�7*5�U��»��u»W¶_�u»��u�¡¶¥»��_����o¶=�u�B����!�B���0Á;�u»���²�¶ª�o³¸�u²!�o¶3$�²�»��!�B�l�/�p!�!�ª�n�g$��;³!¶B�(�!�l�3�;³�7*w�u²!�l�o�ª³��Y�+�"���Æ�¸Á;�B»���²�¶ª�o¶©¶_�WÒ^$l�#�l³��¿�#³�;�&���¡���&�w$��o»��B��´0*·�u²!�s�����5�o�/-�£sÈ"���u²WÁ;�u»���²�¶�»��B�s$/�5-^� �;¶_���w�&�¼�B²��¿Á;�B»���²)�^���u²�»����o¶�»w��»���»¼¶=��»��B���´��B²������o¶=�u�_�(��!�B���0¶B�/-w»�³y�B�($¡¶l£�]¤�¡� ð�/�,» ¶_�u»��u����´a�u²!�`�!�o¶_�B�B����!�u�/�0¶�*�¶_�B��- -^�<���/�f©�jÉ£�k¾²�»um;�¶B²�:�ª³��o³k�u²��¨X�Á;���B�w�;³��*k���u¶c³��¡�+���;�Æ��Á;�u»���²x-^�;�&��²!�o¶&-6�µ�u²�»��¿�o¶'���¡X�³!���)´��;�1 ���B²xp�5���¡¶��o³c¥Ê£�©²��¨¶=��»��B�l¶Ãð I »�³�Að�Å¿¶B²�:�Ë�u²!��������Ì_��$Y�u���;³c��´_ða�;³��n�)� I �B�¡¶&�]£ �,Å5£®�©²��/*�»��B�`���YX�³����c�;³��*¸´����

G 2

X

σ

G1

dom( )σ2

σ2

dom( )σ1

σ1

G

T��oÁ;���_��y�£�å��©Í ¡�hx�Óg ¼/¡ � h���Î6j"�Óg»j«Î�Ï$Ïn§qÐ3§ � h»§Æl_ý�� � Î�¦sæ�Îtg��'hx��Î6jpß�;³���¶B¹y��»��B�,³�<�!�v�������n� �u²!�,¶=�u�_�$¡�B���B�`��´�� I �B�¡¶&�]£p�$ÅH£�k&´����,»�¶B¶_�-Ã�¼»·�B��-^� �;�B»��/´����&-·��o»¨�u²�»��´��;�&���� �u²��1�<$/$l���_�B�¡³$l�1��´¤»v�ª²����u�c»�³�w»`�o»�$C�·¶_¹���»��B�º³�<�!�º»��¾�B²��c¶u»�-Ã�©�u�(-Ã�����u²��c¶_�u»��u�¡¶¾ð I »�³�ð�Å�¶B»��u�#¶_´0*,�u²��©´��;��-·��D»�£@�1�:�®�%m;�l�/���B²��©¶_�u»��u�BðK��´µ�u²!�1$/�5-^� �;¶_�#�B�(�;³�����¡¶�³���¢¶B»��u�#¶_´0*¨�B²��o¶�´��;�&-·�.�D».�¶B�o³.$l�W»6�ª²����u�W»�³�Ñ»6�D»�$C�)¶B¹y��»��_�w³�,���^�<$/$l���¼�o³��ã¸�©²��¡�B�Y´��;�B���s¶u»��B�o¶=´»�$¡�B�(�;³���´��B²��o¶�´��;��-·��o»�o³Ç�u²!�8���&�,$l�¡¶B¶�-��,���/�o¶�����l¶�³.�����(-^��7*�¶B»��u�#¶_´»�$Y�u���;³\��´¢�u²��·´����&-·��o»w�o³Ç�B²��8���#¶_�u�_�(����u����¶=*�¶=�u�/--��,������£Hñ¿�($l��m��l�_¶u».��¶B»��u�#¶_´»�$Y�u�(��³b��´�»¨´��;�&-¨��D»¨�#³½�u²��v�!�o¶_�B�B����!�u�/�¸¶�*�¶_�B��-t-^�,�����/�o¶�³���ª�B�/o���$¡�B���

§H¦rå

Page 145: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

�o³Ç�u²!�8���&�,$l�¡¶B¶`-��,�����#¶l£�T��;�¥�Y�!»�-^��#���]�u²!�·´��;�&-·�.�D»W�B²�»��$�B�¡¹y���o�_�l¶,»_�D»�$C��»�³��»)�ª²����u� ¶B¹y��»��B�³�<�!�,�#¶©¶u»��B�o¶=X����k�o³¸�u²!�`�!�o¶_�B�B����!�u�/�0¶�*�¶_�B��- -^�<���/���<��!�c��³�¶B»��u�#¶_X��/���o³½�B²������&�,$l�¡¶B¶1-��,���/�o¶l£{��©²��)�Y�!»�-^��o��²�»�¶¸¶_²�:�ª³Ò�B²�»��¸¶B»��u�#¶_´»�$Y�u���;³Ä�#¶½³���)���B�¡¶B�l�=m;�/�Ó�o³ÄÁ;�l³��¡�u»���£·k&´��®�)�_�l¶_�B�B��$¡�½�B²���u��-^�p�;�u»��%´��;��-·��D»�¶¿�n�¸¶��4�+$l»��(�#���±¢oÎ � ¡�¢�¼HÎ�Ï%¦Ti,¢7¡6g%�]²�:���/m��l���e���^$l»�³)�l³!¶B���_���B²�»���´��;�¿�H»�$�²��B�!³��#³�u²��_���#¶_�B�B�(!�!�u�/�ʶ�*�¶_�B��- -^�<�!�����B²��l�_�¸�o¶ »x�!�&��Ì_�/$¡�u���;³��;³�»x�����<$¡�l¶B¶8-^�,������¶B�$�²Ô�u²�»��·�u²��¸�_��³¶u»��B�o¶_X��l¶,»b�(�,$H»��a´��;�&-¨��D»w�#³Ç�u²��g���#¶_�B�B�(!�!�u�/�)¶�*�¶_�B��-î-^�<���/�s�#´¾»�³���;³��*��#´¢�u²!�8�(�,$H»��a´��;�&-·�.�D»w�#¶¶u»��B�o¶_X����w�#³W�B²��'�!�&�,$l�l¶_¶"-^�<�!����£@¿ ���<$l»���´��;��-·��D»��#¶®»��u�/-��p�;�u»���´��;�&-·�.�D».�;�B²�»����B�¡´q�¡�B¶��;³��* �&����³�����&�,$l�¡¶B¶c�o³�¶=��»�³$¡��£Z���[ �@� � � @ � A]\ � \ ÌW& BB­ @ b;p�­Ï�t��Â}^ @ `�p�­"D @ `�Â�d�­qp F¿Õ�B��-^� �;�B»���´��;�&-¨��D»kÖs���ª²��¡�B�w�B²��)�!�&�5�p�;¶B���u���;³�»���m�»��_�D»�.�o�l¶ ×�Ø I W�óVó�ó7WuØ 1 �)Ù ÿ �,$�$¡�������o¶¼»�¢oÎ � ¡�¢h»§%¦sæ�Î�Ï�¡�¢Õ¼HÎ�Ï|¦Ti<¢7¡���´Æ�+*,�±��¼� Êø�Ú z��U¸ �ª�#�B²��_�l¶&�±��$Y�¿�&�Ã�B²��¼�#³��u�l�����B�Y��»��B�(�;³KI0� ÿ è ©�jîª�¬.� �¥���#´«´������l»�$�²Ýß � §Õó�ó�óvák�u²��cÁ;�u»���²��($l»��U$��;³!¶_�u�B»��o³���I �Ø¡�0��� �¥îè �\��«¶B»��u�#¶_X��¡¶��u²!�º´��5���(�:�ª�o³�Áv$/�;³�����u���;³�¶l�

Û �u²��¡�B�$�o¶���³��,»�³�6�;³��*)�;³��������<$¡�l¶B¶ª³�,����£b \´#ª�µ°�JI �ØY�����%�Û �u²��������<$¡�l¶_¶º³�,���v£½�#¶���´a�+*<�±�v¼)»�³.�Û I �Ø¡�0����£.�®�#¶��u²����;³.��*b�!�&�,$l�l¶_¶º³.�<���$�#³ô\��

»�³�·´��;�_ß � §ÕóVó�óõá��;�u²!�©³�<�!��£) x¥Ü�#¶Æ�u²!�©¶u»�-Ã��£��}��$l»��(�,£,�B²���æ±ÏuÎ � §CgCgFj«Î�l,§ºÎ%¼Bh ½�§�¢oÎ � ¡�¢�¼HÎ�Ï|¦Ti<¢7¡�£�

¾s¿¤p�Â}^�­ �xA]\ U BB­ @ b;p�­<�t��Â}^ @ `�p�­�D @ `�Â�d�­qp FTÆ�oÁ;�!�B�8y�£��)�!�&�:m��(���¡¶¿�+�"�0�*��»�-���#�l¶���´¢Á;�u»��!²k� �#³y�B�l�����B�Y�u���Ç�B��-^� ���u»��%´��;�&-¨��D»�¶¡£¿�©²��8�!�o¶_�B�B����!�u�/�Á;�u»��!² �¥Ý´��;�s�B²��ºÁ��u»���²!�($H»��<m�»��B�o»��#�l¶��o¶�¶_²�:�ª³½»��¢�B²��©�n�5�^��´±�u²��©X�Á;�!�B��£�k&��$/�;³�¶_�o¶_�B¶���´]»$³��¡�+���;�>�³�<�!�L��´º�+*,�/�Aê¥Þß»�³.�[�;³��6��´º�+*<�±�"ø`ª�¬6âÎê¥Þ��"p���u²Z$��;³��u»��o³��#³�Áà»°��,$l�.-W�¡³y�l£��©²��0�u��-^�p�;�u»��´��;�&-·�.�D»�¶�»��B�®¶B²�:�ª³g/�/�(�:�$£iT��;�a�u²��®�o³��u�¡�&���_�¡��»��u�(��³w��´��B²������&��� �;¶_�#�B�(�;³�»��5m�»��B�D»��o�¡¶�k����³���s¶B².����u²����¡³y�B�o�_��»�¶B¶_�oÁ;³.-W�¡³y�®´��;� �¥��<��!�3�;³�7*w���u¶�$��4�j��5-W»��o³����o¶=�u�B����!�B���¸Á;�B»���²�¶¡£¾�©²!�$»�¶B¶_�oÁ;³-Ã�l³���´�����¥ã$l»�³L±�$�B�/$��;³�¶=�u�_�$¡�B����´q���5-á�u²!�o¶ª�B�/���B�¡¶B�l³��u»��u���;³Lr*¸�B²��¼�#³���*�k»��ª�u²�����,$l�.-W�¡³y�B¶l�lk&´Æ�B²��l�_�¼�#¶»)´¸»��º»��.�<$¡�-W�¡³��¥�o³�»��!�o¶_�B�B����!�u�/��Á;�B»���²L��´s�u²!�,´��;��-·��o».���u²��¨»�¶B¶_�oÁ;³.-W�¡³y�'-W»���¶©�u²��¼�B�%m��#¶B���;³»��&$�²��7m;�©»�³�·�u²��"��<$¡�-Ã�l³�����´ �¥â�&�¥�u²��¡¶B�����Ì_��$Y�u¶l£Ï¿º³�»����;Á5�;��¶���*����u²!�©»�¶B¶_�oÁ;³.-W�¡³y����´��u²!�Bø�ª�¬,âÎê¥Þ³�<�!��»�³� ���u¶H��<$¡�-Ã�l³��s�#¶Æ�o³.���($l»��u�/�9r*¼�B²�� � �&�o³���*�/£Æ�©²��®X��B¶_�sÁ;�u»��!²k� �#³y�B�l�����B�Y�u���¼´��;�&-·�.�D»º�#¶Æ³���»b�(�,$H»��%´��;�&-¨��D».�/¶B�#³$l�·�B²��9$��6�+��5-W»��#³ÇÁ;�u»���²\��´¢�u²�� ¶_��$/�;³��»�¶B¶_�oÁ;³.-W�¡³y�$�_�¡´q�¡�B¶¥�n�½�+���0�B�%m��#¶B���;³»��&$�²��7m;�¡¶l£ã�©²!�)¶u»��B�o¶_´»�$¡�u���;³C��´��B²��o¶W´��;�&-·�.�D»�$l»�³��;³�7*[±�x$�²��/$C����� r*Ò»}Á5���5�»��3m��o�/�ð�;³ä�B²�����o¶=�u�B����!�B���k¶�*�¶_�B��-k£®�©²��`�(�:���l�ª´��;�&-·�.�D»·�o¶c»8�(�,$H»��«´��;�&-¨��D».�!¶B�o³.$l�,�#�3$���³y�u»��o³!¶1��³��*_��³������&�,$l�¡¶B¶³�<�!�Ã�#³)�u²��^$��4�j��5-W»��o³)Á��u»���²!¶$´����$�B²��û�¶B¶_�oÁ;³.-W�¡³y�B¶l£W�©²������<$l»���´����&-·��o»¸�o¶v��´��+*<�±�2ê¥ÞÕ¶_�o³$¡��u²���$����B�B�¡¶&�p�;³���#³�Ág���&�,$l�¡¶B¶c³�,���$�o³¸�u²��,»�¶_¶B�#Á;³-Ã�l³��ª²�»�¶©�u²!�o¶��+*,�/��£

�TU���©�H»�$�²��B��³k�o³¸�u²!�`�!�o¶_�B�B����!�u�/�0¶�*�¶_�B��-û-��,���/�«�u²��¡�B�,�o¶ª»g���&��Ì_��$¡�B�(�;³K�;³�»g���&�,$l�¡¶B¶1-��,�����«¶B�$�²�u²�»����u²��¿�B��³¸¶B»��u�#¶_X��¡¶ª»w�(�,$H»��µ´��;��-·��D»,�o³Ã�u²��v���#¶_�B�B�(!�!�u�/�½¶�*�¶_�B��-½-��,�����/�#´%»�³�_�;³�7*W��´¤�u²��s�(�,$H»��´��;�&-·�.�D»·�o¶©¶B»��u�#¶_X��/���#³½�u²��������<$¡�l¶_¶'-^�<�!����£?¨å � @ `,�� A¤\ � \ Ì�U B_^a`6� e �y`:í�pk� � @ � @ D e pW� ��e D�p�b�� � @ � F�sr5�¾÷Ýé<ø � ���0Ú'�^WCùÏù�WCú,æ,�$��r$v½��|o~H��B|&�!���ir¡�¸~ ç�~l�irutè~�é�r¡ê�|#ë/êYv!�|����Çv��/�0Öì��r�vÃ� ��ê*v��Ù+.���_t¸���Dv�,+©��ç;é�r�û\ �ø$Ú z��U¸�í ©�j � n���Úw�x÷Ðé3�x÷Ýé<ø��&�|WnI<Y$��r ���/r¼�y|o~l���B|&�!��� rl�0~ ç�~l�irutßtÐ����ru��+.��� ÷ÐéÏøv��/�Êî

éö���/rWr�t0�!rl����|o�!ï��Yr��Dv!��| ���Ñ��r�ë!�/rl��|#�~!yx # x !yxàða�/ru� í +.��� rYvyê=�}�H���yðñ|o�°©�j ���±r��Yr·|o~¨v

ß.ü� xI�á4´p�.û.�®~H��ê=�}���µv!� � ¬l������ðe�¿ò�ºó : ��� C Ö�|V+�v��/�ñ������ç¸|Ó+�ðÔò�¿ô ó Ö¥x �§H¦Õ�

Page 146: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

RA PortRA

RA PortRA RA

A global formula

A local formula of type RA

RA

d d

d

PortRARA

p

X

RA

d d

T��oÁ;���_�`y�£v�!�»Ë�¢oÎ�ý�¡�¢e¡�jml�¢oÎ � ¡�¢Õ¼HÎ�Ï|¦Ti,¢7¡6g�ß

õ®ÏuÎ5Î%¼]%�Y��£K �¥ã/�,�u²������&�,$l�¡¶B¶¥³.�<������´s�B²��w���<$l»��]�u�/-��p�;�u»��%´����&-·��o»ÃÖ3»�³�"ð � ��ð���òr�Îð��=§��:óVó�óõ���ª�#�B²ð��#�,� � n � � : � C Wn���Dö%Yc� �¥îè �\ � : � C »��B��³��o³K©�jÉ£®�©²��¡³4�p$�²�<��¶B��ß.üw \I�áf´ �xû���o³k¶B�$�²Ç»g�®»u*5�±¶B�$�²�u²�»�� � � : � C �J£<���o¶��!�¡X�³��/����´Æ»�³�L��³��*w�#´ � ý�÷ � � : � C : � C �J£<�®�#¶����¡X�³!����´����ª»��(���� xk �ø$£k&´ � � : � C �J£<�ª�o¶¿�!³���¡X�³�����´��;�¥»��(�/�c �k �ø��]�H»�$�²Êßxüg ±I�á4´p�.û�1$H»�³\±�9$�²�;¶_�l³]£�k&´ � � : � C �J£<�º�o¶'���¡X�³����´��;�¥»����o�H»�¶_����³��$�c �k �ø��Ùßxü^ �I�áf´ �xû�º�#¶¿��³��#¹y�����7*c���Y�u�¡�&-Ã�o³��/�4�]¶B�#³$l�¼�u²��9�!�&�,$l�l¶_¶$³�<�!� � � : � C ��£<�$��5-Ã�l¶ª´q�&�5-Ý»Ã��³��#¹��!�w�����<$¡�l¶B¶º�o³�¶=��»�³.$l�ëßxü�£cùL���B���:m��l���f#*6���YX�³����u�(��³L��´Æ�u²���$��;³��u�#³y��»��u���;³k²�5�(�!¶�u²�»����ª²!�l³��%m;�l� � � : � C ��£.��»�³� � � : � � C �J£<��»��B�����YX�³��/���u²!�l³ � � : � C ��£.� � � � : � � C �J£<�Y£k&´ � � : � C ��£<� �#¶W�!³���¡X�³����Ä´����w»������ ÿk �øâ�u²��¡³�ð �ò �¿ô ó Ö½r*Z���YX�³��#�B�(�;³Z��´º�u²��k¶u»��B�o¶=´»�$¡�B�(�;³Z��´Á;�u»��!²k� �#³y�B�l�����B�Y�u�����u��-^�p�;�u»��¤´��;��-·��o»�¶l£ m �#³$l��� � ý�÷ � � : � C : � C ��£.�©�o¶c�u²��¡³Ç��³�!�¡X�³��/�)´��;�¿»��(�±�L �k �ø�»�¶�®�/�(���<�®�$Á;�Y� � ¬l� � ��ðe� �ò �ºó : u � � C Ö¿£]%�Y����¶�»�¶B¶B�.-W� ³�:�ú» �c �k �øã¶B�$�²)�B²�»�� � � : � C �J£<�c�#¶����YX�³����«£`�à�·¶B².�����u²!�9$��o»��(-ûr*��#³���$Y�u���;³��m��l�ª�u²��$¶=�u�B�.$¡�u�!�B����´a�u²����(�,$H»��«´��;�&-¨��D» Ö¿£e �5p�`t� @ D ����¯ dab�� � @ �¢û Ø8 ÿ

� �Ó� � ¬l� � � ðe��ò�ºó : u � � C Ø$ü I �Ø��Æîéö �¬¡� � � ðe����òr�sü �¥Ãý :(þ C Ù �¥ ý�÷ � � : � C : ç C »�³�k�B²��l�_�¼�#¶c»��&����»�����o¶=�u�_�(��!�B���K-^�;�&��²!�o¶&- �� ¶B�$�²k�u²�»��©�B²������D»�Á;�u»�-³�=§��"±�����:�X$/�5-�-¨�!�u�¡¶l£�¥Wý :2þ Cÿ��

�� � � � � �� � � � � � �

�� �\µý :(þ Cé���¥ �¥ ý�÷ � � : � C : ç C� �

�����

: I C�� �\ ý*÷ � � : � C : ç C

é���� ���¥ � : ç C��

�� : ŠC

�� �\ � : ç CÈ�*K���YX�³��#�B�(�;³6��´ � ¬l� � ��ðe�|�U���¨²�»:m�� �¥ ý�÷ � � : � C : ç C Ù �¥ � : ç C »�³�Ç» �n���u»��e���o¶=�u�_�(��!�B���6-����&��²��#¶&-�� ��� Á5����#*W�u²���$/�5-��p�;¶_�#�u���;³)��´a�B²��v�5�±�l³K�����<$¡�l¶B¶ª¶_��-W»�³��u�($¡¶��n�·�B²��v���o¶=�u�_�(��!�B���¸¶_��-W»�³��u�($¡¶

§H¦ÕH

Page 147: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

¶B�$�²Ç�B²�»��c�u²��w���D»�Á��u»�-«�x�5��$��5-^-·�!�B�l¶l£1k&��$l»�³x±�¨�l»�¶B����*K$�²��/$C�������u²�»��sI �qØ5�sîéö

ð���òr�%�±��£-��£ðÊò�¿ô ó Ö¿£� � �<ðÜò�¿ô ó ÖÝü I �Ø��cî

éöð��xòr�wü �¥Ãý :2þ C Ù �¥ � : ç C »�³.�ñ�u²!�l�B���o¶W»��&����»��1�!�o¶_�B�B����!�u�/�-����&��²��#¶&- � ¶_�$�²��B²�»��ª�u²������o»�Á;�B»�-³�¦r�"±���(�:�X$��5-^-·�!�B�l¶l£

�¥Wý :2þ Cÿ ��� � � � � �� � � � � ��

�� �\µý :(þ Cé���¥ �¥ � : ç C����

: � C�� �\ � : ç C

�¥ ý�÷ � � : � C : ç C�`� ���

�� :�� C

�� �\ ý*÷ � � : � C : ç Cé� � � �� �

È�*_���YX�³����u�(��³_��´ � ¬l� � ��ðe��»�³.��g����5� ��¶B�#�B�(�;³_�!£2¦!£���H¨´��5���(�:�ª¶ �¥Ãý :(þ C Ù �¥ ý�÷ � � : � C : ç C »�³.�0�B²�»��©�B²�����o¶=�u�_�(��!�B���Z-����&��²��#¶&- �� ò I��� ã\� �o¶g�®�/�(� �+���YX�³����Ä»�³���n���u»���£ñ�©²��c$/�5-�-¨�!��»��B��m��#�+*±��´¿�B²���B�¡¶B����u�o³!Á8���D»�Á��u»�-ö®´��5���(�:�ª¶®´q�&��-á�u²������YX�³����u�(��³_��´��B²���-����&��²��#¶&-öl£�x�a¯ dab�� � @ �Äe �t�y^��ß� � ¬¡� � � ðe�¿ò�¿ó : u � � C �¢ÖÔü � ¬l� � � ðe� �ò �¿ó : u � � C ÖÔü ð �ò �¿ô ó Ö�ü ðÔò�¿ô ó �¢Ö�x�a¯ dab�� � @ �Äe �t�y^�Èß� � ¬l� � � ðe�kò� ó : u � � C Ö I ÈÑÖ®Å�ü � ¬l� � ��ðe�kò� ó : u � � C Ö I »�³� � ¬l� � ��ð��0ò� ó : u � � CÖ®Å�ü ðÊò�¿ô ó Ö I »�³.�ôðÊò�¿ô ó ֮žü ðÊò�¥ô ó Ö I È�Ö®Å5£�x�a¯ dab�� � @ �Äe �t�y^�É � � ¬l������ðe�ºò� ó : u � � C É�Ö�ü � ¬l������ð���ò I ò � ó : u � � C Ö�ü ð�ò I ò �¥ô ó Ö�ü ð�ò�¿ô ó

É�Ö¿£�x�a¯ dab�� � @ �Äe �t�y^�� � � ¬l� � ��ð��¥ò� ó : u � � C �·ÖÔü �;�) ck �ø ó � ¬l� � � ðe��ò � ò � ó : u � � C ÖÔü �;�� xk �ø�óvð®ò � ò �¿ô óÖ�ü ð�ò�¿ô ó �·Ö¿£

|�H��$�²���$C��»ÃÁ5���5�»����!�&�5�±�l�=�+*��#³Ç»g���o¶=�u�_�(��!�B����¶�*�¶_�B��-è�o¶º»������5�o�/- �����,�n�W�B²��`�D»�$C�_��´�»WÁ5���5�»��¶_��»��u��£ªV¥�!�¼�n�Ã�©²��/��£4y�£2¦!£�§t���u²��,¶u»��B�o¶=´»�$¡�B�(�;³6��´¢»g�(�,$H»��]´����&-·��o»Ã�#³k�B²��`���o¶=�u�B����!�B����¶=*�¶_�u�/-ð$l»�³/��$�²!��$C���/�c���<$l»��(�7* �o³¸»����&�,$l�¡¶B¶�-^�<���/��£��©²����(���l»¨�o¶�³�:� �&�9���7m������¥»·Á��(�5�»��µ´����&-·��o»¼�#³¸»¨¶B�Y�3��´�(�,$H»��±´��;�&-·�.�D»�¶/�$�²���$C�½�B²����(�,$H»��/´��;�&-·�.�D»�¶��#³¸�u²��������<$¡�l¶B¶1-^�<���/�o¶©»�³�k�B²����+*,���($l»���-��,���/�4$�²���$C�y¶�ª²��¡�B²��l�ª�u²��,¶u»��u�o¶=´»�$¡�B�(�;³K��´a�u²!�����<$l»��«´��;��-·��D»�¶��o³0�u²��������<$¡�l¶_¶s-^�<���/�o¶©��-���#�o�¡¶��u²!�¼¶B»��u�#¶_´»�$Y�u�(��³��´��B²��$Á5�(���»��/´����&-·��o»·�o³¸�u²!�`�!�o¶_�B�B����!�u�/�0¶�*�¶_�B��- -^�<���/��£?¨å � @ `,�� A¤\ � \ Ì�� BÎ�|E¤^ � b;p�­¾Â @ ¯ ��­ � Â}^Æ­ � � e�� ­ @µ° p�­ e pW� ��e D�p�b�� � @ � F� |./�r��½v·��|o~H��B|&�!���ir¡�·~ ç!~H�irut ~�é�r¡ê�|#ë/êYv!�|����2÷ÐéÏø � ���kÚ'�gWCùÏù�W:ú$æ,�¡xÏ�Ær��l��Ö � � �C9�� �!rªv»+v�tW|#��ç2�,+����êYv��?+.�5�Bt¸���Dv�~D�,+���ç;é�rBû � Àø�Ú z��U¸�í Ö3�!r�vÃ� r�t¼éÏ�5��v��?+.�5�Bt¸���Dv í ©�j ��r¿���±rº�y|#~H��B| �����ir¡�·~ ç�~l�irutt�����r��æ+.��� ÷ÐéÏø v��/�½jQR � nÚ�� ÂÄ ��I<�%WnI<Y$��r¨��/r ��ç;é«|qêYv��¤tÐ����r�� +.���,��/rº|o�±�iru�&é«�*r��&v���|��5�6I¸� ÿ è©�jîª�¬.� �¥\�¡x��Å+ +.���©rYv�ê=� �) � í ò � ó : u � C Ö � +.���©rYvyê=�Ðß� xI�áf´ �xû � ��v��/�)ò� ó"! �$# �:9%� Ö � è Ö��º���±r��ò �¿ô ó Ö¥x �õ®ÏuÎ5Î%¼]%�Y�<ðL±�ª»��B��³Ã�o³9©�jã�y�B²��l³ � ¬l�+��ðe�Æ�#¶�»��B��³Ã�o³·�B²��3���'&,$l�¡¶B¶l-(&,���/�!j ��¼��0�Æ´)&;�s�H»�$�²2ß� \I�á4´p�.û � �*£È�*\���_��-Ã�o¶B���]´)&;���H»�$�²Ç�� ���� � ¬l�»� ðe�Ãò� ó : u � C Ö � ´)&;��»����_ß� [I�áf´ �xû � �*£�È�*)�©²��*&�£�y�£�¦!£�§t�½´)&5�(�+&��ª¶ðäò�¿ô ó Ö � ´)&;�c�H»�$�²½�6 ,�s£�k&´�ò� ó"! �$# �C9�� Ö � è Ö��©�B²��l³Äò�¿ô ó �-# �:9%� Ö � è Ö��c»�$�$*&;�&���#³�ÁW�'&. &;�'&0/+/D»��=*_y�£$��£�²!£¢È�*b���¡X�³!�#�u�+&;³1&�´�¶u»��B�o¶=´»�$¡�B�2&;³"&�´a�u�/-��3&;�u»4//´)&;��-·�5/D»�¶�´)&0/2/+&��ª¶DðÔò�¿ô ó Ö¿£ |

§��Çò

Page 148: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

6 7 8:9 ;=<?> @

A BDCFEHGIBKJ L MONQP

�©²��o¶�R�²�»TS!�u�¡�s�B�*/D»��B�l¶Æ�B²��©»TSUS��'&�»4R�² �o³��u�V&XW��URl�YW �#³¨�u²!�o¶[Z\&;�>�,�'&��Y���o¶=�u�o³!Á¥¶'S±�YR¡�#X]Rl»��u�+&;³¨�u�*R�²�³��#¹��!�l¶´)&;�^W��#¶_�u�_�2_����u�YW)¶a`�¶_�u�*bW¶¡£ �©²��cRY&0bdS�»��_�o¶V&;³Ç�o¶¿Á;���2W!�YWD_e`��u²!�d/#�o¶=�^&�´¾�B�¡¹y���o�_�YbÃ�l³��u¶��f&0»¸¶VS/�*Rl�#Xk�RH»��B�2&;³k�u�YR�²!³��o¹y��� »4/o�B�l»TWU`gbÃ�l³��u�+&;³��YW��o³��B²��¨�#³��u�'&FW��5RY�u�+&;³ih��u²�»��^j©�B�*RH»T/+/�²!�l�B�·»�Á�»��#³]£kjª»TW5W��B²���f&F&0/¤¶B�5SUSl&;�=�mhµ¶B�#³5Rl�¼»�¶'S±�YRl��X]RH»��u�2&�³k�B�YR�²�³��#¹y���¨²�»�¶nbd&;�B�IR�²�»�³5Rl�¡¶¿�f&d_/�¼»TR*Rl�YS��u�YWo&;�©�f&d_/�*RY&0bÃ��o³5W��!¶_�u�_�D»T//�B�*/o�*p�»�³��c�#´rq_�l»�¶V`Ç���f&4�&��¶B�*sÃ�'&X&0/#¶�´)&;���u²!�,¶VS/�*Rl��X]RH»��B�2&;³¸�B�YR�²�³��#¹y���¼�*���o¶_�l£Öæ�5`�dab���d%`�p�­ut e ^Ï��b�� e�û �©²!�l¶B�Ç»�¶'S±�YRY�u¶¸»��_�oR*&;³5Rl�¡�B³��*WvZª�#�B²ñ�u²!�oW��¡¶'Rl�_�2S!�B�2&;³w&�´,»=W!�o¶_�B�B�+_��!�u�*W¶V`�¶_�B�YbñØ�¶¸¶=��»��B��£xj ³yS�»��_�B�2Rl�U/D»��*h®�u²��#¶w�#³5RY/#�5W��l¶W�u²��zR¡���B�_�l³��½�'&0Sl&T/2&;ÁT`,&�´��u²��zW!�o¶_�B�B�+_��!�u�*W

¶V`�¶_�B�Ybgh���£-��£����u¶¸¶_�#�u�¡¶Yh^S!�'&FRl�l¶_¶B�¡¶YhIRY&0bdS3&;³��l³��B¶Yh�»�³UW��B²��l�#�gR*&;³�³��*R¡�B�2&;³]£ �©²��#¶k»�¶'S±�YRY���#¶�Y�XS��_�l¶B¶_�YW{S��_�¡´q�¡�u»T_5/|`ÒÁ;�u»4S�²��2Rl»T/2/|`;£~}�&XRl»T/�¶_�u»��u�¡¶o&�´¨¶B���u�l¶*h�S��'&FRl�¡¶B¶_�l¶Yh,»�³UW�RY&Tb(S3&;³��¡³y�B¶�f&;Á��¡�u²!�l�cZª�#�u²Ô�u²!�l�o���_�Y/D»��u�2&�³�¶Qp��D»�¶B²�»��_�YWwW�»���»)´)&;�Vb �u²��k¶B�*RY&;³UWvS�»��=��&�´¥»HW!�o¶_�B�B�+_��!�u�*W¶_�u»��u��£

� `�p ��e*��� `�ÂàpW� �)�E� p�­\t e ^Ï��b�� e�û ¿OW!�o¶_�B�B�+_��!�u�*W¨¶a`�¶=�u�*bã�o¶�»�³¼�*p0&T/+p��o³�ÁUhTWU`�³�»TbÃ�2R¾¶_�B�B�5RY�u���_��£���pT&4�/o�!�B�2&;³Ã��»����l¶kS5/o»TRl�¥�#³¸�H»TR�²"S�»��_��&�´%�B²���¶V`�¶_�B�Ybk£¢�[&0S3&0/+&;Á;�2Rl»T/µ�B�*RY&;³!X�Á;���u»��u�2&�³ih���£-��£��u²��rRl�B�:�»��u�+&;³�»�³5W��B�*b(&%p�»T/�&�´�¶B���u�¡¶Yh�S��'&FRl�¡¶B¶B�¡¶YhÆ»�³5WHRY&0bdSl&�³��l³��u¶¼»�¶�Z��Y/2/¢»�¶�R*&;³�³��*R¡�B�2&;³HR�²�»�³�Á��l¶»��B�ª»�R¡�B�5R¡�D»T/5S!�'&0S±�l�=��`�&�´/¶V`�¶_�B�Ybö��#³5RY&;�VSl&��u»��B�YW �o³Ã»�³���p0&0/|p��#³�Á$�l³ep��o�V&;³5bÃ�l³��H£�È��l¶B�+W��l¶��B²��³��YR¡�l¶_¶u»��a`ñ¶=��»��B�k�B�u»�³!¶_´)&;�Vbw»��B�2&;³!¶Q&�´¿�B²��"S��'&FRl�¡¶B¶_�l¶½�_�l¶'S«£�/+&XRl»T/�R*&0b(S3&;³��¡³��u¶ �u²��*bW¶_�Y/|p;�l¶*hRY&0bdb·��³!�2RH»��u�2&�³¸»�³5Wk�o³��u�¡�'R*&;³�³��*R¡�u�+&;³�»�¶'S±�YRY�u¶Yh±»�¶ª�_�YS5/#�2RH»��u�2&�³ihUbÃ�oÁ;�B»��u�+&;³ih�»�³5Wk�B�*b(&��u�$�o³k��u�¡�u»TRY�u�2&�³�¶Yh�²�»%p��,�'&c_/�IW��¡¶'Rl�_�2_±�YW�»�¶�Z®�*/2/�£

� � Â}^ �±e�� � �)�m� p�­�t e ^Ï��b�� e�û ¿wW��o¶=�u�_�2_��!�B�YW ¶a`�¶=�u�*b�RY&�³�¶B�#¶_�u¶�&�´µ¶B��p;�l�B»T/��#³y�B�l�B»TR¡�B�o³�Á^R*&0bdSl&;³!�l³��u¶¡£�©²��l�_�¡´)&;�_�Th�»Ç³5&��B�2&;³�&�´º»KRY&Tb(S3&;³��¡³y� »�³5WÊ�u²��¡�o�QR*&0bdSl&;¶_�#�B�2&;³Ñ²�»�¶·�f&K_±�1W��¡X�³��YW��o³Ñ�B²��¶'S±�YR¡�#X]Rl»��u�+&;³��B�YR�²�³��#¹y���·�o³g&;�VW��l�c�f&w¶_�5S5S3&;�_�º�u²���RY&0bdS3&;¶B���u�2&�³g&�´�W��o¶=�u�_�2_��!�B�YWǶa`�¶_�u�*bW¶r_�`�u²��¡�o��R*&0b(S3&;³��¡³��u¶l£

t � p�­�� e��e t e ^Ï��b�� e�û^� ²!�l�B�l»�¶k»�³�»T/|`�¶B�o¶W�u�YR�²!³��o¹y���¡¶k´)&;�w³5&;³k��W��o¶=�u�B�+_��!�B�YW�¶V`�¶=�u�YböYhnS��B�Y´q�l�B»T_5/+`�f&F&0/��&¶B�5SUSl&;�=�u�*Wih�»��_��»T/#�B�H»4WU`¸»·²��#Á;²5/|`�W��¡¶B�#�u»T_5/#�¿´q�H»��u���_�$»�³5W¸´)&XR¡��¶�&�´��B�¡¶B�H»��'R�²k�o³½�u²!��/D»�¶=�W��YRl»TW��¡¶Yh��B²��¸³�»��B���u»4/��o³5R¡�B�l»�¶B�*WwR*&0b(SU/o�Y������`�&�´�W��#¶_�u�_�2_����u�YWÔ¶a`�¶=�u�*bW¶cbW»����0¶B�UR�²�´q�l»��u���_��*p��l³obd&;�_��W��l¶_�o�u»4_5/o���#³0�B²��,»��B�l»�&�´�W!�o¶_�B�B�+_��!�u�*W0¶V`�¶_�B�Yböl£

� �i� ­FÖ]da^a^ � `t� û �©²��¨�f&F&0/a¶B�5SUSl&;�=�¥�#¶rRl�_�5Rl�o»T/%�f&½�u²!�·»TR*Rl�YS���»�³5R¡��»�³5WÇ�B²��·�o³UW���¶_�B�B�o»T/%�B�Y/#�*p�»�³5R¡�&�´Æ»�¶VS/�*Rl��X]RH»��B�2&;³¸�B�YR�²�³��#¹y����£j¿X��B¶=�f/|`=R*&;³�¶_�2W��¡�¼²5&%Z ´»���&;���¼»TS5S!�'&�»TR�²à¶u»��B�o¶=X��l¶,�u²��ô)&0/2/+&�Zª�#³�Ák»�¶'S±�YRY�u¶¨»�³5W W!�o¶'R¡��¶B¶¼�u²��¡³Ñ�B�:�/D»��B�YW½»4S5S��'&;»TR�²��l¶u_�»�¶B�*W1&;³½Á;�B»TS�²w�B�u»�³!¶_´)&;�Vbw»��B�2&;³«£@¿c´ �u�l�aZ�»��'W�¶�j�R*&;³�¶B�+W��l�®»TS5S��V&�»TR�²��¡¶Yh!�B²�»��uW5&³5&��IRY&�³�¶B�+W��l��Á;�B»TS�²)�u�B»�³�¶=´)&;�'bW»��u�+&;³�¶*h«�u²�»��$»��B� �B�YbdSl&;�B»T/�/+&;Á;�+Rl¶YhlS��'&FRl�¡¶B¶¼»T/oÁ��Y_��B»�¶�»�³5WD&0_yÌ_�YR¡�Î�&;�B�#�l³��u�*Wdbd&FW��Y/#�o³�Á¿�B�YR�²�³!�o¹y���l¶*h!�#³�S�»��_�B�2R¡�5/D»��sf¥ùo}�£��©²��ªÁ;�B»TS�² �u�B»�³�¶_´)&��'bW»��u�+&;³�»TS5S��V&�»TR�²��¡¶¾»�³5Wf¥ùo}�»��B��W�»��u»6� ¶=��»��B��W��_�+p;�¡³�»TS5S��V&�»TR�²��¡¶YhiZª²��¡�B�¨�B²��QR¡�l³��u�B»T/�R*&;³5Rl�*S!�$�o¶c�u²���W�»���»W¶_��»��u�·»�³5W)�#�B¶�u�u»�³�¶_´)&;�Vbw»��u�2&�³]£Ô�©²��l¶_�Ç»TS5S!�'&�»TR�²!�l¶½»��B�1Z®�*/2/ª¶B�!�#�u�*Wñ´)&;� �B²��¸�u²��k¶_�B�B�5RY�u���B»T/¿»�³5W��B�u»�³!¶_´)&;�Vbw»6��u�2&�³�»T/�»�¶'S±�YRY�u¶l£·g¢�V&XR¡�l¶_¶¼»4/oÁ;�*_��u»�¶¥»�³5W)�u�*b(S3&;�u»4/�/2&�Á;�2R¡¶¥»��_��S��'&FRl�¡¶B¶Î��W��B�|p;�¡³}»TSUS��'&�»4R�²��l¶IbW»��o³5/|`

§Y��§

Page 149: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

RY&;³5R¡�l�_³��YW Zª���u²��u²��ö'S±�YR¡�#X]Rl»��u�+&;³=&�´��u²��d_±�l²�»mp��2&;�¡£¸V�»��u»¸��`FS±�w¶VS/�*Rl�#X5RH»��B�2&;³�¶¼»��_�W��¶_��»T/+/+`)³5&��¶B�5S5S3&;�=�u�YW�_e`¼�u²���S!�'&FRl�l¶_¶Î��W��B�|p;�l³Ã»TSUS��'&�»4R�²��l¶*heW�»���»º¶_��»��u�l¶¢»��B�aÌ_��¶=�¢»T_�¶=�u�B»TR¡��R*&;³��u�V&0/�¶=��»��B�l¶¡£��©²��S��'&FRl�¡¶B¶Î��W��B�|p;�¡³Ç»TS5S!�'&�»TR�²!�l¶ª´)&XR¡��¶�b(&��B��&;³gRY&0bdS3&;¶B���u�2&�³�»T//»�³5W�»�³�»T/|`�¶_�o¶©»�¶'S±�YR¡�B¶l£

� \ Ì �¨å �z� � �t� � `�pW��� ¯ t½^�^a` � p�b å ����  `�p�^ åy� `�p ��e*��� `�ÂàpW� �)�E� p ��¯ � ��Âà^ � `�p�­\¡ ���m� b�©²��ª»TS5S��V&�»TR�²�&�´µ�B²��o¶�Z\&;�>��RY&TbQ_��o³!�l¶�»¿¶=��»��B����W��B�|p;�l³Ã»TSUS��'&�»4R�²ih;�u²�»����o¶[W��o¶=�u�B�+_��!�B�YW Á;�B»TS�²·�u�B»�³�¶%�´)&;�'bW»��u�+&;³ihµ»�³UWÇ»(S!�'&FRl�l¶_¶Î��W��B�|p;�l³�»4S5S��'&;»TR�²ih/�B²�»��º�o¶ª�u�*b(S3&;�u»4/�/+&;Á;�+R�£��©²��¨�o³��u�¡Á;�u»��B�YW�»TS5S��V&�»TR�²_/�¡³��¡X��B¶c´q�V&0b �B²��,»TWUp�»�³���»�Á;�l¶k&�´a�u²��¡¶B�$��Zu&ö'S±�YR¡�#X]Rl»��u�+&;³0�u�YR�²!³��o¹y���¡¶l£ùg`)»TSUS��'&�»4R�²)�l¶'S±�YR¡�D»T/+/+`�»TW5W!�B�l¶_¶B�¡¶$�B²�� ¶_�B�B�5RY�u���B»T/s»�³5WÇ�u²��·�B�u»�³!¶_´)&;�Vbw»��B�2&;³�»T/a»�¶'S±�YRY�u¶¥�u²�»���»��_��u²��gRY/o»�¶B¶_�2RH»4/�WU&0bw»��o³�¶�&�´c¢£W��#¶_�u�_�2_����u�YW]¤ Á��u»TS�²��u�B»�³�¶_´)&��'bW»��u�+&;³]£��©²����'&0Sl&T/2&;ÁT`Ñ»�³5W��u²��¥/2&FRH»T/¶_��»��u�l¶k&�´Æ»cW��o¶=�u�B�+_��!�B�YW0¶V`�¶_�B�YbÝ»��_�$�Y�XS5/o�+Rl���f/+`(bd&XW��*/o�*W0»�³5W�»��B��bW»�³��+S��5/D»��u�YW¸�_�5/o�:��_�»�¶B�YW«£�©²��(R*&0bdSl&;¶_�#�B�2&;³�»4/s»�¶VS/�*R¡�¼�o¶,»TW5W��_�l¶_¶B�YW}�o³)�u²��#¶�Zu&;�>�K_e`)�u²��Ã�B�¡¶_�u�_�2RY�u�2&�³��'&¥S!�'&FRl�l¶_¶¨�#³�¶_�u»�³5Rl�¡¶»�³5W}�B²��l�#��&0S±�l³�S!�'&FRl�l¶_¶·¶B�*bw»�³y�B�2R¡¶·»�³5Wà�u²��½�_�l¶_�5/#�B¶¼´)&;�,�u²��(RY&0bdSl&�¶B�#�B�2&;³H&�´©�B²���&0S±�l³ S��'&FRl�¡¶B¶¶B�YbW»�³��u�+Rl¶w´)&���S��V&XR¡�l¶B¶_�l¶"_�»�¶_�YWy&;³ä�B²��zR*&0b(S3&;¶_�#�u�+&;³¦&�´��u�B»�³�¶_´)&��'bW»��u�+&;³Ä¶a`�¶=�u�*bW¶1S��V&%p��+W��YW��#³��§I¨n©TªUh §I¨�©0©4��£½�©²��(Z\&;�>��¶_²5&%Zª¶¨�u²�»��¨�B²��(R*&0bQ_��#³�»��B�2&;³H&�´�W��#¶_�B�B�2_!�!�u�*WàÁ;�B»TS�²}�B�u»�³!¶_´)&;�Vbw»��B�2&;³Zª�#�u²,�u�B»�³�¶_´)&��'bW»��u�+&;³¼¶a`�¶_�u�*bW¶Æ�o¶�bW�l»�³��o³!Á�´q�5/-h�¶_�o³5R¡�®�#�Æ»T/+/2&%Zª¶¤�f&r&TS/�¡�u»��B�u&;³5/|`I&;³Q/+&XRl»T/�¶_�u»��u�¡¶Æ�u²�»��RH»�³g_/�IR*&0b(S3&;¶_�YW0�f&W»cW!�o¶_�B�B�+_��!�u�*W�¶a`�¶_�u�*bݶ_��»��u��Zª�#�B²5&;�!�k&0S±�l�B»��u�#³�Á�Zª�#�B²�»�Á0/+&0_�»T/]¶=��»��B��£«j®�!¶B��u²��^_�»�¶B�+RrRY&�³5Rl�*S!�u¶®´)&����u²!�^RY&0bdS3&;¶B���u�2&�³(&�´«�u�u»�³�¶_´)&;�Vbw»��u�2&�³w¶V`�¶=�u�Ybö�S��V&%p��+W��YW¸�#³À�¬§�¨�©0ªUh�§I¨n©0©6��£­n&%Z®��p;�¡�Yh%�#�º�o¶n&;³5/+`�»wX��_¶_��¶=�u�*S]£�§$�V&0®;�:�¯¨ª²5&XW!��S��V&�p��+W��l¶¥�#³{�¬§�¨�©0ªUh�§�¨�©0©4��bd&;�B�¼¶'&0S!²��o¶=�u�2Rl»��u�*WRY&;³5R¡�YS!�B¶c´)&��®�u²��IR*&0b(S3&;¶_�#�u�+&;³ihy�u²�»��c»T/2/+&�Z��'&�¶'S±�YRl��´�`w�B²��IRY&0bdSl&�¶B�#�B�2&;³�»T/l&TS/�¡�u»��B�2&;³�»4//¶_�YbW»�³��u�2R¡¶&�´s»�W��#¶_�B�B�2_!�!�u�*Wk¶a`�¶_�u�*bÝ�*p;�¡³obd&;�B��¶_���#�u»T_5/#��£�©²��IRY&0bQ_!�o³�»��B�2&;³(&�´[W��o¶=�u�B�+_��!�B�YW¸Á;�B»TS�²¸�u�B»�³�¶_´)&��'bW»��u�+&;³(Zª���u²¸�u�*b(S3&;�u»4/l/+&;Á;�2R¿»T/2/+&%Zª¶®�u²���Á��u»TS�²���2RH»4/«»�³UW¸�o³��u�����u�|p;�¿¶VS/�*Rl��X]RH»��B�2&;³�&�´¤�u�*b(S3&;�u»4//¶a`�¶=�u�*b°S��'&TS/�¡�_�u�#�l¶�_e`wÁ;�u»TS!²k� �#³y�B�l�VS��B�Y�u�YWW�u�YbdS3&;�u»T//2&;Á;�+R¼´)&;�Vb·�5/o»�¶l£�jnS��V&%p��+W���»½��`FS��2Rl»T/�bd&XW��*/Æ´)&;��»¸¶_�¡��&�´¾Á;�u»4S�²k� �#³��u�l�VS��B�Y�u�*W�´)&;�Vb·�5/o»�¶º�B²�»��$¶B�USk�Sl&;�=�u¶ª�u²���p;�¡�B�#X5RH»��B�2&;³¥&�´s�u�*b(S3&;�B»T/]´)&;�'b¨�5/D»�¶ª�#³��o³�X�³��#�B�,�B�YbdSl&��u»T/�bd&XW!�Y/o¶¡£k­n&%Z��*p;�¡�Yh«�B²��l�_�·»��_�Á;�u»TS!²k� �#³y�B�l�VS��B�Y�u�YWÃ�u�*b(S3&;�u»4/�´)&;�'b·�U/D»�¶��u²�»���RH»�³�³U&���_±�nR�²!�YRC���*W0�o³��u²��c��`XS!�2RH»4/3bd&FW��Y/µ»�³UW(Zª²��¡�B�»TW5W����u�2&�³�»T/±p��l�B��X]RH»��u�2&�³k�B�YR�²�³��#¹y���l¶¥²�»%p��¼�'&�_±��R*&;³�¶B�+W��l�_�YW]£k­c�l³5R¡�Th±�u²��,��`XS!�2RH»4/�bd&FW��Y/¤�#¶º»�X��B¶=�S��'&0bÃ�o¶_�o³�Áw¶_�u�*S��o³)�u²���»��!�f&0bW»��B�2R�p��l�_�#X]Rl»��u�+&;³K&�´�Á;�u»TS!²k� �#³y�B�l�VS��B�Y�u�YW)´)&;�Vb·�5/o»�¶¿�#³�»"W!�o¶_�B�B�+_��!�u�*W¶V`�¶_�B�Yb²b(&FW��*/�¶'S±�YRl��X��YW(_e`cW��o¶=�u�B�+_��!�B�YW�Á;�u»4S�²Ã�B�u»�³!¶_´)&;�Vbw»��B�2&;³±h0_��!�¾�u²��¡�B�c²�»�¶��f&�_±��WU&;³��ª´q�!�u���_�Zu&;�>�w�f&dS��V&�p��+W���RY&0bdS5/#�¡�u�^p��l�_�#X]Rl»��u�+&;³¸�u�YR�²!³��o¹y���¡¶º´)&;�©Á;�B»TS�²k�&�o³��u�¡�'S��_�¡�B�YW¸´)&;�'b¨�5/D»�¶¡£�©²��©¶u»TbÃ���#¶Æ�u�_���®´)&;�Æ�B²��®�'&X&0/�¶B�US5Sl&��_�H£Æ�©²���RY&0b�_��o³�»��u�2&�³�Zª�#�B²·�u²����u�YbdS3&;�u»T/X/2&;Á��2R�»T/2/+&�Zª¶a�f&���¶_��u²��$�f&F&0/o¶kW���p;�*/2&0S±�YW��o³0�u²��,X��Y/+W¥&�´��u�*b(S3&;�u»4/�/2&;Á;�+RTh5_!�!�º�B²��l�_�¨�#¶�R¡���B�_�l³��f/|`k³5&Ã�'&X&T/�Rl��¶=�f&0bÃ�on¡�YW´)&;��W��#¶_�u�_�2_����u�YW¸Á��u»TS�²½�B�u»�³!¶_´)&;�Vbw»��B�2&;³½»�³5W¸Á;�B»TS�²k�&�o³��u�¡�'S��_�¡�u�*W¸�u�YbdS3&;�u»T/±´)&;�'b¨�5/D»�¶¾�u²�»��©¶B�5SUSl&;�=��u²��kp;�¡�B�#X5RH»��B�2&;³d&�´¤Á;�B»TS�²��+RH»T/+/+`¼¶'S±�YR¡�#X��*W½¶V`�¶_�B�Yb~S��'&TS/�¡�_�u�#�l¶¡£ � �#�B²W�_�l¶'S±�YRY�®�'&¼�f&F&0/#¶Yhy»TS5S!�'&�»TR�²!�l¶/o�Ó���¥�u�*b(S3&;�u»4/±/2&�Á;�2R¡¶�&;�cf¥ùo}}»��B��_±�¡�_�u�l�ª¶_�5S5S3&;�_�B�YWÇ»��©�u²��Ibd&0bW�¡³��H£

� \#¬   `�p�^ åy� `�p ��e*��� `�ÂàpW� �)�E�O³ p eY´�¯ t½^�^a` � p�b å ´�e� \#¬]\ Ì �¼å ´ Z Ô�µ t½^�^a` � p�b åO¶ � Z"· e ¶ `4· ° d ¶ ´�¯v  `�p�^ å¸� `�p]¹ e*��� `�Âàp ¶ · � ¹�©²��·�'&F&��B¶n&�´��B²��¨¶_�o³�ÁT/o��S���¶B²U&;�!��»4S5S��'&;»TR�²Ç�f&(W��o¶=�u�B�+_��!�B�YWÇÁ;�B»TS�²k�u�u»�³�¶_´)&;�Vbw»��u�2&�³¥S��_�l¶_�l³��u�*W��#³�u²��#¶rZu&��'ºz/#�o�¨�#³Ç�u²��QZ\&;�Vºo&�´��Æ»��l³��un¡�l�Yh�Zª²5&"W���p;�*/2&0S±�YW��o³¦».��»��m©0¼¾½�¿TÀ2Á�Â�ÏÃÀJýYÄF¯Å'¿�Æ�Ï'Ç�È]ÉzÂ�ÏVÇTÊUÁ)ËHÎ�ÏÃÌÍ ÇTÂ$À�ξÊ)�#³}�u²���W5&;�5_5/#��Î�S���¶B²U&;�!�"¢V�g�Ï�¤,»TS5S��V&�»TR�²]£Kj ³Ê²!�l��Z\&;�'º�h��u²!�½�2W��l»¥&�´ª�B²��W��Z\&4Î�/o»m`;�l�_�YW¶_�u�_�5R¡�B���B�\&�´!�'&0S3&0/2&;Á4`�»�³5W�/2&FRH»4/�¶_��»��u�l¶a�o¶%�#³y�B�'&FW��5R¡�YWih¾Zª²��l�_�u/2&FRH»4/;¶_�u»��u�¡¶Æ»��_��¶VS/�*Rl��X��YW�_�`�/o»T_/�*/o�*WÁ;�u»TS!²�¶l£s�©²!�nbW»��o³¼´)&XR¡��¶«&�´«²!�l�¾»TS5S��V&�»TR�²Ã�o¶s�'&�S!�'&%p��2W��c»$¶'S±�YRl��X]RH»��u�2&�³��B�YR�²�³!�o¹y���©´)&;�s�u²!��W!�l¶B�#Á;³

§Y��Ð

Page 150: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

S�²�»�¶_��&�´a»QW��o¶=�u�_�2_��!�B�YW½¶a`�¶_�u�*b¥hXZª²��l�_�$»·Á0/2&0_�»T/]p��#�*ZÑRH»�³1_±��»�¶_¶B�5bÃ�YW«£��©²���W��o¶=�u�_�2_��!�B�YW¸¶a`�¶=�u�*b�o¶¢¶'S±�YR¡�#X��*W�_e`ÃÁ0/2&0_�»T/5S��V&XW��UR¡�u�+&;³�¶*hy�B²�»��¾¶'S±�YR¡�#´�`ûT/#¶'&��u²!�º¶a`�³UR�²��'&;³!�onH»��u�2&�³�&�´±/2&FRH»T/5R*&0bdSl&;³!�l³��u¶¡£�©²���&TS/�¡�u»��B�2&;³�»4/¤¶B�YbW»�³��u�+Rl¶c�o¶ªÁ0/+&0_�»T/¤»�¶�Z��Y/+/-h�Á;�|p;�l³¥_e`¸�u²��,¶B�Y�^&�´�W��l�_�+p�»��u�+&;³�¶©��¶_�o³�ÁÃ�u²��,Á0/+&0_�»T/S��'&FW��5RY�u�2&�³�¶l£)V¥�!�w�f&��B²��o¶¼Á0/2&T_�»T/�p��o�*ZIhs�B²��o¶¨»TS5S��V&�»TR�²Ê�#¶¨³5&���Z®�*/2/¾¶B�����u�YWÑ´)&��¨¶B�US5Sl&��_�u�#³�Á��B²���2bdS5/o�*bW�¡³y�u»��u�+&;³�&�´]»�W��#¶_�B�B�2_!�!�u�*Ww¶V`�¶=�u�Ybgh�¶B�o³URl�¥»$Á0/+&0_�»T/5p��o��Z��o³W»IW��o¶=�u�B�+_��!�B�YWw¶a`�¶_�u�*b²W5&��¡¶®³5&���Y���o¶=�H£�[&ÃÁ;�¡�c�_�2W"&�´a�u²��$Á0/+&0_�»T/±p��#�*ZIh��u²!��W5&��5_5/o�ÃÎ�S��!¶B²5&;���¿»4S5S��'&;»TR�²gZ®»�¶c�Y���u�¡³5W��*WÇ�o³=».�kÒ�Ó^Ô�©0©4½¤»�³5W»¬Ò�Ó��k©0ª¾½�_e`zR*&;³5R¡�YS!�B¶$´)&��¿�Y�XS��_�l¶_¶B�o³!Ág/+&XRl»T/o����`0�o³)»ÕW!�o¶_�B�B�+_��!�u�*WǶV`�¶=�u�Ybk£�Öã��`FS/�Q&�´\W!�o¶_�B�B�+_��!�u�*W¶V`�¶_�B�Yb×R*&;³�¶_�o¶_�B�o³�Á(&�´�/+&XRl»T/%¶V`�¶_�B�Ybö^RY&;³!³��YRY�u�YWD_e`��Y�XSl&��_��»�³5WÇ�2bdS3&;�_�c�o³��B�l�_´»4Rl�l¶�Z�»�¶�»�¶B¶_�5bÃ�YW»�³5Wñ»H/+&XRl»T/up��o��Z°&;³Ô�u²��#¶�¶V`�¶_�B�Yb �o¶�W��YX�³��*W]£y}�&XRl»T/up��o��ZØS��V&XW��UR¡�u�+&;³�¶Ã»��_�k�#³��u�'&FW��5R¡�YWih¾�u²�»��RY&;�_�B�l¶VSl&�³5W)�f&w�B²���S��'&FRl�¡¶B¶�S��V&XW!�5R¡�B�2&;³�¶¿�o³��B²��o¶rZ\&;�Vº±£ m `�³5R�²��V&;³��#nH»��B�2&;³oZ®»�¶��*�US!�B�l¶_¶B�*W _e`��B²��»Tbw»4/oÁ�»TbW»��B�2&;³"&�´�S��V&XW��UR¡�u�+&;³�¶¥�_�l¶_�5/#�B�o³�Á0»�Á;»��o³Ç�#³)Á0/2&T_�»T/�S��'&FW��5RY�u�2&�³�¶l£�­n&%Z��*p;�¡�Yh%�u²���S!�'&0_5/#�Yb&�´·»ÔÁ0/+&0_�»T/n&0S/�¡�u»��B�2&;³�»T/¿¶_�YbW»�³��u�2R¡¶1Z�»�¶g/o�Y´ �"&0S±�l³��o³¸_l&��u²yZu&��'ºy¶l£°Ù���¶_��»�¶0�o³Ú».�Æ»��m©0¼4½$h¿�B²��&0S/�¡�u»��B�2&;³�»T/«¶_�YbW»�³��u�2R¡¶º�#¶©Á;�+p��l³g_e`¸�u²���W��l�_�+p�»��B�2&;³¸¶_�l¹y���l³URl�l¶¿��¶B�#³�ÁÃ�B²��,Á0/2&0_�»T/±S��V&XW!�5R¡�B�2&;³�¶ªÁ0&��_�`��B²��w»4bw»T/#Á�»TbW»��u�+&;³]£�Ö~S��'&�Ì_�YR¡�B�2&;³=&�´®�B²��wÁT/2&0_�»4/s¶B�*bw»�³��B�2Rl¶�&;³��u²��(/2&FRH»T/s¶a`�¶_�u�*bW¶�S��'&%p��2W��¡¶�u²��I&0S±�l�B»��u�+&;³�»T//¶B�YbW»�³��u�+Rl¶k&�´a�u²��I/+&XRl»T/«¶a`�¶=�u�*bW¶¡£� �#�u²¸�_�l¶VS/�*R¡�©�f&g».��»��m©0¼¾½]�u²��¥��Z\&ûTS5S��V&�»TR�²��¡¶�»@�kÒ�Ó�Ô^©0©Uh�Ò�Ó��k©0ª4½«Á;�l³��¡�u»T/#�on¡�¿�u²��r/2&FRH»T//¶_��»��u�l¶��'&»��B�B�B�2_!�!�u�*WkÁ��u»TS�²!¶l£¢�©²��o¶ªÁ;�¡³��l�B»T/o�#nH»��B�2&;³w�u»��#¶B�l¶��B²��ISl&%Z��l��&�´a�u²��$¶'S±�YR¡�#X]Rl»��u�+&;³"&�´[/2&FRH»T//¶_��»��u�l¶¡£�©²��^bW»��o³w»TWUp�»�³���»�Á��r&�´¤�B²��¥¶B�#³�Á0/#�rS���¶_²5&;�!�©»TS5S��V&�»TR�²¸�o³(RY&0bdS�»��_�o¶V&;³�Zª�#�B²w�u²!�rW5&;�U_5/o�^S!��¶B²5&��!�»TS5S��V&�»TR�²�»4Û/�YRY�u¶Æ�B²��ª»TS5S5/#�2Rl»��u�+&;³�&�´�S��'&FW��5RY�u�2&�³�¶s»�³UW·�u²���S!�B�l¶_�l�ap�»��u�2&�³�&�´�/2&FRH»T/#�#��`I_3&;��³5W�»��B�#�l¶Æ�#³»cW!�o¶_�B�B�+_��!�u�*W0¶V`�¶_�B�Ybk£�j ³¸�B²��IW5&;�5_5/#��S���¶_²5&;�!�º»TS5S!�'&�»TR�²�» ¶B�Y�n&�´[R*&;³5W����u�+&;³�¶©²�»�¶��'&c_/��R�²��*Rܺ��*W_/�Y´)&;�B�W»¥S��V&XW!�5R¡�B�2&;³HRH»�³ _/�W»TS5S5/#�o�*W]£½��&oR�²��*Rܺà�u²!�l¶B�(RY&;³UW��#�B�2&;³�¶*ha�B²��d_l&;�!³5W�»��_�o�l¶�&�´�/+&XRl»T/o����`²�»mp;�¨�'&Õ_/��Rl�'&�¶B¶B�*Wih]��£���£3Zª²��Y�u²��¡��»�S��V&XW!�5R¡�B�2&;³Ç�#¶¿»4S5S5/o�+RH»T_U/o��&;�¿³5&��¥�o¶c³5&��rW��YR¡�2W�»4_5/o�¼�o³Ç»W�B�H»4/W��o¶=�u�B�+_��!�B�YWÇ�¡³�p��#�'&;³5bÃ�l³��l£ m �o³5R¡�¨�u²!�QRY&;³UW��#�B�2&;³�¶c´)&;�rR�²!�YRܺy�o³�Á¸�B²�� »TS5SU/o�2Rl»��u�+&;³o&�´¾»�S��'&FW��5RY�u�+&;³�o³W�B²��¥¶_�o³�Á0/#�rS��!¶B²5&;���ª»TS5S��V&�»TR�²1Rl»�³Õ_±�¥�B�*W��5Rl�*W"&;�®��p;�l³"&0bÃ�#�_�u�*WW�u²!�¿¶B�#³�Á0/#�rS���¶_²5&;�!�©»TS5S��V&�»TR�²�o¶¸³5&��"&�³5/+`Ä��¶B�Y´q�5/¥´)&;�½�u²!�KW��l¶_�oÁ;³�S�²�»�¶_�Th^_!�!�k»T/o¶V&Ê´)&;�w�u²!���*���YRl���u�2&�³ �#³ »Ê�_�H»T/^W!�o¶_�B�B�+_��!�u�*W�l³ep��o�'&�³5bW�¡³��H£Ör/2/�V�g�Ï�»TS5S��V&�»TR�²��¡¶s�f&^W!�o¶_�B�B�+_��!�u�*W·Á;�B»TS�²¨�B�u»�³�¶=´)&;�'bW»��B�2&;³�bW�¡³��u�2&�³��YW »4_l&%p;��»��B��Z®�*/2/!¶_���#�B�YW¨´)&���u²���W��l¶VRl�B�+S!�u�+&;³z&�´Æ�u²��·¶=��»��B�2Rl»T/a»�¶nZ��Y/+/Æ»�¶c�u²��¼�u�u»�³�¶_´)&;�Vbw»��u�2&�³�»T/¤»�¶VS/�*R¡�B¶l£¥�©²��¼�f&0S3&0/2&�ÁT`"&�´s�B²��W��o¶=�u�B�+_��!�B�YW$¶V`�¶_�B�Yb�»�¶iZ��Y/+/y»�¶�/2&FRH»T/�¶_��»��u�l¶�»��_��RY&;³�¶_�2W��¡�B�*W]£s�©²����u�B»�³�¶=´)&;�'bW»��u�+&;³�&�´X_l&��u²��f&0S3&0/+&;ÁT`»�³5W1/2&FRH»4/±¶=��»��B�l¶��#¶�W��¡¶'Rl�_�2_±�YW¸�#³¸»�³½�#³y�B���#�B�+p��¥»�³5WwÁ;�u»TS!²��2Rl»T/3Z®»m`;£�­n&%Z��*p��l�Yh��B²���»TS5S!�'&�»TR�²!�l¶©»��_�³��l���u²��¡�nR*&0b(S3&;¶_�#�u�+&;³�»T/$h!¶_�o³5R¡�¼�u²!�*`g&0S±�l�u»��u�¼»T/2/�&;³Ç»WÁ0/+&0_�»T/iW!�o¶_�B�B�+_��!�u�*W�¶a`�¶=�u�*b ¶=��»��B�Th±³5&;�º�B²��*`S��'&%p��2W��dp;�¡�B�#X5RH»��B�2&;³�R*&;³5R¡�YS!�B¶l£DÒ]&;�,³5&;³XÎ�W��o¶=�u�B�+_��!�B�YW}Á��u»TS�²à�u�u»�³�¶_´)&;�Vbw»��u�2&�³�¶¼¶_�*p��l�u»4/®�f&F&0/o¶,»��_�Rl���_�B�l³��'/+`1W���p;�*/2&0S±�YW ¢¶_�l�(»¬Ý«Ý«ÓI¨n©T©4½�¤*£�Ò�&���W��o¶=�u�_�2_��!�B�YW0Á;�B»TS�²¸�u�B»�³�¶_´)&��'bW»��u�+&;³ih�» �'&X&T/±_�»�¶_�YW¥&;³Ö�§�§Þ»ßÝ�¨��k©0©4½��#¶¼�+b(SU/o�YbÃ�l³��B�YWÑ»��¼�B²��½�a�YR�²�³��+RH»T/®fº³��|p;�¡�B¶B����` &�´ªÈ®�l�V/o�#³]£��©²!�o¶¼�'&X&T/¾�_�YS��_�l¶_�l³��u¶»�³5&��B²��l�®»TWUp�»�³���»�Á��r&�´¤�B²�� m g�Ï »TS5S��V&�»TR�²w�'&QW��#¶_�u�_�2_����u�YWwÁ;�u»TS!²w�u�B»�³�¶_´)&��'bW»��u�+&;³ih�¶B�#³5Rl�º�u²��#¶¾�'&X&0/�o¶�_�»�¶_�YWg&;³0�u²�� m g�Ïã»TSUS��'&�»4R�²]£

� \#¬]\#¬   `�p�ÂÑÂ}p�` e���� `¸Z"· e ¶ `¾· ° d ¶ ´�¯và � e ¶ ´  eV¥�lÁ�»�³U&à»�³5Wäùg&;³���»�³�»��B�©�o³��B�'&FW��5Rl�*Wñ�#³Ñ»-V$ùoª0á¾½ª»)¶'S±�YR¡�D»T/©Á;�B»TS�²Ô�B��Zª�B���u�o³!Á�´)&��'bW»T/o�#¶'bgh�RH»T/+/o�*WÆ�Ï'Ç Í�Í Ç�ÏfÁ�ËHÎ�Ï�¿TÀ2Á�ÂÏÃÀJýYÄXÂ�Å'¿cÁ�â%Á�Â¯Å Í Á�¢-§$V m ¤Ãh!�f& ¶VS/�*Rl�#´�`ÕW��o¶=�u�B�+_��!�B�YW0¶V`�¶_�B�Yböc»�³5W0�u²��¡�o����p0&0/#�!�u�+&;³Zª�#�u²�¶V`�³5R�²��V&;³��#nH»��B�2&;³��B�l¹y���#�B�*bW�¡³y�B¶l£©�©²���b(&FW��*/�&�´�»(W!�o¶_�B�B�+_��!�u�*W�¶a`�¶=�u�*bãR*&;�B�_�l¶'S3&;³5W!¶º�f&Ã�u²�»��&;³��·Á;�|p;�¡³Ç�o³��B²��o¶�Zu&��'º�h]³�»TbÃ�Y/|`k»½¶V`�¶_�B�YbãRY&;³�¶_�o¶=�u�o³!ÁÕ&�´«RY&�³5Rl���_�B�¡³y�^S��'&FRl�¡¶B¶B�¡¶IRY&0bdb·��³��+RH»��B�o³�Áp��o»(S3&;�_�B¶l£kj ³��B²���§$V m »TSUS��'&�»4R�²ih/Á��u»TS�²!¶¿�B�*S��B�¡¶B�¡³y�¥³5&��^&�³5/+`¸�B²���R¡���B�_�l³���¶_�u»��u��&�´��B²��¨¶a`�¶=�u�*b_��!�¿»T/o¶V&W���u¶ª²��o¶=�f&;�a`;£�j ³�»�ù�g«¨�©0©4½%�u²!�¼²��#¶_�'&;�V`1Z®»�¶¿Á��+p;�¡³��5S�»�³5Wk�u²��¼��¶B��&�´�R*&;³�¶_�B�u»��#³��¿¶V&0/+p��o³!Á

§Y��¦

Page 151: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

�o¶ª�o³��u�V&XW!�5Rl�*W��f&(RY&0S±�IZª�#�u²k�u²��,�B�U/o��bw»��'R�²��o³!Á(S��V&0_5/#�Ybk£�Èu&��B²Ç»TSUS��'&�»4R�²��l¶*h/²5&%Z��*p��l�Yh±RY&;³�¶_�2W��¡�&;³5/+`��B²��¢�f&0S3&0/2&�Á;�2Rl»T/;�*pT&0/o���u�2&�³�&�´!�u²��\W��o¶=�u�B�+_��!�B�YW,¶V`�¶_�B�Ybgh0_��!��W5&¿³5&����B�B�H»����B²��u/+&XRl»T/eW�»��u»º¶_�u»��u�¡¶&�´3S��'&FRl�¡¶B¶B�¡¶¾»�³5WcSl&��_�u¶¡£sg��'&FRl�¡¶B¶_�l¶�»��B�©�_�YS��_�l¶B�¡³��u�YW(_e`·²e`FS/�¡�u»��VRl¶¾»�³5WcS3&;�_�B¶�_e`·³5&FW��l¶¡£ . &;³��u�*���aδq�B�l��S��'&FW��5RY�u�+&;³�¶Yhµ�u²�»��^R*&;�B�_�l¶'S3&;³5WÇ�'&W�B²���S��V&XR¡�l¶_¶^S��'&FW��5RY�u�+&;³�¶r&�´�&;���¿»TS5S��V&�»TR�²ih/�l¹y���2SUS/�*WK_�`¶V`�³5R�²��V&;³��onl»��u�+&;³Ã�B�l¹y���¡¶_�B¶�¶VS/�*Rl�#´�`¨�u²��kS��V&XR¡�l¶B¶�bd&�p��l¶¡£��[&¼»TS5S5/|` »�RY&�³y�B�Y���VÎ�´q�B�¡�nS��V&XW!�5R¡�B�2&;³�Zª�#�B²¶V`�³5R�²��V&;³��onl»��u�+&;³¸�B�¡¹y���o�_�YbÃ�l³��u¶�bÃ�H»�³!¶®�f&�bW»Tº��¥»T/2/±¶B�5R�²gS��V&XR¡�l¶B¶_�l¶ª�*pT&0/+p��¥�u²�»��ª»��B�¿³��YR¡�l¶B¶B»��V`¸�'&¶u»��B�o¶_´�`��u²���¶V`�³5R�²!�'&;³��#nH»��B�2&;³��_�l¹y���o�_�YbÃ�l³��u¶¡£W�©²!�(&0S±�l�B»��u�+&;³�»T/�¶B�*bw»�³��B�2Rl¶$�#¶�Á0/2&0_�»T/s�o³)�B²���¶B�l³!¶B��u²�»��¼�u²��¡�B�¸�#¶·»ÇÁ0/+&0_�»T/¢Á;�B»TS�²�Zª²��¡�B�½�u²!�ÕRY&;³��B�Y���VÎ�´q�B�l�1S!�'&FW��5R¡�B�2&;³!¶ »��B�½»TS5S5/#�o�YW«£Ç�©²��o¶¨�o¶�&�³5/+`Sl&;¶_¶B�+_5/o�,�#´��u²��¡�B�¨�#¶c´)&��º�l»TR�²KRY&;³��B�Y���VÎ�´q�B�l��S��'&FW��5RY�u�+&;³Ç»dbw»��'R�²ih±¶B�5R�²Ç�B²�»��c�u²��¼¶V`�³5R�²��V&;³��onl»��u�+&;³�B�l¹y���¡¶_�B¶¨»��_� ¶u»��B�o¶=X��YW]£¨�©²��l�_�¡´)&;�_�Th¤�u²���&TS/�¡�u»��B�2&;³�»4/ƶB�*bw»�³y�B�2R¡¶��o¶¥³5&��IRY&0bdSl&�¶B�#�B�2&;³�»T/-h±¶B�#³5Rl�·�B²��¶B�YbW»�³��u�+Rl¶ª�o¶©Á��+p;�¡³¸´)&;���u²���Zª²5&T/o�$¶V`�¶_�B�YbÝ»���&;³URl��£�©²��¢�B�YR*&;³!X�Á����u»��B�2&;³�&�´��B²��«W��o¶=�u�_�2_��!�B�YW�¶a`�¶=�u�*bË�o¶]³5&���RY&;³�¶_�2W��¡�B�*W¼�#³d»-V$ùoª0áXh(ù�g�¨�©0©4½��o³¥�B²��¢¶B�l³!¶B��u²�»��¼³��¡�#�u²!�l��S3&;�=�u¶,³5&;��S!�'&FRl�l¶_¶B�¡¶ »��B�(W��Y/#�¡�B�YW]£"j ³¸» . V$ùoªeä¾½®»gp�»��_�D»��B�2&;³D&�´k§,V m �o¶�S��'&0S3&;¶_�YWZª²��2R�²k��¶B�¡¶¿»�bd&;�B��Á��l³��¡�u»T/¤�_�*Zª�B���u�#³�Á�bW�*R�²�»�³��#¶'bÜ»4/2/2&%Zª�#³�Á »T/#¶'& ´)&;�©¶V`�¶=�u�YbÝ�_�YRY&�³!X�Á;���B»��u�+&;³]£Ör/#�'&;Á;�Y�u²��¡�Yh��B²���§,V m »4S5S��'&;»TR�²k»TW5W��_�l¶B¶_�l¶ª�u²��$¶=��»��B�2RH»4/]»�³5W¸�B²��¥�u�B»�³�¶_´)&��'bW»��u�+&;³�»T//»�¶'S±�YRY�u¶�Zª�#�B²�B�l¶VS/�*R¡�c�f& �u²!�,�'&0Sl&T/2&;ÁT`(&�´Æ»dW!�o¶_�B�B�+_��!�u�*W0¶V`�¶_�B�YböYh�_��!��/2&FRH»4/]¶_�u»��u�¡¶n&�´[S��V&XR¡�l¶B¶_�l¶¿»�³5WgSl&;�=�u¶ª»��_�³5&��QR*&;³�¶_�2W��¡�B�YW«£Ç�©²��ÕS��V&XW!�5R¡�B�2&;³�¶¨»��B�w»TS5S5/#�o�*W &;³Ê»kÁ0/2&T_�»T/¢¶_�u»��u�¸»�³5WÊ»��_�w³5&���RY&0bdS3&;¶B���u�2&�³�»T/�o³}�B²��½¶B�¡³�¶B�½�B²�»��¼�u²��½ÁT/2&0_�»4/¾¶=��»��B�½�o¶�RY&0bdS3&;¶B�*WÑ´q�'&0b �u²!�Õ/2&FRH»T/¢¶=��»��B�l¶l£��©²��w¶'S±�YRl��X]RH»��u�2&�³�&�´W��o¶=�u�B�+_��!�B�YW�¶V`�¶_�B�YbÞS��V&0S/�¡�_�B�o�l¶,»�³UW��B²��l�#�^p;�l�_�#X]Rl»��u�+&;³��o¶$³5&��IR*&;³�¶_�2W��¡�B�YW«£W�©²��dRY&TbQ_��o³�»��u�+&;³K&�´�u²��Õ§,V m »TS5S��V&�»TR�² Zª���u²}�B²���R*&;³�¶_�B�u»��#³��·¶'&T/+p��o³�Ák�o¶¨»�³Ñ�#³y�B�l�_�l¶_�B�o³�Á�¶_�B�YSÔ»�³5W}�l³�»T_U/o�l¶,�f&¥bw»Tº����¶B��&�´Æ�B²��¨»4/oÁ0&;�_�#�B²5bW¶�»�³5W��'&X&T/o¶©�o³0�u²!�o¶º»��B�l»!£��©²��¡¶B�·»4/oÁ0&;�_�#�B²5bW¶�»��B��bw»��o³5/|`½��¶_�YW��'&w¶V&0/+p��,�B²��S��'&FW��5RY�u�2&�³gbW»��'R�²��o³�Á�S!�'&0_5/#�YbÞ¢q¶B�¡�¼»4/o¶'&¥»ß¨c�UW]©eá¾½å¤Y£

� \#¬]\+æ µ ^ ´ ¹   `�p�^ åy� `�p]¹ eY��� `�Â}p ¶ · � ¹ à � e ¶ ´  e­º�YRܺ��Y/kS��V&0Sl&�¶B�l¶Ã�o³�»ß­º�*Rm©0ª¾½c»�³!�*ZÜ»4S5S��'&;»TR�²��'&KRY&0bdS3&;¶B���u�2&�³�»T/�b(&FW��Y/#�o³�Áo&�´rR*&;³5R¡���B�_�l³��W»�³5W�B�H»4R¡�u�|p;�¸¶a`�¶=�u�*bW¶*h�Rl»T/2/#�YW ÎÜÈ]Å�Ê�Æ�ÏVÇ�È]É�ÂÏVÇTÊUÁ)ËHÎ�Ï Í ÇT£À�ξÊ�Á�â�Á�Â�Å Í ÁÕ¢-ÏI§ m ¤Y£�j ³Ô�B²��"ÏI§ m »TS5S��V&�»TR�²Á;�u»TS!²à�u�B»�³�¶=´)&;�'bW»��u�+&;³��o¶�b(&FW��*/o�YWH_e`à»�³���Z²/2&F&;¶B��¶B�*bw»�³y�B�2R¡¶l£0�©²��w�+W��H»"&�´��B²���/+&X&�¶B��¶B�*bw»�³FÎ�u�2R¡¶��o¶ �u²�»���&�´¿��³5W��¡�aÎ&¶'S±�YRl��X��YW��u�B»�³�¶_´)&��'bW»��u�+&;³�¶l£��©²��¡¶B�Ƕ_�YbW»�³��u�2R¡¶��o¶Ã»�³Ä�+b(S3&;�=��»�³���R*&;³5Rl�*S!�´)&;�c�B²��QR*&0b(S3&;¶_�#�u�+&;³�»T/ip��l�_�#X]Rl»��u�+&;³o&�´«_±�l²�»%p��+&;�u»T/�S��V&0S±�l�_�B�o�¡¶r&�´¢¶a`�¶=�u�*bW¶¥¶VS/�*Rl��X��YWK_e`k�u�YbdS3&;�u»T//2&;Á;�+R�£��©²��¨�+W��H»c&�´s�B²���/+&X&�¶B�$¶B�*bw»�³��B�2Rl¶c´)&;�c»W¶a`�¶=�u�*b �#¶c�_�*ç��*R¡�B�YW)�o³g&;���º»TS5S!�'&�»TR�²��o³0�u²���&0S±�l³S��'&FRl�¡¶B¶¨¶_�YbW»�³��u�+Rl¶l£1j ³ _l&��B²}»4S5S��'&;»TR�²��l¶*hÆ�u²!�w¶B�*bw»�³y�B�2R¡¶�W��¡¶'R¡�B�2_±�l¶,�u²��(Sl&�¶B¶B�+_5/o����Û«�*R¡�u¶�&�´��B²���l³ep��o�'&�³5bW�¡³��H£s�©²��kbd&;�B���B²��©�l³ep��o�V&;³5bÃ�l³���_/�*RY&0bÃ�l¶�ºy³5&%Zª³Ã�u²���bd&;�B���B²��©¶B�*bw»�³y�B�2R4h;�u²�»��«bÃ�H»�³�¶Sl&;¶_¶B�+_5/o����Û«�*R¡�u¶�&�´a�u²��$�¡³�p��#�'&;³5bÃ�l³��Yh��o¶©�B�¡¶_�B�B�2RY�u�*W]£¢�©²��l�_�¡´)&;�_�Th��u�*b(S3&;�B»T/iS��V&0S/�¡�_�B�o�l¶©¶B»��u�#¶_X��*W��#³»�¶_�o³�ÁT/o��RY&Tb(S3&;³��¡³y�c»��B�,»T/o¶V&�¶u»��B�o¶_X��YWk�o³0»cRY&0bdSl&�¶B�YW"R*&0b(S3&;³��¡³���Zª���u²0�B�¡¶_�B�B�2RY�u�*W¥_±�l²�»mp��2&��l£�©²��¿»4S5S��'&;»TR�²(&�´i­c�YRܺ��*/«�#¶�³5&��¾�l¶VS/�*Rl�D»4/2/+`�W��*p��Y/+&0S/�*WW´)&;��W!�o¶_�B�B�+_��!�u�*W�¶V`�¶_�B�YböYhU_!�!�¢´)&;�s�u²��kp��o��Z�Î_�»�¶B�*W�bd&FW��Y/#�o³�Á\&�´UR*&;³5R¡���B�_�l³���»�³5W$�B�l»TR¡�B�+p;�¢¶a`�¶=�u�*bW¶¡£Æ�©²��¡�B�¡´)&��B�Th�»�³��Y�XS5/#�2R¡�#�¤¶_�YS�»��B»��u�+&;³�_±�¡��Z��l�l³�f&0S3&0/2&�ÁT`,»�³5WQ/+&XRl»T/y¶_�u»��u�¡¶s�o¶�³5&���Á;�|p;�¡³]£Æ�©²���Ï�§ m »TSUS��'&�»4R�² �u»��B²��l�[RY&;³�¶_�2W��¡�B¶s¶_�*p��l�u»4/Up��o�*Zª¶�&;³�»¶'S±�YRl��X]RH»��u�2&�³�&�´µ»º¶V`�¶_�B�Ybì»�³5W·�#�B¶��#³��u�lÁ��u»��B�2&;³$�f&n&;³��®¶a`�¶_�u�*b�bd&XW!�Y/�£%�©²��®¶'S±�YRl��X]RH»��u�2&�³�&�´µ¶a`�¶=�u�*bS��'&0S±�l�=�u�#�l¶®�#¶\S!�'&%p��2W��*W1_�`ÃÁ;�B»TS�²��+RH»T/��B�YbdSl&;�B»T/�´)&;�'b¨�5/D»�¶�»�¶�Z®�*/2/�£Æ�©²��IÏI§ m »TS5S��V&�»TR�²1R*&;³�¶B�+W��l�_¶�u²��1R*&0b(S3&;¶_�#�u�+&;³�»T/�p��l�_�#X]Rl»��u�+&;³�&�´cÁ;�u»4S�²��2Rl»T/¢�u�YbdS3&;�u»T/¾´)&;�'b¨�5/D»�¶¡£ m »��B�o¶_´»4R¡�u�+&;³�&�´©´)&��'b·�5/o»�¶¨�#³&;³���p��o�*ZÑRH»�³¥_±�I/o�#´ �B�YW¸�5S0�f& �B²��$¶u»��B�o¶_´»4R¡�u�+&;³1&�´a�u²���´)&;�Vb·�5/o»·�o³½�u²!�,�#³��u�lÁ��u»��B�YWk¶V`�¶_�B�YbØbd&XW��*/�£fº³!´)&;�=�u��³�»��u�*/+`0h��u²��¡�B�$�Y���o¶=�u¶�Rl���_�B�¡³y�'/+`¸³U&Ã�'&X&0/±´)&;���u²!�o¶ª³��*Z3»TS5S��V&�»TR�²]£

§Y�0�

Page 152: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

� \+æ � ´ Â}^ � `�p�­�¡ ��� ·b e���*b(S3&;�u»4/e}�&;Á;�2R¡¶%»��B�¢��¶_�YW,�f&ª´)&;�'b·�U/D»��B�Æ�u²��¢¶a`�¶=�u�*b��_�l¹y���#�B�YbÃ�l³��B¶��#³¼»�³¨»T_!¶_�u�B»TR¡��Z®»m`;£Æ�a�YbdS3&;�u»T//2&;Á;�+Rl¶c»��_�¼�#³�Á;�¡³��l�B»T/a³5&��º�l¶'S±�YR¡�D»T/+/+`1W!�*p;�*/2&0S±�YW�´)&;�kW��o¶=�u�B�+_��!�B�YW�¶a`�¶_�u�*bW¶¡£º�©²!�*`gS��'&%p��2W!�¼¶VS/�*Rl�D»4/&0S/�¡�u»��'&;�B¶º�f&w´)&;�Vb·�5/o»��u�,¶_�u»��u�*bW�¡³y�B¶�&;³)¶_�u»��u��»�³5W)�*p��l³��$¶B�¡¹��!�l³5R¡�l¶¼»T/2/+&�Z��YW«£��©²�� ¶'S±�YR¡�#X]Rl»��u�+&;³&�´¨�B²���¶_��»��u�l¶k�#�B¶B�*/#´¨»�³5W�²5&%Z ¶_�u»��u�¡¶�»��_�)�u�u»�³�¶_´)&;�VbW�*W �#¶¸³5&��k�o³Ò�u²!�Dp��#�*ZkS3&;�o³��g&�´,�u�YbdS3&;�u»T//2&;Á;�+Rl¶¡£��a�YbdSl&��u»T/]/+&;Á;�2R¡¶�»��_��_±�¡�_�u�¡�¾�!¶B�YWÃ�f&�´)&;�Vb·�5/D»��u���_�l¹y���o�_�YbÃ�l³��u¶¢�u²�»�³Ã´)&���W��l¶_�oÁ;³]£�Ï�³!��bW»��#³´)&XR¡��¶��o³Ê�u²��¸X��*/2W,&�´º�u�YbdS3&;�u»T/\/2&;Á��2R½�#¶·�u²��1p;�¡�B��X]RH»��B�2&;³,&�´º�u�*b(S3&;�u»4/uS��V&0S/�¡�_�B�o�l¶ ´)&;� ¶a`�¶_�u�*bW¶¡£�©²��l¶_�Qp;�l�_�#X]Rl»��u�+&;³��B�YR�²�³��#¹y���l¶$»��_��&�´ �B�l³)¶_�5S5S3&;�_�B�YWK_e`��'&X&T/o¶�»�ù m ©0¼Uh2ù�»�³]©T�4½�£¥�©²!�l�B� �*���o¶_�¥»T/o¶V&»TS5S��V&�»TR�²��¡¶c´)&;���B²��IRY&0bdS3&;¶B���u�2&�³�»T/�p;�l�_�#X]Rl»��u�+&;³"&�´a�u�YbdS3&;�u»T/±S��'&0S±�l�=�u�#�l¶�¢¶_�l��»�ù�g�©0о½�¤*£�©²��Õp;�¡�B�#X5RH»��B�2&;³}�B�YR�²�³!�o¹y���l¶Ã»�³UWÑ�u²��¡�B�¡´)&��B�w�B²��1RY&;�_�B�¡¶'S3&;³5W��#³�Á��f&F&0/#¶¨�B�¡¹y���o�_�½�o³ÑÁ��l³��¡�u»T/®X�³��#�B�b(&FW��Y/#¶º�'&1R�²��YRܺ�»w�B�YbdSl&;�B»T/�´)&��'b·�5/o»!£���&gR*&0S±�QZª�#�u²)�#³!X�³����u�Qbd&FW��Y/#¶¿�o¶¥»ÕRl���_�B�l³���S��V&0_5/o�*b �#³�u²�� �_�l¶B�l»��'R�²=&�´¢�u�*b(S3&;�u»4/�/2&�Á;�2R¡¶l£ m �u�#�'/o�#³�Á5h � »T/+º��¡�Yh%È®�B»TW!X��*/2W�»�³5WD&��B²��l�_¶IS��'&0S3&;¶_�1èoÎ%é'ÇTè Í ÎY¿FÅ�èéÜÉ]ÅÜéÜê¾À�ÊFƼ�f&¸¶'&T/+p;�·�B²���S��V&0_5/o�*bã&�´��#³!X�³����u�Qbd&FW��Y/#¶�» m � ª0©Uh�È m ©0ëXh m � ©TëUh2È��u»0©eÐ�½�£,�©²��cW��+Û/�l�_�l³5R¡��f&��u²��ª��¶_��»T/�bd&XW��*/|Î�R�²��YRܺy�o³!Á¼»4S5S��'&;»TR�²W�#¶s�u²�»��¾´)&��'b·�5/o»�¶�»��_�kR�²��YRܺ��YWÕ_e`��B�Y´q�l�_�l³5R¡�c�'&�S��V&0S±�l�_�B�o�¡¶&�´s»4W�ÌB»TRl�¡³��¿¶=��»��B�l¶l£\¨k&;��Á;²5/|`½¶VS/�l»Tºy�o³�Á5hXZª²��l�_�H»�¶nb(&FW��Y/ìÎ�R�²��*Rܺy�o³�Áû�¶Vº�¶Ií�W5&��¡¶©�u²��#¶�b(&FW��Y/«¶u»��B�o¶_´�`�u²���´)&;�Vb·�5/D»;Àeî|hU/+&XRl»T/ibd&XW!�Y/|Î�R�²��YRܺy�#³�Áû�¶'ºy¶Ií�W5&��l¶©�B²��o¶ª¶_�u»��u�$�#³0�B²��Ib(&FW��*/]¶u»��B�o¶=´�`½�u²���´)&;�Vb·�5/o»�À0î#£Ò�&��nR�²��*Rܺy�o³�Ák»W´)&;�Vb·�5/o»Ã�#³)»�³Ç�#³!X�³����u��b(&FW��Y/�&;³���RY&;³!¶B�2W!�l�B¶r&;³5/+`k¶V&0bW�,X�³����u�¨¶_�5_XÎ�S�»��_�B¶^&�´��B²��b(&FW��Y/«»�³5W0�u�_�o�l¶��f&cR�²��YRܺ¸�B²��¥´)&;�'b¨�5/D»¨�#³¸�u²��¡¶B��X�³����u��S�»��=�u¶¡£\­�&%Z®��p;�l�*h�/2&FRH»T/lb(&FW��Y/±R�²��YRܺy�o³!ÁW�#¶³5&��®´q�U/2/+`W»����f&0bW»��u�+Rc»�³5W¸�B�¡¹y���o�_�l¶©¶'&TbW�º�o³��u�*/2/o�#Á;�l³URl�ª´)&;�®���u¶®�!¶B�Th��u²�»����o¶®�#³½Á;�¡³��l�B»T/±R*&;³�¶B�+W��l�B»T_5/#�º�³U&�Zk/#�YW�Á��r&�´]�B²���b(&FW��Y/�£�j ³Ã�u²��#¶�Z®»m`w�����#¶¢¶B�2bÃ�2/o»��Æ�'&¼�u²!�º��`FS��2Rl»T/�b(&FW��*/3S!�'&0S3&;¶B�*Ww�#³W�u²!�o¶�Zu&��'º�h�u²�»��kWU&W³5&��ª¶'&0/|p;���u²��IS��V&0_5/#�Yb°&�´��o³�X�³��#�B�^bd&XW��*/o¶�R*&0b(SU/o�¡�B�Y/|`½»�¶�Z��Y/+/�£

� \ìï ð¼` � b ´�eHe p�­ ��´ ° `�p eg¢�V&XR¡�l¶_¶�RH»4/2Rl�U/o��bd&XW��*/��u²��g_±�l²�»mp��2&;�c&�´^RY&;³5R¡���B�_�l³��ÕS!�'&FRl�l¶_¶B�¡¶½�o³Ô´)&;�'bñ&�´^R*&;³�¶_�B�u»��#³��u¶d&;³O&0_FζB�l�ap�»T_5/o�k�*p��l³��u¶¡£�Ý�p��l³��u¶½»��B�k»T_5/#�¸�f& W!�l¶'R¡�B�+_/�k¶V`�³5R�²��V&;³5&;�!¶½�o³��u�¡�u»TRY�u�+&;³�¶c_/�Y��Z®�¡�l³vS!�'&FRl�l¶_¶B�¡¶l£g¢�V&XR¡�l¶_¶B�l¶,»��_�QRY&��5S5/o�*WD_�`oSl&��_�u¶¥»�³5WKRY&Tb(S5/#�Y�¥S��V&XR¡�l¶B¶_�l¶�RH»�³K_±�QR*&0b(S3&;¶_�YWÇ´q�'&Tb ¶_�2bdS5/o�¡�r&;³��¡¶_�`¨»º³y�5b�_/�¡��&�´]R*&0b(S3&;¶_�#�u�+&;³�&0S/�¡�u»��'&;�B¶¡£�j&�Æ�o¶�Sl&;¶_¶B�+_5/o�¾�f&rbd&FW��Y/yX�³����u��W�»���»º¶_�u�_�5R¡�B���B�¡¶�_e`�bÃ�H»�³�¶&�´¢�u²���Rl»T/2R¡�5/o��¶*h�_��!���B²��o¶�»4S5S��'&;»TR�²à�#¶¥³5&��¥��¶u»T_U/o� �o³KS!�u»TRY�u�2R¡��£¼�©²��!¶Yha��£-Á�£«�u²!�·´)&;�'bW»T/o�#¶'b .�.©m»�ù��+/åª0©¾½[Z®»�¶IRY&0b�_��o³��*WzZª�#�B²à»4/oÁ;�*_��u»��+R¨¶VS/�*Rl�#X5RH»��B�2&;³KR*&;³5Rl�*S!�u¶$´)&;��»4_�¶_�B�u»TRY�IW�»���»½��`FS±�l¶I/o�l»TW��o³!Á�f& �u²��I/o»�³�Á;��»�Á;�I}�Ï���Ï m »òj m Ï�ª0©4½�£Ò�&��$�B²��w¶VS/�*Rl��X]RH»��B�2&;³H&�´�WX`�³�»TbW�+R��B�YR*&;³!X�Á����u»��B�2&;³±h��u²!�dó±Î�RH»T/+Rl�5/#��¶(»�ù�g � ©0о½®²�»�¶�_±�l�¡³�W���p;�Y/ìÎ&0S/�*W]£,�©²���W��+Û/�l�_�l³5R¡��_/�Y��Z®�¡�l³HW�»��u»¸»�³5WKR�²�»�³!³��Y/�³�»4bW�¡¶¥�Y���o¶=�u�#³�Á¸�o³ .�.©m h]�o¶¥�_�Ybd&%p;�YW��#³Ç�u²��#¶RH»T/+Rl�5/#��¶l£�j&�ª�#¶���¶B��»T/]�f&�p��o¶_��»T/o�#nl�¿�B²���S��V&XR¡�l¶B¶c¶_�B�B�5RY�u���_�I_�`½Á;�u»TS!²�¶l£¢�©²����u�*���u��»T/±W��l¶VRl�B�+S!�u�+&;³"&�´¶B�5R�²�»½�B�*RY&;³�X�Á;���B»��u�+&;³z_±�YRY&TbW�¡¶¥��³��_�H»TW�»4_5/o��p��l�a`ǹy���2Rܺ�/|`;£$�©²��QR*&;�B�_�YR¡�B³��l¶_¶I&�´�»w¶'S±�YR¡�#X]Rl»��u�+&;³�o¶�S��V&�p��l³¥_�`¸�B²��$�l¹y��»T/#�#��`�&�´s»�S��V&XR¡�l¶_¶n_±�l²�»mp��2&���Zª�#�u²k»�³�»T/#�B�H»4WU`Õºy³5&%Zª³oS!�'&FRl�l¶_¶l£g¢�V&XR¡�l¶_¶w»T/#Á;�Y_!�u»�¶�»��_�0»T/o¶V&���¶B�*Wñ�f&DW��¡¶'R¡�B�2_±�¸�u²��"&0S±�l�B»��u�+&;³�»T/®¶B�YbW»�³��u�+Rl¶�&�´n/D»�³�Á;��»�Á��l¶·´)&;��W��Ãζ'Rl�_�2_��#³�Á�W��o¶=�u�B�+_��!�B�YWw¶a`�¶_�u�*bW¶¡£«Ö¿³w�*�!»Tb(SU/o�c�o¶��u²��¿»��'R�²!�#�u�*R¡�B���B��W��l¶VRl�_�2S!�B�2&;³(/D»�³�Á���»�Á;�cVkÖ^¨ � jiø»�ùoÓI©0¼¾½]´)&;��W��¡¶'Rl�_�2_��#³�ÁdW��o¶=�u�B�+_��!�B�YW0¶'&�´ ��Z®»��_�¼»��'R�²����u�YRY�u���_�l¶¡£

� \+ô µ °iõ ´ b ¶Yö µ `¾· ´ ¹ ¶ ´�¯y÷ø�]¯�´ ­£·$¹ � � ´ b å ¹�·£ù]d ´�e���� `½Z"· e ¶ `¾· ° d ¶ ´�¯¸à � e ¶ ´  e�©²���&0_yÌ_�YR¡�aÎ�&;�_�o�¡³y�B�YWzbd&FW��Y/#�o³�ÁcbÃ�¡�u²U&XW�¶º»�³5W¥/D»�³!Á;��»�Á;�¡¶Yh�/o�+º���Ï$ù��~»¬¨cÈ�g«úi©!§*½-h±ÏIÏ$Vû»-È\&X&e©4�T½-h»�³5W½f¿ùo}¦»¬¨c»��f©eá¾½$h�³!�2Rl�*/+`�¶_�5S5S3&;�_���u²��nW��*p��Y/2&TS5bW�¡³���&�´«¶_��»��u�2Rc¶V`�¶=�u�Yb ¶_�B�B�5RY�u���_�l¶YhX/o�+º���RY/D»�¶B¶�»�³5W&0_�Ì_�YRY�¥¶=�u�B�UR¡�u�!�B�l¶*h¤»�¶kZ®�*/2/�»�¶ª�u²���W��l¶VRl�B�+S!�u�+&;³o&�´s¶B�¡¹y���l³��u�o»T/s»�³5WoR*&;³5Rl�!�B�B�¡³���_/�¡²�»mp��2&;�¡£nÒ]&;�©�B²��

§Y��ä

Page 153: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

W��l¶VRl�B�+S!�u�+&;³K&�´®»T/2/+&XRl»��u�+&;³g&�´�&0_�Ì_�YRY�u¶,»�³5W)�u»�¶'ºy¶Yh�&0_yÌ_�YR¡�,�_�YS5/#�2RH»��u�2&�³)»�³5WDbÃ�oÁ;�B»��u�+&;³ihµ�B�*b(&��B� �o³XÎ�u�l�B»TR¡�B�2&;³!¶©»�³5W1WU`�³�»4bW�+R¥³��¡��Z\&;�VºW�f&TSl&0/+&;Á;�#�l¶«Zª²��2R�²k»��_�¥�2bdSl&��_��»�³y���o¶_¶B���¡¶ª�o³ÕW��#¶_�B�B�2_!�!�u�*W1&0_�Ì_�YRY�¶V`�¶_�B�Yböw�u²��¡¶B�k�u�YR�²!³��o¹y���¡¶ÕS��'&TbW�#¶B�k¶B�5S5S3&;�=�mh�_����mh©²5&%Z��*p;�¡�Yhª¶B�¡�Yb �f&=_/�k�o³�¶_�UüdRl�#�l³��H£¸j ³Ä�B²��´)&0/2/+&�Zª�#³�Á5h�Z®�IR*&;³�¶B�+W��l�©�B²��Ib(&;¶=�kS��'&TbW�#¶B�o³!Á�/D»�³�Á���»�Á;�4h�f¥ù¥}¢£f¥ùo}Ç�#¶®»$�B�*Rl�l³���»TS5S��V&�»TR�²w�'&¼¶=�u�B�¡³�Á��B²��l³w�B²��c�*Ûl&;�_�B¶u&�´±W��l¶_�oÁ;³��#³�Á¼»�³�&0_yÌ_�YR¡�aÎ�&;�_�o�¡³y�B�YW(b(&FW��Y/#�o³�Á/D»�³�Á���»�Á;��Zª²��¡�B�·»4/2/ibW»��o³0�#¶B¶B�!�l¶r&�´�¶V`�¶_�B�Ybè»�³�»4/+`�¶B�#¶¿»�³UW¥W��¡¶B�#Á;³Ç»��_�,�u»Tº��¡³Ç�o³��'&w»TR*RY&;�!³y�l£ªf¥ùo}S��'&%p��2W��¡¶rW��*S5/2&%`FbÃ�l³��^W��o»�Á;�B»TbW¶��'&w¶_²5&%Zã»Ã¶V`�¶_�B�Ybgî�¶¿³��¡��Z\&;�'º0�f&TSl&0/+&;ÁT`0»�³5W��B²��¨¶V&�´ ��Z�»��B�QR*&0bcÎSl&;³!�l³��u¶*h[S��V&XR¡�l¶_¶B�l¶¼»�³5W�³5&FW��l¶��B²�»���/o�|p;�Q&;³��u²!�ó!�¡��Z\&;�'º)³5&FW��¡¶l£ m �5R�²}»0³U&XW����_�YS��_�l¶B�¡³��u¶·»�³�`º��#³5Wo&�´�S��'&FRl�¡¶B¶_�o³�Á½�!³��#�l£nÒ]&;�ª�u²!��W��¡¶'Rl�_�2S!�B�2&;³¥&�´�³��Y��Zu&��'º0�f&0S3&0/2&�Á;�o�¡¶c³U&XW��¡¶rbW»m`"_/��RY&;³�³!�YR¡�B�YW_�`}»�¶_¶'&FRl�D»��u�2&�³�¶¼�#³5W��+RH»��B�o³�Á¥RY&0bdb·��³��+RH»��B�2&;³HS�»��B²�¶�_±�¡��Z��l�¡³ñ³U&XW��¡¶l£Kj&�¨�o¶�S3&;¶_¶B�2_U/o�W�'&zW��¡¶'Rl�_�2_±��u²��Iºy�o³5W"&�´Æ»�¶_¶'&FRl�D»��u�2&�³1b(&;�_���Y�!»TRY�f/+`Õ_�`¸�B²��$��¶B�I&�´�¶_�B�l�_�Y&���`FS±�l¶l£j ³�¶_�u»�³5Rl�¡¶c&�´�RY&0bdSl&�³��l³��u¶·»�¶QZ®�*/2/®»�¶QS��V&XR¡�l¶B¶_�l¶W»�³5W�&0_yÌ_�YR¡�B¶·�u²�»���/o�|p;�Õ&;³Ô»Ç³U&XW��½»��B�Õ/+&XRl»��u�*WZª�#�u²!�o³w�B²��o¶�³5&XW!��£�j&´�&;³���R*&0b(S3&;³��¡³��©��¶B�¡¶��u²��¿¶B�l�ap��2Rl�¡¶k&�´a»�³5&��B²��l�uRY&0bdSl&�³��l³����B²��o¶��#¶®�#³5W��2Rl»��u�*W_�`½»QW��YS±�l³UW��l³5R�`"_/�Y��Z®�¡�l³0�u²5&�¶B��RY&Tb(S3&;³��¡³y�B¶l£\Ï^_�Ì_�YRY�u¶�Zª²��+R�²gbd&%p;�^W!���B�#³�Á�»�³¸�o³��B�l�u»4R¡�u�+&;³¸»��_�b(&FW��Y/#�YW1_e`¸��Z\&(&;��bd&;�_���o³�¶=��»�³5R¡�l¶�&;³0¶B��p;�l�B»T/%³5&FW��l¶�RY&;³!³��YRY�u�YW¥_e`¦qV_±�YRY&TbW�¡¶'sdW��YS±�l³5W!�l³5R¡�o�l¶¡£�©²���W��¡¶'Rl�_�2S!�B�2&;³�&�´]R*&;³��u�'&T/Xç]&%ZÔ�o³¨f¥ùo}¸�#¶Æ¶B�US5Sl&��_�u�*W�_e`¼¶_�l¹y���¡³5Rl�c»�³5W�RY&0/+/D»T_3&;�u»��u�2&�³�W��D»�Á��u»Tböl£ù��5/#�B���B²��B�l»TW�¶[&�´�RY&;³��B�'&0/FRH»�³�_/���*�XS��B�¡¶B¶B�*Wc_�`�RY&T/2/D»4_l&;�B»��u�+&;³IW��D»�Á;�u»Tbö�RY&;³��u»��o³��#³�Á¿¶_�*p��l�u»4/�»TRY�u�+p��&0_�Ì_�YRY�u¶¡£��©²��l�_�¨»��B�IW��+Û/�l�_�l³��c��`XS±�l¶�&�´�RY&;³��u�V&0/�ç]&%Z{RY&�³y�u»��o³!�o³�Á�¶V`�³5R�²!�'&;³5&���¶¥»�³UW�»�¶a`�³5R�²��'&�³5&;��¶RY&0bdb·��³��+RH»��B�2&;³ _/�Y��Z®�¡�l³yS��V&XR¡�l¶B¶_�l¶¡£ m �¡¹��!�l³5R¡�)»�³5W¦RY&0/+/D»T_3&;�B»��u�+&;³ W��o»�Á;�B»TbW¶ ³!�lÁ0/#�YR¡���B²��"W��o¶¯Î�u�B�+_��!�B�YW�&T_�Ì_�YRY�©»T/+/2&FRH»��B�2&;³ih��u²y��¶��#�¾³5&��\Sl&�¶B¶B�+_5/o�ª�f&,�Y�XS5/#�2R¡�#�f/|`�»TW5W!�B�l¶_¶��B²��rW��#¶_�B�B�2_!�!�u�+&;³��o¶B¶_���l¶\&�´&0_�Ì_�YRY�c¶V`�¶_�B�YbönW��!�B�o³!Á��B²��I_/�¡²�»mp��2&;�kW��¡¶B�oÁ�³]£�©²����Y���o¶=�u�#³�Á·³5&��u»��u�+&;³�&�´�W��YS5/+&%`XbÃ�l³���W!�D»�Á;�B»Tbö\Rl»TS!�u�!�B�l¶��B²��^W��¡¶'R¡�B�2S��u�2&�³Õ&�´�bW�#Á;�u»��u�o³!Á�&T_�Ì_�YRY�u¶_��!��W5&��l¶�³5&��«S!�'&%p��2W��ª³5&��u»��u�+&;³�»T/��Y/#�YbÃ�l³��u¶��f&$�*�US!�B�l¶_¶��_�YS5/#�2Rl»��u�+&;³Q&�´«»�³c&0_�Ì_�*R¡�H£��©²!�o¶��B�¡¶_�B�B�2RY�u�+&;³¶B�l�*bW¶%�f&�_±���l»�¶B�+/+`��_�Ybd&�p��YW�_�`$�#³ep;�l³��B�o³�Á¿»ª´q���=�u²��¡��¶=�u�¡�B�Y&���`XS±�\Zª²!�2R�²¨�#³5W��+RH»��B�l¶¤�u²��#¶�W��YS±�l³5W!�l³5R�`;£È®�!�$�u²��¡�B���o¶�³U&0´q�l»��u�!�B� �f&gW��l¶VRl�_�2_±���B²��c_/�¡²�»mp��2&;��&;³��_�YS5/#�2RH»��u�YWD&0_yÌ_�YR¡�¼¶_�B�B�5RY�u���_�l¶¡£wVr`�³�»TbÃ�2R³��¡��Z\&;�'ºy�#³�Á·�o¶¢³5&���»TWUW��B�¡¶B¶B�*W1_e`wf¿ùo}�£�ù�»m`X_±�º�B²�»����o¶¢�u²���RH»�¶B�r_±�YRl»���¶_�º�u²!�l�B�º�o¶¢³5&¼�l¶_�u»T_5/#�o¶B²!�YW�u�YR�²!³��o¹y���¥�'&�W��l¶VRl�B�+_/�$»�³1&0_�Ì_�YRY�VÎ�&;�B�#�l³��u�*W¸¶V`�¶_�B�Ybgî�¶k_±�l²�»mp��2&;�\Zª�#�u²U&;�!�©»�³�`w¶B�¡¹��!�l³��u�o»T/i&;�VW��l�_�o³�Á�£�©²����f&F&0/!¶_�5S5S3&;�_�«&�´«f¿ùo}��#¶�&;³��u&�´±�#�u¶�_��oÁ$»TWXp�»�³y�u»�Á;�¡¶Yh;�u²�»��¢²��Y/+S/�*W�f¥ùo}0�f&�_±�YR*&0bW�©�#³5W���¶=�u�_�D»T/�B�Y/#�*p�»�³��H£�­�&�Z��*p��l�*h±�B²����f&F&0/o¶�bW»��#³5/+`W¶B�5SUSl&;�=�ª�u²��IW��¡¶B�oÁ�³¥&�´Æ»cW��o¶=�u�B�+_��!�B�YW0¶V`�¶_�B�Ybè»�³5Wk»��_�I/o�l¶_¶p;�l�_�#X]Rl»��u�+&;³¸�f&F&0/o¶¡£¢�©²��o¶ª�o¶k_�»�¶B�YW¥&;³0�u²��$´»TR¡�Yh��u²�»��¿f¿ùo}}²�»�¶º³5&��¿» ¶_�UüdRl�o�¡³��¿�u²!�Y&;�_�¡�u�+RH»T/�_�»�¶B�#¶`;�¡�l£

§Y�e¼

Page 154: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

6 7 8:9 ;=<?> ý

þ Myÿ��¥C�������Mvÿ��

�©²���¶'S±�YRl��X]RH»��u�2&�³�»�³5WKp;�¡�B�#X5RH»��B�2&;³D&�´�W��#¶_�u�_�2_����u�YW�¶a`�¶=�u�*bW¶$�o¶¥»¸�u»�¶'ºo&�´¾Á;�B�l»��$�2bdSl&��_��»�³5Rl�¨»�³5W_/�*RY&0bÃ�l¶¥��p;�¡³Hbd&;�_�¨�2bdS3&;�_�u»�³��¿»�¶^W��o¶=�u�_�2_��!�B�YWǶa`�¶_�u�*bW¶�_±�YR*&0bÃ��bd&;�B��&;�'W��#³�»��a`;£^j ³��B²��o¶�Zu&��'º�hj�S��B�¡¶B�l³��B�YWñ»��u�*R�²�³��o¹y���½´)&��¼�u²!�½¶'S±�YR¡�#X]Rl»��u�+&;³Ê»�³5W�p��l�_�#X]Rl»��u�+&;³�&�´kW��#¶_�B�B�2_!�!�u�*WѶV`�¶_�B�Ybö�_�»�¶_�YW&;³ÔÁ;�u»TS!²Ô�B�u»�³!¶_´)&;�Vbw»��B�2&;³Ñ»�³5WÊ�u�*b(S3&;�u»4/�/2&;Á��2R�£Hj�S��'&%p��2W��*WwR*&;³5R¡�YS!�B¶Ã´)&;�·�B²��¸¶'S±�YR¡�#X]Rl»��u�+&;³,&�´W��o¶=�u�B�+_��!�B�YWöV`�¶_�B�Yböu_e`dW��o¶=�u�B�+_��!�B�YWÃÁ;�u»TS!²Ã�B�u»�³�¶=´)&;�'bW»��B�2&;³��o³ �B²��º¶_�o³�ÁT/o�kS���¶_²5&;�!�®»TS5S��V&�»TR�²w»�³5W�u²��0¶'S±�YR¡�#X]Rl»��u�+&;³,&�´¥¶a`�¶_�u�*b S��'&0S±�l�=�u�#�l¶�_e`ÔÁ;�u»4S�²XÎ �#³��u�l�VS��B�Y�u�*W��B�YbdSl&;�B»T/�/+&;Á;�2RW´)&;�'b·�U/D»�¶¡£Ê�©²���o³��u�¡Á;�u»��B�2&;³(&�´%Á;�B»TS�²½�u�B»�³�¶=´)&;�'bW»��u�+&;³½»�³5W½�u�*b(S3&;�u»4/3/+&;Á;�+Rc�'&X&0ºdS5/o»TRl�n&�p��l�ª»·¶VS/�*Rl�D»4/«³5&��B�2&;³(&�´�»�u�u»�³�¶B���u�2&�³¼¶a`�¶=�u�*b¥hTZª²!�l�B���u²���¶_�YbW»�³��u�+Rl¶�&�´��u�*b(S3&;�u»4/F/+&;Á;�+R¾�#¶[_�»�¶B�*W�&;³]£ m �o³5R¡�®Á;�B»TS�²XÎ&�o³��u�¡�'S��_�¡�B�YW�u�YbdS3&;�u»T/�/+&;Á;�+R��o¶k&;³5/|`0»W¶VS/�*Rl�D»4/�ºy�#³5W¥&�´�S��'&TSl&;¶_�#�B�2&;³�»4/«�u�*b(S3&;�u»4/�/2&;Á;�+RThUZ��·»��B�¼»T_5/o���'&W��¶_�¼�B²��R�²��YRܺy�o³!ÁÃ�B�YR�²�³��#¹y���l¶ª´)&;���u�*b(S3&;�B»T//´)&;�Vb·�5/o»�¶�W���p;�Y/+&0S±�YWk�o³½�u²!�$X��Y/2W"&�´%�B�YbdSl&;�B»T/i/+&;Á;�2R�£Æ��&cRY&0S±�Zª�#�u²Ô�#³!X�³����u�Õbd&XW!�Y/o¶�j�S��V&%p��+W��YWÊ�B²��"RY&;³�¶=�u�_�5R¡�B�2&;³,&�´¿»���`FS��2Rl»T/�b(&FW��*/\Zª�#�B²Ô�B�l¶VS/�*R¡���f&�»)¶B�Y�&�´®Á��u»TS�²FÎ �o³��B�l�'S!�B�¡�B�YW�´)&;�'b¨�5/D»�¶º�u²�»��$¶_�5S5S3&;�_�B¶Yh�_��!��W5&��l¶$³5&��,¶V&0/+p��dR*&0bdS5/o�Y�u�Y/|`0h«�B²��û��!�'&0bw»��u�2RR�²��YRܺy�o³!Áz&�´®�B�YbdSl&��u»T/Æ´)&��'b·�5/o»�¶��o³��o³�X�³��#�B�cb(&FW��Y/#¶l£Ã�©²���S!�'&0S±�l�=��`D&�´®�B²��Ã��`FS��+RH»T/«bd&XW!�Y/s�#³5W��|ÎRH»��B�l¶·»4/o�B�l»TWU`��u²�»���b�`}»4S5S��'&;»TR�²�W5&��l¶¼³5&��·¶V&0/+p��½»T/+/«S��'&0_U/o�Ybö�&XR*Rl���_�B�o³!Á��o³��u²��W¶'S±�YR¡�#X]Rl»��u�+&;³&�´�W��#¶_�B�B�2_!�!�u�*W�¶a`�¶=�u�*bW¶¡£nÝ�¶VS/�*Rl�D»4/2/+`w�u²��IZu&��'º1Zª�#�B²��_�l¶'S±�YRY�¿�'&Ã�B²��¨Á;�B»TS�²XÎ&�o³��u�¡�'S��_�¡�B�YW0�u�YbdS3&;�u»T//2&;Á;�+R�»�³5W0�u²!�¨»����f&0bW»��u�+Rrp;�¡�B��X]RH»��B�2&;³"&�´ÆÁ;�u»4S�²XÎ �#³��u�l�VS��B�Y�u�*Wk�B�YbdSl&;�B»T/«´)&;�Vb·�5/o»�¶��o¶ª�#³0�B²���_/�¡Á;�o³Xγ��o³�Á!£�j ³¸´»TR¡�Yh5b�`¸»4S5S��'&;»TR�²0�o¶©»�³¸�#³��u�l�_�l¶=�u�o³!Á ¶_�u�*S¥&�³½�u²���Z®»%`W�f&û·¶'S±�YR¡�#X]Rl»��u�+&;³½�u�*R�²�³��#¹��!�$´)&��W��o¶=�u�B�+_��!�B�YWw¶a`�¶_�u�*bW¶u_�»�¶B�*W1&;³½Á;�B»TS�²Ã�u�u»�³�¶_´)&;�Vbw»��u�2&�³ih�_��!�®�B²��l�_�¥»��_�¿¶=�u�2/+/]bw»�³�`d&0S±�l³�S��'&0_U/o�Yböl£j\Zª�2/+/±R*&;³�¶B�+W��l�ª³5&%Z3» ´q��Zx&�´��u²��*b�£

� \ t à ð µ�� · � å ¡ ´� l´ ­�t½^a^a` � p�b åO¶ �}¯ · e ¶ `¾· ° d ¶ ´�¯w� `�p�^ åO¶ `�p]¹ e*��� `�Âàp ¶ · � ¹j^W��*p��Y/+&0S/�*WÑ�u²��W¶B�#³�Á0/o�cS��!¶B²5&;����»TS5S��V&�»TR�²��f&zW��#¶_�B�B�2_!�!�u�*W}Á;�B»TS�²à�B�u»�³!¶_´)&;�Vbw»��B�2&;³±h�Zª²!�l�B��/2&FRH»T/¶_��»��u�l¶¼»��_�W�_�YS��_�l¶B�¡³��u�YW�_e`D&0_yÌ_�YR¡�B¶�&�´�»gRl»��u�¡Á0&;�a` � �u²�»��,²�»�¶,�'&�¶B»��u�#¶_´�`DRl�¡�_�u»��o³HRY&;³UW��#�B�2&;³�¶��#³&;�'W��¡���f&gW��l¶VRl�B�+_/�û¸�u�B»�³�¶_´)&��'bW»��u�+&;³)¶_�B�YS _e`�»"S���¶_²5&;�!�¼�o³)�u²!�dR*&;�B�_�l¶VSl&;³UW��o³�ÁgRH»��u�lÁT&;�V`�£W�©²��#¶º��#³5W1&�´�W��YX�³����u�2&�³½Á;�+p��l¶©�B»��o¶_�º�f&·�B²��¥¹y���¡¶_�u�+&;³1Zª²��¡�B²��l�©�����#¶�Sl&�¶B¶B�+_5/o�c�f&·�#³��u�lÁ��u»��B�^b�`w»TS5S��V&�»TR�²�o³·�u²!��´q�u»TbÃ�*Z\&;�'º�&�´��^À|ƾÉFÌ���Å��TÅ�è���Å�È3è|ÇFéÜÅ Í Å�Ê]¤Í�â%Á�Â¯Å Í Á�»ßÝ¢g¾g�§I©0©Uh�Ý«}�©�¦4½-h�¶_²5&;�=�f/+`Q­r}�¨ñ¶a`�¶_�u�*bW¶¡£­r}�¨ú¶a`�¶=�u�*bW¶�S��V&%p��+W�� »�³�»4_�¶_�B�u»TRY��´q�u»TbÃ�*Z\&;�'ºk�o³¥Zª²��2R�²K&0_yÌ_�YR¡�B¶I&�´¾»�³�»��V_��#�B�u»��a`¥Rl»��u�¡Á0&;�a`Ç»��_��u�u»�³�¶_´)&;�VbW�*W]£$øn&����*p��l�V`zRH»��B�lÁ0&;�a`o/#�H»TW!¶¿�f&w�B²�� ¶u»4bW�¼�B�l¶_�5/#�B¶��]�B²��*`oW��YS±�l³5WKp��l�V`zb·�5R�²K&;³Ç�B²��S��'&0S±�l�=�u�#�l¶�&�´®�B²���Rl»��u�¡Á0&;�V`Th�¶_�2bÃ�2/o»��¿�f&k�u²��dS��V&0S/�¡�_�B�o�l¶�&�´u&;����RH»��B�lÁ0&;�a` � £a�©²!�W´)&FRl��¶�&�´k­n}�¨¶V`�¶_�B�YböW�#¶d&�³��B²��"S��'&0S±�l�=�u�#�l¶c&�´º�#�u¶��#³�¶_�u»�³5Rl�"Rl»��u�¡Á0&;�B�#�l¶¡£Äùk�o³��+bw»T/\RY&;³UW��#�B�2&;³�¶�»��B�0�Y���u�B»TR¡�B�YWZª²��2R�²Ô»T/+/2&%Zì´)&;��W��YX�³��#�B�2&;³!¶·»�³5WÑ�B²��Y&��B�Ybö�R*&;³5R¡�l�B³!�o³�Á5hs´)&��¼�*��»4b(S5/#�Th�S�»��u»T/+/o�*/o�o¶Vb¥h%�*bQ_/�*W5W��#³�Á&;�½»TbW»T/#Á�»TbW»��u�+&;³]£yj ³ä�u²!�o¶�Z®»m`vS��V&0S/�¡�_�B�o�l¶(RH»�³y_±�zS��V&%p;�l³Ò�#³Ä�u²��o_��oÁ;Á��l¶_��RY/o»�¶B¶Õ&�´$�o³�¶=��»�³5R¡�RH»��B�lÁ0&;�_�o�¡¶l£ . ²��*Rܺy�o³�Áw�B²��Q­n}�¨xRY&;³5W!�#�u�+&;³�¶©´)&;��&;���c»TS5S!�'&�»TR�²obw»m`1S��V&%p��+W��¨�!¶�Zª���u²��B²��,�B�l¶_�5/#�B¶&0_!��»��o³��*WÇ�o³K­n}�¨�¶a`�¶=�u�*bW¶*h]´)&;�¿�*��»4b(S5/#��S�»��u»T/+/o�Y/#�o¶Vb�£ � ²��+R�²D­r}�¨øRY&;³5W!�#�u�+&;³�¶nRH»�³K_±��R�²��*Rܺ��*W¶B�5R*Rl�l¶_¶_´q�5/+/+`Ê´)&;��&�����»TS5S��V&�»TR�²¦W��YS±�l³UW�¶�&;³Ê�B²��"&;³��0²�»�³5W¦&;³Ê�u²!�gRl»��u�¡Á0&;�a` � ��¶_�YWñ´)&���/2&FRH»T/¶_��»��u�l¶®»�³5Ww�B²��¿¶=�u�_�5R¡�B���B�^&�´�W��o¶=�u�_�2_��!�B�YWWÁ;�u»TS!²�¶®»�³5WÕW��#¶_�u�_�2_����u�YW(b(&��'S�²��#¶'böl£�Òµ�!�_�u²!�l�\Z\&;�VºÃ²�»�¶�f&�_±��W5&;³��¥�'& �o³ep;�¡¶_�u�#Á�»��B�¥²5&%Z�b¨�5R�²k�B²��l¶_��RY&0bdS3&;³��l³��B¶©�o³Uç��!�l³5R¡�$�B²���¶u»��u�o¶=´»TR¡�B�2&;³�&�´%�u²��I­n}�¨RY&;³5W!�#�u�+&;³�¶¡£

§Y��á

Page 155: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

� \#¬ �Y¹ab � `�^ � `�p ¶ ·£¹ � Z"· e ¶ `¾· ° d ¶ ´�¯ � ´ Â}^ � `�p�­u¡ ��� ·b ejuRY&TbQ_��o³!�YW0Á;�u»4S�²k�B�u»�³!¶_´)&;�Vbw»��B�2&;³(Zª�#�u²�»�S��'&TSl&;¶_�#�B�2&;³�»4//�u�*b(S3&;�B»T/±/+&;Á;�2R4h��B²�»��c�o¶©³5&��º�¡¶'S±�YR¡�D»T/+/+`Rl��¶=�f&0bÃ�on¡�YW}´)&;�,�u²��W�B�¡¹��!�o�B�*bW�¡³��u¶�&�´�W!�o¶_�B�B�+_��!�u�*WѶV`�¶=�u�Yböl£ m �o³5R¡�W�u²!�ÕRY&0b�_��o³�»��u�2&�³à�#¶¨¶'/#�oÁ;²��'/+`�o³5W��*S/�¡³5W��¡³y��&�´¿�B²��¸�u�*b(S3&;�u»4/�/2&;Á;�+RTh�´q���=�u²��¡�dZ\&;�'ºÊ²�»�¶Ã�'&=_±�gW5&;³��0�f&�X�³5WÄ»��B�YbdSl&;�B»T/�/+&;Á;�2Rb(&;�_�ǶB�!�#��»4_5/o��´)&��1W��o¶=�u�B�+_��!�B�YW�¶V`�¶=�u�Yböl£ �©²!�l�B��»��_�K&;³�Á0&��o³�ÁÊ��Û±&;�=�u¶½�'&¦R¡��¶_�'&0bÃ�onl���u�YbdS3&;�u»T//2&;Á;�+Rl¶�´)&;�kW��#¶_�B�B�2_!�!�u�*W�¶V`�¶=�u�YböYh/¶B�¡�¼��£�Á�£�»@øº�o�Y©eá¾½�£®�©²��¼�2W��l»Ã�#¶©�f&�W!�+p��2W����B²���W!�o¶_�B�B�+_��!�u�*W�¶a`�¶=�u�*b�o³H/2&FRH»T/�R*&0b(S3&;³��¡³��u¶·»�³5Wà�'&oW��YX�³���R*&0bdSl&;³!�l³��VÎ&�o³5W��*���YW}�B�YbdSl&;�B»T/�&0S±�l�B»��f&;�_¶l£1Ö~RY&0bdS3&;³��l³��aÎ�o³5W��*���YW0´)&;�'b·�U/D»QRH»�³k�_�¡´q�¡�ª�'&c&;³5/+`�&;³��IRY&Tb(S3&;³��¡³y�k&����f&�¶B��p;�l�B»T/�RY&0bdSl&�³��l³��u¶¡£�Ò�&����H»TR�²�¶B�#³�Á0/o�RY&0bdSl&�³��l³���»Ñ�u�u»�³�¶B���u�2&�³��B�Y/o»��u�+&;³��o¶1W!�¡X�³��*W3»�³UW��B²��DRY&0bdSl&�¶B�#�B�2&;³y&�´¼�B�u»�³�¶_�#�B�2&;³�¶a`�¶=�u�*bW¶g&�´¶B�*p��l�B»T/\R*&0bdSl&;³!�l³��u¶���»4º��l¶�S5/o»TRl�c&%p;�¡��R*&0b(bd&;³�»TRY�u�+&;³�¶l£dÒ]&;�¥�B²��W¶B»��u�#¶_´»TRY�u�+&;³K&�´®´)&��'b·�5/o»�¶¿�B²��RY&0bdSl&�¶B�YW)�B�u»�³�¶_�#�B�2&;³Ç¶a`�¶_�u�*b &�´¾�u²5&;¶_�cRY&0bdSl&�³��l³��u¶��#¶¥��»Tº��l³ih¤�B²�»��I&FRYRl�!���o³Ç�u²!��´)&��'b·�5/o»!£,�©²���o³��u�¡Á;�u»��B�2&;³�&�´a¶B�5R�²�»�W��o¶=�u�B�+_��!�B�YW½�u�*b(S3&;�B»T/l/+&;Á;�+R¥»�³5W0Á;�B»TS�²½�B�u»�³�¶=´)&;�'bW»��B�2&;³½Á��+p;�¡¶��u²���²U&0S/�¥�'&¶'S±�YRl��´�`1W��#¶_�u�_�2_����u�YW0¶a`�¶=�u�*bW¶c�*p��l³obd&;�_�$»TS5S��V&0S��B�o»��u��£

� \+æ �Y¹ab � `�^ � `�p ¶ ·£¹ � ¶�å ´H  `�p�ÂÑÂ}p�`�·$¹ ¶5å ´ � �¤^�·b;p�­ ÷ø�]¯�´ ­fº³��u�+/c³U&�ZIh��B²��oR*&;³�¶=�u�B�UR¡�u�+&;³v&�´¿�u²��k��`XS!�2RH»4/nbd&XW!�Y/kW5&��l¶w³U&���R*&;³�¶_�2W��¡�W�u²!��Á;�B»Tb(bW»��¡£yÒ��'&0b»�¶_�YbW»�³��u�+RH»T/�S3&;�#³y�c&�´np��o��ZIh¾�B²��o¶�Rl»�³¦_/�0¶'&T/+p;�*Wñ¶_�o³5R¡�¸�u²��¸��`FS��2Rl»T/�bd&XW!�Y/��#¶·�u²��¸X�³�»4/�&0_�Ì_�YRY��o³)�u²��cRl»��u�¡Á0&;�V`z&�´I¢»"R¡�l�=��»��#³HR*/D»�¶_¶I&�´Ü¤º�B�u»�³!¶B�#�B�2&;³�¶a`�¶=�u�*bW¶¡£W�©²��¡�B�Y´)&;�B�4ha�B²��l�_�W�*�!�#¶_�B¶¨»¸��³��#¹y���b(&;�VS�²��#¶'b ´q�'&0b �B²��d¢£S3&;¶B¶_�2_5/|`Ã�o³!X�³!�#�u�m¤¢�B�u»�³�¶_�#�B�2&;³W¶V`�¶_�B�YbâÁ;�¡³��l�B»��u�*W½´q�'&0b �u²!�¥Á;�u»4b(bW»��¢�f&¨�B²����`XS!�2RH»4/�&;³���£¨�©²��#¶�b(&;�VS�²��#¶'b bw»��'ºy¶$»½¶B�5_FÎ ¶V`�¶=�u�Yb &�´��B²��·��`FS��2Rl»T/ÆÁ;�B»TS�²)�u�B»�³�¶_�#�u�+&;³Ç¶a`�¶=�u�*b _�`�#�u¶¿�2bW»�Á;��£¼�©²��o¶�¶_�5_XÎ&¶V`�¶_�B�Yb �o¶�¶=�u�+/2/�X�³��#�B�Th¤¶B�#³5Rl�·�B²�� ��`FS��2Rl»T/�bd&XW��*/s�o¶ºX�³��#�B��£ m �o³5R¡�·�u�u»�³�¶B���u�2&�³b(&;�VS�²��#¶'bö�S��_�l¶_�l�Vp��k»�³5WÑ�_�*ç��*R¡��¶u»��u�o¶=´»TR¡�B�2&;³v¢£RY´i£ V¥�¡´i£�ä�£#§�£2¦e¤Ãh�»�´)&;�Vb·�5/o»k¶B»��u�#¶_X��*WÊ�B�l¶VS]£s³5&��¶u»��B�o¶_X��YW��o³Ê�u²��0¶_�5_XÎ ¶a`�¶_�u�*b &�´c�u²��¸��`FS��2Rl»T/�bd&XW��*/��o¶�»4/o¶'&�¶B»��u�#¶_X��*W��_�l¶VS]£¢³5&���¶u»��u�o¶=X��YW��o³Ê�B²���o³!X�³!�#�u�w¶V`�¶_�B�Ybk£ñ�©²��"S��V&0_5/#�Yb �#¶·�f&)X�³5WÔ�u²!�k�+bw»�Á;�Õ&�´¿»�³��o³!X�³!�#�u�W�u�u»�³�¶B���u�2&�³Ê¶V`�¶_�B�Yb �o³Ê�B²����`XS!�2RH»4/�b(&FW��Y/�£�Ò����_�B²��l��Z\&;�Vº¸²�»�¶©�f&c_±��WU&;³����f&�¶'&T/+p;���B²��o¶�S��V&0_5/#�Ybk£

� \ìï � �i� ­ à da^a^ � ` ¶�©²��o¶^Z\&;�'º��o¶�»ÕR*&;³��u�B�+_��!�B�2&;³Ç�'&½�u²��c&;³�ÁT&;�o³�Áw�*Ûl&;�_���'&¸�l¶_�u»T_5/#�o¶B²¦¢)W��o¶=�u�_�2_��!�B�YW�¤¿Á��u»TS�²Ç�B�u»�³!¶_´)&;�¯Îbw»��B�2&;³Ô»�¶w»�¶'S±�YR¡�#X]Rl»��u�+&;³��B�YR�²�³!�o¹y���0´)&;�cRY&;³5R¡���B�_�l³��mh©�_�H»TRY�u�|p;�k»�³5Wx¢�o³,b�`,Rl»�¶B�m¤cW!�o¶_�B�B�+_��!�u�*W¶V`�¶_�B�Yböl£ä�©²��k�l¶=��»T_U/o�o¶_²5bÃ�l³��Ã�o¶�¶B�+b(S5/#�#X��*WÊ�#´c�u²��k¶'S±�YR¡�#X]Rl»��u�+&;³Ô�u�YR�²!³��o¹y�����o¶ ¶B�US5Sl&��_�u�*Wv_e`�»�f&F&0/�£�j ³=S�»��_�B�2Rl�U/D»��*h]�#´¢�u²!�·�u�YR�²!³��o¹y���öB²�»4/2/�_±�YR*&0bÃ�Ã�#³5W���¶=�u�_�D»T/��B�Y/#�*p�»�³5R¡��»½�f&F&0/s�o¶rbw»�³UW�»��f&��V`;£�©²��l�_�¡´)&;�_�Th;�u²!���2bdS5/o�*bW�¡³���»��B�2&;³�&�´±»¿�f&F&0/��o¶[&;³���&�´��B²���bd&;¶_��R�²�»T/+/o�l³!Á;�o³�Á¿»�¶'S±�YRY�u¶�&�´�´q���u���_�uZu&��'ºµ£�[&F&0/o¶c¶B²�»T/2/%¶B�US5Sl&��_�c�u²���W��l¶_�oÁ;³z&�´¢»(W��#¶_�B�B�2_!�!�u�*W�¶V`�¶=�u�Ybã_e`¥W!�o¶_�B�B�+_��!�u�*W�Á;�B»TS�²��B�u»�³!¶_´)&;�Vbw»��B�2&;³»�¶�Z®�*/2/ª»�¶��u²��0¶VS/�*Rl�#X5RH»��B�2&;³¦&�´ºÁ;�u»TS!²XÎ �#³y�B�l�VS��B�Y�u�YW��u�*b(S3&;�u»4/®´)&;�'b¨�5/D»�¶·»�³5WÔ�u²��¡�o��p;�¡�B�#X5RH»��B�2&;³]£�©²����+b(SU/o�YbÃ�l³��u»��u�+&;³�&�´�»��f&F&0/®´)&;���u²!�¥W��¡¶B�#Á;³w&�´�W��o¶=�u�_�2_��!�B�YW�¶V`�¶_�B�Ybö�_e`,W��#¶_�u�_�2_����u�YWñÁ;�u»4S�²�u�u»�³�¶_´)&;�Vbw»��u�2&�³w�o¶�»TW5W��_�l¶B¶_�YW�»��®�B²����a�YR�²�³��+RH»T/]fº³��|p;�l�_¶B����`Õ&�´�È®�¡�'/o�#³ihF_��!���B²��^Zu&��'ºw�#¶�¶_�B�2/+//�#³½�#�B¶_/�¡Á;�o³�³!�o³�Á;¶¡£�Ö¿³�»�³�»4/+`�¶B�#¶��f&F&0/±Z\&;�5/2W0Á;�|p;���u²!�¼»4S5S��'&;»TR�²�»4W5W��#�B�2&;³�»T/]»TR*Rl�*S!��»�³URl��£

§Y�eª

Page 156: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

� ����C��eM��ONQE��! #"

»@È . ù�V�©0ë4½yÙ!£�¨$£�È®���'R�²±h«Ýª£2ù࣠. /D»��Vº��4h�Ó £�}�£Æù¥R5ù��+/2/o»�³ih�»�³5WÊV·£�}�£ÆV¥�+/2/�£ m `FbQ_l&T/o�2Rdbd&XW��*/«R�²��YRܺy�o³!Á��§%ë Å%$ ¶=��»��B�l¶ª»�³UW1_/��`0&;³5W«£�j ³�õ®ÏuÎ%é�&$ίËnÂ�É]Å�'TÂ�É)(rÊ]Ê]ÄUÇTè/Í�â Í È�Î%Á�À�Ä Í Î¾Ê*�%Î'ÆTÀ-érÀ�Ê�+�Î Í È3ÄF¯ÅYÏÍié�À-Å�ʱéÜÅY£�j¯Ý«Ý«Ý . &0b(S!�!�u�¡�-,F&XR¡�o�¡��`/.��B�l¶_¶YhlÙ���³��ç%©0©Të!£

»@È�§$�kªT©4½ ¨,£2ùࣵȮ�!�B¶_�u»T/2/$h�Ù!£¬Ö¨£3§�&;Á;���¡³ihµ»�³5WgÖ¨£���»��'/#�YRܺy��£0,X&0bÃ��Ò���³5W�»TbÃ�l³��u»T/iÖr/#Á;�Y_!�u»��+R��[&F&0/o¶�´)&���u²��*,��YbW»�³��u�2R¡¶�&�´ . &0b(S!�!��»��B�2&;³213.�»��_�æ��1j ³5W��Y���*W . »��B�lÁ0&;�_�o�¡¶l£ }�Ò . ,�¨c�*Sl&��_�4,��¡�B�o�¡¶Ý . ,�ί}�Ò . ,�ίªT©¾Î¯©0ëXh]§%©0ª0©�£

»@Èu&��Yªeá¾½ È¿£�Èu&��l²Ub�£kj ³5W��!¶_�u�_�D»T/!¶'&�´ ��Z®»��B�kbÃ�¡�B�B�2R¡¶s�f&0S �B�l³d/o�o¶=�H£658797:7�Í]ίËÃÂ;�Ç�ÏÜÅ�heS�»�Á;�l¶«ª4�<1XªeäXh=,��YS!�l£§%©0ªeá�£

»@Èu&X&0©T�T½ §�£«Èu&F&XR�²]£�>3ý@?mÅÜé�£ÌA>�Ï�À-Å�Ê]Â�Å'¿)(rÊ3ÇTè â�Á�À2ÁcÇTÊ3¿CBQÅÜÁ�À|ÆTÊD;�À�Â)É*(�ÈeÈ3è À-é'ÇT£À�ξÊUÁY£�È®�l³�ÌB»4bW�#³ . �5b�ÎbW�#³�Á;¶*h«§%©0©4��£

»@È®�u»0©0о½ Ù��5/o�o»�³ . ²�»��V/o�¡¶�È®�u»TW�E��Y/+W]£ F3ÅYÏ�À ËÃâ¾À�ÊFÆHG3Å Í È�Î�ÏVÇTè¾õ�ÏuÎÜÈ]ÅYÏ�£À-ÅÜÁ�ίËwÍ�â�Á�Â�Å Í Á�I ÈKJMLVº�²�»ON�P�¶QN�L*hR ©0©eÐ=I

»@ÈS,U©0ë4½ ÙOP5/MJo»�³�ÈKLu»TW�ETNY/+WÇ»�³5W . &0/MJ#³U,=VWJMLV/MJo³!ÁXI1}�&XRl»T/�ù¥&FWXNY/ . ²XNYRܺ�J#³�Á"Ò]&YLnj ³�E�³XJZVWN[,�V�»\VWN],XS�»4R�Nl¶^I}�Ò . ,"¨_NYS3&YLQV`,�N^LWJZNl¶�Ý . ,�ί}�Ò . ,�ί©Të¾Î RYR äXh R ©0©Të�I

»@ÈKPXLfªT¼4½ .aIyÈKP�L'b)N�Jo¶bV8N^L�IkÖ¸b(&FWXNY/�Vu²XN*&YLWN�V8J2Rk&YLQJMN¡³�VWNYWW»TS5SXLV&�»TR�²cVf&IS�»OLbV8Jo»T/�»T/#ÁYNY_XLB»�¶�IedKÇTÂ)É]Å Í ÇT£À-é'ÇTè�kÅÜÁ%Å'ÇOfÜéÜÉhg4dDÇTÂ�É]Å Í ÇTÂ$À2Á%éÜÉ]Å-iaj<ffÁ%éÜÉFÄFÊFÆThXkeÐ�l�Ð0ä0ám1UÐ0á4�5h R ©0ªT¼�I»onKPXLf©Ok4½ .aIpnKP�L'b)N�JMqbV8N^L�Ir.ts\LQV8JMsOuvsOuZwYNY_�L8sOqx1/sOy*JMy�V8LQzXW�P5R^VWzYLV`{qWPXLapYN*`Th R ©0©Yk�I

»on � ©eä¾½ |}J2R�~XsON�u�nKsOLWL�s\y5W��K~TsOLWuZN�q � N�uZuMq�I�+«ÇTÂ�Å-Æ=j<fÃâ�GiÉ]Å�j<fÃâ^Ëmj<fh+xj Í È3ÄX£À�ÊFÆh�ié�À-Å�ʱéÜÅ�I�.�LWN^y�V8J2R^N­-sOuZu±j%y�VmI|hpqWN*R�zYy5W}NYWXJ�V8JZzYyih R ©0©eä�I»����r|oªeä¾½ Ö0Ip�KzOLWL8s4WXJMyXJ$hX.�IT�eN�w�s\yXz5hTsOyUW}��Ip|}zYy�V8sOyTsOLQJ�I�,XS�NYR^JZ��`=JMyXwc~XJZwY~Xu|`�R^zYy5R�P�LWLWN^y�VnWXs\V�s]qQVWLWP5RÃÎ

V8PXLQN�b4sOyXJ+SXPXu�s<V8JMzOy�I(j%yK§cI�nKP5R*R�JasOy5WD§]I¬Ô9s\uMuMN4hTNYWXJ�V8zYLQqYhx+S>xd}�0�SG�5��[����'���(��_f8jYÇe¿{�kÅ�fÃÌÁ�È]ÅÜé�Â$À��TÅ0j¯Ë)+�Ä�fAffÅ�Ê]Â:B�Å��TÅ�èMjÜÈ Í Å�Ê]Â)Á�I�Ý:uZqWN�p�JZN�L`,XR^JMN�yUR�NTh R ©0ªeä�I»���Ý�ª R ½ ÝSI�|�I��KuMsOL'º\N0sOyUWzÝSI�Ö�I3Ý«b)N�LQqWzYy�I{,�`�y�VW~XN�qQJMq-z\� qV`=y5R�~�LWzYyXJZ¡ms\VWJMzYy}q'º\N�uMN�V8zYy�q`�¢zYLk_XLWsOy5R�~XJZyXwV8J+b4N�VWNYbdS�zYLWsOuTuMzOwYJ2R\I�j%y*��j'ÆTÀ-érj¯ËS�xf8j'ÆOf'Ç Í Á��)£¤j<fÜê%ÁÜÉTjÜÈT¥e¦�j<ffê¾Â§j<;�Ê/��Å�À|ƾÉFÂ)Á�¥��/¦�h�pYzYuZP5b)NR k R zO�:���]+t�pIp,FSXLWJZyXwYN�L*h�|¤sm` R ©0ª R I

»���Ý�}�.«©0¼4½ Ö0I��KzYLWLWsTWXJMy�J-hk­�I�Ý:~�LWJMwUh-|DI�}9¨zTZKN4h-s\y5W�Ù�IS.ts4W5_�N^LWwXI ©S~�NKRms\VWN�wYzYLa`ªzO��V�`FS�NYW«wYL8s4SX~wYL8s4b(b4sOLWq�sOyUW�V8~�N�JMLasTW<¬QP�y5R^VWJMzYy�Z_JZV8~�Rms\VWN�wYzYLQJMN^qazO�5WXN�LQJ+p\s\V8JZzYyXq^Iuj%yC'TÂ�É�5ÃÊ]­&)£¤j<fÜê%ÁÜÉTjÜÈ*j¾Ê��fVÇ�È]É���f'Ç Í�Í ÇOffÁ�ÇTÊ3¿(Â�É]Å�À�f`(�ÈeÈ3è À-é'ÇT£À�j¾ÊKÂ%j}+xj Í È3ÄXÂ�Å�f��ié�À-Å�ʱéÜÅ�hXy�P5bQ_�N�L R ëeáOk]JMyg}�®e�S,3hSTsOwYN^qnäT¼¯1Uá4��I:,XSXLQJMyXwYN^LYh R ©0©0¼�I

»���Ýx,Xª0¼4½ ÝSI�|�I9�KuMsOL'º\NTh\ÝSI�Ö�I«Ý«b)N�LQqWzYy±hKsOyUWwÖ�I°.�I:,�JMqbV8uMs�I Ö-P�V8z0b4s\V8J+R(pON�LWJ�E]Rms<V8JMzOy±z\�`ETy�JZV8NÃÎ%qbV�s\VWNR�zYyUR�PXLQLWN�y�V}qV`=qQVWNYb)q¤PXqQJMyXw�V8N*b(S�zYLWsOueuMzOwYJ2RUqVS�N*R�J�E]Rms\VWJMzYy�q�I j%y²([+ad GXfVÇTÊUÁYÇFé�Â$À�j¾ÊUÁDj¾Ê�xf�j'ÆOfVÇ Í�Í À�ÊFÆ[��ÇTÊFÆTÄUÇ%ÆFÅÜÁ�ÇTÊ3¿4��â%Á�Â¯Å Í Á�h�y=PUbQ_�N^L�ª]¢-Ð0¤Ãh5STsOwON�qnÐ4�0�<1XÐT¼YkUh R ©0ª0¼�I»���}�©0ä¾½ j%yXwYz4�Ku�s\qWqWN^y¤s\y5W}|}J2R�~Ts\N�u�}9¨zTZxNOI�,XR�~XN*b4NrN*pOzYuMP�V8JMzOy*JZyCz0_=¬QN*R^V6zYLWJZN�y�V8N*W"b4zFWXN�uZq�l¬Ö³wYL8s4SX~V8LWsOyXqQ�¢zOL'b4s\V8JZzYy3sTS5S�LWz�sTR�~�I j%y#�xf8j%é�&´£¤j<ffê%ÁÜÉTjÜȵj¾Ê±i�j<f Í ÇTè9dHÅ�Â)ÉTjY¿¾Á¥ÇTÂIÂ�É]Å45A��+a7c¶ ·�'ThR ©0©eä=I

»��S|o¨ ú ©0á¾½²Ö0I��KzYLWLWsTWXJMy�J-h���I�|}zYy�V8sOyTsOLQJ-h�ÒKI±¨6zOqWqWJ$h�­�I±Ý�~XLWJZw5h�¨rIi­`N*RܺON^u-h�sOy5WD|�Ii}x¨z4ZKN\I#��ÇTÊ3¿rý�j¸j%êj¯Ë4��f'Ç�È]ɹ��fVÇ Í�Í ÇOffÁQÇTÊ3¿2+xj Í È3ÄF£À�ÊFÆ6ýYâ¤��fVÇ�È]ɺG�f'ÇTÊUÁ)Ëmj<f Í ÇT£À�j¾ÊUÁ�&}F�j¾è�&�5^�ti�j¾ÄFÊ3¿eÇTÂ$À�j¾ÊUÁ�hR�~TsTS�VWN�LQÖ`uMwYN*_XL8s\J2RcÖrS5S�LWz�sTR�~�N�q[V8zK§rLWsTSX~¹©�L8s\yXqQ�¢zYLVb{s<V8JMzOy¹.asOLQV�j�lan�sOqQJ2R/�KzYy5R�N*S�V8q[sOy5W�ezYP5_XuZN�.�PXqW~�zYP�VnÖrS5SXLQz�sTR�~�I � zYLWu+W¤,FR�JMN^y�V8JZE5RTh R ©T©eá�I»��KzYy]©eá¾½ ¨6N^J2WTs\L6�KzYyXL8s4WXJ-hXN*WXJZVWzYL�I[�xf8j%éÜÅÜÅ'¿TÀ�ÊFƾÁ[j¯Ë�Â�É]Å4»mÂ)É{5ÃÊ]­&C£¤j<ffê%ÁÜÉTjÜÈ�j¾ÊU��j¯ËÃÂ;�ÇOfÜÅc+xj¾Êm¼[ÆTÄ�fVÇTÌÂ$À�j¾Ê¤dKÇTÊ3Ç%ÆFÅ Í Å�Ê]£hXpYzOuMP5b)N R ÐOkeä[zO�:���]+t��hpnxN�LWuZJMyCP�IWs�I|h R ©0©eá�I9,FSXLWJZyXwYN�L^I»��KzYLf©0ë¾½ Ö-y5W�LWNms��KzYLQL8sTWXJZyXJ�I (rÊ�(rè¬ÆFÅ�ý�fVÇTÀ-é{�iÅ Í ÇTÊ]Â$À-éÜÁrËmj<f�GXfVÇTÊUÁ�À�Â$À�j¾Ê±��â�Á�Â�Å Í Á¥ÇTÊ3¿2��j'ÆTÀ-é/�xf8j¾ÌÆOfVÇ Í�Í À�ÊFÆOIr.:~X��VW~XN�qQJMqYhp�6yXJ+pON�LQqWJZV�`hz\� .�JMqWsUh R ©T©0ë�I

R �e©

Page 157: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

»�� � ©eá¾½ ¨6N^J2WTs\Lh�KzYyXLWsTWXJ�sOyUW²nKN^LWyX~XsOL'W � N�qQVQ�¢NYR�~�V8N^u�I ©�z%Z�sOLVWXq}s�P�yXJZ�¢zYLVb pON�LQqWJMzOyÑb)zXW�N�u`�¢zOLqWzO��V�ZKsOLQN�R^zYy�ETwOPXL8s\VWJMzYy"b4sOyTsOwONYb)N�y�VmIIj%y}½8+xj¾Ê�·X»�¾Ãh5STsOwON�q R 1 R áFh R ©0©eá=I

»o�r|oªeá¾½ .aI��eN�w�s\yXz0s\y5WC��I�|}zYy�V8sOyTsOLQJ�I�Ö�b)zXWXN^uT�¢zYL\W�JMqQVWLWJ+_XP�V8N*W{qa`�qbV8N*b4q�_XsOqWN*W/zYy/wYLWsTSX~4LWN*Z_LQJZVaÎJMyXwOq�I[¿Tj¾Ä�fÃÊ3ÇTètj¯Ë`([+ad*¥xÀmÁ�­Ã�ľh R ©Tªeá�I

»ßÝ�Ý«ÓI¨�©0©4½ ­�IlÝ�~XLWJZw5hi§]IlÝ:y�wYN�uZqYhi­�IßίÙ�I±Ó�LQN�z%Z_q'º�J-h�sOy5WD§]I±¨_zY¡^N�y�_�N^LWw5h�NYWXJ�V8zYLQq�I���ÇTÊ3¿rý�j¸j%ê*j¯Ë/��fVÇ�È]É��fVÇ Í�Í ÇOfÜÁDÇTÊ3¿Å+xj Í È3ÄFÂ$À�ÊFÆVýYâ«��f'Ç�È]É!GXfVÇTÊUÁ)Ëmj<f Í ÇTÂ$À�j¾ÊUÁ�&ÆF�j¾è�&-5W5^�-(uÈeÈ3è À-é'ÇTÂ$À�j¾ÊUÁ�¥c�iÇTÊ]ÌÆTÄ5Ç%ÆFÅÜÁ�¥�ÇTÊ3¿DG�j¸j¾è�Á�I � zYLWu+W},XR�JZN�y�V8J�E]RTh R ©0©0©�I»ßÝ�­nÓIú�©eá¾½ ­�I�Ý:~�LWJMwUh«¨�I�­`NYRܺ\N�u$h�|�I�ÓrzOLVÛ[h9|�I�}9¨zTZxNTh�}�I�¨_J2_�N�JMLQz5h�Ö�I � sOwYyXN^LYh9sOy5W�Ö�I:�KzYLWLWsTWXJZyXJ�I�IÇTÊ3¿rý�j¸j%ê±j¯Ë3��fVÇ�È]ɳ��f'Ç Í�Í ÇOffÁDÇTÊ3¿«+xj Í È3ÄFÂ$À�ÊFÆVýYâH��fVÇ�È]ÉÇGXfVÇTÊUÁ)Ëmj<f Í ÇT£À�j¾ÊUÁ�&ÈF�j¾è�&`5��iaj¾ÄFÊ3¿eÇT£À�j¾ÊUÁ�h±R�~TsTS�V8N�L�Ö-uZwYNY_�L8sOJ+R�ÖrSUSXLWz�s4R�~XN�qrV8z¥§�L8sTSX~2©�L8sOy�qQ�¢zYLVb{s\VWJMzYyU.tsOLbV�jVj�l�,�JZyXwYuMN.�PXqW~XzOP�VQÖnS5SXLWzYsTR�~3sOy5W��Kz0bdSTsOLWJZqWzYyHZ_JZVW~¹�ezYPU_XuMN4.�PXqW~XzOP�VQÖnS5SXLWzYsTR�~�I j%y�¨_zY¡�N^y�_�N^LWw»¬¨_zY¡Y©eá¾½$h R ©0©eá=I

»ßÝ�Ó�|o¨�©0©4½v­�I�Ý�~XLWJZw5h\­�IòÎaÙ�I�Ó�LWN�z%Z_qVº=J$hS��Ix|}zOy�V8sOyTsOLQJ-hKsOy5Wy§]I«¨_zY¡�N^yF_�N�LQw5h�N*WXJZVWzYLWq^I ��ÇTÊ3¿rý�j¸j%ê�j¯Ë��fVÇ�È]É���fVÇ Í�Í ÇOffÁcÇTÊ3¿D+xj Í È3ÄX£À�ÊFÆLýYâ2��fVÇ�È]ɺGXfVÇTÊUÁ)Ëmj<f Í ÇTÂ$À�j¾ÊUÁ�&DF�j¾è�&t5Q5W5��S+xj¾Ê±é�Ä=fAfÜÅ�ʱé�⸥��ÇOf'ÇTè�è2Å�è À2Á Í ¥«ÇTÊ3¿)BIÀ2Á�Âf�ÀJýYÄF£À�j¾ÊTI � zYLQu2W},XR^JMN�y�VWJZE]R4h R ©0©0©�I»ßÝ�ÓI¨�© R ½ ­�I�Ý�~XLQJMw5h�­�IßίÙ�IlÓ�LQN�z%Z_q'º�J-h�sOyUWK§]I�¨6zY¡^N�y�_�N�LWwUh�N*WXJZVWzYLWq^IcÁ]Â)É{5ÃÊ]¯Å�fÃÊ3ÇT£À�j¾Ê3ÇTè6£Uj<ffê%ÁÜÉTjÜÈ3j¾Ê��fVÇ�È]É/��fVÇ Í�Í ÇOffÁ�ÇTÊ3¿{GiÉ]Å�À�f (uÈeÈ3è À-é'ÇTÂ$À�j¾ÊcÂ%j]+xj Í È3ÄFÂ�Å�f9�ié�À-Å�ʱéÜÅ�It,XSXLQJMyXwYN^LYh R ©0© R I\}vN*R^V8P�LWN®`zOVWN�q_JMy}�Kz0bdSXP�VWN�L6,XR^JMN^y5R�N�äOkeÐ�I

»ßÝ�}�©Yk¾½ ­�I�Ý�~XLWJZw¤s\y5W�|�I�}9¨zTZxNOIÉ��s\VWN�wYzYLQJ2R�sOu�SXLWJZy5R�J+SXuMN^qYh�V8N*R�~XyXJMÊ�PXN^q]sOy5W�LWN^qWPXu�V8q��¢zOL�~�JMwY~XέuMN�pYN�uLWN*SXu�sTR^NYb)N�y�V6qV`=qQVWNYb)q`JZy¥R^z0bdSXP�V8N^L_q'R�JZN�y5R^NOIc(uÈeÈ3è À-Å'¿U+«ÇTÂ�Å-Æ=j<f�À-é'ÇTè���Â@fÃÄ]é�Â$Ä=ffÅÜÁ�h R ¢ R ¤Al Ð R 1UäTëUhR ©0©Yk�I

»ßÝx|¥ªeä¾½ ­�I«Ý�~XLQJMw�sOy5Wªn`I9|¤sO~XL^I iiÄFÊ3¿eÇ Í Å�Ê]Â�ÇTè�Á}j¯Ë4(rè¬ÆFÅ�ý�fVÇTÀ-éC�0È]ÅÜé�À ¼�é'ÇTÂ$À�j¾ÊªË��D7�ÌYÄ5ÇT£À�j¾ÊUÁ¥ÇTÊ3¿5�Ê]À�£À£ÇTè��iÅ Í ÇTÊ]£À-éÜÁ�hUpYzYuZP5b)NI¼cz\�x7 (�G9+t�¤dDj¾Ê�j'ÆOf'Ç�È]ÉeÁ0j¾ÊªGiÉ]Å�j<fÜÅ�£À-é'ÇTè�+xj Í È3ÄF¯Å�f��ié�À-Å�ʱéÜÅ�I,XSXLQJMyXwYN^LYhTnxN�LWuZJMyih R ©0ªeä=I

»ßÝ«b)Nm©Të4½ ÝSI�Ö0I�Ý�b4N^LWqWzOy�I ©�NYbdS�zYLWsOu�sOyUW³|}zFWTsOuI}vzYwYJ+ROI j%y�i�j<f Í ÇTè Í jY¿FÅ�è�ÁHÇTÊ3¿�Á%Å Í ÇTÊ]Â$À-éÜÁ�hpYzYuZP5b)N}nÍzO���IÇTÊ3¿rý�j¸j%ê�j¯Ë3GiÉ]Å�j<ffÅ�£À-é'ÇTè�+xj Í È3ÄF¯Å�fC�ié�À-Å�ʱéÜÅ�h�STsOwYN^q�©0©0á¸1 R ëeáTÐ�I¦Ý:uZqWN�p�JZN�L*hR ©0©0ë�I

»ßÝ9.:.�§I©0©4½ ­�ITÝ:~�LWJMwUheÒKI�.asOLWJZqWJ|Î%.�LWN�qQJ2R^NTh�sOyUW)|�I�§rs¯¬QN*Z_qVº=J@I�­`JMwO~XÎ%uZN*pYN^u�LQNYSXuMsTR�N*b4N^y�V qV`=qQVWNYb)q«Z_J�V8~csTSFÎSXuMJ+Rms\VWJMzYyrV8zesOuMwYN*_XL8s\J2R9q'S�NYR�J�E]Rms<V8JMzOy]sOy5W�S�N^VWLWJ�y�N^V8q^I�j%yd§cI4¨_zY¡�N^yF_�N�LQw5h�NYW�JZV8zOLYh�½7:Î�d*��·�·Q¾AI� zOLWu2W*,FR�JMN^y�V8JZE5RTh R ©0©T©�I»ßÝ9.9,5á\k4½ ­�I�Ý�~XLQJMw5hp|DI�. �¢N^y5WXN�L*h�sOy5W¥­�I3Ù�I�,XR�~Xy�N�J2W�N�L�Id§�L8s4SX~hwYL8sTbdb4sOLWq^l:sOy¤s\uMwYN*_XL8sOJ+R�sTS5S�LWz�sTR�~�Ij%y�Ë�Á]Â�É4(rÊ]Ê]ÄUÇTè���â Í ÈTj%Á�À�Ä Í j¾Ê¤�p;�À�Â�éÜÉFÀ�ÊFÆÕÇTÊUÁ-(rÄF§j Í ÇTÂ-Ç�GiÉ]Å�j<fÃâ4hUSTsOwYN^q R ¼eá¸1 R ªTëUh R ©0áOk�I»ßÝ�¨a©k©0©4½ �-I�Ý�L'b)N�u$h-|DI�¨6PUWXzYuZ�¯h6sOyUW�§]IK©asON^y�VW¡�N^L�I ½797:Î��e·�·Q¾Ãh�R�~TsTS�VWN�LC©S~XNDÖ�§�§ÈsTS5S�LWz�sTR�~�l}�sOyXwYPTs\wYNrsOy5W*N�yep=JMLQzYy5b)N�y�VmI � zYLWu+W¤,FR�JMN^y�V8JZE5RTh R ©0©T©�I»ßÝ:qbVÜ©eä�½ ÙYsTRܺe`�Ý�qbV8P5_XuZJMN^LYhtN*WXJZVWzYL�IÏ�xf8j%éÜÅÜÅ'¿TÀ�ÊFƾÁCj¯ËdÂ)É]Å0Á]Â)É�ÇTÊ3¿2'TÂ�ÉÐ5ÃÊ]­&²£Uj<ffê%ÁÜÉTjÜÈHj¾Ê3��j¯ËÃÂ@;�ÇOffÅ+xj¾Êm¼[ÆTÄ�fVÇT£À�j¾Ê}dKÇTÊ3Ç%ÆFÅ Í Å�Ê]Â$hFpYzYuZP5b4N R ë0ëeä[zO�:���[+t��hpnKN^LWuMJZyCP�I8s�I+h R ©T©eä�I9,XSXLQJMyXwON�L�I»ßÒtJMq'©0ª4½ j%yXwYLQJ2WÕÒaJMq'R�~�N�L�Ird�jY¿FÅ�è�è À�ÊFÆ���Å�Ä�fVÇTèp��Å�Â;Kj<ffê%Áe;�À�Â�ÉÐ��fVÇ�È]ÉDGXfVÇTÊUÁ)Ëmj<f Í ÇT£À�j¾Êh��â%Á�Â�Å Í Á�I-.�~T�V8~XN^qWJZqYhT�6yXJ+pON�LWqQJZV¸¨s\V�Ý�LWu�s\yXwYN�yFΧ®)¨PXLQy�_�N^LWw5h R ©0©0ª�I�Ö-L'_�N�J�V8qV_�N^LWJ2R�~�VWN�WXN�qkj%yXqbV8JZVWP�V8q���¨PXL\b{s<V8~XNÃÎb{s<V8JMqVR�~XN�|¤sOqVR�~XJMy�N�y¤P�y5W¤��s<V8N�yepON�L8s\L'_�N�JZVWPXyXwo¢£j%y��¢zOL'b4s\V8J+ºU¤ÃhXk R¸Ñ�RYR I

»ßÒ�Ó�©k©0ª4½ j�I�ÒtJZq'R�~XN^LYh�|�I�Ó�zFR�~ih�sOy5W=§]I�©asON�y�VW¡�N�L^Iy}vzXR�sOu[p=JZN*Z_qrzYyDWXJMqbV8LQJ2_XP�VWNYWÐqa`�qbV8N*b4q�sOy5WÐVW~XN�JZLR�z0bdb[PXy�J2Rms<V8JMzOy�Iøj%y,§cI�Ý�yXwYN^uMq�sOy5W�§]I�¨_zY¡�N^yF_�N�LQw5h N*WXJZVWzYLWq*h9�xf8j%é�&�j¯ËCÒ¾Â�ÉÐ5ÃÊ]¯Å�fÃÊ3ÇT£À�j¾Ê3ÇTè£Uj<ffê%ÁÜÉTjÜÈ�j¾ÊºGiÉ]Å�j<fÃâ�ÇTÊ3¿�(�È3è�è À-é'ÇT£À�j¾Ê�j¯Ë[��f'Ç�È]É�GXfVÇTÊUÁYÇVËmj<f Í ÇTÂ$À�j¾Ê]h=y�P5bQ_�N�L�V8L¯Î%LQJ|ί©Tª¾ÎaÐTë R hSTsOwYN^qk�eë¯1F��áFh5©0ª�I

»¬§�­nÓ�©0á¾½ ÒpsT_XJMz�§rsTWXP5R*R�J-h±¨6N^J2º\z1­`N*RܺON�u$hvsOy5WD|}sOy�PXN�u�ÓrzFR�~�ID�Kz0b�_XJMyXJZyXw1§�L8s4SX~U©�L8sOyXqb�¢zYL'b4s\VWJMzYyXqZ_JZVW~�©�NYbdS�zOL8sOu�}vzYwYJ+ROI R ©0©eá=I�ÝtÓ=V8N^y5WXNYW�s4_XqQVWL8sTR�V[sTR*R�N*S�V8N*W¹�¢zYL � zYLVº�qW~Xz0S�zYy�§�N�y�N�L8s\u©S~XN�zOLV`CzO��§rLWsTSX~h©�L8sOyXqb�¢zYL'b4s\VWJMzYy*,F`=qbV8NYb)q�I

R äTë

Page 158: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

»¬§�­nÓ�©Tª4½ ÒKI3§rsTW5WXP5R*R�J$hl¨rI3­`N*RܺON�u$h�sOyUWÐ|�I3Ó�zXR�~�IC|}zFWXN�ua�K~XN*Rܺ�JMyXw"§�L8s4SX~XÎ�j%y�VWN�L'S�LWN^VWNYWU©�NYbdS�zYL8sOuÒTzYL'b[P�u�s�I:j%y¦§cI[Ý�yXwYN�uZq]sOy5W¦§]I[¨6zY¡^N�y�_�N�LWwUh�NYWXJ�V8zYLQqYhx�xf8j%é�&ªj¯ËhÒ¾Â�É25ÃÊ]­&�£¤j<fÜê%ÁÜÉTjÜÈ«j¾ÊGiÉ]Å�j<fÃâHÇTÊ3¿���fVÇ�È]ɵG�f'ÇTÊUÁ)Ëmj<f Í ÇT£À�j¾Ê]h�y�P5bQ_�N�L[V8L¯Î%LQJ|ί©Tª¾ÎaÐTë R h�STs\wYN�qdÐT©0и1UÐT©0©Xh:.tsTWXN^L'_�zYLWy±hR ©0©0ª�I

»¬§�¨�©0ª4½ |¤sOLbV8JMy §�LWzT®YN�Î�¨6~XzFWXN\I Ö-uZwYNY_XLWs!V8LWsOyXqQ�¢zOL'b4s\V8JZzYyÔqV`=qQVWNYb)q«sOy5WÕV8~XN^JMLyR�zTb(S�zYqWJ�V8JZzYy�Ij%y ÝSIIÖ-qQVWN�qQJ�sOyXzUh{NYW�JZV8zOLYh/�xf�j%é�& i±ÄFÊ3¿eÇ Í Å�Ê]Â�ÇTèe(�ÈeÈ�f8jYÇFéÜÉ]ÅÜÁ,Â%jH��j¯ËÃÂ@;�ÇOffÅ37\ÊFÆTÀ�ʱÅÜÅ�fÃÀ�ÊFÆÂ@i�(e�X7)¶ ·Y�^ľh�y=PUbQ_�N^L R k0ªeÐ0JZy¥}�®-�S,lh]STsOwYN^q R ëeá¸1 R Ð0Ð�I:,XS�LWJMy�wYN�L*h]ÖrSXLQJMu R ©T©0ª�I

»¬§�¨�©0©4½ |¤sOLbV8JMy1§rLQz0®YN�Î�¨6~�zXWXN\I^Ö{R�zTb(S�zYqWJ�V8JZzYyTsOu�R�zTb(STs\LWJMqQzYy/zO��qVS�N*R�JZE5Rms\VWJMzYyXqKzO��V8~XN�s\uZV8N^LWyTs<V8JMy�w_XJZV^SXLWzOVWzXR^zYutJZy2�S�S,2sOy5WD�-®�j%©KÖ~_TsOqWN*W�zOy2sOuMwYN*_XL8s{VWL8sOy�qQ�¢zYLVb{s\VWJMzYy}qV`=qQVWNYb)q�Iwj%y3�xf8j%é�&j¯Ë�Â)É]Åe˾Á�Â�5ÃÊ]¯Å�fÃÊ3ÇT£À�j¾Ê3ÇTè9£Uj<ffê%ÁÜÉTjÜÈ2j¾Ê45�Ê]Â�Å-ÆOf'ÇTÂ�Å'¿�iaj<f Í ÇTè�dHÅ�Â)ÉTjY¿¾Á0¢58i dŶ ·�·�ľhYÖ9zYLVº�h��nÓ�hÙOPXyXN R ©0©T©�IeV8z4sTS5S�NmsOLSJZy},XSXLWJZyXwYN^Lk}�®-�S,�I

»ß­e��Ý«}�©0¼4½ ¨�IU­`N*RܺON�u$h]Ö0Ip�KzOLWL8s4WXJMyXJ$hU­�I]Ý�~XLWJZw5hXs\y5W}|�I]}vz�N�ZKN\I�­`zYLQJM¡�zOy�V8sOu�s\y5W1pYN�LbV8J+RmsOu�qQV8LQP5R^VWPXLWJZyXwzO��V�`FS�NYW3wYLWsTSX~¹VWL8sOyXqb�¢zYL'b4s\VWJMzYyDqV`=qQVWNYb)q�I°j%yºdKÇTÂ�É�&���Â@fÃÄ]é�&�À�Ê«+xj Í È�&D�ié�À-Å�ʱéÜÅ�h[STsOwYN^q¼]¢$¼0¤�l�¼ R k¯1X¼4�eªUh R ©0©0¼�I

»ß­`NYRY©eä¾½ ¨6N^J2º\z1­`N*RܺON�u@I�Ö-uZwYNY_XLWsOJ2RQ§rLWsTSX~U©�L8s\yXqQ�¢zYLVb{s<V8JMzOyXqnZ_J�V8~zÖnS5SXuMJ+Rms\VWJMzYyU�KzYy5WXJ�V8JZzYyXq�I¹|¤sOq¯ÎV8N^LYî�q_VW~XN�qQJMq*hT©_��nxN�LWuZJMyih R ©0©eä�I

»ß­`NYRY©0ª4½ ¨6N^J2º\z¥­6NYRܺ\N�u�IÇ>[È]Å�Ê#��fVÇ�È]ɪGXfVÇTÊUÁ)Ëmj<f Í ÇT£À�j¾ÊD��â%Á�Â¯Å Í Á�Ì_(´��Å�;H(uÈeÈ�f8jYÇFéÜÉDÂ%jD+xj Í ÈTj%Á�À�ÌÂ$À�j¾Ê3ÇTè�d�jY¿FÅ�è�è À�ÊFÆhj¯Ë)+xj¾Ê±é�Ä=fAffÅ�Ê]ÂuÇTÊ3¿)�kÅ'ÇFé�£À��TÅ���â%Á�Â¯Å Í Á�I�.�~T��VW~XN�qQJMq*hT©_��nxN�LWuZJMyih R ©0©0ª�I»ß­rÝ � ��©0á¾½¦¨�I3­6NYRܺON^u-h�­�I3Ý:~�LWJMwUh���I � zYuZVWN�L*h�s\y5WzÖ0I��KzYLQL8sTW�JMyXJ@I1j%y�VWN�wYLWs\V8JZyXw4VW~XN0qVS�N*R�J�E]Rms\VWJMzYy*V8N*R�~XÎyXJMÊ�PXN^q_zO��wYL8sTS�~*VWL8sOyXqb�¢zYL'b4s\VWJMzYyCs\y5WCV8NYbdS�zYL8sOu�uMzYwOJ2ROIrj%y2�xf8j%é�&rj¯Ë-d*iS+t��¶ ·X»^¥a�_fVÇTÂ$À2Á�è|ÇO�¾ÇThR ©0©eá=I

»ß­r­`©k©T¼4½ Ö0I�­-sT_�N�u$h�¨�I�­`N*RܺON�u$hKs\y5W¦§cIa©ts\N�y�V8¡^N�L�I §rLWsTSX~3wYLWsTb(b4sOLQq�Z_J�V8~3yXN^w�s\V8J|pYNCs4S5SXuMJ+Rms\VWJMzYyR�zYyUWXJZVWJMzYyXq^I[�0È]ÅÜé�À£ÇTèiÀ2ÁÜÁ�Ä]Å[j¯ËeiiÄFÊ3¿eÇ Í Å�Ê]Â-Ç05�ÊmËmj<f Í ÇT£À-é'ÇFÅ�h]ÐT¼5¢@kUh¬��¤�h R ©0©0¼�I»ß­e|}© � ©eä�½Q¨_N�J+ºOz�­6NYRܺON^u-hnÙ�¨PXLWwON�yH|±¨PXuZuMN^LYh�§rsT_XLQJMN^uMNh©ts\N�y�V8¡^N�LYh`sOy5WOÖ-yXyXJ+º<s � s\wYyXN�L^I Ö�VQV8LWJ+_XP�VWNYW§rLWsTSX~�©aLWsOyXqQ�¢zOL'b4s\V8JZzYyXqcZ_JZV8~#�KzYy�V8LWzOuMuMN*WOÖnS5SXuMJ+Rms\VWJMzYy�zO��¨_PXuZN�q�I j%y¸§]I«Ô9s\uMJMN^y�V8N}sOy5WÒKI�¨_zYqWqQN�uZuMz5hvN*WXJZVWzYLWq*h��xf8j%é�&�+xj¾è�èMj�ÌYÄFÀ�Ä Í j¾Ê#��fVÇ�È]ÉHGXfVÇTÊUÁ)Ëmj<f Í ÇTÂ$À�j¾Ê ÇTÊ3¿¥À�Â�Á0(�ÈeÈ3è À-é'ÇT£À�j¾ÊÀ�Ê3+xj Í È3ÄF¯Å�f��ié�À-Å�ʱéÜÅ�h R ©0©eä�Ir©�NYR�~XyXJ+RmsOu�¨_NYS�zYLbV6nyÎ R ©XhT�`yXJ|pYN^LWqWJ�V�s\VkW�N�uZN�qkj%uMuZN�q_n�s\uMNms\LWq�I»ß­ � ©eä¾½ ¨6N^J2º\z ­`NYRܺ\N�uÕsOyUW Ö-yXyXJ+º<s � sOwOyXN�L^I Ý�yXqWP�LWJMy�w R�zYyXqQJMqbV8N�yUR*` zO� R^zYy5WXJ�V8JZzYyXqWuwYL8s4SX~×wYL8s4b(b4sOLWqøÎ�s R�zOyXqQVWLWP5R�V8J+pONØsTS5SXLQz�sTR�~�I j%y �xf8j%é�& j¯Ë��X7-�x��([�x��(U¶ ·�'��fVÇ�È]ÉÇ�kÅ�;�f�À�£À�ÊFÆ ÇTÊ3¿É+xj Í È3ÄXÂ-ÇTÂ$À�j¾Ê]h*y�P5bQ_�N�LOÐ�I Ý�uMN*R^V8LQzYyXJ+RÅ®6zOV8N^qºzO�¤©6�S,lh R ©0©eä�I~�VWVfS�l ÑYÑ Z�Z�ZrI�N^uMqWN�p=JMN�L^I�y�u Ñ uZzXR�s\V8N Ñ N�y�VfR^q Ñ pOzYuMPUb4NmÐ�I�~�V'b4u@I

»òjb,5Ï�ª0©4½ jb,5Ï[Ivj%y��¢zYLVb{s<V8JMzOy�SXLWzFR�N^qWqWJZyXw�qa`�qbV8N*b4q]1¦Ï^S�N�y#,�`�qbV8N*b4q(j%y�VWN�LVR�zYyXy�NYR^VWJMzYy�1¦}�Ïe©�Ï�,¹1ÖÙ�¢zYLVb{sOu«WXN^q'R^LWJ2S�V8JMzOy�V8NYR�~�yXJMÊ�PXN1_Ts\qWNYW�zYy�VW~XN{VWNYbdS�zYLWsOu9zYL'WXN^LWJZyXwUzO�_z0_�qWN�Lap\s\V8JZzYyTsOu\_�NÃÎ~Tsmp=JMzYPXL^IIj%y�VWN�LQyTs\V8JZzYyTsOuv,=V�sOyUWTsOL'Wgjb,5Ï?ª0ª0ëeáXhUjb,5ÏQh R ©0ª0©�I

»¬Ù0¨n© R ½ �[IiÙYs\yXqWqQN�yXqrsOyUWH§cIl¨6zO¡�N�y�_�N�LQwXI�,=V8LQP5R^VWPXLWN*WUV8L8s\yXqQ�¢zYLVb{s<V8JMzOyXq-s\y5WzR�zTb(SXP�V�s\VWJMzYy}wYL8sTS�~Xq�¢zYL4sTR^VWzYL{wYLWsTbdb{sOLQq�I j%y¸Ý�~XLWJZw¹N^V/sOu�I�»ßÝ�ÓI¨�© R ½$hkSTsOwYN^q��0�e¼¸1F�e¼0ë�I }vNYR�V8PXLQNЮ`zOVWN�q/JZy�Kz0bdSXP�V8N^L6,XR�JZN�y5R^NQä\keÐ�I

»ßÓ�}�§I© R ½ ,�I°|�I�Ó�s4SXu�sOy±h�Ù�I�.aI�}vz%`�sOuZu-hxsOy5W#,�I�Ó]I\§rz=N�LQJMyXw�I ,XS�NYR�J���`=JMyXwDR�zOy5R�PXLQLWN^y�V{u�sOy�wYPTsOwYN^q)sOy5WqV`=qQVWNYb)q�Z_JZVW~CÚ�Î%wYLWsTb(b4sOLQq�Irj%y"Ý�~XLQJMw[N�V_sOu@I�»ßÝ�ÓI¨�© R ½$hUSTs\wYN�q��eá0ä¸1F�eªT©�I^}vNYR�V8PXLQNr®`zOVWN�q�JZy�Kz0bdSXP�V8N^L6,XR�JZN�y5R^NQä\keÐ�I

»ßÓrzFRm©T¼4½ |¤sOy�PXN^u±Ó�zFR�~�Ir|}zFWXN�uZuMJZN�LWP�yXwrPXy5WC®`sTR�~eZKN^JMq�WXN^L�Ó�zYyXqQJMqbV8N�y�¡npYzOyÕpYN�LbV8N^JMuZVWN�y4©aLWsOyXq8s4º�VWJMzYyFÎq'b)zXW�N�uMuZN�y��A¨PXL{��s<V8N�y�_Ts\y5º�qV`=qQVWNYb)NKb4J�V/sOuZwYNY_�L8sOJZq'R�~XN^yy§�L8sTSX~�wYL8sTbdb4s\V8J+ºON�y�I ©�NYR�~�yXJ2R�sOu¨6N*S�zOLQV�©0¼¾Î%k0¼Uh�©_��nxN�LWuZJMyih R ©0©0¼�I

»ß}�Ó � ©Yk¾½ |�I]}9¨zTZxNTh�|�I5ÓrzOLVÛ[hTsOy5W"Ö0I � sOwOyXN�L^I�Ö`y"Ö-uMwONY_XLWsOJ2R�ÒTLWsTb4N�ZKzOL'ºc�¢zYL�V8~XN�©�L8s\yXqQ�¢zYLVb{s<V8JMzOyzO�]Ö�VQV8LWJ+_XP�VWNYWc§�L8sTS�~Xq�I\j%y¹GlÅ�f Í ��f'Ç�È]É��kÅ�;�fÃÀ�Â$À�ÊFÆ�Ì`GiÉ]Å�j<fÃâIÇTÊ3¿-�xf'ÇFé�£À-éÜÅ�hTSXsOwYN�q R ªeä¸1 R ©0©�I� JMuZN*`0h R ©0©Yk�I

R ä R

Page 159: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

»ß}x¨z4Z�©Yk4½ |}J2R�~XsON�u�}9¨zTZxNOI�Ö`uMwYN*_XL8s\J2Res4S5SXLWzYsTR�~CV8z]qWJZyXwYuZN�Î�S�PXqW~XzOP�VSwYLWsTSX~/V8LWsOyXqb�¢zYL'b4s\V8JZzYy�I*GiÉ]Å�j<fÜÅ�£À�Ìé'ÇTè�+xj Í È3ÄF¯Å�fe�ié�À-Å�ʱéÜÅ�hi¢ R ë0©0¤�l R ª R 1UÐTÐ4�5h R ©0©Yk�I�,�~XzYLbV�pYN�LQqWJZzYy}z\�a©�NYR�~�Iu¨_NYS�zYLQV�©Të Ñ ëeäXh�©_�nKN�LQuMJZyih R ©T©0ë�I

»ß}x¨z4Z�©0ª4½ |}J2R�~XsON�u�}9¨zTZxNOIcÝ�JMyC�¢zYLVb{s\uMN�LuÖ-yXqWs\V8¡�¡�PXLnÝ�y�V�Z_J2Rܺ�uMPXy�w{u�s\yXwYuMN*_XJMwON�L_,�z\��V�Z�sOLQN�qa`�qbV8N*b4N0sOP��WXN�L6n�s\qWJMq�pOzYyo§rLWsTSX~XwYLWsTbdb{s\VWJ2º\N�y�Ie©�NYR�~�yXJ2R�sOu�¨6N*S�zYLbV�©0ª¾Î��5hX©_��nKN�LQuMJZyih R ©T©0ª�I

»ß}�¨�©0ª4½ |�Ii}vuMsT_XL=ÛN^qesOyUWDÒKI±¨_zYqQqWN�uZu¸ÛzXI2.�PXqQ~XzYP�VIR^z0bdSXuMN*b4N^y�VWq`�¢zYL-sOL'_�JZV8LWsOLV`gSTs\LQV8JMsOu�sOuMwONY_XLWsOq�IDj%y§cI�Ý�yXwYN^uMq`sOy5WD§]I3¨6zY¡^N�y�_�N�LWwUh�NYW�JZV8zOLWqYhv�xf8j%é�&)j¯Ë)Ò¾Â�Éh5ÃÊ]¯Å�fÃÊ3ÇT£À�j¾Ê3ÇTè6£Uj<ffê%ÁÜÉTjÜȱj¾Ê#GiÉ]Å�j<f�âÇTÊ3¿[(uÈ3è�è À-é'ÇTÂ$À�j¾Ê�j¯Ë)��fVÇ�È]É�G�f'ÇTÊUÁYÇVËmj<f Í ÇT£À�j¾Ê]h�y�P5b�_�N^L_VWLaέLWJ|Î�©0ª¾Î¯ÐTë R h�STsOwON�q�ª0ë¯1Xª0áXh]©0ª�I»�|¤sOy�áT¼¾½ ÝSI�|¤sOyXN^q�I0(rè¬ÆFÅ�ý�f'ÇTÀ-é/GiÉ]Å�j<f�À-ÅÜÁ�I�,FSXLWJZyXwYN�L�Ô:N^LWuMsOw5h R ©0áT¼�I

»�|¤sOy]©T�4½ ÜtIx|¤sOyXyTs�I nKN�`YzYy5Wyb)zFWXN�ukR�~XN*Rܺ=JZyXwXI j%y�Ò¾Â)É�5�Ê]Â�&´+xj¾ÊmËmÅ�ffÅ�ʱéÜÅÐj¾Ê�+xj Í È3ÄF¯Å�f{(rÀ£¿FÅ'¿F3Å�fÃÀ ¼�é'ÇTÂ$À�j¾Ê]hFpYzYuZP5b4NIª R ª]zO�9���[+t��h]STsOwYN^qnÐ0ÐTë¯1UÐTÐ R I:,XS�LWJMy�wYN�L*h R ©0©T��I

»�|}JMu2ª0©4½ ¨�IT|}JMuZyXN�L^Ih+xj Í�Í ÄXÊ]À-é'ÇT£À�j¾ÊDÇTÊ3¿¤+xj¾Ê±é�Ä=fAfÜÅ�ʱé�â<I�.�LWN�y�VWJ2R�NÃί­`sOuMu$h R ©0ªT©�I»�|oÓI©0¼4½ ÙON*Û�|¤s\wYN�N�sOy5WoÙON*ÛHÓ�LWsTb4N^L�Ir�r`=yTsTb)J2R�,=V8LQP5R^VWPXLWN�JMy},�zO��V�ZKsOLQN�Ö`L'R�~XJ�V8N*R^V8P�LWN�q^I�j%y}��smp�J+W§�s\LWu�s\yihtN*WXJZVWzYLYh:�Kf8j%é�&�j¯Ë(Â)É]Å0Á]Â)ÉÐ([+ad ��5\�K��>xieG#��â Í ÈTj%Á�À�Ä Í j¾Ê,Â�É]Å4i�j¾ÄFÊ3¿eÇTÂ$À�j¾ÊUÁhj¯Ë��j¯ËÃÂ@;�ÇOffÅe7\ÊFÆTÀ�ʱÅÜÅ�fÃÀ�ÊFÆTh R ©0©0¼�I

»�|¤.«©eо½ Ü�zY~X~Ts\L)|¤sOyXyTs2sOyUWwÖnb4JZL].�y=P�N�uMJ@I GiÉ]Å�G3Å Í ÈTj<f'ÇTè:��j'ÆTÀ-é¤j¯Ë{�kÅ'ÇFé�£À��TÅgÇTÊ3¿º+xj¾Ê±é�Ä=fAfÜÅ�Ê]Â��â�Á�Â�Å Í Á�¥��0È]ÅÜé�À ¼�é'ÇT£À�j¾ÊTI�,XSXLQJMyXwYN^L�Ô:N�LQu�sOw5h R ©0©eÐ�I»�|¤.«¨n©0©¾½ ��I�|}zYy�V�sOyXsOLWJ$hv|�Iv.�JZqQV8zOLWNTh�sOy5WDÒKIl¨6zOqWqWJ@I3½7:Î�d*��·�·Q¾Ãh±R�~TsTS�VWN�L´|}zFWXN�uZJMyXwh�KzOy5R�PXLQLWN^y�VYh|}z0_XJZuMN`sOy5Wh�Kz=zYLVWXJMyTs<V8NYW/,F`=qQVWNYb)qup=J�sQ§�L8s4SX~/©�L8sOyXqb�¢zYL'b4s\VWJMzYyXq_I � zYLQu2WC,FR�JMN^y�V8JZE5RTh R ©0©0©�I»�|¤. � ©eо½ ¨�I¬Ö0I�|*JMuMy�N�LYh]Ù�Ip.tsOLQLWz%ZIhpsOy5W}�[I � s\u2ºON^L�I�ÖøRmsOu+R�PXuZPXqSzO��b)z0_XJZuMNnSXLWzFR�N^qWqWN^qYh�J�Ý!JMJ@I�5�ÊmËmj<fÃÌÍ ÇTÂ$À�j¾ÊKÇTÊ3¿¤+xj Í È3ÄXÂ-ÇT£À�j¾Ê]h R ë0ë]¢ R ¤�l R 1F�0¼]ÝÚ��á�11á0áXh R ©T©eÐ�I»�|U,U©0¼4½ ÒKIO|}zYuMuZN�LtsOy5Wc.aI�,=V8N�pYN�y�q�I6©S~XNkÝ�WXJMy�_XPXLQwY~)�KzYy5R^PXLWLQN�y5R�` � zYL'º�_�N�y5R�~)PXqWN^L�b{s\y=PXsOu�I R ©0©0¼�I~�VWVfS�l ÑYÑ Z�Z�ZrI�W5R^q�I�NYW�I�sTR\I�P5º Ñ ~�z0b4N Ñ R*Zk_�I

»o®`JMNY©eá¾½ .aN�V8N�Le®`JMN*_�N^LQV�I¤(ÞGlÅ Í ÈTj<fVÇTè���j'ÆTÀ-é\Ëmj<f�Â)É]Å��0È]ÅÜé�À ¼�é'ÇT£À�j¾ÊHÇTÊ3¿±F3Å�fÃÀ ¼�é'ÇT£À�j¾Ê�j¯Ë�BIÀ2Á�ÂfÃÀJýYÄXÂ�Å'¿�^ÅÜÉUÇO�%À�j¾Ä=f�Iµ.:~X�ÉV8~�N�qWJZqYha�`yXJ|pYN^LWqWJ�V¯¨s\V�­6JMu2W�N�qW~�N�J2bgh�ÒpsTR�~�_�N^LWN�J+R�~���¨PXL�|¤s<V8~XN*b{s\VWJ2º�h�j%y��¢zYL¯Îb{s<V8J2º)PXy5W}®-s<V8PXLaZ_JMqWqQN�yXqVR�~Ts\��VWN�yih R ©0©eá=I

»o.aN^Vf¼eо½ �-I�Ö�I�.aN^VWLWJ@I*Î]j Í�Í ÄFÊ]À2êTÇTÂ$À�j¾Ê Í À� (rÄXÂ%j Í ÇT¯Å�ÊTI{.�~T��V8~�N�qWJZqYh�,XR�~XLQJZ��V8N^yoWXN^qrj%yXqbV8J�V8P�VWN�q`��¨PXLj%yXqQVWLWP5b)N�y�VWN�uMuZN�|¤s\VW~XNYb4s\V8J+º�hTnKzYyXy±h R ©0¼eÐ�I»o.:y�P�áTá¾½ Ö0I�.�y�PXN�uZJ�I«©S~XN)©aN*b(S�zYL8s\u«}�zOwYJ2R[z\��SXLQzYwYL8s4b4q^IÑj%y3�xf�j%é�&ÐËY�0Â�É}(rÊ]Ê�&/587:797���â Í È�&2j¾Ê

iaj¾ÄFÊ3¿eÇT£À�j¾ÊUÁ0j¯Ë)+xj Í È3ÄF¯Å�fe�ié�À-Å�ʱéÜÅ�h5SXsOwYN�qk�e¼¸1Uä0áXh R ©eá0á�I»�ß�,Xª R ½ Ù�I°.�Ixß�P�JMN�uZuMNhsOyUWvÙ�Ix,�J��sTº�JMq�I ,FS�N*R�JZE5Rms\VWJMzYy�sOy5W¦pYN�LQJZE]R�s\V8JZzYy±zO�^R^zYy5R�P�LWLWN^y�V/qV`=qbV8NYb)q{JZyR�N^q8sOL^I�j%yÐ�xf�j%é�&�j¯ËIÂ)É]Å�i«À ËÃÂ�É45ÃÊ]¯Å�fÃÊ3ÇT£À�j¾Ê3ÇTè���â Í ÈTj%Á�À�Ä Í À�ʤ�xf8j'ÆOfVÇ Í�Í À�ÊFÆTh R ©0ª R I»ß¨`s\Vf©eá¾½ ¨`s<V8JMzOyTsOu3qWz\��V�Z�sOLQNûR^z�z0S�N�LWs\V8JZzYy�I �6yXJZEXNYWñb)zFWXN�uZJMyXwÕu�s\yXwYPTsOwONOI smp\sOJMuMsT_XuZN p�JMsà¸á%á�â=ã°äOä¯å:å9å-æ�ç�è¸á8éëê�ì<è�í�æoî�ê�ï h R ©T©eá�I

»ß¨`n�. ú © R ½ Ù�I5¨_P5bQ_Ts\PXwY~ihX|�ITnKuMsO~TsUh � IX.�LWN*b4N^LWu�s\yXJ-hXÝSI]Ý�W5WU`0hXsOy5W � I5}vzYLQN�yXqQzYy�I*>3ý@?mÅÜé�Â$ÌA>�fÃÀ-Å�Ê]Â�Å'¿d�jY¿FÅ�è À�ÊFÆ�ÇTÊ3¿cBQÅÜÁ�À|ÆTÊTIr.�LWN^y�VWJ2R^N�­`sOuMulj%y�VWN�LQyTs\V8JZzYyTsOu$h R ©0© R I

»ß¨6N^JåªT�T½ ­`zYLQqQV�¨6N^J2R�~XN^u�IÏ��ÂfÃÄ�é�£Ä�fVÇTèa5�Ê3¿TÄ]é�£À�j¾Ê#j¾Ê¹��ÇOfãÀ£ÇTèt(rè¬ÆFÅ�ý�fVǾÁ�h�pYzYuZP5b4N R ª�IÉ|¤s\V8~�NYb4s\V8J+RmsOu¨6N^qWN�sOL'R�~ih�Önº\s4WXNYb)JMNÃÎ�Ô:N�LQu�sOw[nKN�LQuMJMy±h R ©0ªT��I

»ß¨6N^Jåªeá¾½ � zOuZ�¢w�sOy�w�¨_N�JMqQJMwXI .�u�sTR^N Ñ VWL8sOyXqQJZVWJMzYyªqa`=qQV8N*b4q^I j%y²��Å�ÂfÃÀ���Å�Â)Á2�µ+\Å�Ê]Â@fVÇTèSd�jY¿FÅ�è�ÁKÇTÊ3¿GiÉ]Å�À�f6�xf8jÜÈ]Å�fÃÂ$À-ÅÜÁ�&2hFpYzYuZP5b4N^Ð0ä4�[z\� ��ÅÜé�£Ä=fÜÅ`��j¾Â�ÅÜÁIÀ�Ê�+xj Í È3ÄXÂ�Å�f-�ié�À-Å�ʱéÜÅ�hFSTsOwYN^q RYR áe1 R � R I,XSXLQJMyXwYN^L�Ô:N�LQu�sOw5h R ©0ªeá�I

»ß¨6z0b(©0¼4½ �[I�¨6zTbQ_TsTR�~ih�N*WXJZVWzYL�I��xf8j%é�&2ËY�0Â)ɤ5ÃÊ]¯Å�fÃÊ3ÇT£À�j¾Ê3ÇTèS+xj¾ÊmËmÅ�ffÅ�ʱéÜÅ{j¾Ê���j¯ËÃÂ;�ÇOffÅ]7uÊFÆTÀ�ʱÅÜÅ�fÃÀ�ÊFÆTh}vzYq�Ö-uMsTb4J�V8zYq*hT�uÖ�h R ©0©0¼�I�j¯Ý�Ý«ÝSI

»ß¨6zY¡Y©eá¾½ §rLQ¡�N^wYzYLW¡^¨6zY¡^N�y�_�N�LWwUhTNYWXJ�V8zYL^I0�IÇTÊ3¿rý�j¸j%ê4j¯Ëc��fVÇ�È]ÉD��fVÇ Í�Í ÇOfÜÁIÇTÊ3¿¤+xj Í È3ÄFÂ$À�ÊFÆ�ýYâ¤��fVÇ�È]ÉGXfVÇTÊUÁ)Ëmj<f Í ÇTÂ$À�j¾ÊUÁ�&)F�j¾è�&v5��viaj¾ÄFÊ3¿eÇTÂ$À�j¾ÊUÁ�I � zYLQu2W*,XR^JMN�y�VWJZE]R4h R ©0©eá�I»ß¨6P5W5©eá¾½ |�IÚ¨6P5W�zYuZ�§I Ó�zYyX¡^NYS�VWJMzYy PXy5W j�bdSXuZNYb)N�y�V8JZN�LWP�yXw N^JMyXN^qñj%y�V8N^L'SXLQN^V8N^LWqð��¨PXLñs\VaÎ

R ä0Ð

Page 160: Integration of Graph Transformation and Temporal Logic for the Specification of Distributed

V8LQJ2_XP�VWJMN^LQV8N §�L8s4SX~�V8L8s\yXqQ�¢zYLVb{s<V8JMzOy�I |¤sOqbV8N^LYî�q V8~�N�qWJZqYh ©_� nKN^LWuMJZyih R ©0©eá�I~�VWVfS�l ÑYÑ VW�¢q�I¬R�q^I�VWP�I¬_�N^LWuMJZy�I¬WXN Ñ S�P5_XuMJ+º<s\V8JZzYyXN�y Ñ SXP5_XuZJ2R R ©0©eá�I�~�Vfb)u�I

»�,XR�~]©eо½ §rN^zYLWw),FR�~XJMN*W�Ióò�Hý�Å�f)��fVÇ�È]ÉTÆOf'Ç Í�Í ÇT£À2êeÅ�Ê�¥uÅ�À�ʱÅe�0È]ÅWôYÀ ¼�êTÇTÂ$À�j¾ÊUÁ Í Å�Â�ÉTjY¿FÅ�Ë òÄ=fe�Kf8j'ÆOfVÇ Í�Í À-Å�fÃÌÁ�È�fVÇFéÜÉ]Å�Ê�ÄFÊ3¿��TÅ�fïÅ�À�è Â�ÅÐ�kÅ-ÆFÅ�è�Á�â�Á�Â�Å Í Å�I .�~T�ÈVW~XN�qQJMqYhe�`yXJ|pYN�LQqWJ�V¯¨s\VoÝ�LWu�s\yXwYN�yFΧ®)¨PXLQy�_�N^LWw5hR ©0©eÐ=I Ö-L'_�N�J�V8qV_�N^LWJ2R�~�VWN¥WXN^qcj%yXqQVWJZV8P�V8q]�A¨PXL�b{s<V8~XN*b{s\VWJMqVR�~XN*|¤sOqVR�~XJMyXN^yºPXyUWº��s\VWN�yepYN^L8sOL¯Î_�N^JZVWPXyXw¥¢£j%y��¢zOL'b4s\V8J+ºU¤Ãh]Ð0ä Ñ Ð�I

»�,XR�~]©Yk4½ ­-sOy�qaÎaÙ�¨PXLQwYN�y{,XR�~Xy�N�J2W�N�L�I�Ï�ydRms<V8N�wOzYLWJ+RmsOuTwYLWsTSX~)wYL8s4b(b4sOLWq^l[j%y�VWN�wYLWs\V8JZyXw�qbV8LQP5R^VWPXL8sOupV8LWsOyXq¯Î�¢zYL'b4s\VWJMzYyXq{sOy5WHz0S�N�LWs\V8JZzYyXq/zYyHuMsT_�N^uMq^I GiÉ]Å�j<ffÅ�£À-é'ÇTè0+xj Í È3ÄFÂ�Å�f¤�ié�À-Å�ʱéÜÅ�h R ë0©�l�Ð0ä0á¸1UÐTá4�5hR ©0©Yk�I

»�,�z0b(©0¼4½ j§sOyD,�z0bdb)N�LVp=JZuMuMN4hTNYWXJ�V8zYL^I��Kf8j%éÜÅÜÅ'¿TÀ�ÊFƾÁ)j¯Ë�Â�É]Å{Ò¾Â�É*5ÃÊ]­&�£Uj<ffê%ÁÜÉTjÜȱj¾ÊD��j¯ËÃÂ;�ÇOffÅC+xj¾Êm¼[ÆTÄFÌfVÇTÂ$À�j¾Ê}dKÇTÊ3Ç%ÆFÅ Í Å�Ê]£hUpYzYuZP5b)N RYR ¼eá[zO�:���]+t��hpnKN^LWuZJMyCP�IWs�I+h R ©0©0¼�I:,FSXLWJZyXwYN�L^I»�,=V8J2©eо½ �KzYuMJZy�,=V8JZLWuMJZyXwXI:|*zXWTs\u�sOy5W�©aN*b(S�zYL8s\u�}�zOwYJ2R^q�I«j%y)�nÇFéÜêYÆOf8j¾ÄFÊ3¿��-+xj Í È3ÄFÂ�ÇT£À�j¾Ê3ÇTèTÁ�Â@fÃÄ]é�Â$Ä=ffÅÜÁ�hpYzYuZP5b)N^ÐrzO�t��ÇTÊ3¿rý�j¸j%ê)j¯ËS��j'ÆTÀ-érÀ�Ê�+xj Í È3ÄFÂ�Å�f`�ié�À-Å�ʱéÜÅ�h�STsOwYN^qu��áTá¸1UäT¼Yk�I��Ku�s\LWN�yUWXzYy/.�LQN�qWq*hÏ_õ^Ò[Ï�¨6�Qh R ©0©0Ð�I

»�, � ª0©4½ �-I°.�Ia,=V8JZLWuMJZyXwhsOy5W¹�[I Ù�I � sOu+ºON�L^I?}�zFRms\u�b4zFWXN�u�R�~�NYRܺ�JMyXw¤JMy2V8~XNdb4zFWXN^u�b[PXÎ�R�sOu2R^PXuMP�q�I{j%y�xf�j%é�&:5ÃÊ]¯Å�fÃÊ3ÇT£À�j¾Ê3ÇTèY¿pj¾À�Ê]Ât+xj¾ÊmËmÅ�ffÅ�ʱéÜÅ�j¾ÊUGiÉ]Å�j<fÃâ�ÇTÊ3¿6�xfVÇFé�Â$À-éÜÅ_j¯Ë���j¯ËÃÂ;�ÇOfÜÅ�B�Å��TÅ�èMjÜÈ Í Å�Ê]Â$hy�P5bQ_�N�L6keä R JMy"}�®-�S,lh�STsOwYN^q`kT¼0©¯1�k0ª0ÐXh R ©Tª0©�I

»�, � ©0ë4½ �-I°.�I9,=V8JZLWuZJMyXwÐs\y5Wº�[I�Ù�I � sOu2º\N�L�I ÖÕwYN^yXN�LWsOu�V�sT_�uMNms\P�VWNYR�~Xy�JMÊ�PXNh�¢zYLQpYN^LWJZ��`=JZyXwÐV8NYbdS�zYL8sOuSXLWzTS�N^LQV8JZN�q�zO��R^zYy5R�P�LWLWN^y�V�SXLQzYwYLWsTb4q^Iwj%y3�xf8j%é�&45ÃÊ]¯Å�fÃÊ3ÇT£À�j¾Ê3ÇTè���+t��i�([+t��£¤j<ffê%ÁÜÉTjÜȺj¾Ê�iÅ Í ÇTÊ]Â$À-éÜÁ�Ëmj<fc+xj¾Ê±é�Ä�fAffÅ�ʱé�â4h � zYLVº�qW~Xz0S�q`JZy¤�KzTb(SXP�V8JMy�w5h5STsOwON�q R 1 R äFh R ©0©Të�I»ë©tsONY©0¼4½ §�s4_XLWJZN�uMN�©asON�y�V8¡^N�L^I���ÇOfVÇTè�è2Å�è�ÇTÊ3¿{BIÀ2Á�ÂfÃÀJýYÄXÂ�Å'¿D��fVÇ�È]ɺGXfVÇTÊUÁ)Ëmj<f Í ÇTÂ$À�j¾Ê��eiaj<f Í ÇTè�BQÅÜÁ%é�fÃÀ�È3ÌÂ$À�j¾ÊoÇTÊ3¿�(�ÈeÈ3è À-é'ÇT£À�j¾Ê"§jC+xj Í�Í ÄXÊ]À-é'ÇT£À�j¾Ê]Ì��nǾÁ%Å'¿���â%Á�Â¯Å Í Á�I-.�~T�²V8~XN^qWJZqYh�©_�ÅnKN�LQuMJZyih R ©0©0¼�I,�~TsTº\N�LkÔ:N�LQu�sOwXI

»ë©tsONY©eá¾½ §cI�©tsON^y�V8¡�N^L�I0.tsOLWsOuMuZN�u�~�JMwY~XέuMN�pYN�u�LWNYS�u�sTR^NYb)N�y�V6qV`=qQVWNYb)q�I2G9+t��h�¢ R ªT¼e¤�h R ©0©eá�I»ë©kÒ�Ó^Ô�©0©4½ §cI\©ts\N�y�V8¡^N�LYhFj�IeÒtJZq'R�~XN^LYh=|�I0ÓrzFR�~ih�sOyUWcÔ0ITÔ:zYuZuMNOI��eJMqQVWLWJ+_XP�V8N*W]wYL8s4SX~[V8LWsOyXqQ�¢zOL'b4s\V8JZzYy�Z_JZVW~

sTS5SXuZJ2R�s\V8JZzYy0V8zIp=JMqQPTsOu]WXN^qWJMwOy4zO�±WXJMqbV8LQJ2_XP�VWNYW)qV`=qQVWNYb)q�Inj%y1§]Ie¨6zO¡�N�y�_�N�LQw5h�N*WXJZVWzYLYh���ÇTÊ3¿rý�j¸j%êj¯Ëe��fVÇ�È]ÉC��f'Ç Í�Í ÇOffÁkÇTÊ3¿)+xj Í È3ÄFÂ$À�ÊFÆ`ýYâc��fVÇ�È]É�ÂfVÇTÊUÁ)Ëmj<f Í ÇT£À�j¾Ê�¥`F�j¾è Ä Í ÅSÀ���+xj¾Ê±é�Ä=fAfÜÅ�ʱé�âÇTÊ3¿cBIÀ2Á�ÂfÃÀJýYÄX£À�j¾ÊTI � zOLWu2W},XR^JMN^y�VWJZE]R4h R ©0©T©�I»ë©SJ2Rm©4�T½ � s\uZV8N^L[©SJ2R�~e`ThxN*WXJZVWzYL�I +xj¾Êm¼[ÆTÄ�fVÇT£À�j¾Ê�dKÇTÊ3Ç%ÆFÅ Í Å�Ê]Â$h�pOzYuMP5b)N"ÐUzO�*GXffÅ�Ê3¿¾Á�À�Ê���j¯ËÃÂ;�ÇOfÜÅ�I®`N�ZÅÖ9zYLVº3h R ©0©T�XI

» pXW5­r­ � ©T¼4½�Ö`y5WXL=ÛNrp\sOy1WXN�L�­`z=NYº�hT�eN�y�yXJMqu­`N�J+bQ_XJZwYyXN�L*h�s\y5W1Ö-uZN�Ó�sOy5WXN^L�}�I � zYuZ�§InÖµwYN^yXN�LQJ2RThXS�N^N�L¯Î­V8z¾ÎS�N^N�L�LQNYS�zYqWJ�V8zYLa`��¢zYL�WXJMqbV8LWJ+_XP�VWNYW�R�zOy�ETwYPXLWs\V8JZzYy�b4sOyTsOwYN*b4N^y�VmI�j%y4½�_j Í ·=Ò§¾Ãh0STsOwYN^q:k0ë0ª¯1=k R áXhR ©0©0¼�I

» Ô:zYuå©eá�½ ÓrsOLWqbV8N�y�ÔeJ+R^V8zOLÕÔ:zYuMuZNOI Ô:N^LQV8N^JMu�V8NDÓ�zYy�ETwOPXL8s\VWJMzYy�qVpYN^LVZKsOuZVWPXyXwXl!+S>xdh(-�6BrI´©�NYR�~�yXJ2R�sOuLWN*S�zYLbVmhTnKsOqV`=qr§IbQ_5­�h5Önb � N^J2R�~XqQN�uZw�sOLQVWN�yg�5h]© R ëeäTªcÝ�LWu�s\yXwYN�y±h R ©0©eá=I» Ô � ªYk4½ j�I�Ô:N�qWqQN*`�sOy5WO¨�I � NY_�N�L^I ,�zTb4NC�sTR�V8zYLQq{s4Û�NYR�V8JZyXw=S�LWzYwYLWsTbðLQNYSTsOJZLcb{sOJZy�V8N�yXsOy5R�N{1�sOyNYbdSXJMLQJ2R�sOu�qbV8P5WX`YIU+�([+adoh5STs\wYN�q R ÐTª¸1 R kT�5hUÒTNY_�I R ©0ªOk�I

» � sOw0©eá¾½ Ö-yXy�J2º<s � sOwOyXN�L^I�(³i�j<f Í ÇTè�>3ý@?mÅÜé�Â��0È]ÅÜé�À ¼�é'ÇT£À�j¾Ê�GlÅÜéÜÉFÊ]ÀÌYÄ]Å)�iÁ�À�ÊFÆ��kÄXè2Å�Ì���ǾÁ%Å'¿*GXfVÇTÊUÁ)Ëmj<fÃÌÍ ÇTÂ$À�j¾ÊDj¯Ëe��ÇOfãÀ£ÇTèp(rè¬ÆFÅ�ý�fVǾÁ�I�.:~X��VW~XN�qQJMqYhT©_��nKN^LWuMJZyih R ©0©eá�I

R äOk